comparative evaluation strategies in mergers and acquisitions
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
1/69
!#%#!#%
425,7,9;0;,:,943$97,9008307078
,3/.6:89438
!#%&
$&%%$!##
#$$%%&%
%$%&$
&
-897,.9
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
2/69
:830887,3,9438043 147.47547,90 70897:.9:73 3 90 1472
410707847.6:89438/4908990,9071742;,74:8507850.9;08%8
8 070 ,7808 90 25479,3.0 41 .43/:.93 ,3 007.80 147 0;,:,93
897,9008 147905740.9,3/903,.425,7843,8 94-02,/0849,990
3907089419089,04/07841-499003998349/89:7-0/
%4/4 900;,:,9432094/41;,:3,172,3/90 25,.94120707 3
9047,3,943572,7/,9,,3/,3,9.,/8.:8843,84-9,30/1742
!,3/733/4:99,:7907,3,884170.039207078,8
/430 94,77;0,990.43.:843%8 9088 8,3,9902592,/0 94 13/4:9
90 4592:2 0;,:,9;0 897,9008 :80/ - .425,308 3 207078 ,3/
,.6:8943 . .42203.08 1742 ;,:3 90 172 94 0;,:,93 90
2070/0399
%4/4 900;,:,943 90.,59,-:/093/0.843,8 94-0/430-;07
.,701:0892,93905740.90/1700.,814847/4384430,8 94
,;0 ,3 3/059 340/0 94 1470.,89 90 2,709 90 2070/ 0399 8
0390733943.0988/430903.42089024/0415,390,.6:70/
172%04592:2897,901475,390,.6:70/ 172/0503/:543
903,9:7041,.6:8943
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
3/69
3.0 905,203924/0 8/0907230/903 ,30;,:,943 8 94-0/430 94
13/4:9090790-7,3/ 90 47,3,943 .:9:70 897,90., 198 0,.
4907 %03 43.0 , 9080 0;,:,9438 ,70 /430 903 43 90 /0,
84:/-0 13,0/ 147.,90,2,8 94-0 14720/9705708039,9;0
.4257831742-4990.47547,943
33/,33.,.9;9,874394:3570.0/0390/0;0,3/74
0;031:7907425,308207090,.49073,3/5,79.:,790
9090%!80.94733/,,;0930880/2,2:2-:83088
70897:.9:73147900,740;07924709,3,1419080/0,8
1,8 94 /0;07 907 050.90/ 708:98 ,3/ 84 .425,7843 41 0;,:,943
897,900838.0397,9420707,3/,.6:8943/0.8432,3
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
4/69
.340/02039
9,0 98455479:39940570882/005 80380417,99:/0 9429088
:/0 !74108847#,2,783, 147 8 ;,:,-0 :/,3.0 003 3907089 ,3/
051:.79.82/:7390.4:7804189:/
057088 2 83.070 9,38 94 !740.9:/08 #,82 $:3/7, 147
574;/3,30.088,705/:73905740.947
$#
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
5/69
%,-0414390398
3974/:.943907,9:70#0;0
07078,3/.6:894334;07;0
,.74:3/4190!74-02
030198,3/$.4504190#080,7.
!74-0243909
%047547,90507850.9;0
,80$9:/
',:3$307
;,:,943$97,90083
%,9,%0,908903499%090
#0.42203/,943
#0.42203/,943
43.:843
25.,943
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
6/69
-47,5
5503/08
$34588
%088#0854380$009
":089433,708
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
7/69
07078,3/.6:894334;07;0
0707 8,3 30;9,-050342034341903,9:70. 8;07574259
7010.90/3901472,9434190:3;07809801;0390:2,37,.089,790/
9,207074194.0843,3/83.0:2,3.;,94389,790/013/
492,30,250807038.,204:91742903/42,3//70,20/
,-4:92073490790779470894,3897039,3/5407
:83088 47/ ,8 ,84 -003 349 ,3 0.05943, 1742 98 503420343
;07/,0 13/308 1742/110703980.947841 3/:89708 ,-4:9207078
,3/ ,.6:89438 9,3 5,.0 94 03,3.0 8307 47 94 ,.0;0 850.1.
13,3.,4,0907 3 90 147241.4898,;3,3/0.434208418.,09
908,20 920 9 84-;4:89,99070 8,3 3.70,80 3,..088 94.,59,47
-00;089,9:3/07;,:0/.425,3.,3-09:730/,74:3/
40;07 9 2470 9,3 ,1 41 90 /0,8 1,8 94 /0;07907 050.90/
708:98,.425,7843410;,:,943897,9008 3 8 .0397, 9420707
,3/,.6:8943 /0.843 2,3,./0, 8 84 :36:0 3 90728 41 80
3/:89714.:847047,5.,47039,943,3/900;,:,943897,90089,9
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
8/69
9070 .,3349 -0 43 4300;,:,943 897,9008 . 8 :31472
,55.,-0
302:898009,990/0,2:89/0;0790439072749,3/8:89,30/
57419,-925,8884:/-04349094.425,308199409073,
57,.9.,4713,3.,80380,3/34943090790.4:/97:.42-3094
2,0,409,9,870,9079,3908:241985,798
89047/-0.4208,97:4-,2,7095,.02470,3/24704;0780,8
207078 9, 0 5,.0 ,3/ 3/, 8 349 ,3 0.05943, 944 4-,,943
57;,9,943 ,3/ 70,,943 41 .439748 ,;0 97070/ :3570.0/0390/
:58:703.7488-47/07-3/,3.425,30840;0790574.08841
70897:.9:73 41 3/,3 3/:897 // 349 .42203.0 220/,90 ,1907
-07,,9439,8 90 3/:897, 84 /43 83.094 .
86:000/90574192,738413/,3.47547,90039908,3/ 147.0/90294
70897:.9:709074507,943894,.0;07,907.425099;03088
3/,,8,.6:70/14703.425,308-09003147.4384/,90/
,24:39 41 -43 1440/ - 3 479 -43
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
9/69
4;0780,8,.6:89438479-433,3/3903:2-07,8
430:594,.6:89438479,74:3/-43
%0 .4393:3 545:,79 41 207078 ,3/ ,.6:89438 8 574-,- ,
7010.9434190/08570,/-0019,9,.6:89438574;/0,30,874:9094
,.0;0 7493/03 9 .4208 94 207078:3097,/943,47,3.
749 903,-08.425,308 947,/.,,90790/3,2.841-:83088-
,.0;3749.4898,;38,3/.425099;0,/;,39,0
0 .43/:.93,.425,7843 007.80 41 0;,:,943 897,9008 3
90144388:0884://:-0.438/070/
W /0391.,9434190 84:7.084190 1728 .:77039 ,3/ 1:9:70 .425099;0
8970398
W48:89,3,-0,3/:36:090/03910/8970398,70
W90.42509947705.,9090897,901440/
W90897,90.70,908,704/07;,:0
W',74:8.42543039841.47547,904;073,3.08:.,8903/0503/03.041
90-4,7/41/70.947890,.9;8241,708,704/078
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
10/69
40;07 942,0, 20707 1: 8:..0881:430 .,3349 3470 90 :2,3
,3/.:9:7, 88:08,8708:93200934194,:943424:8.47547,90
.:9:708 03 .425,308 ,70 ,.6:70/ 47 .42-30/ 50450 ,2489
220/,90 89,79 94 14.:8 43 /110703.08 3 90 .425,308 254008
39, 507.0;0 90 4907 .425,38 .:9:70 ,8 09073, 31:03.0 ,3/
1706:039 700.9 9 850., 98 ,5508 3 ,3 ,.6:8943 070 90
,.6:73 .425,3 800 90280;08 ,8 90 33078 ,3/ 90 ,.6:70/
.425,39048078
3,//943 94 9803,207079,085,.0.425,30254008-0.420
.43.0730/ ,-4:9 4- 80.:79 ,3/ 7:2478 89,79 13 42-33 94
.425,308 .,3 .70,90 3907507843, .431.9 740 .431:843 :3.079,39
,-4:9.,30,3/4774170/:3/,3.
