development of electronic microarray for simultaneous detection and typing of avian influenza and...
TRANSCRIPT
Development of Electronic Microarray for
Simultaneous Detection and Typing of
Avian Influenza and Newcastle Disease
Viruses
Samuel Ohene-Adjei
Canadian Food Inspection Agency. Lethbridge AB
CAHLN 2010
Avian Influenza
Highly infectious
High mortality and morbidity rates
Transmission - close contact
Incubation period – within a few days
Economically devastating
16 HA and 9 NA subtypes
Outbreaks of HPAIV
1983 Pennsylvania H5N2 17 million birds mostly chicken and
turkeys
2003 Netherlands H7N7 Virus isolated in 241 farms
30 million birds were culled
2004 Canada H7N3 40 Commercial farms
19 million culled (Fraser Valley, BC)
Newcastle Disease virus
2000- Mexico - Chicken
2002-2003USA (S. California, Nevada, Arizona, Texas)- Game fowl
2002 California (USA) – Transmission to commercial farms
3.5 million birds depopulated
9 Serotypes but 1 serotype associated with defined disease
Remains infectious
in bone marrow and muscle 6 months at -20ºC
in infected egg for over 1 year at 4ºC
Highly contagious – incubation period 4-6 days
Economically devastating (HP)
Objectives•To simultaneously detect AIV and NDV
•To discriminate between high and low pathogenic NDV
Diagnosis
Confirmatory lab diagnosis needed
Complications in veterinary diagnosis:
AIV and NDV may present same clinical symptoms
Possibility of mixed infection of AIV and NDV
SAMPLE
PCR #1
- AIV-Matrix (M)
- NDV-Matrix (M)
- NDV-Fusion (F)
NC #1
- AIV and NDV detection
- NDV pathotyping
PCR #2AIV-HA
PCR #3AIV-NA
NC #2AIV-HA
subtyping
NC #3AIV-NA
subtyping
Overview of assay development
Specificity ExperimentsMultiplex RT-PCRMicroarray 42 AIV lab strains22 NDV strains
NE
G
AIV
2
AIV
3
AIV
4
AIV
5
AIV
6
AIV
7
AIV
8
AIV
9
AIV
10
AIV
11
AIV
12
AIV
13
AIV
14
AIV
15
AIV
16
AIV
17
AIV
18
AIV
19
AIV
20
AIV
21
AIV
22
AIV
23
AIV
24
AIV
25
AIV
26
AIV
27
AIV
28
AIV
29
AIV
30
AIV
31
AIV
32
AIV
33
AIV
34
AIV
35
AIV
36
AIV
37
AIV
38
AIV
39
AIV
40
AIV
41
AIV
42
AIV
43
ND
V 1
ND
V 4
ND
V 6
NE
G
ND
V-1
ND
V-2
ND
V-3
ND
V-4
ND
V-6
D10
D11
D12
E1
E2
E3
E4
E5
E6
E7
E8
E9
E10
E11
E12
F1
F2
Gel images of RT-PCR amplified cDNA from lab strains
AIV NDV
Electronic Microarray
• Electrophoretically driven printing of probes
and minimal amplicon hybridization time
• 400 independently activated test sites
++
Positive Charge
++
Positive Charge
Printing
Biotinylated Capture Probe
Amplicon
Hybridization
Wash
Reporting
Heat map – P:N data. Probe specificity to AI and NDV
AIV
M-0
07 d
eg
AIV
- M-0
08 d
eg
ND
V- M
-01
ND
V- M
-10
FM
D-A
T-2
3
M-
AIV
M-
ND
V- M
-01
ND
V- M
-10
FM
D-A
T-2
3
41 A
IV s
tra
ins
22 N
DV
str
ains
Detectionprobes
41 A
IV s
tra
ins
ND
V1-
HP
ND
V- H
P-1
ND
V- H
P-2
ND
V- H
P-3
ND
V- H
P-4
ND
V- H
P-5
ND
V- H
P-6
ND
V- H
P-7
ND
V- H
P-8
ND
V-H
P8-
VC
22
ND
V-L
P8-
NC
22
ND
V- L
P-4
ND
V- L
P-8
