constitution... · andrew walker, "the 'karen consensus', ethnic politics and...

48

Upload: lamtuyen

Post on 16-Mar-2018

213 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)
Page 2: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)
Page 3: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)
Page 4: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)
Page 5: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)

h w ~ a i u h s a o ~ ~ a 3 w i n ~ 1 " w " ~ & ~ & ~ ~ ~ ? ~ a 0 n t n " w d ~ a n i ~ ~ ~ ~ 7 v i u a ~ u a @ William

A Callahan, "The Discourse of Vote Buying and Political Reform in Thailand," Pacific

Affkir.5' v01.71 NO. 1 (2005).

Page 6: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)

Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use

Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001).

Page 7: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)

"enedict Kerkvliet, Everyday Politics in the Philippines: Class and Status

Relations in a Central Luzon Village (Lanham, MD. ; Oxford: Rowman & Littlefield,

2002).

' lbid., p. 11.

Page 8: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)

' Zbid, Chapter 8.

"enedict Kerkvliet, l3e Power of Everyday Politia: How Vietnamese Peasants

Transformed National Policy (Ithaca, NY. ; Cornell University Press, 2005).

Benedict Kerkvliet, Everyday Politics in the Pbdippines, pp. 242-45.

Page 9: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)

" u n i s d o n ~ a $ ~ @ h z nta tban~s~ws~~uoan"nsdnns~aliawfii)~dw 4 nfs

t~an$mi%nan~o'snT z nfs tbon$smi~nani<tmwn~~~ 3 nts ttazttion&rni2n2~ani "

2 flss

~in%ni~~nuini~~~0s9w~~~1ds::iiTwi16aun1stbon&9wnls~~~~(1nu (~~liuwk16~1~6w

oinpdtiluiitiea gsiw?ln~~~w 812 ~oshin~ri is^, ~o~itical ~ u t ~ ~ o i r y and ~ ~ ~ v i n c i d

Identify in Thiland: Ihe Malting of Banham-bmi (Ithqca, NY. : ComeU University Press,

2011); Katherine k Bowie, "Standing in the Shadow: Of Matrilocality and the Role of

Women in a Village Election in Northern Thailand," American Ethnologist Vol. 35

No. 1 (2008) ; Daniel Arghiros, Democracy, Developmenr, and Decentdsation in

Provincial Thailand (Richmond : Curzon, 2001).

Page 10: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)

Cntlr~ut?naam~ouo~n~ul6vousi~uCuna"~~va~~vo~dr:~~~ r-uulaassu Y .

maom~u~tuu~~~u~i~a"~uarru n ~ ~ u n i r u o ~ i ~ ~ o ~ ~ u u 3 u p 1 i w $ i G G ~ o ~ 5 o A v ~ &npjnuul?uniii5usrru~fil!~~~~vuun (rural eonstituti~n)~~ l u k n u

nirlo~ua~fiium'uu ~mvo~ruuqen'irn~nir~Go~ (dth1aj~nu~n3ntl15~nm:~

uiriou) d ~6~1w~1dhmr~1n"unauqu~taza~1~na1uvou~rru~~n"un1r~4

6iui~ni.miriiioa snuufil!td~~unliluGa~iwuma"ntle:d~~ds:a~6vo~~d~: vii~Cidlgu@rnunianir~ioa liiimroa"nve~q6nxruni~nir~iioalu~mun6 aa:

vi1mi1~~1u~~od~m1un1rl~61u1~mvn1r~1flun1~dfim urm~nnjntiiaddnn~

oii~leiu~m~~lunix~lion&o~6nrdnnsoadauw"os8uua:lunixdx:~~unix

tdon biguia~us: i im~

lo w'nlls:%mantt~ad~yimai6i5rn: i% ti?u?fl??ad ~ 6 ~ ~ u w a i ~ i d . a . d i "?zn5m;q

a ~ u ~ w w ~ s s u ~ CwIwi~ 2534 ~ ~ ~ 8 ~ n i ~ n a u I ~ ~ u n ~ i u w u n ~ w I w ~ a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ u ; ~ i ~ w a i ~ a ' n ~ ~ d

a'nvs 1 % i ~ ~ i ~ ~ n s s ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ u a ' w u ~ ~ ~ ~ k w ~ ~ ~ 9 1 ' i u n ' u 5 ' ~ 6 s s u ~ ~ a 1 ~ ~ n ~ ~ d ~ n ~ ~ s n " ~ w n i n 1 ~ UvOd aS.awIw'~Awi?a "3Zf &I f ZGn rtasauqrndiy9 ~nanunia~~~wgiwKipwussmiani~ww~n

