debt and deleveraging
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
1/72
Debt and Deleveraging
Kinza BajwaManizeh DossaUkasha IqbalAnam ZafarUmair SuhailMay 24h! 2"#2
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
2/72
Research Objective
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
3/72
How We Proceeded?
$o%us Area De&elo'men (ieraure )e&iew Iner&iews Mo*el Analysis
$ee*ba%k sessions
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
4/72
Focus Areas
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
5/72
Debt Growth
+oal *eb relai&e o ,D- inhe en maure e%onomies
in%rease* from abou 2""'er%en of ,D- in #../ oo&er 0"" 'er%en by 2""1+oal *eb in%rease* byabou 3 4" rillion
In he four emerine%onomies a&erae* #05'er%en of ,D- a he en* of2""1
(ow ineresraes
Beha&ioral)es'onses
Sub6-rimeBorrowin
Se%uriizaion
Dereulaion
,lobalize*bankin
$inan%ialSe%or
le&erae
USMorae
(en*in
,rowh ofD7B+
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
6/72
(ow Ineres )aes an* 8ih 8ouse -ri%es +he %on*iions were rihfor 'eo'le o a%hie&e he 9Ameri%an Dream: In he early 2"""s! moraeineres raes were low In a**iion! home 'ri%es in%rease* *ramai%ally! sobuyin a home seeme* like a sure be (en*ers un*ersoo* ha homes makeoo* %ollaeral! so hey were willin o 'ari%i'ae
;ash ou
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
7/72
Banks o offloa* risks from Balan%e Shee
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
8/72
(ow ineresraes
Beha&ioral)es'onses
Sub6-rimeBorrowin
Se%uriizaion
Dereulaion,lobalize*
bankin
$inan%ialSe%or
le&erae
USMorae
(en*in
,rowh ofD7B+
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
9/72
Bubble Bursts!
)eal 7sae ;rash
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
10/72
Deleveraging
Mi%ro (e&elA mi%ro6e%onomi%le&el! *ele&erain refers o he re*u%ion ofhe le&erae raio! or he 'er%enae of *ebin he balan%e sheeof a sinlee%onomi% eniy! su%h as a househol* or a firm I is he o''osie of le&erae!whi%h is he 'ra%i%e of borrowin money o a%quire asses an* muli'ly ainsan* losses
Ma%ro (e&elA ma%ro6e%onomi%le&el! *ele&erain of an e%onomy referso he simulaneous re*u%ion of *eb le&els in muli'le se%ors! in%lu*in boh'ri&ae se%orsan* o&ernmen se%or I is usually measure* by he *e%line ofhe oal *eb o nominal ,D-raio in naional a%%oun
A significant episode of deleveraging in an economy as one in
which the ratio of total debt to GDP declines for at least three
consecutive years and falls by 10 percent or more
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microeconomicshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leverage_ratiohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debthttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balance_sheethttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leverage_(finance)http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macroeconomicshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_sectorshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_sectorhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nominal_GDPhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_accounthttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_accounthttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nominal_GDPhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_sectorhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_sectorshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macroeconomicshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leverage_(finance)http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balance_sheethttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debthttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leverage_ratiohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microeconomics -
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
11/72
Deleveraging Phases and
