deadly energy · es like beijing and delhi, citizens and communities are advocating for urgent...
TRANSCRIPT
Access to energy has a positive effect on the health
and well-being of people worldwide. However, the
use of coal to generate electricity has negative health
consequences that dwarf those of other energy sources,
making coal by far the least preferable resource for meet-
ing energy needs while protecting human health.
Pollutants generated by coal combustion can have pro-
found effects on the health of communities, especially
vulnerable individuals such as children, the elderly, preg-
nant women, and those suffering from asthma and lung
disease in urban settings. Coal’s harmful effects include
cardiovascular and respiratory diseases, and impairment
of brain and nervous system development. Air pollution
is carcinogenic to humans, and long-term exposure in
particular can increase mortality rates, as evaluated by the
World Health Organization. Coal pollution can travel long
distances, thus affecting populations living far away from
power plants. Moreover, coal combustion contributes to cli-
mate change, which is already having and will continue to
have significant and growing health impacts for hundreds
of millions of people worldwide. The mining and transport
of coal, as well as the disposal of coal waste ash, can also
have significant health effects.
Estimates of the combined health costs of coal-fired
power generation are staggering, greatly increasing its
cost to consumers if fully accounted for. Taken together,
the health effects of coal are simply too burdensome to
ignore, morally and financially. Around the world, in plac-
es like Beijing and Delhi, citizens and communities are
advocating for urgent action to address poor air quality
and other deadly impacts of coal.
COAL FACTSHEET #5
Deadly EnergyThe Health Impacts of Coal
Photo Credit: groundWork/FOE South Africa
HEALTH SECTOR SUPPORTS END TO COAL• The World Federation of Public Health
Associations called for “a rapid phase out of coal for electricity production and greater investment in renewable energy technologies as a significant investment in global health and healthy communities.”1
• Ministers of health gathered at the World Health Assembly in 2015 adopted a landmark resolution on “addressing the health impact of air pollution,” which urges governments to redouble efforts to identify, address, and prevent the health impacts of air pollution through multi-sectoral approaches.2
• The 2015 Lancet Commission on Health and Climate Change (a special report from a prestigious medical journal) calls on governments to “protect cardiovascular and respiratory health by ensuring a rapid phase out of coal from the global energy mix.”3
• The Healthy Energy Initiative – a global network of health professionals, academics, and organizations advocating for a shift away from coal and other fossil fuels towards clean, renewable energy – has become active in several countries and at the global level.4
COAL’S EFFECTS ON THE HUMAN BODY
2 | D E A D LY E N E R G Y : T H E H E A LT H I M PA C T S O F C O A L
RESPIRATORY EFFECTSGases and particles (dust and soot) emitted from coal
power plants enter the body through the mouth and nose,
where some of them cause irritation. Eyes can also be irri-
tated from acute exposure to acidic gases. In the bronchia
and lungs, pollutants lead to inflammation and physiologi-
cal stress, which over the long term causes cell death and
changes the lung tissue. The following pollutants are of
particular concern for respiratory health:
• Particulate Matter (PM) emitted or formed as a result
of coal combustion contains small particles less than
2.5 micrometres in diameter (PM2.5) that travel deep
into the airways and lead to respiratory stress, asthma,
impairments in lung function. This results in increased
numbers of emergency department visits and hospital
admissions for infections and chronic obstructive pul-
monary disease. Long-term exposure to PM2.5 is caus-
ally linked to the development of lung-cancer. Note
that NOx and SO2, whose primary health effects are
described below, are also precursor gases that react
in the atmosphere to form secondary PM, which often
produces a greater health burden than the primary PM
directly produced by coal combustion.
• Sulphur Dioxide (SO2) emitted by coal burning power
plants leads to inflammation and hyper responsiveness
of the airways, aggravates bronchitis, decreases lung
function, and increases hospitalizations and emergen-
cy department visits for asthma and other respiratory
conditions, particularly among children and adults over
65. Even low concentrations of SO2 are associated with
increased risk of death from heart and lung conditions.
• Oxides of Nitrogen (NOx) are byproducts of fossil
fuel combustion and react with chemicals in the at-
mosphere to create ground-level ozone (smog) and
nitrogen dioxide (NO2). NO2 exposure among asth-
matic children can increase wheezing, cough, and dec-
rements in lung function. It increases susceptibility to
viral and bacterial infections, increases hospital admis-
sions and emergency department visits for respiratory
causes, and at high concentrations can cause airway
inflammation.
