concrete pavements surface characteristics program a … · concrete pavements surface...
TRANSCRIPT
1
Concrete PavementsSurface Characteristics Program
A Link to Two-Lift Concrete Paving
Robert Rasmussen, Ph.D., P.E.Ted Ferragut, P.E.Paul Wiegand, P.E.Dale Harrington, P.E.Tom Cackler, P.E.
StructuralFaulting, fatigue cracking
MaterialASR, D-cracking
Functional (Surface Characteristics)FrictionNoiseSmoothnessSplash & Spray...
Performance
2
Surface Characteristics
Understand and Control Texture:
Geometry
Texture: Tining
3
Texture: Drag
Texture: Diamond Grinding
4
Texture: Exposed Aggregate
Surface Characteristics
Understand and Control Texture:
Geometry and Durability
5
Age
Func
tion
(Noi
se)
Mix Change
Surface Characteristics
For the same “texture”, we might get...
Surface Characteristics
Understand and Control Texture:
which means...
Mixture and Construction
6
Concrete Pavements
Surface Characteristics
Program
Field ExperimentsKey Study Points
What can we learn from our current inventory?
What can we recommend for the future?
7
CO, ND, MN, IA, AL**, GA, NC, VA,
OH, IN, MI, Quebec, NY, MO
Type 3 Existing
(18 sites)
CO, ND, KS, IA, GA, WI, VA
Type 2 Existing
(8 sites)
IAType 1 New(1 site)
Test Sites
** NCAT
Test Sections395 Unique Textures Tested
140 Transverse Tining (incl. 12 skewed and 2 cross-tined)104 Longitudinal Tining (incl. 2 sinusoidal)
39 Diamond Ground16 Grooved (4 longitudinal, 12 transverse)
59 Drag (Burlap, Turf, Broom, Belt, Carpet)
10 Shot Peened5 Exposed Aggregate2 Milled
20 HMA and Surface Treatments
Over 1000 unique test sectionsOver 240,000 ft. of total length!
8
Test MethodsNoise
On-Board Sound Intensity (OBSI)Wayside (Roadside)In-Vehicle
SmoothnessInertial Profiler
MacrotextureRoboTex (LMI RoLine)Circular Texture Meter (CTM)Sand patch
Microtexture / FrictionLocked wheel skid trailer (smooth tire) Dynamic Friction Tester (DFT)
Noise Testing: OBSIOn-Board Sound Intensity (OBSI)
Developed by Dr. Paul DonavanTwo test tires – Aquatred III and SRTT
9
Noise Testing: Wayside
50 ft.
Controlled pass-by (CPB) measures noise “roadside” using test vehicle under controlled conditionsSame vehicle used for OBSI and CPB noise testing
Noise Testing: In VehicleStandardized by SAE J1477 and ISO 5128Same vehicle used for OBSI and In-Vehicle noise testing
10
Texture Testing: RoboTexRobotic Texture (RoboTex) Measurement SystemBuilt on LMI-Selcom RoLine sensor3-D texture profiling at 0.9 mm × 0.45 mm sample intervalHeight sensor resolution is 0.01 mm (accuracy ~ 0.05 mm)Same line laser sensor currently being used by some profiler vendors to help solve “footprint” issues
RoboTex
11
RoboTex
Friction Testing: Skid TrailerMeasures wet friction at one speedSmooth tire allows for differentiation of macrotexture effects on frictionAllows for comparison to some current DOT practicesStandardized in ASTM E 274 (ASTM E 524 tire)
12
Friction Testing: DFTDynamic Friction Tester (DFT) loan from FHWAMeasures friction as a function of speed – ASTM E 1911Measures wet friction on small rubber pads which slow from 50 mphCoupled with macrotexture, allows prediction of International Friction Index (IFI) and correlated relationships to E 274 trailer
What did we learn?
13
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
D.G
rnd
120
Dee
p-N
rmlS
aw (K
S-2
05-1
,C)
D.G
rnd
(MN
-320
-1,C
)B
rm.D
rag
(MN
-320
-1,C
)D
.Grn
d 11
0 D
eep-
Sngl
Saw
(KS
-205
-1,C
)D
.Grn
d 11
0 D
eep-
Nrm
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,C
)D
.Grn
d (C
O-2
02-1
,C)
Brlp
.Dra
g (S
td) (
IA-1
01-2
,C)
Trf.D
rag
(Hvy
) (C
O-2
02-1
,C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/16
"D+T
urf (
IA-1
01-4
,C)
D.G
rnd
(CO
-202
-1,W
P)Tr
f.Dra
g (H
vy)
(CO
-202
-1,W
P)B
rlp.D
rag
(Std
) (IA
-101
-2,W
P)Br
lp.D
rag
(Hvy
) (IA
-101
-2,W
P)R
ndm
. L.
Tine
1/8
"D+B
rlp (C
O-2
02-1
,C)
Brlp
.Dra
g (H
vy)
(IA-
101-
2,C
)Br
lp.D
rag
(Hvy
) (I
A-10
1-4,
C)
Crp
t.D
rag-
Sng
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,W
P)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/16
"D+T
urf
(IA-1
01-2
,WP
)D
.Grn
d 12
0 D
eep-
Sngl
Saw
(KS
-205
-1,C
)Tr
f.Dra
g (M
O-3
43-1
,WP
)R
ndm
. L.
Tine
1/8
"D+B
rlp (C
O-2
02-1
,WP
)T
rf.D
rag
(Hvy
) (IA
-101
-2,W
P)C
rpt.D
rag-
Nrm
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,W
P)T
.Brm
.Dra
g 1/
16"D
(WI-
207-
1,C
)T
rf.D
rag
(Hvy
) (IA
-101
-4,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Tur
f (IA
-101
-4,C
)D
.Grn
d (I
A-1
01-4
,WP)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/16
"D+T
urf
(IA-1
01-1
,WP
)D
.Grn
d 11
0 D
eep-
Nrm
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,W
P)B
rlp.D
rag
(Std
) (IA
-101
-4,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Tur
f (IA
-101
-4,W
P)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+T
urf (
IA-1
01-2
,WP)
D.G
rnd
130
Dee
p-Sn
glSa
w (K
S-2
05-1
,C)
D.G
rnd
120
Dee
p-S
nglS
aw (
KS-2
05-1
,WP
)D
.Grn
d 11
0 D
eep-
Sng
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,W
P)
Trf.D
rag-
Sng
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,C
)D
.Grn
d (M
O-3
24-1
,C)
Trf.
