cost/benefit analysis of hard/soft egineering projects

2
Cost Benefit Hard Engineer ing Gabions Don’t look very nice Protect historic landmarks Rock Amour Expensive Erodes after a while Holds beach material in place Revetments Doesn’t stop cliff face erosion Absorbs energy Protects cliff foot Sea Wall Can lead to undercutting Expensive Can be used for leisure activities It deflects the waves Groynes Stops longshore drift Builds beaches Slows cliff erosion Offshore Breakwater Alters the wave direction Limits longshore drift Leads to wider beaches Protects cliffs and settlements behind the beaches Soft Engineeri ng Beach Nourishment Takes material out from the sea bed Gives more places for tourists to go Provides a flood barrier Stabilising Sand Dunes Planting the grasses could take time The paths would have to be maintained A flood barrier is created Footpaths prevent trampling Provide habitats Management Retreat Could eventually erode the roads nearby Doesn’t interfere with nature

Upload: laura2611

Post on 10-Apr-2015

145 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

A comparison of different hard and soft engineering projects with their costs and benefits

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Cost/Benefit Analysis of Hard/Soft Egineering Projects

Cost BenefitHard Engineering

Gabions Don’t look very nice

Protect historic landmarks

Rock Amour Expensive Erodes after a while

Holds beach material in place

Revetments Doesn’t stop cliff face erosion

Absorbs energy Protects cliff foot

Sea Wall Can lead to undercutting Expensive

Can be used for leisure activities It deflects the waves

Groynes Stops longshore drift

Builds beaches Slows cliff erosion

Offshore Breakwater

Alters the wave direction Limits longshore drift

Leads to wider beaches Protects cliffs and settlements behind the beaches

Soft Engineering

Beach Nourishment

Takes material out from the sea bed

Gives more places for tourists to go Provides a flood barrier

Stabilising Sand Dunes

Planting the grasses could take time The paths would have to be maintained

A flood barrier is created Footpaths prevent trampling Provide habitats

Management Retreat

Could eventually erode the roads nearby

Doesn’t interfere with nature

Cost Benefit Table For Hard and Soft Engineering Techniques