david einhorn st. joe company slideshow from the value investing congress 2010

Upload: john-carroll

Post on 09-Apr-2018

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    1/139

    !"#$%&'(&)*+#,#-./(&0'1&21"$%&/34&5+#6&7'893&:',#David Einhorn, Greenlight Capital

    Value Investing CongressOctober 13, 2010

    Head to MarketFolly.com for more Value Investing Congress Coverage

    http://www.marketfolly.com/http://www.marketfolly.com/http://www.marketfolly.com/http://www.marketfolly.com/
  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    2/139

    ;

    !"#$%?,-

    @ AB,#>"*?&+?-&>'$$#%&C6&$"D#&?8&?>,6&'(&-3#?,>'$$#>-E&&/39-&C##8>?-#%&$"D#&?&C$?*DC'?>%4&>#C1"$34&?8%>?-#%&?F?"8E&&213&C?-#C?$$&+?-&,?>D#%&3+#&3",#E&&

    5+"-&("#$%4&3+"-&F?,#4&"-&?&G?>3&'(&'1>&G?-34&H?6E&&/3&>#,"8%-&1-&'(&?$$&3+?3&'8*#&I?-&F''%4&?8%&3+?3&*'1$%&C#&?F?"8EJ

    K 5#>>#8*#&L?884&A!"#$%&'(&=>#?,-J ;MNM

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    3/139

    O

    ="-*$?",#>

    5PQ)Q&LB5QH/BR)&)PBRR&S3+&"8&3+"-&G>#-#83?3"'8&+?-&C##8&'C3?"8#% (>',&G1C$"*$6&?X?"$?C$#&-'1>*#-E&&/3&"-&G>'X"%#%&('>&"8('>,?3"'8?$&G1>G'-#-&'8$6&?8%&-+'1$%&8'3&C#&%##,#%&?-&?&

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

    5+#&"8('>,?3"'8&"8&3+"-&G>#-#83?3"'8&"-&G>'X"%#%&?-&'(&3+#&%?3#&+#>#'(&?8%&"-&-1CY#*3&3'&*+?8F#&

    ?3&?86&3",#&?(3#>&3+#&%?3#&+#>#'(Z&G>'X"%#%4&+'I#X#>4&3+?3&("8?8*"?$&%?3?&*'83?"8#%&+#>#"8&"-&?-&'(&=#*#,C#>&[;4&O\\M&18$#--&'3+#>I"-#&-G#*"("#%E

    /8X#-3,#83&?**'183-&,?8?F#%&C6&U>##8$"F+3&?8%&"3-&?(("$"?3#-&,?6 +?X#&?&G'-"3"'8&"8&?86&'(&3+#&-#*1>"3"#-&%"-*1--#%&"8&3+"-&G>#-#83?3"'8E&&U>##8$"F+3&,?6&>##X?$1?3#&"3-&+'$%"8F-&"8&-1*+&G'-"3"'8-&?8%&-#$$&'>&*'X#>&*#>3?"8&G'-"3"'8-E

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    4/139

    [

    /83>'%1*3"'8&3'&5+#&)3E&]'#&:',G?86

    @ 5"*D#>.&]#-&

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    5/139

    `

    /83>'%1*3"'8&3'&5+#&)3E&]'#&:',G?86

    @ ]?$&G1>G'-#-&'(&3+#&:',G?86&I#>#&3'.&

    L?81(?*31>#4&C164&-#$$4&",G'>34&?8%dG'>3&G1$GI''%4&I''%G1$G4&G?G#>4&G?G#>C'?>%4&?8%&?$$&>?I&,?3#>"?$-&?8%&C6KG>'%1*3-&3+#>#'(

    =#?$&"8&?8%&%"-G'-#&'(&?$$&D"8%-&'(&>#?$&?8%&G#>-'8?$&G>'G#>36

    )'1>*#.&]

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    6/139

    a

    /83>'%1*3"'8&3'&5+#&)3E&]'#&:',G?86

    @ B(3#>&%#*?%#-&'(&C#"8F&?&G?G#>&*',G?86&I"3+&X?-3&3",C#>&+'$%"8F-4&]?3#F"*&-+"(3

    ]E&H1,,#$$&-#>X#%&?-&V>#-"%#83&'(&="-8#6&=#X#$'G,#83&?8%&?-&:+?">,?8&'(&7?$3&="-8#6&/,?F"8##>"8F4&3+#&%"X"-"'8&>#-G'8-"C$#&('>&="-8#6f-&I'>$%I"%#&*>#?3"X#&%#-"F84&>#?$-3?3#4&>#-#?>*+&?8%&%#X#$'G,#83&?*3"X"3"#-

    )'1>*#.&!'>C#-&C"'4&+33G.^^G#'G$#E('>C#-E*',^G>'("$#^G#3#>K-K>1,,#$$^cMcc\

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    7/139

    c

    7+?3&Qd?*3$6&"-&/,?F"8##>"8Fg

    The custom at Imagineering has been to start the creativeprocess with the boldest, wildest, best idea one can comeup with. Many Imagineers consider this to be the truebeginning of the design process and operate under thenotion thatif it can be dreamt, it can be built.

    K7"D"G#%"?

    T-#&'(&="-8#6&,?>D-&?8%&F>?G+"*&"-&-3>"*3$6&3'&"$$1-3>?3#&?&G'"83E&5+#>#&"-&8'&*'88#*3"'8&C#3I##8&="-8#6&?8%&)3E&]'#&

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    8/139

    b

    /,?F"8##>"8F

    @ )3E&]'#&3''D&?&,'>#&?FF>#--"X#&?GG>'?*+&3'&"3-&$?8%&+'$%"8F-&C6&C#*',"8F&?8&?*3"X#&$?8%&%#X#$'G#>

    @ This stretch of beach will be branded a nationaldestination with the same kind of recognition asNantucket, Hilton Head Island, or Napa.

    h V#3#>&H1,,#$$4&:Q8"8F-&:?$$&

    j>#(#>#8*"8F&7"8%L?>D&?8%&V'>3&)3E&]'#k

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    9/139

    N

    NANTUCKET

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    10/139

    M

    HILTON HEAD ISLAND

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    11/139

    ;\

    NAPA

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    12/139

    ;;

    PORT ST. JOE & WINDMARK

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    13/139

    ;O

    R?8%&=#X#$'G,#83&5+>'1F+&3+#&2'',

    @ /8&O\\\4&]#-J

    :'8-"-3#%&'(&?GG>'d",?3#$6&b\\4\\\&?*>#-&'(&G"8#&('>#-3-&G$1-&[\\4\\\&?*>#-&'(&,"d#%&3",C#>4&I#3$?8%-4&$?D#&?8%&

    *?8?$

    /8*$1%#%&O[&,"$$"'8&3'8-&'(&-3?8%"8F&G"8#&?8%&;;&,"$$"'8&3'8-&'(&+?>%I''%&"8X#83'>6

    )'1>*#.&]

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    14/139

    ;[

    69a`[a`MNNM;`5",C#>^&!'>#-3>6

    693jO\akjc;k;Ma[;c`;[[;[cO[\b;;a`)3E&]'#&5'3?$&V>#K3?d&V>'("3

    724;\;[[;\\b[a;aabNcNc`M`H1>?$&R?8%

    ;a`

    02

    (99)jOO\kj;MMkjN[kjOak;\McNa\jOk`bH#?$&Q-3?3#&=#X&l&

    Total090807060504030100V>#K3?d&V>'("3&j"8&,"$$"'8-&_k

    ]'("3-&*',#&(>',&H1>?$&R?8%&-?$#-

    7+?3&P?-&]*#.&]3#%&%?3?kS'3#.&H#?$&Q-3?3#&=#X#$'G,#83&l&&X?$1#-&*',C"8#&H#-"%#83"?$ H#?$&Q-3?3#4&:',,#>*"?$&H#?$&Q-3?3#&?8%&&-#F,#83-&

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    15/139

    ;`

    7+?3&P?-&]-=#*&[;4&O\\M=#*&[;4&;MMM

    H#3?"8#%&Q?>8"8F-&m&="X"%#8%-&V#>&B*>#&)'$%& _;4;\O

    j;k ]#3?"8#%?>8"8F-&?33>"C13?C$#&3'&!$'>"%?&

    Q?-3&:'?-3&/8%1-3>"#-&I+"*+&I?-&-G18K'((&"8&O\\\E

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    16/139

    ;a

    7+?3&='&0'1&3+I#-3&!$'>"%?

    b\n&'(&$?8%&+'$%"8F-&I"3+"8&;a&,"$#-&'(&3+#&*'?-3&

    '(&U1$(&'(&L#d"*'

    AV>'X#8&%#X#$'G,#83dG#>3"-#J

    `;4\\\S"3$#%&?*>#-&

    @ B$$'I-&('>&%#X#$'G,#83&'(&`[4\\\&>#-"%#83"?$&18"3-&?8%&'X#>&;[&,"$$"'8&-o1?>#&(##3&'(&*',,#>*"?$&-G?*#

    @ =#X#$'G,#83&'GG'>318"3"#-&?>'18%&8#I&"83#>8?3"'8?$&?">G'>3

    )'1>*#.&]#8*#&'8&L?>*+&M4&O\;\

    MarketFolly.com : Your Source for Coverage of the Value Investing Congress

    http://www.marketfolly.com/http://www.marketfolly.com/
  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    17/139