%w~wnian is~ ioave~~nu "'The -'Thai Cultural Constitution," Kyoto Review of Sooheast

Asia Vol. 3 (2003).

Page 11: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)
Page 12: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)

i{iIunain b ~ o ( b ~ u u n o u n i u h u o ~ ~ ~ u u ~ u o ~ ~ ~ ~ n u n ~ ~ i ~ ainiinir~"joud

~ a o n a u a ~ ~ u u n n ~ i i ~ a o n ~ u n ~ u ns. a~ua(Iclin%b.i oonouii "nitoiuiaan

In' iYuii~aulri nia~minrdonbuiun 1diYuiik~iirnod6n~o~sJd1uz nib.% nudi; m~iuu~odddrin 20 S~dua:l&lti? nuri7ulniiifTnluiR uifil-~ruin"

~unudu101ni%0d"

Page 13: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)

hvio~du di~win&e~miCdu*l~naiufiouS~a"ua~nz~tuuW~oii "W(~oJ"n4

~nutZuaduieiniima~atdua [uiunuu~] iudnuduioind%u&~u7> td&

mm~nmnnudouIu~rmii~{&n4n"u~"o~iuI6 naGiunaionuuoniiwanivi

~a3uloa"iuin ~iuau~~Coul%taa1oeii~uin~udiu~~~10~u3~1o~{noJ"n~ttdaznu

d~~u~nd~mmCi~mti ion& hnCi~un~Giunaiununiani~diioz6o~i

u'.n%un%nira~nzttuuttuuai~taviiuau~niCou tiaziiaiiiimu~%h%n~ozdi

6au dni~tiion&n&~u~wiu1~66auZ (S;liGiio~Gnst8uuinniidn~~niuG)

t t ~ ~ 4 ~ P d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ ~ S I ~ d t ~ i ~ ~ i d f i ~ ~ w " ~ ~ 1 $ t ~ ~ ~ d ~ ~ i ~ n " d 3 ~ 1 8 d ~ ~ i 4 d ~ 4 4 ~ i Z A w ~nu'nriudon~~Iniinaiuar"uwWuiw"~~utS~finuitazlu~S~wuwnuw"o~$u~u~o~

4 4 w cr - 9 $a~nztiuutiion$~luGiut4uui~uwanwuan~1~zd~unuuuttaz"uan~u d W w

tmm~1u~~n~omirun~na~nw"un"uw"o~$uWn1ui~~d~uid~uu~6uin wa

msa.mzuuutiion&~~nu1~nIufiiut~uufit~u1dniun4~nzttuu~"o~duiruu

hmiunlnunii.r ~@lmowun'did6iunzttuut%u~ 38 nzttuuivii$u

ndduno~nu&~udm~nu1ui1ezt~u~aitwud~~6tw~1zivitilud$~noei1~

nii~vaish~~uzPdYo~viuvo~oGn n.n. 1ufi"snYa (na'ian"Pdiiivitgunuvosw"n2~

6x1) (~nr~nnunddmuoi&oa~udimottaz~uo~n aa. Iup~udlilucminr

nuluadmuo~rioo~lu~itnoe~"atdua rnliiez16nzuuuuinni16' usinnu$%n

vo .mf iu1uhaun14t ' ion$~u~~i1 n.nul&a'uo~ruin"udiinoio~oeii~

~in"auinlusiasna"9 G~$iuluuwuiw ni4lilu n.9. tvifilil6i1d4~Iuv~ozl~Ifi ni~"o~dumu (nCnd16~un~ttuui8u~a"iKu~aui (3s nznuu) t9u~n'Ip.g~nir

Page 14: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)
Page 15: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)

" Pasuk Phongpaichit, "Developing Social Alternatives: Walking backward into a

Klong" (paper presented at the 1999 "Thailand Updates: Thailand beyond the Crisis,"

Australian National University, Canberra, 21 April 1999), p. 6.

