collectively intelligent material systems · 2 a. whiten, r. byrne (eds.) machiavellian...

96
Collectively Intelligent Material Systems Compositing Digital Systems within Architectural Smart Material Applications By Matthew Lerch A thesis submitted to the Faculty of Graduate and Postdoctoral Affairs in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Architecture Carleton University Ottawa, Ontario © 2017 Matthew Lerch

Upload: others

Post on 05-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Collectively Intelligent Material SystemsCompositing Digital Systems within Architectural

Smart Material Applications

By

Matthew Lerch

A thesis submitted to the Faculty of Graduate and Postdoctoral Affairs in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of

Master of Architecture

Carleton University Ottawa, Ontario

© 2017Matthew Lerch

Page 2: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:
Page 3: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Developedthroughthefieldof materialscienceinthelate

90’s,‘smartmaterials’havebeenemployedbythefieldsof science

andengineeringtominiaturize,expandandreflectaphysicalworld

saturatedwithinformationrichenvironments.However,these‘smart-

materials’areinfrequentlyemployedbyarchitectstoaddressboth

technical,aestheticandspatialarchitecturalissues.Thisthesisaims

touncoverthishesitationbydesignprofessionals,critiquingthe

referenceof ‘smart’andproposesaCollectivelyIntelligentMaterial

system(CIMsystem).Thisdesignproposalsetsforthapractical

responsetotrulyintelligentarchitecturethroughspecificmodels

of CollectivelyIntelligentMaterial(CIM)applicationsbyproducing

‘smartcomposite’facadeexperimentations.Theworkseeksto

combinetheprocessof opticallithographyandArduinobased

digitalprocessingtodevelopaCIMsystem.Thiscanbeemployed

bythearchitectoverneworexistingfaçadestofacilitateintelligent

buildingsurfaces.

iii

Abstract |

Preliminaries | iii

Page 4: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Mysincerestthanksmustfirstgoouttomyfamilywho

haveencouragedmethroughoutallmyacademicendeavorsand

havefosteredaloveof learningwhichhasguidedmetohave

suchcapacitytocompletethisthesis.Anotherthanksmustgoout

tomyfriendsJeanOlivierLarocqueandPaolaVega;Iholdyour

adviceandexpressionsinthehighestregardandwholeheartedly

appreciateyourunwaveringsupport.

Further,wouldliketoexpressmygratitudetoallmy

undergraduatestudioprofessorswhomrousedmyinsatiable

curiosityof fabricationtechniquesandmaterialapplications.A

specialthankstoJohanVoordouw,mythesisadvisor,forhisgracious

advisementanddedicatedreview.Aswell,Iwouldliketothank

SherylBoyle,whograntedessentialsiteinformationandfacilitated

indispensablecrossdisciplinaryconsultation.Iwouldalsoliketo

thankJeanLarocqueandRuthElderforfacilitatingtheworkshop

spacethroughwhichIhavebeenabletoproduceallthefollowing

physicalmodelsandequipment.

Lastly,thefollowingtechnicalandphysicalprototypes

wouldnothavebeenpossiblewithouttheearnestconsultationof

dedicatedgraduatestudentsandfacultymembersof theCarleton

GraduateEngineeringProgram.Iwouldliketothankinspecific,

IanBeausoleil-Morrisonwhoprovidedthereferencedrawings

necessarytoconstructaworkingprototype.

Acknowledgements |

Preliminaries | iv

Page 5: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

00 | Preliminaries:

Abstract

Acknowledgements

Listof Tables

Listof Illustrations

Listof Appendices

01 | Introduction

Identifyingwithmaterials

Methodology

Scope

02 | Part 1

SmartMaterials

Approachingourenvironments

Notsosmart

03 | Part 2

Collectivelyintelligentmaterialsystems

Makingsubstrates

Opticallithography

Micro-controllers

iii

iv

vi

vi

viii

001

005

006

010

009

021

025

036

040

048

Table of Contents |

04 | Conclusion

ApplyingCIMsystemmethodology

Beyondthesurface

05 | Appendices

TBdatasheets

Componentdatasheets

Arduinocode

Rawdatafrompaneltest

07 | Works Cited

Bibliography

ImageCitation

057

060

070

072

075

083

085

089

Page 6: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Table1.Smartmaterialcharacterization

Table2.Currentsmartenvironmentapproaches

Table3.Currentintelligentenvironmentapproaches

Table4.Futureintelligentenvironmentapproaches

Figure01.NewCaledonianCrow

Figure02.Elemententries

Figure03.Solarhouseaxonometric

Figure04.Solarhousesiteplan

Figure05.SpidermiteonMEMs

Figure06.Ceramics

Figure07.Thermostaticdiagram

Figure08.Thermostaticcoil

Figure09.Thermostaticstrips

Figure10.Biophysicalenvironment

Figure11.Bloom

Figure12.BreezingBlocks

Figure13.ProjectBlackBox

Figure14.DeepBlue

Figure15.ConceptPhoto

Figure16.CIMsystempaneldiagram

Figure17.CIMsystempanel

Figure18.CIMsingleleaf

Figure19.CIMsystempanelgroup

Figure20.CIMsystemmountingorientation

// List of Tables

// List of Illustrations

014

030

030

030

002

004

007

008

011

012

015

015

015

017

018

019

020

024

029

031

033

033

034

034

Preliminaries | vi

Page 7: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

035

035

036

037

038

039

041

043

043

044

045

046

047

048

049

049

050

050

051

052

053

053

054

054

055

056

Figure21.CIMsystemarray

Figure22.CIMsystemarraysketch

Figure23.Sensortest

Figure24.SolarHouseCIMsystemconcept

Figure25.CircuityTest

Figure26.Conductivepaint

Figure27.Sensoriterations

Figure28.220Meshmacro

Figure29.100Meshmacro

Figure30.Iteration1.sensors1/3

Figure31.Iteration1.sensors2/3

Figure32.Iteration1.sensors3/3

Figure33.Printingprocedure

Figure34.ArduinoUnoR3graphic

Figure35.Transmitterperspectiveopen

Figure36.Transmitterperspectiveclose

Figure37.Transmitterelevationlong

Figure38.Transmitterelevationshort

Figure39.Transmitterplan

Figure40.Transmitterdiagram

Figure41.Receiverperspectiveopen

Figure42.Receiverperspectiveclose

Figure43.Receiverelevationlong

Figure44.Receiverelevationshort

Figure45.Receiverplan

Figure46.Receiverdiagram

Preliminaries | vii

Page 8: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

List of Appendicies |

AppendixA-ThermostaticBimetalDataSheets

AppendixB-ComponentDataSheets

AppendixC-ArduinoCode

AppendixD-RawDatafromPanelTest

AppendixE-FinalPrintFrames

069

070

070

079

080

Preliminaries | viii

Figure47.Wiringschematicdrawing

Figure48.NetworkDiagram

Figure49.InterfaceDiagram

Figure50.CodeExample

Figure51.OutputFileDiagram

Figure52.PhysicalPrototypeMock-up

Figure53.Southfacadelocation

Figure54.Conceptualsketchdiagram

Figure55.FinalPrintFrame1/4

Figure56.FinalPrintFrame2/4

Figure57.FinalPrintFrame3/4

Figure58.FinalPrintFrame4/4

057

058

059

060

061

063

064

065

069

080

081

082

Page 9: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Whileourlivingenvironmentsareconceivedthrough

architecture,theylimitedbythematerialswhichareavailableto

thearchitect.1Thisdistinctionhasalwaysbeenprojectedthrough

myprocessandconceptionof designandisapartialmotiveto

pursueamaterialbasedthesis.Thisapproachhasgrownmy

abilitytoeffectivelydesignspaceandhascodifiedanappreciation

fortheuniqueawarenesswhicharchitectshaveof materials.

Therefore,Ifinditof greatinteresttoexplorearchitecturethrough

unconventionalmaterialapplications,undoubtedlyreturning

unconventionalarchitecture.Indoingso,thisthesisfocuses

specificallyuponexploringunconventionalmaterialproperties,

proposingadvancedmanufacturingmethodsandalternativesmart

materialapplicationswithinarchitecture.Thenecessitytoalter

1 Marx,Karl,andFriedrichEngels,TheGermanIdeology,4.

Introduction 01 |

Identifying with

materials

“The things to be prepared are these, l ime, t imber, sand, stone, as also iron, brass, lead, glass and the l ike. But the thing of greatest consequence is to choose skil l ful workmen.” - LeonBatt istaAlber t i 1485

Introduction | 1

Page 10: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

natureisoneof themanycharacteristics,whichdefineintelligent

beings.TakeforexamplethetoolwieldingCrowsof theFrench

Territoryof NewCaledonia.Thisparticularspeciesof crowhave

beenobservedtouseproto-toolssuchassticksandgrasses

tocompletetasksthatwouldrequireanalogicalreasoning.In

particular,thesecondaryactof usingtoolstoretrieveormakenew

toolshavebeenobserved;themeta-tool.2

2 A.Whiten,R.Byrne(Eds.)MachiavellianIntelligenceVolII:EvaluationsandExtensions.Cam-bridgeUniversityPress,Cambridge;1997:289–311

Introduction | 2

Right//

NewCaledoniaCrowholding

fashionedimpliment.

fig.1

proto-tool//

Earliestformof animplement

usedasameansof

accomplishingataskorpurpose

analogicalreasoning//

anytypeof thinkingthatcites

acceptedsimilaritiesbetween

twosystemstosupportthe

conclusionthatsomefurther

similarityexists.

meta-tool//

Conceptof toolsinwhichthree

traitsmustbesatisfied-1.

individualmustrecognizethat

toolscanbeusedonnonfood

objects2.individualmustinitially

inhibitadirectresponsetoward

themaingoalof obtainingfood

3.anindividualmustbecapable

of hierarchicallyorganized

behavior;theymustbeable

toflexiblyintegratenewly

innovatedbehavior(tool>tool)

withestablishedbehaviorsas

asubgoalinachievingamain

goal(tool>tool>food).

Page 11: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Whileitisarguedwithinbehaviouralsciencethattheuse

of meta-toolsistheartifactthatfacilitatedhominidtechnological

evolutionandtheharnessingof nature,3itwouldoverlookthe

fundamentalpropertywhichallowsthetooltophysicallyrevealits

usefulness;asthemediumthroughwhichhumanitycanaltertheir

environments.Thehuman(justasthecrow)musthavethephysical

presenceof materialtomake,asthetoolsrequiresmateriality

tobemadeinthefirstplace.4Thisendowmentof physicalityas

MartinHeideggerdefinesisbetterknownas,“causamaterialis,

thematerial,thematteroutof which[ourtools]aremade”.5Inhis

descriptioncausamaterialismakesuponeof fouressentialcauses

forinstrumentality,akindof physicalmanifestationof technology.As

technologyisameanstoanend,theshapingandcontrollingof our

environments,itisnotthetoolswhichhumanityusestoshapethe

environment.Rather,itisourcapabilitytoidentifywhatismaterial;

whatwecanusetoalterourlandscapes.Humanscanalsodefine

themselvesasacollectionof beingsandconsequentially,beings

madefrommaterials.Wearenotseparatefromourmaterialbodies,

ratherourphysicalpresenceenablesustomakeourenvironments.

Wereigninasortof earthyparadiseof material,6intrinsictonotonly

ourbeing,butfurthertowhatourbeingthencreates.7

3 Taylor,AlexH.,GavinR.Hunt,andJenniferC.Holzhaider.“SpontaneousMetatoolUsebyNewCaledonianCrows.”CurrentBiology17,no.17(September4,2007):1504-507.doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2007.07.057showArticleInfo.

4 Heidegger,Martin.2008.MartinHeidegger-BasicWritings:fromBeingandTimetotheTaskof Thinking.ModernThoughtEdition.EditedbyDavidFarrellKrell.NewYork,NY:HarperPerennial,313.

5 Ibid.

6 Bachelard,Gaston.1994.ThePoeticsof Space.TranslatedbyMariaJolas.Boston,MA:BeaconPress,7.

7 Marx,Karl,andFriedrichEngels.1932.TheGermanIdeology:IdealismandMaterialism.Moscow:Marx-EngelsInstitute,3.

Introduction | 3

reveal//

AsdefinedbyHeidegger,

technologyisafundamental

modeof revealing,tomake

knownthetruthandframing

previouslyconcealedprocesses.

Page 12: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Whenreferringtounconventionalmaterialproperties,the

phrasedoesnotsimplydenoteunusualorunexpectedpropertiesof

materials.Itisinfacttheopposite;wehaveadetailedunderstanding

of materialbehaviour.Sincetheconceptionof theperiodictableby

Mendeleevcirca.1869,8matterhasbeenorganizedcategorically

andelementbehaviourshavebecomerelativelypredictable.

Instead,unconventionalmaterialpropertiesof ourrecentgeneration,

datingbacktotheearly90’s,refertomaterialswhichhavethe

unexpectedcapabilitytorespondtotheirenvironments.9These

‘smartmaterials’,astermedin1992bytheNationalAeronautics

andSpaceAdministration10(NASA),areincreasinglyusedby

engineerstominiaturize,simplifyandadaptexistingengineered

systems(mechanical,electrical,chemical,etc.).Throughaseriesof

tangentialdevelopedinterestsinbothdigitaldesignandadvanced

fabricationtechniques,architectshavenotonlybecomeawareof

smartmaterialsapplicationsbuthavebegunpreliminarydesign

trials,incorporatingselecttypologiesof smartmaterialswithinhighly

specializedarchitecturalapplications.Smartmaterialshavealso

gainedpopularitywitharchitects,inpartduetoopportunitiesof

economizationandoptimization.

Thetoolswhicharchitectsareofferedareindeedmore

flexible(parametricallyconceived),11andthereforematerial

propertiesoughttobeasflexibleastheenvironmentsinwhich

8 Rittner,Don,andRonaldA.Bailey.2005.Encyclopediaof Chemistry.NewYork,NY:FactsOnFileInc.s.v.‘periodictable’

9 Ritter,Axel.2007.Smartmaterialsinarchitecture,interiorarchitecture,anddesign.EnglishEdition.EditedbyAndreasMüller.TranslatedbyRaymondPeat.Basel:Birkhäuser,7.

10 Addington,Michelle,andDanielSchodek.2005.SmartMaterialsandTechnologies:forthearchitectureanddesignprofessions.Oxford:ArchitecturalPress,1.

11 Jabi,Wassim.Parametricdesignforarchitecture.2013London:LaurenceKingPublishing,15.

Introduction | 4

FeIron

26 55.85

Ni

Cu

Nickle

Copper

28

29

65.38

63.55

Above//

Elementsentriesastakenfrom

theperiodtable.

fig.2

smartmaterials//

Materialsandproductsthatare

abletoreversiblychangetheir

shapeand/orpropertiesin

responsetooneormorestimuli

throughexternalinfluences.

parametric//

Relatingtoor

expressedintermsof a

parameterthroughalgorithmic

thinking.

Page 13: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

theyareconceptualized.Thecurrentopportunities,however,of

smartmaterialsshouldbeaddressedcriticality.Architectsshould

considerthelimitationsof smartmaterialsandthereforebekeento

refusetheirapplicationwhere‘dumbmaterial’12wouldbepreferable.

Thequestionthenfollows;howcansmartmaterialsbeused

intelligentlywithinarchitecturetocreatethebespokearchitectural

environmentsdesiredbyaneraof informationrichenvironments?

Throughansweringthisquestionanunderlyinginquiryintohowsuch

intelligencemightbeaddressedcriticallywillrespondtotheirclaim

asaunilateralsolutionforcomplexarchitecturalproblems.13smart

materialandtechnologies.

Itwillbethefirsttaskof thisthesistoconveythe

misunderstandingof thetermsmartmaterials,notonlybecause

‘smart’improperlydefinestheircapabilitiesbutalsobecausesmart

materialsareoversimplifiedasasolutiontoarchitecturalproblems

involvingthemaintainingandmonitoringof buildingdesignand

systems.Throughprobingaseriesof casestudiesbyDorisSung

andNickPackett,thedistinctionbetweenmaterialintelligenceand

highperformancematerialswillbeaddressed.Digitalsystems,

whichusesmartmaterialsasactuators,sensorsandtransducers

applythemselvesinasimilarfashionbuthavebeenusedby

engineerssincetheearly60’supontheadventof thetransistor.

Machinebasedlogicintheformof proprietaryArduino

basedhardwarewillbethemechanismthroughwhichsensors,

actuatorsandtransducerswillbeexplored,toapplyanexisting

12 Addington,Michelle,andDanielSchodek.2005.SmartMaterialsandTechnologies:forthearchitectureanddesignprofessions.Oxford:ArchitecturalPress,9.

