citiplan town and regional planners · the farm lot 221 empangeni no. 10379 registration division...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
West View ©
APPLICATION IN TERMS OF SECTION 27(1)(a) AND (f), OF THE UMHLATHUZE SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BY-LAW, 2017 RELATING TO PORTION 1 OF THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU
PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by
CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS
PO Box 11199
Wierda Park South
0057
Shop 3
Promenade Centre
Richards Bay
3901
Tel: 082 414 5321
Fax: 086 619 8740
Email: [email protected]
MAY 2018 SACPLAN A/1635/2012
![Page 2: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
West View ©
MOTIVATING MEMORANDUM
1. BACKGROUND
The KwaZulu – Natal Development Tribunal on 14 June 2012 approved an
application in terms of the provisions of the Development Facilitation Act,
1995, for:
510 single residential erven
1 commercial erf
4 high density residential
8 open space erven
1 electrical works;
1 worship erf;
1 primary school erf;
1community facility erf;
2 conservation erven;
11 road erven; and
3 erven for future roads.
This approval lapsed on 9 October 2016.
The owner intends to develop according to the original approval,
however two separate planning applications will be submitted for
approval:
• An application for the establishment of a commercial node and
petrol filling station (this application); and
• An application for the remainder of the project, being the
residential component (referred to as X1 in this report).
Separate public participation processes will be followed for each of the
applications.
2. THE APPLICANT
The owner of the application site is Cosmic Gold Trading 364 (Pty) Ltd. The
property, Portion 1 of the Farm Lot 221 Empangeni No. 10379, is held under
Deed of Transfer T 61202/2007 (attached as Annexure A).
The owner, by means of a power of attorney, appointed Citiplan Town
Planners to prepare and submit the planning application on their behalf. The
Power of Attorney is attached as Annexure B.
![Page 3: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
West View ©
3. THE APPLICATION
The application is lodged with reference to a portion of Portion 1 of the Farm
Lot 221 Empangeni No. 10379 in terms of Section 27(1)(a) and (f) of the By-
law to the City of uMhlathuze (“CoU”), for:
Township establishment on a portion of Portion 1 of the Farm Lot 221
Empangeni No. 10379, Empangeni, in order to make provision for land uses
as indicated on the Layout Plan No. WV/221/2018 dated March 2018:
1 Mixed use low impact erf;
1 Service station erf;
1 Public Open Space erf;
1 Conservation erven;
1 Existing Public Roads erf.
5 Total
The amendment of the uMhlathuze Land Use Scheme, 2014 by the
rezoning of the property from “Agriculture 1” to the various zonings as
indicated on the Layout Plan No. WV/221/2018 dated March 2018:
ERF ZONING
Erf 16064 Empangeni
Erf 16065 Empangeni
Erf 15791 Empangeni
Erf 15792 Empangeni
Erf 16304 Empangeni
Mixed use low impact
Service station
Conservation
Public open space
Existing public road
ERF 16064
LAND USE ZONE
Zone Category: Mixed Use Low Impact.
FREE ENTRY USES
Automotive showroom, commercial workshop, launderette, municipal,
purposes, office –general, office – professional, parking erf/parkade, place of
amusement, place of assembly, public office, residential building (except on
ground floor), service workshop and shop – general.
FORMAL AUTHORITY USES
Carwash facility, educational building, home activity, parking erf/parkade,
place of amusement, place of assembly, place of worship, recreational
building, and utilities facility.
CONSENT USE
Funeral parlour, home business, gambling premises, institution, industry –
light, industry – service, night club/bar, shop – wholesale and special use.
![Page 4: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
West View ©
MAXIMUM PERMITTED COVERAGE, FLOOR AREA RATIO AND HEIGHT
Coverage: 50%;
FAR: 0,5;
Height: 2 Storeys
ERF 16065
LAND USE ZONE
Zone Category: Service Station.
FREE ENTRY USES
Municipal purposes and service station.
FORMAL AUTHORITY USES
Automotive showroom, commercial workshop, industry – service and public
garage.
CONSENT USE
Special use.
MAXIMUM PERMITTED COVERAGE, FLOOR AREA RATIO AND HEIGHT
Coverage: 60%;
FAR: 0,50;
Height unrestricted.
ERF 15791
LAND USE ZONE
Zone Category: Conservation.
FREE ENTRY USES
Conservation purposes and utilities facility.
FORMAL AUTHORITY USES
Caretaker accommodation, heritage purposes.
CONSENT USE
Agricultural building, agricultural industry (limited to aquaculture and
mariculture), agricultural land, arts and crafts workshop, camping and
caravan park, conference centre, public / private street, special use and new
servitude (15 m or wider).
MAXIMUM PERMITTED COVERAGE, FLOOR AREA RATIO AND HEIGHT
At sole discretion of Council.
ERF 15792
LAND USE ZONE
Zone Category: Public Open Space
FREE ENTRY USES
Public recreational use, recreational building and utilities facility.
FORMAL AUTHORITY USES
Community garden, heritage purposes and municipal purposes.
CONSENT USE
![Page 5: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
West View ©
Coffee shop / tea garden, parking area/parkade, public/private street, special
use and new servitude (15 m or wider).
ERF 16304
LAND USE ZONE
Zone Category: Existing Public Road.
FREE ENTRY USES
Public street, parking erf / parkade and utilities facility.
FORMAL AUTHORITY USES
Informal trade area and terminal – bus and taxi.
CONSENT USE
Special use.
MAXIMUM PERMITTED COVERAGE, FLOOR AREA RATIO AND HEIGHT
At sole discretion of Council.
4. DEVELOPMENT DETAILS
The proposed development will consist of erven for Mixed Use Low Impact, a
Service Station, Conservation, Public Open Space and Existing Public Road.
Access will be via a road to be constructed (Erf 16304), which intersects with
Provincial Road P230 opposite the entrance to Tronox KZN Sands. .
Erf 16064 will be used for a shopping centre in support of the surrounding
area, passing traffic and the inhabitants of proposed West View X1 to be
submitted in due course.
Parking will be provided in the ratio of 1 parking bay per 30 m² plus 1 parking
bay per 140 m2 floor area or part thereof for warehousing or storage. Loading
will be provided as per the requirements of the uMhlathuze Land Use
Scheme. Coverage will be restricted to 50%, the height to 2 storeys and the
FAR to 0,50.
Erf 16065 will be used for a service station with 60% coverage, FAR of 0,50
and will include an ATM, convenience shop, office space and car wash
facility. It will have a separate access and egress from Erf 16064. Parking
and loading will be provided as per the requirements of the uMhlathuze Land
Use Scheme.
![Page 6: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
West View ©
5. LOCALITY
Portion 1 of the Farm Lot 221 Empangeni No. 10379 is currently
undeveloped farm land, and is located opposite the Qalakabusha Prison and
adjacent to the Hillview Development.
