Considerations in connection with migrating from a GDR listing to a Premium Listing of Shares on the LSELondon Stock Exchange – Russia in Global Markets

Greg Stonefield, Alexandra Schukina and Allan TaylorNovember 2011

2White & Case London Stock Exchange – Russia in Global Markets

Outline

Rationale for migrating from a GDR Listing to a Premium Listing Companies who have migrated from GDRs to Premium Listing Preliminary structuring Issues

Premium listing considerations Retain GDR listing or delist – points to consider Eligibility for FTSE indexation Russian regulatory regime Tax considerations for choice of jurisdiction for incorporation and tax residency Re-domiciliation

Some differences between a GDR Listing and a Premium Listing Additional continuing obligations

3White & Case London Stock Exchange – Russia in Global Markets

Benefits of migrating from a GDR listing to a Premium listing

Higher profile with international and institutional investors Better access to funding Improved trading and liquidity Enhanced acquisition currency Eligibility for FTSE inclusion

FTSE UK Index Series where ListCo is a plc

Stricter corporate governance and disclosure rules

4White & Case London Stock Exchange – Russia in Global Markets

Companies that have migrated from GDR to Premium Listing – An emerging trend...?

AFI Development plc (Cypriot incorporated company) Retains a GDR Listing as well

Polymetal International plc (English incorporated company) Delisted its GDRs

Evraz plc – (English incorporated company) Given notice to delist its GDRs

5White & Case London Stock Exchange – Russia in Global Markets

Preliminary structuring issues – Premium Listing considerations

Free float and independence Minimum free float of 25% of share capital

Shares held by EEA holders unconnected with ListCo Excludes shareholdings in excess of 5%

UKLA must be satisfied that ListCo is able to operate independently of its controlling shareholders

Track record – 3-year revenue earning track record for 75% of ListCo’s business

Sponsor ListCo must have a “sponsor”, which makes various confirmations to the UKLA so will

seek comfort on these items

Responsibility for the prospectus

6White & Case London Stock Exchange – Russia in Global Markets

Premium Listing considerations (cont’d)

Additional continuing obligations Compliance with the UK Corporate Governance Code on a “comply or

explain” basis Consideration of board structure

Majority of board to comprise INEDs to be compliant with the UK Corporate Governance Code

Identification of INED candidates and Chairman candidate with Sponsor and underwriters (can be a time consuming process)

Chairman to be independent Separation of roles of chairman and the CEO

Board committees

Application of UK Takeover Code Mandatory takeover offer rules

7White & Case London Stock Exchange – Russia in Global Markets

Premium Listing considerations (cont’d)

Working capital 12 months working capital statement required in prospectus Detailed working process with reporting accountants

Employee related New employee incentive schemes to be adopted? D&O insurance and prospectus related insurance

Offer structure Mechanism to switch GDR listing to Premium Listing Consider whether to undertake a capital raising exercise at the same time

Domicile and country of incorporation of ListCo: UK vs. other countries (such as Jersey) No formal requirement for ListCo to be incorporated in the UK Decision primarily driven by indexation requirements and tax considerations

8White & Case London Stock Exchange – Russia in Global Markets

Retain GDRs or delist – points to consider

Deposit Agreement Delisting GDRs prior to expiry of the agreed duration of the facility may trigger

termination payment to the Depositary. Check the terms of the engagement letter!

If so, a company with GDRs listed on the LSE may seek a premium listing of shares and retain its listing of GDR programme in place so as to avoid paying termination fees to the Depositary

Usually need to give 90 days notice of termination of the facility

Consents Delisting of GDRs does not need approval of GDR holders under the Listing Rules,

but will need implicit approval as part of any securities exchange If a GDR issuer has issued high yield bonds, bond holder consent to the GDR

delisting may be required General change of control provisions in contracts need to be checked

9White & Case London Stock Exchange – Russia in Global Markets

Retain GDRs or delist – points to consider (cont’d)

Free float 25% free float requirement – the UKLA will not consider shares beneficially held by

GDR holders but registered in the name of the Depositary to count towards the free float

