colorado library leaders
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/14/2019 Colorado Library Leaders
1/10
1
aw,
12.09
TRENDS,TIPS&TECHNIQUES:
INTERVIEWSWITHCOLORADOLIBRARYLEADERS
AspenWalker,ExecutiveAssistanttotheLibraryDirector
Smartleadersunderstand:youcantrunaneffectiveorganizationfromtheconfinesand
blindspotsofan insularbubble.Youhave toreachout,compareexperiences,andsharebest
practices.In2009,Iinterviewed11Coloradolibraryleadersaboutthemetroareapubliclibrary
environment: Shirley Amore (Executive Director, Denver Public Library), Eugene Hainer
(Executive Director, Colorado State Library), Valerie Horton (Executive Director, Colorado
LibraryConsortium),PaulaMiller(ExecutiveDirector,PikesPeakLibraryDistrict),EloiseMay
(Executive Director, Arapahoe Library District), Sharon Morris (Director of Library
Developmentand Innovation,ColoradoStateLibrary), JanineReid
(ExecutiveDirector,High
Plains Library District), Pam Sandlian Smith (Executive Director, Anythink
Libraries/Rangeview Library District), Mary Stansbury (Program Chair and Associate
Professor, University of Denver, Library and Information Science Program), Tony Tallent
(LibraryandArtsDirector,BoulderPublicLibrary),andMarcellusTurner(ExecutiveDirector,
Jefferson County Public Library). Their insights about the economy and rising library use,
staffingpatterns,
performance
measures,
and
the
big
issues
and
trends
of
the
next
three
years
follow.TheBalancingAct:Cutbacks,SustainableService&SurgingPublicLibraryUse
Theinterviewsrevealedavarietyofissuesthoroughlylinkedtotheeconomicwoesofthe
time.Library leadersare looking forways tobalancecostsavingsandbudgetcutbacks,with
sustainabilityandexcellentpatronservice.Meanwhile,libraryuseisswellingacrossthenation,
aspatronslooktothepubliclibraryforaffordableoptionsandresources.
Public libraryusehasbeenon the rise.The InstituteofMuseumandLibraryServices
reports thatpublic libraryvisits increasednationwideby19%between 1997 and 2007,while
circulation increasedby12% (Henderson,2009).Whatsmore,aspublic librariansknow from
experience,economicdownturnsheraldabigbump in libraryuse.Theeconomicrecessionof
200809reiterates thiswisdom. Ina2009LibraryResearchServicesurveyof librarystaff67%
-
8/14/2019 Colorado Library Leaders
2/10
2
aw,
12.09
reported an increase in computer use, 63% noted an increase in library visits, and 54%
announcedariseincirculation(Hovendick,2009).
The interviews reflect this upturn in library use. All of the public library directors
reportedincreasesinlibraryvisits,circulation,andcomputeruseattheirsystem;similarly,the
StateLibraryandCLiChavewitnessed increased libraryuseacross thestate.At someof the
systems, theupsurge inusewasdramatic:HighPlainsestimatesa35% increase inactivityat
theirlibrariesthisyear.TheAnythinkLibrariesanticipatea4050%increaseinusebytheendof
2009. Many were also experiencing a dramatic upwelling in the desire for employment
resourcesandcomputer instruction.JeffersonCountyhas launchedanewmobileservice that
brings training to patrons who need to learn computer skills, or find ajob. Pikes Peak has
partnered with the local work force center to offer employment programs and workshops.
Denver is launching a largescale community technology center, which will offer computer
trainingandmorecomputers,inordertomeetpatrondemand.
Libraryuseisup,butlibrarydirectorsareanticipatingabighittobudgetsintheyearsto
come.LikeDouglasCountyLibraries,mostofthedistrictsarelookingatfairlystablerevenues
in2010,withlesstospendinthefollowingyears.Arapahoehasemployedarigorousfouryear
spendingplan,whichincludestightlycontrolledbudgetsfor2010and2011,sothatsomeofthe
revenuelossin2012andbeyondcanbeabsorbed.HighPlainsiscurrentlyenjoyingarevenue
windfallfromincreasedgasandoilpumping,butanticipatesareturnto2008levelrevenuesfor
2011andbeyond.Theyareplanningforareductioninstaffinglevelsby2011tomeetthisfiscal
decrease. The municipal library systems in Denver and Boulder are having a harder time.
Denverplanstouseaplanthathasworkedinthepast:theywillreducehoursatallbranches,in
the hopes of avoidingbranch closures. Boulder has seen a reduction in service hours, and
administrativecutbacks.
