defendants’ motion to dismiss plaintiff’s class …...as the supreme court held in tellabs, to...

420
54087721;11 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA CASE NO. 9:20-cv-81063-RS STEVE HARTEL, Individually and On Behalf of All Others Similarly Situated, Plaintiff, v. THE GEO GROUP, INC., et al., Defendants. _____________________________________/ DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT AND INCORPORATED MEMORANDUM OF LAW Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 1 of 22

Upload: others

Post on 19-Aug-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

54087721;11

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA

CASE NO. 9:20-cv-81063-RS

STEVE HARTEL, Individually and On Behalf of All Others Similarly Situated,

Plaintiff,

v.

THE GEO GROUP, INC., et al.,

Defendants. _____________________________________/

DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT

AND INCORPORATED MEMORANDUM OF LAW

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 1 of 22

Page 2: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

54087721;11

Pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 9(b), 12(b)(6), and the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act

of 1995 (“PSLRA”), Defendants The GEO Group, Inc. (“GEO Group” or the “Company”), George

C. Zoley and Brian R. Evans (collectively, the “Individual Defendants”) move to dismiss all claims

in Plaintiff’s Class Action Complaint (“Complaint” or “Compl.”).

INTRODUCTION

The Complaint is a text-book example of a baseless “strike suit” following a decline in the

GEO Group’s share price during an unprecedented pandemic that has caused severe disruptions in

global markets. In the midst of the ongoing global pandemic, Plaintiff seeks to capitalize on that

drop in stock price by falsely accusing the GEO Group of failing to disclose that its response to

COVID-19 was allegedly inadequate, notwithstanding that the GEO Group issued guidance to all

of its facilities consistent with guidance for correctional and detention facilities issued by the

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (“CDC”). Plaintiff also speciously claims that an

article, focused on a single halfway house in Kansas, published months into the COVID-19

pandemic’s global disruption, purportedly revealed “the truth” about COVID-19’s impact on the

GEO Group’s business, causing a drop in its stock price.

Plaintiff’s entire theory, however, is premised on a gross distortion of the impact on the

GEO Group’s stock price of that one article focused on one facility. The import of that article is

overstated by Plaintiff to fit his narrative. There was no “truth” revealed by this article; between

March 2020 and June 2020, there were numerous reports of COVID-19 outbreaks, at both private

and government-run correctional facilities. Indeed, an earlier news story reported on the spread of

the coronavirus at the same halfway house several weeks before the end of the alleged class period.

The public was well aware that COVID-19 was an issue at halfway houses and correctional

facilities (as well as across the globe).

Also, the very same day the article that Plaintiff relies on was published, CoreCivic, Inc.

(“CoreCivic”), the GEO Group’s competitor and another major for-profit correctional facility

company in the U.S., publicly announced the decision to suspend its quarterly dividend while it

evaluated its corporate structure and capital allocation. Plaintiff completely ignores this

announcement (as well as prior news stories about the specific halfway house discussed in the

article), and completely ignores the likelihood that the GEO Group’s stock drop was in response

to that industry news –– because it does not fit his contrived narrative.

Rather, in a transparent effort to concoct a securities fraud claim from whole cloth,

Plaintiff’s boiler-plate Complaint simply references the GEO Group’s public statements

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 2 of 22

Page 3: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

2 54087721;11

describing, in detail, its comprehensive response to COVID-19 risks –– following guidance issued

for correctional and detention facilities by the CDC –– and summarily alleges that these statements

were false and misleading. Yet, as shown below, Plaintiff’s allegations fail, as each of the

challenged statements are factually accurate and well-founded when placed in the proper context

of the GEO Group’s public statements.

Ironically, while Plaintiff accuses the GEO Group of omitting material information relating

to its business and operations, the only significant omissions in this case are Plaintiff’s own

intentional failure to reveal critical risk disclosures and cautionary statements in the GEO Group’s

SEC filings that are dispositive of his specious claims. In any event, a cursory review of Plaintiff’s

manufactured securities fraud claims confirms that Plaintiff has not and cannot adequately allege

any basis remotely sufficient to survive scrutiny under the PSLRA and the Supreme Court’s

decision in Tellabs, Inc. v. Makor Issues & Rights, Ltd., 551 U.S. 308 (2007).

First and foremost, Plaintiff has not pled securities fraud with the specificity required by

the PSLRA and Rule 9(b). To the contrary, all of the statements contained in the GEO Group’s

public SEC filings, earnings call, and public statement were true and accurate and did not contain

any false or misleading information. Plaintiff has failed to allege actual facts –– as opposed to

pure opinion and conjecture –– in his Complaint demonstrating otherwise.

Second, Plaintiff has not pled facts even attempting to establish the element of scienter as

to each of the alleged false and misleading statements, much less the required strong inference of

scienter. The Complaint is completely devoid of any factual allegations regarding the state of

mind of the GEO Group’s CEO and CFO as of the time of the alleged false and misleading

statements and falls short of pleading the requisite “strong inference” of scienter.

Third, Plaintiff’s securities fraud claims are based primarily on non-actionable, forward-

looking statements in the GEO Group’s 2019 10-K and 2020 10-Q public filings and quarterly

earnings call that are protected by the safe harbor provision of 15 U.S.C. § 78u-5.

Lastly, Plaintiff fails to sufficiently plead the required element of loss causation; there are

no facts in the Complaint establishing any plausible connection between the alleged statements at

issue and the proximate causation of Plaintiff’s alleged losses.

In short, Plaintiff’s bare-bone allegations of securities fraud are facially defective and

amount to nothing more than a thinly-veiled effort to extort a settlement predicated entirely on a

decline in the GEO Group’s share price in the midst of an unprecedented global pandemic.

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 3 of 22

Page 4: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

3 54087721;11

Plaintiff’s Complaint must be dismissed, with prejudice, for failure to satisfy the fundamental

pleading requirements of the PSLRA and Rule 9(b).

FACTUAL BACKGROUND

A. The Class Action Complaint’s Allegations.

This is a putative securities class action brought against the GEO Group under Section

10(b) and Rule 10b-5 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (“Exchange Act”), on behalf of a

putative class of all purchasers of the GEO Group’s securities between February 27, 2020 and June

16, 2020. Plaintiff’s Complaint also asserts claims against Messrs. Zoley and Evans (the GEO

Group’s CEO and CFO, respectively) for control person liability under Section 20(a) of the

Exchange Act.

The GEO Group specializes in the ownership, leasing, and management of secure facilities,

processing centers and reentry facilities and the provision of community-based services and youth

services in the United States, Australia, South Africa, and the United Kingdom. See the GEO

Group’s 2019 SEC Form 10-K (“2019 10-K”) for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2019,

attached as Exhibit 1, at p. 3.1 As of December 31, 2019, the Company’s worldwide operations

included the management and/or ownership of approximately 95,000 beds at 129 secure and

community-based facilities, including projects under development, and the provision of

community supervision services for more than 210,000 offenders and pretrial defendants,

including approximately 100,000 individuals through an array of technology products. Id.

Plaintiff’s skeletal Complaint alleges that the GEO Group made materially false and

misleading statements in its 2019 10-K, in its SEC Form 10-Q filing for quarter ended March 31,

2020 (“2020 Q1 Form 10-Q” attached as Exhibit 2), and in an earnings call (annexed to the GEO

Group’s SEC Form 8-K, filed May 6, 2020, as Exhibit No. 99.2, and attached here as Exhibit 3).

The Complaint broadly alleges that statements related to just about every aspect of the GEO

Group’s business –– including quality of operations, corporate social responsibility, competitive

strengths, business strategies, health and safety, and COVID-19 response procedures –– were false

and misleading. Compl. ¶¶ 21-30.

Plaintiff makes the same allegations with respect to a statement issued by the GEO Group on

its website entitled “GEO Group Has Taken Comprehensive Steps to Address and Mitigate the Risks

1 It is well-settled that on a motion to dismiss a securities fraud action, the Court is free to consider any public records and documents, including SEC filings, that are central to a plaintiff’s claims or referred to in the Complaint. Bryant v. Avado Brands, Inc., 187 F.3d 1271, 1287 (11th Cir. 1999).

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 4 of 22

Page 5: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

4 54087721;11

of COVID-19 to Those in Our Care and Our Employees” (“COVID-19 Response Statement” attached

as Exhibit 4), Compl. ¶¶ 31-32, which outlines steps taken by the Company to address the risks

of COVID-19 virtually identical to the steps outlined in the GEO Group’s 2020 Q1 Form 10-Q.

Plaintiff then claims that a decline in the GEO Group’s stock price on June 17, 2020

occurred as a result of an article published that day entitled “GEO Group’s Blundering Response

to the Pandemic Helped Spread Coronavirus in Halfway Houses” released by an online news

publication, The Intercept (the “Intercept Article” attached as Exhibit 5). Compl. ¶¶ 5-6. Plaintiff

claims that the Intercept Article reported “details of a significant COVID-19 outbreak at the

Grossman Center, a halfway house in Leavenworth, Kansas, operated by GEO Group,” Compl.

¶ 34, and that “[o]n this news, GEO Group’s stock price fell $1.03 per share, or 7.8%, to close at

$12.17 per share on June 17, 2020.” Id. ¶ 36.

Plaintiff has himself made significant omissions in the Complaint by failing to include

critical risk disclosures and cautionary statements related to pandemic outbreaks –– and

specifically COVID-19 –– from the GEO Group’s SEC filings. Those statements are dispositive

of Plaintiff’s specious fraud claims. The disclosures in the GEO Group’s 2019 10-K and 2020 Q1

Form 10-Q explicitly cautioned the Company’s shareholders that (i) it is unable to predict the

impact that the COVID-19 pandemic will have on its financial condition, results of operations and

cash flows due to numerous uncertainties; (ii) that the Company experienced the transmission of

COVID-19 at a number of its facilities in the second quarter of 2020; (iii) if the Company is unable

to mitigate the transmission of COVID-19 at its facilities it could experience a material adverse

effect on its financial position, results of operations and cash flows; (iv) although the Company is

unable to predict the duration or scope of the COVID-19 pandemic or estimate the extent of the

negative financial impact to its operating results, an extended period of depressed economic

activity necessitated to combatting the disease, and the severity and duration of the related global

economic crisis will adversely impact its future financial performance; and (v) that natural

disasters, pandemic outbreaks, global political events and other serious catastrophic events could

disrupt operations and otherwise materially adversely affect the Company’s business and financial

condition.

Plaintiff also ignored an important and more likely cause of the GEO Group’s stock drop

–– a press release by CoreCivic on the same day the Intercept Article was released announcing its

decision to suspend its quarterly dividend while it evaluated its corporate structure and capital

allocation, generally related to the effects of COVID-19 (“CoreCivic’s Announcement” attached

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 5 of 22

Page 6: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

5 54087721;11

as Exhibit 6). Numerous news articles attribute the GEO Group’s stock decline on June 17 to

CoreCivic’s Announcement. Plaintiff failed to disclose one such article by The Motley Fool

entitled “Why The GEO Group Stock Fell 10% at the Open on June 17” (the “Motley Fool Article”

attached as Exhibit 7), because it unequivocally concluded that the decline in the GEO Group’s

stock price was a consequence of investors’ reaction to CoreCivic’s Announcement.

After cherry-picking statements from the GEO Group, and cherry-picking the Intercept

Article, Plaintiff alleges, in purely conclusory fashion, that the GEO Group’s statements were false

and misleading because they purportedly failed to disclose that: (i) the GEO Group maintained

woefully ineffective COVID-19 response procedures at its halfway houses; (ii) those inadequate

procedures subjected residents of its halfway houses to significant health risks; and

(iii) “accordingly, the Company was vulnerable to significant financial and/or reputational harm.”

Compl. ¶¶ 4, 33.

B. The Complaint Intentionally Omits Highly Material Disclosures.

As an initial matter, Plaintiff’s reference to the GEO Group’s 2019 10-K to support his

argument that the Company made false and misleading statements regarding COVID-19 is entirely

disingenuous. The GEO Group could not have had an opportunity to address COVID-19-related

issues in its 2019 10-K given that COVID-19 concerns only emerged and heightened in the first

quarter of 2020. The GEO Group’s 2020 Q1 Form 10-Q adequately addressed the operational and

performance issues specifically regarding the effects of COVID-19 on the Company’s business

and made numerous disclosures about related risks to the Company’s performance.

As previously noted, the Court may properly consider the GEO Group’s entire SEC filings

–– including all risk disclosures and cautionary statements –– during the purported class period in

determining the sufficiency of Plaintiff’s Complaint. Bryant, 187 F.3d at 1287; see also 15 U.S.C.

§ 78u-5(e) (authorizing the district court in a securities fraud action to consider “any cautionary

statement accompanying the forward-looking statement, which are not subject to material dispute,

cited by the defendant”). This rule is particularly applicable in this action in light of Plaintiff’s

selective reference to the GEO Group’s public SEC filings, as it “prevents a plaintiff from excising

an isolated statement from a document and importing it into the complaint, even though the

surrounding context imparts a plainly non-fraudulent meaning to the allegedly wrongful

statement.” Shaw v. Digital Equip. Corp., 82 F.3d 1194, 1220 (1st Cir. 1996). This is the precise

strategy employed by Plaintiff in pursuit of his specious claims in this action.

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 6 of 22

Page 7: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

6 54087721;11

While Plaintiff seizes on pieces of the GEO Group’s public SEC filings as the basis for his

securities fraud claims, he has predictably omitted from the Complaint highly material risk

disclosures contained in the same filings that are fatal to his claims. Most notably, the Complaint

omits that the GEO Group’s 2019 10-K and 2020 Q1 Form 10-Q filings both contain sections

entitled “Risk Factors,” which disclose multiple risks that may affect the Company’s business,

finances and performance. Exhibit 1, 2019 10-K, p. 24; Exhibit 2, 2020 Q1 Form 10-Q, p. 50.

1. The GEO Group Explicitly Disclosed Potential Risks Associated with the Outbreak of a Pandemic.

The GEO Group’s 2019 10-K for the period ending December 31, 2019 (filed with the SEC

on February 26, 2020, Compl. ¶ 21), provided a non-exhaustive list of risk factors it could face in

its business operations, including an explicit warning related to pandemic outbreaks:

Natural disasters, pandemic outbreaks, global political events and other serious catastrophic events could disrupt operations and otherwise materially adversely affect our business and financial condition.

As owner and operator of secure facilities, processing centers and community reentry centers with operations in many states throughout the United States and multiple foreign countries, we are subject to numerous risks outside of our control, including risks arising from natural disasters, pandemic outbreaks and other global health emergencies or disruptive global political events, including terrorist activity and war, or similar disruptions that could materially adversely affect our business and financial performance. Such occurrences can result in destruction or damage to our secure facilities, processing centers and community reentry centers and our information systems, disruption of our operations, require the evacuation of detainees or our personnel, and require the adoption of specific health protocols or treatments to safeguard the health of our detainees or personnel. Although it is not possible to predict such events or their consequences, these events could materially adversely affect our reputation, business and financial condition.

Exhibit 1, 2019 10-K, p. 36 (emphasis in original). In addition to specific disclosures, the

Company warned: “The risks described below are not the only risks we face. Additional risks not

currently known to us or those we currently deem to be immaterial may also materially and

adversely affect our business operations.” Exhibit 1, p. 24 (italics in original).

2. The GEO Group Explicitly Disclosed Risks Associated with COVID-19.

While the GEO Group’s 2019 10-K could not have specifically addressed the effects of

COVID-19 –– because it preceded the eruption of COVID-19 in the United States –– the

Company’s 2020 Q1 Form 10-Q provided numerous disclosures and cautionary statements related

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 7 of 22

Page 8: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

7 54087721;11

to COVID-19. The “Risks and uncertainties” section of the 2020 Q1 Form 10-Q warned about the

risks of the GEO Group’s inability to mitigate the transmission of COVID-19 in its facilities:

The Company is closely monitoring the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on all aspects of its business and geographies, including how it will impact those entrusted in its care and governmental partners. While the Company did not incur significant disruptions during the three months ended March 31, 2020 from the COVID-19 pandemic, it is unable to predict the impact that the COVID-19 pandemic will have on its financial condition, results of operations and cash flows due to numerous uncertainties.

The COVID-19 pandemic and related government-imposed mandatory closures, shelter in-place restrictions and social distancing protocols have had, and will continue to have, a severe impact on global economic conditions and the environment in which the Company operates.

… Additionally, the Company has experienced the transmission of COVID-19 at a small number of our facilities in the second quarter of 2020. If the Company is unable to mitigate the transmission of COVID-19 at its facilities it could experience a material adverse effect on its financial position, results of operations and cash flows. Although the Company is unable to predict the duration or scope of the COVID-19 pandemic or estimate the extent of the negative financial impact to its operating results, an extended period of depressed economic activity necessitated to combating the disease, and the severity and duration of the related global economic crisis will adversely impact its financial performance.

Exhibit 2, 2020 Q1 Form 10-Q, at p. 7 (emphasis added).

Further, in the “2020 Developments” section of the 2020 Q1 Form 10-Q, the GEO Group

included a paragraph on COVID-19, warning about the Company’s inability to predict the impact

of COVID-19 on its financial condition, results of operations and cash flows. The “Outlook” and

“Economic Impact” sections of the 2020 Q1 Form 10-Q contained additional warnings regarding

the economic impacts of COVID-19 on the Company’s operations. Exhibit 2, at pp. 36, 46. And,

the 2020 Q1 Form 10-Q supplemented the Company’s 2019 10-K with risks associated with the

outbreak of COVID-19. Exhibit 2, 2020 Q1 Form 10-Q, at p. 50.

These detailed disclosures placed Plaintiff –– and every GEO Group shareholder –– on

notice that the Company was unable to predict the impact that the COVID-19 pandemic could have

on the Company’s performance due to uncertainties surrounding the pandemic, thus defeating the

allegations in Plaintiff’s Complaint.

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 8 of 22

Page 9: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

8 54087721;11

3. The GEO Group Explicitly Disclosed the Risks Associated With Adverse Publicity Regarding Its Facilities.

Plaintiff’s central fraud allegation is that the GEO Group failed to affirmatively disclose

that its COVID-19 response procedures were purportedly inadequate, which subjected residents of

the Company’s facilities to health risks, and consequently made the Company vulnerable to

financial and/or “reputational harm.” Compl., ¶¶ 4, 33. Yet, in addition to specifically outlining

its COVID-19 response procedures –– following guidance from the CDC –– the GEO Group’s

SEC filings explicitly warned its shareholders about the risks associated with such reputational

harm relating to the alleged or perceived conditions of its private correctional facilities.

In its 2019 10-K, the heading “[a]dverse publicity may negatively impact our ability to

retain existing contracts and obtain new contracts,” included the following cautionary statement:

Any negative publicity about an escape, riot, other disturbance, death or injury of a detainee, or perceived conditions and access to health care and other services at a facility, including any work program at a facility, under a public-private partnership … may result in publicity adverse to us and public-private partnerships in general. Any of these occurrences or continued trends … could have a material adverse effect on our business.

Exhibit 1, at p. 35. Plaintiff cannot successfully maintain his claim because the GEO Group

adequately warned against the effect of any such adverse publicity.

ARGUMENT

A. THE PSLRA IMPOSES HEIGHTENED PLEADING STANDARDS FOR FEDERAL SECURITIES CLAIMS.

In order to state a viable claim for securities fraud under Section 10(b) and Rule 10b-5 of

the Exchange Act, Plaintiff is required to allege: (1) a misstatement or omission; (2) of a material

fact; (3) made with scienter; (4) on which the Plaintiff justifiably relied; and (5) that proximately

caused the Plaintiff’s injury. Bryant, 187 F.3d at 1281. In an effort to stem the rampant tide of

abusive securities litigation and dispose of non-meritorious securities fraud claims at the pleading

stage, the PSLRA significantly heightened the pleading standards for Section 10(b) claims. Id.

As such, the PSLRA imposes two key requirements and provides that, if they are not satisfied,

“the court shall, on the motion of any defendant, dismiss the complaint.” 15 U.S.C. § 78u-

4(b)(3)(A) (emphasis added).

First, Plaintiff is required to “specify each statement alleged to have been misleading, the

reason or reasons why the statement is misleading, and if an allegation regarding the statement or

omission is made on information and belief,… [to] state with particularity all facts on which that

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 9 of 22

Page 10: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

9 54087721;11

belief is formed.” Id. § 78u-4(b)(1). Second, Plaintiff is required, “with respect to each act or

omission alleged . . . [to] state with particularity facts giving rise to a strong inference that the

defendant acted with the required state of mind.” Id. § 78u-4(b)(2) (emphasis added). To satisfy

this standard, all of the facts alleged, taken together, must give rise to an inference of scienter that

is “cogent and at least as compelling as any opposing inference of nonfraudulent intent.” Tellabs,

551 U.S. at 314.

Section 10(b) claims are also subject to Rule 9(b)’s requirement that fraud must be pled

with particularity, a rule designed to thwart generalized fraud allegations that “enable[] [plaintiffs]

to learn the complaint’s bare essentials through discovery and may needlessly harm a defendant’s

goodwill and reputation . . . .” U.S. ex rel. Atkins v. McInteer, 470 F.3d 1350, 1359 (11th Cir.

2006). Rule 9(b) requires plaintiffs to plead “(1) precisely what statements were made in which

documents or oral representations . . ., and (2) the time and place of each such statement and the

person responsible for making . . . same, and (3) the content of such statements and the manner in

which they misled the plaintiff, and (4) what the defendants obtained as a consequence of the

fraud.” Ziemba v. Cascade Int’l, Inc., 256 F.3d 1194, 1202 (11th Cir. 2001).

B. PLAINTIFF’S BOILERPLATE COMPLAINT FAILS TO STATE A CLAIM.

Plaintiff’s securities fraud claims must be dismissed because his Complaint fails to

adequately plead any of the requisite elements under Section 10(b) and Rule 10b-5.

1. Plaintiff Fails To Plead All Facts.

The Complaint must be dismissed as a threshold matter because Plaintiff has failed to

“specify each statement alleged to have been misleading” and “the reason or reasons why the

statement is misleading” with the particularity required by the PSLRA and Rule 9(b).

Plaintiff’s entire case is built on his flimsy claim that the Intercept Article is per se proof

that the GEO Group made false and misleading statements by failing to disclose that the Company

maintained ineffective COVID-19 response procedures at its facilities which purportedly resulted

in reputational harm to the Company. Plaintiff’s theory of liability is flawed from the outset, as

the Intercept Article contains nothing more than vague purported complaints from residents of the

GEO Group’s Grossman Center in Leavenworth, Kansas.

Plaintiff relies exclusively on those vague, generalized, and conclusory statements as the

basis for his fraud claims, but the Complaint fails to identify any facts that would render any of

the GEO Group’s public statements concerning its facilities or services in any way false or

misleading. Conspicuously, the Intercept Article does not cite a shred of credible and verifiable

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 10 of 22

Page 11: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

10 54087721;11

evidence that supports the purported complaints referenced therein. For instance, the Intercept

Article mentions a purported photo of individuals in bunkbeds without masks, but such photo was

neither included in the Intercept Article nor the Complaint. As such, its context cannot be

determined. There is absolutely nothing that validates the Intercept Article’s unsubstantiated

characterization of the purported condition of the GEO Group’s Grossman Center (or its facilities,

more generally). See Exhibit 4, the Intercept Article.

Further, Plaintiff does not allege that any of the public statements made by the GEO Group

in its SEC filings, earnings call and COVID-19 Response Statement were in any way false or

inaccurate on their face as a factual matter. Plaintiff instead contends that these statements were

rendered false solely because of the allegations made in the Intercept Article. This is the slimmest

reed imaginable upon which to hang a securities fraud claim under Section 10(b) and Rule 10b-5.

2. The GEO Group’s Statements Are Accurate.

Plaintiff’s Complaint similarly fails to allege a single fact showing that the GEO Group’s

challenged public statements in its SEC filings were anything but 100% true and accurate.

(a). The 2019 Form 10-K Was Accurate.

The first set of alleged misrepresentations are statements under the “Quality of Operations”

section in the 2019 10-K. Plaintiff alleges that the statement “[w]e operate each facility in

accordance with our company-wide policies and procedures and with the standards and guidelines

required under the relevant management contract…” was false and misleading. Compl. ¶ 21.

Plaintiff fails to allege any facts demonstrating that this statement was false, but instead predictably

relies exclusively on the Intercept Article for the basis of his allegation that these statements were

somehow false and misleading, with no attempt to explain how or why this is so. Id. at ¶¶ 33-36.

Further, Plaintiff quotes from a section of the 2019 10-K under “Corporate Social

Responsibility” where the GEO Group stated that: “[w]e have referenced the GRI Standards and

the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights as we have recognized the need for a

transparent and disciplined enterprise-wide approach.” The Company further stated that “[i]n

pursuit of this approach, we have begun with the following set of ongoing objectives…” (listing

three ongoing objectives). Compl. ¶ 22 (emphasis added). Plaintiff fails to show how these

statements of ongoing objectives are false or misleading. Further, as discussed below, statements

regarding the Company’s “objectives of management for future operations” are aspirational and

inactionable forward-looking statements which investors are warned are “not guarantees of future

performance.” Exhibit 1, p. 68; Exhibit 2, p. 33 (emphasis added).

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 11 of 22

Page 12: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

11 54087721;11

And, under “Risk Factors,” the Company emphasized that “[w]e are subject to risks related

to corporate social responsibility”:

By electing to publicly share our Human Rights and ESG [environmental, social and governance] report, our business may face increased scrutiny related to our human rights and ESG activities. As a result, our reputation could be adversely impacted if we fail to act responsibly in the areas in which we report, such as human rights, the development of our workforce, safety and security, addressing recidivism, engaging with our stakeholders, ethics and governance, oversight and contract compliance, energy and environmental sustainability and financial management and performance. Any harm to our reputation resulting from setting these standards or our failure or perceived failure to meet such standards could impact: … our investors willingness or ability to purchase or hold our securities; and employee retention and the quality of relations with our employees, any of which could adversely affect our business, financial condition and results of operations.

Exhibit 1, at p. 41. Plaintiff’s allegations fail because the GEO Group specifically warned its

investors and shareholders of the risks related to corporate social responsibility.

Plaintiff has similarly failed to plead specific facts casting any doubt on the truth or

accuracy of the GEO Group’s statements in its 2019 10-K regarding the Company’s “Competitive

Strengths.” Although Plaintiff alleged that statements identifying the GEO Group as a “Leading

Secure Services Provider Uniquely Positioned to Offer a Continuum of Care” and a “Large Scale

Operator with National Presence” were false, Compl. ¶¶ 23, 33, the Complaint is completely silent

as to how or why these statements are misleading.

Next, Plaintiff quotes from the “Business Strategies” section of the 2019 10-K where the

Company states that its “objective” is to “Provide High Quality, Comprehensive Services and Cost

Savings Throughout the Corrections Lifecycle.” Compl. ¶ 24. Again, in addition to the fact that

this is an “objective” –– clearly aspirational and forward-looking –– Plaintiff fails to provide any

basis to establish that this statement is false.

Moreover, these statements under the “Corporate Social Responsibility,” “Competitive

Strengths,” and “Business Strategies” sections of the 2019 10-K are statements of corporate

optimism which cannot form the basis for allegations of fraud and misrepresentation. Compl.

¶¶ 22-24. Plaintiff’s attempt to ground his Section 10(b) and Rule 10b-5 claims on statements of

optimism –– routinely held not actionable under the federal securities laws –– is unavailing. See

In re Royal Caribbean Cruises Ltd. Securities Litig., 2013 WL 3295951, at *12 (S.D. Fla. Apr. 19,

2013) (holding that “[a] statement that is vague, generalized, or ‘mere corporate puffery’ is

immaterial because a reasonable investor would not base a decision on such statements,”);

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 12 of 22

Page 13: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

12 54087721;11

Philadelphia Fin. Mgmt. of San Francisco v. DJSP Enters., Inc., 2011 WL 4591541, at *14, 17

(S.D. Fla. Sept. 30, 2011) (statements about the “efficiency” and “accuracy” of operations and that

company was “well positioned” were “non-actionable ‘puffery’”); Mulvaney v. GEO Grp., Inc.,

237 F. Supp. 3d 1308, 1322 (S.D. Fla. 2017) (“only material misrepresentations or omissions are

actionable.”); Bhatt v. Tech Data Corp., 2018 WL 6504375, at *4 (M.D. Fla. 2018) (citing In re

Winn-Dixie Stores, Inc. Sec. Litig., 531 F. Supp. 2d 1334, 1343-44 (M.D. Fla. 2007)).

Alternatively, the statements are in the nature of predictive opinion, which are actionable

only if they are both subjectively and objectively false –– that is, only (1) if the speaker did not

genuinely hold the opinion and (2) the opinion lacked a reasonable basis. See Virginia Bankshares,

Inc. v. Sandberg, 501 U.S. 1083, 1093 (1991). Plaintiff fails to allege any facts to show that the

GEO Group, and its relevant executives, did not in fact believe the opinions expressed or that the

opinions lacked any reasonable basis. See Belmont Holdings Corp. v. Sun Trust Banks, Inc., No.

1:09-cv-1185-WSD, 2010 WL 3545389, at *6 (N.D. Ga. Sept. 10, 2010) (dismissing claim

“[a]bsent an allegation that Defendants did not believe the statements”).

(b). The 2020 Q1 Form 10-Q and COVID-19 Response Statement Were Accurate.

Plaintiff next turns to the 2020 Q1 Form 10-Q and the GEO Group’s COVID-19 Response

Statement. First, Plaintiff challenges the Company’s statement under the “Health and Safety”

section of the Company’s 2020 Q1 Form 10-Q. Compl. ¶ 28; see also Exhibit 2, at p. 45. There,

the Company discussed the impact of COVID-19 on its facilities, and lists the comprehensive steps

taken to address and mitigate the risks of COVID-19 to staff, inmates, detainees and residents.

Compl. ¶¶ 28-29; see also Exhibit 2, at p. 45. Plaintiff fails to allege how or why this statement is

false or misleading.

And, under the “Economic Impact” section of the 2020 Q1 Form 10-Q, the Company again

accurately disclosed that it has “experienced the transmission of COVID-19 at a small number of

[its] facilities in the second quarter of 2020,” warning that:

If we are unable to mitigate the transmission of COVID-19 at our facilities we could experience a material adverse effect on our financial position, results of operations and cash flows. Although we are unable to predict the duration or scope of the COVID-19 pandemic or estimate the extent of the negative financial impact to our operating results, an extended period of depressed economic activity necessitated to combating the disease, and the severity and duration of the related global economic crisis will adversely impact our future financial performance.

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 13 of 22

Page 14: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

13 54087721;11

Exhibit 2, at p. 46 (emphasis added). Similarly, the Company again emphasized under the “Risk

Factors” section of the 2020 Q1 Form 10-Q that:

The current pandemic of the novel coronavirus, or COVID-19, and the future outbreak of other highly infectious or contagious diseases, could materially and adversely impact or disrupt our business, results of operations, financial condition and liquidity.

Exhibit 2, at p. 50 (emphasis in original).

It is clear that COVID-19 has caused substantial challenges to industries globally. It has

proven highly contagious. The GEO Group has followed CDC guidelines for correctional and

detention facilities to prevent, assess and manage COVID-19. The fact that cases of COVID-19

occurred in any Company’s facilities does not mean that the Company failed to appropriately take

steps to address this pandemic. And, the GEO Group warned that:

The Company is closely monitoring the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on all aspects of its business and geographies, including how it will impact those entrusted in its care and governmental partners. While the Company did not incur significant disruptions during the three months ended March 31, 2020 from COVID-19 pandemic, it is unable to predict the impact that the COVID-19 pandemic will have on its financial condition, results of operations and cash flows due to numerous uncertainties.

Exhibit 2, 2020 Q1 Form 10-Q, at p. 7 (emphasis added). All of Plaintiff’s complaints have been

addressed in risk factors disclosed to the public.

Plaintiff also challenges the GEO Group’s COVID-19 Response Statement, Compl. ¶¶ 31,

33, a list of comprehensive steps taken by the Company to address the impact of COVID-19.

Exhibit 3; see also Exhibit 2, at p. 45. Plaintiff has failed to allege any facts supporting his

contention that this statement is false or misleading.

Considering the multiple reiterations regarding the risks associated with COVID-19 in the

GEO Group’s disclosures and cautionary statements, Plaintiff cannot justifiably state a claim.

(c). The Quarterly Earnings Call Was Accurate.

Plaintiff quotes extensively from the GEO Group’s quarterly earnings call held on April

30, 2020, alleging that statements made during the call were false and misleading. Compl. ¶¶ 4,

26, 27, 33. Once again, Plaintiff fails to identify any actual facts supporting his assertions.

The statements at issue from the Q1 2020 earnings call consist of factual statements

concerning specific steps taken by the Company to mitigate the risks of COVID-19, similar to the

comprehensive steps referenced in the 2020 Q1 Form 10-Q. Compl. ¶¶ 26, 27; Exhibit 2, at p. 45.

Plaintiff does not even attempt to allege with particularity how or why the statements in the GEO

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 14 of 22

Page 15: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

14 54087721;11

Group’s earnings call were in any way false, inaccurate or misleading. Plaintiff does not allege

that any of the detailed statements concerning specific steps taken by the GEO Group to mitigate

the risks of COVID-19 were materially false as a factual matter. Plaintiff similarly fails to plead

specific facts casting doubt on the truth or accuracy of these statements. Plaintiff has failed to

identify facts that would render the statements false or misleading. None of the statements in the

GEO Group’s earnings call is remotely actionable under Section 10(b) or Rule 10b-5.

There are simply no facts alleged to support Plaintiff’s contention that the GEO Group

“maintained woefully ineffective COVID-19 response procedures” which purportedly “subjected

residents of the Company’s halfway houses to significant health risks” and supposedly resulted in

the Company being “vulnerable to significant financial and/or reputational harm.” Compl. ¶¶ 4,

33. To the contrary, as discussed above, the GEO Group followed CDC guidelines for correctional

and detention facilities to prevent, assess and manage COVID-19, and made numerous COVID-

19-specific disclosures in its 2020 Q1 Form 10-Q. Exhibit 2, at pp. 33, 36, 41, 42, 45, 46, 50.

Plaintiff has failed to state a claim for securities fraud based on statements contained in the GEO

Group’s SEC filings or public statements.

3. The Risk Disclosures Are Fatal To Plaintiff’s Omission Claims.

Plaintiff’s claims of fraudulent omission are similarly defective and fail to state a claim

under Section 10(b) and Rule 10b-5 because the GEO Group had ample risk disclosures in its

public SEC filings. As detailed above, the GEO Group’s 2019 10-K and 2020 Q1 Form 10-Q

contained detailed risk disclosures and cautionary statements that fully and adequately warned of

the potential adverse effects of a pandemic, including COVID-19. These disclosures go to the

heart of the Plaintiff’s fraudulent omission claims: the GEO Group’s public SEC filings explicitly

disclosed: (i) the potential risks associated with the outbreak of a pandemic; (ii) the risks associated

specifically with COVID-19; and (iii) the risks associated with adverse publicity regarding its

facilities. Exhibit 1, 2019 10-K, pp. 36, 69; Exhibit 2, 2020 Q1 Form 10-Q, pp. 33, 36, 41, 42, 45,

46, 50. Plaintiff cannot plead his way around the fact that the GEO Group adequately disclosed

the same risk that forms the basis for this strike-suit, i.e., a drop in the Company’s stock price

allegedly caused by the effect of COVID-19 on the Company’s business operations and

performance. The GEO Group’s disclosures are fatal to Plaintiff’s claims since it is axiomatic that

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 15 of 22

Page 16: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

15 54087721;11

a “[p]laintiff cannot premise [his] omission claims on risks that were disclosed.” Bhatt, 2018 WL

6504375, at *5.

4. Plaintiff Fails To Plead A Strong Inference of Scienter.

Plaintiff’s facially defective securities fraud claims must be dismissed for another

fundamental reason: the Complaint fails to plead facts sufficient to support any inference of

scienter, much less the strong inference required by the PSLRA.

The element of scienter necessary to state a claim under Section 10(b) and Rule 10b-5

requires Plaintiff to assert particularized allegations that each defendant acted knowingly or in a

severely reckless manner. See Druskin v. Answerthink, Inc., 299 F. Supp. 2d 1307, 1323 (S.D.

Fla. 2004) (citing Bryant, 187 F.3d at 1283-87). “Severe recklessness” –– the minimum a plaintiff

must plead –– “is limited to those highly unreasonable omissions or misrepresentations that

involve not merely simple or even inexcusable negligence, but an extreme departure from the

standards of ordinary care [such that] . . . the defendant must have been aware of [the fraud].”

Ziemba, 256 F.3d at 1202 (quotation omitted).

As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts

sufficient to make the inference of scienter “more than merely plausible or reasonable –– it must

be cogent and at least as compelling as any opposing inference of non-fraudulent intent.” 551 U.S.

at 314. To determine whether a complaint’s scienter allegations are sufficient, a court “must

engage in a comparative evaluation; it must consider, not only inferences urged by the

plaintiff . . . but also competing inferences rationally drawn from the facts alleged.” Id.

Plaintiff’s paltry scienter allegations in this action consist of just one paragraph that is

patently insufficient under the stringent PSLRA and Tellabs standard. The Complaint contains

only the vaguest, boilerplate allegations directed at Messrs. Zoley and Evans. Compl. ¶¶ 17, 51-

53. Those allegations can be boiled down to a paltry allegation that “[a]s the senior managers

and/or directors of GEO Group, the Individual Defendants had knowledge of the details of GEO

Group’s internal affairs,” which is wholly inadequate to plead the required strong inference of

scienter on the part of the Individual Defendants. See, e.g., Mulvaney, 237 F. Supp. 3d at 1324

(“[M]erely holding a position of power does not lead to an inference of scienter without specific

allegations of the Individual Defendants’ role in the fraud.”). These conclusory statements are

utterly devoid of any factual allegations regarding the state of mind of the Company’s CEO and

CFO as of the time of the allegedly false and misleading statements. Plaintiff has fallen short of

pleading the requisite “strong inference” of scienter.

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 16 of 22

Page 17: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

16 54087721;11

The Eleventh Circuit has consistently admonished that barren allegations of “motive and

opportunity” –– like those asserted in Plaintiff’s Complaint –– are inadequate to support a strong

inference of scienter under the PSLRA. See, e.g., Jiangbo Pharm. Inc., Sec. Litig., 884 F. Supp.

2d 1243, 1261 (S.D. Fla. 2012). Indeed, “mere allegations that Defendants held senior

management positions, had access to inside information, and therefore must have known of the

falsity of certain statements is insufficient to plead scienter.” Hubbard v. BankAtlantic Bancorp,

Inc., 625 F. Supp. 2d 1267, 1286 (S.D. Fla. 2008) (quoting In re Smith Gardner Sec. Litig., 214 F.

Supp. 2d 1291, 1303 (S.D. Fla. 2002)); see also In re: Sunterra Corp. Sec. Litig., 199 F. Supp. 2d

1308, 1324 (M.D. Fla. 2002) (“In essence, the Amended Complaint merely alleges that these

Defendants ‘must have known’ because of the CEO and CFO positions that they held, and such

pleading does not pass muster under the PSLRA.”).

Plaintiff’s Complaint merely parrots the same type of generalized scienter allegations that

this Court has repeatedly found lacking and fails to provide a scintilla of factual support for any

claim that the GEO Group or its officers had knowledge of any alleged fraud. Plaintiff’s glaring

failure to plead any facts supporting a strong inference of scienter requires dismissal of the

Complaint.

5. Plaintiff’s Claims Are Based On Non-Actionable Forward-Looking, Cautionary Statements.

In addition to his failure to specifically plead facts demonstrating any false and misleading

statements or omissions by the GEO Group or any inference of scienter, Plaintiff’s securities fraud

claims are also barred because the alleged misleading statements at issue are clearly protected

forward-looking statements entitled to “Safe Harbor” under the PSLRA.

In an effort to insulate public companies from potential liability for forward-looking

statements and to encourage management to share opinions and projections, Congress included in

the PSLRA a safe harbor that insulates corporate managers from liability for forward-looking

statements. 15 U.S.C. § 78u-5. As a result, there is no liability for forward looking statements

when the statements are identified as such and are “accompanied by meaningful cautionary

statements identifying important factors that could cause actual results to differ materially from

those in the forward-looking statement[s].” 15 U.S.C. § 78u-5(c)(1)(A)(i). Where the alleged

fraud is grounded on forward looking statements, dismissal is required regardless of the state of

mind of the person who made the statement, be it negligent, reckless, or even knowing. Edward

J. Goodman Life Income Trust v. Jabil Circuit, Inc., 594 F.3d 783, 795 (11th Cir. 2010).

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 17 of 22

Page 18: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

17 54087721;11

Here, the GEO Group’s 2019 10-K filing, and the 2020 Q1 Form 10-Q for the purported

class period included conspicuous sections entitled “Forward-Looking Statements — Safe

Harbor” and “Forward-Looking Information,” respectively. The 2019 10-K warned that it

contained “forward-looking” statements within the safe harbor, including “statements regarding

our future financial position, business strategy, budgets, projected costs and plans and objectives

of management for future operations,” and that “[t]hese statements are not guarantees of future

performance and involve certain risks, uncertainties and assumptions, which are difficult to

predict.” See Exhibit 1, 2019 10-K, p. 68 (disclosing that “forward-looking” statements include

plans and objectives of management for future operations and can generally be identified by the

use of forward-looking terminology such as “believe”).

The alleged misleading statements that form the basis for Plaintiff’s fraud claims –– i.e.,

that the GEO Group “believed” its continuum of care platform would result in a higher quality of

care for individuals in the Company’s care, and that its “objective” was to provide federal, state

and local governmental agencies with a comprehensive offering of high quality services –– are the

epitome of non-actionable forward-looking statements that fall squarely within the safe harbor of

the PSLRA. Compl. ¶¶ 23-24. In fact, the GEO Group’s Form 10-K and 2020 Q1 Form 10-Q

filings repeatedly and explicitly identified the exact statements that form the core of Plaintiff’s

securities fraud claims as forward-looking cautionary statements that the Company could neither

guarantee nor predict. For instance, the GEO Group’s 2019 10-K identified its forward-looking,

“cautionary statements” as including statements about (i) “the impact of natural disasters,

pandemic outbreaks, global political events and other serious catastrophic events on our business

and financial condition.” Exhibit 1, p. 69 (emphasis added). And regarding COVID-19, the

Company’s 2020 Q1 Form 10-Q included the following as part of the factors that could cause

actual results to differ materially from those expressed or implied by the forward-looking

statements: (i) “our ability to mitigate the transmission of COVID-19 at our secure facilities,

processing centers and reentry centers; and (ii) “the magnitude, severity and duration of the

COVID-19 pandemic and its impact on our business, financial condition, results of operations and

cash flows.” Exhibit 2, p. 33.

The GEO Group is also shielded from liability for these statements by the safe harbor and

the bespeaks caution doctrine, as the statements are undeniably forward-looking because they

either explicitly speak to future events or involve opinions that can be assessed only in light of

future events. See, e.g., Harris v. Ivax Corporation, 182 F.3d 799, 805 (11th Cir. 1999) (holding

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 18 of 22

Page 19: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

18 54087721;11

that statements that “our fundamental business and … strategies remain intact” and are “very well

positioned” were forward-looking); In re Mako Surgical Corp., 2013 WL 2145661, at *6 (S.D.

Fla. May 15, 2013) (statement that “[w]e anticipate that our positive results in 2011 will carry

forward into 2012” was forward-looking).

6. Plaintiff Has Failed to Sufficiently Plead Loss Causation.

The Complaint also must be dismissed for failure to plead facts establishing “loss

causation,” i.e., that the alleged economic loss was caused by the GEO Group’s purported “fraud.”

A plaintiff asserting claims under Section 10(b) and Rule 10b-5 is required to sufficiently

allege a causal connection between the alleged misrepresentations and the economic loss incurred.

See Dura Pharm., Inc. v. Broudo, 544 U.S. 336, 345-46 (2005); see also 15 U.S.C. §78u-4(b)(4);

Robbins v. Koger Prop., Inc., 116 F.3d 1441, 1447 (11th Cir. 1997). Even in a fraud-on-the-market

case like this one, “the plaintiff must prove not only that a fraudulent misrepresentation artificially

inflated the security’s value but also that ‘the fraud-induced inflation that was baked into the

plaintiff’s purchase price was subsequently removed from the stock’s price, thereby causing losses

to the plaintiff.’” Meyer v. Greene, 710 F.3d 1189, 1195 (11th Cir. 2013) (citations omitted).

Plaintiff fails to even attempt to make such a showing of proximate cause, nor can he, given

the truthful nature of the GEO Group’s alleged false and misleading statements and the vast risk

disclosures contained in the Company’s SEC filings. There is no connection between the GEO

Group’s alleged false and misleading statements, and the drop in the Company’s stock price given

its numerous and timely public disclosures regarding the potential adverse consequences related

to the COVID-19 pandemic on its facilities. Indeed, throughout the entire purported class period,

the GEO Group specifically warned its shareholders about the impact that a pandemic outbreak –

– more specifically COVID-19 –– could have on its business operations and performance.

Additionally, as mentioned above, there are no factual allegations to demonstrate that it

was the release of the Intercept Article that actually caused the decline in the GEO Group’s share

price. Indeed, as noted above, between March 2020 and June 2020, there were numerous reports

of COVID-19 outbreaks, at both private and government-run correctional facilities, and an earlier

news story reported on the spread of the coronavirus at the same halfway house several weeks

before the end of the alleged class period. Plaintiff conveniently ignores the abundance of public

information regarding COVID-19’s effect on the correctional system, including the very facility

discussed in the Intercept Article, and ignores CoreCivic’s Announcement, which was a more

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 19 of 22

Page 20: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

19 54087721;11

likely cause of the decline. That Plaintiff failed to even attempt to distinguish the effect of this

public information speaks volumes about the Complaint’s accuracy.

7. Failure to State a Claim for A Primary Violation of the Exchange Act Requires Dismissal of Count II, Secondary “Control Person” Liability

Because Plaintiff does not state a cause of action for a primary violation of the Exchange

Act in Count I as set forth above, Plaintiff’s claim for secondary, “control person” liability also

fails. Count II seeks to hold the Individual Defendants secondarily liable for the GEO Group’s

alleged violations of the Exchange Act. Section 20(a) of the Exchange Act imposes secondary

liability on certain “control persons” for primary violations of Section 10(b) by a “person liable,”

i.e., the issuer of securities. See Laperriere v. Vesta Ins. Group, Inc., 526 F.3d 715, 721 (11th Cir.

2008). To state a claim, a plaintiff must plead a primary violation in accordance with the

requirements of the PSLRA and Rule 9(b) or be subject to dismissal. See In re Royal Caribbean

Cruises, 2013 WL 3295951 at *19 (dismissing Section 20(a) claim where plaintiffs failed to state

a claim under Section 10(b)); Mizzaro v. Home Depot, Inc., 544 F.3d 1230, 1255 (11th Cir. 2008)

(“Because [plaintiff] failed to adequately plead a violation of § 10(b) and Rule 10b-5 by [the

issuing company], its § 20(a) control-person claims against the individual defendants necessarily

fail as well.”). Thus, when the primary violation fails, there can be no Section 20(a) liability.

Here, because Plaintiff has not adequately pled a primary violation by the issuing company, the

GEO Group, the Section 20(a) claim against the Individual Defendants, Messrs. Zoley and Evans,

necessarily fails as well. See Mulvaney, 237 F. Supp. 3d at 1326 (“Because Plaintiffs fail to plead

a primary violation of Section 10(b) of the Exchange Act, Plaintiffs do not plead a violation of

Section 20(a)”).

8. Count II Fails to Plead Facts to Establish the Individual Defendants as “Control Persons” as Required to State a Claim Under Section 20(a)

Plaintiff’s Section 20(a) claim also fails because Plaintiff does not plead sufficient facts to

establish that either of the Individual Defendants had the power to control the GEO Group’s

business affairs, generally, or the dissemination of the purportedly false and misleading statements

alleged.

Control requires that an individual be in “the possession, direct or indirect, of the power to

direct or cause the direction of the management and policies of a person, whether through

ownership of voting securities, by contract, or otherwise.” Laperriere, 526 F.3d at 723 (quotation

omitted). To plead control under Section 20(a), a plaintiff must do more than restate a legal

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 20 of 22

Page 21: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

20 54087721;11

conclusion of control. In re Smith Barney Transfer Agent Litig., 884 F. Supp. 2d 152, 166

(S.D.N.Y. 2012) (“[C]onclusory allegations of control are insufficient as a matter of law.”); In re

Global Crossing, Ltd., Sec. Litig., No. 02 Civ. 910(GEL), 2005 WL 1907005, at *12 (S.D.N.Y.

Aug. 8, 2005).

The Complaint fails to sufficiently allege facts to support that each Individual Defendant

asserted control for purposes of liability under Section 20(a). Rather, the Complaint lumps both

Individual Defendants into a status of “controlling persons” by means of boilerplate allegations

that they “participated in the operation and management of GEO Group, and conducted and

participated, directly and indirectly, in the conduct of GEO Group’s business affairs.” Compl.

¶ 58. The Complaint then makes the conclusory, and inapplicable, statement that “[b]ecause of

their senior positions, they knew the adverse non-public information about GEO Group’s

misstatement of income and expenses and false financial statements.” Id. (emphasis added). As

this is the first mention of misstated income, expenses, or false financial statements, it appears that

Plaintiff merely copied and pasted this allegation from another boilerplate complaint.

The allegations in the Complaint specifically directed at the Individual Defendants are

only: that the Individual Defendants, collectively, signed the various SEC filings made by the GEO

Group, and that Mr. Zoley participated in an earnings’ call, on April 30, 2020, where he discussed

the same COVID-19 response procedures that would be described in the GEO Group’s SEC

Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q filed on May 6, 2020. Compl. ¶ 26; see also Exhibit 2.

Inexplicably, Plaintiff also admits that Mr. Zoley was not the only executive on the call but alleges

that “other GEO Group executives” made the same representations. Compl. ¶ 27. Nowhere does

the Complaint allege any specific facts to establish that either Individual Defendant effectively

controlled GEO Group with respect to the alleged primary violation or “acted recklessly in failing

to do what they could have done to prevent the primary violation.” Laperriere, 526 F.3d at 725.

At most, the Individual Defendants are alleged to have done their jobs on behalf of the corporate

defendant.

CONCLUSION

For all of the foregoing reasons, Defendants respectfully request that Plaintiff’s Class

Action Complaint be dismissed in its entirety.

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 21 of 22

Page 22: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

54087721;11

Dated: August 12, 2020 Respectfully submitted,

AKERMAN LLPThree Brickell City Centre 98 Southeast Seventh Street Suite 1100 Miami, FL 33131 Telephone: (305) 374-5600 Facsimile: (305) 374-5095

By: /s/ Brian P. Miller Brian P. Miller, Esq. Florida Bar No. 0980633 [email protected] J. Kavanaugh, Esq. Florida Bar No. 0194662 [email protected]

Counsel for Defendant The GEO Group, Inc.

GUNSTER, YOAKLEY & STEWART, P. A. 600 Brickell Avenue, 35th Floor Miami, FL 33131 Telephone: 305-376-6000 Facsimile: 786 425-4090

By: /s/ William K. Hill William K. Hill, Esq. Florida Bar Number: 747180 Primary: [email protected]: [email protected] S. LeMieux, Esq. Florida Bar Number: 16403 Primary: [email protected]: [email protected]: [email protected] “EJ” A. Cox IV, Esq. Florida Bar Number: 124652 Primary: [email protected]: [email protected]

Counsel for Defendants George C. Zoley and Brian R. Evans

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 22 of 22

Page 23: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

EXHIBIT 1

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 1 of 253

Page 24: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

YRMXIH$WXEXIW

WIGYVMXMIW$ERH$I\GLERKI$GSQQMWWMSR[ewlmrkxsr0$H2G2$6498=

$

Jsvq$541O,Qevo$Sri-

# ERRYEP$VITSVX$TYVWYERX$XS$WIGXMSR$57$SV$59,h-$SJ$XLI$WIGYVMXMIWI\GLERKI$EGX$SJ$5=78

Jsv$xli$jmwgep$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=

SV

" XVERWMXMSR$VITSVX$TYVWYERX$XS$WIGXMSR$57$SV$59,h-$SJ$XLI$WIGYVMXMIWI\GLERKI$EGX$SJ$5=78

Jsv$xli$xverwmxmsr$tivmsh$jvsq$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$xs$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$

Gsqqmwwmsr$jmpi$ryqfiv>$51586:4

$

Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2,I|egx$reqi$sj$vikmwxverx$ew$wtigmjmih$mr$mxw$glevxiv-

$ $ $

Jpsvmhe $ :9144874;<

,Wxexi$sv$sxliv$nyvmwhmgxmsr$sjmrgsvtsvexmsr$sv$svkerm~exmsr- $

,M2V2W2$Iqtps}ivMhirxmjmgexmsr$Rs2-

$ $

$ $

8=99$Xiglrspsk}$[e} $ $

Fsge$Vexsr $ 77875

Jpsvmhe $ $

,Ehhviww$sj$tvmrgmtep$i|igyxmzi$sjjmgiw- $ ,^mt$Gshi-

Vikmwxverx×w$xipitlsri$ryqfiv0$mrgpyhmrk$evie$gshi>$,9:5-$<=714545

Wigyvmxmiw$vikmwxivih$tyvwyerx$xs$Wigxmsr$56,f-$sj$xli$Egx>

$ $ $

Xmxpi$sj$Iegl$Gpeww Xvehmrk$W}qfsp,w- Reqi$sj$Iegl$I|glerki$sr$[lmgl$Vikmwxivih

Gsqqsr$Wxsgo0$(4245$Tev$Zepyi KIS Ri{$]svo$Wxsgo$I|glerki

Wigyvmxmiw$vikmwxivih$tyvwyerx$xs$Wigxmsr$56,k-$sj$xli$Egx>

Rsri

$

Mrhmgexi$f}$gligo$qevo$mj$xli$vikmwxverx$mw$e${ipp1ors{r$wiewsrih$mwwyiv0$ew$hijmrih$mr$Vypi$849$sj$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$Egx2$$$$$]iw

$$#$$$$Rs$$"

Mrhmgexi$f}$gligo$qevo$mj$xli$vikmwxverx$mw$rsx$viuymvih$xs$jmpi$vitsvxw$tyvwyerx$xs$Wigxmsr$57$sv$Wigxmsr$59,h-$sj$xli$Egx2$$$$$]iw

$$"$$$$Rs$$#

Mrhmgexi$f}$gligo$qevo${lixliv$xli$vikmwxverx$,5-$lew$jmpih$epp$vitsvxw$viuymvih$xs$fi$jmpih$f}$Wigxmsr$57$sv$59,h-$sj$xli$Wigyvmxmiw

I|glerki$Egx$sj$5=78$hyvmrk$xli$tvigihmrk$56$qsrxlw$,sv$jsv$wygl$wlsvxiv$tivmsh$xlex$xli$vikmwxverx${ew$viuymvih$xs$jmpi$wygl$vitsvxw-0

erh$,6-$lew$fiir$wyfnigx$xs$wygl$jmpmrk$viuymviqirxw$jsv$xli$tewx$=4$he}w2$$$$]iw$$#$$$$Rs$$"

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 2 of 253

Page 25: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 6367<

Mrhmgexi$f}$gligo$qevo${lixliv$xli$vikmwxverx$lew$wyfqmxxih$ipigxvsrmgepp}$iziv}$Mrxivegxmzi$Hexe$Jmpi$viuymvih$xs$fi$wyfqmxxih

tyvwyerx$xs$Vypi$849$sj$Vikypexmsr$W1X$,§6762849$sj$xlmw$gletxiv-$hyvmrk$xli$tvigihmrk$56$qsrxlw$,sv$jsv$wygl$wlsvxiv$tivmsh$xlex$xli

vikmwxverx${ew$viuymvih$xs$wyfqmx$wygl$jmpiw-2$$$$$]iw$$#$$$$Rs$$"

Mrhmgexi$f}$gligo$qevo${lixliv$xli$vikmwxverx$mw$e$pevki$eggipivexih$jmpiv0$er$eggipivexih$jmpiv0$e$rsr1eggipivexih$jmpiv0$e$wqeppiv

vitsvxmrk$gsqter}0$sv$er$iqivkmrk$kvs{xl$gsqter}2$Wii$xli$hijmrmxmsrw$sj$Ôpevki$eggipivexih$jmpiv0Õ$Ôeggipivexih$jmpiv0Õ$Ôwqeppiv

vitsvxmrk$gsqter}0Õ$erh$&iqivkmrk$kvs{xl$gsqter}&$mr$Vypi$56f16$sj$xli$I|glerki$Egx2

Pevki$eggipivexih$jmpiv $

#

$$ Eggipivexih$jmpiv $ "

$ $ $ $

Rsr1eggipivexih$jmpiv $

"

$$ Wqeppiv$vitsvxmrk$gsqter} $ "

$ $ $ $ $ $ $

$ $ $ $ Iqivkmrk$kvs{xl$gsqter} $ "

Mj$er$iqivkmrk$kvs{xl$gsqter}0$mrhmgexi$f}$gligo$qevo$mj$xli$vikmwxverx$lew$ipigxih$rsx$xs$ywi$xli$i|xirhih$xverwmxmsr$tivmsh$jsv

gsqtp}mrk${mxl$er}$ri{$sv$vizmwih$jmrergmep$eggsyrxmrk$wxerhevhw$tvszmhih$tyvwyerx$xs$Wigxmsr$57,e-$sj$xli

I|glerki$Egx2$"

Mrhmgexi$f}$gligo$qevo${lixliv$xli$vikmwxverx$mw$e$wlipp$gsqter}$,ew$hijmrih$mr$Vypi$56f16$sj$xli$Egx-2$$$$]iw$$"$$$$Rs$$#

Xli$ekkvikexi$qevoix$zepyi$sj$xli$<;0;990448$zsxmrk$erh$rsr1zsxmrk$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$liph$f}$rsr1ejjmpmexiw$sj$xli

vikmwxverx$ew$sj$Nyri$6<0$645=$,fewih$sr$xli$pewx$vitsvxih$wepiw$tvmgi$sj$wygl$wxsgo$sr$xli$Ri{$]svo$Wxsgo$I|glerki$sr$wygl$hexi0$xli

pewx$fywmriww$he}$sj$xli$vikmwxverx+w$uyevxiv$irhih$Nyri$740$645=$sj$(65245$tiv$wlevi-${ew$ettvs|mqexip}$(52<$fmppmsr2

Ew$sj$Jifvyev}$650$64640$xli$vikmwxverx$leh$565067;0<49$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$syxwxerhmrk2

Givxemr$tsvxmsrw$sj$xli$vikmwxverx×w$hijmrmxmzi$tvs|}$wxexiqirx$tyvwyerx$xs$Vikypexmsr$58E$sj$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$I|glerki$Egx$sj$5=78

jsv$mxw$6464$erryep$qiixmrk$sj$wlevilsphivw0${lmgl${mpp$fi$jmpih${mxl$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$erh$I|glerki$Gsqqmwwmsr${mxlmr$564$he}w$ejxiv

xli$irh$sj$xli$}iev$gszivih$f}$xlmw$vitsvx0$evi$mrgsvtsvexih$f}$vijivirgi$mrxs$Tevx$MMM$sj$xlmw$vitsvx2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 3 of 253

Page 26: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 7367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

XEFPI$SJ$GSRXIRXW

$

$ $ $

$ $ Teki

TEVX$M $

Mxiq$52 Fywmriww 7

Mxiq$5E2 Vmwo$Jegxsvw 68

Mxiq$5F2 Yrviwspzih$Wxejj$Gsqqirxw 87

Mxiq$62 Tvstivxmiw 87

Mxiq$72 Pikep$Tvsgiihmrkw 87

Mxiq$82 Qmri$Wejix}$Hmwgpswyviw 87

TEVX$MM $

Mxiq$92 Qevoix$jsv$Vikmwxverx×w$Gsqqsr$Iuymx}0$Vipexih$Wxsgolsphiv$Qexxivw$erh$Mwwyiv$Tyvglewiw$sj$Iuymx}$Wigyvmxmiw 87

Mxiq$:2 Wipigxih$Jmrergmep$Hexe 87

Mxiq$;2 Qerekiqirx×w$Hmwgywwmsr$erh$Erep}wmw$sj$Jmrergmep$Gsrhmxmsr$erh$Viwypxw$sj$Stivexmsrw 88

Mxiq$;E2 Uyerxmxexmzi$erh$Uyepmxexmzi$Hmwgpswyviw$Efsyx$Qevoix$Vmwo ;4

Mxiq$<2 Jmrergmep$Wxexiqirxw$erh$Wyttpiqirxev}$Hexe ;5

Mxiq$=2 Glerkiw$mr$erh$Hmwekviiqirxw${mxl$Eggsyrxerxw$sr$Eggsyrxmrk$erh$Jmrergmep$Hmwgpswyvi 58;

Mxiq$=E2 Gsrxvspw$erh$Tvsgihyviw 58;

Mxiq$=F2 Sxliv$Mrjsvqexmsr 58;

TEVX$MMM $

Mxiq$542 Hmvigxsvw0$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgivw$erh$Gsvtsvexi$Kszivrergi 58<

Mxiq$552 I|igyxmzi$Gsqtirwexmsr 58<

Mxiq$562 Wigyvmx}$S{rivwlmt$sj$Givxemr$Firijmgmep$S{rivw$erh$Qerekiqirx$erh$Vipexih$Wxsgolsphiv$Qexxivw 58<

Mxiq$572 Givxemr$Vipexmsrwlmtw$erh$Vipexih$Xverwegxmsrw0$erh$Hmvigxsv$Mrhitirhirgi 58<

Mxiq$582 Tvmrgmtep$Eggsyrxmrk$Jiiw$erh$Wivzmgiw 58<

TEVX$MZ $

Mxiq$592 I|lmfmxw$erh$Jmrergmep$Wxexiqirx$Wglihypiw 58<

Mxiq$5:2 Jsvq$541O$Wyqqev} 58<

$ Wmkrexyviw 599

6

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 4 of 253

Page 27: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 8367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

TEVX$M

$

Mxiq$52 Fywmriww

Ew$ywih$mr$xlmw$vitsvx0$xli$xivqw$Ô{i0Õ$Ôyw0Õ$Ôsyv0Õ$ÔKISÕ$erh$xli$ÔGsqter}Õ$vijiv$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg20$mxw$gsrwspmhexih

wyfwmhmevmiw$erh$mxw$yrgsrwspmhexih$ejjmpmexiw0$yrpiww$sxliv{mwi$i|tviwwp}$wxexih$sv$xli$gsrxi|x$sxliv{mwi$viuymviw2

Kirivep

$$$$

[i$ evi$ e$ jypp}1mrxikvexih$ viep$ iwxexi$ mrziwxqirx$ xvywx$ ,ÔVIMXÕ-$ wtigmepm~mrk$ mr$ xli$ s{rivwlmt0$ piewmrk$ erh$qerekiqirx$ sj

wigyvi$ jegmpmxmiw0$ tvsgiwwmrk$ girxivw$ erh$ viirxv}$ jegmpmxmiw$ erh$ xli$ tvszmwmsr$ sj$ gsqqyrmx}1fewih$ wivzmgiw$ erh$ }syxl$ wivzmgiw$ mr$ xli

Yrmxih$Wxexiw0$Eywxvepme0$Wsyxl$Ejvmge$erh$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq2$[i$s{r0$piewi$erh$stivexi$e$fvseh$verki$sj$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw$mrgpyhmrk

qe|mqyq0$qihmyq$erh$qmrmqyq$ wigyvmx}$ jegmpmxmiw0$ tvsgiwwmrk$ girxivw0$ ew${ipp$ ew$ gsqqyrmx}1fewih$ viirxv}$ jegmpmxmiw2$[i$hizipst

ri{$jegmpmxmiw$fewih$sr$gsrxvegx$e{evhw0$ywmrk$syv$tvsnigx$hizipstqirx$i|tivxmwi$erh$i|tivmirgi$xs$hiwmkr0$gsrwxvygx$erh$jmrergi${lex

{i$ fipmizi$ evi$ wxexi1sj1xli1evx$ jegmpmxmiw$ xlex$ qe|mqm~i$ wigyvmx}$ erh$ ijjmgmirg}2$ [i$ tvszmhi$ mrrszexmzi$ gsqtpmergi$ xiglrspskmiw0

mrhywxv}1piehmrk$ qsrmxsvmrk$ wivzmgiw0$ erh$ izmhirgi1fewih$ wytivzmwmsr$ erh$ xviexqirx$ tvskveqw$ jsv$ gsqqyrmx}1fewih$ tevspiiw0

tvsfexmsrivw$erh$tvixvmep$hijirherxw2$[i$epws$tvszmhi$wigyvi$xverwtsvxexmsr$wivzmgiw$jsv$sjjirhiv$erh$hixemrii$tstypexmsrw$ew$gsrxvegxih

hsqiwxmgepp}$erh$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq$xlvsykl$syv$nsmrx$zirxyvi$KIS$Eqi}$TIGW$Pxh2$,ÔKISEqi}Õ-2$Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0

syv${svph{mhi$stivexmsrw$ mrgpyhih$ xli$qerekiqirx$erh3sv$s{rivwlmt$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$=90444$fihw$ex$56=$ wigyvi$ erh$ gsqqyrmx}1

fewih$ jegmpmxmiw0$ mrgpyhmrk$ mhpi$ jegmpmxmiw$ erh$ tvsnigxw$ yrhiv$ hizipstqirx0$ erh$ epws$ mrgpyhi$ xli$ tvszmwmsr$ sj$ gsqqyrmx}$ wytivzmwmsr

wivzmgiw$ jsv$qsvi$ xler$6540444$ sjjirhivw$ erh$tvixvmep$ hijirherxw0$ mrgpyhmrk$ ettvs|mqexip}$ 5440444$ mrhmzmhyepw$ xlvsykl$ er$ evve}$ sj

xiglrspsk}$tvshygxw$mrgpyhmrk$vehms$jviuyirg}0$KTW0$erh$epgslsp$qsrmxsvmrk$hizmgiw2

[i$tvszmhi$e$hmzivwmjmih$wgsti$sj$wivzmgiw$sr$filepj$sj$syv$kszivrqirx$gpmirxw>

¨ syv$wigyvi$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$wivzmgiw$mrzspzi$xli$tvszmwmsr$sj$wigyvmx}0$ehqmrmwxvexmzi0$vilefmpmxexmsr0

ihygexmsr0$erh$jssh$wivzmgiw0$tvmqevmp}$ex$ehypx$qepi$wigyvi$wivzmgiw$jegmpmxmiw?

¨ syv$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$wivzmgiw$mrzspzi$wytivzmwmsr$sj$ehypx$tevspiiw$erh$tvsfexmsrivw$erh$xli$tvszmwmsr$sj$xiqtsvev}

lsywmrk0$tvskveqqmrk0$iqtps}qirx$ewwmwxergi$erh$sxliv$wivzmgiw${mxl$xli$mrxirxmsr$sj$xli$wyggiwwjyp$vimrxikvexmsr$sj

viwmhirxw$mrxs$xli$gsqqyrmx}?

¨ syv$}syxl$wivzmgiw$mrgpyhi$viwmhirxmep0$wlipxiv$gevi$erh$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$wivzmgiw$epsrk${mxl$vilefmpmxexmzi

erh$ihygexmsrep$tvskveqw?

¨ {i$tvszmhi$gsqtvilirwmzi$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$erh$wytivzmwmsr$wivzmgiw?

¨ {i$hizipst$ri{$jegmpmxmiw0$ywmrk$syv$tvsnigx$hizipstqirx$i|tivmirgi$xs$hiwmkr0$gsrwxvygx$erh$jmrergi${lex${i$fipmizi

evi$wxexi1sj1xli1evx$jegmpmxmiw$xlex$qe|mqm~i$wigyvmx}$erh$ijjmgmirg}?

¨ {i$tvszmhi$wigyvi$xverwtsvxexmsr$wivzmgiw$jsv$sjjirhiv$erh$hixemrii$tstypexmsrw$ew$gsrxvegxih?$erh

¨ syv$wivzmgiw$evi$tvszmhih$ex$jegmpmxmiw${lmgl${i$imxliv$s{r0$piewi$sv$evi$s{rih$f}$syv$gywxsqivw2

[i$fiker$stivexmrk$ ew$ e$VIMX$ jsv$ jihivep$ mrgsqi$ xe|$ tyvtswiw$ ijjigxmzi$ Neryev}$50$ 64572$Ew$ e$ viwypx$ sj$ xli$VIMX$gsrzivwmsr0${i

visvkerm~ih$ syv$ stivexmsrw$ erh$ qszih$ rsr1viep$ iwxexi$ gsqtsrirxw$ mrxs$ xe|efpi$ VIMX$ wyfwmhmevmiw$ ,ÔXVWw&-2$ [i$ evi$ e$ Jpsvmhe

gsvtsvexmsr$erh$syv$tvihigiwwsv$gsvtsvexmsr$tvmsv$xs$xli$VIMX$gsrzivwmsr${ew$svmkmrepp}$svkerm~ih$mr$5=<82

Fywmriww$Wikqirxw

[i$gsrhygx$syv$fywmriww$xlvsykl$jsyv$vitsvxefpi$fywmriww$wikqirxw>$syv$Y2W2$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$wikqirx?$syv$KIS$Gevi$wikqirx?

syv$Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw$wikqirx$erh$syv$Jegmpmx}$Gsrwxvygxmsr$*$Hiwmkr$wikqirx2$[i$lezi$mhirxmjmih$xliwi$jsyv$vitsvxefpi$wikqirxw

xs$vijpigx$syv$gyvvirx$zmi{$xlex${i$stivexi$jsyv$hmwxmrgx$fywmriww$pmriw0$iegl$sj${lmgl$gsrwxmxyxiw$e$qexivmep$tevx$sj$syv$szivepp$fywmriww2

Syv$Y2W2$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$wikqirx$tvmqevmp}$irgsqtewwiw$syv$Y2W21fewih$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmt$wigyvi$wivzmgiw$fywmriww2$Syv

KIS$Gevi$wikqirx0${lmgl$gsrhygxw$mxw$wivzmgiw$mr$xli$Y2W20$gsrwmwxw$sj$syv$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$wivzmgiw$fywmriww0$syv$}syxl$wivzmgiw

fywmriww$erh$syv$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$erh$wytivzmwmsr$wivzmgi2$Syv$Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw$wikqirx$tvmqevmp}$gsrwmwxw$sj$syv$tyfpmg1

tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmt$wigyvi$wivzmgiw$stivexmsrw$mr$Eywxvepme0$Wsyxl$Ejvmge$erh$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq2$Syv$Jegmpmx}$Gsrwxvygxmsr$*$Hiwmkr

wikqirx$tvmqevmp}$gsrxvegxw${mxl$zevmsyw$wxexiw0$psgep$erh$jihivep$ekirgmiw0$ew${ipp$ew$mrxivrexmsrep$ekirgmiw0$jsv$xli$hiwmkr$erh

gsrwxvygxmsr$sj$jegmpmxmiw$jsv${lmgl${i$kirivepp}

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 5 of 253

Page 28: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 9367<

7

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 6 of 253

Page 29: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq :367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

lezi$fiir0$sv$i|tigx$xs$fi0$e{evhih$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw2$Jmrergmep$mrjsvqexmsr$efsyx$xliwi$wikqirxw$jsv$}ievw$645=0$645<$erh$645;

mw$gsrxemrih$mr$Rsxi$5:$Ó$Fywmriww$Wikqirxw$erh$Kiskvetlmg$Mrjsvqexmsr$mrgpyhih$mr$xli$rsxiw$xs$syv$eyhmxih$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep

wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$MM0$Mxiq$<$sj$xlmw$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O2

Vigirx$Hizipstqirxw

$

Gsrxvegx$E{evhw3Qshmjmgexmsrw

Sr$Higiqfiv$740$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$errsyrgih$xlex$KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$wmkrih$e$ri{$qerekih1srp}$gsrxvegx${mxl$xli

Y2W2$Qevwlepw$Wivzmgi$jsv$xli$kszivrqirx1s{rih0$9561fih$Ip$Girxvs$Hixirxmsr$Jegmpmx}$mr$Gepmjsvrme2$Xli$gsrxvegx${mpp$lezi$e$xivq$sj

imklx$}ievw$erh$rmri$qsrxlw0$mrgpywmzi$sj$stxmsr$tivmshw0$ijjigxmzi$Higiqfiv$670$645=2$Xli$gsrxvegx$mw$i|tigxih$xs$kirivexi

ettvs|mqexip}$(6=$qmppmsr$mr$erryepm~ih$viziryiw$jsv$KIS$erh$gviexi$qsvi$xler$684$jypp1xmqi$nsfw2$$$$

Sr$Higiqfiv$670$645=0${i$errsyrgih$xlex${i$irxivih$mrxs$x{s$ri{$gsrxvegxw${mxl$Y2W2$Mqqmkvexmsr$erh$Gywxsqw

Irjsvgiqirx$,ÔMGIÕ-$jsv$jmzi$gsqter}1s{rih$jegmpmxmiw$mr$Gepmjsvrme$xsxepmrk$808=4$fihw2$Xli$gsrxvegxw${mpp$lezi$xivqw$sj$jmjxiir

}ievw0$mrgpywmzi$sj$x{s$jmzi$}iev$stxmsrw0$ijjigxmzi$Higiqfiv$640$645=2$Xli$gsrxvegxw$gsziv$x{s$i|mwxmrk0$gsqter}1s{rih$jegmpmxmiw

gyvvirxp}$stivexih$f}$KIS$sr$filepj$sj$MGI>$xli$50=841fih$Ehiperxs$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxiv$erh$xli$8441fih$Qiwe$Zivhi$MGI

Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxiv2$Xli$gsrxvegxw$epws$mrgsvtsvexi$xlvii$sxliv$gsqter}1s{rih$jegmpmxmiw>$xli$;441fih$Girxvep$Zeppi}$jegmpmx}0$xli$;941

fih$Hiwivx$Zmi{$jegmpmx}0$erh$xli$;441fih$Ksphir$Wxexi$jegmpmx}0$ew$jegmpmx}$erri|iw2$Sr$e$gsqfmrih$fewmw0$xli$gsrxvegxw$evi$i|tigxih$xs

kirivexi$sziv$(644$qmppmsr$mr$erryepm~ih$viziryi$jsv$KIS$erh${mpp$wyttsvx$qsvi$xler$50644$jypp1xmqi$nsfw2

$$$$

Mr$xli$xlmvh$uyevxiv$sj$645=0${i${ivi$e{evhih$e$xir1}iev$gsrxvegx$viri{ep$jsv$xli$gsrxmryih$hipmziv}$sj$wigyvi$xverwtsvxexmsr

yrhiv$syv$KIS$Eqi}$nsmrx$zirxyvi$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq2$Xsxep$viziryi$sziv$xli$xir1}iev$tivmsh$mw$i|tigxih$xs$fi$ettvs|mqexip}

(;:4$qmppmsr2

Sr$Nyri$90$645=0${i$epws$errsyrgih$xlex${i$irxivih$mrxs$e$gsrxvegx$qshmjmgexmsr$xs$mrgviewi$xli$gsrxvegx$getegmx}$ex$syv

gsqter}1s{rih$Qsrxksqiv}$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxiv$mr$Gsrvsi0$Xi|ew$f}$758$fihw$mrgviewmrk$xli$girxiv+w$getegmx}$xs$50758$fihw2$Xli$7581

fih$gsrxvegx$getegmx}$mrgviewi$figeqi$jypp}$stivexmsrep$mr$xli$xlmvh$uyevxiv$sj$645=$erh$mw$i|tigxih$xs$kirivexi$mrgviqirxep$erryepm~ih

viziryiw$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(54$qmppmsr2

Sr$Qe}$60$645=0${i$errsyrgih$xlex${i$irxivih$mrxs$e$ri{$xir1}iev$gsrxvegx0$mrgpywmzi$sj$viri{ep$stxmsr$tivmshw0${mxl$xli

Jihivep$Fyviey$sj$Tvmwsrw$,ÔFSTÕ-$jsv$xli$viegxmzexmsr$sj$syv$i|mwxmrk$gsqter}1s{rih0$50<441fih$Rsvxl$Peoi$Gsvvigxmsrep$Jegmpmx}

psgexih$mr$Feph{mr0$Qmglmker2$Xli$gsrxvegx$figeqi$stivexmsrep$sr$Sgxsfiv$50$645=$erh$mw$i|tigxih$xs$kirivexi$ettvs|mqexip}$(7;

qmppmsr$mr$mrgviqirxep$erryepm~ih$viziryiw2$[i$epws$errsyrgih$sr$Qe}$60$645=$xlex$Viiziw$Gsyrx}0$Xi|ew$irxivih$mrxs$x{s$ri{$xir1

}iev$gsrxvegxw0$mrgpywmzi$sj$viri{ep$tivmshw0${mxl$xli$FST$jsv$xli$gsyrx}1s{rih0$50<441fih$Viiziw$Gsyrx}$Hixirxmsr$Girxiv$M$*$MM

erh$xli$gsyrx}1s{rih0$507;:1fih$Viiziw$Gsyrx}$Hixirxmsr$Girxiv$MMM2$[i$tvszmhi$qerekiqirx$gsrwypxmrk$erh$wyttsvx$wivzmgiw$xs

Viiziw$Gsyrx}2$Xli$ri{$xir1}iev$gsrxvegxw${ivi$e{evhih$xs$KIS$erh$Viiziw$Gsyrx}$yrhiv$e$psrk1wxerhmrk$tvsgyviqirx0$jsv$xli

lsywmrk$sj$rsr1Y2W2$gmxm~ir$gvmqmrep$epmirw0$gsqqsrp}$vijivvih$xs$ew$Gvmqmrep$Epmir$Viuymviqirx$,GEV-$5=0${lmgl${ew$mwwyih$f}$xli

FST$mr$645;2

Sr$Etvmp$690$645=0${i$errsyrgih$xlex${i$wmkrih$e$gsrxvegx$qshmjmgexmsr$jsv$xli$viegxmzexmsr$sj$syv$i|mwxmrk$gsqter}1s{rih

504441fih$Wsyxl$Psymwmere$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxiv$,xli$&Girxiv&-$psgexih$mr$Fewmpi0$Psymwmere2$Xli$tvizmsywp}$mhpih$Girxiv${mpp$lsywi

jihivep$mqqmkvexmsr$hixemriiw$yrhiv$er$i|mwxmrk$mrxivkszivrqirxep$wivzmgi$ekviiqirx2$Xli$Girxiv$fiker$xli$mrxeoi$tvsgiww$hyvmrk$xli

xlmvh$uyevxiv$sj$645=$erh$mw$i|tigxih$xs$kirivexi$ettvs|mqexip}$(69$qmppmsr$mr$mrgviqirxep$erryepm~ih$viziryiw2

Gsrxvegx$Xivqmrexmsrw

$$$$Vigirxp}$Gepmjsvrme$iregxih$pikmwpexmsr$emqih$ex$tlewmrk$syx$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmt$gsrxvegxw$jsv$xli$stivexmsr$sj$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw

{mxlmr$Gepmjsvrme$erh$jegmpmxmiw$syxwmhi$sj$xli$wxexi$sj$Gepmjsvrme$lsywmrk$wxexi$sj$Gepmjsvrme$mrqexiw2$Ew$tvizmsywp}$errsyrgih0$syv

gsrxvegx$jsv$syv$Girxvep$Zeppi}$jegmpmx}${ew$epvieh}$hmwgsrxmryih$f}$xli$Gepmjsvrme$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmsrw$erh$Vilefmpmxexmsr$ex$xli

irh$sj$Witxiqfiv$645=2$[i$i|tigx$xlex$syv$gsrxvegxw${mxl$xli$Gepmjsvrme$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmsrw$erh$Vilefmpmxexmsr$jsv$syv$Hiwivx

Zmi{$jegmpmx}$erh$Ksphir$Wxexi$jegmpmx}${mpp$fi$hmwgsrxmryih$f}$Qevgl$50$6464$erh$Qe}$50$64640$viwtigxmzip}2$Ew$hmwgywwih$efszi0${i

wyfwiuyirxp}$irxivih$mrxs$ri{$gsrxvegxw${mxl$MGI$jsv$syv$Girxvep$Zeppi}0$Hiwivx$Zmi{$erh$Ksphir$Wxexi$jegmpmxmiw$ijjigxmzi$Higiqfiv

640$645=2

8

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 7 of 253

Page 30: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq ;367<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 8 of 253

Page 31: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq <367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Mhpi$Jegmpmxmiw

$$$$$$

Mr$syv$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$wikqirx0${i$evi$gyvvirxp}$qevoixmrk$ettvs|mqexip}$;44$zegerx$fihw${mxl$e$rix$fsso$zepyi$sj$ettvs|mqexip}

(56$qmppmsr$ex$sri$sj$syv$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw$xs$tsxirxmep$gywxsqivw2$Mr$syv$KIS$Gevi$wikqirx0${i$evi$gyvvirxp}$qevoixmrk$ettvs|mqexip}

844$zegerx$fihw${mxl$e$rix$fsso$zepyi$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(=$qmppmsr$ex$sri$sj$syv$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw$xs$tsxirxmep$gywxsqivw2$Xli$gsqfmrih

erryep$gevv}mrk$gswx$sj$xliwi$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw$mr$6464$mw$iwxmqexih$xs$fi$(724$qmppmsr0$mrgpyhmrk$hitvigmexmsr$i|tirwi$sj$(524$qmppmsr2$[i

gyvvirxp}$hs$rsx$lezi$er}$jmvq$gsqqmxqirxw$sv$ekviiqirxw$mr$tpegi$xs$egxmzexi$xliwi$jegmpmxmiw$fyx$lezi$srksmrk$gsrxegx${mxl$wizivep

tsxirxmep$gywxsqivw2$Lmwxsvmgepp}0$wsqi$jegmpmxmiw$lezi$fiir$mhpi$jsv$qypxmtpi$}ievw$fijsvi$xli}$vigimzih$e$ri{$gsrxvegx$e{evh2$Xli$tiv

hmiq$ vexiw$ xlex${i$ glevki$ syv$ gpmirxw$ sjxir$ zev}$ f}$ gsrxvegx$ egvsww$ syv$ tsvxjspms2$Ls{iziv0$ mj$ xli$ x{s$ mhpi$ jegmpmxmiw$ mr$ syv$ Wigyvi

Wivzmgiw$erh$KIS$Gevi$ wikqirxw${ivi$ xs$fi$egxmzexih$ywmrk$syv$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$eziveki$tiv$hmiq$vexi$ mr$645=0$ ,gepgypexih$ ew$ xli

Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$viziryi$hmzmhih$f}$xli$ryqfiv$sj$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$qerhe}w-$erh$fewih$sr$xli$eziveki$sggyterg}$vexi$mr$syv$jegmpmxmiw

jsv$645=0${i${syph$i|tigx$xs$vigimzi$erryep$mrgviqirxep$viziryi$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(69$qmppmsr$erh$er$mrgviewi$mr$erryep$ievrmrkw$tiv

wlevi$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(247$xs$(24:$tiv$wlevi$fewih$sr$syv$eziveki$stivexmrk$qevkmr2

Uyepmx}$sj$Stivexmsrw

[i$stivexi$iegl$jegmpmx}$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$syv$gsqter}1{mhi$tspmgmiw$erh$tvsgihyviw$erh${mxl$xli$wxerhevhw$erh$kymhipmriw$viuymvih

yrhiv$xli$vipizerx$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegx2$Jsv$qer}$jegmpmxmiw0$xli$wxerhevhw$erh$kymhipmriw$mrgpyhi$xlswi$iwxefpmwlih$f}$xli$Eqivmger

Gsvvigxmsrep$ Ewwsgmexmsr0$ sv$ ,&EGE&-2$ Xli$ EGE$ mw$ er$ mrhitirhirx$ svkerm~exmsr$ sj$ gsvvigxmsrw$ tvsjiwwmsrepw0$ {lmgl$ iwxefpmwliw

gsvvigxmsrep$jegmpmx}$wxerhevhw$erh$kymhipmriw$xlex$evi$kirivepp}$egors{pihkih$ew$e$firglqevo$f}$kszivrqirxep$ekirgmiw$viwtsrwmfpi

jsv$ gsvvigxmsrep$ jegmpmxmiw2$Qer}$ sj$ syv$ gsrxvegxw$ mr$ xli$ Yrmxih$ Wxexiw$ viuymvi$ yw$ xs$ wiio$ erh$ qemrxemr$ EGE$ eggvihmxexmsr$ jsv$ syv

jegmpmxmiw2$ [i$ lezi$ wsyklx$ erh$ vigimzih$ EGE$ eggvihmxexmsr$ erh$ vi1eggvihmxexmsr$ jsv$ epp$ wygl$ jegmpmxmiw2$[i$ eglmizih$ e$ qihmer$ vi1

eggvihmxexmsr$wgsvi$sj$ 544)$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=2$Ettvs|mqexip}$=4)$sj$syv$645=$Y2W2$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$ viziryi${ew$hivmzih

jvsq$EGE$eggvihmxih$jegmpmxmiw$jsv$ xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=2$[i$lezi$epws$eglmizih$erh$qemrxemrih$eggvihmxexmsr$f}$Xli

Nsmrx$ Gsqqmwwmsr$ ex$ jmzi$ sj$ syv$ wigyvi$ wivzmgi$ jegmpmxmiw$ erh$ ex$ rmri$ sj$ syv$ }syxl$ wivzmgiw$ psgexmsrw2$[i$ lezi$ fiir$ wyggiwwjyp$ mr

eglmizmrk$erh$qemrxemrmrk$eggvihmxexmsr$yrhiv$xli$Rexmsrep$Gsqqmwwmsr$sr$Gsvvigxmsrep$Liepxl$Gevi$,&RGGLG&-$mr$e$qensvmx}$sj$xli

jegmpmxmiw$xlex${i$gyvvirxp}$stivexi2$Xli$RGGLG$eggvihmxexmsr$mw$e$zspyrxev}$tvsgiww${lmgl${i$lezi$ywih$xs$iwxefpmwl$gsqtvilirwmzi

liepxl$gevi$tspmgmiw$ erh$tvsgihyviw$ xs$qiix$erh$ehlivi$ xs$ xli$EGE$wxerhevhw2$Xli$RGGLG$wxerhevhw0$ mr$qswx$gewiw0$ i|giih$EGE

Liepxl$Gevi$Wxerhevhw$erh${i$lezi$eglmizih$xlmw$eggvihmxexmsr$ex$58$sj$syv$Y2W2$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$jegmpmxmiw$erh$ex$sri$}syxl$wivzmgiw

psgexmsr2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$F2M2$Mrgsvtsvexih$,&FM&-$lew$eglmizih$e$givxmjmgexmsr$jsv$MWS$=445>644<$jsv$xli$hiwmkr0$tvshygxmsr0$mrwxeppexmsr

erh$ wivzmgmrk$ sj$ tvshygxw$ erh$ wivzmgiw$ tvshygih$ f}$ xli$ ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$ fywmriww$ yrmxw0$ mrgpyhmrk$ ipigxvsrmg$ lsqi$ evviwx$ erh

ipigxvsrmg$ qsrmxsvmrk$ xiglrspsk}$ tvshygxw$ erh$ qsrmxsvmrk$ wivzmgiw0$ mrwxeppexmsr$ wivzmgiw0$ erh$ eyxsqexih$ gewipseh$ qerekiqirx

wivzmgiw2

Gsvtsvexi$Wsgmep$Viwtsrwmfmpmx}

$$Mr$Witxiqfiv$645=0${i$mwwyih$syv$jmvwx$Lyqer$Vmklxw$erh$IWK$vitsvx2$Xli$Lyqer$Vmklxw$erh$IWK$vitsvx$fymphw$sr$xli$mqtsvxerx

qmpiwxsri${i$eglmizih$ mr$6457${lir$syv$Fsevh$ehstxih$e$Kpsfep$Lyqer$Vmklxw$Tspmg}$f}$tvszmhmrk$hmwgpswyviw$ vipexih$ xs$ls{${i

mrjsvq$syv$iqtps}iiw$sj$syv$gsqqmxqirx$xs$viwtigxmrk$lyqer$vmklxw?$xli$gvmxivme${i$ywi$xs$ewwiww$lyqer$vmklxw$tivjsvqergi?$erh$syv

gsrxvegx$gsqtpmergi$tvskveq0$viqihmiw$xs$wlsvxgsqmrkw$mr$lyqer$vmklxw$tivjsvqergi0$erh$mrhitirhirx$zivmjmgexmsr$sj$syv$tivjsvqergi

f}$xlmvh$tevx}$svkerm~exmsrw2$Xli$Lyqer$Vmklxw$erh$IWK$vitsvx$epws$ehhviwwiw$gvmxivme0$fewih$sr$vigskrm~ih$IWK$vitsvxmrk$wxerhevhw0

vipexih$xs$xli$hizipstqirx$sj$syv$iqtps}iiw?$syv$ijjsvxw$xs$ehzergi$irzmvsrqirxep$wywxemrefmpmx}$mr$xli$gsrwxvygxmsr$erh$stivexmsr$sj

syv$jegmpmxmiw?$erh$syv$ehlivirgi$xs$ixlmgep$kszivrergi$tvegxmgiw$xlvsyklsyx$syv$gsqter}2$Xli$vitsvx$gszivw$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv

750$ 645<$ {mxl$ wyttsvxmrk$ hexe$ jvsq$ 645:1645<$ {livi$ tswwmfpi2$ Xli$ vitsvx$ wls{gewiw0$ eqsrk$ sxliv$ mxiqw0$ syv$ gsqter}$ {mhi

e{eviriww$erh$ xvemrmrk$tvskveqw0$syv$gsqqmxqirx$ xs$e$weji$erh$lyqeri$irzmvsrqirx$ jsv$iziv}sri$ mr$syv$gevi0$ iqtps}ii$hmzivwmx}0

ehhviwwmrk$ vigmhmzmwq$ xlvsykl$ syv$KIS$Gsrxmryyq$ sj$Gevi0$ syv$ irkekiqirx$ ijjsvxw${mxl$ syv$ wxeoilsphivw0$ szivwmklx$ erh$ gsrxvegx

gsqtpmergi0$gsrwivzexmsr$qiewyviw$erh$irlergih$irzmvsrqirxep$wywxemrefmpmx}$ijjsvxw2

Xli$ Lyqer$ Vmklxw$ erh$ IWK$ vitsvx$ {ew$ tvitevih$ {mxl$ vijivirgi$ xs$ xli$ KVM$ Wxerhevhw$ vipexih$ xs$ Kirivep$ Hmwgpswyviw0$ Igsrsqmg

Xstmgw0$Irzmvsrqirxep$Xstmgw$erh$Wsgmep$Xstmgw$fewih$sr$xli$Kpsfep$Vitsvxmrk$Mrmxmexmzi0$sv$KVM0$mwwyih$f}$xli$Kpsfep$Wywxemrefmpmx}

Wxerhevhw$ Fsevh$ erh$ xli$ YR$ Kymhmrk$ Tvmrgmtpiw$ sr$ Fywmriww$ erh$ Lyqer$ Vmklxw2$ KVM$ mw$ er$ mrxivrexmsrep$ mrhitirhirx$ wxerhevhw

svkerm~exmsr$gviexih$ xs$lipt$fywmriww0$kszivrqirx$erh$sxliv$svkerm~exmsrw$yrhivwxerh$erh$gsqqyrmgexi$ls{$ xlimv$stivexmsrw$ejjigx

mwwyiw$sj$kpsfep$mqtsvxergi0$wygl$ew$lyqer$vmklxw0$gsvvytxmsr$erh$gpmqexi$glerki2$[i$lezi$vijivirgih$xli$KVM$Wxerhevhw$erh$xli$YR

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 9 of 253

Page 32: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq =367<

Kymhmrk$Tvmrgmtpiw$sr$Fywmriww$erh$Lyqer$Vmklxw$ew${i$lezi$vigskrm~ih$xli$riih$jsv$e$xverwtevirx$erh$hmwgmtpmrih$irxivtvmwi1{mhi

ettvsegl2$Mr$syv$tyvwymx$sj$xlmw$ettvsegl0${i$lezi$fikyr${mxl$xli$jspps{mrk$wix$sj$srksmrk$sfnigxmziw>

9

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 10 of 253

Page 33: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 54367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

¨ Tvszmhi$kviexiv$xverwtevirg}$jsv$syv$wxeoilsphivw$erh$xli$kirivep$tyfpmg${mxl$viwtigx$xs$syv$zevmsyw$ijjsvxw$mr$epp$syv$jegmpmxmiw

emqih$ex$viwtigxmrk$lyqer$vmklxw2

¨ Irlergi$ syv$ efmpmx}$ xs$ jpek$ tsxirxmep$ mwwyiw$ mr$ epp$ eview$ sj$ syv$ stivexmsrw$ erh$ gsqtviww$ xli$ xmqi$ mx$ xeoiw$ xs$ viwtsrh${mxl

gsvvigxmzi$qiewyviw2

¨ Ywi$ {mhip}$ eggitxih$ qixlshspskmiw$ jsv$ izepyexmrk$ tivjsvqergi$ erh$ wixxmrk$ sfnigxmziw$ jsv$ mqtvsziqirxw$ mr$ gsvtsvexi

kszivrergi0$gsvtsvexi$wsgmep$tspmg}0$irzmvsrqirxep$mqtegx$erh$irivk}$gsrwivzexmsr2

Xli$IWK$vitsvx$qe}$fi$eggiwwih$sr$syv${ifwmxi$yrhiv$&Mrziwxsvw1Pexiwx$Vitsvxw1Pexiwx$IWK$Vitsvx2&$Xli$mrjsvqexmsr$mrgpyhih$mr$xli

Lyqer$Vmklxw$erh$IWK$vitsvx$mw$rsx$mrgsvtsvexih$f}$vijivirgi$mrxs$xlmw$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O2

Fywmriww$Hizipstqirx$Szivzmi{

[i$ mrxirh$ xs$ tyvwyi$ e$ hmzivwmjmih$ kvs{xl$ wxvexik}$ f}${mrrmrk$ ri{$ gpmirxw$ erh$ gsrxvegxw0$ i|terhmrk$ syv$ kszivrqirx$ wivzmgiw

tsvxjspms$erh$tyvwymrk$wipigxmzi$eguymwmxmsr$sttsvxyrmxmiw2$Syv$tvmqev}$tsxirxmep$gywxsqivw$mrgpyhi>$kszivrqirxep$ekirgmiw$viwtsrwmfpi

jsv$psgep0$wxexi$erh$jihivep$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw$ mr$ xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw?$kszivrqirxep$ekirgmiw$ viwtsrwmfpi$ jsv$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw$ mr$Eywxvepme0

Wsyxl$Ejvmge$erh$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq?$jihivep0$wxexi$erh$psgep$kszivrqirx$ekirgmiw$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw$viwtsrwmfpi$jsv$gsqqyrmx}1

fewih$wivzmgiw$jsv$ehypx$erh$nyzirmpi$sjjirhivw?$jihivep0$wxexi$erh$psgep$kszivrqirx$ekirgmiw$viwtsrwmfpi$jsv$qsrmxsvmrk$gsqqyrmx}1

fewih$ tevspiiw0$ tvsfexmsrivw$ erh$tvixvmep$ hijirherxw?$ erh$sxliv$ jsvimkr$kszivrqirxep$ ekirgmiw2$[i$ eglmizi$svkermg$kvs{xl$ xlvsykl

gsqtixmxmzi$fmhhmrk$xlex$fikmrw${mxl$xli$mwwyergi$f}$e$kszivrqirx$ekirg}$sj$e$viuyiwx$jsv$tvstswep0$sv$VJT2$[i$tvmqevmp}$vip}$sr$xli

VJT$tvsgiww$ jsv$svkermg$kvs{xl$ mr$syv$Y2W2$erh$ mrxivrexmsrep$wigyvi$wivzmgiw$stivexmsrw$ew${ipp$ ew$ mr$syv$gsqqyrmx}$fewih$viirxv}

wivzmgiw$erh$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$wivzmgiw$fywmriww2

Jsv$syv$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw0$syv$wxexi$erh$psgep$i|tivmirgi$lew$fiir$xlex$e$tivmsh$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$:4$xs$=4$he}w$mw

kirivepp}$ viuymvih$ jvsq$ xli$ mwwyergi$ sj$ e$ viuyiwx$ jsv$ tvstswep$ xs$ xli$ wyfqmwwmsr$ sj$ syv$ viwtsrwi$ xs$ xli$ viuyiwx$ jsv$ tvstswep?$ xlex

fix{iir$sri$erh$jsyv$qsrxlw$ipetwi$fix{iir$xli$wyfqmwwmsr$sj$syv$viwtsrwi$erh$xli$ekirg}×w$e{evh$sj$e$gsrxvegx?$erh$xlex$fix{iir

sri$erh$ jsyv$qsrxlw$ipetwi$fix{iir$ xli$e{evh$sj$e$gsrxvegx$ erh$ xli$gsqqirgiqirx$sj$ jegmpmx}$gsrwxvygxmsr$sv$qerekiqirx$sj$ xli

jegmpmx}0$ew$ettpmgefpi2

Jsv$syv$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw0$syv$jihivep$i|tivmirgi$lew$fiir$xlex$e$tivmsh$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$:4$xs$=4$he}w$mw$kirivepp}

viuymvih$jvsq$xli$mwwyergi$sj$e$viuyiwx$jsv$tvstswep$xs$xli$wyfqmwwmsr$sj$syv$viwtsrwi$xs$xli$viuyiwx$jsv$tvstswep?$xlex$fix{iir$56$erh

5<$qsrxlw$ipetwi$fix{iir$xli$wyfqmwwmsr$sj$syv$viwtsrwi$erh$xli$ekirg}×w$e{evh$sj$e$gsrxvegx?$erh$xlex$fix{iir$jsyv$erh$5<${iiow

ipetwi$fix{iir$xli$e{evh$sj$e$gsrxvegx$erh$xli$gsqqirgiqirx$sj$jegmpmx}$gsrwxvygxmsr$sv$qerekiqirx$sj$xli$jegmpmx}0$ew$ettpmgefpi2

Mj$xli$psgep0$wxexi$sv$jihivep$jegmpmx}$jsv${lmgl$er$e{evh$lew$fiir$qehi$qywx$fi$gsrwxvygxih0$syv$i|tivmirgi$mw$xlex$gsrwxvygxmsr

ywyepp}$xeoiw$fix{iir$rmri$erh$68$qsrxlw$xs$gsqtpixi0$hitirhmrk$sr$xli$wm~i$erh$gsqtpi|mx}$sj$xli$tvsnigx2$Xlivijsvi0$qerekiqirx$sj

e$ri{p}$gsrwxvygxih$jegmpmx}$x}tmgepp}$gsqqirgiw$fix{iir$54$erh$6<$qsrxlw$ejxiv$xli$kszivrqirxep$ekirg}×w$e{evh2

Jsv$ xli$ wivzmgiw$ tvszmhih$f}$FM0$ psgep0$ wxexi$erh$ jihivep$ i|tivmirgi$lew$fiir$ xlex$ e$tivmsh$sj$ ettvs|mqexip}$74$ xs$=4$he}w$ mw

kirivepp}$viuymvih$jvsq$xli$mwwyergi$sj$er$VJT$sv$Mrzmxexmsr$xs$Fmh0$sv$MXF0$xs$xli$wyfqmwwmsr$sj$syv$viwtsrwi?$xlex$fix{iir$sri$erh

xlvii$qsrxlw$ipetwi$fix{iir$ xli$ wyfqmwwmsr$sj$syv$ viwtsrwi$erh$ xli$ekirg}×w$e{evh$sj$e$gsrxvegx?$ erh$ xlex$fix{iir$sri$erh$ xlvii

qsrxlw$ipetwi$fix{iir$xli$e{evh$sj$e$gsrxvegx$erh$xli$gsqqirgiqirx$sj$e$tvskveq$sv$xli$mqtpiqirxexmsr$sj$tvskveq$stivexmsrw0$ew

ettpmgefpi2

Xli$xivq$sj$syv$psgep0$wxexi$erh$jihivep$gsrxvegxw$verki$jvsq$sri$xs$jmzi$}ievw$erh$wsqi$gsrxvegxw$mrgpyhi$tvszmwmsrw$jsv$stxmsrep

viri{ep$ xivqw$ fi}srh$ xli$ mrmxmep$ gsrxvegx$ xivq2$ Gsrxvegxw$ ger0$ erh$ evi$ tivmshmgepp}0$ i|xirhih$ fi}srh$ xli$ mrmxmep$ gsrxvegx$ xivq$ erh

stxmsrep$ viri{ep$ xivqw$ xlvsykl$ epxivrexmzi$ tvsgyviqirx$ tvsgiwwiw$ mrgpyhmrk$ wspi$ wsyvgi$ nywxmjmgexmsr$ tvsgiwwiw0$ gsstivexmzi

tvsgyviqirx$zilmgpiw$erh$ekirg}$higmwmsrw$xs$ehh$i|xirwmsr$xmqi$tivmshw2

[i$fipmizi$xlex$syv$psrk$stivexmrk$lmwxsv}$erh$vityxexmsr$lezi$ievrih$yw$gvihmfmpmx}${mxl$fsxl$i|mwxmrk$erh$tvswtigxmzi$gywxsqivw

{lir$fmhhmrk$sr$ri{$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$sv${lir$viri{mrk$i|mwxmrk$gsrxvegxw2$[i$fipmizi$syv$wyggiww$mr$xli$VJT$tvsgiww

lew$viwypxih$mr$e$tmtipmri$sj$ri{$tvsnigxw${mxl$wmkrmjmgerx$viziryi$tsxirxmep2

Mr$ehhmxmsr$xs$tyvwymrk$svkermg$kvs{xl$xlvsykl$xli$VJT$tvsgiww0${i${mpp0$jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi$wipigxmzip}$gsrwmhiv$xli$jmrergmrk

erh$gsrwxvygxmsr$sj$ri{$jegmpmxmiw$sv$i|terwmsrw$ xs$i|mwxmrk$jegmpmxmiw$sr$e$wtigypexmzi$fewmw${mxlsyx$lezmrk$e$ wmkrih$gsrxvegx${mxl$e

ors{r$ gywxsqiv2$ [i$ epws$ tper$ xs$ piziveki$ syv$ i|tivmirgi$ erh$ wgepi$ sj$ wivzmgi$ sjjivmrkw$ xs$ i|terh$ xli$ verki$ sj$ tyfpmg1tvmzexi

tevxrivwlmt$ wivzmgiw$ xlex$ {i$ tvszmhi2$[i${mpp$ gsrxmryi$ xs$ tyvwyi$ wipigxih$ eguymwmxmsr$ sttsvxyrmxmiw$ mr$ syv$ gsvi$ wivzmgiw$ erh$ sxliv

kszivrqirx$wivzmgiw$eview$xlex$qiix$syv$gvmxivme$jsv$kvs{xl$erh$tvsjmxefmpmx}2$[i$lezi$irkekih$erh$mrxirh$mr$xli$jyxyvi$xs$irkeki

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 11 of 253

Page 34: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 55367<

:

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 12 of 253

Page 35: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 56367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

mrhitirhirx$gsrwypxerxw$xs$ewwmwx$yw$mr$hizipstmrk$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmt$sttsvxyrmxmiw$erh$mr$viwtsrhmrk$xs$viuyiwxw$jsv$tvstswepw0

qsrmxsvmrk$xli$pikmwpexmzi$erh$fywmriww$gpmqexi0$erh$qemrxemrmrk$vipexmsrwlmtw${mxl$i|mwxmrk$gywxsqivw2

Jegmpmx}$Hiwmkr0$Gsrwxvygxmsr$erh$Jmrergi

[i$sjjiv$ kszivrqirxep$ ekirgmiw$ gsrwypxexmsr$ erh$qerekiqirx$ wivzmgiw$ vipexmrk$ xs$ xli$hiwmkr$ erh$ gsrwxvygxmsr$sj$ ri{$ wigyvi

jegmpmxmiw$erh$xli$vihiwmkr$erh$virszexmsr$sj$sphiv$jegmpmxmiw$mrgpyhmrk$jegmpmxmiw${i$s{r0$piewi$sv$qereki$ew${ipp$ew$jegmpmxmiw${i$hs$rsx

s{r0$ piewi$ sv$ qereki2$ Hsqiwxmgepp}0$ ew$ sj$ Higiqfiv$ 750$ 645=0$ {i$ lezi$ tvszmhih$ wivzmgiw$ jsv$ xli$ hiwmkr$ erh$ gsrwxvygxmsr$ sj

ettvs|mqexip}$ 99$ jegmpmxmiw$ erh$ jsv$ xli$ vihiwmkr0$ virszexmsr$ erh$ i|terwmsr$ sj$ ettvs|mqexip}$ ;4$ jegmpmxmiw2$ Mrxivrexmsrepp}0$ ew$ sj

Higiqfiv$750$645=0${i$lezi$tvszmhih$wivzmgiw$ jsv$ xli$hiwmkr$erh$gsrwxvygxmsr$sj$55$ jegmpmxmiw$erh$ jsv$ xli$ vihiwmkr0$ virszexmsr$erh

i|terwmsr$sj$x{s$jegmpmxmiw2

Gsrxvegxw$ xs$ hiwmkr$ erh$ gsrwxvygx$ sv$ xs$ vihiwmkr$ erh$ virszexi$ jegmpmxmiw$qe}$ fi$ jmrergih$ mr$ e$ zevmix}$ sj${e}w2$Kszivrqirxep

ekirgmiw$qe}$jmrergi$xli$gsrwxvygxmsr$sj$wygl$jegmpmxmiw$xlvsykl$er}$sj$xli$jspps{mrk$qixlshw>

¨ e$sri$xmqi$kirivep$viziryi$ettvstvmexmsr$f}$xli$kszivrqirxep$ekirg}$jsv$xli$gswx$sj$xli$ri{$jegmpmx}?

¨ kirivep$sfpmkexmsr$fsrhw$xlex$evi$wigyvih$f}$imxliv$e$pmqmxih$sv$yrpmqmxih$xe|$piz}$f}$xli$mwwymrk$kszivrqirxep$irxmx}?$sv

¨ viziryi$ fsrhw$ sv$ givxmjmgexiw$ sj$ tevxmgmtexmsr$ wigyvih$ f}$ er$ erryep$ piewi$ te}qirx$ xlex$ mw$ wyfnigx$ xs$ erryep$ sv$ fm1erryep

pikmwpexmzi$ettvstvmexmsrw2

[i$qe}$epws$egx$ew$e$wsyvgi$sj$jmrergmrk$sv$ew$e$jegmpmxexsv${mxl$viwtigx$xs$xli$jmrergmrk$sj$xli$gsrwxvygxmsr$sj$e$jegmpmx}2$Mr$xliwi

gewiw0$xli$gsrwxvygxmsr$sj$wygl$jegmpmxmiw$qe}$fi$jmrergih$xlvsykl$zevmsyw$qixlshw$mrgpyhmrk$xli$jspps{mrk>

¨ jyrhw$jvsq$iuymx}$sjjivmrkw$sj$syv$wxsgo?

¨ gewl$sr$lerh$erh3sv$gewl$jps{w$jvsq$syv$stivexmsrw?

¨ fsvvs{mrkw$f}$yw$jvsq$ferow$sv$sxliv$mrwxmxyxmsrw$,{lmgl$qe}$sv$qe}$rsx$fi$wyfnigx$xs$kszivrqirx$kyeverxiiw$mr$xli$izirx$sj

gsrxvegx$xivqmrexmsr-?$

¨ jyrhw$jvsq$hifx$sjjivmrkw$sj$syv$rsxiw?$sv

¨ piewi$evverkiqirxw${mxl$xlmvh$tevxmiw2

Mj$xli$tvsnigx$mw$jmrergih$ywmrk$hmvigx$kszivrqirxep$ettvstvmexmsrw0${mxl$tvsgiihw$sj$xli$wepi$sj$fsrhw$sv$sxliv$sfpmkexmsrw$mwwyih

tvmsv$ xs$ xli$ e{evh$ sj$ xli$ tvsnigx0$ xlir$ jmrergmrk$ mw$ mr$ tpegi${lir$ xli$ gsrxvegx$ vipexmrk$ xs$ xli$ gsrwxvygxmsr$ sv$ virszexmsr$ tvsnigx$ mw

i|igyxih2$Mj$xli$tvsnigx$mw$jmrergih$ywmrk$tvsnigx1wtigmjmg$xe|1i|iqtx$fsrhw$sv$sxliv$sfpmkexmsrw0$xli$gsrwxvygxmsr$gsrxvegx$mw$kirivepp}

wyfnigx$xs$xli$wepi$sj$wygl$fsrhw$sv$sfpmkexmsrw2$Kirivepp}0$wyfwxerxmep$i|tirhmxyviw$jsv$gsrwxvygxmsr${mpp$rsx$fi$qehi$sr$wygl$e$tvsnigx

yrxmp$ xli$ xe|1i|iqtx$fsrhw$sv$ sxliv$ sfpmkexmsrw$ evi$ wsph?$ erh0$ mj$ wygl$fsrhw$sv$ sfpmkexmsrw$evi$ rsx$ wsph0$ gsrwxvygxmsr$erh$ xlivijsvi0

qerekiqirx$ sj$ xli$ jegmpmx}0$qe}$ imxliv$ fi$ hipe}ih$yrxmp$ epxivrexmzi$ jmrergmrk$ mw$ tvsgyvih$sv$ xli$hizipstqirx$sj$ xli$tvsnigx${mpp$ fi

wywtirhih$sv$irxmvip}$gergipih2$Mj$xli$tvsnigx$mw$wipj1jmrergih$f}$yw0$xlir$jmrergmrk$mw$kirivepp}$mr$tpegi$tvmsv$xs$xli$gsqqirgiqirx$sj

gsrwxvygxmsr2

Yrhiv$syv$gsrwxvygxmsr$erh$hiwmkr$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw0${i$kirivepp}$ekvii$xs$fi$viwtsrwmfpi$jsv$szivepp$tvsnigx$hizipstqirx

erh$gsqtpixmsr2$[i$x}tmgepp}$egx$ew$xli$tvmqev}$hizipstiv$sr$gsrwxvygxmsr$gsrxvegxw$jsv$jegmpmxmiw$erh$wyfgsrxvegx${mxl$fsrhih$Rexmsrep

erh3sv$Vikmsrep$Hiwmkr$Fymph$Gsrxvegxsvw2$[livi$tswwmfpi0${i$ wyfgsrxvegx${mxl$gsrwxvygxmsr$ gsqtermiw$ xlex${i$lezi${svoih${mxl

tvizmsywp}2$[i$qeoi$ ywi$ sj$ er$ mr1lsywi$ wxejj$ sj$ evglmxigxw$ erh$ stivexmsrep$ i|tivxw$ jvsq$ zevmsyw$ wivzmgi$ hmwgmtpmriw$ ,i2k2$ wigyvmx}0

qihmgep$wivzmgi0$jssh$wivzmgi0$tvskveqw$erh$jegmpmx}$qemrxirergi-$ew$tevx$sj$xli$xieq$xlex$tevxmgmtexiw$jvsq$gsrgitxyep$hiwmkr$xlvsykl

jmrep$gsrwxvygxmsr$sj$xli$tvsnigx2$Xlmw$wxejj$gssvhmrexiw$epp$ewtigxw$sj$xli$hizipstqirx${mxl$wyfgsrxvegxsvw$erh$tvszmhiw$wmxi1wtigmjmg

wivzmgiw2

[lir$hiwmkrmrk$e$jegmpmx}0$syv$evglmxigxw$ywi0${mxl$ettvstvmexi$qshmjmgexmsrw0$tvsxsx}ti$hiwmkrw${i$lezi$ywih$mr$hizipstmrk$tvmsv

tvsnigxw2$[i$fipmizi$ xlex$ xli$ywi$sj$ xliwi$hiwmkrw$epps{w$yw$ xs$ vihygi$ xli$tsxirxmep$sj$gswx$szivvyrw$erh$gsrwxvygxmsr$hipe}w$erh$ xs

vihygi$ xli$ ryqfiv$ sj$ gsvvigxmsrep$ sjjmgivw$ viuymvih$ xs$ tvszmhi$ wigyvmx}$ ex$ e$ jegmpmx}0$ xlyw$ gsrxvsppmrk$ gswxw$ fsxl$ xs$ gsrwxvygx$ erh$ xs

qereki$xli$jegmpmx}2$Syv$jegmpmx}$hiwmkrw$epws$qemrxemr$wigyvmx}$figeywi$xli}$mrgviewi$xli$evie$yrhiv$hmvigx$wyvzimppergi$f}$gsvvigxmsrep

sjjmgivw$erh$qeoi$ywi$sj$ehhmxmsrep$ipigxvsrmg$wyvzimppergi2

Xli$jspps{mrk$xefpi$wixw$jsvxl$syv$gyvvirx$i|terwmsr$erh$hizipstqirx$tvsnigxw$erh$xlimv$wxekiw$sj$gsqtpixmsr$jsv$xli$Gsqter}+w

jegmpmxmiw>$

;

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 13 of 253

Page 36: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 57367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Jegmpmxmiw$Yrhiv$GsrwxvygxmsrRyqfiv$sj

Fihw $ $

IwxmqexihGsqtpixmsr

Hexi $ Gywxsqiv $ Jmrergmrk

Nyrii$Gsvvigxmsrep$Girxvi

8<= $ $ U5$6464 $

Ri{$Wsyxl$[epiw

Gsvvigxmzi$Wivzmgiw $

Ri{$Wsyxl$[epiw

Gsvvigxmzi$Wivzmgiw

Jypleq$Gsvvigxmsrep$Girxvi

57; $ $ U7$6464 $

Wxexi$sj$Zmgxsvme0

Eywxvepme $ KIS

Gsqtixmxmzi$Wxvirkxlw

Piehmrk$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$Tvszmhiv$Yrmuyip}$Tswmxmsrih$xs$Sjjiv$e$Gsrxmryyq$sj$Gevi

[i$evi$xli$wigsrh$pevkiwx$tvszmhiv$sj$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmt$wigyvi$wivzmgiw$erh$tvsgiwwmrk$girxiv$jegmpmxmiw${svph{mhi$erh

xli$pevkiwx$tvszmhiv$sj$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$viirxv}$wivzmgiw0$}syxl$wivzmgiw$erh$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$wivzmgiw$mr$xli$Y2W2$wigyvi$wivzmgiw

wigxsv2$[i$fipmizi$xliwi$piehmrk$qevoix$tswmxmsrw$erh$syv$hmzivwi$erh$gsqtpiqirxev}$wivzmgi$sjjivmrkw$irefpi$yw$xs$qiix$xli$kvs{mrk

hiqerh$ jvsq$ syv$ gpmirxw$ jsv$ gsqtvilirwmzi$ wivzmgiw$ xlvsyklsyx$ xli$ irxmvi$ gsvvigxmsrw$ pmjig}gpi2$ Syv$ gsrxmryyq$ sj$ gevi$ tpexjsvq

irefpiw$ yw$ xs$ tvszmhi$ gsrwmwxirg}$ erh$ gsrxmrymx}$ mr$ gewi$ qerekiqirx0$ {lmgl$ {i$ fipmizi$ viwypxw$ mr$ e$ lmkliv$ uyepmx}$ sj$ gevi$ jsv

mrhmzmhyepw$ mr$ syv$ gevi0$ vihygiw$ vigmhmzmwq0$ ps{ivw$ szivepp$ gswxw$ jsv$ syv$ gpmirxw0$ mqtvsziw$ tyfpmg$ wejix}$ erh$ jegmpmxexiw$ wyggiwwjyp

vimrxikvexmsr$sj$mrhmzmhyepw$fego$mrxs$wsgmix}2

Exxvegxmzi$VIMX$Tvsjmpi

[i$fipmizi$xli$oi}$glevegxivmwxmgw$sj$syv$fywmriww$qeoi$yw$e$lmklp}$exxvegxmzi$VIMX2$[i$evi$mr$e$viep$iwxexi$mrxirwmzi$mrhywxv}2$Wmrgi

syv$ mrgitxmsr0${i$lezi$jmrergih$erh$hizipstih$hs~irw$sj$ jegmpmxmiw2$[i$lezi$e$hmzivwmjmih$wix$sj$ mrziwxqirx$kvehi$gywxsqivw$ mr$ xli

jsvq$sj$kszivrqirx$ ekirgmiw${lmgl$evi$ viuymvih$ xs$te}$yw$sr$ xmqi$f}$ pe{2$[i$lezi$lmwxsvmgepp}$ i|tivmirgih$gywxsqiv$ vixirxmsr$ mr

i|giww$sj$=4)2$Syv$wxvsrk$erh$tvihmgxefpi$sggyterg}$vexiw$kirivexi$e$wxefpi$erh$wywxemrefpi$wxvieq$sj$viziryi2$[i$fipmizi$xlmw$wxvieq

sj$viziryi$gsqfmrih${mxl$syv$ps{$qemrxirergi$getmxep$i|tirhmxyvi$viuymviqirx$xverwpexiw$mrxs$wxieh}$tvihmgxefpi$gewl$jps{2$Xli$VIMX

wxvygxyvi$epws$epps{w$yw$xs$tyvwyi$kvs{xl$sttsvxyrmxmiw$hyi$xs$xli$getmxep$mrxirwmzi$rexyvi$sj$syv$fywmriww2

Pevki$Wgepi$Stivexsv${mxl$Rexmsrep$Tviwirgi

[i$stivexi$ xli$ wizirxl$ pevkiwx$ gsvvigxmsrep$ w}wxiq$ mr$ xli$Y2W2$ f}$ ryqfiv$ sj$ fihw0$ mrgpyhmrk$ xli$ jihivep$ kszivrqirx$ erh$ epp

94$wxexiw2$[i$gyvvirxp}$lezi$ wigyvi$ wivzmgiw$stivexmsrw$ mr$ettvs|mqexip}$77$wxexiw$erh$sjjiv$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$wivzmgiw$ mr$iziv}

wxexi2$ Mr$ ehhmxmsr0$ {i$ lezi$ i|xirwmzi$ i|tivmirgi$ mr$ szivepp$ jegmpmx}$ stivexmsrw0$ mrgpyhmrk$ wxejj$ vigvymxqirx0$ ehqmrmwxvexmsr0$ jegmpmx}

qemrxirergi0$jssh$wivzmgi0$wigyvmx}0$erh$mr$xli$wytivzmwmsr0$xviexqirx$erh$ihygexmsr$sj$mrhmzmhyepw${mxlmr$syv$gevi2$[i$fipmizi$syv$wm~i

erh$fviehxl$sj$wivzmgi$sjjivmrkw$irefpi$yw$xs$kirivexi$igsrsqmiw$sj$wgepi${lmgl$qe|mqm~i$syv$ijjmgmirgmiw$erh$epps{w$yw$xs$teww$epsrk

gswx$wezmrkw$xs$syv$gpmirxw2$Syv$rexmsrep$tviwirgi$epws$tswmxmsrw$yw$xs$fmh$sr$erh$hizipst$ri{$jegmpmxmiw$egvsww$xli$Y2W2

Psrk1Xivq$Vipexmsrwlmtw${mxl$Lmkl1Uyepmx}$Kszivrqirx$Gywxsqivw

[i$lezi$hizipstih$psrk1xivq$vipexmsrwlmtw${mxl$syv$jihivep0$wxexi$erh$sxliv$kszivrqirxep$gywxsqivw0${lmgl${i$fipmizi$irlergi

syv$ efmpmx}$ xs${mr$ ri{$ gsrxvegxw$ erh$ vixemr$ i|mwxmrk$ fywmriww2$[i$ lezi$ tvszmhih$ wigyvi$qerekiqirx$ wivzmgiw$ xs$ xli$Yrmxih$ Wxexiw

Jihivep$Kszivrqirx$ jsv$ 77$}ievw0$ xli$Wxexi$ sj$Gepmjsvrme$ jsv$76$}ievw0$ tvmsv$ xs$ xli$ri{$Gepmjsvrme$ pe{$EF$76$ksmrk$ mrxs$ ijjigx$ sr

Neryev}$50$64640$xli$Wxexi$sj$Xi|ew$jsv$ettvs|mqexip}$76$}ievw0$zevmsyw$Eywxvepmer$wxexi$kszivrqirx$irxmxmiw$jsv$6<$}ievw$erh$xli$Wxexi

sj$Jpsvmhe$jsv$ettvs|mqexip}$6:$}ievw2$Xliwi$gywxsqivw$eggsyrxih$jsv$ettvs|mqexip}$:=)$sj$syv$gsrwspmhexih$viziryiw$jsv$xli$jmwgep

}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=2

Vigyvvmrk$Viziryi${mxl$Wxvsrk$Gewl$Jps{

Syv$viziryi$fewi$mw$hivmzih$jvsq$syv$psrk1xivq$gywxsqiv$vipexmsrwlmtw0${mxl$gsrxvegx$viri{ep$vexiw$erh$jegmpmx}$sggyterg}$vexiw$fsxl

ettvs|mqexmrk$=4)$sziv$xli$tewx$jmzi$}ievw2$[i$lezi$fiir$efpi$xs$i|terh$syv$viziryi$fewi$f}$gsrxmrymrk$xs$vimrziwx$syv$wxvsrk

stivexmrk$gewl$jps{$mrxs$i|terwmsrev}$tvsnigxw$erh$xlvsykl$wxvexikmg$eguymwmxmsrw$xlex$tvszmhi$wgepi$erh$jyvxliv

<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 14 of 253

Page 37: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 58367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

irlergi$syv$wivzmgi$sjjivmrkw2$Syv$gsrwspmhexih$viziryiw$lezi$kvs{r$jvsq$(<;;$qmppmsr$mr$644;$xs$(629$fmppmsr$mr$645=2$[i$i|tigx$syv

stivexmrk$gewl$jps{$xs$fi${ipp$mr$i|giww$sj$syv$erxmgmtexih$erryep$qemrxirergi$getmxep$i|tirhmxyvi$riihw0${lmgl${syph$tvszmhi$yw

wmkrmjmgerx$jpi|mfmpmx}$jsv$kvs{xl$mr$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw0$jyxyvi$hmzmhirh$te}qirxw$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$stivexmrk$ew$e$VIMX0$eguymwmxmsrw

erh3sv$xli$vite}qirx$sj$mrhifxihriww2

Wm~iefpi$Mrxivrexmsrep$Fywmriww

Syv$ mrxivrexmsrep$ mrjvewxvygxyvi0$ {lmgl$ pizivekiw$ syv$ stivexmsrep$ i|gippirgi$ mr$ xli$ Y2W20$ epps{w$ yw$ xs$ ekkviwwmzip}$ xevkix$ jsvimkr

sttsvxyrmxmiw$ xlex$ syv$ Y2W2$ fewih$ gsqtixmxsvw$ {mxlsyx$ szivwiew$ stivexmsrw$ qe}$ lezi$ hmjjmgypx}$ tyvwymrk2$ [i$ gyvvirxp}$ lezi

mrxivrexmsrep$stivexmsrw$mr$Eywxvepme0$Wsyxl$Ejvmge$erh$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq2$Syv$mrxivrexmsrep$wivzmgiw$fywmriww0$mrgpyhmrk$syv$jegmpmx}

gsrwxvygxmsr$ erh$ hiwmkr$ fywmriww$ gyvvirxp}$ mr$ Eywxvepme0$ kirivexih$ ettvs|mqexip}$ (6:624$ qmppmsr$ sj$ viziryiw0$ vitviwirxmrk

ettvs|mqexip}$55)$sj$syv$gsrwspmhexih$viziryiw$jsv$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=2$Mrgpyhih$mr$syv$mrxivrexmsrep$viziryiw$mr$645;

evi$ gsrwxvygxmsr$ viziryiw$ vipexih$ xs$syv$ tvsnigx$ mr$Vezirlepp0$Eywxvepme${lmgl$ evi$ tviwirxih$ mr$ syv$Jegmpmx}$Hiwmkr$*$Gsrwxvygxmsr

wikqirx2$Gsrwxvygxmsr$sj$xli$jegmpmx}${ew$gsqtpixih$hyvmrk$xli$jsyvxl$uyevxiv$sj$645;2$Mrgpyhih$mr$syv$mrxivrexmsrep$viziryiw$mr$645=

erh$645<$evi$gsrwxvygxmsr$viziryiw$vipexih$xs$xli$i|terwmsr$sj$syv$Jypleq$jegmpmx}$mr$Zmgxsvme0$Eywxvepme${lmgl$evi$epws$tviwirxih$mr

syv$Jegmpmx}$Hiwmkr$*$Gsrwxvygxmsr$ wikqirx2$[i$fipmizi${i$ evi${ipp$ tswmxmsrih$ xs$ gsrxmryi$firijmxmrk$ jvsq$ jsvimkr$kszivrqirxw×

mrmxmexmziw$xs$irxiv$mrxs$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw$jsv$wigyvi$wivzmgiw2

I|tivmirgih0$Tvszir$Wirmsv$Qerekiqirx$Xieq

Syv$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$erh$jsyrhiv0$Kisvki$G2$^spi}0$Tl2H20$lew$pih$syv$Gsqter}$jsv$79$}ievw$erh$lew$iwxefpmwlih$e$xvego

vigsvh$sj$kvs{xl$erh$tvsjmxefmpmx}2$Yrhiv$lmw$piehivwlmt0$syv$erryep$gsrwspmhexih$viziryiw$jvsq$stivexmsrw$lezi$kvs{r$jvsq

(8424$qmppmsr$mr$5==5$xs$(629$fmppmsr$mr$645=2$Hv2$^spi}$mw$sri$sj$xli$tmsriivw$sj$xli$mrhywxv}0$lezmrk$hizipstih$erh$stirih${lex${i

fipmizi$xs$fi$sri$sj$xli$jmvwx$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmt$wigyvi$wivzmgiw$jegmpmxmiw$mr$xli$Y2W2$mr$5=<:2$Syv$Glmij$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv0$Fvmer

V2$Izerw0$lew$fiir${mxl$syv$Gsqter}$jsv$sziv$5=$}ievw$erh$pih$syv$gsrzivwmsr$xs$e$VIMX$ew${ipp$ew$xli$mrxikvexmsr$sj$syv$vigirx

eguymwmxmsrw$erh$jmrergmrk$egxmzmxmiw2$Syv$xst$wizir$wirmsv$i|igyxmziw$lezi$er$eziveki$xiryvi${mxl$syv$Gsqter}$sj$sziv$54$}ievw2

Fywmriww$Wxvexikmiw

Tvszmhi$Lmkl$Uyepmx}0$Gsqtvilirwmzi$Wivzmgiw$erh$Gswx$Wezmrkw$Xlvsyklsyx$xli$Gsvvigxmsrw$Pmjig}gpi

Syv$sfnigxmzi$mw$xs$tvszmhi$jihivep0$wxexi$erh$psgep$kszivrqirxep$ekirgmiw${mxl$e$gsqtvilirwmzi$sjjivmrk$sj$lmkl$uyepmx}0$iwwirxmep

wivzmgiw$ex$e$ps{iv$gswx$xler$xli}$xliqwipziw$gsyph$eglmizi2$[i$fipmizi$kszivrqirx$ekirgmiw$jegmrk$fyhkixev}$gsrwxvemrxw${mpp

mrgviewmrkp}$wiio$xs$syxwsyvgi$e$kviexiv$tvstsvxmsr$sj$xlimv$gsvvigxmsrep$riihw$xs$vipmefpi$tvszmhivw$xlex$ger$irlergi$uyepmx}$sj$wivzmgi

ex$e$vihygih$gswx2$[i$fipmizi$syv$i|terhih$erh$hmzivwmjmih$wivzmgi$sjjivmrkw$yrmuyip}$tswmxmsr$yw$xs$fyrhpi$syv$lmkl$uyepmx}$wivzmgiw

erh$tvszmhi$e$gsqtvilirwmzi$gsrxmryyq$sj$gevi$jsv$syv$gpmirxw0${lmgl${i$fipmizi${mpp$pieh$xs$ps{iv$gswx$syxgsqiw$jsv$syv$gpmirxw$erh

pevkiv$wgepi$fywmriww$sttsvxyrmxmiw$jsv$yw2

Qemrxemr$Hmwgmtpmrih$Stivexmrk$Ettvsegl

[i$vijvemr$jvsq$tyvwymrk$gsrxvegxw$xlex${i$hs$rsx$fipmizi${mpp$}miph$exxvegxmzi$tvsjmx$qevkmrw$mr$vipexmsr$xs$xli$ewwsgmexih

stivexmsrep$vmwow2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$epxlsykl${i$irkeki$mr$jegmpmx}$hizipstqirx$jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi${mxlsyx$lezmrk$e$gsvviwtsrhmrk

qerekiqirx$gsrxvegx$e{evh$mr$tpegi0${i$irhiezsv$xs$hs$ws$srp}${livi${i$lezi$hixivqmrih$xlex$xlivi$mw$qihmyq$xs$psrk1xivq$gpmirx

hiqerh$jsv$e$jegmpmx}$mr$xlex$kiskvetlmgep$evie2$[i$lezi$epws$ipigxih$rsx$xs$irxiv$givxemr$mrxivrexmsrep$qevoixw${mxl$e$lmwxsv}$sj

igsrsqmg$erh$tspmxmgep$mrwxefmpmx}2$[i$fipmizi$xlex$syv$wxvexik}$sj$iqtlewm~mrk$ps{iv$vmwo$erh$lmkliv$tvsjmx$sttsvxyrmxmiw$liptw$yw$xs

gsrwmwxirxp}$hipmziv$wxvsrk$stivexmsrep$tivjsvqergi0$ps{iv$syv$gswxw$erh$mrgviewi$syv$szivepp$tvsjmxefmpmx}2

Tyvwyi$Mrxivrexmsrep$Kvs{xl$Sttsvxyrmxmiw

Ew$e$kpsfep$tvszmhiv$sj$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmt$wigyvi$wivzmgiw0${i$evi$efpi$xs$getmxepm~i$sr$sttsvxyrmxmiw$xs$stivexi$i|mwxmrk$sv

ri{$jegmpmxmiw$sr$filepj$sj$jsvimkr$kszivrqirxw2$[i$lezi$wiir$mrgviewih$fywmriww$hizipstqirx$sttsvxyrmxmiw$mrgpyhmrk$sttsvxyrmxmiw$xs

gvsww$wipp$syv$i|terhih$wivzmgi$sjjivmrkw$mr$vigirx$}ievw$mr$xli$mrxivrexmsrep$qevoixw$mr${lmgl${i$stivexi$erh$evi$gyvvirxp}$i|tpsvmrk

sttsvxyrmxmiw$jsv$wizivep$ri{$tvsnigxw2$[i${mpp$gsrxmryi$xs$egxmzip}$fmh$sr$ri{$mrxivrexmsrep$tvsnigxw$mr$syv$gyvvirx$qevoixw$erh$mr$ri{

qevoixw$xlex$jmx$syv$xevkix$tvsjmpi$jsv$tvsjmxefmpmx}$erh$stivexmsrep$vmwo2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 15 of 253

Page 38: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 59367<

=

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 16 of 253

Page 39: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5:367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Wipigxmzip}$Tyvwyi$Eguymwmxmsr$Sttsvxyrmxmiw

[i$mrxirh$xs$gsrxmryi$xs$wyttpiqirx$syv$svkermg$kvs{xl$f}$wipigxmzip}$mhirxmj}mrk0$eguymvmrk$erh$mrxikvexmrk$fywmriwwiw$xlex$jmx

syv$wxvexikmg$sfnigxmziw$erh$irlergi$syv$kiskvetlmg$tpexjsvq$erh$wivzmgi$sjjivmrkw2$Wmrgi$64490$erh$mrgpyhmrk$xli$eguymwmxmsrw$sj

Gsqqyrmx}$Ihygexmsr$Girxivw$,&GIG&-0$Tvsxsgsp$Gvmqmrep$Nywxmgi0$Mrg2$,&Tvsxsgsp&-0$Wsfivpmro0$Mrg2$,&Wsfivpmro&-$erh$xli$gsvvigxmsrep

erh$hixirxmsr$jegmpmxmiw$sj$PGW$Gsvvigxmsrw$Wivzmgiw0$Mrg2$,&PGW$Jegmpmxmiw&$sv$&PGW&-0${i$lezi$gsqtpixih$xir$eguymwmxmsrw$jsv$xsxep

gsrwmhivexmsr0$mrgpyhmrk$hifx$ewwyqih0$mr$i|giww$sj$(624$fmppmsr2$Syv$qerekiqirx$xieq$yxmpm~iw$e$hmwgmtpmrih$ettvsegl$xs$erep}~i$erh

izepyexi$eguymwmxmsr$sttsvxyrmxmiw0${lmgl${i$fipmizi$lew$gsrxvmfyxih$xs$syv$wyggiww$mr$gsqtpixmrk$erh$mrxikvexmrk$syv$eguymwmxmsrw2

Jegmpmxmiw$erh$He}$Vitsvxmrk$Girxivw

Xli$jspps{mrk$xefpi$wyqqevm~iw$givxemr$mrjsvqexmsr${mxl$viwtigx$xs>$,m-$Y2W2$erh$mrxivrexmsrep$wigyvi$wivzmgiw$jegmpmxmiw?

,mm-$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$wivzmgiw$jegmpmxmiw?$erh$,mmm-$viwmhirxmep$erh$rsr1viwmhirxmep$}syxl$wivzmgiw$jegmpmxmiw2$Xli$mrjsvqexmsr$mr$xli$xefpi

mrgpyhiw$xli$jegmpmxmiw$xlex${i$,sv$e$wyfwmhmev}$sv$nsmrx$zirxyvi$sj$KIS-$s{rih0$stivexih$yrhiv$e$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegx0$leh$er

ekviiqirx$xs$tvszmhi$wivzmgiw0$leh$er$e{evh$xs$qereki$sv${ew$mr$xli$tvsgiww$sj$gsrwxvygxmrk$sv$i|terhmrk$hyvmrk$xli$}iev$irhih

Higiqfiv$750$645=>$

Jegmpmx}$Reqi$*Psgexmsrccccccc Getegmx},5- $

Tvmqev}Gywxsqiv $

Jegmpmx}X}ti $

Wigyvmx}Pizip $

Gsqqirgiqirxsj$GyvvirxGsrxvegx$,6- $

FewiTivmsh $

Viri{epStxmsrw $

QerekihPiewih3S{rih

Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$Ó$[iwxivr$Vikmsr>

Ehiperxs$MGI$TvsgiwwmrkGirxiv0$Ehiperxs0$GE$,7-

50=84 $ MGI $JihivepHixirxmsr $

Qmrmqyq3Qihmyq $ Higiqfiv$645= $ 9$}ievw $ X{s0$9$}ievw $ S{rih

Epleqfve$Gmx}$Nemp0$PswErkipiw0$GE

;5 $Gmx}$sj

Epleqfve $ Gmx}$Nemp $Epp

Pizipw $ Nyp}$645: $ 5$}iev $Jmzi0$Sri

]iev $ Qerekih

Eyvsve3GI$TvsgiwwmrkGirxiv$Eyvsve0$GS 50976

$MGI$3$YWQW

$JihivepHixirxmsr $

Epp$Pizipw$

Witxiqfiv$64553Sgxsfiv$6456 $

6$}ievw$36}ievw $

Jsyv0$X{s1}iev$3$Jsyv0X{s1}iev $

S{rih

Feph{mr$Tevo$Gmx}$Nemp0Feph{mr$Tevo0$GE

76 $Psw$Erkipiw

Gsyrx} $ Gmx}$Nemp $Epp

Pizipw $ Nyp}$6447 $ 7$}ievw $Tivtixyep0Xlvii1}iev $ Qerekih

Girxvep$Evm~sreGsvvigxmsrep$erhVilefmpmxexmsr$Jegmpmx}Jpsvirgi0$E^

506<4

$E^$HSG

$

Wxexi$Wi|Sjjirhiv

Gsvvigxmsrep $

Qmrmqyq3Qihmyq

$

Higiqfiv644:

$54$}ievw

$

X{s0$Jmzi1}iev

$Qerekih

Girxvep$Zeppi}$Erri|QgJevperh0$GE

;44 $ Mhpi $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ S{rih

Hiwivx$Zmi{$Erri|Ehiperxs0$GE$,:- ;44

$GHGV

$

WxexiGsvvigxmsrepJegmpmx} $

Qihmyq$

Nyp}$645<$

5$}iev0$<qsrxlw $

Rsri$

S{rih

Hs{ri}$Gmx}$Nemp$PswErkipiw0$GE 77

$

Psw$ErkipiwGsyrx}

$

Gmx}$Nemp

$

EppPizipw

$

Rsziqfiv$6458

$

7$}ievw

$

X{s0$Sri1}iev0$tpyw$sriqsrxl0$tpywSri1x{sqsrxl $

Qerekih

54

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 17 of 253

Page 40: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5;367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Jegmpmx}$Reqi$*Psgexmsrccccccc Getegmx},5- $

Tvmqev}Gywxsqiv $

Jegmpmx}X}ti $

Wigyvmx}Pizip $

Gsqqirgiqirxsj$GyvvirxGsrxvegx$,6- $

FewiTivmsh $

Viri{epStxmsrw $

QerekihPiewih3S{rih

Ip$Girxvs$HixirxmsrJegmpmx}0$GE 956

$YWQW

$

JihivepHixirxmsr

$Qihmyq

$Higiqfiv$645=

$6$}ievw

$

Xlvii0$X{s1}iev$stxmsrw0tpyw$sri0

rmri1qsrxl $Qerekih

Jpsvirgi$[iwx$Gsvvigxmsreperh$VilefmpmxexmsrJpsvirgi0$E^

;94$

E^$HSG$

Wxexi$HYM3VXG

Gsvvigxmsrep $Qmrmqyq

$Sgxsfiv6446 $

54$}ievw$

X{s0$Jmzi1}iev $

Qerekih

Jsrxere$Gmx}$Nemp$PswErkipiw0$GE

69 $Psw$Erkipiw

Gsyrx} $ Gmx}$Nemp $Epp

Pizipw $ Nyp}$645= $ Tivtixyep $ Rsri $ Qerekih

Kevhir$Kvszi$Gmx}$NempPsw$Erkipiw0$GE

5:$

Psw$ErkipiwGsyrx} $

Gmx}$Nemp$

EppPizipw $

Nyp}$6459$

7$}ievw$

Yrpmqmxih0TivtixyepXlvii1]iev $

Qerekih

Ksphir$Wxexi$Erri|QgJevperh0$GE$,:-

;44 $ GHGV $Wxexi

Gsvvigxmsrep $ Qihmyq $ Nyp}$645< $5$}iev0$54qsrxlw $ Rsri $ S{rih

Kyehepyti$Gsyrx}Gsvvigxmsrep$Jegmpmx}$WerxeVswe0$RQ$,7-

:44$

RQGH$1$MKE$

Psgep3WxexiGsvvigxmsrep $

Qihmyq$

Neryev}5=== $

Tivtixyep$

Rsri$

S{rih

Omrkqer$Gsvvigxmsrep$erhVilefmpmxexmsr$jegmpmx}0Omrkqer0$E^

70844$

E^$HSG$

WxexiGsvvigxmsrepJegmpmx} $

Qmrmqyq3Qihmyq $

Neryev}$644<$

54$}ievw$

X{s0$Jmzi1}iev $

Qerekih

Pie$Gsyrx}$GsvvigxmsrepJegmpmx}$Lsffw0$RQ$,7-

50644 $ RQGH$1$MKE $Psgep3WxexiGsvvigxmsrep $ Qihmyq $ Neryev}$5=== $ Tivtixyep $ Rsri $ S{rih

QgJevperh$JiqepiGsqqyrmx}$Viirxv}Jegmpmx}$QgJevperh0$GE

744$

GHGV$

WxexiGsvvigxmsrep $

Qmrmqyq$

Nyp}$645<$

9$}ievw$

Rsri$

S{rih

Qiwe$Zivhi$MGITvsgiwwmrk$GirxivFeoivwjmiph0$GE$,7-

844$

MGI$

WxexiGsvvigxmsrep $

Qmrmqyq$

Higiqfiv$645=$

9$]ievw$

X{s0$Jmzi}iev $

S{rih

Qsrxifipps$Gmx}$Nemp$PswErkipiw0$GE

79

$

Psw$ErkipiwGsyrx}

$Gmx}$Nemp

$

EppPizipw

$Nyp}$6458

$6$]ievw

$

Sri0$X{s1}iev0$TpywSri0$X{s1

}iev $Qerekih

Rsvxl{iwx$MGI$TvsgiwwmrkGirxiv$Xegsqe0$[E

509;9 $ MGI $JihivepHixirxmsr $

EppPizipw $ Witxiqfiv$6459 $ 5$]iev $

Rmri0$Sri1]iev $ S{rih

Srxevms$Gmx}$Nemp$PswErkipiw0$GE

88 $Psw$Erkipiw

Gsyrx} $ Gmx}$Nemp $Er}Pizip $ Nyp}$6458 $ 7$]ievw $

X{s0$Xlvii1}iev $ Qerekih

Tlsirm|$[iwx$Gsvvigxmsreperh$VilefmpmxexmsrTlsirm|0$E^

944$

E^$HSG$

Wxexi$H[MGsvvigxmsrep $

Qmrmqyq$

Nyp}$6446$

54$}ievw$

X{s0$Jmzi1}iev $

Qerekih

[iwxivr$Vikmsr$HixirxmsrJegmpmx}$Wer$Hmiks0$GE

;;4 $ YWQW $JihivepHixirxmsr $ Qe|mqyq $ Rsziqfiv$645; $

5$]iev0$54Qsrxlw $

Jsyv0$X{s1}iev $ Piewih

55

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 18 of 253

Page 41: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5<367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Jegmpmx}$Reqi$*Psgexmsrccccccc Getegmx},5- $

Tvmqev}Gywxsqiv $

Jegmpmx}X}ti $

Wigyvmx}Pizip $

Gsqqirgiqirxsj$GyvvirxGsrxvegx$,6- $

FewiTivmsh $

Viri{epStxmsrw $

QerekihPiewih3S{rih

Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$Ó$Girxvep$Vikmsr>

Fmk$Wtvmrk$GsvvigxmsrepJegmpmx}$Fmk$Wtvmrk0$X\

50;76 $ FST $Jihivep

Gsvvigxmsrep $ Qihmyq $Higiqfiv

645; $ 6$]ievw $Imklx0$Sri

]iev $ S{rih

Jpmklxpmri$GsvvigxmsrepJegmpmx}0$X\

50<44 $ FST $Jihivep

Gsvvigxmsrep $ Qihmyq $ Higiqfiv$645; $ 6$]ievw $Imklx0$Sri

]iev $ S{rih

Fvssow$Gsyrx}$HixirxmsrGirxiv0$X\$,7- :96

$YWQW$1$MKE

$

Psgep$*JihivepHixirxmsr $

Qihmyq$

Qevgl$6457$

Tivtixyep$

Rsri$

S{rih

Girxvep$Xi|ew$HixirxmsrJegmpmx}$Wer$Erxsrms0$X\,7-

:<<$

YWQW$1$MKE$

Psgep$*JihivepHixirxmsr $

Qmrmqyq3Qihmyq $

Sgxsfiv$645:$

Tivtixyep$

Rsri$

Qerekih

Gsewxep$Firh$HixirxmsrGirxiv0X\$,7- 505;:

$YWQW$1$MKE

$

Psgep$*JihivepHixirxmsr $

Qihmyq$

Nyp}$6456$

Tivtixyep$

Rsri$

S{rih

Iekpi$Teww$GsvvigxmsrepJegmpmx}0$Iekpi$Teww0$X\ ::5

$MH$HSG

$

Psgep$*JihivepHixirxmsr $

Qihmyq$

Sgxsfiv$645<$

6$}ievw$

Rsri$

S{rih

Iewx$Lmpheks$HixirxmsrGirxiv$,7- 50744

$YWQW$1$MKE

$

Psgep$*JihivepHixirxmsr $

Qihmyq$

Nyp}$6456$

Tivtixyep$

Rsri$

S{rih

Kviex$Tpemrw$GsvvigxmsrepJegmpmx}$Lmrxsr0$SO 50=84

$

FST

$

JihivepGsvvigxmsrep

$

Qmrmqyq

$

Nyri$6459

$

9$}ievw

$

Jmzi0$Sri1]iev$TpywSri$Wm|1Qsrxl

I|xirwmsr $

S{rih

Nsi$Gsvpi}$TvsgiwwmrkGirxiv$Gsrvsi0$X\ 5095;

$YWQW$3$MGI

$Psgep

Gsvvigxmsrep $Qihmyq

$

Nyp}644<3Witxiqfiv

645< $Tivtixyep39

]ievw $Rsri3Jmzi1

}iev $S{rih

Oevriw$Hixirxmsr$Jegmpmx}Oevriw$Gmx}0$X\$,7-

:;=$

YWQW$1$MKE$

Psgep$*JihivepHixirxmsr $

EppPizipw $

Jifvyev}$5==<$

Tivtixyep$

Rsri$

S{rih

Oevriw$Gsyrx}$Jeqmp}Viwmhirxmep$Girxiv0X\$,7-

5059< $ MGI$1$MKE $JihivepHixirxmsr $

EppPizipw $

Higiqfiv6454 $ 9$}ievw $

Sri0$Jmzi1]iev $ S{rih

Omrri}$Gsyrx}$HixirxmsrGirxiv0$X\$,7- 7<8

$YWQW$1$MKE

$

Psgep$*JihivepHixirxmsr $

Qihmyq$

Witxiqfiv$6457$

Tivtixyep$

Rsri$

Qerekih

Pe{xsr$GsvvigxmsrepJegmpmx}$Pe{xsr0$SO

60:<6$

SO$HSG$

WxexiGsvvigxmsrep $

Qihmyq$

Nyp}$645<$

5$]iev$

Jsyv0EyxsqexmgSri1}iev $

S{rih

Pmfivx}$Gsyrx}$Nemp0$X\,7- 6<9

$YWQE$1$MKE

$

Psgep$*JihivepHixirxmsr $

Qihmyq$

Qe}$5==;$

Tivtixyep$

Rsri$

Qerekih

Qsrxksqiv}$TvsgiwwmrkGirxiv$Gsrvsi0$X\ 50758

$MGI

$

Psgep$*JihivepHixirxmsr $

Epp$pizipw$

Sgxsfiv$645<$

54$qsrxlw$

Rmri0$Sri1}iev $

S{rih

Viiziw$Gsyrx}$HixirxmsrGirxiv$V53V60$X\

50<44

$FST

$

JihivepGsvvigxmsrep

$Ps{

$Sgxsfiv$645=

$7$}iev

$

Wizir0$sri1}iev0$tpywsri0$wm|1qsrxl $

Qerekih

56

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 19 of 253

Page 42: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5=367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Jegmpmx}$Reqi$*Psgexmsrccccccc Getegmx},5- $

Tvmqev}Gywxsqiv $

Jegmpmx}X}ti $

Wigyvmx}Pizip $

Gsqqirgiqirxsj$GyvvirxGsrxvegx$,6- $

FewiTivmsh $

Viri{epStxmsrw $

QerekihPiewih3S{rih

Viiziw$Gsyrx}$HixirxmsrGirxiv$V7$Tigsw0$X\ 5079:

$FST

$

JihivepGsvvigxmsrep

$Ps{

$Nyp}$645=

$7$}ievw

$

Wizir0$sri1}iev0$tpywsri0$wm|1qsrxl $

Qerekih

Vms$Kverhi$TvsgiwwmrkGirxiv$Pevihs0$X\

50=44 $ YWQW $JihivepHixirxmsr $ Qihmyq $

Sgxsfiv644< $ 9$}ievw $

Xlvii0$Jmzi1}iev $ S{rih

Wsyxl$Xi|ew$MGITvsgiwwmrk$Girxiv$Tievwepp0X\

50=48

$

MGI

$

JihivepHixirxmsr

$

EppPizipw

$

Higiqfiv6455

$

55$qsrxlw

$

Jsyv0$Sri1}iev$tpywSri0$Wm|qsrxl

i|xirwmsr0Sri$]ievi|xirwmsr0

tpyw$Sri$Wm|1qsrxl

i|xirwmsrw0tpyw$Sri$91

he}i|xirwmsr0Tpyw$Sri$:1

qsrxli|xirwmsr $

S{rih

Zep$Zivhi$Gsyrx}Hixirxmsr$Jegmpmx}$Hip$Vms0X\$,7-

5084;$

YWQW$1$MKE$

Psgep$*JihivepHixirxmsr $

EppPizipw $

Neryev}6445 $

Tivtixyep$

Rsri$

S{rih

Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$Ó$Iewxivr$Vikmsr>

Epi|erhvme$WxekmrkJegmpmx}$Epi|erhvme0$PE,7-

844$

MGI$1$MKE$

JihivepHixirxmsr $

Qmrmqyq3Qihmyq $

Rsziqfiv$6457$

Tivtixyep$

Rsri$

S{rih

Fe}$Gsvvigxmsrep$erhVilefmpmxexmsr$Jegmpmx}Tereqe$Gmx}0$JP

=<9$

JP$HQW$

WxexiGsvvigxmsrep $

Qmrmqyq3Qihmyq $

Jifvyev}$6458$

7$}ievw$

Yrpmqmxih0X{s1}iev $

Qerekih

Fpego{exiv$VmzivGsvvigxmsrep$erhVilefmpmxexmsr$Jegmpmx}Qmpxsr0$JP

60444

$JP$HQW

$

WxexiGsvvigxmsrep

$

Qihmyq3gpswi

$Sgxsfiv$6454

$7$}ievw

$

Yrpmqmxih0X{s1}iev

$Qerekih

Fvs{evh$XverwmxmsrepGirxiv$Hiivjmiph$Fiegl0JP

;44

$

MGI

$

JihivepHixirxmsr

$

Qmrmqyq

$

Nyp}$6459

$

5$}iev

$

Jmzi0$Sri1}iev$tpywSri0$Wm|1qsrxl

i|xirwmsr $

S{rih

Gvswwvsehw$VigitxmsrGirxiv$Mrhmeretspmw0$MR

744 $ Mhpi $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ S{rih

H2$Ve}$Neqiw$GsvvigxmsrepJegmpmx}$Jspowxsr0$KE

50=44 $ FST $JihivepHixirxmsr $

EppPizipw $

Sgxsfiv6454 $ 8$}ievw $

Xlvii0$X{s1}iev $ S{rih

Jspowxsr$MGI$TvsgiwwmrkGirxiv$,7-$Jspowxsr0$KE

5055< $ MGI$1$MKE $JihivepHixirxmsr $ Qmrmqyq $ Higiqfiv$645: $ 5$}iev $

Jsyv0$Sri1}iev $ S{rih

Kisvki$[2$LmppGsvvigxmsrep$Jegmpmx}0$TE

50=75 $Hipe{eviGsyrx} $

WxexiGsvvigxmsrep $ Qmrmqyq $ Neryev}$645= $ 9$}ievw $

X{s0$X{s1}iev$stxmsrw $ Qerekih

Kvegizmppi$Gsvvigxmsreperh$Vilefmpmxexmsr$Jegmpmx}Negowsr0$JP

50<<8$

JP$HQW$

WxexiGsvvigxmsrep $

EppPizipw $

Jifvyev}$6458$

7$}ievw$

Yrpmqmxih0X{s$}iev $

Qerekih

Livmxeki$Xvemp$GsvvigxmsrepJegmpmx}$Tpemrjmiph0$MR 504::

$

MR$HSG

$

WxexiGsvvigxmsrep

$

Qmrmqyq

$

Qevgl6455

$

8$}ievw

$

Sri0$Jsyv1}iev0$tpywsri0$sri$,5-}iev0$jsyv$,8-qsrxlw$erhx{s$,6-$he}wi|xirwmsr $

Qerekih

NF$Izerw$GsvvigxmsrepGirxiv0$PE

7<< $ Mhpi $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ S{rih

PeWeppi$MGI$TvsgiwwmrkGirxiv$Nire0$PE$,7-

505:4 $ MGI$1$MKE $JihivepHixirxmsr $

Qmrmqyq3Qihmyq $ Rsziqfiv$6457 $ Tivtixyep $ Rsri $ S{rih

57

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 20 of 253

Page 43: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 64367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Jegmpmx}$Reqi$*Psgexmsrccccccc Getegmx},5- $

Tvmqev}Gywxsqiv $

Jegmpmx}X}ti $

Wigyvmx}Pizip $

Gsqqirgiqirxsj$GyvvirxGsrxvegx$,6- $

FewiTivmsh $

Viri{epStxmsrw $

QerekihPiewih3S{rih

Pe{virgizmppiGsvvigxmsrep$erhVilefmpmxexmsr$Jegmpmx}Pe{virgizmppi0$ZE

5097:

$ZE$HSG

$

WxexiGsvvigxmsrep

$Qihmyq

$Eykywx$645<

$9$}ievw

$

Xir0$Sri1}iev

i|xirwmsrw $Qerekih

Qswlerrsr$Zeppi}Gsvvigxmsrep$Jegmpmx}Tlmpmtwfyvk0$TE

50<;<

$FST

$

JihivepGsvvigxmsrep

$Qihmyq

$Etvmp$645:

$9$}ievw

$

Jmzi0$Sri1}iev$tpyw$SriWm|1qsrxli|xirwmsr $

S{rih

Qssvi$LezirGsvvigxmsrep$erhVilefmpmxexmsr$Jegmpmx}Qssvi$Lezir0$JP

=<9

$JP$HQW

$

WxexiGsvvigxmsrep

$

Qmrmqyq3Qihmyq

$Jifvyev}$6458

$7$}ievw

$

Yrpmqmxih0X{s1}iev

$Qerekih

Ri{$Gewxpi$GsvvigxmsrepJegmpmx}$Ri{$Gewxpi0$MR

705=:$

MR$HSG$

WxexiGsvvigxmsrep $

EppPizipw $

Neryev}644: $

8$}ievw$

X{s0$Jmzi1}iev$tpyw$SriWm|1Qsrxl $

Qerekih

Rsvxl$Peoi$GsvvigxmsrepJegmpmx}$Feph{mr0$QM

50;8<

$FST

$

JihivepGsvvigxmsrep

$Qihmyq3Qe|mqyq

$Sgxsfiv$645=

$7$}ievw

$

Wizir0$sri1}iev0$tpywSri$Wm|1Qsrxl $

S{rih

Tivv}$Gsyrx}Gsvvigxmsrep$Jegmpmx}0$EP

:=4 $ Mhpi $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ S{rih

Tmri$Tvemvmi$MGITvsgiwwmrk$Girxiv0$PE$,7-

504=8 $ MGI1MKE $Wxexi

Gsvvigxmsrep $ Qihmyq $ Nyri$6459 $ 9$}ievw $ Rsri $ S{rih

Uyiirw$Hixirxmsr$Jegmpmx}Neqemge0$R] 666

$

YWQW

$

JihivepHixirxmsr

$

Qmrmqyq3Qihmyq

$

Etvmp$645=

$

5$}iev

$

Rmri0$Sri}iev$stxmsrw0Sri$Wm|1qsrxl

i|xirwmsrtpyw$Xlvii1qsrxl0$tpywXlvii$X{s1qsrxlw $

S{rih

Vmzivfirh$Gsvvigxmsreperh$VilefmpmxexmsrJegmpmx}$Qmppihkizmppi0KE

50944

$KE$HSG

$

WxexiGsvvigxmsrep

$Qihmyq

$Nyp}$6454

$5$}iev

$

Jsvx}0$Sri1}iev

$S{rih

Vmzivw$GsvvigxmsrepJegmpmx}$[mrxsr0$RG

50894 $ FST $Jihivep

Gsvvigxmsrep $ Ps{ $ Etvmp$6455 $ 8$}ievw $Xlvii0$X{s1

}iev $ S{rih

Vsfivx$E2$Hi}xsrHixirxmsr$Jegmpmx}Pszins}0$KE

;:<$

YWQW$

JihivepHixirxmsr $

Qihmyq$

Jifvyev}644< $

9$}ievw$

Xlvii0$Jmzi}iev $

Piewih

Wsyxl$Fe}$Gsvvigxmsreperh$VilefmpmxexmsrJegmpmx}$Wsyxl$Fe}0$JP

50=8<$

JP$HQW$

WxexiGsvvigxmsrep $

Qihmyq3Gpswi $

Nyp}$644=$

7$}ievw$

Yrpmqmxih0X{s1}iev $

Qerekih

Wsyxl$PsymwmereGsvvigxmsrep$Girxiv0PE,7-

50444$

MGI1MKE$

WxexiGsvvigxmsrep $

Qihmyq$

Nyri$6459$

9$}ievw$

Rsri$

S{rih

Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$Ó$Eywxvepme>

Evxlyv$KsvvmiGsvvigxmsrep$GirxviUyiirwperh0$Eywxvepme$,;-

<=4

$

UPHHGW

$

WxexiViqerhTvmwsr

$

Lmkl3Qe|mqyq

$

Neryev}644<

$

9$}ievw

$

Sri0$Jmzi1}iev0$TpywJmzi0$Wm|1qsrxl

i|xirwmsrw $

Qerekih

Jypleq$GsvvigxmsrepGirxvi$*$Repy$GleppirkiGsqqyrmx}$Zmgxsvme0Eywxvepme

=66

$ZMG$HSN

$Wxexi$Tvmwsr

$

Qmrmqyq3Qihmyq

$Nyp}$6456

$8$}ievw

$

5=$}ievw0Jsyv$qsrxlw

$Qerekih

Nyrii$Gsvvigxmsrep$GirxviRi{$Wsyxl$[epiw0Eywxvepme

506;=$

RW[$

Wxexi$Tvmwsr$

Qmrmqyq3Qihmyq $

Qevgl$6458$

9$}ievw$

X{s0$Jmzi}iev $

Qerekih

Vezirlepp$GsvvigxmsrepGirxvi$Qipfsyvri0Eywxvepme

50744$

ZMG$HSN$

Wxexi$Tvmwsr$

Qihmyq$

Rsziqfiv$645;$

68$}ievwtpyw$9qsrxlw $

Rsri$

Qerekih

58

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 21 of 253

Page 44: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 65367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Jegmpmx}$Reqi$*Psgexmsrccccccc Getegmx},5- $

Tvmqev}Gywxsqiv $

Jegmpmx}X}ti $

Wigyvmx}Pizip $

Gsqqirgiqirxsj$GyvvirxGsrxvegx$,6- $

FewiTivmsh $

Viri{epStxmsrw $

QerekihPiewih3S{rih

Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$Ó$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq>

Hyrkezip$LsywiMqqmkvexmsr$ViqszepGirxvi0$Wsyxl$Perevowlmvi0YO

68=

$YOFE

$

HixirxmsrGirxvi

$Qmrmqyq

$

Witxiqfiv6455

$9$}ievw

$

Xlvii0$Sri}iev0$Tpywx{s1}iev $

Qerekih

Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$Ó$Wsyxl$Ejvmge>

Oyxeqe1WmrxlyqypiGsvvigxmsrep$GirxviPmqtsts$Tvszmrgi0Vityfpmg$sj$Wsyxl$Ejvmge

70468

$VWE$HGW

$

RexmsrepTvmwsr

$Qe|mqyq

$

Jifvyev}6446

$69$}ievw

$Rsri

$Qerekih

Gsvvigxmsrw$*$Hixirxmsr$Ó$Gerehe>

Ri{$Fvyrw{mgo$]syxlGirxvi$Qmvmqeglm0Gerehe,8-

R3E$

TRF$

TvszmrgmepNyzirmpiJegmpmx} $

Epp$Pizipw$

Sgxsfiv5==; $

69$}ievw$

Sri0Xir1}iev $

Qerekih

KIS$Gevi$Ó$Gsqqyrmx}$Fewih$Wivzmgiw>

EHETTX0$TE :8 $ TE$HSG $Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $ Gsqqyrmx} $ Jifvyev}$645= $ 5$}iev $

Jsyv0$sri}iev$stxmsrw $ S{rih

Epefeqe$XlivetiyxmgIhygexmsr$Jegmpmx}0$EP

;68 $ EP$HSG $Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $ Gsqqyrmx} $ Eykywx$645= $ 5$}iev $ Rsri $ S{rih

Epfivx$&Fs&$VsfmrwsrEwwiwwqirx$*$XviexqirxGirxiv0$RN

=44$

RN$HSG3RNWxexi$Tevspi

Fsevh $Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $

Gsqqyrmx}$

Neryev}$64643Nyp}6458 $

6$}ievw37}ievw $

Sri0$Sri}iev3Xlvii0Sri$}iev $

S{rih

Eppi$Omwom$Tezmppmsr0$TE 548 $ Mhpi $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ S{rih

Evetelsi$Gsyrx}Viwmhirxmep$Girxiv0$GS

684 $EvetelsiGsyrx} $

Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $ Gsqqyrmx} $ Nyp}$645= $ 5$}iev $ Rsri $ S{rih

Fieyqsrx$XverwmxmsrepXviexqirx$GirxivFieyqsrx0$X\

5<4

$XHGN

$

Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw

$Gsqqyrmx}

$

Witxiqfiv6447

$6$}ievw

$

Jmzi0$X{s}iev$tpywJmzi0$Sri}iev $

S{rih

Fvsr|$Gsqqyrmx}$viirxv}Girxiv$Fvsr|0$R] 5=:

$

FST

$

Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw

$

Gsqqyrmx}

$

Eykywx$6458

$

5$}iev

$

Sri0$Sri1}iev0$TpywSri0$Sri1}iev$erh$xlviiqsrxlw0$TpywX{s0$Sri}iev$Stxmsrw0tpyw$SriSri1qsrxli|xirwmsr0tpyw$Sri$x{s1qsrxli|xirwmsr $

Piewih

Gewtiv$Viirxv}$Girxiv0[]

786 $ FST3Rexvsre $Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $ Gsqqyrmx} $

Nyp}$6445=3Neryev}645; $

5$}iev36}ievw $

Jsyv0$Sri}iev3Rsri $ S{rih

59

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 22 of 253

Page 45: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 66367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Jegmpmx}$Reqi$*Psgexmsrccccccc Getegmx},5- $

Tvmqev}Gywxsqiv $

Jegmpmx}X}ti $

Wigyvmx}Pizip $

Gsqqirgiqirxsj$GyvvirxGsrxvegx$,6- $

FewiTivmsh $

Viri{epStxmsrw $

QerekihPiewih3S{rih

Gliwxiv$Gsyrx}0$TE 58= $ TE$HSG $Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $ Gsqqyrmx} $ Jifvyev}$645= $ 5$}iev $

Jsyv0$sri$}ievstxmsrw $ S{rih

Gli}irri$QsyrxemrVigsziv}$Girxiv0$GS ;94

$GS$HSG

$Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $

Gsqqyrmx}$

Witxiqfiv$645=$

9$qsrxlw0$5{iio0$7he}w $

Rsri$

S{rih

Gspiqer$Lepp0$TE 794 $ Mhpi $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ S{rih

Gsqqyrmx}$Epxivrexmziwsj$Ip$Tews$Gsyrx}0$GS

684 $ Ip$Tews$Gsyrx} $Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $ Gsqqyrmx} $ Nyp}$645= $ 5$}iev $ Rsri $ S{rih

Gsvvigxmsrep$EpxivrexmziTpegiqirx$Wivzmgiw0$GS 89

$

58xl$NyhmgmepHmwxvmgx

Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw

Fsevh $

Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw

$

Gsqqyrmx}

$

Nyp}$645=

$

5$}iev

$

Rsri

$

S{rih

Gsqqyrmx}$Epxivrexmziwsj$xli$Fpego$Lmppw0$WH :<

$FST

$Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $

Gsqqyrmx}$

$Sgxsfiv$645:$

5$}iev$

Rmri3Jsyv0$Sri1}iev$tpyw$:qsrxlw $

S{rih

Gsvhsze$GirxivErglsveki0$EO

6=:

$

FST$3$EOHSG

$

Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw

$Gsqqyrmx}

$

Nyri$645=3Nyp}645=

$

5$}iev35}iev

$

Rmri0$Sri1}ievviri{epw3Jsyv0

Sri1}ievviri{epw $

S{rih

Hiperi}$Lepp0$RN 50644

$

YrmsrGsyrx}3Iwwi|Gsyrx}3RNWxexi$Tevspi

Fsevh $

Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw

$

Gsqqyrmx}

$

Neryev}64643Neryev}645;3Nyp}$6458

$

6$}ievw39}ievw37}ievw

$

X{s0$Sri}iev3Rsri3Xlvii0

Sri$}iev$

S{rih

Ip$Qsrxi$Girxiv$IpQsrxi0$GE

;4 $ FST $Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $ Gsqqyrmx} $ Sgxsfiv$645= $ 5$}iev $

Rmri0$Sri1}ievstxmsrw $ Piewih

Kvswwqer$GirxivPiezir{svxl0$OW

594 $ FST $Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $ Gsqqyrmx} $ Nyp}$645= $ 5$}iev $

Rmri0$Sri1}ievstxmsrw $ S{rih

Pew$Zikew$Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrep$Girxiv$PewZikew0$RZ

568$

FST$

Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $

Gsqqyrmx}$

Jifvyev}$645:$

5$}iev$

Jsyv0$Sri1}ievi|xirwmsrw $

S{rih

Pimhip$GsqtvilirwmziWergxmsr$Girxiv$Lsywxsr0X\

5=4$

FST$

Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $

Gsqqyrmx}$

Neryev}645: $

5$}iev$

Jsyv0$Sri$}iev$

S{rih

5:

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 23 of 253

Page 46: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 67367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Jegmpmx}$Reqi$*Psgexmsrccccccc Getegmx},5- $

Tvmqev}Gywxsqiv $

Jegmpmx}X}ti $

Wigyvmx}Pizip $

Gsqqirgiqirxsj$GyvvirxGsrxvegx$,6- $

FewiTivmsh $

Viri{epStxmsrw $

QerekihPiewih3S{rih

Psker$Lepp0$RN 886 $ Mhpi $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ Piewih

Psrk$Fiegl$Gsqqyrmx}Viirxv}$Girxiv0$GE

556

$GHGV

$

Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw

$Gsqqyrmx}

$Rsziqfiv$645=

$

8$}ievw0$;qsrxlw0$8{iiow0$5

he} $Rsri

$Piewih

Qevzmr$Kevhirw$GirxivPsw$Erkipiw0$GE

:4 $ FST $Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $ Gsqqyrmx} $ Higiqfiv$645< $ 5$}iev $

Jsyv0$Sri1}iev $ Piewih

QgGefi$Girxiv$Eywxmr0X\

557 $Xlmvh$Tevx}Xirerx $

Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $ Gsqqyrmx} $ R3E $ R3E $ R3E $ S{rih

Qmh$Zeppi}$LsywiIhmrfyvk0$X\

56<

$

FST

$

Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw

$

Gsqqyrmx}

$

Nyp}$6458

$

5$}iev

$

Sri0$Sri1}iev0$Tpyw

Sri1}iev$erhxlvii$qsrxlw0Tpyw$X{s0Sri$}iev

stxmsrw0$Tpyw0X{s$sri1qsrxl

i|xirwmsrw0Tpyw$Sri0rmri1qsrxli|xirwmsr $

S{rih

Qmhxs{r$GirxivErglsveki0$EO

76 $ EO$HSG $Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $

Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $ Nyri$645= $ 5$}iev $

Jsyv0$Sri1}iev$viri{epw $ S{rih

Ri{$Qi|mgs$QirwVigsziv}$Egehiq}0$RQ

5;8 $ RQ$HSG $Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $

Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $ Nyp}$645= $ 8$}ievw $ Rsri $ Qerekih

Ri{$Qi|mgs$[sqirwVigsziv}$Egehiq}0$RQ

:4 $ RQ$HSG $Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $

Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $ Nyp}$645= $ 8$}ievw $ Rsri $ Qerekih

Rsvxlwxev$GirxivJemvferow0$EO

587

$EO$HSG

$

Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw

$Gsqqyrmx}

$Witxiqfiv$645:

$54$qsrxlw

$

Xlvii1Sri}iev0$tpyw$sriwizir$qsrxli|xirwmsr $

Piewih

Seoperh$Girxiv$Seoperh0GE

:=

$

FST

$

Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw

$

Gsqqyrmx}

$

Rsziqfiv644<

$

7$}ievw

$

Wizir0$Sri}iev0$tpywSri0$Wm|qsrxli|xirwmsr0tpyw$Xlvii0Xlvii1qsrxli|xirwmsrw $

S{rih

Tevozmi{$GirxivErglsveki0$EO

556 $ Mhpi $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ S{rih

Tlmpehiptlme$ViwmhirxmepViirxv}$Girxiv

844 $ FST $Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $ Gsqqyrmx} $ Etvmp$645= $ 5$}iev $

Jsyv0$sri}iev $ S{rih

Viepmx}$LsywiFvs{rwzmppi0$X\

=8 $ FST $Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $ Gsqqyrmx} $ Nyp}$645= $ 5$}iev $

Jsyv0$Sri}iev $ S{rih

5;

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 24 of 253

Page 47: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 68367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Jegmpmx}$Reqi$*Psgexmsrccccccc Getegmx},5- $

Tvmqev}Gywxsqiv $

Jegmpmx}X}ti $

Wigyvmx}Pizip $

Gsqqirgiqirxsj$GyvvirxGsrxvegx$,6- $

FewiTivmsh $

Viri{epStxmsrw $

QerekihPiewih3S{rih

Wepx$Peoi$Gmx}$Girxiv$WepxPeoi$Gmx}0$YX 559 $ FST $

Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $ Gsqqyrmx} $

Nyri645= $ 5$}iev $

Rmri$Sri1}iev $ Piewih

Wgverxsr$Jegmpmx}0$TE 544 $ TE$HSG $Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $ Gsqqyrmx} $ Jifvyev}$645= $ 5$}iev $

Jsyv0$sri}iev$stxmsrw $ Piewih

Wiewmhi$Girxiv$Rsqi0$EO :6 $ EO$HSG $Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $ Gsqqyrmx} $ Nyri$645= $ 5$}iev $

Jsyv0$Sri1}iev$stxmsrw $ S{rih

Wsyxliewx$Xi|ewXverwmxmsrep$GirxivLsywxsr0$X\

944$

XHGN$

Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $

Gsqqyrmx}$

Witxiqfiv6447 $

6$}ievw$

Jmzi0$x{s1}iev$tpyw$Jmzi

sri1}iev $S{rih

Xepfsx$Lepp0$RN 97:

$

RN$HSG

$

Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw

$

Gsqqyrmx}

$

Nyp}$645:

$

6$}ievw

$

Sri0$Sri}iev$stxmsr0Tpyw$Sri0$Wm|

qsrxli|xirwmsr $

Piewih

Xli$Levfsv0$RN 6:4 $ RN$HSG $Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $ Gsqqyrmx} $ Neryev}$6464 $ 6$}ievw $ Sri0$sri1}iev $ Piewih

Xspiv$Lepp0$RN 557

$

FST

$

Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw

$

Gsqqyrmx}

$

Qe}$6456

$

6$}ievw

$

Xlvii0$Sri1}iev0$TpywX{s$wm|1qsrxl

I|xirwmsrw0tpyw$Sri0Wm|1qsrxli|xirwmsr0tpyw$X{s$:1

qsrxli|xirwmsr0tpyw$sri

xlvii1qsrxli|xirwmsr2 $

Piewih

Xsspi}$Lepp0$GS ;4 $Gmx}$*$Gsyrx}sj$Hirziv $

Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $ Gsqqyrmx} $ Nyp}$645= $ :$qsrxlw $ Rsri $ S{rih

Xypp}$Lsywi0$RN 788 $ RN$HSG $Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $ Gsqqyrmx} $ Neryev}$6464 $ 6$}ievw $ Sri0$sri1}iev $ S{rih

Xe}psv$Wxviix$GirxivWer$Jvergmwgs0$GE

684

$FST$3$GHGV

$

Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw

$Gsqqyrmx}

$

Etvmp$645:3Nyp}645;

$

5$}iev37}ievw

$

Jsyv0$Sri}iev3X{s0Sri$}ievStxmsrw $

S{rih

Xyrhve$Girxiv$Fixlip0$EO <9 $ EO$HSG $Gsqqyrmx}Gsvvigxmsrw $ Gsqqyrmx} $ Nyri$645= $ 5$}iev $

Jsyv0$Sri1}iev$stxmsrw $ S{rih

[mppmeqw$Wxviix$Girxiv0$GS <8 $ Mhpi $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ S{rih

KIS$Gevi$Ó$]syxl$Wivzmgiw>

5<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 25 of 253

Page 48: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 69367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Jegmpmx}$Reqi$*Psgexmsrccccccc Getegmx},5- $

Tvmqev}Gywxsqiv $

Jegmpmx}X}ti $

Wigyvmx}Pizip $

Gsqqirgiqirxsj$GyvvirxGsrxvegx$,6- $

FewiTivmsh $

Viri{epStxmsrw $

QerekihPiewih3S{rih

Efve|ew$Egehiq}Qsvkerxs{r0$TE 658 $ Zevmsyw $

]syxlViwmhirxmep $ Wigyvi $ Nyri$6449 $ Rsri $ Rsri $ S{rih

Efve|ew$M$Qevmirzmppi0$TE 648 $ Zevmsyw $]syxl

Viwmhirxmep $WxejjWigyvi $ Qe}$6449 $ Rsri $ Rsri $ S{rih

Efve|ew$Slms$Wlipf}0$SL 544 $ Zevmsyw $]syxl

Viwmhirxmep $WxejjWigyvi $ Nyri$6449 $ Rsri $ Rsri $ S{rih

Efve|ew$]syxl$GirxivWsyxl$Qsyrxemr0$TE ;6

$TE$Hitx$sj

Tyfpmg$[ipjevi $]syxl

Viwmhirxmep $

Wigyvi3WxejjWigyvi $

Nyri$6449$

Rsri$

Rsri$

Piewih

Geqt$Ewtir0$WG 7:$

WG$Hitx2$sjNyzirmpi$Nywxmgi $

]syxlViwmhirxmep $

WxejjWigyvi $

Eykywx$6458$

5$}iev$

Xlvii0$x{s1}iev

i|xirwmsrw $Qerekih

HyTeki$MrxivzirxmsrwLmrwhepi0$MP

7: $ Mhpi $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ S{rih

Ligxsv$Kev~e$GirxivWer$Erxsrms0$X\

57= $ X]G $]syxl

Viwmhirxmep $WxejjWigyvi $ Nyri$6449 $ Rsri $ Rsri $ S{rih

Piehivwlmt$HizipstqirxTvskveq$Wsyxl$Qsyrxemr0TE

56<$

Zevmsyw$

]syxlViwmhirxmep $

WxejjWigyvi $

Nyri$6449$

Rsri$

Rsri$

Piewih

Wsyxlivr$Tieow$VikmsrepXviexqirx$Girxiv$GersrGmx}0$GS

57:$

Zevmsyw$

]syxlViwmhirxmep $

WxejjWigyvi $

Nyri$6449$

Rsri$

Rsri$

S{rih

Wsyxl{ssh$MrxivzirxmsrwGlmgeks0$MP

<4

$

MP$HEWE0Gmx}$sjGlmgeks0Qihmgemh $

]syxlViwmhirxmep

$

WxejjWigyvi

$Nyri$6449

$Rsri

$Rsri

$S{rih

[sshvmhki$Mrxivzirxmsrw[sshvmhki0$MP

=4 $MP$HEWE0Qihmgemh $

]syxlViwmhirxmep $

WxejjWigyvi $ Nyri$6449 $ Rsri $ Rsri $ S{rih

Xli$jspps{mrk$xefpi$wyqqevm~iw$givxemr$mrjsvqexmsr${mxl$viwtigx$xs$syv$viirxv}$He}$Vitsvxmrk$Girxivw0${lmgl${i$vijiv$xs$ew

HVGw2$Xli$mrjsvqexmsr$mr$xli$xefpi$mrgpyhiw$xli$HVGw$xlex${i$,sv$e$wyfwmhmev}$sv$nsmrx$zirxyvi$sj$KIS-$stivexih$yrhiv$e$qerekiqirx

gsrxvegx$sv$leh$er$ekviiqirx$xs$tvszmhi$wivzmgiw$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=>$

HVG$Psgexmsr

Ryqfiv$sjvitsvxmrkgirxivw $

X}ti$sjGywxsqivw $

Gsqqirgiqirxsj$gyvvirxgsrxvegx,w- $

Fewitivmsh $

Viri{epstxmsrw $

Qereki$srp}3piewi

Gspsvehs$,9- 9 $ Wxexi0$Gsyrx} $Zevmsyw0

6459$Ò$645< $ 5$}iev $ Zevmiw $ Piewi

Gepmjsvrme 6= $ Wxexi0$Gsyrx} $ 645; $ 7$}ievw $ Sri0$Sri$}iev $Piewi$sv$Qereki

srp}

Ri{$Nivwi} 9 $ Wxexi0$Gsyrx} $ 6459 $ 8$}ievw $ Sri0$Sri$}iev $ Piewi

Tirrw}pzerme 54 $ Wxexi0$Gsyrx} $Zevmsyw0

644:$Ò$645< $ 7$xs$9$}ievw $ Zevmiw $ Piewi

Mppmrsmw < $ Wxexi0$Gsyrx} $ 645< $ 9$}ievw $Sri0$Jmzi

}iev $Piewi$sv$Qereki

srp}

Oerwew 5 $ Gsyrx} $ 645: $ 5$}iev $Jsyv0$Sri

}iev $ Piewi

Psymwmere : $ Wxexi $ 645< $ 7$}ievw $ Rsri $ Piewi

Oirxygo} 5 $ Gsyrx} $ 6459 $ 5$}iev $ Jsyv0$Sri$}iev $ Piewi

5=

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 26 of 253

Page 49: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 6:367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Gywxsqiv$Pikirh>

$

Effvizmexmsr $$ Gywxsqiv

EP$HSG $ Epefeqe$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmsrw

EO$HSG $$ Epewoe$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmsrw

E^$HSG $$ Evm~sre$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmsrw

FST $$ Jihivep$Fyviey$sj$Tvmwsrw

GHGV $$ Gepmjsvrme$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmsrw$*$Vilefmpmxexmsr

GS$HSG $$ Gspsvehs$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmsrw

JP$HSG $ Jpsvmhe$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmsrw

JP$HQW $$ Jpsvmhe$Hitevxqirx$sj$Qerekiqirx$Wivzmgiw

KE$HSG $$ Kisvkme$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmsrw

MGI $$ Y2W2$Mqqmkvexmsr$*$Gywxsqw$Irjsvgiqirx

MH$HSG $ Mhels$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmsrw

MR$HSG $$ Mrhmere$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmsr

MKE $$ Mrxiv1kszivrqirxep$Ekviiqirx

MP$HEWE $$ Mppmrsmw$Hitevxqirx$sj$Epgslspmwq$erh$Wyfwxergi$Efywi

PE$HSG $$ Psymwmere$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmsrw

RN$HSG $ Ri{$Nivwi}$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmsrw

RQ$HSG $$ Ri{$Qi|mgs$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmsrw

RW[ $$ Gsqqmwwmsriv$sj$Gsvvigxmzi$Wivzmgiw$jsv$Ri{$Wsyxl$[epiw0$Eywxvepme

SO$HSG $$ Sopelsqe$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmsrw

TE$HSG $ Tirrw}pzerme$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmsrw

TRF $$ Tvszmrgi$sj$Ri{$Fvyrw{mgo

UPH$HGW $$ Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmzi$Wivzmgiw$sj$xli$Wxexi$sj$Uyiirwperh0$Eywxvepme

VWE$HGW $$ Vityfpmg$sj$Wsyxl$Ejvmge$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmsrep$Wivzmgiw

WG$Hitx$sj$Nyzirmpi$Nywxmgi $ Wsyxl$Gevspmre$Hitevxqirx$sj$Nyzirmpi$Nywxmgi

WH$HSG $ Wsyxl$Heosxe$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmsrw

XHGN $$ Xi|ew$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gvmqmrep$Nywxmgi

X]G $$ Xi|ew$]syxl$Gsqqmwwmsr

YOFE $$ Yrmxih$Omrkhsq$Fsvhiv$Ekirg}

YWQW $$ Yrmxih$Wxexiw$Qevwlepw$Wivzmgi

ZE$HSG $$ Zmvkmrme$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmsrw

ZMG$HSN $$ Hitevxqirx$sj$Nywxmgi$sj$xli$Wxexi$sj$Zmgxsvme0$Eywxvepme

ZX$HSG $ Zivqsrx$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmsrw

[E$HSG $ [ewlmrkxsr$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmsrw

$

,5- Getegmx}$ew$ywih$ mr$ xli$xefpi$vijivw$xs$stivexmsrep$getegmx}$gsrwmwxmrk$sj$ xsxep$fihw$jsv$epp$jegmpmxmiw$i|gitx$ jsv$xli$wizir$Rsr1

viwmhirxmep$wivzmgi$girxivw$yrhiv$]syxl$Wivzmgiw$jsv${lmgl${i$lezi$tvszmhih$wivzmgi$getegmx}${lmgl$vitviwirxw$xli$ryqfiv$sj

nyzirmpiw$xlex$ger$fi$wivzmgih$hemp}2

,6- Jsv$]syxl$Wivzmgiw$Rsr1Viwmhirxmep$Wivzmgi$Girxivw0$xli$gsrxvegx$gsqqirgiqirx$hexi$vitviwirxw$imxliv$xli$tvskveq$wxevx$hexi

sv$ xli$ hexi$ xlex$ xli$ jegmpmx}$ stivexmsrw$ {ivi$ eguymvih$ f}$ syv$ wyfwmhmev}2$ Xli$ wivzmgi$ ekviiqirxw$ yrhiv$ xliwi$ evverkiqirxw

tvszmhi$jsv$wivzmgiw$sr$er$ew1gsrxvegxih$fewmw$erh$xlivi$evi$rs$kyeverxiih$qmrmqyq$tstypexmsrw$sv$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw${mxl

wtigmjmih$viri{ep$hexiw2$Xliwi$evverkiqirxw$evi$qsvi$tivtixyep$mr$rexyvi2$Jsv$eguymvih$stivexmsrw0$xli$gsqqirgiqirx$hexi$mw

xli$svmkmrep$hexi$sj$gsrxvegx2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 27 of 253

Page 50: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 6;367<

64

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 28 of 253

Page 51: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 6<367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

,7- KIS$tvszmhiw$wivzmgiw$ex$xliwi$jegmpmxmiw$xlvsykl$zevmsyw$Mrxiv1Kszivrqirxep$Ekviiqirxw0$sv$MKEw0$xlvsykl$xli$zevmsyw$gsyrxmiw

erh$sxliv$nyvmwhmgxmsrw2

,8- Xli$gsrxvegx$jsv$xlmw$jegmpmx}$srp}$viuymviw$KIS$xs$tvszmhi$qemrxirergi$wivzmgiw2

,9- Xli$Gspsvehs$He}$Vitsvxmrk$Girxivw$tvszmhi$qer}$sj$xli$weqi$wivzmgiw$ew$xli$jypp$wivzmgi$He}$Vitsvxmrk$Girxivw0$fyx$vexliv

xler$ tvszmhmrk$ xliwi$ wivzmgiw$ xlvsykl$ gsqtvilirwmzi$ xviexqirx$ tperw$ hmgxexih$ f}$ xli$ kszivrmrk$ eyxlsvmx}0$ xliwi$ wivzmgiw$ evi

tvszmhih$sr$e$jii$jsv$wivzmgi$fewmw2$Wygl$wivzmgiw$qe}$fi$gsrrigxih$xs$kszivrqirx$ekirg}$gsrxvegxw$erh${syph$fi$vimqfyvwih

f}$ xlswi$ekirgmiw2$Sxliv$ wivzmgiw$evi$sjjivih$hmvigxp}$ xs$sjjirhivw$epps{mrk$ xliq$xs$qiix$gsyvx1svhivih$viuymviqirxw$erh$evi

temh$f}$xli$sjjirhiv$ew$xli$wivzmgi$mw$tvszmhih2

,:- Xliwi$jegmpmxmiw$evi$fimrk$hmwgsrxmryih$f}$xli$GHGV$fyx$evi$fimrk$xverwmxmsrih$xs$ri{$gsrxvegxw${mxl$MGI2

,;- Xli$Evxlyv$Ksvvmi$Gsvvigxmsrep$Girxvi${mpp$fi$xverwmxmsrih$xs$kszivrqirx$stivexmsr$f}$xli$irh$sj$xli$jmvwx$uyevxiv$sj$64642

Kszivrqirx$Gsrxvegxw$Ó$Xivqmrexmsrw0$Viri{epw$erh$Gsqtixmxmzi$Vi1fmhw

Kirivepp}0${i$qe}$pswi$syv$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$hyi$xs$sri$sj$xlvii$viewsrw>$xli$xivqmrexmsr$f}$e$kszivrqirx$gywxsqiv

{mxl$sv${mxlsyx$geywi$ex$er}$xmqi?$xli$jempyvi$f}$e$gywxsqiv$xs$viri{$e$gsrxvegx${mxl$yw$ytsr$xli$i|tmvexmsr$sj$xli$xlir$gyvvirx$xivq?$sv

syv$jempyvi$xs${mr$xli$vmklx$xs$gsrxmryi$xs$stivexi$yrhiv$e$gsrxvegx$xlex$lew$fiir$gsqtixmxmzip}$vi1fmh$mr$e$tvsgyviqirx$tvsgiww$ytsr$mxw

xivqmrexmsr$sv$i|tmvexmsr2$Syv$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$x}tmgepp}$epps{$e$gsrxvegxmrk$kszivrqirxep$ekirg}$xs$xivqmrexi$e$gsrxvegx

{mxl$sv${mxlsyx$geywi$ex$er}$xmqi$f}$kmzmrk$yw${vmxxir$rsxmgi$verkmrk$jvsq$74$xs$5<4$he}w2$Mj$kszivrqirx$ekirgmiw${ivi$xs$ywi$xliwi

tvszmwmsrw$xs$xivqmrexi0$sv$viriksxmexi$xli$xivqw$sj$xlimv$ekviiqirxw${mxl$yw0$syv$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$gsyph$fi

qexivmepp}$ ehzivwip}$ ejjigxih2$ Wii$ ÔVmwo$ Jegxsvw$ Ó$ Ô[i$ evi$ wyfnigx$ xs$ xli$ psww$ sj$ syv$ jegmpmx}$ qerekiqirx$ gsrxvegxw0$ hyi$ xs

xivqmrexmsrw0$rsr1viri{epw$sv$gsqtixmxmzi$vi1fmhw0${lmgl$gsyph$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$syv$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$erh$pmuymhmx}0$mrgpyhmrk$syv

efmpmx}$xs$wigyvi$ri{$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$jvsq$sxliv$kszivrqirx$gywxsqivwÕ2

Ewmhi$jvsq$syv$gywxsqivw×$yrmpexivep$vmklx$xs$xivqmrexi$syv$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw${mxl$xliq$ex$er}$xmqi$jsv$er}$viewsr0

xlivi$evi$x{s$tsmrxw$hyvmrk$xli$x}tmgep$pmjig}gpi$sj$e$gsrxvegx${lmgl$qe}$viwypx$mr$xli$psww$f}$yw$sj$e$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegx${mxl

syv$gywxsqivw2$[i$vijiv$xs$xliwi$tsmrxw$ew$gsrxvegx$Ôviri{epwÕ$erh$gsrxvegx$Ôvi1fmhw2Õ$Qer}$sj$syv$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw${mxl

syv$kszivrqirx$gywxsqivw$lezi$er$mrmxmep$jm|ih$xivq$erh$wyfwiuyirx$viri{ep$vmklxw$jsv$sri$sv$qsvi$ehhmxmsrep$tivmshw$ex$xli$yrmpexivep

stxmsr$ sj$ xli$ gywxsqiv2$ Figeywi$ qswx$ sj$ syv$ gsrxvegxw$ jsv$ }syxl$ wivzmgiw$ hs$ rsx$ kyeverxii$ tpegiqirx$ sv$ viziryi0$ {i$ lezi$ rsx

gsrwmhivih$xliwi$gsrxvegxw$xs$iziv$fi$mr$xli$viri{ep$sv$vi1fmh$wxeki$wmrgi$xli}$evi$qsvi$tivtixyep$mr$rexyvi2$Ew$wygl0$xli$gsrxvegxw$jsv

}syxl$ wivzmgiw$ evi$ rsx$ gsrwmhivih$ ew$ viri{epw$ sv$ vi1fmhw$ rsv$ evi$ xli}$ mrgpyhih$ mr$ xli$ xefpi$ fips{2$ [i$ gsyrx$ iegl$ kszivrqirx

gywxsqiv×w$vmklx$xs$viri{$e$tevxmgypev$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegx$jsv$er$ehhmxmsrep$tivmsh$ew$e$witevexi$Ôviri{ep2Õ$Jsv$i|eqtpi0$e

jmzi1}iev$ mrmxmep$ jm|ih$ xivq$ gsrxvegx$ {mxl$ gywxsqiv$ stxmsrw$ xs$ viri{$ jsv$ jmzi$ witevexi$ ehhmxmsrep$ sri1}iev$ tivmshw$ {syph0$ mj$ jypp}

i|ivgmwih0$fi$gsyrxih$ew$ jmzi$witevexi$viri{epw0${mxl$sri$viri{ep$gsqmrk$ mr$iegl$sj$ xli$jmzi$}ievw$jspps{mrk$ xli$mrmxmep$ xivq2$Ew$sj

Higiqfiv$750$645=0$7;$sj$syv$ jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$ vitviwirxmrk$ettvs|mqexip}$6:0444$fihw$evi$wglihypih$ xs$i|tmvi$sr$sv

fijsvi$Higiqfiv$750$64640$yrpiww$viri{ih$f}$xli$gywxsqiv$ex$mxw$wspi$stxmsr$mr$givxemr$gewiw0$sv$yrpiww$viri{ih$f}$qyxyep$ekviiqirx

mr$sxliv$gewiw2$Xliwi$gsrxvegxw$vitviwirxih$ettvs|mqexip}$69)$sj$syv$gsrwspmhexih$viziryiw$jsv$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=2

[i$ yrhivxeoi$ wyfwxerxmep$ ijjsvxw$ xs$ viri{$ syv$ jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$ gsrxvegxw2$ Syv$ eziveki$ lmwxsvmgep$ jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$ gsrxvegx

viri{ep$vexi$ettvs|mqexiw$=4)2$Ls{iziv0$kmzir$xlimv$yrmpexivep$rexyvi0${i$gerrsx$ewwyvi$}sy$xlex$syv$gywxsqivw${mpp$mr$jegx$i|ivgmwi

xlimv$ viri{ep$ stxmsrw$ yrhiv$ i|mwxmrk$ gsrxvegxw2$ Mr$ ehhmxmsr0$ mr$ gsrrigxmsr$ {mxl$ gsrxvegx$ viri{epw0$ imxliv$ {i$ sv$ xli$ gsrxvegxmrk

kszivrqirx$ekirg}$lezi$x}tmgepp}$viuyiwxih$glerkiw$sv$ehnywxqirxw$xs$gsrxvegxyep$xivqw2$Ew$e$viwypx0$gsrxvegx$viri{epw$qe}$fi$qehi

sr$xivqw$xlex$evi$qsvi$sv$piww$jezsvefpi$xs$yw$xler$xlswi$mr$i|mwxirgi$tvmsv$xs$xli$viri{epw2

[i$hijmri$gsqtixmxmzi$vi1fmhw$ew$gsrxvegxw$gyvvirxp}$yrhiv$syv$qerekiqirx${lmgl${i$fipmizi0$fewih$sr$syv$i|tivmirgi${mxl$xli

gywxsqiv$erh$xli$jegmpmx}$mrzspzih0${mpp$fi$vi1fmh$xs$yw$erh$sxliv$tsxirxmep$wivzmgi$tvszmhivw$mr$e$gsqtixmxmzi$tvsgyviqirx$tvsgiww$ytsr

xli$ i|tmvexmsr$sv$ xivqmrexmsr$sj$ syv$gsrxvegx0$ ewwyqmrk$epp$ viri{ep$stxmsrw$evi$ i|ivgmwih2$Syv$hixivqmrexmsr$sj${lmgl$ gsrxvegxw${i

fipmizi${mpp$fi$gsqtixmxmzip}$vi1fmh$qe}$mr$wsqi$gewiw$fi$wyfnigxmzi$erh$nyhkqirxep0$fewih$pevkip}$sr$syv$ors{pihki$sj$xli$h}reqmgw

mrzspzmrk$e$tevxmgypev$gsrxvegx0$xli$gywxsqiv$erh$xli$jegmpmx}$mrzspzih2$Gsqtixmxmzi$vi1fmhw$qe}$viwypx$jvsq$xli$i|tmvexmsr$sj$xli$xivq

sj$ e$ gsrxvegx0$ mrgpyhmrk$ xli$ mrmxmep$ jm|ih$ xivq$ tpyw$ er}$ viri{ep$ tivmshw0$ sv$ xli$ ievp}$ xivqmrexmsr$ sj$ e$ gsrxvegx$ f}$ e$ gywxsqiv2

Gsqtixmxmzi$vi1fmhw$evi$sjxir$viuymvih$f}$ettpmgefpi$jihivep$sv$wxexi$tvsgyviqirx$pe{w$tivmshmgepp}$mr$svhiv$xs$irgsyveki$gsqtixmxmzi

tvmgmrk$ erh$ sxliv$ xivqw$ jsv$ xli$ kszivrqirx$ gywxsqiv2$ Tsxirxmep$ fmhhivw$ mr$ gsqtixmxmzi$ vi1fmh$ wmxyexmsrw$ mrgpyhi$ yw0$ sxliv$ tvmzexi

stivexsvw$erh$sxliv$kszivrqirx$irxmxmiw2$[lmpi${i$evi$tpiewih${mxl$syv$lmwxsvmgep${mr$vexi$sr$gsqtixmxmzi$vi1fmhw$erh$evi$gsqqmxxih$xs

gsrxmrymrk$xs$fmh$gsqtixmxmzip}$sr$ettvstvmexi$jyxyvi$gsqtixmxmzi$vi1fmh$sttsvxyrmxmiw0${i$gerrsx

65

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 29 of 253

Page 52: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 6=367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

mr$jegx$ewwyvi$}sy$xlex${i${mpp$tvizemp$mr$jyxyvi$gsqtixmxmzi$vi1fmh$wmxyexmsrw2$Epws0${i$gerrsx$ewwyvi$}sy$xlex$er}$gsqtixmxmzi$vi1fmhw

{i${mr${mpp$fi$sr$xivqw$qsvi$jezsvefpi$xs$yw$xler$xlswi$mr$i|mwxirgi${mxl$viwtigx$xs$xli$i|tmvmrk$gsrxvegx2

Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$7<$sj$syv$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$ew${ipp$ew$givxemr$sj$syv$sxliv$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$xlex

evi$ epws$ wyfnigx$ xs$ gsqtixmxmzi$ vi1fmh$ 0$ mrgpyhmrk$ syv$ gsrxvegx$ xs$ tvszmhi$ wivzmgiw$ xs$ Y2W2$ Mqqmkvexmsr$ erh$ Gywxsqw$ Irjsvgiqirx

,&MGI&-$ yrhiv$ xli$ Mrxirwmzi$ Wytivzmwmsr$ erh$Ettievergi$ Tvskveq$ ,&MWET&-0$qe}$ fi$ wyfnigx$ xs$ gsqtixmxmzi$ vi1fmh$ mr$ 64642$ Xliwi

gsrxvegxw$mr$xli$ekkvikexi$vitviwirxih$5<)$erh$(88926$qmppmsr$sj$syv$645=$gsrwspmhexih$viziryiw2$Xli$jspps{mrk$xefpi$wixw$jsvxl$xli

ryqfiv$sj$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$xlex${i$gyvvirxp}$fipmizi${mpp$fi$wyfnigx$xs$gsqtixmxmzi$vi1fmh$mr$iegl$sj$xli$ri|x$jmzi$}ievw

erh$xliviejxiv0$erh$xli$xsxep$ryqfiv$sj$fihw$vipexmrk$xs$xlswi$tsxirxmep$gsqtixmxmzi$vi1fmh$wmxyexmsrw$hyvmrk$iegl$tivmsh>

$

]iev Vi1fmh $ Xsxep$Ryqfiv$sj$Fihw$yt$jsv$Vi1fmh

6464 7< $ 56069=

6465 67 $ 560=96

6466 56 $ 705;6

6467 ; $ 80544

6468 5: $ 50556

Xliviejxiv 7; $ 7<0797

Xsxep 577 $ ;50=8<

Gsqtixmxmsr

[i$gsqtixi$tvmqevmp}$sr$xli$fewmw$sj$xli$uyepmx}$erh$verki$sj$wivzmgiw${i$sjjiv?$syv$i|tivmirgi$hsqiwxmgepp}$erh$mrxivrexmsrepp}

mr$xli$hiwmkr0$gsrwxvygxmsr0$erh$qerekiqirx$sj$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw$jsv$wigyvi$wivzmgi$jegmpmxmiw?$syv$vityxexmsr?$erh$syv$tvmgmrk2

[i$gsqtixi$hmvigxp}${mxl$xli$tyfpmg$wigxsv0${livi$kszivrqirxep$ekirgmiw$viwtsrwmfpi$jsv$xli$stivexmsr$sj$wigyvi$wivzmgiw0$tvsgiwwmrk

wivzmgiw0$ }syxl$ wivzmgiw0$ gsqqyrmx}1fewih$ wivzmgiw$ erh$ viirxv}$ jegmpmxmiw$ evi$ sjxir$ wiiomrk$ xs$ vixemr$ tvsnigxw$ xlex$ qmklx$ sxliv{mwi

figsqi$ e$ tyfpmg1tvmzexi$ tevxrivwlmt2$ Mr$ xli$ tvmzexi$ wigxsv0$ syv$ Y2W2$ Wigyvi$ Wivzmgiw$ erh$ Mrxivrexmsrep$ Wivzmgiw$ fywmriww$ wikqirxw

gsqtixi${mxl$ e$ ryqfiv$ sj$ gsqtermiw0$ mrgpyhmrk0$ fyx$ rsx$ pmqmxih$ xs>$ Gsvi$Gmzmg?$Qerekiqirx$ erh$ Xvemrmrk$Gsvtsvexmsr?$ Iqiveph

Gsqtermiw?$PeWeppi$Wsyxl{iwx$Gsvvigxmsrw?$Kvsyt$8$Wigyvmgsv?$Wshi|s$Nywxmgi$Wivzmgiw$,jsvqivp}$Oe}p|-?$erh$Wivgs2$Syv$KIS$Gevi

fywmriww$wikqirx$gsqtixiw${mxl$e$ryqfiv$sj$hmjjivirx$wqepp1xs1qihmyq$wm~ih$gsqtermiw0$vijpigxmrk$xli$lmklp}$jvekqirxih$rexyvi$sj

xli$}syxl$wivzmgiw$erh$gsqqyrmx}$fewih$wivzmgiw$mrhywxv}2$FM×w$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$fywmriww$gsqtixiw${mxl$e$ryqfiv$sj$gsqtermiw0

mrgpyhmrk0$fyx$rsx$pmqmxih$xs>$K8$Nywxmgi$Wivzmgiw0$PPG$erh$7Q$Ipigxvsrmg$Qsrmxsvmrk0$e$7Q$Gsqter}2$Wsqi$sj$syv$gsqtixmxsvw$evi

pevkiv$ erh$lezi$qsvi$ viwsyvgiw$ xler${i$ hs2$[i$epws$ gsqtixi$ mr$ wsqi$qevoixw${mxl$ wqepp$ psgep$ gsqtermiw$ xlex$qe}$lezi$ e$fixxiv

ors{pihki$sj$xli$psgep$gsrhmxmsrw$erh$qe}$fi$fixxiv$efpi$xs$kemr$tspmxmgep$erh$tyfpmg$eggitxergi2

Iqtps}iiw$erh$Iqtps}ii$Xvemrmrk

Ex$Higiqfiv$750$645=0${i$leh$ettvs|mqexip}$660444$jypp1xmqi$iqtps}iiw2$Sj$syv$jypp1xmqi$iqtps}iiw0$ettvs|mqexip}$:;4${ivi

iqtps}ih$ex$syv$gsvtsvexi$liehuyevxivw$erh$vikmsrep$sjjmgiw$erh$ettvs|mqexip}$650444${ivi$iqtps}ih$ex$jegmpmxmiw$erh$mrxivrexmsrep

sjjmgiw2$[i$iqtps}$tivwsrrip$mr$tswmxmsrw$sj$qerekiqirx0$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$erh$gpivmgep0$wigyvmx}0$ihygexmsrep$wivzmgiw0$lyqer$viwsyvgi

wivzmgiw0$liepxl$wivzmgiw$erh$kirivep$qemrxirergi$ex$syv$zevmsyw$psgexmsrw2$Ettvs|mqexip}$90444$erh$60444$iqtps}iiw$evi$gszivih$f}

gsppigxmzi$fevkemrmrk$ekviiqirxw$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw$erh$ex$mrxivrexmsrep$sjjmgiw0$viwtigxmzip}2$[i$fipmizi$xlex$syv$vipexmsrw${mxl$syv

iqtps}iiw$evi$wexmwjegxsv}2

Yrhiv$xli$pe{w$ettpmgefpi$xs$qswx$sj$syv$stivexmsrw0$erh$mrxivrep$gsqter}$tspmgmiw0$syv$gsvvigxmsrep$sjjmgivw$evi$viuymvih$xs

gsqtpixi$e$qmrmqyq$eqsyrx$sj$xvemrmrk2$[i$kirivepp}$viuymvi$ex$piewx$84$lsyvw$sj$tvi1wivzmgi$xvemrmrk$fijsvi$er$iqtps}ii$mw$epps{ih

xs$ewwyqi$xlimv$hyxmiw$tpyw$er$ehhmxmsrep$564$lsyvw$sj$xvemrmrk$hyvmrk$xlimv$jmvwx$}iev$sj$iqtps}qirx$mr$syv$hsqiwxmg$jegmpmxmiw0

gsrwmwxirx${mxl$EGE$wxerhevhw$erh3sv$ettpmgefpi$wxexi$pe{w2$Mr$ehhmxmsr$xs$xli$ywyep$5:4$lsyvw$sj$xvemrmrk$mr$xli$jmvwx$}iev0$qswx$wxexiw

viuymvi$84$sv$<4$lsyvw$sj$sr1xli1nsf$xvemrmrk2$Jpsvmhe$pe{$viuymviw$xlex$gsvvigxmsrep$sjjmgivw$vigimzi$964$lsyvw$sj$xvemrmrk2$[i$fipmizi

xlex$syv$xvemrmrk$tvskveqw$qiix$sv$i|giih$epp$ettpmgefpi$viuymviqirxw2

Syv$xvemrmrk$tvskveq$jsv$hsqiwxmg$jegmpmxmiw$x}tmgepp}$fikmrw${mxl$ettvs|mqexip}$84$lsyvw$sj$mrwxvygxmsr$vikevhmrk$syv$tspmgmiw0

stivexmsrep$tvsgihyviw$erh$qerekiqirx$tlmpswstl}2$Xvemrmrk$gsrxmryiw${mxl$er$ehhmxmsrep$564$lsyvw$sj$mrwxvygxmsr$gszivmrk$pikep

mwwyiw0$vmklxw$sj$mrhmzmhyepw${mxlmr$syv$gevi0$xiglrmuyiw$sj$gsqqyrmgexmsr$erh$wytivzmwmsr0$mrxivtivwsrep$womppw

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 30 of 253

Page 53: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 74367<

66

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 31 of 253

Page 54: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 75367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

erh$nsf$xvemrmrk$vipexmrk$xs$xli$tevxmgypev$tswmxmsr$xs$fi$liph2$Iegl$sj$syv$iqtps}iiw${ls$lew$gsrxegx${mxl$mrhmzmhyepw${mxlmr$syv$gevi

vigimziw$e$qmrmqyq$sj$84$lsyvw$sj$ehhmxmsrep$xvemrmrk$iegl$}iev0$erh$iegl$qerekiv$vigimziw$ex$piewx$68$lsyvw$sj$xvemrmrk$iegl$}iev2

Ex$piewx$5:4$lsyvw$sj$xvemrmrk$evi$viuymvih$jsv$syv$iqtps}iiw$mr$Eywxvepme$erh$Wsyxl$Ejvmge$fijsvi$wygl$iqtps}iiw$evi$epps{ih$xs

{svo$mr$tswmxmsrw$xlex${mpp$fvmrk$xliq$mrxs$gsrxegx${mxl$mrhmzmhyepw${mxlmr$syv$gevi2$Syv$iqtps}iiw$mr$Eywxvepme$erh$Wsyxl$Ejvmge

vigimzi$e$qmrmqyq$sj$84$lsyvw$sj$vijviwliv$xvemrmrk$iegl$}iev2$Mr$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq0$syv$gsvvigxmsrw$iqtps}iiw$epws$vigimzi$e

qmrmqyq$sj$684$lsyvw$sj$xvemrmrk$tvmsv$xs$gsqmrk$mr$gsrxegx${mxl$mrhmzmhyepw${mxlmr$syv$gevi$erh$vigimzi$ehhmxmsrep$xvemrmrk$sj

ettvs|mqexip}$69$lsyvw$erryepp}2

[mxl$viwtigx$xs$FM$erh$xli$MWET$wivzmgiw$gsrxvegx0$ri{$iqtps}iiw$evi$viuymvih$xs$gsqtpixi$xvemrmrk$viuymviqirxw$ew$syxpmrih$mr

xli$gsrxvegx${mxlmr$58$he}w$sj$lmvi$erh$tvmsv$xs$fimrk$ewwmkrih$eyxsrsqsyw$MWET$vipexih$hyxmiw2$Xliwi$iqtps}iiw$vigimzi$69$lsyvw$sj

vijviwliv$xvemrmrk$erryepp}$xliviejxiv2$Tvskveq$qerekivw$jsv$syv$MWET$gsrxvegx$qywx$vigimzi$68$lsyvw$sj$ehhmxmsrep$mrmxmep$xvemrmrk2$FM×w

qsrmxsvmrk$ wivzmgiw$ qemrxemrw$ mxw$ s{r$ gsqtvilirwmzi$ givxmjmgexmsr$ erh$ xvemrmrk$ tvskveq$ jsv$ epp$ qsrmxsvmrk$ wivzmgi$ wtigmepmwxw2$[i

viuymvi$ epp$ ri{$ tivwsrrip$ lmvih$ jsv$ e$ tswmxmsr$ mr$ qsrmxsvmrk$ stivexmsrw$ xs$ gsqtpixi$ e$ wizir1{iio$ xvemrmrk$ tvskveq2$ Wyggiwwjyp

gsqtpixmsr$sj$syv$xvemrmrk$tvskveq$erh$e$jmrep$givxmjmgexmsr$mw$viuymvih$sj$epp$sj$syv$tivwsrrip$tivjsvqmrk$qsrmxsvmrk$stivexmsrw2$[i

viuymvi$xlex$givxmjmgexmsr$mw$eglmizih$tvmsv$xs$fimrk$tivqmxxih$xs${svo$mrhitirhirxp}$mr$xli$gepp$girxiv2

Fywmriww$Vikypexmsrw$erh$Pikep$Gsrwmhivexmsrw

Qer}$kszivrqirxep$ekirgmiw$evi$viuymvih$xs$irxiv$mrxs$e$gsqtixmxmzi$fmhhmrk$tvsgihyvi$fijsvi$e{evhmrk$gsrxvegxw$jsv$tvshygxw

sv$ wivzmgiw2$Xli$ pe{w$sj$givxemr$ nyvmwhmgxmsrw$qe}$epws$ viuymvi$yw$ xs$e{evh$ wyfgsrxvegxw$ sr$e$gsqtixmxmzi$fewmw$sv$ xs$ wyfgsrxvegx$sv

tevxriv${mxl$fywmriwwiw$s{rih$f}${sqir$sv$qiqfivw$sj$qmrsvmx}$kvsytw2

Givxemr$ wxexiw0$ wygl$ ew$ Jpsvmhe0$ hiiq$ gsvvigxmsrep$ sjjmgivw$ xs$ fi$ tiegi$ sjjmgivw$ erh$ viuymvi$ syv$ tivwsrrip$ xs$ fi$ pmgirwih$ erh

wyfnigx$xs$fegokvsyrh$mrziwxmkexmsr2$Wxexi$pe{$epws$x}tmgepp}$viuymviw$gsvvigxmsrep$sjjmgivw$xs$qiix$givxemr$xvemrmrk$wxerhevhw2

Xli$ jempyvi$ xs$gsqtp}${mxl$er}$ettpmgefpi$ pe{w0$ vypiw$sv$ vikypexmsrw$sv$ xli$ psww$sj$er}$ viuymvih$ pmgirwi$gsyph$lezi$e$qexivmep

ehzivwi$ijjigx$sr$syv$fywmriww0$ jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2$Jyvxlivqsvi0$syv$gyvvirx$erh$jyxyvi$stivexmsrw$qe}$fi

wyfnigx$xs$ehhmxmsrep$vikypexmsrw$ew$e$viwypx$sj0$eqsrk$sxliv$jegxsvw0$ri{$wxexyxiw$erh$vikypexmsrw$erh$glerkiw$mr$xli$qerriv$mr${lmgl

i|mwxmrk$wxexyxiw$erh$vikypexmsrw$evi$sv$qe}$fi$mrxivtvixih$sv$ettpmih2$Er}$wygl$ehhmxmsrep$vikypexmsrw$gsyph$lezi$e$qexivmep$ehzivwi

ijjigx$sr$syv$fywmriww0$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2

Mrwyvergi

Xli$rexyvi$sj$syv$fywmriww$i|tswiw$yw$xs$zevmsyw$x}tiw$sj$xlmvh1tevx}$pikep$gpemqw0$mrgpyhmrk0$fyx$rsx$pmqmxih$xs0$gmzmp$vmklxw$gpemqw

vipexmrk$ xs$ gsrhmxmsrw$ sj$ gsrjmriqirx$ erh3sv$ qmwxviexqirx0$ wi|yep$ qmwgsrhygx$ gpemqw$ fvsyklx$ f}$ tvmwsrivw$ sv$ hixemriiw0$ qihmgep

qeptvegxmgi$ gpemqw0$ tvshygx$ pmefmpmx}$ gpemqw0$ mrxippigxyep$ tvstivx}$ mrjvmrkiqirx$ gpemqw0$ gpemqw$ vipexmrk$ xs$ iqtps}qirx$ qexxivw

,mrgpyhmrk0$fyx$rsx$pmqmxih$xs0$iqtps}qirx$hmwgvmqmrexmsr$gpemqw0$yrmsr$kvmizergiw$erh${eki$erh$lsyv$gpemqw-0$tvstivx}$psww$gpemqw0

irzmvsrqirxep$gpemqw0$eyxsqsfmpi$pmefmpmx}$gpemqw0$gsrxvegxyep$gpemqw$erh$gpemqw$jsv$tivwsrep$mrnyv}$sv$sxliv$heqekiw$viwypxmrk$jvsq

gsrxegx$ {mxl$ syv$ jegmpmxmiw0$ tvskveqw0$ ipigxvsrmg$ qsrmxsvmrk$ tvshygxw0$ tivwsrrip$ sv$ tvmwsrivw0$ mrgpyhmrk$ heqekiw$ evmwmrk$ jvsq$ e

tvmwsriv×w$iwgeti$sv$jvsq$e$hmwxyvfergi$sv$vmsx$ex$e$jegmpmx}2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$syv$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$kirivepp}$viuymvi$yw$xs$mrhiqrmj}$xli

kszivrqirxep$ ekirg}$ ekemrwx$ er}$ heqekiw$ xs$ {lmgl$ xli$ kszivrqirxep$ ekirg}$ qe}$ fi$ wyfnigx$ mr$ gsrrigxmsr$ {mxl$ wygl$ gpemqw$ sv

pmxmkexmsr2$ [i$ qemrxemr$ e$ fvseh$ tvskveq$ sj$ mrwyvergi$ gsziveki$ jsv$ xliwi$ kirivep$ x}tiw$ sj$ gpemqw0$ i|gitx$ jsv$ gpemqw$ vipexmrk$ xs

iqtps}qirx$qexxivw0$jsv${lmgl${i$gevv}$rs$mrwyvergi2$Xlivi$ger$fi$rs$ewwyvergi$xlex$syv$mrwyvergi$gsziveki${mpp$fi$ehiuyexi$xs$gsziv

epp$gpemqw$ xs${lmgl${i$qe}$fi$i|tswih2$ Mx$ mw$syv$kirivep$tvegxmgi$xs$fvmrk$qivkih$sv$eguymvih$gsqtermiw$mrxs$syv$gsvtsvexi$qewxiv

tspmgmiw$mr$svhiv$xs$xeoi$ehzerxeki$sj$givxemr$igsrsqmiw$sj$wgepi2

[i$gyvvirxp}$qemrxemr$e$kirivep$pmefmpmx}$tspmg}$erh$i|giww$pmefmpmx}$tspmgmiw${mxl$xsxep$pmqmxw$sj$(<424$qmppmsr$tiv$sggyvvirgi$erh

mr$xli$ekkvikexi$gszivmrk$xli$stivexmsrw$sj$Y2W2$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw0$KIS$Gevi+w$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$wivzmgiw0$KIS$Gevi+w$}syxl$wivzmgiw

erh$ FM2$[i$ lezi$ e$ gpemqw1qehi$ pmefmpmx}$ mrwyvergi$ tvskveq${mxl$ e$ wtigmjmg$ psww$ pmqmx$ sj$ (7924$qmppmsr$ tiv$ sggyvvirgi$ erh$ mr$ xli

ekkvikexi$ vipexih$ xs$qihmgep$ tvsjiwwmsrep$ pmefmpmx}$ gpemqw$ evmwmrk$ syx$ sj$ gsvvigxmsrep$ liepxlgevi$ wivzmgiw2$[i$ evi$ yrmrwyvih$ jsv$ er}

gpemqw$ mr$ i|giww$ sj$ xliwi$ pmqmxw2$ [i$ epws$ qemrxemr$ mrwyvergi$ xs$ gsziv$ tvstivx}$ erh$ sxliv$ gewyepx}$ vmwow$ mrgpyhmrk0$ {svoivw×

gsqtirwexmsr0$irzmvsrqirxep$pmefmpmx}$erh$eyxsqsfmpi$pmefmpmx}2

Jsv$qswx$gewyepx}$mrwyvergi$tspmgmiw0${i$gevv}$wyfwxerxmep$hihygxmfpiw$sv$wipj1mrwyvih$vixirxmsrw$sj$(724$qmppmsr$tiv$sggyvvirgi$jsv

kirivep$ pmefmpmx}$ erh$ qihmgep$ tvsjiwwmsrep$ pmefmpmx}0$ (624$ qmppmsr$ tiv$ sggyvvirgi$ jsv$ {svoivw×$ gsqtirwexmsr$ erh$ (524$ qmppmsr$ tiv

sggyvvirgi$ jsv$ eyxsqsfmpi$ pmefmpmx}2$ Mr$ehhmxmsr0$ givxemr$sj$ syv$ jegmpmxmiw$ psgexih$ mr$Jpsvmhe$erh$sxliv$ lmkl1vmwo$lyvvmgeri$ eview$ gevv}

wyfwxerxmep${mrhwxsvq$hihygxmfpiw2$Wmrgi$lyvvmgeriw$evi$gsrwmhivih$yrtvihmgxefpi$jyxyvi$izirxw0$rs$viwivziw$lezi$fiir$iwxefpmwlih$xs

tvi1jyrh$jsv$tsxirxmep${mrhwxsvq$heqeki2$Pmqmxih$gsqqivgmep$ezempefmpmx}$sj$givxemr$x}tiw$sj$mrwyvergi$vipexmrk$xs

67

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 32 of 253

Page 55: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 76367<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 33 of 253

Page 56: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 77367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

{mrhwxsvq$i|tswyvi$ mr$gsewxep$eview$ erh$ ievxluyeoi$ i|tswyvi$qemrp}$ mr$Gepmjsvrme$erh$ xli$Tegmjmg$Rsvxl{iwx$qe}$tvizirx$ yw$ jvsq

mrwyvmrk$wsqi$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$xs$jypp$vitpegiqirx$zepyi2

[mxl$viwtigx$xs$syv$stivexmsrw$mr$Wsyxl$Ejvmge0$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq$erh$Eywxvepme0${i$yxmpm~i$e$gsqfmrexmsr$sj$psgepp}1tvsgyvih

mrwyvergi$erh$kpsfep$tspmgmiw$xs$qiix$gsrxvegxyep$mrwyvergi$viuymviqirxw$erh$xs$tvsxigx$yw2$Mr$ehhmxmsr$xs$xliwi$tspmgmiw0$syv$Eywxvepmer

wyfwmhmev}$gevvmiw$xemp$mrwyvergi$sr$e$kirivep$pmefmpmx}$tspmg}$vipexih$xs$e$hmwgsrxmryih$gsrxvegx2

Sj$xli$viwivziw$hmwgywwih$efszi0$syv$qswx$wmkrmjmgerx$mrwyvergi$viwivziw$vipexi$xs${svoivw×$gsqtirwexmsr0$kirivep$ pmefmpmx}$erh

eyxs$ gpemqw2$ Xliwi$ viwivziw$ evi$ yrhmwgsyrxih$ erh$ {ivi$ (:<26$ qmppmsr$ erh$ (;42=$ qmppmsr$ ew$ sj$ Higiqfiv$ 750$ 645=$ erh$ 645<0

viwtigxmzip}$ erh$ evi$ mrgpyhih$ mr$ eggvyih$ i|tirwiw$ mr$ xli$ eggsqter}mrk$ fepergi$ wliixw2$[i$ywi$ wxexmwxmgep$ erh$ egxyevmep$qixlshw$ xs

iwxmqexi$eqsyrxw$jsv$gpemqw$xlex$lezi$fiir$vitsvxih$fyx$rsx$temh$erh$gpemqw$mrgyvvih$fyx$rsx$vitsvxih2$Mr$ettp}mrk$xliwi$qixlshw$erh

ewwiwwmrk$ xlimv$ viwypxw0$ {i$ gsrwmhiv$ wygl$ jegxsvw$ ew$ lmwxsvmgep$ jviuyirg}$ erh$ wizivmx}$ sj$ gpemqw$ ex$ iegl$ sj$ syv$ jegmpmxmiw0$ gpemq

hizipstqirx0$te}qirx$texxivrw$erh$glerkiw$mr$xli$rexyvi$sj$syv$fywmriww0$eqsrk$sxliv$jegxsvw2$Wygl$jegxsvw$evi$erep}~ih$jsv$iegl$sj

syv$ fywmriww$ wikqirxw2$ Syv$ iwxmqexiw$qe}$ fi$ mqtegxih$ f}$ wygl$ jegxsvw$ ew$ mrgviewiw$ mr$ xli$qevoix$ tvmgi$ jsv$qihmgep$ wivzmgiw$ erh

yrtvihmgxefmpmx}$sj$xli$wm~i$sj$nyv}$e{evhw2$[i$epws$qe}$i|tivmirgi$zevmefmpmx}$fix{iir$syv$iwxmqexiw$erh$xli$egxyep$wixxpiqirx$hyi$xs

pmqmxexmsrw$ mrlivirx$ mr$ xli$ iwxmqexmsr$ tvsgiww0$ mrgpyhmrk$ syv$ efmpmx}$ xs$ iwxmqexi$ gswxw$ sj$ tvsgiwwmrk$ erh$ wixxpmrk$ gpemqw$ mr$ e$ xmqip}

qerriv$ew${ipp$ew$syv$efmpmx}$xs$eggyvexip}$iwxmqexi$syv$i|tswyvi$ex$xli$srwix$sj$e$gpemq2$Figeywi${i$lezi$lmkl$hihygxmfpi$mrwyvergi

tspmgmiw0$xli$eqsyrx$sj$syv$mrwyvergi$i|tirwi$mw$hitirhirx$sr$syv$efmpmx}$xs$gsrxvsp$syv$gpemqw$i|tivmirgi2$Mj$egxyep$pswwiw$vipexih$xs

mrwyvergi$ gpemqw$ wmkrmjmgerxp}$ hmjjiv$ jvsq$ syv$ iwxmqexiw0$ syv$ jmrergmep$ gsrhmxmsr0$ viwypxw$ sj$ stivexmsrw$ erh$ gewl$ jps{w$ gsyph$ fi

qexivmepp}$ehzivwip}$mqtegxih2

Mrxivrexmsrep$Stivexmsrw

Syv$mrxivrexmsrep$stivexmsrw$jsv$jmwgep$}ievw$645=0$645<$erh$645;$gsrwmwxih$sj$xli$stivexmsrw$sj$syv${lspp}1s{rih$Eywxvepmer

wyfwmhmevmiw0$syv${lspp}$s{rih$wyfwmhmev}$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq0$erh$Wsyxl$Ejvmger$Gywxshmep$Qerekiqirx$Tx}2$Pmqmxih0$syv

gsrwspmhexih$nsmrx$zirxyvi$mr$Wsyxl$Ejvmge0${lmgl${i$vijiv$xs$ew$WEGQ2$Mr$Eywxvepme0$syv${lspp}1s{rih$wyfwmhmev}0$KIS$Eywxvepme0

gyvvirxp}$qerekiw$jsyv$jegmpmxmiw2$[i$stivexi$sri$jegmpmx}$mr$Wsyxl$Ejvmge$xlvsykl$WEGQ2$Syv${lspp}1s{rih$wyfwmhmev}$mr$xli$Yrmxih

Omrkhsq0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt$YO$Pxh20$stivexiw$xli$65;1fih$Hyrkezip$Lsywi$Mqqmkvexmsr$Viqszep$Girxvi$psgexih$riev$Kpewks{0

Wgsxperh2$Wii$Mxiq$;$jsv$qsvi$hmwgywwmsr$vipexih$xs$xli$viwypxw$sj$syv$mrxivrexmsrep$stivexmsrw2$Jmrergmep$mrjsvqexmsr$efsyx$syv

stivexmsrw$mr$hmjjivirx$kiskvetlmg$vikmsrw$ettievw$mr$Rsxi15:$Fywmriww$Wikqirxw$erh$Kiskvetlmg$Mrjsvqexmsr$mr$xli$rsxiw$xs$syv

eyhmxih$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$MM0$Mxiq$<$sj$xlmw$erryep$vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O2

Fywmriww$Gsrgirxvexmsr

I|gitx$jsv$xli$qensv$gywxsqivw$rsxih$mr$xli$jspps{mrk$xefpi0$rs$sxliv$wmrkpi$gywxsqiv$qehi$yt$kviexiv$xler$54)$sj$syv

gsrwspmhexih$viziryiw$jsv$xliwi$}ievw2$

Gywxsqiv 645= $ 645< $ 645;

Zevmsyw$ekirgmiw$sj$xli$Y2W2$Jihivep$Kszivrqirx> 97) $ 94) $ 8<)

Gvihmx$vmwo$vipexih$xs$eggsyrxw$vigimzefpi$mw$vijpigxmzi$sj$xli$vipexih$viziryiw2$Xli$qevkmrw$sr$syv$jihivep$gsrxvegxw$evi$efszi$xli

gsqter}$eziveki$hyi$xs$xli$jegx$xlex$xli}$evi$gsqter}1s{rih$jegmpmxmiw2

Ezempefpi$Mrjsvqexmsr

Ehhmxmsrep$mrjsvqexmsr$efsyx$yw$ger$fi$jsyrh$ex${{{2kiskvsyt2gsq2$[i$qeoi$ezempefpi$sr$syv${ifwmxi0$jvii$sj$glevki0$eggiww$xs

syv$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O0$Uyevxivp}$Vitsvxw$sr$Jsvq$541U0$Gyvvirx$Vitsvxw$sr$Jsvq$<1O0$syv$erryep$tvs|}$wxexiqirx$sr

Wglihypi$58E$erh$eqirhqirxw$xs$xlswi$qexivmepw$jmpih$sv$jyvrmwlih$tyvwyerx$xs$Wigxmsr$57,e-$sv$59,h-$sj$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$erh$I|glerki

Egx$sj$5=78$ew$wssr$ew$viewsrefp}$tvegxmgefpi$ejxiv${i$ipigxvsrmgepp}$wyfqmx$wygl$qexivmepw$xs$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$erh$I|glerki

Gsqqmwwmsr0$sv$xli$WIG2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$xli$WIG$qeoiw$ezempefpi$sr$mxw${ifwmxi0$jvii$sj$glevki0$vitsvxw0$tvs|}$erh$mrjsvqexmsr

wxexiqirxw0$erh$sxliv$mrjsvqexmsr$vikevhmrk$mwwyivw$xlex$jmpi$ipigxvsrmgepp}${mxl$xli$WIG0$mrgpyhmrk$KIS2$Xli$WIG×w${ifwmxi$mw$psgexih

ex$lxxt>33{{{2wig2ksz2$Mrjsvqexmsr$tvszmhih$sr$syv${ifwmxi$sv$sr$xli$WIG×w${ifwmxi$mw$rsx$tevx$sj$xlmw$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O2

Mxiq$5E2 Vmwo$Jegxsvw

Xli$jspps{mrk$evi$givxemr$vmwow$xs${lmgl$syv$fywmriww$stivexmsrw$evi$wyfnigx2$Er}$sj$xliwi$vmwow$gsyph$qexivmepp}$ehzivwip}$ejjigx

syv$fywmriww0$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr0$sv$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2$Xliwi$vmwow$gsyph$epws$geywi$syv$egxyep$viwypxw$xs$hmjjiv$qexivmepp}$jvsq$xlswi

mrhmgexih$mr$xli$jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw$gsrxemrih$livimr$erh$ipwi{livi2$Xli$vmwow$hiwgvmfih$fips{$evi$rsx$xli

68

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 34 of 253

Page 57: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 78367<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 35 of 253

Page 58: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 79367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

srp}$vmwow${i$ jegi2$Ehhmxmsrep$vmwow$rsx$gyvvirxp}$ors{r$xs$yw$sv$ xlswi${i$gyvvirxp}$hiiq$xs$fi$mqqexivmep$qe}$epws$qexivmepp}$erh

ehzivwip}$ejjigx$syv$fywmriww$stivexmsrw2

Vmwow$Vipexih$xs$VIMX$Wxexyw

Mj${i$jemp$xs$viqemr$uyepmjmih$ew$e$VIMX0${i${mpp$fi$wyfnigx$xs$Y2W2$jihivep$mrgsqi$xe|$ew$e$vikypev$gsvtsvexmsr$erh$gsyph$jegi$e

wyfwxerxmep$xe|$pmefmpmx}0${lmgl${syph$vihygi$xli$eqsyrx$sj$gewl$ezempefpi$jsv$hmwxvmfyxmsr$xs$syv$wlevilsphivw2

[i$ fiker$ stivexmrk$ ew$ e$ VIMX$ sr$ Neryev}$ 50$ 64572$[i$ vigimzih$ er$ stmrmsr$ sj$ syv$ wtigmep$ VIMX$ xe|$ gsyrwip$ ,ÔWtigmep$ Xe|

GsyrwipÕ-${mxl$viwtigx$xs$syv$uyepmjmgexmsr$ew$e$VIMX2$Mrziwxsvw$wlsyph$fi$e{evi0$ls{iziv0$xlex$stmrmsrw$sj$gsyrwip$evi$rsx$fmrhmrk$sr

xli$Mrxivrep$Viziryi$Wivzmgi$,xli$ÔMVWÕ-$sv$er}$gsyvx2$Xli$stmrmsr$sj$Wtigmep$Xe|$Gsyrwip$vitviwirxw$srp}$xli$zmi{$sj$Wtigmep$Xe|

Gsyrwip$fewih$sr$mxw$vizmi{$erh$erep}wmw$sj$i|mwxmrk$pe{$erh$sr$givxemr$vitviwirxexmsrw$ew$xs$jegxyep$qexxivw$erh$gszirerxw$qehi$f}$yw0

mrgpyhmrk$vitviwirxexmsrw$ vipexmrk$ xs$ xli$zepyiw$sj$syv$ewwixw$erh$ xli$wsyvgiw$sj$syv$ mrgsqi2$Xli$stmrmsr$mw$i|tviwwih$ew$sj$xli$hexi

mwwyih2$Wtigmep$Xe|$Gsyrwip$lew$rs$sfpmkexmsr$xs$ehzmwi$yw$sv$xli$lsphivw$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo$sj$er}$wyfwiuyirx$glerki$mr$xli$qexxivw

wxexih0$vitviwirxih$sv$ewwyqih$sv$sj$er}$wyfwiuyirx$glerki$mr$ettpmgefpi$pe{2$Jyvxlivqsvi0$fsxl$xli$zepmhmx}$sj$xli$stmrmsr$sj$Wtigmep

Xe|$Gsyrwip$ erh$ syv$ uyepmjmgexmsr$ ew$ e$ VIMX${mpp$ hitirh$ sr$ syv$ wexmwjegxmsr$ sj$ givxemr$ ewwix0$ mrgsqi0$ svkerm~exmsrep0$ hmwxvmfyxmsr0

wlevilsphiv$ s{rivwlmt$ erh$ sxliv$ viuymviqirxw$ sr$ e$ gsrxmrymrk$ fewmw0$ xli$ viwypxw$ sj$ {lmgl$ {mpp$ rsx$ fi$ qsrmxsvih$ f}$ Wtigmep$ Xe|

Gsyrwip2$Syv$efmpmx}$xs$wexmwj}$ xli$ewwix$ xiwxw$hitirhw$ytsr$syv$erep}wmw$sj$xli$glevegxivm~exmsr$erh$jemv$qevoix$zepyiw$sj$syv$ewwixw0

wsqi$sj${lmgl$evi$rsx$wywgitxmfpi$xs$e$tvigmwi$hixivqmrexmsr0$erh$jsv${lmgl${i${mpp$rsx$sfxemr$mrhitirhirx$ettvemwepw2

[i$lezi$vigimzih$e$jezsvefpi$tvmzexi$pixxiv$vypmrk$jvsq$xli$MVW${mxl$viwtigx$ xs$givxemr$mwwyiw$vipizerx$xs$syv$uyepmjmgexmsr$ew$e

VIMX2$Epxlsykl${i$qe}$kirivepp}$vip}$ytsr$xli$vypmrk0$rs$ewwyvergi$ger$fi$kmzir$xlex$xli$MVW${mpp$rsx$gleppirki$syv$uyepmjmgexmsr$ew$e

VIMX$sr$xli$fewmw$sj$sxliv$mwwyiw$sv$jegxw$syxwmhi$xli$wgsti$sj$xli$vypmrk2

Mj${i$jemp$ xs$uyepmj}$ew$e$VIMX$mr$er}$ xe|efpi$}iev0${i${syph$fi$wyfnigx$ xs$Y2W2$ jihivep$ mrgsqi$ xe|$sr$syv$ xe|efpi$ mrgsqi$ex

vikypev$gsvtsvexi$vexiw0$erh$hmzmhirhw$temh$xs$syv$wlevilsphivw${syph$rsx$fi$hihygxmfpi$f}$yw$mr$gsqtyxmrk$syv$xe|efpi$mrgsqi2$Er}

viwypxmrk$gsvtsvexi$xe|$pmefmpmx}$gsyph$fi$wyfwxerxmep$erh${syph$vihygi$xli$eqsyrx$sj$gewl$ezempefpi$jsv$hmwxvmfyxmsr$xs$syv$wlevilsphivw0

{lmgl$ mr$ xyvr$ gsyph$ lezi$ er$ ehzivwi$ mqtegx$ sr$ xli$ zepyi$ sj$ syv$ gsqqsr$ wxsgo2$ Yrpiww$ {i$ {ivi$ irxmxpih$ xs$ vipmij$ yrhiv$ givxemr

tvszmwmsrw$sj$xli$Mrxivrep$Viziryi$Gshi$sj$5=<:0$ew$eqirhih$,xli$&Gshi&-0${i$epws${syph$fi$hmwuyepmjmih$jvsq$vi1ipigxmrk$xs$fi$xe|ih

ew$e$VIMX$jsv$xli$jsyv$xe|efpi$}ievw$jspps{mrk$xli$}iev$mr${lmgl${i$jempih$xs$uyepmj}$ew$e$VIMX2$Mj${i$jemp$xs$uyepmj}$jsv$xe|exmsr$ew$e

VIMX0${i$qe}$riih$ xs$fsvvs{$ehhmxmsrep$jyrhw$sv$pmuymhexi$wsqi$mrziwxqirxw$ xs$te}$er}$ehhmxmsrep$xe|$pmefmpmx}2$Eggsvhmrkp}0$jyrhw

ezempefpi$jsv$mrziwxqirx$erh$qeomrk$te}qirxw$sr$syv$mrhifxihriww${syph$fi$vihygih2

Uyepmj}mrk$ew$e$VIMX$mrzspziw$lmklp}$xiglrmgep$erh$gsqtpi|$tvszmwmsrw$sj$xli$Gshi2

Uyepmjmgexmsr$ew$e$VIMX$mrzspziw$xli$ettpmgexmsr$sj$lmklp}$xiglrmgep$erh$gsqtpi|$Gshi$tvszmwmsrw$jsv${lmgl$srp}$pmqmxih$nyhmgmep

erh$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$eyxlsvmxmiw$i|mwx2$Izir$e$xiglrmgep$sv$mrehzivxirx$zmspexmsr$gsyph$nistevhm~i$syv$VIMX$uyepmjmgexmsr2$Syv

uyepmjmgexmsr$ew$e$VIMX${mpp$hitirh$sr$syv$wexmwjegxmsr$sj$givxemr$ewwix0$mrgsqi0$svkerm~exmsrep0$hmwxvmfyxmsr0$wlevilsphiv$s{rivwlmt$erh

sxliv$viuymviqirxw$sr$e$gsrxmrymrk$fewmw2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$syv$efmpmx}$xs$wexmwj}$xli$viuymviqirxw$xs$uyepmj}$ew$e$VIMX$hitirhw$mr$tevx$sr$xli

egxmsrw$sj$xlmvh$tevxmiw$sziv${lmgl${i$lezi$rs$gsrxvsp$sv$srp}$pmqmxih$mrjpyirgi2

Gsqtp}mrk${mxl$xli$VIMX$viuymviqirxw$qe}$geywi$yw$xs$pmuymhexi$sv$jsvks$sxliv{mwi$exxvegxmzi$sttsvxyrmxmiw2

Xs$qemrxemr$syv$uyepmjmgexmsr$ew$e$VIMX0${i$qywx$irwyvi$xlex0$ex$xli$irh$sj$iegl$gepirhev$uyevxiv0$ex$piewx$;9)$sj$xli$zepyi$sj$syv

ewwixw$gsrwmwxw$sj$gewl0$gewl$mxiqw0$kszivrqirx$wigyvmxmiw$erh$Ôviep$iwxexi$ewwixwÕ$,ew$hijmrih$mr$xli$Gshi-0$mrgpyhmrk$givxemr$qsvxkeki

pserw$erh$wigyvmxmiw2$Xli$viqemrhiv$sj$syv$mrziwxqirxw$,sxliv$xler$kszivrqirx$wigyvmxmiw0$uyepmjmih$viep$iwxexi$ewwixw$erh$wigyvmxmiw

mwwyih$f}$e$XVW-$kirivepp}$gerrsx$mrgpyhi$qsvi$xler$54)$sj$xli$syxwxerhmrk$zsxmrk$wigyvmxmiw$sj$er}$sri$mwwyiv$sv$qsvi$xler$54)$sj

xli$xsxep$zepyi$sj$xli$syxwxerhmrk$wigyvmxmiw$sj$er}$sri$mwwyiv2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$mr$kirivep0$rs$qsvi$xler$9)$sj$xli$zepyi$sj$syv$xsxep$ewwixw

,sxliv$xler$kszivrqirx$wigyvmxmiw0$uyepmjmih$viep$iwxexi$ewwixw$erh$wigyvmxmiw$mwwyih$f}$e$XVW-$ger$gsrwmwx$sj$xli$wigyvmxmiw$sj$er}$sri

mwwyiv0$erh$rs$qsvi$xler$64)$sj$xli$zepyi$sj$syv$xsxep$ewwixw$ger$fi$vitviwirxih$f}$wigyvmxmiw$sj$sri$sv$qsvi$XVWw2$Mj${i$jemp$xs$gsqtp}

{mxl$xliwi$viuymviqirxw$ex$xli$irh$sj$er}$gepirhev$uyevxiv0${i$qywx$gsvvigx$xli$jempyvi${mxlmr$74$he}w$ejxiv$xli$irh$sj$xli$gepirhev

uyevxiv$sv$uyepmj}$jsv$givxemr$wxexyxsv}$vipmij$tvszmwmsrw$xs$ezsmh$pswmrk$syv$VIMX$uyepmjmgexmsr$erh$wyjjivmrk$ehzivwi$xe|$gsrwiuyirgiw2

Ew$e$viwypx0${i$qe}$fi$viuymvih$xs$pmuymhexi$sv$jsvks$sxliv{mwi$exxvegxmzi$mrziwxqirxw2$Xliwi$egxmsrw$gsyph$lezi$xli$ijjigx$sj$vihygmrk

syv$mrgsqi0$eqsyrxw$ezempefpi$jsv$hmwxvmfyxmsr$xs$syv$wlevilsphivw$erh$eqsyrxw$ezempefpi$jsv$qeomrk$te}qirxw$sr$syv$mrhifxihriww2

Mr$ehhmxmsr$xs$xli$ewwix$xiwxw$wix$jsvxl$efszi0$xs$qemrxemr$syv$uyepmjmgexmsr$ew$e$VIMX0${i$qywx$gsrxmryepp}$wexmwj}$xiwxw$gsrgivrmrk0

eqsrk$sxliv$xlmrkw0$xli$wsyvgiw$sj$syv$mrgsqi0$xli$eqsyrxw${i$hmwxvmfyxi$xs$syv$wlevilsphivw$erh$xli$s{rivwlmt$sj$syv$wxsgo2$[i$qe}

fi$yrefpi$xs$tyvwyi$mrziwxqirxw$xlex${syph$fi$sxliv{mwi$ehzerxekisyw$xs$yw$mr$svhiv$xs$wexmwj}$xli$wsyvgi1sj1

69

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 36 of 253

Page 59: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 7:367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

mrgsqi$sv$ewwix1hmzivwmjmgexmsr$viuymviqirxw$jsv$uyepmj}mrk$ew$e$VIMX2$Xlyw0$gsqtpmergi${mxl$xli$VIMX$viuymviqirxw$qe}$lmrhiv$syv

efmpmx}$xs$qeoi$givxemr$exxvegxmzi$mrziwxqirxw$erh$qeoi$te}qirxw$sr$syv$mrhifxihriww2

Hmzmhirhw$te}efpi$f}$VIMXw$hs$rsx$uyepmj}$jsv$xli$vihygih$xe|$vexiw$ezempefpi$jsv$wsqi$hmzmhirhw2

Xli$qe|mqyq$Y2W2$jihivep$mrgsqi$xe|$vexi$ettpmgefpi$xs$mrgsqi$jvsq$Ôuyepmjmih$hmzmhirhwÕ$te}efpi$xs$Y2W2$wlevilsphivw$xlex$evi

mrhmzmhyepw0$xvywxw$erh$iwxexiw$mw$gyvvirxp}$64)$i|gpywmzi$sj$xli$72<)$mrziwxqirx$xe|$wyvglevki2$Hmzmhirhw$te}efpi$f}$VIMXw0$ls{iziv0

qe}$srp}$fi$ipmkmfpi$mr$tevx$sv$rsx$ex$epp$jsv$xli$vihygih$vexiw$ettpmgefpi$xs$&uyepmjmih$hmzmhirhw&2$Epxlsykl$xliwi$vypiw$hs$rsx$ehzivwip}

ejjigx$xli$xe|exmsr$sj$VIMXw0$xli$qsvi$jezsvefpi$vexiw$ettpmgefpi$xs$vikypev$gsvtsvexi$uyepmjmih$hmzmhirhw$gsyph$geywi$mrziwxsvw${ls$evi

mrhmzmhyepw0$xvywxw$erh$iwxexiw$xs$tivgimzi$mrziwxqirxw$mr$VIMXw$xs$fi$vipexmzip}$piww$exxvegxmzi$xler$mrziwxqirxw$mr$xli$wxsgow$sj$rsr1

VIMX$gsvtsvexmsrw$ xlex$ te}$ hmzmhirhw0${lmgl$ gsyph$ ehzivwip}$ ejjigx$ xli$zepyi$sj$ xli$ wxsgo$sj$VIMXw0$ mrgpyhmrk$syv$ gsqqsr$ wxsgo2

Ls{iziv0$jsv$xe|efpi$}ievw$xlex$fikmr$ejxiv$Higiqfiv$750$645;$erh$fijsvi$Neryev}$50$646:0$wlevilsphivw$xlex$evi$mrhmzmhyepw0$xvywxw$sv

iwxexiw$evi$kirivepp}$irxmxpih$xs$e$hihygxmsr$iuyep$xs$64)$sj$xli$ekkvikexi$eqsyrx$sj$svhmrev}$mrgsqi$hmzmhirhw$vigimzih$jvsq$e$VIMX0

wyfnigx$xs$givxemr$pmqmxexmsrw2$Xlmw$64)$hihygxmsr$hsiw$rsx$ettp}$xs$Ôuyepmjmih$hmzmhirhw&2

VIMX$hmwxvmfyxmsr$viuymviqirxw$gsyph$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$syv$efmpmx}$xs$i|igyxi$syv$fywmriww$tper2

[i$kirivepp}$qywx$hmwxvmfyxi$erryepp}$ex$piewx$=4)$sj$syv$VIMX$xe|efpi$mrgsqi0$hixivqmrih${mxlsyx$vikevh$xs$xli$hmzmhirhw$temh

hihygxmsr$ erh$ i|gpyhmrk$ er}$rix$ getmxep$ kemrw0$ mr$ svhiv$ jsv$ yw$ xs$qemrxemr$syv$ uyepmjmgexmsr$ ew$ e$VIMX$ ,ewwyqmrk$ xlex$ givxemr$sxliv

viuymviqirxw$evi$epws$wexmwjmih-$ws$xlex$Y2W2$jihivep$gsvtsvexi$mrgsqi$xe|$hsiw$rsx$ettp}$xs$ievrmrkw$xlex${i$hmwxvmfyxi2$Xs$xli$i|xirx

xlex${i$wexmwj}$xlmw$hmwxvmfyxmsr$viuymviqirx$erh$qemrxemr$syv$uyepmjmgexmsr$jsv$xe|exmsr$ew$e$VIMX$fyx$hmwxvmfyxi$piww$xler$544)$sj$syv

VIMX$xe|efpi$mrgsqi0$mrgpyhmrk$er}$rix$getmxep$kemrw0${i${mpp$fi$wyfnigx$xs$Y2W2$jihivep$gsvtsvexi$mrgsqi$xe|$sr$syv$yrhmwxvmfyxih$rix

xe|efpi$ mrgsqi2$ Mr$ ehhmxmsr0$ {i$ {mpp$ fi$ wyfnigx$ xs$ e$ 8)$ rsrhihygxmfpi$ i|gmwi$ xe|$ mj$ xli$ egxyep$ eqsyrx$ xlex$ {i$ hmwxvmfyxi$ xs$ syv

wlevilsphivw$mr$e$gepirhev$}iev$mw$piww$xler$e$qmrmqyq$eqsyrx$wtigmjmih$yrhiv$Y2W2$jihivep$xe|$pe{w2$[i$mrxirh$xs$qeoi$hmwxvmfyxmsrw

xs$syv$wlevilsphivw$xs$gsqtp}${mxl$xli$VIMX$viuymviqirxw$sj$xli$Gshi$erh$ezsmh$gsvtsvexi$mrgsqi$xe|$erh$xli$8)$erryep$i|gmwi$xe|2

Jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi0${i$qe}$kirivexi$xe|efpi$mrgsqi$kviexiv$xler$syv$gewl$jps{$ew$e$viwypx$sj$hmjjivirgiw$mr$xmqmrk$fix{iir$xli

vigskrmxmsr$sj$xe|efpi$mrgsqi$erh$xli$egxyep$vigimtx$sj$gewl$sv$xli$ijjigx$sj$rsrhihygxmfpi$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw0$xli$gviexmsr$sj$viwivziw

sv$viuymvih$hifx$sv$eqsvxm~exmsr$te}qirxw2$Mj${i$hs$rsx$lezi$sxliv$jyrhw$ezempefpi$mr$xliwi$wmxyexmsrw0${i$gsyph$fi$viuymvih$xs$fsvvs{

jyrhw$ sr$ yrjezsvefpi$ xivqw0$ wipp$ ewwixw$ ex$ hmwehzerxekisyw$ tvmgiw$ sv$ hmwxvmfyxi$ eqsyrxw$ xlex${syph$ sxliv{mwi$ fi$ mrziwxih$ mr$ jyxyvi

eguymwmxmsrw$ xs$qeoi$ hmwxvmfyxmsrw$ wyjjmgmirx$ xs$ irefpi$ yw$ xs$ te}$ syx$ irsykl$ sj$ syv$ xe|efpi$ mrgsqi$ xs$ wexmwj}$ xli$VIMX$hmwxvmfyxmsr

viuymviqirx$erh$xs$ezsmh$gsvtsvexi$mrgsqi$xe|$erh$xli$8)$i|gmwi$xe|$mr$e$tevxmgypev$}iev2$Xliwi$epxivrexmziw$gsyph$mrgviewi$syv$gswxw0

vihygi$syv$iuymx}$sv$ehzivwip}$mqtegx$syv$efmpmx}$xs$vemwi$wlsvx$erh$psrk1xivq$hifx2$Jyvxlivqsvi0$ xli$VIMX$hmwxvmfyxmsr$viuymviqirxw

qe}$mrgviewi$xli$jmrergmrk${i$riih$xs$jyrh$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw0$jyxyvi$kvs{xl$erh$i|terwmsr$mrmxmexmziw2$Xlyw0$gsqtpmergi${mxl$xli

VIMX$viuymviqirxw$qe}$lmrhiv$syv$efmpmx}$xs$kvs{0${lmgl$gsyph$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$xli$zepyi$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo2

Syv$gewl$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$evi$rsx$kyeverxiih$erh$qe}$jpygxyexi2

E$VIMX$kirivepp}$mw$viuymvih$xs$hmwxvmfyxi$ex$piewx$=4)$sj$mxw$VIMX$xe|efpi$mrgsqi$xs$mxw$wlevilsphivw2$Syv$fsevh$sj$hmvigxsvw0

mr$mxw$wspi$hmwgvixmsr0${mpp$hixivqmri$sr$e$uyevxivp}$fewmw$xli$eqsyrx$sj$gewl$xs$fi$hmwxvmfyxih$xs$syv$wlevilsphivw$fewih$sr$e$ryqfiv$sj

jegxsvw$ mrgpyhmrk0$ fyx$ rsx$ pmqmxih$ xs0$ syv$ viwypxw$ sj$ stivexmsrw0$ gewl$ jps{$ erh$ getmxep$ viuymviqirxw0$ igsrsqmg$ gsrhmxmsrw0$ xe|

gsrwmhivexmsrw0$fsvvs{mrk$getegmx}$erh$sxliv$jegxsvw0$wygl$ew$hifx$gszirerx$viwxvmgxmsrw$xlex$qe}$mqtswi$pmqmxexmsrw$sr$gewl$te}qirxw

erh$tperw$jsv$jyxyvi$eguymwmxmsrw$erh$hmziwxmxyviw2$Gsrwiuyirxp}0$syv$hmwxvmfyxmsr$pizipw$qe}$jpygxyexi2

Givxemr$sj$syv$fywmriww$ egxmzmxmiw$qe}$fi$ wyfnigx$ xs$gsvtsvexi$ pizip$ mrgsqi$ xe|$erh$ jsvimkr$ xe|iw0${lmgl${syph$vihygi$syv$ gewl

jps{w0$erh$qe}$lezi$tsxirxmep$hijivvih$erh$gsrxmrkirx$xe|$pmefmpmxmiw2

[i$qe}$fi$wyfnigx$xs$givxemr$jihivep0$wxexi0$psgep$erh$jsvimkr$xe|iw$sr$syv$mrgsqi$erh$ewwixw0$xe|iw$sr$er}$yrhmwxvmfyxih$mrgsqi0

jverglmwi0$ tvstivx}$ erh$ xverwjiv$ xe|iw2$ Mr$ ehhmxmsr0${i$ gsyph0$ mr$ givxemr$ gmvgyqwxergiw0$ fi$ viuymvih$ xs$te}$ er$ i|gmwi$sv$ tirepx}$ xe|0

{lmgl$gsyph$fi$ wmkrmjmgerx$ mr$eqsyrx0$ mr$svhiv$ xs$yxmpm~i$sri$sv$qsvi$ vipmij$tvszmwmsrw$yrhiv$ xli$Gshi$ xs$qemrxemr$uyepmjmgexmsr$ jsv

xe|exmsr$ew$e$VIMX2$ Mr$ehhmxmsr0${i$qe}$ mrgyv$e$544)$i|gmwi$ xe|$sr$ xverwegxmsrw${mxl$e$XVW$mj$ xli}$evi$rsx$gsrhygxih$sr$er$evq+w

pirkxl$fewmw2$Er}$sj$xliwi$xe|iw${syph$higviewi$syv$ievrmrkw$erh$syv$ezempefpi$gewl2

Syv$XVW$ ewwixw$ erh$ stivexmsrw${mpp$ gsrxmryi$ xs$ fi$ wyfnigx0$ ew$ ettpmgefpi0$ xs$ jihivep$ erh$ wxexi$ gsvtsvexi$ mrgsqi$ xe|iw$ erh$ xs

jsvimkr$xe|iw$mr$xli$nyvmwhmgxmsrw$mr${lmgl$xlswi$ewwixw$erh$stivexmsrw$evi$psgexih2

[i${mpp$epws$fi$wyfnigx$xs$e$jihivep$gsvtsvexi$pizip$xe|$ex$xli$lmkliwx$vikypev$gsvtsvexi$vexi$sr$xli$kemr$vigskrm~ih$jvsq$e$wepi$sj

ewwixw$sggyvvmrk$hyvmrk$syv$jmvwx$jmzi$}ievw$ew$e$VIMX0$yt$xs$xli$eqsyrx$sj$xli$fympx1mr$kemr$xlex$i|mwxih$sr$Neryev}$50$64570

6:

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 37 of 253

Page 60: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 7;367<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 38 of 253

Page 61: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 7<367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

{lmgl$mw$fewih$sr$xli$jemv$qevoix$zepyi$sj$xlswi$ewwixw$mr$i|giww$sj$syv$xe|$fewmw$ew$sj$Neryev}$50$64572$Jyvxlivqsvi0${i${mpp$fi$wyfnigx

xs$ e$ jihivep$ gsvtsvexi$ pizip$ xe|$ ex$ xli$ lmkliwx$ vikypev$ gsvtsvexi$ vexi$ sr$ xli$ kemr$ vigskrm~ih$ jvsq$ e$ wepi$ sj$ ewwixw$ {i$ eguymvih$ mr

gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$645;$GIG$eguymwmxmsr0$yt$xs$xli$eqsyrx$sj$xli$fympx1mr$kemr$xlex$i|mwxih${lir$xli$VIMX$eguymvih$xli$ewwixw0$mj$e

wepi$sj$wygl$ewwixw$sggyvw$hyvmrk$xli$ettpmgefpi$jmzi1}iev$tivmsh$jspps{mrk$xli$eguymwmxmsr$sj$xli$GIG$ewwixw$f}$xli$VIMX2$Kemr$jvsq$e

wepi$sj$er$ewwix$sggyvvmrk$ejxiv$xli$wtigmjmih$tivmsh$irhw${mpp$rsx$fi$wyfnigx$xs$xlmw$gsvtsvexi$pizip$xe|2$[i$gyvvirxp}$hs$rsx$i|tigx$xs

wipp$ er}$ewwix$ mj$ xli$ wepi${syph$ viwypx$ mr$ xli$ mqtswmxmsr$sj$e$qexivmep$ xe|$ pmefmpmx}2$[i$gerrsx0$ls{iziv0$ ewwyvi$}sy$ xlex${i${mpp$rsx

glerki$syv$tperw$mr$xlmw$vikevh2

VIMX$s{rivwlmt$pmqmxexmsrw$qe}$viwxvmgx$sv$tvizirx$}sy$jvsq$irkekmrk$mr$givxemr$xverwjivw$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo2

Mr$svhiv$xs$wexmwj}$xli$viuymviqirxw$jsv$VIMX$uyepmjmgexmsr0$rs$qsvi$xler$94)$mr$zepyi$sj$epp$gpewwiw$sv$wivmiw$sj$syv$syxwxerhmrk

wleviw$ sj$ wxsgo$qe}$ fi$ s{rih0$ egxyepp}$ sv$ gsrwxvygxmzip}0$ f}$ jmzi$ sv$ ji{iv$ mrhmzmhyepw$ ,ew$ hijmrih$ mr$ xli$ Gshi$ xs$ mrgpyhi$ givxemr

irxmxmiw-$ ex$ er}$ xmqi$ hyvmrk$ xli$ pewx$ lepj$ sj$ iegl$ xe|efpi$ }iev$ fikmrrmrk${mxl$ syv$ 6458$ xe|efpi$ }iev2$Yrhiv$ ettpmgefpi$ gsrwxvygxmzi

s{rivwlmt$vypiw0$er}$wleviw$sj$wxsgo$s{rih$f}$givxemr$ejjmpmexih$s{rivw$kirivepp}${syph$fi$ehhih$xskixliv$jsv$tyvtswiw$sj$xli$gsqqsr

wxsgo$s{rivwlmt$pmqmxw0$erh$er}$wleviw$sj$e$kmzir$gpeww$sv$wivmiw$sj$tvijivvih$wxsgo$s{rih$f}$givxemr$ejjmpmexih$s{rivw$kirivepp}${syph

fi$ ehhih$ xskixliv$ jsv$ tyvtswiw$ sj$ xli$ s{rivwlmt$ pmqmx$ sr$ wygl$ gpeww$ sv$ wivmiw2$Syv$ glevxiv$ tvszmhiw$ jsv$ s{rivwlmt$ pmqmxexmsrw$ xlex

kirivepp}$viwxvmgx$wlevilsphivw$jvsq$s{rmrk$qsvi$xler$=2<)$sj$syv$syxwxerhmrk$wleviw2

Syv$ywi$sj$XVWw$qe}$geywi$yw$xs$jemp$xs$uyepmj}$ew$e$VIMX2

Xli$rix$mrgsqi$sj$syv$XVWw$mw$rsx$viuymvih$xs$fi$hmwxvmfyxih$xs$yw0$erh$wygl$yrhmwxvmfyxih$XVW$mrgsqi$mw$kirivepp}$rsx$wyfnigx$xs

syv$VIMX$hmwxvmfyxmsr$viuymviqirxw2$Ls{iziv0$mj$xli$eggyqypexmsr$sj$gewl$sv$vimrziwxqirx$sj$wmkrmjmgerx$ievrmrkw$mr$syv$XVWw$geywiw

xli$jemv$qevoix$zepyi$sj$syv$wigyvmxmiw$mr$xlswi$irxmxmiw0$xeoir$xskixliv${mxl$sxliv$rsr1uyepmj}mrk$ewwixw$xs$i|giih$69)$sj$xli$jemv$qevoix

zepyi$sj$ syv$ ewwixw0$ mr$ iegl$ gewi$ ew$hixivqmrih$ jsv$VIMX$ewwix$ xiwxmrk$tyvtswiw0${i${syph0$ efwirx$ xmqip}$ viwtsrwmzi$ egxmsr0$ jemp$ xs

qemrxemr$ syv$ uyepmjmgexmsr$ ew$ e$ VIMX2$ Ehhmxmsrepp}0$ fikmrrmrk$ mr$ 645<0$ mj$ xli$ eggyqypexmsr$ sj$ gewl$ sv$ vimrziwxqirx$ sj$ wmkrmjmgerx

ievrmrkw$ mr$syv$XVWw$ geywiw$ xli$ jemv$qevoix$ zepyi$sj$ syv$ wigyvmxmiw$ mr$ xlswi$ irxmxmiw$ xs$i|giih$64)$sj$ xli$ jemv$qevoix$ zepyi$sj$ syv

ewwixw0$mr$iegl$gewi$ew$hixivqmrih$jsv$VIMX$ewwix$xiwxmrk$tyvtswiw0${i${syph0$efwirx$xmqip}$viwtsrwmzi$egxmsr0$wmqmpevp}$jemp$xs$qemrxemr

syv$uyepmjmgexmsr$ew$e$VIMX2

$$

Ri{$pikmwpexmsr$sv$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$sv$nyhmgmep$egxmsr0$mr$iegl$mrwxergi$tsxirxmepp}${mxl$vixvsegxmzi$ijjigx0$gsyph$qeoi$mx$qsvi$hmjjmgypx

sv$mqtswwmfpi$jsv$yw$xs$qemrxemr$syv$uyepmjmgexmsr$ew$e$VIMX2

Xli$ tviwirx$Y2W2$ jihivep$ mrgsqi$ xe|$ xviexqirx$ sj$VIMXw$qe}$ fi$qshmjmih0$ tswwmfp}${mxl$ vixvsegxmzi$ ijjigx0$ f}$ pikmwpexmzi0

nyhmgmep0$sv$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$egxmsr$ex$er}$xmqi0${lmgl$gsyph$ejjigx$xli$Y2W2$jihivep$mrgsqi$xe|$xviexqirx$sj$er$mrziwxqirx$mr$yw2$Xli$Y2W2

jihivep$mrgsqi$xe|$vypiw$hiepmrk${mxl$Y2W2$jihivep$mrgsqi$xe|exmsr$erh$VIMXw$evi$gsrwxerxp}$yrhiv$vizmi{$f}$tivwsrw$mrzspzih$mr$xli

pikmwpexmzi$tvsgiww$erh$f}$xli$MVW$erh$xli$Y2W2$Hitevxqirx$sj$xli$Xviewyv}$,xli$ÔXviewyv}Õ-0${lmgl$viwypxw$mr$wxexyxsv}$glerkiw$ew${ipp

ew$jviuyirx$vizmwmsrw$xs$vikypexmsrw$erh$mrxivtvixexmsrw2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$pikmwpexmzi$fmppw$sv$tvstswepw$lezi$fiir$mrxvshygih$jvsq$xmqi$xs

xmqi${mxl$xli$emq$sj$pmqmxmrk$sv$viwxvmgxmrk$xli$x}tiw$sj$mrhywxvmiw$sv$gsqtermiw$xlex$ger$uyepmj}$ew$e$VIMX2$Ri{$pikmwpexmsr0$Xviewyv}

vikypexmsrw0$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$mrxivtvixexmsrw$sv$gsyvx$higmwmsrw$mqtpiqirxih$sv$ehstxih$mr$xli$jyxyvi$gsyph$wmkrmjmgerxp}$erh$rikexmzip}

ejjigx$syv$efmpmx}$xs$qemrxemr$syv$uyepmjmgexmsr$ew$e$VIMX$sv$xli$Y2W2$jihivep$mrgsqi$xe|$gsrwiuyirgiw$xs$syv$mrziwxsvw$erh$yw$sj$wygl

uyepmjmgexmsr2$[i$gerrsx$tvihmgx$ls{$glerkiw$mr$xli$xe|$pe{w$qmklx$ejjigx$syv$mrziwxsvw$sv$yw2$Vizmwmsrw$mr$Y2W2$jihivep$xe|$pe{w$erh

mrxivtvixexmsrw$ xlivisj$ gsyph$ wmkrmjmgerxp}$ erh$ rikexmzip}$ ejjigx$ syv$ efmpmx}$ xs$ qemrxemr$ syv$ uyepmjmgexmsr$ ew$ e$ VIMX$ erh$ xli$ xe|

gsrwmhivexmsrw$vipizerx$xs$er$mrziwxqirx$mr$yw0$sv$gsyph$geywi$yw$xs$glerki$syv$mrziwxqirxw$erh$gsqqmxqirxw2$]sy$evi$yvkih$xs$gsrwypx

{mxl$ }syv$ xe|$ ehzmwsv$ {mxl$ viwtigx$ xs$ xli$ wxexyw$ sj$ pikmwpexmzi0$ vikypexsv}$ sv$ ehqmrmwxvexmzi$ hizipstqirxw$ erh$ tvstswepw$ erh$ xlimv

tsxirxmep$ijjigx$sr$er$mrziwxqirx$mr$syv$wigyvmxmiw2

$

Vmwow$Vipexih$xs$Syv$Lmkl$Pizip$sj$Mrhifxihriww

Syv$ pizip$ sj$ mrhifxihriww$ gsyph$ ehzivwip}$ ejjigx$ syv$ jmrergmep$ gsrhmxmsr$ erh$ tvizirx$ yw$ jvsq$ jypjmppmrk$ syv$ hifx$ wivzmgi

sfpmkexmsrw2

[i$lezi$e$wmkrmjmgerx$eqsyrx$sj$mrhifxihriww2$Syv$xsxep$gsrwspmhexih$mrhifxihriww$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=${ew$ettvs|mqexip}

(628$fmppmsr0$i|gpyhmrk$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx$sj$(76<26$qmppmsr$erh$jmrergi$piewi$sfpmkexmsrw$sj$(82:$qmppmsr2$Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0${i

leh$ (:624$qmppmsr$ syxwxerhmrk$ mr$ pixxivw$ sj$ gvihmx$ erh$ (9642;$qmppmsr$ mr$ fsvvs{mrkw$ syxwxerhmrk$ yrhiv$ syv$ vizspziv2$ Epws0$ ew$ sj

Higiqfiv$750$645=0${i$leh$xli$efmpmx}$xs$fsvvs{$(75;24$qmppmsr$yrhiv$syv$vizspziv0$ejxiv$ettp}mrk$xli$pmqmxexmsrw$erh$viwxvmgxmsrw$mr

syv$hifx$gszirerxw$erh$wyfnigx$xs$syv$wexmwj}mrk$xli$vipizerx$fsvvs{mrk$gsrhmxmsrw$yrhiv$syv$wirmsv$gvihmx$jegmpmx}${mxl$viwtigx$xs$xli

mrgyvvirgi$ sj$ ehhmxmsrep$ mrhifxihriww2$ Ex$ Higiqfiv$ 750$ 645=0$ {i$ epws$ leh$ ettvs|mqexip}$ EYH$ 9<$ qmppmsr$ mr$ pixxivw$ sj$ gvihmx

syxwxerhmrk$yrhiv$syv$Eywxvepmer$pixxiv$sj$gvihmx$jegmpmx}$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$givxemr$tivjsvqergi

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 39 of 253

Page 62: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 7=367<

6;

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 40 of 253

Page 63: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 84367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

kyeverxiiw$vipexih$xs$xli$Vezirlepp$Tvmwsr$Tvsnigx2$[i$epws$lezi$xli$efmpmx}$xs$mrgviewi$syv$wirmsv$gvihmx$jegmpmx}$f}$er$ehhmxmsrep$(894

qmppmsr0$wyfnigx$xs$pirhiv$hiqerh$erh$tvizempmrk$qevoix$gsrhmxmsrw$erh$wexmwj}mrk$xli$vipizerx$fsvvs{mrk$gsrhmxmsrw2

Syv$wyfwxerxmep$mrhifxihriww$gsyph$lezi$mqtsvxerx$gsrwiuyirgiw2$Jsv$i|eqtpi0$mx$gsyph>

¨ qeoi$mx$qsvi$hmjjmgypx$jsv$yw$xs$wexmwj}$syv$sfpmkexmsrw${mxl$viwtigx$xs$syv$wirmsv$rsxiw$erh$syv$sxliv$hifx$erh$pmefmpmxmiw?

