closed-tube dna barcoding analysis of the species and

1
s.com Abstract Background: Naegleria are abundant, free-living, freshwater amoebae with a worldwide distribution that are able to differentiate into swimming flagellates. Species within this genus are quite diverse, probably because the genus evolved over a billion years ago. Mesophilic species like N. gruberi live on the five temperate continents, but N. antarctica is thermophobic, and N. fowleri are thermophilic opportunistic human pathogens (the brain-eating amoebae). Previous analysis of short ribosomal ITS sequences catalogued roughly 40 geographically separated species. Our analysis, using a combination of Closed-Tube Barcoding of the CO1 gene target plus DNA sequencing suggests better defines the number of species. Analysis of about 75 clonal isolates from around the world using both CO1 and ITS sequences show agreement in the degree of relatedness among isolates in most cases. Results: Closed-Tube DNA Barcoding is an efficient, cost effect method for amplifying the CO1 barcoding target sequence from large numbers of isolates and then scanning the resulting single- stranded DNA for sequence variations using Lights-On/Lights-Off probes. We are using a common set of probes, comprised of three subsets of probes to resolve all species within this genus. Subsets are labeled in different fluorescent colors. This experimental design allows us to compare the fluorescent signatures of different isolates and immediately observe whether sequence differences are clustered in one region of the CO1 target, or distributed throughout. These predictions can be confirmed by Dilute-N’-Go sequencing. Significance: This ground breaking study of Naegleria points the way to using Closed-Tube Barcoding as a method for detection of species variation in microscopic eukaryotes – a world that is largely unknown. Using this approach we will be able to map the species variation in small or large ecosystems. We can also use our approach to selectively test for N. fowleri, or virtually any pathogen in a water sample. Closed-Tube DNA Barcoding Analysis of the Species and Global Distribution of Naegleria: A Worldwide Genus of Single-celled Amoeboflagellates Heather Schiller , John Deng , Elaine Lai , Chandler Fulton , Lawrence J. Wangh Department of Biology, Brandeis University, Waltham Massachusetts, USA Introduction Naegleria: Single-celled, freshwater, eukaryotic Differentiate from limax amoebae to streamlined flagellates Cyst Amoeba Flagellate Once thought to be a genus with one species, Naegleria gruberi The genus has many species, including the human pathogen N. fowleri. The genus has more diversity than mammals. Challenging to define species of Naegleria because of their propensity to reproduce asexually, despite their capacity for sexual reproduction Conclusions from Sequencing Analysis 1. Construction of phylogenetic trees based on ITS and CO1 sequences in this genus is a work in progress. While the trees are broadly similar, certain ambiguities remain to be examined more closely. 2. The ITS tree shows thick branches, while the CO1 tree shows finer arborization. 3. In both trees N. fowleri species (- - - -) group together and cluster on a branch of their own. Species identification: The barcoding sequence of the mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase I CO1 gene (Ref. 2) Diversity Analysis via Closed-Tube Barcoding We utilized LATE-PCR in order to amplify the CO1 region and coated the resulting single-stranded DNA with a set of nine Lights-On Lights-Off probes. When these probes bind and melt off, they increase or decrease their fluorescence, which is detected by a PCR machine. As these probes will bind to different sequences of DNA at different temperatures, each species has a unique fluorescent signature. -3738 -2738 -1738 -738 262 1262 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70 75 80 85 Fluorescence (-R' (T)) Temperature (°C) Fluorescent signatures of FBB #1-8 and NEG-H B2, Repl. 1, FBB1 1:10, Q670 B3, Repl. 1, FBB1 1:10, Q670 B4, Repl. 2, FBB2 1:10, Q670 B5, Repl. 2, FBB2 1:10, Q670 B6, Repl. 2, FBB2 1:10, Q670 C1, Repl. 3, FBB3 1:10, Q670 C2, Repl. 3, FBB3 1:10, Q670 C3, Repl. 3, FBB3 1:10, Q670 C5, Repl. 4, FBB4 1:10, Q670 C6, Repl. 4, FBB4 1:10, Q670 D1, Repl. 5, FBB5 1:10, Q670 D2, Repl. 5, FBB5 1:10, Q670 D3, Repl. 5, FBB5 1:10, Q670 D4, Repl. 6, FBB6 1:10, Q670 D5, Repl. 6, FBB6 1:10, Q670 D6, Repl. 6, FBB6 1:10, Q670 E1, Repl. 7, FBB7 1:10, Q670 E2, Repl. 7, FBB7 1:10, Q670 E3, Repl. 7, FBB7 1:10, Q670 E4, Repl. 8, FBB8 1:10, Q670 E5, Repl. 8, FBB8 1:10, Q670 E6, Repl. 8, FBB8 1:10, Q670 F1, Repl. 9, NEGH 1:10, Q670 F2, Repl. 9, NEGH 1:10, Q670 F3, Repl. 9, NEGH 1:10, Q670 Variation & Coexistence of Naegleria in a Birdbath Birds, rodents, and insects use the birdbath and carry in water and soil. Protocol: Disinfect the birdbath, wait for it to become “dirty,” and then sample the water. Would the same species of Naegleria be reintroduced after each cleaning? 10 isolates of Naegleria were taken from successive water samples At least 3 different species were reintroduced How many Naegleria species can coexist in the birdbath? 13 isolates of Naegleria were taken from one water sample At least 3 different species coexisted in this one sample We conclude that Naegleria species coexistence is possible, even between distantly related species The same species are not always reintroduced Future experiments will evaluate congruence of species defined by CO1 versus ITS gene sequences Conclusions from Closed-Tube Barcoding 1. Every strain or species of Naegleria analyzed thus far by Closed-Tube Barcoding has its own fluorescent signature, reflecting its unique CO1 sequence. 2. N. fowleri has a unique signature which is easily recognized compared to other N. species and may be useful for rapid analysis of clinical samples. Location of the birdbath 42°22'10" N 71°16'56" W References 1. De Jonckheere, J.F. 2004. Molecular definition and the ubiquity of species in the genus Naegleria. Protist 155(1):89- 103. 2. Broekman, R. “Defining Species in the Amoeboflagellate Naegleria using Barcoding Based on the Mitochondrial CO1 Gene.” Senior thesis, Brandeis University, 2011. Acknowledgments Funded in part by Brandeis University. Thank you to Ronit Kaufman, Adam Osborne, Jackie Jeon-Chapman, and Jessica Chow, Aquiles Sanchez. Contact Information: [email protected] Species identification: The mitochondrial ITS (internal transcribed spacer) sequence in the rDNA plasmid (Ref. 1) About Birdbath Samples Red strains: Isolates from successive birdbath samples (FBB). Blue strains: Isolates from one birdbath sample (BBH). 183