34907,850.99,9 84://:-0.438/070/ 89,9 347/07 9474,3/
05,3/ .425,308 2:89 4 147 3 -:8308808 9,9 90 :3/0789,3/
0
0,/3.47547,904:808,;0:3/079,0370897:.9:73007.808,3/
8430419024890110.9;02094/841.47547,9070897:.9:7303.0
,8-0.420,33907,5,794190439072-:83088897,9041
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
11/69
.47547,900390757808;033/,313,3.,807;.083/:897,8
70.430/90300/147.47547,9070897:.9:73,3/2,3-,383
90.4:397,7024;3398/70.943
40;0790708,,8,3,7:2039,,389.43;0703.0
8:08939,93.70,83.4250994390,77;,41904-,
.425,30820,3831:9:70,,3/1:414-,3899:9438
/423,90$4201099,9903/,3.47547,904:/-0.420
54,70/94-,,398,943003/,3/3.05,078,9
,34907#01079483,333/:897944147425099;03088-$!#'99,(
.43.059:,/8.:8843
:83088.42-3,94347-:8308870897:.9:73.,39,03901472841
207078,.6:89438,2,,2,943,3/9,04;078,3/,,;05,0/,3
25479,3974039009073,74941,3:2-07410,/3.4:39708390
47/
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
12/69
%0708,70,9/0,41.431:843,3//8,700203970,7/3900,.9
20,33841,90809072344082039430/,-4;031,.9842041902
,70:80/3907.,30,-94:9090720707,3/.6:8943,70
41903:99070/834324:8-:9909072820707,3/,.6:894320,3
89/1107039938,3,908090728,8,805,7,900,/013943
3,.6:89434..:7803430.425,39,084;07,34907,3/5,5,-
020708,890304307905:7.,808.,0/,3,.6:89437420,
543941;0909,709.425,3.0,80894089,3/90-:078894.
.4393:0894-097,/0/
207074..:780394472470.425,308.42-30394430.425,3
47430472470.425,3082,20709,30893.425,3070747
,2,,2,9432,9,094147280707974:,-8475943
0707974:.4384/,943
0707974:,-8475943
-8475943.,3-0/0130/,890574.08841.42-3394472470
.425,308394,30893.425,3070,90.425,3080.059430
480907/0399470,250,-847594341%,9,0790789/-%,9,
02.,89/
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
13/69
0707974:.4384/,943
390.4397,7.4384/,9438,.42-3,9434194472470.425,308
394,30.425,3,3/39814724120707,.425,308,700,
/884;0/941472,3003993,.4384/,94390,.6:70/.425,3
97,38107898,88098,-908,3/8,7089490,.6:73.425,3
07078.,3-0,,3-74,/.,8810/3901443,
47439, 20707 %8 8, .42-3,9434194472470 1728 3 82,7
95041574/:.9434720734117283908,2089,0413/:897478,20
,70,41-:830888343,847439,20707
'079., 20707 42-3,943 41 94 47 2470 1728 3;4;0/ 3 /1107039
89,08 41 57 4/:.943 47 /897-:943 3 47/07 94 70/:.0 90 .489 41
574/:.9438343,8;079.,20707
434207,9020707%8 8,.42-3,94341 172803,0/ 3:370,90/
30841-:83088,.9;9,250%9%7-03%88:08
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
14/69
40;07,90;07-0901472412070798:3/079,039901443
249;0847347/0794,.0;0901443-030198
29.42509943
&90:3/07:90/2,7095407
%474,3/03,3.057419,-93903/:897
%4,.0;00.434208418.,0
89,-8,97,383,943,-7/00,/94:90.088;089,79:5.4898
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
15/69
,.74:3/4190!74-02
3 94/,8 47/ 41 390380 4-, .42509943 , .47547,90 -002498
708479 949 ,3 ,990259 94 ,99,3 8:708 3 347,3. 749:9
9070 ,70 034724:8 70,8438 41 8:. 1,8 94 ,// ;,:0 47 94
,.0;090/0870/8307$42041902,7050330//43-04
2574507;,:,943 %0 0 94 , 8:..0881: 803 90 7957.0
,3/349,50332470,705,/-:9324894190.,808.425,30803/:53
5,324700908,704/0784190,.6:70/.425,35,79.:,7
19070.0;0.,8/40-:990.4393:38,704/07803/:5990
4-344:8-:7/03414;0757.0/,88098.9/01390.43;.943/:90
907 1:9:70 0,7338 $:. -03 90 20: ,9 -0.4208 25479,39 8
574507;,:,9434190-:83088,3/850.,39,3-0,88098
4,893 4;0789,90/ 830708 %070 8 34 /4:-9 9,9 ,3 ,.6:8943 .,3
.70,90 8307-:9 2,3 9208 .425,308 9 :3.43974,-0 5,59,9438
03/:534;0789,939884.,0/8307%84..:782,3/:0944;07
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
16/69
0892,93 90 7,90 41 .489 70/:.943 ,3/ 4;07 ;,:3 90 309 473
.,59,;070892,938:.8307080,/894,1,:70419020707
:9:7, .,8,.41574507 .422:3.,943,.98 ,8,/8,8907 3 .,8041
4;0780,82070780702,3.:9:7,/110703.080894704;07.:9:7,
/110703.08 /4 708:9 3 1,:7041 5,38 2502039,943 ,3/9070-5,;08
90,147901,:70419020707
!447:83088903 90574/:.947807;.08/408349 193,9:7, 394
90,.6:70782,70938,08/897-:94388902,3/34994-00194:990
/0247,5.,706:70203984190574/:.947807;.0841902070/0399
90392,.70053/0,83011.0393907,943
;070;07,0,8,.6:894381706:039708:9390,.6:707,88:23
9442:./0-9:9:703907089.4898.438:20,70,95479434190,.6:70/
.425,38 0,7338 3 0;03 2489 8074:8 574-02 708:98 03 90
,.6:707705479894.0,58479907213,3.3459438,3/903,8/11.:9
701:3/343,439072-,88
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
17/69
4,7/7442 $59 03 207078 ,70 897:.9:70/ 9 4,7/
705708039,943 47 9 8:-89,39, 705708039,943 1742 90 9,709 /:0
,9903943 84:/ -0 ;03 94 /0907230 90 .425,9-9 41 90 /70.9478
14439020707470,250034-,%807;.08,390.9743.
,9,$8902847547,943$,.6:70/,3,470 -,80/5,88
9/ 43 :30 077#,4 .4393:0/ 94 702,3 .01 00.:9;0 ,9
5,88 -0.,:80 41 8 0507980 3 2,3,02039 ,3/ :3/0789,3/3 90
-:83088
$4204190574-028,70,14702039430/-:99089803/088$:.-03
9020:-014709080 574-028 84:/-0/:,//70880/:998
89:/425,7,9;0;,:,943$97,9008307078,3/.6:89438
-0,//7088390 178994 574-0289,9 8 13/34:9,574507;,:,943
24/0 14790 17294-0,.6:70/4390430,3/,3/43 904907,3/ 9
,8414.:8439413/4:9,57450724/0147;,:38307
-0.9;04190#080,7.
%05708039#080,7.85,330/9489:/9020,8:7089,9.,3-0/8.0730/
,8.4:/574-,-033007,8:..0883,3//039190370/0398
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
18/69
9,9,70706:70/94-01440/94-09907,/0,,89.,3-0/43047
3049,90/4798904-0.9;08,70,81448
%4.425,7090574.088080;,:,9434190172,3/8307
;,:,943
%413/4:9,3,/06:,90897,901475,390,.6:70/172849,9
90708344;070;07,0574-023901:9:70
%4/0907230,34592:20;,:,943897,903
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
19/69
030198,3/$.4504190#080,7.
