downing college cambridge · body downing college, cambridge cb2 1dq patron: hrh the duchess of...
TRANSCRIPT
A N N U A L R E P O RT A N D AC C O U N T S
for the f inancial year ending 30 June 2014
D O W N I N G C O L L E G E C A M B R I D G E
The West Range ©Tim Rawle
www.dow.cam.ac.uk
3
Contents5. Financial Highlights
6. Members of the Governing Body
9. OfficersandPrincipalProfessionalAdvisors
11. ReportoftheGoverningBody
67. Financial Statements
77. PrincipalAccountingStatements
78. ConsolidatedIncome&ExpenditureAccount
79. Consolidated Statement of Total Recognised Gains and Losses
80. Consolidated Balance Sheet
82. ConsolidatedCashflowStatement
85. NotestotheAccounts
5
FINANCIAlHIGHlIGHtS
2014
£
2013
£
2012
£
Income
Income 10,155,889 9,663,733 9,239,544
Donations and Benefactions Received 5,292,916 3,124,484 2,304,365
Conference Services Income 2,042,832 2,130,085 1,875,620
OperatingSurplus/(Deficit) 320,009 336,783 306,969
CostofSpace(£perm2) £150.87 £150.20 £156.65
College Fees:
PubliclyFundedUndergraduates £4,068/£4,500 £3,951/£4,500 £3,951
PrivatelyFundedUndergraduates £7,350 £6,999 £6,000
Graduates £2,424 £2,349 £2,289
lossonCollegeFeeperStudent £2,436 £2,630 £1,995
Capital Expenditure
InvestmentinHistoricalBuildings 1,751,811 573,388 446,851
InvestmentinStudentAccommodation 1,499,507 740,562 2,784,000
Assets
Free Reserves 8,349,966 13,372,300 11,499,498
InvestmentPortfolio 35,775,344 34,917,793 31,785,279
SpendingRuleAmount 1,617,819 1,543,197 1,505,631
totalReturn 7.6% 9.2% 6.2%
totalReturn:3yearaverage 7.7% 10.3% 10.6%
ReturnonProperty 5.8% 7.6% 11.4%
ReturnonProperty:3yearaverage 8.3% 12.1% 14.3%
ReturnonSecurities 8.9% 10.8% 0.0%
ReturnonSecurities:3yearaverage 6.5% 8.1% 6.9%
NetAssets 147,365,167 141,519,568 137,605,725
YearEnded30June2014|FinancialH
ighlights
5
6
YearEnded30June2014|Mem
bersoftheGoverningBody DOWNINGCOllEGE,CAMBRIDGECB21DQ
Patron:HRHtheDuchessofKent,GCVO
Visitor:theCrown
MEMBERSOFtHEGOVERNINGBODYMaster:ProfessorGeoffreyGrimmett,MA(Oxon),DPhil(Oxon),DSc(Oxon),ScD,FRS,ProfessorofMathematicalStatistics
theFellowsoftheCollege(inorderofElection)asof1October2014PaulChristopherMillett,MA,PhD,Vice-Master,CollinsFellowinClassics,UniversitySeniorlecturerinClassics(1983) WilliamMarkAdams,MA,MSc(london),PhD,MoranProfessorofConservationandDevelopment(1984) trevorWilliamClyne,MA,PhD,FREng,ProfessoroftheMechanicsofMaterials(1985) CatherinelynettePhillips,BA(Queen’s),MA(toronto),PhD,RJOwensFellowinEnglish(1988) GrahamJohnVirgo,BCl(Oxon),MA,ProfessorofEnglishPrivatelaw(1989),UniversityPro-Vice-Chancellor(Education) JohnStuartlandrethMcCombie,MA,MA(McMaster),PhD,Tutor,ProfessorofRegionalandAppliedEconomics(1989) DavidJohnWales,MA,PhD,ScD,FRSC,ProfessorofChemicalPhysics(1989) trevorWilliamRobbins,CBE,MA,PhD,FRS,ProfessorofCognitiveNeuroscience(1991) ChristopherAllimHaniff,MA,PhD,Fellows’ Steward,ProfessorofPhysics(1993) NicholasColeman,BSc,MB,ChB(Bristol),PhD,FMedSci,VerjeeFellowinMedicine,ProfessorofMolecularPathology(1994) AdamNoelledgeway,BA(Salford),MA(Manchester),PhD(Manchester),Tutor,ProfessorofItalianandRomancelinguistics(1996) IanRichardJames,MA,MA(Warwick),PhD(Warwick),Graduate Tutor,FellowinModernandMedievallanguages,ReaderinFrench(1996) SusanElizabethlintott,MA,PhD(Kent),Senior Bursar, Senior Treasurer of the Boat Club(1997) ZoeHelenBarber,MA,PhD,ReaderinMaterialsScience(2000) SophiaDemoulini,BA(Wooster),MSc(Minnesota),PhD(Minnesota),FellowinMathematics(2000) IanGarethRoberts,BA(Wales,Bangor)MA(Salford),PhD(SouthernCalifornia),littD,FBA,Professoroflinguistics(2000) MichaeltrevorBravo,BEng(Carleton),MPhil,PhD,UniversitySeniorlecturerattheScottPolarResearchInstitute(2001) DavidRobertPratt,MA,PhD,FRHistS,Secretary to the Governing Body, Fellow Archivist and Keeper of Art and Artefacts,FellowinHistory(2001) DavidJohnFeldman,QC(Hon),MA(Oxon),DCl(Oxon),FBA,FRSA,RouseBallProfessorofEnglishlaw(2003) lipingXu,BSc(Beijing),PhD,Universitylecturerinturbomachinery(2004) PaulDerekBarker,BSc(ImperialCollege,london),DPhil(Oxon)UniversitySeniorlecturerinChemistry(2004) GuyBarnettWilliams,MA,PhD,Senior Tutor,AssistantDirectorofResearch,WolfsonBrainImagingCentre(2004) Marcustomalin,MA,MPhil,PhD,Fellow Librarian, Admissions Tutor (Arts), Graduate Tutor,FellowinEnglish,UniversityResearchAssociate inEngineering(2004) JaytheodoreStock,BA(trent),MSc(Guelph),PhD(toronto),Graduate Tutor,UniversitySeniorlecturerinHumanEvolutionandDevelopment(2005) NataliaMora-Sitja,BSc(Barcelona),MA(Barcelona),MSc(Oxon),DPhil(Oxon),Tutor,UniversitylecturerinEconomicHistory(2005) WilliamO’Neill,BSc(Essex),MSc(Essex),PhD(Imperial),ProfessoroflaserEngineering(2006) AmyCatherineGoymour,MA,BCl(Oxon),Tutor,HopkinsParryFellowinlaw,Universitylecturerinlandlaw(2006) AdrianaIrmaPesci,MS,PhD(NacionaldelaPlata),DarleyFellowinMathematics(2006) AmylouiseMilton,MA,MSc,PhD,Ferreras-WillettsFellowinNeuroscience,UniversitylecturerinExperimentalPsychology(2007) BrigitteSteger,MA,MPhil(Vienna),PhD(Vienna),SeniorlecturerinModernJapaneseStudies(2007)
7
YearEnded30June2014|Mem
bersoftheGoverningBodyJonathantrevor,BA(Glamorgan),MA(Warwick),PhD,Praelector,FellowinManagementStudies,UniversitylecturerinHumanResources
andOrganisations(2008) KennethMcNamara,BSc(Aberdeen),PhD,Dean,UniversitySeniorlecturerinEarthSciences(2008) RichardKeithtaplin,MBE,BSc(lSE),MA,Junior Bursar(2009),UniversityJuniorProctor Jieli,BS(Wuhan),MS(Paris),PhD(Paris),UniversitylecturerinFluidDynamics(2009) KeithJamesEyeons,MA,MA(Nottingham),PhD,Chaplain, Praelector, Fellow Information Officer,Fellowintheology(2010) RobertKeithHarle,MA,PhD,FellowinComputerScience(2010) timothyJamesBurton,MA,MB,BChir,PhD,FellowinPharmacology,ClinicallecturerintranslationalMedicine&therapeutics(2010) MartaMorgadoCorreia,BA(lisbon),PhD,Admissions Tutor (Science),FellowinBiologicalSciences(2010) AliciaHinarejos,BA(Valencia),MPhil(Valencia),BA(UNED),MJur,MPhil,DPhil(Oxon),Universitylecturerinlaw(2011) GabrielleBennett,BA(Virginia),Development Director(2011) MichaelHousden,MSci,MA,PhD,Senior Treasurer of the Amalgamation Club,Mays-WildResearchFellowinChemistry(2012) KamranYunus,BSc(Bath),PhD(Bath),Tutor,FellowinChemicalEngineering(2012) JohnRicher,MA,PhD,ReaderinAstrophysics(2013) SarahKennedy,BA(Melbourn),llB(Melbourn),PhD,ResearchFellowinEnglish(2013) MonicaMorenoFigueroa,BA(leon),MA(MexicoCity),MA(Goldsmiths),PhD(Goldsmiths),FellowinSocialSciences,Universitylecturerin Sociology(2014) BrendanPlant,BEc(Sydney),llB(Sydney),MSc(lSE),PhD,HopkinsParryFellowinlaw(2014)
RetirementsandResignations1July2013–30September2014PeterJamesDuffett-Smith,MA,PhD,Vice-Master,UniversityReaderinExperimentalRadioPhysics(1980)(retired2013) PeterDavidEvans,MA,PhD,ScD,Tutor,FellowinPhysiology,PrincipalInvestigator,BabrahamInstitute(1981)(retired2014) SubhaMukherji,MA(Calcutta),MA(Oxon),MPhil,PhD,UniversitySeniorlecturerinEnglish(2009)(resigned2014) Paullinden,BSc(Adelaide),MSc(Flinders),PhD,FRS,GItaylorProfessorofFluidMechanics(2011)(retired2014) JosephWebster,MAHons(Edinburgh),MScR(Edinburgh),PhD(Edinburgh),IsaacNewton-GrahamRobertsonResearchFellow(2011)(resigned2013)
8
YearEnded30June2014|OtherFellows theHonoraryFellows
GilesSkeyBrindley,MA(london),MD,FRS SirFrancisGrahamSmith,MA,PhD,FRS SirArnoldStanleyVincentBurgen,MA,FRS SirAlanBowness,CBE,MA DameJanetAbbottBaker,CH,DBE, MusD(hon),llD(hon) AlanNormanHoward,MA,PhD,FRIC PeterMathias,CBE,MA,Dlitt,FBA SirtrevorRobertNunn,CBE,BA GodfreyMichaelBradman,FCA ColinBrianBlakemoreMA,ScD,FRS MartinJohnKemp,MA,FBA RichardJohnBowring,MA,PhD,littD DavidStanleyIngram,OBE,MA,PhD,ScD, FRSE SirQuentinSaxbyBlake,CBE,MA,RDI,FCSD, FRA SirlawrenceAntonyCollins,llD,FBA BaronessPhyllisDorothyJames,OBE,JP,FRSl SirDavidAnthonyKing,MA,PhD,ScD,FRS RtRevdNicholasthomasWright,MA,DPhil,DD SirJohnPendry,MA,PhD,FInstP,FRS SirBrianVickers,PhD,Dlitt,FBA AitzazAhsan,MA,llM,Barristeratlaw ProfessorJohnlawrenceCardy,MA,PhD,FRS HowardEricJacobson,MA theRtHonthelordJusticelewison,QC,Kt, MA AirChiefMarshalSirStuartPeach,KCB,CBE, MPhil,Dtech(hon),Dlitt theRtHonthelordJusticelloyd-Jones,QC, Kt,MA,llM theRtHonthelordJusticeMcCombe,Kt,MA BarryJohnEveritt,BSc,MA,PhD,ScD,DSc, DSc(hon),FRS,FMedSci
theEmeritusFellowsAlfredthomasGrove,MA DavidAndrewBlackadder,BSc(Edinburgh), MA,DPhil(Oxon) IanBonartopping,MA RobertJohnRichards,MA,PhD CharlesHarpum,MA,llB,llD JohnAlanHopkins,MA,llB MartinJoshuaMays,MA,PhD BarryCharlesMoore,MA,MSc(lSE) PhilipHusonRubery,MA,PhD,ScD CharlesPorterEllington,BA(Duke),MA,PhD, FRS MargeryAnnBarrand,BSc,PhD RichardSmithBA(london),MA(Oxon),PhD, FBA StaffordWithington,BEng(Bradford), PhD(Manchester) PeterDuffett-Smith,MA,PhD PeterEvans,MA,PhD,ScD Paullinden,BSc(Adelaide),MSc(Flinders), PhD)
theAssociateFellowsJulianJeffs,QC,MA Williamtudor-John,MA GeorgeFrederickPulman,QC,MA JohnNevilletait,MA
FoundationFellowHumphreyBattcock,MA, MBA(londonBusinessSchool)
theWilkinsFellowsGodfreyMichaelBradman,FCA JulianRobinDarley,MA,FEng RichardAlexanderFrischmann,MA ChristianFlemmingHeilmann,MA AlanNormanHoward,MA,PhD,FRIC Joanna Maitland Robinson RumiVerjee,MA timCadbury,MA JanetOwens,MD RichardWilliams,MA JonathanHoward,MA ChrisBartram,MA,FRICS,RA MariaWilletts,MA(Oxon) RobertJohn,MA,Dlitt(Swansea) louiseArnell,MA RobertMarkwick,MA,MBA(Manchester) JamesEdwardSimonArnell,MA,Barrister atlaw
theFellowsCommonerDavidChambers,MSc(lBS),MSc(lSE), PhD(lSE) BarrieHunt,MA,M.Ed(Exeter) timothyRawle,MA Peterthomson,MA MartinVinnell,BSc,PhD(Essex)
theFellowsCommonerEmeritusJohnHicks,MA,FREng
Bye-FellowsDanAlistarh,PhD NigelAllington,BSc(Hull),MA AnnelaAnger-Kraavi,MA,BSc(tallinn),MPhil, PhD RichardBerengarten,MA JimenaBerni,MS,PhD IanBucklow,PhD MarieBuda,PhD MatthewCarter,BA AndrejCorovic, GeorgeCouch KateCrowe NedaFarahi,PhD AndrewHolding Bernadette Holmes VickyJones,MA,MB,Bchir,MRCS luciali,MA,MB,BChir Kathleenliddell,llB,(Melbourne),BSc, (Melbourne),MBioeth,(Monash),DPhil,(Oxon) Andrewlynch,MA,MMath,PhD(Sheffield) ShaneMcCorristine,MA,PhD,FRHistS DouglasMaslin,MA,MBBChir CatherineMaunder,MA AlexMorris,PhD JillPearson,BA,VEtMC,MRCVS IanSabir,MA,MB,BChir,PhD,MRCP JohannaSyrjanen WilliamSchafer,PhD JaneSterling,MB,BChir,MA,PhD,FRCP Garethtaylor,BA,PhD Anastasiatheodosiou,BA,MPhil,MB,BChir MichaelWakelam,BSc(Birmingham), PhD(Birmingham) Haixi Yan
9
YearEnded30June2014|OfficersandPrincipalProfessionalA
dvisors
Inland Revenue Charity No: X2938
Charity Registration No: 1137455
OFFICERSANDPRINCIPAlPROFESSIONAlADVISERS
Masterfrom1October2013:ProfessorGeoffreyGrimmett,MA,DPhil,DSc(Oxon),ScD
Masterto30September2013:ProfessorBarryJohnEveritt,BSc,MA,PhD,ScD,DSc.(Hon.Hull),DSc.(Hon.Birmingham),FRS,FMedSci
Seniortutor:DrGuyWilliams,MA,PhD
SeniorBursar:DrSElintott,MA,PhD(Kent)
ActuariesCartwrightConsultingltd MillPoolHouse Mill Lane GodalmingGU71EY
ArchitectsCarusoStJohn 1 Coate Street londonE29AG
RobertlombardelliPartnership St.luke’sHouse 5WalsworthRoad Hitchin,HertsSG49SP
QuinlanandFrancisterry Old Exchange High Street Dedham ColchesterCO76HA
AuditorsPetersElworthy&Moore SalisburyHouse Station Road CambridgeCB12lA
BankersBarclays Bank 9-11StAndrew’sStreet CambridgeCB23AA
PropertyManagersCarterJonasllP 6-8HillsRoad Cambridge CB2 1NH
PropertyValuersCarterJonasllP 6-8HillsRoad Cambridge CB2 1NH
SecuritiesManagersPartnersCapitalllP 5YoungStreet London W8 5EH
MorganStanleySecuritieslimited PrivateWealthManagement 25CabotSquare londonE144QA
SolicitorsHewitsonsllP ShakespeareHouse 42NewmarketRoad CambridgeCB58EP
PenningtonsllP ClarendonHouse Clarendon Road Cambridge CB2 8FH
Marks&ClerkllP 62-68HillsRoad CambridgeCB21lA
12
1 http://www.topuniversities.com/qs-world-university-rankings
2 http://www.timeshighereducation.co.uk/world-university-rankings/2014-15/world-ranking
3 http://www.thecompleteuniversityguide.co.uk/league-tables/rankings
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody REPORtOFtHEGOVERNINGBODY
theFinancialAccountstheaccountsthatfollowconsolidatethoseoftheCollegeanditswholly-ownedsubsidiaries,DowningCollegeDevelopmentslimited,DowningCambridgeConferenceslimited,andtheMayBallCompanylimited.theCollegeisoneof31autonomous,self-governingCollegeswithintheUniversityofCambridge.theUniversityisconsistentlyrankedamongthetopuniversitiesintheworld;thisyear,itwasrankedjointsecondintheQSWorldUniversityRankings1,fifthinthetimesHigherEducationrankings2,andtopintheCompleteUniversityGuidetoUKUniversities3.
Foundedin1800,theCollegeelecteditsfirstFellowin1808andadmitteditsfirstundergraduatein1817.AbequestfromSirGeorgeDowning3rdBaronet led to the foundationof theCollege,whichwasoriginally formed for theencouragementof the studyoflawandMedicineandof thecognatesubjectsofMoralandNaturalScience.theCollegenowaccepts students inall subjects taught intheUniversityofCambridge.Knownasthe“lastof theoldandthefirstof thenew”, theCollegewasthe17thtobefoundedwithintheUniversity ofCambridge, after a gap of 204 years, some 69 years before the founding of the nextCollege,whichwas the firstwomen’sCollege inCambridge.EachCollege isautonomous, self-governing,anddistinctive.At thebeginningof theacademicyear,ProfessorGeoffreyGrimmett,FRS,wasinstalledastheCollege’s17thMaster.Fortheacademicyear2013-14,thecommunityconsistedof51Fellows,448undergraduates (including twovisitingstudents),and250graduates, reflecting the increasingemphasisplacedbytheUniversityasawholeongraduateeducation,bothintaughtcoursesandresearch.theworkoftheCollegeissupportedby150staff (FtE118.6).
theUndergraduates
Ofthe446undergraduatesinresidence,59%weremenand41%women,and401werehomeorEUstudentsand45overseas.Ofthe370homestudents,59%werefromstate-maintainedschoolsand41%fromtheindependentsector.UndergraduatenumbersaredeterminedbythenumberthattheCollegeisabletoaccommodate;thetargetforentry,therefore,isstaticatapproximately125newentrantsineachyear.Overthelastfiveyears,thetotalnumberofundergraduateshasrangedfrom436to455,withanaverageof446.Exceptformedicineandarchitecture,wherenumbersarecontrolledthroughaUniversitywideagreement,theCollegedoesnotfixthenumberofstudentsinanyonesubject,butratherassessescandidatesacrosssubjects.OneofthemorepopularCollegesintermsofadmissions,879appliedfortheseplaces,617wereinterviewedand141wereofferedplaces,includingsixcandidateswhohaddeferredentryuntil2014.theCollegewishestoencourageapplications,butstressesthehighlevelofacademicattainmentrequiredforsuccess.In2013-14,overallnumbersreflectedtheshapeoftheUniversityasawhole,withtheexceptionoflawandmedicine,twohistoricallystrongsubjects,wherenumberswerehigher,andEnglishandmathematics,whichhadcomparativelyfewerstudents.
AdmissiontotheUniversityishighlycompetitive,withsome16,000applicantseachyear.Applicantnumbershavegrownby17%overthelasttenyears,whilethenumbersadmittedhaveremainedrelativelyconstantatabout3,500.Downing,liketheUniversityasawhole,investstimeandresourcesin(1)attractingindividualswhocanmakethemostoftheeducationalexperiencewithitsemphasisonsmallgroupsupervisionand(2)inencouragingstudentsfromdisadvantagedbackgroundstoaspiretohighereducationandconsiderapplyingtotheUniversity.Veryfew,ifany,undergraduatesdeclinetheiroffers;however,inevitablysomedonotachievetheAlevelandStEPgradesthatareaconditionoftheiroffers.Ofthe141offersmade,124achievedtheirgrades,withtheminimumoffersetatA*AA.Forentryin
13
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody2015,allCollegesarerequiringA*A*Aforsciencesubjects,whichmorecloselyreflectsthegradesachievedbysuccessfulcandidates.
theCollegesuseallavailableinformationtoassesswhetherornottoofferacandidateaplace.However,statisticalevidencehasborneoutthecorrelationinmostsubjectsbetweenhighUMSscoresatASlevelandresultsinthetriposexaminations.theGovernment’srecentdecisionnottoincludeASresultsinthegradeawardedatAlevel,butinsteadtoretainASonastandalonebasis,willinevitablymeanthatsomeschoolswillchoosenottoprepareorentertheirstudentsforASexaminations.theDirectoroftheCambridgeAdmissionsOfficehaswrittentoallschoolswithasixth-formtoreassurethemthatapplicantswithoutASscoreswillnotbeatadisadvantageandexplainthatintheabsenceofASscores,emphasiswillbeputonGCSEresultsandteachers’predictions,whicharenotasstronginpredictingsuccessinhighereducation.thenewsystemappliestostudentsenteringEnglishsixth-formsinSeptember2015.
UnderitsagreementwiththeOfficeforFairAccess(‘OFFA’),theUniversityhascommittedtoincreasetheproportionofUKresidentstudentsadmittedfromUKstatesectorschoolsandcollegessothat theyfallwithinarangeof61-63%by2016-17andtoincreasetheproportionofUKresidentstudentsadmittedfromlowparticipationneighbourhoodstoapproximately4.0%.InOctober2013,theCollege admitted61%ofUK resident students from state schools and2% from low-participationneighbourhoods, adisappointingresult, but similar to that achievedacross theUniversity.As standards cannotbecompromised, emphasis isplacedon recruitmentandinraisingaspirations.Duringtheyear,theCollegereceivedasubstantialdonationtohelpitsworkinoutreachandaspartofthisprogramme,named‘DiscoverDowning’,willshortlybelaunchinganewwebsite.
