deutsches zeitungsmuseum iadm conference 2009 (printing) museums, do they have to be boring? a short...
TRANSCRIPT
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
(Printing) museums,
do they have to be boring?
A short overview
Dr. Roger Münch
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09Introduction
1. Time tunnel
2. Status Quo
3. Quo vadis?
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
Published in 1986 byPetra Schuck-Wersig and Gernot Wersig † (Member of the Advisory Board DZM)
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Sünden wider das Objekt
Isolation
Entfremdung
Beziehungsverrat
Kasernierung
Totschlag
Die Sünden der Ausstellungsmacher
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
2. Sünden wider den Wissenshunger
Unterernährung
Skorbut
Diät
Placebos
Überfütterung
Die Sünden der Ausstellungsmacher
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
3. Sünden wider die Hilfsbedürftigkeit
Unterlassene Hilfeleistung
Fahrlässige Desorientierung
Anwendung physischen Zwangs
Ideologische Penetranz
Die Sünden der Ausstellungsmacher
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
4. Sünden wider das Aufenthaltsrecht
Vorsätzlicher Ausschluß
Soziale Abweisung
Vorsätzliche Ermüdung
Kontaktsperre
Die Sünden der Ausstellungsmacher
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
5. Sünden wider den Stand der Technik
Altertümlichkeit
Material-Einfallslosigkeit
Medien-Abstinenz
Medienfimmel
Die Sünden der Ausstellungsmacher
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
6. Sünden wider den Kulturauftrag
Arroganz
Elitäre Orientierung
Sammelfetischismus
Die Sünden der Ausstellungsmacher
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
7. Sünden wider die Umwelt
Grenzziehungen
Aura-Impertinenz
Aktualitätsverzicht
Umwelt-Abstinenz
Die Sünden der Ausstellungsmacher
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
8. Sünden wider das Nachher
Kleine Nachsorge
Katalogisierung
Blähsucht
Konzeptionslosigkeit
Die Sünden der Ausstellungsmacher
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
9. Sünden wider den gesunden Menschverstand
Faszinationsverzicht
Dekorationismus
Ordnungssucht
Die Sünden der Ausstellungsmacher
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
10. Sünden wider das Kommunikationsprinzip
Einfallslosigkeit
Selbstsucht
Besucherverachtung
Die Sünden der Ausstellungsmacher
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
(Printing) museums =
printing museums and
museums in general.
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
Our Definition:
A traditional printing museum presents
exhibits concerning
Printing Technology (presses, equipment)
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
Our Definition:
A traditional printing museum presents
exhibits concerning
Printing Technology (presses, equipment)
and/or
Print Media (Books, Newspapers, Magazines).
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
Our Definition:
A traditional printing museum presents
exhibits concerning
Printing Technology (presses, equipment)
and/or
Print Media (Books, Newspapers, Magazines).
They can be a standalone museum
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
Our Definition:
A traditional printing museum presents
exhibits concerning
Printing Technology (presses, equipment)
and/or
Print Media (Books, Newspapers, Magazines).
They can be a standalone museum
or
it‘s a Department of a technical museum
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09Introduction
1. Time tunnel
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1877AntwerpenMusée Plantin Moretus
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1877AntwerpenMusée Plantin Moretus
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1884 LeipzigDeutsches Buchgewerbemuseum
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1884 LeipzigDeutsches Buchgewerbemuseum
1950Deutsches Buch- und
SchriftmuseumGerman Book and Writing Museum
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1950Deutsches Buch- und
SchriftmuseumGerman Book and Writing Museum
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1900MainzGutenberg Museum
1927 Römischer Kaiser
1962New Building
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1900MainzGutenberg Museum
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1900MainzGutenberg Museum
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1900MainzGutenberg Museum
2000Grand Reopening
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1900BernSchweizerische Gutenberg Stube
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1900 - 2000FribourgSchweizerisches Gutenberg
MuseumSwiss Museum of graphic industryand communication
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1900MünchenDeutsches MuseumGerman Museum of Masterpieces
of Science and Technology
1927
2008
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1900MünchenDeutsches Museum
1995
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1900MünchenDeutsches Museum
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1909WienTechnisches Museum
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1877Musée Plantin Moretus
1884Deutsches Buch- und Schriftmuseum
1900Gutenberg MuseumDeutsches MuseumSchweizerisches Gutenberg Museum
1909Technisches Museum Wien
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
How did they look like?
