dfpt research has an agreement with experico (fruit ... · pdf filewhen apples are harvested...
TRANSCRIPT
fresh NOTES (106) 3 February 2015 www.hortgroscience.co.za
YOUR LEVY SERVICING YOU - JOU HEFFING TOT JOU DIENS
Post-harvest Seminar
About 64 people braved the sweltering Stellenbosch sun to attend the HORTGRO Science Post-
harvest Seminar on the 22 January 2015. The event had an international flavour with two
presenters from Italy, Andrea Cucchi and Dr Luca Buglia, as well as British exhibitors and
delegates.
Topics unpacked, ranged from the latest research to a stock-take of cold chain management, as
well as exploring the exciting prospect of solar panel usage.
The need to revive the CA Group was also discussed and HORTGRO Science’s Research and
Technology Manager, Richard Hurndall, will launch some initiatives in this regard.
The Seminar kicked off with Asanda Mditshwa, a researcher from Stellenbosch University/ARC,
who discussed recent developments in controlling superficial scald in apples.
fresh NOTES (106) 3 February 2015 www.hortgroscience.co.za
YOUR LEVY SERVICING YOU - JOU HEFFING TOT JOU DIENS
Apple Scald – a Complex Problem When apples are harvested growers apply various treatments
to protect the fruit during cold storage, which can last as long
as a year. Superficial scald is a skin disorder of apples and
pears. It involves brown or grey discoloration of irregularly
shaped areas on the surface of the fruit during or following
storage.
Prolonged cold storage could lead to superficial scald which
results in brown or black patches on fruit surface. For many
years the treatment of choice to try and slow down or prevent
superficial scald was Diphenylamine (DPA). But, following
health concerns, especially in the European Union (EU), export
markets restricted DPA usage. Alternative methods, such as
dynamic controlled atmosphere (DCA), suddenly became very
important.
In their research Mditshwa reported that they investigated the potential of DCA to control
superficial scald in ‘Granny Smith’ apples. Research was conducted to determine the
minimum critical storage period for DCA to control scald and to assess the influence of
intermittent breaks on the efficacy of DCA treatment to control scald. The fruit was
evaluated according to the incidence of scald, flesh firmness and ground colour.
The researchers found that DCA is effective in controlling superficial scald. However
storing apples for 10 weeks at RA after DCA treatment increased
the risk of superficial scald. They also found that DCA
effectiveness was not reduced by intermittent breaks.
“In future we need to evaluate the evolution of superficial scald
associated with metabolites under DCA and develop a prediction
model for superficial scald,” Mditshwa said.
The research team consisted of: L Opara, K van der Merwe, F
Vries, E Crouch
fresh NOTES (106) 3 February 2015 www.hortgroscience.co.za
YOUR LEVY SERVICING YOU - JOU HEFFING TOT JOU DIENS
The many shades of browning. The occurrence of flesh browning in ‘Cripps’ Pink’ apples caused major economic losses
to the South African fresh fruit export industry in recent years. Factors believed to have the
biggest influence on such browning include storage temperatures and duration, cooling
rate (rapid cooling versus stepwise cooling), harvest maturity, cell membranes, and
biochemical antioxidants.
Dr Elke Crouch, researcher from the Department of Horticulture at the University of
Stellenbosch, discussed the differences between radial, diffuse and combination browning
of ‘Cripps’ Pink’ apples.
From left to right: Examples of radial, diffuse and combination browning.
The researchers assessed soil type, tree age and mineral content of fruit of six farms in
the Koue Bokkeveld on the susceptibility towards browning types. Studies showed that the
incidence of three different types of browning was influenced in different ways by pre-
harvest factors such as temperature, soil type, tree age, and mineral composition of the
fruit.
