concept note ieg learning product on maximizing...

1

Concept Note

IEG Learning Product on Maximizing Development Impact in IDA

May 27, 2015

Background and Context

1. The International Development Association (IDA) is the World Bank Group’s (WBG)

fund for the poorest countries. It is replenished every three years by contributions from the

governments of the richer member countries, repayments of IDA credits, and contributions from

the International Bank for Reconstruction and Development (IBRD) and the International

Finance Corporation (IFC).

2. The sixteenth IDA replenishment (IDA16) covered the FY12-14 period. The discussions

for the seventeenth replenishment (IDA17) covering FY15-17 were completed in December

2013 and the final report (the IDA17 Replenishment Report)1 was approved by the Executive

Directors of IDA on March 25, 2014. Early in this period Bank management will deliver its

IDA16 Retrospective (expected to be completed in June 2015), with a subsequent IDA17 mid-

term review half-way through the implementation period. A meeting of the IDA Deputies that is

now planned for March 2016 will review the progress in IDA 17 implementation and also be the

first replenishment meeting for IDA18. As set out in the IEG FY15-17 work program and budget

document2 IEG will also make available, for this meeting, a synthesis (“the Product”) which

brings together findings from recent IEG evaluations pertinent to the core themes of IDA 17.

Product Concept and Purpose

3. Numerous IEG evaluations address issues that are relevant to IDA’s development impact.

With the aim of helping to inform the discussions for the IDA18 replenishment, the planned

report will use a desk exercise to bring such issues together by compiling and synthesizing

relevant evaluation evidence from recently completed IEG evaluations and those expected to be

completed in FY15 and early FY16. This synthesis report will, in this manner, compile and

present such IEG evaluation findings that are relevant for IDA or IDA countries, with particular

attention to the special themes under IDA16 and 17 (para 6 below). It will not be an evaluation

of IDA performance, it will not report on IDA progress or on replenishment commitments, and

will not make recommendations on IDA policy issues (such as graduation criteria as one

example). The preparation of the product will be based on desk work without new field work or

new analyses, except for an updated portfolio analysis.

1 Report from the Executive Directors of the International Development Association to the Board of Governors. Additions to IDA Resources: Seventeenth Replenishment. IDA17: Maximizing Development Impact. Approved by the IDA Executive Directors on March 25, 2014. 2 Independent Evaluation Group, Work Program and Budget (FY15) and Indicative Plan (FY16-17), June 2, 2014.

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

wb350881

Typewritten Text

97626

2

Rationale and Objective

4. IEG’s independent evaluations focus primarily on specific issues of development

effectiveness and provide insight into what works and on strengths and weaknesses of current

approaches. Each individual evaluation addresses specific sets of topics across types of clients

and country circumstances, often covering IDA countries as part of a wider spectrum of Bank

country partners. In contrast, the IEG learning products synthesize and disseminate IEG

evaluation work. The planned synthesis product will in this vein consider the various available

evaluation findings through the IDA lens by drawing from the available individual evaluations

such specific findings, lessons and conclusions on development effectiveness that are directly

applicable for current IDA clients and in particular for the key topics of IDA16 and 17. These

findings will be identified and set in context with attention to connectivities in a concise, reader-

friendly format, with special attention to forward-looking aspects. The synthesis product will be

of direct relevance for the preparations and discussions regarding the forthcoming IDA18

replenishment discussions.

Scope and Key Questions

5. As part of the analysis of issues concerning IDA’s development impact, the synthesis will

address the special themes for the most recent IDA replenishments (IDA 16 and 17), look at

relevant measurements for recent country level performance, and identify drivers of IDA results.

It will to this end draw on findings from relevant recent and ongoing evaluations in IEG’s work

program, for the latter to the extent that their results will in time become available, shared with

the Bank Group Management and presented to CODE. To the extent that evaluative evidence

allows, the synthesis product will cover World Bank Group activities in IDA countries, including

cooperation between the three institutions of World Bank, IFC and MIGA.