Page 16: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)
Page 17: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)

riou~ozrirnslbonb$w~d~u~o~fiiu~GuuIu?ia~Au~ 2547 (n@

n jlmd~IunQ~~u~ndql~fiuCa~~wup~o~n~~~uld~.u"iiau~~ua"mus~~u

d~~;u"ulud~ualnril~u~ <nlnquoi ~n.rn~3$n7nojfiulunfdku1Laz

~gundQussm~~1~onon~zuzw"io~loj~~uluni~1uo1a1<m5ou1?~1~~

~~1GnGusyui1l4Fj1u~Zn q Gau q +~nfun~~ldiau~~uIua"u&ndia Aau

~~iv1afi1panrnsa'11,%j~w"uqwo tw~~nnd~an~cinv~af i~ui~f iunum~znd

dmiiu2 n~umfiul~i~irn~n~n5~nnup.14~1do~ofium"~r~u $laYnr

n u ~ n d n d ~ ~ n ~ ~ m u u n n a ' ~ n ~ ~ w " ~ ~ ? i u ~ u o ~ o ~ n u o ~ a ' ~ d u n ~ x ~ o ~ ~ u ~ ~ A

Page 18: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)
Page 19: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)
Page 20: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)
Page 21: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)
Page 22: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)
Page 23: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)
Page 24: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)
Page 25: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)

4i~erunisnisd~s%~a%~1dsz~ia"od~ia~~~~1ia.n"n~~ l u n i s t ' i o n ~ ~ s : ~ u v i ~ ~ 2544 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ w s s n ~ w f l ~ ~ n ~ w u w o ~ w " n ~ ~ guyms

<utjiiuio $minrwodwuinlwulutwmtii~n~~fiiut~uul6+uau:ld6aun~ttuu

tZo.rfounz 48 woq$uilQhl: d a u l u m s ~ o n b ~ 2548 nrtuuslo.r@linr

lwaYnlwul~;i$ulddq?ouaz 66 n:ttuu~u~auw"u~du~aund~wo~~uauz~unis G A G

1iionmsntnmwimtrnzl~1n~d~mn?~nd~wo4Iwu TnurrnnIwuinIwunroqt~id

mni ;~ 377 d&oin$qnun 500 d&luqmi uir$unAttsnh+i:%~~lmi

nisti~~ar3J"ulniwo~lwud~ssnn1r~io~~ssnt~ual6~on~o~~u~G1w1nuuu $ 4 -$ I t~mslin~uarni n ~ s r i i o n k ~ n n ~ n u ~ ~ ~ o n w u ~ u t ~ a u t u ~ i u u 2 5 4 9 nfioind

$n~ml~ula~unmtdol~tw3~n"unisdszw"a~d~~iu?~~l iadwuiu~auin<u dA E: w d * lunpmrrumuns rrsmd~:aii~mu~~tduwssnd~u~iuluwm:~ums:nunm~i

w~ntwiliilon1ndozauzn1st5on~~l~1~~m~ulon~1u1m~n1stiionk uG<i 01 0 1 0 1

ozlii~uu'.ruirbltGuttQq $ n ~ m n " t ~ n r t r u u ~ u u l d o t i i ~ u i n l u n i s ~ ~ ~ n ~ n Y ~ G

na~ul~rrolodoi~u~aw~~~w~azw"oulXt~uldutwmtiion~~wo~fi~u~iuu x dd t ' l h t ~ ~ a ~ ¶ J ~ ~ V I t l ~ ~ 9169d~~tVlfl L ~ ~ L G ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ o ~ J ~ E ~ ~ u % u ~ B ( ~ I s ~ ~ ~ u w ~ I u

lug 2548 nruuui4u~tf$a~nsoinwssnlwu?nlwul6?uana4i;~~~~nd~ Tnu

Page 26: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)

