disruptors in the stock plan world - global equity · 2017-04-23 · agenda • introduction •...
TRANSCRIPT
Crispin Hanshaw, Managing Director, Charles Schwab & Co.Georgina Lai, Equity Programs, Pinterest
Carine Schneider, CEO, WFFConnectJohan Toll, Associate Vice President, Nasdaq
Disruptors in the Stock Plan World
Agenda• Introduction• Understand new technology
o What is Blockchain?• Changes in brokerage
o Robo advisingo Voice recognition verification (versus pin codes)o “intelligent” advisors
• Change in the private marketo Liquidity programs and secondary shares trading
• Millennial behavioro Changes in communicatingo Changes in plan design (private and public)
Microservices
Quantum Computing
Cryptography
Augmented / Virtual Reality
BLOCKCHAINCloud
ServicesSmartphone Ecosystem
Big Data
Machine Intelligence
INNOVATIONS ADVANCING THE FINTECH LANDSCAPE
Intelligent/Personal Virtual
Assistant
Internetof
Things
DigitalMoney
Technology trends shaping financial services?
SECURE DATA STOREOnly parties who should access it, can access it.
STABILITY THROUGH DECENTRALIZED
CONSENSUSInput is guaranteed /
validated through decentralized consensus.
CRYPTOGRAPHY ENSURES INTEGRITY
Data remains consistent, once written it cannot be
modified.
WHAT IS THE BLOCKCHAIN?
FOUNDATIONAL TECHNOLOGY
It is not a financial asset, it is not a business.
GROWTHPotential enabler for cost savings but also for growth, new business
models and market structures.
INNOVATIONPart of Nasdaq’s larger tech
innovation portfolio.
SECURITY. INTEGRITY. CONSENSUS. FOUNDATIONAL. GROWTH. INNOVATION.What is the Blockchain?
Paper Wallet
Web Wallet
What is a blockchain (distributed ledger)?
• Essential components:o Public-key cryptography (Diffie-Hellman ca 1976)o Proper decentralized peer-to-peer network (Gnutella 2000)
Nodes
Ledger
Private Keys
NETWORKUSERS
There are different kinds of blockchains
BUSINESS APPLICATI
ON
Public Blockchains► Open Internet
► Many miners / independent nodes
► Any and all can join the network
► High complexity / difficulty in verification process
► Independent nodes provide full auditability
Private Ledgers► Restricted Network
► Centralized mining / limited nodes
► Participants must be permissioned
► Lowered complexity / quicker verification
► Requires trust of the node operators and/or third party verification
Public vs.
Private
Where can distributed ledgers be useful?
This technology is good at keeping track of possession of any digitized asset.
Securities
Votes
Money Intellectual Property
Deeds of Ownership
Blockchain affecting us quicker than expectedNASDAQ STRATEGIC DIRECTION• Full senior management commitment• Initial blockchain offering launched to the market in 2015, i.e. Nasdaq Linq• Continued strong focus on investment and evolution of our blockchain
technology into more tangible assets during 2016• Several projects now ongoing within our own clearinghouse as well as with
external customers, to develop and launch BC enabled business applications on our core framework
• A global play where major benefits occur through collaboration between major marketplaces
• Market Technology well placed with more than 80 marketplaces running on our framework
FINANCIAL INDUSTRY MOVING FAST• > 1B USD in venture capital invested since 2012• World Economic Forum believes 10% of global GDP will be registered in
blockchain by 2025• More than 40 banks in a blockchain consortium for how to tap into the
blockchain technology. Pilot case launched in January 2016• Linux Foundation unites industry leaders to advance the blockchain
technology• Exchanges and Clearinghouses invest and pilot on several initiatives• Adoption will occur much faster than expected, heavy focus on
clearing/settlement with clear synergies also in the derivatives clearing
Strategy
Industry
CAPITAL MARKETS ON BLOCKCHAIN
Investor InvestorMarketplace
Government
Corporation
Asset and Cashledger(s)
Central Bank
Capital Markets on Blockchain
ESTONIA VOTING APPLICATION
VOTING SERVICECreated to provide a uniform method of developing secure voting applications.
