dothan lawsuit over press box at westgate park
TRANSCRIPT
8/2/2019 Dothan Lawsuit Over Press Box At Westgate Park
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dothan-lawsuit-over-press-box-at-westgate-park 1/8
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF HOUSTON COUNTY, ALABAMA
DAVID LALIBERTE and
JEAN LALIBERTE,
Plaintiffso
v.
CITY OF DOTHAN and
and t'At', that person, corporationn or
other legal entity who designed the press box
made subject of this Complaintr'(B"rthat
person, corporationo or other legal entity who
constructed the press box made subject
of this Complaint, and t'Ctt, eelJmr'(E')s
rrprr, ncrr and ttHtt those persons or entities
whose negligence or other wrongful or
actionable conduct caused or contributed
to the injuries and damages sustained by
the Plaintiff; the existence and identities
of all such fictitious Defendants being
presently unknown to the Plaintiff' but
will be substituted by amendment when
ascertained.
Ilefendants.
Case No. CY-2012-
Jury Demand Requested
VERI IED qOMPLAINT
STATEMEIYT OF THE PARTIES
1. plaintiff David Laliberte is over the age of nineteen (19) years and resides in Pike
County, Alabama.
-1-
ELECTRONICALLY FILED3/27/2012 2:36 PM
CV-2012-900105.00CIRCUIT COURT OF
HOUSTON COUNTY, ALABAMCARLA H. WOODALL, CLER
8/2/2019 Dothan Lawsuit Over Press Box At Westgate Park
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dothan-lawsuit-over-press-box-at-westgate-park 2/8
2.
J.
4.
Plaintiff Jean Laliberte is over the age of nineteen (19) years and resides in Pike
County, Alabama.
Defendant City of Dothan is a municipality in the State of Alabam4 County of
Houston.
Defendant6'At' is that person, corporation, or other legal entity who designed the
press box made subject of this Complaint, whose identity is presently unknown and
will be added by amendment to this Complaint when ascertained.
Defendant "B" is that person, corporation, or other legal entity who constructed the
press box made subject ofthis Complaint, whose identity is presently unknown and
will be added by amendment to this Complaint when ascertained.
Fictitious Defendants C througtr H, being those persons or entities who may be
legally responsible for the claims set forth herein and who may be added by
amendment by Plaintiffs when their identities are ascertained by further discovery
and who are parties to the actions described herein or a.re otherwise obligated to
perform the duties and obligations described herein, whose identity is presently
unknown and will be added by amendment to this Complaint when ascertained.
This action is based upon an incident occurring in Dothan, Houston County, Alabama
on or about the July 31, 2010.
On November 12,2010, the Plaintiff did submit a Sworn Statement of Claim for
Damages Against City of Dothan, Pursuant to Section ll-47-190-192, Code of
Alabama (1975). The City did not respond to same.
COUNT I.I\"EGLIGENCE
plaintiffs adopt and re-allege paragraphs 1 through 8 above as iffully set forth herein.
On or about the 3l't day of July,2010 at approximately 6:15 p-m., PlaintiffDavid
Laliberte was injured at Westgate Park Recreation Center, property owned and
operated by the City of Dothan. This area of Westgate Park is commonly known as
"The Field of Dreams" designed for persons with handicaps'
plaintiff David Laliberte was an invitee to the property in order to broadcast the 13
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
a
8/2/2019 Dothan Lawsuit Over Press Box At Westgate Park
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dothan-lawsuit-over-press-box-at-westgate-park 3/8
yearold recreation state playoff baseball game.
As Plaintiff David Laliberte was descending the blackpainted stairs of the press box,
a trash receptacle was located on the upper landing near the top of the black painted
stairs. This trash receptacle presented an obstacle to Plaintiff David Laliberte and he
was forced to step to the left side of the staircase. This portion of the stairway is
located in a 90-degree curve and is considerably narrower than the opposing side.
This caused Plaintiff David Laliberte to lose his footing. He attempted to regain his
balance by grasping for the handrail as he was falling, but discovered there were no
handrails installed. Additionally, there was no lighting in the stairway except for any
minimal natural lighting that might come through the windows from the top floor of
the press box.
