clean energy investment in developing countries: wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · ;:6$%?$ $...

10
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·V )LU), 34,+:&41 A:**%&+54,+:& ,: ,6( $&+,(' 34,+:&) K-4*(0:-9 A:&?(&,+:& :& A1+*4,( A64&E( ;$3KAAA@2 +, (X4*+&(' ,6( ?%1&(-4M+1+,= :. +,) 4E-+5%1,%-(2 .:-(),)2 04,(-2 5:4),41 4-(4) 4&' .+)6+&E -():%-5() ,: ,6( +*G45,) :. 51+*4,( ;AL3B#B2

Upload: others

Post on 19-Jan-2021

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · ;:6$%?$ $ "#$%&'(!)*!+,-.& $ "#$%&'(! $$ $)*!+,-.&(! %!!!!!"#$

!

!"#$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8),/9#4:%-'60#!

!"#$ %&'()$

"#$! "%&'()*+&+),(-+%*)!./-!$*0(1,2!34,%-)56%,7!%&'!8(49,:-+)56(-6(+,!;<(-*4&!#+&+),-=!.:-!,6(!>&?+-:&*(&,@!ABCD>! A(&,-:!BE-:&F*+5:!C-:G+541!'(!D&?(),+E45+F&!=!>&)(H4&74!;IG4+&@!;C-:G+541!BE-+5%1,%-(!8()(4-56!4&'!J+E6(-!

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

),! 34,+:&41! A:**%&+54,+:&! ,:! ,6(! $&+,('! 34,+:&)! K-4*(0:-9! A:&?(&,+:&! :&! A1+*4,(! A64&E(! ;$3KAAA@2! +,!(X4*+&('! ,6(!?%1&(-4M+1+,=!:.! +,)!4E-+5%1,%-(2! .:-(),)2!04,(-2!5:4),41!4-(4)!4&'!.+)6+&E!-():%-5()! ,:! ,6(! +*G45,)!:.!51+*4,(! ;AL3B#B2!

Page 2: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · ;:6$%?$ $ "#$%&'(!)*!+,-.& $ "#$%&'(! $$ $)*!+,-.&(! %!!!!!"#$

!

!"#$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8),/9#4:%-'60#!

"###$%! &'()*+'! ,-.! /0-,)102! 32,40-5! 3'01+5! 67-,)1! 8201! 93:/6;6<! "##=$<! 3',25! '0.! .,175! >(,)(,-,?5@! -'5! A)22)B,1+! .57-)(.! A)(!

0@0>-0-,)1!07-,)1C!B0-5(D!E,)@,F5(.,-GD! 0+(,7*2-*(5<! 2,F5.-)7H!01@!A)(5.-(GD!515(+GD! ,1A(0.-(*7-*(5!01@!7)0.-02!*(E01!?)15.D! A,.'5(,5.D!01@!

'502-'%!I,-',1!-'5.5!.57-)(.<!2,15.!)A!07-,)1!>()>).5@!EG!-'5!/0-,)102!32,40-5!3'01+5!67-,)1!8201!93:/6;6<!"##=$!0(5C!

!"#$%&'(#")! 5F02*0-5! 72,40-5! 7'01+5! 5AA57-.! )1! -'5! 'G@()2)+,702! 7G725D! *>@0-5! B0-5(! E020175.! ,1! 7(,-,702! 0(50.D! >()J57-! A*-*(5!0F0,20E,2,-G!)A!B0-5(!A)(!7)1.*4>-,)1!01@!>()@*7-,)1D!>()J57-!'G@()2)+,702! -([email protected]!@5.,+1!0K*,A5(!4)1,-)(,1+!.G.-54.D!0@F0175!

51+0+5451-.!40@5!,1!-'5!/0-,)102!L-(0-5+G!A)(!M1-5+(0-5@!I0-5(.'5@!;010+5451-D!5N57*-5!.-*@G!)1!B0-5(!*.5!01@!5AA,7,517GD!

0>>2G!B0-5(!E020175!4)@52.!-)!1)1O(5+*20-5@!B0-5(.'[email protected]!7(50-5!01!51F,()1451-02!(5.50(7'!751-5(!A)(!-'5!1)(-'5([email protected](-<!B,-'!0!

A)7*.!)1!B0-5(D!E*,2@[email protected],10-,)1!>201-.!,1!1)(-'5(1!3',25D!>*-!20B.!)1!,((,+0-,)1!01@!70102!(5'0E,2,-0-,)1!,1-)!>(07-,75D!5N57*-5!

.-*@,5.!)1!)7501)+(0>'G!01@!45-5)()2)+G!)A!40(,15!E,)@,F5(.,-G!01@!.*E40(,15!4)(>')2)+GD!01@!E*,2@!0!E)0-!A)(!(5.50(7'!)1!

40(,15!E,)@,F5(.,-G!01@!)-'5(!-)>,7.%!

*+,-+.#"$+(/)!PF02*0-5!-'5!5AA57-.!)A!72,40-5!7'01+5! ,1!0(50.!)A!',+'!51F,()1451-02!F02*5!01@! ,1-5(5.-D!0102G?5!5AA57-.!)A!72,40-5!7'01+5! )1! .>57,5.D! ,1,-,0-5! -'5! (5'0E,2,-0-,)1! )A! @5+(0@5@! .G.-54.D! 01@! @5F52)>! 0! >()J57-! )1! -5((5.-(,02! ,1A2*5175! )A! 72,40-5!