    S#I&B">G'>3

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    18/139

    ;b

    S#I&B">G'>3

    @ B-&(?>&C?*D&?-&>#*'>%#%&3>?8-*>"G3-&F'&ji[&9\ak4&],"3-

    !BB9-&H#*'>%&'(&=#*"-"'8&?GG>'X"8F&>#$'*?3"'8

    @ ]3&

    B13+'>"36

    @ ]##%&3'&C?*D-3'G&)'13+I#-3&B">$"8#-9'G#>?3"8F&$'--#-&('>&[&6#?>-4&"(&8#*#--?>6&

    )'1>*#-.&]#--&H#$#?-#&?3&+33G.^^">EY'#E*',^>#$#?-#%#3?"$E*(,gH#$#?-#/=pa\Nc;; ?8%&iO&O\;\?>8"8F-&*?$$&3>?8-*>"G3

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    19/139

    ;N

    S#I&B">G'>3&?-&:?3?$6-3

    @ A7#&+?X#&F>#?3&?--#3-4&I#&?>#&"8&S'>3+I#-3&!$'>"%?4&[\\4\\\&'(&'1>&?*>#-&?>#&I"3+"8&`\&,"$#-&'(&3+?3&8#I&?">G'>3E&&7#&+?X#&%#X#$'G,#83dG#>3"-#Z&

    I#&+?X#&?8d3>#,#$6&-3>'8F&C?$?8*#&-+##3&3'&I#?3+#>&I+?3#X#>&-3'>,-&*',"8F&'1>&I?6E&&7#&+?X#&?&8#I&"83#>8?3"'8?$&?">G'>3&18G>#*#%#83#%&"8&3+#&T8"3#%&)3?3#-&?8%&I#&?>#&G'"-#%&('>&F>'I3+EJ

    K2>"33&U>##8#4&:Q#8*#&[^M^;\

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    20/139

    ;M

    21$$"-+&B">G'>3&R?8%&W?$1?3"'8

    @ /8&*+?-#&3+#&$?8%&?3&3+#&'$%&V?8?,?&:"36&B">G'>3&3'&>#%#X#$'G&"3

    V1>*+?-#%&b\N&?*>#-&('>&_N\4\\\^&?*>#j;k

    @ 21$$-&1-#&3+"-&3'&-?6&'8#&-+'1$%&X?$1#&]#-&?>'18%&3+#&8#I&?">G'>3&?3&_c\4\\\^&?*>#

    [a4\\\&?*>#-&d&_c\4\\\&G#>&?*>#&p&_OE;&C"$$"'8jOk

    @ /(&3+#&$?8%&?>'18%&3+#&?">G'>3&"-&I'>3+&_OE;&C"$$"'84&C1$$-&*$?",&6'1&?>#&F#33"8F&3+#&'3+#>&a\\4\\\&?*>#-&A('>&(>##J

    j;k&R#1*?%"? S?3"'8?$&:'>G&O\\M&;\Ke4&GEO\

    jOk&2>'6+"$$ B--#3&L?8?F#,#834&A216&7+#8&5+#>#9-&J G>#-#83?3"'8&iO&O\;\

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    21/139

    O\

    R#1*?%"?9- V?8?,?&:"36&B">G'>3

    R#1*?%"?9- V?8?,?&:"36&R?8%

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    22/139

    O;

    S'>3+I#-3&!$'>"%?&2#?*+#-&B">G'>3

    ]"%?&2#?*+#-&R?8%

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    23/139

    OO

    5+#&/83#>8?3"'8?$&B">G'>3&"-&P#>#q

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    24/139

    O[

    S'>3+I#-3&!$'>"%?&2#?*+#-&/839$&B">G'>3

    @ ;4`\\&'(&3+#&C#-3&?*>#-&('>&%#X#$'G,#83&?>#&A/8-"%#&5+#&!#8*#J

    5+"-&$?8%&"-&'I8#%&C6&3+#&

    B">G'>3&B13+'>"364&8'3&]##K3>?%#Kr'8#

    5+#&B">G'>3&2'?>%&*?8&"--1#&3?d&(>##&%#C3&3'&*'8-3>1*3&

    C1"$%"8F-&('>%&1-#>- 5+#&B">G'>3&2'?>%&-?6-&"3&

    +?-&8'&*'83>?*3-&I"3+%&1-#>-&

    )'1>*#-.&:'8X#>-?3"'8-&I"3+&5+#&B">G'>3&B13+'>"36&?8%&!#o1#-3&-#83&3'&5+#&B">G'>3&B13+'>"36&2'?>%

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    25/139

    O`

    B$$&'(&]3K'I8#%&$?8%&$'*?3#%&

    A/8-"%#&5+#&!#8*#J

    @ ='#-&]

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    26/139

    Oa

    BGG?>#83$64&3+#6&("F1>#%&"3&'13s

    )'1>*#.&B">G'>3&2'?>%&L"813#-4&]18#&O\;\

    ]

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    27/139

    Oc

    S'>3+I#-3&!$'>"%?&2#?*+#-&/839$&B">G'>3

    @]%&G?>36&%#?$-&'>&%#X#$'G,#83-&j;k

    @7+?3&is 3+#>#g&V"$#-&'(&%">3

    ]',"-#%&3'&C#F"8&*'8-3>1*3"'8&'(&"3-&8#I&+#?%o1?>3#>-&C6&,"3-&('>&X#>3"*?$&%#X#$'G,#83&*1>>#83$6&'8&>#*'>%&j;k

    j;k&!#o1#-3&-#83&3'&5+#&B">G'>3&B13+'>"36&2'?>%

    jOk&iO&O\;\?>8"8F-&*?$$&3>?8-*>"G3

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    28/139

    7+?3&?>#&3+#&>#,?"8"8F&abb4\\\&?*>#-&I'>3+g

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    29/139

    ON

    5",C#>$?8%&?8%&H1>?$&R?8%&W?$1#

    )'1>*#-.&]"*#^B*>#)?$#-&V>"*#B*>#-0#?>]

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    30/139

    OM

    5",C#>$?8%&?8%&H1>?$&R?8%&W?$1#

    $1,184$7,159,136,9006,044,587Total

    _;4Obc_Mb4\\\4\\\bc4\\\O\\c/83#>8?3"'8?$&V?G#>&!'>#-3$?8%&)?$#j`k

    _N`O_`\;4\\\4\\\`bc4\\\O\\c/83#>8?3"'8?$&V?G#>&!'>#-3$?8%&)?$#j`k

    _;4;Mc_c4;\\4\\\4\\\a4;\\4\\\O\\c/83#>8?3"'8?$&V?G#>&!'>#-3$?8%&)?$#j`k

    _;4`MN_O4[bc4M\\;4aNbO\\M5",C#>X#-3 RR:&V1>*+?-#j[k_;4O[;_Mb4ON\4\\\bM4\\\O\;\TE)E&)'13+&H#F"'8&5",C#>$?8%&)?$#-

    jOk

    _;4aO\_OOc4`N\4\\\;`M4\\\O\;\TE)E&)'13+&H#F"'8&5",C#>$?8%&)?$#-jOk

    _;4``O_O[a4\\\4\\\;c[4\\\O\;\/83#>8?3"'8?$&V?G#>&V>'G#>36&)?$#j;k

    Price/AcreSales PriceAcresDateDescription of Transactions

    j;k&/V&Oi&O\;\&;\Ki4&GEOcZ&/V&Oi&O\;\&H#X"#I&G>#-#83?3"'8&%?3#%&]1$6&ON4&O\;\

    jOk&5",C#>&L?>3K)'13+&L?>D#3&S#I-&i1?>3#>$64&O8% i1?>3#>&O\;\&h W'$E;a&S'EOKB

    j[k&7?$3'8&:'18364&!R&G>'G#>36&?GG>?"-#>9-&=#*#,C#>&O\\M&-?$#&$"-3

    j`k&/V&;\Ke4&O\\c&GEO;

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    31/139

    [\

    ]$?8%^H1>?$&R?8%&B*>#?F#

    `;4\\\Q83"3$#%&B*>#?F#

    abb4\\\]#

    W?$1?3"'8&H?8F#.