{iilw%n.m:uuuioun: 60 ~Zonda:'$nilfl%43~7 diGmrl3u nu%ni~uin.r

uInidr:sq4a.rn:ii~ ndiaiinoduiiiioii luia~laaidCn9mo~luii~~ni~ r:~naiusCusyudwsrnivi'$6?ulunir~SonXr:Gum~inaiu kui~d~odi.auin

eranirdon&lus:Guw"o.~~uZaapdlG&4iniu5~niw a"n~&v$a'$dd9~oqi Cn9u

siuirnnrosdiuioiiluniri'i~n~~ %unirl~on$qaui~nsnifiw?"n~u~ 2547 WA ww {soJ"nr?udon&$~nro~ii~~n~ao~i~u~~a:~u~ w~nrunirsod"usyuoeii~~~$~Gu

ainwrmuoaCnn'nPm na"uviiuiiliodi-a~und ua:1umr$on&uiunm~19~um~$~

~~i.ruirniroh.riGa~bu nr. s lu~$a~u~mind~rrni~~~ai iCuuuiunvl Cnlim%

Zviiwm~dodia~3unia (a nruuu) 16iis:i~unuiiiadnirsmr~4~1~3u~dlC?u m1umlood1~n?1~vai~1nuJr:n1~1i1o:1iuu1un aue~nbqlw"%n' &ulnpld

~rnuda:~dodi.riiu 7 ii nuluauuwln'mraCu~Yuw"nn'nPmlun~r~Zon$~~~uu liluionairrilm:lnikui~dr mn:anmmPiiia:<n89ei1uin~osi1ur:uu9d~u&~i

Y w

ljundodujlnioir {i~uuu'mnnuoiiuiro:du~r~1uaod"u1nni1do:w'o1rm1i1 ijjuia

uo~Cn~u~nds:iiiuoin$4ilw7~~on&Iu~uuworii~lr l u u j ~ m ~ i i i i u m i ~

niriiia~w"o~~uniUq6~rru~~~~~~aiaGiu

Page 27: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)
Page 28: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)
Page 29: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)
Page 30: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)

wanai%odnaiu q mid ~n~fi~~v1~nx~n1~a1u~nx~n1xdw"1~~~6md~:~uvod"n"unau1

n a l i ?iiu~ariar~~ib16iau~n~ooz'Ixim~~~6~au33 lnxqmd6%m3dunyu

Iguodi.ruinain.mCiu~o uxrmilnum~mui~~m~~avo~w'o~du bulawir

kunirnm~un$iiu u a : ~ n x ~ n i x d b n ~ ~ m l h n i i ~ n ~ d n i ~ SML luGiulbiuu

1lfiiilnunixlnd16erii.il~nio~Gi~ uino~rlun~C~und.ra'~uu~w~ulnx~n~x w"dxrmnaiuht5e6auZ iiG-mnnixk~:~udou.u"i~q~ Ciu~iuuaiuixn~~uuem

~uw.un'lu~uu$~6ul6~n6au~do~i)~n~au~3nno~f?ui~uaund~i~Guu~d~n

t u n o ~ r l u o d ~ ~ a ~ ~ ~ m o i ~ a z i i n ~ x ~ o ~ u v o ~ a u ~ ~ n ~ ~ u ~ 6 u 6 a u Gui SML gn

i l ~ ~ ~ m 3 r i o a ? l 9 ~ x 9 d 9 1 o 9 n ~ ~ l u $ 9 ~ ~ u ~ n l 3 ~ u ~ m x l d ~ n n i l ~ 5 9 % l o n v u u q

~ut[.uvu ~ m m ~ n ~ ~ i u a u ~ ~ ~ u ~ u ~ 1 u ~ ~ u u ~ ~ ~ 6 ? u a " a ~ 1 1 ~ d u ~ n 1 u 1 ~ n ~ ~ n 1 x