ExaminationResultsArecordnumberoffirsts,116,placedtheCollegeabovetheaveragefortheUniversity,whichcontributedtoahigherrankinginthetompkinstable.25%ofthestudentsreceivedfirsts,and11ofthosecametopoftheirtriposexamination.Forthefirsttime,aDowningstudentbecameSeniorWrangler,thenamegiventothestudentwhocomestopoftheMathematicaltripos.tocelebratethissuccess,theCollege presented the student,Yang li,with theDowningCollegeMedal for ExtraordinaryAchievement, a copper, nickel andgoldmedalcreatedfortheoccasionbyProfessorBillO’Neillusinglasertechnology.Inaddition,twenty-twoprizeswereawardedforspecialperformanceinthetriposexaminations:KateEdwards(EnglishPartII),FreyaPetty(HistoryofArtPartII,top),JohnHolden(landEconomyPartIB,top),JoelNg(lawPartIA),JoeMarshall(lawPartIB),JohnStevens(lawPartII),JamesEgan(lawPartII),Anthonyto(EngineeringPartIA),JackBeattie(ManufacturingEngineeringPartIIA),JamesSmith(GeographyPartIB,top),AngusKeely(MedicalSciencesPartIB),SophialucenaPhillips(MMlSpanishPartIA,top),SarahWeeks(NaturalSciencesPartIA),Richardthorburn(NaturalSciences Part IA),Mike Smith (Natural SciencesMaterials Part II, top),Yao Shi (Natural SciencesChemistry Part III), leor Zmigrod(PsychologicalandBehaviouralSciencesPartI,top),HughChatfield(EconomicsPartI,top),AnnabelDunningham(EducationPrelims,top),Jeremytayler(Bacheloroftheology1stexam,top),andIainMcColl(Bacheloroftheology2ndexam,top).
theGraduatesEachstudentoftheUniversityisrequiredtobeamemberofaCollege.Inthecaseofgraduatestudents,whiletheprimaryadmissionsdecisionlieswiththeUniversity,eachgraduatestudentmustalsobeadmittedbyaCollege.ItistheCollege’sroletoprovideatutorialservicethroughitsgraduatetutors.thetutorsareavailabletohelpwithpastoralandwelfarematters,butalsoprovidethewisdomofexperienceongeneralacademicmatters.Inaddition,theCollegeisabletooffersomefinancialsupportintheformofhardshipgrants,studentships,andfundingfortravelandattendanceatconferences.Oncethedegreehasbeencompleted,itistheCollegethatpresents
14 4 http://www.graduate.study.cam.ac.uk/sites/www.graduate.study.cam.ac.uk/files/attachments/graduateadmissions_2013_2014.pdf
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody thestudenttotheUniversityfortheawardingofthedegree.StudentsarealsoabletotakeadvantageoftheCollege’seducationaland
sportingfacilities,e.g.thelibrary,theSportsGround,theGym,andtheBoatHouse.Inaddition,theCollegeprovidesaMiddleCommonRoomandBar,whichencouragesthecontactacrossdisciplinesthatisnotavailableinthedepartmentsandisoneofthestrengthsofacollegiateuniversity.thereisgraduaterepresentationontheGoverningBodyandthecommitteesthatarerelevanttothegraduateexperience.Allofthiscostsmoney,particularlyasittakesplacewithinGrade1listedBuildings.Atpresent,theCollegesubsidisesitsservicestograduatestudentsby£1,632perstudent.
Recognisingtheimportanceofresearchtoitsworldwidereputation,theUniversity’sstrategyhasbeentoincreasegraduatenumbersby2%ayear,whilekeepingundergraduatenumbersstatic.theCollegeshaveagreedtothislevelofcontrolledexpansion.Overthelastfifteenyears, thenumberof graduateshasgrown from4,819 to6,579 (18.1%) registered students currentlypaying feesacrosstheUniversity. InDowning,whilegraduatenumbersareconsiderablyhigherthanin1999,whentherewere138graduatesintotal,thenumbershaveaveragedat167 fee-payinggraduates.Expansionputspressureonaccommodationandsocial space.thesizeofcentralfacilities,fromDiningHallstoPorters’lodges,hasbeensetinpreviouscenturiesforsmallerstudentbodiesandDowningisnoexception.WiththeconversionofParker’sHouse,theCollegewillbeinapositiontoofferaccommodationtoallgraduateswhowishtoliveontheDomus.
WhilethereisacertainattractioninagraduatecommunitythatreflectsinmicrocosmthecharacteristicsoftheUniversity’sgraduatestudentbody, in termsofsubjects,gender,andnationality,other factors, suchas locationandfinancialsupport,affectapplications.table3.1 in theGraduateAdmissions Statistics4 demonstrates theoverwhelmingpopularityof thoseColleges that are able toofferstudentships,e.g.trinity,where1,107applied, resulting inanacceptance rateofonly17%.Recent legacies,whichhaveprovidedfundingforstudentships,willplaceDowninginabetterpositionfor the future.Giventheproximity to theDowningsite, the JudgeBusinessSchool,Chemistry,andEngineering,itisnotsurprisingthatahigherproportionofDowninggraduatestudents(27.4%)areintheSchoolsoftechnologythantheUniversityaverage(19.2%).therelativelysmallernumberofstudentsfromtheArtsandHumanitiesisagainafunctionoflocationandfunding:lackofpublicfundingforgraduatework,especiallyintheartsandhumanities,meansthatthebetter-endowedColleges,whichareabletoofferstudentships,tendtoattracthighernumbersofapplicants.toillustrate,thecurrentgraduatecommunityinDowningincludesthreeintheFacultyofArchitectureandHistoryofArt,noneinAsianandMiddleEasternStudies,threeinClassics,oneinDivinity,oneinEnglish,sixinModernandMedievallanguages,oneinMusic,andnoneinPhilosophy,whichamountsto15,or8%ofthetotal,whereastheUniversityaverageis11%.Besidesthe109fundedstudents,thereare82self-payingandsevenpart-fundedgraduatestudents.OfthosestudentsregisteredforanMPhil,20outof29areself-funded.
Graduates participate in academic societies, sports teams, and the social life of theCollege togetherwith the undergraduates. Inaddition,thereareseparateacademicandsocialevents,includingthepopulargraduateseminarseries.therecentrefurbishmentofSStaircasehasgreatlyimprovedthefacilitiesfortheMCR.
theFellowsItwasaparticularlysatisfyingyearintermsofrecognitionformembersoftheFellowship.theMasterwaselectedtotheRoyalSociety;ProfessorNickColemanwas elected as a Fellowof theAcademyofMedical Sciences; ProfessortrevorRobbinswas oneof threescientistsawardedtheGretelundbeckEuropeanBrainPrizebytheGretelundbeckBrainResearchFoundationfor“theirpioneeringresearchonhigherbrainmechanisms”.ProfessorGrahamVirgowasappointedto theUniversitypositionofPro-Vice-Chancellor for
15
Education,takinguphisposton1October2014;andHonoraryFellowandformerFellowColinBlakemorewasknighted“forservicestoscientificresearch,policyandoutreach”.
DrJohnRicher,aReaderinAstrophysicsattheCavendishlaboratory,joinedDowninginthesummerof2013.DrRicher’sresearchfocusesonthephysicsofstarformation.HeistheUKscienceleadfortheAtacamalargeMillimetreArray(AlMA),themostcomplexobservatorybuiltonEarth.HeisalsoDirectorofUndergraduateteachingintheDepartmentofPhysics.DrSarahKennedyjoinedtheFellowshipasaResearchFellowon1October2013.DrKennedy’sresearchfallswithintwentieth-centuryandcontemporaryAnglophonepoetry.GiffordCombsandRobertMarkwickbecameWilkinsFellowsinrecognitionoftheirsupportoftheCollege.
theCollegehasreciprocalarrangementsforvisitingacademicsfromKeioUniversity,PomonaCollege,andtheUniversityofVirginia.this year’s visitors were ProfessorMasamichi Komuro, an economist specialising the History of Japanese Economicthought, andProfessorSaraMyers,aclassicistwhowritesonlatinliteratureanditscontext.ProfessorGrimmettwastheDowningvisitortoPomona.
For the fourth year, the Fellowship has organised and participated in the Catalysis Conference, an academic conference thatwasdesignedtobringtogetherdonorsandsupportersoftheCollegeandtheUniversitywithleadingacademicsforaweekendresidentialcolloquium.thisyear’sconference,‘Crisis,whichCrisis?’,beganwithameditationonthenatureofcrisis,‘Crisis:itsuseandabuse’,bytheCollege’sFellowandDirectorofStudiesinClassics,DrPaulMillett,followedbytalksbyProfessorBillO’Neill,aFellowandDirectorofStudiesinEngineering,on‘UKManufacturing:themyths;thetruths;andthefuture’;DrNickBrown,aconsultantmedicalmicrobiologistatAddenbrooke’sNHSFoundationtrustandUniversityAssociatelecturer,on‘Antibioticresistance:acrisisofourownmaking,oraninevitableconsequenceofantibioticuse?’;DrRowanWilliams,MasterofMagdaleneCollege,on‘theCrisisinFaith?’;MrAmolRajan(English,2002),theEditoroftheIndependent,onthemedia,‘HackedOff?’;SirDavidKing,HonoraryFellowandFormerMaster,on‘Improvinghumanwell-beingonaresource-limitedplanet:canwedoit?’;andSirRichardDearlove,MasterofPembroke,on‘theCrisisinIntelligence:BalancingtheprivacyoftheindividualwiththedemandsoftheState’.theformatoftheeventisdesignedtodemonstratetheinterconnectednatureoftheCollegiateUniversitybyincludingbothDowningandUniversityacademicsandguests.Nextyear,thisdonor-recognitionconferencewillbeheldon28March2015andwillbecalled‘livingwithRisk’.
InadditiontotheCatalysisConference,theCollegehoststheOonlecture,heldbienniallyinconjunctionwiththeClinicalSchool.the2014lecturewasgivenbyDanielJDruckerMD,SeniorInvestigator,lunenfeld-tanenbaumResearchInstitute,MountSinaiHospital,toronto.thelecturewasentitled‘lcellpharmacologyadvancesthetreatmentofdiabetesandgastrointestinaldisorders’.
THE SOCIETIES
AcademicSocietiesSubject-basedsocieties,runbythestudents,provideoccasionsforgraduatesandundergraduatesfromallyearstomeet,typicallytohear talksby leadingacademics.theBlakeSociety, for thepromotionof arts subjects,hosted talkson ‘Whateverhappened to the‘FacebookRevolution’?’,‘thepioneeringGarretts:breakingthebarriersforwomen’,and‘FromFootlights,toFrench’s,viaFistofFun’;theCranworthSociety,thelargeststudent-runcollegelawsocietyinCambridge,hadasitsspeaker,SirDavidlloyd-Jones,theChairofthelawCommissionandaformerFellow.theDanbySociety,thesciencesociety,heldsixacademictalkson‘UnmissableCambridge:treasures to enjoy’, ‘theflying trapezium rule’, ‘Why is chemistry difficult’, ‘Why is it difficult, but not impossible, to studymusic
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody
165 Journal of Climate Risk Management, Volume 1, 2014, Pages 51-62
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody scientifically’,‘Firstfootfall:thecolonisationofland’and‘theNeuropsychologicalBasisofCompulsion’.theSubjectscoveredinthe
seriesof talksheldby theMaitlandSocietyduring theyear includedcorporalpunishment in twentieth-centuryBritain (DrDeborahthom),themeaningofslaveryintheAncientGreekworld(ProfessorRobinOsborne),andthetransformationoftheRomanpastintheMiddleAges’ (ProfessorRosamundMcKitterick).theWhitbySocietybringstogetherDowning’smedicalandveterinarystudentsandsupervisors;thelordGuildfordSocietyisthesocietyforclassicists;andtheMathiasSociety,namedafterPeterMathias,aneconomichistorianandaformerMaster,hasanextensiveprogrammeofguestspeakersthroughouttheyear.
thisyear,anewsocietywasformed,theBrammerGeographicalSociety.theinaugurallecturewasgivenbyDrShaneMcCorristine,thecurrentDirectorofStudiesatDowning,andwasentitled‘theSpectralGeographiesoftheArcticRegion’.theSocietywasnamedafterHughBrammer(Geography,1949),asoilscientistandenvironmentalist,whoisstillactivenearlythirtyyearsintohisretirement.Hehasrecentlypublishedanarticleon‘Bangladesh’sdynamiccoastalregionsandsea-levelrise’intheJournalofClimateRiskManagement5.
DramaandMusicSincetheopeningoftheHowardtheatre,Downingstudentshavehadunrivalledfacilities.DesignedbytheatreProjects,oneoftheworld’sleadingcreatorsofperformancespaces,theHowardtheatreisusedforstudentplaysandrecitals,aswellasforacademicandcorporateconferences.thisyear,DowningDramaticSocietyputonGatsby,adaptedbyIssyGateley(linguistics,2013),andStrangeCapers,aperipateticperformance,usingtheDomusasitsbackdrop,consistingofexcerptsfromShakespeare,devisedanddirectedbyDowning1st-yearstudent,lewisScott(Modernlanguages).theSocietyalsosponsoredNougatforKings,co-writtenbySaulBoyer,a3rdyearEnglishstudent,attheEdinburghFringe.
theCollegeisoneofthesixthatroutinelyhosttheCambridgeShakespeareFestival.theJuly2013productionwasCoriolanus,followedbyRichardII,bothofwhichhadthree-weekrunsintheopenairinEastlodgeGarden.
Music inCollegecovers the range fromtheBigBand to theChoir.theMusicSociety includesgraduates andundergraduates andorganisesorchestral,chamber,choral,andotherconcerts,includingtheregularsmallrecitalsintheMaster’slodge.themixed-voiceChoir,oneoftheonlystudent-runchoirsinCambridge,goesontoureveryotheryear,andinsummer2014wentontourtoChina.theChoirvisitedBeijingfortwelvedays,givingperformancesinfiveschoolsasaculturalexchangeduringwhichtheChoirsangsomeofitsmusicandthelocalstudentssangtoit.theChoirthentalkedtothestudentsaboutstudyinginCambridge.ItalsoperformedatadinnerfortheBeijingUnifiedAlumniGroup.Inbetween,itvisitedtheForbiddenCity,thetempleofHeaven,theSummerPalace,tiananmenSquareandtheGreatWall.Muchoftheyearwasspentplanningfortheinstallationofaneworgan,generouslyfundedbyalumni,inthechapel.
SportsAn impressive proportion ofDowning students appear to subscribe to the philosophy ofmens sana in corpore sano.A significantnumberofstudentswhoachievefirstclassresultsinthetriposexcelinsports.NineteenstudentsreceivedBlues,Half-BluesorColoursfortheirperformancesinUniversitySports.Oneofthese,ClarkGlasgow,achievedafirstclassdegreeandalsorepresentedGreatBritainatshowjumping,afeatthatwasrecognisedbytheUniversityBluesCommitteebytheawardofanExtraordinaryFullBlue,whichisbelievedtobethefirsttimesuchanawardhasbeenmadeforequestriansport.theCollegesocietiesalsoencourageparticipationby
17
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBodystudentswhoseenthusiasmisperhapsgreaterthantheirskill.Forinstance,theMen’sFootballClubistraditionallyhighlysuccessful,
havingcometopofthefirstdivisionthreetimesinthelastsixyears,butfieldsthreeteamseachweekend,andthenewlyformedVolleyBallClubincludesplayersofanystandard.theBoatClubaimstoattractrowersofalllevelsofcommitment,butthatremainsachallengein the faceof theextraordinarysuccessesandprofessionalismof theClub.Nevertheless, the ‘RugbyBoat’ took itsplace in the4thDivision,andsomewhatpredictablymanagedtobebumpedonfoursuccessivedays.theMenfinishedHeadoftheRiverinthelentsBumpsforthefirsttimein17yearsandtheWomenfinishedHeadoftheRiverintheMays.Bothcrewscelebratedtheirvictoriesinthetraditionalway.OutsideCambridge,theMensavedthedayforCambridgebybeatingOrielattheHenleyBoatRace,thelastoccasionatHenleybeforetheOxfordandCambridgeWomen’sBoatRacetakesplaceonthethamesonthesamedayastheMen’s.theClubtakesparticularprideinthesuccessesofitsalumni:thisyear,MarkAldred(2005),anoviceatDowning,wonaBronzemedalatthe2013WorldChampionshipsinthelightweightpairandaSilveratthe2014EuropeanChampionshipsinthecoxlesslightweightIV.
Other successes include theMen’sBadmintonteam,whobecameleagueChampions; theladiestennisteam,whowerefinalists;theMixed1stNetballteam,whowon thecupand the1st ladiesNetballteam,whowon the league title.BothDowning’sMen’sandWomen’sAthleticsteamsregainedthechampionshiptitleandtheMixedlacrosseteamfinishedintheFirstDivision,asdidtheBasketballteam.theRugbyteamretainedtheleaguetrophyandwonCuppers,andhasfinishedinthetopfourfor20consecutiveyears.
theDevelopmentoftheCollegethemaintenanceanddevelopmentoftheestateisacontinuingprocess.Evenlistedbuildingsmustrespondtotheneedsandexpectationsofstudents.theCollege’soriginalarchitect,WilliamWilkins,createdtheneo-classicalstyleoftheCollege,whichhasbeencontinuedbysuccessivearchitects:firstbyBarry,thenbyBaker,Scott,Howell,andfinally,Quinlanterry.thisalmostcompleteconsistencyofstyle,rareamongCambridgecolleges,createsresistancetochange,whichcausesitsowndifficultiesinmodernizing,forexample,inreducingenergyconsumption,andintegratingperipheralbuildings,suchastheformerstableswithinthelatestproject,FirstCourt.Nevertheless,planningconsentwasobtainedfortheremodelingofDstaircaseandtheupgradingofserviceswithinitsstudentrooms;foramajorrenovationofHowardBuilding,includingtheinstallationofairconditioningandheatinghiddenbehindagridwithaGreekkeydesign;andadesignforthenewCourtwasagreedwiththeCityCouncil.Inaddition,itwaspossibletoresumetheprogrammetorenovatethelensfieldRoadhouses,completing40to42,andremovingthewallthatformedabarrierbetweenthehousesandtheDomus.thosebricks,CambridgeGrey,willbeusedtomakethewallsinthenewFirstCourt.
Mostdevelopmentisfundedbyacombinationofinternalresourcesanddonations.Anopportunityarosethisyeartotakeadvantageofthehistoricallylowratesandjoinwithseventeenothercollegesinalong-termprivateplacement.thefundsraisedhaveenabledtheCollegetoacceleratetheprogrammeofmuch-neededworkstotheestateandbridgethefinancingneededfortheFirstCourtprojectuntiltheexternalstudenthousesaresold,oncethe78studentroomsareavailableforoccupation.FirstCourtitself,whichwillincludeanartgallery,hasbeendesignedbyCarusoStJohn,thearchitectsresponsiblefortherestorationoftheDiningHall,andwhohavemostrecentlycompletedthereworkingofthetateBritain,asomewhatlargerproject.
Development,ofcourse, isnotconfined tobuildings: fundraising for theEveritt–ButterfieldResearchFellowship inBiomedicalandBiologicalSciencesreachedthelevelatwhichafirstappointmentcanbemadeforOctober2015.
18
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody PUBlICBENEFIt
theCollege’spurpose is toprovideaworld-classeducation to the studentswith themostpotential ineachsubject,whatever theirmeansorsocialbackground.ItisthegoaloftheCollegetoattractthebestapplicantsfromthewidestrangeofschoolsandcolleges.theCollegeactivelysupportstheUniversity’saimtoincreasetheproportionofUKresidentstudentsadmittedfromUKstatesectorschoolsandcollegesandfromlowparticipationneighbourhoods(lPNs),asoutlinedinitsmostrecentOFFAAccessAgreement.Since2000,aspartoftheUniversity’sArealinksScheme,Downinghasengagedparticularly,butnotexclusively,withnon-selectivemaintained-sector11–16and11–18schools,andFurtherEducationandSixthFormCollegesinCornwall,Devon,andDorset.EachoftheCollege’sfull-timeSchoolandCollegeliaisonOfficerstodatehasbeenarecentCambridgegraduateandhastypicallyheldthepositionforatwo-yearstint.InJuly2012,Samturner,arecentDowninggraduateinGeography,tookoverfromCarlGriffiths,whowasinpostfromJanuary2010toJune2012.
In2013-14,theSchoolandCollegeliaisonOfficermade20individualvisitstospeakwithstudentsandstafffrom32differentschoolsandcolleges,visitedthreeUCASHEConventionsandorganisedsixOxfordandCambridgeInformationDaysforover530studentsandschoolsstaffathostschools.theCollegehostedeightdayandresidentialvisitsfromlink-areaschoolgroups,andwelcomed38studentsfrom20differentschoolsandcollegesontheannualSouthWestOpenDayinJune.theseeventshavebeeninstrumentalinraisingaspirationsandencouragingapplicationsfromstudentsatschoolswithoutahistoryofsendingpupilstoCambridge.
Astheaimofthisprogrammeistoencouragestudentswhomayotherwisenotconsiderhighereducationtolookatalloftheuniversityoptionsavailable to them, it is impossible for theCollegeaccurately to judge its success. In the2013admissions round,Downingreceivedapplications from38South-West students,ofwhich25came from13differentmaintained-sectornon-selectiveschools inCornwall,Devon,andDorset.Ofapplicantsfromnon-selectiveschools,placeswereofferedtofive,fourofwhomacceptedandarenowundergraduatesatDowning;andfivewereplacedintheWinterPool,butnoneofthemwaswereofferedaplacebyotherColleges.Since1999,whentheprogrammebegan,58studentsfromtargetschoolsintheSouth-WesthavetakenupplacesatDowning.
Oncehere,studentshaveaccesstoseveralsourcesoffinancialaid.In2013-14,106homeandEUundergraduates(ofaHomeandEUundergraduatepopulationof388)receivedonaverage£2,644throughtheCambridgeBursaryScheme,whichisoperatedincommonwiththeUniversity,otherColleges,andtheIsaacNewtontrust.theSchemeformspartoftheUniversity’sagreementwithOFFAandprovidesbenefits at a substantiallyhigher level than theminimum requiredbyOFFA. Studentswhosehousehold income is below£25,000receiveamaximumgrantof£3,500peryearinadditiontoanygovernmentmeans-testedgrants.thosewithincomesofupto£42,611receiveamountsthattaperto£50.Fifty-twostudents(2012-13:55)studentsreceivedthemaximumawardunderthisScheme.ForstudentswhowillmatriculateinOctober2014,theCambridgeBursarySchemewillcontinuetoprovidethesamelevelofsupport.
thisyear,theCollegepaidout387grantstotalling£412,688(2012-13:£399,469)tosupportthepurchaseofbooksandequipment;attendanceatconferences;travel;studentships;andbursariesincasesoffinancialhardship.trustandotherrestrictedfundsprovided£140,564,£40,329wasmetfromgeneralfunds,and£231,795waspaidthroughtheCambridgeBursaryScheme(2012-13:£245,246).Undergraduatesreceived£333,107ofthetotalpaymentsmade,whichamountedto16.6%ofthetuitionFee.theremainder,£79,581,waspaidtograduates,whichamountedto19.2%oftheGraduateFee.
