chuck johnson v. gawker: anti-slapp/motion to dismiss
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
1/33
"
#$ %&' ($#%') *%+%'* )#*%,#-% -.(,%
'+*%',$ )#*%,#-% ./ 2#**.(,#4'06>:5; )
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
2/33
X
0LL:\: >T0> ):A:;H0;>6 ZRVLTR0L ^0LT: FT0LL:;\:H 6>0>:^:;>6
05: ;?;@0F> H:A0^0>?5_ S >? >T: Z? PT:5: >T:_ :]Z5:66L_ F06> H?RV>
?; >T: >5R>T ?A >T: b5R^?56d KL00>:^:;>6 V_ 5:0H:56 >? M0PQ:5[6
P:V6:6 05: Z5?>:F>:H V_ BE (8*8-8 ` XJNO PT6
Z?6>:H V_ 5:0H:568
.2%2"!"&2 #* *%02.
-6 /+%-&2-**. 0>%$+". :#>&.#& %&' 5#2 &",.
7?T;6?; ?5O 0;H T;:P68F?^ T: Z5
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
3/33
J
ZRVL0>:^:;>6 A0LL ? >T5::
F0>:\?5
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
4/33
B
%6 21?=? -3 &9 .8?7BDB7 :@=B3FB7NB9J 9E?= N1? '?D?JFKJN3
%? :6>0VLT 4"= b0
H:A:;H0;>[6 F?;HRF> P06 F?1:5:H V_ >T: k2R>:d 0;H 4X= b>T: :]:5F
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
5/33
D
F?;1:; EoB8 %T: -?56 P? H:A0^0>
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
6/33
W
L? V: 6RAA:5:H T: A?5R^ 6>0>:8d >.0/+./O W"B /8JH 0> EoW 4^05Q6 ?^>:H=8 M0PQ:5[6
05> 0
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
7/33
E
L% J&:1&/O "JB *8 ->8 EBWO EW" 4XN"B=8 /?5 0;
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
8/33
a
ZL0
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
9/33
o
%6
/AKBJNBDD3 *KBA N9 /AK@3BIAO %AA?H? N1KN '?D?JFKJN3 %7N?F GBN1 %7N@KA !KAB7?
R6 /AKBJNBDD3 K=? /@IAB7 *BH@=?3
%? Z5?>:F> >T: 10L_ ?A ZRVL05_O >T: L0P H:6 V:>P::; Z5: 0;H
PT0> LT b5R;kl >T: 5
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
10/33
"N
:@^0? &?P05H Z? 0;H Z5::^Z>
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
11/33
""
? 0̂ :;H AR>T:5
^:H
5:0H:56 F0; GRH\: A?5 >T:^6:L1:6Y >T:_ :]>:;6 >? >T: >P? 5R^?56 >T:
-?^ZL0 0LL:\:6 05: A0L6:8 ,## +;> ""@"X8
L6
21? %AA?H?FAO '?DKPKN9=O .NKN?P?JN3 %=? %A39 &9N %7NB9JKIA?
R6 21? .NKN?P?JN3 KI9@N /AKBJNBDD34 *K@ANO $?89=NBJH
+L>:5;0>0>:^:;>6 +O eO -O 0;H 7 4']8 "= 6T?RLH V: H
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
12/33
"X
6RZZ?5>:H V_ :]0^ZL:6O
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
13/33
"J
F?;6>5R:H PTT: F?;>:]> ?A >T: 05>0>:^:;>6 >T0> H? ;?> 066:5> 0F>R0L A0F>6 0V?R> 0 ZL0
0F>
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
14/33
"B
>T:_ 05: ;?> 0F>T:5 5:06?;6 4 +## *:F>
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
15/33
"D
M#*&/ L% ;Q5! D/-%O "Xo /8JH JXEO JJN 4B>T - EoN@oX 40H?Z>T:5
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
16/33
"W
)0>:H3 +R\R6> XBO XN"D ,:6Z:F>ARLL_ 6RV^>:HO
+",-.C $-0" S *-&5"$.>C +606
e_3 j6j 7?6:ZT '8 205> :% (5 ;
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
17/33
!"#$%&%!'$" )& *"#+%!"
"#$ %&'$()*+&$' ,$(-*.*$) -#/- 2& -#*) 40-# '/6 2. >%+%)-: 45;
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
18/33
"
#$ %&' ($#%') *%+%'* )#*%,#-% -.(,%
'+*%',$ )#*%,#-% ./ 2#**.(,#4'06>:5; )
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
19/33
Y
"Y4R=4X= Z?> H:Z?;6>50>: 0 Q5?R0RG::5 ?A L0^8 #> ZV6> >G:5:A?5: R: 6>56 0^05H:H >? ):A:;H0;>68
.2%2"!"&2 #* *%02.