93/,,3:5 394,302033:2,;0-0.420088039,
147 347,3.749%8 85,5,-0 3 9090 3/:897. 3 90,
,3/ :30 41 930880/ 498 41 4;0780,8 ,.6:89438 0 ,,
3/:89708,.6:732 2,47%394,;,3/070 1742 9,,3/#,243/8
,.6:70/!479:,-,80/#003.%0908!479:08,299,/,889,90/3
%0%0207941%090841:83088.43429:309030
2,397,147 3/,3 9090 2,478 94 4 4-, 8 .7488 -47/07,.6:89438
7008,$,,70.9470307, 0/07,94341 3/,3 5479
470,3/24704;0780,8,.6:8943.4393:0390,.6:8943
38:.,20:905708039#080,7.-0.420809702025479,39,890
572,714.:8419089:/8940;,:,90897,900830707.6:8943
,3/ 13/34:9 ,34592:22412,35,2039 94 90,.6:70/ 172
;03 ,3,89 1008 9,9 90 74:90 8 ,3 /0, , 1 47 .47547,90
70897:.9:73 $9,793 17 42 82, 3/0503/039 47,3,9438 94 4-,
-002498,8973984594341749
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
20/69
%0 70,843 .,3 -0 ,393 -:9 430 .470 70,843 8 20,38
2574;020393.,59,897:.9:70.03,-08949,030,3//;07810/
,.9;90840;07,2,47 -499030.94 2574;0 90.,59, 897:.9:70 8
54475,20392,/09490,.6:70/.425,3/:73905702070734907
47/8 9 0,038 90 13,3., 548943 41 90 .425,3 %4 ,;4/ 98
574-02 41903 .425,308 ,.6:70 , 2,47 89,0 0,707 ,3/ ,907 /4 90
.425090 ,.6:8943 0 147 0,250 39073,943, ,7093 $,08
74:5!.$,.6:70/2,4789,08 3 3/,8,3//,7093,3/
90702,3390,704394,.6:70-
%0 1443 .,808 -0 ,3,0/ 9 7 0850.9 94 ,77 ;0 17:91:
.43.:8438
%,04;07-%,9,%0,41%0909,8-00324709,3,/0.,/041%,9,%0,
%09074:503,02039,3/902,97243834-7038349
455479:3908147-4941902%,9,%0,8&-,80/.4,-47,947%090
74:5890334;,9474190.43.0594190,-,,3/-;,:0,3/;4:20
,2439094574.07-7,3/83&32/%,9,%0,-4:9&
-,80/%09014754:3/
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
21/69
54909.,.,8089:/9900541,7907..4:39,39,3/!,
54909.,.,8089:/,8-003/0;0450/..4;078,2489,90
574-028,884.,90/94;,:,943394/,8.47547,9047/
!74-0243909
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
22/69
%047547,90!07850.9;0
3 :30 4-, % ,39 0.9743. ,9, $89028 47547,943
,.6:70/ 243 8,708 41,3,470 -,80/5,88 9/ 147#8
.7470
3/,3,:90.4:9:70-8,70438455390302,397,147
3/,390902,4789444-,8974:.7488-47/07,.6:89438
%0 %02079 41 %0908:83088 .4342 9 :30 ,,
3/:89708 ,.6:70/ 2 2,47 %394,;,3/070 1742 9, ,3/ %7/
203843 147,949,.438/07,94341,-4:924343,3
908,200,:0:,7,90,;02.,8,.6:70/,3#;07#,243/43
, ,3/ #,243/8 ,.6:70/ !479:, -,80/ #003. %0908
!479:08,299,/,
5,79 1742 9080 4;07 80,8 ,.6:89438 - 3/,3 3. 90 0,7
930880/90 ,7089 0;074;0780,8 ,.6:8943-,3 3/,3 .425,3 ,8
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
23/69
%,9,%0,,.6:70/90%09074:5147 24354:3/840;07/:7390
5,89/0.,/0 498414-,-00249,8 ,84,.6:70/.425,308 174290
42020:03794,3/,9444;07&3.05581742
279 ,3,85,9 74:5 1 47 ,3 :3/8.480/ 57.0 8 507 90 ,.6:8943
,7002039 794, ,439 90&3.0 558-7,3/ ,84,.6:70/,
10:3:80/,880981742279,3,85,9
9842,3,55033,9-0.420825479,398;,:,9434190
9,709.425,3,3/900892,90/83073548920707039.420894
;,:,9434190,.6:70/.425,341903574-02,78083;,:390$,5
7,944906:08943,7808,98,8,57,94
$,5 7,94 8 907,944190 8,70 0.,307,90414304190 2073
.425,3 9 90 8,70 0.,30 7,90 41 90 4907 .425,3 70508
!74108847$,3/005!1.425,3,3/.425,382073903
$,57,944:/-0
$,57,94.,30#,9041425,3.,30#,9041425,3
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
24/69
%74:/1107039.,8089:/08,3//8.:88438,3,990259,8-0032,/094
0;,:,90 90;,74:8897,9008:80/147;,:3909,709 172,3/8307
.,70/8.:880/3,907.,59078
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
25/69
,80$9:/
%%9/#
#$%%9/
,80/43 31472,943 ,9070/ 1742! ,3/ 43974:90 70.039
-:83088309054909., .,8089:/4307078 ,3/.6:89438 ,8
-003 /0;0450/ 944 90 05 41 2 57 40.9 :/0 !7 4108847
#,2,783,,3/733/4:99,942,090;,:,9438,857,.9.,
,8 5488-0$4204190 ;,:,943897,90089,9,8-003 3.47547,90/ 8
097,.91742242.,8808417,,03/:$,4113,3.0
,.:99,&3;0789
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
26/69
%0,88:259438.,70 900894304190.,8089:/,7003:207,90/
-04
9 8 ,88:20/ 9,9 90 0893 :3/079,38 ,704507,93,9, 0;0
-04 4592:2-:903 90 .42-30 907 7084:7.08 ,3/ 0114798
90 .,3 70/:.0 90 .489 41 57 4/:.943 3.:/3 803 ,3/
,/23897,9;0050380899,00,7894,.0;0988307
4990.425,308/4349,;0,3!7010703.0$,70,59,
908,708,701:5,/:5,3/,:9470/8,70.,59,4199,
44/ 9/ 8 41 8,708 41 7:5008 0,. ,3/ 41,,3,,7
#089,:7,399/8418,70841#80,.
0570.,9438.,.:,90/432383,,3.0094/
%070 8 34 3907089 94 -0 5,/ -,,3,,7 #089,:7,39 9/ ,1907
2070743/0-9.,59,,8 90 4,39,03 174299,44/ 9/4:/
-0,/:890/
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
27/69
%0 0,733841 -4990 17214790 0,7 ,8 -0039,03 147
.,.:,9390!$,190720707
4990.425,308,70890/.425,308
3,3.,0,7147-4990.425,308.4808,9890.02-07
!43994-03490/%0570;,39,7,901470,.0,7,8.,30/
99, 44/ 9/ ,8 089,-80/ 3 94 2,3:1,.9:70 8900
0307,:80/147574/:.3420,55,3.08,3/2,.308%0.425,3
3;0890/ #8 ,.8 3 , 82, .43.073 .,0/ ,,3,,7 #089,:7,39 9/
#:73905,890,7888,08,;0743,9,3,;07,041
,-4:9 0,7 . 8 -0490 3/:897 -03.2,7 ,3/ !%,;0
743,9,-4:9%01:.9:,93574194190.425,3,8.,:80/98!
