copyright © 2005 global insight sector risk ratings a unique tool for active sector-based risk...
Post on 21-Dec-2015
213 views
TRANSCRIPT
Copyright © 2005 Global Insight
Sector Risk Ratings
A Unique Tool for Active Sector-Based Risk Management
2
Introduction to Global Insight’s World Industry Service (WIS) Sector Risk Ratings (SRR)
Why Focus on Sector-Level Risk? Quantifies the sector impact on credit quality relative to that from country or geography Accommodates the greater role of global supply chains and trade in business operations Sector benchmarks link macroeconomic events to impacts on companies and portfolios New Basle II regulations—new requirements for internal risk measures and controls Current phase of business cycle portends changes in credit quality & bankruptcies
What are WIS Sector Risk Ratings? SRR are derived from WIS’ globally consistent sector benchmarks and forecasts
SRR indicate changes in sector-level credit quality across countries and industries Validation of SRR with bond defaults and corporate bankruptcies, country and globally
How to Use WIS Sector Risk Ratings? Monitor changes in risk ratings across sectors and within a set of countries/geographies
Use framework and navigation facilitates to “drill down” for more granular information on “flagged” sectors or countries
Perform stress testing and correlations for active portfolio risk management Quantitative drivers for forecasting loss reserve requirements, bankruptcies, and defaults
3
What Are WIS Sector Risk Ratings (SRR)?
Comparative metrics for each sector and country, history and forecast
Globally consistent sector benchmarks of credit and operating risks
Ratings are created from structural and cyclical indicators that conform
with standard credit risk frameworks
User-friendly tool for risk management and stress testing
Scientific, transparent construct, and long track record
SRR Measure and Rank Sector-Based Credit and Operating Risks
Unique SRR methodology provides globally consistent, forward-looking benchmarks of credit quality for each sector and country
A composite rating from lowest (1) to highest (10) is created for each sector, built up from 40 separate risk factors
4
Growth Risk Growth in real revenue Growth in sales Volatility, turning points
Profitability Risk Pricing strength Operating profitability Free cash flow and variability Return on invested capital Fixed asset turnover Degree of operating leverage
Supply Risk Capital intensity Capacity overhang Depreciation cost of sales
Market Structure Risk Industry structure Dependence on suppliers and customers Dependence on energy and labor Barriers to entry and exit Technology and substitution
Economic & Country Risk Sector cyclicality Sector interest rate sensitivity Country-level sovereign risks (From
Global Insight’s Global Risk Service):– Exchange rate– Equity markets– Regulation policy– Tax policy
Composite Risk Ratings Are Built Up from 40 Individual Risk Factors that Reflect and Predict Changes in Credit Quality
Sector risk factors are derived from the standard credit risk framework used in corporate lending and fixed income portfolios
Sector risk factors show the influence of industry structure, stage in lifecycle, and sovereign/ macroeconomic environment on industry risk profiles
5
The Top-Down Consistency and Credit Framework of WIS SRR Provide Sector Benchmarks that Complement Traditional Bottom-Up Analysis
SRRs Provide a “Top-Down” Complement to Standard “Bottom-Up” Credit Risk Frameworks for Corporates
• Risk ratings and underlying data are credit benchmarks for companies, “peer groups,” and portfolios
• Risk metrics include income statement and cash flow items, metrics of industry structure, and commercial environment
• Transmit “high-level” macro economic events down to sector-level risks and credit benchmarks
• Link macro and industry views directly to portfolio exposures for simulation, stress testing, and active risk management
Credit Risk Framework Top Down Bottom UpMacro & Sector Company Financials
A) Internal Liquidity & Solvency Poor Good
B) Business & Operational Risk Excellent Average
Growth Risk Excellent Average
Operational Characteristics Excellent Good
Oversupply Risk Good AverageC) Industry Risk Excellent Average
Industry Structure Risk Excellent Good
Sector's Political & Economic Risk Excellent Average
D) Financial Risk Average Good
Capital Structure Average Excellent
Rating & Equity Risk Good Good
E) External & Market Liquidity Excellent Average
F) Country & FX Risk Excellent ---
6
Example of Composite Risk Rating for One Sector Shown Over Time and Across Several Geographies
(Sector Ratings between 1 and 10 — Least to Most Risk)
3
4
5
6
7
8
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005E
2006E
2007E
U.S. EMU U.K.
Global Insight’s Sector Risk Ratings Show the Level and Direction of Change in Sector Risks Over Time and Across Countries
• Composite SRR shows the level and direction of operating and credit risks.