Especially the potassium and magnesium ratio, and low potassium levels had an influence
on the incidence of browning. Potassium was known to be involved in reducing stress and
chilling injury. Crouch said that this needs to be studied further and the context evaluated
before recommendations could be made.
fresh NOTES (106) 3 February 2015 www.hortgroscience.co.za
YOUR LEVY SERVICING YOU - JOU HEFFING TOT JOU DIENS
She emphasized that the current data was
preliminary and that a third season of climatic and
mineral trials was underway. Similar browning
trials were also being conducted on ‘Rosy Glow’.
The rest of the research team were: L Butler, E
Lotze, K Theron, H Bergman and I Crouch.
Dr Elke
Crouch
fresh NOTES (106) 3 February 2015 www.hortgroscience.co.za
YOUR LEVY SERVICING YOU - JOU HEFFING TOT JOU DIENS
What you see is not what you get
Mealiness in especially ‘Forelle’ pears,
has been an ongoing headache for
growers, said Tavagwisa Muziri, a
researcher from the Department of
Horticulture at Stellenbosch University.
In an effort to shed light on this
phenomenon and hoping to predict
mealiness in intact fruit, researchers
conducted tests using CT scanning and
Near Infrared Spectroscopy (NIR).
They found that NIR can classify
mealiness non-destructively, possibly at
farm and pack house level, though more
data was needed to develop a universal
model.
The findings of the CT scans were
divided into macro CT and micro CT.
“Macro CT has the potential to predict
mealiness before ripening,” Muziri said.
“In order to do that the mealiness porosity
(the pore spaces inside the fruit)
threshold for what can be considered
mealy needs to be established.”
With Micro CT scans the researchers
could observe that the mealy fruit had
larger pores, consisting of intercellular
spaces and damaged cells. “Cells of
mealy fruit were larger and more
ellipsoidal than non-mealy fruit cells,
which were spherical.”
“CT scans provides us with important
clues about mealiness, especially since
mealiness is there even before ripening
begins,” said Muziri. “We can conclude
that storage does not cause mealiness.
There are pre-harvest factors influencing
mealiness that we need to study.
Research team: E Crouch.
fresh NOTES (106) 3 February 2015 www.hortgroscience.co.za
YOUR LEVY SERVICING YOU - JOU HEFFING TOT JOU DIENS
The need for Container Temperature Management
About 1.8 m tonnes of fruit are annually exported from South
Africa using mainly refrigerated shipping containers (reefers).
Since the 1970’s when reefers were first used, very little about
the internal architecture, the manufacturing methods, and the
materials used in the bodies of these units has changed, said
Prof. Malcolm Dodd, from the University of Stellenbosch, who
studied fruit pulp temperature management in containers.
“This is in contrast to constant innovation of refrigeration units,
which has made them more efficient in terms of refrigerants
used, refrigeration capacity, energy consumption and the
control systems.”
According to Dodd the containers have an inherent problem of uneven air delivery and
short circuiting, which negatively impacts on product temperature, quality, relative humidity
and cold-steri loads.
“Most shipments with insurance claims invariably come about as a result of incorrect
temperatures,” he said. “Precise temperature control is the only way to manage the post-
harvest quality and shelf life of perishables. The reality is that as many as 30% of
shipments suffer from incorrect temperature management. This equates to 27,000
FEU/annum.”
“Just think about it,” he said. “Fruit spends more than 50% of its post-harvest
life somewhere in a reefer. When the port of destination is an Asian market,
fruit can easily expect to be in a reefer for 35 days or even more.”
fresh NOTES (106) 3 February 2015 www.hortgroscience.co.za
YOUR LEVY SERVICING YOU - JOU HEFFING TOT JOU DIENS
According to Dodd, trials have shown that several benefits are achieved by changing the delivery
method of air flow inside a reefer container:
• The fruit pulp temperature can be held closer to set point.
• The range of temperatures (difference between warmest and coldest) is reduced.
• The relative humidity inside the storage area can be increased.
• These improvements in storage environment assist in the maintenance of product
quality and shelf life.
• Probe 3 in cold steri-loads can be held closer to set point.