¨ viuymvi$ yw$ xs$ hihmgexi$ e$ wyfwxerxmep$ tsvxmsr$ sj$ syv$ gewl$ jps{$ jvsq$ stivexmsrw$ xs$ te}qirxw$ sr$ syv$ mrhifxihriww0$ xlivif}

vihygmrk$xli$ezempefmpmx}$sj$syv$gewl$jps{$xs$jyrh${svomrk$getmxep0$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw0$erh$sxliv$kirivep$gsvtsvexi$tyvtswiw

mrgpyhmrk$xs$qeoi$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$sr$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo$ew$gyvvirxp}$gsrxiqtpexih$sv$rigiwwev}$xs$qemrxemr$syv$uyepmjmgexmsr$ew$e

VIMX?

¨ pmqmx$syv$jpi|mfmpmx}$mr$tperrmrk$jsv0$sv$viegxmrk$xs0$glerkiw$mr$syv$fywmriww$erh$xli$mrhywxv}$mr${lmgl${i$stivexi?

¨ mrgviewi$syv$zyprivefmpmx}$xs$ehzivwi$igsrsqmg$erh$mrhywxv}$gsrhmxmsrw?

¨ tpegi$yw$ex$e$gsqtixmxmzi$hmwehzerxeki$gsqtevih$xs$gsqtixmxsvw$xlex$qe}$fi$piww$pizivekih?$

¨ viwxvmgx$yw$jvsq$tyvwymrk$wxvexikmg$eguymwmxmsrw$sv$i|tpsmxmrk$givxemr$fywmriww$sttsvxyrmxmiw?$erh

¨ pmqmx$syv$efmpmx}$xs$fsvvs{$ehhmxmsrep$jyrhw$sv$vijmrergi$i|mwxmrk$mrhifxihriww$sr$jezsvefpi$xivqw2

Mj${i$evi$yrefpi$xs$qiix$syv$hifx$wivzmgi$sfpmkexmsrw0${i$qe}$riih$xs$vihygi$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw0$viwxvygxyvi$sv$vijmrergi$syv

mrhifxihriww0$sfxemr$ehhmxmsrep$iuymx}$jmrergmrk$sv$wipp$ewwixw2$Xli$xivq$pser$yrhiv$syv$wirmsv$gvihmx$jegmpmx}$qexyviw$mr$Qevgl$6468$erh

xli$vizspziv$yrhiv$syv$wirmsv$gvihmx$jegmpmx}$qexyviw$mr$Qe}$64682$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$syv$syxwxerhmrk$jsyv$wivmiw$sj$wirmsv$rsxiw$qexyvi$mr

Neryev}$64660$Etvmp$64670$Sgxsfiv$6468$erh$Etvmp$646:2$Hyvmrk$645=0$wizivep$ jmrergmep$ mrwxmxyxmsrw0$ mrgpyhmrk$wsqi$sj$syv$ pirhivw0

errsyrgih$ xlex$ xli}${mpp$ rsx$ fi$ viri{mrk$i|mwxmrk$ ekviiqirxw$sv$ irxivmrk$ mrxs$ri{$ekviiqirxw${mxl$gsqtermiw$ xlex$ stivexi$ wigyvi

wivzmgiw$jegmpmxmiw$erh$girxivw$tyvwyerx$xs$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw2$[lmpi${i$fipmizi$xlex${i${mpp$gsrxmryi$xs$lezi$eggiww$xs$xli$hifx

erh$getmxep$qevoixw$sr$e$gswx1ijjigxmzi$fewmw$xs$wyttsvx$xli$kvs{xl$erh$i|terwmsr$sj$syv$lmkl1uyepmx}$wivzmgiw0$wygl$hixivqmrexmsrw$f}

jmrergmep$mrwxmxyxmsrw$qe}$ehzivwip}$mqtegx$syv$efmpmx}$xs$vite}0$viwxvygxyvi$sv$vijmrergi$syv$mrhifxihriww0$mrgpyhmrk$f}$sfxemrmrk$hifx

jmrergmrk0$iuymx}$jmrergmrk$sv$wippmrk$ewwixw$sr$wexmwjegxsv}$xivqw0$sv$ex$epp0$sv$qexivmepp}$mrgviewi$xli$gswx$sj$getmxep$erh$ew$e$viwypx$lezi

e$qexivmep$ ehzivwi$ ijjigx$ sr$ syv$ fywmriww0$ jmrergmep$ gsrhmxmsr$ erh$ viwypxw$ sj$ stivexmsrw2$ Mr$ ehhmxmsr0$ syv$ efmpmx}$ xs$ mrgyv$ ehhmxmsrep

mrhifxihriww${mpp$ fi$ viwxvmgxih$f}$ xli$ xivqw$sj$ syv$ wirmsv$ gvihmx$ jegmpmx}0$ xli$ mrhirxyvi$kszivrmrk$ xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$646:

,&:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw&-0$xli$mrhirxyvi$kszivrmrk$xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6467$,&92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw&-0$xli$mrhirxyvi$kszivrmrk

xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466$erh$xli$mrhirxyvi$kszivrmrk$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$64682

[i$evi$mrgyvvmrk$wmkrmjmgerx$mrhifxihriww$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$wyfwxerxmep$srksmrk$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw2$Getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw$jsv

i|mwxmrk$erh$jyxyvi$tvsnigxw$qe}$qexivmepp}$wxvemr$syv$pmuymhmx}2

$$$$

[i$gyvvirxp}$lezi$wizivep$egxmzi$tvsnigxw$xlex${i$erxmgmtexi$wtirhmrk$ettvs|mqexip}$(544$qmppmsr$sr$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw$mr$64642

Mrgpyhih$mr$xliwi$tvsnigxw$mw$ettvs|mqexip}$(68$qmppmsr$sj$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw$vipexih$xs$jegmpmx}$qemrxirergi$gswxw2$[i$mrxirh$xs

jmrergi$xliwi$erh$jyxyvi$tvsnigxw$ywmrk$syv$s{r$jyrhw0$mrgpyhmrk$gewl$sr$lerh0$gewl$jps{$jvsq$stivexmsrw$erh$fsvvs{mrkw$yrhiv$xli

vizspziv2$Mr$ehhmxmsr$xs$xliwi$gyvvirx$iwxmqexih$getmxep$viuymviqirxw$jsv$64640${i$evi$gyvvirxp}$mr$xli$tvsgiww$sj$fmhhmrk$sr0$sv

izepyexmrk$tsxirxmep$fmhw$jsv$xli$hiwmkr0$gsrwxvygxmsr$erh$qerekiqirx$sj$e$ryqfiv$sj$ri{$tvsnigxw2$Mr$xli$izirx$xlex${i${mr$fmhw$jsv

xliwi$tvsnigxw$erh$higmhi$xs$wipj1jmrergi$xlimv$gsrwxvygxmsr0$syv$getmxep$viuymviqirxw$mr$6464$gsyph$qexivmepp}$mrgviewi2$Ew$sj

Higiqfiv$750$645=0${i$leh$xli$efmpmx}$xs$fsvvs{$(75;24$qmppmsr$yrhiv$xli$vizspziv$ejxiv$ettp}mrk$xli$pmqmxexmsrw$erh$viwxvmgxmsrw$mr$syv

hifx$gszirerxw$erh$wyfnigx$xs$syv$wexmwj}mrk$xli$vipizerx$fsvvs{mrk$gsrhmxmsrw$yrhiv$xli$wirmsv$gvihmx$jegmpmx}2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0${i$lezi$xli

efmpmx}$xs$mrgviewi$xli$wirmsv$gvihmx$jegmpmx}$f}$er$ehhmxmsrep$(894$qmppmsr0$wyfnigx$xs$pirhiv$hiqerh$erh$tvizempmrk$qevoix$gsrhmxmsrw

erh$wexmwj}mrk$xli$vipizerx$fsvvs{mrk$gsrhmxmsrw$xliviyrhiv2$[lmpi${i$fipmizi${i$gyvvirxp}$lezi$ehiuyexi$fsvvs{mrk$getegmx}$yrhiv

syv$wirmsv$gvihmx$jegmpmx}$xs$jyrh$syv$stivexmsrw$erh$epp$sj$syv$gsqqmxxih$getmxep$i|tirhmxyvi$tvsnigxw0${i$qe}$riih$ehhmxmsrep

fsvvs{mrkw$sv$jmrergmrk$jvsq$sxliv$wsyvgiw$mr$svhiv$xs$gsqtpixi$tsxirxmep$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw$vipexih$xs$ri{$tvsnigxw$mr$xli$jyxyvi2$[i

gerrsx$ewwyvi$}sy$xlex$wygl$fsvvs{mrkw$sv$jmrergmrk${mpp$fi$qehi$ezempefpi$xs$yw$sr$wexmwjegxsv}$xivqw0$sv$ex$epp2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$xli$pevki

getmxep$gsqqmxqirxw$xlex$xliwi$tvsnigxw${mpp$viuymvi$sziv$xli$ri|x$5615<$qsrxl$tivmsh$qe}$qexivmepp}$wxvemr$syv$pmuymhmx}$erh$syv

fsvvs{mrk$getegmx}$jsv$sxliv$tyvtswiw2$Getmxep$gsrwxvemrxw$geywih$f}$xliwi$tvsnigxw$qe}$epws$geywi$yw$xs$lezi$xs$irxmvip}$vijmrergi$syv

i|mwxmrk$mrhifxihriww$sv$mrgyv$qsvi$mrhifxihriww2$Wygl$jmrergmrk$qe}$lezi$xivqw$piww$jezsvefpi$xler$xlswi${i$gyvvirxp}$lezi$mr$tpegi0

sv$rsx$fi$ezempefpi$xs$yw$ex$epp2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$xli$gsrgyvvirx$hizipstqirx$sj$xliwi$erh$sxliv$pevki$getmxep$tvsnigxw$i|tswiw$yw$xs$qexivmep

vmwow2$Jsv$i|eqtpi0${i$qe}$rsx$gsqtpixi$wsqi$sv$epp$sj$xli$tvsnigxw$sr$xmqi$sv$sr$fyhkix0${lmgl$gsyph$geywi$yw$xs$efwsvf$er}$pswwiw

ewwsgmexih${mxl$er}$hipe}w2

Hiwtmxi$gyvvirx$ mrhifxihriww$ pizipw0${i$qe}$wxmpp$ mrgyv$qsvi$ mrhifxihriww0${lmgl$gsyph$jyvxliv$i|egivfexi$ xli$ vmwow$hiwgvmfih

efszi2

6<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 41 of 253

Page 64: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 85367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Xli$xivqw$sj$xli$mrhirxyviw$kszivrmrk$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466$erh

xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468$erh$syv$ wirmsv$gvihmx$ jegmpmx}$ viwxvmgx$ syv$efmpmx}$ xs$ mrgyv0$fyx$hs$rsx$ tvslmfmx$yw$ jvsq$ mrgyvvmrk0

wmkrmjmgerx$ehhmxmsrep$mrhifxihriww$mr$xli$jyxyvi2$Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0${i$leh$xli$efmpmx}$xs$fsvvs{$er$ehhmxmsrep$(75;24$qmppmsr

yrhiv$xli$vizspziv$tsvxmsr$sj$syv$wirmsv$gvihmx$jegmpmx}$ejxiv$ettp}mrk$xli$pmqmxexmsrw$erh$viwxvmgxmsrw$mr$syv$hifx$gszirerxw$erh$wyfnigx$xs

syv$wexmwj}mrk$xli$vipizerx$fsvvs{mrk$gsrhmxmsrw$yrhiv$xli$wirmsv$gvihmx$jegmpmx}2$[i$epws${syph$lezi$xli$efmpmx}$xs$mrgviewi$xli$wirmsv

gvihmx$jegmpmx}$f}$er$ehhmxmsrep$(894$qmppmsr0$wyfnigx$xs$pirhiv$hiqerh0$tvizempmrk$qevoix$gsrhmxmsrw$erh$wexmwj}mrk$vipizerx$fsvvs{mrk

gsrhmxmsrw2$Epws0${i$qe}$ vijmrergi$ epp$ sv$ e$ tsvxmsr$ sj$ syv$ mrhifxihriww0$ mrgpyhmrk$ fsvvs{mrkw$ yrhiv$ syv$ wirmsv$ gvihmx$ jegmpmx}0$ xli

:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466$erh$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$64682$Xli$xivqw

sj$wygl$vijmrergmrk$qe}$fi$piww$viwxvmgxmzi$erh$tivqmx$yw$xs$mrgyv$qsvi$mrhifxihriww$xler${i$ger$rs{2$Mj$ri{$mrhifxihriww$mw$ehhih$xs

syv$erh$syv$wyfwmhmevmiw×$gyvvirx$hifx$pizipw0$xli$vipexih$vmwow$xlex${i$erh$xli}$rs{$jegi$vipexih$xs$syv$wmkrmjmgerx$pizip$sj$mrhifxihriww

gsyph$mrxirwmj}2

Xli$gszirerxw$mr$xli$mrhirxyviw$kszivrmrk$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466

erh$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468$erh$xli$gszirerxw$mr$syv$Wirmsv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}$mqtswi$wmkrmjmgerx$stivexmrk$erh$jmrergmep

viwxvmgxmsrw${lmgl$qe}$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$syv$efmpmx}$xs$stivexi$syv$fywmriww2

Xli$mrhirxyviw$kszivrmrk$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466$erh$xli$92<;9)

Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468$erh$syv$Wirmsv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}$mqtswi$wmkrmjmgerx$stivexmrk$erh$jmrergmep$viwxvmgxmsrw$sr$yw$erh$givxemr$sj$syv

wyfwmhmevmiw0${lmgl${i$vijiv$xs$ew$viwxvmgxih$wyfwmhmevmiw2$Xliwi$viwxvmgxmsrw$pmqmx$syv$efmpmx}$xs0$eqsrk$sxliv$xlmrkw>

¨ mrgyv$ehhmxmsrep$mrhifxihriww?

¨ te}$hmzmhirhw$erh$sv$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$sr$syv$getmxep$ wxsgo0$ vityvglewi0$ vihiiq$sv$ vixmvi$syv$getmxep$ wxsgo0$tvite}$wyfsvhmrexih

mrhifxihriww0$qeoi$mrziwxqirxw?

¨ mwwyi$tvijivvih$wxsgo$sj$wyfwmhmevmiw?

¨ kyeverxii$sxliv$mrhifxihriww?

¨ gviexi$pmirw$sr$syv$ewwixw?

¨ xverwjiv$erh$wipp$ewwixw?

¨ qeoi$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw$efszi$givxemr$pmqmxw?

¨ gviexi$sv$tivqmx$viwxvmgxmsrw$sr$xli$efmpmx}$sj$syv$viwxvmgxih$wyfwmhmevmiw$xs$te}$hmzmhirhw$sv$qeoi$sxliv$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$xs$yw?

¨ irxiv$mrxs$wepi3piewifego$xverwegxmsrw?

¨ irxiv$mrxs$xverwegxmsrw${mxl$ejjmpmexiw?$erh

¨ qivki$sv$gsrwspmhexi${mxl$ersxliv$gsqter}$sv$wipp$epp$sv$wyfwxerxmepp}$epp$sj$syv$ewwixw2

Xliwi$viwxvmgxmsrw$gsyph$pmqmx$syv$efmpmx}$xs$jmrergi$syv$jyxyvi$stivexmsrw$sv$getmxep$riihw0$qeoi$eguymwmxmsrw$sv$tyvwyi$ezempefpi

fywmriww$ sttsvxyrmxmiw2$ Mr$ ehhmxmsr0$ syv$ wirmsv$ gvihmx$ jegmpmx}$ viuymviw$ yw$ xs$ qemrxemr$ wtigmjmih$ jmrergmep$ vexmsw$ erh$ wexmwj}$ givxemr

jmrergmep$gszirerxw0$mrgpyhmrk$qemrxemrmrk$e$qe|mqyq$wirmsv$wigyvih$piziveki$vexms$erh$xsxep$piziveki$vexms0$erh$e$qmrmqyq$mrxiviwx

gsziveki$vexms2$[i$qe}$fi$viuymvih$xs$xeoi$egxmsr$xs$vihygi$syv$mrhifxihriww$sv$xs$egx$mr$e$qerriv$gsrxvev}$xs$syv$fywmriww$sfnigxmziw

xs$qiix$xliwi$vexmsw$erh$wexmwj}$xliwi$gszirerxw2$[i$gsyph$epws$mrgyv$ehhmxmsrep$mrhifxihriww$lezmrk$izir$qsvi$viwxvmgxmzi$gszirerxw2

Syv$jempyvi$xs$gsqtp}${mxl$er}$sj$xli$gszirerxw$yrhiv$syv$wirmsv$gvihmx$jegmpmx}0$xli$mrhirxyviw$kszivrmrk$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$xli

92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$64660$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$64680$sv$er}$sxliv$mrhifxihriww$gsyph$tvizirx

yw$jvsq$fimrk$efpi$xs$hve{$sr$xli$Vizspziv0$geywi$er$izirx$sj$hijeypx$yrhiv$wygl$hsgyqirxw$erh$viwypx$mr$er$eggipivexmsr$sj$epp$sj$syv

syxwxerhmrk$mrhifxihriww2$Mj$epp$sj$syv$syxwxerhmrk$mrhifxihriww${ivi$xs$fi$eggipivexih0${i$pmoip}${syph$rsx$fi$efpi$xs$wmqypxerisywp}

wexmwj}$epp$sj$syv$sfpmkexmsrw$yrhiv$wygl$mrhifxihriww0${lmgl${syph$qexivmepp}$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$syv$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$viwypxw$sj

stivexmsrw2

Wivzmgmrk$syv$mrhifxihriww${mpp$viuymvi$e$wmkrmjmgerx$eqsyrx$sj$gewl2$Syv$efmpmx}$xs$kirivexi$gewl$hitirhw$sr$qer}$jegxsvw

fi}srh$syv$gsrxvsp$erh${i$qe}$rsx$fi$efpi$xs$kirivexi$xli$gewl$viuymvih$xs$wivzmgi$syv$mrhifxihriww2

Syv$efmpmx}$xs$qeoi$te}qirxw$sr$syv$mrhifxihriww$erh$xs$jyrh$tperrih$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw${mpp$hitirh$sr$syv$efmpmx}$xs$kirivexi

gewl$ mr$ xli$ jyxyvi2$Xlmw0$ xs$ e$ givxemr$ i|xirx0$ mw$ wyfnigx$ xs$ kirivep$ igsrsqmg0$ jmrergmep0$ gsqtixmxmzi0$ pikmwpexmzi0$ vikypexsv}$ erh$sxliv

jegxsvw$xlex$evi$fi}srh$syv$gsrxvsp2

Syv$fywmriww$qe}$rsx$fi$efpi$xs$kirivexi$wyjjmgmirx$gewl$jps{$jvsq$stivexmsrw$sv$jyxyvi$fsvvs{mrkw$qe}$rsx$fi$ezempefpi$xs$yw

yrhiv$syv$wirmsv$gvihmx$jegmpmx}$sv$sxliv{mwi$mr$er$eqsyrx$wyjjmgmirx$xs$irefpi$yw$xs$te}$syv$mrhifxihriww$sv$hifx$wigyvmxmiw0$mrgpyhmrk

xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$64660$erh$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$64680$sv$xs

jyrh$ syv$ sxliv$ pmuymhmx}$ riihw2$ Ew$ e$ viwypx0$ {i$qe}$ riih$ xs$ vijmrergi$ epp$ sv$ e$ tsvxmsr$ sj$ syv$ mrhifxihriww$ sr$ sv$ fijsvi$qexyvmx}2

Ls{iziv0${i$qe}$rsx$fi$efpi$xs$gsqtpixi$wygl$vijmrergmrk$sr$gsqqivgmepp}$viewsrefpi$xivqw$sv$ex$epp2$Mj$jsv$er}$viewsr${i$evi$yrefpi

xs$qiix$syv$hifx$wivzmgi$sfpmkexmsrw0${i${syph$fi$mr$hijeypx$yrhiv$xli$xivqw$sj$xli$ekviiqirxw$kszivrmrk

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 42 of 253

Page 65: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 86367<

6=

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 43 of 253

Page 66: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 87367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

syv$syxwxerhmrk$hifx2$Mj$wygl$e$hijeypx${ivi$xs$sggyv0$xli$pirhivw$yrhiv$xli$wirmsv$gvihmx$jegmpmx}0$erh$lsphivw$sj$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0

xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466$erh$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468$gsyph$ipigx$xs$higpevi$epp$eqsyrxw

syxwxerhmrk$mqqihmexip}$hyi$erh$te}efpi0$erh$xli$pirhivw${syph$rsx$fi$sfpmkexih$xs$gsrxmryi$xs$ehzergi$jyrhw$yrhiv$xli$wirmsv$gvihmx

jegmpmx}2$ Mj$ xli$ eqsyrxw$ syxwxerhmrk$ yrhiv$ xli$ wirmsv$ gvihmx$ jegmpmx}$ sv$ sxliv$ ekviiqirxw$ kszivrmrk$ syv$ syxwxerhmrk$ hifx0$ {ivi

eggipivexih0$syv$ewwixw$qe}$rsx$fi$wyjjmgmirx$xs$vite}$mr$jypp$xli$qsri}$s{ih$xs$syv$pirhivw$erh$lsphivw$sj$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$xli

92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466$erh$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468$erh$er}$sxliv$hifx$lsphivw2

Figeywi$tsvxmsrw$sj$syv$wirmsv$mrhifxihriww$lezi$jpsexmrk$mrxiviwx$vexiw0$e$kirivep$mrgviewi$mr$mrxiviwx$vexiw${syph$ehzivwip}

ejjigx$gewl$jps{w2

Fsvvs{mrkw$yrhiv$syv$wirmsv$gvihmx$jegmpmx}$fiev$mrxiviwx$ex$e$zevmefpi$vexi$ywmrk$e$wtvieh$sziv0$ex$syv$ipigxmsr0$imxliv$PMFSV$sv$er

epxivrexmzi$ fewi$ vexi2$ Ew$ e$ viwypx0$ xs$ xli$ i|xirx$ syv$ i|tswyvi$ xs$ mrgviewiw$ mr$ mrxiviwx$ vexiw$ mw$ rsx$ ipmqmrexih$ xlvsykl$ mrxiviwx$ vexi

tvsxigxmsr$ekviiqirxw0$wygl$mrgviewiw${mpp$viwypx$mr$lmkliv$hifx$wivzmgi$gswxw${lmgl${mpp$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$syv$gewl$jps{w2$[i$gyvvirxp}

hs$rsx$ lezi$ mrxiviwx$ vexi$tvsxigxmsr$ ekviiqirxw$ mr$tpegi$ xs$tvsxigx$ ekemrwx$ mrxiviwx$ vexi$ jpygxyexmsrw$sr$fsvvs{mrkw$yrhiv$syv$ wirmsv

gvihmx$jegmpmx}2$Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0${i$leh$(506=<2;$qmppmsr$sj$mrhifxihriww$syxwxerhmrk$yrhiv$syv$wirmsv$gvihmx$jegmpmx}0$erh$e

sri$ tivgirx$ mrgviewi$ mr$ xli$ mrxiviwx$ vexi$ ettpmgefpi$ xs$ syv$ wirmsv$ gvihmx$ jegmpmx}$ {syph$ mrgviewi$ syv$ erryep$ mrxiviwx$ i|tirwi$ f}

ettvs|mqexip}$ (5724$qmppmsr2$ Mr$ ehhmxmsr0$ er$ mrgviewi$ mr$qevoix$ mrxiviwx$ vexiw$qe}$ pieh$lsphivw$sj$ syv$ gsqqsr$ wxsgo$ xs$ hiqerh$e

lmkliv$}miph$sr$xlimv$wleviw$jvsq$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$f}$yw0${lmgl$gsyph$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$xli$qevoix$tvmgi$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo2

Ehhmxmsrepp}0$sr$Nyp}$6;0$645;0$xli$Jmrergmep$Gsrhygx$Eyxlsvmx}$,xli$eyxlsvmx}$xlex$vikypexiw$PMFSV-$errsyrgih$xlex$mx$mrxirhw$xs$wxst

gsqtippmrk$ferow$xs$wyfqmx$vexiw$jsv$xli$gepgypexmsr$sj$PMFSV$ejxiv$6465$erh$mx$mw$yrgpiev${lixliv$ri{$qixlshw$sj$gepgypexmrk$PMFSV

{mpp$fi$iwxefpmwlih2$Mj$PMFSV$giewiw$xs$i|mwx$ejxiv$64650$syv$fsvvs{mrkw${mpp$fiev$mrxiviwx$ex$er$epxivrexmzi$fewi$vexi$tpyw$e$wtvieh0$erh

syv$efmpmx}$xs$fsvvs{$mr$gyvvirgmiw$sxliv$xler$Y2W2$hsppevw${mpp$fi$pmqmxih0$mr$iegl$gewi$yrxmp$wygl$e$xmqi$ew$e$gsqtevefpi$sv$wyggiwwsv

vijivirgi$vexi$jsv$PMFSV$mw$ettvszih$f}$xli$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$ekirx0$sv$ekviih$xs$f}$xli$Gsqter}$erh$xli$pirhivw$yrhiv$syv$wirmsv$gvihmx

jegmpmx}2$Xli$Y2W2$Jihivep$Viwivzi0$mr$gsrnyrgxmsr${mxl$xli$Epxivrexmzi$Vijivirgi$Vexiw$Gsqqmxxii0$mw$gsrwmhivmrk$vitpegmrk$Y2W2$hsppev

PMFSV${mxl$e$ri{p}$gviexih$mrhi|0$gepgypexih$fewih$sr$vityvglewi$ekviiqirxw$fegoih$f}$xviewyv}$wigyvmxmiw2$Mx$mw$rsx$tswwmfpi$xs

tvihmgx$xli$ijjigx$sj$xliwi$glerkiw0$sxliv$vijsvqw$sv$xli$iwxefpmwlqirx$sj$epxivrexmzi$vijivirgi$vexiw$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw$sv$ipwi{livi2

Xs$xli$i|xirx$xliwi$mrxiviwx$vexiw$mrgviewi0$syv$mrxiviwx$i|tirwi${mpp$mrgviewi0${lmgl$gsyph$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$syv$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr0

stivexmrk$viwypxw$erh$gewl$jps{w2

[i$hitirh$sr$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$jvsq$syv$wyfwmhmevmiw$xs$qeoi$te}qirxw$sr$syv$mrhifxihriww2$Xliwi$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$qe}$rsx$fi$qehi2

E$wyfwxerxmep$tsvxmsr$sj$syv$fywmriww$mw$gsrhygxih$f}$syv$wyfwmhmevmiw2$Xlivijsvi0$syv$efmpmx}$xs$qiix$syv$te}qirx$sfpmkexmsrw$sr

syv$ mrhifxihriww$ mw$ wyfwxerxmepp}$ hitirhirx$ sr$ xli$ ievrmrkw$ sj$ givxemr$ sj$ syv$ wyfwmhmevmiw$ erh$ xli$ te}qirx$ sj$ jyrhw$ xs$ yw$ f}$ syv

wyfwmhmevmiw$ew$hmzmhirhw0$pserw0$ehzergiw$sv$sxliv$te}qirxw2$Syv$wyfwmhmevmiw$evi$witevexi$erh$hmwxmrgx$pikep$irxmxmiw$erh0$yrpiww$xli}

i|tviwwp}$kyeverxii$er}$mrhifxihriww$sj$syvw0$ xli}$evi$rsx$sfpmkexih$xs$qeoi$jyrhw$ezempefpi$jsv$te}qirx$sj$syv$mrhifxihriww$mr$xli

jsvq$sj$pserw0$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$sv$sxliv{mwi2$Syv$wyfwmhmevmiw×$efmpmx}$xs$qeoi$er}$wygl$pserw0$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$sv$sxliv$te}qirxw$xs$yw${mpp

hitirh$ sr$ xlimv$ ievrmrkw0$ fywmriww$ viwypxw0$ xli$ xivqw$ sj$ xlimv$ i|mwxmrk$ erh$ er}$ jyxyvi$ mrhifxihriww0$ xe|$ gsrwmhivexmsrw$ erh$ pikep$ sv

gsrxvegxyep$ viwxvmgxmsrw$ xs${lmgl$ xli}$qe}$fi$wyfnigx2$ Mj$syv$ wyfwmhmevmiw$hs$rsx$qeoi$wygl$te}qirxw$ xs$yw0$syv$efmpmx}$ xs$ vite}$syv

mrhifxihriww$qe}$fi$qexivmepp}$ehzivwip}$ejjigxih2$Jsv$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$syv$wyfwmhmevmiw$eggsyrxih$jsv$:62=)$sj$syv

gsrwspmhexih$viziryiw0$erh$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$syv$wyfwmhmevmiw$eggsyrxih$jsv$=:27)$sj$syv$xsxep$ewwixw2

[i$qe}$rsx$fi$efpi$xs$wexmwj}$syv$vityvglewi$sfpmkexmsrw$mr$xli$izirx$sj$e$glerki$sj$gsrxvsp$figeywi$xli$xivqw$sj$syv$mrhifxihriww

sv$pego$sj$jyrhw$qe}$tvizirx$yw$jvsq$hsmrk$ws2

Ytsr$e$glerki$sj$gsrxvsp$ew$wtigmjmih$mr$xli$mrhirxyviw$kszivrmrk$xli$xivqw$sj$syv$wirmsv$rsxiw0$iegl$lsphiv$sj$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0

xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466$erh$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468${mpp$lezi$xli$vmklx$xs$viuymvi$yw$xs

vityvglewi$xlimv$rsxiw$ex$545)$sj$xlimv$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx0$tpyw$eggvyih$erh$yrtemh$mrxiviwx0$erh0$pmuymhexih$heqekiw0$mj$er}0$xs$xli$hexi

sj$vityvglewi2$Xli$xivqw$sj$xli$wirmsv$gvihmx$jegmpmx}$pmqmx$syv$efmpmx}$xs$vityvglewi$xli$rsxiw$mr$xli$izirx$sj$e$glerki$sj$gsrxvsp2$Er}

jyxyvi$ekviiqirx$kszivrmrk$er}$sj$syv$ mrhifxihriww$qe}$gsrxemr$ wmqmpev$ viwxvmgxmsrw$erh$tvszmwmsrw2$Eggsvhmrkp}0$ mx$ mw$tswwmfpi$ xlex

viwxvmgxmsrw$mr$xli$wirmsv$gvihmx$jegmpmx}$sv$sxliv$mrhifxihriww$xlex$qe}$fi$mrgyvvih$mr$xli$jyxyvi${mpp$rsx$epps{$xli$viuymvih$vityvglewi$sj

xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466$erh$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468$ytsr$e

glerki$sj$gsrxvsp2$Izir$ mj$ wygl$ vityvglewi$ mw$tivqmxxih$f}$ xli$ xivqw$sj$syv$ xlir$i|mwxmrk$ mrhifxihriww0${i$qe}$rsx$lezi$wyjjmgmirx

jyrhw$ezempefpi$xs$wexmwj}$syv$vityvglewi$sfpmkexmsrw2$Syv$jempyvi$xs

74

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 44 of 253

Page 67: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 88367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

tyvglewi$er}$sj$xli$wirmsv$rsxiw${syph$fi$e$hijeypx$yrhiv$xli$mrhirxyvi$kszivrmrk$wygl$rsxiw0${lmgl$mr$xyvr${syph$xvmkkiv$e$hijeypx

yrhiv$xli$wirmsv$gvihmx$jegmpmx}$erh$xli$mrhirxyviw$kszivrmrk$xli$sxliv$wirmsv$rsxiw2

Vmwow$Vipexih$xs$Syv$Fywmriww$erh$Wivzmgiw

Jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi0${i$qe}$rsx$lezi$e$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegx${mxl$e$gpmirx$xs$stivexi$i|mwxmrk$fihw$ex$e$jegmpmx}$sv$ri{$fihw$ex$e

jegmpmx}$xlex${i$evi$i|terhmrk$erh${i$gerrsx$ewwyvi$}sy$xlex$wygl$e$gsrxvegx${mpp$fi$sfxemrih2$Jempyvi$xs$sfxemr$e$qerekiqirx

gsrxvegx$jsv$xliwi$fihw${mpp$wyfnigx$yw$xs$gevv}mrk$gswxw${mxl$rs$gsvviwtsrhmrk$qerekiqirx$viziryi2

Jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi0${i$qe}$rsx$lezi$e$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegx${mxl$e$gywxsqiv$xs$stivexi$i|mwxmrk$fihw$sv$ri{$fihw$ex$jegmpmxmiw

xlex${i$evi$gyvvirxp}$ mr$ xli$tvsgiww$sj$ virszexmrk$erh$i|terhmrk2$[lmpi${i${mpp$ ep{e}w$ wxvmzi$ xs${svo$hmpmkirxp}${mxl$e$ryqfiv$sj

hmjjivirx$gywxsqivw$jsv$xli$ywi$sj$xliwi$fihw0${i$gerrsx$ewwyvi$}sy$xlex$e$gsrxvegx$jsv$xli$fihw${mpp$fi$wigyvih$sr$e$xmqip}$fewmw0$sv$ex

epp2$[lmpi$e$ jegmpmx}$sv$ri{$fihw$ex$ e$ jegmpmx}$evi$zegerx0${i$ mrgyv$gevv}mrk$gswxw2$ Mr$syv$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$ wikqirx0${i$evi$gyvvirxp}

qevoixmrk$ettvs|mqexip}$;44$zegerx$fihw${mxl$e$rix$fsso$zepyi$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(56$qmppmsr$ex$sri$sj$syv$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw$xs$tsxirxmep

gywxsqivw2$ Mr$ syv$ KIS$ Gevi$ wikqirx0$ {i$ evi$ gyvvirxp}$ qevoixmrk$ ettvs|mqexip}$ 844$ zegerx$ fihw$ {mxl$ e$ rix$ fsso$ zepyi$ sj

ettvs|mqexip}$(=$qmppmsr$ex$sri$sj$syv$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw$xs$tsxirxmep$gywxsqivw2$Xli$gsqfmrih$erryep$gevv}mrk$gswx$sj$xliwi$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw

mr$6464$mw$iwxmqexih$xs$fi$(724$qmppmsr0$mrgpyhmrk$hitvigmexmsr$i|tirwi$sj$(524$qmppmsr2$Jempyvi$xs$wigyvi$e$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegx$jsv$e

jegmpmx}$sv$i|terwmsr$tvsnigx$gsyph$lezi$e$qexivmep$ehzivwi$mqtegx$sr$syv$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$erh3sv$gewl$jps{w2

[i$vizmi{$syv$jegmpmxmiw$jsv$mqtemvqirx${liriziv$izirxw$sv$glerkiw$mr$gmvgyqwxergiw$mrhmgexi$xli$rix$fsso$zepyi$sj$xli$jegmpmx}$qe}

rsx$fi$vigszivefpi2$Mqtemvqirx$glevkiw$xeoir$sr$syv$jegmpmxmiw$gsyph$viuymvi$qexivmep$glevkiw$xs$syv$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$mr

svhiv$ xs$ wigyvi$e$qerekiqirx$ gsrxvegx$ jsv$ xliwi$fihw0${i$qe}$riih$ xs$ mrgyv$ wmkrmjmgerx$ getmxep$ i|tirhmxyviw$ xs$ virszexi$sv$ jyvxliv

i|terh$xli$jegmpmx}$xs$qiix$tsxirxmep$gpmirxw×$riihw2

Rikexmzi$ gsrhmxmsrw$ mr$ xli$ getmxep$ qevoixw$ gsyph$ tvizirx$ yw$ jvsq$ sfxemrmrk$ jmrergmrk0$ {lmgl$ gsyph$ qexivmepp}$ levq$ syv

fywmriww2

Syv$efmpmx}$xs$sfxemr$ehhmxmsrep$jmrergmrk$mw$lmklp}$hitirhirx$sr$xli$gsrhmxmsrw$sj$xli$getmxep$qevoixw0$eqsrk$sxliv$xlmrkw2$Xli

getmxep$ erh$gvihmx$qevoixw$lezi$ i|tivmirgih$wmkrmjmgerx$tivmshw$sj$zspexmpmx}$erh$hmwvytxmsr$wmrgi$644<2$Hyvmrk$ xlmw$ xmqi$tivmsh0$ xli

igsrsqmg$mqtegxw$sfwivzih$lezi$mrgpyhih$e$hs{rxyvr$mr$xli$iuymx}$erh$hifx$qevoixw0$xli$xmklxirmrk$sj$xli$gvihmx$qevoixw0$e$kirivep

igsrsqmg$ wps{hs{r$ erh$ sxliv$qegvsigsrsqmg$ gsrhmxmsrw0$ zspexmpmx}$ mr$ gyvvirg}$ i|glerki$ vexiw$ erh$ gsrgivrw$ sziv$ wszivimkr$ hifx

pizipw$ efvseh$ erh$ mr$ xli$Y2W2$ erh$ gsrgivrw$ sziv$ xli$ jempyvi$ xs$ ehiuyexip}$ ehhviww$ xli$ jihivep$ hijmgmx$ erh$ xli$ hifx$ gimpmrk2$ Mj$ xlswi

qegvsigsrsqmg$ gsrhmxmsrw$ gsrxmryi$ sv$ {svwir$ mr$ xli$ jyxyvi0$ {i$ gsyph$ fi$ tvizirxih$ jvsq$ vemwmrk$ ehhmxmsrep$ getmxep$ sv$ sfxemrmrk

ehhmxmsrep$ jmrergmrk$ sr$ wexmwjegxsv}$ xivqw0$ sv$ ex$ epp2$ Hyvmrk$ 645=0$ wizivep$ jmrergmep$ mrwxmxyxmsrw0$ mrgpyhmrk$ wsqi$ sj$ syv$ pirhivw0

errsyrgih$ xlex$ xli}${mpp$ rsx$ fi$ viri{mrk$i|mwxmrk$ ekviiqirxw$sv$ irxivmrk$ mrxs$ri{$ekviiqirxw${mxl$gsqtermiw$ xlex$ stivexi$ wigyvi

wivzmgiw$jegmpmxmiw$erh$girxivw$tyvwyerx$xs$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw2$Wsqi$sj$xliwi$weqi$mrwxmxyxmsrw$lezi$giewih$xlimv$iuymx}$erep}wx

gsziveki$sj$syv$gsqter}2$Mj${i$riih0$fyx$gerrsx$sfxemr0$ehiuyexi$getmxep$ew$e$viwypx$sj$rikexmzi$gsrhmxmsrw$mr$xli$getmxep$qevoixw$sv

sxliv{mwi0$ syv$ fywmriww0$ viwypxw$ sj$ stivexmsrw$ erh$ jmrergmep$ gsrhmxmsr$ gsyph$ fi$ qexivmepp}$ ehzivwip}$ ejjigxih2$ Ehhmxmsrepp}0$ wygl

mrefmpmx}$ xs$ sfxemr$ getmxep$ gsyph$ tvizirx$ yw$ jvsq$ tyvwymrk$ exxvegxmzi$ fywmriww$ hizipstqirx$ sttsvxyrmxmiw0$ mrgpyhmrk$ ri{$ jegmpmx}

gsrwxvygxmsrw$sv$i|terwmsrw$sj$i|mwxmrk$jegmpmxmiw0$erh$fywmriww$sv$ewwix$eguymwmxmsrw2

[i$evi$wyfnigx$xs$xli$psww$sj$syv$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw0$hyi$xs$xivqmrexmsrw0$rsr1viri{epw$sv$gsqtixmxmzi$vi1fmhw0${lmgl

gsyph$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$syv$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$erh$pmuymhmx}0$mrgpyhmrk$syv$efmpmx}$xs$wigyvi$ri{$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw

jvsq$sxliv$kszivrqirx$gywxsqivw2

[i$evi$i|tswih$ xs$ xli$ vmwo$ xlex${i$qe}$ pswi$syv$ jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$ gsrxvegxw$ tvmqevmp}$hyi$ xs$sri$sj$ xlvii$ viewsrw>$ ,m-$ xli

xivqmrexmsr$f}$e$kszivrqirx$gywxsqiv${mxl$sv${mxlsyx$geywi$ex$er}$xmqi?$,mm-$xli$jempyvi$f}$e$gywxsqiv$xs$i|ivgmwi$mxw$yrmpexivep$stxmsr

xs$viri{$e$gsrxvegx${mxl$yw$ytsr$xli$i|tmvexmsr$sj$xli$xlir$gyvvirx$xivq?$sv$,mmm-$syv$jempyvi$xs${mr$xli$vmklx$xs$gsrxmryi$xs$stivexi$yrhiv

e$gsrxvegx$ xlex$lew$fiir$gsqtixmxmzip}$ vi1fmh$ mr$ e$tvsgyviqirx$tvsgiww$ytsr$ mxw$ xivqmrexmsr$sv$ i|tmvexmsr2$Syv$ jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx

gsrxvegxw$ x}tmgepp}$epps{$e$gsrxvegxmrk$kszivrqirxep$ ekirg}$ xs$ xivqmrexi$e$gsrxvegx${mxl$sv${mxlsyx$geywi$ex$ er}$ xmqi$f}$kmzmrk$yw

{vmxxir$rsxmgi$verkmrk$jvsq$74$xs$5<4$he}w2$Mj$kszivrqirx$ekirgmiw${ivi$xs$ywi$xliwi$tvszmwmsrw$xs$xivqmrexi0$sv$viriksxmexi$xli$xivqw

sj$xlimv$ekviiqirxw${mxl$yw0$syv$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$gsyph$fi$qexivmepp}$ehzivwip}$ejjigxih2

Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$7<$sj$syv$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$qe}$fi$wyfnigx$xs$gsqtixmxmzi$vi1fmh$mr$64642$Xliwi$gsrxvegxw

mr$xli$ekkvikexi$vitviwirxih$5527)$erh$(85624$qmppmsr$sj$syv$645=$gsrwspmhexih$viziryiw2$[lmpi${i$evi$tpiewih${mxl$syv$lmwxsvmgep${mr

vexi$ sr$ gsqtixmxmzi$ vi1fmhw$ erh$ evi$ gsqqmxxih$ xs$ gsrxmrymrk$ xs$ fmh$ gsqtixmxmzip}$ sr$ ettvstvmexi$ jyxyvi$ gsqtixmxmzi$ vi1fmh

sttsvxyrmxmiw0$ {i$ gerrsx$ mr$ jegx$ ewwyvi$ }sy$ xlex$ {i$ {mpp$ tvizemp$ mr$ jyxyvi$ vi1fmh$ wmxyexmsrw2$ Epws0$ {i$ gerrsx$ ewwyvi$ }sy$ xlex$ er}

gsqtixmxmzi$ vi1fmhw$ {i${mr${mpp$ fi$ sr$ xivqw$qsvi$ jezsvefpi$ xs$ yw$ xler$ xlswi$ mr$ i|mwxirgi${mxl$ viwtigx$ xs$ xli$ ettpmgefpi$ i|tmvmrk

gsrxvegx2

75

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 45 of 253

Page 68: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 89367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Jsv$ehhmxmsrep$mrjsvqexmsr$sr$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$xlex${i$gyvvirxp}$fipmizi${mpp$fi$gsqtixmxmzip}$vi1fmh$hyvmrk$iegl$sj

xli$ ri|x$ jmzi$}ievw$ erh$ xliviejxiv0$ tpiewi$ wii$ ÔFywmriww$Ó$Kszivrqirx$Gsrxvegxw$Ó$Xivqmrexmsrw0$Viri{epw$ erh$Gsqtixmxmzi$Vi1

fmhwÕ2$ Xli$ psww$ f}$ yw$ sj$ jegmpmx}$ qerekiqirx$ gsrxvegxw$ hyi$ xs$ xivqmrexmsrw0$ rsr1viri{epw$ sv$ gsqtixmxmzi$ vi1fmhw$ gsyph$qexivmepp}

ehzivwip}$ejjigx$syv$ jmrergmep$ gsrhmxmsr0$ viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$erh$ pmuymhmx}0$ mrgpyhmrk$syv$efmpmx}$ xs$ wigyvi$ri{$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx

gsrxvegxw$jvsq$sxliv$kszivrqirx$gywxsqivw2

Syv$kvs{xl$hitirhw$sr$syv$efmpmx}$xs$wigyvi$gsrxvegxw$xs$hizipst$erh$qereki$ri{$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw0$tvsgiwwmrk$girxivw$erh

gsqqyrmx}$fewih$jegmpmxmiw$erh$xs$wigyvi$gsrxvegxw$xs$tvszmhi$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$wivzmgiw0$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$viirxv}$wivzmgiw$erh

qsrmxsvmrk$erh$wytivzmwmsr$wivzmgiw0$xli$hiqerh$jsv${lmgl$mw$syxwmhi$syv$gsrxvsp2

Syv$kvs{xl$mw$tvmqevmp}$hitirhirx$ytsr$syv$efmpmx}$ xs$sfxemr$ri{$gsrxvegxw$ xs$hizipst$erh3sv$qereki$wigyvi0$tvsgiwwmrk0$erh

gsqqyrmx}$ fewih$ jegmpmxmiw$ yrhiv$ tyfpmg1tvmzexi$ tevxrivwlmtw2$ Ehhmxmsrepp}0$ syv$ kvs{xl$ mw$ kirivepp}$ hitirhirx$ ytsr$ syv$ efmpmx}$ xs

sfxemr$ri{$gsrxvegxw$ xs$sjjiv$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$wivzmgiw0$tvszmhi$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$viirxv}$ wivzmgiw$erh$tvszmhi$qsrmxsvmrk$erh

wytivzmwmsr$wivzmgiw2$Hiqerh$jsv$ri{$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmt$jegmpmxmiw$mr$syv$eview$sj$stivexmsr$qe}$higviewi$erh$syv$tsxirxmep$jsv

kvs{xl$ {mpp$ hitirh$ sr$ e$ ryqfiv$ sj$ jegxsvw$ {i$ gerrsx$ gsrxvsp0$ mrgpyhmrk$ szivepp$ igsrsqmg$ gsrhmxmsrw0$ kszivrqirxep$ erh$ tyfpmg

eggitxergi$sj$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw0$kszivrqirx$fyhkixev}$gsrwxvemrxw0$erh$xli$ryqfiv$sj$jegmpmxmiw$ezempefpi$jsv$tyfpmg1tvmzexi

tevxrivwlmtw2

Mr$tevxmgypev0$xli$hiqerh$jsv$syv$wigyvi$jegmpmx}$erh$tvsgiwwmrk$girxiv$wivzmgiw0$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$wivzmgiw0$gsqqyrmx}1fewih

viirxv}$wivzmgiw$erh$qsrmxsvmrk$erh$wytivzmwmsr$wivzmgiw$gsyph$fi$ejjigxih$f}$glerkiw$mr$i|mwxmrk$tspmgmiw${lmgl$ehzivwip}$mqtegx$xli

riih$jsv$erh$eggitxergi$sj$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw$egvsww$xli$wtigxvyq$sj$wivzmgiw${i$tvszmhi2$Zevmsyw$jegxsvw$syxwmhi$syv$gsrxvsp

gsyph$ ehzivwip}$ mqtegx$ xli$ kvs{xl$ sj$ syv$ KIS$ Gevi$ fywmriww0$ mrgpyhmrk$ kszivrqirx$ gywxsqiv$ viwmwxergi$ xs$ xli$ tyfpmg1tvmzexi

tevxrivwlmtw$jsv$viwmhirxmep$gsqqyrmx}$fewih$jegmpmxmiw0$erh$glerkiw$xs$Qihmgemh$erh$wmqmpev$vimqfyvwiqirx$tvskveqw2

[i$qe}$rsx$fi$efpi$xs$qiix$wxexi$viuymviqirxw$jsv$getmxep$mrziwxqirx$sv$psgexi$perh$jsv$xli$hizipstqirx$sj$ri{$jegmpmxmiw0${lmgl

gsyph$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$syv$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$erh$jyxyvi$kvs{xl2

Givxemr$nyvmwhmgxmsrw$lezi$mr$xli$tewx$viuymvih$wyggiwwjyp$fmhhivw$xs$qeoi$e$wmkrmjmgerx$getmxep$mrziwxqirx$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli

jmrergmrk$sj$e$tevxmgypev$tvsnigx2$Mj$xlmw$xvirh${ivi$xs$gsrxmryi$mr$xli$jyxyvi0${i$qe}$rsx$fi$efpi$xs$sfxemr$wyjjmgmirx$getmxep$viwsyvgiw

{lir$riihih$xs$gsqtixi$ijjigxmzip}$jsv$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$syv$wyggiww$mr$sfxemrmrk$ri{$e{evhw$erh$gsrxvegxw

qe}$ hitirh0$ mr$ tevx0$ ytsr$ syv$ efmpmx}$ xs$ psgexi$ perh$ xlex$ ger$ fi$ piewih$ sv$ eguymvih$ yrhiv$ jezsvefpi$ xivqw2$Syv$ mrefmpmx}$ xs$ wigyvi

jmrergmrk$erh$hiwmvefpi$psgexmsrw$jsv$ri{$jegmpmxmiw$gsyph$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$syv$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$erh$jyxyvi$kvs{xl2

[i$tevxriv${mxl$e$pmqmxih$ryqfiv$sj$kszivrqirxep$gywxsqivw${ls$eggsyrx$jsv$e$wmkrmjmgerx$tsvxmsr$sj$syv$viziryiw2$Xli$psww$sj0

sv$e$wmkrmjmgerx$higviewi$mr$viziryiw$jvsq0$xliwi$gywxsqivw$gsyph$wivmsywp}$levq$syv$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2

[i$ gyvvirxp}$ hivmzi0$ erh$ i|tigx$ xs$ gsrxmryi$ xs$ hivmzi0$ e$ wmkrmjmgerx$ tsvxmsr$ sj$ syv$ viziryiw$ jvsq$ e$ pmqmxih$ ryqfiv$ sj

kszivrqirxep$ekirgmiw2$Sj$syv$kszivrqirxep$tevxrivw0$jsyv$gywxsqivw0$xlvsykl$qypxmtpi$mrhmzmhyep$gsrxvegxw0$eggsyrxih$jsv$992:)$erh

8=2;)$ sj$ syv$ gsrwspmhexih$ viziryiw$ jsv$ xli$ }ievw$ irhih$ Higiqfiv$ 750$ 645=$ erh$ 645<0$ viwtigxmzip}2$ Mr$ ehhmxmsr0$ xlvii$ jihivep

kszivrqirxep$ekirgmiw${mxl$gsvvigxmsrep$erh$hixirxmsr$ viwtsrwmfmpmxmiw0$ xli$Fyviey$sj$Tvmwsrw$ ,&FST&-0$ MGI0$erh$ xli$Y2W2$Qevwlepw

Wivzmgi0$ eggsyrxih$ jsv$ 9526)$ erh$ 8=26)$ sj$ syv$ xsxep$ gsrwspmhexih$ viziryiw$ jsv$ xli$ }ievw$ irhih$ Higiqfiv$ 750$ 645=$ erh$ 645<0

viwtigxmzip}0$xlvsykl$qypxmtpi$mrhmzmhyep$gsrxvegxw0${mxl$xli$FST$eggsyrxmrk$jsv$552=)$erh$5625)$sj$syv$xsxep$gsrwspmhexih$viziryiw

jsv$wygl$}ievw0$MGI$eggsyrxmrk$jsv$6<2:)$erh$672=)$sj$syv$xsxep$gsrwspmhexih$viziryiw$jsv$wygl$}ievw0$erh$xli$Y2W2$Qevwlepw$Wivzmgi

eggsyrxmrk$jsv$5527)$erh$5525)$sj$syv$xsxep$gsrwspmhexih$viziryiw$jsv$wygl$}ievw2$Ls{iziv0$rs$mrhmzmhyep$gsrxvegx${mxl$xliwi$gpmirxw

eggsyrxih$ jsv$qsvi$ xler$ 5424)$ sj$ syv$ xsxep$ gsrwspmhexih$ viziryiw$ jsv$ wygl$ }ievw2$Kszivrqirx$ ekirgmiw$ jvsq$ xli$ Wxexi$ sj$ Jpsvmhe

eggsyrxih$jsv$ettvs|mqexip}$9)$sj$syv$xsxep$gsrwspmhexih$viziryiw$jsv$iegl$sj$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$645<$xlvsykl

qypxmtpi$mrhmzmhyep$gsrxvegxw2

Syv$viziryiw$hitirh$sr$syv$kszivrqirxep$gywxsqivw$vigimzmrk$wyjjmgmirx$jyrhmrk$erh$tvszmhmrk$yw${mxl$xmqip}$te}qirx$yrhiv

xli$xivqw$sj$syv$gsrxvegxw2$Mj$xli$ettpmgefpi$kszivrqirxep$gywxsqivw$hs$rsx$vigimzi$wyjjmgmirx$ettvstvmexmsrw$xs$gsziv$xlimv$gsrxvegxyep

sfpmkexmsrw0$ xli}$qe}$ hipe}$ sv$ vihygi$ te}qirx$ xs$ yw$ sv$ xivqmrexi$ xlimv$ gsrxvegxw${mxl$ yw2$[mxl$ viwtigx$ xs$ syv$ jihivep$ kszivrqirx

gywxsqivw0$er}$jyxyvi$mqtewwi$sv$wxvykkpi$mqtegxmrk$xli$jihivep$kszivrqirx×w$efmpmx}$ xs$ viegl$ekviiqirx$sr$xli$jihivep$fyhkix0$hifx

gimpmrk$ sv$ er}$ jyxyvi$ jihivep$ kszivrqirx$ wlyx$ hs{rw$ gsyph$ viwypx$ mr$ qexivmep$ te}qirx$ hipe}w0$ te}qirx$ vihygxmsrw$ sv$ gsrxvegx

xivqmrexmsrw2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$syv$kszivrqirxep$gywxsqivw$qe}$viuyiwx$mr$xli$jyxyvi$xlex${i$vihygi$syv$tiv$hmiq$gsrxvegx$vexiw$sv$jsviks

mrgviewiw$xs$xlswi$vexiw$ew$e${e}$jsv$xlswi$kszivrqirxep$gywxsqivw$xs$gsrxvsp$xlimv$wtirhmrk$erh$ehhviww$xlimv$fyhkixev}$wlsvxjeppw2

76

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 46 of 253

Page 69: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 8:367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Syv$ kszivrqirxep$ gywxsqivw$qe}$ epws$ jvsq$ xmqi$ xs$ xmqi$ ehstx0$ mqtpiqirx$ sv$qshmj}$ givxemr$ tspmgmiw$ sv$ hmvigxmziw$ xlex$qe}

ehzivwip}$ejjigx$syv$fywmriww2$Syv$jihivep0$wxexi$sv$psgep$kszivrqirxep$tevxrivw$qe}$mr$xli$jyxyvi$glsswi$xs$yrhivxeoi$e$vizmi{$sj$xlimv

yxmpm~exmsr$sj$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw0$sv$qe}$gergip$sv$higmhi$rsx$xs$viri{$syv$i|mwxmrk$gsrxvegxw${mxl$xliq2$Jsv$i|eqtpi0$hyvmrk

xli$jsyvxl$uyevxiv$sj$645=0$xli$Wxexi$sj$Gepmjsvrme$iregxih$pikmwpexmsr$xlex$figeqi$ijjigxmzi$sr$Neryev}$50$6464$emqih$ex$tlewmrk$syx

tyfpmg1tvmzexi$ tevxrivwlmt$ gsrxvegxw$ jsv$ xli$ stivexmsr$ sj$ wigyvi$ jegmpmxmiw$ {mxlmr$ Gepmjsvrme$ erh$ jegmpmxmiw$ syxwmhi$ sj$ xli$ Wxexi$ sj

Gepmjsvrme$lsywmrk$Wxexi$sj$Gepmjsvrme$ mrqexiw2$Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$ xli$Wxexi$sj$Gepmjsvrme${ew$eqsrk$syv$ xst$54$gywxsqivw

vipexmrk$xs$syv$s{rih$erh$piewih$jegmpmxmiw2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0${i$lezi$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmt$gsrxvegxw$mr$tpegi${mxl$Y2W2$Mqqmkvexmsr

erh$Gywxsqw$Irjsvgiqirx0$xli$Jihivep$Fyviey$sj$Tvmwsrw$erh$xli$Y2W2$Qevwlepw$Wivzmgi$vipexmrk$xs$jegmpmxmiw$psgexih$mr$Gepmjsvrme2$Ew

{i$tvizmsywp}$hmwgpswih0$syv$gsrxvegx$jsv$syv$Girxvep$Zeppi}$jegmpmx}${ew$hmwgsrxmryih$f}$xli$Wxexi$sj$Gepmjsvrme$ex$xli$irh$sj$Witxiqfiv

645=0$erh${i$i|tigx$syv$x{s$sxliv$Gepmjsvrme$wigyvi$jegmpmx}$gsrxvegxw$xs$i|tmvi$sr$Qevgl$5$jsv$xli$Hiwivx$Zmi{$Jegmpmx}$erh$Qe}$5$jsv

xli$Ksphir$Wxexi$Jegmpmx}2$Hyvmrk$xli$jsyvxl$uyevxiv$sj$645=0${i$wmkrih$x{s$591}iev$gsrxvegxw${mxl$xli$Y2W2$Mqqmkvexmsr$erh$Gywxsqw

Irjsvgiqirx$jsv$jmzi$gsqter}1s{rih$jegmpmxmiw$mr$Gepmjsvrme$xsxepmrk$808=4$fihw$erh$e$qerekih1srp}$gsrxvegx${mxl$xli$Y2W2$Qevwlepw

Wivzmgi$jsv$xli$kszivrqirx1s{rih0$9561fih$Ip$Girxvs$Wivzmgi$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxiv$mr$Gepmjsvrme2$Epxlsykl$xliwi$gsrxvegxw${ivi$irxivih

mrxs$tvmsv$xs$Neryev}$50$64640${i$gerrsx$ewwyvi$}sy$xlex$xlivi${mpp$rsx$fi$tyfpmg$viwmwxergi$xs$xli$mqtpiqirxexmsr$sj$xliwi$gsrxvegxw0

mrgpyhmrk$pmxmkexmsr${lmgl$qe}$viwypx$mr$mrgviewih$pikep$jiiw$erh$gswxw2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0${i$erh$xli$Y2W2$Hitevxqirx$sj$Nywxmgi$lezi$jmpih

witevexi$ pikep$egxmsrw$gleppirkmrk$ xli$gsrwxmxyxmsrepmx}$sj$ xli$exxiqtxih$fer$sr$ri{$jihivep$gsrxvegxw$irxivih$ mrxs$ejxiv$ xli$ijjigxmzi

hexi$sj$xli$Gepmjsvrme$pe{2$[i$gerrsx$ewwyvi$}sy$xlex${i${mpp$fi$wyggiwwjyp$mr$gleppirkmrk$xli$gsrwxmxyxmsrepmx}$sj$xli$exxiqtxih$fer$sr

ri{$jihivep$gsrxvegxw0$sfxemrmrk$e$gsrgpywmsr$xs$wygl$pmxmkexmsr$sr$e$tvsqtx$fewmw0$erh$qerekmrk$ijjmgmirxp}$xli$gswxw$xs$fi$mrgyvvih$f}

yw$erh$xli$ywi$sj$qerekiqirx$xmqi$erh$viwsyvgiw$sr$wygl$pmxmkexmsr2$Xli$Wxexi$sj$[ewlmrkxsr$mw$gsrwmhivmrk$tvstswmrk$xli$ehstxmsr$sj

e$wmqmpev$pe{$xs$xli$Gepmjsvrme$pe{2

Xli$psww$sj0$sv$e$wmkrmjmgerx$higviewi$mr0$syv$gyvvirx$gsrxvegxw${mxl$xli$FST0$MGI0$xli$Y2W2$Qevwlepw$Wivzmgi0$xli$Wxexi$sj$Jpsvmhe

sv$er}$sxliv$wmkrmjmgerx$gywxsqivw$gsyph$wivmsywp}$levq$syv$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2$[i$i|tigx$xliwi$jihivep$erh

wxexi$ekirgmiw$erh$e$vipexmzip}$wqepp$kvsyt$sj$sxliv$kszivrqirxep$gywxsqivw$xs$gsrxmryi$xs$eggsyrx$jsv$e$wmkrmjmgerx$tivgirxeki$sj$syv

viziryiw2

E$higviewi$mr$sggyterg}$pizipw$gsyph$geywi$e$higviewi$mr$viziryiw$erh$tvsjmxefmpmx}2

[lmpi$e$wyfwxerxmep$tsvxmsr$sj$syv$gswx$wxvygxyvi$mw$kirivepp}$jm|ih0$qswx$sj$syv$viziryiw$evi$kirivexih$yrhiv$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx

gsrxvegxw${lmgl$tvszmhi$jsv$tiv$hmiq$te}qirxw$fewih$ytsr$hemp}$sggyterg}2$Wizivep$sj$xliwi$gsrxvegxw$tvszmhi$jm|ih1tvmgi$te}qirxw

xlex$gsziv$e$tsvxmsr$sv$epp$sj$syv$jm|ih$gswxw2$Ls{iziv0$qer}$sj$syv$gsrxvegxw$lezi$rs$jm|ih1tvmgi$te}qirxw$erh$wmqtp}$tvszmhi$jsv$e

tiv$ hmiq$te}qirx$ fewih$sr$ egxyep$ sggyterg}2$Ew$ e$ viwypx0${mxl$ viwtigx$ xs$syv$ gsrxvegxw$ xlex$ lezi$rs$ jm|ih1tvmgi$te}qirxw0${i$ evi

lmklp}$ hitirhirx$ ytsr$ xli$ kszivrqirxep$ ekirgmiw$ {mxl$ {lmgl$ {i$ lezi$ gsrxvegxw$ xs$ yxmpm~i$ syv$ jegmpmxmiw2$ Yrhiv$ e$ tiv$ hmiq$ vexi

wxvygxyvi0$e$higviewi$mr$syv$yxmpm~exmsr$vexiw$gsyph$geywi$e$higviewi$mr$viziryiw$erh$tvsjmxefmpmx}2$[lir$gsqfmrih${mxl$vipexmzip}$jm|ih

gswxw$ jsv$ stivexmrk$ iegl$ jegmpmx}0$ vikevhpiww$ sj$ xli$ sggyterg}$ pizip0$ e$qexivmep$ higviewi$ mr$ sggyterg}$ pizipw$ ex$ sri$ sv$qsvi$ sj$ syv

jegmpmxmiw$gsyph$lezi$e$qexivmep$ehzivwi$ijjigx$sr$syv$viziryiw$erh$tvsjmxefmpmx}0$erh$gsrwiuyirxp}0$sr$syv$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$viwypxw

sj$stivexmsrw2

Wxexi$fyhkixev}$gsrwxvemrxw$qe}$lezi$e$qexivmep$ehzivwi$mqtegx$sr$yw2

Wxexi$fyhkixw$gsrxmryi$xlimv$wps{$xs$qshivexi$vigsziv}2$Eggsvhmrk$xs$xli$Rexmsrep$Gsrjivirgi$sj$Wxexi$Pikmwpexyviw0$xli$syxpsso

jsv$ wxexi$ fyhkixw$ mw$ wxefpi2$ Viziryi$ tivjsvqergi$ mw$ tswmxmzi0$ erh$ i|tirhmxyvi$ szivvyrw$ evi$ vipexmzip}$ qshiwx2$ Szivepp0$ qswx$ wxexi

sjjmgmepw$ erxmgmtexi$ e$ wps{$ erh$ wxieh}$ mqtvsziqirx$ mr$ wxexi$ jmrergiw2$ Ew$ sj$ Higiqfiv$ 750$ 645=0$ KIS$ leh$ wxexi$ gpmirxw>$ Jpsvmhe0

Kisvkme0$Evoerwew0$Psymwmere0$Gspsvehs0$Zmvkmrme0$Mrhmere0$Oirxygo}0$Mppmrsmw0$Sopelsqe0$Ri{$Nivwi}0$Wsyxl$Gevspmre0$Ri{$Qi|mgs0

Evm~sre0$Tirrw}pzerme0$Xi|ew$erh$Gepmjsvrme2$Mj$wxexi$fyhkixev}$gsrhmxmsrw$hixivmsvexi0$syv$5;$wxexi$gywxsqivw×$efmpmx}$xs$te}$yw$qe}$fi

mqtemvih$ erh3sv${i$qe}$ fi$ jsvgih$ xs$ viriksxmexi$ syv$qerekiqirx$ gsrxvegxw${mxl$ xlswi$ gywxsqivw$ sr$ piww$ jezsvefpi$ xivqw$ erh$ syv

jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$sv$gewl$jps{w$gsyph$fi$qexivmepp}$ehzivwip}$ mqtegxih2$ Mr$ehhmxmsr0$fyhkixev}$gsrwxvemrxw$ mr

wxexiw$ xlex$ evi$ rsx$ syv$ gyvvirx$ gywxsqivw$ gsyph$ tvizirx$ xlswi$ wxexiw$ jvsq$ ywmrk$ tyfpmg1tvmzexi$ tevxrivwlmtw$ jsv$ wigyvi$ jegmpmxmiw0

tvsgiwwmrk$girxivw$sv$gsqqyrmx}$fewih$wivzmgi$sttsvxyrmxmiw$xlex${i$sxliv{mwi$gsyph$lezi$tyvwyih2

Gsqtixmxmsr$jsv$gsrxvegxw$qe}$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$xli$tvsjmxefmpmx}$sj$syv$fywmriww2

[i$ gsqtixi$ {mxl$ kszivrqirx$ irxmxmiw$ erh$ sxliv$ tyfpmg1tvmzexi$ tevxrivwlmt$ stivexsvw$ sr$ xli$ fewmw$ sj$ gswx0$ fih$ ezempefmpmx}0

psgexmsr$ sj$ jegmpmx}0$ uyepmx}$ erh$ verki$ sj$ wivzmgiw$ sjjivih0$ i|tivmirgi$ mr$ qerekmrk$ jegmpmxmiw0$ erh$ vityxexmsr$ sj$ qerekiqirx$ erh

tivwsrrip2$ Fevvmivw$ xs$ irxivmrk$ xli$qevoix$ jsv$ xli$qerekiqirx$ sj$ wigyvi$ erh$ tvsgiwwmrk$ jegmpmxmiw$ erh$ xli$ tvszmwmsr$ sj$ gsqqyrmx}

viirxv}$tvskveqw$qe}$rsx$fi$wyjjmgmirx$xs$pmqmx$ehhmxmsrep$gsqtixmxmsr$mr$syv$mrhywxv}2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$wsqi$sj$syv$kszivrqirx$gywxsqivw

qe}$ewwyqi$xli$qerekiqirx$sj$e$jegmpmx}$gyvvirxp}$qerekih$f}$yw$ytsr$xli$xivqmrexmsr$sj$xli$gsvviwtsrhmrk$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegx$sv0

mj$wygl$gywxsqivw$lezi$getegmx}$ex$xli$jegmpmxmiw${lmgl$xli}$stivexi0$xli}$qe}$glsswi$xs$ywi$piww$getegmx}$ex$syv$jegmpmxmiw2$Wmrgi${i$evi

temh$sr$e$tiv$hmiq$fewmw$fewih$sr$egxyep$sggyterg}$yrhiv$wsqi$sj$syv$gsrxvegxw0$e$higviewi$mr$sggyterg}$gsyph$geywi$e$higviewi$mr

fsxl$syv$viziryiw$erh$syv$tvsjmxefmpmx}2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 47 of 253

Page 70: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 8;367<

77

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 48 of 253

Page 71: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 8<367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

[i$evi$hitirhirx$sr$kszivrqirx$ettvstvmexmsrw0${lmgl$qe}$rsx$fi$qehi$sr$e$xmqip}$fewmw$sv$ex$epp$erh$qe}$fi$ehzivwip}

mqtegxih$f}$fyhkixev}$gsrwxvemrxw$ex$xli$jihivep0$wxexi0$psgep$erh$jsvimkr$kszivrqirx$pizipw2

Syv$gewl$jps{$mw$wyfnigx$xs$xli$vigimtx$sj$wyjjmgmirx$jyrhmrk$sj$erh$xmqip}$te}qirx$f}$gsrxvegxmrk$kszivrqirxep$irxmxmiw2$Mj$xli

gsrxvegxmrk$kszivrqirxep$ekirg}$hsiw$rsx$vigimzi$wyjjmgmirx$ettvstvmexmsrw$xs$gsziv$ mxw$gsrxvegxyep$sfpmkexmsrw0$ mx$qe}$ xivqmrexi$syv

gsrxvegx$sv$hipe}$sv$vihygi$te}qirx$xs$yw2$Er}$hipe}w$mr$te}qirx0$sv$xli$xivqmrexmsr$sj$e$gsrxvegx0$gsyph$lezi$e$qexivmep$ehzivwi$ijjigx

sr$syv$gewl$jps{$erh$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr0${lmgl$qe}$qeoi$mx$hmjjmgypx$xs$wexmwj}$syv$te}qirx$sfpmkexmsrw$sr$syv$mrhifxihriww0$mrgpyhmrk

xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$ xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$ xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$64660$ xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468$erh$ xli

wirmsv$gvihmx$jegmpmx}0$mr$e$xmqip}$qerriv2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$ew$e$viwypx$sj0$eqsrk$sxliv$xlmrkw0$vigirx$igsrsqmg$hizipstqirxw0$hsqiwxmgepp}0

jihivep0$wxexi$erh$psgep$kszivrqirxw$lezi$irgsyrxivih0$erh$qe}$gsrxmryi$xs$irgsyrxiv0$yrywyep$fyhkixev}$gsrwxvemrxw2$Ew$e$viwypx0$e

ryqfiv$ sj$ wxexi$ erh$ psgep$ kszivrqirxw$qe}$ fi$ yrhiv$ tviwwyvi$ xs$ gsrxvsp$ ehhmxmsrep$ wtirhmrk$ sv$ vihygi$ gyvvirx$ pizipw$ sj$ wtirhmrk

{lmgl$gsyph$ pmqmx$sv$ipmqmrexi$ettvstvmexmsrw$jsv$ xli$jegmpmxmiw$ xlex${i$stivexi2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$ew$e$ viwypx$sj$ xliwi$jegxsvw0${i$qe}$fi

viuyiwxih$ mr$ xli$ jyxyvi$ xs$ vihygi$ syv$ i|mwxmrk$ tiv$ hmiq$ gsrxvegx$ vexiw$ sv$ jsviks$ tvswtigxmzi$ mrgviewiw$ xs$ xlswi$ vexiw2$ Fyhkixev}

pmqmxexmsrw$qe}$epws$qeoi$ mx$qsvi$hmjjmgypx$ jsv$yw$xs$ viri{$syv$i|mwxmrk$gsrxvegxw$sr$jezsvefpi$ xivqw$sv$ex$epp2$Jyvxliv0$e$ryqfiv$sj

wxexiw$erh$jsvimkr$kszivrqirxw$mr${lmgl${i$stivexi$qe}$i|tivmirgi$fyhkix$gsrwxvemrxw$jsv$jmwgep$}iev$64642$[i$gerrsx$ewwyvi$}sy$xlex

xliwi$ gsrwxvemrxw${syph$ rsx$ viwypx$ mr$ vihygxmsrw$ mr$ tiv$ hmiqw0$ hipe}w$ mr$ te}qirx$ jsv$ wivzmgiw$ virhivih$ sv$ yrmpexivep$ xivqmrexmsr$ sj

gsrxvegxw2

Tyfpmg$viwmwxergi$xs$xli$ywi$sj$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw$jsv$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw0$tvsgiwwmrk$girxivw$erh$gsqqyrmx}$viirxv}$girxivw

gsyph$viwypx$mr$syv$mrefmpmx}$xs$sfxemr$ri{$gsrxvegxw$sv$xli$psww$sj$i|mwxmrk$gsrxvegxw0$mqtegx$syv$efmpmx}$xs$sfxemr$sv$vijmrergi$hifx

jmrergmrk$sv$irxiv$mrxs$gsqqivgmep$evverkiqirxw0${lmgl$gsyph$lezi$e$qexivmep$ehzivwi$ijjigx$sr$syv$fywmriww0$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr0

viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$erh$xli$qevoix$tvmgi$sj$syv$wigyvmxmiw2

Xli$qerekiqirx$erh$stivexmsr$sj$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw0$tvsgiwwmrk$girxivw$erh$gsqqyrmx}$viirxv}$girxivw$yrhiv$tyfpmg1tvmzexi

tevxrivwlmtw$lew$rsx$eglmizih$gsqtpixi$eggitxergi$f}$imxliv$kszivrqirx$ekirgmiw$sv$xli$tyfpmg2$Wsqi$kszivrqirxep$ekirgmiw$lezi

pmqmxexmsrw$sr$xlimv$efmpmx}$xs$hipikexi$xlimv$xvehmxmsrep$qerekiqirx$viwtsrwmfmpmxmiw$jsv$wygl$jegmpmxmiw$erh$girxivw$xs$tvmzexi$wigxsv

gsqtermiw$sv$xli}$qe}$fi$mrwxvygxih$f}$e$kszivrqirxep$ekirg}$sv$eyxlsvmx}$szivwiimrk$xliq$xs$vihygi$xlimv$yxmpm~exmsr$sv$wgsti$sj

tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw$sv$yrhivxeoi$ehhmxmsrep$vizmi{w$sj$xlimv$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw2$Er}$vitsvx$tvitevih$f}$sv$viuyiwxih$f}

e$kszivrqirxep$ekirg}$sv$tyfpmg$sjjmgmep0$mrziwxmkexmsr$sv$mruymv}0$tyfpmg$wxexiqirx$f}$er}$kszivrqirxep$ekirg}$sv$tyfpmg$sjjmgmep0

tspmg}$sv$pikmwpexmzi$glerki0$sv$sxliv$wmqmpev$sggyvvirgi$sv$egxmsr0$xlex$wiiow$xs0$sv$tyvtsvxw$xs0$tvslmfmx0$ipmqmrexi0$sv$sxliv{mwi$viwxvmgx

sv$pmqmx$mr$er}${e}0$xli$jihivep$kszivrqirx+w$,sv$er}$wxexi$sv$psgep$kszivrqirx+w-$efmpmx}$xs$gsrxvegx${mxl$tvmzexi$wigxsv$gsqtermiw$jsv

xli$stivexmsr$sj$xliwi$jegmpmxmiw$erh$girxivw0$gsyph$ehzivwip}$mqtegx$syv$efmpmx}$xs$qemrxemr$sv$viri{$i|mwxmrk$gsrxvegxw$sv$xs$sfxemr$ri{

gsrxvegxw2$Jsv$i|eqtpi0$vigirxp}$Gepmjsvrme$iregxih$pikmwpexmsr$emqih$ex$tlewmrk$syx$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmt$gsrxvegxw$jsv$xli

stivexmsr$sj$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw${mxlmr$Gepmjsvrme$erh$jegmpmxmiw$syxwmhi$sj$xli$wxexi$sj$Gepmjsvrme$lsywmrk$wxexi$sj$Gepmjsvrme$mrqexiw2$Ew$sj

Higiqfiv$750$645=0$xli$Wxexi$sj$Gepmjsvrme$mw$eqsrk$syv$xst$54$gywxsqivw2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0${i$lezi$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmt$gsrxvegxw

mr$tpegi${mxl$Y2W2$Mqqmkvexmsr$erh$Gywxsqw$Irjsvgiqirx0$xli$Jihivep$Fyviey$sj$Tvmwsrw$erh$xli$Y2W2$Qevwlepw$Wivzmgi$vipexmrk$xs

jegmpmxmiw$psgexih$mr$Gepmjsvrme2$Gyvvirxp}0$xli$Wxexi$sj$[ewlmrkxsr$mw$gsrwmhivmrk$tvstswmrk$xli$ehstxmsr$sj$e$wmqmpev$pe{$xs$xli

Gepmjsvrme$pe{2

Mr$ehhmxmsr0$xli$qsziqirx$xs{evh$ywmrk$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw$jsv$wygl$jegmpmxmiw$erh$girxivw$lew$irgsyrxivih$viwmwxergi

jvsq$kvsytw${lmgl$fipmizi$xlex$wygl$jegmpmxmiw$erh$girxivw$wlsyph$srp}$fi$stivexih$f}$kszivrqirxep$ekirgmiw2$Jsv$i|eqtpi0$wizivep

jmrergmep$mrwxmxyxmsrw0$mrgpyhmrk$wsqi$sj$syv$pirhivw0$errsyrgih$hyvmrk$645=$xlex$xli}${mpp$rsx$fi$viri{mrk$i|mwxmrk$ekviiqirxw$sv

irxivmrk$mrxs$ri{$ekviiqirxw${mxl$gsqtermiw$xlex$stivexi$wygl$jegmpmxmiw$erh$girxivw$tyvwyerx$xs$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw2$Wsqi$sj

xliwi$weqi$mrwxmxyxmsrw$lezi$giewih$xlimv$iuymx}$erep}wx$gsziveki$sj$syv$gsqter}2$Tvstswih$erh$jyxyvi$pikmwpexmsr$gsyph$mrhmvigxp}

mqtswi$ehhmxmsrep$jmrergmep$viwxvmgxmsrw${mxl$viwtigx$xs$syv$fywmriww2$Ew$er$i|eqtpi0$Ri{$]svo$Wxexi$Wirexi$Fmpp$W9877E$xlex$tewwih

xli$wxexi$wirexi$mr$Jifvyev}$6464$erh$mw$gyvvirxp}$mr$jvsrx$sj$xli$Ewwiqfp}$Ferow$Gsqqmxxii$tvslmfmxw$Ri{$]svo$wxexi$glevxivih

feromrk$mrwxmxyxmsrw$jvsq$mrziwxmrk$mr$erh$tvszmhmrk$jmrergmrk$jsv$tvmzexip}$stivexih$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw2$Mj$xlmw$fmpp$mw$ypxmqexip}$wmkrih

mrxs$pe{$f}$xli$Ri{$]svo$kszivrsv0$givxemr$ferow$qe}$fi$viwxvmgxih$jvsq$gsrhygxmrk$jmrergmrk$egxmzmxmiw${mxl$yw$erh$xli$wigyvi

wivzmgiw$wigxsv$kirivepp}2$Xlmw$fmpp$sv$er}$wmqmpev$fmppw0$vikypexmsrw$erh$pe{w$xlex$qe}$fi$tvstswih$mr$xli$jyxyvi$qe}$fi$wyfnigx$xs$pikep

egxmsrw$erh$xli$viwspyxmsr$sj$wygl$pikep$egxmsrw$qe}$xeoi$wizivep$}ievw0$qeomrk$mx$hmjjmgypx$xs$erxmgmtexi$xli$szivepp$jmrergmep$mqtegx$sr

yw0$syv$fywmriww0$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$sv$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2$[lmpi${i$fipmizi${i${mpp$gsrxmryi$xs$lezi$eggiww$xs$xli$getmxep$erh$hifx

qevoixw$sr$e$gswx1ijjigxmzi$fewmw$xs$wyttsvx$xli$kvs{xl$erh$i|terwmsr$sj$syv$lmkl1uyepmx}$wivzmgiw0$mj$sxliv$jmrergmep$mrwxmxyxmsrw$sv$xlmvh

tevxmiw$xlex$gyvvirxp}$tvszmhi$yw${mxl$jmrergmrk$sv$xlex${i$hs$fywmriww${mxl$higmhi$mr$xli$jyxyvi$xs$giewi$tvszmhmrk$yw${mxl$jmrergmrk$sv

hsmrk$fywmriww${mxl$yw0$wygl$hixivqmrexmsrw$gsyph$lezi$e$qexivmep$ehzivwi$ijjigx$sr$syv$fywmriww0$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$viwypxw$sj

stivexmsrw2

Mrgviewih$tyfpmg$viwmwxergi$xs$xli$ywi$sj$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw$jsv$syv$jegmpmxmiw$erh$girxivw$mr$er}$sj$xli$qevoixw$mr

{lmgl${i$stivexi0$ew$e$viwypx$sj$xliwi$sv$sxliv$jegxsvw0$gsyph$lezi$e$qexivmep$ehzivwi$ijjigx$sr$syv$fywmriww0$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr0$viwypxw

sj$stivexmsrw$erh$xli$qevoix$tvmgi$sj$syv$wigyvmxmiw2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 49 of 253

Page 72: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 8=367<

78

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 50 of 253

Page 73: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 94367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Stivexmrk$}syxl$wivzmgiw$jegmpmxmiw$tswiw$givxemr$yrmuyi$sv$mrgviewih$vmwow$erh$hmjjmgypxmiw$gsqtevih$xs$stivexmrk$sxliv$jegmpmxmiw2

Ew$ e$ viwypx$ sj$ xli$ eguymwmxmsr$ sj$ Gsvripp$ Gsqtermiw0$ Mrg2$ ,xli$ &Gsvripp$ Eguymwmxmsr&-$ mr$ 64540$ {i$ vi1irxivih$ xli$ qevoix$ sj

stivexmrk$}syxl$ wivzmgiw$ jegmpmxmiw2$Stivexmrk$}syxl$wivzmgiw$ jegmpmxmiw$qe}$tswi$ mrgviewih$stivexmsrep$ vmwow$erh$hmjjmgypxmiw$ xlex$qe}

viwypx$mr$mrgviewih$pmxmkexmsr0$lmkliv$tivwsrrip$gswxw0$lmkliv$pizipw$sj$xyvrsziv$sj$tivwsrrip$erh$vihygih$tvsjmxefmpmx}2$I|eqtpiw$sj$xli

mrgviewih$stivexmsrep$vmwow$erh$hmjjmgypxmiw$mrzspzih$mr$stivexmrk$}syxl$wivzmgiw$jegmpmxmiw$mrgpyhi0$qerhexih$gpmirx$xs$wxejj$vexmsw$ew$lmkl

ew$5>:0$ipizexih$vitsvxmrk$erh$eyhmx$ viuymviqirxw0$e$ vihygih$ryqfiv$sj$qerekiqirx$stxmsrw$ xs$ywi${mxl$ mrhmzmhyepw$mr$syv$gevi$erh

qypxmtpi$jyrhmrk$wsyvgiw$ew$sttswih$xs$e$wmrkpi$wsyvgi$te}iv2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$}syxl$wivzmgiw$gsrxvegxw$vipexih$xs$ihygexmsrep$wivzmgiw$qe}

tvszmhi$jsv$erryep$gsppigxmsr$wizivep$qsrxlw$ejxiv$e$wglssp$}iev$mw$gsqtpixih2$Xlmw$qe}$tswi$e$vmwo$xlex${i${mpp$rsx$fi$efpi$xs$gsppigx

xli$jypp$eqsyrx$s{ih$xlivif}$vihygmrk$syv$tvsjmxefmpmx}$erh3sv$gewl$jps{w0$sv$mx$qe}$ehzivwip}$mqtegx$syv$erryep$fyhkixmrk$tvsgiww$hyi

xs$ xli$ pek$ xmqi$fix{iir$tvszmhmrk$ xli$ihygexmsrep$wivzmgiw$viuymvih$yrhiv$e$gsrxvegx$erh$gsppigxmrk$ xli$eqsyrx$s{ih$ xs$yw$ jsv$wygl

wivzmgiw2

Ehzivwi$tyfpmgmx}$qe}$rikexmzip}$mqtegx$syv$efmpmx}$xs$vixemr$i|mwxmrk$gsrxvegxw$erh$sfxemr$ri{$gsrxvegxw2

Er}$rikexmzi$tyfpmgmx}$efsyx$er$iwgeti0$vmsx0$sxliv$hmwxyvfergi0$hiexl$sv$mrnyv}$sj$e$hixemrii0$sv$tivgimzih$gsrhmxmsrw$erh$eggiww

xs$liepxl$gevi$erh$sxliv$wivzmgiw$ex$e$jegmpmx}0$mrgpyhmrk$er}${svo$tvskveq$ex$e$jegmpmx}0$yrhiv$e$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmt0$er}$jempyviw

i|tivmirgih$f}$syv$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$wivzmgiw$erh$er}$rikexmzi$tyfpmgmx}$efsyx$e$gvmqi$sv$hmwxyvfergi$sggyvvmrk$hyvmrk$e$jempyvi$sj

wivzmgi$sv$xli$psww$sv$yreyxlsvm~ih$eggiww$xs$er}$sj$xli$hexe${i$qemrxemr$mr$xli$gsyvwi$sj$tvszmhmrk$syv$wivzmgiw$qe}$viwypx$mr$tyfpmgmx}

ehzivwi$xs$yw$erh$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw$mr$kirivep2$Er}$sj$xliwi$sggyvvirgiw$sv$gsrxmryih$xvirhw$qe}$qeoi$mx$qsvi$hmjjmgypx$jsv$yw

xs$viri{$i|mwxmrk$gsrxvegxw$sv$xs$sfxemr$ri{$gsrxvegxw$sv$gsyph$viwypx$mr$xli$xivqmrexmsr$sj$er$i|mwxmrk$gsrxvegx$sv$xli$gpswyvi$sj$sri$sv

qsvi$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw0${lmgl$gsyph$lezi$e$qexivmep$ehzivwi$ijjigx$sr$syv$fywmriww2$Wygl$rikexmzi$izirxw$qe}$epws$viwypx$mr$e$wmkrmjmgerx

mrgviewi$mr$syv$pmefmpmx}$mrwyvergi$gswxw2

[i$qe}$mrgyv$wmkrmjmgerx$wxevx1yt$erh$stivexmrk$gswxw$sr$ri{$gsrxvegxw$fijsvi$vigimzmrk$vipexih$viziryiw0${lmgl$qe}$mqtegx$syv

gewl$jps{w$erh$rsx$fi$vigsytih2

[lir${i$evi$e{evhih$e$gsrxvegx$ xs$qereki$e$jegmpmx}0${i$qe}$mrgyv$wmkrmjmgerx$wxevx1yt$erh$stivexmrk$i|tirwiw0$ mrgpyhmrk$xli

gswx$sj$gsrwxvygxmrk$ xli$ jegmpmx}0$tyvglewmrk$iuymtqirx$erh$ wxejjmrk$ xli$ jegmpmx}0$fijsvi${i$ vigimzi$er}$te}qirxw$yrhiv$ xli$gsrxvegx2

Xliwi$i|tirhmxyviw$gsyph$viwypx$mr$e$wmkrmjmgerx$vihygxmsr$mr$syv$gewl$viwivziw$erh$qe}$qeoi$mx$qsvi$hmjjmgypx$jsv$yw$xs$qiix$sxliv$gewl

sfpmkexmsrw0$ mrgpyhmrk$syv$te}qirx$sfpmkexmsrw$sr$ xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$ xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$ xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi

64660$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468$erh$xli$Wirmsv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$e$gsrxvegx$qe}$fi$xivqmrexih$tvmsv$xs$mxw$wglihypih

i|tmvexmsr$erh$ew$e$viwypx${i$qe}$rsx$vigsziv$xliwi$i|tirhmxyviw$sv$viepm~i$er}$vixyvr$sr$syv$mrziwxqirx2

Jempyvi$xs$gsqtp}${mxl$i|xirwmzi$kszivrqirx$vikypexmsr$erh$ettpmgefpi$gsrxvegxyep$viuymviqirxw$gsyph$lezi$e$qexivmep$ehzivwi

ijjigx$sr$syv$fywmriww0$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$sv$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2

Xli$wigxsv$mr${lmgl${i$stivexi$mw$wyfnigx$xs$i|xirwmzi$jihivep0$wxexi$erh$psgep$vikypexmsr0$mrgpyhmrk$ihygexmsrep0$irzmvsrqirxep0

liepxl$gevi$erh$wejix}$pe{w0$vypiw$erh$vikypexmsrw0${lmgl$evi$ehqmrmwxivih$f}$qer}$vikypexsv}$eyxlsvmxmiw2$Wsqi$sj$xli$vikypexmsrw$evi

yrmuyi$ xs$ xli$ wigxsv0$ erh$ xli$ gsqfmrexmsr$ sj$ vikypexmsrw$ ejjigxw$ epp$ eview$ sj$ syv$ stivexmsrw2$ Gsvvigxmsrw$ sjjmgivw$ erh$ nyzirmpi$ gevi

{svoivw$ evi$ gywxsqevmp}$ viuymvih$ xs$ qiix$ givxemr$ xvemrmrk$ wxerhevhw$ erh0$ mr$ wsqi$ mrwxergiw0$ jegmpmx}$ tivwsrrip$ evi$ viuymvih$ xs$ fi

pmgirwih$erh$evi$wyfnigx$xs$fegokvsyrh$mrziwxmkexmsrw2$Givxemr$nyvmwhmgxmsrw$epws$viuymvi$yw$xs$e{evh$wyfgsrxvegxw$sr$e$gsqtixmxmzi$fewmw

sv$xs$wyfgsrxvegx${mxl$fywmriwwiw$s{rih$f}$qiqfivw$sj$qmrsvmx}$kvsytw2$[i$qe}$rsx$ep{e}w$wyggiwwjypp}$gsqtp}${mxl$xliwi$erh$sxliv

vikypexmsrw$xs${lmgl${i$evi$wyfnigx$erh$jempyvi$xs$gsqtp}$ger$viwypx$mr$qexivmep$tirepxmiw$sv$xli$rsr1viri{ep$sv$xivqmrexmsr$sj$jegmpmx}

qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$glerkiw$mr$i|mwxmrk$vikypexmsrw$gsyph$viuymvi$yw$ xs$wyfwxerxmepp}$qshmj}$ xli$qerriv$mr${lmgl${i

gsrhygx$syv$fywmriww$erh0$xlivijsvi0$gsyph$lezi$e$qexivmep$ehzivwi$ijjigx$sr$yw2

Mr$ehhmxmsr0$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw$evi$mrgviewmrkp}$wyfnigx$xs$kszivrqirx$pikmwpexmsr$erh$vikypexmsr$exxiqtxmrk$xs$viwxvmgx$xli

efmpmx}$sj$tvmzexi$ wigxsv$gsqtermiw$ xs$stivexi$ jegmpmxmiw$lsywmrk$givxemr$gpewwmjmgexmsrw$sj$ mrhmzmhyepw0$ wygl$ew$ mrhmzmhyepw$ jvsq$sxliv

nyvmwhmgxmsrw$sv$mrhmzmhyepw$ex$lmkliv$wigyvmx}$pizipw2$Pikmwpexmsr$lew$fiir$iregxih$mr$wizivep$wxexiw0$erh$lew$tvizmsywp}$fiir$tvstswih$mr

xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw$Lsywi$sj$Vitviwirxexmziw0$gsrxemrmrk$wygl$viwxvmgxmsrw2

Kszivrqirxep$ekirgmiw$qe}$mrziwxmkexi$erh$eyhmx$syv$gsrxvegxw$erh0$mj$er}$mqtvstvmixmiw$evi$jsyrh0${i$qe}$fi$viuymvih$xs$vijyrh

eqsyrxw${i$lezi$vigimzih0$xs$jsviks$erxmgmtexih$viziryiw$erh${i$qe}$fi$wyfnigx$xs$tirepxmiw$erh$wergxmsrw0$mrgpyhmrk$tvslmfmxmsrw$sr

syv$fmhhmrk$ mr$ viwtsrwi$ xs$VJTw$ jvsq$kszivrqirxep$ ekirgmiw$ xs$qereki$ wigyvi$ jegmpmxmiw2$Kszivrqirxep$ ekirgmiw${i$ gsrxvegx${mxl

lezi$ xli$eyxlsvmx}$ xs$eyhmx$ erh$ mrziwxmkexi$syv$gsrxvegxw${mxl$ xliq2$Ew$tevx$sj$ xlex$tvsgiww0$kszivrqirxep$ekirgmiw$qe}$ vizmi{$syv

tivjsvqergi$ sj$ xli$ gsrxvegx0$ syv$ tvmgmrk$ tvegxmgiw0$ syv$ gswx$ wxvygxyvi$ erh$ syv$ gsqtpmergi$ {mxl$ ettpmgefpi$ pe{w0$ vikypexmsrw$ erh

wxerhevhw2$Jsv$gsrxvegxw$ xlex$egxyepp}$sv$ijjigxmzip}$tvszmhi$ jsv$givxemr$ vimqfyvwiqirx$sj$i|tirwiw0$ mj$ er$ekirg}$hixivqmriw$ xlex${i

lezi$mqtvstivp}$eppsgexih$gswxw$xs$e$wtigmjmg$gsrxvegx0${i$qe}$rsx$fi$vimqfyvwih$jsv$xlswi$gswxw0$erh${i$gsyph$fi$viuymvih$xs$vijyrh

xli$eqsyrx$sj$er}$wygl$gswxw$xlex$lezi$fiir$vimqfyvwih2$Mj${i$evi$jsyrh$xs$lezi$irkekih$mr$mqtvstiv$sv

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 51 of 253

Page 74: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 95367<

79

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 52 of 253

Page 75: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 96367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

mppikep$ egxmzmxmiw0$ mrgpyhmrk$ yrhiv$ xli$ Yrmxih$ Wxexiw$ Jepwi$ Gpemqw$ Egx0$ {i$ qe}$ fi$ wyfnigx$ xs$ gmzmp$ erh$ gvmqmrep$ tirepxmiw$ erh

ehqmrmwxvexmzi$ wergxmsrw0$ mrgpyhmrk$ xivqmrexmsr$ sj$ gsrxvegxw0$ jsvjimxyviw$sj$ tvsjmxw0$ wywtirwmsr$ sj$ te}qirxw0$ jmriw$ erh$ wywtirwmsr$ sv

hmwuyepmjmgexmsr$jvsq$hsmrk$fywmriww${mxl$givxemr$kszivrqirxep$irxmxmiw2$Er$ehzivwi$hixivqmrexmsr$ mr$er$egxmsr$eppikmrk$ mqtvstiv$sv

mppikep$egxmzmxmiw$f}$yw$gsyph$epws$ehzivwip}$mqtegx$syv$efmpmx}$xs$fmh$mr$viwtsrwi$xs$VJTw$mr$sri$sv$qsvi$nyvmwhmgxmsrw2

Mr$ ehhmxmsr$ xs$ gsqtpmergi$ {mxl$ ettpmgefpi$ pe{w$ erh$ vikypexmsrw0$ syv$ jegmpmx}$ qerekiqirx$ gsrxvegxw$ x}tmgepp}$ lezi$ ryqivsyw

viuymviqirxw$ehhviwwmrk$epp$ewtigxw$sj$syv$stivexmsrw${lmgl${i$qe}$rsx$fi$efpi$ xs$wexmwj}2$Jsv$i|eqtpi0$syv$gsrxvegxw$ viuymvi$yw$ xs

qemrxemr$givxemr$pizipw$sj$gsziveki$jsv$kirivep$pmefmpmx}0${svoivw×$gsqtirwexmsr0$zilmgpi$pmefmpmx}0$erh$tvstivx}$psww$sv$heqeki2$Mj${i$hs

rsx$qemrxemr$xli$viuymvih$gexiksvmiw$erh$pizipw$sj$gsziveki0$ xli$gsrxvegxmrk$kszivrqirxep$ekirg}$qe}$fi$tivqmxxih$xs$xivqmrexi$xli

gsrxvegx2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0${i$evi$viuymvih$yrhiv$syv$gsrxvegxw$xs$mrhiqrmj}$xli$gsrxvegxmrk$kszivrqirxep$ekirg}$jsv$epp$gpemqw$erh$gswxw

evmwmrk$ syx$ sj$ syv$qerekiqirx$ sj$ jegmpmxmiw$ erh0$ mr$ wsqi$ mrwxergiw0${i$ evi$ viuymvih$ xs$qemrxemr$ tivjsvqergi$ fsrhw$ vipexmrk$ xs$ xli

gsrwxvygxmsr0$ hizipstqirx$ erh$ stivexmsr$ sj$ jegmpmxmiw2$ Jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$ gsrxvegxw$ epws$ x}tmgepp}$ mrgpyhi$ vitsvxmrk$ viuymviqirxw0

wytivzmwmsr$ erh$ sr1wmxi$qsrmxsvmrk$ f}$ vitviwirxexmziw$ sj$ xli$ gsrxvegxmrk$ kszivrqirxep$ ekirgmiw2$ Jempyvi$ xs$ tvstivp}$ ehlivi$ xs$ xli

zevmsyw$xivqw$sj$syv$gywxsqiv$gsrxvegxw$gsyph$i|tswi$yw$xs$pmefmpmx}$jsv$heqekiw$vipexmrk$xs$er}$fviegliw$ew${ipp$ew$xli$psww$sj$wygl

gsrxvegxw0${lmgl$gsyph$qexivmepp}$ehzivwip}$mqtegx$yw2

[i$qe}$jegi$gsqqyrmx}$sttswmxmsr$xs$jegmpmx}$psgexmsrw0${lmgl$qe}$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$syv$efmpmx}$xs$sfxemr$ri{$gsrxvegxw2

Syv$wyggiww$mr$sfxemrmrk$ri{$e{evhw$erh$gsrxvegxw$wsqixmqiw$hitirhw0$mr$tevx0$ytsr$syv$efmpmx}$xs$psgexi$perh$xlex$ger$fi$piewih

sv$eguymvih0$sr$igsrsqmgepp}$jezsvefpi$ xivqw0$f}$yw$sv$sxliv$irxmxmiw${svomrk${mxl$yw$ mr$gsrnyrgxmsr${mxl$syv$tvstswep$ xs$gsrwxvygx

erh3sv$qereki$e$jegmpmx}2$Wsqi$psgexmsrw$qe}$fi$mr$sv$riev$tstypsyw$eview$erh0$xlivijsvi0$qe}$kirivexi$pikep$egxmsr$sv$sxliv$jsvqw$sj

sttswmxmsr$ jvsq$ viwmhirxw$ mr$ eview$ wyvvsyrhmrk$ e$ tvstswih$ wmxi2$ [lir$ {i$ wipigx$ xli$ mrxirhih$ tvsnigx$ wmxi0$ {i$ exxiqtx$ xs$ gsrhygx

fywmriww$mr$gsqqyrmxmiw${livi$psgep$piehivw$erh$viwmhirxw$kirivepp}$wyttsvx$xli$iwxefpmwlqirx$sj$e$ri{$tvsnigx2$Jyxyvi$ijjsvxw$xs$jmrh

wymxefpi$lswx$gsqqyrmxmiw$qe}$rsx$fi$wyggiwwjyp2$Mr$qer}$gewiw0$xli$wmxi$wipigxmsr$mw$qehi$f}$xli$gsrxvegxmrk$kszivrqirxep$irxmx}2$Mr

wygl$gewiw0$wmxi$wipigxmsr$qe}$fi$qehi$jsv$viewsrw$vipexih$xs$igsrsqmg$hizipstqirx$mrxiviwxw2

Syv$fywmriww$stivexmsrw$i|tswi$yw$xs$zevmsyw$pmefmpmxmiw$jsv${lmgl${i$qe}$rsx$lezi$ehiuyexi$mrwyvergi$erh$qe}$lezi$e$qexivmep

ehzivwi$ijjigx$sr$syv$fywmriww0$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$sv$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2

Xli$rexyvi$sj$syv$wivzmgiw$i|tswiw$yw$xs$zevmsyw$x}tiw$sj$xlmvh1tevx}$pikep$gpemqw0$mrgpyhmrk0$fyx$rsx$pmqmxih$xs0$gmzmp$vmklxw$gpemqw

vipexmrk$xs$gsrhmxmsrw$sj$gsrjmriqirx$erh3sv$qmwxviexqirx0$wi|yep$qmwgsrhygx$gpemqw$fvsyklx$f}$mrhmzmhyepw${mxlmr$syv$gevi0$qihmgep

qeptvegxmgi$gpemqw0$gpemqw$vipexmrk$xs$xli$jihivep$Xvejjmgomrk$erh$Zmgxmqw$Tvsxigxmsr$Egx0$tvshygx$pmefmpmx}$gpemqw0$mrxippigxyep$tvstivx}

mrjvmrkiqirx$gpemqw0$gpemqw$vipexmrk$ xs$iqtps}qirx$qexxivw$ ,mrgpyhmrk0$fyx$rsx$pmqmxih$ xs0$iqtps}qirx$hmwgvmqmrexmsr$gpemqw0$yrmsr

kvmizergiw$erh${eki$erh$lsyv$gpemqw-0$tvstivx}$psww$gpemqw0$irzmvsrqirxep$gpemqw0$eyxsqsfmpi$pmefmpmx}$gpemqw0$gsrxvegxyep$gpemqw$erh

gpemqw$ jsv$ tivwsrep$ mrnyv}$ sv$ sxliv$ heqekiw$ viwypxmrk$ jvsq$ gsrxegx$ {mxl$ syv$ jegmpmxmiw0$ tvskveqw0$ ipigxvsrmg$ qsrmxsvmrk$ tvshygxw0

tivwsrrip$sv$tvmwsrivw0$mrgpyhmrk$heqekiw$evmwmrk$jvsq$er$mrqexi+w$iwgeti$sv$jvsq$e$hmwxyvfergi$sv$vmsx$ex$e$jegmpmx}2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$syv

qerekiqirx$ gsrxvegxw$ kirivepp}$ viuymvi$yw$ xs$ mrhiqrmj}$ xli$kszivrqirxep$ ekirg}$ ekemrwx$ er}$heqekiw$ xs${lmgl$ xli$kszivrqirxep

ekirg}$qe}$fi$wyfnigx$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$wygl$gpemqw$sv$pmxmkexmsr2$[i$qemrxemr$mrwyvergi$gsziveki$jsv$xliwi$kirivep$x}tiw$sj$gpemqw0

i|gitx$ jsv$ gpemqw$ vipexmrk$ xs$ iqtps}qirx$qexxivw0$ jsv$ {lmgl${i$ gevv}$ rs$ mrwyvergi2$ Ls{iziv0$ {i$ kirivepp}$ lezi$ lmkl$ hihygxmfpi

te}qirx$viuymviqirxw$sr$syv$tvmqev}$mrwyvergi$tspmgmiw0$mrgpyhmrk$syv$kirivep$pmefmpmx}$mrwyvergi0$erh$xlivi$evi$epws$zev}mrk$pmqmxw$sr

xli$qe|mqyq$eqsyrx$sj$syv$szivepp$gsziveki2$Ew$e$viwypx0$xli$mrwyvergi${i$qemrxemr$xs$gsziv$xli$zevmsyw$pmefmpmxmiw$xs${lmgl${i$evi

i|tswih$qe}$rsx$fi$ehiuyexi2$Er}$pswwiw$vipexmrk$xs$qexxivw$jsv${lmgl${i$evi$imxliv$yrmrwyvih$sv$jsv${lmgl${i$hs$rsx$lezi$ehiuyexi

mrwyvergi$ gsyph$ lezi$ e$qexivmep$ ehzivwi$ ijjigx$ sr$ syv$fywmriww0$ jmrergmep$ gsrhmxmsr$ sv$ viwypxw$ sj$ stivexmsrw2$ Mr$ ehhmxmsr0$ er}$ pswwiw

vipexmrk$xs$iqtps}qirx$qexxivw$gsyph$lezi$e$qexivmep$ehzivwi$ijjigx$sr$syv$fywmriww0$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$sv$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2$Xs$xli

i|xirx$xli$izirxw$wivzmrk$ew$e$fewmw$jsv$er}$tsxirxmep$gpemqw$evi$eppikih$sv$hixivqmrih$xs$gsrwxmxyxi$mppikep$sv$gvmqmrep$egxmzmx}0${i$gsyph

epws$fi$wyfnigx$xs$gvmqmrep$pmefmpmx}2$Wygl$pmefmpmx}$gsyph$viwypx$mr$wmkrmjmgerx$qsrixev}$jmriw$erh$gsyph$ejjigx$syv$efmpmx}$xs$fmh$sr$jyxyvi

gsrxvegxw$erh$vixemr$syv$i|mwxmrk$gsrxvegxw2

[i$qe}$rsx$fi$efpi$xs$sfxemr$sv$qemrxemr$xli$mrwyvergi$pizipw$viuymvih$f}$syv$kszivrqirx$gsrxvegxw2

Syv$kszivrqirx$gsrxvegxw$viuymvi$yw$xs$sfxemr$erh$qemrxemr$wtigmjmih$mrwyvergi$pizipw2$Xli$sggyvvirgi$sj$er}$izirxw$wtigmjmg$xs

syv$gsqter}$sv$xs$syv$mrhywxv}0$sv$e$kirivep$vmwi$mr$mrwyvergi$vexiw0$gsyph$wyfwxerxmepp}$mrgviewi$syv$gswxw$sj$sfxemrmrk$sv$qemrxemrmrk

xli$pizipw$sj$mrwyvergi$viuymvih$yrhiv$syv$kszivrqirx$gsrxvegxw0$sv$tvizirx$yw$jvsq$sfxemrmrk$sv$qemrxemrmrk$wygl$mrwyvergi$epxskixliv2

Mj${i$evi$yrefpi$xs$sfxemr$sv$qemrxemr$xli$viuymvih$mrwyvergi$pizipw0$syv$efmpmx}$xs${mr$ri{$kszivrqirx$gsrxvegxw0$viri{$kszivrqirx

gsrxvegxw$ xlex$ lezi$ i|tmvih$ erh$ vixemr$ i|mwxmrk$ kszivrqirx$ gsrxvegxw$ gsyph$ fi$ wmkrmjmgerxp}$ mqtemvih0${lmgl$ gsyph$ lezi$ e$qexivmep

ehzivwi$ijjigx$sr$syv$fywmriww0$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2

Rexyvep$hmwewxivw0$terhiqmg$syxfvieow0$kpsfep$tspmxmgep$izirxw$erh$sxliv$wivmsyw$gexewxvstlmg$izirxw$gsyph$hmwvytx$stivexmsrw$erh

sxliv{mwi$qexivmepp}$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$syv$fywmriww$erh$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 53 of 253

Page 76: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 97367<

7:

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 54 of 253

Page 77: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 98367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Ew$ er$ s{riv$ erh$ stivexsv$ sj$ wigyvi$ jegmpmxmiw0$ tvsgiwwmrk$ girxivw$ erh$ gsqqyrmx}$ viirxv}$ girxivw${mxl$ stivexmsrw$ mr$qer}

wxexiw$xlvsyklsyx$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw$erh$qypxmtpi$jsvimkr$gsyrxvmiw0${i$evi$wyfnigx$xs$ryqivsyw$vmwow$syxwmhi$sj$syv$gsrxvsp0$mrgpyhmrk

vmwow$ evmwmrk$ jvsq$ rexyvep$ hmwewxivw0$ terhiqmg$ syxfvieow$ erh$ sxliv$ kpsfep$ liepxl$ iqivkirgmiw$ sv$ hmwvytxmzi$ kpsfep$ tspmxmgep$ izirxw0

mrgpyhmrk$xivvsvmwx$egxmzmx}$erh${ev0$sv$wmqmpev$hmwvytxmsrw$xlex$gsyph$qexivmepp}$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$syv$fywmriww$erh$jmrergmep$tivjsvqergi2

Wygl$sggyvvirgiw$ger$viwypx$mr$hiwxvygxmsr$sv$heqeki$xs$syv$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw0$tvsgiwwmrk$girxivw$erh$gsqqyrmx}$viirxv}$girxivw$erh$syv

mrjsvqexmsr$ w}wxiqw0$hmwvytxmsr$sj$syv$stivexmsrw0$ viuymvi$ xli$izegyexmsr$sj$hixemriiw$sv$syv$tivwsrrip0$ erh$ viuymvi$ xli$ehstxmsr$sj

wtigmjmg$liepxl$tvsxsgspw$sv$xviexqirxw$xs$wejikyevh$xli$liepxl$sj$syv$hixemriiw$sv$tivwsrrip2$Epxlsykl$mx$mw$rsx$tswwmfpi$xs$tvihmgx$wygl

izirxw$sv$xlimv$gsrwiuyirgiw0$xliwi$izirxw$gsyph$qexivmepp}$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$syv$vityxexmsr0$fywmriww$erh$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr2

Syv$ mrxivrexmsrep$stivexmsrw$i|tswi$yw$ xs$vmwow${lmgl$gsyph$qexivmepp}$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$syv$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$viwypxw$sj

stivexmsrw2

Jsv$ xli$ }iev$ irhih$ Higiqfiv$ 750$ 645=0$ syv$ mrxivrexmsrep$ stivexmsrw$ eggsyrxih$ jsv$ ettvs|mqexip}$ 55)$ sj$ syv$ gsrwspmhexih

viziryiw$jvsq$stivexmsrw2$[i$jegi$vmwow$ewwsgmexih${mxl$syv$stivexmsrw$syxwmhi$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw2$Xliwi$vmwow$mrgpyhi0$eqsrk$sxlivw0

tspmxmgep$erh$igsrsqmg$mrwxefmpmx}0$i|glerki$vexi$jpygxyexmsrw0$xe|iw0$hyxmiw$erh$xli$pe{w$sv$vikypexmsrw$mr$xlswi$jsvimkr$nyvmwhmgxmsrw$mr

{lmgl$ {i$ stivexi2$ Mr$ xli$ izirx$ xlex$ {i$ i|tivmirgi$ er}$ hmjjmgypxmiw$ evmwmrk$ jvsq$ syv$ stivexmsrw$ mr$ jsvimkr$ qevoixw0$ syv$ fywmriww0

jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$qe}$fi$qexivmepp}$ehzivwip}$ejjigxih2

[i$gsrhygx$givxemr$sj$syv$stivexmsrw$ xlvsykl$ nsmrx$zirxyviw$sv$gsrwsvxmyqw0${lmgl$qe}$ pieh$ xs$hmwekviiqirxw${mxl$syv$ nsmrx

zirxyvi$tevxrivw$sv$fywmriww$tevxrivw$erh$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$syv$mrxiviwx$mr$xli$nsmrx$zirxyviw$sv$gsrwsvxmyqw2

[i$gsrhygx$ syv$ stivexmsrw$ mr$Wsyxl$Ejvmge$ xlvsykl$ syv$ gsrwspmhexih$ nsmrx$ zirxyvi0$WEGQ0$ erh$ xlvsykl$syv$ 94)$s{rih$ erh

yrgsrwspmhexih$nsmrx$zirxyvi$Wsyxl$Ejvmger$Gywxshmep$Wivzmgiw$Tx}2$Pmqmxih0$vijivvih$xs$ew$WEGW2$[i$gsrhygx$syv$tvmwsriv$iwgsvx$erh

vipexih$ gywxsh}$ wivzmgiw$ mr$ xli$ Yrmxih$ Omrkhsq$ xlvsykl$ syv$ 94)$ s{rih$ erh$ yrgsrwspmhexih$ nsmrx$ zirxyvi$ mr$ KIS$ Eqi}$ TIGW

Pmqmxih0${lmgl${i$vijiv$xs$ew$KISEqi}2$[i$qe}$irxiv$mrxs$ehhmxmsrep$nsmrx$zirxyviw$mr$xli$jyxyvi2$Epxlsykl${i$lezi$xli$qensvmx}$zsxi

mr$syv$gsrwspmhexih$nsmrx$zirxyvi0$WEGQ0$xlvsykl$syv$s{rivwlmt$sj$:629)$sj$xli$zsxmrk$wleviw0${i$wlevi$iuyep$zsxmrk$gsrxvsp$sr$epp

wmkrmjmgerx$qexxivw$xs$gsqi$fijsvi$WEGW2$[i$epws$wlevi$iuyep$zsxmrk$gsrxvsp$sr$epp$wmkrmjmgerx$qexxivw$xs$gsqi$fijsvi$KISEqi}2$[i

evi$ gsrhygxmrk$ givxemr$ stivexmsrw$ mr$ Zmgxsvme0$ Eywxvepme$ xlvsykl$ e$ gsrwsvxmyq$ gsqtvmwih$ sj$ syv$ {lspp}$ s{rih$ wyfwmhmev}0$ KIS

Eywxvepme0$Nslr$Lspperh$Gsrwxvygxmsr$Jsvirwmg$Gevi$erh$Lsri}{ipp2$Xli$gsrwsvxmyq$hizipstih$erh$mw$qerekmrk$e$50744$fih$jegmpmx}$mr

Vezirlepp0$e$psgexmsr$riev$Qipfsyvri0$Eywxvepme${lmgl${ew$gsqtpixih$mr$Rsziqfiv$645;2$Xliwi$nsmrx$zirxyvi$tevxrivw0$ew${ipp$ew$er}

jyxyvi$tevxrivw0$qe}$lezi$mrxiviwxw$xlex$evi$hmjjivirx$jvsq$syvw${lmgl$qe}$viwypx$mr$gsrjpmgxmrk$zmi{w$ew$xs$xli$gsrhygx$sj$xli$fywmriww

sj$xli$nsmrx$zirxyvi$sv$gsrwsvxmyq2$Mr$xli$izirx$xlex${i$lezi$e$hmwekviiqirx${mxl$e$nsmrx$zirxyvi$tevxriv$sv$gsrwsvxmyq$fywmriww$tevxriv

ew$ xs$ xli$viwspyxmsr$sj$e$tevxmgypev$ mwwyi$ xs$gsqi$fijsvi$ xli$ nsmrx$zirxyvi$sv$gsrwsvxmyq0$sv$ew$ xs$ xli$qerekiqirx$sv$gsrhygx$sj$ xli

fywmriww$ sj$ xli$ nsmrx$ zirxyvi$ sv$ gsrwsvxmyq$ mr$ kirivep0$ {i$ qe}$ rsx$ fi$ efpi$ xs$ viwspzi$ wygl$ hmwekviiqirx$ mr$ syv$ jezsv$ erh$ wygl

hmwekviiqirx$gsyph$lezi$e$qexivmep$ehzivwi$ijjigx$sr$syv$mrxiviwx$mr$xli$nsmrx$zirxyvi$sv$gsrwsvxmyq$sv$xli$fywmriww$sj$xli$nsmrx$zirxyvi

sv$gsrwsvxmyq$mr$kirivep2

[i$evi$hitirhirx$ytsr$syv$wirmsv$qerekiqirx$erh$syv$efmpmx}$xs$exxvegx$erh$vixemr$wyjjmgmirx$uyepmjmih$tivwsrrip2

[i$evi$hitirhirx$ytsr$xli$gsrxmryih$wivzmgi$sj$iegl$qiqfiv$sj$syv$wirmsv$qerekiqirx$xieq0$mrgpyhmrk$Kisvki$G2$^spi}0$Tl2H20

syv$Glemvqer$erh$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv0$Fvmer$V2$Izerw0$syv$Glmij$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv0$Err$Wglpevf0$syv$Wirmsv$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx$erh

Tviwmhirx0$KIS$Gevi0$Hezmh$Zirxyvippe0$syv$Wirmsv$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx0$Fywmriww$Hizipstqirx$erh$epws$syv$sxliv$i|igyxmzi$sjjmgivw$ex$xli

Zmgi$Tviwmhirx$pizip$erh$efszi2$Xli$yri|tigxih$psww$sj$Hv2$^spi}0$Qv2$Izerw$sv$er}$sxliv$oi}$qiqfiv$sj$syv$wirmsv$qerekiqirx$xieq

gsyph$qexivmepp}$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$syv$fywmriww0$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$sv$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2

Mr$ehhmxmsr0$ xli$ wivzmgiw${i$tvszmhi$evi$ pefsv1mrxirwmzi2$[lir${i$evi$e{evhih$e$ jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegx$sv$stir$e$ri{

jegmpmx}0$ hitirhmrk$ sr$ xli$ wivzmgi$ {i$ lezi$ fiir$ gsrxvegxih$ xs$ tvszmhi0$ {i$qe}$ riih$ xs$ lmvi$ stivexmrk0$ qerekiqirx0$ gsvvigxmsrep

sjjmgivw0$wigyvmx}$wxejj0$tl}wmgmerw0$ryvwiw$erh$sxliv$uyepmjmih$tivwsrrip2$Xli$wyggiww$sj$syv$fywmriww$viuymviw$xlex${i$exxvegx0$hizipst

erh$vixemr$xliwi$tivwsrrip2$Syv$mrefmpmx}$xs$lmvi$wyjjmgmirx$uyepmjmih$tivwsrrip$sr$e$xmqip}$fewmw$sv$xli$psww$sj$wmkrmjmgerx$ryqfivw$sj

tivwsrrip$ex$i|mwxmrk$jegmpmxmiw$gsyph$lezi$e$qexivmep$ijjigx$sr$syv$fywmriww0$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$sv$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2

Syv$tvsjmxefmpmx}$qe}$fi$qexivmepp}$ehzivwip}$ejjigxih$f}$mrjpexmsr2

Qer}$ sj$ syv$ jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$ gsrxvegxw$ tvszmhi$ jsv$ jm|ih$qerekiqirx$ jiiw$ sv$ jiiw$ xlex$ mrgviewi$ f}$ srp}$ wqepp$ eqsyrxw

hyvmrk$xlimv$xivqw2$[lmpi$e$wyfwxerxmep$tsvxmsr$sj$syv$gswx$wxvygxyvi$mw$kirivepp}$jm|ih0$mj0$hyi$xs$mrjpexmsr$sv$sxliv$geywiw0$syv$stivexmrk

i|tirwiw0$wygl$ew$gswxw$vipexmrk$xs$tivwsrrip0$yxmpmxmiw0$mrwyvergi0$qihmgep$erh$jssh0$mrgviewi$ex$vexiw$jewxiv$xler$mrgviewiw0$mj$er}0$mr$syv

jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$jiiw0$xlir$syv$tvsjmxefmpmx}$gsyph$fi$qexivmepp}$ehzivwip}$ejjigxih2

7;

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 55 of 253

Page 78: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 99367<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 56 of 253

Page 79: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 9:367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Zevmsyw$vmwow$ewwsgmexih${mxl$xli$s{rivwlmt$sj$viep$iwxexi$qe}$mrgviewi$gswxw0$i|tswi$yw$xs$yrmrwyvih$pswwiw$erh$ehzivwip}$ejjigx

syv$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2

Syv$ s{rivwlmt$ sj$ wigyvi$ erh$ tvsgiwwmrk$ jegmpmxmiw$ wyfnigxw$ yw$ xs$ vmwow$ x}tmgepp}$ ewwsgmexih$ {mxl$ mrziwxqirxw$ mr$ viep$ iwxexi2

Mrziwxqirxw$mr$viep$iwxexi0$erh$mr$tevxmgypev0$wigyvi$erh$tvsgiwwmrk$jegmpmxmiw0$evi$vipexmzip}$mppmuymh$erh0$xlivijsvi0$syv$efmpmx}$xs$hmziwx

syvwipziw$sj$sri$sv$qsvi$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$tvsqtxp}$mr$viwtsrwi$xs$glerkih$gsrhmxmsrw$mw$pmqmxih2$Mrziwxqirxw$mr$wigyvi$erh$tvsgiwwmrk

jegmpmxmiw0$ mr$ tevxmgypev0$ wyfnigx$ yw$ xs$ vmwow$ mrzspzmrk$tsxirxmep$ i|tswyvi$ xs$ irzmvsrqirxep$ pmefmpmx}$ erh$yrmrwyvih$ psww2$Syv$stivexmrk

gswxw$qe}$fi$ejjigxih$f}$xli$sfpmkexmsr$xs$te}$jsv$xli$gswx$sj$gsqtp}mrk${mxl$i|mwxmrk$irzmvsrqirxep$pe{w0$svhmrergiw$erh$vikypexmsrw0

ew${ipp$ew$xli$gswx$sj$gsqtp}mrk${mxl$jyxyvi$pikmwpexmsr2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$epxlsykl${i$qemrxemr$mrwyvergi$jsv$qer}$x}tiw$sj$pswwiw0$xlivi$evi

givxemr$x}tiw$sj$pswwiw0$wygl$ew$pswwiw$jvsq$lyvvmgeriw0$ievxluyeoiw0$vmsxw$erh$egxw$sj$xivvsvmwq0${lmgl$qe}$fi$imxliv$yrmrwyvefpi$sv$jsv

{lmgl$mx$qe}$rsx$fi$igsrsqmgepp}$jiewmfpi$xs$sfxemr$mrwyvergi$gsziveki0$mr$pmklx$sj$xli$wyfwxerxmep$gswxw$ewwsgmexih${mxl$wygl$mrwyvergi2

Ew$e$viwypx0${i$gsyph$pswi$fsxl$syv$getmxep$mrziwxih$mr0$erh$erxmgmtexih$tvsjmxw$jvsq0$sri$sv$qsvi$sj$xli$jegmpmxmiw${i$s{r2$Jyvxliv0$izir

mj${i$lezi$mrwyvergi$jsv$e$tevxmgypev$psww0${i$qe}$i|tivmirgi$pswwiw$xlex$qe}$i|giih$xli$pmqmxw$sj$syv$gsziveki2

Vmwow$vipexih$xs$jegmpmx}$gsrwxvygxmsr$erh$hizipstqirx$egxmzmxmiw$qe}$mrgviewi$syv$gswxw$vipexih$xs$wygl$egxmzmxmiw2

[lir${i$evi$irkekih$xs$tivjsvq$gsrwxvygxmsr$erh$hiwmkr$wivzmgiw$jsv$e$jegmpmx}0${i$x}tmgepp}$egx$ew$xli$tvmqev}$gsrxvegxsv$erh

wyfgsrxvegx$ {mxl$ sxliv$ gsqtermiw$ {ls$ egx$ ew$ xli$ kirivep$ gsrxvegxsvw2$ Ew$ tvmqev}$ gsrxvegxsv0$ {i$ evi$ wyfnigx$ xs$ xli$ zevmsyw$ vmwow

ewwsgmexih$ {mxl$ gsrwxvygxmsr$ ,mrgpyhmrk0$ {mxlsyx$ pmqmxexmsr0$ wlsvxekiw$ sj$ pefsv$ erh$ qexivmepw0$ {svo$ wxsttekiw0$ pefsv$ hmwtyxiw$ erh

{iexliv$mrxivjivirgi-${lmgl$gsyph$geywi$gsrwxvygxmsr$hipe}w2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0${i$evi$wyfnigx$xs$xli$vmwo$xlex$xli$kirivep$gsrxvegxsv${mpp$fi

yrefpi$xs$gsqtpixi$gsrwxvygxmsr${mxlmr$xli$pizip$sj$fyhkixih$gswxw$sv$fi$yrefpi$xs$jyrh$er}$i|giww$gsrwxvygxmsr$gswxw0$izir$xlsykl${i

x}tmgepp}$viuymvi$kirivep$gsrxvegxsvw$xs$tswx$gsrwxvygxmsr$fsrhw$erh$mrwyvergi2$Yrhiv$wygl$gsrxvegxw0${i$evi$ypxmqexip}$pmefpi$jsv$epp$pexi

hipmziv}$tirepxmiw$erh$gswx$szivvyrw2

Xli$vmwmrk$gswx$erh$mrgviewmrk$hmjjmgypx}$sj$sfxemrmrk$ehiuyexi$pizipw$sj$wyvix}$gvihmx$sr$jezsvefpi$xivqw$gsyph$ehzivwip}$ejjigx

syv$stivexmrk$viwypxw2

[i$evi$sjxir$viuymvih$xs$tswx$tivjsvqergi$fsrhw$mwwyih$f}$e$wyvix}$gsqter}$ew$e$gsrhmxmsr$xs$fmhhmrk$sr$sv$fimrk$e{evhih$e

jegmpmx}$ hizipstqirx$ gsrxvegx2$ Ezempefmpmx}$ erh$ tvmgmrk$ sj$ xliwi$ wyvix}$ gsqqmxqirxw$ mw$ wyfnigx$ xs$ kirivep$ qevoix$ erh$ mrhywxv}

gsrhmxmsrw0$eqsrk$sxliv$jegxsvw2$Mj${i$evi$yrefpi$xs$ijjigxmzip}$teww$epsrk$wyvix}$gswxw$xs$syv$gywxsqivw0$er}$mrgviewi$mr$wyvix}$gswxw

gsyph$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$syv$stivexmrk$viwypxw2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0${i$qe}$rsx$gsrxmryi$xs$lezi$eggiww$xs$wyvix}$gvihmx$sv$fi$efpi$xs$wigyvi$fsrhw

igsrsqmgepp}0${mxlsyx$ehhmxmsrep$gsppexivep0$sv$ex$xli$pizipw$viuymvih$jsv$er}$tsxirxmep$jegmpmx}$hizipstqirx$sv$gsrxvegx$fmhw2$Mj${i$evi

yrefpi$xs$sfxemr$ehiuyexi$pizipw$sj$wyvix}$gvihmx$sr$jezsvefpi$xivqw0${i${syph$lezi$xs$vip}$ytsr$pixxivw$sj$gvihmx$yrhiv$syv$wirmsv$gvihmx

jegmpmx}0${lmgl${syph$ irxemp$ lmkliv$ gswxw$ izir$ mj$ wygl$fsvvs{mrk$ getegmx}${ew$ ezempefpi${lir$hiwmvih0$ erh$syv$ efmpmx}$ xs$ fmh$ jsv$ sv

sfxemr$ri{$gsrxvegxw$gsyph$fi$mqtemvih2

Ehzivwi$hizipstqirxw$mr$syv$vipexmsrwlmt${mxl$syv$iqtps}iiw$gsyph$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$syv$fywmriww0$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$sv$viwypxw

sj$stivexmsrw2

Ex$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$ettvs|mqexip}$77)$sj$syv${svojsvgi${ew$gszivih$f}$gsppigxmzi$fevkemrmrk$ekviiqirxw$erh0$ew$sj$wygl

hexi0$gsppigxmzi$fevkemrmrk$ekviiqirxw${mxl$ettvs|mqexip}$;)$sj$syv$iqtps}iiw${ivi$wix$xs$i|tmvi$mr$piww$xler$sri$}iev2$[lmpi$srp}

ettvs|mqexip}$77)$sj$syv${svojsvgi$wglihypi$mw$gszivih$f}$gsppigxmzi$fevkemrmrk$ekviiqirxw0$mrgviewiw$mr$svkerm~exmsrep$egxmzmx}$sv

er}$jyxyvi${svo$wxsttekiw$gsyph$lezi$e$qexivmep$ehzivwi$ijjigx$sr$syv$fywmriww0$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr0$sv$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2

Xiglrspskmgep$ glerkiw$ gsyph$ geywi$ syv$ ipigxvsrmg$ qsrmxsvmrk$ tvshygxw$ erh$ xiglrspsk}$ xs$ figsqi$ sfwspixi$ sv$ viuymvi$ xli

vihiwmkr$sj$syv$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$tvshygxw0${lmgl$gsyph$lezi$e$qexivmep$ehzivwi$ijjigx$sr$syv$fywmriww2

Xiglrspskmgep$ glerkiw$ {mxlmr$ xli$ ipigxvsrmg$ qsrmxsvmrk$ fywmriww$ mr$ {lmgl$ {i$ gsrhygx$ fywmriww$ qe}$ viuymvi$ yw$ xs$ i|tirh

wyfwxerxmep$viwsyvgiw$mr$er$ijjsvx$xs$hizipst$erh3sv$yxmpm~i$ri{$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$tvshygxw$erh$xiglrspsk}2$[i$qe}$rsx$fi$efpi$xs

erxmgmtexi$sv$viwtsrh$xs$xiglrspskmgep$glerkiw$mr$e$xmqip}$qerriv0$erh$syv$viwtsrwi$qe}$rsx$viwypx$mr$wyggiwwjyp$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk

tvshygx$hizipstqirx$erh$xmqip}$tvshygx$mrxvshygxmsrw2$Mj${i$evi$yrefpi$xs$erxmgmtexi$sv$xmqip}$viwtsrh$xs$xiglrspskmgep$glerkiw0$syv

fywmriww$ gsyph$ fi$ ehzivwip}$ ejjigxih$ erh$ gsyph$ gsqtvsqmwi$ syv$ gsqtixmxmzi$ tswmxmsr0$ tevxmgypevp}$ mj$ syv$ gsqtixmxsvw$ errsyrgi$ sv

mrxvshygi$ ri{$ ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$ tvshygxw$ erh$ wivzmgiw$ mr$ ehzergi$ sj$ yw2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$ ri{$ ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$ tvshygxw$ erh

xiglrspsk}$jegi$xli$yrgivxemrx}$sj$gywxsqiv$eggitxergi$erh$viegxmsr$jvsq$gsqtixmxsvw2

Er}$rikexmzi$glerkiw$ mr$ xli$ pizip$sj$eggitxergi$sj$sv$ viwmwxergi$ xs$ xli$ywi$sj$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$tvshygxw$erh$wivzmgiw$f}

kszivrqirxep$gywxsqivw$gsyph$lezi$e$qexivmep$ehzivwi$ijjigx$sr$syv$fywmriww0$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2

7<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 57 of 253

Page 80: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 9;367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Kszivrqirxep$gywxsqivw$ywi$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$tvshygxw$erh$wivzmgiw$xs$qsrmxsv$ps{$vmwo$sjjirhivw$ew$e${e}$xs$lipt$vihygi

szivgvs{hmrk$mr$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw0$ew$e$qsrmxsvmrk$xssp0$erh$xs$tvsqsxi$tyfpmg$wejix}$f}$mqtswmrk$viwxvmgxmsrw$sr$qsziqirx$erh$wivzmrk

ew$e$hixivvirx$jsv$epgslsp$yweki2$Mj$xli$pizip$sj$eggitxergi$sj$sv$viwmwxergi$xs$xli$ywi$sj$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$tvshygxw$erh$wivzmgiw$f}

kszivrqirxep$gywxsqivw${ivi$xs$glerki$sziv$xmqi$mr$e$rikexmzi$qerriv$ws$xlex$kszivrqirxep$gywxsqivw$higmhi$xs$higviewi$xlimv$yweki

pizipw$ erh$ gsrxvegxmrk$ jsv$ ipigxvsrmg$ qsrmxsvmrk$ tvshygxw$ erh$ wivzmgiw0$ xlmw$ gsyph$ lezi$ e$qexivmep$ ehzivwi$ ijjigx$ sr$ syv$ fywmriww0

jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2

[i$hitirh$sr$e$pmqmxih$ryqfiv$sj$xlmvh$tevxmiw$xs$qeryjegxyvi$erh$wyttp}$uyepmx}$mrjvewxvygxyvi$gsqtsrirxw$jsv$syv$ipigxvsrmg

qsrmxsvmrk$tvshygxw2$Mj$syv$wyttpmivw$gerrsx$tvszmhi$xli$gsqtsrirxw$sv$wivzmgiw${i$viuymvi$erh${mxl$wygl$uyepmx}$ew${i$i|tigx0$syv

efmpmx}$xs$qevoix$erh$wipp$syv$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$tvshygxw$erh$wivzmgiw$gsyph$fi$levqih2

Mj$syv$ wyttpmivw$ jemp$ xs$wyttp}$gsqtsrirxw$ mr$e$ xmqip}$qerriv$ xlex$qiixw$syv$uyerxmx}0$uyepmx}0$ gswx$ viuymviqirxw0$sv$ xiglrmgep

wtigmjmgexmsrw0$ {i$ qe}$ rsx$ fi$ efpi$ xs$ eggiww$ epxivrexmzi$ wsyvgiw$ sj$ xliwi$ gsqtsrirxw$ {mxlmr$ e$ viewsrefpi$ tivmsh$ sj$ xmqi$ sv$ ex

gsqqivgmepp}$ viewsrefpi$ vexiw2$ E$ vihygxmsr$ sv$ mrxivvytxmsr$ mr$ xli$ wyttp}$ sj$ gsqtsrirxw0$ sv$ e$ wmkrmjmgerx$ mrgviewi$ mr$ xli$ tvmgi$ sj

gsqtsrirxw0$ gsyph$lezi$e$qexivmep$ ehzivwi$ijjigx$sr$syv$qevoixmrk$erh$wepiw$ mrmxmexmziw0${lmgl$gsyph$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$syv$ jmrergmep

gsrhmxmsr$erh$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2

Xli$mrxivvytxmsr0$hipe}$sv$jempyvi$sj$xli$tvszmwmsr$sj$syv$wivzmgiw$sv$mrjsvqexmsr$w}wxiqw$gsyph$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$syv$fywmriww2

Givxemr$ wikqirxw$ sj$ syv$ fywmriww$ hitirh$ wmkrmjmgerxp}$ sr$ ijjigxmzi$ mrjsvqexmsr$ w}wxiqw2$ Ew$ {mxl$ epp$ gsqtermiw$ xlex$ yxmpm~i

mrjsvqexmsr$ xiglrspsk}0${i$evi$zyprivefpi$ xs$rikexmzi$ mqtegxw$ mj$ mrjsvqexmsr$ mw$ mrehzivxirxp}$ mrxivvytxih0$hipe}ih0$gsqtvsqmwih$sv

pswx2$[i$ vsyxmrip}$ tvsgiww0$ wxsvi$ erh$ xverwqmx$ pevki$ eqsyrxw$ sj$ hexe$ jsv$ syv$ gpmirxw2$[i$ gsrxmryepp}$ {svo$ xs$ ythexi$ erh$qemrxemr

ijjigxmzi$mrjsvqexmsr$w}wxiqw2$Hiwtmxi$xli$wigyvmx}$qiewyviw${i$lezi$mr$tpegi$erh$er}$ehhmxmsrep$qiewyviw${i$qe}$mqtpiqirx$mr$xli

jyxyvi0$syv$ jegmpmxmiw$erh$w}wxiqw0$erh$ xlswi$sj$syv$ xlmvh1tevx}$wivzmgi$tvszmhivw0$gsyph$fi$zyprivefpi$ xs$wigyvmx}$fviegliw0$ gsqtyxiv

zmvywiw0$pswx$sv$qmwtpegih$hexe0$tvskveqqmrk$ivvsvw0$lyqer$ivvsvw0$egxw$sj$zerhepmwq0$sv$sxliv$izirxw2$Jsv$i|eqtpi0$wizivep${ipp1ors{r

gsqtermiw$lezi$sziv$xli$pewx$wizivep$}ievw$hmwgpswih$lmkl1tvsjmpi$wigyvmx}$fviegliw0$mrzspzmrk$wstlmwxmgexih$erh$lmklp}$xevkixih$exxegow

sr$xlimv$gsqter}×w$mrjvewxvygxyvi$sv$xlimv$gywxsqivw×$hexe0${lmgl${ivi$rsx$vigskrm~ih$sv$hixigxih$yrxmp$ejxiv$wygl$gsqtermiw$leh$fiir

ejjigxih$rsx{mxlwxerhmrk$xli$tvizirxexmzi$qiewyviw$xli}$leh$mr$tpegi2$Er}$wigyvmx}$fviegl$sv$izirx$viwypxmrk$mr$xli$mrxivvytxmsr0$hipe}

sv$ jempyvi$ sj$ syv$ wivzmgiw$ sv$ mrjsvqexmsr$ w}wxiqw0$ sv$ xli$qmwettvstvmexmsr0$ psww0$ sv$ sxliv$ yreyxlsvm~ih$ hmwgpswyvi$ sj$ gpmirx$ hexe$ sv

gsrjmhirxmep$ mrjsvqexmsr0${lixliv$f}$yw$hmvigxp}$sv$syv$ xlmvh1tevx}$ wivzmgi$tvszmhivw0$gsyph$heqeki$syv$ vityxexmsr0$ i|tswi$yw$ xs$ xli

vmwow$sj$pmxmkexmsr$erh$pmefmpmx}0$hmwvytx$syv$fywmriww0$viwypx$mr$pswx$fywmriww$sv$sxliv{mwi$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$syv$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2

Er$mrefmpmx}$xs$eguymvi0$tvsxigx$sv$qemrxemr$syv$mrxippigxyep$tvstivx}$erh$texirxw$mr$xli$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$wtegi$gsyph$levq

syv$efmpmx}$xs$gsqtixi$sv$kvs{2

[i$ lezi$ ryqivsyw$ Yrmxih$ Wxexiw$ erh$ jsvimkr$ texirxw$ mwwyih$ ew$ {ipp$ ew$ e$ ryqfiv$ sj$ Yrmxih$ Wxexiw$ texirxw$ tirhmrk$ mr$ xli

ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$wtegi2$Xlivi$ger$fi$rs$ewwyvergi$xlex$xli$tvsxigxmsr$ejjsvhih$f}$xliwi$texirxw${mpp$tvszmhi$yw${mxl$e$gsqtixmxmzi

ehzerxeki0$tvizirx$syv$gsqtixmxsvw$jvsq$hytpmgexmrk$syv$tvshygxw0$sv$xlex${i${mpp$fi$efpi$xs$ewwivx$syv$mrxippigxyep$tvstivx}$vmklxw$mr

mrjvmrkiqirx$egxmsrw2

Mr$ ehhmxmsr0$ er}$ sj$ syv$ texirxw$ qe}$ fi$ gleppirkih0$ mrzepmhexih0$ gmvgyqzirxih$ sv$ virhivih$ yrirjsvgiefpi2$ Xlivi$ ger$ fi$ rs

ewwyvergi$xlex${i${mpp$fi$wyggiwwjyp$wlsyph$sri$sv$qsvi$sj$syv$texirxw$fi$gleppirkih$jsv$er}$viewsr2$Mj$syv$texirx$gpemqw$evi$virhivih

mrzepmh$ sv$ yrirjsvgiefpi0$ sv$ revvs{ih$ mr$ wgsti0$ xli$ texirx$ gsziveki$ ejjsvhih$ xs$ syv$ tvshygxw$ gsyph$ fi$ mqtemvih0$ {lmgl$ gsyph

wmkrmjmgerxp}$mqtihi$syv$efmpmx}$xs$qevoix$syv$tvshygxw0$rikexmzip}$ejjigx$syv$gsqtixmxmzi$tswmxmsr$erh$levq$syv$fywmriww$erh$stivexmrk

viwypxw2

Xlivi$ ger$fi$rs$ ewwyvergi$ xlex$ er}$tirhmrk$sv$ jyxyvi$texirx$ ettpmgexmsrw$liph$f}$yw${mpp$ viwypx$ mr$ er$ mwwyih$texirx0$ sv$ xlex$ mj

texirxw$evi$mwwyih$xs$yw0$xlex$wygl$texirxw${mpp$tvszmhi$qiermrkjyp$tvsxigxmsr$ekemrwx$gsqtixmxsvw$sv$ekemrwx$gsqtixmxmzi$xiglrspskmiw2

Xli$mwwyergi$sj$e$texirx$mw$rsx$gsrgpywmzi$ew$xs$mxw$zepmhmx}$sv$mxw$irjsvgiefmpmx}2$Xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw$jihivep$gsyvxw$sv$iuymzepirx$rexmsrep

gsyvxw$ sv$ texirx$ sjjmgiw$ ipwi{livi$qe}$ mrzepmhexi$ syv$ texirxw$ sv$ jmrh$ xliq$ yrirjsvgiefpi2$ Gsqtixmxsvw$qe}$ epws$ fi$ efpi$ xs$ hiwmkr

evsyrh$syv$texirxw2$Syv$texirxw$erh$texirx$ettpmgexmsrw$gsziv$tevxmgypev$ewtigxw$sj$syv$tvshygxw2$Sxliv$tevxmiw$qe}$hizipst$erh$sfxemr

texirx$tvsxigxmsr$jsv$qsvi$ijjigxmzi$xiglrspskmiw0$hiwmkrw$sv$qixlshw2$Mj$xliwi$hizipstqirxw${ivi$xs$sggyv0$mx$gsyph$lezi$er$ehzivwi

ijjigx$sr$syv$wepiw2$[i$qe}$rsx$fi$efpi$xs$tvizirx$xli$yreyxlsvm~ih$hmwgpswyvi$sv$ywi$sj$syv$xiglrmgep$ors{pihki$sv$xvehi$wigvixw$f}

gsrwypxerxw0$zirhsvw0$jsvqiv$iqtps}iiw$erh$gyvvirx$iqtps}iiw0$hiwtmxi$xli$i|mwxirgi$sj$rsrhmwgpswyvi$erh$gsrjmhirxmepmx}$ekviiqirxw

erh$sxliv$gsrxvegxyep$viwxvmgxmsrw2$Jyvxlivqsvi0$xli$pe{w$sj$jsvimkr$gsyrxvmiw$qe}$rsx$tvsxigx$syv$mrxippigxyep$tvstivx}$vmklxw$ijjigxmzip}

sv$xs$xli$weqi$i|xirx$ew$xli$pe{w$sj$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw2$Mj$syv$mrxippigxyep$tvstivx}$vmklxw$evi$rsx$ehiuyexip}$tvsxigxih0${i$qe}$rsx$fi

efpi$xs$gsqqivgmepm~i$syv$xiglrspskmiw0$tvshygxw$sv$wivzmgiw$erh$syv$gsqtixmxsvw$gsyph$gsqqivgmepm~i$syv$xiglrspskmiw0${lmgl$gsyph

viwypx$mr$e$higviewi$mr$syv$wepiw$erh$qevoix$wlevi$xlex${syph$levq$syv$fywmriww$erh$stivexmrk$viwypxw2

7=

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 58 of 253

Page 81: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 9<367<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 59 of 253

Page 82: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 9=367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Ehhmxmsrepp}0$xli$i|tmvexmsr$sj$er}$sj$syv$texirxw$qe}$vihygi$xli$fevvmivw$xs$irxv}$mrxs$syv$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$pmri$sj$fywmriww

erh$qe}$viwypx$mr$psww$sj$qevoix$wlevi$erh$e$higviewi$mr$syv$gsqtixmxmzi$efmpmxmiw0$xlyw$lezmrk$e$tsxirxmep$ehzivwi$ijjigx$sr$syv$jmrergmep

gsrhmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$erh$gewl$jps{w2

Syv$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$tvshygxw$gsyph$mrjvmrki$sr$xli$mrxippigxyep$tvstivx}$vmklxw$sj$sxlivw0${lmgl$qe}$pieh$xs$pmxmkexmsr$xlex

gsyph$mxwipj$fi$gswxp}0$gsyph$viwypx$mr$xli$te}qirx$sj$wyfwxerxmep$heqekiw$sv$vs}epxmiw0$erh3sv$tvizirx$yw$jvsq$ywmrk$xiglrspsk}$xlex

mw$iwwirxmep$xs$syv$tvshygxw2

Xlivi$ger$fi$rs$ewwyvergi$xlex$syv$gyvvirx$tvshygxw$sv$tvshygxw$yrhiv$hizipstqirx${mpp$rsx$mrjvmrki$er}$texirx$sv$sxliv

mrxippigxyep$tvstivx}$vmklxw$sj$xlmvh$tevxmiw2$Mj$mrjvmrkiqirx$gpemqw$evi$fvsyklx$ekemrwx$yw0${lixliv$wyggiwwjypp}$sv$rsx0$xliwi$ewwivxmsrw

gsyph$hmwxvegx$qerekiqirx$jvsq$sxliv$xewow$mqtsvxerx$xs$xli$wyggiww$sj$syv$fywmriww0$rigiwwmxexi$yw$i|tirhmrk$tsxirxmepp}$wmkrmjmgerx

jyrhw$erh$viwsyvgiw$xs$hijirh$sv$wixxpi$wygl$gpemqw$erh$levq$syv$vityxexmsr2$[i$gerrsx$fi$givxemr$xlex${i${mpp$lezi$xli$jmrergmep

viwsyvgiw$xs$hijirh$syvwipziw$ekemrwx$er}$texirx$sv$sxliv$mrxippigxyep$tvstivx}$pmxmkexmsr2

Mr$ehhmxmsr0$mrxippigxyep$tvstivx}$pmxmkexmsr$sv$gpemqw$gsyph$jsvgi$yw$xs$hs$sri$sv$qsvi$sj$xli$jspps{mrk>

¨ giewi$wippmrk$sv$ywmrk$er}$tvshygxw$xlex$mrgsvtsvexi$xli$ewwivxih$mrxippigxyep$tvstivx}0${lmgl${syph$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$syv

viziryi?

¨ te}$wyfwxerxmep$heqekiw$jsv$tewx$ywi$sj$xli$ewwivxih$mrxippigxyep$tvstivx}?

¨ sfxemr$e$pmgirwi$jvsq$xli$lsphiv$sj$xli$ewwivxih$mrxippigxyep$tvstivx}0${lmgl$pmgirwi$qe}$rsx$fi$ezempefpi$sr$viewsrefpi$xivqw0

mj$ex$epp?$sv

¨ vihiwmkr$sv$vireqi0$mr$xli$gewi$sj$xvehiqevo$gpemqw0$syv$tvshygxw$xs$ezsmh$mrjvmrkmrk$xli$mrxippigxyep$tvstivx}$vmklxw$sj$xlmvh

tevxmiw0${lmgl$qe}$rsx$fi$tswwmfpi$erh$gsyph$fi$gswxp}$erh$xmqi1gsrwyqmrk$mj$mx$mw$tswwmfpi$xs$hs2

Mr$ xli$ izirx$ sj$ er$ ehzivwi$ hixivqmrexmsr$ mr$ er$ mrxippigxyep$ tvstivx}$ wymx$ sv$ tvsgiihmrk0$ sv$ syv$ jempyvi$ xs$ pmgirwi$ iwwirxmep

xiglrspsk}0$syv$wepiw$gsyph$fi$levqih$erh3sv$syv$gswxw$gsyph$mrgviewi0${lmgl${syph$levq$syv$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr2

[i$ pmgirwi$ mrxippigxyep$tvstivx}$ vmklxw$ mr$ xli$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$wtegi0$ mrgpyhmrk$texirxw0$ jvsq$ xlmvh$tevx}$s{rivw2$ Mj$ wygl

s{rivw$ hs$ rsx$ tvstivp}$ qemrxemr$ sv$ irjsvgi$ xli$ mrxippigxyep$ tvstivx}$ yrhivp}mrk$ wygl$ pmgirwiw0$ syv$ gsqtixmxmzi$ tswmxmsr$ erh

fywmriww$tvswtigxw$gsyph$fi$levqih2$Syv$pmgirwsvw$qe}$epws$wiio$xs$xivqmrexi$syv$pmgirwi2

[i$evi$e$tevx}$xs$e$ryqfiv$sj$ pmgirwiw$ xlex$kmzi$yw$vmklxw$ xs$xlmvh1tevx}$ mrxippigxyep$tvstivx}$ xlex$ mw$rigiwwev}$sv$ywijyp$ xs$syv

fywmriww2$ Syv$ wyggiww$ {mpp$ hitirh$ mr$ tevx$ sr$ xli$ efmpmx}$ sj$ syv$ pmgirwsvw$ xs$ sfxemr0$ qemrxemr$ erh$ irjsvgi$ syv$ pmgirwih$ mrxippigxyep

tvstivx}2$Syv$pmgirwsvw$qe}$rsx$wyggiwwjypp}$tvswigyxi$er}$ettpmgexmsrw$jsv$sv$qemrxemr$mrxippigxyep$tvstivx}$xs${lmgl${i$lezi$pmgirwiw0

qe}$ hixivqmri$ rsx$ xs$ tyvwyi$ pmxmkexmsr$ ekemrwx$ sxliv$ gsqtermiw$ xlex$ evi$ mrjvmrkmrk$ wygl$ mrxippigxyep$ tvstivx}0$ sv$qe}$ tyvwyi$ wygl

pmxmkexmsr$piww$ekkviwwmzip}$xler${i${syph2$[mxlsyx$tvsxigxmsr$jsv$xli$mrxippigxyep$tvstivx}${i$pmgirwi0$sxliv$gsqtermiw$qmklx$fi$efpi$xs

sjjiv$wmqmpev$tvshygxw$jsv$wepi0${lmgl$gsyph$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$syv$gsqtixmxmzi$fywmriww$tswmxmsr$erh$levq$syv$fywmriww$tvswtigxw2

Mj${i$ pswi$ er}$sj$syv$ vmklxw$ xs$ywi$ xlmvh1tevx}$ mrxippigxyep$tvstivx}0$ mx$ gsyph$ ehzivwip}$ ejjigx$ syv$ efmpmx}$ xs$ gsqqivgmepm~i$syv

xiglrspskmiw0$tvshygxw$sv$wivzmgiw0$ew${ipp$ew$levq$syv$gsqtixmxmzi$fywmriww$tswmxmsr$erh$syv$fywmriww$tvswtigxw2

[i$qe}$fi$wyfnigx$xs$gswxp}$tvshygx$pmefmpmx}$gpemqw$jvsq$xli$ywi$sj$syv$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$tvshygxw0${lmgl$gsyph$heqeki$syv

vityxexmsr0$mqtemv$xli$qevoixefmpmx}$sj$syv$tvshygxw$erh$wivzmgiw$erh$jsvgi$yw$xs$te}$gswxw$erh$heqekiw$xlex$qe}$rsx$fi$gszivih$f}

ehiuyexi$mrwyvergi2

Qeryjegxyvmrk0$qevoixmrk0$wippmrk0$ xiwxmrk$erh$xli$stivexmsr$sj$syv$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$tvshygxw$erh$wivzmgiw$irxemp$e$vmwo$sj

tvshygx$ pmefmpmx}2$[i$gsyph$fi$ wyfnigx$ xs$ tvshygx$ pmefmpmx}$ gpemqw$ xs$ xli$i|xirx$syv$ ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$tvshygxw$ jemp$ xs$ tivjsvq$ew

mrxirhih2$Izir$yrwyggiwwjyp$gpemqw$ekemrwx$yw$gsyph$viwypx$mr$xli$i|tirhmxyvi$sj$jyrhw$mr$pmxmkexmsr0$xli$hmzivwmsr$sj$qerekiqirx$xmqi

erh$viwsyvgiw0$heqeki$xs$syv$vityxexmsr$erh$mqtemvqirx$mr$xli$qevoixefmpmx}$sj$syv$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$tvshygxw$erh$wivzmgiw2$[lmpi

{i$qemrxemr$ pmefmpmx}$ mrwyvergi0$ mx$ mw$ tswwmfpi$ xlex$ e$ wyggiwwjyp$ gpemq$ gsyph$ fi$qehi$ ekemrwx$ yw0$ xlex$ xli$ eqsyrx$ sj$ syv$ mrwyvergi

gsziveki${syph$rsx$fi$ehiuyexi$xs$gsziv$xli$gswxw$sj$hijirhmrk$ekemrwx$sv$te}mrk$wygl$e$gpemq0$sv$xlex$heqekiw$te}efpi$f}$yw${syph

levq$syv$fywmriww2

[i$qe}$rsx$fi$efpi$xs$wyggiwwjypp}$mhirxmj}0$gsrwyqqexi$sv$mrxikvexi$eguymwmxmsrw2

[i$tyvwyi$wipigx$eguymwmxmsrw$xlex$qiix$syv$gvmxivme$jsv$kvs{xl$erh$tvsjmxefmpmx}${lir$qevoix$sttsvxyrmxmiw$evmwi2$Xli$tyvwymx$sj

eguymwmxmsrw$qe}$tswi$givxemr$ vmwow$ xs$yw2$[i$qe}$rsx$fi$efpi$ xs$ mhirxmj}$ eguymwmxmsr$gerhmhexiw$ xlex$ jmx$ syv$gvmxivme$ jsv$kvs{xl$erh

tvsjmxefmpmx}2$Izir$mj${i$evi$efpi$xs$mhirxmj}$wygl$gerhmhexiw0${i$qe}$rsx$fi$efpi$xs$eguymvi$xliq$sr$xivqw$wexmwjegxsv}$xs$yw2$[i${mpp

mrgyv$ i|tirwiw$ erh$ hihmgexi$ exxirxmsr$ erh$ viwsyvgiw$ ewwsgmexih$ {mxl$ xli$ vizmi{$ sj$ eguymwmxmsr$ sttsvxyrmxmiw0$ {lixliv$ sv$ rsx$ {i

gsrwyqqexi$wygl$eguymwmxmsrw2

84

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 60 of 253

Page 83: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq :4367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Ehhmxmsrepp}0$izir$mj${i$evi$efpi$xs$eguymvi$wymxefpi$xevkixw$sr$ekviiefpi$xivqw0${i$qe}$rsx$fi$efpi$xs$wyggiwwjypp}$mrxikvexi$xlimv

stivexmsrw${mxl$syvw2$Eglmizmrk$xli$erxmgmtexih$firijmxw$sj$er}$eguymwmxmsr${mpp$hitirh$mr$wmkrmjmgerx$tevx$ytsr${lixliv${i$mrxikvexi

wygl$ eguymvih$ fywmriwwiw$ mr$ er$ ijjmgmirx$ erh$ ijjigxmzi$ qerriv2$[i$ qe}$ rsx$ fi$ efpi$ xs$ eglmizi$ xli$ erxmgmtexih$ stivexmrk$ erh$ gswx

w}rivkmiw$ sv$ psrk1xivq$ wxvexikmg$ firijmxw$ sj$ syv$ eguymwmxmsrw$ {mxlmr$ xli$ erxmgmtexih$ xmqmrk$ sv$ ex$ epp2$ Jsv$ i|eqtpi0$ ipmqmrexmsr$ sj

hytpmgexmzi$gswxw$qe}$rsx$fi$jypp}$eglmizih$sv$qe}$xeoi$psrkiv$xler$erxmgmtexih2$Jsv$ex$piewx$xli$jmvwx$}iev$ejxiv$e$wyfwxerxmep$eguymwmxmsr0

erh$tswwmfp}$psrkiv0$xli$firijmxw$jvsq$xli$eguymwmxmsr${mpp$fi$sjjwix$f}$xli$gswxw$mrgyvvih$mr$mrxikvexmrk$xli$fywmriwwiw$erh$stivexmsrw2

[i$qe}$epws$ewwyqi$pmefmpmxmiw$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$eguymwmxmsrw$xlex${i${syph$sxliv{mwi$rsx$fi$i|tswih$xs2$Er$mrefmpmx}$xs$viepm~i$xli

jypp$i|xirx$sj0$sv$er}$sj0$xli$erxmgmtexih$w}rivkmiw$sv$sxliv$firijmxw$sj$er$eguymwmxmsr$ew${ipp$ew$er}$hipe}w$xlex$qe}$fi$irgsyrxivih$mr

xli$mrxikvexmsr$tvsgiww0${lmgl$qe}$hipe}$xli$xmqmrk$sj$wygl$w}rivkmiw$sv$sxliv$firijmxw0$gsyph$lezi$er$ehzivwi$ijjigx$sr$syv$fywmriww

erh$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2

Ew$e$viwypx$sj$syv$eguymwmxmsrw0${i$lezi$vigsvhih$erh${mpp$gsrxmryi$xs$vigsvh$e$wmkrmjmgerx$eqsyrx$sj$kssh{mpp$erh$sxliv

mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw2$Mr$xli$jyxyvi0$syv$kssh{mpp$sv$sxliv$mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw$qe}$figsqi$mqtemvih0${lmgl$gsyph$viwypx$mr$qexivmep$rsr1

gewl$glevkiw$xs$syv$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2

[i$lezi$e$wyfwxerxmep$eqsyrx$sj$kssh{mpp$erh$sxliv$mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw$viwypxmrk$jvsq$fywmriww$eguymwmxmsrw2$Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750

645=0${i$leh$(=<:28$qmppmsr$sj$kssh{mpp$erh$sxliv$mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw2$Ex$piewx$erryepp}0$sv${liriziv$izirxw$sv$glerkiw$mr$gmvgyqwxergiw

mrhmgexi$e$tsxirxmep$mqtemvqirx$mr$xli$gevv}mrk$zepyi$ew$hijmrih$f}$Kirivepp}$Eggitxih$Eggsyrxmrk$Tvmrgmtpiw$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw$sj

Eqivmge0$sv$Y2W2$KEET0${i${mpp$izepyexi$xlmw$kssh{mpp$jsv$mqtemvqirx$f}$jmvwx$ewwiwwmrk$uyepmxexmzi$jegxsvw$xs$hixivqmri${lixliv$xli

i|mwxirgi$sj$izirxw$sv$gmvgyqwxergiw$piehw$xs$e$hixivqmrexmsr$xlex$mx$mw$qsvi$pmoip}$xler$rsx$xlex$xli$jemv$zepyi$sj$xli$vitsvxmrk$yrmx$mw

piww$ xler$ xli$gevv}mrk$eqsyrx2$Iwxmqexih$jemv$zepyiw$gsyph$glerki$ mj$ xlivi$evi$glerkiw$ mr$syv$getmxep$wxvygxyvi0$gswx$sj$hifx0$ mrxiviwx

vexiw0$ getmxep$ i|tirhmxyvi$ pizipw0$ stivexmrk$ gewl$ jps{w0$ sv$qevoix$ getmxepm~exmsr2$ Mqtemvqirxw$ sj$ kssh{mpp$ sv$ sxliv$ mrxerkmfpi$ ewwixw

gsyph$viuymvi$qexivmep$rsr1gewl$glevkiw$xs$syv$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2

[i$evi$wyfnigx$xs$vmwow$vipexih$xs$gsvtsvexi$wsgmep$viwtsrwmfmpmx}2

Xli$gsrwmhivexmsr$sj$IWK$jegxsvw$mr$qeomrk$mrziwxqirx$erh$zsxmrk$higmwmsrw$mw$vipexmzip}$ri{0$erh$jveqi{svow$erh$qixlshw

ywih$ f}$ mrziwxsvw$ jsv$ ewwiwwmrk$IWK$tspmgmiw$ evi$rsx$ jypp}$ hizipstih$ erh$ zev}$ gsrwmhivefp}$ eqsrk$ xli$ mrziwxqirx$ gsqqyrmx}2$ $ Mr

Witxiqfiv$sj$645=0${i$ mwwyih$syv$ jmvwx$Lyqer$Vmklxw$erh$IWK$vitsvx2$Xli$Lyqer$Vmklxw$erh$IWK$vitsvx$fymphw$sr$ xli$ mqtsvxerx

qmpiwxsri${i$eglmizih$ mr$6457${lir$syv$Fsevh$ehstxih$e$Kpsfep$Lyqer$Vmklxw$Tspmg}$f}$tvszmhmrk$hmwgpswyviw$ vipexih$ xs$ls{${i

mrjsvq$syv$iqtps}iiw$sj$syv$gsqqmxqirx$xs$viwtigxmrk$lyqer$vmklxw?$xli$gvmxivme${i$ywi$xs$ewwiww$lyqer$vmklxw$tivjsvqergi?$erh$syv

gsrxvegx$gsqtpmergi$tvskveq0$viqihmiw$xs$wlsvxgsqmrkw$mr$lyqer$vmklxw$tivjsvqergi0$erh$mrhitirhirx$zivmjmgexmsr$sj$syv$tivjsvqergi

f}$xlmvh$tevx}$svkerm~exmsrw2$Xli$Lyqer$Vmklxw$erh$IWK$vitsvx$epws$ehhviwwiw$gvmxivme0$fewih$sr$vigskrm~ih$IWK$vitsvxmrk$wxerhevhw0

vipexih$xs$xli$hizipstqirx$sj$syv$iqtps}iiw?$syv$ijjsvxw$xs$ehzergi$irzmvsrqirxep$wywxemrefmpmx}$mr$xli$gsrwxvygxmsr$erh$stivexmsr$sj

syv$jegmpmxmiw?$erh$syv$ehlivirgi$xs$ixlmgep$kszivrergi$tvegxmgiw$xlvsyklsyx$syv$gsqter}2$Xliwi$tspmgmiw$erh$tvegxmgiw0${lixliv$mx$fi

xli$ wxerhevhw$ {i$ wix$ jsv$ syvwipziw$ sv$ IWK$ gvmxivme$ iwxefpmwlih$ f}$ xlmvh$ tevxmiw0$ erh$ {lixliv$ sv$ rsx$ {i$qiix$ wygl$ wxerhevhw0$ qe}

mrjpyirgi$ syv$ vityxexmsr2$ $ Jsv$ i|eqtpi0$ xli$ tivgitxmsr$ liph$ f}$ syv$ kszivrqirxep$ tevxrivw0$ zirhsvw0$ wyttpmivw0$ wlevilsphivw0$ sxliv

wxeoilsphivw0$xli$gsqqyrmxmiw$mr${lmgl${i$hs$fywmriww$sv$xli$kirivep$tyfpmg$qe}$hitirh0$mr$tevx0$sr$xli$wxerhevhw${i$lezi$glswir$xs

ewtmvi$xs$qiix0${lixliv$sv$rsx${i$qiix$xliwi$wxerhevhw$sr$e$xmqip}$fewmw$sv$ex$epp0$erh${lixliv$sv$rsx${i$qiix$i|xivrep$IWK$jegxsvw

xli}$ hiiq$ vipizerx2$ Xli$ wyfnigxmzi$ rexyvi$ erh$ {mhi$ zevmix}$ sj$ jveqi{svow$ erh$ qixlshw$ ywih$ f}$ zevmsyw$ wxeoilsphivw0$ mrgpyhmrk

mrziwxsvw0$ xs$ewwiww$e$gsqter}${mxl$viwtigx$ xs$IWK$gvmxivme$ger$ viwypx$ mr$ xli$ettpmgexmsr$sv$tivgitxmsr$sj$rikexmzi$IWK$jegxsvw$sv$e

qmwvitviwirxexmsr$ sj$ syv$ IWK$ tspmgmiw$ erh$ tvegxmgiw2$ Syv$ jempyvi$ xs$ eglmizi$ tvskviww$ sr$ syv$ lyqer$ vmklxw$ erh$ IWK$ tspmgmiw$ erh

tvegxmgiw$sr$e$xmqip}$fewmw0$sv$ex$epp0$sv$xs$qiix$lyqer$vmklxw$sv$IWK$gvmxivme$wix$f}$xlmvh$tevxmiw0$gsyph$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$syv$fywmriww0

jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2

F}$ ipigxmrk$ xs$ tyfpmgp}$ wlevi$ syv$Lyqer$Vmklxw$ erh$IWK$ vitsvx0$ syv$ fywmriww$qe}$ jegi$ mrgviewih$ wgvyxmr}$ vipexih$ xs$ syv

lyqer$vmklxw$erh$IWK$egxmzmxmiw2$Ew$e$viwypx0$syv$vityxexmsr$gsyph$fi$ehzivwip}$mqtegxih$mj${i$jemp$xs$egx$viwtsrwmfp}$mr$xli$eview$mr

{lmgl${i$vitsvx0$wygl$ew$lyqer$vmklxw0$xli$hizipstqirx$sj$syv${svojsvgi0$wejix}$erh$wigyvmx}0$ehhviwwmrk$vigmhmzmwq0$irkekmrk${mxl

syv$ wxeoilsphivw0$ ixlmgw$ erh$ kszivrergi0$ szivwmklx$ erh$ gsrxvegx$ gsqtpmergi0$ irivk}$ erh$ irzmvsrqirxep$ wywxemrefmpmx}$ erh$ jmrergmep

qerekiqirx$erh$tivjsvqergi2$Er}$levq$xs$syv$vityxexmsr$viwypxmrk$jvsq$wixxmrk$xliwi$wxerhevhw$sv$syv$jempyvi$sv$tivgimzih$jempyvi$xs

qiix$wygl$wxerhevhw$gsyph$mqtegx>$xli${mppmrkriww$sj$syv$kszivrqirxep$tevxrivw0$zirhsvw$erh$wyttpmivw$xs$hs$fywmriww${mxl$yw$sv$xli

uyepmx}$sj$syv$vipexmsrwlmtw${mxl$syv$kszivrqirxep$tevxrivw0$zirhsvw$erh$wyttpmivw?$syv$efmpmx}$xs$eggiww$getmxep$ mr$xli$hifx$sv$iuymx}

qevoixw?$syv$mrziwxsvw${mppmrkriww$sv$efmpmx}$xs$tyvglewi$sv$lsph$syv$wigyvmxmiw?$erh$iqtps}ii$vixirxmsr$erh$xli$uyepmx}$sj$vipexmsrw${mxl

syv$iqtps}iiw0$er}$sj${lmgl$gsyph$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$syv$fywmriww0$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2$$

85

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 61 of 253

Page 84: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq :5367<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 62 of 253

Page 85: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq :6367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Vmwow$Vipexih$xs$Syv$Gsqqsr$Wxsgo

Xli$qevoix$tvmgi$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo$qe}$zev}$wyfwxerxmepp}2

Xli$xvehmrk$tvmgiw$sj$iuymx}$wigyvmxmiw$mwwyih$f}$VIMXw$lezi$lmwxsvmgepp}$fiir$ejjigxih$f}$glerkiw$mr$qevoix$mrxiviwx$vexiw2$Sri$sj

xli$jegxsvw$xlex$qe}$mrjpyirgi$xli$qevoix$tvmgi$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo$mw$ xli$erryep$}miph$jvsq$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$sr$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo$ew

gsqtevih$ xs$ }miphw$ sr$ sxliv$ jmrergmep$ mrwxvyqirxw2$ Er$ mrgviewi$ mr$ qevoix$ mrxiviwx$ vexiw0$ sv$ e$ higviewi$ mr$ syv$ hmwxvmfyxmsrw$ xs

wlevilsphivw0$qe}$pieh$tvswtigxmzi$tyvglewivw$sj$syv$wleviw$xs$hiqerh$e$lmkliv$erryep$}miph0${lmgl$gsyph$vihygi$xli$qevoix$tvmgi$sj

syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo2

Sxliv$jegxsvw$xlex$gsyph$ejjigx$xli$qevoix$tvmgi$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo$mrgpyhi$xli$jspps{mrk>

¨ egxyep$sv$erxmgmtexih$zevmexmsrw$mr$syv$uyevxivp}$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw?

¨ glerkiw$mr$qevoix$zepyexmsrw$sj$gsqtermiw$mr$syv$mrhywxv}?

¨ glerkiw$mr$i|tigxexmsrw$sj$jyxyvi$jmrergmep$tivjsvqergi$sv$glerkiw$mr$iwxmqexiw$sj$wigyvmxmiw$erep}wxw?

¨ jpygxyexmsrw$mr$wxsgo$qevoix$tvmgiw$erh$zspyqiw?

¨ mwwyergiw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$sv$sxliv$wigyvmxmiw$mr$xli$jyxyvi?

¨ xli$ehhmxmsr$sv$hitevxyvi$sj$oi}$tivwsrrip?

¨ errsyrgiqirxw$f}$yw$sv$syv$gsqtixmxsvw$sj$eguymwmxmsrw0$mrziwxqirxw$sv$wxvexikmg$eppmergiw?$erh

¨ glerkiw$mr$xli$tvswtigxw$sj$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw$mr$xli$wigyvi$wivzmgiw$wigxsv2

Jyxyvi$wepiw$sj$wleviw$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo$gsyph$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$xli$qevoix$tvmgi$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo$erh$qe}$fi$hmpyxmzi$xs

gyvvirx$wlevilsphivw2

Wepiw$sj$wleviw$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo0$sv$ xli$tivgitxmsr$xlex$wygl$wepiw$gsyph$sggyv0$gsyph$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$xli$tvmgi$jsv$syv

gsqqsr$ wxsgo2$ Ew$ sj$ Higiqfiv$ 750$ 645=0$ xlivi$ {ivi$ 5<;09440444$ wleviw$ sj$ gsqqsr$ wxsgo$ eyxlsvm~ih$ yrhiv$ syv$ Evxmgpiw$ sj

Mrgsvtsvexmsr0$ sj$ {lmgl$ 5650669075=$ wleviw$ {ivi$ syxwxerhmrk2$ Syv$ Fsevh$ sj$ Hmvigxsvw$ qe}$ eyxlsvm~i$ xli$ mwwyergi$ sj$ ehhmxmsrep

eyxlsvm~ih$fyx$yrmwwyih$wleviw$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo$sv$sxliv$eyxlsvm~ih$fyx$yrmwwyih$wigyvmxmiw$sj$syvw$ex$er}$xmqi0$mrgpyhmrk$tyvwyerx

xs$iuymx}$mrgirxmzi$tperw$erh$wxsgo$tyvglewi$tperw2

Sr$Sgxsfiv$640$645;0${i$jmpih${mxl$ xli$WIG$er$eyxsqexmg$wlipj$ vikmwxvexmsr$sr$Jsvq$W172$Yrhiv$ xlmw$wlipj$ vikmwxvexmsr0${i

qe}0$jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi0$wipp$er}$gsqfmrexmsr$sj$wigyvmxmiw$hiwgvmfih$mr$xli$tvswtigxyw$mr$sri$sv$qsvi$sjjivmrkw2$Iegl$xmqi$xlex${i$qe}

wipp$wigyvmxmiw0${i${mpp$tvszmhi$e$tvswtigxyw$wyttpiqirx$xlex${mpp$gsrxemr$wtigmjmg$mrjsvqexmsr$efsyx$xli$xivqw$sj$xlex$sjjivmrk$erh$xli

wigyvmxmiw$ fimrk$ sjjivih2$ Sr$ Rsziqfiv$ =0$ 645;0$ mr$ gsrrigxmsr$ {mxl$ xli$ wlipj$ vikmwxvexmsr0$ {i$ jmpih$ {mxl$ xli$ WIG$ e$ tvswtigxyw

wyttpiqirx$vipexih$xs$xli$sjjiv$erh$wepi$jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo$ex$er$ekkvikexi$sjjivmrk$tvmgi$sj$yt$xs$(594$qmppmsr

xlvsykl$wepiw$ekirxw2$Wepiw$sj$ wleviw$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo$yrhiv$ xli$tvswtigxyw$ wyttpiqirx$erh$ xli$iuymx}$hmwxvmfyxmsr$ekviiqirxw

irxivih$mrxs${mxl$xli$wepiw$ekirxw0$mj$er}0$qe}$fi$qehi$mr$riksxmexih$xverwegxmsrw$sv$xverwegxmsrw$xlex$evi$hiiqih$xs$fi$Ôex$xli$qevoixÕ

sjjivmrkw$ew$hijmrih$mr$Vypi$859$yrhiv$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$Egx$sj$5=772$Xlivi${ivi$rs$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$wsph$yrhiv$xlmw$tvswtigxyw

wyttpiqirx$hyvmrk$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=$sv$645<2

Er$sjjivmrk$sj$wleviw$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo$qe}$lezi$e$hmpyxmzi$ijjigx$sr$syv$ievrmrkw$tiv$wlevi$erh$jyrhw$jvsq$stivexmsrw$tiv

wlevi$ejxiv$kmzmrk$ijjigx$xs$xli$mwwyergi$sj$wygl$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$erh$xli$vigimtx$sj$xli$i|tigxih$rix$tvsgiihw2$Xli

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 63 of 253

Page 86: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq :7367<

86

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 64 of 253

Page 87: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq :8367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

egxyep$ eqsyrx$ sj$ hmpyxmsr$ jvsq$ er}$ sjjivmrk$ sj$ syv$ iuymx}$ wigyvmxmiw0$ gerrsx$ fi$ hixivqmrih$ ex$ xlmw$ xmqi2$ Xli$ qevoix$ tvmgi$ sj$ syv

gsqqsr$wxsgo$gsyph$higpmri$ew$e$viwypx$sj$wepiw$sj$e$pevki$ryqfiv$sj$wleviw$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo$mr$xli$qevoix$tyvwyerx$xs$er$sjjivmrk0

sv$sxliv{mwi0$sv$ew$e$viwypx$sj$xli$tivgitxmsr$sv$i|tigxexmsr$xlex$wygl$wepiw$gsyph$sggyv2

Zevmsyw$erxm1xeoisziv$tvsxigxmsrw$ettpmgefpi$xs$yw$qe}$qeoi$er$eguymwmxmsr$sj$yw$qsvi$hmjjmgypx$erh$vihygi$xli$qevoix$zepyi$sj

syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo2

[i$evi$e$Jpsvmhe$gsvtsvexmsr$erh$xli$erxm1xeoisziv$tvszmwmsrw$sj$Jpsvmhe$pe{$mqtswi$zevmsyw$mqtihmqirxw$xs$xli$efmpmx}$sj$e$xlmvh

tevx}$xs$eguymvi$gsrxvsp$sj$syv$gsqter}0$izir$mj$e$glerki$sj$gsrxvsp${syph$fi$firijmgmep$xs$syv$wlevilsphivw2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$tvszmwmsrw$sj

syv$ evxmgpiw$ sj$ mrgsvtsvexmsr$ qe}$qeoi$ er$ eguymwmxmsr$ sj$ syv$ gsqter}$qsvi$ hmjjmgypx2$ Syv$ evxmgpiw$ sj$ mrgsvtsvexmsr$ eyxlsvm~i$ xli

mwwyergi$f}$syv$Fsevh$sj$Hmvigxsvw$sj$Ôfpero$gligoÕ$tvijivvih$wxsgo${mxlsyx$wlevilsphiv$ettvszep2$Wygl$wleviw$sj$tvijivvih$wxsgo$gsyph

fi$ kmzir$ zsxmrk$ vmklxw0$ hmzmhirh$ vmklxw0$ pmuymhexmsr$ vmklxw$ sv$ sxliv$ wmqmpev$ vmklxw$ wytivmsv$ xs$ xlswi$ sj$ syv$ gsqqsr$ wxsgo0$qeomrk$ e

xeoisziv$sj$syv$gsqter}$qsvi$hmjjmgypx$erh$i|tirwmzi2$Mr$ehhmxmsr$xs$hmwgsyvekmrk$xeoiszivw0$xli$erxm1xeoisziv$tvszmwmsrw$sj$Jpsvmhe

pe{$erh$syv$evxmgpiw$sj$mrgsvtsvexmsr$qe}$lezi$xli$mqtegx$sj$vihygmrk$xli$qevoix$zepyi$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo2

Jempyvi$xs$qemrxemr$ijjigxmzi$mrxivrep$gsrxvspw$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$Wigxmsr$848$sj$xli$Wevferiw1S|pi}$Egx$sj$6446$gsyph$lezi$er

ehzivwi$ijjigx$sr$syv$fywmriww$erh$xli$xvehmrk$tvmgi$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo2

Mj${i$jemp$xs$qemrxemr$xli$ehiuyeg}$sj$syv$mrxivrep$gsrxvspw0$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$xli$viuymviqirxw$sj$Wigxmsr$848$sj$xli$Wevferiw1

S|pi}$Egx$sj$64460$ew$wygl$wxerhevhw$evi$qshmjmih0$wyttpiqirxih$sv$eqirhih$jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi0$syv$i|tswyvi$xs$jveyh$erh$ivvsvw$mr

eggsyrxmrk$ erh$ jmrergmep$ vitsvxmrk$ gsyph$ qexivmepp}$ mrgviewi2$ Epws0$ mrehiuyexi$ mrxivrep$ gsrxvspw$ {syph$ pmoip}$ tvizirx$ yw$ jvsq

gsrgpyhmrk$sr$er$srksmrk$fewmw$xlex${i$lezi$ijjigxmzi$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$Wigxmsr$848$sj$xli

Wevferiw1S|pi}$Egx$sj$64462$Wygl$jempyvi$xs$eglmizi$erh$qemrxemr$ijjigxmzi$mrxivrep$gsrxvspw$gsyph$ehzivwip}$mqtegx$syv$fywmriww$erh

xli$tvmgi$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo2

[i$qe}$mwwyi$ehhmxmsrep$hifx$wigyvmxmiw$xlex$gsyph$pmqmx$syv$stivexmrk$jpi|mfmpmx}$erh$rikexmzip}$ejjigx$xli$zepyi$sj$syv$gsqqsr

wxsgo2

Mr$ xli$ jyxyvi0${i$qe}$ mwwyi$ehhmxmsrep$hifx$ wigyvmxmiw${lmgl$qe}$fi$kszivrih$f}$ er$ mrhirxyvi$sv$sxliv$ mrwxvyqirx$gsrxemrmrk

gszirerxw$xlex$gsyph$tpegi$viwxvmgxmsrw$sr$ xli$stivexmsr$sj$syv$fywmriww$erh$xli$i|igyxmsr$sj$syv$fywmriww$wxvexik}$ mr$ehhmxmsr$xs$xli

viwxvmgxmsrw$sr$syv$fywmriww$epvieh}$gsrxemrih$mr$xli$ekviiqirxw$kszivrmrk$syv$i|mwxmrk$hifx2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0${i$qe}$glsswi$xs$mwwyi$hifx

xlex$ mw$ gsrzivxmfpi$ sv$ i|glerkiefpi$ jsv$ sxliv$ wigyvmxmiw0$ mrgpyhmrk$ syv$ gsqqsr$ wxsgo0$ sv$ xlex$ lew$ vmklxw0$ tvijivirgiw$ erh$ tvmzmpikiw

wirmsv$xs$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo2$Figeywi$er}$higmwmsr$xs$mwwyi$hifx$wigyvmxmiw${mpp$hitirh$sr$qevoix$gsrhmxmsrw$erh$sxliv$jegxsvw$fi}srh

syv$gsrxvsp0${i$gerrsx$tvihmgx$sv$iwxmqexi$xli$eqsyrx0$xmqmrk$sv$rexyvi$sj$er}$jyxyvi$hifx$jmrergmrkw$erh${i$qe}$fi$viuymvih$xs$eggitx

yrjezsvefpi$xivqw$jsv$er}$wygl$jmrergmrkw2$Eggsvhmrkp}0$er}$jyxyvi$mwwyergi$sj$hifx$gsyph$hmpyxi$xli$mrxiviwx$sj$lsphivw$sj$syv$gsqqsr

wxsgo$erh$vihygi$xli$zepyi$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo2

Syv$wxsgo$fy}fego$tvskveq$gsyph$mrgviewi$xli$zspexmpmx}$sj$xli$tvmgi$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo2

Mr$Jifvyev}$645<0$syv$Fsevh$sj$Hmvigxsvw$ettvszih$e$wxsgo$fy}fego$tvskveq$eyxlsvm~mrk$yw$xs$vityvglewi$yt$xs$e$qe|mqyq

sj$(64424$qmppmsr$sj$syv$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$xlvsykl$Sgxsfiv$640$64642$Vityvglewiw$qe}$fi$qehi$mr$xli$stir$qevoix0$mr$tvmzexip}

riksxmexih$ xverwegxmsrw$sv$ f}$sxliv$qierw0$ jvsq$ xmqi$ xs$ xmqi0$ wyfnigx$ xs$qevoix$ gsrhmxmsrw0$ ettpmgefpi$ pikep$ viuymviqirxw$ erh$sxliv

jegxsvw0$ mrgpyhmrk$ xli$ pmqmxexmsrw$ wix$ jsvxl$ mr$ syv$ mrhirxyviw$ erh$Wirmsv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}2$Xlivi$ ger$fi$rs$ewwyvergi$ xlex${i${mpp$fy}

wleviw$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo$sv$xli$xmqijveqi$jsv$vityvglewiw$yrhiv$syv$wxsgo$fy}fego$tvskveq$sv$xlex$er}$vityvglewiw${mpp$lezi$e

tswmxmzi$ mqtegx$sr$syv$ wxsgo$tvmgi$sv$ievrmrkw$tiv$ wlevi2$ Mqtsvxerx$ jegxsvw$ xlex$gsyph$geywi$yw$ xs$hmwgsrxmryi$sv$higviewi$syv$ wlevi

vityvglewiw$ mrgpyhi0$ eqsrk$ sxlivw0$ yrjezsvefpi$ qevoix$ gsrhmxmsrw0$ xli$ qevoix$ tvmgi$ sj$ syv$ gsqqsr$ wxsgo0$ xli$ rexyvi$ sj$ sxliv

mrziwxqirx$sv$wxvexikmg$sttsvxyrmxmiw$tviwirxih$xs$yw$jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi0$xli$vexi$sj$hmpyxmsr$sj$syv$iuymx}$gsqtirwexmsr$tvskveqw0$syv

efmpmx}$xs$qeoi$ettvstvmexi0$xmqip}0$erh$firijmgmep$higmwmsrw$ew$xs${lir0$ls{0$erh${lixliv$xs$tyvglewi$wleviw$yrhiv$xli$wxsgo$fy}fego

tvskveq0$erh$xli$ezempefmpmx}$sj$jyrhw$rigiwwev}$xs$gsrxmryi$tyvglewmrk$wxsgo2

$Mxiq$5F2 Yrviwspzih$Wxejj$Gsqqirxw

Rsri2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 65 of 253

Page 88: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq :9367<

Mxiq$62 Tvstivxmiw

Xli$Gsqter}$s{rw$erh$piewiw$mxw$gsvtsvexi$sjjmgiw0${lmgl$evi$fsxl$psgexih$mr$Fsge$Vexsr0$Jpsvmhe2$Xli$Gsqter}$tyvglewih

perh$mr$Fsge$Vexsr0$Jpsvmhe$xs$gsrwxvygx$e$ri{$gsvtsvexi$sjjmgi$fymphmrk${lmgl${ew$gsqtpixih$mr$xli$jmvwx$uyevxiv$sj$645=2$Xli

Gsqter}+w$piewi$sr$mxw$ehhmxmsrep$gsvtsvexi$sjjmgi$wtegi$i|tmviw$mr$Higiqfiv$646<$erh$lew$x{s$91}iev$viri{ep$stxmsrw${lmgl$mj

i|ivgmwih${mpp$viwypx$mr$e$qe|mqyq$xivq$irhmrk$mr$Higiqfiv$647<2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0${i$piewi$sjjmgi$wtegi$jsv$syv$iewxivr$vikmsrep$sjjmgi$mr

Glevpsxxi0$Rsvxl$Gevspmre?$syv$girxvep$vikmsrep$sjjmgi$mr$Wer$Erxsrms0$Xi|ew?$syv${iwxivr$vikmsrep$sjjmgi$mr$Psw$Erkipiw0$Gepmjsvrme?

erh$syv$}syxl$wivzmgiw$hmzmwmsr$mr$Tmxxwfyvkl0$Tirrw}pzerme2$Ew$e$viwypx$sj$xli$FM$eguymwmxmsr$mr$Jifvyev}$6455$erh$xli$Tvsxsgsp

eguymwmxmsr$mr$Jifvyev}$64580${i$evi$epws$gyvvirxp}$piewmrk$sjjmgi$wtegi$mr$Fsyphiv0$Gspsvehs$erh$Eyvsve0$Mppmrsmw0$viwtigxmzip}2$[i$epws

piewi$sjjmgi$wtegi$mr$W}hri}$erh$Qipfsyvri0$Eywxvepme0$erh$mr$Werhxsr0$Wsyxl$Ejvmge0$xlvsykl$syv$szivwiew$ejjmpmexiw$xs$wyttsvx$syv

Eywxvepmer0$erh$Wsyxl$Ejvmger$stivexmsrw0$viwtigxmzip}2$[i$gsrwmhiv$syv$sjjmgi$wtegi$ehiuyexi$jsv$syv$gyvvirx$stivexmsrw2

Wii$xli$Jegmpmxmiw$erh$He}$Vitsvxmrk$Girxivw$pmwxmrk$yrhiv$Mxiq$5$jsv$e$pmwx$sj$xli$gsvvigxmsrep0$hixirxmsr$erh$viirxv}$tvstivxmiw

{i$s{r$sv$piewi$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$syv$stivexmsrw2

$Mxiq$72 Pikep$Tvsgiihmrkw

Xli$mrjsvqexmsr$viuymvih$livimr$mw$mrgsvtsvexih$f}$vijivirgi$jvsq$Rsxi$5<$1$Gsqqmxqirxw$erh$Gsrxmrkirgmiw$mr$xli$Rsxiw$xs

xli$Gsrwspmhexih$Jmrergmep$Wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$MM0$Mxiq$<$sj$xlmw$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O2

$Mxiq$82 Qmri$Wejix}$Hmwgpswyviw

Rsx$ettpmgefpi2

TEVX$MM

$

Mxiq$92 Qevoix$jsv$Vikmwxverx×w$Gsqqsr$Iuymx}0$Vipexih$Wxsgolsphiv$Qexxivw$erh$Mwwyiv$Tyvglewiw$sj$Iuymx}$Wigyvmxmiw

Syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo$xvehiw$sr$xli$Ri{$]svo$Wxsgo$I|glerki$yrhiv$xli$w}qfsp$ÔKIS2Õ$Ew$sj$Jifvyev}$650$64640${i$leh$:<9

wlevilsphivw$sj$vigsvh2$Wlevilsphivw$sj$vigsvh$hsiw$rsx$mrgpyhi$wlevilsphivw${ls$s{r$wleviw$liph$mr$&wxviix$reqi2&

Hmzmhirhw

Ew$e$VIMX0$KIS$mw$viuymvih$ xs$hmwxvmfyxi$erryepp}$ex$ piewx$=4)$sj$ mxw$VIMX$xe|efpi$ mrgsqi$,hixivqmrih${mxlsyx$ vikevh$ xs$ xli

hmzmhirhw$temh$hihygxmsr$erh$f}$i|gpyhmrk$rix$getmxep$kemr-$erh$fiker$te}mrk$vikypev$uyevxivp}$VIMX$hmzmhirhw$mr$64572$Xli$eqsyrx0

xmqmrk$erh$jviuyirg}$sj$jyxyvi$hmzmhirhw0$ls{iziv0${mpp$fi$ex$xli$wspi$hmwgvixmsr$sj$KIS+w$Fsevh$sj$Hmvigxsvw$,xli$&FsevhÕ-$erh${mpp$fi

higpevih$fewih$ytsr$zevmsyw$ jegxsvw0$qer}$sj${lmgl$evi$fi}srh$KIS+w$ gsrxvsp0$ mrgpyhmrk0$KIS+w$ jmrergmep$ gsrhmxmsr$ erh$stivexmrk

gewl$jps{w0$xli$eqsyrx$viuymvih$xs$qemrxemr$VIMX$wxexyw$erh$vihygi$er}$mrgsqi$xe|iw$xlex$KIS$sxliv{mwi${syph$fi$viuymvih$xs$te}0

pmqmxexmsrw$sr$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$mr$KIS+w$i|mwxmrk$erh$jyxyvi$hifx$mrwxvyqirxw0$pmqmxexmsrw$sr$KIS+w$efmpmx}$xs$jyrh$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$ywmrk$gewl

kirivexih$xlvsykl$KIS+w$XVWw$erh$sxliv$jegxsvw$xlex$KIS+w$Fsevh$qe}$hiiq$vipizerx2

Tivjsvqergi$Kvetl

Xli$jspps{mrk$tivjsvqergi$kvetl$gsqteviw$xli$tivjsvqergi$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo$xs$xli$Vywwipp$64440$xli$W*T$944$Gsqqivgmep

Wivzmgiw$erh$Wyttpmiw$Mrhi|0$erh$xli$QWGM$Y2W2$VIMX$Mrhi|$erh$mw$tvszmhih$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$Mxiq$645,i-$sj$Vikypexmsr$W1O2

Gsqtevmwsr$sj$Jmzi1]iev$Gyqypexmzi$Xsxep$Vixyvr.

Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg20$Vywwipp$64440

W*T$944$Gsqqivgmep$Wivzmgiw$erh$Wyttpmiw$Mrhi|

erh$QWGM$Y2W2$VIMX$Mrhi|

,Tivjsvqergi$xlvsykl$Higiqfiv$750$645=-

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 66 of 253

Page 89: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq ::367<

Hexi $Xli$KISKvsyt0$Mrg2 $ Vywwipp$6444 $

W*T$944GsqqivgmepWivzmgiw$erhWyttpmiw $

QWGM$Y2W2VIMX$Mrhi|

Higiqfiv$750$6458 $ ( 544244 $ ( 544244 $ ( 544244 $ ( 544244

Higiqfiv$750$6459 $ ( ;:2== $ ( =826= $ ( =;2=5 $ ( =<28=

Higiqfiv$750$645: $ ( 5482;9 $ ( 5562:9 $ ( 554265 $ ( 5462:9

Higiqfiv$750$645; $ ( 55424; $ ( 56;28: $ ( 5642:5 $ ( 547297

Higiqfiv$750$645< $ ( ==2;< $ ( 5552=8 $ ( 55:2<< $ ( =829=

Higiqfiv$750$645= $ ( =62== $ ( 57<294 $ ( 5:4279 $ ( 558284

Ewwyqiw$(544$mrziwxih$sr$Higiqfiv$750$6458$mr$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo$erh$xli$viwtigxmzi$Mrhi|2

. Xsxep$vixyvr$ewwyqiw$vimrziwxqirx$sj$hmzmhirhw2

Mxiq$:2 Wipigxih$Jmrergmep$Hexe

Xli$jspps{mrk$xefpi$wixw$jsvxl$lmwxsvmgep$jmrergmep$hexe$ew$sj$erh$jsv$iegl$sj$xli$jmzi$}ievw$mr$xli$tivmsh$irhih$Higiqfiv$750

645=2$Xli$wipigxih$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$hexe$wlsyph$fi$vieh$mr$gsrnyrgxmsr${mxl$syv$&Qerekiqirx$Hmwgywwmsr$erh$Erep}wmw$sj

Jmrergmep$Gsrhmxmsr$erh$Viwypxw$sj$Stivexmsrw&$erh$syv$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$erh$xli$rsxiw$xs$xli$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep

wxexiqirxw$,mr$xlsywerhw0$i|gitx$tiv$wlevi$erh$stivexmsrep$hexe-2$Syxwxerhmrk$wlevi$erh$tiv1wlevi$eqsyrxw$hmwgpswih$jsv$epp$tivmshw

tviwirxih$lezi$fiir$vixvsegxmzip}$ehnywxih$xs$vijpigx$xli$ijjigxw$sj$syv$71jsv16$wxsgo$wtpmx$mr$645;2$

87

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 67 of 253

Page 90: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq :;367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

]iev$Irhih> 645= $ 645< $ 645; $ 645: $ 6459

Viwypxw$sj$Gsrxmrymrk$Stivexmsrw> $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Viziryiw ( 608;;0=66 $ ( 6077507<: $ ( 606:70864 $ ( 605;=08=4 $ ( 50<87074;

Stivexmrk$mrgsqi 7440857 $ 6:80::9 $ 68<06<9 $ 6:909<8 $ 6790;6=

Rix$mrgsqi ( 5::0856 $ ( 5880<6; $ ( 58:0468 $ ( 58<08=< $ ( 57=0759

Mrgsqi$tiv$gsqqsr$wlevi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli

KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2> $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Fewmg> ( 5284 $ ( 5265 $ ( 5266 $ ( 5278 $ ( 526:

Hmpyxih> ( 5284 $ ( 5264 $ ( 5265 $ ( 5277 $ ( 5269

[imklxih$Eziveki$Wleviw$Syxwxerhmrk> $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Fewmg 55=04=; $ 5640685 $ 56404=9 $ 55504:9 $ 5540988

Hmpyxih 55=0755 $ 5640;8; $ 5640<58 $ 55508<9 $ 5540==7

Gewl$Hmzmhirhw$tiv$Gsqqsr$Wlevi> $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Gewl$Hmzmhirhw ( 52=6 $ ( 52<< $ ( 52<< $ ( 52;7 $ ( 52:;

Jmrergmep$Gsrhmxmsr> $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Gyvvirx$ewwixw ( 98;0;;< $ ( :450;:6 $ ( 9;=0;4= $ ( :=;0::= $ ( 87<078:

Gyvvirx$pmefmpmxmiw 7=90=6< $ ;49067< $ 7:=09:7 $ 948049< $ 6;<0:68

Xsxep$ewwixw 8075;0978 $ 8069<055< $ 8066:0=4< $ 70;8=084= $ 708:6066;

Psrk1xivq$hifx0$mrgpyhmrk$gyvvirx$tsvxmsr

,i|gpyhmrk$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx$erh$getmxep

piewiw$erh$yreqsvxm~ih$hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw- 6087:047= $ 6086=0756 $ 6065;06<; $ 50=9;0974 $ 50<;<0<;4

Xsxep$Wlevilsphivw×$iuymx} ( ==:048< $ ( 5047=0=48 $ ( 505=<0=5= $ ( =;80=9; $ ( 5044:0<7;

Stivexmsrep$Hexe> $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Jegmpmxmiw$mr$stivexmsr 56= $ 579 $ 585 $ 548 $ 548

Stivexmsrep$getegmx}$sj$gsrxvegxw$,5- =6059: $ <<09:; $ <<06;6 $ <709== $ <70<;<

Gsqtirwexih$qerhe}w$,6- 6<0;9;0856 $ 6<079409=5 $ 6;07650:<9 $ 680<87095: $ 670<85069:

,5-$Vitviwirxw$xli$ryqfiv$sj$fihw$tvmqevmp}$jvsq$wigyvi$wivzmgiw$jegmpmxmiw$erh$i|gpyhiw$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw$erh$fihw$yrhiv$hizipstqirx2

,6-$Gsqtirwexih$qerhe}w$evi$gepgypexih$ew$jspps{w>$,e-$jsv$tiv$hmiq$vexi$jegmpmxmiw$Ó$xli$ryqfiv$sj$fihw$sggytmih$f}$viwmhirxw$sr$e

hemp}$fewmw$hyvmrk$xli$jmwgep$}iev?$erh$,f-$jsv$jm|ih$vexi$jegmpmxmiw$Ó$xli$getegmx}$sj$xli$jegmpmx}$qypxmtpmih$f}$xli$ryqfiv$sj$he}w$xli

jegmpmx}${ew$mr$stivexmsr$hyvmrk$xli$jmwgep$}iev2

Mxiq$;2 Qerekiqirx×w$Hmwgywwmsr$erh$Erep}wmw$sj$Jmrergmep$Gsrhmxmsr$erh$Viwypxw$sj$Stivexmsrw

Mrxvshygxmsr

Xli$jspps{mrk$hmwgywwmsr$erh$erep}wmw$tvszmhiw$mrjsvqexmsr${lmgl$qerekiqirx$fipmiziw$mw$vipizerx$xs$er$ewwiwwqirx$erh

yrhivwxerhmrk$sj$syv$gsrwspmhexih$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$erh$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr2$Xlmw$hmwgywwmsr$gsrxemrw$jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw

xlex$mrzspzi$vmwow$erh$yrgivxemrxmiw2$Syv$egxyep$viwypxw$qe}$hmjjiv$qexivmepp}$jvsq$xlswi$erxmgmtexih$mr$xliwi$jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw

ew$e$viwypx$sj$ryqivsyw$jegxsvw$mrgpyhmrk0$fyx$rsx$pmqmxih$xs0$xlswi$hiwgvmfih$efszi$yrhiv$ÔMxiq$5E2$Vmwo$Jegxsvw0Õ$erh$ÔJsv{evh1

Pssomrk$Wxexiqirxw$1$Weji$LevfsvÕ$fips{2$Xli$hmwgywwmsr$wlsyph$fi$vieh$mr$gsrnyrgxmsr${mxl$xli$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$erh

rsxiw$xlivixs2

$$$$

Xlmw$ wigxmsr$ sj$ xlmw$ Jsvq$ 541O$ kirivepp}$ hmwgywwiw$ 645=$ erh$ 645<$ mxiqw$ erh$ }iev1xs1}iev$ gsqtevmwsrw$ fix{iir$ 645=$ erh$ 645<2

Hmwgywwmsrw$sj$645;$mxiqw$erh$}iev1xs1}iev$gsqtevmwsrw$fix{iir$645<$erh$645;$xlex$evi$rsx$mrgpyhih$mr$xlmw$Jsvq$541O$ger$fi$jsyrh

mr$ ÔQerekiqirx×w$Hmwgywwmsr$ erh$Erep}wmw$ sj$Jmrergmep$Gsrhmxmsr$ erh$Viwypxw$ sj$StivexmsrwÕ$ mr$Tevx$ MM0$ Mxiq$;$sj$ xli$Gsqter}×w

Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O$jsv$xli$jmwgep$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645<$erh$evi$mrgsvtsvexih$livimr$f}$vijivirgi2

88

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 68 of 253

Page 91: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq :<367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

[i$evi$e$viep$iwxexi$mrziwxqirx$xvywx$wtigmepm~mrk$mr$xli$s{rivwlmt0$piewmrk$erh$qerekiqirx$sj$wigyvi0$viirxv}$jegmpmxmiw$erh

tvsgiwwmrk$girxivw$erh$xli$tvszmwmsr$sj$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$wivzmgiw$erh$}syxl$wivzmgiw$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw0$Eywxvepme0$Wsyxl$Ejvmge0$erh

xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq2$[i$s{r0$piewi$erh$stivexi$e$fvseh$verki$sj$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw$mrgpyhmrk$qe|mqyq0$qihmyq$erh$qmrmqyq$wigyvmx}

jegmpmxmiw0$tvsgiwwmrk$girxivw0$erh$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$viirxv}$jegmpmxmiw2$[i$sjjiv$gsyrwipmrk0$ihygexmsr$erh3sv$xviexqirx$jsv$epgslsp$erh

hvyk$efywi$tvsfpiqw$ex$qswx$sj$xli$hsqiwxmg$jegmpmxmiw${i$qereki2$[i$evi$epws$e$tvszmhiv$sj$mrrszexmzi$gsqtpmergi$xiglrspskmiw0

mrhywxv}1piehmrk$qsrmxsvmrk$wivzmgiw0$erh$izmhirgi1fewih$wytivzmwmsr$erh$xviexqirx$tvskveqw$jsv$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$tevspiiw0

tvsfexmsrivw$erh$tvixvmep$hijirherxw2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0${i$lezi$e$gsrxvegx${mxl$MGI$xs$tvszmhi$wytivzmwmsr$erh$vitsvxmrk$wivzmgiw$hiwmkrih

xs$mqtvszi$xli$tevxmgmtexmsr$sj$rsr1hixemrih$epmirw$mr$xli$mqqmkvexmsr$gsyvx$w}wxiq2$[i$hizipst$ri{$jegmpmxmiw$fewih$sr$gsrxvegx

e{evhw0$ywmrk$syv$tvsnigx$hizipstqirx$i|tivxmwi$erh$i|tivmirgi$xs$hiwmkr0$gsrwxvygx$erh$jmrergi${lex${i$fipmizi$evi$wxexi1sj1xli1evx

jegmpmxmiw$xlex$qe|mqm~i$wigyvmx}$erh$ijjmgmirg}2$[i$epws$tvszmhi$wigyvi$xverwtsvxexmsr$wivzmgiw$jsv$sjjirhiv$erh$hixemrii$tstypexmsrw$ew

gsrxvegxih$hsqiwxmgepp}$erh$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq$xlvsykl$syv$nsmrx$zirxyvi$KISEqi}2

Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$syv${svph{mhi$stivexmsrw$mrgpyhih$xli$qerekiqirx$erh3sv$s{rivwlmt$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$=90444$fihw

ex$56=$gsvvigxmsrep0$hixirxmsr$erh$viirxv}$jegmpmxmiw0$mrgpyhmrk$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw$erh$tvsnigxw$yrhiv$hizipstqirx$erh$epws$mrgpyhih$xli

tvszmwmsr$sj$wivzmgmrk$qsvi$xler$6540444$sjjirhivw$mr$e$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$irzmvsrqirx$sr$filepj$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$=44$jihivep0$wxexi

erh$psgep$gsvvigxmsrep$ekirgmiw$psgexih$mr$epp$94$wxexiw2

Jsv$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$645<0${i$leh$gsrwspmhexih$viziryiw$sj$(629$fmppmsr$erh$(627$fmppmsr0$viwtigxmzip}0

erh${i$qemrxemrih$er$eziveki$gsqter}${mhi$jegmpmx}$sggyterg}$vexi$sj$=628)$mrgpyhmrk$=6059:$egxmzi$fihw$erh$i|gpyhmrk$804:<$mhpi

fihw$jsv$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$erh$=62;)$mrgpyhmrk$<<09:;$egxmzi$fihw$erh$i|gpyhmrk$;04:<$mhpi$fihw$erh$fihw$yrhiv

hizipstqirx$jsv$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645<2

VIMX$Gsrzivwmsr

[i$lezi$fiir$e$piehmrk$s{riv0$piwwsv$erh$stivexsv$sj$gsvvigxmsrep0$hixirxmsr$erh$viirxv}$jegmpmxmiw$erh$tvszmhiv$sj$gsqqyrmx}1fewih

wivzmgiw$erh$}syxl$wivzmgiw$mr$xli$mrhywxv}$wmrgi$5=<8$erh$fiker$stivexmrk$ew$e$VIMX$jsv$jihivep$mrgsqi$xe|$tyvtswiw$ijjigxmzi$Neryev}

50$64572$Ew$e$viwypx$sj$xli$VIMX$gsrzivwmsr0${i$visvkerm~ih$syv$stivexmsrw$erh$qszih$rsr1viep$iwxexi$gsqtsrirxw$mrxs$XVWw2$Xlvsykl

xli$XVW$wxvygxyvi0$xli$tsvxmsr$sj$syv$fywmriwwiw${lmgl$evi$rsr1viep$iwxexi$vipexih0$wygl$ew$syv$qerekih1srp}$gsrxvegxw0$mrxivrexmsrep

stivexmsrw0$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$wivzmgiw0$erh$sxliv$rsr1viwmhirxmep$erh$gsqqyrmx}$fewih$jegmpmxmiw0$evi$tevx$sj${lspp}1s{rih$xe|efpi

wyfwmhmevmiw$sj$xli$VIMX2$Qswx$sj$syv$fywmriww$wikqirxw0${lmgl$evi$viep$iwxexi$vipexih$erh$mrzspzi$gsqter}1s{rih$erh$gsqter}1

piewih$jegmpmxmiw0$evi$tevx$sj$xli$VIMX2$Xli$XVW$wxvygxyvi$epps{w$yw$xs$qemrxemr$xli$wxvexikmg$epmkrqirx$sj$epqswx$epp$sj$syv$hmzivwmjmih

fywmriww$wikqirxw$yrhiv$sri$irxmx}2$Xli$XVW$ewwixw$erh$stivexmsrw${mpp$gsrxmryi$xs$fi$wyfnigx$xs$jihivep$erh$wxexi$gsvtsvexi$mrgsqi

xe|iw$erh$xs$jsvimkr$xe|iw$ew$ettpmgefpi$mr$xli$nyvmwhmgxmsrw$mr${lmgl$xlswi$ewwixw$erh$stivexmsrw$evi$psgexih2

Ew$e$VIMX0${i$evi$viuymvih$xs$hmwxvmfyxi$erryepp}$ex$piewx$=4)$sj$syv$VIMX$xe|efpi$mrgsqi$,hixivqmrih${mxlsyx$vikevh$xs$xli$hmzmhirhw

temh$hihygxmsr$erh$f}$i|gpyhmrk$rix$getmxep$kemr-$erh${i$fiker$te}mrk$vikypev$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$mr$64572$[i$higpevih$erh$temh$xli

jspps{mrk$vikypev$VIMX$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$xs$syv$wlevilsphivw$jsv$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$645<${lmgl${ivi$xviexih$jsv

jihivep$mrgsqi$xe|iw$ew$jspps{w>

89

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 69 of 253

Page 92: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq :=367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$ $ $ $ Svhmrev}$Hmzmhirhw $

Higpevexmsr$Hexi $ Te}qirx$Hexi $ Vigsvh$Hexi $HmwxvmfyxmsrTiv$Wlevi $ Uyepmjmih$,5- $

Rsr1Uyepmjmih $

RsrhmzmhirhHmwxvmfyxmsrw$,6-

EkkvikexiTe}qirxEqsyrx,qmppmsrw-

Jifvyev}$90$645< $ Jifvyev}$6;0$645< $ Jifvyev}$5:0$645< $ ( 428; $ ( 4248:55;5 $ ( 4264=4664 $ ( 42658<:4= ( 9<27

Etvmp$550$645< $ Qe}$70$645< $ Etvmp$670$645< $ ( 428; $ ( 4248:55;5 $ ( 4264=4664 $ ( 42658<:4= ( 9;28

Nyp}$540$645< $ Nyp}$6;0$645< $ Nyp}$640$645< $ ( 428; $ ( 4248:55;5 $ ( 4264=4664 $ ( 42658<:4= ( 9;26

Sgxsfiv$590$645< $ Rsziqfiv$60$645< $ Sgxsfiv$6:0$645< $ ( 428; $ ( 4248:55;5 $ ( 4264=4664 $ ( 42658<:4= ( 9;26

Jifvyev}$80$645= $ Jifvyev}$660$645= $ Jifvyev}$590$645= $ ( 428< $ ( Ó $ ( 426;9=:== $ ( 426484745 ( 9;2=

Etvmp$70$645= $ Etvmp$660$645= $ Etvmp$590$645= $ ( 428< $ ( Ó $ ( 426;9=:== $ ( 426484745 ( 9<26

Nyp}$=0$645= $ Nyp}$6:0$645= $ Nyp}$5=0$645= $ ( 428< $ ( Ó $ ( 426;9=:== $ ( 426484745 ( 9<26

Sgxsfiv$580$645= $ Rsziqfiv$50$645= $ Sgxsfiv$690$645= $ ( 428< $ ( Ó $ ( 426;9=:== $ ( 426484745 ( 9<26

,5-$ Jsv$ 645=0$ xlivi$ evi$ rs$ Uyepmjmih$ Hmzmhirhw2$ Uyepmjmih$ Hmzmhirhw$ vitviwirxw$ xli$ tsvxmsr$ sj$ Xsxep$ Svhmrev}$ Hmzmhirhw$ {lmgl

gsrwxmxyxiw$e$&Uyepmjmih$Hmzmhirh&0$ew$hijmrih$f}$xli$Mrxivrep$Viziryi$Wivzmgi2

,6-$Xli$eqsyrx$gsrwxmxyxiw$e$&Vixyvr$sj$Getmxep&0$ew$hijmrih$f}$xli$Mrxivrep$Viziryi$Wivzmgi2

Gvmxmgep$Eggsyrxmrk$Tspmgmiw

[i$fipmizi$xlex$xli$eggsyrxmrk$tspmgmiw$hiwgvmfih$fips{$evi$gvmxmgep$xs$yrhivwxerhmrk$syv$fywmriww0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$erh

jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$figeywi$xli}$mrzspzi$xli$qsvi$wmkrmjmgerx$nyhkqirxw$erh$iwxmqexiw$ywih$mr$xli$tvitevexmsr$sj$syv$gsrwspmhexih

jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw2$[i$lezi$hmwgywwih$xli$hizipstqirx0$wipigxmsr$erh$ettpmgexmsr$sj$syv$gvmxmgep$eggsyrxmrk$tspmgmiw${mxl$xli$eyhmx

gsqqmxxii$sj$syv$Fsevh$sj$Hmvigxsvw0$erh$syv$eyhmx$gsqqmxxii$lew$vizmi{ih$syv$hmwgpswyvi$vipexmrk$xs$syv$gvmxmgep$eggsyrxmrk$tspmgmiw$mr

xlmw$ÔQerekiqirx×w$Hmwgywwmsr$erh$Erep}wmw$sj$Jmrergmep$Gsrhmxmsr$erh$Viwypxw$sj$Stivexmsrw2Õ

Syv$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$evi$tvitevih$mr$gsrjsvqmx}${mxl$eggsyrxmrk$tvmrgmtpiw$kirivepp}$eggitxih$mr$xli$Yrmxih

Wxexiw2$Ew$wygl0${i$evi$viuymvih$xs$qeoi$givxemr$iwxmqexiw0$nyhkqirxw$erh$ewwyqtxmsrw$xlex${i$fipmizi$evi$viewsrefpi$fewih$ytsr$xli

mrjsvqexmsr$ezempefpi2$Xliwi$iwxmqexiw$erh$ewwyqtxmsrw$ejjigx$xli$vitsvxih$eqsyrxw$sj$ewwixw$erh$pmefmpmxmiw$ex$xli$hexi$sj$xli$jmrergmep

wxexiqirxw$erh$xli$vitsvxih$eqsyrxw$sj$viziryiw$erh$i|tirwiw$hyvmrk$xli$vitsvxmrk$tivmsh2$[i$vsyxmrip}$izepyexi$syv$iwxmqexiw$fewih

sr$lmwxsvmgep$i|tivmirgi$erh$sr$zevmsyw$sxliv$ewwyqtxmsrw$xlex$syv$qerekiqirx$fipmiziw$evi$viewsrefpi$yrhiv$xli$gmvgyqwxergiw2

Egxyep$viwypxw$qe}$hmjjiv$jvsq$xliwi$iwxmqexiw$yrhiv$hmjjivirx$ewwyqtxmsrw$sv$gsrhmxmsrw2$Mj$egxyep$viwypxw$wmkrmjmgerxp}$hmjjiv$jvsq$syv

iwxmqexiw0$syv$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$gsyph$fi$qexivmepp}$mqtegxih2

Sxliv$wmkrmjmgerx$eggsyrxmrk$tspmgmiw0$tvmqevmp}$xlswi${mxl$ps{iv$pizipw$sj$yrgivxemrx}$xler$xlswi$hmwgywwih$fips{0$evi$epws

gvmxmgep$xs$yrhivwxerhmrk$syv$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw2$Xli$rsxiw$xs$syv$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$gsrxemr$ehhmxmsrep

mrjsvqexmsr$vipexih$xs$syv$eggsyrxmrk$tspmgmiw$erh$wlsyph$fi$vieh$mr$gsrnyrgxmsr${mxl$xlmw$hmwgywwmsr2

Viziryi$Vigskrmxmsr

$$$$$$$$$

Sr$Neryev}$50$645<0${i$ehstxih$Eggsyrxmrk$Wxerhevhw$Gshmjmgexmsr$,&EWG&-$Xstmg$:4:0$&Viziryi$jvsq$Gsrxvegxw${mxl$Gywxsqivw&

ywmrk$xli$qshmjmih$vixvswtigxmzi$qixlsh$ettpmih$xs$xlswi$gsrxvegxw$xlex${ivi$rsx$gsqtpixih$ew$sj$Neryev}$50$645<2$Xli$ehstxmsr$sj$xlmw

wxerhevh$hmh$rsx$viwypx$mr$e$wmkrmjmgerx$glerki$xs$syv$lmwxsvmgep$viziryi$vigskrmxmsr$tspmgmiw$erh$xlivi${ivi$rs$wmkrmjmgerx$ehnywxqirxw

xlex$viuymvih$e$gyqypexmzi$ehnywxqirx$xs$vixemrih$ievrmrkw$ytsr$xverwmxmsr2

8:

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 70 of 253

Page 93: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq ;4367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Viziryi$mw$vigskrm~ih${lir$gsrxvsp$sj$xli$tvsqmwih$ksshw$sv$wivzmgiw$mw$xverwjivvih$xs$syv$gywxsqivw0$mr$er$eqsyrx$xlex$vijpigxw$xli

gsrwmhivexmsr${i$i|tigx$xs$fi$irxmxpih$xs$mr$i|glerki$jsv$xlswi$ksshw$sv$wivzmgiw2$Wepiw0$zepyi$ehhih$erh$sxliv$xe|iw$xlex${i$gsppigx

gsrgyvvirx${mxl$viziryi$tvshygmrk$egxmzmxmiw$erh$xlex$evi$wyfwiuyirxp}$viqmxxih$xs$kszivrqirxep$eyxlsvmxmiw$evi$i|gpyhih$jvsq

viziryiw2$$Xli$kymhergi$hmwxmrkymwliw$fix{iir$ksshw$erh$wivzmgiw2$Xli$hijmrmxmsr$sj$wivzmgiw$yrhiv$xli$kymhergi$mrgpyhiw$iziv}xlmrk

sxliv$xler$ksshw2$Ew$wygl0$mr$syv$gewi0$xlmw$kymhergi$zmi{w$xli$tvszmwmsr$sj$lsywmrk$ew$e$wivzmgi2

[lir$e$gsrxvegx$mrgpyhiw$zevmefpi$gsrwmhivexmsr0${i$hixivqmri$er$iwxmqexi$sj$xli$zevmefpi$gsrwmhivexmsr$erh$izepyexi${lixliv$xli

iwxmqexi$riihw$xs$fi$gsrwxvemrih?$xlivijsvi0${i$mrgpyhi$xli$zevmefpi$gsrwmhivexmsr$mr$xli$xverwegxmsr$tvmgi$srp}$xs$xli$i|xirx$xlex$mx$mw

tvsfefpi$xlex$e$wmkrmjmgerx$vizivwep$sj$xli$eqsyrx$sj$gyqypexmzi$viziryi$vigskrm~ih${mpp$rsx$sggyv${lir$xli$yrgivxemrx}$ewwsgmexih${mxl

xli$zevmefpi$gsrwmhivexmsr$mw$wyfwiuyirxp}$viwspzih2$Zevmefpi$gsrwmhivexmsr$iwxmqexiw$evi$ythexih$ex$iegl$vitsvxmrk$hexi2$E$pmqmxih

ryqfiv$sj$syv$hsqiwxmg$gsrxvegxw$lezi$tvszmwmsrw$ytsr${lmgl$e$wqepp$tsvxmsr$sj$xli$viziryi$jsv$xli$gsrxvegx$mw$fewih$sr$xli

tivjsvqergi$sj$givxemr$xevkixw2$Hsqiwxmgepp}0$viziryi$fewih$sr$xli$tivjsvqergi$sj$givxemr$xevkixw$mw$piww$xler$5)$sj$syv$gsrwspmhexih

hsqiwxmg$viziryiw$erh${ew$rsx$wmkrmjmgerx$hyvmrk$xli$tivmshw$tviwirxih2$Sri$sj$syv$mrxivrexmsrep$gsrxvegxw0$vipexih$xs$syv$Vezirlepp

gsvvigxmsrep$jegmpmx}$tvsnigx$,hmwgywwih$jyvxliv$fips{-0$gsrxemrw$e$tvszmwmsr${livi$e$wmkrmjmgerx$tsvxmsr$sj$xli$viziryi$jsv$xli$gsrxvegx$mw

fewih$sr$xli$tivjsvqergi$sj$givxemr$xevkixw2$Xliwi$tivjsvqergi$xevkixw$evi$fewih$sr$wtigmjmg$gvmxivme$xs$fi$qix$sziv$wtigmjmg$tivmshw$sj

xmqi2$Wygl$gvmxivme$mrgpyhiw$syv$efmpmx}$xs$eglmizi$givxemr$gsrxvegxyep$firglqevow$vipexmzi$xs$xli$uyepmx}$sj$wivzmgi${i$tvszmhi0$rsr1

sggyvvirgi$sj$givxemr$hmwvytxmzi$izirxw0$ijjigxmziriww$sj$syv$uyepmx}$gsrxvsp$tvskveqw$erh$syv$viwtsrwmziriww$xs$gywxsqiv$viuymviqirxw2

Xli$tivjsvqergi$sj$xliwi$xevkixw$evi$qiewyvih$uyevxivp}$erh$xlivi${ew$rs$wmkrmjmgerx$gsrwxvemrx$sr$xli$iwxmqexi$sj$wygl$zevmefpi

gsrwmhivexmsr$jsv$xlmw$gsrxvegx$hyvmrk$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=$sv$645<2

[i$hs$rsx$hmwgpswi$xli$zepyi$sj$yrwexmwjmih$tivjsvqergi$sfpmkexmsrw$jsv$,m-$gsrxvegxw${mxl$er$i|tigxih$pirkxl$sj$sri$}iev$sv$piww$erh$,mm-

gsrxvegxw$jsv${lmgl$viziryi$mw$vigskrm~ih$ex$xli$eqsyrx$xs${lmgl${i$lezi$xli$vmklx$xs$mrzsmgi$jsv$wivzmgiw$tivjsvqih0${lmgl$mw

kirivepp}$xli$gewi$jsv$epp$sj$syv$gsrxvegxw2$Mrgmhirxep$mxiqw$xlex$evi$mqqexivmep$mr$xli$gsrxi|x$sj$xli$gsrxvegx$evi$vigskrm~ih$ew$i|tirwi2

[i$kirivepp}$hs$rsx$mrgyv$mrgviqirxep$gswxw$vipexih$xs$sfxemrmrk$e$gsrxvegx${mxl$syv$gywxsqivw$xlex${syph$qiix$xli$viuymviqirx$jsv

getmxepm~exmsr2$Xlivi${ivi$rs$ewwixw$vigskrm~ih$jvsq$gswxw$xs$sfxemr$e$gsrxvegx${mxl$e$gywxsqiv$ex$Higiqfiv$750$645=$sv$645<2

Xli$xmqmrk$sj$viziryi$vigskrmxmsr$qe}$hmjjiv$jvsq$xli$xmqmrk$sj$mrzsmgmrk$xs$gywxsqivw2$[i$vigsvh$e$vigimzefpi${lir$wivzmgiw$evi

tivjsvqih${lmgl$evi$hyi$jvsq$syv$gywxsqivw$fewih$sr$xli$tewweki$sj$xmqi2$[i$vigsvh$e$gsrxvegx$pmefmpmx}$mj$gsrwmhivexmsr$mw$vigimzih$mr

ehzergi$sj$xli$tivjsvqergi$sj$wivzmgiw2$Kirivepp}0$syv$gywxsqivw$hs$rsx$tvszmhi$te}qirx$mr$ehzergi$sj$xli$tivjsvqergi$sj$wivzmgiw2

Xlivijsvi0$er}$gsrxvegx$pmefmpmx}$mw$rsx$wmkrmjmgerx$ex$Higiqfiv$750$645=$sv$Higiqfiv$750$645<$erh$viziryi$vigskrm~ih$hyvmrk$xli

}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$645<$xlex${ew$mrgpyhih$mr$xli$stirmrk$fepergi$sj$yrievrih$viziryi${ew$rsx$wmkrmjmgerx2$Xlivi

lezi$fiir$rs$wmkrmjmgerx$eqsyrxw$sj$viziryi$vigsvhih$mr$xli$tivmshw$tviwirxih$jvsq$tivjsvqergi$sfpmkexmsrw$imxliv${lspp}$sv$tevxmepp}

wexmwjmih$mr$tvmsv$tivmshw2

Xli$vmklx$xs$gsrwmhivexmsr$yrhiv$syv$gsrxvegxw$mw$srp}$hitirhirx$sr$xli$tewweki$sj$xmqi$erh$mw$xlivijsvi$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$yrgsrhmxmsrep2

Te}qirx$xivqw$erh$gsrhmxmsrw$zev}$f}$gsrxvegx$x}ti0$epxlsykl0${mxl$xli$i|gitxmsr$sj$xli$gsrxvegx$vigimzefpi$vipexih$xs$syv$Vezirlepp

gsvvigxmsrep$jegmpmx}$,jyvxliv$hmwgywwih$fips{-0$xivqw$kirivepp}$mrgpyhi$e$viuymviqirx$sj$te}qirx${mxlmr$74$he}w$ejxiv$tivjsvqergi

sfpmkexmsrw$evi$wexmwjmih$erh$kirivepp}$hs$rsx$mrgpyhi$e$wmkrmjmgerx$jmrergmrk$gsqtsrirx2$Xlivi$lezi$fiir$rs$wmkrmjmgerx$glerkiw$mr

vigimzefpi$sv$yrievrih$viziryi$fepergiw$hyvmrk$xli$tivmsh$sxliv$xler$vikypev$mrzsmgmrk$erh$gsppigxmsr$egxmzmx}2

$

S{rih$erh$Piewih$1$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw

[i$vigskrm~i$viziryi$jsv$wigyvi$wivzmgiw${livi${i$s{r$sv$piewi$xli$jegmpmx}$ew$wivzmgiw$evi$tivjsvqih2$[i$tvszmhi$jsv$xli$weji$erh

wigyvi$lsywmrk$erh$gevi$sj$mrgevgivexih$mrhmzmhyepw$yrhiv$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw${mxl$jihivep0$wxexi$erh$psgep$kszivrqirx$ekirgmiw2

Xlmw$mrgpyhiw$tvszmhmrk$681lsyv$gevi$erh$wytivzmwmsr0$mrgpyhmrk$fyx$rsx$pmqmxih$xs0$wygl$wivzmgiw$ew$qihmgep0$xverwtsvxexmsr0$jssh

wivzmgi0$peyrhv}$wivzmgiw$erh$zevmsyw$tvskveqqmrk$egxmzmxmiw2$Xliwi$xewow$evi$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$egxmzmxmiw$xs$jypjmpp$xli$weji$erh$wigyvi

lsywmrk$tivjsvqergi$sfpmkexmsr$erh$evi$rsx$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$mrhmzmhyepp}$witevexi$tvsqmwiw$mr$xli$gsrxvegx2$Iegl$sj$xliwi$egxmzmxmiw$mw

lmklp}$mrxivvipexih$erh${i$tivjsvq$e$wmkrmjmgerx$pizip$sj$mrxikvexmsr$sj$xliwi$egxmzmxmiw2$[i$lezi$mhirxmjmih$xliwi$egxmzmxmiw$ew$e$fyrhpi$sj

wivzmgiw$erh$hixivqmrih$xlex$iegl$he}$sj$xli$tvsqmwih$wivzmgi$mw$hmwxmrgx2$Xli$wivzmgiw$tvszmhih$evi$tevx$sj$e$wivmiw$sj$hmwxmrgx$wivzmgiw

xlex$evi$wyfwxerxmepp}$xli$weqi$erh$evi$qiewyvih$ywmrk$xli$weqi$qiewyvi$sj$tvskviww$,xmqi1fewih$syxtyx$qixlsh-2$[i$lezi$hixivqmrih

xlex$viziryi$jsv$xliwi$wivzmgiw$evi$vigskrm~ih$sziv$xmqi$ew$syv$gywxsqivw$wmqypxerisywp}$vigimzi$erh$gsrwyqi$xli$firijmxw$ew$xli

wivzmgiw$evi$tivjsvqih0${lmgl$mw$sr$e$gsrxmryep$hemp}$fewmw0$erh${i$lezi$e$vmklx$xs$te}qirx$jsv$tivjsvqergi$gsqtpixih$xs$hexi2$Xmqi1

fewih$syxtyx$qixlshw$sj$viziryi

8;

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 71 of 253

Page 94: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq ;5367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

vigskrmxmsr$evi$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$e$jemxljyp$hitmgxmsr$sj$syv$ijjsvxw$xs$jypjmpp$syv$sfpmkexmsrw$yrhiv$syv$gsrxvegxw$erh$xlivijsvi$vijpigx$xli

xverwjiv$sj$wivzmgiw$xs$syv$gywxsqivw2$Syv$gywxsqivw$kirivepp}$te}$jsv$xliwi$wivzmgiw$fewih$sr$e$rix$vexi$tiv$he}$tiv$mrhmzmhyep$sv$sr$e

jm|ih$qsrxlp}$vexi2

S{rih$erh$Piewih$1$Gsqqyrmx}1fewih

[i$vigskrm~i$viziryi$jsv$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$viirxv}$wivzmgiw${livi${i$s{r$sv$piewi$xli$jegmpmx}$mr$e$qerriv$wmqmpev$xs$syv$wigyvi

wivzmgiw$hmwgywwih$efszi2$[i$tvszmhi$mrhmzmhyepw$rievmrk$xli$irh$sj$xlimv$wirxirgi${mxl$xli$viwsyvgiw$rigiwwev}$xs$tvshygxmzip}

xverwmxmsr$fego$mrxs$wsgmix}2$Xlvsykl$syv$viwmhirxmep$viirxv}$girxivw0${i$tvszmhi$jihivep$erh$wxexi$tevspiiw$erh$tvsfexmsrivw${mxl

xiqtsvev}$lsywmrk0$vilefmpmxexmsr0$wyfwxergi$efywi$gsyrwipmrk$erh$zsgexmsrep$erh$ihygexmsrep$tvskveqw2$Xliwi$egxmzmxmiw$evi

gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$e$fyrhpi$sj$wivzmgiw${lmgl$evi$e$tevx$sj$e$wivmiw$sj$hmwxmrgx$wivzmgiw$vigskrm~ih$sziv$xmqi$fewih$sr$xli$weqi$gvmxivme$ew

hmwgywwih$efszi$jsv$wigyvi$wivzmgiw$viziryiw2$Syv$gywxsqivw$epws$kirivepp}$te}$jsv$xliwi$wivzmgiw$fewih$sr$e$rix$vexi$tiv$he}$tiv

mrhmzmhyep$sv$sr$e$jm|ih$qsrxlp}$vexi2

S{rih$erh$Piewih$1$]syxl$Wivzmgiw

[i$vigskrm~i$viziryiw$jsv$}syxl$wivzmgiw${livi${i$s{r$sv$piewi$xli$jegmpmx}$mr$xli$weqi$qerriv$ew$hmwgywwih$efszi$jsv$xli$lsywmrk0

wytivzmwmsr0$gevi$erh$vilefmpmxexmsr$sj$xvsyfpih$}syxl$viwmhirxw2$Xli$egxmzmxmiw$xs$lsywi$erh$gevi$jsv$xvsyfpih$}syxl$viwmhirxw$evi$epws

gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$e$fyrhpi$sj$wivzmgiw${lmgl$evi$tevx$sj$e$wivmiw$sj$hmwxmrgx$wivzmgiw$vigskrm~ih$sziv$xmqi$fewih$sr$xli$weqi$gvmxivme

hmwgywwih$jsv$xli$tvizmsyw$x{s$viziryi$wxvieqw2$Syv$gywxsqivw$kirivepp}$te}$jsv$xliwi$wivzmgiw$fewih$sr$e$rix$vexi$tiv$he}$tiv

mrhmzmhyep2

Qerekih$Srp}

[i$vigskrm~i$viziryi$jsv$syv$qerekih$srp}$gsrxvegxw$mr$xli$weqi$qerriv$ew$syv$S{rih$erh$Piewih$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$erh$S{rih$erh

Piewih$Gsqqyrmx}1fewih$gsrxvegxw$ew$hmwgywwih$efszi2$Xli$tvmqev}$i|gitxmsr$mw$xlex${i$hs$rsx$s{r$sv$piewi$xli$jegmpmx}2$Xli$jegmpmx}

mw$s{rih$f}$xli$gywxsqiv2$Mr$givxemr$gmvgyqwxergiw0$syv$gywxsqivw$qe}$viuyiwx$xlex${i$qeoi$givxemr$getmxep$mqtvsziqirxw$xs$xli

jegmpmx}$sv$qeoi$sxliv$te}qirxw$vipexih$xs$xli$jegmpmx}2$Xliwi$te}qirxw$evi$eqsvxm~ih$ew$e$vihygxmsr$sj$viziryiw$sziv$xli$pmji$sj$xli

gsrxvegx2$Syv$gywxsqivw$kirivepp}$te}$jsv$xliwi$wivzmgiw$fewih$sr$e$rix$vexi$tiv$he}$tiv$mrhmzmhyep$sv$e$jm|ih$qsrxlp}$vexi2

Jegmpmx}$Gsrwxvygxmsr$erh$Hiwmkr

Jegmpmx}$Gsrwxvygxmsr$erh$Hiwmkr$viziryiw$hyvmrk$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645;$gsrwmwxih$sj$sri$gsrxvegx${mxl$xli$Hitevxqirx$sj

Nywxmgi$mr$xli$Wxexi$sj$Zmgxsvme$,xli$ÔWxexiÕ-$jsv$xli$hizipstqirx$erh$stivexmsr$sj$e$ri{$507441fih$wigyvi$jegmpmx}$,xli$ÔJegmpmx}Õ-$mr

Vezirlepp0$e$psgepmx}$riev$Qipfsyvri0$Eywxvepme2$Xli$Jegmpmx}${ew$gsqtpixih$hyvmrk$xli$jsyvxl$uyevxiv$sj$645;$erh${i$evi$gyvvirxp}

qerekmrk$xli$Jegmpmx}$yrhiv$e$691}iev$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegx2$Xlivi${ivi$rs$jegmpmx}$gsrwxvygxmsr$erh$hiwmkr$viziryiw$vipexih$xs$xli

jegmpmx}$hyvmrk$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=$sv$645<2$Syv$tvsqmwi$xs$hiwmkr$erh$gsrwxvygx$xli$Jegmpmx}${ew$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$e

witevexi$erh$hmwxmrgx$tivjsvqergi$sfpmkexmsr$jvsq$xli$qerekiqirx$sfpmkexmsr${lmgl$mrgpyhiw$xli$weji$erh$wigyvi$lsywmrk0$gevi$erh

tvskveqqmrk$egxmzmxmiw$jsv$mrgevgivexih$mrhmzmhyepw$wmqmpev$xs$xli$wigyvi$wivzmgiw$hmwgywwih$efszi2$Jsv$xli$sfpmkexmsr$xs$qereki$xli

Jegmpmx}0${i$lezi$hixivqmrih$xlex$viziryi$wlsyph$fi$vigsvhih$sziv$xmqi$ywmrk$e$xmqi1fewih$syxtyx$qixlsh$fewih$sr$xli$weqi$gvmxivme$ew

hmwgywwih$efszi$jsv$gsvvigxmsr$erh$hixirxmsr$wivzmgiw2$Jiiw$mrgpyhih$erh$tvmgih$mr$xli$gsrxvegx$jsv$qerekmrk$xli$Jegmpmx}$evi$gsrwmhivih

xs$fi$wxexih$ex$xlimv$mrhmzmhyep$iwxmqexih$wxerh1epsri$wippmrk$tvmgiw$ywmrk$xli$ehnywxih$qevoix$ewwiwwqirx$ettvsegl2$Xliwi$wivzmgiw$evi

vikypevp}$tvszmhih$f}$yw$sr$e$wxerh1epsri$fewmw$xs$wmqmpev$gywxsqivw${mxlmr$e$wmqmpev$verki$sj$eqsyrxw2$[i$ywih$xli$i|tigxih$gswx$tpyw

qevkmr$ettvsegl$xs$eppsgexi$xli$xverwegxmsr$tvmgi$xs$xli$gsrwxvygxmsr$sfpmkexmsr2$[i${ivi$irxmxpih$yrhiv$xli$gsrxvegx$xs$vigimzi

gsrwmhivexmsr$mr$xli$eqsyrx$sj$syv$gswxw$tpyw$e$qevkmr2

Hyvmrk$xli$hiwmkr$erh$gsrwxvygxmsr$tlewi0${i$hixivqmrih$xlex$viziryi$wlsyph$fi$vigsvhih$sziv$xmqi$erh$ettpmih$gswx$fewih$mrtyx

qixlshw$ywmrk$xli$egxyep$gswxw$mrgyvvih$vipexmzi$xs$xli$xsxep$iwxmqexih$gswxw$,tivgirxeki$sj$gsqtpixmsr$fewmw-$xs$hixivqmri$tvskviww

xs{evhw$gsrxvegx$gsqtpixmsr$erh$xs$gepgypexi$xli$gsvviwtsrhmrk$eqsyrx$sj$viziryi$erh$kvsww$tvsjmx$xs$vigskrm~i2$Gswx$fewih$mrtyx

qixlshw$sj$viziryi$vigskrmxmsr$evi$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$e$jemxljyp$hitmgxmsr$sj$syv$ijjsvxw$xs$wexmwj}$psrk1xivq$gsrwxvygxmsr$gsrxvegxw$erh

xlivijsvi$vijpigx$xli$xverwjiv$sj$ksshw$xs$xli$gywxsqiv$ew$xli$gywxsqiv$gsrxvspw$xli${svo$mr$tvskviww$ew$xli$Jegmpmx}$mw$gsrwxvygxih2$Gswx

fewih$mrtyx$qixlshw$sj$viziryi$vigskrmxmsr$epws$viuymvi$yw$xs$qeoi$iwxmqexiw$sj$rix$gsrxvegx$viziryiw$erh$gswxw$xs$gsqtpixi$xli

tvsnigx2$Wmkrmjmgerx$nyhkqirx${ew$viuymvih$xs$izepyexi$xli$gswxw$xs$gsqtpixi$xli$tvsnigx0$mrgpyhmrk$qexivmepw0$pefsv0$gsrxmrkirgmiw$erh

sxliv$gswxw2$Mj$iwxmqexih$xsxep$gswxw$sr$xli$gsrxvegx$evi$kviexiv$xler$xli$rix$gsrxvegx$viziryiw0$xli$irxmvi$iwxmqexih$psww$sr$xli$gsrxvegx$mw

vigskrm~ih$mr$xli$tivmsh$xli$psww$figsqiw$ors{r2$Xli$gyqypexmzi$ijjigx$sj$vizmwmsrw$xs$iwxmqexiw$vipexih$xs$rix$gsrxvegx$viziryiw$sv

gswxw$xs$gsqtpixi$evi$vigsvhih$mr$xli$tivmsh$mr${lmgl$xli$vizmwmsrw$xs$iwxmqexiw$evi$mhirxmjmih$erh$xli$eqsyrxw$ger$fi$viewsrefp}

iwxmqexih2$X}tmgepp}0${i$irxiv$mrxs$jm|ih$tvmgi$gsrxvegxw$erh$hs$rsx

8<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 72 of 253

Page 95: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq ;6367<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 73 of 253

Page 96: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq ;7367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

tivjsvq$ehhmxmsrep${svo$yrpiww$ettvszih$glerki$svhivw$evi$mr$tpegi2$Gswxw$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$yrettvszih$glerki$svhivw$evi$i|tirwih$mr

xli$tivmsh$mr${lmgl$xli$gswxw$evi$mrgyvvih$mj${i$fipmizi$xlex$mx$mw$rsx$tvsfefpi$xlex$xli$gswxw${mpp$fi$vigszivih$xlvsykl$e$glerki$mr$xli

gsrxvegx$tvmgi2$Mj${i$fipmizi$xlex$mx$mw$tvsfefpi$xlex$xli$gswxw${mpp$fi$vigszivih$xlvsykl$e$glerki$mr$xli$gsrxvegx$tvmgi0$gswxw$vipexih$xs

yrettvszih$glerki$svhivw$evi$i|tirwih$mr$xli$tivmsh$mr${lmgl$xli}$evi$mrgyvvih0$erh$gsrxvegx$viziryi$mw$vigskrm~ih$xs$xli$i|xirx$sj$xli

gswxw$mrgyvvih2$Viziryi$mr$i|giww$sj$xli$gswxw$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$yrettvszih$glerki$svhivw$mw$rsx$vigskrm~ih$yrxmp$xli$glerki$svhiv$mw

ettvszih2$Glerkiw$mr$nsf$tivjsvqergi0$nsf$gsrhmxmsrw0$erh$iwxmqexih$tvsjmxefmpmx}0$mrgpyhmrk$xlswi$evmwmrk$jvsq$gsrxvegx$tirepx}

tvszmwmsrw0$erh$jmrep$gsrxvegx$wixxpiqirxw0$qe}$viwypx$mr$vizmwmsrw$xs$iwxmqexih$gswxw$erh$mrgsqi0$erh$evi$vigskrm~ih$mr$xli$tivmsh$mr

{lmgl$xli$vizmwmsrw$evi$hixivqmrih2$Jsv$xli$tivmshw$tviwirxih0$xlivi${ivi$rs$glerkiw$mr$nsf$tivjsvqergi0$nsf$gsrhmxmsrw$erh$iwxmqexih

tvsjmxefmpmx}$xlex$viuymvih$e$vizmwmsr$xs$xli$iwxmqexih$gswxw$erh$mrgsqi$vigsvhih2

