dead reckoning by sarmila bose - review _ books _ the guardian

7/27/2019 Dead Reckoning by Sarmila Bose - Review _ Books _ the Guardian

1/4

7/29/13 Dead Reckoning by Sarmila Bose - review | Books | The Guardian

www.guardian.co.uk/books/2011/jul/01/dead-reckoning-sarmila-bose-review/print

The eyes would widen and the head move from side to side in the striking Bengali

gesture of affirmation. "How many were killed?" we would ask refugees who had fled

from areas where the Pakistani army and its auxiliaries were attempting to suppress the

Bangladesh independence movement. "Lakhs and lakhs!" came the answer. Journalists

who covered the Bangladesh war in 1971 remember the phrase with a mixture of

amusement and frustration. Lakh is the Indian word for 100,000, and it sometimes

seemed as if the majority of Bengalis knew no other number, or, if they did, it was

"crore" ten million at least when describing the atrocities and depredations of their

West Pakistani oppressors. Reporters had no doubt that there were such atrocities.

Some of them witnessed bloody incidents or their aftermath, but for the most part

correspondents had to rely on the accounts of others. Between the protestations of the

Pakistani military, for whom all Bengali deaths were those of "miscreants" or criminals,

and the manifest exaggerations of inflamed and sometimes bereaved East Bengalis, it

was difficult to steer a measured course.

The numbers mattered, and matter still, because they make the

difference between seeing the war as a tragedy and seeing it as a

terrible crime, indeed as a genocide. That in turn is important

because it profoundly affects the way in which the peoples of

South Asia understand both their separate and their common

histories. Much that is both wrong and dangerous in the

subcontinent today, from Pakistan's paranoia to India's extreme

Welcome Shahab Idrees, sign into the Guardian with Facebook

Dead Reckoning by Sarmila Bose -review

A long-overdue study of Bangladesh's war of independence

Martin Woollacott

The Guardian, Friday 1 July 201 1 23.55 BST

Dead Reckoning:

Memories of th e

1971 Bangladesh

War

by Sarm ila Bose
http://www.guardian.co.uk/profile/martinwoollacotthttp://www.guardian.co.uk/profile/martinwoollacotthttp://www.guardian.co.uk/profile/martinwoollacotthttp://www.guardian.co.uk/https://id.guardian.co.uk/facebook/signin?upsell=1&returnUrl=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.guardian.co.uk%2Fbooks%2F2011%2Fjul%2F01%2Fdead-reckoning-sarmila-bose-review%2Fprinthttp://www.guardian.co.uk/theguardianhttp://www.guardian.co.uk/profile/martinwoollacotthttp://www.guardian.co.uk/profile/martinwoollacotthttps://id.guardian.co.uk/facebook/signin?upsell=1&returnUrl=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.guardian.co.uk%2Fbooks%2F2011%2Fjul%2F01%2Fdead-reckoning-sarmila-bose-review%2Fprinthttp://www.guardian.co.uk/world/gallery/2008/apr/10/bangladesh1971http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/bangladeshhttp://www.guardian.co.uk/


2/4



self-righteousness and Bangladesh's sense that it is neglected and

ignored, can be traced to the 1971 conflict, even if the roots go

back further still. Sarmila Bose's attempt to set the numerical

record straight in her aptly named book is a contribution to a

debate that ought to have taken place a long time ago but instead

has hardly started. It is a grim kind of accountancy, because even

when she concludes, as she often does, that fewer, sometimes farfewer, died than claimed, still we are dealing with murder, rape,

unnatural deaths and the destruction of individuals and their

families in a land that had joyously embraced the idea of Pakistan

less than a generation before.

Her method is to take the worst of the alleged atrocities, and then

to attempt to reconstruct and quantify them by interviewing the

participants on both or, rather, all sides. She wove back and forthbetween Pakistan and Bangladesh, seeing mainly retired Pakistani officers in the west,

and survivors of killings and their relatives in the east, as well as members of the non-

Bengali and non-Muslim minorities. Bose (pictured) seems to have been the first to do

this. It is a method not without its problems. My own feeling, remembering how

charming Pakistani officers, like their Indian equivalents, can be, is that she may have

been a bit too ready to accept the honourable, just-trying-to-do-our-duty image that

those officers naturally prefer to convey, and that she may also be too convinced that the

received wisdom needs to be entirely overturned. Yet when she underlines howstretched the Pakistani forces were, how unready they were for the role of suppression

that was thrust on them, and how perplexed they were in the face of a Bengali hostility

that seemed to them so disproportionate, what she writes rings very true.

Bose's case-by-case arithmetic leads her in the end to estimate that between 50,000

and 100,000 people died in 1971. One lakh, in other words, at most. One cannot say that

she absolutely proves this, but her evidence points in that direction, and, in any case

vastly away from the figure of 3 million still proclaimed in Bangladesh and India. The

wider revision of the conflict's history she implies exonerates the Pakistani government

of any plot to rule the east by force, suggests that the Bengali leader Sheikh Mujibur

Rahman let the genie of nationalism out of the bottle but could not control it, and insists

that the conflict was a civil war within East Pakistan. The killings by Bengalis of non-

Bengali minorities, of Bengalis who stuck with the idea of a united Pakistan, and even of

some Hindu Bengalis all of whose deaths were attributed at the time to the Pakistani

army needs to be reckoned in any fair balance. The notion that the Bangladesh

movement was non-violent, even Gandhian, was always fantastical. Bose has written a

Buy the book

Tell us what you

think: Star-rate and

rev iew th is book
http://www.guardianbookshop.co.uk/BerteShopWeb/viewProduct.do?ISBN=9781849040495http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/data/book/9781849040495http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/history


3/4



What's this?

book that should provoke both fresh research and fresh thinking about a fateful turning

point in the history of the subcontinent.

This article was amended on 4 July 2011. The original referred to a "crore" as one

million. This has been corrected.

What did you think?

Write your review ofthis or any other book, find out what other readersthought or add it to your lists

Rate this book

Review this book

Add to your lists

Buy this book

More from the Guardian

20 1 3 Guar dian News an d Media Limited or its affil iated com panies. All r ights reserv ed.

Transfer window news in

brief

28 Jul 2013

Alan Davies: My family

values

26 Jul 2013

Only God Forgives this level

of tedium

29 Jul 2013

Best non-fiction summer

reads : Difficult Men by Brett

Martin

29 Jul 2013
http://www.guardianbookshop.co.uk/BerteShopWeb/viewProduct.do?ISBN=9781849040495http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/data/book/history/9781849040495/dead-reckoning-memories-of-the-bangladesh-war?INTCMP=ILCBKSTXT4888http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/data/book/history/9781849040495/dead-reckoning-memories-of-the-bangladesh-war?INTCMP=ILCBKSTXT4887#post-areahttp://www.guardian.co.uk/books/data/book/history/9781849040495/dead-reckoning-memories-of-the-bangladesh-war?INTCMP=ILCBKSTXT4886http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/data/search/queryhttp://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2011/jul/01/dead-reckoning-sarmila-bose-review/print#


4/4



dead reckoning by sarmila bose - review _ books _ the guardian

Documents