Given this strainbetween increased use and shrivelingbudgets, I asked the library
leaders to describe how they find abalancebetween costsavings, sustainability and patron
service:
Turnersaidthatlibrariesmustfocusfirstandforemostondeterminingwhatthepublicvaluesandfindsrelevant,andbewillingtotossasidesomeofthethingsweholdsodear.
-
8/14/2019 Colorado Library Leaders
3/10
3
aw,
12.09
MillernotedthatthePikesPeakcommunityhaschanged,andthatmanyofthefastestgrowing neighborhoods lack a nearby library. She is looking at book kiosks and
dispensingmachines,regionalservice(asopposedto littleneighborhood libraries),and
jointuse facilities (includingpartnerships with theYMCA, cityparks and a childrens
museum).
Stansbury called herself a heretic in libraryland, as she felt many libraries spend toomuch time and money on finding and purchasing the perfect authoritative resource,
whentheanswerisoftenavailableforfreeonline.Sherecommendedthatlibrariesspend
more time and money serving patrons personally, while spending less on expensive
resourcesandexhaustivesearches.
Maysaidyoucan findthisbalancebysettingprioritiesbasedonwhatmattersmosttothepeopleyoureserving.Sheaddedthatsheascribes to theShirleyAmoreversionof
budget reductions: give 100% your customer service, but with fewer hours, and if
necessary,fewerstaff.Shesaidothercostsavingmethodstendtowaterdownthevalue
andworthoflibraries.
Hainersaidmanylibrarysystemsarelookingtobecomedistricts,sotheydonothavetorely
on
the
caprice
of
sales
tax
and
municipal
funding.
He
added
that
others
have
closed
theirlibrariestononresidents,andthatmanylibrarysystemsarerelyingmoreandmore
oncrosssystemcollaboration,cooperativesandconsortiums.
Reid reported that her district has employed the principles of a learning organizationfound in Senges book The Fifth Discipline. High Plains counts on innovation (bothtechnological and creative) to improve services,while seeking to consistentlyquestion
theirplansandundertakingstoridthemselvesofsacredcowsandirrelevantpractices.
SandlianSmith saidher library isdelegatingmorework toparaprofessional staff,andreallocating duties across the district. She added that WordThink, their Deweyless
approach tomaterials classification, isalso saving staff time.Patronsare findingwhat
theyneedwithouthelp,andtheshelvingprocessismuchquicker.
Morriscalledforlibrariestogiveupsomeoftheircherished(butoutdated)servicesandpractices, to reexamine theirdefinitionsofqualityandquantity,and to tapvolunteers
(especiallyretiredBabyBoomers)formorehelp.
Hortonsaidcutbacksshouldbevisibletopatrons,sotheyunderstandourfundingneeds.Shereiteratedthenotionthatthisisagoodtimetostopdoingsomethings,butprompted
librariestokeepaneyeonthefutureandrememberthatweareacriticalcomponentof
our communitys ongoing heritage. Many libraries dismantle their historical and
governmentdocumentcollections,inthefavorofhighcirculatingitems.Hortonsaidthat
infiftyyears,peoplewillwantthesehistoricalartifacts,notDanielleSteele. As noted, Amore will employ reduced hours. Earlier this year, Denver surveyed its
patrons;theythoroughlypreferredareductioninhoursatallbranchesoversomebranch
closures.
Tallentcalledfor librariestokeepaneyeontheirstrategicplans,whilespreadingtheirstoriesaboutcutbacksfarandwide.Hesaidmostpatronsdontcomprehendhowmuch
itcoststooperatealibrary.Headdedthatallstaffshouldbeinvolvedinstorytellingand
advocacy.
-
8/14/2019 Colorado Library Leaders
4/10
4
aw,
12.09
StaffingPatternsWith theadventofRFID, selfserviceandautomatedmaterialshandling;a shift inpatron
informationneeds;andanongoinghiring freeze,DouglasCountyLibrarieshasundertakena
newapproachtostaffing.Today,paraprofessionalsareworkingmorecloselywithpatronsand
professionalstaff,andMLSdegreedemployeesaretakingonhigherlevelassignments.Iasked
the library leaders if they were finding a need to adjust job descriptions or the ratio of
paraprofessional to professional staff, and what surprised them about contemporary staffing
patterns. Like DCL, Front Range public libraries are indeed making staffing changes. The
followingthemesemerged:
RFID, selfservice and automated handling are dismantling and transforming thetraditional circulation department. Nearly all of the library systems included in this
studyareusing,orareconsideringatleastoneofthesetechnologies.
