consulting with dahp with... · 2020. 1. 6. · holly borth built environment compliance reviewer....

15
Holly Borth Built Environment Compliance Reviewer CONSULTING WITH DAHP Section 106, 05-05, SEPA

Upload: others

Post on 24-Mar-2021

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: CONSULTING WITH DAHP with... · 2020. 1. 6. · Holly Borth Built Environment Compliance Reviewer. CONSULTING WITH DAHP. Section 106, 05-05, SEPA. Holly Borth (BEU Compliance) Rob

Holly Borth

Built Environment Compliance Reviewer

CONSULTING WITH DAHP Section 106, 05-05, SEPA

Page 2: CONSULTING WITH DAHP with... · 2020. 1. 6. · Holly Borth Built Environment Compliance Reviewer. CONSULTING WITH DAHP. Section 106, 05-05, SEPA. Holly Borth (BEU Compliance) Rob

Holly Borth

(BEU Compliance)

Rob Whitlam

(106, 05-05 Arch) Dennis

Wardlaw

(Transpo Arch)

Sydney Hanson

(Transpo Arch)

Stephanie Jolivette

(SEPA Arch) Michael Houser

(Eligibility BEU)

Nick Vann

(Effects BEU)

Greg Griffith

(Planning BEU)

Kim Gant

(Forms BEU)

DAHP CONSULTATION ORGANIZATION

Page 3: CONSULTING WITH DAHP with... · 2020. 1. 6. · Holly Borth Built Environment Compliance Reviewer. CONSULTING WITH DAHP. Section 106, 05-05, SEPA. Holly Borth (BEU Compliance) Rob

CONSULT with the SHPO on the following, per 36 CFR 800.4:

Area of Potential Effects

Include description and justification

One size does not fit all

Methodology

Include justification

Eligibility

4 Criteria

7 Aspects of Integrity

Effects

“When an undertaking may alter, directly or indirectly, any of the characteristics of a historic property that qualify the property for inclusion in the National Register in a manner that would diminish the integrity of the property’s location, design, setting, materials, workmanship, feeling, or association

Resolution of Adverse Effects

SECTION 106

[email protected]

You can lump,

just be prepared

for feedback!

Page 4: CONSULTING WITH DAHP with... · 2020. 1. 6. · Holly Borth Built Environment Compliance Reviewer. CONSULTING WITH DAHP. Section 106, 05-05, SEPA. Holly Borth (BEU Compliance) Rob

State Capital Funding

Requires ALL state agencies to CONSULT with DAHP, GOIA, and Tribes to consider how projects may impact significant cultural and historic places

No specific process

Follow standard historic property protocol

Contact DAHP early and often – we are the only ones who can tell you what we want

Cultural resource work must be commensurate with the scope of work

EZ-1 for ground disturbing activities – first look

EZ-2 for NON-PROFESSIONALS for built resources over 50 years in age (45 recommended)

Historic Property Inventory forms will be requested if a building is proposed for demolition

Must be completed by a cultural resource professional

GOVERNOR’S EXECUTIVE ORDER 05 -05

[email protected]

Page 5: CONSULTING WITH DAHP with... · 2020. 1. 6. · Holly Borth Built Environment Compliance Reviewer. CONSULTING WITH DAHP. Section 106, 05-05, SEPA. Holly Borth (BEU Compliance) Rob

STATE ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT (SEPA)

[email protected]

• Local Jurisdictions are the decision makers

• SEPA Checklists are submitted to DAHP

• DAHP will provide COMMENTS as necessary

• Final decisions are made by the local jurisdiction

• Each jurisdiction is different

• Demolition of NRHP listed properties will trigger review

• HPIs submitted are reviewed for completeness

• DOEs made upon request of local jurisdiction

Page 6: CONSULTING WITH DAHP with... · 2020. 1. 6. · Holly Borth Built Environment Compliance Reviewer. CONSULTING WITH DAHP. Section 106, 05-05, SEPA. Holly Borth (BEU Compliance) Rob

***Send to the appropriate regulatory inbox***

INCLUDE:

Lead agency

Regulatory context

Project description

What are you

consulting on?

What do you need from DAHP?