19
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBodytUItIONFEESAttHEUNIVERSItYANDItSCOllEGES
tuitionFeesforHomeandEUundergraduatesarechargedatthemaximumpermittedrateof£9,000forstudentsmatriculatingin2012,2013and2014.ApprovalforthisleveloffeewasconditionalonthesigningofanAccessAgreementwithOFFA.6thisfinancialyearwasthesecondofthenewsystem.UndertheCollegeFeeAgreementbetween1999–00and2011–12,theUniversitypassedoveraportionofthefundsthatitreceivedfromtheHigherEducationFundingCouncil(‘HEFCE’),calculatedonapercapitabasis,totheColleges.From2012–13,thetuitionfeefornewstudentsispaideitherbythestudentsthemselvesoronbehalfofthestudentsthroughtheStudentloanCompany.theCollegescollectthesefeesandpasshalfovertotheUniversity.theCollegesandtheUniversitynowpayequalsharestowardstheCambridgeBursaryScheme,withtheIsaacNewtontrustcontributingfundstosupporttheobligationsoftheless-well-endowedColleges,suchasDowning.
theCollegesand theUniversityengage in substantialoutreachactivities toencourageallacademicallyqualified students toapplyfor admission toCambridge,whatever their backgrounds or financial circumstances.theUniversity is committed under theOFFAAgreementtoincreasingtheproportionofUK-residentstudentsadmittedfromUKstate-sectorschoolsandcollegesuntilitfallswithintherange61–63%andtheproportionofUK-residentstudentsadmittedfromlow-participationneighbourhoodstoapproximately4%.Italready meets the benchmark on retention.
the£9,000tuitionfeeisonlyacontributiontotherealcostsofofferingtheformofeducationthatCambridgeprovides.Aninternalstudy recentlyconcluded that, takingarts,humanitiesandsciences together, itcost£17,100perannumin2009–10 toeducateanundergraduate.this figurewas calculatedby applying toCollege costs themethodologyused in theUniversity financial reportingtoHEFCE to arrive at a combined figure.the chart overleaf lists the functions that theUniversity and theColleges each perform:theColleges admit,matriculate, supervise and thenpresent undergraduates for degrees, taking responsibility for pastoral care.theUniversityprovideslecturesandlaboratories,andexaminesandclassifiesstudents.
thedistinguishingfeatureofaneducationatCambridgeorOxfordis theemphasisonsmall-groupteaching,thecostsofwhicharebornebytheColleges.themaximumnumberofsupervisionsperyearis80,dependingontheyearandsubject,approximately10%ofwhichinvolvejustonestudent,butmost(28%)involvegroupsoftwo.thebasicrateisfrom£27.30forsupervisionofonestudent,upto£41.52forsupervisingingroupsofsixormore.Collegesaugmentremunerationindifferentwaysandhavedifferentcontractualarrangements.Forinstance,Downingaugmentstheintercollegiaterateby20%,ifaFellowteachesfor80hoursormoreperyear,andcontributesup to£300 towardsacademicexpenses.thisyear,24Fellows received thisenhancementof supervisionpay.However,provisionofsupervisionscostsconsiderablymorethanpayments tosupervisors:supervisionsrequireasupportorganisationand,ofnecessity,takeplaceinhistoricpremisesthatareexpensivetomaintain.ForDowning,theaveragecostofeducatinganundergraduatein2013-14was£7,901(2012-13:£8,182)peryear.
While,broadly,thereisparityofeducationalprovisionacrosstheColleges,eachCollegewillhaveadifferentcostbase,largelydrivenbythecostsofitsinfrastructureandthebalanceinitsFellowshipbetweenUniversity-employedteachingOfficers,whocanbepaidfor supervisingat the intercollegiate rate,andCollegeteachingOfficers,whosestipend ispaidby theCollege. Inorder tocounterdiseconomies of scale and to promote efficiency, Colleges collaborate to provide various services, and share know-how and bestpracticeinoperationalmatters.Nevertheless,thereisinevitablyadisparityinresourcesanddifferentapproachestomeetingtheshortfallbetweentuitionfeesandthecostofeducation.Anintercollegiatetaxationsystemredistributed£4.0millionin2014,butofthis£2.3millionwentinsupportofpredominantlygraduateColleges.CollegesatCambridge,moresothanatotherUniversities,havehistorically
6 http://www.offa.org.uk/agreements/University%20of%20Cambridge%200114%20access%20agreement%202013-14.pdf
20
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody beensupportedbyphilanthropicgifts fromfoundersandalumniwhoappreciate thebenefitsof thecostlyeducation that theyhave
received.
In2013-14,Downingspent£4.1milliononEducation,ofwhich£3.4million,or£7,901percapita,wasforundergraduates.Ofthetotalamount,49%wasspentonteaching,13%ontutorial,11%onAdmissions,4%onResearch,12%onScholarshipsandAwardsand11%onotherEducationalFacilities.
UNIVERSItYANDCOllEGES:ASYMBIOtICRElAtIONSHIP
21
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBodyUNDERGRADUAtENUMBERS2013-14ASOF1OCtOBER2013
Subject Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Years5-7 Total 2013-14
Total 2012-13
Anglo-Saxon 1 0 1 0 0 2 1
Archaeology&Anthropology 0 2 1 0 0 3 5
Architecture 2 2 2 0 0 6 6
Asian&MiddleEasternStudies 2 1 2 2 0 7 7
Chemical Engineering 0 1 2 1 0 4 4
Chemical Engineering via Engineering 1 0 0 0 0 1 1
ChemicalEngineeringviaNaturalScience 1 0 0 0 0 1 0
Classics 1 4 3 0 0 8 10
Classics–4yr 1 0 0 1 0 2 2
ComputerScience 3 1 2 0 0 6 3
Economics 7 6 6 0 0 19 17
Education 2 1 1 7 1 12 5
Engineering 12 8 8 11 0 39 43
English 2 5 4 0 0 11 17
Geography 4 5 5 0 0 14 16
History 6 5 5 1 0 17 17
HistoryofArt 0 2 0 0 0 2 2
Human,SocialandPoliticalScience 7 1 0 0 0 8 0
Land Economy 2 3 1 0 0 6 6
law 18 18 17 4 0 57 50
linguistics 1 0 1 0 0 2 7
ManagementStudies 0 0 0 3 0 3 1
ManufacturingEngineering 0 0 2 3 0 5 1
Mathematics 2 5 6 5 0 18 21
Medical Sciences 15 16 17 10 23 81 63
Modernlanguages 6 6 5 4 0 21 20
Music 0 1 1 0 0 2 3
NaturalSciences(Biological) 10 15 11 5 0 41 40
NaturalSciences(Physical) 11 10 12 13 0 46 49
Philosophy 1 3 0 0 0 4 6
Politics,PsychologyandSociology 0 2 4 0 0 6 9
PsychologyandBehaviouralSciences 3 0 0 0 0 3 0
Theology 2 2 3 0 0 7 8
Theology BTh 2 2 0 0 0 4 6
VeterinaryMedicine 2 2 0 1 4 9 10
Total 127 129 122 71 28 477 456
22
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody PHDtHESESSUCCESSFUllYDEFENDEDBY
DOWNINGGRADUAtEStUDENtS2013-14Aranterol,P PhD Chemistry(Mechanisticinsightsintotheaggregationofß-Amyloid)Ashford,Al PhD BiologicalScience@Babraham(theroleoftheproteinkinaseDYRK1Bincancercellsurvivalandcellcyclecontrol)Braithwaite,V PhDBiologicalScience@MRCNutrition(PredictorsofricketsintheGambia:Fibroblastgrowthfactor–23)Buda,M PhD Psychology(thecognitiveneuroscienceofrealitymonitoring)Buonincontri,G PhDClinicalNeurosciences(AdvancedMRIforcardiacassessmentinmice)Cawston,AM PhD Philosophy(‘Shornofallcamouflage’:Re-assessingtheproblemofviolence)Chen,B PhD Engineering(CarbonNanotubesforAdhesive,Interconnect,andEnergyStorageApplications)Galej,WP PhD BiologicalScience(StructuralandbiochemicalstudiesofthespliceosomalU5snRNP)Harris,CJ PhD PlantSciences(Analysisandengineeringofvirusresistanceinplants)Haslam,G PhD MaterialsScience(Ni-CandWCmaterialsasfuelcellelectrocatalysts)Humphries,KE PhD Geography(Apoliticalecologyofcommunity-basedforestandwildlifemanagementintanzania:Politics,powerandgovernance)Jia,Y PhD Engineering(theConvergenceofParametricResonanceandVibrationEnergyHarvesting)Keen,PHR PhD ChemicalEngineering(Encapsulationofbiologicalmaterialincolloidosomes)Kosinski,MS PhD SocialandDevelopmentalPsychology(Measurementandpredictionofindividualandgroupdifferencesinthedigitalenvironment)lakadamyali,F PhD Chemistry(Solarlightdrivenhydrogenevolutionwithcobaloximesmodifiedondye-sensitisedtiO2)laraia,l PhD MedicinalChemistry(target-basedandphenotypicapproachestowardsnovelinhibitorsofDNArepairandmitosis)lin,W-C PhD Engineering(Fabricationofzincoxidenanostructuresusingmicroheaters)Macqueen,AR PhD BiologicalScience@Babraham(DifferentialrolesfortheclassIAphosphoinositide-3-kinasesp110a8intcellactivation)Mahendrarajah,S PhD AsianandMiddleEasternStudies(theSufiShaykhsofJam:Ahistory,fromtheIl-Khanstothetimurids)Makhoul,M PhD AsianandMiddleEasternStudies(Seismographyofidentities:reflectionsofPalestinianidentityevolutioninIsraelbetween1948and2010)Mavronicola,N PhD law(DelimitingtheAbsolute:thenatureandscopeofArticle3oftheEuropeanConventiononHumanRights)Murfitt,KJ PhD Biochemistry(Post-transcriptionalregulationofmiRNAactivityandexpressioninC.elegans)Nicholls,tJJ PhD BiologicalScience@MRCMBU(theroleofMGME1inmaintenanceofthehumanmitochondrialgenome)Oberg,EK PhD MaterialsScience(Energy-basedmechanicsofballisticimpactonceramic/compositeprotectiveplates)OrtiCamallonga,SPhD History(theSpanishperceptionoftheJewishexamination,1945-2005)Plant,BC PhD law(MarkingtheBoundarybetweenFactsandNorms:Effectiveness,Effectivités,andtheAdjudicationofInternationalterritorialDisputes)Ramoglou,E PhD ManagementStudies(Arealistanalysisoftheentrepreneurialworldview:under-labouringforascientificstudyofentrepreneurship)Salvaggio,F PhD Chemistry(Synthesisofbiologicallyactivequinolonenaturalproductsextractedfromtheactinomycetepseudonocardiasp.Cl38489)Schmidt,HG PhD Biochemistry(Doestranscriptionactivatordiffusiondrivegeneclusteringineukaryotes?)Shafqat,S PhD SocialandDevelopmentalPsychology(thesocialpsychologyofextremism:reconceptualisingextremismthroughglobalperceptions)Snowdon,lA PhD Physiology,DevelopmentandNeuroscience(InvestigatingtherolesofRme-8andligandmodificationinNotchpathwayregulation)Summers,DM PhD Surgery(MaximisingthepotentialforkidneydonationintheUK:theroleofdonationaftercirculatory-death)Sun,MD PhD Biochemistry(StructuralandfunctionalcharacterisationofhumanDNArepairproteinCtIP/RBBP8)tharnpanich,N PhD landEconomy(thailand’sEconomicGrowthfromaKaldorianPerspective)Vertannes,B PhD History(Crusadeandreform:thelanguageofChristianmartyrdom,c.1095-1190)Wang,X PhD Biochemistry(Definingthemetabolicabnormalitiesunderlyingdiabeticcardiomyopathy)Wang,X PhD Chemistry(Cation-bridgingonnegativelychargedsurfaces)Zhang,Y PhD Architecture(Effectsofstreet-alleywayenvironmentuponpedestrianactivitiesintheoldcityofBeijing)Zhao,J PhD landEconomy(theimplicationsofeconomicdistanceforrealestateresearch) STFC Science and Technology Facilities Council; BBSRC Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council; MRC Medical Research Council; EPSRC Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council; ESRC Economic and Social Research Council; AHRC Arts and Humanities Research Council. NERC National Environment Research Council
23
Adams, Professor WilliamAdams,WM,Small,RDSandVickery,JA(2014),‘theimpactoflandusechangeonmigrantbirdsintheSahel’,Biodiversity,15(2-3):101–108.
Barber, Dr ZoeSenapati,K,Blamire,MGandBarber,ZH(2013),‘SuppressionofmagneticcouplinginsuperconductingGdN-NbN-GdNtrilayers’,Appl. Phys. Lett., 103: 132406.
Barker, Dr PaulScrase,tG,Page,SM,Barker,PDandBoss,SR(2014),‘Folatesarepotentialligandsforrutheniumcompoundsinvivo’,Dalton Transactions 43:8158–8161.
Bravo, Dr MichaelGeomaticsandCartographicResearchCentre,CarletonUniversity(Ottawa,Canada,2014),The Pan-Inuit Trails Atlas, Aporta,C,Bravo,Mtandtaylor,GRF.Availableathttp://www.paninuittrails.org/index.html.
Clyne, Professor William Shinozaki,M,Roberts,KA,vandeGoor,BandClyne,tW(2013),‘Depositionofingestedvolcanicashonsurfacesintheturbineofasmalljetengine’, Advanced Engineering Materials,15(10):986-994.
Coleman, Professor NickMurray,MJ,Saini,HK,Siegler,CA,Hanning, J E, Barker, E M, van Dongen, S,Ward,DM,Raby,Kl,Groves,IJ,Scarpini,CG,Pett,MR,thornton,CM,Enright,AJ,Nicholson,JCandColemanN(2013),‘lIN28expressioninmalignantgermcelltumorsdownregulateslet-7andincreasesoncogenelevels.’,Cancer Research73:4872-4884.
Correia, Dr Marta MorgadoVeenith,tV,Carter,El,Grossac,J,Newcombe,VF,Outtrim,JG,Nallapareddy,S,lupson,V,Correia,MM, Mada, M M, Williams, G B, Menon, D KandColes,JP(2014),‘Useofdiffusiontensorimagingtoassesstheimpactofnormobarichyperoxiawithinat-riskpericontusionaltissueaftertraumaticbraininjury’,J Cereb Blood Flow34(10):1622–1627.
Demoulini, Dr SophiaDemoulini,S(2013),’ConvergenceoftheSelf-DualGinzburg-landauGradientFlow’,Mathematical Physics, Analysis and Geometry,16(3):195-212.
Evans, Dr PeterEvans,PD,Bayliss,AandReale,V(2014)‘GPCR-mediatedrapid,non-genomicactionsofsteroidsinDrosophila.’General and Comparative Endocrinology,195: 157-163.Availableonlineathttp://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ygcen.2013.10.015.
Feldman, Professor DavidFeldman,D(ed.),Law in Politics, Politics in Law,HartPublishing(Oxford,2013).
Goymour, Miss AmyGoymour,A(2013)‘MistakenRegistrationsofland:ExplodingtheMythof‘titlebyRegistration’’,The Cambridge Law Journal,72(03):617-650.Availableonlineathttp://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S000819731300072X.
Grimmett, Professor GeoffreyGrimmett,GRandManolescu,I(2014),‘Bondpercolationonisoradialgraphs:criticalityanduniversality’,Probability and Related Fields159:273–327.
Haniff, Professor ChrisBuscher,DF;Creech-Eakman,M;Farris,A;Haniff,CAandYoung,JS(2013),‘theConceptualDesignoftheMagdalenaRidgeObservatoryInterferometer’, Journal of Astronomical Instrumentation,2(2):1340001.
Harle, Dr RobertHarle,R(2013),‘ASurveyofIndoorInertialPositioningSystemsforPedestrians’,Communications Surveys & Tutorials, IEEE,15(3):1281–1293.Availableonlineathttp://ieeexplore.ieee.org/xpls/icp.jsp?arnumber=6407455.
Hinarejos, Dr AliciaHinarejos,A,‘EconomicandMonetaryUnion’inEuropean Union Law, Barnard, CandPeers,S(eds.)OxfordUniversityPress(Oxford,2014).
James, Dr IanJames,I,‘DifferingonDifference’inNancy Now,Conley,VandGoh,I(eds.)Polity(Cambridge,2014).
Ledgeway, Professor AdamMaiden,M,CharlesSmith,Jandledgeway,A(eds.),The Cambridge History of the Romance Languages, Vol. 2: Contexts, CambridgeUniversityPress(Cambridge,2013).
Linden, Professor PaulMeyer,CRandlinden,PF(2014),‘Stratifiedshearflow:experimentsinaninclinedduct.’J.Fluid Mech.inpress.
McCombie, Professor JohnFelipe,JandMcCombie,JSl(2014),‘theAggregateProductionFunction:‘NotEvenWrong’’,Review of Political Economy, 26 (1):60-84.
McNamara, Dr Ken McNamara,KJ(2014),‘EarlyPaleozoiccolonisationoftheland–evidencefromthetumblagoodaSandstone,SouthernCarnarvonBasin,WesternAustralia.’,Journal of the Royal Society of Western Australia,97:111-132.
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBodySElECtEDPUBlICAtIONSBYDOWNINGFEllOWS2013-14
24
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody
Millett, Dr PaulMillett,P(2014),‘M.I.Finley’slandandCreditinAncientAthensrevisited’,available online athttps://www.repository.cam.ac.uk/handle/1810/245064
Milton, Dr Amy Ratano,P,Everitt,BJandMilton,Al(2014)‘theCB1receptorantagonistAM251impairsreconsolidationofpavlovianfearmemoryintheratbasolateralamygdala.‘Neuropsychopharmacology39(11):2529-2537.
O’Neill, Professor Williamli,K,Sparkes,MandO’Neill,W(2014)‘ComparisonbetweenSingleShotMicromachiningofSiliconwithNanosecondPulseShapedIRFiberlaserandDPSSUVlaser.’IEEE Journal of Selected Topics in Quantum Electronics 20(5):900807.Availableonlineathttp://ieeexplore.ieee.org/stamp/stamp.jsp?arnumber=6687309.
Pesci, Dr AdrianaGoldstein, R E, McTavish, J, Moffatt, HKandPesci,AI(2014)‘BoundarySingularitiesProducedbytheMotionofSoapFilms‘Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA111:8339-8344.
Pratt, Dr DavidPratt,D(2012)‘theVoiceoftheKingin“KingEdgar’sEstablishmentofMonasteries”,Anglo-Saxon England, 41: 145-204.
Richer, Dr JohnWalker-Smith,Sl,Richer,JS,Buckle,JV,Hatchell,JandDrabek-Maunder,E(2014)‘theJamesClerkMaxwelltelescopedensegassurveyofthePerseusmolecularcloud.’,Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society440(4):3568-3587.
Robbins, Professor TrevorWhelan,R,Watts,R,Orr,CA,Robbins,tW,Garavan,H,Schumann,GandothersoftheIMAGENconsortium(2014)‘Neuropsychologicalprofilesofcurrentandfutureadolescentalcoholmisusers.’Nature512:185-189.
Roberts, Professor IanAboh,E,Guasti,M-tandRoberts,I(eds.)LocalityOxfordUniversityPress(Oxford,2014).Biberauer,M-t,Holmberg,AandRoberts,I(2014),‘Asyntacticuniversalanditsconsequences’Linguistic Inquiry45:169-225.
Steger, Dr Brigitte Gill, T, Steger, B and Slater, D H (eds.)Japan Copes with Calamities: Ethnographies of the Earthquake, Tsunami and Nuclear Disasters of March 2011, Peterlang(Oxford,2013).
Stock, Dr Jay Pomeroy,E,Wells,JCK,Stanojevic,S,Miranda,JJ,ColetJandStock,Jt(2014)‘Birthmonthassociationswithheight,headcircumferenceandlimblengthsamongPeruvianchildren.’American Journal of Physical Anthropology 154(1):115-124.
Tomalin, Dr Marcus tomalin,M(2014)‘theIntriguingComplicationsofPocketWatchesintheliteratureofthelongEighteenthCentury’,The Review of English Studies 10.1093.
Trevor, Dr Jonathan Brown,Wandtrevor,J(2014)‘Paymentsystemsandthefallandriseofindividualism.’Historical Studies in Industrial Relations,35(6):143-155.
Virgo, Professor GrahamVirgo,G‘Illegality’sroleinthelawoftort’inUnravelling Tort and Crime,Dyson, M(ed.)CambridgeUniversityPress(Cambridge,2014).
Wales, Professor DavidWales,DJandSalamon,P(2014)‘ObservationtimeScale,FreeEnergylandscapes,andMolecularSymmetry’,Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA111:617-622.
Williams, Dr GuyDiaz-de-Grenu,lZ,Acosta-Cabronero,J,Williams,GBandNestor,PJ(2014)‘Comparingvoxel-basediterativesensitivityandvoxel-basedmorphometrytodetectabnormalitiesint2-weightedMRI.’,Neuroimage100:379-384.
Xu, Dr LipingGiacche,D,Xu,landCoupland,J(2014)‘OptimisationofBypassOutletGuideVaneforlowInteractionNoise’,AIAA Journal52(6):1145-1158.
SElECtEDPUBlICAtIONSBYDOWNINGFEllOWS2013-14
25
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBodyCOllEGEGOVERNANCE
theCollegeisa layeleemosynarycorporationestablishedbyRoyalCharter.theGoverningBodyhasall thepowersofanordinaryperson subject to the College’s statutes and general law and is bound to act in a faithful and properway in accordancewith itspurposes.ActingonthepowersintheCharitiesAct2006,theSecretaryofStateremovedtheexemptstatusoftheCollegesofOxfordandCambridgeon1June2010.theCollegewasthenregisteredwiththeCharityCommissionon12August2010(RegisteredNumber:1137455).theCambridgeCollegesareclassedasaspecialcaseforpurposesofaccountingandcontinuetopublishaccountsintheformofaccountsstipulatedbyStatuteGIII2(i)oftheUniversity,The Recommended Cambridge Colleges Accounts (‘RCCA’),whichis basedon FinancialReporting Standards and is compliantwith theStatement of Recommended Practice: Accounting for Further and Higher Education.theIntercollegiateCollegesAccountsCommitteeadvisesoninterpretation.theCollegeisacharitywithinthemeaningofthetaxesAct1988,s506(1).
theStatutesthatsetoutthearrangementsforgovernanceoftheCollegewerelastcompletelyrevisedduring2005andapprovedbyHerMajesty,withtheadviceofHerPrivyCouncilon9May2006,withapprovalgiventoamendmentson18March2009.theMasterisChairmanoftheGoverningBody;theSeniortutorhasoverallresponsibilityfortheadmission,educationandwelfareofundergraduatesandgraduates;andtheSeniorBursarhasoverallresponsibilityforthefinancesandadministrationoftheCollege.BoththeSeniortutorandtheSeniorBursarareaccountabletotheGoverningBody.MembersoftheGoverningBodyserveuntiltheearlierofretirementortheendoftheacademicyearinwhichtheyreach67yearsofage.MembersoftheGoverningBodyinofficeduringtheperiodandatthedateofthisReportarelistedonpages2and3.Withfewexceptions,FellowsarechosenafterinterviewonthebasisofexcellenceinteachingandresearchandtheircommitmenttoprovidingdirectionofstudiesandsupervisionsacrosstheprincipalsubjectsofferedbytheUniversity.NewmembersoftheGoverningBodyaretrainedinthefulfilmentoftheirresponsibilityforgovernancethroughasystemofmentoring.MembersoftheGoverningBodyhavereceivedtrainingintheirdutiesastrustees.
theGoverningBody,whichmeetsseventimesperyear,dischargesitsresponsibilitiesthroughthestructureofcommitteesshowninthefollowingtable.RepresentativesoftheJCRandtheMCRattendGoverningBodymeetings,eachofthesecondaryCommittees(withtheexceptionoftheFellowshipCommittee),andmostofthetertiaryCommittees.ExternaladvisersserveontheInvestmentsmeetingsoftheFinanceCommittee(4),theDevelopmentCommittee(2),theHealth,Safety,andDomusCommittee(1),andtheRemunerationCommittee,whichconsistsonlyofexternalmembers(5),withtheSeniorBursarinattendance.ItsremitistoreviewtherecommendationsoftheGoverningBody,takenontheadviceofitsFinanceCommittee,ontheremunerationofitsmembers.Inessence,theCommitteecaneitheracceptorreduce(butnotincrease)therecommendedlevelofremuneration.Inaddition,theMaster’sConsultativeCouncilandtheCampaignBoardofferadviceonelementsofCollegestrategy.
