copyright © 2012 by k&l gates llp. all rights reserved. international trade issues in mergers...
TRANSCRIPT
Copyright © 2012 by K&L Gates LLP. All rights reserved.
International Trade Issues in Mergers & Acquisitions (Everything Corporate Lawyers Wanted to Know About International Trade, But Were Afraid to Ask)
Presentation to the New Jersey Corporate Counsel Association
Daniel J. Gerkin, Of Counsel, K&L Gates LLP, Washington, DCDarlene Lapola, In-House Counsel, Avis Budget Group, Inc.Marina Solo, Of Counsel, K&L Gates LLP, Newark, NJJerome J. Zaucha, Partner, K&L Gates LLP, Washington, DC
December 13, 2012
2
Introduction
Companies contemplating mergers and acquisitions with international implications must be mindful of the potential international trade issues associated with the proposed transaction
This presentation will highlight some of the key international trade issues to consider in connection with a potential merger or acquisition, including the following topics:
Notification, Amendment, and Approval Requirements
Due Diligence
Approaches for Dealing with Results of Due Diligence
Evaluation of Potential Impact of Trade Regulations on Post-Acquisition Operation of Business
3
Notification, Amendment, and Approval Requirements
4
Notification, Amendment, and Approval Requirements
If target operates in a regulated industry, consider whether U.S. Government agency imposes any requirements/ restrictions, such as:
The U.S. Department of Agriculture Agricultural land
The U.S. Department of Transportation Air carriers Merchant shipping vessels
The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) Radio licenses
The Federal Reserve Board/The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency
Banks
5
Acquisitions implicating national security considerations
The Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States (“CFIUS”)
U.S. Department of Defense, Defense Security Service (“DSS”)
U.S. Department of State, Directorate of Defense Trade Controls (“DDTC”)
Entities holding licenses/authorizations from U.S. Government International Traffic in Arms Regulations (“ITAR”) Export Administration Regulations (“EAR”) Bonds held in connection with acting as importer of record
Notification, Amendment, and Approval Requirements (cont’d)
5
6
Notification, Amendment, and Approval Requirements (cont’d)
Acquisitions implicating national security considerations (cont’d) The CFIUS
The CFIUS, an interagency committee chaired by the U.S. Department of the Treasury, conducts reviews of proposed mergers, acquisitions or takeovers, of U.S. persons by foreign interests under Section 721 of the Defense Production Act.
Definition of “covered transaction” Treatment in transaction documents
The CFIUS review is a voluntary process and affords an opportunity to foreign persons and U.S. persons entering into a transaction to submit the proposed transaction for review by CFIUS to assess the impact of the transaction on U.S. national security.
Overview of review, investigation, and Presidential review periods
7
Notification, Amendment, and Approval Requirements (cont’d)
Acquisitions implicating national security considerations (cont’d) The CFIUS (cont’d)
Although filing a notice of a transaction with CFIUS is voluntary, CFIUS can initiate a review unilaterally and can compel the production of necessary information regarding the terms of any covered transaction
If CFIUS is not satisfied that national security concerns can be mitigated, it can recommend that the President suspend or prohibit such a transaction, and the President may order divestment if the transaction has been completed, regardless of whether a notice was filed
8
Notification, Amendment, and Approval Requirements (cont’d)
Acquisitions implicating national security considerations (cont’d) The CFIUS (cont’d)
Recent examples: Dubai Ports World – acquisition of company that operated
various U.S. port facilities by Dubai company Firstgold Corp. – failed acquisition of Nevada-based mining
concern Ralls Corporation – President invoked national-security
concerns to prevent a firm owned by two Chinese nationals from acquiring four wind-farm projects in Oregon
9
Notification, Amendment, and Approval Requirements (cont’d)
Acquisitions implicating national security considerations (cont’d) DSS
A Company is considered to be operating under Foreign Ownership, Control, or Influence (“FOCI”) whenever a foreign interest has the power, direct or indirect, whether or not exercised, and whether or not exercisable, to direct or decide matters affecting the management or operations of that company in a manner which may result in unauthorized access to classified information or may adversely affect the performance of classified contracts.