CONSULTATION LETTERS

Page 7: CONSULTING WITH DAHP with... · 2020. 1. 6. · Holly Borth Built Environment Compliance Reviewer. CONSULTING WITH DAHP. Section 106, 05-05, SEPA. Holly Borth (BEU Compliance) Rob

CONSULTATION

Lead Agency SHPO/DAHP

At any time, we may ask for more information to make our decisions,

including, but not limited to:

• Clarification

• Sources

• Historic Context

• Alternatives Considered

• Further consideration under NRHP

Let’s chat!

Page 8: CONSULTING WITH DAHP with... · 2020. 1. 6. · Holly Borth Built Environment Compliance Reviewer. CONSULTING WITH DAHP. Section 106, 05-05, SEPA. Holly Borth (BEU Compliance) Rob

If it’s in your report, it should be in Wisaard

Including previous DOEs

Consultation is NOT a Wisaard tool

Submitting into Wisaard does not initiate consultation

Email: [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]

If you know the right DAHP staff, you can CC them

Consultation letters stay out of Wisaard

Requests for consultation

can only come from the

LEAD AGENCY

REPORTING IN WISAARD

Please

proofread!

Page 9: CONSULTING WITH DAHP with... · 2020. 1. 6. · Holly Borth Built Environment Compliance Reviewer. CONSULTING WITH DAHP. Section 106, 05-05, SEPA. Holly Borth (BEU Compliance) Rob

AREA OF POTENTIAL EFFECT/IMPACT

One size does not

fit all.

How was it

defined?

What effects were

considered?

Does the map

match the

description?

Page 10: CONSULTING WITH DAHP with... · 2020. 1. 6. · Holly Borth Built Environment Compliance Reviewer. CONSULTING WITH DAHP. Section 106, 05-05, SEPA. Holly Borth (BEU Compliance) Rob

METHODOLOGY

Jus

If I’m 50

and in APE,

record me!

Park Neighborhood

Bridge

Historic Downtown

Page 11: CONSULTING WITH DAHP with... · 2020. 1. 6. · Holly Borth Built Environment Compliance Reviewer. CONSULTING WITH DAHP. Section 106, 05-05, SEPA. Holly Borth (BEU Compliance) Rob

*See Standards for Cultural Resource

Reporting*

Common Topics:

• Project Description • Clear and specific

• Methodology • Justify

• Historic Context • Specific to the APE/API

• Survey Results • Align with everything that led up to this

REPORT

Shout it

all out!

Page 12: CONSULTING WITH DAHP with... · 2020. 1. 6. · Holly Borth Built Environment Compliance Reviewer. CONSULTING WITH DAHP. Section 106, 05-05, SEPA. Holly Borth (BEU Compliance) Rob

Utilize:

Previous reports

Historic maps (GLO, Metsker, Sanborn, Kroll, USGS, etc.)

Secondary sources (historic newspapers, books, online articles,

etc.)

HISTORIC CONTEXT

Page 13: CONSULTING WITH DAHP with... · 2020. 1. 6. · Holly Borth Built Environment Compliance Reviewer. CONSULTING WITH DAHP. Section 106, 05-05, SEPA. Holly Borth (BEU Compliance) Rob

Specific to APE/Project Area

Relate to historic resources/HPIs that were found

Don’t forget the Post WWII era! (“Historic Period” now enters 1970s)

Cont’d HISTORIC CONTEXT

Page 14: CONSULTING WITH DAHP with... · 2020. 1. 6. · Holly Borth Built Environment Compliance Reviewer. CONSULTING WITH DAHP. Section 106, 05-05, SEPA. Holly Borth (BEU Compliance) Rob

Three Essential Components:

1. Data

2. Analysis/Interpretation

3. Recommendations

SHOW YOUR WORK

SURVEY RESULTS

Page 15: CONSULTING WITH DAHP with... · 2020. 1. 6. · Holly Borth Built Environment Compliance Reviewer. CONSULTING WITH DAHP. Section 106, 05-05, SEPA. Holly Borth (BEU Compliance) Rob

YOUR KEYS TO SUCCESS

Involve DAHP and Tribes EARLY AND OFTEN.

Don’t hesitate to contact DAHP with questions.

Now come home!!!