6. The overarching theme for IDA17 is “Maximizing Development Impact” and for IDA16

the closely related “Delivering Development Results.” Within these overall headings there was

high continuity of special themes between IDA16 and IDA17, which indicates that these areas

also will be important for IDA going forward. Three of the four themes were unchanged

(although with some differences in formulations): Gender Equality, Climate Change, and Fragile

and Conflict-Affected States. In addition under IDA16 a special theme was Crisis Response, and

under IDA17 Inclusive Growth. The product will seek to address all five of these special

themes. 3

3 For crisis response this will be based on three already completed evaluations (two on response to the financial crisis and one on food crisis).

3

7. The IDA17 replenishment document also focused on leveraging private resources,

leveraging public resources, leveraging knowledge, and IDA’s focus on results, efficiency, and

effectiveness. Where relevant and possible, the product will also touch on some of these aspects.

8. The product will assemble evaluation findings from recently completed evaluations,

relevant follow-up information from the Management Action Record and evaluations expected to

be completed in FY15 and early FY16 relevant to the IDA special themes. Specifically, the

synthesis will bring together findings from thematic, country program, and project performance

evaluations to identify – as possible based on the available evaluative evidence – aspects that

have worked well or not worked so well and why, interconnections between themes, instruments

and approaches, and relations between Bank programs, country counterparts, and development

partners. It will broadly seek to answer the following questions under each theme:

How has IDA addressed these themes in IDA countries through its country programs and

individual operations?

What factors have affected IDA development results at country level in general and

pertaining to inclusive growth, climate change, and gender equality in particular?

How effectively has IDA followed up on its commitments to strengthen its engagement

in fragile and conflict affected states?

What cross-cutting lessons emerge from IEG evaluations to help IDA maximize

development impact?

9. IDA Portfolio. IEG annually updates every year the aggregate numbers for the

performance of the Bank’s portfolio of completed projects and country programs. There was a

deterioration in the portfolio performance in IDA countries in FY11-13 compare to FY08-10.

These findings regarding the performance of country programs and projects for IDA countries

will be updated to the end of FY15, with selective analytical cuts to elaborate on some of the

performance and portfolio trends. The team will also consider whether the available evaluative

evidence would permit any discussion on regional IDA programs. On the assumptions that the

IDA deputies will receive a comprehensive and detailed portfolio and performance analysis of

IDA countries from IDA team in operations, IEG will not go into as much depth in this section.

It will confine itself to an update on the aggregate numbers that IEG normally reports in the

RAP, using IEG validated data with some selected regional or sectoral disaggregation where

appropriate and useful).

10. Previous IEG Evaluations of IDA. IEG has previously undertaken two major evaluations

that were requested from the IDA Deputies: Evaluation of IDA10, 11 and 12 (completed around

2002), and the evaluation of IDA’s internal controls (completed around 2009, with a subsequent

evaluation around 2010 of management’s remediation program), both of which were funded through

special additional, non-fungible budget allocations. The synthesis product will remind readers of these

4

two exercises and their major findings, also to provide some “historical” perspective to IEG’s

engagement with IDA issues.

Evaluative Sources4

11. Country Programs: IDA programs are implemented using a country-based

development model, and the synthesis product will review the performance and draw lessons

from evaluations and validations of country programs in IDA countries. Also, IDA17 documents

expected that in designing Country Partnership Frameworks for IDA countries, attention would

be given to the overarching and special themes. For that reason, the product will address the

evolving country partnership frameworks and in particular their inclusion of the special themes,

and will draw lessons from IEG’s country program evaluations relevant to IDA agenda.

12. IEG has produced eight country program evaluations for IDA countries since FY08, and

another three have been completed as part of clustered evaluations. The FY15 Clustered Country

Program Evaluation on Resource-Rich Countries (11) is assessing WBG support for helping

countries manage the fiscal challenges of natural resource rents while ensuring broad-based

sharing of benefits. The product will review these country program evaluations as well as the

IEG validations of country strategies through FY15 and early FY16 with a view to identify

supplementary findings and trends. The focus of this discussion is likely to be more on what

works and why, and less on numerical portfolio trends.

13. Inclusive Growth. Several recently completed and ongoing FY15 evaluations focus on

certain aspects of inclusive growth and will be analyzed to see how poverty focused IDA country

programs have been, how specifically how specifically IDA country programs aimed to reach the

poor and how effectively they have done so, including what role Bank interventions to enhance

access to finance and youth employment have been and what factors explain success and

failures. Specifically the product will draw on the following thematic evaluations

FY13 Youth Employment took stock of international experience and evaluated the relevance

and effectiveness of WBG support for youth employment, including in IDA countries.