According to Dodd there is huge opportunity to innovate the design and manufacture of
refrigerated shipping containers. Interior architecture of the container can be improved by:
Reducing the amount of expensive extruded aluminium used by replacing the “T” bar floor
with a grooved floor,
Using modern extruded plastics where appropriate,
Upgrade the humidity management system.
Build in temperature and relative humidity recorders that can provide real time information
as to the environment within the containers.
A disposable horizontal airflow kit from Cordstrap, has been designed and commercially tested, to
aid in monitoring temperature inside containers. “When we control container temperature we
control post-harvest quality,” he said.
fresh NOTES (106) 3 February 2015 www.hortgroscience.co.za
YOUR LEVY SERVICING YOU - JOU HEFFING TOT JOU DIENS
Unpacking packing Fruit packing is not just a simple process. It is an art, as
Stellenbosch University researcher, Tarl Berry, explained when
he spoke about the design of future ventilated packaging and the
value of a multi-scale modelling approach.
“Multi-scale packaging is the division of packaging systems into multiple
components/scales, representing levels of complexity in the cold chain. From individual
fruit to internal packaging, carton/box, pallet stack, refrigerated shipping container to reefer
ship.
“By examining all the ‘scales’ as a whole, as well as in isolation, it is possible to identify
new areas of optimisation and even suggest new directions,” he said.
Berry said that there are certain optimisation criteria in package design.
“First we have to look at the mechanical strength – the carton must withstand dynamic
loads over an extended duration in various environmental conditions and protect fruit.
Second we have to look at ventilation – such as forced-air cooling, shipping containers and
atmospheric conditions. Then transport and logistics are important. Shipping systems are
facilitated by the packaging system, which includes
trucks, shipping containers, shipping vessels and finally
destination pack houses. Lastly we look at marketing –
which includes aspects like aesthetics, ergonomics and
convenience.”
About vent design, Berry, said that “we need optimal
designs to enhance the competitiveness of the South
African fruit export”. Here, factors to consider are the
type of fruit, internal packaging, carton production
method and costs, expected fruit cooling rate and energy
efficiency.
“Something such as a vent area is an important factor in
determining airflow and other cooling characteristics.
When we increase the vent area from 1% to 7% the
cooling rate increased by 183.85%, while increasing the
fresh NOTES (106) 3 February 2015 www.hortgroscience.co.za
YOUR LEVY SERVICING YOU - JOU HEFFING TOT JOU DIENS
vent area from 7% to 100% showed cooling rate increase of only 62.04%. Increasing the
number of vents improved airflow and uniformity of produce temperature. Effects of vent
shape on airflow and produce cooling behaviour were minimal.”
So what’s next?
Berry said they plan to use multiple parameters to determine best packaging designs for pallet stack handling. They expect the following outcomes:
• Demonstration of the effects of vent configuration on cooling performance and
energy efficiency of different packing configurations and types of internal packaging
for individual cartons
• Demonstration of the effect of vent configuration on cooling performance and
energy efficiency of stacked cartons
• Development of a design methodology for the optimisation of ventilated multi-scale
packaging systems
First session presenters, from left: Tarl Berry, Asanda Mditshwa, Dr Elke Crouch, Tavagwisa Muziri and Prof.
Malcolm Dodd.
fresh NOTES (106) 3 February 2015 www.hortgroscience.co.za
YOUR LEVY SERVICING YOU - JOU HEFFING TOT JOU DIENS
Time to fill the gaps!
There is great concern in the fruit industry that large amount of fruit and money is lost
every season due to breaks in the cold chain of SA export fruit, said Dr Leila Goedhals-
Gerber.
A research team investigated this worrying trend to determine possible causes of breaks in
the cold chain from pack house to vessel and to develop a Good Cold Chain Practice
guide.