[i${ivi$xli$tvmqev}$hizipstiv$sj$xli$tvsnigx$erh$wyfgsrxvegxih${mxl$e$fsrhih$mrxivrexmsrep$hiwmkr$erh$fymph$gsrxvegxsv$xs$hiwmkr$erh

gsrwxvygx$xli$Jegmpmx}2$Ew$xli$tvmqev}$gsrxvegxsv$jsv$xli$tvsnigx0${i$hixivqmrih$xlex${i${ivi$tvmqevmp}$viwtsrwmfpi$jsv$jypjmppmrk$xli

tvsqmwi$xs$hizipst$erh$tvszmhi$xli$Jegmpmx}$xs$xli$Wxexi0$mrgpyhmrk$szivepp$viwtsrwmfmpmx}$jsv$xli$eggitxefmpmx}$sj$xli$tvsnigx$mr$qiixmrk

xli$Wxexi+w$wtigmjmgexmsrw2$Xlivijsvi0${i${ivi$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$e$tvmrgmtep$mr$xli$xverwegxmsr$erh$gsrwxvygxmsr$viziryiw$erh$gsrwxvygxmsr

gswxw${ivi$vigsvhih$sr$e$kvsww$fewmw2

Xli$gswx$sj$xli$tvsnigx$hyvmrk$xli$hiwmkr$erh$gsrwxvygxmsr$tlewi${ew$jyrhih$f}$hifx$jmrergmrk$epsrk${mxl$e$getmxep$gsrxvmfyxmsr$f}$yw

{lmgl${ew$qehi$mr$Neryev}$645;2$Syv$tvsqmwi$xs$tvszmhi$xli$iuymx}$gsrxvmfyxmsr${ew$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$e$witevexi$erh$hmwxmrgx

tivjsvqergi$sfpmkexmsr$xlex$mw$witevexi$jvsq$xli$gsrwxvygxmsr$erh$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$sfpmkexmsrw2$Xli$gsrxvmfyxmsr$vitviwirxw$e

wmkrmjmgerx$jmrergmrk$ipiqirx${lmgl$tvszmhih$e$firijmx$xs$xli$Wxexi2$Gswxw$mrgyvvih$erh$iwxmqexih$ievrmrkw$mr$i|giww$sj$fmppmrkw${ivi

gpewwmjmih$ew$gsrxvegx$vigimzefpi$mr$xli$eggsqter}mrk$gsrwspmhexih$fepergi$wliixw2$Xli$gsrxvegx$vigimzefpi${ew$tevxmepp}$wexmwjmih

xlvsykl$e$Wxexi$gsrxvmfyxmsr0${lmgl${ew$qehi$mr$Rsziqfiv$645;$ytsr$gsqqivgmep$eggitxergi$sj$xli$Jegmpmx}0$erh$f}$uyevxivp}

te}qirxw$xs$fi$qehi$sziv$xli$691}iev$stivexmrk$tlewi2$Xli$xmqmrk$sj$xliwi$te}qirxw$tvszmhi$xli$Wxexi${mxl$e$wmkrmjmgerx$firijmx$sj

jmrergmrk$jsv$xli$Jegmpmx}$ew$xli$te}qirxw$f}$xli$Wxexi$sggyv$wmkrmjmgerxp}$ejxiv$tivjsvqergi$,gsrwxvygxmsr$sj$xli$Jegmpmx}-2$Xlivijsvi0

xli$gsrxvegx$vigimzefpi$lew$fiir$vigsvhih$ex$rix$tviwirx$zepyi$fewih$sr$xli$xmqmrk$sj$i|tigxih$jyxyvi$wixxpiqirx2$Mrxiviwx$mrgsqi$mw

gepgypexih$ywmrk$er$ijjigxmzi$mrxiviwx$vexi$sj$<2=;)$erh$lew$fiir$tviwirxih$witevexip}$jvsq$jegmpmx}$hiwmkr$erh$gsrwxvygxmsr$viziryi2

Mrxiviwx$mrgsqi$epws$mrgpyhiw$er$iuymx}$vixyvr$jsv$syv$getmxep$gsrxvmfyxmsr2

Hyvmrk$645<$erh$645=0${i$leh$jegmpmx}$gsrwxvygxmsr$*$hiwmkr$wivzmgiw$vipexih$xs$er$i|terwmsr$tvsnigx$ex$syv$Jypleq$Gsvvigxmsrep

Girxvi$mr$Eywxvepme${lmgl$mw$i|tigxih$xs$fi$gsqtpixih$mr$xli$xlmvh$uyevxiv$sj$64642$Viziryiw$lezi$fiir$vigsvhih$yrhiv$xli$weqi

qixlshspsk}$ew$hmwgywwih$efszi2

Rsr1viwmhirxmep$Wivzmgiw$erh$Sxliv

Rsr1viwmhirxmep$Wivzmgiw$erh$Sxliv$viziryi$gsrwmwxw$sj$syv$gsrxvegxw${mxl$jihivep$erh$zevmsyw$wxexi$erh$psgep$kszivrqirxw$xs$tvszmhi

psgexmsr0$epgslsp$erh$hvyk$hixigxmrk$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$erh$gewi$qerekiqirx$wivzmgiw$xs$mrhmzmhyepw$sr$er$ew$riihih$sv$ew$viuyiwxih

fewmw2$Xlmw$gexiksv}$epws$mrgpyhiw$syv$he}$vitsvxmrk$girxivw2

[i$vigskrm~i$viziryiw$jsv$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$erh$gewi$qerekiqirx$wivzmgiw$ew$xli$wivzmgiw$evi$tivjsvqih2$Wivzmgiw$tvszmhih

gsrwmwx$sj$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$wytivzmwmsr$,lsqi$zmwmxw-0$mr1tivwsr$vitsvxmrk0$xipitlsrmg$vitsvxmrk$erh$KTW$erh$sxliv$ipigxsrmg

qsrmxsvmrk$ew${ipp$ew$szivepp$gsrxvegx$qerekiqirx$wivzmgiw2$Xli$vexiw$jsv$xli$zevmsyw$wivzmgiw$evi$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$wxexih$ex$xlimv

mrhmzmhyep$wxerh1epsri$wippmrk$tvmgiw2$[i$lezi$hixivqmrih$xlex$xli$wivzmgiw$xs$fi$tvszmhih$evi$vigskrm~ih$sziv$xmqi$fewih$sr$xli$yrmx$sj

sggyvvirgi$sj$xli$zevmsyw$wivzmgiw$ew$syv$gywxsqiv$wmqypxerisywp}$vigimziw$erh$gsrwyqiw$xli$firijmxw$ew$xli$wivzmgiw$evi$tivjsvqih

erh${i$lezi$e$vmklx$xs$te}qirx$jsv$tivjsvqergi$gsqtpixih$xs$hexi2$Kirivepp}0$xliwi$wivzmgiw$evi$temh$fewih$sr$e$rix$vexi$tiv

sggyvvirgi$erh$e$qsrxlp}$jii$jsv$qerekiqirx$wivzmgiw2

Givxemr$sj$syv$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$gsrxvegxw$mrgpyhi$tvszmhmrk$qsrmxsvmrk$iuymtqirx$erh$vipexih$qsrmxsvmrk$wivzmgiw$egxmzmxmiw$,ywmrk

mrxivrep$tvstvmixev}$wsjx{evi$tpexjsvqw-$xs$syv$gywxsqivw2$Xliwi$xewow$evi$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$egxmzmxmiw$xs$jypjmpp$xli$tvsqmwi$xs$tvszmhi

ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$wivzmgiw$xs$mrhmzmhyepw$erh$evi$rsx$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$mrhmzmhyepp}$witevexi$tvsqmwiw$mr$xli$gsrxvegx2$Mr$xli$gsrxi|x

sj$xli$gsrxvegx0$xli$iuymtqirx$erh$qsrmxsvmrk$wivzmgi$mw$rsx$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$getefpi$sj$fimrk$hmwxmrgx$ew$xli$gywxsqiv$x}tmgepp}$gerrsx

firijmx$jvsq$xli$iuymtqirx$sv$qsrmxsvmrk$wivzmgi$sr$mxw$s{r$sv${mxl$sxliv$viehmp}$ezempefpi$viwsyvgiw2$[i$lezi$mhirxmjmih$xliwi

egxmzmxmiw$ew$e$fyrhpi$sj$wivzmgiw$erh$hixivqmrih$xlex$iegl$he}$sv$yrmx$sj$xli$tvsqmwih$wivzmgi$mw$hmwxmrgx2$Xliwi$wivzmgiw$evi$tevx$sj$e

wivmiw$sj$hmwxmrgx$wivzmgiw$xlex$evi$wyfwxerxmepp}$xli$weqi$erh$evi$qiewyvih$ywmrk$xli$weqi$qiewyvi$sj$tvskviww$,xmqi1fewih$syxtyx

qixlsh-$erh$evi$xlivijsvi$eggsyrxih$jsv$ew$e$wmrkpi$tivjsvqergi$sfpmkexmsr2$[i$lezi$hixivqmrih$xlex$wivzmgiw$evi$vigskrm~ih$sziv$xmqi

ew$xli$gywxsqiv$wmqypxerisywp}$vigimziw$erh$gsrwyqiw$xli$firijmxw$ew$xli$wivzmgiw$evi$tivjsvqih$erh${i$lezi$e$vmklx$xs$te}qirx$jsv

tivjsvqergi$gsqtpixih$xs$hexi2

8=

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 74 of 253

Page 97: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq ;8367<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 75 of 253

Page 98: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq ;9367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Wivzmgiw$tvszmhih$jsv$syv$he}$vitsvxmrk$girxivw$evi$wmqmpev$xs$syv$S{rih$erh$Piewih$Gsqqyrmx}1fewih$wivzmgiw$hmwgywwih$efszi${mxl

xli$i|gitxmsr$sj$xiqtsvev}$lsywmrk2

Viwivziw$jsv$Mrwyvergi$Pswwiw

Xli$rexyvi$sj$syv$fywmriww$i|tswiw$yw$xs$zevmsyw$x}tiw$sj$xlmvh1tevx}$pikep$gpemqw0$mrgpyhmrk0$fyx$rsx$pmqmxih$xs0$gmzmp$vmklxw$gpemqw

vipexmrk$xs$gsrhmxmsrw$sj$gsrjmriqirx$erh3sv$qmwxviexqirx0$wi|yep$qmwgsrhygx$gpemqw$fvsyklx$f}$tvmwsrivw$sv$hixemriiw0$tvshygx

pmefmpmx}$gpemqw0$mrxippigxyep$tvstivx}$mrjvmrkiqirx$gpemqw0$gpemqw$vipexmrk$xs$iqtps}qirx$qexxivw$,mrgpyhmrk0$fyx$rsx$pmqmxih$xs0

iqtps}qirx$hmwgvmqmrexmsr$gpemqw0$yrmsr$kvmizergiw$erh${eki$erh$lsyv$gpemqw-0$tvstivx}$psww$gpemqw0$irzmvsrqirxep$gpemqw0

eyxsqsfmpi$pmefmpmx}$gpemqw0$gsrxvegxyep$gpemqw$erh$gpemqw$jsv$tivwsrep$mrnyv}$sv$sxliv$heqekiw$viwypxmrk$jvsq$gsrxegx${mxl$syv

jegmpmxmiw0$tvskveqw0$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$tvshygxw0$tivwsrrip$sv$tvmwsrivw0$mrgpyhmrk$heqekiw$evmwmrk$jvsq$e$tvmwsriv×w$iwgeti$sv$jvsq

e$hmwxyvfergi$sv$vmsx$ex$e$jegmpmx}2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$syv$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$kirivepp}$viuymvi$yw$xs$mrhiqrmj}$xli$kszivrqirxep$ekirg}

ekemrwx$er}$heqekiw$xs${lmgl$xli$kszivrqirxep$ekirg}$qe}$fi$wyfnigx$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$wygl$gpemqw$sv$pmxmkexmsr2$[i$qemrxemr$e

fvseh$tvskveq$sj$mrwyvergi$gsziveki$jsv$xliwi$kirivep$x}tiw$sj$gpemqw0$i|gitx$jsv$gpemqw$vipexmrk$xs$iqtps}qirx$qexxivw0$jsv${lmgl${i

gevv}$rs$mrwyvergi2$Xlivi$ger$fi$rs$ewwyvergi$xlex$syv$mrwyvergi$gsziveki${mpp$fi$ehiuyexi$xs$gsziv$epp$gpemqw$xs${lmgl${i$qe}$fi

i|tswih2$Mx$mw$syv$kirivep$tvegxmgi$xs$fvmrk$qivkih$sv$eguymvih$gsqtermiw$mrxs$syv$gsvtsvexi$qewxiv$tspmgmiw$mr$svhiv$xs$xeoi$ehzerxeki

sj$givxemr$igsrsqmiw$sj$wgepi2

[i$gyvvirxp}$qemrxemr$e$kirivep$pmefmpmx}$tspmg}$erh$i|giww$pmefmpmx}$tspmgmiw${mxl$xsxep$pmqmxw$sj$(<424$qmppmsr$tiv$sggyvvirgi$erh

(544$qmppmsr$mr$xli$ekkvikexi$gszivmrk$xli$stivexmsrw$sj$Y2W2$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw0$KIS$Gevi+w$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$wivzmgiw0$KIS$Gevi+w

}syxl$wivzmgiw$erh$FM2$[i$lezi$e$gpemqw1qehi$pmefmpmx}$mrwyvergi$tvskveq${mxl$e$wtigmjmg$psww$pmqmx$sj$(7924$qmppmsr$tiv$sggyvvirgi

erh$mr$xli$ekkvikexi$vipexih$xs$qihmgep$tvsjiwwmsrep$pmefmpmx}$gpemqw$evmwmrk$syx$sj$wigyvi$liepxlgevi$wivzmgiw2$[i$evi$yrmrwyvih$jsv$er}

gpemqw$mr$i|giww$sj$xliwi$pmqmxw2$[i$epws$qemrxemr$mrwyvergi$xs$gsziv$tvstivx}$erh$sxliv$gewyepx}$vmwow$mrgpyhmrk0${svoivw×

gsqtirwexmsr0$irzmvsrqirxep$pmefmpmx}0$g}fivwigyvmx}$pmefmpmx}$erh$eyxsqsfmpi$pmefmpmx}2

Jsv$qswx$gewyepx}$mrwyvergi$tspmgmiw0${i$gevv}$wyfwxerxmep$hihygxmfpiw$sv$wipj1mrwyvih$vixirxmsrw$sj$(724$qmppmsr$tiv$sggyvvirgi$jsv

kirivep$pmefmpmx}$erh$qihmgep$tvsjiwwmsrep$pmefmpmx}0$(624$qmppmsr$tiv$sggyvvirgi$jsv${svoivw×$gsqtirwexmsr$erh$(524$qmppmsr$tiv

sggyvvirgi$jsv$eyxsqsfmpi$pmefmpmx}2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$givxemr$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$psgexih$mr$Jpsvmhe$erh$sxliv$lmkl1vmwo$lyvvmgeri$eview$gevv}

wyfwxerxmep${mrhwxsvq$hihygxmfpiw2$Wmrgi$lyvvmgeriw$evi$gsrwmhivih$yrtvihmgxefpi$jyxyvi$izirxw0$rs$viwivziw$lezi$fiir$iwxefpmwlih$xs

tvi1jyrh$jsv$tsxirxmep${mrhwxsvq$heqeki2$Pmqmxih$gsqqivgmep$ezempefmpmx}$sj$givxemr$x}tiw$sj$mrwyvergi$vipexmrk$xs${mrhwxsvq$i|tswyvi

mr$gsewxep$eview$erh$ievxluyeoi$i|tswyvi$qemrp}$mr$Gepmjsvrme$erh$xli$Tegmjmg$Rsvxl{iwx$qe}$tvizirx$xli$Gsqter}$jvsq$mrwyvmrk$wsqi

sj$mxw$jegmpmxmiw$xs$jypp$vitpegiqirx$zepyi2

[mxl$viwtigx$xs$stivexmsrw$mr$Wsyxl$Ejvmge0$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq$erh$Eywxvepme0${i$yxmpm~i$e$gsqfmrexmsr$sj$psgepp}1tvsgyvih

mrwyvergi$erh$kpsfep$tspmgmiw$xs$qiix$gsrxvegxyep$mrwyvergi$viuymviqirxw$erh$tvsxigx$yw2$Mr$ehhmxmsr$xs$xliwi$tspmgmiw0$syv$Eywxvepmer

wyfwmhmev}$gevvmiw$xemp$mrwyvergi$sr$e$kirivep$pmefmpmx}$tspmg}$vipexih$xs$e$hmwgsrxmryih$gsrxvegx2

Sj$xli$mrwyvergi$tspmgmiw$hmwgywwih$efszi0$syv$qswx$wmkrmjmgerx$mrwyvergi$viwivziw$vipexi$xs${svoivw×$gsqtirwexmsr0$kirivep

pmefmpmx}$erh$eyxs$gpemqw2$Xliwi$viwivziw$evi$yrhmwgsyrxih$erh${ivi$(:<26$qmppmsr$erh$(;42=$qmppmsr$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh

645<0$viwtigxmzip}$erh$evi$mrgpyhih$mr$eggvyih$i|tirwiw$mr$xli$eggsqter}mrk$fepergi$wliixw2$[i$ywi$wxexmwxmgep$erh$egxyevmep$qixlshw

xs$iwxmqexi$eqsyrxw$jsv$gpemqw$xlex$lezi$fiir$vitsvxih$fyx$rsx$temh$erh$gpemqw$mrgyvvih$fyx$rsx$vitsvxih2$Mr$ettp}mrk$xliwi$qixlshw

erh$ewwiwwmrk$xlimv$viwypxw0${i$gsrwmhiv$wygl$jegxsvw$ew$lmwxsvmgep$jviuyirg}$erh$wizivmx}$sj$gpemqw$ex$iegl$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw0$gpemq

hizipstqirx0$te}qirx$texxivrw$erh$glerkiw$mr$xli$rexyvi$sj$syv$fywmriww0$eqsrk$sxliv$jegxsvw2$Wygl$jegxsvw$evi$erep}~ih$jsv$iegl$sj

syv$fywmriww$wikqirxw2$Syv$iwxmqexiw$qe}$fi$mqtegxih$f}$wygl$jegxsvw$ew$mrgviewiw$mr$xli$qevoix$tvmgi$jsv$qihmgep$wivzmgiw$erh

yrtvihmgxefmpmx}$sj$xli$wm~i$sj$nyv}$e{evhw2$[i$epws$qe}$i|tivmirgi$zevmefmpmx}$fix{iir$syv$iwxmqexiw$erh$xli$egxyep$wixxpiqirx$hyi$xs

pmqmxexmsrw$mrlivirx$mr$xli$iwxmqexmsr$tvsgiww0$mrgpyhmrk$syv$efmpmx}$xs$iwxmqexi$gswxw$sj$tvsgiwwmrk$erh$wixxpmrk$gpemqw$mr$e$xmqip}

qerriv$ew${ipp$ew$syv$efmpmx}$xs$eggyvexip}$iwxmqexi$syv$i|tswyvi$ex$xli$srwix$sj$e$gpemq2$Figeywi${i$lezi$lmkl$hihygxmfpi$mrwyvergi

tspmgmiw0$xli$eqsyrx$sj$syv$mrwyvergi$i|tirwi$mw$hitirhirx$sr$syv$efmpmx}$xs$gsrxvsp$syv$gpemqw$i|tivmirgi2$Mj$egxyep$pswwiw$vipexih$xs

mrwyvergi$gpemqw$wmkrmjmgerxp}$hmjjiv$jvsq$syv$iwxmqexiw0$syv$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$erh$gewl$jps{w$gsyph$fi

qexivmepp}$ehzivwip}$mqtegxih2

Mrgsqi$Xe|iw

Xli$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$vijpigx$tvszmwmsrw$jsv$jihivep0$wxexi0$psgep$erh$jsvimkr$mrgsqi$xe|iw2$[i$vigskrm~i$hijivvih

xe|$ewwixw$erh$pmefmpmxmiw$jsv$xli$jyxyvi$xe|$gsrwiuyirgiw$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$hmjjivirgiw$fix{iir$xli$jmrergmep$wxexiqirx$gevv}mrk$eqsyrxw$sj

i|mwxmrk$ewwixw$erh$pmefmpmxmiw$erh$xlimv$viwtigxmzi$xe|$fewmw0$ew${ipp$ew$stivexmrk$psww$erh$xe|$gvihmx$gevv}jsv{evhw2$[i$qiewyvi$hijivvih

xe|$ewwixw$erh$pmefmpmxmiw$ywmrk$iregxih$xe|$vexiw$i|tigxih$xs$ettp}$xs$xe|efpi$mrgsqi$mr$xli$}ievw$mr${lmgl$xlswi$xiqtsvev}$hmjjivirgiw

erh$gevv}jsv{evhw$evi$i|tigxih$xs$fi$vigszivih$sv$wixxpih2$Xli$ijjigx$sr$hijivvih$xe|$ewwixw$erh$pmefmpmxmiw$ew$e$viwypx$sj$e$glerki$mr$xe|

vexiw$mw$vigskrm~ih$ew$mrgsqi$mr$xli$tivmsh$xlex$mrgpyhiw$xli$iregxqirx

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 76 of 253

Page 99: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq ;:367<

94

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 77 of 253

Page 100: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq ;;367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

hexi2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$5;1$Mrgsqi$Xe|iw$mr$xli$rsxiw$xs$xli$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$MM0$Mxiq$<$sj$xlmw$Erryep

Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O2$Ijjigxmzi$Neryev}$50$64570$ew$e$VIMX$xlex$mw$viuymvih$xs$hmwxvmfyxi$ex$piewx$=4)$sj$mxw$xe|efpi$mrgsqi$xs

wlevilsphivw0${i$hs$rsx$i|tigx$xs$te}$jihivep$mrgsqi$xe|iw$ex$xli$VIMX$pizip$,mrgpyhmrk$syv$uyepmjmih$VIMX$wyfwmhmevmiw-0$ew$xli

viwypxmrk$hmzmhirhw$temh$hihygxmsr${mpp$kirivepp}$sjjwix$syv$xe|efpi$mrgsqi2$Wmrgi${i$hs$rsx$i|tigx$xs$te}$xe|iw$sr$syv$VIMX$xe|efpi

mrgsqi0${i$hs$rsx$i|tigx$xs$fi$efpi$xs$vigskrm~i$wygl$hijivvih$xe|$ewwixw$erh$pmefmpmxmiw2

Hijivvih$mrgsqi$xe|iw$evi$hixivqmrih$fewih$sr$xli$iwxmqexih$jyxyvi$xe|$ijjigxw$sj$hmjjivirgiw$fix{iir$xli$jmrergmep$wxexiqirx

erh$xe|$fewmw$sj$ewwixw$erh$pmefmpmxmiw$kmzir$xli$tvszmwmsrw$sj$iregxih$xe|$pe{w2$Wmkrmjmgerx$nyhkqirxw$evi$viuymvih$xs$hixivqmri$xli

gsrwspmhexih$tvszmwmsr$jsv$mrgsqi$xe|iw2$Hijivvih$mrgsqi$xe|$tvszmwmsrw$erh$firijmxw$evi$fewih$sr$glerkiw$xs$xli$ewwixw$sv$pmefmpmxmiw

jvsq$}iev$xs$}iev2$Viepm~exmsr$sj$syv$hijivvih$xe|$ewwixw$mw$hitirhirx$ytsr$qer}$jegxsvw$wygl$ew$xe|$vikypexmsrw$ettpmgefpi$xs$xli

nyvmwhmgxmsrw$mr${lmgl${i$stivexi0$iwxmqexiw$sj$jyxyvi$xe|efpi$mrgsqi$erh$xli$glevegxiv$sj$wygl$xe|efpi$mrgsqi2

Xli$Y2W2$Xe|$Gyx$erh$Nsfw$Egx$,&Xe|$Egx&-${ew$iregxih$sr$Higiqfiv$660$645;$erh$mrxvshygih$wmkrmjmgerx$glerkiw$xs$Y2W2

mrgsqi$xe|$pe{2$Ijjigxmzi$Neryev}$50$645<0$xli$Xe|$Egx$vihygih$xli$Y2W2$wxexyxsv}$gsvtsvexi$xe|$vexi$sj$syv$hsqiwxmg$XVWw$jvsq$79)$xs

65)$erh$gviexih$ri{$mxiqw$sj$xe|efpi$mrgsqi$erh$xe|iw$sr$givxemr$jsvimkr$wsyvgih$ievrmrkw$erh$givxemr$vipexih1tevx}$te}qirxw0${lmgl

evi$vijivvih$xs$ew$xli$kpsfep$mrxerkmfpi$ps{1xe|ih$mrgsqi$erh$xli$fewi$ivswmsr$erh$erxm1efywi$xe|0$viwtigxmzip}2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$mr$645;$xli

Xe|$Egx$tvszmhih$jsv$e$sri1xmqi$xverwmxmsr$xe|$sr$eggyqypexih$jsvimkr$wyfwmhmev}$ievrmrkw$rsx$tvizmsywp}$wyfnigx$xs$Y2W2$mrgsqi$xe|2

[lmpi$xli$Gsqter}$lew$jsvimkr$stivexmsrw0$mx$lew$mhirxmjmih$xlex$xlivi$mw$rs$xverwmxmsr$xe|$hyi2$Eggsyrxmrk$jsv$xli$mrgsqi$xe|$ijjigxw$sj

xli$Xe|$Egx$viuymviw$wmkrmjmgerx$nyhkqirxw$erh$iwxmqexiw$mr$xli$mrxivtvixexmsr$erh$gepgypexmsrw$sj$xli$tvszmwmsrw$sj$xli$Xe|$Egx2

Hyi$xs$xli$xmqmrk$sj$xli$iregxqirx$erh$xli$gsqtpi|mx}$mrzspzih$mr$ettp}mrk$xli$tvszmwmsrw$sj$xli$Xe|$Egx0${i$qehi

viewsrefpi$iwxmqexiw$sj$xli$ijjigxw$erh$vigsvhih$tvszmwmsrep$eqsyrxw$mr$mxw$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$jsv$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645;2

Ew${i$gsppigxih$erh$tvitevih$rigiwwev}$hexe0$erh$mrxivtvixih$er}$ehhmxmsrep$kymhergi$mwwyih$f}$xli$Y2W2$Xviewyv}$Hitevxqirx0$xli$MVW

sv$sxliv$wxerhevh1wixxmrk$fshmiw0${i$qehi$ehnywxqirxw$sziv$xli$gsyvwi$sj$xli$}iev$xs$xli$tvszmwmsrep$eqsyrxw0$mrgpyhmrk$vijmriqirxw$xs

hijivvih$xe|iw2$Xli$eggsyrxmrk$jsv$xli$xe|$ijjigxw$sj$xli$iregxqirx$sj$xli$Xe|$Egx$lew$fiir$gsqtpixih$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645<2

Ehhmxmsrepp}0${i$qywx$ywi$wmkrmjmgerx$nyhkqirx$mr$ehhviwwmrk$yrgivxemrxmiw$mr$xli$ettpmgexmsr$sj$gsqtpi|$xe|$pe{w$erh$vikypexmsrw2

Mj$egxyep$gmvgyqwxergiw$hmjjiv$jvsq$syv$ewwyqtxmsrw0$ehnywxqirxw$xs$xli$gevv}mrk$zepyi$sj$hijivvih$xe|$ewwixw$sv$pmefmpmxmiw$qe}$fi

viuymvih0${lmgl$qe}$viwypx$mr$er$ehzivwi$mqtegx$sr$xli$viwypxw$sj$syv$stivexmsrw$erh$syv$ijjigxmzi$xe|$vexi2$Zepyexmsr$epps{ergiw$evi

vigsvhih$vipexih$xs$hijivvih$xe|$ewwixw$fewih$sr$xli$Ôqsvi$pmoip}$xler$rsxÕ$gvmxivme2$[i$lezi$rsx$qehi$er}$wmkrmjmgerx$glerkiw$xs$xli

{e}${i$eggsyrx$jsv$syv$hijivvih$xe|$ewwixw$erh$pmefmpmxmiw$mr$er}$}iev$tviwirxih$mr$xli$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw2$Fewih$sr$syv

iwxmqexi$sj$jyxyvi$ievrmrkw$erh$syv$jezsvefpi$ievrmrkw$lmwxsv}0${i$gyvvirxp}$i|tigx$jypp$viepm~exmsr$sj$xli$hijivvih$xe|$ewwixw$rix$sj$er}

vigsvhih$zepyexmsr$epps{ergiw2$Jyvxlivqsvi0$xe|$tswmxmsrw$xeoir$f}$yw$qe}$rsx$fi$jypp}$wywxemrih$ytsr$i|eqmrexmsr$f}$xli$xe|mrk

eyxlsvmxmiw2$Mr$hixivqmrmrk$xli$ehiuyeg}$sj$syv$tvszmwmsr$,firijmx-$jsv$mrgsqi$xe|iw0$tsxirxmep$wixxpiqirx$syxgsqiw$viwypxmrk$jvsq

mrgsqi$xe|$i|eqmrexmsrw$evi$vikypevp}$ewwiwwih2$Ew$wygl0$xli$jmrep$syxgsqi$sj$xe|$i|eqmrexmsrw0$mrgpyhmrk$xli$xsxep$eqsyrx$te}efpi$sv

xli$xmqmrk$sj$er}$wygl$te}qirxw$ytsr$viwspyxmsr$sj$xliwi$mwwyiw0$gerrsx$fi$iwxmqexih${mxl$givxemrx}2

Tvstivx}$erh$Iuymtqirx

Tvstivx}$erh$iuymtqirx$evi$wxexih$ex$gswx0$piww$eggyqypexih$hitvigmexmsr2$Hitvigmexmsr$mw$gsqtyxih$ywmrk$xli$wxvemklx1pmri

qixlsh$sziv$xli$iwxmqexih$ywijyp$pmziw$sj$xli$vipexih$ewwixw2$Fymphmrkw$erh$mqtvsziqirxw$evi$hitvigmexih$sziv$6$xs$94$}ievw2$Iuymtqirx

erh$jyvrmxyvi$erh$jm|xyviw$evi$hitvigmexih$sziv$7$xs$54$}ievw2$Piewilsph$mqtvsziqirxw$evi$eqsvxm~ih$sr$e$wxvemklx1pmri$fewmw$sziv$xli

wlsvxiv$sj$xli$ywijyp$pmji$sj$xli$mqtvsziqirx$sv$xli$xivq$sj$xli$piewi2$[i$tivjsvq$srksmrk$izepyexmsrw$sj$xli$iwxmqexih$ywijyp$pmziw$sj

xli$tvstivx}$erh$iuymtqirx$jsv$hitvigmexmsr$tyvtswiw2$Xli$iwxmqexih$ywijyp$pmziw$evi$hixivqmrih$erh$gsrxmryepp}$izepyexih$fewih$sr

xli$tivmsh$sziv${lmgl$wivzmgiw$evi$i|tigxih$xs$fi$virhivih$f}$xli$ewwix2$Mj$xli$ewwiwwqirx$mrhmgexiw$xlex$ewwixw${mpp$fi$ywih$jsv$e$psrkiv

sv$wlsvxiv$tivmsh$xler$tvizmsywp}$erxmgmtexih0$xli$ywijyp$pmziw$sj$xli$ewwixw$evi$vizmwih0$viwypxmrk$mr$e$glerki$mr$iwxmqexi2$[i$lezi$rsx

qehi$er}$glerkiw$mr$iwxmqexiw$hyvmrk$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$645<$erh$645;2$Qemrxirergi$erh$vitemvw$evi$i|tirwih$ew

mrgyvvih2$Mrxiviwx$mw$getmxepm~ih$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$gsrwxvygxmsr$sj$gsqter}1s{rih$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw2$Gswx$jsv$wipj1gsrwxvygxih

wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw$mrgpyhiw$hmvigx$qexivmepw$erh$pefsv0$getmxepm~ih$mrxiviwx$erh$givxemr$sxliv$mrhmvigx$gswxw$ewwsgmexih${mxl$gsrwxvygxmsr$sj

xli$jegmpmx}0$wygl$ew$tvstivx}$xe|iw0$sxliv$mrhmvigx$pefsv$erh$vipexih$firijmxw$erh$te}vspp$xe|iw2$[i$fikmr$getmxepm~mrk$gswxw$hyvmrk$xli

tvi1gsrwxvygxmsr$tlewi0${lmgl$mw$xli$tivmsh$hyvmrk${lmgl$gswxw$evi$mrgyvvih$xs$izepyexi$xli$wmxi0$erh$gsrxmryiw$yrxmp$xli$jegmpmx}$mw

wyfwxerxmepp}$gsqtpixi$erh$vieh}$jsv$sggyterg}2$Pefsv$gswxw$getmxepm~ih$jsv$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$645<$erh$645;${ivi

rsx$wmkrmjmgerx2$Getmxepm~ih$mrxiviwx$mw$vigsvhih$ew$tevx$sj$xli$ewwix$xs${lmgl$mx$vipexiw$erh$mw$eqsvxm~ih$sziv$xli$ewwix×w$iwxmqexih$ywijyp

pmji2

95

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 78 of 253

Page 101: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq ;<367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Ewwix$Mqtemvqirxw

[i$leh$ tvstivx}$ erh$ iuymtqirx$ sj$ (625$ fmppmsr$ erh$ (626$ fmppmsr$ ew$ sj$Higiqfiv$ 750$ 645=$ erh$ 645<0$ viwtigxmzip}0$ mrgpyhmrk

ettvs|mqexip}$ ;44$ zegerx$ fihw$ {mxl$ e$ rix$ fsso$ zepyi$ sj$ ettvs|mqexip}$ (56$qmppmsr$ ew$ sj$ Higiqfiv$ 750$ 645=$ ex$ sri$ sj$ syv$ mhpi

jegmpmxmiw$mr$syv$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$wikqirx$xlex${i$evi$gyvvirxp}$qevoixmrk$xs$tsxirxmep$gywxsqivw2$Epws0$mr$syv$KIS$Gevi$wikqirx0${i

evi$gyvvirxp}$qevoixmrk$ettvs|mqexip}$844$zegerx$fihw${mxl$e$rix$fsso$zepyi$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(=24$qmppmsr$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=

ex$sri$sj$syv$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw$xs$tsxirxmep$gywxsqivw2

[i$vizmi{$psrk1pmzih$ewwixw$xs$fi$liph$erh$ywih$jsv$mqtemvqirx${liriziv$izirxw$sv$glerkiw$mr$gmvgyqwxergiw$mrhmgexi$xlex$xli$gevv}mrk

eqsyrx$sj$wygl$ewwixw$qe}$rsx$fi$jypp}$vigszivefpi2$Izirxw$xlex${syph$xvmkkiv$er$mqtemvqirx$ewwiwwqirx$mrgpyhi$hixivmsvexmsr$sj

tvsjmxw$jsv$e$fywmriww$wikqirx$xlex$lew$psrk1pmzih$ewwixw0$sv${lir$sxliv$glerkiw$sggyv$xlex$qmklx$mqtemv$vigsziv}$sj$psrk1pmzih$ewwixw

wygl$ew$xli$xivqmrexmsr$sj$e$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegx$sv$e$wmkrmjmgerx$higviewi$mr$tstypexmsr2$Mj$mqtemvqirx$mrhmgexsvw$evi$tviwirx0${i

tivjsvq$e$vigszivefmpmx}$xiwx$xs$hixivqmri${lixliv$sv$rsx$er$mqtemvqirx$psww$wlsyph$fi$qiewyvih2

[i$xiwx$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw$jsv$mqtemvqirx$ytsr$rsxmjmgexmsr$xlex$xli$jegmpmxmiw${mpp$rs$psrkiv$fi$yxmpm~ih$f}$xli$gywxsqiv2$Mj$e$psrk1pmzih

ewwix$mw$tevx$sj$e$kvsyt$xlex$mrgpyhiw$sxliv$ewwixw0$xli$yrmx$sj$eggsyrxmrk$jsv$xli$psrk1pmzih$ewwix$mw$mxw$kvsyt2$Kirivepp}0${i$kvsyt$ewwixw

f}$jegmpmx}$jsv$xli$tyvtswi$sj$gsrwmhivmrk${lixliv$er}$mqtemvqirx$i|mwxw2$Xli$iwxmqexiw$sj$vigszivefmpmx}$evi$fewih$sr$tvsnigxih

yrhmwgsyrxih$gewl$jps{w$ewwsgmexih${mxl$egxyep$qevoixmrk$ijjsvxw${livi$ezempefpi$sv0$mr$sxliv$mrwxergiw0$tvsnigxih$yrhmwgsyrxih$gewl

jps{w$xlex$evi$gsqtevefpi$xs$lmwxsvmgep$gewl$jps{w$jvsq$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$ex$wmqmpev$jegmpmxmiw$erh$wirwmxmzmx}$erep}wiw$xlex$gsrwmhiv

vihygxmsrw$xs$wygl$gewl$jps{w2$Syv$wirwmxmzmx}$erep}wiw$mrgpyhi$ehnywxqirxw$xs$tvsnigxih$gewl$jps{w$gsqtevih$xs$xli$lmwxsvmgep$gewl

jps{w$hyi$xs$gyvvirx$fywmriww$gsrhmxmsrw${lmgl$mqtegx$tiv$hmiq$vexiw$ew${ipp$ew$pefsv$erh$sxliv$stivexmrk$gswxw0$glerkiw$vipexih$xs

jegmpmx}$qmwwmsr$hyi$xs$glerkiw$mr$tvswtigxmzi$gpmirxw0$erh$glerkiw$mr$tvsnigxih$getegmx}$erh$sggyterg}$vexiw2$[i$epws$jegxsv$mr

tvspsrkih$tivmshw$sj$zegergmiw$ew${ipp$ew$xli$xmqi$erh$gswxw$viuymvih$xs$veqt$yt$jegmpmx}$tstypexmsr$srgi$e$gsrxvegx$mw$sfxemrih2$[i

tivjsvq$xli$mqtemvqirx$erep}wiw$sr$er$erryep$fewmw$jsv$iegl$sj$xli$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw$erh$ythexi$iegl$uyevxiv$jsv$qevoix$hizipstqirxw$jsv

xli$tsxirxmep$yxmpm~exmsr$sj$iegl$sj$xli$jegmpmxmiw$mr$svhiv$xs$mhirxmj}$izirxw$xlex$qe}$geywi$yw$xs$vigsrwmhiv$xli$qswx$vigirx$ewwyqtxmsrw2

Wygl$izirxw$gsyph$mrgpyhi$riksxmexmsrw${mxl$e$tvswtigxmzi$gywxsqiv$jsv$xli$yxmpm~exmsr$sj$er$mhpi$jegmpmx}$ex$xivqw$wmkrmjmgerxp}$piww

jezsvefpi$xler$ywih$mr$syv$qswx$vigirx$mqtemvqirx$erep}wmw0$sv$glerkiw$mr$pikmwpexmsr$wyvvsyrhmrk$e$tevxmgypev$jegmpmx}$xlex$gsyph$mqtegx

syv$efmpmx}$xs$lsywi$givxemr$x}tiw$sj$mrhmzmhyepw$ex$wygl$jegmpmx}2$Jyvxliv0$e$wyfwxerxmep$mrgviewi$mr$xli$ryqfiv$sj$ezempefpi$fihw$ex$sxliv

jegmpmxmiw$xlex${i$s{r0$sv$mr$xli$qevoixtpegi0$gsyph$pieh$xs$hixivmsvexmsr$mr$qevoix$gsrhmxmsrw$erh$tvsnigxih$gewl$jps{w2$Epxlsykl$xli}

evi$rsx$jviuyirxp}$vigimzih0$er$yrwspmgmxih$sjjiv$xs$tyvglewi$er}$sj$syv$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw0$ex$eqsyrxw$xlex$evi$piww$xler$xlimv$gevv}mrk$zepyi

gsyph$epws$geywi$yw$xs$vigsrwmhiv$xli$ewwyqtxmsrw$ywih$mr$xli$qswx$vigirx$mqtemvqirx$erep}wmw2$[i$lezi$mhirxmjmih$qevoixmrk$tvswtigxw

xs$yxmpm~i$iegl$sj$xli$viqemrmrk$gyvvirxp}$mhpih$jegmpmxmiw$erh$hs$rsx$wii$er}$gexep}wxw$xlex${syph$viwypx$mr$e$gyvvirx$mqtemvqirx2

Ls{iziv0${i$ger$tvszmhi$rs$ewwyvergi$xlex${i${mpp$fi$efpi$xs$wigyvi$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$xs$yxmpm~i$syv$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw0$sv$xlex${i${mpp

rsx$mrgyv$mqtemvqirx$glevkiw$mr$xli$jyxyvi2$Mr$epp$gewiw0$xli$tvsnigxih$yrhmwgsyrxih$gewl$jps{w$mr$syv$erep}wmw$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=

wyfwxerxmepp}$i|giihih$xli$gevv}mrk$eqsyrxw$sj$iegl$jegmpmx}2

Syv$izepyexmsrw$epws$xeoi$mrxs$gsrwmhivexmsr$lmwxsvmgep$i|tivmirgi$mr$wigyvmrk$ri{$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$xs$yxmpm~i$jegmpmxmiw$xlex

leh$fiir$tvizmsywp}$mhpih$jsv$tivmshw$gsqtevefpi$xs$sv$mr$i|giww$sj$xli$tivmshw$syv$gyvvirxp}$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw$lezi$fiir$mhpi2$Wygl

tvizmsywp}$mhpih$jegmpmxmiw$evi$gyvvirxp}$fimrk$stivexih$yrhiv$gsrxvegxw$xlex$kirivexi$gewl$jps{w$viwypxmrk$mr$xli$vigszivefmpmx}$sj$xli$rix

fsso$zepyi$sj$xli$tvizmsywp}$mhpih$jegmpmxmiw$f}$wyfwxerxmep$eqsyrxw2$Hyi$xs$e$zevmix}$sj$jegxsvw0$xli$pieh$xmqi$xs$riksxmexi$gsrxvegxw${mxl

jihivep$erh$wxexi$ekirgmiw$xs$yxmpm~i$mhpi$fih$getegmx}$mw$kirivepp}$pirkxl}${lmgl$lew$lmwxsvmgepp}$viwypxih$mr$tivmshw$sj$mhpiriww$wmqmpev

xs$xli$sriw${i$evi$gyvvirxp}$i|tivmirgmrk2$Ew$e$viwypx$sj$syv$erep}wiw0${i$hixivqmrih$iegl$sj$xliwi$ewwixw$xs$lezi$vigszivefpi$zepyiw

wyfwxerxmepp}$mr$i|giww$sj$xli$gsvviwtsrhmrk$gevv}mrk$zepyiw2

F}$xlimv$rexyvi0$xliwi$iwxmqexiw$gsrxemr$yrgivxemrxmiw${mxl$viwtigx$xs$xli$i|xirx$erh$xmqmrk$sj$xli$viwtigxmzi$gewl$jps{w$hyi$xs

tsxirxmep$hipe}w$sv$qexivmep$glerkiw$xs$jsvigewxih$xivqw$erh$gsrhmxmsrw$mr$gsrxvegxw${mxl$tvswtigxmzi$gywxsqivw$xlex$gsyph$mqtegx$xli

iwxmqexi$sj$tvsnigxih$gewl$jps{w2

Vigirx$Eggsyrxmrk$Tvsrsyrgiqirxw

Xli$Gsqter}$mqtpiqirxih$xli$jspps{mrk$eggsyrxmrk$wxerhevhw$hyvmrk$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=>$$$$

Mr$Sgxsfiv$645<0$xli$JEWF$mwwyih$EWY$Rs2$645<15:0$&Hivmzexmziw$erh$Lihkmrk$,Xstmg$<59-&2$Xli$tyvtswi$sj$xlmw$ythexi$mw$xs

mrgpyhi$xli$Wigyvih$Szivrmklx$Jmrergmrk$Vexi$,WSJV-$Szivrmklx$Mrhi|$W{et$Vexi$,SMW-$ew$e$firglqevo$mrxiviwx$vexi$jsv$lihki

eggsyrxmrk$tyvtswiw2$Figeywi$sj$gsrgivrw$efsyx$xli$wywxemrefmpmx}$sj$PMFSV0$xli$Jihivep$Viwivzi$Fsevh$erh$xli$Jihivep$Viwivzi$Fero

sj$Ri{$]svo$mrmxmexih$er$ijjsvx$xs$mrxvshygi$er$epxivrexmzi$vijivirgi$vexi$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw2$Xli$ri{$wxerhevh$figeqi$ijjigxmzi$jsv

xli$Gsqter}$fikmrrmrk$Neryev}$50$645=2$Xli$ehstxmsr$sj$xlmw$wxerhevh$hmh$rsx$lezi$e$qexivmep$mqtegx$sr$xli$Gsqter}+w$jmrergmep

tswmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$sv$gewl$jps{w2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 79 of 253

Page 102: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq ;=367<

96

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 80 of 253

Page 103: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq <4367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Mr$Nyri$645<0$xli$JEWF$mwwyih$EWY$Rs2$645<14;0$&Gsqtirwexmsr$1$Wxsgo$Gsqtirwexmsr$,Xstmg$;5<-0$Mqtvsziqirxw$xs

Rsriqtps}ii$Wlevi1Fewih$Te}qirx$Eggsyrxmrk&$ew$e$tevx$sj$mxw$Wmqtpmjmgexmsr$Mrmxmexmzi2$Xli$eqirhqirxw$mr$xlmw$ythexi$i|terh$xli

wgsti$sj$Xstmg$;5<$xs$mrgpyhi$wlevi1fewih$te}qirx$xverwegxmsrw$jsv$eguymvmrk$ksshw$erh$wivzmgiw$jvsq$rsriqtps}iiw2$Er$irxmx}$wlsyph

ettp}$xli$viuymviqirxw$sj$Xstmg$;5<$xs$rsriqtps}ii$e{evhw$i|gitx$jsv$wtigmjmg$kymhergi$sr$mrtyxw$xs$er$stxmsr$tvmgmrk$qship$erh$xli

tivmsh$sj$xmqi$sziv${lmgl$wlevi1fewih$te}qirx$e{evhw$ziwx$erh$xli$texxivr$sj$gswx$vigskrmxmsr$sziv$xlex$tivmsh2$Xli$eqirhqirxw

wtigmj}$xlex$Xstmg$;5<$ettpmiw$xs$epp$wlevi1fewih$te}qirx$xverwegxmsrw$mr${lmgl$e$kverxsv$eguymviw$ksshw$sv$wivzmgiw$xs$fi$ywih$sv

gsrwyqih$mr$e$kverxsv+w$s{r$stivexmsrw$f}$mwwymrk$wlevi1fewih$te}qirx$e{evhw2$Xli$eqirhqirxw$epws$gpevmj}$xlex$Xstmg$;5<$hsiw$rsx

ettp}$xs$wlevi1fewih$te}qirxw$ywih$xs$ijjigxmzip}$tvszmhi$,5-$jmrergmrk$xs$xli$mwwyiv$sv$,6-$e{evhw$kverxih$mr$gsrnyrgxmsr${mxl$wippmrk

ksshw$sv$wivzmgiw$xs$gywxsqivw$ew$tevx$sj$e$gsrxvegx$eggsyrxih$jsv$yrhiv$Xstmg$:4:0&Viziryi$jvsq$Gsrxvegxw${mxl$Gywxsqivw2&$Xli$ri{

wxerhevh$figeqi$ijjigxmzi$jsv$xli$Gsqter}$fikmrrmrk$Neryev}$50$645=2$Xli$ehstxmsr$sj$xlmw$wxerhevh$hmh$rsx$lezi$e$qexivmep$mqtegx$sr

xli$Gsqter}+w$jmrergmep$tswmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$sv$gewl$jps{w2

$$$$

Mr$Jifvyev}$645<0$xli$JEWF$mwwyih$EWY$Rs2$645<1460$&Mrgsqi$Wxexiqirx1Vitsvxmrk$Gsqtvilirwmzi$Mrgsqi1Vigpewwmjmgexmsr

sj$Givxemr$Xe|$Ijjigxw$jvsq$Eggyqypexih$Sxliv$Gsqtvilirwmzi$Mrgsqi&2$Xli$eqirhqirxw$mr$xlmw$ythexi$epps{$er$irxmx}$xs$ipigx$xs

vigpewwmj}$xli$mrgsqi$xe|$ijjigxw$viwypxmrk$jvsq$xli$Xe|$Gyxw$erh$Nsfw$Egx$sr$mxiqw${mxlmr$eggyqypexih$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi

,&ESGM&-$xs$vixemrih$ievrmrkw2$Xli$ri{$wxerhevh$mw$ijjigxmzi$jsv$epp$irxmxmiw$jsv$jmwgep$}ievw$fikmrrmrk$ejxiv$Higiqfiv$590$645<0$erh

mrxivmq$tivmshw${mxlmr$xlswi$jmwgep$}ievw2$Ievp}$ehstxmsr${ew$tivqmxxih2$Xli$Gsqter}$ehstxih$xli$ri{$wxerhevh$ijjigxmzi$Neryev}$50

645=$erh$lew$qehi$e$tspmg}$ipigxmsr$xs$vigpewwmj}$xli$mrgsqi$xe|$ijjigxw$viwypxmrk$jvsq$xli$Xe|$Gyxw$erh$Nsfw$Egx$sr$mxiqw${mxlmr

ESGM$xs$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$mr$i|giww$sj$ievrmrkw$sr$e$tvswtigxmzi$fewmw2$Ew$e$viwypx0$xli$Gsqter}$vigpewwmjmih$(42;$qmppmsr$jsv$xli$xe|$ijjigx

sj$xli$xe|$vexi$vihygxmsr$vipexih$xs$mxw$tirwmsr$pmefmpmx}$erh$(52;$qmppmsr$jsv$xli$xe|$ijjigx$sj$sxliv$mrgsqi$xe|$ijjigxw$sj$xe|$vijsvq$sr

mxiqw$viqemrmrk$mr$ESGM$vipexih$xs$gyvvirg}$xverwpexmsr$ehnywxqirxw$xs$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$mr$i|giww$sj$ievrmrkw$sr$Neryev}$50$645=2$Xli$rix

ijjigx$sj$fsxl$ehnywxqirxw$viwypxih$mr$er$ekkvikexi$mrgviewi$xs$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$mr$i|giww$sj$ievrmrkw$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(524$qmppmsr2

Mr$Eykywx$645;0$xli$JEWF$mwwyih$EWY$Rs2$645;1560$&Hivmzexmziw$erh$Lihkmrk$1$Xevkixih$Mqtvsziqirxw$xs$Eggsyrxmrk$jsv

Lihkmrk$Egxmzmxmiw2&$Xli$sfnigxmzi$sj$xlmw$kymhergi$mw$xs$mqtvszi$xli$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$sj$lihkmrk$vipexmsrwlmtw$xs$fixxiv$tsvxve}$xli

igsrsqmg$viwypxw$sj$er$irxmx}+w$vmwo$qerekiqirx$egxmzmxmiw$mr$mxw$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw2$Givxemr$sj$xli$eqirhqirxw$mr$xlmw$ythexi$ew$xli}

vipexi$xs$gewl$jps{$lihkiw0$ipmqmrexi$xli$viuymviqirx$xs$witevexip}$vigsvh$lihki$mrijjigxmziriww$gyvvirxp}$mr$ievrmrkw2$Mrwxieh0$xli

irxmvi$glerki$mr$xli$jemv$zepyi$sj$xli$lihkmrk$mrwxvyqirx$mw$vigsvhih$mr$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi2$Xlswi$eqsyrxw$evi$vigpewwmjmih$xs

ievrmrkw$mr$xli$weqi$mrgsqi$wxexiqirx$pmri$mxiq$xlex$mw$ywih$xs$tviwirx$xli$ievrmrkw$ijjigx$sj$xli$lihkih$mxiq${lir$xli$lihkih$mxiq

ejjigxw$ievrmrkw2$Xli$ri{$wxerhevh$figeqi$ijjigxmzi$jsv$xli$Gsqter}$fikmrrmrk$Neryev}$50$645=2$Xli$ehstxmsr$sj$xlmw$wxerhevh$hmh$rsx

lezi$e$qexivmep$mqtegx$sr$xli$Gsqter}+w$jmrergmep$tswmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$sv$gewl$jps{w2

Mr$Jifvyev}$645:0$xli$JEWF$mwwyih$EWY$645:1460$&Piewiw0&${lmgl$viuymviw$irxmxmiw$xs$vigskrm~i$piewi$ewwixw$erh$piewi

pmefmpmxmiw$sr$xli$fepergi$wliix$erh$xs$hmwgpswi$oi}$mrjsvqexmsr$efsyx$piewmrk$evverkiqirxw2$Jsv$jmrergi$piewiw$erh$stivexmrk$piewiw0$e

piwwii$wlsyph$vigskrm~i$mr$xli$wxexiqirx$sj$jmrergmep$tswmxmsr$e$pmefmpmx}$xs$qeoi$piewi$te}qirxw$,xli$piewi$pmefmpmx}-$erh$e$vmklx1sj1ywi

ewwix$vitviwirxmrk$mxw$vmklx$xs$ywi$xli$yrhivp}mrk$ewwix$jsv$xli$piewi$xivq${mxl$iegl$mrmxmepp}$qiewyvih$ex$xli$tviwirx$zepyi$sj$xli$piewi

te}qirxw2$Xli$eqirhqirxw$mr$EWY$645:146$figeqi$ijjigxmzi$jsv$xli$Gsqter}$sr$Neryev}$50$645=2$Xli$Gsqter}$ipigxih$xli$tegoeki

sj$xverwmxmsr$i|tihmirxw$ezempefpi$jsv$i|tmvih$sv$i|mwxmrk$piewi$gsrxvegxw0${lmgl$epps{ih$mx$xs$gevv}$jsv{evh$mxw$lmwxsvmgep$ewwiwwqirxw$sj

,5-${lixliv$gsrxvegxw$evi$sv$gsrxemr$piewiw0$,6-$piewi$gpewwmjmgexmsr$erh$,7-$mrmxmep$hmvigx$gswxw2$Xli$Gsqter}$epws$ipigxih$rsx$xs$ettp}

xli$vigskrmxmsr$viuymviqirxw$xs$piewi$evverkiqirxw$xlex$lezi$xivqw$sj$x{ipzi$qsrxlw$sv$piww2$Xli$ehstxmsr$leh$e$qexivmep$mqtegx$mr$xli

Gsqter}+w$gsrwspmhexih$fepergi$wliixw0$fyx$hmh$rsx$lezi$er$mqtegx$sr$mxw$gsrwspmhexih$wxexiqirxw$sj$stivexmsrw$sv$gewl$jps{w2$Xli

qswx$wmkrmjmgerx$mqtegx${ew$xli$vigskrmxmsr$sj$vmklx1sj1ywi$ewwixw$erh$piewi$pmefmpmxmiw$jsv$stivexmrk$piewiw0${lmpi$syv$eggsyrxmrk$jsv

jmrergi$piewiw$viqemrih$wyfwxerxmepp}$yrglerkih2$Xli$ri{$wxerhevh$viwypxih$mr$xli$vigsvhmrk$sj$stivexmrk$vmklx1sj1ywi$piewi$ewwixw$erh

stivexmrk$piewi$pmefmpmxmiw$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(584$qmppmsr$erh$(58;$qmppmsr0$viwtigxmzip}0$ew$sj$Neryev}$50$645=2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$58$1

Piewiw$jsv$jyvxliv$hmwgywwmsr$erh$ehhmxmsrep$viuymvih$hmwgpswyviw2

$$$$

Xli$jspps{mrk$eggsyrxmrk$wxerhevhw${mpp$fi$ehstxih$mr$jyxyvi$tivmshw>

$$$$

Mr$Eykywx$645<0$xli$JEWF$mwwyih$EWY$Rs2$645<1580$&Gsqtirwexmsr1Vixmviqirx$Firijmxw1Hijmrih$Firijmx$Tperw1Kirivep

,Xstmg$;59264-&$ew$e$tevx$sj$mxw$hmwgpswyvi$jveqi{svo$tvsnigx2$Xli$eqirhqirxw$mr$xlmw$ythexi$viqszi0$qshmj}$erh$ehh

97

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 81 of 253

Page 104: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq <5367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

givxemr$hmwgpswyviw$tvmqevmp}$vipexih$xs$eqsyrxw$mr$eggyqypexih$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$i|tigxih$xs$fi$vigskrm~ih$ew$gsqtsrirxw

sj$rix$tivmshmg$firijmx$gswx$sziv$xli$ri|x$jmwgep$}iev0$i|tperexmsrw$jsv$viewsrw$jsv$wmkrmjmgerx$kemrw$erh$pswwiw$vipexih$xs$glerkiw$mr$xli

firijmx$sfpmkexmsr$jsv$xli$tivmsh0$erh$tvsnigxih$erh$eggyqypexih$firijmx$sfpmkexmsrw2$Xli$ri{$wxerhevh$mw$ijjigxmzi$jsv$xli$Gsqter}

fikmrrmrk$Neryev}$50$64652$Xli$ehstxmsr$sj$xlmw$wxerhevh$mw$rsx$i|tigxih$xs$lezi$e$qexivmep$mqtegx$sr$xli$Gsqter}+w$jmrergmep

tswmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$sv$gewl$jps{w2

Mr$Eykywx$645<0$xli$JEWF$mwwyih$EWY$Rs2$645<1570$&Jemv$Zepyi$Qiewyviqirx$,Xstmg$<64-&$ew$e$tevx$sj$mxw$hmwgpswyvi

jveqi{svo$tvsnigx2$Xli$eqirhqirxw$mr$xlmw$ythexi$viqszi0$qshmj}$erh$ehh$givxemr$hmwgpswyviw$tvmqevmp}$vipexih$xs$xverwjivw$fix{iir

Pizip$5$erh$Pizip$6$sj$xli$jemv$zepyi$lmivevgl}0$zevmsyw$hmwgpswyviw$vipexih$xs$Pizip$7$jemv$zepyi$qiewyviqirxw$erh$mrziwxqirxw$mr

givxemr$irxmxmiw$xlex$gepgypexi$rix$ewwix$zepyi2$Xli$ri{$wxerhevh${ew$ijjigxmzi$jsv$xli$Gsqter}$fikmrrmrk$Neryev}$50$64642$Xli

ehstxmsr$sj$xlmw$wxerhevh$mw$rsx$i|tigxih$xs$lezi$e$qexivmep$mqtegx$sr$xli$Gsqter}+w$jmrergmep$tswmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$sv$gewl

jps{w2

Mr$Nyri$645:0$xli$JEWF$mwwyih$EWG$Rs2$645:1570$&Jmrergmep$Mrwxvyqirxw$Ò$Gvihmx$Pswwiw$,Xstmg$76:->$Qiewyviqirx$sj$Gvihmx

Pswwiw$sr$Jmrergmep$Mrwxvyqirxw&2$Xli$tyvtswi$sj$Ythexi$Rs2$645:157$mw$xs$vitpegi$xli$gyvvirx$mrgyvvih$psww$mqtemvqirx$qixlshspsk}

jsv$jmrergmep$ewwixw$qiewyvih$ex$eqsvxm~ih$gswx${mxl$e$qixlshspsk}$xlex$vijpigxw$i|tigxih$gvihmx$pswwiw$erh$viuymviw$gsrwmhivexmsr$sj$e

fvsehiv$verki$sj$viewsrefpi$erh$wyttsvxefpi$mrjsvqexmsr0$mrgpyhmrk$jsvigewxih$mrjsvqexmsr0$xs$hizipst$gvihmx$psww$iwxmqexiw2$Ythexi

Rs2$645:157${ew$ijjigxmzi$jsv$erryep$tivmshw$fikmrrmrk$ejxiv$Higiqfiv$590$645=0$mrgpyhmrk$mrxivmq$tivmshw${mxlmr$xlswi$erryep

tivmshw2$Ievp}$ehstxmsr$mw$tivqmxxih$jsv$erryep$tivmshw$fikmrrmrk$ejxiv$Higiqfiv$590$645<2$Xli$Gsqter}$lew$gsqtpixih$mxw$tvsgiww$sj

hixivqmrmrk$xli$ijjigx$xlex$xli$ehstxmsr${mpp$lezi$sr$mxw$jmrergmep$tswmxmsr$erh$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$erh$xli$Gsqter}$hsiw$rsx$i|tigx

xli$ri{$wxerhevh${mpp$lezi$e$qexivmep$mqtegx$sr$mxw$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw2

Sxliv$ vigirx$ eggsyrxmrk$ tvsrsyrgiqirxw$ mwwyih$ f}$ xli$ JEWF$ ,mrgpyhmrk$ mxw$ Iqivkmrk$ Mwwyiw$ Xewo$ Jsvgi-0$ xli$ Eqivmger

Mrwxmxyxi$sj$Givxmjmih$Tyfpmg$Eggsyrxerxw$erh$xli$WIG$hmh$rsx0$sv$evi$rsx$i|tigxih$xs0$lezi$e$qexivmep$ijjigx$sr$xli$Gsqter}+w$viwypxw$sj

stivexmsrw$sv$jmrergmep$tswmxmsr2

Viwypxw$sj$Stivexmsrw

Xli$jspps{mrk$hmwgywwmsr$wlsyph$fi$vieh$mr$gsrnyrgxmsr${mxl$syv$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$erh$xli$rsxiw$xs$xli

gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$eggsqter}mrk$xlmw$vitsvx2$Xlmw$hmwgywwmsr$gsrxemrw$jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw$xlex$mrzspzi$vmwow$erh

yrgivxemrxmiw2$Syv$egxyep$viwypxw$qe}$hmjjiv$qexivmepp}$jvsq$xlswi$erxmgmtexih$mr$xli$jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw$ew$e$viwypx$sj$givxemr

jegxsvw0$mrgpyhmrk0$fyx$rsx$pmqmxih$xs0$xlswi$hiwgvmfih$yrhiv$ÔMxiq$5E2$Vmwo$JegxsvwÕ$erh$xlswi$mrgpyhih$mr$sxliv$tsvxmsrw$sj$xlmw$vitsvx2

645=$zivwyw$645<

Viziryiw

$ 645= $)$sj$Viziryi $ 645< $ )$sj$Viziryi $ ($Glerki $ )$Glerki

$ ,Hsppevw$mr$xlsywerhw-

Y2W2$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw ( 50:450:;= $ :82:) $ ( 508=60=;7 $ :824) $ ( 54<0;4: $ ;27$)

KIS$Gevi :58068= $ 682<) $ 9<40757 $ 682=) $ 770=7: $ 92<$)

Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw 676045: $ =28) $ 6970<;8 $ 542=) $ ,650<9<- $ ,<2:-)

Jegmpmx}$Gsrwxvygxmsr$*

Hiwmkr 6=0=;< $ 526) $ 8066: $ 426) $ 690;96 $ 54424$)

Xsxep ( 608;;0=66 $ 54424) $ ( 6077507<: $ 54424) $ ( 58:097: $ :27$)

98

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 82 of 253

Page 105: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq <6367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Y2W2$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw

Viziryiw$mrgviewih$mr$645=$gsqtevih$xs$645<$tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs$ekkvikexi$mrgviewiw$sj$(9627$qmppmsr$hyi$xs$rix$mrgviewiw$mr

tstypexmsr0$xverwtsvxexmsr$wivzmgiw$erh$vexiw2$[i$epws$leh$mrgviewiw$sj$(:82;$qmppmsr$viwypxmrk$jvsq$xli$egxmzexmsr$sj$syv$gsrxvegxw$ex

syv$gsqter}1s{rih$erh$tvizmsywp}$mhpih$Wsyxl$Psymwmere$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxiv$mr$Fewmpi0$Psymwmere$hyvmrk$xli$xlmvh$uyevxiv$sj$645=0

syv$gsqter}1s{rih$Iekpi$Teww$Gsvvigxmsrep$Jegmpmx}$mr$Iekpi$Teww0$Xi|ew${lmgl${ew$egxmzexih$hyvmrk$xli$jsyvxl$uyevxiv$sj$645<0$syv

gsqter}1s{rih$erh$tvizmsywp}$mhpih$Rsvxl$Peoi$Gsvvigxmsrep$Jegmpmx}$mr$Feph{mr0$Qmglmker${lmgl${ew$egxmzexih$sr$Sgxsfiv$50$645=0

xli$gsyrx}1s{rih$Viiziw$Gsyrx}$Hixirxmsr$Girxiv$M$*$MM$mr$Viiziw$Gsyrx}0$Xi|ew${lmgl${ew$egxmzexih$sr$Sgxsfiv$50$645=$erh$syv

gsrxvegx$i|terwmsr$ex$syv$gsqter}1s{rih$Qsrxksqiv}$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxiv$mr$Gsrvsi0$Xi|ew$mr$xli$xlmvh$uyevxiv$sj$645=2$Xliwi

mrgviewiw${ivi$tevxmepp}$sjjwix$f}$rix$higviewiw$sj$(<27$qmppmsr$ex$givxemr$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$hyi$xs$gsrxvegx$xivqmrexmsrw2

Xli$ryqfiv$sj$gsqtirwexih$qerhe}w$mr$Y2W2$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$jegmpmxmiw${ew$ettvs|mqexip}$6729$qmppmsr$mr$645=$erh$662=$qmppmsr$mr

645<2$[i$i|tivmirgih$er$ekkvikexi$rix$mrgviewi$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$:440444$qerhe}w$ew$e$viwypx$sj$tstypexmsr$mrgviewiw${mxl$syv$jihivep

gpmirxw$erh$syv$gsrxvegx$egxmzexmsrw$hmwgywwih$efszi0$sjjwix$f}$gsrxvegx$xivqmrexmsrw2$[i$psso$ex$xli$eziveki$sggyterg}$mr$syv$jegmpmxmiw

xs$hixivqmri$ls{${i$evi$qerekmrk$syv$ezempefpi$fihw2$Xli$eziveki$sggyterg}$mw$gepgypexih$f}$xeomrk$gsqtirwexih$qerhe}w$ew$e

tivgirxeki$sj$getegmx}2$Xli$eziveki$sggyterg}$mr$syv$KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$jegmpmxmiw${ew$=82=)$erh$=928)$sj$getegmx}$mr$645=$erh

645<0$viwtigxmzip}0$i|gpyhmrk$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw2

KIS$Gevi

Viziryiw$mrgviewih$mr$645=$gsqtevih$xs$645<$tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs$ekkvikexi$mrgviewiw$sj$(6:2;$qmppmsr$vipexih$xs$mrgviewiw$mr

eziveki$gpmirx$erh$tevxmgmterx$gsyrxw$yrhiv$syv$MWET$erh$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$wivzmgiw2$[i$epws$leh$mrgviewiw$sj$(7526$qmppmsr$hyi$xs

rix$mrgviewiw$mr$girwyw$pizipw$ex$givxemr$sj$syv$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$erh$viirxv}$girxivw$erh$ri{$tvskveqw$egxmzexih$mr$Higiqfiv$645<2

Xliwi$mrgviewiw${ivi$tevxmepp}$sjjwix$f}$(6824$qmppmsr$vipexih$xs$gsrxvegx$xivqmrexmsrw3gpswyviw$sj$yrhivyxmpm~ih$jegmpmxmiw2

Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw

Viziryiw$jsv$Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw$mr$645=$gsqtevih$xs$645<$higviewih$f}$(652=$qmppmsr2$[i$i|tivmirgih$e$rix$higviewi$mr

viziryiw$sj$(72:$qmppmsr${lmgl${ew$tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs$xli$xverwmxmsr$sj$syv$Tevopie$Gsvvigxmsrep$Girxvi$f}$syv$Eywxvepmer$wyfwmhmev}$xs$e

ri{$stivexsv$mr$Qevgl$645=2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0${i$leh$e$higviewi$hyi$xs$jsvimkr$i|glerki$vexi$jpygxyexmsrw$sj$(5<26$qmppmsr$viwypxmrk$jvsq

xli$wxvirkxlirmrk$sj$xli$Y2W2$hsppev$ekemrwx$givxemr$mrxivrexmsrep$gyvvirgmiw2

Jegmpmx}$Gsrwxvygxmsr$*$Hiwmkr

Fikmrrmrk$mr$xli$jsyvxl$uyevxiv$sj$645<$erh$mrxs$645=0${i$leh$jegmpmx}$gsrwxvygxmsr$*$hiwmkr$wivzmgiw$vipexih$xs$er$i|terwmsr

tvsnigx$ex$syv$Jypleq$Gsvvigxmsrep$Girxvi$mr$Eywxvepme${lmgl$mw$i|tigxih$xs$fi$gsqtpixih$mr$xli$xlmvh$uyevxiv$sj$64642

Stivexmrk$I|tirwiw

$ 645= $)$sj$$Wikqirx

Viziryiw $ 645< $)$sj$$Wikqirx

Viziryiw $ ($Glerki $ )$Glerki

$ ,Hsppevw$mr$xlsywerhw-

Y2W2$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw ( 5064405== $ :829) $ (5055<0;5= $ :72;) $ ( <508<4 $ ;27$)

KIS$Gevi 85;0876 $ 6628) $ 7=70<9: $ 6628) $ 6709;: $ :24$)

Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw 6570667 $ 5529) $ 67<0=;5 $ 572:) $ ,690;8<- $ ,542<-)

Jegmpmx}$Gsrwxvygxmsr$*$Hiwmkr 6=0=48 $ 52:) $ 8066: $ 426) $ 690:;< $ 54424$)

Xsxep ( 50<:40;9< $ 54424) $ (50;990;;6 $ 54424) $ ( 5480=<: $ :24$)

Stivexmrk$i|tirwiw$gsrwmwx$sj$xlswi$i|tirwiw$mrgyvvih$mr$xli$stivexmsr$erh$qerekiqirx$sj$syv$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw0$KIS$Gevi$erh

Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw$jegmpmxmiw$erh$i|tirwiw$mrgyvvih$mr$syv$Jegmpmx}$Gsrwxvygxmsr$*$Hiwmkr$wikqirx2

Y2W2$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw

99

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 83 of 253

Page 106: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq <7367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Stivexmrk$i|tirwiw$jsv$Y2W2$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$mrgviewih$f}$(<529$qmppmsr$mr$645=$gsqtevih$xs$645<2$Xli$mrgviewi${ew

tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs$ekkvikexi$rix$mrgviewiw$mr$tstypexmsr0$xverwtsvxexmsr$wivzmgiw$erh$xli$zevmefpi$gswxw$ewwsgmexih${mxl$xlswi$wivzmgiw$sj

(972=$qmppmsr2$[i$epws$leh$mrgviewiw$sj$(8529$qmppmsr$viwypxmrk$jvsq$xli$egxmzexmsr$sj$syv$gsrxvegxw$ex$syv$gsqter}1s{rih$erh

tvizmsywp}$mhpih$Wsyxl$Psymwmere$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxiv$mr$Fewmpi0$Psymwmere$hyvmrk$xli$xlmvh$uyevxiv$sj$645=0$syv$gsqter}1s{rih

Iekpi$Teww$Gsvvigxmsrep$Jegmpmx}$mr$Iekpi$Teww0$Xi|ew${lmgl${ew$egxmzexih$hyvmrk$xli$jsyvxl$uyevxiv$sj$645<0$syv$gsqter}1s{rih$erh

tvizmsywp}$mhpih$Rsvxl$Peoi$Gsvvigxmsrep$Jegmpmx}$mr$Feph{mr0$Qmglmker${lmgl${ew$egxmzexih$sr$Sgxsfiv$50$645=0$xli$gsyrx}1s{rih

Viiziw$Gsyrx}$Hixirxmsr$Girxiv$M$*$MM$mr$Viiziw$Gsyrx}0$Xi|ew${lmgl${ew$egxmzexih$sr$Sgxsfiv$50$645=$erh$syv$gsrxvegx$i|terwmsr$ex

syv$gsqter}1s{rih$Qsrxksqiv}$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxiv$mr$Gsrvsi0$Xi|ew$mr$xli$xlmvh$uyevxiv$sj$645=2$Xliwi$mrgviewiw${ivi$tevxmepp}

sjjwix$f}$higviewiw$sj$(572=$qmppmsr$ex$givxemr$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs$gsrxvegx$xivqmrexmsrw2

KIS$Gevi

Stivexmrk$i|tirwiw$jsv$KIS$Gevi$mrgviewih$hyvmrk$645=$jvsq$645<$tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs$er$mrgviewi$sj$(7829$qmppmsr$vipexih$xs

ri{$tvskveqw$egxmzexih$mr$Higiqfiv$645<$erh$mrgviewiw$mr$girwyw$pizipw$ex$givxemr$sj$syv$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$erh$viirxv}$girxivw2$[i

epws$i|tivmirgih$er$mrgviewi$sj$(5828$qmppmsr$vipexih$xs$mrgviewiw$mr$eziveki$gpmirx$erh$tevxmgmterx$gsyrxw$yrhiv$syv$MWET$erh

ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$wivzmgiw2$Xliwi$mrgviewiw${ivi$tevxmepp}$sjjwix$f}$higviewiw$sj$(6927$qmppmsr$jvsq$gsrxvegx$xivqmrexmsrw3gpswyviw

sj$yrhivyxmpm~ih$jegmpmxmiw2

Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw

Stivexmrk$i|tirwiw$jsv$Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw$mr$645=$gsqtevih$xs$645<$higviewih$f}$(692;$qmppmsr2$Xlmw$higviewi${ew

tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs$jsvimkr$i|glerki$vexi$jpygxyexmsrw$sj$(5:29$qmppmsr$viwypxmrk$jvsq$xli$wxvirkxlirmrk$sj$xli$Y2W2$hsppev$ekemrwx$givxemr

mrxivrexmsrep$gyvvirgmiw2$[i$epws$i|tivmirgih$e$rix$higviewi$mr$stivexmrk$i|tirwiw$sj$(=26$qmppmsr${lmgl${ew$tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs$xli

xverwmxmsr$sj$syv$Tevopie$Gsvvigxmsrep$Girxvi$f}$syv$Eywxvepmer$wyfwmhmev}$xs$e$ri{$stivexsv$mr$Qevgl$645=2

Jegmpmx}$Gsrwxvygxmsr$*$Hiwmkr

Fikmrrmrk$mr$xli$jsyvxl$uyevxiv$sj$645<$erh$mrxs$645=0${i$leh$jegmpmx}$gsrwxvygxmsr$*$hiwmkr$wivzmgiw$vipexih$xs$er$i|terwmsr

tvsnigx$ex$syv$Jypleq$Gsvvigxmsrep$Girxvi$mr$Eywxvepme${lmgl$mw$i|tigxih$xs$fi$gsqtpixih$mr$xli$xlmvh$uyevxiv$sj$64642

Hitvigmexmsr$erh$Eqsvxm~exmsr

$ 645= $

)$sj$WikqirxViziryi $ 645< $

)$sj$WikqirxViziryi $ ($Glerki $ )$Glerki

$ ,Hsppevw$mr$xlsywerhw-

Y2W2$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw ( ;<0=;8 $ 82=) $ ( ;:0<45 $ 925) $ ( 605;7 $ 62<$)

KIS$Gevi 8=0;<5 $ <25) $ 8;098: $ <26) $ 60679 $ 82;$)

Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw 604;4 $ 42=) $ 604<; $ 42<) $ ,5;- $ ,42<-)

Xsxep ( 5740<69 $ 927) $ ( 56:0878 $ 928) $ ( 807=5 $ 729$)

Y2W2$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw

Y2W2$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr$i|tirwi$mrgviewih$mr$645=$gsqtevih$xs$645<$tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs$xli

egxmzexmsr$sj$syv$gsrxvegxw$ex$syv$gsqter}1s{rih$Iekpi$Teww$Jegmpmx}$mr$Iekpi$Teww0$Xi|ew0$syv$gsqter}1s{rih$Qsrxksqiv}

Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxiv$mr$Gsrvsi0$Xi|ew0$syv$tvizmsywp}$mhpih$Rsvxl$Peoi$Gsvvigxmsrep$Jegmpmx}$mr$Feph{mr0$Qmglmker$erh$syv$gsqter}1

s{rih$Wsyxl$Psymwmere$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxiv$mr$Fewmpi$Psymwmere0$ew${ipp$ew$virszexmsrw$qehi$ex$wizivep$sj$syv$sxliv$jegmpmxmiw2

KIS$Gevi

KIS$Gevi$hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr$i|tirwi$mrgviewih$mr$645=$gsqtevih$xs$645<$tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs$virszexmsrw$ex$givxemr

sj$syv$girxivw2

9:

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 84 of 253

Page 107: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq <8367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw

Hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr$i|tirwi$higviewih$wpmklxp}$mr$645=$gsqtevih$xs$645<$ew$e$viwypx$sj$givxemr$ewwixw$figsqmrk

jypp}$hitvigmexih$erh$xlivi${ivi$rs$wmkrmjmgerx$virszexmsrw$hyvmrk$645<$sv$645=$ex$syv$mrxivrexmsrep$wyfwmhmevmiw2

Sxliv$Yreppsgexih$Stivexmrk$I|tirwiw

$ 645= $ )$sj$Viziryi $ 645< $ )$sj$Viziryi $ ($Glerki $ )$Glerki

$ ,Hsppevw$mr$xlsywerhw-

Kirivep$erh$Ehqmrmwxvexmzi

I|tirwiw ( 5<90=6: $ ;29) $ ( 5<80959 $ <26) $ ( 50855 $ 42<)

Kirivep$erh$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw$gsqtvmwi$wyfwxerxmepp}$epp$sj$syv$sxliv$yreppsgexih$stivexmrk$i|tirwiw${lmgl$tvmqevmp}

mrgpyhiw$gsvtsvexi$qerekiqirx$wepevmiw$erh$firijmxw0$tvsjiwwmsrep$jiiw$erh$sxliv$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw2$Kirivep$erh$ehqmrmwxvexmzi

i|tirwiw$mrgviewih$mr$645=$gsqtevih$xs$645<$tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs$rsvqep$tivwsrrip$erh$gsqtirwexmsr$ehnywxqirxw0$tvsjiwwmsrep0

gsrwypxmrk0$fywmriww$hizipstqirx$erh$sxliv$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw$fyx$epws$higviewih$ew$e$tivgirxeki$sj$viziryi$hyi$xs$gswx$wezmrk

mrmxmexmziw2

Rsr$Stivexmrk$Mrgsqi$erh$I|tirwi

Mrxiviwx$Mrgsqi$erh$Mrxiviwx$I|tirwi

$ 645= $ )$sj$Viziryi $ 645< $ )$sj$Viziryi $ ($Glerki $ )$Glerki

$ ,Hsppevw$mr$xlsywerhw-

Mrxiviwx$Mrgsqi ( 6<0=78 $ 526) $ ( 780;99 $ 529) $ ( ,90<65- $ ,5:2;-)

Mrxiviwx$I|tirwi ( 5950468 $ :25) $ ( 5940547 $ :28) $ ( =65 $ 42:$)

Mrxiviwx$mrgsqi$higviewih$mr$645=$gsqtevih$xs$645<$tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs$e$ps{iv$fepergi$sr$syv$gsrxvegx$vigimzefpi$vipexih$xs$syv

jegmpmx}$mr$Vezirlepp0$Eywxvepme2$Epws$gsrxvmfyxmrk$xs$xli$higviewi${ew$xli$ijjigx$sj$xli$wxvirkxlirmrk$sj$xli$Y2W2$hsppev$ekemrwx$givxemr

mrxivrexmsrep$gyvvirgmiw2

Mrxiviwx$i|tirwi$mr$645=$mrgviewih$wpmklxp}$gsqtevih$xs$645<$tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs$lmkliv$eziveki$hifx$fepergiw$sr$syv$Vizspziv

hyvmrk$645=$gsqtevih$xs$645<2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$571$Hifx$sj$xli$Rsxiw$xs$xli$eyhmxih$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$MM0

Mxiq$<$sj$xlmw$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O2

Psww$sr$I|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$Hifx

$ 645= $)$sj$

Viziryi $ 645< $)$sj$

Viziryi $ ($Glerki $ )$Glerki

$ ,Hsppevw$mr$xlsywerhw-

Psww$sr$I|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$Hifx ( 80;=9 $ Ó) $ ( Ó $ Ó) $ ( 80;=9 $ 54424)

Sr$Qe}$660$645=0${i$gsqtpixih$er$sjjivmrk$sj$rsr1vigsyvwi$rsxiw$vipexih$xs$syv$Vezirlepp$jegmpmx}$mr$Eywxvepme2$Xli$rix$tvsgiihw$jvsq

xlmw$sjjivmrk${ivi$ywih$xs$vijmrergi$syv$syxwxerhmrk$gsrwxvygxmsr$jegmpmx}2$Ew$e$viwypx$sj$xli$xverwegxmsr0${i$mrgyvvih$e$(829$qmppmsr$psww

sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx$vipexih$xs$w{et$xivqmrexmsr$jiiw$erh$yreqsvxm~ih$hijivvih$pser$gswxw$ewwsgmexih${mxl$xli$Gsrwxvygxmsr

Jegmpmx}2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$sr$Nyri$560$645=0$KIS$irxivih$mrxs$Eqirhqirx$Rs2$6$xs$syv$gvihmx$ekviiqirx2$Yrhiv$xli$eqirhqirx0$xli

qexyvmx}$hexi$sj$syv$Vizspziv$lew$fiir$i|xirhih$xs$Qe}$5;0$64682$Ew$e$viwypx$sj$xli$eqirhqirx0${i$mrgyvvih$e$psww$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx

sj$hifx$sj$(526$qmppmsr$vipexih$xs$givxemr$yreqsvxm~ih$hijivvih$pser$gswxw2

Ehhmxmsrepp}0$hyvmrk$645=0${i$vityvglewih$ettvs|mqexip}$(9:$qmppmsr$mr$ekkvikexi$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj$syv$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi

6466$ex$e${imklxih$eziveki$tvmgi$sj$=;299)$jsv$e$xsxep$gswx$sj$(982;$qmppmsr2$Ew$xli$viwypx$sj$xli$vityvglewiw0{i$vigskrm~ih$e$rix$kemr

sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx$sj$(42=$qmppmsr${lmgl$tevxmepp}$sjjwix$xli$psww$hmwgywwih$efszi2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$571$Hifx$sj$xli$Rsxiw$xs$xli

eyhmxih$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$MM0$Mxiq$<$sj$xlmw$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O2

Tvszmwmsr$jsv$Mrgsqi$Xe|iw

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 85 of 253

Page 108: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq <9367<

9;

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 86 of 253

Page 109: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq <:367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$ 645= $ Ijjigxmzi$Vexi $ 645< $ Ijjigxmzi$Vexi $ ($Glerki $ )$Glerki

$ ,Hsppevw$mr$xlsywerhw- $ $ $ $

Tvszmwmsr$jsv$Mrgsqi$Xe|iw

( 5:0:8< $ =2:) $ ( 58055; $ =29) $ ( 60975 $ 5;2=)

$$$$

Xli$tvszmwmsr$jsv$mrgsqi$xe|iw$mr$645=$mrgviewih$gsqtevih$xs$645<$epsrk${mxl$xli$ijjigxmzi$xe|$vexi${lmgl$mw$hyi$xs$e$glerki

mr$xli$gsqtswmxmsr$sj$syv$mrgsqi$erh$givxemr$rsr1vigyvvmrk$mxiqw2$Mr$645=0$xlivi${ew$e$(429$qmppmsr$hmwgvixi$xe|$firijmx0$rix$sj$e$(426

qmppmsr$hmwgvixi$xe|$i|tirwi$vipexih$xs$wxsgo$gsqtirwexmsr$xlex$ziwxih$hyvmrk$xli$tivmsh2$Mr$gsrxvewx0$mr$645<$xlivi${ew$e$(628$qmppmsr

hmwgvixi$xe|$firijmx0$rix$sj$e$(42=$qmppmsr$hmwgvixi$xe|$i|tirwi$vipexih$xs$wxsgo$gsqtirwexmsr$xlex$ziwxih$hyvmrk$xlex$tivmsh2$Ew$e$VIMX0

{i$evi$viuymvih$xs$hmwxvmfyxi$ex$piewx$=4)$sj$syv$xe|efpi$mrgsqi$xs$wlevilsphivw$erh$mr$xyvr$evi$epps{ih$e$hihygxmsr$jsv$xli$hmwxvmfyxmsr

ex$xli$VIMX$pizip2$Syv${lspp}1s{rih$xe|efpi$VIMX$wyfwmhmevmiw$gsrxmryi$xs$fi$jypp}$wyfnigx$xs$jihivep0$wxexi$erh$jsvimkr$mrgsqi$xe|iw0

ew$ettpmgefpi2$[i$iwxmqexi$syv$erryep$ijjigxmzi$xe|$vexi$xs$fi$mr$xli$verki$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$54)$xs$56)$i|gpywmzi$sj$er}$hmwgvixi

mxiqw2

2

2

Iuymx}$mr$Ievrmrkw$sj$Ejjmpmexiw

$ 645= $ )$sj$Viziryi $ 645< $ )$sj$Viziryi $ ($Glerki $ )$Glerki

$ ,Hsppevw$mr$xlsywerhw-

Iuymx}$mr$Ievrmrkw$sj

Ejjmpmexiw ( =0976 $ 428) $ ( =0:6; $ 428) $ ( ,=9- $ ,524-)

Iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw0$tviwirxih$rix$sj$mrgsqi$xe|iw0$vitviwirxw$xli$ievrmrkw$sj$WEGW$erh$KISEqi}$mr$xli

ekkvikexi2$Iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw$mr$645=$gsqtevih$xs$645<$higviewih$wpmklxp}$tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs$pefsv$vipexih$i|tirwiw$mr

gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$veqt$yt$sj$KISEqi}+w$gsyvx$gywxsh}$erh$iwgsvx$wivzmgiw$gsrxvegx$mr$Wgsxperh${lmgl$fiker$mr$xli$jmvwx$uyevxiv$sj

645=2

Jmrergmep$Gsrhmxmsr

Getmxep$Viuymviqirxw

Syv$gyvvirx$gewl$viuymviqirxw$gsrwmwx$sj$eqsyrxw$riihih$jsv${svomrk$getmxep0$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$sj$syv$VIMX$xe|efpi$mrgsqi$mr$svhiv

xs$qemrxemr$syv$VIMX$uyepmjmgexmsr$yrhiv$xli$Gshi0$hifx$wivzmgi0$wyttp}$tyvglewiw0$mrziwxqirxw$mr$nsmrx$zirxyviw0$erh$getmxep

i|tirhmxyviw$vipexih$xs$imxliv$xli$hizipstqirx$sj$ri{$wigyvi0$tvsgiwwmrk$erh$viirxv}$jegmpmxmiw0$sv$xli$qemrxirergi$sj$i|mwxmrk$jegmpmxmiw2

Mr$ehhmxmsr0$wsqi$sj$syv$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$viuymvi$yw$xs$qeoi$wyfwxerxmep$mrmxmep$i|tirhmxyviw$sj$gewl$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$stirmrk

sv$virszexmrk$e$jegmpmx}2$Kirivepp}0$xliwi$mrmxmep$i|tirhmxyviw$evi$wyfwiuyirxp}$jypp}$sv$tevxmepp}$vigszivefpi$ew$teww1xlvsykl$gswxw$sv$evi

fmppefpi$ew$e$gsqtsrirx$sj$xli$tiv$hmiq$vexiw$sv$qsrxlp}$jm|ih$jiiw$xs$xli$gsrxvegxmrk$ekirg}$sziv$xli$svmkmrep$xivq$sj$xli$gsrxvegx2

Ehhmxmsrep$getmxep$riihw$qe}$epws$evmwi$mr$xli$jyxyvi${mxl$viwtigx$xs$tswwmfpi$eguymwmxmsrw0$sxliv$gsvtsvexi$xverwegxmsrw$sv$sxliv

gsvtsvexi$tyvtswiw2

Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0${i${ivi$hizipstmrk$e$ryqfiv$sj$tvsnigxw$xlex${i$iwxmqexi${mpp$gswx$ettvs|mqexip}$(:5$qmppmsr0$sj

{lmgl$(6<$qmppmsr${ew$wtirx$xlvsykl$Higiqfiv$750$645=2$[i$iwxmqexi$syv$viqemrmrk$getmxep$viuymviqirxw$xs$fi$ettvs|mqexip}$(77

qmppmsr2$Xliwi$tvsnigxw$evi$i|tigxih$xs$fi$gsqtpixih$xlvsykl$64642

Pmuymhmx}$erh$Getmxep$Viwsyvgiw

Eqirhih$erh$Viwxexih$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 87 of 253

Page 110: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq <;367<

Sr$Nyri$560$645=0${i$irxivih$mrxs$Eqirhqirx$Rs2$6$xs$Xlmvh$Eqirhih$erh$Viwxexih$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$,xli$&Gvihmx

Ekviiqirx&-$f}$erh$eqsrk$xli$vijmrergmrk$pirhivw$tevx}$xlivixs0$xli$sxliv$pirhivw$tevx}$xlivixs0$KIS$erh$KIS$Gsvvigxmsrw$Lsphmrkw0

Mrg2$erh$xli$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$ekirx2$Yrhiv$xli$eqirhqirx0$xli$qexyvmx}$hexi$sj$xli$vizspziv$gsqtsrirx$sj$xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$lew$fiir

i|xirhih$xs$Qe}$5;0$64682$Xli$fsvvs{mrk$getegmx}$yrhiv$xli$eqirhih$vizspziv${mpp$viqemr$ex$(=44

9<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 88 of 253

Page 111: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq <<367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

qmppmsr0$erh$mxw$tvmgmrk${mpp$viqemr$yrglerkih0$gyvvirxp}$fievmrk$mrxiviwx$ex$PMFSV$tpyw$6269)2$Ew$e$viwypx$sj$xli$xverwegxmsr0${i

mrgyvvih$e$psww$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx$sj$(526$qmppmsr$vipexih$xs$givxemr$yreqsvxm~ih$hijivvih$pser$gswxw2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$pser$gswxw$sj

(82;$qmppmsr${ivi$mrgyvvih$erh$getmxepm~ih$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$xverwegxmsr2

E$w}rhmgexi$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$:9$pirhivw$tevxmgmtexi$mr$syv$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx0$wm|$sj${lmgl$lezi$mrhmgexih$xlex$xli}$hs$rsx$mrxirh$xs

tvszmhi$ri{$jmrergmrk$xs$KIS$fyx${mpp$lsrsv$xlimv$i|mwxmrk$sfpmkexmsrw$,Vijiv$xs$Mxiq$5E$1$Vmwo$Jegxsvw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$M$sj$xlmw

Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O$jsv$jyvxliv$hmwgywwmsr$sr$givxemr$jmrergmep$mrwxmxyxmsrw${ls$errsyrgih$hyvmrk$645=$xlex$xli}${mpp$rsx$fi

viri{mrk$i|mwxmrk$ekviiqirxw$sv$irxivmrk$mrxs$ri{$ekviiqirxw${mxl$gsqtermiw$xlex$stivexi$gsvvigxmsrep$jegmpmxmiw0$tvsgiwwmrk$girxivw

erh$gsqqyrmx}$viirxv}$girxivw$yrhiv$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw-2$Xli$ferow$xlex$lezi${mxlhve{r$tevxmgmtexmsr$viqemr$gsrxvegxyepp}

gsqqmxxih$jsv$ettvs|mqexip}$jsyv$}ievw2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$xliwi$wm|$ferow$vitviwirx$piww$xler$69)$sj$syv$szivepp$fsvvs{mrk$getegmx}$yrhiv

syv$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$erh$xli${mxlhve{ep$sj$xlimv$tevxmgmtexmsr$mw$rsx$i|tigxih$xs$rikexmzip}$mqtegx$syv$jmrergmep$jpi|mfmpmx}2$[i$evi

epws$mr$jviuyirx$gsqqyrmgexmsr${mxl$tsxirxmep$ri{$pirhivw$ew${ipp$ew$xli$gvihmx$vexmrk$ekirgmiw${ls$lezi$rsx$glerkih$syv$gvihmx$vexmrkw

jsv$sziv$77$qsrxlw2

Xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$izmhirgiw$e$gvihmx$jegmpmx}$,xli$&Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}&-$gsrwmwxmrk$sj$xli$(;=624$qmppmsr$xivq$pser$hmwgywwih$efszi$,xli

&Xivq$Pser&-$fievmrk$mrxiviwx$ex$PMFSV$tpyw$6244)$,{mxl$e$PMFSV$jpssv$sj$42;9)-0$erh$e$(=4424$qmppmsr$vizspziv$mrmxmepp}$fievmrk

mrxiviwx$ex$PMFSV$tpyw$6269)$,{mxl$rs$PMFSV$jpssv-$xskixliv${mxl$EYH6;9$qmppmsr$ezempefpi$wspip}$jsv$xli$mwwyergi$sj$jmrergmep

pixxivw$sj$gvihmx$erh$tivjsvqergi$pixxivw$sj$gvihmx0$mr$iegl$gewi$hirsqmrexih$mr$Eywxvepmer$Hsppevw$yrhiv$xli$Eywxvepmer$Hsppev$Pixxiv$sj

Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}$,xli$&Eywxvepmer$PG$Jegmpmx}&-2$Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$xlivi${ivi$rs$pixxivw$sj$gvihmx$mwwyih$yrhiv$xli$Eywxvepmer$PG

Jegmpmx}2$Eqsyrxw$xs$fi$fsvvs{ih$f}$KIS$yrhiv$xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$evi$wyfnigx$xs$xli$wexmwjegxmsr$sj$gywxsqev}$gsrhmxmsrw$xs

fsvvs{mrk2$Xli$Xivq$Pser$gsqtsrirx$mw$wglihypih$xs$qexyvi$sr$Qevgl$670$64682$Xli$vizspzmrk$gvihmx$gsqqmxqirx$gsqtsrirx$mw

wglihypih$xs$qexyvi$sr$Qe}$5;0$64682$Xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$epws$lew$er$eggsvhmsr$jiexyvi$sj$(89424$qmppmsr0$wyfnigx$xs$pirhiv$hiqerh

erh$tvizempmrk$qevoix$gsrhmxmsrw$erh$wexmwj}mrk$xli$vipizerx$fsvvs{mrk$gsrhmxmsrw2

Xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$gsrxemrw$givxemr$gywxsqev}$vitviwirxexmsrw$erh${evverxmiw0$erh$givxemr$gywxsqev}$gszirerxw$xlex$viwxvmgx$KIS×w

efmpmx}$xs0$eqsrk$sxliv$xlmrkw$,m-$gviexi0$mrgyv$sv$ewwyqi$er}$mrhifxihriww0$,mm-$gviexi0$mrgyv0$ewwyqi$sv$tivqmx$pmirw0$,mmm-$qeoi$pserw

erh$mrziwxqirxw0$,mz-$irkeki$mr$qivkivw0$eguymwmxmsrw$erh$ewwix$wepiw0$,z-$qeoi$givxemr$viwxvmgxih$te}qirxw0$,zm-$mwwyi0$wipp$sv$sxliv{mwi

hmwtswi$sj$getmxep$wxsgo0$,zmm-$irkeki$mr$xverwegxmsrw${mxl$ejjmpmexiw0$,zmmm-$epps{$xli$xsxep$piziveki$vexms$xs$i|giih$:269$xs$52440$epps{$xli

wirmsv$wigyvih$piziveki$vexms$xs$i|giih$7294$xs$52440$sv$epps{$xli$mrxiviwx$gsziveki$vexms$xs$fi$piww$xler$7244$xs$52440$,m|-$gergip0$jsvkmzi0

qeoi$er}$zspyrxev}$sv$stxmsrep$te}qirx$sv$tvite}qirx$sr0$sv$vihiiq$sv$eguymvi$jsv$zepyi$er}$wirmsv$rsxiw0$i|gitx$ew$tivqmxxih0$,|-

epxiv$xli$fywmriww$KIS$gsrhygxw0$erh$,|m-$qexivmepp}$mqtemv$KIS×w$pirhivw×$wigyvmx}$mrxiviwxw$mr$xli$gsppexivep$jsv$mxw$pserw2

Izirxw$sj$hijeypx$yrhiv$xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$mrgpyhi0$fyx$evi$rsx$pmqmxih$xs0$,m-$KIS×w$jempyvi$xs$te}$tvmrgmtep$sv$mrxiviwx${lir$hyi0$,mm-

KIS×w$qexivmep$fviegl$sj$er}$vitviwirxexmsr$sv${evverx}0$,mmm-$gszirerx$hijeypxw0$,mz-$pmuymhexmsr0$visvkerm~exmsr$sv$sxliv$vipmij$vipexmrk

xs$ferovytxg}$sv$mrwspzirg}0$,z-$gvsww$hijeypx$yrhiv$givxemr$sxliv$qexivmep$mrhifxihriww0$,zm-$yrwexmwjmih$jmrep$nyhkqirxw$sziv$e

wtigmjmih$xlviwlsph0$,zmm-$givxemr$qexivmep$irzmvsrqirxep$pmefmpmx}$gpemqw$ewwivxih$ekemrwx$KIS0$erh$,zmmm-$e$glerki$mr$gsrxvsp2

Epp$sj$xli$sfpmkexmsrw$yrhiv$xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$evi$yrgsrhmxmsrepp}$kyeverxiih$f}$givxemr$hsqiwxmg$wyfwmhmevmiw$sj$KIS$erh$xli

Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$erh$xli$vipexih$kyeverxiiw$evi$wigyvih$f}$e$tivjigxih$jmvwx1tvmsvmx}$tpihki$sj$wyfwxerxmepp}$epp$sj$KIS×w$tviwirx$erh

jyxyvi$xerkmfpi$erh$mrxerkmfpi$hsqiwxmg$ewwixw$erh$epp$tviwirx$erh$jyxyvi$xerkmfpi$erh$mrxerkmfpi$hsqiwxmg$ewwixw$sj$iegl$kyeverxsv0

mrgpyhmrk$fyx$rsx$pmqmxih$xs$e$jmvwx1tvmsvmx}$tpihki$sj$epp$sj$xli$syxwxerhmrk$getmxep$wxsgo$s{rih$f}$KIS$erh$iegl$kyeverxsv$mr$xlimv

hsqiwxmg$wyfwmhmevmiw2

Xli$Eywxvepmer$fsvvs{ivw$evi${lspp}$s{rih$jsvimkr$wyfwmhmevmiw$sj$KIS2$KIS$lew$hiwmkrexih$iegl$sj$xli$Eywxvepmer$fsvvs{ivw$ew

viwxvmgxih$wyfwmhmevmiw$yrhiv$xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx2$Ls{iziv0$xli$Eywxvepmer$fsvvs{ivw$evi$rsx$sfpmkexih$xs$te}$sv$tivjsvq$er}

sfpmkexmsrw$yrhiv$xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$sxliv$xler$xlimv$s{r$sfpmkexmsrw$ew$Eywxvepmer$fsvvs{ivw$yrhiv$xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx2$Xli

Eywxvepmer$fsvvs{ivw$hs$rsx$tpihki$er}$sj$xlimv$ewwixw$xs$wigyvi$er}$sfpmkexmsrw$yrhiv$xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx2

Sr$Eykywx$5<0$645:0${i$i|igyxih$e$Pixxiv$sj$Sjjiv$f}$erh$eqsrk$KIS$erh$LWFG$Fero$Eywxvepme$Pmqmxih$,xli$ÔPixxiv$sj

SjjivÕ-$tvszmhmrk$jsv$e$fero$kyeverxii$pmri$erh$fero$kyeverxii3wxerhf}$wyf1jegmpmx}$mr$er$ekkvikexi$eqsyrx$sj$EYH544$qmppmsr0$sv

(;425$qmppmsr0$fewih$sr$i|glerki$vexiw$mr$ijjigx$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=$,gsppigxmzip}0$xli$ÔFero$Kyeverxii$Jegmpmx}Õ-2$Xli$Fero

Kyeverxii$Jegmpmx}$epps{w$KIS$xs$tvszmhi$pixxivw$sj$gvihmx$xs$ewwyvi$tivjsvqergi$sj$givxemr$sfpmkexmsrw$sj$mxw${lspp}$s{rih$wyfwmhmev}

vipexmrk$xs$mxw$wigyvi$jegmpmx}$tvsnigx$mr$Vezirlepp0$psgexih$riev$Qipfsyvri0$Eywxvepme2$Mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$xli$Vezirlepp$Gsrxvegx0$ytsr

xli$gsqtpixmsr$sj$e$givxemr$tivmsh$sj$stivexmsrw0$xli$Fero$Kyeverxii$Jegmpmx}${ew$vihygih$hyvmrk$xli$jsyvxl$uyevxiv$sj$645=$xs

ettvs|mqexip}$EYH9<$qmppmsr0$sv$(842;$qmppmsr0$fewih$sr$i|glerki$vexiw$mr

9=

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 89 of 253

Page 112: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq <=367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

ijjigx$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=2Xli$Fero$Kyeverxii$Jegmpmx}$mw$yrwigyvih2$Xli$mwwyergi$sj$pixxivw$sj$gvihmx$yrhiv$xli$Fero$Kyeverxii

Jegmpmx}$mw$wyfnigx$xs$xli$wexmwjegxmsr$sj$xli$gsrhmxmsrw$tvigihirx$wtigmjmih$mr$xli$Pixxiv$sj$Sjjiv2$Pixxivw$sj$gvihmx$mwwyih$yrhiv$xli$fero

kyeverxii$pmriw$evi$hyi$sr$hiqerh$erh$pixxivw$sj$gvihmx$mwwyih$yrhiv$xli$fero$kyeverxii3wxerhf}$wyf1jegmpmx}$gerrsx$lezi$e$hyvexmsr

i|giihmrk$x{ipzi$qsrxlw2$Xli$Fero$Kyeverxii$Jegmpmx}$qe}$fi$xivqmrexih$f}$LWFG$Fero$Eywxvepme$Pmqmxih$sr$=4$he}w${vmxxir

rsxmgi2$Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$xlivi${ew$EYH9<$qmppmsr$mr$pixxivw$sj$gvihmx$mwwyih$yrhiv$xli$Fero$Kyeverxii$Jegmpmx}2

Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0${i$leh$(;;<24$qmppmsr$mr$ekkvikexi$fsvvs{mrkw$syxwxerhmrk$yrhiv$xli$Xivq$Pser$erh$(9642;

qmppmsr$mr$fsvvs{mrkw$yrhiv$xli$Vizspziv0$erh$ettvs|mqexip}$(:624$qmppmsr$mr$pixxivw$sj$gvihmx${lmgl$pijx$(75;24$qmppmsr$mr$ehhmxmsrep

fsvvs{mrk$getegmx}$yrhiv$xli$Vizspziv2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0${i$lezi$xli$efmpmx}$xs$mrgviewi$xli$Wirmsv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}$f}$er$ehhmxmsrep$(89424

qmppmsr0$wyfnigx$xs$pirhiv$hiqerh$erh$tvizempmrk$qevoix$gsrhmxmsrw$erh$wexmwj}mrk$xli$vipizerx$fsvvs{mrk$gsrhmxmsrw$xliviyrhiv2$Vijiv

xs$Rsxi$57$1$Hifx$mr$xli$rsxiw$xs$syv$eyhmxih$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$MM0$Mxiq$<$sj$xlmw$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr

Jsvq$541O2

:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$646:

Sr$Etvmp$5<0$645:0${i$gsqtpixih$er$sjjivmrk$sj$(79424$qmppmsr$ekkvikexi$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj$:244)$wirmsv$rsxiw$hyi$646:2

Xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw${mpp$qexyvi$sr$Etvmp$590$645:$erh${ivi$mwwyih$ex$e$gsytsr$vexi$erh$}miph$xs$qexyvmx}$sj$:244)2$Mrxiviwx$sr$xli

:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$mw$te}efpi$wiqm1erryepp}$sr$Etvmp$59$erh$Sgxsfiv$59$sj$iegl$}iev0$gsqqirgmrk$sr$Sgxsfiv$590$645:2$[i$ywih$xli

rix$tvsgiihw$xs$jyrh$xli$xirhiv$sjjiv$erh$xli$vihiqtxmsr$sj$epp$sj$syv$:2:69)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$,wii$hmwgywwmsr$fips{-0$xs$te}$epp$vipexih

jiiw0$gswxw$erh$i|tirwiw$erh$jsv$kirivep$gsvtsvexi$tyvtswiw$mrgpyhmrk$vite}mrk$fsvvs{mrkw$yrhiv$syv$tvmsv$vizspziv2$Pser$gswxw$sj

ettvs|mqexip}$(:$qmppmsr${ivi$mrgyvvih$erh$getmxepm~ih$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$sjjivmrk2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$57$1$Hifx$mr$xli$rsxiw$xs$syv

eyhmxih$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$MM0$Mxiq$<$sj$xlmw$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O2

92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468

Sr$Witxiqfiv$690$64580${i$gsqtpixih$er$sjjivmrk$sj$(69424$qmppmsr$ekkvikexi$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj$wirmsv$yrwigyvih$rsxiw2

Xli$rsxiw${mpp$qexyvi$sr$Sgxsfiv$590$6468$erh$lezi$e$gsytsr$vexi$erh$}miph$xs$qexyvmx}$sj$92<;9)2$Mrxiviwx$mw$te}efpi$wiqm1erryepp}

mr$gewl$mr$evvievw$sr$Etvmp$59$erh$Sgxsfiv$590${lmgl$gsqqirgih$sr$Etvmp$590$64592$Xli$tvsgiihw$vigimzih$jvsq$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv

Rsxiw$hyi$6468${ivi$ywih$xs$te}$hs{r$e$tsvxmsr$sj$xli$syxwxerhmrk$mrhifxihriww$yrhiv$xli$vizspziv$tsvxmsr$sj$syv$tvmsv$Wirmsv$Gvihmx

Jegmpmx}2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$57$1$Hifx$mr$xli$rsxiw$xs$syv$eyhmxih$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$MM0$Mxiq$<$sj$xlmw$Erryep

Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O2

92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466

Sr$Sgxsfiv$70$64570${i$gsqtpixih$er$sjjivmrk$sj$(69424$qmppmsr$ekkvikexi$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi

64662$Xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466${mpp$qexyvi$sr$Neryev}$590$6466$erh$lezi$e$gsytsr$vexi$erh$}miph$xs$qexyvmx}$sj$92<;9)2

Mrxiviwx$mw$te}efpi$wiqm1erryepp}$sr$Neryev}$59$erh$Nyp}$59$iegl$}iev0${lmgl$gsqqirgih$sr$Neryev}$590$64582$Xli$tvsgiihw$vigimzih

jvsq$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466${ivi$ywih0$xskixliv${mxl$gewl$sr$lerh0$xs$jyrh$xli$vityvglewi0$vihiqtxmsr$sv$sxliv$hmwglevki

sj$syv$;$738)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$645;$erh$xs$te}$vipexih$xverwegxmsr$jiiw$erh$i|tirwiw2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$57$1$Hifx$mr$xli$rsxiw$xs$syv

eyhmxih$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$MM0$Mxiq$<$sj$xlmw$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O2

92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6467

Sr$Qevgl$5=0$64570${i$gsqtpixih$er$sjjivmrk$sj$(74424$qmppmsr$ekkvikexi$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw2$Xli

92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw${mpp$qexyvi$sr$Etvmp$50$6467$erh$lezi$e$gsytsr$vexi$erh$}miph$xs$qexyvmx}$sj$92569)2$Mrxiviwx$mw$te}efpi$wiqm1

erryepp}$sr$Etvmp$5$erh$Sgxsfiv$5$iegl$}iev0${lmgl$gsqqirgih$sr$Sgxsfiv$50$64572$E$tsvxmsr$sj$xli$tvsgiihw$vigimzih$jvsq$xli

92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw${ivi$ywih$sr$xli$hexi$sj$xli$jmrergmrk$xs$vite}$xli$tvmsv$vizspziv$gvihmx$hve{w$syxwxerhmrk$yrhiv$xli$tvmsv$wirmsv

gvihmx$jegmpmx}2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$57$1$Hifx$mr$xli$rsxiw$xs$syv$eyhmxih$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$MM0$Mxiq$<$sj$xlmw

Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O2

Hifx$Vityvglewiw

Sr$Eykywx$5:0$645=0$syv$Fsevh$sj$Hmvigxsvw$eyxlsvm~ih$yw$xs$vityvglewi$erh3sv$vixmvi$e$tsvxmsr$sj$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi

646:0$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$64680$xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$64670$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466$,gsppigxmzip}$xli

&KIS$Wirmsv$Rsxiw&-$erh$syv$xivq$pser$yrhiv$mxw$Eqirhih$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$xlvsykl$gewl$tyvglewiw0$mr$stir

:4

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 90 of 253

Page 113: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq =4367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

qevoix0$tvmzexip}$riksxmexih$xverwegxmsrw0$sv$sxliv{mwi0$yt$xs$er$ekkvikexi$qe|mqyq$sj$(54424$qmppmsr0$wyfnigx$xs$givxemr$pmqmxexmsrw

xlvsykl$Higiqfiv$750$64642

Hyvmrk$645=0${i$vityvglewih$ettvs|mqexip}$(9:24$qmppmsr$mr$ekkvikexi$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj$syv$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi

6466$ex$e${imklxih$eziveki$tvmgi$sj$=;299)$jsv$e$xsxep$gswx$sj$(982;$qmppmsr2$Ew$e$viwypx$sj$xliwi$vityvglewiw0${i$vigskrm~ih$e$rix$psww

sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx$sj$(427$qmppmsr$hyvmrk$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=2

[i$evi$epws$gsrwmhivmrk$sttsvxyrmxmiw$jsv$jyxyvi$fywmriww$erh3sv$ewwix$eguymwmxmsrw2$Mj${i$evi$rsx$wyggiwwjyp$mr$syv$tyvwymx$sj

xliwi$ri{$tvsnigxw0$syv$gewl$sr$lerh0$gewl$jps{w$jvsq$stivexmsrw$erh$fsvvs{mrkw$yrhiv$xli$i|mwxmrk$Wirmsv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}$qe}$rsx

tvszmhi$wyjjmgmirx$pmuymhmx}$xs$qiix$syv$getmxep$riihw$xlvsykl$6464$erh${i$gsyph$fi$jsvgih$xs$wiio$ehhmxmsrep$jmrergmrk$sv$vijmrergi$syv

i|mwxmrk$mrhifxihriww2$Xlivi$ger$fi$rs$ewwyvergi$xlex$er}$wygl$jmrergmrk$sv$vijmrergmrk${syph$fi$ezempefpi$xs$yw$sr$xivqw$iuyep$xs$sv

qsvi$jezsvefpi$xler$syv$gyvvirx$jmrergmrk$xivqw0$sv$ex$epp2$Mr$xli$jyxyvi0$syv$eggiww$xs$getmxep$erh$efmpmx}$xs$gsqtixi$jsv$jyxyvi$getmxep1

mrxirwmzi$tvsnigxw${mpp$epws$fi$hitirhirx$ytsr0$eqsrk$sxliv$xlmrkw0$syv$efmpmx}$xs$qiix$givxemr$jmrergmep$gszirerxw$mr$xli$mrhirxyviw

kszivrmrk$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466$erh$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi

6468$erh$syv$Wirmsv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}2$E$wyfwxerxmep$higpmri$mr$syv$jmrergmep$tivjsvqergi$gsyph$pmqmx$syv$eggiww$xs$getmxep$tyvwyerx$xs

xliwi$gszirerxw$erh$lezi$e$qexivmep$ehzivwi$ejjigx$sr$syv$pmuymhmx}$erh$getmxep$viwsyvgiw$erh0$ew$e$viwypx0$sr$syv$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh

viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2$Mr$ehhmxmsr$xs$xliwi$jsviksmrk$tsxirxmep$gsrwxvemrxw$sr$syv$getmxep0$e$ryqfiv$sj$wxexi$kszivrqirx$ekirgmiw$lezi

fiir$wyjjivmrk$jvsq$fyhkix$hijmgmxw$erh$pmuymhmx}$mwwyiw2$[lmpi${i$i|tigx$xs$fi$mr$gsqtpmergi${mxl$syv$hifx$gszirerxw0$mj$xliwi

gsrwxvemrxw${ivi$xs$mrxirwmj}0$syv$pmuymhmx}$gsyph$fi$qexivmepp}$ehzivwip}$mqtegxih$ew$gsyph$syv$efmpmx}$xs$viqemr$mr$gsqtpmergi${mxl

xliwi$hifx$gszirerxw2

[i$qe}$jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi$wiio$xs$tyvglewi$sv$vixmvi$syv$syxwxerhmrk$wirmsv$rsxiw$xlvsykl$gewl$tyvglewiw$erh3sv$i|glerkiw$jsv

iuymx}$wigyvmxmiw0$mr$stir$qevoix$tyvglewiw0$tvmzexip}$riksxmexmsr$xverwegxmsrw$sv$sxliv{mwi2$Wygl$vityvglewiw$sv$i|glerkiw0$mj$er}0${mpp

hitirh$sr$tvizempmrk$qevoix$gsrhmxmsrw0$syv$pmuymhmx}$viuymviqirxw0$gsrxvegxyep$viwxvmgxmsrw$erh$sxliv$jegxsvw2$Xli$eqsyrxw$mrzspzih

qe}$fi$qexivmep2

Wxsgo$Fy}fego$Tvskveq

Sr$Jifvyev}580$645<0${i$errsyrgih$xlex$syv$Fsevh$sj$Hmvigxsvw$eyxlsvm~ih$e$wxsgo$fy}fego$tvskveq$eyxlsvm~mrk$yw$xs$vityvglewi$yt

xs$e$qe|mqyq$sj$(644$qmppmsr$sj$syv$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo2$Xli$wxsgo$fy}fego$tvskveq${mpp$fi$jyrhih$tvmqevmp}${mxl$gewl$sr$lerh0

jvii$gewl$jps{$erh$fsvvs{mrkw$yrhiv$syv$Vizspziv2$Xli$tvskveq$mw$ijjigxmzi$xlvsykl$Sgxsfiv$640$64642$Xli$wxsgo$fy}fego$tvskveq$mw

mrxirhih$xs$fi$mqtpiqirxih$xlvsykl$tyvglewiw$qehi$jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi$mr$xli$stir$qevoix$sv$mr$tvmzexip}$riksxmexih$xverwegxmsrw0$ mr

eggsvhergi${mxl$ettpmgefpi$WIG$viuymviqirxw2$Xli$wxsgo$fy}fego$tvskveq$hsiw$rsx$sfpmkexi$yw$xs$tyvglewi$er}$wtigmjmg$eqsyrx$sj$syv

gsqqsr$wxsgo$erh$qe}$fi$wywtirhih$sv$i|xirhih$ex$er}$xmqi$ex$xli$hmwgvixmsr$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$Fsevh$sj$Hmvigxsvw2$Hyvmrk$xli$}iev

irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645<0${i$tyvglewih$806540698$wleviw$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo$ex$e$gswx$sj$(=926$qmppmsr$tvmqevmp}$tyvglewih${mxl

tvsgiihw$jvsq$syv$Vizspziv2$Xlivi${ivi$rs$tyvglewiw$sj$wleviw$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo$hyvmrk$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=2$[i

fipmizi$xlex${i$lezi$xli$efmpmx}$xs$gsrxmryi$xs$jyrh$xli$wxsgo$fy}fego$tvskveq0$syv$hifx$wivzmgi$viuymviqirxw$erh$syv$qemrxirergi$erh

kvs{xl$getmxep$i|tirhmxyvi$viuymviqirxw0${lmpi$qemrxemrmrk$wyjjmgmirx$pmuymhmx}$jsv$sxliv$gsvtsvexi$tyvtswiw2

Tvswtigxyw$Wyttpiqirx

Sr$Sgxsfiv$640$645;0${i$jmpih${mxl$xli$WIG$er$eyxsqexmg$wlipj$vikmwxvexmsr$sr$Jsvq$W17EWV2$Yrhiv$xlmw$wlipj$vikmwxvexmsr0${i$qe}0

jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi0$wipp$er}$gsqfmrexmsr$sj$wigyvmxmiw$hiwgvmfih$mr$xli$tvswtigxyw$mr$sri$sv$qsvi$sjjivmrkw2$Iegl$xmqi$xlex${i$qe}$wipp

wigyvmxmiw0${i${mpp$ tvszmhi$ e$ tvswtigxyw$ wyttpiqirx$ xlex${mpp$ gsrxemr$ wtigmjmg$ mrjsvqexmsr$ efsyx$ xli$ xivqw$ sj$ xlex$ sjjivmrk$ erh$ xli

wigyvmxmiw$ fimrk$ sjjivih2$ Sr$ Rsziqfiv$ =0$ 645;0$ mr$ gsrrigxmsr$ {mxl$ xli$ wlipj$ vikmwxvexmsr0$ {i$ jmpih$ {mxl$ xli$ WIG$ e$ tvswtigxyw

wyttpiqirx$vipexih$xs$xli$sjjiv$erh$wepi$jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo$ex$er$ekkvikexi$sjjivmrk$tvmgi$sj$yt$xs$(594$qmppmsr

xlvsykl$wepiw$ekirxw2$Wepiw$sj$ wleviw$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo$yrhiv$ xli$tvswtigxyw$ wyttpiqirx$erh$ xli$iuymx}$hmwxvmfyxmsr$ekviiqirxw

irxivih$mrxs${mxl$xli$wepiw$ekirxw0$mj$er}0$qe}$fi$qehi$mr$riksxmexih$xverwegxmsrw$sv$xverwegxmsrw$xlex$evi$hiiqih$xs$fi$Ôex$xli$qevoixÕ

sjjivmrkw$ew$hijmrih$mr$Vypi$859$yrhiv$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$Egx$sj$5=772$Xlivi${ivi$rs$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$wsph$yrhiv$xlmw$tvswtigxyw

wyttpiqirx$hyvmrk$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=$sv$645<2

VIMX$Hmwxvmfyxmsrw

Ew$e$VIMX0${i$evi$wyfnigx$xs$e$ryqfiv$sj$svkerm~exmsrep$erh$stivexmsrep$viuymviqirxw0$mrgpyhmrk$e$viuymviqirx$xlex${i

erryepp}$hmwxvmfyxi$xs$syv$wlevilsphivw$er$eqsyrx$iuyep$xs$ex$piewx$=4)$sj$syv$VIMX$xe|efpi$mrgsqi$,hixivqmrih$fijsvi$xli

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 91 of 253

Page 114: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq =5367<

:5

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 92 of 253

Page 115: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq =6367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

hihygxmsr$jsv$hmzmhirhw$temh$erh$f}$i|gpyhmrk$er}$rix$getmxep$kemr-2$Kirivepp}0${i$i|tigx$xs$hmwxvmfyxi$epp$sv$wyfwxerxmepp}$epp$sj$syv

VIMX$xe|efpi$mrgsqi$ws$ew$rsx$xs$fi$wyfnigx$xs$xli$mrgsqi$sv$i|gmwi$xe|$sr$yrhmwxvmfyxih$VIMX$xe|efpi$mrgsqi2$Xli$eqsyrx0$xmqmrk$erh

jviuyirg}$sj$hmwxvmfyxmsrw${mpp$fi$ex$xli$wspi$hmwgvixmsr$sj$syv$Fsevh$sj$Hmvigxsvw$erh${mpp$fi$fewih$ytsr$zevmsyw$jegxsvw2

[i$tper$xs$jyrh$epp$sj$syv$getmxep$riihw0$mrgpyhmrk$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$sj$syv$VIMX$xe|efpi$mrgsqi$mr$svhiv$xs$qemrxemr$syv$VIMX

uyepmjmgexmsr0$erh$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw0$jvsq$gewl$sr$lerh0$gewl$jvsq$stivexmsrw0$fsvvs{mrkw$yrhiv$syv$Wirmsv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}$erh$er}

sxliv$jmrergmrkw${lmgl$syv$qerekiqirx$erh$Fsevh$sj$Hmvigxsvw0$mr$xlimv$hmwgvixmsr0$qe}$gsrwyqqexi2$Gyvvirxp}0$syv$tvmqev}$wsyvgi$sj

pmuymhmx}$xs$qiix$xliwi$viuymviqirxw$mw$gewl$jps{$jvsq$stivexmsrw$erh$fsvvs{mrkw$yrhiv$xli$(=4424$qmppmsr$Vizspziv2$Syv$qerekiqirx

fipmiziw$xlex$gewl$sr$lerh0$gewl$jps{w$jvsq$stivexmsrw$erh$ezempefmpmx}$yrhiv$syv$Wirmsv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}${mpp$fi$ehiuyexi$xs$wyttsvx$syv

getmxep$viuymviqirxw$jsv$6464$ew$hmwgpswih$yrhiv$ÔGetmxep$ViuymviqirxwÕ$efszi2

Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Hifx

$

Rsvxl{iwx$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxiv

Sr$Higiqfiv$=0$64550$xli$[ewlmrkxsr$Igsrsqmg$Hizipstqirx$Jmrergi$Eyxlsvmx}$mwwyih$(9828$qmppmsr$sj$mxw$[ewlmrkxsr

Igsrsqmg$Hizipstqirx$Jmrergi$Eyxlsvmx}$Xe|efpi$Igsrsqmg$Hizipstqirx$Viziryi$Fsrhw0$wivmiw$6455$,Ô6455$Viziryi$FsrhwÕ-2

Xli$te}qirx$sj$tvmrgmtep$erh$mrxiviwx$sr$xli$fsrhw$mw$rsr1vigsyvwi$xs$yw2$Rsri$sj$xli$fsrhw$rsv$Gsvvigxmsrep$Wivzmgiw$Gsvtsvexmsrw+

sfpmkexmsrw$yrhiv$xli$pser$evi$syv$sfpmkexmsrw$rsv$evi$xli}$kyeverxiih$f}$yw2

Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$xli$viqemrmrk$fepergi$sj$xli$hifx$wivzmgi$viuymviqirx$vipexih$xs$xli$6455$Viziryi$Fsrhw$mw$(592;

qmppmsr0$sj${lmgl$(;2;$qmppmsr$mw$gpewwmjmih$ew$gyvvirx$mr$xli$eggsqter}mrk$fepergi$wliix2$Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$mrgpyhih$mr

viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$mrziwxqirxw$mw$(82;$qmppmsr$,epp$gyvvirx-$sj$jyrhw$liph$mr$xvywx${mxl$viwtigx$xs$xli$Rsvxl{iwx$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxiv

jsv$hifx$wivzmgi$erh$sxliv$viwivziw${lmgl$leh$rsx$fiir$vipiewih$xs$yw$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$571Hifx$mr$xli$rsxiw$xs

syv$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$MM0$Mxiq$<$sj$xlmw$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O$jsv$jyvxliv$mrjsvqexmsr2

$$$$

Eywxvepme$1$Vezirlepp

Mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$e$hiwmkr$erh$fymph$jegmpmx}$tvsnigx$ekviiqirx${mxl$xli$Wxexi$sj$Zmgxsvme0$mr$Witxiqfiv$6458${i$irxivih$mrxs

e$w}rhmgexih$jegmpmx}$ekviiqirx$,xli$&Gsrwxvygxmsr$Jegmpmx}&-$xs$tvszmhi$hifx$jmrergmrk$jsv$gsrwxvygxmsr$sj$xli$tvsnigx2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$;$1

Gsrxvegx$Vigimzefpi$mr$xli$rsxiw$xs$syv$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$MM0$Mxiq$<$sj$xlmw$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541

O2$Xli$Gsrwxvygxmsr$Jegmpmx}$tvszmhih$jsv$rsr1vigsyvwi$jyrhmrk$yt$xs$EYH$;=5$qmppmsr0$sv$(9982<$qmppmsr0$fewih$sr$i|glerki$vexiw$ew

sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=2$Gsrwxvygxmsr$hve{w${ivi$jyrhih$xlvsyklsyx$xli$tvsnigx$eggsvhmrk$xs$e$jm|ih$yxmpm~exmsr$wglihypi$ew$hijmrih$mr

xli$w}rhmgexih$jegmpmx}$ekviiqirx2$Xli$xivq$sj$xli$Gsrwxvygxmsr$Jegmpmx}${ew$xlvsykl$Witxiqfiv$645=$erh$fsvi$mrxiviwx$ex$e$zevmefpi

vexi$uysxih$f}$givxemr$Eywxvepmer$ferow$tpyw$644$fewmw$tsmrxw2$Sr$Qe}$660$645=0${i$gsqtpixih$er$sjjivmrk$sj$EYH$8:52:$qmppmsr0$sv

(7672<$qmppmsr0$fewih$sr$i|glerki$vexiw$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$ekkvikexi$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj$rsr1vigsyvwi$wirmsv$wigyvih$rsxiw

hyi$6486$,xli$&Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Rsxiw&-2$Xli$eqsvxm~mrk$Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Rsxiw${ivi$mwwyih$f}$Vezirlepp$Jmrergi$Gs$Tx}$Pmqmxih$mr$e

tvmzexi$tpegiqirx$tyvwyerx$xs$Wigxmsr$8,e-,6-$sj$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$Egx$sj$5=770$ew$eqirhih2$Xli$Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Rsxiw${ivi$mwwyih${mxl$e

gsytsr$erh$}miph$xs$qexyvmx}$sj$8267)${mxl$e$qexyvmx}$hexi$sj$Qevgl$750$64862$Xli$rix$tvsgiihw$jvsq$xlmw$sjjivmrk${ivi$ywih$xs

vijmrergi$xli$syxwxerhmrk$Gsrwxvygxmsr$Jegmpmx}$erh$xs$te}$epp$vipexih$jiiw0$gswxw$erh$i|tirwiw$ewwsgmexih${mxl$xli$xverwegxmsr2$Ew$e

viwypx$sj$xli$xverwegxmsr0${i$mrgyvvih$e$(829$qmppmsr$psww$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx$vipexih$xs$w{et$xivqmrexmsr$jiiw$erh$yreqsvxm~ih

hijivvih$pser$gswxw$ewwsgmexih${mxl$xli$Gsrwxvygxmsr$Jegmpmx}2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$pser$gswxw$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(;29$qmppmsr${ivi$mrgyvvih$erh

getmxepm~ih$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$sjjivmrk2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$<$1$Hivmzexmzi$Jmrergmep$Mrwxvyqirxw$mr$xli$rsxiw$xs$syv$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep

wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$MM0$Mxiq$<$sj$xlmw$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O2

Sxliv

Mr$Eykywx$645=0${i$irxivih$mrxs$x{s$mhirxmgep$Rsxiw$,ew$hijmrih$fips{-$mr$xli$ekkvikexi$eqsyrx$sj$(8827$qmppmsr${lmgl$evi

wigyvih$f}$pser$ekviiqirxw$erh$qsvxkeki$erh$wigyvmx}$ekviiqirxw$sr$givxemr$viep$tvstivx}$erh$mqtvsziqirxw2$Xli$xivqw$sj$xli$Rsxiw

evi$xlvsykl$Witxiqfiv$50$6478$erh$fiev$mrxiviwx$ex$PMFSV$tpyw$644$fewmw$tsmrxw$erh$evi$te}efpi$mr$qsrxlp}$mrwxeppqirxw$tpyw$mrxiviwx2

[i$lezi$irxivih$mrxs$mrxiviwx$vexi$w{et$ekviiqirxw$xs$jm|$xli$mrxiviwx$vexi$xs$8266)2$Mrgpyhih$mr$xli$fepergi$ex$Higiqfiv$750$645=$mw

(42;$qmppmsr$sj$hijivvih$pser$gswxw$mrgyvvih$mr$xli$xverwegxmsr2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$<$1$Hivmzexmzi

:6

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 93 of 253

Page 116: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq =7367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Jmrergmep$Mrwxvyqirxw$mr$xli$rsxiw$xs$syv$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$MM0$Mxiq$<$sj$xlmw$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq

541O2

Kyeverxiiw

Xli$Gsqter}$lew$irxivih$mrxs$givxemr$kyeverxiiw$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$hiwmkr0$jmrergmrk$erh$gsrwxvygxmsr$sj$givxemr$jegmpmxmiw$ew

{ipp$ ew$ pser0${svomrk$getmxep$ erh$sxliv$sfpmkexmsr$kyeverxiiw$ jsv$ syv$ wyfwmhmevmiw$ mr$Eywxvepme0$Wsyxl$Ejvmge$erh$syv$ nsmrx$zirxyviw2

Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$57$1$Hifx$mr$xli$rsxiw$xs$syv$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$MM0$Mxiq$<$sj$xlmw$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq

541O2

I|igyxmzi$Vixmviqirx$Ekviiqirxw

[i$lezi$e$rsr1uyepmjmih$hijivvih$gsqtirwexmsr$ekviiqirx${mxl$syv$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv0${ls${i$vijiv$xs$ew$syv$GIS2$Xli

gyvvirx$ekviiqirx0$ew$eqirhih0$tvszmhiw$jsv$e$pyqt$wyq$te}qirx$ytsr$vixmviqirx0$rs$wssriv$xler$eki$992$Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0

syv$GIS$leh$vieglih$eki$99$erh${ew$ipmkmfpi$xs$vigimzi$xli$te}qirx$ytsr$vixmviqirx2$Mj$syv$GIS$leh$vixmvih$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0

{i${syph$lezi$leh$xs$te}$lmq$(<2:$qmppmsr2$Fewih$sr$syv$gyvvirx$getmxepm~exmsr0${i$hs$rsx$fipmizi$xlex$qeomrk$xlmw$te}qirx${syph

qexivmepp}$ehzivwip}$mqtegx$syv$pmuymhmx}2

$

Sjj1Fepergi$Wliix$Evverkiqirxw

I|gitx$ew$hmwgywwih$efszi0$erh$mr$xli$rsxiw$xs$syv$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$MM0$Mxiq$<$sj$xlmw$Erryep

Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O0${i$hs$rsx$lezi$er}$sjj$fepergi$wliix$evverkiqirxw2

[i$evi$epws$i|tswih$xs$zevmsyw$gsqqmxqirxw$erh$gsrxmrkirgmiw${lmgl$qe}$lezi$e$qexivmep$ehzivwi$ijjigx$sr$syv$pmuymhmx}2$Wii

Rsxi$5<$1$Gsqqmxqirxw$erh$Gsrxmrkirgmiw$mr$xli$rsxiw$xs$syv$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$MM0$Mxiq$<$sj$xlmw

Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O2

Hivmzexmziw

$$$$

Mr$Eykywx$645=0${i$irxivih$mrxs$x{s$mrxiviwx$vexi$w{et$ekviiqirxw$mr$xli$ekkvikexi$rsxmsrep$eqsyrx$sj$(8827$qmppmsr$xs$jm|$xli

mrxiviwx$vexi$sr$givxemr$sj$syv$zevmefpi$vexi$hifx$xs$8266)2$[i$lezi$hiwmkrexih$xliwi$mrxiviwx$vexi$w{etw$ew$lihkiw$ekemrwx$glerkiw$mr$xli

gewl$jps{w$sj$x{s$mhirxmgep$tvsqmwwsv}$rsxiw$,xli$&Rsxiw&-${lmgl$evi$wigyvih$f}$pser$ekviiqirxw$erh$qsvxkeki$erh$wigyvmx}

ekviiqirxw$sr$givxemr$viep$tvstivx}$erh$mqtvsziqirxw2$[i$lezi$hixivqmrih$xlex$xli$w{etw$lezi$te}qirx0$i|tmvexmsr$hexiw0$erh

tvszmwmsrw$xlex$gsmrgmhi${mxl$xli$xivqw$sj$xli$Rsxiw$erh$evi$xlivijsvi$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$ijjigxmzi$gewl$jps{$lihkiw2$Eggsvhmrkp}0${i

vigsvh$xli$glerki$mr$jemv$zepyi$sj$xli$mrxiviwx$vexi$w{etw$ew$eggyqypexih$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$,psww-0$rix$sj$ettpmgefpi$xe|iw2

Xsxep$yrviepm~ih$pswwiw$vigsvhih$mr$xsxep$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$,psww-0$rix$sj$xe|0$vipexih$xs$xliwi$gewl$jps{$lihkiw${ew$(529

qmppmsr$hyvmrk$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=2$Xli$xsxep$jemv$zepyi$sj$xli$w{et$pmefmpmxmiw$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=${ew$(52=$qmppmsr

erh$mw$vigsvhih$ew$e$gsqtsrirx$sj$Sxliv$Rsr1Gyvvirx$pmefmpmxmiw${mxlmr$xli$eggsqter}mrk$fepergi$wliix2$Xlivi${ew$rs$qexivmep

mrijjigxmziriww$jsv$xli$tivmsh$tviwirxih2$[i$hs$rsx$i|tigx$xs$irxiv$mrxs$er}$xverwegxmsrw$hyvmrk$xli$ri|x$x{ipzi$qsrxlw${lmgl${syph

viwypx$mr$vigpewwmjmgexmsr$mrxs$ievrmrkw$sv$pswwiw$ewwsgmexih${mxl$xliwi$w{etw$gyvvirxp}$vitsvxih$mr$eggyqypexih$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi

mrgsqi$,psww-2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$57$1$Hifx$erh$Rsxi$<$1$Hivmzexmzi$Jmrergmep$Mrwxvyqirxw$mr$xli$rsxiw$xs$syv$eyhmxih$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep

wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$MM0$Mxiq$<$sj$xlmw$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O$jsv$jyvxliv$mrjsvqexmsr2

Syv$Eywxvepmer$wyfwmhmev}$irxivih$mrxs$mrxiviwx$vexi$w{et$ekviiqirxw$xs$jm|$xli$mrxiviwx$vexi$sr$syv$zevmefpi$vexi$rsr1vigsyvwi

hifx$ vipexih$ xs$ e$ tvsnigx$ mr$ Vezirlepp0$ e$ psgepmx}$ riev$Qipfsyvri0$Eywxvepme$ xs$ 826)2$[i$ hixivqmrih$ xlex$ xli$ w{etw$ leh$ te}qirx0

i|tmvexmsr$hexiw0$erh$tvszmwmsrw$xlex$gsmrgmhih${mxl$xli$xivqw$sj$xli$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx$erh${ivi$xlivijsvi$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$ijjigxmzi

gewl$jps{$lihkiw2$Eggsvhmrkp}0${i$vigsvhih$xli$glerki$mr$xli$jemv$zepyi$sj$xli$mrxiviwx$vexi$w{etw$mr$eggyqypexih$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi

mrgsqi$ ,psww-0$ rix$ sj$ ettpmgefpi$ mrgsqi$ xe|iw2$ Sr$ Qe}$ 660$ 645=0$ {i$ vijmrergih$ xli$ ewwsgmexih$ hifx$ erh$ xivqmrexih$ xli$ w{et

ekviiqirxw$ {lmgl$ viwypxih$ mr$ xli$ vigpewwmjmgexmsr$ sj$ (72=$qmppmsr$ mrxs$ pswwiw$ xlex$ {ivi$ tvizmsywp}$ vitsvxih$ mr$ eggyqypexih$ sxliv

gsqtvilirwmzi$ mrgsqi$ ,psww-2$ Vijiv$ xs$ Rsxi$ 57$ 1$ Hifx$ erh$Rsxi$ <$ 1$ Hivmzexmzi$ Jmrergmep$ Mrwxvyqirxw$ mr$ xli$ rsxiw$ xs$ syv$ eyhmxih

gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$MM0$Mxiq$<$sj$xlmw$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O$jsv$jyvxliv$mrjsvqexmsr2

:7

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 94 of 253

Page 117: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq =8367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Gsrxvegxyep$Sfpmkexmsrw

Xli$jspps{mrk$mw$e$xefpi$sj$givxemr$sj$syv$gsrxvegxyep$sfpmkexmsrw0$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0${lmgl$viuymviw$yw$xs$qeoi$te}qirxw

sziv$xli$tivmshw$tviwirxih2$

$ Te}qirxw$Hyi$f}$Tivmsh

Gsrxvegxyep$Sfpmkexmsrw Xsxep $Piww$Xler5$]iev $ 517$]ievw $ 719$]ievw $

Qsvi$Xler9$]ievw

$ ,Mr$xlsywerhw-

Psrk1Xivq$Hifx ( 5057<04<5 $ ( 5046: $ ( 5=:058: $ ( 99607;8 $ ( 7<<0979

Xivq$Pser ;;<0444 $ <0444 $ 5:0444 $ ;980444 $ Ó

Vizspziv 9640:;5 $ Ó $ Ó $ 9640:;5 $ Ó

Jmrergi$Piewi$Sfpmkexmsrw$,mrgpyhiw$mqtyxih

mrxiviwx- 90547 $ 50=78 $ 705:= $ Ó $ Ó

Stivexmrk$Piewi$Sfpmkexmsrw$,mrgpyhiw$mqtyxih

mrxiviwx- 58<08<4 $ 7507;< $ 890<;= $ 6=09;5 $ 850:96

Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Hifx 76<05;< $ 570=45 $ 660946 $ 5:0=4: $ 6;80<:=

Iwxmqexih$mrxiviwx$te}qirxw$sr$hifx$,e- ;550;49 $ 56;0;<= $ 69609=8 $ 5;40;45 $ 5:40:65

Iwxmqexih$jyrhmrk$sj$tirwmsr$erh$sxliv$tswx

vixmviqirx$firijmxw 7;0995 $ =08:9 $ 50;6< $ 50;<= $ 6809:=

Iwxmqexih$gsrwxvygxmsr$gsqqmxqirxw 770444 5860875 770444 $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó

Xsxep ( 70;440;:= $ ( 66:08=7 $ ( 97<045< $ ( 6048:0456 $ ( <=4068:

$

,e- Hyi$xs$xli$yrgivxemrxmiw$sj$jyxyvi$PMFSV$vexiw0$xli$zevmefpi$mrxiviwx$te}qirxw$sr$syv$Wirmsv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}${ivi$gepgypexih

ywmrk$er$eziveki$PMFSV$vexi$sj$5298)$fewih$sr$tvsnigxih$mrxiviwx$vexiw$xlvsykl$64692

Gewl$Jps{

Gewl0$gewl$iuymzepirxw0$viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=${ew$(:;29$qmppmsr0$gsqtevih$xs$(<829

qmppmsr$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645<$erh${ew$mqtegxih$f}$xli$jspps{mrk>

Rix$gewl$tvszmhih$f}$stivexmrk$egxmzmxmiw$mr$645=$erh$645<${ew$(77<25$qmppmsr$erh$(6;829$qmppmsr0$viwtigxmzip}2$Rix$gewl

tvszmhih$f}$stivexmrk$egxmzmxmiw$mr$645=${ew$tswmxmzip}$mqtegxih$f}$rsr1gewl$i|tirwiw$wygl$ew$hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr0$hijivvih

xe|$firijmx0$eqsvxm~exmsr$sj$hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw0$hmwgsyrx$erh3sv$tviqmyq$erh$sxliv$rsr1gewl$mrxiviwx0$wxsgo1fewih$gsqtirwexmsr

i|tirwi0$psww$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx$erh$hmzmhirhw$vigimzih$jvsq$syv$yrgsrwspmhexih$nsmrx$zirxyvi2$Iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw

rikexmzip}$mqtegxih$gewl2$Glerkiw$mr$eggsyrxw$vigimzefpi0$tvitemh$i|tirwiw$erh$sxliv$ewwixw$mrgviewih$mr$xsxep$f}$e$rix$sj$(<28$qmppmsr0

vitviwirxmrk$e$rikexmzi$mqtegx$sr$gewl2$Xli$mrgviewi${ew$tvmqevmp}$hvmzir$f}$xli$xmqmrk$sj$fmppmrkw$erh$gsppigxmsrw2$Glerkiw$mr

eggsyrxw$te}efpi0$eggvyih$i|tirwiw$erh$sxliv$pmefmpmxmiw$mrgviewih$f}$(542;$qmppmsr${lmgl$tswmxmzip}$mqtegxih$gewl2$Xli$mrgviewi${ew

tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs$xli$xmqmrk$sj$te}qirxw2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$gewl$tvszmhih$f}$stivexmrk$egxmzmxmiw$mr$645=${ew$rikexmzip}$mqtegxih$f}$er

mrgviewi$mr$gsrxvegx$vigimzefpi$sj$(828$qmppmsr2$Xli$mrgviewi$vipexiw$xs$xli$xmqmrk$sj$te}qirxw$vigimzih$erh$mrxiviwx$eggvyih0$epsrk${mxl

xli$ijjigx$sj$jsvimkr$i|glerki$vexiw0$vipexih$xs$xli$Vezirlepp$Tvsnigx2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$;$1$Gsrxvegx$Vigimzefpi$mrgpyhih$mr$xli$rsxiw$xs$syv

eyhmxih$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$MM0$Mxiq$<$sj$xlmw$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O2

Rix$gewl$tvszmhih$f}$stivexmrk$egxmzmxmiw$mr$645<${ew$tswmxmzip}$mqtegxih$f}$rsr1gewl$i|tirwiw$wygl$ew$hitvigmexmsr$erh

eqsvxm~exmsr0$hijivvih$xe|$tvszmwmsr0$eqsvxm~exmsr$sj$hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw0$hmwgsyrx$erh3sv$tviqmyq$erh$sxliv$rsr1gewl$mrxiviwx0$wxsgo1

fewih$gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwi$erh$hmzmhirhw$vigimzih$jvsq$syv$yrgsrwspmhexih$nsmrx$zirxyvi2$Iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw$rikexmzip}

mqtegxih$gewl2$Glerkiw$mr$eggsyrxw$vigimzefpi0$tvitemh$i|tirwiw$erh$sxliv$ewwixw$higviewih$mr$xsxep$f}$e$rix$sj$(::25$qmppmsr0

vitviwirxmrk$e$rikexmzi$mqtegx$sr$gewl2$Xli$higviewi${ew$tvmqevmp}$hvmzir$f}$xli$xmqmrk$sj$fmppmrkw$erh$gsppigxmsrw2$Glerkiw$mr

eggsyrxw$te}efpi0$eggvyih$i|tirwiw$erh$sxliv$pmefmpmxmiw$mrgviewih$f}$(752;$qmppmsr${lmgl$tswmxmzip}$mqtegxih$gewl2$Xli$mrgviewi${ew

tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs$xli$xmqmrk$sj$te}qirxw2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$gewl$tvszmhih$f}$stivexmrk$egxmzmxmiw$mr$645<${ew$rikexmzip}$mqtegxih$f}$er

mrgviewi$mr$gsrxvegx$vigimzefpi$sj$(624$qmppmsr2$Xlmw$mrgviewi$vipexiw$xs$xli$xmqmrk$sj$te}qirxw$vigimzih$erh$mrxiviwx$eggvyih0$epsrk${mxl

xli$ijjigx$sj$jsvimkr$i|glerki$vexiw0$vipexih$xs$xli$Vezirlepp$Tvsnigx2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$;$1$Gsrxvegx$Vigimzefpi$mrgpyhih$mr$xli$rsxiw$xs$syv

eyhmxih$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$MM0$Mxiq$<$sj$xlmw$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O2

:8

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 95 of 253

Page 118: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq =9367<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 96 of 253

Page 119: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq =:367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Rix$gewl$ywih$mr$mrziwxmrk$egxmzmxmiw$sj$(54825$qmppmsr$mr$645=${ew$tvmqevmp}$xli$viwypx$sj$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw$sj$(55;26$qmppmsr0

sjjwix$f}$mrwyvergi$tvsgiihw$jvsq$heqekih$tvstivx}$tvmqevmp}$vipexih$xs$lyvvmgeriw$sj$(5=27$qmppmsr0$tvsgiihw$jvsq$wepi$sj$ewwixw$liph

jsv$wepi$sj$(42<$qmppmsr$erh$tvsgiihw$jvsq$xli$wepi$sj$tvstivx}$erh$iuymtqirx$sj$(428$qmppmsr2$Rix$gewl$ywih$mr$mrziwxmrk$egxmzmxmiw$sj

(5<<29$qmppmsr$mr$645<${ew$tvmqevmp}$xli$viwypx$sj$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw$sj$(5=92;$qmppmsr0$sjjwix$f}$mrwyvergi$tvsgiihw$jvsq$heqeki

tvstivx}$tvmqevmp}$vipexih$xs$lyvvmgeriw$sj$(528$qmppmsr0$tvsgiihw$jvsq$wepi$sj$ewwixw$liph$jsv$wepi$sj$(72<$qmppmsr$erh$tvsgiihw$jvsq$xli

wepi$sj$tvstivx}$erh$iuymtqirx$sj$(625$qmppmsr2

Rix$gewl$ywih$mr$jmrergmrk$egxmzmxmiw$mr$645=$vijpigxw$te}qirxw$sj$(95726$qmppmsr$sr$psrk$xivq$hifx$sjjwix$f}$(96528$qmppmsr$sj

tvsgiihw$jvsq$psrk$xivq$hifx$erh$te}qirxw$sr$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx$sj$(77925$qmppmsr$sjjwix$f}$tvsgiihw$jvsq$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx$sj

(76525$qmppmsr2$[i$epws$temh$gewl$hmzmhirhw$sj$(67629$qmppmsr$erh$hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw$sj$(=2=$qmppmsr2

Rix$gewl$tvszmhih$f}$jmrergmrk$egxmzmxmiw$mr$645<$vijpigxw$te}qirxw$sj$(6<628$qmppmsr$sr$psrk$xivq$hifx$sjjwix$f}$(94724$qmppmsr

sj$tvsgiihw$jvsq$psrk$xivq$hifx$erh$te}qirxw$sr$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx$sj$(5<29$qmppmsr2$[i$epws$temh$gewl$hmzmhirhw$sj$(66=29$qmppmsr0

tyvglewih$(=926$qmppmsr$sj$wleviw$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo$erh$temh$hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw$sj$(524$qmppmsr2

Mrjpexmsr

[i$fipmizi$xlex$mrjpexmsr0$mr$kirivep0$hmh$rsx$lezi$e$qexivmep$ijjigx$sr$syv$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$hyvmrk$645=$erh$645<2$[lmpi

wsqi$sj$syv$gsrxvegxw$mrgpyhi$tvszmwmsrw$jsv$mrjpexmsrev}$mrhi|mrk0$mrjpexmsr$gsyph$lezi$e$wyfwxerxmep$ehzivwi$ijjigx$sr$syv$viwypxw$sj

stivexmsrw$mr$xli$jyxyvi$xs$xli$i|xirx$xlex${ekiw$erh$wepevmiw0${lmgl$vitviwirx$syv$pevkiwx$vigyvvmrk3jm|ih$i|tirwi0$mrgviewi$ex$e$jewxiv

vexi$xler$xli$tiv$hmiq$sv$jm|ih$vexiw$vigimzih$f}$yw$jsv$syv$qerekiqirx$wivzmgiw2

Jyrhw$jvsq$Stivexmsrw

Jyrhw$jvsq$Stivexmsrw$,&JJS&-$mw$e${mhip}$eggitxih$wyttpiqirxep$rsr1KEET$qiewyvi$yxmpm~ih$xs$izepyexi$xli$stivexmrk$tivjsvqergi

sj$viep$iwxexi$gsqtermiw2$Mx$mw$hijmrih$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$xli$wxerhevhw$iwxefpmwlih$f}$xli$Rexmsrep$Ewwsgmexmsr$sj$Viep$Iwxexi

Mrziwxqirx$Xvywxw0$sv$REVIMX0${lmgl$hijmriw$JJS$ew$rix$mrgsqi$,psww-$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$gsqqsr$wlevilsphivw$,gsqtyxih$mr$eggsvhergi

{mxl$Yrmxih$Wxexiw$Kirivepp}$Eggitxih$Eggsyrxmrk$Tvmrgmtpiw-0$i|gpyhmrk$viep$iwxexi$vipexih$hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr0$i|gpyhmrk

kemrw$erh$pswwiw$jvsq$xli$gyqypexmzi$ijjigxw$sj$eggsyrxmrk$glerkiw0$i|xvesvhmrev}$mxiqw$erh$wepiw$sj$tvstivxmiw0$erh$mrgpyhmrk

ehnywxqirxw$jsv$yrgsrwspmhexih$tevxrivwlmtw$erh$nsmrx$zirxyviw2

[i$epws$tviwirx$Rsvqepm~ih$Jyrhw$Jvsq$Stivexmsrw0$sv$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS0$erh$Ehnywxih$Jyrhw$jvsq$Stivexmsrw0$sv$EJJS0$ew

wyttpiqirxep$rsr1KEET$jmrergmep$qiewyviw$sj$viep$iwxexi$gsqtermiw×$stivexmrk$tivjsvqergiw2

Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$mw$hijmrih$ew$JJS$ehnywxih$jsv$givxemr$mxiqw${lmgl$f}$xlimv$rexyvi$evi$rsx$gsqtevefpi$jvsq$tivmsh$xs$tivmsh$sv$xlex

xirh$xs$sfwgyvi$xli$Gsqter}×w$egxyep$stivexmrk$tivjsvqergi0$mrgpyhmrk$jsv$xli$tivmshw$tviwirxih$rix$Xe|$Gyxw$erh$Nsfw$Egx$,&XGNE&-

mqtegx0$tvi1xe|0$kemr3psww$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx0$tvi1xe|0$wxevx1yt$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|0$pikep$vipexih$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|0$iwgvs{

vipiewiw0$tvi1xe|0$gpswi1syx$i|tirwiw$erh$xli$xe|$ijjigx$sj$ehnywxqirxw$xs$jyrhw$jvsq$stivexmsrw2

EJJS$mw$hijmrih$ew$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$ehnywxih$f}$ehhmrk$rsr1gewl$i|tirwiw$wygl$ew$rsr1viep$iwxexi$vipexih$hitvigmexmsr$erh

eqsvxm~exmsr0$wxsgo$fewih$gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwi0$xli$eqsvxm~exmsr$sj$hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw0$hmwgsyrx$erh3sv$tviqmyq$erh$sxliv$rsr1gewl

mrxiviwx0$erh$f}$wyfxvegxmrk$vigyvvmrk$gsrwspmhexih$qemrxirergi$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw2

Figeywi$sj$xli$yrmuyi$hiwmkr0$wxvygxyvi$erh$ywi$sj$syv$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw0$tvsgiwwmrk$girxivw$erh$viirxv}$girxivw${i$fipmizi$xlex$ewwiwwmrk

xli$tivjsvqergi$sj$syv$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw0$tvsgiwwmrk$girxivw$erh$viirxv}$girxivw${mxlsyx$xli$mqtegx$sj$hitvigmexmsr$sv$eqsvxm~exmsr$mw

ywijyp$erh$qiermrkjyp$xs$mrziwxsvw2$Epxlsykl$REVIMX$lew$tyfpmwlih$mxw$hijmrmxmsr$sj$JJS0$gsqtermiw$sjxir$qshmj}$xlmw$hijmrmxmsr$ew

xli}$wiio$xs$tvszmhi$jmrergmep$qiewyviw$xlex$qiermrkjypp}$vijpigx$xlimv$hmwxmrgxmzi$stivexmsrw2$[i$lezi$qshmjmih$JJS$xs$hivmzi

Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$erh$EJJS$xlex$qiermrkjypp}$vijpigx$syv$stivexmsrw2

Syv$ewwiwwqirx$sj$syv$stivexmsrw$mw$jsgywih$sr$psrk1xivq$wywxemrefmpmx}2$Xli$ehnywxqirxw${i$qeoi$xs$hivmzi$xli$rsr1KEET

qiewyviw$sj$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$erh$EJJS$i|gpyhi$mxiqw${lmgl$qe}$geywi$wlsvx1xivq$jpygxyexmsrw$mr$rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS$fyx

lezi$rs$mqtegx$sr$syv$gewl$jps{w0$sv${i$hs$rsx$gsrwmhiv$xliq$xs$fi$jyrheqirxep$exxvmfyxiw$sv$xli$tvmqev}$hvmzivw$sj$syv$fywmriww$tper

erh$xli}$hs$rsx$ejjigx$syv$szivepp$psrk1xivq$stivexmrk$tivjsvqergi2$[i$qe}$qeoi$ehnywxqirxw$xs$JJS$jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi$jsv$givxemr

sxliv$mrgsqi$erh$i|tirwiw$xlex$hs$rsx$vijpigx$e$rigiwwev}$gsqtsrirx$sj$syv$stivexmsrep$tivjsvqergi$sr$xli$fewmw$hmwgywwih$efszi0

izir$xlsykl$wygl$mxiqw$qe}$viuymvi$gewl$wixxpiqirx2$Figeywi$JJS0$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$erh$EJJS$i|gpyhi$hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr

yrmuyi$xs$viep$iwxexi$ew${ipp$ew$rsr1stivexmsrep$mxiqw$erh$givxemr$sxliv$glevkiw$xlex$evi$lmklp}$zevmefpi$jvsq$}iev$xs$}iev0$xli}$tvszmhi

syv$mrziwxsvw${mxl$tivjsvqergi$qiewyviw$xlex$vijpigx$xli$mqtegx$xs$stivexmsrw$jvsq$xvirhw$mr$sggyterg}$vexiw0$tiv$hmiq$vexiw0$stivexmrk

gswxw$erh$mrxiviwx$gswxw0$tvszmhmrk$e$tivwtigxmzi$rsx$mqqihmexip}$ettevirx$jvsq$mrgsqi$jvsq$rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 97 of 253

Page 120: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq =;367<

:9

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 98 of 253

Page 121: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq =<367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

[i$fipmizi$xli$tviwirxexmsr$sj$JJS0$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$erh$EJJS$tvszmhi$ywijyp$mrjsvqexmsr$xs$mrziwxsvw$ew$xli}$tvszmhi$er

mrhmgexmsr$sj$syv$efmpmx}$xs$jyrh$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw$erh$i|terh$syv$fywmriww2$JJS0$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$erh$EJJS$tvszmhi$hmwgpswyvi$sr

xli$weqi$fewmw$ew$xlex$ywih$f}$syv$qerekiqirx$erh$tvszmhi$gsrwmwxirg}$mr$syv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk0$jegmpmxexi$mrxivrep$erh$i|xivrep

gsqtevmwsrw$sj$syv$lmwxsvmgep$stivexmrk$tivjsvqergi$erh$syv$fywmriww$yrmxw$erh$tvszmhi$gsrxmrymx}$xs$mrziwxsvw$jsv$gsqtevefmpmx}

tyvtswiw2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$JJS0$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$erh$EJJS$evi${mhip}$vigskrm~ih$qiewyviw$mr$syv$mrhywxv}$ew$e$viep$iwxexi$mrziwxqirx

xvywx2

Syv$vigsrgmpmexmsr$sj$rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS$xs$JJS0$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$erh$EJJS$jsv$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh

645<0$viwtigxmzip}0$mw$ew$jspps{w$,mr$xlsywerhw->

$ $ Higiqfiv$750$645= $ Higiqfiv$750$645<

Jyrhw$Jvsq$Stivexmsrw $ $ $ $

Rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli

KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2 $( 5::0:47

$( 58904<=

Viep$iwxexi$vipexih$hitvigmexmsr

erh$eqsvxm~exmsr $;605=5

$;409=6

Kemr$sr$wepi$sj$viep$iwxexi$ewwixw0

rix$sj$xe| $60:=7

$8078;

REVIMX$Hijmrih$JJS $ ( 68508<; $ ( 664046<

Rix$Xe|$Gyxw$erh$Nsfw$Egx$Mqtegx $ Ó $ 748

Wxevx1yt$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe| $ <0=9= $ :06==

Psww$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx $ 80;=9 $ 9;8

Pikep$vipexih$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe| $ 60444 $ ;058;

Iwgvs{$vipiewiw0$tvi1xe| $ Ó $ ,606;7-

Gpswi1syx$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe| $ 809;< $ 80689

Xe|$ijjigx$sj$ehnywxqirxw$xs$jyrhw

jvsq$stivexmsrw$. $,504;<-

$,60475-

Rsvqepm~ih$Jyrhw$jvsq

Stivexmsrw $( 6:40;85

$( 67806=7

Rsr1viep$iwxexi$vipexih

hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr $9<0:78

$990<86

Gsrwspmhexih$qemrxirergi$getmxep

i|tirhmxyviw $,650<==-

$,660:7<-

Wxsgo1fewih$gsqtirwexmsr

i|tirwiw $660788

$660494

Eqsvxm~exmsr$sj$hifx$mwwyergi

gswxw0$hmwgsyrx$erh3sv$tviqmyq

erh$sxliv$rsr1gewl$mrxiviwx $

<0:4=

$

<06<6

Ehnywxih$Jyrhw$jvsq

Stivexmsrw $( 76<086=

$( 6=;0<6=

.$Xe|$ehnywxqirxw$vipexi$xs$kemr$sr$wepi$sj$viep$iwxexi$ewwixw0$psww$sr$hifx$i|xmrkymwlqirx0$wxevx1yt$i|tirwiw0$pikep$vipexih

i|tirwiw0$iwgvs{$vipiewiw0$erh$gpswi1syx$i|tirwiw2

Syxpsso

::

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 99 of 253

Page 122: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq ==367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Xli$jspps{mrk$hmwgywwmsr$sj$syv$jyxyvi$tivjsvqergi$gsrxemrw$wxexiqirxw$xlex$evi$rsx$lmwxsvmgep$wxexiqirxw$erh0$xlivijsvi0

gsrwxmxyxi$jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw${mxlmr$xli$qiermrk$sj$xli$Tvmzexi$Wigyvmxmiw$Pmxmkexmsr$Vijsvq$Egx$sj$5==92$Syv$jsv{evh1

pssomrk$wxexiqirxw$evi$wyfnigx$xs$vmwow$erh$yrgivxemrxmiw$xlex$gsyph$geywi$egxyep$viwypxw$xs$hmjjiv$qexivmepp}$jvsq$xlswi$wxexih$sv$mqtpmih

mr$xli$jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirx2$Tpiewi$vijiv$xs$ÔMxiq$5E2$Vmwo$JegxsvwÕ$mr$xlmw$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O0$xli$ÔJsv{evh1Pssomrk

Wxexiqirxw$Ó$Weji$Levfsv0Õ$ew${ipp$ew$xli$sxliv$hmwgpswyviw$gsrxemrih$mr$xlmw$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O0$jsv$jyvxliv$hmwgywwmsr$sr

jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw$erh$xli$vmwow$erh$sxliv$jegxsvw$xlex$gsyph$tvizirx$yw$jvsq$eglmizmrk$syv$ksepw$erh$geywi$xli$ewwyqtxmsrw

yrhivp}mrk$xli$jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw$erh$xli$egxyep$viwypxw$xs$hmjjiv$qexivmepp}$jvsq$xlswi$i|tviwwih$mr$sv$mqtpmih$f}$xlswi

jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw2

Viziryi

[i$gsrxmryi$xs$fi$irgsyvekih$f}$xli$gyvvirx$perhwgeti$sj$kvs{xl$sttsvxyrmxmiw?$ls{iziv$er}$tswmxmzi$xvirhw$qe}0$xs$wsqi$i|xirx0$fi

ehzivwip}$mqtegxih$f}$kszivrqirx$fyhkixev}$gsrwxvemrxw$sv$er}$glerkiw$xs$e$kszivrqirx+w${mppmrkriww$xs$qemrxemr$sv$kvs{$tyfpmg1

tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw$mr$xli$jyxyvi2$[lmpi$wxexi$jmrergiw$szivepp$evi$wxefpi0$jyxyvi$fyhkixev}$tviwwyviw$qe}$geywi$wxexi$ekirgmiw$xs$tyvwyi

e$ryqfiv$sj$gswx$wezmrkw$mrmxmexmziw${lmgl$qe}$mrgpyhi$vihygxmsrw$mr$tiv$hmiq$vexiw$erh3sv$xli$wgsti$sj$wivzmgiw$tvszmhih$f}$tvmzexi

stivexsvw2$Xliwi$tsxirxmep$gswx$wezmrkw$mrmxmexmziw$gsyph$lezi$e$qexivmep$ehzivwi$mqtegx$sr$syv$gyvvirx$stivexmsrw$erh3sv$syv$efmpmx}$xs

tyvwyi$ri{$fywmriww$sttsvxyrmxmiw2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$mj$wxexi$fyhkixev}$gsrwxvemrxw0$ew$hmwgywwih$efszi0$tivwmwx$sv$mrxirwmj}0$syv$wxexi

gywxsqivw×$efmpmx}$xs$te}$yw$qe}$fi$mqtemvih$erh3sv${i$qe}$fi$jsvgih$xs$viriksxmexi$syv$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$sr$piww$jezsvefpi$xivqw

erh$syv$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$sv$gewl$jps{w$gsyph$fi$qexivmepp}$ehzivwip}$mqtegxih2$[i$tper$xs$egxmzip}$fmh$sr$er}

ri{$tvsnigxw$xlex$jmx$syv$xevkix$tvsjmpi$jsv$tvsjmxefmpmx}$erh$stivexmsrep$vmwo2$Epxlsykl${i$evi$tpiewih${mxl$xli$szivepp$mrhywxv}$syxpsso0

tswmxmzi$xvirhw$mr$xli$mrhywxv}$qe}$fi$sjjwix$f}$wizivep$jegxsvw0$mrgpyhmrk$fyhkixev}$gsrwxvemrxw0$gsrxvegx$qshmjmgexmsrw0$gsrxvegx

xivqmrexmsrw0$gsrxvegx$rsr1viri{epw0$erh3sv$gsrxvegx$vi1fmhw$erh$xli$mqtegx$sj$er}$sxliv$tsxirxmep$glerkiw$xs$xli${mppmrkriww$xs

qemrxemr$sv$kvs{$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw$sr$xli$tevx$sj$sxliv$kszivrqirx$ekirgmiw2$[i$fipmizi${i$lezi$e$wxvsrk$vipexmsrwlmt${mxl

syv$kszivrqirx$tevxrivw$erh${i$fipmizi$xlex${i$stivexi$jegmpmxmiw$xlex$qe|mqm~i$wigyvmx}$erh$ijjmgmirg}${lmpi$sjjivmrk$syv$wymxi$sj

KIS$Gsrxmryyq$sj$Gevi$wivzmgiw$erh$viwsyvgiw2

Epxlsykl${i$lezi$lmwxsvmgepp}$leh$e$vipexmzip}$lmkl$gsrxvegx$viri{ep$vexi0$xlivi$ger$fi$rs$ewwyvergi$xlex${i${mpp$fi$efpi$xs$viri{$syv

i|tmvmrk$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$sr$jezsvefpi$xivqw0$sv$ex$epp2$Epws0${lmpi${i$evi$tpiewih${mxl$syv$xvego$vigsvh$mr$vi1fmh$wmxyexmsrw0${i

gerrsx$ewwyvi$xlex${i${mpp$tvizemp$mr$er}$wygl$jyxyvi$wmxyexmsrw2

Vigirxp}$Gepmjsvrme$iregxih$pikmwpexmsr$emqih$ex$tlewmrk$syx$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmt$gsrxvegxw$jsv$xli$stivexmsr$sj$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw

{mxlmr$Gepmjsvrme$erh$ jegmpmxmiw$ syxwmhi$sj$ xli$ wxexi$sj$Gepmjsvrme$lsywmrk$wxexi$sj$Gepmjsvrme$ mrqexiw2$Ew$tvizmsywp}$errsyrgih0$ syv

gsrxvegx$jsv$syv$Girxvep$Zeppi}$jegmpmx}${ew$epvieh}$hmwgsrxmryih$f}$xli$Gepmjsvrme$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmsrw$erh$Vilefmpmxexmsr$ex$xli

irh$sj$Witxiqfiv2$[i$i|tigx$xlex$syv$gsrxvegxw${mxl$xli$Gepmjsvrme$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmsrw$erh$Vilefmpmxexmsr$jsv$syv$Hiwivx$Zmi{

jegmpmx}$erh$Ksphir$Wxexi$jegmpmx}${mpp$fi$hmwgsrxmryih$f}$Qevgl$50$6464$erh$Qe}$50$64640$viwtigxmzip}2

Mrxivrexmsrepp}0${i$evi$i|tpsvmrk$e$ryqfiv$sj$sttsvxyrmxmiw$mr$syv$gyvvirx$qevoixw$erh${mpp$gsrxmryi$xs$egxmzip}$fmh$sr$er}

sttsvxyrmxmiw$xlex$jmx$syv$xevkix$tvsjmpi$jsv$tvsjmxefmpmx}$erh$stivexmsrep$vmwo2$Sr$Qevgl$6=0$645<0${i$errsyrgih$xlex$syv$xverwtsvxexmsr

nsmrx$zirxyvi$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq0$KIS$Eqi}0$wmkrih$e$gsrxvegx${mxl$Wgsxxmwl$Tvmwsr$Wivzmgi$jsv$xli$tvszmwmsr$sj$gsyvx$gywxsh}$erh

iwgsvx$wivzmgiw$mr$Wgsxperh2$Xli$gsrxvegx$lew$e$fewi$xivq$sj$imklx$}ievw$ijjigxmzi$Neryev}$6:0$645=${mxl$e$viri{ep$stxmsr$sj$jsyv$}ievw

erh$mw$i|tigxih$xs$lezi$er$eziveki$erryep$viziryi$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(7=$qmppmsr2$Epws0${i$evi$tpiewih$xs$lezi$fiir$e{evhih$e$xir1}iev

gsrxvegx$viri{ep$jsv$xli$gsrxmryih$hipmziv}$sj$wigyvi$xverwtsvxexmsr$yrhiv$syv$KIS$Eqi}$nsmrx$zirxyvi$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq2$Xsxep

viziryi$sziv$xli$xir1}iev$tivmsh$mw$i|tigxih$xs$fi$ettvs|mqexip}$(;:4$qmppmsr2$Mr$Ri{$Wsyxl$[epiw0$Eywxvepme0${i$evi$hizipstmrk$e

8<=1fih$i|terwmsr$ex$xli$Nyrii$Gsvvigxmsrep$Girxvi${lmgl$mw$i|tigxih$xs$fi$gsqtpixih$hyvmrk$xli$jmvwx$uyevxiv$sj$64642$[i$evi$epws

gsrwxvygxmrk$e$57;1fih$i|terwmsr$ex$xli$Jypleq$Gsvvigxmsrep$Girxvi$mr$Zmgxsvme0$Eywxvepme2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$syv$Eywxvepmer$wyfwmhmev}$mw

gyvvirxp}$mr$hmwgywwmsrw${mxl$xli$Wxexi$sj$Zmgxsvme0$Eywxvepme$xs$mrgviewi$xli$getegmx}$ex$syv$Vezirlepp$Gsvvigxmsrep$Girxvi$f}$er

ehhmxmsrep$744$fihw$mrgviewmrk$xli$getegmx}$sj$xli$jegmpmx}$xs$50:44$fihw2$Xli$7441fih$getegmx}$mrgviewi$mw$i|tigxih$xs$kirivexi

mrgviqirxep$erryepm~ih$viziryiw$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(5=$qmppmsr2$[mxl$viwtigx$xs$xli$Tevopie$Gsvvigxmsrep$Girxvi$mr$Eywxvepme0${i${ivi

yrjsvxyrexip}$yrwyggiwwjyp$hyvmrk$xli$gyvvirx$gsqtixmxmzi$vifmh$tvsgiww$erh$lezi$xverwmxmsrih$xli$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegx$mr$Qevgl$sj

645=2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0${i${ivi$mrjsvqih$f}$xli$Wxexi$sj$Uyiirwperh0$Eywxvepme$xlex$xli$Evxlyv$Ksvvmi$Gsvvigxmsrep$Girxvi${mpp$fi

xverwmxmsrih$xs$kszivrqirx$stivexmsr$f}$xli$irh$sj$xli$jmvwx$uyevxiv$sj$64642

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 100 of 253

Page 123: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 544367<

:;

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 101 of 253

Page 124: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 545367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

[mxl$viwtigx$xs$syv$viirxv}$wivzmgiw0$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$wivzmgiw0$erh$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$wivzmgiw$fywmriww$gsrhygxih$xlvsykl$syv

KIS$Gevi$fywmriww$wikqirx0${i$evi$gyvvirxp}$tyvwymrk$e$ryqfiv$sj$fywmriww$hizipstqirx$sttsvxyrmxmiw2$Vipexih$xs$sttsvxyrmxmiw$jsv

gsqqyrmx}1fewih$viirxv}$wivzmgiw0${i$evi${svomrk${mxl$syv$i|mwxmrk$jihivep0$wxexi0$erh$psgep$gpmirxw$xs$piziveki$ri{$sttsvxyrmxmiw$jsv

fsxl$viwmhirxmep$viirxv}$jegmpmxmiw$ew${ipp$ew$rsr1viwmhirxmep$he}$vitsvxmrk$girxivw2$[i$gsrxmryi$xs$i|tirh$viwsyvgiw$sr$mrjsvqmrk

jihivep0$wxexi$erh$psgep$kszivrqirxw$efsyx$xli$firijmxw$sj$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw0$erh${i$erxmgmtexi$xlex$xlivi${mpp$fi$ri{

sttsvxyrmxmiw$mr$xli$jyxyvi$ew$xlswi$ijjsvxw$gsrxmryi$xs$}miph$viwypxw2$[i$fipmizi${i$evi${ipp$tswmxmsrih$xs$getmxepm~i$sr$er}$wymxefpi

sttsvxyrmxmiw$xlex$figsqi$ezempefpi$mr$xlmw$evie2

$$$$

Stivexmrk$I|tirwiw

Stivexmrk$i|tirwiw$gsrwmwx$sj$xlswi$i|tirwiw$mrgyvvih$mr$xli$stivexmsr$erh$qerekiqirx$sj$syv$gsrxvegxw$xs$tvszmhi$wivzmgiw$xs

syv$kszivrqirxep$gpmirxw2$Pefsv$erh$vipexih$gswx$vitviwirxih$ettvs|mqexip}$:6)$sj$syv$stivexmrk$i|tirwiw$mr$645=2$Ehhmxmsrep

wmkrmjmgerx$stivexmrk$i|tirwiw$mrgpyhi$jssh0$yxmpmxmiw$erh$mrqexi$qihmgep$gswxw2$Mr$645=0$stivexmrk$i|tirwiw$xsxepih$ettvs|mqexip}$;9)

sj$syv$gsrwspmhexih$viziryiw2$Syv$stivexmrk$i|tirwiw$ew$e$tivgirxeki$sj$viziryi$mr$6464${mpp$fi$mqtegxih$f}$xli$stirmrk$sj$er}$ri{

sv$i|mwxmrk$jegmpmxmiw$ew$e$viwypx$sj$xli$gswx$sj$xverwmxmsrmrk$erh3sv$wxevx1yt$stivexmsrw$vipexih$xs$e$jegmpmx}$stirmrk2$Hyvmrk$64640${i${mpp

mrgyv$gevv}mrk$gswxw$jsv$jegmpmxmiw$xlex${ivi$zegerx$mr$645=2$Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$syv${svph{mhi$stivexmsrw$mrgpyhi$xli

qerekiqirx$erh3sv$s{rivwlmt$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$=90444$fihw$ex$56=$gsvvigxmsrep0$hixirxmsr$erh$gsqqyrmx}$wivzmgiw$jegmpmxmiw0

mrgpyhmrk$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw$erh$tvsnigxw$yrhiv$hizipstqirx0$erh$epws$mrgpyhih$xli$tvszmwmsr$sj$qsrmxsvmrk$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$6540444

sjjirhivw$mr$e$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$irzmvsrqirx$sr$filepj$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$=44$jihivep0$wxexi$erh$psgep$gsvvigxmsrep$ekirgmiw$psgexih$mr

epp$94$wxexiw2

$

Kirivep$erh$Ehqmrmwxvexmzi$I|tirwiw

$$$$

Kirivep$erh$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw$gsrwmwx$tvmqevmp}$sj$gsvtsvexi$qerekiqirx$wepevmiw$erh$firijmxw0$tvsjiwwmsrep$jiiw$erh

sxliv$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw2$Mr$645=0$kirivep$erh$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw$xsxepih$ettvs|mqexip}$<)$sj$syv$gsrwspmhexih$viziryiw2

[i$i|tigx$kirivep$erh$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw$ew$e$tivgirxeki$sj$viziryi$mr$6464$xs$viqemr$gsrwmwxirx$sv$higviewi$ew$e$viwypx$sj$gswx

wezmrkw$mrmxmexmziw2$[i$i|tigx$fywmriww$hizipstqirx$gswxw$xs$viqemr$gsrwmwxirx$ew${i$tyvwyi$ehhmxmsrep$fywmriww$hizipstqirx

sttsvxyrmxmiw$mr$epp$sj$syv$fywmriww$pmriw2$[i$epws$tper$xs$gsrxmryi$i|tirhmrk$viwsyvgiw$jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi$sr$xli$izepyexmsr$sj$tsxirxmep

eguymwmxmsr$xevkixw2

Mhpi$Jegmpmxmiw

Mr$ syv$ Wigyvi$ Wivzmgiw$ wikqirx0$ {i$ evi$ gyvvirxp}$ qevoixmrk$ ettvs|mqexip}$ ;44$ zegerx$ fihw$ {mxl$ e$ rix$ fsso$ zepyi$ sj

ettvs|mqexip}$(56$qmppmsr$ex$sri$sj$syv$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw$xs$tsxirxmep$gywxsqivw2$Mr$syv$KIS$Gevi$wikqirx0${i$evi$gyvvirxp}$qevoixmrk

ettvs|mqexip}$844$zegerx$fihw${mxl$e$rix$fsso$zepyi$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(=$qmppmsr$ex$sri$sj$syv$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw$xs$tsxirxmep$gywxsqivw2

Xli$gsqfmrih$erryep$gevv}mrk$gswx$sj$xliwi$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw$mr$6464$mw$iwxmqexih$xs$fi$(724$qmppmsr0$mrgpyhmrk$hitvigmexmsr$i|tirwi$sj

(524$qmppmsr2$[i$ gyvvirxp}$ hs$ rsx$ lezi$ er}$ jmvq$gsqqmxqirxw$ sv$ ekviiqirxw$ mr$tpegi$ xs$ egxmzexi$ xliwi$ jegmpmxmiw$ fyx$ lezi$ srksmrk

gsrxegx${mxl$ wizivep$ tsxirxmep$ gywxsqivw2$Lmwxsvmgepp}0$ wsqi$ jegmpmxmiw$ lezi$fiir$ mhpi$ jsv$qypxmtpi$ }ievw$ fijsvi$ xli}$ vigimzih$ e$ ri{

gsrxvegx$ e{evh2$Xli$tiv$hmiq$vexiw$ xlex${i$glevki$syv$ gpmirxw$ sjxir$zev}$f}$gsrxvegx$ egvsww$syv$tsvxjspms2$Ls{iziv0$ mj$ xli$ x{s$ mhpi

jegmpmxmiw$mr$syv$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$erh$KIS$Gevi$wikqirxw${ivi$xs$fi$egxmzexih$ywmrk$syv$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$eziveki$tiv$hmiq$vexi$mr$645=0

,gepgypexih$ew$xli$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$viziryi$hmzmhih$f}$xli$ryqfiv$sj$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$qerhe}w-$erh$fewih$sr$xli$eziveki$sggyterg}

vexi$mr$syv$jegmpmxmiw$jsv$645=0${i${syph$i|tigx$xs$vigimzi$erryep$mrgviqirxep$viziryi$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(69$qmppmsr$erh$er$mrgviewi$mr

erryep$ievrmrkw$tiv$wlevi$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(247$xs$(24:$tiv$wlevi$fewih$sr$syv$eziveki$stivexmrk$qevkmr2

$$$$$$$$$

Jsv{evh1Pssomrk$Wxexiqirxw$Ó$Weji$Levfsv

Xlmw$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O$erh$ xli$hsgyqirxw$ mrgsvtsvexih$f}$ vijivirgi$livimr$gsrxemr$Ôjsv{evh1pssomrkÕ$ wxexiqirxw

{mxlmr$xli$qiermrk$sj$Wigxmsr$6;E$sj$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$Egx$sj$5=770$ew$eqirhih0$erh$Wigxmsr$65I$sj$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$I|glerki$Egx$sj$5=780

ew$ eqirhih2$ ÔJsv{evh1pssomrkÕ$ wxexiqirxw$ evi$ er}$ wxexiqirxw$ xlex$ evi$ rsx$ fewih$ sr$ lmwxsvmgep$ mrjsvqexmsr2$ Wxexiqirxw$ sxliv$ xler

wxexiqirxw$sj$lmwxsvmgep$jegxw$mrgpyhih$mr$xlmw$vitsvx0$ mrgpyhmrk0${mxlsyx$pmqmxexmsr0$wxexiqirxw$vikevhmrk$syv$jyxyvi$jmrergmep$tswmxmsr0

fywmriww$ wxvexik}0$ fyhkixw0$ tvsnigxih$ gswxw$ erh$ tperw$ erh$ sfnigxmziw$ sj$ qerekiqirx$ jsv$ jyxyvi$ stivexmsrw0$ evi$ Ôjsv{evh1pssomrkÕ

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 102 of 253

Page 125: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 546367<

wxexiqirxw2$Jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw$kirivepp}$ger$fi$mhirxmjmih$f}$xli$ywi$sj$jsv{evh1pssomrk$xivqmrspsk}$wygl$ew$Ôqe}0Õ$Ô{mpp0Õ

Ôi|tigx0Õ$Ôerxmgmtexi0Õ$Ômrxirh0Õ$Ôtper0Õ$Ôfipmizi0Õ$Ôwiio0Õ$ÔiwxmqexiÕ$sv$ÔgsrxmryiÕ$sv$xli$rikexmzi$sj$wygl${svhw

:<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 103 of 253

Page 126: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 547367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

sv$zevmexmsrw$sj$ wygl${svhw$erh$wmqmpev$i|tviwwmsrw2$Xliwi$ wxexiqirxw$evi$rsx$kyeverxiiw$sj$ jyxyvi$tivjsvqergi$erh$ mrzspzi$givxemr

vmwow0$yrgivxemrxmiw$erh$ewwyqtxmsrw0${lmgl$evi$hmjjmgypx$xs$tvihmgx2$Xlivijsvi0$egxyep$syxgsqiw$erh$viwypxw$qe}$hmjjiv$qexivmepp}$jvsq

{lex$mw$i|tviwwih$sv$jsvigewxih$mr$wygl$jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw$erh${i$ger$kmzi$rs$ewwyvergi$xlex$wygl$jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw

{mpp$tvszi$xs$fi$gsvvigx2$Mqtsvxerx$jegxsvw$xlex$gsyph$geywi$egxyep$viwypxw$ xs$hmjjiv$qexivmepp}$jvsq$xlswi$i|tviwwih$sv$mqtpmih$f}$xli

jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw0$sv$Ôgeyxmsrev}$wxexiqirxw0Õ$mrgpyhi0$fyx$evi$rsx$pmqmxih$xs>

¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$xmqip}$fymph$erh3sv$stir$jegmpmxmiw$ew$tperrih0$tvsjmxefp}$qereki$wygl$jegmpmxmiw$erh$wyggiwwjypp}$mrxikvexi$wygl

jegmpmxmiw$mrxs$syv$stivexmsrw${mxlsyx$wyfwxerxmep$ehhmxmsrep$gswxw?

¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$jypjmpp$syv$hifx$wivzmgi$sfpmkexmsrw$erh$mxw$mqtegx$sr$syv$pmuymhmx}?

¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$egxmzexi$xli$mregxmzi$fihw$ex$syv$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw?

¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$qemrxemr$sv$mrgviewi$sggyterg}$vexiw$ex$syv$jegmpmxmiw?

¨ er$mrgviewi$mr$yrvimqfyvwih$pefsv$vexiw?

¨ syv$ efmpmx}$ xs$ i|terh0$ hmzivwmj}$ erh$ kvs{$syv$ wigyvi0$ tvsgiwwmrk0$qirxep$ liepxl0$ viwmhirxmep$ xviexqirx0$ viirxv}0$ gsqqyrmx}1

fewih$ wivzmgiw0$ }syxl$ wivzmgiw0$ qsrmxsvmrk$ wivzmgiw0$ izmhirgi1fewih$ wytivzmwmsr$ erh$ xviexqirx$ tvskveqw$ erh$ wigyvi

xverwtsvxexmsr$wivzmgiw$fywmriwwiw?

¨ syv$efmpmx}$ xs${mr$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$ jsv${lmgl${i$lezi$wyfqmxxih$tvstswepw0$ vixemr$i|mwxmrk$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$erh

qiix$er}$tivjsvqergi$wxerhevhw$viuymvih$f}$wygl$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw?

¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$gsrxvsp$stivexmrk$gswxw$ewwsgmexih${mxl$gsrxvegx$wxevx1ytw?

¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$ vemwi$ri{$tvsnigx$hizipstqirx$getmxep$kmzir$xli$sjxir$wlsvx1xivq$rexyvi$sj$xli$gywxsqivw×$gsqqmxqirx$ xs$ywi

ri{p}$hizipstih$jegmpmxmiw?

¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$iwxmqexi$xli$kszivrqirx×w$pizip$sj$hitirhirg}$sr$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmt$wigyvi$wivzmgiw?

¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$eggyvexip}$tvsnigx$xli$wm~i$erh$kvs{xl$sj$xli$Y2W2$erh$mrxivrexmsrep$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmt$wigyvi$wivzmgiw

mrhywxv}?

¨ xli$mqtegx$sj$tyfpmg$viwmwxergi$xs$xli$ywi$sj$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw$jsv$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw0$tvsgiwwmrk$girxivw$erh$gsqqyrmx}

viirxv}$girxivw?

¨ xli$ mqtegx$ sj$ ehstxih$sv$ tvstswih$ pikmwpexmsr$ emqih$ex$ pmqmxmrk$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw$ jsv$ wigyvi$ jegmpmxmiw0$ tvsgiwwmrk

girxivw$erh$gsqqyrmx}$viirxv}$girxivw$sv$pmqmxmrk$sv$viwxvmgxmrk$xli$fywmriww$erh$stivexmsrw$sj$jmrergmep$mrwxmxyxmsrw$sv$sxlivw

{ls$hs$fywmriww${mxl$yw?

¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$wyggiwwjypp}$viwtsrh$xs$hipe}w$irgsyrxivih$f}$wxexiw$yxmpm~mrk$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmt$wigyvi$wivzmgiw$erh$gswx

wezmrkw$mrmxmexmziw$mqtpiqirxih$f}$e$ryqfiv$sj$wxexiw?

¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$hizipst$psrk1xivq$ievrmrkw$zmwmfmpmx}?

¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$mhirxmj}$wymxefpi$eguymwmxmsrw$erh$xs$wyggiwwjypp}$gsqtpixi$erh$mrxikvexi$wygl$eguymwmxmsrw$sr$wexmwjegxsv}$xivqw0

erh$iwxmqexi$xli$w}rivkmiw$xs$fi$eglmizih$ew$e$viwypx$sj$wygl$eguymwmxmsrw?

¨ syv$i|tswyvi$xs$xli$mqtemvqirx$sj$kssh{mpp$erh$sxliv$mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw$ew$e$viwypx$sj$syv$eguymwmxmsrw?

¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$wyggiwwjypp}$gsrhygx$syv$stivexmsrw$xlvsykl$nsmrx$zirxyviw$erh$gsrwsvxmyqw?

¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$sfxemr$jyxyvi$jmrergmrk$sr$wexmwjegxsv}$xivqw$sv$ex$epp0$mrgpyhmrk$syv$efmpmx}$xs$wigyvi$xli$jyrhmrk${i$riih$xs

gsqtpixi$srksmrk$getmxep$tvsnigxw?

¨ xli$ mqtegx$ sj$ xli$ higmwmsr$ f}$ wizivep$ jmrergmep$ mrwxmxyxmsrw0$ mrgpyhmrk$ wsqi$ sj$ syv$ pirhivw0$ xlex$ xli}${mpp$ rsx$ fi$ viri{mrk

i|mwxmrk$ ekviiqirxw$ sv$ irxivmrk$ mrxs$ ri{$ ekviiqirxw$ {mxl$ gsqtermiw$ xlex$ stivexi$ wigyvi$ wivzmgiw$ jegmpmxmiw$ erh$ girxivw

tyvwyerx$xs$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw?

¨ xli$mqtegx$sj$xli$erxmgmtexih$PMFSV$xverwmxmsr$mr$6465?

¨ syv$i|tswyvi$xs$tspmxmgep$erh$igsrsqmg$mrwxefmpmx}$erh$sxliv$vmwow$mqtegxmrk$syv$mrxivrexmsrep$stivexmsrw?

¨ xli$mrwxefmpmx}$sj$jsvimkr$i|glerki$vexiw0$i|tswmrk$yw$xs$gyvvirg}$vmwow$mr$Eywxvepme0$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq0$erh$Wsyxl$Ejvmge0$sv

sxliv$gsyrxvmiw$mr${lmgl${i$qe}$glsswi$xs$gsrhygx$syv$fywmriww?

¨ syv$i|tswyvi$xs$vmwow$mqtegxmrk$syv$mrjsvqexmsr$w}wxiqw0$mrgpyhmrk$xlswi$xlex$qe}$geywi$er$mrxivvytxmsr0$hipe}$sv$jempyvi$mr$xli

tvszmwmsr$sj$syv$wivzmgiw?

¨ syv$i|tswyvi$xs$vmwmrk$kirivep$mrwyvergi$gswxw?

¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$viqemr$uyepmjmih$jsv$xe|exmsr$ew$e$VIMX?

¨ syv$i|tswyvi$xs$wxexi$erh$jihivep$mrgsqi$xe|$pe{$glerkiw$mrxivrexmsrepp}$erh$hsqiwxmgepp}0$mrgpyhmrk$xli$vigirxp}$iregxih$Xe|

Gyxw$erh$Nsfw$Egx0$erh$syv$i|tswyvi$ew$e$viwypx$sj$jihivep$erh$mrxivrexmsrep$i|eqmrexmsrw$sj$syv$xe|$vixyvrw$sv$xe|$tswmxmsrw?

¨ xli$ mqtegx$ sj$ rexyvep$ hmwewxivw0$ terhiqmg$ syxfvieow0$ kpsfep$ tspmxmgep$ izirxw$ erh$ sxliv$ wivmsyw$ gexewxvstlmg$ izirxw$ sr$ syv

fywmriww$erh$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr?

¨ syv$i|tswyvi$xs$gpemqw$jsv${lmgl${i$evi$yrmrwyvih?

¨ syv$i|tswyvi$xs$vmwmrk$iqtps}ii$erh$mrqexi$qihmgep$gswxw?

¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$qereki$gswxw$erh$i|tirwiw$vipexmrk$xs$srksmrk$pmxmkexmsr$evmwmrk$jvsq$syv$stivexmsrw?

¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$eggyvexip}$iwxmqexi$sr$er$erryep$fewmw0$psww$viwivziw$vipexih$xs$kirivep$pmefmpmx}0${svoivw×$gsqtirwexmsr$erh

eyxsqsfmpi$pmefmpmx}$gpemqw?

¨ xli$efmpmx}$sj$syv$kszivrqirx$gywxsqivw$xs$wigyvi$fyhkixev}$ettvstvmexmsrw$xs$jyrh$xlimv$te}qirx$sfpmkexmsrw$xs$yw$erh$xs

gsrxmryi$xs$stivexi$yrhiv$syv$i|mwxmrk$ekviiqirxw$erh3sv$viri{$syv$i|mwxmrk$ekviiqirxw?

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 104 of 253

Page 127: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 548367<

:=

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 105 of 253

Page 128: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 549367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$te}$uyevxivp}$hmzmhirhw$gsrwmwxirx${mxl$syv$i|tigxexmsrw?

¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$gsqtp}${mxl$kszivrqirx$vikypexmsrw$erh$ettpmgefpi$gsrxvegxyep$viuymviqirxw?

¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$eguymvi0$tvsxigx$sv$qemrxemr$syv$mrxippigxyep$tvstivx}?$erh

¨ sxliv$jegxsvw$gsrxemrih$mr$syv$jmpmrkw${mxl$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$erh$I|glerki$Gsqqmwwmsr0$sv$xli$WIG0$mrgpyhmrk0$fyx$rsx$pmqmxih$xs0

xlswi$hixempih$mr$xlmw$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O0$syv$Uyevxivp}$Vitsvxw$sr$Jsvq$541U$erh$syv$Gyvvirx$Vitsvxw$sr$Jsvq$<1

O$jmpih${mxl$xli$WIG2

[i$yrhivxeoi$rs$sfpmkexmsr$xs$ythexi$tyfpmgp}$er}$jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw0${lixliv$ew$e$viwypx$sj$ri{$mrjsvqexmsr0$jyxyvi

izirxw$sv$sxliv{mwi0$i|gitx$ew$viuymvih$f}$pe{2$Epp$wyfwiuyirx${vmxxir$erh$svep$jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$yw0$sv

tivwsrw$egxmrk$sr$syv$filepj0$evi$i|tviwwp}$uyepmjmih$mr$xlimv$irxmvix}$f}$xli$geyxmsrev}$wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$xlmw$vitsvx2

$

Mxiq$;E2 Uyerxmxexmzi$erh$Uyepmxexmzi$Hmwgpswyviw$Efsyx$Qevoix$Vmwo

Mrxiviwx$Vexi$Vmwo

[i$evi$i|tswih$xs$qevoix$vmwow$vipexih$xs$glerkiw$mr$mrxiviwx$vexiw${mxl$viwtigx$xs$syv$wirmsv$gvihmx$jegmpmx}2$Te}qirxw$yrhiv$xli

Wirmsv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}$evi$mrhi|ih$xs$e$zevmefpi$mrxiviwx$vexi2$Fewih$sr$fsvvs{mrkw$syxwxerhmrk$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=$yrhiv$xli

Wirmsv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}$sj$(506=<2;$qmppmsr0$jsv$iziv}$sri$tivgirx$mrgviewi$mr$xli$mrxiviwx$vexi$ettpmgefpi$xs$xli$Wirmsv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}0$syv

xsxep$erryep$mrxiviwx$i|tirwi${syph$mrgviewi$f}$ettvs|mqexip}$(5724$qmppmsr2

[i$lezi$irxivih$mrxs$givxemr$mrxiviwx$vexi$w{et$evverkiqirxw$jsv$lihkmrk$tyvtswiw0$jm|mrk$xli$mrxiviwx$vexi$sr$syv$Eywxvepmer$rsr1

vigsyvwi$hifx2$Xli$hmjjivirgi$fix{iir$xli$jpsexmrk$vexi$erh$xli$w{et$vexi$sr$xliwi$mrwxvyqirxw$mw$vigskrm~ih$mr$mrxiviwx$i|tirwi${mxlmr

xli$viwtigxmzi$irxmx}2$Figeywi$xli$mrxiviwx$vexiw${mxl$viwtigx$xs$xliwi$mrwxvyqirxw$evi$jm|ih0$e$l}tsxlixmgep$544$fewmw$tsmrx$glerki$mr$xli

gyvvirx$mrxiviwx$vexi${syph$rsx$lezi$e$qexivmep$mqtegx$sr$syv$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$sv$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2

Ehhmxmsrepp}0${i$mrziwx$syv$gewl$mr$e$zevmix}$sj$wlsvx1xivq$jmrergmep$mrwxvyqirxw$xs$tvszmhi$e$vixyvr2$Xliwi$mrwxvyqirxw$kirivepp}

gsrwmwx$sj$lmklp}$pmuymh$mrziwxqirxw${mxl$svmkmrep$qexyvmxmiw$ex$xli$hexi$sj$tyvglewi$sj$xlvii$qsrxlw$sv$piww2$[lmpi$xliwi$mrwxvyqirxw$evi

wyfnigx$xs$mrxiviwx$vexi$vmwo0$e$l}tsxlixmgep$544$fewmw$tsmrx$mrgviewi$sv$higviewi$mr$qevoix$mrxiviwx$vexiw${syph$rsx$lezi$e$qexivmep$mqtegx

sr$syv$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$sv$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2

Jsvimkr$Gyvvirg}$I|glerki$Vexi$Vmwo

[i$evi$i|tswih$xs$qevoix$vmwow$vipexih$xs$jpygxyexmsrw$mr$jsvimkr$gyvvirg}$i|glerki$vexiw$fix{iir$xli$Y2W2$Hsppev0$xli$Eywxvepmer

Hsppev0$xli$Wsyxl$Ejvmger$Verh$erh$xli$Fvmxmwl$Tsyrh$gyvvirg}$i|glerki$vexiw2$Fewih$ytsr$syv$jsvimkr$gyvvirg}$i|glerki$vexi

i|tswyvi$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=${mxl$viwtigx$xs$syv$mrxivrexmsrep$stivexmsrw0$iziv}$54$tivgirx$glerki$mr

;4

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 106 of 253

Page 129: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 54:367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

lmwxsvmgep$gyvvirg}$vexiw${syph$lezi$e$(:24$qmppmsr$ijjigx$sr$syv$jmrergmep$tswmxmsr$erh$e$(625$qmppmsr$mqtegx$sr$syv$viwypxw$sj

stivexmsrw$sziv$xli$ri|x$jmwgep$}iev2

$Mxiq$<2 Jmrergmep$Wxexiqirxw$erh$Wyttpiqirxev}$Hexe

QEREKIQIRX×W$VIWTSRWMFMPMX]$JSV$JMRERGMEP$WXEXIQIRXW

Xs$xli$Wlevilsphivw$sj

Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2>

Xli$eggsqter}mrk$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$lezi$fiir$tvitevih$mr$gsrjsvqmx}${mxl$eggsyrxmrk$tvmrgmtpiw$kirivepp}

eggitxih$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw2$Xli}$mrgpyhi$eqsyrxw$fewih$sr$nyhkqirxw$erh$iwxmqexiw2

Vitviwirxexmsrw$mr$xli$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$erh$xli$jemvriww$erh$mrxikvmx}$sj$wygl$wxexiqirxw$evi$xli$viwtsrwmfmpmx}$sj

qerekiqirx2$Mr$svhiv$xs$qiix$qerekiqirx×w$viwtsrwmfmpmx}0$xli$Gsqter}$qemrxemrw$e$w}wxiq$sj$mrxivrep$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw$erh$e

tvskveq$sj$mrxivrep$eyhmxw$hiwmkrih$xs$tvszmhi$viewsrefpi$ewwyvergi$xlex$syv$ewwixw$evi$gsrxvsppih$erh$wejikyevhih0$xlex$xverwegxmsrw$evi

i|igyxih$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$qerekiqirx×w$eyxlsvm~exmsr$erh$tvstivp}$vigsvhih0$erh$xlex$eggsyrxmrk$vigsvhw$qe}$fi$vipmih$ytsr$mr$xli

tvitevexmsr$sj$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw2

Xli$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$lezi$fiir$eyhmxih$f}$Kverx$Xlsvrxsr$PPT0$mrhitirhirx$vikmwxivih$tyfpmg$eggsyrxerxw0

{lswi$ettsmrxqirx$f}$syv$Eyhmx$Gsqqmxxii${ew$vexmjmih$f}$syv$wlevilsphivw2$Xlimv$vitsvx0${lmgl$mw$mrgpyhih$mr$xlmw$Jsvq$541O0

i|tviwwiw$er$stmrmsr$ew$xs${lixliv$qerekiqirx×w$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$tviwirx$jemvp}$mr$epp$qexivmep$viwtigxw0$xli

Gsqter}+w$jmrergmep$tswmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$erh$gewl$jps{w$jsv$iegl$sj$xli$xlvii$}ievw$mr$xli$tivmsh$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=$mr

gsrjsvqmx}${mxl$eggsyrxmrk$tvmrgmtpiw$kirivepp}$eggitxih$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw$sj$Eqivmge2$Xli$ijjigxmziriww$sj$syv$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp

sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=$lew$epws$fiir$eyhmxih$f}$Kverx$Xlsvrxsr$PPT0$mrhitirhirx$vikmwxivih$tyfpmg

eggsyrxerxw0$ew$wxexih$mr$xlimv$vitsvx${lmgl$mw$mrgpyhih$mr$xlmw$Jsvq$541O2$Xlimv$eyhmxw${ivi$gsrhygxih$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$xli$wxerhevhw

sj$xli$Tyfpmg$Gsqter}$Eggsyrxmrk$Szivwmklx$Fsevh$,Yrmxih$Wxexiw-2

Xli$Eyhmx$Gsqqmxxii$sj$xli$Fsevh$sj$Hmvigxsvw$qiixw$tivmshmgepp}${mxl$vitviwirxexmziw$sj$qerekiqirx0$xli$mrhitirhirx

vikmwxivih$tyfpmg$eggsyrxerxw$erh$syv$mrxivrep$eyhmxsvw$xs$vizmi{$qexxivw$vipexmrk$xs$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk0$mrxivrep$eggsyrxmrk$gsrxvspw$erh

eyhmxmrk2$Fsxl$xli$mrxivrep$eyhmxsvw$erh$xli$mrhitirhirx$vikmwxivih$tyfpmg$eggsyrxerxw$lezi$yrviwxvmgxih$eggiww$xs$xli$Eyhmx$Gsqqmxxii

xs$hmwgyww$xli$viwypxw$sj$xlimv$i|eqmrexmsrw2

Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Glemvqer$erh$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv

Fvmer$V2$Izerw

Wirmsv$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx$erh$Glmij$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv

;5

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 107 of 253

Page 130: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 54;367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

QEREKIQIRX×W$ERRYEP$VITSVX$SR$MRXIVREP$GSRXVSP$SZIV$JMRERGMEP$VITSVXMRK

Syv$qerekiqirx$mw$viwtsrwmfpi$jsv$iwxefpmwlmrk$erh$qemrxemrmrk$ehiuyexi$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$ew$hijmrih$mr

Vypiw$57e159,j-$erh$59h159,j-$yrhiv$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$I|glerki$Egx$sj$5=782$Xli$Gsqter}×w$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$mw$e

tvsgiww$hiwmkrih$yrhiv$xli$wytivzmwmsr$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$erh$Glmij$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv$xlex>$,m-$tivxemrw$xs$xli

qemrxirergi$sj$vigsvhw$xlex0$mr$viewsrefpi$hixemp0$eggyvexip}$erh$jemvp}$vijpigx$xli$xverwegxmsrw$erh$hmwtswmxmsrw$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$ewwixw?

,mm-$tvszmhiw$viewsrefpi$ewwyvergi$xlex$xverwegxmsrw$evi$vigsvhih$ew$rigiwwev}$xs$tivqmx$tvitevexmsr$sj$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$jsv$i|xivrep

vitsvxmrk$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$eggsyrxmrk$tvmrgmtpiw$kirivepp}$eggitxih$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw0$erh$xlex$vigimtxw$erh$i|tirhmxyviw$evi$fimrk

qehi$srp}$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$eyxlsvm~exmsr$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$qerekiqirx$erh$hmvigxsvw?$erh$,mmm-$tvszmhiw$viewsrefpi$ewwyvergi

vikevhmrk$tvizirxmsr$sv$xmqip}$hixigxmsr$sj$yreyxlsvm~ih$eguymwmxmsr0$ywi$sv$hmwtswmxmsr$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$ewwixw$xlex$gsyph$lezi$e

qexivmep$ijjigx$sr$xli$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw2

Figeywi$sj$mxw$mrlivirx$pmqmxexmsrw0$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$qe}$rsx$tvizirx$sv$hixigx$qmwwxexiqirxw2$Epws0

tvsnigxmsrw$sj$er}$izepyexmsr$sj$ijjigxmziriww$xs$jyxyvi$tivmshw$evi$wyfnigx$xs$xli$vmwo$xlex$gsrxvspw$qe}$figsqi$mrehiuyexi$figeywi$sj

glerkiw$mr$gsrhmxmsrw0$sv$xlex$xli$hikvii$sj$gsqtpmergi${mxl$xli$tspmgmiw$sv$tvsgihyviw$qe}$hixivmsvexi2$Qerekiqirx$lew$ewwiwwih$xli

ijjigxmziriww$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=2$Mr$qeomrk$mxw$ewwiwwqirx$sj$mrxivrep

gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk0$qerekiqirx$ywih$xli$gvmxivme$wix$jsvxl$mr$xli$Mrxivrep$Gsrxvsp$1$Mrxikvexih$Jveqi{svo$mwwyih$f}$xli

6457$Gsqqmxxii$sj$Wtsrwsvmrk$Svkerm~exmsrw$sj$xli$Xvieh{e}$Gsqqmwwmsr$,&GSWS&-$,xli$&6457$Mrxivrep$Gsrxvsp$1$Mrxikvexih

Jveqi{svo&-2

Xli$Gsqter}$izepyexih0${mxl$xli$tevxmgmtexmsr$sj$mxw$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$erh$Glmij$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv0$mxw$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp

sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$fewih$sr$xli$6457$Mrxivrep$Gsrxvsp$Ó$Mrxikvexih$Jveqi{svo2$Fewih$sr$xlmw

izepyexmsr0$xli$Gsqter}×w$qerekiqirx$gsrgpyhih$xlex$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$mxw$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$mw

ijjigxmzi$mr$tvszmhmrk$viewsrefpi$ewwyvergi$vikevhmrk$xli$vipmefmpmx}$sj$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$erh$xli$tvitevexmsr$sj$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw

jsv$i|xivrep$tyvtswiw$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$kirivepp}$eggitxih$eggsyrxmrk$tvmrgmtpiw2

Kverx$Xlsvrxsr$PPT0$xli$mrhitirhirx$vikmwxivih$tyfpmg$eggsyrxmrk$jmvq$xlex$eyhmxih$xli$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$xlmw

Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O0$lew$mwwyih$er$exxiwxexmsr$vitsvx$sr$syv$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=2

;6

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 108 of 253

Page 131: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 54<367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

VITSVX$SJ$MRHITIRHIRX$VIKMWXIVIH$TYFPMG$EGGSYRXMRK$JMVQ

Fsevh$sj$Hmvigxsvw$erh$Wlevilsphivw

Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

Stmrmsr$sr$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk

[i$lezi$eyhmxih$xli$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$sj$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2$,e$Jpsvmhe$gsvtsvexmsr-$erh$wyfwmhmevmiw$,xli

ÔGsqter}Õ-$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$fewih$sr$gvmxivme$iwxefpmwlih$mr$xli$6457$Mrxivrep$Gsrxvsp1Mrxikvexih$Jveqi{svo$mwwyih$f}$xli

Gsqqmxxii$sj$Wtsrwsvmrk$Svkerm~exmsrw$sj$xli$Xvieh{e}$Gsqqmwwmsr$,ÔGSWSÕ-2$Mr$syv$stmrmsr0$xli$Gsqter}$qemrxemrih0$mr$epp

qexivmep$viwtigxw0$ijjigxmzi$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$fewih$sr$gvmxivme$iwxefpmwlih$mr$xli$6457

Mrxivrep$Gsrxvsp1Mrxikvexih$Jveqi{svo$mwwyih$f}$GSWS2

[i$epws$lezi$eyhmxih0$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$xli$wxerhevhw$sj$xli$Tyfpmg$Gsqter}$Eggsyrxmrk$Szivwmklx$Fsevh$,Yrmxih$Wxexiw-

,ÔTGESFÕ-0$xli$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$sj$xli$Gsqter}$ew$sj$erh$jsv$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$erh$syv$vitsvx

hexih$Jifvyev}$6:0$6464$i|tviwwih$er$yruyepmjmih$stmrmsr$sr$xlswi$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw2

Fewmw$jsv$stmrmsr

Xli$Gsqter}×w$qerekiqirx$mw$viwtsrwmfpi$jsv$qemrxemrmrk$ijjigxmzi$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$erh$jsv$mxw$ewwiwwqirx$sj

xli$ijjigxmziriww$sj$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk0$mrgpyhih$mr$xli$eggsqter}mrk$Qerekiqirx×w$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Mrxivrep

Gsrxvsp$Sziv$Jmrergmep$Vitsvxmrk2$Syv$viwtsrwmfmpmx}$mw$xs$i|tviww$er$stmrmsr$sr$xli$Gsqter}×w$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep

vitsvxmrk$fewih$sr$syv$eyhmx2$[i$evi$e$tyfpmg$eggsyrxmrk$jmvq$vikmwxivih${mxl$xli$TGESF$erh$evi$viuymvih$xs$fi$mrhitirhirx${mxl

viwtigx$xs$xli$Gsqter}$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$xli$Y2W2$jihivep$wigyvmxmiw$pe{w$erh$xli$ettpmgefpi$vypiw$erh$vikypexmsrw$sj$xli$Wigyvmxmiw

erh$I|glerki$Gsqqmwwmsr$erh$xli$TGESF2

[i$gsrhygxih$syv$eyhmx$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$xli$wxerhevhw$sj$xli$TGESF2$Xlswi$wxerhevhw$viuymvi$xlex${i$tper$erh$tivjsvq$xli$eyhmx$xs

sfxemr$viewsrefpi$ewwyvergi$efsyx${lixliv$ijjigxmzi$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk${ew$qemrxemrih$mr$epp$qexivmep$viwtigxw2

Syv$eyhmx$mrgpyhih$sfxemrmrk$er$yrhivwxerhmrk$sj$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk0$ewwiwwmrk$xli$vmwo$xlex$e$qexivmep${ieoriww

i|mwxw0$xiwxmrk$erh$izepyexmrk$xli$hiwmkr$erh$stivexmrk$ijjigxmziriww$sj$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$fewih$sr$xli$ewwiwwih$vmwo0$erh$tivjsvqmrk$wygl

sxliv$tvsgihyviw$ew${i$gsrwmhivih$rigiwwev}$mr$xli$gmvgyqwxergiw2$[i$fipmizi$xlex$syv$eyhmx$tvszmhiw$e$viewsrefpi$fewmw$jsv$syv

stmrmsr2

Hijmrmxmsr$erh$pmqmxexmsrw$sj$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk

E$gsqter}×w$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$mw$e$tvsgiww$hiwmkrih$xs$tvszmhi$viewsrefpi$ewwyvergi$vikevhmrk$xli$vipmefmpmx}$sj

jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$erh$xli$tvitevexmsr$sj$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$jsv$i|xivrep$tyvtswiw$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$kirivepp}$eggitxih$eggsyrxmrk

tvmrgmtpiw2$E$gsqter}×w$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$mrgpyhiw$xlswi$tspmgmiw$erh$tvsgihyviw$xlex$,5-$tivxemr$xs$xli

qemrxirergi$sj$vigsvhw$xlex0$mr$viewsrefpi$hixemp0$eggyvexip}$erh$jemvp}$vijpigx$xli$xverwegxmsrw$erh$hmwtswmxmsrw$sj$xli$ewwixw$sj$xli

gsqter}?$,6-$tvszmhi$viewsrefpi$ewwyvergi$xlex$xverwegxmsrw$evi$vigsvhih$ew$rigiwwev}$xs$tivqmx$tvitevexmsr$sj$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$mr

eggsvhergi${mxl$kirivepp}$eggitxih$eggsyrxmrk$tvmrgmtpiw0$erh$xlex$vigimtxw$erh$i|tirhmxyviw$sj$xli$gsqter}$evi$fimrk$qehi$srp}$mr

eggsvhergi${mxl$eyxlsvm~exmsrw$sj$qerekiqirx$erh$hmvigxsvw$sj$xli$gsqter}?$erh$,7-$tvszmhi$viewsrefpi$ewwyvergi$vikevhmrk

tvizirxmsr$sv$xmqip}$hixigxmsr$sj$yreyxlsvm~ih$eguymwmxmsr0$ywi0$sv$hmwtswmxmsr$sj$xli$gsqter}×w$ewwixw$xlex$gsyph$lezi$e$qexivmep$ijjigx

sr$xli$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw2

Figeywi$sj$mxw$mrlivirx$pmqmxexmsrw0$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$qe}$rsx$tvizirx$sv$hixigx$qmwwxexiqirxw2$Epws0$tvsnigxmsrw

sj$er}$izepyexmsr$sj$ijjigxmziriww$xs$jyxyvi$tivmshw$evi$wyfnigx$xs$xli$vmwo$xlex$gsrxvspw$qe}$figsqi$mrehiuyexi$figeywi$sj$glerkiw$mr

gsrhmxmsrw0$sv$xlex$xli$hikvii$sj$gsqtpmergi${mxl$xli$tspmgmiw$sv$tvsgihyviw$qe}$hixivmsvexi2

3w3$KVERX$XLSVRXSR$PPT

Qmeqm0$Jpsvmhe

Jifvyev}$6:0$6464

;7

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 109 of 253

Page 132: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 54=367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

VITSVX$SJ$MRHITIRHIRX$VIKMWXIVIH$TYFPMG$EGGSYRXMRK$JMVQ

Fsevh$sj$Hmvigxsvw$erh$Wlevilsphivw

Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

Stmrmsr$sr$xli$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw

[i$lezi$eyhmxih$xli$eggsqter}mrk$gsrwspmhexih$fepergi$wliixw$sj$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2$,e$Jpsvmhe$gsvtsvexmsr-$erh$wyfwmhmevmiw$,xli

ÔGsqter}Õ-$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$645<0$xli$vipexih$gsrwspmhexih$wxexiqirxw$sj$stivexmsrw0$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$,psww-0

wlevilsphivw×$iuymx}0$erh$gewl$jps{w$jsv$iegl$sj$xli$xlvii$}ievw$mr$xli$tivmsh$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$erh$xli$vipexih$rsxiw$erh

jmrergmep$wxexiqirx$wglihypiw$mrgpyhih$yrhiv$Mxiq$59,e-$,gsppigxmzip}$vijivvih$xs$ew$xli$Ôjmrergmep$wxexiqirxwÕ-2$Mr$syv$stmrmsr0$xli

jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$tviwirx$jemvp}0$mr$epp$qexivmep$viwtigxw0$xli$jmrergmep$tswmxmsr$sj$xli$Gsqter}$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$645<0

erh$xli$viwypxw$sj$mxw$stivexmsrw$erh$mxw$gewl$jps{w$jsv$iegl$sj$xli$xlvii$}ievw$mr$xli$tivmsh$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$mr$gsrjsvqmx}

{mxl$eggsyrxmrk$tvmrgmtpiw$kirivepp}$eggitxih$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw$sj$Eqivmge2

[i$epws$lezi$eyhmxih0$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$xli$wxerhevhw$sj$xli$Tyfpmg$Gsqter}$Eggsyrxmrk$Szivwmklx$Fsevh$,Yrmxih$Wxexiw-

,ÔTGESFÕ-0$xli$Gsqter}×w$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$fewih$sr$gvmxivme$iwxefpmwlih$mr$xli

6457$Mrxivrep$Gsrxvsp1Mrxikvexih$Jveqi{svo$mwwyih$f}$xli$Gsqqmxxii$sj$Wtsrwsvmrk$Svkerm~exmsrw$sj$xli$Xvieh{e}$Gsqqmwwmsr

,ÔGSWSÕ-0$erh$syv$vitsvx$hexih$Jifvyev}$6:0$6464$i|tviwwih$er$yruyepmjmih$stmrmsr2

Glerki$mr$eggsyrxmrk$tvmrgmtpi

Ew$hmwgywwih$mr$Rsxi$5$xs$xli$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw0$xli$Gsqter}$lew$glerkih$mxw$qixlsh$sj$eggsyrxmrk$jsv$Piewiw$sr

Neryev}$50$645=$hyi$xs$xli$ehstxmsr$sj$EWY$645:1460$ÔPiewiwÕ2

Fewmw$jsv$stmrmsr

Xliwi$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$evi$xli$viwtsrwmfmpmx}$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$qerekiqirx2$Syv$viwtsrwmfmpmx}$mw$xs$i|tviww$er$stmrmsr$sr$xli

Gsqter}×w$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$fewih$sr$syv$eyhmxw2$[i$evi$e$tyfpmg$eggsyrxmrk$jmvq$vikmwxivih${mxl$xli$TGESF$erh$evi$viuymvih$xs

fi$mrhitirhirx${mxl$viwtigx$xs$xli$Gsqter}$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$xli$Y2W2$jihivep$wigyvmxmiw$pe{w$erh$xli$ettpmgefpi$vypiw$erh

vikypexmsrw$sj$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$erh$I|glerki$Gsqqmwwmsr$erh$xli$TGESF2

[i$gsrhygxih$syv$eyhmxw$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$xli$wxerhevhw$sj$xli$TGESF2$Xlswi$wxerhevhw$viuymvi$xlex${i$tper$erh$tivjsvq$xli$eyhmx

xs$sfxemr$viewsrefpi$ewwyvergi$efsyx${lixliv$xli$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$evi$jvii$sj$qexivmep$qmwwxexiqirx0${lixliv$hyi$xs$ivvsv$sv$jveyh2

Syv$eyhmxw$mrgpyhih$tivjsvqmrk$tvsgihyviw$xs$ewwiww$xli$vmwow$sj$qexivmep$qmwwxexiqirx$sj$xli$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw0${lixliv$hyi$xs$ivvsv

sv$jveyh0$erh$tivjsvqmrk$tvsgihyviw$xlex$viwtsrh$xs$xlswi$vmwow2$Wygl$tvsgihyviw$mrgpyhih$i|eqmrmrk0$sr$e$xiwx$fewmw0$izmhirgi

wyttsvxmrk$xli$eqsyrxw$erh$hmwgpswyviw$mr$xli$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw2$Syv$eyhmxw$epws$mrgpyhih$izepyexmrk$xli$eggsyrxmrk$tvmrgmtpiw$ywih

erh$wmkrmjmgerx$iwxmqexiw$qehi$f}$qerekiqirx0$ew${ipp$ew$izepyexmrk$xli$szivepp$tviwirxexmsr$sj$xli$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw2$[i$fipmizi

xlex$syv$eyhmxw$tvszmhi$e$viewsrefpi$fewmw$jsv$syv$stmrmsr2

Gvmxmgep$eyhmx$qexxivw

Xli$gvmxmgep$eyhmx$qexxivw$gsqqyrmgexih$fips{$evi$qexxivw$evmwmrk$jvsq$xli$gyvvirx$tivmsh$eyhmx$sj$xli$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$xlex${ivi

gsqqyrmgexih$sv$viuymvih$xs$fi$gsqqyrmgexih$xs$xli$eyhmx$gsqqmxxii$erh$xlex>$,5-$vipexi$xs$eggsyrxw$sv$hmwgpswyviw$xlex$evi$qexivmep$xs

xli$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$erh$,6-$mrzspzih$syv$iwtigmepp}$gleppirkmrk0$wyfnigxmzi0$sv$gsqtpi|$nyhkqirxw2$Xli$gsqqyrmgexmsr$sj$gvmxmgep

eyhmx$qexxivw$hsiw$rsx$epxiv$mr$er}${e}$syv$stmrmsr$sr$xli$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw0$xeoir$ew$e${lspi0$erh${i$evi$rsx0$f}$gsqqyrmgexmrk$xli

gvmxmgep$eyhmx$qexxivw$fips{0$tvszmhmrk$witevexi$stmrmsrw$sr$xli$gvmxmgep$eyhmx$qexxivw$sv$sr$xli$eggsyrxw$sv$hmwgpswyviw$xs${lmgl$xli}

vipexi2

Wipj1Mrwyvergi$Viwivziw$erh$Vipexih$I|tirwiw

Ew$hiwgvmfih$jyvxliv$mr$Rsxi$5$xs$xli$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2$,xli$ÔGsqter}Õ-$wipj1mrwyviw0$yt$xs

givxemr$tspmg}1wtigmjmih$pmqmxw0$givxemr$vmwow$vipexih$xs$kirivep$pmefmpmx}0${svoivw×$gsqtirwexmsr0$erh$zilmgpi$pmefmpmx}$gswxw2$Xli

iwxmqexih$gswx$sj$gpemqw$yrhiv$xliwi$wipj1mrwyvergi$tvskveqw$mw$iwxmqexih$erh$eggvyih$ew$xli$gpemqw$evi$mrgyvvih$,epxlsykl$egxyep

wixxpiqirx$sj$xli$gpemqw$qe}$rsx$fi$qehi$yrxmp$jyxyvi$tivmshw-$erh$qe}$wyfwiuyirxp}$fi$vizmwih$fewih$sr$hizipstqirxw$vipexmrk$xs

wygl$gpemqw2$[i$mhirxmjmih$wipj1mrwyvergi$viwivziw$erh$vipexih$i|tirwiw$,Ôwipj1mrwyvergiÕ-$ew$e$gvmxmgep$eyhmx$qexxiv2

Xli$tvmrgmtep$gsrwmhivexmsrw$jsv$syv$hixivqmrexmsr$xlex$wipj1mrwyvergi$mw$e$gvmxmgep$eyhmx$qexxiv$evi$xlex$xli$eggvyep$jsv$wipj1mrwyvergi$lew

lmkliv$vmwo$sj$iwxmqexmsr$yrgivxemrx}$hyi$xs$xli$psww$hizipstqirx$jegxsvw$erh$mrlivirx$ewwyqtxmsrw$mr$egxyevmep$qixlshw$ywih$mr

hixivqmrmrk$xli$viuymvih$viwivziw2$Xli$iwxmqexmsr$yrgivxemrx}$erh$gsqtpi|mx}$sj$xli$egxyevmep$qixlshw$yxmpm~ih$viwypxih$mr$eyhmxsv

nyhkiqirx${lir$ewwiwwmrk$mj$qerekiqirx×w$eggvyep$jsv$wipj1mrwyvergi${ew$hixivqmrih$yxmpm~mrk$e$viewsrefpi$fewmw$erh${ew$qexivmepp}

gsvvigx2

;8

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 110 of 253

Page 133: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 554367<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 111 of 253

Page 134: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 555367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Syv$eyhmx$tvsgihyviw$vipexih$xs$xli$wipj1mrwyvergi$viwivziw$mrgpyhih$xli$jspps{mrk0$eqsrk$sxlivw>

¨ [i$xiwxih$xli$hiwmkr$erh$stivexmrk$ijjigxmziriww$sj$oi}$gsrxvspw$vipexmrk$xs$wipj1mrwyvergi0$mrgpyhmrk0$fyx$rsx$pmqmxih$xs0

gsrxvspw$xlex$,5-$zepmhexi$xlex$gpemqw${ivi$vitsvxih$erh$wyfqmxxih$eggyvexip}$erh$xmqip}0$erh$,6-$zepmhexi$xlex$mrxivrep$gpemqw

hexe${ivi$vigsrgmpih$xs$gpemqw$hexe$qemrxemrih$f}$xli$xlmvh$tevx}$ehqmrmwxvexsv$erh$wyfqmxxih$xs$xli$Gsqter}×w$egxyev}2

¨ [i$yxmpm~ih$e$wtigmepmwx$mr$izepyexmrk$qerekiqirx×w$qixlshw$erh$ewwyqtxmsrw0$mrgpyhmrk$wipigxih$psww$hizipstqirx$jegxsvw2

¨ [i$tivjsvqih$e$vixvswtigxmzi$vizmi{$sj$tvmsv$tvsnigxmsrw$xs$gyvvirx$tvsnigxmsrw$xs$izepyexi$xli$viewsrefpiriww$sj$glerkiw$mr

iwxmqexih$ypxmqexi$pswwiw2

¨ [i$vigsrgmpih$gpemqw$hexe$xs$xli$egxyevmep$mrjsvqexmsr$erh$xiwxih$e$weqtpi$sj$yrhivp}mrk$gpemqw$xlvsykl$vizmi{$sj$eggmhirx

vitsvxw0$mrwyvergi$gpemqw$erh$pikep$vigsvhw$xs$izepyexi${lixliv$mrjsvqexmsr$yxmpm~ih$f}$qerekiqirx$mr$hizipstmrk$xli$eggvyep

jsv$wipj1mrwyvergi${ew$gsqtpixi$erh$eggyvexi2

Eppsgexmsr$sj$i|tirwiw$fix{iir$VIMX$erh$XVW$irxmxmiw

Ew$hiwgvmfih$jyvxliv$mr$Rsxi$5$xs$xli$Gsqter}×w$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw0$xli$Gsqter}$stivexiw$ew$e$VIMX$jsv$jihivep$mrgsqi$xe|

tyvtswiw2$Ew$e$VIMX0$xli$Gsqter}$mw$viuymvih$xs$hmwxvmfyxi$ex$piewx$=4)$sj$mxw$xe|efpi$mrgsqi$xs$wlevilsphivw0$erh$hsiw$rsx$te}$er}

xe|iw$sr$xlex$hmwxvmfyxih$mrgsqi2$Mrgsqi$ievrih$mr$mxw$rsr1viep$iwxexi$gsqtsrirxw0$sv$xe|efpi$VIMX$wyfwmhmevmiw$,ÔXVWwÕ-$evi$wyfnigx$xs

jihivep$erh$wxexi$gsvtsvexi$mrgsqi$xe|iw$erh$xs$jsvimkr$xe|iw$ew$ettpmgefpi$mr$xli$nyvmwhmgxmsrw$mr${lmgl$xlswi$ewwixw$erh$stivexmsrw$evi

psgexih2$Ew$wygl0${i$mhirxmjmih$xli$eppsgexmsr$sj$i|tirwiw0$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$xli$Gsqter}×w$xverwjiv$tvmgmrk$tspmg}0$fix{iir$xli$XVW

erh$VIMX$ew$e$gvmxmgep$eyhmx$qexxiv2

Xli$tvmrgmtep$gsrwmhivexmsrw$jsv$syv$hixivqmrexmsr$xlex$xli$eppsgexmsr$sj$i|tirwiw$fix{iir$xli$XVW$erh$VIMX$mw$e$gvmxmgep$eyhmx$qexxiv

evi$xlex$wmkrmjmgerx$qerekiqirx$nyhkiqirx$mw$viuymvih$xs$hixivqmri$ls{$xverwegxmsrw$fix{iir$xli$VIMX$erh$XVW$irxmxmiw$evi$tvmgih

erh$ls{$wlevih$i|tirwiw$evi$eppsgexih2

Syv$eyhmx$tvsgihyviw$vipexih$xs$xli$eppsgexmsr$sj$i|tirwiw$fix{iir$VIMX$erh$XVW$irxmxmiw$mrgpyhih$xli$jspps{mrk0$eqsrk$sxlivw>

¨ [i$xiwxih$xli$hiwmkr$erh$stivexmrk$ijjigxmziriww$sj$oi}$gsrxvspw$vipexmrk$xs$xli$eppsgexmsr$sj$i|tirwiw$fix{iir$xli$VIMX$erh

XVW$irxmxmiw0$mrgpyhmrk0$fyx$rsx$pmqmxih$xs0$gsrxvspw$xlex$,5-$zepmhexi$xli$wmkrmjmgerx$mrtyxw$ywih$mr$xli$xverwjiv$tvmgmrk$erep}wmw0

,6-$zepmhexi$xli$ettpmgexmsr$sj$xli$xverwjiv$tvmgmrk$xs$vigsvhih$xverwegxmsrw0$erh$,7-$zepmhexi$mrtyxw$erh$ewwyqtxmsrw$ywih$xs

eppsgexi$kirivep$erh$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw2

¨ [i$yxmpm~ih$e$wtigmepmwx$mr$izepyexmrk$xli$viewsrefpiriww$sj$qerekiqirx×w$qixlshw$erh$ewwyqtxmsrw$jsv$hixivqmrmrk$xli

xverwjiv$tvmgmrk$qevoyt$sr$wivzmgiw$tvszmhih$fix{iir$xli$VIMX$erh$XVW$irxmxmiw2

¨ [i$xiwxih$wmkrmjmgerx$mrtyxw$ywih$mr$qerekiqirx×w$xverwjiv$tvmgmrk$erep}wmw0$xiwxih$xli$ettpmgexmsr$sj$xli$xverwjiv$tvmgmrk$xs

vigsvhih$xverwegxmsrw0$erh$xiwxih$qerekiqirx×w$tvsgiww$erh$iwxmqexiw$ywih$xs$eppsgexi$kirivep$erh$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw$xs

ewwiww$xli$eppsgexmsr$sj$xverwegxmsrw$fix{iir$xli$VIMX$erh$XVW$irxmxmiw2

3w3$KVERX$XLSVRXSR$PPT

[i$lezi$wivzih$ew$xli$Gsqter}×w$eyhmxsv$wmrgi$644:2

Qmeqm0$Jpsvmhe

Jifvyev}$6:0$6464

;9

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 112 of 253

Page 135: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 556367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

;:

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 113 of 253

Page 136: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 557367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

XLI$KIS$KVSYT0$MRG2

GSRWSPMHEXIH$WXEXIQIRXW$SJ$STIVEXMSRW

]ievw$Irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$645<$erh$645;

$

$ 645= $ 645< $ 645;

$ ,Mr$xlsywerhw0$i|gitx$tiv$wlevi$hexe-

Viziryiw ( 608;;0=66 $ ( 6077507<: $ ( 606:70864

Stivexmrk$I|tirwiw$,i|gpyhmrk$hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr- 50<:40;9< $ 50;990;;6 $ 50;4408=9

Hitvigmexmsr$erh$Eqsvxm~exmsr 5740<69 $ 56:0878 $ 56806=;

Kirivep$erh$Ehqmrmwxvexmzi$I|tirwiw 5<90=6: $ 5<80959 $ 5=40787

Stivexmrk$Mrgsqi 7440857 $ 6:80::9 $ 68<06<9

Mrxiviwx$Mrgsqi 6<0=78 $ 780;99 $ 950:;:

Mrxiviwx$I|tirwi ,5950468- $ ,5940547- $ ,58<0468-

Psww$sr$I|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$Hifx ,80;=9- $ Ó $ Ó

Mrgsqi$Fijsvi$Mrgsqi$Xe|iw$erh$Iuymx}$mr$Ievrmrkw$sj$Ejjmpmexiw 5;7096< $ 58=075; $ 5950=7;

Tvszmwmsr$jsv$Mrgsqi$Xe|iw 5:0:8< $ 58055; $ 5;0=9<

Iuymx}$mr$Ievrmrkw$sj$Ejjmpmexiw0$rix$sj$mrgsqi$xe|$,firijmx-$tvszmwmsr$sj$(50;:=0

(<<<$erh$(,70:==- =0976 $ =0:6; $ 560489

Rix$Mrgsqi 5::0856 $ 5880<6; $ 58:0468

Psww$Exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Rsrgsrxvsppmrk$Mrxiviwxw 5=5 $ 6:6 $ 65;

Rix$Mrgsqi$Exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2 ( 5::0:47 $ ( 58904<= $ ( 58:0685

$ $ $ $ $ $

[imklxih$Eziveki$Gsqqsr$Wleviw$Syxwxerhmrk> $ $ $ $ $

Fewmg 55=04=; $ 5640685 $ 56404=9

Hmpyxih 55=0755 $ 5640;8; $ 5640<58

Mrgsqi$tiv$Gsqqsr$Wlevi$Exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2> $ $ $ $ $

Fewmg> $ $ $ $ $

Rix$mrgsqi$tiv$wlevi$Ó$fewmg ( 5284 $ ( 5265 $ ( 5266

Hmpyxih> $ $ $ $ $

Rix$mrgsqi$tiv$wlevi$Ó$hmpyxih ( 5284 $ ( 5264 $ ( 5265

Hmzmhirhw$higpevih$tiv$wlevi ( 52=6 $ ( 52<< $ ( 52<<

Xli$eggsqter}mrk$rsxiw$evi$er$mrxikvep$tevx$sj$xliwi$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw2

;;

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 114 of 253

Page 137: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 558367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

XLI$KIS$KVSYT0$MRG2

GSRWSPMHEXIH$WXEXIQIRXW$SJ$GSQTVIRWMZI$MRGSQI$,PSWW-

]ievw$Irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$645<$erh$645;

$ 645= $ 645< $ 645;

$ ,Mr$xlsywerhw-

Rix$Mrgsqi ( 5::0856 $ ( 5880<6; $ ( 58:0468

Jsvimkr$gyvvirg}$xverwpexmsr$ehnywxqirxw 606:; $ ,;055<- $ 70<4<

Tirwmsr$pmefmpmx}$ehnywxqirx0$rix$sj$mrgsqi$xe|$tvszmwmsr$,firijmx-$sj

(,:<5-0$(=57$erh$(,;:8-0$viwtigxmzip} ,7068;- $ 50;<9 $ ,50864-

Glerki$mr$jemv$zepyi$sj$hivmzexmzi$mrwxvyqirx$gpewwmjmih$ew$gewl$jps{

lihki0$rix$sj$mrgsqi$xe|$tvszmwmsr$,firijmx-$sj$(:660$(504<9$erh$(;470

viwtigxmzip} 806;5 $ :058: $ 70=<9

Xsxep$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi0$rix$sj$xe| 706=5 $ <57 $ :07;7

Xsxep$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi 5:=0;47 $ 5890:84 $ 59607=;

Gsqtvilirwmzi$psww$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$rsrgsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw 5<7 $ 6;; $ 655

Gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2 ( 5:=0<<: $ ( 5890=5; $ ( 5960:4<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 115 of 253

Page 138: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 559367<

;<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 116 of 253

Page 139: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 55:367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

XLI$KIS$KVSYT0$MRG2

GSRWSPMHEXIH$FEPERGI$WLIIXW

Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$645<

$ 645= $ 645<

$,Mr$xlsywerhw0$i|gitx

wlevi$hexe-

EWWIXW

Gyvvirx$Ewwixw $ $ $

Gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw ( 7608:7 $ ( 750699

Viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$mrziwxqirxw 76085< $ 950:;<

Eggsyrxw$vigimzefpi0$piww$epps{ergi$jsv$hsyfxjyp$eggsyrxw$sj$(705=9$erh$(805<70$viwtigxmzip} 8740=<6 $ 889096:

Gsrxvegx$vigimzefpi0$gyvvirx$tsvxmsr 5505== $ 590979

Tvitemh$i|tirwiw$erh$sxliv$gyvvirx$ewwixw 840;5: $ 9;0;:<

Xsxep$gyvvirx$ewwixw 98;0;;< $ :450;:6

Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Mrziwxqirxw 740=67 $ 660875

Tvstivx}$erh$Iuymtqirx0$Rix 605880;66 $ 6059<0:54

Gsrxvegx$Vigimzefpi 7:40:8; $ 7:<05;<

Stivexmrk$Piewi$Vmklx1sj1Ywi$Ewwixw0$Rix 565096; $ Ó

Ewwixw$Liph$jsv$Wepi :049= $ 60:78

Hijivvih$Mrgsqi$Xe|$Ewwixw 7:06;< $ 6=0=68

Kssh{mpp ;;:079: $ ;;:079=

Mrxerkmfpi$Ewwixw0$Rix 65404;4 $ 67607:4

Sxliv$Rsr1Gyvvirx$Ewwixw <705;8 $ :90<:4

Xsxep$Ewwixw ( 8075;0978 $ ( 8069<055<

PMEFMPMXMIW$ERH$WLEVILSPHIVW×$IUYMX]

Gyvvirx$Pmefmpmxmiw $ $ $

Eggsyrxw$te}efpi ( ==0676 $ ( =70476

Eggvyih$te}vspp$erh$vipexih$xe|iw 980:;6 $ ;:044=

Eggvyih$i|tirwiw$erh$sxliv$gyvvirx$pmefmpmxmiw 5=50:4< $ 64805;4

Stivexmrk$piewi$pmefmpmxmiw0$gyvvirx$tsvxmsr 6:064< $ Ó

Gyvvirx$tsvxmsr$sj$jmrergi$piewi$pmefmpmxmiw0$psrk1xivq$hifx$erh$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx 68064< $ 776046;

Xsxep$gyvvirx$pmefmpmxmiw 7=90=6< $ ;49067<

Hijivvih$Mrgsqi$Xe|$Pmefmpmxmiw 5=0698 $ 570:<5

Sxliv$Rsr1Gyvvirx$Pmefmpmxmiw <<096: $ <608<5

Stivexmrk$Piewi$Pmefmpmxmiw =;06=5 $ Ó

Jmrergi$Piewi$Sfpmkexmsrw 60=98 $ 809;4

Psrk1Xivq$Hifx 6084<06=; $ 607=;066;

Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Hifx$ 74=067: $ 59045;

Gsqqmxqirxw$erh$Gsrxmrkirgmiw$,Rsxi$5<- $

Wlevilsphivw×$Iuymx} $ $ $

Tvijivvih$wxsgo0$(4245$tev$zepyi0$7404440444$wleviw$eyxlsvm~ih0$rsri$mwwyih$sv$syxwxerhmrk Ó $ Ó

Gsqqsr$wxsgo0$(4245$tev$zepyi0$5<;09440444$wleviw$eyxlsvm~ih0$569087909;7$erh$5680;=80=<:

mwwyih$erh$5650669075=$erh$56409<80;76$syxwxerhmrk0$viwtigxmzip} 50698 $ 5068<

Ehhmxmsrep$temh1mr$getmxep 506740<:9 $ 506540=5:

Hmwxvmfyxmsrw$mr$i|giww$sj$ievrmrkw ,55=0;;=- $ ,960<:<-

Eggyqypexih$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$psww ,640779- $ ,670:5<-

Xviewyv}$wxsgo0$806540698$erh$806540698$wleviw0$ex$gswx0$viwtigxmzip} ,=905;9- $ ,=905;9-

Xsxep$wlevilsphivw×$iuymx}$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2 ==:0<74 $ 504840947

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 117 of 253

Page 140: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 55;367<

Rsrgsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw ,;<6- $ ,9==-

Xsxep$wlevilsphivw×$iuymx} ==:048< $ 5047=0=48

Xsxep$Pmefmpmxmiw$erh$Wlevilsphivw×$Iuymx} ( 8075;0978 $ ( 8069<055<

$

Xli$eggsqter}mrk$rsxiw$evi$er$mrxikvep$tevx$sj$xliwi$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw2

;=

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 118 of 253

Page 141: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 55<367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

XLI$KIS$KVSYT0$MRG2

GSRWSPMHEXIH$WXEXIQIRXW$SJ$GEWL$JPS[W

]iev$Irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$645<$erh$645;

$ 645= $ 645< $ 645;

$ ,Mr$xlsywerhw-

Gewl$Jps{$jvsq$Stivexmrk$Egxmzmxmiw> $ $ $ $ $

Rix$Mrgsqi( 5::0856 $ ( 5880<6; $ ( 58:0468

Rix$psww$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$rsrgsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw5=5 $ 6:6 $ 65;

Rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg25::0:47 $ 58904<= $ 58:0685

Ehnywxqirxw$xs$vigsrgmpi$rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2$xs$rix$gewl$tvszmhih$f}$,ywih$mr-$stivexmrk$egxmzmxmiw> $ $ $ $ $

Hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr$i|tirwi5740<69 $ 56:0878 $ 56806=;

Hijivvih$xe|$tvszmwmsr$,firijmx-,9<<- $ 50674 $ 56067<

Eqsvxm~exmsr$sj$hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw0$hmwgsyrx$erh3sv$tviqmyq$erh$sxliv$rsr1gewl$mrxiviwx<0:4= $ <0<9: $ 5:0984

Wxsgo1fewih$gsqtirwexmsr660788 $ 66048= $ 5=0<88

Psww$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx80;=9 $ Ó $ Ó

Tvszmwmsr$jsv$hsyfxjyp$eggsyrxw5=4 $ <67 $ 6089:

Iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw0$rix$sj$xe|,=0976- $ ,=0:6;- $ ,560489-

Psww$sr$wepi3hmwtswep$sj$tvstivx}$erh$iuymtqirx909;: $ 8067: $ 50964

Psww$sr$ewwixw$liph$jsv$wepi504<7 $ Ó $ Ó

Hmzmhirhw$vigimzih$jvsq$yrgsrwspmhexih$nsmrx$zirxyviw540756 $ 550<8: $ :0576

Glerkiw$mr$ewwixw$erh$pmefmpmxmiw0$rix$sj$eguymwmxmsr> $ $ $ $ $

Glerkiw$mr$eggsyrxw$vigimzefpi0$tvitemh$i|tirwiw$erh$sxliv$ewwixw,<07=5- $ ,::0545- $ 640=7<

Glerkiw$mr$gsrxvegx$vigimzefpi,80799- $ ,6048=- $ 840959

Glerkiw$mr$eggsyrxw$te}efpi0$eggvyih$i|tirwiw$erh$sxliv$pmefmpmxmiw540:;6 $ 750:<= $ 607::

Rix$gewl$tvszmhih$f}$stivexmrk$egxmzmxmiw77<0587 $ 6;808;9 $ 7<50486

Gewl$Jps{$jvsq$Mrziwxmrk$Egxmzmxmiw> $ $ $ $ $

Eguymwmxmsr$sj$GIG0$gewl$gsrwmhivexmsr0$rix$sj$gewl$eguymvihÓ $ Ó $ ,797099:-

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$wepi$sj$tvstivx}$erh$iuymtqirx858 $ 604;; $ 708:4

Mrwyvergi$tvsgiihw$1$heqekih$tvstivx}5=0754 $ 5087< $ 60;98

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$wepi$sj$ewwixw$liph$jsv$wepi<67 $ 70;=; $ Ó

Glerki$mr$viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$mrziwxqirxw,;0884- $ ,56=- $ ,8094;-

Getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw,55;0688- $ ,5=90:::- $ ,58<084:-

Rix$gewl$ywih$mr$mrziwxmrk$egxmzmxmiw,548057;- $ ,5<<08<7- $ ,9440699-

Gewl$Jps{$jvsq$Jmrergmrk$Egxmzmxmiw> $ $ $ $ $

Te}qirxw$sr$psrk1xivq$hifx,957065=- $ ,6<6079<- $ ,505840;<<-

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$psrk$xivq$hifx96507;4 $ 9460==< $ 507<=04<8

Te}qirxw$sr$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx,779055:- $ ,5<0988- $ ,74;0858-

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx7650546 $ Ó $ 5<50:9<

Xe|iw$temh$vipexih$xs$rix$wlevi$wixxpiqirxw$sj$iuymx}$e{evhw,805;=- $ ,70<64- $ ,80586-

Hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw,=0<9:- $ ,==4- $ ,=0986-

Te}qirxw$jsv$tyvglewi$sj$xviewyv}$wleviwÓ $ ,=905;9- $ Ó

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$wxsgo$stxmsrw$i|ivgmwih5069< $ 50<<; $ :0=:6

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$mwwyergi$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$IWTT976 $ 978 $ 8=;

Mwwyergi$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$tyfpmg$sjjivmrkÓ $ Ó $ 6;90<:;

Hmzmhirhw$temh,676098:- $ ,66=08=<- $ ,66;08:7-

Rix$gewl$,ywih$mr-$tvszmhih$f}$jmrergmrk$egxmzmxmiw,6940:98- $ ,5680=::- $ 5:80;5=

Ijjigx$sj$I|glerki$Vexi$Glerkiw$sr$Gewl0$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw$erh$Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw,796- $ ,5404==- $ ,6075<-

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 119 of 253

Page 142: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 55=367<

Rix$,Higviewi-$Mrgviewi$mr$Gewl0$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw$erh$Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw ,5;0444- $ ,8=04;7- $ 8705<<

Gewl0$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw$erh$Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw0$fikmrrmrk$sj$tivmsh<808;6 $ 5770989 $ =4079;

Gewl0$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw$erh$Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw0$irh$sj$tivmsh( :;08;6 $ ( <808;6 $ ( 5770989

Wyttpiqirxep$Hmwgpswyviw $ $ $ $ $

Gewl$temh$hyvmrk$xli$}iev$jsv> $ $ $ $ $

Mrgsqi$xe|iw( 5505:4 $ ( <0479 $ ( 570<4=

Mrxiviwx( 57909;= $ ( 57709:: $ ( 5590798

Rsr1gewl$mrziwxmrk$erh$jmrergmrk$egxmzmxmiw> $ $ $ $ $

Vmklx1sj1ywi$ewwixw$sfxemrih$jvsq$stivexmrk$piewi$pmefmpmxmiw$ytsr$ehstxmsr$sj$ri{$piewi$wxerhevh$1$Vijiv$xs$58$1$Piewiw( 58;0444 $ ( Ó $ ( Ó

Vmklx1sj1ywi$ewwixw$sfxemrih$jvsq$stivexmrk$piewi$pmefmpmxmiw$,wyfwiuyirx$xs$mrmxmep$ehstxmsr-( 560667 $ ( Ó $ ( Ó

Getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw$mr$eggsyrxw$te}efpi$erh$eggvyih$i|tirwiw( 55048= $ ( 590697 $ ( 57047=

Xli$eggsqter}mrk$rsxiw$evi$er$mrxikvep$tevx$sj$xliwi$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw2

<4

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 120 of 253

Page 143: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 564367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

XLI$KIS$KVSYT0$MRG2

GSRWSPMHEXIH$WXEXIQIRXW$SJ$WLEVILSPHIVW×$IUYMX]

]ievw$Irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$645<$erh$645;

$

$ KIS$Kvsyt$Mrg2$Wlevilsphivw $

RsrgsrxvsppmrkMrxiviwx

$

XsxepWlevilsphivw×

Iuymx}

$ Gsqqsr$Wxsgo $ $ $ $ $

EggyqypexihSxliv

GsqtvilirwmziMrgsqi$,Psww- $

Xviewyv}$Wxsgo $ $

$Ryqfivsj$Wleviw $ Eqsyrx $

EhhmxmsrepTemh1MrGetmxep $

,Hmwxvmfyxmsrw$mrI|giww$sj

Ievrmrkw3Ievrmrkwmr$I|giww$sjHmwxvmfyxmsrw $

Ryqfivsj$Wleviw $ Eqsyrx $ $

$ ,Mr$xlsywerhw-

Fepergi0$Neryev}50$645; 556098< $ ( 50569 $ ( <=50==7 $ ( 5560;:7 $ ( ,740<69- $ Ó $ ( Ó $ ( ,==- $ ( =;80=9;

Tvsgiihw$jvsqwxsgo$stxmsrwi|ivgmwih 79< $ 8 $ :0=9< $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ :0=:6

Xe|$firijmxvipexih$xs$iuymx}gsqtirwexmsr Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó

Wxsgo$fewihgsqtirwexmsri|tirwi Ó $ Ó $ 5=0<88 $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ 5=0<88

Wleviw${mxlliphjsv$rix$wixxpiqirxwsj$wlevi1fewihe{evhw$_6a ,57:- $ ,5- $ ,80585- $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ ,80586-

Viwxvmgxih$wxsgokverxih =77 $ = $ ,=- $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó

Viwxvmgxih$wxsgogergipih ,:9- $ ,5- $ 5 $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó

Hmzmhirhw$1$temh Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ ,66;08:7- $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ ,66;08:7-

Mwwyergi$sjgsqqsr$wxsgoyrhiv$tvswtigxywwyttpiqirx 540794 $ 548 $ 6;90;:7 $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ 6;90<:;

Tyvglewi$sjxviewyv}$wleviw Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó

Mwwyergi$sjgsqqsr$wxsgo,IWTT- 64 $ Ó $ 8=; $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ 8=;

Rix$mrgsqi$,psww-Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ 58:0685 $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ ,65;- $ 58:0468

Sxlivgsqtvilirwmzimrgsqi Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ :07;= $ Ó $ Ó $ ,:- $ :07;7

Fepergi0Higiqfiv$750645; 568044< $ ( 50684 $ (505=40=4: $ ( 750985 $ ( ,68088:- $ Ó $ ( Ó $ ( ,766- $ ( 505=<0=5=

Tvsgiihw$jvsqwxsgo$stxmsrwi|ivgmwih 547 $ 5 $ 50<<: $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ 50<<;

Wxsgo$fewihgsqtirwexmsri|tirwi Ó $ Ó $ 66048= $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ 66048=

Wleviw${mxlliphjsv$rix$wixxpiqirxwsj$wlevi1fewihe{evhw$_6a ,5;7- $ ,6- $ ,70<5<- $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ ,70<64-

Viwxvmgxih$wxsgokverxih =4: $ = $ ,=- $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó

Viwxvmgxih$wxsgogergipih ,;7- $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó

Hmzmhirhw$temhÓ $ Ó $ Ó $ ,66=08=<- $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ ,66=08=<-

<5

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 121 of 253

Page 144: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 565367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Tyvglewi$sj$xviewyv}wleviw ,80654- $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ 80654 $ ,=905;9- $ Ó $ ,=905;9-

Mwwyergi$sjgsqqsr$wxsgo,IWTT- 68 $ Ó $ 978 $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ 978

Sxliv$ehnywxqirxwxs$Ehhmxmsrep$Temh1Mr1Getmxep$_5a Ó $ Ó $ ,:76- $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ ,:76-

Rix$mrgsqi$,psww-Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ 58904<= $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ ,6:6- $ 5880<6;

Sxlivgsqtvilirwmzimrgsqi$,psww- Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ <6< $ Ó $ Ó $ ,59- $ <57

Fepergi0$Higiqfiv750$645< 56409<9 $ ( 5068< $ (506540=5: $ ( ,960<:<- $ ( ,670:5<- $ 80654 $ ( ,=905;9- $ ( ,9==- $ ( 5047=0=48

Tvsgiihw$jvsqwxsgo$stxmsrwi|ivgmwih ;< $ Ó $ 5069< $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ 5069<

Wxsgo$fewihgsqtirwexmsri|tirwi Ó $ Ó $ 660788 $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ 660788

Wleviw${mxlliph$jsvrix$wixxpiqirxw$sjwlevi1fewih$e{evhw_6a ,5=<- $ ,6- $ ,805;;- $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ ,805;=-

Viwxvmgxih$wxsgokverxih ;<< $ < $ ,<- $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó

Viwxvmgxih$wxsgogergipih ,9<- $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó

Hmzmhirhw$temh Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ ,676098:- $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ ,676098:-

Tyvglewi$sj$xviewyv}wleviw Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó

Mwwyergi$sjgsqqsr$wxsgo,IWTT- 74 $ Ó $ 976 $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ 976

Xverwmxmsrehnywxqirx$jsveggsyrxmrk$wxerhevhehstxmsr$_7a Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ ,=:<- $ =:< $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó

Rix$mrgsqi$,psww-Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ 5::0:47 $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ ,5=5- $ 5::0856

Sxlivgsqtvilirwmzimrgsqi$,psww- Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ 60759 $ Ó $ Ó $ < $ 60767

Fepergi0$Higiqfiv750$645= 5650669 $ ( 50698 $ (506740<:9 $ ( ,55=0;;=- $ ( ,640779- $ 80654 $ ( ,=905;9- $ ( ,;<6- $ ( ==:048<

_5a$Vitviwirxw$e$gyqypexmzi1ijjigx$ehnywxqirx$ytsr$ehstxmsr$sj$EWY$Rs2$645:15:0$&Mrgsqi$Xe|iw$1$Mrxve1Irxmx}$Xverwjivw$sj$Ewwixw$Sxliv$Xler$Mrzirxsv}2&$Vijiv$xsRsxi$5$1$Wyqqev}$sj$Fywmriww$Svkerm~exmsr0$Stivexmsrw$erh$Wmkrmjmgerx$Eggsyrxmrk$Tspmgmiw$1$Vigirx$Eggsyrxmrk$Tvsrsyrgiqirxw$jsv$jyvxliv$mrjsvqexmsr2

_6a$Hyvmrk$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$645<$erh$645;0$xli$Gsqter}${mxlliph$wleviw$xlvsykl$rix$wlevi$wixxpiqirxw$xs$wexmwj}$wxexyxsv}$xe|${mxllsphmrkviuymviqirxw$ytsr$ziwxmrk$sj$wleviw$sj$viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$liph$f}$iqtps}iiw2

_7a$Sr$Neryev}$50$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$ehstxih$Eggsyrxmrk$Wxerhevh$Ythexi$,&EWY&-$Rs2$645<146$&Mrgsqi$Wxexiqirx1Vitsvxmrk$Gsqtvilirwmzi$Mrgsqi1Vigpewwmjmgexmsrsj$Givxemr$Xe|$Ijjigxw$jvsq$Eggyqypexih$Sxliv$Gsqtvilirwmzi$Mrgsqi&2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$5$1$Wyqqev}$sj$Fywmriww$Svkerm~exmsr0$Stivexmsrw$erh$Wmkrmjmgerx$EggsyrxmrkTspmgmiw$1$Vigirx$Eggsyrxmrk$Tvsrsyrgiqirxw$jsv$jyvxliv$mrjsvqexmsr2

Xli$eggsqter}mrk$rsxiw$evi$er$mrxikvep$tevx$sj$xliwi$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw2

<6

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 122 of 253

Page 145: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 566367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

XLI$KIS$KVSYT0$MRG2

RSXIW$XS$GSRWSPMHEXIH$JMRERGMEP$WXEXIQIRXW

Jsv$xli$]ievw$Irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$645<$erh$645;

