detroit' supermarket supply

47
ABSTRACT Over the past few decades the city of Detroit has not only been going through a serious loss in population and a deterioration of their economy, but they have also suffered in the ability to produce and distribute nutrition throughout the city. Once one of the world’s leaders in automobile design and production, the city had a numer- ous amount of automobile factories and workshops spread through- out the city that specialized highly in the quick and consistent pro- duction of cars. Detroit’s reign over the auto mobile lasted long but unfortunately not long enough as the economy started to suffer after the huge demand of imports from Japan and Germany creating vast competition in 1970. The population of Detroit that was at its peak in the mid-nineties. The city imports food produced at far distances and transported the entire way, causing inconvenience. Due to the overlly high percentage of fringe food locations that are growing, the availability of By exploring the different methods and options of producing as well as distributing food according to the comforts of the Detroit, major developments can be made in creating grand Pro- duction and Distribution centers. Not only will it benefit the economy and create more job opportunities for those in Detroit, it will become a solution to Detroit not being able to support itself as it is supported by its surrounding cities.

Upload: ankush-abbi

Post on 12-Mar-2016

217 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

DESCRIPTION

DETROIT's study of food deserts

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

LEAVE THIS PAGE BLANK

ABSTRACT

Over the past few decades the city of Detroit has not only been going through a serious loss in population and a deterioration of their economy, but they have also suffered in the ability to produce and distribute nutrition throughout the city. Once one of the world’s leaders in automobile design and production, the city had a numer-ous amount of automobile factories and workshops spread through-out the city that specialized highly in the quick and consistent pro-duction of cars. Detroit’s reign over the auto mobile lasted long but unfortunately not long enough as the economy started to suffer after the huge demand of imports from Japan and Germany creating vast competition in 1970. The population of Detroit that was at its peak in the mid-nineties. The city imports food produced at far distances and transported the entire way, causing inconvenience. Due to the overlly high percentage of fringe food locations that are growing, the availability of By exploring the different methods and options of producing as well as distributing food according to the comforts of the Detroit, major developments can be made in creating grand Pro-duction and Distribution centers. Not only will it benefit the economy and create more job opportunities for those in Detroit, it will become a solution to Detroit not being able to support itself as it is supported by its surrounding cities.

Page 2: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

POPULATION DECREASE: ABSOLUTE CHANGE1900 - 1910

• Migra on from farms to ci es • Immig rants from eastern europe to Detroit

Region: 582,236 - 761,481Detroit: 285,704 - 465,766Michigan: 2,420,982 - 2,810,173US: 76,212,168 - 92,228,496

1910 - 1920

• Woodward corridor booms from auto factories

Region: 761,481 - 1,467,964Detroit: 465,766 - 993,678 Michigan: 2,810,173 - 3,668,412 US: 92,228,496 - 106,021,537

1920 - 1930

• Con nued rapid growth • Detroit has largest streetcar system

Region: 1,467,964 - 2,382,195 Detroit: 993,678 - 1,568,662Michigan: 3,668,412 - 4,842,325US: 106,021,537 - 123,202,624

Popula on Decline Popula on Growth No DataNo Popula on Change

Page 3: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

1930 - 1940

• Detroit at a turning point • Growth slowed down

Region: 2,382,195 - 2,613,844 Detroit: 1,568,662 - 1,623,452Michigan: 4,842,325 - 5,256,106 US: 123,202,624 - 132,164,569

1940 - 1950

• WWII war- me growth

Region: 2,613,844 - 3,344,793 Detroit: 1,623,452 - 1,849,568 Michigan: 5,256,106 - 6,371,766US: 132,164,569 - 151,325,798

1940 - 1950

• Start of Detroit decline • Start of Suburban ascendancy • Construc on of highway systems • Dismantling of streetcar systems Region: 3,344,793 - 4,181,354 Detroit: 1,849,568 - 1,670,144Michigan: 6,371,766 - 7,823,194US: 151,325,798 - 179,323,175

No Data

Page 4: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

HighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandParkParkParkParkParkParkParkParkPark

HamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramck

Belle Isle

Detroit River

TelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraph

96

1039

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

75

39

96

10

9694

75nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM

75

75

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

573

10

75

eky

Dna

Vek

yD

naV

eky

Dna

Vek

yD

naV

eky

Dna

Vek

yD

naV

eky

Dna

Vek

yD

naV

eky

Dna

V

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

75

94

94

Persons Per Square Mile40,000 to 56,363 (3)30,000 to 39,999 (11)20,000 to 29,999 (88)10,000 to 19,999 (210)5,000 to 9,999 (93)