Dra
g (H
vy)
(IA-
101-
2,C
)D
.Grn
d 12
0 D
eep-
Nrm
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,W
P)T
rf.D
rag
(Hvy
) (I
A-10
1-4,
C)
D.G
rnd
130
Shl
w-N
rmlS
aw (K
S-2
05-1
,C)
1/2"
T.T
ine
1/16
"D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-2
,WP
)C
rpt.D
rag-
Nrm
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Tur
f (IA
-101
-2,C
)C
rpt.D
rag-
Sngl
Saw
(KS
-205
-1,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Tur
f (IA
-101
-1,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Tur
f (IA
-101
-2,C
)B
rlp.D
rag
(Std
) (IA
-101
-1,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-4,C
)B
rm.D
rag
(MN
-320
-1,W
P)Br
lp.D
rag
(Hvy
) (IA
-101
-4,W
P)T
.Brm
.Dra
g 1/
16"D
(W
I-20
7-1,
WP
)1/
2" T
.Tin
e (G
A-2
03-1
,C)
Trf.D
rag
(Std
) (IA
-101
-2,C
)B
rlp.D
rag
(Std
) (IA
-101
-1,W
P)D
.Grn
d 13
0 D
eep-
Sng
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,W
P)
D.G
rnd
(GA
-203
-1,C
)D
.Grn
d (I
A-1
01-4
,C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+T
urf (
IA-1
01-4
,WP)
D.G
rnd
130
Shl
w-S
nglS
aw (K
S-2
05-1
,C)
Trf.D
rag
(Std
) (IA
-101
-4,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(C
O-2
02-1
,C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/16
"D+T
urf (
IA-1
01-1
,C)
Trf
.Dra
g (S
td)
(WI-
207-
1,C
)1/
2" T
.Tin
e (G
A-2
03-1
,WP
)1/
2" T
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-4,C
)L.
Gro
ove
(CO
-202
-1,C
)L.
Gro
ove
(CO
-202
-1,W
P)B
rlp.D
rag
(Std
) (IA
-101
-4,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-2,W
P)1/
2" T
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-2,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Tur
f (IA
-101
-1,C
)1"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-4
,C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/16
"D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-2
,C)
1/2"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D (W
I-20
7-1,
C)
1/2"
T.T
ine
1/16
"D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-1
,WP
)D
.Grn
d 13
0 Sh
lw-S
nglS
aw (
KS-2
05-1
,WP
)D
.Grn
d 13
0 D
eep-
Nrm
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(Lng
) (IA
-101
-2,W
P)
1" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
(WI-
207-
1,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e (N
D-2
06-1
,WP)
Belt.
Dra
g (V
A-2
09-1
,WP)
Trf.D
rag
(Std
) (IA
-101
-4,C
)Tr
f.Dra
g (M
N-3
20-1
,WP
)Tr
f.Dra
g (S
td) (
IA-2
04-1
,C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
Lng)
(IA
-101
-4,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-1,W
P)D
.Grn
d (G
A-2
03-1
,WP)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/16
"D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-4
,WP)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (C
O-2
02-1
,WP)
Trf.D
rag
(Std
) (IA
-101
-2,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(Lng
) (IA
-101
-4,W
P)
D.G
rnd
(MO
-324
-1,W
P)D
.Grn
d 13
0 S
hlw
-Nrm
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,W
P)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
Lng)
(IA
-101
-2,C
)T
rf.D
rag-
Sng
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,W
P)
1/2"
T.T
ine
1/16
"D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-1
,C)
1/2"
T.T
ine
(GA
-203
-1,C
)D
.Grn
d+L.
Gro
ove
(IN
-311
-1,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-1,C
)D
.Grn
d 13
0 D
eep-
Nrm
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,W
P)1"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-4
,WP
)1/
2" T
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-4,W
P)
1/2"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-2
,WP
)B
rlp.D
rag
(Std
) (IA
-101
-3,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Tur
f (C
O-2
02-1
,C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
Shr
t) (
IA-1
01-4
,C)
Trf.
Dra
g (S
td)
(WI-
207-
1,W
P)D
.Grn
d 10
5 (N
Y-34
1-1,
C)
1/2"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D (
WI-2
07-1
,WP
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(S
hrt)
(IA
-101
-2,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
(S
ine)
+Brlp
(C
O-2
02-1
,C)
Trf.D
rag
(ND
-323
-1,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(Lng
) (IA
-101
-1,W
P)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
Lng)
(IA
-101
-1,C
)D
.Grn
d (I
A-1
01-2
,WP)
1" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
(W
I-20
7-1,
WP
)1/
2" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-2,C
)1/
2" T
.Tin
e (G
A-2
03-1
,WP
)D
.Grn
d+L.
Gro
ove
(IN
-311
-1,W
P)1"
L.T
ine
1/16
"D (W
I-20
7-1,
C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
Shr
t) (
IA-1
01-2
,C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+T
urf
(CO
-202
-1,W
P)
1/2"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-4
,C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/16
"D+T
urf (
IA-1
01-3
,C)
Trf
.Dra
g (H
vy) (
IA-1
01-3
,WP)
Brlp
.Dra
g (H
vy)
(IA-
101-
3,C
)Br
lp.D
rag
(VA
-209
-1,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(S
hrt)
(IA
-101
-4,W
P)B
rlp.D
rag
(Std
) (IA
-101
-3,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Tur
f (IA
-101
-3,W
P)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
Shr
t) (
IA-1
01-1
,WP)
Brlp
.Dra
g (H
vy) (
IA-1
01-3
,WP)
1/2"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-4
,WP
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
(S
ine)
+Brlp
(CO
-202
-1,W
P)1"
L.T
ine
1/16
"D (W
I-20
7-1,
WP)
1/2"
T.T
ine
(GA
-203
-1,C
)D
.Grn
d (I
A-1
01-2
,C)
D.G
rnd
(IA
-101
-3,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Tur
f (IA
-204
-1,C
)Tr
f.Dra
g (S
td) (
IA-2
04-1
,WP)
1/2"
T.T
ine
(GA
-203
-1,W
P)
1/2"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-2
,C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/4"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-4
,C)
D.G
rnd
(MN
-319
-1,C
)Tr
f.Dra
g (M
N-3
19-1
,C)
3/4"
T.G
roov
e (B
ridge
) (G
A-2
03-1
,C)
1/2"
T.T
ine
(GA
-307
-1,C
)3/
4" T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
(WI-
207-
1,C
)1/
2" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-4,C
)D
.Grn
d (C
O-3
05-1
,WP)
3/4"
L.T
ine-
Sng
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Tur
f (IA
-101
-3,C
)D
.Grn
d 10
5 (N
Y-3
41-1
,WP)
1" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
(WI-
208-
1,C
)1/
2" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-2,W
P)1"
T.T
ine
1/16
"D (S
kew
) (W
I-207
-1,C
)1/
2" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-1,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
4"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-2,W
P)T
rf.D
rag
(Hvy
) (I
A-10
1-3,
C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+T
urf (
IA-1
01-3
,WP)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
Shr
t) (
IA-1
01-1
,C)
Trf.D
rag
(Std
) (IA
-101
-3,W
P)1/
2" T
.Tin
e (G
A-3
07-1
,C)
1" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-3,C
)1/
2" T
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-3,W
P)
1" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-3,W
P)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/16
"D+T
urf
(IA-2
04-1
,WP
)1/
2" T
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-3,C
)Tr
f.Dra
g (N
Y-3
42-1
,WP)
Rnd
m. T
.Tin
e (M
rqtt
e.)