FIGURE 1: LOCALITY PLAN
![Page 7: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
West View ©
6. PROPERTY PARTICULARS
6.1 TITLE DEED
Portion 1 of the Farm Lot 221 Empangeni No. 10379 is 60.7028ha in extent
and is held under Deed of Transfer 61202/2007 by Cosmic Gold Trading
364 (Pty) Ltd.
Pipeline servitudes SG2451/2008 and SG2452/2008 are registered in
favour of the Municipality and K1916/2002S in favour of uMhlathuze
Water. Servitude SG 2451/2008 impacts on the application site and will
be registered over Erven 16064 and 16065.
There are no title conditions that would prevent the Municipality from
considering and approving the application submitted.
6.2 ZONING
In terms of the uMhlathuze Land Use Scheme, 2014, the Property is zoned
“Agricultural 1”.
6.3 CHARACTERISTICS
6.3.1 TOPOGRAPHY
The proposed erven has an average descending slope of 11% from
south to north.
6.3.2 GEOLOGY
A geotechnical investigation had been conducted by Davies Lynn &
Partners (Pty) Ltd in 2007 (Annexure C).
The report concludes that the site is considered to be developable and
no potentially unstable areas appear to occur on this site. The ease of
development across the site is related to the landforms and underlying
geology. In general the most favourable areas for development are the
gently sloping hillsides and hilltop areas which comprise approximately
70% of the area investigated. Steeper slopes provide moderate
development potential requiring more extensive earthworks and more
elaborate founding measures.
The subsoil materials encountered necessitate that care is exercised in
the use of the range of in-situ materials to cater for potential movement
![Page 8: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
West View ©
associated with consolidation of clayey soils and settlement of fills.
Similarly, precautions are required during construction in material
selection and placement within platforms ensuring optimum moisture
levels and compaction densities.
Earthworks requiring cut to fill platform are likely to be prevalent across
much of the area. Preference should be given to locating structures in
the cut portion of the layout to reduce- costs associated with foundation
construction wherever possible.
For single storey structures the option of either a stiffened reinforced
concrete (RC) raft or RC strip footings/ground beam foundation to
Engineer's design is recommended to cater for the range in prevailing
subsoil conditions. To counteract the effects of potentially collapsible
clays and differential conditions arising on cut to fill platforms, the
strategic use of concrete pads is advised.
Disposal of stormwater by subsoil percolation methods is "not
recommended”. It is recommended that stormwater be discharged
either on to road hardenings, directly into drainage courses or to
midblock stormwater control systems.
Selected layers will be required to establish layerworks along the
proposed road network where subgrade materials other than suitable
granular materials occur at or below formation level.
A letter of confirmation that the report is still valid had been submitted
(Annexure D).
6.3.3 HYDROLOGY
In its preliminary hydrogeological assessment Davies Lynn & Partners
(Pty) Ltd found the regional water table to be more than 10 m below the
site. Inspection pits extended into the Granite Gneiss bedrock were dry
and seepage is confined to the drainage course.
6.4 CURRENT USE
The Property is currently vacant and used for agricultural purposes.
![Page 9: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
West View ©
7. LEGISLATION
7.1 THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT: MUNICIPAL SYSTEMS ACT, 2000
The constitutive statute of the City of uMhlathuze (“CoU”) is the Local
Government: Municipal Systems Act, 2000 (Act 32 of 2000).
It is trite law that public authorities such as the CoU only has those powers
which are granted to them through its constitutive power, and it is contended
that the CoU is a so-called creature of statute.
In addition to the foregoing the CoU is bound to execute its power under
ancillary statutory provisions such as SPLUMA, the Promotion of
Administrative Justice Act, 2000 (Act 3 of 2000) and its By-law.
One of the statutory obligations of the CoU is the effective administration of
applications launched in terms of the By-law and its uMhlathuze Land Use
Scheme.
7.2 THE SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT ACT,
2013
In terms of Section 6 of SPLUMA:
“1. The general principles set out in this Chapter apply to all organs of State
and other authorities responsible for the implementation of legislation
regulating the use and development of land, and guide –
(a) the preparation, adoption and implementation of any spatial
development framework, policy or by-law concerning spatial planning
and the development or use of land;
(b) the compilation, implementation and administration of any land use
scheme or other regulatory mechanism for the management of the use
of land;
(c) the sustainable use and development of land;
(d) the consideration by a competent authority of any application that
impacts or may impact on upon the use and development of land; and
(e) the performance of any function in terms of this Act or any other law
regulating spatial planning and land use management.
2. Notwithstanding the categorisation of principles in this section, all
principles contained in this Act apply to all aspects of spatial development
planning, land development and land use management.”
![Page 10: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
West View ©
8. POLICY
8.1 INTEGRATED DEVELOPMENT PLAN (“IDP”)
An IDP had been adopted by the CoU in terms of Section 35(1) of the Local
Government: Municipal Systems Act, 2000 (Act 32 of 2000) during 2012. The
status of an IDP is:
“35. (1) An integrated development plan adopted by the council of a
municipality—
(a) is the principal strategic planning instrument which guides and informs all
planning and development, and all decisions with regard to planning,
management and development, in the municipality;
(b) binds the municipality in the exercise of its executive authority, except to
the extent of any inconsistency between a municipality’s integrated
development plan and national or provincial legislation, in which case such
legislation prevails; and
(c) binds all other persons to the extent that those parts of the integrated
development plan that impose duties or affect the rights of’ those persons
have been passed as a by-law.”
The purpose of the IDP is:
“to describe the planning and implementation processes that will be followed
by the municipality to deliver on the developmental agenda on government
pursuant to the below-mentioned strategic objectives: Co-operative
governance and informed decision-making, social and environmental
sustainability, advanced economic growth, optimised infrastructural services,
and organisational excellence.”
Local governments have to follow the following objectives:
• Provide democratic and accountable government;
• Provision of Services to the community in a sustainable manner;
• Promote Social and Economic Development;
• Promote safe and healthy environment; and
• Encourage the involvement of communities and community organisation in
matters of local government.
The uMhlathuze Municipality’s new Vision is:
“The Port City of uMhlathuze offering a better quality of life for all its citizens
through sustainable development and inclusive economic growth.”
