disasters: what we plan for…. john f bradfield, dvm, phd, daclam senior director, aaalac...
TRANSCRIPT
Disasters: What We Plan For….
John F Bradfield, DVM, PhD, DACLAMSenior Director, AAALAC International
Disaster Planning – new?
1965 Edition – Section H –
Emergencies“Provision should be made for emergency care, day or night. Standard operating procedures for emergencies must be listed. These should include such items as-
(a) Name of responsible person or alternate
(b) Means of contacting responsible person or alternate”
Disaster Planning – new?
1972 Edition – Section I.D –
Provisions for emergency care“Provision must be made for the emergency care of animals….. The objective must be to assure that animals will be cared for should an emergency arise.”
Disaster Planning – new? 1978 Edition – Section C.4 – Provisions
for emergency, weekend and holiday care“Provision must be made for the emergency care of animals. Institutional security personnel and fire or police officials should know how to reach a person responsible for the animals. This can be accomplished by prominently posting the names of such responsible persons in the animal facilities, or listing them with the institution’s central telephone center or security department. The objective is to ensure that animals will be cared for in case of emergencies.
Disaster Planning – new?
1985 Edition – Emergency, weekend and
holiday care“In the event of an emergency, institutional security personnel and fire or police officials should be able to contact those people responsible for the animals. This can be accomplished by prominently posting names and phone numbers in the animal facilities, or by listing them with the security department or telephone center.
Disaster Planning – new?
1996 Edition – Emergency, weekend
and holiday care“…In the event of an emergency, institutional security personnel and fire or police officials should be able to reach people responsible for the animals…...
A disaster plan that takes into account both personnel and animals should be prepared as part of the overall safety plan for the animal facility. The colony manger or veterinarian responsible for the animals should be a member of the appropriate safety committee at the institution. He or she should be an “official responder” within the institution and should participate in the response to a disaster….”
2011 Guide - Chapter 2: page 35
Disaster plan
“Facilities must therefore have a disaster plan.”
“The plan should define the actions necessary to prevent animal pain, distress, and deaths due to loss of systems such as those that control ventilation, cooling, heating, or provision of potable water.”
2011 Guide - Chapter 2: page 35
Disaster plan - other key aspects Developed with PI’s If animals cannot be relocated or protected – humane
euthanasia ID essential personnel with advanced training Personnel safety and access Plans should be part of overall institutional plan
coordinated by the IO Plan should be integrated into broader, area-wide
planning (local law enforcement and emergency personnel)
Trend Analysis – reports of disasters
From 2009 – April 2014 Reports of any “disaster” that was judged
to be “significant” Tabulate results Any trends emerge as common
challenges?
Findings Total of 74 reports (since 2009) Categories of findings:
Earthquake Flood Hurricane Terrorism Fire Power outage Tornado Other weather Physical Plant Other
# Reported Events - Category
Earthquake
Flood Hurricane Terrorism Fire Power Outage
Tornado Other Weather
Other0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
# Reports - Category
Earthquake
Flood Hurricane Terrorism Fire Power Outage
Tornado Other Weather
Other Physical Plant
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
1 14
13
6
1 2 2
53
Findings
Physical Plant – sub categories HVAC Steam Water Malfunction/breakage Accident Transport
Equipment Malfunction
HVAC Steam Water Accident Transport0
5
10
15
20
25
# Reports – Physical Plant78%
Examples of Physical Plant Disasters
System/equipment malfunction Steam control – overheating Water – failures in drinking water system Building flood – burst water main Aquatic species – catastrophic equipment
failure (overheated water, water valve failure, etc., tanks ruptured)
Failed heating systems for neonates
Examples of Physical Plant Disasters
HVAC System Failure Temperature excursions - predominately
a problem with overheating Last Winter – some incidents of
hypothermia (failure of heating systems)
Reports by sector
Academic Commercial Government Non Profit Hospital 0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
%
Site Visit Findings Since Fall 2011Program Components
26%
22%18%
14%10% 10%
Animal Environment
OHS
IACUC
Veterinary Care
Instiutional Adminsitra-tion
Physical Plant
Site Visit FindingsSince Fall-2011
Documenta-tion/ records
Training Program Description
Disater Plan Authority/Responsibility
Other0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
30%
35%
Institutional Administration – All findingsSince 2009….• ~ 6% of disaster plans were deficient
Institution type – deficiencies related to the disaster plan
Academic Commercial Government Nonprofit Hospital0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
%
Common Disaster Plan-related Deficiencies
Institutional plan did not include the animal program
Insufficient contingencies for animal care Not all animals were considered in the disaster
plan (remote sites and satellite facilities) Basic contingencies for animal care and
euthanasia were not considered Lack of consideration for essential personnel and
their training Insufficient detail
Site Visit Findings – Physical PlantSince Fall-2011
Institutional Administration – All findings
HVAC Construction/ maintenance
Special facilites Power Design/ layout0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
Site Visit Findings - HVACSince Fall-2011
Institutional Administration – All findings
HVAC Report Environmental Monitoring
T/H Control Air Pressure Differential
Ventialtion0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
Trend Analysis
The largest category of disasters reported is “institutional disasters” (72%)
System/equipment & HVAC malfunctions occur most frequently (78%)
Of “regional disasters” – power outages and hurricanes are most frequent (14% combined)
Trend Analysis cont’d
The most frequently reported disasters occurred without warning (response time?)
6% of existing disaster plans were deficient (site visits)
Physical plant disasters are most common and HVAC deficiencies are among the most common issues cited on site visits……..