Manyof the librariesareexperimentingwitha rovingorembedded servicemodel, inwhichstaffemerge frombehind thedesk toengagepatrons in thestacksorout in the
community.
LikeDCL,Tallentislookingatwaystomergethetraditionalcirculationdepartmentwithreadersadvisory,referenceandyouthservicestocreateatruepublicservicesdivision.
Many libraries have employed a hiring freeze. Hainer reported that several Coloradolibrarieshavealsohadtoresorttodownsizing.
Area librariesare looking forways to centralizeoroutsource someduties, inorder tosave staff timeandmoney.Forexample, likeDCL,Arapahoehascentralizedprogram
planning,collectiondevelopment,andphoneservice,andoutsourcedsomeoftheworktheirtechnicalservicesdepartmentusedtoconduct.
Nearlyalloftheorganizationshave orplanto adjusttheirjobdescriptions.Millernotedthattightbudgetsandfewerstaffnecessitateflexibleandopenjobdescriptions.Horton
said that smaller libraries have always had to take an allencompassing do it all
approachtojobduties,andthatlargerlibrarieswillneedtodothesame.
Similarly, and like DCL, many libraries are looking at job competencies, includingessential skillsandattributes,andhowmuchworkanemployee shouldbeable todo
withinagivenamountoftime.
The function and importance of an MLS is changing.Jefferson County is consideringeveryjobonacasebycasebasistodetermineifitrequiresamastersdegreein library
andinformationscience.AtHighPlains,MLSdegreedlibrariansarenotassignedtothe
floor most of the time; they are available on an oncallbasis and do not focus on a
particularspecialty,likereferenceoryouthservices.Reidsaidprofessionalstaffarealso
being called on to manage largescale projects and initiatives for the entire district.
Arapahoehasundertakenabookalibrarianservice,andisaskingMLSdegreedstaffto
focusmoreonusingtheirprofessionalskillsindeeper,moreimpactfulways.Amoresaid
-
8/14/2019 Colorado Library Leaders
5/10
-
8/14/2019 Colorado Library Leaders
6/10
6
aw,
12.09
have different personnel expenditures, which can skew crosssystem comparison. She
also said that large urban libraries, like Denver, carry much deeper collections than
suburbanorrurallibraries(whichoftenfocusonpopularitems),makingcomparisonsof
thepercentageofitemscheckedoutuneven.
Reid,SandlianSmithandTallentaredevelopingandbuildinguptheir librarysystems,andrefiningtheirapproachtostatisticaltracking.
TrendingTopicsWhattrendsandissuesarelikelytoimpactpubliclibrariesinthenextthreeyears?The
leaderssharedanexcitingvarietyoftrendsthatareofimporttoDCL.Theycanbesortedinto
fourcategories:
1. Informationandtechnology andourrelationshipwithboth arechangingrapidly. Stansburynotedthatmanynewlibrarians aswellasmanyofourpatrons havea
differentapproach
to
information
and
media;
one
that
merges
culture,
technology
andhandsonexpertiseandcontentcreation,withan indifferentattitudetoward
sacred containers (think encyclopedias, or traditional library buildings and
collections).Shesaidthisphenomenoniscloselyrelatedtothemashupculture
flourishing on the Internet, which combines video, text, images and audio, to
createnewandrobust(butoftenscatteredanddisaggregated)content.
Similarly, Stansbury, Miller, Morris and Amore all indicated that libraries andpatrons arebecoming more and more involved in content creation, including
books,video,podcasts,blogsandmore.Inotherwords,weveallbecomeexperts,
publishers, creators, and webliographers. Libraries can make the most of this
trendbyparticipatingincontentcreation,offeringopportunitiesforourpatronsto
create,andhosting/sharing/preserving thiscontent.Hainerremindedus that the
InstituteofMuseumandLibraryServices2009publication,ACatalystforChange(citedbelow)providesawealthofexamplesdemonstratinghowpublic libraries
are transforming their technological offerings and services. Morris noted that
librarians mustbeboth experts and facilitators, who invite the community to
create and collaborate with us. Stansbury pointed out that libraries should also
keepaneyeon thevalueof thiscontenthowmuchdoes it cost to create,and
whatsitsimpact?
May, Miller and Reid noted that a new generation of social tech users areenamored with online selfpromotion and less concerned with privacy. The
LibraryCodeofEthicsremindsus toprotecteach libraryusersright toprivacy
andconfidentiality,butmanyofourpatronsmaynotcareabout,orunderstand
ourefforts.