Archet"es
First PhaseA 'hase for 'ri&ae *ele&erain where firs househol*s!%or'oraions! an* finan%ial insiuions re*u%e *eb sinifi%anly o&er se&eralyears! while e%onomi% rowh is neai&e or minimal an* o&ernmen *eb
rises !econd Phase In his 'hase rowh reboun*s an* o&ernmen *eb isre*u%e* ra*ually o&er many years If he 'ro%ess is sri%ly followe*! *eble&els are re*u%e* an* rowh re&i&es
9Bel6ihenin: In or*er o in%rease ne sa&ins! an e%onomy re*u%ess'en*in an* oes hrouh a 'rolone* 'erio* of auseriy
98ih inflaion: hih inflaion me%hani%ally in%reases nominal ,D- rowh!hus re*u%in he *eb o ,D- raio
9Massi&e *efaul: his usually %omes afer a nasy %urren%y %risis So%k of*eb imme*iaely *e%reases afer massi&e 'ri&ae an* 'ubli% se%or *efauls
9,rowin ou of *eb: if an e%onomy e?'erien%es ra'i* off6ren*C real ,D-rowh! hen is *eb o ,D- raio will *e%rease naurally
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Austerityhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Austerityhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflationhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Default_(finance)http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Currency_crisishttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_GDPhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_GDPhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Currency_crisishttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Default_(finance)http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflationhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Austerityhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Austerity -
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
12/72
Deleveraging #urrent $tatus
%$& $inan%ial6se%or *eb has *e%line* from 31 rillion o 3# rillion an* san*s a4"'er%en of ,D-US househol* *eb has fallen by 3/14 billion! US househol*swoul* %om'lee heir *ele&erain by mi*62"#0
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
13/72
Deleveraging' #urrent $tatus
%(& $or UK! on he oher han* *ele&erain jus bean Briish finan%ialinsiuions also ha&e sinifi%an e?'osure o rouble* euro zone borrowers!mainly in he 'ri&ae se%or 8ousehol* *eb has also in%rease* be%ause banksha&e a*o'e* a fori&in a''roa%h owar*s *efaulers so essenially 're&ene*fore%losures
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
14/72
Deleveraging )*"act
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
15/72
Deleveraging ' )*"acts
$ee*ba%k loo's one wil* +he mos imme*iae risk is inensifi%aion of
he a*&erse fee*ba%k loo's beween so&erein an* bank fun*in 'ressures inhe euro area! resulin in mu%h larer an* more 'rora%e* bank *ele&erainan* sizable %onra%ions in %re*i an* ou'u Bank asse qualiy *eerioraes bymore han in he baseline! owin o hiher losses on so&erein *eb hol*insan* on loans o he 'ri&ae se%or
Eiruous %ir%les an* heir a%%om'anyin animal s'irisC i&e way o &i%ious%y%les! in whi%h lower 'ri%es bee wrie6*owns! whi%h bee lower 'ri%es An*on i oes In he 'ro%ess! ba* asses be%ome o?i%! es'e%ially for finan%ialinsiuions who! unlike oher eniies! ha&e %a'ial requiremens ha mus beme
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
16/72
)*"acts o+ deleveraging
Global
GDP
Growth
Gross
Fi,ed
)nvest
*ent
%ne*"lo
*ent
#redit
$u""l
$ocial Well'
being$aving
out o+
)nco*e
Asset
Prices#onsu*
"tion
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
17/72
$ocial Well Being
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
18/72
$ocial Well Being
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
19/72
Deleveraging
M%Kinsey 8ousehol* *eb rew faser han ,D- in #" mauree%onomies Banks@ fo%us shife* from wholesale *e'osis o len*in$i&e *imensions for analysis of he likely s'ee* an* e?en of
