do not blame merkel for the refugees _ gulfnews.com

Do not blame Merkel for the refugees | GulfNews.com

http://gulfnews.com/opinion/thinkers/do-not-blame-merkel-for-the-refugees-1.1594377[10/4/2015 11:10:54 AM]

SHARE

Do not blame Merkel for the refugees

It is all the fault of Angela Merkel. Had the German Chancellor not held out a hand of welcome, the refugee tide would have turned. Syrians would have stopped in their tracks on the road from Damascus. Iraqis, Afghans, Eritreans and the rest would have straightened their shoulders and faced up with equanimity to penury and death at home. Obvious, really.

Europes response to the refugee crisis has been displacement activity an unedifying game of hide and seek with, save for one or two, politicians doing most of the hiding. The hundreds of thousands of Syrians fleeing barrel bombs and beheading did not need Merkels permission to climb into boats promising a new life. Nor will they be deterred on their long march by the razor-wire fences in one, nasty corner of the continent.

The forces driving the biggest movement of people Europe has seen since the 1940s are heedless also of the recriminations ricocheting between European capitals. The bitter argument about how to share out 120,000 asylum seekers seems almost perverse when there are a million following close behind.

This year has seen the merging of three distinct streams of migration. Tens of thousands from Africas trouble spots have been making their way across the Mediterranean over some years. They were joined in 2014 by large numbers from the western Balkans who have given up waiting to be invited to join the

Image Credit: Bloomberg

Fixing the euro or gaining control of asylum seekers needs the grasp of enlightened self-interest, but with the EU, its political dynamic has gone into reverse

By Philip Stephens

Published: 17:17 October 3, 2015

GulfNews OpinionThinkers

FILED UNDER

TAGS

SYRIA LEBANON

ANGELA MERKEL

Europes reality check

ALSO IN

THINKERS

RELATED OPINION


Tories shouldnt whoop too soon over Corbyn

RELATED NEWS

Israel to seeks to increase population in Golan03:10 AM

Calais refugee camp conditions diabolical

Follow Us

VIEWED COMMENTED ILLUSTRATIONS VIDEOS

Youre fired! wont fix government

Taliban capture of Kunduz is no surprise

Learning from your life as an expat


Looking forward to another successful FNC term

MOST POPULAR

01

02

03

04

05

TRENDING

COUNTRIES

UNITED KINGDOM

IRAQ

SYRIA

IRAN

RUSSIA

UNITED STATES

THINKERSOctober 4, 2015 | Last updated 2 minutes ago

UAE NEWS BUSINESS SPORT OPINION

THINKERS 8 EDITORIALS 3 OFF THE CUFF 1 MEDIA WATCH ANALYSIS 1 TODAY IN HISTORY 1 2

LEISURE LIFE&STYLE CULTURE GUIDES MULTIMEDIA YOUR SAY

IN FOCUS

By Joschka Fischer, Special to Gulf

Merkel took the brave and correct decision to let the refugees enter Germany. For this, she deserves

wholehearted respect and full support.

GN NETWORK RADIO CLASSIFIEDS APPS SUBSCRIBE QUICK LINKS

OR REGISTER NOWSIGN IN



European Union (EU). No one should be surprised that Syrians and Iraqis driven out by war should have now decided they had invested enough in the vain hope of one day returning home.

A year ago, it might have been accurate to say that, overall, so-called economic migrants were in the majority. Now the balance has tilted towards refugees. The scale of the challenge is immense. Numbers may fall during the winter a function of the weather in the Aegean and Mediterranean seas but no one should imagine that this summers influx was a cyclical event. Order has all but broken down across a large swath of the Middle East and Maghreb. The Horn of Africa is riven by conflict. Extremists threaten the safety of parts of west Africa. Escape to Europe seems the only option.

Populists of the xenophobic right have seized the opportunity. Years of economic hardship have offered them fertile ground. No one can be surprised at their appeal to Europeans fearful for their living standards and jobs. However well the migrant inflow is handled, stresses and dislocation are unavoidable. To take a liberal view of Europes obligations to refugees (and, incidentally, of its long-term need for migrant workers) should not be to be blind to the disruption of movements on such a scale. That said, it is clearer still that the angry us and them politics of the ethnic nationalists does not have any answers. You cannot build a wall around Europe.

The infuriating thing about the EUs stumbling response this summer is that everyone knows how the influx could be better handled. In the short term, the imperative must be to spread the burden and this is vital to ensure the task of settling newcomers is not left to individual cities and municipalities. Governments must bend their fiscal rules to make integration work or be ready to pay the price in rising populism.

