dane rudhyar - the fullness of human experience
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
1/147
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
2/147
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Born in Paris, Dane Rudhyar (1895-1985) was ru!y a Renaissan"e #an,having
gained distinction as a composer, pianist, poet, painter, and prolific author in the fields of
astrology, philosophy, and psychology. His creative work was often considered ahead of itstime, and his writings show an insight into the trends of the future.
Rudhyar received the Peabody award for music in 197, and his compositions have been
performed in ma!or concert halls. He held honorary doctorates from the "alifornia #nstitute
of $ranspersonal Psychology and %ohn &. 'ennedy (niversity. He is recogni)ed
internationally as one of the leading figures in the field of transpersonal astrology and
philosophy.
Rudhyar is author of books too numerous to mention, including Asro!o$y o% Persona!iy
and The P!aneari&aion o% 'ons"iousness. He authored five *uest books including
'u!ure, 'risis, and 'reaiiyand the book to which this one is a se+uel, Rhyh# o%
ho!eness.
alley proofs for The *u!!ness o% Hu#an E+erien"ewere finished before Rudhyar-s
death on eptember 1/, 190. #n his final talk in arch, celebrating his 92th birthday, he
said3 4$he power that held my whole being as a lens to bring ideas to a focus will be
released when # go. Perhaps when the person # appear to be is gone, it may be easier to
tune up to that mind5power and what is beyond it 6 the wholeness of spirit, the freed
seed.4
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
3/147
'HAPTER OE
Pre!ude and Basi" The#es - 1
The urose o% his .oo/ is o .rin$ o a #ore "on"ree and e+erienia! !ee!
fundamental concepts of the philosophy of perative 8holeness, which # outlined inmetaphysical form in Parts ne and $wo of my recent book, Rhyh# o% ho!eness. $o
fulfill such a purpose, # shall rephrase in more psychological terms some of the ideas
previously formulated, and define what is involved in characteristically 4human4 situations at
the level of personal eperience, yet without losing sight of the all5inclusive frame of
reference, the cyclic ovement of 8holeness.:1;
ome of the implications of this cyclic structure and the manner in which it should be
approached have re+uired a more complete treatment, and the first chapters of this book
are devoted to such a process of elucidation. $he concept of structural invariance and the
way aleatory developments resulting from individual 4free4 choices are reabsorbed into the
cyclically unfolding pattern of the ovement, will bring, # believe, a deeper understanding of
the twin factors of spiritual "ompassion and karma. $hese ac+uire a new and revealing
meaning when related to the ideal of personhood, and the appearance in the earth5field of
the upreme Person 6 prototype of the state of personhood 6 at a crucial moment in the
planetary cycle.
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
4/147
condition, definable as 4personhood,4 on the basis of the great cycle to which # have
referred as the ovement of 8holeness.
8hat is to be meant by being a person> 8hy are human beings today determined to
operate as autonomous individuals characteristically able to make responsible decisions>
$his basis evidently depends on the particular nature of the
choice being made? yet, whether or not the person reali)es it, anydecision implies the
acceptance of an approach to life and the meaning of eistence which has metaphysical
and@or religious roots.
ost religions or spiritual philosophies assume as an incontrovertible fact of inner
eperiences :particularly in states of intense meditation or ecstasy; that human persons are
essentially spiritual entities :ouls or onads; that, having emerged from 4the ne4 :od or
the
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
5/147
terms of cause and effect.
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
6/147
'HAPTER TO
ho!eness and he E+erien"e o% Periodi" 'han$e - 1
The dyna#is# o% ho!eness
8hen a definable or identifiable boundary can be given to an energy field in which the
activities of a number of elements are functionally interrelated, this field constitutes a4whole.4 $he wholeness of this whole results from the coeistence of a state of #u!i!i"iy
:the many elements the field encompasses; and a state of uniy:the fact that these
elements are circumscribed by boundaries;.
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
7/147
develop a mode of operation 6 a procedure, strategy, or device 6 which makes possible
the repetition of pleasurable :and in general 4desirable4; eperiences, and the avoidance of
painful ones.
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
8/147
'HAPTER TO
ho!eness and he E+erien"e o% Periodi" 'han$e -
The e+erien"e o% i#e
Aecause the eperience of time undertones all other eperiences in which change is
involved, # shall at once pay special attention to what is in fact implied, though largely notunderstood, in it $he eperience should be differentiated from that of the continuum of
change, because while 4change4 should not be considered as raving any beginning or end,
4time4 as an eperience always has a beginning, and it must also end. Aetween the
beginning which was in 4the past4 and the end which will occur in 4the future,4 a 4period of
time4 etends. $he sense of time is not only related to the etension of such a period, but to
a sub!ective personal factor, the desire for some kind of change to occur during that period
of time. $he speed at which time is 4passing4 while the satisfaction of the desire for a
particular :or generali)ed and imprecise; change has to be waited for, gives this time5flow a
specific character. $he waiting for the end of the period may be relaed or tense? time may
seem to pass slowly or +uickly.
< peasant who has sown seeds must wait, perhaps while hungry, for the new harvest? theindividual student also waits for the results of a test which may determine his entire career.
$his waiting 6 a so often repeated human eperience 6 constitutes the eperience of time.
8hen referring to it, the psychologist or philosopher speaks of 4sub!ective4 time. 4b!ective4
time, on the other hand, deals with periods whose beginning and end are established by
eternal events which a collectivity of human beings can observe and use to define and
measure set periods of activity or rest 6 for instance sunrise and sunset, the full moon, the
rise of vegetation in the pring.
$here is actually nothing mysterious about time, ecept the strange ways in which this
basic, common eperience of perpetual change has been interpreted. $he many
interpretations that have been presented by religions and philosophies simply reveal how
difficult, if not incomprehensible, it has always been for human beings to have o waiforthe satisfaction of their desires. $he near5impossibility of an 4instant fulfillment4 of one-s
desires :the passionate ideal of the hippie generationD; has been translated into the binding
power of time? and the fateful nature of this power has been feared, especially with the
reali)ation that death ends the period when even the aniety or anguish :an$sin erman;
of waiting no longer eists. aking a god of 4$ime4 and trying to identify one-s
consciousness with his subliminal nature does not help the situation. Eeither does modern
science-s attempt to divorce time from actual human eperience and make it a dimension of
the hybrid intellectual frame of reference, space5time. Eor does the philosopher-s
interpretation of time as an innate category of the human mind make individuals feel better
as they wait for the distant fulfillment of their epectations. $he division of time into past,
present, and future, and especially into 4moments,4 the length of which can be measuredaccording to the collectively accepted schedule of activity of a particular community or
nation, is also an ineffectual solution to what should simply be considered and accepted as
the basic fact of eistence3 the succession of ever5changing situations which any organi)ed
whole has to meet.
$he fact of change implies the eperience of succession, or se+uence. ne sensation
4follows4 another, even if the first merges unnoticeably into the second. $here is continuity
when no mental activity has yet differentiated any one eperience by relating it to a
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
9/147
possible recurrence and a desire for or fear of that recurrence. #f two eperiences follow
each other, one must come a%erthe other. $his is what is meant by se+uence. < series of
changes constitutes an ordered or structured se+uence of eperiences. #t is only when these
are entiti)ed by the mind as events, having an assumed ob!ective eistence e+erna!to the
eperiencer, that the modern intellectual finds it possible to !uggle pictures or abstract
symbols to which a 4time position4 is attributed. uch a 4position4 can only have meaning ifa starting point for the measurement of ob!ective units has first been established, and the
concept of periods of time has developed in the interpretative mind.
$he beginning and end of a period are established by what # have called 4markers of time.4
$hese are normally provided by common human eperiences, such as sunrise and sunset,
or the appearance of new vegetable growth in the pring? but every society makes its own
markers of time in order to differentiate periods of activity from those of rest #f no period of
time 6 no interval between beginning and end 6 is considered, only a continuum of
changes is eperienced. $his continuum is, strictly speaking, 4time5less4? it does not involve
time. Eevertheless it implies the se2uenia!iyof eperienced changes. #t is interpreted by
the mind as a succession of events and a series of situations, many of which recur
periodically.arkers of time are special moments. $hey are the alpha and omega of a series of events
or, in the absence of consciously noticeable changes during the in5between 4passing of
time,4 of non5events. oments are changes upon which a sub!ect, waiting or deliberately
preparing for the eperience of desire5fulfillment, focuses his or her attention. ome of the
energy of the whole organism is 4tensed toward4 what is happening. 8e can measure the
interval between such occurrences, as well as the speed at which they pass and attract the
consciousness of the sub!ect during a period of waiting.
