does it matter who teaches a core mathematics course to engineering undergraduates ?

17
Ryan Cartwright, Autar Kaw, Ali Yalcin University of South Florida http://nm.MathFor College.com 2013 ASEE Conference & Exposition Atlanta, GA June 25, 2013

Upload: mechelle-gonzales

Post on 03-Jan-2016

14 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Ryan Cartwright, Autar Kaw, Ali Yalcin University of South Florida http://nm.MathFor College.com. Does it Matter Who Teaches a Core Mathematics Course to Engineering Undergraduates ?. 2013 ASEE Conference & Exposition Atlanta, GA June 25, 2013. Background. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Does it  Matter Who Teaches  a  Core Mathematics Course  to  Engineering Undergraduates ?

Ryan Cartwright, Autar Kaw, Ali Yalcin

University of South Florida

http://nm.MathFor College.com

2013 ASEE Conference & ExpositionAtlanta, GA

June 25, 2013

Page 2: Does it  Matter Who Teaches  a  Core Mathematics Course  to  Engineering Undergraduates ?

The nation wants to graduate 100,000 engineers annually.

We want to retain students who declare engineering as a major and part of the “suggested” solution to the retention problem is to teach Math courses in Engineering.

Page 3: Does it  Matter Who Teaches  a  Core Mathematics Course  to  Engineering Undergraduates ?

Students in Mechanical Engineering can take either

MAP2302: Ordinary Differential Equations (MATH ODE)

OR EGN3433: Modeling of Dynamic Systems

(ENG ODE)

Page 4: Does it  Matter Who Teaches  a  Core Mathematics Course  to  Engineering Undergraduates ?

To measure effect of an online resources on student performance in Numerical Methods for Engineers, we were collecting data such as

pre-requisite course grades, age, gender, transfer status

and relating it to performance in pre-concept test, post-concept

test and final examination.

Page 5: Does it  Matter Who Teaches  a  Core Mathematics Course  to  Engineering Undergraduates ?
Page 6: Does it  Matter Who Teaches  a  Core Mathematics Course  to  Engineering Undergraduates ?

Is prior academic performance different for students taking the ODE course in engineering over the ODE course in Math?

Is there a difference in the knowledge they gain from ENG ODE and MATH ODE course?

Is the performance in the ODE questions in Numerical Methods final exam different for students taking the ENG ODE and MATH ODE courses?

Page 7: Does it  Matter Who Teaches  a  Core Mathematics Course  to  Engineering Undergraduates ?
Page 8: Does it  Matter Who Teaches  a  Core Mathematics Course  to  Engineering Undergraduates ?

(n=82 for ENG; n=369 for MATH)

Average grade of Calculus I, Calculus II, Calculus III

Page 9: Does it  Matter Who Teaches  a  Core Mathematics Course  to  Engineering Undergraduates ?

(n=82 for ENG; n=369 for MATH)

Page 10: Does it  Matter Who Teaches  a  Core Mathematics Course  to  Engineering Undergraduates ?

(n=42 for ENG; n=232 for MATH)

Page 11: Does it  Matter Who Teaches  a  Core Mathematics Course  to  Engineering Undergraduates ?

(n=82 for ENG; n=369 for MATH)

Page 12: Does it  Matter Who Teaches  a  Core Mathematics Course  to  Engineering Undergraduates ?
Page 13: Does it  Matter Who Teaches  a  Core Mathematics Course  to  Engineering Undergraduates ?

• Is prior academic performance different for students taking the ODE course in engineering over the ODE course in Math? No Statistical Difference

• Is there a difference in the knowledge they gain from ENG ODE and MATH ODE course?No Statistical Difference

• Is the performance in the ODE questions in Numerical Methods final exam different for students taking the ENG ODE and MATH ODE courses?No Statistical Difference

Page 14: Does it  Matter Who Teaches  a  Core Mathematics Course  to  Engineering Undergraduates ?

Is prior academic performance different for students taking the ODE course in engineering over the ODE course in Math? No Statistical Difference

Is there a difference in the knowledge they gain from ENG ODE and MATH ODE course?No Statistical Difference

Is the performance in the ODE questions asked Numerical Methods course different for students taking the ENG ODE and MATH ODE courses?No Statistical DifferenceUninteresting results or are they?

Page 15: Does it  Matter Who Teaches  a  Core Mathematics Course  to  Engineering Undergraduates ?
Page 16: Does it  Matter Who Teaches  a  Core Mathematics Course  to  Engineering Undergraduates ?
Page 17: Does it  Matter Who Teaches  a  Core Mathematics Course  to  Engineering Undergraduates ?

(n=82 for ENG; n=369 for MATH)