    :'8*$1-"'8.&t_N\\L&W?$1?3"'8

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    32/139

    7+?3&?>#&3+#&`;4\\\&?*>#-&'(S"3$#%&$?8%&I'>3+g

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    33/139

    [O

    7+#>#&"-&]

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    34/139

    [[

    R?8%K1-#&Q83"3$#,#83-

    A7+#8&I#&(">-3,C?>D#%&'8&'1>&+"F+#-3&?8%&C#-3&1-#&-3>?3#F64&

    our priority was to seek as many land-use entitlements for

    commercial and residential development in our region as

    possible. This continues to be one of our core

    competencies, ?8%&I#&8'I&+?X#&$?8%K1-#S"3$#,#83-&

    3'3?$"8F&'X#>&[;4\\\&>#-"%#83"?$&18"3-&?8%&?GG>'d",?3#$6&;;Ec&

    ,"$$"'8&-o1?>#&(##3&'(&*',,#>*"?$&-G?*#E&&&'GG'>318"3"#-&?>#&

    -"F8"("*?834&?8%&I#&C#$"#X#&3+?3&C6&3?D"8F&,#?-1>#%&>"-D-4&I#&

    I"$$&C#&?C$#&3'd3>?*3&,#?8"8F(1$&X?$1#EJ

    K )3E&]'#&O\;\&R#33#>&3'&)+?>#+'$%#>-

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    35/139

    [`

    ]36

    b`MEa5'3?$&/8X#-3,#83&"8&H#?$&Q-3?3#

    OEN/8X#-3,#83&"8&T8*'8-'$"%?3#%&B(("$"?3#-

    j[aE\kR#--.&B**1,1$?3#%&=#G>#*"?3"'8

    O[aEb?3"8F&V>'G#>36

    a[bEN=#X#$'G,#83&V>'G#>36

    1,098.1

    895.2

    202.9

    ;c[E`

    [MEa

    1,098.1

    ;N`EN

    ;c[EN

    Total Equity

    Total Liabilities

    Total Liabilities + Equity

    =#C3

    &R"?C"$"3"#-

    Total Assets

    &B--#3-

    :?-+&?8%&:?-+&Qo1"X?$#83-

    /8X#-3,#83&"8&H#?$&Q-3?3#

    Balance Sheet as of Dec. 31, 2009 (in millions $)

    )'1>*#.&]

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    36/139

    [a

    ]>6"8F&W?$1#&C6&56G#

    746.7

    j[aE\k

    bN;Eb

    bEN

    c\Ea

    `bcEc

    ;bOEM

    c[EM

    (in millions $)j;k

    )1C3'3?$

    R#--.&B**1,1$?3#%&=#G>#*"?3"'8

    H#-"%#83"?$

    5",C#>$?8%-

    T8",G>'X#%&R?8%

    Total Investment in Real Estate jOk

    21"$%"8F-

    R?8%&I"3+&/8(>?-3>1*31>#

    j;k ]#?$-3?3#&'(&_b`MEa&,"$$"'8E

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    37/139

    [c

    P',#&V>"*#-&h !$'>"%?&X-E&TE)E

    c\n

    b\n

    N\n

    M\n

    ;\\n

    ;i

    O\\b

    Oi

    O\\b

    [i

    O\\b

    `i

    O\\b

    ;i

    O\\N

    Oi

    O\\N

    [i

    O\\N

    `i

    O\\N

    ;i

    O\\M

    Oi

    O\\M

    [i

    O\\M

    `i

    O\\M

    ;i

    O\;\

    Oi

    O\;\

    Florida US

    )'1>*#.&+33G.^^IIIE(+(?EF'X^=#(?1$3E?-Gd

    !$'>"%?&+?-&C##8&+"3&X#>6&+?>%

    i1?>3#>$6&:+?8F#&"8&3+#&P',#&V>"*#&/8%#d&jPV/k

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    38/139

    [b

    ]#-&)'$%

    \

    ba

    ;a\

    O\\b O\\N O\\M 05=

    H1>?$&B*>#-&)'$%&j"8&3+'1-?8%-k

    )'1>*#-.&]

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    39/139

    [N

    ]&)?$#-

    ONEa5'3?$&:'-3&'(&H#X#81#-

    ;E;&H#X#81#-

    [aE[5'3?$&H#X#81#-

    `EbH#?$&Q-3?3#&)?$#-

    ;aE`H#-'>3&?8%&:$1C&H#X#81#-

    j_\EOOk

    jO\E\k

    j[OE[k

    OEb

    ;[Ea

    ;aEa

    cEM

    S#3&R'--&V#>&)+?>#

    S#3&R'--

    H#-3>1*31>"8F&:+?>F#-

    ?3"8F&R'--

    :'>G'>?3#&QdG#8-#4&S#3

    &?3"8F&QdG#8-#-

    U>'--&V>'("3

    H#X#81#-

    Income Statement YTD as of June 30, 2010 (in millions $)

    )'1>*#.&Oi&O\;\&;\Ki&j8'3#.&3'3?$-&,?6&8'3&3"#&%1#&3'&>'18%"8Fk

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    40/139

    [M

    _\L

    _O\\L

    _`\\L

    _c\\L

    O\\\ O\\; O\\O O\\[ O\\` O\\a O\\c O\\b O\\N O\\M

    )'1>*#.&]'G#>3"#-

    ]

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    41/139

    `\

    /,G?">,#83-&

    _;`Ea_;OE\_;[E\5'3?$

    _b`MEa_NM\Ec_M``Ea/8X#-3,#83&"8&H#?$&Q-3?3#&jB-&'(&=#*E&[;k

    /,G?">,#83&'(&/8X#-3,#83&"8&H#?$&Q-3?3#.

    _bEOKK_aEOBC?8%'8#%&=#X#$'G,#83&V$?8-

    _bE[_;OE\_bENP',#-&?8%&P',#-"3#-

    O\\MO\\NO\\b"8&,"$$"'8-&_

    )'1>*#.&]#?$-3?3#d*$1%#-&3+#&W"*3'>"?&V?>D&*',,18"36&?8%&3+#&)#X#8)+'>#- *'8%',"8"1,&?8%&,?>"8?&%#X#$'G,#83&G>'Y#*3&?-&3+#-#&%#X#$'G,#83-&I#>#&-'$%&?8%&?>#&8'&$'8F#>&G?>3&'(&]?3"'8-E

    =#-G"3#&,?D"8F&+1F#&"8X#-3,#83-&?+#?%&'(&3+#&C1-34&]"3#K%'I8-

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    42/139

    `;

    ]

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    43/139

    `O

    ]D&2#?*+

    KOc&O&ON&;b&2?67"$%&P#>'8

    `Nc4[N\-(;4cONa;`O4;`OO4b`[7?$3'87?3#>)'18%&j;k

    `b4c\\-(&OOb&M;[&;4;`\&`MM&7?$3'87?3#>:'$'>

    Oa4\\\-(&`;b&NO&`MM&bcO&!>?8D$"8)1,,#>:?,G&2#?*+

    `4a[a4aNN-(O4O[a&O4a[a&`4bb\&[4[b\&R#'8)'13+7''%

    a\\4\\\-(&`4`b\&[\&`4a\\&`4;b\&)3E&]'+8-H"X#>5'I8KN&O&;\&;O\&:?$+'18H"X#>)"%# ?3&:+"G'$?

    KO;b&;M;&`\N&;4`M;&2?6H"X#>:?,G-

    K;b&b&O`&;;[&U1$(R?8%"8F-&?3&7#3?GG'

    KOa&;`[&;cN&NN&2?6P?ID-&R?8%"8F

    KKc;c&c;c&;ba&*"?$&Q83"3$#,#83-

    H#,?"8"8F&

    H#-"%#83"?$&T8"3-

    V>'Y#*3&

    T8"3-&)'$%

    V>'Y#*3&T8"3-

    V>'Y#*3&B*>#-:'1836V>'Y#*3-&/8&=#X#$'G,#83

    )'1>*#.&]

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    44/139

    `[

    ]>6"8F&W?$1#&C6&:'1836

    bN;Eb)1C3'3?$

    j[aE\kR#--.&B**1,1$?3#%&=#G>#*"?3"'8

    As of Dec. 31, 2009 (in millions $) j;k

    ;`[Eb2?6&:'18364&!$'>"%?

    NEO:?$+'18&:'18364&!$'>"%?

    [E\=1X?$&:'18364&!$'>"%?

    `bE;!>?8D$"8&:'18364&!$'>"%?

    cENU?%-%#8&:'18364&!$'>"%?

    OOE[U#'>F"?

    O[[EMU1$(&:'18364&!$'>"%?;E\]#((#>-'8&:'18364&!$'>"%?

    c\EcR#'8&:'18364&!$'>"%?

    [EMR"C#>36&:'18364&!$'>"%?

    \E[&!$'>"%?&:'183"#-

    bcE`)3E&]'+8-&:'18364&!$'>"%?

    \EM7?D1$$?&:'18364&!$'>"%? ;b[Ea7?$3'8&:'18364&!$'>"%?

    746.7Total investment in Real Estate jOk

    j;k ]#?$-3?3#&'(&_b`MEa&,"$$"'8E

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    45/139

    ``

    ;`[Eb2?6&:'18364&!$'>"%?

    bcE`)3E&]'+8-&:'18364&!$'>"%?

    O[[EMU1$(&:'18364&!$'>"%?

    `bE;!>?8D$"8&:'18364&!$'>"%?