< period of waiting may refer to a comple and difficult process of preparation for some final
fulfillment. #t may be a 4test4 which must be undergone, a surgical operation to be
performed, or a decisive meeting with a would5be lover or adversary. uch a period may
seem too brief to the eperiencing person, who may then complain of having 4so little time.4n the contrary, the feeling may be that 4too much time4 may still elapse before a desired
or feared event can occur 6 so much more waiting has to be enduredD #f we say that the
event occurred 4in time,4 we mean that we had accurately evaluated the interval between
that event and the beginning of the process leading to it. 8e had estimated the value of the
interval according to a standard of measurement defined by two markers of time. ur
measuring was accurate? but on what basis was the measuring done>
riginally, as far as human beings are concerned, time measurements have always been
made on the basis of the eperienceability and repetitiveness of situations referring to the
dynamic structure of some 4greater whole4 within whose field of activity the human
eperiencer operated. $hat structure provided him or her with standardi)ed markers of
time? and by so doing it made possible the measurement of repetitive periods of timehaving easily definable and commonly acceptable beginnings and ends. $he selected greater
whole usually was our planet? its daily rotation and its yearly revolution around the sun
evidenced a definite rhythm. ther kinds of greater wholes have been used3 a religion
featuring a series of feast days and centennial periods, the nation whose laws establish
periodical recurrences :such as the date of paying income ta;, or the schedule followed by
a business firm for which a person works. #n all cases, by establishing such markers of time
in the common eperience of a social community, the structure of the greater whole
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
10/147
definitely affects the sense of time of the people of the community. #t affects their general
feeling of having enough or too little time, and of the speed at which this commodity is
being spent.
#n our 8estern civili)ation time is considered an ob!ective commodity of which a small or
large amount is available in the interval between two markers of time. 8e possess such a
commodity? it is a kind of wealth or power. $he amount which is ours to use can bemeasured, apportioned, and spent wisely or carelessly according to the vast number of
biological needs, socio5cultural re+uirements and personal ego5wants seeking satisfaction.
$hese wants may appear to be very personal #n fact, they follow a scale of values definitely
conditioned and often rigidly determined by a collective culture and religion, and by the
eample of parents and friends.
$he main events most people use for determining the amount of time available to them as
particular persons are +uite obviously the birth
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
11/147
'HAPTER TO
ho!eness and he E+erien"e o% Periodi" 'han$e - 3
4iin$ in he now
$he non5eistence of time after the period of beingness of anywhole has ended does not
imply the cessation of the continuum of change, or of the succession of situations producedby the cyclic interplay of the two principles of (nity and ultiplicity. $his interplay is what
human beings perceive as motion, or the dynamic character of 8holeness. otion implies
the unceasing assin$from one state of (nity5to5ultiplicity relatedness to the net $he
word assin$is stressed because as one deals with the process of change as a cyclic whole
:the ovement of 8holeness;, one no longer focuses attention upon moments of time, as if
they could be separated from one another, but rather upon the se+uence of changes.
Eevertheless, if one intends to define the eact relation of an eperienced event to markers
of time in terms of the activity of conscious, autonomous, and responsible individuals, one
has to refer to a precise moment assumed to have a specific character. ne has to i#e
:verb form; actions according to an eperienced or re+uired se+uence of time5entities
:moments; and the possible speed at which the actions can be carried out.#n order to make such a process possible, mind has to interpret the eperience of se+uence
:of before and after; in terms of the +uasi5dimensionality of past, present, and future. $he
individuali)ation of 4time units4 called moments and made :consciously or not; to resemble
living organisms that are born, mature, and die, is undoubtedly necessary when the ego and
its desires dominate the human situation. oreover, at this stage a clearcut distinction is
made between an eperiencing sub!ect and what it eperiences as if it were outside itself.
Aut this is only a phase, however enduring and tenacious, of the human eperience of
change on which the awareness of eistence itself is based. 8hether it is the
individuali)ation of the continuum of change or that of the state of personhood,
individuali)ation inevitably engenders a great deal of confusion and misunderstanding.
$he concept of action 4inthe present4 is particularly confusing. $he reason is that, strictlyspeaking, the present is only a dimensionless line of demarcation between past and future.
#t has no more dimensionality than, in geometry, the lines forming a triangle have
thickness, or a mathematical point has spatial etension. $he present separates the future
from the past but it is also their merging into each other. 8here the future meets the past
is a very vaguely defined yet etensive moment or series of moments called 4now.4 8hen
philosophers, psychologists and mystics speak of 4living in the now,4 they refer to a more or
less brief period of transition which actually has a time5dimension, though it may be
characteri)ed as 4timeless4 because of its special +uality as the moment at which the human
capacity for decision and action should be focused.
8hat is meant by 4living in the now4 :as we are acting or taking decisions; is to be neither
affected :or even haunted; by the memory of past eperiences 6 our own and@or those ofour ancestors, educators or associates 6 nor fascinated by an over5ideali)ed and unrealistic
sub!ective longing for a future state, or by an unrealistic, fear of what it may bring. #t is also
to face in a thoroughly awake condition of consciousness, and with focused intent whatever
situation may be !ust ahead.
$he situation has not come? it is not 4present4 =et one should be in a constant state of
readiness to meet it &or instance, if the driver of a car allows his feelings to dwell upon a
deeply depressing past eperience of frustrated love, or lets his imagination be entranced
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
12/147
by the glowing mistiness of (topian epectations, so that attention is not focused on the
road, he may fail to react effectively to the erratic action of another driver suddenly in the
wrong lane, and a fatal head5on collision may occur. #n this case, of course, the computer5
like level of the mind may have been programmed or trained to react automatically in the
correct manner. Aut any training process implies a reference to and use of a knowledge
based on collective past eperience, and it even includes a certain amount of epectation 6the epectation of possible results.
8hen a modern philosopher5psychologist eulogi)es living in the now, he or she actually
means meeting life-s eperiences as an individual being no longer motivated and deeply
affected by the way of thinking5feeling5behaving which family and culture had imposed upon
mind5development since birth. $heoretically, living in the now should mean being totally
unconditioned by anypast Aut one is always conditioned by the past, whether it be the past
of the long process of biological evolution which built a human body and its brain, or the
past of a people and their culture which provided a language with definite words and a
synta establishing rigid structures of relationship between all the elements of eperience.
$he more intense :as well as traumatic or fame5producing; the events of the first part of a
person-s life have been, the more impossible it will be for the biological, psychic, andintellectual impressions of these events to be totally eradicated, especially if the person
claiming to live in the now has been motivated :consciously or not; by the occurrences to
build on them a philosophy of life.
$he phrase !iin$ in he nowmay be a convenient way of systemati)ing and perhaps
glorifying a somewhat self5conscious approach to human eistence, stressing the specific
+uality of a newly activated center of individuali)ed consciousness. Having succeeded to
some degree in freeing itself from the binding pressures of culture, and being eager to
emphasi)e the value and ecitement of that 4liberation4 6 however relative it may have
been 6 this new center of consciousness is, as it were, mythologi)ing its feeling5responses.
$he basic issue is always the nature or stage of evolution of whoit is that 4lives in the
now.4 Plants and wild animals live in the now, because life 4lives them4 in terms of itsindismissible needs and instinctual modes of response. #n his Bpistles, Paul states that he is
no longer a separate individual entity that 4lives,4 because od 4lives him.4 $o many
mystics and theosophists, living in the now implies living in he resen"eof od or the
4aster.4 Aut the reali)ation of such a 4presence4 should not be confused with what, in
relation to past and future conditions of eistence, is called 4the present.4 Eothing can be
donein the present, for the present 6 # repeat 6 is only an abstract line separating past
from future. =et it need not be considered a dimensionless line? it need not separate any
condition of being, if he assin$6 the moment of being 6 is eperienced as a presence,
as the dynamic aspect of 8holeness.
$here is motion always and everywhere. $hat motion is structured, operating as wholes of
change, as cycles or eons. Giving in the now implies a focusing of the attention of theeperiencing sub!ect upon one particular phase of the cycle of change. #n the fullest
eperience possible to a human being, any phase of the ovement of 8holeness is lived in
terms of what it reveals of the structure and meaning of the whole eon 6 thus su. se"ie
eerniais. $he moment is lived in the presence of 8holeness. $hrough it the entire cyclic
interaction of the two great principles of (nity and ultiplicity is envisioned.
