clinical strategies for incorporating immunotherapy in advanced … · 2019. 7. 29. · clinical...

24
Clinical Strategies for Incorporating Immunotherapy in Advanced Breast Cancer: Insights for Surgeons and Oncologists Final Outcomes Report Merck & Company Grant ID: AAN-171130-045624

Upload: others

Post on 03-Oct-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Clinical Strategies for Incorporating Immunotherapy in Advanced … · 2019. 7. 29. · clinical importance of evolving vaccines use in breast cancer treatment, clinicians will require

Clinical Strategies for Incorporating Immunotherapy in Advanced Breast Cancer: Insights for Surgeons and OncologistsFinal Outcomes ReportMerck & Company Grant ID: AAN-171130-045624

Page 2: Clinical Strategies for Incorporating Immunotherapy in Advanced … · 2019. 7. 29. · clinical importance of evolving vaccines use in breast cancer treatment, clinicians will require

Activity Description: Six expert faculty discussed advances in immunotherapy as it relates to breast cancer. This interview-style format is based on follow-up coverage from the “Immunotherapy and Breast Cancer” symposium at the Society of Surgical Oncology 2018 Annual Cancer Symposium, held on March 23, 2018 in Chicago, Illinois. PowerPoint slides from the symposium, as well as a written transcript of the interviews, were and are still available for download.

Launch Date: May 11, 2018Expiration Date: May 11, 2019

Credit: 1.0 AMA PRA Category 1 CreditsTM; 0.10 CEUs for nurses

Sponsored by: Society of Surgical Oncology in partnership with the Academy for Continued Healthcare Learning Supported by: An educational grant from Merck & Company

Intended Audience: US-based surgical oncologists, medical oncologists, and other healthcare providers involved in the care of patients with breast cancer.

Activity Availability:• http://achlcme.org/IMONC• https://cme2.medpagetoday.com/clinical-strategies-for-incorporating-immunotherapy-in-advanced-breast-cancer-

insights-for-surgeons-and-oncologists/75007/

Overview

Page 3: Clinical Strategies for Incorporating Immunotherapy in Advanced … · 2019. 7. 29. · clinical importance of evolving vaccines use in breast cancer treatment, clinicians will require

Activity Screenshots

Page 4: Clinical Strategies for Incorporating Immunotherapy in Advanced … · 2019. 7. 29. · clinical importance of evolving vaccines use in breast cancer treatment, clinicians will require

Participation4,351 Clinical Participants; 388 Certificates (exceeds guarantee of 1200 participants!)

Practicing Type43% Physician, 33% RN, 6% PA/NP, 18% Other HCP

Objectivity & BalanceObjectivity and balance rated as good/excellent by 100% of learners

Learning Objectives

99% of learners strongly agree or agree that all learning objectives were met

Executive Summary

Page 5: Clinical Strategies for Incorporating Immunotherapy in Advanced … · 2019. 7. 29. · clinical importance of evolving vaccines use in breast cancer treatment, clinicians will require

Executive Summary99% learners indicated participation in the activity has increased their knowledge.

Following the activity learners demonstrated increased knowledge in the use of patient specific factors as prognostic markers for immunotherapy suitability as well as recognition of immunotherapy agents.

65% of learners have indicated that they are either confident or very confident in using immunotherapies as part of a combination strategy in advanced breast cancer patients when approved.

Cost, lack of experience, and reimbursement/insurance issues were reported as the most common barriers to implementing changes in practice.

Changes made from this activity will impact 16,321 to more than 29,674 breast cancer patients each month.

Page 6: Clinical Strategies for Incorporating Immunotherapy in Advanced … · 2019. 7. 29. · clinical importance of evolving vaccines use in breast cancer treatment, clinicians will require

Participation

43%

3%3%

33%

18%

Participation by Clinician Type

PhysicianPhysician AssistantNurse PractitionerNurseOther HCP

Participants Certificates 4,351 388

9%

17%

38%

2%3%

6%

2%

23%

Participation by Specialty

General PracticeSurgeryHematology/OncologyObstetrics/GynecologyPathologyRadiologyPsychiatryOther

Page 7: Clinical Strategies for Incorporating Immunotherapy in Advanced … · 2019. 7. 29. · clinical importance of evolving vaccines use in breast cancer treatment, clinicians will require

Learning Objectives

99% of learners indicate that all learning objectives were met

N=382

Did the activity meet its stated learning objectives: Yes No

Describe how the tumor immune microenvironment may clinically impact patients with breast cancer 99% 1%

Review current immunotherapy treatment options available and in development for patients with breast cancer 99% 1%

Identify potential treatments that may be combined with immunotherapy to enhance treatment response 99% 1%

Page 8: Clinical Strategies for Incorporating Immunotherapy in Advanced … · 2019. 7. 29. · clinical importance of evolving vaccines use in breast cancer treatment, clinicians will require

Satisfaction

97% of learners found this activity important to their practice.