The IDP in Table 82 provides a summary of the municipal strategies, goals
and objectives as well as a summary of the alignment between the
![Page 11: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
West View ©
municipality, provincial and national government. The following Key
Performance Areas would apply to the application:
NATIONAL KPA 3 : LOCAL ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
GOALS OBJECTIVES STRATEGIES
3.1 Viable
Economic Growth
And Development
3.1.1 To promote and facilitate
investment
3.1.1.1 Develop investment
promotion and facilitation
plan 3.1.1.2 Develop township
economy
3.1.1.3 Package council
land to facilitate economic
growth 3.1.2 Stimulate key sectors that promote
economic growth and create jobs
3.1.2.1 Provide support for
prioritised sectors
3.1.2.2 Developing and
implement economic
development sector plan
3.1.3 To create enabling environment
for the informal economy
3.1.3.1 Review and
implement informal
economy policy 3.1.4 Clear City identity 3.1.4.1 To promote the city
as destination of choice
3.1.5 To implement and co-ordinate
Expanded Public Works Programme
(EPWP) in a manner that enhances skills
development and optimizes decent
employment and entrepreneurship
3.1.5.1 Promote economic
growth by successful
implementation of EPWP
community based projects
3.1.5.2 Promoting
economic growth by
providing employment
opportunities for Women
and Youth
3.1.5.3 Promoting
economic growth by
providing skills
empowerment to the
unemployed
3.2 Public Safety
and Security
3.2.1 Provision of efficient and effective
security services
3.2.1.1 Review and
implementation of crime
prevention strategy
3.2.2 To ensure Provision of fire and
rescue services
3.2.2.1 Review and
Implementation of a fire
prevention strategy
![Page 12: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
West View ©
NATIONAL KPA 3 : LOCAL ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
GOALS OBJECTIVES STRATEGIES
3.3 Safe and
Healthy Living
Environment
3.3.1 Efficient an effective waste
management services
3.3.1.1 Review and
Implementation of
Integrated Waste
Management Plan
NATIONAL KPA 6 : CROSS CUTTING
GOALS OBJECTIVES STRATEGIES
6.1 Integrated Urban
and Rural
Development
6.1.1 To plan and
manage existing and
future development
6.1.1.1 Review and Implement Spatial
Development Plan
6.1.1.2 Develop precinct framework
plans
6.1.1.3 Review of Human Settlement
Sector Plan
6.1.1.4 Incremental development of
strategic environmental assessment
for the entire municipal area
6.1.1.5 Implementation of uMhlathuze
Land Use Scheme
6.1.1.6 Compliance with national
Spluma by-law and national building
act.
6.1.1.7 Efficient processing of
development application and
building plans
This application would mainly address National KPA 3 – Local Economic
Development and KPA 6 – Cross Cutting:
The proposed development will create economic growth, job opportunities
and efficient use of engineering services;
Public transport volumes into Empangeni on P230 will be alleviated as
less public transport would enter the CBD for shopping purposes;
It will create a sense of being with a balance of land uses in the proposed
township of West View X1 (to be submitted in due course);
![Page 13: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
West View ©
The shopping centre will contribute to accessibility of the rural area to
retail facilities without travelling to Empangeni CBD;
It will provide a service to passing traffic, the surrounding area and the
future suburbia;
The application ensures compliance with the Spatial Planning and Land
Use Management Act, 2013, and the uMhlathuze Spatial Planning and
Land Use By-law, uMhlathuze Land Use Scheme and the National
Building Regulations and Building Standards Act, 1997 – Building plans
will be submitted for approval in due course.
8.2 THE NATIONAL PLANNING REPORT (“NPR”)
This report aims to lead towards a plan the Government needs to draft to
result in broad consensus on South Africa’s principal national challenges
coming up with sensible and achievable solutions. The IDP is a suitable tool
to direct the NPR towards this goal, finding substance in the final plan.
8.3 NATIONAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN (“NDP”)
In its Overview of the NDP, the National Planning Commission finds that:
Too few people work;
Infrastructure is poorly located, under-maintained and insufficient to foster
higher growth;
Spatial patterns exclude the poor from the fruits of development.
The NDP proposes to create jobs by:
Realizing an environment for sustainable employment and inclusive
economic growth;
Promoting employment in labour-absorbing industries.
Strategies to reverse the spatial effects of apartheid include:
Moving jobs and investment towards dense townships that are on the
margins of cities. Building new settlements far from places of work should
be discouraged, chiefly through zoning regulations responsive to
government policy.
The strategy to enhance social cohesion includes reducing of poverty and
inequality by broadening opportunity through economic inclusion, education
and skills, and specific redress measures.
Targets for human settlements are:
More people living closer to their places of work;
Better quality public transport;
![Page 14: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
West View ©
More jobs in or close to dense, urban townships.
The following applicable critical actions are noted from the NDP:
A strategy to address poverty and its impacts by broadening access to
employment, strengthening the social wage, improving public transport
and raising rural incomes;
Boost private investment in labour-intensive areas, competitiveness and
exports, with adjustments to lower the risk of hiring younger workers;
Public infrastructure investment at 10% of Gross Domestic Product (GDP)
financed through tariffs, public-private partnerships, taxes and loans and
focused on transport, energy and water;
Interventions to ensure environmental sustainability and resilience to
future shocks;
New spatial norms and standards – densifying cities, improving transport,
locating jobs where people live, upgrading informal settlements and fixing
housing market gaps;
Reduce crime by strengthening criminal justice and improving community
environments.
Overarching principles for spatial development should conform to the
following:
Spatial justice – the unfair allocation of public resources between areas
must be reversed;
Spatial sustainability – sustainable patterns of consumption and
production should be supported, with emphasis on the protection of the
natural environment and walkable neighbourhoods;
Spatial resilience – ecological systems should be protected and
replenished;
Spatial quality – the aesthetic and functional features of housing and the
built environment need to be improved;
Spatial efficiency – productive activity and jobs should be supported, and
burdens on business minimised.
8.4 SPATIAL DEVELOPMENT FRAMEWORK (“SDF”)
A SDF is an integral part of the IDP, as contained in the Local Government:
Municipal Systems Act, 2000 (Act 32 of 2000) and the Spatial Planning and
Land Use Management Act, 2013 (Act 16 of 2013).
The Municipal Systems Act Regulations (Act 32 of 2000) outlines the
following specific objectives of an SDF:
o Strategic guidance on the location and nature of development
o Set out basic guidelines for land use management
![Page 15: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
West View ©
o Discourage low-density urban sprawl
o Generate social and economic opportunities
o Promote access to opportunities
o Maximize resource efficiency by: (1) protecting sensitive environments, (2)
protecting productive agricultural land and (3) enhancing the regional identity
and character
In terms of Section 12 and 20 of the Spatial Planning and Land Use
Management Act, 2013 (Act 16 of 2013), each Municipality must prepare and
adopt a Spatial Development Framework
The uMhlathuze Municipality’s SDF was adopted for the period 2017-2022. In
terms of the application, the following should be noted:
The proposed development is situated on a secondary corridor, just
outside the Primary Node of Empangeni in an urban formal area.
The population density in the area is identified as 10 501 – 13 000 people.
The application site is situated in Expansion Area H within the Urban
Development Boundary and the use thereof is proposed as “Commercial
and high density residential”. As such, it is identified as an area of growth
and development in accordance with Map 35 of the SDF, as shown below:
FIGURE 2: AREAS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH AND DEVELOPMENT
![Page 16: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
West View ©
With the adjustment of the Municipal Boundary during 2016, large areas
formerly forming part of the Ntambanana Municipality now forms part of
the uMhlathuze Municipality. The proposed West View commercial node
and filling station is ideally situated to provide convenience shopping
opportunity to these communities, and in particular the Ward 24
community.