$his interaction operates always and everywhere, yet it is ever5changing. Aecause
variations are possible it is always new? yet, as we shall see, it is also invariant in its total
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
13/147
structure because every variation is balanced by a compensatory action. How puny is any
4now4 unless one can feel in and through it the immense resonance of the whole cycle 6
the 4always and everywhere4 of unconditioned 8holenessD
=et the destiny, function, or dharma of humanity re+uires both that the epansive power of
desires for self5actuali)ation and that the capacity of the mind at the human level to
ob!ectify, entiti)e, analy)e, and measure, should eperience their fullest possibledevelopment in an. $he pressure of the principle of ultiplicity compels men and women
to focus their attention upon parts and the mutual interaction of these parts, rather than to
resonate to the rhythm of 8holeness in any whole. $he same pressure leads the human
mind to di#ensiona!iðe continuum of change. $hat pressure must be obeyed during
the phase in the evolution of human culture in which the dominant desire of the sub!ective
factor in human eperience is to epress itself as an ego. $he ego is unconcerned with the
deep tide of human evolution because it feels essentially separate from other individual
persons with conflicting ambitions. $hen the human mind has to measure all it perceives,
because it is urged to control the energies latent in nature for the satisfaction of ever5new
desires.
$he most crucial and fateful application of the power to measure is the measuring of time 6time now ob!ectivi)ed as a commodity and no longer whole, no longer cyclically structured?
the time of stop5watches and electronic interferometers and of the abstract e+uations of the
Binsteinian $heory of Relativity.
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
14/147
'HAPTER TO
ho!eness and he E+erien"e o% Periodi" 'han$e -
O.6e"ie i#e, "ausa!iy, and he #easure o% i#e
$he foregoing discussion dealt with the eperience of sub!ective beings who have desires
:or at the biological level, vital needs; and seek satisfaction of them in and throughsituations able to provide it. $his satisfaction has two basic features3 the process of
fulfillment 4takes time,4 and it usually involves the concept of causation 6 a definite
se+uence of cause5and5effect, the effect being the cause of further effects. #f the principle of
causality as it is usually understood today is to be taken as universally true, the categories
of 4before4 and 4after4 are also to be given an absolute character. < cause occurs before its
effect. #t occurs in what has ambiguously been called 4linear4 time. < particular cause,
believed to be past or present, can be epected to produce a definable future effect.
$hus interpreted, a series of eperienced situations assumes an ob!ective character.
b!ectivity, however, refers to the fact that a re!aionbetween the eperiencing organism
and another entity occupies the mind-s attention. < sub!ective eperience, on the other
hand, refers to the change directly affecting a whole organism and its centrali)ingconsciousness. 8hen a person is burned by a hot stove in the dark, there is in the
eperience itself no immediate reali)ation of the stove as a source of heat. However, the
mind is called upon to establish both the eistence of a hot stove and the precise character
of the gesture which brought about the relation between the hand and the stove. Relation
generates ob!ectivity. $he world around us is ob!ective only because we relate to its many
components.
$herefore what is involved in giving ob!ectivity to time 6 and in a similar sense, to space 6
is the fact that when consciousness is dominated by mental processes, it deals primarily
with relations rather than with eperienced changes :events; in themselves. b!ective time
refers to the succession of changing relations? ob!ective space, to a comple group of
4positions4 occupied by entities with which a human being can, conceptually if not actuallyand eperienceably, relate himself in terms of measurable 4distance4 :proimity or
remoteness;. 8hether we refer to ob!ective time or dimensional space we are dealing with
a su.srau# o% re!aedness? that is, with an abstract factor or principle of eistence
without which there could be no eperienced relation. 8ithin this substratum, events occupy
positions. $he substratum 6 whether it be space or time, or today in science space5time 6
contains time5se+uences and@or space5positions? but in either case the relations between
eperienced events and entities are at least partially determined by their distance :in spatial
terms; and by the before5and5after succession :in terms of time se+uence;. pace and time
are assumed to be empty containers.
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
15/147
effects, but even by the transformation of the before5and5after se+uence. "ausation is, of
course, an eperience common to all human beings? yet today the mind claims the ability to
imagine time5se+uences not sub!ect to the cause5and5effect :or even before5and5after;
se+uence, as well as space5relations between masses which would not obey gravitation. #n
a gravitation5free universe, the concept of physically measurable distance would not be a
determining factor in controlling the motion of spatially5determined entities.#f we think of a measurable space .eweenentities, or of measurable time .eweenthe
emergence of a desire and its satisfaction, we have to give space and time a definitely
o.6e"iereality. $his reality can only have an altogether abstract character, difficult to
understand and impossible to eperience. #t is a construct of the mind which may reveal the
natural way for the human mind to operate at this stage of the planet-s evolution. $he
activities of human beings seemingly re+uire such an abstract frame of reference in which
events occur and physical masses are located. Bvents and material ob!ects must have
positions in space and time, for with5out positions there can be no way of measuring when
and whereto act 8ithout one5directional causation se+uence :before5and5after;,
commonsense daily epectability and the scientific prediction of events would be impossible.
uch an impossibility would deny any meaning to human efforts at transformation and tomoral values, since any act might cause any reaction. &or the mind to assume the reality of
such a non5ordered situation would be in fact suicidal. uch an assumption would separate
mental processes from the eperience of being as an integrated whole in a consistently
organi)ed structure of situations to which a meaning can be given. $his is in fact only
possible through the use of words and relations between words divorced from
eperienceable reality.
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
16/147
'HAPTER TO
ho!eness and he E+erien"e o% Periodi" 'han$e - 5
The a" o% #easurin$ is #os !i/e!y an i#oran arof even the most primitive types
of cultural and collective activities. Aut the principle of measurement in ancient times wascertainly not what it is understood to be today in a 8estern world mentality which, because
of the spectacular way in which the principle has 4worked,4 has made it the basis of the only
kind of scientifically acceptable knowledge. Eot only the practice of measurement, but also
the concept of 2uaniyas a defining factor in all relations, have ac+uired 6 particularly
since the sith century A." in Bast5editerranean regions 6 a rather new and all5pervasive
character. 8hat seems to have been a mostly intuitive sense of proportion and rhythm
became intellectuali)ed and ob!ectivi)ed by the increasingly precise reference of events to
standards of measurement accepted by philosophers and scientists all over the world.
8hen Pythagoras taught his disciples how to refer personal eperiences of tone to a
measurable length of vibrating string :the monochord;, he may have given the impetus
which led the reek culture to glorify the practice of measuring and the meaning of
4proportion.4 =et for him, Eumber and Proportion were not merely abstract concepts but
were cosmic principles which could be eperienced directly, or at least reflectively.
Pythagoras is said to have been able to eperience the 4usic of the pheres4? but when he
referred to planets and the spatial intervals between them, and to what became known as
the Pythagorean scale, he was not thinking of the physical mass of celestial bodies, but of
principles of organi)ation of what he already knew to be a sun5centered cosmos
:heliocosm;.
#n ancient reece the term ine!!e"had a highly spiritual meaning, essentially differentfrom the modern use. 8hat was then the 4new mind4 was a mind of pure relationship and
proportion, rationality, and beauty? and its measuring power was believed to be the means
to give concrete, eperienceable form to cosmic order. $his concreti)ed order was the
invariant foundation of 4the Aeautiful4 #t was only during the fifth and fourth centuries A.".
that an abstract formalism developed, substituting itself for the e+erien"eof pure
proportions.:1;
$he monochord was a rather crude instrument? and so were the sundials and clocks used to
reveal the time at which the bells of churches and city halls were rung as vibrant markers of
time for a whole integrated community. Aut as social and business processes became
increasingly comple and re+uired more precise 4timing4 of eactly when to begin and end a
particular activity, time5measuring devices became more eact $hey also became
individuali)ed, providing for each person his or her own time, thus breaking up the
wholeness of personal eperience into a series of fragmented happenings.
8hen changes which affect and to some etent transform an entity :or group of entities;
are measured in precise +uantitative terms, what is measured has to have an ob!ective
character? it is perceived as being eternal to the measurer. oreover, the entity in
http://www.khaldea.com/rudhyar/fhe/fhe_c2_p5.shtml#a -
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
17/147
+uestion must have a beginning and, however remote it may be, an end. $he process of
change being measured should be divisible and commensurate with a previously accepted
standard of measurement. 8hile in olden days the standard of measurement necessarily
had some kind of relation to the eperiences of the measurer 6 a life5span, certain
proportions of the human body, etc. 6 in modern science the units of measurement, at bothends of the scale of +uantitative values, no longer have any eperienceable or even
rationally imaginable meaning. $his leads to the belief that what the atomic scientist and
astronomer attempt to measure actually belongs to a level of being which transcends, if not
the human condition of eistence, then at least the interpretive power of the modern mind.