4 Attachment 2 lists the available and planned evaluative sources for this product. They cover a wide range of topics, but some unevenness of treatment may inevitably occur depending on the amount of relevant material that will be available for different topics and themes. The IEG sources will provide the bulk of the material for the product, but some other materials, such as management learning reviews, may be also consulted selectively. The numbers shown for convenience in parentheses above for each evaluation refer to the numbered evaluations in Attachment 2. Attachment 3 shows available country program evaluations (CPEs) and Attachment 4a completed and planned project performance assessment reports (PPARs) – these are summarized in Attachment 4b. This is a synthesis of evaluation findings regarding issues and development effectiveness (pertaining to IDA’s issues of focus), which normally do not change quickly over time, and not an evaluation of IDA results over any specific period. For that reason the synthesis will be somewhat flexible how far back it finds it appropriate to go, based on the likely continued relevance going forward of the evaluation findings.

5

FY14 Targeted Support for Small and Medium Enterprises (2) looked at how effectively

WBG support to SMEs has been integrated into the larger thinking on inclusive growth

and job creation.

FY15 Getting to Poverty (10) aims to understand how the Bank designs and implements

country programs to contribute to poverty reduction, with a focus on the adequacy of data

and diagnostics, integration of analytical work into country strategies and selection of

interventions, and effectiveness of feedback loops.

FY15 Inclusive Finance (7) assesses the effectiveness of WBG support to promote

financial inclusion, which is a critical pillar of the inclusive growth theme in IDA17.

14. Gender Equality. Several recent, ongoing and forthcoming IEG evaluations focus inter

alia on gender equality and will be drawn on to assess how effectively IDA has addressed gender

equality in its programs and operations and what lessons emerge to ensure IDA can effectively

support gender equality going forward. Specifically, the product will draw on the following

evaluations: FY14 Gender in Sectors: Social Safety Nets and Gender Equality (6); WBG Support

to FCS Evaluation (1); Investment Climate Reform (5); FY15 Electricity Access (16);

Inclusive Finance (7); and Early Childhood Development (12). The team will explore to what

extent early findings from the gender equality chapter of the Results and Performance (RAP)

2015 can be integrated (the one-stop review of the report is scheduled for October 2015).

15. Climate change. IEG has completed three major evaluations over the past five years on

climate change5 which the IDA synthesis will draw on to the extent that findings remain relevant.

Many of the major sectoral and country evaluations in the IEG program have strong coverage of

climate change-related issues. For example, Electricity Access (16) has looked at the uptake of

renewable energy in rural (off-grid) areas. IEG also chaired recently an Evaluation Oversight

Committee for a special evaluation of the Climate Investment Funds (CIF) for the CIF governing

bodies, Independent Evaluation of the Climate Investment Funds, June 2014. Findings from

these evaluations will be combined with a review of relevant PPARs (Project Performance

Assessment Reports) and Country Program Evaluations to see how effectively IDA helps its

client countries prepare for, and tackle climate change risks, and what lessons emerge to help

IDA assist the poorest and most vulnerable countries with climate change adaptation and

mitigation going forward.

16. Fragile and Conflict-Affected States (FCSs). IEG shared the early findings from its

FY14 WBG Support to FCS Evaluation (1) with the IDA Deputies during the IDA17

replenishment process. The implementation of WBG management’s response to the

5 FY13 Adapting to Climate Change: Assessing World Bank Experience; FY10 The Challenge of Low-Carbon Development: Climate Change and the World Bank Group; and FY09 Climate Change and World Bank Group: Win-Win Energy Policy Reforms.

6

recommendations of the IEG evaluation is one of the IDA17 policy commitments. The synthesis

products will summarize the key findings of FCS evaluation and will follow up the

implementation progress of its recommendations, drawing on MAR reports.