No constraints are identified in the SDF relating to Expansion Area H.
8.5 PROVINCIAL NORMS AND STANDARDS
Provincial norms and standards are not applicable yet.
8.6 GUIDELINES FOR HUMAN SETTLEMENTS AND DESIGN
Planning Guidelines applicable on this application are contained in
Chapter 5 of the “Red Book”.
8.6.1 MOVEMENT NETWORKS
“An analysis of the pattern and mix of existing and anticipated land-use
activity surrounding the particular site, as well as the pattern and mix of
higher order land-use development that is to be encouraged within the
site, will indicate spatial patterns of movement demand (known as
“desire lines”) across, into and from the site.
An indication of the nature of these patterns of movement demand can
be used to inform
• the need for, and alignment of, higher order movement routes
across the site; and
• the need for, and alignment of public transport connections across
the site.
A convenient walking distance is often interpreted as maximum walking
time of 5-10 minutes, and a maximum walking distance of that involving
400-500 metres “.
8.6.2 PUBLIC TRANSPORT
“Settlement planners should ensure that proper facilities for buses and
minibuses are provided from the outset. The following principles need to
be borne in mind:
• roads, which may be used as bus or minibus routes, should connect
activity centres directly and be suitable as regards width, alignment and
construction;
![Page 17: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
West View ©
• corner radii should take into account the fact that buses have a large
swept turning circle (in the order of 20 to 25 m in diameter);
• bus bays and turning areas should be provided as appropriate;
• the minimum width of road for bus operations in new developments
should be 7,3 m, or 9 m where there are more than 30 buses per hour
using the road; and
• where possible, bus services should have balanced traffic in both
directions at peak time. This can be achieved by having employment
areas concentrated at nodes along the main bus corridors”.
The layout plan of the proposed development complies with this
guideline.
8.6.3 LAND SUBDIVISION
“• Encourage higher densities at strategic points (like public transport
stops and adjacent to higher amenity areas such as parks), and along
significant public transport routes. The higher densities would provide
the economies of scale to support the facilities and/or transport service.
This could be achieved by providing for smaller lots, and lots capable of
supporting higher density development at these positions and along
these routes in the settlement.
• A diversity of stand sizes should be provided to accommodate a
range of activities but the following points should be kept in mind:
- the need for business and home-based enterprises to locate in
close proximity to concentrations of economic activities (taking
advantage of agglomeration economics) and along arterial routes (to
ensure optimal access and exposure);
- the ability of land-uses and building forms to act as noise buffers to
external noise sources such as major roads, railways or industries;
- the capacity of potential mixed-use lots, initially developed for
housing, to efficiently convert to or add a business use; and
- opportunities to allocate highly accessible strategic sites on
transport routes to larger scale industrial or distribution uses.
It is therefore necessary to try to attain the highest residential densities
and greater mix of land use along major connection streets and in close
proximity to commercial concentrations”.
8.6.4 PUBLIC UTILITIES
“Utilities are, for the purposes of this sub-chapter, defined as
engineering services including water, sanitation, roads, stormwater
drainage, energy supply, solid-waste removal, communications in the
form of telephones, and postal collection and delivery”.
![Page 18: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
West View ©
Service provision is addressed comprehensively in the Engineers
Services Report.
8.7 COMPLIANCE WITH THE uMHLATHUZE LAND USE SCHEME
The proposed subdivision falls within the uMhlathuze Land Use Scheme
2014.
The Scheme sets minimum subdivision sizes as follows:
ERF ZONING MINIMUM SIZE
PRESCRIBED PROPOSED ERF SIZE
16064 Mixed Use Low Impact 400 m2 24 099 m2
16065 Service Station 2400 m2 4 112 m2
15791 Conservation n/a 1 420 m2
15792 Public Open Space n/a 2 627 m2
16304 Existing Public Road n/a 596 m2
Minimum subdivision sizes, proposed zonings and definitions comply with the
requirements set out in terms of the Scheme.
No negative impact on existing zonings, existing property developments and
rights in the area is envisaged as the proposed development of Expansion
Area H will change the character of the area as a whole in terms of the
guidelines imposed by the SDF.
8.8 ANALYSIS OF ANY PREJUDICE TO BE CAUSED
No prejudice caused by the proposal could be identified at this stage of the
application procedure (i.e. prior to public participation).
9. MERITS OF THE APPLICATION
The merits of an application related to land use or a change thereof, are based
on compliance with the following three elements:
9.1 SPATIAL PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT ACT, 2013
9.1.1 DEVELOPMENT PRINCIPLES
The following general principles for land development as contemplated
in Section 7 of SPLUMA, would be applicable to the proposal:
(a) The principle of spatial sustainability
The municipality is capable to process and consider land use
applications. The Property is not classified as high potential agricultural
![Page 19: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
West View ©
land and due to its size it is not an economical unit. Environmental
management instruments will apply on the same basis as to all
surrounding approved land use applications in terms of the National
Environmental Management Act, 1998.
This principle requires that the private sector’s involvement in land
development should be encouraged and that there should not be
interference in the normal operation of the free market mechanism. This
is evident when reference is made to the fact that the developer intends
to develop the land in an open market in general compliance with this
provision.
Bulk contributions will be payable which will contribute to the
development/upgrading of infrastructure in other areas in need thereof.
The development will function in an urban area, contributing to the
optimized usage of services and land within demarcated boundaries as
defined by the urban edge, resulting in a viable mixed use community.
(b) The principle of efficiency
This principle relates to both private and public sectors. Access roads
and existing infrastructure are optimized as existing networks are
available. Obligations are placed on the municipality to apply decision-
making and application procedures with minimal negative effects with
adherence to prescribed time-frames. In this regard the decision-
making authorities are committed to efficient and effective procedures
to facilitate speedy development.
(c) The principle of spatial resilience
This principle places certain obligations on municipal spatial plans,
policies and land use management systems to be flexible in order to
ensure sustainable communities sensitive to economic and
environmental impacts. The Property is not situated in an area where
such communities exist.
(d) The principle of good administration
The application had been circulated to relevant Governmental and
Provincial Departments and Institutions for comments in terms of its
policies and applicable legislation to ensure an integrated approach.
The application procedure prescribed in the By-law provides for
notification to interested and/or affected parties. The public had been
afforded the opportunity to inspect supporting documentation in respect
![Page 20: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
West View ©
of the development proposal, object and submit comments, thereby
allowing for adequate public consultation and participation as required
in the relevant legislation.
9.1.2 SECTION 42(1)(c) OF SPLUMA
In terms of Section 42(1)(c) of the Spatial Planning and Land Use
Management Act, 2013, the Municipal Planning Tribunal must consider
the following matters when making a decision relating to a land
development application:
(i) The public interest
The public interest will be determined by the public participation
process. Negative comments will be addressed in terms of Schedule 5A
Item 14 of the uMhlathuze Spatial Planning and Land Use By-law. The
public will benefit from the proposed development as property values
will increase as development potential is unlocked.