*ele&erain le&el of le&erae! rowh of le&erae! *eb ser&i%e%a'a%iy! &ulnerabiliy o in%ome sho%ks an* &ulnerabiliy o fun*inan* ineres rae sho%ksC Ar%hey'es of *ele&erain mos %ommone'iso*es *urin whi%h rae of *eb rowh is slower han nominal ,D-rowh! or nominal *eb so%k *e%linesF *urin hese e'iso*es of bel6ihenin! he sa&in rae in%rease* as borrowers re*u%e* heir *ebC
)einhar an* )ooff 2"#"C 8isori%ally! 'erio* of *ele&erain follows
major finan%ial %risis Mo*el su*ies beha&ior of ,D- raes an* ,D-rowh! inflaion! unem'loymen! bank %re*i a&ailabiliy an* real6esae'ri%es *urin %ounry6s'e%ifi% sho%ks an* a*&erse lobal e&ens$in*ins in he *e%a*e followin a finan%ial %risis! real ,D- 'er %a'iais %onsi*erably lower (e&erae in he 'ri&ae se%or *e%reases afer afinan%ial %risis! resulin in lowere* em'loymen raes
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
20/72
-iterature Review
,ol*ber 2"##C Dynami% mo*el of he 'ersisen effe%s of a 'ermanen*e%line in firms@ abiliy o borrow on he labor marke an* %onsum'ion inhe %one? of he im'oran%e of a eneral equilibrium framework for
analyzin he e%onomy@s res'onse o *eerioraion in he qualiy of hefinan%ial sysem $in*ins ;hanes in %ollaeral requiremens! whi%hresul as a shorae of %re*i su''ly 're&ails followin a finan%ial %risis!im'a% he labor marke )e*u%in he sea*y sae &alue %ollaeral &alueof %a'ial in%reases he e?en o whi%h firms *e%rease job %reaionfollowin a neai&e %re*i sho%k! an* in%reases he 'ersisen%e ofunem'loymen
De&ereu? an* Geman 2"".C +heorei%al mo*el of a balan%e shee
%hannel for he inernaional ransmission of sho%ks $in*ins finan%ial*ele&erain! enerae* by a *ownurn in one %ounry! is s'rea* aroun*he lobe hrouh iner%onne%e* 'orfolios rear*less of ra*e linkaes
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
21/72
-iterature Review
8azius 2""1C Im'a% of in%reasin morae %re*i losses asa resul of *e%linin home 'ri%es an* he resulan re*u%ion in
%re*i su''ly on real ,D- rowh $in*ins an o&erall*e%rease in ,D- an* %onsum'ion resuls from *e%rease*%onsru%ion a%i&iy! lai*6off %onsru%ion workers! lowere*home 'ri%es lea*in o a morae liqui*iy effe% an* *e'leionof equiy %a'ial of le&erae* finan%ial insiuions from losseson morae %re*i! re*u%in he su''ly of %re*i o househol*s
for %onsum'ion $o%uses on he a&ailabiliy of %re*i o 'ri&aenonfinan%ial borrowers! asserin ha i is likely o ha&e hemos *ire% effe% on o&erall e%onomi% a%i&iy $rom a 'oli%y'ers'e%i&e! measures o boos he su''ly of %re*i are'romisin ools for sofenin he e%onomi% *ownurn
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
22/72
.odel Objective and .ethodolog
+wo6fol* eneral equilibrium
mo*el o su*y relaionshi'beween
$irm@s %re*i a&ailabiliyan* ma%ro6&ariables
in&esmen *isorions!%onsum'ion!unem'loymenC
;re*i a&ailabiliy an* job
%reaion
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
23/72
Research Findings ' /
;re*i %onra%ion a*&ersely affe%s
in&esmen measure* by oal fa%or'ro*u%i&iyC an* smoohness of %onsum'ionH "#odel of Deleveraging$! ,ol*ber 2"##C
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
24/72
0he .odel1
Fig a ne 'er%enae ofsur&eye* *omesi% banksha re'ore* ha&inihene* he san*ar*s for
loans o boh small an*lar e firms
Fig b&ne 'er%enae ofres'on*ens who! %on*iional onseekin %re*i in he 're&ioushree monhs! re'ore* more
*iffi%uly in obainin %re*i
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
25/72
0he .odel $tudies2
Deleveraging
Credit Contraction
Consumption1.Investment Distortion
2.Unemployment
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
26/72
#redit #ontraction3s 4++ect on
)nvest*ent and #onsu*"tion&
In&esmen Disorion is measure* by +oal$a%or -ro*u%i&iy *ifferen%e beweena%ual +$- an* +$- assumin no borrowin%onsrainsC
In&esmen *isorion is also refle%e* in hea' beween he marinal 'ro*u% of %a'ialan* he ineres raeF he a' is *efine* ashe finan%e 'remium firms are willin o 'ayfor an a**iional uni of borrowin
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
27/72
GDPAs he followin fiure
shows! ,D- is a fun%ionof In&esmen!
