correlation between electrical resistivity …...case study 2 3 wattenberg field * geology the...

21
Naser Tamimi Reservoir Characterization Project, Colorado School of Mines, Golden, CO SIGMA 3 (Sigma Cubed Inc.), Englewood, CO November 2015 1 CORRELATION BETWEEN ELECTRICAL RESISTIVITY AND ANISOTROPIC ELASTIC PROPERTIES OF PIERRE SHALE, WATTENBURG FIELD, COLORADO

Upload: others

Post on 31-Jul-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: CORRELATION BETWEEN ELECTRICAL RESISTIVITY …...Case Study 2 3 WATTENBERG FIELD * Geology The Wattenberg Field is located in NE of Denver. 4 CROSS SECTION MAP VIEW VIEW Top of the

Naser Tamimi

Reservoir Characterization Project, Colorado School of Mines, Golden, CO

SIGMA3 (Sigma Cubed Inc.), Englewood, CO

November 2015

1

CORRELATION BETWEEN ELECTRICAL RESISTIVITY AND ANISOTROPIC ELASTIC PROPERTIES OF PIERRE SHALE,

WATTENBURG FIELD, COLORADO

Page 2: CORRELATION BETWEEN ELECTRICAL RESISTIVITY …...Case Study 2 3 WATTENBERG FIELD * Geology The Wattenberg Field is located in NE of Denver. 4 CROSS SECTION MAP VIEW VIEW Top of the

Case Study

2

Page 3: CORRELATION BETWEEN ELECTRICAL RESISTIVITY …...Case Study 2 3 WATTENBERG FIELD * Geology The Wattenberg Field is located in NE of Denver. 4 CROSS SECTION MAP VIEW VIEW Top of the

3

WATTENBERG FIELD

*

Geology

The Wattenberg Field is located in NE of Denver.

Page 4: CORRELATION BETWEEN ELECTRICAL RESISTIVITY …...Case Study 2 3 WATTENBERG FIELD * Geology The Wattenberg Field is located in NE of Denver. 4 CROSS SECTION MAP VIEW VIEW Top of the

4

MAP VIEWCROSS SECTIONVIEW

Top of the Niobrara Fm.

39.7 m

PIER

RE SH

ALE

VSP well

Page 5: CORRELATION BETWEEN ELECTRICAL RESISTIVITY …...Case Study 2 3 WATTENBERG FIELD * Geology The Wattenberg Field is located in NE of Denver. 4 CROSS SECTION MAP VIEW VIEW Top of the

Methodology

5

Page 6: CORRELATION BETWEEN ELECTRICAL RESISTIVITY …...Case Study 2 3 WATTENBERG FIELD * Geology The Wattenberg Field is located in NE of Denver. 4 CROSS SECTION MAP VIEW VIEW Top of the

Methodology

q (vertical slowness)from Δt

ψ (polar polarization angle)

6

Vibroseis

Polarization angle (ψ)

Ver

tica

lslo

wn

ess

(q

)

Page 7: CORRELATION BETWEEN ELECTRICAL RESISTIVITY …...Case Study 2 3 WATTENBERG FIELD * Geology The Wattenberg Field is located in NE of Denver. 4 CROSS SECTION MAP VIEW VIEW Top of the

q (vertical slowness)from Δt

ψ (polar polarization angle)polarization

angle

7

Vibroseis

Polarization angle (ψ)

Ver

tica

lslo

wn

ess

(q

)

Methodology

Page 8: CORRELATION BETWEEN ELECTRICAL RESISTIVITY …...Case Study 2 3 WATTENBERG FIELD * Geology The Wattenberg Field is located in NE of Denver. 4 CROSS SECTION MAP VIEW VIEW Top of the

q (vertical slowness)from Δt

ψ (polar polarization angle)polarization

angle

8

Vibroseis

Polarization angle (ψ)

Ver

tica

lslo

wn

ess

(q

)

Methodology

Page 9: CORRELATION BETWEEN ELECTRICAL RESISTIVITY …...Case Study 2 3 WATTENBERG FIELD * Geology The Wattenberg Field is located in NE of Denver. 4 CROSS SECTION MAP VIEW VIEW Top of the

q (vertical slowness)from Δt

ψ (polar polarization angle)Ver

tica

lslo

wn

ess

(q

) model: m={δ, η}

Polarization angle (ψ)