As a result of the aforementioned, Plaintiff David Laliberte fell down the entire
stairway to the bottom floor, coming to rest outside the door of the press box.
Plaintiff David Laliberte was transported from the scene via ambulance to Flowers
Hospital. PlaintiffDavid Laliberte received emergency treatment at this time and has
continued to receive surgery, treatments and rehabilitation since this incident.
PlaintiffDavid Laliberte has suffered, continues to suffer and will suffer inthe future
severe physicalpain, permanentinjurieswith lifelong impairment, mental agonyand
anguish, and has incurred expeoses for medical attention.
WHEREFORE, Plaintifts demand judgment against the Defendants, the amount to be
determined by ajury, to compensate the Plaintifffor his personal injuries and costs.
COUNT II. GROSS NEGLIGENCE
Plaintiffs adopt and re-allege paragraphs I through 15 above as if fully set forth
herein.
As PlaintiffDavid Laliberte was descending the black painted stairs ofthe press box,
a trash receptacle was located on the upper landing near the top ofthe black painted
stairs. This trash receptacle presented an obstacle to PlaintiffDavid Laliberte and he
was forced to step to the left side of the staircase. This portion of the stairway is
t2.
13.
14.
15.
T6,
17.
a-J-
8/2/2019 Dothan Lawsuit Over Press Box At Westgate Park
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dothan-lawsuit-over-press-box-at-westgate-park 4/8
located in a 90-degree curve and is considerably narrower than the opposing side-
This caused Plaintiff David Laliberte to lose his footing. He attempted to regain his
balance by grasping for the handrail as he was falling, but discovered there were no
handrails installed. Additionally, there was no lighting in the stairway except for any
minimal natural lighting that might eome through the windows from the top floor of
the press box.
As a direct and proximate cause and result ofDefendants' gross negligence, Plaintiff
David Laliberte was caused to suffer physical injuries, mental pain and agony, and
incurred expenses for medical treatfiIent.
Ptaintiff David Laliberte will continue to suffer physical pain, permanent injuries
with lifelong impairment, mental pain and agony as a result of the Defendants' said
gross negligence and wantonness.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs demand judgment of punitive damages against the Defendants
in the amount to be determined by a jury to punish the Defendants for their grossly negligent actions
and to deter others from same or similar conduct.
20.
COUNT III - I$EGLIGENT CONSTRUgTION
Plaintiffs adopt and re-allege paragraphs 1 through 19 above as if fully set forth
herein.
As Plaintiff David Laliberte was descending the black painted stairs ofthe press box,
a trash receptacle was located on the upper landing near the top of the black painted
stairs. This trash receptacle presented an obstacle to PlaintiffDavid Laliberte and he
was forced to step to the left side of the staircase. This portion of the stairway is
located in a 9Q-degree curve and is considerably narower than the opposing side.
This caused PlaintiffDavid Laliberte to lose his footing. He attempted to regain his
balance by grasping for the handrail as he was falling, but discovered there were no
handrails installed. Additionally, there was no lighting inthe stairway except for any
minimal natural lighting that might come through the windows from the top floor of
the press box.
18.
19.
2t.
-4-
8/2/2019 Dothan Lawsuit Over Press Box At Westgate Park
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dothan-lawsuit-over-press-box-at-westgate-park 5/8
As a direct and proximate cause and result of Defendants' negligent construction,
Plaintiff David Laliberte was caused to suffer physical injuries, permanent injuries
with lifelong impairment, mental pain and agony, and incurred expenses for medical
treatment.
PlaintiffDavid Laliberte will continue to sufferphysical pain, mental painand agony
as a result of the Defendants' said gtoss construction.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs demand judgment of damages against the Defendants in the
amount to be determined by a jury to punish the Defendants for their negligent construction and to
deter others from same or similar conduct.
COT]NT IV - NEGLIGENT DESIGN
Plaintiffs adopt and re-allege paragraphs I through 22 above as if fully set forth
herein.
