documenting human rights violations and facilitating dialogue: english version handouts

67

Upload: dhrp

Post on 04-Apr-2016

218 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

 

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 2: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 3: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 4: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 5: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 6: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 7: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 8: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 9: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 10: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 11: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 12: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 13: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 14: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 15: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 17: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts

1.

2.

23

This material is adapted from Sexual Violence and Exploitation Institute for International Criminal Investigations, 2004 24

This material is drawn in part from Sexual Violence and Exploitation, Institute for International Criminal Investigations, 2004

Page 18: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts

Page 19: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts

Page 20: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts

E.

131.

2.

132.

3.

133.

134.

135.

Page 21: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts

136.

F.

137.

(a)

(b) (c)

(d)

(e)

(f)

(g)

138.

G.

139.

(a) (b)

(c) (d)

140.

Page 22: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts

(a)

(b)

(c)

(d) (e)

(g)

(h)

(i)

Page 23: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts

H.

141.

142.

143.

144.

I.

145.

146.

Page 24: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts

147.

148.

J.

149.

150.

K.

151.

Page 25: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts

L.

152.

153.

154.

155.

25

This material is drawn in part from Sexual Violence and Exploitation, Institute for International Criminal Investigations, 2004 26

Informal communication between Patricia Sellers, Gender Legal Advisor, ICTY and the Women’s Initiatives for Gender Justice, 2004

Page 26: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts

• •

27

Ibid

Page 27: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts

6 Article 68(1) The Court shall take appropriate measures to protect the safety, physical and psychological well-being, dignity and

privacy of victims and witnesses. In so doing, the Court shall have regard to all relevant factors, including age, gender as defined in

article 7, paragraph 3, and health, and the nature of the crime, in particular, but not limited to, where the crime involves sexual or

gender violence or violence against children. The Prosecutor shall take such measures particularly during the investigation and

prosecution of such crimes. These measures shall not be prejudicial to or inconsistent with the rights of the accused and a fair and

impartial trial; (2) As an exception to the principle of public hearings provided for in article 67, the Chambers of the Court may, to

protect victims and witnesses or an accused, conduct any part of the proceedings in camera or allow the presentation of evidence by

electronic or other special means. In particular, such measures shall be implemented in the case of a victim of sexual violence or a

child who is a victim or a witness, unless otherwise ordered by the Court, having regard to all the circumstances, particularly the views

of the victim or witness.

Rule 88 provides that a Chamber may, taking into account the views of the victim or witness, order special measures such as, but not

limited to, measures to facilitate the testimony of a traumatised victim or witness, a child, an elderly person or a victim of sexual

violence, pursuant to article 68, paragraphs 1 and 2.

Page 28: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 29: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 30: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts

Page 31: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts

1.

7 Some material in this section is drawn generally from: Adapted from Callamard, A., Sexual Violence Documenting Human

Rights Violations by State Agents, Amnesty International Publications and the International Centre for Human Rights and Democratic Development, 1999; Sexual Violence and Exploitation, Institute of International Criminal Investigations, 2004.

Page 32: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts

2.

Page 33: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts

3.

Page 34: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts

4.

8 Rule 70(c) of the of the Rome Statute Rules of Procedure and Evidence provides that in cases of sexual violence the

Court shall be guided by and, where appropriate, apply the following principles: (a) consent cannot be inferred by reason

of any words or conduct of a victim where force, threat of force, coercion or taking advantage of a coercive environment

undermined the victim’s ability to give voluntary and genuine consent; (b) consent cannot be inferred by reason of any

words or conduct of a victim where the victim is incapable of giving genuine consent; (c) consent cannot be inferred by

reason of the silence of, or lack of resistance by, a victim to the alleged sexual violence; (d) credibility, character or

predisposition to sexual availability of a victim or witness cannot be inferred by reason of the sexual nature of the prior or

subsequent conduct of a victim or witness.

Page 35: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts

5.

Page 36: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts

Page 37: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 38: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 39: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts

6.1

Page 41: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts

6.3

Page 42: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 43: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts

>

• • • •

>

>

>

Page 44: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts

>

>

>

6.4

Page 45: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 46: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 48: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 49: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts

Page 50: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 51: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 52: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 53: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts

o

o

o

Page 54: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts

9 Information about the initiative can be found at http://www.everycasualty.org/

Page 55: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts

10

http://www.branitelji.hr , last accessed on August 23, 2012 11

Nataša Kandić in an interview for Vijesti.ba (http://www.vijesti.ba/vijesti/bih/124065-Koliko-zrtava-prognanih-jugo-

ratovima.html), last accessed on January 12, 2013

Page 56: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts

12

The elements of division, set forth in a research conducted by the organization Oxford Research Group on the main

practices of documenting in the world, have been partially used here and adjusted by the author.

Page 57: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts

13

Humanitarian Law Centre Belgrade; Humanitarian Law Centre Prishtina; Research-Documentation Centre Sarajevo

Page 58: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 59: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 60: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 61: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 62: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 63: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 64: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 65: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 66: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts
Page 67: DOCUMENTING HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND FACILITATING DIALOGUE: English Version Handouts