"hhuai" $.rl6?un1xa~u~uain?~uia~n6au mCiunundwdia8.r

lnxqnixdii "mliiu&vou$nGero$uin I n x ~ n i x k l ~ u l X ~ n ~ m x n x ~ d u ~ a " a ~ u n a i u w u ~ u ~ u u ~ . i l ~ n ~ n a ~ u u ~ n i ) u I m u ~ ~ u x ~ u ~ ~ ~ t u v ~ a l i ~ u ~ ~ ueneind

iiviaCiud~zuier 20 nhdoud1$iiauiienxxuia3ua?is~iu16$u q $qldu

hun&vo~ Innn i~~eu4~~e~o ivuzna iuu ineu~o~?~u ia uonainduluuiu .s w u

30 uiw?n~1~nI~nvo~~u1an~mxu~du~mou?uod1~a"una1~1e1nnuluw'e~~u

liu LZ ua n"od nixlfinixduquuluuiuii~ 7 umiquiaod"ul6?urnrmlu~a%einxl,uuo~

d i i u1uuiuii.r q gniiuid~dndi.rxamAaGulo lul~a:dli6aqirioiiux:uu

xi.trnixGeqdu na1uxam~a~a~?~u1an'nGerlun1xlXna1~1iaum"a61uni~~u~u

g m a m n i i ~ l ~ ~ ~ d o ~ i u u ~ ~ u i a r i o u n ~ 1 6 Inxqnix SML lilu~aodi.rdgn

6i.ri3.rodliounft lnun1~6gnii~mro9uia~nixxerx~4ni~%u~lunix~"aen$~

itiouqumwiri 254s uazrnuIui~'ou~~uiuu~~Zuatuod"u~o~ naGiu6Iriiu

~uno.r~ulmzo$u~iu:de:~m~u~e~6~1~nx~nixoz' I~w"nax~6?uni~era"n~u

arii1~ziin1~oiidx1unn~Zu~tuo~1~u1nluxz~u~o~6ui1naxi)zI~~uno~~u

adids aiduu~uduoun~~nk~ule~ia:nix~i~~u~nx~nix~~~u~uvu~uxz~u n~Ciun%"Nmxmoq?uodiqZ lu~~idIgupm&6udii~ldein5Zd~u3mi~nvnix

auudn~daz6~io.n~nl3~u~oiauo~n39nl5llaz9ud5:u1erien~au91uxz~uq~

qmw'~una~~uCm~lehr9~~x~%pm~u~~a:~~a"a~a~eluia~6u~ 2548 $du~aai

Page 31: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)

+ a M a ~ ~ d s z ~ i m t ~ a n i s ~ n ~ m ~ ~ i n s i ~ ~ i u n i s d i s a ~ n i a z ~ ~ s ~ g i i ~ t t a z ~ ~ ~ ~ a ~ n ~ a d a u

ir 2550 F m u & 0 a n ~ i u a r i i ~ t t i s m ~ ttad'aPllaer2m~m4~aasa~ds~vivi~%uaiau~aani~nis~n~ms

Q l n World Development Indicators Online Va96ulR15~af l ( t~ l~9~t Iyat&l 2 2 % p l U ~ 2553)

Page 32: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)
Page 33: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)
Page 34: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)
Page 35: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)

oznlnrou&~yn~ni~u~u~z~un?a86u~6t~n"u r n s v i i I ~ t i i n n . n u w i i ~

rznh~iaud~un<~u'~o~viin"un~~iau~nna&niia~~uni~t~uutd~udri A d~luvpa"don1~tZon f id t~ i ' ~oqhu61~%1 q %ufiiutiuunuwu~ttnnqnaiut~u

l ioi iq%i "tdoiiou t8nlnurlnnuttinmiiriw<inKatta"a 60,ooo uin udmoud - 4 s ldnd IMF ut7a twn:a:%$nvlnnu6t~nuilnul?n"9aa tt5a~.1utaut(aaui