13 Ibid.216.

Introduction | 5

Methodology

dumbmaterial//

Anantheticdefinitionof smart

materialsascoinedbyAxel

Ritter.Amaterialwhichdoes

notactivelychangestatein

responsetoenvironmental

stimuli.

digitalsystem//

Acomputational

systemwhichhandlesdiscrete

signals.

transistor//

asemiconductordevicewhich

regulateselectricalsignals

Arduino//

Abrandof opensource

microcontrollerswhichis

aimedatenthusiastslevel

programmingapplications.

sensor//

Adevicewhichdetectsinput

(usuallyenvironmental)and

convertsinputintoanelectrical

signal.

actuator//

Adevicewhichconverts

electricalsignalsinto

mechanicalactiontoactupon

anenvironment.

transducer//

Adevicewhichconvertsone

typeof electricalsignalinto

anothertypeof electricalsignal.

Page 14: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

hardwareunderstandingtoanexistingcategoryof smartmaterials.

Theseexistingmaterialsknownasthermostaticbimetalsarechosen

asanoptimalsubstrateforexperimentationbecausetheyreact

withtheprimaryenvironmentalstimuliwithwhicharchitectureis

concerned(i.e.sunlight,heatgain,andclimate.14Abrief critiqueof

whatdefinesintelligencefromamachinemind(machinelearning)

perspectivewillbeusedasacatalysttoredefinesmartmaterials.

Indoingso,thisredefinitionwillproposeasystembasedapproach

tomaterials,integratingthedigitallogicof theArduinointoa

thermostaticbimetalfaçadesystem.ItermaCollectivelyIntelligent

Materialsystem(CIMsystems),expandinguponboththetraditional

modeof materialsandproposingamediumbywhichtrue‘smart

material’canbeachieved.AsthethesiswillproposeaCIMSystem

tobetested,Part2of thisthesisexploresthemanufacturing

principles,commentsontestedprototypes,andproposesafinal

CIMsystemdesign.

Thefuturedesignproposalsandmethodswillbeginto

explorethesoftwareof CIMsystemcomponents.UsingtheArduino

microcontrollerandtheCprogramminglanguageacomprehensive

designandphysicalprototypewillbecreatedandtested.Thegoal

of thephysicalprototypewillbetotestthefinalCIMsystemiteration

uponarealexteriorfaçadesystem.Thiswouldbeaccomplished

throughdevelopingasmallworkingCIMsystemarraythatcouldbe

installeduponasouthfacingbuildingfaçade.Thechosensitetobe

consideredistheUrbandaleSolarReseachcenterlocatedonthe

14 Banham,Reyner.1984.TheArchitectureof theWellTemperedEnviorment.London:Architec-turalPress,18.

Scope

Introduction | 6

thermostaticbimetals//

Acompositesmartmaterial

comprisedof twometalswith

differentcoefficientsof thermal

expansionthatarebonded

together.Thematerialcanbend

basedonthermalinput(ie.

changeintemperature).

Cprogramminglanguage//

Aprogramming

languagethatisidealfor

developingfirmwareorportable

applicationsondevicessuchas

microcontrollers.

Page 15: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

northcampusof CarletonUniversity.Testingwouldbeconducted

overmultiplesolarcyclesandundervaryingconditionsasoverseen

bytheCarletonGraduateSchoolof EngineeringandDesign.

Introduction | 7

Right//

UrbandaleCenterforHome

EnergyResearchAxonometricfig.3

Page 16: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

fig.4

UrbandaleSolarResearch

Center//

Introduction | 8

Page 17: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Itwillnotbewithinthescopeof thisthesistoexploreastrategy

todeveloptheartificialintelligence(AI)ormachinelearning

componentsof theCIMsystem.Areaswithinneuroscienceand

computerscience/engineeringhavedevelopedsuitablestrategies

toaccompanythephysicalcomponentsof theproposedsystem.

However,furtherresearchwillbeconductedintheareaof AIso

thatasuitablestrategycanbechosenfortheparticularCIMsystem

whichthisthesissubmits.

artificalintelligence//

Abranchof computerscience

dealingwiththesimulationof

humanbehavioursuchasvisual

perception,speechrecognition

anddecisionmaking.

Introduction | 9

Page 18: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Whilethearchitect,developedfromthemasterbuilderof

the14thcentury,hasanintimateunderstandingof thematerials

usedtofabricateanddesign,thisintimacyhasmovedtothe

technicalspecificationof theengineeroverthecourseof the

lasttwodecades.Thisoffloadingof specificbuildingmaterial

knowledgetothearchitecturalconsultantcanbetracedbacktothe

industrialrevolutionyetthespecificalienationof smartmaterials

feltbyarchitectsisprimarilyexpeditedbythedigitalrevolutionof

the1960’s.Specifically,whenmethodstominiaturizeandquantify

materialcharacteristicswererequiredtomakeearlycomputer

hardwarecomponents,engineersbegantodevelopmaterialsthat

requiredgreaterspecificityof response.Miniaturizationrequired

componentsthatcouldpassivelyact,therebyrequiringmaterials

thatcoulddothesame.Thisnewworldof semiconductorsand

digitalmachinesbecamethetoolsthroughwhichactioncouldbe

programmed,aidedbythesenewsmartmaterialabilitiestoswitch

statebasedonadefinedinput(eithermechanicalorelectricalinthe

caseof thedigitalmachine).15

15 Addington,Michelle,andDanielSchodek.SmartMaterialsandTechnologies,8.

Part 1 02 |

The Smart Material

Part 1 | 10

“Some material innovations are unlike plastics, metals or ceramics, invisible: the infromatioin you re-cive from materials wil l change the physical interaction you have with them, rather than change the way they look” - Chris Lefteri 2013

Page 19: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Micro-electro-mechanical-systems(MEMS)exemplifytheshifttominiaturize

andoptimizeelectroniccomponents.MEMSwerefirstproducedcommercially

in1958intheformof straingaugesusingsiliconasabasematerial.16Silicon,

discoveredtohavesmart-materialproperties(piezo-resistiveeffect:whendeformed

resistselectricalcurrent)only4yearsbefore,wasalreadybeingusedtoproduce

semiconductorswithinthefirstcomputers.17AscorrelatedbyAddington,“smart

materialsandmicrotechnologyhadadheredtoparallel,albeitclose,researchand

developmenttracks”,andassuchtheycanbefoundinasymbioticrelationship

withindigitalmachinestoday.18MEMSarecommonlyusedassensorstodetect

environmentalconditions,transducerstorelaydigitalinformation(electricalsignals),

andactuatorstointeractwiththephysicalenvironment.Thesignificantarchitectural

applicationsof MEMSderivefromtheverythingwhichhistoricallyalienatesthem

fromarchitects;theypresenttheopportunitytominiaturizebuildingmaterialsand

programfunctionalitynotperceivedthroughsightratherbybeingexperienced.19

16 Cressler,JohnD.Siliconearth:introductiontomicroelectronicsandnanotechnology.2016,BocaRaton:CRCPress,Taylor&FrancisGroup,332.

17 Ibid.

18 Addington,Michelle,andDanielSchodek.SmartMaterialsandTechnologies,viii.

19 Spiller,N.,&Armstrong,R.(2011,Mar/Apr).ProtocellArchitecture.(H.Castle,Ed.)Architec-turalDesign,81(2),27.

Part 1 | 11

Micro electro-

mechnical systems

fig.5

right//

Twoviewsof aspidermite

crawilingacrossthesurfaceof

amircoelectro-mechnicalgear

chain.

Page 20: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Sincematerialsatamicroscaleactdifferentlyfromthe

samematerialatthemacro(buildingscale),theengineerandthe

architecthaveafundamentallydifferentunderstandingof thesame

materials.Anexampleof thisdisjoinedawarenessisillustrated

byceramics.20Commonlyceramicsareusedbyengineersas

insulatorsof eitherelectricalorthermalenergy.Atthemicro-scale

ceramicsactasresistors,allowingonlysmallamountsof electricity/

heattoflowthroughthem.Thispropertyisessentialtoproducing

computercomponentsthatcanregulateandinterpretelectrical

current.However,architectsselecttheverysameceramicsnotfor

thetaskof regulationbutasafinish.Thepropertiesof durability

andresistancetochemical,thermal,andelectricalresistanceare

alsoexploitedbyarchitectsbutnotwithasimilarintention,nor

understanding.Thearchitecthasdifferentperformancecriteria

whicharemetbyceramicsatthemacroscaleof abuildingmaterial,

whiletheengineerusesceramicsatthemicroscaletosatisfya

differenttask.Smartmaterialsingeneralpresentthemselveswith

thesameunifyingchallenges.Therefore,smartmaterialswhichare

usedinarchitecturetodaymustnotonlybesmart,theyshouldbe

conventionallybuildable.

20 Lefteri,Chris.2014.MaterialsforDesign.London:LaurenceKingPublishing,202.

Part 1 | 12

<>

right//

Acomparisonbetweenceramic

inelectroniccomponents

(resistors)andarchitectural

components(roof tile).

fig.6

Page 21: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Tomakeaconventional‘thing’buildableonemust

understandhowitismanufactured,andunderstandingsmart

materialmanufacturingrequiresacharacterizationof whatmakes

asmartmaterial.Thefirstcharacteristicof anysmartmaterial

isimmediacy.Smartmaterialsmustrespondinrealtime,as

suchtheyaretemporal,changingfrequentlybetweenstatesor

convertingenergyinanimmediatemanner.Asmartmaterialmust

alsohavetransiency,meaningitmustchangebasedondiffering

environmentalstates.21Environmentalstateswhenreferringto

smartmaterialsarenotspecificallyfromthenaturalenvironment,

ratherdifferingstatesof environmentshouldbethoughtof moreas

stimulationorinputviaenergytransfer(e.g.changesintemperature

(thermalenergy)convertedtomovement(mechanicalenergy)).

Smartmaterialsmustbebi-directional,meaningthatthechanges

incurredbydifferentenvironmentalstatesmustberepeatableand

reversible.22Asmart-materialisself-actuatingthroughitsinternal

programmingof molecularstructure,composition,assembly,and

chemicalproperties.Asmart-materialdoesnotrequireanexternal

intelligentsystemtofunction,suchasanelectronicactuatoror

sensorstoprovideinput.Buildingonprogramming,smart-materials

musthaveselectivity.Theymustresponddiscreetlytoenvironmental

conditionsandbepredictabletocontroltheirvariability.Lastly,the

characteristicof “directness[which]posesthegreatestchallenge

toarchitects”23,describestheabilityforasmartmaterialtorespond

21 Addington,Michelle,andDanielSchodek.SmartMaterialsandTechnologies,10.

22 Ritter,Axel.Smartmaterialsinarchitecture,9.

23 Addington,Michelle,andDanielSchodek.SmartMaterialsandTechnologies,10.

Part 1 | 13

immediacy//

thequalityof bringingoneinto

directandinstantinvolvement

withsomething,givingrisetoa

senseof urgencyorexcitement.

transiency//

passingespeciallyquicklyinto

andoutof aparticularstate.

self-actuating//

theachievementof full

potentialthroughcreativity,

independence,spontaneity,and

agraspof therealworld

selectivity//

theabilityof adevicetorespond

toaparticularfrequencywithout

interferencefromothers

directness//

havingtheablitytodesceetly

manageorinteractwithothersin

anauthoratiativemanner

.

Page 22: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

locallytoenvironmentalstatechange.Asbuildingservicesystems

(HVAC,lighting,etc.)withincurrentarchitectureisneitherdiscrete

norresponddirectlytoenvironmentalchanges,thecharacteristics

of smartmaterialsystemsoffersanopportunitytorethinkbuilding

environmentsatthesmallscale;thehumanscale.24

24 Ibid.

Part 1 | 14

Type of Smart Material

Type1PropertyChanging

ThermomochronicsPhotochronicsMechanochronicsChemochronicsElectrochromicsLiquidcrystalSuspendedparticleElectricaleologicalMagnetorheological

Type2EnergyExchanging

ElectroluminecentsPhotoluminecentsChemoluminecentsThermoluminecentsLight-emittingdiodesPhotovoltaics

Type2EnergyExchangingreversible

PiezoelectricPyroelectricThermoelectricElectrorestrictiveMegnetorestrictiveThermostatic

Input

TemperaturedifferenceRadiation(light)DeformationChemicalconcentrationElectricalpotentialdifferenceElectricalpotentialdifferenceElectricalpotentialdifferenceElectricalpotentialdifferenceElectricalpotentialdifference

ElectricalpotentialdifferenceRadiationChemicalconcentrationTemperaturedifferenceElectricalpotentialdifferenceRadiation(light)

DeformationTemperaturedifferenceTemperaturedifferenceElectricalpotentialdifferenceMagneticfeildTemperaturedifference

Output

ColourchangeColourchangeColourchangeColourchangeColourchangeColourchangeColourchangeStiffness/viscositychangeStiffness/viscositychange

LightLightLightLightLightElectricpotentialdifference

ElectricpotentialdifferenceElectricpotentialdifferenceElectricpotentialdifferenceDeformationDeformationDeformation

right//

SmartMaterialCharacterization

Table.Highlightedtermsintable

1.denotesmartmaterialswhich

areexploredinthisthesis

table1.

Page 23: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

ThermostaticBi-metals(TB)arelaminatedcompositematerialsthatconsistof

atleasttwocomponents,usuallybandsorstrips,madeof metalswithdifferent

thermalexpansioncoefficients,whicharepermanentlybondedtooneanother.25The

componentwiththelowercoefficientof thermalexpansioniscalledpassive,theone

withthehighercoefficientactive.26Dependingonthewaythetemperaturechanges

overtime,thecomponentsusedandtheirgeometries,thecompositetakesupa

curvedshapeandcanbeusedasanactuatorinmechanicalapplications(seefig.

7).Architecturally,thermostaticbi-metalshavebeenusedprimarilyinexperimental

façadesystemstocontrolnaturallightandsensetemperaturechangewithinbuilding

servicesystems(viaservicesystemcomponentssuchasthermostats).

25 Ritter,A.(2007).Smartmaterialsinarchitecture,interiorarchitecture,anddesign(EnglishEditioned.).(A.Müller,Ed.,&R.Peat,Trans.)Basel,Switzerland:Birkhäuser.53.

26 Ibid,54.

Part 1 | 15

Thermostaic

Bi-metals

top//

Digramshowingtooperative

qualitiesof abimetalicstrip.

left//

Digramshowingtooperative

qualitiesof abimetalicstrip.

right//

Digramshowingtooperative

qualitiesof abimetalicstrip.

1 2

Active

Passive

fig.7

fig.9fig.8

Page 24: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Architecturewhichincorporatessmart-materialsengage

thelocalphysicalenvironment.Itdoesthisfunctionallythrough

itsfaçadesystem,whichresiststhechangesof thenatural

environmentandallowsanaugmentedinteriorenvironmenttoexist

(referredtoasbiophysicalenvironmentbyHensel,seefig.10).27

Thisaugmentedinteriorenvironmentisfacilitatedthroughbuilding

managementsystems,includingHVAC,lightingcontrols,passive

systemsandothers.Consequentially,thefaçadesystemisthe

componentwhichseparatesthisboundary;asurface.Thesurface

ontheinterior,beingthatof finishedandpleasanttacticallyforthe

occupants,contrastedbytheexteriorsurfacewhichoperatesto

resiststhenaturalelements.InSmartMaterialsandTechnologies,it

isunderstoodbyAddingtonthat,“architects[donot]designspace,

therealityisthatarchitectsmake(draw)surfaces”.28Therefore,since

architecture’sphysicalityisderivedfromsurface,itwouldfollowthat

thissurface’smaterialisprofoundlyessentialindefininghowthat

surfacewillbehave(whatrelationshipitwillhavewiththeinteriorand

exteriorenvironments).

27 Hensel,M.(2013).Perfromance-OrientedArchitecture:RethikingArchitecturalDesignandtheBuiltEnviorment.(M.Swift,Ed.)Chichester,WS,UK:JohnWiley&SonsLtd,56.

28 Addington,Michelle,andDanielSchodek.SmartMaterialsandTechnologies,12.

Approaching our

Environments

Part 1 | 16

“Architectural surfaces are derived first through the visual qualit ies of the material and second by under-standing materials as a barrier” - Micheal Hensel 2013

Page 25: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

below//

Thediagramillustratesthe

relationshipbetweenelements

withinafacadesystemand

thereinteractionwithinthebiotic

enviorment(interior)andthe

abioticenvioremnt(exterior)

Part 1 | 17

fig.10

Page 26: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

DOSUStudioArchitectureisLosAngelesbasedmaterialresearchstudio

thatisprimarilyfocusedonproducingphysicalprototypesusingthermostatic

bimetals.Commentingonhermostrecentinstallation(2012)entitled‘Bloom’,Doris

KimSungsuggests,“challengingthetraditionalpresumptionthatbuildingskinsare

staticandinanimate”.29Theprojectexaminesthereplacementof thestaticbuilding

facadebyproposingaprostheticlayerbetweenpeopleandtheirenvironmentasa

responsiveandactiveskin.Usingsmartmaterialsastheactivecomponentwhich

facilitatesanimationof herfacades,Sungdemonstratestheefficacyof thermostatic

bimetalsasanexteriorbuildingsurfacewithtwofunctions.Thefirstistheuseof

thermostaticbimetalsasasunshadingmechanismthatcontrolslightexposureof

anexteriorcourtyardasthetemperatureincreasesthroughouttheday.30Thesecond

functionof theskinistoventilatehotairthroughthesameperforationwhichexpose

thebimetalflaps.31Theprojectillustratesthepracticaluseof smartmaterialsthrough

aunifiedsurfacemethod.