(IA-3
10-1
,C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (L
ng) (
IA-1
01-3
,WP
)1/
2" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-1,W
P)R
ndm
. T
.Tin
e (3
/4"a
vg,1
:4 S
kew
) (W
I-20
8-1,
C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
Lng)
(IA
-101
-3,C
)3/
4" T
.Tin
e (I
A-3
10-1
,C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/4"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-4
,WP)
Trf.D
rag
(MN
-319
-1,W
P)
Rnd
m.
T.T
ine
(1"a
vg,1
:4 S
kew
) (W
I-20
8-1,
C)
3/4"
L.T
ine-
Nrm
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,C
)R
ndm
. L.T
ine
(1"a
vg)
(WI-
208-
1,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
4"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-2,C
)R
ndm
. L.T
ine
(1"a
vg)
(WI-
208-
1,W
P)1/
2" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-4,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-3,C
)1"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D (
WI-
208-
1,W
P)
2/3"
T.T
ine
1/16
"D+T
urf (
IA-2
04-1
,C)
1" L
.Tin
e (C
O-3
05-1
,WP
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(S
hrt)
(IA
-101
-3,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Tur
f (IA
-204
-1,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Tur
f (IA
-204
-1,C
)3/
4" T
.Gro
ove
(Brid
ge)
(GA
-203
-1,W
P)D
.Grn
d (I
A-1
01-3
,C)
Rnd
m.
T.T
ine
(3/4
"avg
,1:6
Ske
w)
(WI-
208-
1,C
)R
ndm
. T.
Tine
(5/
8" A
vg.)
(NC
-322
-1,C
)R
ndm
. T.T
ine
(3/4
"avg
,1:4
Ske
w) (
WI-2
08-1
,WP
)3/
4" T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
(W
I-207
-1,W
P)
D.G
rnd
(MN
-319
-1,W
P)Tr
f.Dra
g (S
td) (
IA-1
01-3
,C)
Rnd
m. L
.Tin
e (3
/4"a
vg)
(WI-
208-
1,C
)1/
2" T
.Tin
e (N
D-2
06-1
,WP
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-3,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(S
hrt)
(IA
-101
-3,C
)1/
2" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-3,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e-S
nglS
aw (
KS-2
05-1
,WP
)R
ndm
. T
.Tin
e (1
"avg
,1:6
Ske
w) (
WI-
208-
1,C
)R
ndm
. T.T
ine
(3/4
"Avg
.) (
IA-3
10-1
,C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+N
oPre
Tex
(IA-1
01-2
,WP
)3"
T.T
ine
(ND
-206
-1,W
P)
1/2"
T.T
ine
(GA
-307
-1,C
)R
ndm
. T.T
ine
(1"/2
"/3"/
4")
(ND
-206
-1,W
P)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+N
oPre
Tex
(IA
-101
-4,C
)S
hotP
eene
d (M
ediu
m) (
VA
-209
-1,W
P)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+N
oPre
Tex
(IA
-101
-2,C
)1"
T.T
ine
1/16
"D (S
kew
) (W
I-207
-1,W
P)
1/2"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-3
,WP
)1"
T.T
ine
(GA
-203
-1,W
P)
1/2"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-3
,C)
Sho
tPee
ned
(WI-
207-
1,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+NoP
reTe
x (IA
-101
-4,W
P)
4" T
.Tin
e (N
D-2
06-1
,WP
)E
xp.A
gg (
MI-
317-
1,W
P)
1/2"
T.T
ine
(GA
-307
-1,W
P)
Rnd
m.
T.T
ine
(1"a
vg,1
:4 S
kew
) (W
I-208
-1,W
P)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+N
oPre
Tex
(IA-1
01-1
,WP
)1"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-4
,C)
1" T
.Tin
e (S
kew
) (N
D-2
06-1
,WP
)S
hotP
eene
d (W
I-20
7-1,
WP)
1" T
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
(WI-
207-
1,C
)R
ndm
. L.
Tine
(3/
4"av
g) (W
I-20
8-1,
WP)
Exp.
Agg
5-14
mm
(QC
-340
-1,W
P)1/
2" T
.Tin
e (G
A-3
07-1
,WP
)1"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-2
,WP
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
4"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-3,C
)1"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-1
,WP
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
4"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-3,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e-N
rmlS
aw (
KS-2
05-1
,WP
)2/
3" T
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Tur
f (IA
-204
-1,W
P)
3/4"
L.G
roov
e (V
A-3
36-1
,WP)
1" T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-2,C
)R
ndm
. T.T
ine
(1"a
vg)
(WI-
208-
1,C
)1/
2" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-3,W
P)R
ndm
. T.T
ine
(3/4
"avg
,1:6
Ske
w) (
WI-2
08-1
,WP
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+NoP
reT
ex (
IA-1
01-1
,C)
3/4"
T.T
ine
(IA-3
10-1
,WP
)1"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-1
,C)
3/4"
T.T
ine
(ND
-206
-1,W
P)
3/4"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+T
urf (
IA-2
04-1
,C)
1" T
.Tin
e (G
A-2
03-1
,C)
Rnd
m. T
.Tin
e (M
rqtte
.) (IA
-310
-1,W
P)
1/2"
T.T
ine
(GA
-307
-1,W
P)
Exp.