t(ndfiiuin 1 9 o l l i i m d 6 Z iauchuCiiu CdritGuliiozlrtYnodiqY3

in~oCuw%~~~i~iseraoii~uindonaiu~uvouluKaw"n9mff~o n i ~ d t v i A4 u

vouwi5nKuduuiu (n14 a d ~ z n i ~ n ~ n 4 ~ u m dl9 q) muan~mzi%qnnaiunulo

oiiqna"1qvaiq ni~a~~~~inuiudwztuonzu~~dttazn~~n"~nunt~~dm~udt$u~an

n a n u i r v o a u l u u i u i u iaum~mmiunulooin~wuluw"o~~ul6oii~~ntou

msrmra~dtiludnti~av~~uind~ntW"uozI~ttiiuIuuiu u d ~ z n i ~ m n n u L u ~

t n i n " &r inunu i i mul6uluuiulnriia r in is~ i~nounud~nna ' ian i i i

~imlm*~mnn~no~w"u~iuoinn~dnud~u&d~ztn u l u u ~ u d ~ u u l u v i n A' dd

~~~i iun i rmiun~uoi i~&~~oinf l iu t iuu tantiuttiuan"uluwunauvo~d4ztn~1 d W v c : n i ~ d ~ z n i a r a r s n ~ ~ u n " u u ~ t n w ~ n ~ n ~ i ~ ~ ~ $ ~ o ~ t m o ~ u ~ ~ u z d ~ z ~ n d ~ u i u n ~ w twu

$drziin~rnwuazni~8u~~it(t$u~t4~t8nvin"~o~w"n~~ uluuiunjndiauj

~ounuo~~om1u~aadrio~oi1~~n~~~u~"o~6u~on1~tt~in~zo1uvo~u1fi1~un~u

tuiam ~ ~ j n o n n ~ ~ ~ ~ u n a i u ~ ~ n ~ n ~ n r o ~ n u ~ u ~ o ~ i u d ~ u u n i ~ ~ n n i ~ ~ i i ~

tZuuv1n&~d~nnt i iawi i i~uo iv~ in4 g~$uiavooonlnoin14~wuiuialu

iut i ionbtdoi l 2549 tdou1aan:ttuu~~un~uw44n~nu?n~nu ttaYiiluni~ 5 E

tZonm.rnsauubu?nlnuoz!niri~ttaiqffmiu g.ru"uuonii "&dg.rvoumndqm u s c:4 d tduan"flwn~mnnoao~n~n~iud4iuuitnwin 35"ur id~z luu ino q tdoiiou<

rinuinuiweruin want8nlunafiiulo~iituoz ~~dtui? iwant8niauiwuiuiu

u i v l u u n e u ~ a t m e i d l ~ ~ d u u iiBuwantRnlun~fiiudttwaz gatodriouinld

dua~oqtau i=yriztdnria t~ua35"irozsiitoihu1 nuluw~fliuiaun"u&n44uni~ x

ainm~ztauluia~nai~~uvuui 8un~~uni4ttuua"u q ua"atviii~unu!Aoinwaiu

najfliu mf~U$fifi~uldttlluh g ~ t o ~ i ; ~ 2 n d a o n ~ u < ~ t u o z ~ ~ 4 . 4 ttduonm~o~do~ntd~unuivuvuwaiud~zn~~tduan"uwa~~uv~~?~uia

w"nSm via~iu~iuau~17nl~inu1'd%on"uni~noi?d~uvmtvi naiu~14au0ii.a

Page 36: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)

Gndn6iweaw"nGol u a n n " u n i s t o ~ o i g ~ n ' e u a z n i s n s ~ u 9 " i u ~ n i ~ w i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ o ~ ~ ~ i

w a ~ u b ~ I u i a ~ d n ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ w ~ ~ I u ~ ~ u ~ a v i ~ I f i l i n ~ o l m n f i u ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ o ~ n ~ ~ n ~ ~ a w ~ i ~ dunud "lanuin" "lna" uin0ut?uld ~tazttangould6aunu!id5ouga w"mr

t~~Go~oeii.rtrniwa~uIuw~v~afliu udiiniimaiunu Gu?i?6Gw ado nr uuu

Page 37: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)
Page 38: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)
Page 39: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)
Page 40: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)
Page 41: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)
Page 42: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)

'' Benedict J. Kerkvliet and Resil B. Mojares, "Themes in Transition from Marcos

to Aquino: An Introduction," in From Marcos to Aquino: L.ocal Pempectives on Political

Transition in the PhiLippines, ed Benedict J. Kerkvliet and Resil B. Mojares (Manila:

Ateneo de Manila University Press, 1991), p.10.

'' Max Gluclanan, Custom and Conflict in A15ica (Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1955).

Page 43: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)
