development services local member -...

$: DEVELOPMENT SERVICES Local Member - …...F:\MODERNGOV\DATA\PUBLISHED\INTRANET\C00000199\M00002226\AI00025745\0511WR0.DO C DEVELOPMENT SERVICES Local Member - Councillor A. Reay PLANNING$
F:\MODERNGOV\DATA\PUBLISHED\INTRANET\C00000199\M00002226\AI00025745\0511WR0.DO

C

DEVELOPMENT SERVICES Local Member - Councillor A. Reay PLANNING APPLICATION REPORT Date of Validity - 14th March 2005 HELENSBURGH AND LOMOND AREA COMMITTEE Discretionary Hearing Date - 29th November 2005 12th October 2005 Reference Number: 05/00511/DET Applicants Name: Osborne Interiors Ltd., Application Type: Detailed application Application Description: Erection of 8 dwellinghouses Location: Land North of Empress Drive, Helensburgh

(A ) THE APPLICATION (i) Development Requiring Express Planning Permission:

• Erection of 8 dwellings • Formation of 4 new vehicular accesses onto Rhu Road Higher, each serving 2

properties. (ii) Other Specified Operations

• Connection to public water supply • Connection to public sewerage system

(B) RECOMMENDATION It is recommended that planning permission be refused for the reasons listed overleaf.

(C) DETERMINING ISSUES AND MATERIAL CONSIDERATIONS

• Planning permission is sought for the erection of 8 semi-detached dwellings on a 0.4-hectare piece of ground adjacent to Rhu Road Higher. The site is predominantly covered with mature woodland but the rear section of the site contains a number of lock-up garages that are in a poor state of repair. These garages are accessed via a lane that leads onto Empress Drive and are proposed to be demolished as part of the development proposals. The garages are not attractive features but are fairly well screened from public view and do not therefore significantly reduce the visual amenity of the area. The proposed dwellings would be two storeys (8.1m) in height with an integral single garage. Each property would have four bedrooms, two public rooms, 2 ½ bathrooms and measure 9.6m in length and 9.6m in width. Four new vehicular accesses are proposed onto Rhu Road Higher each serving two properties. The existing stone boundary wall would be reduced from 1.2m to 0.9 metres high along its entire length. The houses would be clad in stone, render and grey concrete tiles with upvc windows.

• The application site is an area of woodland protected by a Tree Preservation Order (TPO), all

but 15% of which is larch with the rest made up of sycamore, silver birch and other species. The site is bounded by two storied, rendered former MoD terraced housing and playing fields with bungalows across the road.


C

• The proposed development involves the clear felling of all the existing trees on the site, demolition of the garages and the erection of 8 dwellings, accesses and driveways. Replacement planting would be located to the rear of the development on the boundaries with Empress Drive properties and at the side of the site, leaving the majority of the site clear of trees. The proposed replacement planting would take the form of approximately 120 ‘whips’ that would be 1-1.5 metres in height (approximately 3 – 5 feet)

• In terms of policy the application site is located within a residential area where Policies H4

and H5 of the Dumbarton District, District Wide Local Plan are applicable. These policies together with Policies DC1 and NHL6 state that new development is acceptable only if it has regard to the appearance and character of immediately surrounding areas in terms of design, scale, density and materials and will not lead to the loss of established trees. As the trees on site are covered by a TPO then Policy NHL5 and Structure Plan Policy STRAT FW2 are also applicable. These state that the Council will continue to protect trees within current TPO areas. The proposed development will lead to the total loss of tree cover on this site and thus will obviously not protect trees covered by a TPO. The Council commissioned a detailed tree survey to assess the health and viability of the trees on this site given the applicant’s assertion (and commissioned tree report) that the majority of trees were unsafe. This report concluded that only 4 trees on this site required to be felled for health and safety reasons and that another 18 required remedial works and/or resurvey. This report also concluded that the woodlands did contribute positively to the environment; offering good amenity value and acting as an inter-linking wildlife corridor. The proposed development is therefore contrary to Policies STRAT FW2, NHL5, NHL6, H4(d) and to H5 (b)

• In addition I am of the opinion that the scale and massing of the proposed new houses are not

in keeping with the character of the immediately surrounding area. The site sits between the two storey terraced properties fronting onto Empress Drive located to the rear of the site and bungalows directly opposite fronting onto Rhu Road Higher. The properties on Empress Drive are 8m high, 8 m wide on plots measuring on average 10m wide by 15m in depth. The bungalows opposite are detached properties on plots with an average of size of 22m in width and 45m in depth. However, given that the application site fronts onto and takes access from Rhu Road Higher then the proposed new dwellings will “read” as being more associated with the bungalows directly opposite than the Empress Drive dwellings. The proposed plots at approximately 11.5 m are narrow in comparison with others on Rhu Road Higher and the footprints of the proposed houses are large in relation to this plot size which has a depth of approximately 40m. This will make the proposed houses, which are set out as 4 pairs of semi-detached dwellings, appear crammed onto the site. The whole of the front of each house is required for car parking, access and turning and thus only a comparatively small area of garden will be useable. In my view the proposed semi-detached dwellings would constitute over-development, will be too bulky and dominating in the streetscene, and will look very out of place when juxtaposed next to single storey bungalows or small terraced houses. This dominant appearance will be particularly noticeable, as the existing mature trees will all be gone and any replacements will be very small and insignificant for many years to come. The application is therefore considered to be contrary to Policy H5 (a).

• The application has not attracted any objections from the Area Roads Manager, Scottish

Water or SNH (although a bat survey has identified that the site is used as a feeding ground for Pipistrelle bats). Helensburgh Community Council have objected on the grounds that the development is contrary to several adopted policies and also to proposed policies contained within the consultative draft Local Plan; will lead to the loss of trees protected by a TPO; would have an unacceptable design and scale of development for the area; would adversely affect wildlife habitats and would cause traffic congestion.

• The development has also attracted significant community interest and to date 12 letters of

support and 777 letters of objection have been received. The specific points of representation and the names and addresses of supporters and objectors are contained within the appendices of this report. It should be noted that a large number of these letters refer to all three planning applications submitted by this applicant for residential development in woodland sites on Cumberland Road and Rhu Road Higher.


C

(D) CONCLUSION

In conclusion the proposed development of an area of mature woodland protected by a Tree Preservation Order for a residential development of 8 houses would result in the loss of all existing trees and the complete destruction of the established character and appearance of the site. The trees on this site are considered by the Council commissioned tree surgeon to be generally healthy and viable. Their felling on health or safety grounds is not therefore justified. It is considered that the woodland is an attractive and significant landscape feature in the locality that is of good amenity value to the community and to local wildlife. This area of woodland also provides an important role in integrating existing housing into its setting, softening its impact and screening areas of very different housing styles from each other. The loss of this wooded area and its replacement with a suburban residential development and perimeter whip planting will adversely affect the character and appearance of the area. This development is contrary to a number of development plan policies that seek to protect trees and woodlands from inappropriate development pressure due to their importance as attractive landscape features and amenity resources. In addition, the proposed houses are considered to have excessive bulk and mass in relation to their plot size and to adjacent residential development. This will cause the development to appear cramped, to dominate and to look out of place in the established streetscene, an effect exacerbated by the loss of all the mature trees. It is therefore recommended that planning permission be refused for the reasons listed overleaf.

Angus J Gilmour Head of Planning 12th October 2005 Author: Lisa Cameron tel. 01436 658886 Contact Point: Howard Young tel. 01436 658888


C

REASONS FOR REFUSAL RELATIVE TO APPLICATION 05/00511/DET:

1. The application site has significant amenity value in the immediate area and wider setting of Helensburgh due to its mature tree cover and woodland appearance. The proposed development will result in the loss of this important woodland area, which occupies a prominent position within the locality and which successfully integrates and softens the impact of existing residential development into its wider landscape setting. The total loss of these trees and other vegetation cover and their replacement with substantial dwellings, access road, hardstanding, fences and other associated suburban development will be visually intrusive, visually discordant and will not maintain or enhance the character of the area. The planting of replacement trees 1-1.5 metres in height around part of the perimeter will not be sufficient to retain the woodland character of the site in either the short or the long term. The site is covered by a Tree Preservation Order and the proposal will prevent significant regeneration and replanting of trees by substantially reducing the areas available for tree cover and changing the character of the site from woodland to suburban garden. This in turn will further undermine the amenity value of the site, will be further visually intrusive and will further contribute to its detrimental impact on adjoining properties and the wider area. The proposal is therefore contrary to the terms of Structure Plan Policy STRAT FW2 and Policies DC1, H4, H5 NHL5 and NHL6 of the Dumbarton District, District Wide Local Plan, which seek to prevent the loss of trees and to maintain and enhance the character of existing residential areas.

2. The proposed plots at 11.5m wide are narrow in comparison with other properties on Rhu Road

Higher which on average are 22m in width. The scale and mass of the proposed houses are comparatively large in relation to the overall plots both in terms of available frontage and overall footprint. As such they will give the appearance of over-development and will look crammed within the site. This cramped appearance will be accentuated by the removal of all the mature vegetation at the front of the site and the provision of only limited replanting. Consequently, the proposed dwellings will be visually dominant, intrusive and will look out of place in the established streetscene. As such the proposed development will have a detrimental impact upon the amenity and character of adjoining properties and the wider area. The proposal is therefore contrary to the terms of Policies DC1, H4 and H5 of the Dumbarton District, District Wide Local Plan which seeks to maintain and enhance the character of existing residential areas.


C

APPENDIX RELATIVE TO APPLICATION 05/00511/DET:

A. POLICY OVERVIEW

Argyll and Bute Structure Plan Policy FW2 Development shall not damage nor undermine the key environmental features of important woodland areas including the following categories:

A) Woodland areas and trees which have been mapped for safeguarding in Argyll and Bute

Local Plans or are protected by Tree Preservation Orders or by Conservation Areas.

B) Woodland areas and trees which are identified for safeguarding in planning determinations or agreements or by associated area capacity evaluations or farm, croft and estate development programmes.

C) Woodland and integral open space which is a significant component of determined

woodland grant scheme or equivalent proposal.

D) Ancient and long established semi-natural woodland as identified in Scottish Natural Heritage Inventory sources.

E) Other broadleaf woodland over 1 hectares in extent. Dumbarton District Wide Local Plan Policy DC1 All development proposals will be expected to provide a high standard of building and landscape design, to contribute to environmental quality and to maintain or enhance the amenity of the surrounding area.

All development proposals and applications for planning permission will be considered on the basis of the following Local Plan policy criteria:

1. the location and nature of the proposed development, including land use, layout, design,

external appearance, density, landscaping, open space provision, aspect, daylighting, crime prevention measures and privacy of existing and proposed development;

2. the impact on the natural and built environment, the likely level of environmental pollution and the possible creation of any hazard, or impact on the landscape and overall setting;

3. the relationship to the road and public transport network, means of access, particularly access for disabled people, emergency services, parking provision, and likely scale and type of traffic generation;

4. the availability of infrastructure and relationship to existing community facilities; 5. consistency with the terms of other local plan policies. Policy H4 New housing developments should conform to the following range of considerations: a. Open Space: Open space should be provided in accordance with Policy LR2. b. Phasing of Open Space Provision: The open space provision should be completed

simultaneously with the completion of the housing it is designed to serve and all provision shall be completed not later than the end of the first planting season following the completion of the last house in the development.