Nor is there is any magic about what to do next. Donald Tusk, president of the European Council, has provided a useful list: Re-establishing control over Europes external borders; establishing joint reception centres to identify genuine refugees; funding camps in Turkey, Lebanon and Jordan; and, yes, adding Europes economic and political weight to stalled peacemaking efforts from Syria to Somalia to Libya. The 1 billion (Dh4.14 billion) so far allocated to the task should be seen as but a small down payment.

What unites these measures is the imperative of collaboration. Nationalist rhetoric cannot deliver national solutions. Cooperation is what the EU is for. The founding insight was that states can best achieve their national goals by pooling sovereignty. From time to time this has been dressed up in the vaulting language of European civilisation, values and solidarity. The essential motor of the enterprise, however, has always been the pursuit of national interests.

At the start, the guiding purpose was the avoidance of war shutting down the possibility of a third continent-wide conflagration while building a bulwark against Soviet communism. More recently, the drivers were shared prosperity and, after the fall of the Berlin Wall, the export of stability and democracy to formerly communist states.

The logic of co-operation is as compelling as it has ever been. Fixing the euro or gaining control of migration require the same grasp of enlightened self-interest. The EUs big problem is that the political dynamic has gone into reverse. Electorates willing to share national power during the good times have been driven to try to reclaim it during the bad. When national governments are seen to fail, this cycle takes another turn for the worse.

There will be nothing easy about breaking the cycle. Europes political elites have lost the trust of their citizens. At moments of severe stress, the simple solutions of the populists can seem as beguiling as they are fraudulent. This is why the EU was invented. Todays leaders have painfully short memories.

Financial Times

AGREEMENT POLL

Do you agree with this article?

Agree

Disagree



SHARE

RATING POLL ELEMENT

INSPIRING

WORRYING

0% 0%

0%

MORE FROM THINKERS


Youre fired! wont fix government

Modis domestic barbs abroad could undermine him

Do not blame Merkel for the refugees

Tories shouldnt whoop too soon over Corbyn

The Brics fallacy

Taliban capture of Kunduz is no surprise

The growth that refugees drive

SYRIA

LEBANON

ANGELA MERKEL

JORDAN

LIBYA

TAGS FROM

THIS STORY

QUOTE BOARD

The lesson of the past 15 years is that defeating world poverty is not a hopeless - Tony Blair

Corbyns comment that you may be born poor, but you dont have to stay poor is l d t - Mark Gilbert

This summers loud posturing over the Iran deal shows there was never any question f b itti - Gordon Robison

COMMON SENSE: Provides a logical way forward

INSPIRING: Makes me want to take action

CONTROVERSIAL: Highly unexpected view or opinion

WORRYING: Makes me concerned

100%



MOST POPULAR ON GULF NEWS

FNC Elections 2015: winners announced

Paralysed man unaware of extent of d

Gitex Shopper Autumn opens doors

Identity theft victim cleared with bank's helpMexican wolf man battles isolation

Man in court over child porn surfing

Mandelas king jailed for terrorising people

Syrian, Filipina arrested over ll d b b l

40 dokha stores warned for violation

FEEDBACK GET THE PAPER OUR APPS MOBILE FRIENDLY VERSION

OUR LOCATION ADVANCED SEARCH

SITEMAP

MY GULF NEWSGulfNews.com is the most widely read newspaper, and online site in English in the Middle East. With a daily BPA audited paid circulation of over 108,000, and an online audience of 3.5 million uniques every month, it is your go to source for information on the region. Sign up below to begin personalising your experience

REGISTER

News Business Sport

Leisure Guides Opinion

Multimedia In Focus Life&Style

Culture Your Say

FOLLOW US

SIGN UP FOR NEWSLETTER

Al Nisr Publishing LLC 2015. All rights reserved

Advertise

Print

Direct Marketing

How To Find Gulf News

Contact Us

Print Subscriptions

Register

GN Media

How to follow Gulf News

History of GulfNews

Key Dates

Community

Journalism ethics Ethics Policy

Privacy Policy Terms & Conditions

Readers' Policy FAQs

Open Calais Careers at Gulf News

About Gulf News

New GulfNews.com: A Considerable Step Forward In Terms Of User Experience

gulfnews.comDo not blame Merkel for the refugees | GulfNews.com

RoZS1yZWZ1Z2Vlcy0xLjE1OTQzNzcA: form0: freeText: Search Gulf Newsinput2: freeText_(1): Search Gulf Newsinput2_(1):

RoZS1yZWZ1Z2Vlcy0xLjE1OTQzNzcA: form1: answerId: 0

vote: email: Enter your email id...input2:

do not blame merkel for the refugees _ gulfnews.com

Documents