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
Laurens Janszoon Coster
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
The Gutenberg Bible comes home Mainz 1978
B-42
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
Reconstruction
Original
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1877 - 1980Oldtimers
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1877 - 1980Oldtimers
1980 - 2009Youngtimers
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1980BaselBasler Papiermühle, Schweizerisches Papiermuseum & Museum für Schrift und DruckBasel Paper Mill, the Swiss Museum for Paper, Writing and Printing
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1980BaselBasler Papiermühle
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1980BaselBasler Papiermühle
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1981Odense Danmarks Grafiske Museum
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1981Odense Danmarks Grafiske Museum
1989Danmarks Grafiske/Press Museum
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1981Odense Danmarks Grafiske Museum
1989Danmarks Grafiske/Press Museum
2000Danmarks Mediemuseum
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
2000Danmarks Mediemuseum
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1981MannheimLandesmuseum für Technik und ArbeitState Museum for Technology and Work
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1981MannheimLandesmuseum für Technik und Arbeit
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1981MannheimLandesmuseum für Technik und Arbeit
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1982BerlinMuseum für Technik und VerkehrSince 1997Deutsches Technikmuseum
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1997BerlinDeutsches Technikmuseum
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1993DortmundDeutsches ArbeitsschutzausstellungGerman Occupational Safety and Health Exhibition
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1993DortmundDeutsches Arbeitsschutzausstellung
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1995 LeipzigWerkstätten und Museum für DruckkunstWorkshops and Museum of the Printing Arts
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1995 LeipzigWerkstätten und Museum für Druckkunst
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1997 (first ideas in 1979/80)HamburgMuseum der Arbeit
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
1997 HamburgMuseum der Arbeit
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
2001Nederlands Steendrukmuseum ValkenswaardDutch Museum of Lithography in Valkenswaard
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
2001Nederlands Steendrukmuseum Valkenswaard
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
1. Time Tunnel
2001Nederlands Steendrukmuseum Valkenswaard
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09Introduction
1. Time tunnel
2. Status Quo
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
092. Status Quo
1877 – 1980 OldtimersBased and influenced by:
Homage to Gutenberg
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
092. Status Quo
1877 – 1980 OldtimersBased and influenced by:
Homage to Gutenberg
Schwarze Kunst
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
092. Status Quo
1877 – 1980 OldtimersBased and influenced by:
Homage to Gutenberg
Schwarze Kunst
Masterpieces of Science and Technology
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
092. Status Quo
1877 – 1980 OldtimersBased and influenced by:
Homage to Gutenberg
Schwarze Kunst
Masterpieces of Science and Technology
Masterpieces of Book Art
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
092. Status Quo
1877 – 1980 OldtimersBased and influenced by:
Homage to Gutenberg
Schwarze Kunst
Masterpieces of Science and Technology
Masterpieces of Book Art
Showcases and Do not touch-warning labels
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
092. Status Quo
1877 – 1980 OldtimersBased and influenced by:
Homage to Gutenberg
Schwarze Kunst
Masterpieces of Science and Technology
Masterpieces of Book Art
Showcases and Do not touch-warning labels
Reconstructions of working spaces
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
092. Status Quo
1980 – 2009 YoungtimersBased and influenced by:
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
092. Status Quo
1980 – 2009 YoungtimersBased and influenced by:
Working Museum
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
092. Status Quo
1980 – 2009 YoungtimersBased and influenced by:
Working Museum
Technology and Work
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
092. Status Quo
1980 – 2009 YoungtimersBased and influenced by:
Working Museum
Technology and Work
History from below - Geschichte von unten
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
092. Status Quo
1980 – 2009 YoungtimersBased and influenced by:
Working Museum
Technology and Work
History from below - Geschichte von unten
Workshops and Museum