As Plaintiff David Laliberte was descending the black painted stairs ofthe press box,
a trash receptacle was located on the upper landing near the top of the black painted
stairs. This trash receptacle presented an obstacle to PlaintiffDavid Laliberte and he
was forced to step to the left side of the staircase. This portion of the stairway is
located in a 90-degree curve and is considerably narrower than the opposing side.
This caused Plaintiff David Laliberte to lose his footing. He attempted to regain his
balance by grasping for the handrail as he was falling, but discovered there were no
handrails installed. Additionally, there was no lighting inthe stairway except for any
minimal natural lighting that might come through the windows from the top floor of
the press box.
OSHA Publication 3I24 - Stairways and Ladders states, in part, o'stairways with four
or more risers, or that rise more than 30 inches (76 cm) in height - whichever is less -
must have at least one handrail."
Additionally, the IBC - Internqtional Building Code, Section 1009 Stairways and
Handrails,states, inpart, "1009.1 1 Handrails. Stairways shall have handrails oneach
side."
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
-5-
8/2/2019 Dothan Lawsuit Over Press Box At Westgate Park
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dothan-lawsuit-over-press-box-at-westgate-park 6/8
28. Furthermore,theAmericans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Accessibility Guidelinesfor
Buildings and Facilifles, Section 4.9 Stairs, states, in part, *4.9.4Handrails.
Stairways shall have handrails at both sides of all stairs. Handrails shall comply with
4.26 and shall have the following features: (l) Handrails shall be continuous along
both sides of stairs...(2) If handrails are not continuous, they shall extend at least l2
in (305mm) beyond the top riser and at least 12 in (305 mm) plus the width of one
tread beyond the bottom riser..."
Additionally,the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Accessibility Guidelines for
Buildings and Faciliffes, Section 15 Recreation Facilities states, in part, 'Newly
designed or newly constructed and altered recreation facilities shall comply with the
applicable requirements of Section 4 andthe special application sections, except as
modified or otherwise provided for in this section."
29. As a direct and proximate cause and result of Defendants' negligent construction,
Plaintiff David Laliberte was caused to suffer physical injuries, mental pain and
agony, and incurred expenses for medical treatment.
30. PlaintiffDavid Lalibertewill continueto sufferphysical pain, mentalpainandagony
as a result of the Defendants' said gross negligence and wantonness.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs demand judgment of damages against the Defendants in the
amount to be determined by a jury to punish the Defendants for their negligent design and to deter
others from same or similar conduct.
COUNT V. LOSS OF CONSORTIUM
31. The Plaintiffs adopt and re-allege paragraphs 1 through 30 above as if fully set forth
herein.
32. The Plaintiffs' lives have been so drastically altered due to PlaintiffDavid Laliberte's
injuries that they have been also caused to suffer from the lack of companionship ofeach other, more specifically the sex, society, and services rendered each other has
greatly diminished and/or ended.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs demand judgement against Defendants in an amount to be
-6-
8/2/2019 Dothan Lawsuit Over Press Box At Westgate Park
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dothan-lawsuit-over-press-box-at-westgate-park 7/8
determined by ajury in an amount necessary to compensate them for their loss of consortium claims.
CERVERA, RALPH & REEYES, LLC914 South Brundidge Street
P. O. Box 325
Troy, Alabama 36081
(334) s66-01 l6
David Lalibe
Plaintiff
-7-
8/2/2019 Dothan Lawsuit Over Press Box At Westgate Park
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dothan-lawsuit-over-press-box-at-westgate-park 8/8
STATE OF ALABAMA )couNTY oF PrKE )
Before me, the undersigned authority, in and for said county and state, personallyappeared David Laliberte who being by me first duly sworn, deposes and says on oath that he hasread the foregoing and that the allegations of the foregoing Verified Complaint are true andcorrect to the best of his information and belief.
T]tris 2l-oaay or M0fC h ,zorz.
STATE OF ALABAMACOLINTY OF PIKE
Before me, the undersigned authority, in and for said county and state, personallyappeared Jean Laliberte who being by me first duly sworn, deposes and says on oath that she hasread the foregoing and that the allegations of the foregoing Verified Complaint are true and
correct to the best of her information and belief.
rt""2l-o
)
)
-8-