C

c. Design: Good design in terms of layout, appearance, landscaping and regard for privacy standards, as well as good relationships to landscape setting and the character of neighbouring buildings, will be required.

d. Existing Features: All aspects of the development should retain, and where possible enhance, any positive landscape, ecological or townscape features of the housing site and its immediate surroundings. Consequently, existing trees, hedges, shrubs and other natural and man-made features should be incorporated in layouts at every opportunity.

e. Road and Parking Standards: Developers will normally be required to meet road design and parking standards laid down by the Roads Authority. In appropriate locations the Council will actively encourage developers to introduce pedestrian/vehicle shared surface roads as set out in the Council’s guidelines. Consideration will be given to relaxing parking standards in line with variations set out by the Council where special needs/sheltered housing developments are being proposed.

f. Extensions: New housing should be laid out and designed to allow for subsequent extension within “permitted development” limits whilst ensuring it does not detract from the amenity of surrounding buildings.

g. Density: The density of housing units within new residential development proposals should be in the range of the density of surrounding existing housing areas. Notwithstanding this there will be a general presumption against developments in excess of 4 storeys unless exceptional townscape benefits can be demonstrated.

h. Disabled Access: Within estate housing developments, developers will be encouraged to make provision for an element of barrier-free housing for physically disabled occupants.

Policy H5 The Council will seek to maintain and enhance the character of existing residential areas. Development proposals on infill and gap sites will be considered against the following criteria:

a. Proposals for infill residential development will have regard to the appearance and character of immediately surrounding residential areas in terms of the scale and density of development and use of appropriate design and materials.

b. The loss of established trees and hedgerows will be resisted unless their presence fundamentally prevents the development of a site which satisfies all other development criteria defined by Local Plan policies.

c. There will be a presumption against the development of formal and planned open spaces within existing residential areas, unless they have been identified for residential development within this Local Plan.

d. Residential development proposals which are considered to represent over-development in terms of the density and/or extent of development will be resisted.

House extensions and other developments within the curtilage of an existing dwellinghouse should have a high standard of design and external appearance (further advice on house extensions is available in the Council’s Design Guide).

Proposals for non-residential uses will only be favourably considered where it can be demonstrated that the proposed use is ancillary to, and would not result in a significant loss of amenity of the residential character of the area.

Policy NHL5 The Council will continue to protect trees within current Tree Preservation Orders in the Plan area, and where it is considered necessary for amenity reasons to protect further trees or woodland areas, the Council will serve new Tree Preservation Orders. The Council will also continue to protect trees in Conservation Areas.

Policy NHL6 New development proposed on sites with, or adjacent to, existing trees or woodlands will be assessed in accordance with established guidelines. When approving planning applications,


C

conditions will, be attached to safeguard existing trees and/or plant new trees if appropriate to the size and scale of development.

Scottish Planning Policy (SPP’s) and National Planning Policy Guidance (NPPG’s) NPPG 3: Land for Housing – Indicates that residential development should not result in a loss of green space of importance to the area and valued by the community.

B. OTHER MATERIAL CONSIDERATIONS

(i) Consultations

1. Area Roads Manager (memo dated 1st April 2005) – No objections subject to conditions. 2. Scottish Water (letter dated 31st August 2005) - No objections subject to conditions. 3. SNH (letters dated 25th April and 31st August 2005). – No comments to make on the

proposal except to recommend that a bat survey be carried out at the earliest opportunity prior to determining whether planning permission should be granted. Following receipt of the requested bat survey SNH confirmed that as there were no roost sites identified within the application site then an application for a license would not be necessary on this occasion.

4. Helensburgh Community Council (letter dated 5th April 2005) – Wish to register strong

objections to the proposal on the following grounds; a. The Argyll and Bute Consultative Draft Local Plan indicates that the areas are to be

designated as an ‘Open Space Protection Area’. These local plan policies are material considerations in determining planning applications.

b. The plans contravene items H5, NHL5, NHL6 and DC1 of the Local Plan. Helensburgh Community Council cannot support the contravention of any Local Plan policies.

c. The Council put a Tree Preservation Order on this woodland. While this allows for the felling of diseased or dangerous trees, it assumes that there will replanting. It does not allow for the removal of tracts and the building of dwellings on the site.

d. To approve this development would be to flout the letter and intent of the TPO as well as setting up an unwise and unwanted precedent.

e. The height of the proposed houses, three storeys plus the roof, is not in keeping with the character of the houses in the area, which will be dominated by the new development.

f. There is a real threat to residents posed by increased levels of traffic movement. g. The development would severely conflict with the work of the Tree Conservation Trust

and the sites are also a natural habitat for many species of animals and birds.

5. Forestry Commission (letter dated 4th April 2005) – The clear felling of these woodlands and replacement with relatively dense housing raises the following issues, that should be explored and accounted for in the planning application: a. The loss of landscape features which have become local landmarks and which help ameliorate the surrounding high density housing into the landscape. b. Local members of the community currently heavily use the woodlands for informal recreation and as such the neighbouring residents and local community council should be consulted regarding the loss of this amenity. In addition the exclusion of the public from a recognised recreational resource may have implications under Part 1 of the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003.

(iii) Publicity The application was advertised under Article 9 (Vacant Land) as a potential bad neighbour development and as a potential departure from Policies H5, NHL5 and NHL6 of the adopted


C

Local Plan (overall closing date 29th April 2005). 12 letters of support and 777 letters of objection have been received to date. A significant proportion of all letters (both of support and objection) were of a proforma type. The details of those who have submitted representations are detailed at the end of this report. Summary of the Main Points of Support 1. The project will secure the jobs of employees of the developer for at least 3 years and

will also create employment for others. Comment: In this case this is a very minor and unsubstantiated material consideration that does not overcome the strong policy objections to the development. 2. The site is semi-derelict and the development will greatly enhance the area as straggly

looking trees are an eyesore and give the appearance of being unsafe. The garages have asbestos roofing, which is a health hazard; the site is used for fly tipping and is fouled by dogs.

Comment: I would disagree that the site is semi-derelict or an eyesore. As indicated in my assessment the front of the site is in fact an attractive and heavily wooded area of mature trees and only the garages to the rear are semi-derelict. These are not particularly prominent in the streetscape due to tree-screening. Furthermore, the Council’s appointed tree surgeons have undertaken a detailed tree survey safety inspection and reported that only four trees within this area are required to be felled for safety reasons. I have not observed any significant amounts of fly tipping on this site. 3. Helensburgh needs more housing and the proposed houses although no doubt

expensive will set off a chain reaction releasing cheaper housing as people climb the property ladder. This will attract and retain new people to the town creating employment and prosperity.

Comment: The issue of providing new land for housing in Helensburgh is being dealt with as part of the Local Plan process and in any event is not reason to justify the felling of substantial numbers of trees protected by a Tree Preservation Order. 4. The proposed design of development and the replacement-planting scheme is well

designed and impressive. The local architect and building company are reputable and the building company takes on apprentices, providing opportunities to young people needing employment.

Comment: Please see my assessment. The characters of the applicant or the agent are not material planning matters. 5. The development is in keeping with the aim of preserving the general amenity of the

area while providing additional housing without extending the boundaries of the town. This is preferable to building on sites that extends urban sprawl.

Comment: Please see my assessment. 6. The proposed replacement trees are of a more appropriate species in the long term

than the generally shallow rooted crop trees that are there at present. The presence of these new trees will provide a screening effect and much more interest in terms of shape and colour than the boring monoculture they replace.

Comment: Members considered the existing trees on site worthy of preservation when they approved the Tree Preservation Order for this site and they are still, in my opinion, worthy of retention today. Any wholesale felling and replanting will inevitably result in the site’s character and appearance changing dramatically. In addition, the applicant’s proposed replanting scheme submitted with the application proposes much smaller trees planted


C

primarily to the rear and sides of the site with the majority of the land used for housing and garden. This is contrary to the aims of the Tree Preservation Order policy. 7. This detailed site in Helensburgh has been zoned for decades as building land. This

area does not encroach onto greenbelt and is situated within residential areas. Comment: See my assessment. 8. A comprehensive schedule of re-planting has been professionally drawn up showing

clearly the improvements and quality this area deserves. This re-planting schedule has a five year maintenance programme built into ensure the trees/shrubs will mature and thrive.

Comment: See my assessment. 9. The area in question is nothing more than scrubland at present, having been neglected

for many years by previous owners. Developing this area along with the re-planting could only be an improvement.

Comment: See my assessment. Summary of the Main Points of Objection 1. The proposed houses are inappropriate for the site due to their size and in particular

their height being out of character with that already present in the area. Two storey houses are not in keeping with the bungalows located between Dobbies Garden Centre and the sports field.

Comment: I also have concerns over the scale and massing of the proposed houses. Please see my assessment for further details. 2. There is only a pavement on one side of Rhu Road Higher and the extra driveways will

reduce its safety to pedestrians. There is no room for a pavement on the north side of Rhu Road Higher.

Comment: The Area Roads Manager has no objections to the proposals. 3. The proposed replacement tree planting is mostly of species that will grow high and

have dense foliage in summer and this will cause shading and leaf fall problems for neighbours. The proposed replacement trees will be too close to nearby houses and may also cause damage to property.

Comment: This is not a relevant planning consideration. Damage to property by trees is a civil matter. 4. The site is covered by a Tree Preservation Order (TPO), which should be respected.

TPO’s are being regularly ignored in this area and it is time we respected the TPO’s we have and refuse planning applications that will lead to the loss of protected trees and are thus detrimental to the whole community apart from those who benefit financially.

Comment: See my assessment. 5. The wood is one of the last vestiges of the whole wood owned originally by the MoD. It

is time that we preserved what little is left. Comment: See my assessment. 6. The proposal is contrary to Policies H5, NHL5, NHl6 and DC1 of the Local Plan. Comment: See my assessment.


C

7. The woodland is an important natural habitat for wildlife including 20 species of birds,

hedgehogs, voles, squirrels, bats etc. Comment: SNH have no objections to the proposals in terms of wildlife issues. A bat survey has been carried out and this showed that the site is used as feeding areas by Pipistrelle bats. However, there is no evidence of bat roosts on the site and SNH has advised that an application for a licence will not be required on this occasion. 8. A Tree Conservation Trust was created in Helensburgh over 2 years ago which has

been monitoring old trees and planting new ones throughout the town. This plan is ongoing and successful. In view of this how could a planning application be granted whereby all the trees in question are replaced by expensive housing?

Comment: This point is not relevant to consideration of this planning application. 9. The present character of the area would be severely affected by the loss of the

woodlands and the established amenity would be destroyed if they were to be redeveloped. They are an important environmental feature of the area and of Helensburgh itself and are very prominent and visible from surrounding areas and vantage points.

Comment: See my assessment. 10. The woodlands form a setting for the remains of Ardencaple Castle. Comment: See my assessment. 11. The site has been recognised as being one of the key environmental features of the

area as indicated in the new Local Plan under preparation. Comment: The new Local Plan is not yet a material consideration in the determination of this application. 12. The sites are valued by the community for their contribution to open space provision

within the existing residential area. It is an attractive area that does not have any fly tipping. Generations of children have played in the woods and should be allowed to continue to do so. The owners have been requested to prepare a management plan for the woods and this is welcomed, as it will protect the character of the area as well as existing wildlife.