7'01+5%!

01"+234(3"#56 4+.#$(,276 '8-6 9,"#$("/)! 6102G?5! 72,40-5! F*215(0E,2,-G! 01@! 0@0>-0-,)1D! .G.-540-,?5! >)2,7,5.! 01@! .-(0-5+,5.D! 5F02*0-5!.)7,)57)1)4,7! ,4>07-.! )A! 72,40-5! 7'01+5D! ,@51-,AG! 0@0>-0-,)1! 450.*(5.! 01@! >()J57-.<! ,1! >0(-,7*20(! A)(! .4022O.7025! A0(45(.D!

@5F52)>!0!0+()O72,40-,7!(,.H!4010+5451-!.G.-54D!5N57*-5!0!+515-,7! ,4>()F5451-!>()+(04!-)!@5F52)>!0@0>-5@!0+(,7*2-*(02!01@!

A)(5.-(G!F0(,5-,5.D!01@!>()4)-5!5AA,7,51-!B0-5(!*.5!,1!0+(,7*2-*(5%!

:8#"1/)!PF02*0-5!'G@()2)+,702!F*215(0E,2,-G!)A!-'5!515(+G!.57-)(!01@!,-.!5AA57-.!)1!515(+G!.57*(,-G!,1!3',25%! ;89"'$("32(3"#6 '8-6 2,'$('46 3"<'86 =,8#$)! P20E)(0-5! ,4>07-! .7510(,).! A)(! .*.75>-,E25! ,1A(0.-(*7-*(5! ,1! (,>0(,01! 01@! 7)0.-02! ?)15.D!57)1)4,7! 5F02*0-,)1! )A! ,4>07-.! 01@! >(5F51-,F5!450.*(5.D! 520E)(0-5! 7(,-5(,0! A)(! -'5! 0@0>-0-,)1! )A! (5+,)102! 545(+517G! >201.D!

0@J*.-!@5.,+1!)A!15B!E(,@+5.!01@!'G@()2)+,7!,1A(0.-(*7-*(5D!,17(50.5!,((,+0-5!.*(A075!EG!Q#!>5(!751-!-'()*+'!-'5!7)1.-(*7-,)1!)A!

[email protected]!5N>01@!,((,+0-,)1!01@!B0-5(!>)2,7,5.!-)!,172*@5!.4022!@04.<!0(-,A,7,02!0K*,A5(!(57'0(+5<!70102!(5A*(E,.'451-!01@!+207,5(!

4010+5451-D! 5N>01@! ,1A(0.-(*7-*(5! 01@! E0((,5(! >()+(04! ,1! (,>0(,01! 01@! 7)0.-02! 0(50.D! ,4>()F5! 70>07,-G! A)(! >(5@,7-,)1! 01@!

(5.>)1.5!)A!'G@()2)+,7!545(+517,5.<!,17)(>)(0-5!(5.*2-.!)A!,4>07-!.-*@,5.!,1-)!*(E01!>2011,1+!,1!7)0.-02!01@!(,>0(,01!?)15.D!01@!

,4>()F5!2,1H0+5.!E5-B551!*(E01!>2011,1+!-))2.!01@!.-*@,5.!)1!7)0.-.!01@!B0-5(.'5@.!7)1@*7-5@!EG!)-'5(!0+517,5.%!

!+$%#"+#$)6;)@52!@,.-(,E*-,)1!01@!0E*1@0175!)A!40(,15!.>57,5.!,1!077)(@0175!B,-'!72,40-5!7'01+5!.7510(,).D!01@!520E)(0-5!,4>07-!.7510(,).!)1!5N-(07-,)1!)A!40(,15!(5.)*(75.%!

>#'4(%)6P20E)(0-5!,4>07-!.7510(,).D!520E)(0-5!7(,-5(,0!A)(!0@0>-0-,)1D!57)1)4,7!5F02*0-,)1!)A!>(5F51-,F5!450.*(5.D!.-(51+-'51!-'5!70>07,-,5.!)A!'502-'!.-0AA! ,1!-'5!7)1-5N-!)A!7'01+,[email protected]! ,@51-,AG!F*215(0E25!0(50.!01@!>)>*20-,)1D!.-(51+-'51!4)1,-)(,1+! )A!

Page 3: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · ;:6$%?$ $ "#$%&'(!)*!+,-.& $ "#$%&'(! $$ $)*!+,-.&(! %!!!!!"#$

!

!"#

$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8),/9#4:%-'60#!

"#$%&'#("#)*+!,"*+),!$*&%*-+"./! %#)"&*0)!1%),!'),"&!."0)'&.! )'! %2"#)%34!,"*+),! %(5*0).!'3!0+%(*)"!0,*#6"/! .)&"#6),"#!*#2!0&"*)"!

#"1!0*5*0%)%".!)'!3*0"!4"++'1!3"$"&7!2"#68"!3"$"&!*#2!(*+*&%*!*#2!'),"&!$"0)'&!2%."*."./!*#2!%#0'&5'&*)"!0+%(*)"!0,*#6"!%(5*0).!

'#!,"*+),!%#)'!&%.9!(*#*6"("#)!-4!*2*5)%#6!('#%)'&%#6!.4.)"(.!*#2!"("&6"#04!5+*#.:!

!