Upload: others

Post on 23-Apr-2022

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Closed-Tube DNA Barcoding Analysis of the Species and

RESEARCH POSTER PRESENTATION DESIGN © 2015

www.PosterPresentations.com

AbstractBackground: Naegleria are abundant, free-living, freshwater amoebae with a worldwide distribution that are able to differentiate into swimming flagellates. Species within this genus are quitediverse, probably because the genus evolved over a billion years ago. Mesophilic species like N. gruberi live on the five temperate continents, but N. antarctica is thermophobic, and N. fowleriare thermophilic opportunistic human pathogens (the brain-eating amoebae). Previous analysis of short ribosomal ITS sequences catalogued roughly 40 geographically separated species. Ouranalysis, using a combination of Closed-Tube Barcoding of the CO1 gene target plus DNA sequencing suggests better defines the number of species. Analysis of about 75 clonal isolates fromaround the world using both CO1 and ITS sequences show agreement in the degree of relatedness among isolates in most cases.

Results: Closed-Tube DNA Barcoding is an efficient, cost effect method for amplifying the CO1 barcoding target sequence from large numbers of isolates and then scanning the resulting single-stranded DNA for sequence variations using Lights-On/Lights-Off probes. We are using a common set of probes, comprised of three subsets of probes to resolve all species within this genus.Subsets are labeled in different fluorescent colors. This experimental design allows us to compare the fluorescent signatures of different isolates and immediately observe whether sequencedifferences are clustered in one region of the CO1 target, or distributed throughout. These predictions can be confirmed by Dilute-N’-Go sequencing.

Significance: This ground breaking study of Naegleria points the way to using Closed-Tube Barcoding as a method for detection of species variation in microscopic eukaryotes – a world that islargely unknown. Using this approach we will be able to map the species variation in small or large ecosystems. We can also use our approach to selectively test for N. fowleri, or virtually anypathogen in a water sample.

Closed-Tube DNA Barcoding Analysis of the Species and Global Distribution of Naegleria: A Worldwide Genus of Single-celled AmoeboflagellatesHeather Schiller , John Deng , Elaine Lai , Chandler Fulton , Lawrence J. Wangh

Department of Biology, Brandeis University, Waltham Massachusetts, USA

IntroductionNaegleria:• Single-celled, freshwater, eukaryotic• Differentiate from limax amoebae to streamlined

flagellates

Cyst Amoeba Flagellate• Once thought to be a genus with one species,

Naegleria gruberi• The genus has many species, including the

human pathogen N. fowleri.• The genus has more diversity than mammals.• Challenging to define species of Naegleria

because of their propensity to reproduce asexually, despite their capacity for sexual reproduction

Conclusions from Sequencing Analysis

1. Construction of phylogenetic trees based on ITS and CO1 sequences in this genus is a work in progress. While the trees are broadly similar, certain ambiguities remain to be examined more closely.

