dieudonné modules, part i: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated...

58
Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College May 23, 2016 Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 1 / 58

Upload: others

Post on 14-Aug-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Dieudonneacute modules part Ia study of primitively generated Hopf algebras

Alan Koch

Agnes Scott College

May 23 2016

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 1 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 2 58

Let R be an Fp-algebra for exampleR = Fq q = pn

R = Fq[T1T2 Tr ]

R = Fq(T1T2 Tr )

R = Fq[[T ]]

R = Fq((T ))

Objective Classify finite abelian (commutative cocommutative)R-Hopf algebras of p-power rank free as R-modules

Approach Can we construct a category of modules which areequivalent to this category of Hopf algebras

ldquoIt is probably impossible to do sordquo ndash AJ de Jong describingthe geometric statement of this problem

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 3 58

R an Fp-algebra

Let C be a subcategory of finite abelian R-Hopf algebras of p-powerrank free as R-modules

Objective Classify the objects of C using a category of modules

This can be done for certain C using Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 4 58

Some legal disclaimers

Dieudonneacutersquos original works (Lie groups and hyperalgebras over a ofcharacteristic p gt 0 parts I - VI) focus on abelian Lie groups Heappears to be much more interested in infinite dimensional structures(formal groups p-divisible groups)

Dieudonneacute modules have typically been used by algebraic geometerstrying to describe geometric objects

In many ways the development of Dieudonneacute module theory is betterexpressed geometrically but here (ldquoOmahardquo) algebraicconstructionsexplanations will be a priority

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 5 58

Assumptions

Throughout H is an R Hopf algebra with comultiplication ∆ count εand antipode λ

All Hopf algebras are assumed to be finite abelian free over R and ofp-power rank unless otherwise specified

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 6 58

Possible readings for this talk

A Grothendieck Seacuteminaire de Geacuteomeacutetrie Algeacutebrique duBois-Marie 1967ndash1969 (SGA 7) - Groupes de monodromie engeacuteomeacutetrie algeacutebrique Lecture notes in mathematics 288 BerlinNew York Springer-Verlag (Apparently)AJ de Jong Finite locally free group schemes in characteristic pand Dieudonneacute modules Invent mathematicae 1993 Volume114 Issue 1 pp 89ndash137M Rapoport Formal moduli spaces in equal characteristichttpsmathberkeleyedu aaronlivetexfmsiecpdf

Listed in decreasing order of the amount of algebraic geometryneeded as background

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 7 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 8 58

What is a Hopf algebra

A structure which is both an algebra and a coalgebra where thesestructures get along in a compatible way

Idea what if we focus on Hopf algebras with a particularly simplecoalgebra structure

Let H be finite (ie finitely generated and free) R-Hopf algebra Anelement t isin H is primitive if

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Necessarily if t isin P(H) then ε(t) = 0 and λ(t) = minust

Let P(H) be the set of all primitive elements of H

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 9 58

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Exercise 1 Show P(H) = Rt

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Exercise 2 Show P(H) = Rt + Rtp + middot middot middot+ Rtpnminus1

Example

Let H = R[t1 t2 tn](tp1 t

p2 t

pn ) ∆(ti) = ti otimes 1 + 1 otimes ti

Exercise 3 Describe P(H) as an R-module

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 10 58

ExampleLet H = RΓ Γ an abelian p-group (or any finite group)

Exercise 4 Describe P(H) as an R-module

ExampleLet R be a domain and H = RClowast

p = HomR(RCpR) Cp = 〈σ〉Let

t =pminus1983142

i=1

i983185i

where 983185i(σj) = δij

Exercise 5 Show that H = R[t ](tp minus t) and P(H) = Rt

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 11 58

Properties of P(H)

1 P(H) cap R = 02 t u isin P(H) rArr t + u isin P(H)3 t isin P(H) r isin R rArr rt isin P(H)4 P(H) is an R-submodule of H5 If R is a PID then P(H) is free over R6 t isin P(H) rArr tp isin P(H)

Exercise 6 Prove any subset of the above

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 12 58

Consider

HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H)

where x isin R[x ] is primitive

There is a map HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) rarr P(H) given by

f 983347rarr f (x)

which is an isomorphism

Define a map F HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) rarr HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) by

F (f )(x) = f (xp) = (f (x))p

This induces a map t 983347rarr tp in P(H) which we will also denote F andcall the Frobenius map

Note F (rx) = rpF (x) for all r isin R

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 13 58

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t Then P(H) = Rt and F (t) = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Then P(H) = Rt + Rtp + middot middot middot+ Rtpnminus1and F (tpi

) = tpi+1

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t Then P(H) = Rt and F (t) = tp = t

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 14 58

For any H the group P(H) has an R-module structure and is actedupon by F

Thus H is an R[F ]-module where R[F ] is the non-commutative ring ofpolynomials with

Fr = rpF

for all r isin R

Now suppose φ H1 rarr H2 is a Hopf algebra homomorphism Thenφ(P(H1)) sube φ(P(H2)) Furthermore for t isin P(H1)

Fφ(t) = φ(Ft)

so φ commutes with F

Thus φ983066983066983066P(H1)

is an R[F ]-module map

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 58

Therefore we have a functor

R-Hopf alg rarr R[F ]-modulesH rarr P(H)

which is not a categorical equivalence

Exercise 7 Show that RC2p and RCp2 correspond to the same

R[F ]-module

Exercise 8 Show that the R[F ]-module (R[F ])[X ] does notcorrespond to any Hopf algebra H

We will get a categorical equivalence by restricting the objects in bothcategories

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 58

We say H is primitively generated if no proper subalgebra of Hcontains P(H)Famous examples

1 H = R[t ](tp) t isin P(H)2 H = R[t ](tpn

) t isin P(H)3 H = R[t1 tn](t

pr1

1 tprn

n ) ti isin P(H)4 H = RClowast

p

5 H = R(Cnp )

lowast

Exercise 9 Let H = R[t ](tp2) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This is a Hopf algebra (not the exercise) Show that H is not primitivelygenerated (yes the exercise)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 58

From here on we suppose H is primitively generated and R is a PID

Then P(H) is free over R and of finite type over R[F ]

So the functor from before can restrict to983080

primitively generatedR-Hopf algebras

983081minusrarr

983080R[F ]-modules of finite type

free over R

983081

We claim this is a categorical equivalence

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 58

H 983347rarr P(H)

We will construct an inverse

Let M be an R[F ]-module of finite type free over R

Let e1 e2 en be an R-basis for M

For 1 le i j le n pick aij isin R such that

Fei =n983142

j=1

ajiej

Let

H = R[t1 t2 tn](tpi minus

n983142

j=1

aji tj)

with ti primitive for all i

Then after identifying ti with ei P(H) = M

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 58

We will call any R[F ]-module of finite type over R a Dieudonneacute module

We will write

Dlowast(H) = P(H)

Question Why not simply call the functor P(minus)

For clarity so we may better differentiate H from its DieudonneacutemoduleTo get the audience used to Dlowast which will be used extensivelyover the next few days (and usually wonrsquot mean P(minus))

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 58

Properties of Dlowast

1 Dlowast is covariant (although this is typically referred to as an exampleof a ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo)

2 If G = Spec(H) then the Dieudonneacute module isM = HomR-gr(GGa) where Ga is the additive group schemeSo Spec(H) 983347rarr Dlowast(H) is a contravariant functor

3 Dlowast is an exact functor4 Dlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)5 rankR H = prankR M

6 Dlowast respects base change (explained later)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 58

Some examples

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) t primitive

Then P(H) is generated as a free R-module by t tp tp2 tpnminus1

If we write ei = tpi 0 le i le n minus 1 then

Dlowast(H) =nminus1983131

i=0

Rei Fei = ei+1 Fenminus1 = 0

where i lt n minus 1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 58

Some more examples

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = e

ExampleLet M = Re1 oplus Re2 with

Fe1 = e2 Fe2 = e1

Then the corresponding Hopf algebra is

H = R[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) sim= R[t ](tp2 minus t)

with t primitiveNote that if Fp2 sube R then H = RClowast

p2

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 58

Consider the following problem for a fixed n find all primitivelygenerated R-Hopf algebras of rank pn

Equivalently find all R[F ] modules which are free rank n over R

These can be described with matrices

Let M be a free R-module basis e1 en Pick a matrix A isin Mn(R)and use it to define an F -action on M by

Fei = Aei

Then M corresponds to a Hopf algebra which can be quicklycomputed

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 58

Each element of Mn(R) gives a Hopf algebra

Conversely each Hopf algebra gives a matrix

However different choices of matrices can give the same Hopf algebra

It can be shown (as it was in Exeter) that AB isin Mn(R) give the sameHopf algebra if any only if there is a Θ isin Mn(R)times such that

B = Θminus1AΘ(p) where Θ = (θij) rArr Θp = (θpij)

Thus a parameter space for primitively generated Hopf algebras ofrank pn is Mn(R) sim where sim is the relation above

Presumably this allows for a count of Hopf algebras for certain R egR is a finite field

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 2: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 2 58

Let R be an Fp-algebra for exampleR = Fq q = pn

R = Fq[T1T2 Tr ]

R = Fq(T1T2 Tr )

R = Fq[[T ]]

R = Fq((T ))

Objective Classify finite abelian (commutative cocommutative)R-Hopf algebras of p-power rank free as R-modules

Approach Can we construct a category of modules which areequivalent to this category of Hopf algebras

ldquoIt is probably impossible to do sordquo ndash AJ de Jong describingthe geometric statement of this problem

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 3 58

R an Fp-algebra

Let C be a subcategory of finite abelian R-Hopf algebras of p-powerrank free as R-modules

Objective Classify the objects of C using a category of modules

This can be done for certain C using Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 4 58

Some legal disclaimers

Dieudonneacutersquos original works (Lie groups and hyperalgebras over a ofcharacteristic p gt 0 parts I - VI) focus on abelian Lie groups Heappears to be much more interested in infinite dimensional structures(formal groups p-divisible groups)

Dieudonneacute modules have typically been used by algebraic geometerstrying to describe geometric objects

In many ways the development of Dieudonneacute module theory is betterexpressed geometrically but here (ldquoOmahardquo) algebraicconstructionsexplanations will be a priority

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 5 58

Assumptions

Throughout H is an R Hopf algebra with comultiplication ∆ count εand antipode λ

All Hopf algebras are assumed to be finite abelian free over R and ofp-power rank unless otherwise specified

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 6 58

Possible readings for this talk

A Grothendieck Seacuteminaire de Geacuteomeacutetrie Algeacutebrique duBois-Marie 1967ndash1969 (SGA 7) - Groupes de monodromie engeacuteomeacutetrie algeacutebrique Lecture notes in mathematics 288 BerlinNew York Springer-Verlag (Apparently)AJ de Jong Finite locally free group schemes in characteristic pand Dieudonneacute modules Invent mathematicae 1993 Volume114 Issue 1 pp 89ndash137M Rapoport Formal moduli spaces in equal characteristichttpsmathberkeleyedu aaronlivetexfmsiecpdf

Listed in decreasing order of the amount of algebraic geometryneeded as background

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 7 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 8 58

What is a Hopf algebra

A structure which is both an algebra and a coalgebra where thesestructures get along in a compatible way

Idea what if we focus on Hopf algebras with a particularly simplecoalgebra structure

Let H be finite (ie finitely generated and free) R-Hopf algebra Anelement t isin H is primitive if

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Necessarily if t isin P(H) then ε(t) = 0 and λ(t) = minust

Let P(H) be the set of all primitive elements of H

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 9 58

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Exercise 1 Show P(H) = Rt

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Exercise 2 Show P(H) = Rt + Rtp + middot middot middot+ Rtpnminus1

Example

Let H = R[t1 t2 tn](tp1 t

p2 t

pn ) ∆(ti) = ti otimes 1 + 1 otimes ti

Exercise 3 Describe P(H) as an R-module

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 10 58

ExampleLet H = RΓ Γ an abelian p-group (or any finite group)

Exercise 4 Describe P(H) as an R-module

ExampleLet R be a domain and H = RClowast

p = HomR(RCpR) Cp = 〈σ〉Let

t =pminus1983142

i=1

i983185i

where 983185i(σj) = δij

Exercise 5 Show that H = R[t ](tp minus t) and P(H) = Rt

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 11 58

Properties of P(H)

1 P(H) cap R = 02 t u isin P(H) rArr t + u isin P(H)3 t isin P(H) r isin R rArr rt isin P(H)4 P(H) is an R-submodule of H5 If R is a PID then P(H) is free over R6 t isin P(H) rArr tp isin P(H)

Exercise 6 Prove any subset of the above

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 12 58

Consider

HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H)

where x isin R[x ] is primitive

There is a map HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) rarr P(H) given by

f 983347rarr f (x)

which is an isomorphism

Define a map F HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) rarr HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) by

F (f )(x) = f (xp) = (f (x))p

This induces a map t 983347rarr tp in P(H) which we will also denote F andcall the Frobenius map

Note F (rx) = rpF (x) for all r isin R

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 13 58

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t Then P(H) = Rt and F (t) = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Then P(H) = Rt + Rtp + middot middot middot+ Rtpnminus1and F (tpi

) = tpi+1

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t Then P(H) = Rt and F (t) = tp = t

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 14 58

For any H the group P(H) has an R-module structure and is actedupon by F

Thus H is an R[F ]-module where R[F ] is the non-commutative ring ofpolynomials with

Fr = rpF

for all r isin R

Now suppose φ H1 rarr H2 is a Hopf algebra homomorphism Thenφ(P(H1)) sube φ(P(H2)) Furthermore for t isin P(H1)

Fφ(t) = φ(Ft)

so φ commutes with F

Thus φ983066983066983066P(H1)

is an R[F ]-module map

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 58

Therefore we have a functor

R-Hopf alg rarr R[F ]-modulesH rarr P(H)

which is not a categorical equivalence

Exercise 7 Show that RC2p and RCp2 correspond to the same

R[F ]-module

Exercise 8 Show that the R[F ]-module (R[F ])[X ] does notcorrespond to any Hopf algebra H

We will get a categorical equivalence by restricting the objects in bothcategories

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 58

We say H is primitively generated if no proper subalgebra of Hcontains P(H)Famous examples

1 H = R[t ](tp) t isin P(H)2 H = R[t ](tpn

) t isin P(H)3 H = R[t1 tn](t

pr1

1 tprn

n ) ti isin P(H)4 H = RClowast

p

5 H = R(Cnp )

lowast

Exercise 9 Let H = R[t ](tp2) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This is a Hopf algebra (not the exercise) Show that H is not primitivelygenerated (yes the exercise)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 58

From here on we suppose H is primitively generated and R is a PID

Then P(H) is free over R and of finite type over R[F ]

So the functor from before can restrict to983080

primitively generatedR-Hopf algebras

983081minusrarr

983080R[F ]-modules of finite type

free over R

983081

We claim this is a categorical equivalence

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 58

H 983347rarr P(H)

We will construct an inverse

Let M be an R[F ]-module of finite type free over R

Let e1 e2 en be an R-basis for M

For 1 le i j le n pick aij isin R such that

Fei =n983142

j=1

ajiej

Let

H = R[t1 t2 tn](tpi minus

n983142

j=1

aji tj)

with ti primitive for all i

Then after identifying ti with ei P(H) = M

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 58

We will call any R[F ]-module of finite type over R a Dieudonneacute module

We will write

Dlowast(H) = P(H)

Question Why not simply call the functor P(minus)

For clarity so we may better differentiate H from its DieudonneacutemoduleTo get the audience used to Dlowast which will be used extensivelyover the next few days (and usually wonrsquot mean P(minus))

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 58

Properties of Dlowast

1 Dlowast is covariant (although this is typically referred to as an exampleof a ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo)

2 If G = Spec(H) then the Dieudonneacute module isM = HomR-gr(GGa) where Ga is the additive group schemeSo Spec(H) 983347rarr Dlowast(H) is a contravariant functor

3 Dlowast is an exact functor4 Dlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)5 rankR H = prankR M

6 Dlowast respects base change (explained later)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 58

Some examples

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) t primitive

Then P(H) is generated as a free R-module by t tp tp2 tpnminus1

If we write ei = tpi 0 le i le n minus 1 then

Dlowast(H) =nminus1983131

i=0

Rei Fei = ei+1 Fenminus1 = 0

where i lt n minus 1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 58

Some more examples

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = e

ExampleLet M = Re1 oplus Re2 with

Fe1 = e2 Fe2 = e1

Then the corresponding Hopf algebra is

H = R[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) sim= R[t ](tp2 minus t)

with t primitiveNote that if Fp2 sube R then H = RClowast

p2

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 58

Consider the following problem for a fixed n find all primitivelygenerated R-Hopf algebras of rank pn

Equivalently find all R[F ] modules which are free rank n over R

These can be described with matrices

Let M be a free R-module basis e1 en Pick a matrix A isin Mn(R)and use it to define an F -action on M by

Fei = Aei

Then M corresponds to a Hopf algebra which can be quicklycomputed

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 58

Each element of Mn(R) gives a Hopf algebra

Conversely each Hopf algebra gives a matrix

However different choices of matrices can give the same Hopf algebra

It can be shown (as it was in Exeter) that AB isin Mn(R) give the sameHopf algebra if any only if there is a Θ isin Mn(R)times such that

B = Θminus1AΘ(p) where Θ = (θij) rArr Θp = (θpij)

Thus a parameter space for primitively generated Hopf algebras ofrank pn is Mn(R) sim where sim is the relation above

Presumably this allows for a count of Hopf algebras for certain R egR is a finite field

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 3: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Let R be an Fp-algebra for exampleR = Fq q = pn