!"#$%&'()%*#+,-,*#.(*'/',0#%)1#2&3%&,4'/#5(/67,)&0#;'!.855'&)!%).!&".5'#."!)'!0+%(*)"!0,*#6"7!*!<*)%'#*+!=2$%.'&4!>'((%))""!'#!?+'-*+!>,*#6"!1*.!".)*-+%.,"2!-4!%#!@AAB:!C)!1*.! 3%&.)!

,"*2"2!-4!),"!<*)%'#*+!D#$%&'#("#)!>'((%))""!E>F<=G=H!*#2!.%#0"!IJ@J!-4!),"!#"1+4!0&"*)"2!G%#%.)&4!3'&!D#$%&'#("#)!EGG=H:!

!*#2!

%).! &".5'#."!5+*##%#6!-4! ),"! 0&"*)%'#!'3!>,% <*)%'#*+!>+%(*)"!>,*#6"!K)&*)"64! %#! IJJB:!=2*5)*)%'#! %.!'#"!'3! ),"!

.)&*)"6%0!),"(".:!;,&""!'-L"0)%$".!3*++!8#2"&!),%.!),"("M!"#$%&'#("#)*+!*#2!.'0%'"0'#'(%0!%(5*0)!*.."..("#)7!2"3%#%)%'#!'3!*2*5)*)%'#!

("*.8&".!*#2!"N"08)%'#!'3!*#2!3'++'1O85!'#!*2*5)*)%'#!("*.8&".!;,"!.)&*)"64!%2"#)%3%".!9"4!0,*++"#6".!*.!-"%#6!%(5'&)*#)!9#'1+"26"!

6*5.! %#! )"&(.!'3! $8+#"&*-%+%)4! *#2! *2*5)*)%'#7! *.!1"++! *.! ),"! #""2! )'! %#)"6&*)"! *2*5)*)%'#! %#)'! 2"$"+'5("#)! 5+*#.! *)! 2%33"&"#)! +"$"+.:!

E>F<=G=7!IJJBH:!!

!

P%),!*!$%"1!)'!.5"0%34%#6!),"!.)&*)"6%0!+%#".!'3!),"!<*)%'#*+!>+%(*)"!>,*#6"!K)&*)"647!>F<=G=!EIJJQH!,*.!*+.'!"+*-'&*)"2!*!<*)%'#*+!

>+%(*)"!>,*#6"!=0)%'#!R+*#!3'&!),"!5"&%'2!IJJQ!)'!IJ@I:!C)!2".0&%-".!0+%(*)"!.0"#*&%'.!*#2!$8+#"&*-%+%)4!*.."..("#).7!*#2!0'#)*%#.!*!

2")*%+"2! +%.)! '3! .,'&)O! *#2! ("2%8(O)"&(! *0)%'#.! )'! *22&"..! 9#'1+"26"! *#2! 0*5*0%)4! 6*5.! %#! *2*5)*)%'#:! C)! *+.'! 0*++.! 3'&! *! #*)%'#*+!

*2*5)*)%'#! 5+*#7!1,%0,! ,*.! #')! 4")! -""#! 58-+%.,"2:! "! 0,*#6"!

E?'-%"&#'!2"!>,%+"7!IJ@@H:!

!!"#$%&'(&)%*&+,-%./0%/1&2,$343%5&"/6&7%8,.15&.%9$%413/:&;6"81"13,/&<%%65=&2.3,.313%5&"/6&2$"//%6&;413,/5&

<"0%&,9&2,$34*&;413,/& +,-%./0%/1&>3-353,/&7%58,/53#$%&

?1"1@5& ?%41,.A5B&,9&C,4@5& ?@00".*&6%54.3813,/&

;<# ='->/#?0/').03#+)::,.'60/').#/)#

/9%#@.'/%1#=-0:%()-A#

+).&%./').#).#+3':0/%#+90.B%##

+C?4D4# 8,E:'//%1#'.#

FGGG#

4B-'6,3/,-%H#*)-%>/>H#(0/%-H#

6)0>/03#0-%0>#0.1#*'>9'.B<#

+9'3% >#='->/#?0/').03#+)::,.'60/').#5-)&'1%>#

-%>,3/>#).#&,3.%-0E'3'/I#0>>%>>:%./>#*)-#0#.,:E%-#

)*#>%6/)-><##

F<# ?0/').03#+3':0/%#+90.B%#8/-0/%BI# +C?4D4J#?0/').03#

41&'>)-I#+)::'//%%#).#

K3)E03#+90.B%#

2,E3'>9%1#'.#

FGGL#

D,3/'M>%6/)-03# N9%#>/-0/%BI#1%>6-'E%>#069'%&%:%./>H#

)55)-/,.'/'%>#0.1#69033%.B%>#*)-#+9'3%#'.#/9%#

6)./%O/#)*#63':0/%#690.B%<#4105/0/').#'>#).%#)*#

/9-%%#>/-0/%B'6#/9%:%><#

P<# ?0/').03#+3':0/%#+90.B%#46/').# +C?4D4## 2,E3'>9%1#'.# =-%>9(0/%-#>,553IJ#E')1'&%->'/IJ# N9'>#1%/0'3%1#530.#30I>#),/#63':0/%#>6%.0-')>#0.1#

Page 4: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · ;:6$%?$ $ "#$%&'(!)*!+,-.& $ "#$%&'(! $$ $)*!+,-.&(! %!!!!!"#$

!

!"#$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8),/9#4:%-'60#!