Therefore if a GDR listing is retained it is most likely that shares to be listed on the Premium Listing segment of the offered list will need to be a separate class of share unless a free float (i.e. > 25%) can be achieved for the shares underlying the GDRs

Market class test If ListCo lists a separate class of share, the UKLA may consider that only the class of

shares which are the subject of a premium listing should be included in any class tests

This reduces the market cap of ListCo for class test purposes (more likley that class tests are triggered)

10White & Case London Stock Exchange – Russia in Global Markets

Retain GDRs or delist – points to consider (cont’d)

Voting If a different class of share is listed, the UKLA will require that only holders of shares

subject to the premium listing are eligible to vote on matters included in the Listing Rules and that such shareholders exclusively enjoy the benefit of other rights set out in the Listing Rules

Holders of non-premium listed shares will, however, be able to vote on matters subject to the Listing Rules if required by applicable law

11White & Case London Stock Exchange – Russia in Global Markets

Eligibility for FTSE indexation

Requires a Premium Listing of equity shares Nationality tests will apply

Companies incorporated in the UK with a sole listing in the UK Companies incorporated in the UK with a listing in the UK and other developed

countries (as classified within the FTSE Global Equity Index Series) – subject to a decision of the FTSE Nationality Committee

Companies incorporated in other developed countries or countries internationally recognised as having a low taxation status and approved by the FTSE Nationality Committee (such as Channel Islands, Republic of the Marshall Islands, Bermuda Isles, BVI) – subject to a decision of the FTSE Nationality Committee, but in any event must: publicly acknowledge adherence to the principles of the UK Corporate

Governance Code, pre-emption rights and the UK Takeover Code; and have a free float greater than 50% (double the UKLA premium listing requirement)

Other Price - a sterling denominated price must exist for a company Liquidity test in 3 months prior to indexation

12White & Case London Stock Exchange – Russia in Global Markets

Development of Russian regulatory regime

Restrictive regulations by the FSFM – since 2001 Main conditions and restrictions for Russian issuers to obtain the FSFM

permission for foreign listing: Listing on a Russian stock exchange General limitation on the number of shares that may be placed/circulated abroad

(75% - since 2001, 40% - since 2003, 35% - since 2006, 30% - since 2008, 25% - since January 2010 till present)

Limitation on the number of shares of “strategic” entities that may be placed/circulated abroad (25% - all “strategic” companies, 5% - “strategic” subsoil companies)

Requirement to offer shares in Russia together with the foreign offering

Consequence of restrictions – use of offshore vehicles for foreign listing

13White & Case London Stock Exchange – Russia in Global Markets

Recent initiatives for liberalisation

Draft FSFM regulation of 14 November 2011 No limitation on the number of shares that may be placed/circulated abroad,

except for “strategic” entities (25% - all “strategic” companies, 5% - “strategic” subsoil companies)

No requirement to offer shares in Russia Law on Central Depositary Amendments to the Law on Foreign Investments in Entities of

Strategic Importance for State Defence and Security Made on 16 November 2011; effective from 18 December 2011

14White & Case London Stock Exchange – Russia in Global Markets

Tax considerations for choice of jurisdiction for incorporation

Issues to consider There is usually a tension between choosing to incorporate ListCo in a jurisdiction

(e.g. the UK) to facilitate eligibility to FTSE inclusion and having a tax advantageous structure (e.g. Jersey or Isle of Man)

Tax analysis of competing jurisdictions of incorporation is required Taxation of dividends Taxation of capital gains Stamp duty / stamp duty reserve tax/capital tax Withholding Tax

This tax analysis will be impacted by Residency of management and principal operating companies Considerations of controlling shareholders – what is tax efficient for them?

