copyright © 2003 pearson education, inc.slide 20-1 prepared by shafiq jadallah to accompany...

Copyright © 2003 Pearson Education, Inc.

Slide 20-1

Prepared by Shafiq Jadallah

To Accompany

Fundamentals of Multinational FinanceFundamentals of Multinational FinanceMichael H. Moffett, Arthur I. Stonehill, David K. Eiteman

Chapter 20Chapter 20Multinational Tax ManagementMultinational Tax Management


Slide 20-2

Chapter 20Multinational Tax Management

Learning Objectives• Identify the differences between tax systems employed by

governments around the world

• Compare corporate income and withholding tax rates used across countries and the way tax treaties affect MNEs

• Explain how value added taxes are levied by some countries today

• Compare tax liabilities of domestic and foreign source income for US based firms

• Demonstrate how US based multinationals manage their excess foreign tax credits and deficits to minimize their global tax liabilities


Slide 20-3

Multinational Tax Management

Tax planning for MNE operations is extremely complex but a vital aspect of international business

The primary objective of multinational tax planning is the minimization of the firm’s worldwide tax burden


Slide 20-4

Tax Principles Tax morality – the MNE must decide whether to

follow a practice of full disclosure to tax authorities or to adopt the principle of “when in Rome, do as the Romans”

Tax neutrality – when governments levy taxes, they must consider not only the potential revenue from the tax but also the effect the proposed tax can have on private economic behavior• The ideal tax should not only raise revenue efficiently

but also have as few negative effects on economic behavior as possible


Slide 20-5

Tax Principles Domestic neutrality – the burden of taxation on each

currency unit of profit earned in the home country should equal the burden of taxation on the currency equivalent profit earned by the same firm in its foreign operations

Foreign neutrality – the tax burden on each foreign subsidiary should equal the tax burden on its competitors in the same country

Tax equity – an equitable tax that imposes the same total burden on all taxpayers who are similarly situated and located in the same tax jurisdiction


Slide 20-6

National Tax Environments


Slide 20-7


Nations typically structure their tax systems along one of two basic approaches• Worldwide approach

• Territorial approach


Slide 20-8


Worldwide approach is also referred to as the residential or national approach• It levies taxes on the income earned by firms that are

incorporated in the host country regardless of where the income was earned

Territorial approach is also termed the source approach• It focuses on the income earned by firms within the

legal jurisdiction of the host country, not the country of incorporation


Slide 20-9

National Tax Environments Tax deferral – foreign subsidiaries of MNEs pay host

country income taxes but many parent companies defer claiming additional income taxes on that foreign source income until it is remitted to the parent firm• If the worldwide approach was followed to the letter of

the law, then the tax deferral privilege would end Tax treaties provide a means of reducing double

taxation• They typically define whether taxes are to be imposed

on income earned in one country by the nationals of another country and if so, how much


Slide 20-10


Tax treaties• Tax treaties are bilateral, with the two signatories

specifying what rates are applicable to which types of income

• Tax treaties also typically result in reduced withholding tax rates

• This is important to MNEs operating foreign subsidiaries earning active income and individual investors earning passive income


Slide 20-11

Tax Types

Income Tax – many governments rely on this tax as their primary source of revenue

Withholding Tax – passive income (dividends, royalties, interest) earned by a resident of one country within the jurisdiction of a second country are normally subject to a withholding tax in the second country• Government wishes a minimum payment for earning

income within their tax jurisdiction knowing that party won’t file a tax return in the host country


Slide 20-12

Tax Types

Value-Added Tax – type of national sales tax collected at each stage of production or sale of goods in proportion to the value added during that stage

Other National Taxes – there are several other taxes levied which vary in importance from country to country• Turnover Tax – tax on purchase/sale of securities in

stock market

• Property and Inheritance Tax

• Tax on Undistributed Profits


Slide 20-13

Foreign Tax Credits To prevent double taxation, many countries grant a

foreign tax credit (FTC) for income taxes paid to the host country• FTC’s vary widely by country and are also available

for withholding taxes• Value-added taxes are typically deducted as an

expense from pre-tax income so FTCs don’t apply• A tax credit is a direct reduction of taxes that would

otherwise be due and payable– It is not a deductible expense because it does not reduce

the taxable income


Slide 20-14

Foreign Tax Credits


Slide 20-15

US Taxation of ForeignSource Income

The US applies a worldwide approach to international taxation of US MNEs, but applies a territorial approach to firms operating domestically