$

52 Wyqqev}$sj$Fywmriww$Svkerm~exmsr0$Stivexmsrw$erh$Wmkrmjmgerx$Eggsyrxmrk$Tspmgmiw

Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$ Mrg20$ e$ Jpsvmhe$ gsvtsvexmsr0$ erh$ wyfwmhmevmiw$ ,xli$ ÔGsqter}Õ$ sv$ ÔKISÕ-$ mw$ e$ jypp}1mrxikvexih$ viep$ iwxexi

mrziwxqirx$xvywx$,ÔVIMXÕ-$wtigmepm~mrk$mr$xli$s{rivwlmt0$ piewmrk$erh$qerekiqirx$sj$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw0$tvsgiwwmrk$girxivw$erh$viirxv}

girxivw$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw0$Eywxvepme0$Wsyxl$Ejvmge$erh$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq2$Xli$Gsqter}$s{rw0$piewiw$erh$stivexiw$e$fvseh$verki

sj$ jegmpmxmiw$ mrgpyhmrk$qe|mqyq0$qihmyq$erh$qmrmqyq$wigyvmx}$ jegmpmxmiw0$ tvsgiwwmrk$ girxivw0$ ew${ipp$ ew$ gsqqyrmx}$fewih$ viirxv}

jegmpmxmiw$erh$sjjivw$er$i|terhih$hipmziv}$sj$vilefmpmxexmsr$wivzmgiw$yrhiv$mxw$+KIS$Gsrxmryyq$sj$Gevi+$tpexjsvq2$Xli$+KIS$Gsrxmryyq

sj$Gevi+$tpexjsvq$mrxikvexiw$irlergih$vilefmpmxexmzi$tvskveqw0${lmgl$evi$izmhirgi1fewih$erh$ mrgpyhi$gskrmxmzi$filezmsvep$ xviexqirx

erh$tswx1vipiewi$wivzmgiw0$erh$tvszmhiw$egehiqmg$erh$zsgexmsrep$gpewwiw$mr$pmji$womppw$erh$xviexqirx$tvskveqw${lmpi$liptmrk$mrhmzmhyepw

vimrxikvexi$ mrxs$ xlimv$ gsqqyrmxmiw2$ Xli$Gsqter}$ hizipstw$ ri{$ jegmpmxmiw$ fewih$ sr$ gsrxvegx$ e{evhw0$ ywmrk$ mxw$ tvsnigx$ hizipstqirx

i|tivxmwi$ erh$ i|tivmirgi$ xs$ hiwmkr0$ gsrwxvygx$ erh$ jmrergi${lex$ mx$ fipmiziw$ evi$ wxexi1sj1xli1evx$ jegmpmxmiw$ xlex$qe|mqm~i$ wigyvmx}$ erh

ijjmgmirg}2$ Xli$ Gsqter}$ tvszmhiw$ mrrszexmzi$ gsqtpmergi$ xiglrspskmiw0$ mrhywxv}1piehmrk$ qsrmxsvmrk$ wivzmgiw0$ erh$ izmhirgi1fewih

wytivzmwmsr$erh$xviexqirx$tvskveqw$jsv$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$tevspiiw0$tvsfexmsrivw$erh$tvixvmep$hijirherxw2$Xli$Gsqter}$epws$tvszmhiw

wigyvi$xverwtsvxexmsr$wivzmgiw$jsv$sjjirhiv$erh$hixemrii$tstypexmsrw$ew$gsrxvegxih$hsqiwxmgepp}$erh$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq$xlvsykl$mxw

nsmrx$zirxyvi$KIS$Eqi}$TIGW$Pxh2$,ÔKISEqi}Õ-2$Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$KIS+w${svph{mhi$stivexmsrw$mrgpyhih$xli$s{rivwlmt

erh3sv$qerekiqirx$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$=90444$fihw$ex$56=$wigyvi$erh$gsqqyrmx}$wivzmgiw$jegmpmxmiw0$mrgpyhmrk$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw$erh$tvsnigxw

yrhiv$hizipstqirx0$erh$epws$mrgpyhiw$xli$tvszmwmsr$sj$gsqqyrmx}$wytivzmwmsr$wivzmgiw$jsv$qsvi$xler$6540444$sjjirhivw$erh$tvixvmep

hijirherxw0$mrgpyhmrk$ettvs|mqexip}$5440444$mrhmzmhyepw$xlvsykl$er$evve}$sj$xiglrspsk}$tvshygxw$mrgpyhmrk$vehms$jviuyirg}0$KTW0$erh

epgslsp$qsrmxsvmrk$hizmgiw2

KIS0${lmgl$lew$fiir$mr$stivexmsr$wmrgi$5=<80$fiker$stivexmrk$ew$e$VIMX$jsv$jihivep$mrgsqi$xe|$tyvtswiw$ijjigxmzi$Neryev}$50

64572$Ew$e$viwypx$sj$xli$VIMX$gsrzivwmsr0$KIS$visvkerm~ih$mxw$stivexmsrw$erh$qszih$rsr1viep$iwxexi$gsqtsrirxw$mrxs$xe|efpi$VIMX

wyfwmhmevmiw$,ÔXVWwÕ-2$Xlvsykl$xli$XVW$wxvygxyvi0$xli$tsvxmsr$sj$KIS+w$fywmriwwiw${lmgl$evi$rsr1viep$iwxexi$vipexih0$wygl$ew$mxw

qerekih1srp}$gsrxvegxw0$mrxivrexmsrep$stivexmsrw0$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$wivzmgiw0$erh$sxliv$rsr1viwmhirxmep$erh$gsqqyrmx}$fewih

jegmpmxmiw0$evi$tevx$sj${lspp}1s{rih$xe|efpi$wyfwmhmevmiw$sj$xli$VIMX2$Qswx$sj$KIS+w$fywmriww$yrmxw0${lmgl$evi$viep$iwxexi$vipexih$erh

mrzspzi$gsqter}1s{rih$erh$gsqter}1piewih$jegmpmxmiw0$evi$tevx$sj$xli$VIMX2$Xli$XVW$wxvygxyvi$epps{w$xli$Gsqter}$xs$qemrxemr$xli

wxvexikmg$epmkrqirx$sj$epp$sj$mxw$hmzivwmjmih$fywmriww$wikqirxw$yrhiv$sri$irxmx}2$Xli$XVW$ewwixw$erh$stivexmsrw${mpp$gsrxmryi$xs$fi

wyfnigx$xs$jihivep$erh$wxexi$gsvtsvexi$mrgsqi$xe|iw$erh$xs$jsvimkr$xe|iw$ew$ettpmgefpi$mr$xli$nyvmwhmgxmsrw$mr${lmgl$xlswi$ewwixw$erh

stivexmsrw$evi$psgexih2

Xli$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$lezi$fiir$tvitevih$mr$gsrjsvqmx}${mxl$eggsyrxmrk$tvmrgmtpiw$kirivepp}$eggitxih$mr$xli

Yrmxih$Wxexiw$sj$Eqivmge2$Xli$wmkrmjmgerx$eggsyrxmrk$tspmgmiw$sj$xli$Gsqter}$evi$hiwgvmfih$fips{2

Gsrwspmhexmsr

Xli$eggsqter}mrk$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$ wxexiqirxw$ mrgpyhi$ xli$eggsyrxw$sj$ xli$Gsqter}$erh$ mxw${lspp}1s{rih$wyfwmhmevmiw2

Xli$iuymx}$qixlsh$sj$eggsyrxmrk$mw$ywih$jsv$mrziwxqirxw$mr$rsr1gsrxvsppih$ejjmpmexiw$mr${lmgl$xli$Gsqter}×w$s{rivwlmt$verkiw$jvsq

64$xs$94$tivgirx0$sv$mr$mrwxergiw$mr${lmgl$xli$Gsqter}$mw$efpi$xs$i|ivgmwi$wmkrmjmgerx$mrjpyirgi$fyx$rsx$gsrxvsp2$Xli$Gsqter}$vitsvxw

Wsyxl$Ejvmge$Gywxshmep$ Wivzmgiw$ ,&WEGW&-$ erh$ mxw$ 94)$ s{rih$ nsmrx$ zirxyvi$ mr$ xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq0$KISEqi}0$ yrhiv$ xli$ iuymx}

qixlsh$sj$eggsyrxmrk2$Rsrgsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw$mr$gsrwspmhexih$irxmxmiw$vitviwirx$iuymx}$xlex$sxliv$mrziwxsvw$lezi$gsrxvmfyxih$xs$Wsyxl

Ejvmge$ Gywxshmep$ Qerekiqirx$ ,&WEGQ&-2$ Rsr1gsrxvsppmrk$ mrxiviwxw$ evi$ ehnywxih$ jsv$ mrgsqi$ erh$ pswwiw$ eppsgefpi$ xs$ xli$ sxliv

wlevilsphivw$mr$xliwi$irxmxmiw2$Epp$wmkrmjmgerx$mrxivgsqter}$fepergiw$erh$xverwegxmsrw$lezi$fiir$ipmqmrexih2

Vigpewwmjmgexmsrw

Givxemr$eqsyrxw$mr$xli$tvmsv$tivmsh$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$lezi$fiir$vigpewwmjmih$xs$gsrjsvq$xs$xli$tviwirxexmsr$sj$xli$gyvvirx$tivmsh

jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw2$Xliwi$vigpewwmjmgexmsrw$leh$rs$ijjigx$sr$xli$tvizmsywp}$vitsvxih$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2

Ywi$sj$Iwxmqexiw

Xli$ tvitevexmsr$ sj$ jmrergmep$ wxexiqirxw$ mr$ gsrjsvqmx}$ {mxl$ eggsyrxmrk$ tvmrgmtpiw$ kirivepp}$ eggitxih$ mr$ xli$ Yrmxih$ Wxexiw$ sj

Eqivmge$ viuymviw$qerekiqirx$ xs$qeoi$givxemr$iwxmqexiw0$ nyhkqirxw$erh$ewwyqtxmsrw$ xlex$ejjigx$ xli$ vitsvxih$eqsyrxw$sj$ewwixw$erh

pmefmpmxmiw$erh$hmwgpswyvi$sj$gsrxmrkirx$ewwixw$erh$pmefmpmxmiw$ex$xli$hexi$sj$xli$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$erh$xli$vitsvxih$eqsyrxw$sj$viziryiw

erh$i|tirwiw$hyvmrk$ xli$ vitsvxmrk$tivmsh2$Xli$Gsqter}×w$ wmkrmjmgerx$iwxmqexiw$ mrgpyhi$ viwivziw$ jsv$ wipj1mrwyvih$ vixirxmsr$ vipexih$ xs

kirivep$pmefmpmx}$mrwyvergi0${svoivw×$gsqtirwexmsr$mrwyvergi0$eyxs$pmefmpmx}$mrwyvergi0$qihmgep$qeptvegxmgi$mrwyvergi0$iqtps}iv$kvsyt

liepxl$mrwyvergi0$tvsnigxih$yrhmwgsyrxih$gewl$jps{w$ywih$xs$izepyexi$ewwix$mqtemvqirx0$iwxmqexih$jemv

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 123 of 253

Page 146: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 567367<

<7

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 124 of 253

Page 147: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 568367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

zepyiw$ sj$ fywmriww$ eguymwmxmsrw0$ tirwmsr$ ewwyqtxmsrw0$ tivgirxeki$ sj$ gsqtpixmsr$ erh$ iwxmqexih$ gswx$ xs$ gsqtpixi$ jsv$ gsrwxvygxmsr

tvsnigxw0$ vigszivefmpmx}$ sj$ rsxiw$ vigimzefpi0$ iwxmqexih$ ywijyp$ pmziw$ sj$ tvstivx}$ erh$ iuymtqirx$ erh$ mrxerkmfpi$ ewwixw0$ wxsgo$ fewih

gsqtirwexmsr$ erh$ epps{ergi$ jsv$ hsyfxjyp$ eggsyrxw2$ Xliwi$ iwxmqexiw$ erh$ ewwyqtxmsrw$ ejjigx$ xli$ vitsvxih$ eqsyrxw$ sj$ ewwixw$ erh

pmefmpmxmiw$ex$xli$hexi$sj$xli$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$erh$xli$vitsvxih$eqsyrxw$sj$viziryiw$erh$i|tirwiw$hyvmrk$xli$vitsvxmrk$tivmsh2$[lmpi

xli$Gsqter}$fipmiziw$ xlex$wygl$iwxmqexiw$evi$ viewsrefpi${lir$gsrwmhivih$ mr$gsrnyrgxmsr${mxl$ xli$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw

xeoir$ ew$ e${lspi0$ xli$ egxyep$ eqsyrxw$ sj$ wygl$iwxmqexiw0${lir$ors{r0${mpp$ zev}$ jvsq$ xliwi$ iwxmqexiw2$ Mj$ egxyep$ viwypxw$ wmkrmjmgerxp}

hmjjiv$jvsq$xli$Gsqter}×w$iwxmqexiw0$xli$Gsqter}×w$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$gsyph$fi$qexivmepp}$mqtegxih2

Hmzmhirhw

Ew$e$VIMX0$xli$Gsqter}$mw$viuymvih$xs$hmwxvmfyxi$erryepp}$ex$piewx$=4)$sj$mxw$VIMX$xe|efpi$mrgsqi$,hixivqmrih${mxlsyx$vikevh$xs

xli$hmzmhirhw$temh$hihygxmsr$erh$f}$i|gpyhmrk$rix$getmxep$kemr-2$Xli$eqsyrx0$ xmqmrk$erh$jviuyirg}$sj$jyxyvi$hmwxvmfyxmsrw0$ls{iziv0

{mpp$fi$ex$xli$wspi$hmwgvixmsr$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$Fsevh$sj$Hmvigxsvw$erh${mpp$fi$higpevih$fewih$ytsr$zevmsyw$jegxsvw0$qer}$sj${lmgl$evi

fi}srh$xli$Gsqter}+w$gsrxvsp0$mrgpyhmrk0$xli$Gsqter}+w$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$stivexmrk$gewl$jps{w0$xli$eqsyrx$viuymvih$xs$qemrxemr

VIMX$wxexyw$erh$vihygi$er}$mrgsqi$erh$i|gmwi$xe|iw$xlex$xli$Gsqter}$sxliv{mwi${syph$fi$viuymvih$xs$te}0$pmqmxexmsrw$sr$hmwxvmfyxmsrw

mr$xli$Gsqter}+w$i|mwxmrk$erh$jyxyvi$hifx$mrwxvyqirxw0$pmqmxexmsrw$sr$xli$Gsqter}+w$efmpmx}$xs$jyrh$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$ywmrk$gewl$kirivexih

xlvsykl$syv$XVWw$erh$sxliv$ jegxsvw$ xlex$xli$Gsqter}+w$Fsevh$sj$Hmvigxsvw$qe}$hiiq$vipizerx2$Xli$Gsqter}$fiker$te}mrk$vikypev

VIMX$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$mr$64572$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$71$Wlevilsphivw×$Iuymx}2

E$VIMX$mw$rsx$tivqmxxih$xs$vixemr$ievrmrkw$erh$tvsjmxw$eggyqypexih$hyvmrk$xli$}ievw$mx${ew$xe|ih$ew$e$G$gsvtsvexmsr$sv$ievrmrkw

erh$ tvsjmxw$ eggyqypexih$ f}$ mxw$ wyfwmhmevmiw$ xlex$ lezi$ fiir$ gsrzivxih$ xs$ uyepmjmih$ VIMX$ wyfwmhmevmiw0$ erh$ qywx$ qeoi$ sri$ sv$ qsvi

hmwxvmfyxmsrw$xs$wlevilsphivw$xlex$iuyep$sv$i|giih$xliwi$eggyqypexih$eqsyrxw$f}$xli$irh$sj$xli$jmvwx$VIMX$}iev2$Ievrmrkw$erh$tvsjmxw0

{lmgl$hixivqmri$xli$ xe|efmpmx}$sj$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$xs$wlevilsphivw0${mpp$hmjjiv$jvsq$rix$ mrgsqi$vitsvxih$jsv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$tyvtswiw

hyi$xs$xli$hmjjivirgiw$mr$xli$xviexqirx$sj$kemrw$erh$pswwiw0$viziryi$erh$i|tirwiw0$erh$hitvigmexmsr$jsv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$vipexmzi$xs

jihivep$mrgsqi$xe|$tyvtswiw2

Gewl$erh$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw

Gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw$ mrgpyhi$epp$ mrxiviwx1fievmrk$hitswmxw$sv$ mrziwxqirxw${mxl$svmkmrep$qexyvmxmiw$sj$ xlvii$qsrxlw$sv$ piww

{lir$tyvglewih2$Xli$Gsqter}$qemrxemrw$gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw${mxl$zevmsyw$jmrergmep$mrwxmxyxmsrw2$Xliwi$jmrergmep$mrwxmxyxmsrw$evi

psgexih$ xlvsyklsyx$ xli$ Yrmxih$ Wxexiw0$ Eywxvepme0$ Wsyxl$ Ejvmge$ erh$ xli$ Yrmxih$ Omrkhsq2$ Ew$ sj$ Higiqfiv$ 750$ 645=$ erh$ 645<0$ xli

Gsqter}$leh$(642:$qmppmsr$erh$(5<2=$qmppmsr$mr$gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw$liph$f}$mxw$mrxivrexmsrep$wyfwmhmevmiw0$viwtigxmzip}2

Gsrgirxvexmsr$sj$Gvihmx$Vmwo

Xli$Gsqter}$qemrxemrw$hitswmxw$sj$gewl$mr$i|giww$sj$jihivepp}$mrwyvih$pmqmxw${mxl$givxemr$jmrergmep$mrwxmxyxmsrw$erh$eggsvhmrkp}

xli$Gsqter}$mw$wyfnigx$xs$gvihmx$vmwo2$Sxliv$xler$gewl0$jmrergmep$mrwxvyqirxw$xlex$tsxirxmepp}$wyfnigx$xli$Gsqter}$xs$gsrgirxvexmsrw$sj

gvihmx$ vmwo$ gsrwmwx$ tvmrgmtepp}$ sj$ xvehi$ eggsyrxw$ vigimzefpi0$ gsrxvegx$ vigimzefpi0$ psrk1xivq$ hifx$ erh$ jmrergmep$ mrwxvyqirxw$ ywih$ mr

lihkmrk$egxmzmxmiw2$Xli$Gsqter}×w$gewl$qerekiqirx$erh$mrziwxqirx$tspmgmiw$viwxvmgx$mrziwxqirxw$xs$ps{1vmwo0$lmklp}$pmuymh$wigyvmxmiw0

erh$xli$Gsqter}$tivjsvqw$tivmshmg$izepyexmsrw$sj$xli$gvihmx$wxerhmrk$sj$xli$jmrergmep$mrwxmxyxmsrw${mxl${lmgl$mx$hiepw2

Eggsyrxw$Vigimzefpi

Eggsyrxw$vigimzefpi$gsrwmwxw$tvmqevmp}$sj$xvehi$eggsyrxw$vigimzefpi$hyi$jvsq$jihivep0$wxexi0$ psgep$erh$mrxivrexmsrep$kszivrqirx

ekirgmiw$jsv$stivexmrk$erh$qerekmrk$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw0$tvszmhmrk$}syxl$erh$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$wivzmgiw0$tvszmhmrk$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk

erh$ wytivzmwmsr$ wivzmgiw0$ tvszmhmrk$ gsrwxvygxmsr$ erh$ hiwmkr$ wivzmgiw$ erh$ tvszmhmrk$ viwmhirxmep$ erh$ xverwtsvxexmsr$ wivzmgiw2$ Xli

Gsqter}$kirivexiw$ vigimzefpiw${mxl$ mxw$kszivrqirxep$ gpmirxw$ erh${mxl$sxliv$ tevxmiw$ mr$ xli$rsvqep$ gsyvwi$sj$ fywmriww$ew$e$ viwypx$sj

fmppmrk$erh$vigimzmrk$te}qirx2$Xli$Gsqter}$vikypevp}$vizmi{w$syxwxerhmrk$vigimzefpiw0$erh$tvszmhiw$jsv$iwxmqexih$pswwiw$xlvsykl$er

epps{ergi$ jsv$ hsyfxjyp$ eggsyrxw2$ Mr$ izepyexmrk$ xli$ pizip$ sj$ iwxefpmwlih$ psww$ viwivziw0$ xli$Gsqter}$qeoiw$ nyhkqirxw$ vikevhmrk$ mxw

gywxsqivw×$efmpmx}$xs$qeoi$viuymvih$te}qirxw0$igsrsqmg$izirxw$erh$sxliv$jegxsvw2$Ew$xli$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$sj$xliwi$tevxmiw$glerki0

gmvgyqwxergiw$ hizipst$ sv$ ehhmxmsrep$ mrjsvqexmsr$ figsqiw$ ezempefpi0$ ehnywxqirxw$ xs$ xli$ epps{ergi$ jsv$ hsyfxjyp$ eggsyrxw$ qe}$ fi

viuymvih2$Xli$Gsqter}$epws$tivjsvqw$srksmrk$gvihmx$izepyexmsrw$jsv$wsqi$sj$mxw$gywxsqivw×$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsrw$erh$kirivepp}$hsiw$rsx

viuymvi$gsppexivep2$Kirivepp}0$xli$Gsqter}$vigimziw$te}qirx$jsv$xliwi$wivzmgiw$xlmvx}$xs$wm|x}$he}w$mr$evvievw2$Ls{iziv0$givxemr$sj$xli

Gsqter}×w$eggsyrxw$vigimzefpi$evi$temh$f}$gywxsqivw$ejxiv$xli$gsqtpixmsr$sj$xlimv$tvskveq$}iev$erh$xlivijsvi$ger$fi$ekih$mr$i|giww$sj

sri$}iev2$Xli$Gsqter}$qemrxemrw$viwivziw$jsv$tsxirxmep$gvihmx$pswwiw0$erh$wygl$pswwiw$xvehmxmsrepp}$lezi$fiir${mxlmr$mxw$i|tigxexmsrw2

Egxyep${vmxi1sjjw$ evi$ glevkih$ekemrwx$ xli$ epps{ergi${lir$gsppigxmsr$ijjsvxw$ lezi$fiir$yrwyggiwwjyp2$Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=$ erh

645<0$(428$qmppmsr$erh$(627$qmppmsr0$viwtigxmzip}0$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$xvehi

<8

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 125 of 253

Page 148: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 569367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

vigimzefpiw${ivi$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$psrk1xivq$erh$evi$gpewwmjmih$ew$Sxliv$Rsr1Gyvvirx$Ewwixw$mr$xli$eggsqter}mrk$Gsrwspmhexih$Fepergi

Wliixw2

Rsxi$Vigimzefpi$jvsq$Nsmrx$Zirxyvi

Mr$Qe}$64550$ xli$KIS$Kvsyt$YO$Pmqmxih0$ xli$Gsqter}×w$ wyfwmhmev}$ mr$ xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq$,ÔKIS$YOÕ-0$ i|xirhih$e$rsr1

vizspzmrk$pmri$sj$gvihmx$jegmpmx}$xs$KISEqi}$jsv$xli$tyvtswi$sj$jyrhmrk$qsfmpm~exmsr$gswxw$erh$sr1ksmrk$wxevx$yt$erh$stivexmsrw$mr$xli

tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj$¦56$qmppmsr2$Eqsyrxw$yrhiv$xli$pmri$sj$gvihmx${ivi$hve{r$hs{r$mr$qypxmtpi$ehzergiw$yt$xs$xli$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx

erh$ eggvyih$ mrxiviwx$ ex$ xli$ fewi$ vexi$ sj$ xli$Fero$ sj$Irkperh$ tpyw$ 429)${mxl$ xli$ tvmrgmtep$ eqsyrx$ hyi$ sr$ hiqerh2$ Xli$ Gsqter}

vigskrm~ih$mrxiviwx$mrgsqi$sr$mxw$rsxiw$vigimzefpi$ew$mx$mw$ievrih2$Mr$Sgxsfiv$645<0$xli$rsxi$vigimzefpi$xs$iegl$nsmrx$zirxyvi${ew$temh

sjj$mr$jypp2

Gsrxvegx$Vigimzefpi

Xli$Gsqter}+w$Eywxvepmer$wyfwmhmev}$lew$vigsvhih$e$gsrxvegx$vigimzefpi$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$gsrwxvygxmsr$sj$e$507441fih

hixirxmsr$jegmpmx}$mr$Vezirlepp0$Eywxvepme$jsv$xli$Wxexi$sj$Zmgxsvme2$Xli$gsrxvegx$vigimzefpi$vitviwirxw$gswxw$mrgyvvih$erh$iwxmqexih

ievrmrkw$mr$i|giww$sj$fmppmrkw$erh$mw$vigsvhih$ex$rix$tviwirx$zepyi$fewih$sr$xli$xmqmrk$sj$i|tigxih$jyxyvi$wixxpiqirx2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$;$1

Gsrxvegx$Vigimzefpi$jsv$jyvxliv$mrjsvqexmsr2

Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw

Xli$jspps{mrk$xefpi$tvszmhiw$e$vigsrgmpmexmsr$sj$gewl0$gewl$iuymzepirxw$erh$viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw$vitsvxih$sr$xli

gsrwspmhexih$fepergi$wliixw$xlex$wyq$xs$xli$xsxep$sj$xli$weqi$wygl$eqsyrxw$wls{r$mr$xli$gsrwspmhexih$wxexiqirxw$sj$gewl$jps{w>

$ Higiqfiv$750$645= $ Higiqfiv$750$645< $ Higiqfiv$750$645;

Gewl$erh$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw ( 7608:7 $ ( 750699 $ ( <507;;

Viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$gewl

iuymzepirxw$1$gyvvirx 76085< $ 950:;< $ 880=76

Viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh

mrziwxqirxw$1$rsr1gyvvirx 740=67 $ 660875 $ 6;0===

Piww$Viwxvmgxih$mrziwxqirxw

1$rsr1gyvvirx ,6<0776- $ ,640<=6- $ ,640;:7-

Xsxep$gewl0$gewl$iuymzepirxw

erh$viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$gewl

iuymzepirxw$wls{r$mr$xli

wxexiqirx$sj$gewl$jps{w ( :;08;6 $ ( <808;6 $ ( 5770989

Eqsyrxw$mrgpyhih$mr$viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw$evi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$givxemr$gsrxvegxyep$gewl$viwxvmgxmsr$viuymviqirxw$ex$xli

Gsqter}+w${lspp}$s{rih$Eywxvepmer$wyfwmhmev}$vipexih$xs$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx$erh$ewwix$vitpegiqirx$jyrhw$gsrxvegxyepp}$viuymvih$xs$fi

qemrxemrih$erh$sxliv$kyeverxiiw2$Viwxvmgxih$mrziwxqirxw$1$rsr1gyvvirx$,mrgpyhih$mr$Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Mrziwxqirxw$mr$xli

eggsqter}mrk$gsrwspmhexih$fepergi$wliixw-$gsrwmwxw$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$veffm$xvywx$iwxefpmwlih$jsv$iqtps}ii$erh$iqtps}iv$gsrxvmfyxmsrw

xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2$Rsr1uyepmjmih$Hijivvih$Gsqtirwexmsr$Tper$erh$mw$rsx$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$e$viwxvmgxih$gewl$iuymzepirx2$Vijiv$xs

Rsxi$54$1$Jmrergmep$Mrwxvyqirxw2

$

Tvitemh$i|tirwiw$erh$Sxliv$Gyvvirx$Ewwixw

$$$$Tvitemh$i|tirwiw$erh$sxliv$gyvvirx$ewwixw$mrgpyhi$ewwixw$xlex$evi$i|tigxih$xs$fi$viepm~ih${mxlmr$xli$ri|x$jmwgep$}iev2$Mrgpyhih$mr

xli$ fepergi$ ex$ Higiqfiv$ 750$ 645=$ mw$ ettvs|mqexip}$ (727$qmppmsr$ sj$ jihivep0$ wxexi$ erh$ mrxivrexmsrep$ xe|$ szivte}qirxw$ xlex$ {mpp$ fi

ettpmih$ekemrwx$iwxmqexih$xe|$te}qirxw$hyi$mr$64642$Mrgpyhih$mr$xli$fepergi$ex$Higiqfiv$750$645<$mw$ettvs|mqexip}$(:25$qmppmsr$sj

jihivep0$wxexi$erh$mrxivrexmsrep$xe|$szivte}qirxw$xlex${ivi$ettpmih$ekemrwx$xe|$te}qirxw$mr$645=2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 126 of 253

Page 149: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 56:367<

<9

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 127 of 253

Page 150: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 56;367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Tvstivx}$erh$Iuymtqirx

Tvstivx}$erh$iuymtqirx$evi$wxexih$ex$gswx0$piww$eggyqypexih$eqsvxm~exmsr$erh$hitvigmexmsr2$Hitvigmexmsr$mw$gsqtyxih$ywmrk$xli

wxvemklx1pmri$ qixlsh$ sziv$ xli$ iwxmqexih$ ywijyp$ pmziw$ sj$ xli$ vipexih$ ewwixw2$ Fymphmrkw$ erh$ mqtvsziqirxw$ evi$ hitvigmexih$ sziv$ 6$ xs

94$}ievw2$Iuymtqirx$erh$jyvrmxyvi$erh$jm|xyviw$evi$hitvigmexih$sziv$7$xs$54$}ievw2$Piewilsph$mqtvsziqirxw$evi$eqsvxm~ih$sr$e$wxvemklx1

pmri$fewmw$sziv$xli$wlsvxiv$sj$xli$ywijyp$pmji$sj$xli$mqtvsziqirx$sv$xli$xivq$sj$xli$piewi2$Xli$Gsqter}$tivjsvqw$srksmrk$izepyexmsrw$sj

xli$ iwxmqexih$ ywijyp$ pmziw$ sj$ xli$ tvstivx}$ erh$ iuymtqirx$ jsv$ hitvigmexmsr$ tyvtswiw2$ Xli$ iwxmqexih$ ywijyp$ pmziw$ evi$ hixivqmrih$ erh

gsrxmryepp}$izepyexih$fewih$sr$xli$tivmsh$sziv${lmgl$wivzmgiw$evi$i|tigxih$xs$fi$virhivih$f}$xli$ewwix2$Mj$xli$ewwiwwqirx$mrhmgexiw$xlex

ewwixw${mpp$fi$ywih$jsv$e$psrkiv$sv$wlsvxiv$tivmsh$xler$tvizmsywp}$erxmgmtexih0$ xli$ywijyp$ pmziw$sj$xli$ewwixw$evi$vizmwih0$viwypxmrk$mr$e

glerki$mr$iwxmqexi2$Xli$Gsqter}$lew$rsx$qehi$er}$wygl$glerkiw$mr$iwxmqexiw$hyvmrk$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$645<$erh

645;2$Qemrxirergi$erh$vitemvw$evi$i|tirwih$ew$mrgyvvih2$Mrxiviwx$mw$getmxepm~ih$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$gsrwxvygxmsr$sj$gsqter}1s{rih

wigyvi$ jegmpmxmiw2$Gswx$ jsv$ wipj1gsrwxvygxih$ wigyvi$ jegmpmxmiw$ mrgpyhiw$ hmvigx$qexivmepw$ erh$ pefsv0$ getmxepm~ih$ mrxiviwx$ erh$ givxemr$ sxliv

mrhmvigx$gswxw$ewwsgmexih${mxl$gsrwxvygxmsr$sj$xli$jegmpmx}0$wygl$ew$tvstivx}$xe|iw0$sxliv$mrhmvigx$pefsv$erh$vipexih$firijmxw$erh$te}vspp

xe|iw2$Xli$Gsqter}$fikmrw$xli$getmxepm~exmsr$sj$gswxw$hyvmrk$xli$tvi1gsrwxvygxmsr$tlewi0${lmgl$mw$ xli$tivmsh$hyvmrk${lmgl$gswxw$evi

mrgyvvih$xs$izepyexi$xli$wmxi0$erh$gsrxmryiw$yrxmp$xli$jegmpmx}$mw$wyfwxerxmepp}$gsqtpixi$erh$vieh}$jsv$sggyterg}2$Pefsv$gswxw$getmxepm~ih

jsv$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$645<$erh$645;${ivi$rsx$ wmkrmjmgerx2$Getmxepm~ih$ mrxiviwx$ mw$ vigsvhih$ew$ tevx$sj$ xli$ewwix$ xs

{lmgl$mx$vipexiw$erh$mw$eqsvxm~ih$sziv$xli$ewwix×w$iwxmqexih$ywijyp$pmji2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$:$1$Tvstivx}$erh$Iuymtqirx2

Ewwixw$Liph$jsv$Wepi

Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$leh$jsyv$tvstivxmiw$gpewwmjmih$ew$liph$jsv$wepi$mrgpyhih$mr$mx+w$KIS$Gevi$wikqirx$mr$xli

eggsqter}mrk$gsrwspmhexih$fepergi$wliix2$Xli$Gsqter}$gpewwmjmiw$e$psrk1pmzih$ewwix$,hmwtswep$kvsyt-$ew$liph$jsv$wepi$mr$xli$tivmsh$mr

{lmgl$epp$sj$xli$jspps{mrk$gvmxivme$evi$qix$,m-$Qerekiqirx0$lezmrk$xli$eyxlsvmx}$xs$ettvszi$xli$egxmsr0$gsqqmxw$xs$e$tper$xs$wipp$xli

ewwix$,hmwtswep$kvsyt-0$,mm-$xli$ewwix$,hmwtswep$kvsyt-$mw$ezempefpi$jsv$mqqihmexi$wepi$mr$mxw$tviwirx$gsrhmxmsr$wyfnigx$srp}$xs$xli$xivqw

xlex$evi$ywyep$erh$gywxsqev}$jsv$wepiw$sj$wygl$ewwixw$,hmwtswep$kvsytw-0$,mmm-$er$egxmzi$tvskveq$xs$psgexi$e$fy}iv$erh$sxliv$egxmsrw

viuymvih$xs$gsqtpixi$xli$tper$xs$wipp$xli$ewwix$,hmwtswep$kvsyt-$lezi$fiir$mrmxmexih0$,mz-$xli$wepi$sj$xli$ewwix$,hmwtswep$kvsyt-$mw$tvsfefpi0

erh$xverwjiv$sj$xli$ewwix$,hmwtswep$kvsyt-$mw$i|tigxih$xs$uyepmj}$jsv$vigskrmxmsr$ew$e$gsqtpixih$wepi0${mxlmr$sri$}iev0$i|gitx$ew

tivqmxxih0$,z-$xli$ewwix$,hmwtswep$kvsyt-$mw$fimrk$egxmzip}$qevoixih$jsv$wepi$ex$e$tvmgi$xlex$mw$viewsrefpi$mr$vipexmsr$xs$mxw$gyvvirx$jemv

zepyi0$erh$,zm-$egxmsrw$viuymvih$xs$gsqtpixi$xli$tper$mrhmgexi$xlex$mx$mw$yrpmoip}$xlex$wmkrmjmgerx$glerkiw$xs$xli$tper${mpp$fi$qehi$sv$xlex

xli$tper${mpp$fi${mxlhve{r2$Xli$Gsqter}$vigsvhw$ewwixw$liph$jsv$wepi$ex$xli$ps{iv$sj$gswx$sv$iwxmqexih$jemv$zepyi$erh$iwxmqexiw$jemv

zepyi$f}$ywmrk$xlmvh$tevx}$ettvemwivw$sv$sxliv$zepyexmsr$xiglrmuyiw2$Xli$Gsqter}$hsiw$rsx$vigsvh$hitvigmexmsr$jsv$ewwixw$liph$jsv$wepi2

Er}$kemr$sv$psww$sr$xli$wepi$sj$stivexmrk$ewwixw$mw$mrgpyhih$mr$xli$stivexmrk$mrgsqi$sj$xli$vitsvxefpi$wikqirx$xs${lmgl$mx$vipexiw2

Xli$tvstivxmiw$xlex$evi$gpewwmjmih$ew$liph$jsv$wepi$ex$Higiqfiv$750$645=$evi$e$tevgip$sj$yrhizipstih$perh$mr$Lsfevx0$Mrhmere0

x{s$mhpi$viirxv}$jegmpmxmiw$eguymvih$jvsq$Gsqqyrmx}$Ihygexmsr$Girxivw$,&GIG&-$erh$sri$mhpi$}syxl$jegmpmx}2$Ex$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$xli

ekkvikexi$gevv}mrk$zepyiw$sj$xliwi$tvstivxmiw${ew$ettvs|mqexip}$(:25$qmppmsr2$Ex$Higiqfiv$750$645<0$xli$Gsqter}$leh$x{s$tvstivxmiw

xlex${ivi$gpewwmjmih$ew$liph$jsv$wepi${lmgl$gsrwmwxih$sj$e$tevgip$sj$yrhizipstih$perh$mr$Lsfevx0$Mrhmere$erh$er$mhpi$viirxv}$jegmpmx}

eguymvih$jvsq$GIG2$Ex$Higiqfiv$750$645<0$xli$ekkvikexi$gevv}mrk$zepyi$sj$xli$tvstivxmiw${ew$ettvs|mqexip}$(62:$qmppmsr2

Ewwix$Mqtemvqirxw

Xli$Gsqter}$leh$tvstivx}$erh$iuymtqirx0$rix$sj$(625$fmppmsr$erh$(626$fmppmsr$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$645<0$viwtigxmzip}0

mrgpyhmrk$ettvs|mqexip}$;44$zegerx$fihw${mxl$e$rix$fsso$zepyi$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(56$qmppmsr$ex$Higiqfiv$750$645=$ex$sri$sj$mxw$mhpi

jegmpmxmiw$ mr$ xli$ Wigyvi$ Wivzmgiw$ wikqirx$ xlex$ mx$ mw$ gyvvirxp}$qevoixmrk$ xs$ tsxirxmep$ gywxsqivw2$Epws0$ mr$ mxw$KIS$Gevi$ wikqirx0$ xli

Gsqter}$mw$gyvvirxp}$qevoixmrk$ettvs|mqexip}$844$zegerx$fihw${mxl$e$rix$fsso$zepyi$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(=24$qmppmsr$ex$Higiqfiv$750

645=$ex$sri$sj$mxw$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw$xs$tsxirxmep$gywxsqivw2

Xli$Gsqter}$vizmi{w$psrk1pmzih$ewwixw$xs$fi$liph$erh$ywih$jsv$mqtemvqirx${liriziv$izirxw$sv$glerkiw$mr$gmvgyqwxergiw$mrhmgexi$xlex

xli$ gevv}mrk$ eqsyrx$ sj$ wygl$ ewwixw$ qe}$ rsx$ fi$ jypp}$ vigszivefpi2$ Izirxw$ xlex$ {syph$ xvmkkiv$ er$ mqtemvqirx$ ewwiwwqirx$ mrgpyhi

hixivmsvexmsr$sj$tvsjmxw$jsv$e$fywmriww$wikqirx$xlex$lew$psrk1pmzih$ewwixw0$sv${lir$sxliv$glerkiw$sggyv$xlex$qmklx$mqtemv$vigsziv}$sj

psrk1pmzih$ewwixw$wygl$ew$xli$xivqmrexmsr$sj$e$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegx$sv$e$tvspsrkih$higviewi$mr$tstypexmsr2$Mj$mqtemvqirx$mrhmgexsvw$evi

tviwirx0$xli$Gsqter}$tivjsvqw$e$vigszivefmpmx}$xiwx$xs$hixivqmri${lixliv$sv$rsx$er$mqtemvqirx$psww$wlsyph$fi$qiewyvih2

Xli$Gsqter}$xiwxw$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw$jsv$mqtemvqirx$ytsr$rsxmjmgexmsr$xlex$xli$jegmpmxmiw${mpp$rs$psrkiv$fi$yxmpm~ih$f}$xli$gywxsqiv2$Mj

e$psrk1pmzih$ewwix$mw$tevx$sj$e$kvsyt$xlex$mrgpyhiw$sxliv$ewwixw0$xli$yrmx$sj$eggsyrxmrk$jsv$xli$psrk1pmzih$ewwix$mw$mxw$kvsyt2$Kirivepp}0$xli

Gsqter}$kvsytw$ewwixw$f}$jegmpmx}$jsv$xli$tyvtswi$sj$gsrwmhivmrk${lixliv$er}$mqtemvqirx$i|mwxw2$Xli$iwxmqexiw$sj$vigszivefmpmx}

<:

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 128 of 253

Page 151: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 56<367<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 129 of 253

Page 152: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 56=367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

evi$ fewih$ sr$ tvsnigxih$ yrhmwgsyrxih$ gewl$ jps{w$ ewwsgmexih$ {mxl$ egxyep$ qevoixmrk$ ijjsvxw$ {livi$ ezempefpi$ sv0$ mr$ sxliv$ mrwxergiw0

tvsnigxih$yrhmwgsyrxih$gewl$ jps{w$ xlex$ evi$ gsqtevefpi$ xs$ lmwxsvmgep$ gewl$ jps{w$ jvsq$qerekiqirx$ gsrxvegxw$ ex$ wmqmpev$ jegmpmxmiw$ erh

wirwmxmzmx}$erep}wiw$xlex$gsrwmhiv$vihygxmsrw$xs$wygl$gewl$jps{w2$Xli$Gsqter}+w$wirwmxmzmx}$erep}wiw$mrgpyhi$ehnywxqirxw$xs$tvsnigxih

gewl$jps{w$gsqtevih$xs$xli$lmwxsvmgep$gewl$jps{w$hyi$xs$gyvvirx$fywmriww$gsrhmxmsrw${lmgl$mqtegx$tiv$hmiq$vexiw$ew${ipp$ew$pefsv$erh

sxliv$stivexmrk$gswxw0$glerkiw$vipexih$xs$jegmpmx}$qmwwmsr$hyi$xs$glerkiw$mr$tvswtigxmzi$gpmirxw0$erh$glerkiw$mr$tvsnigxih$getegmx}$erh

sggyterg}$vexiw2$Xli$Gsqter}$epws$jegxsvw$mr$tvspsrkih$tivmshw$sj$zegergmiw$ew${ipp$ew$xli$xmqi$erh$gswxw$viuymvih$xs$veqt$yt$jegmpmx}

tstypexmsr$srgi$e$gsrxvegx$mw$sfxemrih2$Xli$Gsqter}$tivjsvqw$xli$mqtemvqirx$erep}wmw$sr$er$erryep$fewmw$jsv$iegl$sj$xli$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw

erh$xeoiw$mrxs$gsrwmhivexmsr$ythexiw$iegl$uyevxiv$jsv$qevoix$hizipstqirxw$ejjigxmrk$xli$tsxirxmep$yxmpm~exmsr$sj$iegl$sj$xli$jegmpmxmiw$mr

svhiv$xs$mhirxmj}$izirxw$xlex$qe}$geywi$xli$Gsqter}$xs$vigsrwmhiv$xli$qswx$vigirx$ewwyqtxmsrw2$Wygl$izirxw$gsyph$mrgpyhi$riksxmexmsrw

{mxl$ e$ tvswtigxmzi$ gywxsqiv$ jsv$ xli$ yxmpm~exmsr$ sj$ er$ mhpi$ jegmpmx}$ ex$ xivqw$ wmkrmjmgerxp}$ piww$ jezsvefpi$ xler$ xli$ xivqw$ ywih$ mr$ xli

Gsqter}+w$qswx$vigirx$mqtemvqirx$erep}wmw0$sv$glerkiw$mr$pikmwpexmsr$wyvvsyrhmrk$e$tevxmgypev$jegmpmx}$xlex$gsyph$mqtegx$xli$Gsqter}+w

efmpmx}$ xs$lsywi$ givxemr$ x}tiw$sj$ mrhmzmhyepw$ex$ wygl$ jegmpmx}2$Jyvxliv0$ e$ wyfwxerxmep$ mrgviewi$ mr$ xli$ryqfiv$sj$ ezempefpi$fihw$ex$sxliv

jegmpmxmiw$ xli$ Gsqter}$ s{rw0$ sv$ mr$ xli$ qevoixtpegi0$ gsyph$ pieh$ xs$ hixivmsvexmsr$ mr$ qevoix$ gsrhmxmsrw$ erh$ tvsnigxih$ gewl$ jps{w2

Epxlsykl$xli}$evi$rsx$jviuyirxp}$vigimzih0$er$yrwspmgmxih$sjjiv$xs$tyvglewi$er}$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw0$ex$eqsyrxw$xlex$evi$piww

xler$xlimv$gevv}mrk$zepyi$gsyph$epws$geywi$xli$Gsqter}$xs$vigsrwmhiv$xli$ewwyqtxmsrw$ywih$mr$xli$qswx$vigirx$mqtemvqirx$erep}wmw2$Xli

Gsqter}$ lew$ mhirxmjmih$qevoixmrk$ tvswtigxw$ xs$ yxmpm~i$ iegl$ sj$ xli$ viqemrmrk$ gyvvirxp}$ mhpih$ jegmpmxmiw$ erh$ lew$ hixivqmrih$ xlex$ rs

gyvvirx$ mqtemvqirx$i|mwxw2$Ls{iziv0$ xli$Gsqter}$ger$tvszmhi$rs$ ewwyvergi$ xlex$ mx${mpp$ fi$ efpi$ xs$ wigyvi$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$ xs

yxmpm~i$mxw$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw0$sv$xlex$mx${mpp$rsx$mrgyv$mqtemvqirx$glevkiw$mr$xli$jyxyvi2$Mr$epp$gewiw0$xli$tvsnigxih$yrhmwgsyrxih$gewl$jps{w$mr

syv$erep}wmw$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=$wyfwxerxmepp}$i|giihih$xli$gevv}mrk$eqsyrxw$sj$iegl$jegmpmx}2

Xli$Gsqter}+w$izepyexmsrw$epws$xeoi$mrxs$gsrwmhivexmsr$lmwxsvmgep$i|tivmirgi$mr$wigyvmrk$ri{$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$xs

yxmpm~i$ jegmpmxmiw$ xlex$ leh$ fiir$ tvizmsywp}$ mhpih$ jsv$ tivmshw$ gsqtevefpi$ xs$ sv$ mr$ i|giww$ sj$ xli$ tivmshw$ xli$Gsqter}+w$ gyvvirxp}$ mhpi

jegmpmxmiw$lezi$fiir$mhpi2$Wygl$tvizmsywp}$mhpih$jegmpmxmiw$evi$gyvvirxp}$fimrk$stivexih$yrhiv$gsrxvegxw$xlex$kirivexi$gewl$jps{w$viwypxmrk

mr$xli$vigszivefmpmx}$sj$xli$rix$fsso$zepyi$sj$xli$tvizmsywp}$mhpih$jegmpmxmiw$f}$wyfwxerxmep$eqsyrxw2$Hyi$xs$e$zevmix}$sj$jegxsvw0$xli$pieh

xmqi$ xs$ riksxmexi$ gsrxvegxw$ {mxl$ jihivep$ erh$ wxexi$ ekirgmiw$ xs$ yxmpm~i$ mhpi$ fih$ getegmx}$ mw$ kirivepp}$ pirkxl}$ {lmgl$ lew$ lmwxsvmgepp}

viwypxih$mr$tivmshw$sj$mhpiriww$wmqmpev$xs$xli$sriw$xli$Gsqter}$mw$gyvvirxp}$i|tivmirgmrk2

F}$ xlimv$rexyvi0$ xliwi$iwxmqexiw$gsrxemr$yrgivxemrxmiw${mxl$ viwtigx$xs$ xli$i|xirx$erh$xmqmrk$sj$ xli$viwtigxmzi$gewl$jps{w$hyi$ xs

tsxirxmep$hipe}w$sv$qexivmep$glerkiw$xs$jsvigewxih$xivqw$erh$gsrhmxmsrw$mr$gsrxvegxw${mxl$tvswtigxmzi$gywxsqivw$xlex$gsyph$mqtegx$xli

iwxmqexi$sj$tvsnigxih$gewl$jps{w2$Rsx{mxlwxerhmrk$xli$ijjigxw$xli$gyvvirx$igsrsq}$lew$leh$sr$xli$Gsqter}+w$gywxsqivw+$jsv$ezempefpi

fihw$ mr$ xli$ wlsvx$ xivq${lmgl$ lew$ pih$ xs$ mxw$ higmwmsr$ xs$ mhpi$ givxemr$ jegmpmxmiw0$ xli$Gsqter}$ fipmiziw$ xli$ psrk1xivq$ xvirhw$ jezsv$ er

mrgviewi$ mr$ xli$yxmpm~exmsr$sj$ mxw$ mhpi$ jegmpmxmiw2$Xlmw$fipmij$ mw$epws$fewih$sr$ xli$Gsqter}+w$i|tivmirgi$ mr${svomrk${mxl$kszivrqirxep

ekirgmiw$jegih${mxl$wmkrmjmgerx$fyhkixev}$gleppirkiw${lmgl$mw$e$tvmqev}$gsrxvmfyxmrk$jegxsv$xs$xli$pego$sj$ettvstvmexih$jyrhmrk$xs$fymph

ri{$fih$getegmx}$f}$jihivep$erh$wxexi$ekirgmiw2

Ewwixw$Liph$yrhiv$Jmrergi$Piewiw

Ewwixw$liph$yrhiv$jmrergi$piewiw$evi$vigsvhih$ex$ xli$ps{iv$sj$xli$rix$tviwirx$zepyi$sj$xli$qmrmqyq$piewi$te}qirxw$sv$xli$jemv

zepyi$ sj$ xli$ piewih$ ewwix$ ex$ xli$ mrgitxmsr$ sj$ xli$ piewi2$Eqsvxm~exmsr$ i|tirwi$ mw$ vigskrm~ih$ ywmrk$ xli$ wxvemklx1pmri$qixlsh$ sziv$ xli

wlsvxiv$sj$xli$iwxmqexih$ywijyp$pmji$sj$xli$ewwix$sv$xli$xivq$sj$xli$vipexih$piewi$erh$mw$mrgpyhih$mr$hitvigmexmsr$i|tirwi2

Kssh{mpp$erh$Sxliv$Mrxerkmfpi$Ewwixw

Kssh{mpp

Xli$Gsqter}$ lew$ vigsvhih$kssh{mpp$ ew$ e$ viwypx$ sj$ mxw$ fywmriww$ gsqfmrexmsrw2$Kssh{mpp$ mw$ vigsvhih$ ew$ xli$ hmjjivirgi0$ mj$ er}0

fix{iir$ xli$ekkvikexi$gsrwmhivexmsr$temh$ jsv$er$eguymwmxmsr$ erh$ xli$ jemv$ zepyi$sj$ xli$rix$ xerkmfpi$ewwixw$ erh$sxliv$ mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw

eguymvih2$Xli$Gsqter}+w$kssh{mpp$ mw$rsx$eqsvxm~ih$erh$mw$ xiwxih$jsv$mqtemvqirx$erryepp}$sr$xli$jmvwx$he}$sj$ xli$jsyvxl$uyevxiv0$erh

{liriziv$izirxw$sv$gmvgyqwxergiw$evmwi$xlex$mrhmgexi$mqtemvqirx$qe}$lezi$sggyvvih2$Mqtemvqirx$xiwxmrk$mw$tivjsvqih$jsv$epp$vitsvxmrk

yrmxw$xlex$gsrxemr$kssh{mpp2$Xli$vitsvxmrk$yrmxw$evi$xli$weqi$ew$xli$vitsvxefpi$wikqirx$jsv$Y2W2$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$erh$evi$ex$xli$stivexmrk

wikqirx$pizip$jsv$KIS$Gevi2

Sr$xli$erryep$qiewyviqirx$hexi$sj$Sgxsfiv$50$645=0$xli$Gsqter}+w$qerekiqirx$ipigxih$xs$uyepmxexmzip}$ewwiww$xli$Gsqter}+w

kssh{mpp$ jsv$ mqtemvqirx$ jsv$ epp$ sj$ mxw$ vitsvxmrk$ yrmxw2$ Yrhiv$ tvszmwmsrw$ sj$ xli$ uyepmxexmzi$ erep}wmw0$ {lir$ xiwxmrk$ kssh{mpp$ jsv

mqtemvqirx0$ xli$Gsqter}$ jmvwx$ ewwiwwiw$uyepmxexmzi$jegxsvw$ xs$hixivqmri${lixliv$ xli$i|mwxirgi$sj$izirxw$sv$gmvgyqwxergiw$ piehw$ xs$e

hixivqmrexmsr$xlex$mx$mw$qsvi$pmoip}$xler$rsx$xlex$xli$jemv$zepyi$sj$e$vitsvxmrk$yrmx$mw$piww$xler$mxw$gevv}mrk$eqsyrx2$Mj0$ejxiv$ewwiwwmrk$xli

xsxepmx}$sj$izirxw$sv$gmvgyqwxergiw0$xli$Gsqter}$hixivqmriw$mx$mw$qsvi$pmoip}$xler$rsx$xlex$xli$jemv$zepyi$sj$e$vitsvxmrk$yrmx$mw$piww$xler

mxw$gevv}mrk$eqsyrx0$xli$Gsqter}$tivjsvqw$e$uyerxmxexmzi$mqtemvqirx$xiwx$xs$mhirxmj}$kssh{mpp$mqtemvqirx$erh$qiewyviw$xli$eqsyrx$sj

kssh{mpp$mqtemvqirx$psww$xs$fi$vigskrm~ih0$mj$er}2$Xli$uyepmxexmzi$jegxsvw$ywih$f}$xli$Gsqter}×w

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 130 of 253

Page 153: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 574367<

<;

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 131 of 253

Page 154: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 575367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

qerekiqirx$xs$hixivqmri$xli$pmoipmlssh$xlex$xli$jemv$zepyi$sj$xli$vitsvxmrk$yrmx$mw$piww$xler$xli$gevv}mrk$eqsyrx$mrgpyhi0$eqsrk$sxliv

xlmrkw0$e$vizmi{$sj$szivepp$igsrsqmg$gsrhmxmsrw$erh$xlimv$gyvvirx$erh$jyxyvi$mqtegx$sr$xli$Gsqter}×w$i|mwxmrk$fywmriww0$xli$Gsqter}×w

jmrergmep$ tivjsvqergi$ erh$ wxsgo$ tvmgi0$ mrhywxv}$ syxpsso$ erh$ qevoix$ gsqtixmxmsr2$ [mxl$ viwtigx$ xs$ xli$ uyepmxexmzi$ ewwiwwqirxw0

qerekiqirx$hixivqmrih$xlex0$ew$sj$Sgxsfiv$50$645=0$mx${ew$qsvi$pmoip}$xler$rsx$xlex$xli$jemv$zepyiw$sj$xli$vitsvxmrk$yrmxw$i|giihih$xlimv

gevv}mrk$zepyiw2

Sxliv$Mrxerkmfpi$Ewwixw

Xli$Gsqter}$lew$epws$vigsvhih$sxliv$jmrmxi$erh$mrhijmrmxi$pmzih$mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw$ew$e$ viwypx$sj$tvizmsywp}$gsqtpixih$fywmriww

gsqfmrexmsrw2$Sxliv$eguymvih$jmrmxi$erh$mrhijmrmxi$pmzih$mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw$evi$vigskrm~ih$witevexip}$mj$xli$firijmx$sj$xli$mrxerkmfpi$ewwix

mw$sfxemrih$xlvsykl$gsrxvegxyep$sv$sxliv$pikep$vmklxw0$sv$mj$xli$mrxerkmfpi$ewwix$ger$fi$wsph0$xverwjivvih0$pmgirwih0$virxih$sv$i|glerkih0

vikevhpiww$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$mrxirx$xs$hs$ws2$Xli$Gsqter}×w$mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw$mrgpyhi$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw0$xvehi$reqiw$erh

xiglrspsk}2$Xli$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$vitviwirx$gywxsqiv$vipexmsrwlmtw$mr$xli$jsvq$sj$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$eguymvih$ex$xli

xmqi$sj$iegl$fywmriww$gsqfmrexmsr?$xli$zepyi$sj$FM×w$erh$Tvsxsgsp$Gvmqmrep$Nywxmgi0$Mrg2+w$,&Tvsxsgsp&-$xvehi$reqiw$vitviwirx0$eqsrk

sxliv$ mrxerkmfpi$firijmxw0$reqi$ vigskrmxmsr$ xs$ mxw$ gywxsqivw$erh$ mrxippigxyep$ tvstivx}$ vmklxw?$ erh$ xli$ eguymvih$ xiglrspsk}$ vitviwirxw

FM×w$ mrrszexmsr${mxl$viwtigx$ xs$ mxw$KTW$xvegomrk0$qsrmxsvmrk0$ vehms$jviuyirg}$qsrmxsvmrk0$zsmgi$zivmjmgexmsr$qsrmxsvmrk$erh$epgslsp

gsqtpmergi$ w}wxiqw0$ Tvsxsgsp+w$ mrrszexmsr$ {mxl$ viwtigx$ xs$ mxw$ gywxsqiv$ vipexmsrwlmt$ qerekiqirx$ wsjx{evi$ erh$ Wsfivpmro0$ Mrg2+w

mrrszexmsr${mxl$viwtigx$xs$mxw$epgslsp$qsrmxsvmrk$hizmgiw2$[lir$iwxefpmwlmrk$ywijyp$pmziw0$ xli$Gsqter}$gsrwmhivw$xli$tivmsh$erh$xli

texxivr$mr${lmgl$xli$igsrsqmg$firijmxw$sj$xli$mrxerkmfpi$ewwix$evi$gsrwyqih$sv$sxliv{mwi$ywih$yt?$sv0$mj$xlex$texxivr$gerrsx$fi$vipmefp}

hixivqmrih0$ywmrk$e$wxvemklx1pmri$eqsvxm~exmsr$qixlsh$sziv$e$tivmsh$xlex$qe}$fi$wlsvxiv$xler$xli$ypxmqexi$pmji$sj$wygl$mrxerkmfpi$ewwix2

Xli$ Gsqter}$ epws$ gsrwmhivw$ xli$ mqtegx$ sj$ viri{ep$ xivqw$ {lir$ iwxefpmwlmrk$ ywijyp$ pmziw2$ Xli$ Gsqter}$ gyvvirxp}$ eqsvxm~iw$ mxw

eguymvih$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$sziv$tivmshw$verkmrk$jvsq$xlvii$xs$x{irx}1sri$}ievw$erh$ mxw$eguymvih$ xiglrspsk}$sziv$wizir

}ievw$xs$imklx$}ievw2$Xlivi$mw$rs$viwmhyep$zepyi$ewwsgmexih${mxl$xli$Gsqter}×w$jmrmxi1pmzih$mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw2$Xli$Gsqter}$vizmi{w$mxw

xvehi$reqi$ewwixw$jsv$mqtemvqirx${liriziv$izirxw$sv$glerkiw$mr$gmvgyqwxergiw$mrhmgexi$xlex$xli$gevv}mrk$eqsyrx$sj$wygl$ewwixw$qe}

rsx$fi$ jypp}$ vigszivefpi2$Xli$Gsqter}$hsiw$rsx$eqsvxm~i$ mxw$ mrhijmrmxi$ pmzih$ mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw2$Xli$Gsqter}$ vizmi{w$ mxw$ mrhijmrmxi

pmzih$ mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw$erryepp}$sv$qsvi$ jviuyirxp}$ mj$ izirxw$ sv$glerkiw$ mr$gmvgyqwxergiw$ mrhmgexi$ xlex$ xli$ewwix$qmklx$fi$ mqtemvih2

Xliwi$vizmi{w$viwypxih$mr$rs$mqtemvqirx$ xs$ xli$gevv}mrk$zepyi$sj$xli$mrhijmrmxi$pmzih$ mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw$jsv$epp$tivmshw$tviwirxih2$Xli

Gsqter}$vigsvhw$xli$gswxw$ewwsgmexih${mxl$viri{ep$erh$i|xirwmsr$sj$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$ew$i|tirwiw$mr$xli$tivmsh$xli}$evi

mrgyvvih2

Mrxivrep1Ywi$Wsjx{evi

Gswxw$mrgyvvih$xs$hizipst$wsjx{evi$jsv$mrxivrep$ywi$evi$getmxepm~ih$erh$eqsvxm~ih$sziv$xli$iwxmqexih$ywijyp$pmziw$sj$xli$wsjx{evi2

Gswxw$vipexih$xs$hiwmkr$sv$qemrxirergi$sj$mrxivrep1ywi$wsjx{evi$evi$i|tirwih$ew$mrgyvvih2$Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$645<0$mrgpyhih

mr$Tvstivx}$erh$Iuymtqirx0$Rix$mw$ettvs|mqexip}$(5826$qmppmsr$erh$(5:27$qmppmsr$sj$getmxepm~ih$mrxivrep1ywi$wsjx{evi$gswxw0

viwtigxmzip}2

Hifx$Mwwyergi$Gswxw

Hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw0$rix$sj$eggyqypexih$eqsvxm~exmsr$sj$(942<$qmppmsr$erh$(:92;$qmppmsr0$xsxepmrk$(7429$qmppmsr$erh$(7525$qmppmsr

ex$Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$645<0$viwtigxmzip}0$evi$mrgpyhih$mr$Psrk1Xivq$Hifx0$Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Hifx$erh$Sxliv$Rsr1Gyvvirx$Ewwixw$mr

xli$eggsqter}mrk$Gsrwspmhexih$Fepergi$Wliixw$erh$evi$eqsvxm~ih$xs$mrxiviwx$i|tirwi$ywmrk$xli$ijjigxmzi$mrxiviwx$qixlsh$sziv$xli$xivq

sj$xli$vipexih$hifx2

$Zevmefpi$Mrxiviwx$Irxmxmiw

Xli$Gsqter}$izepyexiw$mxw$nsmrx$zirxyviw$erh$sxliv$irxmxmiw$mr${lmgl$mx$lew$e$zevmefpi$mrxiviwx$,e$ÔZMIÕ-0$kirivepp}$mr$xli$jsvq$sj

mrziwxqirxw0$pserw0$kyeverxiiw0$sv$iuymx}$mr$svhiv$xs$hixivqmri$mj$mx$lew$e$gsrxvsppmrk$jmrergmep$mrxiviwx$erh$mw$viuymvih$xs$gsrwspmhexi$xli

irxmx}$ew$e$viwypx2$Xli$vitsvxmrk$irxmx}${mxl$e$zevmefpi$mrxiviwx$xlex$tvszmhiw$xli$irxmx}${mxl$e$gsrxvsppmrk$jmrergmep$mrxiviwx$ mr$xli$ZMI

{mpp$lezi$fsxl$sj$xli$jspps{mrk$glevegxivmwxmgw>$,m-$xli$ts{iv$xs$hmvigx$xli$egxmzmxmiw$sj$e$ZMI$xlex$qswx$wmkrmjmgerxp}$mqtegx$xli$ZMI+w

igsrsqmg$tivjsvqergi$erh$,mm-$xli$sfpmkexmsr$xs$efwsvf$xli$pswwiw$sj$xli$ZMI$xlex$gsyph$tsxirxmepp}$fi$wmkrmjmgerx$xs$xli$ZMI$sv$xli$vmklx

xs$vigimzi$firijmxw$jvsq$xli$ZMI$xlex$gsyph$tsxirxmepp}$fi$wmkrmjmgerx$xs$xli$ZMI2

Xli$Gsqter}$hsiw$rsx$gsrwspmhexi$mxw$94)$s{rih$Wsyxl$Ejvmger$nsmrx$zirxyvi$mrxiviwx$mr$WEGW0$e$ZMI2$WEGW$nsmrx$zirxyvi

mrziwxsvw$evi$KIS$erh$Oirwerm$Gsvvigxmsrw0$Tx}2$Pxh$,er$mrhitirhirx$xlmvh$tevx}-?$iegl$tevxriv$s{rw$e$94)$wlevi2$Xli$Gsqter}$lew

hixivqmrih$ mx$ mw$ rsx$ xli$ tvmqev}$ firijmgmev}$ sj$ WEGW$ wmrgi$ mx$ hsiw$ rsx$ lezi$ xli$ ts{iv$ xs$ hmvigx$ xli$ egxmzmxmiw$ sj$ WEGW$ xlex$qswx

wmkrmjmgerxp}$mqtegx$mxw$tivjsvqergi2$Ew$wygl0$xli$Gsqter}+w$mrziwxqirx$mr$xlmw$irxmx}$mw$eggsyrxih$jsv$yrhiv$xli

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 132 of 253

Page 155: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 576367<

<<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 133 of 253

Page 156: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 577367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

iuymx}$qixlsh$sj$eggsyrxmrk2$WEGW${ew$iwxefpmwlih$erh$wyfwiuyirxp}0$mr$64450${ew$e{evhih$e$691}iev$gsrxvegx$xs$hiwmkr0$jmrergi$erh

fymph$ xli$Oyxeqe$Wmrxlyqypi$Gsvvigxmsrep$Girxvi$ mr$Psymw$ Xvmglevhx0$ Wsyxl$Ejvmge2$ Xs$ jyrh$ xli$ gsrwxvygxmsr$ sj$ xli$ tvmwsr0$ WEGW

sfxemrih$ psrk1xivq$jmrergmrk$jvsq$mxw$iuymx}$tevxrivw$erh$ pirhivw0$ xli$vite}qirx$sj${lmgl$ mw$ jypp}$kyeverxiih$f}$ xli$Wsyxl$Ejvmger

kszivrqirx0$ i|gitx$ mr$ xli$ izirx$ sj$ hijeypx0$ mr${lmgl$ gewi$ xli$kszivrqirx$ kyeverxii$ mw$ vihygih$ xs$<4)2$Xli$Gsqter}+w$qe|mqyq

i|tswyvi$ jsv$ psww$yrhiv$ xlmw$gsrxvegx$ mw$ pmqmxih$ xs$ mxw$ mrziwxqirx$ mr$ xli$ nsmrx$zirxyvi$sj$(5627$qmppmsr$ex$Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$ mxw

kyeverxiiw$vipexih$xs$WEGW$evi$hmwgywwih$mr$Rsxi$57$1$Hifx2

Xli$Gsqter}$hsiw$rsx$gsrwspmhexi$mxw$94)$s{rih$nsmrx$zirxyvi$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq2$Mr$Jifvyev}$64550$KIS$YO0$i|igyxih$e

Wlevilsphivw$Ekviiqirx$ ,xli$ ÔWlevilsphivw$EkviiqirxÕ-$ {mxl$Eqi}$Gsqqyrmx}$ Pmqmxih$ ,ÔEqi}Õ-$ erh$Eqi}$YO$TPG$ ,ÔEqi}

KyeverxsvÕ-$xs$jsvq$KISEqi}0$e$tvmzexi$gsqter}$pmqmxih$f}$wleviw$mrgsvtsvexih$mr$Irkperh$erh$[epiw2$KISEqi}${ew$jsvqih$f}

KIS$YO$erh$Eqi}$,er$mrhitirhirx$xlmvh$tevx}-$jsv$xli$tyvtswi$sj$tivjsvqmrk$tvmwsriv$iwgsvx$erh$vipexih$gywxsh}$wivzmgiw$mr$Irkperh

erh$[epiw2$ Mr$svhiv$ xs$ jsvq$ xlmw$ tvmzexi$ gsqter}0$KISEqi}$ mwwyih$ wlevi$getmxep$ sj$ ¦544$hmzmhih$ mrxs$544$ wleviw$sj$ ¦5$ iegl$ erh

eppsgexih$xli$wleviw$94394$xs$KIS$YO$erh$Eqi}2$KIS$YO$erh$Eqi}$iegl$lezi$xlvii$hmvigxsvw$ettsmrxih$xs$xli$Fsevh$sj$Hmvigxsvw

erh$ rimxliv$ tevx}$ lew$ xli$ ts{iv$ xs$ hmvigx$ xli$ egxmzmxmiw$ xlex$qswx$ wmkrmjmgerxp}$ mqtegx$ xli$ tivjsvqergi$ sj$KISEqi}2$Ew$ wygl0$ xli

Gsqter}+w$mrziwxqirx$mr$xlmw$irxmx}$mw$eggsyrxih$jsv$yrhiv$xli$iuymx}$qixlsh$sj$eggsyrxmrk2$Fsxl$tevxmiw$tvszmhih$pmriw$sj$gvihmx$sj

¦5624$qmppmsr$xs$irwyvi$xlex$KISEqi}$gsyph$gsqtp}${mxl$jyxyvi$gsrxvegxyep$gsqqmxqirxw$vipexih$xs$xli$tivjsvqergi$sj$mxw$stivexmsrw2

Mr$Sgxsfiv$645<0$xli$rsxi$vigimzefpi$xs$iegl$nsmrx$zirxyvi$tevxriv${ew$temh$sjj$mr$jypp2

Jemv$Zepyi$Qiewyviqirxw

Xli$Gsqter}$hijmriw$jemv$zepyi$ew$xli$tvmgi$xlex${syph$fi$vigimzih$xs$wipp$er$ewwix$sv$temh$xs$xverwjiv$e$pmefmpmx}$mr$er$svhivp}

xverwegxmsr$fix{iir$qevoix$tevxmgmterxw$ex$xli$qiewyviqirx$hexi$,Ôi|mx$tvmgiÕ-2$Xli$Gsqter}$gevvmiw$givxemr$sj$mxw$ewwixw$erh$pmefmpmxmiw

ex$jemv$zepyi0$qiewyvih$sr$e$vigyvvmrk$fewmw0$mr$xli$eggsqter}mrk$Gsrwspmhexih$Fepergi$Wliixw2$Xli$Gsqter}$epws$lew$givxemr$ewwixw

erh$ pmefmpmxmiw$ {lmgl$ evi$ rsx$ gevvmih$ ex$ jemv$ zepyi$ mr$ mxw$ eggsqter}mrk$ Gsrwspmhexih$ Fepergi$ Wliixw$ erh$ hmwgpswiw$ xli$ jemv$ zepyi

qiewyviqirxw$gsqtevih$xs$xli$gevv}mrk$zepyiw$ew$sj$iegl$fepergi$wliix$hexi2$Xli$Gsqter}×w$jemv$zepyi$qiewyviqirxw$evi$hmwgpswih$mr

Rsxi$54$1$Jmrergmep$Mrwxvyqirxw$erh$Rsxi$55$1$Jemv$Zepyi$sj$Ewwixw$erh$Pmefmpmxmiw2$Xli$Gsqter}$iwxefpmwliw$jemv$zepyi$sj$mxw$ewwixw$erh

pmefmpmxmiw$ywmrk$e$ jemv$ zepyi$lmivevgl}$ xlex$tvmsvmxm~iw$ xli$ mrtyxw$ xs$zepyexmsr$ xiglrmuyiw$ywih$ xs$qiewyvi$ jemv$ zepyi$ mrxs$ xlvii$fvseh

pizipw${lmgl$hmwxmrkymwl$fix{iir$ewwyqtxmsrw$fewih$sr$qevoix$hexe$,sfwivzefpi$mrtyxw-$erh$xli$Gsqter}×w$ewwyqtxmsrw$,yrsfwivzefpi

mrtyxw-2$Xli$pizip$mr$xli$jemv$zepyi$lmivevgl}${mxlmr${lmgl$xli$viwtigxmzi$jemv$zepyi$qiewyviqirx$jeppw$mw$hixivqmrih$fewih$sr$xli$ps{iwx

pizip$mrtyx$xlex$mw$wmkrmjmgerx$xs$xli$qiewyviqirx$mr$mxw$irxmvix}2$Pizip$5$mrtyxw$evi$uysxih$qevoix$tvmgiw$mr$egxmzi$qevoixw$jsv$mhirxmgep

ewwixw$sv$pmefmpmxmiw2$Pizip$6$mrtyxw$evi$sxliv$xler$uysxefpi$qevoix$tvmgiw$mrgpyhih$mr$Pizip$5$xlex$evi$sfwivzefpi$jsv$xli$ewwix$sv$pmefmpmx}

imxliv$hmvigxp}$sv$mrhmvigxp}$xlvsykl$gsvvsfsvexmsr${mxl$sfwivzefpi$qevoix$hexe2$Pizip$7$mrtyxw$evi$yrsfwivzefpi$mrtyxw$jsv$xli$ewwixw$sv

pmefmpmxmiw$ xlex$ vijpigx$qerekiqirx×w$ s{r$ ewwyqtxmsrw$ efsyx$ xli$ ewwyqtxmsrw$qevoix$ tevxmgmterxw${syph$ ywi$ mr$ tvmgmrk$ xli$ ewwix$ sv

pmefmpmx}2$Xli$Gsqter}$vigskrm~iw$xverwjivw$fix{iir$Pizipw$50$6$erh$7$ew$sj$xli$egxyep$hexi$sj$xli$izirx$sv$glerki$mr$gmvgyqwxergiw$xlex

geywi$xli$xverwjiv2

Viziryi$Vigskrmxmsr

Sr$Neryev}$50$645<0$xli$Gsqter}$ehstxih$Eggsyrxmrk$Wxerhevhw$Gshmjmgexmsr$,&EWG&-$Xstmg$:4:0$&Viziryi$jvsq$Gsrxvegxw${mxl

Gywxsqivw&$ywmrk$xli$qshmjmih$vixvswtigxmzi$qixlsh$ettpmih$xs$xlswi$gsrxvegxw$xlex${ivi$rsx$gsqtpixih$ew$sj$Neryev}$50$645<2$Xli

ehstxmsr$sj$xlmw$wxerhevh$hmh$rsx$viwypx$mr$e$wmkrmjmgerx$glerki$xs$xli$Gsqter}+w$lmwxsvmgep$viziryi$vigskrmxmsr$tspmgmiw$erh$xlivi${ivi

rs$wmkrmjmgerx$ehnywxqirxw$xlex$viuymvih$e$gyqypexmzi$ehnywxqirx$xs$vixemrih$ievrmrkw$ytsr$xverwmxmsr2

Viziryi$mw$vigskrm~ih${lir$gsrxvsp$sj$xli$tvsqmwih$ksshw$sv$wivzmgiw$mw$xverwjivvih$xs$KIS+w$gywxsqivw0$mr$er$eqsyrx$xlex$vijpigxw$xli

gsrwmhivexmsr$KIS$i|tigxw$xs$fi$irxmxpih$xs$mr$i|glerki$jsv$xlswi$ksshw$sv$wivzmgiw2$Wepiw0$zepyi$ehhih$erh$sxliv$xe|iw$KIS$gsppigxw

gsrgyvvirx${mxl$viziryi$tvshygmrk$egxmzmxmiw$erh$xlex$evi$wyfwiuyirxp}$viqmxxih$xs$kszivrqirxep$eyxlsvmxmiw$evi$i|gpyhih$jvsq

viziryiw2$$Xli$kymhergi$hmwxmrkymwliw$fix{iir$ksshw$erh$wivzmgiw2$Xli$hijmrmxmsr$sj$wivzmgiw$yrhiv$xli$kymhergi$mrgpyhiw$iziv}xlmrk

sxliv$xler$ksshw2$Ew$wygl0$mr$xli$gewi$sj$KIS0$xlmw$kymhergi$zmi{w$xli$tvszmwmsr$sj$lsywmrk$ew$e$wivzmgi2

[lir$e$gsrxvegx$mrgpyhiw$zevmefpi$gsrwmhivexmsr0$KIS$hixivqmriw$er$iwxmqexi$sj$xli$zevmefpi$gsrwmhivexmsr$erh$izepyexiw${lixliv$xli

iwxmqexi$riihw$xs$fi$gsrwxvemrih?$xlivijsvi0$KIS$mrgpyhiw$xli$zevmefpi$gsrwmhivexmsr$mr$xli$xverwegxmsr$tvmgi$srp}$xs$xli$i|xirx$xlex$mx$mw

tvsfefpi$xlex$e$wmkrmjmgerx$vizivwep$sj$xli$eqsyrx$sj$gyqypexmzi$viziryi$vigskrm~ih${mpp$rsx$sggyv${lir$xli$yrgivxemrx}$ewwsgmexih${mxl

xli$zevmefpi$gsrwmhivexmsr$mw$wyfwiuyirxp}$viwspzih2$Zevmefpi$gsrwmhivexmsr$iwxmqexiw$evi$ythexih$ex$iegl$vitsvxmrk$hexi2$E$pmqmxih

ryqfiv$sj$KIS+w$hsqiwxmg$gsrxvegxw$lezi$tvszmwmsrw$ytsr${lmgl$e$wqepp$tsvxmsr$sj$xli$viziryi$jsv$xli$gsrxvegx$mw$fewih$sr$xli

tivjsvqergi$sj$givxemr$xevkixw2$Hsqiwxmgepp}0$viziryi$fewih$sr$xli$tivjsvqergi$sj$givxemr$xevkixw$mw$piww$xler$5)$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w

gsrwspmhexih$hsqiwxmg$viziryiw$erh${ew$rsx$wmkrmjmgerx$hyvmrk$xli$tivmshw$tviwirxih2$Sri$sj$KIS+w$mrxivrexmsrep$gsrxvegxw0$vipexih$xs

mxw$Vezirlepp$jegmpmx}$,hmwgywwih$jyvxliv$fips{-0$gsrxemrw$e$tvszmwmsr${livi$e$wmkrmjmgerx$tsvxmsr$sj$xli$viziryi$jsv$xli$gsrxvegx$mw$fewih

sr$xli$tivjsvqergi$sj$givxemr$xevkixw2$Xliwi

<=

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 134 of 253

Page 157: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 578367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

tivjsvqergi$xevkixw$evi$fewih$sr$wtigmjmg$gvmxivme$xs$fi$qix$sziv$wtigmjmg$tivmshw$sj$xmqi2$Wygl$gvmxivme$mrgpyhiw$xli$Gsqter}+w$efmpmx}

xs$eglmizi$givxemr$gsrxvegxyep$firglqevow$vipexmzi$xs$xli$uyepmx}$sj$wivzmgi$mx$tvszmhiw0$rsr1sggyvvirgi$sj$givxemr$hmwvytxmzi$izirxw0

ijjigxmziriww$sj$mxw$uyepmx}$gsrxvsp$tvskveqw$erh$mxw$viwtsrwmziriww$xs$gywxsqiv$viuymviqirxw2$Xli$tivjsvqergi$sj$xliwi$xevkixw$evi

qiewyvih$uyevxivp}$erh$xlivi${ew$rs$wmkrmjmgerx$gsrwxvemrx$sr$xli$iwxmqexi$sj$wygl$zevmefpi$gsrwmhivexmsr$jsv$xlmw$gsrxvegx$hyvmrk$xli

}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$645<2

KIS$hsiw$rsx$hmwgpswi$xli$zepyi$sj$yrwexmwjmih$tivjsvqergi$sfpmkexmsrw$jsv$,m-$gsrxvegxw${mxl$er$i|tigxih$pirkxl$sj$sri$}iev$sv$piww$erh

,mm-$gsrxvegxw$jsv${lmgl$viziryi$mw$vigskrm~ih$ex$xli$eqsyrx$xs${lmgl$KIS$lew$xli$vmklx$xs$mrzsmgi$jsv$wivzmgiw$tivjsvqih0${lmgl$mw

kirivepp}$xli$gewi$jsv$epp$sj$KIS+w$gsrxvegxw2$Mrgmhirxep$mxiqw$xlex$evi$mqqexivmep$mr$xli$gsrxi|x$sj$xli$gsrxvegx$evi$vigskrm~ih$ew

i|tirwi2$KIS$kirivepp}$hsiw$rsx$mrgyv$mrgviqirxep$gswxw$vipexih$xs$sfxemrmrk$e$gsrxvegx${mxl$mxw$gywxsqivw$xlex${syph$qiix$xli

viuymviqirx$jsv$getmxepm~exmsr2$Xlivi${ivi$rs$ewwixw$vigskrm~ih$jvsq$gswxw$xs$sfxemr$e$gsrxvegx${mxl$e$gywxsqiv$ex$Higiqfiv$750$645=

sv$645<2

Xli$xmqmrk$sj$viziryi$vigskrmxmsr$qe}$hmjjiv$jvsq$xli$xmqmrk$sj$mrzsmgmrk$xs$gywxsqivw2$KIS$vigsvhw$e$vigimzefpi${lir$wivzmgiw$evi

tivjsvqih${lmgl$evi$hyi$jvsq$mxw$gywxsqivw$fewih$sr$xli$tewweki$sj$xmqi2$KIS$vigsvhw$e$gsrxvegx$pmefmpmx}$mj$gsrwmhivexmsr$mw$vigimzih

mr$ehzergi$sj$xli$tivjsvqergi$sj$wivzmgiw2$Kirivepp}0$KIS+w$gywxsqivw$hs$rsx$tvszmhi$te}qirx$mr$ehzergi$sj$xli$tivjsvqergi$sj

wivzmgiw2$Xlivijsvi0$er}$gsrxvegx$pmefmpmx}$mw$rsx$wmkrmjmgerx$ex$Higiqfiv$750$645=$sv$645<2$Viziryi$vigskrm~ih$hyvmrk$xli$}ievw$irhih

Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$645<$xlex${ew$mrgpyhih$mr$xli$stirmrk$fepergi$sj$yrievrih$viziryi${ew$rsx$wmkrmjmgerx2$Xlivi$lezi$fiir$rs

wmkrmjmgerx$eqsyrxw$sj$viziryi$vigsvhih$mr$xli$tivmshw$tviwirxih$jvsq$tivjsvqergi$sfpmkexmsrw$imxliv${lspp}$sv$tevxmepp}$wexmwjmih$mr

tvmsv$tivmshw2

Xli$vmklx$xs$gsrwmhivexmsr$yrhiv$KIS+w$gsrxvegxw$mw$srp}$hitirhirx$sr$xli$tewweki$sj$xmqi$erh$mw$xlivijsvi$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi

yrgsrhmxmsrep2$Te}qirx$xivqw$erh$gsrhmxmsrw$zev}$f}$gsrxvegx$x}ti0$epxlsykl0${mxl$xli$i|gitxmsr$sj$xli$gsrxvegx$vigimzefpi$vipexih$xs

KIS+w$Vezirlepp$jegmpmx}$,jyvxliv$hmwgywwih$fips{-0$xivqw$kirivepp}$mrgpyhi$e$viuymviqirx$sj$te}qirx${mxlmr$74$he}w$ejxiv

tivjsvqergi$sfpmkexmsrw$evi$wexmwjmih$erh$kirivepp}$hs$rsx$mrgpyhi$e$wmkrmjmgerx$jmrergmrk$gsqtsrirx2$Xlivi$lezi$fiir$rs$wmkrmjmgerx

glerkiw$mr$vigimzefpiw$sv$yrievrih$viziryi$fepergiw$hyvmrk$xli$tivmshw$sxliv$xler$vikypev$mrzsmgmrk$erh$gsppigxmsr$egxmzmx}2

Xli$jspps{mrk$xefpi$hmwekkvikexiw$KIS+w$viziryi$f}$qensv$wsyvgi$erh$epws$tvszmhiw$e$vigsrgmpmexmsr${mxl$viziryi$mrjsvqexmsr

hmwgpswih$jsv$vitsvxefpi$wikqirxw$mr$Rsxi$5:$1$Fywmriww$Wikqirxw$erh$Kiskvetlmg$Mrjsvqexmsr>

$ ]iev$Irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=$,mr$xlsywerhw- $ $

$

Y2W2$Wigyvi

Wivzmgiw $ KIS$Gevi $ Mrxivrexmsrep $

Jegmpmx}

Gsrwxvygxmsr$erh

Hiwmkr $ Xsxep

S{rih$erh$Piewih>

Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw ( 5066<06== $ ( Ó $ ( Ó $ ( Ó $ ( 5066<06==

S{rih$erh$Piewih>

Gsqqyrmx}1fewih Ó $ 5;:0445 $ Ó $ Ó $ 5;:0445

S{rih$erh$Piewih>

]syxl$Wivzmgiw Ó $ <;05<= $ Ó $ Ó $ <;05<=

Qerekih$Srp} 7;707<4 $ 90967 $ 676045: $ Ó $ :540=5=

Jegmpmx}$Gsrwxvygxmsr

erh$Hiwmkr Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ 6=0=;< $ 6=0=;<

Rsr1viwmhirxmep

Wivzmgiw$erh$Sxliv Ó $ 789097: $ Ó $ Ó $ 789097:

$$Xsxep$Viziryiw ( 50:450:;= $ ( :58068= $ ( 676045: $ ( 6=0=;< $ ( 608;;0=66

=4

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 135 of 253

Page 158: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 579367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$ ]iev$Irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645<$,mr$xlsywerhw- $ $

$

Y2W2$Wigyvi

Wivzmgiw $ KIS$Gevi $ Mrxivrexmsrep $

Jegmpmx}

Gsrwxvygxmsr$erh

Hiwmkr $ Xsxep

S{rih$erh$Piewih$1

Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw ( 505540;8= $ ( Ó $ ( Ó $ ( Ó $ ( 505540;8=

S{rih$erh$Piewih$1

Gsqqyrmx}1fewih Ó $ 5;40<49 $ Ó $ Ó $ 5;40<49

S{rih$erh$Piewih$1

]syxl$Wivzmgiw Ó $ =50<68 $ Ó $ Ó $ =50<68

Qerekih$Srp} 7<60668 $ 80=<5 $ 6970<;8 $ Ó $ :8504;=

Jegmpmx}$Gsrwxvygxmsr

erh$Hiwmkr Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ 8066: $ 8066:

Rsr1viwmhirxmep$Wivzmgiw

erh$Sxliv Ó $ 7560;47 $ Ó $ Ó $ 7560;47

$$Xsxep$Viziryiw ( 508=60=;7 $ ( 9<40757 $ ( 6970<;8 $ ( 8066: $ ( 6077507<:

]iev$Irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645;$,mr$xlsywerhw-

Y2W$Wigyvi

Wivzmgiw KIS$Gevi Mrxivrexmsrep

Jegmpmx}

Gsrwxvygxmsr$erh

Hiwmkr Xsxep

S{rih$erh

Piewih$1$Wigyvi

Wivzmgiw ( 504990698 ( Ó ( Ó ( Ó ( 504990698

S{rih$erh

Piewih$1

Gsqqyrmx}1

fewih Ó 58=0:5= Ó Ó 58=0:5=

S{rih$erh

Piewih$1$]syxl

Wivzmgiw Ó <<05<8 Ó Ó <<05<8

Qerekih$Srp} 7<60;=4 708=9 5=90<4: Ó 9<604=5

Jegmpmx}

Gsrwxvygxmsr$erh

Hiwmkr Ó Ó Ó 5590848 5590848

Rsr1viwmhirxmep

wivzmgiw$erh

Sxliv Ó 6;60<:< Ó Ó 6;60<:<

Xsxep$Viziryiw ( 5087<0488 ( 95805:: ( 5=90<4: ( 5590848 ( 606:70864

S{rih$erh$Piewih$1$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw

KIS$vigskrm~iw$viziryi$jsv$wigyvi$lsywmrk$wivzmgiw${livi$KIS$s{rw$sv$piewiw$xli$jegmpmx}$ew$wivzmgiw$evi$tivjsvqih2$KIS$tvszmhiw

jsv$xli$weji$erh$wigyvi$lsywmrk$erh$gevi$sj$mrgevgivexih$mrhmzmhyepw$yrhiv$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw${mxl$jihivep0$wxexi$erh$psgep

kszivrqirx$ekirgmiw2$Xlmw$mrgpyhiw$tvszmhmrk$681lsyv$gevi$erh$wytivzmwmsr0$mrgpyhmrk$fyx$rsx$pmqmxih$xs0$wygl$wivzmgiw$ew$qihmgep0

xverwtsvxexmsr0$jssh$wivzmgi0$peyrhv}$wivzmgiw$erh$zevmsyw$tvskveqqmrk$egxmzmxmiw2$Xliwi$xewow$evi$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$egxmzmxmiw$xs$jypjmpp

xli$weji$erh$wigyvi$lsywmrk$tivjsvqergi$sfpmkexmsr$erh$evi$rsx$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$mrhmzmhyepp}$witevexi$tvsqmwiw$mr$xli$gsrxvegx2$Iegl$sj

xliwi$egxmzmxmiw$mw$lmklp}$mrxivvipexih$erh$KIS$tivjsvqw$e$wmkrmjmgerx$pizip$sj$mrxikvexmsr$sj$xliwi$egxmzmxmiw2$KIS$lew$mhirxmjmih$xliwi

egxmzmxmiw$ew$e$fyrhpi$sj$wivzmgiw$erh$hixivqmrih$xlex$iegl$he}$sj$xli$tvsqmwih$wivzmgi$mw$hmwxmrgx2$Xli$wivzmgiw$tvszmhih$evi$tevx$sj$e

wivmiw$sj$hmwxmrgx$wivzmgiw$xlex$evi$wyfwxerxmepp}$xli$weqi$erh$evi$qiewyvih$ywmrk$xli$weqi$qiewyvi$sj$tvskviww$,xmqi1fewih$syxtyx

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 136 of 253

Page 159: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 57:367<

qixlsh-2$KIS$lew$hixivqmrih$xlex$viziryi$jsv$xliwi$wivzmgiw$evi$vigskrm~ih$sziv$xmqi$ew$mx+w$gywxsqivw$wmqypxerisywp}$vigimzi$erh

gsrwyqi$xli$firijmxw$ew$xli$wivzmgiw$evi

=5

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 137 of 253

Page 160: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 57;367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

tivjsvqih0${lmgl$mw$sr$e$gsrxmryep$hemp}$fewmw0$erh$KIS$lew$e$vmklx$xs$te}qirx$jsv$tivjsvqergi$gsqtpixih$xs$hexi2$Xmqi1fewih$syxtyx

qixlshw$sj$viziryi$vigskrmxmsr$evi$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$e$jemxljyp$hitmgxmsr$sj$KIS+w$ijjsvxw$xs$jypjmpp$mxw$sfpmkexmsrw$yrhiv$mxw$gsrxvegxw

erh$xlivijsvi$vijpigx$xli$xverwjiv$sj$wivzmgiw$xs$mxw$gywxsqivw2$KIS+w$gywxsqivw$kirivepp}$te}$jsv$xliwi$wivzmgiw$fewih$sr$e$rix$vexi$tiv

he}$tiv$mrhmzmhyep$sv$sr$e$jm|ih$qsrxlp}$vexi2

S{rih$erh$Piewih$1$Gsqqyrmx}1fewih

KIS$vigskrm~iw$viziryi$jsv$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$viirxv}$wivzmgiw${livi$KIS$s{rw$sv$piewiw$xli$jegmpmx}$mr$e$qerriv$wmqmpev$xs$mxw$wigyvi

wivzmgiw$hmwgywwih$efszi2$KIS$tvszmhiw$mrhmzmhyepw$rievmrk$xli$irh$sj$xlimv$wirxirgi${mxl$xli$viwsyvgiw$rigiwwev}$xs$tvshygxmzip}

xverwmxmsr$fego$mrxs$wsgmix}2$Xlvsykl$mxw$viwmhirxmep$viirxv}$girxivw0$KIS$tvszmhiw$jihivep$erh$wxexi$tevspiiw$erh$tvsfexmsrivw${mxl

xiqtsvev}$lsywmrk0$vilefmpmxexmsr0$wyfwxergi$efywi$gsyrwipmrk$erh$zsgexmsrep$erh$ihygexmsrep$tvskveqw2$Xliwi$egxmzmxmiw$evi

gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$e$fyrhpi$sj$wivzmgiw${lmgl$evi$e$tevx$sj$e$wivmiw$sj$hmwxmrgx$wivzmgiw$vigskrm~ih$sziv$xmqi$fewih$sr$xli$weqi$gvmxivme$ew

hmwgywwih$efszi$jsv$wigyvi$wivzmgiw$viziryiw2$KIS+w$gywxsqivw$epws$kirivepp}$te}$jsv$xliwi$wivzmgiw$fewih$sr$e$rix$vexi$tiv$he}$tiv

mrhmzmhyep$sv$sr$e$jm|ih$qsrxlp}$vexi2

S{rih$erh$Piewih$1$]syxl$Wivzmgiw

KIS$vigskrm~iw$viziryiw$jsv$}syxl$wivzmgiw${livi$KIS$s{rw$sv$piewiw$xli$jegmpmx}$mr$xli$weqi$qerriv$ew$hmwgywwih$efszi$jsv$xli

lsywmrk0$wytivzmwmsr0$gevi$erh$vilefmpmxexmsr$sj$xvsyfpih$}syxl$viwmhirxw2$Xli$egxmzmxmiw$xs$lsywi$erh$gevi$jsv$xvsyfpih$}syxl$viwmhirxw

evi$epws$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$e$fyrhpi$sj$wivzmgiw${lmgl$evi$tevx$sj$e$wivmiw$sj$hmwxmrgx$wivzmgiw$vigskrm~ih$sziv$xmqi$fewih$sr$xli$weqi

gvmxivme$hmwgywwih$jsv$xli$tvizmsyw$x{s$viziryi$wxvieqw2$KIS+w$gywxsqivw$kirivepp}$te}$jsv$xliwi$wivzmgiw$fewih$sr$e$rix$vexi$tiv$he}

tiv$mrhmzmhyep2

Qerekih$Srp}

KIS$vigskrm~iw$viziryi$jsv$mxw$qerekih$srp}$gsrxvegxw$mr$xli$weqi$qerriv$ew$mxw$S{rih$erh$Piewih$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$erh$S{rih$erh

Piewih$Gsqqyrmx}1fewih$gsrxvegxw$ew$hmwgywwih$efszi2$Xli$tvmqev}$i|gitxmsr$mw$xlex$KIS$hsiw$rsx$s{r$sv$piewi$xli$jegmpmx}2$Xli

jegmpmx}$mw$s{rih$f}$xli$gywxsqiv2$Mr$givxemr$gmvgyqwxergiw0$KIS+w$gywxsqivw$qe}$viuyiwx$xlex$KIS$qeoi$givxemr$getmxep

mqtvsziqirxw$xs$xli$jegmpmx}$sv$qeoi$sxliv$te}qirxw$vipexih$xs$xli$jegmpmx}2$Xliwi$te}qirxw$evi$eqsvxm~ih$ew$e$vihygxmsr$sj$viziryiw

sziv$xli$pmji$sj$xli$gsrxvegx2$KIS+w$gywxsqivw$kirivepp}$te}$jsv$xliwi$wivzmgiw$fewih$sr$e$rix$vexi$tiv$he}$tiv$mrhmzmhyep$sv$e$jm|ih

qsrxlp}$vexi2

Jegmpmx}$Gsrwxvygxmsr$erh$Hiwmkr

Jegmpmx}$Gsrwxvygxmsr$erh$Hiwmkr$viziryiw$hyvmrk$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645;$gsrwmwxih$sj$sri$gsrxvegx${mxl$xli$Hitevxqirx$sj

Nywxmgi$mr$xli$Wxexi$sj$Zmgxsvme$,xli$ÔWxexiÕ-$jsv$xli$hizipstqirx$erh$stivexmsr$sj$e$ri{$507441fih$wigyvi$jegmpmx}$,xli$ÔJegmpmx}Õ-$mr

Vezirlepp0$e$psgepmx}$riev$Qipfsyvri0$Eywxvepme2$Xli$Jegmpmx}${ew$gsqtpixih$hyvmrk$xli$jsyvxl$uyevxiv$sj$645;$erh$KIS$mw$gyvvirxp}

qerekmrk$xli$Jegmpmx}$yrhiv$e$691}iev$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegx2$Xlivi${ivi$rs$jegmpmx}$gsrwxvygxmsr$erh$hiwmkr$viziryiw$vipexih$xs$xli

Jegmpmx}$hyvmrk$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=$sv$645<2$KIS+w$tvsqmwi$xs$hiwmkr$erh$gsrwxvygx$xli$Jegmpmx}${ew$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$e

witevexi$erh$hmwxmrgx$tivjsvqergi$sfpmkexmsr$jvsq$xli$qerekiqirx$sfpmkexmsr${lmgl$mrgpyhiw$xli$weji$erh$wigyvi$lsywmrk0$gevi$erh

tvskveqqmrk$egxmzmxmiw$jsv$mrgevgivexih$mrhmzmhyepw$wmqmpev$xs$xli$wigyvi$wivzmgiw$hmwgywwih$efszi2$Jsv$xli$sfpmkexmsr$xs$qereki$xli

Jegmpmx}0$KIS$hixivqmrih$viziryi$wlsyph$fi$vigsvhih$sziv$xmqi$ywmrk$e$xmqi1fewih$syxtyx$qixlsh$fewih$sr$xli$weqi$gvmxivme$ew

hmwgywwih$efszi$jsv$wigyvi$wivzmgiw2$Jiiw$mrgpyhih$erh$tvmgih$mr$xli$gsrxvegx$jsv$qerekmrk$xli$Jegmpmx}$evi$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$wxexih$ex

xlimv$mrhmzmhyep$iwxmqexih$wxerh1epsri$wippmrk$tvmgiw$ywmrk$xli$ehnywxih$qevoix$ewwiwwqirx$ettvsegl2$Xliwi$wivzmgiw$evi$vikypevp}

tvszmhih$f}$KIS$sr$e$wxerh1epsri$fewmw$xs$wmqmpev$gywxsqivw${mxlmr$e$wmqmpev$verki$sj$eqsyrxw2$KIS$ywih$xli$i|tigxih$gswx$tpyw

qevkmr$ettvsegl$xs$eppsgexi$xli$xverwegxmsr$tvmgi$xs$xli$gsrwxvygxmsr$sfpmkexmsr2$KIS${ew$irxmxpih$yrhiv$xli$gsrxvegx$xs$vigimzi

gsrwmhivexmsr$mr$xli$eqsyrx$sj$mxw$gswxw$tpyw$e$qevkmr2

Hyvmrk$xli$hiwmkr$erh$gsrwxvygxmsr$tlewi0$KIS$hixivqmrih$xlex$viziryi$wlsyph$fi$vigsvhih$sziv$xmqi$erh$ettpmih$gswx$fewih$mrtyx

qixlshw$ywmrk$xli$egxyep$gswxw$mrgyvvih$vipexmzi$xs$xli$xsxep$iwxmqexih$gswxw$,tivgirxeki$sj$gsqtpixmsr$fewmw-$xs$hixivqmri$tvskviww

xs{evhw$gsrxvegx$gsqtpixmsr$erh$xs$gepgypexi$xli$gsvviwtsrhmrk$eqsyrx$sj$viziryi$erh$kvsww$tvsjmx$xs$vigskrm~i2$Gswx$fewih$mrtyx

qixlshw$sj$viziryi$vigskrmxmsr$evi$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$e$jemxljyp$hitmgxmsr$sj$KIS+w$ijjsvxw$xs$wexmwj}$psrk1xivq$gsrwxvygxmsr$gsrxvegxw

erh$xlivijsvi$vijpigx$xli$xverwjiv$sj$ksshw$xs$xli$gywxsqiv$ew$xli$gywxsqiv$gsrxvspw$xli${svo$mr$tvskviww$ew$xli$Jegmpmx}$mw$gsrwxvygxih2

Gswx$fewih$mrtyx$qixlshw$sj$viziryi$vigskrmxmsr$epws$viuymvi$KIS$xs$qeoi$iwxmqexiw$sj$rix$gsrxvegx$viziryiw$erh$gswxw$xs$gsqtpixi

xli$tvsnigx2$Wmkrmjmgerx$nyhkqirx${ew$viuymvih$xs$izepyexi$xli$gswxw$xs$gsqtpixi$xli$tvsnigx0$mrgpyhmrk$qexivmepw0$pefsv0$gsrxmrkirgmiw

erh$sxliv$gswxw2$Mj$iwxmqexih$xsxep$gswxw$sr$xli$gsrxvegx$evi$kviexiv$xler$xli$rix$gsrxvegx$viziryiw0$xli$irxmvi$iwxmqexih$psww$sr$xli

gsrxvegx$mw$vigskrm~ih$mr$xli$tivmsh$xli$psww$figsqiw$ors{r2$Xli$gyqypexmzi$ijjigx$sj$vizmwmsrw$xs$iwxmqexiw$vipexih$xs$rix$gsrxvegx

viziryiw$sv$gswxw$xs$gsqtpixi$evi$vigsvhih$mr$xli$tivmsh$mr${lmgl$xli

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 138 of 253

Page 161: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 57<367<

=6

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 139 of 253

Page 162: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 57=367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

vizmwmsrw$xs$iwxmqexiw$evi$mhirxmjmih$erh$xli$eqsyrxw$ger$fi$viewsrefp}$iwxmqexih2$X}tmgepp}0$xli$Gsqter}$irxivw$mrxs$jm|ih$tvmgi

gsrxvegxw$erh$hsiw$rsx$tivjsvq$ehhmxmsrep${svo$yrpiww$ettvszih$glerki$svhivw$evi$mr$tpegi2$Gswxw$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$yrettvszih$glerki

svhivw$evi$i|tirwih$mr$xli$tivmsh$mr${lmgl$xli$gswxw$evi$mrgyvvih$mj$xli$Gsqter}$fipmiziw$xlex$mx$mw$rsx$tvsfefpi$xlex$xli$gswxw${mpp$fi

vigszivih$xlvsykl$e$glerki$mr$xli$gsrxvegx$tvmgi2$Mj$xli$Gsqter}$fipmiziw$xlex$mx$mw$tvsfefpi$xlex$xli$gswxw${mpp$fi$vigszivih$xlvsykl$e

glerki$mr$xli$gsrxvegx$tvmgi0$gswxw$vipexih$xs$yrettvszih$glerki$svhivw$evi$i|tirwih$mr$xli$tivmsh$mr${lmgl$xli}$evi$mrgyvvih0$erh

gsrxvegx$viziryi$mw$vigskrm~ih$xs$xli$i|xirx$sj$xli$gswxw$mrgyvvih2$Viziryi$mr$i|giww$sj$xli$gswxw$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$yrettvszih$glerki

svhivw$mw$rsx$vigskrm~ih$yrxmp$xli$glerki$svhiv$mw$ettvszih2$Glerkiw$mr$nsf$tivjsvqergi0$nsf$gsrhmxmsrw0$erh$iwxmqexih$tvsjmxefmpmx}0

mrgpyhmrk$xlswi$evmwmrk$jvsq$gsrxvegx$tirepx}$tvszmwmsrw0$erh$jmrep$gsrxvegx$wixxpiqirxw0$qe}$viwypx$mr$vizmwmsrw$xs$iwxmqexih$gswxw$erh

mrgsqi0$erh$evi$vigskrm~ih$mr$xli$tivmsh$mr${lmgl$xli$vizmwmsrw$evi$hixivqmrih2$Jsv$xli$tivmshw$tviwirxih0$xlivi${ivi$rs$glerkiw$mr$nsf

tivjsvqergi0$nsf$gsrhmxmsrw$erh$iwxmqexih$tvsjmxefmpmx}$xlex$viuymvih$e$vizmwmsr$xs$xli$iwxmqexih$gswxw$erh$mrgsqi$vigsvhih2

KIS${ew$xli$tvmqev}$hizipstiv$sj$xli$tvsnigx$erh$wyfgsrxvegxih${mxl$e$fsrhih$mrxivrexmsrep$hiwmkr$erh$fymph$gsrxvegxsv$xs$hiwmkr$erh

gsrwxvygx$xli$Jegmpmx}2$Ew$xli$tvmqev}$gsrxvegxsv$jsv$xli$tvsnigx0$KIS$hixivqmrih$xlex$mx${ew$tvmqevmp}$viwtsrwmfpi$jsv$jypjmppmrk$xli

tvsqmwi$xs$hizipst$erh$tvszmhi$xli$Jegmpmx}$xs$xli$Wxexi0$mrgpyhmrk$szivepp$viwtsrwmfmpmx}$jsv$xli$eggitxefmpmx}$sj$xli$tvsnigx$mr$qiixmrk

xli$Wxexi+w$wtigmjmgexmsrw2$Xlivijsvi0$KIS${ew$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$e$tvmrgmtep$mr$xli$xverwegxmsr$erh$gsrwxvygxmsr$viziryiw$erh

gsrwxvygxmsr$gswxw${ivi$vigsvhih$sr$e$kvsww$fewmw2

Xli$gswx$sj$xli$tvsnigx$hyvmrk$xli$hiwmkr$erh$gsrwxvygxmsr$tlewi${ew$jyrhih$f}$hifx$jmrergmrk$epsrk${mxl$e$getmxep$gsrxvmfyxmsr$f}

KIS${lmgl${ew$qehi$mr$Neryev}$645;2$KIS+w$tvsqmwi$xs$tvszmhi$xli$iuymx}$gsrxvmfyxmsr${ew$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$e$witevexi$erh$hmwxmrgx

tivjsvqergi$sfpmkexmsr$xlex$mw$witevexi$jvsq$xli$gsrwxvygxmsr$erh$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$sfpmkexmsrw2$Xli$gsrxvmfyxmsr$vitviwirxw$e

wmkrmjmgerx$jmrergmrk$ipiqirx${lmgl$tvszmhih$e$firijmx$xs$xli$Wxexi2$Gswxw$mrgyvvih$erh$iwxmqexih$ievrmrkw$mr$i|giww$sj$fmppmrkw${ivi

gpewwmjmih$ew$gsrxvegx$vigimzefpi$mr$xli$eggsqter}mrk$gsrwspmhexih$fepergi$wliixw2$Xli$gsrxvegx$vigimzefpi${ew$tevxmepp}$wexmwjmih

xlvsykl$e$Wxexi$gsrxvmfyxmsr0${lmgl${ew$qehi$mr$Rsziqfiv$645;$ytsr$gsqqivgmep$eggitxergi$sj$xli$Jegmpmx}0$erh$f}$uyevxivp}

te}qirxw$xs$fi$qehi$sziv$xli$691}iev$stivexmrk$tlewi2$Xli$xmqmrk$sj$xliwi$te}qirxw$tvszmhi$xli$Wxexi${mxl$e$wmkrmjmgerx$firijmx$sj

jmrergmrk$jsv$xli$Jegmpmx}$ew$xli$te}qirxw$f}$xli$Wxexi$sggyv$wmkrmjmgerxp}$ejxiv$tivjsvqergi$,gsrwxvygxmsr$sj$xli$Jegmpmx}-2$Xlivijsvi0

xli$gsrxvegx$vigimzefpi$lew$fiir$vigsvhih$ex$rix$tviwirx$zepyi$fewih$sr$xli$xmqmrk$sj$i|tigxih$jyxyvi$wixxpiqirx2$Mrxiviwx$mrgsqi$mw

gepgypexih$ywmrk$er$ijjigxmzi$mrxiviwx$vexi$sj$<2=;)$erh$lew$fiir$tviwirxih$witevexip}$jvsq$jegmpmx}$hiwmkr$erh$gsrwxvygxmsr$viziryi2

Mrxiviwx$mrgsqi$epws$mrgpyhiw$er$iuymx}$vixyvr$jsv$KIS+w$getmxep$gsrxvmfyxmsr2

Hyvmrk$645=$erh$645<0$xli$Gsqter}$leh$jegmpmx}$gsrwxvygxmsr$*$hiwmkr$wivzmgiw$vipexih$xs$er$i|terwmsr$tvsnigx$ex$mxw$Jypleq

Gsvvigxmsrep$Girxvi$mr$Eywxvepme${lmgl$mw$i|tigxih$xs$fi$gsqtpixih$mr$xli$xlmvh$uyevxiv$sj$64642$Viziryiw$lezi$fiir$vigsvhih$yrhiv

xli$weqi$qixlshspsk}$ew$hmwgywwih$efszi2

Rsr1viwmhirxmep$Wivzmgiw$erh$Sxliv

Rsr1viwmhirxmep$Wivzmgiw$erh$Sxliv$viziryi$gsrwmwxw$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$gsrxvegxw${mxl$jihivep$erh$zevmsyw$wxexi$erh$psgep$kszivrqirxw

xs$tvszmhi$psgexmsr0$epgslsp$erh$hvyk$hixigxmrk$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$erh$gewi$qerekiqirx$wivzmgiw$xs$mrhmzmhyepw$sr$er$ew$riihih$sv

ew$viuyiwxih$fewmw2$Xlmw$gexiksv}$epws$mrgpyhiw$xli$Gsqter}+w$he}$vitsvxmrk$girxivw2

KIS$vigskrm~iw$viziryiw$jsv$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$erh$gewi$qerekiqirx$wivzmgiw$ew$xli$wivzmgiw$evi$tivjsvqih2$Wivzmgiw$tvszmhih

gsrwmwx$sj$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$wytivzmwmsr$,lsqi$zmwmxw-0$mr1tivwsr$vitsvxmrk0$xipitlsrmg$vitsvxmrk$erh$KTW$erh$sxliv$ipigxsrmg

qsrmxsvmrk$ew${ipp$ew$szivepp$gsrxvegx$qerekiqirx$wivzmgiw2$Xli$vexiw$jsv$xli$zevmsyw$wivzmgiw$evi$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$wxexih$ex$xlimv

mrhmzmhyep$wxerh1epsri$wippmrk$tvmgiw2$KIS$lew$hixivqmrih$xlex$xli$wivzmgiw$xs$fi$tvszmhih$evi$vigskrm~ih$sziv$xmqi$fewih$sr$xli$yrmx

sj$sggyvvirgi$sj$xli$zevmsyw$wivzmgiw$ew$mxw$gywxsqiv$wmqypxerisywp}$vigimziw$erh$gsrwyqiw$xli$firijmxw$ew$xli$wivzmgiw$evi$tivjsvqih

erh$KIS$lew$e$vmklx$xs$te}qirx$jsv$tivjsvqergi$gsqtpixih$xs$hexi2$Kirivepp}0$xliwi$wivzmgiw$evi$temh$fewih$sr$e$rix$vexi$tiv

sggyvvirgi$erh$e$qsrxlp}$jii$jsv$qerekiqirx$wivzmgiw2

Givxemr$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$gsrxvegxw$mrgpyhi$tvszmhmrk$qsrmxsvmrk$iuymtqirx$erh$vipexih$qsrmxsvmrk$wivzmgiw

egxmzmxmiw$,ywmrk$mrxivrep$tvstvmixev}$wsjx{evi$tpexjsvqw-$xs$mxw$gywxsqivw2$Xliwi$xewow$evi$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$egxmzmxmiw$xs$jypjmpp$xli

tvsqmwi$xs$tvszmhi$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$wivzmgiw$xs$mrhmzmhyepw$erh$evi$rsx$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$mrhmzmhyepp}$witevexi$tvsqmwiw$mr$xli

gsrxvegx2$Mr$xli$gsrxi|x$sj$xli$gsrxvegx0$xli$iuymtqirx$erh$qsrmxsvmrk$wivzmgi$mw$rsx$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$getefpi$sj$fimrk$hmwxmrgx$ew$xli

gywxsqiv$x}tmgepp}$gerrsx$firijmx$jvsq$xli$iuymtqirx$sv$qsrmxsvmrk$wivzmgi$sr$mxw$s{r$sv${mxl$sxliv$viehmp}$ezempefpi$viwsyvgiw2

Qerekiqirx$lew$mhirxmjmih$xliwi$egxmzmxmiw$ew$e$fyrhpi$sj$wivzmgiw$erh$hixivqmrih$xlex$iegl$he}$sv$yrmx$sj$xli$tvsqmwih$wivzmgi$mw

hmwxmrgx2$Xliwi$wivzmgiw$evi$tevx$sj$e$wivmiw$sj$hmwxmrgx$wivzmgiw$xlex$evi$wyfwxerxmepp}$xli$weqi$erh$evi$qiewyvih$ywmrk$xli$weqi$qiewyvi

sj$tvskviww$,xmqi1fewih$syxtyx$qixlsh-$erh$evi$xlivijsvi$eggsyrxih$jsv$ew$e$wmrkpi$tivjsvqergi$sfpmkexmsr2$KIS$lew$hixivqmrih$xlex

wivzmgiw$evi$vigskrm~ih$sziv$xmqi$ew$xli$gywxsqiv$wmqypxerisywp}$vigimziw$erh$gsrwyqiw$xli$firijmxw$ew$xli$wivzmgiw$evi$tivjsvqih$erh

KIS$lew$e$vmklx$xs$te}qirx$jsv$tivjsvqergi$gsqtpixih$xs$hexi2

=7

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 140 of 253

Page 163: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 584367<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 141 of 253

Page 164: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 585367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Wivzmgiw$tvszmhih$jsv$KIS+w$he}$vitsvxmrk$girxivw$evi$wmqmpev$xs$mxw$S{rih$erh$Piewih$Gsqqyrmx}1fewih$wivzmgiw$hmwgywwih$efszi

{mxl$xli$i|gitxmsr$sj$xiqtsvev}$lsywmrk2

Mrgsqi$Xe|iw

Xli$ gsrwspmhexih$ jmrergmep$ wxexiqirxw$ vijpigx$ tvszmwmsrw$ jsv$ jihivep0$ wxexi0$ psgep$ erh$ jsvimkr$ mrgsqi$ xe|iw2$ Xli$ Gsqter}

vigskrm~iw$hijivvih$xe|$ewwixw$erh$pmefmpmxmiw$jsv$xli$jyxyvi$xe|$gsrwiuyirgiw$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$hmjjivirgiw$fix{iir$xli$jmrergmep$wxexiqirx

gevv}mrk$eqsyrxw$sj$i|mwxmrk$ewwixw$erh$pmefmpmxmiw$erh$xlimv$viwtigxmzi$xe|$fewmw0$ew${ipp$ew$stivexmrk$psww$erh$xe|$gvihmx$gevv}jsv{evhw2

Xli$Gsqter}$qiewyviw$hijivvih$xe|$ewwixw$erh$pmefmpmxmiw$ywmrk$iregxih$xe|$vexiw$i|tigxih$xs$ettp}$xs$xe|efpi$mrgsqi$mr$xli$}ievw$mr

{lmgl$ xlswi$ xiqtsvev}$hmjjivirgiw$erh$gevv}jsv{evhw$evi$i|tigxih$ xs$fi$ vigszivih$sv$ wixxpih2$Xli$ijjigx$sr$hijivvih$ xe|$ewwixw$erh

pmefmpmxmiw$ew$e$viwypx$sj$e$glerki$mr$xe|$vexiw$mw$vigskrm~ih$ew$mrgsqi$mr$xli$tivmsh$xlex$mrgpyhiw$xli$iregxqirx$hexi2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$5;1

Mrgsqi$Xe|iw2$Ijjigxmzi$Neryev}$50$64570$ew$e$VIMX$xlex$mw$viuymvih$xs$hmwxvmfyxi$ex$piewx$=4)$sj$mxw$xe|efpi$mrgsqi$xs$wlevilsphivw0$xli

Gsqter}$hsiw$rsx$i|tigx$ xs$te}$jihivep$ mrgsqi$xe|iw$ex$ xli$VIMX$pizip$,mrgpyhmrk$mxw$uyepmjmih$VIMX$wyfwmhmevmiw-0$ew$ xli$viwypxmrk

hmzmhirhw$temh$hihygxmsr${mpp$kirivepp}$sjjwix$mxw$xe|efpi$mrgsqi2$Wmrgi$xli$Gsqter}$hsiw$rsx$i|tigx$xs$te}$xe|iw$sr$mxw$VIMX$xe|efpi

mrgsqi0$mx$hsiw$rsx$i|tigx$xs$fi$efpi$xs$vigskrm~i$wygl$hijivvih$xe|$ewwixw$erh$pmefmpmxmiw2

Hijivvih$ mrgsqi$ xe|iw$ vipexih$ xs$ xli$ XVW$ wxvygxyvi$ evi$ hixivqmrih$ fewih$ sr$ xli$ iwxmqexih$ jyxyvi$ xe|$ ijjigxw$ sj$ hmjjivirgiw

fix{iir$xli$jmrergmep$wxexiqirx$erh$xe|$fewmw$sj$ewwixw$erh$pmefmpmxmiw$kmzir$xli$tvszmwmsrw$sj$iregxih$xe|$pe{w2$Wmkrmjmgerx$nyhkqirxw

evi$ viuymvih$ xs$ hixivqmri$ xli$ gsrwspmhexih$ tvszmwmsr$ jsv$ mrgsqi$ xe|iw2$ Hijivvih$ mrgsqi$ xe|$ tvszmwmsrw$ erh$ firijmxw$ evi$ fewih$ sr

glerkiw$xs$xli$ewwixw$sv$pmefmpmxmiw$jvsq$}iev$xs$}iev2$Viepm~exmsr$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$hijivvih$xe|$ewwixw$mw$hitirhirx$ytsr$qer}$jegxsvw

wygl$ ew$ xe|$ vikypexmsrw$ ettpmgefpi$ xs$ xli$ nyvmwhmgxmsrw$ mr${lmgl$ xli$Gsqter}$ stivexiw0$ iwxmqexiw$ sj$ jyxyvi$ xe|efpi$ mrgsqi$ erh$ xli

glevegxiv$sj$wygl$xe|efpi$mrgsqi2

Xli$Y2W2$Xe|$Gyx$erh$Nsfw$Egx$,&Xe|$Egx&-${ew$iregxih$sr$Higiqfiv$660$645;$erh$mrxvshygih$wmkrmjmgerx$glerkiw$xs$Y2W2

mrgsqi$xe|$pe{2$Ijjigxmzi$Neryev}$50$645<0$xli$Xe|$Egx$vihygih$xli$Y2W2$wxexyxsv}$gsvtsvexi$xe|$vexi$sj$syv$hsqiwxmg$XVWw$jvsq$79)$xs

65)$erh$gviexih$ri{$mxiqw$sj$xe|efpi$mrgsqi$erh$xe|iw$sr$givxemr$jsvimkr$wsyvgih$ievrmrkw$erh$givxemr$vipexih1tevx}$te}qirxw0${lmgl

evi$vijivvih$xs$ew$xli$kpsfep$mrxerkmfpi$ps{1xe|ih$mrgsqi$erh$xli$fewi$ivswmsr$erh$erxm1efywi$xe|0$viwtigxmzip}2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$mr$645;$xli

Xe|$Egx$tvszmhih$jsv$e$sri1xmqi$xverwmxmsr$xe|$sr$eggyqypexih$jsvimkr$wyfwmhmev}$ievrmrkw$rsx$tvizmsywp}$wyfnigx$xs$Y2W2$mrgsqi$xe|2

[lmpi$xli$Gsqter}$lew$jsvimkr$stivexmsrw0$mx$lew$mhirxmjmih$xlex$xlivi$mw$rs$xverwmxmsr$xe|$hyi2$Eggsyrxmrk$jsv$xli$mrgsqi$xe|$ijjigxw$sj

xli$Xe|$Egx$viuymviw$wmkrmjmgerx$nyhkqirxw$erh$iwxmqexiw$mr$xli$mrxivtvixexmsr$erh$gepgypexmsrw$sj$xli$tvszmwmsrw$sj$xli$Xe|$Egx2

Hyi$xs$xli$xmqmrk$sj$xli$iregxqirx$erh$xli$gsqtpi|mx}$mrzspzih$mr$ettp}mrk$xli$tvszmwmsrw$sj$xli$Xe|$Egx0$xli$Gsqter}$qehi

viewsrefpi$iwxmqexiw$sj$xli$ijjigxw$erh$vigsvhih$tvszmwmsrep$eqsyrxw$mr$mxw$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$jsv$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645;2

Ew$xli$Gsqter}$gsppigxih$erh$tvitevih$rigiwwev}$hexe0$erh$mrxivtvixih$er}$ehhmxmsrep$kymhergi$mwwyih$f}$xli$Y2W2$Xviewyv}

Hitevxqirx0$xli$MVW$sv$sxliv$wxerhevh1wixxmrk$fshmiw0$mx$qehi$ehnywxqirxw$sziv$xli$gsyvwi$sj$xli$}iev$xs$xli$tvszmwmsrep$eqsyrxw0

mrgpyhmrk$vijmriqirxw$xs$hijivvih$xe|iw2$Xli$eggsyrxmrk$jsv$xli$xe|$ijjigxw$sj$xli$iregxqirx$sj$xli$Xe|$Egx$lew$fiir$gsqtpixih$ew$sj

Higiqfiv$750$645<2

Ehhmxmsrepp}0$xli$Gsqter}$qywx$ywi$wmkrmjmgerx$nyhkqirx$mr$ehhviwwmrk$yrgivxemrxmiw$mr$xli$ettpmgexmsr$sj$gsqtpi|$xe|$pe{w$erh

vikypexmsrw2$Mj$egxyep$gmvgyqwxergiw$hmjjiv$jvsq$xli$Gsqter}×w$ewwyqtxmsrw0$ehnywxqirxw$xs$xli$gevv}mrk$zepyi$sj$hijivvih$xe|$ewwixw$sv

pmefmpmxmiw$qe}$fi$viuymvih0${lmgl$qe}$viwypx$mr$er$ehzivwi$mqtegx$sr$xli$viwypxw$sj$mxw$stivexmsrw$erh$mxw$ijjigxmzi$xe|$vexi2$Zepyexmsr

epps{ergiw$evi$ vigsvhih$vipexih$ xs$hijivvih$ xe|$ewwixw$fewih$sr$ xli$Ôqsvi$ pmoip}$ xler$rsxÕ$gvmxivme2$Xli$Gsqter}$lew$rsx$qehi$er}

wmkrmjmgerx$glerkiw$xs$xli${e}$mx$eggsyrxw$jsv$mxw$hijivvih$xe|$ewwixw$erh$pmefmpmxmiw$mr$er}$}iev$tviwirxih$mr$xli$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep

wxexiqirxw2$Fewih$sr$mxw$iwxmqexi$sj$jyxyvi$ievrmrkw$erh$mxw$jezsvefpi$ievrmrkw$lmwxsv}0$xli$Gsqter}$gyvvirxp}$i|tigxw$jypp$viepm~exmsr$sj

xli$hijivvih$xe|$ewwixw$rix$sj$er}$vigsvhih$zepyexmsr$epps{ergiw2$Jyvxlivqsvi0$xe|$tswmxmsrw$xeoir$f}$xli$Gsqter}$qe}$rsx$fi$jypp}

wywxemrih$ ytsr$ i|eqmrexmsr$ f}$ xli$ xe|mrk$ eyxlsvmxmiw2$ Mr$ hixivqmrmrk$ xli$ ehiuyeg}$ sj$ syv$ tvszmwmsr$ ,firijmx-$ jsv$ mrgsqi$ xe|iw0

tsxirxmep$ wixxpiqirx$ syxgsqiw$ viwypxmrk$ jvsq$ mrgsqi$ xe|$ i|eqmrexmsrw$ evi$ vikypevp}$ ewwiwwih2$ Ew$ wygl0$ xli$ jmrep$ syxgsqi$ sj$ xe|

i|eqmrexmsrw0$ mrgpyhmrk$ xli$ xsxep$ eqsyrx$ te}efpi$ sv$ xli$ xmqmrk$ sj$ er}$ wygl$ te}qirxw$ ytsr$ viwspyxmsr$ sj$ xliwi$ mwwyiw0$ gerrsx$ fi

iwxmqexih${mxl$givxemrx}2

Viwivziw$jsv$Mrwyvergi$Pswwiw

Xli$rexyvi$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$fywmriww$i|tswiw$mx$xs$zevmsyw$x}tiw$sj$xlmvh1tevx}$pikep$gpemqw0$mrgpyhmrk0$fyx$rsx$pmqmxih$xs0$gmzmp

vmklxw$gpemqw$vipexmrk$xs$gsrhmxmsrw$sj$gsrjmriqirx$erh3sv$qmwxviexqirx0$wi|yep$qmwgsrhygx$gpemqw$fvsyklx$f}$mrhmzmhyepw${mxlmr$syv

gevi0$qihmgep$qeptvegxmgi$ gpemqw0$ tvshygx$ pmefmpmx}$ gpemqw0$ mrxippigxyep$ tvstivx}$ mrjvmrkiqirx$ gpemqw0$ gpemqw$ vipexmrk$ xs$ iqtps}qirx

qexxivw$,mrgpyhmrk0$fyx$rsx$pmqmxih$xs0$iqtps}qirx$hmwgvmqmrexmsr$gpemqw0$yrmsr$kvmizergiw$erh${eki$erh$lsyv$gpemqw-0$tvstivx}$psww

gpemqw0$irzmvsrqirxep$gpemqw0$eyxsqsfmpi$pmefmpmx}$gpemqw0$gsrxvegxyep$gpemqw$erh$gpemqw$jsv$tivwsrep$mrnyv}$sv$sxliv

=8

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 142 of 253

Page 165: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 586367<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 143 of 253

Page 166: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 587367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

heqekiw$viwypxmrk$jvsq$gsrxegx${mxl$syv$jegmpmxmiw0$tvskveqw0$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$tvshygxw0$tivwsrrip$sv$mrhmzmhyepw${mxlmr$syv$gevi0

mrgpyhmrk$heqekiw$evmwmrk$jvsq$er$mrqexi×w$iwgeti$sv$jvsq$e$hmwxyvfergi$sv$vmsx$ex$e$jegmpmx}2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$xli$Gsqter}×w$qerekiqirx

gsrxvegxw$kirivepp}$viuymvi$mx$xs$mrhiqrmj}$xli$kszivrqirxep$ekirg}$ekemrwx$er}$heqekiw$xs${lmgl$xli$kszivrqirxep$ekirg}$qe}$fi

wyfnigx$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$wygl$gpemqw$sv$pmxmkexmsr2$Xli$Gsqter}$qemrxemrw$e$fvseh$tvskveq$sj$mrwyvergi$gsziveki$jsv$xliwi$kirivep

x}tiw$ sj$ gpemqw0$ i|gitx$ jsv$ gpemqw$ vipexmrk$ xs$ iqtps}qirx$qexxivw0$ jsv${lmgl$ xli$Gsqter}$ gevvmiw$ rs$ mrwyvergi2$ Xlivi$ ger$ fi$ rs

ewwyvergi$xlex$xli$Gsqter}×w$mrwyvergi$gsziveki${mpp$fi$ehiuyexi$xs$gsziv$epp$gpemqw$xs${lmgl$mx$qe}$fi$i|tswih2$Mx$mw$xli$Gsqter}×w

kirivep$ tvegxmgi$ xs$ fvmrk$ qivkih$ sv$ eguymvih$ gsqtermiw$ mrxs$ mxw$ gsvtsvexi$ qewxiv$ tspmgmiw$ mr$ svhiv$ xs$ xeoi$ ehzerxeki$ sj$ givxemr

igsrsqmiw$sj$wgepi2

Xli$Gsqter}$gyvvirxp}$qemrxemrw$e$kirivep$ pmefmpmx}$tspmg}$ erh$ i|giww$ pmefmpmx}$tspmgmiw${mxl$ xsxep$ pmqmxw$sj$(<424$qmppmsr$ tiv

sggyvvirgi$erh$(544$qmppmsr$mr$xli$ekkvikexi$gszivmrk$xli$stivexmsrw$sj$Y2W2$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw0$KIS$Gevi+w$gsqqyrmx}$fewih$wivzmgiw0

KIS$Gevi+w$}syxl$wivzmgiw$erh$FM2$Xli$Gsqter}$lew$e$gpemqw1qehi$ pmefmpmx}$ mrwyvergi$tvskveq${mxl$e$wtigmjmg$ psww$ pmqmx$sj$(7924

qmppmsr$ tiv$ sggyvvirgi$ erh$ mr$ xli$ ekkvikexi$ vipexih$ xs$ qihmgep$ tvsjiwwmsrep$ pmefmpmx}$ gpemqw$ evmwmrk$ syx$ sj$ gsvvigxmsrep$ liepxlgevi

wivzmgiw2$Xli$Gsqter}$mw$yrmrwyvih$jsv$er}$gpemqw$mr$i|giww$sj$xliwi$pmqmxw2$[i$epws$qemrxemr$mrwyvergi$xs$gsziv$tvstivx}$erh$sxliv

gewyepx}$vmwow$mrgpyhmrk0${svoivw×$gsqtirwexmsr0$irzmvsrqirxep$pmefmpmx}0$g}fivwigyvmx}$pmefmpmx}$erh$eyxsqsfmpi$pmefmpmx}2

Jsv$qswx$gewyepx}$mrwyvergi$tspmgmiw0$xli$Gsqter}$gevvmiw$wyfwxerxmep$hihygxmfpiw$sv$wipj1mrwyvih$vixirxmsrw$sj$(724$qmppmsr$tiv

sggyvvirgi$ jsv$ kirivep$ pmefmpmx}$ erh$qihmgep$ tvsjiwwmsrep$ pmefmpmx}0$ (624$qmppmsr$ tiv$ sggyvvirgi$ jsv${svoivw×$ gsqtirwexmsr$ erh$ (524

qmppmsr$tiv$sggyvvirgi$jsv$eyxsqsfmpi$pmefmpmx}2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$givxemr$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$jegmpmxmiw$psgexih$mr$Jpsvmhe$erh$sxliv$lmkl1vmwo

lyvvmgeri$eview$gevv}$wyfwxerxmep${mrhwxsvq$hihygxmfpiw2$Wmrgi$lyvvmgeriw$evi$gsrwmhivih$yrtvihmgxefpi$jyxyvi$izirxw0$rs$viwivziw$lezi

fiir$iwxefpmwlih$xs$tvi1jyrh$jsv$tsxirxmep${mrhwxsvq$heqeki2$Pmqmxih$gsqqivgmep$ezempefmpmx}$sj$givxemr$x}tiw$sj$mrwyvergi$vipexmrk$xs

{mrhwxsvq$ i|tswyvi$ mr$ gsewxep$ eview$ erh$ ievxluyeoi$ i|tswyvi$ qemrp}$ mr$ Gepmjsvrme$ erh$ xli$ Tegmjmg$ Rsvxl{iwx$ qe}$ tvizirx$ xli

Gsqter}$jvsq$mrwyvmrk$wsqi$sj$mxw$jegmpmxmiw$xs$jypp$vitpegiqirx$zepyi2

[mxl$viwtigx$xs$stivexmsrw$mr$Wsyxl$Ejvmge0$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq$erh$Eywxvepme0$xli$Gsqter}$yxmpm~iw$e$gsqfmrexmsr$sj$psgepp}1

tvsgyvih$ mrwyvergi$ erh$ kpsfep$ tspmgmiw$ xs$ qiix$ gsrxvegxyep$ mrwyvergi$ viuymviqirxw$ erh$ tvsxigx$ xli$ Gsqter}2$ Mr$ ehhmxmsr$ xs$ xliwi

tspmgmiw0$xli$Gsqter}×w$Eywxvepmer$wyfwmhmev}$gevvmiw$xemp$mrwyvergi$sr$e$kirivep$pmefmpmx}$tspmg}$vipexih$xs$e$hmwgsrxmryih$gsrxvegx2

Sj$xli$mrwyvergi$tspmgmiw$hmwgywwih$efszi0$xli$Gsqter}×w$qswx$wmkrmjmgerx$mrwyvergi$viwivziw$vipexi$xs${svoivw×$gsqtirwexmsr0

kirivep$pmefmpmx}$erh$eyxs$gpemqw2$Xliwi$viwivziw$evi$yrhmwgsyrxih$erh${ivi$(:<26$qmppmsr$erh$(;42=$qmppmsr$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=

erh$645<0$viwtigxmzip}0$erh$evi$mrgpyhih$mr$Eggvyih$I|tirwiw$mr$xli$eggsqter}mrk$Gsrwspmhexih$Fepergi$Wliixw2$Xli$Gsqter}$ywiw

wxexmwxmgep$ erh$ egxyevmep$ qixlshw$ xs$ iwxmqexi$ eqsyrxw$ jsv$ gpemqw$ xlex$ lezi$ fiir$ vitsvxih$ fyx$ rsx$ temh$ erh$ gpemqw$ mrgyvvih$ fyx$ rsx

vitsvxih2$ Mr$ ettp}mrk$ xliwi$ qixlshw$ erh$ ewwiwwmrk$ xlimv$ viwypxw0$ xli$ Gsqter}$ gsrwmhivw$ wygl$ jegxsvw$ ew$ lmwxsvmgep$ jviuyirg}$ erh

wizivmx}$sj$gpemqw$ex$iegl$sj$mxw$jegmpmxmiw0$gpemq$hizipstqirx0$te}qirx$texxivrw$erh$glerkiw$mr$xli$rexyvi$sj$mxw$fywmriww0$eqsrk$sxliv

jegxsvw2$Wygl$jegxsvw$evi$erep}~ih$jsv$iegl$sj$ xli$Gsqter}×w$fywmriww$wikqirxw2$Xli$Gsqter}$iwxmqexiw$qe}$fi$ mqtegxih$f}$wygl

jegxsvw$ew$mrgviewiw$mr$xli$qevoix$tvmgi$jsv$qihmgep$wivzmgiw$erh$yrtvihmgxefmpmx}$sj$xli$wm~i$sj$nyv}$e{evhw2$Xli$Gsqter}$epws$qe}

i|tivmirgi$zevmefmpmx}$fix{iir$mxw$iwxmqexiw$erh$xli$egxyep$wixxpiqirx$hyi$xs$pmqmxexmsrw$mrlivirx$mr$xli$iwxmqexmsr$tvsgiww0$mrgpyhmrk$mxw

efmpmx}$xs$iwxmqexi$gswxw$sj$tvsgiwwmrk$erh$wixxpmrk$gpemqw$mr$e$xmqip}$qerriv$ew${ipp$ew$mxw$efmpmx}$xs$eggyvexip}$iwxmqexi$xli$Gsqter}×w

i|tswyvi$ex$xli$srwix$sj$e$gpemq2$Figeywi$xli$Gsqter}$lew$lmkl$hihygxmfpi$mrwyvergi$tspmgmiw0$xli$eqsyrx$sj$mxw$mrwyvergi$i|tirwi$mw

hitirhirx$ sr$ mxw$ efmpmx}$ xs$ gsrxvsp$ mxw$ gpemqw$ i|tivmirgi2$ Mj$ egxyep$ pswwiw$ vipexih$ xs$ mrwyvergi$ gpemqw$ wmkrmjmgerxp}$ hmjjiv$ jvsq$ xli

Gsqter}×w$iwxmqexiw0$mxw$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$erh$gewl$jps{w$gsyph$fi$qexivmepp}$ehzivwip}$mqtegxih2

Gsqtvilirwmzi$Mrgsqi$,Psww-

Gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$,psww-$vitviwirxw$xli$glerki$mr$wlevilsphivw×$iuymx}$jvsq$xverwegxmsrw$erh$sxliv$izirxw$erh$gmvgyqwxergiw

evmwmrk$jvsq$rsr1wlevilsphiv$wsyvgiw2$Xli$Gsqter}×w$xsxep$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$mw$gsqtvmwih$sj$rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS0$rix

mrgsqi$ exxvmfyxefpi$ xs$ rsrgsrxvsppmrk$ mrxiviwxw0$ jsvimkr$ gyvvirg}$ xverwpexmsr$ ehnywxqirxw$ xlex$ evmwi$ jvsq$ gsrwspmhexmrk$ jsvimkr

stivexmsrw$ xlex$ hs$ rsx$ mqtegx$ gewl$ jps{w0$ rix$ yrviepm~ih$ kemrw$ erh3$ sv$ pswwiw$ sr$ hivmzexmzi$ mrwxvyqirxw0$ erh$ tirwmsr$ pmefmpmx}

ehnywxqirxw$mr$xli$gsrwspmhexih$wxexiqirxw$sj$wlevilsphivw×$iuymx}2

Xli$ gsqtsrirxw$ sj$ eggyqypexih$ sxliv$ gsqtvilirwmzi$ psww$ exxvmfyxefpi$ xs$ KIS$ mrgpyhih$ mr$ xli$ gsrwspmhexih$ wxexiqirx$ sj

wlevilsphivw+$iuymx}$evi$ew$jspps{w$,mr$xlsywerhw->

=9

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 144 of 253

Page 167: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 588367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Jsvimkr$gyvvirg}

xverwpexmsr

ehnywxqirxw0$rix$sj

xe|$exxvmfyxefpi$xs

Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0

Mrg2$_5a

Yrviepm~ih$psww$sr

hivmzexmziw0$rix$sj

xe|$_6a

Tirwmsr$ehnywxqirxw0

rix$sj$xe| Xsxep

Fepergi0$Neryev}$50$645= ( ,5809;7- ( ,90;8:- ( ,706==- ( ,670:5<-

Gyvvirx1tivmsh$sxliv

gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$,psww-

fijsvi$vigpewwmjmgexmsrw 6069= 85= ,7068:- ,9:<-

Eqsyrxw$vigpewwmjmih$jvsq$sxliv

gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$mrxs

ievrmrkw Ó 70<95 Ó 70<95

Rix$gyvvirx1tivmsh$gsqtvilirwmzi

mrgsqi$,psww- 6069= 806;4 ,7068:- 706<7

Fepergi0$Higiqfiv$750$645= ( ,560758- ( ,508;:- ( ,:0989- ( ,640779-

$ $

Jsvimkr$gyvvirg}

xverwpexmsr

ehnywxqirxw0$rix$sj

xe|$exxvmfyxefpi$xs

Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0

Mrg2$_5a $

Yrviepm~ih$psww$sr

hivmzexmziw0$rix$sj

xe| $

Tirwmsr$ehnywxqirxw0

rix$sj$xe| $ Xsxep

Fepergi0$Neryev}$50

645< $ ( ,;08;4- $ ( ,550<=6- $ ( ,904<8- $ ( ,68088:-

Gyvvirx1tivmsh$sxliv

gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi

,psww- $ ,;0547- $ :058: $ 50;<9 $ <6<

Fepergi0$Higiqfiv$750

645< $ ( ,5809;7- $ ( ,90;8:- $ ( ,706==- $ ( ,670:5<-

_5a$Xli$jsvimkr$gyvvirg}$xverwpexmsr$ehnywxqirx0$rix$sj$xe|0$vipexih$xs$rsrgsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw${ew$rsx$wmkrmjmgerx$jsv$xli$}ievw

irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=$sv$645<2

_6a$Sr$Qe}$660$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$vijmrergih$xli$hifx$ewwsgmexih${mxl$mxw$Vezirlepp$tvsnigx$erh$xivqmrexih$xli$ewwsgmexih

mrxiviwx$vexi$w{et$hivmzexmziw${lmgl$viwypxih$mr$xli$vigpewwmjmgexmsr$sj$(72=$qmppmsr$mrxs$psww$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx$xlex

{ivi$tvizmsywp}$vitsvxih$mr$eggyqypexih$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$,psww-2$Mr$Eykywx$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$irxivih$mrxs$x{s

mhirxmgep$tvsqmwwsv}$rsxiw$mr$xli$ekkvikexi$eqsyrx$sj$(8827$qmppmsr${lmgl$evi$wigyvih$f}$pser$ekviiqirxw$erh$qsvxkeki$erh

wigyvmx}$ekviiqirxw$sr$givxemr$viep$tvstivx}$erh$mqtvsziqirxw2$Xli$Gsqter}$lew$irxivih$mrxs$mrxiviwx$vexi$w{et$ekviiqirxw

xs$jm|$xli$mrxiviwx$vexi$ex$8266)2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$<$1$Hivmzexmzi$Jmrergmep$Mrwxvyqirxw$erh$Rsxi$57$1$Hifx$jsv$ehhmxmsrep

mrjsvqexmsr2

Xlivi${ivi$rs$vigpewwmjmgexmsrw$syx$sj$eggyqypexih$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$,psww-$hyvmrk$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750

645<2

Jsvimkr$Gyvvirg}$Xverwpexmsr

Xli$Gsqter}×w$jsvimkr$stivexmsrw$ywi$xlimv$psgep$gyvvirgmiw$ew$xlimv$jyrgxmsrep$gyvvirgmiw2$Ewwixw$erh$pmefmpmxmiw$sj$xli$stivexmsrw

evi$xverwpexih$ex$xli$i|glerki$vexiw$mr$ijjigx$sr$xli$fepergi$wliix$hexi$erh$wlevilsphivw×$iuymx}$mw$xverwpexih$ex$lmwxsvmgep$vexiw2$Mrgsqi

wxexiqirx$ mxiqw$ evi$ xverwpexih$ ex$ xli$ eziveki$ i|glerki$ vexiw$ jsv$ xli$ }iev2$ Er}$ ehnywxqirx$ viwypxmrk$ jvsq$ xverwpexmrk$ xli$ jmrergmep

wxexiqirxw$ sj$ xli$ jsvimkr$ wyfwmhmev}$ mw$ vijpigxih$ ew$ sxliv$ gsqtvilirwmzi$ mrgsqi0$ rix$ sj$ vipexih$ xe|2$ Kemrw$ erh$ pswwiw$ sr$ jsvimkr

gyvvirg}$xverwegxmsrw$evi$mrgpyhih$mr$xli$wxexiqirx$sj$stivexmsrw2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 145 of 253

Page 168: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 589367<

Hivmzexmziw

Xli$Gsqter}×w$tvmqev}$sfnigxmzi$ mr$lsphmrk$hivmzexmziw$mw$ xs$vihygi$ xli$zspexmpmx}$sj$ievrmrkw$erh$gewl$jps{w$ewwsgmexih${mxl

glerkiw$mr$mrxiviwx$vexiw2$Xli$Gsqter}$qiewyviw$mxw$hivmzexmzi$jmrergmep$mrwxvyqirxw$ex$jemv$zepyi$erh$vigsvhw$hivmzexmziw$ew

=:

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 146 of 253

Page 169: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 58:367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

imxliv$ ewwixw$ sv$ pmefmpmxmiw$ sr$ xli$ fepergi$ wliix2$ Jsv$ hivmzexmziw$ xlex$ evi$ hiwmkrih$ ew$ erh$ uyepmj}$ ew$ ijjigxmzi$ gewl$ jps{$lihkiw0$ xli

tsvxmsr$sj$kemr$sv$ psww$sr$ xli$hivmzexmzi$mrwxvyqirx$ijjigxmzi$ex$sjjwixxmrk$glerkiw$mr$ xli$lihkih$ mxiq$mw$ vitsvxih$ew$e$gsqtsrirx$sj

eggyqypexih$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$erh$vigpewwmjmih$mrxs$ievrmrkw${lir$xli$lihkih$xverwegxmsr$ejjigxw$ievrmrkw2$Jsv$hivmzexmzi

mrwxvyqirxw$xlex$evi$hiwmkrexih$ew$erh$uyepmj}$ew$ijjigxmzi$jemv$zepyi$lihkiw0$xli$kemr$sv$psww$sr$xli$hivmzexmzi$mrwxvyqirxw$ew${ipp$ew$xli

sjjwixxmrk$kemr$sv$psww$sr$xli$lihkih$mxiqw$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$xli$lihkih$vmwo$mw$vigskrm~ih$mr$gyvvirx$ievrmrkw$ew$mrxiviwx$mrgsqi$,i|tirwi-

hyvmrk$ xli$tivmsh$ sj$ xli$ glerki$ mr$ jemv$ zepyiw2$ Jsv$hivmzexmzi$ mrwxvyqirxw$ xlex$ hs$ rsx$qiix$ xli$ viuymviqirxw$ jsv$ lihki$ eggsyrxmrk0

glerkiw$mr$jemv$zepyi$evi$vigsvhih$mr$ievrmrkw2

Xli$ Gsqter}$ jsvqepp}$ hsgyqirxw$ epp$ vipexmsrwlmtw$ fix{iir$ lihkmrk$ mrwxvyqirxw$ erh$ lihki$ mxiqw0$ ew$ {ipp$ ew$ mxw$ vmwo1

qerekiqirx$sfnigxmzi$erh$wxvexik}$jsv$yrhivxeomrk$zevmsyw$lihki$xverwegxmsrw2$Xlmw$tvsgiww$mrgpyhiw$exxvmfyxmrk$epp$hivmzexmziw$xlex$evi

hiwmkrexih$ew$gewl$jps{$lihkiw$xs$jpsexmrk$vexi$pmefmpmxmiw$erh$exxvmfyxmrk$epp$hivmzexmziw$xlex$evi$hiwmkrexih$ew$jemv$zepyi$lihkiw$xs$jm|ih

vexi$pmefmpmxmiw2$Xli$Gsqter}$epws$ewwiwwiw${lixliv$iegl$hivmzexmzi$ mw$lmklp}$ijjigxmzi$mr$sjjwixxmrk$glerkiw$ mr$xli$gewl$jps{w$sj$xli

lihkih$mxiq2$Jpygxyexmsrw$mr$xli$zepyi$sj$xli$hivmzexmzi$mrwxvyqirxw$evi$kirivepp}$sjjwix$f}$glerkiw$mr$xli$lihkih$mxiq?$ls{iziv0$mj$mx$mw

hixivqmrih$xlex$e$hivmzexmzi$mw$rsx$lmklp}$ijjigxmzi$ew$e$lihki$sv$mj$e$hivmzexmzi$giewiw$xs$fi$e$lmklp}$ijjigxmzi$lihki0$xli$Gsqter}${mpp

hmwgsrxmryi$lihki$eggsyrxmrk$tvswtigxmzip}$jsv$xli$ejjigxih$hivmzexmzi2

Wxsgo1Fewih$Gsqtirwexmsr$I|tirwi

Xli$Gsqter}$vigskrm~iw$xli$gswx$sj$wxsgo1fewih$gsqtirwexmsr$e{evhw$fewih$ytsr$xli$kverx$hexi$jemv$zepyi$sj$xlswi$e{evhw2$Xli

mqtegx$ sj$ jsvjimxyviw$ xlex$ qe}$ sggyv$ tvmsv$ xs$ ziwxmrk$ mw$ epws$ iwxmqexih$ erh$ gsrwmhivih$ mr$ xli$ eqsyrx$ vigskrm~ih2$ Wxsgo1fewih

gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwi$mw$vigskrm~ih$vexefp}$sziv$xli$viuymwmxi$wivzmgi$tivmsh0${lmgl$mw$x}tmgepp}$xli$ziwxmrk$tivmsh2

Xli$ jemv$ zepyi$ sj$ wxsgo1fewih$ stxmsr$ e{evhw${ew$ iwxmqexih$ ywmrk$ xli$Fpego1Wglspiw$ stxmsr1tvmgmrk$qship${mxl$ xli$ jspps{mrk

{imklxih$eziveki$ewwyqtxmsrw$jsv$stxmsrw$e{evhih$hyvmrk$}ievw$645=0$645<$erh$645;>$

$ $ 645= $ 645< $ 645;

Vmwo$jvii$mrxiviwx$vexiw $ 6288) $ 62<8) $ 5297)

I|tigxih$xivq $ 819$}ievw $ 819$}ievw $ 819$}ievw

I|tigxih$zspexmpmx} $ 85) $ 84) $ 7:)

I|tigxih$hmzmhirh$vexi $ <28;) $ <2;4) $ 92;=)

Xli$ Gsqter}$ ywiw$ lmwxsvmgep$ hexe$ xs$ iwxmqexi$ e{evh$ i|ivgmwiw$ erh$ iqtps}ii$ xivqmrexmsrw$ {mxlmr$ xli$ zepyexmsr$ qship2$ Xli

i|tigxih$xivq$sj$xli$e{evhw$vitviwirxw$xli$tivmsh$sj$xmqi$xlex$e{evhw$kverxih$evi$i|tigxih$xs$fi$syxwxerhmrk$erh$mw$fewih$sr$lmwxsvmgep

hexe$erh$i|tigxih$lsphmrk$tivmshw2

Jsv$ viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$wlevi1fewih$e{evhw$xlex$gsrxemr$e$tivjsvqergi$gsrhmxmsr0$ xli$eglmiziqirx$sj$xli$xevkixw$qywx$fi$tvsfefpi

fijsvi$ er}$ wlevi1fewih$ gsqtirwexmsr$ mw$ vigsvhih2$ Mj$ wyfwiuyirx$ xs$ xli$ mrmxmep$qiewyviqirx$ xlivi$ mw$ e$ glerki$ mr$ xli$ iwxmqexi$sj$ xli

tvsfefmpmx}$ sj$qiixmrk$ xli$ tivjsvqergi$ gsrhmxmsr0$ xli$ ijjigx$ sj$ xli$ glerki$ mr$ xli$ iwxmqexih$ uyerxmx}$ sj$ e{evhw$ i|tigxih$ xs$ ziwx$ mw

vigskrm~ih$f}$gyqypexmzip}$ehnywxmrk$gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwi2$Mj$ypxmqexip}$xli$tivjsvqergi$xevkixw$evi$rsx$qix0$jsv$er}$e{evhw${livi

ziwxmrk${ew$tvizmsywp}$hiiqih$tvsfefpi0$tvizmsywp}$vigskrm~ih$gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwi${mpp$fi$vizivwih$mr$xli$tivmsh$mr${lmgl$ziwxmrk

mw$rs$psrkiv$hiiqih$tvsfefpi2

Jsv$ viwxvmgxih$ wxsgo$ wlevi1fewih$ e{evhw$ xlex$ gsrxemr$ e$qevoix$ gsrhmxmsr0$ xli$ tvsfefmpmx}$ sj$ wexmwj}mrk$ xli$qevoix$ gsrhmxmsr$ mw

gsrwmhivih$ mr$ xli$ iwxmqexi$ sj$ kverx1hexi$ jemv$ zepyi$ erh$ tvizmsywp}$ vigsvhih$ gsqtirwexmsr$ i|tirwi$ mw$ rsx$ vizivwih$ mj$ xli$ qevoix

gsrhmxmsr$ mw$ riziv$qix2$ Xli$ jemv$ zepyi$ sj$ viwxvmgxih$ wxsgo$ e{evhw$ kverxih$ mr$ 645=0$ 645<$ erh$ 645;${mxl$qevoix1fewih$ tivjsvqergi

gsrhmxmsrw${ew$hixivqmrih$fewih$sr$e$Qsrxi$Gevps$wmqypexmsr0${lmgl$gepgypexiw$e$verki$sj$tswwmfpi$syxgsqiw$erh$xli$tvsfefmpmxmiw$xlex

xli}${mpp$sggyv0$ywmrk$xli$jspps{mrk$eziveki$oi}$ewwyqtxmsrw>

$ 645= 645< 645;

I|tigxih$zspexmpmx} 872;) 8829) 8626)

Fixe 5244 5249 5255

Vmwo$jvii$mrxiviwx$vexi 6297) 629<) 528:)

Ievrmrkw$Tiv$Wlevi

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 147 of 253

Page 170: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 58;367<

Fewmg$ ievrmrkw$ tiv$ wlevi$ mw$ gsqtyxih$ f}$ hmzmhmrk$ xli$ rix$ mrgsqi$ exxvmfyxefpi$ xs$ KIS0$ f}$ xli$ {imklxih$ eziveki$ ryqfiv$ sj

syxwxerhmrk$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo2$Xli$gepgypexmsr$sj$hmpyxih$ievrmrkw$tiv$wlevi$mw$wmqmpev$xs$xlex$sj$fewmg$ievrmrkw$tiv$wlevi0$i|gitx

xlex$ xli$hirsqmrexsv$ mrgpyhiw$ xli$hmpyxmzi$ijjigx0$ mj$er}0$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$iuymzepirxw$wygl$ew$wxsgo$stxmsrw$erh$wleviw$sj$ viwxvmgxih

wxsgo2

=;

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 148 of 253

Page 171: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 58<367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Vigirx$Eggsyrxmrk$Tvsrsyrgiqirxw

$$$$

Xli$Gsqter}$mqtpiqirxih$xli$jspps{mrk$eggsyrxmrk$wxerhevhw$hyvmrk$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=>$$$$

Mr$Sgxsfiv$645<0$xli$JEWF$mwwyih$EWY$Rs2$645<15:0$&Hivmzexmziw$erh$Lihkmrk$,Xstmg$<59-&2$Xli$tyvtswi$sj$xlmw$ythexi$mw$xs

mrgpyhi$xli$Wigyvih$Szivrmklx$Jmrergmrk$Vexi$,WSJV-$Szivrmklx$Mrhi|$W{et$Vexi$,SMW-$ew$e$firglqevo$mrxiviwx$vexi$jsv$lihki

eggsyrxmrk$tyvtswiw2$Figeywi$sj$gsrgivrw$efsyx$xli$wywxemrefmpmx}$sj$PMFSV0$xli$Jihivep$Viwivzi$Fsevh$erh$xli$Jihivep$Viwivzi$Fero

sj$Ri{$]svo$mrmxmexih$er$ijjsvx$xs$mrxvshygi$er$epxivrexmzi$vijivirgi$vexi$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw2$Xli$ri{$wxerhevh$figeqi$ijjigxmzi$jsv

xli$Gsqter}$fikmrrmrk$Neryev}$50$645=2$Xli$ehstxmsr$sj$xlmw$wxerhevh$hmh$rsx$lezi$e$qexivmep$mqtegx$sr$xli$Gsqter}+w$jmrergmep

tswmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$sv$gewl$jps{w2

$$$$

Mr$Nyri$645<0$xli$JEWF$mwwyih$EWY$Rs2$645<14;0$&Gsqtirwexmsr$1$Wxsgo$Gsqtirwexmsr$,Xstmg$;5<-0$Mqtvsziqirxw$xs

Rsriqtps}ii$Wlevi1Fewih$Te}qirx$Eggsyrxmrk&$ew$e$tevx$sj$mxw$Wmqtpmjmgexmsr$Mrmxmexmzi2$Xli$eqirhqirxw$mr$xlmw$ythexi$i|terh$xli

wgsti$sj$Xstmg$;5<$xs$mrgpyhi$wlevi1fewih$te}qirx$xverwegxmsrw$jsv$eguymvmrk$ksshw$erh$wivzmgiw$jvsq$rsriqtps}iiw2$Er$irxmx}$wlsyph

ettp}$xli$viuymviqirxw$sj$Xstmg$;5<$xs$rsriqtps}ii$e{evhw$i|gitx$jsv$wtigmjmg$kymhergi$sr$mrtyxw$xs$er$stxmsr$tvmgmrk$qship$erh$xli

tivmsh$sj$xmqi$sziv${lmgl$wlevi1fewih$te}qirx$e{evhw$ziwx$erh$xli$texxivr$sj$gswx$vigskrmxmsr$sziv$xlex$tivmsh2$Xli$eqirhqirxw

wtigmj}$xlex$Xstmg$;5<$ettpmiw$xs$epp$wlevi1fewih$te}qirx$xverwegxmsrw$mr${lmgl$e$kverxsv$eguymviw$ksshw$sv$wivzmgiw$xs$fi$ywih$sv

gsrwyqih$mr$e$kverxsv+w$s{r$stivexmsrw$f}$mwwymrk$wlevi1fewih$te}qirx$e{evhw2$Xli$eqirhqirxw$epws$gpevmj}$xlex$Xstmg$;5<$hsiw$rsx

ettp}$xs$wlevi1fewih$te}qirxw$ywih$xs$ijjigxmzip}$tvszmhi$,5-$jmrergmrk$xs$xli$mwwyiv$sv$,6-$e{evhw$kverxih$mr$gsrnyrgxmsr${mxl$wippmrk

ksshw$sv$wivzmgiw$xs$gywxsqivw$ew$tevx$sj$e$gsrxvegx$eggsyrxih$jsv$yrhiv$Xstmg$:4:0&Viziryi$jvsq$Gsrxvegxw${mxl$Gywxsqivw2&$Xli$ri{

wxerhevh$figeqi$ijjigxmzi$jsv$xli$Gsqter}$fikmrrmrk$Neryev}$50$645=2$Xli$ehstxmsr$sj$xlmw$wxerhevh$hmh$rsx$lezi$e$qexivmep$mqtegx$sr

xli$Gsqter}+w$jmrergmep$tswmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$sv$gewl$jps{w2

$$$$

Mr$Jifvyev}$645<0$xli$JEWF$mwwyih$EWY$Rs2$645<1460$&Mrgsqi$Wxexiqirx1Vitsvxmrk$Gsqtvilirwmzi$Mrgsqi1Vigpewwmjmgexmsr

sj$Givxemr$Xe|$Ijjigxw$jvsq$Eggyqypexih$Sxliv$Gsqtvilirwmzi$Mrgsqi&2$Xli$eqirhqirxw$mr$xlmw$ythexi$epps{$er$irxmx}$xs$ipigx$xs

vigpewwmj}$xli$mrgsqi$xe|$ijjigxw$viwypxmrk$jvsq$xli$Xe|$Gyxw$erh$Nsfw$Egx$sr$mxiqw${mxlmr$eggyqypexih$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi

,&ESGM&-$xs$vixemrih$ievrmrkw2$Xli$ri{$wxerhevh$mw$ijjigxmzi$jsv$epp$irxmxmiw$jsv$jmwgep$}ievw$fikmrrmrk$ejxiv$Higiqfiv$590$645<0$erh

mrxivmq$tivmshw${mxlmr$xlswi$jmwgep$}ievw2$Ievp}$ehstxmsr${ew$tivqmxxih2$Xli$Gsqter}$ehstxih$xli$ri{$wxerhevh$ijjigxmzi$Neryev}$50

645=$erh$lew$qehi$e$tspmg}$ipigxmsr$xs$vigpewwmj}$xli$mrgsqi$xe|$ijjigxw$viwypxmrk$jvsq$xli$Xe|$Gyxw$erh$Nsfw$Egx$sr$mxiqw${mxlmr

ESGM$xs$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$mr$i|giww$sj$ievrmrkw$sr$e$tvswtigxmzi$fewmw2$Ew$e$viwypx0$xli$Gsqter}$vigpewwmjmih$(42;$qmppmsr$jsv$xli$xe|$ijjigx

sj$xli$xe|$vexi$vihygxmsr$vipexih$xs$mxw$tirwmsr$pmefmpmx}$erh$(52;$qmppmsr$jsv$xli$xe|$ijjigx$sj$sxliv$mrgsqi$xe|$ijjigxw$sj$xe|$vijsvq$sr

mxiqw$viqemrmrk$mr$ESGM$vipexih$xs$gyvvirg}$xverwpexmsr$ehnywxqirxw$xs$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$mr$i|giww$sj$ievrmrkw$sr$Neryev}$50$645=2$Xli$rix

ijjigx$sj$fsxl$ehnywxqirxw$viwypxih$mr$er$ekkvikexi$mrgviewi$xs$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$mr$i|giww$sj$ievrmrkw$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(524$qmppmsr2

Mr$Eykywx$645;0$xli$JEWF$mwwyih$EWY$Rs2$645;1560$&Hivmzexmziw$erh$Lihkmrk$1$Xevkixih$Mqtvsziqirxw$xs$Eggsyrxmrk$jsv

Lihkmrk$Egxmzmxmiw2&$Xli$sfnigxmzi$sj$xlmw$kymhergi$mw$xs$mqtvszi$xli$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$sj$lihkmrk$vipexmsrwlmtw$xs$fixxiv$tsvxve}$xli

igsrsqmg$viwypxw$sj$er$irxmx}+w$vmwo$qerekiqirx$egxmzmxmiw$mr$mxw$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw2$Givxemr$sj$xli$eqirhqirxw$mr$xlmw$ythexi$ew$xli}

vipexi$xs$gewl$jps{$lihkiw0$ipmqmrexi$xli$viuymviqirx$xs$witevexip}$vigsvh$lihki$mrijjigxmziriww$gyvvirxp}$mr$ievrmrkw2$Mrwxieh0$xli

irxmvi$glerki$mr$xli$jemv$zepyi$sj$xli$lihkmrk$mrwxvyqirx$mw$vigsvhih$mr$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi2$Xlswi$eqsyrxw$evi$vigpewwmjmih$xs

ievrmrkw$mr$xli$weqi$mrgsqi$wxexiqirx$pmri$mxiq$xlex$mw$ywih$xs$tviwirx$xli$ievrmrkw$ijjigx$sj$xli$lihkih$mxiq${lir$xli$lihkih$mxiq

ejjigxw$ievrmrkw2$Xli$ri{$wxerhevh$figeqi$ijjigxmzi$jsv$xli$Gsqter}$fikmrrmrk$Neryev}$50$645=2$Xli$ehstxmsr$sj$xlmw$wxerhevh$hmh$rsx

lezi$e$qexivmep$mqtegx$sr$xli$Gsqter}+w$jmrergmep$tswmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$sv$gewl$jps{w2

Mr$Jifvyev}$645:0$xli$JEWF$mwwyih$EWY$645:1460$&Piewiw0&${lmgl$viuymviw$irxmxmiw$xs$vigskrm~i$piewi$ewwixw$erh$piewi

pmefmpmxmiw$sr$xli$fepergi$wliix$erh$xs$hmwgpswi$oi}$mrjsvqexmsr$efsyx$piewmrk$evverkiqirxw2$Jsv$jmrergi$piewiw$erh$stivexmrk$piewiw0$e

piwwii$wlsyph$vigskrm~i$mr$xli$wxexiqirx$sj$jmrergmep$tswmxmsr$e$pmefmpmx}$xs$qeoi$piewi$te}qirxw$,xli$piewi$pmefmpmx}-$erh$e$vmklx1sj1ywi

ewwix$vitviwirxmrk$mxw$vmklx$xs$ywi$xli$yrhivp}mrk$ewwix$jsv$xli$piewi$xivq${mxl$iegl$mrmxmepp}$qiewyvih$ex$xli$tviwirx$zepyi$sj$xli$piewi

te}qirxw2$Xli$eqirhqirxw$mr$EWY$645:146$figeqi$ijjigxmzi$jsv$xli$Gsqter}$sr$Neryev}$50$645=2$Xli$Gsqter}$ipigxih$xli$tegoeki

sj$xverwmxmsr$i|tihmirxw$ezempefpi$jsv$i|tmvih$sv$i|mwxmrk$piewi$gsrxvegxw0${lmgl$epps{ih$mx$xs$gevv}$jsv{evh$mxw$lmwxsvmgep$ewwiwwqirxw$sj

,5-${lixliv$gsrxvegxw$evi$sv$gsrxemr$piewiw0$,6-$piewi$gpewwmjmgexmsr$erh$,7-$mrmxmep$hmvigx$gswxw2$Xli$Gsqter}$epws$ipigxih$rsx$xs$ettp}

xli$vigskrmxmsr$viuymviqirxw$xs$piewi$evverkiqirxw$xlex$lezi$xivqw$sj$x{ipzi$qsrxlw$sv$piww2$Xli$ehstxmsr$leh$e$qexivmep$mqtegx$mr$xli

Gsqter}+w$gsrwspmhexih$fepergi$wliixw0$fyx$hmh$rsx$lezi$er

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 149 of 253

Page 172: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 58=367<

=<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 150 of 253

Page 173: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 594367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

mqtegx$sr$mxw$gsrwspmhexih$wxexiqirxw$sj$stivexmsrw$sv$gewl$jps{w2$Xli$qswx$wmkrmjmgerx$mqtegx${ew$xli$vigskrmxmsr$sj$vmklx1sj1ywi

ewwixw$erh$piewi$pmefmpmxmiw$jsv$stivexmrk$piewiw0${lmpi$syv$eggsyrxmrk$jsv$jmrergi$piewiw$viqemrih$wyfwxerxmepp}$yrglerkih2$Xli$ri{

wxerhevh$viwypxih$mr$xli$vigsvhmrk$sj$stivexmrk$vmklx1sj1ywi$piewi$ewwixw$erh$stivexmrk$piewi$pmefmpmxmiw$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(584$qmppmsr

erh$(58;$qmppmsr0$viwtigxmzip}0$ew$sj$Neryev}$50$645=2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$58$1$Piewiw$jsv$jyvxliv$hmwgywwmsr$erh$ehhmxmsrep$viuymvih

hmwgpswyviw2

$$$$

Xli$jspps{mrk$eggsyrxmrk$wxerhevhw${mpp$fi$ehstxih$mr$jyxyvi$tivmshw>

$$$$$$$$

Mr$Eykywx$645<0$xli$JEWF$mwwyih$EWY$Rs2$645<1580$&Gsqtirwexmsr1Vixmviqirx$Firijmxw1Hijmrih$Firijmx$Tperw1Kirivep

,Xstmg$;59264-&$ew$e$tevx$sj$mxw$hmwgpswyvi$jveqi{svo$tvsnigx2$Xli$eqirhqirxw$mr$xlmw$ythexi$viqszi0$qshmj}$erh$ehh$givxemr

hmwgpswyviw$tvmqevmp}$vipexih$xs$eqsyrxw$mr$eggyqypexih$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$i|tigxih$xs$fi$vigskrm~ih$ew$gsqtsrirxw$sj$rix

tivmshmg$firijmx$gswx$sziv$xli$ri|x$jmwgep$}iev0$i|tperexmsrw$jsv$viewsrw$jsv$wmkrmjmgerx$kemrw$erh$pswwiw$vipexih$xs$glerkiw$mr$xli$firijmx

sfpmkexmsr$jsv$xli$tivmsh0$erh$tvsnigxih$erh$eggyqypexih$firijmx$sfpmkexmsrw2$Xli$ri{$wxerhevh$mw$ijjigxmzi$jsv$xli$Gsqter}$fikmrrmrk

Neryev}$50$64652$Xli$ehstxmsr$sj$xlmw$wxerhevh$mw$rsx$i|tigxih$xs$lezi$e$qexivmep$mqtegx$sr$xli$Gsqter}+w$jmrergmep$tswmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj

stivexmsrw$sv$gewl$jps{w2

Mr$Eykywx$645<0$xli$JEWF$mwwyih$EWY$Rs2$645<1570$&Jemv$Zepyi$Qiewyviqirx$,Xstmg$<64-&$ew$e$tevx$sj$mxw$hmwgpswyvi

jveqi{svo$tvsnigx2$Xli$eqirhqirxw$mr$xlmw$ythexi$viqszi0$qshmj}$erh$ehh$givxemr$hmwgpswyviw$tvmqevmp}$vipexih$xs$xverwjivw$fix{iir

Pizip$5$erh$Pizip$6$sj$xli$jemv$zepyi$lmivevgl}0$zevmsyw$hmwgpswyviw$vipexih$xs$Pizip$7$jemv$zepyi$qiewyviqirxw$erh$mrziwxqirxw$mr

givxemr$irxmxmiw$xlex$gepgypexi$rix$ewwix$zepyi2$Xli$ri{$wxerhevh${ew$ijjigxmzi$jsv$xli$Gsqter}$fikmrrmrk$Neryev}$50$64642$Xli

ehstxmsr$sj$xlmw$wxerhevh$mw$rsx$i|tigxih$xs$lezi$e$qexivmep$mqtegx$sr$xli$Gsqter}+w$jmrergmep$tswmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$sv$gewl

jps{w2

Mr$Nyri$645:0$xli$JEWF$mwwyih$EWG$Rs2$645:1570$&Jmrergmep$Mrwxvyqirxw$Ò$Gvihmx$Pswwiw$,Xstmg$76:->$Qiewyviqirx$sj$Gvihmx

Pswwiw$sr$Jmrergmep$Mrwxvyqirxw&2$Xli$tyvtswi$sj$Ythexi$Rs2$645:157$mw$xs$vitpegi$xli$gyvvirx$mrgyvvih$psww$mqtemvqirx$qixlshspsk}

jsv$jmrergmep$ewwixw$qiewyvih$ex$eqsvxm~ih$gswx${mxl$e$qixlshspsk}$xlex$vijpigxw$i|tigxih$gvihmx$pswwiw$erh$viuymviw$gsrwmhivexmsr$sj$e

fvsehiv$verki$sj$viewsrefpi$erh$wyttsvxefpi$mrjsvqexmsr0$mrgpyhmrk$jsvigewxih$mrjsvqexmsr0$xs$hizipst$gvihmx$psww$iwxmqexiw2$Ythexi

Rs2$645:157${ew$ijjigxmzi$jsv$erryep$tivmshw$fikmrrmrk$ejxiv$Higiqfiv$590$645=0$mrgpyhmrk$mrxivmq$tivmshw${mxlmr$xlswi$erryep

tivmshw2$Ievp}$ehstxmsr$mw$tivqmxxih$jsv$erryep$tivmshw$fikmrrmrk$ejxiv$Higiqfiv$590$645<2$Xli$Gsqter}$lew$gsqtpixih$mxw$tvsgiww$sj

hixivqmrmrk$xli$ijjigx$xlex$xli$ehstxmsr${mpp$lezi$sr$mxw$jmrergmep$tswmxmsr$erh$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$erh$xli$Gsqter}$hsiw$rsx$i|tigx

xli$ri{$wxerhevh${mpp$lezi$e$qexivmep$mqtegx$sr$mxw$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw2

Sxliv$ vigirx$ eggsyrxmrk$ tvsrsyrgiqirxw$ mwwyih$ f}$ xli$ JEWF$ ,mrgpyhmrk$ mxw$ Iqivkmrk$ Mwwyiw$ Xewo$ Jsvgi-0$ xli$ Eqivmger

Mrwxmxyxi$sj$Givxmjmih$Tyfpmg$Eggsyrxerxw$erh$xli$WIG$hmh$rsx0$sv$evi$rsx$i|tigxih$xs0$lezi$e$qexivmep$ijjigx$sr$xli$Gsqter}+w$viwypxw$sj

stivexmsrw$sv$jmrergmep$tswmxmsr2

62 Fywmriww$Gsqfmrexmsrw

Gsqqyrmx}$Ihygexmsr$Girxivw$Eguymwmxmsr

Sr$Etvmp$90$645;0$xli$Gsqter}$gsqtpixih$mxw$eguymwmxmsr$sj$GIG0$tyvwyerx$xs$e$hijmrmxmzi$qivkiv$ekviiqirx$irxivih$mrxs$sr$Jifvyev}

560$645;$fix{iir$xli$Gsqter}0$KIS3HI3QG345$PPG0$erh$GIG$Tevirx$Lsphmrkw$PPG2$GIG$mw$e$tvmzexi$tvszmhiv$sj$vilefmpmxexmsr

wivzmgiw$jsv$sjjirhivw$mr$viirxv}$erh$mr1tvmwsr$xviexqirx$jegmpmxmiw$ew${ipp$ew$qerekiqirx$wivzmgiw$jsv$gsyrx}0$wxexi$erh$jihivep

gsvvigxmsrep$erh$hixirxmsr$jegmpmxmiw2$Yrhiv$xli$xivqw$sj$xli$qivkiv$ekviiqirx0$xli$Gsqter}$eguymvih$544)$sj$xli$zsxmrk$mrxiviwxw$mr

GIG$jsv$(7972:$qmppmsr2

Xli$eppsgexmsr$sj$xli$tyvglewi$tvmgi$jsv$xlmw$xverwegxmsr${ew$gsqtpixi$ew$sj$Qevgl$750$645<2$Hyvmrk$xli$qiewyviqirx$tivmsh0$xli

Gsqter}$ehnywxih$tvszmwmsrep$eqsyrxw${mxl$viwtigx$xs$xli$GIG$eguymwmxmsr$xlex${ivi$vigskrm~ih$ex$xli$eguymwmxmsr$hexi$xs$vijpigx$ri{

mrjsvqexmsr$sfxemrih$efsyx$jegxw$erh$gmvgyqwxergiw$xlex$i|mwxih$ew$sj$xli$eguymwmxmsr$hexi$xlex0$mj$ors{r0${syph$lezi$ejjigxih$xli

qiewyviqirx$sj$xli$eqsyrxw$vigskrm~ih$ew$sj$xlex$hexi2$Xlswi$glerkiw$evi$vijpigxih$mr$xli$xefpi$fips{2$Xli$tyvglewi$tvmgi$eppsgexmsr

ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645;$erh$ew$sj$Qevgl$750$645<$erh$ehnywxqirxw$qehi$xs$xli$iwxmqexih$eguymwmxmsr$hexi$jemv$zepyiw$hyvmrk$xli$jmwgep

}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645<$evi$ew$jspps{w$,mr$xlsywerhw->

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 151 of 253

Page 174: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 595367<

==

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 152 of 253

Page 175: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 596367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

Eguymwmxmsr$Hexi

Iwxmqexih$Jemv$Zepyi

ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750

645; $

Qiewyviqirx

Tivmsh

Ehnywxqirxw $

Jmrep$Eguymwmxmsr

Hexi$Jemv$Zepyi$ew$sj

Qevgl$750$645<

Eggsyrxw$Vigimzefpi ( 760<:= $ ( Ó $ ( 760<:=

Tvitemh$erh$sxliv$gyvvirx$ewwixw 807=; $ Ó $ 807=;

Tvstivx}$erh$iuymtqirx 56:0954 $ Ó $ 56:0954

Mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw ;:0444 $ Ó $ ;:0444

Jezsvefpi$piewi$ewwixw 70554 $ Ó $ 70554

Hijivvih$mrgsqi$xe|$ewwixw 8055: $ 88 $ 805:4

Sxliv$rsr1gyvvirx$ewwixw 8076; $ Ó $ 8076;

$$Xsxep$ewwixw$eguymvih ( 695076= $ ( 88 $ ( 69507;7

Eggsyrxw$te}efpi$erh$eggvyih$i|tirwiw 950:95 $ ,5077=- $ 940756

Yrjezsvefpi$piewi$pmefmpmxmiw 506== $ Ó $ 506==

Sxliv$rsr1gyvvirx$pmefmpmxmiw 5408;= $ ,505::- $ =0757

$$Xsxep$pmefmpmxmiw$ewwyqih ( :7086= $ ( ,60949- $ ( :40=68

$$Xsxep$mhirxmjmefpi$rix$ewwixw 5<;0=44 $ 6098= $ 5=4088=

Kssh{mpp 5:90:9: $ ,6098=- $ 5:7054;

Xsxep$gsrwmhivexmsr$temh0$rix$sj$gewl

eguymvih ( 797099: $ ( Ó $ ( 797099:

Xli$Gsqter}$vigskrm~ih$e$vihygxmsr$sj$stivexmrk$i|tirwiw$sj$(627$qmppmsr$vipexih$xs$xli$GIG$eguymwmxmsr$hyvmrk$xli

x{ipzi$qsrxlw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645<$ew$e$viwypx$sj$e$vigsziv}$sj$jyrhw$liph$mr$iwgvs{$ejxiv$xli$qiewyviqirx$tivmsh$leh

irhih2

Ew$wls{r$efszi0$xli$Gsqter}$vigsvhih$(5:725$qmppmsr$sj$kssh{mpp$vipexih$xs$xli$tyvglewi$sj$GIG2$Xli$wxvexikmg$firijmxw$sj

xli$qivkiv$mrgpyhi$xli$Gsqter}+w$efmpmx}$xs$jyvxliv$tswmxmsr$mxwipj$xs$qiix$xli$hiqerh$jsv$mrgviewmrkp}$hmzivwmjmih$gsvvigxmsrep0

hixirxmsr$erh$gsqqyrmx}$viirxv}$jegmpmxmiw$erh$wivzmgiw$erh$xli$Gsqter}+w$efmpmx}$xs$i|terh$xli$hipmziv}$sj$irlergih$mr1

tvmwsr$vilefmpmxexmsr$mrgpyhmrk$izmhirgi1fewih$xviexqirx0$mrxikvexih${mxl$tswx1vipiewi$wyttsvx$wivzmgiw$xlvsykl$KIS+w

Gsrxmryyq$sj$Gevi$tpexjsvq2$Xliwi$jegxsvw$gsrxvmfyxih$xs$xli$kssh{mpp$xlex${ew$vigsvhih$ytsr$gsrwyqqexmsr$sj$xli

xverwegxmsr2$Xli$Gsqter}$hsiw$rsx$fipmizi$xlex$er}$sj$xli$kssh{mpp$vigsvhih$ew$e$viwypx$sj$xli$GIG$eguymwmxmsr${mpp$fi

hihygxmfpi$jsv$jihivep$mrgsqi$xe|$tyvtswiw2

Mhirxmjmefpi$mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw$tyvglewih$mr$xli$eguymwmxmsr$erh$xlimv${imklxih$eziveki$eqsvxm~exmsr

tivmshw$mr$xsxep$erh$f}$qensv$mrxerkmfpi$ewwix$gpeww0$ew$ettpmgefpi0$evi$mrgpyhih$mr$xli$xefpi$fips{>

$[imklxih$EzivekiYwijyp$Pmji$,}ievw- $ Jemv$Zepyi$ew$sj$Etvmp$90$645;

Jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw 5< $ ( ;90744

Gszirerxw$rsx$xs$gsqtixi 5 $ ;44

Xsxep$eguymvih$mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw $ $ ( ;:0444

Tvs$jsvqe$jmrergmep$mrjsvqexmsr$,Yreyhmxih-

Xli$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$sj$GIG$evi$mrgpyhih$mr$xli$Gsqter}+w$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$jvsq$Etvmp$90$645;2$Xli$jspps{mrk

yreyhmxih$tvs$jsvqe$mrjsvqexmsr$gsqfmriw$xli$gsrwspmhexih$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$sj$xli$Gsqter}$erh$GIG$ew$mj$xli

eguymwmxmsr$leh$sggyvvih$ex$Neryev}$50$645;0${lmgl$mw$xli$fikmrrmrk$sj$xli$ievpmiwx$tivmsh$tviwirxih2$Xli$tvs$jsvqe$eqsyrxw$evi

mrgpyhih$jsv$gsqtevexmzi$tyvtswiw$erh$qe}$rsx$rigiwwevmp}$vijpigx$xli$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$xlex${syph$lezi$viwypxih$leh$xli

eguymwmxmsr$fiir$gsqtpixih$ex$xli$fikmrrmrk$sj$xli$ettpmgefpi$tivmsh$erh$qe}$rsx$fi$mrhmgexmzi$sj$xli$viwypxw$xlex${mpp$fi

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 153 of 253

Page 176: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 597367<

544

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 154 of 253

Page 177: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 598367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

exxemrih$mr$xli$jyxyvi$,mr$xlsywerhw->

$]iev$Irhih,yreyhmxih-

$Higiqfiv$750

645; $

Tvs$jsvqe$viziryiw ( 607440444 $

Tvs$jsvqe$rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$xli$KIS

Kvsyt0$Mrg2 ( 5:40444 $

Xli$yreyhmxih$tvs$jsvqe$gsqfmrih$jmrergmep$mrjsvqexmsr$tviwirxih$efszi$mw$gsqtmpih$jvsq$xli$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$sj$xli

gsqfmrih$gsqtermiw$erh$mrgpyhiw$tvs$jsvqe$ehnywxqirxw$jsv>$,m-$iwxmqexih$glerkiw$mr$hitvigmexmsr$i|tirwi0$mrxiviwx$i|tirwi$erh

eqsvxm~exmsr$i|tirwi?$,mm-$ehnywxqirxw$xs$ipmqmrexi$mrxivgsqter}$xverwegxmsrw?$,mmm-$ehnywxqirxw$xs$viqszi$ettvs|mqexip}$(59$qmppmsr0

jsv$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645;0$viwtigxmzip}0$sj$rsr1vigyvvmrk$xverwegxmsr$erh$qivkiv$vipexih$gswxw$hmvigxp}$vipexih$xs$xli$GIG

eguymwmxmsr$xlex$evi$mrgpyhih$mr$xli$gsqfmrih$gsqtermiw×$jmrergmep$viwypxw?$erh$,mz-$xli$mrgsqi$xe|$mqtegx$sj$xli$ehnywxqirxw2$Xli

yreyhmxih$tvs$jsvqe$jmrergmep$mrjsvqexmsr$hsiw$rsx$mrgpyhi$er}$ehnywxqirxw$xs$vijpigx$xli$mqtegx$sj$gswx$wezmrkw$sv$sxliv$w}rivkmiw$xlex

qe}$viwypx$jvsq$xlmw$eguymwmxmsr2$Ew$rsxih$efszi0$xli$yreyhmxih$tvs$jsvqe$jmrergmep$mrjsvqexmsr$hsiw$rsx$tyvtsvx$xs$fi$mrhmgexmzi$sj$xli

egxyep$viwypxw$xlex${syph$lezi$fiir$eglmizih$f}$xli$gsqfmrih$gsqtermiw$jsv$xli$tivmshw$tviwirxih$sv$xlex$qe}$fi$eglmizih$f}$xli

gsqfmrih$gsqtermiw$mr$xli$jyxyvi2

Xli$Gsqter}$lew$mrgpyhih$viziryi$erh$ievrmrkw$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(5;5$qmppmsr$erh$(66$qmppmsr0$viwtigxmzip}0$mr$mxw

gsrwspmhexih$wxexiqirxw$sj$stivexmsrw$jsv$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645;$jsv$GIG$egxmzmx}$wmrgi$Etvmp$90$645;0$xli

hexi$sj$eguymwmxmsr2

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$

72 Wlevilsphivw×$Iuymx}

Gsqqsr$Wxsgo

Iegl$lsphiv$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$gsqqsr$wxsgo$mw$irxmxpih$xs$sri$zsxi$tiv$wlevi$sr$epp$qexxivw$xs$fi$zsxih$ytsr$f}$xli$Gsqter}×w

wlevilsphivw2$Ytsr$ er}$ pmuymhexmsr0$ hmwwspyxmsr$ sv${mrhmrk$ yt$ sj$ xli$Gsqter}0$ xli$ lsphivw$ sj$ gsqqsr$ wxsgo$ evi$ irxmxpih$ xs$ wlevi

iuyepp}$mr$epp$ewwixw$ezempefpi$jsv$hmwxvmfyxmsr$ejxiv$te}qirx$sj$epp$pmefmpmxmiw0$wyfnigx$xs$xli$pmuymhexmsr$tvijivirgi$sj$wleviw$sj$tvijivvih

wxsgo0$mj$er}0$xlir$syxwxerhmrk2

Hmwxvmfyxmsrw

Ew$e$VIMX0$KIS$mw$viuymvih$ xs$hmwxvmfyxi$erryepp}$ex$ piewx$=4)$sj$ mxw$VIMX$xe|efpi$ mrgsqi$,hixivqmrih${mxlsyx$ vikevh$ xs$ xli

hmzmhirhw$temh$hihygxmsr$erh$f}$i|gpyhmrk$rix$getmxep$kemr-$erh$fiker$te}mrk$vikypev$uyevxivp}$VIMX$hmzmhirhw$mr$64572$Xli$eqsyrx0

xmqmrk$erh$jviuyirg}$sj$jyxyvi$hmzmhirhw0$ls{iziv0${mpp$fi$ex$xli$wspi$hmwgvixmsr$sj$KIS+w$Fsevh$sj$Hmvigxsvw$,xli$&FsevhÕ-$erh${mpp$fi

higpevih$fewih$ytsr$zevmsyw$ jegxsvw0$qer}$sj${lmgl$evi$fi}srh$KIS+w$ gsrxvsp0$ mrgpyhmrk0$KIS+w$ jmrergmep$ gsrhmxmsr$ erh$stivexmrk

gewl$jps{w0$xli$eqsyrx$viuymvih$xs$qemrxemr$VIMX$wxexyw$erh$vihygi$er}$mrgsqi$xe|iw$xlex$KIS$sxliv{mwi${syph$fi$viuymvih$xs$te}0

pmqmxexmsrw$sr$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$mr$KIS+w$i|mwxmrk$erh$jyxyvi$hifx$mrwxvyqirxw0$pmqmxexmsrw$sr$KIS+w$efmpmx}$xs$jyrh$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$ywmrk$gewl

kirivexih$xlvsykl$KIS+w$XVWw$erh$sxliv$jegxsvw$xlex$KIS+w$Fsevh$qe}$hiiq$vipizerx2

545

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 155 of 253

Page 178: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 599367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Hyvmrk$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$645<$erh$645;0$KIS$higpevih$erh$temh$xli$jspps{mrk$vikypev$gewl$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$xs$mxw

wxsgolsphivw${lmgl${ivi$xviexih$jsv$jihivep$mrgsqi$xe|iw$ew$jspps{w$,vixvsegxmzip}$ehnywxih$xs$vijpigx$xli$ijjigxw$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$71

jsv16$wxsgo$wtpmx->

Svhmrev}$Hmzmhirhw

HigpevexmsrHexi Te}qirx$Hexi Vigsvh$Hexi

HmwxvmfyxmsrTiv$Wlevi Uyepmjmih$,5-

Rsr1Uyepmjmih

RsrhmzmhirhHmwxvmfyxmsrw$,6-

EkkvikexiTe}qirxEqsyrx,qmppmsrw-

Jifvyev}$:0645; $ Jifvyev}$6;0$645; $

Jifvyev}$5;0645; $ 428; $ ( 4245;9:66 $ ( 4268:<846 $ ( 426469=;9 ( 9629

Etvmp$690645; $ Qe}$5=0$645; $ Qe}$=0$645; $ ( 428; $ ( 4245;:;95 $ ( 4268<869= $ ( 42647<==4 ( 9<28

Nyp}$540645; $ Nyp}$6<0$645; $

Nyp}$650645; $ 428; $ ( 4245;:;95 $ ( 4268<869= $ ( 42647<==4 ( 9<27

Sgxsfiv$560645; Sgxsfiv$740$645;

Sgxsfiv$670645; $ ( 428; $ ( 4245;:;95 $ ( 4268<869= $ ( 42647<==4 ( 9<27

Jifvyev}$90645< $ Jifvyev}$6;0$645< $

Jifvyev}$5:0645< $ ( 428; $ ( 4248:55;5 $ ( 4264=4664 $ ( 42658<:4= ( 9<27

Etvmp$550645< $ Qe}$70$645< $

Etvmp$670645< $ ( 428; $ ( 4248:55;5 $ ( 4264=4664 $ ( 42658<:4= ( 9;28

Nyp}$540645< $ Nyp}$6;0$645< $

Nyp}$640645< $ ( 428; $ ( 4248:55;5 $ ( 4264=4664 $ ( 42658<:4= ( 9;26

Sgxsfiv$590645< $ Rsziqfiv$60$645< $

Sgxsfiv$6:0645< $ ( 428; $ ( 4248:55;5 $ ( 4264=4664 $ ( 42658<:4= ( 9;26

Jifvyev}$80645= $ Jifvyev}$660$645= $

Jifvyev}$590645= $ ( 428< $ ( Ó $ ( 426;9=:== $ ( 426484745 ( 9;2=

Etvmp$70645= $ Etvmp$660$645= $

Etvmp$590645= $ ( 428< $ ( Ó $ ( 426;9=:== $ ( 426484745 ( 9<26

Nyp}$=0$645= $ Nyp}$6:0$645= $Nyp}$5=0

645= $ ( 428< $ ( Ó $ ( 426;9=:== $ ( 426484745 ( 9<26

Sgxsfiv$580645= $ Rsziqfiv$50$645= $

Sgxsfiv$690645= $ ( 428< $ ( Ó $ ( 426;9=:== $ ( 426484745 ( 9<26

,5-$ Jsv$ 645=0$ xlivi$ evi$ rs$ Uyepmjmih$ Hmzmhirhw2$ Uyepmjmih$ Hmzmhirhw$ vitviwirxw$ xli$ tsvxmsr$ sj$ Xsxep$ Svhmrev}$ Hmzmhirhw$ {lmgl

gsrwxmxyxiw$e$&Uyepmjmih$Hmzmhirh&0$ew$hijmrih$f}$xli$Mrxivrep$Viziryi$Wivzmgi2

,6-$Xli$eqsyrx$gsrwxmxyxiw$e$&Vixyvr$sj$Getmxep&0$ew$hijmrih$f}$xli$Mrxivrep$Viziryi$Wivzmgi2

Wxsgo$Fy}fego$Tvskveq

Sr$ Jifvyev}$ 580$ 645<0$ xli$ Gsqter}$ errsyrgih$ xlex$ mxw$ Fsevh$ eyxlsvm~ih$ e$ wxsgo$ fy}fego$ tvskveq$ eyxlsvm~mrk$ xli$ Gsqter}$ xs

vityvglewi$yt$xs$e$qe|mqyq$sj$(644$qmppmsr$sj$mxw$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo2$Xli$wxsgo$fy}fego$tvskveq${mpp$fi$jyrhih$tvmqevmp}${mxl

gewl$sr$lerh0$jvii$gewl$jps{$erh$fsvvs{mrkw$yrhiv$xli$Gsqter}+w$(=44$qmppmsr$vizspzmrk$gvihmx$jegmpmx}$,xli$&Vizspziv&-2$Xli$tvskveq

mw$ijjigxmzi$xlvsykl$Sgxsfiv$640$64642$Xli$wxsgo$fy}fego$tvskveq$mw$mrxirhih$xs$fi$mqtpiqirxih$xlvsykl$tyvglewiw$qehi$jvsq$xmqi$xs

xmqi$ mr$ xli$stir$qevoix$sv$mr$tvmzexip}$riksxmexih$ xverwegxmsrw0$ mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$ettpmgefpi$Wigyvmxmiw$erh$I|glerki$Gsqqmwwmsr

,&WIG&-$ viuymviqirxw2$Xli$ wxsgo$fy}fego$tvskveq$hsiw$rsx$sfpmkexi$ xli$Gsqter}$ xs$tyvglewi$er}$wtigmjmg$eqsyrx$sj$ mxw$gsqqsr

wxsgo$erh$qe}$fi$wywtirhih$sv$i|xirhih$ex$er}$xmqi$ex$xli$hmwgvixmsr$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$Fsevh2$Hyvmrk$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750

645<0$xli$Gsqter}$tyvglewih$806540698$wleviw$sj$mxw$gsqqsr$wxsgo$ex$e$gswx$sj$(=926$qmppmsr$tvmqevmp}$tyvglewih${mxl$tvsgiihw$jvsq

xli$Gsqter}+w$Vizspziv2$Xlivi${ivi$rs$tyvglewiw$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$gsqqsr$wxsgo$hyvmrk$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=2$Xli

Gsqter}$fipmiziw$mx$lew$xli$efmpmx}$xs$gsrxmryi$xs$jyrh$xli$wxsgo

546

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 156 of 253

Page 179: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 59:367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

fy}fego$tvskveq0$mxw$hifx$wivzmgi$viuymviqirxw$erh$mxw$qemrxirergi$erh$kvs{xl$getmxep$i|tirhmxyvi$viuymviqirxw0${lmpi$qemrxemrmrk

wyjjmgmirx$pmuymhmx}$jsv$sxliv$gsvtsvexi$tyvtswiw2

Tvswtigxyw$Wyttpiqirx

Sr$Sgxsfiv$640$645;0$xli$Gsqter}$jmpih${mxl$xli$WIG$er$eyxsqexmg$wlipj$vikmwxvexmsr$sr$Jsvq$W17EWV2$Yrhiv$xlmw$wlipj$vikmwxvexmsr0

xli$Gsqter}$qe}0$ jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi0$wipp$er}$gsqfmrexmsr$sj$wigyvmxmiw$hiwgvmfih$ mr$xli$tvswtigxyw$ mr$sri$sv$qsvi$sjjivmrkw2$Iegl

xmqi$xlex$xli$Gsqter}$qe}$wipp$wigyvmxmiw0$ xli$Gsqter}${mpp$tvszmhi$e$tvswtigxyw$wyttpiqirx$xlex${mpp$gsrxemr$wtigmjmg$mrjsvqexmsr

efsyx$xli$xivqw$sj$xlex$sjjivmrk$erh$xli$wigyvmxmiw$fimrk$sjjivih2$Sr$Rsziqfiv$=0$645;0$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$wlipj$vikmwxvexmsr0$xli

Gsqter}$jmpih${mxl$xli$WIG$e$tvswtigxyw$wyttpiqirx$vipexih$xs$xli$sjjiv$erh$wepi$jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$gsqqsr$wxsgo

ex$er$ekkvikexi$sjjivmrk$tvmgi$sj$yt$xs$(594$qmppmsr$xlvsykl$wepiw$ekirxw2$Wepiw$sj$wleviw$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$gsqqsr$wxsgo$yrhiv$xli

tvswtigxyw$ wyttpiqirx$erh$ xli$iuymx}$hmwxvmfyxmsr$ekviiqirxw$irxivih$ mrxs${mxl$ xli$wepiw$ekirxw0$ mj$ er}0$qe}$fi$qehi$ mr$riksxmexih

xverwegxmsrw$sv$xverwegxmsrw$xlex$evi$hiiqih$xs$fi$Ôex$xli$qevoixÕ$sjjivmrkw$ew$hijmrih$mr$Vypi$859$yrhiv$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$Egx$sj$5=772

Xlivi${ivi$rs$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$wsph$yrhiv$xlmw$tvswtigxyw$wyttpiqirx$hyvmrk$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=$sv$645<2

Tvijivvih$Wxsgo

Mr$Etvmp$5==80$xli$Gsqter}×w$Fsevh$eyxlsvm~ih$74$qmppmsr$wleviw$sj$Ôfpero$gligoÕ$tvijivvih$wxsgo2$Xli$Fsevh$mw$eyxlsvm~ih$xs

hixivqmri$xli$vmklxw$erh$tvmzmpikiw$sj$er}$jyxyvi$mwwyergi$sj$tvijivvih$wxsgo$wygl$ew$zsxmrk$erh$hmzmhirh$vmklxw0$pmuymhexmsr$tvmzmpikiw0

vihiqtxmsr$vmklxw$erh$gsrzivwmsr$tvmzmpikiw2$Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$xlivi${ivi$rs$wleviw$sj$tvijivvih$wxsgo$syxwxerhmrk2

Rsrgsrxvsppmrk$Mrxiviwxw

Xli$ Gsqter}$ mrgpyhiw$ xli$ viwypxw$ sj$ stivexmsrw$ erh$ jmrergmep$ tswmxmsr$ sj$ WEGQ$ sv$ xli$ Ônsmrx$ zirxyviÕ0$ mxw$ qensvmx}1s{rih

wyfwmhmev}0$mr$mxw$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw2$WEGQ${ew$iwxefpmwlih$mr$6445$xs$stivexi$gsvvigxmsrep$girxivw$mr$Wsyxl$Ejvmge2$Xli

nsmrx$ zirxyvi$ gyvvirxp}$ tvszmhiw$ wigyvmx}$ erh$ sxliv$ qerekiqirx$ wivzmgiw$ jsv$ xli$ Oyxeqe$ Wmrxlyqypi$ Gsvvigxmsrep$ Girxvi$ mr$ xli

Vityfpmg$sj$Wsyxl$Ejvmge$yrhiv$e$691}iev$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegx${lmgl$gsqqirgih$ mr$Jifvyev}$64462$Xli$Gsqter}×w$erh$ xli$ nsmrx

zirxyvi$ tevxriv×w$ wleviw$ mr$ xli$ tvsjmxw$ sj$ xli$ nsmrx$ zirxyvi$ evi$ <<2;9)$ erh$ 55269)0$ viwtigxmzip}2$ Xlivi$ {ivi$ rs$ glerkiw$ mr$ xli

Gsqter}×w$s{rivwlmt$tivgirxeki$sj$xli$gsrwspmhexih$wyfwmhmev}$hyvmrk$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$645<$erh$645;2

82 Iuymx}$Mrgirxmzi$Tperw

Xli$ Fsevh$ lew$ ehstxih$ Xli$ KIS$ Kvsyt0$ Mrg2$ 645<$ Wxsgo$ Mrgirxmzi$ Tper$ ,xli$ &645<$ Tper&-0$ {lmgl$ {ew$ ettvszih$ f}$ xli

Gsqter}+w$wlevilsphivw$sr$Etvmp$680$645<2$Xli$645<$Tper$vitpegih$xli$6458$Wxsgo$Mrgirxmzi$Tper2$Ew$sj$xli$hexi$xli$645<$Tper${ew

ehstxih0$mx$tvszmhih$jsv$e$viwivzi$sj$80:440444$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$xlex$qe}$fi$mwwyih$tyvwyerx$xs$e{evhw$kverxih$yrhiv$xli$645<

Tper2$Xli$Gsqter}$jmpih$e$Jsvq$W1<$vikmwxvexmsr$wxexiqirx$vipexih$xs$xli$645<$Tper$sr$Qe}$550$645<2

Yrhiv$xli$xivqw$sj$xli$645<$Tper0$xli$ziwxmrk$tivmsh$erh0$mr$xli$gewi$sj$wxsgo$stxmsrw0$xli$i|ivgmwi$tvmgi$tiv$wlevi0$evi$hixivqmrih

f}$xli$ xivqw$sj$iegl$kverx$ekviiqirx2$Epp$wxsgo$stxmsrw$xlex$lezi$fiir$kverxih$yrhiv$ xli$Gsqter}$tperw$evi$i|ivgmwefpi$ex$ xli$jemv

qevoix$zepyi$sj$ xli$gsqqsr$wxsgo$ex$ xli$hexi$sj$ xli$kverx2$Kirivepp}0$ xli$wxsgo$stxmsrw$ziwx$erh$figsqi$i|ivgmwefpi$ vexefp}$sziv$e

jsyv1}iev$tivmsh2$Epp$wxsgo$stxmsrw$e{evhih$yrhiv$xli$645<$Tper$i|tmvi$rs$pexiv$xler$xir$}ievw$ejxiv$xli$hexi$sj$xli$kverx2$[lir$stxmsrw

evi$i|ivgmwih0$xli$Gsqter}$mwwyiw$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$vipexih$xs$xli$i|ivgmwih$stxmsrw2$$

Xli$Gsqter}$vigskrm~ih$gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwi$vipexih$xs$xli$Gsqter}$tperw$jsv$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$645<$erh

645;$ew$jspps{w$,mr$xlsywerhw->$

$ $ 645= $ 645< $ 645;

Wxsgo$stxmsr$tper$i|tirwi $ ( 504<9 $ ( ==: $ ( 50749

Viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$i|tirwi $ ( 6506:4 $ ( 650497 $ ( 5<097=

Wxsgo$Stxmsrw

E$wyqqev}$sj$xli$egxmzmx}$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$wxsgo$stxmsrw$tperw$mw$tviwirxih$fips{>

547

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 157 of 253

Page 180: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 59;367<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 158 of 253

Page 181: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 59<367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

$ $ Wleviw $

[xh2$Ezk2I|ivgmwiTvmgi $

[xh2$Ezk2Viqemrmrk

Gsrxvegxyep$Xivq,}ievw- $

EkkvikexiMrxvmrwmgZepyi

$ $ ,Mr$xlsywerhw- $ $ $ $ $ ,Mr$xlsywerhw-

Stxmsrw$syxwxerhmrk$ex$Neryev}$50$645= $ 508:6 $ ( 68274 $ ;264 $ ( =68

Kverxih $ 7=5 $ 662:< $ $ $ $

I|ivgmwih $ ,;<- $ 5:247 $ $ $ $

Jsvjimxih3Gergipih $ ,5<9- $ 682:4 $ $ $ $

Stxmsrw$syxwxerhmrk$ex$Higiqfiv$750$645= $ 509=4 $ ( 6826= $ :2=4 $ ( 676

Stxmsrw$ziwxih$erh$i|tigxih$xs$ziwx$ex$Higiqfiv

750$645= $ 50965 $ ( 68278 $ :2<6 $ ( 676

Stxmsrw$i|ivgmwefpi$ex$Higiqfiv$750$645= $ <4= $ ( 682<8 $ 9297 $ ( 676

Xli$ ekkvikexi$ mrxvmrwmg$ zepyi$ mr$ xli$ xefpi$ efszi$ vitviwirxw$ xli$ xsxep$ tvixe|$ mrxvmrwmg$ zepyi$ ,m2i20$ xli$ hmjjivirgi$fix{iir$ xli

Gsqter}×w$ gpswmrk$ wxsgo$ tvmgi$ sr$ xli$ pewx$ xvehmrk$ he}$ sj$ 645=$ erh$ xli$ i|ivgmwi$ tvmgi0$ xmqiw$ xli$ ryqfiv$ sj$ wleviw$ xlex$ evi$ Ômr$ xli

qsri}Õ-$xlex${syph$lezi$fiir$vigimzih$f}$xli$stxmsr$lsphivw$leh$epp$stxmsr$lsphivw$i|ivgmwih$xlimv$stxmsrw$sr$Higiqfiv$750$645=2

Xlmw$eqsyrx$glerkiw$fewih$sr$xli$jemv$zepyi$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$wxsgo2

Xli$jspps{mrk$xefpi$wyqqevm~iw$mrjsvqexmsr$vipexmzi$xs$wxsgo$stxmsr$egxmzmx}$hyvmrk$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$645<

erh$645;$,mr$xlsywerhw->$

$ $ 645= $ 645< $ 645;

Mrxvmrwmg$zepyi$sj$stxmsrw$i|ivgmwih $ ( 877 $ ( 95= $ ( 8056:

Jemv$zepyi$sj$wleviw$ziwxih $ ( =;5 $ ( ;=8 $ ( 7;7

Xli$jspps{mrk$xefpi$wyqqevm~iw$mrjsvqexmsr$efsyx$xli$i|ivgmwi$tvmgiw$erh$vipexih$mrjsvqexmsr$sj$wxsgo$stxmsrw$syxwxerhmrk$yrhiv

xli$Gsqter}$tperw$ex$Higiqfiv$750$645=>$

$ $ Stxmsrw$Syxwxerhmrk $ Stxmsrw$I|ivgmwefpi

I|ivgmwi$Tvmgiw$,(- $Ryqfiv

Syxwxerhmrk $

[xh2$Ezk2ViqemrmrkGsrxvegxyep

Pmji $

[xh2$$Ezk2I|ivgmwiTvmgi $

RyqfivI|ivgmwefpi $

[xh2$Ezk2ViqemrmrkGsrxvegxyep

Pmji $

[xh2$$Ezk2I|ivgmwiTvmgi

$ $ ,Mr$xlsywerhw- $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

415<267 $ 556 $ 52;7 $ ( 58298 $ 556 $ 52;7 $ ( 58298

5<26816626: $ :5< $ ;25: $ ( 65244 $ 6<; $ :269 $ ( 642;5

6626;16=27= $ 95= $ ;2:5 $ ( 6924; $ 647 $ 925; $ ( 6<2;;

6=284194244 $ 785 $ ;248 $ ( 76275 $ 64; $ :2=9 $ ( 76275

Xsxep $ 509=4 $ :2=4 $ ( 6826= $ <4= $ 9297 $ ( 682<8

Xli${imklxih$eziveki$kverx$hexi$ jemv$zepyi$sj$stxmsrw$kverxih$hyvmrk$ xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$645<$ erh$645;${ew

(72=:0$(72:8$erh$(92=5$tiv$ wlevi0$ viwtigxmzip}2$Xlivi${ivi$428$qmppmsr0$429$qmppmsr$ erh$429$qmppmsr$stxmsrw$kverxih$hyvmrk$ xli$}iev

irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$645<$erh$645;0$viwtigxmzip}2

Xli$jspps{mrk$ xefpi$ wyqqevm~iw$ xli$ wxexyw$sj$rsr1ziwxih$wxsgo$stxmsrw$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$ glerkiw$hyvmrk$ xli$}iev

irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=>$

548

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 159 of 253

Page 182: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 59=367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$ $ Ryqfiv$sj$Wleviw $[xh2$Ezk2$KverxHexi$Jemv$Zepyi

$ $ ,Mr$xlsywerhw- $ $

Stxmsrw$rsr1ziwxih$ex$Neryev}$50$645= $ <5: $ ( 72<:

Kverxih $ 7=5 $ 72=:

Ziwxih $ ,685- $ 7299

Jsvjimxih $ ,5<9- $ 8248

Stxmsrw$rsr1ziwxih$ex$Higiqfiv$750$645= $ ;<5 $ ( 72==

Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$leh$(626$qmppmsr$sj$yrvigskrm~ih$gsqtirwexmsr$gswxw$vipexih$xs$rsr1ziwxih$wxsgo$stxmsr

e{evhw$xlex$evi$i|tigxih$xs$fi$vigskrm~ih$sziv$e${imklxih$eziveki$tivmsh$sj$629$}ievw2

Viwxvmgxih$Wxsgo

Hyvmrk$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$kverxih$ettvs|mqexip}$;<<0444$wleviw$sj$viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$xs$givxemr

iqtps}iiw$erh$i|igyxmzi$sjjmgivw2$Sj$xliwi$e{evhw0$6940444$evi$qevoix$erh$tivjsvqergi1fewih$e{evhw${lmgl${mpp$fi$jsvjimxih$mj$xli

Gsqter}$hsiw$rsx$eglmizi$givxemr$erryep$qixvmgw$hyvmrk$645=0$6464$erh$64652$Xli$jemv$zepyi$sj$viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$e{evhw0${lmgl$hs$rsx

gsrxemr$e$tivjsvqergi1fewih$gsrhmxmsr0$mw$hixivqmrih$ywmrk$xli$gpswmrk$tvmgi$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$gsqqsr$wxsgo$sr$xli$hexi$sj$xli$kverx

erh$gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwi$mw$vigskrm~ih$sziv$xli$ziwxmrk$tivmsh2$Kirivepp}0$xli$viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$e{evhw$ziwx$mr$iuyep$mrgviqirxw$sziv

imxliv$e$xlvii$sv$jsyv$}iev$tivmsh2

$$$$

Xli$ziwxmrk$sj$tivjsvqergi1fewih$viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$kverxw$evi$wyfnigx$xs$xli$eglmiziqirx$f}$KIS$sj$x{s$erryep$tivjsvqergi

qixvmgw$ew$jspps{w>$,m-$yt$xs$94)$sj$xli$wleviw$sj$viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$,&XWV$Xevkix$E{evh&-$ger$ziwx$ex$xli$irh$sj$e$xlvii1}iev$tivjsvqergi

tivmsh$mj$KIS$qiixw$givxemr$xsxep$wlevilsphiv$vixyvr$,&XWV&-$tivjsvqergi$xevkixw0$ew$gsqtevih$xs$xli$xsxep$wlevilsphiv$vixyvr$sj$e$tiiv

kvsyt$sj$gsqtermiw0$sziv$e$xlvii$}iev$tivmsh$jvsq$Neryev}$50$645=$xs$Higiqfiv$750$6465$erh$,mm-$yt$xs$94)$sj$xli$wleviw$sj$viwxvmgxih

wxsgo$,&VSGI$Xevkix$E{evh&-$ger$ziwx$ex$xli$irh$sj$e$xlvii1}iev$tivmsh$mj$KIS$qiixw$givxemr$vixyvr$sr$getmxep$iqtps}ih$,&VSGI&-

tivjsvqergi$xevkixw$sziv$e$xlvii$}iev$tivmsh$jvsq$Neryev}$50$645=$xs$Higiqfiv$750$64652$Xliwi$qevoix$erh$tivjsvqergi$e{evhw$ger

ziwx$ex$fix{iir$4)$erh$644)$sj$xli$xevkix$e{evhw$jsv$fsxl$qixvmgw2$Xli$ryqfiv$sj$wleviw$wls{r$jsv$xli$tivjsvqergi1fewih$e{evhw$mw

fewih$sr$xli$xevkix$e{evhw$jsv$fsxl$qixvmgw2

$$$$

Hyvmrk$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645<0$xli$Gsqter}$kverxih$ettvs|mqexip}$=4:0444$wleviw$sj$viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$xs$givxemr

iqtps}iiw$erh$i|igyxmzi$sjjmgivw2$Sj$xliwi$e{evhw0$7960944$evi$tivjsvqergi1fewih$e{evhw${lmgl${mpp$fi$jsvjimxih$mj$xli$Gsqter}

hsiw$rsx$eglmizi$givxemr$erryep$qixvmgw$sziv$e$xlvii$}iev$tivmsh$jvsq$Neryev}$50$645<$xs$Higiqfiv$750$64642

Xli$ziwxmrk$sj$xli$tivjsvqergi1fewih$viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$kverxw$e{evhih$mr$645<$evi$wyfnigx$xs$xli$eglmiziqirx$f}$KIS$sj$x{s$erryep

tivjsvqergi$qixvmgw$ew$jspps{w>$,m-$yt$xs$94)$sj$xli$XWV$Xevkix$E{evh$ger$ziwx$ex$xli$irh$sj$e$xlvii1}iev$tivjsvqergi$tivmsh$mj$KIS

qiixw$givxemr$XWV$tivjsvqergi$ xevkixw0$ew$gsqtevih$ xs$ xli$ xsxep$wlevilsphiv$ vixyvr$sj$e$tiiv$kvsyt$sj$gsqtermiw0$sziv$e$xlvii$}iev

tivmsh$jvsq$Neryev}$50$645<$xs$Higiqfiv$750$6464?$erh$,mm-$yt$xs$94)$sj$xli$VSGI$Xevkix$E{evh$ger$ziwx$ex$xli$irh$sj$e$xlvii1}iev

tivjsvqergi$tivmsh$mj$KIS$qiixw$givxemr$VSGI$tivjsvqergi$xevkixw$sziv$e$xlvii$}iev$tivmsh$jvsq$Neryev}$50$645<$xs$Higiqfiv$750

64642$Xliwi$tivjsvqergi$e{evhw$ger$ziwx$ex$fix{iir$4)$erh$644)$sj$xli$xevkix$e{evhw$jsv$fsxl$qixvmgw2$Xli$ryqfiv$sj$wleviw$wls{r

jsv$xli$tivjsvqergi1fewih$e{evhw$mw$fewih$sr$xli$xevkix$e{evhw$jsv$fsxl$qixvmgw2

Hyvmrk$ xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645;0$ xli$Gsqter}$kverxih$=770444$wleviw$sj$ viwxvmgxih$ wxsgo$ xs$ mxw$ i|igyxmzi$sjjmgivw$erh$ xs

givxemr$wirmsv$iqtps}iiw2$Sj$xliwi$e{evhw0$7960944$evi$tivjsvqergi1fewih$e{evhw${lmgl${mpp$fi$jsvjimxih$ mj$ xli$Gsqter}$hsiw$rsx

eglmizi$givxemr$erryep$qixvmgw$sziv$e$xlvii$}iev$tivmsh$jvsq$Neryev}$50$645;$xs$Higiqfiv$750$645=2$Xli$ziwxmrk$sj$xli$tivjsvqergi1

fewih$viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$kverxw$e{evhih$mr$645;$evi$wyfnigx$xs$xli$eglmiziqirx$f}$KIS$sj$x{s$erryep$tivjsvqergi$qixvmgw$ew$jspps{w>

,m-$yt$xs$94)$sj$xli$XWV$Xevkix$E{evh$ger$ziwx$ex$xli$irh$sj$e$xlvii1}iev$tivjsvqergi$tivmsh$mj$KIS$qiixw$givxemr$XWV$tivjsvqergi

xevkixw0$ew$gsqtevih$ xs$ xli$ xsxep$wlevilsphiv$ vixyvr$sj$e$tiiv$kvsyt$sj$gsqtermiw0$sziv$e$ xlvii$}iev$tivmsh$jvsq$Neryev}$50$645;$ xs

Higiqfiv$750$645=?$erh$,mm-$yt$xs$94)$sj$ xli$VSGI$Xevkix$E{evh$ger$ziwx$ex$ xli$irh$sj$e$xlvii1}iev$tivmsh$mj$KIS$qiixw$givxemr

VSGI$tivjsvqergi$xevkixw$sziv$e$xlvii$}iev$tivmsh$jvsq$Neryev}$50$645;$xs$Higiqfiv$750$645=2$Xliwi$tivjsvqergi$e{evhw$ger$ziwx$ex

xli$irh$sj$xli$xlvii$}iev$tivjsvqergi$tivmsh$ex$fix{iir$4)$erh$644)$sj$ xli$ xevkix$e{evhw$ jsv$fsxl$qixvmgw2$Xli$ryqfiv$sj$ wleviw

wls{r$jsv$xli$tivjsvqergi1fewih$e{evhw$mw$fewih$sr$xli$xevkix$e{evhw$jsv$fsxl$qixvmgw2

Xli$qixvmg$vipexih$xs$XWV$mw$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$e$qevoix$gsrhmxmsr2$Jsv$wlevi1fewih$e{evhw$xlex$gsrxemr$e$qevoix$gsrhmxmsr0$xli

tvsfefmpmx}$sj$wexmwj}mrk$ xli$qevoix$gsrhmxmsr$qywx$fi$gsrwmhivih$ mr$ xli$iwxmqexi$sj$kverx1hexi$ jemv$zepyi2$Gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwi$ mw

vigskrm~ih$sziv$xli$ziwxmrk$tivmsh$erh$tvizmsywp}$vigsvhih$gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwi$mw$rsx$vizivwih$mj$xli$qevoix$gsrhmxmsr$mw$riziv$qix2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 160 of 253

Page 183: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5:4367<

Vijiv$ xs$Rsxi$ 5$ 1$ Wyqqev}$ sj$Fywmriww$Svkerm~exmsr0$Stivexmsrw$ erh$Wmkrmjmgerx$Eggsyrxmrk$Tspmgmiw1Wxsgo1Fewih$Gsqtirwexmsr

I|tirwi0$jsv$xli$ewwyqtxmsrw$erh$qixlsh$ywih$xs$zepyi$xliwi$e{evhw2

549

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 161 of 253

Page 184: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5:5367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Xli$qixvmg$vipexih$xs$VSGI$mw$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$e$tivjsvqergi$gsrhmxmsr2$Jsv$wlevi1fewih$e{evhw$xlex$gsrxemr$e$tivjsvqergi$gsrhmxmsr0

xli$eglmiziqirx$sj$xli$xevkixw$qywx$fi$tvsfefpi$fijsvi$er}$wlevi1fewih$gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwi$mw$vigsvhih2$Xli$Gsqter}$vizmi{w$xli

pmoipmlssh$sj${lmgl$ xevkix$ mr$ xli$ verki${mpp$ fi$ eglmizih$erh$ mj$hiiqih$tvsfefpi0$ gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwi$ mw$ vigsvhih$ex$ xlex$ xmqi2$ Mj

wyfwiuyirx$ xs$ xli$mrmxmep$qiewyviqirx$xlivi$mw$e$glerki$ mr$xli$iwxmqexi$sj$ xli$tvsfefmpmx}$sj$qiixmrk$ xli$tivjsvqergi$gsrhmxmsr0$ xli

ijjigx$ sj$ xli$ glerki$ mr$ xli$ iwxmqexih$ uyerxmx}$ sj$ e{evhw$ i|tigxih$ xs$ ziwx$ mw$ vigskrm~ih$ f}$ gyqypexmzip}$ ehnywxmrk$ gsqtirwexmsr

i|tirwi2$Mj$ypxmqexip}$xli$tivjsvqergi$xevkixw$evi$rsx$qix0$jsv$er}$e{evhw${livi$ziwxmrk${ew$tvizmsywp}$hiiqih$tvsfefpi0$tvizmsywp}

vigskrm~ih$gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwi${mpp$fi$vizivwih$mr$xli$tivmsh$ mr${lmgl$ziwxmrk$mw$rs$psrkiv$hiiqih$tvsfefpi2$Hyvmrk$645=0$645<

erh$ 645;0$ xli$ Gsqter}$ hiiqih$ xli$ eglmiziqirx$ sj$ xli$ xevkix$ e{evh$ xs$ fi$ tvsfefpi$ erh$ xlivi$ {ivi$ rs$ glerkiw$ mr$ xli$ iwxmqexih

uyerxmx}$ sj$ e{evhw$ i|tigxih$ xs$ ziwx2$ Xli$ jemv$ zepyi$ sj$ xliwi$ e{evhw${ew$ hixivqmrih$ fewih$ sr$ xli$ gpswmrk$ tvmgi$ sj$ xli$Gsqter}+w

gsqqsr$wxsgo$sr$xli$hexi$sj$kverx2

Xli$jspps{mrk$xefpi$wyqqevm~iw$xli$wxexyw$sj$viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$e{evhw$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$glerkiw$hyvmrk$xli$}iev$irhih

Higiqfiv$750$645=>$

$ $ Wleviw $

[xh2$Ezk2Kverx$$hexiJemv$zepyi

$ $ ,Mr$xlsywerhw- $ $

Viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$syxwxerhmrk$ex$Neryev}$50$645= $ 6045< $ ( 6;2:6

Kverxih $ ;<< $ 672;=

Ziwxih $ ,;45- $ 6824=

Jsvjimxih3Gergipih $ ,9<- $ 672==

Viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$syxwxerhmrk$ex$Higiqfiv$750$645= $ 6048; $ ( 6;277

Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$leh$(6;26$qmppmsr$sj$yrvigskrm~ih$gsqtirwexmsr$gswx$xlex$mw$i|tigxih$xs$fi$vigskrm~ih

sziv$e${imklxih$eziveki$tivmsh$sj$625$}ievw2

Iqtps}ii$Wxsgo$Tyvglewi$Tper

Xli$Gsqter}$tvizmsywp}$ehstxih$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt$Mrg2$6455$Iqtps}ii$Wxsgo$Tyvglewi$Tper$,xli$ÔTperÕ-0${lmgl${ew$ettvszih

f}$xli$Gsqter}+w$wlevilsphivw2$Xli$tyvtswi$sj$xli$Tper0${lmgl$mw$uyepmjmih$yrhiv$Wigxmsr$867$sj$xli$Mrxivrep$Viziryi$Wivzmgi$Gshi$sj

5=<:0$ew$eqirhih0$mw$xs$irgsyveki$wxsgo$s{rivwlmt$xlvsykl$te}vspp$hihygxmsrw$f}$xli$iqtps}iiw$sj$KIS$erh$hiwmkrexih$wyfwmhmevmiw

sj$KIS$mr$svhiv$xs$mrgviewi$xlimv$mhirxmjmgexmsr${mxl$xli$Gsqter}×w$ksepw$erh$wigyvi$e$tvstvmixev}$mrxiviwx$mr$xli$Gsqter}×w$wyggiww2

Xliwi$hihygxmsrw$evi$ywih$xs$tyvglewi$wleviw$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$Gsqqsr$Wxsgo$ex$e$9)$hmwgsyrx$jvsq$xli$xlir$gyvvirx$qevoix$tvmgi2

Xli$Gsqter}$lew$qehi$ezempefpi$yt$xs$;940444$wleviw$sj$mxw$gsqqsr$wxsgo0${lmgl${ivi$vikmwxivih${mxl$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$erh$I|glerki

Gsqqmwwmsr$sr$Qe}$80$64560$ew$eqirhih$sr$Nyp}$5<0$64580$jsv$wepi$xs$ipmkmfpi$iqtps}iiw2

Xli$Tper$ mw$ gsrwmhivih$ xs$ fi$rsr1gsqtirwexsv}2$Ew$ wygl0$ xlivi$ mw$ rs$ gsqtirwexmsr$ i|tirwi$ viuymvih$ xs$fi$ vigskrm~ih2$Wlevi

tyvglewiw$yrhiv$xli$Tper$evi$qehi$sr$xli$pewx$he}$sj$iegl$qsrxl2$Hyvmrk$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$645<$erh$645;0$7405970

6807:9$erh$64044=$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo0$viwtigxmzip}0${ivi$mwwyih$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$Tper2

92 Ievrmrkw$Tiv$Wlevi

Fewmg$erh$hmpyxih$ievrmrkw$tiv$wlevi$,ÔITWÕ-$jvsq$gsrxmrymrk$stivexmsrw${ivi$gepgypexih$jsv$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0

645<0$erh$645;$viwtigxmzip}0$ew$jspps{w>

54:

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 162 of 253

Page 185: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5:6367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Jmwgep$]iev 645= $ 645< $ 645;

$ ,Mr$xlsywerhw0$i|gitx$tiv$wlevi$hexe-

Rix$Mrgsqi ( 5::0856 $ ( 5880<6; $ ( 58:0468

Psww$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$rsrgsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw 5=5 $ 6:6 $ 65;

Rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2 ( 5::0:47 $ ( 58904<= $ ( 58:0685

Fewmg$ievrmrkw$tiv$wlevi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2> $ $ $ $ $

[imklxih$eziveki$wleviw$syxwxerhmrk 55=04=; $ 5640685 $ 56404=9

Tiv$wlevi$eqsyrx ( 5284 $ ( 5265 $ ( 5266

Hmpyxih$ievrmrkw$tiv$wlevi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2> $ $ $ $ $

[imklxih$eziveki$wleviw$syxwxerhmrk 55=04=; $ 5640685 $ 56404=9

Hmpyxmzi$ijjigx$sj$iuymx}$mrgirxmzi$tperw 658 $ 94: $ ;5=

[imklxih$eziveki$wleviw$ewwyqmrk$hmpyxmsr 55=0755 $ 5640;8; $ 5640<58

Tiv$wlevi$eqsyrx$1$hmpyxih ( 5284 $ ( 5264 $ ( 5265

Jsv$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$508=90654${imklxih$eziveki$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$yrhivp}mrk$stxmsrw${ivi

i|gpyhih$jvsq$xli$gsqtyxexmsr$sj$hmpyxih$ITW$figeywi$xli$ijjigx${syph$fi$erxm1hmpyxmzi2$Jsv$xli$weqi$tivmsh0$5095805;;$gsqqsr$wxsgo

iuymzepirxw$jvsq$viwxvmgxih$wleviw${ivi$erxm1hmpyxmzi$erh$i|gpyhih$jvsq$xli$gsqtyxexmsr$sj$hmpyxih$ITW2

Jsv$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645<0$=7508;7${imklxih$eziveki$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$yrhivp}mrk$stxmsrw${ivi$i|gpyhih

jvsq$xli$gsqtyxexmsr$sj$hmpyxih$ITW$figeywi$xli$ijjigx${syph$fi$erxm1hmpyxmzi2$Jsv$xli$weqi$tivmsh0$:<404:6$gsqqsr$wxsgo

iuymzepirxw$jvsq$viwxvmgxih$wleviw${ivi$erxm1hmpyxmzi$erh$i|gpyhih$jvsq$xli$gsqtyxexmsr$sj$hmpyxih$ITW2

Jsv$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645;0$:5;0469${imklxih$eziveki$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$yrhivp}mrk$stxmsrw${ivi$i|gpyhih

jvsq$xli$gsqtyxexmsr$sj$hmpyxih$ITW$figeywi$xli$ijjigx${syph$fi$erxm1hmpyxmzi2$Jsv$xli$weqi$tivmsh0$;5=0648$gsqqsr$wxsgo

iuymzepirxw$jvsq$viwxvmgxih$wleviw${ivi$erxm1hmpyxmzi$erh$i|gpyhih$jvsq$xli$gsqtyxexmsr$sj$hmpyxih$ITW2

:2 Tvstivx}$erh$Iuymtqirx

Tvstivx}$erh$iuymtqirx$gsrwmwx$sj$xli$jspps{mrk$ex$jmwgep$}iev$irh>$

$ $YwijypPmji $ 645= $ 645<

$ $ ,]ievw- $ ,Mr$xlsywerhw-

Perh $ Ó $ ( 56<0<;8 $ ( 57507;;

Fymphmrkw$erh$mqtvsziqirxw $ 6$xs$94 $ 6066=0=9: $ 605880858

Piewilsph$mqtvsziqirxw $ 5$xs$6= $ 6=50955 $ 747078<

Iuymtqirx $ 7$xs$54 $ 65:0:48 $ 64:05=5

Jyvrmxyvi0$jm|xyviw$erh$gsqtyxiv$wsjx{evi $ 5$xs$; $ :80<6< $ :4059=

Jegmpmx}$gsrwxvygxmsr$mr$tvskviww $ Ó $ 750=;= $ :906<6

Xsxep $ $ $ ( 60=:70;96 $ ( 60=540;;5

Piww$eggyqypexih$hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr $ $ $ ,<5=0474- $ ,;9605:5-

Tvstivx}$erh$iuymtqirx0$rix $ $ $ ( 605880;66 $ ( 6059<0:54

Xli$Gsqter}$eqsvxm~iw$mxw$piewilsph$mqtvsziqirxw$sziv$xli$wlsvxiv$sj$xlimv$iwxmqexih$ywijyp$pmziw$sv$xli$xivqw$sj$xli$piewiw

mrgpyhmrk$viri{ep$tivmshw$xlex$evi$viewsrefp}$ewwyvih2$Xli$Gsqter}×w$gsrwxvygxmsr$mr$tvskviww$tvmqevmp}$gsrwmwxw$sj$ri{$gsrwxvygxmsr

erh$virszexmsrw$xs$jegmpmxmiw$xlex$evi$s{rih$f}$xli$Gsqter}2$Mrxiviwx$getmxepm~ih$mr$tvstivx}$erh$iuymtqirx$jsv$xli$}ievw$irhih

Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$645<${ew$(428$qmppmsr$erh$(72;$qmppmsr0$viwtigxmzip}2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 163 of 253

Page 186: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5:7367<

Hitvigmexmsr$i|tirwi${ew$(54;2=$qmppmsr0$(54729$qmppmsr$erh$(=<2=$qmppmsr$jsv$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$645<$erh

645;0$viwtigxmzip}2

54;

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 164 of 253

Page 187: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5:8367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Ex$fsxl$Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$645<0$xli$Gsqter}$leh$(5;25$qmppmsr$sj$ewwixw$vigsvhih$yrhiv$jmrergi$piewiw$vipexih$xs$perh0

fymphmrkw$erh$mqtvsziqirxw2$Jmrergi$piewiw$evi$vigsvhih$rix$sj$eggyqypexih$eqsvxm~exmsr$sj$(5826$qmppmsr$erh$(5726$qmppmsr0$ex

Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$645<0$viwtigxmzip}2$Hitvigmexmsr$i|tirwi$vipexih$xs$ewwixw$vigsvhih$yrhiv$getmxep$piewiw$jsv$iegl$sj$xli$}ievw

irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$645<$erh$645;${ew$(524$qmppmsr$erh$mw$mrgpyhih$mr$Hitvigmexmsr$erh$Eqsvxm~exmsr$mr$xli$eggsqter}mrk

gsrwspmhexih$wxexiqirxw$sj$stivexmsrw2

;2 Gsrxvegx$Vigimzefpi

Sr$Witxiqfiv$5:0$64580$KIS+w${lspp}1s{rih$wyfwmhmev}0$KIS$Vezirlepp$Tx}2$Pxh20$mr$mxw$getegmx}$ew$xvywxii$sj$ersxliv

{lspp}1s{rih$wyfwmhmev}0$KIS$Vezirlepp$Xvywx$,&Tvsnigx$Gs&-0$wmkrih$xli$Vezirlepp$Tvmwsr$Tvsnigx$Ekviiqirx$,&Vezirlepp$Gsrxvegx&-

{mxl$xli$Wxexi$sj$Zmgxsvme$,xli$&Wxexi&-$jsv$xli$hizipstqirx$erh$stivexmsr$sj$e$507441fih$jegmpmx}$mr$Vezirlepp0$e$psgepmx}$riev

Qipfsyvri0$Eywxvepme$yrhiv$e$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmt$jmrergmrk$wxvygxyvi2$Xli$hiwmkr$erh$gsrwxvygxmsr$tlewi$,&H*G$Tlewi&-$sj$xli

ekviiqirx$fiker$mr$Witxiqfiv$6458$erh${ew$gsqtpixih$mr$Rsziqfiv$645;2$Tvsnigx$Gs${ew$xli$tvmqev}$hizipstiv$hyvmrk$xli$H*G

Tlewi$erh$wyfgsrxvegxih${mxl$e$fsrhih$mrxivrexmsrep$hiwmkr$erh$fymph$gsrxvegxsv$xs$hiwmkr$erh$gsrwxvygx$xli$jegmpmx}2$KIS+w${lspp}1

s{rih$wyfwmhmev}0$xli$KIS$Kvsyt$Eywxvepewme$Tx}2$Pxh2$,&KIS$Eywxvepme&-$mw$gyvvirxp}$stivexmrk$xli$jegmpmx}$yrhiv$e$691}iev

qerekiqirx$gsrxvegx$,&Stivexmrk$Tlewi&-2$Hyvmrk$xli$H*G$Tlewi0$KIS$Eywxvepme$tvszmhih$gsrwxvygxmsr$qerekiqirx$erh$gsrwypxerx

wivzmgiw$xs$xli$Wxexi2

Xli$gswx$sj$xli$tvsnigx$hyvmrk$xli$H*G$Tlewi${ew$jyrhih$f}$hifx$jmrergmrk$epsrk${mxl$e$getmxep$gsrxvmfyxmsr$f}$KIS$mr$xli

eqsyrx$sj$EYH$559$qmppmsr0$sv$(<42;$qmppmsr$fewih$sr$i|glerki$vexiw$ex$Higiqfiv$750$645=0${lmgl${ew$gsrxvmfyxih$mr$Neryev}$645;

,Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$57$1$Hifx-2$Ersxliv${lspp}1s{rih$wyfwmhmev}$sj$KIS0$Vezirlepp$Jmrergi$Gs$Tx}2$Pmqmxih$,&Jmrergi$Gs&-0$irxivih$mrxs

e$w}rhmgexih$jegmpmx}$ekviiqirx${mxl$Rexmsrep$Eywxvepme$Fero$Pmqmxih$xs$tvszmhi$xli$hifx$jmrergmrk$jsv$xli$tvsnigx2$Mr$svhiv$xs$jm|$xli

mrxiviwx$vexi$sr$xlmw$zevmefpi$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx0$Jmrergi$Gs$irxivih$mrxs$mrxiviwx$vexi$w{et$ekviiqirxw2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$<$1$Hivmzexmzi

Jmrergmep$Mrwxvyqirxw2$Ytsr$gsqtpixmsr$erh$gsqqivgmep$eggitxergi$sj$xli$jegmpmx}$mr$Rsziqfiv$645;0$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$xli

Vezirlepp$Gsrxvegx0$xli$Wxexi$qehi$e$pyqt$wyq$te}qirx$sj$EYH$754$qmppmsr0$sv$(65;28$qmppmsr$fewih$sr$i|glerki$vexiw$ew$sj

Higiqfiv$750$645=0$xs{evhw$e$tsvxmsr$sj$xli$syxwxerhmrk$fepergi2$Xli$viqemrmrk$fepergi${mpp$fi$temh$sziv$xli$pmji$sj$xli$691}iev

qerekiqirx$gsrxvegx2

Hyvmrk$xli$H*G$Tlewi0$xli$Gsqter}$vigskrm~ih$viziryi$ew$ievrih$sr$e$tivgirxeki$sj$gsqtpixmsr$fewmw$qiewyvih$f}$xli

tivgirxeki$sj$gswxw$mrgyvvih$xs$hexi$ew$gsqtevih$xs$xli$iwxmqexih$xsxep$gswxw$jsv$xli$hiwmkr$erh$gsrwxvygxmsr$sj$xli$jegmpmx}2$Gswxw

mrgyvvih$erh$iwxmqexih$ievrmrkw$mr$i|giww$sj$fmppmrkw$evi$gpewwmjmih$ew$Gsrxvegx$Vigimzefpi$mr$xli$eggsqter}mrk$gsrwspmhexih$fepergi

wliixw2$Xli$xsxep$fepergi$sj$xli$Gsrxvegx$Vigimzefpi$ex$Higiqfiv$750$645=$mw$(7;52<$qmppmsr${lmgl$mw$vigsvhih$ex$rix$tviwirx$zepyi

fewih$sr$xli$xmqmrk$sj$i|tigxih$jyxyvi$wixxpiqirx2$Mrxiviwx$mrgsqi$mw$vigsvhih$ew$ievrih$ywmrk$er$ijjigxmzi$mrxiviwx$vexi$sj$<2=;)2$Ew

xli$tvmqev}$gsrxvegxsv0$Tvsnigx$Gs${ew$i|tswih$xs$xli$zevmsyw$vmwow$ewwsgmexih${mxl$xli$H*G$Tlewi2$Eggsvhmrkp}0$xli$Gsqter}

vigsvhih$gsrwxvygxmsr$viziryi$sr$e$kvsww$fewmw$erh$mrgpyhih$xli$vipexih$gswxw$sj$gsrwxvygxmsr$egxmzmxmiw$mr$stivexmrk$i|tirwiw${mxlmr$xli

Jegmpmx}$Hiwmkr$*$Gsrwxvygxmsr$wikqirx2$Vimqfyvwefpi$teww$xlvsykl$gswxw${ivi$i|gpyhih$jvsq$viziryiw$erh$i|tirwiw2

<2 Hivmzexmzi$Jmrergmep$Mrwxvyqirxw

Xli$Gsqter}×w$tvmqev}$sfnigxmzi$mr$lsphmrk$hivmzexmziw$mw$xs$vihygi$xli$zspexmpmx}$sj$ievrmrkw$erh$gewl$jps{w$ewwsgmexih${mxl

glerkiw$mr$mrxiviwx$vexiw2$Xli$Gsqter}$qiewyviw$mxw$hivmzexmzi$jmrergmep$mrwxvyqirxw$ex$jemv$zepyi2

Mr$Eykywx$ 645=0$ xli$Gsqter}$ irxivih$ mrxs$ x{s$ mrxiviwx$ vexi$ w{et$ ekviiqirxw$ mr$ xli$ ekkvikexi$ rsxmsrep$ eqsyrx$ sj$ (8827

qmppmsr$xs$jm|$xli$mrxiviwx$vexi$sr$givxemr$sj$mxw$zevmefpi$vexi$hifx$xs$8266)2$Xli$Gsqter}$lew$hiwmkrexih$xliwi$mrxiviwx$vexi$w{etw$ew

lihkiw$ekemrwx$glerkiw$mr$xli$gewl$jps{w$sj$x{s$mhirxmgep$tvsqmwwsv}$rsxiw$,xli$&Rsxiw&-${lmgl$evi$wigyvih$f}$pser$ekviiqirxw$erh

qsvxkeki$ erh$ wigyvmx}$ ekviiqirxw$ sr$ givxemr$ viep$ tvstivx}$ erh$ mqtvsziqirxw2$ Xli$ Gsqter}$ lew$ hixivqmrih$ xlex$ xli$ w{etw$ lezi

te}qirx0$i|tmvexmsr$hexiw0$erh$tvszmwmsrw$xlex$gsmrgmhi${mxl$xli$xivqw$sj$xli$Rsxiw$erh$evi$xlivijsvi$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$ijjigxmzi$gewl

jps{$lihkiw2$Eggsvhmrkp}0$xli$Gsqter}$vigsvhw$xli$glerki$mr$jemv$zepyi$sj$xli$mrxiviwx$vexi$w{etw$ew$eggyqypexih$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi

mrgsqi$,psww-0$rix$sj$ettpmgefpi$xe|iw2$Xsxep$yrviepm~ih$pswwiw$vigsvhih$mr$xsxep$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$,psww-0$rix$sj$xe|0$vipexih$xs

xliwi$gewl$jps{$lihkiw${ew$(529$qmppmsr$hyvmrk$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=2$Xli$xsxep$jemv$zepyi$sj$xli$w{et$ pmefmpmxmiw$ew$sj

Higiqfiv$750$645=${ew$(52=$qmppmsr$erh$mw$vigsvhih$ew$e$gsqtsrirx$sj$Sxliv$Rsr1Gyvvirx$pmefmpmxmiw${mxlmr$xli$eggsqter}mrk$fepergi

wliix2$Xlivi${ew$rs$qexivmep$ mrijjigxmziriww$ jsv$ xli$tivmsh$tviwirxih2$Xli$Gsqter}$hsiw$rsx$ i|tigx$ xs$ irxiv$ mrxs$ er}$ xverwegxmsrw

hyvmrk$ xli$ ri|x$ x{ipzi$qsrxlw${lmgl${syph$ viwypx$ mr$ vigpewwmjmgexmsr$ mrxs$ ievrmrkw$ sv$ pswwiw$ ewwsgmexih${mxl$ xliwi$ w{etw$ gyvvirxp}

vitsvxih$mr$eggyqypexih$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$,psww-2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$57$1$Hifx$jsv$ehhmxmsrep$mrjsvqexmsr2

54<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 165 of 253

Page 188: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5:9367<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 166 of 253

Page 189: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5::367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Xli$Gsqter}×w$Eywxvepmer$ wyfwmhmev}$irxivih$ mrxs$ mrxiviwx$ vexi$ w{et$ekviiqirxw$ xs$ jm|$ xli$ mrxiviwx$ vexi$sr$ mxw$zevmefpi$ vexi

rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx$vipexih$xs$e$tvsnigx$ mr$Vezirlepp0$e$ psgepmx}$riev$Qipfsyvri0$Eywxvepme$xs$826)2$Xli$Gsqter}$hixivqmrih$xlex$xli

w{etw$ leh$ te}qirx0$ i|tmvexmsr$ hexiw0$ erh$ tvszmwmsrw$ xlex$ gsmrgmhih$ {mxl$ xli$ xivqw$ sj$ xli$ rsr1vigsyvwi$ hifx$ erh$ {ivi$ xlivijsvi

gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$ijjigxmzi$gewl$jps{$lihkiw2$Eggsvhmrkp}0$xli$Gsqter}$vigsvhih$xli$glerki$mr$xli$jemv$zepyi$sj$xli$mrxiviwx$vexi$w{etw

mr$eggyqypexih$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$ mrgsqi$ ,psww-0$rix$sj$ettpmgefpi$ mrgsqi$ xe|iw2$Sr$Qe}$660$645=0$ xli$Gsqter}$vijmrergih$ xli

ewwsgmexih$ hifx$ erh$ xivqmrexih$ xli$ w{et$ ekviiqirxw$ {lmgl$ viwypxih$ mr$ xli$ vigpewwmjmgexmsr$ sj$ (72=$ qmppmsr$ mrxs$ pswwiw$ xlex$ {ivi

tvizmsywp}$vitsvxih$mr$eggyqypexih$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$,psww-2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$57$1$Hifx$jsv$ehhmxmsrep$mrjsvqexmsr2

$$$$

$$$$$

$

=2 Kssh{mpp$erh$Sxliv$Mrxerkmfpi$Ewwixw0$Rix

Xli$Gsqter}$lew$vigsvhih$kssh{mpp$ew$e$viwypx$sj$mxw$zevmsyw$fywmriww$gsqfmrexmsrw2$Sr$Etvmp$90$645;0$xli$Gsqter}$gsqtpixih

mxw$eguymwmxmsr$sj$GIG2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$6$1$Fywmriww$Gsqfmrexmsrw2$Kssh{mpp$mw$vigsvhih$ew$xli$hmjjivirgi0$mj$er}0$fix{iir$xli$ekkvikexi

gsrwmhivexmsr$temh$jsv$er$eguymwmxmsr$erh$xli$jemv$zepyi$sj$xli$xerkmfpi$ewwixw$erh$mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw$eguymvih$rix$sj$pmefmpmxmiw$ewwyqih0

mrgpyhmrk$rsrgsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw2$Glerkiw$mr$xli$Gsqter}×w$kssh{mpp$fepergiw$vigskrm~ih$hyvmrk$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750

645=$erh$645<${ivi$ew$jspps{w$,mr$xlsywerhw->$

$ $ 563753645< $ $

Jsvimkrgyvvirg}xverwpexmsr $ 563753645=

Y2W2$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw $ ( 75:07:: $ $ ( Ó $ ( 75:07::

KIS$Gevi $ 89=09<= $ $ Ó $ 89=09<=

Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw $ 848 $ $ ,7- $ 845

Xsxep$Kssh{mpp $ ( ;;:079= $ $ ( ,7- $ ( ;;:079:

$ $ 563753645; $Eguymwmxmsrw$,rix$sj

hmwtswmxmsrw-

Jsvimkrgyvvirg}xverwpexmsr $ 563753645<

Y2W2$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw $ ( 75;0449 $ ( ,:7=- ( Ó $ ( 75:07::

KIS$Gevi $ 8:508== $ ,50=54- Ó $ 89=09<=

Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw $ 88; $ Ó ,87- $ 848

Xsxep$Kssh{mpp $ ( ;;<0=95 $ ( ,6098=- ( ,87- $ ( ;;:079=

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 167 of 253

Page 190: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5:;367<

54=

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 168 of 253

Page 191: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5:<367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw$gsrwmwxih$sj$xli$jspps{mrk$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$645<$,mr$xlsywerhw->$

$ $ Higiqfiv$750$645= $ Higiqfiv$750$645<

$

[imklxihEziveki$YwijypPmji$,}ievw-

KvswwGevv}mrkEqsyrx $

EggyqypexihEqsvxm~exmsr $

RixGevv}mrkEqsyrx $

KvswwGevv}mrkEqsyrx $

EggyqypexihEqsvxm~exmsr $

RixGevv}mrkEqsyrx

Jegmpmx}$qerekiqirxgsrxvegxw

5:27( 74<0876 $ ( ,58<05;5- $ ( 5:406:5 $ ( 74<085= $ ( ,56;08<5- $ ( 5<40=7<

Gszirerxw$rsx$xs$gsqtixi 5 Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ ;44 $ ,;44- $ Ó

Xiglrspsk} ;27 770;44 $ ,6=04=5- $ 80:4= $ 770;44 $ ,6;08;<- $ :0666

Xvehi$reqiw Mrhijmrmxi 890644 $ Ó $ 890644 $ 890644 $ Ó $ 890644

Xsxep$eguymvih$mrxerkmfpiewwixw $ ( 7<;0776 $ ( ,5;;06:6- $ ( 65404;4 $ ( 7<<045= $ ( ,5990:9=- $ ( 67607:4

Xli$eggsyrxmrk$jsv$vigskrm~ih$mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw$mw$fewih$sr$xli$ywijyp$pmziw$xs$xli$vitsvxmrk$irxmx}2$Mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw${mxl$jmrmxi

ywijyp$pmziw$evi$eqsvxm~ih$sziv$xlimv$ywijyp$pmziw$erh$mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw${mxl$mrhijmrmxi$ywijyp$pmziw$evi$rsx$eqsvxm~ih2$Xli$Gsqter}

iwxmqexiw$xli$ywijyp$pmziw$sj$mxw$mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw$xeomrk$mrxs$gsrwmhivexmsr$,m-$xli$i|tigxih$ywi$sj$xli$ewwix$f}$xli$Gsqter}0$,mm-$xli

i|tigxih$ywijyp$pmziw$sj$sxliv$vipexih$ewwixw$sv$kvsytw$sj$ewwixw0$,mmm-$pikep$sv$gsrxvegxyep$pmqmxexmsrw0$,mz-$xli$Gsqter}+w$lmwxsvmgep

i|tivmirgi$mr$viri{mrk$sv$i|xirhmrk$wmqmpev$evverkiqirxw0$,z-$xli$ijjigxw$sj$sfwspiwgirgi0$hiqerh0$gsqtixmxmsr$erh$sxliv$igsrsqmg

jegxsvw$erh$,zm-$xli$pizip$sj$qemrxirergi$i|tirhmxyviw$viuymvih$xs$sfxemr$xli$i|tigxih$gewl$jps{w$jvsq$xli$ewwix2

Eqsvxm~exmsr$i|tirwi${ew$(6627$qmppmsr0$(662=$qmppmsr$erh$(682;$qmppmsr$jsv$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$645<$erh

645;0$viwtigxmzip}0$erh$tvmqevmp}$vipexih$xs$xli$Y2W2$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$erh$KIS$Gevi$wikqirxw×$eqsvxm~exmsr$sj$mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw$jsv

eguymvih$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw2$Xli$Gsqter}$vipmiw$sr$mxw$lmwxsvmgep$i|tivmirgi$mr$hixivqmrmrk$xli$ywijyp$pmji$sj$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx

gsrxvegxw2$Xli$Gsqter}$qeoiw$ewwyqtxmsrw$vipexih$xs$eguymvih$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$fewih$sr$xli$gsqtixmxmzi$irzmvsrqirx

jsv$mrhmzmhyep$gsrxvegxw0$syv$lmwxsvmgep$wyggiww$vexiw$mr$vixemrmrk$gsrxvegxw0$xli$wyttp}$sj$ezempefpi$fihw$mr$xli$qevoix0$glerkiw$mr

pikmwpexmsr0$xli$tvsnigxih$tvsjmxefmpmx}$sj$xli$jegmpmxmiw$erh$sxliv$qevoix$gsrhmxmsrw2$Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$xli${imklxih$eziveki

tivmsh$fijsvi$xli$ri|x$gsrxvegx$viri{ep$sv$i|xirwmsr$jsv$xli$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw${ew$ettvs|mqexip}$52<$}ievw2$Epxlsykl$xli

jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$eguymvih$lezi$viri{ep$erh$i|xirwmsr$xivqw$mr$xli$riev$xivq0$xli$Gsqter}$lew$lmwxsvmgepp}$qemrxemrih

xliwi$vipexmsrwlmtw$fi}srh$xli$gsrxvegxyep$tivmshw2

Iwxmqexih$eqsvxm~exmsr$i|tirwi$vipexih$xs$xli$Gsqter}×w$jmrmxi1pmzih$mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw$jsv$6464$xlvsykl$6468$erh$xliviejxiv$mw$ew

jspps{w$,mr$xlsywerhw->

Jmwgep$]ievXsxep$$Eqsvxm~exmsr$I|tirwi

6464 ( 6606<<

6465 5=0;<6

6466 5<057<

6467 5708=8

6468 =0;:5

Xliviejxiv <5084;

$$

$ ( 5:80<;4

$$

$$$$

542 Jmrergmep$Mrwxvyqirxw

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 169 of 253

Page 192: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5:=367<

Xli$jspps{mrk$xefpi$tvszmhiw$e$wyqqev}$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$wmkrmjmgerx$jmrergmep$ewwixw$erh$pmefmpmxmiw$gevvmih$ex$jemv$zepyi$erh

qiewyvih$sr$e$vigyvvmrk$fewmw$,mr$xlsywerhw->$

554

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 170 of 253

Page 193: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5;4367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$ $ $ $ Jemv$Zepyi$Qiewyviqirxw$ex$Higiqfiv$750$645=

$ $Gevv}mrk$Zepyi$exHigiqfiv$750$645= $

Uysxih$Tvmgiw$mrEgxmzi$Qevoixw

,Pizip$5- $

Wmkrmjmgerx$SxlivSfwivzefpi$$Mrtyxw

,Pizip$6- $

WmkrmjmgerxYrsfwivzefpiMrtyxw$,Pizip$7-

Ewwixw> $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Viwxvmgxih$mrziwxqirxw> $ $ $ $

Veffm$Xvywx $ ( 6<0776 $ ( Ó $ ( 6<0776 $ ( Ó

Jm|ih$mrgsqi$wigyvmxmiw $ 50<=6 $ Ó $ 50<=6 $ Ó

Pmefmpmxmiw> $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Mrxiviwx$vexi$w{et$hivmzexmziw $ ( 50<:= $ ( Ó $ ( 50<:= $ ( Ó

$ $ $ $ Jemv$Zepyi$Qiewyviqirxw$ex$Higiqfiv$750$645<

$ $Gevv}mrk$Zepyi$exHigiqfiv$750$645< $

Uysxih$Tvmgiw$mrEgxmzi$Qevoixw

,Pizip$5- $

Wmkrmjmgerx$SxlivSfwivzefpi$$Mrtyxw

,Pizip$6- $

WmkrmjmgerxYrsfwivzefpiMrtyxw$,Pizip$7-

Ewwixw> $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Viwxvmgxih$mrziwxqirxw> $ $ $ $

$$$$Veffm$Xvywx $ ( 640<=6 $ ( Ó $ ( 640<=6 $ ( Ó

Jm|ih$mrgsqi$wigyvmxmiw $ 50<45 $ Ó $ 50<45 $ Ó

Pmefmpmxmiw> $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Mrxiviwx$vexi$w{et$hivmzexmziw $ ( <0:7< $ ( Ó $ ( <0:7< $ ( Ó

Xli$Gsqter}×w$Pizip$ 6$ jmrergmep$ mrwxvyqirxw$ mrgpyhih$ mr$ xli$ xefpiw$ efszi$ ew$ sj$Higiqfiv$ 750$ 645=$ erh$ 645<$ gsrwmwx$ sj

mrxiviwx$vexi$w{et$hivmzexmzi$pmefmpmxmiw$liph$f}$KIS$erh$xli$Gsqter}+w$Eywxvepmer$wyfwmhmev}0$xli$Gsqter}+w$veffm$xvywx$iwxefpmwlih$jsv

KIS$iqtps}ii$erh$iqtps}iv$gsrxvmfyxmsrw$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2$Rsr1uyepmjmih$Hijivvih$Gsqtirwexmsr$Tper$erh$er$mrziwxqirx$mr

Gerehmer$hsppev$ hirsqmrexih$ jm|ih$ mrgsqi$ wigyvmxmiw2$Sr$Qe}$660$ 645=0$ xli$Gsqter}$ xivqmrexih$ xli$ mrxiviwx$ vexi$ w{et$hivmzexmzi

pmefmpmxmiw$ mr$ gsrrigxmsr$ {mxl$ e$ hifx$ vijmrergmrk$ xverwegxmsr$ f}$ syv$ Eywxvepmer$ wyfwmhmev}2$ Vijiv$ xs$ Rsxi$ <$ 1$ Hivmzexmzi$ Jmrergmep

Mrwxvyqirxw$erh$Rsxi$57$1$Hifx$jsv$ehhmxmsrep$mrjsvqexmsr2

Xli$ mrxiviwx$ vexi$w{et$hivmzexmzi$ pmefmpmxmiw$evi$zepyih$ywmrk$e$hmwgsyrxih$gewl$jps{$qship$fewih$sr$tvsnigxih$fsvvs{mrk$ vexiw2$Xli

Gsqter}+w$ viwxvmgxih$ mrziwxqirx$ mr$ xli$veffm$ xvywx$ mw$ mrziwxih$ mr$Gsqter}1s{rih$ pmji$ mrwyvergi$tspmgmiw${lmgl$evi$vigsvhih$ex$ xlimv

gewl$wyvvirhiv$zepyiw2$Xliwi$mrziwxqirxw$evi$zepyih$fewih$sr$xli$yrhivp}mrk$mrziwxqirxw$liph$mr$xli$tspmgmiw+$witevexi$eggsyrx2$Xli

yrhivp}mrk$ewwixw$evi$iuymx}$erh$jm|ih$mrgsqi$tsspih$jyrhw$xlex$evi$gsqtvmwih$sj$Pizip$5$erh$Pizip$6$wigyvmxmiw2$Xli$Gerehmer$hsppev

hirsqmrexih$wigyvmxmiw0$rsx$egxmzip}$xvehih0$evi$zepyih$ywmrk$uysxih$vexiw$jsv$xliwi$erh$wmqmpev$wigyvmxmiw2

Hyvmrk$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$645<0$xli$Gsqter}$xverwjivvih$givxemr$eggsyrxw$vigimzefpi$fepergiw$xlex$leh$e

gevv}mrk$zepyi$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(724$qmppmsr$erh$(:2=$qmppmsr0$viwtigxmzip}0$xs$er$yrvipexih$xlmvh$tevx}2$Xli$xverwjivw${ivi$eggsyrxih

jsv$ ew$ wepiw$ erh$ xli$Gsqter}$ lew$ rs$ gsrxmrymrk$ mrzspziqirx${mxl$ xli$ xverwjivvih$ ewwixw2$ Xli$Gsqter}$ vigimzih$ gewl$ tvsgiihw$ mr

gsrrigxmsr${mxl$ xli$ wepiw$ sj$ ettvs|mqexip}$ (724$qmppmsr$ erh$ (:2=$qmppmsr0$ viwtigxmzip}0$ erh$ ew$ wygl0$ xlivi$ {ew$ rs$ kemr$ sv$ psww$ mr

gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$xverwegxmsrw2

552 Jemv$Zepyi$sj$Ewwixw$erh$Pmefmpmxmiw

Xli$Gsqter}×w$Gsrwspmhexih$Fepergi$Wliixw$vijpigx$givxemr$jmrergmep$mrwxvyqirxw$ex$gevv}mrk$zepyi2$Xli$jspps{mrk$xefpi$tviwirxw

xli$gevv}mrk$zepyiw$sj$xlswi$mrwxvyqirxw$erh$xli$gsvviwtsrhmrk$iwxmqexih$jemv$zepyiw$,mr$xlsywerhw->