17. Project Level Evaluations. The Product will update from RAP2013 and RAP2014 (8)

summarized findings from project level evaluations for IDA countries, most importantly levels

and trends for project ratings, and also including applicable lessons from relevant Project

Performance Assessment Reports (PPARs), as well as the findings of FY14-15 Learning and

Results in WBG Operations (13). This will provide an overview of what has worked and what

has not worked and why. Attachment 4(a) lists relevant recent and ongoing/planned PPARs.

Audience

18. The main audience for this synthesis product will be World Bank Board members (and

specifically CODE) and IDA Deputies. Bank senior management, which is implementing the

IDA program, and client country stakeholders, who would stand to benefit from the appropriate

implementation of the limited IDA resources. Generally, the synthesis should also be useful for

individual program task teams and task team leaders engaged in the identification, preparation,

or supervision of IDA operations.

Quality Assurance and Team

19. The evaluation will be overseen by Nick York, Director, IEGCC and Geeta Batra,

Manager, IEGCC. Peer reviewers are Johannes Linn (former Vice President for ECA Region)

and Henock Kifle (former Chief Economist for African Development Bank and Permanent

Secretary of the Ministry of Agriculture in Ethiopia). The synthesis product will be written by

a small team led by Ismail Arslan, including Monika Huppi, Nils Fostvedt , Xue Li and Kendra

Diane White (focus on economic and portfolio analysis). The team would be supplemented by

additional IEG staff and consultants as needed.

Timeline

20. This product is expected to be produced based on existing evaluative evidence and other

relevant material available, with no mission travel. The synthesis report had originally been timed

for delivery in FY17, but has been brought forward to FY16 to ensure that it will be timely for the

IDA18 discussions. To ensure that the report is useful to the Board, IDA Deputies, and World Bank

Management, , it will be finalized by February 2016, in line with the timing of the planned first

replenishment meeting for IDA18 in March 2016. The timing of this delivery is of essence and will be

maintained even if some of the planned evaluation inputs (discussed earlier in this note) should be

delayed. Even so, it is of vital importance for this tight deadline that the team for this report will have

free and early access to the relevant evaluative material as this would become available, including

drafts of background papers and country case study reports.

7

21. As a synthesis of other evaluative material it is expected that the product will provide findings

and lessons but will not include recommendations.

22. The report will be finalized and shared with the Board through CODE in March 2016, in

line with making the report available to IDA Deputies in time for their first replenishment meeting for

IDA18 in March 2016.

8

Attachment 1: References

IEG (Independent Evaluation Group). 2013. World Bank Group Assistance to Low-Income Fragile and Conflict-Affected States. Washington, DC: World Bank.

____. 2014. The Big Business of Small Enterprises: Evaluation of the World Bank Group Experience with Targeted Support to SMEs, 2006–12. Washington, DC: World Bank.

____. 2014. Learning and Results in World Bank Operations: How the Bank Learns. Evaluation 1. Washington, DC: World Bank.

____. 2014. World Bank Group Support to Health Financing. Washington, DC: World Bank.

____. 2014. Investment Climate Reforms. An Independent Evaluation of World Bank Group Support to Reforms of Business Regulations. Washington, DC: World Bank.

____. 2014. Social Safety Nets and Gender Learning From Impact Evaluations and

World Bank Projects. Washington, DC: World Bank.

____. 2014. Results and Performance of the World Bank Group 2014. Achieving the MDGs. An Independent Evaluation. Washington, DC: World Bank.

____. 2014. Investments in Renewable Energy Generation. IEG Learning Product. Washington, DC: World Bank

____. 2015. Financial Inclusion – A Foothold on the Ladder Toward Prosperity? An IEG Evaluation of World Bank Group Support for Financial Inclusion for Low-Income Households and Microenterprises. Washington, DC: World Bank (forthcoming).

____. 2015. The Poverty Focus of Country Programs: Lessons from World Bank Experience. Washington, DC: World Bank (forthcoming).

____. 2015. World Bank Group Engagement in Resource- Rich Developing Countries: The Cases of Bolivia, Kazakhstan, Mongolia, and Zambia. Clustered Country Program Evaluation Synthesis Report. Washington, DC: World Bank (forthcoming).

____. 2015. World Bank Support to Early Childhood Development. Washington, DC: World Bank (forthcoming).

____. 2015. Learning and Results in World Bank Operations: How the Bank Learns. Evaluation 2. Washington, DC: World Bank (forthcoming).