7,9494-02:.4
%4 70/:.0 98 0,733 389,-9 8 34 5,333 94 ,.6:70
430785 3# . ,8 , 5447 2,3,02039 ,3/ 94 2,0 9 98
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
28/69
8:-8/,7:7703988,70 8803147#83902,709%0
830708147,.6:73#,7003:207,90/-04
%09,709.425,3-0430/949070,90/-:83088849053
;079.,20707,3/503097,9033007,70,
9,80307,90/,89,,7944/,24390.438:207,3/8920
434:70/,8,44/":.$07;.0#089,:7,39"$#
9,/4:909830,3/:2-,%070;03:00307,90/
174290804:90980532,39,33,89,-0!7,94
#8343147986:,941574/:.98,3/807;.083.:/39,8,
89743 489. 97 4:4:9 98 4:9098 8570,/ ,.7488 90 .,59, ,3/
:2-, %0 .425,3 8 5,333 94 2,0 98 2,/03 0397 3 4,9,
:0 94 5447 2,3,02039 ,3/ ,. 41 334;,9;0 /808 90 .425,38
5071472,3.0,8-40//4399003974130/8390-4.%0
.425,3.4:/3495,00/94574/:.9 334;,943/:0 94 90.48941
7,2,907,,3/574.0880/9028706:70/1478:.3/0,;4:7
#8 8,08,;0 743,9,3 ,;07,0 41507 0,7 %0 .425,38
0,733,8-003 4/:094/0.30 38,08,3/90,;07,02,70957.0
41.425,3 8 8,708 3 70.039 9208 ,8 -003 4079,3 98 -44;,:0
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
29/69
%0-4,7/41#9389,90390944,4,3 1742# 9050/
902 94 /0, 9 907 13,3., 3,/06:,. ,3/ 34 1 9043 9
90 .,3 09 7, 2,907, ,3/ 574.088 370/0398 ,9 407 .4898
174290 :2:34:8 574/:.95479144414704;078 8:55
.,303,-00,8,;,,-94190574/:.983,904:9098
%0 .:7703957.041#88,70 8#8439389,9 190
.4:/,.6:70# 90.4:/ 9:73 ,74:3/90 .425,3 ,3/ 3.70,80 98
8,70 ;,:0 3 90 2,709 40;07# 1,;4:70/ 20707 9
3890,/41-0.423, 8:-8/,7..47/3 94 8,704/07841# 1
430 .425,3 8 2,/0 , 8:-8/,7 41 4907 90 /0, -03/ 90 8307
4:/1,,3/9070349-0,3:310/.422,3/,899,39,24:3994-0
/423,90/-905,7039.425,3
:9,390/94,.6:70#,3/.,20/94749078,08-
9378-:9,8#,884 47497,90 38,08-0
5,39021470,.8,70,3,24:392:.4079,3907.:770392,709
57.0#,700/949,9-:9907.43/943,894097,2,907,8,9,
2:.2470407.4898.059470/:.0.4894144/884/,90,89
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
30/69
418,08,39.5,9089,9948:554798,087494141#
90,;094-0,7,.,5006:,94418,0814790178978
4 90 243/4,7 6:08943 ,7808 0907 -49 90 .425,308
,;0 ,3 3.70,80/ !$ 3 90 5489 2070720: ,3/,957.0
84:/5,94#190207090,.4907742#8543941
;0 , ;079., 3907,943 41 :58970,2 8:55078 0 #0,3.0
!0974.02.,8 9/9#0,3.0 3/:89708 9/ 3 90 0,7 05
90.425,394,.0;090/0870/708:9418307,3/70/:.090.48941
574/:.943
%0 13,3., 89,902039 3 , 8:22,70/ 1472 88:0/ - -49 90
.425,308147900,703/0/890.02-07,70;03-04
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
31/69
99,44/89/
$:22,70/!89,90203914790,891;00,78#83
0,7
09$,08
4894144/84/0570.,943$03/23503808
%49,0503808
%
3907089
%
%,
!%
!078,70/,9,
0,7
!$#8
44',:0#8
,709',:0#8
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
32/69
$:22,70/,,3.0$009
843890.02-07
,-908#8394:8,3/
$4:7.0841:3/8
$,704/078:3/
!,/:5.,59,8,7081#80,.#0807;0,3/8:75:8
47740/:3/8
$0.:70/&380.:70/
:77039,-908
88098
74884.
088/0570.,943094.3;08920394,394$&90705489:7703988098
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
33/69
,,3,,7#089,:7,3989/
$:22,70/!89,90203914790,891;00,78#830,7 09$,08 4894144/84/ 0570.,943 $03/23 503808
%49,0503808 % 3907089 % %,
!%
!078,70/,9,
0,7 !$#8
44',:0#8
,709',:0#8
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
34/69
$:22,70/,,3.0$009
843890.02-07
,-
908#8394:8,3/
$4:7.0841:3/8
$,704/078:3/
!,/:5.,59,8,7081#80,.#0807;0,3/8:75:8
47740/:3/84,31742$
:77039,-908
88098
74884.
088/0570.,943094.3;0892039:7703988098
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
35/69
4 8973 94 13/4:990;,:041# 347/07 94/09072300907 98
4799420709#47980:80 90,5574,.94/0907230 90
;,:041#,3/979413/4:990;,:,943418307
,5574,.
3904380941982094/00892,9090170014-5740.943418,08889,90/
0,707$&390,890,78,8743,9,3,;07,07,9041-:9$.,28
90.,33.70,80908,08948.4385.:4:8174290"#08:94190420
743,39,-:73/,9/99440,794,.0;090/0870/8,08749
1742,.6:70/-7,3/8/43/4248/45.,3/$,3170817429089,-041,8,7,
%07014700,88:20#88,084:/702,3,9147890,7843907/
0,7,3/9070,1907$4908,08-0#8#8#8#8
,3/#870850.9;0147900,7,3/
;,,-9417,2,907,8,9.0,507.4898 ,3//:0 94 904507,93011.03.08 ,8
4-807;0/ 3.,8041#0,3.0 3/:89708 9/9#0,3.0!457450308 9/%0.489
4144/884/$ -0 70/:.0/ 94098 ,88:20 99,08420920 147
$&94 70/:.0 98 .489$4$.,3 -0 ,88:20/ 94 -0 3,3/
147,3/9070,1907#0,7/3803,3/,/2305038080307,9,8
-0038003970/:.08390890,78-:9/:0943,-941902070/47,3,94394
.450 :5 9 90 3.70,80 3 90 ;4:20 41 8,08 9 3.70,808 ,3/ 903 9 1,8
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
36/69
/7,2,9.,0570.,943 .,3 -0 0892,90/ 0053 3 23/90 ,39.5,90/.,50 3
0,.0,7. 84190 8,08 ,3/,;07,0 ,33:, /0570.,9437,90 8 89,90/
0,707 /0570.,943 -0 .,.:,90/ - /2383 -,,3.0 2094/ ,9 %:8
/0570.,9431742948
!!
!
!
!
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
37/69
!
%0 3/ 8905 8 94 0892,90 90 .489 41 .,59, $3.0 0 ,70 /0907233#8 ;,:0 90/8.4:397,9084:/ -0#8 ,;07,0 .48941.,59, 4790 0,7
904:989,3/3/0-94190.425,38 ,.8,3/39070895,/,33:2
8#894:8,3/0,88:20072,73,7,904139070898,4390,19079,
-,88%0.48941/0-94:/-0070 8 90 9,
7,90 3.:/3'%,3/$07;.0%,41,55.,-0 174210,88:20
9,990.425,3,8-0035,3,-4:941980,733,3/709,3390701470
570;,3.4894106:9
410**************47%0,;07,0709:734306:9!%%#%%:890.425,387497,9047
%0701470#81:9:700
$&824:39#$309489
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
38/69
90/.4896:90-9
,5574
3.70,803
!708039!07.039,041948,080,7#8394:8,3/
3.70,803
,,3,,7$900&90388
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
39/69
892,94341,8481473091;00,78
!,79.:,78
09$,08
$
$03/235
0570.,943
%49,5
!%
%,
!%
//0570.,943
:3/8742507,943
0883.70,803413098,08
,817424507,943
088,50
09,81494$
!'