N=382

Overall Evaluation Yes No

This activity was scientifically rigorous 96% 4%

The content of this activity matched my current (or potential) scope of practice 88% 12%

Did you find the format of this educational activity to be valuable 99% 1%

Page 9: Clinical Strategies for Incorporating Immunotherapy in Advanced … · 2019. 7. 29. · clinical importance of evolving vaccines use in breast cancer treatment, clinicians will require

Objectivity & Balance

Activity was perceived as objective, balanced and non-biased

100%

Was this activity fair, balanced, and free of commercial bias?

Yes No

N=382

Page 10: Clinical Strategies for Incorporating Immunotherapy in Advanced … · 2019. 7. 29. · clinical importance of evolving vaccines use in breast cancer treatment, clinicians will require

Outcomes Reporting Methodology• First-attempt posttest scores are reported throughout.

• Initial answer choices for the post-test provide insight into the learner’s ability to immediately recall and apply the education

• For post-activity questions administered as part of the evaluation (versus the online survey), only first-attempt was collected

• Pre- and posttest responses have been paired/matched. Non-completer data has been omitted from the analysis to ensure comparison groups are equivalent.

Page 11: Clinical Strategies for Incorporating Immunotherapy in Advanced … · 2019. 7. 29. · clinical importance of evolving vaccines use in breast cancer treatment, clinicians will require

Pretest vs. Posttest Summary

Participants demonstrated improved knowledge and competence on all pre/posttest questions with an average of 29% change.

29%

49%

73%

46%

32%

53% 49%

79%

55%46%

0%

20%

40%

60%

80%

100%

Topic 1 Topic 2 Topic 3 Topic 4 Topic 5

Pre Post

Topic % Change

1. Clinical factors of lymphocyte density 83%

2. Clinical scenario peptide vaccine use 0%

3. Checkpoint inhibitor recognition 8%

4. Abscopal effect in radiation therapy 20%

5. Evaluating TILs in the TME 34%

Overview of Correct Responses

Page 12: Clinical Strategies for Incorporating Immunotherapy in Advanced … · 2019. 7. 29. · clinical importance of evolving vaccines use in breast cancer treatment, clinicians will require

36%32%

29%

3%

27%19%

53%

1%

A B C D0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Pre (n=381) Post (n=381)

Knowledge Acquisition: Clinical Factors

Knowledge of clinical factors correlated with lymphocyte density in breast cancer increased by a significant 83% following the educational activity.

Additional education reinforcing the nuances of this topic would be of continued interest to clinicians for use in evaluation of patients suitable

for immunotherapy.

1. The clinical variable most correlated with a high density of lymphocytes in breast cancer is:A. Lymph node involvement B. Inflammatory breast cancerC. Biologic subtypeD. Patient age

Clinical factors of lymphocyte density

Page 13: Clinical Strategies for Incorporating Immunotherapy in Advanced … · 2019. 7. 29. · clinical importance of evolving vaccines use in breast cancer treatment, clinicians will require

26%

49%

11% 14%

24%

49%

10%17%

A B C D0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Pre (n=381) Post (n=381)

Knowledge Acquisition: Peptide Vaccines

Knowledge of ineffective use of HER2-targeted peptide vaccine in breast remained the same following the educational activity. Given the

clinical importance of evolving vaccines use in breast cancer treatment, clinicians will require greater enforcement and exposure to real-world

scenarios and patient-specific characteristics for appropriate and effective utilization. Additional education exploring and addressing

these advances and barriers will prove critical.

2. In which clinical scenario are HER2-targeted peptide vaccines least likely to be effective?A. As a single agent to prevent the development of breast cancerB. As a single agent in patients with diffusely metastatic

diseaseC. In combination with trastuzumabD. In combination with other forms of immunotherapy to include

checkpoint blockade agents

Clinical scenario peptide vaccine use

Page 14: Clinical Strategies for Incorporating Immunotherapy in Advanced … · 2019. 7. 29. · clinical importance of evolving vaccines use in breast cancer treatment, clinicians will require

73%

10% 9%5% 4%

79%

6% 8%4% 3%

A B C D E0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Pre (n=381) Post (n=381)

Knowledge Acquisition: Checkpoint Inhibitors

Knowledge of checkpoint inhibitor types used in cancer was high prior to the educational activity, yet the activity helped to reinforce and

increase recognition of these agents by an additional 8%.