Ourpatrons,likeourstaff,havediverseneedsandperspectiveswhenitcomestoboth informationand technology.Socialnetworking,downloadable contentand
mobile computing are here to stay, and we need to embrace and master these
trendstoremainrelevant.Butconversely,manypatronsstill looktoprintorthe
-
8/14/2019 Colorado Library Leaders
7/10
7
aw,
12.09
reference librarians ability to answer their questions; others require basic
technology training.Turnerremarked thatwhilereferencework ischanging,we
still have many opportunities to help patrons with their information and
technologyneeds.Morrisassertedthattechnologyisamovingtarget,andthatwe
mustbepreparedtoservearangeofusers:frompeoplewhowanttomakemovies
forYouTube,tothosewhodontknowwhatYouTubeis.
2. TheEconomyisChangingUs. Turnerstated that like technology, theeconomy ischangingpublic libraries.We
areexpectedtodomorewithless,andthatshardtoaccomplish.Hortonworried
thatemergencyreservesaredryingup,andthatmanylibrarieswillhavetowater
downanddismantletheirofferings,whichcanbehardtobouncebackfrom.Reid
pointedthatdiminishedlibraryserviceinonecommunitywillhaveanimpacton
neighboring library systems, as patrons look to tap into their services instead.
Tallent reflected that thedifficulteconomic climatemakes ithard tojustifyand
nourish change and innovation, which spawns a disparitybetween thegreatest
ideasanddreamsofourprofession,andtherealityofwhatwecanactuallyafford
topulloff.
Amore and May noted that many more public libraries will probably seek tobecomeindependentdistricts.Thatsaid,Amendment60,whichwillappearonthe
2010Coloradoballot,couldimpactpropertytaxandultimately,thedesiretoform
newlibrarydistricts.
Itsnotalldoomandgloom:thereportsofrising libraryuseandnewprogramsfocusingonemploymentandtechnologyaroundthestateshowthatlibrariesare
respondingtotheneedsofourcommunities.Librarianslovetoserveothers,and
theeconomyyieldsnewopportunitiesforsmallbusinessbuildingandeconomicgardening, as well as the occasion to help patrons with theirjob search needs.
Though money is tight, we have the ability to make a positive impact in our
communities,anddemonstratethetransformativepowerofpubliclibraries.
3. CollaborateandPartner(EvenMore). The lackluster economy, and the more social and democratic approach to
information and technology calls for more collaboration within our local
communitiesandtheColoradolibrarycommunityasawhole.Amore,Miller,and
Turner indicated they are working with organizations in their communities toshare expenses, promote lifelong learning, and boost the local economy by
providing job training. Similarly, Hainer, Morris and Reid remind us of the
benefitsoflibraryconsortiumsandcollaborations,includingcontinuingeducation
andtraining,andsharedresources.Stansburysaid that ifourcollaborationsand
consortiums weaken at any node, it will weaken all Colorado public libraries.
Reid,AmoreandHortonsaidtheyarehopefulaboutashared,andpossiblyopen
sourceILSsystem,andincreasedpossibilitiesforresourcesharing.
-
8/14/2019 Colorado Library Leaders
8/10
8
aw,
12.09
4. WemustembracethemessagesofOCLCsFromAwarenesstoFundingandchangeperceptionsaboutlibraries.
Ivesortedthissectionofmyreportintofourcategories,inanattempttoorganizea
lotof ideas ina succinct fashion.But Imust remark:allof the trendsand issues I
discussedwith the library leadersare thoroughly related to this finalcategory, the
OCLC report, and the national need to change perceptions about public libraries
whileboosting librarysupportandfunding.Ourcontinuedexcellenceandsurvival
dependonourabilitytoconvincevotersthatlibrariesandlibrarians:
1.Transformlives.
2.Buildcommunity.
3.Areavital,relevantandnecessarypartofcommunityinfrastructure
andlifeinthe21stCentury.
Hainer,May,Miller,Morris,SandlianSmith,andTallentallindicatedthattheOCLC
report was of great concern and import to them; and all of the leaders discussed
themes that tie intoFromAwareness toFunding.DCLsit supportmarketing
campaign,aswellasLaRuesworktoengageandemployexternallibraryadvocates
around the stateareon trackwith the leadersurgency tochangeperceptionsand
buildlongtermsupport.Withthisinmind,theleadersrevealedafewmoretrends
ofworthtoDCLandallpubliclibraries:
We must continue our efforts to foster and promote early literacy. May andStansburysaidthiswillhaveavisible,longtermimpactonchildrenandfamilies,
improvelives,andbuildcommunity.