First generation powered by Chain Smart Contract Scripts developed jointly by Nasdaq and Chain.
Second generation powered by Trusted Oracles developed by Nasdaq.
BLOCKCHAINBallot Record of Truth
VOTING APPLICATIONCreated to manage the voting life-cycle for the Estonia Proxy Voting Proof of Concept.
Built using the Voting and Blockchain Services and supports:
Creation of Voter and Administration AccountsIssuance/Transfer/Rescinding of Voting RightsCreation of Voting Token(s)Registration To Vote/Cast VoteViewing Voting Results
Estonia Voting Application
VOTING SERVICE TOKEN STATE DIAGRAM
RegisteredDistributed LockedVoted
Register To Vote Revote
Reset
Cast Ballot
Session End
Voting Service Token State Diagram
► A Blockchain-enabled platform for managing electronic records of ownership in privately issued securities
► Issuance and immediate transfer of shares without CSD or CCP
► Complete historical record,► Cap table management interface to
blockchain► Will support liquidity events through
integration with bank partners
IN PRODUCTION
“Enables First-Ever Private Securities Issuance Documented with Blockchain Technology”
Nasdaq Private Market - LINQ
The technology itself needs to evolve and be proven
Visions need to be distilled down to workable market models and structures
Existing legislation and regulation does not anticipate new business models enabled by blockchain technology
New technology and market structures need to be integrated with existing complex ecosystem of infrastructure
E.g. in relation to security. Smartcontracts. 50 different ledger protocols.
Governance a key piece of this. Information security policies, data policies.
Legislative and regulatory voids.
Credible integration and transition plans need to be developed and communicated before market participants are willing to make a bet on new technology and market models.
Increasing belief that the technology will work.
Industry initiatives. Legal certainty not fully in place.
Hurdles to Wide-Scale Adoption of Blockchain Technology in Capital Markets
Important trends are reshaping investment advice
Evolving technology
Rapid Industry Growth
Changing investor demands
Digital advice is growing rapidly
Sources: Cerulli, Retail Direct Firms and Digital Advice Providers 2015.
Cerulli's estimate of US digital-advisory AUM, $B
2016 2017 2018 2019 20200
600
400
200
800
ProjectionHigh Estimate
Low Estimate
40-60% annual growth
Underpinning the projected growth of digital advice is a broad appealConsumer likelihood to use robo-advice
Sources: A.T .Kearney 2015 Robo-Advisory Services Study of 4000 banked consumers. Likely+ is Likely, Very Likely or Extremely Likely. Schwab data as of 1/12016.
Schwab Intelligent PortfoliosTM
shows wide age appeal
Existing Clients
35%
24%
New to Schwab
Clients under 40
40% over 60
Likely+
36%Somewhat Likely
33%
NotLikely
31%
Schwab Intelligent PortfoliosTM illustrates appeal of digital advice
• Launched Mar 2015• $12.1 B in AUM• 118K accounts • $105K account averageo 14% have $250 K+ in Intelligent Portfolios
o 14% have $1 Million or more at Schwab For Illustrative Purposes Only
What we are learning about clients
Need
Help making good investment choices
Peace of mind
Benefits
Technology Diversified portfolio Automatic rebalancing No Advisory Fees Charged
Human Backed Professional investment insight from
Charles Schwab Investment Advisory, Inc. Access to Schwab professionals
24/7/365Schwab Intelligent Portfolios™ charges no advisory fees, account service fees, or commissions. Schwab affiliates earn revenue from the underlying assets in Schwab Intelligent Portfolio accounts. This revenue comes from managing Schwab ETFs™ and providing servicesrelating to certain third-party ETFs that can be selected for the portfolio, and from the cash feature on the accounts. Revenue may also be received from the market centers where ETF trade orders are routed for execution.