#t makes one suspect that the most basic postulate of science 6 i.e. that 4laws of nature4
are true everywhere in space and at any time :even at the Aig AangD; 6 is not true,
because the method and perhaps the very concept of measurement apply only to the space
4in the neighborhood4 of the measurer 6 which may mean in astronomical terms our ilky
8ay galay, or what the eperience of human eyes can observe and directly measure.
ne might phrase the issue differently by asking whether man should trust his mental
processes of interpretation rather than his senses. o stated, the issue seems easily
answered by the obvious unreliability of human senses in many well5known situations. =et
what is unreliable are the sense5perceptions of an indiidua! hu#an .ein$. $hey are
unreliable because they originate not only from one local point of observation, but also from
the specific perspective of a particular culture? and perhaps above all because they are
affected by the sub!ective state and the desires :unconscious though they be; of an
individual perceiver and eperiencer.
$he preceding statement, however, should not be construed to imply that anything
depending upon a sub!ective factor is unreliable 6 though this is the general approachtaken by modern 8estern science. $here could be a unani#ousas well as an
indiidua!i&edkind of sub!ectivity, and # shall deal with the former when speaking of the
Pleroma state of being. #ndeed, a gradually emerging desire to base collective decisions on
a consensus :thus the principle of unanimity; rather than on ma!ority rule has recently
become noticeable. $his may be not only because of the irrational assumption that the
decision of 01 of a people is wiser than that of I9, but also because of the deep feeling
that anything having a fundamental human validity should involve the whole of mankind. #t
should command unanimous acceptance at the level of sub!ectivity, rather than in terms of
a system of intellectual concepts mathematically proven to be 4true.4 Aut how could all
human beings reach a state of unanimity of desires> How could they a!!have the same
desire epressing a unified, all5human sub!ective self as they are confronted by a
fundamental eperience implying a crucial choice>
a!ority rule and the statistical approach in general are concepts whose validity is evident
where strictly intellectual processes operate. $hey belong to the level not only of formalistic
theories, but to the concept of form itself. odern science has recogni)ed the pitfalls of such
thinking by stressing the need for any eperiment to be repeatable under varying
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
18/147
circumstances for a relative consensus of trained observers and theorists. Gikewise, modern
democracy since the foundation of the (nited tates of
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
19/147
'HAPTER TO
ho!eness and he E+erien"e o% Periodi" 'han$e -
aura! i#e is :od;s i#e
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
20/147
known should be available to anyone, at any time, in any place, and under any conditions,
are very new factors in the development of the human mind. #n all previous cultures the
value of knowledge and the advisability of imparting it have been conditioned by the state
of being of the person who would receive that knowledge, and therefore by the epected
use this knower would make of it. $his use is evidently motivated by the nature and +uality
of the knower-s desires 6 thus by the level at which his or her sub!ective self operates 6which in turn depends upon his or her state of evolution as a living organism of the homo
sapiens type and as a participant in a sociocultural system of organi)ation. cience is
usually considered today as the product of a basic human impulse to ascertain more and
more facts, and to discover the invariable laws according to which matter, life, society and
individual persons operate. Aut only in our mind5dominated culture is this impulse to know
isolated from its basic, even if unconscious, motive3 the control of the power which can be
released and used in any situation a human being may face.
$here are evidently many scientists motivated in their research and their comple
intellectual operations solely by what can be rightfully called the 4search for knowledge.4
Aut it can be so defined because such persons have their consciousness focused mainly at
the level of intellectual processes of formulation and :more specifically; formali)ation. $hemind factor dominates their eperiences, at least at the level of culture and institutionali)ed
social relationships. $hey are born to take new steps in the development of the collective
mind of their society. #t is their dharma? and naturally they give to their :in some instances;
obsessive impulse a meaning to which a high social value is attached.
$he desire to control is in itself a fundamental characteristic of the human state. Aecause
human beings can to some etent control the se+uence of natural changes and introduce
into it unnatural releases of power, they are able to take, "ons"ious!y and de!i.erae!y,
the net step in the evolutionary process operating within the all5inclusive field of activity of
the earth as a planetary organism.
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
21/147
what # shall soon define as 4"ompassion.4 n the other hand, the desire to control
situations for the sake of eperiencing, at the level of the ego, a sub!ective feeling of power
and personal or collective pride, inevitably leads, sooner or later, to destructive results. $his
kind of desire unfortunately is very powerful in the approach our modern civili)ation takes to
time. Aehind such an approach is the increasingly feverish multiplication and
compleification of desires which the consciousness of the individual person, operating atthe ego level of sub!ectivity, seeks to cram between an immense number of narrowly
separated markers of time, and especially of course between the two fundamental ones 6
birth and death 6 the beginning and end of measurable time.
Aecause an over5stimulated mind presents to the ego an unaccomplishable array of
possibilities to be desired, there seems to be never 4enough time4 to actuali)e them. $he
more time is measured in small units, the more crowded it becomes, and the more the end
of time, death, is feared. =et if the individuali)ed consciousness could rela into a state of
desirelessness and accept the cyclic rhythm of change, death could be but a rite of passage
from one level of eperiential situations to another.
$he fragmented concept of measured time finds its opposite in the reali)ation of the
wholeness of time. $he isolated moment so rapidly passing, and the aniety of 4not enoughtime4 can vanish or be transcended when the consciousness accepts the cyclic nature of
eistence. "yclicity is indeed the dynamic aspect of 8holeness.
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
22/147
'HAPTER THREE
The 'y"!i" =ru"ure o% he 7oe#en o% ho!eness - 1
A.sra" aerns and e+erien"ed sy#.o!s
8hen a person-s attention is focused upon a repetitive series of common humaneperiences indicating the working of a cyclic process, three basic approaches are possible3
the person may try to live as fully as possible the unfolding, concrete situations as they are
being eperienced one after the other? the most noticeable events may be given a symbolic
character revealing their meaning in terms of the whole process of change? or general
principles may be abstracted from the se+uence of events, indicating the way the process
and all similar ones are structured.
$he first approach is eperiential and mostly personal, re+uiring an open and holistic
response to each event as it is eperienced in itself, with a minimum of attention given to
its causes and probable conse+uences. $he second or symbolic approach is concerned not
only with the events and the eperiences they engender, but also with the relation between
these events considered as phases of a whole process. oreover, it is involved with the
meaning of the effects of these events in terms of more or less common human needs or
desires, and with the possibility of influencing or controlling these effects. $his approach
stresses the value of interpersonal communication by means of symbols or myths able to
transmit information. $he knowledge this information is meant to convey refers specifically
to the development of a consciousness of processes, and thus of wholes of eperience
within definable periods of time.
$he third approach seeks to ascertain the structural character of any cyclic series of
developments produced by a basic and recurrent situation. #t 4ab5stracts4 operativeprinciples, not so much from the events and the eperiences they elicit as from their
se+uence and essential character. $he character is 4essential4 in the sense that it has a
fundamental relevance to situations which in themselves may greatly differ, if only because
they operate at different levels of eperience. $he situations differ eistentially, but the
sru"ureof the process relating the situations is understood to be the same. #t is
invariant, however varied may be the outer, empirically analy)able events it interrelates.
uch a structure can only be discovered through the operation of the human mind when a
particular level of mental development has been reached, at least by the intellectual
vanguard of mankind. Historically speaking, this seems to have occurred during the sith
century A.", particularly in #ndia with autama the Auddha, and in the reek world.
$he circular pattern indicating the cyclic se+uence of phases of the ovement of 8holeness,
first presented in Rhyh# o% ho!enessand reproduced here with a few changes in
terminology, is the product of this abstract approach. #t gives a diagrammatical form to the
ever5changing but symmetrical relationship between two fundamental principles. (nity and
ultiplicity, which in psychological terms may be interpreted as sub!ectivity and ob!ectivity.
$hese principles alternately wa and wane, producing an oscillatory type of motion. Eeither
http://www.khaldea.com/rudhyar/rw/index.shtml -
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
23/147
can ever totally overpower the other.