5 percent ownership threshold (SF-328)
10
Notification, Amendment, and Approval Requirements (cont’d)
Acquisitions implicating national security considerations (cont’d) DSS (cont’d)
The following factors relating to a company, the foreign interest, and the government of the foreign interest are reviewed in the aggregate in determining whether a company is under FOCI:
Record of economic and government espionage against U.S. targets; Record of enforcement and/or engagement in unauthorized technology
transfer; The type and sensitivity of the information that shall be accessed; The source, nature and extent of FOCI; Record of compliance with pertinent U.S. laws, regulations and contracts; The nature of any bilateral and multilateral security and information
exchange agreements that may pertain; and Ownership or control, in whole or in part, by a foreign government
11
Notification, Amendment, and Approval Requirements (cont’d)
Acquisitions implicating national security considerations (cont’d) DSS (cont’d)
When a company with a facility security clearance enters into negotiations for the proposed merger, acquisition, or takeover by a foreign interest, the contractor must submit notification to DSS of the commencement of such negotiations.
The notification shall include the type of transaction under negotiation (stock purchase, asset purchase, etc.), the identity of the potential foreign investor, and a plan to mitigate/negate the FOCI consistent with paragraph 2-303, National Industrial Security Program Operating Manual (NISPOM).
FOCI Mitigation
12
Notification, Amendment, and Approval Requirements (cont’d)
Acquisitions implicating national security considerations (cont’d) DDTC
A company registered with DDTC (as a manufacturer/exporter or broker of defense articles, defense services, or related technical data) under the International Traffic in Arms Regulations (22 C.F.R. Part 120, et seq.; “ITAR”) must notify DDTC at least 60 days in advance of any intended sale or transfer of ownership or control to a foreign person
Section 122.4(b) of the ITAR CFIUS overlay; ordinarily not treated as a consent
13
Notification, Amendment, and Approval Requirements (cont’d)
Acquisitions implicating national security considerations (cont’d) DDTC (cont’d)
A company registered with DDTC under the ITAR must, within five days of the event, notify DDTC if there is a material change in the information contained in the company’s Statement of Registration, including, for example, the establishment, acquisition, or divestment of a subsidiary or foreign affiliate
Section 122.4(a)(2) of the ITAR
14
Notification, Amendment, and Approval Requirements (cont’d) In connection with offshore transactions by U.S.
companies
Exemplary jurisdictions Australia/New Zealand Brazil India
15
Due Diligence
16
Due Diligence (cont’d)
Importance/purpose of international trade due diligence relates to: Successor liability – minimizing potential liability for prior
activities of the target (Sigma Aldrich ALJ decision); Severe penalties
Ensuring proper valuation and minimize disruption; Potential for cost savings
Identifying existing and avoiding future compliance issues; Assessing timeline and cost of post-acquisition
compliance; and Assisting in integration of the target’s business into the
business of the acquiring company Substantial lead time required
17
Due Diligence (cont’d)
There are an array of issues that should be covered in any international trade due diligence Such issues go beyond penalties for prior violations by the
company being acquired
Although any due diligence inquires should be tailored to a particular transaction, the following general areas should be analyzed: The nature and type of target’s international commercial activities; The target’s affiliates, customers, agents, distributors, and export
destinations; The target’s suppliers and the nature and type and origin of raw
materials or finished goods sourced by the target Prior enforcement actions, prior disclosures, and legal advice; and Existing compliance and recordkeeping programs
18
Due Diligence
The United States traditionally substantially regulated both import and export trade, although it is becoming apparent that more and more countries are following this pattern and increasing regulations on import and export activities Accordingly, also now focus on compliance with the trade laws of other
countries
The following are examples of U.S. international trade-related issues that should be considered in connection with due diligence Export Controls
Antiboycott
Embargo Restrictions and Sanctions
Customs Compliance
Foreign Corrupt Practices Act/Anti-Money Laundering
19
Due Diligence (cont’d)
International Trade Topics to Cover (cont’d) Export Controls
Applicable laws Export Administration Regulations (15 C.F.R. Part 730, et seq.; EAR), which are
administered by BIS International Traffic in Arms Regulations (22 C.F.R. Part 120, et seq.; ITAR), which
are administered by DDTC
Brief overview of topics to cover Classification of target’s commodities, software, and/or technology Foreign national employees – I-129 work visa Export activities/licenses and other authorizations Automated Export System (AES) compliance Prior investigations, enforcement actions, and disclosures Antiboycott issues – focus on transactions in certain regions Existence of export compliance policies/procedures Prior contact with U.S. Government Results of any prior export control-related audits by the target
20
Due Diligence (cont’d)
International Trade Topics to Cover (cont’d) Embargo Restrictions and Sanctions
Applicable laws The various statutes, Executive Orders, and regulations (including 31 C.F.R. Part
500, et seq.), which are administered by OFAC Statutes and Executive Orders authorizing the imposition of sanctions on non-U.S.