;onsum'ion an*7?'ors ,i&en ,D-@s
&ulnerabiliy o*ele&erain an* he
em'hasis of 'oli%ymakers on manain
rowh! i is im'oran osee how %onra%ion in
%re*i su''ly affe%sin&esmen an*
%onsum'ion an*
herefore ,ross Domesi%-ro*u% a a ma%ro le&el
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
28/72
Research .ethodolog
+o %om'are he sea*y6saes of wo e%onomies ha ha&e *ifferen le&els
of moral hazar* bu oherwise i*eni%al 'arameers! we %om'are sae'ro'eries of a bench*ar5 econo* o ha of an e%onomy where +ir*s3abilit to borrow is lower than in the bench*ar5 In he ben%hmarke%onomy! he 'le*eabiliy 'arameer is # J "2F he new &alue of isaken o be as 2 J "4.! refle%in a /6 "ercentage "oint decrease in+ir*3s abilit to borrow 0his lower value +or 7 corres"onds to
greater *oral ha8ard and lower abilit to co**it to re"a*ent9
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
29/72
+he +irst row shows losses in measure* total +actor "roductivit:0FP; ;onsi*erin a decrease in the +ir*3s abilit to borrow< i+ the
interest rates were held constan! +$- losses woul* in%rease by"00 'er%enae 'oins -arial 7quilibriumC 8owe&er! in or*er oobtain stead'state e=uilibriu*< the interest rate *ust +allf %ourse! he e=uilibriu* counter"art o+ a reduction inthe +inancial assets su""lied b +ir*s is a reduction in
the assets held b wor5ers
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
34/72
+he decrease in +ir*s borrowing abilit resuls in an in%rease in he sea*y6sae liqui* wealh of firms! as firms
require *ore li=uid wealth to "ursue invest*ento""ortunities 8owe&er< the increase in li=uid wealth is less than it would
have been i+ the interest rate were unchanged
+his! aain! refle%s he endogenous decrease in the interest
rate
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
35/72
Research .ethodolog
+he general'e=uilibriu* a*"li+ication o+ invest*entdistortions%an be furher un*ersoo* by %onsi*erin how*isorions &ary wih he ineres rae $or a i&en ineresrae! he stead'state invest*ent distortions are%om'ue* in $iure abo&e +he sea*y6sae *isorions are
decreasing in the interest rate
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
36/72
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
37/72
#redit #ontraction3s 4++ect on
%ne*"lo*ent
Data and .ethodolog&
Daa use* has been e?ra%e* from I-A ables from he B7A!from he e -er%enae of Domesi% )es'on*ens +iheninSan*ar*s for ;ommer%ial an* In*usrial (oans an* from heSenior (oan >ffi%er >'inion Sur&ey on Bank (en*in -ra%i%esfrom he Federal Reserve Board and the ational Federation o+
)nde"endent Business9
+he econo*icgrowth or GD- an*hereforeunem'loymen@sCaffe% on Hu*an
Develo"*ent )nde,in he followinfiure shows how adecreased
econo*ic activit
and une*"lo*ent
due todeleveraging %anaffe% he eneraldevelo"*ent o+ an
econo*as well
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
38/72
Research Findings
+here is a 'osii&e relaionshi' beween%re*i %onra%ion an* *e%rease in job%reaion
6 "%orrowing &onstraints' &ollateralFunctions' and the (abor #ar)et$! Nulio
2"##C
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
39/72
0he .odel1
>bje%i&e is o analyze he e++ect o+ credit contraction onune*"lo*entwhi%h 'ro'oses o e?'lain the i*"lications
o+ a sudden increase on +rictions associated with hiringwor5ers ie he abilit o+ +ir*s to create jobs an* headverse a++ect triggered in hu*an develo"*ent and
social indicator +ront
+he mo*el has two t"es o+ agents Households'ro&i*elabor an* fun*s! #a"italistsown he %a'ial so%k
In he mo*el! +ir*s can +inance their o"erations throughthe use o+ debt or e=uit
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
40/72
+o co*bat against the "ossibilit o+ de+ault loans aresubje% o he collateral re=uire*ents
