dark diversity in the tundra: the source of future ... · isabel barrio, alessandro petraglia,...

26
Dark diversity in the tundra: the source of future biodiversity change? with Isla Myers-Smith, Christian Rixen, Anne Bjorkman, Toke Høye, Greg Henry, Nicoletta Cannone, Rien Aerts, Petr Macek, Jacob Harris, Kayla Arey, Zoe Panchen, Elise Gallois, Sofie Agger, Cassandra Elphinstone, IngaSvala Jonsdottir, Sonja Wipf, Isabel Barrio, Alessandro Petraglia, Michele Carbognani, Marcello Tomaselli, Anne Tolvanen and the ITEX Species Pool Consortium GERGANA DASKALOVA PHD STUDENT , UNI OF EDINBURGH @gndaskalova gndaskalova.com #TeamShrub Isla Myers-Smith

Upload: others

Post on 12-Mar-2021

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Dark diversity in the tundra: the source of future ... · Isabel Barrio, Alessandro Petraglia, Michele Carbognani, Marcello Tomaselli, Anne Tolvanenand the ITEX Species Pool Consortium

Dark diversity in the tundra:

the source of future biodiversity change?

with Isla Myers-Smith, Christian Rixen, Anne Bjorkman, Toke Høye, Greg Henry, Nicoletta Cannone, Rien Aerts, Petr Macek, Jacob Harris, Kayla Arey, Zoe Panchen, Elise Gallois, Sofie Agger, Cassandra Elphinstone, IngaSvala Jonsdottir, Sonja Wipf, Isabel Barrio, Alessandro Petraglia, Michele Carbognani, Marcello Tomaselli, Anne Tolvanen and the ITEX Species Pool Consortium

GERGANA

DASKALOVA

PHD STUDENT,

UNI OF EDINBURGH

@gndaskalova gndaskalova.com #TeamShrub

Isla Myers-Smith

Page 2: Dark diversity in the tundra: the source of future ... · Isabel Barrio, Alessandro Petraglia, Michele Carbognani, Marcello Tomaselli, Anne Tolvanenand the ITEX Species Pool Consortium

“Panoramas never twice alike”Henry Cowles 1899

Page 3: Dark diversity in the tundra: the source of future ... · Isabel Barrio, Alessandro Petraglia, Michele Carbognani, Marcello Tomaselli, Anne Tolvanenand the ITEX Species Pool Consortium

Jeff Kerby

Page 4: Dark diversity in the tundra: the source of future ... · Isabel Barrio, Alessandro Petraglia, Michele Carbognani, Marcello Tomaselli, Anne Tolvanenand the ITEX Species Pool Consortium

Gergana DaskalovaGergana Daskalova

Page 5: Dark diversity in the tundra: the source of future ... · Isabel Barrio, Alessandro Petraglia, Michele Carbognani, Marcello Tomaselli, Anne Tolvanenand the ITEX Species Pool Consortium

The composition of tundra plant communities is changing

Elmendorf et al. 2012, NCC

Page 6: Dark diversity in the tundra: the source of future ... · Isabel Barrio, Alessandro Petraglia, Michele Carbognani, Marcello Tomaselli, Anne Tolvanenand the ITEX Species Pool Consortium

Tundra plant communities are getting taller

New species invading

communities over time

Bjorkman et al. 2018, Nature

The traits of tundra plant communities are changing

Page 7: Dark diversity in the tundra: the source of future ... · Isabel Barrio, Alessandro Petraglia, Michele Carbognani, Marcello Tomaselli, Anne Tolvanenand the ITEX Species Pool Consortium

Beyond the plots

Page 8: Dark diversity in the tundra: the source of future ... · Isabel Barrio, Alessandro Petraglia, Michele Carbognani, Marcello Tomaselli, Anne Tolvanenand the ITEX Species Pool Consortium

How do species pools vary across the tundra?

How much diversity is there hidden beyond the ITEX plots?

Research questions

?

Page 9: Dark diversity in the tundra: the source of future ... · Isabel Barrio, Alessandro Petraglia, Michele Carbognani, Marcello Tomaselli, Anne Tolvanenand the ITEX Species Pool Consortium

SPECIES POOL“All species that are present in an ecological community.”

Gergana Daskalova

Page 10: Dark diversity in the tundra: the source of future ... · Isabel Barrio, Alessandro Petraglia, Michele Carbognani, Marcello Tomaselli, Anne Tolvanenand the ITEX Species Pool Consortium

100 m

The ITEX Species Pool Protocol

Page 11: Dark diversity in the tundra: the source of future ... · Isabel Barrio, Alessandro Petraglia, Michele Carbognani, Marcello Tomaselli, Anne Tolvanenand the ITEX Species Pool Consortium
Page 12: Dark diversity in the tundra: the source of future ... · Isabel Barrio, Alessandro Petraglia, Michele Carbognani, Marcello Tomaselli, Anne Tolvanenand the ITEX Species Pool Consortium

QikiqtarukUtqiagvik

Atqasuk

Abisko

Narsarsuaq

Svalbard

Stelvio

Ellesmere

Kilpisjarvi

GaviaValBercla

Siberia

Tibet

Iceland

40 50 60 70lat

QikiqtarukUtqiagvik

Atqasuk

Abisko

Narsarsuaq

Svalbard

Stelvio

Ellesmere

Kilpisjarvi

GaviaValBercla

Siberia

Tibet

Iceland

40 50 60 70lat

Latitude

14 sites

29 plant communities

More on the way!