Dividends received from US corporate subsidiaries are fully taxable at US tax rates but with credit allowed for direct taxes paid in the foreign country


Slide 20-16

US Taxation of ForeignSource Income

The amount of foreign tax allowed as a credit depends on five tax parameters• Foreign corporate income tax rate• US corporate income tax rate• Foreign corporate dividend withholding tax rate for

non-residents• Proportion of ownership held by US corporation in the

foreign firm• Proportion of net income distributed, the dividend

payout rate


Slide 20-17

US Taxation of Foreign

Source Income


Slide 20-18

Excess Foreign Tax Credits If a US based MNE receives income from a foreign

subsidiary that imposes higher corporate tax rates than the US, total creditable taxes will exceed US taxes on that foreign income

This results in excess foreign tax credits There are three basic ways to manage tax liabilities in

order to minimize the MNE’s tax liability• Foreign tax credit limitation• Tax credit carry-forward/carry-back• Foreign tax averaging


Slide 20-19

Excess Foreign Tax Credits

Foreign tax credit limitation• The amount of credit a taxpayer can use in any one

year is limited to the US tax on that foreign income

• Foreign tax credits cannot be used to reduce taxes levied on domestic income

• The total foreign tax creditable is limited according to this formula

income on total tax x USincome taxabletotal

income xableforeign ta totallimit tax Creditable


Slide 20-20

Excess Foreign Tax Credits Tax credit carry-forward/carry-back

• Excess FTCs may be carried forward five years and carried back two years against similar tax liabilities

– Unfortunately, since excess FTC arise from differing taxes, and tax rates change slowly, a firm may experience an excess FTC year after year

Tax averaging• In the US, it is possible to offset foreign tax credits

derived from one source against another assuming that they are from the same type of income

• This is termed tax averaging


Slide 20-21

Excess Foreign Tax Credits

Tax averaging• This means that if income is derived from a high-tax

country, creating excess FTCs, these credits can be used against a deficit FTC position from repatriating income from a low-tax country

• The difficulty is the inability to average across different types of income


Slide 20-22

Subpart F Income

In 1962, the US government amended the rule that US shareholders do not pay US taxes on foreign source income until the income is remitted by creating the special subpart F income

This revision was created to prevent the use of arrangements between operating and base companies located in tax havens as a means of deferring US taxes


Slide 20-23

Subpart F Income

Subpart F Income is subject to immediate US taxation even when not remitted

It is income that includes• Passive income

• Income from insurance of US risks

• Financial service income

• Shipping income

• Oil-related income

• Certain related party sales and service income


Slide 20-24

Branch versus LocallyIncorporated Subsidiary

As an MNE chooses whether to organize a foreign subsidiary as a branch or as locally incorporated subsidiary, both tax and non-tax consequences must be considered

One major tax consideration is whether or not the subsidiary will operate at a loss for several years• If so, it might be preferable to organize it as a branch to permit

the parent to consolidate the losses for tax purposes The second consideration is the net tax burden after paying

withholding taxes on dividends• A branch’s income would only bear the burden of income tax in

its host-country and is concurrently consolidated with the parent with no foreign corporate income tax or withholding tax


Slide 20-25

Tax Haven Subsidiaries andOffshore Financial Centers

Many MNEs have foreign subsidiaries that act as tax havens for corporate funds awaiting reinvestment or repatriation

Tax haven subsidiaries are usually located in countries that meet the following requirements• Low tax on foreign investment or sales income earned by

resident corporations and a low dividend withholding tax paid to parent

• Stable currency to permit easy conversion of funds; can be met by permitting and facilitating use of Eurocurrenies

• Facilities to support financial services (i.e. communications, reputable banking services, etc.)