8 to 4,999 (30)Population Density

1960 Census TractsSource: US Census Bureau, 1960

Detroit, Michigan

CULMA/Center for Urban Studies/jcb 2001 Wayne State University

4

HighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandParkParkParkParkParkParkParkParkPark

HamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramck

Belle Isle

Detroit River

TelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraph

96

1039

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

75

39

96

10

9694

75nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM

75

75

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

573

10

75

eky

Dna

Vek

yD

naV

eky

Dna

Vek

yD

naV

eky

Dna

Vek

yD

naV

eky

Dna

Vek

yD

naV

eky

Dna

V

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

75

94

94

Persons Per Square Mile40,000 to 67,068 (16)30,000 to 39,999 (35)20,000 to 29,999 (102)10,000 to 19,999 (137)5,000 to 9,999 (58)

8 to 4,999 (21)

Population Density,1950 Census Tracts

Source: US Census Bureau, 1950 Detroit, Michigan

CULMA/Center for Urban Studies/jcb 2001 Wayne State University

DETROIT: DENSITY 1950 - 2000

Page 5: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

5

HighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandParkParkParkParkParkParkParkParkPark

HamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramck

Belle Isle

Detroit River

TelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraph

96

1039

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

75

39

96

10

9694

75nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM

75

75

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

573

10

75

eky

Dna

Vek

yD

naV

eky

Dna

Vek

yD

naV

eky

Dna

Vek

yD

naV

eky

Dna

Vek

yD

naV

eky

Dna

V

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

75

94

94

Persons Per Square Mile30,000 to 39,641 (7)20,000 to 29,999 (52)10,000 to 19,999 (212)5,000 to 9,999 (108)

402 to 4,999 (42) Population Density1970 Census TractsSource: US Census Bureau, 1970

Detroit, Michigan

HighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandParkParkParkParkParkParkParkParkPark

HamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramck

Belle Isle

Detroit River

TelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraph

96

1039

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

75

39

96

10

9694

75nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM

75

75

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

573

10

75

eky

Dna

Vek

yD

naV

eky

Dna

Vek

yD

naV

eky

Dna

Vek

yD

naV

eky

Dna

Vek

yD

naV

eky

Dna

V

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

75

94

94

Persons Per Square Mile32,719 (1)20,000 to 24,488 (4)10,000 to 19,999 (153)5,000 to 9,999 (142)

31 to 4,999 (43)No Population (1)

Population Density1980 Census TractsSource: US Census Bureau, 1980

Detroit, Michigan

CULMA/Center for Urban Studies/jcb 2001 Wayne State University

0

Page 6: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

DETROIT: DENSITY 1970

6

HighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandParkParkParkParkParkParkParkParkPark

HamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramck

Belle Isle

Detroit River

hhT

lh

Tl

hT

lhh

96

1039

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

75

39

96

10

9694

75nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM

75

75

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

573

10

75

eky

Dna

Vek

yD

naV

eky

Dna

Vek

yD

naV

eky

Dna

Vek

yD

naV

eky

Dna

Vek

yD

naV

eky

Dna

V

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

75

94

94

Persons Per Square Mile10,000 to 16,927 (92)5,000 to 9,999 (168)

115 to 4,999 (60)No Population (1) Population Density

1990 Census TractsSource: US Census Bureau, 1990

Detroit, Michigan

CULMA/Center for Urban Studies/jcbayne State University

HighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandHighlandParkParkParkParkParkParkParkParkPark

HamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramckHamtramck

Belle Isle

Detroit River

TelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraphTelegraph

96

1039

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

Grand River

75

39

96

10

9694

75nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM nagihciM

75

75

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

Woodward

573

10

75

eky

Dna

Vek

yD

naV

eky

Dna

Vek

yD

naV

eky

Dna

Vek

yD

naV

eky

Dna

Vek

yD

naV

eky

Dna

V

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

Grat

iot

75

94

94

Persons Per Square Mile10,000 to 17,115 (73)5,000 to 9,999 (176)

7 to 4,999 (64)No Population (1) Population Density

2000 Census TractsSource: US Census Bureau, 2000

Detroit, Michigan

CULMA/Center for Urban Studies/jcb 2001 Wayne State University

Page 7: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

7

Page 8: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

19001903

11930

1960

1990

Auto Industry Dies = Population Decrease = Businesses Die

Ford Moto

F

Page 9: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

3

1941

1950

1955

1967

1980 - 1990

2000

Population

1910: 465,766

1930: 1,568,662

1950: 1,849,568

2000: 886,000

Motors Founded

Ford Contracts Major Auto Firms

Fifth Largest City in the US

Economic Peak

Competition Arises: Imports

Dodge Main Plant workers: 30,000 to few thousand

Chrysler: 130,000 - 50,000

Page 10: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

DETROIT: FOOD DESERTS“Roughly 550,000 Detroit residents - over half the city’s total population - live in areas that are far out - of - balance in terms of day - to day food availibility”