R = Fq[T1T2 Tr ]

R = Fq(T1T2 Tr )

R = Fq[[T ]]

R = Fq((T ))

Objective Classify finite abelian (commutative cocommutative)R-Hopf algebras of p-power rank free as R-modules

Approach Can we construct a category of modules which areequivalent to this category of Hopf algebras

ldquoIt is probably impossible to do sordquo ndash AJ de Jong describingthe geometric statement of this problem

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 3 58

R an Fp-algebra

Let C be a subcategory of finite abelian R-Hopf algebras of p-powerrank free as R-modules

Objective Classify the objects of C using a category of modules

This can be done for certain C using Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 4 58

Some legal disclaimers

Dieudonneacutersquos original works (Lie groups and hyperalgebras over a ofcharacteristic p gt 0 parts I - VI) focus on abelian Lie groups Heappears to be much more interested in infinite dimensional structures(formal groups p-divisible groups)

Dieudonneacute modules have typically been used by algebraic geometerstrying to describe geometric objects

In many ways the development of Dieudonneacute module theory is betterexpressed geometrically but here (ldquoOmahardquo) algebraicconstructionsexplanations will be a priority

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 5 58

Assumptions

Throughout H is an R Hopf algebra with comultiplication ∆ count εand antipode λ

All Hopf algebras are assumed to be finite abelian free over R and ofp-power rank unless otherwise specified

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 6 58

Possible readings for this talk

A Grothendieck Seacuteminaire de Geacuteomeacutetrie Algeacutebrique duBois-Marie 1967ndash1969 (SGA 7) - Groupes de monodromie engeacuteomeacutetrie algeacutebrique Lecture notes in mathematics 288 BerlinNew York Springer-Verlag (Apparently)AJ de Jong Finite locally free group schemes in characteristic pand Dieudonneacute modules Invent mathematicae 1993 Volume114 Issue 1 pp 89ndash137M Rapoport Formal moduli spaces in equal characteristichttpsmathberkeleyedu aaronlivetexfmsiecpdf

Listed in decreasing order of the amount of algebraic geometryneeded as background

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 7 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 8 58

What is a Hopf algebra

A structure which is both an algebra and a coalgebra where thesestructures get along in a compatible way

Idea what if we focus on Hopf algebras with a particularly simplecoalgebra structure

Let H be finite (ie finitely generated and free) R-Hopf algebra Anelement t isin H is primitive if

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Necessarily if t isin P(H) then ε(t) = 0 and λ(t) = minust

Let P(H) be the set of all primitive elements of H

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 9 58

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Exercise 1 Show P(H) = Rt

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Exercise 2 Show P(H) = Rt + Rtp + middot middot middot+ Rtpnminus1

Example

Let H = R[t1 t2 tn](tp1 t

p2 t

pn ) ∆(ti) = ti otimes 1 + 1 otimes ti

Exercise 3 Describe P(H) as an R-module

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 10 58

ExampleLet H = RΓ Γ an abelian p-group (or any finite group)

Exercise 4 Describe P(H) as an R-module

ExampleLet R be a domain and H = RClowast

p = HomR(RCpR) Cp = 〈σ〉Let

t =pminus1983142

i=1

i983185i

where 983185i(σj) = δij

Exercise 5 Show that H = R[t ](tp minus t) and P(H) = Rt

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 11 58

Properties of P(H)

1 P(H) cap R = 02 t u isin P(H) rArr t + u isin P(H)3 t isin P(H) r isin R rArr rt isin P(H)4 P(H) is an R-submodule of H5 If R is a PID then P(H) is free over R6 t isin P(H) rArr tp isin P(H)

Exercise 6 Prove any subset of the above

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 12 58

Consider

HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H)

where x isin R[x ] is primitive

There is a map HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) rarr P(H) given by

f 983347rarr f (x)

which is an isomorphism

Define a map F HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) rarr HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) by

F (f )(x) = f (xp) = (f (x))p

This induces a map t 983347rarr tp in P(H) which we will also denote F andcall the Frobenius map

Note F (rx) = rpF (x) for all r isin R

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 13 58

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t Then P(H) = Rt and F (t) = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Then P(H) = Rt + Rtp + middot middot middot+ Rtpnminus1and F (tpi

) = tpi+1

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t Then P(H) = Rt and F (t) = tp = t

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 14 58

For any H the group P(H) has an R-module structure and is actedupon by F

Thus H is an R[F ]-module where R[F ] is the non-commutative ring ofpolynomials with

Fr = rpF

for all r isin R

Now suppose φ H1 rarr H2 is a Hopf algebra homomorphism Thenφ(P(H1)) sube φ(P(H2)) Furthermore for t isin P(H1)

Fφ(t) = φ(Ft)

so φ commutes with F

Thus φ983066983066983066P(H1)

is an R[F ]-module map

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 58

Therefore we have a functor

R-Hopf alg rarr R[F ]-modulesH rarr P(H)

which is not a categorical equivalence

Exercise 7 Show that RC2p and RCp2 correspond to the same

R[F ]-module

Exercise 8 Show that the R[F ]-module (R[F ])[X ] does notcorrespond to any Hopf algebra H

We will get a categorical equivalence by restricting the objects in bothcategories

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 58

We say H is primitively generated if no proper subalgebra of Hcontains P(H)Famous examples

1 H = R[t ](tp) t isin P(H)2 H = R[t ](tpn

) t isin P(H)3 H = R[t1 tn](t

pr1

1 tprn

n ) ti isin P(H)4 H = RClowast

p

5 H = R(Cnp )

lowast

Exercise 9 Let H = R[t ](tp2) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This is a Hopf algebra (not the exercise) Show that H is not primitivelygenerated (yes the exercise)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 58

From here on we suppose H is primitively generated and R is a PID

Then P(H) is free over R and of finite type over R[F ]

So the functor from before can restrict to983080

primitively generatedR-Hopf algebras

983081minusrarr

983080R[F ]-modules of finite type

free over R

983081

We claim this is a categorical equivalence

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 58

H 983347rarr P(H)

We will construct an inverse

Let M be an R[F ]-module of finite type free over R

Let e1 e2 en be an R-basis for M

For 1 le i j le n pick aij isin R such that

Fei =n983142

j=1

ajiej

Let

H = R[t1 t2 tn](tpi minus

n983142

j=1

aji tj)

with ti primitive for all i

Then after identifying ti with ei P(H) = M

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 58

We will call any R[F ]-module of finite type over R a Dieudonneacute module

We will write

Dlowast(H) = P(H)

Question Why not simply call the functor P(minus)

For clarity so we may better differentiate H from its DieudonneacutemoduleTo get the audience used to Dlowast which will be used extensivelyover the next few days (and usually wonrsquot mean P(minus))

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 58

Properties of Dlowast

1 Dlowast is covariant (although this is typically referred to as an exampleof a ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo)

2 If G = Spec(H) then the Dieudonneacute module isM = HomR-gr(GGa) where Ga is the additive group schemeSo Spec(H) 983347rarr Dlowast(H) is a contravariant functor

3 Dlowast is an exact functor4 Dlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)5 rankR H = prankR M

6 Dlowast respects base change (explained later)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 58

Some examples

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) t primitive

Then P(H) is generated as a free R-module by t tp tp2 tpnminus1

If we write ei = tpi 0 le i le n minus 1 then

Dlowast(H) =nminus1983131

i=0

Rei Fei = ei+1 Fenminus1 = 0

where i lt n minus 1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 58

Some more examples

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = e

ExampleLet M = Re1 oplus Re2 with

Fe1 = e2 Fe2 = e1

Then the corresponding Hopf algebra is

H = R[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) sim= R[t ](tp2 minus t)

with t primitiveNote that if Fp2 sube R then H = RClowast

p2

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 58

Consider the following problem for a fixed n find all primitivelygenerated R-Hopf algebras of rank pn

Equivalently find all R[F ] modules which are free rank n over R

These can be described with matrices

Let M be a free R-module basis e1 en Pick a matrix A isin Mn(R)and use it to define an F -action on M by

Fei = Aei

Then M corresponds to a Hopf algebra which can be quicklycomputed

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 58

Each element of Mn(R) gives a Hopf algebra

Conversely each Hopf algebra gives a matrix

However different choices of matrices can give the same Hopf algebra

It can be shown (as it was in Exeter) that AB isin Mn(R) give the sameHopf algebra if any only if there is a Θ isin Mn(R)times such that

B = Θminus1AΘ(p) where Θ = (θij) rArr Θp = (θpij)

Thus a parameter space for primitively generated Hopf algebras ofrank pn is Mn(R) sim where sim is the relation above

Presumably this allows for a count of Hopf algebras for certain R egR is a finite field

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 4: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

R an Fp-algebra

Let C be a subcategory of finite abelian R-Hopf algebras of p-powerrank free as R-modules

Objective Classify the objects of C using a category of modules

This can be done for certain C using Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 4 58

Some legal disclaimers

Dieudonneacutersquos original works (Lie groups and hyperalgebras over a ofcharacteristic p gt 0 parts I - VI) focus on abelian Lie groups Heappears to be much more interested in infinite dimensional structures(formal groups p-divisible groups)

Dieudonneacute modules have typically been used by algebraic geometerstrying to describe geometric objects

In many ways the development of Dieudonneacute module theory is betterexpressed geometrically but here (ldquoOmahardquo) algebraicconstructionsexplanations will be a priority

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 5 58

Assumptions

Throughout H is an R Hopf algebra with comultiplication ∆ count εand antipode λ

All Hopf algebras are assumed to be finite abelian free over R and ofp-power rank unless otherwise specified

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 6 58

Possible readings for this talk

A Grothendieck Seacuteminaire de Geacuteomeacutetrie Algeacutebrique duBois-Marie 1967ndash1969 (SGA 7) - Groupes de monodromie engeacuteomeacutetrie algeacutebrique Lecture notes in mathematics 288 BerlinNew York Springer-Verlag (Apparently)AJ de Jong Finite locally free group schemes in characteristic pand Dieudonneacute modules Invent mathematicae 1993 Volume114 Issue 1 pp 89ndash137M Rapoport Formal moduli spaces in equal characteristichttpsmathberkeleyedu aaronlivetexfmsiecpdf

Listed in decreasing order of the amount of algebraic geometryneeded as background

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 7 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 8 58

What is a Hopf algebra

A structure which is both an algebra and a coalgebra where thesestructures get along in a compatible way

Idea what if we focus on Hopf algebras with a particularly simplecoalgebra structure

Let H be finite (ie finitely generated and free) R-Hopf algebra Anelement t isin H is primitive if

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Necessarily if t isin P(H) then ε(t) = 0 and λ(t) = minust

Let P(H) be the set of all primitive elements of H

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 9 58

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Exercise 1 Show P(H) = Rt

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Exercise 2 Show P(H) = Rt + Rtp + middot middot middot+ Rtpnminus1

Example

Let H = R[t1 t2 tn](tp1 t

p2 t

pn ) ∆(ti) = ti otimes 1 + 1 otimes ti

Exercise 3 Describe P(H) as an R-module

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 10 58

ExampleLet H = RΓ Γ an abelian p-group (or any finite group)

Exercise 4 Describe P(H) as an R-module

ExampleLet R be a domain and H = RClowast

p = HomR(RCpR) Cp = 〈σ〉Let

t =pminus1983142

i=1

i983185i

where 983185i(σj) = δij

Exercise 5 Show that H = R[t ](tp minus t) and P(H) = Rt

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 11 58

Properties of P(H)

1 P(H) cap R = 02 t u isin P(H) rArr t + u isin P(H)3 t isin P(H) r isin R rArr rt isin P(H)4 P(H) is an R-submodule of H5 If R is a PID then P(H) is free over R6 t isin P(H) rArr tp isin P(H)

Exercise 6 Prove any subset of the above

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 12 58

Consider

HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H)

where x isin R[x ] is primitive

There is a map HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) rarr P(H) given by

f 983347rarr f (x)

which is an isomorphism

Define a map F HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) rarr HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) by

F (f )(x) = f (xp) = (f (x))p

This induces a map t 983347rarr tp in P(H) which we will also denote F andcall the Frobenius map

Note F (rx) = rpF (x) for all r isin R

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 13 58

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t Then P(H) = Rt and F (t) = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Then P(H) = Rt + Rtp + middot middot middot+ Rtpnminus1and F (tpi

) = tpi+1

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t Then P(H) = Rt and F (t) = tp = t

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 14 58

For any H the group P(H) has an R-module structure and is actedupon by F

Thus H is an R[F ]-module where R[F ] is the non-commutative ring ofpolynomials with

Fr = rpF

for all r isin R

Now suppose φ H1 rarr H2 is a Hopf algebra homomorphism Thenφ(P(H1)) sube φ(P(H2)) Furthermore for t isin P(H1)

Fφ(t) = φ(Ft)

so φ commutes with F

Thus φ983066983066983066P(H1)

is an R[F ]-module map

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 58

Therefore we have a functor

R-Hopf alg rarr R[F ]-modulesH rarr P(H)

which is not a categorical equivalence

Exercise 7 Show that RC2p and RCp2 correspond to the same

R[F ]-module

Exercise 8 Show that the R[F ]-module (R[F ])[X ] does notcorrespond to any Hopf algebra H

We will get a categorical equivalence by restricting the objects in bothcategories

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 58

We say H is primitively generated if no proper subalgebra of Hcontains P(H)Famous examples

1 H = R[t ](tp) t isin P(H)2 H = R[t ](tpn

) t isin P(H)3 H = R[t1 tn](t

pr1

1 tprn

n ) ti isin P(H)4 H = RClowast

p

5 H = R(Cnp )

lowast

Exercise 9 Let H = R[t ](tp2) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This is a Hopf algebra (not the exercise) Show that H is not primitivelygenerated (yes the exercise)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 58

From here on we suppose H is primitively generated and R is a PID

Then P(H) is free over R and of finite type over R[F ]

So the functor from before can restrict to983080

primitively generatedR-Hopf algebras

983081minusrarr

983080R[F ]-modules of finite type

free over R

983081

We claim this is a categorical equivalence

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 58

H 983347rarr P(H)

We will construct an inverse

Let M be an R[F ]-module of finite type free over R

Let e1 e2 en be an R-basis for M

For 1 le i j le n pick aij isin R such that

Fei =n983142

j=1

ajiej

Let

H = R[t1 t2 tn](tpi minus

n983142

j=1

aji tj)

with ti primitive for all i

Then after identifying ti with ei P(H) = M

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 58

We will call any R[F ]-module of finite type over R a Dieudonneacute module

We will write

Dlowast(H) = P(H)

Question Why not simply call the functor P(minus)

For clarity so we may better differentiate H from its DieudonneacutemoduleTo get the audience used to Dlowast which will be used extensivelyover the next few days (and usually wonrsquot mean P(minus))

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 58

Properties of Dlowast

1 Dlowast is covariant (although this is typically referred to as an exampleof a ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo)

2 If G = Spec(H) then the Dieudonneacute module isM = HomR-gr(GGa) where Ga is the additive group schemeSo Spec(H) 983347rarr Dlowast(H) is a contravariant functor

3 Dlowast is an exact functor4 Dlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)5 rankR H = prankR M

6 Dlowast respects base change (explained later)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 58

Some examples

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) t primitive

Then P(H) is generated as a free R-module by t tp tp2 tpnminus1

If we write ei = tpi 0 le i le n minus 1 then

Dlowast(H) =nminus1983131

i=0

Rei Fei = ei+1 Fenminus1 = 0

where i lt n minus 1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 58

Some more examples

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = e

ExampleLet M = Re1 oplus Re2 with

Fe1 = e2 Fe2 = e1

Then the corresponding Hopf algebra is

H = R[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) sim= R[t ](tp2 minus t)

with t primitiveNote that if Fp2 sube R then H = RClowast

p2

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 58

Consider the following problem for a fixed n find all primitivelygenerated R-Hopf algebras of rank pn

Equivalently find all R[F ] modules which are free rank n over R

These can be described with matrices

Let M be a free R-module basis e1 en Pick a matrix A isin Mn(R)and use it to define an F -action on M by

Fei = Aei

Then M corresponds to a Hopf algebra which can be quicklycomputed

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 58

Each element of Mn(R) gives a Hopf algebra

Conversely each Hopf algebra gives a matrix

However different choices of matrices can give the same Hopf algebra

It can be shown (as it was in Exeter) that AB isin Mn(R) give the sameHopf algebra if any only if there is a Θ isin Mn(R)times such that

B = Θminus1AΘ(p) where Θ = (θij) rArr Θp = (θpij)

Thus a parameter space for primitively generated Hopf algebras ofrank pn is Mn(R) sim where sim is the relation above

Presumably this allows for a count of Hopf algebras for certain R egR is a finite field

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 5: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Some legal disclaimers

Dieudonneacutersquos original works (Lie groups and hyperalgebras over a ofcharacteristic p gt 0 parts I - VI) focus on abelian Lie groups Heappears to be much more interested in infinite dimensional structures(formal groups p-divisible groups)

Dieudonneacute modules have typically been used by algebraic geometerstrying to describe geometric objects

In many ways the development of Dieudonneacute module theory is betterexpressed geometrically but here (ldquoOmahardquo) algebraicconstructionsexplanations will be a priority

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 5 58

Assumptions

Throughout H is an R Hopf algebra with comultiplication ∆ count εand antipode λ

All Hopf algebras are assumed to be finite abelian free over R and ofp-power rank unless otherwise specified