Agg
5-20
mm
(QC
-340
-1,W
P)T
.Tin
e (M
I-317
-1,W
P)
1" T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
(WI-
208-
1,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e (N
Y-3
42-1
,WP)
Col
dMill
ed (
IA-2
04-1
,C)
2/3"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+T
urf (
IA-2
04-1
,C)
1" T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
(WI-
207-
1,C
)2"
T.T
ine
(ND
-206
-1,W
P)
1" T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
(WI-
207-
1,C
)R
ndm
. T.
Tine
(5/8
" Avg
.) (N
C-3
22-1
,WP)
Rnd
m. T
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Tur
f (3/
4" A
vg.)
(IA
-204
-1,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+NoP
reT
ex (
IA-1
01-3
,C)
Rnd
m.
T.T
ine
1/8"
D (W
I-20
7-1,
C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+N
oPre
Tex
(IA-1
01-3
,WP
)1"
T.T
ine
1/16
"D (
WI-2
07-1
,WP
)R
ndm
. T
.Tin
e (1
"avg
,1:6
Ske
w) (
WI-2
08-1
,WP
)S
hotP
eene
d (Q
C-3
40-1
,WP)
1" T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
(WI-
207-
1,C
)3/
4" T
.Gro
ove
(GA
-307
-1,C
)3/
4" T
.Gro
ove
(IA
-204
-1,C
)R
ndm
. T.T
ine
1/8"
D (
WI-2
07-1
,WP
)R
ndm
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
Wis
DO
T)
(IA-1
01-1
,C)
1" T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
(W
I-207
-1,W
P)
Rnd
m T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(W
isD
OT
) (IA
-101
-2,C
)1"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-4
,WP
)1"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-3
,C)
3/4"
T.T
ine
(OH
-325
-1,W
P)
3/4"
T.T
ine
(OH
-325
-1,C
)3/
4" T
.Tin
e (O
H-3
25-1
,WP
)3/
4" T
.Gro
ove
(GA
-307
-1,W
P)1"
T.T
ine
(GA
-307
-1,C
)3/
4" T
.Tin
e (O
H-3
25-1
,WP
)R
ndm
. T.
Tine
(3/
4"Av
g.) (
IA-3
10-1
,WP
)C
oldM
illed
(IA
-204
-1,W
P)3/
4" T
.Tin
e (O
H-3
25-1
,WP
)3/
4" T
.Gro
ove
(GA
-307
-1,C
)2/
3" T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Tur
f (IA
-204
-1,W
P)
3/4"
T.T
ine
(IA
-309
-1,C
)3/
4" T
.Tin
e (O
H-3
25-1
,WP
)3/
4" T
.Tin
e (I
A-3
09-1
,C)
X.T
ine
(WI-2
07-1
,WP
)3/
4" T
.Gro
ove
(GA
-307
-1,W
P)1"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D (
WI-2
07-1
,WP
)3/
4" T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Tur
f (IA
-204
-1,W
P)
3/4"
T.T
ine
(OH
-325
-1,C
)1"
T.T
ine
(ND
-206
-1,W
P)
1" T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-3,W
P)
Rnd
m T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(Wis
DO
T)
(IA-1
01-2
,WP
)3/
4" T
.Gro
ove
(IA
-204
-1,W
P)1"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D (W
I-20
7-1,
C)
3/4"
T.T
ine
(OH
-325
-1,C
)3/
4" T
.Tin
e (O
H-3
25-1
,C)
3/4"
T.T
ine
(OH
-325
-1,C
)R
ndm
. T
.Tin
e (N
Y-3
42-1
,WP
)T
.Tin
e (R
ndm
. 1.1
" Avg
.) (Q
C-3
40-1
,WP)
X.T
ine
(WI-
207-
1,C
)R
ndm
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
Wis
DO
T)
(IA-1
01-4
,C)
Rnd
m.
T.Ti
ne 1
/16"
D+T
urf (
3/4"
Avg
.) (IA
-204
-1,W
P)
3/4"
T.T
ine
(IA
-309
-1,C
)R
ndm
. T.T
ine
(1"a
vg)
(WI-
208-
1,W
P)R
ndm
. T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Tur
f (3/
4" A
vg.)
(IA
-204
-1,C
)1-
1/2"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D (W
I-20
7-1,
C)
Rnd
m T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(W
isD
OT
) (IA
-101
-3,C
)1"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D (
WI-2
08-1
,WP
)1-
1/2"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D (
WI-2
07-1
,WP
)3/
4" T
.Tin
e (IA
-309
-1,W
P)
3/4"
T.T
ine
(IA-3
09-1
,WP
)R
ndm
. T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Tur
f (3/
4" A
vg.)
(IA
-204
-1,W
P)1"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D (
WI-2
07-1
,WP
)R
ndm
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (W
isD
OT
) (IA
-101
-1,W
P)
1" T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
(W
I-207
-1,W
P)
3/4"
T.T
ine
(IA-3
09-1
,WP
)R
ndm
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (W
isD
OT
) (IA
-101
-4,W
P)
Rnd
m.
T.T
ine
(ND
-323
-1,W
P)
1" T
.Tin
e (G
A-3
07-1
,WP
)R
ndm
. T.
Tine
(MN
-319
-1,C
)1"
T.G
roov
e 1/
4"D
+Brlp
(VA
-209
-1,W
P)R
ndm
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (W
isD
OT
) (IA
-101
-3,W
P)
Rnd
m.