MembersoftheGoverningBodyarerequiredtoactwithintegrity,toactintheCollege’sinterestswithoutregardtotheirownprivateinterests, and tomanage theaffairsof theCollegeprudently,balancing long-termand short-termconsiderations.thedirect costofgovernancefor2013-14was£32,833(2012-13:£34,528).
the College is a legally autonomous body; however, it existswithin the federal structure of theUniversity.Matters of concern toallCollegesand theUniversityarediscussedandactedon througha systemofUniversity-widecommittees, suchas theColleges’Committee,ofwhichallHeadsofHousesaremembers,theSeniortutors’Committee,whichischairedbytheVice-Chancellor,andtheBursars’Committee.RepresentativesoftheSeniortutorsandBursarssitoneachother’scommitteesandontheColleges’Committee.thesecommitteesworkthroughthebuildingofconsensus,astheirdecisionsarenotconstitutionallybinding.
27
7 See Note 1, ‘Academic Fees and Charges’, excluding Research/Teaching Grants and Other Fees and note 4 ‘Education Expenditure’
8 In 2013, the size of the endowment (net of loans) placed Downing at 22nd of 31 (2012: 22nd) in terms of this measure of wealth. Colleges of a similar sized student body (+/-50) have endowments ranging between £42.3 million and £136.8 million. The median of all Colleges was £58.1 million (2012: £50.9 million).
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBodyCOllEGEFUNDING
the College funds its activities from academic fees, charges for student residences and catering, income from its conference andfunctionsbusiness,itsinvestments,andfromdonationsandbequests.
AcademicFeesAcademicfeesconsistoftheCollegeFeeandgrantstosupportteachingandresearch.Ofthese,themostsignificantsourceoffundingisthetuitionfeespayablebyoronbehalfofundergraduates.ForstudentsmatriculatinginOctober2013,theCollegecollecteda£9,000tuitionFeefromHome/EUstudents,passingonhalftotheUniversity(seeseparatesectiononp.19–20).theUniversitypaidtheCollege£1,666,991fromitsHEFCEgranttowardsthecostofadmitting,supervising,andprovidingtutorialsupportandsocialandrecreationalfacilities.thetotalfeesthattheCollegereceivedforeducatingundergraduates,includingtheprivatefeespayablebyoverseasstudents,was, therefore, £2,007,242,which amounted to 19.8% of total income (2012–13: £1,863,895 and 19.3%).the fee forHome/EUstudentshasremainedunchangedsince2012;forallothers,thefeewas£4,068.Privatelyfundedundergraduatespaidatuitionfeeof£7,350.thefeepayablebyallgraduatestudentswas£2,424.
thecontrolofcosts,coupledwithamodestincreaseinstudentnumbers,resultedinadecreaseof7.4%intheshortfallperstudent,from£2,630to£2,436(onafullyallocatedbasis7).UsingamethodologyconsistentwiththatusedbytheUniversity,theCollegehascalculatedthatitcost£7,901toeducateanundergraduate.(2012-13:£7,914).themodel,whichallocatescostsbetweenundergraduatesandgraduates,calculatedthattheshortfalloneachgraduatestudentwas£4,047(2012-13:£4,031).Becauseofthehighleveloffixedcosts,reducingthenumberofstudentswouldnothelpthefinancialposition.thecostsarehighlysensitivetothecostofprovidingspace,whichisaffectedbyenergyandlabourcosts.thefundingshortfallispartlyoffsetbyincomefromcharitablefunds.
theCollegesFundtheCollegesFund,whichisfundedthroughtheintercollegiatetaxationsystem,makesgrantstoCollegeswithinsufficientendowments8. Inthepast,theCollegehasreceivedgrants,totalling£663,800overthelasttenyears.For2013-14,theCollegewasnotawardedagrant,anoutcomethatisindicativeoftheflawsinthemodel,ratherthanoftheachievementofself-sufficiency.theCollege’sendowment,takentogetherwithanassumedlevelofprofitfromtheconferencebusiness,wasdeemedtobeadequateforitssize(measuredbythenumbersofundergraduates,graduates,college teachingofficersandFellows),whenclearly it isnot.theCollegeconsiders that theburdenofbuildingsmaintenancerequiresamoresubstantialendowment,whichwasthemaindriverforthelaunchofthefundraisingcampaign.
StipendsUndertheCambridgesystem,themajorityoftheFellowsofaCollegearepaidtheirprincipalstipendsbytheUniversity.RemunerationsystemsamongtheCollegesdiffer.InDowning,FellowswhoholdpositionsintheUniversity–themajority–arepaidforthesupervisionsthat theyundertake forDowning students (or for students of otherColleges inorder toobtain exchange teaching) at an enhancedintercollegiatehourly rate, provided that at least 80hours of supervisions are taught, and are given rooms andother benefits.theintercollegiate rate for2013–14 for anhour’s supervisionof two studentswas£33.46.theCollegeStatutespermitOfficial Fellows
28
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody toresidewithintheCollege:asofOctober2014,threeFellowsareresidentinCollege.Allofthesecosts,includingthecostof
maintainingpremises,areincludedwithinthecostsofEducationintheIncomeandExpenditureAccount.DirectstaffcostsareshowninNote9.In2013–14,thecostpersquaremetreofprovidingspacewas£150.87comparedwith£150.20in2012–13,anincreaseof0.5%.Fromtimetotime,DowningappointsCollegeteachingOfficers(whoareOfficialFellows)inthosesubjectsinwhicheitherthereisasubstantialneedforundergraduateteaching,butforwhichtheCollegehasbeenunabletosecureUniversityteachingOfficers as Fellows, or forwhich it has received special funding that enables the College to support an additionalFellowinsubjectsinwhichithasaparticularstrength.FromOctober2014,threefull-time(English,History,andlaw)andonequarter-time(SocialandPoliticalScience)CollegeteachingOfficersarefundedbytheCollege.Approximately£5.0millionoftheCollege’s£36milliontotalendowmentisrequiredtosupporttheCollegeteachingOfficerposts.
the cost of providing education is considerably greater than themoney that theCollege receives fromacademic fees. Since 1999–00,theyearinwhichtheGovernmentimposeda21.8%cutintheCollegeFee,thecumulativeshortfallhasbeen£18.7million.Fromtheintroductionofthe£9,000tuitionFeeinOctober2012,theshortfallhasbeen£3.0million.
DevelopmentInordertoboostthecharitablefundsnecessarytosupportitseducationalmission,theCollegehaslaunchedvariousappeals.thefundssoobtainedhaveenabledtheCollegetocommemoratetheworkofitsmostoutstandingFellowsandMastersandcertainofitssuccessfulalumnithroughtheestablishmentofnamedscholarshipsandFellowships.theProfessorSirlionelWhitbyMemorialFundandtheOonFundprovidescholarshipsinMedicine,andtheHarrisFundprovidesprizesandscholarshipsinlaw.theGlynnJonesFundprovidessupportforDowningmenandwomenwhowishtotakecoursesinmanagementstudies.theDarleyFellowshipFundhelpssupportaFellowshipinMathematics,andthelordButterfieldFundmakesitpossibleforDowningstudentstospendaperiodofstudyatHarvard.theOctaviusAugustusGlasierCollinsFellowshipFundhelpssupportaFellowinClassics.theVerjeeFellowshipFundsupportsaFellowshipinMedicine,theHopkinsParryFellowshipfundsaFellowshipinlaw,andtheMaysWildFellowshipfundsaFellowshipinNaturalSciences.DrJanetOwensgenerouslysupplementedthefundthatsupportstheRJOwensFellowshipinEnglish,andRobertJohnhasprovidedfundingtosupportaFellowshipinExperimentalPsychology.MembersoftheCollegehavealsocontributedgenerouslytotheestate–forexample,towardstheSirMortimerSingerGraduateBuildingwithitsFrischmannandHeilmannWings,theHowardtheatre,HowardCourt,andtheHowardBuilding,theMaitlandRobinsonlibrary,andthelieutenantColonelAndersonFitnessRoom.Mostrecently,theHowardFoundation,recognisingtheimportanceofappearancetotheconferencetrade,kindlypaidforsubstantialimprovementstothecarpark,HumphreyBattcockhascontributedtotheconversionofParker’sHouse,andChristopherBartramtothecreationofanartgallery.FriendsofDowninghavealsomademajorcontributionstosupport theCollege’seducationalmission:theFerrerasWilletts familyhasendowedaFellowshipinNeuroscienceandGiffordCombshassponsoredtheCatalysisConferenceandcontributedtothenewCourt.Mostrecently,underthechairmanshipoflukeNunneley(1981,law)andKatePanter(1981,Medicine),fundshavebeenraisedtosupporttheEverittButterfieldFellowshipinBiomedicalandBiologicalSciences.AgenerousdonationfromJamie(1988,law)and louiseArnell (1987,Classics) supports theCollege’swork inwidening participation. In addition, theDowningCollegeAlumniAssociationraisesmoneythroughthesaleofmerchandiseinordertofundprizesforacademicachievementandgrantsforstudenthardship.
29
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBodyIn1996,theCollegeestablishedaDevelopmentOfficeinordertomaintainlinkswithmembersoftheCollegeoutofresidence.
It sponsors events such as alumni days, reunions, andmeetings; it also focuses giving through appeals.Amajor fundraisingcampaignforendowment,‘Catalysis’,waslaunchedatthelondonEventon2November2009.Attheendofthefinancialyear,£17.1millionhadbeenpledged.BecauseofthetrustsandRestrictedFundsitholds,theCollegeisabletosupportitsstudentswithgrants,bursaries,andhardshipfunds.Inaddition,itisabletorewardexcellencethroughscholarshipsandprizes.thisyear,theCollegemadeawardsof£469,843ofwhich£195,530wasprovidedbyRestrictedFundsincludingtrustFunds,£42,518wasmetfromgeneralfundsand£231,795wasreceivedasarefund(partlypaidfromUniversityfeeincomeandpartlyfromtheIsaacNewtontrust).
Conferencesthrough its subsidiaryDowningCambridgeConferences limited, theCollege continues to focus on building its commercialbusiness,whichconsistsofconferencesandfunctions.Incomefromcommercialactivitiesisintendedtocovertheout-of-termportionoftheyear-roundcostsoftheestateandthestaff.Profitsfromthis,togetherwithfundraisingefforts,rigorouscostcontrol,andmoreeconomicallyappropriatechargingpoliciesarekeycontributors to thestrategyneeded toaddress theunfavourablebusinessenvironmentwithinwhichOxbridgecollegesoperate.
Trinity CollegetheCollegehasbenefitedfromthegenerosityoftrinityCollege.theCollegecontinuestobenefitfromthediscountedrentpayableonthesportsgroundlease.theIsaacNewtontrust,establishedbytrinityin1988topromoteeducation,learning,andresearchintheUniversityofCambridge,donatedatotalof£150,000overtheperiod1999–2004onamatchingbasistocreateanendowmentforsupportingstudentsexperiencingfinancialhardship.Since2006,theIsaacNewtontrusthasoperatedandcontributestotheCambridgeUniversityBursariesScheme,wherebyaportionofthetop-upfeeissetasidetofundbursariesofupto£3,500.In2013–14,theCollegereceived£231,795(2012–13:£245,246)tooffsetitsobligationsundertheScheme.Inthepast,thetrusthasalsopaidtheCollegeforthereleaseofCollegeteachingOfficers’timeforteachingfortheUniversity,supportingFellowswithpostdoctoral researchposts,andcontributing towardsResearchFellowcostswith the IsaacNewtontrustResearchFellowshipScheme.thisyear,itpaid£18,750,beinghalfthecostoftheMaysWildResearchFellow.
theIsaacNewtontrusthasrecentlyannounceditswithdrawalfromtheCambridgeBursarySchemefrom2016–17inordertofocusonfundinggraduatestudentships.
30
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody S IGNIFICANtPOlICIES
1.RESERVES1. totalFundsstoodat£147.4millionat30 June2014.Of thisamount,£84.0million isdesignatedasoperationalassets,
representing thenetbookvalueof thebuildings that arenot supportedby theRevaluationReserveorDeferredCapitalGrantsthatarisefromdonations.thesefundsaredesignatedbecausetheyrepresentfunctionalfixedassetsthatcannotbespentasincome.
2. In formulating the reserves policy, the Governing Body has considered the factors which cause variations in income.theseare:studentnumbers,changesintheapportionmentoftheCollegeFeeandinthefundsawardedbyHEFCEtotheUniversity,thesusceptibilityoftheconferencebusinesstocorporatecutbacksandgeopoliticalevents,andthevolatilityoftheinvestmentportfoliocausedbymovementsinworldmarketsandunanticipatedrentalvoids.theGoverningBodyhasalsoconsideredexamplesofhistoricalunanticipatedexpenditure,inparticularthosethathavearisenfromproblemsinthefabricofthebuilding,e.g.dryrot.theReservesalsosupportanyliabilityarisingfromtheCCFPSfinalsalarypensionschemeforstaffunderFRS17(2014:£2,038,725;2013:£1,825,322).
3. theGoverningBodythereforeconsidersthatfreereservesshouldrepresentoneyear’sworthofexpenditureanda£1millionunanticipatedexpenditureon repairs.to that end, itbelieves that the free reserves shouldbeno less than£10million.However,theprogrammeofconversionofinvestmentpropertiesforoperationalusehastheeffectofdiminishingthefreereserves,whichtheGoverningBodyacceptsmayleadtoalowerlevelofreservesthanisdesirable.
4. the level of reserves is reviewed routinely by the FinanceCommittee and in response to any relevant, specific interimrequestsforexpenditure.
5. At30June2014,freereserves(GeneralReservelesspensionliability)stoodat£8.3million(2013:£13.4million).
2.INVEStMENtPRINCIPlES(the“SIP”)1. theCollegemayinvestinsecuritiesandinrealorpersonalproperty.(SeeStatuteXlVII,approvedbyHerMajestyinCouncil
on19July2005,andsupersededbythefullsetofstatutesapprovedon9May2006).
2. theCollegemanagesitsinvestmentsinsecuritiesandpropertytoproducethehighestreturnconsistentwiththepreservationofcapitalvalueinrealtermsforthelongterm,netofcostsandapprovedwithdrawals.Asubsidiaryaimistoenhancethevalueofthecapitalforfuturebeneficiaries.thegoalimpliesatime-weightednetreturntargetofinflation(approximatedbyalong-terminflationrateof4%)plus4%measuredoverfive-yearperiods.
3. theInvestmentCommitteesets theoverallassetallocationandappointsadvisorsandmanagers.On1August2009, theCollegeappointedPartnersCapital toadviseonandmanagethesecuritiesportfolio.Suchappointmentsarereviewedatthree-yearlyintervalsorinresponsetospecificproblemsoropportunities.thereviewconsiderstherisk/returnparametersthathavebeengiventothemanagers,whethertheseparametersstillaccordwiththeCollege’sinvestmentobjectives,theperformancebenchmarkresultingfromtheseparameters,andthelong-terminvestmentobjective.theportfolioadvisedonbyPartnersCapitalisdesignedtogenerateanominal,unleveredreturnof9.3%(5.3%real+4%costofinflation)afterallmanagementcharges,leavingamarginof1.3%(9.3%–8%)tobuildacushionagainsttheriskofdownturns.
31
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody4. Forthefinancialyear2013–14,forperformancemeasurementpurposes,thebenchmarkconsistedofEquities:40%,MSCIWorld
Index(inlocalcurrency);FixedIncome:12%,FtSEABritishGovernmentAllStocks;HedgedFunds:22%,HFRIFundofFundsComposite;Cash:2%,UKthree-monthlIBORIndex;InflationlinkedBonds:4%,FtSEA(Indexlinked)BritishGovernmentAllStocks;Commodities:3%,S&PGoldmanSachsCommodityIndex;andPrivateEquity:17%,CambridgeAssociatesPrivateEquityIndex.tacticalAllocation rangeswere cash:0–5%;Fixed Income:0–18%;HedgeFunds:10–33%;Equities: 20–50%;PrivateEquity:10–25%;Commodities:0–6%;andInflationlinkedBonds:0–10%.
5. FromAugust2009,thecustodianforthemajorityofthesecuritieswasBNPParibasSecuritiesServicesS.A.
6. Since1August1957,theCollegehasoperatedanAmalgamatedFundmadeundertheUniversitiesandColleges(trusts)Act1943,inwhichpermanentcapital,expendablecapital,restrictedfunds(includingtrusts),andunrestrictedfundsholdunits.theFundisinvestedtooptimisetotalreturn.theCollegeadoptedaspendingrulethatwasdesignedtosmoothspendingandreducetheeffectonincomeoffluctuationsinmarketperformance.theamountofreturnrecognisedintheIncomeandExpenditureAccountisequaltotheweightedaverageofprioryear’sspendingadjustedforinflationmeasuredbyRPI+1%(70%weight)plustheamountthatwouldhavebeenspentusing4.5%oftheprioryear’sclosingvalueoftheinvestments(30%weight).Informulatingthisrule,theCollegehadregardtotheunappliedtotalreturnonfundsinvested.Until2008–09,anamountequaltointerestexpenseonloanstakenoutinplaceofwithdrawalsfromtheportfoliowasalsoincludedinthedrawdown.From2009–10,interestexpensehas not been covered.
7. Since1July2010,theunitsoftheAmalgamatedFundhavealsobeeninvestedintheCollege’scommercialpropertyportfolio.theCollegeonlyinvestsdirectlyinpropertyheldforstrategicpurposes.Inthecaseofcommercialproperty,theinvestmentanalysismustdemonstrateanacceptablecommercialyield.ForanyinvestmentinresidentialpropertyforusebytheCollege’sstudents,thenetyieldmustbepositive,withtheprospectofanappropriatecapitalgain.Nosuchpurchasesarecontemplatedinthenearterm.SuchpurchasesmustalsotakeaccountoftheCollege’soverallliquidityandincomerequirements.In2008,theCollege,actingonadvicefromCarterJonas,undertookananalysisofitsRegentStreetpropertiestoestablishwhichpropertiescouldbeconvertedtostudentaccommodationandwhichwouldbeheldaslong-terminvestments.Followingthisanalysis,theSpendingRuleoutlinedinparagraph6wasadjustedtoincorporatethetotalreturnfromtheinvestmentsinproperty.
8. theunappliedtotalreturnstandsat£8,402,036forthesecuritiesportfolioandincludesreturnsfromcommercialpropertysince1July2007.
9. theCollege’spropertyportfolioispresentlymanagedbyCarterJonasllP.RoutinedecisionsaretakenbytheSeniorBursaractingonadvicefromCarterJonasandthelawfirmHewitsons.
10. Allinvestments,includingtheparametersfortheinvestmentofcash,areoverseenbytheInvestmentsCommittee,withday-to-daymanagement delegated to the SeniorBursar.Membershipof the InvestmentCommittee consists of eightmembers of theFinanceCommitteebutaugmentedbyfourexternalmemberswithprofessionalexpertise.theInvestmentCommitteereportstotheGoverningBody,whichisresponsibleforauthorisingmajorchangesofstrategy,theappointmentoffundmanagers,andalldirectholdingsofproperty.
11. theInvestmentCommitteeisrequiredtomeetthreetimesayearinordertoreviewinvestmentperformance;inpractice,however,ittendstomeetmorefrequentlyinordertoconsiderspecificinvestmentopportunitiesorunusualevents.theCommitteereceivesquarterlyperformancereportsfromitscoresecuritiesportfoliomanager,representativesofwhichalsoattendtheprincipalmeetings.
12. thisStatementhasbeenreviewedinNovember2014andwillbereviewedatleasteverythreeyears.
32
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody 3.RISK
Becauseoftherelativelysmallsizeofitsinvestmentportfolio,theCollegehasadoptedacautiousstrategytowardsitsinvestments.theCollegehascommissionedaseriesofreviewsofitssecuritiesholdingsinordertoquantifytherisk/returnprofileoftheportfolioandtorecommendanappropriatestrategicassetallocationtoreducethevolatilityofreturns.Althoughtheportfolioiswelldiversifiedandtakesintoaccounttherisk-adjustedreturnsofeachassetclassanditsrolewithintheportfolio(e.g.volatilityreduction,provisionofincome,returnenhancement,deflationhedge,orinflationhedge),theturmoilinthefinancialmarketstowardstheendof2008resultedinmostassetclassesbeingaffectednegativelywithassetswithlonghistoricaltrendsoflowcorrelationtoeachothermovingintandem.theCollegerespondedbyconductingadetailedandcarefulanalysisandconcludedthatitsstrategyissound,butthatimplementationshouldbeonthebasisofadvicefromathirdpartyratherthanthroughdiscretionaryfundmanagement.Duringthemostrecentfinancialproblems,theportfolioappearstobebehavingaccordingtothemodellingwhichinformeditsconstruction.
theportfoliohassubstantialexposuretocurrencymovements,whichislimitedthroughforeignexchangeforwardcontractstotargethedging70%oftheUSdollar,Euro,andJapaneseYenexposure.Onlycurrencieswithpotentialexposureofgreaterthan5%oftheportfolioaresubjecttocurrencymanagement.
4.EtHICAlINVEStMENttheCollegekeepsitsdutyinregardtotheethicalinvestmentofitsfundsunderreview.InlinewiththefindingsoftheHarriescase(BishopofOxfordv.ChurchCommissioners,1992),theoverridingprincipleguidingtheCollege’sinvestmentsisthefinancialreturnoftheportfolio,unlesssuchinvestmentsarecontrarytothecharity’saims.Categoriesofexclusionthatmayfallwithinthisdefinitionarecompanieswhoseactivitiesviolatehumanrights,theenvironment,andbestpracticeinsocialandstakeholdermatters.Afteraperiodofassessmentofmethodsofmanaginginvestments,theCollegedecidedtochangeitssystemofinvesting.Witheffectfromthefinancialyearbeginningon1August2009,theCollegewithdrewitsportfoliofromitsdiscretionarymanagerandappointedafirmofadvisorsthatprovidesarangeofpooledfundsinwhichtoinvest.theInvestmentCommitteeisresponsiblefordecisionsonassetallocation,butdoesnotselectindividualstocks.
5.RISKMANAGEMENttheGoverningBody’sRiskManagementRegisteriskeptunderreview.therelevantCommitteeshaveconsideredtherisksinherentintheirareasofresponsibilityandhaveadvisedtheGoverningBodyontheprobabilityofoccurrenceandthelikelyimpact,togetherwiththestepstakeninmitigation.Althoughriskscanbeidentifiedandplanstodealwithsuchrisksformulated,theCollegeisneverthelessexposedtoavarietyofrisks,someofwhichcannotbeaddressedthroughinsurance.theageoftheestate,partsofwhichare200yearsold,means that problems inevitablyoccur, sometimeswithoutwarning andoften at great expense.Annual results canbe affectedby large swings in student numbers, principally in the graduate community andmainly because ofmultiple applications and theuncertaintyoffunding.AwiderangeoftheCollege’soperationsareaffectedbyvolatilityinthefinancialmarketsandbyrecessionintherealeconomy,theeffectsofwhicharehardtomitigate.Alloperationswouldbeimpactedbyapandemic.theCollegehasmadeanappropriateplantominimiseproblems.