Comment: See my assessment. 13. The blocking of existing footpaths in the woods with felled timber is unacceptable. Comment: This is not directly a planning matter. 14. SNH is carrying out a bio-diversity study on the woodlands, investigating the possibility

of bats roosting therein. Bats are protected by law and no development should be allowed if their presence is confirmed.

Comment: See point 7 above. 15. Recent government policies encourage the planting of trees within communities and

trees are vital to the health of people. They should not be removed. Comment: See my assessment. 16. The application states that 4 parking spaces will be provided for each house and this will

lead to traffic congestion as well as dangers to pedestrians and children. The proposal


C

will result in an unacceptable increase in traffic on Rhu Road Higher and Cumberland Avenue especially at peak times. If residential development is permitted on this site there should be a roundabout installed to calm traffic.

Comment: The Area Roads Manager has no objections on road safety grounds. 17. Too many new driveways are proposed which will also compromise safety. Comment: See point 16 above. 18. The loss of some trees on this site as a result of recent felling is an act of vandalism. Comment: A separate report on this matter was presented to the August 2005 Area Committee. 19. The removal of the trees could give rise to rainwater flooding to the houses in

Ardencaple Drive and an increase in soil erosion to surrounding areas. Comment: The removal of trees does have the potential to give rise to flooding and erosion. If I was recommending approval of this application then I would recommend that appropriate conditions be imposed to ensure that any surface water runoff was being attenuated and that appropriate drainage was being provided. 20. The proposals are contrary to Policy FW2 of the Strathclyde Structure Plan and to

guidance contained in NPPG 3, 11 and 14 Comment: See my assessment. 21. Perimeter planting of trees does not compensate for the loss of these woodlands. Comment: See my assessment.

22. The development would breach Green Belt policies. Comment: The site is not part of the Green Belt. 23. The recent tree removal has significantly increased the echo effect of noise, which

reverberates between the banking and Ardencaple Drive and this will increase as more trees are removed.

Comment: This is not a relevant ground for refusing planning permission. 24. How was land purchased from the MoD for a relatively small sum to yield £2.5 – £3

million in sales for speculators? Comment: This is not a relevant planning matter. 25. There is a Right of Way across the site. Comment: I am advised that there is no formally recognised Right of Way through the site at present. However, I understand that the Council is investigating (in consultation with the Rights of Way Society) whether there is enough evidence to support the assertion by several individuals that the site meets the criteria for it to be added to the Right of Way. If a Right of Way were shown to have been established then this would be a material planning consideration in the determination of this application. 26. The present semi-rural character of the site will be damaged by the partial removal and reduction in height of the dry stone dyke, which runs the length of the site.


C

Comment; The reduction in height to 0.9 metre of this traditional stone wall would be an untypical height for this sort of feature. 27. The development will increase the visibility of the former MoD houses on Empress Drive that are of poor aesthetic quality. Comment: The removal of all the trees will remove all the screening between the road and the houses on Empress Drive. 28.The new development will have multiple car parking to the front and this will give the appearance of a garage forecourt.

Comment: I would agree that a very substantial area to the front of the proposed houses would be hard surfaced. Together with the loss of vegetation and the reduction in height of wall this will, in my opinion, have a negative impact upon the streetscape. 29. The development will affect a well-used access through the existing wood for pedestrians. Comment: See point 25 above. In addition to the Right of Way issue there is now a right of access in terms of the Land Reform Act. 30. The submitted plans do not show the correct boundary with some properties on Empress Drive.

Comment: I have checked this point with the applicants and they have confirmed that the application boundary edged in red relates wholly to land within the applicants’ ownership. This boundary relates to the kerb inside the fence and not the fence itself. 31. The area of tarmac in front of the existing garages allows access to the rear of Empress Drive properties and aids security. The loss of this access will reduce safety. Comment: This is a civil matter. 32. The tarmac area to the front of the garages is also the location for telephone poles and the development would limit access and maintenance.

Comment: This is a civil matter. Access to services would require to be maintained or the telephone poles would require to be moved at the applicants’ expense. 33. The proposed development will destroy the outlook from 39 Rhu Road Higher as a brick

gable wall will be located only yards from the living room window and cause significant loss of light to all the main rooms.

Comment: The proposed house will be 15 metres from the back wall of number 39 Rhu Road Higher. Mature trees on the boundary already shade the property. I am therefore of the opinion that the neighbouring house will not cause significant loss of light. 34. The development will affect the value of neighbouring property. Comment: This is not a material planning consideration. 35. The proposal involves too much development being squeezed into the available space

and the development will look crammed. Comment: The density of proposed development will give an average plot size of under 400 square metres. In this location and given that substantial houses are proposed in comparatively small gardens I would also be of the opinion that the scale of development is out of keeping with surrounding houses.


C

36. The proposed replacement trees will be too small to have a screening effect. The development will also cause an invasion of privacy due to overlooking of gardens and habitable rooms.

Comment: I would agree that the replacement planting will not provide effective screening for a number of years and that this will lead to a very open form of development. With regard to privacy there is at least 24 metres between the habitable rooms of the proposed houses and those established properties on Empress Drive. This is in excess of the minimum 18 metres window to window distance required by policy and I am therefore satisfied that there will be no loss of privacy to habitable rooms. There will however be an amount of overlooking of private rear gardens by upper windows in the new development. 37. The proposed new development does not include any affordable housing. Comment: This is correct. There is no requirement to provide affordable housing in the current Local Plan except where specifically identified on the Local Plan map. 38. The site has never had any windblown trees. In fact the trees have always acted as a

windbreak protecting adjacent housing. Comment: See my assessment. 39. If housing is required in the area it should be in the form of bungalows.

Comment: I would agree that the proposed development is out of keeping with the established built form. However, there are also serious policy constraints on the site that presume against the principle of any residential development on this site. 40. The applicants’ woodland management plan/survey is inaccurate, ambiguous and the

proposed replacement planting does not tie in with the proposed replacement planting in the planning application. The sizes of replacement trees proposed in the planning application also do not reflect the conclusions of the management plan which recommended that a variety of sizes of replacement trees be planted on site.

Comment: I assume that this point refers to the differences between the replanting scheme proposed as part of the planning application and the replanting scheme proposed as part of the earlier woodland management plan submitted as part of the justification for felling trees covered by a TPO. There are considerable differences between these plans, however this report is concerned only with the planning application proposals.


C

APPENDIX 2 – LETTERS OF REPRESENTATION

Lorna Masterton 8 Frazer Avenue Helensburgh G84 8Qp 16-Mar-05 Neil Carslaw Brookfield, Rhu Road Higher, Rhu 29-Mar- 05 Mr D K Arnold Knockderry Coach House Shore Road Cove G84 0NX 16-Mar-05 Margaret McKenzie 3 Cumberland Avenue, Helensburgh Mrs J Griffiths 4 Kent Drive, Helensburgh, G84 Ron Kenherm 4 Kathleen Park, Helensburgh A D McFadyen 27 Laggary Road, Rhu M McCann 1 Laggary Road, Rhu Joy Crawford 9 Empress Drive Ardencaple Helensburgh G84 8QL 17-Mar-05 Alan Mauchan No Address Given 17-Mar-05 Mr James And Mrs T Miller Dunstaffnage Rhu Road Higher Helensburgh G84 8JR 18-Mar-05 N Maidment 21 Duncan Road Helensburgh G84 9DH 21-Mar-05 Mrs Pam Miller Old Ravenshaw Farm Netherton Road Langbank PA14 21-Mar-05 Mark Crawford 9 Empress Drive Ardencaple Helensburgh G84 8QL 21-Mar-05 Miss Ashley Bysouth 5 Empress Drive Helensburgh G84 8QL 21-Mar-05 Mr And Mrs Flint 3 Empress Drive Helensburgh G84 8QL 21-Mar-05 Mr D K Arnold Knockderry Coach House Shore Road Cove G84 0NX 21-Mar-05 Jayne Kelly 17 Empress Drive Helensburgh G84 8QL 22-Mar-05 G W Armitage 2 Rowcliffe Avenue Chester CH4 7PW 22-Mar-05 Sophie Finn 3 Empress Drive Helensburgh G84 8QL 22-Mar-05 Erwin Losekoot 19 Napier Avenue Cardross G82 5LY 23-Mar-05 Neil Carslaw Brookfield Rhu Road Higher Helensburgh G84 8JR 23-Mar-05 D Payne & R Payne Ashton Rhu Road Higher Helensburgh G84 8JR 23-Mar-05 Lorna Hanson & Lucy Hanson Tairlaw Rhu Road Higher Helensburgh G84 8JR 23-Mar-05 Tom Adam 19 Cumberland Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QE 23-Mar-05 Mrs Mary F Glennie Tairlaw Rhu Road Higher G84 8JR 24-Mar-05 Mr And Mrs Board 1 Empress Drive Helensburgh G84 8QL 24-Mar-05 Mrs M Adam 19 Cumberland Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QE 24-Mar-05 Linda Leishman 39 Rhu Road Higher Helensburgh G84 8QH 24-Mar-05 Mrs J Whitelaw Lochan 2 Kathleen Park Helensburgh G84 8TH 29-Mar-05 Neill Carslaw Brookfield Rhu Road Higher Helensburgh G84 8JR 29-Mar-05 Lorna Masterton 8 Fraser Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QP 29-Mar-05 Robert Speirs 38 Frazer Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QR 29-Mar-05 J Wallace 29-Mar-05 G Armitage 8 Frazer Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QP 29-Mar-05 Craig MacPhee 39 Ardencaple Drive Helensburgh G84 29-Mar-05 Graham Sutton 40 Frazer Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QP 29-Mar-05 K Leishman 39 Rhu Road Higher Helensburgh G84 8QH 29-Mar-05 L Leishman 39 Rhu Road Higher Helensburgh G84 8QH 29-Mar-05 Mr R Hamilton 16 Fraser Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QP 29-Mar-05 Mrs Sheila Mathers 6 Fraser Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QP 29-Mar-05 Mrs M McNeil 46 Ardencaple Drive Helensburgh G84 8PT 29-Mar-05 John McNeil 46 Ardencaple Drive Helensburgh G84 8PT 29-Mar-05 Neill Carslaw Brookfield Rhu Road Higher Helensburgh G84 8JR 30-Mar-05 Jackie Baillie MSP Constituency Office 125 College Street Dumbarton G82 30-Mar-05 Miss Mary Tudhope 20 Frazer Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QP 30-Mar-05 H Masterton 5 Rosebank Cottage Garelochhead Dunbartonshire 30-Mar-05