29 Sung,Doris.2014.“DigitalandParameticArchitecture.”EditedbyCarloAiello.(EVOLO,Inc)(6):117.

30 Fox,Michael.2016.Interactivearchitecture:adaptiveworld.NewYork:PrincetonArchitecturalPress,132.

31 Sung,Doris.2014.“DigitalandParameticArchitecture.”EditedbyCarloAiello.(EVOLO,Inc)(6):117.

Part 1 | 18

Doris Sung

Case Study

fig.11

Bloom

right//

Exteriorarchitecturalinstallation

utilizingthematerialproperties

of thermostaticbimetals.

Page 27: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Incontrastherapproachtowindowshuttersystemsutilizes‘breezingblocks’.32

Thesesmartmaterialcomponentsaresynthesizedusingthermostaticbimetalsand

traditionalglassfacadesaimedatdevelopingbuildingcomponentsforindustry.

Basedontheprincipalof solarheatgain,Sungexploresaseriesof patternswhich

utilizeprogrammedbimetallicstrips.Thesestripswithinthewallcomponentsbend

basedupontheamountof thermalgain,shadingtheinteriorenvironments.Sung

speculates“thispanelsystemcanhelpreduceheatgain,reducetheneedfor

artificialair-conditioning,andconserveenergy”.33

32 Ibid.

33 Ibid,118.

Part 1 | 19

Breezing Blocks

right//

facadeconstructionutilizingTB

flapstoregulatesolarexposure

withinwallcavity.

fig.12

Page 28: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

ProjectBlackBoxisaresearchinitiativeauthoredbyNickPuckett,founding

directorof AltNResearch+Design.Begunin2012,ProjectBlackBoxexploresthe

applicationof shapememorypolymers(SMPs)intwodistinctmethods.34Thefirst

methodappliesopensourcemethodologiesof softwareandhardwaredevelopment

totherealmof materialsscience.Developedin1980,SMPsareclassifiedas

temperatureresponsivematerials(thermostatic),butunlikebimetalstheycanbe

programmedtoshapetoaspecificcurvature.35Thisisdonethroughheatingthe

materialtotheGlassTransitionTemperature;thespecifictemperatureregionwhere

thepolymertransitionsfromahard,glassymaterialtoasoft,rubberymaterial.36

Essentiallythematerialcanbeprogrammed,inthesamemannerbywhichwe

programopensourcehardware(i.e.Arduino).Inthiswaythedesigncommunityis

beginningtoclaimmaterialasthenewsoftware.37

34 Puckett,N.(2014).If materialisthenewsoftware,thenhowdoIwriteit?InD.D.Gerber,ParadigmsinComputing(pp.288-297).LosAngeles:eVoloPress,289.

35 Ibid,290.

36 Ibid,293.

37 Nicholas,P.(2013).DesigningMaterialMaterialisingDesign.(R.Roke,Ed.)Waterloo,ON,Canada:RiversideArchitecturalPress.12.

Part 1 | 20

Nick Puckett

Case Study

Project Black Box

fig.13

Page 29: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Inhissecondbookof theTenBooksonArchitecture,

Vitruviuswritesabout“MaterialsSuitedfortheConstructionof

Buildings”.38Thesematerialsfortraditionalconstruction,suchas

wood,stoneandtimber,havebeenusedfortheiruniquematerial

properties,exhibitingstableandpredicablebehavioursforspecific

architecturalpurposes.AsdescribedbyAddington,traditional

materialswouldseemdumbincomparisontosmartmaterials

exhibitingtransientbehaviours.39Whiletraditional‘dumb’materials

seemmoreakintotherawmaterialsfoundwithinnature,“dumb

materialsandstructurescontrastsharplywiththenaturalworld”.40

Naturedisplaystheabilitytoadapttotheenvironmentinrealtime.41

Therefore,throughthecultivationof materialsweproducedumb

materials;theyareessentiallyzombiesof theirnaturalbeing,defined

asadeadbodygiventhesemblanceof lifebutmuteandwill-less.42

Thisapproachof identifyingdumbmaterialsyieldsananthropic

perspective,onewhere‘smartness’and‘dumbness’havebeen

appropriatedtovaguelydefinecharacteristicswhichdistinguish

materialepochs.

Thisphenomenoniscorrelatedwiththemarketingapproach

of smartmaterialtechnology.Initsinfancy,thetermsmartmaterial

developedinaneradesignatedbytheGeorgeBushadministration

as‘thedecadeof thebrain’.43Itwasadecadeoccurringbetween

38 Vitruvius.(1914).TheTenBooksonArchitecture.London:HarvardUniversityPress,41.

39 Addington,Michelle,andDanielSchodek.SmartMaterialsandTechnologies,10.

40 Friend,C.(1996).Smartmaterials:theemergingtechnology.MaterialsWorld,4,16.

41 Ibid.

42 PenguinReference.(2004).ConciseEnglishDictonary.(R.Allen,Ed.)Oxford,UK:Pengin Group,s.v.zombie.

43 George,J.D.(2001).TheDecadeof theBrain-Adecadeof Scholarship.Journalof theHistoryof theNurosciences,10(1),113.

Part 1 | 21

Not so smart

Page 30: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

1990-2000,whichsensationalizedcutting-edgeresearchon

cognitionandneuroscientificresearch,encouragingpublicdialogue

throughinteragencyinitiatives.44Heavilyfunded,theseinitiatives

notonlyspurredoriginalresearch,italsomarketedthebrainand

subsequentlyitsfunctionasthezeitgeistof the90’s.Therefore,the

term‘smart’beingthatof quickwittedintelligence,45isnotsomuch

definingthefunctionalityof thematerialasitisretailingmaterial

research.

Moreover,theterm‘smart’insmartmaterialscanbe

critiquedfromanetymologicalperspective.If smartinfersquick

wittedintelligence,thenitwouldfollowthatsmartmaterialsnotonly

havetobeintelligentbutarequickwittedaswell.Quickwitted,

superficiallyreferencestheabilitytorespondwithwit.46Again,the

anthropictraitsuggeststhatsmartmaterialsassomethingderived

fromcultivationbyhumansisfalse.Infact,natureusesmaterialsina

muchmoreintelligentfashion(eg.DNAwithinacellwhichencodes

biologicaldatathroughmaterialproperties).Thelattertermof

intelligenceisevenmoreproblematicasitinsinuatesthatmaterials

canlearn,understandordealwithnewortryingsituations.47

Throughthecasestudiespresented,byDorisKimSungandNick

Puckett,smartmaterialsareusednottoprocessenvironmentaldata,

likethatof abrain(referringtoartificialintelligencewhenreferencing

machinebasedminds),rathertheyarereactionaryelements.This

isillustratedbytheactof programmingmaterialstodocyclical

44 Ibid.

45 PenguinReference.(2004).ConciseEnglishDictonary.(R.Allen,Ed.)Oxford,UK:PenguinGroup,s.v.smart.

46 Ibid,s.v.wit.

47 Ibid,s.v.intellegnce.

Part 1 | 22

Page 31: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

tasks.Inthecaseof thethermostaticbi-metalskinusedinthe

BloomprojectbyDorisSung(seefig.10),thefaçadesystemis

programmedtoreactbasedonthedailyexposureof directsunlight.

Itisnotcapableof reactingbeyondwhatitsprogrammedsurface

featuresandmaterialpropertiesallow.Therefore,itsresponse

ismorelikethatof atransducer,thanabrain.Thecapabilityof

NickPuckett’sshapememorypolymersismoreintelligent,asthe

substratecanbereprogramedatwillwithinthesamethermalinput.

Thisenablesactuationyetthematerialisstilldirectlychangingin

responsetoitsenvironmentalstimuli.

Lookingbacktothefieldwhichisdirectlyimplicatedin

understandingintelligence,cognitiveneurosciencedefinesnon-

biologicalcognitionasartificialintelligence(AI).48Developedby

GeorgeMiller,EugeneGalanter,andKarlPribramin1959,thefirst

theoryforanAIwasdevelopedbasedontheconceptof feedback

loops,whichtheycalledTOTEunits(TOTEstandsforTest-Operate-

Test-Exit).49Thebasicconceptwasthat,withinthebrain,aninitial

testevaluatesagivencurrentstate(thestatecouldbederivedfrom

environmentalstimuli)againstagivengoal.If thestatesdonot

correlate,instructionsaregiventocarryoutanoperationtoreduce

thedifferencesuntilamatchoccursthroughaseriesof repeating

tests.50

48 Kolak,D.,Willkiam,H.,Mandik,P.,&Waskan,J.(2006).CognityiveScience:AnIntroductiontoMindandBrain.London:Routledge,24.

49 Ibid.

50 Ibid,25.

Part 1 | 23

Page 32: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Tolinkartificialintelligencewithsmartmaterialsthefollowing

questionmustbeasked.If allformsof traditionalmaterialscome

fromnaturebutloosetheirnaturalistictraitsuponcultivation,arethey

thenconsideredartificial?AstheOxfordEnglishdictionarydefines,

artificialis:“somethingproducedbyhumanbeingsratherthan

occurringnaturally,typicallyasacopyof somethingnatural”.51This

wouldimplythatif amaterialhasbeenprocessedinafashionthat

replicatessomethingfromnature,itwouldbeartificial.Therefore,

if smartmaterialsaimtoreplicatecognitiveprocessesfoundwithin

nature,theymustthenbeconsideredartificialyetasalreadyproven

throughthepreviouslymentionedcasestudiesbyDorisSungand

NickPuckett,smartmaterialsarenotintelligent,theyareresponsive.

If so,itthenfollowsthattheword‘smart’,insmartmaterials,seems

tobeanill-fittingadjective.

51 PenguinReference.(2004).ConciseEnglishDictonary.(R.Allen,Ed.)Oxford,UK:PenguinGroup,s.v.artificial.

Part 1 | 24

fig.14

right//

CreatedbyIBMin1989,Deep

Blueexmeplifedthepushto

createartificalintellegence

throughtheTOTEmethod.Its

taskwastodefeatworldclass

chesschampions,whichit

suceededatin1997against

GarryKasparov

Page 33: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Thefollowingchapterselaborateuponanapproachof material

designcalledCollectivelyIntelligentMaterialsystems(CIM

system).Thisapproachwillbeusedtofabricateatestmaterial

systemusingsmartmaterialsasasubstrate,opticallithographyto

producesensorsandArduinobasedmicrocontrollerstoconnect

thefunctionalityof boththesubstrateandthesensorstogether.A

finaldesignislaterproposedthroughwhichintelligentarchitectural

façadesystemscanbecomerealizedusingCIMsystem.

Smartmaterialsofferimbeddedcapabilitiesof acting

inresponsetoenvironmentalinput.Focusinguponthermostatic

bi-metals,theseactionsareactuated(movement),particularly

whenanenvironmentalchangeof radiation(light)orheatoccurs.

Whilenotsatisfyingthetraditionaldefinitionof intelligenceas

discussedearlier,thesematerialsdopossestheabilitytointerpret

theirenvironmentandactwithinit;similartoanactuatororsensor.

If smartmaterialsdonotprovidethefullsolutiontointelligent

architectureorevenanapproachtoasystemthatcouldbeapplied

architecturally;whatisthisparticularsmartsystemandwhat

“There are also apparatuses that inform dynamically . . . these ‘smar t tools’ replace human work and l ib-erate human beings from the obli-gation to work: from then on they are free to play” - Vilém Flusser

Collectively

Intelligent Material

Systems

Part 2 | 25

Part 2 03 |

Page 34: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

materialsmakeitup?

Therearethreemajorapproachestocharacterizeintelligent

architecturalsystems(environments)basedupontheirfunctionality:

environmentcharacterizations,cognitioncharacterizations,and

implementationcharacterizations.52Thefirststream,environmental

characterizations,encompassestheadvancementof human

occupationanduseof spatialenvironments.53Specifically

processesthatembedsensingandcomputingtomakeourhomes

andworkplacescontextuallyaware.54Cognitioncharacterizations

includeapproachesthatengagehumanemotionsthoughtsand

cognitionsoccurringintheenvironments.Finally,implementation

characterizations,focusonstrategieswhichenhancements

areinvoked,operatedandcontrolled.55Manyattemptsto

make‘intelligentspatialenvironments’focusspecificallyupon

oneapproach,potentiallyignoringthebenefitsof combining

approacheswhichexpresssimultaneityandcongruency,while

relinquishingtheideaof auniversalsystem.56

TheapproachwhichtheproposedCollectivelyIntelligent

Materialsystemtakesistooperatewithinallthreecharacterizations.

Futureintelligentenvironments,asAddingtionsuggestswill

52 Addington,Michelle,andDanielSchodek.SmartMaterialsandTechnologies,205.

53 Ibid,206.

54 Glynn,R.(2014,0101).AnimatingArchitecture.(B.Sheil,Ed.)HighDefinition:ZeroToleranceinDesignandProduction,102.

55 Addington,Michelle,andDanielSchodek.SmartMaterialsandTechnologies,209.

56 Ibid,216.

Part 2 | 26

Page 35: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

incorporatecombinedapproacheswhichnotonlyenhancethe

physicalenvironmentsurroundinghumanusers,butalsomaintains

approachesthataidinworkprocesses(seetable3,4and5).57 Due

tothecollectiveapproachof CIMSystems,functionalcategorization

isnotanidealapproachtodefiningitsspatialandmaterial

organizationimplications.Therefore,MichaelHensel’sconceptof

activeagencydomainsisabetterstrategy.Agencyasdescribedby

Hensel,definesthecapacityof aCIMtoactwithinfourarchitectural

domains(refertotable2.):58

1. localcommunities

2. bioticfactorsandinteractions

3. thelocalphysicalenvironments:abioticprocesses

4. thespatialandmaterialorganizationcomplex.

Thefirsttwodomains,spatialandmaterialorganization

complexarecombinedtomakeupthephysicalmanifestationof

theCIMsystemmodel.Assuch,allcomponentswhichmakeup

collectivelyintelligentmaterialsystemsincludinghardwareand

softwaredelineatethemselvesasactuators-intelligentbuilding

system,transducers-Arduinomicrocontrollers,andsensors–CIM

systemfaçademodules(seefig.13).Thephysicalcomponentsof

thesystemallowthespatialandmaterialcomplextointeractwiththe

thirddomain–thelocalenvironment.59

57 Ibid.

58 Hensel,M.(2013).Perfromance-OrientedArchitecture:RethikingArchitecturalDesignandtheBuiltEnviorment.(M.Swift,Ed.)Chichester,WS,UK:JohnWiley&SonsLtd,55.

59 Ibid.

Part 2 | 27

Page 36: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

ThelocalenvironmentswhichtheCIMsystemconcerns

itself with,wasexplainedearlierinthe‘approachingour

environments’chapter.Localenvironments,of theproposedCIM

system,facilitatethemajorenvironmentalinputsof thesolaractivity

whichmodulatetemperateandlightexposure.Thegoalof theCIM

systemistoactivelymediatetheeffectsof thelocalenvironment

uponthebuildingbeforetheycandirectlyinteractwiththespatialor

materialcomplexandsimultaneouslycommunicatethestateof the

localenvironmenttoanintelligentbuildingsystem.

Lastly,thedomainof localcommunitiesiseffectedbythe

localenvironmentcontrolledbytheCIMsystem.Henseldescribes

thisprocessaseithersupportingordiminishinglocalecosystems

andculturalpatterns.60Ultimatelythegoalof creatingsucha

complexarchitecturalmaterialsystemistobenefitthisdomain,

thereforeasRuairiGlynnaffirms,“thekeyroleinthescenariowillbe

to‘closetheloop’–designingtheformsof actuationthatfeedback

intothebuiltenvironment”.61

60 Ibid.

61 Glynn,R.(2014,0101).AnimatingArchitecture.(B.Sheil,Ed.)HighDefinition:ZeroToleranceinDesignandProduction,103.

Part 2 | 28

Page 37: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

“Holist ic approaches are good at dealing with well-defined domains such as room temperature and l ight levels but not so good at dealing with unpredictable domains l ike human behaviour” - Ruairi Glynn

right//

Conceptualimagepresenting

the‘self’maskedbythe

complexyof informationand

lodgic.

fig.15

Part 2 | 29

Page 38: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Part 2 | 30

top//

Currentapproachestousing

smartmaterialsinmakingsmark

enviromentsviaenhanced

mechatronic,constitutiveIand

IImodels.

middle//

Currentapprochestomaking

intellegntenviormentsusing

mico-controllers,actuators,

sensorsandtransducers.

bottom//

Furture(proposed)approach

usingacombinationof smart

materialsandcurrentintellegent

enviormentapproaches.Atifical

intellegenceusescontextto

defineresultingenviorment

table.3

table.4

table.5

Page 39: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Collectivelyintelligentmaterialsystemsrequirecomponents

whichcanconvertenergyfromonetypeof energytoanother.Like

smartmaterials,conversionisfacilitatedthroughaninputof stimuli

whichisnotnecessarilyenvironmental.Alternatively,inputcould

beproducedthroughdirectlyconnectingmaterialstogether(one

materialaugmentinganother).InCIMsystem,environmentalinputs

arefirstreceivedbyeithertransducercomponentsorsensorsand

thensent,receivedandconvertedbyactuators.