33
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody6.tHEENVIRONMENt
GreenPolicytheCollegewillcomplyfullywithenvironmentallegislationandrelevantofficiallyapprovedcodesofpractice,inorderto:
• promotesoundenvironmentalmanagementpoliciesandpracticesinallareasofitsactivities
• minimisetheconsumptionofcarbon-richenergyandofwater
• minimisewasteandpollutionandoperateeffectivewastemanagementandrecyclingprocedures
• increaseawarenessofenvironmentalresponsibilitiesamongFellows,students,staff,andguests
• encouragemodesoftransportwhichminimisetheenvironmentalimpact
ManagementPolicytheCollegeaimstobeattheforefrontinenvironmentalplanningandimplementationamongCambridgeColleges.Itwillachievethisby:
• researchingtechniquestoachieveenergyandwastereduction
• implementingstringentintra-Collegepolicies,withpre-determinedtargetsforenergyandwastereductionovertime
• applyingenvironmentallysustainablepurchasingpolicies,includingtotalsupplychainandwhole-life-costingtechniques
• communicatingtargets,monitoringachievement,andfeedingbackresultstoparticipants
ScopetheEnvironmentalPolicycoversthefollowingareas:
• reducing the carbon footprint by consuming less energy and converting tomore environmentally-friendly sources of energywherepracticable
• promotingrecycling,aidedbyminimisingandresponsiblydisposingofnon-recyclablewaste(egundertheWEEEregulations)
• reducingtheper capitaconsumptionofwater
• promotingaGreentravelpolicyforFellows,staff,students,andguests
• monitoringconsumptionofenergyandwater,investigatinganomalies,andfeedinginformationbacktoconsumers
• usingenvironmentally-soundbuildingandrefurbishmentmethods
34
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody ReducingConsumption
theCollegeaimstomeetorexceedallnationalandsectortargetsforcarbonreduction.thesetargetsincludethoseundertheCarbonReductionCommitment(CRC),theHigherEducationFundingCouncilforEngland(HEFCE),andthosedefinedbytheCambridgeColleges.
Currenttargetsinclude:
• requalificationof theCarbontrustStandard(originallyawarded2009);Downingis theonlyOxbridgeCollegetohaveachievedcertification
• the‘14/14’Commitment.theCollegeaimedtouse14%lessenergyin2014,comparedwiththatusedin2010
• reducingper capita waterconsumptionby10%by2013/14(baseline2010)
• reducingcarbonconsumptionbybetween34%and50%by2020(baseline2005)
• reducingcarbonconsumptionbetween80%and100%by2050(baseline2005)
Recycling and Waste ManagementtheCollegeundertakestoreducetheabsolutequantityofwastegeneratedand,specifically,thevolumesenttolandfill,year-on-year.
thisreductionwillbeachievedby:
• purchasingitemswithreducedpackaging
• reducingwastearisingfromfoodpreparationbymeansofbetterstockcontrolandportionmanagement
• involvingstaffandstudentsincorrectlysegregatingwastestreamstomaximiserecycling
• workingwiththeCityCouncilandotherwastedisposalagenciestorecyclemoreeffectively
• creatingnewrecyclingchannelswherepossible
GreaterEnvironmentalAwarenesstheCollegewillactivelypromoteenvironmentalawarenessamongFellows,students,staffandconferenceguests.
Increasedawarenesswillbeachievedby:
• activelypublicisingnationalandlocalenvironmentalinitiatives
• managingCollegeinitiativesthroughtheHealth,Safety&DomusCommittee,andtheBuildingsandEnvironmentCommittee
• involvingJCRandMCRGreenOfficersinallinitiatives
• including,wherepracticable,environmentallybasedincentivesinstaffperformancetargetsandinstudentrents
• monitoringandpublicisingenergy-savingandenvironmentaltargetsandperformance,includinginformingconferenceguests
• improvingconformancewiththequalificationcriteriaforGreentourism
35
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBodyGreentransportPolicy
theCollegeencouragesresponsibletravelarrangements:
• generally,studentsmaynotbringmotorvehiclestoCambridge
• Fellows,students,andstaffareencouragedtowalkorbicycletoworkmorefrequently
• bypublicisinginformationonroutes,conferenceandnon-conferenceguestswillbeencouragedtocometotheCollegebypublictransport
• workpatternsmaybeadjustedwherepossibletofacilitateuseofpublictransport:theCollegewillprovideincentivestostafftousepublictransportifeconomicallyjustified
ActionsandtargetstheCollegewill:
• aimtoreducegrossenergyconsumptionby14%in2014,comparedwitha2010baseline
• installadditionalvoluntarymeteringandprovidemonthlydatatoresidentsontheirenergyconsumption
• maintainCarbontrustStandardCertification
• reducevolumesofwasteby5%in2013/14andincreasetheproportionrecycledbyafurther5%againstthe2009baseline
• assessbuildingsforenergyefficiencyandundertakeaprogrammeofremedialactiontoimprovetheirperformance(insulationetc)
• achieve20%renewablecontentinelectricityprocurementby2015
• supporttheeffortsofGreenOfficersbyprovidingpastannualandcurrentmonthlyenergyconsumptiondata.Acontinualdisplayofon-domusenergyconsumptionisdisplayedonascreeninsidethePorters’lodge.
36
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody ProgressonGreenInitiatives
• 19February2008,DowningwasthefirstCollegetosigntheCambridgeClimateChangeCharterandhasremainedintheforefrontofenvironmentalimprovement
• 1July2009,theCollegebecamethefirstCollege,andremainstheonlyCollege,togainCarbontrustAccreditation;Accreditationwasrenewedin2012,andweareseekingrecertificationfor2014
• On1April2010,theClimateChangeAct2008cameintoforce,whichimposedamandatorycarbontradingscheme.DowningwasaleaderindefiningtheprocessesfortheCambridgeCollegestoparticipatejointly
• 2010,QuentinBlake(1953–56:English),anHonoraryFellowandChildren’slaureate,donatedthedrawingofa‘GreenGriffin’totheCollege.theGreenGriffinisthefigureheadfortheenvironmentalawarenessstrategy
• InMay2012,theCollegecametop(equalwithJesus)intheColleges’Environmentalleaguetable
• InMarch2013,DowningagaintoppedtheColleges’Environmentalleaguetable
• InMarch2014,DowningonceagainachievedthehighestoverallCUECSranking
• During2011–12,whiledegreedaysincreasedby4%comparedwith2010–11,gasconsumptionincreasedby11%.thiswaslargelybecauseofaverycoldAprilandMay,whichmeantthatheatingwaskeptrunningforthreeweekslongerthannormal
• In2012–13,theCollegekeptheatingrunningforanadditionalsixweeksbecauseofcoldweather,whichmeantthatweusedmoregasthaninanyoftheprecedingthreeyears.Electricityuse,whileunacceptablyhigh,waslowerthanthatin2009
• AfurtherfourBMSsystemswereretrofittedtoboilersontheDomus
• In2012,SolarPVwasinstalledontheEastRange,contributing1.76MWhduringthefirsteightmonthsofoperation
• SolarPVwasinstalledinthenewlyconvertedGriphonHouse,increasingdailygeneratingcapacityby11.5kWp
• Asurveywasundertakenusingadvancedinfra-redimagingtodetectareasofheatloss,andthisdata,alliedwithstudentfeedbackoncoldroomshashelpedtoprioritisedraught-proofingwork
• theCollegeobtainedEnglishHeritagesupportforretrofittingGeorgianwindowsinroomC03withspecialistdoubleglazing
• Roomrentalagreementshavebeenamendedwherepracticable to reduce theneed forparental transportduringChristmasandEaster vacations
• theCollegeprovidesincentivestostafftousethetrainandotherlower-carbonmodesoftransport
• In2013,theCollegesigneduptothe‘StudentSwitchOff’Campaign,designedtoemphasiseenergysavingsinitiatives;Downinghadthehighestpercentagesign-uprateamongtheColleges,andcamethirdoverall.Wearesignedupagainforthe2014Campaign
• In2014,theCollegeachievedthetoprankingamongCambridgeCollegesfortheStudentSwitchOffCampaign2013/14.
• DowningachievedGoldStandard–beingoneofonlythreeCollegesintheUniversity-wideGreenImpactawards(18June2014)
• theCollegewasalsoawardedaGoldlevelGreentourismawardinJuly2014
A Degree Day is any day in which the outside temperature falls below 15.5ºC multiplied by the number of degrees below 15.5ºC
37
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBodyRESUltSINtHEFORMAtREPORtEDtOtHECHARItYCOMMISSION
The Summary Information Return (‘SIR’) that ismade annually totheCharityCommission is based onThe Charities Statement of Recommended Practice, which has a different emphasis from that of the standard profit and lossmodel of accounts that informsThe Statement of Recommended Practice: Accounting for Further and Higher Education and the Recommended Cambridge Colleges Accounts(‘RCCA’).WhereastheRCCAinevitablyfocusesusers’attentionontheefficiencyandviabilityofanentityasmeasuredbythesurplusordeficitoftheperiod’soperations,theSIRincorporatesinitsdefinitionofincomeallthefundsflowingintotheentity,includingcapitaldonationstoendowment.
Byhighlighting thecostsofgovernance, investmentmanagement,andtradingtoraise funds, theSIRframesanentity’sefficiencyintermsofitssuccessinkeepingadministrationcoststoaminimum.WhenpublishedontheCharityCommission’swebsite,informationispresentedpictorially.thepiechartsillustratetheCollege’sdependenceoncurrentandpastdonations(37%ofIncome)tosupportits£8.24millionspendingonitscharitableactivities.thechartsalsoprovideameasureofprofitabilityontradingtoraisefunds.thatcontribution, however, should not be taken at face value: the commercial conference business absorbs overhead costs thatwouldotherwisefalloncharitableactivities.
Afurtherchartshowstheextenttowhichfundshavebeenusedtosupportthecurrentyear’sactivitiesandtheextenttowhichtheyhavebeenretainedforfutureuse,althoughinmanycasesthatdivisionreflectsthetermsofthedonations.
Comparedwith2012-13,incomefor2013-14increasedby17.8%to£14.88million,principallyasaresultofincreaseddonationstoendowment.Incomefromcharitableactivitiesincreasedby5.1%,withthemostsignificantrisebeingfromstudentchargesandfees.Incomefromcommercialconferenceswas£1.25million,down9.1%fromlastyear’s£1.37million;however,therewasnochangeincharitable(i.e.academic)conferences,whichremainedat£0.8million.Spendingoncharitableactivitiesincreasedby3.8%to£8.24million.Ofthe£5.52millionindonationsreceivedduring2013-14,£5.05millionwereretainedforfutureuse.
38
FINANCIAlREVIEW
Incomeandexpenditure• Surplusof£0.3million
• Incomeupby5.6%
• Conferenceincomedownby4.1%
thesurplusof£0.3millionwasbroadlyinlinewiththatoflastyear.However,lastyear’ssurplusincludedasubstantialprofitonthesaleofoperatingproperty:onalike-for-likebasis,thisyear’ssurpluswassignificantlyhigherby£0.2million-aparticularlypleasingresultinthatthisyear’saccountsincludetheinterestontheprivateplacement.Removingtheinterest,theoperatingresultswouldhavebeen£0.4millionvstheprioryear’sresultof£0.1million,asignificantimprovementthatwasespeciallyencouraginginthattheHowardBuilding,abusyvenueforconferences,wasoutofcommissionforsixmonths.
theCollege’sIncomeismadeupofAcademicFees,the‘StudentHotel’,Conferences,andInvestmentReturns.takentogether,incomeincreasedfrom£9.7millionto£10.2million,upsome5.1%.theincreaseof4.5%infeeswaspartlytheresultofareturntoamoretypical levelof studentnumbersandpartly theeffectofanothercohortattracting the£9,000 fee,50%ofwhich is for theCollege.Withtheintroductionofthe£9,000tuitionfeeforHome/EUundergraduatesinOctober2012,theCollege’sfundingstreamschangedsubstantially.Overa15-yearperiod,education,onceseenasapublicgoodhasbeenredefinedasaprivategoodforwhichtherecipientmustpay.theslashingoffundingforundergraduateeducationinthegranttotheUniversityfromtheHigherEducationFundingCouncilrequiredare-examinationoftherespectivecostsoftheCollegesandtheUniversity,leadingtoanagreementthateachwouldreceivehalfofthetuitionfeeandpayhalfofthecostsassociatedwiththeOFFAAgreementintermsofbursariesandthepromotionofwideningparticipation. Special funding streams for StEM (Science,technology, Engineering andMathematics) subjects and seed funding formandatedinitiativesremainswiththeUniversity.thetransitionwillbecompletedwhenthosestudentsonsix-yearcoursesgraduatein2018.DespiteariseinRPIfromSeptember2012–14of5.5%,therehasbeennoinflationaryincreasesincetheinitialratewassetinOctober2012,andneitherwilltherebeinOctober2015.Atthemargins,theoveralllossoneachundergraduate(£2,762)andgraduate(£1,632)isdecreasedbyanyshortfallasthebiggestcontributortothecostsofprovidingacademicservicesistheexpenditureontheprovisionofspace(20%),whichisafixedcost.
Progress continues to be made towards realistic charging for non-academic services; however, the costs of providing studentaccommodationwithinaGrade1listedsiteareinexcessoftheamountthatitisreasonabletochargestudents,giventhatthemaximummaintenanceloan,firstintroducedin1990–91andallbutfrozensince2009,is£3,610,againstanaveragerentof£3,913for30weeksand£4,695for38weeks.From2008-09to2014-15,themaximummaintenanceloanhasreducedinrealtermsby£483(13.9%).thosestudentswhosehouseholdincomeisbelow£25,000andwhoareentitledtoamaximumCambridgeBursaryof£3,500inadditiontotheGovernmentgrantof£3,387andtheloanof£3,862arewellprovided.Studentswhosehouseholdincomeisabove£42,875andwhomayalsohavesiblingsatUniversityatthesametime,however,oftenstruggle,giventheprohibitiononterm-timeworking.Duringtheyear,£280,300waspaidoutundertheCambridgeBursarySchemeand£19,164inresponsetospecificneeds.
Incomefromthe‘StudentHotel’reflectedanincreaseintherentrollof5.2%,whichincluded3.9%ofaboveinflationincreasestoreducefurtherthegapbetweenincomeandcosts.thelengtheningofthecontractforallofthelensfieldRoadhousesandtwostaircases
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody
39
to38weeks(witharebatefortwoweekstorecognisethereductionofoverheadsovertheChristmasperiod)hashelpedabsorbfixedcostswhile recognising thatacademicandothercommitments frequently requireanextension to the traditionalOxbridge30weekperiodofresidence.Overthelastfiveyears,theaverageweeklyrenthasincreasedfrom£90.41to£130.43(44.3%)andmorenearlycoverscosts,inlinewiththeCollege’spolicyofresistingblanketsubsidies.Despitethissignificantincrease,rentsareconsiderablylessthancomparablepurpose-builtfacilitiesontheopenmarketinCambridge.Anyfurthergrowthinincomefromthe‘studenthotel’islikelytocomefromincreasedvolumeratherthanprices,particularlyastheParker’sHousedevelopmentwillprovidetheopportunityfor78studentstomakefulleruseofthecateringfacilities.
thefourmainareasofexpenditure,education,food,estatemaintenance,andoverheads,accountedfor36.8%ofoperatingexpenses.Educationcostsreflectedanincreaseinthenumberofprizesawardedandagreaterneedforstudenthardshipgrants,includingahighercontribution to thecostsof theCambridgeBursaryScheme.Foodcosts increased,but theprofitmargin fell from59.2% to55.6%,reflectingthechangeinmix:thehigher-marginconferenceandfunctionsalesdropped4.5%andlower-marginstudentsalesincreased,principallyatthelordButterfieldCafeandBar.thechangewasnot,however,apermanentsubstitutionoflow-marginbusinessforhigh-marginbusiness:therenovationoftheHowardBuildingresultedinthelossof6monthsofpotentialsales.theresultsoftheConferencebusinessfortheimportantthree-monthsummerperiodsuggestareturntothelevelsofactivitybeforetherenovationoftheHowardBuilding.theincreaseinestatecostsreflectedthecostsofaddressingthebacklog.theyear’sresultsbenefitedfromthemildwinter,whichbothreducesenergycostsandlowersthecarbontaxpayable.
Overall,costs,excluding interest,grewby1.7%,comparedwithageneral inflationfigureof2.6%,although food inflation for thatperiodwas4%.Despitetheadditionof3.5intheFulltimeEquivalentStafftosupporttheincreasedactivityincatering(up5.4%)andthebuildingprogramme,theincreaseinpaywhichaccountsforjustunderhalfoftotalcostsat£4.4millionwaslimitedto2.4%.Onceagain,thecostoflivingawardwaslimitedto1%forbothacademicandsupportstaff,alevelwhichisunsustainableoverthelong-term,especiallygiventhatthemedianlevelofstaffpaywas£18,358.Duringtheyear,amajorreorganisationofthestaffwasimplemented,atanannualcostof£100,000,toacknowledgechangingexpectationswithregardtocommunication,toensurethattheexistingestatewasproperlymaintainedwhileamajordevelopmentoftheDomuswasundertaken,andtocreateacareerstructureforloyalstaff.
Salaries grew by 2.3%, reflecting the savings from a research fellow leaving early to take up an academic teaching post and theappointmentofanewresearchfellowonanon-stipendiarybasis.theresultsfor2014/15will,however,presentaverydifferentpictureasthefullcostoftheregradingsfromthereorganisationtakeseffect,togetherwiththedecisiontoensurethateverypermanentmemberofstaffispaidatleast£7.64perhour.WiththehelpoftheIsaacNewtontrust,andtheCambridgePhilosophicalSociety,theCollegehasbeenabletocontinuetoappointitsfullquotaofresearchfellowsandtocontributetoresearchandacademiabyprovidingthisfirstpositioninanacademiccareer.theimportanceofthesepostshasbeenrecognisedwithintheCatalysisCampaigninthatthroughfundraising,theCollegehassuccessfullyendowedaresearchfellowshipintheBiomedicalSciences.
theCollegeendeavourstocompensateforthelossesincurredinprovidingnon-economicservicesbyexploitingitsassetstothefullfor the benefit of the beneficiaries of its charitable purposes.During term time, theHowardConferenceCentre and public roomsthroughouttheCollegeareavailablefordayconferencesand,whenthestudentsarenotinresidence,theroomsareusedforresidentialconferenceswithsparecapacityusedtoaccommodatebedandbreakfastguests.thisbusinessgeneratedover£2millioninrevenuein2013-14,yieldinganestimatednetprofitof£0.5million,butcontributingapproximately£0.8milliontowardsfixedexpenditure.
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody
40
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody Althoughthecommercialbusinesshelpstooffsetoperatingexpenditure,thereisneverthelessanintractablegapbetweentheincome
generatedbyoperationsandtheircost,whichisfundedbyreturnsontheinvestmentoftheCollege’sendowment.thatgapremainedthesameasin2012–13at£1.9million.AlumniandotherfriendsoftheCollegehaveaddedsubstantiallytotheendowmentovertheyears,withanadditional£17.1millionreceivedtodatefromtheCatalysisCampaign.Inordertodevelop,aswellastosustain,theCollege,itisnecessarytocontinuetocallontheloyaltyofoldmembers.In2013-14,17%respondedtothecall,andofthe8,919livingalumni,36%havegivenatsomepoint.Asthecurrentleveloffundingeducationisinadequate,alldevelopmentdepends,ineffect,ontherecognitionofformerstudentsofthevalueoftheirownCollegeexperienceandtheirwillingnesstoensurethatfuturestudentscanbenefitfromthesamelevelofindividualsupervisionandpastoralcare.
41
DEVElOPMENt:AlUMNIRElAtIONSANDFUNDRAISING• Pledgesmadeandcashreceived:£5.5million
• totalGiftsrecordedintheaccounts:£5.3million
• telephoneFundraisingCampaign:£0.2million
• Legacies: £3.2 million
• Participationrate:18%
• NumberofGiftsreceived:1,482
Downinghasjustclosedoneofitsbestyearseverintermsoffundraising.thetotalraisedintheCatalysisCampaignnowstandsat£17.1million,after£5.5millionwasraisedindonationsandpledgesbetween1July2013and30June2014.In2009,theCollegesetagoalfortheCatalysisCampaignofraising£20millionbytheendof2015.However,astheCampaignwaslaunched,financialmarketsaroundtheworldtumbledanditseemedthatitwouldbeimpossibletomeetthedeadlineundersucheconomiccircumstances.As2015approaches,itappearsthatafterall,theoriginalgoalwillbereachedontime.
theannualfundraisingactivities,suchasthetelephonecampaign,directmailings,andtheCatalysisConference,remainedontrack.thisyearthedifferencewasinthelegaciesreceived.Havingbeenfoundedbyalegacythatwasdepletedsignificantlybydecadesoflitigation,legaciesareaheadlinefortheCollegethisyearforaverydifferentreason.Becauseoflegacies–andinparticularthoseofthreeDowningalumni:JohnWhitworth(1949,History),AlfredMonk(1956,English),andHaroldJohnson(1951,Geography)–£3.1millionwasreceivedbytheCollege.Alfred‘Alf’MonkandJohnWhitworthhadbeenschoolteachersandHaroldJohnsonwasaprofessorofhistory.
theCollegetakesveryseriouslyitscommitmenttothankthosewhohaverememberedDowningintheirwills.thosewhohavedonesoareinvitedtobecomemembersofthe1749SocietyandtheCollegestrivestosay‘thankyou’inasmanywaysasitcan,whileitcan.Membershipofthe1749Societyhasincreasedto243members,with71newmembershavingjoinedinthelasttwoyears.thissurgeinmembershipisduetoare-invigoratedlegacyprogrammeofregularmailings,theinvolvementofyearrepresentatives,anddiscussionsinthetelephonecampaignduringotheractivitiesandinface-to-facemeetings.thestoryoftwoteachersandahistoryprofessorwho,betweenthem,gaveinexcessof£3milliontoDowningwithinonefinancialyearillustratesthetransformativeimportanceoflegaciestotheCollege.
the‘quiet’phaseoffundraisingforParker’sHouseandFirstCourtraised£2.6millionby30June2014.thequietphaseistheperiodoftimeduringwhichsomeofthelargerdonationsaresecured,andinthiscasewascoincidentwiththefinalstagesoftheplanningpermissionprocess.Convention suggests that thepublicphase forabuilding fundraisingproject shouldbe launchedwhenat least20–25%ofthefundshavebeencommitted.theprojectfinishedtheyearwithover30%oftherequiredfundsraised.InNovember2014,thepublicphasewillbelaunched.Forthenexttwoyears,Parker’sHouseandFirstCourtwillbethepriorityoftheCollege’sfundraisingeffortsandwillincludemailings,thetelephonecampaign,andfeaturesintheCollege’smagazine,[email protected]‘buyabrick’andhavetheirname(orthenameofwhomevertheychoose)permanentlydisplayedinthisbeautifulnewcourt.
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody
42
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody thetablesbelowshowthetotalfundsrecognisedfortheyears2013-14,2012–13and2011–12;theStatusofDonorsandMembers
outofResidencein2013-14,2012–13and2011–12;andattendanceatAlumniandDonoreventsin2014-15,2013–14,2012–13and2011–12.