A negative credit shoc5H tightening o+ credit conditionsH re*u%es he amoun he firm %an borrow aains is%ollaeral
A contraction in credit will howe&er! i*"rove thebargaining "osition o+ +ir*s by in%reasin he sensii&iy of
he firm=s sur'lus o %hanes in waes +herefore! s*all changes in wages will likely enerae
larger *ove*ents in labor *ar5et variables! in 'ari%ularem'loymen an* job6%reaion
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
41/72
#redit #ontraction3s 4++ect on
%ne*"lo*ent& Euantitative Analsis
+he +unctional +or*s +or "re+erences! adjust*entcosts! an* vacanc costs are 'resene* in +ablefollowin -erri an* Oua*rini 2"##C an* ;huh
2"".C +he &alues of he "ara*eters o+ the baseline case
%an be seen in +ables 2 an* 0
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
42/72
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
43/72
)*"ulse Res"onse& 0otal Factor
Productivit :0FP; shoc5s$iure 0 shows he res"onseo+ so*e o+ the variablesofhe mo*el o a one san*ar**e&iaion 'osii&e sho%k oareae 'ro*u%i&iy$ollowin a "ositivetechnolog shoc5 +ir*s
increase their hiring! wih&a%an%ies in%reasin on
im'a% almos by 0P A hesame ime! une*"lo*entdecreases< causing an even
larger increase in labor
*ar5et tightness9
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
44/72
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
45/72
Result
;re*i sho%ks affe% flu%uaions of 5e labor *ar5et variables li5eune*"lo*ent< vacanc "osting< and labor *ar5et tightness +his
resuls from he fa% ha while wages are ver sensitive to "roductivitshoc5s< credit shoc5s are not Be%ause changes in collateral
re=uire*ents do not translate into large changes in wages< these
disturbances have large e++ects on the abilit o+ +ir*s to create jobs Ina**iion o his! if firms fa%e! on a&erae! tighter collateral constraints! hen
he res"onse o+ labor *ar5et variables to +inancial shoc5s is greaterIn oher wor*s! reducing the stead state value collateral value o+ ca"ital
increases the e,tent to which +ir*s decrease job creation +ollowing anegative credit shoc5< and increases the "ersistence o+ une*"lo*ent9
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
46/72
Pa5istan and Global Deleveraging
Pa5istan Debt'to'GDP Ratio @.ature 4cono*ies Debt'to'GDP Ratio
to 6
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
47/72
Pa5istan3s Debt
-akisan >usan*in-ubli% Deb Nune 2"#"C
USD#"15 More han half is forein
*eb +his is aroun* 5"P of ,D-!
%omin *own from morehan ./ 'er%en of he ,D-in 2"""Q"#
$orein an* *omesi% *ebea%h %onsiue abou a hir*of he annual ,D-
Deb has in%rease*%oninuously in absolue *ollarerms o&er he las # years +he rae of in%rease was
quie shar' o&er he years of
he finan%ial %risis! ie2""5Q"1 o 2"".Q#"
Sin%e he rae of inflaion in-akisan has been mu%hhiher han he rae of*e're%iaion of he -akisanru'ee aains he US *ollar!
he rae of rowh in nominal,D- has e?%ee*e* he rae
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
48/72
Wh Pa5istan3s Debt is a Proble*2
-akisan *oes no'ossesses suffi%ienforein %urren%yreser&es o ser&i%eIM$ an* oher forein*eb
-akisani )u'ee is noa *esirable %urren%y'eo'le wish o hol*
,o&ernmen raisesinflaion o ser&i%e *eb
minin moneyC)u'ee6Dollare?%hane rae risesfurher! im'a%infuure abiliy o ser&i%e*eb! effe%i&e rae of
ineres balloons
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
49/72
)*"act o+ 4uro"ean
Deleveraging
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
50/72
4cono*ic Activit in Pa5istan