Part 2 | 31

Sensors, Actuators

and Transducers

right//

DiagramsummarizingCIM

systempanelcomponents

fig.16

Page 40: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Producersof micro-controllers,suchasScottFitzgerald

of Arduinodefinethefirstsetof components(i.e.transducers)

as,“devicesthatconvertvariationsinphysicalquantity,suchas

pressureorbrightness,intoanelectricalsignal,orviceversa”.62The

initialiterationsof theproposedCIMSfaçadeusestheArduinoitself

asakindof complextransducer;convertinganalogueinputfrom

theCIMsystemmodulestoaformwhichcanbeinterpretedbyan

intelligentbuildingsystem.Sensors,definedascomponentswhich

convertotherformsof energyintoelectricalenergyareusedbythe

Arduinotogainanunderstandingof theenvironmentalconditions.63

Thesensorsusedintheinitialiterationsfocusonconverting

environmentalconditionsof movementandheatintoananalogue

signal;intheinitialiteration,thisanaloguesignalisaconsistentDC

currentwhichisaugmentedbasedonthenumberof stimulated

CIMsystemmodules.Finally,theactuators,definedascomponents

whichconvertelectricalenergyintootherformsof energy,usethe

digitalinformationconvertedbytheArduinotoaugmentarchitectural

environmentsintelligently.64Theactuatorinintelligentarchitectural

environmentsmightbeasGlynndescribesas,“machinelearning

algorithmsrunningonremoteserverscollectingandmakingsense

of thesecomplexinterconnections”.65Ultimately,theinformation

providedbytheCIMSmodules(effectivelytheexteriorfaçade

system),encompassesallthreetypesof components.

62 Fitzgerald,S.,&Shiloh,M.(2015).ArduionoProjectsBook(3ed.).(T.Igoe,Ed.)Torino,Italy:ArduinoSrl,21.

63 Ibid.

64 Ibid.

65 Glynn,R.(2014,0101).AnimatingArchitecture.(B.Sheil,Ed.)HighDefinition:ZeroToleranceinDesignandProduction,103.

Part 2 | 32

Page 41: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

CIM system

design concept

TBSubstrate//

Preliminarydesignincorporates

ironnickelalloyontopactive

surface(facingtoexterior).

Resistivesilkscreenedcircuit//

Identifiespanelinmoduleas

havingauniqueresistance

ratingthroughalteringthelength

of printedwire.

ConductiveSub-Structure//

Contactsarelocatedbelow

eachbimetallicsubstrate.

Whenstripbendstotheclosed

positioncoppertheresistive

circuitscontactinparallelwith

theconductivesub-structure.

Thisinturn,increasesthe

overallresistanceinthesystem

whichisrelayedbacktothe

microcontroller.

Adhesivelayer//

BondstheCIMScomponents

together.ThisAdhesivelayeris

halftonedtoallowforexpansion

of substrate.

Fasteners//

SingleCIMsystemcomponents

areboltedtotheconductivesub

structuretomakeCIMsystem

modules.

Part 2 | 33

fig.17

fig.18

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

bottom//

CIMsystemcompositepanels

Iteration2.

Page 42: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

CIMsystemmodule//

CIMsystemcomponentsbend

basedonheatgenerated

throughsolarintensity.Modules

aremadeupof severalCIM

systemcomponentswhichare

thencoupledtoformlarger

arrays.

Part 2 | 34

fig.19

fig.20

Page 43: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

CIMsystemarray:

Arraysareconceivedtomake

upthesensorcomponent

of aCIMsystem.These

sensingarrayarefastenedto

facadesusingtheconductive

substructure.Asthesun

exposure(environmental

conditions)changesthearrayis

abletoactuate,senseandrelay

itsprogrammedinterpretationof

theenvironmentalconditions.

Part 2 | 35

fig.22

fig.21

Page 44: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Smartmaterialpropertiesof thermostaticbi-metals,are

usedinthemakingof thesubstratesastheactivecomponentwithin

theCIMsystemmodules.Theactivecomponentservesasthe

elementswhichdirectlyinteractwiththelocalenvironment.Using

thebendingactuationof thebimetallicmaterials,alogiciscreated

intwoways.Thefirstisthebendingindicatingthatthematerialis

receivingthermalsimulation.

IntheCIMsystemproposedthiswouldoccurduetothe

varianceinsolaractivitythroughouttheday.Secondlythebending

Part 2 | 36

Making substrates

right//

Firstsensoriterationwithcircuit

layeringmethod

fig.23

Page 45: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

isusedtoelectricallycontactthesubgridstructureasproposed

inthefirstdesigniteration(seefig.13,14and15).Additionally,the

thermostaticbi-metallayerisconceivedtopassivelyactasasun

shadingdeviceregardlessif thesystemisengaged.Thisstrategy

byitself isexemplaryof currentsmartenvironmentalapproaches

(seetable5.).

Printedcopperconductivecircuits,makeupthesensors/

communicationstrategyof thesubstrates.Thesubstraterequires

Part 2 | 37

right//

Conceptrenderingof CIM

systempanelonUrbandale

SolarResearchCenter

fig.24

Page 46: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

thesecircuitstosensethebendingactuationof thethermostatic

bi-metalliccomponent.Theproposedsensorsusethedetection

strategyof resistancecircuitstogaugetheproximityanddegreeof

actuationof eachCIMsystemmodule.Theinitialsensoriterations

weremodeledoff of beatfrequencyoscillationsensors(see.fig.

17),acommontechnologyusedinconsumermetaldetectors.This

methodhadtheadditionalbenefitof notonlycommunicatingif the

moduleisopenorclosed(binary)butalsocommunicatingarange

of actuation(analogue).66Whilethisstrategywasthefirsttobe

explored,itwasimpracticaltoproducethistypeof sensorwiththe

toolsathand.ThereforethefinalCIMsystemprototypewillnotuse

thisparticularmethod.

66 Kroschwitz,J.(1992).Encylopediaof ChemicalTechnology.NewYork,NY,USA:JohnWiely&Sons.

Part 2 | 38 Part 2 | 38

right//

Usingadigitalmultimetertotake

resistancemeasuremntof athe

firstbeatfrequecnyocillation

sensoriteration.

fig.25

Page 47: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

TheCIMsystemwhichthisthesisproposes,employsthe

processof opticallithographytocreatetwointegralcomponents

Part 2 | 39

right//

Waterbasedcoatingcontaining

tarnishreistantcopperparticles

forsuperiorcondiuctivity.

SeeAppendixBforproduct

specifications

. fig.26

.

Page 48: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

of theCIMsystem.Thefirstaretheconductivetraceswhichallow

electricalsignalstobetransferredfromthesensorstothemicro-

controller;thesecondarethesensorsthemselves.

AsdefinedbytheSocietyof Photo-opticalInstrumentation

Engineers,“opticallithographyisaphotographicprocessby

whichalightsensitivepolymercalledaphoto-resist,isexposed

anddevelopedtoform3drelief imagesonthesubstrate”.67This

developedsubstrate(seefig.13-15)canthenbeusedtoprintthe

intendeddesignorpattern.Boththesensorsandtheelectrical

tracesarerequiredtobeelectricallyconductiveonceprintedand

cured,thereforeconductiveinksmustbeusedastheprinting

medium.Sincethesmartmaterial,whichthepatternisbeingprinted

ontoisaconductivesubstrate(thermostatic-bimetal),patternsfor

insulationmasksmustalsobemanufacturedtoprintinsulation

layers.Theinsulationlayersareprintedusingawaterbasedink,

whichprovidesnotonlyasurfacethatpreventsshortcircuiting

betweenelectricalcomponentsbutalsoallowsthedesignof the

sensorsandtracestobelayered.Thismethodof opticallithography,

developedin1940byOscarSuB68,alsofacilitatesanefficient

printedcircuitdesignandisintegraltothesensorsfunctionality.The

inksarealsobothwaterbasedsoproperadhesionbetweenlayers

mayoccur.

Thefollowingmanufacturingprocessoutlinesageneral

overviewof thespecificmethodof opticallithographyusedin

67 Mack,C.A.(2006).Feildguidetoopticallithography(Vol.FG06).Bellingham,WA,USA:Spie,2.

68 Wilson,C.G.,Dammel,R.R.,&Reiser,A.(1997).Photoresistmaterials:ahistoricalperspec-tive.AdvancesinResistTechnologyandProcessingXIV.3049.SantaClara:SPIE,32.

Part 2 | 40

Optical lithography

Page 49: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

thisthesis.Althoughthefunctionallyof theconductivetraces

andsensorswithintheCIMsystemsaredifferent,theprocess

formanufacturingeitherareessentiallythesame.Therefore,the

followingdescribesthemanufacturingof thesensorcomponent,

asitistechnicallymorecomplicatedandisoneof thefunctional

componentswithinthefinalCIMsystemdesign.

Thefirststepinmanufacturingthesensingcomponents

withintheCIMsystemisbuildingthesilkscreenframetoactasthe

Part 2 | 41

right//

Screenprintframewithsensors

designsmadewithlight

sensitiveemulsion.

.

fig.27

.

Page 50: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

photo-resistsubstrate.Thisisdonebyfirstselectinganappropriate

mesh;coarseforprintingthickerinsulationlayers,fineforprinting

detailedelectricalcomponents.Themeshmustthenbestretched

overtheframeandalayerof sensitizedphotoresistapplied.The

photoresististhenlefttodryinlowlightconditions(approx.3

hours).Oncedrythepreppedframeismovedtoanexposuretable

whereafilmpositiveof theintendeddesign(i.e.electricaltraces

andsensors)isplacedovertheareatobedeveloped.Ahigh

intensityUVlamp(approx.800W)isusedtoexposetheframefor

twelveandahalf (12.5)minutes.Thiscurestheexposedphoto-

resist(notcoveredbythefilmpositive).Theframeisthensoaked

inawaterbathandthenahigh-pressurejetof waterisusedto

expungeanyremainingunexposedphotoresist.Thefinalframe,

alsoknownasasilkscreen,isthenlefttocompletelydryunderthe

exposurelamp,inastepcalledpostbaking.Postbakinghardens

theremainingphotoresistandreadiestheframeforitsfirstuse.

Thenextstepalignsthevariousscreenprintframeswithone

another.Ajigisbuiltusingproprietaryclampinghinges,whichnot

onlyalignallthelayerstobeprintedbutalsoallowsthesilkscreens

tobeswappedoutefficiently.Thejig,whichisbuiltinthisthesis,

utilizesasetof slotswhicharepre-milledoutof theplywoodframes

usingaCNCmill.Boltsarethreadedthroughtheseslotsand

tightenedoncethedesiredalignmentisachieved.

Thefinalstepbeforeprintingcanoccuristheloadingof

thescreen.Thisiskeytoproducingprintswhichhaveaneven

thicknessandcrisptransfer.Inkisplacedwithinthesilkscreen

framebutoutsideof theprintingarea.Alight,evenpasswitha

Part 2 | 42

Page 51: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

silkscreensqueegeeloadstheprintareawithink.Theprintisthen

alignedontothebimetallicsubstrate,andtheinkisforcedthrough

theuncoveredscenebyasinglefirmpass.Thisappliedsensor

designisthencuredontothesubstratethroughdryingandthen

subsequentbakingat170˚C.Thislaststepiscrucial,especiallyfor

theconductiveink,asthespacebetweencopperparticlesshrinks

asheatisapplied.Thusreducingtheoverallelectricalresistanceof

thecureddesignandvulcanizesthebindertoincreaselong-term

durability.

Part 2 | 43

fig.28

.

fig.29

.

top//

220threadper-inchmesh

(curcuitdetails)

bottom//

100threadper-inchmesh

(masking)

.

Page 52: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Adhesivelayerappearsasafiftypercenthalftone,patternfill,(top

of fig.xx).Thebaseshieldinglayer,appliedasabaseoverthe

bimetallicsubstratebeforethecoillayerisapplied.(bottomof fig.

xx).

Part 2 | 44

Sensor iteration 1.

fig.30

.

Masksnecessaryforthefirst

sensoriteration.

Refertofig.28fig.29andfig.30

Page 53: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Thecoillayersweredesignedsothatthepointsof contactwould

overlaptoallowconsecutivelayering.Bothlayerswinedinthe

samedirectiontoincreasethesensorsstrengthasmorelayersare

applied.

Part 2 | 45

fig.31

.

Page 54: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Thecoilshielinglayerisappliedbetweenalternatingcoillayers.

Appearingontherighttemplateisaminiaturearrayof coils,its

purposewastotestthelimitationsof scaleandprintingresolution.

1.UnexposedSilkscreenFrame13”x19”–220threadperinchpolyesterfabric

screenstretchedoverCNCmilledplywoodframecompletewithdriedsensitized

Part 2 | 46

fig.32

.

Page 55: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

emulsion.

2.VacuumUnit16”x24”bedsize-vacuumpumpfacilitatesevenclampingpressureusing1/8”acrylicsheet.

3.AcrylicSheet16”x24”–appliespressuretopositivefilm,flatteningthedesigntounexposedsilkscreenframe.

(requiredtomakepositivecontact)

4.FilmPositiveCircuitDesign–Printedusingtwo(2)8.5”x11”inkjettransparencyfilm.

5.SafetyUVglasses–UVglassesfilterhighintensitylightfromhalogenlampduringexposure.

6.HalogenExposureLamp800w–Exposurelampisplacedapproximately30”fromfilmsurface.Exposurelampis

controlledbyenlarginglamptimer.

7.EnlargingLampTimer–Usedtocontrolexposuretime(approximately12.5minutes).Timerisconnectedtohousehold

powerandthenoutputstoexposinglamp.

8.AlternativeFilmPositiveDesigns–includeselectricalshieldinglayers(insulation),wiringleaddesigns,adhesivelayer

andsmallscalesensorarraytest.

9.EmulsionApplicator–usedtoevenlyapplysensitizedemulsiontostretchedsilkscreenframe.

Micro-controllerssuchastheArduinoplatformarecommonlyassociatedtotheInternet

Part 2 | 47

fig.33

.

Exposure Process

Page 56: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

of Things(IoT)movementwhichwasfirstestablishedbytheGlobal

StandardsInitiativeinJulyof 2012.69DefinedbytheEncyclopedia

of ElectronicEngineeringasasingleintegratedcircuitwhichis

dedicatedtoperformonetaskandexecuteonespecificapplication,

theycontainmemory,programmableinput/outputperipheralsaswell

aprocessor.70

IntheproposedCIMsystem,theArduinomicro-controllerisused

asatransducertoreceiveandtransmitanaloguesignalsfromthe

CIMsystemmodules.Thedesignof theArduinoisconceivedintwo

parts;oneasthetransmittingmodule(fig.34,fig.35,fig.36,fig.37)

andtheotherasthereceivermodule(fig.38,fig.39,fig.40,fig.41,

fig.42).

69 ITUT.(2012,July04).NEWITUSTANDARDSDEFINETHEINTERNETOFTHINGSANDPROVIDETHEBLUEPRINTSFORITSDEVELOPMENT.Retrievedfromitunewslog:http://newslog.itu.int/archives/245

70 Webster,J.G.(1999).WileyEncyclopediaof electricalandelectronicengineering.NewYork:JohnWileyandSons.

Part 2 | 48

Micro-controllers

“Through the coupling of high definit ion sensing and actuation, space wil l become ever more animate, perceptively processing a l i fe of i ts own, populated with agency, in constant conversation with its sur roundings” - Ruairi Glynn

above//

ArduinoUnoR3MicroController

PlanView

fig.34

Page 57: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Thetransmittingmoduleistaskedwithconvertingthe

analoguesignalof theCIMsystemmodulesintoadigitalsignal

whichisthentransmittedoveraproprietaryradiofrequency

transmitter.ThistransmitterallowstheArduinotocommunicate

wirelessly,limitingtheneedtopenetratethebuildingenvelopeand

allowingforexpandability.

Part 2 | 49

fig.35

.

fig.36

.

top//

Finaltransmittingmoduleinside

waterproof housing.Basemicro-

controllerisanArduinoUnoR3

withMicrobread-boardand9v

powersupply.

bottom//

Transmittingmoduleinsidewhen

housingisclosed

Page 58: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Part 2 | 50

top//

Finalreceivingmoduleinside

waterproof housing.Basemicro-

controllerisanArduinoMega

2556R3withbread-board.

RFreceiverenableswireless

communicationbetween

devices.SDcardmodule

enablesdatatobewrittento

file.LCDScreenbuttonsand

switchesaremountedtothe

exteriorof thecaseforeaseof

use.

bottom//

Receivingmoduleinsidewhen

housingisclosed

fig.37

.

fig.38

.

Page 59: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Part 2 | 51

right//

Finalreceivingmoduleinside

waterproof housing.Basemicro-

controllerisanArduinoMega

2556R3withbread-board.