CARDIOVASCULAR EFFECTSInhalation of PM2.5 has been linked to cardiovascular
disease and death. The World Health Organization esti-
mates that worldwide, 5% of cardiopulmonary deaths are
due to particulate matter pollution. Long term exposure to
PM2.5 can accelerate the buildup of plaque inside arteries
and increase emergency department visits and hospital
admissions for heart disease and congestive heart failure.
An 8-18% increase in cardiovascular deaths is estimated to
occur per 10 µg/m3 increase in average PM2.5 concentra-
tion. Furthermore, the arteries nourishing the brain can be
affected, leading to an increased risk of stroke.
CANCER AND OTHER CHRONIC DISEASESNot only has air pollution been classified as a known can-
cer-causing substance for humans, but also coal mining
dust emissions can increase the risk for lung cancers. Heavy
metals (such as arsenic and cadmium) and organic toxicants
(such as PAHs and dioxins) are present in high concentra-
tions in coal fly ash and coal sludge, and are also emitted
directly from smoke stacks. They can harm the liver and
kidneys as well as other vital organs, and can cause cancer.
REPRODUCTIVE HEALTHEvidence is sufficient to conclude that exposure to air
pollution (containing SO2, PM, NO2, and ozone) during
pregnancy can cause low birth weight,9 pre-term birth
and complications during pregnancy.10 Infant mortality
was shown to increase with increased coal consumption
in countries that had mid to low infant mortality rate at
baseline (in 1965) such as Chile, China, Mexico, Thailand,
Germany, and Australia.
NEUROLOGICAL EFFECTSCoal power plants are the second largest source of mercury
releases to the environment globally, due to their emissions
of gaseous mercury as well as mercury in their waste water.
Mercury is known to accumulate in sediments and organic
tissue, thus increasing in concentration while making its way
up the food chain. Human exposure occurs mostly through
the consumption of contaminated fish and shellfish. Con-
sumption of methyl mercury-contaminated food by young
children and pregnant women can cause developmental
effects in these children and in the foetus. Effects include
lower intelligence levels, delayed development of the brain
and central nervous system,11 attention deficit disorders,12
and subtle changes in vision, memory, and language.
MENTAL HEALTH AND SOCIAL HARMSCoal projects can also impact mental health (which also
affects physical health) and damage the social and eco-
nomic well-being of communities. These mental health
and social harms may include: distress related to concerns
about adverse health impacts; costs associated with en-
vironmental damage and declining land values; concerns
regarding noise and air pollution; social divisions and in-
equalities between those benefiting from the coal industry
and those who do not; and distress and disempowerment
resulting from asymmetries of power, influence, and ac-
cess to information and resources.13
E N D C O A L | 3Infograhic courtesy of Greenpeace
COST OF THE HEALTH BURDEN FROM THE USE OF COAL
The monetary value of the damage to public health and the environment has been
estimated to be 18-45 US cents per kWh for US power plants, which would at least
triple its cost to consumers. An EU-wide cost estimate arrived at 5.3 c€ per kWh,
ranging between 0.4 and 29.5 c€ per kWh for individual countries. In the EU alone,
coal is responsible for 18,000 premature deaths and four million lost working days
each year, costing up to €43 billion annually.7 The costs of coal pollution are esti-
mates of direct health costs such as medication and hospital visits from the higher
rates of disease, lost productivity as people are sick and remain absent from work, as
well as societal costs from premature mortality.
Additionally, researchers at the International Monetary Fund recently estimated that
fossil fuels are subsidized by US $5.3 trillion in 2015, 6.5% of global GDP, greater than
the health spending of all the world’s governments. Ending these subsidies, which
include the health and other costs imposed on governments for dealing with air
pollution, would slash premature deaths from outdoor air pollution by 55% – about 1.6
million lives a year – with coal accounting for a 93% share of this reduction.14
COAL KILLSWhile a global estimate is
not yet available, an aggre-
gation of estimates from
different countries suggest
that at least 800,000 people
die prematurely each year
as a consequence of coal :
• 670,000 premature
deaths per year in China5
• 80,000 to 115,000 pre-
mature deaths per year
in India6
• 13,000 premature
deaths per year in the
United States7
• 23,300 premature
deaths per year in
Europe8
HEALTH IMPACTS OF COAL THROUGH ITS LIFE CYCLEEach step in the coal life cycle generates pollution that has repercussions for
human health. To learn more, refer to Coal Factsheet #1, available at http://
endcoal.org/resources/end-coal-fact-sheets/.