3. The following are examples of checkpoint inhibitors used in cancer therapy:A. Anti-PD1 antibodies (such as nivolumab or pembrolizumab)B. Interleukin 2C. Interferon gammaD. Talimogene laherparepvecE. Abscopal effect

Checkpoint inhibitor recognition

Page 15: Clinical Strategies for Incorporating Immunotherapy in Advanced … · 2019. 7. 29. · clinical importance of evolving vaccines use in breast cancer treatment, clinicians will require

18%

8%

46%

11%16%18%

6%

55%

6%

15%

A B C D E0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Pre (n=381) Post (n=381)

Knowledge Acquisition: Abscopal Effect

Knowledge of the abscopal effect in radiation therapy increased by 20% following the educational activity. Awareness of such effects is important,

particularly as patients may be treated with combination regimens involving both immunotherapy and radiation therapy and therefore require accurate clinician oversight to ensure optimal outcomes.

4. The abscopal effect in radiation therapy refers to:A. The dose of radiation most effective in treating breast cancerB. A form of partial breast radiationC. The impact of causing regression of other non-radiated

tumorsD. Is not mediated by the immune response E. None of the above

Abscopal effect in radiation therapy

Page 16: Clinical Strategies for Incorporating Immunotherapy in Advanced … · 2019. 7. 29. · clinical importance of evolving vaccines use in breast cancer treatment, clinicians will require

16%

32%

8%

45%

12%

46%

8%

34%

A B C D0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Pre (n=381) Post (n=381)

Clinical Competence: Evaluating TILs

Understanding and ability to evaluate patient levels of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes in the tumor microenvironment increased by 44% following the educational activity. With pending approvals, such clinical cases are crucial for clinicians to implement in a prognostic

manner so they can effectively identify and select patients who would be most responsive to checkpoint inhibitor therapy.

5. A 60-year-old woman presents with metastatic disease that is subsequently established as a triple-negative case. Further characterization of the tumor lesions indicated a high mutational load. Which of the following is an additional patient marker that can be evaluated for deciding if the patient is a suitable candidate for immunotherapy treatment using checkpoint inhibitors?

A. Levels of estrogen receptor expression on the tumor cells

B. Levels of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes in the tumor microenvironment

C. Blood T-cell levels

D. PD-L1 expression level in the T-cell population of the ascending lymph node

Evaluating TILs in the TME

Page 17: Clinical Strategies for Incorporating Immunotherapy in Advanced … · 2019. 7. 29. · clinical importance of evolving vaccines use in breast cancer treatment, clinicians will require

Polling: Immunotherapy Considerations in Advanced Breast Cancer

16%43% 30%

12%0%

50%

100%

Large extent Moderateextent

Mild extent Not at all

n=240

To what extent would available patient biomarkers such as tumor-infiltrating lymphocyte levels influence your use of a checkpoint inhibitor as part of a treatment regimen for advanced breast cancer patients?

Looking beyond current frontline treatments for advanced breast cancer patients, including triple negative cases, and given acceptable efficacy, safety and tolerability, how likely are you to employ immunotherapies for treatment if or when approved?

58%

25% 16%2%

0%

50%

100%

Very likely Moderatelylikely

Somewhatlikely

Not at alllikely

n=219

82% of learners indicated they are likely to employ immunotherapies for treatment of advanced breast cancer if or when approved. Such clinical enthusiasm for application of new treatment types for advanced breast cancer suggest broad

clinical adoption with new approvals; as such, this topic will require education for reinforcement into practice.

A majority of learners indicated that the availability of clinically relevant prognostic biomarkers of checkpoint inhibitor therapy response would be to a large extent

important for selecting that treatment regimen.

Page 18: Clinical Strategies for Incorporating Immunotherapy in Advanced … · 2019. 7. 29. · clinical importance of evolving vaccines use in breast cancer treatment, clinicians will require

Confidence Assessment

65% of learners have indicated that they are either confident or very confident in using immunotherapies in clinical practice.

10%

25%

41%

24%

17%

26%

34%

23%

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50%

Not Confident

Somewhat Confident

Confident

Very Confident

Polling (n=464)Posttest (n=382)

If or when approved, how confident are you in using immunotherapies in clinical practice as part of a combination strategy for advanced breast cancer patients, including triple negative cases?

Page 19: Clinical Strategies for Incorporating Immunotherapy in Advanced … · 2019. 7. 29. · clinical importance of evolving vaccines use in breast cancer treatment, clinicians will require

Activity Impact

This activity was highly effective, with 99% of attendees indicating participation in this activity has increased their knowledge of the topics discussed.