    ;b[Ea7?$3'8&:'18364&!$'>"%?

    cb`Ec)1C3'3?$

    jOaEMkR#--.&B**1,1$?3#%&=#G>#*"?3"'8

    648.7Investment in Selected Real Estate

    As of Dec. 31, 2009 (in millions $)

    )'1>*#.&]#-#83-&tNcn&'(&]>6"8F&W?$1#

    ]>6"8F&W?$1#&C6&:'1836

    =#X#$'G,#83&=##G&="X#

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    46/139

    `a

    =#X#$'G,#83&=##G&="X#

    a\\4\\\-(

    )'18%

    10%16%% of planned

    OO`OOc=#X#$'G#%&T8"3-15%45%% of planned

    bc4;ab-(Oa4\\\-(H#,?"8"8F&:',,#>*"?$Q83"3$#,#83-

    ;`NNOT8"3-&)'$%

    ;4a;c`MMV$?88#%&T8"3-

    U1$(!>?8D$"8:'1836

    7"8%L?>D

    )1,,#>:?,G

    =#X#$'G,#83

    )'1>*#-.&]%-

    S'3#.&=#X#$'G#%&18"3-&?-&G#>&,'-3&>#*#83&=H/&'>4&I+#8&8'3&?X?"$?C$#4-3",?3#%&C?-#%&'8&*'1836&?GG>?"-?$&>#*'>%-&

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    47/139

    H"X#>5'I8

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    48/139

    `b

    H"X#>5'I84&)3E&]'+8-&:'1836

    Tallahassee

    Jacksonville

    RiverTown

    x

    Northwest Florida Beaches Airport

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    49/139

    `N

    H"X#>5'I8

    @ AH"X#>5'I8&"-&-"31?3#%&'8&?GG>'d",?3#$6&`4;b\&?*>#-&$'*?3#%&"8&)3E&]'+8-&:'1836&-'13+&'(&]?*D-'8X"$$#&?$'8F&3+#&)3E&]'+8-&H"X#>E&&7"3+&G?>D-&?8%&

    G1C$"*&,##3"8F&G$?*#-4&H"X#>5'I8&"-&C#"8F&G$?88#%&('>&`4a\\&+'1-"8F&

    18"3-&?8%&a\\4\\\&-o1?>#&(##3&'(&*',,#>*"?$&-G?*#E&&

    @ H"X#>5'I8&I"$$&+?X#&-#X#8&18"o1#&8#"F+C'>+''%-&"83#>I'X#8&I"3+&

    *',,18"36&?8%&>#3?"$&?>#?-&C6&?&-#>"#-&'(&C"D#&G?3+-&?8%&I?$DI?6-4&I"3+&

    ?$$&>'?%-&$#?%"8F&3'&3+#&*',,18"369-&*#83#>G"#*#4&3+#&)3E&]'+8-&>"X#>E&&

    @ H"X#>5'I8&I"$$&'((#>&+',#C16#>-&?&I"%#&X?>"#36&'(&G>"*#&G'"83-&?8%&

    $"(#-36$#-4&?GG#?$"8F&3'&-#X#>?$&%"((#>#83&3?>F#3&,?>D#3-4&"8*$1%"8F&G>",?>6&

    ?8%&-#*'8%?>6&+',#&C16#>-E&&:'8-3>1*3"'8&'(&H"X#>5'I8&-3?>3#%&"8 O\\c&?8%&-?$#-&?>#dG#*3#%&3'&C#F"8&"8&O\\bEJ

    h O\\c&;\Ke4&G?F#&N

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    50/139

    `M

    H"X#>5'I8

    )'1>*#.&]

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    51/139

    a\

    H"X#>5'I8K AL''8-*?G#J

    )'1>*#.&/--? P',#-&XE&5+#&)3E&]'#&:',G?864&("$#%&L?6&OO4&O\\M

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    52/139

    a;

    ]"8F&H#G'>3

    )'1>*#.&&H"X#>5'I8&=#X#$'G,#83&'(&H#F"'8?$&/,G?*3&2"#88"?$&L'8"3'>"8F&H#G'>3&O\\NKO\\M4&%?3#%&]?81?>6&[;4&O\;\

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    53/139

    aO

    H"X#>5'I8&=#X#$'G,#83&V>'F>#--&

    S'8#&:',G$#3#%S'8#&:',G$#3#%KKOa&B*>#-L"%%$#&)*+''$

    S'8#&:',G$#3#%S'8#&:',G$#3#%;a&B*>#-;a&B*>#-Q$#,#83?>6&)*+''$-&jOk

    S'8#&:',G$#3#%/8&V>'F>#--KKaN&B*>#-H"X#>(>'83&V?>D

    [b&B*>#-[b&B*>#-KK;Nc&B*>#-:',,18"36&V?>D-

    S'8#&:',G$#3#%S'8#&:',G$#3#%KK;N&P'$#-U'$(&:'1>-#

    S'8#&:',G$#3#%S'8#&:',G$#3#%a\4\\\&)E!Ea\4\\\&)E!ER"F+3&/8%1-3>"?$

    S'8#&:',G$#3#%S'8#&:',G$#3#%a\4\\\&)E!Ea\4\\\&)E!E3&O\\NKO\\M4&%?3#%&]?81?>6&[;4&O\;\

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    54/139

    a[

    H"X#>5'I8&h ]#?,

    )'1>*#.&H"X#>5'I8&=#X#$'G,#83&'(&H#F"'8?$&/,G?*3&2"#88"?$&L'8"3'>"8F&H#G'>3&O\\NKO\\M4&%?3#%&]?81?>6&[;4&O\;\

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    55/139

    a`

    H"X#>5'I8&:'-3-&3'&=#X#$'G&

    ]?F#&*'-3&3'&%#X#$'G&?&$'3&"8&H"X#>5'I8

    )'1>*#.&L?"8&)3>##3&jH"X#>5'I8k&O\\N&:==&2'8%&"8F&V>'-G#*31-

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    56/139

    aa

    H"X#>5'I8&)?$#-&O\\b

    ]&$'3.&$72,133

    )'1>*#.&&)3E&]'+8-&:'1836&5?d&BGG>?"-?$&

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    57/139

    ac

    H"X#>5'I8&)?$#-&O\;\

    abn&%#*$"8#&"8&$'3&X?$1#

    ]&$'3.$31,250

    )'1>*#.&&)3E&]'+8-&:'1836&5?d&BGG>?"-?$&

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    58/139

    ab

    H"X#>5'I8

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    59/139

    aN

    H"X#>5'I8&h B#>"?$&V+'3'

    Sold Properties: 30*

    Houses: 12

    )'1>*#.&)3E&]'+8-&:'1836&5?d&BGG>?"-?$&

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    60/139

    aM

    H"X#>5'I8&K 5+#&H#?$&V>'F>#--&H#G'>3

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    61/139

    c\

    )3E&]'+8-&W?*?83&=#X#$'G#%&R'3&/8X#83'>6

    RiverTown

    )'1>*#.&L#3>'-31%6 ]?*D-'8X"$$#&H#-"%#83"?$&)1>X#64&;i&O\;\

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    62/139

    c;

    )3E&]'+8-&W?*?83&=#X#$'G#%&R'3&/8X#83'>6

    S#?>$6&M&6#?>-&'(&"8X#83'>6

    )'1>*#.&L#3>'-31%6 ]?*D-'8X"$$#&H#-"%#83"?$&)1>X#64&;i&O\;\

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    63/139

    cO

    H"X#>5'I8&:?>>6"8F&W?$1#

    )'1>*#.&]>6"8F&X?$1#&'(&H"X#>5'I8&>#-"%#83"?$&>#?$-3?3#

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    64/139

    c[

    H"X#>5'I8&:'8*$1-"'8-

    @ H"X#>5'I8&"-&van&%#X#$'G#% !1>3+#>&%#X#$'G,#83&"-&8'8K#*'8',"*

    ;Na&>#,?"8"8F&%#X#$'G#%&$'3-&?3&_[;4Oa\^&$'3&p&_c&,"$$"'8&"8&X?$1#&

    :?>>6"8F&X?$1#&"-&_b`Ea&,"$$"'8&'>&_`\\4\\\^&%#X#$'G#%&$'3

    M&6#?>-&'(&-1GG$6&",G$"#-&X?$1#-&8'3&F'"8F&1G

    @ 7+?3d?*3$6&%"%&]5'I8&%#X#$'G,#83.&&)+'1$%&C#&",G?">#%

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    65/139

    c`

    7?3#>:'$'> l&7?3#>)'18%

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    66/139

    ca

    7?3#>:'$'> l&7?3#>)'18%4&7?$3'8&:'1836

    x

    WaterColor

    WaterSound West Beach

    Northwest Florida Beaches Airport

    WaterSound Beach

    WaterSound

    Tallahassee

    Jacksonville

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    67/139

    cc

    ]#?%6&)'$%&"3-&2#-3&B--#3-

    7?3#>:'$'> "-&?&8"*#&G>'G#>36

    L?8?F#,#83&$'X#-&3'&-+'I&"8X#-3'>-&7?3#>:'$'>&

    2T54&7?3#>:'$'> "-&tM\n&%#X#$'G#%&l&tN\n&-'$%

    7?3#>:'$'> "-&8'3&",G?*3(1$&3'&3+#&X?$1?3"'8&'>&VlR&F'"8F&('>I?>%

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    68/139

    cb

    7?3#>:'$'>

    )'1>*#.&]