The main focus of the study was on fruit that is exported in reefers and that is very sensitive to temperature and breaks in the cold chain, such as grapes, summer pears and plums. “In order to determine the causes of temperature breaks in the cold chain, we made observations on fruit farms, in pack houses, in cold stores as well as at the Container Terminal in the Port of Cape Town; we analysed temperature data received from exporters, and conducted temperature trials. “We know that temperature is the main determinant of the deterioration rate and potential shelf life of fresh produce. Humidity is also extremely important, but the higher the temperature, the higher the risk of quality problems such as fungus growth. We believe the effect of the temperature breaks are additive.”
fresh NOTES (106) 3 February 2015 www.hortgroscience.co.za
YOUR LEVY SERVICING YOU - JOU HEFFING TOT JOU DIENS
According to Goedhals-Gerber the team observed the
following:
At Farms:
Protocols state that fruit should be picked early in the morning when it’s cool, but fruit is sometimes picked in high temperatures in the middle of the day because it must be harvested urgently.
Once the fruit has been picked it must be transported to the pack house as soon as possible and cooled to remove the field heat, but sometimes the tractors and trailers are busy elsewhere and then the fruit still stands in the vineyard or orchard until noon.
At pack houses:
The receiving area does not always have sufficient shade, depending on the position of the sun.
The pack houses are usually not cooled or well insulated leading to temperatures inside that often exceed 30°C, as opposed to the 25°C in the protocol.
Although the field heat is normally removed before the fruit is packed and in the case of pome fruit it is often packed from cold storage, summer pears sometimes had a pulp temperature of 29.5°C after packaging. As a result of the packaging, the fruit also takes longer to cool to the required -1.5°C.
At cold stores:
The cold stores usually do not have airlock loading bays leading to the pallets being stacked outside in the shade while the container is being loaded.
It takes at least 20 minutes to load the container, during which time the fruit pulp temperature increases, especially when the ambient temp is above 30°C.
If an airlock loading bay is available, the container can be pre-cooled and the fruit will be loaded without a break in the cold chain.
Some cold stores load at night to minimise the impact of the break.
At ports:
At times there are long queues at the port (e.g. due to wind delays) and containers that travel from cold stores with less than 2 hours travel time are not fitted with gensets.
Some cold stores load at night to avoid queues.
fresh NOTES (106) 3 February 2015 www.hortgroscience.co.za
YOUR LEVY SERVICING YOU - JOU HEFFING TOT JOU DIENS
Containers should be offloaded on a FCFS basis at the stacks, which does not
always happen. Containers are also not always immediately plugged into the power
source.
The team also analysed historic temperature data received from a number of exporters.
The data covered the ambient temperatures inside the container, measured near the door every 20 or 30 minutes from the time of loading until the container is reopened at the destination.
“We received data from past seasons for the grape, plum, apple & pear export supply chains from the Port of CT to Europe and the UK. The optimum storage and shipping temperature for most of the summer fruit is -0.5°C. For the purposes of the study, a cold chain break was defined as any rise in ambient temp above 2°C for longer than 90 minutes,” said Goedhals-Gerber. “The sample included 123 containers for which 183 breaks were identified.”
As a final output of the study, a good cold chain practice guide for the export of table grapes was developed to help the fruit industry to minimise these cold chain breaks. The guide was developed from a logistics point of view and is presented in pictorial form for easy understanding by all role-players. It contains a section for each segment of the supply chain, e.g. pack house, cold store, etc., which can be displayed in poster format. Recommendations Pack houses: The roofs of pack houses should be insulated for reduced temperatures inside. Pack houses should not become warmer than 25°C.
Loading of container:
Making use of airlock loading bays is the ideal. Cold stores could also invest in air lock loading bays enabling pallets that can be loaded straight out of the cold store into the container without coming into contact with the warmer air outside. This will eliminate breaks during the loading process, said Goedhals-Gerber.
(The rest of the team consisted of: L Haasbroek, C Stander, M Dodd, E van Dyk, H Freiboth)
fresh NOTES (106) 3 February 2015 www.hortgroscience.co.za
YOUR LEVY SERVICING YOU - JOU HEFFING TOT JOU DIENS
Controlling your atmosphere Dynamic feedback systems to control CA composition
should be reliable, continuous, non-destructive, measurable
at distance from commodity, capable of automation, and
correlate directly with specific quality parameters,” said
Andrew Brink from Gas At Site.
