January 2000

Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 1

doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/012r3

Submission

IEEE P802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks

TG1 Report #2

David Intercontinental Hotel 12, Kaufman St. Tel Aviv Israel

January 2000

Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 2

doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/012r3

Submission

Contents

• TG1 Summary• Overview of Tel-Aviv

– Objectives– Submissions– Motion Scheduling – Session

• Next Steps

January 2000

Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 3

doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/012r3

Submission

Summary

• LB1 yielded 1013 comments to be resolved against P802.15.1/D0.6– 193 Technical Comments and– 818 Editorial Comments

• LB1 Comment Resolution 10Jan00 - 11Feb00• LB(2) 21Feb00 to 2Mar00• LB(3) 19May00 to 22Jun00• Draft ready for Sponsor Ballot Jul00

January 2000

Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 4

doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/012r3

Submission

Tel-Aviv Objectives

• 1. LETTER BALLOT 1 COMMENT RESOLUTION/DISPOSITION

• 2. PROVIDE AN UPDATE ON TG1• 3. PROVIDE AN OVERVIEW OF THE BLUETOOTH

VERSION 1.0 B SPECIFICATION(S), IN SESSION & TUTORIAL

• 4. PLAN FOR DRAFT STANDARD• 5. VOTE TO FORWARD/RECIRCULATE THE DRAFT

TO SPONSOR/WG RECIRC LB• 6. VOTE TO REVIEW THE RECIRC COMMENTS FROM

WG LB #X BEFORE PLENARY

January 2000

Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 5

doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/012r3

Submission

Tel-Aviv - SubmissionsDoc # Doc Doc FIle Sub Web802.15- File Name Title Format Author Dir99/148 g 99148r2P802-15 WG-TG1-Timeline mpp Siep Jan99/160 g 99160r1P802-15 TG1-Tentative-Agenda-Jan00 xls Gifford Jan99/168 g 99168r0P802-15 TG1-Draft-Standards-Bearer-Feb00 doc Gifford Jan99/169 g 99169r0P802-15 Bluetooth-Liaison-Report ppt Gifford Jan99/170 g 99170r0P802-15 Bluetooth-PM-Joint-Meeting ppt Gifford Jan99/172 g 99172r0P802-15 TG1 LB1 Comments pdf Siep Jan99/173 g 99173r0P802-15 TG1 LB1 Comment Resolution pdf Siep Jan99/174 g 99174r0P802-15 WG Liaison Report 5 ppt Gifford Jan99/175 g 99175r0P802-15 WG TG1 Report ppt Gifford Jan99/176 g 99176r0P802-15 WG Suggested Session Changes ppt Gifford Jan99/177 g 99177r0P802-15 TG1 Working Agenda ppt Gifford Jan99/178 g 99178r0P802-15 TG1 Comment Reolution Discussion ppt Siep Jan99/179 g 99179r0P802-15 TG1 Tut. Overview & LB1 Summary ppt Gifford Jan99/180 g 99180r0P802-15 TG1 Tut. Overview v1.0B diff pdf Siep Jan99/182 g 99182r0P802-15 TG1 Minutes doc Kinney Jan00/001 g 00001r0P802-15 TG1 SDL for MAC L2CAP pdf Cypher Jan00/003 g 00003r0P802-15 TG1 Bluetooth Liaison Letter doc Gifford Jan00/012 g 00012r0P802-15 TG1 Report 2 ppt Gifford Jan

January 2000

Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 6

doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/012r3

Submission

TG1/WG Motion Scheduling

• Motions– Motion #1 - Empower the WG

Technical Editor for resolution

– Motion #2 - Empower the WG to recirculate a Draft LB

January 2000

Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 7

doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/012r3

Submission

MOTION #1

• MOTION: I move that we empower the WG Technical Editor to be able to continue with TG1 Comment Resolution between 14Jan00 & 5Mar00.

• Non Technical 50% (Procedural)

• Mover: Ian

• Second: Tom

• Y/N/A: 8/0/0

• Pass/Fail?: Pass

January 2000

Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 8

doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/012r3

Submission

MOTION #2

• MOTION: I move that we empower the WG chair to be able to conduct a 10 Day Electronic Letter Ballot for approval of the application of -99/173r5 to the current P802.15.1 Draft Standard between 14Jan00 & 5Mar00.

