8/13/2019 Crim.marco - Conspiracy x Stabbing

1/1

epublic of the PhilippinesSUPREME COURT

ManilaSECOND DIVISION

G.R. Nos. L-28324-5 May 19, 1978THE PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee,vs.RAFAEL MARCO, SIMEON MARCO and DULCISIMO BELTRAN, defendants. RAFAELMARCO, defendant-appellant.Jose P. Bengzon (Counsel de Oficio) for appellant.Solicitor General Felix V. Makasiar, Assistant Solicitor General Felisicimo R. Rosete and SolicitorTeodulo R. Dino for appellee.BARREDO, J .:Appeal by accused Rafael Marco from the judgment of the Court of First Instance of Zamboangadel Sur in Criminal Case No. 2757, entitled People of the Philippines vs. Rafael Marco, Dulcisimo

Beltran and Simeon Marco, the dispositive part of which reads thus:WHEREFORE, the Court renders judgment as follows:(1) In Criminal Case No, 2757, the Court finds Rafael Marco, Dulcisimo Beltran,and Simeon Marco, guilty beyond reasonable doubt of the crime of Murder,qualified by abuse of superior strength' and hereby sentences Rafael Marco, whohas neither aggravating circumstance against him or any mitigating circumstancein his favor, to RECLUSION PERPETUA. Simeon Marco and Dulcisimo Beltran,who surrendered voluntarily, are hereby sentenced EACH to an indeterminatepenalty consisting of TEN (10) YEARS and ONE (1) DAY of prision mayor, asminimum, to SEVENTEEN (17) YEARS, FOUR (4) MONTHS, and ONE (1) DAYof reclusion temporal as maximum.

The Court further sentences the three defendants to pay, jointly and severally, to the heirs of

Bienvenido Sabelbero, the amount of P6,000.00, to suffer the accessory penalties of the law, andto pay the costs. (Page 69, Record.) Actually, there were two cases filed against appellant in connection with two successive phasesof a single occurrence. The two cases were consolidated and tried together. In Criminal Case No.2757, he was charged together with his son Simeon and one Dulcisimo Beltran with the allegedmurder of one Bienvenido Sabelbero. 1In Criminal Case 2758, he was charged together also withhis son Simeon with frustrated murder allegedly committed against Constancio Sabelbero, abrother Bienvenido. In this second case, herein appellant was found guilty only a slight physicalinjuries and sentenced to twelve (12) days of arresto menor. He did not appeal. Simeon wasacquitted.The incident in question took place on November 5, 1964 at about 2:30 o'clock in the afternoonwithin the vicinity of the market place of Barrio Subang, Pagadian, Zamboanga del Sur. There

was a fiesta being celebrated, but it was raining. The details, according to the the are as follows:Constancio Sabelbero was approached by Simeon Marco