discovery and identification of the very high redshift...

26
Discovery and Identification of the Very High Redshift Afterglow of GRB 050904 J. Hailsip, M. Nysewander, D. Reichart, A. Levan, N. Tavir, S. B. Cenko, D. Fox, et al. Accepted to Nature (astro-ph/0509660)

Upload: others

Post on 16-Aug-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Discovery and Identification of the Very High Redshift ...newviews.uchicago.edu/talks/december_11/parallel/room_c/reichart/… · We began observing the field with 4.1m SOAR at ≈3

Discovery and Identification of the Very High Redshift Afterglow of GRB 050904J. Hailsip, M. Nysewander, D. Reichart, A. Levan, N. Tavir, S. B. Cenko, D. Fox, et al.

Accepted to Nature(astro-ph/0509660)

Page 2: Discovery and Identification of the Very High Redshift ...newviews.uchicago.edu/talks/december_11/parallel/room_c/reichart/… · We began observing the field with 4.1m SOAR at ≈3

We began observing the field with 4.1m SOAR at ≈3 hoursJ ≈ 17.4 mag at 3.1 hoursThe Palomar 60-inch and one of the six 0.41m PROMPT telescopes detected nothing at visible wavelengths

Swift detected a very long duration (T90 ≈ 225 sec) GRBBAT: 4′-radius localization at 81 secondsXRT: 6"-radius localization at 76 minutes

4.1m SOAR 0.41m PROMPT 8.1m Gemini South

Infrared Visible Both

GRB 050904: A Red Afterglow

High Redshift or High Extinction

NIR spectral index β = -1.25 + 0.15 but NIR to visible β < -5.9 (3σ)

6 < z < 8 z ≈ 6

Page 3: Discovery and Identification of the Very High Redshift ...newviews.uchicago.edu/talks/december_11/parallel/room_c/reichart/… · We began observing the field with 4.1m SOAR at ≈3

A Global Campaign

Page 4: Discovery and Identification of the Very High Redshift ...newviews.uchicago.edu/talks/december_11/parallel/room_c/reichart/… · We began observing the field with 4.1m SOAR at ≈3

A Global Campaign

SOAR

Page 5: Discovery and Identification of the Very High Redshift ...newviews.uchicago.edu/talks/december_11/parallel/room_c/reichart/… · We began observing the field with 4.1m SOAR at ≈3

A Global Campaign

UKIRT

Page 6: Discovery and Identification of the Very High Redshift ...newviews.uchicago.edu/talks/december_11/parallel/room_c/reichart/… · We began observing the field with 4.1m SOAR at ≈3

A Global Campaign

Palomar

Page 7: Discovery and Identification of the Very High Redshift ...newviews.uchicago.edu/talks/december_11/parallel/room_c/reichart/… · We began observing the field with 4.1m SOAR at ≈3

A Global Campaign

IRTF

Page 8: Discovery and Identification of the Very High Redshift ...newviews.uchicago.edu/talks/december_11/parallel/room_c/reichart/… · We began observing the field with 4.1m SOAR at ≈3

A Global Campaign

PROMPT

Page 9: Discovery and Identification of the Very High Redshift ...newviews.uchicago.edu/talks/december_11/parallel/room_c/reichart/… · We began observing the field with 4.1m SOAR at ≈3

A Global Campaign

BOOTES

Page 10: Discovery and Identification of the Very High Redshift ...newviews.uchicago.edu/talks/december_11/parallel/room_c/reichart/… · We began observing the field with 4.1m SOAR at ≈3

A Global Campaign

Calar Alto

Page 11: Discovery and Identification of the Very High Redshift ...newviews.uchicago.edu/talks/december_11/parallel/room_c/reichart/… · We began observing the field with 4.1m SOAR at ≈3

A Global Campaign

Gemini South

Page 12: Discovery and Identification of the Very High Redshift ...newviews.uchicago.edu/talks/december_11/parallel/room_c/reichart/… · We began observing the field with 4.1m SOAR at ≈3

The Light CurveReverse Shock?

TAROT – Boer et al. 2005

α1 ≈ -1.36α2 ≈ -0.82

Undersampling a variable lightcurve?