!708039',:0
%49,',:041##8!708039;,:041#8#8',:041#88,708#8#8;,:0 088/0-9
%0701470;,:041#88,708
',:05078,70#8#8
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
40/69
%0 2,2:2 57.0 507 8,70 8 5705,70/ 94 5, 147#8 8,70 8 #8
. 8-0490.:770392,70957.0#8:982,70957.05078,70 8#8
8490708,5488-99,92,709;,:041#,843.70,80
4906:08943,7808484:/$13,3.0,.6:894341$&
9.,3-0/430394,809073.,841107470.,30418,708
,841107,.,841107 8 , 897,9147,7/20,3841 13,3.3,207079/408349
.,:80 ,3 /,9,943 3 !$ ,3/ 90 430785 41 90 0893 8,704/078 41 90
,.6:73.425,3$,;0945,#8147,.6:73$&
$,700.,308,700.,30411078708:9394908,73414307854190
,.6:73 .425,3 -09003 98 0893 8,704/078 893 8,704/078 41
#8%00,7338,3/-0301984:/,84-08,70/-0900390809474:5841
8,704/078 %0 570.800903941309 -0301989,9,..7:0 940,.74:5/0503/843
0.,307,9403.,8041#0,3.0/0207074307418,70849$,70841
#0,3.0 307 '039:708 9/ ,3/ 90 0893 8,70 4/078 // 349 ,;0 94
.42574280
%4 5, #8 ,8 98 .:77039 2,709 57.0 507 8,708 #8 90 .425,3 2:89
0.,30 8,708 ,3/ 03.0 5489 207074:/ ,;0
8,708 3 90 .42-30/ 172#8 8,704/078 4:/ 4/ 41 8,708
$4:/ -0411073 8,708 1474:9 89,3/3 8,70841#.
20,38 8,70841 147430 8,70 41# %0 -44;,:0418 ,3/
#88,703870850.9;0#8,3/#8$4174290-44;,:0543941
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
41/69
;0 .4:/ 41107 8,708 147 0,. 4:989,3/3 8,70 41#
94:9/:935708039-44;,:084439,;0,574-021904110741
988,70894#
25,.943!$0983413/4:9 1!$-0/:90/ 1 90.,30/8,708 94
$&8,88:20/0,70709,0900,733841-49901728147900,7147
.425:93!$,190720707
99,44/89/25,.94120707843!$
#8394:8,3/
8!%-0147020707!%,
#8!%12070/9$!,9
!%4190.42-30/17284110720707
!%,!%-!%,-
8!$-0147020707!$,#8
,2:2344188,7082,39,33!$41#8
%,98
84:989,3/38,708-0147020707
,2:23:2-07418,70894-00.,30/94:9/:93!$
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
42/69
%0701470.4:/0.,3041988,7081474308,7041
#94:9/:9398!$,190720707$3.0980.,338,70898
!$,1907207074:/-0,8843-04
!%,-
%49,34418,708,190720707
%0701470!$,-
#80707419#25,.943!%
#
0147020707190720707!%#83
41$,708
!$#8
9;,:0
%49,9,59,,943#83,.
#8#825,.943!7,94%0!7,9441.42-30/1724://0.301742!7,94,8!7,94413/.42-30/1724:/-0:9#,;0,33.70,803!7,94898!7,94
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
43/69
'&$#
$3078902,.,147.09,9,4814703,3.0/.489011.03.08419030
-:83088..,39,0 3 90 147241 70;03:0 03,3.02039 ,3/ .489 8,;38
%01472418307803890/-04
$9,1170/:.9438%48420090392070770/:.08,-47
.43420841 8.,0 0907 9 8 5:7.,83, 82, 89,9430747,.6:73,
-7,3/.434208418.,0.,3-0,.0;0/,3,.434208418.,00594
70/:.0.48941574/:.943
.6:733090.344$30708294..:7-,.6:733090.344
2574;0/ 2,709 70,.08 ,3/ 2,709 8,70 1903 425,308 94 503097,90 3
3007,70,8,.6:70,4.,.425,33/8307.,3-0,.0;0/-90-030198
41902,7093,3//897-:943414.,.425,3
%0704:994-00.434208418.,0 3 90 .42-30/172-:9 32,3.,808
430,3/430,///40834906:,94944930.088,70;0720707708:93
8307 789 41 , 9070 ,8 94 -0 , .:9:7, 19 -09003 90 94 2073
47,3,943,3/903438307.,3-0,.0;0/:994,;0,8307343
7:3,9706:70889,990574/:.947807;.0/0;070/-9047,3,94329
19 90 47,3,943 574/:.9 5479144 7008 $,2,79 $3 41 ,3//
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
44/69
,7093$00,.6:8943,894-0897,90.,19-493 9072841-7,3/,3/
.:9:70 8 ,.6:8943 41 4/073 144/8 1990/ 90 -7,3/ -:9 9070 ,8 34
.:9:7, 19 -09003 90 94 47,3,9438 ..47/3 94 !8 :83088 ,3/
,70938,79.049:89,3-4/50,80:3,-0948:89,3488088
5:993:54/07344/1478,0
490243/4,76:08943,7808494;,:08307$3079,39,24:39
9409.4342.',:0'.,7808174290097,;,:00307,90/-90
.42-30/172
10.438/07900,25041909417282039430/34:70,707.,5907903
0988,',:04190.42-30/17287057080390/-'
',:041'
',:041#'
''''
098,88:20,.6:7357.085,/3.,8
4894120707,85,/'
''4894120707
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
45/69
;,:,943$97,90083
%8/8.:88438-,80/4390572,7/,9,.40.90/,19072009397
3,3/'072,3884.,90'.0!708/03941!3/,!7;,909/!8
,$907,3/-,80/.434207,90.2,3,.98,813,3.,.438:9,39,3/
0;,:,9089013,3.,-03019841207078
",984:/-090.47088:0-0147013,3,20707/0,
384490708348:.,7/,3/17897:09,984:/-0;03.470
25479,3.03,/0,:91000703/,3.47547,90288084:9-
9208,;4/3909,,9435,79%057023,7,3/43041902,3938
.84:/-09,03394,..4:3900;,:,939020707/0,8
9,,943$42092081909,,943/0,80850.,033/,3.425,308
41474-,,.6:89438909,,9433472884:/-0;0390.470
25479,3.0113909,574.0/:704790489.4:397,8,890524907
,999:/09039070834543994.4393:099020707
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
46/69
"4/4084300;,:,9090437:3-030198574;/0/-9020707/0,
3802,31442094/440894/0907230090794207047,9
-03019905740.984394574;/0390437:3%080,70
/8.4:390/.,814
448.425,7,9;0.425,3,3,88
%#$.425,397,38,.943
'309,8809;,:0
390,.6:731728-:3-:8308841909,7091727,907
9,3 , 850.1. ,8809 %0 ,.6:73 172 84:/ ,557,80 20707 ,8 , .,59,
-:/093 /0.843 144390 ,5574,.9 84:/9794 0;,:,90 90
0892,90/8,08,3/,3490784:7.04170;03:00307,943147,90,890,781
90-:8308883499442:..,59,39038;0
%0 2,3 /7,-,.4198 2094/ 8 9,9 9 8 ;07 39738. ,3/ ,94: 9
14.:8083901:9:70;,:0-:9/408399,0394438/07,943 902,709;,:08
3825047/8025,808247043920;,:0412430%4.4:390798
/7,-,.,98:08987084793949574-,-9/897-:943.,3;0
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
47/69
,..:7,90 708:9 %070 ,70 97 00 47 14:7 25479,39 ;,7,-08 480 574-,-9
/897-:943.,30 9003970 ;,:,943412070784 94-0438,108/0 98
-0990794:804190,.6:73.425,3,890!'