____. 2015. Review of DPO Instruments. Washington, DC: World Bank (forthcoming).

____. 2015. WBG Transformational Engagements. Washington, DC: World Bank (forthcoming).

____. 2015. World Bank Group Support to Electricity Access FY2000-FY2014. Washington, DC: World Bank (forthcoming).

9

Attachment 2: Selected Delivered and Planned Evaluation Products, FY14-16

N. Evaluation Evaluation type

Report

One-Stop Report

Submission

CODE SC

Meeting

1 WBG Support to FCS Major Evaluations 15-Aug-13 27-Sep-13 21-Oct-13

2 Targeted Support for SMEs Major Evaluations 25-Sep-13 23-Dec-13 29-Jan-14

3 Support to Health Financing Major Evaluations 23-Jan-14 23-May-14 18-Jun-14

4 Learning and Results in World Bank Operations - Phase I Major Evaluations 18-Feb-14 31-Mar-14 12-May-14

5 Investment Climate Reform Major Evaluations 31-Mar-14 27-Jun-14 21-Jul-14

6 Gender in Sectors: Social Safety Nets and Gender Equality Other 8-May-14 30-Jun-14

7 Inclusive Finance Major Evaluations 26-Feb-14 5-Jun-15 FY16 Q1

8 RAP 2014: Achieving the MDGs Major Evaluations 3-Nov-14 4-Feb-15

9 Renewable Energy Other 17-Nov-14 30-Dec-14

10 Getting to Poverty Major Evaluations 18-Nov-14 5-Mar-15 FY15 Q3 or

Q4

11 Clustered CPE on Resource-Rich Countries Major Evaluations 16-Dec-14 19-Mar-15 FY15 Q3

12 WBG Support to Early Childhood Development Major Evaluations 7-Jan-15 30-Mar-15 FY15 Q4

13 Learning and Results in World Bank Operations - Phase II Major Evaluations 13-Jan-15 31-Mar-15 FY15 Q4

14 Review of Instruments: DPO (5 notes) Other 16-Mar-15 10-Apr-15

15 WBG Transformational Engagements Other 9-Apr-15 29-Jun-15

16 Electricity Access Other 25-Feb-15 8-Apr-15

17 WBG Support Fragile Situations in Non-FCS Countries Major Evaluations

10

Attachment 3: Delivered and Planned Country Program Evaluations from IDA and Blend countries, FY09-16

Delivery FY Country Region

Lending

Category

2008 Cambodia EAP IDA

2009 Uganda AFR IDA

2009 Bangladesh SAR IDA

2009 Nepal SAR IDA

2010 Mozambique AFR IDA

2011 Timor-Leste EAP Blend

2012 Liberia AFR IDA

2012 Afghanistan SAR IDA

2015 Mongolia * ECA Blend

2015 Bolivia * LCR Blend

2015 Zambia * AFR IDA

Notes: * Country/Regional Program Evaluation to be produced as part of the Resource-Rich Cluster Evaluation.

11

Attachment 4a: Projects from IDA and Blend countries reviewed by completed and planned PPARs, FY12-15