• Stable government that encourages the establishment of foreign owned financial and service facilities within its borders


Slide 20-26

Tax Haven Subsidiaries andOffshore Financial Centers


Slide 20-27

Foreign Sales Corporations

Foreign Sales Corporations (FSC) were introduced in the Tax Reform Act of 1984 as a device to provide tax-exempt income for US persons or corporations having export oriented activities• Exempt foreign trade income of an FSC is not subject

to US income taxes and is income from foreign sources that is not connected to the conduct of trade within the US

– Exempt income is limited to 34% of the FSC’s total income


Slide 20-28

US Taxation – Summary Points

U.S.-BasedMultinational Enterprise

Subsidiary A:Earning

Passive Income

Subsidiary B:Earning

Active Income

Subsidiary C:Earning

Active Income

Income will betaxed by U.S.

tax authoritiesas earned,

regardless ofremittance.

U.S. tax gross-upresults in excessforeign tax credit

U.S. tax gross-upresults in deficitforeign tax credit

U.S. tax authoritiestax only upon remittance.

If same “income basket” tax credit applied to tax deficit

Foreign-Source Income Domestic-Source Income

Foreign and domestic sourceincome categories are separable.

Tax credits or debits in onecategory cannot be applied in the other.

U.S. taxation of foreign-source income depends

on its classificationas either Active or Passive.


Slide 20-29

Tax Management at Trident Trident (the hypothetical MNE) has operations in

Brazil and Germany and must manage its taxes when remitting income from these subsidiaries• The corporate tax rate in Germany is 40%, higher than

the US rate of 35%– Because this rate is higher, the US parent will realize

excess FTCs

• The corporate tax rate in Brazil is 25%, thus the parent will not realize FTCs

• Management would like to manage the dividend remittances to match the credits with the deficits


Slide 20-30

Tax Management at Trident

Efficient managementof Trident’s foreign taxposition requires it to

try and balance Deficit Foreign Tax

Credits againstExcess Foreign Tax Credits

Trident BrazilPays corporate income taxes

in Brazil of 25%

Dividend remitted after-tax

Has paid less than US taxrequirement of 35% on income

Declares a dividend to its US parent

Withholding taxes are deductedfrom the dividend before leavingBrazil of an additional 5%

Trident USAPays corporate income taxesin the United States of 35%

Deficit Foreign Tax Credit

Trident GermanyPays corporate income taxes

in Germany of 40%

Withholding taxes are deductedfrom the dividend before leavingGermany of an additional 10%

Dividend remitted after-tax

Has paid more than US taxrequirement of 35% on income

Declares a dividend to its US parent

Excess Foreign Tax Credit


Slide 20-31

Summary of Learning Objectives Nations typically structure their tax systems along one of two

basic approaches: the worldwide approach or the territorial approach

Both approaches are attempts to determine which firms, foreign or domestic by incorporation, or which incomes are subject to the taxation of the host country

The worldwide approach levies taxes on the income earned by firms that are incorporated in the host country, regardless of where the income was earned

The territorial approach focuses on the income earned by firms within the legal jurisdiction of the host country, not the country of incorporation


Slide 20-32

Summary of Learning Objectives

A network of bilateral tax treaties provides a means of reducing double taxation

Tax treaties normally define whether taxes are to be imposed on income earned in one country by the nationals of another, and if so, how. Tax treaties are bilateral with two signatories specifying what rates are applicable to which type of income

The value-added tax is a type of national sales tax collected at each stage of production or sale of goods in proportion to the value added during that stage


Slide 20-33

Summary of Learning Objectives The US differentiates foreign source income from domestic

source income; each is taxed separately and tax credits/deficits in one category may not be used against credits/deficits in another category

If a US based MNE receives income from a foreign country that imposes higher taxes than that of the US, total creditable taxes will exceed the US taxes on that foreign income. The result is excess foreign tax credits

All firms wish to manage their tax liabilities globally so that they don’t end up paying more on foreign sourced income than they do on domestic sourced income

copyright © 2003 pearson education, inc.slide 20-1 prepared by shafiq jadallah to accompany...

Documents

tax jurisdiction slide

tax systems

tax principles tax morality

ideal tax

proposed tax

equitable tax

tax authorities

country tax equity