RFreceiverenableswireless

communicationbetween

devices.SDcardmodule

enablesdatatobewrittento

file.LCDScreenbuttonsand

switchesaremountedtothe

exteriorof thecaseforeaseof

use.

fig.39

.

Page 60: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Part 2 | 52

fig.40

.

1500mAhrechargeablebatterypack-Batterylifeof

approximately60hourswhencontinuouslyactive.

ArduinoUnoR3-Estimatedbatterylifeisbaseduponan

activestateandthereforedoesnotreflectdurationof sleep

modebetweenloggingintervals.If sleepmodeisenabled,

expectedbatterylifeincreasestoapproximately7500

stand-byhours.If loggingintervalsaresettoevery10mins

@a1minutetransmittingperiodthistranslatesintothe

moduletransmitting6timesin1hourorabouta1:9active

tostandbyratio.TheArduinoUnoR3hasanactivemA

drawof around25mAandastandbymAdrawof around

0.2mA.Conservatively,theestimationof batterylifewould

bearound47days.

MaletoFemaleDCadapter-Usedtorerouteandcompact

powercablemanagment.

CIMPanelInputconnector-Constructedfromamodified

femaleDCconnector.Weatherproofsconnectionbetween

panelandtransmitter.Environmentalseparationisessential

toensuredurabilityof electroniccomponents.

Radiofrequencytransmitter433mHz-usedtosendRF

signalstoCIMreceivermodule.Rangeislimitedtowithin

thehousehoweverthelackdirectwiringpreventbuilding

envelopepenetrations.Thisistheessentialcomponent

whichallowsthesystemtooperatewirelessly.

InsulatingFoam-Insulationisprovidedaroundall

electroniccomponentstoprovidecushioningaroundall

sensitivecomponents.Thisinsulationalsoprovidessome

thermalprotectionwheninoperation.

MaletoMaleDCadaptercable-connectsCIMSystem

paneltoTransmittingModule

USBTypeBtoTypeAconnector-Allowstransmittercode

tobeupdated/modified.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

right//

TransmittingModuleSchematic

Diagram

CIM System Transmitting Module

Page 61: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Thereceivermoduleisusedtorelaythedigitalsignalto

astoragedevicewhichlogstheinformationinaformwhichcan

bereadbyanintelligentbuildingsystem.Throughthisdesign,

informationisorganizedbaseduponmodulelocation,degreeof

smartmaterialsubstrateresponseandtime/date

einwhichthedataisassociated,unifyingtheembeddedlogicin

theCIMsystemmoduleswiththeintelligentbuildingsystem.

Part 2 | 53

fig.42

.

fig.41

.

top//

Finalreceivingmoduleinside

waterproof housing.Basemicro-

controllerisanArduinoMega

2556R3withbread-board.

RFreceiverenableswireless

communicationbetween

devices.SDcardmodule

enablesdatatobewrittento

file.LCDScreenbuttonsand

switchesaremountedtothe

exteriorof thecaseforeaseof

use.

bottom//

Receivingmoduleinsidewhen

housingisclosed

Page 62: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Part 2 | 54 Part 2 | 54

top//

Finalreceivingmoduleinside

waterproof housing.Base

microcontrollerisanArduino

Mega2556R3withbread-

board.RFreceiverenavbles

wirelesscommunication

betweendevices.SDcard

moduleenablesdatatobe

writtentofile.LCDSceen

buttonsandswitchesare

mountedtotheexteriorof the

caseforeaseof use.

bottom//

Receivingmoduleinsidewhen

housingisclosed

fig.43

.

fig.44

.

Page 63: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Part 2 | 55 Part 2 | 55

right//

Finalreceivingmoduleinside

waterproof housing.Base

microcontrollerisanArduino

Mega2556R3withbread-

board.RFreceiverenavbles

wirelesscommunication

betweendevices.SDcard

moduleenablesdatatobe

writtentofile.LCDSceen

buttonsandswitchesare

mountedtotheexteriorof the

caseforeaseof use.

fig.45

.

Page 64: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

fig.46

.

Radiofrequencyreceiver433mHz-usedtoreceiveRF

signalsfromCIMsystemtransmittingmodule.Thisisthe

essentialcomponentwhichallowsthesystemtooperate

wirelessly.

SDCardShield-devicewhichpermitsdatastoragevia

SDcards.Arduinostorespaneldataviathiscomponent.

SDCard-storesloggedpaneldatatobeusedby

intelligentsystemwithinSolarResearchCenter

InsulatingFoam

Toggleon/off switchandexternalbuttons-allowsuser

tooperateCIMSystemReceiverModulewhileunitis

closedwithincase.

ACtoDCpowerconverter-convertshouseholdAC

powertoDC.ArduinoMegarequireshouseholdpowerto

belimitedto7-12VDC@1Amperesmax.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

right//

ReceivingModuleSchematic

Diagram

9vDCmalejack-powersmodulewhileseparatinginput

plugfrommoduleitself incaseof servicing.

9vDCfemalejack-routesDCpowertoexternalon/off

toggleswitch

ArduinoMega2560-TheMega2560isamicrocontroller

boardbasedontheATmega2560.Ithas54digital

input/outputpins,16analoginputs,aUSBconnection,

apowerjack,andaresetbutton.Thisversionof the

ArduinoMegawasrequiredtoholdamoreextensive

codeasthememorycapacityof theArduinoUnoR3

wasnosufficient.

PushbuttonswitchesandLCDShield-Usedtocontrol

functionsof CIMSystemReceiverModule.LCDdisplays

2linesof 16characters.

USBTypeBtoTypeAconnector-Allowsreceivercode

tobeupdated/modified.

USBTypeBtoTypeAconnector

MaletoFemaleDCadapter-Usedtorerouteand

compactpowercablemanagmentfromtoggleon/off

switchtoArduinoMegaDCin.

CIM System Receiving Module

Part 2 | 56

Page 65: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Thisgraphicviewof theproposedArduinoUNObasedschematicdiagram,illustrates

thehardwarecomponentsof theradiofrequencytransmitterandreceiver.Theupper

ArduinomoduleismadeusinganArduinoUNOR3fittedtoabreadboard(used

toprototypecircuits)andaradiofrequencytransmitterwithsomeaccompanying

passivecomponents.Whilebothmodulesarepoweredinthisfirstiterationbya

9vbattery,thefinaliterationswillpushtomakeafullysolarpowereddesign.The

lowerreceivermoduleusesanArduinoMegawithmoreperipheralpins.Thisisto

accommodatetheliquidcrystaldisplay(LCD),aradiofrequencyreceiverandan

assortmentof passivecomponents.

doubleThermistor(intRawADC){doubleThermistor(intRawADC){doubleTemp;Temp=log(((10240000/RawADC)-10000));Temp=1/(0.001129148+(0.000234125*Temp)+(0.0000000876741*Temp*Temp*Temp));

Part 2 | 57

Wiring Schematic

Design

Receiver and

Transmitter

right//

ThedesignfortheTransmitter

andReceivermodulehas

beenadaptedfromseveral

opensourceprojectsbyAlex

StrandburgandScottFitzgerald.fig.47

.

Page 66: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

fig.48

.

Userinterfaceof computer-usedtomanipulatecode,

connectcomponentsandconnectuserwiththedevice.

ComputerDisplay

Variousdatastreams-inthecaseof theArduinoinformation

issentviaUSBconnections.SincebothAtmegachipsonthe

ArduinotakeserialinputstheUSBsignalisconvertedbythe

proprietaryArduinoprogrammer.

USBdataoutputtointerface

SDcardinput/output-datafromSDcardisloadedonto

computertothenbesenttointelligentbuildingmanagement

software.ProprietarysoftwareforintelligentHVACwithinSolar

ResearchCentermodifiesHVACfunctionality.

1

2

3

4

5

below//

CIMSystemNetworkDiagram

Part 2 | 58

CIM System Network

Page 67: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

fig.49

.

USBdatainputtointerface

Interface-CodinghappenswithintheCprogramming

language.Thislanguagecanbeinterpretedbythe

Arduino,andmorespecificallybytheAtmegachips,

intofunctionswhichthemodulesthenperform.

ArduinoCodingEnvironment-Codecontrolsall

functionalityandtellsArduinohowtotakeinandsend

informationtoothercomponents.Thisisessential

whatthesoftwarelookslike.

Compiler/WarningMessageList-Thisareaof the

interfacedisplaysanyerrormessagesorconflicts

withinthecodeonceverifiedbythecompiler.The

Arduinocompilerautomaticallychecksthatthe

programrunsandif notitwillsendbackanerror

messageinstructingthecoderhowtoaddressany

conflict.

ConnectionType-identifieswhichArduinoispluggedin

and/orassociatedwiththecode.Thisareaalsoshows

whichCOMchannelissendingthedata(thisisavirtual

serialoutputcreatedtosendcodeviaUSB)

LineNumber-indicateswhichlineyouarecurrently

editingwithinthecode

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

below//

CIMSystemInterfaceDiagram

Part 2 | 59

CIM System Interface

Page 68: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Temp=Temp-273.15; returnTemp;}

voidprintTemp(void){ doublefT; doublet=Thermistor(analogRead(15));fT=(t*1.8)+32.0;lcd.setCursor(0,1); if(unit==CELSIUS){lcd.print(t);lcd.write((char)223);lcd.print(“C“); } elseif (unit==FAHRENHEIT){lcd.print(fT);lcd.write((char)223);lcd.print(“F“); } elseif (unit==BOTHUNITS){lcd.print(fT);lcd.write((char)223);lcd.print(“F“);lcd.print(t);lcd.write((char)223);lcd.print(“C“); } elseif (unit==BOTHUNITS2){lcd.print(t);lcd.write((char)223);lcd.print(“C“);lcd.print(fT);lcd.write((char)223);lcd.print(“F“); }

Part 2 | 60

Code Sample

Calculating and

writing temperature

from sensor data

TheabovecodeistakenfromtheprogramwrittenintheCprogramming

languageforthereceivermodule.Thispartof thecodeisessentialinconvertingthe

electricalsignalfromthesensorsinthepaneltoatemperaturevaluewhichcanbe

printedtotheLCDorloggedtotheSDcardmodule.Thestepsareasfollows.

Step1.Calculatetemperaturefromanalogueinputpin53

Step2.ConverttemperatrurefromKelvintoCelcius

Step3.Printthecalculatedtemperatureif inCelciustoLCD

Step4.Orprintcalculatedtemperatureif inFahrenheittoLCD

Step5.Orprintcalculatedtemperatureif inbothunits(Fahrenheitfirst)

Step6.Orprintcalculatedtemperatureif inbothunits(Celciusfirst)

Step1.

Step2.Structure//

anargumentwhcihisdefinedby

astatment.

Variables//

aplaceholderforavalue.

Functions//

agroupof statementsthat

togetherperformatask

Step3.

Step4.

Step5.

Step6.

fig.50

.

Page 69: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

fig.51

.

USBConnectiontoComputer-DatafromSDcardis

displayedbycomputerforviewingpurposes.Note

thattheinformationwouldnotrequireviewingtobe

readbyanintelligentbuildingmanagementsystem

CSVFile-CommaSeparatedValuesFileisa

standardfiletypewhichcanbereadbyprograms

suchasMicrosoftExcelandtheCprogramming

language.

Values-Valuesareseparatedbydateandthenpanel

number

1

2

3

right//

OutputfileDiagram

Part 2 | 61

CIM System Interface

Page 70: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Conclusion | 62

“Today, the design of material al lows performance and negotiation to be located directly in the organization of a material substructure, rather than through the interface of discreet elements in component assemblies” - Paul Nicholas

Applying CIM system

methodology

Conclusion 04 |

Theproposalof aCIMsystemchallengestheconventional

wayinwhicharchitectsandsmartmaterialsrelatetoconventional

architecture.Theinitialquestionposedbythisthesisasks,howcan

smartmaterialsbeusedbyarchitectswithinarchitecturetocreate

thebespokearchitecturalenvironmentsdesiredbyanerawhich

lookstobecomemoreinterconnected,adaptiveandinformation

rich?Inaddressingthisquestionthethesisalsotoucheduponthe

natureof smartmaterialsandtheirimplicationsintermsof truly

intelligentarchitecturalfaçadesystems.Smartmaterials,asthis

thesisconcludes,arepositionedbetweentheworldof optimization

–characteristicof theprofessions;scienceandengineering–

andderivingexperienceandengagementwiththeenvironment

–wheretheprofessionof architecturespecializes.Assuch,a

multidisciplinaryapproachisnecessarytofacilitatebothnecessary

facetsof aCIMsystem,thetechnicalandtheexperiential.Further,

thetermsmartmaterialaspresentlyusedprovidesnorealsolutions

toaddressthisdisparity.Althoughthetermitself suggestsa

physicalmaterialwhichcouldbeideallymanipulatedbythe

architect,itsformisdirectlyrelatedtothefinalfunctionally-andan

Page 71: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Conclusion | 63

intentiontobeintelligent.Thislimitstheintricacyandcomplexity

necessarytoprovideamaterialwhichistrulyintelligent.Theonly

courseof actionasreiteratedbyAddingtonandHenselisforthe

architecttousesmartmaterialsasacomponentwithinagreater

system.ThissystemasthisthesisproposesistermedaCollectively

IntelligentMaterialsystem,whichincorporatesthebenefitof the

smartmaterial’sabilitytoengagewiththespecificlocalenvironment.

fig.52

.

right//

CIMsystemmock-upactuating

toheatgain.Imageontheleft

illustratesclosed,coldcondition

incontrasttoopen,warming

condition.Panelswereexcited

usingheatgunattypical

operatingtemperature.

Page 72: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Conclusion | 64

While,theaimistoprovideasinglesolutiontoaddress

thequestionposed,thecourseof researchrequiresexpertisein

multiplefields.Inparticular,thesolutionrequiresthedevelopment

of skillsandknowledgeof computersciencewhichaidein

developingCprogrammingcodeandbuildingafunctioningCIM

systemprototype.Furtherknowledgeinthefieldsof mechanical

engineeringandchemicalengineeringarerequiredtofullygrasp

thepropertiesof multiplematerialtypologiesincludingthermostatic

bimetals,materialcompositesandconventionalbuildingmaterials.

Allthreetypologiesarerequiredduetotheapplicationof theCIM

systemuponanexistingstructure,therebyrequiringaprecise

understandingof conventionalmaterialuses(walldetails,etc.).

Facadeswhichusethermostaticbimetalsasthesensingcomponent

alsorequireafullunderstandingof solarorientationandmaterial

heatgainproperties.Thisisrequiredbeforeasystemcanbe

designedasitsfunctionalitywilldependonwhichenvironmental

factorisbeingexploited(heatgain,radiation,weather).

fig.53

.

right//

CIMsystemproposedlocation

onsouthfacadeof Urbandale

CenterforHomeEnergy

Research

Page 73: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Throughcombiningapproachesthefutureapplicationof

CIMsystemsisexponentiallydiverse.Alternativeenvironmental

factorsinwhichmaterialscanrespondwillundoubtedlydevelop

thisdiversity.Aswell,thewayinwhichdataprocessingdevelops

infutureiterationsof aCIMsystemwillallowinterior(controlled)

environmentstorespondathigherlevelsof accuracyandfulfilla

moreaccuratedefinitionof intelligence.Onesuchmethodof data

processingknownasneuralnetworking,developedbythefieldof

cognitivescience,proposesdataprocessingwhichmimicsthat

of thehumanbrain.Asdefinedearliertheanthropicperspective

of smartlendsthatif CIMsystemsweretoincludeaprofession

whichweretospecializeinthehumanmind,onecouldtheoretically

produceanidealintelligentmaterial;onethatmightblurtheline

betweenbioticandinanimate.

Further,theprojectproposedaCIMsystemprimarily

appliedtothebuildingfacadeandenvelopecomponents.Such,

anapproachlimitsthescopeof applicationtothatof surfaces.As

discussedearlierinthethesis,AddintonbelievesthatArchitecture

Beyond the Surface(Post Script)

fig.54

.

Conclusion | 65

Page 74: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Conclusion | 66

isdescribedprimarilythroughsurface.While,thispointprompted

thethesistofocusonredefiningsurface,CIMsystemsinthis

thesisdidnotcovertheirapplicationinareasof architecturewhich

cannotbedescribedbysurface.Itcouldbefurtherarguedthat

architecturehasspatialcomponents,solids,voidsandotherartifacts

whichdidnotfallunderthescopeof thisthesis.Itwouldtherefore

beinterestingtofurtherresearchthewaysinwhichCollectively

IntelligentMaterialscouldbeappliedtotheseothercomponents

whichmakeuparchitecture.Questionssuchas,howdoesa

CollectivelyIntelligentMaterialsystemdifferwhenvoidsarethe

objectof application?

Suchquestionswoulddrivetowardsamore

thoroughinquiryonthenatureof whatconstitutesarchitectural

materials.Vitruviusmentionedtheuseof physicalmaterialsinhis

treatisewhichadoptsadefinitionof materialsastactileandreal.