Page 11: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

on od

Page 12: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

DETROIT: FRINGE VS MAINSTREAM

“In correlating food access to diet - related health outcomes, a more important measure is food balance, which tells us how easy or difficult is to choose between a mainstream and fringe food location on a daily basis”

“The greatest contributor to the heavy concentration of fringe food op-tions and to the negative diet - related health effects of food imbalance is not fast food, but USDA Food Stamp retailers.”

“c

Page 13: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

M

lt y

p-ce

“Unless access to healthy food greatly improves, residents will continue to have greater rates of premature illness and death.”

Page 14: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

ASHO ASHO

PS

PRODUCTIONPHASE

OUTSOURCED

PARENTCOMPANIES

ORDERPROCESSING

PHASE

ORDERDELIVERY

PHASE

ORDERFULLFILLMENT

SUPPLY NETWORK: SCHOOL CAFETERIA

TYPICAL DETROITSUPERMARKET

NETWORK

THE ENTIRE LINK DURING THE ORDER PROCESSING PHASE IS OUTSOURCED. NO PROFIT FOR DETROIT.

TYPICAL DETROITCAFETERIA SUPPLY NETWORK

DETROIT’S SCHOOL CAFETERIAS ARE DISTRIBUTED THEIR FOOD AFTER GOING THROUGH PROCESSES WITH THE AMERICAN SCHOOL HEALTH ORGANIZATION, THE MISSING LINK COMES THEN THE DISTRIBUTION COMES INTO PLAY AND IS ALSO OUTSOURCED.

DETROIT: CAFETERIA

Page 15: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

D

“Roughly 550,000 Detroit residents - over half the city’s total popula on - live in areas that are far out - of - balance in terms of day - to day food availibility”

- MARI GALLAGHER RESEARCH AND CONSULTING GROUP

Page 16: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

ASHO

LIVINGSTON, MI

WASHTENA,

Page 17: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

PS

PS

TOTAL: 91 Miles

OAKLAND, MI

OAKLAND, MIMACOMB, MI

DETROIT, MI

DETROIT, MI

TENA, MI

Page 18: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

TYPICAL DETROIT SUPERMARKET NETWORK

THE ENTIRE LINK DURING THE ORDER PROCESSING PHASE IS OUTSOURCED. NO PROFIT FOR DETROIT. LESS SUPERMARKETS ARE PRESENT AND MAINSTREAM SUPPLY OF FOOD IS LACKING. THE NETWORK SHOWS THE SEVERAL STAGES OF OUTSOURCING DETROIT GOES THROUGH.

DETROIT: SUPERMARKET

PRODUCTIONPHASE

OUTSOURCED

PARENTCOMPANIES

ORDERPROCESSING

PHASE

ORDERDELIVERY

PHASE

ORDERFULLFILLMENT

SUPPLY NETWORK:

SUPERMARKETS

TYPICAL DETROITSUPERMARKET

NETWORK

THE ENTIRE LINK DURING THE ORDER PROCESSING PHASE IS OUTSOURCED. NO PROFIT FOR DETROIT.

Page 19: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

D “56% of USDA food stamp ‘convenience stores’ were recoded into party stores, liquor stores, dollar stores, bakeries, and other venues”. - MARI GALLAGHER RESEARCH AND CONSULTING GROUP

Page 20: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

OAKLAND, MI

LIVINGSTON, MI

WASHTENA, MI

Page 21: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

TOTAL: 179 Miles

OAKLAND, MI

DETROIT, MI

DETROIT, MI

Page 22: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

TYPICAL DETROIT ORGANIC RESTAURANT NETWORK

ORGANIC RESTAURANTS GO THROUGH A PROCESS WHERE ALL PHASES LEAD TO THE ENTIRE STOCK BEING DELIVERED TO THE RESTAURANT. HOWEVER THE LOCATION OF THE ORGANIC FARM AND DISTRIBUTION CENTER ARE HIGHLY CRITICAL.

PRODUCTIONPHASE

OUTSOURCED

PARENTCOMPANIES

ORDERPROCESSING

PHASE

ORDERDELIVERY

PHASE

ORDERFULLFILLMENT

SUPPLY NETWORK:

ORGANIC RESTAURANT

TYPICAL DETROITORGANIC REST

NETWORK

THE ENTIRE LINK DURING THE ORDER PROCESSING PHASE IS OUTSOURCED. NO PROFIT FOR DETROIT.

