distributed cognition and the social web

20
Distributed Cognition and The Social Web Brynn M. Evans Reboot 10 University of California Copenhagen, Denmark at San Diego 27 June 2008

Upload: brynn-evans

Post on 28-Jan-2015

104 views

Category:

Technology


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Theories like Distributed Cognition may help us understand user interactions and information flows on social web services. I discuss theory, provide examples from research, and look at limitations of current thinking on measuring and studying social interactions online.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Distributed Cognition and The Social Web

Distributed Cognition and

The Social Web

Brynn M. Evans Reboot 10University of California Copenhagen, Denmark at San Diego 27 June 2008

Page 2: Distributed Cognition and The Social Web

About me

PhD student studying cognitive science

focus: how (if) social web services facilitate information discovery & sensemaking

Page 3: Distributed Cognition and The Social Web

BRAIN • BEHAVIOR • COMPUTATION

Page 4: Distributed Cognition and The Social Web

COGNITIVE SCIENCE

psychology linguistics

computerscience

anthropology

neuroscience

human-computer interaction

philosophy

Page 5: Distributed Cognition and The Social Web

the emphasis on finding and describing ‘knowledge structures’ that are somewhere ‘inside’ the individual encourages us to overlook the fact that human cognition is always situated in a complex sociocultural world and cannot be unaffected by it

DISTRIBUTED COGNITION

Ed HutchinsCognition in the Wild (1995) p.xiii

Page 6: Distributed Cognition and The Social Web

Source: Ed Hutchins

Page 7: Distributed Cognition and The Social Web

What DISTRIBUTED COGNITION is NOT:

• NOT the study of social networks• NOT the same as “collective intelligence”• NOT the “wisdom of crowds” effect• NOT a type of cognition

Page 8: Distributed Cognition and The Social Web

• other people• material artifacts• culture

What DISTRIBUTED COGNITION is:

Page 9: Distributed Cognition and The Social Web

Source: Ed Hutchins

Page 10: Distributed Cognition and The Social Web

Source: Rod Stockwell

Page 11: Distributed Cognition and The Social Web

• friends, buddy lists

• interfaces, social objects

• social roles, rules

• other people

• material artifacts

• culture

In the real world In the online world

Page 12: Distributed Cognition and The Social Web

What is the appropriate unit of analysis?

Source: Chris Messina

Page 13: Distributed Cognition and The Social Web

What is the appropriate unit of analysis?

Page 14: Distributed Cognition and The Social Web

What is the appropriate unit of analysis?

Page 15: Distributed Cognition and The Social Web

Applying the theory...

Page 16: Distributed Cognition and The Social Web

Individual user:

Page 17: Distributed Cognition and The Social Web

Information:

Page 18: Distributed Cognition and The Social Web
Page 19: Distributed Cognition and The Social Web

Your thoughts...

Page 20: Distributed Cognition and The Social Web

References:

- Ed Hutchins, Cognition in the Wild (1995)

- G. Salomon, Editor’s introduction to Distributed Cognitions (1997)

BOOKS

ARTICLES

- Ed Hutchins, How a cockpit remembers its speed (1995)

- Yvonne Rogers, A brief introduction to distributed cognition (1997)

- Hollan, Hutchins & Kirsh, Distributed Cognition: a new foundation for human-computer interaction research. (2002)

- C. Halverson, Activity theory and distributed cognition: Or what does CSCW need to DO with theories? (2002)