555

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 171 of 253

Page 194: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5;5367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$ Iwxmqexih$Jemv$Zepyi$Qiewyviqirxw$ex$Higiqfiv$750$645=

$Gevv}mrk$Zepyi$ew$sjHigiqfiv$750$645= $ Xsxep$Jemv$Zepyi $ Pizip$5 $ Pizip$6 $ Pizip$7

Ewwixw> $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

$$$Gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw ( 7608:7 $ ( 7608:7 $ ( 7608:7 $ ( Ó $ ( Ó

$$$Viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$mrziwxqirxw 790454 $ 790454 $ 790454 $ Ó $ Ó

Pmefmpmxmiw> $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

$$$Fsvvs{mrkw$yrhiv$Wirmsv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx} ( 506=<0:;5 $ ( 5065<0<:5 $ ( Ó $ ( 5065<0<:5 $ ( Ó

92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466 5=70=9< $ 5=8067= $ Ó $ 5=8067= $ Ó

92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw 7440444 $ 6<;0=<6 $ Ó $ 6<;0=<6 $ Ó

$$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468 6940444 $ 66<08=7 $ Ó $ 66<08=7 $ Ó

:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw 7940444 $ 7580496 $ Ó $ 7580496 $ Ó

Rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx 76<05;< $ 76;0;=6 $ Ó $ 76;0;=6 $ Ó

$ Iwxmqexih$Jemv$Zepyi$Qiewyviqirxw$ex$Higiqfiv$750$645<

$Gevv}mrk$Zepyi$ew$sjHigiqfiv$750$645< $ Xsxep$Jemv$Zepyi $ Pizip$5 $ Pizip$6 $ Pizip$7

Ewwixw> $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw ( 750699 $ ( 750699 $ ( 750699 $ ( Ó $ ( Ó

Viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$mrziwxqirxw 97065; $ 97065; $ 9408== $ 60;5< $ Ó

Pmefmpmxmiw> $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

$$$Fsvvs{mrkw$yrhiv$Wirmsv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx} ( 506;70=:9 $ ( 505<<05=: $ ( Ó $ ( 505<<05=: $ ( Ó

$$$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466 6940444 $ 6880994 $ Ó $ 6880994 $ Ó

$$$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw 7440444 $ 6;50==6 $ Ó $ 6;50==6 $ Ó

$$$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468 6940444 $ 66809=4 $ Ó $ 66809=4 $ Ó

$$$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw 7940444 $ 75405;; $ Ó $ 75405;; $ Ó

Rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx 7840=54 $ 78<06;8 $ Ó $ 78<06;8 $ Ó

Xli$jemv$zepyiw$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw0$erh$viwxvmgxih$gewl$ettvs|mqexiw$xli$gevv}mrk$zepyiw$sj$xliwi$ewwixw

ex$Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$645<2$Viwxvmgxih$gewl$gsrwmwxw$sj$qsri}$qevoix$jyrhw0$gsqqivgmep$tetiv$erh$xmqi$hitswmxw$ywih$jsv

te}qirxw$sr$xli$Gsqter}×w$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx$erh$ewwix$vitpegiqirx$jyrhw$gsrxvegxyepp}$viuymvih$xs$fi$qemrxemrih$ex$xli$Gsqter}+w

Eywxvepmer$wyfwmhmev}2$Xli$jemv$zepyi$sj$xli$qsri}$qevoix$jyrhw$mw$fewih$sr$uysxih$qevoix$tvmgiw$,pizip$5-$erh$xli$jemv$zepyi$sj

gsqqivgmep$tetiv$erh$xmqi$hitswmxw$mw$fewih$sr$qevoix$tvmgiw$jsv$wmqmpev$mrwxvyqirxw$,pizip$6-2$Xli$jemv$zepyiw$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w

:244)$wirmsv$yrwigyvih$rsxiw$hyi$646:$,xli$Ô:244)$Wirmsv$RsxiwÕ-0$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6467$,xli$Ô92569)$Wirmsv$RsxiwÕ-0

92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466$,xli$&92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466Õ-$erh$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468$,xli$&92<;9)$Wirmsv

Rsxiw$hyi$6468&-0$epxlsykl$rsx$egxmzip}$xvehih0$evi$fewih$sr$tyfpmwlih$jmrergmep$hexe$jsv$xliwi$mrwxvyqirxw2$Xli$jemv$zepyi$sj$xli

Gsqter}×w$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx$mw$fewih$sr$iwxmqexi$sj$xvehmrk$zepyi$gsrwmhivmrk$xli$Gsqter}+w$fsvvs{mrk$vexi0$xli$yrhve{r$wtvieh$erh

wmqmpev$mrwxvyqirxw2$Xli$jemv$zepyi$sj$fsvvs{mrkw$yrhiv$xli$Wirmsv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}$mw$epws$fewih$sr$er$iwxmqexi$sj$xvehmrk$zepyi

gsrwmhivmrk$xli$Gsqter}×w$fsvvs{mrk$vexi0$xli$yrhve{r$wtvieh$erh$wmqmpev$mrwxvyqirxw2

$$$$

562 Eggvyih$I|tirwiw$erh$sxliv$gyvvirx$pmefmpmxmiw

Eggvyih$i|tirwiw$erh$sxliv$gyvvirx$pmefmpmxmiw$gsrwmwxih$sj$xli$jspps{mrk$,mr$xlsywerhw->$

556

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 172 of 253

Page 195: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5;6367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$ $ 645= $ 645<

Eggvyih$mrxiviwx $ ( 5;0<94 $ ( 5=0998

Eggvyih$fsryw $ 5:0=58 $ 59048;

Eggvyih$mrwyvergi $ ;705=6 $ ;50968

Eggvyih$vitemv$sfpmkexmsrw$jsv$heqekih$tvstivx} $ 80787 $ 5=04:;

Eggvyih$tvstivx}$erh$sxliv$xe|iw $ 7905=6 $ 6:0<6<

Gsrwxvygxmsr$vixemreki $ 504=; $ 50=57

Sxliv $ 870464 $ 94067;

Xsxep $ ( 5=50:4< $ ( 64805;4

572 Hifx

Hifx$gsrwmwxih$sj$xli$jspps{mrk$,mr$xlsywerhw->

$

$ $ Higiqfiv$750$645= $ Higiqfiv$750$645<

Wirmsv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}> $ $

$$$$Xivq$pser $ ( ;;<0444 $ ( ;<:0444

$$$$Yreqsvxm~ih$hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw$sr$xivq$pser $ ,90854- $ ,:0<6:-

$$$$Yreqsvxm~ih$hmwgsyrx$sr$xivq$pser $ ,606<5- $ ,60<;<-

$$$$Vizspziv $ 9640:;5 $ 8=40<87

Xsxep$Wirmsv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx} $ ( 506=40=<4 $ ( 506:;057=

:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw> $ $ $ $

$$$$Rsxiw$Hyi$mr$646: $ ( 7940444 $ ( 7940444

$$$$Yreqsvxm~ih$hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw $ ,806<6- $ ,80<64-

Xsxep$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$Hyi$mr$646: $ ( 7890;5< $ ( 78905<4

92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw> $ $ $ $

$$$$Rsxiw$Hyi$mr$6468 $ ( 6940444 $ ( 6940444

$$$$Yreqsvxm~ih$hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw $ ,60976- $ ,60=;5-

Xsxep$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$Hyi$mr$6468 $ ( 68;08:< $ ( 68;046=

92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw> $ $ $ $

$$$$Rsxiw$Hyi$mr$6467 $ ( 7440444 $ ( 7440444

$$$$Yreqsvxm~ih$hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw $ ,60<;:- $ ,7098<-

Xsxep$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$Hyi$mr$6467 $ ( 6=;0568 $ ( 6=:0896

92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw> $ $ $ $

$$$$Rsxiw$Hyi$mr$6466 $ ( 5=70=9< $ ( 6940444

$$$$Yreqsvxm~ih$hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw $ ,50795- $ ,60958-

Xsxep$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$Hyi$mr$6466 $ ( 5=60:4; $ ( 68;08<:

Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Hifx> $ $ $

$$$$Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Hifx $ ( 76<05;< $ ( 78504;8

$$$$Yreqsvxm~ih$hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw$sr$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx $ ,906;=- $ ,70<<7-

$$$$Hmwgsyrx$sr$Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Hifx $ ,<5- $ ,5:8-

Xsxep$Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Hifx $ ( 7660<5< $ ( 77;046;

Jmrergi$Piewi$Sfpmkexmsrw $ 809;4 $ :049=

Sxliv$hifx $ 870854 $ 608:=

Xsxep$hifx $ ( 60;880:=9 $ ( 60;8<0<85

Gyvvirx$tsvxmsr$sj$jmrergi$piewi$sfpmkexmsrw0$psrk1xivq$hifx$erh$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx$_5a $ ,68064<- $ ,776046;-

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 173 of 253

Page 196: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5;7367<

Jmrergi$Piewi$Sfpmkexmsrw0$psrk1xivq$tsvxmsr $ ,60=98- $ ,809;4-

Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Hifx0$psrk1xivq$tsvxmsr $ ,74=067:- $ ,59045;-

Psrk1Xivq$Hifx $ ( 6084<06=; $ ( 607=;066;

_5a$Fepergi$ex$Higiqfiv$750$645<$mrgpyhiw$xli$fepergi$sj$xli$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx$vipexih$xs$Vezirlepp${lmgl0$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$xli

w}rhmgexih$jegmpmx}$ekviiqirx0$leh$xs$fi$vijmrergih$mr$Witxiqfiv$645=2$Ew$wygl0$xli$fepergi$lew$fiir$vijpigxih$ew$gyvvirx

557

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 174 of 253

Page 197: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5;8367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645<2$Mr$Qe}$645=0$xli$hifx${ew$vijmrergih$erh$xli$psrk1xivq$tsvxmsr${ew$vigpewwmjmih2

Eqirhih$erh$Viwxexih$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx

Sr$Nyri$560$645=0$KIS$irxivih$mrxs$Eqirhqirx$Rs2$6$xs$Xlmvh$Eqirhih$erh$Viwxexih$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$,xli$&Gvihmx

Ekviiqirx&-$f}$erh$eqsrk$xli$vijmrergmrk$pirhivw$tevx}$xlivixs0$xli$sxliv$pirhivw$tevx}$xlivixs0$KIS$erh$KIS$Gsvvigxmsrw$Lsphmrkw0

Mrg2$erh$xli$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$ekirx2$Yrhiv$xli$eqirhqirx0$xli$qexyvmx}$hexi$sj$xli$vizspziv$gsqtsrirx$sj$xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$lew$fiir

i|xirhih$xs$Qe}$5;0$64682$Xli$fsvvs{mrk$getegmx}$yrhiv$xli$eqirhih$vizspziv${mpp$viqemr$ex$(=44$qmppmsr0$erh$mxw$tvmgmrk${mpp$viqemr

yrglerkih0$gyvvirxp}$fievmrk$mrxiviwx$ex$PMFSV$tpyw$6269)2$Ew$e$viwypx$sj$xli$xverwegxmsr0$xli$Gsqter}$mrgyvvih$e$psww$sr

i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx$sj$(526$qmppmsr$vipexih$xs$givxemr$yreqsvxm~ih$hijivvih$pser$gswxw2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$pser$gswxw$sj$(82;$qmppmsr${ivi

mrgyvvih$erh$getmxepm~ih$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$xverwegxmsr2

Xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$izmhirgiw$e$gvihmx$jegmpmx}$,xli$&Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}&-$gsrwmwxmrk$sj$xli$(;=624$qmppmsr$xivq$pser$hmwgywwih

efszi$,xli$&Xivq$Pser&-$fievmrk$mrxiviwx$ex$PMFSV$tpyw$6244)$,{mxl$e$PMFSV$jpssv$sj$42;9)-0$erh$e$(=4424$qmppmsr$Vizspziv$mrmxmepp}

fievmrk$mrxiviwx$ex$PMFSV$tpyw$6269)$,{mxl$rs$PMFSV$jpssv-$xskixliv${mxl$EYH6;9$qmppmsr$ezempefpi$wspip}$jsv$xli$mwwyergi$sj

jmrergmep$pixxivw$sj$gvihmx$erh$tivjsvqergi$pixxivw$sj$gvihmx0$mr$iegl$gewi$hirsqmrexih$mr$Eywxvepmer$Hsppevw$yrhiv$xli$Eywxvepmer$Hsppev

Pixxiv$sj$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}$,xli$&Eywxvepmer$PG$Jegmpmx}&-2$Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$xlivi${ivi$rs$pixxivw$sj$gvihmx$mwwyih$yrhiv$xli

Eywxvepmer$PG$Jegmpmx}2$Eqsyrxw$xs$fi$fsvvs{ih$f}$KIS$yrhiv$xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$evi$wyfnigx$xs$xli$wexmwjegxmsr$sj$gywxsqev}

gsrhmxmsrw$xs$fsvvs{mrk2$Xli$Xivq$Pser$gsqtsrirx$mw$wglihypih$xs$qexyvi$sr$Qevgl$670$64682$Xli$vizspzmrk$gvihmx$gsqqmxqirx

gsqtsrirx$mw$wglihypih$xs$qexyvi$sr$Qe}$5;0$64682$Xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$epws$lew$er$eggsvhmsr$jiexyvi$sj$(89424$qmppmsr0$wyfnigx$xs

pirhiv$hiqerh$erh$tvizempmrk$qevoix$gsrhmxmsrw$erh$wexmwj}mrk$xli$vipizerx$fsvvs{mrk$gsrhmxmsrw2

Xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$gsrxemrw$givxemr$gywxsqev}$vitviwirxexmsrw$erh${evverxmiw0$erh$givxemr$gywxsqev}$gszirerxw$xlex

viwxvmgx$KIS×w$efmpmx}$xs0$eqsrk$sxliv$xlmrkw$,m-$gviexi0$mrgyv$sv$ewwyqi$er}$mrhifxihriww0$,mm-$gviexi0$mrgyv0$ewwyqi$sv$tivqmx$pmirw0$,mmm-

qeoi$pserw$erh$mrziwxqirxw0$,mz-$irkeki$mr$qivkivw0$eguymwmxmsrw$erh$ewwix$wepiw0$,z-$qeoi$givxemr$viwxvmgxih$te}qirxw0$,zm-$mwwyi0$wipp

sv$sxliv{mwi$hmwtswi$sj$getmxep$wxsgo0$,zmm-$irkeki$mr$xverwegxmsrw${mxl$ejjmpmexiw0$,zmmm-$epps{$xli$xsxep$piziveki$vexms$xs$i|giih$:269$xs

52440$epps{$xli$wirmsv$wigyvih$piziveki$vexms$xs$i|giih$7294$xs$52440$sv$epps{$xli$mrxiviwx$gsziveki$vexms$xs$fi$piww$xler$7244$xs$52440$,m|-

gergip0$jsvkmzi0$qeoi$er}$zspyrxev}$sv$stxmsrep$te}qirx$sv$tvite}qirx$sr0$sv$vihiiq$sv$eguymvi$jsv$zepyi$er}$wirmsv$rsxiw0$i|gitx$ew

tivqmxxih0$,|-$epxiv$xli$fywmriww$KIS$gsrhygxw0$erh$,|m-$qexivmepp}$mqtemv$KIS×w$pirhivw×$wigyvmx}$mrxiviwxw$mr$xli$gsppexivep$jsv$mxw

pserw2

Izirxw$sj$hijeypx$yrhiv$xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$mrgpyhi0$fyx$evi$rsx$pmqmxih$xs0$,m-$KIS×w$jempyvi$xs$te}$tvmrgmtep$sv$mrxiviwx

{lir$hyi0$,mm-$KIS×w$qexivmep$fviegl$sj$er}$vitviwirxexmsr$sv${evverx}0$,mmm-$gszirerx$hijeypxw0$,mz-$pmuymhexmsr0$visvkerm~exmsr$sv$sxliv

vipmij$vipexmrk$xs$ferovytxg}$sv$mrwspzirg}0$,z-$gvsww$hijeypx$yrhiv$givxemr$sxliv$qexivmep$mrhifxihriww0$,zm-$yrwexmwjmih$jmrep$nyhkqirxw

sziv$e$wtigmjmih$xlviwlsph0$,zmm-$givxemr$qexivmep$irzmvsrqirxep$pmefmpmx}$gpemqw$ewwivxih$ekemrwx$KIS0$erh$,zmmm-$e$glerki$mr$gsrxvsp2

Epp$sj$xli$sfpmkexmsrw$yrhiv$xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$evi$yrgsrhmxmsrepp}$kyeverxiih$f}$givxemr$hsqiwxmg$wyfwmhmevmiw$sj$KIS

erh$xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$erh$xli$vipexih$kyeverxiiw$evi$wigyvih$f}$e$tivjigxih$jmvwx1tvmsvmx}$tpihki$sj$wyfwxerxmepp}$epp$sj$KIS×w

tviwirx$erh$jyxyvi$xerkmfpi$erh$mrxerkmfpi$hsqiwxmg$ewwixw$erh$epp$tviwirx$erh$jyxyvi$xerkmfpi$erh$mrxerkmfpi$hsqiwxmg$ewwixw$sj$iegl

kyeverxsv0$mrgpyhmrk$fyx$rsx$pmqmxih$xs$e$jmvwx1tvmsvmx}$tpihki$sj$epp$sj$xli$syxwxerhmrk$getmxep$wxsgo$s{rih$f}$KIS$erh$iegl$kyeverxsv

mr$xlimv$hsqiwxmg$wyfwmhmevmiw2

Xli$Eywxvepmer$fsvvs{ivw$evi${lspp}$s{rih$jsvimkr$wyfwmhmevmiw$sj$KIS2$KIS$lew$hiwmkrexih$iegl$sj$xli$Eywxvepmer

fsvvs{ivw$ew$viwxvmgxih$wyfwmhmevmiw$yrhiv$xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx2$Ls{iziv0$xli$Eywxvepmer$fsvvs{ivw$evi$rsx$sfpmkexih$xs$te}$sv

tivjsvq$er}$sfpmkexmsrw$yrhiv$xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$sxliv$xler$xlimv$s{r$sfpmkexmsrw$ew$Eywxvepmer$fsvvs{ivw$yrhiv$xli$Gvihmx

Ekviiqirx2$Xli$Eywxvepmer$fsvvs{ivw$hs$rsx$tpihki$er}$sj$xlimv$ewwixw$xs$wigyvi$er}$sfpmkexmsrw$yrhiv$xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx2

Sr$Eykywx$5<0$645:0$xli$Gsqter}$i|igyxih$e$Pixxiv$sj$Sjjiv$f}$erh$eqsrk$KIS$erh$LWFG$Fero$Eywxvepme$Pmqmxih$,xli

ÔPixxiv$sj$SjjivÕ-$tvszmhmrk$jsv$e$fero$kyeverxii$pmri$erh$fero$kyeverxii3wxerhf}$wyf1jegmpmx}$mr$er$ekkvikexi$eqsyrx$sj$EYH544

qmppmsr0$sv$(;425$qmppmsr0$fewih$sr$i|glerki$vexiw$mr$ijjigx$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=$,gsppigxmzip}0$xli$ÔFero$Kyeverxii$Jegmpmx}Õ-2$Xli

Fero$Kyeverxii$Jegmpmx}$epps{w$KIS$xs$tvszmhi$pixxivw$sj$gvihmx$xs$ewwyvi$tivjsvqergi$sj$givxemr$sfpmkexmsrw$sj$mxw${lspp}$s{rih

wyfwmhmev}$vipexmrk$xs$mxw$wigyvi$jegmpmx}$tvsnigx$mr$Vezirlepp0$psgexih$riev$Qipfsyvri0$Eywxvepme2$Mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$xli$Vezirlepp

Gsrxvegx0$ytsr$xli$gsqtpixmsr$sj$e$givxemr$tivmsh$sj$stivexmsrw0$xli$Fero$Kyeverxii$Jegmpmx}${ew$vihygih$hyvmrk$xli$jsyvxl$uyevxiv$sj

645=$xs$ettvs|mqexip}$EYH9<$qmppmsr0$sv$(842;$qmppmsr0$fewih$sr$i|glerki$vexiw$mr$ijjigx$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=2$Xli$Fero

Kyeverxii$Jegmpmx}$mw$yrwigyvih2$Xli$mwwyergi$sj$pixxivw$sj$gvihmx$yrhiv$xli$Fero$Kyeverxii$Jegmpmx}$mw$wyfnigx$xs$xli$wexmwjegxmsr$sj$xli

gsrhmxmsrw$tvigihirx$wtigmjmih$mr$xli$Pixxiv$sj$Sjjiv2$Pixxivw$sj$gvihmx

558

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 175 of 253

Page 198: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5;9367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

mwwyih$yrhiv$xli$fero$kyeverxii$pmriw$evi$hyi$sr$hiqerh$erh$pixxivw$sj$gvihmx$mwwyih$yrhiv$xli$fero$kyeverxii3wxerhf}$wyf1jegmpmx}

gerrsx$lezi$e$hyvexmsr$i|giihmrk$x{ipzi$qsrxlw2$Xli$Fero$Kyeverxii$Jegmpmx}$qe}$fi$xivqmrexih$f}$LWFG$Fero$Eywxvepme$Pmqmxih

sr$=4$he}w${vmxxir$rsxmgi2$Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$xlivi${ew$ettvs|mqexip}$EYH9<$qmppmsr$mr$pixxivw$sj$gvihmx$mwwyih$yrhiv$xli$Fero

Kyeverxii$Jegmpmx}2

Ew$ sj$Higiqfiv$ 750$ 645=0$ xli$ Gsqter}$ leh$ (;;<24$qmppmsr$ mr$ ekkvikexi$ fsvvs{mrkw$ syxwxerhmrk$ yrhiv$ xli$ Xivq$ Pser0

(9642;$qmppmsr$ mr$ fsvvs{mrkw$yrhiv$ xli$Vizspziv0$ erh$ ettvs|mqexip}$(:624$qmppmsr$ mr$ pixxivw$ sj$ gvihmx${lmgl$ pijx$ (75;24$qmppmsr$ mr

ehhmxmsrep$fsvvs{mrk$getegmx}$yrhiv$xli$Vizspziv2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$xli$Gsqter}$lew$xli$efmpmx}$xs$mrgviewi$xli$Wirmsv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}$f}$er

ehhmxmsrep$(89424$qmppmsr0$wyfnigx$xs$pirhiv$hiqerh$erh$tvizempmrk$qevoix$gsrhmxmsrw$erh$wexmwj}mrk$xli$vipizerx$fsvvs{mrk$gsrhmxmsrw

xliviyrhiv2$Xli${imklxih$eziveki$mrxiviwx$vexi$sr$syxwxerhmrk$fsvvs{mrkw$yrhiv$xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=${ew

72<)2

:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$646:

Sr$Etvmp$5<0$645:0$xli$Gsqter}$gsqtpixih$er$sjjivmrk$sj$(79424$qmppmsr$ekkvikexi$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj$:244)$wirmsv$rsxiw

hyi$646:2$Xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw${ivi$sjjivih$erh$wsph$mr$e$vikmwxivih$sjjivmrk$tyvwyerx$xs$er$yrhiv{vmxmrk$ekviiqirx0$hexih$ew$sj

Etvmp$550$645:$,xli$ÔYrhiv{vmxmrk$EkviiqirxÕ-$eqsrk$xli$Gsqter}0$givxemr$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$hsqiwxmg$wyfwmhmevmiw0$ew$kyeverxsvw

erh$[ippw$Jevks$Wigyvmxmiw0$PPG0$ew$vitviwirxexmzi$jsv$xli$yrhiv{vmxivw$reqih$xlivimr2$Xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw${ivi$mwwyih$f}$xli

Gsqter}$tyvwyerx$xs$xli$Mrhirxyvi0$hexih$ew$sj$Witxiqfiv$690$6458$,xli$ÔFewi$MrhirxyviÕ-0$f}$erh$fix{iir$xli$Gsqter}$erh$[ippw

Jevks$Fero0$Rexmsrep$Ewwsgmexmsr0$ew$xvywxii0$ew$wyttpiqirxih$f}$e$Wigsrh$Wyttpiqirxep$Mrhirxyvi0$hexih$ew$sj$Etvmp$5<0$645:$,xli

ÔWigsrh$Wyttpiqirxep$MrhirxyviÕ$erh$xskixliv${mxl$xli$Fewi$Mrhirxyvi0$xli$ÔMrhirxyviÕ-0$f}$erh$eqsrk$xli$Gsqter}0$xli$kyeverxsvw

erh$xli$xvywxii${lmgl$kszivrw$xli$xivqw$sj$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw2$Xli$wepi$sj$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw${ew$vikmwxivih$yrhiv$KIS×w

tvmsv$wlipj$vikmwxvexmsr$wxexiqirx$sr$Jsvq$W17$jmpih$sr$Witxiqfiv$560$64580$ew$eqirhih$,Jmpi$Rs2$77715=<;6=-2$Xli$:244)$Wirmsv

Rsxiw${ivi$mwwyih$ex$e$gsytsr$vexi$erh$}miph$xs$qexyvmx}$sj$:244)2$Mrxiviwx$sr$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$mw$te}efpi$wiqm1erryepp}$sr

Etvmp$59$erh$Sgxsfiv$59$sj$iegl$}iev0$gsqqirgmrk$sr$Sgxsfiv$590$645:2$Xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$qexyvi$sr$Etvmp$590$646:2$Xli

Gsqter}$ywih$xli$rix$tvsgiihw$xs$jyrh$xli$xirhiv$sjjiv$erh$xli$vihiqtxmsr$sj$epp$sj$mxw$:2:69)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$,wii$hmwgywwmsr$fips{-0$xs

te}$epp$vipexih$jiiw0$gswxw$erh$i|tirwiw$erh$jsv$kirivep$gsvtsvexi$tyvtswiw$mrgpyhmrk$vite}mrk$fsvvs{mrkw$yrhiv$xli$Gsqter}+w

Vizspziv2

Yt$xs$79)$sj$xli$ekkvikexi$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$gsyph$lezi$fiir$vihiiqih$sr$sv$tvmsv$xs$Etvmp$590

645=0${mxl$xli$rix$gewl$tvsgiihw$jvsq$givxemr$iuymx}$sjjivmrkw$ex$e$vihiqtxmsr$tvmgi$iuyep$xs$54:2444)$sj$xlimv$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx0$tpyw

eggvyih$erh$yrtemh$mrxiviwx0$mj$er}0$xs$xli$vihiqtxmsr$hexi2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$KIS$qe}0$ex$mxw$stxmsr0$vihiiq$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$mr

{lspi$sv$mr$tevx$fijsvi$Etvmp$590$6465$ex$e$vihiqtxmsr$tvmgi$iuyep$xs$544)$sj$xli$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$fimrk

vihiiqih$tpyw$e$Ôqeoi1{lspiÕ$tviqmyq0$xskixliv${mxl$eggvyih$erh$yrtemh$mrxiviwx0$mj$er}0$xs$xli$vihiqtxmsr$hexi2

Sr$sv$ejxiv$Etvmp$590$64650$KIS$qe}0$ex$mxw$stxmsr0$vihiiq$epp$sv$tevx$sj$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$ytsr$rsx$piww$xler$74$rsv

qsvi$xler$:4$he}w×$rsxmgi0$ex$xli$vihiqtxmsr$tvmgiw$,i|tviwwih$ew$tivgirxekiw$sj$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx-$wix$jsvxl$fips{0$tpyw$eggvyih$erh

yrtemh$mrxiviwx0$mj$er}0$sr$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$vihiiqih0$xs$xli$ettpmgefpi$vihiqtxmsr$hexi0$mj$vihiiqih$hyvmrk$xli$561qsrxl

tivmsh$fikmrrmrk$sr$Etvmp$59$sj$xli$}ievw$mrhmgexih$fips{>

$ $ $

]iev $$ Tivgirxeki

6465 $$ 5472444)

6466 $$ 5462444)

6467 $$ 5452444)

6468$erh$xliviejxiv $$ 5442444)

Mj$xlivi$mw$e$Ôglerki$sj$gsrxvspÕ$,ew$hijmrih$mr$xli$Mrhirxyvi-0$lsphivw$sj$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw${mpp$lezi$xli$vmklx$xs$geywi

KIS$xs$vityvglewi$xlimv$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$ex$e$tvmgi$iuyep$xs$545)$sj$xli$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$vityvglewih

tpyw$eggvyih$erh$yrtemh$mrxiviwx0$mj$er}0$xs$xli$tyvglewi$hexi2

Xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$evi$kyeverxiih$sr$e$wirmsv$yrwigyvih$fewmw$f}$xli$kyeverxsvw2$Xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$erh$xli

kyeverxiiw$evi$yrwigyvih0$yrwyfsvhmrexih$sfpmkexmsrw$sj$KIS$erh$xli$kyeverxsvw2$Xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$vero$iuyepp}$mr$vmklx$sj

te}qirx${mxl$er}$yrwigyvih0$yrwyfsvhmrexih$mrhifxihriww$sj$KIS$erh$xli$kyeverxsvw0$mrgpyhmrk$KIS×w$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi

64660$xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6467$erh$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$64680$erh$xli$kyeverxsvw×$kyeverxiiw$xlivisj0$wirmsv$mr$vmklx

sj$te}qirx$xs$er}$jyxyvi$mrhifxihriww$sj$KIS$erh$xli$kyeverxsvw$xlex$mw$i|tviwwp}$wyfsvhmrexih$xs$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$erh$xli

kyeverxiiw0$ijjigxmzip}$nyrmsv$xs$er}$wigyvih$mrhifxihriww$sj$KIS$erh$xli

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 176 of 253

Page 199: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5;:367<

559

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 177 of 253

Page 200: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5;;367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

kyeverxsvw0$mrgpyhmrk$mrhifxihriww$yrhiv$KIS×w$Wirmsv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}0$xs$xli$i|xirx$sj$xli$zepyi$sj$xli$ewwixw$wigyvmrk$wygl

mrhifxihriww0$erh$wxvygxyvepp}$nyrmsv$xs$epp$sfpmkexmsrw$sj$KIS×w$wyfwmhmevmiw$xlex$evi$rsx$kyeverxsvw0$mrgpyhmrk$xvehi$te}efpiw2

Xli$Mrhirxyvi$gsrxemrw$gszirerxw${lmgl0$eqsrk$sxliv$xlmrkw0$pmqmx$xli$efmpmx}$sj$KIS$erh$mxw$Ôviwxvmgxih$wyfwmhmevmiwÕ$,ew

hijmrih$mr$xli$Mrhirxyvi-$xs$mrgyv$ehhmxmsrep$mrhifxihriww$sv$mwwyi$tvijivvih$wxsgo0$qeoi$hmzmhirh$te}qirxw$sv$sxliv$viwxvmgxih

te}qirxw$,sxliv$xler$xli$te}qirx$sj$hmzmhirhw$sv$sxliv$hmwxvmfyxmsrw0$sv$er}$sxliv$egxmsrw$rigiwwev}$xs$qemrxemr$KIS×w$wxexyw$ew$e$viep

iwxexi$mrziwxqirx$xvywx-0$gviexi$pmirw0$wipp$ewwixw0$irkeki$mr$wepi$erh$piewi$fego$xverwegxmsrw0$gviexi$sv$tivqmx$viwxvmgxmsrw$sr$xli$efmpmx}$sj

xli$viwxvmgxih$wyfwmhmevmiw$xs$te}$hmzmhirhw$sv$qeoi$sxliv$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$xs$KIS0$irxiv$mrxs$xverwegxmsrw${mxl$ejjmpmexiw0$erh$irxiv$mrxs

qivkivw0$gsrwspmhexmsrw$sv$wepiw$sj$epp$sv$wyfwxerxmepp}$epp$sj$xlimv$ewwixw2$Xliwi$gszirerxw$evi$wyfnigx$xs$e$ryqfiv$sj$pmqmxexmsrw$erh

i|gitxmsrw$ew$wix$jsvxl$mr$xli$Mrhirxyvi2

Xli$Mrhirxyvi$epws$gsrxemrw$izirxw$sj$hijeypx${mxl$viwtigx$xs0$eqsrk$sxliv$xlmrkw0$xli$jspps{mrk>$jempyvi$f}$KIS$xs$te}

mrxiviwx$sr$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw${lir$hyi0${lmgl$jempyvi$gsrxmryiw$jsv$74$he}w?$jempyvi$f}$KIS$xs$te}$xli$tvmrgmtep$sj0$sv$tviqmyq0

mj$er}0$sr0$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw${lir$hyi?$jempyvi$f}$KIS$sv$er}$sj$mxw$viwxvmgxih$wyfwmhmevmiw$xs$gsqtp}${mxl$xlimv$sfpmkexmsrw$xs

sjjiv$xs$vityvglewi$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$ex$xli$stxmsr$sj$xli$lsphivw$sj$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$ytsr$e$glerki$sj$gsrxvsp0$xs$sjjiv$xs

vihiiq$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$yrhiv$givxemr$gmvgyqwxergiw$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$ewwix$wepiw${mxl$Ôi|giww$tvsgiihwÕ$,ew$hijmrih$mr$xli

Mrhirxyvi-$mr$i|giww$sj$(9424$qmppmsr$sv$xs$sfwivzi$givxemr$viwxvmgxmsrw$sr$qivkivw0$gsrwspmhexmsrw$erh$wepiw$sj$wyfwxerxmepp}$epp$sj$xlimv

ewwixw?$xli$jempyvi$f}$KIS$sv$er}$kyeverxsv$xs$gsqtp}${mxl$er}$sj$xli$sxliv$ekviiqirxw$mr$xli$Mrhirxyvi0${lmgl$jempyvi$gsrxmryiw$jsv$:4

he}w$ejxiv$rsxmgi?$erh$givxemr$izirxw$sj$ferovytxg}$sv$mrwspzirg}$sj$KIS$sv$e$viwxvmgxih$wyfwmhmev}$xlex$mw$e$wmkrmjmgerx$wyfwmhmev}$sv

er}$kvsyt$sj$viwxvmgxih$wyfwmhmevmiw$xlex$xskixliv${syph$gsrwxmxyxi$e$wmkrmjmgerx$wyfwmhmev}2

92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468

Sr$Witxiqfiv$690$64580$xli$Gsqter}$gsqtpixih$er$sjjivmrk$sj$(69424$qmppmsr$ekkvikexi$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj$wirmsv

yrwigyvih$rsxiw$,xli$&92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468&-2$Xli$rsxiw${mpp$qexyvi$sr$Sgxsfiv$590$6468$erh$lezi$e$gsytsr$vexi$erh$}miph$xs

qexyvmx}$sj$92<;9)2$Mrxiviwx$mw$te}efpi$wiqm1erryepp}$mr$gewl$mr$evvievw$sr$Etvmp$59$erh$Sgxsfiv$590$fikmrrmrk$Etvmp$590$64592$Xli

92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468$evi$kyeverxiih$sr$e$wirmsv$yrwigyvih$fewmw$f}$epp$xli$Gsqter}×w$viwxvmgxih$wyfwmhmevmiw$xlex$kyeverxii

sfpmkexmsrw2$Xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468$vero$iuyepp}$mr$vmklx$sj$te}qirx${mxl$er}$yrwigyvih0$yrwyfsvhmrexih$mrhifxihriww$sj

xli$Gsqter}$erh$xli$kyeverxsvw0$mrgpyhmrk$xli$Gsqter}×w$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$64660$xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$64670$xli

:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$646:0$erh$xli$kyeverxsvw×$kyeverxiiw$xlivisj0$wirmsv$mr$vmklx$sj$te}qirx$xs$er}$jyxyvi$mrhifxihriww$sj$xli

Gsqter}$erh$xli$kyeverxsvw$xlex$mw$i|tviwwp}$wyfsvhmrexih$xs$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468$erh$xli$kyeverxiiw0$ijjigxmzip}$nyrmsv

xs$er}$wigyvih$mrhifxihriww$sj$xli$Gsqter}$erh$xli$kyeverxsvw0$mrgpyhmrk$mrhifxihriww$yrhiv$xli$Gsqter}×w$Wirmsv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}0$xs

xli$i|xirx$sj$xli$zepyi$sj$xli$ewwixw$wigyvmrk$wygl$mrhifxihriww0$erh$wxvygxyvepp}$nyrmsv$xs$epp$sfpmkexmsrw$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$wyfwmhmevmiw

xlex$evi$rsx$kyeverxsvw2$Xli$wepi$sj$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468${ew$vikmwxivih$yrhiv$xli$Gsqter}+w$tvmsv$wlipj$vikmwxvexmsr

wxexiqirx$sr$Jsvq$W17$jmpih$sr$Witxiqfiv$560$64580$ew$wyttpiqirxih$f}$xli$Tvipmqmrev}$Tvswtigxyw$Wyttpiqirx$jmpih$sr$Witxiqfiv

660$6458$erh$xli$Tvswtigxyw$Wyttpiqirx$jmpih$sr$Witxiqfiv$680$64582

Xli$Gsqter}$gsyph$lezi0$ex$mxw$stxmsr0$vihiiqih$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468$mr${lspi$sv$mr$tevx$fijsvi$Sgxsfiv$590

645=$ex$e$vihiqtxmsr$tvmgi$iuyep$xs$544)$sj$xli$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468$fimrk$vihiiqih$tpyw$e$Ôqeoi1

{lspiÕ$tviqmyq0$xskixliv${mxl$eggvyih$erh$yrtemh$mrxiviwx0$mj$er}0$xs$xli$vihiqtxmsr$hexi2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$xli$Gsqter}$qe}0$ex$mxw$stxmsr0

vihiiq$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468$mr${lspi$sv$mr$tevx$sr$sv$ejxiv$Sgxsfiv$590$645=$xlvsykl$6468$erh$xliviejxiv$ew$mrhmgexih

fips{>

$

$ $ $

]iev $$ Tivgirxeki

6464 $$ 5452=9<)

6465 $$ 5442=;=)

6466$erh$xliviejxiv $$ 5442444)

Xli$mrhirxyvi$gsrxemrw$gszirerxw${lmgl0$eqsrk$sxliv$xlmrkw0$pmqmx$xli$efmpmx}$sj$xli$Gsqter}$erh$mxw$viwxvmgxih

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 178 of 253

Page 201: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5;<367<

55:

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 179 of 253

Page 202: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5;=367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

wyfwmhmevmiw$xs$mrgyv$ehhmxmsrep$mrhifxihriww$sv$mwwyi$tvijivvih$wxsgo0$qeoi$hmzmhirh$te}qirxw$sv$sxliv$viwxvmgxih$te}qirxw$,sxliv$xler

xli$te}qirx$sj$hmzmhirhw$sv$sxliv$hmwxvmfyxmsrw0$sv$er}$sxliv$egxmsrw$rigiwwev}$xs$qemrxemr$xli$Gsqter}×w$wxexyw$ew$e$viep$iwxexi

mrziwxqirx$xvywx-0$gviexi$pmirw0$wipp$ewwixw0$irkeki$mr$wepi$erh$piewi$fego$xverwegxmsrw0$gviexi$sv$tivqmx$viwxvmgxmsrw$sr$xli$efmpmx}$sj$xli

viwxvmgxih$wyfwmhmevmiw$xs$te}$hmzmhirhw$sv$qeoi$sxliv$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$xs$xli$Gsqter}0$irxiv$mrxs$xverwegxmsrw${mxl$ejjmpmexiw0$erh$irxiv$mrxs

qivkivw0$gsrwspmhexmsrw$sv$wepiw$sj$epp$sv$wyfwxerxmepp}$epp$sj$xlimv$ewwixw2$Xliwi$gszirerxw$evi$wyfnigx$xs$e$ryqfiv$sj$pmqmxexmsrw$erh

i|gitxmsrw$ew$wix$jsvxl$mr$xli$mrhirxyvi2

Xli$mrhirxyvi$epws$gsrxemrw$izirxw$sj$hijeypx${mxl$viwtigx$xs0$eqsrk$sxliv$xlmrkw0$xli$jspps{mrk>$jempyvi$f}$xli$Gsqter}$xs

te}$mrxiviwx$sr$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468${lir$hyi0${lmgl$jempyvi$gsrxmryiw$jsv$74$he}w?$jempyvi$f}$xli$Gsqter}$xs$te}$xli

tvmrgmtep$sj0$sv$tviqmyq0$mj$er}0$sr0$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468${lir$hyi?$jempyvi$f}$xli$Gsqter}$sv$er}$sj$mxw$viwxvmgxih

wyfwmhmevmiw$xs$gsqtp}${mxl$xlimv$sfpmkexmsrw$xs$sjjiv$xs$vityvglewi$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468$ex$xli$stxmsr$sj$xli$lsphivw$sj

xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468$ytsr$e$glerki$sj$gsrxvsp0$xs$sjjiv$xs$vihiiq$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468$yrhiv$givxemr

gmvgyqwxergiw$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$ewwix$wepiw${mxl$i|giww$tvsgiihw$mr$i|giww$sj$(6924$qmppmsr$sv$xs$sfwivzi$givxemr$viwxvmgxmsrw$sr

qivkivw0$gsrwspmhexmsrw$erh$wepiw$sj$wyfwxerxmepp}$epp$sj$xlimv$ewwixw?$xli$jempyvi$f}$xli$Gsqter}$sv$er}$kyeverxsv$xs$gsqtp}${mxl$er}$sj

xli$sxliv$ekviiqirxw$mr$xli$mrhirxyvi0${lmgl$jempyvi$gsrxmryiw$jsv$:4$he}w$ejxiv$rsxmgi?$erh$givxemr$izirxw$sj$ferovytxg}$sv$mrwspzirg}

sj$KIS$sv$e$viwxvmgxih$wyfwmhmev}$xlex$mw$e$wmkrmjmgerx$wyfwmhmev}$sv$er}$kvsyt$sj$viwxvmgxih$wyfwmhmevmiw$xlex$xskixliv${syph$gsrwxmxyxi$e

wmkrmjmgerx$wyfwmhmev}2$Xli$Gsqter}${ew$mr$gsqtpmergi${mxl$epp$sj$xli$jmrergmep$gszirerxw$sj$xli$mrhirxyvi$kszivrmrk$xli$92<;9)

Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=2

92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6467

Sr$Qevgl$5=0$64570$ xli$Gsqter}$gsqtpixih$er$sjjivmrk$sj$(74424$qmppmsr$ekkvikexi$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj$wirmsv$yrwigyvih

rsxiw$ mr$ e$ tvmzexi$ sjjivmrk$ yrhiv$ xli$ Mrhirxyvi$ hexih$ ew$ sj$ Qevgl$ 5=0$ 6457$ eqsrk$ KIS0$ givxemr$ sj$ mxw$ hsqiwxmg$ wyfwmhmevmiw0$ ew

kyeverxsvw0$ erh$[ippw$ Jevks$Fero0$Rexmsrep$Ewwsgmexmsr0$ ew$ xvywxii2$ Xli$ 92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw${ivi$ sjjivih$ erh$ wsph$ xs$ &uyepmjmih

mrwxmxyxmsrep$fy}ivw&$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$Vypi$588E$yrhiv$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$Egx$sj$5=770$ew$eqirhih$,xli$&Wigyvmxmiw$Egx&-0$erh$syxwmhi

xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw$xs$rsr1Y2W2$tivwsrw$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$Vikypexmsr$W$yrhiv$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$Egx2$Xli$rsxiw${mpp$qexyvi$sr$Etvmp$50$6467

erh$ lezi$ e$ gsytsr$ vexi$ erh$ }miph$ xs$ qexyvmx}$ sj$ 92569)2$ Mrxiviwx$ mw$ te}efpi$ wiqm1erryepp}$ sr$ Etvmp$ 5$ erh$ Sgxsfiv$ 5$ iegl$ }iev0

fikmrrmrk$Sgxsfiv$50$64572$Xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$evi$kyeverxiih$sr$e$wirmsv$yrwigyvih$fewmw$f}$epp$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$viwxvmgxih

wyfwmhmevmiw$ xlex$kyeverxii$sfpmkexmsrw$yrhiv$ xli$Wirmsv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}0$ xli$Gsqter}+w$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$ xli$Gsqter}+w$92<;9)

Wirmsv$ Rsxiw$ hyi$ 6466$ erh$ xli$ 92<;9)$ Wirmsv$Rsxiw$ hyi$ 64682$ Xli$ 92569)$ Wirmsv$ Rsxiw$ erh$ xli$ kyeverxiiw$ evi$ xli$ Gsqter}+w

kirivep$yrwigyvih$wirmsv$sfpmkexmsrw$erh$vero$iuyepp}$mr$vmklx$sj$te}qirx${mxl$epp$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$erh$xli$kyeverxsvw+$i|mwxmrk$erh

jyxyvi$yrwigyvih$wirmsv$hifx0$mrgpyhmrk$xli$Gsqter}+w$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466$erh$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv

Rsxiw$hyi$64682$Xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$erh$xli$kyeverxiiw$evi$ijjigxmzip}$wyfsvhmrexih$xs$er}$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$erh$xli$kyeverxsvw+

i|mwxmrk$erh$jyxyvi$wigyvih$hifx$xs$xli$i|xirx$sj$xli$zepyi$sj$xli$ewwixw$wigyvmrk$wygl$hifx0$mrgpyhmrk$epp$erxmgmtexih$fsvvs{mrkw$yrhiv

xli$Wirmsv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}2$Xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$evi$wxvygxyvepp}$wyfsvhmrexih$xs$epp$i|mwxmrk$erh$jyxyvi$pmefmpmxmiw$,mrgpyhmrk$xvehi

te}efpiw-$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$wyfwmhmevmiw$xlex$hs$rsx$kyeverxii$xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw2

$$$$

Ex$er}$xmqi$tvmsv$xs$Etvmp$50$645<0$xli$Gsqter}$gsyph$lezi0$ex$mxw$stxmsr0$vihiiqih$epp$sv$e$tevx$sj$xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw

ytsr$rsx$ piww$ xler$74$he}w$rsv$qsvi$ xler$:4$he}w$tvmsv$rsxmgi$ex$ e$ vihiqtxmsr$tvmgi$ iuyep$ xs$ xli$ wyq$sj$ ,m-$544)$sj$ xli$ tvmrgmtep

eqsyrx$ xlivisj0$ tpyw$ ,mm-$ xli$Ettpmgefpi$ Tviqmyq$ ,ew$hijmrih$ mr$ xli$ mrhirxyvi-$ ew$ sj$ xli$hexi$sj$ vihiqtxmsr0$ tpyw$ ,mmm-$ eggvyih$ erh

yrtemh$mrxiviwx$erh$pmuymhexih$heqekiw0$mj$er}0$xs$xli$hexi$sj$vihiqtxmsr2$Sr$sv$ejxiv$Etvmp$50$645<0$xli$Gsqter}$qe}0$ex$mxw$stxmsr0

vihiiq$epp$sv$e$tevx$sj$ xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$ytsr$rsx$ piww$ xler$74$he}w$rsv$qsvi$ xler$:4$he}w$rsxmgi$ ex$ xli$ vihiqtxmsr$tvmgiw

,i|tviwwih$ew$tivgirxekiw$sj$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx-$wix$jsvxl$fips{0$tpyw$eggvyih$erh$yrtemh$mrxiviwx$erh$pmuymhexih$heqekiw0$mj$er}0$sr$xli

92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$vihiiqih0$xs$ xli$ettpmgefpi$vihiqtxmsr$hexi0$ mj$ vihiiqih$hyvmrk$ xli$tivmsh$fikmrrmrk$sr$Etvmp$5$sj$xli$}ievw

mrhmgexih$fips{>

]iev Tivgirxeki

6464 5442<98)

6465$erh$xliviejxiv 5442444)

$$$$

Mj$xlivi$mw$e$&glerki$sj$gsrxvsp&$,ew$hijmrih$mr$xli$Mrhirxyvi-0$lsphivw$sj$xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw${mpp$lezi$xli$vmklx$xs$geywi$KIS$xs

vityvglewi$xlimv$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$ex$e$tvmgi$iuyep$xs$545)$sj$xli$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj$xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$vityvglewih$tpyw

eggvyih$erh$yrtemh$mrxiviwx$erh$pmuymhexih$heqekiw0$mj$er}0$xs$xli$tyvglewi$hexi2

55;

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 180 of 253

Page 203: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5<4367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Xli$ mrhirxyvi$kszivrmrk$ xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$ gsrxemrw$ givxemr$ gszirerxw0$ mrgpyhmrk$ pmqmxexmsrw$ erh$ viwxvmgxmsrw$sr$ xli

Gsqter}$erh$mxw$viwxvmgxih$wyfwmhmevmiw×$efmpmx}$xs>$mrgyv$ehhmxmsrep$mrhifxihriww$sv$mwwyi$tvijivvih$wxsgo?$qeoi$hmzmhirh$te}qirxw$sv

sxliv$viwxvmgxih$te}qirxw?$gviexi$pmirw?$wipp$ewwixw?$irxiv$mrxs$xverwegxmsrw${mxl$ejjmpmexiw?$erh$irxiv$mrxs$qivkivw0$gsrwspmhexmsrw$sv$wepiw

sj$epp$sv$wyfwxerxmepp}$epp$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$ewwixw2$Ew$sj$xli$hexi$sj$xli$mrhirxyvi0$epp$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$wyfwmhmevmiw0$sxliv$xler$givxemr

hsvqerx$ hsqiwxmg$ erh$ sxliv$ wyfwmhmevmiw$ erh$ epp$ jsvimkr$ wyfwmhmevmiw$ mr$ i|mwxirgi$ sr$ xli$ hexi$ sj$ xli$ mrhirxyvi0$ {ivi$ viwxvmgxih

wyfwmhmevmiw2$Xli$Gsqter}×w$jempyvi$xs$gsqtp}${mxl$givxemr$sj$xli$gszirerxw$yrhiv$xli$mrhirxyvi$kszivrmrk$xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw

gsyph$geywi$er$izirx$sj$hijeypx$sj$er}$mrhifxihriww$erh$viwypx$ mr$er$eggipivexmsr$sj$wygl$ mrhifxihriww2$ Mr$ehhmxmsr0$ xlivi$ mw$e$gvsww1

hijeypx$tvszmwmsr${lmgl$figsqiw$irjsvgiefpi$ytsr$jempyvi$sj$te}qirx$sj$mrhifxihriww$ex$jmrep$qexyvmx}2$Xli$Gsqter}×w$yrviwxvmgxih

wyfwmhmevmiw${mpp$rsx$fi$wyfnigx$ xs$er}$sj$xli$viwxvmgxmzi$gszirerxw$ mr$ xli$ mrhirxyvi2$Xli$Gsqter}${ew$mr$gsqtpmergi${mxl$epp$sj$ xli

jmrergmep$gszirerxw$sj$xli$mrhirxyvi$kszivrmrk$xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=2

Xli$mrhirxyvi$epws$gsrxemrw$izirxw$sj$hijeypx${mxl$viwtigx$xs0$eqsrk$sxliv$xlmrkw0$ xli$jspps{mrk>$jempyvi$f}$xli$Gsqter}$xs

te}$mrxiviwx$erh$pmuymhexih$heqekiw0$mj$er}0$sr$xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw${lir$hyi0${lmgl$jempyvi$gsrxmryiw$jsv$74$he}w?$jempyvi$f}$xli

Gsqter}$xs$te}$ xli$tvmrgmtep$sj0$sv$tviqmyq0$ mj$er}0$sr0$ xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw${lir$hyi?$ jempyvi$f}$ xli$Gsqter}$sv$er}$sj$ mxw

viwxvmgxih$wyfwmhmevmiw$xs$gsqtp}${mxl$xlimv$sfpmkexmsrw$xs$sjjiv$xs$vityvglewi$xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$ex$xli$stxmsr$sj$xli$lsphivw$sj

xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$ytsr$e$glerki$sj$gsrxvsp0$xs$sjjiv$xs$vihiiq$rsxiw$yrhiv$givxemr$gmvgyqwxergiw$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$ewwix$wepiw

{mxl$ Ôi|giww$ tvsgiihwÕ$ ,ew$ hijmrih$ mr$ xli$ mrhirxyvi-$ mr$ i|giww$ sj$ (6924$ qmppmsr$ sv$ xs$ sfwivzi$ givxemr$ viwxvmgxmsrw$ sr$ qivkivw0

gsrwspmhexmsrw$erh$wepiw$sj$wyfwxerxmepp}$epp$sj$xlimv$ewwixw?$xli$jempyvi$f}$xli$Gsqter}$sv$er}$kyeverxsv$xs$gsqtp}${mxl$er}$sj$xli$sxliv

ekviiqirxw$ mr$ xli$ mrhirxyvi0${lmgl$jempyvi$gsrxmryiw$jsv$:4$he}w$ejxiv$rsxmgi?$erh$givxemr$izirxw$sj$ferovytxg}$sv$ mrwspzirg}$sj$ xli

Gsqter}$sv$e$viwxvmgxih$wyfwmhmev}$xlex$mw$e$wmkrmjmgerx$wyfwmhmev}$sv$er}$kvsyt$sj$viwxvmgxih$wyfwmhmevmiw$xlex$xskixliv${syph$gsrwxmxyxi

e$wmkrmjmgerx$wyfwmhmev}2

Yrhiv$xli$xivqw$sj$e$vikmwxvexmsr$vmklxw$ekviiqirx$hexih$ew$sj$Qevgl$5=0$64570$eqsrk$KIS0$xli$kyeverxsvw$erh$Qivvmpp$P}rgl0

Tmivgi0$Jirriv$*$Wqmxl$Mrgsvtsvexih0$ew$xli$vitviwirxexmzi$sj$xli$mrmxmep$tyvglewivw$sj$xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$KIS$ekviih$xs$vikmwxiv

yrhiv$ xli$ Wigyvmxmiw$ Egx$ rsxiw$ lezmrk$ xivqw$ mhirxmgep$ mr$ epp$qexivmep$ viwtigxw$ xs$ xli$ 92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$ ,xli$ Ô92569)$I|glerki

RsxiwÕ-$ erh$ xs$ qeoi$ er$ sjjiv$ xs$ i|glerki$ xli$ 92569)$ I|glerki$ Rsxiw$ jsv$ xli$ 92569)$ Wirmsv$ Rsxiw2$ KIS$ jmpih$ xli$ vikmwxvexmsr

wxexiqirx$sr$Qe}$740$6457${lmgl${ew$higpevih$ijjigxmzi$sr$Witxiqfiv$560$64572$KIS$peyrglih$xli$i|glerki$sjjiv$sr$Witxiqfiv$570

6457$erh$xli$i|glerki$sjjiv$i|tmvih$sr$Sgxsfiv$550$64572

92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466

Sr$Sgxsfiv$70$64570$ xli$Gsqter}$gsqtpixih$er$sjjivmrk$sj$(69424$qmppmsr$ekkvikexi$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj$wirmsv$rsxiw$hyi

6466$,xli$Ô92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466Õ-$mr$e$tvmzexi$sjjivmrk$yrhiv$xli$Mrhirxyvi$hexih$ew$sj$Sgxsfiv$70$6457$eqsrk$KIS0$givxemr

sj$mxw$hsqiwxmg$wyfwmhmevmiw0$ew$kyeverxsvw0$erh$[ippw$Jevks$Fero0$Rexmsrep$Ewwsgmexmsr0$ew$xvywxii2$Xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466

{ivi$sjjivih$erh$wsph$xs$Ôuyepmjmih$mrwxmxyxmsrep$fy}ivwÕ$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$Vypi$588E$yrhiv$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$Egx0$erh$syxwmhi$xli$Yrmxih

Wxexiw$xs$rsr1Y2W2$tivwsrw$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$Vikypexmsrw$W$yrhiv$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$Egx2$Xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466${ivi$mwwyih

ex$e$gsytsr$vexi$erh$}miph$xs$qexyvmx}$sj$92<;9)2$Mrxiviwx$sr$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466$mw$te}efpi$wiqm1erryepp}$mr$gewl$mr

evvievw$sr$Neryev}$59$erh$Nyp}$590$gsqqirgmrk$sr$Neryev}$590$64582$Xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466$qexyvi$sr$Neryev}$590$64662

Xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466$erh$ xli$kyeverxiiw$evi$ xli$Gsqter}+w$kirivep$yrwigyvih$wirmsv$sfpmkexmsrw$erh$vero$iuyepp}$ mr

vmklx$sj$te}qirx${mxl$epp$sj$ xli$Gsqter}+w$erh$ xli$kyeverxsvw+$ i|mwxmrk$erh$ jyxyvi$yrwigyvih$wirmsv$hifx0$ mrgpyhmrk$ xli$Gsqter}+w

:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$ xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$erh$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$64682$Xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466$erh$ xli

kyeverxiiw$evi$ijjigxmzip}$wyfsvhmrexih$xs$er}$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$erh$xli$kyeverxsvw+$i|mwxmrk$erh$jyxyvi$wigyvih$hifx$xs$xli$i|xirx$sj$xli

zepyi$sj$xli$ewwixw$wigyvmrk$wygl$hifx0$mrgpyhmrk$epp$erxmgmtexih$fsvvs{mrkw$yrhiv$xli$Wirmsv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}2$Xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw

hyi$6466$evi$wxvygxyvepp}$wyfsvhmrexih$xs$epp$i|mwxmrk$erh$jyxyvi$pmefmpmxmiw$,mrgpyhmrk$xvehi$te}efpiw-$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$wyfwmhmevmiw$xlex

hs$rsx$kyeverxii$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$64662

Sr$sv$ejxiv$Neryev}$590$645;0$KIS$qe}0$ex$mxw$stxmsr0$vihiiq$epp$sv$tevx$sj$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$6466$ytsr$rsx$piww$xler

74$he}w$rsv$qsvi$xler$:4$he}w×$rsxmgi0$ex$xli$vihiqtxmsr$tvmgiw$,i|tviwwih$ew$tivgirxekiw$sj$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx-$wix$jsvxl$fips{0$tpyw

eggvyih$ erh$ yrtemh$ mrxiviwx$ erh$ mrgpyhmrk$ pmuymhexih$ heqekiw0$ mj$ er}0$ sr$ xli$ 92<;9)$ Wirmsv$ Rsxiw$ hyi$ 6466$ vihiiqih0$ xs$ xli

ettpmgefpi$vihiqtxmsr$hexi0$mj$vihiiqih$hyvmrk$xli$561qsrxl$tivmsh$fikmrrmrk$sr$Neryev}$59$sj$xli$}ievw$mrhmgexih$fips{>

]iev Tivgirxeki

6464$erh$xliviejxiv 5442444)

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 181 of 253

Page 204: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5<5367<

Mj$xlivi$mw$e$Ôglerki$sj$gsrxvspÕ$,ew$hijmrih$mr$xli$Mrhirxyvi-0$lsphivw$sj$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466${mpp$lezi$xli$vmklx

xs$geywi$KIS$xs$vityvglewi$xlimv$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466$ex$e$tvmgi$iuyep$xs$545)$sj$xli$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj

55<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 182 of 253

Page 205: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5<6367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466$vityvglewih$tpyw$eggvyih$erh$yrtemh$mrxiviwx$erh$pmuymhexih$heqekiw0$mj$er}0$xs$xli$tyvglewi$hexi2

Xli$ mrhirxyvi$ kszivrmrk$ xli$ rsxiw$ gsrxemrw$ givxemr$ gszirerxw0$ mrgpyhmrk$ pmqmxexmsrw$ erh$ viwxvmgxmsrw$ sr$ xli$ Gsqter}$ erh$ mxw

viwxvmgxih$wyfwmhmevmiw×$efmpmx}$ xs>$ mrgyv$ehhmxmsrep$ mrhifxihriww$sv$ mwwyi$tvijivvih$ wxsgo?$qeoi$hmzmhirh$te}qirxw$sv$sxliv$ viwxvmgxih

te}qirxw?$ gviexi$ pmirw?$ wipp$ ewwixw?$ irxiv$ mrxs$ xverwegxmsrw$ {mxl$ ejjmpmexiw?$ erh$ irxiv$ mrxs$ qivkivw0$ gsrwspmhexmsrw$ sv$ wepiw$ sj$ epp$ sv

wyfwxerxmepp}$epp$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$ewwixw2$Ew$sj$xli$hexi$sj$xli$mrhirxyvi0$epp$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$wyfwmhmevmiw0$sxliv$xler$givxemr$hsvqerx

hsqiwxmg$erh$sxliv$wyfwmhmevmiw$erh$epp$jsvimkr$wyfwmhmevmiw$mr$i|mwxirgi$sr$xli$hexi$sj$xli$mrhirxyvi0${ivi$viwxvmgxih$wyfwmhmevmiw2$Xli

Gsqter}×w$ jempyvi$xs$gsqtp}${mxl$givxemr$sj$xli$gszirerxw$yrhiv$xli$mrhirxyvi$kszivrmrk$ xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466$gsyph

geywi$er$izirx$sj$hijeypx$sj$er}$mrhifxihriww$erh$viwypx$ mr$er$eggipivexmsr$sj$wygl$mrhifxihriww2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$xlivi$mw$e$gvsww1hijeypx

tvszmwmsr$ {lmgl$ figsqiw$ irjsvgiefpi$ ytsr$ jempyvi$ sj$ te}qirx$ sj$ mrhifxihriww$ ex$ jmrep$ qexyvmx}2$ Xli$ Gsqter}×w$ yrviwxvmgxih

wyfwmhmevmiw${mpp$rsx$fi$wyfnigx$ xs$er}$sj$xli$viwxvmgxmzi$gszirerxw$ mr$ xli$ mrhirxyvi2$Xli$Gsqter}${ew$mr$gsqtpmergi${mxl$epp$sj$ xli

jmrergmep$gszirerxw$sj$xli$mrhirxyvi$kszivrmrk$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=2

Xli$ Mrhirxyvi$ epws$ gsrxemrw$ izirxw$ sj$ hijeypx$ {mxl$ viwtigx$ xs0$ eqsrk$ sxliv$ xlmrkw0$ xli$ jspps{mrk>$ jempyvi$ f}$KIS$ xs$ te}

mrxiviwx$erh$pmuymhexih$heqekiw0$mj$er}0$sr$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466${lir$hyi0${lmgl$jempyvi$gsrxmryiw$jsv$74$he}w?$jempyvi$f}

KIS$ xs$ te}$ xli$ tvmrgmtep$ sj0$ sv$ tviqmyq0$ mj$ er}0$ sr0$ xli$ 92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$ hyi$6466${lir$ hyi?$ jempyvi$ f}$KIS$sv$ er}$ sj$ mxw

viwxvmgxih$wyfwmhmevmiw$xs$gsqtp}${mxl$xlimv$sfpmkexmsrw$xs$sjjiv$xs$vityvglewi$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466$ex$ xli$stxmsr$sj$xli

lsphivw$ sj$ xli$ 92<;9)$ Wirmsv$ Rsxiw$ hyi$ 6466$ ytsr$ e$ glerki$ sj$ gsrxvsp0$ xs$ sjjiv$ xs$ vihiiq$ rsxiw$ yrhiv$ givxemr$ gmvgyqwxergiw$ mr

gsrrigxmsr$ {mxl$ ewwix$ wepiw$ {mxl$ Ôi|giww$ tvsgiihwÕ$ ,ew$ hijmrih$ mr$ xli$ Mrhirxyvi-$ mr$ i|giww$ sj$ (6924$qmppmsr$ sv$ xs$ sfwivzi$ givxemr

viwxvmgxmsrw$sr$qivkivw0$gsrwspmhexmsrw$erh$wepiw$sj$wyfwxerxmepp}$epp$sj$xlimv$ewwixw?$xli$jempyvi$f}$KIS$sv$er}$kyeverxsv$xs$gsqtp}${mxl

er}$sj$ xli$sxliv$ ekviiqirxw$ mr$ xli$ Mrhirxyvi0${lmgl$ jempyvi$ gsrxmryiw$ jsv$:4$he}w$ ejxiv$ rsxmgi?$ erh$ givxemr$ izirxw$ sj$ ferovytxg}$ sv

mrwspzirg}$sj$KIS$sv$e$viwxvmgxih$wyfwmhmev}$xlex$mw$e$wmkrmjmgerx$wyfwmhmev}$sv$er}$kvsyt$sj$viwxvmgxih$wyfwmhmevmiw$xlex$xskixliv${syph

gsrwxmxyxi$e$wmkrmjmgerx$wyfwmhmev}2

Yrhiv$xli$xivqw$sj$xli$Vikmwxvexmsr$Vmklxw$Ekviiqirx0$hexih$ew$sj$Sgxsfiv$70$64570$eqsrk$KIS0$xli$kyeverxsvw$erh$[ippw

Jevks$Wigyvmxmiw0$PPG0$ew$xli$vitviwirxexmzi$sj$xli$mrmxmep$tyvglewivw$sj$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466$,xli$ÔVikmwxvexmsr$Vmklxw

EkviiqirxÕ-0$ KIS$ ekviih$ xs$ vikmwxiv$ yrhiv$ xli$ Wigyvmxmiw$ Egx$ rsxiw$ lezmrk$ xivqw$ mhirxmgep$ mr$ epp$qexivmep$ viwtigxw$ xs$ xli$ 92<;9)

Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466$,xli$Ô92<;9)$I|glerki$RsxiwÕ-$erh$xs$qeoi$er$sjjiv$xs$i|glerki$xli$92<;9)$I|glerki$Rsxiw$jsv$xli$92<;9)

Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$64662$KIS$jmpih$ xli$ vikmwxvexmsr$wxexiqirx$sr$Sgxsfiv$60$6457${lmgl${ew$higpevih$ijjigxmzi$sr$ Neryev}$:0$64582

KIS$peyrglih$xli$i|glerki$sjjiv$sr$Neryev}$:0$6458$erh$xli$i|glerki$sjjiv$i|tmvih$sr$Jifvyev}$80$64582

Hifx$Vityvglewiw

Sr$Eykywx$5:0$645=0$xli$Gsqter}+w$Fsevh$sj$Hmvigxsvw$eyxlsvm~ih$xli$Gsqter}$xs$vityvglewi$erh3sv$vixmvi$e$tsvxmsr$sj$xli

:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$646:0$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$64680$xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$64670$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi

6466$,gsppigxmzip}$xli$&KIS$Wirmsv$Rsxiw&-$erh$xli$Gsqter}+w$xivq$pser$yrhiv$mxw$Eqirhih$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$xlvsykl$gewl

tyvglewiw0$mr$stir$qevoix0$tvmzexip}$riksxmexih$xverwegxmsrw0$sv$sxliv{mwi0$yt$xs$er$ekkvikexi$qe|mqyq$sj$(54424$qmppmsr0$wyfnigx$xs

givxemr$pmqmxexmsrw$xlvsykl$Higiqfiv$750$64642

Hyvmrk$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$vityvglewih$ettvs|mqexip}$(9:24$qmppmsr$mr$ekkvikexi$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj$mxw$92<;9)$Wirmsv

Rsxiw$hyi$6466$ex$e${imklxih$eziveki$tvmgi$sj$=;299)$jsv$e$xsxep$gswx$sj$(982;$qmppmsr2$Ew$e$viwypx$sj$xliwi$vityvglewiw0$xli$Gsqter}

vigskrm~ih$e$rix$psww$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx$sj$(427$qmppmsr$hyvmrk$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=2

Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Hifx

Rsvxl{iwx$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxiv

Sr$Higiqfiv$=0$64550$xli$[ewlmrkxsr$Igsrsqmg$Hizipstqirx$Jmrergi$Eyxlsvmx}$mwwyih$(9828$qmppmsr$sj$mxw$[ewlmrkxsr

Igsrsqmg$Hizipstqirx$Jmrergi$Eyxlsvmx}$Xe|efpi$Igsrsqmg$Hizipstqirx$Viziryi$Fsrhw0$wivmiw$6455$,Ô6455$Viziryi$FsrhwÕ-2

Xli$fsrhw${ivi$vexih$EE1$f}$Wxerhevh$*$Tssv×w$Vexmrkw$Wivzmgiw$erh$xli$wglihypih$te}qirx$sj$tvmrgmtep$erh$mrxiviwx$mw$kyeverxiih$f}

qyrmgmtep$fsrh$mrwyvergi$mwwyih$f}$Ewwyvih$Kyeverx}$Qyrmgmtep$Gsvt2$Xli$6455$Viziryi$Fsrhw$lezi$er$eziveki$epp1mr$gswx$sj

ettvs|mqexip}$:28)0$mrgpyhmrk$hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw$erh$xli$fsrh$hmwgsyrx0$erh$qexyvmx}$hexiw$verkmrk$xlvsykl$Sgxsfiv$50$64652$Xli

6455$Viziryi$Fsrhw${ivi$mwwyih$xs$tvszmhi$jyrhw$xs$qeoi$e$pser$xs$GWG$sj$Xegsqe0$PPG$,&GWG&-$jsv$tyvtswiw$sj$vimqfyvwmrk$KIS

jsv$gswxw$mrgyvvih$f}$KIS$jsv$xli$644=$i|terwmsr$sj$xli$Rsvxl{iwx$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk

55=

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 183 of 253

Page 206: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5<7367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Girxiv$erh$te}mrk$xli$gswxw$sj$mwwymrk$xli$6455$Viziryi$Fsrhw2$Xli$te}qirx$sj$tvmrgmtep$erh$mrxiviwx$sr$xli$fsrhw$mw$rsr1vigsyvwi$xs

KIS2$Rsri$sj$xli$fsrhw$rsv$GWG×w$sfpmkexmsrw$yrhiv$xli$pser$evi$sfpmkexmsrw$sj$KIS$rsv$evi$xli}$kyeverxiih$f}$KIS2

Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$xli$viqemrmrk$fepergi$sj$xli$hifx$wivzmgi$viuymviqirx$vipexih$xs$xli$6455$Viziryi$Fsrhw$mw$(592;

qmppmsr0$sj${lmgl$(;2;$qmppmsr$mw$gpewwmjmih$ew$gyvvirx$mr$xli$eggsqter}mrk$fepergi$wliix2$Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$mrgpyhih$mr

viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$mrziwxqirxw$mw$(82;$qmppmsr$,epp$gyvvirx-$sj$jyrhw$liph$mr$xvywx${mxl$viwtigx$xs$xli$Rsvxl{iwx$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxiv

jsv$hifx$wivzmgi$erh$sxliv$viwivziw${lmgl$leh$rsx$fiir$vipiewih$xs$xli$Gsqter}$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=2

Eywxvepme$1$Vezirlepp

Mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$e$hiwmkr$erh$fymph$jegmpmx}$tvsnigx$ekviiqirx${mxl$xli$Wxexi$sj$Zmgxsvme0$mr$Witxiqfiv$6458$xli$Gsqter}

irxivih$mrxs$e$w}rhmgexih$jegmpmx}$ekviiqirx$,xli$&Gsrwxvygxmsr$Jegmpmx}&-$xs$tvszmhi$hifx$jmrergmrk$jsv$gsrwxvygxmsr$sj$xli$tvsnigx2

Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$;$1$Gsrxvegx$Vigimzefpi2$Xli$Gsrwxvygxmsr$Jegmpmx}$tvszmhih$jsv$rsr1vigsyvwi$jyrhmrk$yt$xs$EYH$;=5$qmppmsr0$sv$(9982<

qmppmsr0$fewih$sr$i|glerki$vexiw$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=2$Gsrwxvygxmsr$hve{w${ivi$jyrhih$xlvsyklsyx$xli$tvsnigx$eggsvhmrk$xs$e$jm|ih

yxmpm~exmsr$wglihypi$ew$hijmrih$mr$xli$w}rhmgexih$jegmpmx}$ekviiqirx2$Xli$xivq$sj$xli$Gsrwxvygxmsr$Jegmpmx}${ew$xlvsykl$Witxiqfiv$645=

erh$fsvi$mrxiviwx$ex$e$zevmefpi$vexi$uysxih$f}$givxemr$Eywxvepmer$ferow$tpyw$644$fewmw$tsmrxw2$Sr$Qe}$660$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$gsqtpixih

er$sjjivmrk$sj$EYH$8:52:$qmppmsr0$sv$(7672<$qmppmsr0$fewih$sr$i|glerki$vexiw$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$ekkvikexi$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj

rsr1vigsyvwi$wirmsv$wigyvih$rsxiw$hyi$6486$,xli$&Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Rsxiw&-2$Xli$eqsvxm~mrk$Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Rsxiw${ivi$mwwyih$f}

Vezirlepp$Jmrergi$Gs$Tx}$Pmqmxih$mr$e$tvmzexi$tpegiqirx$tyvwyerx$xs$Wigxmsr$8,e-,6-$sj$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$Egx$sj$5=770$ew$eqirhih2$Xli

Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Rsxiw${ivi$mwwyih${mxl$e$gsytsr$erh$}miph$xs$qexyvmx}$sj$8267)${mxl$e$qexyvmx}$hexi$sj$Qevgl$750$64862$Xli$rix

tvsgiihw$jvsq$xlmw$sjjivmrk${ivi$ywih$xs$vijmrergi$xli$syxwxerhmrk$Gsrwxvygxmsr$Jegmpmx}$erh$xs$te}$epp$vipexih$jiiw0$gswxw$erh$i|tirwiw

ewwsgmexih${mxl$xli$xverwegxmsr2$Ew$e$viwypx$sj$xli$xverwegxmsr0$xli$Gsqter}$mrgyvvih$e$(829$qmppmsr$psww$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx

vipexih$xs$w{et$xivqmrexmsr$jiiw$erh$yreqsvxm~ih$hijivvih$pser$gswxw$ewwsgmexih${mxl$xli$Gsrwxvygxmsr$Jegmpmx}2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$pser$gswxw

sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(;29$qmppmsr${ivi$mrgyvvih$erh$getmxepm~ih$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$sjjivmrk2

Sxliv

Mr$Eykywx$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$irxivih$mrxs$x{s$mhirxmgep$tvsqmwwsv}$rsxiw$mr$xli$ekkvikexi$eqsyrx$sj$(8827$qmppmsr${lmgl$evi

wigyvih$f}$pser$ekviiqirxw$erh$qsvxkeki$erh$wigyvmx}$ekviiqirxw$sr$givxemr$viep$tvstivx}$erh$mqtvsziqirxw2$Xli$xivqw$sj$xli

tvsqmwwsv}$rsxiw$evi$xlvsykl$Witxiqfiv$50$6478$erh$fiev$mrxiviwx$ex$PMFSV$tpyw$644$fewmw$tsmrxw$erh$evi$te}efpi$mr$qsrxlp}

mrwxeppqirxw$tpyw$mrxiviwx2$Xli$Gsqter}$lew$irxivih$mrxs$mrxiviwx$vexi$w{et$ekviiqirxw$xs$jm|$xli$mrxiviwx$vexi$ex$8266)2$Mrgpyhih$mr$xli

fepergi$ex$Higiqfiv$750$645=$mw$(42;$qmppmsr$sj$hijivvih$pser$gswxw$mrgyvvih$mr$xli$xverwegxmsr2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$<$1$Hivmzexmzi$Jmrergmep

Mrwxvyqirxw$jsv$jyvxliv$mrjsvqexmsr2

Hifx$Vite}qirx

Hifx$vite}qirx$wglihypiw$yrhiv$Jmrergi$Piewi$Sfpmkexmsrw0$Psrk1Xivq$Hifx0$Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Hifx$erh$xli$Wirmsv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}

evi$ew$jspps{w>$

564

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 184 of 253

Page 207: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5<8367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Jmwgep$]ievJmrergiPiewiw $

Psrk1XivqHifx $

Rsr1VigsyvwiHifx $ Vizspziv $

XivqPserw $

XsxepErryep

Vite}qirx

$ ,Mr$xlsywerhw-

6464 ( 50=78 $ ( 5046: $ ( 570=45 $ ( Ó $ ( <0444 $ ( 680<:5

6465 50=7: $ 504;5 $ 580;<4 $ Ó $ <0444 $ 690;<;

6466 50677 $ 5=904;9 $ ;0;66 $ Ó $ <0444 $ 6560474

6467 Ó $ 74505:: $ <065< $ Ó $ <0444 $ 75;07<8

6468 Ó $ 695064< $ <0:<< $ 9640:;5 $ ;8:0444 $ 5096:09:;

Xliviejxiv Ó $ 7<<0979 $ 6;80<:= $ Ó $ Ó $ ::70848

$ 90547 $ 5057<04<5 $ 76<05;< $ 9640:;5 $ ;;<0444 $ 60;;40477

Mrxiviwx$mqtyxih$sr$Getmxep$Piewiw ,977- $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó $ ,977-

Svmkmrep$mwwyi$hmwgsyrx Ó $ Ó $ ,<5- $ Ó $ ,606<5- $ ,607:6-

Gyvvirx$tsvxmsr ,50:5:- $ ,5046:- $ ,570=45- $ Ó $ ,<0444- $ ,680987-

Rsr1gyvvirx$tsvxmsr ( 60=98 $ ( 5057;0499 $ ( 75805=: $ ( 9640:;5 $ ( ;:;0;5= $ ( 60;8609=9

Kyeverxiiw

Xli$Gsqter}$lew$irxivih$mrxs$givxemr$kyeverxiiw$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$tivjsvqergi$sj$e$jegmpmx}$mr$Eywxvepme$,Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$;$1

Gsrxvegx$Vigimzefpi-2$Xli$sfpmkexmsrw$eqsyrxih$xs$ettvs|mqexip}$EYH9<$qmppmsr0$sv$(842;$qmppmsr0$fewih$sr$i|glerki$vexiw$mr$ijjigx

ew$ sj$ Higiqfiv$ 750$ 645=2$ Xliwi$ kyeverxiiw$ evi$ wigyvih$ f}$ syxwxerhmrk$ pixxivw$ sj$ gvihmx$ yrhiv$ xli$ Gsqter}+w$ Vizspziv$ ew$ sj

Higiqfiv$750$645=2

Ex$Higiqfiv$ 750$ 645=0$ xli$ Gsqter}$ epws$ leh$ imklx$ pixxivw$ sj$ kyeverxii$ syxwxerhmrk$ yrhiv$ witevexi$ mrxivrexmsrep$ jegmpmxmiw

vipexmrk$xs$tivjsvqergi$kyeverxiiw$sj$mxw$Eywxvepmer$wyfwmhmev}$xsxepmrk$(542<$qmppmsr2

Mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$gviexmsr$sj$Wsyxl$Ejvmger$Gywxshmep$Wivzmgiw$Tx}2$Pmqmxih$,&WEGW&-0$xli$Gsqter}$irxivih$mrxs$givxemr

kyeverxiiw$vipexih$xs$xli$jmrergmrk0$gsrwxvygxmsr$erh$stivexmsr$sj$xli$Wsyxl$Ejvmger$jegmpmx}2$Xli$Gsqter}$kyeverxiih$givxemr

sfpmkexmsrw$sj$WEGW$yrhiv$mxw$hifx$ekviiqirxw$xs$WEGW+$jsvqiv$wirmsv$pirhivw$xlvsykl$xli$mwwyergi$sj$pixxivw$sj$gvihmx$yrhiv$xli

Gsqter}+w$Vizspziv2$Mr$Nyp}$645<0$WEGW$wixxpih$epp$eqsyrxw$hyi$yrhiv$xli$hifx$jegmpmxmiw$erh$lew$xlivijsvi$hmwglevkih$xli$kyeverxiih

sfpmkexmsrw0$xlivijsvi$xli$kyeverxiiw$vipexih$xs$xliwi$sfpmkexmsrw${ivi$rs$psrkiv$rigiwwev}$erh$xli$pixxivw$sj$gvihmx${ivi$rsx$viri{ih2

Ehhmxmsrepp}0$WEGW${ew$viuymvih$xs$qemrxemr$jyrhmrk$mr$e$vigxmjmgexmsr$eggsyrx$qemrxemrih$jsv$xli$te}qirx$sj$givxemr$gswxw$mr$xli$izirx

sj$gsrxvegx$xivqmrexmsr2$WEGW$lew$qix$xli$viuymvih$jyrhmrk$sfpmkexmsr$erh$xlivi$mw$rs$jyvxliv$viuymviqirx$xs$qemrxemr$xli$viuymvih

jyrhmrk$vigxmjmgexmsr$eggsyrx2

Mr$ehhmxmsr$xs$xli$efszi0$xli$Gsqter}$leh$epws$ekviih$xs$tvszmhi$e$pser0$mj$viuymvih0$sj$yt$xs$64$qmppmsr$Wsyxl$Ejvmger$Verh0

sv$(528$qmppmsr$fewih$sr$i|glerki$vexiw$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$vijivvih$xs$ew$xli$wlevilsphiv+w$wxerhf}$jegmpmx}0$xs$WEGW$jsv$xli

tyvtswi$sj$jmrergmrk$WEGW×$sfpmkexmsrw$yrhiv$mxw$gsrxvegx${mxl$xli$Wsyxl$Ejvmger$kszivrqirx2$Rs$eqsyrxw$lezi$fiir$jyrhih$yrhiv

xli$wlevilsphiv+w$wxerhf}$jegmpmx}2$Xli$Gsqter}×w$sfpmkexmsrw$yrhiv$xli$wlevilsphiv+w$wxerhf}$jegmpmx}$i|tmvih$ytsr$WEGW×$vipiewi

jvsq$mxw$sfpmkexmsrw$yrhiv$xli$gsqqsr$xivqw$ekviiqirx$mr$Jifvyev}$645=${mxl$xli$jmrep$te}qirx$sj$xli$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$jiiw2

Xli$Gsqter}$epws$kyeverxiih$givxemr$sfpmkexmsrw$sj$WEGW$xs$xli$wigyvmx}$xvywxii$jsv$WEGW×$pirhivw2$Xli$Gsqter}$wigyvih

mxw$kyeverxii$xs$xli$wigyvmx}$xvywxii$f}$gihmrk$mxw$vmklxw$xs$gpemqw$ekemrwx$WEGW$mr$viwtigx$sj$er}$pserw$sv$sxliv$jmrergi$ekviiqirxw0$erh

f}$tpihkmrk$xli$Gsqter}×w$wleviw$mr$WEGW2$Xli$Gsqter}×w$pmefmpmx}$yrhiv$xli$kyeverxii$mw$pmqmxih$xs$xli$giwwmsr$erh$tpihki$sj$wleviw2

Xli$kyeverxii$i|tmvih$mr$Jifvyev}$645=${lir$sj$epp$WEGW+$sfpmkexmsrw$mr$xivqw$sj$xli$jmrergi$ekviiqirxw${ivi$wixxpih2

Mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$gviexmsr$sj$KISEqi}0$xli$Gsqter}$erh$mxw$nsmrx$zirxyvi$tevxriv$kyeverxii$xli$ezempefmpmx}$sj${svomrk

getmxep$mr$iuyep$tvstsvxmsr$xs$irwyvi$xlex$KISEqi}$ger$gsqtp}${mxl$gyvvirx$erh$jyxyvi$gsrxvegxyep$gsqqmxqirxw$vipexih$xs$xli

tivjsvqergi$sj$mxw$stivexmsrw2$Xli$Gsqter}$erh$xli$94)$nsmrx$zirxyvi$tevxriv$leh$iegl$i|xirhih$e$¦56$qmppmsr$pmri$sj$gvihmx$xs$xli

nsmrx$zirxyvi2$Xli$Gsqter}×w$qe|mqyq$i|tswyvi$vipexmzi$xs$xli$nsmrx$zirxyvi${ew$mxw$rsxi$vigimzefpi$erh$jyxyvi$jmrergmep$wyttsvx

rigiwwev}$xs$kyeverxii$tivjsvqergi$yrhiv$xli$gsrxvegx2$Mr$Sgxsfiv$645<0$xli$rsxiw$vigimzefpi$xs$iegl$nsmrx$zirxyvi$tevxriv${ivi$temh

sjj$mr$jypp2

I|gitx$ew$hmwgywwih$efszi0$xli$Gsqter}$hsiw$rsx$lezi$er}$sjj$fepergi$wliix$evverkiqirxw2

565

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 185 of 253

Page 208: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5<9367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

582 Piewiw

Sr$Neryev}$50$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$ehstxih$Eggsyrxmrk$Wxerhevh$Ythexi$,&EWY&-$Rs2$645:1460$&Piewiw&$,Xstmg$<86-${lmgl$viuymviw

xlex$irxmxmiw$vigsvh$piewi$ewwixw$erh$piewi$pmefmpmxmiw$sr$xli$fepergi$wliix$erh$hmwgpswi$oi}$mrjsvqexmsr$efsyx$piewmrk$evverkiqirxw2$Xli

Gsqter}$mqtpiqirxih$xli$ri{$wxerhevh$ywmrk$xli$xverwmxmsr$qixlsh$xlex$tvszmhih$jsv$ehstxmsr$sr$xli$ehstxmsr$hexi$erh$vigskrm~mrk$e

gyqypexmzi1ijjigx$ehnywxqirx$xs$vixemrih$ievrmrkw0$mj$er}0$ytsr$ehstxmsr2$Xlivijsvi0$xli$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$jsv$xli$}iev

irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=$evi$tviwirxih$yrhiv$xli$ri{$wxerhevh0${lmpi$gsqtevexmzi$}ievw$tviwirxih$evi$rsx$ehnywxih$erh$gsrxmryi$xs$fi

vitsvxih$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$xli$Gsqter}+w$lmwxsvmgep$eggsyrxmrk$tspmg}2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$5$1$Wyqqev}$sj$Fywmriww$Svkerm~exmsr0

Stivexmsrw$erh$Wmkrmjmgerx$Eggsyrxmrk$Tspmgmiw$1$Vigirx$Eggsyrxmrk$Tvsrsyrgiqirxw$jsv$jyvxliv$mrjsvqexmsr2

Xli$Gsqter}$lew$stivexmrk$erh$jmrergi$piewiw$jsv$jegmpmxmiw0$kvsyrh$piewiw0$sjjmgi$wtegi0$gsqtyxivw0$gstmiv$iuymtqirx$erh

xverwtsvxexmsr$zilmgpiw$xlex$lezi$viqemrmrk$piewi$xivqw$sj$sri$}iev$xs$wizirx}1wizir$}ievw0$wsqi$sj${lmgl$mrgpyhi$stxmsrw$xs$i|xirh$xli

piewi$jsv$yt$xs$xir$}ievw2$Jsv$piewiw${mxl$xivqw$kviexiv$xler$56$qsrxlw0$xli$Gsqter}$vigsvhw$xli$vipexih$ewwix$erh$sfpmkexmsr$ex$xli

tviwirx$zepyi$sj$xli$piewi$te}qirxw$sziv$xli$xivq$sj$xli$piewi2$Qer}$sj$KIS+w$piewiw$mrgpyhi$virxep$iwgepexmsr$gpeywiw0$viri{ep$stxmsrw

erh3sv$xivqmrexmsr$stxmsrw$xlex$evi$jegxsvih$mrxs$xli$hixivqmrexmsr$sj$piewi$te}qirxw${lir$ettvstvmexi2$Srp}$viri{ep$sv$xivqmrexmsr

stxmsrw$xlex$evi$viewsrefp}$givxemr$xs$fi$i|ivgmwih$f}$xli$Gsqter}$evi$mrgpyhih$mr$xli$piewi$xivq${lmgl$mw$ywih$mr$xli$gepgypexmsr$sj

piewi$pmefmpmxmiw$erh$vmklx1sj1ywi$ewwixw2$KIS$hsiw$rsx$x}tmgepp}$irxiv$mrxs$piewi$ekviiqirxw$xlex$gsrxemr$e$viwmhyep$kyeverxii$sv$xlex

tvszmhi$jsv$zevmefpi$piewi$te}qirxw2

[lir$ezempefpi0$KIS$ywiw$xli$vexi$mqtpmgmx$mr$xli$piewi$xs$hmwgsyrx$piewi$te}qirxw$xs$tviwirx$zepyi0$ls{iziv0$qswx$sj$KIS+w$piewi

ekviiqirxw$hs$rsx$tvszmhi$e$viehmp}$hixivqmrefpi$mqtpmgmx$vexi2$Xlivijsvi0$xli$Gsqter}$qywx$iwxmqexi$mxw$mrgviqirxep$fsvvs{mrk$vexi

xs$hmwgsyrx$xli$piewi$te}qirxw$fewih$sr$mrjsvqexmsr$ezempefpi$ex$piewi$gsqqirgiqirx2

Piewi$vipexih$ewwixw$erh$pmefmpmxmiw$evi$vigsvhih$sr$xli$fepergi$wliix$ew$jspps{w$,mr$xlsywerhw->

$ $ Gpewwmjmgexmsr$sr$xli$Fepergi$Wliix $ Higiqfiv$750$645=

Ewwixw $ $ $ $

$$Stivexmrk$piewi$ewwixw $ Stivexmrk$Piewi$Vmklx1sj1Ywi$Ewwixw0$Rix $ ( 565096;

$$Jmrergi$piewi$ewwixw $ Tvstivx}$erh$Iuymtqirx0$Rix $ 60<<4

Xsxep$piewi$ewwixw $ $ $ ( 568084;

$ $ $ $ $

Pmefmpmxmiw $ $ $ $

Gyvvirx $ $ $ $

$$$Stivexmrk $ Stivexmrk$piewi$pmefmpmxmiw0$gyvvirx$tsvxmsr $ ( 6:064<

$$$Jmrergi$_5a$

Gyvvirx$tsvxmsr$sj$jmrergi$pmefmpmxmiw0$psrk1xivq$hifx$erh$rsr1

vigsyvwi$hifx $ 50:5:

Rsrgyvvirx $ $ $ $

$$$Stivexmrk $ Stivexmrk$Piewi$Pmefmpmxmiw $ =;06=5

$$$Jmrergi$_5a $ Jmrergi$Piewi$Pmefmpmxmiw $ 60=98

Xsxep$piewi$pmefmpmxmiw $ $ $ ( 56<04:=

_5a$Epws$vijiv$xs$Rsxi$57$1$Hifx2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 186 of 253

Page 209: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5<:367<

566

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 187 of 253

Page 210: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5<;367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Givxemr$mrjsvqexmsr$vipexih$xs$xli$piewi$gswxw$jsv$jmrergi$erh$stivexmrk$piewiw$mw$tviwirxih$ew$jspps{w$,mr$xlsywerhw->

$ $ $

]iev$Irhih$Higiqfiv

750$645=

Stivexmrk$piewi$gswx $ $ ( 8:0=78

Jmrergi$piewi$gswx> $ $ $

$$$$Eqsvxm~exmsr$sj$vmklx1sj1ywi$ewwixw $ $ 50467

$$$$Mrxiviwx$sr$piewi$pmefmpmxmiw $ $ 798

$$$$Xsxep$jmrergi$piewi$gswx $ $ 507;;

Wlsvx1xivq$piewi$gswx $ $ 50=97

Xsxep$piewi$gswx $ $ ( 9406:8

$ $ $ $

Gewl$temh$jsv$eqsyrxw$mrgpyhih$mr$xli

qiewyviqirx$sj$piewi$pmefmpmxmiw $ $ $

$$$$Stivexmrk$gewl$jps{w$jsv$stivexmrk$piewiw $ $ ( 8<0<77

$$$$Stivexmrk$gewl$jps{w$jsv$jmrergi$piewiw $ $ ( 767

$$$$Jmrergmrk$egxmzmxmiw$jsv$jmrergi$piewiw $ $ ( 50:54

Vmklx1sj1ywi$ewwixw$sfxemrih$mr$i|glerki$jsv$ri{

stivexmrk$piewi$pmefmpmxmiw $ $ ( 560667

$ $ $ $

[imklxih$eziveki$viqemrmrk$piewi$xivq> $ $ $

$$$$Stivexmrk$piewiw $ $ ;27$}ievw

$$$$Jmrergi$piewiw $ $ 62;$}ievw

[imklxih$eziveki$hmwgsyrx$vexi> $ $ $

$$$$Stivexmrk$piewiw $ $ 82;9)

$$$$Jmrergi$piewiw $ $ <26;)

Yrhmwgsyrxih$Gewl$Jps{w

Xli$xefpi$fips{$vigsrgmpiw$xli$yrhmwgsyrxih$gewl$jps{w$jsv$iegl$sj$xli$jmvwx$jmzi$}ievw$erh$xsxep$sj$xli$viqemrmrk$}ievw$xs$xli$stivexmrk

piewi$pmefmpmxmiw$erh$jmrergi$piewi$pmefmpmxmiw$vigsvhih$sr$xli$fepergi$wliix$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=$,mr$xlsywerhw-2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 188 of 253

Page 211: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5<<367<

567

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 189 of 253

Page 212: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5<=367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$ $ Stivexmrk$Piewiw $ Jmrergi$Piewiw

6464 $ ( 7507;< $ ( 50=78

6465 $ 6:05<< $ 50=7:

6466 $ 5=0:=5 $ 50677

6467 $ 5:0488 $ Ó

6468 $ 57096; $ Ó

Xliviejxiv $ 850:96 $ Ó

Xsxep$qmrmqyq$piewi$te}qirxw $ 58<08<4 $ 90547

Piww>$eqsyrx$sj$piewi$te}qirx

vitviwirxmrk$mrxiviwx $ ,680=<5- $ ,977-

Tviwirx$zepyi$sj$jyxyvi$qmrmqyq$piewi

te}qirxw $ 56708== $ 809;4

Piww>$gyvvirx$sfpmkexmsrw$yrhiv$piewiw $ ,6:064<- $ ,50:5:-

Psrk1xivq$piewi$sfpmkexmsrw $ ( =;06=5 $ ( 60=98

592 Firijmx$Tperw

Xli$Gsqter}×w$iqtps}iiw$tevxmgmtexi$mr$er$Iqtps}ii$Vixmviqirx$Wezmrkw$Tper$,xli$ÔVixmviqirx$TperÕ-$yrhiv$Wigxmsr$845,o-$sj

xli$ Mrxivrep$ Viziryi$Gshi$ xlex$ gszivw$ wyfwxerxmepp}$ epp$Y2W2$ fewih$ wepevmih$ iqtps}iiw2$ Iqtps}iiw$qe}$ gsrxvmfyxi$ e$ tivgirxeki$ sj

ipmkmfpi$gsqtirwexmsr$xs$xli$tper0$wyfnigx$xs$givxemr$pmqmxw$yrhiv$xli$Mrxivrep$Viziryi$Gshi2$Jsv$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0

645<$erh$645;0$xli$Gsqter}$tvszmhih$qexglmrk$gsrxvmfyxmsrw$sj$(927$qmppmsr0$(92=$qmppmsr$erh$(82=$qmppmsr0$viwtigxmzip}2

Xli$Gsqter}$lew$x{s$rsr1gsrxvmfyxsv}$hijmrih$firijmx$tirwmsr$tperw$gszivmrk$givxemr$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$i|igyxmziw2$Vixmviqirx

firijmxw$evi$fewih$sr$}ievw$sj$wivzmgi0$iqtps}iiw×$eziveki$gsqtirwexmsr$jsv$xli$pewx$jmzi$}ievw$tvmsv$xs$vixmviqirx$erh$wsgmep$wigyvmx}

firijmxw2$ Gyvvirxp}0$ xli$ tperw$ evi$ rsx$ jyrhih2$ Xli$ Gsqter}$ tyvglewih$ erh$ mw$ xli$ firijmgmev}$ sj$ pmji$ mrwyvergi$ tspmgmiw$ jsv$ givxemr

tevxmgmterxw$irvsppih$mr$xli$tperw2$Xlivi${ivi$rs$wmkrmjmgerx$xverwegxmsrw$fix{iir$xli$iqtps}iv$sv$vipexih$tevxmiw$erh$xli$tperw$hyvmrk

645=0$645<$sv$645;2

Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$leh$e$rsr1uyepmjmih$hijivvih$gsqtirwexmsr$ekviiqirx${mxl$mxw$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv

,ÔGISÕ-2$Xli$ekviiqirx$tvszmhiw$ jsv$e$ pyqt$wyq$te}qirx$ytsr$vixmviqirx0$rs$wssriv$ xler$eki$992$Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$xli

GIS$ leh$ vieglih$ eki$ 99$ erh$ {ew$ ipmkmfpi$ xs$ vigimzi$ xli$ te}qirx$ ytsr$ vixmviqirx2$ Mj$ xli$ Gsqter}×w$ GIS$ leh$ vixmvih$ ew$ sj

Higiqfiv$750$645=0$xli$Gsqter}${syph$lezi$leh$xs$te}$lmq$(<2:$qmppmsr2$Xli$psrk1xivq$tsvxmsr$sj$xli$tirwmsr$pmefmpmx}$vipexih$xs$xli

hijmrih$firijmx$tperw$erh$xli$hijivvih$gsqtirwexmsr$ekviiqirx${mxl$xli$GIS$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$645<${ew$(7;26$qmppmsr

erh$(7625$qmppmsr0$viwtigxmzip}0$erh$mw$mrgpyhih$mr$Sxliv$Rsr1Gyvvirx$pmefmpmxmiw$mr$xli$eggsqter}mrk$gsrwspmhexih$fepergi$wliixw2

Xli$jspps{mrk$xefpi$wyqqevm~iw$oi}$mrjsvqexmsr$vipexih$xs$xli$Gsqter}×w$tirwmsr$tperw$erh$vixmviqirx$ekviiqirxw2$Xli$xefpi

mppywxvexiw$ xli$ vigsrgmpmexmsr$ sj$ xli$ fikmrrmrk$ erh$ irhmrk$ fepergiw$ sj$ xli$ firijmx$ sfpmkexmsr$ wls{mrk$ xli$ ijjigxw$ hyvmrk$ xli$ tivmshw

tviwirxih$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$wivzmgi$gswx0$mrxiviwx$gswx0$tper$eqirhqirxw0$xivqmrexmsr$firijmxw0$egxyevmep$kemrw$erh$pswwiw2$Xli$ewwyqtxmsrw

ywih$ mr$xli$Gsqter}×w$gepgypexmsr$sj$eggvyih$tirwmsr$gswxw$evi$fewih$sr$qevoix$mrjsvqexmsr$erh$ xli$Gsqter}×w$lmwxsvmgep$vexiw$ jsv

iqtps}qirx$gsqtirwexmsr$erh$hmwgsyrx$vexiw2$

568

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 190 of 253

Page 213: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5=4367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$ Higiqfiv$750$645= $ Higiqfiv$750$645<

Eggyqypexih$Firijmx$Sfpmkexmsr0$Irh$sj$]iev ( 74057= $ ( 690;;;

$ $ $ $

Glerki$mr$Tvsnigxih$Firijmx$Sfpmkexmsr $ $ $

Tvsnigxih$Firijmx$Sfpmkexmsr0$Fikmrrmrk$sj$]iev ( 7608;8 $ ( 760<64

Wivzmgi$Gswx ==< $ 50644

Mrxiviwx$Gswx 507=7 $ 50686

Egxyevmep$,Kemr-$Psww 7088= $ ,605::-

Firijmxw$Temh ,;:7- $ ,:66-

Tvsnigxih$Firijmx$Sfpmkexmsr0$Irh$sj$]iev ( 7;0995 $ ( 7608;8

Glerki$mr$Tper$Ewwixw $ $ $

Tper$Ewwixw$ex$Jemv$Zepyi0$Fikmrrmrk$sj$]iev ( Ó $ ( Ó

Gsqter}$Gsrxvmfyxmsrw ;:7 $ :66

Firijmxw$Temh ,;:7- $ ,:66-

Tper$Ewwixw$ex$Jemv$Zepyi0$Irh$sj$]iev ( Ó $ ( Ó

Yrjyrhih$Wxexyw$sj$xli$Tper ( ,7;0995- $ ( ,7608;8-

Eqsyrxw$Vigskrm~ih$mr$Eggyqypexih$Sxliv$Gsqtvilirwmzi$Mrgsqi $ $ $

Rix$Psww <06<9 $ 9048;

Xsxep$Tirwmsr$Gswx ( <06<9 $ ( 9048;

$

$ 645= $ 645<

Gsqtsrirxw$sj$Rix$Tivmshmg$Firijmx$Gswx $ $ $

Wivzmgi$Gswx ( ==< $ ( 50644

Mrxiviwx$Gswx 507=7 $ 50686

Eqsvxm~exmsr$sj> $ $ $

Rix$Psww 654 $ 976

Rix$Tivmshmg$Tirwmsr$Gswx ( 60:45 $ ( 60=;8

[imklxih$Eziveki$Ewwyqtxmsrw$jsv$I|tirwi $ $ $

Hmwgsyrx$Vexi 7284) $ 8294)

I|tigxih$Vixyvr$sr$Tper$Ewwixw R3E $ R3E

Vexi$sj$Gsqtirwexmsr$Mrgviewi 8284) $ 8284)

Xli$eqsyrx$mrgpyhih$mr$eggyqypexih$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=$xlex$lew$rsx$}ix$fiir$vigskrm~ih$ew$e

gsqtsrirx$ sj$ rix$ tivmshmg$ firijmx$ gswx$ mw$ (<27$qmppmsr2$ Xli$ eqsyrx$ mrgpyhih$ mr$ sxliv$ eggyqypexih$ gsqtvilirwmzi$ mrgsqi$ ew$ sj

Higiqfiv$750$645=$xlex$mw$i|tigxih$xs$fi$vigskrm~ih$ew$e$gsqtsrirx$sj$rix$tivmshmg$firijmx$gswx$mr$jmwgep$}iev$645=$mw$(429$qmppmsr2

Xli$ firijmx$ te}qirxw$ vijpigxih$ mr$ xli$ xefpi$ fips{$ vitviwirx$ xli$ Gsqter}×w$ sfpmkexmsrw$ xs$ iqtps}iiw$ xlex$ evi$ ipmkmfpi$ jsv

vixmviqirx$sv$lezi$epvieh}$vixmvih$erh$evi$vigimzmrk$hijivvih$gsqtirwexmsr$firijmxw>$

Jmwgep$]ievTirwmsrFirijmxw

$ ,Mr$xlsywerhw-

6464 ( =08:9

6465 <:<

6466 <:4

6467 <94

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 191 of 253

Page 214: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5=5367<

6468 =7=

Xliviejxiv 6809:=

$$

$ ( 7;0995

$$

569

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 192 of 253

Page 215: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5=6367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Xli$ Gsqter}$ epws$ qemrxemrw$ Xli$ KIS$ Kvsyt$ Mrg2$ Hijivvih$ Gsqtirwexmsr$ Tper$ ,ÔHijivvih$ Gsqtirwexmsr$ TperÕ-0$ e$ rsr1

uyepmjmih$hijivvih$gsqtirwexmsr$tper$jsv$iqtps}iiw${ls$evi$mripmkmfpi$xs$tevxmgmtexi$mr$mxw$uyepmjmih$845,o-$tper2$Ipmkmfpi$iqtps}iiw

qe}$hijiv$e$ jm|ih$tivgirxeki$sj$ xlimv$wepev}$erh$xli$Gsqter}$qexgliw$iqtps}ii$gsrxvmfyxmsrw$yt$xs$e$givxemr$eqsyrx$fewih$sr$xli

iqtps}ii×w$}ievw$sj$wivzmgi2$Te}qirxw${mpp$fi$qehi$ex$vixmviqirx$eki$sj$:90$ex$xivqmrexmsr$sj$iqtps}qirx$sv$ievpmiv$hitirhmrk$sr$xli

iqtps}iiw×$ ipigxmsrw2$ Xli$ Gsqter}$ iwxefpmwlih$ e$ veffm$ xvywx?$ xli$ tyvtswi$ sj$ {lmgl$ mw$ xs$ wikvikexi$ xli$ ewwixw$ sj$ xli$ Hijivvih

Gsqtirwexmsr$Tper$jvsq$xli$Gsqter}×w$gewl$fepergiw2$Xli$jyrhw$mr$xli$veffm$xvywx$evi$mrgpyhih$mr$Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Mrziwxqirxw$mr

xli$eggsqter}mrk$Gsrwspmhexih$Fepergi$Wliixw2$Xliwi$jyrhw$evi$rsx$ezempefpi$xs$xli$Gsqter}$jsv$er}$tyvtswi$sxliv$xler$xs$jyrh$xli

Hijivvih$Gsqtirwexmsr$Tper?$ls{iziv0$xliwi$jyrhw$qe}$fi$ezempefpi$xs$xli$Gsqter}×w$gvihmxsvw$mr$xli$izirx$xli$Gsqter}$figsqiw

mrwspzirx2$ Xli$ veffm$ xvywx$ leh$ e$ fepergi$ sj$ ettvs|mqexip}$ (6<27$ qmppmsr$ ex$ Higiqfiv$ 750$ 645=2$ Epp$ iqtps}ii$ erh$ iqtps}iv

gsrxvmfyxmsrw$vipexmzi$xs$xli$Hijivvih$Gsqtirwexmsr$Tper$evi$qehi$hmvigxp}$xs$xli$veffm$xvywx2$Xli$Gsqter}$vigskrm~ih$i|tirwi$vipexih

xs$mxw$gsrxvmfyxmsrw$sj$(425$qmppmsr$jsv$iegl$sj$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$645<$erh$645;2$Xli$xsxep$pmefmpmx}$jsv$xlmw$tper$ex

Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$645<${ew$ettvs|mqexip}$(6=29$qmppmsr$erh$(6526$qmppmsr0$viwtigxmzip}0$erh$mw$mrgpyhih$mr$Sxliv$Rsr1Gyvvirx

Pmefmpmxmiw$mr$xli$eggsqter}mrk$Gsrwspmhexih$Fepergi$Wliixw2$Xli$gyvvirx$tsvxmsr$sj$xli$pmefmpmx}${ew$(529$qmppmsr$erh$(52;$qmppmsr$ew

sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$645<0$viwtigxmzip}2

5:2 Fywmriww$Wikqirxw$erh$Kiskvetlmg$Mrjsvqexmsr

Stivexmrk$erh$Vitsvxmrk$Wikqirxw

Xli$Gsqter}$gsrhygxw$mxw$fywmriww$xlvsykl$jsyv$vitsvxefpi$fywmriww$wikqirxw>$xli$Y2W2$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$wikqirx?$xli$KIS$Gevi

wikqirx?$ xli$ Mrxivrexmsrep$ Wivzmgiw$ wikqirx?$ erh$Jegmpmx}$Gsrwxvygxmsr$*$Hiwmkr$ wikqirx2$ Xli$Gsqter}$ lew$ mhirxmjmih$ xliwi$ jsyv

vitsvxefpi$ wikqirxw$ xs$ vijpigx$ xli$ gyvvirx$ zmi{$ xlex$ xli$Gsqter}$ stivexiw$ jsyv$ hmwxmrgx$ fywmriww$ pmriw0$ iegl$ sj${lmgl$ gsrwxmxyxiw$ e

qexivmep$tevx$sj$ mxw$szivepp$fywmriww2$Xli$Y2W2$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$wikqirx$tvmqevmp}$irgsqtewwiw$Y2W21fewih$ wigyvi$wivzmgiw$fywmriww2

Xli$Gsqter}×w$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$wivzmgiw0$}syxl$wivzmgiw$erh$FM$evi$stivexmrk$wikqirxw$ekkvikexih$yrhiv$xli$KIS$Gevi$vitsvxmrk

wikqirx2$Xli$KIS$Gevi$wikqirx0${lmgl$gsrhygxw$mxw$wivzmgiw$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw0$vitviwirxw$wivzmgiw$tvszmhih$xs$ehypxw$erh$nyzirmpiw

jsv$ rsr1viwmhirxmep$ xviexqirx0$ ihygexmsrep$ erh$ gsqqyrmx}$ fewih$ tvskveqw0$ tvi1vipiewi$ erh$ lepj1{e}$ lsywi$ tvskveqw0$ gsqtpmergi

xiglrspskmiw0$ qsrmxsvmrk$ wivzmgiw$ erh$ izmhirgi1fewih$ wytivzmwmsr$ erh$ xviexqirx$ tvskveqw$ jsv$ gsqqyrmx}1fewih$ tevspiiw0

tvsfexmsrivw0$ erh$ tvixvmep$ hijirherxw2$ Xli$ Mrxivrexmsrep$ Wivzmgiw$ wikqirx$ tvmqevmp}$ gsrwmwxw$ sj$ wigyvi$ wivzmgiw$ stivexmsrw$ mr$ Wsyxl

Ejvmge0$Eywxvepme$erh$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq2$Xli$Jegmpmx}$Gsrwxvygxmsr$*$Hiwmkr$wikqirx$tvmqevmp}$gsrxvegxw${mxl$zevmsyw$wxexi0$psgep

erh$ jihivep$ ekirgmiw$ jsv$ xli$hiwmkr$ erh$ gsrwxvygxmsr$sj$ jegmpmxmiw$ jsv${lmgl$ xli$Gsqter}$lew$qerekiqirx$ gsrxvegxw2$Kirivepp}0$ xli

ewwixw$ erh$ viziryiw$ jvsq$ xli$ Jegmpmx}$ Gsrwxvygxmsr$ *$ Hiwmkr$ wikqirx$ evi$ sjjwix$ f}$ e$ wmqmpev$ eqsyrx$ sj$ pmefmpmxmiw$ erh$ i|tirwiw2

Wikqirx$ hmwgpswyviw$ fips{$ ,mr$ xlsywerhw-$ vijpigx$ xli$ viwypxw$ sj$ gsrxmrymrk$ stivexmsrw2$ Epp$ xverwegxmsrw$ fix{iir$ wikqirxw$ evi

ipmqmrexih2

$

56:

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 193 of 253

Page 216: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5=7367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Jmwgep$]iev $ 645= $ 645< $ 645;

Viziryiw> $ $ $

Y2W2$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw $ ( 50:450:;= $ ( 508=60=;7 $ ( 5087<0488

KIS$Gevi $ :58068= $ 9<40757 $ 95805::

Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw $ 676045: $ 6970<;8 $ 5=90<4:

Jegmpmx}$Gsrwxvygxmsr$erh$Hiwmkr$_5a$_6a $ 6=0=;< $ 8066: $ 5590848

Xsxep$viziryiw $ ( 608;;0=66 $ ( 6077507<: $ ( 606:70864

Getmxep$I|tirhmxyviw> $ $ $ $ $ $

Y2W2$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw $ ( :=04;8 $ ( 5:7064< $ ( 55;05<:

KIS$Gevi $ 890444 $ 74057: $ 6806:7

Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw $ 508:< $ 60766 $ :0=9;

Xsxep$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw$_5a $ ( 5590986 $ ( 5=90::: $ ( 58<084:

Hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr> $ $ $

Y2W2$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw $ ( ;<0=;8 $ ( ;:0<45 $ ( ;906;:

KIS$Gevi $ 8=0;<5 $ 8;098: $ 8;0547

Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw $ 604;4 $ 604<; $ 50=5<

Xsxep$hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr$_5a $ ( 5740<69 $ ( 56:0878 $ ( 56806=;

Stivexmrk$Mrgsqi> $ $ $

Y2W2$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw $ ( 766094: $ ( 6=;0897 $ ( 74608<<

KIS$Gevi $ 58;047: $ 57<0=55 $ 5670969

Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw $ 5:0;67 $ 560<5: $ 580679

Jegmpmx}$Gsrwxvygxmsr$*$Hiwmkr$_5a$_6a $ ;8 $ Ó $ ,50:64-

Stivexmrk$mrgsqi$jvsq$wikqirxw $ ( 8<:077= $ ( 88=05<4 $ ( 87<0:6<

Kirivep$erh$Ehqmrmwxvexmzi$I|tirwiw $ ,5<90=6:- $ ,5<80959- $ ,5=40787-

Xsxep$stivexmrk$mrgsqi $ ( 7440857 $ ( 6:80::9 $ ( 68<06<9

_5a$Xli$Gsqter}$fiker$xli$hiwmkr$erh$gsrwxvygxmsr$sj$e$wigyvi$jegmpmx}$psgexih$mr$Vezirlepp0$e$psgepmx}$riev$Qipfsyvri0$Eywxvepme$mr

64582$Xli$jegmpmx}${ew$gsqtpixih$mr$Rsziqfiv$645;2$Xlivi${ivi$rs$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw$sv$hitvigmexmsr$sv$eqsvxm~exmsr$ewwsgmexih

{mxl$xlmw$wikqirx$mr$645=0$645<$sv$645;2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$;$1$Gsrxvegx$Vigimzefpi2

_6a$Hyvmrk$645=$erh$645<0$xli$Gsqter}$leh$jegmpmx}$gsrwxvygxmsr$*$hiwmkr$viziryiw$vipexih$xs$er$i|terwmsr$tvsnigx$ex$mxw$Jypleq

Gsvvigxmsrep$Girxvi$mr$Eywxvepme${lmgl$mw$i|tigxih$xs$fi$gsqtpixih$mr$xli$xlmvh$uyevxiv$sj$64642

Tvi1Xe|$Mrgsqi$Vigsrgmpmexmsr$sj$Wikqirxw

Xli$jspps{mrk$mw$e$vigsrgmpmexmsr$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$xsxep$stivexmrk$mrgsqi$jvsq$mxw$vitsvxefpi$wikqirxw$xs$xli$Gsqter}×w$mrgsqi

fijsvi$mrgsqi$xe|iw$erh$iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw0$mr$iegl$gewi0$hyvmrk$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$645<$erh$645;0

viwtigxmzip}2$

Jmwgep$]iev$Irhih 645= $ 645< $ 645;

$ ,Mr$xlsywerhw-

Stivexmrk$mrgsqi$jvsq$wikqirxw ( 8<:077= $ ( 88=05<4 $ ( 87<0:6<

Yreppsgexih$eqsyrxw> $ $

Kirivep$erh$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwi ,5<90=6:- $ ,5<80959- $ ,5=40787-

Rix$mrxiviwx$i|tirwi ,56604=4- $ ,559078<- $ ,=:078<-

Psww$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx ,80;=9- $ Ó $ Ó

Mrgsqi$fijsvi$mrgsqi$xe|iw$erh$iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw ( 5;7096< $ ( 58=075; $ ( 5950=7;

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 194 of 253

Page 217: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5=8367<

56;

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 195 of 253

Page 218: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5=9367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$ $ 645= $ 645< 645;

$$ $ ,Mr$xlsywerhw- $

Wikqirx$ewwixw> $ $ $

Y2W2$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw $ ( 60:5<0:6= $ ( 609=40;66 ( 607<904:=

KIS$Gevi $ 505560<<4 $ 504:708<8 505650;=6

Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw $ <604=; $ <80=55 84049:

Jegmpmx}$Gsrwxvygxmsr$*$Hiwmkr $ 7;50<8: $ 7<70;57 8==084:

Xsxep$wikqirx$ewwixw $ ( 805<90896 $ ( 805660<74 ( 8048:0767

Ewwix$Vigsrgmpmexmsr

Xli$jspps{mrk$mw$e$vigsrgmpmexmsr$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$vitsvxefpi$wikqirx$ewwixw$xs$xli$Gsqter}×w$xsxep$ewwixw$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750

645=$erh$645<0$viwtigxmzip}2$

$ 645= $ 645<

$ ,Mr$xlsywerhw-

Vitsvxefpi$wikqirx$ewwixw ( 805<90896 $ ( 805660<74

Gewl 7608:7 $ 750699

Hijivvih$mrgsqi$xe|$ewwixw 7:06;< $ 6=0=68

Viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$mrziwxqirxw0$gyvvirx$erh$rsr1gyvvirx :70785 $ ;8054=

Xsxep$ewwixw ( 8075;0978 $ ( 8069<055<

Kiskvetlmg$Mrjsvqexmsr

Hyvmrk$iegl$sj$ xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$ 645<$ erh$645;0$ xli$Gsqter}×w$ mrxivrexmsrep$ stivexmsrw${ivi$ gsrhygxih

xlvsykl$,m-$xli$Gsqter}×w${lspp}$s{rih$Eywxvepmer$wyfwmhmev}0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt$Eywxvepme$Tx}2$Pxh20$xlvsykl${lmgl$xli$Gsqter}$lew

qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$jsv$jsyv$gsvvigxmsrep$jegmpmxmiw0$,mm-$xli$Gsqter}+w${lspp}$s{rih$wyfwmhmevmiw0$KIS$Vezirlepp$Jmrergi$Lsphmrkw

Tx}2$Pxh2$erh$KIS$Vezirlepp$Lsphmrkw$Tx}2$Pxh2${lmgl0$ xskixliv0$leh$e$hiwmkr$erh$gsrwxvygxmsr$gsrxvegx$ jsv$e$ jegmpmx}$ mr$Vezirlepp0

Eywxvepme${lmgl${ew$ gsqtpixih$ mr$Rsziqfiv$645;0$ ,mmm-$ xli$Gsqter}×w${lspp}1s{rih$ wyfwmhmev}$ mr$Wsyxl$Ejvmge0$WEGQ0$ xlvsykl

{lmgl$xli$Gsqter}$qerekiw$sri$gsvvigxmsrep$jegmpmx}0$erh$,mz-$xli$Gsqter}×w${lspp}1s{rih$wyfwmhmev}$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq0$Xli

KIS$Kvsyt$YO$Pxh20$xlvsykl${lmgl$xli$Gsqter}$qerekiw$xli$Hyrkezip$Lsywi$Mqqmkvexmsr$Viqszep$Girxvi2

Jmwgep$]iev 645= $ 645< $ 645;

$ ,Mr$xlsywerhw-

Viziryiw> $ $ $ $ $

Y2W2$stivexmsrw ( 6065:0845 $ ( 604;706<: $ ( 50=960654

Eywxvepme$stivexmsrw 67908:6 $ 67505:8 $ 6<90;46

Wsyxl$Ejvmger$stivexmsrw 5<0;;= $ 5=0<4: $ 5<0695

Yrmxih$Omrkhsq$stivexmsrw ;06<4 $ ;0574 $ ;069;

Xsxep$viziryiw ( 608;;0=66 $ ( 6077507<: $ ( 606:70864

Tvstivx}$erh$Iuymtqirx0$rix> $ $

Y2W2$stivexmsrw ( 605750<;; $ ( 6058905=; $ ( 604:50;55

Eywxvepme$stivexmsrw 560659 $ 57044: $ 5:06<5

Wsyxl$Ejvmger$stivexmsrw 5<6 $ << $ 575

Yrmxih$Omrkhsq$stivexmsrw 88< $ 75= $ Ó

Xsxep$Tvstivx}$erh$Iuymtqirx0$rix ( 605880;66 $ ( 6059<0:54 $ ( 604;<0567

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 196 of 253

Page 219: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5=:367<

Wsyvgiw$sj$Viziryi

Xli$Gsqter}$hivmziw$qswx$sj$mxw$viziryi$jvsq$xli$qerekiqirx$sj$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw$xlvsykl$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw2$Xli

Gsqter}$epws$hivmziw$viziryi$jvsq$xli$tvszmwmsr$sj$gsqqyrmx}$fewih$erh$}syxl$wivzmgiw0$qsrmxsvmrk$erh$izmhirgi1fewih

56<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 197 of 253

Page 220: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5=;367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

wytivzmwmsr$erh$xviexqirx$tvskveqw$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw0$erh$i|terwmsr$sj$ri{$erh$i|mwxmrk$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw0$tvsgiwwmrk$girxivw$erh

viirxv}$girxivw2$

Jmwgep$]iev $ 645= $ 645< $ 645;

$ $ ,Mr$xlsywerhw-

Viziryiw> $ $ $ $ $ $

Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw $ ( 50<770:=9 $ ( 50;8:0<8; $ ( 50:770<94

KIS$Gevi $ :58068= $ 9<40757 $ 95805::

Jegmpmx}$Gsrwxvygxmsr$erh$Hiwmkr $ 6=0=;< $ 8066: $ 5590848

Xsxep$viziryiw $ ( 608;;0=66 $ ( 6077507<: $ ( 606:70864

Iuymx}$mr$Ievrmrkw$sj$Ejjmpmexiw

Iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw$jsv$645=0$645<$erh$645;$mrgpyhiw$xli$stivexmrk$viwypxw$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$nsmrx$zirxyviw$mr$WEGW

erh$KISEqi}2$Xliwi$nsmrx$zirxyviw$evi$eggsyrxih$jsv$yrhiv$xli$iuymx}$qixlsh$erh$xli$Gsqter}×w$mrziwxqirxw$mr$WEGW$erh

KISEqi}$evi$tviwirxih$ew$e$gsqtsrirx$sj$sxliv$rsr1gyvvirx$ewwixw$mr$xli$eggsqter}mrk$Gsrwspmhexih$Fepergi$Wliixw2

Xli$Gsqter}$lew$vigsvhih$(924$qmppmsr0$(;28$qmppmsr$erh$(542<$qmppmsr$mr$ievrmrkw0$rix$sj$xe|$mqtegx0$jsv$WEGW$stivexmsrw$hyvmrk$xli

}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$645<$erh$645;0$viwtigxmzip}0${lmgl$evi$mrgpyhih$mr$iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw0$rix$sj$mrgsqi$xe|

tvszmwmsr$mr$xli$eggsqter}mrk$Gsrwspmhexih$Wxexiqirxw$sj$Stivexmsrw2$Hyvmrk$645;0$WEGW${ew$wyggiwwjyp$mr$sfxemrmrk$e$jezsvefpi$xe|

nyhkqirx${lmgl$viwypxih$mr$er$mrgviewi$mr$ievrmrkw$rix$sj$xe|iw$sj$(929$qmppmsr$Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$645<0$xli$Gsqter}×w

mrziwxqirx$mr$WEGW${ew$(5627$qmppmsr$erh$(5728$qmppmsr0$viwtigxmzip}2$Xli$mrziwxqirx$mw$mrgpyhih$mr$sxliv$rsr1gyvvirx$ewwixw$mr$xli

eggsqter}mrk$Gsrwspmhexih$Fepergi$Wliixw2$Xli$Gsqter}$vigimzih$hmzmhirh$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$sj$(:27$qmppmsr$erh$(552<$qmppmsr0$mr$645=

erh$645<0$viwtigxmzip}$jvsq$xlmw$yrgsrwspmhexih$nsmrx$zirxyvi2

Xli$Gsqter}$lew$vigsvhih$(82:$qmppmsr0$(626$qmppmsr$erh$(526$qmppmsr$mr$ievrmrkw0$rix$sj$xe|$mqtegx0$jsv$KISEqi}×w$stivexmsrw

hyvmrk$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$645<$erh$645;0$viwtigxmzip}0${lmgl$evi$mrgpyhih$mr$iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw0$rix$sj

mrgsqi$xe|$tvszmwmsr0$mr$xli$eggsqter}mrk$Gsrwspmhexih$Wxexiqirxw$sj$Stivexmsrw2$Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$645<0$xli

Gsqter}×w$mrziwxqirx$mr$KISEqi}${ew$(92;$qmppmsr$erh$(82<$qmppmsr0$viwtigxmzip}0$erh$vitviwirxw$mxw$wlevi$sj$gyqypexmzi$vitsvxih

ievrmrkw2$Xli$Gsqter}$vigimzih$hmzmhirh$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$sj$(824$qmppmsr$mr$645=$jvsq$xlmw$yrgsrwspmhexih$nsmrx$zirxyvi2$Xlivi${ivi$rs

hmzmhirh$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$jvsq$xlmw$yrgsrwspmhexih$nsmrx$zirxyvi$mr$645<2

Fywmriww$Gsrgirxvexmsr

I|gitx$jsv$xli$qensv$gywxsqiv$rsxih$mr$xli$jspps{mrk$xefpi0$rs$sxliv$wmrkpi$gywxsqiv$qehi$yt$kviexiv$xler$54)$sj$xli

Gsqter}×w$gsrwspmhexih$viziryiw$jsv$xli$jspps{mrk$jmwgep$}ievw>$

Gywxsqiv $ 645= $ 645< $ 645;

Zevmsyw$ekirgmiw$sj$xli$Y2W$Jihivep$Kszivrqirx> $ 97) $ 94) $ 8<)

Xli$gsrgirxvexmsrw$efszi$vipexi$irxmvip}$xs$xli$Gsqter}+w$Y2W2$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$wikqirx2

Gvihmx$vmwo$vipexih$xs$eggsyrxw$vigimzefpi$mw$vijpigxmzi$sj$xli$vipexih$viziryiw2

5;2 Mrgsqi$Xe|iw

Xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw$erh$jsvimkr$gsqtsrirxw$sj$mrgsqi$fijsvi$mrgsqi$xe|iw$erh$iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$mr$ejjmpmexiw$evi$ew$jspps{w>$

56=

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 198 of 253

Page 221: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5=<367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$ $ 645= $ 645< $ 645;

$ $ ,Mr$xlsywerhw-

Mrgsqi$fijsvi$mrgsqi$xe|iw$erh$iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$mr$ejjmpmexiw $ $ $ $ $ $

Yrmxih$Wxexiw $ ( 5990<88 $ ( 57506:5 $ ( 5740649

Jsvimkr $ 5;0:<8 $ 5<049: $ 650;76

Mrgsqi$fijsvi$mrgsqi$xe|iw$erh$iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$mr

ejjmpmexiw $ ( 5;7096< $ ( 58=075; $ ( 5950=7;

Xli$tvszmwmsr$jsv$mrgsqi$xe|iw$gsrwmwxw$sj$xli$jspps{mrk$gsqtsrirxw>$

$ $ 645= $ 645< $ 645;

$ $ ,Mr$xlsywerhw-

Jihivep$mrgsqi$xe|iw> $ $ $ $ $ $

Gyvvirx $ ( 57045< $ ( =0784 $ ( 570=6<

Hijivvih $ ,;046<- $ ,605=9- $ ,70<47-

$ $ 90==4 $ ;0589 $ 540569

Wxexi$mrgsqi$xe|iw> $ $ $

Gyvvirx $ 904=7 $ 70494 $ 7077;

Hijivvih $ ,7<7- $ ,50<<=- $ ,606:=-

$ $ 80;54 $ 505:5 $ 504:<

Jsvimkr$mrgsqi$xe|iw> $ $ $

Gyvvirx $ ,<;9- $ 8=; $ ,550989-

Hijivvih $ :0<67 $ 90758 $ 5<0754

$ $ 90=8< $ 90<55 $ :0;:9

Xsxep$Y2W2$erh$jsvimkr$tvszmwmsr$jsv$mrgsqi$xe|iw $ ( 5:0:8< $ ( 58055; $ ( 5;0=9<

Xli$Y2W2$Xe|$Gyxw$erh$Nsfw$Egx$,&Xe|$Egx&-$iregxih$sr$Higiqfiv$660$645;$mrxvshygih$wmkrmjmgerx$glerkiw$xs$Y2W2$mrgsqi$xe|$pe{2

Ijjigxmzi$645<0$xli$Xe|$Egx$vihygih$xli$Y2W2$wxexyxsv}$gsvtsvexi$xe|$vexi$jvsq$79)$xs$65)2$Xli$65)$Y2W2$wxexyxsv}$gsvtsvexi$xe|$vexi

mw$ettpmgefpi$wxevxmrk$mr$645<2

Hyi$xs$xli$xmqmrk$sj$xli$iregxqirx$erh$xli$gsqtpi|mx}$mrzspzih$mr$ettp}mrk$xli$tvszmwmsrw$sj$xli$Xe|$Egx0$xli$Gsqter}$lew

qehi$viewsrefpi$iwxmqexiw$sj$xli$ijjigxw$erh$vigsvhih$tvszmwmsrep$eqsyrxw$mr$mxw$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$jsv$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750

645;2$Ew$xli$Gsqter}$gsppigxih$erh$tvitevih$rigiwwev}$hexe0$erh$mrxivtvixih$er}$ehhmxmsrep$kymhergi$mwwyih$f}$xli$Y2W2$Xviewyv}

Hitevxqirx0$xli$MVW$sv$sxliv$wxerhevh1wixxmrk$fshmiw0$mx$qehi$ehnywxqirxw$sziv$xli$gsyvwi$sj$xli$}iev$xs$xli$tvszmwmsrep$eqsyrxw0

mrgpyhmrk$vijmriqirxw$xs$hijivvih$xe|iw2$Xli$eggsyrxmrk$jsv$xli$xe|$ijjigxw$sj$xli$iregxqirx$sj$xli$Xe|$Egx$lew$fiir$gsqtpixih$ew$sj

Higiqfiv$750$645<2

Er}$pikmwpexmzi$glerkiw0$ew${ipp$ew$er}$sxliv$ri{$sv$tvstswih$Xviewyv}$vikypexmsrw$xs$ehhviww$uyiwxmsrw$xlex$evmwi$figeywi$sj

xli$Xe|$Egx0$qe}$viwypx$mr$ehhmxmsrep$mrgsqi$xe|$mqtegxw2$Xlivi$evi$rs$wmkrmjmgerx$mqtegxw$xs$mrgsqi$xe|$jsv$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv

750$645<$erh$645=2

Hyi$xs$xli$glerki$mr$xli$wxexyxsv}$xe|$vexi$jvsq$xli$Xe|$Egx0$xli$Gsqter}$viqiewyvih$mxw$hijivvih$xe|iw$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750

645;$xs$vijpigx$xli$vihygih$vexi$xlex${mpp$ettp}$mr$jyxyvi$tivmshw${lir$xliwi$hijivvih$xe|iw$evi$wixxpih$sv$viepm~ih2

Xli$rix$xe|$i|tirwi$,firijmx-$vigskrm~ih$vipexih$xs$xli$Xe|$Egx${ew$(,427-$qmppmsr$erh$(=2:$qmppmsr$jsv$645<$erh$645;0$viwtigxmzip}2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 199 of 253

Page 222: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 5==367<

574

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 200 of 253

Page 223: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 644367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

E$vigsrgmpmexmsr$sj$xli$wxexyxsv}$Y2W2$jihivep$xe|$vexi$sj$65)$erh$xli$ijjigxmzi$mrgsqi$xe|$vexi$mw$ew$jspps{w>$

$ $ 645= $ 645< $ 645;

$ $ ,Mr$xlsywerhw-

Tvszmwmsrw$ywmrk$wxexyxsv}$jihivep$mrgsqi$xe|$vexi $ ( 7:08;: $ ( 750784 $ ( 9705;9

Wxexi$mrgsqi$xe|iw$,firijmx-0$rix$sj$jihivep$xe|$firijmx $ 60865 $ 50=59 $ ,;;:-

VIMX$firijmx $ ,6607=9- $ ,5=0==6- $ ,870998-

Glerki$mr$zepyexmsr$epps{ergi $ 5089: $ ,50689- $ 60499

Jihivep$xe|$gvihmxw $ ,6055<- $ ,50=48- $ ,6045:-

$Xe|$Gyx$erh$Nsfw$Egx$mqtegx $ Ó $ ,745- $ =09<8

Jsvimkr$mrgsqi$xe|iw$,firijmx- $ 50=78 $ 508;= $ ,50<74-

Sxliv0$rix $ ,5056:- $ 60<69 $ 50764

Xsxep$tvszmwmsr$jsv$mrgsqi$xe|iw $ ( 5:0:8< $ ( 58055; $ ( 5;0=9<

Xli$Gsqter}+w$ijjigxmzi$xe|$vexi$hmjjivw$jvsq$xli$Y2W2$wxexyxsv}$vexi$sj$65)$tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs$e$~ivs$xe|$vexi$sr$ievrmrkw

kirivexih$f}$xli$Gsqter}+w$VIMX$stivexmsrw2$Wxexi$mrgsqi$xe|iw$,firijmx-0$rix$sj$jihivep$xe|$firijmxw$sj$(628$qmppmsr0$(52=$qmppmsr$erh

(,42<-$qmppmsr$jsv$645=0$645<$erh$645;0$viwtigxmzip}0$mw$tviwirxih$i|gpywmzi$sj$xli$vipexih$glerki$mr$zepyexmsr$epps{ergi$sj$wxexi

mrgsqi$xe|$hijivvih$mxiqw2$Rix$sj$xli$vipexih$glerki$mr$zepyexmsr$epps{ergiw$xli$wxexi$mrgsqi$xe|iw0$rix$sj$jihivep$xe|$firijmxw$mw$(825

qmppmsr0$(527$qmppmsr$erh$(529$qmppmsr$jsv$645=0$645<$erh$645;0$viwtigxmzip}2

Xli$jspps{mrk$xefpi$tviwirxw$xli$fvieohs{r$fix{iir$rsr1gyvvirx$rix$hijivvih$xe|$ewwixw$ew$gpewwmjmih$sr$xli$fepergi$wliixw$ew$sj

Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$645<>$

$ $ 645= $ 645<

$ $ ,Mr$xlsywerhw-

Hijivvih$xe|$ewwixw$1$rsr$gyvvirx $ ( 7:06;< $ ( 6=0=68

Hijivvih$xe|$pmefmpmxmiw$1$rsr$gyvvirx $ ,5=0698- $ ,570:<5-

Xsxep$rix$hijivvih$xe|$ewwixw $ ( 5;0468 $ ( 5:0687

575

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 201 of 253

Page 224: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 645367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Xli$wmkrmjmgerx$gsqtsrirxw$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$hijivvih$xe|$ewwixw$erh$pmefmpmxmiw$gsrwmwxih$sj$xli$jspps{mrk$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750

645=$erh$645<>

$ $ 645= $ 645<

$Hijivvih$xe|$ewwixw> $ ,Mr$xlsywerhw-

Rix$stivexmrk$pswwiw $ ( 7607=8 $ ( 790=68

Eggvyih$pmefmpmxmiw $ 680896 $ 670;5=

Hijivvih$gsqtirwexmsr $ 590496 $ 560475

Eggvyih$gsqtirwexmsr $ ;067= $ ;0;79

Hijivvih$viziryi $ 57065= $ <089<

Xe|$gvihmxw $ 90667 $ :0<94

Iuymx}$e{evhw $ 80<=8 $ 8085=

Hitvigmexmsr $ 590868 $ =0=:4

Stivexmrk$piewi$pmefmpmx} $ 570584 $ Ó

Sxliv0$rix $ 50<5; $ Ó

Zepyexmsr$epps{ergi $ ,660;<:- $ ,650777-

Xsxep$hijivvih$xe|$ewwixw $ ( 55404:< $ ( <;0;:7

Hijivvih$xe|$pmefmpmxmiw> $ $ $ $

Mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw $ ( ,6804=;- $ ( ,6:0987-

Getmxepm~ih$xverwegxmsr$gswxw $ ,5:0;=;- $ ,5:0:87-

Eggsyrxmrk$qixlsh$glerki $ ,;045=- $ Ó

Tvitemh$i|tirwiw$erh$sxliv $ ,7608=7- $ ,6<0658-

Piewi$vmklx1sj1ywi$ewwixw $ ,560:7<- $ Ó

$$$$$$$Sxliv0$rix $ Ó $ ,564-

Xsxep$hijivvih$xe|$pmefmpmxmiw $ ( ,=70488- $ ( ,;50964-

$ $ $ $ $

Xsxep$rix$hijivvih$xe|$ewwixw $ ( 5;0468 $ ( 5:0687

Hijivvih$mrgsqi$xe|iw$wlsyph$fi$vihygih$f}$e$zepyexmsr$epps{ergi$mj$mx$mw$rsx$qsvi$pmoip}$xler$rsx$xlex$wsqi$tsvxmsr$sv$epp$sj$xli

hijivvih$xe|$ewwixw${mpp$fi$viepm~ih2$Sr$e$tivmshmg$fewmw0$qerekiqirx$izepyexiw$erh$hixivqmriw$xli$eqsyrx$sj$xli$zepyexmsr$epps{ergi

viuymvih$erh$ehnywxw$ wygl$zepyexmsr$epps{ergi$eggsvhmrkp}2$Ex$}iev$irh$645=$erh$645<0$ xli$Gsqter}$lew$e$zepyexmsr$epps{ergi$sj

(662<$qmppmsr$erh$(6527$qmppmsr0$viwtigxmzip}$vipexih$xs$hijivvih$xe|$ewwixw$jsv$jsvimkr$rix$stivexmrk$pswwiw0$wxexi$rix$stivexmrk$pswwiw

erh$wxexi$xe|$gvihmxw2$Xli$zepyexmsr$epps{ergi$mrgviewih$f}$(529$qmppmsr$hyvmrk$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=2

Xli$ Gsqter}$ tvszmhiw$ mrgsqi$ xe|iw$ sr$ xli$ yrhmwxvmfyxih$ ievrmrkw$ sj$ rsr1Y2W2$ wyfwmhmevmiw$ i|gitx$ xs$ xli$ i|xirx$ xlex$ wygl

ievrmrkw$ evi$ tivqerirxp}$ mrziwxih$ syxwmhi$ xli$ Yrmxih$ Wxexiw2$ Ex$ Higiqfiv$ 750$ 645=0$ (=2=$ qmppmsr$ sj$ eggyqypexih$ yrhmwxvmfyxih

ievrmrkw$ sj$ rsr1Y2W2$ wyfwmhmevmiw$ {ivi$ tivqerirxp}$ mrziwxih$ syxwmhi$ xli$ Yrmxih$ Wxexiw2$ Ex$ xli$ i|mwxmrk$ Y2W2$ jihivep$ mrgsqi$ erh

ettpmgefpi$jsvimkr${mxllsphmrk$xe|$vexiw0$ehhmxmsrep$xe|iw$,rix$sj$jsvimkr$xe|$gvihmxw-$sj$(429$qmppmsr0$gsrwmwxmrk$wspip}$sj${mxllsphmrk

xe|iw0${syph$lezi$xs$fi$tvszmhih$mj$wygl$ievrmrkw${ivi$viqmxxih$gyvvirxp}2

Ew$sj$ xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$ xli$Gsqter}$leh$(8725$qmppmsr$sj$Jihivep$ rix$stivexmrk$ psww$ gevv}jsv{evhw${lmgl

fikmr$ xs$i|tmvi$ mr$6476$erh$(6472;$qmppmsr$sj$gsqfmrih$rix$stivexmrk$ psww$gevv}jsv{evhw$ mr$zevmsyw$wxexiw${lmgl$fikmr$ xs$i|tmvi$ mr

645=2$Xli$Jihivep$rix$stivexmrk$pswwiw$evi$ex$ xli$Gsqter}+w$VIMX${lmgl$ mw$rsx$wyfnigx$ xs$xe|2$Xli$Gsqter}$lew$ vigsvhih$e$tevxmep

zepyexmsr$epps{ergi$ekemrwx$xli$hijivvih$xe|$ewwixw$vipexih$xs$xli$wxexi$stivexmrk$pswwiw2

Epws0$ew$sj$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$leh$(9;2=$qmppmsr$sj$jsvimkr$stivexmrk$pswwiw${lmgl$gevv}$jsv{evh

mrhijmrmxip}$ erh$ (925$qmppmsr$ sj$ wxexi$ xe|$ gvihmxw$ {lmgl$ fikmr$ xs$ i|tmvi$ mr$ 645=2$ Xli$ Gsqter}$ lew$ vigsvhih$ e$ tevxmep$ zepyexmsr

epps{ergi$ekemrwx$xli$hijivvih$xe|$ewwixw$vipexih$xs$xli$jsvimkr$stivexmrk$pswwiw$erh$wxexi$xe|$gvihmxw2

Xli$Gsqter}$vigskrm~iw$xli$gswx$sj$iqtps}ii$wivzmgiw$vigimzih$mr$i|glerki$jsv$e{evhw$sj$iuymx}$mrwxvyqirxw$fewih$ytsr$xli

kverx$hexi$jemv$zepyi$sj$xlswi$e{evhw2$Xli$i|ivgmwi$sj$rsr1uyepmjmih$wxsgo$stxmsrw$erh$ziwxmrk$sj$viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$e{evhw${lmgl$lezi

fiir$kverxih$yrhiv$xli$Gsqter}×w$iuymx}$e{evh$tperw$kmzi$vmwi$xs$gsqtirwexmsr$mrgsqi${lmgl$mw$mrgpyhefpi$mr$xli$xe|efpi$mrgsqi$sj

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 202 of 253

Page 225: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 646367<

xli$ettpmgefpi$iqtps}iiw$erh$xli$qensvmx}$sj${lmgl$ mw$hihygxmfpi$f}$xli$Gsqter}$jsv$jihivep$erh$wxexi$mrgsqi$xe|$tyvtswiw2$ Mr$xli

gewi$sj$rsr1uyepmjmih$wxsgo$stxmsrw0$xli$gsqtirwexmsr$mrgsqi$viwypxw$jvsq$mrgviewiw$mr$xli$jemv$qevoix$zepyi$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$gsqqsr

wxsgo$wyfwiuyirx$xs$xli$hexi$sj$kverx2$Ex$}iev$irh$645=0$xli$hijivvih$xe|$ewwix$rix$sj$e$zepyexmsr$epps{ergi

576

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 203 of 253

Page 226: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 647367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

vipexih$xs$yri|ivgmwih$wxsgo$stxmsrw$erh$viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$kverxw$jsv${lmgl$xli$Gsqter}$lew$vigsvhih$e$fsso$i|tirwi${ew$(82=$qmppmsr2

Xli$Gsqter}$vigskrm~iw$xli$jmrergmep$wxexiqirx$firijmx$sj$e$xe|$tswmxmsr$srp}$ejxiv$hixivqmrmrk$xlex$xli$vipizerx$xe|$eyxlsvmx}

{syph$qsvi$pmoip}$xler$rsx$wywxemr$xli$tswmxmsr$jspps{mrk$er$eyhmx2$Jsv$xe|$tswmxmsrw$qiixmrk$xli$qsvi1pmoip}1xler1rsx$xlviwlsph0$ xli

eqsyrx$vigskrm~ih$mr$xli$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$mw$xli$pevkiwx$firijmx$xlex$lew$e$kviexiv$xler$94$tivgirx$pmoipmlssh$sj$fimrk$viepm~ih$ytsr

ypxmqexi$wixxpiqirx${mxl$xli$vipizerx$xe|$eyxlsvmx}2

E$vigsrgmpmexmsr$sj$xli$fikmrrmrk$erh$irhmrk$eqsyrx$sj$yrvigskrm~ih$xe|$firijmxw$mw$ew$jspps{w>

$

$ $ 645= $ 645< $ 645;

$ $ ,Mr$xlsywerhw-

Fepergi$ex$Fikmrrmrk$sj$Tivmsh $ ( 809<8 $ ( 808:5 $ ( 50:84

Ehhmxmsrw$fewih$sr$xe|$tswmxmsrw$vipexih$xs$xli$gyvvirx$}iev $ Ó $ Ó $ Ó

Ehhmxmsrw$jsv$xe|$tswmxmsrw$sj$tvmsv$}ievw $ ==8 $ 6=< $ Ó

Ehhmxmsrw$jvsq$gyvvirx$}iev$eguymwmxmsrw $ Ó $ Ó $ 80565

Vihygxmsrw$jsv$xe|$tswmxmsrw$sj$tvmsv$}ievw $ Ó $ Ó $ ,506=4-

Vihygxmsrw$ew$e$viwypx$sj$e$petwi$sj$ettpmgefpi$wxexyxiw$sj$pmqmxexmsrw $ ,54=- $ ,5;9- $ ,54-

Fepergi$ex$Irh$sj$Tivmsh $ ( 908:= $ ( 809<8 $ ( 808:5

Epp$eqsyrxw$mr$xli$vigsrgmpmexmsr$evi$vitsvxih$sr$e$kvsww$fewmw$erh$hs$rsx$vijpigx$e$jihivep$xe|$firijmx$sr$wxexi$mrgsqi$xe|iw2$Xli

Gsqter}$lew$eggvyih$(927$qmppmsr$sj$eggvyih$yrgivxemr$ xe|$firijmxw$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=${lmgl$ mw$ mrgpywmzi$sj$ xli$ jihivep$ xe|

firijmx$ sr$ wxexi$ mrgsqi$ xe|iw2$ Xli$ Gsqter}$ fipmiziw$ xlex$ mx$ mw$ viewsrefp}$ tswwmfpi$ xlex$ e$ higviewi$ qe}$ fi$ rigiwwev}$ mr$ xli

yrvigskrm~ih$ xe|$firijmxw${mxlmr$x{ipzi$qsrxlw$sj$ xli$vitsvxmrk$hexi$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(4248$qmppmsr0$vipexih$xs$wxexi$xe|$i|tswyviw0

hyi$ xs$ e$ petwi$ sj$ xli$ wxexyxi$ sj$ pmqmxexmsr2$ Xli$ eggvyih$ yrgivxemr$ xe|$ fepergi$ ex$ Higiqfiv$ 750$ 645=$ mrgpyhiw$ (927$ qmppmsr$ sj

yrvigskrm~ih$xe|$firijmxw${lmgl0$mj$ypxmqexip}$vigskrm~ih0${mpp$vihygi$xli$Gsqter}×w$erryep$ijjigxmzi$xe|$vexi2

Xli$ Gsqter}$ mw$ wyfnigx$ xs$ mrgsqi$ xe|iw$ mr$ xli$ Y2W2$ jihivep$ nyvmwhmgxmsr0$ erh$ zevmsyw$ wxexiw$ erh$ jsvimkr$ nyvmwhmgxmsrw2$ Xe|

vikypexmsrw$ {mxlmr$ iegl$ nyvmwhmgxmsr$ evi$ wyfnigx$ xs$ xli$ mrxivtvixexmsr$ sj$ xli$ vipexih$ xe|$ pe{w$ erh$ vikypexmsrw$ erh$ viuymvi$ wmkrmjmgerx

nyhkqirx$ xs$ettp}2$[mxl$ ji{$i|gitxmsrw0$ xli$Gsqter}$ mw$rs$ psrkiv$ wyfnigx$ xs$Y2W2$ jihivep0$ wxexi$erh$ psgep0$sv$rsr1Y2W2$ mrgsqi$ xe|

i|eqmrexmsrw$f}$ xe|$eyxlsvmxmiw$ jsv$ xli$}ievw$fijsvi$64592$Xli$Gsqter}${ew$yrhiv$eyhmx$f}$ xli$MVW$jsv$ xli$6457$ xe|$}iev0$ mxw$ jmvwx

VIMX$}iev2$ Mr$ xli$ jsyvxl$uyevxiv$sj$645;0$ xli$Gsqter}$vigimzih$e$rs$glerki$ pixxiv$ jvsq$xli$MVW$jsv$ xli$6457$ xe|$}iev2$Sri$sj$syv

jsvimkr$wyfwmhmevmiw$mw$yrhiv$i|eqmrexmsr$mr$e$jsvimkr$nyvmwhmgxmsr$jsv$xe|$}ievw$6459$xs$645<0$rs$ewwiwwqirx$lew$fiir$qehi2

Xli$ gepgypexmsr$sj$ xli$Gsqter}×w$ tvszmwmsr$ ,firijmx-$ jsv$ mrgsqi$ xe|iw$ viuymviw$ xli$ ywi$ sj$ wmkrmjmgerx$ nyhkqirx$ erh$ mrzspziw

hiepmrk${mxl$ yrgivxemrxmiw$ mr$ xli$ ettpmgexmsr$ sj$ gsqtpi|$ xe|$ pe{w$ erh$ vikypexmsrw2$ Mr$ hixivqmrmrk$ xli$ ehiuyeg}$ sj$ xli$ Gsqter}×w

tvszmwmsr$,firijmx-$jsv$mrgsqi$xe|iw0$tsxirxmep$wixxpiqirx$syxgsqiw$viwypxmrk$jvsq$mrgsqi$xe|$i|eqmrexmsrw$evi$vikypevp}$ewwiwwih2$Ew

wygl0$xli$jmrep$syxgsqi$sj$xe|$i|eqmrexmsrw0$mrgpyhmrk$xli$xsxep$eqsyrx$te}efpi$sv$xli$xmqmrk$sj$er}$wygl$te}qirxw$ytsr$viwspyxmsr$sj

xliwi$mwwyiw0$gerrsx$fi$iwxmqexih${mxl$givxemrx}2

Hyvmrk$xli$}ievw$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$645<0$xli$Gsqter}$hmh$rsx$vigskrm~i$er}$mrxiviwx$erh$tirepxmiw2$Xli$Gsqter}

gpewwmjmiw$mrxiviwx$erh$tirepxmiw$ew$mrxiviwx$i|tirwi$erh$sxliv$i|tirwi0$viwtigxmzip}2

5<2 Gsqqmxqirxw$erh$Gsrxmrkirgmiw

Gsppigxmzi$Fevkemrmrk$Ekviiqirxw

Xli$Gsqter}$leh$ettvs|mqexip}$77)$sj$mxw${svojsvgi$gszivih$f}$gsppigxmzi$fevkemrmrk$ekviiqirxw$ex$Higiqfiv$750$645=2

Gsppigxmzi$fevkemrmrk$ekviiqirxw${mxl$;)$sj$iqtps}iiw$evi$wix$xs$i|tmvi$mr$piww$xler$sri$}iev2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 204 of 253

Page 227: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 648367<

Gsrxvegx$E{evhw3Qshmjmgexmsrw

577

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 205 of 253

Page 228: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 649367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Sr$Higiqfiv$740$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$errsyrgih$xlex$KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$wmkrih$e$ri{$qerekih1srp}$gsrxvegx${mxl$xli

Y2W2$Qevwlepw$Wivzmgi$jsv$xli$kszivrqirx1s{rih0$9561fih$Ip$Girxvs$Wivzmgi$Hixirxmsr$Jegmpmx}$mr$Gepmjsvrme2$Xli$gsrxvegx${mpp$lezi$e

xivq$sj$imklx$}ievw$erh$rmri$qsrxlw0$mrgpywmzi$sj$stxmsr$tivmshw0$ijjigxmzi$Higiqfiv$670$645=2$$$$

Sr$Higiqfiv$670$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$errsyrgih$xlex$mx$irxivih$mrxs$x{s$ri{$gsrxvegxw${mxl$Y2W2$Mqqmkvexmsr$erh$Gywxsqw

Irjsvgiqirx$,ÔMGIÕ-$jsv$jmzi$gsqter}1s{rih$jegmpmxmiw$mr$Gepmjsvrme$xsxepmrk$808=4$fihw2$Xli$gsrxvegxw${mpp$lezi$xivqw$sj$59$}ievw

}ievw0$mrgpywmzi$sj$x{s$jmzi$}iev$stxmsrw0$ijjigxmzi$Higiqfiv$640$645=2$Xli$gsrxvegxw$gsziv$x{s$i|mwxmrk0$gsqter}1s{rih$jegmpmxmiw

gyvvirxp}$stivexih$f}$KIS$sr$filepj$sj$MGI>$xli$50=841fih$Ehiperxs$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxiv$erh$xli$8441fih$Qiwe$Zivhi$MGI

Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxiv2$Xli$gsrxvegxw$epws$mrgsvtsvexi$xlvii$sxliv$gsqter}1s{rih$jegmpmxmiw>$xli$;441fih$Girxvep$Zeppi}$jegmpmx}0$xli$;941

fih$Hiwivx$Zmi{$jegmpmx}0$erh$xli$;441fih$Ksphir$Wxexi$jegmpmx}0$ew$jegmpmx}$erri|iw2

$$$$

Mr$xli$xlmvh$uyevxiv$sj$645=0$xli$Gsqter}${ew$e{evhih$e$xir1}iev$gsrxvegx$viri{ep$jsv$xli$gsrxmryih$hipmziv}$sj$wigyvi

xverwtsvxexmsr$yrhiv$syv$KIS$Eqi}$nsmrx$zirxyvi$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq2

Sr$Nyri$90$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$errsyrgih$xlex$mx$irxivih$mrxs$e$gsrxvegx$qshmjmgexmsr$xs$mrgviewi$xli$gsrxvegx$getegmx}$ex$mxw

gsqter}1s{rih$Qsrxksqiv}$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxiv$mr$Gsrvsi0$Xi|ew$f}$758$fihw$mrgviewmrk$xli$girxiv+w$getegmx}$xs$50758$fihw2$Xli$7581

fih$gsrxvegx$getegmx}$mrgviewi$figeqi$jypp}$stivexmsrep$mr$xli$xlmvh$uyevxiv$sj$645=2

Sr$Qe}$60$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$errsyrgih$xlex$mx$irxivih$mrxs$e$ri{$xir1}iev$gsrxvegx0$mrgpywmzi$sj$viri{ep$stxmsr$tivmshw0

{mxl$xli$Jihivep$Fyviey$sj$Tvmwsrw$,ÔFSTÕ-$jsv$xli$viegxmzexmsr$sj$mxw$i|mwxmrk$gsqter}1s{rih0$50<441fih$Rsvxl$Peoi$Gsvvigxmsrep

Jegmpmx}$psgexih$mr$Feph{mr0$Qmglmker2$Xli$gsrxvegx$figeqi$stivexmsrep$sr$Sgxsfiv$50$645=2$Xli$Gsqter}$epws$errsyrgih$sr$Qe}$60

645=$xlex$Viiziw$Gsyrx}0$Xi|ew$irxivih$mrxs$x{s$ri{$xir1}iev$gsrxvegxw0$mrgpywmzi$sj$viri{ep$tivmshw0${mxl$xli$FST$jsv$xli$gsyrx}1

s{rih0$50<441fih$Viiziw$Gsyrx}$Hixirxmsr$Girxiv$M$*$MM$erh$xli$gsyrx}1s{rih0$507;:1fih$Viiziw$Gsyrx}$Hixirxmsr$Girxiv$MMM2$KIS

{mpp$tvszmhi$qerekiqirx$gsrwypxmrk$erh$wyttsvx$wivzmgiw$xs$Viiziw$Gsyrx}2$Xli$ri{$xir1}iev$gsrxvegxw${ivi$e{evhih$xs$KIS$erh

Viiziw$Gsyrx}$yrhiv$e$psrk1wxerhmrk$tvsgyviqirx0$jsv$xli$lsywmrk$sj$rsr1Y2W2$gmxm~ir$gvmqmrep$epmirw0$gsqqsrp}$vijivvih$xs$ew

Gvmqmrep$Epmir$Viuymviqirx$,GEV-$5=0${lmgl${ew$mwwyih$f}$xli$FST$mr$645;2

Sr$Etvmp$690$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$errsyrgih$xlex$mx$wmkrih$e$gsrxvegx$qshmjmgexmsr$jsv$xli$viegxmzexmsr$sj$mxw$i|mwxmrk$gsqter}1

s{rih$504441fih$Wsyxl$Psymwmere$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxiv$,xli$&Girxiv&-$psgexih$mr$Fewmpi0$Psymwmere2$Xli$tvizmsywp}$mhpih$Girxiv${mpp

lsywi$jihivep$mqqmkvexmsr$hixemriiw$yrhiv$er$i|mwxmrk$mrxivkszivrqirxep$wivzmgi$ekviiqirx2$Xli$Girxiv$fiker$xli$mrxeoi$tvsgiww

hyvmrk$xli$xlmvh$uyevxiv$sj$645=2

Gsrxvegx$Xivqmrexmsrw

$$$$Vigirxp}$Gepmjsvrme$iregxih$pikmwpexmsr$emqih$ex$tlewmrk$syx$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmt$gsrxvegxw$jsv$xli$stivexmsr$sj$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw

{mxlmr$Gepmjsvrme$erh$jegmpmxmiw$syxwmhi$sj$xli$wxexi$sj$Gepmjsvrme$lsywmrk$wxexi$sj$Gepmjsvrme$mrqexiw2$Ew$tvizmsywp}$errsyrgih0$xli

Gsqter}+w$gsrxvegx$jsv$mxw$Girxvep$Zeppi}$jegmpmx}${ew$epvieh}$hmwgsrxmryih$f}$xli$Gepmjsvrme$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmsrw$erh

Vilefmpmxexmsr$ex$xli$irh$sj$Witxiqfiv$645=2$Xli$Gsqter}$i|tigxw$xlex$mxw$gsrxvegxw${mxl$xli$Gepmjsvrme$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmsrw

erh$Vilefmpmxexmsr$jsv$mxw$Hiwivx$Zmi{$jegmpmx}$erh$Ksphir$Wxexi$jegmpmx}${mpp$fi$hmwgsrxmryih$f}$Qevgl$50$6464$erh$Qe}$50$64640

viwtigxmzip}2$Ew$hmwgywwih$efszi0$xli$Gsqter}$wyfwiuyirxp}$irxivih$mrxs$ri{$gsrxvegxw${mxl$MGI$jsv$mxw$Girxvep$Zeppi}0$Hiwivx$Zmi{

erh$Ksphir$Wxexi$jegmpmxmiw$ijjigxmzi$Higiqfiv$640$645=2

Gsqqmxqirxw

Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$leh$gsrxvegxyep$gsqqmxqirxw$jsv$e$ryqfiv$sj$tvsnigxw$ywmrk$i|mwxmrk$Gsqter}

jmrergmrk$jegmpmxmiw2$Xli$Gsqter}×w$qerekiqirx$iwxmqexiw$xlex$xliwi$i|mwxmrk$getmxep$tvsnigxw${mpp$gswx$ettvs|mqexip}$(:524$qmppmsr0$sj

{lmgl$(6<24$qmppmsr${ew$wtirx$xlvsykl$645=2$Xli$Gsqter}$iwxmqexiw$xli$viqemrmrk$getmxep$viuymviqirxw$vipexih$xs$xliwi$getmxep

tvsnigxw$xs$fi$ettvs|mqexip}$(7724$qmppmsr2$Xliwi$tvsnigxw$evi$i|tigxih$xs$fi$gsqtpixih$xlvsykl$64642

Mr$ehhmxmsr$xs$xliwi$gyvvirx$iwxmqexih$getmxep$viuymviqirxw0$xli$Gsqter}$mw$gyvvirxp}$mr$xli$tvsgiww$sj$fmhhmrk$sr0$sv$izepyexmrk

tsxirxmep$fmhw$jsv$xli$hiwmkr0$gsrwxvygxmsr$erh$qerekiqirx$sj$e$ryqfiv$sj$ri{$tvsnigxw2$Mr$xli$izirx$xlex$xli$Gsqter}${mrw$fmhw$jsv

xliwi$tvsnigxw$erh$higmhiw$xs$wipj1jmrergi$xlimv$gsrwxvygxmsr0$mxw$getmxep$viuymviqirxw$gsyph$qexivmepp}$mrgviewi2

578

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 206 of 253

Page 229: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 64:367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Pmxmkexmsr0$Gpemqw$erh$Ewwiwwqirxw

Ew$tvizmsywp}$vitsvxih$erh$hiwgvmfih$mr$xli$Gsqter}+w$tvmsv$tivmshmg$vitsvxw0$mrgpyhmrk$qswx$vigirxp}$mr$mxw$Jsvq$541U$jsv$xli

uyevxiv$irhih$Witxiqfiv$740$645=0$jsvqiv$gmzmp$mqqmkvexmsr$hixemriiw$ex$xli$Eyvsve$Mqqmkvexmsr$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxiv$jmpih$e$gpeww$egxmsr

pe{wymx$sr$Sgxsfiv$660$64580$ekemrwx$xli$Gsqter}$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw$Hmwxvmgx$Gsyvx$jsv$xli$Hmwxvmgx$sj$Gspsvehs$,xli$ÔGsyvxÕ-2$Xli

gsqtpemrx$eppikiw$xlex$xli$Gsqter}${ew$mr$zmspexmsr$sj$xli$Gspsvehs$Qmrmqyq$[ekiw$sj$[svoivw$Egx$erh$xli$jihivep$Xvejjmgomrk

Zmgxmqw$Tvsxigxmsr$Egx$,&XZTE&-2$Xli$tpemrxmjj$gpeww$gpemqw$xlex$xli$Gsqter}${ew$yrnywxp}$irvmglih$figeywi$sj$xli$pizip$sj$te}qirx

xli$hixemriiw$vigimzih$jsv${svo$tivjsvqih$ex$xli$jegmpmx}0$izir$xlsykl$xli$zspyrxev}${svo$tvskveq$ew${ipp$ew$xli${eki$vexiw$erh

wxerhevhw$ewwsgmexih${mxl$xli$tvskveq$xlex$evi$ex$mwwyi$mr$xli$gewi$evi$eyxlsvm~ih$f}$xli$Jihivep$kszivrqirx$yrhiv$kymhipmriw$ettvszih

f}$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw$Gsrkviww2$Sr$Nyp}$:0$64590$xli$Gsyvx$jsyrh$xlex$hixemriiw${ivi$rsx$iqtps}iiw$yrhiv$xli$Gspsvehs$Qmrmqyq

[eki$Svhiv$erh$hmwqmwwih$xlmw$gpemq2$Mr$Jifvyev}$645;0$xli$Gsyvx$kverxih$xli$tpemrxmjj1gpeww×$qsxmsr$jsv$gpeww$givxmjmgexmsr$sr$xli

XZTE$erh$yrnywx$irvmglqirx$gpemqw2$Xli$tpemrxmjj$gpeww$wiiow$egxyep$heqekiw0$gsqtirwexsv}$heqekiw0$i|iqtpev}$heqekiw0$tyrmxmzi

heqekiw0$viwxmxyxmsr0$exxsvri}w×$jiiw$erh$gswxw0$erh$wygl$sxliv$vipmij$ew$xli$Gsyvx$qe}$hiiq$tvstiv2$Mr$xli$xmqi$wmrgi$xli$Gspsvehs$wymx

{ew$mrmxmepp}$jmpih0$xlvii$wmqmpev$pe{wymxw$lezi$fiir$jmpih$1$x{s$mr$[ewlmrkxsr$erh$sri$mr$Gepmjsvrme2$Mr$[ewlmrkxsr0$sri$sj$xli$x{s

pe{wymxw${ew$jmpih$sr$Witxiqfiv$=0$645;$f}$mqqmkvexmsr$hixemriiw$ekemrwx$xli$Gsqter}$mr$xli$Y2W2$Hmwxvmgx$Gsyvx$jsv$xli$[iwxivr

Hmwxvmgx$sj$[ewlmrkxsr2$Xli$wigsrh$pe{wymx${ew$jmpih$sr$Witxiqfiv$640$645;$f}$xli$Wxexi$Exxsvri}$Kirivep$ekemrwx$xli$Gsqter}$mr$xli

Wytivmsv$Gsyvx$sj$xli$Wxexi$sj$[ewlmrkxsr$jsv$Tmivgi$Gsyrx}0${lmgl$xli$Gsqter}$viqszih$xs$xli$Y2W2$Hmwxvmgx$Gsyvx$jsv$xli$[iwxivr

Hmwxvmgx$sj$[ewlmrkxsr$sr$Sgxsfiv$=0$645;2$Mr$Gepmjsvrme0$e$gpeww1egxmsr$pe{wymx${ew$jmpih$sr$Higiqfiv$5=0$645;$f}$mqqmkvexmsr

hixemriiw$ekemrwx$xli$Gsqter}$mr$xli$Y2W2$Hmwxvmgx$Gsyvx$Iewxivr$Hmzmwmsr$sj$xli$Girxvep$Hmwxvmgx$sj$Gepmjsvrme2$Epp$xlvii$pe{wymxw$eppiki

zmspexmsrw$sj$xli$viwtigxmzi$wxexi×w$qmrmqyq${eki$pe{w2$Ls{iziv0$xli$Gepmjsvrme$pe{wymx0$pmoi$xli$Gspsvehs$wymx0$epws$mrgpyhiw$gpemqw

xlex$xli$Gsqter}$zmspexih$xli$XZTE$erh$Gepmjsvrme+w$iuymzepirx$wxexi$wxexyxi2$Sr$Witxiqfiv$6;0$645=0$xli$Gepmjsvrme$tpemrxmjj$gpeww

jmpih$e$qsxmsr$jsv$gpeww$givxmjmgexmsr$sj$fsxl$Gepmjsvrme1fewih$erh$rexmsr{mhi$gpewwiw2$Xli$Gsqter}$jmpih$e$viwtsrwi$xs$xlmw$qsxmsr

hmwtyxmrk$xli$tpemrxmjj$gpeww+$vmklx$xs$fvseh$gpeww$xviexqirx$sj$xli$gpemqw$ex$mwwyi2$Sr$Nyp}$60$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$jmpih$e$Qsxmsr$jsv

Wyqqev}$Nyhkqirx$mr$xli$[ewlmrkxsr$Exxsvri}$Kirivep×w$Xegsqe$pe{wymx$fewih$sr$xli$Gsqter}×w$tswmxmsr$xlex$mxw$pikep$hijirwiw

tvizirx$xli$gewi$jvsq$tvsgiihmrk$xs$xvmep2$Xli$jihivep$gsyvx$mr$[ewlmrkxsr$hirmih$xli$Gsqter}+w$Qsxmsr$jsv$Wyqqev}$Nyhkqirx$sr

Eykywx$:0$645=2$Ls{iziv0$sr$Eykywx$640$645=0$xli$Hitevxqirx$sj$Nywxmgi$jmpih$e$Wxexiqirx$sj$Mrxiviwx0${lmgl$ewoih$xli$[ewlmrkxsr

gsyvx$xs$vizmwmx$mxw$tvmsv$hirmep$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$mrxivkszivrqirxep$mqqyrmx}$hijirwi$mr$xli$gewi2$[lmpi$xli$[ewlmrkxsr$gsyvx

ypxmqexip}$ipigxih$rsx$xs$hmwqmww$xli$gewi$ex$xli$xmqi0$mxw$svhiv$mqtsvxerxp}$higpevih$xlex$xli$Gsqter}+w$mrxivkszivrqirxep$mqqyrmx}

hijirwi${ew$pikepp}$zmefpi0$xs$fi$ypxmqexip}$hixivqmrih$ex$xvmep2$Xli$x{s$[ewlmrkxsr$gewiw$evi$gyvvirxp}$wix$jsv$xvmep$mr$Etvmp$64642$Xli

Gsqter}$mrxirhw$xs$xeoi$epp$rigiwwev}$wxitw$xs$zmksvsywp}$hijirh$mxwipj$erh$lew$gsrwmwxirxp}$vijyxih$xli$eppikexmsrw$erh$gpemqw$mr$xliwi

pe{wymxw2$Xli$Gsqter}$lew$rsx$vigsvhih$er$eggvyep$vipexmrk$xs$xliwi$qexxivw$ex$xlmw$xmqi0$ew$e$psww$mw$rsx$gsrwmhivih$tvsfefpi$rsv

viewsrefp}$iwxmqefpi$ex$xlmw$wxeki$sj$xli$pe{wymxw2$Xli$Gsqter}$iwxefpmwliw$eggvyepw$jsv$wtigmjmg$pikep$tvsgiihmrkw${lir$mx$mw

gsrwmhivih$tvsfefpi$xlex$e$psww$lew$fiir$mrgyvvih$erh$xli$eqsyrx$sj$xli$psww$ger$fi$viewsrefp}$iwxmqexih2$Ls{iziv0$xli$viwypxw$sj$xliwi

gpemqw$sv$tvsgiihmrkw$gerrsx$fi$tvihmgxih${mxl$givxemrx}0$erh$er$yrjezsvefpi$viwspyxmsr$sj$sri$sv$qsvi$sj$xliwi$gpemqw$sv$tvsgiihmrkw

gsyph$lezi$e$qexivmep$ehzivwi$ijjigx$sr$xli$Gsqter}+w$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$sv$gewl$jps{w2$Xli$Gsqter}+w$eggvyepw

jsv$psww$gsrxmrkirgmiw$evi$vizmi{ih$uyevxivp}$erh$ehnywxih$ew$ehhmxmsrep$mrjsvqexmsr$figsqiw$ezempefpi2$Xli$Gsqter}$hsiw$rsx$eggvyi

jsv$erxmgmtexih$pikep$jiiw$erh$gswxw$fyx$i|tirwiw$xlswi$mxiqw$ew$mrgyvvih2

Sr$Higiqfiv$740$645=0$KIS$jmpih$e$pe{wymx$jsv$higpevexsv}$erh$mrnyrgxmzi$vipmij$gleppirkmrk$Gepmjsvrme×w$ri{p}$iregxih$pe{$1

Ewwiqfp}$Fmpp$76$,EF176-$1${lmgl$fevw$xli$jihivep$kszivrqirx$jvsq$irkekmrk$KIS$sv$er}$sxliv$kszivrqirx$gsrxvegxsvw$xs$tvszmhi

hixirxmsr$wivzmgiw$jsv$mppikep$epmirw2$KIS×w$gpemqw0$ew$hiwgvmfih$mr$xli$pe{wymx0$evi$kvsyrhih$mr$eyxlsvmxexmzi$pikep$hsgxvmri$xlex$yrhiv

xli$Gsrwxmxyxmsr×w$Wytviqeg}$Gpeywi0$ xli$ jihivep$ kszivrqirx$ mw$ jvii$ jvsq$ vikypexmsr$f}$ er}$ wxexi2$F}$tvslmfmxmrk$ jihivep$ hixirxmsr

jegmpmxmiw$ mr$Gepmjsvrme0$ xli$ pe{wymx$ evkyiw$EF176$ wyfwxerxmepp}$ mrxivjiviw${mxl$ xli$ efmpmx}$ sj$YWQW$ erh$ MGI$ xs$ gevv}$ syx$ hixirxmsr

viwtsrwmfmpmxmiw$ jsv$ xli$ jihivep$ kszivrqirx2$ Wigsrhp}0$ figeywi$ EF176$ gviexiw$ i|gitxmsrw$ xs$ xli$ Wxexi$ {lir$ ywmrk$ KIS$ sv$ er}

kszivrqirx$gsrxvegxsvw$,xs$eppizmexi$szivgvs{hmrk-0$Gepmjsvrme×w$wxexyxi$yrpe{jypp}$hmwgvmqmrexiw$ekemrwx$ xli$jihivep$kszivrqirx2$Sr

Higiqfiv$750$645=0$KIS$jmpih$mxw$qsxmsr$jsv$e$tvipmqmrev}$mrnyrgxmsr$viwxvemrmrk$Gepmjsvrme×w$Kszivrsv$erh$Exxsvri}$Kirivep$jvsq

irjsvgmrk$EF176$ekemrwx$KIS×w$hixirxmsr$jegmpmxmiw$sr$filepj$sj$YWQW$erh$MGI2

Xli$rexyvi$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$fywmriww$i|tswiw$mx$xs$zevmsyw$x}tiw$sj$xlmvh1tevx}$pikep$gpemqw$sv$pmxmkexmsr$ekemrwx$xli$Gsqter}0

mrgpyhmrk0$fyx$rsx$pmqmxih$xs0$gmzmp$vmklxw$gpemqw$vipexmrk$xs$gsrhmxmsrw$sj$gsrjmriqirx$erh3sv$qmwxviexqirx0$wi|yep$qmwgsrhygx$gpemqw

fvsyklx$f}$tvmwsrivw$sv$hixemriiw0$qihmgep$qeptvegxmgi$gpemqw0$tvshygx$pmefmpmx}$gpemqw0$mrxippigxyep$tvstivx}$mrjvmrkiqirx$gpemqw0

gpemqw$vipexmrk$xs$iqtps}qirx$qexxivw$,mrgpyhmrk0$fyx$rsx$pmqmxih$xs0$iqtps}qirx$hmwgvmqmrexmsr$gpemqw0

579

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 207 of 253

Page 230: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 64;367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

yrmsr$kvmizergiw$erh${eki$erh$lsyv$gpemqw-0$tvstivx}$psww$gpemqw0$irzmvsrqirxep$gpemqw0$eyxsqsfmpi$pmefmpmx}$gpemqw0$mrhiqrmjmgexmsr

gpemqw$f}$mxw$gywxsqivw$erh$sxliv$xlmvh$tevxmiw0$gsrxvegxyep$gpemqw$erh$gpemqw$jsv$tivwsrep$mrnyv}$sv$sxliv$heqekiw$viwypxmrk$jvsq

gsrxegx${mxl$xli$Gsqter}+w$jegmpmxmiw0$tvskveqw0$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$tvshygxw0$tivwsrrip$sv$tvmwsrivw0$mrgpyhmrk$heqekiw$evmwmrk

jvsq$e$tvmwsriv+w$iwgeti$sv$jvsq$e$hmwxyvfergi$sv$vmsx$ex$e$jegmpmx}2$Xli$Gsqter}$eggvyiw$jsv$pikep$gswxw$ewwsgmexih${mxl$psww

gsrxmrkirgmiw${lir$xlswi$gswxw$evi$tvsfefpi$erh$viewsrefp}$iwxmqefpi2$Xli$Gsqter}$hsiw$rsx$i|tigx$xli$syxgsqi$sj$er}$tirhmrk

gpemqw$sv$pikep$tvsgiihmrkw$xs$lezi$e$qexivmep$ehzivwi$ijjigx$sr$mxw$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$sv$gewl$jps{w2

$$$$

Sxliv$Ewwiwwqirx

E$wxexi$rsr1mrgsqi$xe|$eyhmx$gsqtpixih$mr$645:$mrgpyhih$xe|$tivmshw$jsv${lmgl$xli$wxexi$xe|$eyxlsvmx}$leh$e$ryqfiv$sj$}ievw

eks$tvsgiwwih$e$wyfwxerxmep$xe|$vijyrh2$Ex$xli$gsqtpixmsr$sj$xli$eyhmx$jmiph{svo0$xli$Gsqter}$vigimzih$e$rsxmgi$sj$eyhmx$jmrhmrkw

hmwepps{mrk$hihygxmsrw$xlex${ivi$tvizmsywp}$gpemqih$f}$xli$Gsqter}0$ettvszih$f}$xli$wxexi$xe|$eyxlsvmx}$erh$wivzih$ew$xli$fewmw

jsv$xli$ettvszih$vijyrh$gpemq2$Mr$ievp}$Neryev}$645;0$xli$Gsqter}$vigimzih$e$jsvqep$Rsxmgi$sj$Ewwiwwqirx$sj$Xe|iw$erh$Hiqerh$jsv

Te}qirx$jvsq$xli$xe|mrk$eyxlsvmx}$hmwepps{mrk$xli$hihygxmsrw2$Xli$xsxep$xe|0$tirepx}$erh$mrxiviwx$ewwiwwih$mw$ettvs|mqexip}$(5<2=

qmppmsr2$Xli$Gsqter}$lew$jmpih$er$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$tvsxiwx$erh$hmwekviiw${mxl$xli$ewwiwwqirx$erh$mrxirhw$xs$xeoi$epp$rigiwwev}$wxitw$xs

zmksvsywp}$hijirh$mxw$tswmxmsr2$$Xli$Gsqter}$lew$iwxefpmwlih$e$viwivzi$fewih$sr$mxw$iwxmqexi$sj$xli$qswx$tvsfefpi$psww$fewih$sr$xli

jegxw$erh$gmvgyqwxergiw$ors{r$xs$hexi$erh$xli$ehzmgi$sj$syxwmhi$gsyrwip$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xlmw$qexxiv2

5=2 Wipigxih$Uyevxivp}$Jmrergmep$Hexe$,Yreyhmxih-

Xli$Gsqter}×w$wipigxih$uyevxivp}$jmrergmep$hexe$mw$ew$jspps{w$,mr$xlsywerhw0$i|gitx$tiv$wlevi$hexe$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS->$

$

Jmvwx

Uyevxiv $

Wigsrh

Uyevxiv $

Xlmvh

Uyevxiv $

Jsyvxl

Uyevxiv

645= $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Viziryiw ( :540::; $ ( :570=:: $ ( :7509;= $ ( :650;54

Stivexmrk$mrgsqi ;80;;; $ <505;9 $ ;<059= $ ::0746

Rix$Mrgsqi 840:8= $ 850<7: $ 890<<9 $ 7<0486

Rix$Mrgsqi$Exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2 840;49 $ 850=58 $ 890=76 $ 7<0496

Fewmg$ievrmrkw$tiv$wlevi> $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Rix$mrgsqi$tiv$wlevi ( 4278 $ ( 4279 $ ( 427= $ ( 4276

Hmpyxih$ievrmrkw$tiv$wlevi> $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Rix$mrgsqi$tiv$wlevi$. ( 4278 $ ( 4279 $ ( 427= $ ( 4276

$

$Jmvwx

Uyevxiv $WigsrhUyevxiv $

XlmvhUyevxiv $

JsyvxlUyevxiv

645< $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Viziryiw ( 9:80=5; $ ( 9<7094= $ ( 9<70974 $ ( 9==0874

Stivexmrk$mrgsqi :80894 $ ::0=95 $ :=0;<4 $ :708<8

Rix$Mrgsqi 780=64 $ 7;0769 $ 7=066= $ 770797

Rix$Mrgsqi$Exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2 780=<; $ 7;0865 $ 7=06<= $ 7707=6

Fewmg$ievrmrkw$tiv$wlevi> $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Rix$mrgsqi$tiv$wlevi ( 426= $ ( 4275 $ ( 4277 $ ( 426<

Hmpyxih$ievrmrkw$tiv$wlevi> $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Rix$mrgsqi$tiv$wlevi$. ( 426= $ ( 4275 $ ( 4277 $ ( 426<

$

.$Ievrmrkw$tiv$wlevi$xefpi$gsrxemrw$wpmklx$wyqqexmsr$hmjjivirgiw$hyi$xs$vsyrhmrk2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 208 of 253

Page 231: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 64<367<

642 Gsrhirwih$Gsrwspmhexmrk$Jmrergmep$Mrjsvqexmsr

Xli$jspps{mrk$gsrhirwih$gsrwspmhexmrk$jmrergmep$mrjsvqexmsr0${lmgl$lew$fiir$tvitevih$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$xli$viuymviqirxw$jsv

tviwirxexmsr$sj$Vypi$7154,h-$sj$Vikypexmsr$W1\$tvsqypkexih$yrhiv$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$Egx0$tviwirxw$xli$gsrhirwih$gsrwspmhexmrk$jmrergmep

mrjsvqexmsr$witevexip}$jsv>

57:

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 209 of 253

Page 232: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 64=367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

,m-$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$ Mrg20$ew$ xli$ mwwyiv$sj$ xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$ hyi0$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$ hyi$64660$ 92<;9)$Wirmsv

Rsxiw$hyi$6468$erh$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$,gsppigxmzip}0$xli$&Rsxiw&-?

,mm-$Xli$Wyfwmhmev}$Kyeverxsvw0$sr$ e$gsqfmrih$fewmw0${lmgl$evi$544)$s{rih$ f}$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$ Mrg20$ erh${lmgl$ evi

kyeverxsvw$sj$xli$Rsxiw?

,mmm-$Xli$Gsqter}×w$sxliv$wyfwmhmevmiw0$sr$e$gsqfmrih$fewmw0${lmgl$evi$rsx$kyeverxsvw$sj$xli$Rsxiw$,xli$ÔWyfwmhmev}$Rsr1

KyeverxsvwÕ-?

,mz-$Gsrwspmhexmrk$irxvmiw$erh$ipmqmrexmsrw$vitviwirxmrk$ehnywxqirxw$xs>$,e-$ipmqmrexi$mrxivgsqter}$xverwegxmsrw$fix{iir$sv

eqsrk$ xli$ Gsqter}0$ xli$ Wyfwmhmev}$ Kyeverxsvw$ erh$ xli$ Wyfwmhmev}$ Rsr1Kyeverxsvw$ erh$ ,f-$ ipmqmrexi$ xli$ mrziwxqirxw$ mr$ xli

Gsqter}×w$wyfwmhmevmiw?$erh

,z-$Xli$Gsqter}$erh$mxw$wyfwmhmevmiw$sr$e$gsrwspmhexih$fewmw2

Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$57$1$Hifx$jsv$e$hiwgvmtxmsr$sj$xli$rsxiw$xlex$evi$jypp}$erh$yrgsrhmxmsrepp}$kyeverxiih$sr$e$nsmrx$erh$wizivep$wirmsv

yrwigyvih$fewmw$f}$xli$Gsqter}$erh$givxemr$sj$mxw${lspp}1s{rih$hsqiwxmg$wyfwmhmevmiw2

57;

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 210 of 253

Page 233: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 654367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

GSRHIRWIH$GSRWSPMHEXMRK$WXEXIQIRX$SJ$GSQTVILIRWMZI$MRGSQI

,mr$xlsywerhw-

$

$ Jsv$xli$]iev$Irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=

$Xli$KISKvsyt0$Mrg2 $

GsqfmrihWyfwmhmev}Kyeverxsvw $

GsqfmrihRsr1KyeverxsvWyfwmhmevmiw $ Ipmqmrexmsrw $ Gsrwspmhexih

Viziryiw ( =85055; $ ( 6045409:5 $ ( 6;60:57 $ ( ,;8:07:=- $ ( 608;;0=66

Stivexmrk$i|tirwiw ;990887 $ 50:6<08;4 $ 6670658 $ ,;8:07:=- $ 50<:40;9<

Hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr 6=0:<< $ =;069= $ 70<;< $ Ó $ 5740<69

Kirivep$erh$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw :=0=:= $ =90:<= $ 6406:< $ Ó $ 5<90=6:

Stivexmrk$mrgsqi <:045; $ 5<=0587 $ 690697 $ Ó $ 7440857

Mrxiviwx$mrgsqi 570=9: $ ;06=7 $ 6;06;4 $ ,5=09<9- $ 6<0=78

Mrxiviwx$i|tirwi ,=4056;- $ ,9;0449- $ ,6708;;- $ 5=09<9 $ ,5950468-

Psww$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx ,8<:- $ 599 $ ,808:8- $ Ó $ ,80;=9-

Mrgsqi$fijsvi$mrgsqi$xe|iw$erh$iuymx}$mr

ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw =07:4 $ 57=09<: $ 6809<6 $ Ó $ 5;7096<

Tvszmwmsr$jsv$mrgsqi$xe|iw 508;6 $ =09=9 $ 909<5 $ Ó $ 5:0:8<

Iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw0$rix$sj

mrgsqi$xe|$tvszmwmsr Ó $ Ó $ =0976 $ Ó $ =0976

Mrgsqi$jvsq$stivexmsrw$fijsvi$iuymx}$mr

mrgsqi$sj$gsrwspmhexih$wyfwmhmevmiw ;0<<< $ 56=0==5 $ 6<0977 $ Ó $ 5::0856

Mrgsqi$jvsq$gsrwspmhexih$wyfwmhmevmiw0$rix

sj$mrgsqi$xe|$tvszmwmsr 59<0968 $ Ó $ Ó $ ,59<0968- $ Ó

Rix$mrgsqi 5::0856 $ 56=0==5 $ 6<0977 $ ,59<0968- $ 5::0856

Psww$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$rsrgsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw Ó $ Ó $ 5=5 $ Ó $ 5=5

Rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0

Mrg2 ( 5::0856 $ ( 56=0==5 $ ( 6<0;68 $ ( ,59<0968- $ ( 5::0:47

Rix$mrgsqi ( 5::0856 $ ( 56=0==5 $ ( 6<0977 $ ( ,59<0968- $ ( 5::0856

Sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$,psww-0$rix$sj

xe| ,508;:- $ ,7068;- $ <0458 $ Ó $ 706=5

Xsxep$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi ( 5:80=7: $ ( 56:0;88 $ ( 7:098; $ ( ,59<0968- $ ( 5:=0;47

Gsqtvilirwmzi$psww$exxvmfyxefpi$xs

rsrgsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw Ó $ Ó $ 5<7 $ Ó $ 5<7

Gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli

KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2 ( 5:80=7: $ ( 56:0;88 $ ( 7:0;74 $ ( ,59<0968- $ ( 5:=0<<:

57<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 211 of 253

Page 234: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 655367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

GSRHIRWIH$GSRWSPMHEXMRK$WXEXIQIRXW$SJ$GSQTVILIRWMZI$MRGSQI

,mr$xlsywerhw-

$

$ Jsv$xli$]iev$Irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645<

$Xli$KISKvsyt0$Mrg2 $

GsqfmrihWyfwmhmev}Kyeverxsvw $

GsqfmrihRsr1KyeverxsvWyfwmhmevmiw $ Ipmqmrexmsrw $ Gsrwspmhexih

Viziryiw ( <6;08;7 $ ( 50=490687 $ ( 6:<0;67 $ ( ,:;40497- $ ( 6077507<:

Stivexmrk$i|tirwiw ::80798 $ 5097=0787 $ 666056< $ ,:;40497- $ 50;990;;6

Hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr 6;047: $ =90948 $ 70<=8 $ Ó $ 56:0878

Kirivep$erh$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw :80<96 $ =<0:45 $ 6504:6 $ Ó $ 5<80959

Stivexmrk$mrgsqi ;50675 $ 5;50;=9 $ 650:7= $ Ó $ 6:80::9

Mrxiviwx$mrgsqi 580;46 $ 908=8 $ 790945 $ ,640=86- $ 780;99

Mrxiviwx$i|tirwi ,<5089:- $ ,9:05=8- $ ,7707=9- $ 640=86 $ ,5940547-

Mrgsqi$fijsvi$mrgsqi$xe|iw$erh$iuymx}$mr

ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw 808;; $ 56504=9 $ 670;89 $ Ó $ 58=075;

Tvszmwmsr$jsv$mrgsqi$xe|iw =;6 $ ;0868 $ 90;65 $ Ó $ 58055;

Iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw0$rix$sj

mrgsqi$xe|$firijmx Ó $ Ó $ =0:6; $ Ó $ =0:6;

Mrgsqi$jvsq$stivexmsrw$fijsvi$iuymx}$mr

mrgsqi$sj$gsrwspmhexih$wyfwmhmevmiw 70949 $ 5570:;5 $ 6;0:95 $ Ó $ 5880<6;

Mrgsqi$jvsq$gsrwspmhexih$wyfwmhmevmiw0$rix

sj$mrgsqi$xe|$tvszmwmsr 5850766 $ Ó $ Ó $ ,5850766- $ Ó

Rix$mrgsqi 5880<6; $ 5570:;5 $ 6;0:95 $ ,5850766- $ 5880<6;

Psww$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$rsrgsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw ( Ó $ ( Ó $ ( 6:6 $ ( Ó $ ( 6:6

Rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0

Mrg2 ( 5880<6; $ ( 5570:;5 $ ( 6;0=57 $ ( ,5850766- $ ( 58904<=

Rix$mrgsqi ( 5880<6; $ ( 5570:;5 $ ( 6;0:95 $ ( ,5850766- $ ( 5880<6;

Sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$,psww-0$rix$sj

xe| Ó $ 50;<9 $ ,=;6- $ Ó $ <57

Xsxep$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi ( 5880<6; $ ( 559089: $ ( 6:0:;= $ ( ,5850766- $ ( 5890:84

Gsqtvilirwmzi$psww$exxvmfyxefpi$xs

rsrgsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw Ó $ Ó $ 6;; $ Ó $ 6;;

Gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli

KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2 ( 5880<6; $ ( 559089: $ ( 6:0=9: $ ( ,5850766- $ ( 5890=5;

57=

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 212 of 253

Page 235: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 656367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

GSRHIRWIH$GSRWSPMHEXMRK$WXEXIQIRXW$SJ$GSQTVILIRWMZI$MRGSQI

,mr$xlsywerhw-

$

$ Jsv$xli$]iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645;

$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2 $

GsqfmrihWyfwmhmev}Kyeverxsvw $

GsqfmrihRsr1KyeverxsvWyfwmhmevmiw $ Ipmqmrexmsrw $ Gsrwspmhexih

Viziryiw ( ;550457 $ ( 50<5406:6 $ ( 7650:56 $ ( ,9;=08:;- $ ( 606:70864

Stivexmrk$i|tirwiw 9:<04:5 $ 508850<<8 $ 6;4045; $ ,9;=08:;- $ 50;4408=9

Hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr 6809<4 $ =:0495 $ 70::: $ Ó $ 56806=;

Kirivep$erh$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw 9=05=8 $ 54807;7 $ 6:0;;: $ Ó $ 5=40787

Stivexmrk$mrgsqi 9=05;< $ 5:;0=98 $ 650597 $ Ó $ 68<06<9

Mrxiviwx$mrgsqi 5:0644 $ 806=8 $ 9604:= $ ,640<<;- $ 950:;:

Mrxiviwx$i|tirwi ,:=0=:=- $ ,9904<4- $ ,870<:6- $ 640<<; $ ,58<0468-

Mrgsqi$fijsvi$mrgsqi$xe|iw$erh$iuymx}$mr

ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw 9084= $ 55;05:< $ 6=07:4 $ Ó $ 5950=7;

Tvszmwmsr$jsv$mrgsqi$xe|iw 50547 $ =0:4< $ ;068; $ Ó $ 5;0=9<

Iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw0$rix$sj$mrgsqi

xe|$tvszmwmsr Ó $ Ó $ 560489 $ Ó $ 560489

Mrgsqi$jvsq$stivexmsrw$fijsvi$iuymx}$mr

mrgsqi$sj$gsrwspmhexih$wyfwmhmevmiw 8074: $ 54;09:4 $ 78059< $ Ó $ 58:0468

Mrgsqi$jvsq$gsrwspmhexih$wyfwmhmevmiw0$rix$sj

mrgsqi$xe|$tvszmwmsr 5850;5< $ Ó $ Ó $ ,5850;5<- $ Ó

Rix$mrgsqi 58:0468 $ 54;09:4 $ 78059< $ ,5850;5<- $ 58:0468

Psww$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$rsrgsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw ( Ó $ ( Ó $ ( 65; $ ( Ó $ ( 65;

Rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0

Mrg2 ( 58:0468 $ ( 54;09:4 $ ( 7807;9 $ ( ,5850;5<- $ ( 58:0685

Rix$mrgsqi ( 58:0468 $ ( 54;09:4 $ ( 78059< $ ( ,5850;5<- $ ( 58:0468

Sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$,psww-0$rix$sj$xe| Ó $ ,50864- $ ;0;=7 $ Ó $ :07;7

Xsxep$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi ( 58:0468 $ ( 54:0584 $ ( 850=95 $ ( ,5850;5<- $ ( 59607=;

Gsqtvilirwmzi$psww$exxvmfyxefpi$xs

rsrgsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw Ó $ Ó $ 655 $ Ó $ 655

Gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli

KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2 ( 58:0468 $ ( 54:0584 $ ( 8605:6 $ ( ,5850;5<- $ ( 5960:4<

584

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 213 of 253

Page 236: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 657367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

GSRHIRWIH$GSRWSPMHEXMRK$FEPERGI$WLIIX

,mr$xlsywerhw-

$

585

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 214 of 253

Page 237: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 658367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$ Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=

$Xli$KISKvsyt0$Mrg2 $

GsqfmrihWyfwmhmev}Kyeverxsvw $

GsqfmrihRsr1KyeverxsvWyfwmhmevmiw $ Ipmqmrexmsrw $ Gsrwspmhexih

EWWIXW

Gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw ( =0<84 $ ( Ó $ ( 660:67 $ ( Ó $ ( 7608:7

Viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$mrziwxqirxw Ó $ Ó $ 76085< $ Ó $ 76085<

Eggsyrxw$vigimzefpi0$piww$epps{ergi$jsv

hsyfxjyp$eggsyrxw 5:;0;:= $ 65<0=64 $ 8505;9 $ 7055< $ 8740=<6

Gsrxvegx$vigimzefpi0$gyvvirx$tsvxmsr $ Ó $ 5505== $ Ó $ 5505==

Tvitemh$i|tirwiw$erh$sxliv$gyvvirx$ewwixw 506;7 $ 7605<; $ =0759 $ ,6049=- $ 840;5:

$$$$$$$Xsxep$gyvvirx$ewwixw 5;<0<<6 $ 695054; $ 55:0;74 $ 5049= $ 98;0;;<

Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Mrziwxqirxw Ó $ 6<0:8< $ 606;9 $ Ó $ 740=67

Tvstivx}$erh$Iuymtqirx0$Rix <8:06=; $ 506580:=; $ <70;6< $ Ó $ 605880;66

Vmklx1sj1Ywi$Ewwixw$Stivexmrk$Piewiw 650==9 $ =<0:98 $ <;< $ Ó $ 565096;

Gsrxvegx$Vigimzefpi Ó $ Ó $ 7:40:8; $ Ó $ 7:40:8;

Ewwixw$Liph$jsv$Wepi ;49 $ 90798 $ Ó $ Ó $ :049=

Mrxivgsqter}$Vigimzefpi =;<077; $ 67<0:<4 $ 5;0494 $ ,5067804:;- $ Ó

Hijivvih$Mrgsqi$Xe|$Ewwixw Ó $ 7909<8 $ :=8 $ Ó $ 7:06;<

Kssh{mpp Ó $ ;;90=97 $ 847 $ Ó $ ;;:079:

Mrxerkmfpi$Ewwixw0$Rix Ó $ 64=0998 $ 95: $ Ó $ 65404;4

Mrziwxqirx$mr$Wyfwmhmevmiw 508<80=74 $ 9;70<5: $ 605<= $ ,604:40=79- $ Ó

Sxliv$Rsr1Gyvvirx$Ewwixw 5<076= $ 5670;=; $ 5<0<97 $ ,;;0<49- $ <705;8

Xsxep$Ewwixw ( 7096=08;9 $ ( 709990<88 $ ( :470=:7 $ ( ,707;50;8<- $ ( 8075;0978

PMEFMPMXMIW$ERH$WLEVILSPHIVW×$IUYMX]

Eggsyrxw$te}efpi ( 5:0:=4 $ ( ;:0:75 $ ( 90=55 $ ( Ó $ ( ==0676

Eggvyih$te}vspp$erh$vipexih$xe|iw Ó $ 7<0687 $ 5:086= $ Ó $ 980:;6

Eggvyih$i|tirwiw$erh$sxliv$gyvvirx

pmefmpmxmiw 7605;9 $ 5750475 $ 6<0;:9 $ ,7:7- $ 5=50:4<

Stivexmrk$piewi$pmefmpmxmiw0$gyvvirx$tsvxmsr 90676 $ 640;;; $ 5== $ Ó $ 6:064<

Gyvvirx$tsvxmsr$sj$jmrergi$piewi$sfpmkexmsrw0

psrk1xivq$hifx$erh$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx <0444 $ 60:6: $ 5709<6 $ Ó $ 68064<

Xsxep$gyvvirx$pmefmpmxmiw :604=; $ 6:=074< $ :80<<: $ ,7:7- $ 7=90=6<

Hijivvih$Mrgsqi$Xe|$Pmefmpmxmiw Ó $ Ó $ 5=0698 $ Ó $ 5=0698

Mrxivgsqter}$Te}efpi 54:046= $ 5054406== $ 6:075: $ ,506760:88- $ Ó

Sxliv$Rsr1Gyvvirx$Pmefmpmxmiw 709;6 $ 5:6046: $ ;77 $ ,;;0<49- $ <<096:

Stivexmrk$Piewi$Pmefmpmxmiw 5;0765 $ ;=06=4 $ :<4 $ Ó $ =;06=5

Jmrergi$Piewi$Sfpmkexmsrw Ó $ 60=98 $ Ó $ Ó $ 60=98

Psrk1Xivq$Hifx 607870:6: $ Ó $ :80:;5 $ Ó $ 6084<06=;

Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Hifx Ó $ Ó $ 74=067: $ Ó $ 74=067:

Gsqqmxqirxw$*$Gsrxmrkirgmiw $ $ $ $

Wlevilsphivw+$Iuymx}> $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Xsxep$wlevilsphivw×$iuymx}$exxvmfyxefpi$xs

Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2 ==:0<74 $ 50=850=:; $ 55<0=:= $ ,604:40=7:- $ ==:0<74

Rsrgsrxvsppmrk$Mrxiviwxw Ó $ Ó $ ,;<6- $ Ó $ ,;<6-

Xsxep$Wlevilsphivw×$Iuymx} ==:0<74 $ 50=850=:; $ 55<05<; $ ,604:40=7:- $ ==:048<

Xsxep$Pmefmpmxmiw$erh$Wlevilsphivw+$Iuymx} ( 7096=08;9 $ ( 709990<88 $ ( :470=:7 $ ( ,707;50;8<- $ ( 8075;0978

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 215 of 253

Page 238: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 659367<

586

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 216 of 253

Page 239: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 65:367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

GSRHIRWIH$GSRWSPMHEXMRK$FEPERGI$WLIIX

,mr$xlsywerhw-

$

$ Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645<

$Xli$KISKvsyt0$Mrg2 $

GsqfmrihWyfwmhmev}Kyeverxsvw $

GsqfmrihRsr1KyeverxsvWyfwmhmevmiw $ Ipmqmrexmsrw $ Gsrwspmhexih

EWWIXW

Gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw ( 808:< $ ( ;0<;7 $ ( 5<0=58 $ ( Ó $ ( 750699

Viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$mrziwxqirxw 60<98 $ Ó $ 8<0<68 $ Ó $ 950:;<

Eggsyrxw$vigimzefpi0$piww$epps{ergi$jsv

hsyfxjyp$eggsyrxw 5=409=8 $ 6650=9; $ 8807;; $ ,550846- $ 889096:

Gsrxvegx$vigimzefpi0$gyvvirx$tsvxmsr Ó $ Ó $ 590979 $ Ó $ 590979

Tvitemh$i|tirwiw$erh$sxliv$gyvvirx$ewwixw 60455 $ 9408<6 $ ;0558 $ ,50<7=- $ 9;0;:<

Xsxep$gyvvirx$ewwixw 5==0=6; $ 6<40756 $ 5780;:8 $ ,570685- $ :450;:6

Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Mrziwxqirxw Ó $ 65044= $ 50866 $ Ó $ 660875

Tvstivx}$erh$Iuymtqirx0$Rix <8906=5 $ 5066;0667 $ <:04=: $ Ó $ 6059<0:54

Gsrxvegx$Vigimzefpi Ó $ Ó $ 7:<05;< $ Ó $ 7:<05;<

Ewwixw$Liph$jsv$Wepi ;49 $ 50=6= $ Ó $ Ó $ 60:78

Mrxivgsqter}$Vigimzefpi ==407:9 $ 5940;54 $ 66084; $ ,505:708<6- $ Ó

Hijivvih$Mrgsqi$Xe|$Ewwixw ;=< $ 6;0=6< $ 505=< $ Ó $ 6=0=68

Kssh{mpp Ó $ ;;90=99 $ 848 $ Ó $ ;;:079=

Mrxerkmfpi$Ewwixw0$Rix Ó $ 6750;<; $ 9;7 $ Ó $ 67607:4

Mrziwxqirx$mr$Wyfwmhmevmiw 509470<85 $ 89<066= $ 605=4 $ ,50=:806:4- $ Ó

Sxliv$Rsr1Gyvvirx$Ewwixw =0985 $ 5590:=9 $ 5=0778 $ ,;<0;54- $ :90<:4

Xsxep$Ewwixw ( 7099408:< $ ( 706=40;;; $ ( :7:09:: $ ( ,7065=0:=7- $ ( 8069<055<

PMEFMPMXMIW$ERH$WLEVILSPHIVW×$IUYMX]

Eggsyrxw$te}efpi ( 5709:: $ ( ;6056< $ ( ;077< $ ( Ó $ ( =70476

Eggvyih$te}vspp$erh$vipexih$xe|iw Ó $ 9:0987 $ 5=08:: $ Ó $ ;:044=

Eggvyih$i|tirwiw$erh$sxliv$gyvvirx

pmefmpmxmiw 6709:9 $ 5:<0675 $ 690:59 $ ,570685- $ 64805;4

Gyvvirx$tsvxmsr$sj$jmrergi$piewi$sfpmkexmsrw0

psrk1xivq$hifx$erh$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx <0444 $ 6045; $ 7660454 $ Ó $ 776046;

Xsxep$gyvvirx$pmefmpmxmiw 890575 $ 6=<0=5= $ 7;8086= $ ,570685- $ ;49067<

Hijivvih$Mrgsqi$Xe|$Pmefmpmxmiw Ó $ Ó $ 570:<5 $ Ó $ 570:<5

Mrxivgsqter}$Te}efpi 5860499 $ =<=0<9: $ 7509;5 $ ,505:708<6- $ Ó

Sxliv$Rsr1Gyvvirx$Pmefmpmxmiw 507=9 $ 5960<59 $ :0=<5 $ ,;<0;54- $ <608<5

Jmrergi$Piewi$Sfpmkexmsrw Ó $ 809;4 $ Ó $ Ó $ 809;4

Psrk1Xivq$Hifx 6076507<8 $ Ó $ ;90<87 $ Ó $ 607=;066;

Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Hifx Ó $ Ó $ 59045; $ Ó $ 59045;

Gsqqmxqirxw$*$Gsrxmrkirgmiw $ $ $ $

Wlevilsphivw+$Iuymx}> $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Xsxep$wlevilsphivw×$iuymx}$exxvmfyxefpi$xs

Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2 504840947 $ 50<880:5; $ 55=0:87 $ ,50=:806:4- $ 504840947

Rsrgsrxvsppmrk$Mrxiviwxw Ó $ Ó $ ,9==- $ Ó $ ,9==-

Xsxep$Wlevilsphivw×$Iuymx} 504840947 $ 50<880:5; $ 55=0488 $ ,50=:806:4- $ 5047=0=48

Xsxep$Pmefmpmxmiw$erh$Wlevilsphivw+$Iuymx} ( 7099408:< $ ( 706=40;;; $ ( :7:09:: $ ( ,7065=0:=7- $ ( 8069<055<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 217 of 253

Page 240: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 65;367<

587

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 218 of 253

Page 241: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 65<367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

GSRHIRWIH$GSRWSPMHEXMRK$WXEXIQIRXW$SJ$GEWL$JPS[W

,mr$xlsywerhw-

$

$ Jsv$xli$]iev$Irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=

$Xli$KISKvsyt0$Mrg2 $

GsqfmrihWyfwmhmev}Kyeverxsvw $

GsqfmrihRsr1KyeverxsvWyfwmhmevmiw $ Gsrwspmhexih

Gewl$Jps{$jvsq$Stivexmrk$Egxmzmxmiw> $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Rix$gewl$tvszmhih$f}$stivexmrk$egxmzmxmiw ( 6;9056: $ ( 9<0974 $ ( 808<; $ ( 77<0587

Gewl$Jps{$jvsq$Mrziwxmrk$Egxmzmxmiw> $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$wepi$sj$tvstivx}$erh$iuymtqirx Ó $ 858 $ Ó $ 858

Mrwyvergi$tvsgiihw$1$heqekih$tvstivx} Ó $ 5=0754 $ Ó $ 5=0754

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$wepi$sj$ewwixw$liph$jsv$wepi Ó $ <67 $ Ó $ <67

Glerki$mr$viwxvmgxih$mrziwxqirxw Ó $ ,;0884- $ Ó $ ,;0884-

Getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw ,790=:<- $ ,;=0:6;- $ ,50:8=- $ ,55;0688-

Rix$gewl$ywih$mr$mrziwxmrk$egxmzmxmiw ,790=:<- $ ,::0964- $ ,50:8=- $ ,548057;-

Gewl$Jps{$jvsq$Jmrergmrk$Egxmzmxmiw> $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Te}qirxw$sr$psrk1xivq$hifx ,957065=- $ Ó $ Ó $ ,957065=-

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$psrk1xivq$hifx 96507;4 $ Ó $ Ó $ 96507;4

Te}qirxw$sr$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx Ó $ Ó $ ,779055:- $ ,779055:-

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx Ó $ Ó $ 7650546 $ 7650546

Xe|iw$temh$vipexih$xs$rix$wlevi$wixxpiqirxw$sj$iuymx}

e{evhw ,805;=- $ Ó $ Ó $ ,805;=-

Hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw ,=0<9:- $ Ó $ Ó $ ,=0<9:-

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$wxsgo$stxmsrw$i|ivgmwih 5069< $ Ó $ Ó $ 5069<

Hmzmhirhw$temh ,676098:- $ Ó $ Ó $ ,676098:-

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$mwwyergi$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$mr$gsrrigxmsr

{mxl$IWTT 976 $ Ó $ Ó $ 976

Rix$gewl$ywih$mr$jmrergmrk$egxmzmxmiw ,67:0:84- $ Ó $ ,580458- $ ,6940:98-

Ijjigx$sj$I|glerki$Vexi$Glerkiw$sr$Gewl0$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw

erh$Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw Ó $ Ó $ ,796- $ ,796-

Rix$,Higviewi-$Mrgviewi$mr$Gewl2$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw$erh

Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw 6095< $ ,;0==4- $ ,55096<- $ ,5;0444-

Gewl0$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw$erh$Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Gewl

Iuymzepirxw0$fikmrrmrk$sj$tivmsh ;0766 $ ;0==4 $ :=05:4 $ <808;6

Gewl0$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw$erh$Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Gewl

Iuymzepirxw0$irh$sj$tivmsh ( =0<84 $ ( Ó $ ( 9;0:76 $ ( :;08;6

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 219 of 253

Page 242: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 65=367<

588

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 220 of 253

Page 243: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 664367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

GSRHIRWIH$GSRWSPMHEXMRK$WXEXIQIRXW$SJ$GEWL$JPS[W

,mr$xlsywerhw-

$ Jsv$xli$]iev$Irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645<

$Xli$KISKvsyt$Mrg2 $

GsqfmrihWyfwmhmev}Kyeverxsvw $

GsqfmrihRsr1KyeverxsvWyfwmhmevmiw $ Gsrwspmhexih

Gewl$Jps{$jvsq$Stivexmrk$Egxmzmxmiw> $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Rix$gewl$tvszmhih$f}$stivexmrk$egxmzmxmiw ( 59:0;98 $ ( <:0=;8 $ ( 740;8; $ ( 6;808;9

Gewl$Jps{$jvsq$Mrziwxmrk$Egxmzmxmiw> $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$wepi$sj$tvstivx}$erh$iuymtqirx Ó $ 6:< $ 50<4= $ 604;;

Mrwyvergi$tvsgiihw$1$heqekih$tvstivx} Ó $ 5087< $ Ó $ 5087<

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$ewwixw$liph$jsv$wepi Ó $ 70;=; $ $ 70;=;

Glerki$mr$viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$mrziwxqirxw Ó $ ,56=- $ Ó $ ,56=-

Getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw ,5480478- $ ,<=0754- $ ,60766- $ ,5=90:::-

Rix$gewl$ywih$mr$mrziwxmrk$egxmzmxmiw ,5480478- $ ,<70=7:- $ ,957- $ ,5<<08<7-

Gewl$Jps{$jvsq$Jmrergmrk$Egxmzmxmiw> $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Te}qirxw$sr$psrk1xivq$hifx ,6;:0444- $ Ó $ ,:079<- $ ,6<6079<-

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$psrk1xivq$hifx 9460==< $ Ó $ Ó $ 9460==<

Te}qirxw$sr$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx Ó $ Ó $ ,5<0988- $ ,5<0988-

Xe|iw$temh$vipexih$xs$rix$wlevi$wixxpiqirxw$sj$iuymx}

e{evhw ,70<64- $ Ó $ Ó $ ,70<64-

Te}qirxw$jsv$vityvglewiw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo ,=905;9- $ Ó $ Ó $ ,=905;9-

Hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw ,==4- $ Ó $ Ó $ ,==4-

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$wxsgo$stxmsrw$i|ivgmwih 50<<; $ Ó $ Ó $ 50<<;

Hmzmhirhw$temh ,66=08=<- $ Ó $ Ó $ ,66=08=<-

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$mwwyergi$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$mr$gsrrigxmsr

{mxl$IWTT 978 $ $ $ Ó $ 978

Rix$gewl$ywih$mr$jmrergmrk$egxmzmxmiw ,54404:8- $ Ó $ ,680=46- $ ,5680=::-

Ijjigx$sj$I|glerki$Vexi$Glerkiw$sr$Gewl0$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw

erh$Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw Ó $ Ó $ ,5404==- $ ,5404==-

Rix$,Higviewi-$Mrgviewi$mr$Gewl0$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw$erh

Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw ,8;0788- $ 7047< $ ,80;:;- $ ,8=04;7-

Gewl0$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw$erh$Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Gewl

Iuymzepirxw0$fikmrrmrk$sj$tivmsh 980::: $ 80=96 $ ;70=6; $ 5770989

Gewl0$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw$erh$Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Gewl

Iuymzepirxw0$irh$sj$tivmsh ( ;0766 $ ( ;0==4 $ ( :=05:4 $ ( <808;6

589

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 221 of 253

Page 244: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 665367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

GSRHIRWIH$GSRWSPMHEXMRK$WXEXIQIRXW$SJ$GEWL$JPS[W

,mr$xlsywerhw-

$

$ Jsv$xli$]iev$Irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645;

$Xli$KISKvsyt$Mrg2 $

GsqfmrihWyfwmhmev}Kyeverxsvw $

GsqfmrihRsr1KyeverxsvWyfwmhmevmiw $ Gsrwspmhexih

Gewl$Jps{$jvsq$Stivexmrk$Egxmzmxmiw> $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Rix$gewl$tvszmhih$f}$,ywih$mr-$stivexmrk$egxmzmxmiw 55<045< $ =505;8 $ 5;50<94 $ 7<50486

Gewl$Jps{$jvsq$Mrziwxmrk$Egxmzmxmiw> $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Eguymwmxmsr$sj$GIG0$rix$sj$gewl$eguymvih ,797099:- $ Ó $ Ó $ ,797099:-

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$wepi$sj$tvstivx}$erh$iuymtqirx 7087: $ Ó $ 68 $ 708:4

Mrwyvergi$tvsgiihw$1$heqekih$tvstivx} 60;98 $ Ó $ Ó $ 60;98

Glerki$mr$viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$mrziwxqirxw Ó $ ,8094;- $ Ó $ ,8094;-

Getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw ,970474- $ ,<:077:- $ ,=0484- $ ,58<084:-

Rix$gewl$ywih$mr$mrziwxmrk$egxmzmxmiw ,84407=:- $ ,=40<87- $ ,=045:- $ ,9440699-

Gewl$Jps{$jvsq$Jmrergmrk$Egxmzmxmiw> $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$psrk1xivq$hifx 507<=04<8 $ Ó $ Ó $ 507<=04<8

Te}qirxw$sr$psrk1xivq$hifx ,505840;<<- $ $ $ Ó $ ,505840;<<-

Te}qirxw$sr$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx Ó $ Ó $ ,74;0858- $ ,74;0858-

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx Ó $ Ó $ 5<50:9< $ 5<50:9<

Xe|iw$temh$vipexih$xs$rix$wlevi$wixxpiqirxw$sj$iuymx}

e{evhw ,80586- $ Ó $ Ó $ ,80586-

Hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw ,<0;45- $ Ó $ ,<85- $ ,=0986-

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$wxsgo$stxmsrw$i|ivgmwih :0=:6 $ Ó $ Ó $ :0=:6

Hmzmhirhw$temh ,66;08:7- $ Ó $ Ó $ ,66;08:7-

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$mwwyergi$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$mr$gsrrigxmsr

{mxl$tyfpmg$sjjivmrk 6;90<:; $ Ó $ Ó $ 6;90<:;

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$mwwyergi$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$mr$gsrrigxmsr

{mxl$IWTT 8=; $ Ó $ Ó $ 8=;

Rix$gewl$tvszmhih$f}$,ywih$mr-$jmrergmrk$egxmzmxmiw 6=5075: $ Ó $ ,56:09=;- $ 5:80;5=

Ijjigx$sj$I|glerki$Vexi$Glerkiw$sr$Gewl$erh$Gewl

Iuymzepirxw Ó $ Ó $ ,6075<- $ ,6075<-

Rix$Mrgviewi$mr$Gewl$erh$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw <0=7< $ 775 $ 770=5= $ 8705<<

Gewl$erh$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw0$fikmrrmrk$sj$tivmsh 890;6< $ 80:65 $ 84044< $ =4079;

Gewl$erh$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw0$irh$sj$tivmsh ( 980::: $ ( 80=96 $ ( ;70=6; $ ( 5770989

58:

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 222 of 253

Page 245: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 666367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

652 Wyfwiuyirx$Izirxw

Hmzmhirh

Sr$Jifvyev}$70$64640$xli$Fsevh$sj$Hmvigxsvw$higpevih$e$uyevxivp}$gewl$hmzmhirh$sj$(428<$tiv$wlevi$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo0${lmgl

{ew$temh$sr$Jifvyev}$650$6464$xs$wlevilsphivw$sj$vigsvh$ew$sj$xli$gpswi$sj$fywmriww$sr$Jifvyev}$580$64642

Stxmsrw$erh$Viwxvmgxih$Wxsgo$E{evhw

Sr$ Jifvyev}$ 540$ 64640$ xli$ Gsqtirwexmsr$ Gsqqmxxii$ sj$ xli$ Fsevh$ sj$ Hmvigxsvw$ viwspzih$ xs$ kverx$ ettvs|mqexip}$ 8=40444

stxmsrw$erh$=860444$wleviw$sj$viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$xs$givxemr$iqtps}iiw$erh$hmvigxsvw$sj$xli$Gsqter}$ijjigxmzi$Qevgl$50$64642$Sj$xli$xsxep

wleviw$ sj$ viwxvmgxih$ wxsgo$ kverxih0$ 7:40444$ evi$ tivjsvqergi1fewih$ e{evhw$ {lmgl$ ziwx$ wyfnigx$ xs$ xli$ eglmiziqirx$ sj$ givxemr$ xsxep

wlevilsphiv$vixyvr$erh$vixyvr$sr$getmxep$iqtps}ih$qixvmgw$sziv$e$xlvii1}iev$tivmsh2

Mxiq$=2 Glerkiw$mr$erh$Hmwekviiqirxw${mxl$Eggsyrxerxw$sr$Eggsyrxmrk$erh$Jmrergmep$Hmwgpswyvi

Rsri2

$Mxiq$=E2 Gsrxvspw$erh$Tvsgihyviw

Hmwgpswyvi$Gsrxvspw$erh$Tvsgihyviw

Syv$ qerekiqirx0$ {mxl$ xli$ tevxmgmtexmsr$ sj$ syv$ Glmij$ I|igyxmzi$ Sjjmgiv$ erh$ syv$ Glmij$ Jmrergmep$ Sjjmgiv0$ lew$ izepyexih$ xli

ijjigxmziriww$sj$syv$hmwgpswyvi$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw$,ew$wygl$xivq$mw$hijmrih$mr$Vypiw$57e159,i-$erh$59h159,i-$yrhiv$xli$Wigyvmxmiw

I|glerki$Egx$sj$5=780$ew$eqirhih0$vijivvih$xs$ew$xli$I|glerki$Egx-0$ew$sj$xli$irh$sj$xli$tivmsh$gszivih$f}$xlmw$vitsvx2$Sr$xli$fewmw$sj

xlmw$vizmi{0$syv$qerekiqirx0$mrgpyhmrk$syv$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$erh$syv$Glmij$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv0$lew$gsrgpyhih$xlex$ew$sj$xli$irh

sj$ xli$ tivmsh$ gszivih$ f}$ xlmw$ vitsvx0$ syv$ hmwgpswyvi$ gsrxvspw$ erh$ tvsgihyviw$ {ivi$ ijjigxmzi$ xs$ kmzi$ viewsrefpi$ ewwyvergi$ xlex$ xli

mrjsvqexmsr$ viuymvih$ xs$ fi$ hmwgpswih$ mr$ syv$ vitsvxw$ jmpih$ {mxl$ xli$ Wigyvmxmiw$ erh$ I|glerki$ Gsqqmwwmsr0$ sv$ xli$ WIG0$ yrhiv$ xli

I|glerki$Egx$mw$vigsvhih0$tvsgiwwih0$wyqqevm~ih$erh$vitsvxih${mxlmr$xli$xmqi$tivmshw$wtigmjmih$mr$xli$vypiw$erh$jsvqw$sj$xli$WIG0

erh$xs$irwyvi$xlex$xli$mrjsvqexmsr$viuymvih$xs$fi$hmwgpswih$mr$xli$vitsvxw$jmpih$sv$wyfqmxxih$yrhiv$xli$I|glerki$Egx$mw$eggyqypexih$erh

gsqqyrmgexih$ xs$ syv$qerekiqirx0$ mrgpyhmrk$syv$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$erh$syv$Glmij$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv0$ mr$e$qerriv$ xlex$ epps{w

xmqip}$higmwmsrw$vikevhmrk$viuymvih$hmwgpswyvi2

Mx$ wlsyph$ fi$ rsxih$ xlex$ xli$ ijjigxmziriww$ sj$ syv$ w}wxiq$ sj$ hmwgpswyvi$ gsrxvspw$ erh$ tvsgihyviw$ mw$ wyfnigx$ xs$ givxemr$ pmqmxexmsrw

mrlivirx$ mr$ er}$ w}wxiq$ sj$ hmwgpswyvi$ gsrxvspw$ erh$ tvsgihyviw0$ mrgpyhmrk$ xli$ i|ivgmwi$ sj$ nyhkqirx$ mr$ hiwmkrmrk0$ mqtpiqirxmrk$ erh

izepyexmrk$ xli$ gsrxvspw$ erh$ tvsgihyviw0$ xli$ ewwyqtxmsrw$ ywih$ mr$ mhirxmj}mrk$ xli$ pmoipmlssh$ sj$ jyxyvi$ izirxw0$ erh$ xli$ mrefmpmx}$ xs

ipmqmrexi$qmwgsrhygx$gsqtpixip}2$Eggsvhmrkp}0$ xlivi$ger$fi$rs$ewwyvergi$ xlex$syv$hmwgpswyvi$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw${mpp$hixigx$epp

ivvsvw$ sv$ jveyh2$Ew$ e$ viwypx0$ f}$ mxw$ rexyvi0$ syv$ w}wxiq$sj$ hmwgpswyvi$ gsrxvspw$ erh$tvsgihyviw$ ger$ tvszmhi$ srp}$ viewsrefpi$ ewwyvergi

vikevhmrk$qerekiqirx×w$gsrxvsp$sfnigxmziw2

Mrxivrep$Gsrxvsp$Sziv$Jmrergmep$Vitsvxmrk

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 223 of 253

Page 246: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 667367<

,e-$Qerekiqirx×w$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Mrxivrep$Gsrxvsp$Sziv$Jmrergmep$Vitsvxmrk

Wii$ ÔMxiq$ <2$ Ó$ Jmrergmep$ Wxexiqirxw$ erh$ Wyttpiqirxev}$ Hexe$ Ó$ Qerekiqirx×w$ Erryep$ Vitsvx$ sr$ Mrxivrep$ Gsrxvsp$ Sziv

Jmrergmep$VitsvxmrkÕ$jsv$qerekiqirx×w$vitsvx$sr$xli$ijjigxmziriww$sj$syv$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750

645=2

,f-$Exxiwxexmsr$Vitsvx$sj$xli$Vikmwxivih$Tyfpmg$Eggsyrxmrk$Jmvq

Wii$ÔMxiq$<2$Ó$Jmrergmep$Wxexiqirxw$erh$Wyttpiqirxev}$Hexe$Ó$Vitsvx$sj$Mrhitirhirx$Vikmwxivih$Tyfpmg$Eggsyrxmrk$JmvqÕ$jsv

xli$vitsvx$sj$syv$mrhitirhirx$vikmwxivih$tyfpmg$eggsyrxmrk$jmvq$sr$xli$ijjigxmziriww$sj$syv$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$ew$sj

Higiqfiv$750$645=2

,g-$Glerkiw$mr$Mrxivrep$Gsrxvsp$sziv$Jmrergmep$Vitsvxmrk

Syv$qerekiqirx$ mw$ viwtsrwmfpi$ jsv$ vitsvxmrk$ er}$ glerkiw$ mr$ syv$ mrxivrep$ gsrxvsp$ sziv$ jmrergmep$ vitsvxmrk$ ,ew$ wygl$ xivqw$ evi

hijmrih$mr$Vypiw$57e159,j-$erh$59h159,j-$yrhiv$xli$I|glerki$Egx-$hyvmrk$xli$tivmsh$xs${lmgl$xlmw$vitsvx$vipexiw$xlex$lezi$qexivmepp}

ejjigxih0$sv$evi$viewsrefp}$pmoip}$xs$qexivmepp}$ejjigx0$syv$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk2$Qerekiqirx$fipmiziw$xlex$xlivi$lezi

rsx$fiir$er}$glerkiw$mr$syv$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$,ew$wygl$xivq$mw$hijmrih$mr$Vypiw$57e159,j-$erh$59h159,j-$yrhiv

xli$I|glerki$Egx-$hyvmrk$ xli$tivmsh$ xs${lmgl$ xlmw$ vitsvx$vipexiw$xlex$lezi$qexivmepp}$ejjigxih0$sv$evi$ viewsrefp}$ pmoip}$xs$qexivmepp}

ejjigx0$syv$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$ vitsvxmrk2$[i$mqtpiqirxih$givxemr$mrxivrep$gsrxvspw$xs$irwyvi${i$ehiuyexip}$izepyexih$syv

piewi$gsrxvegxw$erh$tvstivp}$ewwiwwih$xli$mqtegx$sj$xli$ri{$eggsyrxmrk$wxerhevh$vipexih$xs$piewi$eggsyrxmrk$sr$syv$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw0

mrgpyhmrk$vipizerx$hmwgpswyviw0$xs$jegmpmxexi$xlmw$ehstxmsr$sr$Neryev}$50$645=2$Xlivi${ivi$rs$wmkrmjmgerx$glerkiw$xs$syv$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp

sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$hyvmrk$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=$hyi$xs$xli$ehstxmsr$sj$xlmw$wxerhevh$sr$Neryev}$50$645=2

$Mxiq$=F2 Sxliv$Mrjsvqexmsr

Rsx$ettpmgefpi2

58;

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 224 of 253

Page 247: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 668367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

TEVX$MMM

MXIQ$542$$$$Hmvigxsvw0$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgivw$erh$Gsvtsvexi$Kszivrergi

[i$lezi$ehstxih$e$gshi$sj$fywmriww$gsrhygx$erh$ixlmgw$ettpmgefpi$xs$epp$sj$syv$hmvigxsvw0$sjjmgivw0$iqtps}iiw0$ekirxw$erh

vitviwirxexmziw0$mrgpyhmrk$syv$gsrwypxerxw2$Xli$gshi$wxvmziw$xs$hixiv${vsrkhsmrk$erh$tvsqsxi$lsriwx$erh$ixlmgep$gsrhygx0$xli$ezsmhergi

sj$gsrjpmgxw$sj$mrxiviwx0$jypp0$jemv0$eggyvexi0$xmqip}$erh$xverwtevirx$hmwgpswyvi0$gsqtpmergi${mxl$xli$ettpmgefpi$kszivrqirx$erh$wipj1

vikypexsv}$svkerm~exmsr$pe{w0$vypiw$erh$vikypexmsrw0$tvsqtx$mrxivrep$vitsvxmrk$sj$zmspexmsrw$sj$xli$gshi0$erh$eggsyrxefmpmx}$jsv

gsqtpmergi${mxl$xli$gshi2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0${i$lezi$ehstxih$e$gshi$sj$ixlmgw$jsv$xli$GIS0$syv$wirmsv$jmrergmep$sjjmgivw$erh$epp$sxliv

iqtps}iiw2$Xli$gshiw$ger$fi$jsyrh$sr$syv${ifwmxi$ex$lxxt>33{{{2kiskvsyt2gsq$f}$gpmgomrk$sr$xli$pmro$ÔEfsyx$YwÕ$sr$syv$lsqiteki

erh$xlir$gpmgomrk$sr$xli$pmro$ÔGsvtsvexi$Kszivrergi2Õ$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$xli$gshiw$evi$ezempefpi$mr$tvmrx$xs$er}$wlevilsphiv${ls$viuyiwx$xliq

f}$gsrxegxmrk$syv$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx$sj$Gsvtsvexi$Vipexmsrw$ex$9:51===1;74:2$Mr$xli$izirx$xlex${i$eqirh$sv${emzi$er}$sj$xli$tvszmwmsrw$sj

xli$gshi$sj$fywmriww$gsrhygx$erh$ixlmgw$erh$xli$gshi$sj$ixlmgw$jsv$xli$GIS0$syv$wirmsv$jmrergmep$sjjmgivw$erh$iqtps}iiw$xlex$vipexi$xs

er}$ipiqirx$sj$xli$gshi$sj$ixlmgw$hijmrmxmsr$iryqivexih$mr$Mxiq$84:,f-$sj$Vikypexmsr$W1O0${i$mrxirh$xs$hmwgpswi$xli$weqi$sr$syv

Mrziwxsv$Vipexmsrw${ifwmxi2$Xli$sxliv$mrjsvqexmsr$viuymvih$f}$xlmw$mxiq${mpp$fi$gsrxemrih$mr0$erh$mw$mrgsvtsvexih$f}$vijivirgi$jvsq0$xli

tvs|}$wxexiqirx$jsv$syv$6464$erryep$qiixmrk$sj$wlevilsphivw0${lmgl${mpp$fi$jmpih${mxl$xli$WIG$tyvwyerx$xs$Vikypexmsr$58E${mxlmr$564

he}w$ejxiv$xli$irh$sj$xli$}iev$gszivih$f}$xlmw$vitsvx2

MXIQ$552$$$$I|igyxmzi$Gsqtirwexmsr

Xli$mrjsvqexmsr$viuymvih$f}$xlmw$mxiq${mpp$fi$gsrxemrih$mr0$erh$mw$mrgsvtsvexih$f}$vijivirgi$jvsq0$xli$tvs|}$wxexiqirx$jsv$syv

6464$erryep$qiixmrk$sj$wlevilsphivw0${lmgl${mpp$fi$jmpih${mxl$xli$WIG$tyvwyerx$xs$Vikypexmsr$58E${mxlmr$564$he}w$ejxiv$xli$irh$sj$xli

jmwgep$}iev$gszivih$f}$xlmw$vitsvx2

MXIQ$562$$$$Wigyvmx}$S{rivwlmt$sj$Givxemr$Firijmgmep$S{rivw$erh$Qerekiqirx$erh$Vipexih$Wxsgolsphiv$Qexxivw

Xli$mrjsvqexmsr$viuymvih$f}$xlmw$mxiq${mpp$fi$gsrxemrih$mr0$erh$mw$mrgsvtsvexih$f}$vijivirgi$jvsq0$xli$tvs|}$wxexiqirx$jsv$syv

6464$erryep$qiixmrk$sj$wlevilsphivw0${lmgl${mpp$fi$jmpih${mxl$xli$WIG$tyvwyerx$xs$Vikypexmsr$58E${mxlmr$564$he}w$ejxiv$xli$irh$sj$xli

jmwgep$}iev$gszivih$f}$xlmw$vitsvx2

MXIQ$572$$$$Givxemr$Vipexmsrwlmtw$erh$Vipexih$Xverwegxmsrw0$erh$Hmvigxsv$Mrhitirhirgi

Xli$mrjsvqexmsr$viuymvih$f}$xlmw$mxiq${mpp$fi$gsrxemrih$mr0$erh$mw$mrgsvtsvexih$f}$vijivirgi$jvsq0$xli$tvs|}$wxexiqirx$jsv$syv

6464$erryep$qiixmrk$sj$wlevilsphivw0${lmgl${mpp$fi$jmpih${mxl$xli$WIG$tyvwyerx$xs$Vikypexmsr$58E${mxlmr$564$he}w$ejxiv$xli$irh$sj$xli

jmwgep$}iev$gszivih$f}$xlmw$vitsvx2

MXIQ$582$$$$Tvmrgmtep$Eggsyrxmrk$Jiiw$erh$Wivzmgiw

Xli$mrjsvqexmsr$viuymvih$f}$xlmw$mxiq${mpp$fi$gsrxemrih$mr0$erh$mw$mrgsvtsvexih$f}$vijivirgi$jvsq0$xli$tvs|}$wxexiqirx$jsv$syv

6464$erryep$qiixmrk$sj$wlevilsphivw0${lmgl${mpp$fi$jmpih${mxl$xli$WIG$tyvwyerx$xs$Vikypexmsr$58E${mxlmr$564$he}w$ejxiv$xli$irh$sj$xli

jmwgep$}iev$gszivih$f}$xlmw$vitsvx2

TEVX$MZ

$

Mxiq$592 I|lmfmxw0$Jmrergmep$Wxexiqirx$Wglihypiw

,e-,5-$Jmrergmep$Wxexiqirxw2

Xli$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$sj$KIS$evi$jmpih$yrhiv$Mxiq$<$sj$Tevx$MM$sj$xlmw$vitsvx2

,6-$Jmrergmep$Wxexiqirx$Wglihypiw2

Wglihypi$MM$Ó$Zepyexmsr$erh$Uyepmj}mrk$Eggsyrxw$Ó$Teki$5:7

58<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 225 of 253

Page 248: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 669367<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 226 of 253

Page 249: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 66:367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Wglihypi$MMM$$Ó$Viep$Iwxexi$erh$Eggyqypexih$Hitvigmexmsr$$Ó$Teki$5:8

Epp$sxliv$wglihypiw$wtigmjmih$mr$xli$eggsyrxmrk$vikypexmsrw$sj$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$erh$I|glerki$Gsqqmwwmsr$lezi$fiir$sqmxxih

figeywi$xli}$evi$imxliv$mrettpmgefpi$sv$rsx$viuymvih2

,7-$I|lmfmxw$Viuymvih$f}$Mxiq$:45$sj$Vikypexmsr$W1O2$Xli$jspps{mrk$i|lmfmxw$evi$jmpih$ew$tevx$sj$xlmw$Erryep$Vitsvx>$

I|lmfmxRyqfiv

$$Hiwgvmtxmsr $

$ $ $

725

$

Eqirhih$ erh$ Viwxexih

Evxmgpiw$ sj$ Mrgsvtsvexmsr

,mrgsvtsvexih$f}$vijivirgi$ xs

I|lmfmx$725$xs$xli$Gsqter}×w

vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$<1O0$ jmpih$sr

Nyri$740$6458-2 lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=7569586988=53h;94:79hi|752lxq

$ $ $ $

726

$

Evxmgpiw$ sj$ Qivkiv0$ ijjigxmzi

ew$ sj$ Nyri$ 6;0$ 6458

,mrgsvtsvexih$f}$vijivirgi$ xs

I|lmfmx$726$xs$xli$Gsqter}×w

vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$<1O0$ jmpih$sr

Nyri$740$6458-2 lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=7569586988=53h;94:79hi|762lxq

$ $ $

727 $$ Evxmgpiw$sj$Eqirhqirx$xs$xli

Eqirhih$ erh$ Viwxexih

Evxmgpiw$ sj$ Mrgsvtsvexmsr$ sj

Xli$ KIS$ Kvsyt0$ Mrg2

,mrgsvtsvexih$f}$vijivirgi$ xs

I|lmfmx$725$xs$xli$Gsqter}×w

vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$<1O0$ jmpih$sr

Etvmp$6:0$645;-2 lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=75695;57;7883h7<8;=<hi|752lxq

$ $ $

728 $$ Wigsrh$ Eqirhih$ erh

Viwxexih$F}pe{w$sj$Xli$KIS

Kvsyt0$ Mrg2$ ,mrgsvtsvexih$ f}

vijivirgi$xs$I|lmfmx$725$xs$xli

Gsqter}×w$vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$<1

O0$jmpih$sr$Etvmp$5;0$645;-2 lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=75695;56:5483h7;;=74hi|752lxq

$ $ $ $

729

$

Eqirhqirx$ xs$ Wigsrh

Eqirhih$ erh$ Viwxexih

F}pe{w$ Ehstxih$ sr$ Nyp}$ :0

645<$ ,mrgsvtsvexih$ f}

vijivirgi$xs$I|lmfmx$725$xs$xli

Gsqter}×w$vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$<1

O$jmpih$sr$Nyp}$550$645<-2

lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=75695<65:59:3h89<5:9hi|752lxq

$ $ $ $

72: $ Eqirhqirx$ xs$ Wigsrh

Eqirhih$ erh$ Viwxexih

F}pe{w$ Ehstxih$ sr

Witxiqfiv$ 540$ 645<

,mrgsvtsvexih$f}$vijivirgi$ xs

lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=75695<6;6=483h:687=7hi|752lxq

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 227 of 253

Page 250: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 66;367<

I|lmfmx$725$xs$xli$Gsqter}×w

vitsvx$ sr$ Jsvq$ <1O$ jmpih$ sr

Witxiqfiv$570$645<-2

$ $ $ $

72;

$

Eqirhqirx$ xs$ Wigsrh

Eqirhih$ erh$ Viwxexih

F}pe{w$ Ehstxih$ sr

Rsziqfiv$ 6=0$ 645<

,mrgsvtsvexih$f}$vijivirgi$ xs

I|lmfmx$725$xs$xli$Gsqter}×w

vitsvx$ sr$ Jsvq$ <1O$ jmpih$ sr

Rsziqfiv$740$645<-2

lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=75695<77=<853h::9:64hi|752lxq

$ $ $ $

72<

$

Eqirhqirx$ xs$ xli$ Wigsrh

Eqirhih$ erh$ Viwxexih

F}pe{w$ sj$ Xli$ KIS$ Kvsyt0

Mrg20$ ijjigxmzi$ Sgxsfiv$ =0

645=$ ,mrgsvtsvexih$ f}

vijivirgi$xs$I|lmfmx$725$xs$xli

Gsqter}+w$vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$<1

O$jmpih$sr$Sgxsfiv$5:0$645=-2

lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=75695=6:<96:3h<5<:<<hi|752lxq

58=

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 228 of 253

Page 251: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 66<367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$ $ $ $

825 $$ Mrhirxyvi0$ hexih$ ew$ sj$ Qevgl

5=0$ 64570$ f}$ erh$ eqsrk$ xli

Gsqter}0$xli$Kyeverxsvw$tevx}

xlivixs0$erh$[ippw$Jevks$Fero0

Rexmsrep$ Ewwsgmexmsr$ ew

Xvywxii$ vipexmrk$ xs$ xli$92569)

Wirmsv$ Rsxiw$ hyi$ 6467

,mrgsvtsvexih$ f}$ vijivirgi$ xs

I|lmfmx$ 825$ xs$ xli$ Gsqter}×w

vitsvx$ sr$ Jsvq$ <1O0$ jmpih$ sr

Qevgl$690$6457-2 lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=75695756897:3h94=69:hi|852lxq

$ $ $

826 $$ Jsvq$ sj$ 92569)$ Wirmsv$ Rsxi

hyi$ 6467$ ,mrgpyhih$ mr$ I|lmfmx

825-2 lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=75695756897:3h94=69:hi|852lxq

$ $ $

827 $$ Mrhirxyvi0$ hexih$ew$sj$Sgxsfiv

70$ 64570$ f}$ erh$ eqsrk$ xli

Gsqter}0$xli$Kyeverxsvw$tevx}

xlivixs0$erh$[ippw$Jevks$Fero0

Rexmsrep$ Ewwsgmexmsr$ ew

Xvywxii$ vipexmrk$ xs$ xli$ 9$ ;3<)

Wirmsv$ Rsxiw$ hyi$ 6466

,mrgsvtsvexih$ f}$ vijivirgi$ xs

I|lmfmx$ 825$ xs$ xli$ Gsqter}×w

vitsvx$ sr$ Jsvq$ <1O0$ jmpih$ sr

Sgxsfiv$=0$6457-2 lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=7569577=979;3h:547<5hi|852lxq

$ $ $ $

828

$

Jsvq$ sj$ 9$ ;3<)$ Wirmsv$ Rsxi

hyi$ 6466$ ,mrgpyhih$ mr$ I|lmfmx

827-2 lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=7569577=979;3h:547<5hi|852lxq

$ $ $ $

829

$

Wyttpiqirxep$ Mrhirxyvi$ hexih

ew$ sj$ Nyri$ 6;0$ 64580$ xs

Mrhirxyvi$ hexih$ ew$ sj$ Qevgl

5=0$ 64570$ {mxl$ viwtigx$ xs$ xli

Tvihigiwwsv$ Vikmwxverx×w

92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$fix{iir

xli$Gsqter}$ erh$[ippw$Jevks

Fero0$Rexmsrep$Ewwsgmexmsr0$ew

Xvywxii$ ,mrgsvtsvexih$ f}

vijivirgi$ xs$I|lmfmx$ 828$ xs$ xli

Gsqter}×w$ vitsvx$ sr$ Jsvq$ <1

O0$jmpih$sr$Nyri$740$6458-2 lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=7569586988=53h;94:79hi|882lxq

$ $ $ $

82: $ Wyttpiqirxep$ Mrhirxyvi$ hexih

ew$ sj$ Nyri$ 6;0$ 64580$ xs

Mrhirxyvi$ hexih$ ew$ sj$ Sgxsfiv

70$ 64570$ {mxl$ viwtigx$ xs$ xli

Tvihigiwwsv$ Vikmwxverx×w$ 9

;3<)$ Wirmsv$ Rsxiw0$ fix{iir

xli$Gsqter}$ erh$[ippw$Jevks

Fero0$Rexmsrep$Ewwsgmexmsr0$ew

lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=7569586988=53h;94:79hi|892lxq

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 229 of 253

Page 252: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 66=367<

Xvywxii$ ,mrgsvtsvexih$ f}

vijivirgi$ xs$I|lmfmx$ 829$ xs$ xli

Gsqter}×w$ vitsvx$ sr$ Jsvq$ <1

O0$jmpih$sr$Nyri$740$6458-2

$ $ $ $

82;

$

Mrhirxyvi0$ hexih$ ew$ sj

Witxiqfiv$ 690$ 64580$ f}$ erh

fix{iir$KIS$erh$[ippw$Jevks

Fero0$Rexmsrep$Ewwsgmexmsr0$ew

Xvywxii$ ,mrgsvtsvexih$ f}

vijivirgi$ xs$I|lmfmx$ 825$ xs$ xli

Gsqter}×w$ vitsvx$ sr$ Jsvq$ <1

O0$jmpih$sr$Sgxsfiv$50$6458-2 lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=7569587:4<9;3h;=9:77hi|852lxq

$ $ $ $

82<

$

Jmvwx$ Wyttpiqirxep$ Mrhirxyvi0

hexih$ ew$ sj$ Witxiqfiv$ 690

64580$ f}$ erh$ eqsrk$ KIS0

givxemr$ wyfwmhmev}$ kyeverxsvw

erh$ [ippw$ Jevks$ Fero0

Rexmsrep$ Ewwsgmexmsr0$ ew

Xvywxii$ {mxl$ viwtigx$ xs$ xli

92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468

,mrgsvtsvexih$ f}$ vijivirgi$ xs

I|lmfmx$ 826$ xs$ xli$ Gsqter}×w

vitsvx$ sr$ Jsvq$ <1O0$ jmpih$ sr

Sgxsfiv$50$6458-2 lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=7569587:4<9;3h;=9:77hi|862lxq

$ $ $ $

82=

$

Jsvq$ sj$ 92<;9)$ Wirmsv$ Rsxi

hyi$ 6468$ ,mrgpyhih$ mr$ I|lmfmx

82<-2 lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=7569587:4<9;3h;=9:77hi|862lxq

$ $ $ $

8254

$

Wigsrh$ Wyttpiqirxep

Mrhirxyvi0$hexih$ew$sj$Etvmp$5<0

645:0$f}$erh$eqsrk$Xli$KIS

Kvsyt0$ Mrg20$ xli$ wyfwmhmev}

kyeverxsvw$ reqih$ xlivimr$ erh

[ippw$ Jevks$ Fero0$ Rexmsrep

Ewwsgmexmsr0$ ew$ Xvywxii$ {mxl

viwtigx$ xs$ xli$ :244)$ Wirmsv

Rsxiw$ hyi$ 646:$ ,mrgsvtsvexih

f}$ vijivirgi$ xs$ I|lmfmx$ 825$ xs

xli$Gsqter}×w$vitsvx$sr$Jsvq

<1O0$jmpih$sr$Etvmp$5<0$645:-2 lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=75695:98944<3h5;65;7hi|852lxq

$ $ $ $

594

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 230 of 253

Page 253: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 674367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

8255

$

Jsvq$sj$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw

hyi$ 646:$ ,mrgpyhih$ mr

I|lmfmx$8254-2 lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=75695:98944<3h5;65;7hi|852lxq

$ $ $ $

8256

$

Jsvq$sj$Mrhirxyvi$jsv$Wirmsv

Hifx$ Wigyvmxmiw

,mrgsvtsvexih$f}$vijivirgi$xs

I|lmfmx$ 825$ xs$ xli

Gsqter}×w$ vikmwxvexmsr

wxexiqirx$sr$Jsvq$W17EWV0

jmpih$sr$Sgxsfiv$640$645;-2 lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=58:;4344455=75695;7599653h8;84;5hi|852lxq

$ $ $ $

8257

$

Jsvq$ sj$ Mrhirxyvi$ jsv

Wyfsvhmrexih$ Hifx

Wigyvmxmiw$ ,mrgsvtsvexih$ f}

vijivirgi$ xs$ I|lmfmx$ 826$ xs

xli$ Gsqter}×w$ vikmwxvexmsr

wxexiqirx$sr$Jsvq$W17EWV0

jmpih$sr$Sgxsfiv$640$645;-2 lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=58:;4344455=75695;7599653h8;84;5hi|862lxq

$ $ $ $

8258

$

Hiwgvmtxmsr$ sj$ Vikmwxverx+w

Wigyvmxmiw. $

5425

$

Jsvq$ sj$ Mrhiqrmjmgexmsr

Ekviiqirx$ fix{iir$ xli

Gsqter}$ erh$ mxw$ Sjjmgivw

erh$ Hmvigxsvw$ ,mrgsvtsvexih

livimr$ f}$ vijivirgi$ xs

I|lmfmx$ 5427$ xs$ xli

Gsqter}×w$ vikmwxvexmsr

wxexiqirx$sr$Jsvq$W150$jmpih

sr$Qe}$680$5==8-£ $

$ $ $

5426 $$ Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2$Wirmsv

Qerekiqirx$ Tivjsvqergi

E{evh$ Tper0$ ew$ Eqirhih

erh$ Viwxexih$ ,mrgsvtsvexih

f}$ vijivirgi$ xs$I|lmfmx$5427

xs$ xli$ Gsqter}+w$ vitsvx$ sr

Jsvq$ 541O0$ jmpih$ sr

Jifvyev}$6:0$645=-$£ lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=75695=4944983h::7854hi|5472lxq

$ $ $

5427 $$ Eqirhih$ erh$ Viwxexih$ Xli

KIS$ Kvsyt0$ Mrg2$ Wirmsv

Sjjmgiv$ Vixmviqirx$ Tper0

ijjigxmzi$Higiqfiv$750$644<

,mrgsvtsvexih$f}$vijivirgi$xs

I|lmfmx$ 542<$ xs$ xli

Gsqter}×w$ vitsvx$ sr$ Jsvq

<1O$Neryev}$;0$644=-£ lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:34444=945884=4445543k5;674i|z54{<2lxq

$ $ $

5428 $$ Wirmsv$ Sjjmgiv$ Iqtps}qirx

Ekviiqirx0$ hexih$Eykywx$ 70

644=0$ f}$ erh$ fix{iir$ xli

Gsqter}$ erh$ Fvmer$ Izerw

lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:34444=945674=46<==;3k5==<8i|z54{52lxq

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 231 of 253

Page 254: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 675367<

,mrgsvtsvexih$f}$vijivirgi$xs

I|lmfmx$ 5425$ xs$ xli

Gsqter}×w$ vitsvx$ sr$ Jsvq

541U0$ jmpih$ sr$ Eykywx$ 70

644=-£

$ $ $

5429

$

Wirmsv$ Sjjmgiv$ Iqtps}qirx

Ekviiqirx0$ hexih$ Jifvyev}

50$645:0$f}$erh$fix{iir$xli

Gsqter}$ erh$ N2$ Hezmh

Hsrelyi$ ,mrgsvtsvexih

livimr$ f}$ vijivirgi$ xs

I|lmfmx$ 542;$ xs$ xli

Gsqter}+w$ vitsvx$ sr$ Jsvq

541O0$ jmpih$ sr$ Jifvyev}$ 690

645=-$£ lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=75695=4944983h::7854hi|54;2lxq

$ $ $ $

542: $$ Jmvwx$ Eqirhqirx$ xs$ Wirmsv

Sjjmgiv$ Iqtps}qirx

Ekviiqirx0$ ijjigxmzi$Qevgl

50$64550$f}$erh$fix{iir$xli

Gsqter}$ erh$ Fvmer$ V2

Izerw$ ,mrgsvtsvexih$ f}

vijivirgi$xs$I|lmfmx$5426<$xs

xli$ Gsqter}×w$ vitsvx$ sr

Jsvq$ 541O0$ jmpih$ sr$ Qevgl

60$6455-£ lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:34444=9456755464=663k69849i|z54{6<2lxq

$ $ $

542; $$ Eqirhih$ erh$ Viwxexih$ Xli

KIS$Kvsyt0$ Mrg2$ I|igyxmzi

Vixmviqirx$ Tper$ ,ijjigxmzi

Neryev}$ 50$ 644<-

,mrgsvtsvexih$f}$vijivirgi$xs

I|lmfmx$ 5427:$ xs$ xli

Gsqter}×w$ vitsvx$ sr$ Jsvq

541O0$ jmpih$ sr$ Qevgl$ 50

6456-£ lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=7569564=46:=3h69=9=4hi|547:2lxq

542< $$ Eqirhqirx$ xs$ Xli$ KIS

Kvsyt0$ Mrg2$ I|igyxmzi

Vixmviqirx$ Tper

,mrgsvtsvexih$f}$vijivirgi$xs

I|lmfmx$ 5427;$ xs$ xli

Gsqter}×w$ vitsvx$ sr$ Jsvq

541O0$ jmpih$ sr$ Qevgl$ 50

6456-£ lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=7569564=46:=3h69=9=4hi|547;2lxq

595

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 232 of 253

Page 255: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 676367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

542= $$ Xli$ KIS$ Kvsyt0$ Mrg2

Hijivvih$ Gsqtirwexmsr

Tper$ ,ew$ eqirhih$ erh

viwxexih$ijjigxmzi$Neryev}$50

644<-$ ,mrgsvtsvexih$ f}

vijivirgi$xs$I|lmfmx$5427<$xs

xli$ Gsqter}×w$ vitsvx$ sr

Jsvq$ 541O0$ jmpih$ sr$Qevgl

50$6456-£ lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=7569564=46:=3h69=9=4hi|547<2lxq

$ $ $

54254 $$ Eqirhqirx$ xs$ Xli$ KIS

Kvsyt0$ Mrg2$ Hijivvih

Gsqtirwexmsr$ Tper

,mrgsvtsvexih$ f}$ vijivirgi

xs$ I|lmfmx$ 5427=$ xs$ xli

Gsqter}×w$ vitsvx$ sr$ Jsvq

541O0$ jmpih$ sr$ Qevgl$ 50

6456-£ lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=7569564=46:=3h69=9=4hi|547=2lxq

$ $ $

54255 $$ Eqirhqirx$ xs$ Xli$ KIS

Kvsyt0$ Mrg2$ Hijivvih

Gsqtirwexmsr$ Tper

,mrgsvtsvexih$ f}$ vijivirgi

xs$ I|lmfmx$ 54284$ xs$ xli

Gsqter}×w$ vitsvx$ sr$ Jsvq

541O0$ jmpih$ sr$ Qevgl$ 50

6456-£ lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=7569564=46:=3h69=9=4hi|54842lxq

$ $ $

54256 $$ Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$ Mrg2$ 6455

Iqtps}ii$ Wxsgo$ Tyvglewi

Tper$ ,mrgsvtsvexih$ f}

vijivirgi$xs$I|lmfmx$54285$xs

xli$ Gsqter}×w$ Vikmwxvexmsr

Wxexiqirx$ sr$ Jsvq$ W1<0

jmpih$ sr$ Qe}$ 80$ 6456$ ,Jmpi

Rs2$77715<55;9--£ lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=75695665667:3h78;6:;hi|54852lxq

$ $ $

54257 $$ Xlmvh$ Eqirhih$ erh

Viwxexih$ I|igyxmzi

Iqtps}qirx$ Ekviiqirx0

hexih$ Eykywx$ 660$ 64560$ f}

erh$ fix{iir$ Xli$ KIS

Kvsyt0$ Mrg2$ erh$ Kisvki$ G2

^spi}$ ,mrgsvtsvexih$ f}

vijivirgi$xs$I|lmfmx$54286$xs

xli$ Gsqter}×w$ vitsvx$ sr

Jsvq$ <1O0$ jmpih$ sr$ Eykywx

6<0$6456-£ lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=7569567;645;3h84756<hi|54862lxq

$ $ $

54258 $$ Eqirhih$ erh$ Viwxexih

I|igyxmzi$ Vixmviqirx

Ekviiqirx0$ hexih$ Eykywx

660$ 64560$ f}$ erh$ fix{iir

Xli$ KIS$ Kvsyt0$ Mrg2$ erh

lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=7569567;645;3h84756<hi|54872lxq

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 233 of 253

Page 256: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 677367<

Kisvki$ G2$ ^spi}

,mrgsvtsvexih$ f}$ vijivirgi

xs$ I|lmfmx$ 54287$ xs$ xli

Gsqter}×w$ vitsvx$ sr$ Jsvq

<1O0$ jmpih$ sr$ Eykywx$ 6<0

6456-£

$ $ $

54259

$

Jmvwx$ Eqirhqirx$ xs$ Xlmvh

Eqirhih$ erh$ Viwxexih

I|igyxmzi$ Iqtps}qirx

Ekviiqirx0$ hexih$ Etvmp$ 6=0

64570$ f}$ erh$ fix{iir$ Xli

KIS$ Kvsyt0$ Mrg2$ erh

Kisvki$ G2$ ^spi}

,mrgsvtsvexih$ f}$ vijivirgi

xs$ I|lmfmx$ 5425$ xs$ xli

Gsqter}×w$ vitsvx$ sr$ Jsvq

<1O0$ jmpih$ sr$ Etvmp$ 740

6457-$£2 lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=7569575<76663h97578=hi|5452lxq

$ $ $

5425:

$

Wigsrh$ Eqirhqirx$ xs

Xlmvh$ Eqirhih$ erh

Viwxexih$ I|igyxmzi

Iqtps}qirx$ Ekviiqirx0

hexih$Qe}$6=0$64570$f}$erh

fix{iir$ Xli$ KIS$ Kvsyt0

Mrg2$ erh$ Kisvki$ G2$ ^spi}

,mrgsvtsvexih$ f}$ vijivirgi

xs$ I|lmfmx$ 5425$ xs$ xli

Gsqter}×w$ vitsvx$ sr$ Jsvq

<1O0$ jmpih$ sr$ Nyri$ 80$ 6457-

£2 lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=75695768:=983h98=;88hi|5452lxq

$ $ $

5425;

$

Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$ Mrg2$ 6458

Wxsgo$ Mrgirxmzi$ Tper

,mrgsvtsvexih$ f}$ vijivirgi

xs$ I|lmfmx$ 5425$ xs$ xli

Gsqter}×w$ vitsvx$ sr$ Jsvq

<1O0$jmpih$sr$Qe}$90$6458-2

£ lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=7569585<6:9:3h;6556:hi|5452lxq

$ $ $ $

5425<

$

Pixxiv$ sj$ Sjjiv0$ hexih

Eykywx$ 5<0$ 645:0$ fix{iir

Xli$ KIS$ Kvsyt0$ Mrg2$ erh

LWFG$ Fero$ Eywxvepme

Pmqmxih$ ,mrgsvtsvexih$ f}

vijivirgi$ xs$I|lmfmx$ 5425$ xs

xli$ Gsqter}×w$ vitsvx$ sr

Jsvq$ <1O0$ jmpih$ sr$ Eykywx

680$645:-2 lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=75695::=448<3h68;899hi|5452lxq

$ $ $ $

596

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 234 of 253

Page 257: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 678367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

5425=

$

Xlmvh$Eqirhih$erh$Viwxexih

Gvihmx$ Ekviiqirx0$ hexih$ ew

sj$ Qevgl$ 670$ 645;0$ eqsrk

Xli$ KIS$ Kvsyt0$ Mrg20$ KIS

Gsvvigxmsrw$Lsphmrkw0$Mrg20$ew

xli$Fsvvs{ivw0$xli$Eywxvepmer

Fsvvs{ivw$ tevx}$ xlivixs0$ xli

Pirhivw$ tevx}$ xlivixs$ erh

FRT$ Tevmfew0$ ew

ehqmrmwxvexmzi$ ekirx2

,mrgsvtsvexih$f}$vijivirgi$ xs

I|lmfmx$ 5425$ xs$ xli

Gsqter}×w$vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$<1

O0$ jmpih$ sr$Qevgl$ 6=0$ 645;2

Tsvxmsrw$ sj$ xlmw$ i|lmfmx$ lezi

fiir$ sqmxxih$ erh$ jmpih

witevexip}${mxl$xli$Wigyvmxmiw

erh$ I|glerki$ Gsqqmwwmsr

tyvwyerx$ xs$ e$ viuyiwx$ jsv

gsrjmhirxmep$xviexqirx2-

lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=75695;545=983h75:;87hi|5452lxq

$ $ $ $

54264

$

Xli$ KIS$ Kvsyt0$ Mrg2$ 645<

Wxsgo$ Mrgirxmzi$ Tper

,mrgsvtsvexih$f}$vijivirgi$ xs

I|lmfmx$ 5425$ xs$ xli

Gsqter}×w$vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$<1

O$jmpih$sr$Etvmp$740$645<-2

lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=75695<58799:3h9;4<8;hi|5452lxq

$ $ $ $

54265

$

Eqirhqirx$ Rs2$ 5$ xs$ xli

Xlmvh$Eqirhih$erh$Viwxexih

Gvihmx$ Ekviiqirx0$ hexih$ ew

sj$ Etvmp$ 740$ 645<0$ f}$ erh

eqsrk$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg20

KIS$ Gsvvigxmsrw$ Lsphmrkw0

Mrg20$ FRT$ Tevmfew0$ ew

ehqmrmwxvexmzi$ ekirx$ jsv$ xli

pirhivw0$ xli$ vijmrergmrk

pirhivw$tevx}$xlivixs$erh$iegl

sxliv$ pirhiv$ tevx}$ xlivixs

,mrgsvtsvexih$f}$vijivirgi$ xs

I|lmfmx$ 5425$ xs$ xli

Gsqter}×w$vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$<1

O$jmpih$sr$Qe}$80$645<-2

lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=75695<596;9<3h9:887=hi|5452lxq

$ $ $ $

54266

$

Gsrwypxerx$ Ekviiqirx0

ijjigxmzi$Neryev}$50$645=0$f}

erh$ fix{iir$ xli$ Gsqter}

erh$ Nslr$ Fypjmr

,mrgsvtsvexih$f}$vijivirgi$ xs

I|lmfmx$ 5425$ xs$ xli

Gsqter}×w$vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$<1

O$ jmpih$ sr$ Higiqfiv$ 560

645<-2

lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=75695<78;<:53h:;66;:hi|5452lxq

$ $ $ $

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 235 of 253

Page 258: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 679367<

54267 $ Wirmsv$ Sjjmgiv$ Iqtps}qirx

Ekviiqirx0$ hexih$ Nyp}$ 650

64580$ f}$ erh$ fix{iir$ xli

Gsqter}$ erh$ Err$ Wglpevf

,mrgsvtsvexih$f}$vijivirgi$ xs

I|lmfmx$ 5425$ xs$ xli

Gsqter}+w$ vitsvx$ sr$ Jsvq

541U0$jmpih$sr$Qe}$:0$645=-£

lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=75695=57<8693h:95<45hi|5452lxq

$ $ $ $

54268

$

Eqirhqirx$ Rs2$ 6$ xs$ Xlmvh

Eqirhih$ erh$ Viwxexih

Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx0$hexih$Nyri

560$645=0$f}$erh$eqsrk$Xli

KIS$ Kvsyt0$ Mrg2$ erh$ KIS

Gsvvigxmsrw$Lsphmrkw0$Mrg20$ew

xli$ Fsvvs{ivw0$ KIS

Eywxvepewme$ Lsphmrkw$ TX]

PXH0$ KIS$ Eywxvepewme

Jmrergi$Lsphmrkw$TX]$PXH0

ew$ xvywxii$ sj$ xli$ KIS

Eywxvepewme$ Jmrergi$ Lsphmrk

Xvywx0$ FRT$ Tevmfew0$ ew

ehqmrmwxvexmzi$ ekirx0$ erh$ xli

pirhivw$ tevx}$ xlivixs

,tsvxmsrw$sj$ xlmw$i|lmfmx$lezi

fiir$ sqmxxih-$ ,mrgsvtsvexih

f}$ vijivirgi$ xs$ I|lmfmx$ 5425

xs$ xli$ Gsqter}+w$ vitsvx$ sr

Jsvq$ 541U0$ jmpih$ sr$ Eykywx

60$645=-

lxxtw>33{{{2wig2ksz3Evglmziw3ihkev3hexe3=67;=:344455=75695=6565463h;9=77;hi|5452lxq

$ $ $ $

6525

$

Wyfwmhmevmiw$ sj$ xli

Gsqter}. $

$ $ $ $

6725

$

Gsrwirx$ sj$ Kverx$ Xlsvrxsr

PPT0$ Mrhitirhirx$ Vikmwxivih

Tyfpmg$Eggsyrxmrk$Jmvq. $

$ $ $ $

7525

$

Vypi$ 57e158,e-$ Givxmjmgexmsr

mr$ eggsvhergi$ {mxl$ Wigxmsr

746$ sj$ xli$ Wevferiw1S|pi}

Egx$sj$6446. $

$ $ $ $

7526

$

Vypi$ 57e158,e-$ Givxmjmgexmsr

mr$ eggsvhergi$ {mxl$ Wigxmsr

746$ sj$ xli$ Wevferiw1S|pi}

Egx$sj$6446. $

597

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 236 of 253

Page 259: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 67:367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$ $ $ $

7625 $$ Givxmjmgexmsr$ tyvwyerx$ xs$ 5<$ Y2W2G2$ Wigxmsr$ 57940$ ew$ ehstxih

tyvwyerx$xs$Wigxmsr$=4:$sj$xli$Wevferiw1S|pi}$Egx$sj$6446. $

$ $ $

7626 $$ Givxmjmgexmsr$ tyvwyerx$ xs$ 5<$ Y2W2G2$ Wigxmsr$ 57940$ ew$ ehstxih

tyvwyerx$xs$Wigxmsr$=4:$sj$xli$Wevferiw1S|pi}$Egx$sj$6446. $

$ $ $

$ $ $

545. $$ Xli$jspps{mrk$jmrergmep$mrjsvqexmsr$jvsq$xli$Gsqter}+w$Erryep

Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O$jsv$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0

jsvqexxih$mr$Mrpmri$\FVP$,I|xirwmfpi$Fywmriww$Vitsvxmrk

Perkyeki-$mrgpyhiw>$,m-$xli$Gsrwspmhexih$Wxexiqirxw$sj

Stivexmsrw0$,mm-$xli$Gsrwspmhexih$Wxexiqirxw$sj$Gsqtvilirwmzi

Mrgsqi$,Psww-0$,mmm-$xli$Gsrwspmhexih$Fepergi$Wliixw0$,mz-$xli

Gsrwspmhexih$Wxexiqirxw$sj$Gewl$Jps{w0$,z-$xli$Gsrwspmhexih

Wxexiqirxw$sj$Wxsgolsphivw+$Iuymx}0$erh$,zm-$xli$Rsxiw$xs$xli

Gsrwspmhexih$Jmrergmep$Wxexiqirxw2$Xli$mrwxergi$hsgyqirx$hsiw

rsx$ettiev$mr$xli$mrxivegxmzi$hexe$jmpi$figeywi$mxw$\FVP$xekw$evi

iqfihhih${mxlmr$xli$Mrpmri$\FVP$hsgyqirx2 $

$ $ $ $

548$.