Mos of he rowh ha *i* o%%ur %an be aribue* o he ser&i%es se%or!while he 'ro*u%ion se%or! im'e*e* by &arious fa%ors! %oul* no make asinifi%an %onribuion! an* owin o &arious e?ien%ies su%h as eneryshoraes in he in*usrial se%or! floo* effe%e* %ro' loss in he ari%uluralse%or! lower %ommo*iy 'ri%es in he lobal markes an* lowere* e?'ors*eman* from ;hina an* 7uro'e! e%onomi% a%i&iy has been affe%e* more
in real erms han hrouh finan%ial linkaes wih maure e%onomies
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
51/72
)nterest Rate
Business se%ors suffer hih finan%in %oss whi%h %onribue o heirhih %oss of 'ro*u%ion! makin %om'ein in he lobal arena wihlow6%os 'ro*u%ers su%h as Banla*esh in e?ile for e?am'le
*iffi%ul +his furher %lam's *own ,D- rowh
8ih Ineres )aeen%ouraeshousehol* sa&in
an* *e%reases%onsum'ion!im'a%in o&eralle%onomi% a%i&iy
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
52/72
4cono*ic Activit in Pa5istan
8ih-ro*u%ion
;oss
Businesses
Un'rofiable
on6-erformin
Bank (oans
;re*i;onra%ion
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
53/72
Sae of In&esmen in -akisan
-(@s;re*i
;onra%ion
Share -ri%es $all>her in&esmen
e ol*
(ow In&esor;onfi*en%e
UnhealhyBank
Balan%eSheesF
$orein In&esmen-ulls ou
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
54/72
4,"orts
Due o lobal *ele&erain! here is *e%rease* lobal *eman* 7%onomies like;hina an* 7uro'e 'ro*u%e less *eman* for -akisani e?'ors As a resul! we seea ren* of *iminishin e?'or a%i&iy 'os %risis
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
55/72
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
56/72
$ocial )ndicators
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
57/72
Polic Res"onse Focus& Global
+he *ele&erain 'ro%ess ha bean in 2""1 is 'ro&in o belon an* 'ainful
+o o&er%ome his e%onomi% malfun%ion! 'roress has o bema*e on &arious frons in%lu*in rowh ! resru%urin ! *ebre*u%ion ! banks an* reulaions! inflaion! auseriy amonoher
$or business lea*ers ryin o na&iae he new worl* of *eb
re*u%ion! un*ersan*in he %ourse of *ele&erain is of%rii%al im'oran%e Alhouh rowh in he ime of *ele&erainmay be slower an* more &olaile in some %ounries! here arealso %lear o''oruniies o in&es ahea* of *eman* an* e?'loi'o%kes of rowh e&en wihin slowly e?'an*in e%onomies HM%Kinsey ,lobal Insiue
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
58/72
+he e%onomies of $weden and Finland ha&e e?'erien%e* aurnaroun* in rowh! by *e%isi&ely resol&in he finan%ial %risis
arisin from se&ere re%essions s'urre* by *e%line in 'ri&aese%or *eb whils a shar' in%rease in 'ubli% se%or *eb +he
L*ele&erain e'iso*es@ of boh Swe*en an* $inlan* are
hihlihe* in he +able below
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
59/72
I+o*ay! he %nited $tates is +ollowing the $wedish and Finnish e?am'lesmos %losely an* may be wo years or so away from %om'lein 'ri&ae6se%or*ele&erain +he %nited (ingdo* and $"ain have *ade less "rogressand could be a decade awa +ro* reducing their "rivate'sector debt to
the "re'bubble trend: H M%Kinsey ,lobal Insiue
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
60/72
$i, #ritical .ar5ers )denti+ied b
.c(inse )nstitute
$tabilit o+ the ban5ing sste* :Basel )));
-ong ter* +iscal sustainabilit $tructural re+or*s
Rising e,"orts
Rising "rivate invest*ent
$tabili8ation o+ the housing *ar5et
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
61/72
Polic Res"onse Focus& Pa5istan
,i&en he s%enario in -akisan! where househol* %onsum'ionis low an* business a%i&iy is im'e*e* by a myria* of fa%orsin%lu*in low %re*i su''ly! a su*y by he M%Kinsey ,lobalInsiue %lassifies his as a Cbelt'tightening3 archet"e o+deleveraging