C

Mr L W Mouat 39 Cumberland Avenue Ardencaple Helensburgh G84 30-Mar-05 B Carroll Casita Rhu Road Higher Helensburgh G84 8JR 30-Mar-05 R Lane & Elizabeth Henry 14 Frazer Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QP 30-Mar-05 Mr And Mrs T A Evans 1 Mains Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QW 30-Mar-05 Mrs V Watkinson Clunes Rhu Road Higher Helensburgh G84 8JR 31-Mar-05 Arian And Bill Inglis Gareside Cottage Shandon Helensburgh G84 8NW 31-Mar-05 Mr And Mrs M Taheny 6 Bonar Law Avenue Helensburgh G84 8HD 31-Mar-05 J Rydall The Rowans 12A Queen Street Helensburgh 31-Mar-05 J Macintyre Bath House 131 East Princes Street Helensburgh G84 31-Mar-05 Findlay McQuarrie 6 Kathleen Park Helensburgh G84 8TH 01-Apr-05 April Wylie MA 5 Scotstoun Street Whiteinch Glasgow G14 0TA 01-Apr-05 James P Rogers 1 Cumberland Avenue Helensburgh 04-Apr-05 Gillian Rogers 1 Cumberland Avenue Helensburgh 04-Apr-05 Mr D E And Mrs B P Lewis 29 Ardencaple Drive Helensburgh G84 8PT 04-Apr-05 Ann R Leggat 45 Loch Drive Helensburgh G84 8PZ 05-Apr-05 Alastair Macbeth 40 West Montrose Street Helensburgh G84 9PF 05-Apr-05 Mrs J Mance 7 Cumberland Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QE 05-Apr-05 Mr H Mance 7 Cumberland Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QE 05-Apr-05 Mrs L J Thorndike 11 Cumberland Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QE 05-Apr-05 Michael V Leech 6 Dalmore Crescent Helensburgh G84 8JP 05-Apr-05 C F Leggat 45 Loch Drive Helensburgh G84 8PZ 05-Apr-05 Mrs A Brown 38 Ardencaple Drive Helensburgh G84 8PT 06-Apr-05 T Stewart Aitken FRICS 4 Sinclair Drive Helensburgh G84 9AZ 07-Apr-05 Helensburgh Community Council C/o Nigel Millar 28 George Street Helensburgh 07-Apr-05 Helensburgh And District Civic Society The Old Manse Shandon Helensburgh G84 8NP 11-Apr-05 Geraldine Whyte Kirkpark Cottages Church Road Rhu G84 8RW 12-Apr-05

Stan Latimer Chairman Helensburgh Community Woodlands Group) 17 Cumberland Avenue Helensburgh G84 12-Apr-05

J MacAuley 8 Summerhouse Summerhouse Darlington DL2 3OD 12-Apr-05 Helen Whyte 9 Broomieknowe Gardens Burnside Rutherglen G73 3 12-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 2 Troon Avenue East Kilbride G84 8TH 12-Apr-05 Louise Pope 26 Bullwood Avenue Crookston Glasgow G53 7PL 12-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 8 Frazer Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QP 12-Apr-05 Mrs P M Newton 69 East King Street Helensburgh G84 7RE 12-Apr-05 T G Milne 1 Hillview Drive Helensburgh G84 9BW 12-Apr-05 O M Salmond Hawksdale Church Avenue Cardross G82 5NS 12-Apr-05 P M Nisbet Tyrhiu Rhu By Helensburgh 12-Apr-05 G Laird 2/1 12 Salen Street Craigton Glasgow G52 1EB 12-Apr-05 P Kennedy Levenford Villa 17 Westbridgend Dumbarton G82 4AD 12-Apr-05 Mrs P Kennedy 17 West Bridgend Dumbarton G82 4AD 12-Apr-05 E Angus 6 Duchess Park Helensburgh 12-Apr-05 Cecelia Griffin Bridgend Portincaple By Garelochhead G84 12-Apr-05 J McCowan Auchendennan Farm Arden G83 8RB 12-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier Auchendennan Farm Arden G83 8RB 12-Apr-05 David McCowan Auchendennan Farm Arden G83 8RB 12-Apr-05 L Smart 126 East Princes Street Helensburgh G84 7DU 12-Apr-05 Ian Williams Kirkton Farm Cottage Darleith Road Cardross G82 5EL 12-Apr-05 D Carmichael 26 Cobbler View Arrochar 12-Apr-05


C

Tina Rickby Mambeg Farm Rahane G84 0QW 12-Apr-05 E Thomson 8 Craigrownie Gardens Kilcreggan G84 0HY 12-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 11 Lochranza Drive Helensburgh G84 9DY 12-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 2 Bruce Court Cardross G82 5QN 12-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 21 Smugglers Way Rhu G84 12-Apr-05 Liz Rutherford 83 East Princes Street Helensburgh 12-Apr-05 J M Govern 3 Gibson Drive Helensburgh 12-Apr-05 Mr John Simpson 3 Mitchell Drive Cardross G82 5EJ 12-Apr-05 D Stevens 175 Old Luss Road Helensburgh G84 7LR 12-Apr-05 Lois Galloway Burnshill Granville Street Helensburgh G84 7LI 12-Apr-05 E Colmer 11 Machrie Drive Helensburgh G84 9EJ 12-Apr-05 K White 4 West Abercromby Street Helensburgh G84 9LJ 12-Apr-05 R Joseph 5 Glenan Gardens West Argyle Street Helensburgh G84 12-Apr-05 Paul Thompson 3 Gareloch Brae Shandon G84 12-Apr-05 Sarah McHard 4 Upper Sutherland Crescent Helensburgh G84 9PQ 12-Apr-05 C Harrison-Grant 11 Eastwood Lane Helensburgh G84 7At 12-Apr-05 R J McInroy 12 Kennedy Drive Helensburgh G84 9AR 12-Apr-05 Pallwood Caladh-Phort Shore Road Garelochhead G84 0EL 12-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 4 Kennilworth Avenue Helensburgh G84 7JR 12-Apr-05 J Martin Daisybank Upper Cumberland Road Rhu 12-Apr-05 C Colmer 11 Machrie Drive Helensburgh G84 12-Apr-05 L Smith Ardenmohr Cottage Pier Road Rhu G84 8LH 12-Apr-05 D M Lans 9 Cumberland Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QE 12-Apr-05 Elisabeth A Dow 15 Cumberland Avenue Helensburgh G84 8LE 12-Apr-05 Frances Masceranhas 4 Cumberland Avenue Helensburgh G84 12-Apr-05 Alan And Elise Adamson 35 Loch Drive Helensburgh G84 8PZ 12-Apr-05 Margaret Spiers 15 Kidston Drive Helensburgh G84 8QB 12-Apr-05 Mrs E Taylor 35 Ardencaple Drive Helensburgh 12-Apr-05 Robert Wood Flat3 9 Cairndhu Gardens Helensburgh 12-Apr-05 James Anderson 9/3 Cairndhu Gardens Helensburgh 12-Apr-05 Elizabeth Brady 9/3 Cairndhu Gardens Helensburgh 12-Apr-05 Joan S Spencer Flat 5 9 Cairndhu Gardens Hlensburgh G84 8PG 12-Apr-05 Jessie Brookes 9/1 Cairndhu Gardens Helensburgh 12-Apr-05 Jean Kane 14 Guthrie Place Rhu G84 8RF 12-Apr-05 C Craig 9/2 Caindhu Gardens Helensburgh G84 12-Apr-05 Jonathan Stevenson 8 Cumberland Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QG 12-Apr-05 Mr And Mrs S Mennie 33 Ardencaple Drive Helensburgh G84 8PT 12-Apr-05 Allan And Elise Adamson 35 Loch Drive Helensburgh G84 8PZ 12-Apr-05 J B Bratt Greenoak 13 Ardencaple Drive Helensburgh 12-Apr-05 P Gibson 30 Dalmore Crescent Helensburgh 12-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 26 Dalmore Crescent Helensburgh G84 12-Apr-05 Doris McColl 2 Dalmore Crescent Helensburgh G84 8JP 12-Apr-05 William McColl 2 Dalmore Crescent Helensburgh G84 8JP 12-Apr-05 Pat McGinley 4 Dalmore Crescent Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 18 Dalmore Crescent Helensburgh G84 8JP 13-Apr-05 Linda Meiklejohn 10 Dalmore Crescent Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 G Meiklejohn 10 Dalmore Crescent Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 A McGinley 2 Castle Avenue Helensburgh 13-Apr-05 S Taylor 47 Millig Street Helensburgh G84 9PN 13-Apr-05


C

S M Alexander 20 Lever Road Helensburgh G84 9DP 13-Apr-05 Mrs G R Walker 98 East Princes Street Helensburgh 13-Apr-05 Sheila Dunn 60 Abercromby Crescent Helensburgh G84 9DX 13-Apr-05 Elizabeth M Hoare Redcliffe 1a Sinclair Drive Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 E Ashton 19 Macleod Drive Helensburgh G84 9QS 13-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 19 East King Street Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 Aileen Baird 234 West Princes Street Helensburgh G84 8HA 13-Apr-05 S MacKinlay 8 Paterson Drive Helensburgh G84 9QY 13-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier Knockderry Lodge Barbour Road Cove G84 0PG 13-Apr-05 S Cashmore 7 Albert Terrace Victoria Road Helensburgh G84 7RY 13-Apr-05 K Bolt 20 Baird Avenue Helensburgh G84 8DW 13-Apr-05 J Lyon 20 Crawford Drive Helensburgh G84 9BL 13-Apr-05 Alison Lyon 115 West King Street Helensburgh G84 8DQ 13-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier Ardmore View 72 East Clyde Street Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 S MacLachlan 25 Bain Crescent Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 Charlotte Gregor Clachan Bridge Cottage Rosneath G84 0RG 13-Apr-05 Mrs R Brown 43 Barrs Road Cardross G82 5PR 13-Apr-05 Irene Hensman 13 Pladda Way Helensburgh G84 9SE 13-Apr-05 J A Dow 15 Cumberland Avenue Helensburgh G84 8LE 13-Apr-05 Barbara E Dow 15 Cumberland Avenue Helensburgh G84 8LE 13-Apr-05 Chrystal Wylie 8 Paterson Drive Helensburgh G84 9QY 13-Apr-05 A Jamieson 61 East King Street Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 M M Booth 11 Ardencaple Drive Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 P D Booths 11 Ardencaple Drive Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 W And G Willow 21 Kidston Drive Helensburgh G84 8QB 13-Apr-05 Joanna Dunbar Rees Rosedale Gardens Helensburgh 13-Apr-05 J Johnston Woodlea 5 Kathleen Park Helensburgh G84 8TH 13-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 4 Kathleen Park Helensburgh 13-Apr-05 L Hanson 45 Cumberland Avenue Helensburgh 13-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 10 Kathleen Park Helensburgh 13-Apr-05 C C Goodall 12 Ardencaple Drive Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 15 Machrie Drive Helensburgh G84 9EJ 13-Apr-05 P Latimer 15 Machrie Drive Helensburgh G84 9EJ 13-Apr-05 Cathrine Quinlan 3 Strathclyde Court Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 Geoffrey L Pickard 5 Cumberland Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QA 13-Apr-05 Jean H Pickard 5 Cumberland Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QE 13-Apr-05 F Mochal Arlington 5a Sutherland Street Helensburgh G84 8EN 13-Apr-05 D Walker 4 Victoria Road Helensburgh G84 7RT 13-Apr-05 Margaret McKenzie 3 Cumberland Avenue Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 D E Mochal Arlington 5a Sutherland Street Helensburgh G84 8EE 13-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 3 Cumberland Avenue Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 George Robertson 6 Mains Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QW 13-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 4 Mains Avenue Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 R Dundas 7 Mains Avenue Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 5 Mains Avenue Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 L Munro 15 Empress Drive Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 47 Mains Avenue Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 G D'Agostino 126 West Princes Street Helensburgh 13-Apr-05 Gina D’Agostino 126 West Princes Street Helensburgh


