8/2/2019 Cra Appraisal Udb471 Wst End Highgate Hill_ 2011

1/2

UDB471 URBAN PLANNING PRACTICE APPRAISAL ASSESSMENT, CRITERIA REFERENCED ASSESSMENT SHEET

Student Name: StudentScore............./20

Criteria 7 6 5 4 3 2-1

1. Effectiveinvestigation,research and insightto interpret andevaluate howsignificant planningissues and currentpolicies and issuesinteract with andinfluence land usesand activities in thestudy area

Excellentinvestigation,research andinsight to interpretand evaluate howsignificant planningissues and currentpolicies interactwith and influenceland uses andactivities in WestEnd- Highgate Hill

Very goodinvestigation,research and insightto describe, interpret,and evaluate howsignificant planningissues and currentpolicies interact withand influence landuses and activities inWest End- HighgateHill

. .

Creditableinvestigation,research and insightto describe, interpret,and evaluate howsignificant planningissues and currentpolicies interact withand influence landuses and activities inWest End- HighgateHill

.

Adequateinvestigation,research andinsight to describe,interpret, andevaluate howsignificantplanning issuesand currentpolicies influenceand interact withland uses andactivities in West

End- Highgate Hill

Barely adequateinvestigation,research andinsight to describe,interpret, andevaluate howsignificantplanning issuesand currentpolicies interactwith and influenceland uses andactivities in West

End- Highgate Hill.

Inadequateinvestigation,research andinsight to describe,interpret, andevaluate howsignificantplanning issuesand currentpolicies interactwith and influenceland uses andactivities in West

End- Highgate Hill

2. Wide rangingcritical and creativethinking, evaluation& synthesis,includingconsideration of themetropolitan context.

Excellent wideranging review,assessment andsynthesis, includingconsideration of themetropolitancontext.

Very good range ofreview, assessmentand synthesis,includingconsideration of themetropolitan context.

Creditable review,assessment andsynthesis, includingconsideration of themetropolitan context.

Adequate review,assessment andsynthesis,includingconsideration ofthe metropolitancontext.

Barely adequatereview,assessment &synthesis includingconsideration ofthe metropolitancontext.,

Inadequate review,assessment andsynthesis,includingconsideration ofthe metropolitancontext.

3. Creative andimaginativeanticipation of future

problems,potentialities andappropriateobjectives.

Excellent creativityand imagination inanticipating future

problems,beneficial directionsand objectives

Very good creativityand imagination inanticipating future

problems, beneficialdirections andobjectives

Creditableimagination inanticipating future

problems, beneficialdirections andobjectives

Adequateanticipation of

future problems,

directions andobjectives

Barely adequateanticipation offuture problems,

directions andobjectives

Failure toanticipate futureproblems,

directions andobjectives

Criteria 7 6 5 4 3 2-1

8/2/2019 Cra Appraisal Udb471 Wst End Highgate Hill_ 2011

2/2

4. Social and ethicalresponsibility inconsidering theneeds and views ofgroups andcommunities likely tobe affected

Excellent use ofinquiry,consultation andinterpretation ofevidence tocontribute to issuesand draft objectives

Very good use ofinquiry, consultationand interpretation ofevidence tocontribute to issuesand draft objectives

Creditable use ofinquiry andconsultation tocontribute to issuesand draft objectives

Adequate use ofinquiry and,consultation tocontribute toissues and draftobjectives

Barely adequateuse of inquiry andconsultation tocontribute toissues and draftobjectives

Failure to useinquiry andconsultation tocontribute toissues and draftobjectives

5. Writtencommunication ofcomplex ideas andinterpretations

Vivid, clear andaccuratecommunication ofcomplex ideas inexcellent writing,

Clear and accuratecommunication ofcomplex ideas ineffective writing

Creditablecommunication ofsignificant ideas ineffective writing

Adequatecommunication ofideas in effectivewriting

Barely adequatecommunication ofideas in writing

Inadequatecommunication ofideas in writing

6. Overall quality ofpresentation,including

supporting graphics,diagrams ,photography andreferences

Excellentpresentation andstructure to

communicateclearly and logicallyusing highlyeffective graphics,diagrams,photography,appendices andreferences.

Very goodpresentation andstructure to

communicate clearlyand logically usinghighly effectivegraphics, diagrams,photography,appendices andreferences

Creditablepresentation andstructure to

communicate clearlyand logically usingeffective graphics,diagrams,photography,appendices andreferences.

Adequatepresentation andstructure to

communicateclearly andlogically usingadequategraphics,diagrams,photography,appendices andreferences.

Barely adequatepresentation andstructure to

communicateclearly andlogically usingbarely adequategraphics,diagrams,photography,appendices andreferences.

Inadequatepresentation andstructure to

communicateclearly andlogically usinggraphics,diagrams,photography,appendices andreferences.

Overall comments