Morris reported that librariesaround the stateareemployinggreen technology,andthenusingthistechnologytoshowpatronsthechangestheycanmakeintheir
ownlivesandneighborhoods.
Tallent lauded DCLs efforts in merchandising library materials. He noted thatthese innovationscantransformhowpatronsperceivethe library,andassertthe
ideathatthelibraryisrelevantandforwardthinking.
Theleadersrepeatedlyexpressedthatthepubliclibraryshouldbeaculturalhubofthecommunity,andseektosolvecommunityproblems.Denversnewstrategic
plan includesaphilosophystatement thatmakescertain toexpress the librarys
desiretomakeanextraordinarydifferenceinthecommunity.BothAmoreand
May commented on their work to establish community outcomes. Miller said
PikesPeakhaspartneredwithotheragencies for theDreamCityproject.The
organizationsarestrivingtobuildthekindofcitythecommunitywants.Shesaid
the library is the village green, where people can share ideas and learn new
-
8/14/2019 Colorado Library Leaders
9/10
9
aw,
12.09
things inanonjudgmentalenvironment.SandlianSmithsaid thenewAnythink
Librariesareaboutgiving the libraryback to the community,and rescuingand
preservingthepubliclibraryforgenerationstocome.Their2010summerreading
programwill focuson creating anew crossgenerational library experience that
buildscommunity,createsconnection,andfocusesonthetransformational nature
of reading.Shenoted that reading isavehicle toget someplaceelse, learnnew
things and grow as a person, and notjust about finishing abook. She hopes
Anythinkcanboost theemotionalattachmentpeople inhercommunityhave to
libraries.
InConclusionThelibraryleadersIinterviewedweregenerouswiththeirtimeandinsight.WhileIhave
donemybest to capture their wisdom, this report provides only a snapshot of more than a
dozenhoursofconversation.Anaspiringlibraryleadermyself,Iappreciatetheopportunityto
learnfrom
their
experience
and
thinking.
In
meeting
with
these
exemplary
leaders
Iobserved
qualitiesandleadershipstylesthatareofinspirationtome,andofnotetoDCLandallpublic
librarians.Successful library leaderscombineapenchant fornimbleadaptabilitywitha long
term focuson strategicplanning and sustainability.Moreover, thesequalitiesmust restona
firmcommitment topeople, including thepublic libraryuserand thecommunitiesweserve.
Hainer reminds us we are in the business of serving people, not the business of serving
informationtopeople.Thisfocusonpeopleandserviceisimportantinsomanyways,aspublic
librariesstandonthebrinkofanewera.Ourpatronsneedsareshifting,andourfundingisin
peril. We must adapt and thrive in the new Age of Information and a currently stunted
economy,whileaugmentingperceptionsaboutourpurpose,vitalityandessentialcontribution
to community infrastructure. Librarianship is loaded with tradition, and while much of that
knowledgeandpracticeremainsrelevant,wemusttreatourfieldasaworkinprogress.Tallent
notedthatweneedtocultivatemorestrongvoicesandleadersinpubliclibraries.Bystepping
up to the plate and sharing our experiences with one another, we can transform lives and
sustainandenhanceoneofourbesttraditionsandinventionswehave:publiclibraries.
-
8/14/2019 Colorado Library Leaders
10/10
10
aw,
12.09
RESOURCES
AmericanLibraryAssociation. CodeofEthics. ALA.org.2009.AmericanLibraryAssociation,21Dec2009..
.
DeRosa,Cathy,andJennyJohnson.FromAwarenesstoFunding:AStudyofLibrarySupportinAmerica:aReporttotheOCLCMembership.Dublin,Ohio:OCLC,2008.
Henderson,Everett. U.S.ServiceTrendsinPublicLibraries,19972007. imls.gov.2009.InstituteofMuseumand
LibraryServices,Web.21Dec2009..
Hovendick,Briana. LibrariesandLibrariansFeelingEffectsofEconomicSlowdown. lrs.org.2009.LibraryResearch
Service,Web.21Dec2009..
InstituteofMuseumandLibraryServices(U.S.).ACatalystforChangeLSTAGrantstoStatesProgramActivitiesandtheTransformationofLibraryServicestothePublic.[Washington,D.C.]:InstituteofMuseumandLibraryServices,2009.
ProtectColoradosCommunities. Amendment60:LocalPropertyTaxRevenue. ProtectColoradosCommunities.net.
2009.ProtectColoradosCommunities,Web.21Dec2009..
.