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 6 58

Possible readings for this talk

A Grothendieck Seacuteminaire de Geacuteomeacutetrie Algeacutebrique duBois-Marie 1967ndash1969 (SGA 7) - Groupes de monodromie engeacuteomeacutetrie algeacutebrique Lecture notes in mathematics 288 BerlinNew York Springer-Verlag (Apparently)AJ de Jong Finite locally free group schemes in characteristic pand Dieudonneacute modules Invent mathematicae 1993 Volume114 Issue 1 pp 89ndash137M Rapoport Formal moduli spaces in equal characteristichttpsmathberkeleyedu aaronlivetexfmsiecpdf

Listed in decreasing order of the amount of algebraic geometryneeded as background

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 7 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 8 58

What is a Hopf algebra

A structure which is both an algebra and a coalgebra where thesestructures get along in a compatible way

Idea what if we focus on Hopf algebras with a particularly simplecoalgebra structure

Let H be finite (ie finitely generated and free) R-Hopf algebra Anelement t isin H is primitive if

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Necessarily if t isin P(H) then ε(t) = 0 and λ(t) = minust

Let P(H) be the set of all primitive elements of H

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 9 58

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Exercise 1 Show P(H) = Rt

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Exercise 2 Show P(H) = Rt + Rtp + middot middot middot+ Rtpnminus1

Example

Let H = R[t1 t2 tn](tp1 t

p2 t

pn ) ∆(ti) = ti otimes 1 + 1 otimes ti

Exercise 3 Describe P(H) as an R-module

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 10 58

ExampleLet H = RΓ Γ an abelian p-group (or any finite group)

Exercise 4 Describe P(H) as an R-module

ExampleLet R be a domain and H = RClowast

p = HomR(RCpR) Cp = 〈σ〉Let

t =pminus1983142

i=1

i983185i

where 983185i(σj) = δij

Exercise 5 Show that H = R[t ](tp minus t) and P(H) = Rt

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 11 58

Properties of P(H)

1 P(H) cap R = 02 t u isin P(H) rArr t + u isin P(H)3 t isin P(H) r isin R rArr rt isin P(H)4 P(H) is an R-submodule of H5 If R is a PID then P(H) is free over R6 t isin P(H) rArr tp isin P(H)

Exercise 6 Prove any subset of the above

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 12 58

Consider

HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H)

where x isin R[x ] is primitive

There is a map HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) rarr P(H) given by

f 983347rarr f (x)

which is an isomorphism

Define a map F HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) rarr HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) by

F (f )(x) = f (xp) = (f (x))p

This induces a map t 983347rarr tp in P(H) which we will also denote F andcall the Frobenius map

Note F (rx) = rpF (x) for all r isin R

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 13 58

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t Then P(H) = Rt and F (t) = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Then P(H) = Rt + Rtp + middot middot middot+ Rtpnminus1and F (tpi

) = tpi+1

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t Then P(H) = Rt and F (t) = tp = t

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 14 58

For any H the group P(H) has an R-module structure and is actedupon by F

Thus H is an R[F ]-module where R[F ] is the non-commutative ring ofpolynomials with

Fr = rpF

for all r isin R

Now suppose φ H1 rarr H2 is a Hopf algebra homomorphism Thenφ(P(H1)) sube φ(P(H2)) Furthermore for t isin P(H1)

Fφ(t) = φ(Ft)

so φ commutes with F

Thus φ983066983066983066P(H1)

is an R[F ]-module map

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 58

Therefore we have a functor

R-Hopf alg rarr R[F ]-modulesH rarr P(H)

which is not a categorical equivalence

Exercise 7 Show that RC2p and RCp2 correspond to the same

R[F ]-module

Exercise 8 Show that the R[F ]-module (R[F ])[X ] does notcorrespond to any Hopf algebra H

We will get a categorical equivalence by restricting the objects in bothcategories

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 58

We say H is primitively generated if no proper subalgebra of Hcontains P(H)Famous examples

1 H = R[t ](tp) t isin P(H)2 H = R[t ](tpn

) t isin P(H)3 H = R[t1 tn](t

pr1

1 tprn

n ) ti isin P(H)4 H = RClowast

p

5 H = R(Cnp )

lowast

Exercise 9 Let H = R[t ](tp2) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This is a Hopf algebra (not the exercise) Show that H is not primitivelygenerated (yes the exercise)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 58

From here on we suppose H is primitively generated and R is a PID

Then P(H) is free over R and of finite type over R[F ]

So the functor from before can restrict to983080

primitively generatedR-Hopf algebras

983081minusrarr

983080R[F ]-modules of finite type

free over R

983081

We claim this is a categorical equivalence

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 58

H 983347rarr P(H)

We will construct an inverse

Let M be an R[F ]-module of finite type free over R

Let e1 e2 en be an R-basis for M

For 1 le i j le n pick aij isin R such that

Fei =n983142

j=1

ajiej

Let

H = R[t1 t2 tn](tpi minus

n983142

j=1

aji tj)

with ti primitive for all i

Then after identifying ti with ei P(H) = M

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 58

We will call any R[F ]-module of finite type over R a Dieudonneacute module

We will write

Dlowast(H) = P(H)

Question Why not simply call the functor P(minus)

For clarity so we may better differentiate H from its DieudonneacutemoduleTo get the audience used to Dlowast which will be used extensivelyover the next few days (and usually wonrsquot mean P(minus))

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 58

Properties of Dlowast

1 Dlowast is covariant (although this is typically referred to as an exampleof a ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo)

2 If G = Spec(H) then the Dieudonneacute module isM = HomR-gr(GGa) where Ga is the additive group schemeSo Spec(H) 983347rarr Dlowast(H) is a contravariant functor

3 Dlowast is an exact functor4 Dlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)5 rankR H = prankR M

6 Dlowast respects base change (explained later)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 58

Some examples

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) t primitive

Then P(H) is generated as a free R-module by t tp tp2 tpnminus1

If we write ei = tpi 0 le i le n minus 1 then

Dlowast(H) =nminus1983131

i=0

Rei Fei = ei+1 Fenminus1 = 0

where i lt n minus 1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 58

Some more examples

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = e

ExampleLet M = Re1 oplus Re2 with

Fe1 = e2 Fe2 = e1

Then the corresponding Hopf algebra is

H = R[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) sim= R[t ](tp2 minus t)

with t primitiveNote that if Fp2 sube R then H = RClowast

p2

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 58

Consider the following problem for a fixed n find all primitivelygenerated R-Hopf algebras of rank pn

Equivalently find all R[F ] modules which are free rank n over R

These can be described with matrices

Let M be a free R-module basis e1 en Pick a matrix A isin Mn(R)and use it to define an F -action on M by

Fei = Aei

Then M corresponds to a Hopf algebra which can be quicklycomputed

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 58

Each element of Mn(R) gives a Hopf algebra

Conversely each Hopf algebra gives a matrix

However different choices of matrices can give the same Hopf algebra

It can be shown (as it was in Exeter) that AB isin Mn(R) give the sameHopf algebra if any only if there is a Θ isin Mn(R)times such that

B = Θminus1AΘ(p) where Θ = (θij) rArr Θp = (θpij)

Thus a parameter space for primitively generated Hopf algebras ofrank pn is Mn(R) sim where sim is the relation above

Presumably this allows for a count of Hopf algebras for certain R egR is a finite field

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 6: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Assumptions

Throughout H is an R Hopf algebra with comultiplication ∆ count εand antipode λ

All Hopf algebras are assumed to be finite abelian free over R and ofp-power rank unless otherwise specified

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 6 58

Possible readings for this talk

A Grothendieck Seacuteminaire de Geacuteomeacutetrie Algeacutebrique duBois-Marie 1967ndash1969 (SGA 7) - Groupes de monodromie engeacuteomeacutetrie algeacutebrique Lecture notes in mathematics 288 BerlinNew York Springer-Verlag (Apparently)AJ de Jong Finite locally free group schemes in characteristic pand Dieudonneacute modules Invent mathematicae 1993 Volume114 Issue 1 pp 89ndash137M Rapoport Formal moduli spaces in equal characteristichttpsmathberkeleyedu aaronlivetexfmsiecpdf

Listed in decreasing order of the amount of algebraic geometryneeded as background

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 7 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 8 58

What is a Hopf algebra

A structure which is both an algebra and a coalgebra where thesestructures get along in a compatible way

Idea what if we focus on Hopf algebras with a particularly simplecoalgebra structure

Let H be finite (ie finitely generated and free) R-Hopf algebra Anelement t isin H is primitive if

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Necessarily if t isin P(H) then ε(t) = 0 and λ(t) = minust

Let P(H) be the set of all primitive elements of H

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 9 58

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Exercise 1 Show P(H) = Rt

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Exercise 2 Show P(H) = Rt + Rtp + middot middot middot+ Rtpnminus1

Example

Let H = R[t1 t2 tn](tp1 t

p2 t

pn ) ∆(ti) = ti otimes 1 + 1 otimes ti

Exercise 3 Describe P(H) as an R-module

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 10 58

ExampleLet H = RΓ Γ an abelian p-group (or any finite group)

Exercise 4 Describe P(H) as an R-module

ExampleLet R be a domain and H = RClowast

p = HomR(RCpR) Cp = 〈σ〉Let

t =pminus1983142

i=1

i983185i

where 983185i(σj) = δij

Exercise 5 Show that H = R[t ](tp minus t) and P(H) = Rt

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 11 58

Properties of P(H)

1 P(H) cap R = 02 t u isin P(H) rArr t + u isin P(H)3 t isin P(H) r isin R rArr rt isin P(H)4 P(H) is an R-submodule of H5 If R is a PID then P(H) is free over R6 t isin P(H) rArr tp isin P(H)

Exercise 6 Prove any subset of the above

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 12 58

Consider

HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H)

where x isin R[x ] is primitive

There is a map HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) rarr P(H) given by

f 983347rarr f (x)

which is an isomorphism

Define a map F HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) rarr HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) by

F (f )(x) = f (xp) = (f (x))p

This induces a map t 983347rarr tp in P(H) which we will also denote F andcall the Frobenius map

Note F (rx) = rpF (x) for all r isin R

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 13 58

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t Then P(H) = Rt and F (t) = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Then P(H) = Rt + Rtp + middot middot middot+ Rtpnminus1and F (tpi

) = tpi+1

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t Then P(H) = Rt and F (t) = tp = t

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 14 58

For any H the group P(H) has an R-module structure and is actedupon by F

Thus H is an R[F ]-module where R[F ] is the non-commutative ring ofpolynomials with

Fr = rpF

for all r isin R

Now suppose φ H1 rarr H2 is a Hopf algebra homomorphism Thenφ(P(H1)) sube φ(P(H2)) Furthermore for t isin P(H1)

Fφ(t) = φ(Ft)

so φ commutes with F

Thus φ983066983066983066P(H1)

is an R[F ]-module map

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 58

Therefore we have a functor

R-Hopf alg rarr R[F ]-modulesH rarr P(H)

which is not a categorical equivalence

Exercise 7 Show that RC2p and RCp2 correspond to the same

R[F ]-module

Exercise 8 Show that the R[F ]-module (R[F ])[X ] does notcorrespond to any Hopf algebra H

We will get a categorical equivalence by restricting the objects in bothcategories

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 58

We say H is primitively generated if no proper subalgebra of Hcontains P(H)Famous examples

1 H = R[t ](tp) t isin P(H)2 H = R[t ](tpn

) t isin P(H)3 H = R[t1 tn](t

pr1

1 tprn

n ) ti isin P(H)4 H = RClowast

p

5 H = R(Cnp )

lowast

Exercise 9 Let H = R[t ](tp2) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This is a Hopf algebra (not the exercise) Show that H is not primitivelygenerated (yes the exercise)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 58

From here on we suppose H is primitively generated and R is a PID

Then P(H) is free over R and of finite type over R[F ]

So the functor from before can restrict to983080

primitively generatedR-Hopf algebras

983081minusrarr

983080R[F ]-modules of finite type

free over R

983081

We claim this is a categorical equivalence

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 58

H 983347rarr P(H)

We will construct an inverse

Let M be an R[F ]-module of finite type free over R

Let e1 e2 en be an R-basis for M

For 1 le i j le n pick aij isin R such that

Fei =n983142

j=1

ajiej

Let

H = R[t1 t2 tn](tpi minus

n983142

j=1

aji tj)

with ti primitive for all i

Then after identifying ti with ei P(H) = M

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 58

We will call any R[F ]-module of finite type over R a Dieudonneacute module

We will write

Dlowast(H) = P(H)

Question Why not simply call the functor P(minus)

For clarity so we may better differentiate H from its DieudonneacutemoduleTo get the audience used to Dlowast which will be used extensivelyover the next few days (and usually wonrsquot mean P(minus))

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 58

Properties of Dlowast

1 Dlowast is covariant (although this is typically referred to as an exampleof a ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo)

2 If G = Spec(H) then the Dieudonneacute module isM = HomR-gr(GGa) where Ga is the additive group schemeSo Spec(H) 983347rarr Dlowast(H) is a contravariant functor

3 Dlowast is an exact functor4 Dlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)5 rankR H = prankR M

6 Dlowast respects base change (explained later)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 58

Some examples

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) t primitive

Then P(H) is generated as a free R-module by t tp tp2 tpnminus1

If we write ei = tpi 0 le i le n minus 1 then

Dlowast(H) =nminus1983131

i=0

Rei Fei = ei+1 Fenminus1 = 0

where i lt n minus 1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 58

Some more examples

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = e

ExampleLet M = Re1 oplus Re2 with

Fe1 = e2 Fe2 = e1

Then the corresponding Hopf algebra is

H = R[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) sim= R[t ](tp2 minus t)

with t primitiveNote that if Fp2 sube R then H = RClowast

p2

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 58

Consider the following problem for a fixed n find all primitivelygenerated R-Hopf algebras of rank pn

Equivalently find all R[F ] modules which are free rank n over R

These can be described with matrices

Let M be a free R-module basis e1 en Pick a matrix A isin Mn(R)and use it to define an F -action on M by

Fei = Aei

Then M corresponds to a Hopf algebra which can be quicklycomputed

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 58

Each element of Mn(R) gives a Hopf algebra

Conversely each Hopf algebra gives a matrix

However different choices of matrices can give the same Hopf algebra

It can be shown (as it was in Exeter) that AB isin Mn(R) give the sameHopf algebra if any only if there is a Θ isin Mn(R)times such that

B = Θminus1AΘ(p) where Θ = (θij) rArr Θp = (θpij)

Thus a parameter space for primitively generated Hopf algebras ofrank pn is Mn(R) sim where sim is the relation above

Presumably this allows for a count of Hopf algebras for certain R egR is a finite field

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 7: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Possible readings for this talk

A Grothendieck Seacuteminaire de Geacuteomeacutetrie Algeacutebrique duBois-Marie 1967ndash1969 (SGA 7) - Groupes de monodromie engeacuteomeacutetrie algeacutebrique Lecture notes in mathematics 288 BerlinNew York Springer-Verlag (Apparently)AJ de Jong Finite locally free group schemes in characteristic pand Dieudonneacute modules Invent mathematicae 1993 Volume114 Issue 1 pp 89ndash137M Rapoport Formal moduli spaces in equal characteristichttpsmathberkeleyedu aaronlivetexfmsiecpdf

Listed in decreasing order of the amount of algebraic geometryneeded as background

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 7 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 8 58

What is a Hopf algebra

A structure which is both an algebra and a coalgebra where thesestructures get along in a compatible way

Idea what if we focus on Hopf algebras with a particularly simplecoalgebra structure

Let H be finite (ie finitely generated and free) R-Hopf algebra Anelement t isin H is primitive if

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Necessarily if t isin P(H) then ε(t) = 0 and λ(t) = minust

Let P(H) be the set of all primitive elements of H

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 9 58

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Exercise 1 Show P(H) = Rt

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Exercise 2 Show P(H) = Rt + Rtp + middot middot middot+ Rtpnminus1

Example

Let H = R[t1 t2 tn](tp1 t

p2 t

pn ) ∆(ti) = ti otimes 1 + 1 otimes ti

Exercise 3 Describe P(H) as an R-module

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 10 58

ExampleLet H = RΓ Γ an abelian p-group (or any finite group)

Exercise 4 Describe P(H) as an R-module

ExampleLet R be a domain and H = RClowast

p = HomR(RCpR) Cp = 〈σ〉Let

t =pminus1983142

i=1

i983185i

where 983185i(σj) = δij

Exercise 5 Show that H = R[t ](tp minus t) and P(H) = Rt

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 11 58

Properties of P(H)

1 P(H) cap R = 02 t u isin P(H) rArr t + u isin P(H)3 t isin P(H) r isin R rArr rt isin P(H)4 P(H) is an R-submodule of H5 If R is a PID then P(H) is free over R6 t isin P(H) rArr tp isin P(H)

Exercise 6 Prove any subset of the above

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 12 58

Consider

HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H)

where x isin R[x ] is primitive

There is a map HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) rarr P(H) given by

f 983347rarr f (x)

which is an isomorphism

Define a map F HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) rarr HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) by

F (f )(x) = f (xp) = (f (x))p

This induces a map t 983347rarr tp in P(H) which we will also denote F andcall the Frobenius map

Note F (rx) = rpF (x) for all r isin R

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 13 58

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t Then P(H) = Rt and F (t) = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Then P(H) = Rt + Rtp + middot middot middot+ Rtpnminus1and F (tpi

) = tpi+1

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t Then P(H) = Rt and F (t) = tp = t

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 14 58

For any H the group P(H) has an R-module structure and is actedupon by F

Thus H is an R[F ]-module where R[F ] is the non-commutative ring ofpolynomials with

Fr = rpF

for all r isin R

Now suppose φ H1 rarr H2 is a Hopf algebra homomorphism Thenφ(P(H1)) sube φ(P(H2)) Furthermore for t isin P(H1)