(ii) The constitutional transformation imperatives and related
duties of the State
The duties of the State and the CoU include the constitutional obligation
to ensure that all have equal access opportunities to development to
comply with transformation goals.
(iii) The facts and circumstances relevant to the application
These elements relate to the market for residential development and
the supporting policies thereto. The area had been identified by the
CoU for residential development and the proposed commercial node
will support such residential development. Engineering services had
been planned for. The Property is situated in an area which is a logical
expansion for Empangeni to the west. The market is ready for the
proposed development.
(iv) The respective rights and obligations of all those affected
All affected and interested parties have the right to exploit and accept
development in a free market economy, provided it conforms with policy
and legislation. The CoU is obliged to process such applications in a
responsible and effective manner to the benefit of all concerned.
(v) The state and impact of engineering services, social
infrastructure and open space requirements
Engineering services had been investigated by professional engineers
and found to be adequate with capacity. The impact thereof on the
![Page 21: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
West View ©
infrastructure will be calculated by the CoU and provided for by the
payment of services bulk contributions. The proposed development will
not require additional social infrastructure as it will only be a place of
business that will rely on existing places of residence, schools,
churches and recreational facilities that is provided for in the vicinity.
(vi) Any factors that may be prescribed, including timeframes
for making decisions
The timeframes for the processing of the application is enshrined in the
By-law and decision-making will be effected within the period as
prescribed.
9.2 SUSTAINABILITY
Sustainability is the most important aspect of any long term enterprise,
and relies on the following elements:
9.2.1 ENGINEERING SERVICES
An Engineering Services Design Report for the extended West View
Development was undertaken by DMV Consultants during July 2010, as
part of the planning application submitted in terms of the DFA, which is
attached as Annexure E.
For the purpose of the commercial and filling station development, an
Addendum to this report was prepared, which is attached as Annexure
F.
The report concludes as follows:
a) Stormwater:
All Stormwater Designs will conform to the "Red Book - Guidelines
for Human Settlement Planning and Design" and accordingly the
Stormwater Drainage Network comprises a piped/channelled system
discharging into natural watercourses independent of any other
services systems such as Water and Sewer.
The Commercial Site will be graded to ensure free flow of runoff and
to prevent ponding of water in areas where grading of natural
ground is necessary. This will be easily achieved by following the
gradient of the natural ground.
![Page 22: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
West View ©
The surface run-off area pertaining to the commercial allotment
equals 30 942 m2 and the run-off per m² has been determined at
0,046f/s under a maximum 1 in 5 Year Flood Condition. Hence the
total maximum floodwater run-off parameter determined equals
1413 Sf/s, but with an average rain condition stormwater run-off of
859,5t/s. The piped network will be designed accordingly.
All Stormwater Pipes will be installed in accordance with the
standards and requirements of SANS 1200 and Stormwater
Catchpits, Manholes and Headwalls etc will be designed in
accordance with the requirements of the City of Umhlathuze.
Any outlet or other areas that may possibly be susceptible to erosion
will be protected by means of gabions, grassing I anti-erosion
vegetation cultivation or any other water-energy dissipation
methodology.
b) Water
Average annual daily demand = 400f /day per 100 m2 of commercial
land with a Peak factor of 4.0
Fire water demand = l00f/sec for 4,0 hours assuming 4 hydrants
open at a time for the whole development including commercial
land.
Hillview Reservoir is deemed the most suitable source for the bulk .
supply of water to the proposed development.
Initially, a 250mm uPVC water connection is proposed off the
existing ¢ 400mm uPVC municipal main supplying line to Tronox
KZN Sands which will distribute into a network of the internal water
reticulation including the commercial allotment
c) Sewer
The sewer demand associated with the proposed Commercial Land
Allotment is as follows :-
Average annual daily demand = 400 t/day per 100m2 of Commercial
and with a Peak Factor of 2,0.
![Page 23: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
West View ©
The average annual daily sewer demand may be regarded as
124kl/day as can be referenced in the 2010 Report.
As indicated in the 2010 Report, all internal sewer reticulation for
entire development will mainly drain into a 250mm ¢ main that
gravitates to the sump manhole at the intersection of the main road
no. 230 and Gwala Gwala Avenue. Additional sewer will drain into
another 250 mm ¢ main further north, draining towards the pump
station. From the pump station the sewer is pumped south to the
sump manhole from where it gravitates to the pump station east of
Qalakabusha Prison. The existing 250 mm ¢ sewer main from
Hillview to the pump station will be upgraded to a 300 mm ¢ due to
the reduced capacity resulting from the new development.
Since the Addendum to the 2010 report, the coverage for Erf 16064
(Mixed use low impact) had been amended from 100% to 50%, and
the FSR from 1,00 to 0,50. The coverage for Erf 16065 (Service
station) had been amended from 40% to 60%, and the FSR from
0,40 to 0,50.
The amendments had been provided to DMV Consultants in order to
amend its Addendum if necessary. Pages 4 and 5 of the Addendum
had been revised on 8 May 2018, as indicated at the top of the
mentioned pages.
9.2.2 ACCESS, ROADS AND TRAFFIC IMPACT ASSESSMENT
Access to the development will be via a road to be constructed (Erf
16304), which intersects with Provincial Road P230 opposite the
entrance to Tronox KZN Sands.
The intension is to extend Erf 16304 to provide access to the X1
development in future. At this stage, however, the road will consist of a
cul-de-sac configuration, and for this purpose it is proposed to register a
temporary road servitude over Erf 16064 (shown on the layout plan).
During 2015 and as part of an environmental impact assessment for
the proposed filing station, a TIA was concluded, and conditions that
have been reflected in the draft Conditions of Establishment The KZN
Department of Transport replied with positive comments (see
Annexure G and Section 10 of this report).
![Page 24: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
West View ©
For the purpose of this application, an updated TIA had been
concluded by Pieter Wilken during August 2017 (Annexure H). The
report concludes that:
the traffic generated by the development could be accommodated
on the street network. The Tronox intersection with the P230 route
is to be upgraded to make provision for the required traffic
movements, and approval of such intersection was granted by the
KZN Department of Transport, subject to conditions;
the access road to the new development must be constructed to the
satisfaction of the municipality and according to the minimum
design guidelines applicable to access roads;
all parking should be provided on the sites. No direct parking would
be allowed from the adjacent roadways;
all off-loading facilities must be provided on site in accordance to
the land use scheme of the municipality. All turning facilities for
goods vehicles must be provided on site to prevent reversing onto
streets. Sufficient manoeuvring space is to be provided at loading
bays where heavy vehicles are to circulate;
public transport facilities, bus and taxi bays, are to be provided
along the main road where workers and visitors to the development
sites could be dropped off and picked up;
it is not expected that the development would generate a large
number of pedestrian volumes. The site (complete development
including development of X1) is however expected to generate a
substantial number of taxi trips. Specific provision must therefore be
made on the commercial site for the provision of taxi loading and
holding areas; and
The developers are to construct all boundary and internal roads as
required for township development at their own cost and pay the
required road contribution.