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    69/139

    cN

    7?3#>:'$'>

    7?3#>:'$'> A?X?"$?C$#&('>&-?$#J

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    70/139

    cM

    7?3#>)'18%&V>'G#>3"#-

    7?3#>)'18%

    7?3#>)'18%&2#?*+

    7?3#>)'18%&7#-3&2#?*+

    P"F+I?6&MN

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    71/139

    b\

    7?3#>)'18%

    @ A7?3#>)'18%4&$'*?3#%&'8&?GG>'d",?3#$6&;4`\O ?*>#-&?8%&*1>>#83$6&G$?88#%&('>&?&;4[[\K18"3&,"d#%K1-#&%#X#$'G,#834&"-&?&>#-'>3&*',,18"36&?GG>'d",?3#$6&3+>##&,"$#-&(>',&7?3#>)'18%&2#?*+&8'>3+&'(&TE)E MN&"8&7?$3'8&:'1836E&&

    7?3#>)'18%&$?8%K1-#S"3$#,#83-&"8*$1%#&`ab4[N\ -o1?>#&(##3&'(&*',,#>*"?$&-G?*#E&&5+#&=H/&G>'*#--&('>&7?3#>)'18%&I?-&*',G$#3#%&"8&O\\aE&&5+"-&>#-'>3&3'I8&"-&C#"8F&G$?88#%&('>&3+#&G>#K>#3">#,#83&?8%&-#*'8%K+',#&,?>D#3-&I"3+&-"d&?8%&8"8#K+'$#&F'$(&*'1>-#-&?$'8F&I"3+&

    G''$-4&C#?*+&?**#--&?8%&'3+#>&?,#8"3"#-E&&)?$#-&?3&7?3#>)'18%&?>#dG#*3#%&3'&C#F"8&"8&,"%KO\\cEJ

    @ K]

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    72/139

    b;

    7?3#>)'18%&V>'G#>3"#-

    )'1>*#.&]

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    73/139

    bO

    7?3#>)'18%&2#?*+

    Unsold Properties: 14

    Houses: 100

    Sold Lots: 311*

    )'1>*#.&7?$3'8&:'1836&5?d&BGG>?"-?$&

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    74/139

    b[

    ])'18%&2#?*+(>'83&R'3&)?$#

    )'1>*#.&7?>>?836&=##%&'8&("$#&I"3+&7?$3'8&:'1836

    ]"*#.&$1,253,800

    7 3 ) % 7 3 2 +

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    75/139

    b`

    7?3#>)'18%&7#-3&2#?*+

    Unsold Properties: 155

    Houses: 5Sold Properties: 44*

    )'1>*#.&7?$3'8&:'1836&5?d&BGG>?"-?$&

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    76/139

    ba

    7?3#>)'18%

    Unsold Properties: 84

    Houses: 9Sold Properties: 29*

    )'1>*#.&7?$3'8&:'1836&5?d&BGG>?"-?$&

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    77/139

    bc

    ])'18%&H#G'>3

    O`&P'$#-

    \

    \

    \

    Completed(2)

    2007-2008

    O`&P'$#-\\[N&P'$#-U'$(jP'$#-k

    \\\;Ob4[N\&)E!E#&!##3k

    O;;&T8"3-O;;&T8"3-\;4`[O&T8"3-H#-"%#83"?$j=I#$$"8F&T8"3-k

    CumulativeCompleted

    CumulativeInitiated

    Initiated(1)

    2007-2008DRI

    EntitlementsDRILand Uses

    )'1>*#.&7?3#>)'18%&S'>3+&=H/4&O\\bKO\\N&2"#88"?$&H#G'>34&5?C$#&:K;

    @ /8(>?-3>1*31>#&*'8-3>1*3"'8&-3?>3#%&C#3I##8&]?81?>6&;4&O\\b&?8%&=#*#,C#>&[;4&O\\N

    @ /8(>?-3>1*31>#&*'8-3>1*3"'8&*',G$#3#%&C#3I##8&]?81?>6&;4&O\\b&?8%&=#*#,C#>&[;4&O\\N

    ]

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    78/139

    bb

    ]'G#>36

    @ 7?3#>:'$'> M\n&%#X#$'G#%4&N\n&-'$%

    S'&C#?*+(>'83&G>'G#>36&$#(3

    @ 7?3#>)'18%

    "'>&$'3-

    S'&C#?*+(>'83&G>'G#>36&$#(3

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    79/139

    bN

    )1,,#>:?,G

    ) : ! D$" : 3

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    80/139

    bM

    )1,,#>:?,G4&!>?8D$"8&:'1836

    x

    Northwest Florida Beaches Airport

    SummerCamp Beach

    Tallahassee

    Jacksonville

    ) ,,#>:?,G

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    81/139

    N\

    )1,,#>:?,G

    @ A)1,,#>:?,G4&"8&!>?8D$"8&:'18364&"-&-"31?3#%&'8&3+#&U1$(&'(&L#d"*'&'8&?GG>'d",?3#$6&bcO&?*>#-E&V$?8-&"8*$1%#&?GG>'d",?3#$6&`MM&18"3-4&?&C#?*+&*$1C4&?&*',,18"36&%'*D&?8%&8?31>#&3>?"$-EJ

    @ K O\\c&;\Ke4&G?F#&N

    !>?8D$"8 :'1836 X"#I

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    82/139

    N;

    !>?8D$"8&:'1836&X"#I

    @ V'G1$?3"'8j;k.&;;4ON\

    t;[n&$"X#&"8&!>?8D$"8&:'18369-&G>"-'8jOk

    @ R?C'>&!'>*#j;k.&`4M[`

    @ V#>-'8-&V#>&)o1?>#&L"$#j;k.&O;

    @ L#%"?8&P'1-#+'$%&/8*',#j;k.&_[`4bNb

    @ L?Y'>&G>"X?3#&-#*3'>,G$'6#>-j[k.

    7##,-&L#,'>"?$&P'-G"3?$&K cc

    R#?X"8- )#?(''%&K aa U>##8-3##$ P',#-&K [\

    j;k T)&:#8-1-&O\\M-3",?3#4&+33G.^^o1"*D(?*3-E*#8-1-EF'X

    jOk /8,?3#&G'G1$?3"'8&"8('>,?3"'8&$"-34&+33G.^^IIIE%*E-3?3#E($E1-^?*3"X#"8,?3#-^$"-3E?-Gg=?3?B*3"'8pV?F"8F

    j[k +33G.^^IIIE#($'>"%?E*',^($'>"%?->#F"'8-)1CG?F#E?-Gdg"%pON`

    !>?8D$"8 :'1836 :133#> H"%F#

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    83/139

    NO

    !>?8D$"8&:'1836&h :133#>&H"%F#

    !>?8D$"8 :'1836 :133#> H"%F#

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    84/139

    N[

    !>?8D$"8&:'1836&h :133#>&H"%F#

    !>?8D$"8 :'1836 :133#> H"%F#

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    85/139

    N`

    !>?8D$"8&:'1836&h :133#>&H"%F#

    jak&B&G>'Y#*3&"-&A"8&%#X#$'G,#83&I+#8&*'8-3>1*3"'8&'8&3+#&G>'Y#*3&+?-&*',,#8*#%E&&B&G>'Y#*3&"8&AG>#K%#X#$'G,#83J +?-&$?8%K1-#S"3$#,#83-&C13&"-&-3"$$&18%#>&"83#>8?$?$1?3"'8&'>&>#o1">#-&'8#&'>&,'>#&?%%"3"'8?$&G#>,"3-&G>"'>&3'&3+#&*',,#8*#,#83&'(&*'8-3>1*3"'8E

    )'1>*#.&]?8D$"8 :'1836 :133#> H"%F#

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    86/139

    Na

    !>?8D$"8&:'1836&h :133#>&H"%F#

    !''38'3#&jak&8#I&$?8F1?F#.&&!'>&*#>3?"8&G>'Y#*3-&"8&G>#K%#X#$'G,#834&-',#&+'>"r'83?$&*'8-3>1*3"'8&,?6&+?X#&'**1>>#%4&C13&8'&-?$#-&'>&,?>D#3"8F&?*3"X"3"#-&?>#dG#*3#%&"8&3+#&('>#-##?C$#&(131>#E

    )'1>*#.&]:?,G

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    87/139

    Nc

    )1,,#>:?,G

    )1,,#>:?,G

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    88/139

    Nb

    )1,,#>:?,G

    Q?-37#-3

    )1,,#>:?,G

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    89/139

    NN

    )1,,#>:?,G&

    )1,,#>:?,G

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    90/139

    NM

    )1,,#>:?,G

    )'1>*#.&]:?,G 7#-3

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    91/139

    M\

    )1,,#>:?,G&h 7#-3

    )'1>*#.&!>?8D$"8&:'1836&5?d&BGG>?"-?$&:?,G h Q?-3

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    92/139

    M;