Page 13: Dark diversity in the tundra: the source of future ... · Isabel Barrio, Alessandro Petraglia, Michele Carbognani, Marcello Tomaselli, Anne Tolvanenand the ITEX Species Pool Consortium

QikiqtarukUtqiagvik

Atqasuk

Abisko

Narsarsuaq

Svalbard

Stelvio

Ellesmere

Kilpisjarvi

GaviaValBercla

Siberia

Tibet

Iceland

40 50 60 70lat

QikiqtarukUtqiagvik

Atqasuk

Abisko

Narsarsuaq

Svalbard

Stelvio

Ellesmere

Kilpisjarvi

GaviaValBercla

Siberia

Tibet

Iceland

40 50 60 70lat

Latitude

How do species pools vary across the tundra?

Qikiqtaruk

Daskalova et al. in prep.

Specie

s

Specie

s

Specie

s

Specie

s

Specie

s

Distance

Distance

Distance

Distance

Distance

Page 14: Dark diversity in the tundra: the source of future ... · Isabel Barrio, Alessandro Petraglia, Michele Carbognani, Marcello Tomaselli, Anne Tolvanenand the ITEX Species Pool Consortium

How do species pools vary across the tundra?

QikiqtarukUtqiagvik

Atqasuk

Abisko

Narsarsuaq

Svalbard

Stelvio

Ellesmere

Kilpisjarvi

GaviaValBercla

Siberia

Tibet

Iceland

40 50 60 70lat

Latitude

Up to 10-folddifference in species pool size

Daskalova et al. in prep.

Page 15: Dark diversity in the tundra: the source of future ... · Isabel Barrio, Alessandro Petraglia, Michele Carbognani, Marcello Tomaselli, Anne Tolvanenand the ITEX Species Pool Consortium

Why do species pools matter?

Colonisation

Competition

Composition

Function

Gergana Daskalova

Page 16: Dark diversity in the tundra: the source of future ... · Isabel Barrio, Alessandro Petraglia, Michele Carbognani, Marcello Tomaselli, Anne Tolvanenand the ITEX Species Pool Consortium

DARK DIVERSITY“All species that are present in an ecological community but have never been recorded inside the plots.”

Gergana Daskalova

Page 17: Dark diversity in the tundra: the source of future ... · Isabel Barrio, Alessandro Petraglia, Michele Carbognani, Marcello Tomaselli, Anne Tolvanenand the ITEX Species Pool Consortium

How much diversity is there hidden beyond the ITEX plots?

+

Page 18: Dark diversity in the tundra: the source of future ... · Isabel Barrio, Alessandro Petraglia, Michele Carbognani, Marcello Tomaselli, Anne Tolvanenand the ITEX Species Pool Consortium
Page 19: Dark diversity in the tundra: the source of future ... · Isabel Barrio, Alessandro Petraglia, Michele Carbognani, Marcello Tomaselli, Anne Tolvanenand the ITEX Species Pool Consortium
Page 20: Dark diversity in the tundra: the source of future ... · Isabel Barrio, Alessandro Petraglia, Michele Carbognani, Marcello Tomaselli, Anne Tolvanenand the ITEX Species Pool Consortium

How much diversity is there hidden beyond the ITEX plots?

QikiqtarukUtqiagvik

Atqasuk

Abisko

Narsarsuaq

Svalbard

Stelvio

Ellesmere

Kilpisjarvi

GaviaValBercla

Siberia

Tibet

Iceland

40 50 60 70lat

Latitude Weak latitudinal gradient in dark diversity

species on average that have never been detected inside plots

30

Daskalova et al. in prep.

Page 21: Dark diversity in the tundra: the source of future ... · Isabel Barrio, Alessandro Petraglia, Michele Carbognani, Marcello Tomaselli, Anne Tolvanenand the ITEX Species Pool Consortium

Why does dark diversity matter?

Gergana Daskalova

Higher dark diversity

Future biodiversity change

Species detectability & monitoring

Page 22: Dark diversity in the tundra: the source of future ... · Isabel Barrio, Alessandro Petraglia, Michele Carbognani, Marcello Tomaselli, Anne Tolvanenand the ITEX Species Pool Consortium

What’s next?

Jeff Kerby

Page 23: Dark diversity in the tundra: the source of future ... · Isabel Barrio, Alessandro Petraglia, Michele Carbognani, Marcello Tomaselli, Anne Tolvanenand the ITEX Species Pool Consortium

Where are the

hotspots of dark

diversity?Isla Myers-Smith

Page 24: Dark diversity in the tundra: the source of future ... · Isabel Barrio, Alessandro Petraglia, Michele Carbognani, Marcello Tomaselli, Anne Tolvanenand the ITEX Species Pool Consortium

Prediction: In warmer and wetter microclimates?

Daskalova et al. in prep.

Page 25: Dark diversity in the tundra: the source of future ... · Isabel Barrio, Alessandro Petraglia, Michele Carbognani, Marcello Tomaselli, Anne Tolvanenand the ITEX Species Pool Consortium

Species pools across the tundra vary up to 10 times, likely due more to topographic variation than latitude.

Biodiversity is out there, but we can miss it in our plots.

On average there are 30 species just outside plots that could be the source of future tundra biodiversity change.

Research questions

?

Page 26: Dark diversity in the tundra: the source of future ... · Isabel Barrio, Alessandro Petraglia, Michele Carbognani, Marcello Tomaselli, Anne Tolvanenand the ITEX Species Pool Consortium

By looking beyond the plots, we can better understand ongoing and future biodiversity change

across the tundra biome.

@gndaskalova gndaskalova.com #TeamShrub

KEY MESSAGE