T.T
ine
(MN
-319
-1,W
P)
1" T
.Gro
ove
1/4"
D+B
elt
(VA
-209
-1,W
P)
Nominal Texture
Ave
rage
OB
SI L
evel
and
Var
iabi
lity (
44-ft
Avg
, PW
L=95
%) (
dBA
)
Diamond GrindingDragLongitudinal TiningTransverse TiningLongitudinal GroovingTransverse GroovingExposed AggregateShot PeenedOther
OBSI Noise Catalog
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
D.G
rnd
120
Dee
p-N
rmlS
aw (K
S-2
05-1
,C)
D.G
rnd
(MN
-320
-1,C
)B
rm.D
rag
(MN
-320
-1,C
)D
.Grn
d 11
0 D
eep-
Sngl
Saw
(KS
-205
-1,C
)D
.Grn
d 11
0 D
eep-
Nrm
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,C
)D
.Grn
d (C
O-2
02-1
,C)
Brlp
.Dra
g (S
td) (
IA-1
01-2
,C)
Trf.D
rag
(Hvy
) (C
O-2
02-1
,C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/16
"D+T
urf (
IA-1
01-4
,C)
D.G
rnd
(CO
-202
-1,W
P)Tr
f.Dra
g (H
vy)
(CO
-202
-1,W
P)B
rlp.D
rag
(Std
) (IA
-101
-2,W
P)Br
lp.D
rag
(Hvy
) (IA
-101
-2,W
P)R
ndm
. L.
Tine
1/8
"D+B
rlp (C
O-2
02-1
,C)
Brlp
.Dra
g (H
vy)
(IA-
101-
2,C
)Br
lp.D
rag
(Hvy
) (I
A-10
1-4,
C)
Crp
t.D
rag-
Sng
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,W
P)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/16
"D+T
urf
(IA-1
01-2
,WP
)D
.Grn
d 12
0 D
eep-
Sngl
Saw
(KS
-205
-1,C
)Tr
f.Dra
g (M
O-3
43-1
,WP
)R
ndm
. L.
Tine
1/8
"D+B
rlp (C
O-2
02-1
,WP
)T
rf.D
rag
(Hvy
) (IA
-101
-2,W
P)C
rpt.D
rag-
Nrm
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,W
P)T
.Brm
.Dra
g 1/
16"D
(WI-
207-
1,C
)T
rf.D
rag
(Hvy
) (IA
-101
-4,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Tur
f (IA
-101
-4,C
)D
.Grn
d (I
A-1
01-4
,WP)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/16
"D+T
urf
(IA-1
01-1
,WP
)D
.Grn
d 11
0 D
eep-
Nrm
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,W
P)B
rlp.D
rag
(Std
) (IA
-101
-4,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Tur
f (IA
-101
-4,W
P)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+T
urf (
IA-1
01-2
,WP)
D.G
rnd
130
Dee
p-Sn
glSa
w (K
S-2
05-1
,C)
D.G
rnd
120
Dee
p-S
nglS
aw (
KS-2
05-1
,WP
)D
.Grn
d 11
0 D
eep-
Sng
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,W
P)
Trf.D
rag-
Sng
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,C
)D
.Grn
d (M
O-3
24-1
,C)
Trf.
Dra
g (H
vy)
(IA-
101-
2,C
)D
.Grn
d 12
0 D
eep-
Nrm
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,W
P)T
rf.D
rag
(Hvy
) (I
A-10
1-4,
C)
D.G
rnd
130
Shl
w-N
rmlS
aw (K
S-2
05-1
,C)
1/2"
T.T
ine
1/16
"D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-2
,WP
)C
rpt.D
rag-
Nrm
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Tur
f (IA
-101
-2,C
)C
rpt.D
rag-
Sngl
Saw
(KS
-205
-1,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Tur
f (IA
-101
-1,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Tur
f (IA
-101
-2,C
)B
rlp.D
rag
(Std
) (IA
-101
-1,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-4,C
)B
rm.D
rag
(MN
-320
-1,W
P)Br
lp.D
rag
(Hvy
) (IA
-101
-4,W
P)T
.Brm
.Dra
g 1/
16"D
(W
I-20
7-1,
WP
)1/
2" T
.Tin
e (G
A-2
03-1
,C)
Trf.D
rag
(Std
) (IA
-101
-2,C
)B
rlp.D
rag
(Std
) (IA
-101
-1,W
P)D
.Grn
d 13
0 D
eep-
Sng
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,W
P)
D.G
rnd
(GA
-203
-1,C
)D
.Grn
d (I
A-1
01-4
,C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+T
urf (
IA-1
01-4
,WP)
D.G
rnd
130
Shl
w-S
nglS
aw (K
S-2
05-1
,C)
Trf.D
rag
(Std
) (IA
-101
-4,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(C
O-2
02-1
,C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/16
"D+T
urf (
IA-1
01-1
,C)
Trf
.Dra
g (S
td)
(WI-
207-
1,C
)1/
2" T
.Tin
e (G
A-2
03-1
,WP
)1/
2" T
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-4,C
)L.
Gro
ove
(CO
-202
-1,C
)L.
Gro
ove
(CO
-202
-1,W
P)B
rlp.D
rag
(Std
) (IA
-101
-4,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-2,W
P)1/
2" T
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-2,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Tur
f (IA
-101
-1,C
)1"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-4
,C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/16
"D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-2
,C)
1/2"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D (W
I-20
7-1,
C)
1/2"
T.T
ine
1/16
"D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-1
,WP
)D
.Grn
d 13
0 Sh
lw-S
nglS
aw (
KS-2
05-1
,WP
)D
.Grn
d 13
0 D
eep-
Nrm
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(Lng
) (IA
-101
-2,W
P)
1" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
(WI-
207-
1,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e (N
D-2
06-1
,WP)
Belt.
Dra
g (V
A-2
09-1
,WP)
Trf.D
rag
(Std
) (IA
-101
-4,C
)Tr
f.Dra
g (M
N-3
20-1
,WP
)Tr
f.Dra
g (S
td) (
IA-2
04-1
,C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
Lng)
(IA
-101
-4,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-1,W
P)D
.Grn
d (G
A-2
03-1
,WP)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/16
"D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-4
,WP)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (C
O-2
02-1
,WP)
Trf.D
rag
(Std
) (IA
-101
-2,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(Lng
) (IA
-101
-4,W
P)
D.G
rnd
(MO
-324
-1,W
P)D
.Grn
d 13
0 S
hlw
-Nrm
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,W
P)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
Lng)
(IA
-101
-2,C
)T
rf.D
rag-
Sng
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,W
P)
1/2"
T.T
ine
1/16
"D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-1
,C)
1/2"
T.T
ine
(GA
-203
-1,C
)D
.Grn
d+L.
