doc.: ieee 802.11-11/0028r1 submission january 2011 bruce kraemer, marvellslide 1 smart grid update...

January 2011

Bruce Kraemer, Marvell

Slide 1

doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0028r1

Submission

Smart Grid Update – January 2011

Date: 2011-January-10

Abstract: NIST PAP#2 StatusAustralian Smart Metering

R1 = Minutes of Jan 12 Teleconference added.

Name Company Address Phone emailBruce Kraemer Marvell 5488 Marvell Lane,

Santa Clara, CA, 95054

+1-321-751-3988 [email protected]

Jon Rosdahl CSR 10871 N 5750 W

Highland, UT 84003

=1801-492-4024 [email protected]

January 2011


Slide 2

doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0028r1

Submission

Call Topics• Agenda Topics for this call

• PAP2 Report Status

• New Australian Smart Metering RFI

• Additional topics for LA

• SGIP news

• UK Consultation Status

• FG-Smart in ITU

January 2011


Slide 3

doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0028r1

Submission

NIST Timeline

Release of draft 0.6

Release of Version 1

Draft 0.5July 28, 2010

Call for Input to Section 6August 4, 2010

End of draft 0.5 review periodSeptember 15, 2010

December 3, 2010

November 4, 2010

SGIP face-to-face, ChicagoPAP 2 meeting

OpenSG meeting, MiamiTentative PAP 2 meeting

SGIP face-to-face, St LouisTentative PAP 2 meeting

September 16, 2010

End of draft 0.6 review period

September 30, 2010

October 29, 2010

January 2011


Slide 4

doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0028r1

Submission

NIST Timeline

Release of draft 0.6

Draft 0.5July 28, 2010

Call for Input to Section 6August 4, 2010

End of draft 0.5 review periodSeptember 15, 2010

December 3, 2010

November 4, 2010 OpenSG + PAP2 meeting, Fort Lauderdale

SGIP face-to-face, St LouisTentative PAP 2 meeting

September 16, 2010

End of draft 0.6 review period

September 30, 2010

October 29, 2010

Release of Version 1January 15, 2011

Extended edit period

Release of Version 2June/July 2011

Continuation of project to extend findings

January 2011


Slide 5

doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0028r1

Submission

NIST PAP2

• Version 0.6 was reviewed extensively in 802 and suggested changes generated by group and documented in 1316r4 were supplied to NIST (Doc 1396-r3)

• NIST Version 1.0 of the PAP2 report is expected to be available for review around January 15– perhaps in time for the Los Angeles meeting.

January 2011


Slide 6

doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0028r1

Submission

Australia

• Australia has issued a call for candidates for their Smart Metering HAN

• Responses from 802 should be provided– Probably best from individual WG, e.g 802.11, 802.15 but some

coordinated discussion required

– Because of the tight association of technology to metering application functionality, responses to many of the questions will be very difficult

– http://share.aemo.com.au/smartmetering/default.aspx

January 2011


Slide 7

doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0028r1

Submission

More Details

The NSMP HAN interface standard RFI document, and the Smart Metering Infrastructure Minimum Functionality Specification documents are published below (under BRWG documentation) or downloaded via the following links:

NSMP - HAN interface standard RFI version 1.1, PDF, 156KB

BRWG deliverable 01 - Smart Metering Infrastructure (SMI) Minimum Functionality Specification v1.1, PDF, 1237KB

~ 100 additional documents on meetings minutes, requirements, national goals, etc can be found on the web site.

http://share.aemo.com.au/smartmetering/Pages/BRWG.aspx

January 2011


Slide 8

doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0028r1

Submission

Australian HAN RFI• Request for information– home area network (HAN) interface standard

• The NSSC is required under its terms of reference to provide advice to the Ministerial Council on Energy's (MCE's) Standing Committee of Officials (SCO) on an open standard to support the provision of a home area network (HAN) for customers using the smart metering infrastructure.The NSSC has issued a request for information (RFI) to standard organisations to provide information on the capabilities of their HAN standard to meet the minimum functionality requirements for a HAN.The objectives of the RFI are to confirm that:– the HAN minimum functionality requirements (section 7.9 of the Smart Metering

Infastructure Minimum Functionality Specification, version 1.1) are clearly understood and unambiguously stated

– one or more standards are capable of meeting the minimum functionality requirements for a HAN interface


January 2011


Slide 9

doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0028r1

Submission

Australian HAN RFI

• The schedule for the RFI is as follows:

• 20 December 2010 Issue the RFI to standards organisations

• 21 January 2011 Standards organisations to register their participation via email

• 31 January 2011 Closing date for questions

• 11 February 2011 Submissions due date

• 14 to 25 February 2011 Preparation of initial evaluation and first draft of review to be sent to the BRWG

• 28 February 2011 Issue RFI draft evaluation to the BRWG

• 8-9 March 2011 First BRWG workshop review

• 10-18 March 2011 BRWG's HAN Technical Group work (as required)

• 5-6 April 2011Final BRWG workshop review

• 12 April 2011 Submission of the RFI report and Smart Metering Infrastructure Functionality Specification Change Control to the NSSC