$

Gsziv$Teki$Mrxivegxmzi$Hexe$Xmxpi$1$xli$gsziv$teki$\FVP$xekw

evi$iqfihhih${mxlmr$xli$Mrpmri$\FVP$hsgyqirx2 $

. Jmpih$livi{mxl2

..$Givxemr$i|lmfmxw$erh$wglihypiw$xs$xli$ekviiqirx$lezi$fiir$sqmxxih$tyvwyerx$xs$Mxiq$:45,f-,6-$sj$Vikypexmsr$W1O2$[i$ekvii$xs

jyvrmwl$wyttpiqirxepp}$xs$xli$WIG0$ytsr$viuyiwx0$e$gst}$sj$xli$sqmxxih$i|lmfmxw$erh$wglihypiw2

...$Tsvxmsrw$sj$xlmw$i|lmfmx$lezi$fiir$sqmxxih$erh$jmpih$witevexip}${mxl$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$erh$I|glerki$Gsqqmwwmsr$tyvwyerx$xs$e$viuyiwx

jsv$gsrjmhirxmep$xviexqirx2

£ Qerekiqirx$gsrxvegx$sv$gsqtirwexsv}$tper0$gsrxvegx$sv$ekviiqirx$ew$hijmrih$mr$Mxiq$846$,e-,7-$sj$Vikypexmsr$W1O2

Mxiq$5:2$Jsvq$541O$Wyqqev}2

Rsri2

598

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 237 of 253

Page 260: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 67;367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

WMKREXYVIW

Tyvwyerx$xs$xli$viuymviqirxw$sj$Wigxmsr$57$sv$59,h-$sj$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$I|glerki$Egx$sj$5=780$xli$vikmwxverx$lew$hyp}$geywih$xlmw

vitsvx$xs$fi$wmkrih$sr$mxw$filepj$f}$xli$yrhivwmkrih0$xliviyrxs$hyp}$eyxlsvm~ih2$

XLI$KIS$KVSYT0$MRG2

$

3w3$$$$FVMER$V2$IZERW

Fvmer$V2$Izerw

Wirmsv$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx$erh$Glmij$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv

Hexi>$Jifvyev}$6:0$6464

Tyvwyerx$xs$xli$viuymviqirxw$sj$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$I|glerki$Egx$sj$5=780$xlmw$vitsvx$lew$fiir$wmkrih$fips{$f}$xli$jspps{mrk$tivwsrw

sr$filepj$sj$xli$vikmwxverx$erh$mr$xli$getegmxmiw$erh$sr$xli$hexiw$mrhmgexih2$

599

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 238 of 253

Page 261: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 541O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=h54o2lxq 67<367<

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

Wmkrexyvi $ Xmxpi $ Hexi

$ $ $

3w3$$$$Kisvki$G2$^spi} $$ Glemvqer$sj$xli$Fsevh$erh$Glmij $ Jifvyev}$6:0$6464

Kisvki$G2$^spi}$

I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv

,tvmrgmtep$i|igyxmzi$sjjmgiv- $ $

$ $ $

3w3$$$$Fvmer$V2$Izerw $$ Wirmsv$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx$erh $ Jifvyev}$6:0$6464

Fvmer$V2$Izerw$

Glmij$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv

,tvmrgmtep$jmrergmep$sjjmgiv- $ $

$ $ $

3w3$$$$Vsreph$E2$Fvego $$

I|igyxmzi

Zmgi$Tviwmhirx0$Glmij$Eggsyrxmrk$Sjjmgiv $ Jifvyev}$6:0$6464

Vsreph$E2$Fvego$

erh$Gsrxvsppiv

,tvmrgmtep$eggsyrxmrk$sjjmgiv- $ $

$ $ $

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 239 of 253

Page 262: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\16525

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=hi|6552lxq 535

I|lmfmx$6525

Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2$Wyfwmhmevmiw

Xli$jspps{mrk$mw$e$pmwx$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$wyfwmhmevmiw$ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=$,i|gitx$jsv$givxemr$wyfwmhmevmiw$xlex0$mr$xli$ekkvikexi0${syph$rsx$fi$e

Ôwmkrmjmgerx$wyfwmhmev}Õ$ew$hijmrih$mr$Vypi$5146$,{-$sj$Vikypexmsr$W1\-2$Yrpiww$sxliv{mwi$wxexih0$xli$Gsqter}$lsphw$hmvigxp}$sv$mrhmvigxp}$544)$sj$xli

wyfwmhmevmiw$pmwxih$fips{2

F2M2$Mrgsvtsvexih$,GS-

Gsvripp$Gsqtermiw0$Mrg2$,HI-

Gsvvigxmsrep$Wivzmgiw$Gsvtsvexmsr0$PPG$,HI-

GTX$Stivexmrk$Tevxrivwlmt$P2T2$,HI-

KIS$Gsvvigxmsrw$Lsphmrkw0$Mrg2$,JP-

KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw0$PPG$,JP-

[FT$Piewmrk0$PPG$,HI-

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 240 of 253

Page 263: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\16725

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=hi|6752lxq 535

I|lmfmx$6725

GSRWIRX$SJ$MRHITIRHIRX$VIKMWXIVIH$TYFPMG$EGGSYRXMRK$JMVQ

[i$lezi$mwwyih$syv$vitsvxw$hexih$Jifvyev}$6:0$64640${mxl$viwtigx$xs$xli$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$erh$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk

mrgpyhih$mr$xli$Erryep$Vitsvx$sj$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2$sr$Jsvq$541O$jsv$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=2$[i$gsrwirx$xs$xli$mrgsvtsvexmsr$f}

vijivirgi$sj$wemh$vitsvxw$mr$xli$Vikmwxvexmsr$Wxexiqirxw$sj$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2$sr$Jsvq$W17$,Jmpi$Rs2$7771665499-$erh$sr$Jsvqw$W1<$,Jmpi

Rs2$7771668<;50$Jmpi$Rs2$77715=:9480$Jmpi$Rs2$77715<55;90$Jmpi$Rs2$77715:=5=<0$erh$Jmpi$Rs2$77715869<=2

3w3$KVERX$XLSVRXSR$PPT$$$$

Qmeqm0$Jpsvmhe

Jifvyev}$6:0$6464

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 241 of 253

Page 264: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\17525

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=hi|7552lxq 535

I\LMFMX$7525

XLI$KIS$KVSYT0$MRG2

GIVXMJMGEXMSR$SJ$GLMIJ$I\IGYXMZI$SJJMGIV

M0$Kisvki$G2$^spi}0$givxmj}$xlex>$

52 M$lezi$vizmi{ih$xlmw$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O$sj$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2?$

62 Fewih$sr$q}$ors{pihki0$xlmw$vitsvx$hsiw$rsx$gsrxemr$er}$yrxvyi$wxexiqirx$sj$e$qexivmep$jegx$sv$sqmx$xs$wxexi$e$qexivmep$jegx$rigiwwev}$xs$qeoi$xli

wxexiqirxw$qehi0$mr$pmklx$sj$xli$gmvgyqwxergiw$yrhiv${lmgl$wygl$wxexiqirxw${ivi$qehi0$rsx$qmwpiehmrk${mxl$viwtigx$xs$xli$tivmsh$gszivih$f}$xlmw

vitsvx?$

72 Fewih$sr$q}$ors{pihki0$xli$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw0$erh$sxliv$jmrergmep$mrjsvqexmsr$mrgpyhih$mr$xlmw$vitsvx0$jemvp}$tviwirx$mr$epp$qexivmep$viwtigxw$xli

jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$erh$gewl$jps{w$sj$xli$vikmwxverx$ew$sj0$erh$jsv0$xli$tivmshw$tviwirxih$mr$xlmw$vitsvx?$

82 Xli$vikmwxverx×w$sxliv$givxmj}mrk$sjjmgiv$erh$M$evi$viwtsrwmfpi$jsv$iwxefpmwlmrk$erh$qemrxemrmrk$hmwgpswyvi$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw$,ew$hijmrih$mr

I|glerki$Egx$Vypiw$57e159,i-$erh$59h159,i--$erh$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$,ew$hijmrih$mr$I|glerki$Egx$Vypiw$57e159,j-$erh$59h1

59,j--$jsv$xli$vikmwxverx$erh$lezi>

,e-$Hiwmkrih$wygl$hmwgpswyvi$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw0$sv$geywih$wygl$hmwgpswyvi$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw$xs$fi$hiwmkrih$yrhiv$syv

wytivzmwmsr0$xs$irwyvi$xlex$qexivmep$mrjsvqexmsr$vipexmrk$xs$xli$vikmwxverx0$mrgpyhmrk$mxw$gsrwspmhexih$wyfwmhmevmiw0$mw$qehi$ors{r$xs$yw$f}

sxlivw${mxlmr$xlswi$irxmxmiw0$tevxmgypevp}$hyvmrk$xli$tivmsh$mr${lmgl$xlmw$vitsvx$mw$fimrk$tvitevih?

,f-$Hiwmkrih$wygl$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk0$sv$geywih$wygl$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$xs$fi$hiwmkrih$yrhiv

syv$wytivzmwmsr0$xs$tvszmhi$viewsrefpi$ewwyvergi$vikevhmrk$xli$vipmefmpmx}$sj$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$erh$xli$tvitevexmsr$sj$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw

jsv$i|xivrep$tyvtswiw$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$kirivepp}$eggitxih$eggsyrxmrk$tvmrgmtpiw?

,g-$Izepyexih$xli$ijjigxmziriww$sj$xli$vikmwxverx×w$hmwgpswyvi$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw$erh$tviwirxih$mr$xlmw$vitsvx$syv$gsrgpywmsrw$efsyx$xli

ijjigxmziriww$sj$xli$hmwgpswyvi$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw0$ew$sj$xli$irh$sj$xli$tivmsh$gszivih$f}$xlmw$vitsvx$fewih$sr$wygl$izepyexmsr?$erh

,h-$Hmwgpswih$mr$xlmw$vitsvx$er}$glerki$mr$xli$vikmwxverx×w$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$xlex$sggyvvih$hyvmrk$xli$vikmwxverx×w$qswx

vigirx$jmwgep$uyevxiv$,xli$vikmwxverx×w$jsyvxl$jmwgep$uyevxiv$mr$xli$gewi$sj$er$erryep$vitsvx-$xlex$lew$qexivmepp}$ejjigxih0$sv$mw$viewsrefp}$pmoip}

xs$qexivmepp}$ejjigx0$xli$vikmwxverx×w$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk?$erh$

92 Xli$vikmwxverx×w$sxliv$givxmj}mrk$sjjmgiv$erh$M$lezi$hmwgpswih0$fewih$sr$syv$qswx$vigirx$izepyexmsr$sj$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk0$xs$xli

vikmwxverx×w$eyhmxsvw$erh$xli$eyhmx$gsqqmxxii$sj$xli$vikmwxverx×w$fsevh$sj$hmvigxsvw$,sv$tivwsrw$tivjsvqmrk$xli$iuymzepirx$jyrgxmsrw->

,e-$Epp$wmkrmjmgerx$hijmgmirgmiw$erh$qexivmep${ieoriwwiw$mr$xli$hiwmkr$sv$stivexmsr$sj$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk${lmgl$evi

viewsrefp}$pmoip}$xs$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$xli$vikmwxverx×w$efmpmx}$xs$vigsvh0$tvsgiww0$wyqqevm~i$erh$vitsvx$jmrergmep$mrjsvqexmsr?$erh

,f-$Er}$jveyh0${lixliv$sv$rsx$qexivmep0$xlex$mrzspziw$qerekiqirx$sv$sxliv$iqtps}iiw${ls$lezi$e$wmkrmjmgerx$vspi$mr$xli$vikmwxverx×w

mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk2

$Hexi>$Jifvyev}$6:0$6464 $ $ $ 3w3$Kisvki$G2$^spi}

$ $ $$$$ $ Kisvki$G2$^spi}

$ $ $ Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 242 of 253

Page 265: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\17526

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=hi|7562lxq 535

I\LMFMX$7526

XLI$KIS$KVSYT0$MRG2

GIVXMJMGEXMSR$SJ$GLMIJ$JMRERGMEP$SJJMGIV

M0$Fvmer$V2$Izerw0$givxmj}$xlex>$

52 M$lezi$vizmi{ih$xlmw$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O$sj$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2?$

62 Fewih$sr$q}$ors{pihki0$xlmw$vitsvx$hsiw$rsx$gsrxemr$er}$yrxvyi$wxexiqirx$sj$e$qexivmep$jegx$sv$sqmx$xs$wxexi$e$qexivmep$jegx$rigiwwev}$xs$qeoi$xli

wxexiqirxw$qehi0$mr$pmklx$sj$xli$gmvgyqwxergiw$yrhiv${lmgl$wygl$wxexiqirxw${ivi$qehi0$rsx$qmwpiehmrk${mxl$viwtigx$xs$xli$tivmsh$gszivih$f}$xlmw

vitsvx?$

72 Fewih$sr$q}$ors{pihki0$xli$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw0$erh$sxliv$jmrergmep$mrjsvqexmsr$mrgpyhih$mr$xlmw$vitsvx0$jemvp}$tviwirx$mr$epp$qexivmep$viwtigxw$xli

jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$erh$gewl$jps{w$sj$xli$vikmwxverx$ew$sj0$erh$jsv0$xli$tivmshw$tviwirxih$mr$xlmw$vitsvx?$

82 Xli$vikmwxverx×w$sxliv$givxmj}mrk$sjjmgiv$erh$M$evi$viwtsrwmfpi$jsv$iwxefpmwlmrk$erh$qemrxemrmrk$hmwgpswyvi$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw$,ew$hijmrih$mr

I|glerki$Egx$Vypiw$57e159,i-$erh$59h159,i--$erh$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$,ew$hijmrih$mr$I|glerki$Egx$Vypiw$57e159,j-$erh

59h159,j--$jsv$xli$vikmwxverx$erh$lezi>$

$

,e- Hiwmkrih$wygl$hmwgpswyvi$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw0$sv$geywih$wygl$hmwgpswyvi$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw$xs$fi$hiwmkrih$yrhiv$syv$wytivzmwmsr0

xs$irwyvi$xlex$qexivmep$mrjsvqexmsr$vipexmrk$xs$xli$vikmwxverx0$mrgpyhmrk$mxw$gsrwspmhexih$wyfwmhmevmiw0$mw$qehi$ors{r$xs$yw$f}$sxlivw${mxlmr

xlswi$irxmxmiw0$tevxmgypevp}$hyvmrk$xli$tivmsh$mr${lmgl$xlmw$vitsvx$mw$fimrk$tvitevih?$

$

,f- Hiwmkrih$wygl$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk0$sv$geywih$wygl$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$xs$fi$hiwmkrih$yrhiv$syv

wytivzmwmsr0$xs$tvszmhi$viewsrefpi$ewwyvergi$vikevhmrk$xli$vipmefmpmx}$sj$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$erh$xli$tvitevexmsr$sj$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$jsv

i|xivrep$tyvtswiw$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$kirivepp}$eggitxih$eggsyrxmrk$tvmrgmtpiw?$

$,g- Izepyexih$xli$ijjigxmziriww$sj$xli$vikmwxverx×w$hmwgpswyvi$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw$erh$tviwirxih$mr$xlmw$vitsvx$syv$gsrgpywmsrw$efsyx$xli

ijjigxmziriww$sj$xli$hmwgpswyvi$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw0$ew$sj$xli$irh$sj$xli$tivmsh$gszivih$f}$xlmw$vitsvx$fewih$sr$wygl$izepyexmsr?$erh$

$

,h- Hmwgpswih$mr$xlmw$vitsvx$er}$glerki$mr$xli$vikmwxverx×w$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$xlex$sggyvvih$hyvmrk$xli$vikmwxverx×w$qswx

vigirx$jmwgep$uyevxiv$,xli$vikmwxverx×w$jsyvxl$jmwgep$uyevxiv$mr$xli$gewi$sj$er$erryep$vitsvx-$xlex$lew$qexivmepp}$ejjigxih0$sv$mw$viewsrefp}$pmoip}

xs$qexivmepp}$ejjigx0$xli$vikmwxverx×w$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk?$erh$

92 Xli$vikmwxverx×w$sxliv$givxmj}mrk$sjjmgiv$erh$M$lezi$hmwgpswih0$fewih$sr$syv$qswx$vigirx$izepyexmsr$sj$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk0$xs$xli

vikmwxverx×w$eyhmxsvw$erh$xli$eyhmx$gsqqmxxii$sj$xli$vikmwxverx×w$fsevh$sj$hmvigxsvw$,sv$tivwsrw$tivjsvqmrk$xli$iuymzepirx$jyrgxmsrw->$

$,e- Epp$wmkrmjmgerx$hijmgmirgmiw$erh$qexivmep${ieoriwwiw$mr$xli$hiwmkr$sv$stivexmsr$sj$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk${lmgl$evi

viewsrefp}$pmoip}$xs$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$xli$vikmwxverx×w$efmpmx}$xs$vigsvh0$tvsgiww0$wyqqevm~i$erh$vitsvx$jmrergmep$mrjsvqexmsr?$erh$

$,f- Er}$jveyh0${lixliv$sv$rsx$qexivmep0$xlex$mrzspziw$qerekiqirx$sv$sxliv$iqtps}iiw${ls$lezi$e$wmkrmjmgerx$vspi$mr$xli$vikmwxverx×w$mrxivrep

gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk2

Hexi>$Jifvyev}$6:0$6464 $ $ $ 3w3$Fvmer$V2$Izerw

$ $ $ Fvmer$V2$Izerw

$ $ $ Glmij$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 243 of 253

Page 266: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\17625

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=hi|7652lxq 535

I|lmfmx$7625

GIVXMJMGEXMSR$TYVWYERX$XS

5<$Y2W2G2$WIGXMSR$57940

EW$EHSTXIH$TYVWYERX$XS

WIGXMSR$=4:$SJ$XLI$WEVFERIW1S\PI]$EGX$SJ$6446

Mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O$sj$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2$,xli$ÔGsqter}Õ-$jsv$xli$tivmsh$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=

ew$jmpih${mxl$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$erh$I|glerki$Gsqqmwwmsr$sr$xli$hexi$livisj$,xli$ÔVitsvxÕ-0$M0$Kisvki$G2$^spi}0$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$sj$xli$Gsqter}0

livif}$givxmj}0$tyvwyerx$xs$5<$Y2W2G2$Wigxmsr$57940$ew$ehstxih$tyvwyerx$xs$Wigxmsr$=4:$sj$xli$Wevferiw1S|pi}$Egx$sj$6446$xlex>$

$ ,5- xli$Vitsvx$jypp}$gsqtpmiw${mxl$xli$viuymviqirxw$sj$Wigxmsr$57,e-$sv$59,h-$sj$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$I|glerki$Egx$sj$5=780$ew$eqirhih?$erh$

$,6- xli$mrjsvqexmsr$gsrxemrih$mr$xli$Vitsvx$jemvp}$tviwirxw0$mr$epp$qexivmep$viwtigxw0$xli$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$sj$xli

Gsqter}2

3w3$Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv

Hexi>$Jifvyev}$6:0$6464

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 244 of 253

Page 267: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\17626

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=hi|7662lxq 535

I|lmfmx$7626

GIVXMJMGEXMSR$TYVWYERX$XS

5<$Y2W2G2$WIGXMSR$57940

EW$EHSTXIH$TYVWYERX$XS

WIGXMSR$=4:$SJ$XLI$WEVFERIW1S\PI]$EGX$SJ$6446

Mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O$sj$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2$,xli$ÔGsqter}Õ-$jsv$xli$tivmsh$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=

ew$jmpih${mxl$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$erh$I|glerki$Gsqqmwwmsr$sr$xli$hexi$livisj$,xli$ÔVitsvxÕ-0$M0$Fvmer$V2$Izerw0$Glmij$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv$sj$xli$Gsqter}0

livif}$givxmj}0$tyvwyerx$xs$5<$Y2W2G2$Wigxmsr$57940$ew$ehstxih$tyvwyerx$xs$Wigxmsr$=4:$sj$xli$Wevferiw1S|pi}$Egx$sj$6446$xlex>$

$ ,5- xli$Vitsvx$jypp}$gsqtpmiw${mxl$xli$viuymviqirxw$sj$Wigxmsr$57,e-$sv$59,h-$sj$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$I|glerki$Egx$sj$5=780$ew$eqirhih?$erh$

$,6- xli$mrjsvqexmsr$gsrxemrih$mr$xli$Vitsvx$jemvp}$tviwirxw0$mr$epp$qexivmep$viwtigxw0$xli$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$sj$xli

Gsqter}2

3w3$Fvmer$V2$Izerw

Fvmer$V2$Izerw

Glmij$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv

Hexi>$Jifvyev}$6:0$6464

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 245 of 253

Page 268: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\18258

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=hi|8582lxq 53<

I|lmfmx$8258

HIWGVMTXMSR$SJ$XLI$VIKMWXVERX×W$WIGYVMXMIW

VIKMWXIVIH$TYVWYERX$XS$WIGXMSR$56

SJ$XLI$WIGYVMXMIW$I\GLERKI$EGX$SJ$5=780$EW$EQIRHIH

Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2$,xli$ÔGsqter}0Õ$ÔKIS0Õ$Ô{i0Õ$Ôyw0Õ$sv$ÔsyvÕ-$leh$sri$gpeww$sj$wigyvmxmiw$vikmwxivih$yrhiv

Wigxmsr$56$sj$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$I|glerki$Egx$sj$5=780$ew$eqirhih>$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo2

Xli$jspps{mrk$mw$e$hiwgvmtxmsr$sj$xli$qexivmep$xivqw$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo$erh$yrhiwmkrexih$tvijivvih$wxsgo$ew$wix$jsvxl$mr$syv$Eqirhih$erh

Viwxexih$Evxmgpiw$sj$Mrgsvtsvexmsr0$ew$eqirhih$,xli$ÔEqirhih$EvxmgpiwÕ-$erh$syv$Wigsrh$Eqirhih$erh$Viwxexih$F}pe{w0$ew$eqirhih$,xli$ÔEqirhih

F}pe{wÕ-0${lmgl$kszivr$xli$vmklxw$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo2$Xlmw$hiwgvmtxmsr$mw$srp}$e$wyqqev}2$]sy$wlsyph$vieh$mx$xskixliv${mxl$xli$Eqirhih$Evxmgpiw$erh

Eqirhih$F}pe{w0${lmgl$evi$mrgpyhih$ew$i|lmfmxw$xs$xli$Gsqter}×w$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O$jsv$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh

mrgsvtsvexih$f}$vijivirgi$livimr2

Eyxlsvm~ih$Getmxep

Xli$Eqirhih$Evxmgpiw$eyxlsvm~i$KIS$xs$mwwyi$yt$xs$65;09440444$wleviw$sj$getmxep$wxsgo0$gsrwmwxmrk$sj$5<;09440444$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo0$tev

zepyi$(4245$tiv$wlevi0$erh$7404440444$wleviw$sj$tvijivvih$wxsgo0$tev$zepyi$(4245$tiv$wlevi2

Gsqqsr$Wxsgo

Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$5650669075=$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo${ivi$mwwyih$erh$syxwxerhmrk22

Zsxmrk$Vmklxw2$[mxl$viwtigx$xs$epp$qexxivw$ytsr${lmgl$wlevilsphivw$evi$irxmxpih$xs$zsxi0$xli$lsphivw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$evi$irxmxpih$xs$sri$zsxi$mr

tivwsr$sv$f}$tvs|}$jsv$iegl$wlevi$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$syxwxerhmrk$mr$xli$reqi$sj$wygl$wlevilsphivw$sr$xli$vigsvh$sj$wlevilsphivw2$Kirivepp}0$epp$qexxivw$xs

fi$zsxih$sr$f}$wlevilsphivw$qywx$fi$ettvszih$f}$e$qensvmx}$,sv$f}$e$tpyvepmx}$mr$xli$gewi$sj$ipigxmsr$sj$hmvigxsvw${livi$xli$ryqfiv$sj$gerhmhexiw

rsqmrexih$jsv$ipigxmsr$i|giihw$xli$ryqfiv$sj$hmvigxsvw$xs$fi$ipigxih-$sj$xli$zsxiw$irxmxpih$xs$fi$gewx$f}$epp$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$tviwirx$mr$tivwsr$sv

f}$tvs|}2

Hmzmhirhw2$Wyfnigx$xs$ettpmgefpi$pe{$erh$vmklxw0$mj$er}0$sj$xli$lsphivw$sj$er}$syxwxerhmrk$wivmiw$sj$tvijivvih$wxsgo$sv$er}$gpeww$sv$wivmiw$sj$wxsgo

lezmrk$e$tvijivirgi$sziv$gsqqsr$wxsgo${mxl$viwtigx$xs$xli$te}qirx$sj$hmzmhirhw0$hmzmhirhw$qe}$fi$higpevih$erh$temh$sr$xli$gsqqsr$wxsgo$jvsq$xmqi

xs$xmqi$erh$mr$eqsyrxw$ew$xli$fsevh$sj$hmvigxsvw$qe}$hixivqmri2$[i$gsqqirgih$higpevmrk$vikypev$uyevxivp}$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$fikmrrmrk$xli$jmvwx$uyevxiv$sj

64572$Xli$eqsyrx0$xmqmrk$erh$jviuyirg}$sj$hmzmhirhw0$ls{iziv${mpp$fi$ex$xli$wspi$hmwgvixmsr$sj$xli$fsevh$sj$hmvigxsvw$fewih$ytsr$zevmsyw$jegxsvw2$

5

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 246 of 253

Page 269: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\18258

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=hi|8582lxq 63<

Pmuymhexmsr$Vmklxw2$Ytsr$xli$pmuymhexmsr0$hmwwspyxmsr$sv${mrhmrk$yt$sj$KIS0${lixliv$zspyrxev}$sv$mrzspyrxev}0$xli$lsphivw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo${mpp

fi$irxmxpih$xs$wlevi$vexefp}$mr$epp$ewwixw$ezempefpi$jsv$hmwxvmfyxmsr$ejxiv$te}qirx$mr$jypp$xs$gvihmxsvw$erh$te}qirx$mr$jypp$xs$lsphivw$sj$tvijivvih$wxsgo$xlir

syxwxerhmrk$sj$er}$eqsyrx$viuymvih$xs$fi$temh$xs$xliq2$Rimxliv$xli$qivkiv0$gsrwspmhexmsr$sv$fywmriww$gsqfmrexmsr$sj$KIS${mxl$sv$mrxs$er}$sxliv$irxmx}

mr${lmgl$syv$wlevilsphivw$vigimzi$getmxep$wxsgo$erh3sv$sxliv$wigyvmxmiw$,mrgpyhmrk$hifx$wigyvmxmiw-$sj$xli$wyvzmzmrk$irxmx}$,sv$xli$hmvigx$sv$mrhmvigx$tevirx

irxmx}$xlivisj-0$rsv$xli$wepi0$piewi$sv$xverwjiv$f}$yw$sj$er}$tevx$sj$syv$fywmriww$erh$ewwixw0$rsv$xli$vihygxmsr$sj$syv$getmxep$wxsgo0${mpp$fi$hiiqih$xs$fi$e

zspyrxev}$sv$mrzspyrxev}$pmuymhexmsr0$hmwwspyxmsr$sv${mrhmrk$yt2

Sxliv$Tvszmwmsrw2$Xli$lsphivw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$lezi$rs$tviiqtxmzi0$wyfwgvmtxmsr$sv$vihiqtxmsr$vmklxw$erh$evi$rsx$irxmxpih$xs$xli$firijmx$sj$er}

wmromrk$jyrh2

KIS$mw$rsx$tivqmxxih$xs$wyfhmzmhi0$gsqfmri0$sv$te}$sv$higpevi$er}$wxsgo$hmzmhirh$sr0$xli$syxwxerhmrk$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$yrpiww$epp

syxwxerhmrk$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$evi$wyfhmzmhih$sv$gsqfmrih$sv$xli$lsphivw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$vigimzi$e$tvstsvxmsrexi$hmzmhirh2

Tvijivvih$Wxsgo

Tyvwyerx$xs$xli$Eqirhih$Evxmgpiw0$xli$fsevh$sj$hmvigxsvw$mw$iqts{ivih0${mxlsyx$er}$ettvszep$sj$syv$wlevilsphivw0$xs$mwwyi$wleviw$sj$tvijivvih

wxsgo$mr$sri$sv$qsvi$wivmiw0$xs$iwxefpmwl$xli$ryqfiv$sj$wleviw$mr$iegl$wivmiw0$erh$xs$jm|$xli$vipexmzi$vmklxw0$tvijivirgiw0$ts{ivw0$uyepmjmgexmsrw0$pmqmxexmsrw

erh$viwxvmgxmsrw$sj$iegl$wygl$wivmiw2$Xli$wtigmjmg$qexxivw$xlex$qe}$fi$hixivqmrih$f}$xli$fsevh$sj$hmvigxsvw$mrgpyhi>$

$

¨ $ {lixliv$xli$wleviw$sj$xli$wivmiw$evi$vihiiqefpi0$erh$mj$ws0$xli$tvmgiw$ex${lmgl0$erh$xli$xivqw$erh$gsrhmxmsrw$sr${lmgl0$xli$wleviw$qe}$fi

vihiiqih0$mrgpyhmrk$xli$hexi$sv$hexiw$ytsr$sv$ejxiv${lmgl$xli$wleviw$wlepp$fi$vihiiqefpi$erh$xli$eqsyrx$tiv$wlevi$te}efpi$mr$gewi$sj

vihiqtxmsr?$

$

¨ $ {lixliv$wleviw$sj$xli$wivmiw${mpp$fi$irxmxpih$xs$vigimzi$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$erh0$mj$ws0$xli$hmwxvmfyxmsr$vexi$sr$xli$wleviw0$er}$viwxvmgxmsr0$pmqmxexmsr

sv$gsrhmxmsr$ytsr$xli$te}qirx$sj$xli$hmwxvmfyxmsrw0${lixliv$hmwxvmfyxmsrw${mpp$fi$gyqypexmzi0$erh$xli$hexiw$sr${lmgl$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$evi

te}efpi?$

$¨ $ er}$tvijivirxmep$eqsyrx$te}efpi$ytsr$wleviw$sj$xli$wivmiw$mr$xli$izirx$sj$zspyrxev}$sv$mrzspyrxev}$pmuymhexmsr0$hmwwspyxmsr$sv${mrhmrk$yt$sj

KIS?$

$

¨ $ {lixliv$xli$wleviw$sj$xli$wivmiw$evi$gsrzivxmfpi0$sv$i|glerkiefpi$jsv0$wleviw$sj$er}$sxliv$gpeww$sv$gpewwiw$sj$wxsgo$sv$sj$er}$sxliv$wivmiw$sj

wxsgo0$sv$er}$sxliv$wigyvmxmiw$sj$KIS0$erh$mj$ws0$xli$xivqw$erh$gsrhmxmsrw$sj$wygl$gsrzivwmsr$sv$i|glerki0$mrgpyhmrk$tvmgi$sv$vexiw$sj

gsrzivwmsr$ex${lmgl0$erh$xli$xivqw$erh$gsrhmxmsrw$sr${lmgl0$xli$wleviw$sj$xli$wivmiw$qe}$fi$gsrzivxih$sv$i|glerkih$mrxs$sxliv$wigyvmxmiw?$

$ ¨ $ xivqw$erh$gsrhmxmsrw$sj$vixmviqirx$sv$wmromrk$jyrh$tvszmwmsrw0$mj$er}0$jsv$xli$tyvglewi$sv$vihiqtxmsr$sj$wleviw$sj$xli$wivmiw?$

$ ¨ $ xli$hmwxmrgxmzi$hiwmkrexmsr$sj$iegl$wivmiw$erh$xli$ryqfiv$sj$wleviw$xlex${mpp$gsrwxmxyxi$xli$wivmiw?$

$ ¨ $ xli$zsxmrk$ts{iv0$mj$er}0$sj$wleviw$sj$xli$wivmiw?$erh$

$ ¨ $ er}$sxliv$vipexmzi$vmklxw0$tvijivirgiw$sv$pmqmxexmsrw2$

6

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 247 of 253

Page 270: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\18258

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=hi|8582lxq 73<

Gyvvirxp}0$xlivi$evi$rs$wleviw$sj$tvijivvih$wxsgo$mwwyih$erh$syxwxerhmrk2

Figeywi$xli$fsevh$sj$hmvigxsvw${mpp$lezi$xli$ts{iv$xs$iwxefpmwl$xli$tvijivirgiw$erh$vmklxw$sj$iegl$wivmiw$sj$tvijivvih$wxsgo0$mx$qe}$ejjsvh$xli

wlevilsphivw$sj$er}$wivmiw$sj$tvijivvih$wxsgo$tvijivirgiw0$ts{ivw$erh$vmklxw$wirmsv$xs$xli$vmklxw$sj$lsphivw$sj$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo${lmgl$gsyph$lezi

xli$ijjigx$sj$hipe}mrk0$hijivvmrk$sv$tvizirxmrk$e$glerki$mr$gsrxvsp$sj$KIS2

Viwxvmgxmsrw$sr$S{rivwlmt$erh$Xverwjiv

Xs$jegmpmxexi$gsqtpmergi${mxl$xli$viep$iwxexi$mrziwxqirx$xvywx$,ÔVIMXÕ-$vypiw$mr$xli$Mrxivrep$Viziryi$Gshi$sj$5=<:0$ew$eqirhih$,xli$ÔGshiÕ-0$xli

Eqirhih$Evxmgpiw$gsrxemr$wxerhevh$VIMX$viwxvmgxmsrw$sr$wxsgo$s{rivwlmt$erh$wxsgo$xverwjivw2

Epp$givxmjmgexiw$vitviwirxmrk$wleviw$sj$getmxep$wxsgo0$mj$er}0${mpp$fiev$pikirhw$hiwgvmfmrk$xli$s{rivwlmt$erh$xverwjiv$viwxvmgxmsrw2$Jyvxliv0$xliwi

s{rivwlmt$erh$xverwjiv$viwxvmgxmsrw$gsyph$hipe}0$hijiv$sv$tvizirx$e$xverwegxmsr$sv$e$glerki$mr$gsrxvsp$xlex$qmklx$mrzspzi$e$tviqmyq$tvmgi$jsv$xli$gsqqsr

wxsgo$sv$sxliv{mwi$fi$mr$xli$fiwx$mrxiviwx$sj$xli$wlevilsphivw2

Jsv$yw$xs$uyepmj}$ew$e$VIMX$yrhiv$xli$Gshi0$KIS$wxsgo$qywx$fi$firijmgmepp}$s{rih$f}$544$sv$qsvi$tivwsrw$hyvmrk$ex$piewx$779$he}w$sj$e$xe|efpi

}iev$sj$56$qsrxlw$sv$hyvmrk$e$tvstsvxmsrexi$tevx$sj$e$wlsvxiv$xe|efpi$}iev$,sxliv$xler$xli$jmvwx$}iev$jsv${lmgl$er$ipigxmsr$xs$fi$e$VIMX$lew$fiir$qehi-2

Epws0$rsx$qsvi$xler$94)$sj$xli$zepyi$sj$xli$syxwxerhmrk$wleviw$sj$KIS$wxsgo$qe}$fi$s{rih0$hmvigxp}$sv$mrhmvigxp}0$f}$jmzi$sv$ji{iv$ÔmrhmzmhyepwÕ$,ew

hijmrih$mr$xli$Gshi$xs$mrgpyhi$givxemr$irxmxmiw$wygl$ew$tvmzexi$jsyrhexmsrw-$hyvmrk$xli$pewx$lepj$sj$e$xe|efpi$}iev$,sxliv$xler$xli$jmvwx$xe|efpi$}iev$jsv

{lmgl$er$ipigxmsr$xs$fi$e$VIMX$lew$fiir$qehi-2$Xs$wexmwj}$xliwi$s{rivwlmt$viuymviqirxw$erh$sxliv$viuymviqirxw$jsv$gsrxmryih$uyepmjmgexmsr$ew$e$VIMX

erh$xs$sxliv{mwi$tvsxigx$yw$jvsq$xli$gsrwiuyirgiw$sj$e$gsrgirxvexmsr$sj$s{rivwlmt$eqsrk$KIS×w$wlevilsphivw0$xli$Eqirhih$Evxmgpiw$gsrxemr

tvszmwmsrw$viwxvmgxmrk$xli$s{rivwlmt$sv$xverwjiv$sj$wleviw$sj$KIS$wxsgo2

Xli$vipizerx$wigxmsrw$sj$xli$Eqirhih$Evxmgpiw$tvszmhi$xlex0$wyfnigx$xs$xli$i|gitxmsrw$erh$xli$gsrwxvygxmzi$s{rivwlmt$vypiw$hiwgvmfih$fips{0$rs

tivwsr$,ew$hijmrih$mr$xli$Eqirhih$Evxmgpiw-$qe}$firijmgmepp}$sv$gsrwxvygxmzip}$s{r$qsvi$xler$=2<)$mr$zepyi$sj$xli$ekkvikexi$sj$KIS×w$syxwxerhmrk

wleviw$sj$wxsgo0$mrgpyhmrk$KIS×w$gsqqsr$wxsgo$erh$tvijivvih$wxsgo0$sv$qsvi$xler$=2<)$mr$zepyi$sv$mr$ryqfiv$sj$wleviw$,{lmgliziv$mw$qsvi$viwxvmgxmzi-

sj$er}$gpeww$sv$wivmiw$sj$syxwxerhmrk$KIS$wxsgo2$[i$vijiv$xs$xliwi$viwxvmgxmsrw$ew$xli$Ôs{rivwlmt$pmqmxw2Õ

Xli$ettpmgefpi$gsrwxvygxmzi$s{rivwlmt$vypiw$yrhiv$xli$Gshi$evi$gsqtpi|$erh$qe}$geywi$wxsgo$s{rih$egxyepp}$sv$gsrwxvygxmzip}$f}$e$kvsyt$sj

vipexih$mrhmzmhyepw$erh3sv$irxmxmiw$xs$fi$xviexih$ew$s{rih$f}$sri$mrhmzmhyep$sv$irxmx}2$Ew$e$viwypx0$xli$eguymwmxmsr$sj$piww$xler$=2<)$mr$zepyi$sv$ryqfiv$sj

wleviw$sj$KIS×w$syxwxerhmrk$wxsgo$sv$er}$gpeww$sv$wivmiw$sj$KIS$getmxep$wxsgo$,mrgpyhmrk$xlvsykl$xli$eguymwmxmsr$sj$er$mrxiviwx$mr$er$irxmx}$xlex$s{rw0

egxyepp}$sv$gsrwxvygxmzip}0$er}$gpeww$sv$wivmiw$sj$KIS$wxsgo-$f}$er$mrhmzmhyep$sv$irxmx}$gsyph$rizivxlipiww$geywi$xlex$mrhmzmhyep$sv$irxmx}0$sv$ersxliv

mrhmzmhyep$sv$irxmx}0$xs$s{r0$gsrwxvygxmzip}$sv$firijmgmepp}0$mr$i|giww$sj$=2<)$mr$zepyi$sv$ryqfiv$sj$wleviw$sj$KIS×w$syxwxerhmrk$wxsgo$sv$er}$gpeww$sv

wivmiw$sj$KIS$getmxep$wxsgo2$

7

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 248 of 253

Page 271: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\18258

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=hi|8582lxq 83<

Mr$ehhmxmsr$xs$xli$s{rivwlmt$pmqmxw0$xli$Eqirhih$Evxmgpiw$tvslmfmx$er}$tivwsr$jvsq$egxyepp}$sv$gsrwxvygxmzip}$s{rmrk$wleviw$sj$KIS$wxsgo$xs$xli

i|xirx$xlex$wygl$s{rivwlmt${syph$geywi$er}$sj$syv$mrgsqi$xlex${syph$sxliv{mwi$uyepmj}$ew$Ôvirxw$jvsq$viep$tvstivx}Õ$jsv$tyvtswiw$sj$Wigxmsr$<9:,h-$sj

xli$Gshi$xs$jemp$xs$uyepmj}$ew$wygl2

KIS×w$fsevh$sj$hmvigxsvw$qe}0$mr$mxw$wspi$hmwgvixmsr0$i|iqtx$e$tivwsr$jvsq$xli$s{rivwlmt$pmqmxw$erh$givxemr$sxliv$pmqmxw$sr$s{rivwlmt$erh$xverwjiv

sj$KIS$wxsgo$hiwgvmfih$efszi0$erh$qe}$iwxefpmwl$e$hmjjivirx$pmqmx$sr$s{rivwlmt$jsv$er}$wygl$tivwsr2$Ls{iziv0$xli$fsevh$sj$hmvigxsvw$qe}$rsx$i|iqtx

er}$tivwsr${lswi$s{rivwlmt$sj$syxwxerhmrk$wxsgo$mr$zmspexmsr$sj$xliwi$pmqmxw${syph$viwypx$mr$syv$jempmrk$xs$uyepmj}$ew$e$VIMX2$Mr$svhiv$xs$fi$gsrwmhivih

f}$xli$fsevh$sj$hmvigxsvw$jsv$i|iqtxmsr$sv$e$hmjjivirx$pmqmx$sr$s{rivwlmt0$e$tivwsr$qywx$qeoi$wygl$vitviwirxexmsrw$erh$yrhivxeomrkw$ew$evi$viewsrefp}

rigiwwev}$xs$ewgivxemr$xlex$wygl$tivwsr×w$firijmgmep$sv$gsrwxvygxmzi$s{rivwlmt$sj$KIS$wxsgo${mpp$rsx$rs{$sv$mr$xli$jyxyvi$nistevhm~i$syv$efmpmx}$xs$uyepmj}

ew$e$VIMX$yrhiv$xli$Gshi$erh$qywx$ekvii$xlex$er}$zmspexmsr$sv$exxiqtxih$zmspexmsr$sj$wygl$vitviwirxexmsrw$sv$yrhivxeomrkw$,sv$sxliv$egxmsr$xlex$mw

gsrxvev}$xs$xli$s{rivwlmt$pmqmxw$erh$givxemr$sxliv$VIMX$pmqmxw$sr$s{rivwlmt$erh$xverwjiv$sj$KIS$wxsgo$hiwgvmfih$efszi-${mpp$viwypx$mr$xli$wleviw$sj$wxsgo

fimrk$eyxsqexmgepp}$xverwjivvih$xs$e$xvywx$ew$hiwgvmfih$fips{2$Ew$e$gsrhmxmsr$sj$mxw${emziv0$xli$fsevh$sj$hmvigxsvw$qe}$viuymvi$er$stmrmsr$sj$gsyrwip$sv

Mrxivrep$Viziryi$Wivzmgi$,ÔMVWÕ-$vypmrk$wexmwjegxsv}$xs$xli$fsevh$sj$hmvigxsvw${mxl$viwtigx$xs$syv$uyepmjmgexmsr$ew$e$VIMX$erh$qe}$mqtswi$wygl$sxliv

gsrhmxmsrw$ew$mx$hiiqw$ettvstvmexi$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$kverxmrk$sj$xli$i|iqtxmsr$sv$e$hmjjivirx$pmqmx$sr$s{rivwlmt2

Mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli${emziv$sj$xli$s{rivwlmt$pmqmxw$sv$ex$er}$sxliv$xmqi0$xli$fsevh$sj$hmvigxsvw$qe}$jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi$mrgviewi$xli$s{rivwlmt

pmqmxw$jsv$sri$sv$qsvi$tivwsrw$erh$higviewi$xli$s{rivwlmt$pmqmxw$jsv$epp$sxliv$tivwsrw?$tvszmhih$xlex$xli$ri{$s{rivwlmt$pmqmxw$qe}$rsx0$ejxiv$kmzmrk

ijjigx$xs$wygl$mrgviewi$erh$yrhiv$givxemr$ewwyqtxmsrw$wxexih$mr$xli$Eqirhih$Evxmgpiw0$viwypx$mr$yw$fimrk$Ôgpswip}$liphÕ${mxlmr$xli$qiermrk$sj

Wigxmsr$<9:,l-$sj$xli$Gshi$,{mxlsyx$vikevh$xs${lixliv$xli$s{rivwlmt$mrxiviwxw$evi$liph$hyvmrk$xli$pewx$lepj$sj$e$xe|efpi$}iev-2$Vihygih$s{rivwlmt$pmqmxw

{mpp$rsx$ettp}$xs$er}$tivwsr${lswi$tivgirxeki$s{rivwlmt$sj$KIS×w$xsxep$wleviw$sj$wxsgo$sv$sj$xli$wleviw$sj$e$gpeww$sv$wivmiw$sj$KIS$wxsgo0$ew$ettpmgefpi0

mw$mr$i|giww$sj$wygl$higviewih$s{rivwlmt$pmqmxw$yrxmp$wygl$xmqi$ew$wygl$tivwsr×w$tivgirxeki$sj$xsxep$wleviw$sj$wxsgo$sv$sj$xli$wleviw$sj$e$gpeww$sv$wivmiw$sj

wxsgo0$ew$ettpmgefpi0$iuyepw$sv$jeppw$fips{$xli$higviewih$s{rivwlmt$pmqmxw0$fyx$er}$jyvxliv$eguymwmxmsr$sj$KIS×w$wleviw$sj$wxsgo$sv$sj$xli$wleviw$sj$e$gpeww

sv$wivmiw$sj$KIS$wxsgo0$ew$ettpmgefpi0$mr$i|giww$sj$wygl$tivgirxeki$s{rivwlmt$sj$wleviw$sj$wxsgo$sv$sj$e$gpeww$sv$wivmiw$sj$wxsgo${mpp$fi$mr$zmspexmsr$sj$xli

s{rivwlmt$pmqmxw2

Xli$Eqirhih$Evxmgpiw$jyvxliv$tvslmfmx>$

$¨ $ er}$tivwsr$jvsq$xverwjivvmrk$wleviw$sj$KIS$wxsgo$mj$wygl$xverwjiv${syph$viwypx$mr$wleviw$sj$KIS$wxsgo$fimrk$firijmgmepp}$s{rih$f}$ji{iv

xler$544$tivwsrw$,hixivqmrih${mxlsyx$vijivirgi$xs$er}$vypiw$sj$exxvmfyxmsr-?$erh$

$¨ $ er}$tivwsr$jvsq$firijmgmepp}$sv$gsrwxvygxmzip}$s{rmrk$wleviw$sj$KIS$wxsgo$mj$wygl$s{rivwlmt${syph$viwypx$mr$syv$jempmrk$xs$uyepmj}$ew$e

VIMX2$

8

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 249 of 253

Page 272: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\18258

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=hi|8582lxq 93<

Xli$jsviksmrk$tvszmwmsrw$sr$xverwjivefmpmx}$erh$s{rivwlmt${mpp$rsx$ettp}$mj$xli$fsevh$sj$hmvigxsvw$hixivqmriw$xlex$mx$mw$rs$psrkiv$mr$syv$fiwx

mrxiviwxw$xs$exxiqtx$xs$uyepmj}0$sv$xs$gsrxmryi$xs$uyepmj}0$ew$e$VIMX2

Er}$tivwsr${ls$eguymviw$sv$exxiqtxw$sv$mrxirhw$xs$eguymvi$firijmgmep$sv$gsrwxvygxmzi$s{rivwlmt$sj$wleviw$sj$KIS$wxsgo$xlex${mpp$sv$qe}$zmspexi

xli$jsviksmrk$viwxvmgxmsrw$sr$xverwjivefmpmx}$erh$s{rivwlmt${mpp$fi$viuymvih$xs$kmzi$rsxmgi$xs$yw$mqqihmexip}$,sv0$mr$xli$gewi$sj$e$tvstswih$sv$exxiqtxih

xverwegxmsr0$ex$piewx$59$he}w$tvmsv$xs$wygl$xverwegxmsr-$erh$tvszmhi$yw${mxl$wygl$sxliv$mrjsvqexmsr$ew${i$qe}$viuyiwx$mr$svhiv$xs$hixivqmri$xli$ijjigx0$mj

er}0$sj$wygl$xverwjiv$sr$syv$uyepmjmgexmsr$ew$e$VIMX2

Tyvwyerx$xs$xli$Eqirhih$Evxmgpiw0$mj$xlivi$mw$er}$tyvtsvxih$xverwjiv$sj$KIS$wxsgo$sv$sxliv$izirx$sv$glerki$sj$gmvgyqwxergiw$xlex0$mj$ijjigxmzi$sv

sxliv{mwi0${syph$zmspexi$er}$sj$xli$viwxvmgxmsrw$hiwgvmfih$efszi0$xlir$xli$ryqfiv$sj$wleviw$geywmrk$xli$zmspexmsr$,vsyrhih$yt$xs$xli$rieviwx${lspi$wlevi-

{mpp$fi$eyxsqexmgepp}$xverwjivvih$xs$e$xvywx$jsv$xli$i|gpywmzi$firijmx$sj$e$hiwmkrexih$glevmxefpi$firijmgmev}0$i|gitx$xlex$er}$xverwjiv$xlex$viwypxw$mr$xli

zmspexmsr$sj$xli$viwxvmgxmsr$vipexmrk$xs$KIS$wxsgo$fimrk$firijmgmepp}$s{rih$f}$ji{iv$xler$544$tivwsrw${mpp$fi$eyxsqexmgepp}$zsmh$erh$sj$rs$jsvgi$sv

ijjigx2$Xli$eyxsqexmg$xverwjiv${mpp$fi$ijjigxmzi$ew$sj$xli$gpswi$sj$fywmriww$sr$xli$fywmriww$he}$tvmsv$xs$xli$hexi$sj$xli$tyvtsvxih$xverwjiv$sv$sxliv$izirx$sv

glerki$sj$gmvgyqwxergiw$xlex$viuymviw$xli$xverwjiv$xs$xli$xvywx2$[i$vijiv$fips{$xs$xli$tivwsr$xlex${syph$lezi$s{rih$xli$wleviw$mj$xli}$leh$rsx$fiir

xverwjivvih$xs$xli$xvywx$ew$xli$tyvtsvxih$xverwjivii2$Er}$svhmrev}$hmzmhirh$temh$xs$xli$tyvtsvxih$xverwjivii0$tvmsv$xs$syv$hmwgsziv}$xlex$xli$wleviw$leh$fiir

eyxsqexmgepp}$xverwjivvih$xs$e$xvywx$ew$hiwgvmfih$efszi0$qywx$fi$vitemh$xs$xli$xvywxii$ytsr$hiqerh2$Xli$Eqirhih$Evxmgpiw$epws$tvszmhi$jsv$ehnywxqirxw

xs$xli$irxmxpiqirx$xs$vigimzi$i|xvesvhmrev}$hmzmhirhw$erh$sxliv$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$ew$fix{iir$xli$tyvtsvxih$xverwjivii$erh$xli$xvywx2$Mj$xli$xverwjiv$xs$xli$xvywx

ew$hiwgvmfih$efszi$mw$rsx$eyxsqexmgepp}$ijjigxmzi0$jsv$er}$viewsr0$xs$tvizirx$zmspexmsr$sj$xli$ettpmgefpi$viwxvmgxmsr$gsrxemrih$mr$xli$Eqirhih$Evxmgpiw0

xlir$xli$xverwjiv$sj$xli$i|giww$wleviw${mpp$fi$eyxsqexmgepp}$zsmh$erh$sj$rs$jsvgi$sv$ijjigx2

Wleviw$sj$KIS$wxsgo$xverwjivvih$xs$xli$xvywxii$evi$hiiqih$xs$fi$sjjivih$jsv$wepi$xs$yw$sv$syv$hiwmkrii$ex$e$tvmgi$tiv$wlevi$iuyep$xs$xli$piwwiv$sj

,m-$xli$tvmgi$tiv$wlevi$mr$xli$xverwegxmsr$xlex$viwypxih$mr$wygl$xverwjiv$xs$xli$xvywx$sv0$mj$xli$tyvtsvxih$xverwjivii$hmh$rsx$kmzi$zepyi$jsv$xli$wleviw$mr

gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$izirx$geywmrk$xli$wleviw$xs$fi$liph$mr$xvywx$,i2k20$mr$xli$gewi$sj$e$kmjx0$hizmwi$sv$sxliv$wygl$xverwegxmsr-0$xli$qevoix$tvmgi$ex$xli$xmqi

sj$wygl$izirx$erh$,mm-$xli$qevoix$tvmgi$sr$xli$hexi${i$eggitx0$sv$syv$hiwmkrii$eggitxw0$wygl$sjjiv2$[i$lezi$xli$vmklx$xs$eggitx$wygl$sjjiv$yrxmp$xli$xvywxii

lew$wsph$xli$wleviw$sj$KIS$wxsgo$liph$mr$xli$xvywx$tyvwyerx$xs$xli$gpeywiw$hmwgywwih$fips{2$Ytsr$e$wepi$xs$yw0$xli$mrxiviwx$sj$xli$glevmxefpi$firijmgmev}$mr

xli$wleviw$wsph$xivqmrexiw$erh$xli$xvywxii$qywx$hmwxvmfyxi$xli$rix$tvsgiihw$sj$xli$wepi$xs$xli$tyvtsvxih$xverwjivii0$i|gitx$xlex$xli$xvywxii$qe}$vihygi$xli

eqsyrx$te}efpi$xs$xli$tyvtsvxih$xverwjivii$f}$xli$eqsyrx$sj$er}$svhmrev}$hmzmhirhw$xlex${i$temh$xs$xli$tyvtsvxih$xverwjivii$tvmsv$xs$syv$hmwgsziv}$xlex

xli$wleviw$leh$fiir$xverwjivvih$xs$xli$xvywx$erh$xlex$mw$s{ih$f}$xli$tyvtsvxih$xverwjivii$xs$xli$xvywxii$ew$hiwgvmfih$efszi2$Er}$rix$wepiw$tvsgiihw$mr

i|giww$sj$xli$eqsyrx$te}efpi$xs$xli$tyvtsvxih$xverwjivii$wlepp$fi$mqqihmexip}$temh$xs$xli$glevmxefpi$firijmgmev}0$erh$er}$svhmrev}$hmzmhirhw$liph$f}$xli

xvywxii${mxl$viwtigx$xs$wygl$wxsgo${mpp$fi$temh$xs$xli$glevmxefpi$firijmgmev}2$

9

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 250 of 253

Page 273: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\18258

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=hi|8582lxq :3<

Mj${i$hs$rsx$fy}$xli$wleviw0$xli$xvywxii$qywx0$ew$wssr$ew$viewsrefp}$tvegxmgefpi$,erh0$mj$xli$wleviw$evi$pmwxih$sr$e$rexmsrep$wigyvmxmiw$i|glerki0

{mxlmr$64$he}w-$ejxiv$vigimzmrk$rsxmgi$jvsq$yw$sj$xli$xverwjiv$sj$wleviw$xs$xli$xvywx0$wipp$xli$wleviw$xs$e$tivwsr$sv$irxmx}${ls$gsyph$s{r$xli$wleviw${mxlsyx

zmspexmrk$xli$viwxvmgxmsrw$hiwgvmfih$efszi2$Ytsr$wygl$e$wepi0$xli$xvywxii$qywx$hmwxvmfyxi$xs$xli$tyvtsvxih$xverwjivii$er$eqsyrx$iuyep$xs$xli$piwwiv$sj$,m-$xli

tvmgi$temh$f}$xli$tyvtsvxih$xverwjivii$jsv$xli$wleviw$sv0$mj$xli$tyvtsvxih$xverwjivii$hmh$rsx$kmzi$zepyi$jsv$xli$wleviw$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$izirx$geywmrk

xli$wleviw$xs$fi$liph$mr$xvywx$,i2k20$mr$xli$gewi$sj$e$kmjx0$hizmwi$sv$sxliv$wygl$xverwegxmsr-0$xli$qevoix$tvmgi$sj$xli$wleviw$sr$xli$he}$sj$xli$izirx$geywmrk

xli$wleviw$xs$fi$liph$mr$xli$xvywx0$erh$,mm-$xli$wepiw$tvsgiihw$,rix$sj$gsqqmwwmsrw$erh$sxliv$i|tirwiw$sj$wepi-$vigimzih$f}$xli$xvywxii$jsv$xli$wleviw2$Xli

xvywxii$qe}$vihygi$xli$eqsyrx$te}efpi$xs$xli$tyvtsvxih$xverwjivii$f}$xli$eqsyrx$sj$er}$svhmrev}$hmzmhirhw$xlex${i$temh$xs$xli$tyvtsvxih$xverwjivii

fijsvi$syv$hmwgsziv}$xlex$xli$wleviw$leh$fiir$xverwjivvih$xs$xli$xvywx$erh$xlex$mw$s{ih$f}$xli$tyvtsvxih$xverwjivii$xs$xli$xvywxii$ew$hiwgvmfih$efszi2$Er}

rix$wepiw$tvsgiihw$mr$i|giww$sj$xli$eqsyrx$te}efpi$xs$xli$tyvtsvxih$xverwjivii${mpp$fi$mqqihmexip}$temh$xs$xli$glevmxefpi$firijmgmev}0$xskixliv${mxl$er}

svhmrev}$hmzmhirhw$liph$f}$xli$xvywxii${mxl$viwtigx$xs$wygl$wxsgo2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$mj$tvmsv$xs$hmwgsziv}$f}$yw$xlex$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$lezi$fiir

xverwjivvih$xs$e$xvywx0$wygl$wleviw$sj$wxsgo$evi$wsph$f}$e$tyvtsvxih$xverwjivii0$xlir$wygl$wleviw${mpp$fi$hiiqih$xs$lezi$fiir$wsph$sr$filepj$sj$xli$xvywx

erh0$xs$xli$i|xirx$xlex$xli$tyvtsvxih$xverwjivii$vigimzih$er$eqsyrx$jsv$sv$mr$viwtigx$sj$wygl$wleviw$xlex$i|giihw$xli$eqsyrx$xlex$wygl$tyvtsvxih$xverwjivii

{ew$irxmxpih$xs$vigimzi$ew$hiwgvmfih$efszi0$wygl$i|giww$eqsyrx$wlepp$fi$temh$xs$xli$xvywxii$ytsr$hiqerh2$Xli$tyvtsvxih$xverwjivii$lew$rs$vmklxw$mr$xli

wleviw$liph$f}$xli$xvywxii2

Xli$xvywxii${mpp$fi$mrhiqrmjmih$f}$yw$sv$jvsq$xli$tvsgiihw$sj$wepiw$sj$wxsgo$mr$xli$xvywx$jsv$mxw$gswxw$erh$i|tirwiw$viewsrefp}$mrgyvvih$mr

gsrrigxmsr${mxl$gsrhygxmrk$mxw$hyxmiw$erh$wexmwj}mrk$mxw$sfpmkexmsrw$yrhiv$xli$Eqirhih$Evxmgpiw2$Xli$xvywxii${mpp$epws$fi$irxmxpih$xs$viewsrefpi

gsqtirwexmsr$jsv$wivzmgiw$tvszmhih$ew$hixivqmrih$f}$ekviiqirx$fix{iir$xli$xvywxii$erh$xli$fsevh$sj$hmvigxsvw0${lmgl$gsqtirwexmsr$qe}$fi$jyrhih$f}

yw$sv$xli$xvywx2$Mj${i$te}$er}$wygl$mrhiqrmjmgexmsr$sv$gsqtirwexmsr0${i$evi$irxmxpih$sr$e$jmvwx$tvmsvmx}$fewmw$,wyfnigx$xs$xli$xvywxii×w$mrhiqrmjmgexmsr$erh

gsqtirwexmsr$vmklxw-$xs$fi$vimqfyvwih$jvsq$xli$xvywx2$Xs$xli$i|xirx$xli$xvywx$jyrhw$er}$wygl$mrhiqrmjmgexmsr$erh$gsqtirwexmsr0$xli$eqsyrxw$ezempefpi

jsv$te}qirx$xs$e$tyvtsvxih$xverwjivii$,sv$xli$glevmxefpi$firijmgmev}-${syph$fi$vihygih2

Xli$xvywxii${mpp$fi$hiwmkrexih$f}$yw$erh$qywx$fi$yrejjmpmexih${mxl$yw$erh${mxl$er}$tyvtsvxih$xverwjivii2$Tvmsv$xs$xli$wepi$sj$er}$wleviw$f}$xli$xvywx0

xli$xvywxii${mpp$vigimzi0$mr$xvywx$jsv$xli$firijmgmev}0$epp$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$temh$f}$yw${mxl$viwtigx$xs$xli$wleviw0$erh$qe}$epws$i|ivgmwi$epp$zsxmrk$vmklxw${mxl

viwtigx$xs$xli$wleviw2

Wyfnigx$xs$xli$Jpsvmhe$Fywmriww$Gsvtsvexmsr$Egx0$ijjigxmzi$ew$sj$xli$hexi$xlex$xli$wleviw$lezi$fiir$xverwjivvih$xs$xli$xvywx0$xli$xvywxii${mpp$lezi$xli

eyxlsvmx}0$ex$xli$xvywxii×w$wspi$hmwgvixmsr>$

$ ¨ $ xs$viwgmrh$ew$zsmh$er}$zsxi$gewx$f}$e$tyvtsvxih$xverwjivii$tvmsv$xs$syv$hmwgsziv}$xlex$xli$wleviw$lezi$fiir$xverwjivvih$xs$xli$xvywx?$erh$

:

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 251 of 253

Page 274: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\18258

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=hi|8582lxq ;3<

$ ¨ $ xs$vigewx$xli$zsxi$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$xli$hiwmviw$sj$xli$xvywxii$egxmrk$jsv$xli$firijmx$sj$xli$glevmxefpi$firijmgmev}$sj$xli$xvywx2

Ls{iziv0$mj${i$lezi$epvieh}$xeoir$gsvtsvexi$egxmsr0$xlir$xli$xvywxii$qe}$rsx$viwgmrh$erh$vigewx$xli$zsxi2

Mr$ehhmxmsr0$mj$xli$fsevh$sj$hmvigxsvw$hixivqmriw$xlex$e$tvstswih$sv$tyvtsvxih$xverwjiv${syph$zmspexi$xli$viwxvmgxmsrw$sr$s{rivwlmt$erh$xverwjiv$sj

KIS$wxsgo$wix$jsvxl$mr$xli$Eqirhih$Evxmgpiw0$xli$fsevh$sj$hmvigxsvw$qe}$xeoi$wygl$egxmsr$ew$mx$hiiqw$ehzmwefpi$xs$vijywi$xs$kmzi$ijjigx$xs$sv$xs$tvizirx

wygl$zmspexmsr0$mrgpyhmrk$fyx$rsx$pmqmxih$xs0$geywmrk$yw$xs$vityvglewi$wleviw$sj$KIS$wxsgo0$vijywmrk$xs$kmzi$ijjigx$xs$xli$xverwjiv$sr$syv$fssow$sv

mrwxmxyxmrk$tvsgiihmrkw$xs$irnsmr$xli$xverwjiv2

[mxlmr$74$he}w$ejxiv$xli$irh$sj$iegl$VIMX$xe|efpi$}iev0$iziv}$s{riv$sj$9)$sv$qsvi$,sv$wygl$ps{iv$tivgirxeki$ew$viuymvih$f}$xli$Gshi$sv$xli

Xviewyv}$vikypexmsrw$xliviyrhiv-$sj$xli$syxwxerhmrk$wleviw$sj$er}$gpeww$sv$wivmiw$sj$KIS$wxsgo0$qywx0$ytsr$viuyiwx0$tvszmhi$yw${vmxxir$rsxmgi$sj$xli

tivwsr×w$reqi$erh$ehhviww0$xli$ryqfiv$sj$wleviw$sj$iegl$gpeww$erh$wivmiw$sj$KIS$wxsgo$xlex$xli$tivwsr$firijmgmepp}$s{rw$erh$e$hiwgvmtxmsr$sj$xli

qerriv$mr${lmgl$xli$wleviw$evi$liph2$Iegl$wygl$s{riv$qywx$epws$tvszmhi$yw${mxl$wygl$ehhmxmsrep$mrjsvqexmsr$ew${i$qe}$viuyiwx$mr$svhiv$xs$hixivqmri

xli$ijjigx0$mj$er}0$sj$wygl$s{riv×w$firijmgmep$s{rivwlmt$sr$syv$uyepmjmgexmsr$ew$e$VIMX$erh$xs$irwyvi$gsqtpmergi${mxl$xli$s{rivwlmt$pmqmxw2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0

iegl$firijmgmep$s{riv$sv$gsrwxvygxmzi$s{riv$sj$KIS$wxsgo0$erh$er}$tivwsr$,mrgpyhmrk$xli$wlevilsphiv$sj$vigsvh-${ls$mw$lsphmrk$wleviw$sj$KIS$wxsgo$jsv

e$firijmgmep$s{riv$sv$gsrwxvygxmzi$s{riv${mpp0$ytsr$hiqerh0$fi$viuymvih$xs$tvszmhi$yw${mxl$wygl$mrjsvqexmsr$ew${i$qe}$viuyiwx$mr$kssh$jemxl$mr$svhiv$xs

hixivqmri$syv$uyepmjmgexmsr$ew$e$VIMX$erh$xs$gsqtp}${mxl$xli$viuymviqirxw$sj$er}$xe|mrk$eyxlsvmx}$sv$kszivrqirxep$eyxlsvmx}$sv$xs$hixivqmri$wygl

gsqtpmergi2

Tvs|}$Eggiww

Syv$Eqirhih$F}pe{w$tivqmx$e$wlevilsphiv0$sv$e$kvsyt$sj$yt$xs$x{irx}$,64-$wlevilsphivw0$s{rmrk$xlvii$tivgirx$,7)-$sv$qsvi$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w

syxwxerhmrk$gsqqsr$wxsgo$gsrxmrysywp}$jsv$ex$piewx$xlvii$,7-$}ievw0$xs$rsqmrexi$x{irx}$tivgirx$,64)-$sj$xli$ryqfiv$sj$hmvigxsvw$xlir$mr$sjjmgi

,vsyrhmrk$hs{r$xs$xli$rieviwx${lspi$ryqfiv-$tvszmhih$xlex$xli$wlevilsphiv$sv$kvsyt$erh$iegl$rsqmrii$wexmwj}$xli$ipmkmfmpmx}0$tvsgihyvep$erh$hmwgpswyvi

viuymviqirxw$jsv$tvs|}$eggiww$ew$wtigmjmih$mr$xli$F}pe{w0$mrgpyhmrk$xlex$xli$Gsqter}$vigimzi$rsxmgi$sj$wygl$rsqmrexmsrw$fix{iir$=4$erh$564$he}w$tvmsv

xs$xli$errmzivwev}$hexi$sj$xli$tvizmsyw$}iev×w$erryep$qiixmrk$sj$wlevilsphivw2$Xli$rsxmgi$qywx$gsrxemr$givxemr$mrjsvqexmsr$wtigmjmih$mr$xli$Eqirhih

F}pe{w2

Pmwxmrk

Syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo$mw$pmwxih$sr$xli$R]WI$yrhiv$xli$xvehmrk$w}qfsp$ÔKIS2Õ$

;

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 252 of 253

Page 275: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\18258

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h<85;6=hi|8582lxq <3<

Xverwjiv$Ekirx$erh$Vikmwxvev

Xli$xverwjiv$ekirx$erh$vikmwxvev$jsv$KIS×w$gsqqsr$wxsgo$mw$Gsqtyxivwlevi$Xvywx$Gsqter}0$R2E20${lswi$tvmrgmtep$i|igyxmzi$sjjmgi$mw$psgexih$ex

694$Vs}epp$Wxviix0$Gerxsr0$QE$464652$

<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 253 of 253

Page 276: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

EXHIBIT 2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 1 of 88

Page 277: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 53;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$$

YRMXIH$WXEXIW

WIGYVMXMIW$ERH$I\GLERKI$GSQQMWWMSR[ewlmrkxsr0$H2G2$6498=$

$

JSVQ$541U$

# UYEVXIVP]$VITSVX$TYVWYERX$XS$WIGXMSR$57$SV$59,h-$SJ$XLI$WIGYVMXMIW

I\GLERKI$EGX$SJ$5=78

Jsv$xli$uyevxivp}$tivmsh$irhih$Qevgl$750$6464

SV

" XVERWMXMSR$VITSVX$TYVWYERX$XS$WIGXMSR$57$SV$59,h-$SJ$XLI$WIGYVMXMIW

I\GLERKI$EGX$SJ$5=78

Jsv$xli$xverwmxmsr$tivmsh$jvsq$cccccc$xsccccccc$$$$$$$$$$$$$

Gsqqmwwmsr$jmpi$ryqfiv>$51586:4$$

Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2,I|egx$reqi$sj$vikmwxverx$ew$wtigmjmih$mr$mxw$glevxiv-$

$

$

Jpsvmhe $ :9144874;<,Wxexi$sv$sxliv$nyvmwhmgxmsr$sjmrgsvtsvexmsr$sv$svkerm~exmsr- $

,MVW$Iqtps}ivMhirxmjmgexmsr$Rs2-

$ $ $

8=99$Xiglrspsk}$[e}

Fsge$Vexsr0$Jpsvmhe $ 77875,Ehhviww$sj$tvmrgmtep$i|igyxmzi$sjjmgiw- $ ,^mt$Gshi-

$

,9:5-$<=714545,Vikmwxverx×w$xipitlsri$ryqfiv0$mrgpyhmrk$evie$gshi-

,Jsvqiv$reqi0$jsvqiv$ehhviww$erh$jsvqiv$jmwgep$}iev$mj$glerkih$wmrgi$pewx$vitsvx-$

Wigyvmxmiw$vikmwxivih$tyvwyerx$xs$Wigxmsr$56,f-$sj$xli$Egx>$

Xmxpi$sj$iegl$gpeww $ Xvehmrk$W}qfsp,w- $ Reqi$sj$iegl$i|glerki$sr${lmgl$vikmwxivih

Gsqqsr$Wxsgo0$(4245$tev$zepyi$tiv$wlevi $ KIS $ Ri{$]svo$Wxsgo$I|glerki$

Mrhmgexi$f}$gligo$qevo${lixliv$xli$vikmwxverx$,5-$lew$jmpih$epp$vitsvxw$viuymvih$xs$fi$jmpih$f}$Wigxmsr$57$sv$59,h-$sj$xli$Wigyvmxmiw

I|glerki$Egx$sj$5=78$hyvmrk$xli$tvigihmrk$56$qsrxlw$,sv$jsv$wygl$wlsvxiv$tivmsh$xlex$xli$vikmwxverx${ew$viuymvih$xs$jmpi$wygl$vitsvxw-0

erh$,6-$lew$fiir$wyfnigx$xs$wygl$jmpmrk$viuymviqirxw$jsv$xli$tewx$=4$he}w2$$$$]iw$$#$$$$Rs$$"

Mrhmgexi$f}$gligo$qevo${lixliv$xli$vikmwxverx$lew$wyfqmxxih$ipigxvsrmgepp}$iziv}$Mrxivegxmzi$Hexe$Jmpi$viuymvih$xs$fi$wyfqmxxih

tyvwyerx$xs$Vypi$849$sj$Vikypexmsr$W1X$,§6762849$sj$xlmw$gletxiv-$hyvmrk$xli$tvigihmrk$56$qsrxlw$,sv$jsv$wygl$wlsvxiv$tivmsh$xlex$xli

vikmwxverx${ew$viuymvih$xs$wyfqmx$wygl$jmpiw-2$$$$]iw$$#$$$$Rs$$"

Mrhmgexi$f}$gligo$qevo${lixliv$xli$vikmwxverx$mw$e$pevki$eggipivexih$jmpiv0$er$eggipivexih$jmpiv0$e$rsr1eggipivexih$jmpiv0$e$wqeppiv$vitsvxmrk

gsqter}0$sv$er$iqivkmrk$kvs{xl$gsqter}2$Wii$xli$hijmrmxmsrw$sj$Ôpevki$eggipivexih$jmpiv0Õ$Ôeggipivexih$jmpiv0Õ$Ôwqeppiv$vitsvxmrk

gsqter}0Õ$erh$&iqivkmrk$kvs{xl$gsqter}&$mr$Vypi$56f16$sj$xli$I|glerki$Egx2$

Pevki$eggipivexih$jmpiv # Eggipivexih$jmpiv "$ $ $ $

Rsr1eggipivexih$jmpiv "$ Wqeppiv$vitsvxmrk$gsqter} "$ $ $ $

$ $ Iqivkmrk$kvs{xl$gsqter} "$

Mj$er$iqivkmrk$kvs{xl$gsqter}0$mrhmgexi$f}$gligo$qevo$mj$xli$vikmwxverx$lew$ipigxih$rsx$xs$ywi$xli$i|xirhih$xverwmxmsr$tivmsh$jsv

gsqtp}mrk${mxl$er}$ri{$sv$vizmwih$jmrergmep$eggsyrxmrk$wxerhevhw$tvszmhih$tyvwyerx$xs$Wigxmsr$57,e-$sj$xli$I|glerki$Egx2 "

Mrhmgexi$f}$gligo$qevo${lixliv$xli$vikmwxverx$mw$e$wlipp$gsqter}$,ew$hijmrih$mr$Vypi$56f16$sj$xli$I|glerki$Egx-2$$$$]iw$$"$$$Rs$$#

Ew$sj$Qe}$90$64640$xli$vikmwxverx$leh$56507:50==<$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$syxwxerhmrk2$

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 2 of 88

Page 278: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 63;9

$

$

$

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 3 of 88

Page 279: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 73;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

XEFPI$SJ$GSRXIRXW

$TEVX$M$1$JMRERGMEP$MRJSVQEXMSR 7

MXIQ$52$JMRERGMEP$WXEXIQIRXW 7

GSRWSPMHEXIH$WXEXIQIRXW$SJ$STIVEXMSRW$,YREYHMXIH-$JSV$XLI$XLVII$QSRXLW$IRHIH$QEVGL$750

6464$ERH$645= 7

GSRWSPMHEXIH$WXEXIQIRXW$SJ$GSQTVILIRWMZI$MRGSQI$,YREYHMXIH-$JSV$XLI$XLVII$QSRXLW$IRHIH

QEVGL$750$6464$ERH$645= 8

GSRWSPMHEXIH$FEPERGI$WLIIXW$EW$SJ$QEVGL$750$6464$,YREYHMXIH-$ERH$HIGIQFIV$750$645= 9

GSRWSPMHEXIH$WXEXIQIRXW$SJ$GEWL$JPS[W$,YREYHMXIH-$JSV$XLI$XLVII$QSRXLW$IRHIH$QEVGL$750

6464$ERH$645= :

RSXIW$XS$YREYHMXIH$GSRWSPMHEXIH$JMRERGMEP$WXEXIQIRXW ;

MXIQ$62$QEREKIQIRX×W$HMWGYWWMSR$ERH$EREP]WMW$SJ$JMRERGMEP$GSRHMXMSR$ERH$VIWYPXW$SJ

STIVEXMSRW 77

MXIQ$72$UYERXMXEXMZI$ERH$UYEPMXEXMZI$HMWGPSWYVIW$EFSYX$QEVOIX$VMWO 8=

MXIQ$82$GSRXVSPW$ERH$TVSGIHYVIW 8=

TEVX$MM$1$SXLIV$MRJSVQEXMSR 94

MXIQ$52$PIKEP$TVSGIIHMRKW 94

MXIQ$5E2$VMWO$JEGXSVW 94

MXIQ$62$YRVIKMWXIVIH$WEPIW$SJ$IUYMX]$WIGYVMXMIW$ERH$YWI$SJ$TVSGIIHW 95

MXIQ$72$HIJEYPXW$YTSR$WIRMSV$WIGYVMXMIW 95

MXIQ$82$QMRI$WEJIX]$HMWGPSWYVIW 95

MXIQ$92$SXLIV$MRJSVQEXMSR 95

MXIQ$:2$I\LMFMXW 96

WMKREXYVIW 97

$

6

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 4 of 88

Page 280: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 83;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

TEVX$M$1$JMRERGMEP$MRJSVQEXMSR

MXIQ$52$JMRERGMEP$WXEXIQIRXW

XLI$KIS$KVSYT0$MRG2

GSRWSPMHEXIH$WXEXIQIRXW$SJ$STIVEXMSRW

,Yreyhmxih-

JSV$XLI$XLVII$QSRXLW$IRHIH

Qevgl$750$6464$ERH$645=

,Mr$xlsywerhw0$i|gitx$tiv$wlevi$hexe-

$

$ Xlvii$Qsrxlw$Irhih $ $

$ $ Qevgl$750$6464 $ $ Qevgl$750$645= $ $

Viziryiw $ ( :49045;$ $ ( :540::;$ $

Stivexmrk$i|tirwiw $ $ 8:50766$ $ $ 89:0==;$ $

Hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr $ $ 77076;$ $ $ 7608:=$ $

Kirivep$erh$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw $ $ 970;<6$ $ $ 8:0868$ $

Stivexmrk$mrgsqi $ $ 9:09<:$ $ $ ;80;;;$ $

Mrxiviwx$mrgsqi $ $ 9087<$ $ $ <07=:$ $

Mrxiviwx$i|tirwi $ $ ,7805<4- $ $ ,8406<4- $

Kemr$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx $ $ 509:7$ $ $ Ó$ $

Mrgsqi$fijsvi$mrgsqi$xe|iw$erh$iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw $ $ 6=084;$ $ $ 860<=7$ $

Tvszmwmsr$jsv$mrgsqi$xe|iw $ $ :098:$ $ $ 80<84$ $

Iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw0$rix$sj$mrgsqi$xe|$tvszmwmsr$sj

$$$(8880$erh$(79=0$viwtigxmzip} $ $ 606:4$ $ $ 609=:$ $

Rix$mrgsqi $ $ 690565$ $ $ 840:8=$ $

Rix$psww$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$rsrgsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw $ $ :4$ $ $ 9:$ $

Rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2 $ ( 6905<5$ $ ( 840;49$ $

$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

[imklxih1eziveki$gsqqsr$wleviw$syxwxerhmrk> $ $ $$ $ $ $ $ $

Fewmg $ $ 55=07=8$ $ $ 55<0;;8$ $

Hmpyxih $ $ 55=0=77$ $ $ 55=08=:$ $

Rix$mrgsqi$tiv$gsqqsr$wlevi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0

$$$Mrg2> $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Fewmg> $ $ $$ $ $ $ $ $

Rix$mrgsqi$tiv$gsqqsr$wlevi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0

$$$Mrg2$1$fewmg $ ( 4265$ $ ( 4278$ $

Hmpyxih> $ $ $$ $ $ $ $ $

Rix$mrgsqi$tiv$gsqqsr$wlevi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0

$$$Mrg2$1$hmpyxih $ ( 4265$ $ ( 4278$ $

Hmzmhirhw$higpevih$tiv$wlevi $ ( 428<$ $ ( 428<$$

$Xli$eggsqter}mrk$rsxiw$evi$er$mrxikvep$tevx$sj$xliwi$yreyhmxih$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw2

7

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 5 of 88

Page 281: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 93;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

XLI$KIS$KVSYT0$MRG2

GSRWSPMHEXIH$WXEXIQIRXW$SJ$GSQTVILIRWMZI$MRGSQI

,Yreyhmxih-

JSV$XLI$XLVII$QSRXLW$IRHIH

QEVGL$750$6464$ERH$645=

,Mr$xlsywerhw-

$

$ Xlvii$Qsrxlw$Irhih $ $

$ $ Qevgl$750$6464 $ $ Qevgl$750$645= $ $

Rix$mrgsqi $ ( 690565$ $ ( 840:8=$ $

Sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$,psww-0$rix$sj$xe|> $ $ $$ $ $ $$ $

Jsvimkr$gyvvirg}$xverwpexmsr$ehnywxqirxw $ $ ,<0<4;- $ $ 50;7:$ $

Tirwmsr$pmefmpmx}$ehnywxqirx0$rix$sj$xe|$tvszmwmsr

$$$sj$(6<0$erh$(550$viwtigxmzip} $ $ 54;$ $ $ ,:8<- $

Glerki$mr$jemv$zepyi$sj$hivmzexmzi$mrwxvyqirx

$$$gpewwmjmih$ew$gewl$jps{$lihki0$rix$sj$xe|$,firijmx-$tvszmwmsr$sj

$$$(,5064;-0$erh$(6490$viwtigxmzip} $ $ ,80956- $ $ 505:8$ $

Xsxep$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$psww0$rix$sj$xe| $ $ ,570656- $ $ 60696$ $

Xsxep$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi $ $ 550=4=$ $ $ 860=45$ $

Gsqtvilirwmzi$psww$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$rsrgsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw $ $ 54<$ $ $ 9:$ $

Gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2 $ ( 56045;$ $ ( 860=9;$$

$Xli$eggsqter}mrk$rsxiw$evi$er$mrxikvep$tevx$sj$xliwi$yreyhmxih$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw2

8

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 6 of 88

Page 282: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq :3;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

XLI$KIS$KVSYT0$MRG2

GSRWSPMHEXIH$FEPERGI$WLIIXW

QEVGL$750$6464$ERH$HIGIQFIV$750$645=

,Mr$xlsywerhw0$i|gitx$wlevi$hexe-

$

$Qevgl$750

6464 $ $Higiqfiv$750

645= $

$ $ ,Yreyhmxih- $ $ $ $ $

EWWIXW $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Gyvvirx$Ewwixw $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw $ ( 760858$ $ ( 7608:7$

Viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw $ $ 6;0<:9$ $ $ 76085<$

Eggsyrxw$vigimzefpi0$piww$epps{ergi$jsv$hsyfxjyp$eggsyrxw$sj$(60::<$erh$(805<70

$$$viwtigxmzip} $ $ 7;90897$ $ $ 8740=<6$

Gsrxvegx$vigimzefpi0$gyvvirx$tsvxmsr $ $ 80:<:$ $ $ 5505==$

Tvitemh$i|tirwiw$erh$sxliv$gyvvirx$ewwixw $ $ 7:054<$ $ $ 840;5:$

Xsxep$gyvvirx$ewwixw $ $ 8;:096:$ $ $ 98;0;;<$

Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Mrziwxqirxw $ $ 6;06;5$ $ $ 740=67$

Tvstivx}$erh$Iuymtqirx0$Rix $ $ 605860974$ $ $ 605880;66$

Ewwixw$Liph$jsv$Wepi $ $ 80849$ $ $ :049=$

Gsrxvegx$Vigimzefpi $ $ 75=0<5=$ $ $ 7:40:8;$

Stivexmrk$Piewi$Vmklx1sj1Ywi$Ewwixw0$Rix $ $ 56708:9$ $ $ 565096;$

Hijivvih$Mrgsqi$Xe|$Ewwixw $ $ 7:06;<$ $ $ 7:06;<$

Kssh{mpp $ $ ;;:074:$ $ $ ;;:079:$

Mrxerkmfpi$Ewwixw0$Rix $ $ 64807<;$ $ $ 65404;4$

Sxliv$Rsr1Gyvvirx$Ewwixw $ $ ;:0<:4$ $ $ <705;8$

Xsxep$Ewwixw $ ( 805<;0<8;$ $ ( 8075;0978$

PMEFMPMXMIW$ERH$WLEVILSPHIVW×$IUYMX] $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Gyvvirx$Pmefmpmxmiw $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Eggsyrxw$te}efpi $ ( =60<<;$ $ ( ==0676$

Eggvyih$te}vspp$erh$vipexih$xe|iw $ $ :70449$ $ $ 980:;6$

Eggvyih$i|tirwiw$erh$sxliv$gyvvirx$pmefmpmxmiw $ $ 5;<0<78$ $ $ 5=50:4<$

Stivexmrk$piewi$pmefmpmxmiw0$gyvvirx$tsvxmsr $ $ 6:0=:<$ $ $ 6:064<$

Gyvvirx$tsvxmsr$sj$jmrergi$piewi$pmefmpmxmiw0$psrk1xivq$hifx$erh$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx $ $ 670:69$ $ $ 68064<$

Xsxep$gyvvirx$pmefmpmxmiw $ $ 7<9075=$ $ $ 7=90=6<$

Hijivvih$Mrgsqi$Xe|$Pmefmpmxmiw $ $ 5=0698$ $ $ 5=0698$

Sxliv$Rsr1Gyvvirx$Pmefmpmxmiw $ $ <609=5$ $ $ <<096:$

Stivexmrk$Piewi$Pmefmpmxmiw $ $ ==0758$ $ $ =;06=5$

Jmrergi$Piewi$Pmefmpmxmiw $ $ 609:7$ $ $ 60=98$

Psrk1Xivq$Hifx $ $ 607;40<=4$ $ $ 6084<06=;$

Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Hifx $ $ 6;408:4$ $ $ 74=067:$

Gsqqmxqirxw$erh$Gsrxmrkirgmiw$,Rsxi$55- $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Wlevilsphivw×$Iuymx} $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Tvijivvih$wxsgo0$(4245$tev$zepyi0$7404440444$wleviw$eyxlsvm~ih0

$$$rsri$mwwyih$sv$syxwxerhmrk $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$

Gsqqsr$wxsgo0$(4245$tev$zepyi0$5<;09440444$wleviw$eyxlsvm~ih0

$$$56:058=095:$erh$569087909;7$mwwyih$erh$56507<909=;

$$$5650669075=$syxwxerhmrk0$viwtigxmzip} $ $ 506:6$ $ $ 50698$

Ehhmxmsrep$temh1mr$getmxep $ $ 5068;04:<$ $ $ 506740<:9$

Hmwxvmfyxmsrw$mr$i|giww$sj$ievrmrkw $ $ ,5960745- $ $ ,55=0;;=-

Eggyqypexih$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$psww $ $ ,7708==- $ $ ,640779-

Xviewyv}$wxsgo0$80;:70=5=$erh$806540698$wleviw0$ex$gswx0$viwtigxmzip} $ $ ,54805<8- $ $ ,=905;9-

Xsxep$wlevilsphivw×$iuymx}$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2 $ $ =9<078:$ $ $ ==:0<74$

Rsrgsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw $ $ ,<=4- $ $ ,;<6-

Xsxep$wlevilsphivw×$iuymx} $ $ =9;089:$ $ $ ==:048<$

Xsxep$Pmefmpmxmiw$erh$Wlevilsphivw×$Iuymx} $ ( 805<;0<8;$ $ ( 8075;0978$

$Xli$eggsqter}mrk$rsxiw$evi$er$mrxikvep$tevx$sj$xliwi$yreyhmxih$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 7 of 88

Page 283: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq ;3;9

9

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 8 of 88

Page 284: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq <3;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

XLI$KIS$KVSYT0$MRG2

GSRWSPMHEXIH$WXEXIQIRXW$SJ$GEWL$JPS[W

,Yreyhmxih-

JSV$XLI$XLVII$QSRXLW$IRHIH

QEVGL$750$6464$ERH$645=

,Mr$xlsywerhw-

$$ Xlvii$Qsrxlw$Irhih $

$ $Qevgl$750

6464 $ $Qevgl$750

645= $

Gewl$Jps{$jvsq$Stivexmrk$Egxmzmxmiw> $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $Rix$mrgsqi $ ( 690565$ $ ( 840:8=$Rix$psww$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$rsrgsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw $ $ :4$ $ $ 9:$

Rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2 $ $ 6905<5$ $ $ 840;49$Ehnywxqirxw$xs$vigsrgmpi$rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2$xs$rix$gewl$$$tvszmhih$f}$stivexmrk$egxmzmxmiw> $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr$i|tirwi $ $ 77076;$ $ $ 7608:=$Wxsgo1fewih$gsqtirwexmsr $ $ =0;:<$ $ $ :0;6;$Kemr$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx $ $ ,509:7- $ $ Ó$Eqsvxm~exmsr$sj$hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw0$hmwgsyrx$erh3sv$tviqmyq$erh$sxliv$rsr1gewl$$$mrxiviwx $ $ 50:;4$ $ $ 609:7$Tvszmwmsr$jsv$hsyfxjyp$eggsyrxw $ $ 69$ $ $ 575$Iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw0$rix$sj$xe| $ $ ,606:4- $ $ ,609=:-Hmzmhirhw$vigimzih$jvsq$yrgsrwspmhexih$nsmrx$zirxyvi $ $ :77$ $ $ 704<<$Psww$sr$wepi3hmwtswep$sj$tvstivx}$erh$iuymtqirx0$rix $ $ 748$ $ $ :=;$Psww$sr$ewwixw$liph$jsv$wepi $ $ Ó$ $ $ 504<7$

Glerkiw$mr$ewwixw$erh$pmefmpmxmiw0$rix$sj$ijjigxw$sj$eguymwmxmsrw> $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $Glerkiw$mr$eggsyrxw$vigimzefpi0$tvitemh$i|tirwiw$erh$sxliv$ewwixw $ $ 970654$ $ $ 6;096;$Glerkiw$mr$gsrxvegx$vigimzefpi $ $ 5064:$ $ $ 5088:$Glerkiw$mr$eggsyrxw$te}efpi0$eggvyih$i|tirwiw$erh$sxliv$pmefmpmxmiw $ $ :0;9<$ $ $ ,580<6=-

Rix$gewl$tvszmhih$f}$stivexmrk$egxmzmxmiw $ $ 56<069=$ $ $ ==0455$

Gewl$Jps{$jvsq$Mrziwxmrk$Egxmzmxmiw> $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $Mrwyvergi$tvsgiihw$1$heqekih$tvstivx} $ $ Ó$ $ $ 60947$Tvsgiihw$jvsq$wepi$sj$tvstivx}$erh$iuymtqirx $ $ 6:8$ $ $ 6;8$Tvsgiihw$jvsq$wepi$sj$ewwixw$liph$jsv$wepi $ $ 50744$ $ $ Ó$Glerki$mr$viwxvmgxih$mrziwxqirxw $ $ 707:7$ $ $ ,804:6-Getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw $ $ ,740:96- $ $ ,6<04<8-

Rix$gewl$ywih$mr$mrziwxmrk$egxmzmxmiw $ $ ,690;69- $ $ ,6=07:=-

Gewl$Jps{$jvsq$Jmrergmrk$Egxmzmxmiw> $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $Tvsgiihw$jvsq$psrk1xivq$hifx $ $ =:0444$ $ $ 5740444$Te}qirxw$sr$psrk1xivq$hifx $ $ ,5690949- $ $ ,=:0=6:-Te}qirxw$sr$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx $ $ ,507:6- $ $ ,604<=-Xe|iw$temh$vipexih$xs$rix$wlevi$wixxpiqirxw$sj$iuymx}$e{evhw $ $ ,60:76- $ $ ,805;6-Tvsgiihw$jvsq$mwwyergi$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$IWTT $ $ 594$ $ $ 568$Te}qirx$jsv$vityvglewiw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo $ $ ,=044=- $ $ Ó$Tvsgiihw$jvsq$xli$i|ivgmwi$sj$wxsgo$stxmsrw $ $ Ó$ $ $ 777$Gewl$hmzmhirhw$temh $ $ ,9;0;47- $ $ ,9;0=89-

Rix$gewl$ywih$mr$jmrergmrk$egxmzmxmiw $ $ ,54404:5- $ $ ,740:;9-

Ijjigx$sj$I|glerki$Vexi$Glerkiw$sr$Gewl0$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw$erh$Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$$$erh$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw $ $ ,;07:8- $ $ 7::$

Rix$Mrgviewi$,Higviewi-$mr$Gewl0$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw$erh$Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$$$erh$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw $ $ ,80<=5- $ $ 7=0777$Gewl0$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw$erh$Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw0$fikmrrmrk$sj$tivmsh $ $ :;08;6$ $ $ <808;6$

Gewl0$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw$erh$Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw0$irh$sj$tivmsh $ ( :609<5$ $ ( 5670<49$

Wyttpiqirxep$Hmwgpswyviw> $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $Rsr1gewl$Mrziwxmrk$erh$Jmrergmrk$egxmzmxmiw> $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $Vmklx1sj1ywi$ewwixw$sfxemrih$jvsq$stivexmrk$piewi$pmefmpmxmiw$ytsr$ehstxmsr$sj$ri{$$$piewi$wxerhevh $ ( Ó$ $ ( 58;0444$

Gsrzivwmsr$sj$tirwmsr$pmefmpmx}$xs$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo $ ( <0=69$ $ ( Ó$

Getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw$mr$eggsyrxw$te}efpi$erh$eggvyih$i|tirwiw $ ( 70748$ $ ( 904<5$

$Xli$eggsqter}mrk$rsxiw$evi$er$mrxikvep$tevx$sj$xliwi$yreyhmxih$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw2

:

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 9 of 88

Page 285: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq =3;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

XLI$KIS$KVSYT0$MRG2

RSXIW$XS$YREYHMXIH$GSRWSPMHEXIH$JMRERGMEP$WXEXIQIRXW

52$FEWMW$SJ$TVIWIRXEXMSR

Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg20$e$Jpsvmhe$gsvtsvexmsr0$erh$wyfwmhmevmiw$,xli$ÔGsqter}Õ$sv$ÔKISÕ-$mw$e$jypp}1mrxikvexih$viep$iwxexi$mrziwxqirx

xvywx$,ÔVIMXÕ-$wtigmepm~mrk$mr$xli$hiwmkr0$jmrergmrk0$hizipstqirx$erh$stivexmsr$sj$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw0$tvsgiwwmrk$girxivw$erh$gsqqyrmx}

viirxv}$girxivw$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw0$Eywxvepme0$Wsyxl$Ejvmge$erh$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq2$Xli$Gsqter}$s{rw0$piewiw$erh$stivexiw$e$fvseh

verki$sj$jegmpmxmiw$mrgpyhmrk$qe|mqyq0$qihmyq$erh$qmrmqyq$wigyvmx}$jegmpmxmiw0$tvsgiwwmrk$girxivw0$ew${ipp$ew$gsqqyrmx}1fewih

viirxv}$jegmpmxmiw$erh$sjjivw$er$i|terhih$hipmziv}$sj$vilefmpmxexmsr$wivzmgiw$yrhiv$mxw$+KIS$Gsrxmryyq$sj$Gevi+$tpexjsvq2$Xli$+KIS

Gsrxmryyq$sj$Gevi+$tvskveq$mrxikvexiw$irlergih$vilefmpmxexmzi$tvskveqw0${lmgl$evi$izmhirgi1fewih$erh$mrgpyhi$gskrmxmzi$filezmsvep

xviexqirx$erh$tswx1vipiewi$wivzmgiw0$erh$tvszmhiw$egehiqmg$erh$zsgexmsrep$gpewwiw$mr$pmji$womppw$erh$xviexqirx$tvskveqw${lmpi$liptmrk

mrhmzmhyepw$vimrxikvexi$mrxs$xlimv$gsqqyrmxmiw2$Xli$Gsqter}$hizipstw$ri{$jegmpmxmiw$fewih$sr$gsrxvegx$e{evhw0$ywmrk$mxw$tvsnigx

hizipstqirx$i|tivxmwi$erh$i|tivmirgi$xs$hiwmkr0$gsrwxvygx$erh$jmrergi${lex$mx$fipmiziw$evi$wxexi1sj1xli1evx$jegmpmxmiw$xlex$qe|mqm~i

wigyvmx}$erh$ijjmgmirg}2$Xli$Gsqter}$tvszmhiw$mrrszexmzi$gsqtpmergi$xiglrspskmiw0$mrhywxv}1piehmrk$qsrmxsvmrk$wivzmgiw0$erh

izmhirgi1fewih$wytivzmwmsr$erh$xviexqirx$tvskveqw$jsv$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$tevspiiw0$tvsfexmsrivw$erh$tvixvmep$hijirherxw2$Xli$Gsqter}

epws$tvszmhiw$wigyvi$xverwtsvxexmsr$wivzmgiw$jsv$mrhmzmhyepw$ew$gsrxvegxih$hsqiwxmgepp}$erh$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq$xlvsykl$mxw$nsmrx

zirxyvi$KIS$Eqi}$TIGW$Pxh2$,ÔKISEqi}Õ-2$Ex$Qevgl$750$64640$xli$Gsqter}×w${svph{mhi$stivexmsrw$mrgpyhi$xli$qerekiqirx

erh3sv$s{rivwlmt$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$=80444$fihw$ex$56:$jegmpmxmiw0$mrgpyhmrk$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw0$tvsnigxw$yrhiv$hizipstqirx$erh$vigirxp}

e{evhih$gsrxvegxw0$erh$epws$mrgpyhi$xli$tvszmwmsr$sj$gsqqyrmx}$wytivzmwmsr$wivzmgiw$jsv$qsvi$xler$6540444$mrhmzmhyepw0$mrgpyhmrk

ettvs|mqexip}$5440444$xlvsykl$er$evve}$sj$xiglrspsk}$tvshygxw$mrgpyhmrk$vehms$jviuyirg}0$KTW0$erh$epgslsp$qsrmxsvmrk$hizmgiw2

$

Xli$Gsqter}+w$yreyhmxih$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$xlmw$Uyevxivp}$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541U$lezi$fiir$tvitevih$mr

eggsvhergi${mxl$eggsyrxmrk$tvmrgmtpiw$kirivepp}$eggitxih$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw$erh$xli$mrwxvygxmsrw$xs$Jsvq$541U$erh$gsrwiuyirxp}$hs

rsx$mrgpyhi$epp$hmwgpswyviw$viuymvih$f}$Jsvq$541O2$Xli$eggsyrxmrk$tspmgmiw$jspps{ih$jsv$uyevxivp}$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$evi$xli$weqi$ew

xlswi$hmwgpswih$mr$xli$Rsxiw$xs$Gsrwspmhexih$Jmrergmep$Wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$xli$Gsqter}×w$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O$jmpih${mxl

xli$Wigyvmxmiw$erh$I|glerki$Gsqqmwwmsr$sr$Jifvyev}$6:0$6464$jsv$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=2$Xli$eggsqter}mrk

Higiqfiv$750$645=$gsrwspmhexih$fepergi$wliix$lew$fiir$hivmzih$jvsq$xlswi$eyhmxih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw2$Ehhmxmsrep$mrjsvqexmsr$qe}

fi$sfxemrih$f}$vijivvmrk$xs$xli$Gsqter}×w$Jsvq$541O$jsv$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=2$Mr$xli$stmrmsr$sj$qerekiqirx0$epp

ehnywxqirxw$,gsrwmwxmrk$srp}$sj$rsvqep$vigyvvmrk$mxiqw-$rigiwwev}$jsv$e$jemv$tviwirxexmsr$sj$xli$jmrergmep$mrjsvqexmsr$jsv$xli$mrxivmq

tivmshw$vitsvxih$mr$xlmw$Uyevxivp}$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541U$lezi$fiir$qehi2$Viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$jsv$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750

6464$evi$rsx$rigiwwevmp}$mrhmgexmzi$sj$xli$viwypxw$jsv$xli$irxmvi$}iev$irhmrk$Higiqfiv$750$64640$sv$jsv$er}$sxliv$jyxyvi$mrxivmq$sv$erryep

tivmshw2

$

Vmwow$erh$yrgivxemrxmiw

Mr$Higiqfiv$645=0$e$rszip$wxvemr$sj$gsvsrezmvyw0$rs{$ors{r$ew$GSZMH15=$,ÔGSZMH15=Õ-0${ew$vitsvxih$mr$[yler0$Glmre$erh$lew

wmrgi$i|xirwmzip}$mqtegxih$xli$kpsfep$liepxl$erh$igsrsqmg$irzmvsrqirx2$Mr$Neryev}$64640$xli$[svph$Liepxl$Svkerm~exmsr$,Ô[LSÕ-

higpevih$mx$e$Tyfpmg$Liepxl$Iqivkirg}$sj$Mrxivrexmsrep$Gsrgivr2$Sr$Jifvyev}$6<0$64640$xli$[LS$vemwih$mxw$ewwiwwqirx$sj$xli$GSZMH1

5=$xlviex$jvsq$lmkl$xs$ziv}$lmkl$ex$e$kpsfep$pizip$hyi$xs$xli$gsrxmryih$mrgviewi$mr$xli$ryqfiv$sj$gewiw$erh$ejjigxih$gsyrxvmiw0$erh$sr

Qevgl$550$64640$xli$[LS$glevegxivm~ih$GSZMH15=$ew$e$terhiqmg2$$

Xli$Gsqter}$mw$gpswip}$qsrmxsvmrk$xli$mqtegx$sj$xli$GSZMH15=$terhiqmg$sr$epp$ewtigxw$sj$mxw$fywmriww$erh$kiskvetlmiw0$mrgpyhmrk

ls{$mx${mpp$mqtegx$xlswi$irxvywxih$mr$mxw$gevi$erh$kszivrqirxep$tevxrivw2$[lmpi$xli$Gsqter}$hmh$rsx$mrgyv$wmkrmjmgerx$hmwvytxmsrw

hyvmrk$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$6464$jvsq$xli$GSZMH15=$terhiqmg0$mx$mw$yrefpi$xs$tvihmgx$xli$mqtegx$xlex$xli$GSZMH15=

terhiqmg${mpp$lezi$sr$mxw$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$erh$gewl$jps{w$hyi$xs$ryqivsyw$yrgivxemrxmiw2

Xli$GSZMH15=$terhiqmg$erh$vipexih$kszivrqirx1mqtswih$qerhexsv}$gpswyviw0$wlipxiv$mr1tpegi$viwxvmgxmsrw$erh$wsgmep$hmwxergmrk

tvsxsgspw lezi$leh0$erh${mpp$gsrxmryi$xs$lezi0$e$wizivi$mqtegx$sr$kpsfep$igsrsqmg$gsrhmxmsrw$erh$xli$irzmvsrqirx$mr${lmgl$xli

Gsqter}$stivexiw2$Wxevxmrk$mr$pexi$Qevgl$erh$ievp}$Etvmp0$xli$Gsqter}$fiker$xs$sfwivzi$rikexmzi$mqtegxw$jvsq$xli$terhiqmg$sr$mxw

tivjsvqergi$mr$mxw$wigyvi$wivzmgiw$fywmriww0$wtigmjmgepp}${mxl$mxw$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxivw$erh$Y2W2$Qevwlepw$Jegmpmxmiw0$ew$e$viwypx$sj

higpmriw$mr$gvswwmrkw$erh$ettvilirwmsrw$epsrk$xli$Wsyxl{iwx$fsvhiv0$ew${ipp$ew0$e$higviewi$mr$gsyvx$wirxirgmrk$ex$xli$jihivep$pizip2

Ehhmxmsrepp}0$mxw$viirxv}$wivzmgiw$fywmriww$gsrhygxih$xlvsykl$mxw$KIS$Gevi$fywmriww$wikqirx$lew$epws$fiir$rikexmzip}$mqtegxih0

wtigmjmgepp}$mxw$viwmhirxmep$viirxv}$girxivw$erh$rsr1viwmhirxmep$he}$vitsvxmrk$tvskveqw${ivi$mqtegxih$f}$higpmriw$mr$tvskveqw$hyi$xs

ps{iv$pizipw$sj$vijivvepw$f}$jihivep0$wxexi$erh$psgep$ekirgmiw2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$xli$Gsqter}$lew$i|tivmirgih$xli$xverwqmwwmsr$sj$GSZMH1

5=$ex$e$wqepp$ryqfiv$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$mr$xli$wigsrh$uyevxiv$sj$64642$Mj$xli$Gsqter}$mw$yrefpi$xs$qmxmkexi$xli$xverwqmwwmsr$sj$GSZMH1

5=$ex$mxw$jegmpmxmiw$mx$gsyph$i|tivmirgi$e$qexivmep$ehzivwi$ijjigx$sr$mxw$jmrergmep$tswmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$erh$gewl$jps{w2$Epxlsykl

xli$Gsqter}$mw$yrefpi$xs$tvihmgx$xli$hyvexmsr$sv$wgsti$sj$xli$GSZMH15=$terhiqmg$sv$iwxmqexi$xli$i|xirx$sj$xli$rikexmzi$jmrergmep

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 10 of 88

Page 286: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 543;9

mqtegx$xs$mxw$stivexmrk$viwypxw0$er$i|xirhih$tivmsh$sj$hitviwwih$igsrsqmg$egxmzmx}$rigiwwmxexih$xs$gsqfexmrk$xli$hmwiewi0$erh$xli

wizivmx}$erh$hyvexmsr$sj$xli$vipexih$kpsfep$igsrsqmg$gvmwmw${mpp$ehzivwip}$mqtegx$mxw$jyxyvi$jmrergmep$tivjsvqergi2

$

;

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 11 of 88

Page 287: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 553;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

$ $ $ $ $ $

62$KSSH[MPP$ERH$SXLIV$MRXERKMFPI$EWWIXW

Xli$Gsqter}$lew$vigsvhih$kssh{mpp$ew$e$viwypx$sj$mxw$zevmsyw$fywmriww$gsqfmrexmsrw2$Kssh{mpp$mw$vigsvhih$ew$xli$hmjjivirgi0$mj$er}0

fix{iir$xli$ekkvikexi$gsrwmhivexmsr$temh$jsv$er$eguymwmxmsr$erh$xli$jemv$zepyi$sj$xli$xerkmfpi$ewwixw$erh$mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw$eguymvih$rix

sj$pmefmpmxmiw$ewwyqih0$mrgpyhmrk$rsrgsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw2$Glerkiw$mr$xli$Gsqter}+w$kssh{mpp$fepergiw$jvsq$Neryev}$50$6464$xs

Qevgl$750$6464$evi$ew$jspps{w$,mr$xlsywerhw->

$

$Neryev}$50

6464 $ $Jsvimkr$Gyvvirg}

Xverwpexmsr $ $Qevgl$750

6464 $

KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw $ ( 75:07::$ $ ( Ó$ $ ( 75:07::$

KIS$Gevi $ $ 89=09<=$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 89=09<=$

Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw $ $ 845$ $ $ ,94- $ $ 795$

Xsxep$Kssh{mpp $ ( ;;:079:$ $ ( ,94- $ ( ;;:074:$

$Xli$Gsqter}$lew$epws$vigsvhih$sxliv$jmrmxi$erh$mrhijmrmxi1pmzih$mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw$ew$e$viwypx$sj$mxw$zevmsyw$fywmriww$gsqfmrexmsrw2$Xli

Gsqter}+w$mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw$mrgpyhi$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw0$gszirerxw$rsx$xs$gsqtixi0$xvehi$reqiw$erh$xiglrspsk}0$ew$jspps{w

,mr$xlsywerhw->

$

$ Qevgl$750$6464 $ $ Higiqfiv$750$645= $

$ $

[imklxihEziveki

Ywijyp$Pmji,}ievw- $ $

KvswwGevv}mrkEqsyrx $ $

EggyqypexihEqsvxm~exmsr$ $

RixGevv}mrkEqsyrx $ $

KvswwGevv}mrkEqsyrx $ $

EggyqypexihEqsvxm~exmsr$ $

RixGevv}mrkEqsyrx $

Jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw $ $ 5:27$ $ ( 74<075<$ $ ( ,597077;- $ ( 5980=<5$ $ ( 74<0876$ $ ( ,58<05;5- $ ( 5:406:5$

Xiglrspsk} $ $ ;27$ $ $ 770;44$ $ $ ,6=08=8- $ $ 8064:$ $ $ 770;44$ $ $ ,6=04=5- $ $ 80:4=$

Xvehi$reqiw $ Mrhijmrmxi$ $ $ 890644$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 890644$ $ $ 890644$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 890644$

Xsxep$eguymvih$mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw $ $ $$ $ ( 7<;065<$ $ ( ,5<60<75- $ ( 64807<;$ $ ( 7<;0776$ $ ( ,5;;06:6- $ ( 65404;4$

$Eqsvxm~exmsr$i|tirwi${ew$(92:$qmppmsr$jsv$iegl$sj$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$6464$erh$645=0$viwtigxmzip}2$Eqsvxm~exmsr

i|tirwi${ew$tvmqevmp}$vipexih$xs$xli$KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$erh$KIS$Gevi$wikqirxw+$eqsvxm~exmsr$sj$eguymvih$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx

gsrxvegxw2$Ew$sj$Qevgl$750$64640$xli${imklxih$eziveki$tivmsh$fijsvi$xli$ri|x$gsrxvegx$viri{ep$sv$i|xirwmsr$jsv$xli$eguymvih$jegmpmx}

qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw${ew$ettvs|mqexip}$52;$}ievw2$Epxlsykl$xli$jegmpmx}$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$eguymvih$lezi$viri{ep$erh$i|xirwmsr

xivqw$mr$xli$riev$xivq0$xli$Gsqter}$lew$lmwxsvmgepp}$qemrxemrih$xliwi$vipexmsrwlmtw$fi}srh$xli$gyvvirx$gsrxvegxyep$tivmshw2

Iwxmqexih$eqsvxm~exmsr$i|tirwi$vipexih$xs$xli$Gsqter}+w$jmrmxi1pmzih$mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw$jsv$xli$viqemrhiv$sj$6464$xlvsykl$6468$erh

xliviejxiv$mw$ew$jspps{w$,mr$xlsywerhw->

$

Jmwgep$]iev $

XsxepEqsvxm~exmsr

I|tirwi $

Viqemrhiv$sj$6464 $ ( 5;06:;$

6465 $ $ 5=0;::$

6466 $ $ 5<0566$

6467 $ $ 5708;<$

6468 $ $ =0;89$

Xliviejxiv $ $ <40<4=$

$ $ ( 59=05<;$

$

<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 12 of 88

Page 288: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 563;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

72$JMRERGMEP$MRWXVYQIRXW

Xli$jspps{mrk$xefpiw$tvszmhi$e$wyqqev}$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$wmkrmjmgerx$jmrergmep$ewwixw$erh$pmefmpmxmiw$gevvmih$ex$jemv$zepyi$erh$qiewyvih

sr$e$vigyvvmrk$fewmw$ew$sj$Qevgl$750$6464$erh$Higiqfiv$750$645=$,mr$xlsywerhw->

$

$ $ $ $ $ Jemv$Zepyi$Qiewyviqirxw$ex$Qevgl$750$6464 $

$ $

Gevv}mrk$Zepyi$exQevgl$750

6464 $ $

Uysxih$Tvmgiw$mrEgxmzi$Qevoixw

,Pizip$5- $ $

Wmkrmjmgerx$SxlivSfwivzefpi$Mrtyxw

,Pizip$6- $ $

WmkrmjmgerxYrsfwivzefpiMrtyxw$,Pizip$7- $

Ewwixw> $ $ $$ $ $ $$ $ $ $$ $ $ $ $

Viwxvmgxih$mrziwxqirx> $ $ $$ $ $ $$ $ $ $$ $ $ $ $

Veffm$Xvywx $ ( 680=:=$ $ ( Ó$ $ ( 680=:=$ $ ( Ó$

Jm|ih$mrgsqi$wigyvmxmiw $ $ 50<6=$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 50<6=$ $ $ Ó$

Pmefmpmxmiw> $ $ $$ $ $ $$ $ $ $$ $ $ $ $

Mrxiviwx$vexi$w{et$hivmzexmziw $ ( ;0:5:$ $ ( Ó$ $ ( ;0:5:$ $ ( Ó$

$

$ $ $ $ $ Jemv$Zepyi$Qiewyviqirxw$ex$Higiqfiv$750$645= $

$ $

Gevv}mrk$Zepyi$exHigiqfiv$750

645= $ $

Uysxih$Tvmgiw$mrEgxmzi$Qevoixw

,Pizip$5- $ $

Wmkrmjmgerx$SxlivSfwivzefpi$Mrtyxw

,Pizip$6- $ $

WmkrmjmgerxYrsfwivzefpiMrtyxw$,Pizip$7- $

Ewwixw> $ $ $$ $ $ $$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Viwxvmgxih$mrziwxqirxw> $ $ $$ $ $ $$ $ $ $$ $ $ $ $

Veffm$Xvywx $ ( 6<0776$ $ ( Ó$ $ ( 6<0776$ $ ( Ó$

Jm|ih$mrgsqi$wigyvmxmiw $ $ 50<=6$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 50<=6$ $ $ Ó$

Pmefmpmxmiw> $ $ $$ $ $ $$ $ $ $$ $ $ $ $

Mrxiviwx$vexi$w{et$hivmzexmziw $ ( 50<:=$ $ ( Ó$ $ ( 50<:=$ $ ( Ó$

$Xli$Gsqter}×w$Pizip$6$jmrergmep$mrwxvyqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$xli$xefpiw$efszi$ew$sj$Qevgl$750$6464$erh$Higiqfiv$750$645=$gsrwmwx$sj

mrxiviwx$vexi$w{et$hivmzexmzi$pmefmpmxmiw$liph$f}$KIS$erh$xli$Gsqter}+w$Eywxvepmer$wyfwmhmev}0$xli$Gsqter}+w$veffm$xvywx$iwxefpmwlih$jsv

KIS$iqtps}ii$erh$iqtps}iv$gsrxvmfyxmsrw$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2$Rsr1uyepmjmih$Hijivvih$Gsqtirwexmsr$Tper$erh$er$mrziwxqirx$mr

Gerehmer$hsppev$hirsqmrexih$jm|ih$mrgsqi$wigyvmxmiw2$Sr$Qe}$660$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$xivqmrexih$xli$mrxiviwx$vexi$w{et$hivmzexmzi

pmefmpmxmiw$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$e$hifx$vijmrergmrk$xverwegxmsr$f}$syv$Eywxvepmer$wyfwmhmev}2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$=$1$Hivmzexmzi$Jmrergmep

Mrwxvyqirxw$erh$Rsxi$54$1$Hifx$jsv$ehhmxmsrep$mrjsvqexmsr2

Xli$mrxiviwx$vexi$w{et$hivmzexmzi$pmefmpmxmiw$evi$zepyih$ywmrk$e$hmwgsyrxih$gewl$jps{$qship$fewih$sr$tvsnigxih$fsvvs{mrk$vexiw2$Xli

Gsqter}+w$viwxvmgxih$mrziwxqirx$mr$xli$veffm$xvywx$mw$mrziwxih$mr$Gsqter}1s{rih$pmji$mrwyvergi$tspmgmiw${lmgl$evi$vigsvhih$ex$xlimv

gewl$wyvvirhiv$zepyiw2$Xliwi$mrziwxqirxw$evi$zepyih$fewih$sr$xli$yrhivp}mrk$mrziwxqirxw$liph$mr$xli$tspmgmiw+$witevexi$eggsyrx2$Xli

yrhivp}mrk$ewwixw$evi$iuymx}$erh$jm|ih$mrgsqi$tsspih$jyrhw$xlex$evi$gsqtvmwih$sj$Pizip$5$erh$Pizip$6$wigyvmxmiw2$Xli$Gerehmer$hsppev

hirsqmrexih$wigyvmxmiw0$rsx$egxmzip}$xvehih0$evi$zepyih$ywmrk$uysxih$vexiw$jsv$xliwi$erh$wmqmpev$wigyvmxmiw2

$

=

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 13 of 88

Page 289: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 573;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

82$JEMV$ZEPYI$SJ$EWWIXW$ERH$PMEFMPMXMIW

Xli$Gsqter}×w$gsrwspmhexih$fepergi$wliixw$vijpigx$givxemr$jmrergmep$ewwixw$erh$pmefmpmxmiw$ex$gevv}mrk$zepyi2$Xli$gevv}mrk$zepyi$sj

givxemr$hifx$mrwxvyqirxw0$mj$ettpmgefpi0$mw$rix$sj$yreqsvxm~ih$hmwgsyrx2$Xli$jspps{mrk$xefpiw$tviwirx$xli$gevv}mrk$zepyiw$sj$xlswi

jmrergmep$mrwxvyqirxw$erh$xli$iwxmqexih$gsvviwtsrhmrk$jemv$zepyiw$ex$Qevgl$750$6464$erh$Higiqfiv$750$645=$,mr$xlsywerhw->

$

$ $ $ $ $ Iwxmqexih$Jemv$Zepyi$Qiewyviqirxw$ex$Qevgl$750$6464 $

$ $

Gevv}mrk$Zepyi$ewsj$Qevgl$750

6464 $ $Xsxep$JemvZepyi $ $ Pizip$5 $ $ Pizip$6 $ $ Pizip$7 $

Ewwixw> $ $ $$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $$ $ $ $$ $ $ $ $

Gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw $ ( 760858$ $ ( 760858$ $ ( 760858$ $ ( Ó$ $ ( Ó$

Viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$mrziwxqirxw $ $ 7405:;$ $ $ 7405:;$ $ $ 7405:;$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$

Pmefmpmxmiw> $ $ $$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $$ $ $ $$ $ $ $ $

Fsvvs{mrkw$yrhiv$wirmsv$gvihmx$jegmpmx} $ ( 506:90<<:$ $ ( 504=50:=:$ $ ( Ó$ $ ( 504=50:=:$ $ ( Ó$

92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466 $ $ 5=70=9<$ $ $ 5;805=4$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 5;805=4$ $ $ Ó$

92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6467 $ $ 6=80944$ $ $ 66809<:$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 66809<:$ $ $ Ó$

92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468 $ $ 6940444$ $ $ 5<407=<$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 5<407=<$ $ $ Ó$

:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$646: $ $ 7940444$ $ $ 66<0<4:$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 66<0<4:$ $ $ Ó$

Rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx $ $ 6<<04;8$ $ $ 6<<0597$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 6<<0597$ $ $ Ó$

$

$ $ $ $ $ Iwxmqexih$Jemv$Zepyi$Qiewyviqirxw$ex$Higiqfiv$750$645= $

$ $

Gevv}mrk$Zepyi$ewsj$Higiqfiv$750

645= $ $Xsxep$JemvZepyi $ $ Pizip$5 $ $ Pizip$6 $ $ Pizip$7 $

Ewwixw> $ $ $$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $$ $ $ $$ $ $ $ $

Gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw $ ( 7608:7$ $ ( 7608:7$ $ ( 7608:7$ $ ( Ó$ $ ( Ó$

Viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$mrziwxqirxw $ $ 790454$ $ $ 790454$ $ $ 790454$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$

Pmefmpmxmiw> $ $ $$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $$ $ $ $$ $ $ $ $

Fsvvs{mrkw$yrhiv$wirmsv$gvihmx$jegmpmx} $ ( 506=<0:;5$ $ ( 5065<0<:5$ $ ( Ó$ $ ( 5065<0<:5$ $ ( Ó$

92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466 $ $ 5=70=9<$ $ $ 5=8067=$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 5=8067=$ $ $ Ó$

92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6467 $ $ 7440444$ $ $ 6<;0=<6$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 6<;0=<6$ $ $ Ó$

92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468 $ $ 6940444$ $ $ 66<08=7$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 66<08=7$ $ $ Ó$

:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$646: $ $ 7940444$ $ $ 7580496$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 7580496$ $ $ Ó$

Rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx $ $ 76<05;<$ $ $ 76;0;=6$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 76;0;=6$ $ $ Ó$

$Xli$jemv$zepyiw$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw0$erh$viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$mrziwxqirxw$ettvs|mqexiw$xli$gevv}mrk$zepyiw$sj

xliwi$ewwixw$ex$Qevgl$750$6464$erh$Higiqfiv$750$645=2$Viwxvmgxih$gewl$gsrwmwxw$sj$qsri}$qevoix$jyrhw0$fero$hitswmxw0$gsqqivgmep

tetiv$erh$xmqi$hitswmxw$ywih$jsv$ewwix$vitpegiqirx$jyrhw$erh$sxliv$jyrhw$gsrxvegxyepp}$viuymvih$xs$fi$qemrxemrih$ex$xli$Gsqter}+w

Eywxvepmer$wyfwmhmev}2$Xli$jemv$zepyi$sj$xli$qsri}$qevoix$jyrhw$erh$fero$hitswmxw$mw$fewih$sr$uysxih$qevoix$tvmgiw$,Pizip$5-$erh$xli

jemv$zepyi$sj$gsqqivgmep$tetiv$erh$xmqi$hitswmxw$mw$fewih$sr$qevoix$tvmgiw$jsv$wmqmpev$mrwxvyqirxw$,Pizip$6-2

Xli$jemv$zepyiw$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$92<;9)$wirmsv$yrwigyvih$rsxiw$hyi$6466$,&92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466&-0$92<;9)$wirmsv

yrwigyvih$rsxiw$hyi$6468$,&92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468&-0$:244)$wirmsv$yrwigyvih$rsxiw$hyi$646:$,Ô:244)$Wirmsv$RsxiwÕ-0$erh$xli

92569)$wirmsv$yrwigyvih$rsxiw$hyi$6467$,&92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw&-0$epxlsykl$rsx$egxmzip}$xvehih0$evi$fewih$sr$tyfpmwlih$jmrergmep$hexe

jsv$xliwi$mrwxvyqirxw2$Xli$jemv$zepyiw$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx$vipexih$xs$xli$[ewlmrkxsr$Igsrsqmg$Hizipstqirx$Jmrergi

Eyxlsvmx}$,&[IHJE&-$erh$xli$Gsqter}×w$Eywxvepmer$wyfwmhmev}$evi$iwxmqexih$fewih$sr$qevoix$tvmgiw$sj$wmqmpev$mrwxvyqirxw2$Xli$jemv

zepyi$sj$fsvvs{mrkw$yrhiv$xli$wirmsv$gvihmx$jegmpmx}$mw$fewih$sr$er$iwxmqexi$sj$xvehmrk$zepyi$gsrwmhivmrk$xli$Gsqter}×w$fsvvs{mrk$vexi0

xli$yrhve{r$wtvieh$erh$wmqmpev$mrwxvyqirxw2

54

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 14 of 88

Page 290: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 583;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

92$VIWXVMGXIH$GEWL$ERH$GEWL$IUYMZEPIRXW

Xli$jspps{mrk$xefpi$tvszmhiw$e$vigsrgmpmexmsr$sj$gewl0$gewl$iuymzepirxw$erh$viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw$vitsvxih$sr$xli

gsrwspmhexih$fepergi$wliixw$xlex$wyq$xs$xli$xsxep$sj$xli$weqi$wygl$eqsyrxw$wls{r$mr$xli$gsrwspmhexih$wxexiqirxw$sj$gewl$jps{w>

$

$Qevgl$750

6464 $ $Qevgl$750

645= $

Gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw $ ( 760858$ $ ( :;0;6<$

Viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw$1$gyvvirx $ $ 6;0<:9$ $ $ 970;8=$

Viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$mrziwxqirxw$1$rsr1gyvvirx $ $ 6;06;5$ $ $ 6;06<6$

Piww$Viwxvmgxih$mrziwxqirxw$1$rsr1gyvvirx $ $ ,680=:=- $ $ ,680=98-

Xsxep$gewl0$gewl$iuymzepirxw$erh$viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$gewl

$$$iuymzepirxw$wls{r$mr$xli$wxexiqirx$sj$gewl$jps{w $ ( :609<5$ $ ( 5670<49$

$Eqsyrxw$mrgpyhih$mr$viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw$evi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$givxemr$gsrxvegxyep$gewl$viwxvmgxmsr$viuymviqirxw$ex$xli

Gsqter}+w${lspp}$s{rih$Eywxvepmer$wyfwmhmev}$vipexih$xs$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx$erh$ewwix$vitpegiqirx$jyrhw$gsrxvegxyepp}$viuymvih$xs$fi

qemrxemrih$erh$sxliv$kyeverxiiw2$Viwxvmgxih$mrziwxqirxw$1$rsr1gyvvirx$,mrgpyhih$mr$Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Mrziwxqirxw$mr$xli

eggsqter}mrk$gsrwspmhexih$fepergi$wliixw-$gsrwmwxw$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$veffm$xvywx$iwxefpmwlih$jsv$iqtps}ii$erh$iqtps}iv$gsrxvmfyxmsrw

xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2$Rsr1uyepmjmih$Hijivvih$Gsqtirwexmsr$Tper$erh$mw$rsx$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$e$viwxvmgxih$gewl$iuymzepirx2$Vijiv$xs

Rsxi$7$1$Jmrergmep$Mrwxvyqirxw2

:2$WLEVILSPHIVW×$IUYMX]

Xli$jspps{mrk$xefpi$tviwirxw$xli$glerkiw$mr$wlevilsphivw×$iuymx}$xlex$evi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$xli$Gsqter}×w$wlevilsphivw$erh$xs

rsrgsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw$jsv$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$6464$erh$645=$,mr$xlsywerhw->

$

$ Gsqqsr$wleviw $ $EhhmxmsrepTemh1Mr $ $

Hmwxvmfyxmsrwmr$I|giww$sj $ $

EggyqypexihSxliv

Gsqtvilirwmzi $ $ Xviewyv}$wleviw $ $ Rsrgsrxvsppmrk$ $Xsxep

Wlevilsphivw+$

$ $ Wleviw $ $ Eqsyrx $ $ Getmxep $ $ Ievrmrkw $ $ Psww $ $ Wleviw $ $ Eqsyrx $ $ Mrxiviwxw $ $ Iuymx} $

Jsv$xli$Xlvii

$$$Qsrxlw$Irhih

$$$Qevgl$750$6464 $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Fepergi0$Neryev}$50

6464 $ $ 5650669$ $( 50698$ $ (506740<:9$ $ ( ,55=0;;=- $ ( ,640779- $ $ 80654$ $ ( ,=905;9- $ ( ,;<6- $ ( ==:048<$

Wxsgo1fewih

$$$gsqtirwexmsr

$$$i|tirwi $ $ Ó$ $$ Ó$ $ $ =0;:<$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ =0;:<$

Viwxvmgxih$wxsgo

kverxih $ $ =44$ $$ =$ $ $ ,=- $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$

Viwxvmgxih$wxsgo

$$$gergipih $ $ ,65- $$ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$

Hmzmhirhw$temh$_5a $ $ Ó$ $$ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,9;0;47- $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,9;0;47-

Sxliv$ehnywxqirx$xs

ehhmxmsrep$temh1mr

getmxep$_6a $ $ Ó$ $$ Ó$ $ $ <0=69$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ <0=69$

Tyvglewi$sj$xviewyv}

wleviw $ $ ,998- $$ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 998$ $ $ ,=044=- $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,=044=-

Wleviw${mxlliph$jsv$rix

$$$wixxpiqirxw$sj$wlevi1

$$$fewih$e{evhw$_7a $ $ ,5;8- $$ ,6- $ $ ,60:74- $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,60:76-

Mwwyergi$sj$gsqqsr

$$$wxsgo$1$IWTT $ $ 54$ $ $ 5$ $ $ 58=$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 594$

Rix$mrgsqi$,psww- $ $ Ó$ $$ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 6905<5$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,:4- $ $ 690565$

Sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi

$$$mrgsqi$,psww- $ $ Ó$ $$ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,5705:8- $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,8<- $ $ ,570656-

Fepergi0$Qevgl$750

$$$6464 $ $ 56507<:$ $( 506:6$ $ (5068;04:<$ $ ( ,5960745- $ ( ,7708==- $ $ 80;:8$ $ ( ,54805<8- $ ( ,<=4- $ ( =9;089:$

55

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 15 of 88

Page 291: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 593;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

$

$ Gsqqsr$wleviw $ $EhhmxmsrepTemh1Mr $ $

Hmwxvmfyxmsrwmr

I|giww$sj $ $

EggyqypexihSxliv

Gsqtvilirwmzi $ $ Xviewyv}$wleviw $ $ Rsrgsrxvsppmrk$ $Xsxep

Wlevilsphivw+$

$ $ Wleviw $ $ Eqsyrx $ $ Getmxep $ $ Ievrmrkw $ $ Psww $ $ Wleviw $ $ Eqsyrx $ $ Mrxiviwxw $ $ Iuymx} $

Jsv$xli$Xlvii

$$$Qsrxlw$Irhih

$$$Qevgl$750$645= $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Fepergi0$Neryev}$50

645= $ ( 56409<9$ $ ( 5068<$ $ (506540=5:$ $ ( ,960<:<- $ ( ,670:5<- $ $ 80654$ $ ( ,=905;9- $ ( ,9==- $ (5047=0=48$

Tvsgiihw$jvsq

i|ivgmwi

$$$sj$wxsgo$stxmsrw $ $ 66$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 777$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 777$

Wxsgo1fewih

$$$gsqtirwexmsr

$$$i|tirwi $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ :0;6;$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ :0;6;$

Viwxvmgxih$wxsgo

$$$kverxih $ $ ;;<$ $ $ <$ $ $ ,<- $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 1$

Viwxvmgxih$wxsgo

$$$gergipih $ $ ,:- $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 1$

Hmzmhirhw$temh $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,9;0=89- $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,9;0=89-

Wleviw${mxlliph$jsv

rix

$$$wixxpiqirxw$sj$wlevi1

$$$fewih$e{evhw$_7a $ $ ,5=<- $ $ ,6- $ $ ,805;4- $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,805;6-

Xverwmxmsr$ehnywxqirx

jsv$eggsyrxmrk

wxerhevh$ehstxmsr$_8a $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,=:<- $ $ =:<$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 1$

Mwwyergi$sj$gsqqsr

$$$wxsgo$1$IWTT $ $ :$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 568$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 568$

Rix$mrgsqi$,psww- $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 840;49$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,9:- $ $ 840:8=$

Sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi

$$$mrgsqi$,psww- $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 506<8$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 506<8$

Fepergi0

$$$Qevgl$750$645= $ $ 56505<;$ $ ( 50698$ $ (506570=66$ $ ( ,;504;:- $ ( ,6507::- $ $ 80654$ $ ( ,=905;9- $ ( ,:99- $ (5046:0=48$

$$

_5a Hmzmhirhw$temh$evi$rix$sj$hmzmhirhw$jsvjimxih$sr$yrziwxih$wleviw$sj$viwxvmgxih$wxsgo2

$

_6a Sr$Jifvyev}$6:0$6464$,xli$&Ijjigxmzi$Hexi&-0$xli$Gsqter}$erh$mxw$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$,ÔGISÕ-$irxivih$mrxs$er$eqirhih

erh$viwxexih$i|igyxmzi$vixmviqirx$ekviiqirx$xlex$eqirhw$erh$vitpegiw$xli$GIS×w$tvmsv$i|igyxmzi$vixmviqirx$ekviiqirx2$Xli

eqirhih$erh$viwxexih$i|igyxmzi$vixmviqirx$ekviiqirx$tvszmhiw$xlex$ytsr$xli$GIS×w$vixmviqirx$jvsq$xli$Gsqter}0$xli$Gsqter}

{mpp$te}$e$pyqt$wyq$eqsyrx$gyvvirxp}$iuyep$xs$(<0=6904:9$,xli$ÔKverhjexlivih$Te}qirxÕ-${lmgl${mpp$fi$temh$mr$xli$jsvq$sj$xli

Gsqter}×w$gsqqsr$wxsgo2$Xli$jemv$zepyi$sj$xli$Kverhjexlivih$te}qirx${ew$vigpewwmjmih$xs$wxsgolsphivw×$iuymx}$ew$sj$Qevgl$750

64642$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$57$Ò$Firijmx$Tperw$jsv$jyvxliv$mrjsvqexmsr2

$

_7a Hyvmrk$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$6464$erh$645=0$xli$Gsqter}${mxlliph$wleviw$xlvsykl$rix$wlevi$wixxpiqirxw$xs$wexmwj}

wxexyxsv}$xe|${mxllsphmrk$viuymviqirxw$ytsr$ziwxmrk$sj$wleviw$sj$viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$liph$f}$iqtps}iiw2

_8a Sr$Neryev}$50$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$ehstxih$Eggsyrxmrk$Wxerhevh$Ythexi$,&EWY&-$Rs2$645<146$&Mrgsqi$Wxexiqirx1Vitsvxmrk

Gsqtvilirwmzi$Mrgsqi1Vigpewwmjmgexmsr$sj$Givxemr$Xe|$Ijjigxw$jvsq$Eggyqypexih$Sxliv$Gsqtvilirwmzi$Mrgsqi&2

$

VIMX$Hmwxvmfyxmsrw

Ew$e$VIMX0$KIS$mw$viuymvih$xs$hmwxvmfyxi$erryepp}$ex$piewx$=4)$sj$mxw$VIMX$xe|efpi$mrgsqi$,hixivqmrih${mxlsyx$vikevh$xs$xli$hmzmhirhw

temh$hihygxmsr$erh$f}$i|gpyhmrk$rix$getmxep$kemr-$erh$fiker$te}mrk$vikypev$uyevxivp}$VIMX$hmzmhirhw$mr$64572$Xli$eqsyrx0$xmqmrk$erh

jviuyirg}$sj$jyxyvi$hmzmhirhw0$ls{iziv0${mpp$fi$ex$xli$wspi$hmwgvixmsr$sj$KIS+w$Fsevh$sj$Hmvigxsvw$,xli$&FsevhÕ-$erh${mpp$fi$higpevih

fewih$ytsr$zevmsyw$jegxsvw0$qer}$sj${lmgl$evi$fi}srh$KIS+w$gsrxvsp0$mrgpyhmrk0$KIS+w$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$stivexmrk$gewl$jps{w0

xli$eqsyrx$viuymvih$xs$qemrxemr$VIMX$wxexyw0$pmqmxexmsrw$sr$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$mr$KIS+w$i|mwxmrk$erh$jyxyvi$hifx$mrwxvyqirxw0$pmqmxexmsrw$sr

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 16 of 88

Page 292: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 5:3;9

KIS+w$efmpmx}$xs$jyrh$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$ywmrk$gewl$kirivexih$xlvsykl$KIS+w$xe|efpi$VIMX$wyfwmhmevmiw$,&XVWw&-$erh$sxliv$jegxsvw$xlex

KIS+w$Fsevh$qe}$hiiq$vipizerx2

56

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 17 of 88

Page 293: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 5;3;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

Hyvmrk$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$6464$erh$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$KIS$higpevih$erh$temh$xli$jspps{mrk$vikypev

gewl$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$xs$mxw$wlevilsphivw$ew$jspps{w>

$

Higpevexmsr$Hexi $ Vigsvh$Hexi $ Te}qirx$Hexi $HmwxvmfyxmsrTiv$Wlevi $ $

EkkvikexiTe}qirx$Eqsyrx

,mr$qmppmsrw- $

Jifvyev}$80$645= $ Jifvyev}$590$645= $ Jifvyev}$660$645= $ ( 428<$ $ ( 9;2=$

Etvmp$70$645= $ Etvmp$590$645= $ Etvmp$660$645= $ ( 428<$ $ ( 9<26$

Nyp}$=0$645= $ Nyp}$5=0$645= $ Nyp}$6:0$645= $ ( 428<$ $ ( 9<26$

Sgxsfiv$580$645= $ Sgxsfiv$690$645= $ Rsziqfiv$50$645= $ ( 428<$ $ ( 9<26$

Jifvyev}$70$6464 $ Jifvyev}$580$6464 $ Jifvyev}$650$6464 $ ( 428<$ $ ( 9<26$

$Wxsgo$Fy}fego$Tvskveq

Sr$Jifvyev}$580$645<0$xli$Gsqter}$errsyrgih$xlex$mxw$Fsevh$eyxlsvm~ih$e$wxsgo$fy}fego$tvskveq$eyxlsvm~mrk$xli$Gsqter}$xs

vityvglewi$yt$xs$e$qe|mqyq$sj$(64424$qmppmsr$sj$mxw$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo2$Xli$wxsgo$fy}fego$tvskveq${mpp$fi$jyrhih$tvmqevmp}

{mxl$gewl$sr$lerh0$jvii$gewl$jps{$erh$fsvvs{mrkw$yrhiv$xli$Gsqter}+w$(=4424$qmppmsr$vizspzmrk$gvihmx$jegmpmx}$,xli$&Vizspziv&-2$Xli

tvskveq$mw$ijjigxmzi$xlvsykl$Sgxsfiv$640$64642$Xli$wxsgo$fy}fego$tvskveq$mw$mrxirhih$xs$fi$mqtpiqirxih$xlvsykl$tyvglewiw$qehi

jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi$mr$xli$stir$qevoix$sv$mr$tvmzexip}$riksxmexih$xverwegxmsrw0$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$ettpmgefpi$Wigyvmxmiw$erh$I|glerki

Gsqqmwwmsr$,&WIG&-$viuymviqirxw2$Xli$wxsgo$fy}fego$tvskveq$hsiw$rsx$sfpmkexi$xli$Gsqter}$xs$tyvglewi$er}$wtigmjmg$eqsyrx$sj$xli

Gsqter}+w$gsqqsr$wxsgo$erh$qe}$fi$wywtirhih$sv$i|xirhih$ex$er}$xmqi$ex$xli$hmwgvixmsr$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$Fsevh2$Xli$Gsqter}

vityvglewih$9970::9$wleviw$sj$mxw$gsqqsr$wxsgo$hyvmrk$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$64642$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$57$Ò$Firijmx$Tperw$jsv

jyvxliv$mrjsvqexmsr2$Xli$Gsqter}$fipmiziw$mx$lew$xli$efmpmx}$xs$gsrxmryi$xs$jyrh$xli$wxsgo$fy}fego$tvskveq0$mxw$hifx$wivzmgi

viuymviqirxw$erh$mxw$qemrxirergi$erh$kvs{xl$getmxep$i|tirhmxyvi$viuymviqirxw0${lmpi$qemrxemrmrk$wyjjmgmirx$pmuymhmx}$jsv$sxliv

gsvtsvexi$tyvtswiw2

Tvswtigxyw$Wyttpiqirx

Sr$Sgxsfiv$640$645;0$xli$Gsqter}$jmpih${mxl$xli$WIG$er$eyxsqexmg$wlipj$vikmwxvexmsr$sr$Jsvq$W172$Yrhiv$xlmw$wlipj$vikmwxvexmsr0$xli

Gsqter}$qe}0$jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi0$wipp$er}$gsqfmrexmsr$sj$wigyvmxmiw$hiwgvmfih$mr$xli$tvswtigxyw$mr$sri$sv$qsvi$sjjivmrkw2$Iegl$xmqi

xlex$xli$Gsqter}$qe}$wipp$wigyvmxmiw0$xli$Gsqter}${mpp$tvszmhi$e$tvswtigxyw$wyttpiqirx$xlex${mpp$gsrxemr$wtigmjmg$mrjsvqexmsr$efsyx

xli$xivqw$sj$xlex$sjjivmrk$erh$xli$wigyvmxmiw$fimrk$sjjivih2$Sr$Rsziqfiv$=0$645;0$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$wlipj$vikmwxvexmsr0$xli

Gsqter}$jmpih${mxl$xli$WIG$e$tvswtigxyw$wyttpiqirx$vipexih$xs$xli$sjjiv$erh$wepi$jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$gsqqsr$wxsgo

ex$er$ekkvikexi$sjjivmrk$tvmgi$sj$yt$xs$(594$qmppmsr$xlvsykl$wepiw$ekirxw2$Wepiw$sj$wleviw$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$gsqqsr$wxsgo$yrhiv$xli

tvswtigxyw$wyttpiqirx$erh$xli$iuymx}$hmwxvmfyxmsr$ekviiqirxw$irxivih$mrxs${mxl$xli$wepiw$ekirxw0$mj$er}0$qe}$fi$qehi$mr$riksxmexih

xverwegxmsrw$sv$xverwegxmsrw$xlex$evi$hiiqih$xs$fi$Ôex$xli$qevoixÕ$sjjivmrkw$ew$hijmrih$mr$Vypi$859$yrhiv$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$Egx$sj$5=772

Xlivi${ivi$rs$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$wsph$yrhiv$xlmw$tvswtigxyw$wyttpiqirx$hyvmrk$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$6464$sv$645=2

Gsqtvilirwmzi$Mrgsqi$,Psww-

Gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$,psww-$vitviwirxw$xli$glerki$mr$wlevilsphivw+$iuymx}$jvsq$xverwegxmsrw$erh$sxliv$izirxw$erh$gmvgyqwxergiw

evmwmrk$jvsq$rsr1wlevilsphiv$wsyvgiw2$Xli$Gsqter}+w$xsxep$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$,psww-$mw$gsqtvmwih$sj$rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs

KIS0$rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$rsrgsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw0$jsvimkr$gyvvirg}$xverwpexmsr$ehnywxqirxw$xlex$evmwi$jvsq$gsrwspmhexmrk$jsvimkr

stivexmsrw$xlex$hs$rsx$mqtegx$gewl$jps{w0$rix$yrviepm~ih$kemrw$erh3sv$pswwiw$sr$hivmzexmzi$mrwxvyqirxw0$erh$tirwmsr$pmefmpmx}$ehnywxqirxw

{mxlmr$wlevilsphivw+$iuymx}$erh$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$,psww-2

Xli$gsqtsrirxw$sj$eggyqypexih$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$,psww-$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS${mxlmr$wlevilsphivw+$iuymx}$evi$ew$jspps{w>

$

$ Xlvii$Qsrxlw$Irhih$Qevgl$750$6464 $

$ $ ,Mr$xlsywerhw- $

$ $

Jsvimkr$gyvvirg}xverwpexmsrehnywxqirxw0rix$sj$xe|

exxvmfyxefpixs$Xli$KIS

Kvsyt0$Mrg2$,5- $ $

Glerkimr$jemvzepyi$sj

hivmzexmziw0rix$sj$xe| $ $

Tirwmsrehnywxqirxw0rix$sj$xe| $ $ Xsxep $

Fepergi0$Neryev}$50$6464 $ ( ,560758- $ ( ,508;:- $ ( ,:0989- $ ( ,640779-

Gyvvirx1tivmsh$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$,psww- $ $ ,<0;9=- $ $ ,80956- $ $ 54;$ $ $ ,5705:8-

Fepergi0$Qevgl$750$6464 $ ( ,6504;7- $ ( ,90=<<- $ ( ,:087<- $ ( ,7708==-

$$ ,5- Xli$jsvimkr$gyvvirg}$xverwpexmsr$vipexih$xs$rsrgsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw${ew$rsx$wmkrmjmgerx$ex$Qevgl$750$64642

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 18 of 88

Page 294: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 5<3;9

$

57

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 19 of 88

Page 295: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 5=3;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

$ Xlvii$Qsrxlw$Irhih$Qevgl$750$645= $

$ $ ,Mr$xlsywerhw- $

$

$

Jsvimkr$gyvvirg}xverwpexmsrehnywxqirxw0rix$sj$xe|

exxvmfyxefpixs$Xli$KIS

Kvsyt0$Mrg2$,5- $ $

Glerkimr$jemvzepyi$sj

hivmzexmziw0rix$sj$xe| $ $

Tirwmsrehnywxqirxw0rix$sj$xe| $ $ Xsxep $

Fepergi0$Neryev}$50$645= $ $ ,5809;7- $ $ ,90;8:- $ $ ,706==- $ $ ,670:5<-

Gyvvirx1tivmsh$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$,psww- $ $ 50;7:$ $ $ 505:8$ $ $ ,:8<- $ $ 60696$

Fepergi0$Qevgl$750$645= $ $ ,560<7;- $ $ ,809<6- $ $ ,70=8;- $ $ ,6507::-

$$ ,5- Xli$jsvimkr$gyvvirg}$xverwpexmsr$vipexih$xs$rsrgsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw${ew$rsx$wmkrmjmgerx$ex$Qevgl$750$645=2

$

;2$IUYMX]$MRGIRXMZI$TPERW

Xli$Fsevh$ehstxih$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2$645<$Wxsgo$Mrgirxmzi$Tper$,xli$&645<$Tper&-0${lmgl${ew$ettvszih$f}$xli$Gsqter}+w

wlevilsphivw$sr$Etvmp$680$645<2$Xli$645<$Tper$vitpegih$xli$6458$Wxsgo$Mrgirxmzi$Tper$,xli$&6458$Tper&-2$Ew$sj$xli$hexi$xli$645<$Tper

{ew$ehstxih0$mx$tvszmhih$jsv$e$viwivzi$sj$80:440444$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$xlex$qe}$fi$mwwyih$tyvwyerx$xs$e{evhw$kverxih$yrhiv$xli

645<$Tper2$Xli$Gsqter}$jmpih$e$Jsvq$W1<$vikmwxvexmsr$wxexiqirx$vipexih$xs$xli$645<$Tper$sr$Qe}$550$645<2

Wxsgo$Stxmsrw

Xli$Gsqter}$ywiw$e$Fpego1Wglspiw$stxmsr$zepyexmsr$qship$xs$iwxmqexi$xli$jemv$zepyi$sj$iegl$xmqi1fewih$sv$tivjsvqergi1fewih$stxmsr

e{evhih2$Jsv$stxmsrw$kverxih$hyvmrk$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$64640$xli$jemv$zepyi${ew$iwxmqexih$ywmrk$xli$jspps{mrk

ewwyqtxmsrw>$,m-$zspexmpmx}$sj$85285)?$,mm-$i|tigxih$xivq$sj$924$}ievw?$,mmm-$vmwo$jvii$mrxiviwx$vexi$sj$52;=)?$erh$,mz-$i|tigxih$hmzmhirh

}miph$sj$57255)2$E$wyqqev}$sj$xli$egxmzmx}$sj$wxsgo$stxmsr$e{evhw$mwwyih$erh$syxwxerhmrk$yrhiv$Gsqter}$tperw${ew$ew$jspps{w$jsv$xli

xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$6464>

$

$ Wleviw $ $

[xh2$Ezk2I|ivgmwiTvmgi $ $

[xh2$Ezk2ViqemrmrkGsrxvegxyepXivq$,}ievw- $ $

EkkvikexiMrxvmrwmgZepyi $

$ $ ,mr$xlsywerhw-$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ ,mr$xlsywerhw- $

Stxmsrw$syxwxerhmrk$ex$Neryev}$50$6464 $ $ 509=4$ $ ( 6826=$ $ $ :2=4$ $ ( 676$

Stxmsrw$kverxih $ $ 8<4$ $ $ 582:8$ $ $ $$ $ $ $ $

Stxmsrw$i|ivgmwih $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ $$ $ $ $ $

Stxmsrw$jsvjimxih3gergipih3i|tmvih $ $ ,67- $ $ 692:<$ $ $ $$ $ $ $ $

Stxmsrw$syxwxerhmrk$ex$Qevgl$750$6464 $ $ 6048;$ $ ( 66246$ $ $ ;288$ $ ( Ó$

Stxmsrw$ziwxih$erh$i|tigxih$xs$ziwx$ex$Qevgl$750$6464 $ $ 50=4=$ $ ( 66274$ $ $ ;274$ $ ( Ó$

Stxmsrw$i|ivgmwefpi$ex$Qevgl$750$6464 $ $ 504<;$ $ ( 6829;$ $ $ 92=9$ $ ( Ó$

$Sr$Qevgl$50$64640$xli$Gsqter}$kverxih$ettvs|mqexip}$8<40444$stxmsrw$xs$givxemr$iqtps}iiw${lmgl$leh$e$tiv$wlevi$kverx$hexi$jemv

zepyi$sj$(529=2$Jsv$iegl$sj$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$6464$erh$645=0$xli$eqsyrx$sj$wxsgo1fewih$gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwi$vipexih

xs$wxsgo$stxmsrw${ew$(427$qmppmsr2$Ew$sj$Qevgl$750$64640$xli$Gsqter}$leh$(627$qmppmsr$sj$yrvigskrm~ih$gsqtirwexmsr$gswxw$vipexih$xs

rsr1ziwxih$wxsgo$stxmsr$e{evhw$xlex$evi$i|tigxih$xs$fi$vigskrm~ih$sziv$e${imklxih$eziveki$tivmsh$sj$724$}ievw2

Viwxvmgxih$Wxsgo

Gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwi$jsv$rsrziwxih$wxsgo$e{evhw$mw$vigsvhih$sziv$xli$ziwxmrk$tivmsh$fewih$sr$xli$jemv$zepyi$ex$xli$hexi$sj$kverx2

Kirivepp}0$xli$viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$e{evhw$ziwx$mr$iuyep$mrgviqirxw$sziv$imxliv$e$xlvii$sv$jsyv1}iev$tivmsh2$Xli$jemv$zepyi$sj$viwxvmgxih$wxsgo

e{evhw0${lmgl$hs$rsx$gsrxemr$e$qevoix1fewih$ziwxmrk$gsrhmxmsr0$mw$hixivqmrih$ywmrk$xli$gpswmrk$tvmgi$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$gsqqsr$wxsgo

sr$xli$hexi$sj$kverx2$Xli$Gsqter}$lew$lmwxsvmgepp}$mwwyih$wlevi1fewih$e{evhw${mxl$wivzmgi1fewih0$tivjsvqergi1fewih$erh$qevoix1fewih

ziwxmrk$gvmxivme2

58

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 20 of 88

Page 296: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 643;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

E$wyqqev}$sj$xli$egxmzmx}$sj$viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$syxwxerhmrk$mw$ew$jspps{w$jsv$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$6464>

$

$ Wleviw $ $

[xh2$Ezk2Kverx$HexiJemv$Zepyi $

$ $ ,mr$xlsywerhw- $ $ $ $ $

Viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$syxwxerhmrk$ex$Neryev}$50$6464 $ $ 6048;$ $ ( 6;277$

Kverxih $ $ =44$ $ $ 59274$

Ziwxih $ $ ,;76- $ $ 6;2<5$

Jsvjimxih3gergipih $ $ ,65- $ $ 662:;$

Viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$syxwxerhmrk$ex$Qevgl$750$6464 $ $ 605=8$ $ ( 6429=$

$Sr$Qevgl$750$64640$xli$Gsqter}$kverxih$ettvs|mqexip}$=440444$wleviw$sj$viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$xs$givxemr$iqtps}iiw$erh$i|igyxmzi

sjjmgivw2$Sj$xliwi$e{evhw0$7:40444$evi$qevoix$erh$tivjsvqergi1fewih$e{evhw${lmgl${mpp$fi$jsvjimxih$mj$xli$Gsqter}$hsiw$rsx$eglmizi

givxemr$erryep$qixvmgw$hyvmrk$64640$6465$erh$64662

Xli$ziwxmrk$sj$xliwi$tivjsvqergi1fewih$viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$kverxw$evi$wyfnigx$xs$xli$eglmiziqirx$f}$KIS$sj$x{s$erryep$tivjsvqergi

qixvmgw$ew$jspps{w>$,m-$yt$xs$94)$sj$xli$wleviw$sj$viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$,&XWV$Xevkix$E{evh&-$ger$ziwx$ex$xli$irh$sj$e$xlvii$}iev$tivjsvqergi

tivmsh$mj$KIS$qiixw$givxemr$xsxep$wlevilsphiv$vixyvr$,&XWV&-$tivjsvqergi$xevkixw0$ew$gsqtevih$xs$xli$xsxep$wlevilsphiv$vixyvr$sj$e$tiiv

kvsyt$sj$gsqtermiw0$sziv$e$xlvii$}iev$tivmsh$jvsq$Neryev}$50$6464$xs$Higiqfiv$750$6466$erh$,mm-$yt$xs$94)$sj$xli$wleviw$sj$viwxvmgxih

wxsgo$,&VSGI$Xevkix$E{evh&-$ger$ziwx$ex$xli$irh$sj$e$xlvii$}iev$tivmsh$mj$KIS$qiixw$givxemr$vixyvr$sr$getmxep$iqtps}ih$,&VSGI&-

tivjsvqergi$xevkixw$sziv$e$xlvii$}iev$tivmsh$jvsq$Neryev}$50$6464$xs$Higiqfiv$750$64662$Xliwi$qevoix$erh$tivjsvqergi$e{evhw$ger

ziwx$ex$fix{iir$4)$erh$644)$sj$xli$xevkix$e{evhw$jsv$fsxl$qixvmgw2$Xli$ryqfiv$sj$wleviw$wls{r$jsv$xli$tivjsvqergi1fewih$e{evhw$mw

fewih$sr$xli$xevkix$e{evhw$jsv$fsxl$qixvmgw2

Xli$qixvmg$vipexih$xs$VSGI$mw$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$e$tivjsvqergi$gsrhmxmsr2$Jsv$wlevi1fewih$e{evhw$xlex$gsrxemr$e$tivjsvqergi$gsrhmxmsr0

xli$eglmiziqirx$sj$xli$xevkixw$qywx$fi$tvsfefpi$fijsvi$er}$wlevi1fewih$gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwi$mw$vigsvhih2$Xli$Gsqter}$vizmi{w$xli

pmoipmlssh$sj${lmgl$xli$xevkix$mr$xli$verki${mpp$fi$eglmizih$erh$mj$hiiqih$tvsfefpi0$gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwi$mw$vigsvhih$ex$xlex$xmqi2$Mj

wyfwiuyirx$xs$mrmxmep$qiewyviqirx$xlivi$mw$e$glerki$mr$xli$iwxmqexi$sj$xli$tvsfefmpmx}$sj$qiixmrk$xli$tivjsvqergi$gsrhmxmsr0$xli$ijjigx

sj$xli$glerki$mr$xli$iwxmqexih$uyerxmx}$sj$e{evhw$i|tigxih$xs$ziwx$mw$vigskrm~ih$f}$gyqypexmzip}$ehnywxmrk$gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwi2$Mj

ypxmqexip}$xli$tivjsvqergi$xevkixw$evi$rsx$qix0$jsv$er}$e{evhw${livi$ziwxmrk${ew$tvizmsywp}$hiiqih$tvsfefpi0$tvizmsywp}$vigskrm~ih

gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwi${mpp$fi$vizivwih$mr$xli$tivmsh$mr${lmgl$ziwxmrk$mw$rs$psrkiv$hiiqih$tvsfefpi2$Xli$jemv$zepyi$sj$xliwi$e{evhw${ew

hixivqmrih$fewih$sr$xli$gpswmrk$tvmgi$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$gsqqsr$wxsgo$sr$xli$hexi$sj$kverx2

Xli$qixvmg$vipexih$xs$XWV$mw$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$e$qevoix$gsrhmxmsr2$Jsv$wlevi1fewih$e{evhw$xlex$gsrxemr$e$qevoix$gsrhmxmsr0$xli

tvsfefmpmx}$sj$wexmwj}mrk$xli$qevoix$gsrhmxmsr$qywx$fi$gsrwmhivih$mr$xli$iwxmqexi$sj$kverx1hexi$jemv$zepyi$erh$tvizmsywp}$vigsvhih

gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwi$mw$rsx$vizivwih$mj$xli$qevoix$gsrhmxmsr$mw$riziv$qix2$Xli$jemv$zepyi$sj$xliwi$e{evhw${ew$hixivqmrih$fewih$sr$e

Qsrxi$Gevps$wmqypexmsr0${lmgl$gepgypexiw$e$verki$sj$tswwmfpi$syxgsqiw$erh$xli$tvsfefmpmxmiw$xlex$xli}${mpp$sggyv0$ywmrk$xli$jspps{mrk

oi}$ewwyqtxmsrw>$,m-$zspexmpmx}$sj$7427)?$,mm-$fixe$sj$525?$erh$,mmm-$vmwo$jvii$vexi$sj$42<9)2

Jsv$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$6464$erh$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$vigskrm~ih$(=29$qmppmsr$erh$(:29$qmppmsr0$viwtigxmzip}0$sj

gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwi$vipexih$xs$mxw$viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$e{evhw2$Ew$sj$Qevgl$750$64640$xli$Gsqter}$leh$(7829$qmppmsr$sj$yrvigskrm~ih

gsqtirwexmsr$gswxw$vipexih$xs$rsr1ziwxih$viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$e{evhw0$mrgpyhmrk$rsr1ziwxih$viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$e{evhw${mxl$tivjsvqergi1fewih

erh$qevoix1fewih$ziwxmrk0$xlex$evi$i|tigxih$xs$fi$vigskrm~ih$sziv$e${imklxih$eziveki$tivmsh$sj$62:$}ievw2

Iqtps}ii$Wxsgo$Tyvglewi$Tper

Xli$Gsqter}$tvizmsywp}$ehstxih$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt$Mrg2$6455$Iqtps}ii$Wxsgo$Tyvglewi$Tper$,xli$ÔTper$sv$&IWTTÕ-${lmgl${ew

ettvszih$f}$xli$Gsqter}+w$wlevilsphivw2$Xli$tyvtswi$sj$xli$Tper0${lmgl$mw$uyepmjmih$yrhiv$Wigxmsr$867$sj$xli$Mrxivrep$Viziryi

Wivzmgi$Gshi$sj$5=<:0$ew$eqirhih0$mw$xs$irgsyveki$wxsgo$s{rivwlmt$xlvsykl$te}vspp$hihygxmsrw$f}$xli$iqtps}iiw$sj$KIS$erh

hiwmkrexih$wyfwmhmevmiw$sj$KIS$mr$svhiv$xs$mrgviewi$xlimv$mhirxmjmgexmsr${mxl$xli$Gsqter}×w$ksepw$erh$wigyvi$e$tvstvmixev}$mrxiviwx$mr

xli$Gsqter}×w$wyggiww2$Xliwi$hihygxmsrw$evi$ywih$xs$tyvglewi$wleviw$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$gsqqsr$wxsgo$ex$e$9)$hmwgsyrx$jvsq$xli$xlir

gyvvirx$qevoix$tvmgi2$Xli$Gsqter}$lew$qehi$ezempefpi$yt$xs$;940444$wleviw$sj$mxw$gsqqsr$wxsgo0${lmgl${ivi$vikmwxivih${mxl$xli$WIG

sr$Qe}$80$64560$ew$eqirhih$sr$Nyp}$5<0$64580$jsv$wepi$xs$ipmkmfpi$iqtps}iiw$yrhiv$xli$Tper2

Xli$Tper$mw$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$rsr1gsqtirwexsv}2$Ew$wygl0$xlivi$mw$rs$gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwi$viuymvih$xs$fi$vigskrm~ih2$Wlevi$tyvglewiw

yrhiv$xli$Tper$evi$qehi$sr$xli$pewx$he}$sj$iegl$qsrxl2$Hyvmrk$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$64640$540769$wleviw$sj$xli

Gsqter}+w$gsqqsr$wxsgo${ivi$mwwyih$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$Tper2

59

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 21 of 88

Page 297: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 653;9

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 22 of 88

Page 298: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 663;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

<2$IEVRMRKW$TIV$WLEVI

Fewmg$ievrmrkw$tiv$wlevi$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$mw$gsqtyxih$f}$hmzmhmrk$xli$rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2$f}$xli

{imklxih$eziveki$ryqfiv$sj$syxwxerhmrk$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo2$Xli$gepgypexmsr$sj$hmpyxih$ievrmrkw$tiv$wlevi$mw$wmqmpev$xs$xlex$sj

fewmg$ievrmrkw$tiv$wlevi$i|gitx$xlex$xli$hirsqmrexsv$mrgpyhiw$hmpyxmzi$gsqqsr$wxsgo$iuymzepirxw$wygl$ew$wxsgo$stxmsrw$erh$wleviw$sj

viwxvmgxih$wxsgo2$Fewmg$erh$hmpyxih$ievrmrkw$tiv$wlevi${ivi$gepgypexih$jsv$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$6464$erh$645=$ew$jspps{w

,mr$xlsywerhw0$i|gitx$tiv$wlevi$hexe->

$

$ Xlvii$Qsrxlw$Irhih $ $

$$

Qevgl$7506464 $ $

Qevgl$750645= $ $

Rix$mrgsqi $ ( 690565$ $ ( 840:8=$ $

Rix$psww$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$rsrgsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw $ $ :4$ $ $ 9:$ $

Rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2 $ $ 6905<5$ $ $ 840;49$ $

Fewmg$ievrmrkw$tiv$wlevi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0

$$$Mrg2> $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

[imklxih$eziveki$wleviw$syxwxerhmrk $ $ 55=07=8$ $ $ 55<0;;8$ $

Tiv$wlevi$eqsyrx $ ( 4265$ $ ( 4278$ $

Hmpyxih$ievrmrkw$tiv$wlevi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0

$$$Mrg2> $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

[imklxih$eziveki$wleviw$syxwxerhmrk $ $ 55=07=8$ $ $ 55<0;;8$ $

Hmpyxmzi$ijjigx$sj$iuymx}$mrgirxmzi$tperw $ $ 97=$ $ $ ;66$ $

[imklxih$eziveki$wleviw$ewwyqmrk$hmpyxmsr $ $ 55=0=77$ $ $ 55=08=:$ $

Tiv$wlevi$eqsyrx $ ( 4265$ $ ( 4278$$

$

$

Jsv$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$64640$50:6:0645${imklxih$eziveki$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$yrhivp}mrk$stxmsrw${ivi$i|gpyhih

jvsq$xli$gsqtyxexmsr$sj$hmpyxih$ievrmrkw$tiv$wlevi$,&ITW&-$figeywi$xli$ijjigx${syph$fi$erxm1hmpyxmzi2$Xlivi${ivi$=:;0;<8$gsqqsr

wxsgo$iuymzepirxw$jvsq$viwxvmgxih$wleviw$xlex${ivi$erxm1hmpyxmzi2

Jsv$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$645=0$505=5064:${imklxih$eziveki$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$yrhivp}mrk$stxmsrw${ivi$i|gpyhih

jvsq$xli$gsqtyxexmsr$sj$hmpyxih$ITW$figeywi$xli$ijjigx${syph$fi$erxm1hmpyxmzi2$Xlivi${ivi$;9=07<6$gsqqsr$wxsgo$iuymzepirxw$jvsq

viwxvmgxih$wleviw$xlex${ivi$erxm1hmpyxmzi2

=2$HIVMZEXMZI$JMRERGMEP$MRWXVYQIRXW

Xli$Gsqter}×w$tvmqev}$sfnigxmzi$mr$lsphmrk$hivmzexmziw$mw$xs$vihygi$xli$zspexmpmx}$sj$ievrmrkw$erh$gewl$jps{w$ewwsgmexih${mxl$glerkiw

mr$mrxiviwx$vexiw2$Xli$Gsqter}$qiewyviw$mxw$hivmzexmzi$jmrergmep$mrwxvyqirxw$ex$jemv$zepyi2

Mr$Eykywx$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$irxivih$mrxs$x{s$mrxiviwx$vexi$w{et$ekviiqirxw$mr$xli$ekkvikexi$rsxmsrep$eqsyrx$sj$(8827$qmppmsr$xs$jm|

xli$mrxiviwx$vexi$sr$givxemr$sj$mxw$zevmefpi$vexi$hifx$xs$8266)2$Xli$Gsqter}$lew$hiwmkrexih$xliwi$mrxiviwx$vexi$w{etw$ew$lihkiw$ekemrwx

glerkiw$mr$xli$gewl$jps{w$sj$x{s$mhirxmgep$tvsqmwwsv}$rsxiw$,xli$&Rsxiw&-${lmgl$evi$wigyvih$f}$pser$ekviiqirxw$erh$qsvxkeki$erh

wigyvmx}$ekviiqirxw$sr$givxemr$viep$tvstivx}$erh$mqtvsziqirxw2$Xli$Gsqter}$lew$hixivqmrih$xlex$xli$w{etw$lezi$te}qirx0$i|tmvexmsr

hexiw0$erh$tvszmwmsrw$xlex$gsmrgmhi${mxl$xli$xivqw$sj$xli$Rsxiw$erh$evi$xlivijsvi$gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$ijjigxmzi$gewl$jps{$lihkiw2

Eggsvhmrkp}0$xli$Gsqter}$vigsvhw$xli$glerki$mr$jemv$zepyi$sj$xli$mrxiviwx$vexi$w{etw$ew$eggyqypexih$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi0$rix

sj$ettpmgefpi$xe|iw2$Xsxep$yrviepm~ih$pswwiw$vigsvhih$mr$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi0$rix$sj$xe|0$vipexih$xs$xliwi$gewl$jps{$lihkiw${ew

(829$qmppmsr$hyvmrk$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$64642$Xli$xsxep$jemv$zepyi$sj$xli$w{et$pmefmpmxmiw$ew$sj$Qevgl$750$6464${ew$(;2:

qmppmsr$erh$mw$vigsvhih$ew$e$gsqtsrirx$sj$Sxliv$Rsr1Gyvvirx$pmefmpmxmiw${mxlmr$xli$eggsqter}mrk$gsrwspmhexih$fepergi$wliix2$Xlivi

{ew$rs$qexivmep$mrijjigxmziriww$jsv$xli$tivmsh$tviwirxih2$Xli$Gsqter}$hsiw$rsx$i|tigx$xs$irxiv$mrxs$er}$xverwegxmsrw$hyvmrk$xli$ri|x

x{ipzi$qsrxlw${lmgl${syph$viwypx$mr$vigpewwmjmgexmsr$mrxs$ievrmrkw$sv$pswwiw$ewwsgmexih${mxl$xliwi$w{etw$gyvvirxp}$vitsvxih$mr

eggyqypexih$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$,psww-2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$54$1$Hifx$jsv$ehhmxmsrep$mrjsvqexmsr2

5:

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 23 of 88

Page 299: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 673;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

Xli$Gsqter}×w$Eywxvepmer$wyfwmhmev}$leh$irxivih$mrxs$mrxiviwx$vexi$w{et$ekviiqirxw$xs$jm|$xli$mrxiviwx$vexi$sr$mxw$zevmefpi$vexi$rsr1

vigsyvwi$hifx$vipexih$xs$e$tvsnigx$mr$Vezirlepp0$e$psgepmx}$riev$Qipfsyvri0$Eywxvepme$xs$826)2$Xli$Gsqter}$leh$hixivqmrih$xlex$xli

w{etw$leh$te}qirx0$i|tmvexmsr$hexiw0$erh$tvszmwmsrw$xlex$gsmrgmhih${mxl$xli$xivqw$sj$xli$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx$erh${ivi$xlivijsvi

gsrwmhivih$xs$fi$ijjigxmzi$gewl$jps{$lihkiw2$Eggsvhmrkp}0$xli$Gsqter}$vigsvhih$xli$glerki$mr$xli$jemv$zepyi$sj$xli$mrxiviwx$vexi$w{etw

mr$eggyqypexih$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi0$rix$sj$ettpmgefpi$mrgsqi$xe|iw2$Sr$Qe}$660$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$vijmrergih$xli$ewwsgmexih

hifx$erh$xivqmrexih$xli$w{et$ekviiqirxw${lmgl$viwypxih$mr$xli$vigpewwmjmgexmsr$sj$(72=$qmppmsr$mrxs$pswwiw$xlex${ivi$tvizmsywp}$vitsvxih

mr$eggyqypexih$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$54$1$Hifx$jsv$ehhmxmsrep$mrjsvqexmsr2

542$HIFX

Hifx$syxwxerhmrk$ew$sj$Qevgl$750$6464$erh$Higiqfiv$750$645=$gsrwmwxih$sj$xli$jspps{mrk$,mr$xlsywerhw->

$

$Qevgl$750

6464 $ $Higiqfiv$750

645= $

Wirmsv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}> $ $ $$ $ $ $ $

Xivq$pser $ ( ;;:0444$ $ ( ;;<0444$

Yreqsvxm~ih$hmwgsyrx$sr$xivq$pser $ $ ,60579- $ $ ,606<5-

Yreqsvxm~ih$hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw$sr$xivq$pser $ $ ,904:8- $ $ ,90854-

Vizspziv $ $ 8<=0<<:$ $ $ 9640:;5$

Xsxep$Wirmsv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx} $ $ 5069<0:<;$ $ $ 506=40=<4$

:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw> $ $ $$ $ $ $ $

Rsxiw$Hyi$mr$646: $ $ 7940444$ $ $ 7940444$

Yreqsvxm~ih$hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw $ $ ,80588- $ $ ,806<6-

Xsxep$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$Hyi$mr$646: $ $ 7890<9:$ $ $ 7890;5<$

92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw> $ $ $$ $ $ $ $

Rsxiw$Hyi$mr$6468 $ $ 6940444$ $ $ 6940444$

Yreqsvxm~ih$hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw $ $ ,6085<- $ $ ,60976-

Xsxep$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$Hyi$mr$6468 $ $ 68;09<6$ $ $ 68;08:<$

92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw> $ $ $$ $ $ $ $

Rsxiw$Hyi$mr$6467 $ $ 6=80944$ $ $ 7440444$

Yreqsvxm~ih$hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw $ $ ,60:97- $ $ ,60<;:-

Xsxep$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$Hyi$mr$6467 $ $ 6=50<8;$ $ $ 6=;0568$

92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw> $ $ $$ $ $ $ $

Rsxiw$Hyi$mr$6466 $ $ 5=70=9<$ $ $ 5=70=9<$

Yreqsvxm~ih$hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw $ $ ,505=9- $ $ ,50795-

Xsxep$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$Hyi$mr$6466 $ $ 5=60;:7$ $ $ 5=60:4;$

Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Hifx $ $ 6<<04;8$ $ $ 76<05;<$

Yreqsvxm~ih$hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw$sr$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx $ $ ,8098=- $ $ ,906;=-

Yreqsvxm~ih$hmwgsyrx$sr$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx $ $ ,::- $ $ ,<5-

Xsxep$Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Hifx $ $ 6<7089=$ $ $ 7660<5<$

Jmrergi$Piewi$Pmefmpmxmiw $ $ 805;=$ $ $ 809;4$

Sxliv$hifx $ $ 8705:9$ $ $ 870854$

Xsxep$hifx $ $ 60::;097<$ $ $ 60;880:=9$

Gyvvirx$tsvxmsr$sj$jmrergi$piewi$pmefmpmxmiw0$psrk1xivq$hifx$erh

$$$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx $ $ ,670:69- $ $ ,68064<-

Jmrergi$Piewi$Pmefmpmxmiw0$psrk1xivq$tsvxmsr $ $ ,609:7- $ $ ,60=98-

Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Hifx0$psrk1xivq$tsvxmsr $ $ ,6;408:4- $ $ ,74=067:-

Psrk1Xivq$Hifx $ ( 607;40<=4$ $ ( 6084<06=;$

$Eqirhih$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx

Sr$Nyri$560$645=0$KIS$irxivih$mrxs$Eqirhqirx$Rs2$6$xs$Xlmvh$Eqirhih$erh$Viwxexih$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$,xli$&Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx&-

f}$erh$eqsrk$xli$vijmrergmrk$pirhivw$tevx}$xlivixs0$xli$sxliv$pirhivw$tevx}$xlivixs0$KIS$erh$KIS$Gsvvigxmsrw$Lsphmrkw0$Mrg2$erh$xli

ehqmrmwxvexmzi$ekirx2$Yrhiv$xli$eqirhqirx0$xli$qexyvmx}$hexi$sj$xli$vizspziv$gsqtsrirx$sj$xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx${ew$i|xirhih$xs

Qe}$5;0$64682$Xli$fsvvs{mrk$getegmx}$yrhiv$xli$eqirhih$vizspziv$viqemrw$ex$(=4424$qmppmsr0$erh$mxw$tvmgmrk$viqemrw$yrglerkih

gyvvirxp}$fievmrk$mrxiviwx$ex$PMFSV$tpyw$6269)2$Ew$e$viwypx$sj$xli$xverwegxmsr0$xli$Gsqter}$mrgyvvih$e$psww$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 24 of 88

Page 300: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 683;9

sj$(526$qmppmsr$vipexih$xs$givxemr$yreqsvxm~ih$hijivvih$pser$gswxw2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$pser$gswxw$sj$(82;$qmppmsr${ivi$mrgyvvih$erh$getmxepm~ih

mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$xverwegxmsr2

5;

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 25 of 88

Page 301: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 693;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

Xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$izmhirgiw$e$gvihmx$jegmpmx}$,xli$&Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}&-$gsrwmwxmrk$sj$e$(;=624$qmppmsr$xivq$pser$fievmrk$mrxiviwx$ex

PMFSV$tpyw$6244)$,{mxl$e$PMFSV$jpssv$sj$42;9)-0$erh$e$(=4424$qmppmsr$vizspziv$mrmxmepp}$fievmrk$mrxiviwx$ex$PMFSV$tpyw$6269)$,{mxl

rs$PMFSV$jpssv-$xskixliv${mxl$EYH6;9$qmppmsr$ezempefpi$wspip}$jsv$xli$mwwyergi$sj$jmrergmep$pixxivw$sj$gvihmx$erh$tivjsvqergi$pixxivw

sj$gvihmx0$mr$iegl$gewi$hirsqmrexih$mr$Eywxvepmer$Hsppevw$yrhiv$xli$Eywxvepmer$Hsppev$Pixxiv$sj$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}$,xli$&Eywxvepmer$PG

Jegmpmx}&-2$Ew$sj$Qevgl$750$64640$xlivi${ivi$rs$pixxivw$sj$gvihmx$mwwyih$yrhiv$xli$Eywxvepmer$PG$Jegmpmx}2$Eqsyrxw$xs$fi$fsvvs{ih$f}

KIS$yrhiv$xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$evi$wyfnigx$xs$xli$wexmwjegxmsr$sj$gywxsqev}$gsrhmxmsrw$xs$fsvvs{mrk2$Xli$xivq$pser$gsqtsrirx$mw

wglihypih$xs$qexyvi$sr$Qevgl$670$64682$Xli$vizspzmrk$gvihmx$gsqqmxqirx$gsqtsrirx$mw$wglihypih$xs$qexyvi$sr$Qe}$5;0$64682$Xli

Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$epws$lew$er$eggsvhmsr$jiexyvi$sj$(89424$qmppmsr0$wyfnigx$xs$pirhiv$hiqerh$erh$tvizempmrk$qevoix$gsrhmxmsrw$erh

wexmwj}mrk$xli$vipizerx$fsvvs{mrk$gsrhmxmsrw2

Xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$gsrxemrw$givxemr$gywxsqev}$vitviwirxexmsrw$erh${evverxmiw0$erh$givxemr$gywxsqev}$gszirerxw$xlex$viwxvmgx$KIS×w

efmpmx}$xs0$eqsrk$sxliv$xlmrkw$,m-$gviexi0$mrgyv$sv$ewwyqi$er}$mrhifxihriww0$,mm-$gviexi0$mrgyv0$ewwyqi$sv$tivqmx$pmirw0$,mmm-$qeoi$pserw

erh$mrziwxqirxw0$,mz-$irkeki$mr$qivkivw0$eguymwmxmsrw$erh$ewwix$wepiw0$,z-$qeoi$givxemr$viwxvmgxih$te}qirxw0$,zm-$mwwyi0$wipp$sv$sxliv{mwi

hmwtswi$sj$getmxep$wxsgo0$,zmm-$irkeki$mr$xverwegxmsrw${mxl$ejjmpmexiw0$,zmmm-$epps{$xli$xsxep$piziveki$vexms$xs$i|giih$:269$xs$52440$epps{$xli

wirmsv$wigyvih$piziveki$vexms$xs$i|giih$7294$xs$52440$sv$epps{$xli$mrxiviwx$gsziveki$vexms$xs$fi$piww$xler$7244$xs$52440$,m|-$gergip0$jsvkmzi0

qeoi$er}$zspyrxev}$sv$stxmsrep$te}qirx$sv$tvite}qirx$sr0$sv$vihiiq$sv$eguymvi$jsv$zepyi$er}$wirmsv$rsxiw0$i|gitx$ew$tivqmxxih0$,|-

epxiv$xli$fywmriww$KIS$gsrhygxw0$erh$,|m-$qexivmepp}$mqtemv$KIS×w$pirhivw×$wigyvmx}$mrxiviwxw$mr$xli$gsppexivep$jsv$mxw$pserw2

Izirxw$sj$hijeypx$yrhiv$xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$mrgpyhi0$fyx$evi$rsx$pmqmxih$xs0$,m-$KIS×w$jempyvi$xs$te}$tvmrgmtep$sv$mrxiviwx${lir$hyi0$,mm-

KIS×w$qexivmep$fviegl$sj$er}$vitviwirxexmsr$sv${evverx}0$,mmm-$gszirerx$hijeypxw0$,mz-$pmuymhexmsr0$visvkerm~exmsr$sv$sxliv$vipmij$vipexmrk

xs$ferovytxg}$sv$mrwspzirg}0$,z-$gvsww$hijeypx$yrhiv$givxemr$sxliv$qexivmep$mrhifxihriww0$,zm-$yrwexmwjmih$jmrep$nyhkqirxw$sziv$e

wtigmjmih$xlviwlsph0$,zmm-$givxemr$qexivmep$irzmvsrqirxep$pmefmpmx}$gpemqw$ewwivxih$ekemrwx$KIS0$erh$,zmmm-$e$glerki$mr$gsrxvsp2

Epp$sj$xli$sfpmkexmsrw$yrhiv$xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$evi$yrgsrhmxmsrepp}$kyeverxiih$f}$givxemr$hsqiwxmg$wyfwmhmevmiw$sj$KIS$erh$xli

Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$erh$xli$vipexih$kyeverxiiw$evi$wigyvih$f}$e$tivjigxih$jmvwx1tvmsvmx}$tpihki$sj$wyfwxerxmepp}$epp$sj$KIS×w$tviwirx$erh

jyxyvi$xerkmfpi$erh$mrxerkmfpi$hsqiwxmg$ewwixw$erh$epp$tviwirx$erh$jyxyvi$xerkmfpi$erh$mrxerkmfpi$hsqiwxmg$ewwixw$sj$iegl$kyeverxsv0

mrgpyhmrk$fyx$rsx$pmqmxih$xs$e$jmvwx1tvmsvmx}$tpihki$sj$epp$sj$xli$syxwxerhmrk$getmxep$wxsgo$s{rih$f}$KIS$erh$iegl$kyeverxsv$mr$xlimv

hsqiwxmg$wyfwmhmevmiw2

KIS$Eywxvepewme$Lsphmrkw$Tx}$Pxh0$KIS$Eywxvepewme$Jmrergi$Lsphmrkw$Tx}$Pxh$ew$xvywxii$jsv$xli$KIS$Eywxvepewme$Jmrergi$Lsphmrk

Xvywx0$erh$xskixliv${mxl$KIS$Eywxvepewme$Lsphmrkw0$gsppigxmzip}$,&xli$Eywxvepmer$Fsvvs{ivw&-$evi${lspp}$s{rih$jsvimkr$wyfwmhmevmiw$sj

KIS2$KIS$lew$hiwmkrexih$iegl$sj$xli$Eywxvepmer$Fsvvs{ivw$ew$viwxvmgxih$wyfwmhmevmiw$yrhiv$xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx2$Ls{iziv0$xli

Eywxvepmer$Fsvvs{ivw$evi$rsx$sfpmkexih$xs$te}$sv$tivjsvq$er}$sfpmkexmsrw$yrhiv$xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$sxliv$xler$xlimv$s{r$sfpmkexmsrw

ew$Eywxvepmer$Fsvvs{ivw$yrhiv$xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx2$Xli$Eywxvepmer$Fsvvs{ivw$hs$rsx$tpihki$er}$sj$xlimv$ewwixw$xs$wigyvi$er}

sfpmkexmsrw$yrhiv$xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx2

Sr$Eykywx$5<0$645:0$xli$Gsqter}$i|igyxih$e$Pixxiv$sj$Sjjiv$tvszmhmrk$jsv$e$fero$kyeverxii$pmri$erh$fero$kyeverxii3wxerhf}$wyf1

jegmpmx}$mr$er$ekkvikexi$eqsyrx$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$EYH9<$qmppmsr0$sv$(792:$qmppmsr0$fewih$sr$i|glerki$vexiw$mr$ijjigx$ew$sj$Qevgl$750

6464$,gsppigxmzip}0$xli$ÔFero$Kyeverxii$Jegmpmx}Õ-2$Xli$Fero$Kyeverxii$Jegmpmx}$epps{w$KIS$xs$tvszmhi$pixxivw$sj$gvihmx$xs$ewwyvi

tivjsvqergi$sj$givxemr$sfpmkexmsrw$sj$mxw${lspp}$s{rih$wyfwmhmev}$vipexmrk$xs$mxw$gsvvigxmsrep$jegmpmx}$mr$Vezirlepp0$psgexih$riev

Qipfsyvri0$Eywxvepme2$Xli$Fero$Kyeverxii$Jegmpmx}$mw$yrwigyvih2$Xli$mwwyergi$sj$pixxivw$sj$gvihmx$yrhiv$xli$Fero$Kyeverxii$Jegmpmx}$mw

wyfnigx$xs$xli$wexmwjegxmsr$sj$xli$gsrhmxmsrw$tvigihirx$wtigmjmih$mr$xli$Pixxiv$sj$Sjjiv2$Pixxivw$sj$gvihmx$mwwyih$yrhiv$xli$fero$kyeverxii

pmriw$evi$hyi$sr$hiqerh$erh$pixxivw$sj$gvihmx$mwwyih$yrhiv$xli$fero$kyeverxii3wxerhf}$wyf1jegmpmx}$gerrsx$lezi$e$hyvexmsr$i|giihmrk

x{ipzi$qsrxlw2$Xli$Fero$Kyeverxii$Jegmpmx}$qe}$fi$xivqmrexih$f}$xli$pirhiv$sr$=4$he}w${vmxxir$rsxmgi2$Ew$sj$Qevgl$750$64640$xlivi

{ew$EYH9<$qmppmsr$mr$pixxivw$sj$gvihmx$mwwyih$yrhiv$xli$Fero$Kyeverxii$Jegmpmx}2

Ew$sj$Qevgl$750$64640$xli$Gsqter}$leh$ettvs|mqexip}$(;;:24$qmppmsr$mr$ekkvikexi$fsvvs{mrkw$syxwxerhmrk$yrhiv$mxw$xivq$pser0

ettvs|mqexip}$(8<=2=$qmppmsr$mr$fsvvs{mrkw$yrhiv$mxw$vizspziv0$erh$ettvs|mqexip}$(:52;$qmppmsr$mr$pixxivw$sj$gvihmx${lmgl$pijx

ettvs|mqexip}$(78<28$qmppmsr$mr$ehhmxmsrep$fsvvs{mrk$getegmx}$yrhiv$xli$Vizspziv2$Xli${imklxih$eziveki$mrxiviwx$vexi$sr$syxwxerhmrk

fsvvs{mrkw$yrhiv$xli$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$ew$sj$Qevgl$750$6464${ew$724<)2

:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$646:

Mrxiviwx$sr$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$eggvyiw$ex$xli$wxexih$vexi2$Xli$Gsqter}$te}w$mrxiviwx$wiqm1erryepp}$mr$evvievw$sr$Etvmp$59$erh

Sgxsfiv$59$sj$iegl$}iev2$Sr$sv$ejxiv$Etvmp$590$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$qe}0$ex$mxw$stxmsr0$vihiiq$epp$sv$tevx$sj$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$ex

xli$vihiqtxmsr$tvmgiw$wix$jsvxl$mr$xli$mrhirxyvi$kszivrmrk$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw2$Xli$mrhirxyvi$gsrxemrw$givxemr$gszirerxw0$mrgpyhmrk

pmqmxexmsrw$erh$viwxvmgxmsrw$sr$xli$Gsqter}$erh$mxw$wyfwmhmev}$kyeverxsvw2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$591$Gsrhirwih$Gsrwspmhexmrk$Jmrergmep

Mrjsvqexmsr2

5<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 26 of 88

Page 302: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 6:3;9

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 27 of 88

Page 303: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 6;3;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468

Mrxiviwx$sr$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468$eggvyiw$ex$xli$wxexih$vexi2$Xli$Gsqter}$te}w$mrxiviwx$wiqm1erryepp}$mr$evvievw$sr

Etvmp$59$erh$Sgxsfiv$59$sj$iegl$}iev2$Sr$sv$ejxiv$Sgxsfiv$590$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$qe}0$ex$mxw$stxmsr0$vihiiq$epp$sv$tevx$sj$xli$92<;9)

Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468$ex$xli$vihiqtxmsr$tvmgiw$wix$jsvxl$mr$xli$mrhirxyvi$kszivrmrk$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$64682$Xli$mrhirxyvi

gsrxemrw$givxemr$gszirerxw0$mrgpyhmrk$pmqmxexmsrw$erh$viwxvmgxmsrw$sr$xli$Gsqter}$erh$mxw$wyfwmhmev}$kyeverxsvw2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$591

Gsrhirwih$Gsrwspmhexmrk$Jmrergmep$Mrjsvqexmsr2

92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6467

Mrxiviwx$sr$xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$eggvyiw$ex$xli$wxexih$vexi2$Xli$Gsqter}$te}w$mrxiviwx$wiqm1erryepp}$mr$evvievw$sr$Etvmp$5$erh

Sgxsfiv$5$sj$iegl$}iev2$Sr$sv$ejxiv$Etvmp$50$645<0$xli$Gsqter}$qe}0$ex$mxw$stxmsr0$vihiiq$epp$sv$tevx$sj$xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$ex$xli

vihiqtxmsr$tvmgiw$wix$jsvxl$mr$xli$mrhirxyvi$kszivrmrk$xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw2$Xli$mrhirxyvi$gsrxemrw$givxemr$gszirerxw0$mrgpyhmrk

pmqmxexmsrw$erh$viwxvmgxmsrw$sr$xli$Gsqter}$erh$mxw$wyfwmhmev}$kyeverxsvw2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$591$Gsrhirwih$Gsrwspmhexmrk$Jmrergmep

Mrjsvqexmsr2

92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466

Mrxiviwx$sr$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466$eggvyiw$ex$xli$wxexih$vexi2$Xli$Gsqter}$te}w$mrxiviwx$wiqm1erryepp}$mr$evvievw$sr

Neryev}$59$erh$Nyp}$59$sj$iegl$}iev2$Sr$sv$ejxiv$Neryev}$590$645;0$xli$Gsqter}$qe}0$ex$mxw$stxmsr0$vihiiq$epp$sv$tevx$sj$xli$92<;9)

Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466$ex$xli$vihiqtxmsr$tvmgiw$wix$jsvxl$mr$xli$mrhirxyvi$kszivrmrk$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$64662$Xli$mrhirxyvi

gsrxemrw$givxemr$gszirerxw0$mrgpyhmrk$pmqmxexmsrw$erh$viwxvmgxmsrw$sr$xli$Gsqter}$erh$mxw$wyfwmhmev}$kyeverxsvw2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$591

Gsrhirwih$Gsrwspmhexmrk$Jmrergmep$Mrjsvqexmsr2

Hifx$Vityvglewiw

Sr$Eykywx$5:0$645=0$xli$Gsqter}+w$Fsevh$sj$Hmvigxsvw$eyxlsvm~ih$xli$Gsqter}$xs$vityvglewi$erh3sv$vixmvi$e$tsvxmsr$sj$xli$:244)

Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$646:0$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$64680$xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$64670$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466

,gsppigxmzip}$xli$&KIS$Wirmsv$Rsxiw&-$erh$xli$Gsqter}+w$xivq$pser$yrhiv$mxw$Eqirhih$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$xlvsykl$gewl$tyvglewiw0$mr

stir$qevoix$tyvglewiw0$tvmzexip}$riksxmexih$xverwegxmsrw0$sv$sxliv{mwi0$yt$xs$er$ekkvikexi$qe|mqyq$sj$(54424$qmppmsr0$wyfnigx$xs

givxemr$pmqmxexmsrw$xlvsykl$Higiqfiv$750$64642

Hyvmrk$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$vityvglewih$ettvs|mqexip}$(9:24$qmppmsr$mr$ekkvikexi$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj$mxw$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi

6466$ex$e${imklxih$eziveki$tvmgi$sj$=;299)$jsv$e$xsxep$gswx$sj$(982;$qmppmsr2$Ew$e$viwypx$sj$xliwi$vityvglewiw0$xli$Gsqter}$vigskrm~ih

e$rix$kemr$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx$sj$(427$qmppmsr2

Hyvmrk$xli$jmvwx$uyevxiv$sj$64640$xli$Gsqter}$vityvglewih$ettvs|mqexip}$(929$qmppmsr$mr$ekkvikexi$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj$mxw$92569)

Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6467$ex$e${imklxih$eziveki$tvmgi$sj$;42:<)$jsv$e$xsxep$gswx$sj$(72=$qmppmsr2$Ew$e$viwypx$sj$xliwi$vityvglewiw0$xli

Gsqter}$vigskrm~ih$e$rix$kemr$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx$sj$(52:$qmppmsr2

$

Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Hifx

Rsvxl{iwx$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxiv

Xli$viqemrmrk$fepergi$sj$xli$svmkmrep$hifx$wivzmgi$viuymviqirx$yrhiv$xli$(9828$qmppmsr$rsxi$te}efpi$,&6455$Viziryi$Fsrhw&-$xs

[IHJE$mw$(592;$qmppmsr0$sj${lmgl$(;2;$qmppmsr$mw$gpewwmjmih$ew$gyvvirx$mr$xli$eggsqter}mrk$gsrwspmhexih$fepergi$wliix$ew$sj

Qevgl$750$64642$Xli$te}qirx$sj$tvmrgmtep$erh$mrxiviwx$sr$xli$6455$Viziryi$Fsrhw$mwwyih$f}$[IHJE$mw$rsr1vigsyvwi$xs$KIS2$Xli

6455$Viziryi$Fsrhw${mpp$qexyvi$mr$Sgxsfiv$6465${mxl$e$jm|ih$gsytsr$vexi$sj$9269)2

Ew$sj$Qevgl$750$64640$mrgpyhih$mr$gyvvirx$viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw$mw$(82;$qmppmsr$sj$jyrhw$liph$mr$xvywx$jsv$hifx$wivzmgi$erh

sxliv$viwivziw${mxl$viwtigx$xs$xli$efszi$qirxmsrih$rsxi$te}efpi$xs$[IHJE2

Eywxvepme$1$Vezirlepp

Mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$e$hiwmkr$erh$fymph$tvsnigx$ekviiqirx${mxl$xli$Wxexi$sj$Zmgxsvme0$mr$Witxiqfiv$64580$xli$Gsqter}$irxivih$mrxs$e

w}rhmgexih$jegmpmx}$ekviiqirx$,xli$&Gsrwxvygxmsr$Jegmpmx}&-$xs$tvszmhi$hifx$jmrergmrk$jsv$gsrwxvygxmsr$sj$xli$tvsnigx2$Xli$Gsrwxvygxmsr

Jegmpmx}$tvszmhih$jsv$rsr1vigsyvwi$jyrhmrk$yt$xs$EYH;=5$qmppmsr0$sv$ettvs|mqexip}$(8<92<$qmppmsr0$fewih$sr$i|glerki$vexiw$ew$sj

Qevgl$750$64642$Mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$xli$xivqw$sj$xli$gsrxvegx0$ytsr$gsqtpixmsr$erh$gsqqivgmep$eggitxergi$sj$xli$tvsnigx0$xli$Wxexi

qehi$e$pyqt$wyq$te}qirx$sj$EYH754$qmppmsr0$sv$ettvs|mqexip}$(5=428$qmppmsr0$fewih$sr$i|glerki$vexiw$ew$sj$Qevgl$750$64642$Xli

xivq$sj$xli$Gsrwxvygxmsr$Jegmpmx}${ew$xlvsykl$Witxiqfiv$645=$erh$fsvi$mrxiviwx$ex$e$zevmefpi$vexi$uysxih$f}$givxemr$Eywxvepmer$ferow

tpyw$644$fewmw$tsmrxw2$Sr$Qe}$660$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$gsqtpixih$er$sjjivmrk$sj$EYH8:6$qmppmsr0$sv$(6<729$qmppmsr0$fewih$sr

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 28 of 88

Page 304: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 6<3;9

i|glerki$vexiw$ew$sj$Qevgl$750$64640$ekkvikexi$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj$rsr1vigsyvwi$wirmsv$wigyvih$rsxiw$hyi$6486$,xli$&Rsr1Vigsyvwi

Rsxiw&-2$Xli$eqsvxm~mrk$Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Rsxiw${ivi$mwwyih$f}$Vezirlepp$Jmrergi$Gs$Tx}$Pmqmxih$mr$e$tvmzexi$tpegiqirx$tyvwyerx$xs

Wigxmsr$8,e-,6-$sj$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$Egx$sj$5=770$ew$eqirhih2$Xli$Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Rsxiw${ivi$mwwyih${mxl$e$gsytsr$erh$}miph$xs$qexyvmx}$sj

8267)${mxl$e

5=

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 29 of 88

Page 305: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 6=3;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

qexyvmx}$hexi$sj$Qevgl$750$64862$Xli$rix$tvsgiihw$jvsq$xlmw$sjjivmrk${ivi$ywih$xs$vijmrergi$xli$syxwxerhmrk$Gsrwxvygxmsr$Jegmpmx}$erh

xs$te}$epp$vipexih$jiiw0$gswxw$erh$i|tirwiw$ewwsgmexih${mxl$xli$xverwegxmsr2$Ew$e$viwypx$sj$xli$xverwegxmsr0$xli$Gsqter}$mrgyvvih$e$(829

qmppmsr$psww$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx$vipexih$xs$w{et$xivqmrexmsr$jiiw$erh$yreqsvxm~ih$hijivvih$gswxw$ewwsgmexih${mxl$xli

Gsrwxvygxmsr$Jegmpmx}2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$pser$gswxw$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(;29$qmppmsr${ivi$mrgyvvih$erh$getmxepm~ih$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli

sjjivmrk2

Sxliv

Mr$Eykywx$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$irxivih$mrxs$x{s$mhirxmgep$Rsxiw$mr$xli$ekkvikexi$eqsyrx$sj$(8827$qmppmsr${lmgl$evi$wigyvih$f}$pser

ekviiqirxw$erh$qsvxkeki$erh$wigyvmx}$ekviiqirxw$sr$givxemr$viep$tvstivx}$erh$mqtvsziqirxw2$Xli$xivqw$sj$xli$Rsxiw$evi$xlvsykl

Witxiqfiv$50$6478$erh$fiev$mrxiviwx$ex$PMFSV$tpyw$644$fewmw$tsmrxw$erh$evi$te}efpi$mr$qsrxlp}$mrwxeppqirxw$tpyw$mrxiviwx2$Xli

Gsqter}$lew$irxivih$mrxs$mrxiviwx$vexi$w{et$ekviiqirxw$xs$jm|$xli$mrxiviwx$vexi$xs$8266)2$Mrgpyhih$mr$xli$fepergi$ex$Qevgl$750$6464$mw

(42;$qmppmsr$sj$hijivvih$pser$gswxw$mrgyvvih$mr$xli$xverwegxmsr2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$=$1$Hivmzexmzi$Jmrergmep$Mrwxvyqirxw$jsv$jyvxliv

mrjsvqexmsr2

Kyeverxiiw

Eywxvepme

Xli$Gsqter}$lew$irxivih$mrxs$e$kyeverxii$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$stivexmrk$tivjsvqergi$sj$e$jegmpmx}$mr$Eywxvepme2$Xli$sfpmkexmsr

eqsyrxih$xs$ettvs|mqexip}$EYH9<$qmppmsr0$sv$(792:$qmppmsr0$fewih$sr$i|glerki$vexiw$ew$sj$Qevgl$750$64642$Xli$kyeverxii$mw$wigyvih

f}$syxwxerhmrk$pixxivw$sj$gvihmx$yrhiv$xli$Gsqter}+w$Vizspziv2

Ex$Qevgl$750$64640$xli$Gsqter}$epws$leh$wizir$sxliv$pixxivw$sj$gvihmx$syxwxerhmrk$yrhiv$witevexi$mrxivrexmsrep$jegmpmxmiw$vipexmrk$xs

tivjsvqergi$kyeverxiiw$sj$mxw$Eywxvepmer$wyfwmhmev}$xsxepmrk$(=28$qmppmsr2

I|gitx$ew$hmwgywwih$efszi0$xli$Gsqter}$hsiw$rsx$lezi$er}$sjj$fepergi$wliix$evverkiqirxw2

552$GSQQMXQIRXW$ERH$GSRXMRKIRGMIW

Pmxmkexmsr0$Gpemqw$erh$Ewwiwwqirxw

$

Ew$tvizmsywp}$vitsvxih$erh$hiwgvmfih$mr$xli$Gsqter}+w$tvmsv$tivmshmg$vitsvxw0$mrgpyhmrk$qswx$vigirxp}$mr$mxw$Jsvq$541O$jsv$xli

}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$jsvqiv$gmzmp$mqqmkvexmsr$hixemriiw$ex$xli$Eyvsve$Mqqmkvexmsr$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxiv$jmpih$e$gpeww$egxmsr

pe{wymx$sr$Sgxsfiv$660$64580$ekemrwx$xli$Gsqter}$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw$Hmwxvmgx$Gsyvx$jsv$xli$Hmwxvmgx$sj$Gspsvehs$,xli$ÔGsyvxÕ-2$Xli

gsqtpemrx$eppikiw$xlex$xli$Gsqter}${ew$mr$zmspexmsr$sj$xli$Gspsvehs$Qmrmqyq$[ekiw$sj$[svoivw$Egx$erh$xli$jihivep$Xvejjmgomrk

Zmgxmqw$Tvsxigxmsr$Egx$,&XZTE&-2$Xli$tpemrxmjj$gpeww$gpemqw$xlex$xli$Gsqter}${ew$yrnywxp}$irvmglih$figeywi$sj$xli$pizip$sj$te}qirx

xli$hixemriiw$vigimzih$jsv${svo$tivjsvqih$ex$xli$jegmpmx}0$izir$xlsykl$xli$zspyrxev}${svo$tvskveq$ew${ipp$ew$xli${eki$vexiw$erh

wxerhevhw$ewwsgmexih${mxl$xli$tvskveq$xlex$evi$ex$mwwyi$mr$xli$gewi$evi$eyxlsvm~ih$f}$xli$Jihivep$kszivrqirx$yrhiv$kymhipmriw$ettvszih

f}$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw$Gsrkviww2$Sr$Nyp}$:0$64590$xli$Gsyvx$jsyrh$xlex$hixemriiw${ivi$rsx$iqtps}iiw$yrhiv$xli$Gspsvehs$Qmrmqyq

[eki$Svhiv$erh$hmwqmwwih$xlmw$gpemq2$Mr$Jifvyev}$645;0$xli$Gsyvx$kverxih$xli$tpemrxmjj1gpeww×$qsxmsr$jsv$gpeww$givxmjmgexmsr$sr$xli

XZTE$erh$yrnywx$irvmglqirx$gpemqw2$Xli$tpemrxmjj$gpeww$wiiow$egxyep$heqekiw0$gsqtirwexsv}$heqekiw0$i|iqtpev}$heqekiw0$tyrmxmzi

heqekiw0$viwxmxyxmsr0$exxsvri}w×$jiiw$erh$gswxw0$erh$wygl$sxliv$vipmij$ew$xli$Gsyvx$qe}$hiiq$tvstiv2$Mr$xli$xmqi$wmrgi$xli$Gspsvehs$wymx

{ew$mrmxmepp}$jmpih0$xlvii$wmqmpev$pe{wymxw$lezi$fiir$jmpih$1$x{s$mr$[ewlmrkxsr$erh$sri$mr$Gepmjsvrme2$Mr$[ewlmrkxsr0$sri$sj$xli$x{s

pe{wymxw${ew$jmpih$sr$Witxiqfiv$=0$645;$f}$mqqmkvexmsr$hixemriiw$ekemrwx$xli$Gsqter}$mr$xli$Y2W2$Hmwxvmgx$Gsyvx$jsv$xli$[iwxivr

Hmwxvmgx$sj$[ewlmrkxsr2$$Xli$wigsrh$pe{wymx${ew$jmpih$sr$Witxiqfiv$640$645;$f}$xli$Wxexi$Exxsvri}$Kirivep$ekemrwx$xli$Gsqter}$mr

xli$Wytivmsv$Gsyvx$sj$xli$Wxexi$sj$[ewlmrkxsr$jsv$Tmivgi$Gsyrx}0${lmgl$xli$Gsqter}$viqszih$xs$xli$Y2W2$Hmwxvmgx$Gsyvx$jsv$xli

[iwxivr$Hmwxvmgx$sj$[ewlmrkxsr$sr$Sgxsfiv$=0$645;2$Mr$Gepmjsvrme0$e$gpeww1egxmsr$pe{wymx${ew$jmpih$sr$Higiqfiv$5=0$645;$f}

mqqmkvexmsr$hixemriiw$ekemrwx$xli$Gsqter}$mr$xli$Y2W2$Hmwxvmgx$Gsyvx$Iewxivr$Hmzmwmsr$sj$xli$Girxvep$Hmwxvmgx$sj$Gepmjsvrme2$Epp$xlvii

pe{wymxw$eppiki$zmspexmsrw$sj$xli$viwtigxmzi$wxexi×w$qmrmqyq${eki$pe{w2$Ls{iziv0$xli$Gepmjsvrme$pe{wymx0$pmoi$xli$Gspsvehs$wymx0$epws

mrgpyhiw$gpemqw$xlex$xli$Gsqter}$zmspexih$xli$XZTE$erh$Gepmjsvrme+w$iuymzepirx$wxexi$wxexyxi2$Sr$Witxiqfiv$6;0$645=0$xli$Gepmjsvrme

tpemrxmjj$gpeww$jmpih$e$qsxmsr$jsv$gpeww$givxmjmgexmsr$sj$fsxl$Gepmjsvrme1fewih$erh$rexmsr{mhi$gpewwiw2$Xli$Gsqter}$jmpih$e$viwtsrwi$xs

xlmw$qsxmsr$hmwtyxmrk$xli$tpemrxmjj$gpeww+$vmklx$xs$fvseh$gpeww$xviexqirx$sj$xli$gpemqw$ex$mwwyi2$Sr$Nyp}$60$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$jmpih$e

Qsxmsr$jsv$Wyqqev}$Nyhkqirx$mr$xli$[ewlmrkxsr$Exxsvri}$Kirivep×w$Xegsqe$pe{wymx$fewih$sr$xli$Gsqter}×w$tswmxmsr$xlex$mxw$pikep

hijirwiw$tvizirx$xli$gewi$jvsq$tvsgiihmrk$xs$xvmep2$Xli$jihivep$gsyvx$mr$[ewlmrkxsr$hirmih$xli$Gsqter}+w$Qsxmsr$jsv$Wyqqev}

Nyhkqirx$sr$Eykywx$:0$645=2$Ls{iziv0$sr$Eykywx$640$645=0$xli$Hitevxqirx$sj$Nywxmgi$jmpih$e$Wxexiqirx$sj$Mrxiviwx0${lmgl$ewoih$xli

[ewlmrkxsr$gsyvx$xs$vizmwmx$mxw$tvmsv$hirmep$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$mrxivkszivrqirxep$mqqyrmx}$hijirwi$mr$xli$gewi2$[lmpi$xli$[ewlmrkxsr

gsyvx$ypxmqexip}$ipigxih$rsx$xs$hmwqmww$xli$gewi$ex$xli$xmqi0$mxw$svhiv$mqtsvxerxp}$higpevih$xlex$xli$Gsqter}+w$mrxivkszivrqirxep

mqqyrmx}$hijirwi${ew$pikepp}$zmefpi0$xs$fi$ypxmqexip}$hixivqmrih$ex$xvmep2$Xvmep$jsv$xli$x{s$[ewlmrkxsr$gewiw$lew$fiir$gsrxmryih$yrxmp

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 30 of 88

Page 306: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 743;9

wsqixmqi$tewx$Nyri$64642$Xli$Gsqter}$mrxirhw$xs$xeoi$epp$rigiwwev}$wxitw$xs$zmksvsywp}$hijirh$mxwipj$erh$lew$gsrwmwxirxp}$vijyxih$xli

eppikexmsrw$erh$gpemqw$mr$xliwi$pe{wymxw2$Xli$Gsqter}$lew$rsx$vigsvhih$er$eggvyep$vipexmrk$xs$xliwi$qexxivw$ex$xlmw$xmqi0$ew$e$psww$mw$rsx

gsrwmhivih$tvsfefpi$rsv$viewsrefp}$iwxmqefpi$ex$xlmw$wxeki$sj$xli$pe{wymxw2$Xli$Gsqter}$iwxefpmwliw$eggvyepw$jsv$wtigmjmg$pikep

tvsgiihmrkw${lir$mx$mw$gsrwmhivih$tvsfefpi$xlex$e$psww$lew$fiir$mrgyvvih$erh$xli

64

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 31 of 88

Page 307: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 753;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

eqsyrx$sj$xli$psww$ger$fi$viewsrefp}$iwxmqexih2$Ls{iziv0$xli$viwypxw$sj$xliwi$gpemqw$sv$tvsgiihmrkw$gerrsx$fi$tvihmgxih${mxl$givxemrx}0

erh$er$yrjezsvefpi$viwspyxmsr$sj$sri$sv$qsvi$sj$xliwi$gpemqw$sv$tvsgiihmrkw$gsyph$lezi$e$qexivmep$ehzivwi$ijjigx$sr$xli$Gsqter}+w

jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$sv$gewl$jps{w2$Xli$Gsqter}+w$eggvyepw$jsv$psww$gsrxmrkirgmiw$evi$vizmi{ih$uyevxivp}$erh

ehnywxih$ew$ehhmxmsrep$mrjsvqexmsr$figsqiw$ezempefpi2$Xli$Gsqter}$hsiw$rsx$eggvyi$jsv$erxmgmtexih$pikep$jiiw$erh$gswxw$fyx$i|tirwiw

xlswi$mxiqw$ew$mrgyvvih2

$

Sr$Higiqfiv$740$645=0$KIS$jmpih$e$pe{wymx$jsv$higpevexsv}$erh$mrnyrgxmzi$vipmij$gleppirkmrk$Gepmjsvrme×w$ri{p}$iregxih$pe{$1

Ewwiqfp}$Fmpp$76$,EF176-$1${lmgl$fevw$xli$jihivep$kszivrqirx$jvsq$irkekmrk$KIS$sv$er}$sxliv$kszivrqirx$gsrxvegxsvw$xs$tvszmhi

hixirxmsr$wivzmgiw$jsv$mppikep$epmirw2$KIS×w$gpemqw0$ew$hiwgvmfih$mr$xli$pe{wymx0$evi$kvsyrhih$mr$eyxlsvmxexmzi$pikep$hsgxvmri$xlex$yrhiv

xli$Gsrwxmxyxmsr×w$Wytviqeg}$Gpeywi0$xli$jihivep$kszivrqirx$mw$jvii$jvsq$vikypexmsr$f}$er}$wxexi2$F}$tvslmfmxmrk$jihivep$hixirxmsr

jegmpmxmiw$mr$Gepmjsvrme0$xli$pe{wymx$evkyiw$EF176$wyfwxerxmepp}$mrxivjiviw${mxl$xli$efmpmx}$sj$Y2W2$Qevwlepw$Wivzmgi$,ÔYWQWÕ-$erh$MGI

xs$gevv}$syx$hixirxmsr$viwtsrwmfmpmxmiw$jsv$xli$jihivep$kszivrqirx2$Wigsrhp}0$figeywi$EF176$gviexiw$i|gitxmsrw$xs$xli$Wxexi${lir$ywmrk

KIS$sv$er}$kszivrqirx$gsrxvegxsvw$,xs$eppizmexi$szivgvs{hmrk-0$Gepmjsvrme×w$wxexyxi$yrpe{jypp}$hmwgvmqmrexiw$ekemrwx$xli$jihivep

kszivrqirx2$Sr$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$KIS$jmpih$mxw$qsxmsr$jsv$e$tvipmqmrev}$mrnyrgxmsr$viwxvemrmrk$Gepmjsvrme×w$Kszivrsv$erh$Exxsvri}

Kirivep$jvsq$irjsvgmrk$EF176$ekemrwx$KIS×w$hixirxmsr$jegmpmxmiw$sr$filepj$sj$YWQW$erh$MGI2$Xli$gsyvx$kverxih$xli$tevxmiw×$nsmrx

qsxmsr$xs$viwglihypi$xli$lievmrk$xs$Nyp}$5:0$64642

$

Xli$rexyvi$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$fywmriww$i|tswiw$mx$xs$zevmsyw$x}tiw$sj$xlmvh1tevx}$pikep$gpemqw$sv$pmxmkexmsr$ekemrwx$xli$Gsqter}0

mrgpyhmrk0$fyx$rsx$pmqmxih$xs0$gmzmp$vmklxw$gpemqw$vipexmrk$xs$gsrhmxmsrw$sj$gsrjmriqirx$erh3sv$qmwxviexqirx0$wi|yep$qmwgsrhygx$gpemqw

fvsyklx$f}$tvmwsrivw$sv$hixemriiw0$qihmgep$qeptvegxmgi$gpemqw0$tvshygx$pmefmpmx}$gpemqw0$mrxippigxyep$tvstivx}$mrjvmrkiqirx$gpemqw0

gpemqw$vipexmrk$xs$iqtps}qirx$qexxivw$,mrgpyhmrk0$fyx$rsx$pmqmxih$xs0$iqtps}qirx$hmwgvmqmrexmsr$gpemqw0$yrmsr$kvmizergiw$erh${eki

erh$lsyv$gpemqw-0$tvstivx}$psww$gpemqw0$irzmvsrqirxep$gpemqw0$eyxsqsfmpi$pmefmpmx}$gpemqw0$mrhiqrmjmgexmsr$gpemqw$f}$mxw$gywxsqivw$erh

sxliv$xlmvh$tevxmiw0$gsrxvegxyep$gpemqw$erh$gpemqw$jsv$tivwsrep$mrnyv}$sv$sxliv$heqekiw$viwypxmrk$jvsq$gsrxegx${mxl$xli$Gsqter}+w

jegmpmxmiw0$tvskveqw0$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$tvshygxw0$tivwsrrip$sv$tvmwsrivw0$mrgpyhmrk$heqekiw$evmwmrk$jvsq$e$tvmwsriv+w$iwgeti$sv$jvsq

e$hmwxyvfergi$sv$vmsx$ex$e$jegmpmx}2$Xli$Gsqter}$eggvyiw$jsv$pikep$gswxw$ewwsgmexih${mxl$psww$gsrxmrkirgmiw${lir$xlswi$gswxw$evi$tvsfefpi

erh$viewsrefp}$iwxmqefpi2$Xli$Gsqter}$hsiw$rsx$i|tigx$xli$syxgsqi$sj$er}$tirhmrk$gpemqw$sv$pikep$tvsgiihmrkw$xs$lezi$e$qexivmep

ehzivwi$ijjigx$sr$mxw$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$sv$gewl$jps{w2

Sxliv$Ewwiwwqirx

E$wxexi$rsr1mrgsqi$xe|$eyhmx$gsqtpixih$mr$645:$mrgpyhih$xe|$tivmshw$jsv${lmgl$xli$wxexi$xe|$eyxlsvmx}$leh$tvizmsywp}$tvsgiwwih$e

wyfwxerxmep$xe|$vijyrh2$Ex$xli$gsqtpixmsr$sj$xli$eyhmx$jmiph{svo0$xli$Gsqter}$vigimzih$e$rsxmgi$sj$eyhmx$jmrhmrkw$hmwepps{mrk

hihygxmsrw$xlex${ivi$tvizmsywp}$gpemqih$f}$xli$Gsqter}0$ettvszih$f}$xli$wxexi$xe|$eyxlsvmx}$erh$wivzih$ew$xli$fewmw$jsv$xli$ettvszih

vijyrh$gpemq2$Mr$ievp}$Neryev}$645;0$xli$Gsqter}$vigimzih$e$jsvqep$Rsxmgi$sj$Ewwiwwqirx$sj$Xe|iw$erh$Hiqerh$jsv$Te}qirx$jvsq$xli

xe|mrk$eyxlsvmx}$hmwepps{mrk$xli$hihygxmsrw2$Xli$xsxep$xe|0$tirepx}$erh$mrxiviwx$vipexih$xs$xli$ewwiwwqirx$mw$ettvs|mqexip}$(5=25$qmppmsr2

Xli$Gsqter}$lew$jmpih$er$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$tvsxiwx$erh$hmwekviiw${mxl$xli$ewwiwwqirx$erh$mrxirhw$xs$xeoi$epp$rigiwwev}$wxitw$xs

zmksvsywp}$hijirh$mxw$tswmxmsr2$$Xli$Gsqter}$lew$iwxefpmwlih$e$viwivzi$fewih$sr$mxw$iwxmqexi$sj$xli$qswx$tvsfefpi$psww$fewih$sr$xli

jegxw$erh$gmvgyqwxergiw$ors{r$xs$hexi$erh$xli$ehzmgi$sj$syxwmhi$gsyrwip$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xlmw$qexxiv2

Gsqqmxqirxw

Xli$Gsqter}$gyvvirxp}$lew$gsrxvegxyep$gsqqmxqirxw$jsv$e$ryqfiv$sj$tvsnigxw$ywmrk$Gsqter}$jmrergmrk2$Xli$Gsqter}×w$qerekiqirx

iwxmqexiw$xlex$xli$gswx$sj$xliwi$i|mwxmrk$getmxep$tvsnigxw${mpp$fi$ettvs|mqexip}$(:5$qmppmsr$sj${lmgl$(85$qmppmsr${ew$wtirx$xlvsykl$xli

jmvwx$xlvii$qsrxlw$sj$64642$Xli$Gsqter}$iwxmqexiw$xli$viqemrmrk$getmxep$viuymviqirxw$vipexih$xs$xliwi$getmxep$tvsnigxw${mpp$fi$(64

qmppmsr${lmgl${mpp$fi$wtirx$xlvsykl$xli$viqemrhiv$sj$64642

Mhpi$Jegmpmxmiw

Ew$sj$Qevgl$750$64640$xli$Gsqter}${ew$qevoixmrk$ettvs|mqexip}$50444$zegerx$fihw$ex$x{s$sj$mxw$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw$xs$tsxirxmep$gywxsqivw2

Xli$gevv}mrk$zepyiw$sj$xliwi$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw0${lmgl$evi$mrgpyhih$mr$Tvstivx}$erh$Iuymtqirx0$Rix$mr$xli$eggsqter}mrk$gsrwspmhexih

fepergi$wliixw0$xsxepih$(642;$qmppmsr$ew$sj$Qevgl$750$64640$i|gpyhmrk$iuymtqirx$erh$sxliv$ewwixw$xlex$ger$fi$iewmp}$xverwjivvih$jsv$ywi

ex$sxliv$jegmpmxmiw2$Xlivi${ew$rs$mrhmgexmsr$sj$mqtemvqirx$vipexih$xs$xli$Gsqter}+w$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw$ex$Qevgl$750$64642

65

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 32 of 88

Page 308: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 763;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

562$FYWMRIWW$WIKQIRXW$ERH$KISKVETLMG$MRJSVQEXMSR

Stivexmrk$erh$Vitsvxmrk$Wikqirxw

Xli$Gsqter}$gsrhygxw$mxw$fywmriww$xlvsykl$jsyv$vitsvxefpi$fywmriww$wikqirxw>$xli$KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$wikqirx?$xli$KIS$Gevi

wikqirx?$xli$Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw$wikqirx?$erh$xli$Jegmpmx}$Gsrwxvygxmsr$*$Hiwmkr$wikqirx2$Xli$Gsqter}+w$wikqirx$viziryiw$jvsq

i|xivrep$gywxsqivw$erh$e$qiewyvi$sj$wikqirx$tvsjmx$evi$ew$jspps{w$,mr$xlsywerhw->

$

$ Xlvii$Qsrxlw$Irhih $ $

$$

Qevgl$7506464 $ $

Qevgl$750645= $ $

Viziryiw> $ $ $$ $ $ $ $ $

KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw $ ( 7=<054=$ $ ( 7=40954$ $

KIS$Gevi $ $ 58808:7$ $ $ 5970<87$ $

Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw $ $ 9:0<94$ $ $ :80668$ $

Jegmpmx}$Gsrwxvygxmsr$*$Hiwmkr$_5a $ $ 909=9$ $ $ 604=4$ $

Xsxep$viziryiw $ ( :49045;$ $ ( :540::;$ $

Stivexmrk$mrgsqi$jvsq$wikqirxw> $ $ $$ $ $ $ $ $

KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw $ ( ;8044=$ $ ( ;:0=68$ $

KIS$Gevi $ $ 740:==$ $ $ 7<097<$ $

Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw $ $ 90:94$ $ $ 90;7=$ $

Jegmpmx}$Gsrwxvygxmsr$*$Hiwmkr$_5a $ $ 54$ $ $ Ó$ $

Stivexmrk$mrgsqi$jvsq$wikqirxw $ ( 55407:<$ $ ( 5650645$ $

Kirivep$erh$Ehqmrmwxvexmzi$I|tirwiw $ $ ,970;<6- $ $ ,8:0868- $

Xsxep$Stivexmrk$Mrgsqi $ ( 9:09<:$ $ ( ;80;;;$$

$_5a Jegmpmx}$Gsrwxvygxmsr$*$Hiwmkr$viziryiw$vipexi$xs$er$i|terwmsr$tvsnigx$ex$xli$Gsqter}+w$qerekih1srp}$Jypleq$Gsvvigxmsrep

Girxvi$mr$Eywxvepme${lmgl$mw$i|tigxih$xs$fi$gsqtpixih$mr$xli$xlmvh$uyevxiv$sj$64642

Tvi1Xe|$Mrgsqi$Vigsrgmpmexmsr$sj$Wikqirxw

Xli$jspps{mrk$mw$e$vigsrgmpmexmsr$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$xsxep$stivexmrk$mrgsqi$jvsq$mxw$vitsvxefpi$wikqirxw$xs$xli$Gsqter}×w$mrgsqi

fijsvi$mrgsqi$xe|iw$erh$iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw$,mr$xlsywerhw->

$

$ Xlvii$Qsrxlw$Irhih $ $

$ $Qevgl$750

6464 $ $Qevgl$750

645= $ $

Stivexmrk$mrgsqi$jvsq$wikqirxw $ ( 55407:<$ $ ( 5650645$ $

Yreppsgexih$eqsyrxw> $ $ $$ $ $ $ $ $

Kirivep$erh$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw $ $ ,970;<6- $ $ ,8:0868- $

Rix$mrxiviwx$i|tirwi $ $ ,6<0;86- $ $ ,750<<8- $

Kemr$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx $ $ 509:7$ $ $ Ó$ $

Mrgsqi$fijsvi$mrgsqi$xe|iw$erh$iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj

$$$ejjmpmexiw $ ( 6=084;$ $ ( 860<=7$$

$Iuymx}$mr$Ievrmrkw$sj$Ejjmpmexiw

Iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw$mrgpyhiw$xli$Gsqter}×w$94)$s{rih$nsmrx$zirxyviw$mr$WEGW0$psgexih$mr$Wsyxl$Ejvmge0$erh$KISEqi}0

psgexih$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq2$Xli$Gsqter}+w$mrziwxqirxw$mr$xliwi$irxmxmiw$evi$eggsyrxih$jsv$yrhiv$xli$iuymx}$qixlsh$sj$eggsyrxmrk2

Xli$Gsqter}×w$mrziwxqirxw$mr$xliwi$irxmxmiw$evi$tviwirxih$ew$e$gsqtsrirx$sj$Sxliv$Rsr1Gyvvirx$Ewwixw$mr$xli$eggsqter}mrk

gsrwspmhexih$fepergi$wliixw2$

66

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 33 of 88

Page 309: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 773;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

Xli$Gsqter}$lew$vigsvhih$(524$qmppmsr$mr$ievrmrkw0$rix$sj$xe|0$jsv$WEGW$stivexmsrw$hyvmrk$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$64640

erh$(528$qmppmsr$mr$ievrmrkw0$rix$sj$xe|0$jsv$WEGW$stivexmsrw$hyvmrk$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$645=0${lmgl$evi$mrgpyhih$mr

iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw0$rix$sj$mrgsqi$xe|$tvszmwmsr$mr$xli$eggsqter}mrk$gsrwspmhexih$wxexiqirxw$sj$stivexmsrw2$Ew$sj

Qevgl$750$6464$erh$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$xli$Gsqter}×w$mrziwxqirx$mr$WEGW${ew$(<2=$qmppmsr$erh$(5627$qmppmsr0$viwtigxmzip}0$erh

vitviwirxw$mxw$wlevi$sj$gyqypexmzi$vitsvxih$ievrmrkw2

Xli$Gsqter}$lew$vigsvhih$(526$qmppmsr$mr$ievrmrkw0$rix$sj$xe|0$jsv$KIS$Eqi}+w$stivexmsrw$hyvmrk$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750

64640$erh$(526$qmppmsr$mr$ievrmrkw0$rix$sj$xe|0$jsv$KIS$Eqi}+w$stivexmsrw$hyvmrk$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$645=0${lmgl$evi

mrgpyhih$mr$iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw0$rix$sj$mrgsqi$xe|$tvszmwmsr$mr$xli$eggsqter}mrk$gsrwspmhexih$wxexiqirxw$sj$stivexmsrw2$Ew

sj$Qevgl$750$6464$erh$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$xli$Gsqter}×w$mrziwxqirx$mr$KISEqi}${ew$(:29$qmppmsr$erh$(92;$qmppmsr0$viwtigxmzip}0

erh$vitviwirxw$mxw$wlevi$sj$gyqypexmzi$vitsvxih$ievrmrkw2

572$FIRIJMX$TPERW

Xli$jspps{mrk$xefpi$wyqqevm~iw$oi}$mrjsvqexmsr$vipexih$xs$xli$Gsqter}×w$tirwmsr$tperw$erh$vixmviqirx$ekviiqirxw$,mr$xlsywerhw->

$

$

Xlvii$Qsrxlw$IrhihQevgl$750

6464 $ $

]iev$IrhihHigiqfiv$750

645= $

Glerki$mr$Tvsnigxih$Firijmx$Sfpmkexmsr $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Tvsnigxih$firijmx$sfpmkexmsr0$fikmrrmrk$sj$tivmsh $ ( 7;0995$ $ ( 7608;8$

Wivzmgi$gswx $ $ 757$ $ $ ==<$

Mrxiviwx$gswx $ $ 76:$ $ $ 507=7$

Egxyevmep$kemr $ $ Ó$ $ $ 7088=$

Sxliv$vigpewwmjmgexmsr$_5a $ $ ,<0=69- $ $ Ó$

Firijmxw$temh $ $ ,5<<- $ $ ,;:7-

Tvsnigxih$firijmx$sfpmkexmsr0$irh$sj$tivmsh $ ( 6=04;;$ $ ( 7;0995$

Glerki$mr$Tper$Ewwixw $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Tper$ewwixw$ex$jemv$zepyi0$fikmrrmrk$sj$tivmsh $ ( Ó$ $ ( Ó$

Gsqter}$gsrxvmfyxmsrw $ $ 5<<$ $ $ ;:7$

Firijmxw$temh $ $ ,5<<- $ $ ,;:7-

Tper$ewwixw$ex$jemv$zepyi0$irh$sj$tivmsh $ ( Ó$ $ ( Ó$

Yrjyrhih$Wxexyw$sj$xli$Tper $ ( 6=04;;$ $ ( 7;0995$

$

$ Xlvii$Qsrxlw$Irhih $ $

$$

Qevgl$7506464 $ $

Qevgl$750645= $ $

Gsqtsrirxw$sj$Rix$Tivmshmg$Firijmx$Gswx $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Wivzmgi$gswx $ ( 757$ $ ( 694$ $

Mrxiviwx$gswx $ $ 76:$ $ $ 78<$ $

Rix$psww $ $ 579$ $ $ 97$ $

Rix$tivmshmg$tirwmsr$gswx $ ( ;;8$ $ ( :95$$

$$

#%$ Xli$Gsqter}$lew$e$rsr1uyepmjmih$hijivvih$gsqtirwexmsr$ekviiqirx${mxl$mxw$GIS2$Xli$ekviiqirx$tvszmhih$jsv$e$pyqt$wyq

te}qirx$ytsr$vixmviqirx0$rs$wssriv$xler$eki$992$Ew$sj$Qevgl$750$64640$xli$GIS$leh$vieglih$eki$99$erh${ew$ipmkmfpi$xs$vigimzi$xli

te}qirx$ytsr$vixmviqirx2$Mj$xli$Gsqter}×w$GIS$leh$vixmvih$ew$sj$Qevgl$750$64640$xli$Gsqter}${syph$lezi$leh$xs$te}$lmq

ettvs|mqexip}$(<2=$qmppmsr"

$Sr$Jifvyev}$6:0$6464$,xli$&Ijjigxmzi$Hexi&-0$xli$Gsqter}$erh$mxw$GIS$irxivih$mrxs$er$eqirhih$erh$viwxexih$i|igyxmzi$vixmviqirx

ekviiqirx$xlex$eqirhw$erh$vitpegiw$xli$GIS×w$tvmsv$i|igyxmzi$vixmviqirx$ekviiqirx$hmwgywwih$efszi2

$

Xli$eqirhih$erh$viwxexih$i|igyxmzi$vixmviqirx$ekviiqirx$tvszmhiw$xlex$ytsr$xli$GIS×w$vixmviqirx$jvsq$xli$Gsqter}0$xli$Gsqter}

{mpp$te}$e$pyqt$wyq$eqsyrx$iuyep$xs$(<0=6904:9$,hixivqmrih$ew$sj$Jifvyev}$6:0$6464-$,xli$ÔKverhjexlivih$Te}qirxÕ-${lmgl${mpp$fi

temh$mr$xli$jsvq$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$gsqqsr$wxsgo2$Xli$Kverhjexlivih$Te}qirx${mpp$fi$hipe}ih$jsv$wm|$qsrxlw$erh$e$he}$jspps{mrk$xli

ijjigxmzi$hexi$sj$xli$GIS×w$xivqmrexmsr$sj$iqtps}qirx$mr$gsqtpmergi${mxl$Wigxmsr$84=E$sj$xli$Mrxivrep$Viziryi$Gshi$sj$5=<:0$ew

eqirhih2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 34 of 88

Page 310: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 783;9

$

Fikmrrmrk$sr$xli$Ijjigxmzi$Hexi0$er$eqsyrx$iuyep$xs$xli$Kverhjexlivih$Te}qirx$wlepp$fi$mrziwxih$mr$xli$Gsqter}×w$gsqqsr$wxsgo

,ÔKIS$WleviwÕ-2$Xli$ryqfiv$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$ew$sj$xli$Ijjigxmzi$Hexi$wlepp$fi$iuyep$xs$xli$Kverhjexlivih

67

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 35 of 88

Page 311: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 793;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

Te}qirx$hmzmhih$f}$xli$gpswmrk$tvmgi$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$gsqqsr$wxsgo$sr$xli$Ijjigxmzi$Hexi$,vsyrhih$yt$xs$xli$rieviwx${lspi$ryqfiv

sj$wleviw-0${lmgl$iuyepw$9970::9$wleviw$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$gsqqsr$wxsgo2$Ehhmxmsrep$wleviw$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$gsqqsr$wxsgo${mpp$fi

gvihmxih${mxl$e$zepyi$iuyep$xs$er}$hmzmhirhw$higpevih$erh$temh$sr$xli$Gsqter}×w$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo0$gepgypexih$f}$vijivirgi$xs

xli$gpswmrk$tvmgi$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$gsqqsr$wxsgo$sr$xli$te}qirx$hexi$jsv$wygl$hmzmhirhw$,vsyrhih$yt$xs$xli$rieviwx${lspi$ryqfiv$sj

wleviw-2

$

Xli$Gsqter}$lew$iwxefpmwlih$wizivep$xvywxw$jsv$xli$tyvtswi$sj$te}mrk$xli$vixmviqirx$firijmx$tyvwyerx$xs$xli$eqirhih$erh$viwxexih

i|igyxmzi$vixmviqirx$ekviiqirx2$Xli$xvywxw$wlepp$fi$vizsgefpi$Ôveffm$xvywxwÕ$erh$xli$ewwixw$sj$xli$xvywxw$wlepp$fi$wyfnigx$xs$xli$gpemqw$sj

xli$Gsqter}×w$gvihmxsvw$mr$xli$izirx$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$mrwspzirg}2

$

Xli$Gsqter}$vityvglewih$wleviw$sj$mxw$syxwxerhmrk$gsqqsr$wxsgo$yrhiv$mxw$wxsgo$fy}fego$tvskveq$erh$gsrxvmfyxih$wygl$wleviw$xs$xli

xvywxw$mr$svhiv$xs$jyrh$xli$vixmviqirx$firijmx$yrhiv$xli$eqirhih$erh$viwxexih$i|igyxmzi$vixmviqirx$ekviiqirx2$Mr$eggsvhergi${mxl

Eggsyrxmrk$Wxerhevhw$Gshmjmgexmsr$,ÔEWGÕ-$;54$Ò$Gsqtirwexmsr1Kirivep0$xli$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$liph$mr$xli$veffm$xvywxw$evi

gpewwmjmih$ew$xviewyv}$wxsgo2$$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$xli$eqirhih$erh$viwxexih$i|igyxmzi$vixmviqirx$ekviiqirx$uyepmjmiw$jsv$iuymx}$eggsyrxmrk$yrhiv

EWG$;54$erh$xlivijsvi0$xli$jemv$zepyi$sj$xli$Kverhjexlivih$te}qirx$lew$fiir$vigpewwmjmih$xs$wxsgolsphivw×$iuymx}$ew$sj$Qevgl$750$64642

$

Xli$psrk1xivq$tsvxmsr$sj$xli$tirwmsr$pmefmpmx}$ew$sj$Qevgl$750$6464$erh$Higiqfiv$750$645=${ew$(6<2;$qmppmsr$erh$(7;26$qmppmsr0

viwtigxmzip}0$erh$mw$mrgpyhih$mr$Sxliv$Rsr1Gyvvirx$Pmefmpmxmiw$mr$xli$eggsqter}mrk$gsrwspmhexih$fepergi$wliixw2

$

$

$

$

$

$

68

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 36 of 88

Page 312: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 7:3;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

582$VIGIRX$EGGSYRXMRK$TVSRSYRGIQIRXW

Xli$Gsqter}$mqtpiqirxih$xli$jspps{mrk$eggsyrxmrk$wxerhevhw$hyvmrk$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$6464>$$$$

$

Mr$Eykywx$645<0$xli$JEWF$mwwyih$EWY$Rs2$645<1570$&Jemv$Zepyi$Qiewyviqirx$,Xstmg$<64-&$ew$e$tevx$sj$mxw$hmwgpswyvi

jveqi{svo$tvsnigx2$Xli$eqirhqirxw$mr$xlmw$ythexi$viqszi0$qshmj}$erh$ehh$givxemr$hmwgpswyviw$tvmqevmp}$vipexih$xs$xverwjivw$fix{iir

Pizip$5$erh$Pizip$6$sj$xli$jemv$zepyi$lmivevgl}0$zevmsyw$hmwgpswyviw$vipexih$xs$Pizip$7$jemv$zepyi$qiewyviqirxw$erh$mrziwxqirxw$mr

givxemr$irxmxmiw$xlex$gepgypexi$rix$ewwix$zepyi2$Xli$ri{$wxerhevh${ew$ijjigxmzi$jsv$xli$Gsqter}$fikmrrmrk$Neryev}$50$64642$Xli

ehstxmsr$sj$xlmw$wxerhevh$hmh$rsx$lezi$e$qexivmep$mqtegx$sr$xli$Gsqter}+w$jmrergmep$tswmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$sv$gewl$jps{w2

$

Mr$Nyri$645:0$xli$JEWF$mwwyih$EWG$Rs2$645:1570$&Jmrergmep$Mrwxvyqirxw$Ò$Gvihmx$Pswwiw$,Xstmg$76:->$Qiewyviqirx$sj$Gvihmx

Pswwiw$sr$Jmrergmep$Mrwxvyqirxw&2$Xli$tyvtswi$sj$Ythexi$Rs2$645:157$mw$xs$vitpegi$xli$gyvvirx$mrgyvvih$psww$mqtemvqirx$qixlshspsk}

jsv$jmrergmep$ewwixw$qiewyvih$ex$eqsvxm~ih$gswx${mxl$e$qixlshspsk}$xlex$vijpigxw$i|tigxih$gvihmx$pswwiw$erh$viuymviw$gsrwmhivexmsr$sj$e

fvsehiv$verki$sj$viewsrefpi$erh$wyttsvxefpi$mrjsvqexmsr0$mrgpyhmrk$jsvigewxih$mrjsvqexmsr0$xs$hizipst$gvihmx$psww$iwxmqexiw2$Ythexi

Rs2$645:157${ew$ijjigxmzi$jsv$xli$Gsqter}$fikmrrmrk$Neryev}$50$64642$Xli$ehstxmsr$sj$xlmw$wxerhevh$hmh$rsx$lezi$e$qexivmep$mqtegx

sr$xli$Gsqter}+w$jmrergmep$tswmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$sv$gewl$jps{w2

$

Xli$jspps{mrk$eggsyrxmrk$wxerhevhw${mpp$fi$ehstxih$mr$jyxyvi$tivmshw>

$

Mr$Qevgl$64640$xli$JEWF$mwwyih$EWY$64641480$ÔVijivirgi$Vijsvq$Vexi$,Xstmg$<8<->$Jegmpmxexmsr$sj$xli$Ijjigxw$sj$Vijivirgi

Vexi$Vijsvq$sr$Jmrergmep$Vitsvxmrk0Õ$xs$tvszmhi$xiqtsvev}$stxmsrep$i|tihmirxw$erh$i|gitxmsrw$xs$xli$gsrxvegx$qshmjmgexmsrw0$lihki

vipexmsrwlmtw$erh$sxliv$xverwegxmsrw$ejjigxih$f}$vijivirgi$vexi$vijsvq$mj$givxemr$gvmxivme$evi$qix2$Xlmw$EWY0${lmgl${ew$ijjigxmzi$ytsr

mwwyergi$erh$qe}$fi$ettpmih$xlvsykl$Higiqfiv$750$64660$mw$ettpmgefpi$xs$epp$gsrxvegxw$erh$lihkmrk$vipexmsrwlmtw$xlex$vijivirgi$xli

Psrhsr$Mrxivfero$Sjjivih$Vexi$sv$er}$sxliv$vijivirgi$vexi$i|tigxih$xs$fi$hmwgsrxmryih2$Xli$Gsqter}$mw$gyvvirxp}$izepyexmrk$xli

mqtegx$sj$vijivirgi$vexi$vijsvq$erh$xli$tsxirxmep$ettpmgexmsr$sj$xlmw$kymhergi2

$

Mr$Eykywx$645<0$xli$JEWF$mwwyih$EWY$Rs2$645<1580$&Gsqtirwexmsr1Vixmviqirx$Firijmxw1Hijmrih$Firijmx$Tperw1Kirivep

,Xstmg$;59264-&$ew$e$tevx$sj$mxw$hmwgpswyvi$jveqi{svo$tvsnigx2$Xli$eqirhqirxw$mr$xlmw$ythexi$viqszi0$qshmj}$erh$ehh$givxemr

hmwgpswyviw$tvmqevmp}$vipexih$xs$eqsyrxw$mr$eggyqypexih$sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$i|tigxih$xs$fi$vigskrm~ih$ew$gsqtsrirxw$sj$rix

tivmshmg$firijmx$gswx$sziv$xli$ri|x$jmwgep$}iev0$i|tperexmsrw$jsv$viewsrw$jsv$wmkrmjmgerx$kemrw$erh$pswwiw$vipexih$xs$glerkiw$mr$xli$firijmx

sfpmkexmsr$jsv$xli$tivmsh0$erh$tvsnigxih$erh$eggyqypexih$firijmx$sfpmkexmsrw2$Xli$ri{$wxerhevh$mw$ijjigxmzi$jsv$xli$Gsqter}$fikmrrmrk

Neryev}$50$64652$Xli$ehstxmsr$sj$xlmw$wxerhevh$mw$rsx$i|tigxih$xs$lezi$e$qexivmep$mqtegx$sr$xli$Gsqter}+w$jmrergmep$tswmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj

stivexmsrw$sv$gewl$jps{w2

Sxliv$vigirx$eggsyrxmrk$tvsrsyrgiqirxw$mwwyih$f}$xli$JEWF$,mrgpyhmrk$mxw$Iqivkmrk$Mwwyiw$Xewo$Jsvgi-0$xli$Eqivmger$Mrwxmxyxi$sj

Givxmjmih$Tyfpmg$Eggsyrxerxw$erh$xli$WIG$hmh$rsx0$sv$evi$rsx$i|tigxih$xs0$lezi$e$qexivmep$ijjigx$sr$xli$Gsqter}+w$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw

sv$jmrergmep$tswmxmsr2

592$GSRHIRWIH$GSRWSPMHEXMRK$JMRERGMEP$MRJSVQEXMSR

Ew$sj$Qevgl$750$64640$xli$Gsqter}+w$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466$erh$xli$92<;9)

Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6468${ivi$jypp}$erh$yrgsrhmxmsrepp}$kyeverxiih$sr$e$nsmrx$erh$wizivep$wirmsv$yrwigyvih$fewmw$f}$xli$Gsqter}$erh

givxemr$sj$mxw${lspp}1s{rih$hsqiwxmg$wyfwmhmevmiw$,xli$ÔWyfwmhmev}$KyeverxsvwÕ-2$Xli$jspps{mrk$gsrhirwih$gsrwspmhexmrk$jmrergmep

mrjsvqexmsr0${lmgl$lew$fiir$tvitevih$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$xli$viuymviqirxw$jsv$tviwirxexmsr$sj$Vypi$7154,h-$sj$Vikypexmsr$W1\

tvsqypkexih$yrhiv$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$Egx0$tviwirxw$xli$gsrhirwih$gsrwspmhexmrk$jmrergmep$mrjsvqexmsr$witevexip}$jsv>

$ ,m- Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg20$ew$xli$mwwyiv$sj$xli$rsxiw?

$ ,mm- Xli$Wyfwmhmev}$Kyeverxsvw0$sr$e$gsqfmrih$fewmw0${lmgl$evi$544)$s{rih$f}$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg20$erh${lmgl$evi

kyeverxsvw$sj$xli$rsxiw?

$ ,mmm- Xli$Gsqter}×w$sxliv$wyfwmhmevmiw0$sr$e$gsqfmrih$fewmw0${lmgl$evi$rsx$kyeverxsvw$sj$xli$rsxiw$,xli$ÔRsr1Kyeverxsv

WyfwmhmevmiwÕ-?