C

P Jones 29 Johnston Court Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 Mrs O'Donnell 33 Mains Avenue Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 Billy Gilmour 35 Mains Avenue Helensburgh 13-Apr-05 J Craig 21 Mains Avenue Helensburgh 13-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 17 Mains Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QW 13-Apr-05 C Cook 47 Loch Drive Helensburgh 13-Apr-05 L A Cook 47 Loch Drive Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 Ian MacLead 221 East Clyde Street Helensburgh 13-Apr-05 M Paterson 11 MacLeod Drive Helensburgh G84 9QS 13-Apr-05 M McLean 14 Rhuellen Court Rhu G84 8SD 13-Apr-05 Carol Reid 33a Campbell Street Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 Catherine Hood 39 Charlotte Street Helensburgh G84 7SE 13-Apr-05 Ina Colquhoun 53D West King Street Helensburgh 13-Apr-05 Rosemary McGinley 10 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh G84 8DR 13-Apr-05 Mr And Mrs S Kay 23D John Street Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 12 East Lennox Drive Helensburgh 13-Apr-05 Ailsa Mocky 50 Mcleod Drive Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 Mary Latimer 17 Cumberland Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QE 13-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 7 Strathclyde Place Helensburgh G84 8DN 13-Apr-05 E Laird 114 Drumfork Road Helensburgh G84 7TY 13-Apr-05 Mrs A Douglas 26 Havelock Place Helensburgh G84 7AJ 13-Apr-05 C McCallan High Westerton Station Road Shandon G84 8NX 13-Apr-05 Mr J Robinson 161 Hawthornhill Road Dumbarton G82 5JL 13-Apr-05 Margaret Lauder 31 Barclay Drive Helensburgh G84 9RA 13-Apr-05 Mr And Mrs David Ross 19 Frazer Avenue Helensburgh G84 8Qp 13-Apr-05 F Tierney 23 Napier Avenue Cardross 13-Apr-05 J Mckenzie 22 Baird Avenue Helensburgh G84 8DW 13-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier Hilltown Glenoran Road Helensburgh 13-Apr-05 G McGuinn 11 Adelaide Street Helensburgh 13-Apr-05 M Lyon 12 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh 13-Apr-05 Rona MacDonald 46 West Princes Street Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 6 Hanover Street Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 M Diaper 35 Crawford Drive Helensburgh 13-Apr-05 Jean Cairns 74 Sinclair Street Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 Jessica Smith 1A West King Street Helensburgh G84 8UN 13-Apr-05 E Yule 11 Campbell Street Helensburgh 13-Apr-05 M McTurk 61 Hillside Road Cardross 13-Apr-05 Sheila Hipkin 2 Campbell Drive Helensburgh 13-Apr-05 Wilma Hanlon 125A East Princes Street Helensburgh 13-Apr-05 Rev. Terence Friel 66 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh G84 8DR 13-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 2 Upper Adelaide Street Helensburgh 13-Apr-05 Alexander Johnston No Address Supplied 13-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 66 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh G84 Owner/Occupier 66 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05 Franusco Amosiotequi Flat G1 28 Lethington Avenue Glasgow G41 3HY 13-Apr-05 A Cradosshank 14 Lyndale Road Maryhill Glasgow G20 0JS 13-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 15 Queens Point Shandon G84 8QS 13-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 15 Hornbean Drive Clydebank G81 3PJ 13-Apr-05 M Matheson 7 Larchfield Colquhoun Street Helensburgh G84 13-Apr-05


C

S Forsyth 47 Montgomery Avenue Coatbridge ML5 1QS 13-Apr-05 R Fairley 40 Riddrie Knowes Glasgow G33 2QH 13-Apr-05 Bryan Fleming 2 Seton Terrace Dennistoun Glasgow G31 2HU 13-Apr-05 Lucy Byrne 146 Spruce Road Abronhill Cumbernauld G67 3DS 13-Apr-05 L Wojciechowska 41 The Mooring Paisley PA2 9BD 13-Apr-05 George Foster 8 McNiven Court Stonehouse Larkhall ML9 3 DY 13-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 55 Pochart Crescent Polmont FK2 0RE 13-Apr-05 J Greig And C Greig 31 Ardencaple Drive Helensburgh G84 8PT 13-Apr-05 Tom Greig And Family 454 Kilmarnock Road Newlands Glasgow G43 2RL 13-Apr-05 Helen K MacLeod 2 Kidston Drive Helensburgh G84 8QA 13-Apr-05 Kenina MacLeod 2/8 Hood Court Helensburgh 13-Apr-05 Sonia MacLeod 2 Kidston Drive Helensburgh G84 8QA 13-Apr-05 Rosemary Cox 5 Kidston Drive Helensburgh 13-Apr-05 J L Cox 5 Kidston Drive Helensburgh 13-Apr-05 Rosemary Stevenson 8 Cumberland Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QG 13-Apr-05 John F Stirling 15 Duchess Drive Helensburgh G84 9PR 14-Apr-05 M Malan No Address Given 14-Apr-05 W Malan No Address Given 14-Apr-05

John Riley Burnside Cottage Lower Station Road Tyndrum Perthshire FK20 8RY 14-Apr-05

Catriona Malan 36a James Street Helensburgh G84 8UH 14-Apr-05 D Irvine 9 West Argyle Street Helensburgh G84 8UU 14-Apr-05 Delia D Irvine 9 West Argyle Street Helensburgh G84 8UU 14-Apr-05 J S Craig 27 Kennedy Drive Helensburgh G84 9AR 14-Apr-05 Elizabeth Hamilton 7 Lomond Court Helensburgh G84 7PY 14-Apr-05 S Bosworth 27 Stuart Drive Drymen G63 0BZ 14-Apr-05 Stan Latimer 17 Cumberland Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QE 14-Apr-05 Moira Brodie 9 Drumfork Road Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Robert Brodie 9 Drumfork Road Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Winnie Power 188 West Princes Street Helensburgh G84 8HA 14-Apr-05 A Finlayson 60 Maitland Court Helensburgh G84 14-Apr-05 M Kenmuir 105 West Princes Street Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 G W Kenmuir The Shire Church Road Rhu G84 8RW 14-Apr-05 Julie Cavana 7 Frazer Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QP 14-Apr-05 A Leitch 10 Frazer Avenue Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 R Leitch 10 Frazer Avenue Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Mr S McEwan 1 Frazer Avenue Ardencaple Helensburgh G84 8QP 14-Apr-05 Mrs Patterson 11 Frazer Avenue Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Lynn McEwan 1 Fraser Avenue Ardencaple Estate Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Mr S McEwan 1 Fraser Avenue Ardencaple Estate Helensburgh G84 14-Apr-05 Mr L McEwan 1 Fraser Avenue Ardencaple Estate Helensburgh G84 14-Apr-05 A McEwan 1 Fraser Avenue Ardencaple Estate Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 R Mathers 6 Frazer Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QP 14-Apr-05 R C Mathers 6 Frazer Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QP 14-Apr-05 Catriona Mathers 6 Frazer Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QP 14-Apr-05 E Mathers 6 Frazer Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QP 14-Apr-05 J Lunet 8 Frazer Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QP 14-Apr-05 S Lunet 8 Frazer Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QP 14-Apr-05 Ronald Reid Woodburn Cottage Argyll Road Kilcreggan 14-Apr-05


C

Kay Murrary 14 Lochbview Ardpeaton Helensburgh G84 0PF 14-Apr-05 J McGrath And L McGrath 5 Frazer Avenue Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 A Whitehead Alba Voyager Rhu Marina Rhu 14-Apr-05 Chris Turner 5 Redcliffe Gardens Helensburgh G84 9JJ 14-Apr-05 McDonagh Campbell Street Helensburgh G84 8BG 14-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 2 Fruin Lane The Hermiatge Helensburgh G84 7SY 14-Apr-05 Michelle Murrary 10 Duncan Road Helensburgh G84 9DH 14-Apr-05 Kim Dall 31 Drumfork Road Helensburgh G84 7TN 14-Apr-05 Anita Williams 89 Kent Drive Helensburgh G84 9RU 14-Apr-05 Linda Camellish 4 Tallisman Crescent Helensburgh G84 7TD 14-Apr-05 C D Street 2 Machrie Drive Helensburgh G84 9EJ 14-Apr-05 Mrs E A Street 2 Machrie Drive Helensburgh G84 9EJ 14-Apr-05 W Butler 6 Strathclyde Place Helensburgh G84 8DN 14-Apr-05 Jean G Butler 6 Strathclyde Place Helensburgh G84 8Dn 14-Apr-05 Elizabeth Hatton 6 Rhu House Main Road Rhu Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 John Williams 11 Braeside Drive Bellsmyre Dumbarton 14-Apr-05 I Kenmuir The Shire Church Road Rhu Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Linda Robertson 36 Loch Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Anne Thomson 50a Campbell Street Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Ross MacLachlan 25 Bain Crescent Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Ann Morrison 22 West Montrose Street Helensburgh G84 9NF 14-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier Fairfield 5 West Abercromby Street Helensburgh G84 14-Apr-05 G Patterson 3 Courtai Avenue Helensburgh G84 8EP 14-Apr-05 High Scott 18 Barclay Drive Helensburgh G84 9RB 14-Apr-05 M Mitchell 14 Barrs Terrace Cardross G82 5PP 14-Apr-05 Donald Y Womack Rockburn School Road G84 0HN 14-Apr-05 Christina Bryden 146 East King Street Helensburgh G84 7BP 14-Apr-05 Isobel Elliott Westlands Shore Road Ardpeaton Cove Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 J Bernard 12 Talisman Crescent Helensburgh G84 7TD 14-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 1 Ardmore View 72 East Clyde Street Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 A Thompson 65 Malcolm Place Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Neil M MacLeod 20 Havelock Place Helensburgh G84 7HJ 14-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 20 Chapelacre Grove Helensburgh G84 7SH 14-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 44 Campbell Street Helensburgh G84 8XZ 14-Apr-05 K Edwards Lagarie Cottage Torwoodhill Road Rhu Helensburgh G84 14-Apr-05 Catherine Wright 30 Clarnish Balloch G83 8SE 14-Apr-05 A S Law 23 Loch Drive Helensburgh G84 8PY 14-Apr-05 Helena J Monteith Croftland 8 Kidston Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Margaret S Edwards 13 Loch Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 7 Loch Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Andrew Galbraith And Karen Fraser 2 McAuley Place Helensburgh G84 8PR 14-Apr-05 M Ferguson 1 McAulay Place Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 A Stevenson 6 Cairndhu Avenue Helensburgh G84 8PW 14-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 2E Cairndhu Avenue Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 S Milne 2d Cairndhu Avenue Helensburgh G84 8PW 14-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 2b Cairndhu Avenue Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 17 Loch Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 2A Cairndhu Avenue Helensburgh G84 8PW 14-Apr-05