-5 /+%-&2-**.4 0#&2$#;"$.-%+ .2
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
20/33
J
1?'46F 3)).#66#6 -J *#+ ,-./ 240#6 E#K-.$#.6DO M?> $:^6 4$?18 YDO YN"B=O
G>>Q3eeP?>;:^68F?ZeF0;>@QVRL:56O 0;H >G: ^5?;P QV5: ?A
_70FTG: ^?Z0; 0> >G: F:;>:5 ?A E-''4=5 9$-=#[6 0LL:P:H 50Q: 6>?5\ 0> >G: (;G5:0>6O R06:L:66 FL0
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
21/33
B
HV: >? G
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
22/33
D
G>>Q3ee^^^8 >:5@G05066Z:;>@FG05L:6@F@W?G;6?;@R?06>6@H?n>Q3ee^?;T:>>:8F?ZeDXjDJDe>^>:56@R@6FVZR0P@FGVFT@F@
W?G;6?;@?V>6@50Q:@1?@>:0FG@A:Z %5?>>:5[6 A F?LVZ; ^06 Q?6>:H8
9## 2F-?\ 61K.& 0> J8 *? H
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
23/33
X
FG05L:6@W?G;6?;@QL0;6@LG0; >? >G5:0>:; LG:5 W?V5;0L68
+H0Z *>:>Q3ee0H0Z6>:
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
24/33
E
Q5:6VZQ>
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
25/33
j
5:L0> $:^6[6 0LL:P:H _L?6> RV6 Z:;>6] : 506>O 2 R: :10H:H R\ :;0RLG:? ?>G:5 6>0>:68
--5 /+%-&2-**.4 0#!/+%-&2 .>#(+' ?" '-.!-.."' (&'"$ 2>"
0%+-*#$&-% %&2-:.+%// .2%2(2"
%5 239 087BD@FNB8 %NJB:.+%// .J8JEJ9
_*9+KK] 50>:P R: FGG5?VPG 0RV6: ?A >G: WVH
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
26/33
k
6Q::FG 56 0> >G: :05L 6>0P: ?A >G: F06:O] W1=:6B L% 9&=)'#. O "BX -0L8 +QQ8 B>G "DBNO "DBJ
4YNNE=O 0;H
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
27/33
"N
H:Z?;6>50>: 0 Q5?R0RG0> >G: -0LV>: ^06 H:6?
:;6V5: Q5?>:F>
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
28/33
""
>G0> KL0:5 ̂ :5: G?>L\@H:R0>:H _
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
29/33
"Y
0F>V0L Z0LG: 05> d>G: QL0:F>:H ?Q
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
30/33
"J
J8 %G: 6>0>:Z:;>6 R\ %5?>>:5 0;H &?^05H 0R?V> 5VZ?56 >G0> 7?G;6?; H:A:F0>:H ?; 0
AL??5 0;H F?ZZ>:H R:6>?5\ Z:0;:F>:H R\ >G: / +Z:;HZ:;>O A?5 :G:5 ?A >^? 5:06?;68 9## 2%) 0> "Y@"J8 T4.6$ O
>G: >:;?5 ?A >G: 05>G0> >G:\ 05: >?;PV:@6 >? Q?T: AV; 0>
7?G;6?;[6 :nQ:;6: 0;H H? ;?> QV5Q?5> >? 066:5> >G:6: 5VZ?56 06 A0F>8 #> 0RLG0>
0>>:ZQ>6 0> 60>? R: 06>: ?5 ;?>O 05: ;?> 0F> 0F>
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
31/33
"B
G=# 240#D= 4_+;H 6? # 06T \?VO H:05:6> 5:0H:563 )G: AL??5 >L:H >G0> bV:6> 0F>
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
32/33
"D
)0>:H3 +VPV6> YBO YN"D ,:6Q:F>AVLL\ 6VRZ>:HO
+",-.G $-0" R *-&="$.>G +505
l\3 e6e 7?6:QG '8 205> :% 55 ;
-
8/20/2019 Chuck Johnson v. Gawker: Anti-SLAPP/Motion to Dismiss
33/33
!"#$%&%!'$" )& *"#+%!"
"#$ %&'$()*+&$' ,$(-*.*$) -#/- 2& -#*) 40-# '/6 2. >%+%)-: 45;