persons for engaging in certain activities relating to Iran
Brief overview of topics to cover Nature of U.S. involvement in non-U.S. business activities of the target Identification of prior and ongoing dealings with countries and persons that currently
are or have, within the last five (5) years, been subject to embargo-type restrictions Nature of non-U.S. operations involving and structure of the entities engaged in
dealings with embargoed countries/persons Existing compliance policies/procedures Prior investigations, enforcement actions, and disclosures Prior contact with U.S. Government Results of any prior embargo-related audits undertaken by the target
21
Due Diligence (cont’d)
International Trade Topics to Cover (cont’d) Customs Compliance
Brief overview of topics to cover Prior applications/requests to CBP Prior investigations, enforcement actions, and disclosures Existing compliance policies/procedures Identification of imports into the United States
Importer of record Classification (e.g., Pharmaceutical Appendix) Valuation Country of origin (e.g., API) Preferential trade programs Customs brokers and bonds
Prior contact with U.S. Government Results of any prior customs-related audits undertaken by the target
22
Due Diligence (cont’d)
International Trade Topics to Cover (cont’d) Foreign Corrupt Practices Act
Brief overview of topics to cover Identification of target’s practices with respect to foreign agents,
consultants, and distributors Existing manuals and compliance procedures Possible violations Prior investigation and enforcement matters Prior contact with U.S. Government Results of any prior audits undertaken by the target Nature of non-U.S. operations
23
Due Diligence (cont’d)
International Trade Topics to Cover (cont’d) Other
Government Contracts Facility Security Clearances
Issues relating to classified information
24
Notification, Amendment, and Approval Considerations
25
Notification, Amendment, and Approval Considerations U.S. Regulatory Issues Offshore Regulatory Issues
Regional/Local Counsel
26
Approaches for Dealing with Results of Due Diligence
27
Approaches for Dealing with Results of Due Diligence
There are a number of approaches for dealing with violations discovered in connection with due diligence Valuation reduction Escrow – sum of money withheld from sales price to offset costs
associated with potential penalties for violations Require target to file voluntary disclosure with relevant U.S.
Government agency prior to closing Buyer can make closing terms contingent upon outcome of action on
voluntary disclosure Indemnification (possibly in conjunction with a post-closing voluntary
prior disclosure) Require post-closing cooperation in connection with future audits etc. Earn-out where the parameters are defined by losses resulting from
penalties and audits Stripping “offending” assets out of the transaction or isolating them in a
separate acquisition vehicle or cancellation of transaction altogether
28
Evaluation of Potential Impact of Trade Regulations on Post-Acquisition Operation of Business
29
Evaluation of Potential Impact of Trade Regulations on Post-Acquisition Operation of Business
International trade issues may impact the feasibility/objective of a potential merger or acquisition
Because of substantial restrictions that can apply, evaluation of any such restrictions must be undertaken
For example:
Involvement of Restricted/Denied Parties
Exports of technology to country in which acquiring company is organized and/or located May not be feasible to combine target’s technology with acquiring
company’s technology
If acquisition is intended to allow acquired company to act as distributor of goods and an antidumping or countervailing duty order applies to such goods, may not be feasible
30
Questions?
31
Contact Information
Daniel J. GerkinWashington, [email protected](202) 778-9168
Darlene LapolaAvis Budget Group, [email protected]
Marina [email protected](973) 848-4129
Jerome J. Zaucha Washington, [email protected](202) 778-9013