• Which geographies lead into or lag behind global sector risk changes?
• What is the outlook for future sector risk migrations?
• How does the outlook compare with historical performances?
Communication Equipment
7
Change in Risk Measures
Sector Risk Levels:
Falling Risk
Static Risk
Rising Risk
Low Risk
Moderate Risk
Yellow Flag
High Risk Potential
Recovery?
Red Flag
WIS Sector Risk Ratings Facilitate Active Management of Sector-Based Credit Risks
Which Sectors Have High Risk Profiles?Which Sectors Are Improving or Deteriorating? • Monitor Sector Risk
Profiles through changes in the composite risk ratings
• Flag strategic sectors or ones with changing risk profiles for deeper investigation
• “Drill down” to the 40 individual sub-factors and underlying sector data to see the drivers for changing risk profiles
• Compare sector risk factors on a global and country basis, compare risks across sectors
8
Color-Coded Monitor of Changes in Sector Risk Rankings: Example of Within One Country Over Time
ISIC Sector Description
ISIC Code
2004 Sales (Mill US $)
2005 Composite Risk Rating
2005 Rank* of Composite Risk Rating
Change in Rating**: 2006 – 2004
Change in 2006*** Composite Risk Rating
Basic Industrial Chemicals
3511 119912 5.4 46 0.9 -0.4
Computing Machinery
3825 73015 5.6 49 -1 -0.8
Energy Mining 2a 258486 6.6 70 2.3 -0.1
Watches & Clocks
3853 724 6.6 68 -0.3 0.5
US Example of WIS Sector Risk Ratings with Rankings Across Industries
** Represents the change in Composite Risk over the specified time periods
High Risk Sectors (6.1 — 10.0) expected to Improve
High Risk Sectors (6.1 — 10.0) expected to Degenerate
Moderate Risk Sectors (4.6 — 6.0) expected to Degenerate*** Represents the change in Composite Risk from the previous forecast
* Represents the rank for a given sector across all 71 industries
9
Use Navigator to “Drill Sown” to 40 Individual Risk Factors to Investigate Changes in Sector Risk Profiles
WIS SRR Navigator Allows Easy “Point-and-Click” Web Access to all of the Sector Risk Rating Factors and Benchmarks For All Countries, All Sectors Global Insight offers a variety
of methods for access to the WIS and the Sector Risk Ratings. One of them is the WIS Sector Risk Ratings (SRR) Navigator
The WIS SRR Navigator provides easy point-and-click access to the Risk Ratings, both history and forecast
Data retrieval results are displayed in Microsoft® Excel, and queries can be saved for easy update and alteration
WIS SRR Navigator supplies instant, Web-based updates
10
WIS Sector Risk Ratings Correlate with Standard Measures of Credit Quality
Composite Risk Ratings Have Current and Leading Indicator Relationships with Corporate Bankruptcies (Correlation Coefficient over 1990-2003)
0.000.100.200.300.400.500.600.700.800.90
Japan Germany UK
Contemporary Correlation between Composite Risk Rating & Corporate Bunkruptcy
Year Ahead Correlation between Composite Risk Rating & Corporate Bankruptcy
All of the data shown are available in Global Insight data bases
Source: World Industry Service Sector Risk Rationgs; UK National Statistics, Financial Statistics Freestanding Table Number: fsfreFSF, Total Company Insolvencies; Japan - Release by Teikoku Data Bank, Business Failures, Total Number of Cases; Germany - Statistisches Bundesamt Business Failures, Total Company Insolvencies;
11
0.40
0.50
0.60
0.70
0.80
0.90
Fran
ce
Japa
n
Sw
eden
Nor
way
Ger
man
y
Finl
and
Several of the WIS Ratings Components Correlate Well with Bankruptcies (Example of Revenue Growth Risk Factor)
Correlation Coefficient Between the Number of Corporate Bankruptcies and the Sub-factor for Real Revenue Risk Ratings, the “All Corporate” Sector (1993-2004)
• “Real revenue” growth is consistently correlated with corporate bankruptcies across a variety of countries
• This is despite each country having its own unique definition of bankruptcies
• Norway: # of bankruptcies proceedings commenced; Finland: # of bankruptcy proceedings instituted; Germany: # of bankruptcies resolved
Source: World Industry Service; Teikoku Data Bank, Statistisches Bundesamt, INSEE, Statistics Norway, Statistica Centralbyran, Statistics Finland