    )1,,#>:?,G&h Q?-3

    Unsold Properties: 144

    Houses: 4

    Sold Properties: 82*

    SummerCamp East and West

    )'1>*#.&!>?8D$"8&:'1836&5?d&BGG>?"-?$&:?,G 2#?*+ !>'83 R'3 )?$#- O\\c

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    93/139

    MO

    )1,,#>:?,G&2#?*+&!>'83&R'3&)?$#-&O\\c

    ]&O\\c

    BX#>?F#&G>"*#&G#>&$'3._NN\4\\\j;k

    j;k&!>?8D$"8&:'1836&V>'G#>36&BGG>?"-#>9-&I#C-"3#4&+33G.^^oG1C$"*E8#3^(>?8D$"8^"8%#dE+3,$

    )1,,#>:?,G 2#?*+ !>'83 R'3 )?$#- O\;\

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    94/139

    M[

    )1,,#>:?,G&2#?*+&!>'83&R'3&)?$#-&O\;\

    ]?8D$"8&:'1836&V>'G#>36&BGG>?"-#>9-&I#C-"3#4&+33G.^^oG1C$"*E8#3^(>?8D$"8^"8%#dE+3,$E&)?$#&"8*$1%#%&;&"83#>"'>&$'3&I"3+&-3>1*31>#4&?GG>?"-#%&?3&_[Oc4cONE&&Qd*$1%"8F&3+"-&$'34&3+#&C#?*+ (>'83&$'3-&-'$%&('>&?GG>'d",?3#$6&_[[;e&^&$'3E

    ]'X"%#% L'>3F?F# ('> O\;\ )?$#-

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    95/139

    M`

    ]'X"%#%&L'>3F?F#&('>&O\;\&)?$#-

    ]'X"%#%&3+#&,'>3F?F#&('>&3+#&-?$#&

    '(&3+#&`&C#?*+&(>'83&$'3-

    +33G.^^IIIE,6($'>"%?*'1836E*',^-#>X"*#-^'(("*"?$>#*'>%-x"83>'E-+3,$

    )1,,#>:?,G /83#>"'> R'3 R"-3"8F-

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    96/139

    Ma

    )1,,#>:?,G&/83#>"'>&R'3&R"-3"8F-

    @ O\;\.

    /83#>"'>&$'3-&'((#>#%&C6&]"'>&j8'8&C#?*+&(>'83k&$'3-&-'$%&('>&t_;a\D&3'&_;caD&jOk

    j;k R"-3"8F&'((#>#%&C6&)1,,#>:?,Gd#*13"X#&>#?$3'>E&=#?$&"-&*'83"8F#83&1G'8&+',#&C1"$3&I"3+"8&-"d&,'83+-&'(&G1>*+?-#E

    jOk !>?8D$"8&:'1836&V>'G#>36&BGG>?"-#>9-&I#C-"3#4&+33G.^^oG1C$"*E8#3^(>?8D$"8^"8%#dE+3,$

    !>?8D$"8 :'1836 W?$1#-

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    97/139

    Mc

    !>?8D$"8&:'1836&W?$1#-

    )1,,#>:?,G.

    ,"8",?$S^BS^B:133#>&H"%F#

    $14,850,000Total

    _b4Oc\4\\\_c\4\\\;O;H#,?"8"8F&/83#>"'>&R'3-

    _b4aM\4\\\_[[\4\\\O[H#,?"8"8F&2#?*+(>'83&R'3-

    5'3?$&W?$1#)?$#&V>"*#R'3-

    _`;4bcN4\\\&p&]>6"8F&X?$1#&'(&>#-"%#83"?$&>#?$-3?3#&('>&!>?8D$"8&:'1836j;k

    )'1>*#.&!>?8D$"8&:'1836&5?d&BGG>?"-?$&

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    98/139

    Mb

    !>?8D$"8&:'1836&:?>>6"8F&W?$1#

    )'1>*#.&]>6"8F&X?$1#&'(&)1,,#>:?,G&?8%&:133#>H"%F#>#-"%#83"?$&>#?$-3?3#

    )1,,#>:?,G :'8*$1-"'8-

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    99/139

    MN

    )1,,#>:?,G&:'8*$1-"'8-

    @ )1,,#>:?,G&"-&v;cn&-'$% ;``&>#,?"8"8F&%#X#$'G#%&$'3-&F#8#>'1-$6&X?$1#%&?3&_;a&

    ,"$$"'8&

    :?>>6"8F&X?$1#&"-&_`O&,"$$"'8&'>&t_OM\4\\\&G#>&

    %#X#$'G#%&$'3

    5+#&?>#?&"-&-G?>-#$6&G'G1$?3#%

    @ 7+?3d?*3$6&%"%&]:?,Gg

    @ )1,,#>:?,G&%#X#$'G,#83.&&)+'1$%&C#&",G?">#%

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    100/139

    MM

    7"8%L?>D

    7"8%L?>D4 U1$( :'1836

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    101/139

    ;\\

    7"8%L?>D4&U1$(&:'1836

    x

    Northwest Florida Beaches Airport

    WindMark

    Tallahassee

    Jacksonville

    Port St. Joe

    7"8%L?>D

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    102/139

    ;\;

    7"8%L?>D

    @ A7"8%L?>D&2#?*+&"-&-"31?3#%&'8&?GG>'d",?3#$6&O4\O\&?*>#-&"8&U1$(&:'1836&8#?>&3+#&3'I8&'(&V'>3&)3E&]'#&?8%&"8*$1%#-&?GG>'d",?3#$6&;a4\\\&(##3&'(&C#?*+(>'83E&&5+"-&C#?*+(>'83&>#-'>3&%#-3"8?3"'8&"-&G$?88#%&3'&"8*$1%#&?GG>'d",?3#$6&;4ccO&18"3-&?3&(1$$&C1"$%K'134&3'F#3+#>&I"3+&ba4\\\&-o1?>#&(##3&'(&*',,#>*"?$&-G?*#E&&:'8-3>1*3"'8&3'&>#?$"F8&?GG>'d",?3#$6&('1>&,"$#-&'(&TE)E&P"F+I?6&MN&?I?6&(>',&3+#&C#?*+(>'83&I?-&*',G$#3#%&"8&O\\cE&&)?$#-&"8&3+#&-#*'8%&G+?-#&'(&7"8%L?>D&2#?*+&C#F?8&"8&O\\cEJ

    @

    @ K O\\c&;\Ke4&G?F#&N

    U1$( :'1836 X"#I

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    103/139

    ;\O

    U1$(&:'1836&X"#I

    @ V'G1$?3"'8j;k.&;a4baa

    @ R?C'>&!'>*#j;k.&c4`;;

    @ V#>-'8-&V#>&)o1?>#&L"$#j;k.&OM

    @ L#%"?8&P'1-#+'$%&/8*',#j;k

    .&_[N4c[O@ L?Y'>&G>"X?3#&-#*3'>,G$'6#>-jOk.

    UB:&:'83>?*3'>-&K O\b

    2?6&)3E&]'-#G+&:?>#&:#83#>&K ;a\

    V"FF$6 7"FF$6&h Na

    !?">G'"83 :',,18"*?3"'8-&h aN

    j;k T)&:#8-1-&O\\M-3",?3#4&+33G.^^o1"*D(?*3-E*#8-1-EF'X

    jOk +33G.^^IIIE#($'>"%?E*',^($'>"%?->#F"'8-)1CG?F#E?-Gdg"%pON`

    ]

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    104/139

    ;\[

    ]D

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    105/139

    ;\`

    7"8%L?>D

    7"8%L?>D&V+?-#&//

    7"8%L?>D&V+?-#&/

    7"8%L?>D

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    106/139

    ;\a

    % ?

    7"8%L?>D

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    107/139

    ;\c)'1>*#.&]

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    108/139

    ;\b

    Unsold Properties: 72

    Homes: 6

    Sold Lots: 42

    )'1>*#.&U1$(&:'1836&5?d&BGG>?"-?$&

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    109/139

    ;\N

    F G

    )'1>*#.&&7"8%L?>D&2#?*+&=#X#$'G,#83&'(&H#F"'8?$&/,G?*3&2"#88"?$&L'8"3'>"8F&H#G'>3&O\\NKO\;\4&%?3#%&BG>"$&;4&O\;\

    7"8%L?>D&=#X#$'G,#83&V>'F>#--

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    110/139

    ;\M

    G F

    ;4\;O&B*>#-

    M

    O&)"3#-

    ;N&P'$#-

    ObN&H'',-

    ;\4\\\&)E!E

    ca4\\\&)E!E

    ;4a;c&=ETE-

    Total

    ProposedTo DatePhase I &II- 2004-2018

    \E\\On

    \E\n

    ;\\E\n

    \E\n

    \E\n

    \E\n

    \E\n

    \Ean

    Measure(%)