Fφ(t) = φ(Ft)

so φ commutes with F

Thus φ983066983066983066P(H1)

is an R[F ]-module map

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 58

Therefore we have a functor

R-Hopf alg rarr R[F ]-modulesH rarr P(H)

which is not a categorical equivalence

Exercise 7 Show that RC2p and RCp2 correspond to the same

R[F ]-module

Exercise 8 Show that the R[F ]-module (R[F ])[X ] does notcorrespond to any Hopf algebra H

We will get a categorical equivalence by restricting the objects in bothcategories

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 58

We say H is primitively generated if no proper subalgebra of Hcontains P(H)Famous examples

1 H = R[t ](tp) t isin P(H)2 H = R[t ](tpn

) t isin P(H)3 H = R[t1 tn](t

pr1

1 tprn

n ) ti isin P(H)4 H = RClowast

p

5 H = R(Cnp )

lowast

Exercise 9 Let H = R[t ](tp2) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This is a Hopf algebra (not the exercise) Show that H is not primitivelygenerated (yes the exercise)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 58

From here on we suppose H is primitively generated and R is a PID

Then P(H) is free over R and of finite type over R[F ]

So the functor from before can restrict to983080

primitively generatedR-Hopf algebras

983081minusrarr

983080R[F ]-modules of finite type

free over R

983081

We claim this is a categorical equivalence

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 58

H 983347rarr P(H)

We will construct an inverse

Let M be an R[F ]-module of finite type free over R

Let e1 e2 en be an R-basis for M

For 1 le i j le n pick aij isin R such that

Fei =n983142

j=1

ajiej

Let

H = R[t1 t2 tn](tpi minus

n983142

j=1

aji tj)

with ti primitive for all i

Then after identifying ti with ei P(H) = M

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 58

We will call any R[F ]-module of finite type over R a Dieudonneacute module

We will write

Dlowast(H) = P(H)

Question Why not simply call the functor P(minus)

For clarity so we may better differentiate H from its DieudonneacutemoduleTo get the audience used to Dlowast which will be used extensivelyover the next few days (and usually wonrsquot mean P(minus))

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 58

Properties of Dlowast

1 Dlowast is covariant (although this is typically referred to as an exampleof a ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo)

2 If G = Spec(H) then the Dieudonneacute module isM = HomR-gr(GGa) where Ga is the additive group schemeSo Spec(H) 983347rarr Dlowast(H) is a contravariant functor

3 Dlowast is an exact functor4 Dlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)5 rankR H = prankR M

6 Dlowast respects base change (explained later)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 58

Some examples

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) t primitive

Then P(H) is generated as a free R-module by t tp tp2 tpnminus1

If we write ei = tpi 0 le i le n minus 1 then

Dlowast(H) =nminus1983131

i=0

Rei Fei = ei+1 Fenminus1 = 0

where i lt n minus 1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 58

Some more examples

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = e

ExampleLet M = Re1 oplus Re2 with

Fe1 = e2 Fe2 = e1

Then the corresponding Hopf algebra is

H = R[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) sim= R[t ](tp2 minus t)

with t primitiveNote that if Fp2 sube R then H = RClowast

p2

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 58

Consider the following problem for a fixed n find all primitivelygenerated R-Hopf algebras of rank pn

Equivalently find all R[F ] modules which are free rank n over R

These can be described with matrices

Let M be a free R-module basis e1 en Pick a matrix A isin Mn(R)and use it to define an F -action on M by

Fei = Aei

Then M corresponds to a Hopf algebra which can be quicklycomputed

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 58

Each element of Mn(R) gives a Hopf algebra

Conversely each Hopf algebra gives a matrix

However different choices of matrices can give the same Hopf algebra

It can be shown (as it was in Exeter) that AB isin Mn(R) give the sameHopf algebra if any only if there is a Θ isin Mn(R)times such that

B = Θminus1AΘ(p) where Θ = (θij) rArr Θp = (θpij)

Thus a parameter space for primitively generated Hopf algebras ofrank pn is Mn(R) sim where sim is the relation above

Presumably this allows for a count of Hopf algebras for certain R egR is a finite field

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 8: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 8 58

What is a Hopf algebra

A structure which is both an algebra and a coalgebra where thesestructures get along in a compatible way

Idea what if we focus on Hopf algebras with a particularly simplecoalgebra structure

Let H be finite (ie finitely generated and free) R-Hopf algebra Anelement t isin H is primitive if

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Necessarily if t isin P(H) then ε(t) = 0 and λ(t) = minust

Let P(H) be the set of all primitive elements of H

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 9 58

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Exercise 1 Show P(H) = Rt

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Exercise 2 Show P(H) = Rt + Rtp + middot middot middot+ Rtpnminus1

Example

Let H = R[t1 t2 tn](tp1 t

p2 t

pn ) ∆(ti) = ti otimes 1 + 1 otimes ti

Exercise 3 Describe P(H) as an R-module

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 10 58

ExampleLet H = RΓ Γ an abelian p-group (or any finite group)

Exercise 4 Describe P(H) as an R-module

ExampleLet R be a domain and H = RClowast

p = HomR(RCpR) Cp = 〈σ〉Let

t =pminus1983142

i=1

i983185i

where 983185i(σj) = δij

Exercise 5 Show that H = R[t ](tp minus t) and P(H) = Rt

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 11 58

Properties of P(H)

1 P(H) cap R = 02 t u isin P(H) rArr t + u isin P(H)3 t isin P(H) r isin R rArr rt isin P(H)4 P(H) is an R-submodule of H5 If R is a PID then P(H) is free over R6 t isin P(H) rArr tp isin P(H)

Exercise 6 Prove any subset of the above

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 12 58

Consider

HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H)

where x isin R[x ] is primitive

There is a map HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) rarr P(H) given by

f 983347rarr f (x)

which is an isomorphism

Define a map F HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) rarr HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) by

F (f )(x) = f (xp) = (f (x))p

This induces a map t 983347rarr tp in P(H) which we will also denote F andcall the Frobenius map

Note F (rx) = rpF (x) for all r isin R

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 13 58

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t Then P(H) = Rt and F (t) = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Then P(H) = Rt + Rtp + middot middot middot+ Rtpnminus1and F (tpi

) = tpi+1

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t Then P(H) = Rt and F (t) = tp = t

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 14 58

For any H the group P(H) has an R-module structure and is actedupon by F

Thus H is an R[F ]-module where R[F ] is the non-commutative ring ofpolynomials with

Fr = rpF

for all r isin R

Now suppose φ H1 rarr H2 is a Hopf algebra homomorphism Thenφ(P(H1)) sube φ(P(H2)) Furthermore for t isin P(H1)

Fφ(t) = φ(Ft)

so φ commutes with F

Thus φ983066983066983066P(H1)

is an R[F ]-module map

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 58

Therefore we have a functor

R-Hopf alg rarr R[F ]-modulesH rarr P(H)

which is not a categorical equivalence

Exercise 7 Show that RC2p and RCp2 correspond to the same

R[F ]-module

Exercise 8 Show that the R[F ]-module (R[F ])[X ] does notcorrespond to any Hopf algebra H

We will get a categorical equivalence by restricting the objects in bothcategories

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 58

We say H is primitively generated if no proper subalgebra of Hcontains P(H)Famous examples

1 H = R[t ](tp) t isin P(H)2 H = R[t ](tpn

) t isin P(H)3 H = R[t1 tn](t

pr1

1 tprn

n ) ti isin P(H)4 H = RClowast

p

5 H = R(Cnp )

lowast

Exercise 9 Let H = R[t ](tp2) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This is a Hopf algebra (not the exercise) Show that H is not primitivelygenerated (yes the exercise)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 58

From here on we suppose H is primitively generated and R is a PID

Then P(H) is free over R and of finite type over R[F ]

So the functor from before can restrict to983080

primitively generatedR-Hopf algebras

983081minusrarr

983080R[F ]-modules of finite type

free over R

983081

We claim this is a categorical equivalence

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 58

H 983347rarr P(H)

We will construct an inverse

Let M be an R[F ]-module of finite type free over R

Let e1 e2 en be an R-basis for M

For 1 le i j le n pick aij isin R such that

Fei =n983142

j=1

ajiej

Let

H = R[t1 t2 tn](tpi minus

n983142

j=1

aji tj)

with ti primitive for all i

Then after identifying ti with ei P(H) = M

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 58

We will call any R[F ]-module of finite type over R a Dieudonneacute module

We will write

Dlowast(H) = P(H)

Question Why not simply call the functor P(minus)

For clarity so we may better differentiate H from its DieudonneacutemoduleTo get the audience used to Dlowast which will be used extensivelyover the next few days (and usually wonrsquot mean P(minus))

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 58

Properties of Dlowast

1 Dlowast is covariant (although this is typically referred to as an exampleof a ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo)

2 If G = Spec(H) then the Dieudonneacute module isM = HomR-gr(GGa) where Ga is the additive group schemeSo Spec(H) 983347rarr Dlowast(H) is a contravariant functor

3 Dlowast is an exact functor4 Dlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)5 rankR H = prankR M

6 Dlowast respects base change (explained later)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 58

Some examples

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) t primitive

Then P(H) is generated as a free R-module by t tp tp2 tpnminus1

If we write ei = tpi 0 le i le n minus 1 then

Dlowast(H) =nminus1983131

i=0

Rei Fei = ei+1 Fenminus1 = 0

where i lt n minus 1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 58

Some more examples

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = e

ExampleLet M = Re1 oplus Re2 with

Fe1 = e2 Fe2 = e1

Then the corresponding Hopf algebra is

H = R[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) sim= R[t ](tp2 minus t)

with t primitiveNote that if Fp2 sube R then H = RClowast

p2

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 58

Consider the following problem for a fixed n find all primitivelygenerated R-Hopf algebras of rank pn

Equivalently find all R[F ] modules which are free rank n over R

These can be described with matrices

Let M be a free R-module basis e1 en Pick a matrix A isin Mn(R)and use it to define an F -action on M by

Fei = Aei

Then M corresponds to a Hopf algebra which can be quicklycomputed

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 58

Each element of Mn(R) gives a Hopf algebra

Conversely each Hopf algebra gives a matrix

However different choices of matrices can give the same Hopf algebra

It can be shown (as it was in Exeter) that AB isin Mn(R) give the sameHopf algebra if any only if there is a Θ isin Mn(R)times such that

B = Θminus1AΘ(p) where Θ = (θij) rArr Θp = (θpij)

Thus a parameter space for primitively generated Hopf algebras ofrank pn is Mn(R) sim where sim is the relation above

Presumably this allows for a count of Hopf algebras for certain R egR is a finite field

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 9: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

What is a Hopf algebra

A structure which is both an algebra and a coalgebra where thesestructures get along in a compatible way

Idea what if we focus on Hopf algebras with a particularly simplecoalgebra structure

Let H be finite (ie finitely generated and free) R-Hopf algebra Anelement t isin H is primitive if

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Necessarily if t isin P(H) then ε(t) = 0 and λ(t) = minust

Let P(H) be the set of all primitive elements of H

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 9 58

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Exercise 1 Show P(H) = Rt

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Exercise 2 Show P(H) = Rt + Rtp + middot middot middot+ Rtpnminus1

Example

Let H = R[t1 t2 tn](tp1 t

p2 t

pn ) ∆(ti) = ti otimes 1 + 1 otimes ti

Exercise 3 Describe P(H) as an R-module

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 10 58

ExampleLet H = RΓ Γ an abelian p-group (or any finite group)

Exercise 4 Describe P(H) as an R-module

ExampleLet R be a domain and H = RClowast

p = HomR(RCpR) Cp = 〈σ〉Let

t =pminus1983142

i=1

i983185i

where 983185i(σj) = δij

Exercise 5 Show that H = R[t ](tp minus t) and P(H) = Rt

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 11 58

Properties of P(H)

1 P(H) cap R = 02 t u isin P(H) rArr t + u isin P(H)3 t isin P(H) r isin R rArr rt isin P(H)4 P(H) is an R-submodule of H5 If R is a PID then P(H) is free over R6 t isin P(H) rArr tp isin P(H)

Exercise 6 Prove any subset of the above

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 12 58

Consider

HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H)

where x isin R[x ] is primitive

There is a map HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) rarr P(H) given by

f 983347rarr f (x)

which is an isomorphism

Define a map F HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) rarr HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) by

F (f )(x) = f (xp) = (f (x))p

This induces a map t 983347rarr tp in P(H) which we will also denote F andcall the Frobenius map

Note F (rx) = rpF (x) for all r isin R

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 13 58

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t Then P(H) = Rt and F (t) = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Then P(H) = Rt + Rtp + middot middot middot+ Rtpnminus1and F (tpi

) = tpi+1

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t Then P(H) = Rt and F (t) = tp = t

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 14 58

For any H the group P(H) has an R-module structure and is actedupon by F

Thus H is an R[F ]-module where R[F ] is the non-commutative ring ofpolynomials with

Fr = rpF

for all r isin R

Now suppose φ H1 rarr H2 is a Hopf algebra homomorphism Thenφ(P(H1)) sube φ(P(H2)) Furthermore for t isin P(H1)

Fφ(t) = φ(Ft)

so φ commutes with F

Thus φ983066983066983066P(H1)

is an R[F ]-module map

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 58

Therefore we have a functor

R-Hopf alg rarr R[F ]-modulesH rarr P(H)

which is not a categorical equivalence

Exercise 7 Show that RC2p and RCp2 correspond to the same

R[F ]-module

Exercise 8 Show that the R[F ]-module (R[F ])[X ] does notcorrespond to any Hopf algebra H

We will get a categorical equivalence by restricting the objects in bothcategories

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 58

We say H is primitively generated if no proper subalgebra of Hcontains P(H)Famous examples

1 H = R[t ](tp) t isin P(H)2 H = R[t ](tpn

) t isin P(H)3 H = R[t1 tn](t

pr1

1 tprn

n ) ti isin P(H)4 H = RClowast

p

5 H = R(Cnp )

lowast

Exercise 9 Let H = R[t ](tp2) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This is a Hopf algebra (not the exercise) Show that H is not primitivelygenerated (yes the exercise)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 58

From here on we suppose H is primitively generated and R is a PID

Then P(H) is free over R and of finite type over R[F ]

So the functor from before can restrict to983080

primitively generatedR-Hopf algebras

983081minusrarr

983080R[F ]-modules of finite type

free over R

983081

We claim this is a categorical equivalence

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 58

H 983347rarr P(H)

We will construct an inverse

Let M be an R[F ]-module of finite type free over R

Let e1 e2 en be an R-basis for M

For 1 le i j le n pick aij isin R such that

Fei =n983142

j=1

ajiej

Let

H = R[t1 t2 tn](tpi minus

n983142

j=1

aji tj)

with ti primitive for all i

Then after identifying ti with ei P(H) = M

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 58

We will call any R[F ]-module of finite type over R a Dieudonneacute module

We will write

Dlowast(H) = P(H)

Question Why not simply call the functor P(minus)

For clarity so we may better differentiate H from its DieudonneacutemoduleTo get the audience used to Dlowast which will be used extensivelyover the next few days (and usually wonrsquot mean P(minus))

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 58

Properties of Dlowast

1 Dlowast is covariant (although this is typically referred to as an exampleof a ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo)

2 If G = Spec(H) then the Dieudonneacute module isM = HomR-gr(GGa) where Ga is the additive group schemeSo Spec(H) 983347rarr Dlowast(H) is a contravariant functor

3 Dlowast is an exact functor4 Dlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)5 rankR H = prankR M

6 Dlowast respects base change (explained later)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 58

Some examples

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) t primitive

Then P(H) is generated as a free R-module by t tp tp2 tpnminus1

If we write ei = tpi 0 le i le n minus 1 then

Dlowast(H) =nminus1983131

i=0

Rei Fei = ei+1 Fenminus1 = 0

where i lt n minus 1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 58

Some more examples

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = e

ExampleLet M = Re1 oplus Re2 with

Fe1 = e2 Fe2 = e1

Then the corresponding Hopf algebra is

H = R[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) sim= R[t ](tp2 minus t)

with t primitiveNote that if Fp2 sube R then H = RClowast

p2

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 58

Consider the following problem for a fixed n find all primitivelygenerated R-Hopf algebras of rank pn

Equivalently find all R[F ] modules which are free rank n over R

These can be described with matrices

Let M be a free R-module basis e1 en Pick a matrix A isin Mn(R)and use it to define an F -action on M by

Fei = Aei

Then M corresponds to a Hopf algebra which can be quicklycomputed

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 58

Each element of Mn(R) gives a Hopf algebra

Conversely each Hopf algebra gives a matrix

However different choices of matrices can give the same Hopf algebra

It can be shown (as it was in Exeter) that AB isin Mn(R) give the sameHopf algebra if any only if there is a Θ isin Mn(R)times such that

B = Θminus1AΘ(p) where Θ = (θij) rArr Θp = (θpij)

Thus a parameter space for primitively generated Hopf algebras ofrank pn is Mn(R) sim where sim is the relation above

Presumably this allows for a count of Hopf algebras for certain R egR is a finite field

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 10: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Exercise 1 Show P(H) = Rt

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Exercise 2 Show P(H) = Rt + Rtp + middot middot middot+ Rtpnminus1

Example

Let H = R[t1 t2 tn](tp1 t

p2 t

pn ) ∆(ti) = ti otimes 1 + 1 otimes ti

Exercise 3 Describe P(H) as an R-module

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 10 58

ExampleLet H = RΓ Γ an abelian p-group (or any finite group)