Gro
ove
(IN
-311
-1,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-1,C
)D
.Grn
d 13
0 D
eep-
Nrm
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,W
P)1"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-4
,WP
)1/
2" T
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-4,W
P)
1/2"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-2
,WP
)B
rlp.D
rag
(Std
) (IA
-101
-3,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Tur
f (C
O-2
02-1
,C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
Shr
t) (
IA-1
01-4
,C)
Trf.
Dra
g (S
td)
(WI-
207-
1,W
P)D
.Grn
d 10
5 (N
Y-34
1-1,
C)
1/2"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D (
WI-2
07-1
,WP
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(S
hrt)
(IA
-101
-2,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
(S
ine)
+Brlp
(C
O-2
02-1
,C)
Trf.D
rag
(ND
-323
-1,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(Lng
) (IA
-101
-1,W
P)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
Lng)
(IA
-101
-1,C
)D
.Grn
d (I
A-1
01-2
,WP)
1" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
(W
I-20
7-1,
WP
)1/
2" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-2,C
)1/
2" T
.Tin
e (G
A-2
03-1
,WP
)D
.Grn
d+L.
Gro
ove
(IN
-311
-1,W
P)1"
L.T
ine
1/16
"D (W
I-20
7-1,
C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
Shr
t) (
IA-1
01-2
,C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+T
urf
(CO
-202
-1,W
P)
1/2"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-4
,C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/16
"D+T
urf (
IA-1
01-3
,C)
Trf
.Dra
g (H
vy) (
IA-1
01-3
,WP)
Brlp
.Dra
g (H
vy)
(IA-
101-
3,C
)Br
lp.D
rag
(VA
-209
-1,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(S
hrt)
(IA
-101
-4,W
P)B
rlp.D
rag
(Std
) (IA
-101
-3,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Tur
f (IA
-101
-3,W
P)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
Shr
t) (
IA-1
01-1
,WP)
Brlp
.Dra
g (H
vy) (
IA-1
01-3
,WP)
1/2"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-4
,WP
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
(S
ine)
+Brlp
(CO
-202
-1,W
P)1"
L.T
ine
1/16
"D (W
I-20
7-1,
WP)
1/2"
T.T
ine
(GA
-203
-1,C
)D
.Grn
d (I
A-1
01-2
,C)
D.G
rnd
(IA
-101
-3,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Tur
f (IA
-204
-1,C
)Tr
f.Dra
g (S
td) (
IA-2
04-1
,WP)
1/2"
T.T
ine
(GA
-203
-1,W
P)
1/2"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-2
,C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/4"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-4
,C)
D.G
rnd
(MN
-319
-1,C
)Tr
f.Dra
g (M
N-3
19-1
,C)
3/4"
T.G
roov
e (B
ridge
) (G
A-2
03-1
,C)
1/2"
T.T
ine
(GA
-307
-1,C
)3/
4" T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
(WI-
207-
1,C
)1/
2" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-4,C
)D
.Grn
d (C
O-3
05-1
,WP)
3/4"
L.T
ine-
Sng
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Tur
f (IA
-101
-3,C
)D
.Grn
d 10
5 (N
Y-3
41-1
,WP)
1" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
(WI-
208-
1,C
)1/
2" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-2,W
P)1"
T.T
ine
1/16
"D (S
kew
) (W
I-207
-1,C
)1/
2" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-1,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
4"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-2,W
P)T
rf.D
rag
(Hvy
) (I
A-10
1-3,
C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+T
urf (
IA-1
01-3
,WP)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
Shr
t) (
IA-1
01-1
,C)
Trf.D
rag
(Std
) (IA
-101
-3,W
P)1/
2" T
.Tin
e (G
A-3
07-1
,C)
1" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-3,C
)1/
2" T
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-3,W
P)
1" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-3,W
P)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/16
"D+T
urf
(IA-2
04-1
,WP
)1/
2" T
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-3,C
)Tr
f.Dra
g (N
Y-3
42-1
,WP)
Rnd
m. T
.Tin
e (M
rqtt
e.)
(IA-3
10-1
,C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (L
ng) (
IA-1
01-3
,WP
)1/
2" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-1,W
P)R
ndm
. T
.Tin
e (3
/4"a
vg,1
:4 S
kew
) (W
I-20
8-1,
C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
Lng)
(IA
-101
-3,C
)3/
4" T
.Tin
e (I
A-3
10-1
,C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/4"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-4
,WP)
Trf.D
rag
(MN
-319
-1,W
P)
Rnd
m.
T.T
ine
(1"a
vg,1
:4 S
kew
) (W
I-20
8-1,
C)
3/4"
L.T
ine-
Nrm
lSaw
(KS
-205
-1,C
)R
ndm
. L.T
ine
(1"a
vg)
(WI-
208-
1,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
4"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-2,C
)R
ndm
. L.T
ine
(1"a
vg)
(WI-
208-
1,W
P)1/
2" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-4,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-3,C
)1"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D (
WI-
208-
1,W
P)
2/3"
T.T
ine
1/16
"D+T
urf (
IA-2
04-1
,C)
1" L
.Tin
e (C
O-3
05-1
,WP
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(S
hrt)
(IA
-101
-3,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Tur
f (IA
-204
-1,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Tur
f (IA
-204
-1,C
)3/
4" T
.Gro
ove
(Brid
ge)
(GA
-203
-1,W
P)D
.Grn
d (I
A-1
01-3
,C)
Rnd
m.
T.T
ine
(3/4
"avg
,1:6
Ske
w)
(WI-
208-
1,C
)R
ndm
. T.
Tine
(5/
8" A
vg.)