C

John Phillips 30 Loch Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Liz Phillips 30 Loch Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 E Livingstone 26 Loch Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Greta Allen 24 Loch Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Michael Allen 24 Loch Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 David W Burnett 20 Loch Drive Helensburgh G84 8PY 14-Apr-05 E Burnett 20 Loch Drive Helensburgh G84 8PY 14-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 16 Loch Drive Helensburgh G84 8PY 14-Apr-05 Mr Black 8 Loch Drive Helensburgh G84 8PY 14-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 4 Loch Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 4 Loch Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Eleanor F Milne 1 Hillview Drive Helensburhg G84 9BW 14-Apr-05 Frank McCrachan 207 East Clyde Street Helensburgh G84 7AP 14-Apr-05 Chanter 9 Butt Avenue Helensburgh G84 9DA 14-Apr-05 Iain Paterson Guithas Cottage Glen Croe Arrochar G83 7AS 14-Apr-05 Jean Turner 23 Malcolm Place Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Rosemary Lawson 92 East King Street Helensburgh G84 7RE 14-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 62 Camperdown Court Helensburgh G84 9JH 14-Apr-05 A Groves Altair 6 Middleton Drive Craigendoran Helensburgh G8 14-Apr-05 Louise Elliott 6 Colquhoun Square Helensburgh G84 8AD 14-Apr-05 Aileen Crolla A1 Camis Eskan House Helensburgh G84 7JZ 14-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier Bookworms 7 East Clyde Street Helensburgh G84 7NY 14-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 9 Corrie Place Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Carole Carman 4 Kidston Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 L Williams 15 Talisman Crescent Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 David Elliott 24 Jutland Court Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 J Carson 3 Caldwell Place Rhu Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier No Address Given 14-Apr-05 Y Macleod Brookvale Shore Road Cove 14-Apr-05 Pamela Oliver 1E Nursery Street Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 L Reeve 6 McColl Walk Garelochhead G84 0BP 14-Apr-05 Linda Partidge The Glen 21 Victoria Road Helensburgh G84 7RT 14-Apr-05 Moira Hyatt 4 Glebefield Road Rhu G84 8SZ 14-Apr-05 C Ferrier 37 Baird Avenue Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 C Gallacher 31 Baird Avenue Helensburgh G84 8DW 14-Apr-05 W Beeson 21 Baird Avenue Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 J McKenzie 19 Baird Avenue Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Tom Jones 29 Johnson Court Helensburgh G84 7LJ 14-Apr-05 M Cudby 1 Rosslyn Terrace Maitland Street Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Barbara Stones 1E Nursery Street Helensburgh G84 7DZ 14-Apr-05 Robert B Mair 28 Baird Avenue Helensburgh G84 8DW 14-Apr-05 Mrs Hunter 32 Baird Avenue Helensburgh G84 8DW 14-Apr-05 Mrs Catherine Campbell 35 Baird Avenue Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 H Lafferty 23F Baird Avenue Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 J Lafferty 23F Baird Avenue Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Janet Hamilton 21D Baird Avenue Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 J Morton 4 Cove Place Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 H Scullion 1D Rosneath Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 F Steele 1A Rosneath Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05


C

Jospeh J Jordan 1B Rosneath Drive Helensburgh G84 �DP 14-Apr-05 D Clark 26 Baird Avenue Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Janette Mair 28 Baird Avenue Helensburgh G84 14-Apr-05 Elizabeth M Campbell 1 Kidston Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 7B Edward Drive Helensburgh G84 9QR 14-Apr-05 David Tipple 4 Frazer Avenue Ardencaple G84 8QP 14-Apr-05 Dorothy Robertson 17B Baird Avenue Helensburgh G84 9HW 14-Apr-05 Niall Nawrocki 4F Rosneath Drive Helensburgh G84 8DP 14-Apr-05 Fay Fairley 4E Rosneath Drive Helensburgh G84 8DP 14-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 4c Rosneath Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Claire McCormack 20 Lynn Walk Garelochhead G84 0DS 14-Apr-05 D Harper 4A Rosneath Drive Helensburgh G84 8DP 14-Apr-05 Mrs L Johnston 3B Rosneath Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 E Urquhart 3A Rosneath Drive Helensburgh G84 8DP 14-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 1E Rosneath Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Margaret Campbell 2 Rosneath Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 P Robertson Cairndhu Lodge Helensburgh G84 8PH 14-Apr-05 Peter Campbell 1 Kidston Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 M Smith 2 Rosneath Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 B Johnston 2 Rosneath Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 D Johnston 2 Rosneath Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 J Graham 2E Rosneath Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Walter Cameron 4 Kidston Drive Helensburgh G84 8QA 14-Apr-05 R J Fowler 6 Cairndhu Gardens Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 O Stewart 4 Cairndhu Gardens Helensburgh G84 8PG 14-Apr-05 J Ross 11 Kidston Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 A Cordell 12 Kidston Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 P C Penman 13 Kidston Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 7 Kidston Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 I Graham 12 Albert Drive Helensburgh G84 7HF 14-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 114 West King Street Helensburgh G84 8DQ 14-Apr-05 E Ross 11 Kidston Drive Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 David A Ross 19 Frazer Avenue Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Mrs A McGivern 1 Frazer Avenue Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 K Armstrong 3 Frazer Avenue Helensburgh 14-Apr-05 Mrs K Siddle 12 Duchess Drive Helensburgh G84 9PY 15-Apr-05 Marion And Ian Gillies Duchalis 42 William Street Helensburgh G84 8XX 15-Apr-05 F Hanney 129 West Princes Street Helensburgh G84 8EX 15-Apr-05 J R McKenzie 99 West Princes Street Helensburgh G84 8BH 18-Apr-05 Eddie Hart 20 Chapelacre Grove Helensburgh G84 7SH 18-Apr-05 Peter Davies Chesterhill 66 James Street Helensburgh G84 9LF 18-Apr-05 M Kinloch 46 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 J McTeague 48 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Veronique Bonnelane 32 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh G84 8DR 18-Apr-05 E McTeague 48 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Mubarka Khatoon 50 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 J Falconer 56 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh G84 8DR 18-Apr-05 Mary Sharkey 19D Eastfield Crescent Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Chris Wardle 68 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh G84 8DR 18-Apr-05


C

Miss M Mundie 52 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh G84 8DR 18-Apr-05 Mrs M T Cairney 44 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh G84 8DR 18-Apr-05 Mr T Cairney 44 Ardencaple Qudrant Helensburgh G84 8DR 18-Apr-05 Denis Cairney 106 Bonhill Road Dumbarton G82 2DX 18-Apr-05 Jan K Marley 76 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Mrs A Spy 72 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh G84 8DR 18-Apr-05 Suzanne Wardle 68 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh G84 8DR 18-Apr-05 W Dickson 35 Garshake Road Dumbarton G82 3LE 18-Apr-05 Linda Hunter 58c Whiteford Road Dumbarton G82 3JD 18-Apr-05 E Murray 64 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh G84 8DR 18-Apr-05 M Murray 64 Ardencaple Road Helensburgh G84 8DR 18-Apr-05 Walter Stewart And C Averill 22 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh G74 5JQ 18-Apr-05 Mrs C Averill 22 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh G84 8DR 18-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 20 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 K McCrea 20 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Mrs Christine Byrd 15B West Argyle Street Helensburgh G84 8UU 18-Apr-05 M Mackenzie 18 Ardencaple Drive Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 A C Mackenzie 18 Ardencaple Drive Helensburgh G84 8PS 18-Apr-05 Ian Brown 47 Napier Avenue Cardross G82 5JH 18-Apr-05 R Reading 8 Stafford Street Helensburgh G84 9JU 18-Apr-05 T C Lamb Rhu Cottage Ferry Road Rhu Helensburgh G84 8NF 18-Apr-05 Mr G Betts 20 Baird Avenue Helensburgh G84 8DW 18-Apr-05 Margaret G Hendrie 4 Hanover Street Helensburgh G84 7HL 18-Apr-05 Mr D Keir 20 Baird Avenue Helensburgh G84 8DW 18-Apr-05 Mr D Smith 20 Baird Avenue Helensburgh G84 8DW 18-Apr-05 A S Young 160/8 West King Street Helensburgh G84 8DT 18-Apr-05 A Smith 10 Inchkeith Avenue Dundee DD5 24S 18-Apr-05 K Betts 65 Millstroun Crescent Paisley PA11 1RG 18-Apr-05 Elizabeth K Sinclair 4 Glenan Gardens Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 R Doig 6 Sunningdale Place Helensburgh G84 7JB 18-Apr-05 G Wylie 33 Barclay Drive Helensburgh G84 9RA 18-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 15B Buchanan Road Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 M E M Cooper 160/10 West King Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Sarah M Macklin 160/12 West King Street Helensburgh G84 8DT 18-Apr-05 Mick McGourlay 160/12 West King Street Helensburgh G84 8DT 18-Apr-05 M Macklin 160/12 West King Street Helensburgh G84 8DT 18-Apr-05 Tina Smith Flat 6 160 West King Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 5 Armstrong Road Helensburgh G84 7UE 18-Apr-05 Mr R D Baker 5 Armstrong Road Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 160/5 West King Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Michael Cluer 160/5 West King Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 John Delaney 160/1 West King Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Sarah Ingram 160/7 West King Street Helensburgh G84 8DT 18-Apr-05 N Wilson 158/10 West King Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 69 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Hugh Ward 126 West King Street Helensburgh G84 8DH 18-Apr-05 Andrew Falconer 126 West King Street Helensburgh G84 8DH 18-Apr-05 Jenny Falconer 126 West King Street Helensburgh G84 8DH 18-Apr-05 Miss C MacLure 3 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh G84 8DR 18-Apr-05


C

F P MacDonald 5 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Janet MacDonald 5 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Emma Craig 14 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 M MacDougall 18 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Mrs Fiona Baxter 16 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh G84 8DR 18-Apr-05 R Miller 24 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 H Stenhouse 34 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 John Sharkey 129 West King Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Rita Sharkey 129 West King Street Helensburgh G84 8DH 18-Apr-05 J Sharkey 129 West King Street Helensburgh G84 8DH 18-Apr-05 E Thomson 127 West King Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Mrs C Connelly 125 West King Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Mark Waugh 121 West King Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 T Willis 95 West King Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 C Benst 11 Sutherland Street Helensburgh G84 8EW 18-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 13 Sutherland Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 David Andrews 15 Sutherland Street Helensburgh G84 8EW 18-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 17 Sutherland Street Helensburgh G84 8EW 18-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 22 Sutherland Street Helensburgh G84 8EW 18-Apr-05 K Stocks 14 Sutherland Street Helensburgh G84 8EW 18-Apr-05 A G Stocks 14 Sutherland Street Helensburgh G84 8EW 18-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier Kossington 10 Sutherland Street Helesnburgh G84 8EW 18-Apr-05 Roger P H Green 170 West Princes Street Helensburgh G84 8EY 18-Apr-05 Anne M Green 170 West Princes Street Helensburgh G84 8EY 18-Apr-05 Jean Howie 8 Sutherland Place Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Alan Day 4 Sutherland Place Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Audrey Day 4 Sutherland Place Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier Glyndale 6 McKenzie Drive Balloch G83 8HL 18-Apr-05 M Bateman 2 Sutherland Place Helensburgh G84 8BF 18-Apr-05 C Marrison 6 Sutherland Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Mrs Foster 4 Sutherland Street Helensburgh G84 8EN 18-Apr-05 M Carroll Casita Rhu Road Higher Helensburgh G84 8JR 18-Apr-05 B Carroll Casita Rhu Road Higher Helensburgh G84 8JR 18-Apr-05 Miss Linda Burrell 145 Feorlin Way Garelochhead G84 0BE 18-Apr-05 Graham Paterson 6 Princes Street Campbeltown PA28 6DX 18-Apr-05 Arthur Finlay 128 Mingulay Street Milton Glasgow G22 7DH 18-Apr-05 Tom McAuley Camdamora Church Road Arrochar G83 6AB 18-Apr-05 Nigel Brendan Burns 158/12 West King Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Linda Lamington 130 West King Street Helensburgh G84 8DJ 18-Apr-05 Joe Ward 25 Barrs Road Cardross 18-Apr-05 Mr Jamie Wrethman 2 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh G84 8DR 18-Apr-05 Mrs J Wrethman 2 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh G84 8DR 18-Apr-05 Lisa Smith 132 West King Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Danielle Pearson 3 Lineside Walk Rhu Helensburgh G84 8JH 18-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 132 West King Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 132 West King Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 132 West King Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 A Chalmer 132 West King Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Douglas McGugan 136 West King Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05