FM
D-A
T-2
3
8 H
P N
DV
str
ain
s1
4 L
P N
DV
str
ain
s
ND
V1-
HP
ND
V- H
P-1
ND
V- H
P-2
ND
V- H
P-3
ND
V- H
P-4
ND
V- H
P-5
ND
V- H
P-6
ND
V- H
P-7
ND
V- H
P-8
ND
V-H
P8-
VC
22
ND
V-L
P8-
NC
22
ND
V- L
P-4
ND
V- L
P-8
FM
D-A
T-2
3Pathotypingprobes
Sensitivity
Sensitivity of detection probe to DYH Amazon (HP)
0
5
10
15
20
25
NDV-M-10 FMD-AT-23
Probe
P:N
10̂ 5 10̂ 4 10̂ 3 10̂ 2 10̂ 1 10̂ 0 10̂ -1 NTC
Limit of detection 103 TCID50 /ml
Limit of detection for NDV B2 using detection probe 101 TCID50/ml
pathotyping probe 102 TCID50 / ml
Limit of detection 103 TCID50 / ml
Detection probe Pathotyping probe
Sensitivity of HP probe
0
5
10
15
20
25
HP 3 FMD-AT-23 HP3 FMD-AT-23
Probe
P:N
10̂ 5 10̂ 4 10̂ 3 10̂ 2 10̂ 1 10̂ 0 10̂ -1 10̂ -2 NTC
DYH Amazon (HP) B2 (LP)
NDV Clinical Testing
Comparison of Microarray to RT-PCR
Bird 642 Cloacal swab
02468
101214161820
NDV-M-01 NDV-HP-3 FMD-AT-23
Probe
P:N
1 dpi
2 dpi
3 dpi
NTC
Cloaca
DPI Array RT-PCR
1 7 9
2 10 10
3 7 10
Clinical samples
10 birds infected with APMV-1 Amazon
Sampling: Swabs: oropharynx, cloaca
Dpi: 1, 2, 3
Total = 60 samples
Field negative samples = 40
Samples not detected
• RT-PCR Ct values close to cutoff (36)
• Faint bands in PCR for array
• Results highly comparable with
RT-PCR
Avian HA and NA subtyping40/41 strains correctly HA subtyped
All 41 strains correctly NA subtyped
Sensitivity: comparable to real time PCR
data
Limit of detection of NA assay 43 - 2320
EID50
Limit of detection of HA assay 4 - 23
EID50
Summary
• Simultaneous detection of AIV and
NDV and further pathotype NDV
• No cross reactions observed
• Assay useful for single and mixed
infection
• Results highly comparable to RT-
PCR
N1 -
021
N1 -
026
N2 -
008
N2 -
014l
ong1
N3 -
002
N4 -
022
N5 -
017
NA
6-2(
qiu)
N7 -
005
N8 -
015
N9 -
022
Neg
.Con
t.
NA Specificity
Probes
Str
ains
AIV Heat map of P:N ratio data
N1
N2
N3
N4
N5N6
N7
N8
N9
NTC
CFIA, LethbridgeOliver Lung Dirk Deregt *Tara Furukawa-Stoffer Kimberley Burton HughesMathew FisherAnne Beeston*Kristen Hahn*Jennifer Geddes*Billy Mauro*
Nexogen, Inc. Dalibor Hodko
CFIA, NCFAD, Winnipeg John Pasick Yohannes BerhaneAnimal and Technical Staff Alfonso Clavijo*
IAH, Pirbright, UKDonald KingScott Reid
Funding:CRTI (The Chemical, Biological, Radiological or Nuclear Research and Technology Initiative)
* Former members
CFIA Lethbridge Laboratory
Outline
Outbreaks Outbreaks
Electronic MicroarrayElectronic Microarray
Overview of Avian HC Assay: Design and DevelopmentOverview of Avian HC Assay: Design and Development
ResultsResults
NDV/AIV Multiplex RT-PCR Design and Development
NDV Matrix (M) gene1 1097
NDV Fusion (F) gene16621
Cleavage Region
400 bp
344 bp
AIV Matrix (M) gene1 1027
280 bp
Electronic Microarray
• Electrophoretically driven printing and hybridization
Time (seconds) Time (hours) Electronic Passive
(Movie here)
CMOS Chip PlatinumMicroelectrode