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
24/147
speak of such a state as the eperience of 8holeness 6 an eperience which nevertheless
inevitably takes different forms at different levels of being.:1;
$he long period during which humanity evolves from a primitive, strictly biological and4natural4 state to that of spiritually 4#llumined an4 constitutes the predominantly ob!ective
series of phases, which are given a mythical interpretation in terms of the daily cycle of
human consciousness on this rotating planet. $his is the stage of 4waking consciousness.4
ankind, in both an individual and a collective sense, has a function to perform.
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
25/147
beings mean by the term 4personality4 or 4personhood.4 =et because in such a condition of
being, as well as in any other. 8holeness must include the operation of both fundamental
principles. (nity and ultiplicity, an eperience of the neness which would absolutely
eclude the drive toward ultiplicity is impossible. #n the odhead, a tremendous surge of
"ompassion arises which, as we shall see, takes the ideal form of a new universe which willprovide a 4second chance4 for the failures of the past universe to eperience 8holeness in a
fully re5 awakened state.
< new cycle thus begins at the symbolic idnight hour with the odhead-s vision of what is
needed to offset and neutrali)e the negative memory5remains and waste5products of the old
cycle. $he envisioned ideal gradually assumes comple archetypal forms, and a moment
comes :the symbolic unrise; when a tremendous surge of 4creative4 power arises out of
the undefinable immensity of pace 6 a surge which theologians have interpreted as the
"reative
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
26/147
'HAPTER THREE
The 'y"!i" =ru"ure o% he 7oe#en o% ho!eness -
The #eanin$ o% sy##ery
$he circular diagram of the cycle of being printed here does noalways refer to time as ameasured factor. 8hen the Hindu Puranasspeak of periods of cosmic manifestation
:#ananaras; and non5manifestation :ra!ayas; of Arahman as being e+ual in terms of
years, the statement is relatively meaningless insofar as the pralayas are concerned. $ime,
as the ob!ective factor to which human beings respond when they measure the speed of
changes between markers of time indicating the beginning and end of a period, can have no
eperiential human meaning when there are no clocks, no moving celestial bodies, no atoms
in the process of disintegration to serve as standards of measurement. #f a specific length is
given to pralaya, conceived as the 4non5manifestation4 of Arahman, it can only be because
one assumes that the states of manifestation and non5manifestation in the whole cycle must
be of e+ual duration. $he cyclic pattern is assumed to be symmetrical. Aut the word
sy##eri"a!must be given a very broad meaning which suggests 4correspondence4 rather
than what geometry calls symmetry. ymmetry should be understood in a +ualitative rather
than +uantitative and measurable sense. $he oscillations of a pendulum are measurably
symmetrical, but the development of material and biological systems during one of the four
+uarters of the circular pattern :from unrise to Eoon;, and whatever is implied in the
activity and consciousness of Pleromas in the opposite +uarter from unset to idnight, do
not have to be symmetrical in terms of measured time. =et the process of involution 6 from
idnight to Eoon 6 develops in a manner that can be called symmetrical to that of the
process of evolution from Eoon to idnight. #nvolution and, evolution are processes ofopposite polarities, and in terms of the wholeness of the cycle they are complementary and
symmetrical. $he symmetry refers to the structural factor, but not necessarily to eistential
realities.
ne could evidently imagine and postulate that there is no essential structure, no definable
order in the series of changes in the relation (nity5to5ultiplicity. 8hatever happens and
produces the impression of change in human organisms could be interpreted as a random
se+uence of alterations in the relationship of the eperiencing organism to its total
environment. =et the periodic recurrence of many situations characteri)ing human eistence
assuredly implies the eistence of at least a considerable degree of order. oreover, the
reali)ation that our eistence takes place within a field of ordered activities displaying
definite :if not always easily definable; structural characteristics, seems essential to the full
development of human consciousness. #f there is random motion in the universe, this
randomness may be attributed to the activity of the principle of ultiplicity? but while
always present, it is nevertheless balanced in human situations by a factor of order. #ndeed,
the essential drive in the constitution, destiny, or dharma of humanity is the attempt
constantly to increase the reali)ation of that fundamental order and to give it a wider, more
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
27/147
inclusive scope. uch an attempt is collective and takes the form of a culture.
Bach culture seeks to define this universal order in a specific way, and to establish a set of
structural principles. #n most cultures these principles are thought to be the dictates of a
creative od? but the classical sciences, which for centuries have dominated the 8estern
mind, speak of these principles of order as natural Gaw. $he term !awunfortunately evokesthe eistence of a law5giver? and science has no way to eplain how these Gaws of nature
were imposed upon the release of cosmic energy in a postulated Aig Aang. #f we refuse to
accept the reality of such a causal se+uence of "reator and "reation, the bipolar cyclic
pattern of the ovement of 8holeness may be considered the Gaw of Aeness. #ts structure
is very simple and repetitive.
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
28/147
'HAPTER THREE
The 'y"!i" =ru"ure o% he 7oe#en o% ho!eness - 3
Hu#an %ree wi!! and he ro"ess o% read6us#en
#n its most divine aspect, "ompassion takes the form of the odhead-s desire to give to theat least partial failures of the past universe a new chance to eperience 8holeness fully and
concretely. "ompassion inspires the vow Aodhisattvas are said to take as they renounce,
through immense periods yet to unfold, the supreme bliss of Eirvana in order to be able to
assist 4all sentient beings4 on this planet in eperiencing this state of +uasi5absolute
sub!ectivity and oneness. $his assistance undoubtedly takes forms it is impossible for the
ordinary human mind to picture, because they refer to the evolution of humanity as a
whole, and indeed of the earth as a planetary being.
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
29/147
the word #oion. Eewton-s laws of motion imply the eistence of material entities moving
through space considered as an empty container? but such entities are not directly and
originally eperienced. $he mind of a recently born child gives to a series of recurrent
changes, periodically affecting his or her biological organism in a pleasantly or painfully
remembered way, the character of entities 6 a character further emphasi)ed and set by thenames attributed to them by his or her family.:3; #nfants and primitive people who interpret
their collective eperiences in animistic terms seem to think of motion as the result of some
entity-s a"ions. Bven at the sophisticated and rationalistic level of classical Buropean
thinking, the "reation of all material entities was an act of od who, as causeless &irst
"ause and 4Prime over,4 created them 4out of nothing4 :e+ nihi!o;, very much as a
dramatist imagines a new situation which he intends to make into a play, but whose
development has a will of its own and needs to be watched 6 a thoroughly
anthropomorphic conceptD
< much5needed alternative is the idea of perpetual cyclic motion without beginning or end.
$here is neither beginning nor end in the sense that a whole of motion :a cycle, an Bon; can
be made to begin with any phase of the movement.
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
30/147
30$he process of formation of the ego is discussed in my book P!aneari&aion o%
'ons"iousnessand in the booklet Beyond Personhood:an &rancisco, "alifornia3
Rudhyar #nstitute for $ranspersonal
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
31/147
'HAPTER THREE
The 'y"!i" =ru"ure o% he 7oe#en o% ho!eness -
> is hard o "on"eie how he inarian sru"ureof cyclic being can be maintained
under the conditions of perpetual variability which the human situation makes possible. nehas to postulate the operation, through "ompassion and karma, of a metacosmic power
able perpetually to read!ust all dise+uilibratory individual actions generated by human
desires and individual free will. $he myths of many religions provide a guarded eplanation
of various ways in which such a process of reabsorption :or karmic neutrali)ation; takes
place. "lassical reece believed in the actually unimaginable work of the three &ates
:7oiraein reek, Par"aein Gatin; continually weaving the ever5changing patterns of
interpersonal relationships and intercultural events? a blind procedure, for no human
consciousness could possibly envision the +uasi5infinite compleity of the meshing of more
or less individuali)ed lines of read!ustment. $he unmeasurable number of crossings of
event5lines, which not only every human being but humanity as a whole, the planet, the
solar system, etc. lives through as eperienceable situations, cannot be interpreted
ade+uately in terms of what is now popularly known as 4synchronicity.4 8hat happens as an
apparently significant coincidence :significant to some individuali)ed mind; at a 4moment4
isolated from the entire cycle of time is not the important fact. $he entire meshing of
destinies within a whole of balanced motion is involved.
8e can, of course, establish boundaries separating the line of read!ustment of an assumedly
individual and uni+ue person. Peter or %ane, from the lives of other persons? but if we do
that, we in fact isolate what we take to be the cause of a series of effects from the comple
group of desires that emerged from the sub!ectivity factor in Peter-s or %ane-s eperienceslargely as the result of their relatedness to family, culture, and the whole planet.