9

Vibroseis

Methodology

Page 10: CORRELATION BETWEEN ELECTRICAL RESISTIVITY …...Case Study 2 3 WATTENBERG FIELD * Geology The Wattenberg Field is located in NE of Denver. 4 CROSS SECTION MAP VIEW VIEW Top of the

q (vertical slowness)from Δt

ψ (polar polarization angle)

m={δ, η}

10

Joint Slowness-PolarizationMethod (JSPM)

Vibroseis

S-wave data

P-wave data

Ver

tica

lslo

wn

ess

(q

)

Polarization angle (ψ)

Page 11: CORRELATION BETWEEN ELECTRICAL RESISTIVITY …...Case Study 2 3 WATTENBERG FIELD * Geology The Wattenberg Field is located in NE of Denver. 4 CROSS SECTION MAP VIEW VIEW Top of the

Anisotropy parameters δ and η

11

Z-axis

VTI modelCijs are stiffness coefficients.

(Alkhalifah and Tsvankin, 1995)

(Thomsen, 1986)

Page 12: CORRELATION BETWEEN ELECTRICAL RESISTIVITY …...Case Study 2 3 WATTENBERG FIELD * Geology The Wattenberg Field is located in NE of Denver. 4 CROSS SECTION MAP VIEW VIEW Top of the

Synthetic DataResults

12

Improvement

Improvement

Page 13: CORRELATION BETWEEN ELECTRICAL RESISTIVITY …...Case Study 2 3 WATTENBERG FIELD * Geology The Wattenberg Field is located in NE of Denver. 4 CROSS SECTION MAP VIEW VIEW Top of the

13

SE VerticalSymmetry Plane

MAP VIEW

Page 14: CORRELATION BETWEEN ELECTRICAL RESISTIVITY …...Case Study 2 3 WATTENBERG FIELD * Geology The Wattenberg Field is located in NE of Denver. 4 CROSS SECTION MAP VIEW VIEW Top of the

JSPM Results

Page 15: CORRELATION BETWEEN ELECTRICAL RESISTIVITY …...Case Study 2 3 WATTENBERG FIELD * Geology The Wattenberg Field is located in NE of Denver. 4 CROSS SECTION MAP VIEW VIEW Top of the

Results and Discussion

15

Page 16: CORRELATION BETWEEN ELECTRICAL RESISTIVITY …...Case Study 2 3 WATTENBERG FIELD * Geology The Wattenberg Field is located in NE of Denver. 4 CROSS SECTION MAP VIEW VIEW Top of the

16

Correlation between the estimated anisotropy parameter η and well logs

Ab

solu

te Valu

e of C

orrelatio

n

High Correlation

Page 17: CORRELATION BETWEEN ELECTRICAL RESISTIVITY …...Case Study 2 3 WATTENBERG FIELD * Geology The Wattenberg Field is located in NE of Denver. 4 CROSS SECTION MAP VIEW VIEW Top of the

17

Correlation between the estimated anisotropy parameter η and resistivity log

PIE

RR

E SH

ALE

FO

RM

ATIO

N

Page 18: CORRELATION BETWEEN ELECTRICAL RESISTIVITY …...Case Study 2 3 WATTENBERG FIELD * Geology The Wattenberg Field is located in NE of Denver. 4 CROSS SECTION MAP VIEW VIEW Top of the

18

Fabric vs. Concentration

Alignment of elements is important.Amount of elements is also important

Alignment of elements is NOT important.Amount of elements is important

Electrical properties

Elastic properties

Permeability

Radioactive properties(Gamma log, neutron log) Porosity

Density

Page 19: CORRELATION BETWEEN ELECTRICAL RESISTIVITY …...Case Study 2 3 WATTENBERG FIELD * Geology The Wattenberg Field is located in NE of Denver. 4 CROSS SECTION MAP VIEW VIEW Top of the

19

Page 20: CORRELATION BETWEEN ELECTRICAL RESISTIVITY …...Case Study 2 3 WATTENBERG FIELD * Geology The Wattenberg Field is located in NE of Denver. 4 CROSS SECTION MAP VIEW VIEW Top of the

1. Using the joint P- and SV-wave slowness-polarization method (JSPM)

and borehole seismic data, I could determine anisotropic properties

of Pierre shale more precisely.

2. Comparing anisotropic properties (derived from seismic data) with

well logs showed a high correlation with resistivity logs.

3. Rock fabric properties are highly correlated and they could be good

source of information for confirming each other.

CONCLUSIONS

20

Page 21: CORRELATION BETWEEN ELECTRICAL RESISTIVITY …...Case Study 2 3 WATTENBERG FIELD * Geology The Wattenberg Field is located in NE of Denver. 4 CROSS SECTION MAP VIEW VIEW Top of the

End .

21