    \E\\OnOE[&B*>#-\;4\;O&B*>#-:',,'8&)G?*#

    [[E[n[\c=?6&='*D-

    ;\\E\nO&)"3#-\O&)"3#-2#?*+&B**#--

    \E\n\\;N&P'$#-U'$(^H#-"%#83"?$

    \E\n\\Oc`&H'',-/88

    `aE\n`4a`a&)E!E\;\4\\\&)E!E34&Qd+"C"3&:&h)1,,?>6&'(&:',G?>"-'8&'(&=#X#$'G,#83&B*3"X"36

    j;k&=ETE- >#(#>&3'&%I#$$"8F&18"3-&I+"*+&"8*$1%#-&*'8%',"8"1,&18"3-E

    jOk&5+#&("F1>#-&-+'I8&?C'X#&?>#&8'3&"8*$1-"X#&'(&?8*"$$?>6&1-#-&?8%&(?*"$"3"#-&*1-3',?>"$6&"8*"%#83?$&3'&G>'G#>36&1-#-&j"E#E4&-3'>?F#4

    ,?"83#8?8*#4&,#*+?8"*?$4&*',,'84*Ek

    7"8%L?>D&V+?-#&/&2#?*+(>'83&R'3&)?$#&O\\M

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    111/139

    ;;\

    2#?*+(>'83&$'3&-'$%&"8&7"8%L?>D&V+?-#&/&

    "8&'G#>36&BGG>?"-#>9-&I#C-"3#4&+33G.^^IIIEoG1C$"*E8#3^F1$(^H#G>#-#83-&3+#&,'-3&>#*#83&*',G?>?C$#&"83#>"'>&$'3&-?$#

    7"8%L?>D&V+?-#&//&/83#>"'>&R'3&)?$#&O\;\

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    112/139

    ;;;

    /83#>"'>&$'3&-'$%&"8&

    7"8%L?>D&V+?-#&//&"8&B1F1-3&O\;\

    )?$#-&G>"*#. _;\`4\\\j;k

    j;k U1$(&:'1836&V>'G#>36&BGG>?"-#>9-&I#C-"3#4&+33G.^^IIIEoG1C$"*E8#3^F1$(^H#G>#-#83-&3+#&,'-3&>#*#83&*',G?>?C$#&"83#>"'>&$'3&-?$#

    U1$(&:'1836&W?$1#-

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    113/139

    ;;O

    6

    _a4Ma\4\\\_[a\4\\\;b2#?*+(>'83&R'3-

    _c4Nba4\\\_;Oa4\\\aaS'8KC#?*+(>'83&R'3-

    _a4\\\4\\\S^BS^B:'8%',"8"1,&T8"3-

    7"8%L?>D&V+?-#&//.

    $17,825,000Total

    5'3?$&W?$1#)?$#&V>"*#T8"3-

    _;c`4a;;4\\\&p&]>6"8F&X?$1#&('>&U1$(&:'1836&>#-"%#83"?$&>#?$-3?3#j;k

    )'1>*#.&U1$(&:'1836&5?d&BGG>?"-?$&D&H#-"%#83"?$&:?>>6"8F&W?$1#

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    114/139

    ;;[

    6 F

    _;c`EaL&p&:?>>6"8F&X?$1#&'(&

    7"8%L?>D&>#-"%#83"?$&>#?$-3?3#

    )'1>*#.&]

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    115/139

    ;;`

    @ tOO`&%#X#$'G#%&>#-"%#83"?$&$'3-&'(&3'3?$&G$?88#%&;4a;c v&;an&'(&>#-"%#83"?$&18"3-&"8&7"8%L?>D&?>#&%#X#$'G#%

    @ _;caL&*?G"3?$"r#%&*'-3-&'8&C?$?8*#&-+##3

    /(&I#&?$$'*?3#&3+'-#&*'-3-&'X#>&OO`&?*31?$&%#X#$'G#%&$'3-4&3+?3&",G$"#-&_b[c4\\\&*'-3&G#>&$'3

    QX#8&"(&?$$&>#,?"8"8F&;4[cb&$'3-&I#>#&%#X#$'G#%4&3+?3&I'1$%&",G$6&y&_;O\4\\\&*'-3&?$$'*?3#%&3'?*+&$'3&C#('>#&*'183"8F&3+#&(131>#&*'-3-&3'&%#X#$'G&3+#,E

    @ 7+?3d?*3$6&%"%&]D&:'8*$1-"'8-

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    116/139

    ;;a

    @ 7"8%L?>D&*',,#>*"?$&-G?*#&"-&v&a\n&%#X#$'G#%

    7"8%L?>D&%#X#$'G#%&*',,#>*"?$&-G?*#&"-&Man&X?*?83

    _`OE[&,"$$"'8&*',,#>*"?$&*?G"3?$"r#%&*'-3-&"8&U1$(&:'1836&3+?3&-+'1$%&C#?$1?3#%&('>&",G?">,#83

    @ 7"8%L?>D&%#X#$'G,#83.&&)+'1$%&C#&",G?">#%

    ]

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    117/139

    ;;c

    @ A:'-3-&?--'*"?3#%&I"3+&?&-G#*"("*&>#?$-3?3#&G>'Y#*3&?>#&*?G"3?$"r#%&%1>"8F&3+#&%#X#$'G,#83&G#>"'%E&&7#&*?G"3?$"r#&*'-3-&%">#*3$6&?--'*"?3#%&I"3+&%#X#$'G,#83&?8%&*'8-3>1*3"'8&'(&"%#83"("#%&>#?$-3?3#&G>'Y#*3-E&&/8%">#*3&*'-3-&3+?3&*$#?>$6>#$?3#&3'&?&-G#*"("*&G>'Y#*3&18%#>&%#X#$'G,#834&-1*+&?-&"83#>8?$&*'-3-&'(&?&>#F"'8?$&G>'Y#*3&("#$%&'(("*#4&?>#&?$-'&

    *?G"3?$"r#%E&&7#&*?G"3?$"r#&"83#>#-3&j1G&3'&3'3?$&"83#>#-3dG#8-#k&C?-#%&'8&3+#&?,'183&'(&18%#>$6"8FdG#8%"31>#-&?8%&>#?$-3?3#&3?d#-&'8&>#?$-3?3#&G>'Y#*3-&18%#>&%#X#$'G,#83E&&/(&I#&%#3#>,"8#&8'3&3'&*',G$#3#&?&G>'Y#*34&?86&G>#X"'1-$6&*?G"3?$"r#%&*'-3-&?>#dG#8-#%&"8&3+#&G#>"'%&-1*+&

    %#3#>,"8?3"'8&"-&,?%#EJ

    h O\\M&;\Ke4&G?F#&Oc

    ]

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    118/139

    ;;b

    @ A/(&3+#&,?>D#3&X?$1#-&'(&'1>&+',#-"3#-4&'1>&>#,?"8"8F&"8X#83'>6&'(&*',G$#3#%&+',#-&?8%&'3+#>&%#X#$'G#%&>#?$-3?3#&?--#3-&I#>#&3'&%>'G&C#$'I&3+#&C''D&X?$1#&'(&3+'-#&G>'G#>3"#-4&I#&I'1$%&C#&

    >#o1">#%&3'&I>"3#K%'I8&3+#&C''D&X?$1#&'(&3+'-#&G>'G#>3"#-4&I+"*+&I'1$%&+?X#&?8&?%X#>-#&?((#*3&'8&'1>&C?$?8*#&-+##3&?8%&'1>?>8"8F-EJ

    h O\\M&;\Ke4&G?F#&;O

    ]

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    119/139

    ;;N

    16.7%

    bE\

    [aE\

    `OE\

    )#X#8)+'>#-

    46.2%14.0%% of Carrying Value Before Sale

    [E\;;E\!"8?$&)?$#-&V>"*#

    [EacbEN5'3?$&/,G?">,#83&:+?>F#-

    cEabNEN:?>>6"8F&W?$1#&2#('>#&)?$#

    )3E&]'+8-U'$(&:'1>-#

    W"*3'>"?V?>DIn Millions $

    )'1>*#.&O\\M&;\Ke4&GGE`4&[`K[a

    W"*3'>"?&V?>D&

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    120/139

    ;;M

    @ 2#3I##8&O\\[&?8%&O\\a. P',#-&-'$%&('>&?8&?X#>?F#&'(&_O`\4\\\?*+

    R'3-&-'$%&('>&?8&?X#>?F#&'(&_MM4\\\?*+&

    @ 26&3+#%&'(&O\\M4&8#?>$6&+?$(&j`ank&'(&?$$&G$?88#%&>#-"%#83"?$&18"3-&+?%&C##8&-'$%

    @ 2#('>#&"3-#831?$&I>"3#K%'I84&W"*3'>"?&V?>D9-&*?>>6"8F&X?$1#&I?-&_bNEN&,"$$"'8

    )'1>*#-.&O\\a&;\Ke4&O\\M&;\Ke

    W"*3'>"?&V?>D&

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    121/139

    ;O\

    @ &;b4&O\\M4&]"?&V?>D9-&

    >#,?"8"8F&?--#3-&('>&_;;&,"$$"'8 5+#&>#,?"8"8F&?--#3-&"8*$1%#%&ON&+',#-4&[a\&$'3-4&`cN&