• Non Technical 50% (Procedural)• Mover: Ian• Second: Tom• Y/N/A: 8/0/0• Pass/Fail?: Pass

January 2000

Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 9

doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/012r3

Submission

New TG1 -99/160r1 GraphicTIMES SUNDAY MONDAY FRIDAY

07:00-08:00

08:00-10:00802.15 WG

Opening TG1 MC TG1 MC

10:00-10:30 Break 10:30-12:00 HRSG TG1 HRSG TG1 HRSG

12:00-13:00 Lunch 13:00-15:00 TG2 TG1 Joint TG1 TG2

15:00-15:30 Break

15:30-17:00 TG1 TG1 TG2

17:00-18:30 Dinner

18:30-20:00 AC TG1 20:00-21:30

802.15 WG Closing

Dinner

TG1 Social

THURSDAYAC

TG1

BreakTG1

Lunch

Break

Dinner

TG1 Tutorial

Break

Social

TG1

TUESDAY

TG1

Break

Lunch

Break

WEDNESDAY

Break

Lunch

Break

Note: This graphic describes the weekly session of the IEEE P802.15, w/ TG1 highlighted. TG1 are r1 new adds.

January 2000

Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 10

doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/012r3

Submission

Next Steps/TG1 Roadmap

• 14Jan00 post Tel-Aviv, IL– Complete Comment Resolution(s) -99/173r5– Change IEEE P802.15.1/D0.6 to reflect Bluetooth Specification(s)

v1.0 B; will become P802.15.1/D0.7– Electronic Letter Ballot of the -99/173r5

• 6-10Mar00 Albuquerque, NM USA– Based on results of Ballot apply -99/173r5 to P802.15.1/D0.7 this

becomes P802.15.1/D0.8

• 8-12May00 Seattle, WA USA– Electronic Letter Ballot of P802.15.1/D0.8

• 10-14Jul00 LaJolla, CA USA– LB Comment Resolution of P802.15.1/D0.8

January 2000

Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 11

doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/012r3

Submission

Comment Codes

• [1] Planned– TG1 Concurs

• [2] Research– TG1 needs to do more research

• [3] Discussion– TG1 needs to discuss in more detail

• [4] Clarification– TG1 will request more detail from the Author

• [5] BSIG Discussion– TG1 needs to discuss the comment w/ BSIG

• [6] Decline– TG1 declines the comment from the Author

• [7] Verify– TG1 we need to review Bluetooth Specification(s) v1.0 B

• [8] Defer– TG1 requires and Bluetooth has not determined need

• [9] Editor Discretion– Anything coded as E/e/N

January 2000

Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 12

doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/012r3

Submission

LB1 Results - Overview

• 42 Total Voting Members

• 35 Total Votes (18/15/2)

• 7 Total Failed to vote (2 of 7 were incomplete No's)

VOTE CATEGORY NUMBER PERCENTAGEYea 18 43%Nea 15 36%Abstain 2 5%Failed to vote 7 17%Total 42 100%

January 2000

Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 13

doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/012r3

Submission

LB1 Results - DetailNO LAST NAME STATUS LB1 VOTE

1 Bien Mr. Alan (Alan) voter a2 Pan Dr. Davis (Davis) voter a3 Baatz Mr. Simon (Simon) voter n4 Bisdikian Dr. Chatschik (Chatschik) voter n5 Eckard Mr. Richard (Dick) voter n6 Gifford Mr. Ian (Ian) voter n7 Golmie Ms. Nada (Nada) voter n8 Heberling Mr. Allen (Allen) voter n9 Heile Mr. Robert (Bob) voter n

10 Kinney Mr. Patrick (Pat) voter n11 Kraemer Mr. Bruce P. (Bruce) voter n12 McInnis Mr. Michael D. (Mike) voter n13 Mueller Mr. Thomas voter n14 Palin Mr. Arto (Arto) voter n15 Shellhammer Dr. Stephen J. (Steve) voter n16 Siep Mr. Thomas (Tom) voter n17 Watanabe Dr. Fujio (Fujio) voter n18 McGlynn Mr. Daniel R. voter n-w/o19 Reede Mr. Ivan (Ivan) voter n-w/o20 Alexandrou Mr. Dimitri (Dimitri) voter y21 Batliwala Mr. Edul voter y