The KZN Department of Transport considered the updated TIA and
recommended the following in accordance with their letter dated 7
March 2018 which is attached as Annexure I:
That there is no objection to the application;
Proposed slip lanes as per paragraph 7.9 of the Traffic Impact
Assessment will not be allowed;
Only one access to Provincial Road P230 will be allowed;
The Site Development Plan must comply with the Department of
Transport’s requirements.
![Page 25: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
West View ©
These comments are accepted and will be included in the Site
Development Plan when submitted after approval of this application.
Since the updated August 2017 TIA, the coverage for Erf 16064
(Mixed use low impact) had been amended from 100% to 50%, and
the FSR from 1,00 to 0,50. The coverage for Erf 16065 (Service
station) had been amended from 40% to 60%, and the FSR from
0,40 to 0,50.
The initial trip generation for the commercial node had been
calculated in August 2017 at 2 625 trips/day. The amendments had
been provided to Pieter Wilken in order to amend his updated TIA,
which is attached as Annexure J. It concludes that the trip
generation had been calculated to 4 933 trips/day and that the
increase will have no effect on the conclusions and
recommendations contained in the August 2017 report.
9.2.3 ELECTRICAL SERVICES
An Electrical Engineering Services Design Report for the extended
West View Development was undertaken by Motla Consulting
Engineers (Pty) Ltd. during June 2008, as part of the planning
application submitted in terms of the DFA, which is attached as
Annexure K.
For the purpose of the commercial and filling station development, an
Addendum to this report was prepared during May 2017, which is
attached as Annexure L.
The report concludes as follows:
The filling station and commercial development would require a
1 596 kVA electricity supply;
The developer would be responsible for any cost with regards to the
connection to the existing electricity grid.
Since the May 2017 Addendum, the coverage for Erf 16064 (Mixed
use low impact) had been amended from 100% to 50%, and the
FSR from 1,00 to 0,50. The coverage for Erf 16065 (Service station)
had been amended from 40% to 60%, and the FSR from 0,40 to
0,50.
The amendments had been provided to Motla Consulting Engineers
(Pty) Ltd in order to revise its Addendum if necessary, and in its
![Page 26: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
West View ©
letter dated 8 May 2018 (Annexure M), confirmed that the effect on
the electrical services will be minimal.
9.2.4 ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY
On 19 January 2010, the (then) KZN Department of Agriculture,
Environmental Affairs and Rural Development approved the West View
Residential Development, consisting of various land uses including
residential, commercial, roads, etc (Application No. DC28/0024/07 –
Annexure N).
An application was submitted to the Department of Economic
Development, Tourism and Environmental Affairs to amend the
authorisation, which amendment was granted on 16 October 2017
(Annexure O). The completion date for the development has been
extended to 31 December 2023.
In addition, the developer also obtained environmental authorisation on
4 August 2016 for the development of the proposed filling station on
proposed Erf 16065 (attached as Annexure P).
The authorisations do not impact on this planning application, but must
be implemented and adhered to during construction.
9.2.5 SOCIO-ECONOMICAL SUSTAINABILITY
The provision of employment and training with adequate services is
imperative to any proposed development. Supportive uses will
compliment the socio-economical well-being of the proposed
development.
9.2.6 HERITAGE SUSTAINABILITY
No element of historical value is present on the Property.
9.2.7 GEOTECHNICAL SUSTAINABILITY
Geotechnical investigations proved the soil conditions to be stable, with
certain conditions for foundations.
Details of the Geotechnical Assessment are provided under section
6.3.2 of this report.
9.2.8 FLOOD LINE
None of the proposed erven is situated below these flood lines as
certified in the engineering services report.
![Page 27: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
West View ©
9.2.9 AGRICULTURAL SUSTAINABILITY
Although the proposed development will be constructed on agricultural
land, no impact thereon will be imposed. The Property had been
exempted from the provisions of the Subdivision of Agricultural Land
Act, 1970 by the Department of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries
(Annexure Q).
9.2.10 LAND RESTITUTION
The Regional Land Claims Commissioner confirmed in their letter dated
8 August 2017 that no claim for restitution had been lodged in respect
of the Property (Annexure R).
9.2.11 ECONOMIC SUSTAINABILITY
A Market Study was undertaken by Urban Studies during September
2015 (Annexure S) for the proposed filling station. The main focus of
the market research is to quantify the potential for a proposed service
station and the impact on the existing stations.
The report concludes that, with an expected increase in volumes and
car ownership, the impact on filling stations in Empangeni will be
between 4% and 8%. This is low enough to warrant development in
future. The proposed development will focus strongly on the expected
residential growth.
The number of vehicles using the road per day is low and the
warranted litreage is less than the required volumes for establishing a
filling station at this stage.
The expected number of users will double with the development of
5 500 housing units. The most important aspect regarding this
development is the fact that all vehicles into the residential area will
have to drive past the filling station.
The projected West View development and its completion within the
next 5-10 years, as well as the increase in current vehicle volumes
passing the site, the potential for a filling station will double from
± 150 000 litres to between 270 000 and 330 000 litres per month by
2020 - 2025.
The TIA, however, predicts the sale of approximately 532 900 litres per
month.
![Page 28: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
West View ©
9.3 NEED AND DESIRABILITY
9.3.1 NEED
The need for a proposed use is defined by the lack thereof in a given
society or region, inclusive of secondary services and subservient uses.
The CoU has concluded its IDP and SDF based on economic
investigations and growth expectations. These policy documents
provide sufficient information for prospective developers to invest in the
economy of the municipality, province and national.
Based on the findings of the Market Study and the TIA, the need for the
service station had been proven.
The approval of this application is viable, based on the following:
In terms of the By-law the developer has 5 years to complete the
development. West View and West View Extension X1will be developed
within this period which will result in the viability of the proposed service
station;
Town planning is not restricted to present developments – it is also
responsible for future land uses within policy frameworks. It is expected
that there is a growing need for convenience shopping and a filling
station in the vicinity of the Hillview and the newly incorporated
Macecane community. This need will continue to grow if the West View
X1 development is approved for development.
9.3.2 DESIRABILITY
The desirability of a land use is determined by the suitability of a
property for a specific use. Access, environmental and other issues,
noise and pollution generation, availability of services and locality in
relation to its marked are factors to consider.
The suitability of the subject property is evident as the proposed
development complies with all policies.
The current agricultural character of Expansion Area H will be impacted
on, but as the proposed development is in line with the SDF, it is to be
expected as economic development is the backbone of any
municipality. Also, the area has been released from the provisions of
the Subdivision of Agricultural Land Act, Act 70 of 1970. No element of
cultural heritage to be protected is present on the Property.
