copyright 2004 monash university ims1805 systems analysis week 1: understanding systems analysis
Post on 22-Dec-2015
216 views
TRANSCRIPT
Copyright 2004 Monash University2
Agenda
Aims: • To introduce the unit and the way it will be taught• To develop an understanding of the basic concepts of
analysis as a human activity, and to prepare the ground for the rest of the unit
Unit Administration Teaching the unit Analysis
• what is it?• what forms does it take?• why do we do it?• who does it?
Copyright 2004 Monash University3
1. Introductions
Lecturer and Unit Leader - Martin Atchison Tutors:
• Martin Atchison• Anne Hamilton• Manoj Kathpalia
Class
Copyright 2004 Monash University4
Unit Administration: General
See unit outline No more handouts! Use the web site For tutorial allocation, use Allocate+ To change into a tute which is full, find someone
who is prepared to swap with you If you have a problem with tutorial allocation,
talk to your tutor
Copyright 2004 Monash University5
Unit Administration:Help with Problems or Complaints Fellow students Tutor Lecturer Unit Leader Undergraduate co-ordinator (Kathy Lynch) Associate Head of School (Chris Gonsalvez) Head of School (Graham Farr) etc
Copyright 2004 Monash University6
2. Teaching the unit
See unit outline for details of official teaching objectives and content
Your objectives My objectives Possible teaching approaches Proposed teaching format Lecture and tute materials
Copyright 2004 Monash University7
Problems you may have
With the unit• It seems too easy (conceptually simple)• It seems too hard (practically impossible)• You can’t see the point of it; it doesn’t seem to apply
to anything• You can’t find the limits to it; it seems to include
everything With me
• I talk too much (and too fast)• I use obscure examples• I expect too much of you
Copyright 2004 Monash University8
Problems I may have
With the unit• Too much to get through• Material too complex (or too apparently simple)• Too hard to explain (in both its simplicity and its
complexity)• I know it too well to be able to explain it well
With you• You won’t get interested• You won’t do the work• You won’t understand
Copyright 2004 Monash University9
Teaching perspectives
The view from outer space The view from 10,000 metres The view from 500 metres The view from 20 metres The view from ground level
Copyright 2004 Monash University10
My expectations
You will develop a sound understanding of the basic concepts of analysis
You will develop an understanding of how these concepts are applied in practice through various analytical techniques
You will develop the ability to carry out some basic analytical techniques
You won’t become an expert (and may start to feel that you never will!)
Copyright 2004 Monash University11
Teaching method
Lectures – role and purpose Tutorials – role and purpose Teaching sequence:
• Teach then do?• Do then teach?• … Teach - Do – Teach – Do – Teach - Do - ….
Copyright 2004 Monash University12
3. Analysing Analysis
To Analyse: “To take to pieces; to separate, distinguish, or ascertain the elements of anything complex, as a material collection, chemical compound, light, sound, a miscellaneous list, account or statement, a sentence, phrase, word, conception, feeling, action, process, etc.”
(OED online) How much time do you spend doing analysis each day?
Copyright 2004 Monash University13
Examples of analysis in action
Instinctive analysis Learned informal analysis Learned formal analysis
Copyright 2004 Monash University14
Informal analysis versus formal analysis
Informal analysis Intuitive, instinctive Based on learned
behaviour/previous experiences
Inductive Internalised Techniques used but
not explicit
Formal analysis Rational, structured Based on formal logic
Deductive Externalised Based on techniques
Copyright 2004 Monash University15
Key elements of analysis
1. Observation/perception: Gathering information about the object/situation
2. Discrimination/selection: Choosing what is important and what isn’t; focussing on the key factors within context
3. Identification/Comprehension: Identifying relationships and patterns; establishing causal relationships and connections
4. Representation: Describing and modelling the object of analysis
Copyright 2004 Monash University17
Human beings as analysts
In certain respects, we are analytical machines:
• Our input devices
• Our processing device
• Our storage device
• Our output devices
Doing analysis is fundamental to our nature and existence; it distinguishes us from other creatures
(Consider a baby as an analyst; Consider Tom Hanks in ‘Castaway’)
Copyright 2004 Monash University18
Does analysis matter? Human beings are creatures of habit; we
like to use familiar standard behaviour patterns and responses
Action is easy; analysis and understanding can be hard
Stable environments – established patterns work; the less the need for formal analysis
Unstable environments – the greater the likelihood that established patterns will not work; the greater the need for analysis
What are the consequences of action based on an inaccurate understanding?
Copyright 2004 Monash University19
The need for formal analysis: Problem-related factors
Because the situation is too complex for informal analysis to work:
• Many elements; many inter-relationships, complex inter-relationships; many possible outcomes; etc
Because the need to get it exactly right is so great that we cannot risk using informal analysis
Because we need to communicate our understanding of the situation to others
Because the environment is changing and we want to make sure our current understanding will continue to be accurate
Because we want to develop and use tools to help automate parts of the analysis
Copyright 2004 Monash University20
The need for formal analysis: Person-related factors
Because the situation is unfamiliar to us and we cannot rely on instinct or previous experience
Because we want to learn and improve our understanding of the object/situation
Because we want to change parts of the object/situation to improve outcomes
Copyright 2004 Monash University22
Informal analysis
We can’t stop ourselves from doing it! We do it all the time! We all have basic skills at a wide range of
informal analytical tasks (but a wide variation in the highest level of skill we can achieve)
Our ability to perform different types of informal analysis is heavily dependent on our personality and physical attributes (which are hard to change)
Experience and attitude can help to varying degrees depending on the analytical task
Copyright 2004 Monash University23
Formal analysis
Most formal analysis requires formal training Many simple formal analytical techniques are
learnt very early in life by most people More advanced techniques need to be learnt and
practised Differences in personality and mental make-up
influence how well we can do different types of formal analysis
The need to learn and practise means our attitudes towards analysis strongly influence how skilled we become
Copyright 2004 Monash University24
What skills/attitudes are neededin a good analyst?
• Skill at informal analysis does not necessarily correlate with skill at formal analysis
Different types of analysis require different skills and aptitudes
Consider in more detail tomorrow