N. Evaluation

FY

Lending

category Region Country Project Name

1 2012 IDA AFR Burundi BI - Food Crisis Response DP Grant - P113438

2 2012 - LCR Caribbean GEF 6R-CRB PLANNING FOR ADAPT CLIM CHANG -

P040739

3 2012 - LCR Caribbean GEF MACC 6R Mainstreaming Adapt to Clima - P073389

4 2012 IDA AFR Congo, DRC DRC Econ Recovery Credit SAL (FY02) - P057293

5 2012 IDA AFR Congo, DRC DRC - POST-REUNIFICATION - ERC - P082443

6 2012 IDA MNA Djibouti Djibouti - Food Crisis Response Dev. - P112017

7 2012 - EAP Mekong 4M-MEKONG WATER UTILIZ. - P045864

8 2012 IDA AFR Mozambique MZ-Roads & Bridges MMP (FY02) - P001785

9 2012 IDA AFR Mozambique MZ-Railway & Port Restr (FY00) - P042039

10 2012 Blend SAR Pakistan BSRPP - P055292

11 2012 Blend SAR Pakistan PK Banking Sector Dev. Policy Credit - P083079

12 2012 Blend AFR Republic of

Congo Congo Rep -Post Conflict - Econ. Rehab - P073316

13 2012 Blend AFR Republic of

Congo CG-Econ Recovery Credit ERL (FY05) - P083627

14 2012 Blend EAP Vietnam VN - MEKONG DELTA WATER - P004845

15 2012 Blend EAP Vietnam VN-3 CITIES SANITATION - P051553

16 2013 IDA SAR Afghanistan AF - Programmatic Support for Inst. Bldg - P078618

17 2013 IDA SAR Afghanistan AF Program. Support for Inst. Bldg II - P090829

18 2013 IDA SAR Afghanistan Program. Support for Inst. Bldg III - P102709

19 2013 IDA SAR Afghanistan Afg Strengthening Institutions DPG - P107921

20 2013 IDA AFR Gambia GM-Gateway SIL (FY02) - P057394

21 2013 IDA AFR Ghana GH Land Administration (FY04) - P071157

22 2013 IDA AFR Malawi MW-Com Based Rural Land Dev (FY04) - P075247

23 2013 IDA SAR Nepal NP: Avian Flu - P100342

24 2013 Blend AFR Nigeria Avian Influenza Emergency ERL (FY06) - P100122

25 2013 IDA AFR Sierra Leone SL-Natl Soc Action (FY03) - P079335

26 2013 IDA AFR Sierra Leone SL-DPL-FOOD CRISIS RESPONSE - P113219

27 2013 Blend SAR Sri Lanka Relevance and Quality of Undergrad. Educ - P050741

28 2013 Blend SAR Sri Lanka LK: Education Sector Development Project - P084580

29 2013 IDA ECA Tajikistan AVIAN FLU - TJ - P100451

30 2013 IDA AFR Tanzania TZ-PRSC 1 (first) - P074072

31 2013 IDA AFR Tanzania TZ-PRSC2 (intermediate) - P074073

32 2013 IDA AFR Tanzania TZ-PRSC 3 (last) - P087256

33 2013 IDA AFR Tanzania TZ-PRSC 4 DPL (1st of 2nd series) - P095509

34 2013 IDA AFR Tanzania TZ-PRSC 5 (2nd of 2nd series) - P095657

35 2013 IDA AFR Tanzania TZ-PRSC 6 (3rd of 2nd series) - P101229

36 2013 IDA AFR Tanzania TZ-PRSC 7 (4th in 2nd series) - P101230

37 2013 IDA AFR Tanzania TZ-PRSC 8 (5th and last in 2nd series) - P116666

38 2014 IDA SAR Bangladesh Primary Education Development Project II

39 2014 IDA SAR Bangladesh Health, Nutrition, and Population Sector Program

12

N. Evaluation

FY

Lending


40 2014 IDA SAR Bangladesh Rural Electricity and Renewable Energy Development Project

(P071794) (RERED)

41 2014 IDA SAR Bangladesh Power Sector Development Technical Assistance Project

(P78707

42 2014 IDA SAR Bangladesh Power Sector Development Policy Loan (P107797)

43 2014 IDA AFR Ethiopia Ethiopia Protection of Basic Services

44 2014 IDA AFR Ghana Trade Gateway & Investment Project

45 2014 IDA AFR Ghana Rural Finance Services SIL

46 2014 IDA AFR Ghana First Natural Resource and Environmental Governance

Projects (IDA-44260, IDA-46270, IDA-47460)

47 2014 IDA AFR Ghana Second Natural Resource and Environmental Governance


48 2014 IDA AFR Ghana Third Natural Resource and Environmental Governance


49 2014 IDA EAP Laos Second Land Titling Project (P132897)

50 2014 IDA AFR Mozambique Decentralization Planning & Fin SIL

51 2014 IDA AFR Mozambique Enterprise Development

52 2014 IDA AFR Mozambique Public Sector Reform Project

53 2014 Blend AFR Nigeria Nigeria State Education Sector Project

54 2014 Blend AFR Nigeria Nigeria Community Based Poverty Reduction Project

55 2014 Blend AFR Nigeria Fadama II

56 2014 IDA AFR Senegal Energy Sector Recovery Development Policy

57 2014 IDA AFR Senegal Electricity Sector Efficiency - Phase 1 - Apl 1

58 2014 Blend SAR Sri Lanka Renewable Energy for Rural Economic Dev. Proj. (P077761)