DETROIT: ORGANIC REST.

Page 23: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

D “In correla ng food access to diet - related health outcomes, a more important measure is food balance, which tells us how easy or diffi cult is to choose between a mainstream and fringe food loca on on a daily basis”

- MARI GALLAGHER RESEARCH AND CONSULTING GROUP

Page 24: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

OAKLAND, MI

WASHTENA, MI

MONROE, MI

MONROE, MI

Page 25: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

TOTAL: 143 Miles

DETROIT, MI

DETROIT, MI

MI

Page 26: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

TYPICAL DETROIT VENDOR NETWORK

DETROIT OUTSOURCES FOR ALMOST MOST PRODUCTS, HARDLY ANY OF THEM ARE PRODUCED THERE. ORGANIC RESTAU-RANTS TEND TO IMPORT FOOD FROM GREAT DISTANCES FORCING INCONVENIENCE AND LESS CHOICE OF MAINSTREAM FOOD.

PRODUCTIONPHASE

OUTSOURCED

PARENTCOMPANIES

ORDERPROCESSING

PHASE

ORDERDELIVERY

PHASE

ORDERFULLFILLMENT

SUPPLY NETWORK: VENDORS

TYPICAL DETROIT VENDOR

NETWORK

THE ENTIRE LINK DURING THE ORDER PROCESSING PHASE IS OUTSOURCED. NO PROFIT FOR DETROIT.

DETROIT: VENDORS

“iha

Page 27: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

ED “Unless access to healthy food greatly improves, residents will con nue to have greater rates of premature illness and death.”

- MARI GALLAGHER RESEARCH AND CONSULTING GROUP

Page 28: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

OAKLAND, MI

OAKLAND

WASHTENA, MI

MONROE, MI

Page 29: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

TOTAL: 154 Miles

KLAND, MI OAKLAND, MI

DETROIT, MI

Page 30: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

DETROIT: Interferance

Page 31: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY
Page 32: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

DISTRIBUTION CENTER SUPERMARKET

DELIVERYCENTER

STORAGECENTER

AVERAGE SQ Ft: 500,000 AVERAGE SQ Ft: 64,000

AVERAGE SQ Ft: 20,000 AVERAGE SQ Ft: 20,000

Page 33: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

ORDERFULFILL.

ORDERPLACEM.

PACKAGEHANDLING

ORGANICFARM

AVERAGE SQ Ft: 10,000 AVERAGE SQ Ft: 8,000

AVERAGE SQ Ft: 15,000 AVERAGE SQ Ft: 15,000

Page 34: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

CROSSDOCK

BULKBREAK

ASHO

ORG.REST.

AVERAGE SQ Ft: 10,000

AVERAGE SQ Ft: 10,000 AVERAGE SQ Ft: 10,000

AVERAGE SQ Ft: 4,000

Page 35: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

SCHOOlCAFE

VENDOR

AVERAGE SQ Ft: 5,000 AVERAGE SQ Ft: 100

Page 36: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

CROSSDOCK

BULKBREAK

DISTRIBUTIONCENTER

PACKAGEHANDLING

ORDERFULLFIL

DELIVERYCENTER

SUPERMARKET TOTAL: 565,000 sf. SCHOOL CAFES TOTAL: 540,000 sf.

CROSSDOCK

ASHO

DISTRIBUTIONCENTER

PACKAGEHANDLING

ORDERFULLFIL

DELIVERYCENTER

CROSSDOCK

ORDERPLACE

DISTRIBUTIONCENTER

STORAGE

ORDERFULLFIL

DELIVERYCENTER

Page 37: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY
Page 38: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

DESIGN VIA IMAGEDESIGN OPTIONS: STACK TOWER

Page 39: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY
Page 40: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

=DESIGN VIA IMAGEDESIGN OPTIONS: URBAN CENTER

Page 41: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

+ + +=

Page 42: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

=DESIGN VIA IMAGEDESIGN OPTIONS: REDEVELOP HOUSING

Page 43: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

+ + +=

Page 44: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

=DESIGN VIA IMAGEDESIGN OPTIONS: Farm & Distribute Strips

Page 45: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

+ + +=

Page 46: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

=DESIGN VIA IMAGEDESIGN OPTIONS: COMMERCIAL STRIPS

Page 47: DETROIT' SUPERMARKET SUPPLY

+ + += ASHO