Exercise 4 Describe P(H) as an R-module

ExampleLet R be a domain and H = RClowast

p = HomR(RCpR) Cp = 〈σ〉Let

t =pminus1983142

i=1

i983185i

where 983185i(σj) = δij

Exercise 5 Show that H = R[t ](tp minus t) and P(H) = Rt

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 11 58

Properties of P(H)

1 P(H) cap R = 02 t u isin P(H) rArr t + u isin P(H)3 t isin P(H) r isin R rArr rt isin P(H)4 P(H) is an R-submodule of H5 If R is a PID then P(H) is free over R6 t isin P(H) rArr tp isin P(H)

Exercise 6 Prove any subset of the above

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 12 58

Consider

HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H)

where x isin R[x ] is primitive

There is a map HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) rarr P(H) given by

f 983347rarr f (x)

which is an isomorphism

Define a map F HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) rarr HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) by

F (f )(x) = f (xp) = (f (x))p

This induces a map t 983347rarr tp in P(H) which we will also denote F andcall the Frobenius map

Note F (rx) = rpF (x) for all r isin R

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 13 58

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t Then P(H) = Rt and F (t) = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Then P(H) = Rt + Rtp + middot middot middot+ Rtpnminus1and F (tpi

) = tpi+1

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t Then P(H) = Rt and F (t) = tp = t

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 14 58

For any H the group P(H) has an R-module structure and is actedupon by F

Thus H is an R[F ]-module where R[F ] is the non-commutative ring ofpolynomials with

Fr = rpF

for all r isin R

Now suppose φ H1 rarr H2 is a Hopf algebra homomorphism Thenφ(P(H1)) sube φ(P(H2)) Furthermore for t isin P(H1)

Fφ(t) = φ(Ft)

so φ commutes with F

Thus φ983066983066983066P(H1)

is an R[F ]-module map

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 58

Therefore we have a functor

R-Hopf alg rarr R[F ]-modulesH rarr P(H)

which is not a categorical equivalence

Exercise 7 Show that RC2p and RCp2 correspond to the same

R[F ]-module

Exercise 8 Show that the R[F ]-module (R[F ])[X ] does notcorrespond to any Hopf algebra H

We will get a categorical equivalence by restricting the objects in bothcategories

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 58

We say H is primitively generated if no proper subalgebra of Hcontains P(H)Famous examples

1 H = R[t ](tp) t isin P(H)2 H = R[t ](tpn

) t isin P(H)3 H = R[t1 tn](t

pr1

1 tprn

n ) ti isin P(H)4 H = RClowast

p

5 H = R(Cnp )

lowast

Exercise 9 Let H = R[t ](tp2) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This is a Hopf algebra (not the exercise) Show that H is not primitivelygenerated (yes the exercise)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 58

From here on we suppose H is primitively generated and R is a PID

Then P(H) is free over R and of finite type over R[F ]

So the functor from before can restrict to983080

primitively generatedR-Hopf algebras

983081minusrarr

983080R[F ]-modules of finite type

free over R

983081

We claim this is a categorical equivalence

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 58

H 983347rarr P(H)

We will construct an inverse

Let M be an R[F ]-module of finite type free over R

Let e1 e2 en be an R-basis for M

For 1 le i j le n pick aij isin R such that

Fei =n983142

j=1

ajiej

Let

H = R[t1 t2 tn](tpi minus

n983142

j=1

aji tj)

with ti primitive for all i

Then after identifying ti with ei P(H) = M

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 58

We will call any R[F ]-module of finite type over R a Dieudonneacute module

We will write

Dlowast(H) = P(H)

Question Why not simply call the functor P(minus)

For clarity so we may better differentiate H from its DieudonneacutemoduleTo get the audience used to Dlowast which will be used extensivelyover the next few days (and usually wonrsquot mean P(minus))

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 58

Properties of Dlowast

1 Dlowast is covariant (although this is typically referred to as an exampleof a ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo)

2 If G = Spec(H) then the Dieudonneacute module isM = HomR-gr(GGa) where Ga is the additive group schemeSo Spec(H) 983347rarr Dlowast(H) is a contravariant functor

3 Dlowast is an exact functor4 Dlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)5 rankR H = prankR M

6 Dlowast respects base change (explained later)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 58

Some examples

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) t primitive

Then P(H) is generated as a free R-module by t tp tp2 tpnminus1

If we write ei = tpi 0 le i le n minus 1 then

Dlowast(H) =nminus1983131

i=0

Rei Fei = ei+1 Fenminus1 = 0

where i lt n minus 1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 58

Some more examples

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = e

ExampleLet M = Re1 oplus Re2 with

Fe1 = e2 Fe2 = e1

Then the corresponding Hopf algebra is

H = R[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) sim= R[t ](tp2 minus t)

with t primitiveNote that if Fp2 sube R then H = RClowast

p2

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 58

Consider the following problem for a fixed n find all primitivelygenerated R-Hopf algebras of rank pn

Equivalently find all R[F ] modules which are free rank n over R

These can be described with matrices

Let M be a free R-module basis e1 en Pick a matrix A isin Mn(R)and use it to define an F -action on M by

Fei = Aei

Then M corresponds to a Hopf algebra which can be quicklycomputed

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 58

Each element of Mn(R) gives a Hopf algebra

Conversely each Hopf algebra gives a matrix

However different choices of matrices can give the same Hopf algebra

It can be shown (as it was in Exeter) that AB isin Mn(R) give the sameHopf algebra if any only if there is a Θ isin Mn(R)times such that

B = Θminus1AΘ(p) where Θ = (θij) rArr Θp = (θpij)

Thus a parameter space for primitively generated Hopf algebras ofrank pn is Mn(R) sim where sim is the relation above

Presumably this allows for a count of Hopf algebras for certain R egR is a finite field

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 11: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

ExampleLet H = RΓ Γ an abelian p-group (or any finite group)

Exercise 4 Describe P(H) as an R-module

ExampleLet R be a domain and H = RClowast

p = HomR(RCpR) Cp = 〈σ〉Let

t =pminus1983142

i=1

i983185i

where 983185i(σj) = δij

Exercise 5 Show that H = R[t ](tp minus t) and P(H) = Rt

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 11 58

Properties of P(H)

1 P(H) cap R = 02 t u isin P(H) rArr t + u isin P(H)3 t isin P(H) r isin R rArr rt isin P(H)4 P(H) is an R-submodule of H5 If R is a PID then P(H) is free over R6 t isin P(H) rArr tp isin P(H)

Exercise 6 Prove any subset of the above

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 12 58

Consider

HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H)

where x isin R[x ] is primitive

There is a map HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) rarr P(H) given by

f 983347rarr f (x)

which is an isomorphism

Define a map F HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) rarr HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) by

F (f )(x) = f (xp) = (f (x))p

This induces a map t 983347rarr tp in P(H) which we will also denote F andcall the Frobenius map

Note F (rx) = rpF (x) for all r isin R

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 13 58

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t Then P(H) = Rt and F (t) = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Then P(H) = Rt + Rtp + middot middot middot+ Rtpnminus1and F (tpi

) = tpi+1

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t Then P(H) = Rt and F (t) = tp = t

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 14 58

For any H the group P(H) has an R-module structure and is actedupon by F

Thus H is an R[F ]-module where R[F ] is the non-commutative ring ofpolynomials with

Fr = rpF

for all r isin R

Now suppose φ H1 rarr H2 is a Hopf algebra homomorphism Thenφ(P(H1)) sube φ(P(H2)) Furthermore for t isin P(H1)

Fφ(t) = φ(Ft)

so φ commutes with F

Thus φ983066983066983066P(H1)

is an R[F ]-module map

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 58

Therefore we have a functor

R-Hopf alg rarr R[F ]-modulesH rarr P(H)

which is not a categorical equivalence

Exercise 7 Show that RC2p and RCp2 correspond to the same

R[F ]-module

Exercise 8 Show that the R[F ]-module (R[F ])[X ] does notcorrespond to any Hopf algebra H

We will get a categorical equivalence by restricting the objects in bothcategories

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 58

We say H is primitively generated if no proper subalgebra of Hcontains P(H)Famous examples

1 H = R[t ](tp) t isin P(H)2 H = R[t ](tpn

) t isin P(H)3 H = R[t1 tn](t

pr1

1 tprn

n ) ti isin P(H)4 H = RClowast

p

5 H = R(Cnp )

lowast

Exercise 9 Let H = R[t ](tp2) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This is a Hopf algebra (not the exercise) Show that H is not primitivelygenerated (yes the exercise)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 58

From here on we suppose H is primitively generated and R is a PID

Then P(H) is free over R and of finite type over R[F ]

So the functor from before can restrict to983080

primitively generatedR-Hopf algebras

983081minusrarr

983080R[F ]-modules of finite type

free over R

983081

We claim this is a categorical equivalence

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 58

H 983347rarr P(H)

We will construct an inverse

Let M be an R[F ]-module of finite type free over R

Let e1 e2 en be an R-basis for M

For 1 le i j le n pick aij isin R such that

Fei =n983142

j=1

ajiej

Let

H = R[t1 t2 tn](tpi minus

n983142

j=1

aji tj)

with ti primitive for all i

Then after identifying ti with ei P(H) = M

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 58

We will call any R[F ]-module of finite type over R a Dieudonneacute module

We will write

Dlowast(H) = P(H)

Question Why not simply call the functor P(minus)

For clarity so we may better differentiate H from its DieudonneacutemoduleTo get the audience used to Dlowast which will be used extensivelyover the next few days (and usually wonrsquot mean P(minus))

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 58

Properties of Dlowast

1 Dlowast is covariant (although this is typically referred to as an exampleof a ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo)

2 If G = Spec(H) then the Dieudonneacute module isM = HomR-gr(GGa) where Ga is the additive group schemeSo Spec(H) 983347rarr Dlowast(H) is a contravariant functor

3 Dlowast is an exact functor4 Dlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)5 rankR H = prankR M

6 Dlowast respects base change (explained later)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 58

Some examples

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) t primitive

Then P(H) is generated as a free R-module by t tp tp2 tpnminus1

If we write ei = tpi 0 le i le n minus 1 then

Dlowast(H) =nminus1983131

i=0

Rei Fei = ei+1 Fenminus1 = 0

where i lt n minus 1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 58

Some more examples

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = e

ExampleLet M = Re1 oplus Re2 with

Fe1 = e2 Fe2 = e1

Then the corresponding Hopf algebra is

H = R[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) sim= R[t ](tp2 minus t)

with t primitiveNote that if Fp2 sube R then H = RClowast

p2

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 58

Consider the following problem for a fixed n find all primitivelygenerated R-Hopf algebras of rank pn

Equivalently find all R[F ] modules which are free rank n over R

These can be described with matrices

Let M be a free R-module basis e1 en Pick a matrix A isin Mn(R)and use it to define an F -action on M by

Fei = Aei

Then M corresponds to a Hopf algebra which can be quicklycomputed

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 58

Each element of Mn(R) gives a Hopf algebra

Conversely each Hopf algebra gives a matrix

However different choices of matrices can give the same Hopf algebra

It can be shown (as it was in Exeter) that AB isin Mn(R) give the sameHopf algebra if any only if there is a Θ isin Mn(R)times such that

B = Θminus1AΘ(p) where Θ = (θij) rArr Θp = (θpij)

Thus a parameter space for primitively generated Hopf algebras ofrank pn is Mn(R) sim where sim is the relation above

Presumably this allows for a count of Hopf algebras for certain R egR is a finite field

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 12: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Properties of P(H)

1 P(H) cap R = 02 t u isin P(H) rArr t + u isin P(H)3 t isin P(H) r isin R rArr rt isin P(H)4 P(H) is an R-submodule of H5 If R is a PID then P(H) is free over R6 t isin P(H) rArr tp isin P(H)

Exercise 6 Prove any subset of the above

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 12 58

Consider

HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H)

where x isin R[x ] is primitive

There is a map HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) rarr P(H) given by

f 983347rarr f (x)

which is an isomorphism

Define a map F HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) rarr HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) by

F (f )(x) = f (xp) = (f (x))p

This induces a map t 983347rarr tp in P(H) which we will also denote F andcall the Frobenius map

Note F (rx) = rpF (x) for all r isin R

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 13 58

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t Then P(H) = Rt and F (t) = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Then P(H) = Rt + Rtp + middot middot middot+ Rtpnminus1and F (tpi

) = tpi+1

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t Then P(H) = Rt and F (t) = tp = t

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 14 58

For any H the group P(H) has an R-module structure and is actedupon by F

Thus H is an R[F ]-module where R[F ] is the non-commutative ring ofpolynomials with

Fr = rpF

for all r isin R

Now suppose φ H1 rarr H2 is a Hopf algebra homomorphism Thenφ(P(H1)) sube φ(P(H2)) Furthermore for t isin P(H1)

Fφ(t) = φ(Ft)

so φ commutes with F

Thus φ983066983066983066P(H1)

is an R[F ]-module map

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 58

Therefore we have a functor

R-Hopf alg rarr R[F ]-modulesH rarr P(H)

which is not a categorical equivalence

Exercise 7 Show that RC2p and RCp2 correspond to the same

R[F ]-module

Exercise 8 Show that the R[F ]-module (R[F ])[X ] does notcorrespond to any Hopf algebra H

We will get a categorical equivalence by restricting the objects in bothcategories

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 58

We say H is primitively generated if no proper subalgebra of Hcontains P(H)Famous examples

1 H = R[t ](tp) t isin P(H)2 H = R[t ](tpn

) t isin P(H)3 H = R[t1 tn](t

pr1

1 tprn

n ) ti isin P(H)4 H = RClowast

p

5 H = R(Cnp )

lowast

Exercise 9 Let H = R[t ](tp2) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This is a Hopf algebra (not the exercise) Show that H is not primitivelygenerated (yes the exercise)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 58

From here on we suppose H is primitively generated and R is a PID

Then P(H) is free over R and of finite type over R[F ]

So the functor from before can restrict to983080

primitively generatedR-Hopf algebras

983081minusrarr

983080R[F ]-modules of finite type

free over R

983081

We claim this is a categorical equivalence

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 58

H 983347rarr P(H)

We will construct an inverse

Let M be an R[F ]-module of finite type free over R

Let e1 e2 en be an R-basis for M

For 1 le i j le n pick aij isin R such that

Fei =n983142

j=1

ajiej

Let

H = R[t1 t2 tn](tpi minus

n983142

j=1

aji tj)

with ti primitive for all i

Then after identifying ti with ei P(H) = M

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 58

We will call any R[F ]-module of finite type over R a Dieudonneacute module

We will write

Dlowast(H) = P(H)

Question Why not simply call the functor P(minus)

For clarity so we may better differentiate H from its DieudonneacutemoduleTo get the audience used to Dlowast which will be used extensivelyover the next few days (and usually wonrsquot mean P(minus))

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 58

Properties of Dlowast

1 Dlowast is covariant (although this is typically referred to as an exampleof a ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo)

2 If G = Spec(H) then the Dieudonneacute module isM = HomR-gr(GGa) where Ga is the additive group schemeSo Spec(H) 983347rarr Dlowast(H) is a contravariant functor

3 Dlowast is an exact functor4 Dlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)5 rankR H = prankR M

6 Dlowast respects base change (explained later)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 58

Some examples

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) t primitive

Then P(H) is generated as a free R-module by t tp tp2 tpnminus1

If we write ei = tpi 0 le i le n minus 1 then

Dlowast(H) =nminus1983131

i=0

Rei Fei = ei+1 Fenminus1 = 0

where i lt n minus 1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 58

Some more examples

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = e

ExampleLet M = Re1 oplus Re2 with

Fe1 = e2 Fe2 = e1

Then the corresponding Hopf algebra is

H = R[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) sim= R[t ](tp2 minus t)

with t primitiveNote that if Fp2 sube R then H = RClowast

p2

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 58

Consider the following problem for a fixed n find all primitivelygenerated R-Hopf algebras of rank pn

Equivalently find all R[F ] modules which are free rank n over R

These can be described with matrices

Let M be a free R-module basis e1 en Pick a matrix A isin Mn(R)and use it to define an F -action on M by

Fei = Aei

Then M corresponds to a Hopf algebra which can be quicklycomputed

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 58

Each element of Mn(R) gives a Hopf algebra

Conversely each Hopf algebra gives a matrix

However different choices of matrices can give the same Hopf algebra

It can be shown (as it was in Exeter) that AB isin Mn(R) give the sameHopf algebra if any only if there is a Θ isin Mn(R)times such that

B = Θminus1AΘ(p) where Θ = (θij) rArr Θp = (θpij)

Thus a parameter space for primitively generated Hopf algebras ofrank pn is Mn(R) sim where sim is the relation above

Presumably this allows for a count of Hopf algebras for certain R egR is a finite field

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 13: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Consider

HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H)

where x isin R[x ] is primitive

There is a map HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) rarr P(H) given by

f 983347rarr f (x)

which is an isomorphism

Define a map F HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) rarr HomR-Hopf(R[x ]H) by

F (f )(x) = f (xp) = (f (x))p

This induces a map t 983347rarr tp in P(H) which we will also denote F andcall the Frobenius map

Note F (rx) = rpF (x) for all r isin R

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 13 58

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t Then P(H) = Rt and F (t) = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Then P(H) = Rt + Rtp + middot middot middot+ Rtpnminus1and F (tpi

) = tpi+1

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t Then P(H) = Rt and F (t) = tp = t

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 14 58

For any H the group P(H) has an R-module structure and is actedupon by F

Thus H is an R[F ]-module where R[F ] is the non-commutative ring ofpolynomials with