N=382

1%

11%

11%

77%

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90%

Did not increase my knowledge

Somewhat increased my knowledge

Increased my knowledge

Greatly increased my knowledge

Page 20: Clinical Strategies for Incorporating Immunotherapy in Advanced … · 2019. 7. 29. · clinical importance of evolving vaccines use in breast cancer treatment, clinicians will require

Practice Change

62% of learners will change their practice!

38%

13%

28%

32%

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50%

This activity validated my currentpractice; no changes will be made

Other changes

Create/revise protocols, policies,and/or procedures

Change the management and/ortreatment of my patients

N=381; multiple responses allowed

Page 21: Clinical Strategies for Incorporating Immunotherapy in Advanced … · 2019. 7. 29. · clinical importance of evolving vaccines use in breast cancer treatment, clinicians will require

Patient Care Impact

25%

40%

15%

20%

Number of breast cancer patients affected by these changes each month:

0

1-10

11-20

>20

Changes will impact 16,321 to more than 29,674 patients each month. This data is extrapolated to be representative of all healthcare participants of this activity (4351). Data was sourced from participants (382) who

indicated they would make a change as a result of this activity (62%).

Page 22: Clinical Strategies for Incorporating Immunotherapy in Advanced … · 2019. 7. 29. · clinical importance of evolving vaccines use in breast cancer treatment, clinicians will require

Barriers to Planned Change

43%

8%

8%

7%

18%

19%

8%

6%

9%

28%

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50%

No barriers

Lack of resources (equipment)

Lack of consensus or professional guidelines

Lack of administrative support

Reimbursement/insurance issues

Lack of experience

Lack of opportunity (patients)

Lack of time to assess/counsel patients

Patient compliance issues

Cost

Participants indicated cost (28%) as most common barrier to implementing changes in their practice, followed by lack of experience (19%) and reimbursement/insurance issues (18%). Of those who identified barriers, 87% will

attempt to address the perceived barrier(s) in order to affect change.

N=382; multiple responses allowed

Page 23: Clinical Strategies for Incorporating Immunotherapy in Advanced … · 2019. 7. 29. · clinical importance of evolving vaccines use in breast cancer treatment, clinicians will require

Activity ImpactSelf-reported practice changes• I may be more involved in treating breast cancer patients than I am

now. I now mainly advise on therapy for melanoma patients• Continue to monitor the utilization of biological tx for breast cancer• Keep up to date with current treatment options• Be more watchful for interactions of immunotherapy with radiotherapy

(since I am a radiation oncologist)• Work with my medical oncology colleagues about immunotherapy use

prior to surgery• Refer for immune to earlier• Incorporate immunotherapy• The change will result in a change of standard of care which then will

result in a change in my practice...• heightened awareness of progression in option and educate patients

and support patient in pursuit of possibilities for benefits of new therapies in improved outcomes

• We will have to revise our current treatment plans to include the new immunotherapies and educated staff

• MD will add on immunotherapy as indicated by NCCN guidelines• Use immunotherapy agents that are not currently approved by the FDA• Treatment regimens in EMR will be modified to include approved

agents

• Earlier evaluation and treatment• Assist patient with understanding recommended tx• Treatment regimen builds will be updated in EMR• Incorporate immune therapy into breast cancer treatment when/if it

becomes a standard of care• I will be able to better help patients understand their treatment and

treatment options• Change overall patient's management• Change treatment regimens for certain patients• introducing better neoadjuvant and preventive treatments; increase

breast conservation, needs more work for toxicity of treatments though• My job is to educate and support patients throughout treatment. I will

be able to better help patients understand their treatment and treatment options. Understanding is power. Also I will be responsible for finding resources to help patients pay for treatments, and advocate to facilitate making these treatments available in our facility as new treatment options become available, and if patients cannot get tailored cancer treatment at our facility, coordinating to get treatment at other facilities

• I will be more knowledgeable about how my sister's and my wife's cancer is being treated

• practices and regimens are up to our physicians here, but I am sure as a teaching facility we are always changing

Page 24: Clinical Strategies for Incorporating Immunotherapy in Advanced … · 2019. 7. 29. · clinical importance of evolving vaccines use in breast cancer treatment, clinicians will require

Contact InformationPatti Stella, CAE, CHCPDirector of EducationSociety for Surgical [email protected] x104

Amanda Kaczerski, MS, CHCP Senior Director, Education Strategy and DesignAcademy for Continued Healthcare Learning (ACHL)[email protected] ext. 148