• 20 April 2011 NSSC meeting

• May 2011 Issue HAN interface standard report to the MCE's SCO


January 2011


Slide 10

doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0028r1

Submission

RFI Sample

1.1 HAN Interface Standard Evaluation Criteria

Section 3 of this RFI sets out the RFI questions from Standard organisations by evaluation criteria. The following weights will be applied to the valuation criteria by the BRWG in assessing each HAN Interface standard:

Evaluation Criteria (from Section 3 RFI Questions) Weight

3.1 Standard organisation and governance 10%

3.2 Minimum functionality requirements (application layer) 40%

3.3 Physical architecture 5%

3.4 Testing and certification requirements 20%

3.5 HAN Device commissioning and HAN security 20%

3.6 Other functionality requirements 5%

January 2011


Slide 11

doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0028r1

Submission

RFI Sample

1.1 Physical Architecture

Questions Response

1. The NSSC feels that there is a need to support both RF and power-line communications. Please describe physical transmission media supported by the standard. For each please outline the typical range and throughput that can be expected. What are the typical constraints that may limit the expected range?

2. The Australian Communications and Media Authority assign the frequency range available for use by different devices. For the physical communications media described above please detail the specific frequency range used by the standard.

3. Please describe what limits the number of devices that can be supported on a home area network.

4. Please describe the home area network topology and architecture. For example how the network is formed, this should cover the types of devices, the need for a network coordinator, ability for nodes to work as repeaters and access control.

5. How does the standard ensure that collocated networks are isolated from each other (cannot share information) and do not interfere with each other?

6. What measures have been taken to avoid interference from other devices?

7. What measures have been taken to avoid interfering with other devices?

8. What is the practical data speed of communications between HAN devices?

January 2011


Slide 12

doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0028r1

Submission

1.1 Minimum Functionality Requirements (Application layer)

Questions Please indicate: C – complies, PC – partially compliance (describe), NC – does not comply

7.9.1.1 HAN Device Management

a) The meter shall be capable of performing as the ESI for the utility HAN.

b) The SMI shall support a means of securely registering HAN Devices to the ESI. Only registered HAN Devices shall be allowed to share information with the ESI and other HAN Devices on the utility HAN.

c) The SMI shall support the registration of 16 individual HAN Devices on the utility HAN.

d) The ESI shall be able to register more than one meter on the utility HAN

e) The ESI shall be able to register other utility meter types on the utility HAN.

f) The SMI shall be able to individually communicate with each registered HAN Device on the utility HAN.

g) The SMI shall be able to upgrade the software in a registered HAN Device1 on the utility HAN including the ESI

h) The ESI shall be able to determine received signal strength at a registered HAN Device on the utility HAN (for diagnostic purposes).

i) The SMI shall support the setting of a commencement date. This shall be used by:

(i) meters to ensure that HAN Devices cannot access data stored before the specified commencement date (this ensures HAN Devices cannot access historical data stored in meters before the specified date)

(ii) The ESI to ensure that HAN Devices cannot access information received before the specified commencement date. (this ensures HAN Devices cannot access messages or tariffs, sent before the specified date)

j) The SMI shall support a means of removing HAN Devices from the utility HAN to ensure that they can no longer share information with the ESI or other HAN Devices on the utility HAN

k) The SMI shall support turning off HAN transmissions from the ESI.

l) The ESI shall be able to identify the HAN Device type, services, functionality and capability supported by each HAN Device on the utility HAN. The SMI can read this information from the ESI.

m) The ESI shall retain the last date and time that a registered HAN Device was seen on the utility HAN. The SMI can read this information from the ESI using Remote Service Check.

1 This assumes that the registered HAN device has been certified to under the standard to accept software upgrades

January 2011


Slide 13

doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0028r1

Submission

Basic Project Plan

• 802.11 submitted notification of intent to respond.

• Use Jan 12 call to raise awareness & determine how/if to respond

• Use Smart Grid ad hoc meetings in LA to – Coordinate with 802.15

– generate questions

– identify volunteers

– prepare initial responses

• Use reflector and subsequent calls to finalize responses prior to Feb 11 deadline

January 2011


Slide 14

doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0028r1

Submission

Minutes for Teleconference Jan 12, 2011Attendees: Dalton Victor and Cristina Seibert -- Silver Springs Ted Booth and Bill Carney -- Sony John Buffington -- ITron Chi Wang and Henry Ptasinski -- Broadcom Dorothy Stanley -- Aruba Jon Rosdahl -- CSR 1. Call started at 2:05pm ET

2. Remind we are operating with IEEE-SA Meeting Rules and Patent Policy no issues.

3. Review of Document 11-11/0028r0. We walked through the slides. There was no questions or comments. No disagreement to discussion topics for next week. Only comment was satisfaction noting that we were coordinating this effort with 802.15, and that the discussion

would be carried on both reflectors. I noted that there were two times in the 802.11 schedule, and that the 802.15 folks were welcome to attend.

4. Topics for discussion next week:

PAP2 Report StatusNew Australian Smart Metering RFIAdditional topics for LA SGIP news UK Consultation StatusFG-Smart in ITU

5. Adjourned 2:18pm

Minutes

doc.: ieee 802.11-11/0028r1 submission january 2011 bruce kraemer, marvellslide 1 smart grid update...

Documents