Fr = rpF

for all r isin R

Now suppose φ H1 rarr H2 is a Hopf algebra homomorphism Thenφ(P(H1)) sube φ(P(H2)) Furthermore for t isin P(H1)

Fφ(t) = φ(Ft)

so φ commutes with F

Thus φ983066983066983066P(H1)

is an R[F ]-module map

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 58

Therefore we have a functor

R-Hopf alg rarr R[F ]-modulesH rarr P(H)

which is not a categorical equivalence

Exercise 7 Show that RC2p and RCp2 correspond to the same

R[F ]-module

Exercise 8 Show that the R[F ]-module (R[F ])[X ] does notcorrespond to any Hopf algebra H

We will get a categorical equivalence by restricting the objects in bothcategories

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 58

We say H is primitively generated if no proper subalgebra of Hcontains P(H)Famous examples

1 H = R[t ](tp) t isin P(H)2 H = R[t ](tpn

) t isin P(H)3 H = R[t1 tn](t

pr1

1 tprn

n ) ti isin P(H)4 H = RClowast

p

5 H = R(Cnp )

lowast

Exercise 9 Let H = R[t ](tp2) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This is a Hopf algebra (not the exercise) Show that H is not primitivelygenerated (yes the exercise)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 58

From here on we suppose H is primitively generated and R is a PID

Then P(H) is free over R and of finite type over R[F ]

So the functor from before can restrict to983080

primitively generatedR-Hopf algebras

983081minusrarr

983080R[F ]-modules of finite type

free over R

983081

We claim this is a categorical equivalence

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 58

H 983347rarr P(H)

We will construct an inverse

Let M be an R[F ]-module of finite type free over R

Let e1 e2 en be an R-basis for M

For 1 le i j le n pick aij isin R such that

Fei =n983142

j=1

ajiej

Let

H = R[t1 t2 tn](tpi minus

n983142

j=1

aji tj)

with ti primitive for all i

Then after identifying ti with ei P(H) = M

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 58

We will call any R[F ]-module of finite type over R a Dieudonneacute module

We will write

Dlowast(H) = P(H)

Question Why not simply call the functor P(minus)

For clarity so we may better differentiate H from its DieudonneacutemoduleTo get the audience used to Dlowast which will be used extensivelyover the next few days (and usually wonrsquot mean P(minus))

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 58

Properties of Dlowast

1 Dlowast is covariant (although this is typically referred to as an exampleof a ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo)

2 If G = Spec(H) then the Dieudonneacute module isM = HomR-gr(GGa) where Ga is the additive group schemeSo Spec(H) 983347rarr Dlowast(H) is a contravariant functor

3 Dlowast is an exact functor4 Dlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)5 rankR H = prankR M

6 Dlowast respects base change (explained later)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 58

Some examples

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) t primitive

Then P(H) is generated as a free R-module by t tp tp2 tpnminus1

If we write ei = tpi 0 le i le n minus 1 then

Dlowast(H) =nminus1983131

i=0

Rei Fei = ei+1 Fenminus1 = 0

where i lt n minus 1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 58

Some more examples

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = e

ExampleLet M = Re1 oplus Re2 with

Fe1 = e2 Fe2 = e1

Then the corresponding Hopf algebra is

H = R[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) sim= R[t ](tp2 minus t)

with t primitiveNote that if Fp2 sube R then H = RClowast

p2

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 58

Consider the following problem for a fixed n find all primitivelygenerated R-Hopf algebras of rank pn

Equivalently find all R[F ] modules which are free rank n over R

These can be described with matrices

Let M be a free R-module basis e1 en Pick a matrix A isin Mn(R)and use it to define an F -action on M by

Fei = Aei

Then M corresponds to a Hopf algebra which can be quicklycomputed

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 58

Each element of Mn(R) gives a Hopf algebra

Conversely each Hopf algebra gives a matrix

However different choices of matrices can give the same Hopf algebra

It can be shown (as it was in Exeter) that AB isin Mn(R) give the sameHopf algebra if any only if there is a Θ isin Mn(R)times such that

B = Θminus1AΘ(p) where Θ = (θij) rArr Θp = (θpij)

Thus a parameter space for primitively generated Hopf algebras ofrank pn is Mn(R) sim where sim is the relation above

Presumably this allows for a count of Hopf algebras for certain R egR is a finite field

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 14: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t Then P(H) = Rt and F (t) = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t

Then P(H) = Rt + Rtp + middot middot middot+ Rtpnminus1and F (tpi

) = tpi+1

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) ∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t Then P(H) = Rt and F (t) = tp = t

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 14 58

For any H the group P(H) has an R-module structure and is actedupon by F

Thus H is an R[F ]-module where R[F ] is the non-commutative ring ofpolynomials with

Fr = rpF

for all r isin R

Now suppose φ H1 rarr H2 is a Hopf algebra homomorphism Thenφ(P(H1)) sube φ(P(H2)) Furthermore for t isin P(H1)

Fφ(t) = φ(Ft)

so φ commutes with F

Thus φ983066983066983066P(H1)

is an R[F ]-module map

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 58

Therefore we have a functor

R-Hopf alg rarr R[F ]-modulesH rarr P(H)

which is not a categorical equivalence

Exercise 7 Show that RC2p and RCp2 correspond to the same

R[F ]-module

Exercise 8 Show that the R[F ]-module (R[F ])[X ] does notcorrespond to any Hopf algebra H

We will get a categorical equivalence by restricting the objects in bothcategories

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 58

We say H is primitively generated if no proper subalgebra of Hcontains P(H)Famous examples

1 H = R[t ](tp) t isin P(H)2 H = R[t ](tpn

) t isin P(H)3 H = R[t1 tn](t

pr1

1 tprn

n ) ti isin P(H)4 H = RClowast

p

5 H = R(Cnp )

lowast

Exercise 9 Let H = R[t ](tp2) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This is a Hopf algebra (not the exercise) Show that H is not primitivelygenerated (yes the exercise)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 58

From here on we suppose H is primitively generated and R is a PID

Then P(H) is free over R and of finite type over R[F ]

So the functor from before can restrict to983080

primitively generatedR-Hopf algebras

983081minusrarr

983080R[F ]-modules of finite type

free over R

983081

We claim this is a categorical equivalence

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 58

H 983347rarr P(H)

We will construct an inverse

Let M be an R[F ]-module of finite type free over R

Let e1 e2 en be an R-basis for M

For 1 le i j le n pick aij isin R such that

Fei =n983142

j=1

ajiej

Let

H = R[t1 t2 tn](tpi minus

n983142

j=1

aji tj)

with ti primitive for all i

Then after identifying ti with ei P(H) = M

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 58

We will call any R[F ]-module of finite type over R a Dieudonneacute module

We will write

Dlowast(H) = P(H)

Question Why not simply call the functor P(minus)

For clarity so we may better differentiate H from its DieudonneacutemoduleTo get the audience used to Dlowast which will be used extensivelyover the next few days (and usually wonrsquot mean P(minus))

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 58

Properties of Dlowast

1 Dlowast is covariant (although this is typically referred to as an exampleof a ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo)

2 If G = Spec(H) then the Dieudonneacute module isM = HomR-gr(GGa) where Ga is the additive group schemeSo Spec(H) 983347rarr Dlowast(H) is a contravariant functor

3 Dlowast is an exact functor4 Dlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)5 rankR H = prankR M

6 Dlowast respects base change (explained later)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 58

Some examples

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) t primitive

Then P(H) is generated as a free R-module by t tp tp2 tpnminus1

If we write ei = tpi 0 le i le n minus 1 then

Dlowast(H) =nminus1983131

i=0

Rei Fei = ei+1 Fenminus1 = 0

where i lt n minus 1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 58

Some more examples

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = e

ExampleLet M = Re1 oplus Re2 with

Fe1 = e2 Fe2 = e1

Then the corresponding Hopf algebra is

H = R[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) sim= R[t ](tp2 minus t)

with t primitiveNote that if Fp2 sube R then H = RClowast

p2

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 58

Consider the following problem for a fixed n find all primitivelygenerated R-Hopf algebras of rank pn

Equivalently find all R[F ] modules which are free rank n over R

These can be described with matrices

Let M be a free R-module basis e1 en Pick a matrix A isin Mn(R)and use it to define an F -action on M by

Fei = Aei

Then M corresponds to a Hopf algebra which can be quicklycomputed

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 58

Each element of Mn(R) gives a Hopf algebra

Conversely each Hopf algebra gives a matrix

However different choices of matrices can give the same Hopf algebra

It can be shown (as it was in Exeter) that AB isin Mn(R) give the sameHopf algebra if any only if there is a Θ isin Mn(R)times such that

B = Θminus1AΘ(p) where Θ = (θij) rArr Θp = (θpij)

Thus a parameter space for primitively generated Hopf algebras ofrank pn is Mn(R) sim where sim is the relation above

Presumably this allows for a count of Hopf algebras for certain R egR is a finite field

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 15: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

For any H the group P(H) has an R-module structure and is actedupon by F

Thus H is an R[F ]-module where R[F ] is the non-commutative ring ofpolynomials with

Fr = rpF

for all r isin R

Now suppose φ H1 rarr H2 is a Hopf algebra homomorphism Thenφ(P(H1)) sube φ(P(H2)) Furthermore for t isin P(H1)

Fφ(t) = φ(Ft)

so φ commutes with F

Thus φ983066983066983066P(H1)

is an R[F ]-module map

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 15 58

Therefore we have a functor

R-Hopf alg rarr R[F ]-modulesH rarr P(H)

which is not a categorical equivalence

Exercise 7 Show that RC2p and RCp2 correspond to the same

R[F ]-module

Exercise 8 Show that the R[F ]-module (R[F ])[X ] does notcorrespond to any Hopf algebra H

We will get a categorical equivalence by restricting the objects in bothcategories

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 58

We say H is primitively generated if no proper subalgebra of Hcontains P(H)Famous examples

1 H = R[t ](tp) t isin P(H)2 H = R[t ](tpn

) t isin P(H)3 H = R[t1 tn](t

pr1

1 tprn

n ) ti isin P(H)4 H = RClowast

p

5 H = R(Cnp )

lowast

Exercise 9 Let H = R[t ](tp2) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This is a Hopf algebra (not the exercise) Show that H is not primitivelygenerated (yes the exercise)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 58

From here on we suppose H is primitively generated and R is a PID

Then P(H) is free over R and of finite type over R[F ]

So the functor from before can restrict to983080

primitively generatedR-Hopf algebras

983081minusrarr

983080R[F ]-modules of finite type

free over R

983081

We claim this is a categorical equivalence

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 58

H 983347rarr P(H)

We will construct an inverse

Let M be an R[F ]-module of finite type free over R

Let e1 e2 en be an R-basis for M

For 1 le i j le n pick aij isin R such that

Fei =n983142

j=1

ajiej

Let

H = R[t1 t2 tn](tpi minus

n983142

j=1

aji tj)

with ti primitive for all i

Then after identifying ti with ei P(H) = M

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 58

We will call any R[F ]-module of finite type over R a Dieudonneacute module

We will write

Dlowast(H) = P(H)

Question Why not simply call the functor P(minus)

For clarity so we may better differentiate H from its DieudonneacutemoduleTo get the audience used to Dlowast which will be used extensivelyover the next few days (and usually wonrsquot mean P(minus))

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 58

Properties of Dlowast

1 Dlowast is covariant (although this is typically referred to as an exampleof a ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo)

2 If G = Spec(H) then the Dieudonneacute module isM = HomR-gr(GGa) where Ga is the additive group schemeSo Spec(H) 983347rarr Dlowast(H) is a contravariant functor

3 Dlowast is an exact functor4 Dlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)5 rankR H = prankR M

6 Dlowast respects base change (explained later)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 58

Some examples

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) t primitive

Then P(H) is generated as a free R-module by t tp tp2 tpnminus1

If we write ei = tpi 0 le i le n minus 1 then

Dlowast(H) =nminus1983131

i=0

Rei Fei = ei+1 Fenminus1 = 0

where i lt n minus 1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 58

Some more examples

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = e

ExampleLet M = Re1 oplus Re2 with

Fe1 = e2 Fe2 = e1

Then the corresponding Hopf algebra is

H = R[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) sim= R[t ](tp2 minus t)

with t primitiveNote that if Fp2 sube R then H = RClowast

p2

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 58

Consider the following problem for a fixed n find all primitivelygenerated R-Hopf algebras of rank pn

Equivalently find all R[F ] modules which are free rank n over R

These can be described with matrices

Let M be a free R-module basis e1 en Pick a matrix A isin Mn(R)and use it to define an F -action on M by

Fei = Aei

Then M corresponds to a Hopf algebra which can be quicklycomputed

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 58

Each element of Mn(R) gives a Hopf algebra

Conversely each Hopf algebra gives a matrix

However different choices of matrices can give the same Hopf algebra

It can be shown (as it was in Exeter) that AB isin Mn(R) give the sameHopf algebra if any only if there is a Θ isin Mn(R)times such that

B = Θminus1AΘ(p) where Θ = (θij) rArr Θp = (θpij)

Thus a parameter space for primitively generated Hopf algebras ofrank pn is Mn(R) sim where sim is the relation above

Presumably this allows for a count of Hopf algebras for certain R egR is a finite field

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 16: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Therefore we have a functor

R-Hopf alg rarr R[F ]-modulesH rarr P(H)

which is not a categorical equivalence

Exercise 7 Show that RC2p and RCp2 correspond to the same

R[F ]-module

Exercise 8 Show that the R[F ]-module (R[F ])[X ] does notcorrespond to any Hopf algebra H

We will get a categorical equivalence by restricting the objects in bothcategories

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 16 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 58

We say H is primitively generated if no proper subalgebra of Hcontains P(H)Famous examples

1 H = R[t ](tp) t isin P(H)2 H = R[t ](tpn

) t isin P(H)3 H = R[t1 tn](t

pr1

1 tprn

n ) ti isin P(H)4 H = RClowast

p

5 H = R(Cnp )

lowast

Exercise 9 Let H = R[t ](tp2) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This is a Hopf algebra (not the exercise) Show that H is not primitivelygenerated (yes the exercise)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 58

From here on we suppose H is primitively generated and R is a PID

Then P(H) is free over R and of finite type over R[F ]

So the functor from before can restrict to983080

primitively generatedR-Hopf algebras

983081minusrarr

983080R[F ]-modules of finite type

free over R

983081

We claim this is a categorical equivalence

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 58

H 983347rarr P(H)

We will construct an inverse

Let M be an R[F ]-module of finite type free over R

Let e1 e2 en be an R-basis for M

For 1 le i j le n pick aij isin R such that

Fei =n983142

j=1

ajiej

Let

H = R[t1 t2 tn](tpi minus

n983142

j=1

aji tj)

with ti primitive for all i

Then after identifying ti with ei P(H) = M

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 58

We will call any R[F ]-module of finite type over R a Dieudonneacute module

We will write

Dlowast(H) = P(H)

Question Why not simply call the functor P(minus)

For clarity so we may better differentiate H from its DieudonneacutemoduleTo get the audience used to Dlowast which will be used extensivelyover the next few days (and usually wonrsquot mean P(minus))

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 58

Properties of Dlowast

1 Dlowast is covariant (although this is typically referred to as an exampleof a ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo)

2 If G = Spec(H) then the Dieudonneacute module isM = HomR-gr(GGa) where Ga is the additive group schemeSo Spec(H) 983347rarr Dlowast(H) is a contravariant functor

3 Dlowast is an exact functor4 Dlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)5 rankR H = prankR M

6 Dlowast respects base change (explained later)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 58

Some examples

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) t primitive

Then P(H) is generated as a free R-module by t tp tp2 tpnminus1

If we write ei = tpi 0 le i le n minus 1 then

Dlowast(H) =nminus1983131

i=0

Rei Fei = ei+1 Fenminus1 = 0

where i lt n minus 1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 58

Some more examples

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = e

ExampleLet M = Re1 oplus Re2 with

Fe1 = e2 Fe2 = e1

Then the corresponding Hopf algebra is

H = R[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) sim= R[t ](tp2 minus t)

with t primitiveNote that if Fp2 sube R then H = RClowast

p2

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 58

Consider the following problem for a fixed n find all primitivelygenerated R-Hopf algebras of rank pn

Equivalently find all R[F ] modules which are free rank n over R

These can be described with matrices

Let M be a free R-module basis e1 en Pick a matrix A isin Mn(R)and use it to define an F -action on M by

Fei = Aei

Then M corresponds to a Hopf algebra which can be quicklycomputed

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 58

Each element of Mn(R) gives a Hopf algebra

Conversely each Hopf algebra gives a matrix

However different choices of matrices can give the same Hopf algebra

It can be shown (as it was in Exeter) that AB isin Mn(R) give the sameHopf algebra if any only if there is a Θ isin Mn(R)times such that

B = Θminus1AΘ(p) where Θ = (θij) rArr Θp = (θpij)

Thus a parameter space for primitively generated Hopf algebras ofrank pn is Mn(R) sim where sim is the relation above

Presumably this allows for a count of Hopf algebras for certain R egR is a finite field

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 17: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 17 58

We say H is primitively generated if no proper subalgebra of Hcontains P(H)Famous examples

1 H = R[t ](tp) t isin P(H)2 H = R[t ](tpn

) t isin P(H)3 H = R[t1 tn](t

pr1

1 tprn

n ) ti isin P(H)4 H = RClowast

p

5 H = R(Cnp )

lowast

Exercise 9 Let H = R[t ](tp2) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This is a Hopf algebra (not the exercise) Show that H is not primitivelygenerated (yes the exercise)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 58

From here on we suppose H is primitively generated and R is a PID

Then P(H) is free over R and of finite type over R[F ]