Hydrogel Permeation LayerContaining Streptavidin
50 m diameter test site
Array
• 400 independently activated test sites
Heat map – P:N data. Reactivity of probes to AI and NDV
AIV
M-0
07 d
eg
AIV
- M-0
08 d
eg
ND
V- M
-01
ND
V- M
-10
FM
D-A
T-2
3
00W1015 00.09.28 98 IMP 134 2CE
M-
AIV
M-
ND
V- M
-01
ND
V- M
-10
FM
D-A
T-2
3
H2N3 A/Mallard/AB/77/1977H3N2 A/TY/Eng/1969H4N8 A/Parrot/England/1970H5N1 A/CK/Scot/1959H5N2 A/CK/Hild/26654-1368/1994H5N2 A/CK/Penn/1370H5N2 A/TK/Minn/3689-1551/1981
H5N2 A/DK/BC/26-6/2000
H5N3 A/TY/CA/35621/1984H5N8 A/TY/Ireland/1963H5N9 A/TY/ON/7732/1966H5N9 A/TY/Wisconsin/1968H6N2 A/TY/Mass/1965H6N8 A/TY/ON/1963H7N1 A/TY/ON/18-2/2000H7N3 A/CK/Aust/3634/1992H7N3 A/CK/BC/514/2004H7N7 A/CK/Victoria/32972/1985H7N8 A/MR/China/28710/1995
H8N4 A/TY/ON/6118/1967H9N2 A/TY/Minn/12../1981H10N7 A/CK/Germany/1949H11N1 A/DK/Eng/1956H12N5 A/DK/AB/60/1976H13N1 A/Gull/MD/704/1977H14N5 A/Mallard/Gurjev/263/1982H15N8 A/DK/Aust/341/1983H16N3 A/BHG/Sweden/5/1999H2N9 A/Pintail/AB/293/7H4N6 A/DK/Czech/1956H9N9 A/Pheasant/WA/373H3N8 A/Mallard/AB/431/1983H5N2 A/Mallard/QC/2323-25/2006H1N1 A/Mallard/AB/306/06H5N2 A/Goose/MB/428/2006H5N2 A/Mallard/BC/8038/2006H10N7 A/CK/ON/01/1999H11N1 A/Goose/MB/321/2006H13N6 A/Gull/SK/283/1999H1N1 A/Mallard/ON/269/2005H1N2 A/Goose/MB/325/2006
WIN-AH-2008-OTH-0027 276 KI ICENDV CK/US ROAKIN/48 2 CE
(NDV) DYHAMAZON ICE 99-10-25PMV-1 Australia Velogenic d10PMV-1 California Kimber VelogenicPMV-1 Fontana 1083 VelogenicPMV-1 G.B. Texas VelogenicNDV B1PMV-1 Ireland/Ulster E3/76PMV-1 LaSota LentogenicPMV-1 Conneticut 1960 WIN-AH-2008-OTH-0069WIN-AH-2003-CN-00013WIN-AH-2003-CN-0009WIN-AH-2001-NS-01416WIN-AH-2008-FAV-0001WIN-AH-2005-NS-03042WIN-AH-2006-IM-00028WIN-AH-2006-NS-000924WIN-AH-2001-CN-0001796CNN0057NTC
-
--
-
-
-AH- -OTH-
-10-25- d10---
NDV B1--1 -1
WIN- - -OTH-WIN-AH-2003-CN-00013WIN-AH-2003-CN-0009WIN-AH-2001-NS-01416WIN-AH-2008-FAV-0001WIN-AH-2005-NS-03042WIN-AH-2006-IM-00028WIN-AH-2006-NS-000924WIN-AH-2001-CN-0001796CNN0057NTC
41 A
IV s
tra
ins
22 N
DV
str
ains
Detectionprobes
41 A
IV s
tra
ins
ND
V1-
HP
ND
V- H
P-1
ND
V- H
P-2
ND
V- H
P-3
ND
V- H
P-4
ND
V- H
P-5
ND
V- H
P-6
ND
V- H
P-7
ND
V- H
P-8
ND
V-H
P8-
VC
22
ND
V-L
P8-
NC
22
ND
V- L
P-4
ND
V- L
P-8
FM
D-A
T-2
3
8 H
P N
DV
str
ain
s1
4 L
P N
DV
str
ain
s
ND
V1-
HP
ND
V- H
P-1
ND
V- H
P-2
ND
V- H
P-3
ND
V- H
P-4
ND
V- H
P-5
ND
V- H
P-6
ND
V- H
P-7
ND
V- H
P-8
ND
V-H
P8-
VC
22
ND
V-L
P8-
NC
22
ND
V- L
P-4
ND
V- L
P-8
FM
D-A
T-2
3Pathotypingprobes
00W1015 00.09.28 98 IMP 134 2CE
H2N3 A/Mallard/AB/77/1977H3N2 A/TY/Eng/1969H4N8 A/Parrot/England/1970H5N1 A/CK/Scot/1959H5N2 A/CK/Hild/26654-1368/1994H5N2 A/CK/Penn/1370H5N2 A/TK/Minn/3689-1551/1981
H5N2 A/DK/BC/26-6/2000
H5N3 A/TY/CA/35621/1984H5N8 A/TY/Ireland/1963H5N9 A/TY/ON/7732/1966H5N9 A/TY/Wisconsin/1968H6N2 A/TY/Mass/1965H6N8 A/TY/ON/1963H7N1 A/TY/ON/18-2/2000H7N3 A/CK/Aust/3634/1992H7N3 A/CK/BC/514/2004H7N7 A/CK/Victoria/32972/1985H7N8 A/MR/China/28710/1995