9;om'are* o oher reions of he worl*! -akisan is sill well'la%e* o res'on* o sho%ks wih %ouner%y%li%al fis%al 'oli%y!bu many e%onomies ha&e hiher 'ubli% *eb le&els han hey*i* a he en* of 2""5 An* as real 'oli%y raes are%onsi*erably below hisori%al a&eraes in all e%onomies in hereion in Mar%h 2"#2! he room o ease moneary 'oli%y is alsoless han before he lobal finan%ial %risis: 6 *orld +conomic!ituation and Prospects ,011
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
62/72
)*"roving Budget Allocations
+he bur*en of *eb ser&i%in is borne by he a? 'ayers of he %ounry +heables below! e?ra%e* from he Bu*e )e'ors 2"##62"#2 of he,o&ernmen of -akisan! $inan%e Di&ision! i&e a fair a''ro?imaion as ohe 'ro'orion of bu*e 6 4"P 6 /"P 6 allo%ae* owar*s *eb ser&in
+he *eb siuaion mus be %onrolle* in -akisan oherwise i %an lea* o
worsenin of inflaion raes +his is be%ause 'ubli% *eb se&erely %row*sou 'ri&ae *ebF an* he o&ernmen in or*er o re'ay inernal an*e?ernal loans mus resor o 'rinin ru'ees if he *eb ser&i%in amoun%anno be %om'leely raise* hrouh a?aion
+his 'ra%i%e has resule* in inflaion raes skyro%kein in *e&elo'in
%ounries like ieria an* Arenina
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
63/72
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
64/72
#urbing 0a, 4vasion
+he aforemenione* 'roblems *ire%ly link o a? e&asion as majoriy of-akisan@s a? re&enue arises from in*ire% a?es an* a?es on%or'oraions In*ire% a?es are reressi&e in naure an* hen%e a bur*enon he lower an* mi**le in%ome rou's of he 'o'ulaion
In or*er o ser&i%e an* re'ay e?ernal an* inernal *eb he o&ernmen
in%reases he rae of a?es le&ie* raher han e?'an* he a?'ayers@ base
9-akisan=s a?6o6,D- raio *e%line* from .# 'er%en in 2""16".reiserin he same raio in 2"".6#"C o 1 'er%en in 2"#"6## whilere&enue %olle%ion! he -resi*en 'rou*ly announ%e* in his s'ee%h o he
join siin of 'arliamen! *ouble* from )s #""" billion o abou )s 2"""
billion sin%e 2""1: 6 Business )e%or*er 2"#2C
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
65/72
$tructural adjust*ents
+he *eb6o6,D- raio of -akisan is ho&erin %lose o 5"P +his is amaer of %on%ern be%ause of he im'en*in neai&e e?%hane raeim'li%aions whi%h may resul from an in%reasin *eb6o6equiy raio
-olii%al insabiliy an* he %a'ial flih of $orein Dire% In&esmen Hfollowin he so%k marke %rash from a''ro?imaely #/!""" o /""
basis 'oins H in 2""1 ha* sho%ke* -akisan=s e%onomy +he abo&e%ou'le* wih hih inflaion resule* in a %rash in he &alue of he)u'ee! whi%h fell from "H# USD o o&er 1"6# USD in a few monhs in2""1 I was s'e%ulae* hen ha! for he firs ime in years! -akisanmay ha&e o seek e?ernal fun*in as Balan%e of -aymens su''or
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
66/72
9;onsequenly! SR- lowere* -akisan@s forein %urren%y *eb rain o
;;;6'lus from B! jus se&eral no%hes abo&e a le&el ha woul* in*i%ae*efaul -akisan@s lo%al %urren%y *eb rain was lowere* o B6minus from
BB6minus ;re*i aen%y Moo*y@s In&esors Ser&i%e %u is oulook on-akisan@s *eb o neai&e from sable *ue o 'olii%al un%erainy! houhi mainaine* he %ounry@s rain a B2: H 7%onomy of -akisan 2""1C!
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
67/72
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
68/72
+he followin +able %om'ares he *eb6o6,D- raios of he*e&elo'in e%onomies of he 7as Asia reion wih -akisanAlhouh he *eb6o6,D- raio of some maure e%onomies!
in%lu*in he US! is aroun* 2"" P i is no an a''ro'riaeben%hmark be%ause of sron %urren%y rains of he *ollar
Alhouh he *eb6o6,D- raio of some maure e%onomies!in%lu*in he US! is aroun* 2"" P i is no an a''ro'riae
ben%hmark be%ause of sron %urren%y rains of he *ollar
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
69/72
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
70/72
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
71/72
-
8/10/2019 Debt and Deleveraging
72/72
ORA