!"#$%&'%(&)*+,%-+.*&/% 0&1$2/#$/.%3*1*4*&/%5$46&/4*7)$%

8.".94% 8$+.&2:4;%&'%<&+94% 89##"2,%=$4+2*6.*&/%

230.# ;<<"# 0=-'6,3/,-%>#3'&%?/)6@#0.1#

*)-%?/-AB#%.%-=AB#'.*-0?/-,6/,-%#

0.1#6)0?/03#,-C0.#D).%?B#

:0-'.%#*'?9%-'%?B#0.1#9,:0.#

9%03/9#

&,3.%-0C'3'/A#0??%??:%./#*)-#&0-'),?#?%6/)-?#0.1#

1%?6-'C%?#?5%6'*'6#3'.%?#)*#0105/0/').#06/').#*)-#

%069#?%6/)-E#

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

!"#$% C7D$+.*1$4% <9/=$2:4;% E#6)$#$/.*/F%-F$/+,:4;%

>,6$%&'%62&D$+.%

392".*&/% (2*&2*.,%8$+.&2:4;%

0$&F2"6B*+%'&+94%:*'%"/,;%

!".*&/")%-+.*&/%

FE #G%&%3)5'.=#0#+3':0/%#

4105/0/').#8/-0/%=A#*)-#

80./'0=)#1%#+9'3%#0.1#0#

H%/()-@#)*#I%=06'/'%?FJK#

G%&%3)5#63':0/%#690.=%#0105/0/').#:%0?,-%?#

*)-#/9%#I%/-)5)3'/0.#$%=').#)*#80./'0=)#1%#

+9'3%#'.#/9%#@%A#0-%0?#)*#%.%-=A>#(0/%-#0.1#

30.1#,?%>#/9-),=9#/9%#*)33)('.=#?/%5?7#63':0/%#

690.=%#':506/B#1%&%3)5>#%&03,0/%>#5-')-'/'D%#

0.1#530.#/)#':53%:%./#63':0/%#0105/0/').#

:%0?,-%?B#0.1#?5-%01#-%?,3/?#/)#)/9%-#6'/'%?#'.#

/9%#L0/'.#4:%-'60#-%=').#/9-),=9#0#-%=').03#

3%0-.'.=#.%/()-@E#

MIN#

O/9-),=9#

P./%-.0/').03#

+3':0/%#

P.'/'0/'&%Q#

#

"#$%&'(!N8R;EFS#

:'33').#

+TH4I4>#

U+L4+>#

N.'&%-?'/'%?#'.#

V%-:0.A#0.1#

+9'3%#

4??%??:%./B#

W.)(3%1=%#

6)::,.'60/')

.##

;<<! ;<F;# U.%-=AB#

X-%?9(0/%-#

?,553AB#N-C0.#

0-%0?#

80./'0=)#1%#

+9'3%#

;E #+3':0/%#+90.=%#46/').#

230.#*)-#V306'%-#

U&03,0/').#)*#/9%#%6).):'6#':506/#)*#=306'%-#

:%3/'.=#0.1#1%&%3)5#0#:).'/)-'.=#530.#*)-#/9%#

P4GM>#6)Y

*'.0.6'.=#

I'.'?/-A#*)-#

2,C3'6#Z)-@?#

$%?%0-69# ;<F<#Y#[# X-%?9(0/%-#

?,553A#

V306'%-?#0.1#

(0/%-?9%1?#

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!CDE!F<G?!9''3HII,,,;0/.=J%(/&659.'>(-('(&'()$;2$I$-I3#+4$5'6K3LDM2LNOE!!

Page 5: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · ;:6$%?$ $ "#$%&'(!)*!+,-.& $ "#$%&'(! $$ $)*!+,-.&(! %!!!!!"#$

!

!!"

#$%&$'"()"*+,,$-."/-0"12/--$0"30/4./.&(-"35.&(-6"7(+.8"39$,&5/"!

!"#$% &'($)*+,$-% ./01$23-4% 5#67$#$0*+08%98$0):3-4%

;:6$%<=%62<($)*%

>/2"*+<0% ?2+<2+*:%@$)*<23-4%

A$<82"6B+)%=<)/-%3+=%"0:4%

*(-:$,%/.&(-" ;/.&(-/2"<2/5&$,"7.,/.$=>?" "

"#$%&'(""@7ABCBDEEE"

?"2*+)+6"*+<0%+0%C$8+<0"7%"01%A7<'"7%9)*+<0-%

F? "*2&9/.$"*8/-=$"/-0"

G,,&=/.$0"3=,&5+2.+,$6"

H('/,0:"/"I$..$,"

+-0$,:./-0&-="()"0,&%&-="

)(,5$:"/-0")$$0I/5J:"

I$.'$$-"0$5&:&(-"9/J$,:"

/-0"I&(48>:&5/2"

$-%&,(-9$-.:"/-0".8$&,"

&94/5.:"(-"8>0,(2(=&5/2"

5>52$"/-0"2/-0"+:$CFK

"

L%/2+/.$"&94/5.:"()"52&9/.$"/-0"2/-0"+:$"

58/-=$"(-"&,,&=/.$0"/=,&5+2.+,$"/-0"

58/,/5.$,&M$")$$0I/5J:"I$.'$$-"$-%&,(-9$-."