(NC
-322
-1,C
)R
ndm
. T.T
ine
(3/4
"avg
,1:4
Ske
w) (
WI-2
08-1
,WP
)3/
4" T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
(W
I-207
-1,W
P)
D.G
rnd
(MN
-319
-1,W
P)Tr
f.Dra
g (S
td) (
IA-1
01-3
,C)
Rnd
m. L
.Tin
e (3
/4"a
vg)
(WI-
208-
1,C
)1/
2" T
.Tin
e (N
D-2
06-1
,WP
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-3,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(S
hrt)
(IA
-101
-3,C
)1/
2" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-3,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e-S
nglS
aw (
KS-2
05-1
,WP
)R
ndm
. T
.Tin
e (1
"avg
,1:6
Ske
w) (
WI-
208-
1,C
)R
ndm
. T.T
ine
(3/4
"Avg
.) (
IA-3
10-1
,C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+N
oPre
Tex
(IA-1
01-2
,WP
)3"
T.T
ine
(ND
-206
-1,W
P)
1/2"
T.T
ine
(GA
-307
-1,C
)R
ndm
. T.T
ine
(1"/2
"/3"/
4")
(ND
-206
-1,W
P)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+N
oPre
Tex
(IA
-101
-4,C
)S
hotP
eene
d (M
ediu
m) (
VA
-209
-1,W
P)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+N
oPre
Tex
(IA
-101
-2,C
)1"
T.T
ine
1/16
"D (S
kew
) (W
I-207
-1,W
P)
1/2"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-3
,WP
)1"
T.T
ine
(GA
-203
-1,W
P)
1/2"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-3
,C)
Sho
tPee
ned
(WI-
207-
1,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+NoP
reTe
x (IA
-101
-4,W
P)
4" T
.Tin
e (N
D-2
06-1
,WP
)E
xp.A
gg (
MI-
317-
1,W
P)
1/2"
T.T
ine
(GA
-307
-1,W
P)
Rnd
m.
T.T
ine
(1"a
vg,1
:4 S
kew
) (W
I-208
-1,W
P)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+N
oPre
Tex
(IA-1
01-1
,WP
)1"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-4
,C)
1" T
.Tin
e (S
kew
) (N
D-2
06-1
,WP
)S
hotP
eene
d (W
I-20
7-1,
WP)
1" T
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
(WI-
207-
1,C
)R
ndm
. L.
Tine
(3/
4"av
g) (W
I-20
8-1,
WP)
Exp.
Agg
5-14
mm
(QC
-340
-1,W
P)1/
2" T
.Tin
e (G
A-3
07-1
,WP
)1"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-2
,WP
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
4"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-3,C
)1"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-1
,WP
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
4"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-3,W
P)3/
4" L
.Tin
e-N
rmlS
aw (
KS-2
05-1
,WP
)2/
3" T
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Tur
f (IA
-204
-1,W
P)
3/4"
L.G
roov
e (V
A-3
36-1
,WP)
1" T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-2,C
)R
ndm
. T.T
ine
(1"a
vg)
(WI-
208-
1,C
)1/
2" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-3,W
P)R
ndm
. T.T
ine
(3/4
"avg
,1:6
Ske
w) (
WI-2
08-1
,WP
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+NoP
reT
ex (
IA-1
01-1
,C)
3/4"
T.T
ine
(IA-3
10-1
,WP
)1"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-1
,C)
3/4"
T.T
ine
(ND
-206
-1,W
P)
3/4"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+T
urf (
IA-2
04-1
,C)
1" T
.Tin
e (G
A-2
03-1
,C)
Rnd
m. T
.Tin
e (M
rqtte
.) (IA
-310
-1,W
P)
1/2"
T.T
ine
(GA
-307
-1,W
P)
Exp.
Agg
5-20
mm
(QC
-340
-1,W
P)T
.Tin
e (M
I-317
-1,W
P)
1" T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
(WI-
208-
1,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e (N
Y-3
42-1
,WP)
Col
dMill
ed (
IA-2
04-1
,C)
2/3"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+T
urf (
IA-2
04-1
,C)
1" T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
(WI-
207-
1,C
)2"
T.T
ine
(ND
-206
-1,W
P)
1" T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
(WI-
207-
1,C
)R
ndm
. T.
Tine
(5/8
" Avg
.) (N
C-3
22-1
,WP)
Rnd
m. T
.Tin
e 1/
16"D
+Tur
f (3/
4" A
vg.)
(IA
-204
-1,C
)3/
4" L
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+NoP
reT
ex (
IA-1
01-3
,C)
Rnd
m.
T.T
ine
1/8"
D (W
I-20
7-1,
C)
3/4"
L.T
ine
1/8"
D+N
oPre
Tex
(IA-1
01-3
,WP
)1"
T.T
ine
1/16
"D (
WI-2
07-1
,WP
)R
ndm
. T
.Tin
e (1
"avg
,1:6
Ske
w) (
WI-2
08-1
,WP
)S
hotP
eene
d (Q
C-3
40-1
,WP)
1" T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
(WI-
207-
1,C
)3/
4" T
.Gro
ove
(GA
-307
-1,C
)3/
4" T
.Gro
ove
(IA
-204
-1,C
)R
ndm
. T.T
ine
1/8"
D (
WI-2
07-1
,WP
)R
ndm
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
Wis
DO
T)
(IA-1
01-1
,C)
1" T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
(W
I-207
-1,W
P)
Rnd
m T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(W
isD
OT
) (IA
-101
-2,C
)1"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-4
,WP
)1"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
IA-1
01-3
,C)
3/4"
T.T
ine
(OH
-325
-1,W
P)
3/4"
T.T
ine
(OH
-325
-1,C
)3/
4" T
.Tin
e (O
H-3
25-1
,WP
)3/
4" T
.Gro
ove
(GA
-307
-1,W
P)1"
T.T
ine
(GA
-307
-1,C
)3/
4" T
.Tin
e (O
H-3
25-1
,WP
)R
ndm
. T.
Tine
(3/
4"Av
g.) (
IA-3
10-1
,WP
)C
oldM
illed
(IA
-204
-1,W
P)3/
4" T
.Tin
e (O
H-3
25-1
,WP
)3/
4" T
.Gro
ove
(GA
-307
-1,C
)2/
3" T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Tur
f (IA
-204
-1,W
P)
3/4"
T.T
ine
(IA
-309
-1,C
)3/
4" T
.Tin
e (O
H-3
25-1
,WP
)3/
4" T
.Tin
e (I
A-3
09-1
,C)
X.T
ine
(WI-2
07-1
,WP
)3/
4" T
.Gro
ove
(GA
-307
-1,W
P)1"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D (
WI-2
07-1
,WP
)3/
4" T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Tur
f (IA
-204
-1,W
P)
3/4"
T.T
ine
(OH
-325
-1,C
)1"
T.T
ine
(ND
-206
-1,W
P)
1" T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(IA
-101
-3,W
P)
Rnd
m T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(Wis
DO
T)
(IA-1
01-2
,WP
)3/
4" T
.Gro
ove
(IA
-204
-1,W
P)1"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D (W
I-20
7-1,
C)
3/4"
T.T
ine
(OH
-325
-1,C
)3/
4" T
.Tin
e (O
H-3
25-1
,C)
3/4"
T.T
ine
(OH
-325
-1,C
)R
ndm
. T
.Tin
e (N
Y-3
42-1
,WP
)T
.Tin
e (R
ndm
. 1.1
" Avg
.) (Q
C-3
40-1
,WP)
X.T
ine
(WI-
207-
1,C
)R
ndm
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (
Wis
DO
T)
(IA-1
01-4
,C)
Rnd
m.