So the functor from before can restrict to983080

primitively generatedR-Hopf algebras

983081minusrarr

983080R[F ]-modules of finite type

free over R

983081

We claim this is a categorical equivalence

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 58

H 983347rarr P(H)

We will construct an inverse

Let M be an R[F ]-module of finite type free over R

Let e1 e2 en be an R-basis for M

For 1 le i j le n pick aij isin R such that

Fei =n983142

j=1

ajiej

Let

H = R[t1 t2 tn](tpi minus

n983142

j=1

aji tj)

with ti primitive for all i

Then after identifying ti with ei P(H) = M

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 58

We will call any R[F ]-module of finite type over R a Dieudonneacute module

We will write

Dlowast(H) = P(H)

Question Why not simply call the functor P(minus)

For clarity so we may better differentiate H from its DieudonneacutemoduleTo get the audience used to Dlowast which will be used extensivelyover the next few days (and usually wonrsquot mean P(minus))

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 58

Properties of Dlowast

1 Dlowast is covariant (although this is typically referred to as an exampleof a ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo)

2 If G = Spec(H) then the Dieudonneacute module isM = HomR-gr(GGa) where Ga is the additive group schemeSo Spec(H) 983347rarr Dlowast(H) is a contravariant functor

3 Dlowast is an exact functor4 Dlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)5 rankR H = prankR M

6 Dlowast respects base change (explained later)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 58

Some examples

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) t primitive

Then P(H) is generated as a free R-module by t tp tp2 tpnminus1

If we write ei = tpi 0 le i le n minus 1 then

Dlowast(H) =nminus1983131

i=0

Rei Fei = ei+1 Fenminus1 = 0

where i lt n minus 1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 58

Some more examples

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = e

ExampleLet M = Re1 oplus Re2 with

Fe1 = e2 Fe2 = e1

Then the corresponding Hopf algebra is

H = R[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) sim= R[t ](tp2 minus t)

with t primitiveNote that if Fp2 sube R then H = RClowast

p2

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 58

Consider the following problem for a fixed n find all primitivelygenerated R-Hopf algebras of rank pn

Equivalently find all R[F ] modules which are free rank n over R

These can be described with matrices

Let M be a free R-module basis e1 en Pick a matrix A isin Mn(R)and use it to define an F -action on M by

Fei = Aei

Then M corresponds to a Hopf algebra which can be quicklycomputed

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 58

Each element of Mn(R) gives a Hopf algebra

Conversely each Hopf algebra gives a matrix

However different choices of matrices can give the same Hopf algebra

It can be shown (as it was in Exeter) that AB isin Mn(R) give the sameHopf algebra if any only if there is a Θ isin Mn(R)times such that

B = Θminus1AΘ(p) where Θ = (θij) rArr Θp = (θpij)

Thus a parameter space for primitively generated Hopf algebras ofrank pn is Mn(R) sim where sim is the relation above

Presumably this allows for a count of Hopf algebras for certain R egR is a finite field

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 18: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

We say H is primitively generated if no proper subalgebra of Hcontains P(H)Famous examples

1 H = R[t ](tp) t isin P(H)2 H = R[t ](tpn

) t isin P(H)3 H = R[t1 tn](t

pr1

1 tprn

n ) ti isin P(H)4 H = RClowast

p

5 H = R(Cnp )

lowast

Exercise 9 Let H = R[t ](tp2) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This is a Hopf algebra (not the exercise) Show that H is not primitivelygenerated (yes the exercise)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 18 58

From here on we suppose H is primitively generated and R is a PID

Then P(H) is free over R and of finite type over R[F ]

So the functor from before can restrict to983080

primitively generatedR-Hopf algebras

983081minusrarr

983080R[F ]-modules of finite type

free over R

983081

We claim this is a categorical equivalence

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 58

H 983347rarr P(H)

We will construct an inverse

Let M be an R[F ]-module of finite type free over R

Let e1 e2 en be an R-basis for M

For 1 le i j le n pick aij isin R such that

Fei =n983142

j=1

ajiej

Let

H = R[t1 t2 tn](tpi minus

n983142

j=1

aji tj)

with ti primitive for all i

Then after identifying ti with ei P(H) = M

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 58

We will call any R[F ]-module of finite type over R a Dieudonneacute module

We will write

Dlowast(H) = P(H)

Question Why not simply call the functor P(minus)

For clarity so we may better differentiate H from its DieudonneacutemoduleTo get the audience used to Dlowast which will be used extensivelyover the next few days (and usually wonrsquot mean P(minus))

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 58

Properties of Dlowast

1 Dlowast is covariant (although this is typically referred to as an exampleof a ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo)

2 If G = Spec(H) then the Dieudonneacute module isM = HomR-gr(GGa) where Ga is the additive group schemeSo Spec(H) 983347rarr Dlowast(H) is a contravariant functor

3 Dlowast is an exact functor4 Dlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)5 rankR H = prankR M

6 Dlowast respects base change (explained later)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 58

Some examples

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) t primitive

Then P(H) is generated as a free R-module by t tp tp2 tpnminus1

If we write ei = tpi 0 le i le n minus 1 then

Dlowast(H) =nminus1983131

i=0

Rei Fei = ei+1 Fenminus1 = 0

where i lt n minus 1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 58

Some more examples

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = e

ExampleLet M = Re1 oplus Re2 with

Fe1 = e2 Fe2 = e1

Then the corresponding Hopf algebra is

H = R[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) sim= R[t ](tp2 minus t)

with t primitiveNote that if Fp2 sube R then H = RClowast

p2

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 58

Consider the following problem for a fixed n find all primitivelygenerated R-Hopf algebras of rank pn

Equivalently find all R[F ] modules which are free rank n over R

These can be described with matrices

Let M be a free R-module basis e1 en Pick a matrix A isin Mn(R)and use it to define an F -action on M by

Fei = Aei

Then M corresponds to a Hopf algebra which can be quicklycomputed

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 58

Each element of Mn(R) gives a Hopf algebra

Conversely each Hopf algebra gives a matrix

However different choices of matrices can give the same Hopf algebra

It can be shown (as it was in Exeter) that AB isin Mn(R) give the sameHopf algebra if any only if there is a Θ isin Mn(R)times such that

B = Θminus1AΘ(p) where Θ = (θij) rArr Θp = (θpij)

Thus a parameter space for primitively generated Hopf algebras ofrank pn is Mn(R) sim where sim is the relation above

Presumably this allows for a count of Hopf algebras for certain R egR is a finite field

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 19: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

From here on we suppose H is primitively generated and R is a PID

Then P(H) is free over R and of finite type over R[F ]

So the functor from before can restrict to983080

primitively generatedR-Hopf algebras

983081minusrarr

983080R[F ]-modules of finite type

free over R

983081

We claim this is a categorical equivalence

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 19 58

H 983347rarr P(H)

We will construct an inverse

Let M be an R[F ]-module of finite type free over R

Let e1 e2 en be an R-basis for M

For 1 le i j le n pick aij isin R such that

Fei =n983142

j=1

ajiej

Let

H = R[t1 t2 tn](tpi minus

n983142

j=1

aji tj)

with ti primitive for all i

Then after identifying ti with ei P(H) = M

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 58

We will call any R[F ]-module of finite type over R a Dieudonneacute module

We will write

Dlowast(H) = P(H)

Question Why not simply call the functor P(minus)

For clarity so we may better differentiate H from its DieudonneacutemoduleTo get the audience used to Dlowast which will be used extensivelyover the next few days (and usually wonrsquot mean P(minus))

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 58

Properties of Dlowast

1 Dlowast is covariant (although this is typically referred to as an exampleof a ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo)

2 If G = Spec(H) then the Dieudonneacute module isM = HomR-gr(GGa) where Ga is the additive group schemeSo Spec(H) 983347rarr Dlowast(H) is a contravariant functor

3 Dlowast is an exact functor4 Dlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)5 rankR H = prankR M

6 Dlowast respects base change (explained later)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 58

Some examples

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) t primitive

Then P(H) is generated as a free R-module by t tp tp2 tpnminus1

If we write ei = tpi 0 le i le n minus 1 then

Dlowast(H) =nminus1983131

i=0

Rei Fei = ei+1 Fenminus1 = 0

where i lt n minus 1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 58

Some more examples

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = e

ExampleLet M = Re1 oplus Re2 with

Fe1 = e2 Fe2 = e1

Then the corresponding Hopf algebra is

H = R[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) sim= R[t ](tp2 minus t)

with t primitiveNote that if Fp2 sube R then H = RClowast

p2

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 58

Consider the following problem for a fixed n find all primitivelygenerated R-Hopf algebras of rank pn

Equivalently find all R[F ] modules which are free rank n over R

These can be described with matrices

Let M be a free R-module basis e1 en Pick a matrix A isin Mn(R)and use it to define an F -action on M by

Fei = Aei

Then M corresponds to a Hopf algebra which can be quicklycomputed

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 58

Each element of Mn(R) gives a Hopf algebra

Conversely each Hopf algebra gives a matrix

However different choices of matrices can give the same Hopf algebra

It can be shown (as it was in Exeter) that AB isin Mn(R) give the sameHopf algebra if any only if there is a Θ isin Mn(R)times such that

B = Θminus1AΘ(p) where Θ = (θij) rArr Θp = (θpij)

Thus a parameter space for primitively generated Hopf algebras ofrank pn is Mn(R) sim where sim is the relation above

Presumably this allows for a count of Hopf algebras for certain R egR is a finite field

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 20: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

H 983347rarr P(H)

We will construct an inverse

Let M be an R[F ]-module of finite type free over R

Let e1 e2 en be an R-basis for M

For 1 le i j le n pick aij isin R such that

Fei =n983142

j=1

ajiej

Let

H = R[t1 t2 tn](tpi minus

n983142

j=1

aji tj)

with ti primitive for all i

Then after identifying ti with ei P(H) = M

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 20 58

We will call any R[F ]-module of finite type over R a Dieudonneacute module

We will write

Dlowast(H) = P(H)

Question Why not simply call the functor P(minus)

For clarity so we may better differentiate H from its DieudonneacutemoduleTo get the audience used to Dlowast which will be used extensivelyover the next few days (and usually wonrsquot mean P(minus))

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 58

Properties of Dlowast

1 Dlowast is covariant (although this is typically referred to as an exampleof a ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo)

2 If G = Spec(H) then the Dieudonneacute module isM = HomR-gr(GGa) where Ga is the additive group schemeSo Spec(H) 983347rarr Dlowast(H) is a contravariant functor

3 Dlowast is an exact functor4 Dlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)5 rankR H = prankR M

6 Dlowast respects base change (explained later)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 58

Some examples

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) t primitive

Then P(H) is generated as a free R-module by t tp tp2 tpnminus1

If we write ei = tpi 0 le i le n minus 1 then

Dlowast(H) =nminus1983131

i=0

Rei Fei = ei+1 Fenminus1 = 0

where i lt n minus 1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 58

Some more examples

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = e

ExampleLet M = Re1 oplus Re2 with

Fe1 = e2 Fe2 = e1

Then the corresponding Hopf algebra is

H = R[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) sim= R[t ](tp2 minus t)

with t primitiveNote that if Fp2 sube R then H = RClowast

p2

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 58

Consider the following problem for a fixed n find all primitivelygenerated R-Hopf algebras of rank pn

Equivalently find all R[F ] modules which are free rank n over R

These can be described with matrices

Let M be a free R-module basis e1 en Pick a matrix A isin Mn(R)and use it to define an F -action on M by

Fei = Aei

Then M corresponds to a Hopf algebra which can be quicklycomputed

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 58

Each element of Mn(R) gives a Hopf algebra

Conversely each Hopf algebra gives a matrix

However different choices of matrices can give the same Hopf algebra

It can be shown (as it was in Exeter) that AB isin Mn(R) give the sameHopf algebra if any only if there is a Θ isin Mn(R)times such that

B = Θminus1AΘ(p) where Θ = (θij) rArr Θp = (θpij)

Thus a parameter space for primitively generated Hopf algebras ofrank pn is Mn(R) sim where sim is the relation above

Presumably this allows for a count of Hopf algebras for certain R egR is a finite field

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 21: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

We will call any R[F ]-module of finite type over R a Dieudonneacute module

We will write

Dlowast(H) = P(H)

Question Why not simply call the functor P(minus)

For clarity so we may better differentiate H from its DieudonneacutemoduleTo get the audience used to Dlowast which will be used extensivelyover the next few days (and usually wonrsquot mean P(minus))

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 21 58

Properties of Dlowast

1 Dlowast is covariant (although this is typically referred to as an exampleof a ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo)

2 If G = Spec(H) then the Dieudonneacute module isM = HomR-gr(GGa) where Ga is the additive group schemeSo Spec(H) 983347rarr Dlowast(H) is a contravariant functor

3 Dlowast is an exact functor4 Dlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)5 rankR H = prankR M

6 Dlowast respects base change (explained later)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 58

Some examples

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) t primitive

Then P(H) is generated as a free R-module by t tp tp2 tpnminus1

If we write ei = tpi 0 le i le n minus 1 then

Dlowast(H) =nminus1983131

i=0

Rei Fei = ei+1 Fenminus1 = 0

where i lt n minus 1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 58

Some more examples

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = e

ExampleLet M = Re1 oplus Re2 with

Fe1 = e2 Fe2 = e1

Then the corresponding Hopf algebra is

H = R[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) sim= R[t ](tp2 minus t)

with t primitiveNote that if Fp2 sube R then H = RClowast

p2

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 58

Consider the following problem for a fixed n find all primitivelygenerated R-Hopf algebras of rank pn

Equivalently find all R[F ] modules which are free rank n over R

These can be described with matrices

Let M be a free R-module basis e1 en Pick a matrix A isin Mn(R)and use it to define an F -action on M by

Fei = Aei

Then M corresponds to a Hopf algebra which can be quicklycomputed

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 58

Each element of Mn(R) gives a Hopf algebra

Conversely each Hopf algebra gives a matrix

However different choices of matrices can give the same Hopf algebra

It can be shown (as it was in Exeter) that AB isin Mn(R) give the sameHopf algebra if any only if there is a Θ isin Mn(R)times such that

B = Θminus1AΘ(p) where Θ = (θij) rArr Θp = (θpij)

Thus a parameter space for primitively generated Hopf algebras ofrank pn is Mn(R) sim where sim is the relation above

Presumably this allows for a count of Hopf algebras for certain R egR is a finite field

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 22: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Properties of Dlowast

1 Dlowast is covariant (although this is typically referred to as an exampleof a ldquocontravariant Dieudonneacute module theoryrdquo)

2 If G = Spec(H) then the Dieudonneacute module isM = HomR-gr(GGa) where Ga is the additive group schemeSo Spec(H) 983347rarr Dlowast(H) is a contravariant functor

3 Dlowast is an exact functor4 Dlowast(H1 otimes H2) sim= Dlowast(H1)times Dlowast(H2)5 rankR H = prankR M

6 Dlowast respects base change (explained later)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 22 58

Some examples

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) t primitive

Then P(H) is generated as a free R-module by t tp tp2 tpnminus1

If we write ei = tpi 0 le i le n minus 1 then

Dlowast(H) =nminus1983131

i=0

Rei Fei = ei+1 Fenminus1 = 0

where i lt n minus 1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 58

Some more examples

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = e

ExampleLet M = Re1 oplus Re2 with

Fe1 = e2 Fe2 = e1

Then the corresponding Hopf algebra is

H = R[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) sim= R[t ](tp2 minus t)

with t primitiveNote that if Fp2 sube R then H = RClowast

p2

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 58

Consider the following problem for a fixed n find all primitivelygenerated R-Hopf algebras of rank pn

Equivalently find all R[F ] modules which are free rank n over R

These can be described with matrices

Let M be a free R-module basis e1 en Pick a matrix A isin Mn(R)and use it to define an F -action on M by

Fei = Aei

Then M corresponds to a Hopf algebra which can be quicklycomputed

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 58

Each element of Mn(R) gives a Hopf algebra

Conversely each Hopf algebra gives a matrix

However different choices of matrices can give the same Hopf algebra

It can be shown (as it was in Exeter) that AB isin Mn(R) give the sameHopf algebra if any only if there is a Θ isin Mn(R)times such that

B = Θminus1AΘ(p) where Θ = (θij) rArr Θp = (θpij)

Thus a parameter space for primitively generated Hopf algebras ofrank pn is Mn(R) sim where sim is the relation above

Presumably this allows for a count of Hopf algebras for certain R egR is a finite field

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 23: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Some examples

ExampleLet H = R[t ](tp) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = 0

Example

Let H = R[t ](tpn) t primitive

Then P(H) is generated as a free R-module by t tp tp2 tpnminus1

If we write ei = tpi 0 le i le n minus 1 then

Dlowast(H) =nminus1983131

i=0

Rei Fei = ei+1 Fenminus1 = 0

where i lt n minus 1

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 23 58

Some more examples

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = e

ExampleLet M = Re1 oplus Re2 with

Fe1 = e2 Fe2 = e1

Then the corresponding Hopf algebra is

H = R[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) sim= R[t ](tp2 minus t)

with t primitiveNote that if Fp2 sube R then H = RClowast

p2

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 58

Consider the following problem for a fixed n find all primitivelygenerated R-Hopf algebras of rank pn

Equivalently find all R[F ] modules which are free rank n over R

These can be described with matrices

Let M be a free R-module basis e1 en Pick a matrix A isin Mn(R)and use it to define an F -action on M by

