christian doutremepuich and antoine doutremepuich v. … · 2019. 10. 28. · paris, 20 march 2017...

12
Christian DOUTREMEPUICH and Antoine DOUTREMEPUICH v. REPUBLIC OF MAURITIUS Respondent’s Closing Statement The Hague, 13 June 2019 1

Upload: others

Post on 01-Apr-2021

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Christian DOUTREMEPUICH and Antoine DOUTREMEPUICH v. … · 2019. 10. 28. · Paris, 20 March 2017 Dear Prime Minister, we are writing to you on behalf of Pr. Christian DOUTREMEPUICH,

Christian DOUTREMEPUICH

and

Antoine DOUTREMEPUICH

v.

REPUBLIC OF MAURITIUS

Respondent’s Closing Statement

The Hague, 13 June 2019

1

ecaroit
Typewriter
ecaroit
Rectangle
Page 2: Christian DOUTREMEPUICH and Antoine DOUTREMEPUICH v. … · 2019. 10. 28. · Paris, 20 March 2017 Dear Prime Minister, we are writing to you on behalf of Pr. Christian DOUTREMEPUICH,

2

Doutremepuich v. Mauritius (Jurisdiction)

The Tribunal lacks jurisdiction ratione materiae

Page 3: Christian DOUTREMEPUICH and Antoine DOUTREMEPUICH v. … · 2019. 10. 28. · Paris, 20 March 2017 Dear Prime Minister, we are writing to you on behalf of Pr. Christian DOUTREMEPUICH,

3

Doutremepuich v. Mauritius (Jurisdiction)

E-mail from the BOI to the

Claimants including a draft

letter to the PM’s office,

C-14, p. 2 (pdf)

Page 4: Christian DOUTREMEPUICH and Antoine DOUTREMEPUICH v. … · 2019. 10. 28. · Paris, 20 March 2017 Dear Prime Minister, we are writing to you on behalf of Pr. Christian DOUTREMEPUICH,

4

Doutremepuich v. Mauritius (Jurisdiction)

E-mail from Claimants’

counsel to the PM

office,

20 March 2017,

Pièce 13 (RfA), pp. 1-2

Page 5: Christian DOUTREMEPUICH and Antoine DOUTREMEPUICH v. … · 2019. 10. 28. · Paris, 20 March 2017 Dear Prime Minister, we are writing to you on behalf of Pr. Christian DOUTREMEPUICH,

5

Doutremepuich v. Mauritius (Jurisdiction)

Updated Business Plan,

dated 4 November 2015,

C-17-1(RfA)/Pièce 17,

Annex 1, p. 2

Page 6: Christian DOUTREMEPUICH and Antoine DOUTREMEPUICH v. … · 2019. 10. 28. · Paris, 20 March 2017 Dear Prime Minister, we are writing to you on behalf of Pr. Christian DOUTREMEPUICH,

6

Doutremepuich v. Mauritius (Jurisdiction)

C-17(RfA)/Pièce 17,

Tableaux, p. 1 (pdf)

Page 7: Christian DOUTREMEPUICH and Antoine DOUTREMEPUICH v. … · 2019. 10. 28. · Paris, 20 March 2017 Dear Prime Minister, we are writing to you on behalf of Pr. Christian DOUTREMEPUICH,

7

Doutremepuich v. Mauritius (Jurisdiction)

Evidence on the Claimants’ expenditure

Page 8: Christian DOUTREMEPUICH and Antoine DOUTREMEPUICH v. … · 2019. 10. 28. · Paris, 20 March 2017 Dear Prime Minister, we are writing to you on behalf of Pr. Christian DOUTREMEPUICH,

8

Doutremepuich v. Mauritius (Jurisdiction)

E-mail from

Mr Ahmed Rawat

to the Claimants,

9 November 2015,

Pièce 11 (RfA)/C-15,

pp. 1-2 (pdf)

Page 9: Christian DOUTREMEPUICH and Antoine DOUTREMEPUICH v. … · 2019. 10. 28. · Paris, 20 March 2017 Dear Prime Minister, we are writing to you on behalf of Pr. Christian DOUTREMEPUICH,

9

Doutremepuich v. Mauritius (Jurisdiction)

The Tribunal lacks jurisdiction ratione voluntatis

Page 10: Christian DOUTREMEPUICH and Antoine DOUTREMEPUICH v. … · 2019. 10. 28. · Paris, 20 March 2017 Dear Prime Minister, we are writing to you on behalf of Pr. Christian DOUTREMEPUICH,

10

Doutremepuich v. Mauritius (Jurisdiction)

France-Mauritius BIT,

C-2, Art. 8

Page 11: Christian DOUTREMEPUICH and Antoine DOUTREMEPUICH v. … · 2019. 10. 28. · Paris, 20 March 2017 Dear Prime Minister, we are writing to you on behalf of Pr. Christian DOUTREMEPUICH,

11

Doutremepuich v. Mauritius (Jurisdiction)

France-Mauritius BIT, C-2,

Art. 9

Page 12: Christian DOUTREMEPUICH and Antoine DOUTREMEPUICH v. … · 2019. 10. 28. · Paris, 20 March 2017 Dear Prime Minister, we are writing to you on behalf of Pr. Christian DOUTREMEPUICH,

12

Doutremepuich v. Mauritius (Jurisdiction)

Finland-Mauritius BIT,

C-3, Art. 9