/-0"/0/4./.&(-"0$5&:&(-:N"/::$::"58/-=$:"&-"

'/.$,"0$9/-0:"/-0"&,,&=/.&(-"-$$0:"/.".8$"

,$=&(-/2"2$%$2"&-",$:4(-:$".("58/-=$:"&-"8>0,(O

9$.$(,(2(=&5/2"5(-0&.&(-:"/-0"2/-0"+:$N"

/-/2>M$".8$"%+2-$,/I&2&.>"()"'/.$,"/-0"2/-0"+:$"

:>:.$9N"&0$-.&)>"/-0"$%/2+/.$"/0/4./.&(-"

(44(,.+-&.&$:")(,"0$5&:&(-"9/J$,:"

G-.$,O

39$,&5/-"

G-:.&.+.$")(,"

<2(I/2"

*8/-=$"

#$:$/,58"

"

"#$%&'(!@7AP"9&22&(-"

"1(-.&)&5&/"

@-&%$,:&0/0"

*/.(2&5/"0$"

*8&2$N"*(,-$22"

@-&%$,:&.>N"

Q&/9&"

#(:$-:.,$2"

758((2N"G;H3"

1(2&5>"

)(,9/.&(-"/-0"

&942$9$-./.&

(-""

BEEP BECC" R,$:8'/.$,"

:+442>N"

3=,&5+2.+,$"

)&%*+,-.(!3,=$-.&-/D"

*8&2$"

/,!01*.&("3-/2>:&:"./J$:"42/5$"&-".8$"#&("Q/&4("#&%$,"S/:&-?"

T? "*(9&-="U('-".8$"

Q(+-./&-6"@-0$,:./-0&-="

.8$"%+2-$,/I&2&.>"()"

3-0$/-"5(99+-&.&$:".("

8>0,(52&9/.(2(=&5"

%/,&/I&2&.>"/-0"=2(I/2"

$-%&,(-9$-./2"58/-=$CF!"

H("&0$-.&)>"/-0"58/,/5.$,&M$"%+2-$,/I&2&.&$:"()"

:4$5&)&5":./J$8(20$,:".("52&9/.$"%/,&/I&2&.>"/-0"

52&9/.$O&-0+5$0"'/.$,"4,(I2$9:N"$%/2+/.$"

4(2&5&$:"/-0"5/4/5&.&$:"()"'/.$,"9/-/=$9$-."

&-:.&.+.&(-:".(",$0+5$".8$"%+2-$,/I&2&.&$:"()"

:./J$8(20$,:N"/-0"/-/2>M$",$:+2.:"()"(IV$5.&%$:"

C"/-0"B",$2/.&%$".(",$=&(-/2"52&9/.$"58/-=$"

:5$-/,&(:"/-0")+.+,$"8>0,(2(=&5/2"5(-0&.&(-:?"

G-.$,O

39$,&5/-"

G-:.&.+.$")(,"

<2(I/2"

*8/-=$"

#$:$/,58"

@-&%$,:&.>"()"

#$=&-/"

W*/-/0/X"

#$:$/,58N"

*/4/5&.>"

I+&20&-="

BEEP BECC" 3=,&5+2.+,$N"

R,$:8'/.$,"

:+442>"

)&%*+,-.(!3,=$-.&-/D"

S(2&%&/D"

*8&2$"

/,!01*.&("#$:$/,58"&-"*8&2$"./J$:"42/5$"&-".8$"L2Y+&"#&%$,"S/:&-?"

Z? "#$%&$'"()".8$"L5(-(9&5:"

()"*2&9/.$"*8/-=$"&-"

7(+.8"39$,&5/CTE

"

H8$"4+,4(:$"()".8$":.+0>"&:".("9/J$"/"

:(5&($5(-(9&5"/-/2>:&:"()".8$"&94/5.:"()"

52&9/.$"58/-=$"&-":$2$5.$0"5(+-.,&$:"()"7(+.8"

39$,&5/D"0$%$2(4"9&.&=/.&(-"/-0"/0/4./.&(-"

4(2&5&$:"/-0"2$%$,/=$")&-/-5&/2",$:(+,5$:?"G-"

/00&.&(-D".8&:"4,(V$5."&-52+0$:"/"5(94(-$-."

G3USD"@[D"

U$-9/,JD"

74/&-D"L@D"

<$,9/->"

L*\3*" 3::$::9$-.N"

1(2&5>"

)(,9/.&(-"/-0"

&-.$=,/.&(-"

BEEK BEE!" *(/:./2"M(-$"

9/-/=$9$-.N"

<(%$,-9$-."

)&%*+,-.(!3,=$-.&-/D"

S(2&%&/D"

S,/M&2D"*8&2$D""

*(2(9I&/D"

L5+/0(,D"

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$!%&%'!())*+,,-.-/0"1-.-1-2),34-5/-2,67%890:;<3)=8>[email protected]<=,6A95B>,C.3)=(<<)=,6A95B>8#1*DE!!"#F!%&%'!())*+,,-.-/0"1-.-1-2),34-5/-2,67%890:;<3)=8>[email protected]<=,6A95B>,C.3)=(<<)=,6A95B>8G1*DE!"GH!I7J&7'!())*+,,KKK1<3L.31:04,D@..(,2:)-3-.=,2:)-3-.=,M,#NM#M,[email protected]<4:80<331*DE!

Page 6: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · ;:6$%?$ $ "#$%&'(!)*!+,-.& $ "#$%&'(! $$ $)*!+,-.&(! %!!!!!"#$

!

!""#$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8),/9#4:%-'60#!