448070 90 .425,30843..425,7843 8 /430 84:/ /0, -0 ,
890/.425,3 90 .425,7843 89,798 174270;03:0 0307,90/-90 .425,308
.,705,333942070 9030/0907230%,7338-01470/0-9
3907089,3/9,08-0.,:8090583023,9307747,89/1107039,908-09003
.,80397,3/-440397,81470,250/0570.,943
1907 9,9 9 9,08 394 .438/07,943 90 039075780 ;,:0 47 ' . ,70
8:22,943 41 2,709 .,59, ,3/ 90 -44 ;,:0 41 /0-9 47 3 4907 47/8
8:22,9434110/,88098,3/473.,59,
3.0 90 ' 90 % ,70 /0907230/ 90 309 8905 8 94 .,.:,90 90
2:9508907,948%700-74,/2:9508:80/147;,:,943,70
'$$
'%
#%!%$#!
!%$#
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
48/69
%4 800.9 90 .425,308 147 .425,7843 90 .425,308 ,70 8479 890/
,..47/394.,70.480705708039,9;0410,.490739072841802,709
.,59,,943 ,3/ 574/:.9 5479144 %0 /039., 705708039,9;0 8 .4803 90
4308. ,8 82,7 050703.0 8:-0.9;0 ,3,88 ,3/ 7841 -:83088 90
.425,308,70/0,3909.3041902,3/7,-,.84144889,99
/40839 9,08 394 ,..4:39 90 97,38,.943 5702:2 84 90 309 2094/ 41
;,:,9438:80/
4%7,38,.94347.425,397,38,.943025,8084390,24:393;4;0/
147,.6:7390.425,3%8890720/,8.4894120707%0.439745702:2
1742 94 .70,90 , 89743 ;,7,943 3 90 .489 41 20707 ,8 147
0,250,7:9&/49/0390.425,384/9843078594$::
3
$::,8 945,,:0,24:39,8.425,70/9490,24:39-035,/19,/
,.6:70/0889,3
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
49/69
"33/,33.,9,70902,3,70,8.,;0930882,2:2
,.9;9,3/8050.90/94930882470390.4231:9:70
380989080.947,3/0;0390%,3/!80.94734:7.4:397
/:7390,89/0.,/0/:0944-,,943,3/-07,,94349841%,3/!
80.9478 ,70 02073 %0 708479 94 207078 94 /07;0 90 -03019 411 8470
84:7.3 %8 8 2,3 90 70,843 498 41 4;0780,8 ,.6:8943 89,3 5,.0
70.039 ,8 147 0,2509 703. 1,728 ,3/ 4:9-4:3/ 3;08920398 ,70
9,35,.0 5,79 174298 ,34907 89743249;,931,.947 147 8 78
/;0781.,943 ,3/ 3 98 70,7/ 90 -,33 80.947 ,8 930880/ 498 41
47439,2070780%9
",984:/,2,3,0714.:81789-0147013,3,/0,
38%0430,3/43249;041902,3,0784:/-08948009,98,704/078
39070898349,25070/,9,3.4897,907,/0,84:/-0.43.0730/43
,-4:92,238,704/0780,920,3981742,2,3,078507850.9;0
",91,.9478249;,908.425,308944147
38090249;,943,1,.947/0503/84390804190.425,3,3/070
90,39 94 74 0090790,39 94 74 3 90743 30472070
9490770,90/80.94703.,8041;079.,20707881470,250
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
50/69
.425,308 708479 94 207078 94 503097,90 3 3007 ,70,8 0 3 574
039070/ 3 90 144/ 80203941,1907,.6:7390:.4;9,-7,3/1742
;0303.425,308,39944,-74,/90708479944;0780,8,.6:894380
9,:70,3/!74288,774:53,3,/085407,3/8900
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
51/69
%,9,%0,908903499%090
%8 .,
808 ,3,0
/ 94 /09072
30 4 ,
3 ,.6
:8943
.,3 059
4,.
0;0 9
0
83079,8 -003 24709,3, /0.,/041%,9,%0,%09074:5 03,02039
,3/902,97243834-7038349455479:3908147-4941902%0
80.43/,70898007415,.0990,33/,%,9,90,,83.47547,90/3,3/
94/,,8 089,908 8.,99070/ 3 88,208903,%,2,/: ,3/07,,
%,9,%0,8&-,80/.4,-47,947%09074:5890334;,9474190.43.05941
90,-,,3/-;,:0,3/;4:20,2439094574.07-7,3/83&
,-,.390,054798,870/:.0/,3/90708:9,398:75:8,/34,
49079,3 90/42089.2,709.,889://0/97043,-7,3/8,3/90
5702:2802039,8/423,90/-#8243%,,,-7,3/174290
89,-0413/:89,30;07$:.-039020:%,9,%0,14720/,439;039:70
9%09074:5,3/%090/;843,897,3810770/9490;039:703
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
52/69
%0 0,7 930880/ 90 ,7089 0;074;0780,8 ,.6:8943 - ,3 3/,3
.425,3,8%,9,%0,,.6:70/90%09074:514724354:3/8%88,
,90780/0;039147-4990.425,308,898/0,7010.9890.42394090741
,.425,39;078974343 90,574/:.9438/0,3/904907430;0789743
43902,70938/0
%03094.,8905,89020707419094039908,3/,890,7%,9,%0,9/
2070/904430/8:-8/,7%,9,%090290/99801%8,85,79
4190897,904189703903390%,9,%0,5479144
%0%09074:5,8-003,.,8.4147%,9,%0,,3/9885,5,-03 90
70.039,.6:89434102.,-%,9,%0,.8-031:3/0/-343049079,3
-://%09074:5
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
53/69
#%
47547,90 9,08 5,.0 94 03,3.0 8307 - 2,23 8,704/078
0,940;07419039708:983,/03913,3.,4,190743974:90
.,8089:/,3/70.039,.6:894380%,9,%0,9070.42203/,9438,7089,90/
-04:990.,80,8/0;0450/-,80/4331472,943/07;0/1742!84
13,3., 0;,:,943 ,8 5488-0 43 147 9,9 .,80 47 0;,:,93 4907
897,9008419,87084790/9470.039
;,:,9313,3.,/,9,
%00.4342.,3817429020707414:/.420174290078,08
749,3/ 2574;0/57419,-9/:0 94 90 70/:.943 3 90.4894144/84/
7428 5439 41 ;0 9 84:/ 2070 9# 7,907 2,3 9 ,
8:-8/,7-0.,:80.48970/:.943,3/:390/.422,3/834990703,8:-8/,7
,3/4/370,9434704;07207303,-0,33.70,803!%-#8
147900,703/0/890.02-071742#841890.02-07
,3/!$41#8,190720707%078.,3-0/;07810/944
742#8543941;09020707059029409574.0880/2,907,
,9.0,507.48941574/:.943%0!$4190.425,33.70,80-
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
54/69
%0 2,709 ;,:0 41 # 3.70,80 ,3/ 90 8:5508 41 7, 2,907, 47
390720/,7574/:.9-08,10:,7/0/
;,:,93904907897,9008
471:9:70749-:8308847,3,9438,;0,,87084790/94%88
850., ,55.,-0 3 .,80 41 9090 ,3/ 3/:897:9 ,9 -0.4208
25479,39 8 94800090790,.6:8943 198-4990.425,308%40;,:,90
8:.19430,8 94/490$%,3,8834943174213,3.,5439-:9,84
1742490708943080.:9:7,-7,3/507.05943/42,34174909.