69

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 37 of 88

Page 313: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 7;3;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

$ ,mz- Gsrwspmhexmrk$irxvmiw$erh$ipmqmrexmsrw$vitviwirxmrk$ehnywxqirxw$xs$,e-$ipmqmrexi$mrxivgsqter}$xverwegxmsrw$fix{iir$sv

eqsrk$xli$Gsqter}0$xli$Wyfwmhmev}$Kyeverxsvw$erh$xli$Wyfwmhmev}$Rsr1Kyeverxsvw$erh$,f-$ipmqmrexi$xli$mrziwxqirxw$mr

xli$Gsqter}×w$wyfwmhmevmiw?$erh

$ ,z- Xli$Gsqter}$erh$mxw$wyfwmhmevmiw$sr$e$gsrwspmhexih$fewmw2

6:

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 38 of 88

Page 314: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 7<3;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

GSRHIRWIH$GSRWSPMHEXMRK$WXEXIQIRX$SJ$STIVEXMSRW$ERH$GSQTVILIRWMZI$MRGSQI

,hsppevw$mr$xlsywerhw-

,yreyhmxih-

$

$ Jsv$xli$Xlvii$Qsrxlw$Irhih$Qevgl$750$6464 $

$

$Xli$KISKvsyt0$Mrg2 $ $

GsqfmrihWyfwmhmev}Kyeverxsvw $ $

GsqfmrihRsr1

KyeverxsvWyfwmhmevmiw $ $ Ipmqmrexmsrw $ $ Gsrwspmhexih $

Viziryiw $ ( 67<0;59$ $ ( 8=60;;8$ $ ( :90555$ $ ( ,5=509<7- $ ( :49045;$

Stivexmrk$i|tirwiw $ $ 5<;09::$ $ $ 8580:7=$ $ $ 940;44$ $ $ ,5=509<7- $ $ 8:50766$

Hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr $ $ ;0<5:$ $ $ 6809;8$ $ $ =7;$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 77076;$

Kirivep$erh$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw $ $ 650465$ $ $ 6;046;$ $ $ 90;78$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 970;<6$

Stivexmrk$mrgsqi $ $ 660756$ $ $ 6:0978$ $ $ ;0;84$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 9:09<:$

Mrxiviwx$mrgsqi $ $ 7079<$ $ $ 507;6$ $ $ 90449$ $ $ ,806=;- $ $ 9087<$

Mrxiviwx$i|tirwi $ $ ,640;7<- $ $ ,570:5:- $ $ ,80567- $ $ 806=;$ $ $ ,7805<4-

Kemr$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx $ $ Ó$ $ $ 509:7$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 509:7$

Mrgsqi$fijsvi$mrgsqi$xe|iw$erh$iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj

$$$ejjmpmexiw $ $ 80=76$ $ $ 590<97$ $ $ <0:66$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 6=084;$

Mrgsqi$xe|$tvszmwmsr $ $ 5=<$ $ $ 80478$ $ $ 60758$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ :098:$

Iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw0$rix$sj$mrgsqi

$$$xe|$tvszmwmsr $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 606:4$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 606:4$

Mrgsqi$fijsvi$iuymx}$mr$mrgsqi$sj$gsrwspmhexih

$$$wyfwmhmevmiw $ $ 80;78$ $ $ 550<5=$ $ $ <09:<$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 690565$

Mrgsqi$jvsq$gsrwspmhexih$wyfwmhmevmiw0$rix$sj$mrgsqi

$$$xe|$tvszmwmsr $ $ 6407<;$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,6407<;- $ $ Ó$

Rix$mrgsqi $ $ 690565$ $ $ 550<5=$ $ $ <09:<$ $ $ ,6407<;- $ $ 690565$

Rix$psww$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$rsrgsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ :4$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ :4$

Rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2 $ ( 690565$ $ ( 550<5=$ $ ( <0:6<$ $ ( ,6407<;- $ ( 6905<5$

$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $$ $ $ $$ $ $ $$

Rix$mrgsqi $ ( 690565$ $ ( 550<5=$ $ ( <09:<$ $ ( ,6407<;- $ ( 690565$

Sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$,psww-0$rix$sj$xe| $ $ ,80956- $ $ 54;$ $ $ ,<0<4;- $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,570656-

Xsxep$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi $ ( 640:4=$ $ ( 550=6:$ $ ( ,67=- $ ( ,6407<;- $ ( 550=4=$

Gsqtvilirwmzi$psww$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$rsrgsrxvsppmrk

$$$mrxiviwxw $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 54<$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 54<$

Gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$,psww-$exxvmfyxefpi$xs

$$$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2 $ ( 640:4=$ $ ( 550=6:$ $ ( ,575- $ ( ,6407<;- $ ( 56045;$

6;

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 39 of 88

Page 315: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 7=3;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

GSRHIRWIH$GSRWSPMHEXMRK$WXEXIQIRX$SJ$STIVEXMSRW$ERH$GSQTVILIRWMZI$MRGSQI

,hsppevw$mr$xlsywerhw-

,yreyhmxih-

$

$ Jsv$xli$Xlvii$Qsrxlw$Irhih$Qevgl$750$645= $

$ $Xli$KISKvsyt0$Mrg2 $ $

GsqfmrihWyfwmhmev}Kyeverxsvw $ $

GsqfmrihRsr1

KyeverxsvWyfwmhmevmiw $ $ Ipmqmrexmsrw $ $ Gsrwspmhexih $

Viziryiw $ ( 66<07<6$ $ ( 8=80<=4$ $ ( :<0=:<$ $ ( ,5<509;7- $ ( :540::;$

Stivexmrk$i|tirwiw $ $ 5;5095:$ $ $ 8560897$ $ $ 980:45$ $ $ ,5<509;7- $ $ 89:0==;$

Hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr $ $ ;085=$ $ $ 6805<9$ $ $ <:9$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 7608:=$

Kirivep$erh$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw $ $ 5;0644$ $ $ 680474$ $ $ 905=8$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 8:0868$

Stivexmrk$mrgsqi $ $ 76068;$ $ $ 780666$ $ $ <074<$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ ;80;;;$

Mrxiviwx$mrgsqi $ $ 708;<$ $ $ 50779$ $ $ <05=<$ $ $ ,80:59- $ $ <07=:$

Mrxiviwx$i|tirwi $ $ ,6706=:- $ $ ,570<8;- $ $ ,;0;96- $ $ 80:59$ $ $ ,8406<4-

Mrgsqi$fijsvi$mrgsqi$xe|iw$erh$iuymx}$mr

$$$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw $ $ 56086=$ $ $ 650;54$ $ $ <0;98$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 860<=7$

Mrgsqi$xe|$tvszmwmsr $ $ 6<=$ $ $ 607;=$ $ $ 605;6$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 80<84$

Iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw0$rix$sj$mrgsqi

$$$xe|$tvszmwmsr $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 609=:$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 609=:$

Mrgsqi$fijsvi$iuymx}$mr$mrgsqi$sj$gsrwspmhexih

$$$wyfwmhmevmiw $ $ 560584$ $ $ 5=0775$ $ $ =05;<$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 840:8=$

Mrgsqi$jvsq$gsrwspmhexih$wyfwmhmevmiw0$rix$sj$mrgsqi

$$$xe|$tvszmwmsr $ $ 6<094=$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,6<094=- $ $ Ó$

Rix$mrgsqi $ $ 840:8=$ $ $ 5=0775$ $ $ =05;<$ $ $ ,6<094=- $ $ 840:8=$

Rix$psww$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$rsrgsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 9:$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 9:$

Rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2 $ ( 840:8=$ $ ( 5=0775$ $ ( =0678$ $ ( ,6<094=- $ ( 840;49$

$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $$ $ $ $$ $ $ $$

Rix$mrgsqi $ ( 840:8=$ $ ( 5=0775$ $ ( =05;<$ $ ( ,6<094=- $ ( 840:8=$

Sxliv$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$,psww-0$rix$sj$xe| $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,:8<- $ $ 60=44$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 60696$

Xsxep$gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi $ ( 840:8=$ $ ( 5<0:<7$ $ ( 5604;<$ $ ( ,6<094=- $ ( 860=45$

Gsqtvilirwmzi$psww$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$rsrgsrxvsppmrk

$$$mrxiviwxw $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 9:$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 9:$

Gsqtvilirwmzi$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs

$$$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2 $ ( 840:8=$ $ ( 5<0:<7$ $ ( 560578$ $ ( ,6<094=- $ ( 860=9;$

$

6<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 40 of 88

Page 316: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 843;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

GSRHIRWIH$GSRWSPMHEXMRK$FEPERGI$WLIIX

,hsppevw$mr$xlsywerhw-

,yreyhmxih-

$

$ Ew$sj$Qevgl$750$6464 $

$ $Xli$KISKvsyt0$Mrg2 $ $

GsqfmrihWyfwmhmev}Kyeverxsvw $ $

GsqfmrihRsr1

KyeverxsvWyfwmhmevmiw $ $ Ipmqmrexmsrw $ $ Gsrwspmhexih $

EWWIXW $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw $ ( <0:;7$ $ ( =78$ $ ( 660<4;$ $ ( Ó$ $ ( 760858$

Viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 6;0<:9$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 6;0<:9$

Eggsyrxw$vigimzefpi0$piww$epps{ergi$jsv$hsyfxjyp

$$$eggsyrxw $ $ 5960445$ $ $ 5<;097=$ $ $ 760;=8$ $ $ 7055=$ $ $ 7;90897$

Gsrxvegx$vigimzefpi0$gyvvirx$tsvxmsr $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 80:<:$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 80:<:$

Tvitemh$i|tirwiw$erh$sxliv$gyvvirx$ewwixw $ $ 50::;$ $ $ 6<07;;$ $ $ <05;=$ $ $ ,60559- $ $ 7:054<$

Xsxep$gyvvirx$ewwixw $ $ 5:60785$ $ $ 65:0<94$ $ $ =:0775$ $ $ 50448$ $ $ 8;:096:$

Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Mrziwxqirxw $ $ Ó$ $ $ 690587$ $ $ 6056<$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 6;06;5$

Tvstivx}$erh$Iuymtqirx0$Rix $ $ <8<0=6:$ $ $ 50656044<$ $ $ <509=:$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 605860974$

Ewwixw$Liph$jsv$Wepi $ $ ;49$ $ $ 70;44$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 80849$

Gsrxvegx$Vigimzefpi $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 75=0<5=$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 75=0<5=$

Stivexmrk$Piewi$Vmklx1sj1Ywi$Ewwixw0$Rix $ $ 640:85$ $ $ 54605:9$ $ $ :9=$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 56708:9$

Mrxivgsqter}$Vigimzefpi $ $ =:50589$ $ $ 6860;;;$ $ $ 580;58$ $ $ ,5065<0:7:- $ $ Ó$

Hijivvih$Mrgsqi$Xe|$Ewwixw $ $ Ó$ $ $ 7909<9$ $ $ :=7$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 7:06;<$

Kssh{mpp $ $ Ó$ $ $ ;;90=98$ $ $ 796$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ ;;:074:$

Mrxerkmfpi$Ewwixw0$Rix $ $ Ó$ $ $ 6470==9$ $ $ 7=6$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 64807<;$

Mrziwxqirx$mr$Wyfwmhmevmiw $ $ 50898067<$ $ $ 9;70<5:$ $ $ 605=4$ $ $ ,604740688- $ $ Ó$

Sxliv$Rsr1Gyvvirx$Ewwixw $ $ 5;0:=<$ $ $ 5640:54$ $ $ 5:04<4$ $ $ ,;;096<- $ $ ;:0<:4$

Xsxep$Ewwixw $ ( 708:90:=8$ $ ( 709560:47$ $ ( 9780=98$ $ ( ,707690848- $ ( 805<;0<8;$

$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $$ $ $ $$ $ $ $$

PMEFMPMXMIW$ERH$WLEVILSPHIVW×$IUYMX] $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Eggsyrxw$te}efpi $ ( 550:=4$ $ ( ;<0<=5$ $ ( 6074:$ $ ( Ó$ $ ( =60<<;$

Eggvyih$te}vspp$erh$vipexih$xe|iw $ $ Ó$ $ $ 8:0=<8$ $ $ 5:0465$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ :70449$

Eggvyih$i|tirwiw$erh$sxliv$gyvvirx$pmefmpmxmiw $ $ 7<08=:$ $ $ 559075;$ $ $ 690884$ $ $ ,85=- $ $ 5;<0<78$

Stivexmrk$piewi$pmefmpmxmiw0$gyvvirx$tsvxmsr $ $ 9076<$ $ $ 650998$ $ $ <:$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 6:0=:<$

Gyvvirx$tsvxmsr$sj$jmrergi$piewi$pmefmpmxmiw0$psrk1xivq

$$$hifx$erh$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx $ $ <0444$ $ $ 60:6:$ $ $ 560===$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 670:69$

Xsxep$gyvvirx$pmefmpmxmiw $ $ :70958$ $ $ 6:907;6$ $ $ 9:0<96$ $ $ ,85=- $ $ 7<9075=$

Hijivvih$Mrgsqi$Xe|$Pmefmpmxmiw $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 5=0698$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 5=0698$

Mrxivgsqter}$Te}efpi $ $ 5490699$ $ $ 504<;0=<5$ $ $ 670=;:$ $ $ ,5065;0656- $ $ Ó$

Sxliv$Rsr1Gyvvirx$Pmefmpmxmiw $ $ 80;59$ $ $ 5990554$ $ $ 6=8$ $ $ ,;;096<- $ $ <609=5$

Stivexmrk$piewi$Pmefmpmxmiw $ $ 590<:4$ $ $ <60<<5$ $ $ 9;7$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ ==0758$

Jmrergi$Piewi$Pmefmpmxmiw $ $ Ó$ $ $ 609:7$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 609:7$

Psrk1Xivq$Hifx $ $ 6075<0448$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 960<<:$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 607;40<=4$

Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Hifx $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 6;408:4$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 6;408:4$

Gsqqmxqirxw$*$Gsrxmrkirgmiw$erh$Sxliv $ $ $$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $$ $ $ $$ $ $ Ó$

Wlevilsphivw+$Iuymx}> $ $ $$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $$ $ $ $$ $ $ Ó$

Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2$Wlevilsphivw+$Iuymx} $ $ =9<078:$ $ $ 50=5<0:=:$ $ $ 555098=$ $ $ ,604740689- $ $ =9<078:$

Rsrgsrxvsppmrk$Mrxiviwxw $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,<=4- $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,<=4-

Xsxep$Wlevilsphivw×$Iuymx} $ $ =9<078:$ $ $ 50=5<0:=:$ $ $ 5540:9=$ $ $ ,604740689- $ $ =9;089:$

Xsxep$Pmefmpmxmiw$erh$Wlevilsphivw+$Iuymx} $ ( 708:90:=8$ $ ( 709560:47$ $ ( 9780=98$ $ ( ,707690848- $ ( 805<;0<8;$

$

6=

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 41 of 88

Page 317: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 853;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

GSRHIRWIH$GSRWSPMHEXMRK$FEPERGI$WLIIX

,hsppevw$mr$xlsywerhw-

,yreyhmxih-

$

$ Ew$sj$Higiqfiv$750$645= $

$ $Xli$KISKvsyt0$Mrg2 $ $

GsqfmrihWyfwmhmev}Kyeverxsvw $ $

GsqfmrihRsr1

KyeverxsvWyfwmhmevmiw $ $ Ipmqmrexmsrw $ $ Gsrwspmhexih $

EWWIXW $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw $ ( =0<84$ $ ( Ó$ $ ( 660:67$ $ ( Ó$ $ ( 7608:7$

Viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 76085<$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 76085<$

Eggsyrxw$vigimzefpi0$piww$epps{ergi$jsv$hsyfxjyp

$$$eggsyrxw $ $ 5:;0;:=$ $ $ 65<0=64$ $ $ 8505;9$ $ $ 7055<$ $ $ 8740=<6$

Gsrxvegx$vigimzefpi0$gyvvirx$tsvxmsr $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 5505==$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 5505==$

Tvitemh$i|tirwiw$erh$sxliv$gyvvirx$ewwixw $ $ 506;7$ $ $ 7605<;$ $ $ =0759$ $ $ ,6049=- $ $ 840;5:$

Xsxep$gyvvirx$ewwixw $ $ 5;<0<<6$ $ $ 695054;$ $ $ 55:0;74$ $ $ 5049=$ $ $ 98;0;;<$

Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Mrziwxqirxw $ $ Ó$ $ $ 6<0:8<$ $ $ 606;9$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 740=67$

Tvstivx}$erh$Iuymtqirx0$Rix $ $ <8:06=;$ $ $ 506580:=;$ $ $ <70;6<$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 605880;66$

Vmklx1sj1Ywi$Ewwixw$Stivexmrk$Piewiw $ $ 650==9$ $ $ =<0:98$ $ $ <;<$ $ $ $$ $ $ 565096;$

Ewwixw$Liph$jsv$Wepi $ $ ;49$ $ $ 90798$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ :049=$

Gsrxvegx$Vigimzefpi $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 7:40:8;$ $ $ $$ $ $ 7:40:8;$

Mrxivgsqter}$Vigimzefpi $ $ =;<077;$ $ $ 67<0:<4$ $ $ 5;0494$ $ $ ,5067804:;- $ $ Ó$

Hijivvih$Mrgsqi$Xe|$Ewwixw $ $ Ó$ $ $ 7909<8$ $ $ :=8$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 7:06;<$

Kssh{mpp $ $ Ó$ $ $ ;;90=97$ $ $ 847$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ ;;:079:$

Mrxerkmfpi$Ewwixw0$Rix $ $ Ó$ $ $ 64=0998$ $ $ 95:$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 65404;4$

Mrziwxqirx$mr$Wyfwmhmevmiw $ $ 508<80=74$ $ $ 9;70<5:$ $ $ 605<=$ $ $ ,604:40=79- $ $ Ó$

Sxliv$Rsr1Gyvvirx$Ewwixw $ $ 5<076=$ $ $ 5670;=;$ $ $ 5<0<97$ $ $ ,;;0<49- $ $ <705;8$

Xsxep$Ewwixw $ ( 7096=08;9$ $ ( 709990<88$ $ ( :470=:7$ $ ( ,707;50;8<- $ ( 8075;0978$

$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $$ $ $ $$ $ $ $$

PMEFMPMXMIW$ERH$WLEVILSPHIVW×$IUYMX] $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

Eggsyrxw$te}efpi $ ( 5:0:=4$ $ ( ;:0:75$ $ ( 90=55$ $ ( Ó$ $ ( ==0676$

Eggvyih$te}vspp$erh$vipexih$xe|iw $ $ Ó$ $ $ 7<0687$ $ $ 5:086=$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 980:;6$

Eggvyih$i|tirwiw$erh$sxliv$gyvvirx$pmefmpmxmiw $ $ 7605;9$ $ $ 5750475$ $ $ 6<0;:9$ $ $ ,7:7- $ $ 5=50:4<$

Stivexmrk$piewi$pmefmpmxmiw0$gyvvirx$tsvxmsr $ $ 90676$ $ $ 640;;;$ $ $ 5==$ $ $ $$ $ $ 6:064<$

Gyvvirx$tsvxmsr$sj$jmrergi$piewi$pmefmpmxmiw0$psrk1xivq

$$$hifx$erh$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx $ $ <0444$ $ $ 60:6:$ $ $ 5709<6$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 68064<$

Xsxep$gyvvirx$pmefmpmxmiw $ $ :604=;$ $ $ 6:=074<$ $ $ :80<<:$ $ $ ,7:7- $ $ 7=90=6<$

Hijivvih$Mrgsqi$Xe|$Pmefmpmxmiw $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 5=0698$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 5=0698$

Mrxivgsqter}$Te}efpi $ $ 54:046=$ $ $ 5054406==$ $ $ 6:075:$ $ $ ,506760:88- $ $ Ó$

Sxliv$Rsr1Gyvvirx$Pmefmpmxmiw $ $ 709;6$ $ $ 5:6046:$ $ $ ;77$ $ $ ,;;0<49- $ $ <<096:$

Stivexmrk$Piewi$Pmefmpmxmiw $ $ 5;0765$ $ $ ;=06=4$ $ $ :<4$ $ $ $$ $ $ =;06=5$

Jmrergi$Piewi$Pmefmpmxmiw $ $ Ó$ $ $ 60=98$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 60=98$

Psrk1Xivq$Hifx $ $ 607870:6:$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ :80:;5$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 6084<06=;$

Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Hifx $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 74=067:$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 74=067:$

Gsqqmxqirxw$*$Gsrxmrkirgmiw$erh$Sxliv $ $ $$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $$ $ $ $$ $ $ Ó$

Wlevilsphivw+$Iuymx}> $ $ $$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $$ $ $ $$ $ $ Ó$

Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2$Wlevilsphivw+$Iuymx} $ $ ==:0<74$ $ $ 50=850=:;$ $ $ 55<0=:=$ $ $ ,604:40=7:- $ $ ==:0<74$

Rsrgsrxvsppmrk$Mrxiviwxw $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,;<6- $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,;<6-

Xsxep$Wlevilsphivw×$Iuymx} $ $ ==:0<74$ $ $ 50=850=:;$ $ $ 55<05<;$ $ $ ,604:40=7:- $ $ ==:048<$

Xsxep$Pmefmpmxmiw$erh$Wlevilsphivw+$Iuymx} $ ( 7096=08;9$ $ ( 709990<88$ $ ( :470=:7$ $ ( ,707;50;8<- $ ( 8075;0978$

$

74

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 42 of 88

Page 318: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 863;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

GSRHIRWIH$GSRWSPMHEXMRK$WXEXIQIRX$SJ$GEWL$JPS[W

,hsppevw$mr$xlsywerhw-

,yreyhmxih-

$

$ Jsv$xli$Xlvii$Qsrxlw$Irhih$Qevgl$750$6464 $

$ $Xli$KISKvsyt0$Mrg2 $ $

GsqfmrihWyfwmhmev}Kyeverxsvw $ $

GsqfmrihRsr1

KyeverxsvWyfwmhmevmiw $ $ Gsrwspmhexih $

Gewl$Jps{$jvsq$Stivexmrk$Egxmzmxmiw> $ $ $$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $$

Rix$gewl$tvszmhih$f}$stivexmrk$egxmzmxmiw $ ( 54904=8$ $ ( 580956$ $ ( <0:97$ $ ( 56<069=$

Gewl$Jps{$jvsq$Mrziwxmrk$Egxmzmxmiw> $ $ $$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $$

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$wepi$sj$tvstivx}$erh$iuymtqirx $ $ Ó$ $ $ 6:8$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 6:8$

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$wepi$sj$ewwixw$liph$jsv$wepi $ $ Ó$ $ $ 50744$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 50744$

Glerki$mr$viwxvmgxih$mrziwxqirxw $ $ Ó$ $ $ 707:7$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 707:7$

Getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw $ $ ,5509<7- $ $ ,5<0:8;- $ $ ,866- $ $ ,740:96-

Rix$gewl$ywih$mr$mrziwxmrk$egxmzmxmiw $ $ ,5509<7- $ $ ,570;64- $ $ ,866- $ $ ,690;69-

Gewl$Jps{$jvsq$Jmrergmrk$Egxmzmxmiw> $ $ $$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $$

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$psrk1xivq$hifx $ $ =:0444$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ =:0444$

Te}qirxw$sr$psrk1xivq$hifx $ $ ,56508<9- $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,80464- $ $ ,5690949-

Te}qirxw$sr$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,507:6- $ $ ,507:6-

Xe|iw$temh$vipexih$xs$rix$wlevi$wixxpiqirxw$sj$iuymx}$e{evhw $ $ ,60:76- $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,60:76-

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$mwwyergi$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$mr$gsrrigxmsr

$$${mxl$IWTT $ $ 594$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 594$

Te}qirx$jsv$vityvglewiw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo $ $ ,=044=- $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,=044=-

Hmzmhirhw$temh $ $ ,9;0;47- $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,9;0;47-

Rix$gewl$ywih$mr$jmrergmrk$egxmzmxmiw $ $ ,=80:;=- $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,907<6- $ $ ,54404:5-

Ijjigx$sj$I|glerki$Vexi$Glerkiw$sr$Gewl0$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw

$$$erh$Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,;07:8- $ $ ,;07:8-

Rix$,Higviewi-$Mrgviewi$mr$Gewl2$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw$erh

$$$Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw $ $ ,505:<- $ $ ;=6$ $ $ ,80959- $ $ ,80<=5-

Gewl0$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw$erh$Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Gewl

$$$Iuymzepirxw0$fikmrrmrk$sj$tivmsh $ $ =0<84$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 9;0:76$ $ $ :;08;6$

Gewl0$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw$erh$Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Gewl

$$$Iuymzepirxw0$irh$sj$tivmsh $ ( <0:;6$ $ ( ;=6$ $ ( 97055;$ $ ( :609<5$

75

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 43 of 88

Page 319: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 873;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

GSRHIRWIH$GSRWSPMHEXMRK$WXEXIQIRX$SJ$GEWL$JPS[W

,hsppevw$mr$xlsywerhw-

,yreyhmxih-

$

$ Jsv$xli$Xlvii$Qsrxlw$Irhih$Qevgl$750$645= $

$ $Xli$KISKvsyt0$Mrg2 $ $

GsqfmrihWyfwmhmev}Kyeverxsvw $ $

GsqfmrihRsr1

KyeverxsvWyfwmhmevmiw $ $ Gsrwspmhexih $

Gewl$Jps{$jvsq$Stivexmrk$Egxmzmxmiw> $ $ $$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $$

Rix$gewl$tvszmhih$f}$stivexmrk$egxmzmxmiw $ ( 580798$ $ ( 640<;=$ $ ( :70;;<$ $ ( ==0455$

Gewl$Jps{$jvsq$Mrziwxmrk$Egxmzmxmiw> $ $ $$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $$

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$wepi$sj$tvstivx}$erh$iuymtqirx $ $ Ó$ $ $ 6;8$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 6;8$

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$wepi$sj$ewwixw$liph$jsv$wepi $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ $$ $ $ Ó$

Mrwyvergi$tvsgiihw$1$heqekih$tvstivx} $ $ Ó$ $ $ 60947$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 60947$

Glerki$mr$viwxvmgxih$mrziwxqirxw $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,804:6- $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,804:6-

Getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw $ $ ,:0:4<- $ $ ,650896- $ $ ,68- $ $ ,6<04<8-

Rix$gewl$ywih$mr$mrziwxmrk$egxmzmxmiw $ $ ,:0:4<- $ $ ,660;7;- $ $ ,68- $ $ ,6=07:=-

Gewl$Jps{$jvsq$Jmrergmrk$Egxmzmxmiw> $ $ $$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $$

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$psrk1xivq$hifx $ $ 5740444$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 5740444$

Te}qirxw$sr$psrk1xivq$hifx $ $ ,=:0=6:- $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,=:0=6:-

Te}qirxw$sr$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,604<=- $ $ ,604<=-

Xe|iw$temh$vipexih$xs$rix$wlevi$wixxpiqirxw$sj$iuymx}$e{evhw $ $ ,805;6- $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,805;6-

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$mwwyergi$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$mr$gsrrigxmsr

$$${mxl$IWTT $ $ 568$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 568$

Tvsgiihw$jvsq$wxsgo$stxmsrw$i|ivgmwih $ $ 777$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 777$

Hmzmhirhw$temh $ $ ,9;0=89- $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,9;0=89-

Rix$gewl$ywih$mr$jmrergmrk$egxmzmxmiw $ $ ,6<09<:- $ $ Ó$ $ $ ,604<=- $ $ ,740:;9-

Ijjigx$sj$I|glerki$Vexi$Glerkiw$sr$Gewl0$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw

$$$erh$Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw $ $ Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ $ 7::$ $ $ 7::$

Rix$,Higviewi-$Mrgviewi$mr$Gewl0$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw$erh

$$$Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw $ $ ,640<84- $ $ ,50<9<- $ $ :60475$ $ $ 7=0777$

Gewl0$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw$erh$Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Gewl

$$$Iuymzepirxw0$fikmrrmrk$sj$tivmsh $ $ 980:::$ $ $ 80<67$ $ $ 680=<7$ $ $ <808;6$

Gewl0$Gewl$Iuymzepirxw$erh$Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Gewl

$$$Iuymzepirxw0$irh$sj$tivmsh $ ( 770<6:$ $ ( 60=:9$ $ ( <;0458$ $ ( 5670<49$

$5:2$WYFWIUYIRX$IZIRXW

Hmzmhirh

Sr$Etvmp$:0$64640$xli$Fsevh$sj$Hmvigxsvw$higpevih$e$uyevxivp}$gewl$hmzmhirh$sj$(428<$tiv$wlevi$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo${lmgl${ew$temh$sr

Etvmp$680$6464$xs$wlevilsphivw$sj$vigsvh$ew$sj$xli$gpswi$sj$fywmriww$sr$Etvmp$5;0$64642

$

$

$

76

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 44 of 88

Page 320: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 883;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

MXIQ$62$QEREKIQIRX×W$HMWGYWWMSR$ERH$EREP]WMW$SJ$JMRERGMEP$GSRHMXMSR$ERH$VIWYPXW$SJ

STIVEXMSRW2

Jsv{evh1Pssomrk$Mrjsvqexmsr

Xlmw$Uyevxivp}$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541U$erh$xli$hsgyqirxw$mrgsvtsvexih$f}$vijivirgi$livimr$gsrxemr$Ôjsv{evh1pssomrkÕ$wxexiqirxw${mxlmr

xli$qiermrk$sj$Wigxmsr$6;E$sj$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$Egx$sj$5=770$ew$eqirhih0$erh$Wigxmsr$65I$sj$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$I|glerki$Egx$sj$5=780$ew

eqirhih2$ÔJsv{evh1pssomrkÕ$wxexiqirxw$evi$er}$wxexiqirxw$xlex$evi$rsx$fewih$sr$lmwxsvmgep$mrjsvqexmsr2$Wxexiqirxw$sxliv$xler

wxexiqirxw$sj$lmwxsvmgep$jegxw$mrgpyhih$mr$xlmw$vitsvx0$mrgpyhmrk0${mxlsyx$pmqmxexmsr0$wxexiqirxw$vikevhmrk$syv$jyxyvi$jmrergmep$tswmxmsr0

fywmriww$wxvexik}0$xli$mqtegx$sj$GSZMH15=$sr$syv$fywmriww0$fyhkixw0$tvsnigxih$gswxw$erh$tperw$erh$sfnigxmziw$sj$qerekiqirx$jsv

jyxyvi$stivexmsrw0$evi$Ôjsv{evh1pssomrkÕ$wxexiqirxw2$Jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw$kirivepp}$ger$fi$mhirxmjmih$f}$xli$ywi$sj$jsv{evh1

pssomrk$xivqmrspsk}$wygl$ew$Ôqe}0Õ$Ô{mpp0Õ$Ôi|tigx0Õ$Ôerxmgmtexi0Õ$Ômrxirh0Õ$Ôtper0Õ$Ôfipmizi0Õ$Ôwiio0Õ$ÔiwxmqexiÕ$sv$ÔgsrxmryiÕ$sv$xli

rikexmzi$sj$wygl${svhw$sv$zevmexmsrw$sj$wygl${svhw$erh$wmqmpev$i|tviwwmsrw2$Xliwi$wxexiqirxw$evi$rsx$kyeverxiiw$sj$jyxyvi$tivjsvqergi

erh$mrzspzi$givxemr$vmwow0$yrgivxemrxmiw$erh$ewwyqtxmsrw0${lmgl$evi$hmjjmgypx$xs$tvihmgx2$Xlivijsvi0$egxyep$syxgsqiw$erh$viwypxw$qe}

hmjjiv$qexivmepp}$jvsq${lex$mw$i|tviwwih$sv$jsvigewxih$mr$wygl$jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw$erh${i$ger$kmzi$rs$ewwyvergi$xlex$wygl

jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw${mpp$tvszi$xs$fi$gsvvigx2$Mqtsvxerx$jegxsvw$xlex$gsyph$geywi$egxyep$viwypxw$xs$hmjjiv$qexivmepp}$jvsq$xlswi

i|tviwwih$sv$mqtpmih$f}$xli$jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw0$sv$Ôgeyxmsrev}$wxexiqirxw0Õ$mrgpyhi0$fyx$evi$rsx$pmqmxih$xs>

$ ¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$qmxmkexi$xli$xverwqmwwmsr$sj$GSZMH15=$ex$syv$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw0$tvsgiwwmrk$girxivw$erh$viirxv}$girxivw?

$ ¨ xli$qekrmxyhi0$wizivmx}$erh$hyvexmsr$sj$xli$GSZMH15=$terhiqmg$erh$mxw$mqtegx$sr$syv$fywmriww0$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr0

viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$erh$gewl$jps{w?

$ ¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$xmqip}$fymph$erh3sv$stir$jegmpmxmiw$ew$tperrih0$wyggiwwjypp}$qereki$wygl$jegmpmxmiw$erh$wyggiwwjypp}$mrxikvexi

wygl$jegmpmxmiw$mrxs$syv$stivexmsrw${mxlsyx$wyfwxerxmep$ehhmxmsrep$gswxw?

$ ¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$jypjmpp$syv$hifx$wivzmgi$sfpmkexmsrw$erh$mxw$mqtegx$sr$syv$pmuymhmx}?

$ ¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$iwxmqexi$xli$kszivrqirx×w$pizip$sj$yxmpm~exmsr$sj$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw$jsv$wigyvi$wivzmgiw$erh$xli$mqtegx

sj$er}$qshmjmgexmsrw$sv$vihygxmsrw$f}$syv$kszivrqirx$gywxsqivw$sj$xlimv$yxmpm~exmsr$sj$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw?

$ ¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$eggyvexip}$tvsnigx$xli$wm~i$erh$kvs{xl$sj$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw$jsv$wigyvi$wivzmgiw$mr$xli$Y2W2$erh

mrxivrexmsrepp}$erh$syv$efmpmx}$xs$getmxepm~i$sr$sttsvxyrmxmiw$jsv$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw?

$ ¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$wyggiwwjypp}$viwtsrh$xs$er}$gleppirkiw$sv$gsrgivrw$xlex$syv$kszivrqirx$gywxsqivw$qe}$vemwi$vikevhmrk$xlimv

ywi$sj$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw$jsv$wigyvi$wivzmgiw0$mrgpyhmrk$jmrhmrk$sxliv$kszivrqirx$gywxsqivw$sv$epxivrexmzi$ywiw$jsv

jegmpmxmiw${livi$e$kszivrqirx$gywxsqiv$lew$hmwgsrxmryih$sv$errsyrgih$xlex$e$gsrxvegx${mxl$yw${mpp$fi$hmwgsrxmryih?

$ ¨ xli$mqtegx$sj$ehstxih$sv$tvstswih$pikmwpexmsr$emqih$ex$pmqmxmrk$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw$jsv$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw0$tvsgiwwmrk

girxivw$erh$gsqqyrmx}$viirxv}$girxivw$sv$pmqmxmrk$sv$viwxvmgxmrk$xli$fywmriww$erh$stivexmsrw$sj$jmrergmep$mrwxmxyxmsrw$sv

sxlivw${ls$hs$fywmriww${mxl$yw?

$ ¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$wyggiwwjypp}$viwtsrh$xs$hipe}w$irgsyrxivih$f}$wxexiw$tyvwymrk$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw$jsv$wigyvi$wivzmgiw

erh$gswx$wezmrkw$mrmxmexmziw$mqtpiqirxih$f}$e$ryqfiv$sj$wxexiw?

$ ¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$egxmzexi$xli$mregxmzi$fihw$ex$syv$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw?

$ ¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$qemrxemr$sv$mrgviewi$sggyterg}$vexiw$ex$syv$jegmpmxmiw?

$ ¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$i|terh0$hmzivwmj}$erh$kvs{$syv$wigyvi$wivzmgiw0$viirxv}0$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$wivzmgiw0$}syxl$wivzmgiw0

qsrmxsvmrk$wivzmgiw0$izmhirgi1fewih$wytivzmwmsr$erh$xviexqirx$tvskveqw$erh$wigyvi$xverwtsvxexmsr$wivzmgiw$fywmriwwiw?

$ ¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs${mr$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$jsv${lmgl${i$lezi$wyfqmxxih$tvstswepw0$vixemr$i|mwxmrk$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw0

tvizemp$mr$er}$gleppirki$sv$tvsxiwx$mrzspzmrk$xli$e{evh$sj$e$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegx$erh$qiix$er}$tivjsvqergi$wxerhevhw

viuymvih$f}$wygl$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw?

$ ¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$gsrxvsp$stivexmrk$gswxw$ewwsgmexih${mxl$gsrxvegx$wxevx1ytw?

$ ¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$vemwi$ri{$tvsnigx$hizipstqirx$getmxep$kmzir$xli$sjxir$wlsvx1xivq$rexyvi$sj$xli$gywxsqivw×$gsqqmxqirx$xs$ywi

ri{p}$hizipstih$jegmpmxmiw?

$ ¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$hizipst$psrk1xivq$ievrmrkw$zmwmfmpmx}?

$ ¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$mhirxmj}$wymxefpi$eguymwmxmsrw0$erh$xs$wyggiwwjypp}$gsqtpixi$erh$mrxikvexi$wygl$eguymwmxmsrw$sr$wexmwjegxsv}

xivqw0$xs$irlergi$sggyterg}$pizipw$erh$xli$jmrergmep$tivjsvqergi$sj$ewwixw$eguymvih$erh$iwxmqexi$xli$w}rivkmiw$xs$fi

eglmizih$ew$e$viwypx$sj$wygl$eguymwmxmsrw?

$ ¨ syv$i|tswyvi$xs$xli$mqtemvqirx$sj$kssh{mpp$erh$sxliv$mrxerkmfpi$ewwixw$ew$e$viwypx$sj$syv$eguymwmxmsrw?

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 45 of 88

Page 321: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 893;9

77

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 46 of 88

Page 322: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 8:3;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

$ ¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$wyggiwwjypp}$gsrhygx$syv$stivexmsrw$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq0$Wsyxl$Ejvmge$erh$Eywxvepme$xlvsykl$nsmrx

zirxyviw$sv$e$gsrwsvxmyq?

$ ¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$sfxemr$jyxyvi$jmrergmrk0$sv$vijmrergi$er}$sj$syv$gyvvirx$hifx$sfpmkexmsrw$sr$wexmwjegxsv}$xivqw$sv$ex$epp0

mrgpyhmrk$syv$efmpmx}$xs$wigyvi$xli$jyrhmrk${i$riih$xs$gsqtpixi$srksmrk$getmxep$tvsnigxw?

$ ¨ xli$mqtegx$sj$xli$erxmgmtexih$PMFSV$xverwmxmsr$mr$6465?

$ ¨ syv$i|tswyvi$xs$tspmxmgep$erh$igsrsqmg$mrwxefmpmx}$erh$sxliv$vmwow$mqtegxmrk$syv$mrxivrexmsrep$stivexmsrw?

$ ¨ xli$mrwxefmpmx}$sj$jsvimkr$i|glerki$vexiw0$i|tswmrk$yw$xs$gyvvirg}$vmwow$mr$Eywxvepme0$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq0$erh$Wsyxl$Ejvmge0

sv$sxliv$gsyrxvmiw$mr${lmgl${i$qe}$glsswi$xs$gsrhygx$syv$fywmriww?

$ ¨ syv$i|tswyvi$xs$vmwow$mqtegxmrk$syv$mrjsvqexmsr$w}wxiqw0$mrgpyhmrk$xlswi$xlex$qe}$geywi$er$mrxivvytxmsr0$hipe}$sv$jempyvi$mr

xli$tvszmwmsr$sj$syv$wivzmgiw?

$ ¨ syv$i|tswyvi$xs$vmwmrk$kirivep$mrwyvergi$gswxw?

$ ¨ er$mrgviewi$mr$yrvimqfyvwih$pefsv$vexiw?

$ ¨ syv$i|tswyvi$xs$jihivep0$wxexi$erh$jsvimkr$mrgsqi$xe|$pe{$glerkiw0$mrgpyhmrk$glerkiw$xs$xli$VIMX$tvszmwmsrw$erh$xli$Xe|

Gyxw$erh$Nsfw$Egx$erh$syv$i|tswyvi$ew$e$viwypx$sj$jihivep0$wxexi$erh$mrxivrexmsrep$i|eqmrexmsrw$sj$syv$xe|$vixyvrw$sv$xe|

tswmxmsrw$erh$i|eqmrexmsrw$sj$rsr1mrgsqi$xe|$jmpmrkw$ew${ipp$ew$glerkiw$mr$vipexih$pe{w?

$ ¨ syv$i|tswyvi$xs$gpemqw$jsv${lmgl${i$evi$yrmrwyvih?

$ ¨ syv$i|tswyvi$xs$vmwmrk$qihmgep$gswxw?

$ ¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$qereki$gswxw$erh$i|tirwiw$vipexmrk$xs$srksmrk$pmxmkexmsr$evmwmrk$jvsq$syv$stivexmsrw?

$ ¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$eggyvexip}$iwxmqexi$sr$er$erryep$fewmw0$psww$viwivziw$vipexih$xs$kirivep$pmefmpmx}0${svoivw$gsqtirwexmsr$erh

eyxsqsfmpi$pmefmpmx}$gpemqw?

$ ¨ xli$efmpmx}$sj$syv$kszivrqirx$gywxsqivw$xs$wigyvi$fyhkixev}$ettvstvmexmsrw$xs$jyrh$xlimv$te}qirx$sfpmkexmsrw$xs$yw$erh

gsrxmryi$xs$stivexi$yrhiv$syv$i|mwxmrk$ekviiqirxw$erh3sv$viri{$syv$i|mwxmrk$ekviiqirxw?

$ ¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$te}$uyevxivp}$hmzmhirhw$gsrwmwxirx${mxl$syv$viuymviqirxw$ew$e$VIMX0$erh$i|tigxexmsrw$ew$xs$xmqmrk$erh

eqsyrxw?

$ ¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$viqemr$uyepmjmih$jsv$xe|exmsr$ew$e$viep$iwxexi$mrziwxqirx$xvywx0$sv$VIMX?

$ ¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$gsqtp}${mxl$kszivrqirx$vikypexmsrw$erh$ettpmgefpi$gsrxvegxyep$viuymviqirxw?

$ ¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$eguymvi0$tvsxigx$sv$qemrxemr$syv$mrxippigxyep$tvstivx}?

$ ¨ xli$vmwo$xlex$e$ryqfiv$sj$jegxsvw$gsyph$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$xli$qevoix$tvmgi$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo?

$ ¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$jypp}$mqtpiqirx$syv$wxsgo$fy}fego$tvskveq$erh$xli$xmqmrk$erh$eqsyrx$sj$er}$wygl$jyxyvi$wxsgo$vityvglewiw?

$ ¨ syv$efmpmx}$xs$tyvglewi$sv$vixmvi$e$tsvxmsr$sj$syv$syxwxerhmrk$wirmsv$rsxiw$erh$syv$xivq$pser$erh$xli$xmqmrk$erh$eqsyrxw$sj

er}$jyxyvi$tyvglewiw$erh3sv$vixmviqirx?$erh

$ ¨ sxliv$jegxsvw$gsrxemrih$mr$syv$jmpmrkw${mxl$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$erh$I|glerki$Gsqqmwwmsr0$sv$xli$WIG0$mrgpyhmrk0$fyx$rsx$pmqmxih

xs0$xlswi$hixempih$mr$syv$Uyevxivp}$Vitsvxw$sr$Jsvq$541U0$syv$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O$jsv$xli$}iev$irhih

Higiqfiv$750$645=$erh$syv$Gyvvirx$Vitsvxw$sr$Jsvq$<1O$jmpih${mxl$xli$WIG2

[i$yrhivxeoi$rs$sfpmkexmsr$xs$ythexi$tyfpmgp}$er}$jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw0${lixliv$ew$e$viwypx$sj$ri{$mrjsvqexmsr0$jyxyvi$izirxw$sv

sxliv{mwi2$Epp$wyfwiuyirx${vmxxir$erh$svep$jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$yw0$sv$tivwsrw$egxmrk$sr$syv$filepj0$evi$i|tviwwp}

uyepmjmih$mr$xlimv$irxmvix}$f}$xli$geyxmsrev}$wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$xlmw$Uyevxivp}$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541U2

Mrxvshygxmsr

Xli$jspps{mrk$hmwgywwmsr$erh$erep}wmw$tvszmhiw$mrjsvqexmsr${lmgl$qerekiqirx$fipmiziw$mw$vipizerx$xs$er$ewwiwwqirx$erh

yrhivwxerhmrk$sj$syv$gsrwspmhexih$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$erh$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr2$Xlmw$hmwgywwmsr$gsrxemrw$jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw

xlex$mrzspzi$vmwow$erh$yrgivxemrxmiw2$Syv$egxyep$viwypxw$qe}$hmjjiv$qexivmepp}$jvsq$xlswi$erxmgmtexih$mr$xliwi$jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw

ew$e$viwypx$sj$ryqivsyw$jegxsvw$mrgpyhmrk0$fyx$rsx$pmqmxih$xs0$xlswi$hiwgvmfih$efszi$yrhiv$ÔJsv{evh1Pssomrk$MrjsvqexmsrÕ0$xlswi

hiwgvmfih$fips{$yrhiv$&Tevx$MM$1$Mxiq$5E2$Vmwo$Jegxsvw&$erh$yrhiv$ÔTevx$M$1$Mxiq$5E2$Vmwo$JegxsvwÕ$mr$syv$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O

jsv$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=2$Xli$hmwgywwmsr$wlsyph$fi$vieh$mr$gsrnyrgxmsr${mxl$syv$yreyhmxih$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep

wxexiqirxw$erh$rsxiw$xlivixs$mrgpyhih$mr$xlmw$Uyevxivp}$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541U2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 47 of 88

Page 323: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 8;3;9

78

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 48 of 88

Page 324: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 8<3;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

[i$evi$e$viep$iwxexi$mrziwxqirx$xvywx$,ÔVIMXÕ-$wtigmepm~mrk$mr$xli$s{rivwlmt0$piewmrk$erh$qerekiqirx$sj$wigyvi$wivzmgiw$erh$viirxv}

jegmpmxmiw$erh$xli$tvszmwmsr$sj$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$wivzmgiw$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw0$Eywxvepme0$Wsyxl$Ejvmge0$erh$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq2$[i

s{r0$piewi$erh$stivexi$e$fvseh$verki$sj$wigyvi$wivzmgiw$jegmpmxmiw$mrgpyhmrk$qe|mqyq0$qihmyq$erh$qmrmqyq$wigyvmx}$jegmpmxmiw0

tvsgiwwmrk$girxivw0$erh$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$viirxv}$jegmpmxmiw$erh${i$sjjiv$er$i|terhih$hipmziv}$sj$vilefmpmxexmsr$wivzmgiw$yrhiv$syv$+KIS

Gsrxmryyq$sj$Gevi+$tpexjsvq2$[i$sjjiv$gsyrwipmrk0$ihygexmsr$erh3sv$xviexqirx$xs$mrhmzmhyepw${mxl$epgslsp$erh$hvyk$efywi$tvsfpiqw$ex

qswx$sj$xli$hsqiwxmg$jegmpmxmiw${i$qereki2$[i$evi$epws$e$tvszmhiv$sj$mrrszexmzi$gsqtpmergi$xiglrspskmiw0$mrhywxv}1piehmrk$qsrmxsvmrk

wivzmgiw0$erh$izmhirgi1fewih$wytivzmwmsr$erh$xviexqirx$tvskveqw$jsv$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$tevspiiw0$tvsfexmsrivw$erh$tvixvmep$hijirherxw2

Ex$Qevgl$750$64640$syv${svph{mhi$stivexmsrw$mrgpyhi$xli$qerekiqirx$erh3sv$s{rivwlmt$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$=80444$fihw$ex$56:$wigyvi

wivzmgiw$erh$viirxv}$jegmpmxmiw0$mrgpyhmrk$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw0$tvsnigxw$yrhiv$hizipstqirx$erh$vigirxp}$e{evhih$gsrxvegxw0$erh$epws$mrgpyhi$xli

tvszmwmsr$sj$gsqqyrmx}$wytivzmwmsr$wivzmgiw$jsv$qsvi$xler$6540444$mrhmzmhyepw0$mrgpyhmrk$ettvs|mqexip}$5440444$xlvsykl$er$evve}$sj

xiglrspsk}$tvshygxw$mrgpyhmrk$vehms$jviuyirg}0$KTW0$erh$epgslsp$qsrmxsvmrk$hizmgiw2

[i$tvszmhi$e$hmzivwmjmih$wgsti$sj$wivzmgiw$sr$filepj$sj$syv$kszivrqirx$gpmirxw>

$ ¨ syv$wigyvi$qerekiqirx$wivzmgiw$mrzspzi$xli$tvszmwmsr$sj$wigyvmx}0$ehqmrmwxvexmzi0$vilefmpmxexmsr0$ihygexmsr$erh$tvszmwmsr$sj

qiepw0$tvmqevmp}$ex$ehypx$qepi$wigyvi$wivzmgiw$jegmpmxmiw?

$ ¨ syv$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$wivzmgiw$mrzspzi$wytivzmwmsr$sj$tevspiiw$erh$tvsfexmsrivw$erh$xli$tvszmwmsr$sj$xiqtsvev}$lsywmrk0

tvskveqqmrk0$iqtps}qirx$ewwmwxergi$erh$sxliv$vilefmpmxexmzi$erh$ihygexmsrep$tvskveqw$erh$wivzmgiw${mxl$xli$mrxirxmsr$sj

xli$wyggiwwjyp$vimrxikvexmsr$sj$viwmhirxw$mrxs$xli$gsqqyrmx}?

$ ¨ syv$qsrmxsvmrk$wivzmgiw$tvszmhi$syv$kszivrqirxep$gpmirxw${mxl$mrrszexmzi$gsqtpmergi$xiglrspskmiw0$mrhywxv}1piehmrk

qsrmxsvmrk$wivzmgiw0$erh$izmhirgi1fewih$wytivzmwmsr$erh$xviexqirx$tvskveqw$jsv$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$tevspiiw0$tvsfexmsrivw

erh$tvixvmep$hijirherxw?$mrgpyhmrk$wivzmgiw$tvszmhih$yrhiv$xli$Mrxirwmzi$Wytivzmwmsr$Ettievergi$Tvskveq0${lmgl${i$vijiv

xs$ew$MWET0$jsv$xli$tvszmwmsr$sj$wivzmgiw$hiwmkrih$xs$mqtvszi$xli$tevxmgmtexmsr$mr$xli$mqqmkvexmsr$gsyvx$w}wxiq?

$ ¨ {i$hizipst$ri{$jegmpmxmiw$ywmrk$syv$tvsnigx$hizipstqirx$i|tivmirgi$xs$hiwmkr0$gsrwxvygx$erh$jmrergi${lex${i$fipmizi$evi

wxexi1sj1xli1evx$jegmpmxmiw$xlex$qe|mqm~i$wigyvmx}$erh$ijjmgmirg}?

$ ¨ {i$tvszmhi$wigyvi$xverwtsvxexmsr$wivzmgiw$jsv$mrhmzmhyepw$ew$gsrxvegxih$hsqiwxmgepp}$erh$mrxivrexmsrepp}$1$syv$nsmrx$zirxyvi

KISEqi}$mw$viwtsrwmfpi$jsv$tvszmhmrk$iwgsvx$erh$gywxsh}$wivzmgiw$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq0$mrgpyhmrk$epp$sj$[epiw$erh

Irkperh$i|gitx$Psrhsr$erh$xli$Iewx$sj$Irkperh?$erh

$ ¨ syv$wivzmgiw$evi$tvszmhih$ex$jegmpmxmiw${lmgl${i$imxliv$s{r0$piewi$sv$evi$s{rih$f}$syv$gywxsqivw2

Jsv$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$6464$erh$645=0${i$leh$gsrwspmhexih$viziryiw$sj$(:4924$qmppmsr$erh$(:542;$qmppmsr0

viwtigxmzip}2$[i$qemrxemrih$er$eziveki$gsqter}1{mhi$jegmpmx}$sggyterg}$vexi$sj$=426)$mrgpyhmrk$=40<:9$egxmzi$fihw$erh$i|gpyhmrk

707:<$mhpi$fihw${lmgl$mrgpyhiw$xlswi$fimrk$qevoixih$xs$tsxirxmep$gywxsqivw$erh$fihw$yrhiv$hizipstqirx$jsv$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih

Qevgl$750$64640$erh$=728)$mrgpyhmrk$<;0;88$egxmzi$fihw$erh$i|gpyhmrk$;04:<$mhpi$fihw${lmgl$mrgpyhiw$xlswi$fimrk$qevoixih$xs

tsxirxmep$gywxsqivw$erh$fihw$yrhiv$hizipstqirx$jsv$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$645=2

Ew$e$VIMX0${i$evi$viuymvih$xs$hmwxvmfyxi$erryepp}$ex$piewx$=4)$sj$syv$VIMX$xe|efpi$mrgsqi$,hixivqmrih${mxlsyx$vikevh$xs$xli$hmzmhirhw

temh$hihygxmsr$erh$f}$i|gpyhmrk$rix$getmxep$kemr-$erh${i$fiker$te}mrk$vikypev$uyevxivp}$VIMX$hmzmhirhw$mr$64572$Xli$eqsyrx0$xmqmrk

erh$jviuyirg}$sj$jyxyvi$hmzmhirhw0$ls{iziv0${mpp$fi$ex$xli$wspi$hmwgvixmsr$sj$syv$Fsevh$sj$Hmvigxsvw$,xli$&FsevhÕ-$erh${mpp$fi$higpevih

fewih$ytsr$zevmsyw$jegxsvw0$qer}$sj${lmgl$evi$fi}srh$syv$gsrxvsp0$mrgpyhmrk0$syv$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$stivexmrk$gewl$jps{w0$xli

eqsyrx$viuymvih$xs$qemrxemr$VIMX$wxexyw0$pmqmxexmsrw$sr$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$mr$syv$i|mwxmrk$erh$jyxyvi$hifx$mrwxvyqirxw0$pmqmxexmsrw$sr$syv

efmpmx}$xs$jyrh$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$ywmrk$gewl$kirivexih$xlvsykl$syv$xe|efpi$VIMX$wyfwmhmevmiw$,&XVWw&-$erh$sxliv$jegxsvw$xlex$syv$Fsevh$qe}

hiiq$vipizerx2

Hyvmrk$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$6464$erh$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$viwtigxmzip}0${i$higpevih$erh$temh$xli

jspps{mrk$vikypev$gewl$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$xs$syv$wlevilsphivw$ew$jspps{w>

Higpevexmsr$Hexi $ Vigsvh$Hexi $ Te}qirx$Hexi $HmwxvmfyxmsrTiv$Wlevi $ $

EkkvikexiTe}qirx$Eqsyrx

,mr$qmppmsrw- $

Jifvyev}$80$645= $ Jifvyev}$590$645= $ Jifvyev}$660$645= $ ( 428<$ $ ( 9;2=$

Etvmp$70$645= $ Etvmp$590$645= $ Etvmp$660$645= $ ( 428<$ $ ( 9<26$

Nyp}$=0$645= $ Nyp}$5=0$645= $ Nyp}$6:0$645= $ ( 428<$ $ ( 9<26$

Sgxsfiv$580$645= $ Sgxsfiv$690$645= $ Rsziqfiv$50$645= $ ( 428<$ $ ( 9<26$

Jifvyev}$70$6464 $ Jifvyev}$580$6464 $ Jifvyev}$650$6464 $ ( 428<$ $ ( 9<26$

$$

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 49 of 88

Page 325: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 8=3;9

79

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 50 of 88

Page 326: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 943;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

Sr$Etvmp$:0$64640$syv$Fsevh$higpevih$e$uyevxivp}$gewl$hmzmhirh$sj$(428<$tiv$wlevi$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo${lmgl${ew$temh$sr$Etvmp$680$6464

xs$wlevilsphivw$sj$vigsvh$ew$sj$xli$gpswi$sj$fywmriww$sr$Etvmp$5;0$64642

Vijivirgi$mw$qehi$xs$Tevx$MM0$Mxiq$;$sj$syv$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O$jmpih${mxl$xli$WIG$sr$Jifvyev}$6:0$64640$jsv$jyvxliv

hmwgywwmsr$erh$erep}wmw$sj$mrjsvqexmsr$tivxemrmrk$xs$syv$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$ew$sj$erh$jsv$xli$jmwgep$}iev$irhih

Higiqfiv$750$645=2

6464$Hizipstqirxw

$

GSZMH15=

[i$evi$gpswip}$qsrmxsvmrk$xli$mqtegx$sj$xli$GSZMH15=$terhiqmg$sr$epp$ewtigxw$sj$syv$fywmriww$erh$kiskvetlmiw0$mrgpyhmrk$ls{$mx${mpp

mqtegx$xlswi$irxvywxih$mr$syv$gevi$erh$kszivrqirxep$tevxrivw2$[lmpi${i$hmh$rsx$mrgyv$wmkrmjmgerx$hmwvytxmsrw$hyvmrk$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw

irhih$Qevgl$750$6464$jvsq$xli$GSZMH15=$terhiqmg0${i$evi$yrefpi$xs$tvihmgx$xli$mqtegx$xlex$xli$GSZMH15=$terhiqmg${mpp$lezi$sr

syv$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$erh$gewl$jps{w$hyi$xs$ryqivsyw$yrgivxemrxmiw2$Vijiv$xs$jyvxliv$hmwgywwmsr$vikevhmrk$xli

igsrsqmg$mqtegxw$sj$GSZMH15=$xs$syv$stivexmsrw$mr$xli$Syxpsso$wigxmsr$jyvxliv$fips{2

Gsrxvegx$E{evhw

Sr$Qevgl$680$6464${i$errsyrgih$xlex$syv${lspp}1s{rih$wyfwmhmev}0$FM$Mrgsvtsvexih0$lew$wmkrih$e$gsrxvegx${mxl$Y2W2$Mqqmkvexmsr$erh

Gywxsqw$Irjsvgiqirx$,ÔMGIÕ-$jsv$xli$gsrxmryih$tvszmwmsr$sj$gewi$qerekiqirx$erh$wytivzmwmsr$wivzmgiw$yrhiv$xli$jihivep

kszivrqirx×w$Mrxirwmzi$Wytivzmwmsr$erh$Ettievergi$Tvskveq$,ÔMWETÕ-2$Xli$gsrxvegx${mpp$lezi$e$xivq$sj$jmzi$}ievw0$ijjigxmzi$Etvmp$50

6464$erh$mw$i|tigxih$xs$wivzi$=40444$xs$5440444$tevxmgmterxw$hemp}0$gsrwmwxirx${mxl$xli$eziveki$ryqfiv$sj$hemp}$tevxmgmterxw$hyvmrk$xli

tewx$}iev2$Wyfwiuyirxp}$e$gsqtixmxsv$lew$jmpih$e$tvsxiwx$gleppirkmrk$xli$e{evh$sj$xli$gsrxvegx2$Epxlsykl${i$evi$gsrjmhirx$xlex$syv

fmhhmrk$tvsgiww$wexmwjmih$epp$ettpmgefpi$viuymviqirxw0$xli$Y2W2$Mqqmkvexmsr$erh$Gywxsqw$Irjsvgiqirx$qywx$gsqtpixi$mxw$vizmi{$sj$xli

tvsxiwx$erh${i$gerrsx$kyeverxii$xlex${i${mpp$tvizemp2

$

Mhpi$Jegmpmxmiw

[i$evi$gyvvirxp}$qevoixmrk$ettvs|mqexip}$50444$zegerx$fihw$ex$x{s$sj$syv$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw$xs$tsxirxmep$gywxsqivw2$Xli$gevv}mrk$zepyiw$sj

xliwi$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw$xsxepih$(642;$qmppmsr$ew$sj$Qevgl$750$64640$i|gpyhmrk$iuymtqirx$erh$sxliv$ewwixw$xlex$ger$fi$iewmp}$xverwjivvih$jsv

ywi$ex$sxliv$jegmpmxmiw2

Gvmxmgep$Eggsyrxmrk$Tspmgmiw

Xli$eggsqter}mrk$yreyhmxih$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$evi$tvitevih$mr$gsrjsvqmx}${mxl$eggsyrxmrk$tvmrgmtpiw$kirivepp}

eggitxih$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw2$Ew$wygl0${i$evi$viuymvih$xs$qeoi$givxemr$iwxmqexiw0$nyhkqirxw$erh$ewwyqtxmsrw$xlex${i$fipmizi$evi

viewsrefpi$fewih$ytsr$xli$mrjsvqexmsr$ezempefpi2$Xliwi$iwxmqexiw$erh$ewwyqtxmsrw$ejjigx$xli$vitsvxih$eqsyrxw$sj$ewwixw$erh$pmefmpmxmiw

ew$sj$xli$hexi$sj$xli$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$erh$xli$vitsvxih$eqsyrxw$sj$viziryi$erh$i|tirwiw$hyvmrk$xli$vitsvxmrk$tivmsh2$[i$vsyxmrip}

izepyexi$syv$iwxmqexiw$fewih$sr$lmwxsvmgep$i|tivmirgi$erh$sr$zevmsyw$sxliv$ewwyqtxmsrw$xlex$qerekiqirx$fipmiziw$evi$viewsrefpi$yrhiv

xli$gmvgyqwxergiw2$Egxyep$viwypxw$qe}$hmjjiv$jvsq$xliwi$iwxmqexiw$yrhiv$hmjjivirx$ewwyqtxmsrw$sv$gsrhmxmsrw2$Hyvmrk$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw

irhih$Qevgl$750$64640${i$hmh$rsx$i|tivmirgi$er}$wmkrmjmgerx$glerkiw$mr$iwxmqexiw$sv$nyhkqirxw$mrlivirx$mr$xli$tvitevexmsr$sj$syv

gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw2$E$wyqqev}$sj$syv$wmkrmjmgerx$eggsyrxmrk$tspmgmiw$mw$gsrxemrih$mr$Rsxi$5$xs$syv$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep

wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$syv$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O$jsv$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=2

7:

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 51 of 88

Page 327: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 953;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

VIWYPXW$SJ$STIVEXMSRW

Xli$jspps{mrk$hmwgywwmsr$erh$erep}wmw$wlsyph$fi$vieh$mr$gsrnyrgxmsr${mxl$syv$yreyhmxih$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$erh$xli$rsxiw

xs$syv$yreyhmxih$gsrwspmhexih$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$M0$Mxiq$50$sj$xlmw$Uyevxivp}$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541U2

Gsqtevmwsr$sj$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$6464$erh$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$645=

Viziryiw

$

$ 6464 $ $ )$sj$Viziryi$ $ 645= $ $ )$sj$Viziryi$ $ ($Glerki $ $ )$Glerki $

$ $ ,Hsppevw$mr$xlsywerhw- $

KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw $ ( 7=<054=$ $ $ :92<) $ ( 7=40954$ $ $ :72=) $ ( ;09==$ $ $ 52=)

KIS$Gevi $ $ 58808:7$ $ $ 672=) $ $ 5970<87$ $ $ 6926) $ $ ,=07<4- $ $ ,:25-)

Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw $ $ 9:0<94$ $ $ =28) $ $ :80668$ $ $ 5429) $ $ ,;07;8- $ $ ,5529-)

Jegmpmx}$Gsrwxvygxmsr$*$Hiwmkr $ $ 909=9$ $ $ 42=) $ $ 604=4$ $ $ 428) $ $ 70949$ $ $ 54424)

Xsxep $ ( :49045;$ $ $ 54424) $ ( :540::;$ $ $ 54424) $ ( ,90:94- $ $ ,42=-)

$

KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw

Viziryiw$mrgviewih$mr$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$6464$gsqtevih$xs$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$645=$tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs$ekkvikexi$mrgviewiw$sj$(;26$qmppmsr$hyi$xs

ekkvikexi$rix$mrgviewiw$mr$tstypexmsr0$xverwtsvxexmsr$wivzmgiw$erh3sv$vexiw2$[i$epws$leh$mrgviewiw$sj$(5929$qmppmsr$viwypxmrk$jvsq$xli

egxmzexmsr$sj$syv$gsrxvegxw$ex$syv$gsqter}1s{rih$erh$tvizmsywp}$mhpih$Wsyxl$Psymwmere$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxiv$mr$Fewmpi0$Psymwmere$hyvmrk

xli$xlmvh$uyevxiv$sj$645=0$ew${ipp$ew$syv$gsqter}1s{rih$erh$tvizmsywp}$mhpih$Rsvxl$Peoi$Gsvvigxmsrep$Jegmpmx}$mr$Feph{mr$Qmglmker

{lmgl${ew$egxmzexih$sr$Sgxsfiv$50$645=2$Xliwi$mrgviewiw${ivi$tevxmepp}$sjjwix$f}$rix$higviewiw$sj$(5925$qmppmsr$ex$givxemr$sj$syv

jegmpmxmiw$hyi$xs$gsrxvegx$xivqmrexmsrw2

Xli$ryqfiv$sj$gsqtirwexih$qerhe}w$mr$KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$jegmpmxmiw${ew$ettvs|mqexip}$92;$qmppmsr$mr$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$6464$erh$92<

qmppmsr$mr$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$645=2$[i$i|tivmirgih$er$ekkvikexi$rix$higviewi$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$5440444$qerhe}w$ew$e$viwypx$sj$tstypexmsr

higviewiw${mxl$syv$jihivep$gpmirxw$erh$gsrxvegx$xivqmrexmsrw0$tevxmepp}$sjjwix$f}$gsrxvegx$egxmzexmsrw$hmwgywwih$efszi2$[i$psso$ex$xli

eziveki$sggyterg}$mr$syv$jegmpmxmiw$xs$hixivqmri$ls{${i$evi$qerekmrk$syv$ezempefpi$fihw2$Xli$eziveki$sggyterg}$mw$gepgypexih$f}

xeomrk$gsqtirwexih$qerhe}w$ew$e$tivgirxeki$sj$getegmx}2$Xli$eziveki$sggyterg}$mr$syv$KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$jegmpmxmiw${ew$=624)$erh

=92<)$sj$getegmx}$mr$xli$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$6464$erh$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$645=0$viwtigxmzip}0$i|gpyhmrk$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw2

KIS$Gevi

Viziryiw$higviewih$mr$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$6464$gsqtevih$xs$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$645=$tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs$ekkvikexi$higviewiw$sj$(<2:$qmppmsr$vipexih

xs$gsrxvegx$xivqmrexmsrw3gpswyviw$sj$yrhivyxmpm~ih$jegmpmxmiw2$[i$epws$i|tivmirgih$e$higviewi$sj$(627$qmppmsr$hyi$xs$higviewiw$mr$eziveki

gpmirx$erh$tevxmgmterx$gsyrxw$yrhiv$syv$MWET$erh$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$wivzmgiw$ew$e$viwypx$sj$tspmg}$glerkiw$f}$xli$ehqmrmwxvexmsr

{lmgl$vihygih$xli$ryqfiv$sj$irvsppqirxw$ex$xli$wsyxlivr$fsvhiv2$Xliwi$higviewiw${ivi$tevxmepp}$sjjwix$f}$rix$mrgviewiw$sj$(529$qmppmsr

hyi$xs$rix$mrgviewiw$mr$girwyw$pizipw$ex$givxemr$sj$syv$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$erh$viirxv}$girxivw$ew${ipp$ew$ri{$tvskveqw$egxmzexih2

Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw

Viziryiw$jsv$Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw$higviewih$f}$(;28$qmppmsr$mr$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$6464$gsqtevih$xs$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$645=2$[i$i|tivmirgih$e

rix$higviewi$mr$viziryiw$sj$(724$qmppmsr${lmgl${ew$tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs$xli$xverwmxmsr$sj$syv$Tevopie$Gsvvigxmsrep$Girxvi$f}$syv$Eywxvepmer

wyfwmhmev}$xs$e$ri{$stivexsv$mr$Qevgl$645=2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0${i$leh$e$higviewi$hyi$xs$jsvimkr$i|glerki$vexi$jpygxyexmsrw$sj$(828$qmppmsr

viwypxmrk$jvsq$xli$wxvirkxlirmrk$sj$xli$Y2W2$hsppev$ekemrwx$givxemr$mrxivrexmsrep$gyvvirgmiw2

Jegmpmx}$Gsrwxvygxmsr$*$Hiwmkr

Mr$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$6464$erh$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$645=0${i$leh$jegmpmx}$gsrwxvygxmsr$*$hiwmkr$wivzmgiw$vipexih$xs$er$i|terwmsr$tvsnigx$ex$syv

Jypleq$Gsvvigxmsrep$Girxvi$mr$Eywxvepme${lmgl$mw$i|tigxih$xs$fi$gsqtpixih$mr$xli$xlmvh$uyevxiv$sj$64642

Stivexmrk$I|tirwiw

$

$ 6464 $ $)$sj$WikqirxViziryiw $ $ 645= $ $

)$sj$WikqirxViziryiw $ $ ($Glerki $ $ )$Glerki $

$ $ ,Hsppevw$mr$xlsywerhw- $

KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw $ ( 7470=78$ $ $ ;:27) $ ( 6=6086=$ $ $ ;82=) $ ( 550949$ $ $ 72=)

KIS$Gevi $ $ 54504<<$ $ $ ;424) $ $ 548084:$ $ $ :;2=) $ $ ,7075<- $ $ ,726-)

Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw $ $ 940;59$ $ $ <=26) $ $ 9<04;6$ $ $ =428) $ $ ,;079;- $ $ ,562;-)

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 52 of 88

Page 328: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 963;9

Jegmpmx}$Gsrwxvygxmsr$*$Hiwmkr $ $ 909<9$ $ $ ==2<) $ $ 604=4$ $ $ 54424) $ $ 708=9$ $ $ 54424)

Xsxep $ ( 8:50766$ $ $ ;:26) $ ( 89:0==;$ $ $ ;82<) $ ( 80769$ $ $ 42=)

7;

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 53 of 88

Page 329: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 973;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

$KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw

Stivexmrk$i|tirwiw$jsv$KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$mrgviewih$f}$(5529$qmppmsr$mr$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$6464$gsqtevih$xs$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$645=2$Xli

mrgviewi${ew$tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs$ekkvikexi$rix$mrgviewiw$mr$tstypexmsr0$xverwtsvxexmsr$wivzmgiw$erh$xli$zevmefpi$gswxw$ewwsgmexih${mxl$xlswi

wivzmgiw$sj$(5926$qmppmsr2$[i$epws$i|tivmirgih$mrgviewiw$sj$(5627$qmppmsr$viwypxmrk$jvsq$xli$egxmzexmsr$sj$syv$gsrxvegxw$ex$syv$gsqter}1

s{rih$erh$tvizmsywp}$mhpih$Wsyxl$Psymwmere$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxiv$mr$Fewmpi0$Psymwmere$hyvmrk$xli$xlmvh$uyevxiv$sj$645=0$syv$gsqter}1

s{rih$erh$tvizmsywp}$mhpih$Rsvxl$Peoi$Gsvvigxmsrep$Jegmpmx}$mr$Feph{mr$Qmglmker${lmgl${ew$egxmzexih$sr$Sgxsfiv$50$645=0$ew${ipp$ew

wxevx1yt$gswxw$mrgyvvih$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$syv$ri{$qerekih1srp}$gsrxvegx$jsv$xli$kszivrqirx$s{rih$9561fih$Ip$Girxvs$Hixirxmsr

Jegmpmx}$mr$Gepmjsvrme2$Xliwi$mrgviewiw${ivi$tevxmepp}$sjjwix$f}$higviewiw$sj$(5:24$qmppmsr$ex$givxemr$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs

gsrxvegx$xivqmrexmsrw2

KIS$Gevi

Stivexmrk$i|tirwiw$jsv$KIS$Gevi$higviewih$hyvmrk$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$6464$jvsq$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$645=$tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs$(92<$qmppmsr$jvsq

gsrxvegx$xivqmrexmsrw3gpswyviw$sj$yrhivyxmpm~ih$jegmpmxmiw2$Xlmw$higviewi${ew$tevxmepp}$sjjwix$f}$(629$qmppmsr$sj$rix$mrgviewiw$vipexih$xs

girwyw$pizipw$ex$givxemr$sj$syv$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$erh$viirxv}$girxivw$erh$ri{$tvskveqw$egxmzexih2

Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw

Stivexmrk$i|tirwiw$jsv$Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw$higviewih$f}$(;28$qmppmsr$mr$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$6464$gsqtevih$xs$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$645=2$[i

i|tivmirgih$e$rix$higviewi$mr$stivexmrk$i|tirwiw$sj$(728$qmppmsr${lmgl${ew$tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs$xli$xverwmxmsr$sj$syv$Tevopie$Gsvvigxmsrep

Girxvi$f}$syv$Eywxvepmer$wyfwmhmev}$xs$e$ri{$stivexsv$mr$Qevgl$645=2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0${i$leh$e$higviewi$hyi$xs$jsvimkr$i|glerki$vexi

jpygxyexmsrw$sj$(824$qmppmsr$viwypxmrk$jvsq$xli$wxvirkxlirmrk$sj$xli$Y2W2$hsppev$ekemrwx$givxemr$mrxivrexmsrep$gyvvirgmiw2

Jegmpmx}$Gsrwxvygxmsr$*$Hiwmkr

Mr$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$6464$erh$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$645=0${i$leh$jegmpmx}$gsrwxvygxmsr$*$hiwmkr$wivzmgiw$vipexih$xs$er$i|terwmsr$tvsnigx$ex$syv

Jypleq$Gsvvigxmsrep$Girxvi$mr$Eywxvepme${lmgl$mw$i|tigxih$xs$fi$gsqtpixih$mr$xli$xlmvh$uyevxiv$sj$64642

Hitvigmexmsr$erh$Eqsvxm~exmsr

$

$ 6464 $ $)$sj$Wikqirx

Viziryi $ $ 645= $ $)$sj$Wikqirx

Viziryi $ $ ($Glerki $ $ )$Glerki $

$ $ ,Hsppevw$mr$xlsywerhw- $

KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw $ ( 6405::$ $ $ 925) $ ( 65059;$ $ $ 928) $ ( ,==5- $ $ ,82;-)

KIS$Gevi $ $ 560:;:$ $ $ <2<) $ $ 540<==$ $ $ ;25) $ $ 50;;;$ $ $ 5:27)

Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw $ $ 8<9$ $ $ 42=) $ $ 857$ $ $ 42:) $ $ ;6$ $ $ 5;28)

Xsxep $ ( 77076;$ $ $ 929) $ ( 7608:=$ $ $ 927) $ ( <9<$ $ $ 62:)

$KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw

KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr$i|tirwi$higviewih$wpmklxp}$mr$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$6464$gsqtevih$xs$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$645=

tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs$givxemr$mxiqw$figsqmrk$jypp}$hitvigmexih2

KIS$Gevi

KIS$Gevi$hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr$i|tirwi$mrgviewih$mr$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$6464$gsqtevih$xs$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$645=$tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs

virszexmsrw$ex$givxemr$sj$syv$girxivw2

Mrxivrexmsrep$Wivzmgiw

Hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr$i|tirwi${ew$vipexmzip}$gsrwmwxirx$mr$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$6464$gsqtevih$xs$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$645=$ew$e$viwypx$sj

givxemr$ewwixw$figsqmrk$jypp}$hitvigmexih$erh$xlivi${ivi$rs$wmkrmjmgerx$virszexmsrw$hyvmrk$645=$sv$6464$ex$syv$mrxivrexmsrep

wyfwmhmevmiw2

Sxliv$Yreppsgexih$Stivexmrk$I|tirwiw

$

$ 6464 $ $ )$sj$Viziryi$ $ 645= $ $ )$sj$Viziryi$ $ ($Glerki $ $ )$Glerki $

$ $ ,Hsppevw$mr$xlsywerhw- $

Kirivep$erh$Ehqmrmwxvexmzi$I|tirwiw $ ( 970;<6$ $ $ <2=) $ ( 8:0868$ $ $ ;2:) $ ( ;079<$ $ $ 592<)

$

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 54 of 88

Page 330: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 983;9

7<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 55 of 88

Page 331: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 993;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

Kirivep$erh$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw$gsqtvmwi$wyfwxerxmepp}$epp$sj$syv$sxliv$yreppsgexih$stivexmrk$i|tirwiw${lmgl$tvmqevmp}$mrgpyhiw

gsvtsvexi$qerekiqirx$wepevmiw$erh$firijmxw0$tvsjiwwmsrep$jiiw$erh$sxliv$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw2$Kirivep$erh$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw

mrgviewih$mr$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$6464$gsqtevih$xs$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$645=$tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs$lmkliv$wxsgo$fewih$gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwi$sj$(724

qmppmsr$ew${ipp$ew$rsvqep$tivwsrrip$erh$gsqtirwexmsr$ehnywxqirxw0$tvsjiwwmsrep0$gsrwypxmrk0$fywmriww$hizipstqirx$erh$sxliv

ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw2

Rsr$Stivexmrk$I|tirwiw

Mrxiviwx$Mrgsqi$erh$Mrxiviwx$I|tirwi

$

$ 6464 $ $ )$sj$Viziryi$ $ 645= $ $ )$sj$Viziryi$ $ ($Glerki $ $ )$Glerki $

$ $ ,Hsppevw$mr$xlsywerhw- $

Mrxiviwx$Mrgsqi $ ( 9087<$ $ $ 42=) $ ( <07=:$ $ $ 528) $ ( ,60=9<- $ $ ,7926-)

Mrxiviwx$I|tirwi $ ( 7805<4$ $ $ 92:) $ ( 8406<4$ $ $ :2:) $ ( ,:0544- $ $ ,5925-)

$Mrxiviwx$mrgsqi$higviewih$mr$xli$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$6464$gsqtevih$xs$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$645=$tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs$e$ps{iv$fepergi$sr$syv$gsrxvegx

vigimzefpi$vipexih$xs$syv$jegmpmx}$mr$Vezirlepp0$Eywxvepme2$Epws$gsrxvmfyxmrk$xs$xli$higviewi${ew$xli$ijjigx$sj$xli$wxvirkxlirmrk$sj$xli

Y2W2$hsppev$ekemrwx$givxemr$mrxivrexmsrep$gyvvirgmiw2

Mrxiviwx$i|tirwi$higviewih$mr$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$6464$gsqtevih$xs$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$645=$tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs$ps{iv$szivepp$hifx$fepergiw$ew${ipp$ew

ps{iv$mrxiviwx$vexiw$sr$syv$zevmefpi$vexi$hifx2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$hyvmrk$xli$xlmvh$uyevxiv$sj$645=0${i$vityvglewih$ettvs|mqexip}$(7824

qmppmsr$mr$ekkvikexi$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj$syv$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$64662$Epws0$hyvmrk$xli$jmvwx$uyevxiv$sj$64640${i$vityvglewih

ettvs|mqexip}$(929$qmppmsr$mr$ekkvikexi$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj$syv$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$64672$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$541$Hifx$sj$xli$Rsxiw

xs$Yreyhmxih$Gsrwspmhexih$Jmrergmep$Wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$M0$Mxiq$5$sj$xlmw$Uyevxivp}$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541U$jsv$jyvxliv$hmwgywwmsr

$

2$ $ 6464 $ $ )$sj$Viziryi$ $ 645= $ $ )$sj$Viziryi$ $ ($Glerki $ $ )$Glerki $

$ $ ,Hsppevw$mr$xlsywerhw- $

Kemr$sr$I|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$Hifx $( 509:7$ $ $ 427) $( Ó$ $ $ ,Ó-)$( 509:7$ $ $ 54424)

Hyvmrk$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$64640${i$vityvglewih$ettvs|mqexip}$(929$qmppmsr$mr$ekkvikexi$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj$syv$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi

6467$ex$e${imklxih$eziveki$tvmgi$sj$;42:<)$jsv$e$xsxep$gswx$sj$(72=$qmppmsr2$Ew$e$viwypx$sj$xliwi$vityvglewiw0${i$vigskrm~ih$e$rix$kemr

sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx$sj$(52:$qmppmsr2

$

Mrgsqi$Xe|$Tvszmwmsr

$

$ 6464 $ $ Ijjigxmzi$Vexi$ $ 645= $ $ Ijjigxmzi$Vexi$ $ ($Glerki $ $ )$Glerki $

$ $ ,Hsppevw$mr$xlsywerhw- $

Tvszmwmsr$jsv$Mrgsqi$Xe|iw $ ( :098:$ $ $ 6627) $ ( 80<84$ $ $ 5527) $ ( 50;4:$ $ $ 7926)

$Xli$tvszmwmsr$jsv$mrgsqi$xe|iw$hyvmrk$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$6464$mrgviewih$gsqtevih$xs$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$645=$epsrk${mxl$syv$ijjigxmzi$xe|$vexi2$Mr

xli$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$sj$64640$xlivi${ew$e$(62;$qmppmsr$hmwgvixi$xe|$i|tirwi${lmgl${ew$(429$qmppmsr$mr$xli$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$sj$645=$vipexih$xs

wxsgo$gsqtirwexmsr$xlex$ziwxih$hyvmrk$xli$viwtigxmzi$tivmshw2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$xli$mrgviewi$mr$xli$ijjigxmzi$vexi$mw$mr$tevx$hyi$xs$e$glerki$mr

xli$gsqtswmxmsr$sj$syv$mrgsqi2$Ew$e$VIMX0${i$evi$viuymvih$xs$hmwxvmfyxi$ex$piewx$=4)$sj$syv$xe|efpi$mrgsqi$xs$wlevilsphivw$erh$mr$xyvr

{i$evi$epps{ih$e$hihygxmsr$jsv$xli$hmwxvmfyxmsr$ex$xli$VIMX$pizip2$Syv${lspp}$s{rih$xe|efpi$VIMX$wyfwmhmevmiw$gsrxmryi$xs$fi$jypp}

wyfnigx$xs$jihivep0$wxexi$erh$jsvimkr$mrgsqi$xe|iw0$ew$ettpmgefpi2$[i$iwxmqexi$syv$erryep$ijjigxmzi$xe|$vexi$xs$fi$mr$xli$verki$sj

ettvs|mqexip}$56)$xs$58)$i|gpywmzi$sj$er}$hmwgvixi$mxiqw

Iuymx}$mr$Ievrmrkw$sj$Ejjmpmexiw0$rix$sj$Mrgsqi$Xe|$Tvszmwmsr

$

$ 6464 $ $ )$sj$Viziryi$ $ 645= $ $ )$sj$Viziryi$ $ ($Glerki $ $ )$Glerki $

$ $ ,Hsppevw$mr$xlsywerhw- $

Iuymx}$mr$Ievrmrkw$sj$Ejjmpmexiw $ ( 606:4$ $ $ 428) $ ( 609=:$ $ $ 428) $ ( ,77:- $ $ ,562=-)

$

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 56 of 88

Page 332: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 9:3;9

Iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw0$tviwirxih$rix$sj$mrgsqi$xe|$tvszmwmsr0$vitviwirxw$xli$ievrmrkw$sj$WEGW$erh$KISEqi}$mr$xli

ekkvikexi2$Iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw$hyvmrk$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$6464$gsqtevih$xs$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$645=$higviewih$wpmklxp}$tvmqevmp}$hyi$xs

pefsv$vipexih

7=

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 57 of 88

Page 333: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 9;3;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

i|tirwiw$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$veqt$yt$sj$KISEqi}+w$gsyvx$gywxsh}$erh$iwgsvx$wivzmgiw$gsrxvegx$mr$Wgsxperh${lmgl$fiker$mr$Jmvwx

Uyevxiv$645=2

Jmrergmep$Gsrhmxmsr

Getmxep$Viuymviqirxw

Syv$gyvvirx$gewl$viuymviqirxw$gsrwmwx$sj$eqsyrxw$riihih$jsv${svomrk$getmxep0$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$sj$syv$VIMX$xe|efpi$mrgsqi$mr$svhiv$xs

qemrxemr$syv$VIMX$uyepmjmgexmsr0$hifx$wivzmgi0$wyttp}$tyvglewiw0$mrziwxqirxw$mr$nsmrx$zirxyviw0$erh$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw$vipexih$xs$imxliv

xli$hizipstqirx$sj$ri{$wigyvi$wivzmgiw$erh$viirxv}$jegmpmxmiw0$sv$xli$qemrxirergi$sj$i|mwxmrk$jegmpmxmiw2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$wsqi$sj$syv

qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$viuymvi$yw$xs$qeoi$wyfwxerxmep$mrmxmep$i|tirhmxyviw$sj$gewl$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$stirmrk$sv$virszexmrk$e$jegmpmx}2

Kirivepp}0$xliwi$mrmxmep$i|tirhmxyviw$evi$wyfwiuyirxp}$jypp}$sv$tevxmepp}$vigszivefpi$ew$teww1xlvsykl$gswxw$sv$evi$fmppefpi$ew$e$gsqtsrirx

sj$xli$tiv$hmiq$vexiw$sv$qsrxlp}$jm|ih$jiiw$xs$xli$gsrxvegxmrk$ekirg}$sziv$xli$svmkmrep$xivq$sj$xli$gsrxvegx

[i$gyvvirxp}$lezi$gsrxvegxyep$gsqqmxqirxw$jsv$e$ryqfiv$sj$tvsnigxw$ywmrk$Gsqter}$jmrergmrk2$[i$iwxmqexi$xlex$xli$gswx$sj$xliwi

i|mwxmrk$getmxep$tvsnigxw${mpp$fi$ettvs|mqexip}$(:5$qmppmsr$sj${lmgl$(85$qmppmsr${ew$wtirx$xlvsykl$Qevgl$750$64642$[i$iwxmqexi$xlex

xli$viqemrmrk$getmxep$viuymviqirxw$vipexih$xs$xliwi$getmxep$tvsnigxw${mpp$fi$(64$qmppmsr${lmgl${mpp$fi$wtirx$xlvsykl$64642

Pmuymhmx}$erh$Getmxep$Viwsyvgiw

Mrhifxihriww

Sr$Nyri$560$645=0${i$irxivih$mrxs$Eqirhqirx$Rs2$6$xs$xli$Xlmvh$Eqirhih$erh$Viwxexih$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$,xli$&Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx&-

f}$erh$eqsrk$xli$vijmrergmrk$pirhivw$tevx}$xlivixs0$xli$sxliv$pirhivw$tevx}$xlivixs0$KIS$erh$KIS$Gsvvigxmsrw$Lsphmrkw0$Mrg2$erh$xli

ehqmrmwxvexmzi$ekirx2$Yrhiv$xli$eqirhqirx0$xli$qexyvmx}$hexi$sj$xli$vizspziv${ew$i|xirhih$xs$Qe}$5;0$64682$Xli$fsvvs{mrk$getegmx}

yrhiv$xli$eqirhih$vizspziv$viqemrw$ex$(=4424$qmppmsr0$erh$mxw$tvmgmrk$viqemrw$yrglerkih$gyvvirxp}$fievmrk$mrxiviwx$ex$PMFSV$tpyw

6269)2$Ew$e$viwypx$sj$xli$eqirhqirx0${i$mrgyvvih$e$psww$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx$sj$(526$qmppmsr$vipexih$xs$givxemr$yreqsvxm~ih

hijivvih$pser$gswxw2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$pser$gswxw$sj$(82;$qmppmsr${ivi$mrgyvvih$erh$getmxepm~ih$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$eqirhqirx2

E$w}rhmgexi$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$:9$pirhivw$tevxmgmtexi$mr$syv$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx0$wm|$sj${lmgl$lezi$mrhmgexih$xlex$xli}$hs$rsx$mrxirh$xs

tvszmhi$ri{$jmrergmrk$xs$KIS$fyx${mpp$lsrsv$xlimv$i|mwxmrk$sfpmkexmsrw$,Vijiv$xs$Mxiq$5E$1$Vmwo$Jegxsvw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$M$sj$xli

Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O$jsv$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750645=$jsv$jyvxliv$hmwgywwmsr2$Xli$ferow$xlex$lezi${mxlhve{r

tevxmgmtexmsr$viqemr$gsrxvegxyepp}$gsqqmxxih$jsv$ettvs|mqexip}$jmzi$}ievw2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$xliwi$wm|$ferow$vitviwirx$piww$xler$69)$sj$syv

szivepp$fsvvs{mrk$getegmx}$yrhiv$syv$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$erh$xli${mxlhve{ep$sj$xlimv$tevxmgmtexmsr$mw$rsx$i|tigxih$xs$rikexmzip}$mqtegx

syv$jmrergmep$jpi|mfmpmx}2$[i$evi$epws$mr$jviuyirx$gsqqyrmgexmsr${mxl$tsxirxmep$ri{$pirhivw$ew${ipp$ew$xli$gvihmx$vexmrk$ekirgmiw${ls

lezi$rsx$glerkih$syv$gvihmx$vexmrkw$jsv$sziv$7:$qsrxlw2

Ew$sj$Qevgl$750$64640${i$leh$ettvs|mqexip}$(;;:$qmppmsr$mr$ekkvikexi$fsvvs{mrkw$syxwxerhmrk0$rix$sj$hmwgsyrx0$yrhiv$syv$xivq$pser

erh$ettvs|mqexip}$(8<=2=$qmppmsr$mr$fsvvs{mrkw$yrhiv$syv$Vizspziv0$erh$ettvs|mqexip}$(:6$qmppmsr$mr$pixxivw$sj$gvihmx${lmgl$pijx

ettvs|mqexip}$(78<28$qmppmsr$mr$ehhmxmsrep$fsvvs{mrk$getegmx}$yrhiv$syv$Vizspziv2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$54$1$Hifx$sj$xli$Rsxiw$xs$Yreyhmxih

Gsrwspmhexih$Jmrergmep$Wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$M0$Mxiq$5$sj$xlmw$Uyevxivp}$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541U$jsv$jyvxliv$hmwgywwmsr2

Eywxvepme$1$Vezirlepp

Mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$e$hiwmkr$erh$fymph$tvsnigx$ekviiqirx${mxl$xli$Wxexi$sj$Zmgxsvme0$mr$Witxiqfiv$64580${i$irxivih$mrxs$e$w}rhmgexih

jegmpmx}$ekviiqirx$,xli$&Gsrwxvygxmsr$Jegmpmx}&-$xs$tvszmhi$hifx$jmrergmrk$jsv$gsrwxvygxmsr$sj$xli$tvsnigx2$Xli$Gsrwxvygxmsr$Jegmpmx}

tvszmhih$jsv$rsr1vigsyvwi$jyrhmrk$yt$xs$EYH$;=524$qmppmsr0$sv$ettvs|mqexip}$(8<92<$qmppmsr0$fewih$sr$i|glerki$vexiw$ew$sj

Qevgl$750$64642$Mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$xli$xivqw$sj$xli$gsrxvegx0$ytsr$gsqtpixmsr$erh$gsqqivgmep$eggitxergi$sj$xli$tvsnigx0$xli$Wxexi

qehi$e$pyqt$wyq$te}qirx$sj$EYH754$qmppmsr0$sv$ettvs|mqexip}$(5=428$qmppmsr0$fewih$sr$i|glerki$vexiw$ew$sj$Qevgl$750$64642$Xli

xivq$sj$xli$Gsrwxvygxmsr$Jegmpmx}${ew$xlvsykl$Witxiqfiv$645=$erh$fsvi$mrxiviwx$ex$e$zevmefpi$vexi$uysxih$f}$givxemr$Eywxvepmer$ferow

tpyw$644$fewmw$tsmrxw2$Sr$Qe}$660$645=0${i$gsqtpixih$er$sjjivmrk$sj$EYH$8:52:$qmppmsr0$sv$(6<729$qmppmsr0$fewih$sr$i|glerki$vexiw

ew$sj$Qevgl$750$64640$ekkvikexi$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj$xli$Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Rsxiw2$Xli$eqsvxm~mrk$Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Rsxiw${ivi$mwwyih$f}

Vezirlepp$Jmrergi$Gs$Tx}$Pmqmxih$mr$e$tvmzexi$tpegiqirx$tyvwyerx$xs$Wigxmsr$8,e-,6-$sj$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$Egx$sj$5=770$ew$eqirhih2$Xli

Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Rsxiw${ivi$mwwyih${mxl$e$gsytsr$erh$}miph$xs$qexyvmx}$sj$8267)${mxl$e$qexyvmx}$hexi$sj$Qevgl$750$64862$Xli$rix

tvsgiihw$jvsq$xlmw$sjjivmrk${ivi$ywih$xs$vijmrergi$xli$syxwxerhmrk$Gsrwxvygxmsr$Jegmpmx}$erh$xs$te}$epp$vipexih$jiiw0$gswxw$erh$i|tirwiw

ewwsgmexih${mxl$xli$xverwegxmsr2$Ew$e$viwypx$sj$xli$xverwegxmsr0${i$mrgyvvih$e$(829$qmppmsr$psww$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx$vipexih$xs$w{et

xivqmrexmsr$jiiw$erh$yreqsvxm~ih$hijivvih$gswxw$ewwsgmexih${mxl$xli$Gsrwxvygxmsr$Jegmpmx}2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$pser$gswxw$sj$ettvs|mqexip}

(;29$qmppmsr${ivi$mrgyvvih$erh$getmxepm~ih$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$sjjivmrk2

Sxliv

Mr$Eykywx$645=0${i$irxivih$mrxs$x{s$mhirxmgep$Rsxiw$mr$xli$ekkvikexi$eqsyrx$sj$(8827$qmppmsr${lmgl$evi$wigyvih$f}$pser$ekviiqirxw

erh$qsvxkeki$erh$wigyvmx}$ekviiqirxw$sr$givxemr$viep$tvstivx}$erh$mqtvsziqirxw2$Xli$xivqw$sj$xli$Rsxiw$evi$xlvsykl$Witxiqfiv$50

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 58 of 88

Page 334: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 9<3;9

6478$erh$fiev$mrxiviwx$ex$PMFSV$tpyw$644$fewmw$tsmrxw$erh$evi$te}efpi$mr$qsrxlp}$mrwxeppqirxw$tpyw$mrxiviwx2$[i$lezi$irxivih$mrxs

mrxiviwx$vexi$w{et$ekviiqirxw$xs$jm|$xli$mrxiviwx$vexi$xs$8266)2$Mrgpyhih$mr$xli$fepergi$ex$Qevgl$750$6464$mw$(42;$qmppmsr$sj$hijivvih

pser$gswxw

84

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 59 of 88

Page 335: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq 9=3;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

mrgyvvih$mr$xli$xverwegxmsr2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$=$1$Hivmzexmzi$Jmrergmep$Mrwxvyqirxw$erh$Rsxi$54$1$Hifx$sj$xli$Rsxiw$xs$Yreyhmxih

Gsrwspmhexih$Jmrergmep$Wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$M0$Mxiq$5$sj$xlmw$Uyevxivp}$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541U$jsv$jyvxliv$hmwgywwmsr2

Mr$ehhmxmsr$xs$xli$hifx$syxwxerhmrk$yrhiv$xli$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}0$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$xli$92<;92)$Wirmsv

Rsxiw$hyi$6466$erh$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$64680${i$epws$lezi$wmkrmjmgerx$hifx$sfpmkexmsrw${lmgl0$epxlsykl$xliwi$sfpmkexmsrw$evi

rsr1vigsyvwi$xs$yw0$viuymvi$gewl$i|tirhmxyviw$jsv$hifx$wivzmgi2$Syv$wmkrmjmgerx$hifx$sfpmkexmsrw$gsyph$lezi$qexivmep$gsrwiuyirgiw2$Wii

ÔVmwo$Jegxsvw1Vmwow$Vipexih$xs$Syv$Lmkl$Pizip$sj$MrhifxihriwwÕ$mr$Mxiq$5E$sj$syv$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O$jsv$xli$}iev$irhih

Higiqfiv$750$645=2$[i$evi$i|tswih$xs$zevmsyw$gsqqmxqirxw$erh$gsrxmrkirgmiw${lmgl$qe}$lezi$e$qexivmep$ehzivwi$ijjigx$sr$syv

pmuymhmx}2$[i$epws$lezi$kyeverxiih$givxemr$sfpmkexmsrw$jsv$givxemr$sj$syv$mrxivrexmsrep$wyfwmhmevmiw2$Xliwi$rsr1vigsyvwi$sfpmkexmsrw0

gsqqmxqirxw$erh$gsrxmrkirgmiw$erh$kyeverxiiw$evi$jyvxliv$hmwgywwih$mr$syv$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O$jsv$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv

750$645=2

Hifx$Vityvglewiw

Sr$Eykywx$5:0$645=0$xli$Gsqter}+w$Fsevh$sj$Hmvigxsvw$eyxlsvm~ih$xli$Gsqter}$xs$vityvglewi$erh3sv$vixmvi$e$tsvxmsr$sj$xli$:244)

Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$646:0$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$64680$xli$92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$64670$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6466

,gsppigxmzip}$xli$&KIS$Wirmsv$Rsxiw&-$erh$xli$Gsqter}+w$xivq$pser$yrhiv$mxw$Eqirhih$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx$xlvsykl$gewl$tyvglewiw0$mr

stir$qevoix$tyvglewiw0$tvmzexip}$riksxmexih$xverwegxmsrw0$sv$sxliv{mwi0$yt$xs$er$ekkvikexi$qe|mqyq$sj$(54424$qmppmsr0$wyfnigx$xs

givxemr$pmqmxexmsrw$xlvsykl$Higiqfiv$750$64642

Hyvmrk$645=0$xli$Gsqter}$vityvglewih$ettvs|mqexip}$(9:24$qmppmsr$mr$ekkvikexi$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj$mxw$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi

6466$ex$e${imklxih$eziveki$tvmgi$sj$=;299)$jsv$e$xsxep$gswx$sj$(982;$qmppmsr2$Ew$e$viwypx$sj$xliwi$vityvglewiw0$xli$Gsqter}$vigskrm~ih

e$rix$kemr$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx$sj$(427$qmppmsr2

Hyvmrk$xli$jmvwx$uyevxiv$sj$64640$xli$Gsqter}$vityvglewih$ettvs|mqexip}$(929$qmppmsr$mr$ekkvikexi$tvmrgmtep$eqsyrx$sj$mxw$92569)

Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$6467$ex$e${imklxih$eziveki$tvmgi$sj$;42:<)$jsv$e$xsxep$gswx$sj$(72=$qmppmsr2$Ew$e$viwypx$sj$xliwi$vityvglewiw0$xli

Gsqter}$vigskrm~ih$e$rix$kemr$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx$sj$(52:$qmppmsr2

Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$54$1$Hifx$sj$xli$Rsxiw$xs$Yreyhmxih$Gsrwspmhexih$Jmrergmep$Wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$M0$Mxiq$5$sj$xlmw$Uyevxivp}$Vitsvx

sr$Jsvq$541U$jsv$jyvxliv$mrjsvqexmsr$sr$syv$mrhifxihriww2

[i$gsrwmhiv$sttsvxyrmxmiw$jsv$jyxyvi$fywmriww$erh3sv$ewwix$eguymwmxmsrw$ew${i$hiiq$ettvstvmexi${lir$qevoix$gsrhmxmsrw$tviwirx

sttsvxyrmxmiw2$Mj${i$evi$wyggiwwjyp$mr$syv$tyvwymx$sj$er}$ri{$tvsnigxw0$syv$gewl$sr$lerh0$gewl$jps{w$jvsq$stivexmsrw$erh$fsvvs{mrkw

yrhiv$xli$i|mwxmrk$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}$qe}$rsx$tvszmhi$wyjjmgmirx$pmuymhmx}$xs$qiix$syv$getmxep$riihw$erh${i$gsyph$fi$jsvgih$xs$wiio

ehhmxmsrep$jmrergmrk$sv$vijmrergi$syv$i|mwxmrk$mrhifxihriww2$Xlivi$ger$fi$rs$ewwyvergi$xlex$er}$wygl$jmrergmrk$sv$vijmrergmrk${syph$fi

ezempefpi$xs$yw$sr$xivqw$iuyep$xs$sv$qsvi$jezsvefpi$xler$syv$gyvvirx$jmrergmrk$xivqw0$sv$ex$epp2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$xli$qekrmxyhi0$wizivmx}$erh

hyvexmsr$sj$xli$GSZMH15=$terhiqmg$qe}$rikexmzip}$mqtegx$xli$ezempefmpmx}$sj$sttsvxyrmxmiw$jsv$jyxyvi$fywmriww$erh3sv$ewwix

eguymwmxmsrw$erh$qevoix$gsrhmxmsrw$kirivepp}2$Mr$xli$jyxyvi0$syv$eggiww$xs$getmxep$erh$efmpmx}$xs$gsqtixi$jsv$jyxyvi$getmxep$mrxirwmzi

tvsnigxw${mpp$epws$fi$hitirhirx$ytsr0$eqsrk$sxliv$xlmrkw0$syv$efmpmx}$xs$qiix$givxemr$jmrergmep$gszirerxw$mr$xli$mrhirxyvi$kszivrmrk$xli

92569)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw0$xli$mrhirxyvi$kszivrmrk$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$64660$xli$mrhirxyvi$kszivrmrk$xli$92<;9)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw

hyi$64680$xli$mrhirxyvi$kszivrmrk$xli$:244)$Wirmsv$Rsxiw$hyi$646:$erh$syv$Gvihmx$Ekviiqirx2$E$wyfwxerxmep$higpmri$mr$syv$jmrergmep

tivjsvqergi$gsyph$pmqmx$syv$eggiww$xs$getmxep$tyvwyerx$xs$xliwi$gszirerxw$erh$lezi$e$qexivmep$ehzivwi$ijjigx$sr$syv$pmuymhmx}$erh$getmxep

viwsyvgiw$erh0$ew$e$viwypx0$sr$syv$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2$Mr$ehhmxmsr$xs$xliwi$jsviksmrk$tsxirxmep$gsrwxvemrxw$sr

syv$getmxep0$e$ryqfiv$sj$wxexi$kszivrqirx$ekirgmiw$lezi$fiir$wyjjivmrk$jvsq$fyhkix$hijmgmxw$erh$pmuymhmx}$mwwyiw2$[lmpi${i$i|tigx$xs$fi

mr$gsqtpmergi${mxl$syv$hifx$gszirerxw0$mj$xliwi$gsrwxvemrxw${ivi$xs$mrxirwmj}0$syv$pmuymhmx}$gsyph$fi$qexivmepp}$ehzivwip}$mqtegxih$ew

gsyph$syv$efmpmx}$xs$viqemr$mr$gsqtpmergi${mxl$xliwi$hifx$gszirerxw2

[i$qe}$jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi$wiio$xs$tyvglewi$wxsgo$yrhiv$syv$wxsgo$fy}fego$tvskveq$erh3sv$tyvglewi$sv$vixmvi$syv$syxwxerhmrk$wirmsv

rsxiw$xlvsykl$gewl$tyvglewiw$erh3sv$i|glerkiw$jsv$iuymx}$wigyvmxmiw0$mr$stir$qevoix$tyvglewiw0$tvmzexip}$riksxmexih$xverwegxmsrw$sv

sxliv{mwi2$$Wygl$vityvglewiw$sv$i|glerkiw0$mj$er}0${mpp$hitirh$sr$tvizempmrk$qevoix$gsrhmxmsrw0$syv$pmuymhmx}$viuymviqirxw0$gsrxvegxyep

viwxvmgxmsrw$erh$sxliv$jegxsvw2$$Xli$eqsyrxw$mrzspzih$qe}$fi$qexivmep2

85

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 60 of 88

Page 336: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq :43;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

Ew$e$VIMX0${i$evi$wyfnigx$xs$e$ryqfiv$sj$svkerm~exmsrep$erh$stivexmsrep$viuymviqirxw0$mrgpyhmrk$e$viuymviqirx$xlex${i$erryepp}

hmwxvmfyxi$xs$syv$wlevilsphivw$er$eqsyrx$iuyep$xs$ex$piewx$=4)$sj$syv$VIMX$xe|efpi$mrgsqi$,hixivqmrih$fijsvi$xli$hihygxmsr$jsv

hmzmhirhw$temh$erh$f}$i|gpyhmrk$er}$rix$getmxep$kemr-2$Kirivepp}0${i$i|tigx$xs$hmwxvmfyxi$epp$sv$wyfwxerxmepp}$epp$sj$syv$VIMX$xe|efpi

mrgsqi$ws$ew$rsx$xs$fi$wyfnigx$xs$xli$mrgsqi$sv$i|gmwi$xe|$sr$yrhmwxvmfyxih$VIMX$xe|efpi$mrgsqi2$Xli$eqsyrx0$xmqmrk$erh$jviuyirg}$sj

hmwxvmfyxmsrw${mpp$fi$ex$xli$wspi$hmwgvixmsr$sj$syv$Fsevh$erh${mpp$fi$fewih$ytsr$zevmsyw$jegxsvw2

[i$tper$xs$jyrh$epp$sj$syv$getmxep$riihw0$mrgpyhmrk$hmwxvmfyxmsrw$sj$syv$VIMX$xe|efpi$mrgsqi$mr$svhiv$xs$qemrxemr$syv$VIMX

uyepmjmgexmsr0$erh$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw0$jvsq$gewl$sr$lerh0$gewl$jvsq$stivexmsrw0$fsvvs{mrkw$yrhiv$syv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}$erh$er}$sxliv

jmrergmrkw${lmgl$syv$qerekiqirx$erh$Fsevh0$mr$xlimv$hmwgvixmsr0$qe}$gsrwyqqexi2$Gyvvirxp}0$syv$tvmqev}$wsyvgi$sj$pmuymhmx}$xs$qiix

xliwi$viuymviqirxw$mw$gewl$jps{$jvsq$stivexmsrw$erh$fsvvs{mrkw$yrhiv$syv$(=4424$qmppmsr$Vizspziv2$Syv$qerekiqirx$fipmiziw$xlex$syv

jmrergmep$viwsyvgiw$erh$wsyvgiw$sj$pmuymhmx}${mpp$epps{$yw$xs$qereki$xli$erxmgmtexih$mqtegx$sj$GSZMH15=$sr$syv$fywmriww0$jmrergmep

gsrhmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$erh$gewl$jps{w2$Jsv$xli$jypp1}iev$64640${i$lezi$vihygih$syv$tperrih$getmxep$wtirhmrk$f}$hijivvmrk

getmxep$i|tirhmxyvi$tvsnigxw${livi$tswwmfpi$erh$gpswip}$qerekmrk$syv${svomrk$getmxep2$Syv$qerekiqirx$fipmiziw$xlex$gewl$sr$lerh0

gewl$jps{w$jvsq$stivexmsrw$erh$ezempefmpmx}$yrhiv$syv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}${mpp$fi$ehiuyexi$xs$wyttsvx$syv$getmxep$viuymviqirxw$jsv$6464$ew

hmwgpswih$yrhiv$ÔGetmxep$ViuymviqirxwÕ$efszi2$Xli$gleppirkiw$tswih$f}$GSZMH15=$kirivepp}$erh$sr$xli$Gsqter}+w$fywmriww$evi

izspzmrk$vetmhp}2$Gsrwiuyirxp}0$xli$Gsqter}${mpp$gsrxmryi$xs$izepyexi$mxw$jmrergmep$tswmxmsr$mr$pmklx$sj$jyxyvi$hizipstqirxw0

tevxmgypevp}$xlswi$vipexmrk$xs$GSZMH15=2

$

Wxsgo$Fy}fego$Tvskveq

Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$:$1$Wlevilsphivw+$Iuymx}$sj$xli$Rsxiw$xs$Yreyhmxih$Gsrwspmhexih$Jmrergmep$Wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$M0$Mxiq$5$sj$xlmw

Uyevxivp}$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541U$jsv$jyvxliv$mrjsvqexmsr2

Tvswtigxyw$Wyttpiqirx

Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$:$1$Wlevilsphivw+$Iuymx}$sj$xli$Rsxiw$xs$Yreyhmxih$Gsrwspmhexih$Jmrergmep$Wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$M0$Mxiq$5$sj$xlmw

Uyevxivp}$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541U$jsv$jyvxliv$mrjsvqexmsr2

I|igyxmzi$Vixmviqirx$Ekviiqirx

[i$lezi$e$rsr1uyepmjmih$hijivvih$gsqtirwexmsr$ekviiqirx${mxl$syv$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$,&GIS&-2$Xli$gyvvirx$ekviiqirx0$ew

eqirhih0$tvszmhih$jsv$e$pyqt$wyq$te}qirx$ytsr$vixmviqirx0$rs$wssriv$xler$eki$992$Syv$GIS$lew$vieglih$eki$99$erh$mw$ipmkmfpi$xs

vigimzi$xli$te}qirx$ytsr$vixmviqirx2$Mj$syv$GIS$leh$vixmvih$ew$sj$Qevgl$750$64640${i${syph$lezi$leh$xs$te}$lmq$xli$pyqt$wyq

eqsyrx$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(<2=$qmppmsr$,gepgypexih$ew$sj$Jifvyev}$6:0$6464-$mr$wxsgo$ew$hmwgywwih$fips{2

$

Sr$Jifvyev}$6:0$6464$,xli$&Ijjigxmzi$Hexi&-0$KIS$erh$syv$GIS$irxivih$mrxs$xli$eqirhih$erh$viwxexih$i|igyxmzi$vixmviqirx$ekviiqirx

xlex$eqirhw$erh$vitpegiw$xli$GIS×w$tvmsv$i|igyxmzi$vixmviqirx$ekviiqirx$hmwgywwih$efszi2

$

Xli$eqirhih$erh$viwxexih$i|igyxmzi$vixmviqirx$ekviiqirx$tvszmhiw$xlex$ytsr$syv$GIS×w$vixmviqirx$jvsq$xli$Gsqter}0${i${mpp$te}$e

pyqt$wyq$eqsyrx$iuyep$xs$(<0=6904:9$,hixivqmrih$ew$sj$Jifvyev}$6:0$6464-$,xli$ÔKverhjexlivih$Te}qirxÕ-${lmgl${mpp$fi$temh$mr$xli

jsvq$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo2$Xli$Kverhjexlivih$Te}qirx${mpp$fi$hipe}ih$jsv$wm|$qsrxlw$erh$e$he}$jspps{mrk$xli$ijjigxmzi$hexi$sj$xli

GIS×w$xivqmrexmsr$sj$iqtps}qirx$,ÔWm|$Qsrxl$Hipe}Õ-$mr$gsqtpmergi${mxl$Wigxmsr$84=E$sj$xli$Mrxivrep$Viziryi$Gshi$sj$5=<:0$ew

eqirhih2

$

Fikmrrmrk$sr$xli$Ijjigxmzi$Hexi0$er$eqsyrx$iuyep$xs$xli$Kverhjexlivih$Te}qirx$wlepp$fi$mrziwxih$mr$xli$Gsqter}×w$gsqqsr$wxsgo

,ÔKIS$WleviwÕ-2$Xli$ryqfiv$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$ew$sj$xli$Ijjigxmzi$Hexi$wlepp$fi$iuyep$xs$xli$Kverhjexlivih

Te}qirx$hmzmhih$f}$xli$gpswmrk$tvmgi$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$gsqqsr$wxsgo$sr$xli$Ijjigxmzi$Hexi$,vsyrhih$yt$xs$xli$rieviwx${lspi$ryqfiv

sj$wleviw-0${lmgl$iuyepw$9970::9$wleviw$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$gsqqsr$wxsgo2$Ehhmxmsrep$wleviw$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$gsqqsr$wxsgo${mpp$fi

gvihmxih${mxl$e$zepyi$iuyep$xs$er}$hmzmhirhw$higpevih$erh$temh$sr$xli$Gsqter}×w$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo0$gepgypexih$f}$vijivirgi$xs

xli$gpswmrk$tvmgi$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$gsqqsr$wxsgo$sr$xli$te}qirx$hexi$jsv$wygl$hmzmhirhw$,vsyrhih$yt$xs$xli$rieviwx${lspi$ryqfiv$sj

wleviw-2

$

Xli$Gsqter}$lew$iwxefpmwlih$wizivep$xvywxw$jsv$xli$tyvtswi$sj$te}mrk$xli$vixmviqirx$firijmx$tyvwyerx$xs$xli$eqirhih$erh$viwxexih

i|igyxmzi$vixmviqirx$ekviiqirx2$Xli$xvywxw$wlepp$fi$vizsgefpi$Ôveffm$xvywxwÕ$erh$xli$ewwixw$sj$xli$xvywxw$wlepp$fi$wyfnigx$xs$xli$gpemqw$sj

xli$Gsqter}×w$gvihmxsvw$mr$xli$izirx$sj$xli$Gsqter}×w$mrwspzirg}2

$

Xli$Gsqter}$vityvglewih$wleviw$sj$mxw$syxwxerhmrk$gsqqsr$wxsgo$yrhiv$mxw$wxsgo$fy}fego$tvskveq$erh$gsrxvmfyxih$wygl$wleviw$xs$xli

xvywxw$mr$svhiv$xs$jyrh$xli$vixmviqirx$firijmx$yrhiv$xli$eqirhih$erh$viwxexih$i|igyxmzi$vixmviqirx$ekviiqirx2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 61 of 88

Page 337: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq :53;9

$

$

$

86

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 62 of 88

Page 338: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq :63;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

Sjj1Fepergi$Wliix$Evverkiqirxw

I|gitx$ew$hmwgywwih$mr$xli$rsxiw$xs$syv$Yreyhmxih$Gsrwspmhexih$Jmrergmep$Wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$M0$Mxiq$5$sj$xlmw$uyevxivp}$vitsvx

sr$Jsvq$541U0${i$hs$rsx$lezi$er}$sjj1fepergi$wliix$evverkiqirxw2

Gewl$Jps{

Gewl0$gewl$iuymzepirxw$erh$viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw$ew$sj$Qevgl$750$6464${ew$(:62:$qmppmsr0$gsqtevih$xs$(5672<$qmppmsr$ew

sj$Qevgl$750$645=2

Stivexmrk$Egxmzmxmiw

Gewl$tvszmhih$f}$stivexmrk$egxmzmxmiw$eqsyrxih$xs$(56<27$qmppmsr$jsv$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$6464$zivwyw$gewl$tvszmhih$f}

stivexmrk$egxmzmxmiw$sj$(==24$qmppmsr$jsv$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$645=2$Gewl$tvszmhih$f}$stivexmrk$egxmzmxmiw$hyvmrk$xli$xlvii

qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$6464${ew$tswmxmzip}$mqtegxih$f}$rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS0$rsr1gewl$i|tirwiw$wygl$ew$hitvigmexmsr$erh

eqsvxm~exmsr0$eqsvxm~exmsr$sj$hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw0$hmwgsyrx$erh3sv$tviqmyq$erh$sxliv$rsr1gewl$mrxiviwx$erh$wxsgo1fewih$gsqtirwexmsr

i|tirwi2$Iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw0$rix$sj$xe|$erh$kemr$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx$rikexmzip}$mqtegxih$gewl2$Glerkiw$mr$eggsyrxw

vigimzefpi0$tvitemh$i|tirwiw$erh$sxliv$ewwixw$higviewih$mr$xsxep$f}$(9726$qmppmsr0$vitviwirxmrk$e$tswmxmzi$mqtegx$sr$gewl2$Xli$higviewi

{ew$tvmqevmp}$hvmzir$f}$xli$xmqmrk$sj$fmppmrkw$erh$gsppigxmsrw2$Glerkiw$mr$eggsyrxw$te}efpi0$eggvyih$i|tirwiw$erh$sxliv$pmefmpmxmiw

mrgviewih$f}$(:2<$qmppmsr${lmgl$tswmxmzip}$mqtegxih$gewl2$Xli$mrgviewi${ew$tvmqevmp}$hvmzir$f}$xli$xmqmrk$sj$te}qirxw2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0

gewl$tvszmhih$f}$stivexmrk$egxmzmxmiw$jsv$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$6464${ew$tswmxmzip}$mqtegxih$f}$e$higviewi$mr$glerkiw$mr

gsrxvegx$vigimzefpi$vipexih$xs$syv$gsvvigxmsrep$jegmpmx}$mr$Vezirlepp0$Eywxvepme$sj$(526$qmppmsr${lmgl${ew$e$viwypx$sj$xli$xmqmrk$sj

mrxiviwx$eggvyepw$erh$te}qirxw$qehi$xs{evhw$xli$gsrxvegx$vigimzefpi2

Gewl$tvszmhih$f}$stivexmrk$egxmzmxmiw$hyvmrk$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$645=${ew$tswmxmzip}$mqtegxih$f}$rix$mrgsqi

exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS0$rsr1gewl$i|tirwiw$wygl$ew$hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr0$eqsvxm~exmsr$sj$hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw0$hmwgsyrx$erh3sv

tviqmyq$erh$sxliv$rsr1gewl$mrxiviwx$erh$wxsgo1fewih$gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwi2$Iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw$rikexmzip}$mqtegxih$gewl2

Glerkiw$mr$eggsyrxw$vigimzefpi0$tvitemh$i|tirwiw$erh$sxliv$ewwixw$higviewih$mr$xsxep$f}$(6;29$qmppmsr0$vitviwirxmrk$e$tswmxmzi$mqtegx

sr$gewl2$Xli$higviewi${ew$tvmqevmp}$hvmzir$f}$xli$xmqmrk$sj$fmppmrkw$erh$gsppigxmsrw2$Glerkiw$mr$eggsyrxw$te}efpi0$eggvyih$i|tirwiw

erh$sxliv$pmefmpmxmiw$higviewih$f}$(582<$qmppmsr${lmgl$rikexmzip}$mqtegxih$gewl2$Xli$higviewi${ew$tvmqevmp}$hvmzir$f}$xli$xmqmrk$sj

te}qirxw2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$gewl$tvszmhih$f}$stivexmrk$egxmzmxmiw$jsv$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$645=${ew$tswmxmzip}$mqtegxih$f}$e

higviewi$mr$glerkiw$mr$gsrxvegx$vigimzefpi$vipexih$xs$syv$gsvvigxmsrep$jegmpmx}$mr$Vezirlepp0$Eywxvepme$sj$(528$qmppmsr${lmgl${ew$e$viwypx

sj$xli$xmqmrk$sj$mrxiviwx$eggvyepw$erh$te}qirxw$qehi$xs{evhw$xli$gsrxvegx$vigimzefpi2

Mrziwxmrk$Egxmzmxmiw

Gewl$ywih$mr$mrziwxmrk$egxmzmxmiw$sj$(692;$qmppmsr$hyvmrk$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$6464${ew$tvmqevmp}$xli$viwypx$sj$getmxep

i|tirhmxyviw$sj$(742;$qmppmsr2$Gewl$ywih$mr$mrziwxmrk$egxmzmxmiw$sj$(6=28$qmppmsr$hyvmrk$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$645=${ew

tvmqevmp}$xli$viwypx$sj$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw$sj$(6<25$qmppmsr2

Jmrergmrk$Egxmzmxmiw

Gewl$ywih$mr$jmrergmrk$egxmzmxmiw$hyvmrk$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$6464${ew$ettvs|mqexip}$(54425$qmppmsr$gsqtevih$xs$gewl

ywih$mr$jmrergmrk$egxmzmxmiw$sj$(742;$qmppmsr$hyvmrk$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$645=2$Gewl$ywih$mr$jmrergmrk$egxmzmxmiw$hyvmrk

xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$6464${ew$tvmqevmp}$xli$viwypx$sj$hmzmhirhw$temh$sj$(9;2;$qmppmsr0$te}qirxw$sr$psrk1xivq$hifx$sj

(56929$qmppmsr0$te}qirxw$sr$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx$sj$(528$qmppmsr$erh$vityvglewiw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo$sj$(=24$qmppmsr2$Xliwi$higviewiw

{ivi$tevxmepp}$sjjwix$f}$tvsgiihw$jvsq$psrk1xivq$hifx$sj$(=:24$qmppmsr2$Gewl$ywih$mr$jmrergmrk$egxmzmxmiw$hyvmrk$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih

Qevgl$750$645=${ew$tvmqevmp}$xli$viwypx$sj$hmzmhirhw$temh$sj$(9;2=$qmppmsr0$te}qirxw$sr$psrk1xivq$hifx$sj$(=:2=$qmppmsr$erh$te}qirxw

sr$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx$sj$(625$qmppmsr2$Xliwi$higviewiw${ivi$tevxmepp}$sjjwix$f}$tvsgiihw$jvsq$psrk1xivq$hifx$sj$(57424$qmppmsr2

Rsr1KEET$Qiewyviw

Jyrhw$jvsq$Stivexmsrw$,&JJS&-$mw$e${mhip}$eggitxih$wyttpiqirxep$rsr1KEET$qiewyvi$yxmpm~ih$xs$izepyexi$xli$stivexmrk$tivjsvqergi

sj$viep$iwxexi$mrziwxqirx$xvywxw2$Mx$mw$hijmrih$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$xli$wxerhevhw$iwxefpmwlih$f}$xli$Rexmsrep$Ewwsgmexmsr$sj$Viep$Iwxexi

Mrziwxqirx$Xvywxw0$sv$REVIMX0${lmgl$hijmriw$JJS$ew$rix$mrgsqi$,psww-$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$gsqqsr$wlevilsphivw$,gsqtyxih$mr$eggsvhergi

{mxl$Kirivepp}$Eggitxih$Eggsyrxmrk$Tvmrgmtpiw-0$i|gpyhmrk$viep$iwxexi$vipexih$hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr0$i|gpyhmrk$kemrw$erh

pswwiw$jvsq$xli$gyqypexmzi$ijjigxw$sj$eggsyrxmrk$glerkiw0$i|xvesvhmrev}$mxiqw$erh$wepiw$sj$tvstivxmiw0$erh$mrgpyhmrk$ehnywxqirxw$jsv

yrgsrwspmhexih$tevxrivwlmtw$erh$nsmrx$zirxyviw2

[i$epws$tviwirx$Rsvqepm~ih$Jyrhw$Jvsq$Stivexmsrw0$sv$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS0$erh$Ehnywxih$Jyrhw$jvsq$Stivexmsrw0$sv$EJJS0$ew

wyttpiqirxep$rsr1KEET$jmrergmep$qiewyviw$sj$viep$iwxexi$mrziwxqirx$xvywxw+$stivexmrk$tivjsvqergi2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 63 of 88

Page 339: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq :73;9

Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$mw$hijmrih$ew$JJS$ehnywxih$jsv$givxemr$mxiqw${lmgl$f}$xlimv$rexyvi$evi$rsx$gsqtevefpi$jvsq$tivmsh$xs$tivmsh$sv$xlex

xirh$xs$sfwgyvi$xli$Gsqter}×w$egxyep$stivexmrk$tivjsvqergi0$mrgpyhmrk$jsv$xli$tivmshw$tviwirxih$Gszmh15=$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|0$kemr3psww

sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx0$tvi1xe|0$wxevx1yt$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|0$gpswi1syx$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|$erh$xli$xe|$ijjigx$sj$ehnywxqirxw$xs$JJS2

87

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 64 of 88

Page 340: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq :83;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

EJJS$mw$hijmrih$ew$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$ehnywxih$f}$ehhmrk$rsr1gewl$i|tirwiw$wygl$ew$rsr1viep$iwxexi$vipexih$hitvigmexmsr$erh

eqsvxm~exmsr0$wxsgo1fewih$gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwi0$xli$eqsvxm~exmsr$sj$hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw0$hmwgsyrx$erh3sv$tviqmyq$erh$sxliv$rsr1gewl

mrxiviwx0$erh$f}$wyfxvegxmrk$vigyvvmrk$gsrwspmhexih$qemrxirergi$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw2

Figeywi$sj$xli$yrmuyi$hiwmkr0$wxvygxyvi$erh$ywi$sj$syv$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw0$tvsgiwwmrk$girxivw$erh$viirxv}$girxivw0${i$fipmizi$xlex

ewwiwwmrk$xli$tivjsvqergi$sj$syv$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw0$tvsgiwwmrk$girxivw$erh$viirxv}$girxivw${mxlsyx$xli$mqtegx$sj$hitvigmexmsr$sv

eqsvxm~exmsr$mw$ywijyp$erh$qiermrkjyp$xs$mrziwxsvw2$Epxlsykl$REVIMX$lew$tyfpmwlih$mxw$hijmrmxmsr$sj$JJS0$gsqtermiw$sjxir$qshmj}

xlmw$hijmrmxmsr$ew$xli}$wiio$xs$tvszmhi$jmrergmep$qiewyviw$xlex$qiermrkjypp}$vijpigx$xlimv$hmwxmrgxmzi$stivexmsrw2$[i$lezi$qshmjmih$JJS

xs$hivmzi$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$erh$EJJS$xlex$qiermrkjypp}$vijpigx$syv$stivexmsrw2

Syv$ewwiwwqirx$sj$syv$stivexmsrw$mw$jsgywih$sr$psrk1xivq$wywxemrefmpmx}2$Xli$ehnywxqirxw${i$qeoi$xs$hivmzi$xli$rsr1KEET$qiewyviw

sj$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$erh$EJJS$i|gpyhi$mxiqw${lmgl$qe}$geywi$wlsvx1xivq$jpygxyexmsrw$mr$rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS$fyx$lezi$rs

mqtegx$sr$syv$gewl$jps{w0$sv${i$hs$rsx$gsrwmhiv$xliq$xs$fi$jyrheqirxep$exxvmfyxiw$sv$xli$tvmqev}$hvmzivw$sj$syv$fywmriww$tper$erh$xli}

hs$rsx$ejjigx$syv$szivepp$psrk1xivq$stivexmrk$tivjsvqergi2$[i$qe}$qeoi$ehnywxqirxw$xs$JJS$jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi$jsv$givxemr$sxliv

mrgsqi$erh$i|tirwiw$xlex$hs$rsx$vijpigx$e$rigiwwev}$gsqtsrirx$sj$syv$stivexmsrep$tivjsvqergi$sr$xli$fewmw$hmwgywwih$efszi0$izir

xlsykl$wygl$mxiqw$qe}$viuymvi$gewl$wixxpiqirx2$Figeywi$JJS0$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$erh$EJJS$i|gpyhi$hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr

yrmuyi$xs$viep$iwxexi$ew${ipp$ew$rsr1stivexmsrep$mxiqw$erh$givxemr$sxliv$glevkiw$xlex$evi$lmklp}$zevmefpi$jvsq$}iev$xs$}iev0$xli}$tvszmhi

syv$mrziwxsvw${mxl$tivjsvqergi$qiewyviw$xlex$vijpigx$xli$mqtegx$xs$stivexmsrw$jvsq$xvirhw$mr$sggyterg}$vexiw0$tiv$hmiq$vexiw0$stivexmrk

gswxw$erh$mrxiviwx$gswxw0$tvszmhmrk$e$tivwtigxmzi$rsx$mqqihmexip}$ettevirx$jvsq$rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS2

[i$fipmizi$xli$tviwirxexmsr$sj$JJS0$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$erh$EJJS$tvszmhi$ywijyp$mrjsvqexmsr$xs$mrziwxsvw$ew$xli}$tvszmhi$er$mrhmgexmsr

sj$syv$efmpmx}$xs$jyrh$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw$erh$i|terh$syv$fywmriww2$JJS0$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$erh$EJJS$tvszmhi$hmwgpswyvi$sr$xli$weqi

fewmw$ew$xlex$ywih$f}$syv$qerekiqirx$erh$tvszmhi$gsrwmwxirg}$mr$syv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk0$jegmpmxexi$mrxivrep$erh$i|xivrep

gsqtevmwsrw$sj$syv$lmwxsvmgep$stivexmrk$tivjsvqergi$erh$syv$fywmriww$yrmxw$erh$tvszmhi$gsrxmrymx}$xs$mrziwxsvw$jsv$gsqtevefmpmx}

tyvtswiw2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$JJS0$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$erh$EJJS$evi${mhip}$vigskrm~ih$qiewyviw$mr$syv$mrhywxv}$ew$e$viep$iwxexi$mrziwxqirx

xvywx2

Syv$vigsrgmpmexmsr$sj$rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2$xs$JJS0$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$erh$EJJS$jsv$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih

Qevgl$750$6464$erh$645=$mw$ew$jspps{w$,mr$xlsywerhw->

$

$ Xlvii$Qsrxlw$Irhih $

$ $Qevgl$750

6464 $ $Qevgl$750

645= $

Rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2 $ ( 6905<5$ $ ( 840;49$

Ehh$,Wyfxvegx-> $ $ $ $ $ $ $$

Viep$iwxexi$vipexih$hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr $ $ 5<07=9$ $ $ 5<0547$

,Kemr-$psww$sr$viep$iwxexi$ewwixw $ $ ,868- $ $ 508=;$

REVIMX$Hijmrih$JJS $ ( 870596$ $ ( :40749$

Ehh$,Wyfxvegx-> $ $ $ $ $ $ $$

,Kemr-$psww$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx0$tvi1xe| $ $ ,509:7- $ $ Ó$

Wxevx1yt$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe| $ $ 50=97$ $ $ Ó$

Gszmh15=$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe| $ $ <=6$ $ $ Ó$

Gpswi1syx$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe| $ $ 50=7:$ $ $ Ó$

Xe|$ijjigx$sj$ehnywxqirxw$xs$Jyrhw$Jvsq$Stivexmsrw$. $ $ <7;$ $ $ ,89-

Rsvqepm~ih$Jyrhw$jvsq$Stivexmsrw $ ( 8;064;$ $ ( :406:4$

Ehh$,Wyfxvegx-> $ $ $ $ $ $ $$

Rsr1viep$iwxexi$vipexih$hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr $ $ 580=76$ $ $ 5807::$

Gsrwspmhexih$qemrxirergi$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw $ $ ,;046;- $ $ ,70:78-

Wxsgo1fewih$gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwi $ $ =0;:<$ $ $ :0;6;$

Eqsvxm~exmsr$sj$hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw0$hmwgsyrx$erh3sv

$$$tviqmyq$erh$sxliv$rsr1gewl$mrxiviwx $ $ 50:;4$ $ $ 609:7$

Ehnywxih$Jyrhw$jvsq$Stivexmsrw $ ( ::0994$ $ ( <406<6$

$. Xe|$ijjigx$sj$ehnywxqirxw$vipexi$xs$kemr$,psww-$sr$viep$iwxexi$ewwixw0$kemr$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx0$wxevx1yt$i|tirwiw0$Gszmh15=

i|tirwiw0$gpswi1syx$i|tirwiw$erh$psww$sr$mrziwxqirx$mr$pmji$mrwyvergi2

Syxpsso

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 65 of 88

Page 341: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq :93;9

Xli$jspps{mrk$hmwgywwmsr$gsrxemrw$wxexiqirxw$xlex$evi$rsx$lmwxsvmgep$wxexiqirxw$erh0$xlivijsvi0$gsrwxmxyxi$jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw

{mxlmr$xli$qiermrk$sj$xli$Tvmzexi$Wigyvmxmiw$Pmxmkexmsr$Vijsvq$Egx$sj$5==92$Syv$jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw$evi$wyfnigx$xs$vmwow$erh

yrgivxemrxmiw$xlex$gsyph$geywi$egxyep$viwypxw$xs$hmjjiv$qexivmepp}$jvsq$xlswi$wxexih$sv$mqtpmih$mr$xli$jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw2$Tpiewi

88

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 66 of 88

Page 342: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq ::3;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

vijiv$xs$ÔTevx$M$1$Mxiq$5E2$Vmwo$JegxsvwÕ$erh$xli$&Jsv{evh$Pssomrk$Wxexiqirxw$1$Weji$Levfsv&$wigxmsrw$mr$syv$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq

541O$jsv$xli$jmwgep$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=0$ew${ipp$ew$xli$&Tevx$MM$Ò$Mxiq$5E2$Vmwo$Jegxsvw&$erh$xli$&Jsv{evh1Pssomrk

Wxexiqirxw$1$Weji$Levfsv&$wigxmsr$erh$sxliv$hmwgpswyviw$gsrxemrih$mr$xlmw$Jsvq$541U$jsv$jyvxliv$hmwgywwmsr$sr$jsv{evh1pssomrk

wxexiqirxw$erh$xli$vmwow$erh$sxliv$jegxsvw$xlex$gsyph$tvizirx$yw$jvsq$eglmizmrk$syv$ksepw$erh$geywi$xli$ewwyqtxmsrw$yrhivp}mrk$xli

jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw$erh$xli$egxyep$viwypxw$xs$hmjjiv$qexivmepp}$jvsq$xlswi$i|tviwwih$mr$sv$mqtpmih$f}$xlswi$jsv{evh1pssomrk

wxexiqirxw2

$

Gsvsrezmvyw$Hmwiewi$,GSZMH15=-$Terhiqmg

Mr$Higiqfiv$645=0$e$rszip$wxvemr$sj$gsvsrezmvyw0$rs{$ors{r$ew$GSZMH15=$,ÔGSZMH15=Õ-0${ew$vitsvxih$mr$[yler0$Glmre$erh$lew

wmrgi$i|xirwmzip}$mqtegxih$xli$kpsfep$liepxl$erh$igsrsqmg$irzmvsrqirx2$Mr$Neryev}$64640$xli$[svph$Liepxl$Svkerm~exmsr$,Ô[LSÕ-

higpevih$mx$e$Tyfpmg$Liepxl$Iqivkirg}$sj$Mrxivrexmsrep$Gsrgivr2$Sr$Jifvyev}$6<0$64640$xli$[LS$vemwih$mxw$ewwiwwqirx$sj$xli$GSZMH1

5=$xlviex$jvsq$lmkl$xs$ziv}$lmkl$ex$e$kpsfep$pizip$hyi$xs$xli$gsrxmryih$mrgviewi$mr$xli$ryqfiv$sj$gewiw$erh$ejjigxih$gsyrxvmiw0$erh$sr

Qevgl$550$64640$xli$[LS$glevegxivm~ih$GSZMH15=$ew$e$terhiqmg2$$

Liepxl$erh$Wejix}

Ew$xli$GSZMH15=$terhiqmg$lew$mqtegxih$gsqqyrmxmiw$egvsww$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw$erh$evsyrh$xli${svph0$syv$iqtps}iiw$erh$jegmpmxmiw

lezi$epws$fiir$mqtegxih$f}$xli$wtvieh$sj$GSZMH15=2$Irwyvmrk$xli$liepxl$erh$wejix}$sj$syv$iqtps}iiw$erh$epp$xlswi$mr$syv$gevi$lew

ep{e}w$fiir$syv$ryqfiv$sri$tvmsvmx}2$Ew$e$psrkwxerhmrk$tvszmhiv$sj$iwwirxmep$kszivrqirx$wivzmgiw0${i$lezi$i|tivmirgi${mxl$xli

mqtpiqirxexmsr$sj$fiwx$tvegxmgiw$jsv$xli$tvizirxmsr0$ewwiwwqirx0$erh$qerekiqirx$sj$mrjigxmsyw$hmwiewiw2

$ ¨ Epp$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$tvszmhi$683;$eggiww$xs$liepxlgevi?

$ ¨ Epp$sj$syv$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxivw$x}tmgepp}$lezi$ettvs|mqexip}$hsyfpi$xli$ryqfiv$sj$liepxlgevi$wxejj0$gsqtevih$xs$wxexi

gsvvigxmsrep$jegmpmxmiw?

$ ¨ Qer}$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$evi$iuymttih${mxl$Emvfsvri$Mrjigxmsr$Mwspexmsr$Vssqw?

$ ¨ Epp$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$stivexi$wejip}$erh${mxlsyx$er}$szivgvs{hih$gsrhmxmsrw?$erh

$ ¨ Epp$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$lezi$eggiww$xs$vikypev$lerh{ewlmrk${mxl$gpier${exiv$erh$wset2

$

Jvsq$xli$syxwix$sj$xli$GSZMH15=$kpsfep$terhiqmg0$syv$gsvtsvexi0$vikmsrep$erh$jmiph$wxejj$lezi$mqtpiqirxih$gsqtvilirwmzi$wxitw$xs

ehhviww$erh$qmxmkexi$xli$vmwow$sj$GSZMH15=$xs$epp$xlswi$mr$syv$gevi$erh$syv$iqtps}iiw2

$

$ ¨ [i$mwwyih$kymhergi$xs$epp$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw0$gsrwmwxirx${mxl$xli$kymhergi$mwwyih$jsv$gsvvigxmsrep$erh$hixirxmsr$jegmpmxmiw$f}$xli

Girxivw$jsv$Hmwiewi$Gsrxvsp$erh$Tvizirxmsr$Mrxivmq$Kymhergi$sr$Qerekiqirx$sj$Gsvsrezmvyw$Hmwiewi$645=$,Gszmh15=-$mr

Gsvvigxmsrep$erh$Hixirxmsr$Jegmpmxmiw?

$ ¨ [i$ythexih$syv$tspmgmiw$erh$tvsgihyviw$xs$mrgpyhi$fiwx$tvegxmgiw$jsv$xli$tvizirxmsr0$ewwiwwqirx0$erh$qerekiqirx$sj$GSZMH1

5=0$mrgpyhmrk$xli$mqtpiqirxexmsr$sj$uyeverxmri$erh$gslsvxmrk$tvsgihyviw$xs$mwspexi$gsrjmvqih$erh$tviwyqtxmzi$gewiw$sj

GSZMH15=0$mrgpyhmrk$qihmgep$mwspexmsr$erh$xli$ywi$sj$Emvfsvri$Mrjigxmsr$Mwspexmsr$Vssqw?

$ ¨ [i$svhivih$erh$vigimzih$w{ef$omxw$jsv$GSZMH15=$jvsq$e$rexmsrep$wyttpmiv0$erh${i$iregxih$uyeverxmri$erh$xiwxmrk$tvsgihyviw

jsv$er}$iqtps}iiw${ls$qe}$lezi$gsqi$mrxs$gsrxegx${mxl$er}$mrhmzmhyep${ls$lew$xiwxih$tswmxmzi$jsv$GSZMH15=?

$ ¨ Mr$Qevgl$64640${i$wxevxih$tvsgyvmrk$ehhmxmsrep$Tivwsrep$Tvsxigxmzi$Iuymtqirx$erh$fiker$mwwymrk$mx$ew$gpmrmgepp}$riihih$ex

jegmpmxmiw$mqtegxih$f}$GSZMH15=?

$ ¨ Sziv$xli$gsyvwi$sj$Etvmp$64640${i$gssvhmrexih${mxl$syv$kszivrqirx$tevxrivw$xs$hmwxvmfyxi$Tivwsrep$Tvsxigxmzi$Iuymtqirx0

mrgpyhmrk$jegi$qewow$xs$epp$wxejj0$mrqexiw0$hixemriiw$erh$viwmhirxw$ew$e$tvigeyxmsrev}$qiewyvi$ex$epp$sj$syv$Jihivep$Fyviey$sj

Tvmwsrw$jegmpmxmiw0$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxivw0$Y2W2$Qevwlepw$jegmpmxmiw0$wxexi$gsvvigxmsrep$jegmpmxmiw0$psgep$gsvvigxmsrep$jegmpmxmiw$erh

nempw0$viwmhirxmep$viirxv}$girxivw0$erh$}syxl$wivzmgiw$viwmhirxmep$jegmpmxmiw?

$ ¨ [i$tvszmhih$ihygexmsrep$kymhergi$xs$syv$iqtps}iiw$erh$mrhmzmhyepw$mr$syv$gevi$sr$xli$fiwx$tvizirxexmzi$qiewyviw$xs$ezsmh

xli$wtvieh$sj$GSZMH15=$wygl$ew$jviuyirx$erh$gevijyp$lerh{ewlmrk0$ezsmhmrk$xsyglmrk$eview$sj$xli$jegi0$mrgpyhmrk$jegmep$lemv0

89

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 67 of 88

Page 343: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq :;3;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

$ ezsmhmrk$mrhmzmhyepw$i|lmfmxmrk$jpy1pmoi$w}qtxsqw0$tvstiv$gsykl$erh$wrii~i$ixmuyixxi0$wsgmep$hmwxergmrk$viuymviqirxw$erh

ehnywxqirxw$xs$peyrhv}$erh$qiep$wglihypiw?

$ ¨ [i$mrgviewih$xli$jviuyirg}$sj$hmwxvmfyxmsr$sj$tivwsrep$l}kmiri$tvshygxw0$mrgpyhmrk$wset0$wleqtss$erh$fsh}${ewl$erh$xmwwyi

tetiv0$erh${i$evi$irwyvmrk$xli$hemp}$ezempefmpmx}$sj$fevw$sj$wset$sv$wset$hmwtirwivw$ex$iegl$wmro$jsv$lerh${ewlmrk$mr$epp$sj$syv

jegmpmxmiw?

$ ¨ [i$ehzmwih$syv$iqtps}iiw$xs$viqemr$lsqi$mj$xli}$i|lmfmx$jpy1pmoi$w}qtxsqw0$erh${i$lezi$i|ivgmwih$jpi|mfpi$temh$piezi$erh

temh$xmqi$sjj$tspmgmiw$xs$epps{$jsv$iqtps}iiw$xs$viqemr$lsqi$mj$xli}$i|lmfmx$jpy1pmoi$w}qtxsqw$sv$xs$gevi$jsv$e$jeqmp}

qiqfiv?

$ ¨ [i$tvsgyvih$ehhmxmsrep$gpiermrk$iuymtqirx$erh$wermxexmsr$tvshygxw$xlex$evi$tvszir$liepxlgevi$kvehi$hmwmrjigxerxw?

$ ¨ [i$hitps}ih$wtigmepm~ih$wermxexmsr$xieqw$xs$wxivmpm~i$lmkl1gsrxegx$eview$ex$syv$jegmpmxmiw$erh$lezi$hizipstih$mrxirwmzi

wglihypiw$erh$tvsgihyviw$jsv$xli$gpiermrk$erh$hmwmrjigxmrk$sj$jegmpmx}$wtegiw$efszi$erh$fi}srh$rsvqep$gpiermrk$egxmzmxmiw?

$ ¨ Ex$iziv}$sri$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw0${i$lezi${svoih$gpswip}${mxl$syv$kszivrqirx$ekirg}$tevxrivw$erh$psgep$liepxl$sjjmgmepw$xs

hizipst$GSZMH15=$iqivkirg}$tperw$erh$xiwxmrk$tspmgmiw$jsv$xli$mrhmzmhyepw$mr$syv$gevi?$erh

$ ¨ [i$irkekih${mxl$syv$kszivrqirx$ekirg}$tevxrivw$xs$tvsqtxp}$wywtirh$rsr1iwwirxmep$zmwmxexmsr$ex$epp$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw0$erh${i

lezi$iqtps}ih$ehhmxmsrep$qiewyviw$hyvmrk$xli$mrxeoi$erh$irxv}$tvsgiww$ex$epp$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$xs$mrgpyhi$wgviirmrk$wtigmjmg$xs

GSZMH15=0$mrgpyhmrk$xiqtivexyvi$gligow$jsv$epp$wxejj$erh$er}$pikepp}$viuymvih$zmwmxsvw$fijsvi$irxivmrk$syv$jegmpmxmiw0$ew${ipp

ew0$zivfep$qihmgep$wgviirmrk$uyiwxmsrremviw2

$

[i${mpp$gsrxmryi$xs$gssvhmrexi$gpswip}${mxl$syv$kszivrqirx$ekirg}$tevxrivw$erh$psgep$liepxl$ekirgmiw$xs$irwyvi$xli$liepxl$erh$wejix}

sj$epp$xlswi$mr$syv$gevi$erh$syv$iqtps}iiw2$[i$evi$kvexijyp$jsv$syv$jvsrxpmri$iqtps}iiw${ls$evi$qeomrk$wegvmjmgiw$hemp}$xs$tvszmhi$gevi

jsv$epp$xlswi$mr$syv$jegmpmxmiw$hyvmrk$xlmw$yrtvigihirxih$kpsfep$terhiqmg2$Mrjsvqexmsr$sr$xli$wxitw${i$lezi$xeoir$xs$ehhviww$erh

qmxmkexi$xli$vmwow$sj$GSZMH15=$ger$fi$jsyrh$ex${{{2kiskvsyt2gsq3GSZMH5=2

Igsrsqmg$Mqtegx

Xli$GSZMH15=$terhiqmg$erh$vipexih$kszivrqirx1mqtswih$qerhexsv}$gpswyviw0$wlipxiv$mr1tpegi$viwxvmgxmsrw$erh$wsgmep$hmwxergmrk

tvsxsgspw lezi$leh0$erh${mpp$gsrxmryi$xs$lezi0$e$wizivi$mqtegx$sr$kpsfep$igsrsqmg$gsrhmxmsrw$erh$xli$irzmvsrqirx$mr${lmgl${i

stivexi2$Wxevxmrk$mr$pexi$Qevgl$erh$ievp}$Etvmp0${i$fiker$xs$sfwivzi$rikexmzi$mqtegxw$jvsq$xli$terhiqmg$sr$syv$tivjsvqergi$mr$syv

wigyvi$wivzmgiw$fywmriww0$wtigmjmgepp}${mxl$syv$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxivw$erh$Y2W2$Qevwlepw$Jegmpmxmiw0$ew$e$viwypx$sj$higpmriw$mr$gvswwmrkw

erh$ettvilirwmsrw$epsrk$xli$Wsyxl{iwx$fsvhiv0$ew${ipp$ew0$e$higviewi$mr$gsyvx$wirxirgmrk$ex$xli$jihivep$pizip${lmgl$mw$i|tigxih$xs$viwypx

mr$er$iwxmqexih$viziryi$higpmri$sj$<$tivgirx$hyvmrk$64642$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$syv$viirxv}$wivzmgiw$fywmriww$gsrhygxih$xlvsykl$syv$KIS$Gevi

fywmriww$wikqirx$lew$epws$fiir$rikexmzip}$mqtegxih0$wtigmjmgepp}$syv$viwmhirxmep$viirxv}$girxivw$erh$rsr1viwmhirxmep$he}$vitsvxmrk

tvskveqw${ivi$mqtegxih$f}$higpmriw$mr$tvskveqw$hyi$xs$ps{iv$pizipw$sj$vijivvepw$f}$jihivep0$wxexi$erh$psgep$ekirgmiw0${lmgl$mw$i|tigxih

xs$viwypx$mr$er$iwxmqexih$viziryi$higpmri$sj$8$tivgirx$hyvmrk$64642$Ehhmxmsrepp}0${i$lezi$i|tivmirgih$xli$xverwqmwwmsr$sj$GSZMH15=$ex

e$wqepp$ryqfiv$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$mr$xli$wigsrh$uyevxiv$sj$64642$Mj${i$evi$yrefpi$xs$qmxmkexi$xli$xverwqmwwmsr$sj$GSZMH15=$ex$syv

jegmpmxmiw${i$gsyph$i|tivmirgi$e$qexivmep$ehzivwi$ijjigx$sr$syv$jmrergmep$tswmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$erh$gewl$jps{w2$Epxlsykl${i$evi

yrefpi$xs$tvihmgx$xli$hyvexmsr$sv$wgsti$sj$xli$GSZMH15=$terhiqmg$sv$iwxmqexi$xli$i|xirx$sj$xli$rikexmzi$jmrergmep$mqtegx$xs$syv

stivexmrk$viwypxw0$er$i|xirhih$tivmsh$sj$hitviwwih$igsrsqmg$egxmzmx}$rigiwwmxexih$xs$gsqfexmrk$xli$hmwiewi0$erh$xli$wizivmx}$erh

hyvexmsr$sj$xli$vipexih$kpsfep$igsrsqmg$gvmwmw${mpp$ehzivwip}$mqtegx$syv$jyxyvi$jmrergmep$tivjsvqergi2

Viziryi

Hyi$xs$xli$yrgivxemrx}$wyvvsyrhmrk$xli$GSZMH15=$terhiqmg0${i$evi$yrefpi$xs$hixivqmri$xli$jyxyvi$perhwgeti$sj$kvs{xl$sttsvxyrmxmiw

mr$xli$riev$xivq?$ls{iziv$er}$tswmxmzi$xvirhw$qe}0$xs$wsqi$i|xirx0$fi$ehzivwip}$mqtegxih$f}$kszivrqirx$fyhkixev}$gsrwxvemrxw$mr$pmklx

sj$xli$terhiqmg$sv$er}$glerkiw$xs$e$kszivrqirx+w${mppmrkriww$xs$qemrxemr$sv$kvs{$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw$mr$xli$jyxyvi2$[lmpi$wxexi

jmrergiw$szivepp${ivi$wxefpi$tvmsv$xs$xli$GSZMH15=$terhiqmg0$jyxyvi$fyhkixev}$tviwwyviw$qe}$geywi$wxexi$ekirgmiw$xs$tyvwyi$e$ryqfiv

sj$gswx$wezmrkw$mrmxmexmziw${lmgl$qe}$mrgpyhi$vihygxmsrw$mr$tiv$hmiq$vexiw$erh3sv$xli$wgsti$sj$wivzmgiw$tvszmhih$f}$tvmzexi$stivexsvw2

Xliwi$tsxirxmep$gswx$wezmrkw$mrmxmexmziw$gsyph$lezi$e$qexivmep$ehzivwi$mqtegx$sr$syv$gyvvirx$stivexmsrw$erh3sv$syv$efmpmx}$xs$tyvwyi$ri{

fywmriww$sttsvxyrmxmiw2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$mj$wxexi$fyhkixev}$gsrwxvemrxw0$ew$hmwgywwih$efszi0$tivwmwx$sv$mrxirwmj}0$syv$wxexi$gywxsqivw×$efmpmx}

xs$te}$yw$qe}$fi$mqtemvih$erh3sv${i$qe}$fi$jsvgih$xs$viriksxmexi$syv$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$sr$piww$jezsvefpi$xivqw$erh$syv$jmrergmep

gsrhmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$sv$gewl$jps{w$gsyph$fi$qexivmepp}$ehzivwip}$mqtegxih2$[i$tper$xs$egxmzip}$fmh$sr$er}$ri{$tvsnigxw$xlex

jmx$syv$xevkix$tvsjmpi$jsv$tvsjmxefmpmx}$erh$stivexmsrep$vmwo2$Er}$tswmxmzi$xvirhw$mr$xli$mrhywxv}$qe}$fi$sjjwix$f}$wizivep$jegxsvw0$mrgpyhmrk

fyhkixev}$gsrwxvemrxw0$gsrxvegx$qshmjmgexmsrw0$gsrxvegx$xivqmrexmsrw0$gsrxvegx$rsr1viri{epw0$erh3sv$gsrxvegx$vi1fmhw$erh$xli$mqtegx$sj

8:

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 68 of 88

Page 344: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq :<3;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

er}$sxliv$tsxirxmep$glerkiw$xs$xli${mppmrkriww$sv$efmpmx}$xs$qemrxemr$sv$kvs{$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw$sr$xli$tevx$sj$sxliv$kszivrqirx

ekirgmiw2$[i$fipmizi${i$lezi$e$wxvsrk$vipexmsrwlmt${mxl$syv$kszivrqirx$ekirg}$tevxrivw$erh${i$fipmizi$xlex${i$stivexi$jegmpmxmiw$xlex

qe|mqm~i$wigyvmx}0$wejix}$erh$ijjmgmirg}${lmpi$sjjivmrk$syv$wymxi$sj$KIS$Gsrxmryyq$sj$Gevi$wivzmgiw$erh$viwsyvgiw2

Epxlsykl${i$lezi$lmwxsvmgepp}$leh$e$vipexmzip}$lmkl$gsrxvegx$viri{ep$vexi0$xlivi$ger$fi$rs$ewwyvergi$xlex${i${mpp$fi$efpi$xs$viri{$syv

i|tmvmrk$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$sr$jezsvefpi$xivqw0$sv$ex$epp2$Epws0${lmpi${i$evi$tpiewih${mxl$syv$xvego$vigsvh$mr$vi1fmh$wmxyexmsrw0${i

gerrsx$ewwyvi$xlex${i${mpp$tvizemp$mr$er}$wygl$jyxyvi$wmxyexmsrw2

Vigirxp}$Gepmjsvrme$iregxih$pikmwpexmsr$emqih$ex$tlewmrk$syx$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmt$gsrxvegxw$jsv$xli$stivexmsr$sj$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw

{mxlmr$Gepmjsvrme$erh$jegmpmxmiw$syxwmhi$sj$xli$wxexi$sj$Gepmjsvrme$lsywmrk$wxexi$sj$Gepmjsvrme$mrqexiw2$Ew$tvizmsywp}$errsyrgih0$syv

gsrxvegx$jsv$syv$Girxvep$Zeppi}$jegmpmx}${ew$epvieh}$hmwgsrxmryih$f}$xli$Gepmjsvrme$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmsrw$erh$Vilefmpmxexmsr$ex$xli

irh$sj$Witxiqfiv$645=2$Syv$gsrxvegx${mxl$xli$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmsrw$erh$Vilefmpmxexmsr$jsv$syv$Hiwivx$Zmi{$jegmpmx}${ew

hmwgsrxmryih$ew$sj$Jifvyev}$6=0$6464$erh${i$i|tigx$xlex$syv$gsrxvegx0$epws${mxl$xli$Gepmjsvrme$Hitevxqirx$sj$Gsvvigxmsrw$erh

Vilefmpmxexmsr0$jsv$syv$Ksphir$Wxexi$jegmpmx}${mpp$fi$hmwgsrxmryih$f}$xli$irh$sj$Qe}$64642

Mrxivrexmsrepp}0${i$evi$i|tpsvmrk$e$ryqfiv$sj$sttsvxyrmxmiw$mr$syv$gyvvirx$qevoixw$erh${mpp$gsrxmryi$xs$egxmzip}$fmh$sr$er}

sttsvxyrmxmiw$xlex$jmx$syv$xevkix$tvsjmpi$jsv$tvsjmxefmpmx}$erh$stivexmsrep$vmwo2$Sr$Qevgl$6=0$645<0${i$errsyrgih$xlex$syv$xverwtsvxexmsr

nsmrx$zirxyvi$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq0$KIS$Eqi}0$wmkrih$e$gsrxvegx${mxl$Wgsxxmwl$Tvmwsr$Wivzmgi$jsv$xli$tvszmwmsr$sj$gsyvx$gywxsh}$erh

iwgsvx$wivzmgiw$mr$Wgsxperh2$Xli$gsrxvegx$lew$e$fewi$xivq$sj$imklx$}ievw$ijjigxmzi$Neryev}$6:0$645=${mxl$e$viri{ep$stxmsr$sj$jsyv$}ievw

erh$mw$i|tigxih$xs$lezi$er$eziveki$erryep$viziryi$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(7=$qmppmsr2$Epws0${i$evi$tpiewih$xs$lezi$fiir$e{evhih$e$xir1}iev

gsrxvegx$viri{ep$jsv$xli$gsrxmryih$hipmziv}$sj$wigyvi$xverwtsvxexmsr$yrhiv$syv$KIS$Eqi}$nsmrx$zirxyvi$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq2$Xsxep

viziryi$sziv$xli$xir1}iev$tivmsh$mw$i|tigxih$xs$fi$ettvs|mqexip}$(;:4$qmppmsr2$Mr$Ri{$Wsyxl$[epiw0$Eywxvepme0${i$evi$hizipstmrk$e

8<=1fih$i|terwmsr$ex$xli$Nyrii$Gsvvigxmsrep$Girxvi${lmgl$mw$i|tigxih$xs$fi$gsqtpixih$hyvmrk$xli$xlmvh$uyevxiv$sj$64642$[i$evi$epws

gsrwxvygxmrk$e$57;1fih$i|terwmsr$ex$xli$Jypleq$Gsvvigxmsrep$Girxvi$mr$Zmgxsvme0$Eywxvepme$epws$i|tigxih$xs$fi$gsqtpixih$hyvmrk$xli

xlmvh$uyevxiv$sj$64642$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$syv$Eywxvepmer$wyfwmhmev}$mw$gyvvirxp}$mr$riksxmexmsr$hmwgywwmsrw${mxl$xli$Wxexi$sj$Zmgxsvme0$Eywxvepme

xs$mrgviewi$xli$getegmx}$ex$syv$Vezirlepp$Gsvvigxmsrep$Girxvi$f}$er$ehhmxmsrep$744$fihw$mrgviewmrk$xli$getegmx}$sj$xli$jegmpmx}$xs$50:44

fihw2$Xli$7441fih$getegmx}$mrgviewi$mw$i|tigxih$xs$kirivexi$mrgviqirxep$erryepm~ih$viziryiw$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(5=$qmppmsr2$[mxl

viwtigx$xs$xli$Tevopie$Gsvvigxmsrep$Girxvi$mr$Eywxvepme0${i${ivi$yrjsvxyrexip}$yrwyggiwwjyp$hyvmrk$xli$gyvvirx$gsqtixmxmzi$vifmh

tvsgiww$erh$xverwmxmsrih$xli$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegx$mr$Qevgl$sj$645=2$Mr$ehhmxmsr0${i$i|tigx$xs$xverwmxmsr$xli$Evxlyv$Ksvvmi$Gsvvigxmsrep

Girxvi$xs$kszivrqirx$stivexmsr$mr$xli$Wxexi$sj$Uyiirwperh0$Eywxvepme$ex$xli$irh$sj$Nyri$64642$$

$

[mxl$viwtigx$xs$syv$viirxv}$wivzmgiw0$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk$wivzmgiw0$erh$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$wivzmgiw$fywmriww$gsrhygxih$xlvsykl$syv

KIS$Gevi$fywmriww$wikqirx0${i$evi$gyvvirxp}$tyvwymrk$e$ryqfiv$sj$fywmriww$hizipstqirx$sttsvxyrmxmiw2$Vipexih$xs$sttsvxyrmxmiw$jsv

gsqqyrmx}1fewih$viirxv}$wivzmgiw0${i$evi${svomrk${mxl$syv$i|mwxmrk$jihivep0$wxexi0$erh$psgep$gpmirxw$xs$piziveki$ri{$sttsvxyrmxmiw$jsv

fsxl$viwmhirxmep$viirxv}$jegmpmxmiw$ew${ipp$ew$rsr1viwmhirxmep$he}$vitsvxmrk$girxivw2$Ls{iziv0$mr$pmklx$sj$xli$yrgivxemrx}$wyvvsyrhmrk$xli

GSZMH15=$terhiqmg0${i$qe}$rsx$fi$wyggiwwjyp2$[i$gsrxmryi$xs$i|tirh$viwsyvgiw$sr$mrjsvqmrk$jihivep0$wxexi$erh$psgep$kszivrqirxw

efsyx$xli$firijmxw$sj$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw0$erh${i$erxmgmtexi$xlex$xlivi${mpp$fi$ri{$sttsvxyrmxmiw$mr$xli$jyxyvi$ew$xlswi$ijjsvxw

gsrxmryi$xs$}miph$viwypxw2$[i$fipmizi${i$evi${ipp$tswmxmsrih$xs$getmxepm~i$sr$er}$wymxefpi$sttsvxyrmxmiw$xlex$figsqi$ezempefpi$mr$xlmw

evie2

Stivexmrk$I|tirwiw

Stivexmrk$i|tirwiw$gsrwmwx$sj$xlswi$i|tirwiw$mrgyvvih$mr$xli$stivexmsr$erh$qerekiqirx$sj$syv$gsrxvegxw$xs$tvszmhi$wivzmgiw$xs$syv

kszivrqirxep$gpmirxw2$Pefsv$erh$vipexih$gswxw$vitviwirxih$9;29)$erh$9;2:)$sj$syv$stivexmrk$i|tirwiw$hyvmrk$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih

Qevgl$750$6464$erh$645=0$viwtigxmzip}2$Ehhmxmsrep$wmkrmjmgerx$stivexmrk$i|tirwiw$mrgpyhi$jssh0$yxmpmxmiw$erh$qihmgep$gswxw2$Hyvmrk$xli

xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$6464$erh$645=0$stivexmrk$i|tirwiw$xsxepih$;:26)$erh$;82<)0$viwtigxmzip}0$sj$syv$gsrwspmhexih

viziryiw2$[i$i|tigx$syv$stivexmrk$i|tirwiw$ew$e$tivgirxeki$sj$viziryiw$mr$6464${mpp$fi$mqtegxih$f}$xli$stirmrk$sj$er}$ri{$sv

i|mwxmrk$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw$ew$e$viwypx$sj$xli$gswx$sj$xverwmxmsrmrk$erh3sv$wxevx1yt$stivexmsrw$vipexih$xs$e$jegmpmx}$stirmrk2$Hyvmrk$64640${i

{mpp$mrgyv$gevv}mrk$gswxw$jsv$jegmpmxmiw$xlex$evi$gyvvirxp}$zegerx2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0${i$lezi$gyvvirxp}$mrgviewih$syv$wtirhmrk$mr$tivwsrep

tvsxigxmzi$iuymtqirx0$hmekrswxmg$xiwxmrk$erh$qihmgep$i|tirwiw$ew$viwypx$sj$GSZMH15=$erh$i|tigx$xs$mrgyv$wizivep$qmppmsrw$sj$hsppevw$mr

wygl$rsr1vigyvvmrk$gswxw$mr$64642

Ew$sj$Qevgl$750$64640$syv${svph{mhi$stivexmsrw$mrgpyhi$xli$qerekiqirx$erh3sv$s{rivwlmt$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$=80444$fihw$ex$56:

jegmpmxmiw0$mrgpyhmrk$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw0$tvsnigxw$yrhiv$hizipstqirx$erh$vigirxp}$e{evhih$gsrxvegxw0$erh$epws$mrgpyhi$xli$tvszmwmsr$sj

gsqqyrmx}$wytivzmwmsr$wivzmgiw$jsv$qsvi$xler$6540444$mrhmzmhyepw0$mrgpyhmrk$ettvs|mqexip}$5440444$xlvsykl$er$evve}$sj$xiglrspsk}

tvshygxw$mrgpyhmrk$vehms$jviuyirg}0$KTW0$erh$epgslsp$qsrmxsvmrk$hizmgiw2

Kirivep$erh$Ehqmrmwxvexmzi$I|tirwiw

Kirivep$erh$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw$gsrwmwx$tvmqevmp}$sj$gsvtsvexi$qerekiqirx$wepevmiw$erh$firijmxw0$tvsjiwwmsrep$jiiw$erh$sxliv

ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw2$Hyvmrk$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$6464$erh$645=0$kirivep$erh$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw$xsxepih$<2=)

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 69 of 88

Page 345: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq :=3;9

erh$;2:)0$viwtigxmzip}0$sj$syv$gsrwspmhexih$viziryiw2$[i$i|tigx$kirivep$erh$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw$ew$e$tivgirxeki$sj$viziryiw$mr

6464$xs$viqemr$gsrwmwxirx$sv$higviewi$ew$e$viwypx$sj$gswx$wezmrkw$mrmxmexmziw2$[i$i|tigx$fywmriww$hizipstqirx$gswxw$xs$viqemr$gsrwmwxirx

sv$mrgviewi$wpmklxp}$ew${i$tyvwyi$ehhmxmsrep$fywmriww$hizipstqirx$sttsvxyrmxmiw$mr$epp$sj$syv$fywmriww$pmriw2$[i$epws$tper$xs$gsrxmryi

i|tirhmrk$viwsyvgiw$jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi$sr$xli$izepyexmsr$sj$tsxirxmep$eguymwmxmsr$xevkixw2

8;

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 70 of 88

Page 346: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq ;43;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

$

Mhpi$Jegmpmxmiw

[i$evi$gyvvirxp}$qevoixmrk$ettvs|mqexip}$50444$zegerx$fihw$ex$sri$sj$syv$KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$erh$sri$sj$syv$KIS$Gevi$mhpi

jegmpmxmiw$xs$tsxirxmep$gywxsqivw2$Xli$erryep$gevv}mrk$gswx$sj$syv$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw$mr$6464$mw$iwxmqexih$xs$fi$(52:$qmppmsr0$mrgpyhmrk

hitvigmexmsr$i|tirwi$sj$(42<$qmppmsr2$Ew$sj$Qevgl$750$64640$xliwi$x{s$jegmpmxmiw$leh$e$rix$fsso$zepyi$sj$(642;$qmppmsr2$[i$gyvvirxp}$hs

rsx$lezi$er}$jmvq$gsqqmxqirx$sv$ekviiqirx$mr$tpegi$xs$egxmzexi$xli$viqemrmrk$jegmpmxmiw2$Lmwxsvmgepp}0$wsqi$jegmpmxmiw$lezi$fiir$mhpi$jsv

qypxmtpi$}ievw$fijsvi$xli}$vigimzih$e$ri{$gsrxvegx$e{evh2$Xliwi$mhpi$jegmpmxmiw$evi$mrgpyhih$mr$xli$KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$erh$KIS$Gevi

wikqirxw2$Xli$tiv$hmiq$vexiw$xlex${i$glevki$syv$gpmirxw$sjxir$zev}$f}$gsrxvegx$egvsww$syv$tsvxjspms2$Ls{iziv0$mj$xli$x{s$viqemrmrk$mhpi

jegmpmxmiw${ivi$xs$fi$egxmzexih$ywmrk$syv$KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$erh$KIS$Gevi$eziveki$tiv$hmiq$vexiw$mr$6464$,gepgypexih$ew$xli$KIS

Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$erh$KIS$Gevi$viziryi$hmzmhih$f}$xli$ryqfiv$sj$KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$erh$KIS$Gevi$qerhe}w-$erh$fewih$sr$xli

eziveki$sggyterg}$vexi$mr$syv$jegmpmxmiw$xlvsykl$Qevgl$750$64640${i${syph$i|tigx$xs$vigimzi$mrgviqirxep$erryepm~ih$viziryi$sj

ettvs|mqexip}$(68$qmppmsr$erh$er$erryepm~ih$mrgviewi$mr$ievrmrkw$tiv$wlevi$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(4247$xs$(424:$tiv$wlevi$fewih$sr$syv

eziveki$stivexmrk$qevkmrw2

8<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 71 of 88

Page 347: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq ;53;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

MXIQ$72$UYERXMXEXMZI$ERH$UYEPMXEXMZI$HMWGPSWYVIW$EFSYX$QEVOIX$VMWO2

Mrxiviwx$Vexi$Vmwo

[i$evi$i|tswih$xs$qevoix$vmwow$vipexih$xs$glerkiw$mr$mrxiviwx$vexiw${mxl$viwtigx$xs$syv$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}2$Te}qirxw$yrhiv$xli$Gvihmx

Jegmpmx}$evi$mrhi|ih$xs$e$zevmefpi$mrxiviwx$vexi2$Fewih$sr$fsvvs{mrkw$syxwxerhmrk$yrhiv$xli$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(506::

qmppmsr$erh$ettvs|mqexip}$(:6$qmppmsr$mr$syxwxerhmrk$pixxivw$sj$gvihmx0$ew$sj$Qevgl$750$64640$jsv$iziv}$sri$tivgirx$mrgviewi$mr$xli

eziveki$mrxiviwx$vexi$ettpmgefpi$xs$xli$Gvihmx$Jegmpmx}0$syv$xsxep$erryep$mrxiviwx$i|tirwi${syph$mrgviewi$f}$ettvs|mqexip}$(57$qmppmsr2

Ehhmxmsrepp}0${i$mrziwx$syv$gewl$mr$e$zevmix}$sj$wlsvx1xivq$jmrergmep$mrwxvyqirxw$xs$tvszmhi$e$vixyvr2$Xliwi$mrwxvyqirxw$kirivepp}$gsrwmwx

sj$lmklp}$pmuymh$mrziwxqirxw${mxl$svmkmrep$qexyvmxmiw$ex$xli$hexi$sj$tyvglewi$sj$xlvii$qsrxlw$sv$piww2$[lmpi$xliwi$mrwxvyqirxw$evi$wyfnigx

xs$mrxiviwx$vexi$vmwo0$e$l}tsxlixmgep$544$fewmw$tsmrx$mrgviewi$sv$higviewi$mr$qevoix$mrxiviwx$vexiw${syph$rsx$lezi$e$qexivmep$mqtegx$sr$syv

jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$sv$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw2

Jsvimkr$Gyvvirg}$I|glerki$Vexi$Vmwo

[i$evi$epws$i|tswih$xs$qevoix$vmwow$vipexih$xs$jpygxyexmsrw$mr$jsvimkr$gyvvirg}$i|glerki$vexiw$fix{iir$xli$Y2W2$hsppev0$erh$xli

Eywxvepmer$hsppev0$xli$Wsyxl$Ejvmger$Verh$erh$xli$Fvmxmwl$Tsyrh$gyvvirg}$i|glerki$vexiw2$Fewih$ytsr$syv$jsvimkr$gyvvirg}$i|glerki

vexi$i|tswyvi$ex$Qevgl$750$64640$iziv}$54$tivgirx$glerki$mr$lmwxsvmgep$gyvvirg}$vexiw${syph$lezi$ettvs|mqexip}$e$(924$qmppmsr$ijjigx

sr$syv$jmrergmep$tswmxmsr$erh$ettvs|mqexip}$e$(42;$qmppmsr$mqtegx$sr$syv$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$hyvmrk$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750

64642

MXIQ$82$GSRXVSPW$ERH$TVSGIHYVIW2

Izepyexmsr$sj$Hmwgpswyvi$Gsrxvspw$erh$Tvsgihyviw2

Syv$qerekiqirx0${mxl$xli$tevxmgmtexmsr$sj$syv$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$erh$syv$Glmij$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv0$lew$izepyexih$xli$ijjigxmziriww

sj$syv$hmwgpswyvi$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw$,ew$wygl$xivq$mw$hijmrih$mr$Vypiw$57e159,i-$erh$59h159,i-$yrhiv$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$I|glerki$Egx

sj$5=780$ew$eqirhih0$vijivvih$xs$ew$xli$I|glerki$Egx-0$ew$sj$xli$irh$sj$xli$tivmsh$gszivih$f}$xlmw$vitsvx2$Sr$xli$fewmw$sj$xlmw$vizmi{0

syv$qerekiqirx0$mrgpyhmrk$syv$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$erh$syv$Glmij$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv0$lew$gsrgpyhih$xlex$ew$sj$xli$irh$sj$xli$tivmsh

gszivih$f}$xlmw$vitsvx0$syv$hmwgpswyvi$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw${ivi$ijjigxmzi$xs$kmzi$viewsrefpi$ewwyvergi$xlex$xli$mrjsvqexmsr$viuymvih

xs$fi$hmwgpswih$mr$syv$vitsvxw$jmpih${mxl$xli$WIG0$yrhiv$xli$I|glerki$Egx$mw$vigsvhih0$tvsgiwwih0$wyqqevm~ih$erh$vitsvxih${mxlmr$xli

xmqi$tivmshw$wtigmjmih$mr$xli$vypiw$erh$jsvqw$sj$xli$WIG0$erh$xs$irwyvi$xlex$xli$mrjsvqexmsr$viuymvih$xs$fi$hmwgpswih$mr$xli$vitsvxw$jmpih

sv$wyfqmxxih$yrhiv$xli$I|glerki$Egx$mw$eggyqypexih$erh$gsqqyrmgexih$xs$syv$qerekiqirx0$mrgpyhmrk$syv$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv

erh$syv$Glmij$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv0$mr$e$qerriv$xlex$epps{w$xmqip}$higmwmsrw$vikevhmrk$viuymvih$hmwgpswyvi2

Mx$wlsyph$fi$rsxih$xlex$xli$ijjigxmziriww$sj$syv$w}wxiq$sj$hmwgpswyvi$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw$mw$wyfnigx$xs$givxemr$pmqmxexmsrw$mrlivirx$mr

er}$w}wxiq$sj$hmwgpswyvi$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw0$mrgpyhmrk$xli$i|ivgmwi$sj$nyhkqirx$mr$hiwmkrmrk0$mqtpiqirxmrk$erh$izepyexmrk$xli

gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw0$xli$ewwyqtxmsrw$ywih$mr$mhirxmj}mrk$xli$pmoipmlssh$sj$jyxyvi$izirxw0$erh$xli$mrefmpmx}$xs$ipmqmrexi$qmwgsrhygx

gsqtpixip}2$Eggsvhmrkp}0$xlivi$ger$fi$rs$ewwyvergi$xlex$syv$hmwgpswyvi$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw${mpp$hixigx$epp$ivvsvw$sv$jveyh2$Ew$e

viwypx0$f}$mxw$rexyvi0$syv$w}wxiq$sj$hmwgpswyvi$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw$ger$tvszmhi$srp}$viewsrefpi$ewwyvergi$vikevhmrk$qerekiqirx×w

gsrxvsp$sfnigxmziw2

Glerkiw$mr$Mrxivrep$Gsrxvsp$Sziv$Jmrergmep$Vitsvxmrk2

Syv$qerekiqirx$mw$viwtsrwmfpi$xs$vitsvx$er}$glerkiw$mr$syv$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$,ew$wygl$xivq$mw$hijmrih$mr$Vypiw

57e159,j-$erh$59h159,j-$yrhiv$xli$I|glerki$Egx-$hyvmrk$xli$tivmsh$xs${lmgl$xlmw$vitsvx$vipexiw$xlex$lezi$qexivmepp}$ejjigxih0$sv$evi

viewsrefp}$pmoip}$xs$qexivmepp}$ejjigx0$syv$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk2$Qerekiqirx$fipmiziw$xlex$xlivi$lezi$rsx$fiir$er}

glerkiw$mr$syv$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$,ew$wygl$xivq$mw$hijmrih$mr$Vypiw$57e159,j-$erh$59h159,j-$yrhiv$xli$I|glerki

Egx-$hyvmrk$xli$tivmsh$xs${lmgl$xlmw$vitsvx$vipexiw$xlex$lezi$qexivmepp}$ejjigxih0$sv$evi$viewsrefp}$pmoip}$xs$qexivmepp}$ejjigx0$syv

mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk2$Xlivi${ivi$rs$wmkrmjmgerx$glerkiw$xs$syv$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$hyvmrk$xli

xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750$64642

8=

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 72 of 88

Page 348: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq ;63;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

TEVX$MM$1$SXLIV$MRJSVQEXMSR

MXIQ$52$PIKEP$TVSGIIHMRKW2

Xli$mrjsvqexmsr$viuymvih$livimr$mw$mrgsvtsvexih$f}$vijivirgi$jvsq$Rsxi$55$1$Gsqqmxqirxw$erh$Gsrxmrkirgmiw$mr$xli$Rsxiw$xs$xli

Yreyhmxih$Gsrwspmhexih$Jmrergmep$Wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$M0$Mxiq$5$sj$xlmw$Uyevxivp}$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541U2

MXIQ$5E2$VMWO$JEGXSVW2

Mxiq$5E$sj$Tevx$M$sj$syv$Erryep$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541O$jsv$xli$}iev$irhih$Higiqfiv$750$645=$,xli$Ô645=$Jsvq$541OÕ-$mrgpyhiw$e

hixempih$hmwgywwmsr$sj$xli$vmwo$jegxsvw$xlex$gsyph$qexivmepp}$ejjigx$syv$fywmriww0$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$sv$jyxyvi$tvswtigxw2$Wix$jsvxl$fips{

mw$er$ehhmxmsrep$vmwo$jegxsv$xs$syv$i|mwxmrk$vmwo$jegxsvw$tvizmsywp}$hmwgpswih$mr$xli$645=$Jsvq$541O2$Xli$mrjsvqexmsr$fips{$wyttpiqirxw

xli$i|mwxmrk$vmwo$jegxsvw$erh$wlsyph$fi$vieh$mr$gsrnyrgxmsr${mxl0$xli$vmwo$jegxsvw$mr$syv$645=$Jsvq$541O2$[i$irgsyveki$}sy$xs$vieh

xliwi$vmwo$jegxsvw$mr$xlimv$irxmvix}2

$

Xli$gyvvirx$terhiqmg$sj$xli$rszip$gsvsrezmvyw0$sv$GSZMH15=0$erh$xli$jyxyvi$syxfvieo$sj$sxliv$lmklp}$mrjigxmsyw$sv$gsrxekmsyw

hmwiewiw0$gsyph$qexivmepp}$erh$ehzivwip}$mqtegx$sv$hmwvytx$syv$fywmriww0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw0$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$pmuymhmx}2

Wmrgi$fimrk$vitsvxih$mr$Higiqfiv$645=0$GSZMH15=$lew$wtvieh$kpsfepp}0$mrgpyhmrk$xs$iziv}$wxexi$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw2$Sr$Qevgl

550$64640$xli$[svph$Liepxl$Svkerm~exmsr$higpevih$GSZMH15=$e$terhiqmg0$erh$sr$Qevgl$570$64640$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw$higpevih$e

rexmsrep$iqivkirg}${mxl$viwtigx$xs$GSZMH15=2

Ew$sj$ievp}$Qe}$64640$e$ji{$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$tvmqevmp}$mr$syv$Iewxivr$vikmsr$lezi$i|tivmirgih$qypxmtpi$gewiw$sj$GSZMH15=$mr

fsxl$syv$wxejj$erh$mrhmzmhyepw$irxvywxih$xs$syv$gevi2$[i$lezi$xeoir$e$ryqfiv$sj$gsqtvilirwmzi$wxitw$erh$qiewyviw$xs$qmxmkexi$xli

xverwqmwwmsr$erh$vmwow$sj$GSZMH15=${lmgl${i$lezi$syxpmrih$mr$xlmw$Jsvq$541U0$mrgpyhmrk$mwwymrk$kymhergi$xs$epp$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw

xlex$mw$gsrwmwxirx${mxl$xli$kymhergi$mwwyih$jsv$gsvvigxmsrep$erh$hixirxmsr$jegmpmxmiw$f}$xli$Girxivw$jsv$Hmwiewi$Gsrxvsp$erh

Tvizirxmsr?$ythexmrk$syv$tspmgmiw$erh$tvsgihyviw$xs$mrgpyhi$fiwx$tvegxmgiw$jsv$xli$tvizirxmsr0$ewwiwwqirx0$erh$qerekiqirx$sj

GSZMH15=0$mrgpyhmrk$xli$mqtpiqirxexmsr$sj$uyeverxmri$erh$gslsvxmrk$tvsgihyviw$xs$mwspexi$gsrjmvqih$erh$tviwyqtxmzi$gewiw$sj

GSZMH15=?$svhivmrk$erh$vigimzmrk$GSZMH15=$w{ef$omxw?$tyvglewmrk$erh$hmwxvmfyxmrk$tivwsrep$tvsxigxmzi$iuymtqirx0$mrgpyhmrk

jegiqewow$xs$epp$wxejj$erh$mrhmzmhyepw$mr$syv$gevi$ex$syv$jegmpmxmiw?$erh$mrgviewmrk$xli$jviuyirg}$sj$hmwxvmfyxmsr$sj$tivwsrep$l}kmiri

tvshygxw0$mrgpyhmrk$wset0$wleqtss$erh$fsh}${ewl$erh$xmwwyi$tetiv2$$Ls{iziv0$xliwi$wxitw$erh$qiewyviw$qe}$tvszi$xs$fi

mrwyjjmgmirx$mr$wxsttmrk$sv$wps{mrk$xli$xverwqmwwmsr$sj$GSZMH15=$erh$xli$vmwow$mx$tswiw$xs$syv$wxejj$erh$mrhmzmhyepw$irxvywxih$xs$syv

gevi2

Givxemr$wxexiw$erh$gmxmiw$mr$xli$Y2W2$lezi$epws$viwtsrhih$xs$GSZMH15=$f}$mrwxmxyxmrk$uyeverxmriw0$viwxvmgxmsrw$sr$xvezip0$Ôwlipxiv$mr

tpegiÕ$vypiw0$erh$viwxvmgxmsrw$sr$x}tiw$sj$fywmriww$xlex$qe}$gsrxmryi$xs$stivexi2$Ew$e$viwypx0$xli$GSZMH15=$terhiqmg$mw$rikexmzip}

mqtegxmrk$epqswx$iziv}$mrhywxv}$hmvigxp}$sv$mrhmvigxp}2$Izir$xlsykl${i$lezi$gsrxmryih$syv$stivexmsrw$ew$er$iwwirxmep$kszivrqirx

wivzmgi$tvszmhiv0$xli$wtvieh$sj$GSZMH15=$lew$viwypxih$mr$ps{iv$sggyterg}$ex$e$ryqfiv$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$erh$tvskveqw$fikmrrmrk$mr

pexi$Qevgl$erh$mw$xlivijsvi$i|tigxih$xs$viwypx$mr$ps{iv$jypp$}iev$viziryiw0$tvmqevmp}$jsv$syv$MGI$erh$Y2W2$Qevwlep$jegmpmxmiw$erh$syv

KIS$Viirxv}$Wivzmgiw$fywmriww2$Syv$MGI$erh$Y2W2$Qevwlepw$jegmpmxmiw$lezi$i|tivmirgih$ps{iv$szivepp$sggyterg}$ew$e$viwypx$sj

higpmriw$mr$gvswwmrkw$erh$ettvilirwmsrw$epsrk$xli$Wsyxl{iwx$fsvhiv0$ew${ipp$ew$e$higviewi$mr$gsyvx$erh$wirxirgmrk$egxmzmx}$ex$xli

jihivep$pizip2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$xli$jihivep$kszivrqirx$vigirxp}$mwwyih$GSZMH15=$stivexmsrep$kymhergi$vigsqqirhmrk$xli$vihygxmsr

xs$;9)$getegmx}$ex$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxivw${livi$tswwmfpi$xs$tvsqsxi$wsgmep$hmwxergmrk$tvegxmgiw2

Xli$GSZMH15=$terhiqmg$lew$leh$vitivgywwmsrw$egvsww$vikmsrep$erh$kpsfep$igsrsqmiw$erh$jmrergmep$qevoixw2$Xli$syxfvieo$sj

GSZMH15=$mr$qer}$gsyrxvmiw0$mrgpyhmrk$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw0$lew$wmkrmjmgerxp}$ehzivwip}$mqtegxih$kpsfep$igsrsqmg$egxmzmx}$erh$lew

gsrxvmfyxih$xs$wmkrmjmgerx$zspexmpmx}$erh$rikexmzi$tviwwyvi$mr$jmrergmep$qevoixw2$Gyvvirxp}0$xli$getmxep$qevoixw$erh$gvihmx$qevoixw

lezi$fiir$hmwvytxih$f}$xli$GSZMH15=$terhiqmg$erh$syv$efmpmx}$xs$sfxemr$er}$ehhmxmsrep$jmrergmrk$sr$jezsvefpi$xivqw0$sv$ex$epp0$mw

rsx$kyeverxiih$erh$pevkip}$hitirhirx$ytsr$izspzmrk$qevoix$gsrhmxmsrw$erh$sxliv$jegxsvw2$$Hitirhmrk$sr$xli$qekrmxyhi$erh

hyvexmsr$sj$xli$GSZMH15=$terhiqmg0$xli$ehzivwi$mqtegx$sj$xli$GSZMH15=$terhiqmg$sr$syv$fywmriww0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw0

jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$pmuymhmx}$gsyph$fi$qexivmep2$$Izir$ejxiv$xli$GSZMH15=$terhiqmg$lew$wyfwmhih0${i$qe}$gsrxmryi$xs

i|tivmirgi$wmkrmjmgerx$ehzivwi$ijjigxw$xs$syv$fywmriww$ew$e$viwypx$sj$mxw$kpsfep$igsrsqmg$mqtegx0$mrgpyhmrk$er}$igsrsqmg$vigiwwmsr

sv$hs{rxyvr$erh$xli$tswwmfmpmx}$xlmw${mpp$viwypx$mr$kszivrqirx$fyhkixev}$gsrwxvemrxw$sv$er}$glerkiw$xs$e$kszivrqirx+w${mppmrkriww

xs$qemrxemr$sv$kvs{$tyfpmg1tvmzexi$tevxrivwlmtw$mr$xli$jyxyvi2

$

$

94

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 73 of 88

Page 349: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq ;73;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

MXIQ$62$YRVIKMWXIVIH$WEPIW$SJ$IUYMX]$WIGYVMXMIW$ERH$YWI$SJ$TVSGIIHW2

$

Tivmsh $

XsxepRyqfivsj$WleviwTyvglewih

,5- $

EzivekiTvmgi

Temh$tivWlevi $ $

XsxepRyqfivsj$WleviwTyvglewihew$Tevx$sjTyfpmgp}

ErrsyrgihTperw$svTvskveqw $ $

Ettvs|mqexiHsppevZepyi$sj

Wleviw$xlexQe}$]ix$FiTyvglewihYrhiv$xliTperw$svTvskveqw,mr$qmppmsrw-

,6- $

Neryev}$50$6464$1$Neryev}$750$6464 $ $ 50;49$ $ ( 5:2:5$ $ $ Ó$ $ ( 5482<$

Jifvyev}$50$6464$1$Jifvyev}$6=0$6464 $ $ Ó$ $ ( Ó$ $ $ Ó$ $ ( 5482<$

Qevgl$50$6464$1$Qevgl$750$6464 $ $ 9970::9$ $ ( 5:256$ $ $ 9970::9$ $ ( =92<$

Xsxep $ $ 99907;4$ $ $ $$ $ $ 9970::9$ $ $ $$

$,5- [i${mxlliph$50;49$wleviw$xlvsykl$rix$wlevi$wixxpiqirxw$xs$wexmwj}$wxexyxsv}$xe|${mxllsphmrk$viuymviqirxw$ytsr$ziwxmrk$sj$wleviw

sj$viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$liph$f}$iqtps}iiw2$Xliwi$tyvglewiw${ivi$rsx$qehi$ew$tevx$sj$e$tyfpmgp}$errsyrgih$tper$sv$tvskveq2

,6- Sr$Jifvyev}$580$645<0${i$errsyrgih$xlex$syv$Fsevh$sj$Hmvigxsvw$eyxlsvm~ih$e$wxsgo$fy}fego$tvskveq$eyxlsvm~mrk$yw$xs

vityvglewi$yt$xs$(64424$qmppmsr$sj$syv$wleviw$sj$gsqqsr$wxsgo2$Xli$tvskveq$mw$ijjigxmzi$xlvsykl$Sgxsfiv$640$64642$Xlivi${ivi

9970::9$wleviw$sj$syv$gsqqsr$wxsgo$vityvglewih$yrhiv$xli$wxsgo$fy}fego$tvskveq$hyvmrk$xli$xlvii$qsrxlw$irhih$Qevgl$750

6464$mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$syv$eqirhih$erh$viwxexih$i|igyxmzi$vixmviqirx$ekviiqirx${mxl$syv$GIS2$Vijiv$xs$Rsxi$57$Ò$Firijmx

Tperw$mr$xli$Rsxiw$xs$xli$Yreyhmxih$Gsrwspmhexih$Jmrergmep$Wxexiqirxw$mrgpyhih$mr$Tevx$M0$Mxiq$5$sj$xlmw$Uyevxivp}$Vitsvx$sr

Jsvq$541U2

MXIQ$72$HIJEYPXW$YTSR$WIRMSV$WIGYVMXMIW2

Rsx$ettpmgefpi2

MXIQ$82$QMRI$WEJIX]$HMWGPSWYVIW

Rsx$ettpmgefpi2

MXIQ$92$SXLIV$MRJSVQEXMSR2

Rsx$ettpmgefpi2

$

95

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 74 of 88

Page 350: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq ;83;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

MXIQ$:2$I\LMFMXW2

$ ,E- I|lmfmxw

$5425

$

Eqirhih$erh$Viwxexih$I|igyxmzi$Vixmviqirx$Ekviiqirx0$hexih$Jifvyev}$6:0$64640$f}$erh$fix{iir$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0

Mrg2$erh$Kisvki$G2$^spi}$,mrgsvtsvexih$f}$vijivirgi$xs$I|lmfmx$5425$xs$xli$Gsqter}×w$vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$<1O$jmpih$sr

Jifvyev}6<0$6464-2$ $ $

5426

$Wirmsv$Sjjmgiv$Iqtps}qirx$Ekviiqirx0$hexih$ew$sj$Neryev}$50$64580$f}$erh$fix{iir$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2$erh$Hezmh

Zirxyvippe2$.$ $ $

$$7525 $ WIGXMSR$746$GIS$Givxmjmgexmsr2$ $

$$7526 $ WIGXMSR$746$GJS$Givxmjmgexmsr2$ $

$$7625 $ WIGXMSR$=4:$GIS$Givxmjmgexmsr2$ $

$$7626 $ WIGXMSR$=4:$GJS$Givxmjmgexmsr2$ $

5452MRW

$Mrpmri$\FVP$Mrwxergi$Hsgyqirx$1$Xli$mrwxergi$hsgyqirx$hsiw$rsx$ettiev$mr$xli$mrxivegxmzi$hexe$jmpi$figeywi$mxw$\FVP

xekw$evi$iqfihhih${mxlmr$xli$Mrpmri$\FVP$hsgyqirx2$ $

5452WGL $ Mrpmri$\FVP$Xe|srsq}$I|xirwmsr$Wgliqe$ $

5452GEP $ Mrpmri$\FVP$Xe|srsq}$I|xirwmsr$Gepgypexmsr$Pmrofewi$ $

5452HIJ $ Mrpmri$\FVP$Xe|srsq}$I|xirwmsr$Hijmrmxmsr$Pmrofewi$ $

5452PEF $ Mrpmri$\FVP$Xe|srsq}$I|xirwmsr$Pefip$Pmrofewi$ $

5452TVI $ Mrpmri$\FVP$Xe|srsq}$I|xirwmsr$Tviwirxexmsr$Pmrofewi$ $ $

548

$Xli$gsziv$teki$jvsq$xli$Gsqter}+w$Uyevxivp}$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541U$jsv$xli$uyevxiv$irhih$Qevgl$750$64640$lew$fiir

jsvqexxih$mr$Mrpmri$\FVP$,mrgpyhih${mxl$xli$I|lmfmx$545$exxeglqirxw-2

$ $ $$$$$$$$$$$. $ Jmpih$livi{mxl2

$$

$

96

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 75 of 88

Page 351: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis154uc646447752lxq

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3OGsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3kis154uc646447752lxq ;93;9

Xefpi$sj$Gsrxirxw

$

WMKREXYVIW

Tyvwyerx$xs$xli$viuymviqirxw$sj$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$I|glerki$Egx$sj$5=780$xli$vikmwxverx$lew$hyp}$geywih$xlmw$vitsvx$xs$fi$wmkrih$sr$mxw

filepj$f}$xli$yrhivwmkrih$xliviyrxs$hyp}$eyxlsvm~ih2

$$ $ $ XLI$KIS$KVSYT0$MRG2

$ $ $ $

Hexi> Qe}$:0$6464 $ 3w3$Fvmer$V2$Izerw

$ $ $ Fvmer$V2$Izerw

$ $ $ Wirmsv$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx$*$Glmij$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv

$ $ $ ,hyp}$eyxlsvm~ih$sjjmgiv$erh$tvmrgmtep$jmrergmep$sjjmgiv-

$

97

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 76 of 88

Page 352: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis1i|546c6772lxq

jmpi>333G>3Ywivw3Ogsrrspp}3EttHexe3Psgep3Xiqt3893{~jigj3kis1i|546c6772lxq 53<

$I\LMFMX$5426

WIRMSV$SJJMGIV$IQTPS]QIRX$EKVIIQIRX

XLMW$WIRMSV$SJJMGIV$IQTPS]QIRX$EKVIIQIRX$,xlmw$&Ekviiqirx&-$ mw$irxivih$ mrxs$ijjigxmzi$ xli5wx$he}$sj$Neryev}0$6458$f}$erh$fix{iir$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2$,xli$&Gsqter}&-$erh$Hezmh$Zirxyvippe$,xli$&$Iqtps}ii&erh0$xskixliv${mxl$xli$Gsqter}0$xli$&Tevxmiw&-2

[LIVIEW0$ xli$ xivqw$ sj$ xlmw$ Ekviiqirx$ lezi$ fiir$ vizmi{ih$ erh$ ettvszih$ f}$ xli$ qiqfivw$ sj$ xliGsqtirwexmsr$Gsqqmxxii$sj$xli$Fsevh$sj$Hmvigxsvw$sj$xli$Gsqter}$,xli$&$Fsevh&-2

RS[$XLIVI$JSVI0$mr$gsrwmhivexmsr$sj$xli$qyxyep$gszirerxw$erh$ekviiqirxw$gsrxemrih$livimr0$erh$jsv$sxlivzepyefpi$gsrwmhivexmsr$xli$vigimtx$erh$ehiuyeg}$sj${lmgl$mw$livif}$egors{pihkih0$xli$Tevxmiw$livif}$ekvii$ew$jspps{w>

52 Tswmxmsr$erh$Hyxmiw2$Xli$Gsqter}$livif}$ekviiw$xs$gsrxmryi$xs$iqtps}$xli$Iqtps}ii$erh$xli$Iqtps}iilivif}$eggitxw$gsrxmryih$iqtps}qirx$erh$ekviiw$xs$gsrxmryi$xs$wivzi$ew$Wirmsv$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx0$Fywmriww$Hizipstqirx$sj$xliGsqter}2$Xli$Iqtps}ii${mpp$tivjsvq$epp$hyxmiw$erh$viwtsrwmfmpmxmiw$erh${mpp$lezi$epp$eyxlsvmx}$mrlivirx$mr$xli$tswmxmsr$sjWirmsv$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx0$Fywmriww$Hizipstqirx2

62 Xivq$sj$Ekviiqirx$erh$Iqtps}qirx2$Xli$ xivq$sj$ xli$Iqtps}ii+w$ iqtps}qirx$yrhiv$xlmw$Ekviiqirx{mpp$ fi$jsv$er$mrmxmep$tivmsh$sj$x{s$,6-$}ievw0$fikmrrmrk$ sr$xli$ ijjigxmzi$ hexi$sj$ xlmw$Ekviiqirx0$ erh$ xivqmrexmrk$ x{s$ }ievwxliviejxiv2$ Xli$xivq$sj$iqtps}qirx$yrhiv$xlmw$Ekviiqirx${mpp$fi$eyxsqexmgepp}$i|xirhih$f}$sri$he}$iziv}$he}$wygl$xlex$mxlew$e$gsrxmrysyw$&vsppmrk&$x{s1}iev$xivq$yrxmp$xli$eki$sj$:;$}ievw0$yrpiww$sxliv{mwi$xivqmrexih$tyvwyerx$xs$Wigxmsr$:$sv$;$sjxlmw$Ekviiqirx2

72 Hijmrmxmsr$ 1$Geywi2$ Jsv$ tyvtswiw$ sj$ xlmw$ Ekviiqirx0$ &Geywi&$ jsv$ xli$ xivqmrexmsr$ sj$ xli$Iqtps}ii+wiqtps}qirx$liviyrhiv$wlepp$fi$hiiqih$xs$i|mwx$mj0$mr$xli$viewsrefpi$nyhkqirx$sj$xli$Gsqter}+w$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$,GIS->,m-$ xli$Iqtps}ii$gsqqmxw$ jveyh0$ xlijx$sv$iqfi~~piqirx$ekemrwx$ xli$Gsqter}$sv$er}$wyfwmhmev}$sv$ejjmpmexi$xlivisj?$ ,mm-$ xliIqtps}ii$ gsqqmxw$ e$ jipsr}$ sv$ e$ gvmqi$ mrzspzmrk$ qsvep$ xyvtmxyhi?$ ,mmm-$ xli$ Iqtps}ii$ fviegliw$ er}$ rsr$$ gsqtixmxmsr0gsrjmhirxmepmx}$sv$rsr1wspmgmxexmsr$ekviiqirx${mxl$xli$Gsqter}$sv$er}$wyfwmhmev}$sv$ejjmpmexi$xlivisj?$,mz-$xli$Iqtps}ii$fviegliwer}$sj$xli$xivqw$sj$xlmw$Ekviiqirx$erh$jempw$xs$gyvi$wygl$fviegl${mxlmr$74$he}w$ejxiv$xli$vigimtx$sj${vmxxir$rsxmgi$sj$wygl$fviegljvsq$xli$Gsqter}?$sv$,z-$xli$Iqtps}ii$irkekiw$mr$kvsww$rikpmkirgi$sv${mppjyp$qmwgsrhygx$xlex$geywiw$levq$ xs$xli$ fywmriwwerh$stivexmsrw$sj$xli$Gsqter}$sv$e$wyfwmhmev}$sv$ejjmpmexi$xlivisj2

82 Gsqtirwexmsr2

$ E2 Erryep$Fewi$Wepev}2$Xli$Iqtps}ii$wlepp$fi$temh$lmw$gyvvirx$erryep$fewi$wepev}$sj$(7690444244jsv$ xli$ viqemrhiv$ sj$ gepirhev$}iev$ 6458$ ,ew$ wygl$ qe}$ fi$ eqirhih$ jvsq$ xmqi$ xs$ xmqi0$ xli&Erryep$ Fewi$ Wepev}&-2$ Xli$ Gsqter}$ qe}$ mrgviewi$ xli$ Erryep$ Fewi$ Wepev}$ temh$ xs$ xliIqtps}ii$mr$er$eqsyrx$xs$fi$hixivqmrih$f}$xli$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$sj$xli$Gsqter}2$XliErryep$ Fewi$ Wepev}$ wlepp$ fi$ te}efpi$ ex$ wygl$ vikypev$xmqiw$ erh$ mrxivzepw$ ew$ xli$ Gsqter}gywxsqevmp}$te}w$mxw$iqtps}iiw$jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi2

$ F2 Erryep$Tivjsvqergi$E{evh2$Jsv$iegl$jmwgep$}iev$sj$iqtps}qirx$hyvmrk${lmgl$xli$Gsqter}iqtps}w$xli$Iqtps}ii0$xli$Iqtps}ii$wlepp$$fi$irxmxpih$xs$vigimzi$e$xevkix$erryep$tivjsvqergie{evh$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$xli$xivqw$sj$er}$tper$kszivrmrk$iqtps}ii$tivjsvqergi$e{evhw$xlirmr$ijjigx$ew$iwxefpmwlih$f}$xli$Fsevh$,xli$&Erryep$Tivjsvqergi$E{evh&-2

$

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 77 of 88

Page 353: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis1i|546c6772lxq

jmpi>333G>3Ywivw3Ogsrrspp}3EttHexe3Psgep3Xiqt3893{~jigj3kis1i|546c6772lxq 63<

$

92 Iqtps}ii$Firijmxw2$Xli$Iqtps}ii$ {mpp$ fi$ irxmxpih$ xs$ x{irx}1sri$ ,65-$ temh1xmqi1$ sjj$ ,TXS-$ he}w$ sjzegexmsr$tiv$jmwgep$}iev$hyvmrk$lmw3liv$jmvwx$xir$,54-$}ievw$sj$wivzmgi0$erh$x{irx}1wm|$,6:-$temh1xmqi1sjj$,TXS-$he}w$sj$zegexmsrtiv$jmwgep$}iev$xliviejxiv2$Xli$Iqtps}ii0$xli$Iqtps}ii+w$wtsywi0$erh$uyepmj}mrk$qiqfivw$sj$xli$Iqtps}ii+w$jeqmp}$${mpp$$fiipmkmfpi$ jsv$ erh${mpp$ tevxmgmtexi$ mr$ er}$ firijmxw$ erh$ tivuymwmxiw$ ezempefpi$ xs$ sxliv$ wirmsv$ zmgi$ tviwmhirxw$ sj$ xli$ Gsqter}0mrgpyhmrk$ er}$kvsyt$liepxl0$ hirxep0$ pmji$ mrwyvergi0$ hmwefmpmx}0$ sv$ sxliv$ $ jsvq$ $ sj$ iqtps}ii$ firijmx$ tper$ sv$ tvskveq$sj$ xliGsqter}$rs{$i|mwxmrk$sv$xlex$qe}$fi$pexiv$ehstxih$f}$xli$Gsqter}$,gsppigxmzip}0$xli$&Iqtps}ii$Firijmxw&-2

:2 Hiexl$sv$Hmwefmpmx}2$Xli$Iqtps}ii+w$iqtps}qirx${mpp$xivqmrexi$mqqihmexip}$ytsr$xli$Iqtps}ii+w$hiexl2Mj$xli$Iqtps}ii$figsqiw$tl}wmgepp}$sv$qirxepp}$hmwefpih$ws$ew$xs$figsqi$yrefpi$jsv$e$tivmsh$sj$qsvi$xler$jmzi$gsrwigyxmziqsrxlw$sv$jsv$wlsvxiv$tivmshw$ekkvikexmrk$ex$ piewx$jmzi$qsrxlw$hyvmrk$er}$ x{ipzi1qsrxl$tivmsh$ xs$tivjsvq$ xli$Iqtps}ii+whyxmiw$liviyrhiv$sr$e$wyfwxerxmepp}$jypp1xmqi$fewmw0$xli$Iqtps}ii+w$iqtps}qirx${mpp$xivqmrexi$ew$sj$xli$irh$sj$wygl$jmzi1qsrxl$svx{ipzi1qsrxl$tivmsh$erh$xlmw$wlepp$fi$gsrwmhivih$e$&$hmwefmpmx}&$yrhiv$ xlmw$Ekviiqirx2$ Wygl$ xivqmrexmsr$ wlepp$ rsx$ ejjigx$ xliIqtps}ii+w$firijmxw$yrhiv$xli$Gsqter}+w$hmwefmpmx}$mrwyvergi$tvskveq0$mj$er}0$xlir$mr$ijjigx2

;2 Xivqmrexmsr2$Imxliv$xli$Iqtps}ii$sv$xli$Gsqter}$qe}$xivqmrexi$xlmw$Ekviiqirx$jsv$er}$viewsr$ytsr$rsxpiww$xler$xlmvx}$,74-$he}w${vmxxir$rsxmgi2

$ E2 Xivqmrexmsr$ sj$ Iqtps}qirx$ [mxlsyx$ Geywi$ sv$ Ytsr$ xli$ Hiexl$ sv$ Hmwefmpmx}$ sj$ xli

Iqtps}ii2$Ytsr$xli$xivqmrexmsr$sj$xli$Iqtps}ii+w$iqtps}qirx$yrhiv$xlmw$Ekviiqirx$f}$xliGsqter}${mxlsyx$Geywi$sv$xli$hiexl$sv$hmwefmpmx}$sj$xli$Iqtps}ii0$xli$jspps{mrk$wlepp$ettp}>

$ ,m- Xivqmrexmsr$ Te}qirx2$Xli$Iqtps}ii$ wlepp$ fi$ irxmxpih$ xs$ erh$ temh$ e$ xivqmrexmsrte}qirx$,xli$&Xivqmrexmsr$Te}qirx&-$iuyep$xs$x{s$,6-$}ievw+$Erryep$Fewi$Wepev}$ewwix$ jsvxl$ mr$ Wigxmsr$ 8$ fewih$ ytsr$ xli$ xlir$ gyvvirx$ wepev}$ pizip2$ Xli$ XivqmrexmsrTe}qirx$ wlepp$ fi$qehi${mxlmr$54$he}w$sj$ er}$ xivqmrexmsr$ tyvwyerx$ xs$ xlmw$ Wigxmsr;,E-2

$ ,mm- Xivqmrexmsr$Firijmxw2$Xli$Gsqter}$wlepp$gsrxmryi$xs$tvszmhi$xli$Iqtps}ii$erh$er}gszivih$ hitirhirxw$ sj$ xli$Iqtps}ii$ ,erh$ mj$ ettpmgefpi0$ lmw$ firijmgmevmiw-$ {mxl$ xliIqtps}ii$Firijmxw$,ew$hiwgvmfih$mr$Wigxmsr$9$livisj-$jsv$e$tivmsh$sj$6$}ievw$ejxiv$xlihexi$ sj$ xivqmrexmsr$ sj$ xli$ Iqtps}ii+w$ iqtps}qirx$ {mxl$ xli$ Gsqter}2$ WyglIqtps}ii$Firijmxw$wlepp$fi$tvszmhih$ex$rs$gswx$xs$xli$Iqtps}ii$mr$rs$ piww$ xler$ xliweqi$eqsyrx0$erh$sr$xli$weqi$xivqw$erh$gsrhmxmsrw0$ew$mr$ijjigx$sr$xli$hexi$sr${lmglxli$xivqmrexmsr$sj$iqtps}qirx$sggyvw2$Mj$xli$Iqtps}ii$hmiw$hyvmrk$xli$61}iev$tivmshjspps{mrk$e$xivqmrexmsr$tyvwyerx$xs$xlmw$Wigxmsr$;,E-0$$xli$Gsqter}$wlepp$gsrxmryi$xstvszmhi$xli$Iqtps}ii$Firijmxw$xs$xli$Iqtps}ii+w$gszivih$hitirhirxw$yrhiv$xli$weqixivqw$ ew$ {ivi$ fimrk$ tvszmhih$ tvmsv$ xs$ xli$ Iqtps}ii+w$ hiexl$ erh0$ xs$ xli$ i|xirxettpmgefpi0$xs$xli$Iqtps}ii+w$iwxexi2

6

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 78 of 88

Page 354: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis1i|546c6772lxq

jmpi>333G>3Ywivw3Ogsrrspp}3EttHexe3Psgep3Xiqt3893{~jigj3kis1i|546c6772lxq 73<

$

$ ,mmm- Xivqmrexmsr$Eyxsqsfmpi2$[mxlmr$54$he}w$jspps{mrk$xivqmrexmsr0$xli$Gsqter}$wleppxverwjiv$epp$sj$ mxw$ mrxiviwx$ mr$er}$eyxsqsfmpi$ $ ywih$f}$ xli$Iqtps}ii$tyvwyerx$ xs$ xliGsqter}+w$Iqtps}ii$Eyxsqsfmpi$Tspmg}$ ,xli$ &Iqtps}ii$Eyxsqsfmpi$ Tspmg}&-$ erhwlepp$te}$xli$fepergi$sj$er}$syxwxerhmrk$pserw$sv$piewiw$sr$wygl$eyxsqsfmpi$,{lixlivwygl$sfpmkexmsrw$evi$ xlswi$sj$ xli$Iqtps}ii$sv$ xli$Gsqter}-$ws$ xlex$ xli$Iqtps}iis{rw$xli$eyxsqsfmpi$syxvmklx$,mr$xli$izirx$wygl$eyxsqsfmpi$ mw$ piewih0$ xli$Gsqter}wlepp$te}$xli$viwmhyep$gswx$sj$wygl$piewi-2

$ ,mz- Xivqmrexmsr$Wxsgo$Stxmsrw$erh$Viwxvmgxih$Wxsgo2$Epp$sj$xli$syxwxerhmrk$yrziwxihwxsgo$stxmsrw$erh$viwxvmgxih$wxsgo$kverxih$ xs$ xli$Iqtps}ii$tvmsv$ xs$ xivqmrexmsr${mppjypp}$ziwx$mqqihmexip}$ytsr$xivqmrexmsr0$tvszmhih$ls{iziv0$xlex$er}$viwxvmgxih$wxsgoxlex$mw$wxmpp$wyfnigx$xs$tivjsvqergi$fewih$ziwxmrk$ex$xli$xmqi$sj$wygl$xivqmrexmsr$wleppsrp}$ziwx${lir$erh$xs$xli$i|xirx$xli$Gsqtirwexmsr$Gsqqmxxii$sj$xli$Fsevh$givxmjmiwxlex$xli$tivjsvqergi$ksepw$evi$egxyepp}$qix2

$ F2 Xivqmrexmsr$ sj$ Iqtps}qirx$ f}$ Viwmkrexmsr$ sj$ Iqtps}ii$ sv$ f}$ xli$ Gsqter}$ [mxl

Geywi2$Ytsr$xli$xivqmrexmsr$sj$xli$Iqtps}ii+w$iqtps}qirx$f}$ xli$ zspyrxev}$ viwmkrexmsr$ sjxli$ Iqtps}ii$ sv$ f}$ xli$ Gsqter}$ {mxl$ Geywi0$ xli$ Iqtps}ii$ wlepp$ fi$ hyi$ rs$ jyvxlivgsqtirwexmsr$ yrhiv$ xlmw$ Ekviiqirx$ vipexih$ xs$ Erryep$ Fewi$ Wepev}0$ Erryep$ TivjsvqergiE{evh0$Iqtps}ii$Firijmxw0$sv$Xivqmrexmsr$Te}qirx$sxliv$xler$${lex$mw$hyi$erh$s{mrk$xlvsyklxli$ijjigxmzi$hexi$sj$xli$Iqtps}ii+w$viwmkrexmsr$sv$xivqmrexmsr2

$ G2 Vixmviqirx$Tper$Vmklxw$Yrejjigxih2$Xivqmrexmsr$ sj$ xli$Iqtps}ii+w$ iqtps}qirx$ yrhiv$ xlmwEkviiqirx$ jsv$ er}$ viewsr0$ {lexwsiziv0$ wlepp$ rsx$ ejjigx$ xli$ Iqtps}ii+w$ vmklxw$ yrhiv$ xliGsqter}+w$vixmviqirx$tper$ettpmgefpi$xs$xli$Iqtps}ii2

<2 Viwxvmgxmzi$Gszirerxw2

$ E2 Kirivep2$ Xli$ Gsqter}$ erh$ xli$ Iqtps}ii$ livif}$ egors{pihki$ erh$ ekvii$ xlex$ ,m-$ xliIqtps}ii$ mw$ mr$ tswwiwwmsr$ sj$ xvehi$ wigvixw$ ,ew$ hijmrih$ mr$Wigxmsr$ :<<2446,8-$ sj$ xli$ JpsvmheWxexyxiw-$sj$xli$Gsqter}$,xli$&Xvehi$Wigvixw&-0$,mm-$ xli$ viwxvmgxmzi$gszirerxw$ gsrxemrih$ mr$ xlmwWigxmsr$ <$ evi$ nywxmjmih$f}$ pikmxmqexi$ fywmriww$ mrxiviwxw$ sj$ xli$ Gsqter}0$ mrgpyhmrk0$ $ fyx$ rsxpmqmxih$xs0$xli$tvsxigxmsr$sj$xli$Xvehi$Wigvixw$0$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$Wigxmsr$9862779,5-,i-$sj$xliJpsvmhe$Wxexyxiw0$erh$,mmm-$xli$viwxvmgxmzi$gszirerxw$gsrxemrih$mr$xlmw$Wigxmsr$<$evi$ viewsrefp}rigiwwev}$xs$tvsxigx$wygl$pikmxmqexi$fywmriww$mrxiviwxw$sj$xli$Gsqter}2

$ F2 Rsr$Gsqtixmxmsr2$Hyvmrk$xli$tivmsh$sj$xli$$Iqtps}ii+$w$$iqtps}qirx${mxl$xli$Gsqter}$erhyrxmp$x{s$,6-$}ievw$ejxiv$xli$xivqmrexmsr$sj$xli$Iqtps}ii+w$iqtps}qirx${mxl$xli$Gsqter}0$xliIqtps}ii${mpp$ rsx0$ hmvigxp}$ sv$ mrhmvigxp}0$ imxliv$ ,m-$ sr$ xli$Iqtps}ii+$ w$ s{r$ filepj$ sv$ ew$ etevxriv0$sjjmgiv0$hmvigxsv0$xvywxii0$iqtps}ii0$ekirx0$$gsrwypxerx$$sv$qiqfiv$sj$er}$tivwsr0$jmvqsv$gsvtsvexmsr0$sv$sxliv{mwi0$irxiv$mrxs$xli$iqtps}$sj0$virhiv$er}$wivzmgi$ xs0$sv$irkeki$mr$ er}fywmriww$ sv$ egxmzmx}$ {lmgl$ mw$ xli$ weqi$ ew$ sv$ gsqtixmxmzi$ {mxl$ er}$ fywmriww$ sv$ egxmzmx}gsrhygxih$f}$xli$Gsqter}$sv$er}$sj$mxw$ejjmpmexiw$sv$qensvmx}1s{rih$wyfwmhmevmiw$sv$,mm-$figsqier$sjjmgiv0$ iqtps}ii$ sv$ gsrwypxerx$ sj0$ sv$ sxliv{mwi$ ewwyqi$ e$ wyfwxerxmep$ vspi$sv$ vipexmsrwlmt{mxl0$er}$kszivrqirxep$irxmx}0$ekirg}$sv$tspmxmgep$wyfhmzmwmsr$xlex$mw$e$gpmirx$sv$gywxsqiv$sj$xliGsqter}$sv$er}

7

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 79 of 88

Page 355: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis1i|546c6772lxq

jmpi>333G>3Ywivw3Ogsrrspp}3EttHexe3Psgep3Xiqt3893{~jigj3kis1i|546c6772lxq 83<

$

$ wyfwmhmev}$ sv$ ejjmpmexi$ sj$ xli$ Gsqter}?$ tvszmhih0$ ls{iziv0$ xlex$ xli$ jsviksmrk$ wlepp$ rsx$ fihiiqih$xs$tvizirx$xli$Iqtps}ii$jvsq$mrziwxmrk$mr$wigyvmxmiw$sj$er}$gsqter}$lezmrk$e$gpeww$sjwigyvmxmiw$ {lmgl$ mw$ tyfpmgp}$ xvehih0$ ws$ psrk$ ew$ xlvsykl$ wygl$ mrziwxqirx$ lsphmrkw$ mr$ xliekkvikexi0$xli$Iqtps}ii$mw$rsx$hiiqih$xs$fi$xli$firijmgmep$s{riv$sj$qsvi$xler$9)$sj$xli$gpewwsj$wigyvmxmiw$xlex$mw$ws$tyfpmgp}$xvehih2$Hyvmrk$xli$tivmsh$sj$ xli$Iqtps}ii+$w$ iqtps}qirx$ erhyrxmp$x{s$,6-$}ievw$ejxiv$xli$xivqmrexmsr$$sj$$xli$Iqtps}ii+$w$iqtps}qirx0$ xli$Iqtps}ii${mpprsx0$hmvigxp}$sv$ mrhmvigxp}0$sr$ xli$Iqtps}ii+$w$s{r$filepj$ sv$ ew$ e$ tevxriv0$ wlevilsphiv0$sjjmgiv0iqtps}ii0$hmvigxsv0$xvywxii0$ekirx0$gsrwypxerx$sv$qiqfiv$sj$er}$$tivwsr0$jmvq$sv$gsvtsvexmsr$svsxliv{mwi0$wiio$xs$iqtps}$sv$sxliv{mwi$wiio$xli$wivzmgiw$sj$er}$iqtps}ii$sj$xli$Gsqter}$sver}$sj$mxw$ejjmpmexiw$sv$qensvmx}1s{rih$wyfwmhmevmiw2

$ G2 Gsrjmhirxmepmx}2$Hyvmrk$ erh$ jspps{mrk$ xli$ tivmsh$ sj$ xli$ Iqtps}ii+$ w$ iqtps}qirx$ {mxl$ xliGsqter}0$xli$Iqtps}ii${mpp$rsx$ywi$jsv$xli$Iqtps}ii+w$s{r$firijmx$sv$jsv$xli$firijmx$sj$sxlivw0sv$ hmzypki$ xs$ sxlivw0$ er}$ mrjsvqexmsr0$ Xvehi$ Wigvixw0$ ors{pihki$ sv$ hexe$ sj$ e$ wigvix$ svgsrjmhirxmep$rexyvi$erh$sxliv{mwi$rsx$ezempefpi$xs$qiqfivw$sj$xli$kirivep$ tyfpmg$ xlex$ gsrgivrwxli$fywmriww$sv$ejjemvw$sj$xli$Gsqter}$sv$mxw$wyfwmhmevmiw$sv$ejjmpmexiw$erh${lmgl${ew$eguymvihf}$xli$Iqtps}ii$ex$er}$xmqi$tvmsv$xs$sv$hyvmrk$xli$xivq$sj$xli$Iqtps}ii+$w$iqtps}qirx${mxl$xliGsqter}0$i|gitx${mxl$xli$wtigmjmg$tvmsv${vmxxir$gsrwirx$sj$xli$Gsqter}2

$ H2 [svo$Tvshygx2$Xli$Iqtps}ii$ekviiw$xlex$epp$tvskveqw0$mrzirxmsrw0$mrrszexmsrw0$mqtvsziqirxwhizipstqirxw$qixlshw0$hiwmkrw0$erep}wiw0$ vitsvxw$erh$epp$wmqmpev$ sv$ vipexih$ mrjsvqexmsr$ {lmglvipexi$xs$xli$fywmriww$sj$xli$Gsqter}$erh$mxw$wyfwmhmevmiw$erh$ejjmpmexiw0$egxyep$sv$erxmgmtexih0$svxs$ er}$ egxyep$ sv$ erxmgmtexih$ viwievgl$ erh$ hizipstqirx$ gsrhygxih$ mr$ gsrrigxmsr$ {mxl$ xlifywmriww$sj$xli$Gsqter}$erh$mxw$$wyfwmhmevmiw$ejjmpmexiw0$erh$epp$i|mwxmrk$sv$jyxyvi$tvshygxw$svwivzmgiw0${lmgl$ evi$ gsrgimzih0$hizipstih$ sv$ qehi$ f}$ xli$ Iqtps}ii$ ,epsri$ sv$ {mxl$ sxlivw-hyvmrk$xli$ xivq$sj$xlmw$Ekviiqirx$ ,&[svo$Tvshygx&-$fipsrk$ xs$ xli$Gsqter}2$Xli$Iqtps}ii{mpp$gsstivexi$jypp}$mr$xli$iwxefpmwlqirx$erh$qemrxirergi$sj$epp$vmklxw$sj$xli$Gsqter}$erh$mxwwyfwmhmevmiw$ erh$ ejjmpmexiw$ mr$ wygl$[svo$ Tvshygx2$ Xli$ tvszmwmsrw$ sj$ xlmw$ Wigxmsr$ <,H-$ {mppwyvzmzi$xivqmrexmsr$sj$xlmw$Ekviiqirx$mrhijmrmxip}$xs$xli$i|xirx$rigiwwev}$xs$viuymvi$egxmsrw$xsfi$xeoir$f}$xli$Iqtps}ii$ejxiv$xli$xivqmrexmsr$sj$xli$Ekviiqirx${mxl$viwtigx$xs$[svo$Tvshygxgviexih$hyvmrk$xli$xivq$sj$xlmw$Ekviiqirx2

$ I2 Irjsvgiqirx2$Xli$Tevxmiw$ekvii$erh$egors{pihki$xlex$xli$viwxvmgxmsrw$gsrxemrih$mr$xlmw$Wigxmsr<$evi$viewsrefpi$mr$wgsti$erh$hyvexmsr$erh$evi$rigiwwev}$xs$tvsxigx$xli$Gsqter}$sv$er}$sj$mxwwyfwmhmevmiw$sv$ejjmpmexiw2$Mj$er}$gszirerx$sv$ekviiqirx$gsrxemrih$mr$xlmw$Wigxmsr$<$mw$jsyrh$f}$egsyvx$ lezmrk$ nyvmwhmgxmsr$ xs$ fi$ yrviewsrefpi$ mr$ hyvexmsr0$ kiskvetlmgep$ wgsti$ sv$ glevegxiv$ sjviwxvmgxmsr0$xli$gszirerx$sv$ekviiqirx${mpp$rsx$fi$virhivih$yrirjsvgiefpi$xlivif}$fyx$vexliv$xlihyvexmsr0$kiskvetlmgep$wgsti$sv$glevegxiv$sj$viwxvmgxmsr$sj$wygl$gszirerx$sv$ekviiqirx${mpp$fivihygih$sv$qshmjmih${mxl$ vixvsegxmzi$ ijjigx$ xs$qeoi$ wygl$ gszirerx$sv$ ekviiqirx$ viewsrefpi0erh$wygl$gszirerx$sv$ekviiqirx${mpp$ fi$ irjsvgih$ ew$ ws$qshmjmih2$Xli$Iqtps}ii$ ekviiw$ erhegors{pihkiw$xlex$xli$fviegl$sj$xlmw$Wigxmsr$<${mpp$geywi$mvvitevefpi$mrnyv}$xs$xli$Gsqter}$sver}$sj$mxw$wyfwmhmevmiw$sv$ejjmpmexiw$erh$ytsr$xli$fviegl$sj$er}$tvszmwmsr$sj$xlmw$Wigxmsr$<0$xliGsqter}$sv$ er}$sj$ mxw$ wyfwmhmevmiw$sv$ ejjmpmexiw$ wlepp$ fi$ irxmxpih$ xs$ mrnyrgxmzi$ vipmij0$ wtigmjmgtivjsvqergi$sv$sxliv$iuymxefpi$vipmij0${mxlsyx$fimrk$viuymvih$xs$tswx$e$fsrh?$tvszmhih0$$ls{iziv0xlex0$xlmw$wlepp$$mr$rs${e}$pmqmx$er}$sxliv

8

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 80 of 88

Page 356: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis1i|546c6772lxq

jmpi>333G>3Ywivw3Ogsrrspp}3EttHexe3Psgep3Xiqt3893{~jigj3kis1i|546c6772lxq 93<

$

$ viqihmiw$ {lmgl$ xli$ Gsqter}$ sv$ er}$ sj$ mxw$ wyfwmhmevmiw$ sv$ ejjmpmexiw$ qe}$ lezi$ ,mrgpyhmrk0{mxlsyx$pmqmxexmsr0$xli$vmklx$xs$wiio$qsrixev}$heqekiw-2

=2 Vitviwirxexmsrw2$Xli$Iqtps}ii$livif}$vitviwirxw$erh${evverxw$xs$xli$Gsqter}$xlex$,m-$ xli$i|igyxmsr0hipmziv}$erh$jypp$tivjsvqergi$sj$xlmw$Ekviiqirx$f}$xli$Iqtps}ii$hsiw$rsx$erh${mpp$rsx$gsrjpmgx${mxl0$fviegl0$zmspexi$sv$geywie$hijeypx$yrhiv$er}$ekviiqirx0$gsrxvegx$sv$mrwxvyqirx$xs${lmgl$xli$Iqtps}ii$mw$e$tevx}$sv$er}$nyhkqirx0$svhiv$sv$higvii$xs{lmgl$ xli$ Iqtps}ii$ mw$ wyfnigx?$ ,mm-$ xli$ Iqtps}ii$ mw$ rsx$ e$ tevx}$ sv$ fsyrh$ f}$ er}$ iqtps}qirx$ ekviiqirx0$ gsrwypxmrkekviiqirx0$ekviiqirx$rsx$xs$gsqtixi0$gsrjmhirxmepmx}$ekviiqirx$sv$wmqmpev$ekviiqirx${mxl$er}$sxliv$tivwsr$sv$irxmx}?$erh$,mmm-ytsr$ xli$ i|igyxmsr$ erh$ hipmziv}$ sj$ xlmw$ Ekviiqirx$ f}$ xli$ Iqtps}ii$ erh$ xli$ Gsqter}0$ xlmw$ Ekviiqirx$ {mpp$ fi$ xliIqtps}ii+w$zepmh$erh$fmrhmrk$sfpmkexmsr0$irjsvgiefpi$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$mxw$xivqw2

542 Evfmxvexmsr2$Mr$xli$izirx$sj$er}$hmwtyxi$fix{iir$xli$Gsqter}$erh$ xli$Iqtps}ii${mxl$viwtigx$xs$ xlmwEkviiqirx0$imxliv$tevx}$qe}0$mr$mxw$wspi$hmwgvixmsr$f}$rsxmgi$xs$xli$sxliv0$viuymvi$wygl$hmwtyxi$xs$fi$wyfqmxxih$xs$evfmxvexmsr2Xli$evfmxvexsv${mpp$fi$wipigxih$f}$ekviiqirx$sj$xli$Tevxmiw$sv0$mj$ xli}$gerrsx$ekvii$sr$er$evfmxvexsv$sv$evfmxvexsvw${mxlmr$74he}w$ ejxiv$ xli$ kmzmrk$ sj$ wygl$ rsxmgi0$ xli$ evfmxvexsv$ {mpp$ fi$ wipigxih$ f}$ xli$ Eqivmger$ Evfmxvexmsr$ Ewwsgmexmsr2$ $ Xlihixivqmrexmsr$vieglih$mr$wygl$evfmxvexmsr${mpp$fi$jmrep$erh$fmrhmrk$sr$fsxl$Tevxmiw${mxlsyx$er}$vmklx$sj$ettiep2$I|igyxmsr$sjxli$hixivqmrexmsr$f}$wygl$evfmxvexsv$qe}$fi$wsyklx$mr$er}$gsyvx$lezmrk$nyvmwhmgxmsr2$Yrpiww$sxliv{mwi$ekviih$f}$xli$Tevxmiw0er}$wygl$evfmxvexmsr${mpp$xeoi$tpegi$mr$[iwx$Tepq$Fiegl0$Jpsvmhe$erh${mpp$fi$gsrhygxih$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$xli$vypiw$sj$xliEqivmger$Evfmxvexmsr$ Ewwsgmexmsr2$ Mj$ xli$ Iqtps}ii$ mw$ xli$ tvizempmrk$ tevx}$ mr$ er}$ wygl$ evfmxvexmsr0$ li$ {mpp$ fi$ irxmxpih$ xsvimqfyvwiqirx$f}$xli$Gsqter}$sj$epp$viewsrefpi$gswxw$erh$i|tirwiw$,mrgpyhmrk$exxsvri}w+$jiiw$mrgyvvih$mr$wygl$evfmxvexmsr-2

552 Ewwmkrqirx2$Xli$Iqtps}ii$qe}$rsx$ewwmkr0$ xverwjiv0$gsrzi}0$qsvxkeki0$l}tsxligexi0$ tpihki$sv$ mr$ er}{e}$irgyqfiv$ xli$ gsqtirwexmsr$ sv$ sxliv$ firijmxw$te}efpi$ xs$ xli$Iqtps}ii$ sv$ er}$ vmklxw${lmgl$ xli$Iqtps}ii$qe}$leziyrhiv$xlmw$Ekviiqirx2$Rimxliv$xli$Iqtps}ii$rsv$xli$Iqtps}ii+w$firijmgmev}$sv$firijmgmevmiw${mpp$lezi$er}$vmklx$xs$vigimzier}$gsqtirwexmsr$sv$sxliv$firijmxw$yrhiv$xlmw$Ekviiqirx0$i|gitx$ex$xli$xmqi0$mr$xli$eqsyrxw$erh$mr$xli$qerriv$tvszmhih$mrxlmw$Ekviiqirx2$Xlmw$Ekviiqirx${mpp$mryvi$xs$xli$firijmx$sj$erh${mpp$fi$fmrhmrk$ytsr$er}$wyggiwwsv$xs$xli$Gsqter}0$erh$er}wyggiwwsv$xs$xli$Gsqter}$wlepp$fi$eyxlsvm~ih$xs$irjsvgi$xli$xivqw$erh$gsrhmxmsrw$sj$xlmw$Ekviiqirx0$mrgpyhmrk$xli$xivqw$erhgsrhmxmsrw$sj$xli$viwxvmgxmzi$gszirerxw$gsrxemrih$mr$Wigxmsr$<$livisj2$Ew$ywih$mr$xlmw$Ekviiqirx0$xli$xivq$&wyggiwwsv&$qierwer}$tivwsr0$jmvq0$gsvtsvexmsr$sv$sxliv$fywmriww$irxmx}${lmgl$ex$er}$xmqi0${lixliv$f}$qivkiv0$tyvglewi$sv$sxliv{mwi0$eguymviwepp$sv$wyfwxerxmepp}$epp$sj$xli$getmxep$wxsgo$sv$ewwixw$sj$xli$Gsqter}2$Xlmw$Ekviiqirx$qe}$rsx$sxliv{mwi$fi$ewwmkrih$f}$xliGsqter}2

562 Kszivrmrk$Pe{2$Xlmw$Ekviiqirx$wlepp$fi$kszivrih$f}$xli$pe{w$sj$xli$Wxexi$sj$Jpsvmhe${mxlsyx$vikevh$xsxli$ettpmgexmsr$sj$gsrjpmgxw$sj$pe{w2

572 Irxmvi$Ekviiqirx2$ Xlmw$Ekviiqirx$ gsrwxmxyxiw$ xli$srp}$ekviiqirx$ fix{iir$ xli$ Gsqter}$ erh$ xliIqtps}ii$vikevhmrk$xli$Iqtps}ii+w$iqtps}qirx$f}$xli$Gsqter}2$Xlmw$Ekviiqirx$wytivwihiw$er}$erh$epp$sxliv$ekviiqirxw$erhyrhivwxerhmrkw0${vmxxir$sv$svep0$fix{iir$ xli$Gsqter}$erh$ xli$Iqtps}ii$vikevhmrk$xli$wyfnigx$qexxiv$ livisj$ erh$ xlivisj2$E{emziv$f}$imxliv$tevx}$sj$er}$tvszmwmsr$sj$xlmw$Ekviiqirx$sv$er}$fviegl$sj$wygl$tvszmwmsr$mr$er$mrwxergi${mpp$rsx$fi$hiiqih$svgsrwxvyih$xs$fi$e${emziv$sj$wygl$tvszmwmsr$jsv$xli$jyxyvi0$sv$sj$er}$wyfwiuyirx$fviegl$sj$wygl$tvszmwmsr2$Xlmw$Ekviiqirx$qe}fi$eqirhih0$qshmjmih$sv$glerkih$srp}$f}$jyvxliv${vmxxir$ekviiqirx$fix{iir$xli$Gsqter}$erh$xli$Iqtps}ii0$hyp}$i|igyxihf}$fsxl$Tevxmiw2

582 Wizivefmpmx}?$Wyvzmzep2$Mr$ xli$ izirx$ xlex$ er}$tvszmwmsr$ sj$ $ xlmw$ $Ekviiqirx$ $ mw$ jsyrh$ xs$ fi$ zsmh$ erhyrirjsvgiefpi$f}$e$gsyvx$sj$gsqtixirx$nyvmwhmgxmsr0$xlir$wygl$yrirjsvgiefpi$tvszmwmsr$wlepp$fi$hiiqih$qshmjmih$ws$ew$xs$fiirjsvgiefpi$ ,sv$ mj$ rsx$ wyfnigx$ xs$qshmjmgexmsr$ xlir$ ipmqmrexih$ livijvsq-$ xs$ xli$ i|xirx$rigiwwev}$ xs$tivqmx$ xli$ viqemrmrktvszmwmsrw$xs$fi$irjsvgih$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$xli$Tevxmiw+$mrxirxmsr2

9

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 81 of 88

Page 357: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis1i|546c6772lxq

jmpi>333G>3Ywivw3Ogsrrspp}3EttHexe3Psgep3Xiqt3893{~jigj3kis1i|546c6772lxq :3<

$

Xli$tvszmwmsrw$sj$Wigxmsr$<$,erh$xli$viwxvmgxmzi$gszirerxw$gsrxemrih$xlivimr-$wlepp$wyvzmzi$xli$xivqmrexmsr$jsv$er}$viewsr$sjxlmw$Ekviiqirx$erh3sv$xli$Iqtps}ii+w$vipexmsrwlmt${mxl$xli$Gsqter}2

592 Rsxmgiw2$Er}$erh$epp$rsxmgiw$viuymvih$sv$tivqmxxih$xs$fi$kmzir$liviyrhiv${mpp$fi$mr${vmxmrk$erh${mpp$fihiiqih$xs$lezi$fiir$kmzir${lir$hitswmxih$mr$Yrmxih$Wxexiw$qemp0$givxmjmih$sv$vikmwxivih$qemp0$tswxeki$tvitemh2$ Er}$rsxmgi$xsfi$kmzir$f}$xli$Iqtps}ii$liviyrhiv${mpp$fi$ ehhviwwih$ xs$xli$Gsqter}$ xs$xli$exxirxmsr$ sj$ mxw$Kirivep$Gsyrwip$ ex$mxw$qemrsjjmgi0$Sri$Tevo$Tpegi0$Wymxi$;440$:65$Rsvxl{iwx$ 97vh$Wxviix0$Fsge$Vexsr0$Jpsvmhe$778<;2$ Er}$rsxmgi$ xs$fi$kmzir$ xs$ xliIqtps}ii${mpp$fi$ehhviwwih$xs$xli$Iqtps}ii$ex$xli$Iqtps}ii+w$viwmhirgi$ehhviww$pewx$tvszmhih$f}$xli$Iqtps}ii$xs$Gsqter}2Imxliv$tevx}$qe}$glerki$ xli$ehhviww$ xs${lmgl$rsxmgiw$ evi$xs$fi$ehhviwwih$f}$rsxmgi$mr${vmxmrk$ xs$ xli$sxliv$ tevx}$ kmzir$ mreggsvhergi${mxl$xli$xivqw$sj$xlmw$Wigxmsr2

5:2 Liehmrkw2$Wigxmsr$liehmrkw$evi$jsv$gsrzirmirgi$sj$vijivirgi$srp}$erh$wlepp$rsx$pmqmx$sv$sxliv{mwi$ejjigxxli$qiermrk$sv$mrxivtvixexmsr$sj$xlmw$Ekviiqirx$sv$er}$sj$mxw$xivqw$erh$gsrhmxmsrw2

5;2 WIGXMSR$84=E$GSQTPMERGI2

$ E2 KIRIVEP2$Mx$mw$xli$mrxirxmsr$sj$fsxl$xli$Gsqter}$erh$xli$Iqtps}ii$xlex$xli$firijmxw$erh$vmklxw$xs{lmgl$xli$Iqtps}ii$mw$irxmxpih$tyvwyerx$xs$xlmw$Ekviiqirx$gsqtp}${mxl$Gshi$Wigxmsr$84=E0$xs$xlii|xirx$xlex$xli$viuymviqirxw$sj$Gshi$Wigxmsr$84=E$evi$ettpmgefpi$xlivixs0$erh$xli$tvszmwmsrw$sj$xlmwEkviiqirx$wlepp$fi$gsrwxvyih$mr$e$qerriv$gsrwmwxirx${mxl$xlex$mrxirxmsr2$Mj$xli$Iqtps}ii$sv$xliGsqter}$fipmiziw0$ex$er}$xmqi0$xlex$er}$wygl$firijmx$sv$vmklx$xlex$mw$wyfnigx$xs$$Gshi$Wigxmsr$84=E$hsiwrsx$ws$gsqtp}0$mx$wlepp$tvsqtxp}$ehzmwi$xli$sxliv$$erh$wlepp$riksxmexi$viewsrefp}$erh$mr$kssh$jemxl$xseqirh$xli$xivqw$sj$wygl$firijmxw$erh$vmklxw$wygl$xlex$xli}$gsqtp}${mxl$Gshi$Wigxmsr$84=E$,{mxl$xliqswx$pmqmxih$tswwmfpi$igsrsqmg$ijjigx$sr$xli$Iqtps}ii$erh$sr$xli$Gsqter}-2

$ F2 HMWXVMFYXMSRW$SR$EGGSYRX$SJ$WITEVEXMSR$JVSQ$WIVZMGI2$Xs$xli$i|xirx$viuymvih$xsgsqtp}${mxl$Gshi$Wigxmsr$84=E0$er}$te}qirx$sv$firijmx$viuymvih$xs$fi$temh$yrhiv$xlmw$Ekviiqirx$sreggsyrx$sj$xivqmrexmsr$sj$ xli

Iqtps}ii+w$wivzmgi$,sv$er}$sxliv$wmqmpev$ xivq-$wlepp$ fi$qehi$ srp}$ mr$ gsrrigxmsr${mxl$ e$ &witevexmsrjvsq$wivzmgi&${mxl$viwtigx$xs$xli$Iqtps}ii${mxlmr$xli$qiermrk$sj$Gshi$Wigxmsr$84=E2

$ G2 RS$EGGIPIVEXMSR$SJ$TE]QIRXW2$Rimxliv$xli$Gsqter}$rsv$xli$Iqt5s}ii0$mrhmzmhyepp}$sv$mrgsqfmrexmsr0$qe}$eggipivexi$er}$te}qirx$sv$firijmx$xlex$mw$wyfnigx$xs$Gshi$Wigxmsr$84=E0$i|gitx$mrgsqtpmergi${mxl$Gshi$Wigxmsr$84=E$erh$xli$tvszmwmsrw$sj$xlmw$Ekviiqirx0$erh$rs$eqsyrx$xlex$mwwyfnigx$xs$Gshi$Wigxmsr$84=E$wlepp$fi$temh$tvmsv$xs$xli$ievpmiwx$hexi$sr${lmgl$mx$qe}$fi$temh${mxlsyxzmspexmrk$Gshi$Wigxmsr$84=E2

$ H2 WM\$QSRXL$HIPE]$JSV$WTIGMJMIH$IQTPS]IIW2$Mr$xli$izirx$xlex$xli$Iqtps}ii$mw$e$&wtigmjmihiqtps}ii&$,ew$hiwgvmfih$mr$Gshi$Wigxmsr$$84=E-0$$erh$er}$te}qirx$sv$firijmx$te}efpi$tyvwyerx$xs$xlmwEkviiqirx$ gsrwxmxyxiw$ hijivvih$ gsqtirwexmsr$ yrhiv$Gshi$Wigxmsr$ 84=E0$ xlir$ xli$Gsqter}$ erh$ xliIqtps}ii$ wlepp$ gsstivexi$ mr$ kssh$ jemxl$ xs$ yrhivxeoi$ er}$ egxmsrw$ xlex${syph$ geywi$ wygl$ te}qirx$ svfirijmx$rsx$xs$gsrwxmxyxi$hijivvih$gsqtirwexmsr$yrhiv$Gshi$Wigxmsr$84=E2$pr$xli$izirx$xlex0$jspps{mrkwygl$ijjsvxw0$xli$Gsqter}$hixivqmriw$,ejxiv$gsrwypxexmsr${mxl$mxw$gsyrwip-$xlex$wygl$te}qirx$sv$firijmxmw$wxmpp$wyfnigx$xs$xli$ wm|1qsrxl$hipe}$ viuymviqirx$hiwgvmfih$ mr$Gshi$Wigxmsr$84=E,6-,f-$ mr$svhiv$ jsvwygl$te}qirx$sv$firijmx$xs$gsqtp}${mxl$xli$viuymviqirxw$sj$Gshi$Wigxmsr$84=E0$xlir$rs$wygl$te}qirxsv$firijmx$wlepp$fi$qehi$fijsvi$xli$hexi$xlex

:

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 82 of 88

Page 358: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis1i|546c6772lxq

jmpi>333G>3Ywivw3Ogsrrspp}3EttHexe3Psgep3Xiqt3893{~jigj3kis1i|546c6772lxq ;3<

$

$ mw$wm|$qsrxlw$ejxiv$xli$Iqtps}ii+w$&witevexmsr$jvsq$wivzmgi&$,ew$hiwgvmfih$mr$Gshi$Wigxmsr$84=E-$,sv0$mjievpmiv0$ xli$ hexi$ sj$ xli$ Iqtps}ii+w$ hiexl-2$ Er}$ te}qirx$ sv$ firijmx$ hipe}ih$ f}$ viewsr$ sj$ xli$ tvmsvwirxirgi$wlepp$fi$temh$syx$sv$tvszmhih$mr$e$wmrkpi$pyqt$wyq$ex$xli$irh$sj$wygl$viuymvih$hipe}$tivmsh$mrsvhiv$xs$gexgl$yt$xs$xli$svmkmrep$te}qirx$wglihypi2

$ I2 XVIEXQIRX$SJ$IEGL$MRWXEPPQIRX$EW$E$WITEVEXI$TE]QIRX2$Jsv$tyvtswiw$sj$ettp}mrkxli$tvszmwmsrw$sj$Gshi$Wigxmsr$84=E$xs$xlmw$Ekviiqirx0$iegl$witevexip}$mhirxmjmih$eqsyrx$xs${lmgl$xliIqtps}ii$mw$irxmxpih$yrhiv$ xlmw$Ekviiqirx$wlepp$fi$ xviexih$ew$e$witevexi$te}qirx2$ Mr$ehhmxmsr0$ xs$ xlii|xirx$tivqmwwmfpi$yrhiv$Gshi$Wigxmsr$84=E0$er}$wivmiw$sj$mrwxeppqirx$te}qirxw$yrhiv$xlmw$Ekviiqirxwlepp$fi$xviexih$ew$e$vmklx$xs$e$wivmiw$sj$witevexi$te}qirxw2

$ J2 VIMQFYVWIQIRXW$ ERH$ MR1OMRH$ FIRIJMXW2$ [mxl$ viwtigx$ xs$ vimqfyvwiqirxw$ erh$ mr1omrhfirijmxw$ xlex$qe}$ fi$ tvszmhih$ yrhiv$ xli$Ekviiqirx$ ,xli$ &Vimqfyvwiqirx$ Tperw&-0$ xs$ xli$ i|xirx$ er}firijmxw$ tvszmhih$ yrhiv$ xli$ Vimqfyvwiqirx$ Tperw$ evi$ wyfnigx$ xs$ Wigxmsr$ 84=E0$ xli$ VimqfyvwiqirxTperw$wlepp$qiix$xli$jspps{mrk$viuymviqirxw>

,m- Vimqfyvwiqirx$ Tperw$ wlepp$ ywi$ er$ sfnigxmzip}$ hixivqmrefpi0$ rsrhmwgvixmsrev}hijmrmxmsr$sj$xli$i|tirwiw$ipmkmfpi$jsv$vimqfyvwiqirx$sv$sj$xli$mr1omrh$firijmxw$xs$fi$tvszmhih?

,mm- Vimqfyvwiqirx$ Tperw$ wlepp$ tvszmhi$ xlex$ xli$ eqsyrx$ sj$ i|tirwiw$ ipmkmfpi$ jsvvimqfyvwiqirx0$ sv$ mr1omrh$ firijmxw$ tvszmhih0$ hyvmrk$ xli$ Iqtps}ii+w$ xe|efpi$ }iev$qe}$ rsx$ ejjigx$ xlii|tirwiw$ ipmkmfpi$ jsv$ vimqfyvwiqirx0$ sv$ mr1omrh$ firijmxw$ xs$ fi$ tvszmhih0$ mr$ er}$ sxliv$ xe|efpi$ }iev0tvszmhih0$ls{iziv0$ xlex$Vimqfyvwiqirx$Tperw$tvszmhmrk$jsv$vimqfyvwiqirx$sj$i|tirwiw$vijivvih$ xs$ mrGshi$Wigxmsr$549,f-$wlepp$rsx$jemp$xs$qiix$xli$viuymviqirx$sj$xlmw$Wigxmsr$5<,K-,mm-$wspip}$figeywi$wyglVimqfyvwiqirx$Tperw$tvszmhi$jsv$e$pmqmx$sr$xli$eqsyrx$sj$i|tirwiw$xlex$qe}$fi$vimqfyvwih$yrhiv$wyglevverkiqirxw$sziv$wsqi$sv$epp$sj$xli$tivmsh$mr${lmgl$Vimqfyvwiqirx$Tperw$viqemr$mr$ijjigx?

,mmm- Xli$vimqfyvwiqirx$sj$er$ipmkmfpi$i|tirwi$mw$qehi$sr$sv$fijsvi$xli$pewx$he}$sj$xliIqtps}ii+$w$xe|efpi$}iev$jspps{mrk$xli$xe|efpi$}iev$mr${lmgl$xli$i|tirwi${ew$mrgyvvih?$erh

,mz- Xli$vmklx$xs$vimqfyvwiqirx$sv$mr1omrh$firijmxw$yrhiv$xli$Vimqfyvwiqirx$Tperw$wlepprsx$fi$wyfnigx$xs$pmuymhexmsr$sv$i|glerki$jsv$ersxliv$firijmx2

$ K2 IQTPS]II$FIRIJMXW2$[mxl$viwtigx$xs$er}$Iqtps}ii$Firijmxw$xlex$hs$rsx$gsqtp}${mxl$,sv$evi$rsxi|iqtx$jvsq-$Gshi$Wigxmsr$84=E0$xs$xli$i|xirx$ ettpmgefpi0$ xli$Iqtps}ii$ wlepp$ fi$ hiiqih$ xs$ vigimzijvsq$xli$Gsqter}$e$qsrxlp}$te}qirx$rigiwwev}$jsv$xli$Iqtps}ii$xs$tyvglewi$xli$firijmx$mr$uyiwxmsr2

;

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 83 of 88

Page 359: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis1i|546c6772lxq

jmpi>333G>3Ywivw3Ogsrrspp}3EttHexe3Psgep3Xiqt3893{~jigj3kis1i|546c6772lxq <3<

$MR$[MXRIWW$[LIVISJ0$xli$Tevxmiw$livixs$lezi$i|igyxih$erh$hipmzivih$xlmw$Ekviiqirx$yrhiv$wiep$ew$sj$xli

hexi$jmvwx$efszi${vmxxir2$

$ $ XLI$KIS$KVSYT0$MRG2 $

$ $ $ $ $

$ $ $ $ $

$ $ F}> 3w3$Kisvki$G2$^spi} $

$ $ $ Reqi>$Kisvki$G2$^spi} $

$ $ $ Xmxpi>$Glemvqer$*$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv $

$ $ $ $ $

$ $ IQTPS]II $

$ $ $ $ $

$ $ $ F}> 3w3$Hezmh$Zirxyvippe $

$ $ $ Reqi>Hezmh$Zirxyvippe $

$ $ $

Xmxpi>$Wirmsv$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx0$FywmriwwHizipstqirx

$ $ $ Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2$

<

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 84 of 88

Page 360: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis1i|755c=2lxq

jmpi>333G>3Ywivw3Ogsrrspp}3EttHexe3Psgep3Xiqt3893{~99h<3kis1i|755c=2lxq 535

I\LMFMX$7525

XLI$KIS$KVSYT0$MRG2

GIVXMJMGEXMSR$SJ$GLMIJ$I\IGYXMZI$SJJMGIV

M0$Kisvki$G2$^spi}0$givxmj}$xlex>

52 M$lezi$vizmi{ih$xlmw$Uyevxivp}$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541U$sj$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2?

62 Fewih$sr$q}$ors{pihki0$xlmw$vitsvx$hsiw$rsx$gsrxemr$er}$yrxvyi$wxexiqirx$sj$e$qexivmep$jegx$sv$sqmx$xs$wxexi$e$qexivmep$jegx

rigiwwev}$xs$qeoi$xli$wxexiqirxw$qehi0$mr$pmklx$sj$xli$gmvgyqwxergiw$yrhiv${lmgl$wygl$wxexiqirxw${ivi$qehi0$rsx$qmwpiehmrk

{mxl$viwtigx$xs$xli$tivmsh$gszivih$f}$xlmw$vitsvx?

72 Fewih$sr$q}$ors{pihki0$xli$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw0$erh$sxliv$jmrergmep$mrjsvqexmsr$mrgpyhih$mr$xlmw$vitsvx0$jemvp}$tviwirx$mr$epp

qexivmep$viwtigxw$xli$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$erh$gewl$jps{w$sj$xli$vikmwxverx$ew$sj0$erh$jsv0$xli$tivmshw$tviwirxih

mr$xlmw$vitsvx?

82 Xli$vikmwxverx×w$sxliv$givxmj}mrk$sjjmgiv$erh$M$evi$viwtsrwmfpi$jsv$iwxefpmwlmrk$erh$qemrxemrmrk$hmwgpswyvi$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw

,ew$hijmrih$mr$I|glerki$Egx$Vypiw$57e159,i-$erh$59h159,i--$erh$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$,ew$hijmrih$mr$I|glerki

Egx$Vypiw$57e159,j-$erh$59h159,j--$jsv$xli$vikmwxverx$erh$lezi>

$ ,e- Hiwmkrih$wygl$hmwgpswyvi$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw0$sv$geywih$wygl$hmwgpswyvi$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw$xs$fi$hiwmkrih$yrhiv

syv$wytivzmwmsr0$xs$irwyvi$xlex$qexivmep$mrjsvqexmsr$vipexmrk$xs$xli$vikmwxverx0$mrgpyhmrk$mxw$gsrwspmhexih$wyfwmhmevmiw0$mw

qehi$ors{r$xs$yw$f}$sxlivw${mxlmr$xlswi$irxmxmiw0$tevxmgypevp}$hyvmrk$xli$tivmsh$mr${lmgl$xlmw$vitsvx$mw$fimrk$tvitevih?

$ ,f- Hiwmkrih$wygl$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk0$sv$geywih$wygl$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$xs$fi

hiwmkrih$yrhiv$syv$wytivzmwmsr0$xs$tvszmhi$viewsrefpi$ewwyvergi$vikevhmrk$xli$vipmefmpmx}$sj$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$erh$xli

tvitevexmsr$sj$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$jsv$i|xivrep$tyvtswiw$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$kirivepp}$eggitxih$eggsyrxmrk$tvmrgmtpiw?

$ ,g- Izepyexih$xli$ijjigxmziriww$sj$xli$vikmwxverx×w$hmwgpswyvi$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw$erh$tviwirxih$mr$xlmw$vitsvx$syv

gsrgpywmsrw$efsyx$xli$ijjigxmziriww$sj$xli$hmwgpswyvi$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw0$ew$sj$xli$irh$sj$xli$tivmsh$gszivih$f}$xlmw

vitsvx$fewih$sr$wygl$izepyexmsr?$erh

$ ,h- Hmwgpswih$mr$xlmw$vitsvx$er}$glerki$mr$xli$vikmwxverx×w$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$xlex$sggyvvih$hyvmrk$xli

vikmwxverx×w$qswx$vigirx$jmwgep$uyevxiv$,xli$vikmwxverx×w$jsyvxl$jmwgep$uyevxiv$mr$xli$gewi$sj$er$erryep$vitsvx-$xlex$lew

qexivmepp}$ejjigxih0$sv$mw$viewsrefp}$pmoip}$xs$qexivmepp}$ejjigx0$xli$vikmwxverx×w$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk?$erh

92 Xli$vikmwxverx×w$sxliv$givxmj}mrk$sjjmgiv$erh$M$lezi$hmwgpswih0$fewih$sr$syv$qswx$vigirx$izepyexmsr$sj$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv

jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk0$xs$xli$vikmwxverx×w$eyhmxsvw$erh$xli$eyhmx$gsqqmxxii$sj$xli$vikmwxverx×w$fsevh$sj$hmvigxsvw$,sv$tivwsrw

tivjsvqmrk$xli$iuymzepirx$jyrgxmsrw->

$ ,e- Epp$wmkrmjmgerx$hijmgmirgmiw$erh$qexivmep${ieoriwwiw$mr$xli$hiwmkr$sv$stivexmsr$sj$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk

{lmgl$evi$viewsrefp}$pmoip}$xs$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$xli$vikmwxverx×w$efmpmx}$xs$vigsvh0$tvsgiww0$wyqqevm~i$erh$vitsvx$jmrergmep

mrjsvqexmsr?$erh

$ ,f- Er}$jveyh0${lixliv$sv$rsx$qexivmep0$xlex$mrzspziw$qerekiqirx$sv$sxliv$iqtps}iiw${ls$lezi$e$wmkrmjmgerx$vspi$mr$xli

vikmwxverx×w$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk2

$

Hexi>$Qe}$:0$6464 $ $ 3w3$Kisvki$G2$^spi}

$ $ $ Kisvki$G2$^spi}

$ $ $ Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$$

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 85 of 88

Page 361: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis1i|756c<2lxq

jmpi>333G>3Ywivw3Ogsrrspp}3EttHexe3Psgep3Xiqt3893{~ge:g3kis1i|756c<2lxq 535

I\LMFMX$7526

XLI$KIS$KVSYT0$MRG2

GIVXMJMGEXMSR$SJ$GLMIJ$JMRERGMEP$SJJMGIV

M0$Fvmer$V2$Izerw0$givxmj}$xlex>

52 M$lezi$vizmi{ih$xlmw$Uyevxivp}$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541U$sj$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2?