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
092. Status Quo
1980 – 2009 YoungtimersBased and influenced by:
Working Museum
Technology and Work
History from below - Geschichte von unten
Workshops and Museum
Hands-on and Minds-on
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
092. Status Quo
1980 – 2009 YoungtimersBased and influenced by:
Working Museum
Technology and Work
History from below - Geschichte von unten
Workshops and Museum
Hands-on and Minds-on
Mensch-Arbeit-Technik
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
092. Status Quo
1980 – 2009 YoungtimersBased and influenced by:
Working Museum
Technology and Work
History from below - Geschichte von unten
Workshops and Museum
Hands-on and Minds-on
Mensch-Arbeit-Technik
Scenography
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
092. Status Quo
1980 – 2009 YoungtimersBased and influenced by:
Working Museum
Technology and Work
History from below - Geschichte von unten
Workshops and Museum
Hands-on and Minds-on
Mensch-Arbeit-Technik
Scenography
Multimedia
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
092. Status Quo
Situation 2009
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
092. Status Quo
Situation 2009
Oldtimers and Youngtimers were updated in the last 20 years
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
092. Status Quo
Situation 2009
Oldtimers and Youngtimers were updated in the last 20 years
The Europe Guide Schwarze Kunst, New edition 2009,counts over 170 Museums in 16 countries
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
092. Status Quo
Situation 2009
Oldtimers and Youngtimers were updated in the last 20 years
The Europe Guide Schwarze Kunst, New edition 2009,counts over 170 Museums in 16 countries
How does the structure of this community look like?
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
092. Status Quo
How does the structure of this community look like?
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
092. Status Quo
How does the structure of this community look like?
Studien und Essays zur Druckgeschichte,Published in 1997
Gegenständliche Quellen zur Druckgeschichte by Roger Münch
An attempt to categorize the EuropeanPrinting museums
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
092. Status Quo
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
092. Status Quo
The DASA places peoples' physical, mental,
social and cultural interests at the centre of
attention, not the artefacts or exhibits.
?
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
092. Status Quo
The DASA places peoples' physical, mental,
social and cultural interests at the centre of
attention, not the artefacts or exhibits.
The specific link between traditional museum
design and modern educational didactic,
distinguishes the DASA from other museums. It
cannot be compared to a museum of technology
or a science centre.
?
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
092. Status Quo
The DASA places peoples' physical, mental,
social and cultural interests at the centre of
attention, not the artefacts or exhibits.
The specific link between traditional museum
design and modern educational didactic,
distinguishes the DASA from other museums. It
cannot be compared to a museum of technology
or a science centre.
The DASA will never be completed.
?
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
092. Status Quo
Andreas Heller: With all one‘s senses, or the visitor as an „exhibit“.
Lecture in January 2009, DASA-KollquiumSzenografie in Ausstellungen und Museen
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
092. Status Quo
„Perhaps the future will be shaped by large „contextual museums“ (Zusammenhangsmuseen), whose designers will be faced with entirely new challenges.“
Andreas Heller
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09Introduction
1. Time tunnel
2. Status Quo
3. Quo vadis?
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
093. Quo vadis?
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
3. Quo vadis?
Challenges and Questions:
3. Quo vadis?
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
3. Quo vadis?
Challenges and Questions:
3. Quo vadis?
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
3. Quo vadis?
Challenges and Questions:
3. Quo vadis?
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
3. Quo vadis?
Challenges and Questions:
3. Quo vadis?
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
3. Quo vadis?
Challenges and Questions:
3. Quo vadis?
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
3. Quo vadis?
Challenges and Questions:
3. Quo vadis?
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
3. Quo vadis?
Challenges and Questions:
3. Quo vadis?
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
3. Quo vadis?
Challenges and Questions:
3. Quo vadis?
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
3. Quo vadis?
Challenges and Questions:
3. Quo vadis?
Deu
tsch
es
Zeit
un
gsm
useu
m
IAD
M C
on
fere
nce
20
09
I
Thank you very much for your attention