However,whenmaterial,andcomponentsinmaterialsminiaturize

itisespeciallylimitingtousesuchasdefinitionasourperceptions

withinhumanbodiescanonlydiscernmaterialfromnomaterial

whenweexhaustwhatoursenseswillallow.Forexample,applying

materialswithinvoidswouldrequireimperceptibility-visual,tactile

andauditory.Thereforeamaterialwouldeitherhavetobemadeas

aconglomerateof micromaterialormaterialswouldberequiredto

actuateandtransduceenvironmentalstimulifromadistance(solid

space).

Thefurthereffectsof integratingprogrammedand

intelligentlyresponsivematerialwithinvoidsconstitutesarchitecture

whichisnotobviouslyintelligent.Spaceswithinarchitecturewould

Page 75: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Conclusion | 67

thenbecomeawareof occupantswithouttheoccupantsbeing

awareof thearchitecture(if voidasarchitecturalcomponentwas

tobecomeaCIM).Thisisnotovertlyabsurdasdatafromonline

usageistrackeddailyandusedbyInternetServiceProvides

(ISPs)tointelligently“watch”theuser.Thissamestrategycouldbe

employedbydesignersof intelligentenvironments.Ratherthan

simplywatchingtheuser,architecturecoulduseCIMtoaugment

itsphysicalaspectsandadjustparameterssuchasbuildingform,

spatialconstructs,environmentalsystemsandoccupantwork-flows.

Additionallytheembeddedsensors,transducersandactuators

withinmaterialscouldbeseamlesslyusedbyoccupantstodirect

architecturalfunctionality.

Incontrasttothetechnicaladvantagesof futureCIM

speculation,thevisualimplicationof actuationanddependencyis

alsoafruitfulexploration.UsingtheproposedCIMsystempanel

constructionasanexample,facadesmadewiththisproposed

systemwould“blush”(revealunderlyingredrainscreen).This

blushingactionwouldproposearchitecturewhichpassively

communicatesabuilding’sresponsetooccupantsandenvironment.

Futureiterationsof CollectivelyIntelligentMaterialsystems

implyafundamentalshiftfromeffectinglocalizedenvironments

(singularstructures)toinfluencingglobal(multi-structures).Partially,

thisisspeculatedbecauseateveryiterationproposedwithinthis

thesismodularitywasessentialinfacilitatingaworkingsystem.

Throughaggregatinginformationfromdifferentsensornodes,much

likeif datawasgainedfrommultiplestructures,amoreaccurate

andsubsequentlyintelligentresponsecouldbeformulated.Inthe

Page 76: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Conclusion | 68

caseof theCIMsystempanel,installingsuchasystemuponmulti-

storystructuresyieldsamoreusefulsystemthanoneonasmaller

structuresuchastheUrbandaleCenterforHomeEnergyResearch.

Themainbenefitderivesfromthegreaterdiversityof functions

andprogrammingof spaceswithinlargermulti-storystructures.

Asanexamplethesystemcouldprovideheatgainanalyticsto

bestschedulemeetingsforidealoccupantcomfortandlighting

withinspecificworkspacesatspecifictimes.Algorithmsandfuture

artificialintelligenceswouldusetheseanalyticstopredictoccupant

usagewithinbuildingsandultimatelyprovideuserswithoptimized

environmentstoconductthemselveswithinarchitecture.

Page 77: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Appendices | 69

Appendices 05 |

Appendix A

Page 78: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Appendices | 70

Appendix B / C

Arduino Code for

receiver

//Librariesused#include<VirtualWire.h>#include<LiquidCrystal.h>#include<math.h>#include<stdlib.h>#include<TimeLib.h>#include<SD.h>

#include<TimerThree.h>

//UsedtowritesymbolstotheLCDmoreeasily#defineNO_SYMBOL-1#defineDEGREE_SYMBOL0#defineRIGHT_ARROW_SYMBOL1#defineUP_ARROW_SYMBOL2#defineDOWN_ARROW_SYMBOL3

//CustomsymbolsfortheLCDbytedegree[8]={B110,B1001,B1001,B110,B0,B0,B0,};byterightArrow[8]={B0,B1000,B1100,B1110,B1100,B1000,B0};byteupArrow[8]={B0,B0,B100,B1110,B11111,B0,B0,};bytedownArrow[8]={B0,B0,B11111,B1110,B100,B0,B0,};

#defineHELPTEXTSIZE29

//TextforinstructionsmenuStringhelpText[HELPTEXTSIZE]={“UPandDOWN:to”,“scroll,RT:Exit”,“ONMAINSCREEN:”,“LFT:Disp.temp”,“RT:Logging*SD”,“UP:Logging*PC”,“DWN:Log*Both”,“WHENDISP.TEMP”,“HOLD+RELEASE:”,“SEL:ChangeUnit”,“LFT:ToggleLight”,“RST:ChangeMode”,“WHENLOGGING:”,“HOLD+RELEASE:”,“SEL:ChangeUnit”,“LFT:ToggleLight”,“UP:*LOGRATE”,“DWN:*LOGRATE”,“RT:LogON/OFF”,“RST:ChangeMode”,“Usetransmitter”,“w/sensoror”,“connectsensor”,“toreceiver”,“Usearrowkeys”,“toenterdata,”,“pressRIGHT”,“whendone”,};

//WhetherornotsymbolsareusedlinebylineforthehelpsectioninthelpTextSpecialChars[HELPTEXTSIZE]={NO_SYMBOL,NO_SYMBOL,NO_SYMBOL,NO_SYMBOL,RIGHT_ARROW_SYMBOL,RIGHT_ARROW_SYMBOL,RIGHT_ARROW_SYMBOL,NO_SYMBOL,

Page 79: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Appendices | 71

NO_SYMBOL,NO_SYMBOL,NO_SYMBOL,NO_SYMBOL,NO_SYMBOL,NO_SYMBOL,NO_SYMBOL,NO_SYMBOL,UP_ARROW_SYMBOL,DOWN_ARROW_SYMBOL,NO_SYMBOL,NO_SYMBOL,NO_SYMBOL,NO_SYMBOL,NO_SYMBOL,NO_SYMBOL,NO_SYMBOL,NO_SYMBOL,NO_SYMBOL,NO_SYMBOL,};inthelpPos=0;

//Whichmodeistheloggerin?#defineNOTSET0#defineDISPTEMP1#defineLOGSD2#defineLOGPC3#defineLOGBOTH4

intmode=NOTSET;booleansetupDone=false;

Stringtemp=“”;StringfTemp=“”;booleancheckingCelsius=true;

LiquidCrystallcd(8,9,4,5,6,7);intbackLight=10;

constintchipSelect=53;

#defineFAHRENHEIT0#defineCELSIUS1#defineBOTHUNITS2#defineBOTHUNITS23intunit=FAHRENHEIT;

unsignedlongreceiveFail=0;

unsignedlonganalogReadDelay=0;

//Loginterval#defineLOG1SEC0#defineLOG5SEC1#defineLOG10SEC2#defineLOG30SEC3#defineLOG1MIN4#defineLOG10MIN5#defineLOG30MIN6#defineLOG1HOUR7intlogInterval=-1;

//Logtimeinmillisecondform#defineTIME1SEC1000

#defineTIME5SEC5000#defineTIME10SEC10000#defineTIME30SEC30000#defineTIME1MIN60000#defineTIME10MIN600000#defineTIME30MIN1800000#defineTIME1HOUR3600000unsignedlonglogWait=TIME1SEC;unsignedlonglastLogged=0;

booleanlogOn=false;

booleansdInserted=false;

booleantimeIsSet=false;

intbackLightLevel=255;

//definesomevaluesusedbythepanelandbuttonsintlcd_key=0;intadc_key_in=0;#definebtnRIGHT0#definebtnUP1#definebtnDOWN2#definebtnLEFT3#definebtnSELECT4#definebtnNONE5

//readthebuttonsintread_LCD_buttons(){adc_key_in=analogRead(0);//readthevaluefromthesensor//mybuttonswhenreadarecenteredatthesevalies:0,144,329,504,741//weaddapprox50tothosevaluesandchecktoseeif wearecloseif (adc_key_in>1000)returnbtnNONE;//Wemakethisthe1stoptionforspeed

reasonssinceitwillbethemostlikelyresultif (adc_key_in<50)returnbtnRIGHT;if (adc_key_in<195)returnbtnUP;if (adc_key_in<380)returnbtnDOWN;if (adc_key_in<555)returnbtnLEFT;if (adc_key_in<790)returnbtnSELECT;returnbtnNONE;//whenallothersfail,returnthis...}

voidwaitUntilNoButtonPressed(){while(read_LCD_buttons()!=btnNONE);}

//Roundsdown(viaintermediaryintegerconversiontruncation)StringdoubleToString(doubleinput,intdecimalPlaces){if(decimalPlaces!=0){Stringstring=String((int)(input*pow(10,decimalPlaces)));if(abs(input)<1){if(input>0)string=“0”+string;elseif(input<0)string=string.substring(0,1)+”0”+string.substring(1); }returnstring.substring(0,string.length()-decimalPlaces)+”.”+string.sub-

string(string.length()-decimalPlaces); }else{returnString((int)input); }}

doubleThermistor(intRawADC){

Page 80: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Appendices | 72

doubleTemp;//Seehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermistorforexplanationof formulaTemp=log(((10240000/RawADC)-10000));Temp=1/(0.001129148+(0.000234125*Temp)+(0.0000000876741*Temp

*Temp*Temp));Temp=Temp-273.15;//ConvertKelvintoCelciusreturnTemp;}

voidprintTemp(void){doublefT;doublet=Thermistor(analogRead(15));//ReadsensorfT=(t*1.8)+32.0;//ConverttoUSAlcd.setCursor(0,1);if(unit==CELSIUS){lcd.print(t);lcd.write((char)223);lcd.print(“C“); }elseif (unit==FAHRENHEIT){lcd.print(fT);lcd.write((char)223);lcd.print(“F“); }elseif (unit==BOTHUNITS){lcd.print(fT);lcd.write((char)223);lcd.print(“F“);lcd.print(t);lcd.write((char)223);lcd.print(“C“); }elseif (unit==BOTHUNITS2){lcd.print(t);lcd.write((char)223);lcd.print(“C“);lcd.print(fT);lcd.write((char)223);lcd.print(“F“); }temp=doubleToString(t,2);fTemp=doubleToString(fT,2);}

//Checksif anybuttonsarepressedandactsaccordinglyvoidbackgroundButtonPressCheck(){intbutton=btnNONE;if (read_LCD_buttons()!=btnNONE)button=read_LCD_buttons();if (button!=btnNONE){if (button==btnSELECT&&millis()<(receiveFail+10000)&&mode!=NO-

TSET&&setupDone){//Changeunitsunit++;if(unit>BOTHUNITS2)unit=FAHRENHEIT;lcd.clear();waitUntilNoButtonPressed();if (sdInserted){FiledataFile=SD.open(“settings.txt”,FILE_WRITE);dataFile.seek(0);dataFile.print(unit);dataFile.close(); }lcd.setCursor(0,0);if (mode==DISPTEMP)lcd.print(“Temperatureis:”);else{lcd.print(“Log”);lcd.write(RIGHT_ARROW_SYMBOL);

if (mode==LOGPC)lcd.print(“PC:“);elseif (mode==LOGSD)lcd.print(“SD:“);elseif (mode==LOGBOTH)lcd.print(“Both:“);if (logOn){if (logInterval==LOG1SEC)lcd.print(“1sec”);elseif (logInterval==LOG5SEC)lcd.print(“5sec”);elseif (logInterval==LOG10SEC)lcd.print(“10sec”);elseif (logInterval==LOG30SEC)lcd.print(“30sec”);elseif (logInterval==LOG1MIN)lcd.print(“1min”);elseif (logInterval==LOG10MIN)lcd.print(“10min”);elseif (logInterval==LOG30MIN)lcd.print(“30min”);elseif (logInterval==LOG1HOUR)lcd.print(“1hr”); }else{if (mode==LOGBOTH)lcd.setCursor(9,0);lcd.print(“STOPPED”); } } }elseif (button==btnRIGHT&&mode!=NOTSET&&mode!=DISPTEMP&&mil-

lis()<(receiveFail+10000)&&setupDone){//Stop/Startlogginglcd.clear();waitUntilNoButtonPressed();lcd.print(“Log”);lcd.write(RIGHT_ARROW_SYMBOL);if (mode==LOGPC)lcd.print(“PC:“);elseif (mode==LOGSD)lcd.print(“SD:“);elseif (mode==LOGBOTH)lcd.print(“Both:“);if (logOn==false){if (logInterval==LOG1SEC)lcd.print(“1sec”);elseif (logInterval==LOG5SEC)lcd.print(“5sec”);elseif (logInterval==LOG10SEC)lcd.print(“10sec”);elseif (logInterval==LOG30SEC)lcd.print(“30sec”);elseif (logInterval==LOG1MIN)lcd.print(“1min”);elseif (logInterval==LOG10MIN)lcd.print(“10min”);elseif (logInterval==LOG30MIN)lcd.print(“30min”);elseif (logInterval==LOG1HOUR)lcd.print(“1hr”);logOn=true;lastLogged=millis(); }else{if (mode==LOGBOTH)lcd.setCursor(9,0);lcd.print(“STOPPED”);logOn=false; } }elseif (button!=btnSELECT&&button!=btnLEFT&&button!=btnRIGHT&&-

mode!=NOTSET&&mode!=DISPTEMP&&millis()<(receiveFail+10000)&&logOn){

//Increase/DecreaseLogRateintbutton=read_LCD_buttons();if (button==btnUP)if (logInterval!=LOG1HOUR)logInterval++;if (button==btnDOWN)if (logInterval!=LOG1SEC)logInterval--;if (logInterval==LOG1SEC)logWait=TIME1SEC;elseif (logInterval==LOG5SEC)logWait=TIME5SEC;elseif (logInterval==LOG10SEC)logWait=TIME10SEC;elseif (logInterval==LOG30SEC)logWait=TIME30SEC;elseif (logInterval==LOG1MIN)logWait=TIME1MIN;elseif (logInterval==LOG10MIN)logWait=TIME10MIN;elseif (logInterval==LOG30MIN)logWait=TIME30MIN;elseif (logInterval==LOG1HOUR)logWait=TIME1HOUR;if (sdInserted){FilesettingsFile=SD.open(“settings.txt”,FILE_WRITE);//if thefileisavailable,readit:if (settingsFile){settingsFile.seek(1);

Page 81: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Appendices | 73

settingsFile.print(logInterval);settingsFile.close(); } }lcd.clear();waitUntilNoButtonPressed();lcd.print(“Log”);lcd.write(RIGHT_ARROW_SYMBOL);if (mode==LOGPC)lcd.print(“PC:“);elseif (mode==LOGSD)lcd.print(“SD:“);elseif (mode==LOGBOTH)lcd.print(“Both:“);if (logInterval==LOG1SEC)lcd.print(“1sec”);elseif (logInterval==LOG5SEC)lcd.print(“5sec”);elseif (logInterval==LOG10SEC)lcd.print(“10sec”);elseif (logInterval==LOG30SEC)lcd.print(“30sec”);elseif (logInterval==LOG1MIN)lcd.print(“1min”);elseif (logInterval==LOG10MIN)lcd.print(“10min”);elseif (logInterval==LOG30MIN)lcd.print(“30min”);elseif (logInterval==LOG1HOUR)lcd.print(“1hr”);lastLogged=millis(); }elseif (button==btnLEFT&&mode!=NOTSET&&setupDone){//BacklightcontrolbackLightLevel-=51;if (backLightLevel<0)backLightLevel=255;analogWrite(backLight,backLightLevel);waitUntilNoButtonPressed(); } }}

voidsetup(){Serial.begin(9600);pinMode(13,OUTPUT);pinMode(backLight,OUTPUT);analogWrite(backLight,backLightLevel);//turnbacklighton.Replace‘HIGH’with

‘LOW’toturnitoff. lcd.begin(16,2);//rows,columns.use16,2fora16x2LCD,etc.lcd.clear();//startwithablankscreenlcd.setCursor(0,0);//setcursortocolumn0,row0 lcd.createChar((char)223,degree);lcd.createChar(RIGHT_ARROW_SYMBOL,rightArrow);lcd.createChar(UP_ARROW_SYMBOL,upArrow);lcd.createChar(DOWN_ARROW_SYMBOL,downArrow); lcd.setCursor(0,0);lcd.print(“WirelessTemp.”);lcd.setCursor(0,1);lcd.print(“Logger”);

//InitialisetheIOandISRvw_set_ptt_inverted(true);//RequiredforRXLinkModulevw_setup(1200);//Bitspersecvw_set_rx_pin(30);//Wewillbereceivingonpin3()ietheRXpinfromthe

moduleconnectstothispin.vw_set_tx_pin(31);vw_rx_start();//Startthereceiver Timer3.initialize(200000);Timer3.attachInterrupt(backgroundButtonPressCheck); delay(1000);}

voidloop()