&or the individual person, the choice is nevertheless open. He or she may accept the karmic
confrontation and the %u!!implications of the situation confronting the individual 6 thus
restoring 8holeness and re5attuning oneself to the rhythmic flow of the ovement. He or
she may also repeat once more the ancient disturbance and deepen the need for future
karmic impacts, unless a power of "ompassion is able to act within and transfigure the
situation.
#f, however, we think of indiidua!i&edkarma, we have to accept the idea of 4something4
to which this karma clings and can be transmitted from one biological organism and
personality to the net. $his 4something4 has been understood in two basically different
ways3 as an individual supernatural and spiritual entity that periodically reincarnates, or as
a set of 4imprints4 which karma5producing desires, thoughts, and acts have made upon a
postulated substance or substratum of being :often referred to as 4astral light4 or 4akhasa4;.
$hese imprints condition the formation of the structure of a new body and personality,
giving it the possibility of either erasing the imprints or deepening them through repetition.$he first way of dealing with the problem of karma5transmission is most generally accepted
by anyone believing in reincarnation.:; $he karma5affected spiritual entity may be thought
of as a od5created individual oul as a perpetually eistent monad, as an a#an
essentially identical to the universal Brah#anthough appearing to be an individual entity.
$he alternative solution has been most clearly advanced by autama, the Auddha, in his
ana#adoctrine, and the transmitted karmic imprints are known in Auddhism as the
s/andhas. $he concept introduced by the philosophy of perative 8holeness is closer to
the latter interpretation than to the first. #t may indeed be very close to what autama
might have said if he had not deliberately avoided any metaphysical speculation. #nstead,
he solely concentrated on the basic situation concretely evident in the lives of human
beings, without relating it to pre5 or post5human phases of an all5inclusive cycle of
being.:5; He apparently was solely concerned :at least in his public message; with the
healing of the suffering5producing stresses :du//ha; he saw inherent in the human
situation. Perhaps an alternative approach is possible which, by integrating the human
situation within an all5inclusive cycle of being, gives it a more acceptable and ealting
meaning by presenting it as a necessary transition 6 indeed a prelude 6 to a more5than5
http://www.khaldea.com/rudhyar/fhe/fhe_c3_p4.shtml#ehttp://www.khaldea.com/rudhyar/fhe/fhe_c3_p4.shtml#d -
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
33/147
human condition, the Pleroma state.
#f one imagines a metaphysical, mystical, non5eistential condition transcending the human
situation in an absolute sense, and if one speaks of it as perfect Aliss or subliminal ecstasy,
it seems obvious that what is evoked has to be understood as the opposite of whatever one
has felt to be limiting, imperfect, and a cause of suffering, aniety, or impotency in one-s lifeas a human being. $he od of most theologies has, in a perfect and sublime condition, all
the +ualities a human person longs to have but does not possess. < state of consciousness
called mystical may give a human being who has concentrated upon and visuali)ed images
of perfection and unchanging bliss the sub!ective feeling5reali)ation that he or she has
reached such a state for what seems a timeless moment. Aut it is a sub!ective state, and no
hu#ansituation can occur that would give it the character of actually changeless
permanence. #n order to reach it, other factors in the situation 6 implied in the personhood
of the mystic 6 have to be not only devalued, but in a very real sense paraly)ed. $he
resulting situation thus is no longer 4whole.4 < feeling5eperience of unification or oneness
may be reached? but as we saw, the principle of (nity is only one of the two components of
8holeness. "an we or should we try to deny any reality to the principle of ultiplicity> #f we
do, the very possibility of 4being4 is denied. Aut then 4who4 is it who denies> $he very act of
denial is an affirmation of beingness.
8hat is fundamentally at stake is the interpretation given to the human situation in general
6 and secondarily to any particular and personal situation being eperienced. #t is a
+uestion of whether or not one somehow assumes that the eperience is ousidethe
situation which mind 6 one-s own mind 6 interprets. Aut nothing can 4be4 outside the
ovement of 8holeness. 8hat 4is4 may be a step in the direction of 4light,4 or one in the
direction of 4darkness.4 Aut, as noted earlier, both directions are implied in 8holeness, !ustas (nity and ultiplicity are inherent and inseparable factors in any whole. Eevertheless,
from a strictly human point of view, the ideal of encompassing (nity is closer to the idea of
8holeness than the evident fact of the multiplicity of cells in the single body of a person.
$hese many cells can be separated from one another? yet if separated they die as cells
:thus as units of organi)ation; unless a biologist, by giving them food 6 the energy
potential in material aggregates 6 maintains their beingness as units.
#ndeed, human evolution is the gradual process during which the 4Presence4 of the principle
of (nity becomes an ever more powerful factor in the most basic situations. $hese,
however, operate as vast currents in the oceanic depths of being, they allow storms to
agitate the surface of the water. $he power of the principle of ultiplicity, no longer
e+erna!i&edin a multitude of slightly different biological features, is inerna!i&edin
typically human situations. $his may take the form of ambition and hunger for power and
wealth of a multitude of egos 6 as the craving of an artist for originality, of a scientist to be
the first to make a discovery, or of a mountain climber to reach the peak of ount Bverest.
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
34/147
minimi)e their importance and power.
< psychology and an ethics of 8holeness have to be based on the inclusion of a!!factors in
any situation. < metaphysics of 8holeness must take into consideration and encompass
every possibility of relationship between the principles of (nity and ultiplicity 6 including
those in which one of the two principles is near!y, but not +uite, all5powerful. < religion of8holeness should include od within the cycle of 8holeness :in whatever form this
Presence may be conceived or felt; as one of these etreme states of being? and an and
Eature should be included as well. uch a religion also should not shrink from the reali)ation
that od must have a polar opposite, and that the fullness of eperience possible for the
odhead has to be balanced by the devastated emptiness of whatever is represented by the
condition of nearly absolute ultiplicity.:;
Toa! in"!usionis the unavoidable attitude of whomever understands and is ready, willing,
and able to apply the concept of perative 8holeness to any situation with which he or she
is confronted and accepts to live through and endure. $his is an etremely difficult attitude
to maintain. #f what it implies is clearly understood at an intellectual level, the acceptance of
any situation at an emotional level will be made easier.
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
35/147
'HAPTER *OUR
The Hu#an =iuaion - 1
The 7oe#en o% ho!eness
as a "y"!i" series o% siuaions
#n this book the word siuaionis given a very broad meaning which includes yettranscends its ordinary use. < situation is one of the many possible ways in which a phase
of the ovement of 8holeness is actuali)ed. $he character and inherent +uality of that
phase refers to a particular relationship between the dynamic polarities of being. (nity and
ultiplicity. # speak of a 4situation4 whether the principle of (nity or the principle of
ultiplicity is dominant? thus, whether that situation occurs in a physically ob!ective
universe or in a mostly sub!ective realm of being that may be called 4divine.4 $he odhead
state is a situation? so is the life5span of a biological organism.
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
36/147
more than reflect 4divine4 modes of consciousness.
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
37/147
destroy all natural human organisms. Bsoteric students assume that this kind of matter5
energy appertains only to the highest 4etheric4 sub5planes :sith and seventh; of the
physical world, while what we perceive as solid, li+uid and gaseous matter refers to the
first, second and third sub5planes 6 the fourth :fire; and perhaps the fifth :more specifically
mental; are related to all radical transformation and personal metamorphosis.
