Developing Effective Use Developing Effective Use of the Blackboard and of the Blackboard and

Student Note Taking Skills Student Note Taking Skills Through Lesson StudyThrough Lesson Study

Developing Effective Use Developing Effective Use of the Blackboard and of the Blackboard and

Student Note Taking Skills Student Note Taking Skills Through Lesson StudyThrough Lesson Study

Makoto Yoshida, Global Education ResourcesMakoto Yoshida, Global Education Resources

Percentage of Use of Chalkboard and Overhead Projector in Classrooms

93100

67

24

6

58

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

Germany Japan United States

Chalkboard

Overhead

Source: U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics. Third International Mathematics and Science Study, Videotape Classroom Study, 1994-95.

Percentage of Tasks, Situations, and PPDs (Principles/properties/definitions) Written on the Chalkboard that were

Erased or Remained on the Chalkboard at the End of the Lesson

39.1

17.1

51.9

60.9

82.9

48.1

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

Germany Japan United States

Erased

Remained

Source: U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics. Third International Mathematics and Science Study, Videotape Classroom Study, 1994-95.

Typical Use of OHP and Blackboard in US classrooms

• To focus students’ attention

• To display information in written or graphic form

Source: Stigler & Hiebert (1999) The Teaching Gap

Typical Use of OHP and Blackboard in Japanese

Classrooms

• Provide a record of the problems, solution methods, and principles that are discussed during the lesson

Source: Stigler & Hiebert (1999) The Teaching Gap

• Japanese teachers rarely erase what they write on the blackboard. Everything they choose to record has a meaning and purpose, as it has been carefully planned in advance.

Source: Yoshida (1999) Lesson Study: A Case Study of A Japanese Approach to Improving Instruction Through School-Based Teacher Development

One Japanese teacher described the importance Japanese teachers place on using the blackboard:

“My senior teachers told me ‘you should not erase what you write if you write on the blackboard and you should not write on the board if you are going to erase it.’”

Source: Yoshida (1999) Lesson Study: A Case Study of A Japanese Approach to Improving Instruction Through School-Based Teacher Development

Another Japanese teacher described it like this:

“I try to organize the blackboard in such a way that my students and I can see and understand how the lesson progressed and what was talked about during the lesson and at the end of the lesson.”

Source: Yoshida (1999) Lesson Study: A Case Study of A Japanese Approach to Improving Instruction Through School-Based Teacher Development

Lesson Coherence

The connectedness or relatedness of the mathematics across the lesson•Well-Formed Stories:

– A sequence of events that fit together to reach the final conclusion.

– Easier to comprehend

•Lesson Coherence:– Helps students make sense of what is going on

Source: Stigler & Hiebert (1999) The Teaching Gap

Typical Lessons: Japan and U.S.

American Lesson

• Teacher poses rich problem

• Students struggle with problem on their own

• Students present their ideas and discuss them

• Teacher concludes lesson

• Teacher instructs students about concept or skill and demonstrates how to solve example problems

• Students practice on their own while teacher helps individuals

Japanese Lesson

The Four-Part Organization of Chinese Poetry

起承転結 (Ki-sho-ten-ketsu)

The course of an Event:• Introduction• Development • Turn• Conclusion

Lesson Process in a Japanese Lesson Plan

1. Introduction to the Problem

2. Understanding the Problem and Solving the Problem

3. Development• Presenting Solutions• Comparing and Discussing

4. Conclusion/Summary

5. Extension (Optional)

Using the Blackboard to Tell the Well-formed Story

• The blackboard is often used to show the flow of the lesson process described in the lesson plan

• The blackboard is also a tool used to connect parts of the lesson coherently together in order to build student understanding

Use or Organization of Blackboard

板書 (Bansho) (Board-Writing)

• A technical term created by Japanese teachers

• Considered an important teaching skill• Considered one of the necessary tools for

child-centered discovery-oriented lessons

Lesson Study and Organization of Blackboard

• Organization of blackboard is often discussed during Lesson Study as a part of planning lessons

• Some groups of teachers actually done Lesson Study on effective use of blackboard, OHP, and other medias

• There are some books available on effective use of blackboard which are developed through Lesson Study

How Do Japanese Teachers Use the Blackboard?

1. Keep a Record of the Lesson• Problem• Questions• Student voices, opinion, things noticed• Student solutions• Student discussions• Important mathematical ideas

2. Help Students Remember What They Need to Do and Think• Problem• Directions• Tasks• Questions

3. Help students see the connections of different parts of lesson and the progression of the lesson• Summary of the entire lesson• Coherent flow of the lesson (how we reached the

conclusion)• How student ideas were discussed and evolved in

order to reach the conclusion

4. A Place to Contrast and Discuss ideas students presented (Collective Think-Pad #1)• Recording various ideas• Discussing similarities and differences in ideas• Discussing merits of certain methods• Discovering/developing new ideas and questions

5. A Place to help organize student thinking and discover new ideas (Collective Think-Pad #2)• Manipulating (sorting, lining up, categorizing,

moving directions, etc.) objects on the board and thinking about or discovering mathematical ideas.

6. Fostering students’ organized note-taking skills by modeling good organization

Planning Organization of the Blackboard

板書計画 (Bansho-keikaku) (Board-Writing-Planning)

• Logical and coherent organization• Easy to understand the connections• Clear goal and task• Incorporate student ideas and strategies to build

understanding

A Blackboard Plan

Blackboard from Actual Lesson

A Blackboard Plan

How Japanese Teachers Learn to be Better at Organizing the

Board?• Observing other teachers’ lessons

– Stealing good ideas– Try out what is learned and evaluate

• Participating in Lesson Study• Continuously thinking about making

connections and building up to the lesson conclusion during the lesson.

Source: Yoshida (1999) Lesson Study: A Case Study of A Japanese Approach to Improving Instruction Through School-Based Teacher Development

Progression of Blackboard

Influence of Organization of Blackboard on Student

Organization of Note Taking

5th Grade Lesson:Multiplication of Decimal

Numbers