22 Crosswy Mr. Wm. Caldwell (Caldwell) voter y23 Ditch Mr. Richard (Rich) voter y24 Fischer Mr. Kurt (Kurt) voter y25 Frank Mr. Matthias (Matthias) voter y26 Jones Mr. John Paul (John) voter y27 Kerry Mr. Stuart (Stuart) voter y28 Miura Dr. Akira (Akira) voter y29 Murray Mr. Peter voter y30 Noble Mr. Erwin R. (Erwin) voter y31 Rios Mr. Carlos A. (Carlos) voter y32 Schwarz Mr. Karlheinz (Karlheinz) voter y33 Torp Mr. Steve (Steve) voter y34 Alborzi Mr. Houman (Houman) voter y/c35 Li Dr. Yunxin (Yunxin) voter y/c36 Paczonay Mr. Mike (Mike) voter y/c37 Stapleton Mr. Nick (Nick) voter y/c38 Carlson Mr. Dave voter f39 Chhaya Mr. Harshal (Harshal) voter f40 Kandala Dr. Srinivas (Srinivas) voter f41 Kermani Dr. Parviz (Parviz) voter f42 Roan Mr. Brian E. (Brian) voter f

a = Abstainn = Do Not Approve (Negative)y = Approve (Affirmative)/c = with Comments w/o = with out Comments y = failed to respond

January 2000

Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 14

doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/012r3

Submission

Type of comments (e/E/t/T) - LB1 #

TG1 appreciates the work the eighteen (18) Members didin providing these 1013 Comments! 2 not coded.

Minor Editorial Major Editorial Minor Technical Major TechnicalNO LAST NAME LB1 VOTE INITIAL "e" "E" "t" "T" TOTAL

1 Alborzi Mr. Houman (Houman) y/c hxa 39 7 15 1 622 Baatz Mr. Simon (Simon) n smb 0 0 2 5 73 Bisdikian Dr. Chatschik (Chatschik) n ccb 14 22 0 3 394 Eckard Mr. Richard (Dick) n rge 0 17 0 5 225 Gifford Mr. Ian (Ian) n icg 34 4 0 0 386 Golmie Ms. Nada (Nada) n NG 94 48 59 18 2197 Heberling Mr. Allen (Allen) n ADH 68 36 4 12 1208 Heile Mr. Robert (Bob) n rfh 0 1 0 0 19 Kinney Mr. Patrick (Pat) n pwk 0 12 0 7 19

10 Kraemer Mr. Bruce P. (Bruce) n bpk 0 0 0 1 111 Li Dr. Yunxin (Yunxin) y/c yxl 34 208 4 3 24912 McInnis Mr. Michael D. (Mike) n mdm 11 1 0 5 1713 Mueller Mr. Thomas n tm 0 5 8 15 2814 Paczonay Mr. Mike (Mike) y/c mjp 132 0 4 3 13915 Palin Mr. Arto (Arto) n atp 2 0 2 2 616 Shellhammer Dr. Stephen J. (Steve) n Sjs 0 1 0 6 717 Siep Mr. Thomas (Tom) n tms 0 0 0 7 718 Stapleton Mr. Nick (Nick) y/c nms 2 0 0 0 219 Watanabe Dr. Fujio (Fujio) n fxw 24 2 1 1 28

454 364 99 94 1011

January 2000

Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 15

doc.: IEEE 802.15-00/012r3

Submission

Type of comments (e/E/t/T) - LB1 #/%

1011 Comments• Minor Editorial "e”

– 454 (45%)

• Major Editorial "E”– 364 (36%)

• Minor Technical "t”– 99 (10%)

• Major Technical "T”– 94 (9%)

45%

36%

10%

9%

Minor Editorial

Major Editorial

Minor Technical

Major Technical

454

364

99

94

Minor Editorial

Major Editorial

Minor Technical

Major Technical