COAL, CLIMATE CHANGE, AND HEALTH
ENDNOTES
1 World Federation of Public Health Associations (2015): Kolkata Call to Action. http://www.wfpha.org/images/declarations/150216_Kolkata_Call_to_Action_FINAL.pdf
2 World Health Organization (2014) : Health and the environment : addressing the health impact of air pollution. http://apps.who.int/gb/ebwha/pdf_files/WHA68/A68_R8-en.pdf
3 Watt N, et al. (2015) : “Health and climate change: policy responses to protect public health.” Lancet http://climatehealthcommission.org/the-report/
4 Healthy Energy Initiative. www.healthyenergyinitiative.org .
5 Li J (2014) : 670,000 smog-related deaths a year : the cost of China’s reliance on coal. South China Morning Post http://endcoal.org/2014/11/670000-smog-related-deaths-a-year-the-cost-of-chinas-reliance-on-coal/
6 Conservation Action Trust, Urban Emissions, and Greenpeace (2013): http://www.greenpeace.org/india/Global/india/report/Coal_Kills.pdf
7 Clean Air Task Force (2010) : The Toll from Coal : An Updated Assessment of Death and Disease from America’s Dirtiest Energy Source. http://www.catf.us/resources/publications/view/138
8 Health and Environment Alliance (2013) : The Unpaid Health Bill : How coal power plants make us sick http://www.env-health.org/IMG/pdf/heal_report_the_unpaid_health_bill_how_coal_power_plants_make_us_sick_final.pdf
9 Dadvand P, Parker J, Bell ML, et al. (2013): Maternal Exposure to Particulate Air Pollution and Term Birth Weight: A Multi-Country Evaluation of Effect and Heterogeneity. Environmental Health Perspectives Online. http://dx.doi.org/10.1289/ehp.1205575
10 Olsson D, Mogren I, Forsberg B (2013): Air pollution exposure in early pregnancy and adverse pregnancy outcomes: a register-based cohort study. British Medical Journal BMJ Open. http://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/3/2/e001955.abstract
11 Grandjean P, Weihe P, White RF, et al. (1997): Cognitive deficit in 7-year-old children with prenatal exposure to methylmercury. Neurotoxicology and Teratology, 1997, 19:417–428
12 Boucher O, Jacobson SW, Plusquellec P, et al. (2012): Prenatal Methylmercury, Postnatal Lead Exposure, and Evidence of Attention Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder among Inuit Children in Arctic Québec. Environmental Health Perspectives, 2012, 120:1456–1461. http://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/2012/10/1204976/ ; Sagiv SK, Thurston SW, Bellinger DC, et al. (2012): Prenatal exposure to mercury and fish consumption during pregnancy and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder-related behavior in children. Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine, 2012 December, 166(12):1123-31. doi: 10.1001/archpediatrics.2012.1286
13 Climate and Health Alliance (2014) : Health and Energy Choices : Background Briefing Paper. http://caha.org.au/health-and-energy-background-briefing-paper/
14 Coady D, Parry IWH, Sears L, Shang B (2015): How large are global energy subsidies? The International Monetary Fund https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/cat/longres.aspx?sk=42940.0
15 International Energy Agency (2014) : CO2 emissions from fossil fuel combustion, 2014 edition. https://www.iea.org/publications/freepublications/publication/CO2Emissions FromFuelCombustionHighlights2014.pdf
ENDCOAL.ORG
The Lancet Commission on Health and Climate Change
states that “climate change is the biggest global health
threat of the 21st century,” and that “responding to climate
change could be the greatest global health opportunity of
the 21st century.”3
Two of the major greenhouse gases contributing to
climate change, carbon dioxide and nitrous oxide, are
products of coal combustion. In fact, coal is responsible
for 44% of global CO2 emissions.15 Coal mining releases
methane, a potent greenhouse gas.
Public health will be affected by climate change as a
result of:
• extreme weather events such as floods, hurricanes,
and droughts that in turn, increase disease and injury,
and adversely affect water quality and food security;
• changing precipitation patterns and higher tempera-
tures with adverse effects on food security, leading to
malnutrition of large population groups;
• an increase in the growing ranges of some weeds,
grasses, and trees that may increase the severity and
prevalence of allergies;
• the spread of climate-sensitive diseases such as tick- and
mosquito-borne diseases and food- and water-borne
pathogens an increase in ground-level ozone and smog
which aggravate asthma and increase hospital visits; and
an increase in the number of extremely hot days and
tropical nights which leads to heat-related mortality.
Coal is a deadly and costly source of energy that must
be phased out of the global energy mix in order to
protect the lives, health, and well-being of current and
future generations.
NOTE: Unless specifically cited, the source for information in this fact sheet is: Burt E, Orris P, and
Buchanan S. (2013): Scientific Evidence of Health Effects from Coal Use in Energy Generation.
University of Illinois at Chicago and Health Care Without Harm.
4 | D E A D LY E N E R G Y : T H E H E A LT H I M PA C T S O F C O A L