contact center agent coaching: addressing challenges in agent …€¦ · contact center agent...
TRANSCRIPT
1
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Welcome to . . .
Contact Center Agent Coaching: Addressing Challenges in Agent
Development April 27, 2012
2:00‐4:00 PM Eastern
Presented by: Kelly Brickley
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
2
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Agenda
1. Addressing performance challenges
2. The dirty dozen
3. Sherlock coach
4. Create a SAFE process
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Responsibility & Consequences
Your responsibility: Managing & developing
the organization’s resources to achieve desired results.
3
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Responsibility & Consequences
It’s self-destructive for us to blame agents for failure when we are responsible for managing the organization’s resources.
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Responsibility & Consequences
Especially when we know the cost of replacement* is significantly higher than developing existing resources.
*Hiring costs
*Training costs
*Increased management support
*Diminished service levels
*Decreased customer satisfaction
*Lower employee satisfaction
Replacement costs
Developing existing
resources
4
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Replacement Costs
1. Direct costs, such as recruiting costs, training costs and paying temporary agency fees and overtime.
2. Opportunity costs, which include lost customers due to poor service and quality, decreased productivity and having to operate under‐capacity.
3. Indirect costs, such as reduced morale, loss of organizational knowledge, hampered growth rates and inefficient use of corporate staff time.
Source: S. Burchman and Debra Schmitt, “Understanding the Costly Threat of Agent Turnover”, CCMR November 2000.
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Responsibility & Consequences
People do not go through this world
behaving illogically.
There are consequencesto every action.
5
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
2 Types of Challenges
Negotiable
Non-Negotiable
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
2 Types of Challenges
Negotiable• Determine negotiable items
• Practice negotiation, action plans
• Negotiate whenever you can
• Take a long view of performanceimprovement
6
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
2 Types of Challenges
Non-negotiable• Consistently & fairly applied
• Within the grasp of 100% of employees
• Emphasize consequences
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Polling Question 1
1. Are most of your coaching challenges over negotiable or non‐negotiable performance standards?
a. Negotiable
b. Non‐negotiable
c. Both
d. Other (send text)
7
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Text Question
What is one negotiable standard in your call center? Please type in your answer.
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
ICMI’s Dirty Dozen1. Deliver it face to face2. Question Assumptions3. Keep Your Emotions in Check4. Be Objective5. Set Realistic Expectations6. Stick to the Behavior7. Explain the Consequences of Non-compliance8. Be Positive and Encouraging9. Avoid a Laundry List10. Recognize Effort and Improvement11. Put it in Writing12. Follow Up
8
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Deliver It Face-to-face
Sp
ecia
l Co
nsi
der
atio
ns
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Question Assumptions
Sp
ecia
l Co
nsi
der
atio
ns
9
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Keep Your Emotions in Check
Sp
ecia
l Co
nsi
der
atio
ns
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Transactional Analysis Chart
Parent
Adult
ChildChild
Adult
Parent
10
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
• Deal with only the issue at hand
• Avoid “halo or horns” effect
Be Objective
Sp
ecia
l Co
nsi
der
atio
ns
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
“If you are late again, you’ll be
fired.”
unrealistic
Set Realistic Expectations
Sp
ecia
l Co
nsi
der
atio
ns
11
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
“If you are not here at the start of your shift more than once per month, you’ll receive another warning. Three warnings in a two-month period and your job here will be terminated.”
realistic
Set Realistic Expectations
Sp
ecia
l Co
nsi
der
atio
ns
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
• Eliminate the word “attitude”
from discussion
• Discuss only observable, measurable behaviors
• Provide data, specific examples
Stick to the Behavior
Sp
ecia
l Co
nsi
der
atio
ns
12
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Polling Question 2
2. In which area do your coaches need the most development?
a. Deliver it face‐to‐face
b. Question assumptions
c. Keep your emotions in check
d. Be objective
e. Set realistic expectations
f. Stick to the behavior
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
“Don’t do that
again.”
Explain Consequences
Sp
ecia
l Co
nsi
der
atio
ns
13
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
“If this continues to happen, you’ll receive an unsatisfactory rating from
me, which will keep you from applying for any internal
promotions.”
Explain Consequences
Sp
ecia
l Co
nsi
der
atio
ns
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
• Non-threatening
• Clear and dispassionate
• Present as a choice
• Express your preference
• Establish timeframes for
improvement, consequences,
clearance
Explain Consequences
Sp
ecia
l Co
nsi
der
atio
ns
14
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
“If this happens again this month, it will be documented and placed in your employee file. I really think you’re doing a great job otherwise. I would hate to see you make that choice.”