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
38/147
'HAPTER *OUR
The Hu#an =iuaion -
>n a su.se2uen "haer > sha!! "onsider #ore %u!!ythe meaning of the upreme
Person and the influence #t has upon the evolution of personhood and of humanity as a
whole. # should nevertheless state here that the effectiveness of the prototype of anyinstrumentality intended to bring about the large5scale transformation of whatever it is to
replace can only be demonstrated when this prototype is reproduced in a large number of
specimens of the same type. $he odhead-s olution proves ade+uate and successful to the
etent that the personhood of the upreme Person will be replicated in many human
persons as yet to evolve. $hese beings, now ready or karmically impelled to eperience the
human state, had known varying degrees of failure in the past 6 or from another point of
view, are the heirs to the 4karmic residua4 :or s/andhas; of ancient failures. Replication
here, however, is a comple process, because !ust as failure can take an immense variety of
forms, so the 4redemptive4 process of "ompassion and karma must be ad!usted to each
category of persons and events. $he upreme Person, therefore, has potentially to embody
an etremely comple olution.$he human situation implied in the concrete application of this multilevel olution to a
myriad of specific types of failure must also be immensely comple and differentiated.
oreover, it has to be worked out at the various sublevels of a strictly human kind of
substantiality 6 thus, in terms of the actual eperience of human beings operating at
different stages of the evolutionary process. $he process of karmic redemption or
neutrali)ation re+uires the development in earth5time of a long series of cultures, in some
cases operating simultaneously on different continents. Bach culture presents a limited
collective kind of solution befitting the basic needs of persons born in the society, or even
more specifically in one of its particular classes or religions. Bach group has its own
collective desires and epectations through which it has to face its karma and work its
4redemption.4 < culture is inspired at the core of its collective being :its 4psychism4; by oneof the basic aspects of the immensely comple upreme Person. $his one particular aspect
becomes the spiritual source of the culture. #t embodies itself in a secondary kind of
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
39/147
practices, or had gained through intuitive, suprasensible and metalogical contacts with their
already developed higher mind, or with Pleroma beings who helped them to understand the
deeper ob!ective meaning of their eperiences while on the Path.
# shall return to the meaning which can be given to the polari)ation of the symbolic
idnight@Eoon phases of the ovement of 8holeness and its relation to the upreme
Person. # should nevertheless state here that this polari)ation constitutes a situation inwhich the most etreme values of the polar trends toward (nity and ultiplicity can be
integrated. $heir integration is the supreme manifestation of 8holeness because in it the
tension between (nity and ultiplicity reaches a degree of maimum intensity. $he stresses
this tension produces in the ovement of being are the greatest possible. $his maimum of
tension and stress characteri)es the human situation. #t is the foundation re+uired for the
development of what is ambiguously called human 4free will4 6 the capacity to choose
between alternatives.
everal possibilities of action or thought may be possible, yet ultimately there are two basic
alternatives3 on the one hand, the way that is attuned to the increasing power of the
principle of (nity after the Eoon point of the cycle? and on the other, the way which resists
that increase and clings to the desire for an ideal of individual or group power. $he firstalternative leads to what may be termed spiritual 4success4 during the human period of the
great cycle of being? the second, to at least partial failure.
#n most cases, failure means not having been able fully to apply, in terms of concrete
eistential events and decisions, the particular solution envisioned by the odhead and
formulated by the celestial Hierarchies with reference to a specific set or collection of karmic
deposits when a period of choice in the person-s :or humanity as a whole-s; life5cycle comes
to an end. #n a planetary sense, this crucial moment after which no fundamental choice is
possible has been symboli)ed as the separation of the sheep from the goats. $his process of
separation does not refer to a final 4%udgement,4 since many superficial improvements may
still occur. Aut a no5longer5modifiable limit is nevertheless established, which defines what
is possible to whatever has evolved so far.8hen one tries to understand and to accept or re!ect 6 partially if not totally 6 any
situation, the ossi.i!iyof transformation is the basic factor to consider. $he sub!ect :4#,4
the individual who assumedly has the capacity to choose; may desire a radical
transformation, and mind may present various procedures or a specific and formali)ed
techni+ue to achieve what 4seems4 to be the 4heart-s desire4? but neither desire nor
techni+ue can become concretely and substantially actuali)ed unless a third factor
ade+uately operates. $his factor is oen"y. $he power to perform the action which has
been chosen has to be latent in the situation. #t is not latent only in the sub!ect considered
as an entity in itself, or in the mental processes formulating a possible method of
achievement? yet it is potentially related to both the sub!ect and the mental factors. $he
three factors are interrelated in the new eperience.$o assert that an individual meets a situation and eists apart from it in a mysteriously
sub!ective yet conscious manner is confusing and unrealistic. < sub!ect does not 4have4 an
eperience which the particular situation elicits. $he sub!ect is an integral component of the
situation, and does not essentially eist outside the eperiencing. Bach new or old situation,
each eperience implies a sub!ective factor which belongs to it, !ust as it implies the
operation of mind5processes and the release of kinetic energy 6 i.e. of the power to act.
Bvery eperience is triune. $he ovement of 8holeness is a cyclic series of situations giving
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
40/147
rise to eperiences to which the sub!ective factor of desire gives a particular purpose, and
the operation of mind a particular meaning. Aut these eperiences must, first of all, be
possible. Purpose and meaning re+uire the possibility of fully eperiencing the situation 6
any situation.
fifth :more specifically mental; are related to all radical transformation and personal
metamorphosis.
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
41/147
'HAPTER *OUR
The Hu#an =iuaion - 3
A ho!ono!o$i"a! iew o% hu#an e+erien"e
#n ordinary use, the word e+erien"e, whether as a noun :4y wife had a wonderful
eperience4; or as a verb :4# eperienced much pain4;, implies an eperienceer. 4omeone4in a particular situation 4had4 an eperience. $he situation gave rise to or produced an
eperience affecting the consciousness and the state of wholeness of abeing. $his being
eisted as an organismic whole before the situation occurred which affected him or her as
eperiencer. $hough he or she may be affected by what took place, the eperiencer is
believed to retain his or her identity ousidethe situation which gave rise to the
eperience. 8hat is considered 4the same4 situation may be eperienced differently by
several entities, each reacting to it in a particular manner according to his or her nature and
character. Gikewise, the same person may be assumed to have different eperiences arising
from different situations. #n all cases the fact that an eperiencer considers an eperience
as 4his or her own4 implies the seemingly incontrovertible feeling of eisting outside the
eperience, even if the latter deeply modifies the state of being with which the eperiencerhad until then identified himself or herself 6 his or her self5image.
&rom the point of view of the philosophy of perative 8holeness, and also according to the
ana#adoctrine constituting the foundation of Auddhist thought :at least in its public
aspect;, no situation is ever the same. $here is likewise no eperiencing sub!ect having a
separate permanent being as an a#anoutside the situation he or she eperiences.
ituations always change, and so does the sub!ective factor inherent in them. #n ancient
reece, before Parmenides apparently introduced the dualistic notion of being and becoming
6 a notion which has plagued 8estern civili)ation ever since 6 Heraclitus had asserted that
no one crossing a river at different times eperiences the same water. Aut in the same
century, the Auddha taught in #ndia that the person who at different times enters the ever5
flowing stream is also not the same person.
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
42/147
impotency producing an epectation of failure. #n the first case the memory factor has its
source in mind. $his may be the mind of the individual person faced by the situation and
remembering one or more similar events, or the collective mind of a culture, a particular
religion, or social class that impressed forcibly upon the personal mind a doctrine or a
particular way of life which ecludes numerous possible responses to rigidly defined
situations. #n the second case, the lack of attention :or even more, the sense of not beingable to rise to the occasion; has its roots in some organismic lack 6 thus in an ineffective
presence of 8holeness, and :at the biological level; the absence of vital energy.
"onsciousness, as an operative aspect of 8holeness, condenses itself into a sub!ect when
an organi)ed whole a""esto eperience the confronting situation.
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
43/147
need, not only of humanity but the whole planet considered as the Barth5being within which
mankind fulfills a definite function, is not what is usually called 4altruism.4 Eevertheless, we are accustomed to give to eperience a
narrow significance. 8e reduce it to the human level at which personhood develops? we
identify the sub!ective factor in 4our4 eperiences with the whole person of which we
assume 4#4 is the independent and at least essentially transcendent sub!ect 6 in religious
terms, the individual oul. $he result is, # believe, a fundamental kind of psychological
confusion, unavoidable as it may be in a period of transition between two levels of being.
#n the net chapter # shall attempt to show how the operations of the three basic factors in
eperience can be at least broadly or abstractly envisioned throughout the entire cycle of
8holeness. 8e shall then be better able to give to ersonhoodits fullest and mostessential meaning. #t has such a meaning in the upreme Person whose appearance in the
field of eistence of the Barth5being occurs at the symbolic Eoon of the ovement of
8holeness when the rise of the principle of (nity begins. =et this prototypal meaning will
only be reali)ed in the fullness of human nature on a transformed earth, when the human
cycle ends and the Pleroma of the Perfect 6 the seed remnants of our humanity 6 pursue
their evolution in a realm of being in which the drive toward a state of all5inclusive neness
increasingly yet never absolutely overpowers the trend toward ultiplicity.