62 Fewih$sr$q}$ors{pihki0$xlmw$vitsvx$hsiw$rsx$gsrxemr$er}$yrxvyi$wxexiqirx$sj$e$qexivmep$jegx$sv$sqmx$xs$wxexi$e$qexivmep$jegx

rigiwwev}$xs$qeoi$xli$wxexiqirxw$qehi0$mr$pmklx$sj$xli$gmvgyqwxergiw$yrhiv${lmgl$wygl$wxexiqirxw${ivi$qehi0$rsx$qmwpiehmrk

{mxl$viwtigx$xs$xli$tivmsh$gszivih$f}$xlmw$vitsvx?

72 Fewih$sr$q}$ors{pihki0$xli$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw0$erh$sxliv$jmrergmep$mrjsvqexmsr$mrgpyhih$mr$xlmw$vitsvx0$jemvp}$tviwirx$mr$epp

qexivmep$viwtigxw$xli$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr0$viwypxw$sj$stivexmsrw$erh$gewl$jps{w$sj$xli$vikmwxverx$ew$sj0$erh$jsv0$xli$tivmshw$tviwirxih

mr$xlmw$vitsvx?

82 Xli$vikmwxverx×w$sxliv$givxmj}mrk$sjjmgiv$erh$M$evi$viwtsrwmfpi$jsv$iwxefpmwlmrk$erh$qemrxemrmrk$hmwgpswyvi$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw

,ew$hijmrih$mr$I|glerki$Egx$Vypiw$57e159,i-$erh$59h159,i--$erh$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$,ew$hijmrih$mr$I|glerki

Egx$Vypiw$57e159,j-$erh$59h159,j--$jsv$xli$vikmwxverx$erh$lezi>

$ ,e- Hiwmkrih$wygl$hmwgpswyvi$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw0$sv$geywih$wygl$hmwgpswyvi$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw$xs$fi$hiwmkrih$yrhiv

syv$wytivzmwmsr0$xs$irwyvi$xlex$qexivmep$mrjsvqexmsr$vipexmrk$xs$xli$vikmwxverx0$mrgpyhmrk$mxw$gsrwspmhexih$wyfwmhmevmiw0$mw

qehi$ors{r$xs$yw$f}$sxlivw${mxlmr$xlswi$irxmxmiw0$tevxmgypevp}$hyvmrk$xli$tivmsh$mr${lmgl$xlmw$vitsvx$mw$fimrk$tvitevih?

$ ,f- Hiwmkrih$wygl$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk0$sv$geywih$wygl$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$xs$fi

hiwmkrih$yrhiv$syv$wytivzmwmsr0$xs$tvszmhi$viewsrefpi$ewwyvergi$vikevhmrk$xli$vipmefmpmx}$sj$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$erh$xli

tvitevexmsr$sj$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$jsv$i|xivrep$tyvtswiw$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$kirivepp}$eggitxih$eggsyrxmrk$tvmrgmtpiw?

$ ,g- Izepyexih$xli$ijjigxmziriww$sj$xli$vikmwxverx×w$hmwgpswyvi$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw$erh$tviwirxih$mr$xlmw$vitsvx$syv

gsrgpywmsrw$efsyx$xli$ijjigxmziriww$sj$xli$hmwgpswyvi$gsrxvspw$erh$tvsgihyviw0$ew$sj$xli$irh$sj$xli$tivmsh$gszivih$f}$xlmw

vitsvx$fewih$sr$wygl$izepyexmsr?$erh

$ ,h- Hmwgpswih$mr$xlmw$vitsvx$er}$glerki$mr$xli$vikmwxverx×w$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk$xlex$sggyvvih$hyvmrk$xli

vikmwxverx×w$qswx$vigirx$jmwgep$uyevxiv$,xli$vikmwxverx×w$jsyvxl$jmwgep$uyevxiv$mr$xli$gewi$sj$er$erryep$vitsvx-$xlex$lew

qexivmepp}$ejjigxih0$sv$mw$viewsrefp}$pmoip}$xs$qexivmepp}$ejjigx0$xli$vikmwxverx×w$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk?$erh

92 Xli$vikmwxverx×w$sxliv$givxmj}mrk$sjjmgiv$erh$M$lezi$hmwgpswih0$fewih$sr$syv$qswx$vigirx$izepyexmsr$sj$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv

jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk0$xs$xli$vikmwxverx×w$eyhmxsvw$erh$xli$eyhmx$gsqqmxxii$sj$xli$vikmwxverx×w$fsevh$sj$hmvigxsvw$,sv$tivwsrw

tivjsvqmrk$xli$iuymzepirx$jyrgxmsrw->

$ ,e- Epp$wmkrmjmgerx$hijmgmirgmiw$erh$qexivmep${ieoriwwiw$mr$xli$hiwmkr$sv$stivexmsr$sj$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk

{lmgl$evi$viewsrefp}$pmoip}$xs$ehzivwip}$ejjigx$xli$vikmwxverx×w$efmpmx}$xs$vigsvh0$tvsgiww0$wyqqevm~i$erh$vitsvx$jmrergmep

mrjsvqexmsr?$erh

$ ,f- Er}$jveyh0${lixliv$sv$rsx$qexivmep0$xlex$mrzspziw$qerekiqirx$sv$sxliv$iqtps}iiw${ls$lezi$e$wmkrmjmgerx$vspi$mr$xli

vikmwxverx×w$mrxivrep$gsrxvsp$sziv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk2

$

Hexi>$Qe}$:0$6464 $ $ 3w3$Fvmer$V2$Izerw

$ $ $ Fvmer$V2$Izerw

$ $ $ Glmij$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv$$$

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 86 of 88

Page 362: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis1i|765c;2lxq

jmpi>333G>3Ywivw3Ogsrrspp}3EttHexe3Psgep3Xiqt3893{~8e4g3kis1i|765c;2lxq 535

I|lmfmx$7625

GIVXMJMGEXMSR$TYVWYERX$XS

5<$Y2W2G2$WIGXMSR$57940

EW$EHSTXIH$TYVWYERX$XS

WIGXMSR$=4:$SJ$XLI$WEVFERIW1S\PI]$EGX$SJ$6446

Mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$Uyevxivp}$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541U$sj$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2$,xli$ÔGsqter}Õ-$jsv$xli$tivmsh$irhih

Qevgl$750$6464$ew$jmpih${mxl$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$erh$I|glerki$Gsqqmwwmsr$sr$xli$hexi$livisj$,xli$ÔVitsvxÕ-0$M0$Kisvki$G2$^spi}0$Glmij

I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$sj$xli$Gsqter}0$livif}$givxmj}0$tyvwyerx$xs$5<$Y2W2G2$Wigxmsr$57940$ew$ehstxih$tyvwyerx$xs$Wigxmsr$=4:$sj$xli

Wevferiw1S|pi}$Egx$sj$6446$xlex>

$ ,5- xli$Vitsvx$jypp}$gsqtpmiw${mxl$xli$viuymviqirxw$sj$Wigxmsr$57,e-$sv$59,h-$sj$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$I|glerki$Egx$sj$5=780$ew

eqirhih?$erh

$ ,6- xli$mrjsvqexmsr$gsrxemrih$mr$xli$Vitsvx$jemvp}$tviwirxw0$mr$epp$qexivmep$viwtigxw0$xli$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$viwypxw$sj

stivexmsrw$sj$xli$Gsqter}2

$

3w3$Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv

$Hexi>$Qe}$:0$6464

$

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 87 of 88

Page 363: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 kis1i|766c:2lxq

jmpi>333G>3Ywivw3Ogsrrspp}3EttHexe3Psgep3Xiqt3893{~f<5<3kis1i|766c:2lxq 535

I|lmfmx$7626

GIVXMJMGEXMSR$TYVWYERX$XS

5<$Y2W2G2$WIGXMSR$57940

EW$EHSTXIH$TYVWYERX$XS

WIGXMSR$=4:$SJ$XLI$WEVFERIW1S\PI]$EGX$SJ$6446

Mr$gsrrigxmsr${mxl$xli$Uyevxivp}$Vitsvx$sr$Jsvq$541U$sj$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2$,xli$ÔGsqter}Õ-$jsv$xli$tivmsh$irhih

Qevgl$750$6464$ew$jmpih${mxl$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$erh$I|glerki$Gsqqmwwmsr$sr$xli$hexi$livisj$,xli$ÔVitsvxÕ-0$M0$Fvmer$V2$Izerw0$Glmij

Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv$sj$xli$Gsqter}0$livif}$givxmj}0$tyvwyerx$xs$5<$Y2W2G2$Wigxmsr$57940$ew$ehstxih$tyvwyerx$xs$Wigxmsr$=4:$sj$xli

Wevferiw1S|pi}$Egx$sj$6446$xlex>

$ ,5- xli$Vitsvx$jypp}$gsqtpmiw${mxl$xli$viuymviqirxw$sj$Wigxmsr$57,e-$sv$59,h-$sj$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$I|glerki$Egx$sj$5=780$ew

eqirhih?$erh

$ ,6- xli$mrjsvqexmsr$gsrxemrih$mr$xli$Vitsvx$jemvp}$tviwirxw0$mr$epp$qexivmep$viwtigxw0$xli$jmrergmep$gsrhmxmsr$erh$viwypxw$sj

stivexmsrw$sj$xli$Gsqter}2

$

3w3$Fvmer$V2$Izerw

Fvmer$V2$Izerw

Glmij$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv

$Hexi>$Qe}$:0$6464

$

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 88 of 88

Page 364: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

EXHIBIT 3

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 1 of 34

Page 365: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 <1O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=h<o2lxq 539

$$

YRMXIH$WXEXIWWIGYVMXMIW$ERH$I\GLERKI$GSQQMWWMSR

[EWLMRKXSR0$H2G2$6498=

$

JSVQ$<1O

$

GYVVIRX$VITSVX

Tyvwyerx$xs$Wigxmsr$57$sv$59,h-

sj$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$I|glerki$Egx$sj$5=78

Hexi$sj$Vitsvx$,Hexi$sj$ievpmiwx$izirx$vitsvxih->$Etvmp$740$6464

$

XLI$KIS$KVSYT0$MRG2,I|egx$Reqi$sj$Vikmwxverx$ew$Wtigmjmih$mr$Glevxiv-

$

Jpsvmhe $ 51586:4 $ :9144874;<,Wxexi$sv$Sxliv$Nyvmwhmgxmsr

sj$Mrgsvtsvexmsr-$ ,Gsqqmwwmsr

Jmpi$Ryqfiv-$ ,MVW$Iqtps}iv

Mhirxmjmgexmsr$Rs2-

8=99$Xiglrspsk}$[e}0$Fsge$Vexsr0$Jpsvmhe $ 77875,Ehhviww$sj$Tvmrgmtep$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiw- $ ,^mt$Gshi-

Vikmwxverx×w$xipitlsri$ryqfiv0$mrgpyhmrk$evie$gshi$,9:5-$<=714545

R3E,Jsvqiv$Reqi$sv$Jsvqiv$Ehhviww0$mj$Glerkih$Wmrgi$Pewx$Vitsvx-

$

Gligo$xli$ettvstvmexi$fs|$fips{$mj$xli$Jsvq$<1O$jmpmrk$mw$mrxirhih$xs$wmqypxerisywp}$wexmwj}$xli$jmpmrk$sfpmkexmsr$sj$xli$vikmwxverx$yrhiv$er}

sj$xli$jspps{mrk$tvszmwmsrw$,wii$Kirivep$Mrwxvygxmsrw$E262$fips{->

$ " [vmxxir$gsqqyrmgexmsrw$tyvwyerx$xs$Vypi$869$yrhiv$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$Egx$,5;$GJV$6742869-

$ " Wspmgmxmrk$qexivmep$tyvwyerx$xs$Vypi$58e156$yrhiv$xli$I|glerki$Egx$,5;$GJV$684258e156-

$ " Tvi1gsqqirgiqirx$gsqqyrmgexmsrw$tyvwyerx$xs$Vypi$58h16,f-$yrhiv$xli$I|glerki$Egx$,5;$GJV$684258h16,f--

$ " Tvi1gsqqirgiqirx$gsqqyrmgexmsrw$tyvwyerx$xs$Vypi$57i18,g-$yrhiv$xli$I|glerki$Egx$,5;$GJV$684257i18,g--

Wigyvmxmiw$vikmwxivih$tyvwyerx$xs$Wigxmsr$56,f-$sj$xli$Egx>

Xmxpi$sj$iegl$gpeww $XvehmrkW}qfsp $

Reqi$sj$iegl$i|glerkisr${lmgl$vikmwxivih

Gsqqsr$Wxsgo0$(4245$Tev$Zepyi $ KIS $ Ri{$]svo$Wxsgo$I|glerki

Mrhmgexi$f}$gligo$qevo${lixliv$xli$vikmwxverx$mw$er$iqivkmrk$kvs{xl$gsqter}$ew$hijmrih$mr$Vypi$849$sj$xliWigyvmxmiw$Egx$sj$5=77$,5;$GJV

§6742849-$sv$Vypi$56f16$sj$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$I|glerki$Egx$sj$5=78,5;$GJV$§684256f16-2

Iqivkmrk$kvs{xl$gsqter}$$"

Mj$er$iqivkmrk$kvs{xl$gsqter}0$mrhmgexi$f}$gligo$qevo$mj$xli$vikmwxverx$lew$ipigxih$rsx$xs$ywi$xli$i|xirhih$xverwmxmsr$tivmsh$jsv$gsqtp}mrk${mxl

er}$ri{$sv$vizmwih$jmrergmep$eggsyrxmrk$wxerhevhw$tvszmhih$tyvwyerx$xs$Wigxmsr$57,e-$sj$xli$I|glerki$Egx2$$"

$$

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 2 of 34

Page 366: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 <1O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=h<o2lxq 639

Wigxmsr$6$Jmrergmep$Mrjsvqexmsr

Mxiq$62462 Viwypxw$sj$Stivexmsrw$erh$Jmrergmep$Gsrhmxmsr2

Sr$Etvmp$740$64640$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2$,ÔKISÕ$sv$xli$ÔGsqter}Õ-$mwwyih$e$tviww$vipiewi$,xli$ÔIevrmrkw$Tviww$VipiewiÕ-$errsyrgmrk$mxw

jmrergmep$viwypxw$jsv$xli$uyevxiv$irhih$Qevgl$750$64640$ythexmrk$mxw$jmrergmep$kymhergi$jsv$xli$jypp$}iev$6464$erh$mwwymrk$mxw$jmrergmep$kymhergi$jsv$xli

wigsrh$uyevxiv$64642$E$gst}$sj$xli$Ievrmrkw$Tviww$Vipiewi$mw$jyvrmwlih$livixs$ew$I|lmfmx$==252$KIS$epws$liph$e$gsrjivirgi$gepp$sr$Etvmp$740$6464$xs

hmwgyww$xliwi$qexxivw0$e$xverwgvmtx$sj${lmgl$mw$jyvrmwlih$livixs$ew$I|lmfmx$==262

Mr$xli$Ievrmrkw$Tviww$Vipiewi0$KIS$tvszmhih$Rix$Stivexmrk$Mrgsqi0$IFMXHEvi0$Ehnywxih$IFMXHEvi0$Jyrhw$Jvsq$Stivexmsrw0$Rsvqepm~ih

Jyrhw$Jvsq$Stivexmsrw0$Ehnywxih$Jyrhw$Jvsq$Stivexmsrw$erh$Ehnywxih$Rix$Mrgsqi$jsv$xli$uyevxiv$irhih$Qevgl$750$6464$erh$xli$gsqtevefpi$tvmsv1

}iev$tivmshw$xlex${ivi$rsx$gepgypexih$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$Kirivepp}$Eggitxih$Eggsyrxmrk$Tvmrgmtpiw$,xli$ÔRsr1KEET$MrjsvqexmsrÕ-$erh$evi$tviwirxih

ew$wyttpiqirxep$hmwgpswyviw2$Kirivepp}0$jsv$tyvtswiw$sj$Vikypexmsr$K$yrhiv$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$I|glerki$Egx$sj$5=780$Rsr1KEET$Mrjsvqexmsr$mw$er}

ryqivmgep$qiewyvi$sj$e$gsqter}×w$tivjsvqergi0$jmrergmep$tswmxmsr0$sv$gewl$jps{w$xlex$imxliv$i|gpyhiw$sv$mrgpyhiw$eqsyrxw$xlex$evi$rsx$rsvqepp}

i|gpyhih$sv$mrgpyhih$mr$xli$qswx$hmvigxp}$gsqtevefpi$qiewyvi$gepgypexih$erh$tviwirxih$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$KEET2$Xli$Ievrmrkw$Tviww$Vipiewi$tviwirxw

xli$jmrergmep$qiewyvi$gepgypexih$erh$tviwirxih$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$KEET0${lmgl$mw$xli$qswx$hmvigxp}$gsqtevefpi$xs$xli$Rsr1KEET$Mrjsvqexmsr0${mxl$e

tvsqmrirgi$iuyep$xs$sv$kviexiv$xler$mxw$tviwirxexmsr$sj$xli$Rsr1KEET$Mrjsvqexmsr2$Xli$Ievrmrkw$Tviww$Vipiewi$epws$gsrxemrw$e$vigsrgmpmexmsr$sj

xli$Rsr1KEET$Mrjsvqexmsr$xs$xli$jmrergmep$qiewyvi$gepgypexih$erh$tviwirxih$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$KEET${lmgl$mw$xli$qswx$hmvigxp}$gsqtevefpi$xs

xli$Rsr1KEET$Mrjsvqexmsr2

Rix$Stivexmrk$Mrgsqi$mw$hijmrih$ew$viziryiw$piww$stivexmrk$i|tirwiw0$i|gpyhmrk$hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr$i|tirwi0$kirivep$erh

ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw0$viep$iwxexi$vipexih$stivexmrk$piewi$i|tirwi0$erh$wxevx1yt$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|2$Rix$Stivexmrk$Mrgsqi$mw$gepgypexih$ew$rix$mrgsqi

ehnywxih$f}$wyfxvegxmrk$iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw0$rix$sj$mrgsqi$xe|$tvszmwmsr0$erh$f}$ehhmrk$mrgsqi$xe|$tvszmwmsr0$mrxiviwx$i|tirwi0$rix$sj$mrxiviwx

mrgsqi0$kemr3psww$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx0$hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr$i|tirwi0$kirivep$erh$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw0$viep$iwxexi$vipexih$stivexmrk

piewi$i|tirwi0$kemr3psww$sr$viep$iwxexi$ewwixw0$tvi1xe|0$erh$wxevx1yt$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|2

IFMXHEvi$,IFMXHE$jsv$viep$iwxexi-$mw$hijmrih$ew$rix$mrgsqi$ehnywxih$f}$ehhmrk$tvszmwmsrw$jsv$mrgsqi$xe|0$mrxiviwx$i|tirwi0$rix$sj$mrxiviwx

mrgsqi0$hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr0$erh$kemr3psww$sr$viep$iwxexi$ewwixw0$tvi1xe|2$Ehnywxih$IFMXHEvi$,Ehnywxih$IFMXHE$jsv$viep$iwxexi-$mw$hijmrih$ew

IFMXHEvi$ehnywxih$jsv$rix$psww$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$rsr1gsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw0$wxsgo1fewih$gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|0$erh$givxemr$sxliv$ehnywxqirxw$ew

hijmrih$jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi0$mrgpyhmrk$jsv$xli$tivmshw$tviwirxih$wxevx1yt$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|0$GSZMH15=$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|0$erh$gpswi1syx$i|tirwiw0

tvi1xe|2$Kmzir$xli$rexyvi$sj$KIS×w$fywmriww$ew$e$viep$iwxexi$s{riv$erh$stivexsv0$KIS$fipmiziw$xlex$IFMXHEvi$erh$Ehnywxih$IFMXHEvi$evi$liptjyp$xs

mrziwxsvw$ew$qiewyviw$sj$mxw$stivexmsrep$tivjsvqergi$figeywi$xli}$tvszmhi$er$mrhmgexmsr$sj$mxw$efmpmx}$xs$mrgyv$erh$wivzmgi$hifx0$xs$wexmwj}$kirivep

stivexmrk$i|tirwiw0$xs$qeoi$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw$erh$xs$jyrh$sxliv$gewl$riihw$sv$vimrziwx$gewl$mrxs$mxw$fywmriww2$KIS$fipmiziw$xlex$f}$viqszmrk$xli

mqtegx$sj$mxw$ewwix$fewi$,tvmqevmp}$hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr-$erh$i|gpyhmrk$givxemr$rsr1gewl$glevkiw0$eqsyrxw$wtirx$sr$mrxiviwx$erh$xe|iw0$erh

givxemr$sxliv$glevkiw$xlex$evi$lmklp}$zevmefpi$jvsq$}iev$xs$}iev0$IFMXHEvi$erh$Ehnywxih$IFMXHEvi$tvszmhi$mxw$mrziwxsvw${mxl$tivjsvqergi$qiewyviw

xlex$vijpigx$xli$mqtegx$xs$stivexmsrw$jvsq$xvirhw$mr$sggyterg}$vexiw0$tiv$hmiq$vexiw$erh$stivexmrk$gswxw0$tvszmhmrk$e$tivwtigxmzi$rsx$mqqihmexip}

ettevirx$jvsq$rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS2

Xli$ehnywxqirxw$KIS$qeoiw$xs$hivmzi$xli$rsr1KEET$qiewyviw$sj$IFMXHEvi$erh$Ehnywxih$IFMXHEvi$i|gpyhi$mxiqw${lmgl$qe}$geywi$wlsvx1

xivq$jpygxyexmsrw$mr$mrgsqi$jvsq$gsrxmrymrk$stivexmsrw$erh${lmgl$KIS$hsiw$rsx$gsrwmhiv$xs$fi$xli$jyrheqirxep$exxvmfyxiw$sv$tvmqev}$hvmzivw$sj$mxw

fywmriww$tper$erh$xli}$hs$rsx$ejjigx$KIS×w$szivepp$psrk1xivq$stivexmrk$tivjsvqergi2$IFMXHEvi$erh$Ehnywxih$IFMXHEvi$tvszmhi$hmwgpswyvi$sr$xli

weqi$fewmw$ew$xlex$ywih$f}$KIS×w$qerekiqirx$erh$tvszmhi

6

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 3 of 34

Page 367: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 <1O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=h<o2lxq 739

gsrwmwxirg}$mr$mxw$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk0$jegmpmxexi$mrxivrep$erh$i|xivrep$gsqtevmwsrw$sj$mxw$lmwxsvmgep$stivexmrk$tivjsvqergi$erh$mxw$fywmriww$yrmxw$erh

tvszmhi$gsrxmrymx}$xs$mrziwxsvw$jsv$gsqtevefmpmx}$tyvtswiw2

Jyrhw$Jvsq$Stivexmsrw0$sv$JJS0$mw$hijmrih$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$wxerhevhw$iwxefpmwlih$f}$xli$Rexmsrep$Ewwsgmexmsr$sj$Viep$Iwxexi$Mrziwxqirx$Xvywxw0

sv$REVIMX0${lmgl$hijmriw$JJS$ew$rix$mrgsqi3psww$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$gsqqsr$wlevilsphivw$,gsqtyxih$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$Yrmxih$Wxexiw$Kirivepp}

Eggitxih$Eggsyrxmrk$Tvmrgmtpiw-0$i|gpyhmrk$viep$iwxexi$vipexih$hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr0$i|gpyhmrk$kemrw$erh$pswwiw$jvsq$xli$gyqypexmzi$ijjigxw$sj

eggsyrxmrk$glerkiw0$i|xvesvhmrev}$mxiqw$erh$wepiw$sj$tvstivxmiw0$erh$mrgpyhmrk$ehnywxqirxw$jsv$yrgsrwspmhexih$tevxrivwlmtw$erh$nsmrx$zirxyviw2

Rsvqepm~ih$Jyrhw$jvsq$Stivexmsrw0$sv$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS0$mw$hijmrih$ew$JJS$ehnywxih$jsv$givxemr$mxiqw${lmgl$f}$xlimv$rexyvi$evi$rsx$gsqtevefpi$jvsq

tivmsh$xs$tivmsh$sv$xlex$xirh$xs$sfwgyvi$KIS×w$egxyep$stivexmrk$tivjsvqergi0$mrgpyhmrk$jsv$xli$tivmshw$tviwirxih$kemr3psww$sr$xli$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx0

tvi1xe|0$wxevx1yt$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|0$GSZMH15=$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|0$gpswi1syx$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|0$erh$xe|$ijjigx$sj$ehnywxqirxw$xs$JJS2

Ehnywxih$Jyrhw$Jvsq$Stivexmsrw0$sv$EJJS0$mw$hijmrih$ew$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$ehnywxih$f}$ehhmrk$rsr1gewl$i|tirwiw$wygl$ew$rsr1viep$iwxexi$vipexih

hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr0$wxsgo$fewih$gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwi0$xli$eqsvxm~exmsr$sj$hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw0$hmwgsyrx$erh3sv$tviqmyq$erh

sxliv$rsr1gewl$mrxiviwx0$erh$f}$wyfxvegxmrk$vigyvvmrk$gsrwspmhexih$qemrxirergi$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw2

Ehnywxih$Rix$Mrgsqi$mw$hijmrih$ew$Rix$Mrgsqi$Exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS$ehnywxih$jsv$givxemr$mxiqw${lmgl$f}$xlimv$rexyvi$evi$rsx$gsqtevefpi$jvsq

tivmsh$xs$tivmsh$sv$xlex$xirh$xs$sfwgyvi$KIS×w$egxyep$stivexmrk$tivjsvqergi0$mrgpyhmrk$jsv$xli$tivmshw$tviwirxih$kemr3psww$sr$viep$iwxexi$ewwixw0$tvi1xe|0

kemr3psww$sr$xli$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx0$tvi1xe|0$wxevx1yt$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|0$GSZMH15=$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|0$gpswi1syx$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|$erh$xe|$ijjigx$sj

ehnywxqirxw$xs$Rix$Mrgsqi$Exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS2

Figeywi$sj$xli$yrmuyi$hiwmkr0$wxvygxyvi$erh$ywi$sj$KIS×w$gsvvigxmsrep$jegmpmxmiw0$tvsgiwwmrk$girxivw0$erh$viirxv}$girxivw0$xli$Gsqter}$fipmiziw

xlex$ewwiwwmrk$xli$tivjsvqergi$sj$mxw$gsvvigxmsrep$jegmpmxmiw0$tvsgiwwmrk$girxivw0$erh$viirxv}$girxivw${mxlsyx$xli$mqtegx$sj$hitvigmexmsr$sv$eqsvxm~exmsr$mw

ywijyp$erh$qiermrkjyp$xs$mrziwxsvw2$Epxlsykl$REVIMX$lew$tyfpmwlih$mxw$hijmrmxmsr$sj$JJS0$gsqtermiw$sjxir$qshmj}$xlmw$hijmrmxmsr$ew$xli}$wiio$xs

tvszmhi$jmrergmep$qiewyviw$xlex$qiermrkjypp}$vijpigx$xlimv$hmwxmrgxmzi$stivexmsrw2$KIS$lew$qshmjmih$JJS$xs$hivmzi$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$erh$EJJS$xlex

qiermrkjypp}$vijpigx$mxw$stivexmsrw2

KIS×w$ewwiwwqirx$sj$mxw$stivexmsrw$mw$jsgywih$sr$psrk1xivq$wywxemrefmpmx}2$Xli$ehnywxqirxw$KIS$qeoiw$xs$hivmzi$xli$rsr1KEET$qiewyviw$sj

Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$erh$EJJS$i|gpyhi$mxiqw${lmgl$qe}$geywi$wlsvx1xivq$jpygxyexmsrw$mr$rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS$fyx$lezi$rs$mqtegx$sr$KIS×w

gewl$jps{w0$sv$xli$Gsqter}$hsiw$rsx$gsrwmhiv$xliq$xs$fi$jyrheqirxep$exxvmfyxiw$sv$xli$tvmqev}$hvmzivw$sj$KIS×w$fywmriww$tper$erh$xli}$hs$rsx$ejjigx

KIS×w$szivepp$psrk1xivq$stivexmrk$tivjsvqergi2$KIS$qe}$qeoi$ehnywxqirxw$xs$JJS$jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi$jsv$givxemr$sxliv$mrgsqi$erh$i|tirwiw$xlex$hs

rsx$vijpigx$e$rigiwwev}$gsqtsrirx$sj$KIS×w$stivexmsrep$tivjsvqergi$sr$xli$fewmw$hmwgywwih$efszi0$izir$xlsykl$wygl$mxiqw$qe}$viuymvi$gewl$wixxpiqirx2

Figeywi$JJS0$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$erh$EJJS$i|gpyhi$hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr$yrmuyi$xs$viep$iwxexi$ew${ipp$ew$rsr1stivexmsrep$mxiqw$erh$givxemr$sxliv

glevkiw$xlex$evi$lmklp}$zevmefpi$jvsq$}iev$xs$}iev0$xli}$tvszmhi$KIS×w$mrziwxsvw${mxl$tivjsvqergi$qiewyviw$xlex$vijpigx$xli$mqtegx$xs$stivexmsrw$jvsq

xvirhw$mr$sggyterg}$vexiw0$tiv$hmiq$vexiw0$stivexmrk$gswxw$erh$mrxiviwx$gswxw0$tvszmhmrk$e$tivwtigxmzi$rsx$mqqihmexip}$ettevirx$jvsq$Rix$Mrgsqi

Exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS2

KIS$fipmiziw$xli$tviwirxexmsr$sj$JJS0$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$erh$EJJS$tvszmhi$ywijyp$mrjsvqexmsr$xs$mrziwxsvw$ew$xli}$tvszmhi$er$mrhmgexmsr$sj

KIS×w$efmpmx}$xs$jyrh$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw$erh$i|terh$mxw$fywmriww2$JJS0$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$erh$EJJS$tvszmhi$hmwgpswyvi$sr$xli$weqi$fewmw$ew$xlex$ywih

f}$KIS×w$qerekiqirx$erh$tvszmhi$gsrwmwxirg}$mr$mxw$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk0$jegmpmxexi$mrxivrep$erh$i|xivrep$gsqtevmwsrw$sj$mxw$lmwxsvmgep$stivexmrk

tivjsvqergi$erh$mxw$fywmriww$yrmxw$erh$tvszmhi$gsrxmrymx}$xs$mrziwxsvw$jsv$gsqtevefmpmx}$tyvtswiw2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$JJS0$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$erh$EJJS$evi

{mhip}$vigskrm~ih$qiewyviw$mr$KIS×w$mrhywxv}$ew$e$viep$iwxexi$mrziwxqirx$xvywx2

7

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 4 of 34

Page 368: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 <1O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=h<o2lxq 839

Xli$Ievrmrkw$Tviww$Vipiewi$gsrxemrw$vigsrgmpmexmsr$xefpiw$jsv$Rix$Stivexmrk$Mrgsqi0$IFMXHEvi0$Ehnywxih$IFMXHEvi0$Jyrhw$jvsq$Stivexmsrw0

Rsvqepm~ih$Jyrhw$jvsq$Stivexmsrw0$Ehnywxih$Jyrhw$jvsq$Stivexmsrw$erh$Ehnywxih$Rix$Mrgsqi2

KIS$lew$tviwirxih$mr$xli$Ievrmrkw$Tviww$Vipiewi$givxemr$jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw$efsyx$KIS×w$jyxyvi$jmrergmep$tivjsvqergi$xlex

mrgpyhi$rsr1KEET$jmrergmep$qiewyviw0$mrgpyhmrk0$Rix$Stivexmrk$Mrgsqi0$Ehnywxih$IFMXHEvi0$Jyrhw$jvsq$Stivexmsrw0$Rsvqepm~ih$Jyrhw$jvsq

Stivexmsrw0$erh$Ehnywxih$Jyrhw$jvsq$Stivexmsrw2$Xli$hixivqmrexmsr$sj$xli$eqsyrxw$xlex$evi$mrgpyhih$sv$i|gpyhih$jvsq$xliwi$rsr1KEET$jmrergmep

qiewyviw$mw$e$qexxiv$sj$qerekiqirx$nyhkqirx$erh$hitirhw$ytsr0$eqsrk$sxliv$jegxsvw0$xli$rexyvi$sj$xli$yrhivp}mrk$i|tirwi$sv$mrgsqi$eqsyrxw

vigskrm~ih$mr$e$kmzir$tivmsh2$[lmpi$KIS$lew$tvszmhih$e$lmkl$pizip$vigsrgmpmexmsr$jsv$xli$kymhergi$verkiw$jsv$jypp$}iev$64640$mx$mw$yrefpi$xs$tviwirx$e

qsvi$hixempih$uyerxmxexmzi$vigsrgmpmexmsr$sj$xli$jsv{evh1pssomrk$rsr1KEET$jmrergmep$qiewyviw$xs$xlimv$qswx$hmvigxp}$gsqtevefpi$jsv{evh1pssomrk

KEET$jmrergmep$qiewyviw$figeywi$qerekiqirx$gerrsx$vipmefp}$tvihmgx$epp$sj$xli$rigiwwev}$gsqtsrirxw$sj$wygl$KEET$qiewyviw2$Xli$uyerxmxexmzi

vigsrgmpmexmsr$sj$xli$jsv{evh1pssomrk$rsr1KEET$jmrergmep$qiewyviw${mpp$fi$tvszmhih$jsv$gsqtpixih$erryep$erh$uyevxivp}$tivmshw0$ew$ettpmgefpi0

gepgypexih$mr$e$gsrwmwxirx$qerriv${mxl$xli$uyerxmxexmzi$vigsrgmpmexmsr$sj$rsr1KEET$jmrergmep$qiewyviw$tvizmsywp}$vitsvxih$jsv$gsqtpixih$erryep$erh

uyevxivp}$tivmshw2

Xli$Rsr1KEET$Mrjsvqexmsr$wlsyph$fi$gsrwmhivih$mr$ehhmxmsr$xs$viwypxw$xlex$evi$tvitevih$yrhiv$gyvvirx$eggsyrxmrk$wxerhevhw$fyx$wlsyph$rsx$fi

gsrwmhivih$e$gsrwspmhexih$wyfwxmxyxi$jsv0$sv$wytivmsv$xs0$jmrergmep$mrjsvqexmsr$tvitevih$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$KEET2$Xli$Rsr1KEET$Mrjsvqexmsr$qe}

hmjjiv$jvsq$wmqmpevp}$xmxpih$qiewyviw$tviwirxih$f}$sxliv$gsqtermiw2$Xli$Rsr1KEET$Mrjsvqexmsr0$ew${ipp$ew$sxliv$mrjsvqexmsr$mr$xli$Ievrmrkw$Tviww

Vipiewi0$wlsyph$fi$vieh$mr$gsrnyrgxmsr${mxl$KIS×w$jmrergmep$wxexiqirxw$jmpih${mxl$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$erh$I|glerki$Gsqqmwwmsr2

Xli$mrjsvqexmsr$wix$jsvxl$mr$Mxiq$6246$mr$xlmw$Jsvq$<1O$mw$fimrk$jyvrmwlih$erh$wlepp$rsx$fi$hiiqih$ÔjmpihÕ$jsv$tyvtswiw$sj$Wigxmsr$5<$sj$xli

Wigyvmxmiw$I|glerki$Egx$sj$5=780$ew$eqirhih0$sv$sxliv{mwi$wyfnigx$xs$xli$pmefmpmxmiw$sj$xlex$wigxmsr2$Xli$mrjsvqexmsr$wix$jsvxl$mr$Mxiq$6246$mr$xlmw

Jsvq$<1O$wlepp$rsx$fi$mrgsvtsvexih$f}$vijivirgi$mrxs$er}$vikmwxvexmsr$wxexiqirx$sv$sxliv$hsgyqirx$tyvwyerx$xs$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$Egx$sj$5=770$ew$eqirhih2

Mxiq$=2452 Jmrergmep$Wxexiqirxw$erh$I|lmfmxw2

I|lmfmx$$$Rs2$$

$

$ Hiwgvmtxmsr$ $ $ $ $

$ ==25 $ $ Tviww$Vipiewi0$hexih$Etvmp$740$64640$errsyrgmrk$KIS×w$jmrergmep$viwypxw$jsv$xli$uyevxiv$irhih$Qevgl$750$64642$ $ $ $ $

$ ==26 $ $ Xverwgvmtx$sj$Gsrjivirgi$Gepp$hmwgywwmrk$KIS×w$jmrergmep$viwypxw$jsv$xli$uyevxiv$irhih$Qevgl$750$64642$ $ $ $ $

$ 548 $ $ Gsziv$Teki$Mrxivegxmzi$Hexe$Jmpi$,iqfihhih${mxlmr$xli$Mrpmri$\FVP$hsgyqirx-2

8

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 5 of 34

Page 369: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 <1O

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=h<o2lxq 939

WMKREXYVIW

Tyvwyerx$xs$xli$viuymviqirxw$sj$xli$Wigyvmxmiw$I|glerki$Egx$sj$5=780$xli$vikmwxverx$lew$hyp}$geywih$xlmw$vitsvx$xs$fi$wmkrih$sr$mxw$filepj$f}

xli$yrhivwmkrih$liviyrxs$hyp}$eyxlsvm~ih2

$ $ XLI$KIS$KVSYT0$MRG2$ $ $ $ $ $ $

Qe}$:0$6464 $ $ F}>$ 3w3$Fvmer$V2$Izerw

Hexi $ $ $ Fvmer$V2$Izerw

$ $ $ Wirmsv$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx$erh$Glmij$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv

$ $ $ ,Tvmrgmtep$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv-

9

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 6 of 34

Page 370: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 7 of 34

Page 371: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\1==25

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=hi|==52lxq 6358

RI[W$VIPIEWI$

GSZMH15=$Ythexi

Ew$xli$GSZMH15=$terhiqmg$lew$mqtegxih$gsqqyrmxmiw$egvsww$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw$erh$evsyrh$xli${svph0$syv$iqtps}iiw$erh$jegmpmxmiw$lezi$epws$fiir

mqtegxih$f}$xli$wtvieh$sj$GSZMH15=2$Irwyvmrk$xli$liepxl$erh$wejix}$sj$syv$iqtps}iiw$erh$epp$xlswi$mr$syv$gevi$lew$ep{e}w$fiir$syv$ryqfiv$sri

tvmsvmx}2$Ew$e$psrkwxerhmrk$tvszmhiv$sj$iwwirxmep$kszivrqirx$wivzmgiw0${i$lezi$i|tivmirgi${mxl$xli$mqtpiqirxexmsr$sj$fiwx$tvegxmgiw$jsv$xli$tvizirxmsr0

ewwiwwqirx0$erh$qerekiqirx$sj$mrjigxmsyw$hmwiewiw2$

$ ¨ $ Epp$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$stivexi$wejip}$erh${mxlsyx$szivgvs{hih$gsrhmxmsrw2$

$ ¨ $ Epp$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$lezi$eggiww$xs$vikypev$lerh{ewlmrk${mxl$gpier${exiv$erh$wset2$

$ ¨ $ Epp$sj$syv$wigyvi$wivzmgiw$jegmpmxmiw$tvszmhi$683;$eggiww$xs$liepxlgevi2$

$¨ $ Epp$sj$syv$Y2W2$Mqqmkvexmsr$erh$Gywxsqw$Irjsvgiqirx$,ÔMGIÕ-$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxivw$x}tmgepp}$lezi$ettvs|mqexip}$hsyfpi$xli$ryqfiv$sj

liepxlgevi$wxejj0$gsqtevih$xs$wxexi$gsvvigxmsrep$jegmpmxmiw2$

$ ¨ $ Qswx$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$evi$iuymttih${mxl$Emvfsvri$Mrjigxmsr$Mwspexmsr$Vssqw2

Jvsq$xli$syxwix$sj$xli$GSZMH15=$kpsfep$terhiqmg0$syv$gsvtsvexi0$vikmsrep$erh$jmiph$wxejj$lezi$mqtpiqirxih$gsqtvilirwmzi$wxitw$xs$ehhviww$erh

qmxmkexi$xli$vmwow$sj$GSZMH15=$xs$epp$xlswi$mr$syv$gevi$erh$syv$iqtps}iiw2$

$¨ $ [i$mwwyih$kymhergi$xs$epp$syv$jegmpmxmiw0$gsrwmwxirx${mxl$xli$kymhergi$mwwyih$jsv$gsvvigxmsrep$erh$hixirxmsr$jegmpmxmiw$f}$xli$Girxivw$jsv

Hmwiewi$Gsrxvsp$erh$Tvizirxmsr2$

$

¨ $ [i$ythexih$syv$tspmgmiw$erh$tvsgihyviw$xs$mrgpyhi$fiwx$tvegxmgiw$jsv$xli$tvizirxmsr0$ewwiwwqirx0$erh$qerekiqirx$sj$GSZMH15=0$mrgpyhmrk

xli$mqtpiqirxexmsr$sj$uyeverxmri$erh$gslsvxmrk$tvsgihyviw$xs$mwspexi$gsrjmvqih$erh$tviwyqtxmzi$gewiw$sj$GSZMH15=0$mrgpyhmrk$qihmgep

mwspexmsr$erh$xli$ywi$sj$Emvfsvri$Mrjigxmsr$Mwspexmsr$Vssqw2$

$

¨ $ [i$tvszmhih$ihygexmsrep$kymhergi$xs$syv$iqtps}iiw$erh$mrhmzmhyepw$mr$syv$gevi$sr$xli$fiwx$tvizirxexmzi$qiewyviw$xs$ezsmh$xli$wtvieh$sj

GSZMH15=$wygl$ew$jviuyirx$erh$gevijyp$lerh{ewlmrk?$ezsmhmrk$xsyglmrk$eview$sj$xli$jegi0$mrgpyhmrk$jegmep$lemv?$ezsmhmrk$mrhmzmhyepw

i|lmfmxmrk$jpy1pmoi$w}qtxsqw?$tvstiv$gsykl$erh$wrii~i$ixmuyixxi?$wsgmep$hmwxergmrk$viuymviqirxw?$erh$ehnywxqirxw$xs$peyrhv}$erh$qiep

wglihypiw2$

$¨ $ [i$mrgviewih$xli$jviuyirg}$sj$hmwxvmfyxmsr$sj$tivwsrep$l}kmiri$tvshygxw0$mrgpyhmrk$wset0$wleqtss$erh$fsh}${ewl0$erh$xmwwyi$tetiv0$erh${i

evi$irwyvmrk$xli$hemp}$ezempefmpmx}$sj$fevw$sj$wset$sv$wset$hmwtirwivw$ex$iegl$wmro$jsv$lerh${ewlmrk$mr$epp$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw2$

$¨ $ [i$hitps}ih$wtigmepm~ih$wermxexmsr$xieqw$xs$wxivmpm~i$lmkl1gsrxegx$eview$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$erh$lezi$hizipstih$mrxirwmzi$wglihypiw$erh

tvsgihyviw$jsv$xli$gpiermrk$erh$hmwmrjigxmrk$sj$jegmpmx}$wtegiw$efszi$erh$fi}srh$rsvqep$gpiermrk$egxmzmxmiw2$

$ ¨ $ [i$tvsgyvih$ehhmxmsrep$gpiermrk$iuymtqirx$erh$wermxexmsr$tvshygxw$xlex$evi$tvszir$liepxlgevi$kvehi$hmwmrjigxerxw2$

$¨ $ [i$ehzmwih$syv$iqtps}iiw$xs$viqemr$lsqi$mj$xli}$i|lmfmx$jpy1pmoi$w}qtxsqw0$erh${i$lezi$i|ivgmwih$jpi|mfpi$temh$piezi$erh$Temh$Xmqi$Sjj

tspmgmiw$xs$epps{$jsv$iqtps}iiw$xs$viqemr$lsqi$mj$xli}$i|lmfmx$jpy1pmoi$w}qtxsqw$sv$xs$gevi$jsv$e$jeqmp}$qiqfiv2

ÓQsviÓ$

Gsrxegx>$Tefps$I2$Tei~ $$ ,<::-$745$887:

I|igyxmzi$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx0$Gsvtsvexi$Vipexmsrw $$

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 8 of 34

Page 372: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\1==25

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=hi|==52lxq 7358

RI[W$VIPIEWI$

$

¨ $ [i$irkekih${mxl$syv$kszivrqirx$ekirg}$tevxrivw$xs$tvsqtxp}$wywtirh$rsr1iwwirxmep$zmwmxexmsr$ex$epp$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw0$erh${i$lezi

iqtps}ih$ehhmxmsrep$qiewyviw$hyvmrk$xli$mrxeoi$erh$irxv}$tvsgiww$ex$epp$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$xs$mrgpyhi$wgviirmrk$wtigmjmg$xs$GSZMH15=0

mrgpyhmrk$xiqtivexyvi$gligow$jsv$epp$wxejj$erh$er}$pikepp}$viuymvih$zmwmxsvw$fijsvi$irxivmrk$syv$jegmpmxmiw0$ew${ipp$ew0$zivfep$qihmgep

wgviirmrk$uyiwxmsrremviw2$

$¨ $ [i$svhivih$erh$vigimzih$w{ef$omxw$jsv$GSZMH15=$jvsq$e$rexmsrep$wyttpmiv0$erh${i$iregxih$uyeverxmri$erh$xiwxmrk$tspmgmiw$jsv$er}

iqtps}iiw${ls$qe}$lezi$gsqi$mrxs$gsrxegx${mxl$er}$mrhmzmhyep${ls$lew$xiwxih$tswmxmzi$jsv$GSZMH15=2$

$¨ $ Ex$iziv}$sri$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw0${i$lezi${svoih$gpswip}${mxl$syv$kszivrqirx$ekirg}$tevxrivw$erh$psgep$liepxl$sjjmgmepw$xs$hizipst

GSZMH15=$iqivkirg}$tperw$erh$xiwxmrk$tspmgmiw$jsv$xli$mrhmzmhyepw$mr$syv$gevi2$

$¨ $ Mr$Qevgl$sj$64640${i$wxevxih$tvsgyvmrk$ehhmxmsrep$Tivwsrep$Tvsxigxmzi$Iuymtqirx$erh$fiker$mwwymrk$mx$ew$gpmrmgepp}$riihih$ex$jegmpmxmiw

mqtegxih$f}$GSZMH15=2$

$

¨ $ Sziv$xli$gsyvwi$sj$Etvmp$sj$64640${i$gssvhmrexih${mxl$syv$kszivrqirx$ekirg}$tevxrivw$xs$hmwxvmfyxi$Tivwsrep$Tvsxigxmzi$Iuymtqirx0

mrgpyhmrk$jegiqewow$xs$epp$wxejj0$mrqexiw0$hixemriiw0$erh$viwmhirxw$ew$e$tvigeyxmsrev}$qiewyvi$ex$epp$sj$syv$Jihivep$Fyviey$sj$Tvmwsrw

jegmpmxmiw0$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxivw0$Y2W2$Qevwlepw$jegmpmxmiw0$wxexi$gsvvigxmsrep$jegmpmxmiw0$psgep$gsvvigxmsrep$jegmpmxmiw$erh$nempw0$viwmhirxmep

viirxv}$girxivw0$erh$}syxl$wivzmgiw$viwmhirxmep$jegmpmxmiw2

[i${mpp$gsrxmryi$xs$gssvhmrexi$gpswip}${mxl$syv$kszivrqirx$ekirg}$tevxrivw$erh$psgep$liepxl$ekirgmiw$xs$irwyvi$xli$liepxl$erh$wejix}$sj$epp$xlswi$mr$syv

gevi$erh$syv$iqtps}iiw2$[i$evi$kvexijyp$jsv$syv$jvsrxpmri$iqtps}iiw${ls$evi$qeomrk$wegvmjmgiw$hemp}$xs$tvszmhi$gevi$jsv$epp$xlswi$mr$syv$jegmpmxmiw$hyvmrk

xlmw$yrtvigihirxih$kpsfep$terhiqmg2$Mrjsvqexmsr$sr$xli$wxitw${i$lezi$xeoir$xs$ehhviww$erh$qmxmkexi$xli$vmwow$sj$GSZMH15=$ger$fi$jsyrh$ex

{{{2kiskvsyt2gsq3GSZMH5=2

Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$6464$Vizmi{

[i$vitsvxih$jmvwx$uyevxiv$6464$rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS$sj$(6926$qmppmsr0$sv$(4265$tiv$hmpyxih$wlevi0$gsqtevih$xs$(842;$qmppmsr0$sv$(4278$tiv

hmpyxih$wlevi0$jsv$xli$jmvwx$uyevxiv$645=2$[i$vitsvxih$xsxep$viziryiw$jsv$xli$jmvwx$uyevxiv$6464$sj$(:4924$qmppmsr$gsqtevih$xs$(:542;$qmppmsr$jsv$xli$jmvwx

uyevxiv$645=2

Ehhmxmsrepp}0$jmvwx$uyevxiv$6464$viwypxw$vijpigx$e$(428$qmppmsr$kemr$sr$viep$iwxexi$ewwixw$tvi1xe|0$e$(52:$qmppmsr$kemr$sr$xli$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx0$tvi1xe|0

(624$qmppmsr$mr$wxevx1yt$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|0$(52=$qmppmsr$mr$gpswi1syx$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|0$(42=$qmppmsr$mr$GSZMH15=$vipexih$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|0$erh

(42<$qmppmsr$mr$xli$xe|$ijjigx$sj$ehnywxqirxw$xs$rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS2$I|gpyhmrk$xliwi$mxiqw0${i$vitsvxih$jmvwx$uyevxiv$6464$Ehnywxih$Rix

Mrgsqi$sj$(6<2<$qmppmsr0$sv$(4268$tiv$hmpyxih$wlevi2

[i$vitsvxih$jmvwx$uyevxiv$6464$Rsvqepm~ih$Jyrhw$Jvsq$Stivexmsrw$,ÔRsvqepm~ih$JJSÕ-$sj$(8;26$qmppmsr0$sv$(427=$tiv$hmpyxih$wlevi0$gsqtevih$xs

(:427$qmppmsr0$sv$(4294$tiv$hmpyxih$wlevi0$jsv$xli$jmvwx$uyevxiv$645=2$[i$vitsvxih$jmvwx$uyevxiv$6464$Ehnywxih$Jyrhw$Jvsq$Stivexmsrw$,ÔEJJSÕ-$sj

(::2:$qmppmsr0$sv$(4299$tiv$hmpyxih$wlevi0$gsqtevih$xs$(<427$qmppmsr0$sv$(42:;$tiv$hmpyxih$wlevi0$jsv$xli$jmvwx$uyevxiv$645=2

ÓQsviÓ$

Gsrxegx>$Tefps$I2$Tei~ $$ ,<::-$745$887:

I|igyxmzi$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx0$Gsvtsvexi$Vipexmsrw $$

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 9 of 34

Page 373: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\1==25

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=hi|==52lxq 8358

RI[W$VIPIEWI$

6464$Jmrergmep$Kymhergi

[i$ythexih$syv$jmrergmep$kymhergi$jsv$xli$jypp1}iev$sj$6464$erh$mwwyih$kymhergi$jsv$xli$wigsrh$uyevxiv$sj$64642$Izir$xlsykl${i$lezi$gsrxmryih$syv

stivexmsrw$ew$er$iwwirxmep$kszivrqirx$wivzmgiw$tvszmhiv0$xli$wtvieh$sj$GSZMH15=$lew$rikexmzip}$mqtegxih$e$ryqfiv$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$erh$tvskveqw$erh

mw$i|tigxih$xs$viwypx$mr$ps{iv$jypp1}iev$6464$viziryiw0$tvmqevmp}$jsv$syv$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxivw$erh$Y2W2$Qevwlepw$Wivzmgi$jegmpmxmiw$erh$syv$KIS

Viirxv}$Wivzmgiw$fywmriww2

Syv$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxivw$erh$Y2W2$Qevwlepw$Wivzmgi$jegmpmxmiw$fiker$i|tivmirgmrk$ps{iv$szivepp$sggyterg}$mr$pexi$Qevgl$6464$ew$e$viwypx$sj$higpmriw

mr$gvswwmrkw$erh$ettvilirwmsrw$epsrk$xli$Y2W2$Wsyxl{iwx$fsvhiv0$ew${ipp$ew0$e$higviewi$mr$gsyvx$erh$wirxirgmrk$egxmzmx}$ex$xli$jihivep$pizip$mr$xli$Yrmxih

Wxexiw$hyi$xs$xli$GSZMH15=$terhiqmg2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$xli$Y2W2$jihivep$kszivrqirx$vigirxp}$mwwyih$GSZMH15=$stivexmsrep$kymhergi$vigsqqirhmrk$e

vihygxmsr$xs$;9$tivgirx$sj$getegmx}$ex$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxivw${livi$tswwmfpi$xs$tvsqsxi$wsgmep$hmwxergmrk$tvegxmgiw2

Syv$KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$gsrxvegxw$x}tmgepp}$gsrxemr$jm|ih1tvmgi$sv$qmrmqyq$kyeverxii$te}qirx$tvszmwmsrw$mrxirhih$xs$irwyvi$ehiuyexi$wxejjmrk$pizipw

erh$gsrwmwxirx$wivzmgi$hipmziv}2$Syv$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxivw$erh$Y2W2$Qevwlepw$Wivzmgi$jegmpmxmiw$evi$gyvvirxp}$stivexmrk$ex$sv$evsyrh$xli$getegmx}$pizip

xmih$xs$xli$jm|ih1tvmgi$sv$qmrmqyq$kyeverxii$te}qirx$tvszmwmsrw2$[lmpi$mx$mw$tswwmfpi$xlex${i$qe}$i|tivmirgi$er$mqtvsziqirx$ex$xliwi$jegmpmxmiw$pexiv

xlmw$}iev0$syv$ythexih$jypp1}iev$6464$kymhergi$ewwyqiw$e$gsrxmryexmsr$sj$ps{iv$sggyterg}$pizipw$xlvsykl$xli$irh$sj$xli$}iev0$viwypxmrk$mr$er$iwxmqexih

viziryi$higpmri$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$<)$jsv$xli$jypp1}iev$64642

Syv$KIS$Viirxv}$Wivzmgiw$fywmriww$epws$fiker$i|tivmirgmrk$e$higpmri$mr$sggyterg}$mr$pexi$Qevgl$6464$ex$syv$viwmhirxmep$viirxv}$girxivw$erh

rsr1viwmhirxmep$he}$vitsvxmrk$tvskveqw$hyi$xs$ps{iv$pizipw$sj$vijivvepw$f}$jihivep0$wxexi$erh$psgep$kszivrqirx$ekirgmiw$figeywi$sj$xli$GSZMH15=

terhiqmg2$[lmpi$mx$mw$tswwmfpi$xlex$vijivvep$pizipw$jsv$syv$KIS$Viirxv}$Wivzmgiw$fywmriww$qe}$mrgviewi$pexiv$xlmw$}iev0$syv$ythexih$jypp1}iev$6464

kymhergi$ewwyqiw$ps{iv$sggyterg}$pizipw$jsv$syv$viwmhirxmep$viirxv}$girxivw$erh$he}$vitsvxmrk$tvskveqw$xlvsykl$xli$irh$sj$xli$}iev0$viwypxmrk$mr$er

iwxmqexih$viziryi$higpmri$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$8)$jsv$xli$jypp1}iev$64642

[i$lezi$epws$mrgviewih$syv$wtirhmrk$sr$tivwsrep$tvsxigxmzi$iuymtqirx0$hmekrswxmg$xiwxmrk0$erh$qihmgep$i|tirwiw$ew$e$viwypx$sj$xli$GSZMH15=$terhiqmg

erh$i|tigx$xs$mrgyv$wizivep$qmppmsr$hsppevw$mr$rsr1vigyvvmrk$gswxw$hyvmrk$64642$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$syv$ythexih$kymhergi$gsrxmryiw$xs$ewwyqi$rs$gsrxvmfyxmsr

jvsq$syv$;441fih$Girxvep$Zeppi}0$;941fih$Hiwivx$Zmi{0$erh$;441fih$Ksphir$Wxexi$jegmpmxmiw$mr$Gepmjsvrme0$izir$xlsykl${i$evi$lstijyp$xliwi$jegmpmxmiw

{mpp$fi$egxmzexih$ew$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxiv$erri|iw$hyvmrk$xli$wigsrh$lepj$sj$64642

Ew$e$viwypx$sj$xliwi$jegxsvw0${i$lezi$ythexih$syv$jypp1}iev$6464$kymhergi$jsv$Rix$Mrgsqi$Exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS$xs$e$verki$sj$(42=6$xs$(5248$tiv$hmpyxih

wlevi?$Ehnywxih$Rix$Mrgsqi$xs$e$verki$sj$(5244$xs$(5256$tiv$hmpyxih$wlevi?$erh$EJJS$xs$e$verki$sj$(6269$xs$(6279$tiv$hmpyxih$wlevi2$[i$i|tigx$jypp1}iev

6464$viziryiw$xs$fi$ettvs|mqexip}$(627<$fmppmsr2

Jsv$xli$wigsrh$uyevxiv$sj$64640${i$i|tigx$Rix$Mrgsqi$Exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS$xs$fi$mr$e$verki$sj$(4264$xs$(4268$tiv$hmpyxih$wlevi?$Ehnywxih$Rix$Mrgsqi$xs

fi$mr$e$verki$sj$(4267$xs$(426;$tiv$hmpyxih$wlevi?$erh$EJJS$xs$fi$mr$e$verki$sj$(4298$xs$(429<$tiv$hmpyxih$wlevi2$Gsqtevih$xs$syv$jmvwx$uyevxiv$6464

viwypxw0$wigsrh$uyevxiv$6464$kymhergi$vijpigxw$ps{iv$iqtps}qirx$xe|$i|tirwiw0${lmgl$evi$jvsrx1psehih$mr$xli$jmvwx$uyevxiv$sj$iegl$}iev2

ÓQsviÓ$

Gsrxegx>$Tefps$I2$Tei~ $$ ,<::-$745$887:

I|igyxmzi$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx0$Gsvtsvexi$Vipexmsrw $$

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 10 of 34

Page 374: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\1==25

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=hi|==52lxq 9358

RI[W$VIPIEWI$

Jmrergmep$Jpi|mfmpmx}$erh$Pmuymhmx}

Ex$xli$irh$sj$xli$jmvwx$uyevxiv$sj$64640${i$leh$ettvs|mqexip}$(76$qmppmsr$mr$gewl$sr$lerh$erh$ettvs|mqexip}$(794$qmppmsr$mr$ezempefpi$fsvvs{mrk

getegmx}$yrhiv$syv$(=44$qmppmsr$vizspzmrk$gvihmx$jegmpmx}0${lmgl$qexyviw$mr$Qe}$64680$mr$ehhmxmsr$xs$er$eggsvhmsr$jiexyvi$sj$(894$qmppmsr$yrhiv$syv

wirmsv$gvihmx$jegmpmx}2$Jsv$xli$jypp1}iev$64640${i$lezi$vihygih$syv$tperrih$getmxep$wtirhmrk$f}$hijivvmrk$getmxep$i|tirhmxyvi$tvsnigxw${livi$tswwmfpi$erh

gpswip}$qerekmrk$syv${svomrk$getmxep2$[i$i|tigx$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw$mr$6464$xs$xsxep$ettvs|mqexip}$(<9$qmppmsr0$mrgpyhmrk$(5=$qmppmsr$mr$qemrxirergi

getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw2

Vigsrgmpmexmsr$Xefpiw$erh$Wyttpiqirxep$Mrjsvqexmsr

KIS$lew$qehi$ezempefpi$Wyttpiqirxep$Mrjsvqexmsr${lmgl$gsrxemrw$vigsrgmpmexmsr$xefpiw$sj$Rix$Mrgsqi$Exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS$xs$Rix$Stivexmrk$Mrgsqi0

Rix$Mrgsqi$xs$IFMXHEvi$,IFMXHE$jsv$viep$iwxexi-$erh$Ehnywxih$IFMXHEvi$,Ehnywxih$IFMXHE$jsv$viep$iwxexi-0$erh$Rix$Mrgsqi$Exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS

xs$JJS0$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$erh$EJJS0$epsrk${mxl$wyttpiqirxep$jmrergmep$erh$stivexmsrep$mrjsvqexmsr$sr$KIS×w$fywmriww$erh$sxliv$mqtsvxerx$stivexmrk

qixvmgw0$erh$mr$xlmw$tviww$vipiewi0$Rix$Mrgsqi$Exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS$xs$Ehnywxih$Rix$Mrgsqi2$Xli$vigsrgmpmexmsr$xefpiw$evi$epws$tviwirxih$livimr2$Tpiewi

wii$xli$wigxmsr$fips{$xmxpih$ÔRsxi$xs$Vigsrgmpmexmsr$Xefpiw$erh$Wyttpiqirxep$Hmwgpswyvi$1$Mqtsvxerx$Mrjsvqexmsr$sr$KIS×w$Rsr1KEET$Jmrergmep

QiewyviwÕ$jsv$mrjsvqexmsr$sr$ls{$KIS$hijmriw$xliwi$wyttpiqirxep$Rsr1KEET$jmrergmep$qiewyviw$erh$vigsrgmpiw$xliq$xs$xli$qswx$hmvigxp}$gsqtevefpi

KEET$qiewyviw2$KIS×w$Vigsrgmpmexmsr$Xefpiw$ger$fi$jsyrh$livimr$erh$mr$KIS×w$Wyttpiqirxep$Mrjsvqexmsr$ezempefpi$sr$KIS×w$mrziwxsv${ifteki$ex

mrziwxsvw2kiskvsyt2gsq2

Gsrjivirgi$Gepp$Mrjsvqexmsr

KIS$lew$wglihypih$e$gsrjivirgi$gepp$erh$wmqypxerisyw${ifgewx$jsv$xshe}$ex$55>44$EQ$,Iewxivr$Xmqi-$xs$hmwgyww$KIS×w$jmvwx$uyevxiv$6464$jmrergmep

viwypxw$ew${ipp$ew$mxw$syxpsso2$Xli$gepp1mr$ryqfiv$jsv$xli$Y2W2$mw$51<;;169415997$erh$xli$mrxivrexmsrep$gepp1mr$ryqfiv$mw$518561986185892$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$e

pmzi$eyhms${ifgewx$sj$xli$gsrjivirgi$gepp$qe}$fi$eggiwwih$sr$xli$Izirxw$erh$[ifgewxw$wigxmsr$yrhiv$xli$Ri{w0$Izirxw$erh$Vitsvxw$xef$sj$KIS×w

mrziwxsv$vipexmsrw${ifteki$ex$mrziwxsvw2kiskvsyt2gsq2$E$vitpe}$sj$xli${ifgewx${mpp$fi$ezempefpi$sr$xli${ifwmxi$jsv$sri$}iev2$E$xipitlsrmg$vitpe}$sj$xli

gsrjivirgi$gepp${mpp$fi$ezempefpi$yrxmp$Qe}$580$6464$ex$51<;;17881;96=$,Y2W2-$erh$51856175;144<<$,Mrxivrexmsrep-2$Xli$tevxmgmterx$tewwgshi$jsv$xli

xipitlsrmg$vitpe}$mw$54586<;62

Efsyx$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt

Xli$KIS$Kvsyt$,R]WI>$KIS-$mw$xli$jmvwx$jypp}$mrxikvexih$iuymx}$viep$iwxexi$mrziwxqirx$xvywx$wtigmepm~mrk$mr$xli$hiwmkr0$jmrergmrk0$hizipstqirx0$erh

stivexmsr$sj$wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw0$tvsgiwwmrk$girxivw0$erh$gsqqyrmx}$viirxv}$girxivw$mr$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw0$Eywxvepme0$Wsyxl$Ejvmge0$erh$xli$Yrmxih$Omrkhsq2

KIS$mw$e$piehmrk$tvszmhiv$sj$irlergih$mr1gywxsh}$vilefmpmxexmsr0$tswx1vipiewi$wyttsvx0$ipigxvsrmg$qsrmxsvmrk0$erh$gsqqyrmx}1fewih$tvskveqw2$KIS×w

{svph{mhi$stivexmsrw$mrgpyhi$xli$s{rivwlmt$erh3sv$qerekiqirx$sj$56:$jegmpmxmiw$xsxepmrk$ettvs|mqexip}$=80444$fihw0$mrgpyhmrk$tvsnigxw$yrhiv

hizipstqirx0${mxl$e${svojsvgi$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$670444$tvsjiwwmsrepw2

ÓQsviÓ$

Gsrxegx>$Tefps$I2$Tei~ $$ ,<::-$745$887:

I|igyxmzi$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx0$Gsvtsvexi$Vipexmsrw $$

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 11 of 34

Page 375: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\1==25

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=hi|==52lxq :358

RI[W$VIPIEWI$

Rsxi$xs$Vigsrgmpmexmsr$Xefpiw$erh$Wyttpiqirxep$Hmwgpswyvi$Ò

Mqtsvxerx$Mrjsvqexmsr$sr$KIS×w$Rsr1KEET$Jmrergmep$Qiewyviw

Rix$Stivexmrk$Mrgsqi0$IFMXHEvi0$Ehnywxih$IFMXHEvi0$Jyrhw$jvsq$Stivexmsrw0$Rsvqepm~ih$Jyrhw$jvsq$Stivexmsrw0$Ehnywxih$Jyrhw$jvsq$Stivexmsrw0

erh$Ehnywxih$Rix$Mrgsqi$evi$rsr1KEET$jmrergmep$qiewyviw$xlex$evi$tviwirxih$ew$wyttpiqirxep$hmwgpswyviw2$KIS$lew$tviwirxih$livimr$givxemr$jsv{evh1

pssomrk$wxexiqirxw$efsyx$KIS×w$jyxyvi$jmrergmep$tivjsvqergi$xlex$mrgpyhi$rsr1KEET$jmrergmep$qiewyviw0$mrgpyhmrk$Ehnywxih$Rix$Mrgsqi0$Ehnywxih

IFMXHEvi0$Rix$Stivexmrk$Mrgsqi0$JJS0$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS0$erh$EJJS2$Xli$hixivqmrexmsr$sj$xli$eqsyrxw$xlex$evi$mrgpyhih$sv$i|gpyhih$jvsq$xliwi

rsr1KEET$jmrergmep$qiewyviw$mw$e$qexxiv$sj$qerekiqirx$nyhkqirx$erh$hitirhw$ytsr0$eqsrk$sxliv$jegxsvw0$xli$rexyvi$sj$xli$yrhivp}mrk$i|tirwi$sv

mrgsqi$eqsyrxw$vigskrm~ih$mr$e$kmzir$tivmsh2$[lmpi${i$lezi$tvszmhih$e$lmkl$pizip$vigsrgmpmexmsr$jsv$xli$kymhergi$verkiw$jsv$jypp$}iev$64640${i$evi

yrefpi$xs$tviwirx$e$qsvi$hixempih$uyerxmxexmzi$vigsrgmpmexmsr$sj$xli$jsv{evh1pssomrk$rsr1KEET$jmrergmep$qiewyviw$xs$xlimv$qswx$hmvigxp}$gsqtevefpi

jsv{evh1pssomrk$KEET$jmrergmep$qiewyviw$figeywi$qerekiqirx$gerrsx$vipmefp}$tvihmgx$epp$sj$xli$rigiwwev}$gsqtsrirxw$sj$wygl$KEET$qiewyviw2$Xli

uyerxmxexmzi$vigsrgmpmexmsr$sj$xli$jsv{evh1pssomrk$rsr1KEET$jmrergmep$qiewyviw${mpp$fi$tvszmhih$jsv$gsqtpixih$erryep$erh$uyevxivp}$tivmshw0$ew

ettpmgefpi0$gepgypexih$mr$e$gsrwmwxirx$qerriv${mxl$xli$uyerxmxexmzi$vigsrgmpmexmsr$sj$rsr1KEET$jmrergmep$qiewyviw$tvizmsywp}$vitsvxih$jsv$gsqtpixih

erryep$erh$uyevxivp}$tivmshw2

Rix$Stivexmrk$Mrgsqi$mw$hijmrih$ew$viziryiw$piww$stivexmrk$i|tirwiw0$i|gpyhmrk$hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr$i|tirwi0$kirivep$erh$ehqmrmwxvexmzi

i|tirwiw0$viep$iwxexi$vipexih$stivexmrk$piewi$i|tirwi0$erh$wxevx1yt$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|2$Rix$Stivexmrk$Mrgsqi$mw$gepgypexih$ew$rix$mrgsqi$ehnywxih$f}

wyfxvegxmrk$iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw0$rix$sj$mrgsqi$xe|$tvszmwmsr0$erh$f}$ehhmrk$mrgsqi$xe|$tvszmwmsr0$mrxiviwx$i|tirwi0$rix$sj$mrxiviwx$mrgsqi0

kemr3psww$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx0$hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr$i|tirwi0$kirivep$erh$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw0$viep$iwxexi$vipexih$stivexmrk$piewi

i|tirwi0$kemr3psww$sr$viep$iwxexi$ewwixw0$tvi1xe|0$erh$wxevx1yt$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|2

IFMXHEvi$,IFMXHE$jsv$viep$iwxexi-$mw$hijmrih$ew$rix$mrgsqi$ehnywxih$f}$ehhmrk$tvszmwmsrw$jsv$mrgsqi$xe|0$mrxiviwx$i|tirwi0$rix$sj$mrxiviwx$mrgsqi0

hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr0$erh$kemr3psww$sr$viep$iwxexi$ewwixw0$tvi1xe|2$Ehnywxih$IFMXHEvi$,Ehnywxih$IFMXHE$jsv$viep$iwxexi-$mw$hijmrih$ew

IFMXHEvi$ehnywxih$jsv$rix$psww$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$rsr1gsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw0$wxsgo1fewih$gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|0$erh$givxemr$sxliv$ehnywxqirxw$ew

hijmrih$jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi0$mrgpyhmrk$jsv$xli$tivmshw$tviwirxih$wxevx1yt$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|0$GSZMH15=$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|0$erh$gpswi1syx$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|2

Kmzir$xli$rexyvi$sj$syv$fywmriww$ew$e$viep$iwxexi$s{riv$erh$stivexsv0${i$fipmizi$xlex$IFMXHEvi$erh$Ehnywxih$IFMXHEvi$evi$liptjyp$xs$mrziwxsvw$ew

qiewyviw$sj$syv$stivexmsrep$tivjsvqergi$figeywi$xli}$tvszmhi$er$mrhmgexmsr$sj$syv$efmpmx}$xs$mrgyv$erh$wivzmgi$hifx0$xs$wexmwj}$kirivep$stivexmrk

i|tirwiw0$xs$qeoi$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw$erh$xs$jyrh$sxliv$gewl$riihw$sv$vimrziwx$gewl$mrxs$syv$fywmriww2$[i$fipmizi$xlex$f}$viqszmrk$xli$mqtegx$sj$syv

ewwix$fewi$,tvmqevmp}$hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr-$erh$i|gpyhmrk$givxemr$rsr1gewl$glevkiw0$eqsyrxw$wtirx$sr$mrxiviwx$erh$xe|iw0$erh$givxemr$sxliv

glevkiw$xlex$evi$lmklp}$zevmefpi$jvsq$}iev$xs$}iev0$IFMXHEvi$erh$Ehnywxih$IFMXHEvi$tvszmhi$syv$mrziwxsvw${mxl$tivjsvqergi$qiewyviw$xlex$vijpigx$xli

mqtegx$xs$stivexmsrw$jvsq$xvirhw$mr$sggyterg}$vexiw0$tiv$hmiq$vexiw$erh$stivexmrk$gswxw0$tvszmhmrk$e$tivwtigxmzi$rsx$mqqihmexip}$ettevirx$jvsq$rix

mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS2

Xli$ehnywxqirxw${i$qeoi$xs$hivmzi$xli$rsr1KEET$qiewyviw$sj$IFMXHEvi$erh$Ehnywxih$IFMXHEvi$i|gpyhi$mxiqw${lmgl$qe}$geywi$wlsvx1xivq

jpygxyexmsrw$mr$mrgsqi$jvsq$gsrxmrymrk$stivexmsrw$erh${lmgl${i$hs$rsx$gsrwmhiv$xs$fi$xli$jyrheqirxep$exxvmfyxiw$sv$tvmqev}$hvmzivw$sj$syv$fywmriww$tper

erh$xli}$hs$rsx$ejjigx$syv$szivepp$psrk1xivq$stivexmrk$tivjsvqergi2$IFMXHEvi$erh$Ehnywxih$IFMXHEvi$tvszmhi$hmwgpswyvi$sr$xli$weqi$fewmw$ew$xlex

ywih$f}$syv$qerekiqirx$erh$tvszmhi$gsrwmwxirg}$mr$syv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk0$jegmpmxexi$mrxivrep$erh$i|xivrep$gsqtevmwsrw$sj$syv$lmwxsvmgep$stivexmrk

tivjsvqergi$erh$syv$fywmriww$yrmxw$erh$tvszmhi$gsrxmrymx}$xs$mrziwxsvw$jsv$gsqtevefmpmx}$tyvtswiw2

ÓQsviÓ$

Gsrxegx>$Tefps$I2$Tei~ $$ ,<::-$745$887:

I|igyxmzi$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx0$Gsvtsvexi$Vipexmsrw $$

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 12 of 34

Page 376: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\1==25

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=hi|==52lxq ;358

RI[W$VIPIEWI$

Jyrhw$Jvsq$Stivexmsrw0$sv$JJS0$mw$hijmrih$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$wxerhevhw$iwxefpmwlih$f}$xli$Rexmsrep$Ewwsgmexmsr$sj$Viep$Iwxexi$Mrziwxqirx$Xvywxw0$sv

REVIMX0${lmgl$hijmriw$JJS$ew$rix$mrgsqi3psww$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$gsqqsr$wlevilsphivw$,gsqtyxih$mr$eggsvhergi${mxl$Yrmxih$Wxexiw$Kirivepp}$Eggitxih

Eggsyrxmrk$Tvmrgmtpiw-0$i|gpyhmrk$viep$iwxexi$vipexih$hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr0$i|gpyhmrk$kemrw$erh$pswwiw$jvsq$xli$gyqypexmzi$ijjigxw$sj

eggsyrxmrk$glerkiw0$i|xvesvhmrev}$mxiqw$erh$wepiw$sj$tvstivxmiw0$erh$mrgpyhmrk$ehnywxqirxw$jsv$yrgsrwspmhexih$tevxrivwlmtw$erh$nsmrx$zirxyviw2

Rsvqepm~ih$Jyrhw$jvsq$Stivexmsrw0$sv$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS0$mw$hijmrih$ew$JJS$ehnywxih$jsv$givxemr$mxiqw${lmgl$f}$xlimv$rexyvi$evi$rsx$gsqtevefpi$jvsq

tivmsh$xs$tivmsh$sv$xlex$xirh$xs$sfwgyvi$KIS×w$egxyep$stivexmrk$tivjsvqergi0$mrgpyhmrk$jsv$xli$tivmshw$tviwirxih$kemr3psww$sr$xli$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx0

tvi1xe|0$wxevx1yt$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|0$GSZMH15=$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|0$gpswi1syx$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|0$erh$xe|$ijjigx$sj$ehnywxqirxw$xs$JJS2

Ehnywxih$Jyrhw$Jvsq$Stivexmsrw0$sv$EJJS0$mw$hijmrih$ew$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$ehnywxih$f}$ehhmrk$rsr1gewl$i|tirwiw$wygl$ew$rsr1viep$iwxexi$vipexih

hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr0$wxsgo$fewih$gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwi0$xli$eqsvxm~exmsr$sj$hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw0$hmwgsyrx$erh3sv$tviqmyq$erh$sxliv$rsr1gewl

mrxiviwx0$erh$f}$wyfxvegxmrk$vigyvvmrk$gsrwspmhexih$qemrxirergi$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw2

Ehnywxih$Rix$Mrgsqi$mw$hijmrih$ew$Rix$Mrgsqi$Exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS$ehnywxih$jsv$givxemr$mxiqw${lmgl$f}$xlimv$rexyvi$evi$rsx$gsqtevefpi$jvsq$tivmsh$xs

tivmsh$sv$xlex$xirh$xs$sfwgyvi$KIS×w$egxyep$stivexmrk$tivjsvqergi0$mrgpyhmrk$jsv$xli$tivmshw$tviwirxih$kemr3psww$sr$viep$iwxexi$ewwixw0$tvi1xe|0$kemr3psww

sr$xli$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx0$tvi1xe|0$wxevx1yt$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|0$GSZMH15=$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|0$gpswi1syx$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe|0$erh$xe|$ijjigx$sj

ehnywxqirxw$xs$Rix$Mrgsqi$Exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS2

Figeywi$sj$xli$yrmuyi$hiwmkr0$wxvygxyvi$erh$ywi$sj$syv$gsvvigxmsrep$jegmpmxmiw0$tvsgiwwmrk$girxivw0$erh$viirxv}$girxivw0${i$fipmizi$xlex$ewwiwwmrk$xli

tivjsvqergi$sj$syv$gsvvigxmsrep$jegmpmxmiw0$tvsgiwwmrk$girxivw0$erh$viirxv}$girxivw${mxlsyx$xli$mqtegx$sj$hitvigmexmsr$sv$eqsvxm~exmsr$mw$ywijyp$erh

qiermrkjyp$xs$mrziwxsvw2$Epxlsykl$REVIMX$lew$tyfpmwlih$mxw$hijmrmxmsr$sj$JJS0$gsqtermiw$sjxir$qshmj}$xlmw$hijmrmxmsr$ew$xli}$wiio$xs$tvszmhi$jmrergmep

qiewyviw$xlex$qiermrkjypp}$vijpigx$xlimv$hmwxmrgxmzi$stivexmsrw2$[i$lezi$qshmjmih$JJS$xs$hivmzi$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$erh$EJJS$xlex$qiermrkjypp}$vijpigx

syv$stivexmsrw2

Syv$ewwiwwqirx$sj$syv$stivexmsrw$mw$jsgywih$sr$psrk1xivq$wywxemrefmpmx}2$Xli$ehnywxqirxw${i$qeoi$xs$hivmzi$xli$rsr1KEET$qiewyviw$sj$Rsvqepm~ih

JJS$erh$EJJS$i|gpyhi$mxiqw${lmgl$qe}$geywi$wlsvx1xivq$jpygxyexmsrw$mr$rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS$fyx$lezi$rs$mqtegx$sr$syv$gewl$jps{w0$sv${i

hs$rsx$gsrwmhiv$xliq$xs$fi$jyrheqirxep$exxvmfyxiw$sv$xli$tvmqev}$hvmzivw$sj$syv$fywmriww$tper$erh$xli}$hs$rsx$ejjigx$syv$szivepp$psrk1xivq$stivexmrk

tivjsvqergi2$[i$qe}$qeoi$ehnywxqirxw$xs$JJS$jvsq$xmqi$xs$xmqi$jsv$givxemr$sxliv$mrgsqi$erh$i|tirwiw$xlex$hs$rsx$vijpigx$e$rigiwwev}$gsqtsrirx$sj

syv$stivexmsrep$tivjsvqergi$sr$xli$fewmw$hmwgywwih$efszi0$izir$xlsykl$wygl$mxiqw$qe}$viuymvi$gewl$wixxpiqirx2$Figeywi$JJS0$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$erh

EJJS$i|gpyhi$hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr$yrmuyi$xs$viep$iwxexi$ew${ipp$ew$rsr1stivexmsrep$mxiqw$erh$givxemr$sxliv$glevkiw$xlex$evi$lmklp}$zevmefpi

jvsq$}iev$xs$}iev0$xli}$tvszmhi$syv$mrziwxsvw${mxl$tivjsvqergi$qiewyviw$xlex$vijpigx$xli$mqtegx$xs$stivexmsrw$jvsq$xvirhw$mr$sggyterg}$vexiw0$tiv$hmiq

vexiw0$stivexmrk$gswxw$erh$mrxiviwx$gswxw0$tvszmhmrk$e$tivwtigxmzi$rsx$mqqihmexip}$ettevirx$jvsq$Rix$Mrgsqi$Exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS2

[i$fipmizi$xli$tviwirxexmsr$sj$JJS0$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$erh$EJJS$tvszmhi$ywijyp$mrjsvqexmsr$xs$mrziwxsvw$ew$xli}$tvszmhi$er$mrhmgexmsr$sj$syv$efmpmx}$xs

jyrh$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw$erh$i|terh$syv$fywmriww2$JJS0$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$erh$EJJS$tvszmhi$hmwgpswyvi$sr$xli$weqi$fewmw$ew$xlex$ywih$f}$syv

qerekiqirx$erh$tvszmhi$gsrwmwxirg}$mr$syv$jmrergmep$vitsvxmrk0$jegmpmxexi$mrxivrep$erh$i|xivrep$gsqtevmwsrw$sj$syv$lmwxsvmgep$stivexmrk$tivjsvqergi$erh

syv$fywmriww$yrmxw$erh$tvszmhi$gsrxmrymx}$xs$mrziwxsvw$jsv$gsqtevefmpmx}$tyvtswiw2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$JJS0$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$erh$EJJS$evi${mhip}$vigskrm~ih

qiewyviw$mr$syv$mrhywxv}$ew$e$viep$iwxexi$mrziwxqirx$xvywx2

ÓQsviÓ$

Gsrxegx>$Tefps$I2$Tei~ $$ ,<::-$745$887:

I|igyxmzi$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx0$Gsvtsvexi$Vipexmsrw $$

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 13 of 34

Page 377: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\1==25

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=hi|==52lxq <358

RI[W$VIPIEWI$

Weji1Levfsv$Wxexiqirx

Xlmw$tviww$vipiewi$gsrxemrw$jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw$vikevhmrk$jyxyvi$izirxw$erh$jyxyvi$tivjsvqergi$sj$KIS$xlex$mrzspzi$vmwow$erh$yrgivxemrxmiw$xlex

gsyph$qexivmepp}$ejjigx$egxyep$viwypxw0$mrgpyhmrk$wxexiqirxw$vikevhmrk$jmrergmep$kymhergi$jsv$xli$jypp$}iev$erh$wigsrh$uyevxiv$sj$64640$xli$ewwyqtxmsrw

yrhivp}mrk$wygl$kymhergi0$erh$wxexiqirxw$vikevhmrk$xli$mqtegx$sj$GSZMH15=0$syv$ezempefpi$fsvvs{mrk$getegmx}$erh$pmuymhmx}0$vihygih$tperrih$getmxep

wtirhmrk$erh$xli$eppsgexmsr$sj$getmxep$xs$irlergi$psrk1xivq$zepyi$jsv$syv$wlevilsphivw2$Jegxsvw$xlex$gsyph$geywi$egxyep$viwypxw$xs$zev}$jvsq$gyvvirx

i|tigxexmsrw$erh$jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw$gsrxemrih$mr$xlmw$tviww$vipiewi$mrgpyhi0$fyx$evi$rsx$pmqmxih$xs>$,5-$KIS×w$efmpmx}$xs$qiix$mxw$jmrergmep

kymhergi$jsv$6464$kmzir$xli$zevmsyw$vmwow$xs${lmgl$mxw$fywmriww$mw$i|tswih0$mrgpyhmrk$xli$qekrmxyhi0$wizivmx}0$erh$hyvexmsr$sj$xli$gyvvirx$GSZMH15=

kpsfep$terhiqmg$erh$mxw$mqtegx$sr$KIS?$,6-$KIS×w$efmpmx}$xs$higpevi$jyxyvi$uyevxivp}$gewl$hmzmhirhw$erh$xli$xmqmrk$erh$eqsyrx$sj$wygl$jyxyvi$gewl

hmzmhirhw?$,7-$KIS×w$efmpmx}$xs$wyggiwwjypp}$tyvwyi$jyvxliv$kvs{xl$erh$gsrxmryi$xs$gviexi$wlevilsphiv$zepyi?$,8-$KIS×w$efmpmx}$xs$sfxemr$jyxyvi$jmrergmrk

sr$eggitxefpi$xivqw?$,9-$KIS×w$efmpmx}$xs$eggiww$xli$getmxep$qevoixw$mr$xli$jyxyvi$sr$wexmwjegxsv}$xivqw$sv$ex$epp?$,:-$vmwow$ewwsgmexih${mxl$KIS×w$efmpmx}

xs$gsrxvsp$stivexmrk$gswxw$ewwsgmexih${mxl$gsrxvegx$wxevx1ytw?$,;-$KIS×w$efmpmx}$xs$xmqip}$stir$jegmpmxmiw$ew$tperrih0$tvsjmxefp}$qereki$wygl$jegmpmxmiw$erh

wyggiwwjypp}$mrxikvexi$wygl$jegmpmxmiw$mrxs$KIS×w$stivexmsrw${mxlsyx$wyfwxerxmep$gswxw?$,<-$KIS×w$efmpmx}$xs${mr$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw$jsv${lmgl$mx$lew

wyfqmxxih$tvstswepw$erh$xs$vixemr$i|mwxmrk$qerekiqirx$gsrxvegxw?$,=-$KIS×w$efmpmx}$xs$wywxemr$sv$mqtvszi$gsqter}1{mhi$sggyterg}$vexiw$ex$mxw$jegmpmxmiw

mr$pmklx$sj$xli$GSZMH15=$kpsfep$terhiqmg?$,54-$xli$mqtegx$sj$er}$jyxyvi$vikypexmsrw$sv$kymhergi$sr$xli$Xe|$Gyxw$erh$Nsfw$Egx?$,55-$KIS×w$efmpmx}$xs

viqemr$uyepmjmih$ew$e$VIMX?$,56-$xli$mrgyvvirgi$sj$VIMX$vipexih$i|tirwiw?$erh$,57-$sxliv$jegxsvw$gsrxemrih$mr$KIS×w$Wigyvmxmiw$erh$I|glerki

Gsqqmwwmsr$tivmshmg$jmpmrkw0$mrgpyhmrk$mxw$Jsvq$541O0$541U$erh$<1O$vitsvxw2$

Gsrxegx>$Tefps$I2$Tei~ $$ ,<::-$745$887:

I|igyxmzi$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx0$Gsvtsvexi$Vipexmsrw $$

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 14 of 34

Page 378: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\1==25

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=hi|==52lxq =358

RI[W$VIPIEWI$

Gsrhirwih$Gsrwspmhexih$Fepergi$Wliixw.

,Yreyhmxih-

$$ $$ Ew$sj $ $$ Ew$sj $$ $$ Qevgl$750$6464$ $$ Higiqfiv$750$645=$$ $$ ,yreyhmxih- $ $$ ,yreyhmxih- $

EWWIXW $$ $$

Gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw $$ ( 760858$$$ ( 7608:7$

Viwxvmgxih$gewl$erh$gewl$iuymzepirxw $$ $ 6;0<:9$$$ $ 76085<$

Eggsyrxw$vigimzefpi0$piww$epps{ergi$jsv$hsyfxjyp$eggsyrxw $$ $ 7;90897$$$ $ 8740=<6$

Gsrxvegx$vigimzefpi0$gyvvirx$tsvxmsr $$ $ 80:<:$$$ $ 5505==$

Tvitemh$i|tirwiw$erh$sxliv$gyvvirx$ewwixw $$ $ 7:054<$$$ $ 840;5:$$$ $ $

$$$ $ $

$

Xsxep$gyvvirx$ewwixw $$ ( 8;:096:$$$ ( 98;0;;<$

Viwxvmgxih$Gewl$erh$Mrziwxqirxw $$ $ 6;06;5$$$ $ 740=67$

Tvstivx}$erh$Iuymtqirx0$Rix $$ $ 605860974$$$ $ 605880;66$

Gsrxvegx$Vigimzefpi $$ $ 75=0<5=$$$ $ 7:40:8;$

Stivexmrk$Piewi$Vmklx1sj1Ywi$Ewwixw0$Rix $$ $ 56708:9$$$ $ 565096;$

Ewwixw$Liph$jsv$Wepi $$ $ 80849$$$ $ :049=$

Hijivvih$Mrgsqi$Xe|$Ewwixw $$ $ 7:06;<$$$ $ 7:06;<$

Mrxerkmfpi$Ewwixw0$Rix$,mrgpyhmrk$kssh{mpp- $$ $ =<40:=7$$$ $ =<:086:$

Sxliv$Rsr1Gyvvirx$Ewwixw $$ $ ;:0<:4$$$ $ <705;8$$$ $ $

$$$ $ $

$

Xsxep$Ewwixw $$ ( 805<;0<8;$$$ ( 8075;0978$$$ $ $

$

$$ $ $

$

PMEFMPMXMIW$ERH$WLEVILSPHIVW×$IUYMX] $$ $$

Eggsyrxw$te}efpi $$ ( =60<<;$$$ ( ==0676$

Eggvyih$te}vspp$erh$vipexih$xe|iw $$ $ :70449$$$ $ 980:;6$

Eggvyih$i|tirwiw$erh$sxliv$gyvvirx$pmefmpmxmiw $$ $ 5;<0<78$$$ $ 5=50:4<$

Stivexmrk$piewi$pmefmpmxmiw0$gyvvirx$tsvxmsr $$ $ 6:0=:<$$$ $ 6:064<$

Gyvvirx$tsvxmsr$sj$jmrergi$piewi$sfpmkexmsrw0$psrk1xivq$hifx0$erh$rsr1vigsyvwi$hifx $$ $ 670:69$$$ $ 68064<$$$ $ $

$$$ $ $

$

Xsxep$gyvvirx$pmefmpmxmiw $$ ( 7<9075=$$$ ( 7=90=6<$

Hijivvih$Mrgsqi$Xe|$Pmefmpmxmiw $$ $ 5=0698$$$ $ 5=0698$

Sxliv$Rsr1Gyvvirx$Pmefmpmxmiw $$ $ <609=5$$$ $ <<096:$

Stivexmrk$Piewi$Pmefmpmxmiw $$ $ ==0758$$$ $ =;06=5$

Jmrergi$Piewi$Pmefmpmxmiw $$ $ 609:7$$$ $ 60=98$

Psrk1Xivq$Hifx $$ $ 607;40<=4$$$ $ 6084<06=;$

Rsr1Vigsyvwi$Hifx $$ $ 6;408:4$$$ $ 74=067:$

Xsxep$Wlevilsphivw×$Iuymx} $$ $ =9;089:$$$ $ ==:048<$$$ $ $

$$$ $ $

$

Xsxep$Pmefmpmxmiw$erh$Wlevilsphivw×$Iuymx} $$ ( 805<;0<8;$$$ ( 8075;0978$$$ $ $

$

$$ $ $

$

$

. epp$jmkyviw$mr$Ö444w$

Ó$Qsvi$Ó

$Gsrxegx>$Tefps$I2$Tei~ $$ ,<::-$745$887:

I|igyxmzi$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx0$Gsvtsvexi$Vipexmsrw $$

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 15 of 34

Page 379: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\1==25

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=hi|==52lxq 54358

RI[W$VIPIEWI$

Gsrhirwih$Gsrwspmhexih$Wxexiqirxw$sj$Stivexmsrw.

,Yreyhmxih-

$$ $$ U5$6464 $ $ U5$645= $$ $$ ,yreyhmxih-$ $ ,yreyhmxih-$

Viziryiw $$ (:49045;$ $ (:540::;$

Stivexmrk$i|tirwiw $$ $ 8:50766$ $ $ 89:0==;$

Hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr $$ $ 77076;$ $ $ 7608:=$

Kirivep$erh$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw $$ $ 970;<6$ $ $ 8:0868$$$ $ $

$$ $ $

$

Stivexmrk$mrgsqi $$ $ 9:09<:$ $ $ ;80;;;$

Mrxiviwx$mrgsqi $$ $ 9087<$ $ $ <07=:$

Mrxiviwx$i|tirwi $$ $ ,7805<4-$$ $ ,8406<4-$

Kemr$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx $$ $ 509:7$ $ $ Ó$$$$$ $ $

$$ $ $

$

Mrgsqi$fijsvi$mrgsqi$xe|iw$erh$iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw $$ $ 6=084;$ $ $ 860<=7$

Tvszmwmsr$jsv$mrgsqi$xe|iw $$ $ :098:$ $ $ 80<84$

Iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw0$rix$sj$mrgsqi$xe|$tvszmwmsr $$ $ 606:4$ $ $ 609=:$$$ $ $

$$ $ $

$

Rix$mrgsqi $$ $ 690565$ $ $ 840:8=$

Piww>$Rix$psww$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$rsrgsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw $$ $ :4$ $ $ 9:$$$ $ $

$$ $ $

$

Rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2 $$ ( 6905<5$ $ ( 840;49$$$ $ $

$

$ $ $

$

[imklxih$Eziveki$Gsqqsr$Wleviw$Syxwxerhmrk> $$ $

Fewmg $$ $ 55=07=8$ $ $ 55<0;;8$

Hmpyxih $$ $ 55=0=77$ $ $ 55=08=:$

Rix$mrgsqi$tiv$Gsqqsr$Wlevi$Exxvmfyxefpi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2$> $$ $

Fewmg> $$ $

Rix$mrgsqi$tiv$wlevi$Ó$fewmg $$ ( 4265$ $ ( 4278$$$ $ $

$

$ $ $

$

Hmpyxih> $$ $

Rix$mrgsqi$tiv$wlevi$Ó$hmpyxih $$ ( 4265$ $ ( 4278$$$ $ $

$

$ $ $

$

Vikypev$Hmzmhirhw$Higpevih$tiv$Gsqqsr$Wlevi $$ ( 428<$ $ ( 428<$$$ $ $

$

$ $ $

$

$. epp$jmkyviw$mr$Ö444w0$i|gitx$tiv$wlevi$hexe$

Ó$Qsvi$Ó

$Gsrxegx>$Tefps$I2$Tei~ $$ ,<::-$745$887:

I|igyxmzi$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx0$Gsvtsvexi$Vipexmsrw $$

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 16 of 34

Page 380: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\1==25

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=hi|==52lxq 55358

RI[W$VIPIEWI$

Vigsrgmpmexmsr$sj$Rix$Mrgsqi$Exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS$xs$Ehnywxih$Rix$Mrgsqi

,Mr$xlsywerhw0$i|gitx$tiv$wlevi$hexe-,Yreyhmxih-

$$ $$ U5$6464 $ $ U5$645= $

Rix$Mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS $$ ( 6905<5$ $ ( 840;49$

Ehh> $$ $

,Kemr-3Psww$sr$viep$iwxexi$ewwixw0$tvi1xe| $$ $ ,868-$$ $ 508=;$

,Kemr-3Psww$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx0$tvi1xe| $$ $ ,509:7-$$ $ Ó$$$

Wxevx1yt$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe| $$ $ 50=97$ $ $ Ó$$$

GSZMH15=$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe| $$ $ <=6$ $ $ Ó$$$

Gpswi1syx$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe| $$ $ 50=7:$ $ $ Ó$$$

Xe|$ijjigx$sj$ehnywxqirxw$xs$Rix$Mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS $$ $ <7;$ $ $ ,89-$$$ $ $

$$ $ $

$

Ehnywxih$Rix$Mrgsqi $$ ( 6<0<56$ $ ( 86059;$$$ $ $

$

$ $ $

$

[imklxih$eziveki$gsqqsr$wleviw$syxwxerhmrk$1$Hmpyxih $$ $ 55=0=77$ $ $ 55=08=:$

Ehnywxih$Rix$Mrgsqi$Tiv$Hmpyxih$Wlevi $$ ( 4268$ $ ( 4279$$

Ó$Qsvi$Ó

$Gsrxegx>$Tefps$I2$Tei~ $$ ,<::-$745$887:

I|igyxmzi$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx0$Gsvtsvexi$Vipexmsrw $$

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 17 of 34

Page 381: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\1==25

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=hi|==52lxq 56358

RI[W$VIPIEWI$

Vigsrgmpmexmsr$sj$Rix$Mrgsqi$Exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS$xs$JJS0$Rsvqepm~ih$JJS0$erh$EJJS.

,Yreyhmxih-

$$ $$ U5$6464 $ $ U5$645= $$ $$ ,yreyhmxih-$ $ ,yreyhmxih-$

Rix$Mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS $$ ( 6905<5$ $ ( 840;49$

Ehh$,Wyfxvegx-> $$ $

Viep$Iwxexi$Vipexih$Hitvigmexmsr$erh$Eqsvxm~exmsr $$ $ 5<07=9$ $ $ 5<0547$

,Kemr-3Psww$sr$viep$iwxexi$ewwixw $$ $ ,868-$$ $ 508=;$$$ $ $

$$ $ $

$

Iuyepw>$REVIMX$hijmrih$JJS $$ ( 870596$ $ ( :40749$$$ $ $

$

$ $ $

$

Ehh$,Wyfxvegx-> $$ $

,Kemr-3Psww$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx0$tvi1xe| $$ $ ,509:7-$$ $ Ó$$$

Wxevx1yt$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe| $$ $ 50=97$ $ $ Ó$$$

GSZMH15=$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe| $$ $ <=6$ $ $ Ó$$$

Gpswi1syx$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe| $$ $ 50=7:$ $ $ Ó$$$

Xe|$Ijjigx$sj$ehnywxqirxw$xs$Jyrhw$Jvsq$Stivexmsrw$.. $$ $ <7;$ $ $ ,89-$$$ $ $

$$ $ $

$

Iuyepw>$JJS0$rsvqepm~ih $$ ( 8;064;$ $ ( :406:4$$$ $ $

$

$ $ $

$

Ehh$,Wyfxvegx-> $$ $

Rsr1Viep$Iwxexi$Vipexih$Hitvigmexmsr$*$Eqsvxm~exmsr $$ $ 580=76$ $ $ 5807::$

Gsrwspmhexih$Qemrxirergi$Getmxep$I|tirhmxyviw $$ $ ,;046;-$$ $ ,70:78-$

Wxsgo$Fewih$Gsqtirwexmsr$I|tirwiw $$ $ =0;:<$ $ $ :0;6;$

Eqsvxm~exmsr$sj$hifx$mwwyergi$gswxw0$hmwgsyrx$erh3sv$tviqmyq$erh$sxliv$rsr1gewl$mrxiviwx $$ $ 50:;4$ $ $ 609:7$$$ $ $

$$ $ $

$

Iuyepw>$EJJS $$ ( ::0994$ $ ( <406<6$$$ $ $

$

$ $ $

$

[imklxih$eziveki$gsqqsr$wleviw$syxwxerhmrk$1$Hmpyxih $$ $ 55=0=77$ $ $ 55=08=:$

JJS3EJJS$tiv$Wlevi$1$Hmpyxih $$ $

Rsvqepm~ih$JJS$Tiv$Hmpyxih$Wlevi $$ ( 427=$ $ ( 4294$

EJJS$Tiv$Hmpyxih$Wlevi $$ ( 4299$ $ ( 42:;$

$$$$Vikypev$Gsqqsr$Wxsgo$Hmzmhirhw$tiv$gsqqsr$wlevi $$ ( 428<$ $ ( 428<$

$. epp$jmkyviw$mr$Ö444w0$i|gitx$tiv$wlevi$hexe

.. xe|$ehnywxqirxw$vipexih$xs$,Kemr-3Psww$sr$viep$iwxexi$ewwixw0$,Kemr-3Psww$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx0$Wxevx1yt$i|tirwiw0$Gszmh15=$i|tirwiw0

Gpswi1syx$i|tirwiw$erh$Psww$sr$Mrziwxqirx$mr$Pmji$Mrwyvergi2$

Ó$Qsvi$Ó

$Gsrxegx>$Tefps$I2$Tei~ $$ ,<::-$745$887:

I|igyxmzi$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx0$Gsvtsvexi$Vipexmsrw $$

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 18 of 34

Page 382: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\1==25

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=hi|==52lxq 57358

RI[W$VIPIEWI$

Vigsrgmpmexmsr$sj$Rix$Mrgsqi$Exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS$xs

Rix$Stivexmrk$Mrgsqi0$IFMXHEvi$erh$Ehnywxih$IFMXHEvi.

,Yreyhmxih-

$$ $$ U5$6464 $ $ U5$645= $$ $$ ,yreyhmxih-$ $ ,yreyhmxih-$

Rix$Mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS $$ ( 6905<5$ $ ( 840;49$

Piww $$ $

Rix$psww$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$rsrgsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw $$ $ :4$ $ $ 9:$$$ $ $

$$ $ $

$

Rix$Mrgsqi $$ ( 690565$ $ ( 840:8=$

Ehh$,Wyfxvegx-> $$ $

Iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw0$rix$sj$mrgsqi$xe|$tvszmwmsr $$ $ ,606:4-$$ $ ,609=:-$

Mrgsqi$xe|$tvszmwmsr $$ $ :098:$ $ $ 80<84$

Mrxiviwx$i|tirwi0$rix$sj$mrxiviwx$mrgsqi $$ $ 6<0;86$ $ $ 750<<8$

,Kemr-3Psww$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx $$ $ ,509:7-$$ $ Ó$$$

Hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr $$ $ 77076;$ $ $ 7608:=$

Kirivep$erh$ehqmrmwxvexmzi$i|tirwiw $$ $ 970;<6$ $ $ 8:0868$$$ $ $

$$ $ $

$

Rix$Stivexmrk$Mrgsqi0$rix$sj$stivexmrk$piewi$sfpmkexmsrw $$ (5870:=9$ $ (5970:;4$$$ $ $

$

$ $ $

$

Ehh> $$ $

Stivexmrk$piewi$i|tirwi0$viep$iwxexi $$ $ 80=97$ $ $ :0:4<$

,Kemr-3Psww$sr$viep$iwxexi$ewwixw0$tvi1xe| $$ $ ,868-$$ $ 508=;$

Wxevx1yt$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe| $$ $ 50=97$ $ $ Ó$$$$$ $ $

$$ $ $

$

Rix$Stivexmrk$Mrgsqi$,RSM- $$ (59405;;$ $ (5:50;;9$$$ $ $

$

$ $ $

$

$ $$ U5$6464 $ $ U5$645= $$ $$ ,yreyhmxih-$ $ ,yreyhmxih-$

Rix$Mrgsqi $$ ( 690565$ $ ( 840:8=$

Ehh$,Wyfxvegx-> $$ $

Mrgsqi$xe|$tvszmwmsr$.. $$ $ :0=<=$ $ $ 905==$

Mrxiviwx$i|tirwi0$rix$sj$mrxiviwx$mrgsqi$... $$ $ 6;05;=$ $ $ 750<<8$

Hitvigmexmsr$erh$eqsvxm~exmsr $$ $ 77076;$ $ $ 7608:=$

,Kemr-3Psww$sr$viep$iwxexi$ewwixw0$tvi1xe| $$ $ ,868-$$ $ 508=;$$$ $ $

$$ $ $

$

IFMXHEvi $$ ( =605=6$ $ ( 5550:=<$$$ $ $

$

$ $ $

$

Ehh$,Wyfxvegx-> $$ $

Rix$psww$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$rsrgsrxvsppmrk$mrxiviwxw $$ $ :4$ $ $ 9:$

Wxsgo$fewih$gsqtirwexmsr$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe| $$ $ =0;:<$ $ $ :0;6;$

Wxevx1yt$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe| $$ $ 50=97$ $ $ Ó$$$

GSZMH15=$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe| $$ $ <=6$ $ $ Ó$$$

Gpswi1syx$i|tirwiw0$tvi1xe| $$ $ 50=7:$ $ $ Ó$$$$$ $ $

$$ $ $

$

Ehnywxih$IFMXHEvi $$ (54:0<45$ $ (55<08<5$$$ $ $

$

$ $ $

$

$. epp$jmkyviw$mr$Ö444w

.. mrgpyhmrk$mrgsqi$xe|$tvszmwmsr$sr$iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw

... mrgpyhiw$,kemr-3psww$sr$i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx$

Ó$Qsvi$Ó

$Gsrxegx>$Tefps$I2$Tei~ $$ ,<::-$745$887:

I|igyxmzi$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx0$Gsvtsvexi$Vipexmsrw $$

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 19 of 34

Page 383: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\1==25

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=hi|==52lxq 58358

RI[W$VIPIEWI$

6464$Syxpsso3Vigsrgmpmexmsr

,Mr$xlsywerhw0$i|gitx$tiv$wlevi$hexe-

,Yreyhmxih-

$$ $$ J]$6464 $

Rix$Mrgsqi$Exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS $$(5540944$ $ $ xs$$$(5670944$

Viep$Iwxexi$Vipexih$Hitvigmexmsr$erh$Eqsvxm~exmsr $$ $ ;80944$ $ $$ $ ;80944$$$ $ $

$$ $$ $ $

$

Jyrhw$jvsq$Stivexmsrw$,JJS- $$(5<90444$ $ $ xs$$$(5=<0444$$$ $ $

$$ $$ $ $

$

Rix$Ehnywxqirxw$,Kemr$sr$I|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$Hifx0$Wxevx1yt$i|tirwiw0$Gpswi1syx$i|tirwiw0$GSZMH15=$i|tirwiw- $$ $ 540444$ $ $$ $ 540444$$$ $ $

$$ $$ $ $

$

Rsvqepm~ih$Jyrhw$jvsq$Stivexmsrw $$(5=90444$ $ $ xs$$$(64<0444$$$ $ $

$$ $$ $ $

$

Rsr1Viep$Iwxexi$Vipexih$Hitvigmexmsr$erh$Eqsvxm~exmsr $$ $ :60444$ $ $$ $ :60444$

Gsrwspmhexih$Qemrxirergi$Geti| $$ $ ,5=0444-$$ $$ $ ,5=0444-$

Rsr1Gewl$Wxsgo$Fewih$Gsqtirwexmsr $$ $ 680944$ $ $$ $ 680944$

Rsr1Gewl$Mrxiviwx$I|tirwi $$ $ ;0444$ $ $$ $ ;0444$$$ $ $

$$ $$ $ $

$

Ehnywxih$Jyrhw$Jvsq$Stivexmsrw$,EJJS- $$(6:=0944$ $ $ xs$$$(6<60944$$$ $ $

$$ $$ $ $

$

Rix$Mrxiviwx$I|tirwi $$ $ 5490444$ $ $$ $ 5490444$

Rsr1Gewl$Mrxiviwx$I|tirwi $$ $ ,;0444-$$ $$ $ ,;0444-$

Gsrwspmhexih$Qemrxirergi$Geti| $$ $ 5=0444$ $ $$ $ 5=0444$

Mrgsqi$Xe|iw$,mrgpyhmrk$mrgsqi$xe|$tvszmwmsr$sr$iuymx}$mr$ievrmrkw$sj$ejjmpmexiw- $$ $ 5<0944$ $ $$ $ 5<0944$$$ $ $

$$ $$ $ $

$

Ehnywxih$IFMXHEvi $$(8490444$ $ $ xs$$$(85<0444$$$ $ $

$$ $$ $ $

$

K*E$I|tirwiw $$ $ 5=<0444$ $ $$ $ 5=<0444$

Rsr1Gewl$Wxsgo$Fewih$Gsqtirwexmsr $$ $ ,680944-$$ $$ $ ,680944-$

Iuymx}$mr$Ievrmrkw$sj$Ejjmpmexiw $$ $ ,;0444-$$ $$ $ ,;0444-$

Viep$Iwxexi$Vipexih$Stivexmrk$Piewi$I|tirwi $$ $ 5<0444$ $ $$ $ 5<0444$$$ $ $

$$ $$ $ $

$

Rix$Stivexmrk$Mrgsqi $$(9<=0944$ $ $ xs$$$(:460944$$$ $ $

$$ $$ $ $

$

Ehnywxih$Rix$Mrgsqi$Tiv$Hmpyxih$Wlevi $$( 5244$ $ $ xs$$$( 5256$

EJJS$Tiv$Hmpyxih$Wlevi $$( 6269$ $ $ xs$$$( 6279$

[imklxih$Eziveki$Gsqqsr$Wleviw$Syxwxerhmrk1Hmpyxih $$ $ 5640444$ $ $ xs$$$ $ 5640444$$

Ó$IrhÓ

$Gsrxegx>$Tefps$I2$Tei~ $$ ,<::-$745$887:

I|igyxmzi$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx0$Gsvtsvexi$Vipexmsrw $$

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 20 of 34

Page 384: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\1==26

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=hi|==62lxq 5358

I|lmfmx$==26

$GSVTSVEXI$TEVXMGMTERXW $$

Tefps$I2$Tei~

I|igyxmzi$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx1Gsvtsvexi$Vipexmsrw0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2 $$

N2$Hezmh$Hsrelyi

Wirmsv$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx$*$Tviwmhirx1KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw0$Xli$KIS

Kvsyt0$Mrg2

Kisvki$G2$^spi} $$Err$Q2$Wglpevf

Glemvqer0$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$*$Jsyrhiv0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2 $$Wirmsv$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx$*$Tviwmhirx1KIS$Gevi0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

Fvmer$V2$Izerw $$

Glmij$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv$*$Wirmsv$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2 $$

SXLIV$TEVXMGMTERXW $$

Nsi$Ksqiw $$Hezmh$Rejx~kiv

Erep}wx0$Rsfpi$Getmxep$Qevoixw0$Mrg2 $$Erep}wx0$Evxmie$Getmxep$Qerekiqirx2

Qmxve$Veqkstep $$Levzi}$Tsttip

Erep}wx0$Wmhsxm$*$Gs2$PPG $$S{riv0$Tstxigl$PT

$Qerekiqirx$Hmwgywwmsr$Wigxmsr

Stivexsv

Kssh$qsvrmrk0$erh${ipgsqi$xs$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt$Jmvwx$Uyevxiv$6464$Ievrmrkw$Gsrjivirgi$Gepp2$Epp$tevxmgmterxw${mpp$fi$mr$e$pmwxir1srp}$qshi2$_Stivexsv

Mrwxvygxmsrwa$Ejxiv$xshe}×w$tviwirxexmsr0$xlivi${mpp$fi$er$sttsvxyrmx}$xs$ewo$uyiwxmsrw2$_Stivexsv$Mrwxvygxmsrwa$Tpiewi$rsxi$xlmw$izirx$mw$fimrk$vigsvhih2

M${syph$rs{$pmoi$xs$xyvr$xli$gsrjivirgi$sziv$xs$Tefps$Tei~0$I|igyxmzi$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx$sj$Gsvtsvexi$Vipexmsrw2$Tpiewi$ks$elieh2

Tefps$I2$Tei~

I|igyxmzi$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx1Gsvtsvexi$Vipexmsrw0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

Xlero$}sy0$stivexsv2$Kssh$qsvrmrk0$iziv}sri0$erh$xlero$}sy$jsv$nsmrmrk$yw$jsv$xshe}×w$hmwgywwmsr$sj$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt×w$jmvwx$uyevxiv$6464$ievrmrkw

viwypxw2$[mxl$yw$xshe}$evi$Kisvki$^spi}0$Glemvqer$erh$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv?$Fvmer$Izerw0$Wirmsv$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx$erh$Glmij$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv?$Err

Wglpevf0$Wirmsv$Tviwmhirx$erh$Tviwmhirx$sj$KIS$Gevi?$erh$Hezmh$Hsrelyi0$Wirmsv$Tviwmhirx$sj$KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw2

Xlmw$qsvrmrk0${i${mpp$hmwgyww$syv$jmvwx$uyevxiv$viwypxw$erh$syxpsso$jsv$xli$fepergi$sj$xli$}iev2$[i${mpp$gsrgpyhi$xli$gepp${mxl$e$uyiwxmsr1erh1erw{iv

wiwwmsr2$Xlmw$gsrjivirgi$gepp$mw$epws$fimrk${ifgewx$pmzi$sr$syv$Mrziwxsv${ifwmxi$ex$mrziwxsvw2kiskvsyt2gsq2

Xshe}0${i${mpp$hmwgyww$rsr1KEET$fewmw$mrjsvqexmsr2$E$vigsrgmpmexmsr$jvsq$rsr1KEET$fewmw$mrjsvqexmsr$xs$KEET$fewmw$viwypxw$mw$mrgpyhih$mr$xli$tviww

vipiewi$erh$wyttpiqirxep$hmwgpswyvi${i$mwwyih$xlmw$qsvrmrk2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$qygl$sj$xli$mrjsvqexmsr${i${mpp$hmwgyww$xshe}0$mrgpyhmrk$xli$erw{ivw${i$kmzi

mr$viwtsrwi$xs$}syv$uyiwxmsrw0$qe}$mrgpyhi$jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw$vikevhmrk$syv$fipmijw$erh$gyvvirx$i|tigxexmsrw${mxl$viwtigx$xs$zevmsyw$qexxivw2

Xliwi$jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw$evi$mrxirhih$xs$jepp${mxlmr$xli$Weji$Levfsv$tvszmwmsrw$sj$xli$wigyvmxmiw$pe{w2$Syv$egxyep$viwypxw$qe}$hmjjiv$qexivmepp}

jvsq$xlswi$mr$xli$jsv{evh1pssomrk$wxexiqirxw$ew$e$viwypx$sj$zevmsyw$jegxsvw$gsrxemrih$mr$syv$Wigyvmxmiw$erh$I|glerki$Gsqqmwwmsr$jmpmrkw0$mrgpyhmrk$xli

Jsvq$541O0$541U$erh$<1O$vitsvxw2

[mxl$xlex0$tpiewi$epps{$qi$xs$xyvr$xlmw$gepp$sziv$xs$syv$Glemvqer$erh$GIS0$Kisvki$^spi}2$KisvkiC

Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Glemvqer0$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$*$Jsyrhiv0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 21 of 34

Page 385: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\1==26

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=hi|==62lxq 6358

Xlero$}sy0$Tefps0$erh$kssh$qsvrmrk$xs$iziv}sri2$Xlmw$qsvrmrk0${i$vitsvxih$syv$jmvwx$uyevxiv$viwypxw0$ythexih$syv$kymhergi$jsv$xli$jypp$}iev$erh$mwwyih

kymhergi$jsv$xli$wigsrh$uyevxiv2$Ew$syv$gsyrxv}$erh$xli${svph$jegih$er$yrtvigihirxih$liepxl$erh$igsrsqmg$gvmwmw0$KIS$iqtps}iiw$erh$jegmpmxmiw

xlvsyklsyx$xli$Yrmxih$Wxexiw$erh$mrxivrexmsrepp}$lezi$epws$fiir$mqtegxih$f}$xli$wtvieh$sj$GSZMH15=$zmvyw2$Wsqi$sj$syv$iqtps}iiw$pmzi$mr$gsqqyrmxmiw

xlex$lezi$irhyvih$wmkrmjmgerx$levhwlmt$erh$e$ji{$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$lezi$i|tivmirgih$gewiw$sj$GSZMH15=$mr$fsxl$syv$wxejj$erh$mrhmzmhyepw$irxvywxih$xs$syv

gevi2$Jvsq$xli$syxwix$sj$xlmw$kpsfep$terhiqmg0$syv$gsvtsvexi0$vikmsrep$erh$jmiph$wxejj$lezi$mqtpiqirxih$gsqtvilirwmzi$wxitw$xs$ehhviww$erh$qmxmkexi$xli

vmwow$sj$GSZMH15=$xs$epp$sj$xlswi$mr$syv$gevi$erh$syv$iqtps}iiw2$Irwyvmrk$xli$liepxl$erh$wejix}$sj$epp$xlswi$mr$syv$jegmpmxmiw$erh$syv$iqtps}iiw$lew

ep{e}w$fiir$syv$ryqfiv$sri$tvmsvmx}2

Ew$e$psrkwxerhmrk$tvszmhiv$sj$iwwirxmep$kszivrqirx$wivzmgiw0${i$lezi$xli$i|tivmirgi${mxl$xli$mqtpiqirxexmsr$sj$fiwx$tvegxmgiw$jsv$xli$tvizirxmsr0

ewwiwwqirx$erh$xli$qerekiqirx$sj$mrjigxmsyw$hmwiewiw2$Epp$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$stivexi$wejip}$erh${mxlsyx$szivgvs{hih$gsrhmxmsrw2$Epp$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$lezi

eggiww$xs$vikypev$lerh${ewlmrk${mxl$gpier${exiv$erh$wset$ew${ipp$ew$eqtpi$l}kmiri$erh$wermxexmsr$tvshygxw2$Epp$sj$syv$KIS$Wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw$tvszmhi

683;$eggiww$xs$liepxlgevi2$Mr$xli$gewi$sj$syv$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxivw0$xli$ryqfiv$sj$liepxlgevi$wxejj$mw$x}tmgepp}$hsyfpi$xli$ryqfiv$sj$liepxlgevi$wxejj$ex

wxexi$gsvvigxmsrep$jegmpmxmiw2$Qswx$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$evi$iuymttih${mxl$emvfsvri$mrjigxmsr$mwspexmsr$vssqw$wtigmjmgepp}$hiwmkrih$xs$qereki$mrjigxmsyw

hmwiewiw2

Hyvmrk$xlmw$gepp0$Hezmh$Hsrelyi$erh$Err$Wglpevf${mpp$hmwgyww$xli$wxitw${i×zi$xeoir$ex$syv$KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$erh$KIS$Gevi$jegmpmxmiw$xs$mqtpiqirx

fiwx$tvegxmgiw$gsrwmwxirx${mxl$xli$kymhergi$mwwyih$f}$xli$Girxiv$jsv$Hmwiewi$Gsrxvsp$erh$Tvizirxmsr2$Izir$xlsykl${i$lezi$gsrxmryih$syv$stivexmsrw$ew

er$iwwirxmep$kszivrqirx$wivzmgi$tvszmhiv0$xli$wtvieh$sj$GSZMH15=$lew$epws$rikexmzip}$mqtegxih$syv$tvsnigxih$viziryiw$erh$gewl$jps{w$jsv$xli$}iev2

Syv$MGI$erh$Y2W2$Qevwlepw$jegmpmxmiw$lezi$i|tivmirgih$ps{iv$szivepp$sggyterg}$ew$e$viwypx$sj$higpmriw$mr$gvswwmrkw$erh$ettvilirwmsrw$epsrk$xli

Wsyxl{iwx$fsvhiv0$ew${ipp$ew$e$higviewi$mr$gsyvx$erh$wirxirgmrk$egxmzmx}$ex$xli$jihivep$pizip2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$xli$jihivep$kszivrqirx$vigirxp}$mwwyih

GSZMH15=$stivexmsrep$kymhergi$vigsqqirhmrk$xli$vihygxmsr$xs$;9)$getegmx}$ex$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxivw${livi$tswwmfpi$xs$tvsqsxi$wsgmep$hmwxergmrk

tvegxmgiw2

Mx×w$mqtsvxerx$xs$rsxi$xlex$qswx$sj$syv$KIS$Wigyvi$jegmpmxmiw$gsrxvegx$gsrxemr$jm|ih$tvmgi$sv$qmrmqyq$kyeverxii$te}qirx$tvszmwmsrw$mrxirhih$xs$irwyvi

ehiuyexi$wxejjmrk$pizipw$erh$gsrwmwxirx$wivzmgi$hipmziv}2$Gyvvirxp}0$syv$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxivw$erh$Y2W2$Qevwlepw$jegmpmxmiw$evi$stivexmrk$ex$evsyrh$xli

getegmx}$pizip$xmih$xs$xli$jm|ih$tvmgi$sv$qmrmqyq$kyeverxii$te}qirx$tvszmwmsrw2$Epxlsykl$mx$mw$tswwmfpi$xlex${i$qe}$i|tivmirgi$er$mqtvsziqirx$mr

sggyterg}$pizipw$ex$MGI$mr$Y2W2$Qevwlepw$jegmpmxmiw$pexiv$xlmw$}iev0$syv$ythexih$jmrergmep$kymhergi$ewwyqiw$e$gsrxmryexmsr$sj$xli$gyvvirxp}$ps{iv$pizipw

jsv$xli$irxmvi$}iev2$[mxl$viwtigx$xs$sjjwmxi$qihmgep$i|tirwiw$ex$syv$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxivw$erh$Y2W2$Qevwlepw$jegmpmxmiw0$xli$jihivep$kszivrqirx$x}tmgepp}

fievw$xli$gswx$jsv$sjjwmxi$qihmgep$gevi2

Syv$KIS$Gevi$wikqirx$lew$epws$i|tivmirgih$e$higpmri$mr$viziryi0$tvmqevmp}$vipexih$xs$ps{iv$sggyterg}$egvsww$syv$KIS$Viirxv}$girxivw$erh$he}

vitsvxmrk$tvskveqw2$[lmpi${i$lsti$xli$xvirhw${mpp$mqtvszi$pexiv$xlmw$}iev0$syv$ythexih$kymhergi$ewwyqiw$ps{iv$sggyterg}$pizipw$jsv$xli$irxmvi$}iev2

Hyvmrk$xli$jmvwx$uyevxiv0${i$fiker$xli$mrxeoi$tvsgiww$ex$xli$kszivrqirx$s{rih$9561fih$Ip$Girxvs$Hixirxmsr$Jegmpmx}$mr$Gepmjsvrme$yrhiv$e$ri{$rmri$}iev

jm|ih$qsrxlp}$tvmgi$gsrxvegx${mxl$xli$Y2W2$Qevwlepw$Wivzmgi2

[i$epws$gsqtpixih$xli$mrxeoi$tvsgiww$erh$eglmizih$rsvqepm~ih$stivexmsrw$ex$syv$gsqter}1s{rih$50<441fih$Rsvxl$Peoi$Gsvvigxmsrep$Jegmpmx}$mr

Qmglmker2$Erh$mr$Xi|ew0${i$gsqtpixih$xli$mrxeoi$tvsgiww$erh$eglmizih$rsvqepm~ih$stivexmsrw$ex$xli$gsyrx}1s{rih$50<44$fih$Viiziw$Gsyrx}$Hixirxmsr

Girxiv$M$*$MM$erh$Ò$M$erh$xli$507;:$fih$Viiziw$Gsyrx}$Hixirxmsr$Girxiv$MMM2$Xliwi$jegmpmxmiw${ivi$egxmzexih$yrhiv$ri{$54$}iev$gsrxvegxw${mxl$xli$Jihivep

Fyviey$sj$Tvmwsrw0$tvszmhmrk$jsv$jm|ih$qsrxlp}$te}qirxw2

Fijsvi$M$xyvr$xli$gepp$sziv$xs$Fvmer$Izerw$xs$vizmi{$xli$viwypxw$syxpsso$erh$pmuymhmx}$tswmxmsr0$M${syph$pmoi$xs$we}$e$ji{${svhw$efsyx$syv$jvsrxpmri

iqtps}iiw2$Iziv}$he}$qsvi$xler$640444$KIS$iqtps}iiw$vitsvx$xs${svo$ex$sziv$644$KIS$jegmpmxmiw$erh$tvskveq$psgexmsrw2$Xliwi$jvsrxpmri$iqtps}iiw

qeoi$hemp}$wegvmjmgiw$xs$gevi$jsv$epp$sj$xlswi$mr$syv$jegmpmxmiw$erh$tvskveqw2$Xli}$evi$wigyvmx}$sjjmgivw0$wsgmep${svoivw0$gewi$qerekivw0$xieglivw0

qemrxirergi$wxejj0$hsgxsvw0$ryvwiw0$fyx$qsvi$mqtsvxerxp}$xli}$evi$qiqfivw$sj$xli$hmzivwi$gsqqyrmxmiw${lswi$jeqmpmiw$lezi$epws$fiir$mqtegxih$pmoi

iziv}sri$ipwi2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 22 of 34

Page 386: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\1==26

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=hi|==62lxq 7358

M×h$pmoi$xs$i|tviww$syv$hiitiwx$kvexmxyhi$erh$ettvigmexmsr$xs$epp$sj$syv$jvsrxpmri$KIS$iqtps}iiw$jsv$xlimv$hemp}$hihmgexmsr$erh$wegvmjmgi${lmgl$mw$xvyp}$er

mrwtmvexmsr$jsv$yw$epp2$Hiwtmxi$xlmw$uyevxiv×w$qer}$gleppirkiw0$syv$viziryiw$erh$gewl$jps{w$viqemrih$viwmpmirx$erh$gsrxmryi$xs$wyttsvx$syv$hmzmhirh

te}qirxw2

M×pp$rs{$xyvr$xli$gepp$sziv$xs$Fvmer$Izerw2

Fvmer$V2$Izerw

Glmij$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv$*$Wirmsv$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

Xlero$}sy0$Kisvki2$Kssh$qsvrmrk0$iziv}sri2$Xshe}0${i$vitsvxih$jmvwx$uyevxiv$viziryiw$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$(:49$qmppmsr$erh$rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs

KIS$sj$(4265$tiv$hmpyxih$wlevi2$Syv$jmvwx$uyevxiv$viwypxw$vijpigx$ettvs|mqexip}$(4247$tiv$wlevi$mr$lmkliv$iqtps}qirx$xe|$i|tirwi${lmgl$evi$jvsrxpsehih

mr$xli$jmvwx$uyevxiv$sj$iegl$}iev2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$syv$jmvwx$uyevxiv$viwypxw$vijpigx$e$(8440444$kemr$sr$viep$iwxexi$ewwixw0$e$(52:$qmppmsr$kemr$sr$xli

i|xmrkymwlqirx$sj$hifx0$(6$qmppmsr$mr$wxevxyt$i|tirwiw0$(52=$qmppmsr$mr$gpswisyx$i|tirwiw$erh$(=440444$mr$GSZMH15=$vipexih$i|tirwiw$epp$tvi1xe|

ewwsgmexih${mxl$ehhmxmsrep$tivwsrep$tvsxigxmzi$iuymtqirx0$hmekrswxmg$xiwx$erh$qihmgep$i|tirwiw2

I|gpyhmrk$xliwi$mxiqw0${i$vitsvxih$jmvwx$uyevxiv$ehnywxih$rix$mrgsqi$sj$(4268$tiv$hmpyxih$wlevi2$[i$epws$vitsvxih$jmvwx$uyevxiv$6464$EJJS$sj$(4299$tiv

hmpyxih$wlevi2$Ew$Kisvki$hmwgywwih0$xli$wtvieh$sj$GSZMH15=$lew$viwypxih$mr$ps{iv$sggyterg}$ex$e$ryqfiv$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$erh$tvskveqw$fikmrrmrk$mr

pexi$Qevgl$erh$mw$xlivijsvi$i|tigxih$xs$viwypx$mr$ps{iv$jypp$}iev$viziryiw0$tvmqevmp}$jsv$syv$MGI$erh$Y2W2$Qevwlep$jegmpmxmiw$erh$syv$KIS$Viirxv}

Wivzmgiw$fywmriww2

Gyvvirxp}0$syv$MGI$erh$Y2W2$Qevwlepw$jegmpmxmiw$evi$stivexmrk$ex$sv$evsyrh$xli$getegmx}$pizip$xmih$xs$xli$jm|ih$tvmgi$erh$qmrmqyq$sggyterg}$te}qirx

tvszmwmsrw$mr$syv$gsrxvegx2$[lmpi$mx$mw$tswwmfpi$xlex${i$qe}$i|tivmirgi$er$mrgviewi$mr$sggyterg}$pizipw$ex$xliwi$jegmpmxmiw$pexiv$xlmw$}iev0$syv$ythexih$jypp

}iev$kymhergi$ewwyqiw$e$gsrxmryexmsr$sj$xli$gyvvirxp}$ps{iv$pizipw$xlvsykl$xli$irh$sj$xli$}iev0$viwypxmrk$mr$er$iwxmqexih$viziryi$higpmri$sj

ettvs|mqexip}$<)$jsv$xli$jypp$}iev2

Syv$KIS$Viirxv}$Wivzmgiw$fywmriww$lew$epws$wiir$er$sggyterg}$higpmri$fikmrrmrk$mr$pexi$Qevgl$mr$fsxl$syv$viwmhirxmep$girxivw$erh$rsr1viwmhirxmep$he}

vitsvxmrk$girxivw$hyi$xs$ps{iv$pizipw$sj$vijivvepw$f}$jihivep0$wxexi$erh$psgep$ekirgmiw2

Ekemr0${lmpi$mx$mw$tswwmfpi$xlex$vijivvep$pizipw$qe}$mrgviewi$pexiv$xlmw$}iev0$syv$ythexih$jypp$}iev$kymhergi$ewwyqiw$ps{iv$sggyterg}$pizipw$jsv$syv

Viirxv}$wikqirx$xlvsykl$xli$irh$sj$xli$}iev0$viwypxmrk$mr$er$iwxmqexih$viziryi$higpmri$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$8)$jsv$xli$jypp$}iev2$[i$lezi$epws$mrgviewih$syv

wtirhmrk$sr$tivwsrep$tvsxigxmzi$iuymtqirx0$hmekrswxmg$xiwxmrk$erh$qihmgep$i|tirwiw$ew$e$viwypx$sj$GSZMH15=$erh$i|tigx$xs$mrgyv$wizivep$qmppmsr$hsppevw

mr$rsr1vigyvvmrk$gswxw$hyvmrk$64642

Syv$ythexih$kymhergi$gsrxmryiw$xs$ewwyqi$rs$gsrxvmfyxmsr$jvsq$syv$Girxvep$Zeppi}0$Hiwivx$Zmi{$erh$Ksphir$Wxexi$jegmpmxmiw$mr$Gepmjsvrme2$Izir$xlsykl

{i$evi$lstijyp$xliwi$jegmpmxmiw${mpp$fi$egxmzexih$ew$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxiv$erri|iw$hyvmrk$xli$wigsrh$lepj$sj$xlmw$}iev2$Hiwtmxi$wizivep$gleppirkiw0${i

fipmizi$xlex$syv$gewl$jps{w$erh$viziryiw$viqemr$viwmpmirx2$[i$i|tigx$jypp$}iev$rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS$xs$fi$mr$e$verki$sj$(42=6$xs$(5248$tiv

hmpyxih$wlevi2$[i$i|tigx$jypp$}iev$ehnywxih$rix$mrgsqi$xs$fi$mr$e$verki$sj$(5$xs$(5256$tiv$hmpyxih$wlevi2$[i$i|tigx$jypp$}iev$EJJS$xs$fi$mr$e$verki$sj

(6269$xs$(6279$tiv$hmpyxih$wlevi2

Jsv$xli$wigsrh$uyevxiv0${i$i|tigx$rix$mrgsqi$exxvmfyxefpi$xs$KIS$xs$fi$mr$e$verki$sj$(4264$xs$(4268$tiv$hmpyxih$wlevi$erh$ehnywxih$rix$mrgsqi$xs$fi$mr$e

verki$sj$(4267$xs$(426;$tiv$hmpyxih$wlevi2$[i$i|tigx$wigsrh$uyevxiv$EJJS$xs$fi$fix{iir$(4298$erh$(429<$tiv$hmpyxih$wlevi2$Ew$e$viqmrhiv0$gsqtevih$xs

syv$jmvwx$uyevxiv$viwypxw0$syv$wyfwiuyirx$uyevxivw$lmwxsvmgepp}$vijpigx$ps{iv$iqtps}qirx$xe|$i|tirwiw${lmgl$evi$jvsrx1psehih$mr$xli$jmvwx$uyevxiv$sj$iegl

}iev2

Qszmrk$xs$syv$getmxep$wxvygxyvi2$Ex$xli$irh$sj$xli$jmvwx$uyevxiv0${i$leh$ettvs|mqexip}$(76$qmppmsr$mr$gewl$sr$lerh$erh$ettvs|mqexip}$(794$qmppmsr$mr

ezempefpi$getegmx}$yrhiv$syv$vizspzmrk$gvihmx$jegmpmx}0$mr$ehhmxmsr$xs$er$eggsvhmsr$jiexyvi$(894$qmppmsr$yrhiv$syv$gvihmx$jegmpmx}2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 23 of 34

Page 387: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\1==26

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=hi|==62lxq 8358

[mxl$viwtigx$xs$syv$getmxep$i|tirhmxyviw0${i$i|tigx$xsxep$GetI|$mr$6464$xs$fi$ettvs|mqexip}$(<9$qmppmsr0$mrgpyhmrk$(64$qmppmsr$Ò$(5=$qmppmsr$jsv

qemrxirergi$GetI|$fips{$syv$tvizmsyw$iwxmqexi2

Ex$xlmw$xmqi0$M${mpp$xyvr$xli$gepp$sziv$xs$Hezi$Hsrelyi$jsv$e$vizmi{$sj$KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$wikqirx2

N2$Hezmh$Hsrelyi

Wirmsv$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx$*$Tviwmhirx1KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

Xlerow0$Fvmer0$erh$kssh$qsvrmrk0$iziv}sri2$M×h$pmoi$xs$tvszmhi$}sy${mxl$er$ythexi$sr$syv$KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$fywmriww$yrmx$erh$wtigmjmgepp}$sr$xli

wxitw${i×zi$xeoir$ex$syv$Wigyvi$Wivzmgi$jegmpmxmiw$xs$ehhviww$erh$qmxmkexi$xli$vmwo$ewwsgmexih${mxl$GSZMH15=2$Jvsq$xli$srwix$sj$xli$terhiqmg0${i$mwwyih

kymhergi$xs$epp$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$gsrwmwxirx${mxl$xli$kymhergi$mwwyih$jsv$Gsvvigxmsrep$erh$Hixirxmsr$Jegmpmxmiw$f}$xli$Girxivw$jsv$Hmwiewi$Gsrxvsp$erh

Tvizirxmsr2$[i$mqqihmexip}$ythexih$syv$tspmgmiw$erh$tvsgihyviw$xs$mrgpyhi$fiwx$tvegxmgiw$jsv$xli$tvizirxmsr0$ewwiwwqirx$erh$qerekiqirx$sj

GSZMH15=0$ekemr$vip}mrk$sr$xli$kymhergi$mwwyih$f}$xli$GHG2$Xliwi$fiwx$tvegxmgiw$mrgpyhi$xli$mqtpiqirxexmsr$sj$uyeverxmri$erh$gslsvxmrk$tvsgihyviw

xs$mwspexi$gsrjmvqih$erh$tviwyqtxmzi$gewiw$sj$GSZMH15=0$mrgpyhmrk$qihmgep$mwspexmsr$erh$xli$ywi$sj$emvfsvri$mrjigxmsr$mwspexmsr$vssqw$ex$syv$jegmpmxmiw2

[i$epws$tvszmhih$ihygexmsrep$kymhergi$xs$syv$iqtps}iiw$erh$mrhmzmhyepw$mr$syv$gevi$sr$xli$fiwx$tvizirxmzi$qiewyviw$xs$ezsmh$xli$wtvieh$sj$GSZMH15=0

wygl$ew$jviuyirx$erh$gevijyp$lerh{ewlmrk0$ezsmhmrk$xsyglmrk$eview$sj$xli$jegi$mrgpyhmrk$jegmep$lemv0$ezsmhmrk$mrhmzmhyepw$i|lmfmxmrk$jpy1pmoi$w}qtxsqw0

tvstiv$gsykl$erh$wrii~i$ixmuyixxi0$wsgmep$hmwxergmrk$viuymviqirxw0$erh$ehnywxqirxw$xs$peyrhv}$erh$qiep$wglihypiw2$[i$lezi$mrgviewih$xli$hmwxvmfyxmsr$sj

tivwsrep$l}kmiri$tvshygxw$mrgpyhmrk$wset0$wleqtss$erh$fsh}${ewl$erh$xmwwyi$tetiv$xs$ex$piewx$x{mgi$tiv${iio$ex$epp$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$erh$qsvi$jviuyirxp}

mj$riihih2$Ehhmxmsrepp}0$fevw$sj$wset$sv$wset$hmwtirwivw$evi$tpegih$ex$iegl$wmro$hemp}$jsv$lerh1{ewlmrk2

[i$lezi$epws$hitps}ih$wtigmepm~ih$wermxexmsr$xieqw$xs$wxivmpm~i$lmkl$gsrxegx$eview$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$erh$lezi$hizipstih$mrxirwmzi$wglihypiw$erh

tvsgihyviw$jsv$xli$gpiermrk$erh$hmwmrjigxmrk$sj$jegmpmx}$wtegiw$efszi$erh$fi}srh$rsvqep$gpiermrk$egxmzmxmiw2$[i$lezi$tvsgyvih$ehhmxmsrep$gpiermrk

iuymtqirx$erh$wermxexmsr$tvshygxw$xlex$evi$tvszir$liepxlgevi$kvehi$hmwmrjigxerxw2$[i$ehzmwi$syv$iqtps}iiw$xs$viqemr$lsqi$mj$xli}$i|lmfmx$jpy1pmoi

w}qtxsqw0$erh${i×zi$i|ivgmwih$jpi|mfpi$temh$piezi$erh$temh$xmqi$sjj$tspmgmiw$xs$epps{$jsv$iqtps}iiw$xs$viqemr$lsqi$mj$xli}$i|lmfmx$jpy1pmoi$w}qtxsqw

sv$xs$gevi$jsv$e$jeqmp}$qiqfiv2

[i$irkeki${mxl$syv$kszivrqirx$tevxrivw$xs$tvsqtxp}$wywtirh$rsr1iwwirxmep$zmwmxexmsr$ex$epp$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$erh${i$lezi$iqtps}ih$ehhmxmsrep$qiewyviw

hyvmrk$xli$mrxeoi$tvsgiww$mr$epp$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$xs$mrgpyhi$wgviirmrk$wtigmjmg$xs$GSZMH15=2$Xliwi$ehhmxmsrep$wgviirmrk$tvsgihyviw$mrgpyhi$xiqtivexyvi

gligow$jsv$epp$wxejj$erh$er}$pikepp}$viuymvih$zmwmxw$fijsvi$irxivmrk$syv$jegmpmxmiw$ew${ipp2$Zivfep$qihmgep$wgviir$uyiwxmsrremviw$evi$epws$ezempefpi2$[i

svhivih$erh$vigimzih$w{ef$omxw$jsv$GSZMH15=$jvsq$e$rexmsrep$wyttpmiv$erh${i$iregxih$uyeverxmri$erh$xiwxmrk$tspmgmiw$jsv$er}$iqtps}iiw${ls$qe}$lezi

gsqi$mrxs$gsrxegx${mxl$er}$mrhmzmhyep${ls$lew$xiwxih$tswmxmzi$jsv$GSZMH15=2$Ex$iziv}$sri$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw0${i$lezi${svoih$gpswip}${mxl$syv

kszivrqirx$ekirg}$tevxrivw$erh$psgep$liepxl$sjjmgmepw$xs$hizipst$GSZMH15=$iqivkirg}$tperw$erh$xiwxmrk$tspmgmiw$jsv$xli$mrhmzmhyepw$mr$syv$gevi2

Mr$Qevgl$sj$xlmw$}iev0${i$wxevxih$tvsgyvmrk$ehhmxmsrep$tivwsrep$tvsxigxmzi$iuymtqirx$erh$fiker$mwwymrk$mx$gpmrmgepp}$riihih$ex$jegmpmxmiw$mqtegxih$f}

GSZMH15=$erh$sziv$xli$gsyvwi$sj$Etvmp${i$gssvhmrexih${mxl$syv$kszivrqirx$tevxrivw$xs$hmwxvmfyxi$tivwsrep$tvsxigxmzi$iuymtqirx$mrgpyhmrk$jegi$qewow

xs$epp$wxejj0$mrqexiw$erh$hixemriiw$ew$e$tvigeyxmsrev}$qiewyvi$ex$epp$sj$syv$KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$jegmpmxmiw2$E$ji{$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$tvmqevmp}$mr$syv$iewxivr

vikmsr$sj$xli$gsyrxv}$lezi$i|tivmirgih$qypxmtpi$gewiw$sj$GSZMH15=$mr$fsxl$syv$wxejj$erh$mrhmzmhyepw$irxvywxih$mr$syv$gevi2

E$wqepp$tivgirxeki$sj$xliwi$gewiw$lezi$viuymvih$lswtmxepm~exmsr$erh$e$ziv}$wqepp$ryqfiv$xvekmgepp}$viwypxih$mr$jexepmxmiw${lmgl$lew$pijx$epp$sj$yw${mxl$ziv}

liez}$lievxw2$Ls{iziv0$syv$jegmpmxmiw$lezi$xlerojypp}$rsx$i|tivmirgih$e$hmwtvstsvxmsrexi$mqtegx$jvsq$xli$terhiqmg$erh$qswx$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$lezi$leh

ziv}$ji{$sv$rs$gewiw$sj$GSZMH15=2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 24 of 34

Page 388: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\1==26

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=hi|==62lxq 9358

[i$evi$mrgvihmfpi$kvexijyp$jsv$syv$jvsrxpmri$iqtps}iiw${ls$qeoi$hemp}$wegvmjmgiw$xs$vitsvx$xs${svo$erh$tvszmhi$lmkl1uyepmx}$erh$gsqtewwmsrexi$gevi$xs

epp$sj$xlswi$mr$syv$jegmpmxmiw2$[i$fipmizi$mx$mw$xlimv$hihmgexmsr$erh$gsqqmxqirx$xlex$lezi$epps{ih$KIS$xs$ijjigxmzip}$qereki$xli$wtvieh$sj$GSZMH15=

erh$qmxmkexi$mxw$vmwo2

Fijsvi$M$xyvr$xli$gepp$sziv$xs$Err0$M×h$pmoi$xs$fvmijp}$hmwgyww$e$ji{$sxliv$stivexmsrep$lmklpmklxw$mr$xli$uyevxiv2$Hyvmrk$xli$jmvwx$uyevxiv0${i$fiker$xli

mrxeoi$tvsgiww$yrhiv$e$ri{$qerekih1srp}$gsrxvegx${mxl$xli$Y2W2$Qevwlepw$Wivzmgi$ex$xli$kszivrqirx1s{rih$9561fih$Ip$Girxvs$Hixirxmsr$Jegmpmx}$mr

Gepmjsvrme2$Xlmw$ri{$gsrxvegx$lew$e$xivq$sj$ettvs|mqexip}$rmri$}ievw$erh$mw$i|tigxih$xs$kirivexi$ettvs|mqexip}$(6=$qmppmsr$mr$erryepm~ih$viziryi2

Ehhmxmsrepp}0${i$gsqtpixih$xli$mrxeoi$tvsgiww$erh$eglmizih$rsvqepm~ih$stivexmsrw$ex$syv$gsqter}1s{rih$5<441fih$Rsvxlpeoi$Gsvvigxmsrep$Jegmpmx}$mr

Qmglmker$yrhiv$e$ri{$541}iev$gsrxvegx${mxl$xli$Jihivep$Fyviey$sj$Tvmwsrw2$Xlmw$541}iev$gsrxvegx$mw$i|tigxih$xs$kirivexi$ettvs|mqexip}$(7;$qmppmsr$mr

erryepm~ih$viziryiw2$Erh$mr$Xi|ew0$yrhiv$x{s$ri{$541}iev$gsrxvegxw${mxl$xli$Fyviey$sj$Tvmwsrw0${i${svo${mxl$Viiziw$Gsyrx}$xs$gsqtpixi$xli$mrxeoi

tvsgiww$erh$lezi$eglmizih$rsvqepm~ih$stivexmsrw$ex$xli$gsyrx}1s{rih$5<441fih$Viiziw$Gsyrx}$Hixirxmsr$Girxiv$sj$5$erh$60$erh$xli$507;:1fih$Viiziw

Gsyrx}$Hixirxmsr$Girxiv$72

Ew$e$viqmrhiv0$KIS$tvszmhiw$qerekiqirx$gsrwypxmrk$erh$wyttsvx$wivzmgiw$xs$Viiziw$Gsyrx}$mr$vipexmsr$xs$xlmw$jegmpmx}0${lmpi$xli$gsyrx}$lsphw$xli

gsrxvegx${mxl$xli$Fyviey$sj$Tvmwsrw$jsv$xli$stivexmsr$sj$xli$jegmpmx}2

Jmrepp}0${i$evi$gsrxmrymrk$xs$yrhivxeoi$i|terwmsr$tvsnigxw$ex$syv$Vezirlepp0$Nyrii$erh$Jypleq$jegmpmxmiw$mr$Eywxvepme0${lmgl$evi$i|tigxih$xs$ehh$gpswi$xs

50444$fihw$hyvmrk$64642

Ex$xlmw$xmqi0$M×pp$xyvr$xli$gepp$sziv$xs$Err$jsv$e$vizmi{$sj$KIS$Gevi2$ErrC

Err$Q2$Wglpevf

Wirmsv$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx$*$Tviwmhirx1KIS$Gevi0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

Xlero$}sy0$Hezi2$Kssh$qsvrmrk0$iziv}sri2$M×h$pmoi$xs$tvszmhi$}sy$er$ythexi$sr$xli$wxitw${i×zi$xeoir$xs$ehhviww$xli$vmwo$erh$qmxmkexi$xli$wtvieh$sj

GSZMH15=$egvsww$syv$KIS$Gevi$fywmriww$yrmx2$Gsrwmwxirx${mxl$xli$ijjsvxw$yrhivxeoir$f}$syv$KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$jegmpmxmiw0$epp$sj$syv$viwmhirxmep

jegmpmxmiw$mr$KIS$Viirxv}$erh$KIS$]syxl$Wivzmgiw$leh$mwwyih$GSZMH15=$kymhergi0$gsrwmwxirx${mxl$xli$kymhergi$mwwyih$f}$xli$Girxivw$jsv$Hmwiewi

Gsrxvsp$erh$Tvizirxmsr2$[i$lezi$ythexih$syv$tspmgmiw$erh$tvsgihyviw$xs$mrgpyhi$fiwx$tvegxmgiw$jsv$xli$tvizirxmsr0$ewwiwwqirx$erh$qerekiqirx$sj

GSZMH15=0$mrgpyhmrk$xli$mqtpiqirxexmsr$sj$uyeverxmri$erh$gslsvxmrk$tvsgihyviw$xs$mwspexi$gsrjmvqih$erh$tviwyqtxmzi$gewiw$sj$GSZMH15=2

[i$lezi$tvszmhih$ihygexmsrep$kymhergi$xs$syv$iqtps}iiw$erh$epp$mrhmzmhyepw$mr$syv$gevi$sj$xli$fiwx$tvizirxexmzi$qiewyviw$xs$ezsmh$xli$wtvieh$sj

GSZMH15=$erh${i$lezi$mrgviewih$xli$hmwxvmfyxmsr$sj$tivwsrep$l}kmiri$tvshygxw2$Wmqmpev$xs$syv$KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw$jegmpmxmiw0${i$lezi$hitps}ih

wtigmepm~ih$wermxexmsr$xieqw$xs$wxivmpm~i$lmkl$gsrxegx$eview$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$erh$lezi$hizipstih$wtigmep$wglihypiw$erh$tvsgihyviw$jsv$xli$gpiermrk$erh

hmwmrjigxmrk$syv$jegmpmx}$wtegiw$ywmrk$wermxexmsr$tvshygxw$xlex$evi$tvszir$liepxlgevi$kvehi$hmwmrjigxerxw2

[i$lezi$epws$ehzmwih$syv$iqtps}iiw$xs$viqemr$lsqi$mj$xli}$i|lmfmx$jpy1pmoi$w}qtxsqw$erh$lezi$i|ivgmwih$jpi|mfpi$temh$piezi$erh$temh$xmqi1sjj$tspmgmiw

xs$epps{$jsv$iqtps}iiw$xs$viqemr$lsqi$ew$riihih2$[i$lezi$mqtpiqirxih$ehhmxmsrep$wgviirmrk$qiewyviw$jsv$irxv}$mrxs$syv$jegmpmxmiw$erh${i$evi$tvszmhmrk

jegi$qewow$xs$epp$wxejj$erh$viwmhirxw2$Ex$epp$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw0${i$lezi${svoih$gpswip}${mxl$syv$kszivrqirx$ekirg}$tevxrivw$erh$psgep$liepxl$sjjmgmepw$xs

hizipst$GSZMH15=$iqivkirg}$tper$erh$xiwxmrk$tspmgmiw$gsrwmwxirx${mxl$GHG$kymhergi2$[i$lezi$epws$iwxefpmwlih$vetmh$viwtsrwi$xieqw$xs$fi$hitps}ih

xs$ewwmwx$jegmpmxmiw$xlex$lezi$fiir$mqtegxih$f}$GSZMH15=2$Xli$GSZMH15=$terhiqmg$lew$ejjigxih$qer}$gsqqyrmxmiw${livi$syv$iqtps}iiw$pmzi

iwtigmepp}$mr$xli$Rsvxliewx2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 25 of 34

Page 389: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\1==26

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=hi|==62lxq :358

Fijsvi$M$xyvr$xli$gepp$fego$xs$Kisvki0$M${syph$epws$pmoi$xs$xlero$epp$syv$KIS$Gevi$iqtps}iiw${lswi$hihmgexmsr$erh$hemp}$wegvmjmgi$qeoi$yw$epp$ziv}

tvsyh2$Syv$jvsrxpmri$iqtps}iiw$vitsvx$xs${svo$iziv}$he}$xs$gevi$jsv$epp$syv$tevxmgmterxw$mr$fsxl$viwmhirxmep$erh$rsr1viwmhirxmep$tvskveqw$erh$lezi$jsyrh

mrrszexmzi${e}w$xs$hipmziv$vilefmpmxexmsr$tvskveqqmrk$xlvsykl$zmvxyep$xiglrspskmiw$mr${e}w${i$lezi$riziv$wiir$fijsvi2$[i$evi$mrgvihmfp}$tvsyh$sj$epp$sj

syv$iqtps}iiw2

Ex$xlmw$xmqi0$M×pp$xyvr$xli$gepp$fego$xs$Kisvki$jsv$lmw$gpswmrk$viqevow2$KisvkiC

Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Glemvqer0$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$*$Jsyrhiv0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

Xlero$}sy0$Err2$Ex$xmqiw$sj$yrtvigihirxih$yrgivxemrx}0${i$sjxir$wii$xli$fiwx$mr$syv$tistpi$erh$xlimv$efmpmxmiw2$[i$evi$mrgvihmfp}$tvsyh$sj$epp$sj$syv

iqtps}iiw${lswi$hemp}$gsqqmxqirx$erh$hihmgexmsr$lew$epps{ih$syv$gsqter}$xs$qiix$xlmw$gvmwmw$lieh$sr2$Ew$}sy×zi$lievh$xshe}0${i$lezi$xeoir

gsqtvilirwmzi$wxitw$xs$ehhviww$erh$qmxmkexi$xli$vmwow$sj$GSZMH15=$egvsww$epp$sj$syv$jegmpmxmiw$erh$tvskveqw2$Irwyvmrk$xli$liepxl$erh$wejix}$sj$epp$sj

xlswi$mr$syv$gevi$erh$syv$iqtps}iiw$lew$ep{e}w$fiir$syv$ryqfiv$sri$tvmsvmx}2

[i$evi$gsqqmxxih$xs${svomrk$gpswip}${mxl$syv$kszivrqirx$ekirg}$tevxrivw$erh$psgep$liepxl$sjjmgmepw$egvsww$xli$gsyrxv}$ew${ipp$ew$gsrxmryi$xs$jmklx$xli

wtvieh$sj$GSZMH15=2$Hiwtmxi$xli$wmkrmjmgerx$gleppirkiw$ewwsgmexih${mxl$xlmw$kpsfep$terhiqmg0$syv$fywmriww$ievrmrkw$erh$gewl$jps{w$viqemr$viwmpmirx2

[i×zi$xeoir${lex${i$fipmizi$mw$e$tvyhirx$ettvsegl$xs$syv$kymhergi$jsv$xli$jypp$}iev$erh${i$fipmizi${i$lezi$ehiuyexi$pmuymhmx}$erh$eggiww$xs$getmxep2$[i

viqemr$jsgywih$sr$xli$ijjigxmzi$eppsgexmsr$sj$getmxep$erh$sr$xli$gsrxmryih$irlergiqirx$sj$psrk1xivq$zepyi$jsv$syv$wlevilsphivw0${lmgl$mrgpyhi$qer}$sj

syv$iqtps}iiw2

Jmrepp}0$M${erx$xs$xlero$Hezmh$Hsrelyi$jsv$lmw$55$}ievw${mxl$KIS$erh$fvmrkmrk$er$ehhmxmsrep$tvsjiwwmsrepmwq$xs$syv$gsqter}2$Hezmh${mpp$fi$vixmvmrk$sr

Nyp}$55$erh${mpp$fi$jspps{ih$f}$Fpeoi$Hezmw0${ls$mw$tviwirxp}$mr$xli$vspi$sj$Tviwmhirx$sj$KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw2

Xlex$gsqtpixiw$syv$tviwirxexmsr2$[i${mpp$fi$kpeh$xs$ehhviww$er}$uyiwxmsrw2

Uyiwxmsr$Erh$Erw{iv$Wigxmsr

Stivexsv

[i${mpp$rs{$fikmr$xli$uyiwxmsr1erh1erw{iv$wiwwmsr2$_Stivexsv$Mrwxvygxmsrwa$Erh$syv$jmvwx$uyiwxmsr$gsqiw$jvsq$Nsi$Ksqiw$sj$Rsfpi$Getmxep2$Tpiewi$ks

elieh2

Nsi$Ksqiw

Erep}wx0$Rsfpi$Getmxep$Qevoixw0$Mrg2

Kssh$qsvrmrk0$erh$xlerow$jsv$xeomrk$q}$uyiwxmsrw2$Ger$}sy$liev$qiC

Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Glemvqer0$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$*$Jsyrhiv0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

]iw0$M$ger2$Kssh$qsvrmrk2

Nsi$Ksqiw

Erep}wx0$Rsfpi$Getmxep$Qevoixw0$Mrg2

Soe}2$Xlero$}sy2$Nywx${erxih$xs$jmvwx$omrh$sj$wxevxmrk${mxl$Ò$mj$}sy$gsyph$kmzi$qi$e$pmxxpi$vizmi{$sj$ls{$xli$uyevxiv$tpe}ih$syx0${i$leh$Neryev}0

Jifvyev}0${ivi$}sy$gpswi$xs$sv$efszi$}syv$i|tigxih$tperC$Erh$xlir0${lir$mr$Qevgl$hmh$}sy$viepp}$wxevx$xs$wii$xli$GSZMH$mqtegxC

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 26 of 34

Page 390: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\1==26

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=hi|==62lxq ;358

Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Glemvqer0$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$*$Jsyrhiv0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

M$xlmro$mx${ew$qmh1Qevgl0$ws$mx${ew$pexi$mr$xli$uyevxiv2$Erh${i$qehi$syv$uyevxiv$viwypxw0$fyx$syv$vizmwih$kymhergi$mw$mrhmgexmsr$xlex$xli$sggytergmiw$hmh

vigihi$mr$pexi$Qevgl$erh$lezi$wxe}ih$xlivi$erh${i×zi$xeoir0$M$xlmro0$xli$tvyhirx$ettvsegl$sj$jsvigewxmrk$xli$gsrxmryexmsr$yrxmp$xli$wmxyexmsr$glerkiw2

Fvmer$V2$Izerw

Glmij$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv$*$Wirmsv$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

Erh$Nsi0$mj$M$gsyph$nywx$ehh$xs${lex$Kisvki$qirxmsrih0$syv$rsvqep$i|tigxexmsr$mr$U7${syph$lezi$fiir$Ò$sv$U5${syph$lezi$fiir$xlex$xli$ryqfivw${syph

lezi$wxevxih$xs$Ò$syv$sggyterg}$pizipw${syph$lezi$wxevxih$xs$mqtvszi$xs{evhw$xli$irh$sj$xli$jmvwx$uyevxiv2$G}gpmgepp}0$xli$jmvwx$uyevxiv$mw$ywyepp}$ps{iv

sggyterg}$pizipw0$fyx$mrwxieh$sj$xlex$mqtvsziqirx$wxevxmrk${lmgl$mw${l}$}sy$wii$xli$wxit$yt$mr$syv$svmkmrep$kymhergi$jvsq$U5$xs$U6$xlvsykl$xli$viwx$sj

xli$}iev$erh$mrwxieh${i×zi$iwwirxmepp}$liph$xli$ryqfivw$omrh$sj${livi${i$evi$xshe}$sjjwix$f}$wsqi$mqtvsziqirx$jvsq$te}vspp$xe|$i|tirwi$rsx$fimrk$ew

lmkl$mr$xli$wigsrh0$xlmvh$erh$jsyvxl$uyevxiv2$Ws0$xlex×w$omrh$sj$xli${e}$xlmrkw$xvirhih$ekemrwx${lex${i${syph$rsvqepp}$i|tigx$xs$sggyv2

Nsi$Ksqiw

Erep}wx0$Rsfpi$Getmxep$Qevoixw0$Mrg2

Soe}2$Erh$omrh$sj$e$jspps{1yt$sr$xlex$sri2$Ws0$mj$}sy$psso$ex$MGI$eziveki$hemp}$tstypexmsrw0$ex$xli$irh$sj$xli$}iev0$jsv$xli$qsrxl$sj$Higiqfiv0$xlivi$evi

8604440$pewx$Ò$M$xlmro$mx${ew$pewx${iio$sv$x{s${iiow$eks0$xli}${ivi$ex$740444$ew$er$eziveki$hemp}$tstypexmsr$jsv$xli${iio$sv$vsyklp}$e$6:)$higpmri$jvsq

xli$fikmrrmrk$sj$xli$}iev0$erh$}sy$ky}w$evi$xepomrk$efsyx$er$<)$higpmri$mr$}syv$viziryi$jvsq$MGI$}iev1sziv1}iev0$erh$M$nywx${srhivih$qe}fi$mj$}sy

gsyph$kmzi$e$pmxxpi$gspsv$xs$xlex$ew$xs$ls{$}sy$wuyevi$xlex${mxl$wygl$e$wlevt$hvst$mr$xli$MGI$tstypexmsr$wmrgi$xli$fikmrrmrk$sj$xli$}ievC

Fvmer$V2$Izerw

Glmij$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv$*$Wirmsv$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

Wyvi2$Ws0$jmvwx$sj$epp0$ew${i$qirxmsrih$mr$xli$gepp$xlex$<)${ew$e$gsqfmrexmsr$sj$MGI$erh$Y2W2$Qevwlepw2$Fyx$ew${i$qirxmsrih$erh$M$xlmro${i$qirxmsrih

mr$xli$gepp$xli$qensvmx}$sj$syv$gsrxvegxw${mxl$Ò$M$lezi$e$jm|ih$tvmgi$gsqtsrirx0$e$wmkrmjmgerx$jm|ih$tvmgi$gsqtsrirx$xs$gsziv$xli$lmkl1pizip$sj$jm|ih$gswx

xlex$mx$xeoiw$xs$stivexi$e$jegmpmx}2$Ws0$izir$xlsykl$xli$sggyterg}$pizipw$evi$ps{iv0$mx×w$rsx$e$tvstsvxmsrexi$mqtegx$xs$syv$viziryiw$jvsq$xli$ps{iv

sggyterg}$pizipw2$Ws0$xlex×w${l}$xlswi$qmrmqyq$sggytergmiw$sv$jm|ih$tvmgi$gsqtsrirxw$sj$syv$gsrxvegxw$evi$ws$mqtsvxerx2$Erh$qswx$ew$Kisvki

qirxmsrih0$qswx$sj$syv$MGI$gsrxvegx$lezi$xlex0$rsx$uymxi$ew$qer}$sj$xli$Y2W2$Qevwlepw0$xlivi×w$e$pmxxpi$qsvi$zevmefmpmx}2$Erh$xlir0$qswx$sj$syv$wxexi$erh

syv$FST$gsrxvegxw$epws$lezi$xlswi$jm|ih$tvmgi$evverkiqirxw2$Ws0$xlex×w${l}$}sy$wii$xli$mqtegx$qsvi$sr$MGI$wmhi$nywx$hyi$xs$xli$zspexmpmx}$mr$xlswi

gsrxvegxw$erh$xli$Y2W2$Qevwlepw2

Nsi$Ksqiw

Erep}wx0$Rsfpi$Getmxep$Qevoixw0$Mrg2

Soe}$kviex2$Xlerow$jsv$xli$gspsv$sr$xlex2$Erh$xlir0$pewxp}0$mj$}sy$gsyph$nywx$xepo$e$pmxxpi$fmx$}syv$i|tivmirgi$mr$tvizmsyw$igsrsqmg$hs{rxyvrw$sr$szivepp

tvmwsr$tstypexmsr$ew${i$ors{$xli$tvmwsr$Ò$szivepp$tvmwsr$tstypexmsrw$lezi$fiir$higpmrmrk$sziv$xmqi$livi2$[lex$lezi$}sy$ky}w$wiir$mr$xli$tewx${lir

{i×zi$wiir$er$igsrsqmg$hs{rxyvr$sr$xli$mqtegx$imxliv$tswmxmzip}$sv$rikexmzip}$sr$tvmwsr$tstypexmsrwC

Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Glemvqer0$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$*$Jsyrhiv0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

[ipp0$ywyepp}$xli$uyiwxmsr$mw$efsyx$igsrsqmg$wmxyexmsrw2$Syv$gsqter}$wiiqw$xs$hs$nywx$ew${ipp$mr$hmjjmgypx$igsrsqmg$wmxyexmsrw2$Ew$jev$ew$wxexi

tstypexmsrw0$syv$wxexi$sggyterg}$mw$jemvp}$wxexmg2$Syv$jegmpmxmiw$evi$qihmyq$wigyvmx}$erh$yt2$Ws0${i×vi$rsx$pswmrk$tvmwsrivw2$Xli$sriw$xlex$evi$fimrk

vipiewih$ex$xli$jihivep$pizip$evi$rsx$syv$tvmwsrivw2$Xli}×vi$mr$sxliv$x}tiw$sj$jegmpmxmiw$mr$xli$wxexi$jegmpmxmiw$ew${ipp2$Xli}×vi$ywyepp}$vipiewih$jvsq$ps{

wigyvmx}$mrwxmxyxmsrw2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 27 of 34

Page 391: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\1==26

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=hi|==62lxq <358

Nsi$Ksqiw

Erep}wx0$Rsfpi$Getmxep$Qevoixw0$Mrg2

Soe}0$kviex2$M×pp$nyqt$fego$mr$pmri2$Xlero$}sy$ziv}$qygl2

Stivexsv

Syv$ri|x$uyiwxmsr$gsqiw$jvsq$Qmxve$Veqkstep$sj$Wmhsxm2$Tpiewi$ks$elieh2

Qmxve$Veqkstep

Erep}wx0$Wmhsxm$*$Gs2$PPG

]iw0$lm2$Kssh$qsvrmrk2$Xlerow$jsv$xeomrk$xli$uyiwxmsrw2$M${ew$nywx$gyvmsyw$mr$xivqw$sj$ls{$}sy$wii$xli$irzmvsrqirx$tpe}mrk$syx$ewwyqmrk${i$kix$fego$xs

lstijypp}$rsvqep$fijsvi$xli$irh$sj$xli$}iev2$Erh$M×q$vijivvmrk$xs0$M$xlmro$}sy$qirxmsrih$xli$MGI$Tvsgiwwmrk$Girxivw0$xli$stivexmsrep$kymhergi$sj$;9)

getegmx}$xs$tvsqsxi$wsgmep$hmwxergi$erh$tvegxmgiw2$Erh$M${ew$gyvmsyw$mj$}sy$wii$xlex$figsqmrk$xli$rsvq$sv$}sy$tvsfefp}$ks$fego$xs$ls{$xlmrkw${ivi$tvi

GSZMH15=C

Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Glemvqer0$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$*$Jsyrhiv0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

[i$xlmro$xlex$xli$kymhergi$xlex${ew$mwwyih$efsyx$xli$GSZMH15=$ex$;9)$sggyterg}$sv$fips{$mw$e$xiqtsvev}$qiewyvi$xlex${mpp$fi$pmjxih$srgi$xli$liepxl

wmxyexmsrw$mr$xlimv$viwtigxmzi$gsqqyrmxmiw$mqtvsziw2$Syv$jegmpmxmiw$evi$tvmqevmp}$mr$xli$Wyr$Fipx$wxexiw${livi$xlivi$lew$fiir$piww$egxmzmx}$sj$xli$zmvyw$erh

{i×vi$lstijyp$xlex$xli$wxexiw$xlex$evi$vistirmrk$rs{$ew$}sy$liev$xliq$vitsvxih$sr$xli$ri{w$xlex$xlmrkw${mpp$kix$fego$xs$rsvqep$mr$xli$ri|x$sri0$x{s0$xlvii

qsrxlw2$Fyx$ew$e$tyfpmgp}1xvehih$gsqter}0$M$xlmro${i$lezi$xs$fi$jemvp}$tvyhirx$erh$gsrwivzexmzi$mr$syv$jsvigewxw$xs$eggsyrx$jsv$epp$omrhw$sj$wgirevmsw$xlex

qe}$sggyv2$Ws0$xli$fewmw$sj$syv$jsvigewx$mw0$ew$Fvmer$qirxmsrih$mw$e$gsrxmryexmsr$sj$xli$i|mwxmrk$wmxyexmsr${lmgl${i${mpp$lsti${mpp$irh$mr$xli$riev$jyxyvi2

Fyx${i×zi$tvszmhih$kymhergi$ew${i$jiip$ettvstvmexi2

Qmxve$Veqkstep

Erep}wx0$Wmhsxm$*$Gs2$PPG

Soe}2$Erh$xlir0$nywx$e$jspps{1yt$sr$xlex2$M$kyiww0$sfzmsywp}$}sy×zi$xeoir$e$ryqfiv$sj$wxitw$xs$mqtvszi$xli$wejix}0$ix$gixive$erh$xli$wermxexmsr0$M$xlmro

}sy$qirxmsrih$xlmrkw$pmoi$hemp}$wset$fimrk$ezempefpi0$ix$gixive2$Evi$xlswi$xlmrkw$epws$nywx$xiqtsvev}$sv$mw$xlex$ksmrk$xs$fi$wsvx$sj$xli$rsvq$ksmrk

jsv{evhC

Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Glemvqer0$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$*$Jsyrhiv0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

M$xlmro$xli}×vi$xiqtsvev}$mr$xli$qekrmxyhi$xlex$xli}×vi$fimrk$ettpmih$ex$xlmw$xmqi2$[i×vi$mrgyvvmrk$gswx$jsv$qewow$erh$kpsziw$erh$hmwmrjigxerxw$ex$e$qygl

lmkliv$pizip$xler${i${syph$i|tigx$mr$xli$jyxyvi2$Fyx$xlivi$tvsfefp}${mpp$fi$e$gsrxmryexmsr$xs$e$piwwiv$hikvii$sj$wsqi$sj$xliwi$tvsgihyviw$nywx$ew$wsqi

tvihmgxih0$xlivi$gsyph$fi$e$jyvxliv$syxfvieo$mr$jepp$nywx$pmoi$xli$jpy$wiewsr2$Fyx${i$lezi$jegih$xliwi$wmxyexmsrw$sr$e$pevkiv$i|xirx$tvizmsywp}${livi$}sy

lezi$syxfvieow$sj$qyqtw$sv$qiewpiw$erh$tistpi$lezi$xs$fi$uyeverxmrih2$Erh$ws0$mr$MGI0$mr$tevxmgypev0${i$jegih$xliwi$wmxyexmsrw0${i$lezi$xli$tvsgihyviw0

{i$lezi$xli$svkerm~exmsrep$erh$jmrergmep$viwsyvgiw$xs$hiep${mxl$xliwi$omrh$sj$wmxyexmsrw2

N2$Hezmh$Hsrelyi

Wirmsv$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx$*$Tviwmhirx1KIS$Wigyvi$Wivzmgiw0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

Qmxve0$xlmw$mw$Hezi$erh$xs$ehh$xs$Kisvki×w$gsqqirx0$xli$jsgyw$erh$wyttsvx$jsv$tivwsrep$l}kmiri$lew$ep{e}w$fiir$wywxemrih$erh$qemrxemrih$ex$ziv}$lmkl1

pizip$mr$syv$svkerm~exmsr2$Ws0$xlswi$tvsxigxmzi$iuymtqirx$xlex$evi$rs{$wtigmjmg$xs$GSZMH15=0${i${syph$erxmgmtexi$xlswi$xs$fi$piwwirih$mr$xli$jyxyvi$ew

xli$terhiqmg$mw$sfzmsywp}$qihmgepp}$yrhivwxssh$erh$wgmirxmjmgepp}$gsrxvsppih2$Fyx0$syv$jsgyw$sr$tivwsrep$l}kmiri$lew$ep{e}w$fiir$ex$xli$lmkliwx$pizipw2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 28 of 34

Page 392: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\1==26

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=hi|==62lxq =358

Qmxve$Veqkstep

Erep}wx0$Wmhsxm$*$Gs2$PPG

Ws0$xlerow2$M$ettvigmexi$xli$gpevmjmgexmsr2$Nywx${erxih$xs$xsygl$fewi$sr$GetI|0$M$ors{$}sy$typpih$sr$xlex$e$pmxxpi$erh$e$ryqfiv$sj$gsqtermiw$evi

sfzmsywp}$wgepmrk$fego$xlimv$GetI|$sv$mrziwxqirx$wtirhmrk$kmzir$xli$ps{$zmwmfmpmx}$erh$xli$yrgivxemrx}$xlex×w$syx$xlivi$vmklx$rs{2$Fyx0$nywx$gyvmsyw$jsv

wsqi$sj$xliq0$mx×w$qsvi$efsyx$gewl$gsrwxvemrih0$ix$gixive2$Mx$wiiqw$pmoi$mr$}syv$gewi0$mx×w$tvsfefp}$qsvi$nywx$vihygih$sttsvxyrmxmiw$mr$xli$riev1xivq$kmzir

xli$irzmvsrqirx$ew$sttswih$qsvi$pmuymhmx}$mwwyiw2$Mw$xlex$jemvC

Fvmer$V2$Izerw

Glmij$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv$*$Wirmsv$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

Xlex×w$gsvvigx2$M$xlmro${i$pssoih$ex$Ò${i$glerkih$xli$kvs{xl$GetI|$e$pmxxpi$fmx0$fyx$qswx$sj$xli$vihygxmsr${ew$sr$xli$qemrxirergi$wmhi$erh$M$xlmro$xlex×w

nywx$hijivvmrk$erh$tywlmrk$wsqi$wxyjj$syx$e$pmxxpi$fmx$jyvxliv2$Ws0$rs$pmuymhmx}$mwwyiw0$nywx$xv}mrk$xs$jmrh$wsqi$sjjwixw$xs$xli$vihygxmsrw$xlex${i$leh$xs$xeoi

sr$xli$viziryi$wmhi2

Qmxve$Veqkstep

Erep}wx0$Wmhsxm$*$Gs2$PPG

Xlerow2$Erh$xlir0$nywx$jmrepp}$ekemr$sr$xli$kvs{xl$mrmxmexmziw0$sfzmsywp}0$mrxivrexmsrep$mw$wsqixlmrk$}sy$lezi$ep{e}w$fiir$pssomrk$ex$mr$xivqw$sj

i|terhmrk2$M${ew$nywx$gyvmsyw0$mj$}sy×vi$wiimrk$er}$qensv$glerkiw$sr$xlex$jvsrx$mr$pmklx$sj$e$kpsfep$terhiqmgC$Erh$epws0$nywx$sr$xli$eguymwmxmsr$jvsrx0$M×q

ewwyqmrk$xlex$wsqi$sj$}syv$gsqtixmxsvw$sv$sxliv$tpe}ivw$mr$xli$wtegi$evi$lezmrk$Ò${syph$pmoi$xs$fi$epws$i|tivmirgmrk$wsqi$xsykl$gsrhmxmsrw$erh$qmklx

tviwirx$wsqi$sttsvxyrmxmiw$jsv$}sy$riev0$qihmyq$xivq$erh$er}$xlsyklxw$sr$xlexC

Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Glemvqer0$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$*$Jsyrhiv0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

[ipp0$sr$xli$mrxivrexmsrep$jvsrx0${i$lezi$i|terwmsrw$sggyvvmrk$mr$Eywxvepme$ew0$M$xlmro0$Hezi$qirxmsrih2$Ws0$xlex$wxmpp$pssow$uymxi$kssh$jsv$yw2$Erh$ew$jev

ew$eguymwmxmsrw0${i$viepp}$hsr×x$xepo$efsyx$xlex$ziv}$qygl2

Qmxve$Veqkstep

Erep}wx0$Wmhsxm$*$Gs2$PPG

Soe}2$Xlerow$ekemr$jsv$xeomrk$xli$uyiwxmsrw2$_Stivexsv$Mrwxvygxmsrwa

Stivexsv

Erh$syv$ri|x$uyiwxmsr${mpp$gsqi$jvsq$Qexxli{$Pevwsr$sj$Rexmsrep$Wigyvmxmiw2$Tpiewi$ks$elieh2

Soe}2$Xlerow$jsv$xeomrk$q}$gepp2$Ettvigmexi$mx2$M×q$rsx$viepp}$wyvtvmwih$xlex$}syv$kymhergi$jsv$xli$viqemrhiv$sj$xli$}iev$lew$fiir$piwwirih0$M$qier0$xli

zmvyw$mwwyi$lew$qehi$fywmriww$hmjjmgypx$egvsww$epp$mrhywxvmiw2$Erh$egxyepp}$}syv$vihygxmsr$mw0$xs$qi0$qmrmqep2$Mj$M×q$pssomrk$ex$xli$ryqfivw0$}syv$viziryiw

{ivi$hs{r$(544$qmppmsr$erh$}syv$EJJS${ew$hs{r$efsyx$54)$sv$56)$sv$wsqixlmrk$pmoi$xlex2$Fyx$xli$wxsgo×w$hs{r$uymxi$e$fmx$qsvi$xler$xlex2$Erh$mr$e

{svph${livi$}miph$mw$ex$e$tviqmyq$erh$xli$}miph$xlex×w$jvsq$}syv$hmzmhirh$mw$viepp}$irsvqsyw0${lmgl$wlsyph$fi$exxvegxmzi$xs$tistpi0${lex$hs$}sy$xlmro

}sy$epp$gsyph$hs$xs$kix$}syv$wxsgo$tvmgi$ytC$M$qier$xli$}miph$wlsyph$fi$exxvegxmrk$tistpi$erh$M$yrhivwxerh$xlex$xlivi$mw$givxemr$kvsytw$sj$tistpi${ls

{sr×x$mrziwx$mr$jsv$tvsjmx$tvmwsrw$erh$xlmrkw$pmoi$xlex2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 29 of 34

Page 393: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\1==26

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=hi|==62lxq 54358

Fyx0$wmrgi$xlivi×w$viepp}$srp}$x{s$jmvqw$}syvwipj$erh$GsviGmzmg$xlex$evi$tyfpmgp}$xvehih$mr$xlmw$evie$erh$xlivi×w$tpirx}$sj$tvmzexi$iuymx}$qsri}$syx$xlivi0

xvmppmsrw$M$yrhivwxerh0$xlex${syph$pszi$xli$wsvx$sj$vixyvr$}sy×vi$efpi$xs$kirivexi2$Mw$xlivi$e$keqi$tper$xs$lstijypp}$kix$xlmw$tvmgi$yt0$wmrgi$}sy$hsr×x$lezi

er}$gsziveki$sv$wtsrwsvwlmt$syx$xlivi$erh$sxliv${e}w$xlex$rsvqepp}$}sy$qmklx$fi$efpi$xs$kirivexi$wsqi$mrxiviwx$mr$xli$wxsgo0$srgi$wsqi$sj$xliwi

gsrgivrw$jehi$e{e}0${lixliv$xli$tspmxmgep$gsrgivrw0$sv$mj$xli$zmvyw$jmrepp}$efexiwC

Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Glemvqer0$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$*$Jsyrhiv0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

[ipp0$M$xlmro0$ew$xli$wigsrh$uyevxiv$yrjsphw0$wlevilsphivw${mpp$wii$e$wxevo$gsqtevmwsr$fix{iir$syv$gsqter}$erh$xli$mrhywxv}$zivwyw$sxlivw$erh${i×vi$er

iwwirxmep$kszivrqirx$wivzmgi$tvszmhivw0$}sy$gsvvigxp}$wxexih$xlex$syv$tvsjmxefmpmx}$mw$qe}$fi$gsqtviwwmrk$f}$54)0$55)0$fyx$xlex×w$jev$fixxiv$xler$xli

x}tmgep$gsqtermiw$xlvsyklsyx$xli$gsyrxv}0$erh$M$xlmro$wlevilsphivw$erh$mrziwxsvw${mpp$wii$e$wxevo$gsqtevmwsr$ew$xmqi$qsziw$jsv{evh$xlmw$}iev0$erh${i

tper$xs$viegl$syx$xs$xli$mrziwxqirx$gsqqyrmx}$xlvsyklsyx$xli$}iev$mr$hmjjivirx$vseh$wls{w$erh$xepo$efsyx$xli$gsqter}$erh$viqmrh$xliq$sj$xli$omrh$sj

fywmriww${i×vi$mr0$xli$tvihmgxefmpmx}$sj$syv$gewl$jps{w$erh$xli$kirivsyw$rexyvi$sj$syv$hmzmhirh2$Ws${i$xlmro$xli$igsrsqmg$gsrhmxmsrw$evi$mr$syv$jezsv

erh0$mr$xmqi0$qsvi$erh$qsvi$tistpi${mpp$wii$xlmw$erh$xli$wxsgo${mpp$mrgviewi2

Epp$vmklx2$Soe}2$Xlero$}sy2$Xlex×w$omrh$sj$q}$xlsyklxw$ew${ipp0$mx×w$nywx$e$qexxiv$sj$xmqi$ew$psrk$ew$}sy$ger$i|igyxi2$Mr$xli$qierxmqi0$mj$}sy$ger

qemrxemr$wsqi$wiqfpergi$sj$}syv$gyvvirx$hmzmhirh$xlex×w$ksmrk$xs$gsrxmryi$xs$exxvegx$wsqi$exxirxmsr2$Ws0$xlerow$jsv$}syv$xmqi$xlmw$qsvrmrk2

Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Glemvqer0$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$*$Jsyrhiv0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

Xlero$}sy2

Stivexsv

Syv$ri|x$uyiwxmsr$gsqiw$jvsq$Hezmh$Rejx~kiv$sj$Evxmie$Getmxep$Qerekiqirx2$Tpiewi$ks$elieh2

Hezmh$Rejx~kiv

Erep}wx0$Evxmie$Getmxep$Qerekiqirx2

Lm2$Q}$uyiwxmsr$mw$omrh$sj$mr$xli$pmri$sj$xli$pewx$sri$erh$Ò$egxyepp}$pewx$x{s2$[lex$tsvxmsr$sj$Ò$M$qier0$}syv$mrhywxv}$mw$yrhiv$exxego$f}$e$givxemr$kvsyt$sj

tistpi$mr$xli$gsyrxv}0${lex$tsvxmsr$sj$tvmwsrw$fi}srh$xli$x{s$tyfpmg$gsqtermiw$evi$tvmzexi$tvmwsr$jegmpmxmiwC

Fvmer$V2$Izerw

Glmij$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv$*$Wirmsv$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

M$qier0$fix{iir$syvwipziw$erh$GsviGmzmg0${i×vi$efsyx$<4)$sj$xli$tvmzexip}$qerekih$jegmpmxmiw$mr$xli$YW2

Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Glemvqer0$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$*$Jsyrhiv0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

Qe}fi$qsvi2

Fvmer$V2$Izerw

Glmij$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv$*$Wirmsv$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

]iel0$qe}fi$e$pmxxpi$fmx$qsvi$rs{0$ws$piww$xler$Ò$64)$sv$piww2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 30 of 34

Page 394: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\1==26

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=hi|==62lxq 55358

Hezmh$Rejx~kiv

Erep}wx0$Evxmie$Getmxep$Qerekiqirx2

Soe}2$Erh$hs$}sy$lezi$er}$mrgirxmzi0$sxliv$xler$nywx$fimrk$kssh$gsvtsvexi$gmxm~irw$erh$gmxm~irw$sj${svph$jsv$KIS$GeviC$Hs$}sy$kix$er}$vi{evh$mr$wsqi

{e}$jsv$liptmrk$}syv$texmirxw$erh$vihygmrk$vigmhmzmwqC

Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Glemvqer0$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$*$Jsyrhiv0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

[ipp0$M$xlmro0$syv$wxexi$gpmirxw$mr$tevxmgypevp}$ors{$xli$zepyi$sj$xli$Gsrxmryyq$sj$Gevi$tvskveq$xlex${i×zi$iwxefpmwlih0${lmgl${i$xlmro$mw$eqsrk$xli$fiwx

sjjirhiv$vilefmpmxexmsr$tvskveqw$mr$xli${svph0$figeywi$mx×w$ws$gsqtvilirwmzi$mr$rexyvi${mxl$viwtigx$xs$mxw$vilefmpmxexmsr$gsqtsrirxw$sr1wmxi$ew${ipp$ew$xli

tswx1vipiewi$wivzmgiw${lmgl${i$tvszmhi$srgi$xli}$piezi$xli$jegmpmx}$mr$tvszmhmrk$xliq$ewwmwxergi$jsv$jmrergmep$tyvtswiw0$xverwtsvxexmsr0$iqtps}qirx0

lsywmrk2$[i$lezi$M$xlmro$59$tswmxmsrw$wpsxxih$nywx$jsv$xlex$tyvtswi0$tswx1vipiewi$wivzmgiw2$Ws0$mr$xli$wxexi$mrgevgivexmsr$wigxsv0${i$xlmro${i×vi$fvmrkmrk$e

psx$xs$xli$xefpi$ew$jev$ew$vilefmpmxexmsr$qsvi$xler$er}$sxliv$svkerm~exmsr$M×q$e{evi$sj2$[i$lezi$94$tistpi$mr$syv$gsvtsvexi$sjjmgiw2$Xlex×w${lex$xli}$hs2

Xli}×vi$tevx$sj$xli$vilefmpmxexmsr$tvskveq2$Ws0$M×q$rsx$e{evi$sj$er}$sxliv$svkerm~exmsr$mr$xli${svph$gsvvigxmsrep0$tyfpmg$sv$tvmzexi$xlex$lew$ewwiqfpih$xli

ryqfiv$sj$tistpi$xlex${i$lezi$erh$gsrxvmfyxiw$Ó${lex$tsvxmsr$sj$syv$tvsjmx$mw$mxC

Fvmer$V2$Izerw

Glmij$Jmrergmep$Sjjmgiv$*$Wirmsv$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

54)2

Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Glemvqer0$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$*$Jsyrhiv0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

54)$sj$KIS×w$rix$tvsjmx$mw$wtirx$sr$wyttsvxmrk$xlmw$sjjirhiv$vilefmpmxexmsr$tvskveq2$M$ger×x$xlmro$sj$er}$sxliv$gsqtermiw$mr$xli${svph$xlex$gsqqmxxih

54)$sj$xlimv$tvsjmxw$xs$sjjirhiv$vilefmpmxexmsr$sv$gvmqmrep$nywxmgi$vijsvq$ew${i$lezi2

Hezmh$Rejx~kiv

Erep}wx0$Evxmie$Getmxep$Qerekiqirx2

Soe}2$[ipp$M×q$kpeh$xs$liev$xlex$figeywi$mx×w$wygl$e$tspmxmgep$mwwyi$sj${lex$}sy$hs2$Erh$ew$e$fipmiziv$mr$kssh$getmxepmwq0$M$xlmro$xlex$lettirw$epp$sj$xli

xmqi2$Fyx$xli${e}$}sy$kix$}sy×vi$yrhiv$exxego$ew$xlsykl$}sy×vi$rsx$hsmrk0$fyx$q}$wywtmgmsr$mw$}sy×vi$hsmrk$fixxiv$xler$xli$wxexi1vyr$jegmpmxmiw$erh$xli

jihivep$jegmpmxmiw2$Erh$M$nywx$pmoi222

Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Glemvqer0$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$*$Jsyrhiv0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

]iel2

Hezmh$Rejx~kiv

Erep}wx0$Evxmie$Getmxep$Qerekiqirx2

222$xli$tvizmsyw$uyiwxmsr${ew222

Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Glemvqer0$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$*$Jsyrhiv0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

Erh${i222

Hezmh$Rejx~kiv

Erep}wx0$Evxmie$Getmxep$Qerekiqirx2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 31 of 34

Page 395: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\1==26

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=hi|==62lxq 56358

222$ls{$hs$}sy$kix$xli${svh$syx$erh$kix$xli$tistpi$fy}$xli$wxsgoC

Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Glemvqer0$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$*$Jsyrhiv0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

[i${syph$fi$vipiewmrk$syv$ri|x$erryep$vitsvx$xlex$hiwgvmfiw$xli$egxmzmxmiw$sj$xli$Gsrxmryyq$sj$Gevi$tvskveq$jsv$645=2$Xlex${mpp$fi$syx$ri|x$qsrxl$erh

{i×pp$Ò${i×pp$wirh$xlex$xs$epp$sj$syv$wlevilsphivw$erh$mrziwxsvw2

Hezmh$Rejx~kiv

Erep}wx0$Evxmie$Getmxep$Qerekiqirx2

Soe}2$Psso$jsv{evh$xs$mx$figeywi$M×h$pmoi$xs$lezi$qsvi$kssh$jiipmrk$tyfpmgmx}$vexliv$xler$tistpi$we}mrk0$sl0$wxexi222

Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Glemvqer0$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$*$Jsyrhiv0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

]iel2

Hezmh$Rejx~kiv

Erep}wx0$Evxmie$Getmxep$Qerekiqirx2

2222$tvmzexi$mrhywxv}$wlsyph$rsx$tvsjmx$jvsq$tvmwsrivw$ew$xlsykl$}sy$gviexi$tvmwsrivw0$}sy$hsr×x$gviexi$tvmwsrivw0$}sy222

Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Glemvqer0$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$*$Jsyrhiv0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

Rs2

Hezmh$Rejx~kiv

Erep}wx0$Evxmie$Getmxep$Qerekiqirx2

222lsywi$xliq2$Vmklx2

Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Glemvqer0$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$*$Jsyrhiv0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

[i$xeoi$gevi$sj$xliq$erh$mx${ew$viepp}$mr$syv$s{r$mrmxmexmzi$xlex${i$hizipstih$xlmw$tvskveq2$[i${ivir×x$temh$xs$hs$mx2$[i$wtirx$syv$s{r$qsri}

hizipstmrk$mx$jsv$qer}0$qer}$}ievw$erh${i×vi$tvsyh$xlex${i$lezi${lex${i$fipmizi$mw$tswwmfp}$xli$jmriwx$sjjirhiv$vilefmpmxexmsr$tvskveq$mr$xli${svph2

Hezmh$Rejx~kiv

Erep}wx0$Evxmie$Getmxep$Qerekiqirx2

Oiit$yt$xli$kssh${svo$erh$kix$xli${svh$syx2$Xlero$}sy2

Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Glemvqer0$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$*$Jsyrhiv0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

Xlero$}sy2

Stivexsv

Syv$ri|x$uyiwxmsr$gsqiw$jvsq$Levzi}$Tsttip$sj$Tstxigl$PT2$Tpiewi$ks$elieh2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 32 of 34

Page 396: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\1==26

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=hi|==62lxq 57358

Levzi}$Tsttip

S{riv0$Tstxigl$PT

Xlero$}sy$ziv}$qygl2$]sy×zi$fiir$ziv}$gpiev$efsyx$xli$mqtegx2$M$ettvigmexi$xli$gpevmx}2$]sy$qehi$sri$gsqqirx$xlsykl$ziv}$fvmijp}$erh$M${syph${erx

xs$nywx$lezi$}sy$gsqqirx$sr$mx2$]sy$wemh$wsqixlmrk$xs$xli$ijjigx$xlex$}syv$viwypxw$evi$ehiuyexi$xs$gsziv$xli$hmzmhirh0$hsiw$xlex$mqtp}$xlex$xli$hmzmhirh$mw

weji$jsv$rs{C

Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Glemvqer0$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$*$Jsyrhiv0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

Mw$wejiv$Ó$M×q$rsx$wyvi${lex$}syv$uyiwxmsrw$mw2$Mw$Ó$evi$}sy$ewomrk${lixliv$mx×w$xiqtsvevmp}$wejiC

Levzi}$Tsttip

S{riv0$Tstxigl$PT

[ipp0$M$xlmro0${lexiziv$gsqqirxw$}sy×pp$lezi0$fyx$ls{$jev$syx$mw$mx$hs$}sy$wii$xlex$mx×w$wejiC

Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Glemvqer0$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$*$Jsyrhiv0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

[ipp0$mx×w$givxemrp}$weji$gsrwmwxirx${mxl$syv$jsvigewxw0$syv$kymhergi2

Levzi}$Tsttip

S{riv0$Tstxigl$PT

Soe}2$Kssh2$Xli$wigsrh$uyiwxmsr$xlex×w$Ò$xlex×w$xli$gpevmjmgexmsr$M${ew$pssomrk$jsv2$Xli$wigsrh$uyiwxmsr$mw$vikevhmrk$xli$szivlerk$sr$xli$wxsgo${lmgl

gsqiw$jvsq$xli$xlviex$sj$e$Hiqsgvexmg$w{iit$ex$xli$irh$Ò$mr$Rsziqfiv2$Erh${syph$pmoi$xs$kix$}syv$gsqqirxw$sr${lex$xli$hs{rwmhi$sj$xlex$qmklx$psso

pmoi$erh$ls{$}sy×vi$tvitevmrk$jsv$mxC

Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Glemvqer0$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$*$Jsyrhiv0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

[ipp0$xlivi$qmklx$fi$piww$sggyterg}$mr$syv$MGI$jegmpmxmiw0$fyx$M$hsr×x$xlmro$mx${syph$fi$piww$xler$mx$mw$xshe}2$[i$stivexih$ziv}$tvsjmxefp}$yrhiv$xli$imklx

}ievw$sj$xli$Sfeqe$ehqmrmwxvexmsr2$Mr$jegx0${i$i|terhih$gsrwmhivefp}$yrhiv$xli$Sfeqe$ehqmrmwxvexmsr0$erh$xli$viewsr${l}$mw$figeywi$yrhiv$xlex

ehqmrmwxvexmsr0$xlivi${ew$e$vemwmrk$sj$xli$wxerhevhw$sj$uyepmx}$jsv$xlswi$xlex${ivi$gmzmpp}$hixemrih2$Erh$xlivi${ivi$tl}wmgep$tperx$ytkvehiw$xlex${ivi

rigiwwev}0$wxejjmrk$ytkvehiw0$liepxlgevi$ytkvehiw0$erh$e$psx$sj$xli$tvizmsyw$kszivrqirxep$wivzmgi$tvszmhivw$jsv$MGI$mr$tevxmgypev$wemh0$rs0${i×vi$rsx$efpi

xs$qiix$xlswi$viuymviqirxw$erh$xli$MGI$xyvrih$xs$xli$tvmzexi$wigxsv${lmgl$hmh$qiix$xlswi$wxerhevhw2$Ws${i$fympx$ri{$jegmpmxmiw$erh$xlex$qix$xlswi

wxerhevhw0$erh${i$kvi{$yrhiv$e$hiqsgvexmg$ehqmrmwxvexmsr$erh$xlex0$M${syph$xlmro0$mj$xlivi$mw$e$hiqsgvexmg$Tviwmhirx$wygl$ew$xli$jsvqiv$Zmgi$Tviwmhirx

xlex$li${syph$lezi$e$gsrxmryexmsr$sj$xlswi$tspmgmiw2

Levzi}$Tsttip

S{riv0$Tstxigl$PT

Soe}2$Xlero$}sy$ziv}$qygl2

Stivexsv

Xlmw$gsrgpyhiw$syv$uyiwxmsr1erh1erw{iv$wiwwmsr2$M${syph$pmoi$xs$xyvr$xli$gsrjivirgi$fego$sziv$xs$Kisvki$^spi}$jsv$er}$gpswmrk$viqevow2

Kisvki$G2$^spi}

Glemvqer0$Glmij$I|igyxmzi$Sjjmgiv$*$Jsyrhiv0$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 33 of 34

Page 397: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

<35436464 I\1==26

jmpi>33thg1jwz463qme1ywiv3Ogsrrspp}3Hiwoxst3KIS$jmpmrk3h=695:=hi|==62lxq 58358

[ipp0$xlerow$xs$iziv}sri$jsv$nsmrmrk$yw$xshe}2$[i$psso$jsv{evh$xs$ehhviwwmrk$}sy$sr$xli$wigsrh$uyevxiv$ievrmrkw$gepp2$Xlero$}sy2

Stivexsv

Xli$gsrjivirgi$lew$rs{$gsrgpyhih2$Xlero$}sy$jsv$exxirhmrk$xshe}×w$tviwirxexmsr2$Erh$}sy$qe}$rs{$hmwgsrrigx2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 34 of 34

Page 398: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

EXHIBIT 4

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-4 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 1 of 3

Page 399: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-4 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 2 of 3

Page 400: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-4 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 3 of 3

Page 401: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

EXHIBIT 5

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-5 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 1 of 13

Page 402: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

;35736464 KIS$Kvsyt×w$Fpyrhivmrk$Liptih$Wtvieh$Gsvsrezmvyw

lxxtw>33xlimrxivgitx2gsq3646434:35;3lepj{e}1lsywi1gsvsrezmvyw1kis1kvsyt3 5359

"--5342'4,0/7 &+) "/4)2()14

)'1")4172È5"$.70&'4+0)4'52105'"61"6*'"2#0&'/+%*'.2'&"524'#&%1410#8+475"+0"*#.(9#;

*175'5$,-,'/' %)*52'

#5/) := ;9;96 <799 '8.8

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-5 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 2 of 13

Page 403: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

;35736464 KIS$Kvsyt×w$Fpyrhivmrk$Liptih$Wtvieh$Gsvsrezmvyw

lxxtw>33xlimrxivgitx2gsq3646434:35;3lepj{e}1lsywi1gsvsrezmvyw1kis1kvsyt3 6359

Vjg"yqogp"ygtg"vjg"hktuv"vq"igv"ukem0"ÈKv"ycu"nkmg"hnw"u{orvqou.É

tgecnngf"c"tgukfgpv"qh�vjg"yqogpÇu"fqto"cv"vjg"Itquuocp"Egpvgt."c

hgfgtcn"jcnhyc{"jqwug"kp"Ngcxgpyqtvj."Mcpucu."twp"d{"vjg"rtkxcvg"rtkuqp

eqorcp{"IGQ"Itqwr0"Vyq"yqogp"dgicp"eqwijkpi."igvvkpi"eqnf"uygcvu.

cpf"twppkpi"c"hgxgt"ctqwpf"okf/"vq"ncvg"Crtkn0"D{"vjg"gpf"qh"vjg"oqpvj.

vjg{"jcf"dggp"vcmgp"vq"vjg"jqurkvcn"cpf�vguvgf"rqukvkxg"hqt"vjg

eqtqpcxktwu0"ÈCpf"vjcvÇu"yjgp"vjg{"uvctvgf"vguvkpi"cnn"qh"wu0É

Kp"vjg"yqogpÇu"fqto."c"jcnh/fq|gp"tgukfgpvu"jcf"dggp"yqtmkpi"cv

Vtkworj"Hqqfu."c"rqtm"rtqeguukpi"rncpv"kp"Uv0�Lqugrj."Okuuqwtk."uqog"62

okngu"pqtvj"qh"vjg"jcnhyc{"jqwug0"ÈJqpguvn{."kv"ycu"jqttkdng.É"uckf"qpg

yqocp"yjq"jcf"c"lqd"ewvvkpi"ogcv"qp"cp"cuugodn{"nkpg0"Vjg"urceg"ycu

etqyfgf."cpf"ujg"ycu"eqpuvcpvn{"eqnf"gxgp"dgpgcvj"nc{gtu"qh"rtqvgevkxg

igct."yjkej"tgswktgf"jgt"vq"cttkxg"gctn{"kp"qtfgt"vq"igv"ftguugf0"Vjg

nqemgt"tqqou"yqwnf"igv"uq"hwnn."cpqvjgt"yqtmgt"uckf."vjcv"ujg"jcf"vq

yckv"hqt"qvjgtu"vq"gzkv"dghqtg"ujg"eqwnf"iq"kp0

Vjg"hktuv"vyq"rqukvkxg"ecugu"cv"vjg"Vtkworj"rncpv�ygtg"eqphktogf"qp

Crtkn"420"Uqqp"vjgtg"ygtg"jwpftgfu"oqtg0"Yqtmgtu"ncwpejgf"c

Ejcpig0qti"rgvkvkqp�kp"Urcpkuj"cpf"Gpinkuj."cumkpi"vjcv"vjg"rncpv"dg

vgorqtctkn{"enqugf."cpf"yctpkpi"qh"vjg�vjtgcv"vq"vjg"uwttqwpfkpi

eqoowpkv{0"D{"gctn{"Oc{."c"yqtmgt"jcf"fkgf"cpf"vjg"rncpv"jcf"dggp

nkpmgf"vq"tkukpi�eqtqpcxktwu"ecugu"kp"cpf"ctqwpf"Mcpucu"Ekv{0"ÈKÇo"tgcnn{

eqpegtpgf"cdqwv"vjku.É"vjg"nqecn"jgcnvj"fgrctvogpv"fktgevqt"vqnf"vjg

rtguu0"ÈVjku"ikxgu"{qw"c"iqqf"gzcorng"vjcv"vjgtg"ctg"c"nqv"oqtg"ecugu

qwv"vjgtg"vjcv"yg"fqpÇv"mpqy"cdqwv0É

Cetquu"vjg"dqtfgt"kp"Mcpucu."chvgt"vjg"hktuv"vyq"jcnhyc{"jqwug"tgukfgpvu

iqv"ukem."cnoquv"cnn"vjg"yqogp"yjq"yqtmgf"cv"vjg"rncpv"vguvgf"rqukvkxg

vqq0"Vjqug"yjq"vguvgf"pgicvkxg"ygtg"oqxgf."hktuv"wruvcktu"vq"vjg"tqqo

vjcv"jcf"dggp"wugf"vq"swctcpvkpg"vjg"ukem"yqogp."cpf"vjgp"fqypuvcktu

vq"c"urceg"wuwcnn{"tgugtxgf"cu"c"lqd"egpvgt0"ÈVjcv"ycu"jqttkdng"dgecwug"kv

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-5 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 3 of 13

Page 404: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

;35736464 KIS$Kvsyt×w$Fpyrhivmrk$Liptih$Wtvieh$Gsvsrezmvyw

lxxtw>33xlimrxivgitx2gsq3646434:35;3lepj{e}1lsywi1gsvsrezmvyw1kis1kvsyt3 7359

ycu"nkmg"c"tgcnn{"uocnn"ctgc"hqt"cnn"hqwt"qh"wu.É"qpg"qh"vjgo"tgecnngf0

Fgurkvg"vjg"cvvgorvu"cv"swctcpvkpg."c"yggm"ncvgt."ujg"vguvgf"rqukvkxg"vqq0

4mti|ml

#{"%wzwvi~qz}{"5xzmil{"qv"(mlmzit"2zq{wv{½"%i{m{"qv"*itn�i�*w}{m{"#zm"$mqvo"7vlmzkw}v|ml

Ogcpyjkng."qp"vjg"ogpÇu"ukfg."tgukfgpvu"ygtg"pqvkhkgf"vjcv"vjg

eqtqpcxktwu"jcf"ocfg"kvu"yc{"kpvq"vjg"Itquuocp"Egpvgt0"Qpg"hqtogt

tgukfgpv"ycu"cv"yqtm"qp"Crtkn"52"yjgp"jg"iqv"c"rjqpg"ecnn�qtfgtkpi"jko

vq"tgvwtp"vq"vjg"jcnhyc{"jqwug0�Yjgp"jg"iqv"vjgtg."c"swctcpvkpg"fqto

ycu"dgkpi"ugv"wr��tgukfgpvu"ygtg"dgkpi"oqxgf"vq"engct"urceg0"Jku"wpkv

yqwnf"dg"vguvgf"vjg"pgzv"fc{0

Dwv"vjcv"ucog"pkijv."jg"uckf."vyq"pgy"rgqrng"cttkxgf0"Dqvj"ogp"jcf

dggp"vtcpuhgttgf"htqo"vjg"Hgfgtcn"Eqttgevkqpcn"Kpuvkvwvkqp"kp"Gnmvqp.

Qjkq"Ñ"c"ygnn/mpqyp"eqtqpcxktwu"jqv"urqv0"Vjg"ogp"ygtg"rncegf"kp"c

etqyfgf"wpkv="È44"qh"wu"nkxkpi"kp"vjg"ctgc"qh"c"vjtgg/ect"ictcig.É�vjg

hqtogt"tgukfgpv"tgecnngf0"Vjg"pgzv"oqtpkpi."qp"Htkfc{."Oc{"3."vjg{"ygtg

cnn"vguvgf"hqt"Eqxkf/3;0"Yjgp"vjg"tguwnvu"ecog"dcem"vjg"hqnnqykpi

Oqpfc{."qpg"qh"vjg"ogp"htqo"Gnmvqp"jcf"vguvgf"rqukvkxg0"Kp"qvjgt

yqtfu."vjg"hqtogt"tgukfgpv"uckf."jg"jcf"dggp"kphgevgf"dghqtg"cttkxkpi"cv

vjg"jcnhyc{"jqwug0

Gxgp"oqtg"cnctokpi."cu"vjg{"cyckvgf"vguv"tguwnvu"qxgt"vjg"yggmgpf.

gxgt{qpg"jcf"tgockpgf"okzgf"vqigvjgt."ykvjqwv"mpqykpi"yjq"okijv"dg

gzrqukpi"yjqo0"Qp"Oqpfc{."vjg"ucog"fc{"jg�hqwpf"qwv"jgÇf"vguvgf

pgicvkxg."vjg"tgukfgpv"dgicp"vq"hggn"wpfgt"vjg"ygcvjgt<"Èc"nkvvng"ft{

eqwij."c"jgcfcejg."cpf"c"uetcvej{"vjtqcv0É"Jg"tgrqtvgf"jku"u{orvqou"vq

uvchh"vq"pq"cxckn0"D{"Ygfpgufc{"oqtpkpi."jg"yqmg"wr"ftgpejgf"kp

uygcv."{gv"uq"eqnf"jku"vggvj"ygtg"ejcvvgtkpi0"Chvgt"vjcv."Èvjg"dqf{"cejgu

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-5 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 4 of 13

Page 405: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

;35736464 KIS$Kvsyt×w$Fpyrhivmrk$Liptih$Wtvieh$Gsvsrezmvyw

lxxtw>33xlimrxivgitx2gsq3646434:35;3lepj{e}1lsywi1gsvsrezmvyw1kis1kvsyt3 8359

ecog0"Cnn"vjku"uvwhh"ecog"kp"ycxgu"cpf"vjg{"ygtg"uq"ugxgtg0"K"iqvvc"dg

jqpguv"ykvj"{qw."K"fkfpÇv"vjkpm"K"ycu"iqppc"ocmg"kv0É

,wqv"1}z"0m�{tm||mz1zqoqvit"zmxwz|qvoÀ"(miztm{{"rw}zvitq{uÀ"&mtq~mzml"|w"�w}À

Vjcv"ocp"tgewrgtcvgf"cpf"jcu"ukpeg"dggp"rncegf"kp"jqog"eqphkpgogpv.

cnqpi"ykvj"fq|gpu"qh"qvjgt"tgukfgpvu0"Vqfc{."vjg"Ngcxgpyqtvj"Eqwpv{

Fgrctvogpv"qh"Jgcnvj"uc{u"vjcv"gxgt{qpg"yjq"vguvgf"rqukvkxg"cv"vjg

Itquuocp"Egpvgt"jcu"tgeqxgtgf0"[gv"vjg"hwnn"vqnn"qh"vjg"qwvdtgcm

tgockpu"korquukdng"vq"ogcuwtg0"Ngcxgpyqtvj"Eqwpv{"ycu"jqog"vq"qpg

qh"vjg"uvcvgÇu"nctiguv�Eqxkf/3;�qwvdtgcmu�Ñ"cpf"rctv"qh"c"tgikqpcn"enwuvgt

kp"Mcpucu"cnqpg"vjcv�kpenwfgf�vjqwucpfu"qh"ecugu0�Cv�vjg"Ncpukpi

Eqttgevkqpcn"Hceknkv{�lwuv"uqwvj"qh"vjg"Itquuocp"Egpvgt."cv"ngcuv":57

ecugu"ygtg"tgeqtfgf0"Vyq"rtkuqp"yqtmgtu"cpf"hqwt�kpectegtcvgf"rgqrng

fkgf"htqo"eqornkecvkqpu"tgncvgf"vq"Eqxkf/3;0

Cnvjqwij�vjg"pwodgt"qh"eqphktogf"ecugu"cv"vjg"Itquuocp"Egpvgt"ku

owej"uocnngt"vjcp"cv"vjg"rtkuqp"qt"ogcvrcemkpi"rncpv."tgukfgpvu"cv

vjg�jcnhyc{"jqwug"fguetkdg"eqpfkvkqpu"vjcv"rqugf"c�ukoknct"fcpigt"vq

vjg�uwttqwpfkpi"eqoowpkv{0"Gxgp"cu"vjg"rcpfgoke"hqtegf"vjg"eqwpvt{

kpvq"nqemfqyp"dgikppkpi"kp"Octej."tgukfgpvu"uvknn"e{engf"kp"cpf"qwv"qh

vjg"hceknkv{"vjtqwij"vjg"gpf"qh"Crtkn0"Vjqug"hqtegf"vq"ngcxg"vjgkt"rquvu"cv

vjg"Vtkworj"rncpv"chvgt"vjg"eqtqpcxktwu"ycu"fkueqxgtgf"vjgtg"ygtg

pgxgtvjgnguu"cnnqygf"vq"igv"qvjgt"lqdu"Ñ"kpenwfkpi"qpg"yqocp"yjq

yqwnf"gxgpvwcnn{"vguv"rqukvkxg"hqt"Eqxkf/3;0"Cpqvjgt"tgukfgpv."yjq

cttkxgf"cv"vjg"Itquuocp"Egpvgt"kp"ncvg"Crtkn."ycu"cdqwv"vq"uvctv"c"lqd"cv

c"pwtukpi"jqog"kp"Ncpukpi"dghqtg"vjg"jcnhyc{"jqwug"ycu"hkpcnn{"nqemgf

fqyp0"Vjcv"tgukfgpv"vguvgf"rqukvkxg"vqq0

Cnvjqwij"kv"jcu"ukpeg"dggp"uwtrcuugf"d{�qvjgt"hceknkvkgu."vjg"Itquuocp

Egpvgt"ycu"hqt"yggmu"vjg"jctfguv"jkv"hgfgtcn"jcnhyc{"jqwug"kp"vjg

+Èu"qv 8

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-5 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 5 of 13

Page 406: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

;35736464 KIS$Kvsyt×w$Fpyrhivmrk$Liptih$Wtvieh$Gsvsrezmvyw

lxxtw>33xlimrxivgitx2gsq3646434:35;3lepj{e}1lsywi1gsvsrezmvyw1kis1kvsyt3 9359

eqwpvt{."ceeqtfkpi"vq"vjg"Dwtgcw"qh"Rtkuqpu0"Vjg"nqecn"jgcnvj

fgrctvogpv"eqwpvgf"89"ecugu"Ñ"jkijgt"vjcp"vjg"dwtgcwÇu"vcnn{."yjkej

fqgu"pqv"kpenwfg"uvchh"qt"rgqrng"kp"vjg"ewuvqf{"qh"qvjgt"cigpekgu0

Ceeqtfkpi"vq"tgukfgpvu"cpf"qvjgtu"hcoknkct"ykvj"vjg"ukvwcvkqp"Ñ"cnn"qh

yjqo"urqmg"vq"Vjg"Kpvgtegrv"qp"eqpfkvkqp"qh"cpqp{okv{"hqt"hgct"qh

tgvcnkcvkqp"Ñ"gxgp"vjg"fktgevqt"qh"vjg"Itquuocp"Egpvgt"tgrqtvgfn{

eqpvtcevgf"vjg"xktwu0"Igq"Itqwr"fkf"pqv"tgurqpf"vq"swguvkqpu"cdqwv"vjku

qt"cp{"curgev"qh"kvu"jcpfnkpi"qh"vjg"rcpfgoke0

Cu"pcvkqpcn"cvvgpvkqp"vwtpgf"htqo"vjg�eqtqpcxktwu�vq"vjg"rtqvguvu"qxgt

tcekuv"rqnkeg"xkqngpeg"hqnnqykpi"vjg"owtfgt"qh"Igqtig"Hnq{f."Eqxkf/3;

jcu"eqpvkpwgf"vq"urtgcf"cetquu"hgfgtcn"rtkuqpu"cpf"jcnhyc{"jqwugu.

kpenwfkpi"vjqug"twp"d{"IGQ"Itqwr0"Ykvj"vjg"DQR"eqpvkpwkpi"vq

vtcpuhgt�rgqrng"htqo"rtkuqp"vq"jcnhyc{"jqwugu"cetquu"vjg"eqwpvt{

vjtqwijqwv"vjg"rcpfgoke"Ñ"cpf"ykvj"ocp{�uvcvgu"ewttgpvn{

gzrgtkgpekpi"c"tguwtigpeg"qh"ecugu"Ñ"vjg"tkum"ku"hct"htqo"qxgt0

#"2iz|qit"2qk|}zm

Vjg"Itquuocp"Egpvgt"ku"nqecvgf"pqtvjyguv"qh"Mcpucu"Ekv{.�pqv"hct

htqo�yjgtg"vjg"Okuuqwtk"Tkxgt"hqtou"McpucuÇu"gcuvgtp"dqtfgt0"C"4239

cwfkv"fguetkdgu"vjg"dwknfkpi"cu"Èc"ogvcn"uvtwevwtg"ykvj"vyq"hnqqtu.É"ykvj

ukz"fqtokvqt{/uv{ng"jqwukpi"wpkvu"eqpvckpkpi"c"vqvcn"qh"366"dgfu0"Qwvukfg

vjgtgÇu"c"tgetgcvkqp"ctgc"ykvj"c"dcumgvdcnn"jqqr"cpf"rkepke"vcdngu0"C

tgukfgpv"jcpfdqqm"htqo"4235"nc{u"qwv"c"nkuv"qh"Tgukfgpv"Tkijvu.

kpenwfkpi"Èvjg"tkijv"vq"c"jwocpg"gpxktqpogpv"vjcv"rtqxkfgu"tgcuqpcdng

rtqvgevkqp"htqo"jcto.É"cpf"vjg"Ètkijv"vq"dg"vtgcvgf"ykvj"fkipkv{"cpf

tgurgev0É

Nkmg"cnn"jcnhyc{"jqwugu."vjg"Itquuocp"Egpvgt"ku"uwrrqugf"vq"cuukuv

rgqrng"tgvwtpkpi"htqo"rtkuqp"kp"hkpfkpi"lqdu"cpf"jqwukpi."vq"gcug"vjgkt

vtcpukvkqp"dcem"kpvq"uqekgv{0"Kp"IGQ"ItqwrÇu"eqtrqtcvg"rctncpeg."vjku"ku

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-5 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 6 of 13

Page 407: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

;35736464 KIS$Kvsyt×w$Fpyrhivmrk$Liptih$Wtvieh$Gsvsrezmvyw

lxxtw>33xlimrxivgitx2gsq3646434:35;3lepj{e}1lsywi1gsvsrezmvyw1kis1kvsyt3 :359

4mil"1}z"%wuxtm|m"%w~mziom

6pm"%wzwvi~qz}{"%zq{q{

rctv"qh"kvu"gxgt/gzrcpfkpi"Eqpvkpwwo"qh"Ectg"Fkxkukqp."Ègpjcpegf"kp/

ewuvqf{"qhhgpfgt"tgjcdknkvcvkqp"rtqitcookpi"Ã"kpvgitcvgf"ykvj"rquv/

tgngcug"uwrrqtv"ugtxkegu0É"Ncuv"{gct."vjg"eqtrqtcvkqp"tgrqtvu"urgpfkpi

uqog"&32"oknnkqp"qp"vjg"Eqpvkpwwo"qh"Ectg"rtqitco."yjkej"kv

fguetkdgu"cu"ÈIGQÇu"eqpvtkdwvkqp"vq"etkokpcn"lwuvkeg"tghqto0É

Qh"eqwtug."IGQ"Itqwr"ku"oquv"hcoqwu"hqt"kvu"rtkoct{"dwukpguu."rtkxcvg

rtkuqpu."cpf"gurgekcnn{"hqt"kpectegtcvkpi"wpfqewogpvgf"kookitcpvu"hqt

vjg"hgfgtcn"iqxgtpogpv0"Kp"tgegpv"{gctu."vjg"eqorcp{"jcu"hqwijv

cvvgorvu"vq"dcp"kvu"hceknkvkgu"cpf"dggp"hqtegf"vq"fghgpf"kvu"tgrwvcvkqp=

ncuv"{gct."c"RT"hkto"ewv"vkgu"ykvj"vjg"eqtrqtcvkqp"lwuv"vyq"oqpvju"chvgt

ncpfkpi�vjg"eqpvtcev"chvgt"kvu"qyp"gornq{ggu"tgxqnvgf0

Cokf"uwej"dcemncuj"Ñ"cpf"ykvj"vjg"tkug"qh"etkokpcn"lwuvkeg"tghqto"cu"c

ockpuvtgco"rqnke{"iqcn"Ñ"IGQ"Itqwr"jcu"oqxgf"kpetgcukpin{"kpvq

tggpvt{"cpf"cnvgtpcvkxgu"vq"kpectegtcvkqp0"Kp"4239"kv"ceswktgf

Eqoowpkv{"Gfwecvkqp"Egpvgtu."ickpkpi"vjqwucpfu"qh"tggpvt{"dgfu0

Cnqpi"ykvj"EqtgEkxke.�kv"cnuq"xqecnn{"uwrrqtvgf"vjg"hgfgtcn"Hktuv"Uvgr"Cev

rcuugf"kp"423:."yjkej"rngfigf"jwpftgfu"qh"oknnkqpu"qh"fqnnctu"vq

gzrcpfgf"tggpvt{"ugtxkegu0"Vqfc{"IGQ"Itqwr"eqwpvu"67"tgukfgpvkcn

tggpvt{"egpvgtu."qt"TTEu."cu"rctv"qh"kvu"yjqnn{"qypgf"uwdukfkct{."IGQ

Ectg0"Cnvjqwij"oquv"eqpvtcev"cv"vjg"uvcvg"ngxgn."cv"ngcuv�36"jcxg

eqpvtcevu"ykvj"vjg"DQR."kpenwfkpi"vjg"Itquuocp"Egpvgt0"Cpqvjgt"ugv

uvknn"qrgtcvg"wpfgt"vjg�EGE"pcog."cnvjqwij"vjg"rtgekug"pwodgt"ku

wpengct0

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-5 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 7 of 13

Page 408: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

;35736464 KIS$Kvsyt×w$Fpyrhivmrk$Liptih$Wtvieh$Gsvsrezmvyw

lxxtw>33xlimrxivgitx2gsq3646434:35;3lepj{e}1lsywi1gsvsrezmvyw1kis1kvsyt3 ;359

Jcnhyc{"jqwugu"jcxg"dggp"nctign{"qxgtnqqmgf"fwtkpi"vjg"eqtqpcxktwu

etkuku0"Cnvjqwij"vjg{"ctg"c"urgem�kp"vjg"eqwpvt{Çu"ectegtcn"ncpfuecrg.

vjg{"ctg"cnuq"wpkswgn{"uwkvgf"vq"dg"xgevqtu"hqt"vjg"xktwu0"Cv"vjg"hgfgtcn

ngxgn."vjg"pwodgt"qh"TTEu"ykvj"eqphktogf"ecugu"jcu"vkemgf"uvgcfkn{

wryctf."cu"jcxg"vjg"vqvcn"pwodgt"qh"tgukfgpvu"vguvkpi"rqukvkxg"hqt"Eqxkf/

3;0"Kp"ncvg"Oc{."vjg"DQR"eqwpvgf"452"Eqxkf/3;"ecugu"cetquu"64"TTEu0

Vqfc{"kv"eqwpvu"497"ecugu"cetquu"6:"TTEu0"[gv"gxgp"vjgug"pwodgtu"ctg"c

rctvkcn"rkevwtg"cv"dguv0"Hqt"qpg."vjg"DQR"vcnn{"fqgu"pqv"eqwpv"tgukfgpvu

yjq"ctg"kp"vjg"ewuvqf{"qh"qvjgt"hgfgtcn"qhhkegu."uwej"cu"W0U0"Rtqdcvkqp

cpf"Rctqng0"Pqt"fqgu"kv"eqwpv"jcnhyc{"jqwug"uvchh"Ñ"c"ukipkhkecpv

qokuukqp0"Vjg"vcnnkgu"nkpmgf"vq"kpfkxkfwcn"hceknkvkgu"jcxg"cnuq"ycxgtgf

kpgzrnkecdn{0"Ykvj"vjg"DQR"vtcemkpi"ÈKpocvgu"RqukvkxgÉ"cu"ygnn"cu

ÈKpocvgu"Tgeqxgtgf.É"vjg"vqvcn"ecugu"vkgf"vq"c"ikxgp"TTE"ujqwnf

eqpvkpwg"vq"iq"wr"qt"qvjgtykug"uvc{"uvgcf{"gxgp"cu"tgukfgpvu"iq"htqo

+tt}{|zi|qwv¿"6pm"+v|mzkmx|

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-5 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 8 of 13

Page 409: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

;35736464 KIS$Kvsyt×w$Fpyrhivmrk$Liptih$Wtvieh$Gsvsrezmvyw

lxxtw>33xlimrxivgitx2gsq3646434:35;3lepj{e}1lsywi1gsvsrezmvyw1kis1kvsyt3 <359

#t|pw}op"pitn�i�pw}{m{"izm"i"{xmks"qv|pm"kw}v|z�È{kizkmzit"tivl{kixm½|pm�"izm"it{w}vqy}mt�"{}q|ml"|w"jm~mk|wz{"nwz"|pmkwzwvi~qz}{À

vjg"hqtogt"vq"vjg"ncvvgt0"Kpuvgcf."vjg"pwodgtu"ctg"ftqrrkpi="vjg

Itquuocp"Egpvgt"rtgxkqwun{"ujqygf"79"ecugu0"Vqfc{"kv"ujqyu"6:0

Cv"ngcuv�ukz"tgukfgpvu"qh

hgfgtcn"jcnhyc{"jqwugu"jcxg

fkgf"qh"Eqxkf/3;."ceeqtfkpi

vq"vjg"DQR."vtkrnkpi"vjg

pwodgtu"uggp"kp"ncvg�Oc{0

Cu"ykvj"rtgxkqwu"fgcvju"cv

TTEu."pq"hwtvjgt

kphqtocvkqp"jcu"dggp

tgngcugf"cdqwv"vjg"hcvcnkvkgu0

Vjtgg"qh"vjg"hcvcnkvkgu"ctg

nkpmgf"vq"IGQ"Itqwr.

kpenwfkpi"vjg"oquv"tgegpv.

yjkej"vqqm"rnceg"cv"c

jcnhyc{"jqwug"kp"Jqwuvqp.

vjg"ugeqpf"cv"vjcv"hceknkv{0

Vjg"qvjgt"ycu"c"tgukfgpv"cv"c

IGQ"hceknkv{"kp"vjg"Dtqpz0"Vjg"eqorcp{"jcu"pqv"tgurqpfgf"vq"swguvkqpu

cdqwv"vjg"fgcvju0

Cpqvjgt"vjtgg"IGQ"Itqwr�TTEu�cetquu"vjg"eqwpvt{"jcxg"tgrqtvgf

rqukvkxg"ecugu"vq"vjg"DQR.�cnqpi"ykvj"vyq"EGE"jcnhyc{"jqwugu0"Ownvkrng

tgukfgpvu"qh"c"IGQ"Itqwr"jcnhyc{"jqwug"kp"Qcmncpf."Ecnkhqtpkc.

fguetkdgf"c"f{uhwpevkqpcn"tgurqpug"vq"vjg"etkuku."vgnnkpi"Vjg"Kpvgtegrv

vjcv"kvu"hktuv"rqukvkxg"ecug"kp"okf/Crtkn"ycu"ogv"ykvj"ukngpeg"htqo"vjg

hceknkv{Çu"fktgevqt0"Dghqtg"c"ugeqpf"ecug"ycu"fkueqxgtgf"c"hgy"fc{u"ncvgt.

tgukfgpvu"yjqug"lqdu"ygtg"fggogf"guugpvkcn"ygtg"cnnqygf"vq"eqpvkpwg

iqkpi"vq"yqtm0"Uvchh"vtkgf"vq"mggr"vjg"ecug"c"ugetgv"tcvjgt"vjcp"ocmg

gxgt{qpg"cyctg"qh"vjg"pggf"vq"vcmg"cffkvkqpcn"rtgecwvkqpu"Ñ"kpenwfkpi

htqo"vjg"ocpÇu"hqtogt"tqqoocvgu."yjq"ygtg"ukorn{"vqnf"vjg{"jcf"vq

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-5 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 9 of 13

Page 410: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

;35736464 KIS$Kvsyt×w$Fpyrhivmrk$Liptih$Wtvieh$Gsvsrezmvyw

lxxtw>33xlimrxivgitx2gsq3646434:35;3lepj{e}1lsywi1gsvsrezmvyw1kis1kvsyt3 =359

tgockp"kuqncvgf"ykvjqwv"gzrncpcvkqp0"Chvgt"cumkpi"cdqwv"vjg"ecug."qpg

tgukfgpv"tgecnnu"dgkpi"vqnf."ÈYg"fqpÇv"mpqy"yjcv"{qwÇtg"vcnmkpi"cdqwv0É

#"$t}vlmzqvo"4m{xwv{m

Cu"vjg"Itquuocp"Egpvgt"ycu"uetcodnkpi"vq"eqpvckp"vjg"xktwu."IGQ

Itqwr"gzgewvkxgu"ygtg"rtqlgevkpi"eqphkfgpeg"vjcv"vjg"eqorcp{"jcf

vjkpiu"wpfgt"eqpvtqn0"ÈHtqo"vjg"qwvugv"qh"vjku"inqdcn"rcpfgoke"qwt

eqtrqtcvg"tgikqpcn"cpf"hkgnf"uvchh"jcxg"korngogpvgf"eqortgjgpukxg

uvgru"vq"cfftguu"cpf"okvkicvg"vjg"tkumu"qh"Eqxkf/3;"vq"cnn"qh"vjqug"kp"qwt

ectg.É"IGQ"Itqwr"hqwpfgt"cpf"EGQ"Igqtig"\qng{"vqnf"kpxguvqtu"fwtkpi"c

swctvgtn{"gctpkpiu"ecnn"jgnf"qp"Crtkn"520"Vjg"jgcnvj"cpf"uchgv{"qh"vjqug

kpukfg"kvu"hceknkvkgu"Èjcu"cnyc{u"dggp"qwt�Pq0"3"rtkqtkv{.É"jg"uckf."cffkpi

vjcv"Ècnn"qh"qwt"hceknkvkgu"qrgtcvg"uchgn{"cpf"ykvjqwv"qxgtetqyfgf

eqpfkvkqpu0É

Nkmg"gxgt{qpg"hqtegf"vq"cpuygt"hqt"jcnhyc{"jqwugu"kp"cp"qhhkekcn

ecrcekv{."IGQ"Ectg"Rtgukfgpv"Cpp"Uejnctd"uckf"vjg"eqorcp{Çu"tggpvt{

hceknkvkgu"ygtg"hqnnqykpi"iwkfcpeg"htqo"vjg"Egpvgtu"hqt"Fkugcug"Eqpvtqn

cpf"Rtgxgpvkqp0"Cnqpi"ykvj"kpetgcugf"rgtuqpcn"j{ikgpg"rtqfwevu."ujg

uckf."Èyg"jcxg"fgrnq{gf"urgekcn"ucpkvcvkqp"vgcou"vq"uvgtknk|g"jkij/

eqpvcev"ctgcu"qh"qwt"hceknkvkgu"cpf"jcxg"fgxgnqrgf"urgekcn"uejgfwngu"cpf

rtqegfwtgu"hqt"vjg"engcpkpi"cpf"fkukphgevkpi"qh"hceknkv{"urcegu"wukpi

ucpkvcvkqp"rtqfwevu"vjcv"ctg"rtqxgp"jgcnvj"ectg/itcfg"fkukphgevcpvu0É

Qp"c"nguu"rqukvkxg"pqvg"Ñ"cpf"fgurkvg"vjg"hcev"vjcv"IGQ"Itqwr"rtqxkfgu

cp"Èguugpvkcn"iqxgtpogpv"ugtxkegÉ"Ñ"\qng{"tgrqtvgf"vjcv"ÈEqxkf/3;"jcu

cnuq"pgicvkxgn{"korcevgf"qwt"rtqlgevgf"tgxgpwgu"cpf"ecuj"hnqyu"hqt"vjg

{gct0É"Cnqpi"ykvj"Kookitcvkqp"cpf"Ewuvqou"Gphqtegogpv"cpf"W0U0

Octujcnu"hceknkvkgu."Èqwt"IGQ"Tggpvt{"Ugtxkegu"dwukpguu"jcu"cnuq"uggp"cp

qeewrcpe{"fgenkpg"dgikppkpi"kp"ncvg"Octej.É"jg"uckf."vjqwij"Èyg"jqrg

vjg"vtgpfu"yknn"kortqxg"ncvgt"vjku"{gct0É

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-5 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 10 of 13

Page 411: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

;35736464 KIS$Kvsyt×w$Fpyrhivmrk$Liptih$Wtvieh$Gsvsrezmvyw

lxxtw>33xlimrxivgitx2gsq3646434:35;3lepj{e}1lsywi1gsvsrezmvyw1kis1kvsyt3 54359

Kp"c"uwdugswgpv"S(C."kpxguvqtu"uqwijv"fgvcknu"cdqwv"vjg"eqtrqtcvkqpÇu

hkpcpekcn"qwvnqqm0"Qpg"cumgf"yjgvjgt"vjg"rtqurgev"qh"c"Fgoqetcvke

cfokpkuvtcvkqp"okijv"dg"dcf"hqt"dwukpguu"cpf"ycu"tgcuuwtgf"vjcv"kv

yqwnf"pqv0"Cpqvjgt"ecnngt"pqvgf"vjcv"È{qwt"kpfwuvt{"ku"wpfgt"cvvcem"d{"c

egtvckp"itqwr"qh"rgqrng"kp"qwt"eqwpvt{.É"uc{kpi"vjcv"jgÇf"nkmg"vq"ugg

Èoqtg"iqqf/hggnkpi"rwdnkekv{É"ctqwpf"gpfgcxqtu"nkmg"IGQÇu"Eqpvkpwwo

qh"Ectg"fkxkukqp0"Chvgt"cnn."È{qw"fqpÇv"etgcvg"rtkuqpgtu."{qw"jqwug"vjgo0É

\qng{"eqpewttgf0"ÈYg"vcmg"ectg"qh"vjgo0"Ã"Cpf"ygÇtg"rtqwf"vjcv"yg

jcxg"yjcv"yg"dgnkgxg"ku"rquukdn{"vjg"hkpguv"qhhgpfgt"tgjcdknkvcvkqp

rtqitco"kp"vjg"yqtnf0É

Fq"{qw"jcxg"c"eqtqpcxktwu"uvqt{"{qw"ycpv"vq"ujctgA"Gockn"wu"cv

eqtqpcxktwuBvjgkpvgtegrv0eqo"qt"wug"qpg"qh"vjgug"ugewtg"ogvjqfu"vq"eqpvcev"c

tgrqtvgt0

Qp"vjg"ucog"fc{"cu"vjg"ecnn."Itquuocp"Egpvgt"tgukfgpvu"ygtg"dgkpi

ujwhhngf"vq"fkhhgtgpv"ugevkqpu"qh"vjg"hceknkv{0"Dwv"vjg

dnwpfgtkpi�tgurqpug�qpn{"ocfg"vjkpiu"yqtug."tgukfgpvu"uckf.

gorjcuk|kpi"vjcv"vjg"xktwu"urtgcf"pqv"kp"urkvg"qh"vjg"hceknkv{Çu"ghhqtvu"vq

eqpvckp"kv."dwv"dgecwug"qh"kv0"Qpg"tgukfgpv"ugpv"rjqvqu"ujqykpi"ogp"kp"c

etqyfgf"dwpm="uqog�yqtg"ocumu"dwv"oquv"fkf"pqv0"Jg"cnuq"ugpv"rjqvqu

qh"vjg"ogcn"rcemgvu"vjcv"ygtg"rtqxkfgf"kp"rnceg"qh"jqv"hqqf"chvgt

mkvejgp"uvchh"uvqrrgf"eqokpi"vq"yqtm<"rncuvke"rqwejgu"eqpvckpkpi

ocemgtgn"hknngvu."ucnvkpgu."cpf"rgcpwv"dwvvgt"etcemgtu0

Eqpvtct{"vq"vjg"encko"vjcv"IGQ"Itqwr"ycu"rtgrctgf"htqo"vjg"qwvugv"vq

tgurqpf"vq"vjg"rcpfgoke."qpg"tgukfgpv"yjq"cttkxgf"cv"vjg"Itquuocp

Egpvgt"kp"Octej"uckf"vjg"hceknkv{"jcf"fqpg"Ècduqnwvgn{"pqvjkpiÉ"vq

okvkicvg"vjg"xktwu."crctv"htqo"uwurgpfkpi"vjg"64/jqwt"rcuugu"vjcv"cnnqy

tgukfgpvu"vq"iq"ugg"hcokn{."cu"qtfgtgf"d{"vjg"DQR0"Cv"qpg"rqkpv."jg"uckf.

Èvjg{"vcrgf"wr"vjgug"dgpejgu"cpf"uckf"vjcv"yg"jcf"vq"ukv."nkmg."c"egtvckp

fkuvcpeg"crctv"htqo"qpg"cpqvjgt0"Ã"Dwv"{qw"jcxg"vq"wpfgtuvcpf."vjg{

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-5 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 11 of 13

Page 412: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

;35736464 KIS$Kvsyt×w$Fpyrhivmrk$Liptih$Wtvieh$Gsvsrezmvyw

lxxtw>33xlimrxivgitx2gsq3646434:35;3lepj{e}1lsywi1gsvsrezmvyw1kis1kvsyt3 55359

É6pm�"pi~m"tq|mzitt�lwvm"vw|pqvo"|wxzw|mk|"}{"nzwukwv|zik|qvo"|pm~qz}{ÀÊ

jcxg"wu"kp"vjgug"wpkvu"vjcv"ctg"uwrgt"uocnn.É"ykvj"c�nkokvgf"pwodgt"qh

dcvjtqqo"uvcnnu."ukpmu."cpf"ujqygtu0"ÈUq"dcukecnn{"tgictfnguu"qh"vjg

rtqvqeqnu"vjg{"vt{"vq"fq"qwvukfg"vjg"wpkv."kpukfg"vjg"wpkv."vjg{"nkvgtcnn{

jcxg"wu"ujqxgf"kp"qp"vqr"qh"gcej"qvjgt0"Uq"vjgtgÇu"tgcnn{"pq"yc{"hqt"wu

vq"jcxg"cp{"v{rg"qh"fkuvcpekpi0"KvÇu"korquukdng0É

Kp"gctn{"Oc{."cu"vjg"ecugu"cv"vjg"Itquuocp"Egpvgt"ujqv"wr."c"yqocp"iqv

c"ugtkgu"qh"oguucigu"htqo"jgt"rctvpgt."c"tgukfgpv"cv"vjg"jcnhyc{"jqwug0

ÈVjg{"jcxg"nkvgtcnn{"fqpg"pqvjkpi"vq"rtqvgev"wu"htqo"eqpvtcevkpi"vjg

xktwu.É"jg"ytqvg0"ÈYg"ctg"kp"vjg"ucog"ctgcu"cu"vjg"qpgu"yjq"ctg"vguvgf

rqukvkxg0É"Oqtgqxgt."cu"vjg"jcnhyc{"jqwug"oqxgf"vjg"tgukfgpvu"htqo

fqto"vq"fqto."jg"uckf"vjcv"tgukfgpvu"jcf"vq"engcp"vjg"ctgcu"vjgougnxgu.

uykrkpi"engcpkpi"uwrrnkgu"vjcv"vjg{"ygtg"pqv"vgejpkecnn{"gxgp"cnnqygf

vq"wug0

Jg"cnuq"tgrqtvgf"vjcv"uvchh

ygtg"igvvkpi"ukem."cnvjqwij

uqog"ygtg"vt{kpi"vq"jkfg"kv0

Cv"ngcuv"qpg"gornq{gg

eqpvkpwgf"vq"eqog"vq"yqtm

fgurkvg"pqv"hggnkpi"ygnn.

yjkng"vt{kpi"vq"mggr"vjgkt

u{orvqou"wpfgt"ytcru."jg

vqnf"jgt0"Cv"qpg"rqkpv."vjg

fktgevqt"fkucrrgctgf"htqo

vjg"jcnhyc{"jqwug0"Cnvjqwij

Vjg"Kpvgtegrv"ycu"pqv"cdng

vq"eqphkto"kv."ukz"fkhhgtgpv"uqwtegu"uckf"vjg{"ygtg"vqnf"vjcv"jg"jcf

eqpvtcevgf"Eqxkf/3;0

Kp"okf/Oc{."chvgt"yggmu"qh"tgukuvcpeg"htqo"vjg"jcnhyc{"jqwug"cpf"DQR.

fq|gpu"qh"tgukfgpvu"ygtg"hkpcnn{�cnnqygf"vq"iq"vq"jqog"eqphkpgogpv0

Vjqug"yjq"tgockpgf"cv"vjg"Itquuocp"Egpvgt"ncvg"ncuv"oqpvj"uckf"vjg{

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-5 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 12 of 13

Page 413: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

;35736464 KIS$Kvsyt×w$Fpyrhivmrk$Liptih$Wtvieh$Gsvsrezmvyw

lxxtw>33xlimrxivgitx2gsq3646434:35;3lepj{e}1lsywi1gsvsrezmvyw1kis1kvsyt3 56359

hgnv"cdcpfqpgf0"ÈVjgtg"ycu"c"nqv"qh"uvchh"yjgp"K"iqv"vjgtg.É"qpg"tgukfgpv

uckf0"ÈPqy"kvÇu"nkmg"pqdqf{Çu"dctgn{"jgtg0É"Vjcv"tgukfgpv"cttkxgf"cv"vjg

hceknkv{"kp"ncvg"Crtkn."hqnnqykpi"c"nqpi"cpf"etqyfgf"Itg{jqwpf"dwu"vtkr

chvgt"dgkpi"tgngcugf"htqo"rtkuqp0"Jcxkpi"tgegkxgf"kpuvtwevkqpu"vq"ugnh/

swctcpvkpg"cv"jqog"hqt"36"fc{u"rtkqt"vq"cttkxkpi"cv"vjg"hceknkv{."vjg

tgukfgpv"vjgp"tgrqtvgf"vq"vjg"jcnhyc{"jqwug0

Dwv"ujqtvn{"chvgt"igvvkpi"c"lqd."vjg"qwvdtgcm"dgicp0"ÈK"vguvgf"pgicvkxg"cv

hktuv.É"vjg"tgukfgpv"uckf0"Dwv"nkmg"uq"ocp{"qvjgtu."vjg"xktwu"gxgpvwcnn{

ecwijv"wr"ykvj"vjgo0"ÈO{"hcokn{"fqgupÇv"wpfgtuvcpf"yj{"vjg{"ocfg

og"eqog"vq"vjku"hceknkv{"kh"vjg{"jcxg"vjku"xktwu"jgtg0É

Cnn"qh"vjg"tgukfgpvu"vqnf"Vjg"Kpvgtegrv"vjcv"vjg{"ygtg"fkuvwtdgf"d{"vjg

ncem"qh"wtigpe{"kp"rtqxkfkpi"ogfkecn"ectg0"ÈKvÇu"rtgvv{"vqwij"fgcnkpi

ykvj"dgkpi"uq"ukem"ykvj"Eqxkf/3;"kp"vjku"hceknkv{"dgecwug"vjg"rgqrng"vjcv

twp"kv"jcxg"pq"eqpegtp"hqt"vjg"hcev"vjcv"ygÇtg"cevwcnn{"ukem.É"qpg"ocp

uckf0"ÈKvÇu"lwuv"nkmg"uvcvkuvkecn"pwodgt"rtqeguukpi0É"Cpqvjgt"tgukfgpv

ecnngf"kv"yqtug"vjcp"rtkuqp0"ÈOgpvcnn{"KÇo"iqkpi"etc|{.É"vjg{"uckf0

Fgurkvg"vjg"qwvfqqt"tgetgcvkqp"ctgc."vjg{"ygtg"pqv"dgkpi"cnnqygf"qwv

hqt"htguj"ckt0"ÈYgÇtg"kp"vjku"tqqo"ykvj"qpn{"qpg"ykpfqy."cpf"vjg{"jcxg

hkno"qxgt"vjg"ykpfqy."uq"yg"ecpÇv"ugg"qwvukfg0É

Vqfc{"oquv"qh"vjg"rgqrng"yjq"urqmg"vq"Vjg"Kpvgtegrv"ctg"pq"nqpigt"kp

vjg"jcnhyc{"jqwug0"Vjg"fktgevqt"jcu"tgvwtpgf"vq"yqtm."cpf"rgqrng"ctg

iqkpi"dcem"vq"yqtm"qp"vjg"qwvukfg�Ñ"cnvjqwij"pqv"cv"vjg"Vtkworj

rncpv0"Qvjgtykug."Èkv"fqgupÇv"uggo"nkmg"owej"jcu"ejcpigf"cu"hct"cu"vjgkt

uchgv{"ogcuwtgu"iq.É"qpg"tgukfgpv"uckf0

Vjg"rqrwncvkqp"ku"uvctvkpi"vq"iq"wr"cickp."vqq0"Qp"vjg"ogpÇu"ukfg"ncuv

yggm."qpg"tgukfgpv"uckf."uqog"45"pgy�rgqrng"ygtg"vtcpuhgttgf"vq"vjg

hceknkv{0"Cpf"vjgtg"ku"c"itqwr"qh"yqogp"rqkugf"vq"cttkxg"cu"ygnn0

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-5 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 13 of 13

Page 414: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

EXHIBIT 6

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 1 of 4

Page 415: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 2 of 4

Page 416: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

are a publicly traded REIT and the nation’s largest owner of partnership correctional, detention and residential reentry facilities. We also believe we arethe largest private owner of real estate used by U.S. government agencies. The Company has been a flexible and dependable partner for government

for more than 35 years. Our employees are driven by a deep sense of service, high standards of professionalism and a responsibility to helpgovernment better the public good. Learn more at http://www.corecivic.com/.

Forward-Looking Statements

This press release contains statements as to our beliefs and expectations of the outcome of future events that are "forward-looking" statements withinthe meaning of Section 21E of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended, and the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Theseforward-looking statements are subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ materially from the statements made. These

include, but are not limited to, the risks and uncertainties associated with: (i) whether we conclude that an alternative corporate structure or capitalreallocation is appropriate, can be cost effectively implemented, and in fact provides the expected benefits; (ii) the duration of the federal government'sdenial of entry at the United States southern border to asylum-seekers and anyone crossing the southern border without proper documentation or

authority in an effort to contain the spread of COVID-19; (iii) government and staff responses to staff or residents testing positive for COVID-19 withinpublic and private correctional, detention, and reentry facilities; (iv) the location and duration of shelter in place orders associated with COVID-19 thatdisrupt the criminal justice system, along with government policies or prosecutions and newly ordered legal restrictions that affect the number of

people placed in correctional, detention, and reentry facilities; (v) general economic and market conditions, including, but not limited to, the impactgovernmental budgets can have on our contract renewals and renegotiations, per diem rates, and occupancy; (vi) fluctuations in our operating resultsbecause of, among other things, changes in occupancy levels, competition, contract renegotiations or terminations, increases in costs of operations,

fluctuations in interest rates and risks of operations; (vii) our ability to obtain and maintain correctional, detention, and residential reentry facilitymanagement contracts because of reasons including, but not limited to, sufficient governmental appropriations, contract compliance, negativepublicity, and effects of inmate disturbances; (viii) changes in the privatization of the corrections and detention industry, the acceptance of our services,

the timing of the opening of new facilities and the commencement of new management contracts (including the extent and pace at which newcontracts are utilized), as well as our ability to utilize available beds; (ix) changes in government policy, legislation and regulations that affect utilizationof the private sector for corrections, detention, and residential reentry services, in general, or our business, in particular, including but not limited to, the

continued utilization of the South Texas Family Residential Center (STFRC) by ICE under terms of the current contract, and the impact of any changesto immigration reform and sentencing laws (Our company does not, under longstanding policy, lobby for or against policies or legislation that woulddetermine the basis for, or duration of, an individual's incarceration or detention.); (x) our ability to successfully identify and consummate future

acquisitions and our ability to successfully integrate the operations of completed acquisitions and realize projected returns resulting therefrom; (xi) ourability to meet and maintain qualification for taxation as a REIT; and (xii) the availability of debt and equity financing on terms that are favorable to us,or at all. Other factors that could cause operating and financial results to differ are described in the filings we make from time to time with the Securities

and Exchange Commission.

The Company takes no responsibility for updating the information contained in this press release following the date hereof to reflect events or

circumstances occurring after the date hereof or the occurrence of unanticipated events or for any changes or modifications made to this press releaseor the information contained herein by any third-parties, including, but not limited to, any wire or internet services.

CORECIVIC, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIESSUPPLEMENTAL FINANCIAL INFORMATION

(UNAUDITED AND AMOUNTS IN THOUSANDS)

CALCULATION OF FUNDS FROM OPERATIONS AND NORMALIZED FUNDS FROM OPERATIONS

For the Months Ended

April 30, 2020 May 31, 2020

Net income $ 10,192 $ 15,274

Depreciation and amortization of real estate assets 9,287 9,565

Gain on sale of real estate - (2,818 )

Funds From Operations $ 19,479 $ 22,021

Expenses associated with COVID-19 2,891 3,005

Normalized Funds From Operations $ 22,370 $ 25,026

NOTE TO SUPPLEMENTAL FINANCIAL INFORMATION

Funds From Operations (FFO) and Normalized FFO are non-GAAP financial measures. The Company believes that these measures are important

operating measures that supplement discussion and analysis of the Company's results of operations and are used to review and assess operatingperformance of the Company and its properties and their management teams. The Company believes that it is useful to provide investors, lenders andsecurity analysts disclosures of its results of operations on the same basis that is used by management. FFO, in particular, is a widely accepted

non-GAAP supplemental measure of REIT performance, grounded in the standards for FFO established by the National Association of Real EstateInvestment Trusts (NAREIT).

NAREIT defines FFO as net income computed in accordance with GAAP, excluding gains (or losses) from sales of property and extraordinary items,plus depreciation and amortization of real estate and impairment of depreciable real estate and after adjustments for unconsolidated partnerships andjoint ventures calculated to reflect funds from operations on the same basis. Normalized FFO is useful as supplemental measures of performance of

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 3 of 4

Page 417: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

the Company's properties because such measures do not take into account depreciation and amortization. Because the historical cost accountingconvention used for real estate assets requires depreciation (except on land), this accounting presentation assumes that the value of real estate

assets diminishes at a level rate over time. Because of the unique structure, design and use of the Company's properties, management believes thatassessing performance of the Company's properties without the impact of depreciation or amortization is useful. The Company may makeadjustments to FFO from time to time for certain other income and expenses that it considers non-recurring, infrequent or unusual, even though such

items may require cash settlement, because such items do not reflect a necessary or ordinary component of the ongoing operations of the Company. Start-up expenses represent the incremental operating losses incurred during the period we activate idle correctional facilities. Normalized FFOexcludes the effects of such items. The Company calculates Normalized FFO by adding to GAAP Net Income expenses associated with the

Company’s debt refinancing, M&A activity, start-up expenses, and certain impairments and other charges that the Company believes are unusual ornon-recurring to provide an alternative measure of comparing operating performance for the periods presented. Even though expenses associatedwith mergers and acquisitions may be recurring, the magnitude and timing fluctuate based on the timing and scope of M&A activity, and therefore,

such expenses, which are not a necessary component of the ongoing operations of the Company, may not be comparable from period to period.

Other companies may calculate FFO and Normalized FFO differently than the Company does, or adjust for other items, and therefore comparability

may be limited. FFO and Normalized FFO are not measures of performance under GAAP, and should not be considered as an alternative to cashflows from operating activities, a measure of liquidity or an alternative to net income as indicators of the Company's operating performance or anyother measure of performance derived in accordance with GAAP. This data should be read in conjunction with the Company's consolidated financial

statements and related notes included in its filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission.

Contact: Investors: Cameron Hopewell - Managing Director, Investor Relations - (615) 263-3024Media: Steve Owen, Managing Director, Communications - (615) 263-3107

Source: CoreCivic, Inc.

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-6 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 4 of 4

Page 418: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

EXHIBIT 7

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 1 of 3

Page 419: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 2 of 3

Page 420: DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF’S CLASS …...As the Supreme Court held in Tellabs, to survive dismissal a complaint must allege facts sufficient to make the inference

;35:36464 [l}$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt$Wxsgo$Jipp$54)$ex$xli$Stir$sr$Nyri$5;$�$Xli$Qsxpi}$Jssp

lxxtw>33{{{2jssp2gsq3mrziwxmrk3646434:35;3{l}1xli1kis1kvsyt1wxsgo1jipp1541ex1xli1stir1sr1nyr2ewt| 637

MQEKI$WSYVGI>$KIXX]$MQEKIW

Xli$gvy|$sj$xli$mwwyi$mw$xli$VIMX$wxvygxyvi0${lmgl$epps{w$gsqtermiw$xs$ezsmh

gsvtsvexi1pizip$xe|exmsr$fyx$viuymviw$xliq$xs$teww$ex$piewx$=4)$sj$xlimv$xe|efpi

mrgsqi$sr$xs$wlevilsphivw2$Epxlsykl$xlex$viqsziw$xli$mwwyi$sj$hsyfpi$xe|exmsr

erh$piehw$xs$pevki$te}syxw$jsv$mrziwxsvw$,{ls$qywx$xviex$xli$hmzmhirhw$ew$vikypev

mrgsqi$jsv$xe|$tyvtswiw-0$mx$pieziw$VIMXw$epqswx$xsxepp}$vipmerx$sr$xli$getmxep

qevoixw$xs$jyrh$xlimv$kvs{xl$mrziwxqirxw2$GsviGmzmg+w$wxsgo$lew$fiir

perkymwlmrk$ex$ps{$pizipw$erh$mxw$fsrh$tvmgiw$lezi$fiir${ieo0$xss0$ws$mxw$gswx$sj

getmxep$lew$fiir$vipexmzip}$lmkl2$Xlmw$i|tpemrw${l}$mx+w$gsrwmhivmrk$hvsttmrk$xli

VIMX$wxvygxyvi2Ä

Xli$KIS$Kvsyt$jegiw$wmqmpev$lieh{mrhw$sr$xli$getmxep$jvsrx0$ws$mx$qeoiw$wirwi

xlex$mrziwxsvw${syph$fi${svvmih$xlex$mx$xss$qe}$wywtirh$mxw$hmzmhirh$erh$wxevx

{imklmrk$epxivrexmzi$gsvtsvexi$wxvygxyviw2$Xlyw0$ew$mrziwxsvw$wsph$GsviGmzmg0$xli}

epws$wsph$wleviw$sj$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt2

Rs{${lexEpxlsykl$xlivi+w$rsxlmrk$ex$xlmw$tsmrx$xs$wykkiwx$xlex$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt${mpp

wywtirh$mxw$hmzmhirh$sv$epxiv$mxw$gsvtsvexi$wxvygxyvi0$wlmjxw$pmoi$xli$sri$GsviGmzmg

mw$gsrwmhivmrk$hs$sjxir$w{iit$xlvsykl$mrhywxv}$rmgliw2$Xli$tvsfpiq$mw$xlex0$yrxmp

Xli$KIS$Kvsyt$gsqqirxw$sr$mxw$mrxirxmsrw0$mrziwxsvw${mpp$lezi$rs$mrhmgexmsr

efsyx${lex$mxw$tperw$qmklx$fi2$Yrgivxemrx}$mw$mr$xli$emv$jsv$xli$xmqi$fimrk0$erh

xlex$mrgviewiw$vmwow$jsv$mrgsqi$mrziwxsvw${ls$gsyrx$sr$xli$hmzmhirhw$xlmw$VIMX

vikypevp}$xlvs{w$sjj2

54$wxsgow${i$pmoi$fixxiv$xler$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2[lir$mrziwxmrk$kirmywiw$Hezmh$erh$Xsq$Kevhriv$lezi$e$wxsgo$xmt0$mx$ger$te}$xs

pmwxir2$Ejxiv$epp0$xli$ri{wpixxiv$xli}$lezi$vyr$jsv$sziv$e$higehi0$Qsxpi}$Jssp$Wxsgo

Ehzmwsv0$lew$xvmtpih$xli$qevoix2.

Hezmh$erh$Xsq$nywx$viziepih${lex$xli}$fipmizi$evi$xli$xir$fiwx$wxsgow$jsv

mrziwxsvw$xs$fy}$vmklx$rs{Í$erh$Xli$KIS$Kvsyt0$Mrg2${ewr+x$sri$sj$xliq%$Xlex+w

vmklx$11$xli}$xlmro$xliwi$54$wxsgow$evi$izir$fixxiv$fy}w2

Case 9:20-cv-81063-RS Document 6-7 Entered on FLSD Docket 08/12/2020 Page 3 of 3