XRT – Watson et al. 2005

Page 13: Discovery and Identification of the Very High Redshift ...newviews.uchicago.edu/talks/december_11/parallel/room_c/reichart/… · We began observing the field with 4.1m SOAR at ≈3

Photometric RedshiftAssuming negligible emission

blueward of Lyα:z = 6.39 ± 0.12

Consistent with spectroscopy (Kawai et al. 2005):

z = 6.295 ± 0.002For WMAP cosmology:

12.8 Billion Years AgoUniverse 6% Current Age

Page 14: Discovery and Identification of the Very High Redshift ...newviews.uchicago.edu/talks/december_11/parallel/room_c/reichart/… · We began observing the field with 4.1m SOAR at ≈3

Proof of ConceptLamb & Reichart 2000:

The first stars probably formed when the universe was only about 1% of its current age

Since massive stars live short lives, the first GRBs should also have occurred around this time

Furthermore:The gamma rays should be detectable, even from these distancesThe afterglows should also be detectable from these distancesThey should occur in great enough numbers for sensitive GRB

satellites coupled with ground-based observations to break the distance record about once per year

Page 15: Discovery and Identification of the Very High Redshift ...newviews.uchicago.edu/talks/december_11/parallel/room_c/reichart/… · We began observing the field with 4.1m SOAR at ≈3

Bromm & Loeb 2005

GRBs as Probes1. Star-formation history of the universe

3. Extinction curves as a function of redshift

4. Epoch of reionization

5. High-redshift galaxies.

2. Metallicity history of the universe.

Page 16: Discovery and Identification of the Very High Redshift ...newviews.uchicago.edu/talks/december_11/parallel/room_c/reichart/… · We began observing the field with 4.1m SOAR at ≈3

GRBs as Probes1. Star-formation history of the universe

3. Extinction curves as a function of redshift

4. Epoch of reionization

5. High-redshift galaxies.

2. Metallicity history of the universe.

Valageas & Silk 1999

Zs,Zc = disk gas

Zh = halo gas

Page 17: Discovery and Identification of the Very High Redshift ...newviews.uchicago.edu/talks/december_11/parallel/room_c/reichart/… · We began observing the field with 4.1m SOAR at ≈3

GRBs as Probes1. Star-formation history of the universe

3. Extinction curves as a function of redshift

4. Epoch of reionization

5. High-redshift galaxies.

2. Metallicity history of the universe.

Reichart et al. 2001

Page 18: Discovery and Identification of the Very High Redshift ...newviews.uchicago.edu/talks/december_11/parallel/room_c/reichart/… · We began observing the field with 4.1m SOAR at ≈3

GRBs as Probes1. Star-formation history of the universe

3. Extinction curves as a function of redshift

4. Epoch of reionization

5. High-redshift galaxies. Becker et al. 2001

2. Metallicity history of the universe.

Page 19: Discovery and Identification of the Very High Redshift ...newviews.uchicago.edu/talks/december_11/parallel/room_c/reichart/… · We began observing the field with 4.1m SOAR at ≈3

GRBs as Probes1. Star-formation history of the universe

3. Extinction curves as a function of redshift

4. Epoch of reionization

5. High-redshift galaxies.

2. Metallicity history of the universe.

Pelló et al. 2004

z ~ 10?

Page 20: Discovery and Identification of the Very High Redshift ...newviews.uchicago.edu/talks/december_11/parallel/room_c/reichart/… · We began observing the field with 4.1m SOAR at ≈3

6 × 0.41m PROMPT CTIO, Chile

UNC GRB TELESCOPES

Page 21: Discovery and Identification of the Very High Redshift ...newviews.uchicago.edu/talks/december_11/parallel/room_c/reichart/… · We began observing the field with 4.1m SOAR at ≈3

Lamb & Reichart 2000

Page 22: Discovery and Identification of the Very High Redshift ...newviews.uchicago.edu/talks/december_11/parallel/room_c/reichart/… · We began observing the field with 4.1m SOAR at ≈3

4.1m SOARCTIO, Chile

UNC GRB TELESCOPES

Page 23: Discovery and Identification of the Very High Redshift ...newviews.uchicago.edu/talks/december_11/parallel/room_c/reichart/… · We began observing the field with 4.1m SOAR at ≈3

8.1m Gemini SouthCTIO, Chile

UNC GRB TELESCOPES

Page 24: Discovery and Identification of the Very High Redshift ...newviews.uchicago.edu/talks/december_11/parallel/room_c/reichart/… · We began observing the field with 4.1m SOAR at ≈3

UNC GRB TELESCOPES

9.2m SALTSAAO, South Africa

Page 25: Discovery and Identification of the Very High Redshift ...newviews.uchicago.edu/talks/december_11/parallel/room_c/reichart/… · We began observing the field with 4.1m SOAR at ≈3

FUN GRB TELESCOPES

The “Follow-Up Network for Gamma-Ray Bursts” Collaboration

SKYNET

Page 26: Discovery and Identification of the Very High Redshift ...newviews.uchicago.edu/talks/december_11/parallel/room_c/reichart/… · We began observing the field with 4.1m SOAR at ≈3

Southern Hemisphere: Same-site combination of PROMPT + SOAR + Gemini South with SALT for follow up

Northern Hemisphere: Many FUN GRB telescopes soon to be joined by SKYNET robotic telescope network

However, we are still building. With the completion of PROMPT we will be much quicker.

GRB 050904: Proof of concept, but failure in terms of same-night spectroscopy.

Conclusion