decision support systems for decisions about water · carl gutwin, venkat bandi, ricardo rheeder,...

34
Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019

Upload: others

Post on 13-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations

Decision Support Systemsfor Decisions about Water

Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan SaxenaIMPC 2019

Page 2: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations
Page 3: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations

Outline

•What is decision support?

•A bit of theory: sense-making and boundary objects

•Visualization for decision-making

• System demo

Page 4: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations

What is Decision Support, anyway?

Page 5: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations

What is Decision Support, anyway?

•What types of decisions?

•Optimizations• “Decide where is the best place to locate the intake”

•Resource allocation• “Who should get what amount of water?”

• Tradeoffs• “Decide whether irrigation should be reduced”

Page 6: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations
Page 7: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations

Theory part 1: Sense-making

Page 8: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations

Theory part 1: Sense-making

Framework orhypothesis

Gather information

Evaluate basedon evidence

Create a story

Re-frame

Page 9: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations

Collaborative sense-making

Framework orhypothesis

Gather information

Evaluate basedon evidence

Create a story

Re-frame

Page 10: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations

Visualization for decision-making

Page 11: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations
Page 12: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations
Page 13: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations
Page 14: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations
Page 15: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations
Page 16: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations

Visualization for decision-making

Page 17: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations

Visualization for decision-making

Page 18: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations

Theory part 1: Sense-making

Framework orhypothesis

Gather information

Evaluate basedon evidence

Create a story

Re-frame

Page 19: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations

Theory part 2: Boundary objects

Page 20: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations
Page 21: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations

Theory part 2: Boundary objects

Page 22: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations
Page 23: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations
Page 24: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations
Page 25: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations
Page 26: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations

Other levels of abstraction

Page 27: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations

Other levels of abstraction

Page 28: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations

Other levels of abstraction

Page 29: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations

Other levels of abstraction

Page 30: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations

Other levels of abstraction

Page 31: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations

Other levels of abstraction

Page 32: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations
Page 33: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations

Interactive demo at coffee!

Page 34: Decision Support Systems for Decisions about Water · Carl Gutwin, Venkat Bandi, Ricardo Rheeder, Ishan Saxena IMPC 2019. Outline ... Red Deer River Bow R Select Non-Irrigations