![Page 29: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
West View ©
The impact of the proposed development will be of a positive nature on
existing land uses in the CoU as it will be supportive of the
manufacturing, export and trade industrial economy of scale.
Municipal resources to the proposed development are adequate and
available. The arterial roads will enhance accessibility for policing and
emergency services.
No compensation is applicable as the registered owners are
responsible for the proposed development.
No past racially discriminatory and segregatory legislation need to be
addressed for historical imbalances. The proposed development will
provide much needed engineering services and job creation attributes.
10. PROPOSED CONDITIONS OF ESTABLISHMENT
NOTICE OF DECISION REGARDING AN APPLICATION SUBMITTED IN
TERMS OF SECTION 27(1)(a) AND (f) OF THE UMHLATHUZE SPATIAL
PLANNING AND LAND USE MANAGEMENT BY-LAW, 2017 ON PORTION 1
OF THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379, HELD UNDER DEED OF
TRANSFER T61202/2007 FOR THE CREATION OF DESIGNATED ERVEN
15791, 15792, 16064, 16065 AND 16304 SITUATED IN THE UMHLATHUZE
MUNICIPAL AREA, REGISTRATION DIVISION GU, PROVINCE OF
KWAZULU- NATAL
With reference to your application proposed on behalf of Cosmic Gold Trading
364(Pty) Ltd the Municipality is pleased to approve the application in terms of
Section 42(3)(b) of the uMhlathuze Spatial Planning and Land Use Management
By-law, 2017 (“By-law”) and in accordance with the accompanying Layout Plan
No. WV/221/2018 dated March 2018 (Municipal Reference …………), subject to
the following conditions imposed in terms of section 43(2)(c) of the By-law:
A. REGISTRATION ARRANGEMENTS
1. Designation
The name of the development shall be West View, which name is to be
confirmed by the Surveyor-General.
The layout as indicated on Layout Plan No. WV/221/2018 dated March 2018
(Municipal Reference ……….), shall be designated as Erven numbered 15791,
15792, 16064, 16065 and 16304, West View.
![Page 30: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
West View ©
2. Lodging of General Plan/s or SG Diagrams with the Surveyor General’s
Office
The owner shall lodge the General Plan/s or diagrams relating to the proposed
development with the Surveyor General for approval.
3. Lodging in the Deeds Office
When registration is sought, a copy of this decision, the approved diagrams
together with the deeds and other documents that the Registrar of Deeds may
require for the registration of the erven, as well as the certificate contemplated by
Sections 48(1) of the By-law are to be lodged.
4. Reserved subdivisions
The following subdivisions shall be reserved for the purposes set out below:
4.1 Roads
The following erf is to be reserved as “Roads” and is to be transferred to
the uMhlathuze Municipality at no cost upon completion of the
development :-
Erf 16304
4.2 Conservation
The following erf is to be reserved for conservation purposes and is to be
transferred to the uMhlathuze Municipality, at no cost to the Municipality
upon completion of the development.
Erf 15791
4.3 Public Open Space
The following erf is to be reserved as Public Open Space and is to be
transferred to the uMhlathuze Municipality, at no cost to the Municipality
upon completion of the development :-
Erf 15792
5. Temporary Road Servitude
Designated Erf 16064 shall be subject to the registration of a temporary road
servitude in favour of the Municipality.
![Page 31: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
West View ©
The configuration of the servitude in the form of a turning circle shall be
determined in coordination with the Municipality, is to be surveyed in accordance
with the Survey Regulations and registered in favour of the Municipality prior to or
simultaneously with the first registration.
B. COMPLIANCE WITH CONDITIONS
Prior to the issuing of the certificate as contemplated in sections 48(1) of the By-
law, the owner must comply with the following conditions, to the satisfaction of
the local municipality:
1. Acceptance of Conditions
The owner is to signify in writing to the Municipality, formal acceptance of the
conditions subject to which this application is approved.
2. Approved General Plan / SG Diagrams
The owner shall submit to the Municipality, a certified copy of the approved
General Plan / diagram/s within 30 days after the date on which the Surveyor–
General has approved the diagram/s.
3. Provision of Engineering Services
The owner shall, to the satisfaction of the municipality, provide for engineering
services in respect of each Erf to be transferred.
The owner shall provide for the following engineering services in respect of each
Erf to be transferred and to the satisfaction of the municipality, or where the
municipality is not the supplier of a particular service, to the satisfaction of the
relevant service authority.
Written proof of compliance from the authority concerned will be required in
respect of each condition.
The owner shall act on the advice of a professional engineer in respect of any
work done in compliance with the conditions. For the purposes of this condition,
a “professional engineer” shall mean:-
“a person who is registered as a professional engineer in terms of the
Engineering Professions Act, 2000 (No. 46 of 2000) and who possesses cognate
experience in the particular branch of engineering applicable to the service under
consideration”.
![Page 32: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
West View ©
The owner shall enter into a services agreement with the municipality and obtain
the necessary approvals from the Municipality and/or service authority prior to
construction.
a) Water and Sanitation
The owner shall provide a supply of potable water and an efficient and sanitary
system for the disposal of sewage and waste water to within the normal
connection distance of the boundary of Erven 16064 and 16065 and to the
satisfaction of the Municipality, in line with the responsibilities as set out in the
Services Agreement to be concluded. The application may be subject to payment
of bulk engineering contributions, in line with Council’s Policy and Annual Tariff of
Charges.
The outcomes and recommendations of the civil engineering report by DMV
Consultants dated July 2010, and the Addendum thereto dated April 2017, or
such updated version as may be required by the Municipality, must be
implemented at the cost of the owner.
b) Electricity
The owner shall provide an efficient supply of electricity to within the normal
connection distance of the boundary of Erven 16064 and 16065 and to the
satisfaction of the Municipality, in line with the responsibilities as set out in the
Services Agreement to be concluded.
The outcomes and recommendations of the electrical services report by Motla
Engineering dated 23 June 2008, and the Addendum thereto dated 22 May 2017
and 8 May 2018, or such updated version as may be required by the Municipality,
must be implemented at the cost of the owner.
The application may be subject to payment of bulk engineering contributions, in
line with Council’s Policy and Annual Tariff of Charges.
c) Access and Roads:
The owner shall construct the road referred to in the application as Erf 16304 and
a turning circle over the temporary road servitude indicated on the layout plan,
and provide adequate access to each site and to the satisfaction of the
Municipality, in line with the responsibilities as set out in the Services Agreement
to be concluded.
![Page 33: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
West View ©
The outcomes and recommendations of the civil engineering report by DMV
Consultants dated July 2010, and the Addendum thereto dated April 2017, as
well as the Traffic Impact Assessment by Pieter Wilken, dated August 2017
(revised April 2018), or such updated version/s as may be required by the
Municipality, must be implemented at the cost of the owner.
The application is subject to payment of bulk engineering contributions, in line
with Council’s Policy and Annual Tariff of Charges.