{if(mode==NOTSET){lcd.clear();lcd.setCursor(0,0);lcd.print(“SEL:Instructions”);lcd.setCursor(0,1);lcd.print(“orchoosemode”);intbutton=btnNONE;while(button==btnNONE){button=read_LCD_buttons(); }if (button==btnSELECT){//Printshelptextaccordingtopositioninarrayof textwaitUntilNoButtonPressed();while(helpPos!=-1){lcd.clear();lcd.setCursor(0,0);if(helpTextSpecialChars[helpPos]==-1){lcd.print(helpText[helpPos]);}else{lcd.print(helpText[helpPos].substring(0,helpText[helpPos].indexOf(“*”)));lcd.write(helpTextSpecialChars[helpPos]);lcd.print(helpText[helpPos].substring(helpText[helpPos].indexOf(“*”)+1)); }lcd.setCursor(15,0);lcd.write(UP_ARROW_SYMBOL);lcd.setCursor(0,1);if(helpTextSpecialChars[helpPos+1]==-1){lcd.print(helpText[helpPos+1]);}else{lcd.print(helpText[helpPos+1].substring(0,helpText[helpPos+1].index-

Of(“*”)));lcd.write(helpTextSpecialChars[helpPos+1]);lcd.print(helpText[helpPos+1].substring(helpText[helpPos+1].index-

Of(“*”)+1)); }lcd.setCursor(15,1);lcd.write(DOWN_ARROW_SYMBOL); button=btnNONE;while(button!=btnUP&&button!=btnDOWN&&button!=btnRIGHT){button=read_LCD_buttons(); }if(button==btnUP&&helpPos!=0){helpPos-=2;lcd.setCursor(15,0);lcd.print(““); }elseif (button==btnDOWN&&helpPos<HELPTEXTSIZE-3){helpPos+=2;lcd.setCursor(15,1);lcd.print(““); }elseif (button==btnRIGHT)helpPos=-1;waitUntilNoButtonPressed(); }helpPos=0; }elseif (button==btnLEFT||button==btnUP||button==btnDOWN||button==bt-

nRIGHT){//ReadssettingsonSDcardwaitUntilNoButtonPressed();if (button==btnLEFT)mode=DISPTEMP;elseif (button==btnUP)mode=LOGPC;elseif (button==btnDOWN)mode=LOGBOTH;elseif (button==btnRIGHT)mode=LOGSD;

Page 82: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Appendices | 74

if (mode==DISPTEMP||mode==LOGPC){lcd.clear();lcd.setCursor(0,0);lcd.print(“Readingsettings”);if (mode==LOGPC)delay(500); } if (mode==LOGBOTH||mode==LOGSD){lcd.clear();lcd.setCursor(0,0);lcd.print(“InsertSDcard”);while(!SD.begin(chipSelect)){delay(5000); }sdInserted=true;}else{if (SD.begin(chipSelect))sdInserted=true; } if (mode!=DISPTEMP&&mode!=LOGPC){lcd.clear();lcd.setCursor(0,0);lcd.print(“Readingsettings”);delay(500); } if (sdInserted){FilesettingsFile=SD.open(“settings.txt”);//if thefileisavailable,readit:if (settingsFile){unit=settingsFile.read()-‘0’;logInterval=settingsFile.read()-’0’;if (mode!=DISPTEMP){lcd.setCursor(0,1);lcd.print(“Every“);if (logInterval==LOG1SEC)lcd.print(“1second“);elseif (logInterval==LOG5SEC)lcd.print(“5seconds“);elseif (logInterval==LOG10SEC)lcd.print(“10seconds“);elseif (logInterval==LOG30SEC)lcd.print(“30seconds“);elseif (logInterval==LOG1MIN)lcd.print(“1minute“);elseif (logInterval==LOG10MIN)lcd.print(“10minutes“);elseif (logInterval==LOG30MIN)lcd.print(“30minutes“);elseif (logInterval==LOG1HOUR)lcd.print(“1hour“);if (logInterval==LOG1SEC)logWait=TIME1SEC;elseif (logInterval==LOG5SEC)logWait=TIME5SEC;elseif (logInterval==LOG10SEC)logWait=TIME10SEC;elseif (logInterval==LOG30SEC)logWait=TIME30SEC;elseif (logInterval==LOG1MIN)logWait=TIME1MIN;elseif (logInterval==LOG10MIN)logWait=TIME10MIN;elseif (logInterval==LOG30MIN)logWait=TIME30MIN;elseif (logInterval==LOG1HOUR)logWait=TIME1HOUR;delay(2000); }settingsFile.close(); } else{settingsFile.close();FilenewSettingsFile=SD.open(“settings.txt”,FILE_WRITE);newSettingsFile.print(FAHRENHEIT);newSettingsFile.print(LOG1SEC);newSettingsFile.close();delay(500);lcd.setCursor(0,1);lcd.print(“Noneoncard”);delay(2000); }

}else{delay(500);lcd.clear();lcd.setCursor(0,0);lcd.print(“Failed,using”);lcd.setCursor(0,1);lcd.print(“defaultsettings”);delay(3000); } lcd.clear();lcd.setCursor(0,0);lcd.print(“TurnonTransm./”);lcd.setCursor(0,1);lcd.print(“Insertsensor”); uint8_tbuf[VW_MAX_MESSAGE_LEN];uint8_tbuflen=VW_MAX_MESSAGE_LEN;while(analogRead(15)<20&&!vw_get_message(buf,&buflen)){delay(1000); }lcd.clear();lcd.setCursor(0,0);if (mode==DISPTEMP){lcd.print(“Temperatureis:”);setupDone=true;}else{if (sdInserted){FilelogFile=SD.open(“log.csv”);if (!logFile){FilenewLogFile=SD.open(“log.csv”,FILE_WRITE);newLogFile.println(“Date/Time,Fahrenheit,Celsius”);newLogFile.close(); } }lcd.print(“Setloginterval”);lcd.setCursor(0,1); inttempChoice=LOG1SEC;lcd.print(“1second“);lcd.write(UP_ARROW_SYMBOL);lcd.print(“/”);lcd.write(DOWN_ARROW_SYMBOL); while(logInterval==-1){intbutton=read_LCD_buttons();if (button!=btnNONE){if (button==btnUP)if (tempChoice!=LOG1HOUR)tempChoice++;if (button==btnDOWN)if (tempChoice!=LOG1SEC)tempChoice--;if (button==btnSELECT){logInterval=tempChoice;if (logInterval==LOG1SEC)logWait=TIME1SEC;elseif (logInterval==LOG5SEC)logWait=TIME5SEC;elseif (logInterval==LOG10SEC)logWait=TIME10SEC;elseif (logInterval==LOG30SEC)logWait=TIME30SEC;elseif (logInterval==LOG1MIN)logWait=TIME1MIN;elseif (logInterval==LOG10MIN)logWait=TIME10MIN;elseif (logInterval==LOG30MIN)logWait=TIME30MIN;elseif (logInterval==LOG1HOUR)logWait=TIME1HOUR;if (sdInserted){FilesettingsFile=SD.open(“settings.txt”,FILE_WRITE);//if thefileisavailable,readit:if (settingsFile){settingsFile.seek(1);settingsFile.print(logInterval);settingsFile.close(); }

Page 83: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Appendices | 75

} }lcd.clear();lcd.setCursor(0,0);lcd.print(“Setloginterval”);lcd.setCursor(0,1);if (tempChoice==LOG1SEC)lcd.print(“1second“);elseif (tempChoice==LOG5SEC)lcd.print(“5seconds“);elseif (tempChoice==LOG10SEC)lcd.print(“10seconds“);elseif (tempChoice==LOG30SEC)lcd.print(“30seconds“);elseif (tempChoice==LOG1MIN)lcd.print(“1minute“);elseif (tempChoice==LOG10MIN)lcd.print(“10minutes“);elseif (tempChoice==LOG30MIN)lcd.print(“30minutes“);elseif (tempChoice==LOG1HOUR)lcd.print(“1hour“);lcd.write(UP_ARROW_SYMBOL);lcd.print(“/”);lcd.write(DOWN_ARROW_SYMBOL); waitUntilNoButtonPressed(); } }if (mode==LOGBOTH||mode==LOGSD){//Asksusertosetdate/timelcd.clear();lcd.setCursor(0,0);lcd.print(“Set”);lcd.setCursor(0,1);lcd.print(“Date:”);lcd.setCursor(7,0);lcd.print(“1/1/00”);lcd.setCursor(7,1);lcd.write(UP_ARROW_SYMBOL); intsetPos=0;intdata[7]={1,1,2000,12,00,0};while(!timeIsSet){intbutton=read_LCD_buttons();if (button!=btnNONE){if (button==btnUP){if (setPos==0&&data[0]!=12)data[0]++;elseif (setPos==1&&data[1]!=31)data[1]++;elseif (setPos==2)data[2]++;elseif (setPos==3){if (data[3]<11){data[3]++;}elseif (data[3]==12)data[3]=1;elseif (data[3]==11){data[5]++;if (data[5]==2)data[5]=0;data[3]=12; } }elseif (setPos==4){if (data[4]<59)data[4]++;elsedata[4]=0; } }elseif (button==btnDOWN){ if (setPos==0&&data[0]!=1)data[0]--;elseif (setPos==1&&data[1]!=1)data[1]--;elseif (setPos==2&&data[2]!=2000)data[2]--;elseif (setPos==3){if (data[3]>1&&data[3]!=12){data[3]--;}elseif (data[3]==1)data[3]=12;elseif (data[3]==12){

data[5]--;if (data[5]==-1)data[5]=1;data[3]=11; } }elseif (setPos==4){if (data[4]>0)data[4]--;elsedata[4]=59; } }elseif (button==btnRIGHT&&setPos!=4)setPos++;elseif (button==btnRIGHT&&setPos==4){timeIsSet=true;if (data[5]==1)data[3]+=12;setTime(data[3],data[4],0,data[1],data[0],data[2]); }elseif (button==btnLEFT&&setPos!=0)setPos--; }delay(300); if (setPos<3){lcd.clear();lcd.setCursor(0,0);lcd.print(“Set”);lcd.setCursor(0,1);lcd.print(“Date:”);lcd.setCursor(7,0);lcd.print(data[0]);lcd.print(“/”);lcd.print(data[1]);lcd.print(“/”);lcd.print(String(data[2]).substring(2,4));}else{lcd.clear();lcd.setCursor(0,0);lcd.print(“Set”);lcd.setCursor(0,1);lcd.print(“Time:”);lcd.setCursor(7,0);lcd.print(data[3]);lcd.print(“:”);if (data[4]<10)lcd.print(“0”);lcd.print(data[4]);if (data[5]==0)lcd.print(“AM”);elselcd.print(“PM”); } if (setPos==0){lcd.setCursor(7,1);lcd.write(UP_ARROW_SYMBOL);if (data[0]>9)lcd.write(UP_ARROW_SYMBOL);}elseif (setPos==1){lcd.setCursor(9,1);if (data[0]>9)lcd.print(““);lcd.write(UP_ARROW_SYMBOL);if (data[1]>9)lcd.write(UP_ARROW_SYMBOL);}elseif (setPos==2){lcd.setCursor(11,1);if (data[0]>9)lcd.print(““);if (data[1]>9)lcd.print(““);lcd.write(UP_ARROW_SYMBOL);lcd.write(UP_ARROW_SYMBOL);}elseif (setPos==3){lcd.setCursor(7,1);lcd.write(UP_ARROW_SYMBOL);if (data[3]>9)lcd.write(UP_ARROW_SYMBOL);lcd.print(“--”);

Page 84: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Appendices | 76

}elseif (setPos==4){lcd.setCursor(9,1);if (data[3]>9)lcd.print(““);lcd.write(UP_ARROW_SYMBOL);lcd.write(UP_ARROW_SYMBOL); } } }lcd.clear();lcd.setCursor(0,0);lcd.print(“Log”);lcd.write(RIGHT_ARROW_SYMBOL);if (mode==LOGPC)lcd.print(“PC:“);elseif (mode==LOGBOTH)lcd.print(“Both:”);elseif (mode==LOGSD)lcd.print(“SD:“);lcd.print(“STOPPED”);setupDone=true; } }}else{uint8_tbuf[VW_MAX_MESSAGE_LEN];uint8_tbuflen=VW_MAX_MESSAGE_LEN;if (vw_get_message(buf,&buflen))//checktoseeif anythinghasbeen

received{if (backLightLevel>0)digitalWrite(13,HIGH);if (millis()>(receiveFail+10000)){lcd.clear();lcd.setCursor(0,0);if (mode==DISPTEMP)lcd.print(“Temperatureis:”);else{lcd.print(“Log”);lcd.write(RIGHT_ARROW_SYMBOL);if (mode==LOGPC)lcd.print(“PC:“);elseif (mode==LOGBOTH)lcd.print(“Both:“);elseif (mode==LOGSD)lcd.print(“SD:“);if (logOn){if (logInterval==LOG1SEC)lcd.print(“1sec”);elseif (logInterval==LOG5SEC)lcd.print(“5sec”);elseif (logInterval==LOG10SEC)lcd.print(“10sec”);elseif (logInterval==LOG30SEC)lcd.print(“30sec”);elseif (logInterval==LOG1MIN)lcd.print(“1min”);elseif (logInterval==LOG10MIN)lcd.print(“10min”);elseif (logInterval==LOG30MIN)lcd.print(“30min”);elseif (logInterval==LOG1HOUR)lcd.print(“1hr”); }else{if (mode==LOGBOTH)lcd.setCursor(9,0);lcd.print(“STOPPED”); } } }receiveFail=0;inti;//Messagewithagoodchecksumreceived.temp=””;fTemp=””;for(i=0;i<buflen;i++){if (checkingCelsius){if (buf[i]!=’C’)temp+=buf[i];//thereceiveddataisstoredinbufferelsecheckingCelsius=false; }else{if (buf[i]!=’F’)fTemp+=buf[i];elsecheckingCelsius=true; }

} lcd.setCursor(0,1);if(unit==CELSIUS){lcd.print(temp);lcd.write((char)223);lcd.print(“C“); }elseif (unit==FAHRENHEIT){lcd.print(fTemp);lcd.write((char)223);lcd.print(“F“); }elseif (unit==BOTHUNITS){lcd.print(fTemp);lcd.write((char)223);lcd.print(“F“);lcd.print(temp);lcd.write((char)223);lcd.print(“C“); }elseif (unit==BOTHUNITS2){lcd.print(temp);lcd.write((char)223);lcd.print(“C“);lcd.print(fTemp);lcd.write((char)223);lcd.print(“F“); }digitalWrite(13,LOW); }elseif (analogRead(15)>20){delay(100);if (analogRead(15)>20&&millis()>(analogReadDelay+500)){if (backLightLevel>0)digitalWrite(13,HIGH);if (millis()>(receiveFail+10000)){lcd.clear();lcd.setCursor(0,0);if (mode==DISPTEMP)lcd.print(“Temperatureis:”);else{lcd.print(“Log”);lcd.write(RIGHT_ARROW_SYMBOL);if (mode==LOGPC)lcd.print(“PC:“);elseif (mode==LOGBOTH)lcd.print(“Both:“);elseif (mode==LOGSD)lcd.print(“SD:“);if (logOn){if (logInterval==LOG1SEC)lcd.print(“1sec”);elseif (logInterval==LOG5SEC)lcd.print(“5sec”);elseif (logInterval==LOG10SEC)lcd.print(“10sec”);elseif (logInterval==LOG30SEC)lcd.print(“30sec”);elseif (logInterval==LOG1MIN)lcd.print(“1min”);elseif (logInterval==LOG10MIN)lcd.print(“10min”);elseif (logInterval==LOG30MIN)lcd.print(“30min”);elseif (logInterval==LOG1HOUR)lcd.print(“1hr”); }else{if (mode==LOGBOTH)lcd.setCursor(9,0);lcd.print(“STOPPED”); } } }receiveFail=millis();;analogReadDelay=millis();printTemp();digitalWrite(13,LOW); } }

Page 85: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Appendices | 77

else{if (receiveFail==0)receiveFail=millis();if (millis()>(receiveFail+10000)){lcd.clear();lcd.setCursor(0,0);lcd.print(“TurnonTransm./”);lcd.setCursor(0,1);lcd.print(“Insertsensor”);delay(2000); } } unsignedlongcurrent=millis();if (current>(receiveFail+10000)&&((current-lastLogged)>=logWait)){lastLogged=current;}elseif ((current-lastLogged)>=logWait){if (logOn)delay(100);if (logOn){if (mode==LOGPC||mode==LOGBOTH){//LogstoserialSerial.print(fTemp);Serial.print(“F_”);Serial.print(temp);Serial.println(“C|”); }if (mode==LOGSD||mode==LOGBOTH){//LogstoSDcardFilelogFile=SD.open(“log.csv”,FILE_WRITE);if (logFile){logFile.print(month());logFile.print(“/”);logFile.print(day());logFile.print(“/”);logFile.print(String(year()).substring(2,4));logFile.print(““);logFile.print(hourFormat12());logFile.print(“:”);if (minute()<10)logFile.print(“0”);logFile.print(minute());logFile.print(“:”);if (second()<10)logFile.print(“0”);logFile.print(second());if (isAM()&&hourFormat12()!=12)logFile.print(“AM”);elseif (isAM()&&hourFormat12()==12)logFile.print(“PM”);elseif (isPM()&&hourFormat12()==12)logFile.print(“AM”);elselogFile.print(“PM”);logFile.print(“,”);logFile.print(fTemp);logFile.print(“,”);logFile.println(temp); }logFile.close(); }lastLogged=current;delay(100); } } } }