59 2014 Blend LCR St. Lucia Economic and Social Development Loan

60 2014 IDA AFR Tanzania Public Sector Reform

61 2014 IDA AFR Uganda Local Governance Development 2

62 2014 Blend EAP Vietnam Transmission, Dist., and Disaster Recon. Proj. (P045628)

63 2014 Blend EAP Vietnam Systems Energy Equitization

64 2014 Blend EAP Vietnam Rural Energy Proj. (P056452)

65 2015 IDA SAR Afghanistan AAA PAR on Public Expenditure and Fiduciary Aspects

66 2015 IDA SAR Afghanistan AAA PAR on Public Administration and Governance

67 2015 IDA SAR Afghanistan AAA PAR on Health

68 2015 IDA SAR Afghanistan AAA PAR on ICTs

69 2015 IDA SAR Afghanistan AAA PAR on Microfinance

70 2015 IDA SAR Afghanistan PAR on Business Development

71 2015 IDA EAP Laos Poverty Reduction Fund (P077326)

72 2015 IDA SAR Nepal Nepal Education for All

73 2015 IDA LCR Nicaragua Education Project (P078990)

74 2015 Blend SAR Pakistan Pakistan Sindh Educ. Sector Proj. (P107300)

75 2015 Blend SAR Pakistan Punjab Education Sector Proj. (P102608)

76 2015 IDA AFR Rwanda Decentralization & Community Development

77 2015 IDA AFR Senegal Senegal Long Term Water Sector Project P041528

78 2015 IDA AFR Senegal Supporting Access To On-site Sanitation P102478

79 2015 IDA AFR Senegal Integrated Marine and Coastal Res. Management project

(P086480)

80 2015 IDA AFR Senegal Sustainable management of fish resources (P105881)

81 2015 Blend SAR Sri Lanka Sri Lanka Cluster - Gemi Dirlya I (P074872)

13

N. Evaluation

FY

Lending


82 2015 Blend SAR Sri Lanka Sri Lanka Cluster - North-East Irrigated Agric. (P058070)

83 2015 IDA AFR Tanzania Tanzania Government Support Project (P070736)

84 2015 IDA AFR Uganda Uganda DPO - 2 PRSC series (PRSCs 5- 7 and 8 - 9) + 1

financial DPO (truncated series)

85 2015 IDA AFR Uganda Millennium Science Initiative

86 2015 Blend ECA Uzbekistan Uzbekistan Rural Water Supply and Sanitation Project

(P009121)

87 2015 Blend ECA Uzbekistan Bukhara & Samarkand Water Supply Proj. (P049621)

88 2015 Blend EAP Vietnam Second Rural Finance Project (P072601)

89 2015 Blend EAP Vietnam Third Rural Finance Project (P100916)

90 2015 Blend EAP Vietnam 2nd Higher Education Project

91 2015 Blend EAP Vietnam Vietnam Poverty Reduction Support Credit 6 P101724





96 2015 Blend EAP Vietnam VN-Public Investment Reform 1 P117723

97 2015 Blend EAP Vietnam VN-Public Investment Reform 2 P120946

98 2015 Blend EAP Vietnam VN - Program 135 Phase 2 Support Credit P104097

99 2015 Blend EAP Vietnam Second Program 135 Phase 2 Support P107062

100 2015 Blend EAP Vietnam Third Program 135 Phase 2 Development Policy Support

Operation P117610

14

Attachment 4b: Summary of Projects from IDA and Blend countries reviewed by completed and planned PPARS, FY12-15

Regions

Evaluation Fiscal Year

2012-2015 2012 2013 2014 2015*

AFR 7 14 16 8 45

EAP 3 4 14 21

ECA 1 2 3

LCR 2 1 1 4

MNA 1 1

SAR 2 7 6 11 26

Total 15 22 27 36 100

* Planned deliveries

concept note ieg learning product on maximizing...

Documents