Actualfundsrecognisedduringtheyear
2013-14
£
2012-13
£
2011-12
£
Unrestricted
Endowment 844,750 857,984 1,287,809
AnnualFund 216,506 150,156 145,679
1,061,256 1,008,140 1,433,488
Restricted
StudentAccommodation 3,332 11,583 4,457
Hall Restoration 2,285 5,438 8,274
HowardFoundationProjects 410,794 — 333,060
Parker’sHouse 446,942 1,079,025 850
Teaching and Research 279,180 523,125 265,706
StudentSupport 2,972,211 422,218 144,617
Sports&Cultural(incl.BoatClub) 82,745 58,290 63,863
DowningEnterpriseScheme 34,171 16,667 50,000
Other — — 50
4,231,660 2,116,344 870,877
TOTAL 5,292,916 3,124,484 2,304,365
Inaddition,theSegreantstrust(formerlytheBoathouseCentenarytrust)receiveddonationsof£22,171duringtheyear,bringingthetotalithasraisedto£1,213,938.Alumniclubs,suchastheSegreants,theGriffins,andtheDowningCollegeAlumniAssociation,alsoraisefundstosupportmembersinresidence.
43
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBodyStatusofMembersoutofResidenceandDonors
MEMBERSHIP DATABASE 2013-14 2012-13 2011-12
NumberofAlumni(livinganddeceased) 11,138 10,919 10,685
includingformerundergraduates 9,361 9,223 9,160
includingformergraduates 1,777 1,696 1,525
Deceased 2,211 1,879 1,826
Living Members 8,919 9,040 8,859
Addressknown(MembersinContact) 7,529 7,254 6,998
includingformerundergraduates 6,206 6,127 5,983
includingformergraduates 1,323 1,127 1,015
%Addressknown 84% 80% 79%
Emailaddressknown 6,155 5,835 5,479
%Emailaddressknown(ofthosewhoseaddressisknown) 82% 80% 78%
Addressunknown 1,390 1,786 1,861
Requestnottobemailed 80 80 117
PARTICIPATION RATES
livingdonorsthisfinancialyear 1,270 1,358 1,262
includingformerundergraduates 1,134 1,220 1,147
includingformergraduates 95 97 86
includingothers 41 41 31
MemberswhohaveevercontributedtotheCollege 3,757 3,639 3,547
livingmembersincontactwhohavecontributed 3,175 3,054 2,982
% of total living members 36% 34% 34%
% of members in contact 42% 42% 43%
ParticipationRatethisfinancialyearoflivingmembers 14% 15% 14%
ParticipationRatethisfinancialyearoflivingmembersincontact 17% 19% 18%
% former undergraduates 18% 20% 19%
%formergraduates 7% 9% 8%
44
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody Events and other Forms of Contact
EventAttendancebyFinancialYear(1July–30June)
2014-15 2013-14 2012-13 2011-12
Total Alumni Total Alumni Total Alumni Total Alumni
1749Reception:July 77 33 103 45 62 39 52 27
AlumniDay:September 201 122 232 143 168 94 171 94
AssociationDinner:September 144 96 170 110 148 88 162 96
Parentslunch:November 159 1 149 1 79 — — —
londonEvent:October/November 132 105 147 121 158 133 107 85
150thAnniversaryofDCBC — — 158 106 — —
Griffins’Dinner:January 21 14 21 14 16 16
YearRepsMeeting:January 26 19 26 19 28 22
Catalysis Conference 108 38 103 40 98 51
ReunionDinner:March/April 167 156 141 134 154 148
SegreantsDinner:April 102 56 133 82 38 38
MAAwardsDinner:May 99 83 100 80 109 158
DonorsGardenParty:June 162 68 188 72 128 70
GraduandsReception:June 348 97 224 — 228 —
Other events 159 109 481 341 430 419
TOTAL 1,993 1,060 2,190 1,242 1,612 1,194
www.twitter.com/downingcollege www.flickr.com/photos/downingcollege Followers:2,504 Photos:1,978 tweets:1,169 Views:15,452
www.facebook.com/downingcollege DowningCollegelinkedInGroup Fans: 3,712 Members: 1,077
45
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBodyCONFERENCESERVICES
• ConferenceServicesincome:£2.0million–down4.1%
• CharitableConferences:£0.8million-flat
• totalroomnightsdecreasedfrom16,849to15,337–down9.0%
Asaresultofthesix-monthrenovationofoneofthetwoprincipalvenues,conferenceincomedecreasedby4.1%to£2.0million.thismajorrefurbishmentofthe30-year-oldHowardBuilding,partlyfundedbytheHowardFoundation,broughtallservicestopresent-daystandardsandintroducedair-conditioning.Inordertohonourcommitmentstolong-termclients,eventsweretransferredtotheHowardtheatre,whichresultedinlosingtheopportunitytoselltheHowardtheatre,withitsgreatercapacity,forlargerevents.However,thereductioninincomefromtheclosurewasnotasmuchasoriginallyfeared.
Incomewasalsoaffectedbya significantdrop in residentialbookings,bothcorporate andacademic,which fell by8%and37%.this reductionwasoffsetbyan increased levelof revenue from functions,whichwentupby28%.Although thegeneralbedroomoccupancyratefellby9.7%,thehigher-valueen-suiteroomssawtheiroccupancyratefallbyonly3.7%.theCollegeisconfidentthatthepartnershipsfosteredwithitsmostsignificantclientswillensurethatbusinesslostinthisperiodwillnotbelostpermanentlyandthatfutureincomewillcontinuetorise.thelevelofrepeatbusinesshasincreasedtoasatisfying55%ofthetotal,andtheCollege’srelationshipwithUniversitydepartments,andespeciallytheJudgeBusinessSchool,isacontinuingsourceofreliableincome.
theCollege continues to invest in themarketing of its facilities andwas awarded theGoldAward forGreentourism in June.Anacknowledgedtouristdestination,Cambridgeisalsoamajorcentreforbio-technology,and,thereforeanincreasinglypopularvenueforscientificconferences.therehas,however,beenacorrespondingincreaseinthesupplyofvenues,withCollegestakingadvantageoftheopportunitiesforearningincomefromimprovedandnewstudentfacilities.togetherwithanincreaseinthenumberofhotelrooms,competitionfromotherCollegesandtheUniversitywillinevitablyputdownwardpressureonmargins,whichthestaffareencouragedtoresist.Withoutariver,DowninghashadtocreateabrandthatdifferentiatestheCollegefromothers.WiththeadventoftheHowardtheatre,theelegantrestorationoftheHall,andtherenovatedHowardBuilding,theCollegehascreatedastunningcomplex.thesepublicfacilities,inconjunctionwiththeCollege’sdistinctivearchitectureandsuperioren-suiterooms,havehelpedtheCollegemaintainitspositioninthetopquartileamongCollegesmeasuredbyrevenue.Whilecomparativeinformationisnotavailable,itishopedthattheemphasisoncostawarenessandtheneedforefficiencymarksouttheCollegeasequallysuccessfulintermsofprofitability.
46
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody REPRESENtAtIVEEVENtSINtHECOllEGE–1JUlY2013tO30JUNE2014
2013 Group Title
7-27July theCambridgeShakespeareFestival Cymbeline
25-26July Fine Cell Work FineCellWorkSummerExhibition
2-3August UKShootlimited Ramanujan–FilmShoot
7-12September HHA-HowardFoundationCambridgetour HHAFarfieldHall
20-21September UniversityofCambridge French Embassy Conference
20September Hawking-UKPremiereDrinksReception VertigoFilms
23–24September ArtsMarketingAssociation AmbassadorsAwayDay
3 October Local World Ltd CambridgeNewsCommunityAwards
10 October CambridgeBIDAwards Cambridge BID
11 October CUDevelopmentOffice Chemistry Next Generation Event
24 October CUOfficeofCommunicationsandExternalRelations Festival of Ideas
30 October DanbySociety–talkbyDrRobWallach ‘MuseumsinCambridge’
6 November FriendsoftheFitzwilliamlecture theHon.JamesStourton–Sothebys
7 November Mathias Society Raakhi Odedra on Scottish Economy
11 November BlakeSociety–talkbyDrAnneAlexander ‘WhateverhappenedtotheFacebookRevolution?’
29 November WhitbySociety–talkbyMrlerouxFourie ‘Hyenabites’
4 December DowningCollegeStudents PhilippinestyphoonReliefVarietyShow
2014
29January BlakeSociety–talkbyJeniferGlynn ‘thePioneeringGarretts:BreakingtheBarriersforWomen'
12February theOonlecturebyDrDanielJDrucker ‘lcellpharmacologyadvancesthetreatmentofdiabetes
andgastrointestinaldisorders’
13February theRoyalAeronauticalSociety the14thSirArthurMarshalllecture
17-22February DowningCollegeDramaSociety ‘Gatsby’
27February CUOrientalDanceSociety DanceShow
3 March DowningCollegeMusicSociety Lent Concert
7 March BlakeSociety-talkbyBillCashmore ‘FromFootlightstoFrench’s,viaFistofFun’
8-9March CUChineseSociety AnnualVarietyShow
11 March MaitlandSociety-talkbyDrCarolineBurt ‘EdwardtheSecond’
12 March CambridgeUniversityEnvironmentalConsultingSociety launchEventforthe2014/15Greenleaguetable
13 March CambridgeCommonwealth,EuropeanandInternationaltrust CambridgetrustScholars’lecture
25April BrammerGeographicalSociety ‘Bangladesh’sDynamicGeologyandSea-levelRise’
28April Centre for Family Research Hora Chilena Film Screening
11-13June CUInstituteforSustainabilityleadership Saint-GobainSustainabilityleadershipProgramme
47
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBodyINVEStMENtS
• totalReturn:7.6%
• £22.8millioninsecurities:8.9%totalreturn
• £13.0millioninproperty:5.8%totalreturn
• EndowmentDrawdown:£1.5million
• Additionstothesecuritiesportfolio:£3.9million
thefinancialcrisisof2008promptedintensescrutinyofalloperationalandfinancialmatters,whichledtothedecisiontochangefundmanagers for thesecuritiesportfolioandto takemorecontrol throughanadvisory, rather thanadiscretionary,mandate.themodelwhichwasadoptedatthatpointwasdesignedtoachievetwo-thirdsoftheupsideinworldequityreturns,whilerestrictingdownsidelossestoone-third.thatstrategywaschosenasthebestmeansofprotectingvalueintheportfoliofromthevolatilityinherentinequitymarketsandofmaintainingsufficientliquiditytopermittheCollegetoaccessfunds.thesedecisionsreflectedtheimportanceofthesecuritiesportfolioinsupportingtheoperationsoftheCollege.
RiskwithintheportfolioismeasuredbycalculatingtheEquivalentNetEquityBeta(‘ENEB’),whichlooksthroughallinvestmentsintheportfoliotocalculatetheircorrelationwithequitymarkets.themodelhasperformedinlinewiththeagreedriskprofileof60%equityriskmeasuredoverathree-yearperiodand63%riskduringthelastyear.theexpectedreturnforthethree-yearperiodwas24.1%,whiletheportfolioachieveda25.7%return,excludingtheeffectofforeigncurrencyhedges.Forthemostrecentyear,theexpectedreturnwas13.1%,comparedwitharesult,beforetheeffectofhedging,of12.9%.Returnsaremeasuredafterdeductingallcosts,includingfees.Becauseofthe12.7%lossinvalueofthepoundbetweentheJunefinancialyearendsin2013and2014,thehedgingprogrammepreserved2.8%ofthereturnswhentranslatedintosterling,whichwouldhavebeenespeciallyimportanthadtheCollegeneededtowithdrawa significant amountof theportfolio’s funds.Performance in the individual yearshasdemonstrated the robustnessof themodel:for2011-12,whenequitymarkets(measuredbyMSCIACWorldNRlC)lost2.8%invalue,theCollege’sportfoliobrokeeven;andinthemostrecentyear,whenworldmarketsreturned20.8%,theportfolioachieved63%ofthatreturn.
While the strategy since2008-09has been to protect valueby limiting risk andhedging foreign currency exposure, the increasedresilienceoftheCollege’sotherfinancialactivitieshasledtoareassessment.theCommitteeconsidersthatlong-termgrowthintheportfoliocanonlybeachievedbyassumingmoreriskwithintheportfolioandthattheeffectofvolatilityinreturns,bothinmovementsinthecurrencyandequitymarkets,canbesmoothedwithinthespendingrule.thecontributiontocash-flowfromrentshasprovided74%oftheliquidityforspendingoverthelastthreeyears,whichpermitsemphasiswithintheportfolioonilliquidinvestments.FollowingthecommencementoftheParker’sHouseproject,therentalcash-flowhasnowreducedandthecontributionwillfalltonearer50%.Byyear-endtheENEBwasraisedto70%,18%oftheportfoliowasinilliquidsecuritiesand72%oftheportfoliowasinsterlinginvestments.SinceJune2014,PartnersCapitalhashaddiscretionovertheinvestmentsintheportfoliowithintheguidelinesagreedintheStatementofInvestmentPrinciples.Aspartofthefive-yearassessmentofthefund’sperformance,theCommitteeisintheprocessofreviewingtargetsforrisk,returns,hedging,andliquidity.
48
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody Property
the InvestmentPortfolio is generallyconsideredanapproximate for theCollege’s Endowment, and its size isoften thoughtof asameasure of financial resilience and sound stewardship.Using size as a shorthand, however, is itself a limitation: at year-end, theportfolioappearedtoincreasebyonly2.5%,despiteanadditionof£3.9millioninphilanthropiccontributions.theendingbalancedoesnotsignifylossesintheportfoliobutistheresultofa£4millionreductionintheCollege’spropertyholdingsasaconsequenceofachangeofusefromaninvestmenttoanoperationalproperty.thesecondsuchtransferinfouryears,thisdecisiontoinvestintheCollege’sownoperationsinpursuitofitsstrategyofaimingtohouseallstudentswithinitstwenty-acresiteisareminderthattheroleoftheendowmentistosupporttheoperationsoftheCollege,whichmustsometimestaketheformofasignificantcapitalcontribution.thevaluationoftheremainderofthepropertyportfolioremainedflat,buttherehasbeensomesuccessinattractingnewtenantswithstrong covenants to create an interior design destination.
49
DistributionsforSpendingDuring2013-14,thespendingruledelivered£1.6millioninsupportofcurrentoperations,broadlysimilartothatinpreviousyears.thespendingruleensuresthatinvestmentreturnsaresmoothedtoprotectoperationsfromthevolatilityofreturnsandthattheamountavailable for spending is known in advance. the relatively small increase reflects the adjustments through smoothing that havecompensatedfortheoverspendbetween2009andnowintimesofportfoliolosses.theformulaappliesaweightof70%tothepreviousyear’sdistribution,increasedbyRPI+1%(astandardmeasureofinflationfortheeducationsector)and4.5%oftheaverageforthelasttwelvequartersofendowmentcapitalvalues.thedistributionfor2014-15increasedto£1.02perunitonaunitvalueof£22.69versus£1.01perunit for2013-14 (onaunitvalueof£22.17).thedistribution for2014-15 representsayieldof4.61%on the three-yearaveragefundunitvalueand4.49%ontheclosingfundunitvalueasat30June2014.Whentheyieldfallsto4.5%inbothcalculations,theportfolio’svaluewillhaverecoveredfromtheoverspendfrom2009tothepresent,whichwasoneconsequenceofthe2008financialcrash.Iftheyielddrops,theportfolioretainsreturnsasacushionagainstfuturedownturns.Insettingthespendingrule,theCommitteeisconsciousoftheneedtobalancetheclaimsofpresentwithfuturebeneficiariesandaimstopreservethepurchasingpoweroftheendowment.Sincetheinceptionofthisportfoliointhefourthquarterof2009,educationalinflationhasrunat24.6%,whilethetotalreturnontheportfoliohasbeen39.4%.However,inordertopreservethepurchasingpoweroftheportfoliooverthisperiod,aspendrateofonly2.5%wouldhavebeenrequired.
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody
50
CompositionofInvestmentPortfolio
30June2014
£
30June2013
£
30June2012
£
1.SecuritiesCorePortfolioCash* 1,758,792 2,568,000 1,150,120
ForwardForeignExchangeHedges 108,791 (130,556) 20,179
Fixed Income — — 977,115
Credit 1,828,812 2,445,001 1,749,672
AbsoluteReturn 2,165,428 2,426,224 2,210,363
HedgedEquities 2,552,546 1,034,564 1,306,265
GlobalEquities 10,652,959 6,050,458 4,314,086
PrivateEquity 2,416,374 2,065,922 1,930,040
InflationlinkedBonds 1,327,382 979,154 801,863
CommodityFund — 399,767 424,219
Total 22,811,084 17,838,533 14,883,921
OtherPrivateEquity** — — 12,098
tOtAlSECURItIES 22,811,084 17,838,533 14,896,019
2.PropertyOffice 5,345,660 10,209,966 10,151,704
Retail 7,618,600 6,869,294 6,737,556
tOtAlPROPERtY*** 12,964,260 17,079,260 16,889,260
tOtAlPORtFOlIO 35,775,344 34,917,793 31,785,279
* Includes donated cash and shares held at nil value.
** Includes donated shares in three new ventures, held at nil value.
*** This excludes the residential properties: 25 Parkside, 96A Regent Street, 76 Regent Street, 70 Regent Street and 65 Devonshire Road. These have a combined value of £6,100,000 but are treated as the College’s operational property in the accounts. Because the costs of a formal valuation would outweigh the likely benefits, the values given are provided by Carter Jonas on the basis of an informal assessment.
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody
51
CAPItAlANDRESERVES• £147.4millionincapitalandreserves(includingbuildings)-up4.1%
• £110.7millioninbuildings
• £35.8millionininvestmentassets–up2.5%
• £3.9millioninbenefactionsanddonationstransferredtoPartnersCapital
• £8.3millioningeneralreserves–down37.6%
By year-end, the College’s capital base had increased by 4.1%.this improvementwas the result of (i) a surplus on operations of£0.3million, (ii) benefactions anddonations of £3.9million, and (iii) unspent returns on the investment portfolio of £1.6million.theseadditionstoreserves,however,wereonceagainoffsetbyfurtheractuariallossesontheclosedstaffpensionscheme,CambridgeColleges Federated Pension Scheme (‘CCFPS’) of £0.2million.the benefactions of £3.9million added to the endowmentwere inadditiontocontributionsof£0.9milliontobuildingprojectsandof£0.2milliontoannualcosts,whicharerecognisedrespectivelyinthedeferredcapitalgrantssectionoftheBalanceSheetandtheIncomeandExpenditureaccount.thecapitaldonations,combinedwithareturnof8.9%intheSecuritiesPortfolioand5.8%inthePropertyPortfolio,ledtoanoverallincreaseof£5.0millioninInvestmentAssets.However, an amountof £4.1millionwas transferred tooperational buildings, representing the valueof theupperfloorsofParker’sHouse,whicharethesubjectofconversiontostudentaccommodation.thenetincreaseinInvestmentAssets,therefore,was£0.9million.Attheendoftheyear,InvestmentAssetsstoodat£35.8million,anincreaseof2.5%.
Generalreserveshavedecreasedby37.6%(£5.0million),whichatyearendstoodat£8.3million.thevalueofinvestmentsheldbygeneralreservesincreasedby3.6%(£0.5million).However,therewasadecreaseof41.5%(£5.5million)duetothetransfertothedesignatedbuildingsreservefollowing(i)thetransferfrominvestmentassetstooperationalpropertyofthevalueofParker’sHouseand(ii)thevalueofbuildingworksundertakenduringtheyear,includingthecostsofrenovatingtheHowardBuilding.
takentogether,thesetransactionsaccountedforanadditionof£5.8millionforanendingbalanceoncapitalandreservesof£147.4million.
CASHFlOW
• Cashflowfromearningsbeforedepreciation,interestexpense,andchangesinworkingcapital:£1.9million
• Changeincashbalancesinyear:£1.0millionreduction
• totalcapitalexpenditure:£3.5million
• totalcapitalexpenditureexcludingdonor-fundedandspecialprojects:£3.0million
Cashconsumedbyallactivitiesresultedinadecreaseof£1.0millionincashbalances,withcashheldatyearendof£2.6million.Cashgenerationfromoperatingactivitiesbeforetheeffectsofworkingcapitalandtheproceedsfromprivateplacementamountedto£0.2million,aslightimprovementonlastyear’sbreakeven,reflectingthebetteroperatingperformance.Endowmentincomelessinterestpayablecontributedafurther£1.3millionofcash.
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody
52 9. The placement was in two tranches, one for £2.9 million at 4.40% (£1.3 million for 30 years, £1.6 million for 40 years) and the second for £2.1 million at 4.45% for 30 years.
thelong-overduerenovationoftheHowardBuildingandoftwostudenthousesinlensfieldRoadledtoanunusuallyhighlevelofcapitalexpenditureof£3.5million.ExcludingtheHowardBuildingcostsandotherworksfundedbydonationsfromthetotal,£2millionwasinvestedincapitalexpenditure,whichwasnotquitecoveredbyearningsbeforedepreciationof£1.7million.Furthermore,forthefirsttimeinfouryears,thecashgeneratedwouldnothavebeenabletocovertherecommendedallowanceof1.5%(£1.7million)oftheinsuredvalueofthebuildings(£112million).
In2013,theCollegeraised£5millioninalong-termprivateplacement,withtheintentionoftakingadvantageofhistorically-lowrates9 inordertoprovidebridgefinancingfortheParker’sHouseprojectandacceleratetherefurbishmentofstudentaccommodation.theproceedswereinvestedinaspecialliquidportfolio,shownasacurrentassetinvestmentonthebalancesheet.Fundshavenotasyetbeenwithdrawn.
thesignificantcontributionbydonors,whichthisyearcameto£5.3million,demonstratestheCollege’srelianceonthegenerosityofalumnibothtodevelopandtosustainitsactivities.Ofthis,£0.4millionwasreceivedfortheParker’sHouseproject,resultingincashof£2.0millionheldspecificallyfortheproject,and£3.9millionwaspassedovertoPartnersCapitalforinvestment,comparedwith£1.7million last year.
INVEStMENtFORtHEFUtUREAcollectiveconsciousnessofhistoricalrootshastendedtoinspirethelongview,withfuturegenerationsbenefitingfromdecisionstakeninpreviousdecades.Inthe1980s,adecisionwasmadetonegotiatealeaseonadevelopmentontheeasternborderoftheCollege(Parker’sHouse).thetermsweresofavourabletotheCollegethatrenegotiationwouldbecomeinevitableandcreateanopportunitytobuyout the investor’s remaininghundred-year interest at a timeof depressedprices.theneed tohouse an expanding graduatecommunitymaynothavebeentotheforefrontintheearly1980s,butcreatingtheconditionsforfuturedevelopmentwillresultintheCollegebeingabletoaccommodateallstudentswithinitstwenty-acresiteby2016.theconversionofthe1980sofficeblockinto78studenten-suiteroomswillformanewcourt,FirstCourt,whichlinksthisspacetothehistoricalcircumstancesthatcreatedtheCollege:theCourtcommemoratesSirGeorgeDowning,3rdbaronet’sgrandfather,SirGeorgeDowning,1stbaronet,whosewealtheventuallyfundedthefoundationoftheCollege.
theperiodbetweenthere-purchaseoftheleasein2010andthetimewhenconstructioncouldbeginontheexpirationofatenancyinMarch2014permittedtheCollegetoexplorethepotentialoftheprojecttosolvelogisticalissuesinservicingtheDomusandtoconsiderwaysinwhichtosatisfytherequirementtocontribute1%oftheconstructioncoststopublicart.theCollegeconsultedAdamCarusoofCarusoStJohn,thearchitectsresponsiblefortherestorationoftheDiningHall,whochangedafundamentallyutilitarianprojectintoanarchitecturallyinterestingadditiontotheDomus.Byidentifyingtheformerstablesasaspaceinwhichartcouldbeexhibited,Caruso’splannotonlyfulfilsthepublicartrequirementbutalsogivespurposeandsignificancetoFirstCourt.Withthehelpofalumniandfriendsintheartworld,plansforthethreeyearsofpublicexhibitionstowhichtheCollegeiscommittedarewellunderway.AcreativesolutiontoanaccommodationproblemhasledtothedevelopmentoftheCollege’sculturallife.