C

Fiona Black 136 West King Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Stephen Merrigan 140 West King Street Helensburgh G84 8DJ 18-Apr-05 J M Queen 148 West King Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Carol McGourlay 150 West King Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Alison Butler 6 Strathclyde Place Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Doreen McLean 23 Waverley Avenue Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 E Doig 6 Sunningdale Place Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 R E Petrie 50 Loch Drive Helensburgh G84 8PZ 18-Apr-05 A Stenhouse 144 West King Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 J P Hanning 6 Waverely Avenue Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 K Stenhouse 144 West King Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 7 Sutherland Street Helensburgh G84 8EN 18-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 1 Sutherland Place Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 A Gardner 4 Courtrai Avenue Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 9 Sutherland Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Isobel Turnball 139 West Princes Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 143 West Princes Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 J Taylor 210 West Princes Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 212 West Princes Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 J Crawford 157 West Princes Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 A C Watson 19 Ferniegair Avenue Helensburgh G84 8HB 18-Apr-05 J Smith 240 West Princes Street Helensburgh G84 8HA 18-Apr-05 David Speed 153 West Princes Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 A C Dickson 238 West Princes Street Helensburgh G84 8HA 18-Apr-05 Iain Baird 234 West Princes Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 A M Eaton 236 West Princes Street Helensburgh G84 8HA 18-Apr-05 J L Eaton 236 West Princes Street Helensburgh G84 8HA 18-Apr-05 K Davis 232 West Princes Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 J Davis 232 West Princes Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Margaret Horrell 222 West Princes Street Helensburgh G84 8HA 18-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 218 West Princes Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 D M Saville 216 West Princes Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 E Blackwell 18 Bonar Law Avenue Helensburgh G84 8HD 18-Apr-05 J K Blackwell 18 Bonar Law Avenue Helensburgh G84 8HD 18-Apr-05 Robert King-Clark Amberwood Shandon Helensburgh G84 8NP 18-Apr-05 Jean King-Clark Amberwood Shandon Helensburgh G84 8NP 18-Apr-05 J S Martin 5 Bonar Law Avenue Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier Northborne Ferniegair Avenue Helensburgh G84 8HB 18-Apr-05 A Stewart 2 Ferniegair Avenue Helensburgh G84 8HB 18-Apr-05 Angela D Stewart 2 Ferniegair Avenue Helensburgh G84 8HB 18-Apr-05 G Fleming 12 Courthill Rosneath Helensburgh G84 0RW 18-Apr-05 John And Barbara Gilchrist Flat 8 Larchfield Colquhoun Street Helensburgh G84 9JG 18-Apr-05 Kim Moore 1/5 Hood Court Helensburgh G84 8DS 18-Apr-05 E Kirkby Flat 9 158 West King Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Alexis Waddell 158/11 West King Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 E O'Donnell 158/4 West King Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 S Johnston 40 Johnson Court Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 C J Clark 2/3 Hood Court Helensburgh G84 8DS 18-Apr-05 E Clark 2/3 Hood Court Helensburgh G84 8DS 18-Apr-05


C

Mr And Mrs McMurdo 2/5 Hood Court Ardencaple Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Lynda Paterson 2-2 Hood Court Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Mr W McRae 2/6 Hood Court Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 S Cavant 3/3 Hood Court Helensburgh G84 8DS 18-Apr-05 Struan Robertson 3/12 Hood Court Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Mr A Orr 3/10 Hood Court Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 A Millar 2/3 Hood COurt Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 L Charlton 2/12 Hood Court Helensburgh G84 8DS 18-Apr-05 Patricia Duffy Flat 2 158 West King Street Helensburgh G84 8DT 18-Apr-05 Damian Duffy Flat 2 158 West King Street Helensburgh G84 8DT 18-Apr-05 C Traynor 3/1 Hood Court Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 G Traynor 3/1 Hood Court Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 R Traynor 3/1 Hood Court Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 2/11 Hood Court Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 2/4 Hood COurt Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Catherine Bellah 2/10 Hood Court Helensburgh G84 8DS 18-Apr-05 Mr D Wedgeworth 158/1 West King Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Mrs M Wedgeworth 158/1 West King Street Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 1/9 Hood Court Helensburgh 18-Apr-05 Ewan Latimer 96 Grovepark Street Glasgow G20 7JQ 18-Apr-05 Graham MacDougall 32 Stewartville Street Partick Glasgow G11 5PJ 18-Apr-05 Byron Latimer Aros-Ard Grosvenor Crescent Connel Argyll 18-Apr-05 Iain Latimer 96 Grovepark Street Glasgow 18-Apr-05 Peter Smith 4 Lismore Crescent Dunollie Oban 18-Apr-05 Mrs J A Call 6 Courtrai Avenue Helensburgh G84 8EP 19-Apr-05 H J Sykes 16 Dalmore Crescent Helensburgh G84 8JP 19-Apr-05 N Graham 47 Hillhead Street Glasgow G12 8QA 19-Apr-05 Mr James C Paton 163 Orchard Park Avenue Giffnock Glasgow G46 7BW 19-Apr-05 Mrs Susan Paton Planetree Cottage Portincaple Garelochhead Helensburgh 19-Apr-05 Mrs D MacNab Planetree Cottage Portincaple Helensburgh G84 0ET 19-Apr-05 William B Watson Rockmount Portincaple By Garelochhead G84 0EY 19-Apr-05 Robert R Smith Struan Teighness Arrochar G83 7AQ 19-Apr-05 Shelley Spencer 17 Greenwood Road Clarkston Glasgow G76 7AF 19-Apr-05 Claire Appelquist Anchorage Old School Road Garelochhead G84 0AY 19-Apr-05 E Macaulay No Address 19-Apr-05 G E Skingley 9 Ferniegair Avenue Helensburgh G84 8HB 19-Apr-05 A N MacInnes Ashford Upper Glenfinlas Street Helensburgh G84 7HE 20-Apr-05 J M Christy No Address 20-Apr-05 Illegible No Address 20-Apr-05 Maureen Leaf 3 Sinclair Drive Helensburgh G84 20-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier Cedarholm 20 Millig Street Helensburgh 20-Apr-05 Alistair Wylie Cedarholm 20 Millig Street Helensburgh G84 20-Apr-05 R Armitage No Address Supplied 21-Apr-05 Mr A Morris 19 Torrninch Drive Balloch G83 8JL 21-Apr-05 Mrs C Grant 18A Upper Glenfinlas Street Helensburgh G84 7HD 21-Apr-05 I Grant 18A Upper Glenfinlas Street Helensburgh 21-Apr-05 R Chesher 19 Dalmore Crescent Helensburgh G84 8JP 21-Apr-05 R Van Runkel Camis Eskan House Helensburgh G84 7JL 21-Apr-05 Mr F Steel 74 Ardencaple Quardrant Helensburgh G84 8DR 22-Apr-05


C

Mrs Steel 74 Ardencaple Quadrant Helensburgh G84 8DR 22-Apr-05

Mr Latimer Chairman Helensburgh Community Woodland Group 17 Cumberland Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QE 25-Apr-05

Mr K D Griffiths 4 Kent Drive Churchill Helensburgh G84 9RP 25-Apr-05 Fiona Chalmers 19 Campbell Street Helensburgh G84 8BQ 25-Apr-05 David Robertson 38 Loch Drive Helensburgh G84 8PZ 25-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 10 Paterson Drive Helensburgh G84 9QY 25-Apr-05 M Winton 1 Paterson Drive Helensburgh G84 9QY 25-Apr-05 D M Stalker Glenburn Cottage Shore Road Clynder G84 25-Apr-05 N Peden 29 Craigrownie Gardens Kilcreggan G84 0HY 25-Apr-05 E Sanderson 5 Paterson Drive Helensburgh G84 9QY 25-Apr-05 P Miller 60 East King Street Helensburgh G84 7QR 25-Apr-05 Elizabeth MacLaren 4 Kildonan Drive Helensburgh G84 9SA 25-Apr-05 Isobel Jones Clarendale Main Road Garelochhead G84 0EG 25-Apr-05 A B Costello 6 Bannachra Drive Helensburgh G84 8DF 25-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 7 MacLeod Crescent Helensburgh G84 9QX 25-Apr-05 Martyn Ross 9 MacLeod Crescent Helensburgh 25-Apr-05 C C Finn 11 MacLeod Crescent Helensburgh G84 9QX 25-Apr-05 Mr J Sawyer 13 MacLeod Crescent Helensburgh 25-Apr-05 Mrs J MacPherson 15 McLeod Crescent Helensburgh G84 9QX 25-Apr-05 M Ferguson 16 Paterson Drive Helensburgh G84 9QY 25-Apr-05 Mr And Mrs Ferguson 16 Paterson Drive Helenburgh G84 9QY 25-Apr-05 Margaret Roberts 12 Paterson Drive Helensburgh 25-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 14 Paterson Drive Helensburgh G84 9QY 25-Apr-05 J Shilp 68 Coulport Place Helensburgh 25-Apr-05 Mrs Catherine Shilp 68 Coulport Place Helensburgh G84 8TL 25-Apr-05 Rosaleen Bray 96 West King Street Helensburgh 25-Apr-05 N Bray 96 West King Street Helensburgh 25-Apr-05 E Buist 100 West King Street Helensburgh G84 8EQ 25-Apr-05 C McLaren Strathcona 116 West King Street Helensburgh 25-Apr-05 P Mckay 118 West King Street Helensburgh G84 8oQ 25-Apr-05 B McKay 118 West King Street Helensburgh G84 8DQ 25-Apr-05 R Foy Woodneuk 120 West King Street Helensburgh G84 8DQ 25-Apr-05 L Coyle 137 West King Street Helensburgh G84 25-Apr-05 J Coyle 137 West King Street Helensburgh 25-Apr-05 G G Coyle 137 West King Street Helensburgh 25-Apr-05 Andrea M Hunt 119 West King Street Helensburgh 25-Apr-05 Sheila Wilson 66 Campbell Street Helensburgh G84 9QN 25-Apr-05 Miss J A Peart Flat G 23 John Street Helensburgh G84 8XL 25-Apr-05 Laura M Cowan 19 Bannachra Drive Helensburgh G84 25-Apr-05 A Roders 23 Bannachra Drive Helensburgh 25-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 1 Bannachra Drive Helensburgh G84 25-Apr-05 Amanda McDonald 17 Parkvale Way Erskine 25-Apr-05 C R Parkes Kinnoul Drymen Road Balloch 25-Apr-05

Owner/Occupier 16 Normanhurst Court 124 West King Street Helensburgh G84 8Dhj 25-Apr-05

Alan Boag Flat 2/1 70 Bolldale Street Quayside Glasgow 25-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 184 Middleton Street Alexandria G83 0DJ 25-Apr-05 G Watson 10 Broom Road Rosneath G84 0RY 25-Apr-05