2. The ITS tree shows thick branches, while the CO1 tree shows finer arborization.

3. In both trees N. fowleri species (- - - -) group together and cluster on a branch of their own.

Species identification:

• The barcoding sequence of the mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase I CO1 gene (Ref. 2)

Diversity Analysis via Closed-Tube BarcodingWe utilized LATE-PCR in order to amplify the CO1region and coated the resulting single-stranded DNAwith a set of nine Lights-On Lights-Off probes. Whenthese probes bind and melt off, they increase ordecrease their fluorescence, which is detected by aPCR machine. As these probes will bind to differentsequences of DNA at different temperatures, eachspecies has a unique fluorescent signature.

-3738

-2738

-1738

-738

262

1262

25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70 75 80 85

Flu

ore

sce

nce

(-R

' (T)

)

Temperature (°C)

Fluorescent signatures of FBB #1-8 and NEG-H

B2, Repl. 1, FBB1 1:10, Q670 B3, Repl. 1, FBB1 1:10, Q670 B4, Repl. 2, FBB2 1:10, Q670

B5, Repl. 2, FBB2 1:10, Q670 B6, Repl. 2, FBB2 1:10, Q670 C1, Repl. 3, FBB3 1:10, Q670

C2, Repl. 3, FBB3 1:10, Q670 C3, Repl. 3, FBB3 1:10, Q670 C5, Repl. 4, FBB4 1:10, Q670

C6, Repl. 4, FBB4 1:10, Q670 D1, Repl. 5, FBB5 1:10, Q670 D2, Repl. 5, FBB5 1:10, Q670

D3, Repl. 5, FBB5 1:10, Q670 D4, Repl. 6, FBB6 1:10, Q670 D5, Repl. 6, FBB6 1:10, Q670

D6, Repl. 6, FBB6 1:10, Q670 E1, Repl. 7, FBB7 1:10, Q670 E2, Repl. 7, FBB7 1:10, Q670

E3, Repl. 7, FBB7 1:10, Q670 E4, Repl. 8, FBB8 1:10, Q670 E5, Repl. 8, FBB8 1:10, Q670

E6, Repl. 8, FBB8 1:10, Q670 F1, Repl. 9, NEGH 1:10, Q670 F2, Repl. 9, NEGH 1:10, Q670

F3, Repl. 9, NEGH 1:10, Q670

Variation & Coexistence of Naegleria in a Birdbath

Birds, rodents, and insects use the birdbath and carry in water and soil.

Protocol: Disinfect the birdbath, wait for it to become “dirty,” and then sample the water.

• Would the same species of Naegleria be reintroduced after each cleaning?

10 isolates of Naegleria were taken from successive water samples

At least 3 different species were reintroduced

• How many Naegleria species can coexist in the birdbath?

13 isolates of Naegleria were taken from one water sample

At least 3 different species coexisted in this one sample

• We conclude that Naegleria species coexistence is possible, even between distantly related species

• The same species are not always reintroduced

• Future experiments will evaluate congruence of species defined by CO1 versus ITS gene sequences

Conclusions from Closed-Tube Barcoding

1. Every strain or species of Naegleria analyzed thus far by Closed-Tube Barcoding has its own fluorescent signature, reflecting its unique CO1 sequence.

2. N. fowleri has a unique signature which is easily recognized compared to other N. species and may be useful for rapid analysis of clinical samples.

Location of the birdbath42°22'10" N 71°16'56" W

References1. De Jonckheere, J.F. 2004. Molecular definition and the ubiquity of species in the genus Naegleria. Protist 155(1):89-103. 2. Broekman, R. “Defining Species in the AmoeboflagellateNaegleria using Barcoding Based on the Mitochondrial CO1 Gene.” Senior thesis, Brandeis University, 2011.

AcknowledgmentsFunded in part by Brandeis University. Thank you to Ronit

Kaufman, Adam Osborne, Jackie Jeon-Chapman, and Jessica Chow, Aquiles Sanchez.Contact Information:[email protected]

Species identification:• The mitochondrial ITS

(internal transcribed spacer) sequence in the rDNA plasmid (Ref. 1)

About Birdbath SamplesRed strains: Isolates from successive birdbath samples (FBB).

Blue strains: Isolates from one birdbath sample (BBH).

183