    ?*>#-&'(&18%#X#$'G#%&$?8%4&?&F'$(&*'1>-#4&?8%&_bE`&,"$$"'8&8'3#-&>#*#"X?C$#&(>',&C1"$%#>-

    U"X"8F&]&t_O\4\\\?*+

    @ T8%#X#$'G#%&?*>#-&-'$%&('>&t_O4\\\?*+

    @ ]'3#&%'I8&3+#&W"*3'>"?&V?>D&?--#3-&'8&=#*#,C#>&;a4&O\\M4&'8$6&3I'&%?6-&C#('>#&3+#">&-?$#

    )'1>*#.&O\\M&;\Ke4d*#G3&('>-3",?3#%&X?$1#-&'(?*+&?--#3&j"E#E4&+',#-4&$'3-&?8%&18%#X#$'G#%&$?8%k

    j;k&B$3#>8?3"X#$6&"(&3+#&C1"$%#>&8'3#-&?8%&F'$(&*'1>-#&I#>#&,'8#6&F''%4&3+#8&],#83

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    122/139

    ;O;

    &)3?>3#%

    ;`NNO;4NM;T8"3-&)'$%

    10%16%45%% of Planned Units

    ;4a;c`MM`4O\\V$?88#%&!"8?$&T8"3-

    U1$(!>?8D$"8W'$1-"?:'1836

    7"8%L?>D)1,,#>:?,GW"*3'>"?&V?>D

    )'1>*#.&O\\M&;\Ke&?8%&O\\`&;\Ke

    /,G?">,#83

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    123/139

    ;OO

    g

    ;bEN

    ;c`Ea

    U1$(

    7"8%L?>D

    !>?8D$"8)3E&]'+8-:'1836

    [NEb;`EMcE\7+?3&7#&:?8&)##

    ON\EN`;ENb`EaH#-"%#83"?$&H#?$Q-3?3#&:?>>6"8F&W?$1#

    ggggg/,G?">,#83

    H"X#>5'I8 5'3?$)1,,#>:?,Gj"8&,"$$"'8-&_k

    )'1>*#.&O\\M&;\Ke4&GGE`4&[`K[a

    7+6&+?X#893&3+#-#&C##8&I>"33#8&%'I8g

    B,#8"3"#-&l&:HQ&/,G?">,#83-

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    124/139

    ;O[

    @ ]>6"8F&X?$1#&'(&_;b[&,"$$"'8&"8&>#-"%#83"?$&>#?$-3?3#&?,#8"3"#-&"8*$1%"8F&?8&"884&F'$(&*'1>-#-4&C#?*+&*$1C-4&G?>D-&?8%&*',,'8&?>#?-

    5+#-#&?,#8"3"#-&F#8#>?3#&t_[\&,"$$"'8&"8&>#X#81#-&G#>&6#?>&?8%&$'-#&t_[&,"$$"'8&G#>&6#?>

    B,#8"3"#-&-+'1$%&C#?$1?3#%&('>&",G?">,#83

    @ ]>6"8F&X?$1#&'(&_aM&,"$$"'8&>#$?3#%&3'&*',,#>*"?$&>#?$-3?3#

    H#X#81#-&?>#&,"8",?$4&X?*?8*"#-&?>#&+"F+

    :',,#>*"?$&>#?$-3?3#&-+'1$%&C#?$1?3#%&('>&",G?">,#83

    )'1>*#.&O\\M&;\Ke

    :'8*$1-"'8-

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    125/139

    ;O`

    @ 5+#&C#-3&-31((&+?-&C##8&-'$%

    @ H#?$-3?3#&%#X#$'G,#83&+?-&8'3&+?%&?&G'-"3"X#&>#31>8#8&"(&3+#&("8?8*"?$-&?>#&*'>>#*3

    @ ]'6-&X?$1#

    @ ]

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    126/139

    R#F?$&R'33#>6&P'G#-

    R?3#-3&l&U>#?3#-3.&=##GI?3#>&P'>"r'8&="-?-3#>

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    127/139

    ;Oc

    @ ]3'84&LK/&)7B:?8-'*#?8&

    =#("8"8F&%?,?F#-&?-&-3'*D&G>"*#&%#*$"8#&'(&`\n&

    @ ]3'8&Q8#>F6&)#>X"*#-4&/8*4&("$#%&B1F1-3&`4&O\;\Z&5+#&)3E&]'#&:',G?86&XE&LK/4&RERE:E&?^D^?&LK/&)7B:

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    128/139

    ;Ob

    @ A/8&(?*34&'1>&)3E&]'#&C#?*+#-&+?X#&C##8&('>318?3#&3'dG#>"#8*#&,"8",?$&3?>&C?$$-&>#*#83$6&?8%&+?X#&8#*#--"3?3#%&(#I#>&I'>D#>-&3'&?**',G$"-+&3+#&-$"F+3&*$#?8K1G&>#o1">#%E&&7#&+?X#&-","$?>$6&>#%1*#%&3+#&81,C#>&'(&G>"X?3#&I'>D#>-&>#o1">#%&3'&,?"83?"8&'1>&

    C#?13"(1$&C#?*+#-EJ

    ]

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    129/139

    ;ON

    @ S'&>#?$&%?,?F#

    @ S'3&?I?>#&'(&G>#*#%#83&('>&>#*'X#>"8F&$'-3&-3'*D&,?>D#3&X?$1#

    @ ]

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    130/139

    )1,,?>6&l&:'8*$1-"'8-

    )1,,?>6

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    131/139

    ;[\

    @ V#3#>&H1,,#$$&-G#83&+18%>#%-&'(&,"$$"'8-&'(&%'$$?>-&%#X#$'G"8F&)3E&]'#9-&$?8%

    @ 5+#&C#-3&G>'G#>3"#-&+?X#&C##8&-'$%

    @ L?86&$'3-&I#>#&-'$%&3'&-G#*1$?3'>-&%1>"8F&3+#&C'',

    @ 7+#8&3+#&C'',%#%4&C1-"8#----#83"?$$6&-3'GG#%

    )1,,?>6

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    132/139

    ;[;

    @ ],#>&-G#*1$?3'>-&'>&3+#">&C?8D-&I'1$%&$"D#&3'&-#$$

    @ 5+#>#&"-&$"33$#"%#8*#&'(&+'I&]

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    133/139

    ;[O

    @ 7+#8&3+#&C'',%#%4&,?8?F#,#83&%"-3>?*3#%&"8X#-3'>-&('>&-#X#>?$&6#?>-&I"3+&?&A7?"3&('>&3+#&?">G'>3qJ -3'>6

    @ 5+#&?">G'>3&"-&+#>#4&C13&G>#-#83-&$"33$#&'GG'>318"36

    @ S'I4&,?8?F#,#83&"-&3>6"8F&3'&%"-3>?*3&

    "8X#-3'>-&C6&C$?,"8F&3+#&'"$&-G"$$&?8%&+'G"8F&('>&3+#&A$#F?$&$'33#>6J I"8%(?$$

    )1,,?>6

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    134/139

    ;[[

    @ /(&8'&",G?">,#83&"-&8##%#%4&3+#>#&+?-&C##8&?&8#F?3"X#&>#31>8&'8&%#X#$'G,#834#8&I"3+&],#834&3+#&>#31>8&'8&%#X#$'G,#83&"-&+"F+$6&8#F?3"X#

    @ /3&*'-3-&,'>#&3'&31>8&>?I&$?8%&"83'&?&("8"-+#%&$'3&

    3+?8&3+#&$'3&"-&I'>3+s ?8%&"3&"-893#8&*$'-#

    )1,,?>6

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    135/139

    ;[`

    @ !1>3+#>&%#X#$'G,#83&"-&$"D#$6&3'&%#-3>'6&?%%"3"'8?$&X?$1#

    @ ]&3+#&`;4\\\S"3$#%&?*>#-

    )3>?3#F"*&="$#,,?

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    136/139

    ;[a

    @ L?8?F#,#83&-+'1$%&-#$$&3+#&*',G?86s

    @ 2134&"3&*?893&C#*?1-#&3+#&-3'*D&G>"*#&"-&3''&+"F+s j"3&I'1$%&+?X#&3'&C#&?&3?D#K18%#>k

    @ So what is JOE doing?

    )3>?3#F"*&="$#,,?

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    137/139

    ;[c

    @ ]?3#&X?$1#&3'&*'X#>&"3-&

    'G#>?3"8F&*'-3-

    @ ]#%1*#@ ]?$&$?8%&-?$#-&*?8&(18%&?C'13&;a&6#?>-&'(&'X#>+#?%4&G>'X"%#%&]#&,'8#6&'8&%#X#$'G,#83

    )3>?3#F"*&="$#,,?

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    138/139

    ;[b

    @ 5+#&C1$$-&%>#?,&?C'13&I+?3&]-

    @ H#?$"36&"-&3+?3&C6&3+#8&3+#>#&,?6&C#&8'&>1>?$&

    $?8%&$#(34&C13s

    5+#>#&L?6&2#&)"3#-&R#(3&"8&H"X#>5'I8

  • 8/8/2019 David Einhorn St. Joe Company Slideshow from the Value Investing Congress 2010

    139/139