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
44/147
'HAPTER *>?E
The Three *a"ors in E+erien"e
and Their 'y"!i" Trans%or#aion - 1
=u.6e"iiy and desire#n the preceding chapter the factor of sub!ectivity was shown to result from a condensation
of the 8holeness of an organi)ed whole whose attention had been aroused by a developing
situation. $his whole is organi)ed, in the sense that it is based on and structured by a
particular value and +uality of the cyclically and symmetrically unfolding relationship
between the principles of (nity and ultiplicity. $his whole thus operates as one of the
many manifestations of a particular and definable phase of the ovement of 8holeness. ?E
The Three *a"ors in E+erien"e
and Their 'y"!i" Trans%or#aion - 3
The e+endiure and reoenia!i&aion o% ener$yBnergy, understood in its most fundamental nature, is the product of a dynamic state of
relationship. $he concept of 8holeness implies such a state, whose two polarities are the
principles of (nity and ultiplicity.
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
51/147
devotion to the
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
52/147
#t must do so because the principle of ultiplicity aggressively dominates the realm of life5
systems, and the principle of (nity can only maintain the operation of the system as a
whole between two markers of time, birth and death
0$wo entities occupying the same area of space at the same time are not related? they
constitute a single entity. $he concept of knowledge through what is assumed to be
4identification4 is the result of a semantic confusion. Perfect resonan"eis meant, not
identification. imilarly, a reflection is not the 4real4 source of the light5rays.
30ee Rhyh# o% ho!eness, chapter twelve, p. 19, for a definition of science.
http://www.khaldea.com/rudhyar/rw/rw_c12_p1.shtmlhttp://www.khaldea.com/rudhyar/rw/rw_c12_p1.shtml -
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
53/147
'HAPTER *>?E
The Three *a"ors in E+erien"e
and Their 'y"!i" Trans%or#aion -
A he so"io"u!ura! !ee!,the process of negentropy assumes the character of4information.4 #n childhood one may refer to it as the process of education? but what is
usually called education is actually instruction. $o be 4in5structed4 is to be fed informational
data, operational formulae, and officially tested and validated techni+ues.
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
54/147
begins to overcome that of the trend toward ultiplicity, which by then is in retreat and in a
defensive role. #n the Pleroma type of organi)ation the process of repotentiali)ation leads to
an increasing condensation of energy.
pace itself is being condensed. $his condensation process is the polar opposite of the
cosmic scattering and differentiation of energy which followed the 4"reation4 of theuniverse, now given a new form :perhaps as mythologicalD; as modern science-s Aig Aang.
$he repotentiali)ation of energy through a hierarchical series of metacosmic and
predominantly sub!ective Pleroma states leads to an a!#ostotal concentration of energy
and space. pace is condensed into an increasingly small area, yet can never be reduced to
a mathematical point. oreover, all +uantitative values and the possibility of measurement
are evidently not applicable to such a 4divine4 state. #n this odhead state everything may
seem possible, and potential energy might be considered infinite. =et as immense
"ompassion arises, the olution envisioned has to balance and eactly fit the karmic
remains of the by then concluded cycle. Bverything is possible that is needed.
Bnergy is always there, available? but the character of that available energy is determined
by the balance of power of the two principles of (nity and ultiplicity in that particular
phase of the ovement of 8holeness. $he availability of the power is also related to the
nature and material characteristics of the locality at which energy is to be used. 8hat we
call 4matter4 is a condition in which energy has reached a degree of stability. atter :or in a
more general sense, substance, whether or not it is 4physical4; is energy in form? and as we
shall presently see, form :in the true sense of the word; is the basic product of the mind
factor. However, this is mind operating at a cosmogenetic, biogenetic level and, during the
human period of evolution, as builder of the comple structures of a vast series of cultures.
Bach culture is intended to stress a particular aspect of the supreme ideal of personhoodwhich the odhead had envisioned during the idnight phase of the great cycle.
8hat is needed of the infinite potential of energy available to the odhead at that idnight
moment of reversal of cyclic motion is used by the divine ind, acting through what past
mythologies have called 4celestial Hierarchies4 of Auilders of the "osmos. However, the
mobili)ed energy is operating within the divine ind, of which these Hierarchies are
differentiated aspects. Bach Hierarchy releases a specific type of energy which eventually,
during the evolutionary development of humanity, will be characteristically available to a
particular series of cultures. Human persons may become 4agents4 for the release of the
energy or the basic archetypal structures that a Hierarchy, with which the persons are in
tune, has created.
$rue 4creativity4 is the ability to reflect and concreti)e an archetype eisting at the higher
level of mind. "reativity should not mean merely or essentially personal 4self5epression.4 #f
it does it has to be considered the release of internal tensions. ost of the time, however, it
refers to the making of a product which answers the desire of a group of human beings, and
may bring some kind of profit. Aut productivity should not be confused with creativity.
#nternal psychological tensions do undoubtedly generate some kind of energy5but emotions
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
55/147
operate at a level essentially different from that of cosmic or evolutionary movements.:;
$hese are attuned to what is intended and possible in terms of the karma5neutrali)ing
process. $hey work hrou$hpersonhood, but they ac+uire the particular character and
often inconsistent rhythm of emotional releases :perhaps interpreted as self5epression;
engendered by the desires of a sub!ect :#, myself; having separated itself from the cyclicprocess and intent on proving its freedom of choice. 8hen this occurs, personhood becomes
a means which insists on being an end in itself. $his happens when mind provides a
rationali)ed interpretation and !ustification for the desires of the sub!ect of whom it has
become a servant. $hat mind, however, may refer to a collective type of mentality
superimposed upon the individual situation, whether this mentality is traditional and
religion5based or the product of a generation-s revolt against past standards. ind can
indeed be a tyrant after having begun as a servant.
0ln my earliest work Ar as Re!ease o% Power:19/2; # stressed this distinction between"yclic :or "osmic; otions and personal emotions, particularly in the chapter 4
-
8/13/2019 Dane Rudhyar - The Fullness of Human Experience
56/147
'HAPTER *>?E
The Three *a"ors in E+erien"e
and Their 'y"!i" Trans%or#aion - 5
7ind< iner#ediary, inerreer and e"hni"ian
#n any situation a desire is aroused. #t may be an unconscious or a conscious desire? it maybe the taken5for5granted motive that once led to the formation of a habit 6 a sub!ective
manner of reacting to an often repeated situation. Aut however it manifests, and whatever
the name given to it, the desire factor is operating, epressing a sub!ective state of being, a
preference for a particular type of response.
$he desire5motive re+uires the release of some kind of energy in order to be actuali)ed? yet
many psychologists and philosophers do not seem to reali)e that the sub!ective factor never
deals dire"!ywith energy. < third factor, mind, is needed as an intermediary. ind has to
operate not only as a linking activity but as an interpreter and :in the broadest sense of the
word; a technician.
#n a famous illustration, the dualistic ankhya chool of philosophy in old #ndia spoke of
urusha:spirit; as being lame, and ra/rii:the substratum of matter5energy; as beingblind. Purusha is being carried over Prakriti-s shoulder, showing the way to the blind. $his is,
however, an incomplete and misleading image? for while Prakriti may be blind, it is shown in
the story to be organi)ed as a body able and trained to walk, while the seeing Purusha can
somehow choose :or is led to choose; one of several possible options in directing the steps
:the operational activity; of Prakriti. < third activity is implied in the activities of the pair.
$his factor 6 mind operating at the biological level as a generic formative principle 6 has
given an organically effective structure to the vital energies of the integrated collectivity of
cells of the body? this body can at least walk. $his same factor, operating at the level of
culture and personhood, enables the desire to reach a goal :or at least to follow a definable
direction; and to translate itself into a directive or order which can be transmitted to and
sufficiently understood by the blind body of Prakriti.Aecause the operations of mind are manifold and assume varied aspects, the whole range of
the mind-s activity is not recogni)ed for what it is. =et these activities should never be
absolutely ignored or denied, !ust as a sub!ective and a potency factor can never be entirely
absent from any situation. $hey may at most be rendered temporarily ineffectual or
intentionally paraly)ed in some special and abnormal eperiences. $he inactivity of any one
of the three factors may indeed be valuable in some special human situations, but such an
inactivity can only be a means to force an issue which has produced intense stress and
tensions. #n the best possible cases it may produce a state of etremely focused 4at5tention4
to the possibility of solving a problem posed by human free will? and free will is the strictly
human ability of the sub!ective factor to detach itself from a situation and operate as an
eternal and assumedly unconditioned sub!ect.#n one identifiable mode of activity or another, mind operates in all situations, thus in all
phases of the g