C

C Lee 31 Suffolk Street Helensburgh 25-Apr-05 Julie Fraser 14 Barclay Drive Helensburgh 25-Apr-05 A McGlynn 10 Barclay Drive Helensburgh G84 9RD 25-Apr-05 S Hamilton 8 Barclay Drive Helensburgh 25-Apr-05 E Whatney 6 Barclay Drive Helensburgh G84 25-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 26 Barclay Drive Helensburgh G84 9RB 25-Apr-05 Anne Baker` 27 Barclay Drive Helensburgh G84 9RA 25-Apr-05 M Woods 24 Edward Drive Helensburgh 25-Apr-05 C G Young 22 Edward Drive Helensburgh G84 9QP 25-Apr-05 Stephanie Matheson 20 Edward Drive Helensburgh G84 9Qp 25-Apr-05 Gillian Farrow 16 Edward Drive Helensburgh G84 9QP 25-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 14 Edward Drive Helensburgh G84 9QP 25-Apr-05 Steve Kirkby 8 Edward Drive Helensburgh G84 9QP 25-Apr-05 Susan King 3a Edward Drive Helensburgh G84 9QP 25-Apr-05 Ellen Booth 46 Suffolk Street Helensburgh G84 25-Apr-05 F Booth 46 Suffolk Street Helensburgh G84 9QZ 25-Apr-05

N D Bowers 17 Edward Drive Helensburgh

25-Apr-05

Mr Kenneth White 30 Barclay Drive Woodend Helensburgh G84 9RA 25-Apr-05 A Christie 44 Suffolk Street Helensburgh G84 9QZ 25-Apr-05 Mrs J A Lang 75 Kent Drive Helensburgh G84 9RU 25-Apr-05 Martin Robertson 83 Kent Drive Helensburgh G84 9RU 25-Apr-05 Alex Robinson 83 Kent Drive Helensburgh G84 9RU 25-Apr-05 Denise Munro 85 Kent Drive Helensburgh G84 9RU 25-Apr-05 Joanne Johnson 107 Kent Drive Helensburgh G84 9RU 25-Apr-05 T Gallier 105 Kent Drive Helensburgh G84 9RU 25-Apr-05 Mr A K Webb 99 Kent Drive Helensburgh G84 9RU 25-Apr-05 Mr M Kennedy 95 Kent Drive Helensburgh G84 9RU 25-Apr-05 Fiona Gumbrell 91 Kent Drive Helensburgh G84 9RU 26-Apr-05 Mr R MacAuley 40 Kent Drive Helensburgh G84 9RR 26-Apr-05 Mr L Pickard - Morris 28 Kent Drive Helensburgh 26-Apr-05 Mrs L Pickard - Morris 28 Kent Drive Helensburgh G84 9RP 26-Apr-05 Keith Beggs 2 Kent Court Helensburgh 26-Apr-05 Andy Middleton 12 Kent Drive Helensburgh 26-Apr-05 A M Barton 7 Kent Drive Helensburgh G84 9RT 26-Apr-05 Wendy Young 25/27 Kent Drive Helensburgh G84 9RT 26-Apr-05 Rose Bell 29 Kent Drive Helensburgh 26-Apr-05 Mrs A Turner 49 Kent Drive Helensburgh 26-Apr-05 Leigh Marshall 67 Kent Drive Helensburgh G84 9RT 26-Apr-05 Mr C F Martin 57 Kent Drive Helensburgh 26-Apr-05 H E Sharkey 17 Williamson Drive Helensburgh 26-Apr-05 J Rogers 16 Williamson Drive Helensburgh G84 26-Apr-05 Lewis Halbrook 53 Kent Drive Helensburgh G84 9RT 26-Apr-05 B Weintz 9 MacLachlan Road Helensburgh G84 9BX 26-Apr-05 Marion Hawthorn 65 Abbott Crescent Clydebank G81 1AB 26-Apr-05 John Hawthorn 65 Abbott Crescent Clydebank G81 1AB 26-Apr-05 Ken Prior 10 Golf View Bearsden Glasgow 26-Apr-05


C

Mairi Prior 10 Golf View Bearsden G61 4HJ 26-Apr-05 Dawn Ferry 77 Feorlin Way Garelochheaf G84 0DX 26-Apr-05 Mr Jamie Braton 21 Dennistoun Crescent Helensburgh G84 26-Apr-05 Miss Amanda Paton 143 Feorlin Way Garelochhead G84 0EB 26-Apr-05 Mrs R Postlethwaite 143 Feorlin Way Garelochhead G84 0EB 26-Apr-05 Miss Michelle Melville 141 Feorlin Way Garelochhead G84 0EB 26-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 4 Greenfield Way Garelochhead G84 OBN 26-Apr-05 Douglas Murray Blmbank House Shore Road Clynder G84 0QD 26-Apr-05 Owner/occupier 8 Kirkwood Drive Clydebank G81 2HA 26-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier Elmbank Shore Road Clynder G84 0QD 26-Apr-05 James D Murray Elmbank Shore Road Clynder 26-Apr-05 Mary M Love 30 Feorlin Way Garelochhead G84 0DJ 26-Apr-05 B H Petchey 30 Laggary Road Rhu 26-Apr-05 Mrs M McGhie 1 Caldwell Place Rhu G84 8RH 26-Apr-05 Miss H C Drummond 28 Laggary Road Rhu G84 26-Apr-05 Claire MacGregor 14 Fisher Place Helensburgh G84 9RJ 26-Apr-05 Joanne Mills 28 Fisher Place Churchill Helensburgh G84 9RJ 26-Apr-05 A Trotter 22 Laggary Road Rhu G84 8RJ 26-Apr-05 Mrs G L Boyde 26 Laggary Road Rhu G84 26-Apr-05

Mr David Boyde 26 Laggary Road Rhu G84 8RJ

26-Apr-05

David Reid 3 Laggary Road Helensburgh G84 8RJ 26-Apr-05 Ian Fraser 29 Laggary Park Rhu 26-Apr-05 A D MacFadgen 27 Laggary Road RHU G84 26-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 7 Laggary Road Rhu G84 8RJ 26-Apr-05 Mrs Janette McCann 1 Laggary Road Rhu G84 8RJ 26-Apr-05 A MacFadyen 4 Laggary Road Rhu 26-Apr-05 Tracey Ryance 12 Laggary Road Rhu G84 8RJ 26-Apr-05 E Noble 14 Laggary Road Rhu G84 26-Apr-05 Miss C Huie 25 Laggary Road Rhu G84 26-Apr-05 C McCabe 19 Laggary Road Rhu G84 26-Apr-05 Frank Goodfellow 21 Laggary Road Rhu G84 9RJ 26-Apr-05 Reana McCabe 19 Laggary Road Rhu G84 26-Apr-05 Jason McCabe 19 Laggary Road Rhu G84 8RJ 26-Apr-05 Mhairi Goodfellow 21 Laggary Road Rhu G84 8JJ 26-Apr-05 Mrs M Goodfellow 13 Laggary Road Rhu G84 8RJ 26-Apr-05 Mr M Divers 13 Laggary Road Rhu G84 8RJ 26-Apr-05 Alistair Robertson 18 Laggary Road Rhu G84 8RJ 26-Apr-05 Miss E Brogan 17 Laggary Road Rhu G84 26-Apr-05 M Sutter 15 Laggary Road Rhu G84 8RJ 26-Apr-05 H Scobie 2 Braehead Place Rhu G84 26-Apr-05 NORMA MONTGOMERY 6 Quarry Knowe Rhu G84 26-Apr-05 Owner/Occupier 62 Colquhoun Street Helensburgh G84 26-Apr-05 Janet Brown Fairmead Cottage Aros Road Rhu 26-Apr-05 Alison Burnhill 8 Mill Road Cardross 26-Apr-05 Emilia Martin 32 Maitland Court Helensburgh 26-Apr-05 Ella Szraga 11 Barge Court Rhu G84 26-Apr-05


C

Maria Marton 13 Barge Court Rhu G84 26-Apr-05 Ian Matheson 9 Laggary Road Rhu G84 26-Apr-05 Anna Marton 11 Laggary Road Rhu G84 26-Apr-05 F McBrierty 7 Laggary Road Rhu G84 8RJ 26-Apr-05 Mr A S Young 160/8 West King Street Helensburgh G84 8DT 26-Apr-05 Elizabeth Speller 81 East King Street Helensburgh G84 7RG 26-Apr-05 Mr And Mrs A J Stewart 29 Loch Drive Helensburgh G84 8PZ 27-Apr-05 Miss E Scott-Adamson Endrick 21 Dalmore Crescent Helensburgh G84 8JP 29-Apr-05 Mr N Conley And Miss L Conley 30 Baird Avenue Helensburgh G84 8DW 03-May-05 S Mannucci Camis Eskan House Coach House No. 3 Helensburgh 04-May-05 A Forsyth 13 Glen Drive Helensburgh G48 9BJ 06-May-05 Mr McConnell 27 John Street Helensburgh G84 8XL 06-May-05 L Proctor 2 Baird Avenue Helensburgh G84 8DW 06-May-05 Owner/Occupier 10 Queen Street Helensburgh G84 9LG 06-May-05 Amy Hall 3 Lever Road Helensburgh G84 9DP 06-May-05 Julie Andrew 17 Malcolm Place Churchill Helensburgh G84 9HW 06-May-05 Alison McGall Dunadd Pier Road Rhu Helensburgh 06-May-05 Helensburgh Community Council Nigel Miller (Chairman) 29 George Street Helensburgh 18-May-05 Mrs J A Heap 14 Arkwright Road Marple Stockport Cheshire SK6 7DE 20-May-05 Dubhghlas Irbhinn 4 Alltna Blathach Loch Eck Argyll PA23 8SG 20-May-05 Tina Irbhinn 4 Alt Na Blathaich Loch Eck Argyll PA23 8SG 20-May-05 Mrs Elaine Allan 9 Alyssum Crescent Motherwell ML1 1DF 20-May-05

J Abbott 15 Kirkmichael Avenue Glasgow G11 7QP

20-May-05

Mr R Allan 9 Alyssum Crescent Motherwell ML1 1DF 20-May-05 Miss Lesley Cameron 6 Riverview Place Glasgow G5 8GB 20-May-05 Dr Gayle M Addis 36 Westbourne Gardens Glasgow G12 9PF 20-May-05 Mr Neil N B Conley 30 Baird Avenue Helensburgh G84 8DW 23-May-05 Mr Jonathan Stevenson 8 Cumberland Avenue Helensburgh G84 8QG 21-Jun-05


C

LETTERS OF SUPPORT

1. Geraldine Whyte Kirkpark Cottages Church Road Rhu G84 8RW 12-Apr-052. Ian Cameron 158/7 West King Street Helensburgh 13-Apr-053. Richard Schooling 10 West Montrose Street Helensburgh G84 9NE 19-Apr-054. S Paterson 4 St Modens Way Rosneath Helensburgh 21-Apr-055. H Daly 28 East King Street Helensburgh 21-Apr-056. Mr H Paterson 93 East Clyde Street Helensburgh 21-Apr-057. Mrs E Arnott 7 Westborne Gardens Helensburgh 21-Apr-058. Fiona Chalmers 19 Campbell Street Helensburgh G84 8BQ 26-Apr-059. Mr C Conkie 24 Normanhurst Court West King Street Helensburgh 27-Apr-0510. Alistair Bellshaw 17 Ferry Road, Rosneath 10-Oct-0511. Derek Harkin 41 Kirkmichael Road, Helensburgh 5-Oct-05

12. D S C Arthur 26 West Argyle Street, Helensburgh 29-Sep-05

development services local member -...

Documents