According to Brink, a chlorophyll fluorescence-based dynamic controlled atmosphere
(DCA-CF) allows one to store fruit at the lowest possible oxygen level with a high degree
of confidence. “It extends storage life, improves flavour and ripening, firmness and scald
control.”
However, there are prerequisites for effective DCA storage:
Well-sealed CA Stores (Pressure Drop 25-18mm water gauge in less than 30 mins). Adequate On-Site Nitrogen supply. High-performance CO2 scrubbers that can operate at low CO2 levels, without
adding O2 to the CA store.
Brink said that there are numerous benefits to DCA – CF. “Chemical-free scald control,
better firmness and flavour, and a marked reduction of internal browning, are all
possibilities. It also benefits pear storage.”
According to Brink, future technologies to keep an eye on include ozone - used in the USA
mainly for moulds; DCA-CF and 1-MCP – used in both Italy and USA; and DCA-CF and 1
MCP and Ozone: Zirkle Fruit, Columbia Reach.
fresh NOTES (106) 3 February 2015 www.hortgroscience.co.za
YOUR LEVY SERVICING YOU - JOU HEFFING TOT JOU DIENS
Modern CA-ULO-Dynamic technology Dr Luca Buglia, from Fruit Control Equipment in Italy, made some recommendations for
DCA and explained why the Swinglos System is so impressive.
The Swinglos System
“Certain conditions must be met to fully utilise modern CA-ULO-Dynamic technology,” said
Buglia. These include:
Rooms with perfect gas tightness and a well-sized refrigerated plant.
Apples with same ripening parameters, harvested in the right period.
Rooms filled with the same variety.
Apples cooled before the first stress (pulp temp. 1,3 – 1,5°C).
fresh NOTES (106) 3 February 2015 www.hortgroscience.co.za
YOUR LEVY SERVICING YOU - JOU HEFFING TOT JOU DIENS
Mantaintenance of the same parameters during the
stress periods (+/- 0,1%).
Preparation of significant samples that represent the
main part of the room (5-8 wood box close to the
inspection window).
Alcohol analysis during stress period (total analysis 6-7).
Check fruits (samples), leaving them in RA storage
According to Buglia the Swinglos System is reliable, safe,
successful and economical. “It is reliable because the
occurrence of alcohol is strictly related to scald control.
Therefore alcohol is the most important parameter to control.
“Because alcohol is the only real risk of the system, it is completely safe. It is also hugely
successful. Over the last 10 years, Swinglos has been applied more than 3 000 times
without any single scald loss or instance of high alcohol levels. Lastly Swinglos is cheap –
the alcohol detection kit is a simple unit and easy to use.”
Simple and easy! The alcohol test kit
fresh NOTES (106) 3 February 2015 www.hortgroscience.co.za
YOUR LEVY SERVICING YOU - JOU HEFFING TOT JOU DIENS
Best of Both Andrea Cucchi, from Agrofresh in Italy, explained how to
get the best out of AdvanStore and SmartFresh and the role
it plays in the automatic control of respiration.
“Apples are alive – they respire, produce heat, loose water,
get sick and can even die,” said Cucchi.
“If we want to extend the post-harvest life of apples we need
to understand the biological process of respiration - the process of obtaining energy from
the oxidation of organic compounds, accompanied by the consumption of oxygen (when
available) and the release of carbon dioxide.”
By utilizing O2 and CO2 sensors, AdvanStore measures the changes in the Respiration
Quotient (RQ, CO2 / O2) of the entire room fruit load.
After the initial pull-down, oxygen levels will be decreased stepwise till the RQ readings
show a significant decrease in the fruit respiration. If and when RQ values go up, the
oxygen levels will be slowly and automatically increased to avoid fruit fermentation.