H8N4 A/TY/ON/6118/1967H9N2 A/TY/Minn/12../1981H10N7 A/CK/Germany/1949H11N1 A/DK/Eng/1956H12N5 A/DK/AB/60/1976H13N1 A/Gull/MD/704/1977H14N5 A/Mallard/Gurjev/263/1982H15N8 A/DK/Aust/341/1983H16N3 A/BHG/Sweden/5/1999H2N9 A/Pintail/AB/293/7H4N6 A/DK/Czech/1956H9N9 A/Pheasant/WA/373H3N8 A/Mallard/AB/431/1983H5N2 A/Mallard/QC/2323-25/2006H1N1 A/Mallard/AB/306/06H5N2 A/Goose/MB/428/2006H5N2 A/Mallard/BC/8038/2006H10N7 A/CK/ON/01/1999H11N1 A/Goose/MB/321/2006H13N6 A/Gull/SK/283/1999H1N1 A/Mallard/ON/269/2005H1N2 A/Goose/MB/325/2006
WIN-AH-2008-OTH-0027 276 KI ICENDV CK/US ROAKIN/48 2 CE
(NDV) DYHAMAZON ICE 99-10-25PMV-1 Australia Velogenic d10PMV-1 California Kimber VelogenicPMV-1 Fontana 1083 VelogenicPMV-1 G.B. Texas VelogenicNDV B1PMV-1 Ireland/Ulster E3/76PMV-1 LaSota LentogenicPMV-1 Conneticut 1960 WIN-AH-2008-OTH-0069WIN-AH-2003-CN-00013WIN-AH-2003-CN-0009WIN-AH-2001-NS-01416WIN-AH-2008-FAV-0001WIN-AH-2005-NS-03042WIN-AH-2006-IM-00028WIN-AH-2006-NS-000924WIN-AH-2001-CN-0001796CNN0057NTC
-
--
-
-
-AH- -OTH-
-10-25- d10---
NDV B1--1 -1
WIN- - -OTH-WIN-AH-2003-CN-00013WIN-AH-2003-CN-0009WIN-AH-2001-NS-01416WIN-AH-2008-FAV-0001WIN-AH-2005-NS-03042WIN-AH-2006-IM-00028WIN-AH-2006-NS-000924WIN-AH-2001-CN-0001796CNN0057NTC
Sensitivity of detection probes
Sensitivity of detection probe to APMV-1 Amazon (HP)
0
5
10
15
20
25
NDV-M-10 FMD-AT-23
Probe
P:N
10^5
10^4
10^3
10^2
10^1
10^0
10^-1
NTC
Sensitivity of detection probe to NDV B2 (LP)
0
5
10
15
20
25
NDV-M-10 FMD-AT-23
Probe
P:N
10^5
10^4
10^3
10^2
10^1
10^0
10^-1
10^-2
NTC
Limit of detection 103 TCID50 /ml
Limit of detection 101 TCID50/ml
Sensitivity of Pathotyping Probes
Sensitivity of HP probe
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
HP 3 FMD-AT-23 HP3 FMD-AT-23
Probe
P:N
10^5 10^4 10^3 10^2 10^1 10^0 10^-1 10^-2 NTC
DYH Amazon (HP) B2 (LP) DYH Amazon (HP)B2 (LP)
Limit of detection 103 TCID50 / ml
Limit of detection 102 TCID50 / ml
Sensitivity of LP probe
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
LP8 NC22 FMD-AT-23 LP8 NC22 FMD-AT-23
Probe
P:N
10^5 10^4 10^3 10^2 10^1 10^0 10^-1 10^-2 NTC
NDV Clinical Testing
Comparison of Microarray to RT-PCR
Bird 642 Cloacal swab
02468
101214161820
NDV-M-01 NDV-HP-3 FMD-AT-23
Probe
P:N
1 dpi
2 dpi
3 dpi
NTC
Bird 642 Oropharyngeal swab
02468
101214161820
NDV-M-01 NDV-HP-3 FMD-AT-23
Probe
P:N
1 dpi
2 dpi
3 dpi
NTC
Cloaca Oropharynx
DPI Array RT-PCR Array RT-PCR
1 7 9 0 1
2 10 10 5 8
3 7 10 8 10
Clinical samples
10 birds infected with APMV-1 Amazon
Sampling: Swabs: oropharynx, cloaca
Dpi: 1, 2, 3
Total = 60 samples
Field negative samples = 40
BSE facts1997 Rum to rum feed ban – pet food. Livestock feedd, fetrilizers, skull, brain, eyes tonsils, CFIA control collection2001 National TSE network2001 Canadian cattle IDMay 2003 National BSE case
TSE Lab Network scrapie associated fibrils