.6:89438,;094-0897,90.,199339072841-49-7,3/,3/.:9:701
9070,70.:9:7,282,9.-09003 9447,3,9438 90334,.6:89438.,3
8:..088 ,3/ 98 -4:3/ 94 ,;0 , 1,:70 ,.9 ,9 ,55030/ 03
,.6:70/4/07344/83/,9908,209204.,4,-03,174290
.4:397 41 &3.0 $,2 944 ,90,89 1;0 0,78 94 2,9. 9 3/,3 -:83088
.:9:70,3/90390,.6:70/%:28&5
34907.47088:09,9,894-0,//70880/89413/4:9,3,/06:,90897,90147
5,390,.6:70/172$49,9-5,308890,.6:70/172/408398:1107
,3/,9908,2090-5,3247090,.6:707/40839,;094-0,790-:7/0341
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
55/69
4;07/0-9.29708:930;07,0574-023901:9:70%885,5,-03
.,8041;;,,.6:73207&$..47/39490.43.05941:7450,3
2-0//0/',:047';;,85,39208'147207&$.8
2:.2470,8.425,70/94'5,/-7,3.08039,.6:70/
39079:7/4384;;,89,3,78,89813,3.,.43/943.
43.43889841-43.,8,850798-,,3.0800943890.02-07
834989743034:
%03,9-0.420825479,398949,0,574507.,59,-:/093/0.843%8
,894-0/430-;07.,701:0892,93905740.90/1700.,8148%03
2:95347097,54,9390790723,;,:047/4384430,894,;0,
974:340/0941470.,89902,709902070/039980390733941907
9090723,;,:0411700.,8148,7034390348941,59,39072841
13,3.39020707/0,,894-013/4:982039430/0,707,3/4304190
4-0.9;0419889:/894/0907230904592:2897,901475,390
,.6:70/1723.090.48941.,59,8/0907230/9039,894-0.43;0790/
3945708039;,:0-2:9539990/8.4:390/1,.94780;3.0/1742
90.,8089:/98,,8,/;.0,-09,990/8.4:3931,.94784:/-090
090/;07,048941,59,4190,.6:70/172
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
56/69
33/,33./0,,.9;9,874394:3570.0/0390/0;0,3/74
0;031:790731:9:7033/,3.47547,9047/425,308207090,.
4907 3 98 9703/ -:9 0307, 43,1 419080 207078,;0 8:..00/0/ 3
,//3;,:0%4,//;,:090,14702039430/70.42203/,943884://:-0
1440/%,9890897,900884:/-00;,:,90/38:.,,9,99-030198
-4990172%0-7,3/193088.:9:7,193088,80,8 9024/0415,2039
84:/-0.7488.0.0/80;07,92089908,20920,9-0.420825479,39
8940;,:,9090/0,1742,59,:/093543941;0%0,24:3994
-0 5,/ 94 909,709 .425,3 147902:89-00;,:,90/-:830
050.90/;,:,9432094/8
3.0 90/0, 8 ,5574;0/, 90,2 ,8 94 -0 14720/9705708039,9;0
.425783 17 42 -49 90 .47547,943 . -0 0,/0/ - 90 .01
31472,943411.07940;,:,9000.:90,3/25020399003970574.088
%0 830708 1742 90 300/ 94 -0 .,7 01: 0892,90/ 3 /1107039
8.03,748-0893472,,3/4789.,80
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
57/69
43.:8438
924709,3,14190/0,1,394/0;07907050.90/708:98,3/
,8507:83088$9,3/,7/8,79.0439::89434:9410;078
.,3-0.430/,88:..0881:$4,.425,7843410;,:,943897,900838
.0397, 9420707 ,3/,.6:8943 /0.8432,3%803,-0090790
94 .425,308 19 940907 3,57,.9., 47 13,3., 80380 ,3/34943 0907
90 .4:/97: .42-30 942,0,409,9,8 70,9079,3 90 8:241 98
5,798
:9-01470/438:..42509943,80,7391742!,9-0.420825479,39
894/03919084:7.0841901728.:77039,3/1:9:70.425099;089703983
490747/894/090723048:89,3,-0,3/:36:0,7090/03910/8970398
%8 03,-0 94 8945 90 14.:8 43 /110703.08 3 90 .425,308 .
0254008220/,9089,79/4343.090/0,825020390/,80/439080
/03910/ 8:89,3,-0 8970398 41 -49 90 47,3,9438 90 8307 ,8 94 -0
0892,90/ ,3/-/4384 .47547,9438.,-,;4/9070,9050.9,9434190
4;0789,90/8307
%0390;,:,94341909,709.425,3894-0/430,3/9034907897,9008
,7094-00;,:,90/3/,8,88:20/0/0;045390.,8089:/90
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
58/69
47,3,943,704507,93-04904592:20;04/83.,804170,
.47547,9047/:09413,3.,47,34907.43897,3934-:8308847,3,943
770850.9;04198804507,90894,34592:20;000;,:,9390
897,900898,894-0.438/070/0.,:804198/7,-,.41349507147233
4592:20;047,3,9438.4208940907944;07.4200,.49078-499030.8
%8883079,08-79,3/8:.83079,08,92094-0,.0;0/%8920
29/0503/843905,7,20907841903,9:7041-:830889880,3/80;07,4907
1,.9478
3.090;,:,94341909,7091728/430903,9-0.420825479,39894
13/4:99024/02415,2039%8.,3-0/430394,84308-.,8
41107,3/9080.43/4308-0.,338,70847,49938,7089490
8,704/0784190,.6:70/.425,3039.4208,492039418,7089,8
94-070202-070/9,9430,894005323/9025,.943!$,1907,90
:92,904-0.9;041,2,3,078942,208,704/0780,9%0390
9,,94388:0,84-0.420825479,39.,..47/39473,3/'072,38
43041902,4770,84381471,:7041/0,894,//;,:0
3904;07,3/,33.8.03,74909090%!80.94733/,
,;0930880/2,2:2-:8308870897:.9:73147900,7
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
59/69
25.,9438
489 41 90 /0,8 3 3/,3 3. ,8 1,0/ 94 ,// ;,:0 -0.,:80 41 349
.43/:.93,574507.425,7,9;00;,:,9434190;,74:8897,90083;4;0/-49
3 57020707 8.03,74 ,3/ 3 5489 20707 8.03,74 070 3/,3 .425,308
288084:9-92083.0.39446:.,3/347390$%,3,8841
49439,9248941902,3,078 14.:839443,77443 90
25,.9 41 207078 3 90 /,94/, 4507,943 41 90 -:83088 9 /01390
.43;.943989,39,24:3994,70.50147/8,8907
:98:..0881:,.6:70789,0,/1107039,5574,.0,-:703 9,.6:70/
,8,7, 90 90890/ , 90 /8.530/57479,943 ,3/ 1:3/,2039, 897,9008
,3/573.50808590-03,3,3.0 9088897,90089,9,70 94-00;,:,90/
.,3349 3470 ,34907.7:., 88:0 .:9:70 ;03 3 4-, .47547,9020: 944
2,320707-4:3/8/43495,00/94 9801,.947. 8842:.
549039, 9,9 9 .,3 2,0 47 -70, ,3 /0, 0 8 ,.6:8943 41
4/073 44/ //3492,9.990 .:9:7041 -499047,3,943 ,3/34
,8 5,38 94 8,04/073 144/ :9:7, /:0 /03.0 .,3 8 , 88902,9.