“AdvanStore allows for more comprehensive and robust fruit quality management during
storage by automatically controlling and adjusting the O2 levels in the room. It is the only
system able to measure the respiration of all fruits stored,” he said.
According to Cucchi, the combination of AdvanStore with the SmartFresh technology,
create increased confidence about fruit quality.
“What we have seen is excellent shelf life and quality maintenance benefits even during
long distance exports and breaks of the cold chain; SmartFresh reduces the fruit
respiration and consequently the risk for fermentation at low oxygen levels; The
combination of the technologies will further reduce the risk for storage disorders such as
scald or bitter pit, especially for long-term storage. According to Cucchi, there is also huge
opportunity for energy saving. “One can compare different rooms based on their
Respiration Quotients. Lastly, controlling the ethylene production and monitoring the
respiration maximizes the storage potential of your fruit.”
fresh NOTES (106) 3 February 2015 www.hortgroscience.co.za
YOUR LEVY SERVICING YOU - JOU HEFFING TOT JOU DIENS
Solar Resourcefulness Any business needs continuous and regular access to energy. None more so than fruit
pack houses and cold stores, said Clemens Brandt from Red Engineering.
“The solar generation is growing up fast and timing couldn’t be better with ever looming
power outages and soaring energy bills on the horizon.”
Brandt said that in 2007 South Africa had a “wake-up call”.
“We have an energy crisis. The reliability of energy supply is under strain. Energy costs
are escalating and will continue to do so for some time. Carbon tax is looming and there is
greater carbon footprint awareness than ever before.”
fresh NOTES (106) 3 February 2015 www.hortgroscience.co.za
YOUR LEVY SERVICING YOU - JOU HEFFING TOT JOU DIENS
According to Brandt the only way to solve the power problem is “to improve our energy
efficiency and generate our own electricity”.
South Africa has access to an abundance of sunshine compared to Europe, and yet we
lag behind. “Since June last year, Germany managed to generate over half its electricity
from solar, and the UK, France, Italy and Denmark are also believed to have generated
record amounts.”
The cost of photovoltaic (PV) systems in South Africa has fallen dramatically over the past
6 to 7 years. Large solar farms are being built by IPPs, providing electricity to the grid and
small to medium systems can provide decentralised energy for own use which will reduce
the load locally.
Brandt used the installation of 1876 PV modules at Arbeidsvreugd Fruit Packers,
Villiersdorp as a case study. During 2014 they had a 700,000 kWh/a ouput; saved 680t/a
CO2and 990,000 l/a H
2O.
“Pack houses and cold stores are ideal candidates for PV installations with pay-back as
low as 4 years. It can significantly reduce loads and has
a direct impact on one’s CO2 footprint.”
Brandt urged delegates to familiarise themselves with
the solar decision-making tool and investigate alternative
sources of energy.
http://phi.redengineering.co.za/index.php?id=306
Clemens Brandt
fresh NOTES (106) 3 February 2015 www.hortgroscience.co.za
YOUR LEVY SERVICING YOU - JOU HEFFING TOT JOU DIENS
Reviving the CA Group? To end off the Seminar, Richard Hurndall, Research and Technology Manager of HORTGRO Science, discussed the possible revival of the CA Group which was originally created in 1997. Hurndall explained the value and function of such a group and asked delegates whether such a group should be revived. There were some positive indications that it should be explored further. Topics covered by the previous CA Group included looking at new technologies, equipment, storage regimes, safety and post-harvest issues in general. It also oversaw CA room inspections by the ARC and produced the CA Operator's Manual. “We need to consider existing forums and groups,” Hurndall said, “but we need to explore whether there is an industry need for an additional CA Group.” One such endeavour that the CA Group could undertake is an international tour to visit other CA facilities. The current CA manual can be found on: http://www.hortgro.co.za/production-techical-information/packhouse-action-group-pag/
All the way from the UK: Jason Knowels, Redpack, and David Hind, locally, from Fruit Sizer’s & Allied.