Explain Consequences
Sp
ecia
l Co
nsi
der
atio
ns
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
“Timesheet falsification is cause for immediate termination
without notice. If this happens again, ever, you will be fired
immediately ”
Explain Consequences
Sp
ecia
l Co
nsi
der
atio
ns
15
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
“I know this is difficult for you, but I know you can do
it.”
“I want you to succeed in this
job.”
Be Positive and Encouraging
“You can do it.”“With practice, I
think you’ll master this in no time.”
Sp
ecia
l Co
nsi
der
atio
ns
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Avoid a Laundry List
Sp
ecia
l Co
nsi
der
atio
ns
16
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Recognize Effort and Improvement
Sp
ecia
l Co
nsi
der
atio
ns
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Put It in Writing
Document for
• Goal‐setting
• Clarity
• Record
Sp
ecia
l Co
nsi
der
atio
ns
17
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Put It in Writing
• Positive and action‐specific
• Not a threat or “documenting out the door”
• Action plan and consequences, including supervisor support responsibilities
• Examples: Action plan, disciplinarydocumentation, performance review, periodic feedback record
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Follow up
• Overall success of coaching efforts
hinge here
• Highlight importance by following up
• Recognize subsequent achievement (effort, whole, part) to encourage continuation
18
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Polling Question 3
3. In which area do your coaches need the most development?
a. Explain consequences of non‐compliance
b. Be positive and encouraging
c. Avoid a laundry list
d. Recognize effort and improvement
e. Put it in writing
f. Follow up
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
• To address ongoing, deficient behaviors
• Resolve disagreement or determine cause for lack of improvement
A Coaching Process
Formal coaching
19
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
1. ? to clarify understanding of desired behaviorDoes she understand the performance requirement?
2. ? to identify ability to demonstrate desired behaviorDoes she understand what the skill looks like and how to do it?
3. ? to test desire to improve Does she know why she should do it? Is she committed to change?
Coaching Process
Fo
rmal
co
ach
ing
sk
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
1. ? to clarify understanding of desired behavior2. ? to identify ability to demonstrate desired behavior3. ? to test desire to improve
Fo
rmal
co
ach
ing
Coaching Process
Negotiable Non-Negotiable
sk
4. Does s/he understand the consequences of non-compliance?
5. Can the skill be negotiated or broken down?
sk yourself
20
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Sherlock Coach
Detective Work Handout 3: Handout 3: What Would You Do? Exercises
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
What Would You Do?
When Mr. Jones inquired about the specifics of the email offer he received today, Tracy told him the offer included a 3-month trial.
The trial membership is 1 month. A memo was distributed about the weekly email offer on Monday, as usual.
21
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Source of the Challenge
1. Does she understand the performance requirement?
Source: Ferdinand Fournies, Coaching for Improved Work Performance
“Tracy, did you read this week’s email update?”
“What’s the offer for this week?”
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
No improvement…
22
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
What Would You Do?
You’ve coached Linda multiple times about speaking more conversationally when she reads the required scripts.
While she agrees she sounds robotic and monotone, her performance hasn’t improved.
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Source of the Challenge
2. Does she understand what that skill looks like and how to demonstrate it?
Source: Ferdinand Fournies, Coaching for Improved Work Performance
“Linda, let me show you what I mean.” (model)
“You try it now” (praise or adjust)
23
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
No improvement…
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
What Would You Do?
During the last few weeks, you’ve determined that Joe understands the opening standard and when you’re in a coaching session, he can do it. But it’s not consistently happening during most calls.
24
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Source of the Challenge
3. Does he know why he should do it?
Source: Ferdinand Fournies, Coaching for Improved Work Performance
“Do you understand why it’s important to ask ‘How may I help you?’ in your opening?” (if not, explain, assess buy-in)
“Why do you think it’s important to express willingness to help when greeting the caller?”
“What do you think the openingshould be?”
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
No improvement…
25
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
What Would You Do?
Neil says he wants to be at work on time but he consistently fails to meet the minimum standard in place.
You no longer believe Neil’s promises and don’t know what to do except to document his actions.
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Source of the Challenge
4. Is he committed to change?
“Neil, we’ve discussed why this is an important objective and you’ve committed to it yet you’re
consistently failing to meet it.
“What’s going on?”
“How do you explain the gap between what you say you’re going to do and what you’re actually
doing?”
Source: Ferdinand Fournies, Coaching for Improved Work Performance
26
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
No improvement…
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
What Would You Do?
Tamika knows she’s responsible for logging and coding every call she handles. You’ve verified steps 1-4 and haven’t been able to get at the root of the problem.