Fei = Aei

Then M corresponds to a Hopf algebra which can be quicklycomputed

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 58

Each element of Mn(R) gives a Hopf algebra

Conversely each Hopf algebra gives a matrix

However different choices of matrices can give the same Hopf algebra

It can be shown (as it was in Exeter) that AB isin Mn(R) give the sameHopf algebra if any only if there is a Θ isin Mn(R)times such that

B = Θminus1AΘ(p) where Θ = (θij) rArr Θp = (θpij)

Thus a parameter space for primitively generated Hopf algebras ofrank pn is Mn(R) sim where sim is the relation above

Presumably this allows for a count of Hopf algebras for certain R egR is a finite field

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 24: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Some more examples

ExampleLet H = RClowast

p = R[t ](tp minus t) t primitiveThen Dlowast(H) = Re with Fe = e

ExampleLet M = Re1 oplus Re2 with

Fe1 = e2 Fe2 = e1

Then the corresponding Hopf algebra is

H = R[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) sim= R[t ](tp2 minus t)

with t primitiveNote that if Fp2 sube R then H = RClowast

p2

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 24 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 58

Consider the following problem for a fixed n find all primitivelygenerated R-Hopf algebras of rank pn

Equivalently find all R[F ] modules which are free rank n over R

These can be described with matrices

Let M be a free R-module basis e1 en Pick a matrix A isin Mn(R)and use it to define an F -action on M by

Fei = Aei

Then M corresponds to a Hopf algebra which can be quicklycomputed

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 58

Each element of Mn(R) gives a Hopf algebra

Conversely each Hopf algebra gives a matrix

However different choices of matrices can give the same Hopf algebra

It can be shown (as it was in Exeter) that AB isin Mn(R) give the sameHopf algebra if any only if there is a Θ isin Mn(R)times such that

B = Θminus1AΘ(p) where Θ = (θij) rArr Θp = (θpij)

Thus a parameter space for primitively generated Hopf algebras ofrank pn is Mn(R) sim where sim is the relation above

Presumably this allows for a count of Hopf algebras for certain R egR is a finite field

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 25: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 25 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 58

Consider the following problem for a fixed n find all primitivelygenerated R-Hopf algebras of rank pn

Equivalently find all R[F ] modules which are free rank n over R

These can be described with matrices

Let M be a free R-module basis e1 en Pick a matrix A isin Mn(R)and use it to define an F -action on M by

Fei = Aei

Then M corresponds to a Hopf algebra which can be quicklycomputed

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 58

Each element of Mn(R) gives a Hopf algebra

Conversely each Hopf algebra gives a matrix

However different choices of matrices can give the same Hopf algebra

It can be shown (as it was in Exeter) that AB isin Mn(R) give the sameHopf algebra if any only if there is a Θ isin Mn(R)times such that

B = Θminus1AΘ(p) where Θ = (θij) rArr Θp = (θpij)

Thus a parameter space for primitively generated Hopf algebras ofrank pn is Mn(R) sim where sim is the relation above

Presumably this allows for a count of Hopf algebras for certain R egR is a finite field

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 26: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 26 58

Consider the following problem for a fixed n find all primitivelygenerated R-Hopf algebras of rank pn

Equivalently find all R[F ] modules which are free rank n over R

These can be described with matrices

Let M be a free R-module basis e1 en Pick a matrix A isin Mn(R)and use it to define an F -action on M by

Fei = Aei

Then M corresponds to a Hopf algebra which can be quicklycomputed

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 58

Each element of Mn(R) gives a Hopf algebra

Conversely each Hopf algebra gives a matrix

However different choices of matrices can give the same Hopf algebra

It can be shown (as it was in Exeter) that AB isin Mn(R) give the sameHopf algebra if any only if there is a Θ isin Mn(R)times such that

B = Θminus1AΘ(p) where Θ = (θij) rArr Θp = (θpij)

Thus a parameter space for primitively generated Hopf algebras ofrank pn is Mn(R) sim where sim is the relation above

Presumably this allows for a count of Hopf algebras for certain R egR is a finite field

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 27: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Consider the following problem for a fixed n find all primitivelygenerated R-Hopf algebras of rank pn

Equivalently find all R[F ] modules which are free rank n over R

These can be described with matrices

Let M be a free R-module basis e1 en Pick a matrix A isin Mn(R)and use it to define an F -action on M by

Fei = Aei

Then M corresponds to a Hopf algebra which can be quicklycomputed

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 27 58

Each element of Mn(R) gives a Hopf algebra

Conversely each Hopf algebra gives a matrix

However different choices of matrices can give the same Hopf algebra

It can be shown (as it was in Exeter) that AB isin Mn(R) give the sameHopf algebra if any only if there is a Θ isin Mn(R)times such that

B = Θminus1AΘ(p) where Θ = (θij) rArr Θp = (θpij)

Thus a parameter space for primitively generated Hopf algebras ofrank pn is Mn(R) sim where sim is the relation above

Presumably this allows for a count of Hopf algebras for certain R egR is a finite field

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 28: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Each element of Mn(R) gives a Hopf algebra

Conversely each Hopf algebra gives a matrix

However different choices of matrices can give the same Hopf algebra

It can be shown (as it was in Exeter) that AB isin Mn(R) give the sameHopf algebra if any only if there is a Θ isin Mn(R)times such that

B = Θminus1AΘ(p) where Θ = (θij) rArr Θp = (θpij)

Thus a parameter space for primitively generated Hopf algebras ofrank pn is Mn(R) sim where sim is the relation above

Presumably this allows for a count of Hopf algebras for certain R egR is a finite field

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 28 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 29: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 29 58

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 30: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Let H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra and let End(H) bethe R-Hopf algebra endomorphisms of H

If φ H rarr H is a map of Hopf algebras it induces a map Θ M rarr M ofR[F ]-modules where M = Dlowast(H) We view Θ as a matrix with respectto a choice of some basis for M

Again as M is a free R-module for the same choice of basis theaction of F is determined by a matrix A

ThenΘA = AΘ(p)

Thus the elements in End(H) are in 1-1 correspondence with matricesin Mn(R) such that the equality above holds

The ones with Θ isin Mn(R)times are of course the automorphisms

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 30 58

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 31: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Example

Let H = R[t ](tp2) t primitive Then assuming Dlowast(H) = Re1 oplus Re2

where e1 corresponds to t and e2 to tp

A =

9830720 01 0

983073

Then if Θ =

983072a bc d

983073is an R[F ]-linear map

ΘA =

983072a bc d

9830739830720 01 0

983073=

983072b 0d 0

983073

AΘ(p) =

9830720 01 0

983073983072ap bp

cp dp

983073=

9830720 0ap bp

983073

so d = ap b = 0The corresponding φ H rarr H is given by φ(t) = at + ctp for a c isin Rclearly an isomorphism iff a isin Rtimes

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 31 58

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 32: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Exercises

Exercise 10 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(RClowastp)

Exercise 11 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(RClowastp)

Exercise 12 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe End(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Exercise 13 Use Dieudonneacute modules to describe Aut(R(Cp times Cp)lowast)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 32 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 33: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 33 58

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 34: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

The theory of Dieudonneacute modules can be extended beyond finiteR-Hopf algebras

For example H = R[t ]∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t corresponds to a freeR[F ]-module of rank 1

This allows us to construct projective resolutions for Dieudonneacutemodules and extensions of Dieudonneacute modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 34 58

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 35: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

An example

Let H = R[t ](tp) M its Dieudonneacute module

Let Dlowast(R[t ]) = R[F ]e (a free R[F ] module of rank 1)

Multiplication by F R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e gives the projective resolution

0 rarr R[F ]e rarr R[F ]e rarr M rarr 0

for M

This gives rise to

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 35 58

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 36: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

0 rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

We have HomR[F ](R[F ]eM) sim= M by f 983347rarr f (e) hence

0 rarr M rarr M rarr Ext1R[F ](MM) rarr 0

The map M rarr M induced from middotF is trivial (since Fm = 0 for allm isin M) giving

Ext1R[F ](MM) sim= M

Explicitly for [f ] isin Ext1R[F ](MM) arising from f isin HomR[F ](R[F ]eM)the extension Mf obtained is (R[F ]e times M)I where

I = (Fx f (x)) x isin R[F ]e

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 36 58

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 37: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Does Ext1R[F ](MM) give all the Hopf algebra extensions

Exercise 14 Prove that the answer is no Hint considerH = R[t ](tp2

) with

∆(t) = t otimes 1 + 1 otimes t +pminus1983142

i=1

1i(p minus i)

tpi otimes tp(pminusi)

This H is a Hopf algebra (still not the exercise)

Note That the H above is in fact a Hopf algebra will be obvious aftertomorrow

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 37 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 38: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 38 58

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 39: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Base change

Let S be a flat extension of R

Then we have two Dieudonneacute module theories1 R-Hopf algebras to R[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastR2 S-Hopf algebras to S[F ]-modules Denote this functor DlowastS

How are they related

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 39 58

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 40: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Very closely

PropositionLet H be a primitively generated R-Hopf algebra Then H otimesR S is aprimitively generated S-Hopf algebra and

DlowastS(H otimesR S) = DlowastR(H)otimesR S

ProofObvious or

Exercise 15 Prove the above proposition

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 40 58

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 41: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Let R = K a field (still char p) and let H1H2 be primitively generatedK -Hopf algebras

Let S = L be an extension of K

Then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifH1 otimesK L sim= H2 otimesK L as L-Hopf algebras

Alternatively H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if and only ifDlowastL(H1 otimesK L) sim= DlowastL(H2 otimesK L)

If Mi = DlowastL(Hi) i = 1 2 then H1 and H2 are L-forms of each other if

LM1sim= LM2

as L[F ]-modules

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 41 58

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 42: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

ExampleLet H = Fp[t ](tp minus 2t)Then H ∕sim= FpClowast

p since this would imply the existence of an invertible1 times 1 matrix Θ = (θ) θ isin Fp such that

θ middot 2 = θp ( ldquoΘA = BΘ(p)rsquorsquo)

in which case θpminus1 = 2However let L = Fppminus1 Then such a θ isin L existsSo H and FpClowast

p are L-forms of each other

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 42 58

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 43: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

More exercises

Exercise 16 Show that K [t ](tpn) has no non-trivial L forms for any L

Exercise 17 Let H = Fp[t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1) Determine if possible

the smallest field L such that H and (KCp2)lowast are L-forms

Exercise 18 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F acts freely on M Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are K sep-formsfor some p-group Γ

Exercise 19 Let M = Dlowast(H) for H a K -Hopf algebra of rank pnSuppose F r M = 0 for some r gt 0 Show that H and (KΓ)lowast are notK sep-forms for any p-group Γ

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 43 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 44: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 44 58

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 45: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Let R = Fq[[T ]] K = Fq((T )) p | q

(This is more structure than necessary For much of what follows Rcould be a DVR of characteristic p)

Let vK be the valuation on K with vK (T ) = 1

We have Dlowast compatible for the extension R rarr K

Pick AB isin Mn(R) and construct R-Dieudonneacute modules MAMB withrankR MA = rankR MB = n where the action of F is given by ABrespectively for some fixed R-basis for each

Write MA = Dlowast(HA) and MB = Dlowast(HB)

Now KHAsim= KHB if and only if there is a Θ isin GLn(K ) such that

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 45 58

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 46: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )

Write A = (aij)B = (bij)Θ = (θij) Then

HA is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using A ie

HA = R[u1 un](upi minus

983142ajiuj)

HB is viewed as an R-Hopf algebra using B ie

HB = R[t1 tn](tpi minus

983142bji tj)

KHB is viewed as a K -Hopf algebra in the obvious wayHB is viewed as an order in KHB in the obvious wayHA is viewed as an order in KHB through Θ ie

HA = R

983104

983106

983110983114

983112

n983142

j=1

θji tj 1 le i le n

983111983115

983113

983105

983107 sub KHB

(apologies for the abuses of language amp the re-use of an old slide)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 46 58

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 47: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

rank p

Recall that K -Hopf algebras of rank p correspond to rank 1 Dieudonneacutemodules over K

Fix b isin K and let M = Ke with Fe = be

The corresponding Hopf algebra is Hb = K [t ](tp minus bt)

Furthermore Ha sim= Hb if and only if there is a θ isin Ktimes with θa = bθp

Case b = 0 This is the algebra K [t ](tp)

Case b ∕= 0 From the exercises Hb is an K sep-form of KClowastp

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 47 58

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 48: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Case b ∕= 0

Since K [t ](tp minus bt) sim= K [t ](tp minus T pminus1bt) by the map t 983347rarr Tminus1t wemay assume

0 le vK (b) lt p minus 1

Pick θ isin Ktimes and let a = bθpminus1

Provided a isin R (which holds iff θ isin R) we have

Hθ = R[θt ] sub K [t ](tp minus bt)

If u = θt thenup = (θt)p = θptp = θpminus1bθt = au

and so Hθ = R[u](up minus au)Here Hθ depends only on vK (θ) so a complete list is

Hi = R983158T i t

983159 i ge 0

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 48 58

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 49: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Case b = 0

Clearly θa = bθp can occur only if a = 0

So any two R-Hopf orders in K [t ](tp) are isomorphic as Hopfalgebras

However They are not necessarily the same Hopf order It dependson the chosen embedding Θ = (θ) isin GL1(K )

Let θ isin Ktimes

Then R[θt ] is a Hopf order in K [t ](tp)

As R[θt ] = R[(rθ)t ] r isin Rtimes the complete list is

Hi = R[T i t ] i isin Z

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 49 58

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 50: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Overview for all n

Pick a K -Hopf algebra H and find the B isin Mn(K ) which is used inthe construction of its K -Dieudonneacute moduleFind A isin Mn(R) such that ΘA = BΘ(p) for some Θ isin GLn(K )(One such example A = B Θ = I )Construct the R-Dieudonneacute module corresponding to AConstruct the R-Hopf algebra HA corresponding to this DieudonneacutemoduleThe algebra relations on HA are given by the matrix AHA can be viewed as a Hopf order in H using ΘHA1 = HA2 if and only if Θminus1Θprime is an invertible matrix in R where

ΘA1 = BΘ(p) and ΘprimeA2 = B(Θprime)(p)

Alternatively HA1 = HA2 if and only if Θprime = ΘU for some U isin Mn(R)times

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 50 58

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 51: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

ΘA = BΘ(p)

One strategy Given B set A = Θminus1BΘ(p)

This will generate a Hopf order iff A has coefficients in R

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Notice that

(ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) = Uminus1983070Θminus1BΘ(p)

983071U(p)

and so (ΘU)minus1B(ΘU)(p) isin Mn(R) iff Θminus1BΘ(p) isin Mn(R)

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 51 58

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 52: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

But we can replace Θ with ΘU for U isin M2(R)times

Theorem (New)Let H be a primitively generated K -Hopf algebra of rank pn and let Bbe the matrix associated to H Let H0 be an R-Hopf order in H and letA be the matrix associated to H0 Then there existsΘ = (θij) isin GLn(K ) such that

1 Θ is lower triangular2 vK (θii) ge vK (θij) j le i le n3 θii = T vK (θii )4 ΘA = BΘ(p)

In the case n = 2 the Hopf orders are of the form

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159

with vK (θ) le j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 52 58

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 53: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Hi j θ = R983056T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983057 vK (θ) le j

Q When is Hijθ = Hi primej primeθprime

Precisely when there is a U isin Mn(R)times such that983072

T i 0θ T j

983073=

983072T i prime 0θprime T j

983073U

Such a U exists if and only if

i = i prime

j = j prime

vK (θ minus θprime) ge j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 53 58

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 54: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

An example H = K [t ](tp2) = K [t1 t2](t

p1 t

p2 minus t1)

A =

983072θpTminusi T pjminusi

minusθp+1Tminus(i+j) θT (pminus1)jminusi

983073

To give a Hopf order we require pj ge i and

vK (θ) ge minip (i + j)(p + 1) i minus (p minus 1)j

which can be simplified significantly giving

Hijθ = R983158T i t1 + θt2T j t2

983159= R

983158T i tp + θt T j t

983159

pj ge i i minus (p minus 1)j le vK (θ) le j

Note Hijθ is monogenic if and only if pj = i and vK (θ) = j

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 54 58

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 55: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

More exercises All Hopf algebras below are primitively generated

Exercise 20 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 )

Exercise 21 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 t

p2 minus t2)

Exercise 22 Find all Hopf orders in H = (KC2p)

lowast

Exercise 23 Determine which of the Hopf orders in (KC2p)

lowast aremonogenic

Exercise 24 Find all Hopf orders in H = K [t1 t2](tp1 minus t2 t

p2 minus t1)

Exercise 25 Determine which of the Hopf orders in the previousproblem are monogenic

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 55 58

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 56: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Outline

1 Overview

2 Primitive Elements

3 A Dieudonneacute Correspondence

4 ApplicationsClassification of Hopf algebrasEndomorphisms of Hopf algebrasExtensions of Hopf algebrasForms of Hopf algebrasHopf orders

5 Want more

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 56 58

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 57: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Letrsquos assume you do

There is a theory which is dual to that of primitively generated Hopfalgebras

In other words a theory to classify H where Hlowast is primitivelygenerated

This would include elementary abelian group rings

As far as I can figure out given such an H define

Dlowast(H) = H+(H+)2 H+ = ker ε

It turns out that Dlowast(H) = (Dlowast(Hlowast))lowast = HomR(Dlowast(Hlowast)R)

I donrsquot know how the correspondence works without passing to duals

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 57 58

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58

Page 58: Dieudonné modules, part I: a study of primitively ...€¦ · a study of primitively generated Hopf algebras Alan Koch Agnes Scott College ... be the set of all primitive elements

Thank you

Alan Koch (Agnes Scott College) 58 58