12
0.40
0.50
0.60
0.70
0.80
Co
nst
ruct
ion
Ch
emic
alIn
du
stri
es
Lea
ther
Pro
du
cts
Wo
od
Pro
du
cts
Tra
nsp
ort
atio
n
Wh
ole
sale
&R
etai
l Tra
de
Mac
hin
ery
WIS Sector Risk Ratings Correlate with Sector-Level Bankruptcies in Japan
Correlation Coefficient Between the Number of Bankruptcies in a Sector and WIS Composite Risk Rating in the Same Sector in Japan (1990-2004)
Source: Source: World Industry Service; World Industry Service; Teikoku Data BankTeikoku Data Bank
13
0.00
0.10
0.20
0.30
0.40
0.50
0.60
0.70
0.80
0.90
1993-1998 1993-2000 1993-2004
Contemporary Correlation between Composite Risk Rating & Corporate Bunkruptcy
Year Ahead Correlation between Composite Risk Rating & Corporate Bankruptcy
WIS Sector Risk Ratings’ Correlation with Bankruptcies in Germany Is Stronger in Recent Years
“Current year” and “year ahead” correlation coefficient between the total number of insolvencies in Germany and the WIS Composite Risk Rating for the total corporate sector
Sector Risk Ratings Anticipate Changes in Germany’s Corporate Insolvencies
Source: World Industry Service; Statistisches Bundesamt Business Failures, Total Company Number Insolvencies
14
Global Insight’s Composite Risk Ratings and Bond Default Rates in North America
3
3.4
3.8
4.2
4.6
5
19
90
19
91
19
92
19
93
19
94
19
95
19
96
19
97
19
98
19
99
20
00
20
01
20
02
20
03
20
04
20
05
E
20
06
E
20
07
E0
1
2
3
4
5
Global Insight's Composite Risk Rating for NorthAmerica Corporate Sector (LHS)
Moody's North America All-Corp. Bond IssuerDefault Rate (RHS)
WIS Sector Risk Ratings Correlate Well with Bond Default Rates in North America
0.00
0.10
0.20
0.30
0.40
0.50
0.60
0.70
0.80
0.90
1990-2004
1995-2004
2000-2004
Correlation Coefficient Between WIS Composite Risk Rating for North America’s Corporate Sector and
Moody’s Bond Default Rate In North America
Source: World Industry Service, Moody‘s Investors Service Global Credit Research
15
Global Insight’s Composite Risk Ratings and Bond Default Rates in Europe & CIS
3.6
3.8
4
4.2
4.4
4.6
4.8
5
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
E
2006
E
2007
E
2008
E
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
1-year Ahead WIS Composite Risk Rating for All European(incl. CIS) Private Non-Ag Sectors (LHS)
Moody's European All-Corp. Bond Issuer Default Rate (RHS)
WIS Sector Risk Ratings Correlate Well with Bond Default Rates in Europe and the CIS
0.00
0.10
0.20
0.30
0.40
0.50
0.60
0.70
0.80
0.90
1994-2004 1999-2004 2001-2004
Correlation Coefficient Between WIS Composite Risk Rating for European
Corporate Sector and Moody's Corporate Bond Issuer Default Rate in Europe & CIS
Source: World Industry Service, Moody‘s Investors Service Global Credit Research
16
WIS Composite Sector Risk Ratings and Global Corporate Bond Issuer Default Counts Globally
3
3.5
4
4.5
5
5.5
6
6.5
7
19
92
19
93
19
94
19
95
19
96
19
97
19
98
19
99
20
00
20
01
20
02
20
03
20
04
20
05E
20
06E
20
07E
0
25
50
75
100
125
150
175
200
WIS SRR Profitability & Pricing Risk Factor (LHS)
Bond Issuer Default Counts (RHS)
WIS Sector Risk Rating Factors Correlate Well with Bond Default Counts Globally
0.000.100.200.300.400.500.600.700.800.90
1992-2004 1999-2004 2001-2004
Current Year Correlation
Year Ahead Correlation
Correlation Coefficient Between WIS Profitability/Pricing Risk and Bond
Issuer Default Counts Globally
Source: World Industry Service; Moody‘s Investors Service Global Credit Research
17
Sector Risk Ratings Help Evaluate and Anticipate Changes in Credit Profiles of Companies and Portfolios
Quantify the Risk Profile of Key Sectors in a Loan or Bond Portfolio Is portfolio risk high or low? Is it improving or deteriorating? Identify groups of correlated industries that improve/deteriorate together Use rigorous framework for evaluating diversification and strategy
Monitor and Anticipate Changes in Sector Credit Quality Monitor composite ratings, flag sectors to “drill down” for deeper investigation
– Which risk factors are driving the change?– What is the geographical composition of the sector change?