17 million calls per year1 million chats per year14 contact centers335 branches
Voice Biometrics Improving Customer Experience and Security
530ktotal voice
authentications
3000hours of handle
time saved
77%enrollment opt-in rate
94%successful
authentication rate
The numbers, thus far…
U.S. Companies are staying private longer• On April 5, 2012, the Jumpstart Our Business Startups (JOBS) Act was signed
into law by President Barack Obama. The Act requires the SEC to write rules and issue studies on capital formation, disclosure and registration requirements.
• JOBS Act primary objective is to “increase American job creation and economic growth by improving access to the public capital markets for emerging growth companies.”
• The JOBS Act is considered as the most significant Congressional relaxation in memory of restrictions surrounding the IPO process, public company reporting and private capital formation
• Includes provisions that ease the IPO process and subsequent public reporting obligations for emerging growth companies. EGC is defined in the Securities Act and the Exchange Act as an issuer with “total annual gross revenues” of less than $1 billion during its most recently completed fiscal year.
• Increases the shareholder threshold requiring a private company to begin public reporting.
Liquidity Programs continue to be popular
• Average time from founding to IPO is between 11 – 13 years (depending on the source)
• Shareholder rights are changing (i.e., Snap class A versus B stock)
• Concern should be taken with your stock plan (ISO/NQSO issues in the U.S.)
• Are private company ESPP’s becoming trendy?
Nasdaq Private Market statistics• $1 Billion in Transaction Volume over 32 Liquidity Programs -- 58% share
repurchases• -- 42% third-party tender offers• Median Program Size: $34 million• Average Company Profile of NPM’s Clients in 2016:-- Company age: 11
years• -- Number of employees: 220• -- Primary capital raised: $120 million• -- Valuation: $500 million• Profile of Eligible Seller Pool-- 74% current employees• -- 17% former employees• -- 8% investors• -- 1% other
How does this impact public companies?
• Recruiting• Retention• Flexibility• The rise of the private market/liquidity
Changing labor demographics
• Disruption from a changing labor force• Millennials to baby boomers – work is changing
Millennials - Characteristics
• Most educated generation• Multitaskers• Instant gratification• Connected
Millennials - Communications
• E-mail is considered “old-school”• TL:DR• Be ConciseoUse bullets
• Provide various optionsoOn premise presentations Stream/record
o Intranet/WikioOffice hours
Millennials - Mobile
• Consumption of information via mobile deviceoMobile phoneso Tablets
• Format friendly• Brevity• Use of videos• Interactive
Stock Option Extensions
• Private companies are staying private longer• Employees have less liquidity to exercise their stock options
• Extending the time to exercise stock options is becoming more acceptable
Stock Option Extensions
Pros• Value to employees• Parity with RSU Grants• Allows employees who want to move on the leaveoNo handcuffs or those employees “resting and vesting”
• Competitive with other pre-IPO companies
Stock Option ExtensionsCons• Potential Turnover • Triggers Modification for SBC Expense • Tracking of Terminated Employees • ISO/NQ 100K Rule* • Administrative Difficulties o System Limitationso ISOs will require a Tender Offero Education/ Need to partner with Tax Advisors
Stock Option ExtensionsThings to Consider • Estimated Timing of IPO (if private)• Expense Impact• ISO/NQ• Adverse International Impact...?• Population Affected • Equity System Capability
o Will workarounds be needed; what is the cost?
• Strategy• Are Stock Options Still Being Awarded?• Already Terminated Employees• Consistent Messaging
Stock Option Extensions
Recommendations• Extend “Post-Termination Exercise Period” to the life of the grant
• “One and Done” and• “All or Nothing” Approach
Stock Option Extension
Plan Design Considerations• ISO/NQ benefit• Design the option award with exercisability for the life of the awardoNo worries of a modification of the award
• Expense concern
Thank YouCrispin Hanshaw
Charles Schwab & [email protected]
Carine SchneiderWFFConnect
Georgina LaiPinterest
Johan TollNasdaq