!"#$% &'($)*+,$-% ./01$23-4% 5#67$#$0*+08%98$0):3-4%

;:6$%<=%62<($)*%

>/2"*+<0% ?2+<2+*:%@$)*<23-4%

A$<82"6B+)%=<)/-%3+=%"0:4%

*)6,;%1#).#/9%#':506/#)*#63':0/%#690.<%#'.#6)0;/03#0-%0; +=4#>+0:?')#+3':0/'6)#%.#30;#+)0;/0;#1%#4:%-'60#@0/'.0#A#+0-'?%BC##

20-0<,0AD#2%-,D#E-,<,0AD#F%.%G,%30#

"#!$%&'()#H,-/9%-#'.*)-:0/').#.%%1%1C#

IC #+3':0/%#+90.<%#F,3.%-0?'3'/A#J&03,0/').#)*#+)0;/03#0.1#K0-'.%#4-%0;!L!#

M9';#5-)N%6/#';#50-/#)*#/9%#O?%-)P4:%-'60.#2-)<-0::%#).#/9%#J&03,0/').#)*#O:506/;D#F,3.%-0?'3'/A#0.1#4105/0/').#/)#+3':0/%#+90.<%#>2O4++B#0.1#0':;#/)#1%/%-:'.%#/9%#':506/;#)*#63':0/%#690.<%#).#/9%#6)0;/;#)*#0.A#6),./-A#'.#850.';9#0.1#2)-/,<,%;%#;5%0Q'.<#6),./-'%;#)*#@0/'.#4:%-'60#0.1#/9%#+0-'??%0.C#O/#90;#0#50-/'6,30-#*)6,;#).#/9%#1A.0:'6;#)*#?%069%;D#%;/,0-'%;D#30<)).;D#1%3/0;D#63'**;#0.1#1,.%;D#6)0;/03#%-);').D#*3))1#-';Q;#0.1#6)0;/03#'.*-0;/-,6/,-%C#M9';#'.'/'0/'&%#';#3'.Q%1#/)#/9%#

+%./-03#4:%-'60#P# !LR#*,.1%1#?A#O4STD#EUD#S%.:0-QD#850'.D#JE#0.1#V%-:0.AC#

850'.# J+@4+D#E.'&%-;'/A#)*#+0./0?-'0D#.0/').03#6),./%-50-/;#

+0506'/A#?,'31'.<W#4;;%;;:%./W#U.)(3%1<%#6)::,.'60/').#

R""X R"!!# +)0;/03#G).%#:0.0<%:%./##

K);/#$OY++#6),./-'%;!L=#'.63,1'.<7##4-<%./'.0D#T-0G'3D#+9'3%D#+)3):?'0D#J6,01)-D#2%-,D#E-,<,0A#0.1#F%.%G,%30#

"#!$%&'()!H,-/9%-#'.*)-:0/').#-%Z,'-%1C#

[C #+3':0/%#2)3'6A#R"!R7#J\/%.;').#)*#/9%#<3)?03#

S%&%3)5:%./#*)-#2)3'6A#K0Q%-;#/)#411-%;;#+3':0/%#

!LL##

M9%#E]S2#$%<').03#T,-%0,#*)-#@0/'.#4:%-'60#0.1#/9%#+0-'??%0.#90;#%\50.1%1#).#/9%#<3)?03#

-%<').#/)#5-)&'1%#/%69.'603#;,55)-/#/)#.0/').03#5)3'6A#:0Q%-;#0.1#'/;#+),./-A#Y**'6%;#0.1#;/-%.</9%.#60506'/A#).#?,1<%/0-A#';;,%;#-%30/%1#/)#/9%#5);/PR"!R#63':0/%#-%<':%C#

850'.D#E]S2##*+,-(.)#E8^=CI#:'33').#

E]S2# +0506'/A#?,'31'.<W#2)3'6A#*)-:0/').#0.1#'./%<-0/').#

R""X R"!!# V)&%-.:%./## /0$!1(-&2#)!4-<%./'.0D#T)3'&'0D#T-0G'3D#+9'3%D#+)3):?'0D#+);/0#$'60D#+,?0D#S):'.'60.#

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

Page 7: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · ;:6$%?$ $ "#$%&'(!)*!+,-.& $ "#$%&'(! $$ $)*!+,-.&(! %!!!!!"#$

!

!"!#$%&'%(#)*#+,--%./#0.1#230..%1#4105/0/').#46/').7#8),/9#4:%-'60#!

!"#$% &'($)*+,$-% ./01$23-4% 5#67$#$0*+08%98$0):3-4%

;:6$%<=%62<($)*%

>/2"*+<0% ?2+<2+*:%@$)*<23-4%

A$<82"6B+)%=<)/-%3+=%"0:4%

46/'&'/'%;#'.63,1%#/%69.'603#<06=;/)55'.>#*)-#6),./-'%;#/90/#<%>'.#/)#6).;'1%-#0105/0/').#/)#63':0/%#690.>%#'.#/9%'-#?0/').03#@%&%3)5:%./#230.;A#