T.Ti
ne 1
/16"
D+T
urf (
3/4"
Avg
.) (IA
-204
-1,W
P)
3/4"
T.T
ine
(IA
-309
-1,C
)R
ndm
. T.T
ine
(1"a
vg)
(WI-
208-
1,W
P)R
ndm
. T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Tur
f (3/
4" A
vg.)
(IA
-204
-1,C
)1-
1/2"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D (W
I-20
7-1,
C)
Rnd
m T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Brlp
(W
isD
OT
) (IA
-101
-3,C
)1"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D (
WI-2
08-1
,WP
)1-
1/2"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D (
WI-2
07-1
,WP
)3/
4" T
.Tin
e (IA
-309
-1,W
P)
3/4"
T.T
ine
(IA-3
09-1
,WP
)R
ndm
. T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
+Tur
f (3/
4" A
vg.)
(IA
-204
-1,W
P)1"
T.T
ine
1/8"
D (
WI-2
07-1
,WP
)R
ndm
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (W
isD
OT
) (IA
-101
-1,W
P)
1" T
.Tin
e 1/
8"D
(W
I-207
-1,W
P)
3/4"
T.T
ine
(IA-3
09-1
,WP
)R
ndm
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (W
isD
OT
) (IA
-101
-4,W
P)
Rnd
m.
T.T
ine
(ND
-323
-1,W
P)
1" T
.Tin
e (G
A-3
07-1
,WP
)R
ndm
. T.
Tine
(MN
-319
-1,C
)1"
T.G
roov
e 1/
4"D
+Brlp
(VA
-209
-1,W
P)R
ndm
T.T
ine
1/8"
D+B
rlp (W
isD
OT
) (IA
-101
-3,W
P)
Rnd
m.
T.T
ine
(MN
-319
-1,W
P)
1" T
.Gro
ove
1/4"
D+B
elt
(VA
-209
-1,W
P)
Nominal Texture
Ave
rage
OB
SI L
evel
and
Var
iabi
lity (
44-ft
Avg
, PW
L=95
%) (
dBA
)
Zone 1
Zone 2
Zone 3
Noise Zones
14
Zone 3 – “No Zone”~ Above 104/105 dBA (OBSI, Aquated)
Mixed PopulationTransverse
Some Longitudinal
Harsh Texture AND Worn Texture
Rougher Pavement
Deteriorated Joints
Learn and eliminate !!
Zone 3Noise Zones
Zone 2 – “Quality Zone”~ 99/100 to 104/105 dBA (OBSI, Aquatred)
Mixed SolutionsLongitudinal, Drag, GrindingSome Transverse
Lower VariabilityBetter Joints
Zone 2Noise Zones
15
Zone 2 – “Quality Zone”~ 99/100 to 104/105 dBA (OBSI, Aquatred)
Quieter Solutions <102 dBA OBSIImprove mixturesUnderstand construction operationsExperiment with two-lift construction
Thin top course with high quality mixShould improve and hold friction and noiseMay prove economical
Zone 2Noise Zones
Zone 1 – “Innovation Zone”~ Below 99/100 dBA (OBSI, Aquatred)
Beyond capability of dense concreteNo current solutionsInnovative Possibilities
Need small negative textureMechanical damping ??Porous, inclusions, polymers ??Low Volume – pervious pavements ??High Volume – thin overlay w/polymers and fibers ??Two-lift a key since the innovation must also accommodate structure and economics
Zone 1Noise Zones
16
Texture vs. Noise ???
98
101
104
107
110
113
0 1 2 3 4 5
Maximum Texture Height (mm)
OB
SI L
evel
, 0.5
sec
sam
ple
(dB
A)
L.Tine-3/4"S-1/8"DL.Tine-1/2"S-1/8"DBurlap-StandardL.Tine-3/4"S-1/8"D-NoPreTexL.Tine-3/4"S-1/8"DL.Tine-3/4"S-1/4"DBurlap-HeavyT.Tine-1/2"S-1/8"DT.Tine-1/2"S-1/16"DT.Tine-1"S-1/8"DT.Tine-RandomS-1/8"DTurf-StandardDiamond GrindingTurf-HeavyL.Tine-3/4"S-1/16"D-TurfL.Tine-3/4"S-1/8"D-TurfL.Tine-3/4"S-1/16"D
Random T. Tine
1” T. Tine No pretexture
Drag Noise can not bePredicted byTexture Depth !!!
1/8" Deep Transverse Random Spacing + Burlap 17108.4 dBA
ZONE 2. 102 dBA
17
1/8" Deep Transverse Random Spacing + Burlap 17108.4 dBA
ZONE 3. 110 dBA
1:1 TrendlineR2 = 0.87StdErr = 0.9 dBA
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112
Measured Site Average OBSI Level (dBA)
Text
ure-
Pre
dict
ed S
ite A
vera
ge O
BS
I Lev
el (d
BA
)
Transverse TiningLongitudinal TiningDragDiamond Grinding
Transverse Tining OBSI = f (Ltx,160 , Ltx,25 , Rk,TR)Longitudinal Tining OBSI = f (Ltx,40)Diamond Grinding OBSI = f (Ltx,80+63+50+40 , SkewTR)Drag OBSI = f (Ltx,50+40 , SkewTR, Rk,TR)
• Ltx per ISO/CD 13473-4 (Draft) • Rk,TR(ansverse) per ISO 13565-2 • SkewTR(ansverse) per ASME B46.1
Texture vs. Noise
18
What can we recommend?
Learn More
19
Learn More
MP
DL6
3L4
Line LaserReal-TimeTextureMeasurement
AutomatedTexture
Machine
Texture FeedbackControl Panel
Better PracticesMinimize Construction VariabilityDurable ConcreteImproved CuringNominal Texture
Narrower JointsTwo-Lift Applications
Exposed Aggregate TrialsMore Durable Conventional Texture
Interim Recommendations