Stress test the portfolio through simulation and “what if” scenarios
Forecast Changes in Bankruptcies, Defaults, and Loan Loss Requirements For individual sectors as well as for entire portfolio
Use SRR as Sector Benchmark for Corporate Credit Research Compare company risk prospects to that of its own sector peer group Analyze market prospects for key client markets into which it sells product
18
WIS SRR Provides a Framework for Stress Testing Credit Portfolios Under Variety of Scenarios and Conditions
Evaluate the Impact of Stress Factors on Portfolio Credit Quality Given Certain Hypothetical Macroeconomic, Government Policy, and Industry-Specific Events
Derive the sector and portfolio impact of internal “house views” Analyze the potential impact on portfolio values of unlikely but
plausible events Evaluate expected portfolio losses over a given time horizon,
assess the capital adequacy of individual firms and industries Research the migration of the company credit ratings, changes in
expected losses, and economic capital on the industry level Address shortcomings of value-at-risk analysis
References for Stress Testing of Portfolios: Lopez, J., 2005 “Stress Tests: Useful Complements to Financial Risk Models”, FRBSF Economic Letter, June 2005, http://www.frbsf.org/publications/economics/letter/2005/el2005-14.html
Sorge, M. 2004. "Stress-Testing Financial Systems: An Overview of Current Methodologies." Working paper no. 165, Monetary and Economic Department, Bank for International Settlements. http://www.bis.org/publ/work165.htm
19
WIS SRR Uses Two Common Techniques for Stress Testing of Sectors and Custom Portfolios
Global Insight Can Help: Develop rationale and design for
macro- and industry-level scenarios and simulations for the purpose of assessing impacts on credit quality in portfolio segments
Use our tools and economic models to simulate sensitivity tests and macro environments; derive the sector impacts on sales, pricing, profits, and capex; and calculate the changes in Sector Risk Ratings and the credit prospects for sectors and portfolios
Quantify likely changes in migration patterns in sector credit quality
1) Scenario Tests Risk managers identify portfolio’s key financial drivers and then formulate scenarios in which these drivers are stressed beyond standard VAR levels
Event-driven approach analysis addresses the manner in which plausible but unlikely events might affect the risk factors relevant to a portfolio
2) Sensitivity TestsAssess the impact of large movements in financial variables on portfolios without specifying the reasons for such movements
Examples include a 100-basis-point increase across the yield curve and a sudden, 20% depreciation of currency
20
Typical Process for Stress Testing Portfolios — Flow Chart of Basic Steps for Stress Testing
Common Stress Factors include:
• Oil prices• GDP growth• Inflation• Interest rate• Currency• Policy
Use Impacts on Sector Sales, Profits, Capex, Free Cash Flow, and SRR Factors to Derive Changes in Credit Quality for Sectors and Custom Portfolios
Calculate impacts on key Financial Ratios Used in Agency Ratings:
• EBITDA interest coverage• Operating margins• Free cash flow/total debt• Return on invested capital
Use Global Insight’s Economic Models of Macro and Industry to Calculate the Response to a Range of Scenarios
WIS provides the link between macroeconomic scenarios and performance of portfolio exposures
Project movements in default migration
Develop groups of industries that are hurt or helped by scenarios
Simulate changes in sector correlations
Identify Stress Factors
Simulate Macro Models to Derive Industry Drivers
Simulation of Industry
Performances
Asses Impact On SRR and
PortfolioCredit Quality
21
Why Use Global Insight for Sector Risk Ratings?
The SRR framework has been designed, tested, and used extensively by a number of banks in the United States and Europe for over 10 years. The original product, and subsequent improvements, were designed in collaboration with our banking clients and the RMA
Quantitative rigor provides a critical component for analysis and risk strategy; it provides a between link sector risk measures and custom portfolio analytics, active risk management
Unique and globally consistent coverage of all sectors in all countries
Global Insight is a global leader in custom analysis and sector stress testing
The product is delivered via Global Insight’s Web site, with easy navigation and monitoring of results across risk dimensions; includes telephone access to sector and country analysts
22
Please contact us for a personal demonstration!
More Information?
Mark Killion, CFAManaging Director, World Industry [email protected]
Natasha MuravytskaEconomist, World Industry [email protected]