$%5,<3'6B#C6,01)-B#C3#803&01)-B#D,0/%:030B#E).1,-0;B#F%G'6)B#?'60-0>,0B#20.0:0B#20-0>,0HB#2%-,B#I-,>,0HB#0.1#J%.%K,%30#

"#!$%&'()!L,-/9%-#'.*)-:0/').#-%M,'-%1A#

NA #F'/'>0/').#0.1#4105/0/').#/)#+3':0/%#+90.>%#'.#8,;/0'.0<3%#L)-%;/#F0.0>%:%./#'.#O<%-)P4:%-'60!QR#

20-/#)*#2O4++B#/9';#5-)S%6/#0':;#/)#>%.%-0/%#.%(#'.*)-:0/').#0.1#=.)(3%1>%#0.1#;/-%.>/9%.#/9%#60506'/H#)*#-%;%0-69#'.;/'/,/').;#'.#/9%#*)-%;/-H#;%6/)-#).#3'.='.>#;,;/0'.0<3%#*)-%;/#:0.0>%:%./#('/9#0105/0/').#0.1#:'/'>0/').#/)#63':0/%#690.>%A#T9';#'.63,1%;#;/-%.>/9%.'.>#;5%6'*'6#-%;%0-69#06/'&'/'%;B#1%&%3)5'.>#0.1#1';;%:'.0/'.>#:%/9)1)3)>'%;#0.1#60;%#;/,1'%;B#;/-%.>/9%.'.>#9,:0.#-%;),-6%;#0.1#*);/%-'.>#/9%#-%5-%;%./0/').#)*#/9%#*)-%;/#;%6/)-#'.#/9%#-%>').03#0.1#'./%-.0/').03#1'03)>,%A#

850'.# O?O4B#+OLU$B#+4TOCB#2)3H/%69.'603#I.'&%-;'/H#)*#F01-'1##

+0506'/H#<,'31'.>V#$%;%0-69V#W.)(3%1>%#6)::,.'60/').#

X""Y X"!!# L)-%;/-H# $OU++#6),./-'%;B#'.63,1'.>7##4->%./'.0B#Z)3'&'0B#Z-0K'3B#+9'3%B#+)3):<'0B#C6,01)-B#20-0>,0HB#2%-,B#I-,>,0HB#0.1#J%.%K,%30#

"#!$%&'()!L,-/9%-#'.*)-:0/').#-%M,'-%1A#

YA #4105/0/').#/)#+3':0/%#+90.>%#)*#[9%0/#0.1#

T9%#)<S%6/'&%#)*#/9';#5-)>-0:#';#/)#6)./-'<,/%#/)#/9%#':5-)&%:%./#)*#/9%#0105/'&%#60506'/H#

O4@ZB#6)P*'.0.6'.>#

O.;/'/,/)#1%#O.&%;/'>06').%;#

$%;%0-69V#+0506'/H#

X"!"#P#\# 4>-'6,3/,-%## *(+&,#-')!+9'3%B#2%-,B#

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$!%&'()*+'!,-./!0++123344451&'()*+'6785*'63!

Page 8: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · ;:6$%?$ $ "#$%&'(!)*!+,-.& $ "#$%&'(! $$ $)*!+,-.&(! %!!!!!"#$

!

!"#$%&'(&)$*+$,-..&/0$1/2$341//&2$5216010(*/$570(*/8$9*-0:$5;&.(71$!

!"#$% &'($)*+,$-% ./01$23-4% 5#67$#$0*+08%98$0):3-4%

;:6$%<=%62<($)*%

>/2"*+<0% ?2+<2+*:%@$)*<23-4%

A$<82"6B+)%=<)/-%3+=%"0:4%

3*010*&<$3.*2-70('&$9=<0&;<!>?$

*+$0:&$.&@(*/A$0:.*-@:$1/$(/7.&1<&$(/$0:&$7*;6&0(0('&/&<<$*+$0:&$6.*2-70('&$<=<0&;<$*+$6*010*$1/2$):&10$0*$74(;10&$7:1/@&$(/$9*-0:$5;&.(71B$96&7(+(7144=A$0:&$6.*C&70$)(44$<-66*.0$0:&$<&4&70(*/$1/2$2&'&4*6;&/0$*+$@&/*0=6&<$)(0:$(/7.&1<&2$0*4&.1/7&$0*$2.*-@:0$1/2$:(@:$0&;6&.10-.&<B$D:&$6.*C&70$(<$E&(/@$4&2$1/2$(;64&;&/0&2$E=$4*714$(/<0(0-0(*/<B$

$"#$%&'(!F9GH#"A"""$

5@.*6&7-1.(*<$ E-(42(/@$$ F.-@-1=$

)*!+,-.&8$I-.0:&.$(/+*.;10(*/$.&J-(.&2B$

!"B $K/0&@.10(/@$,4(;10&$,:1/@&$5216010(*/$(/0*$L10(*/14$M&'&4*6;&/0$3.*7&<<&<$(/$N10(/$5;&.(71$1/2$0:&$,1.(EE&1/$

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

961(/$$"#$%&'(!F9G>ARSTA#RR$

FLU3$ 5<<&<<;&/0Q$,1617(0=$E-(42(/@Q$6*4(7=$+*.;10(*/$1/2$(/0&@.10(*/$

#"!" #"!R$$ V*'&./;&/0Q$5@.(7-40-.&Q$I.&<:)10&.$<-664=$

/0+!1&%-2*(!3:1<&$!8$!H$%KW,,$7*-/0.(&<!>S$$$3:1<&$#8$RXT$7*-/0.(&<$YM*;(/(71/$%&6-E4(7$!<0$7*-/0.=$<&4&70&2Z$

)*!+,-.&($I-.0:&.$(/+*.;10(*/$/&&2&2B$

!

!"#$%&'&()*#+*,'-,-.&/#+0-.&/#"#! $%&! '($()&*! +%,-&! &./&0$1! $2! 3&#&',$! ')24! 5! 0244,$4&#$! 36! $%&! 7#,$&8! 9$5$&1! $2! ,#:&1$! 5)2(#8! 79;<! 4,--,2#! ,#! 585/$5$,2#! ,#!