Page 44: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)

Arghiros, Daniel. 2001. Democracy, Development and Decentralization in

Provincial nailand. Richmond : Curzon.

Bunbongkarn, Suchit. 1996. Elections and Democratization in Thailand."

In The Politics o f Elections in Southeast Asia. R.H. Taylor, ed.

Washington, DC : Woodrow Wilson Center Press.

Callahan, William A.. 2005. "The Discourse of Vote Buying and Political

Reform in Thailand." Pacific Aff;.iirs Vol. 7 1 No. 1 : 9 5 - 1 13.

Connors, M.K.. 2003. Democracy and National Identity in Thailand.

London : RoutledgeCurzon.

Gluckman, Max. 1955. Custom and Conflict in Africa. Oxford : Basil

Blackwell.

Hewison, Kevin. 2002. "Responding to Economic Crisis : Thailand's

Localism." In Reforming 7k i Politics. D. McCargo, ed. Copenhagen :

Nordic Institute of Asian Studies Press.

- - - - - - - . 2008. "A Book, the King and the 2006 Coup." Journal of

Contemporary Asia Vol. 38 No. 1 : 190-211.

Hirsch, P.. 1997. Seeing Forests for Trees: hvironment and Environmentalism

in Thailand. Chiangmai : Silkworm Books.

Kerkvliet, Benedict J. and Resil B. Mojares. 1991. "Themes in the

Transition from Marcos to Aquino : An Introduction." In From

Marcos to Aquino : Local Perspectives on Political Transilion in

the Philippines. ene edict J. Kerkvliet and Resil B. Mojares, eds.

Manila: Ateneo de Manila University Press.

Kerkvliet, Benedict J.. 1995. "Toward aMore Comprehensive Analysis of

Philippine Politics : Beyond the Patron-Client, Factional Framework"

Journal of Southeast Asian Studies Vol. 26 No. 2 : 4 10 - 19.

- - - - - - - . 2005. 7he Power of Everyday Politics: How Vietnamese Peasants

Transformed National Policy. Ithaca : Cornell University Press.

Page 45: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)

- - - - - - - . 2002. Everyday Politics in the Philippines : Class and Status

Relations in a C e n d Luzon Village Lanham : Rowman & Littlefield

Laothamatas, Anek. 1996. L'A Tale of Two Democracies : Conflicting

Perceptions of Elections and Democracy in Thailand." In The

Politics of Elections in Southeast Asia, Washington. R. Taylor,

ed. DC : Woodrow Wilson Center Press.

Maisrikrod, Surin and Duncan McCargo. 1997. "Electoral Politics :

Commercialisation and Exclusion." In Political Change in Thailand :

Democracy and Participation. Kevin Hewison, ed. London :

Routledge.

McCargo, Duncan. 2006. "The 19 September 2006 Coup-Preliminary

Thoughts on the Implications for the Future Directions of Thai

Politics." Asia Research Institute, National University of Singapore.

http: / /www.ari.nus.edu.sg/showfrle.asp?eventfii90, downloaded

February 20, 2007.

McVey, R. T., ed. 2000. Money and Power in Provincial Thailand.

Copenhagen: Nordic Institute of Asian Studies Press.

Missingham, B. D., 2003. The Assembly of the Poor in Thailand: From

Local Struggles to National Protest Movement Chiangmai : Silkworm

Books.

Nelson, M. H.. 1998. Central Authority and Local Democratization in

nailand : A Case Study fiom Chachoengsao Province. Bangkok :

White Lotus Press.

Nidhi Eoseewong. 2003. "The Thai Cultural Constitution." Kyoto Review

of Southeast Asia No. 3. http://kyotoreview.cseas.kyoto-u.ac.jp/issue/

issue2/index.html. downloaded February 26, 2007.