In addition, the applicant must comply with the requirements of the KZN
Department of Transport, as per their letter dated 7 March 2018.
Prior to any development taking place and in terms of section 21 of the Kwazulu-
Natal Provincial Road Act No. 4 of 2001, 5 copies of a detailed to-scale site
development plan showing the property boundary with co-ordinates, elevations
and sections and adhering to the following conditions, are to be submitted first to
the Municipality’s Land Use Management and Transportation Sections and then
to the Department of Transport for assessment, comment and approval:
- Main road 230 has an expropriated road reserve width of 30 metres
measured 15 metres on either side of the constructed road centre line;
- In terms of section 13 of the Kwazulu-Natal Provincial Roads Act No. 4 of
2001, no buildings or any structure including the positioning of bowsers,
canopies, fuel holding tanks, etc. whatsoever, other than a fence, hedge or
wall which does not rise higher than 2,1 metres above the surface of the
land on which it stands, shall be erected on the land within a distance of
15 metres measured from the road reserve boundary of Main Road 230;
- Access to Main Road 230 shall be designed by a registered professional
engineer, in consultation with the Design Engineer Head Office, KZN
Department of Transport, to a type “B2” blacktop standard with double
right turn refuge lanes symmetrical about the centre line of Main Road
230. The design (inclusive of pavement design obtainable from Design
Engineer: Department of Transport) in accordance with the design check
list and the Department’s standard detail SD 0305/c) shall be submitted
first to the Municipality’s Transportation Section and then to the
Department of Transport for approval.
- Adequate parking facilities must be provided within each site as per the
requirements of the uMhlathuze Land Use Scheme.
- Public transport facilities shall be provided as required by the Municipality
and as detailed in the Traffic Impact Assessment.
- When the necessity for the signalization of the intersection is required,
application must be made to Mr. W. Gorny, Head Office, accompanied by
![Page 34: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
West View ©
the warrants and a detailed traffic Signal layout design plan for his
approval.
d) Stormwater Management
The owner shall provide infrastructure necessary for the control and disposal of
stormwater from each application site and to the satisfaction of the Municipality
and in line with the responsibilities as set out in the Services Agreement.
The outcomes and recommendations of the civil engineering report by DMV
Consultants dated July 2010, and the Addendum thereto dated April 2017, or
such updated version as may be required by the Municipality, must be
implemented at the cost of the owner.
In addition, the applicant must comply with the requirements of the KZN
Department of Transport, as per their letter dated 7 March 2018.
The owner/s attention is drawn to the relevant stormwater clause contained in
section 12 of the Kwazulu-Natal Provincial Roads Act No. 4 of 2001, and section
5 of the Roads regulations, wherein it is advised that the disposal of stormwater
emanating from the road reserve through the layout, or any stormwater
emanating from the layout through the road reserve, shall be indicated on a
detailed to-scale site development plan which is to be submitted to the KZN
Department of Transport for assessment and comments. The implementation of
stormwater disposal shall be undertaken in consultation with and to the
satisfaction of the Department’s Cost Centre Manager, Eshowe (Telephone: 035
474-2031) during the development of the property concerned.
C. CONDITIONS TO BE MET DURING DEVELOPMENT
1. Outcomes of the Geotechnical Assessment
The outcomes and recommendations of the Geotechnical Assessment by Davies
Lynn and Partners (Pty) Ltd., dated August 2007, shall be implemented at the
cost of the owner.
2. Environmental Authorisation
Any development shall be subject to the conditions as contained in the environmental approvals:
- EIA DC28/0024/07 (as amended); and
- EIA DC28/0003/2016
![Page 35: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
West View ©
D. PROPOSED CONDITIONS OF TITLE
1. Designated Erven 16064 and 16065 located within “West View” shall be
subject to the following conditions:-
a) Omnibus servitude for services
The land shall be subject to a servitude in favour of the local municipality and any
other relevant service provider for the provision of storm-water drainage, water
supply, irrigation, sewerage, electricity, gas/or fuel supply, telecommunications,
radio and television services, over or under the land, along any boundary thereof,
other than a road frontage and within a distance of 2 m from such boundary.
Reasonable access shall be provided to such servitude at all times for the
purpose of installation, maintenance, removal or extension of such services.
The owner of the land shall, without compensation, be obliged to allow the
servicing of any other land or street to be conveyed along such servitude,
provided that if the owner of the land is aggrieved by the unreasonable exercise
of these rights, he shall have the right of appeal.
Maintenance shall include cutting, trimming or otherwise dealing with vegetation
so as to prevent interference with any service. The Municipality, or any other
body or person legally authorized to provide such services, shall exercise the
right conferred by this condition for the benefit of the inhabitants of the township.
b) Deposit of Material
The owner of the land shall, without compensation, be obliged to permit such
deposit of material or excavation on the land as may, in connection with the
formation of any street in the township and owing to differences in level between
the land and the street, be deemed necessary by the responsible authority, in
order to provide a safe and proper slope to the cut and fill commencing from the
boundary of the land, unless he/she shall elect, at his own cost, to building a
retaining wall.
2. Designated Erf 16064 shall be subject to the following condition:
a) Temporary Road Servitude
A temporary road is to be established on Erf 16064. Such temporary road is to
be registered as a road servitude in favour of the Municipality in such a manner
that it shall lapse when the Municipality certifies that Erf 16304 has been
![Page 36: CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL PLANNERS · THE FARM LOT 221 EMPANGENI NO. 10379 REGISTRATION DIVISION GU PREPARED FOR: COSMIC GOLD TRADING 364 (PTY) LTD by CITIPLAN TOWN AND REGIONAL](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042918/5f5dfdb214f4056272364a10/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
West View ©
extended to the satisfaction of the Municipality to serve a future extension of
West View.
3. Designated Erven 15791, 16064 and 16065 located within “West View”
shall be subject to the following conditions:
The properties shall have no direct access from Provincial Road P230.
4. Designated Erven 16064, 16065, 15791 and the Remainder of Portion 1 of
the farm Lot 221 Empangeni No. 10379 shall be subject to the following
condition:
a) Building Line (Department of Transport: KwaZulu-Natal)
In terms of section 13 of the Kwazulu-Natal Provincial Roads Act No. 4 of
2001, no buildings or any structure including the positioning of bowsers,
canopies, fuel holding tanks, etc. whatsoever, other than a fence, hedge or
wall which does not rise higher than 2,1 metres above the surface of the land
on which it stands, shall be erected on the land within a distance of 15 metres
measured from the road reserve boundary of Main Road 230.
In terms of section 13 of the Kwazulu-Natal Provincial Roads Act No. 4 of
2001, no service roads or parking as required in the Land Use Scheme, shall
be erected within a distance of 7,5 metres measured from the road reserve
boundary of Main Road 230.
11. CONCLUSION
The application complies with all aspects of legislation, policy and sustainability
on which the merits thereof rely.