15White & Case London Stock Exchange – Russia in Global Markets

Re-domiciliation – possible structures

Share exchange offer (Polymetal and Evraz) New ListCo makes an offer to acquire the entire issued share capital of the existing

company (including any shares represented by GDRs) Offer of new shares does not need to be on a one for one basis (e.g. Evraz used

1 for 9 basis) Want to obtain irrevocable undertakings to accept offer by certain shareholders Acceptance level may be impacted by squeeze out rules (if any)

Termination of Deposit Agreement will be conditional upon offer being declared unconditional after which application is made to cancel GDR listing on Official List and on the London Stock Exchange Liquidity in and market value of existing shares and GDRs will be reduced so

investors have an incentive to participate

16White & Case London Stock Exchange – Russia in Global Markets

Re-domiciliation – possible structures (cont’d)

Dual Premium Listing of shares and GDR Listing (AFI Developments) ListCo does not change, but makes a bonus issue/distribution of a new class of

shares to existing holders of shares / GDRs May need to have distributable reserves for bonus issue/distribution Complication of dual listings and inability to convert GDRs into shares Avoids termination of deposit agreement and cancellation fees

Restructuring of existing ListCo Requires ListCo to be able to re-register and/or re-domicile in the UK (e.g. Societe

Europa) Would involve cancellation of GDRs and underlying shares being able to be settled

via CREST Consider use of depositary interests

Limited application in practice

17White & Case London Stock Exchange – Russia in Global Markets

Some differences between a Premium Listing and a GDR Listing

Prospectus ListCo and directors will need to accept responsibility for an equity prospectus More extensive disclosure than on a GDR listing

Sponsor/Underwriting agreement Warranties and indemnities will need to be provided by the ListCo, the selling

shareholder(s) (if any) and the directors

Increased scope of comfort package Working capital report Financial reporting procedures memorandum “Long form report” from the reporting accountants Comfort letters to the sponsor from ListCo and its advisers

18White & Case London Stock Exchange – Russia in Global Markets

Some differences between a Premium Listing and a GDR Listing (cont’d)

Is a relationship agreement needed? Ensures independence of ListCo from major shareholder (30%+)

Contains provisions relating to non-interference, non-competition, and dealing with conflicts of interest and information rights

Terminates at a certain shareholding threshold (usually 30%) or if the ListCo ceases to be listed Major shareholder usually requires board seat to remain in place above

certain voting threshold even if terminated

19White & Case London Stock Exchange – Russia in Global Markets

Additional continuing obligations

Numerous sources of additional continuing obligations for premium listed companies

Increased corporate governance UK Corporate Governance Code

Compliance with on a “comply or explain” basis (i.e. non-compliance will need to be explained on an ongoing basis in ListCo’s annual report)

Model Code on share dealings Applies to persons discharging managerial responsibility (prevents trading of

shares, options etc. in periods adjacent to financial reporting) Institutional investor guidelines

Rules governing executive compensation and share based remuneration, shares issues on a non pre-emptive basis, board effectiveness etc.

Takeover Code Rules on takeover offers for ListCo, including mandatory takeover rules if acquire

more than 30%

20White & Case London Stock Exchange – Russia in Global Markets

Additional continuing obligations (cont’d)

Listing Rules Must comply with Listing Principles

General principles applying the “spirit” of the Listing Rules Increased reporting in annual report Significant transactions

Transactions to be class tested (against size of ListCo) Class 1 transactions (over 25% of certain ratios) will need shareholder approval

and the publication of a UKLA approved circular Related party transactions

Related party transactions over 5% (including amendments) require the publication of a circular and shareholder approval (where the related party cannot vote)

Purchase of own shares and contents of circulars

21White & Case London Stock Exchange – Russia in Global Markets

Additional continuing obligations (cont’d)

Disclosure requirements Disclosure of all share dealings by directors (DTR 3) Disclosure of dealings by significant shareholders (3%+) (DTR 5) Disclosure on corporate governance (DTR 7 and LR 9)

Periodic financial reporting (DTR 4) Must half-year (un-audited) financial reports within 2 months of period end

Less extensive disclosure than annual financial statements, but prepared on the same basis

Need to provide quarterly trading updates (interim management statements) Do not need to contain quarterly accounts, but must describe material events and

transactions and financial position and performance of ListCo

Worldwide. For Our Clients.

In this presentation, White & Case means the international legal practice comprising White & Case LLP, a New York State registered limited liability partnership, White & Case LLP, a limited liability partnership incorporated under English law and all other affiliated partnerships, companies and entities.

whitecase.com

White & Case LLP5 Old Broad StreetLondon, EC2N 1DWUnited KingdomTel: + 44 20 7532 1000Fax: + 44 20 7532 1001

3943973