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody
53
tENYEARCAPItAlPROGRAMME
At1October2014Netcurrentroomsrefurbishedoracquiredinlasttenyears(2005–2014):130(26%)
totalStudentRooms:490
RestorationandMajorRefurbishmentYear Building NumberofStudentRoomsifApplicable
2005 28lensfieldRoad 8
KitchenRefurbishment
2006 54lensfieldRoad 7
ParlourExtensionandOffices
2007 50lensfieldRoad 7
Hall
UStaircase
2008 Howardlodge 32
2009 VStaircase
2010 Howardtheatre
BoathouseFloodprevention 6
Master’slodgeFlat
HStairBathroomsandKitchen
2011 Master’slodgeRoof
Parker’sHousetopFloor(Conferenceuse)
KandlStaircaseBathrooms(12) 12
Howardlodgebathrooms
2012 GriphonHouse(formerly14RegentSt) 22
ButterfieldBuilding
2013 ChapelRamp
RoseGardenFlat(part)
40/42lensfieldRoad 19
2014 D Staircase 4
ChapelandOrgan
MCRandOffices
Total 117
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody
54
NewandAcquiredBuildings,land,andleasesYear location NumberofStudentRooms(ifApplicable)
2005 96aRegentStreet(Flats) 3
2006 76 Regent Street 4
2009 70 Regent Street 6
Howardtheatre
Groundsman’sStore(BartonRoad)
2010 14RegentStreet(conversionto22studentrooms)
2011 Parker’sHouse(topfloorchangeofuse)
2012 Nil
2013 Barton Road Development Consortium
2014 Parker’sHouse(1st&2ndFloors)
Total (excluding sold houses) 13
SaleofOperationalPropertyandterminationofleasesYear Property NumberofStudentRooms(ifApplicable)
2005 91MawsonRoad 5
2007 55Warkworthterrace 7
2012 65lensfieldRoad(and1DowningArchway) 12
2013 1,2and3GonvillePlace(leasesterminated) 26
Total 50
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody
55
FINANCIAlOUtlOOKthefive-yearperiod following thefinancial crisis sawa re-shapingof expectations: external funding shouldbe sought for researchpositions;multi-use,but subject specific, fundswere targetedat generaleducationalpurposes; ingenuitywasexercised in securingteachingatmarginalcosts;charging for studentaccommodationshould reflectcosts;passingcatering tradeshouldbecourted. Anatmosphereofprivationpervaded.thesemeasureshavehelpedreturnasurplusforthethirdyearinarow.Changedcircumstancesnowmeanthat,inordertosecureappropriateteachinginlaw,theHopkinsParryFundmustagainsupportaCollegeteachingOfficerratherthanbeusedtosupportlawmoregenerallyintheCollege.ExternalfactorswillalsoaffecttheCollege’sabilitytomakeendsmeet:inadditiontotheextracostofimplementingtheadministrativelycumbersomeauto-enrolmentpensionscheme,thecostsofUSSaresettorise,andinfuturethedisaggregationoftheliabilitiesoftheschemewillaffectboththeIncomeandExpenditureStatementandBalanceSheet.DespitetheclosureoftheDowningsectionoftheschemein2009,thefundingdeficitontheCollege’sportionoftheCambridgeCollegesFederatedPensionSchemecontinuestogrow,thisyearreaching£2.0million.Whileacademicandacademic-relatedsalariesarecontainedbynationalagreements,themarketsetsthelevelofthemajority(77%)ofthesalarybill.AlthoughtheCollegecannotprudentlycommittothelivingwagecampaign,itneverthelessrecognisesthedifficultiesexperiencedbythelowest-paidworkersandhasthereforeraisedthepayforthelowest-paidpermanentstaffabove£7.64perhour.
AshiftinpolicyattheIsaacNewtontrustmeansthatinsteadofsubsidisingtheCambridgeBursaryScheme,fundswillsupportgraduatestudentships.Downingreceived£63,020insubsidiesin2013-14fromtheIsaacNewtontrustfortheCambridgeBursaryScheme.
PlANSFORtHEFUtUREtheCatalysisCampaignwasoriginallyconceived in2009asacampaign toraise fundsprincipally tosustainexistingactivities thatmightbethreatenedbythevicissitudesofthefundingofhighereducation.However,prioritieschangesubtlyovertimeandthewishesofdonorscreatenewopportunities,forexample,byprovidingstudentshipsforgraduates.Withthesupportofalumniandfriends,thegoalofraising£20millionshouldbereachedduringthecomingyear,butthepressureonfundingcoreactivitiesinGrade1listedpremisespersists.thelong-termprivateplacementof£5millionhasnotonlyprovidedfinancingtobridgethegapbetweentheconstructionofParker’sHouseandthesubsequentsaleoftheoutlyingproperties,butalsoitalsopermitstheaccelerationoftheprojectsforamajorrenovationof fourhousesonlensfieldRoad.While it is possible to imagineaplan inwhichcurrent activities arefinancially self-sustaining,fundswillinevitablyberequiredtoinvestbothinthedevelopmentoftheestate,itsbuildings,and,mostimportantly,thelifewithin.
On behalf of the Governing Body:
ProfGRGrimmett,MasterDrSusanlintott,SeniorBursar Date:18December2014
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody
56
* The table ranks the results of the undergraduates in 29 of the Colleges, expressing the results as a % of the score that would be achieved if everyone were to get a First. Five points are awarded for a First, three for a 2:1, two for a 2:2, and one for a Third.
10 Special Prizes are awarded to those in the top 2.5% of their University Class List
COllEGEStAtIStICSANDFINANCIAlHIGHlIGHtS
Financial Year End: 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010
1. Educationtompkinstables* 11 12 20 17 15
Undergraduateclassificationofdegrees
1st 116 87 82 76 81
2:1 213 228 219 217 209
2 13 17 34 45 41
2:2 54 50 60 50 47
3 9 8 14 8 14
Pass 13 14 13 15 16
DDH(Deemedtohavedeservedhonours) 1 5 4 8 9
Ordinary 0 0 0 1 0
Fail 5 2 1 1 0
NumberofSpecialPrizes10 19 14 13 9 6
Graduatedegreesawarded:
PhD(includingMBPhD) 39 35 38 42 38
MPhil,llM,MBAetal 64 47 65 54 38
MB BChir 7(inc
2xVetMB)
9(inc
2xVetMB)
12(inc
2xVetMB)
12(inc
2xVetMB)
2
2. AdmissionsNumberofOpenDays
CollegeOpenDays 5 5 3 4 4
UniversityOpenDays 2 2 2 2 2
SouthWestOpenDays 1 1 1 1 1
NumbersvisitingOpenDays 834 1,046 1,022 1,041 1,195
%subsequentlyapplyingtoDowning(inOctoberfollowing) 17% 19% 19% 19% 21%
ApplicantsfromSouth–Westinitiative(Octoberfollowing) 38 40 31 44 44
ApplicantsfromSouth-Westnon-selectiveschools(includedabove) 25 27 23 38 31
AdmissionsfromSouth-Westnon-selectiveschools 2 4 4 8 1
Applicantsfromlowparticipationneighbourhoods 16 22 30 — —
Admissionsfromlowparticipationneighbourhoods 2 6 — — —
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody
57
COllEGEStAtIStICSANDFINANCIAlHIGHlIGHtSCONtINUED
Financial Year End: 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010
2. Admissions continuedtotalNumberofApplicantsforUndergraduateCourses(inOctober
following)
733 879 818 769 719
% Women: % Men 48:52 47:53 44:56 43:57 45:55
ApplicantsfromMaintainedSchools 341 391 383 381 358
%Maintained/%Independent 62:38 59:41 61:39 62:38 60:40
Admissions(IncludingSummerPool) 124 120 125 132 128
% Women: % Men 44:56 43:58 45:55 42:58 38:62
AdmissionsfromMaintainedSchools 62 63 61 72 69
%Maintained/%Independent 61:39 59:41 56:44 58:42 58:42
Applicationsbysubject
Asian&MiddleEasternStudies 4 6 6 4 3
ASN&C — 1 2 2 4
Archaeology&Anthropology — — 4 3 6
Architecture 25 28 24 18 24
Chemical Engineering via Engineering 9 16 11 — —
ChemicalEngineeringviaNaturalSciences 14 20 18 — —
Classics 5 12 13 9 12
ComputerScience 10 17 15 10 5
Economics 69 77 70 77 78
Education 2 5 1 1 —
Engineering 73 111 105 91 59
English 22 21 27 20 31
Geography 30 42 26 31 29
History 14 21 19 13 23
HistoryofArt 2 2 4 3 6
Human,Social&PoliticalSciences 30 35 — — —
Land Economy 15 17 13 19 13
law 84 81 77 70 103
linguistics 3 1 3 4 3
Mathematics 43 35 38 30 37
Medicine 76 91 102 125 82
Modern&Medievallanguages 19 17 25 19 21
Music 1 4 3 2 1
NaturalSciences(Biological) 67 77 75 67 68
NaturalSciences(Physical) 54 84 88 94 59
Philosophy 5 5 6 5 8
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody
58 11 Cambridge Student Statistics Office figures (excluding incoming exchange and visiting students).
COllEGEStAtIStICSANDFINANCIAlHIGHlIGHtSCONtINUED
Financial Year End: 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010
2. Admissions continuedPolitics,Psychology&Sociology — — 30 34 28
Psychological&BehaviouralSciences 47 24 — — —
Theology 2 9 5 5 3
VeterinaryMedicine 8 20 8 13 13
RatioofApplicationstoOffers 5.0:1 6.0:1 5.7:1 5.3:1 4.9:1
%Applicantswhoareadmitted 16.8% 14.1% 14.7% 16.3% 18.4%
%South-WestApplicantswhoareadmitted 16.0% 7.4% 17.4% 10.5% 25.8%
totalUniversityFull-timeUndergraduates11 11,781 11,820 11,948 11,945 12,192
% Female: % Male 46:54 47:53 47:53 47:53 48:52
totalFull-timeDowningUndergraduates 446 436 455 446 445
% Female: % Male 41:59 41:59 41:59 43:57 44:56
NumbersofUndergraduatesleavingbeforegraduating 4 4 2 0 0
totalUniversityFull-timePostgraduates11 6,579 6,451 6,295 6,346 5,795
% Female: % Male 44:56 44:56 45:55 45:55 46:54
totalDowningFull-timePostgraduates11 163 154 170 163 165
% Female: % Male 44:56 39:61 42:58 36:64 39:61
totalUniversitynumbersenteringcourseforthefirsttimewhich
attractundergraduatefees113,617 3,536 3,663 3,630 3,951
% Female: % Male 47:53 48:52 47:53 48:52 47:53
Downingnumbersadmittedtocurrentcourseintheprevious
twelvemonthswhichattractundergraduatefees11137 130 133 141 148
% Female: % Male 42:58 40:60 41:59 44:56 39:61
totalUniversitynumbersadmittedtofull-timepostgraduatecourses
intheprevioustwelvemonths114,015 3,930 3,794 3,962 3,346
% Female: % Male 46:54 46:54 47:53 47:53 49:51
Downingnumbersadmittedtofull-timepostgraduatecoursesinthe
previoustwelvemonths1188 76 94 80 72
% Female: % Male 48:52 33:67 45:55 38:62 40:60
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody
59
COllEGEStAtIStICSANDFINANCIAlHIGHlIGHtSCONtINUED
Financial Year End: 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010
3. Composition of Full-time Students11
Undergraduates
Home 370 370 397 403 —
EU 31 26 24 15 —
Overseas 45 40 34 28 —
Total 446 436 455 446 —
Postgraduates
Home 58 61 59 53 —
EU 41 40 42 44 —
Overseas 64 53 69 66 —
Total 163 154 170 163 —
4. Financial Support for Students: Number of Students Receiving GrantsCambridgeBursaryScheme(formerlyIsaacNewtonGrants) 106 111 111 105 92
CambridgeCommonwealthtrust 8 4 12 8 12
CambridgeEuropeantrust 8 1 5 8 12
CambridgeOverseastrust 16 12 24 21 9
GatesCambridgetrust 2 — 3 5 4
AveragevalueofCambridgeBursarySchemeGrants £2,644 £2,508 £2,585 £2,435 £2,099
5. AccommodationAverageWeeklyRentUndergraduateStudyBedroom £130.43 £119.92 £109.14 £103.33 £96.46
AverageWeeklyRentGraduateStudyBedroom £131.72 £115.46 £112.29 £106.62 £99.69
UndergraduatesHousedinCollegeAccommodation 374 378 384 389 379
GraduatesHousedinCollegeAccommodation 108 120 117 101 106
totalUnitsofStudentAccommodation 488 515 505 505 502
6. Student Catering Incomelunch £86,013 £79,144 £88,728 £102,142 £90,991
Dinner £88,769 £90,412 £90,584 £92,525 £94,625
Café £130,068 £74,890 £41,502 £56,201 £65,367
Formal Hall £50,204 £52,362 £53,520 £49,590 £42,459
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody
60
12 Definitions changed in 2010-11.
13 The Spending Rule is the amount determined that can be spent and still preserve the purchasing power of the endowment for the long-term. It also constitutes the amount of the total return recognised in the income and expenditure account (note 3a).
COllEGEStAtIStICSANDFINANCIAlHIGHlIGHtSCONtINUED
Financial Year End: 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010
7. Conference & FunctionsConferenceandFunctionIncome £2,042,832 £2,130,084 £1,875,620 £1,886,940 £1,616,911
Total Room nights 15,337 16,849 14,696 14,743 11,410
CapacityUtilisationtotalConferenceRooms 31.6% 35.0% 32.6% — —
En—suiteRooms 32.0% 33.2% 33.0% — —
AveragePriceAchievedperRoomUsed £55.68 £52.46 £50.65 £46.08 £49.57
8. Development and FundraisingDevelopmentCampaignCashRecognised(includingbythe
Segreantstrust)
£4,904,293 £3,150,706 £2,325,775 £2,856,898 £2,721,334
Living donors as a % of members in contact 42% 42% 43% 43% 44%
ParticipationRatethisFinancialYearoflivingMembersinContact 21% 19% 18% 17% 18%
DirectFundraisingCosts:
DonationsRaisedexcludinglegaciesandtheHowardGift 5:1 7:1 3:1 7:1 1:1
DonationsRaisedincludinglegaciesbutexcludingtheHowardGift 13:1 9:1 6:1 11:1 6:1
DonationsRaisedincludinglegaciesbutexcludingtheHowardGift
(5yearaverage)
9:1 7:1 6:1 6:1 4:1
9. Income and Expenditure%Surplus(Deficit)turnover 2.3% 2.8% 3.0% (4.4%) (10.0%)
%Surplus(Deficit)FreeReserves12 2.8% 2.0% 2.4% (2.7%) (53.7%)
Staffcostsasa%ofturnover 43.0% 44.2% 43.6% 45.1% 48.7%
£persq.metrecostofupkeepofBuildings £150.87 £150.20 £156.65 £175.42 £188.32
10. Charitable FundsCharitableFundsInvested(includingWorksofArt,etc.)12 £43,751,076 £42,860,536 £39,732,187 £36,425,533 £30,408,247
EndowmentAssetslessloansperFull-timeStudents12 £54,599 £63,323 £54,771 £50,781 £40,844
CapitalValueperUnit £22.69 £22.17 £21.39 £21.02 £19.37
SpendingRuleAmount13 £1,617,819 £1,543,197 £1,505,631 £1,467,740 £1,497,688
SpendingRuleAmountas%Income 15.9% 16.0% 16.3% 16.6% 18.1%
SpendingRuleAmountas%Income(FiveYearAverage) 16.6% 17.9% 19.3% 20.7% 21.6%
SpendingRuleAmountas%InvestmentPortfolio 4.5% 4.4% 4.7% 5.0% 5.9%
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody
61
14 The Total Actual Endowment Withdrawal is: (a) the amount actually withdrawn from the portfolio, plus (b) the donations and bequests that have been invested in units of the Amalgamated Fund at year-end that are netted against withdrawals for the Spending Rule Amount rather than disturb the portfolio, plus (c) EBITDA less interest and less capital expenditure (ex. Howard Foundation projects).
COllEGEStAtIStICSANDFINANCIAlHIGHlIGHtSCONtINUED
Financial Year End: 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010
10. Charitable Funds continuedtotalActualEndowmentWithdrawal14 £3,116,516 £1,630,510 £1,243,975 £2,704,863 £1,637,621
totalActualEndowmentWithdrawalas%ofCharitableFunds 7.1% 3.8% 3.1% 7.4% 5.4%
PerformanceofCoreSecuritiesPortfolio(netoffees) 8.9% 10.8% 0.0% 14.0% 7.2%
Annualthree-yearCumulative 6.5% 8.1% 6.9% (1.5%) (6.7%)
AnnualFive-yearCumulative 8.1% 1.2% (1.6%) 0.3% (0.5%)
PerformanceofPropertyPortfolio 5.8% 7.6% 11.4% 17.4% 14.1%
Annualthree-yearCumulative 8.3% 12.1% 14.3% 10.6% 2.4%
AnnualFive-yearCumulative 11.2% 10.2% 7.0% 5.8% 5.5%
11. Inflation Measurements RPI 2.6% 3.3% 2.8% 5.0% 5.0%
RPIX 2.7% 3.3% 2.8% 5.0% 5.0%
HEPPI–nowdiscontinued — — — — 2.2%
tenderPriceInflation(October–October)DavislangdontenderPriceIndex
4.9% 2.0% 0.5% (0.5%) (2.0%)
12. The FellowshipFellowship(as of 1 October 2014) 47 50 52 53 52
UniversityPrincipalEmployer 33 36 38 39 37
Professors 13 14 14 13 12
Readers 3 4 2 4 4
Seniorlecturers 6 7 6 6 6
lecturers 8 8 11 12 12
Other 3 3 5 4 3
CollegeteachingOfficers 3 2 2 4 4
ResearchFellowships 2 3 3 2 3
Stipendiary 1 2 3 2 3
Non-stipendiary 1 1 — — —
Administrative+Chaplain 4 4 4 4 3
Female 14 14 14 16 16
Male 33 36 38 37 36
Resident 3 5 7 8 8
Non-Resident 44 45 45 45 44
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody
62
COllEGEStAtIStICSANDFINANCIAlHIGHlIGHtSCONtINUED
Financial Year End: 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010
13. Support StaffSupportStaffHeadcount 155 144 139 135 137
Female 90 82 82 78 81
Male 65 62 57 57 56
turnover
Appointments 36 23 30
Retirements 5 2 3 2 2
Resignations 19 13 18 21 18
Deceased — 1 1 — —
Dismissal/Redundancy 1 2 4 4 1
Days Sickness 618 944 895 1,123 1,508
ReportsunderRIDDOR — — 1 1 —
14. PensionsMembersintheUSSPensionScheme 76 74 78 86 95
MembersinMoneyPurchaseScheme 72 7 5 3 2
MembersintheCCFPSPensionScheme
atthetriennialActuarialValuation31March
2 2 4 4 4
Pensioners 34 — — 27 —
Male 17 — — 12 —
Female 17 — — 15 —
Deferred 50 — — 59 —
Male 23 — — 31 —
Female 27 — — 28 —
ActiveMembers 2 — — 4 —
AverageAge 64.0 — — 51.7 —
Male 1 — — 2 —
AverageAge 57.5 — — 59.5 —
Female 1 — — 2 —
AverageAge 60.7 — — 43.8 —
PensionfundAssets(CCFPS)attriennialValuationAssets £4,497,500 — — £3,551,000 —
PastServiceFundinglevelDeficit (£925,600) — — (£274,000 —
Fundinglevel% 79% — — 93% —
MembersofPreviousCollegeStaffScheme(Retired) 5 5 5 6 7
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody
63
COllEGEStAtIStICSANDFINANCIAlHIGHlIGHtSCONtINUED
Financial Year End: 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010
15. Environmental MeasuresCollegesEnvironmentalleaguetable 1 1 1= 6 1
Management Rank 3 2= 1 6 2
Management Score 260pts 86% NA 71% 73.6%
EnergyRank(CO2emissions2014) 6 7 NA 4 7
EnergyScore(CO2emissions) 9.3kg/p/day 11.5kg/p/day 30.0kWh/p/
day
57.0kWh/p/
day
60.0kWh/p/
day
Water Rank 3 2 NA 5 6
Water Score 142litres/p/
day
166litres/p/
day
<250litres/p/
day
279litres/p/
day
275litres/p/
day
Recycling Rank 1 2 NA 12 1
Recycling Score NA 64% 92.1% 65% 97.6%
WaterUse £74,713 £84,706 £78,662 £62,460 £76,630
GasUse £167,491 £180,292 £163,061 £140,637 £128,415
ElectricityUse £178,146 £192,065 £157,110 £163,981 £201,318
Gasunitprice(p/kWh) 2.32p 2.32p 2.548p 1.9804p 1.9804p
Electricityunitprice(p/kWh) 9.236p 9.236p 7.905p 7.905p 10.533p
Scope1CarbonEmissions
Gas(tonne/CO2e) 943 1070 1,198 903 1,006
Fuel(tonne/CO2e) 0 <1 <6 <1 <1
Scope2CarbonEmissions
Electricity(tonne/CO2e) 910 950 990 979 1,002
16. GovernanceFreedomofInformationrequests 61 25 14 — —
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody
64
ACCOUNtING
1. Donations and BenefactionstheCollegeincreasinglyreliesondonationsandbenefactions,thesebeingreceivedprincipallyfrommembersoutofresidence.theaccountingtreatmentofadonationdependsonthenatureandextentofrestrictionsspecifiedbythedonor.Donationswithnosubstantialrestrictionsarerecognisedasincomeintheincomeandexpenditureaccount.DonationswhicharetoberetainedforthefuturebenefitoftheCollege,andotherdonationswithsubstantiallyrestrictedpurposes,otherthanfortheacquisitionorconstructionoftangiblefixedassets,arerecognisedinthestatementoftotalrecognisedgainsandlossesasnewendowments.
2. LegaciesBecauseofitshistoricalexperience,theCollegetreatslegaciesashavingbeenreceivedonlywhentheyhavebeenpaid,orwhenitbecomesindisputablycertainthattheywillbepaid.
3. TaxationOn1June2010,theCollegeceasedtobeanexemptcharitywithinthemeaningofSchedule2oftheCharitiesAct1993andbecamearegisteredcharity,number1137455,on12August2010.
theCollegeisalsoacharitywithinthemeaningofSection506(1)of thetaxesAct1988.Accordingly, theCollegeisexemptfromtaxationinrespectofincomeorcapitalgainsreceivedwithinthecategoriescoveredbySection505ofthetaxesAct1988orSection256ofthetaxationofChargeableGainsAct1992totheextentthatsuchincomeorgainsareappliedtoexclusivelycharitablepurposes.
theCollegereceivesnosimilarexemptioninrespectofValueAddedtax.theCollegeisapartiallyexemptorganisationforVAtpurposes.WiththeapprovalofHMRevenueandCustoms,ithasadoptedamethodologythatenablesittorecoverpartoftheVAtonitsexpenses.thoughrecoveredVAtsignificantlyexceedstheVAtpreviouslyrecoverableundertheoldCVCPGuidelines,inputtaxonpurchasesis,nevertheless,largelyirrecoverable.In2013-14,theCollegereceived£160,148inrefundsonpurchasesof£6.0million.
theCollege’ssubsidiarycompanies,DowningCollegeDevelopmentslimited,DowningCambridgeConferenceslimitedandtheMayBall Company limited are not subject to these exemptions and are liable for Corporationtax.However, all taxable profits of thesubsidiariesaregiftaidedtotheCollege,therebyextinguishinganycorporationtaxthatmaybeassessable.