Page 86: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Appendices | 78

Arduino Code for

transmitter

#include<VirtualWire.h>//youmustdownloadandinstalltheVirtualWire.htoyourhardware/librariesfolder#include<math.h>

#undef int#undef abs#undef double#undef float#undef round

StringtextToSend="";

voidsetup(){pinMode(13,OUTPUT);//InitialisetheIOandISRvw_set_ptt_inverted(true);//RequiredforRFLinkmodulevw_setup(1200);//Bitspersecvw_set_tx_pin(3);//pin3isusedasthetransmitdataoutintotheTXLinkmodule,changethistosuit

yourneeds.pinMode(10,INPUT);pinMode(9,OUTPUT);pinMode(11,OUTPUT);digitalWrite(9,LOW);digitalWrite(11,HIGH);}

doubleThermistor(intRawADC){doubleTemp;//Seehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermistorforexplanationof formulaTemp=log(((10240000/RawADC)-10000));Temp=1/(0.001129148+(0.000234125*Temp)+(0.0000000876741*Temp*Temp*Temp));Temp=Temp-273.15;//ConvertKelvintoCelciusreturnTemp;}

voidprintTemp(){doublefTemp;doubletemp=Thermistor(analogRead(0));//ReadsensortextToSend=doubleToString(temp,2);textToSend+="C";fTemp=(temp*1.8)+32.0;//ConverttoUSAtextToSend+=doubleToString(fTemp,2);textToSend+="F";}

//Roundsdown(viaintermediaryintegerconversiontruncation)StringdoubleToString(doubleinput,intdecimalPlaces){if(decimalPlaces!=0){Stringstring=String((int)(input*pow(10,decimalPlaces)));if(abs(input)<1){if(input>0)string="0"+string;elseif(input<0)string=string.substring(0,1)+"0"+string.substring(1); }returnstring.substring(0,string.length()-decimalPlaces)+"."+string.substring(string.length()-decimalPlaces); }else{returnString((int)input); }}

voidloop(){while(analogRead(0)!=0){if (digitalRead(10)==HIGH)digitalWrite(13,HIGH);printTemp();chartemp[50];textToSend.toCharArray(temp,50);constchar*msg=temp;//thisisyourmessagetosendvw_send((uint8_t*)msg,strlen(msg));vw_wait_tx();//WaitformessagetofinishdigitalWrite(13,LOW);delay(500); }}

Page 87: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Appendices | 79

Appendix D

2017/04/2012:49:30PM,Panel8,Panel9,Pane10,Panel11,Panel122017/04/2012:59:30PM,Panel8,Panel9,Pane10,Panel11,Panel12,Panel132017/04/2001:09:30PM,Panle5,Panel8,Panel9,Pane10,Panel11,Panel12,Panel132017/04/2001:19:30PM,Panel8,Panel9,Pane10,Panel11,Panel122017/04/2001:29:30PM,Panel5,Panel8,Panel9,Pane10,Panel11,Panel122017/04/2001:39:30PM,Panel8,Panel9,Pane10,Panel11,Panel12,Panel132017/04/2001:49:30PM,Panel4,Panel8,Panel9,Pane10,Panel11,Panel12,Panel132017/04/2001:59:30PM,Panel8,Panel9,Pane10,Panel11,Panel12,Panel132017/04/2002:09:30PM,Panel8,Panel9,Pane10,Panel11,Panel122017/04/2002:19:30PM,Panel8,Panel9,Pane10,Panel11,Panel122017/04/2002:29:30PM,Panel8,Panel9,Pane10,Panel11,Panel122017/04/2002:39:30PM,Panel8,Panel9,Pane10,Panel11,Panel122017/04/2002:49:30PM,Panel8,Panel9,Pane10,Panel11,Panel12,Panel132017/04/2002:59:30PM,Panel8,Panel9,Pane10,Panel11,Panel12,Panel132017/04/2003:09:30PM,Panel8,Panel9,Pane10,Panel11,Panel12,Panel132017/04/2003:19:30PM,Panel8,Panel9,Pane10,Panel11,Panel12,PAnel13close2017/04/2006:49:30PM,Panel8,Panel9,Pane10,Panel11,Panel122017/04/2006:59:30PM,Panel8,Panel9,Pane10,Panel11,Panel122017/04/2007:09:30PM,Panel8,Panel9,Pane10,Panel11,Panel122017/04/2007:19:30PM,Panel8,Panel9,Pane10,Panel11,Panel122017/04/2007:29:30PM,Panel8,Panel9,Pane10,Panel11,2017/04/2007:39:30PM,Panel8,Panel9,Pane10,2017/04/2007:49:30PM,Panel8,Panel9,2017/04/2007:59:30PM,2017/04/2008:09:30PM,2017/04/2008:19:30PM,2017/04/2008:29:30PM,2017/04/2008:39:30PM,2017/04/2008:49:30PM,2017/04/2008:59:30PM,2017/04/2009:09:30PM,2017/04/2009:19:30PM,2017/04/2009:29:30PM,close2017/04/2106:49:30AM,Panel1,Panel2,Panel32017/04/2106:59:30AM,Panel1,Panel2,Panel32017/04/2107:09:30AM,Panel1,Panel2,Panel3close2017/04/2109:09:30AM,Panel1,Panel2,Panel3,Panel4,Panel5,Panel6,Panel7,Panel8,Panle9,Panel10,

Panel11,Panel12,Panel132017/04/2109:19:30AM,Panel1,Panel2,Panel3,Panel4,Panel5,Panel6,Panel7,Panel8,Panle9,Panel10,

Panel11,Panel12,Panel132017/04/2109:29:30AM,Panel1,Panel2,Panel3,Panel4,Panel5,Panel6,Panel7,Panel8,Panle9,Panel10,

Panel11,Panel12,Panel132017/04/2109:39:30AM,Panel1,Panel2,Panel3,Panel4,Panel5,Panel6,Panel7,Panel8,Panle9,Panel10,

Panel11,Panel12,Panel13close2017/04/2110:09:30AM,Panel1,Panel2,Panel3,Panel4,Panel5,Panel6,Panel7,Panel8,Panle9,Panel10,

Panel11,Panel12,Panel132017/04/2110:19:30AM,Panel1,Panel2,Panel3,Panel4,Panel5,Panel6,Panel7,Panel8,Panle9,Panel10,

Panel11,Panel12,Panel132017/04/2110:29:30AM,Panel1,Panel2,Panel3,Panel4,Panel5,Panel6,Panel7,Panel8,Panle9,Panel10,

Panel11,Panel12,Panel132017/04/2110:39:30AM,Panel1,Panel2,Panel3,Panel4,Panel5,Panel6,Panel7,Panel8,Panle9,Panel10,

Panel11,Panel12,Panel132017/04/2110:49:30AM,Panel1,Panel2,Panel3,Panel4,Panel5,Panel6,Panel7,Panel8,Panle9,Panel10,

Panel11,Panel12,Panel13close2017/04/2112:49:30PM,Panel8,Panel9,Pane10,Panel11,Panel122017/04/2112:59:30PM,Panel8,Panel9,Pane10,Panel11,Panel122017/04/2101:09:30PM,Panel8,Panel9,Pane10,Panel11,Panel12

Panel Test Output

CSV File

Page 88: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Appendix E

Appendices | 80

Final Print Frames

fig.55

.

Page 89: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Appendices | 81

fig.56

.

Page 90: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Appendices | 82

fig.57

.

Page 91: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Appendices | 83

fig.58

.

Page 92: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Work Cited | 84

Work Cited 06 |

Addington,M.(2003,May).Energy,Body,Building.HarvardDesign

Magazine,1(18),1-6.

Addington,M.,&Schodek,D.(2005).SmartMaterialsand

Technologies:forthearchitectureanddesignprofessions.

Oxford,UnitedKingdom:ArchitecturalPress.

Agkathidis,A.(2015).GenerativeDesign:FormFinidngTechniques

inArchitecture.London,UK:LaurenceKingPublishing.

Arendt,H.(1998).TheHumanCondition(SecondEditioned.).

Chicago,IL,USA:Universityof Chicago.

Bachelard,G.(1994).ThePoeticsof Space.(M.Jolas,Trans.)

Boston,MA,USA:BeaconPress.

Banham,R.(1984).TheArchitectureof theWellTempered

Enviorment.London,UK:ArchitecturalPress.

Boch,P.(2007).Historyof Ceramics.InP.Boch,&J.-C.Niepce,

CeramicMaterials:procesespropertiesandapplications(p.

32).London:ISTELtd.

Cache,B.(2011).Projectiles(ArchitectureWords6ed.,Vol.VI).(B.

Steele,Ed.)London,UK:AAPublications.

Colley,M.,Clarke,G.,Hagras,H.,Callaghan,V.,&Pounds-Cornish,

A.(2001).IntellegentInhabitedEnviorments:Cooperative

Robotics&Buildings.32ndInternationalSymposiumon

Robotics(pp.1-6).Seoul,Korea:EssexUniversity.

Davidson,P.,&Boman,M.(2000).EnergySavingandValueAdded

Services:ControllingIntellegentBuildingsUsingaMulti-

AgentSystemApproach.Universityof Karlskrona/Ronneby

andStockholmUniversity,Departmentof ComputerScience.

Stockholm:Universityof Stockholm.

Print

Page 93: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Work Cited | 85

Davies,M.(1981).AWallforAllSeasons.RIBAJournal(2),88.

Dunn,N.(2012).DigitalFabricationinArchitecture.London,UK:

LaurenceKingPublishingLdt.

Fitzgerald,S.,&Shiloh,M.(2015).ArduionoProjectsBook(3ed.).

(T.Igoe,Ed.)Torino,Italy:ArduinoSrl.

Flusser,V.(2012).TowardsaPhilosophyof Photography.(A.

Mathews,Trans.)London,UK:ReaktionBooksLtd.

Friend,C.(1996).Smartmaterials:theemergingtechnology.

MaterialsWorld,4,pp.16-18.

George,J.D.(2001).TheDecadeof theBrain-Adecadeof

Scholarship.JournalfotheHiustoryof theNurosciences,

10(1),113-121.

Glynn,R.(2014,0101).AnimatingArchitecture.(B.Sheil,Ed.)High

Definition:ZeroToleranceinDesignandProduction,pp.100-

105.

Hagan,S.(2008).Digitalia:architectureandthedigital,the

enviormentandtheavant-garde.NewYork,NY,USA:

Routledege.

Heidegger,M.(2008).MartinHeidegger-BasicWritings:fromBeing

andTimetotheTaskof Thinking(ModernThoughtEdition

ed.).(D.F.Krell,Ed.)NewYork,NY,USA:HarperPerennial.

Hensel,M.(2013).Perfromance-OrientedArchitecture:Rethiking

ArchitecturalDesignandtheBuiltEnviorment.(M.Swift,Ed.)

Chichester,WS,UK:JohnWiley&SonsLtd.

Huang,G.(2003,July1).CastingtheWirelessSensorNet.MIT

TechnologyReview,32-35.

ITUT.(2012,July04).NEWITUSTANDARDSDEFINETHE

INTERNETOFTHINGSANDPROVIDETHEBLUEPRINTSFOR

Page 94: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Work Cited | 86

ITSDEVELOPMENT.Retrievedfromitunewslog:http://newslog.

itu.int/archives/245

Jackson,P.(2012).StructuralPackaging:DesignYourOwnBoxes

and3-DFoms.London,UK:LaurenceKing.

Kolak,D.,Willkiam,H.,Mandik,P.,&Waskan,J.(2006).Cognityive

Science:AnIntroductiontoMindandBrain.London:

Routledge.

Kroschwitz,J.(1992).Encylopediaof ChemicalTechnology.New

York,NY,USA:JohnWiely&Sons.

Leach,N.(2006).ForgetHeidegger.Bucharest,UK:Paideia.

Lefteri,C.(2014).MaterialsforDesign.London,UK:LaurenceKing

Publishing.

Lynn,G.(1993,Sept1).FoldinginArchitecture.Architectural

Design,63(1).

Mack,C.A.(2006).Feildguidetoopticallithography(Vol.FG06).

Bellingham,WA,USA:Spie.

Marx,K.,&Engels,F.(1932).TheGermanIdeology:Idealismand

Materialism.Moscow,RUS:Marx-EngelsInstitute.

Nicholas,P.(2013).DesigningMaterialMaterialisingDesign.(R.

Roke,Ed.)Waterloo,ON,Canada:RiversideArchitectural

Press.

PenguinReference.(2004).ConciseEnglishDictonary.(R.Allen,

Ed.)Oxford,UK:PenguinGroup.

Picon,A.,&Legendre,G.L.(2011,Jul/Aug).Mathematicsof Space.

(H.Castle,Ed.)ArchitecturalDesign,81(4),pp.9-44.

Puckett,N.(2014).If materialisthenewsoftware,thenhowdoI

writeit?InD.D.Gerber,ParadigmsinComputing(pp.288-

Page 95: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Work Cited | 87

297).LosAngeles:eVoloPress.

Ritter,A.(2007).Smartmaterialsinarchitecture,interiorarchitecture,

anddesign(EnglishEditioned.).(A.Müller,Ed.,&R.Peat,

Trans.)Basel,Switzerland:Birkhäuser.

Rittner,D.,&Bailey,R.A.(2005).Encyclopediaof Chemistry.New

York,NY,USA:FactsOnFileInc.

Schwartz,M.(2002).TheEncylopediaof SmartMaterials(Vol.II).

JohnWiley&Sons.

Spiller,N.,&Armstrong,R.(2011,Mar/Apr).ProtocellArchitecture.

(H.Castle,Ed.)ArchitecturalDesign,81(2),pp.17-42.

Stanovich,K.E.(2005).TheRobot’sRebellion:FindingMeaningin

theAgeof Darwin.Chicago,IL,USA:Universityof Chicago

Press.

Sung,D.(2014).DigitalandParameticArchitecture.(C.Aiello,Ed.)

(6),110-120.

Vitruvius.(1914).TheTenBooksonArchitecture.London:Harvard

UniversityPress.

Webster,J.G.(1999).WileyEncyclopediaof electricalandelectronic

engineering.NewYork:JohnWileyandSons.

Wilson,C.G.,Dammel,R.R.,&Reiser,A.(1997).Photoresist

materials:ahistoricalperspective.AdvancesinResist

TechnologyandProcessingXIV.3049.SantaClara:SPIE.

Page 96: Collectively Intelligent Material Systems · 2 A. Whiten, R. Byrne (Eds.) Machiavellian Intelligence Vol II: Evaluations and Extensions. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge; 1997:

Work Cited | 88

Figures and Tables Figure01.Walker,Simon.“NewCaledonianCrow.”Digitalimage.AnimalCulturesNature’sSecondInheritanceSystem.AccessedMarch02,2017.https://synergy.st-andrews.ac.uk/animalcultures/.

Figure04.http://carleton.ca/sbes/wp-content/uploads/CHEeR.jpgFigure05.Addington,Michelle,andDanielSchodek.SmartMaterials

andTechnologies,10.Table01.Addington,Michelle,andDanielSchodek.SmartMaterials

andTechnologies,83.Figure08.Ritter,A.(2007).Smartmaterialsinarchitecture,interior

architecture,anddesign(EnglishEditioned.).(A.Müller,Ed.,&R.Peat,Trans.)Basel,Switzerland:Birkhäuser.54

Figure09.Ritter,A.(2007).Smartmaterialsinarchitecture,interiorarchitecture,anddesign(EnglishEditioned.).(A.Müller,Ed.,&R.Peat,Trans.)Basel,Switzerland:Birkhäuser.54

Figure10.Source:Sung,Doris.2014.“DigitalandParameticArchitecture.”EditedbyCarloAiello.(EVOLO,Inc)(6):117.

Figure11.Source:Sung,Doris.2014.“DigitalandParameticArchitecture.”EditedbyCarloAiello.(EVOLO,Inc)(6):118.

Figure12.Puckett,N.(2014).If materialisthenewsoftware,thenhowdoIwriteit?InD.D.Gerber,ParadigmsinComputing(pp.288-297).LosAngeles:eVoloPress,289.

Figure13.https://cdn0.vox-cdn.com/thumbor/83oCJk-sX-HJi6BHPY1B919KMbQ=/0x25:680x408/1600x900/cdn0.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_image/image/42598430/deep-blue-kasparov.0.jpeg

Table03.Addington,Michelle,andDanielSchodek.SmartMaterialsandTechnologies,216.

Table04.Addington,Michelle,andDanielSchodek.SmartMaterialsandTechnologies,216.

Table05.Addington,Michelle,andDanielSchodek.SmartMaterialsandTechnologies,216.

Imagesnotcitedareassumedtobethework

of theauthor