Nishizaki, Yoshinori, 2005. "The Moral Origin of Thailand's Provincial

Strongman: The Case of Banharn Silpa-Archa" South East Asia

Research Vol. 13 No. 2 : 184-234.

Page 46: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)

Ockey, James. 2000. "The Rise of Local Power in Thailand : Provincial

Crime, Elections and the Bureaucracy." In Money and Power in

Provincial Thailand. R. McVey, ed. Singapore: ISEAS.

- - - - - - - . 2004. Making Democracy: Leadership, Class, Gender, and Politid

Participation in Thailand Honolulu : University of Hawaii Press.

Phatharathananunth, Somchai. 2008. "The Thai Rak Thai Party and

Elections in North-eastern Thailand." Journal o f Contemporary

Asia Vol. 38 No. 1 : 106-23.

Phongpaichit, Pasuk and C. Baker. 2008. "Thaksin's Populism." Journal

of Contemporary Asia Vol. 38 No. 1 : 62-83. - - - - - - - . 1999. "Developing Social Alternatives : Walking Backwards into

a Klong." Paper presented to the Thai Update, Canberra, Australian

National University, 2 1 April.

Pye, 0. and W. Schaffar. 2008. "The 2006 Anti-Thaksin Movement

in Thailand : An Analysis." Journal of Contemporary Asia Vol. 38

NO. 1: 38-61.

Scott, J. C.. 1976. The Moral Economy of the Peasant: Rebellion and

Subsistence in Southeast Asia New Haven: Yale University Press.

- - - - - - - . 19 8 5. Weapons o f the Weak : Everyday Forms of Peasant

Resistance. New Haven : Yale University Press.

- - - - - - - . 1998. Seeing Like a State : How Certain Schemes to Improve

the Human Condition Have Failed New Haven: Yale University

Press.

Tanun, A. R.. 1994. "Campaign Techniques of the Thai Members of

Parliament in the 1988 General Elections." Unpublished PhD

Thesis, Northern Illinois University.

Tejapira, Kasian. 2006. "Toppling Thaksiin" New Left Review No. 39 : 5-37.

Turton, Andrew. 1984. "Limits of Ideological Domination and the Formation . -

of Social Consciousness." In History and Peasant Consciousness

in South East Asia A. Turton and S. Tanabe, eds. Osaka: National

Page 47: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)

Museum of Ethnology.

Walker, Andrew. 2001. "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and

Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand." Asian Ethnicity

V0l. 2 NO. 2 : 145-62. - - - - - - - . 2004. "Seeing Farmers for the Trees: Community Forestry and

the Arborealisation of Agriculture in Northern Thailand." Asia Pacific

Viewpoint Vol. 45 No. 3 : 31 1-24. - - - - - - - . 2006. "What About Some Political Education for the Elite?."

New Mandala http: //rspas.anu.edu.au/rmap/newmandala/2006/ 101

~l/what-about-some-political-education-for-the-elte/. downloaded

April 1, 2007.

- - - - - - - . 2007. "Beyond the Rural Betrayal : Lessons from the Thaksin

Era for the Mekong Region." Paper presented at the International

Conference on Critical Transitions in the Mekong Region,

Chlangmai Grand View Hotel, January 29-31.

Yoshifumi, Tarnada. 1991. "Itthiphon and Amnat: An Informal Aspect of

Thai Politics." Southeast Asian Studies Vol. 28 No. 4 : 445-65.

Page 48: Constitution... · Andrew Walker, "The 'Karen Consensus', Ethnic Politics and Resource-Use Legitimacy in Northern Thailand," Asian Ethnicity Vol. 2 No. 2 (2001)