/0;.0 147 2,3 1,3,9. .4890110.9;0 ,8808820398 41 90 .:9:708 41 -49
,.6:707172,3/909,709172
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
60/69
42-33 94 -:83088 47,3,943 8 , :2:34:8 0, ,3/ 4507,943,
.,030 ,3/ 98 8 070 0;,:,93 , 90 897,9008 3 -0.4208
25479,39%0-08957,.9.04198007.80.,370/:.0 90783;4;03
,70490243/4,76:08943,7808494.42203.090007.8041
.425,7,9;00;,:,943897,90084194380917429,3,.425090
44,9, 90700;,3984:7.0841;,:0,3/78-/090723390;,:04190
9,709172%83.70,80890.,3.0841,8:..0881:,.6:8943
43;03943, 3907,9438,;0 -003:3/079,03 ,8, 20,8:70 94 8,;0
.4898,3/94023,90 70/:3/,3.3 98089430 94/,8,.6:707889,794;07
0892,9390830708$498;0725479,39940;,:,908307,3/903300/
9470,0,8843390.,8089:/99,088420 920 94,.0;090/0870/
8307$4.425,30884:/349:77:594,.0;09006:,94341305:8
302,0897003/900573.50-03/-:3,.425,384:/-0 94
.70,90 8,704/07 ;,:0 ,3/ 349 2070 14.:83 43 4507,943, 8307 %0
2,709 ;,:0 4190 94 .425,308 940907 84:/ -0 2470 ;,:,-09,3 94
805,7,90 .425,308 %0 .,8089:/9,9,8 -003 /8.:880/ 0,707 0;3.08 4
902,7093;,:04190.42-30/172,894-0/0907230/
002498 00543-:382,07 .425,308 94.70,90,2470.425099;0
.425,3 3/ 98 8 5,5,-0 3 90 47/ . ,8 930880/ 90
2,2:2/0,8 41 3/,3 3. 49 43 3 3 4907 /42,3 ,84
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
61/69
.425,308.42094090745394,3,70,9072,7098,704794,.0;0
70,907011.03.3/9829708:93243454..,3,110.9904;07,
0.4342
1903,-4423894.2,70903.4:7,08207078..,3.70,90 974:-0 147
90.4:39780.43420,8/43097,90/894.80,8,3/.0,5-:9
9070834574507897,90.933-03/9
34;07,,1907 /0;045390 03970 9088 90 25.,9438 ,70 90/0,
2:89 /0;07 90 439072 749 ,3/ 8:89,30/ 57 419,-9 3/ 025,88
84:/-04349094.425,308199409073,57,.9.,4713,3.,80380
7,9079,343090790.4:/97:.42-30942,0,409,9,870,907
9,3908:241985,798
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
62/69
-47,5
79.0-!74108847$,3/005
79.08 - 7 ,,03/: $, 3,3.0 ,.:99,
&3;0789
79.08-!7418,9,24/,7,3:7:41',:,943
:83088$9,3/,7/,32,77,08479::89
:83088,3/.43429:309:
!8:83088,3/,70939::899::89
13,3.0#0,/070-
3,3.,,3,02039-!741!,3/0
07.,39,33-!741,3
!:-.#00,808-%
890733:0/:
8 3 ,33 3/:897 944 147 425099;03088 -
$!#'99,
3/,31430.42
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
63/69
5503/.08
$34588
0,9:84743:889070.03984,34194/,8.47547,9047/.8
107.0.425099;0%8.425099435,7,/4.,;0878094970,98.7488
170,3/97,/07;,7.5,;0890,1478.3088,3/.48:7041.47547,90
039075780$42,3.47547,9047,3,9438,70708479394-:8308870897:.9:73
390147241207078,3/,.6:8943
40;07.425,308-0147043147207078479,04;07/4007.80,3
0;,:,9;0897,90147905740.9%0800;,:,9;0897,9008,;094-0;07
1703/,3/3494890-0.,:80:308898,3389:,943147-495,793078
3420707847,.6:8943.,39,05,.0
07078,3/9,04;078,70249;,90/,3/3049,90/-,80/4390800;,:,943
897,900884430.,334934709025479,3.0410;,:,943897,9008307078
,3/.6:8943&308898,48909,04;0790,.6:707.425,384:/
144,5745070;,:,943897,90147;,:3909,709.425,3
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
64/69
%04;0732039,84,8,54.948,10:,7/903907089418,704/078,3/
3;089478-0147043147,20707$4900;,:,9432094/:80/307078,3/
.6:894389,894005323/9,9984:/-0,3389:,943147-49
905,790843430,3/,3/,9904907,3/984:/-0349,,38990390708941
8,704/078,3/3;089478
%890888,3,9902599413/4:9900;,:,9;0897,9008:80/-.425,3083
207078,3/,.6:8943,3/.425,73902-,80/43907,-9941:190
5,7,2090782039430/,-4;0
!1,.:9202-07!74108847#,2,783,4:/:/0,3/,888920390
9088%07080,7.2094/444:/.42203.01742.40.93/,9,-49
1742572,7,3/80.43/,784:7.081440/-,33/059,3,8841.40.90/
/,9,
$,72,
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
65/69
%088#0854380$009
O ,2093$,72,
O :2-07
O %90 41 90 $9:/ 425,7,9;0 ;,:,943 $97,9008 3 07078 ,3/
.6:89438
O ,900390:/0,8.438:90/
O %04:9.4204190/8.:8843
%0 1472,9/,9,.40.9432094/84:7.08 147 .40.93572,7/,9,
,8 /0907230/ 0 ,84,/,/8.:8843 41 90 574-028 9,9 2, 4..:7
00;,:,9390897,90083
O %0!7470884190%088
4944;07.420 90,14702039430/574-02,8/0907230/ ,3/
4;07,904-0.9;04127080,7.,85,5,-089,-80/
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
66/69
%088#0854380$009
O ,2093$,72,
O :2-07
O %90 41 90 $9:/ 425,7,9;0 ;,:,943 $97,9008 3 07078 ,3/
.6:89438
O ,900390:/0,8.438:90/
O %04:9.4204190/8.:8843
%02,3574-02,3/.470,70,894-014.:80/0;,:,9434190172
,3/8307,8/0907230/
%088#0854380$009
O ,2093$,72,
O :2-07
O %90 41 90 $9:/ 425,7,9;0 ;,:,943 $97,9008 3 07078 ,3/
.6:89438
O ,900390:/0,8.438:90/
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
67/69
O %04:9.4204190/8.:8843
$420.,308,702,/0390.,8089:/,3/9070.42203/,9435,79,8
/8.:880/
O %0!7470884190%088
%0574-025,79,8.425090/
%088#0854380$009
O ,2093$,72,
O :2-07
O %90 41 90 $9:/ 425,7,9;0 ;,:,943 $97,9008 3 07078 ,3/
.6:89438
O ,900390:/0,8.438:90/
O %04:9.4204190/8.:8843
%070.42203/,9435,79,8.,30/03970,3/2:/0//8420
;,:0,//943949
O %0!7470884190%088
%070.42203/,9435,79,8.425090/
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
68/69
%088#0854380$009
O ,2093$,72,
O :2-07
O %90 41 90 $9:/ 425,7,9;0 ;,:,943 $97,9008 3 07078 ,3/
.6:89438
O ,900390:/0,8.438:90/
O %0!7470884190%088
3/41909088
-
8/3/2019 Comparative Evaluation Strategies in Mergers and Acquisitions
69/69
":089433,708
,984:/-090.47088:0-0147013,3,20707/0,
4/4084300;,:,9090437:3-030198574;/0/-9020707/0,
3 3/,3 3. ,9 ,70 90 2,3 ,70,8 . ,;0 93088 2,2:2
,.9;9,3/8050.90/94930882470390.4231:9:70
,984:/,2,3,0714.:81789-0147013,3,3/0,
,91,.9478249;,908.425,308944147
4 ,70 90 897,9008 147 94 -0 0;,:,90/