=)>&#$,#5*!?&)(!5#8!+%,-&!$%)2(>%!$%&!@#&)>6!5#8!+-,45$&!?5)$#&)1%,/!2'!$%&!=4&),051A!=1!B&--*!=)>&#$,#5!,1!-,C&-6!$2!/5)$,0,/5$&!,#!$%&!

246*!

/)28 !

%!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

<DE!"=FG*!%$$/HIIBBBA,583A2)>I&#I/)2J&0$1I/)2J&0$*<KLKA%$4-M,8N)>O$<EPQ!

<DQ!R%&!<S!T"U++!02(#$),&1!5)&H!=)>&#$,#5*!G2-,:,5*!G)5V,-*!+%,-&*!+2-243,5*!+21$5!T,05*!+(35*!F24,#,05#!T&/(3-,0*!@0(582)*!@-!95-:582)*!W(5$&45-5*!X2#8()51*!

Y&.,02*!Z,05)5>(5*!?5#545*!?5)5>(56*!?&)(*!7)(>(56!5#8![&#&V(&-5A!

Page 9: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · ;:6$%?$ $ "#$%&'(!)*!+,-.& $ "#$%&'(! $$ $)*!+,-.&(! %!!!!!"#$

!

!"#$%&'(&)$*+$,-..&/0$1/2$341//&2$5216010(*/$570(*/8$9*-0:$5;&.(71$!

!"#$%&'(&)*+,+-%.&/.",0"01+2&/301+2-&

!"#$% 4#5%3016%-& !7,%&+8&,*+5%30& )*1+*107&9%30+*:-;& <%+=*",>13&8+3?-&:18&"27;&

!< $=/&.>?$1/2$,4(;10&$31.0/&.@:(6$*+$0:&$5;&.(71@$

$ $ $ "#$%&'()*!5.>&/0(/1A$,:(4&A$3&.-$

@+0%-(/(0(10('&$)(44$6.*'(2&$166.*B(;10&4?$C!$;(44(*/$+*.$1216010(*/$0*$74(;10&$7:1/>&<$D*$+-.0:&.$2&01(4@$1.&$E/*)/<$

F< $G;6170@$*+$,4(;10&$,:1/>&$(/$5>.(7-40-.14$H*/&@$1/2$%&4&'1/0$9&70*.@$(/$,:(4&$5.>&/0(/1$1/2$I*;(/(71/$%&6-J4(78$=7*/*;?A$6.*2-70(*/A$)10&.$.&K-(.&;&/0@A$1216010(*/$1/2$6*4(7?$*.(&/010(*/$$

,*/0.(J-0&$0*$0:&$7*;6&0(0('&/&@@$1/2$+**2$@&7-.(0?$*+$0:&$1>.(7-40-.14$@&70*.$(/$5.>&/0(/1A$,:(4&$1/2$I*;(/(71/$%&6-J4(7$0:.*->:$/&)$E/*)4&2>&$>&/&.10&2$J?$0:&$@(;-410(*/$1/2$&'14-10(*/$*+$&7*/*;(7$1/2$6.*2-70('&$(;6170@$*+$74(;10&$7:1/>&A$6.*6*@(0(*/$*+$1216010(*/$;&1@-.&@$J?$@&70*.$1/2$.&@-40(/>$6*4(7?$.&7*;;&/210(*/@$1/2$@-66*[email protected]&>(&@<$$

3*4(7?$+*.;10(*/$1/2$(/0&>.10(*/$$$

5>.(7-40-.&$ +,-!"#$%&'*!5.>&/0(/1A$,:(4&A$I*;(/(71/$%&6-J4(7$

@+0%-8$,144$+*.$J(2@$(@@-&2$(/$F"!"$LMNDO5P%NA$F"!"Q$

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

Page 10: Clean Energy Investment in Developing Countries: Wind power in … · 2012. 3. 15. · ;:6$%?$ $ "#$%&'(!)*!+,-.& $ "#$%&'(! $$ $)*!+,-.&(! %!!!!!"#$

!

!"#$%&'(&)$*+$,-..&/0$1/2$341//&2$5216010(*/$570(*/8$9*-0:$5;&.(71$!

!"#"$"%&"'()

"#$%&%!'()))*+!",-./ 0!1-203!$43-564.!"57786-943-56!35!3,/!:6-3/;!$43-560!1247/<52=!"56>/63-56!56!".-743/!",46?/+!!"#$%&%!'())@*+!A03243/?-4!$49-564.!;/!"47B-5!".-7C3-95+!!"#$%&%!'())D*+!E.46!;/!%99-F6!$49-564.!;/!"47B-5!".-7C3-95+!())D ()G(+!!A.!156;5!H/?-564.!;/!I/965.5?J4!%?25K/9842-4!L1#$I%MH#N!'()G)*+!E/2O-.!;/!E25P/935!"56>594352-4!"47B-5!".-7C3-95!1#$I%MH#!()G)+!H/32-/>/;!O257!,33KQRR<<<+O5634?25+52?R94..0R()G)R/>4.K/2O-./0RG))G(+K;O!!M5B-/265!;/!",-./!'()GG*+!E25?2474!;/!M5B-/265+!H/32-/>/;!O257!,33KQRR<<<+?5B+9.RK25?2474S;/S?5B-/265R!!!

! !