This is a foundational call center skill and call center policy requires that the agent receive a written warning if she fails to meet the requirement in 50% of her call monitoring two months in a row. Tamika failed to meet the standard this month.
27
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Source of the Challenge
5. Does she understand consequences of non‐compliance? (if there are any)
Source: Ferdinand Fournies, Coaching for Improved Work Performance
“Tamika, it’s important that you take responsibility for what could happen here. I want to be clear that if you fail to meet this standard again next month, this could result in a written warning. If
this continues into the third month, you could be terminated. I would hate to see that happen. Do
you see the decision you have to make here?
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
No improvement…
28
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
What Would You Do?
Paul hasn’t been consistently offering the required cross sell items in his calls. When he does offer them, he sounds awkward and uncomfortable.
You’ve tried everything you know how, but efforts to increase his sales numbers have been unsuccessful so far.
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Source of the Challenge
6. Can the skill be negotiated or broken down?
Source: Ferdinand Fournies, Coaching for Improved Work Performance
“Paul, for the next week, I want you to get the offer in there consistently on every call. Don’t worry about the how right now and don’t worry about your sales numbers.
Once you get that down, we’ll move on to your sales technique.”
29
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
No improvement…
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
The Role of Disciplinary Action
• Focus on correction, not punishment
• Encourage desired behaviors, not absence
of misbehavior
• Maintain and enhance relationships
30
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
The Role of Disciplinary Action
• Understood, accepted and supported
• Emphasize choices, decisions,
responsibility
• Consistently and fairly applied
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Polling Question 4
4. Which of the following do you think would have the biggest impact on improving how your coaches handle performance challenges?
a. More coach training and coach‐the‐coach opportunities
b. Increased support from upper management and human resources
c. More authority to take disciplinary action
d. Increased time to observe performance and provide face‐to‐face feedback
e. More flexibility in managing individual agent's performance challenges
31
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
ummarize observed behavior(s)
sk for input
ormulate plan of action
xpress gratitude
A Model
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
“This is the third time you’ve been more than 10 minutes late this month. Did you see our service level this morning? Your not being here had an effect on that, as well as the pressure your
coworkers felt with having to pick up the slack in your absence. I know you’ve been having problems with your transportation, but we haven’t discussed specifics about how you’re going to resolve
this issue. I’d like to do that now.”
SAFE Model
ummarize observed behavior(s)
32
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
“You know that being late again this month isn’t an option for you if you’d like to continue your employment here. It’s
essential that you’re here every day on time to do your job. What are you going to do to ensure that you can be here on
time tomorrow and every other day for the rest of the month?… I know you’re going to try harder, but I’d like to
hear specifically how you’re going to do that. What are you going to do differently tomorrow, that you didn’t do this
morning? …”
SAFE Model
sk for input
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
“OK, so you are committing to setting your alarm clock fifteen minutes earlier so you can catch the earlier bus at
8:00? …That should leave you plenty of time to be here by 9:00am. If you do this, everyone’s morning will be much more pleasant - you won’t feel rushed and stressed, our
service level will improve and there will be a more equitable distribution of work.”
SAFE Model
ormulate plan of action
33
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
“Thank you for coming up with this plan. I know you can do this and I really want to see you succeed here. This is the only thing holding you back. I’ll see you at 9am here
tomorrow.”
SAFE Model
xpress gratitude
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Practical Application
1. Create a SAFE environment for employees to risk, grow, achieve
34
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Practical Application
2. Document processes & policies, disciplinary procedures
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Practical Application
3. Document common performance challenges & established procedures for your coaches
35
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Practical Application
4. Create additional written tools (action plans, agreements, disciplinary procedures, periodic feedback records)
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
Recommended Resources
• Role play, discuss in team meetings
• Promote learningFerdinand Fournies:
Why employees don’t do what they’re supposed to do and what to do about it
Coaching for Improved Work Performance
Dick Grote: Discipline Without Punishment
36
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
International Customer Management Institute (ICMI)121 South Tejon Street, Suite 1100
Colorado Springs, CO 80903USA
800‐672‐6177719‐268‐0184 fax
Contact Us
©2012 International Customer Management Institute (ICMI). All Rights Reserved icmi.com I 800.672.6177
More Virtual Classroom Training…
MAY
04
MAY
18
MAY
22
JUN
01
Contact Center Agent Coaching: Inspiring Employees Through Positive Feedback
Designing a Contact Center Incentive Program that Drives Results
Do-It-Yourself Workforce Management: For Small Centers Without the Fancy Software
Contact Center Forecasting: The Fundamentals of Success