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody
65
15 Certain of the College buildings were first listed as buildings of “special architectural or historic interest” on 26 April 1950. The buildings that are classified as Grade 1 (“buildings of exceptional interest”, comprising about 2% of the 1989 resurvey) are: east and west Ranges, including the Hall, the Master’s Lodge and the east and west lodges. Those classified as Grade 2 (“particularly important buildings of more than special interest”, comprising about 4% of the list) are: The Gate lodge [with 36 Regent Street], and gates to Regent Street; the West Gate onto Tennis Court Road, including short screen walls on either side; North-west Gate onto Tennis Court Road opposite Fitzwilliam Street; Boundary Wall fronting Tennis Court Road.
4.Fundsi) DeferredCapital:
DeferredCapitalrepresentsdonationstowardsthecostofpurchaseorconstructionofatangiblefixedassetotherthanland.
ii) Endowment: EndowmentfundsareheldontrusttoberetainedforthebenefitoftheCollege.theycanbeeitherpermanentfunds(ofeitherarestrictedorunrestrictednature)whichmustbeinvestedpermanentlytogenerateanincomestream,orexpendablefunds,whichmaybeconvertedtoincomeandarerestrictedonly.Restrictedfundsaresubjecttospecifictrusts,whichmaybedeclaredbythedonor(s)orwiththeirauthority,orcreatedthroughalegalprocess.therestrictionmayapplytoincomeorcapital,orboth.
iii) Reserves: UnrestrictedfundsareavailabletotheCollegeforgeneralpurposesandareexpendableattheCollege’sdiscretion.theCollegehasdesignatedpartofthefundforaparticularpurpose,theDesignatedBuildingReserve.thisreserve,togetherwiththeRevaluationReserveandDeferredCapital,representsthenetbookvalueofthefixedassetsusedforoperationalpurposes.
5.Depreciationtheearliestbuildings,designedbyWilliamWilkins,formasignificantpartoftheDomusandarelistedasGradeI.15Allotherbuildingson theDomuscomewithin the curtilageof thosebuildings andare therefore subject to someof the same restrictions.thelistingimposesanobligationtorepairandrestore.AfullquinquennialassetvaluationoftheoperationalestateforaccountingpurposeswaspreparedbyGeraldEvellP,CharteredSurveyors,asat30June2011.theresultingvalueofthebuildingswasincludedinFixedAssetsontheBalanceSheet.Allrepairsthatrestorevaluearecapitalised,asareimprovements.Otherrepairsarechargedagainstincome.Forinsurancepurposes,thereplacementcostofthebuildingshasbeenvaluedat£112.9million.
6.PensionsFRS17hasbeenadoptedinfull,enablingtheestimatedcostofprovidingthepensionbenefitsearnedduringtheyeartobeincludedasastaffcostwithinexpenditure.thedeficitontheschemeisshownasaliabilityoftheCollegeanddeductedfromreserves.
YearEnded30June2014|ReportoftheGoverningBody
68
YearEnded30June2014|FinancialStatements RESPONSIBIlItIESOFtHEGOVERNINGBODY
theGoverningBodyisresponsiblefortheadministrationandmanagementoftheCollege’saffairs.
theGoverningBodypresentsauditedfinancialstatementsforeachfinancialyear.thesearepreparedinaccordancewiththeprovisionsoftheStatutesoftheCollegeandoftheUniversityofCambridgeandapplicableUnitedKingdomAccountingStandards,includingtheStatementofRecommendedPractice ‘Accounting forFurtherandHigherEducation Institutions’, as interpretedby theUniversityofCambridgeintheirRecommendedCambridgeCollegeAccounts.
With reference to theaboveprovisions, theGoverningBody is responsible forensuring that there isaneffective systemof internalcontrolandthataccountingrecordsareproperlykept.
Itisrequiredtopresentauditedfinancialstatementsforeachfinancialyear,preparedinaccordancewiththeStatutesoftheUniversity.
Incausingthefinancialstatementstobeprepared,theGoverningBodyhassoughttoensurethat:
• Suitableaccountingpoliciesareselectedandappliedconsistently;
• Judgementsandestimatesaremadethatarereasonableandprudent;
• Applicableaccountingstandardshavebeenfollowed,subjecttoanymaterialdeparturesdisclosedandexplainedinthefinancialstatements.
theGoverningBodyissatisfiedthattheCollegehasadequateresourcestocontinueinoperationfortheforeseeablefuture.thefinancialstatementsareaccordinglypreparedonagoingconcernbasis.
theGoverningBodyhastakenreasonablestepstoensurethat thereareappropriatefinancialandmanagementcontrols inplacetosafeguardtheassetsoftheCollegeandpreventanddetectfraud.
Anysystemofinternalfinancialcontrol,however,canonlyprovidereasonable,notabsolute,assuranceagainstmaterialmisstatementor loss.
theGoverning Body is responsible for themaintenance and integrity of the corporate and financial information included on theCollege’swebsite.legislationintheUnitedKingdomgoverningthepreparationanddisseminationoffinancialstatementsmaydifferfromlegislationinotherjurisdictions.
69
YearEnded30June2014|FinancialStatementsINDEPENDENtAUDItORS’REPORttOtHEGOVERNINGBODYOF
DOWNING COLLEGEWehaveauditedthefinancialstatementsofDowningCollegefortheyearended30June2014whichcomprisetheconsolidatedincomeandexpenditureaccount,theconsolidatedstatementoftotalrecognisedgainsandlosses,theconsolidatedandCollegebalancesheet,theconsolidatedcashflowstatementandrelatednotes.thefinancialreportingframeworkthathasbeenappliedintheirpreparationisapplicablelawandUnitedKingdomAccountingStandards(UnitedKingdomGenerallyAcceptedAccountingPractice).
thisreportismadesolelytotheCollege’strustees,asabody,inaccordancewithCollege’sStatutes,theStatutesoftheUniversityofCambridgeandwithsection151oftheCharitiesAct2011andregulationsmadeundersection154ofthatAct.OurauditworkhasbeenundertakensothatwemightstatetotheCollege’strusteesthosematterswearerequiredtostatetotheminanauditors’reportandfornootherpurpose.tothefullestextentpermittedbylaw,wedonotacceptorassumeresponsibilitytoanyoneotherthantheCollegeandtheCollege’strusteesasabody,forourauditwork,forthisreport,orfortheopinionswehaveformed.
RESPECtIVERESPONSIBIlItIESOFtHEGOVERNINGBODYANDAUDItORSAsexplainedmorefullyintheGoverningBody’sResponsibilitiesStatementsetoutonpage68,theGoverningBodyisresponsibleforthepreparationoffinancialstatementswhichgiveatrueandfairview.
Wehavebeenappointedasauditorsundersection151oftheCharitiesAct2011andreportinaccordancewithregulationsmadeundersection154ofthatAct.OurresponsibilityistoauditandexpressanopiniononthefinancialstatementsinaccordancewithapplicablelawandInternationalStandardsonAuditing(UKandIreland).thosestandardsrequireustocomplywiththeAuditingPracticesBoard’s(APB’s)EthicalStandardsforAuditors.
SCOPEOFtHEAUDItOFFINANCIAlStAtEMENtSAn audit involves obtaining evidence about the amounts and disclosures in the financial statements sufficient to give reasonableassurancethatthefinancialstatementsarefreefrommaterialmisstatement,whethercausedbyfraudorerror.thisincludesanassessmentof:whethertheaccountingpoliciesareappropriatetothecharity’scircumstancesandhavebeenconsistentlyappliedandadequatelydisclosed; the reasonablenessof significantaccountingestimatesmadeby the trustees;and theoverallpresentationof thefinancialstatements. In addition,we read all the financial and non-financial information in theAnnualtrustees’ Report to identifymaterialinconsistencieswiththeauditedfinancialstatementsandtoidentifyanyinformationthatisapparentlymateriallyincorrectbasedon,ormateriallyinconsistentwith,theknowledgeacquiredbyusinthecourseofperformingtheaudit.Ifwebecomeawareofanyapparentmaterialmisstatementsorinconsistenciesweconsidertheimplicationsforourreport.
70
YearEnded30June2014|FinancialStatements OPINIONONFINANCIAlStAtEMENtS
Inouropinion:
• thefinancial statementsgivea trueand fair viewof the stateof theCollege’saffairs asat30 June2014andof its incomeandexpenditurefortheyearthenended;
• thefinancialstatementshavebeenproperlypreparedinaccordancewithUnitedKingdomGenerallyAcceptedAccountingPractice;
• thefinancialstatementshavebeenpreparedinaccordancewiththerequirementsoftheCharitiesAct2011,theCollege’sStatutesandtheStatutesoftheUniversityofCambridge;
• thecontributionduefromtheCollegetotheUniversityhasbeencorrectlycomputedasadvisedintheprovisionalassessmentbytheUniversityofCambridgeandinaccordancewiththeprovisionsofStatuteG,II,oftheUniversityofCambridge.
MAttERSONWHICHWEAREREQUIREDtOREPORtBYEXCEPtION
WehavenothingtoreportinrespectofthefollowingmatterswheretheCharitiesAct2011requiresustoreporttoyouif,inouropinion:
• theinformationgivenintheGoverningBodyAnnualReportisinconsistentinanymaterialrespectwiththefinancialstatements;or
• sufficientaccountingrecordshavenotbeenkept;or
• thefinancialstatementsarenotinagreementwiththeaccountingrecordsandreturns;or
• wehavenotreceivedalltheinformationandexplanationswerequireforouraudit.
PEtERSElWORtHY&MOORE CharteredAccountantsandStatutoryAuditors SalisburyHouse Station Road CAMBRIDGECB12lA
Date: 19 December 2014
PetersElworthy&Mooreiseligibletoactasanauditorintermsofsection1212oftheCompaniesAct2006.
72
YearEnded30June2014|Statem
entofPrincipalAccountingPolicies BASISOFPREPARAtION
thefinancialstatementshavebeenpreparedinaccordancewiththeprovisionsoftheStatutesoftheCollegeandoftheUniversityofCambridgeandapplicableAccountingStandards. Inaddition,thefinancialstatementscomplywiththeStatementofRecommendedPractice‘AccountingforFurtherandHigherEducationInstitutions’(theSORP).
theincomeandexpenditureaccountincludesactivityanalysisinordertodemonstratethattheCollegeissatisfyingitsobligationstotheUniversityofCambridgewithregardtotheuseofpublicfunds.theanalysisrequiredbytheSORPissetoutinnote8.
BASISOFACCOUNtINGthefinancialstatementshavebeenpreparedunderthehistoricalcostconvention,asmodifiedbytherevaluationofinvestmentassetsandcertainlandandbuildings.
BASISOFCONSOlIDAtIONtheconsolidatedfinancialstatementsconsolidatethefinancialstatementsoftheCollegeanditssubsidiaryundertakingsfortheyearended30June2014.theresultsofsubsidiaryundertakingsacquiredordisposedofduringtheperiodareincludedintheconsolidatedincomeandexpenditureaccountfromthedateofacquisitionoruptothedateofdisposal.theactivitiesofstudentsocietieshavenotbeenconsolidated.
AseparatebalancesheetandrelatednotesfortheCollegearenotincludedintheaccountsbecausetheCollege’ssubsidiarycompaniesareadesignandbuildcompany,aconferencetradingcompanyandacompanyoperatingthebiannualMayBallandthereforethebalancesheetwouldnotbemateriallydifferentfromtheoneincludedintheaccounts.
RECOGNITION OF INCOME
a)AcademicfeesCollegefeeincomeisrecognisedintheperiodforwhichitisreceivedandincludesallfeeschargeabletostudentsortheirsponsors.
b)DonationsandbenefactionsCharitabledonationsarerecognisedonreceiptorwherethereiscertaintyof futurereceiptandthevaluecanbemeasuredreliably.theaccountingtreatmentofadonationdependsonthenatureandextentofrestrictionsspecifiedbythedonor.Donationswithno
73
YearEnded30June2014|Statem
entofPrincipalAccountingPoliciessubstantialrestrictionsarerecognisedasincomeintheincomeandexpenditureaccount.Donationswhicharetoberetainedforthe
futurebenefitoftheCollege,andotherdonationswithsubstantiallyrestrictedpurposes,otherthanfortheacquisitionorconstructionoftangiblefixedassets,arerecognisedinthestatementoftotalrecognisedgainsandlossesasnewendowments.
c)CapitalgrantsanddonationsGrants anddonationsare received for thepurposesof funding theacquisitionandconstructionof tangiblefixedassets. In thecaseofdepreciableassetsthesearecreditedtodeferredcapitalgrantswhentherelatedcapitalexpenditureisincurredandreleasedtoincomeovertheestimatedusefullifeoftherespectiveassetsinlinewiththedepreciationpolicy.Grantsanddonationsof,orfortheacquisitionof,freeholdlandorheritageassets,whicharenon-depreciableassets,arecreditedtotheincomeandexpenditureaccountintheyearofacquisition.
d)OtherincomeIncomeisreceivedfromarangeofactivitiesincludingresidences,cateringconferencesandotherservicesrendered.
e)EndowmentandinvestmentincomeAllinvestmentincomeiscreditedtotheincomeandexpenditureaccountintheperiodinwhichitisearned.Incomefromrestrictedendowments not expended in accordancewith the restrictions of the endowment is transferred from the income and expenditureaccounttorestrictedendowments.
f)totalreturntheCollegeoperatesatotalreturnpolicywithregardtoitsendowmentassets(includingproperty).theendowmentspendingpolicyisspecificallydesignedtostabiliseannualspendinglevelsandtopreservetherealvalueoftheendowmentportfolioovertime.thespendingpolicyattemptstoachievethesetwoobjectivesbyusingalong-termtargetedspendingratecombinedwithasmoothingrule,whichadjustsspendinggraduallytochangesintheendowmentmarketvalue.theactualrateofspendingfor2014whenmeasuredagainstthepreviousyear’smarketvaluewas4.5%.
Foreigncurrenciestransactionsdenominatedinforeigncurrenciesarerecordedattherateofexchangerulingatthedatesofthetransactions.Monetaryassetsandliabilitiesdenominatedinforeigncurrenciesaretranslatedintosterlingatyear-endratesor,wheretherearerelatedforwardforeignexchangecontracts,atcontract rates.the resultingexchangedifferencesaredealtwith in thedeterminationof incomeandexpenditureforthefinancialyear.
74
YearEnded30June2014|Statem
entofPrincipalAccountingPolicies tANGIBlEFIXEDASSEtS
a)FreeholdlandandBuildingsBuildingsarestatedatvaluation,theaggregatesurplusordeficitistransferredtoarevaluationreserveincludedwithinReserves.
Existinglandisnotcapitalisedunlessitisheldforinvestmentpurposes.Purchasedlandiscapitalisedinthebalancesheet.
Wherebuildingshavebeenrevalued,theyarevaluedonthebasisoftheirdepreciatedreplacementcost.Afullassetvaluationoftheoperationalestate foraccountspurposeswascarriedoutbyGeraldEvellP,Surveyors, asat30 June2011.Freeholdbuildingsaredepreciatedonastraightlinebasisovertheirexpectedusefuleconomiclivesof100,50,or20years.
Wherebuildingsareacquiredwiththeaidofspecificbequestsordonationstheyarecapitalisedanddepreciatedasabove.therelatedbenefactionsarecreditedtoadeferredcapitalaccountandarereleasedto the IncomeandExpenditureAccountover theexpectedusefuleconomiclifeoftherelatedassetonabasisconsistentwiththedepreciationpolicy.
Areviewforimpairmentofafixedassetiscarriedoutifeventsorchangesincircumstancesindicatethatthecarryingamountofthefixedasset may not be recoverable.
Buildingsunderconstructionarevaluedatcost,basedonthevalueofarchitects’certificatesandotherdirectcostsincurredto30Juneandaredepreciatedwhenbroughtintouse.
b)Maintenanceofpremisesthecostofmajorrefurbishmentandmaintenancethatrestoresvalueiscapitalisedanddepreciatedovertheexpectedusefuleconomiclife of the asset concerned.
c)Furniture,fittingsandequipmentFurniture,fittings,andequipmentarecapitalisedanddepreciatedovertheirexpectedusefullifeasfollows:
Cateringequipment 5 years
Furnitureandequipment 10 years
Information Technology 3 years
Library books 30 years
75
YearEnded30June2014|Statem
entofPrincipalAccountingPoliciesINVEStMENtS
a)SecuritiesSecuritiesareshownattheirmarketvalue.Investmentincomeisincludedwhendividendsandinterestbecomepayable.Interestonbankdepositsisincludedasearned.
b)WorksofArtWorksofartandsilverareincludedattheirmarketvalueasassessedbyChristie’son4October2012.
c)EstatePropertiesInvestmentpropertiesareincludedatvaluationandtheaggregatesurplusordeficitistransferredtoarevaluationreserveincludedwithinReserves.AnannualassessmentwascarriedoutbyCarterJonas,PropertyConsultants,at30June2014.
StOCKSStocksarevaluedatthelowerofcostandnetrealisablevalue.
PROVISIONSProvisionsarerecognisedwhentheCollegehasapresentlegalorconstructiveobligationasaresultofapastevent,anditisprobablethatatransferofeconomicbenefitwillberequiredtosettletheobligationandareliableestimatecanbemadeoftheamountoftheobligation.
ENDOWMENtFUNDSEndowmentfundsareclassifiedunderthreeheadings:
WherethedonorhasspecifiedthatthefundistobepermanentlyinvestedtogenerateanincomestreamforthegeneralpurposesoftheCollege,thefundisclassifiedasanunrestrictedpermanentendowment.
Wherethedonorhasspecifiedthatthefundistobepermanentlyinvestedtogenerateanincomestreamtobeappliedforarestrictedpurpose,thefundisclassifiedasarestrictedpermanentendowment.
Wherethedonorhasspecifiedaparticularobjectiveotherthantheacquisitionorconstructionoftangiblefixedassets,andthattheCollegemustormayconvertthedonatedsumintoincome,thefundisclassifiedasarestrictedexpendableendowment.
76
YearEnded30June2014|Statem
entofPrincipalAccountingPolicies RESERVES
WithinthedetailednotestothefinancialstatementsthesplitofGeneralReserves,betweenfreereservesandthosedesignatedfortherepairandmaintenanceofthehistoricbuildings,hasbeenincludedtohighlighttheextentoftheCollegecommitment.
tAXAtIONtheCollegeisaregisteredcharity(number1137455)andalsoacharitywithinthemeaningofSection506(1)ofthetaxesAct1988.Accordingly,theCollegeisexemptfromtaxationinrespectofincomeorcapitalgainsreceivedwithinthecategoriescoveredbySection505ofthetaxesAct1988orSection256ofthetaxationofChargeableGainsAct1992totheextentthatsuchincomeorgainsareappliedtoexclusivelycharitablepurposes.
theCollegereceivesnosimilarexemptioninrespectofValueAddedtax.
CONtRIBUtIONUNDERStAtUtEG,I ItheCollegeisliabletobeassessedforContributionundertheprovisionsofStatuteG,IIoftheUniversityofCambridge.ContributionisusedtofundgrantstoCollegesfromtheCollegesFund.theCollegereceivedgrantsof£Nil(2013:£72,000)whichiscreditedtopermanentendowment.
PENSIONSCHEMEStheCollegeparticipatesintheUniversitiesSuperannuationScheme,adefinedbenefitschemewhichisexternallyfundedandcontractedoutoftheStateEarnings-RelatedPensionScheme.thefundisvaluedeverythreeyearsbyaprofessionallyqualifiedindependentactuaryusingtheprojectedunitmethod,theratesofcontributionpayablebeingdeterminedbythetrusteesontheadviceoftheactuary.Intheinterveningyears,theactuaryreviewstheprogressofthescheme.PensioncostsareaccountedforovertheperiodduringwhichtheCollegebenefitsfromtheemployees’services.
theCollegealsocontributestotheCambridgeCollegesFederatedPensionScheme,whichisasimilardefinedbenefitpensionscheme.Unlike theUniversities Superannuation Scheme, this schemehas surpluses anddeficits directly attributable to individualColleges.PensioncostsareaccountedforovertheperiodduringwhichtheCollegebenefitsfromtheemployees’services.
the College also contributes to the personal pension schemes of employees.these funds are held separately from the assets andliabilitiesoftheCollege.thecontributionsarechargedtotheIncomeandExpenditureAccountasincurredandrepresenttheamountspayablebytheCollegetothefundfortheyear.
78
YearEnded30June2014|PrincipalA
ccountingStatem
ents CONSOlIDAtEDINCOMEANDEXPENDItUREACCOUNt
FORtHEYEARENDED30JUNE2014
Note
2014 £000
2013 £000
Income
AcademicFeesandCharges 1 2,713 2,596
Residences, Catering and Conferences 2 5,173 5,044
EndowmentandInvestmentIncome 3 1,687 1,548
Donations 4 574 468
Other Income 9 229
Total Income 10,156 9,885
Expenditure
Education 5 4,133 4,025
Residences, Catering and Conferences 6 5,571 5,369
Other(InvestmentandPropertyManagement) 132 155
Total Expenditure 8 9,836 9,549
Surplus on Continuing Operations before Contribution under Statute G, II 320 336
ContributionunderStatuteG,II 7 — —
Surplus on Continuing Operations after Contribution under Statute G, II 320 336
SurplusfortheyeartransferredtoAccumulatedIncomeinEndowmentFunds (87) (70)
Surplus for the year retained within General Reserves 233 266
All items dealt with in arriving at the Surplus for 2014 and Surplus 2013 relate to continuing operations.
NoteofHistoricalCostSurplusesandDeficitsthedifferencebetweentheresultsasdisclosedintheIncomeandExpenditureAccountandtheresultonanunmodifiedcostbasisisnotmaterial.
79
YearEnded30June2014|PrincipalA
ccountingStatem
entsCONSOlIDAtEDStAtEMENtOFtOtAlRECOGNISEDGAINSANDlOSSES
FORtHEYEARENDED30JUNE2014
Note
RestrictedFunds
£000
UnrestrictedFunds
£000
totalFunds
2014
£000
totalFunds
2013
£000
Surplusonincomeandexpenditureaccount — 233 233 266
Unspentendowmentfundincome 87 — 87 70
totalReturnnotrecognisedintheIncome&Expenditure
Account 3b 301 553 854 1,217
Increaseinmarketvalueoffixedassetinvestmentsexcludedfrom
totalReturn — 147 147 25
CapitalgrantfromCollegesFund 19 — — — 72
Newendowments 19 3,178 845 4,023 1,744
Increaseinmarketvalueofcurrentassetinvestments — 65 65 —
Actuariallossinrespectofpensionschemes — (266) (266) (409)
Total recognised gains relating to the year 3,566 1,577 5,143 2,985
Reconciliation
Openingreservesandendowments 28 13,106 109,609 122,715 119,730
Total recognised gains for the year 3,566 1,577 5,143 2,985
Closing reserves and endowments 16,672 111,186 127,858 122,715
80
CONSOlIDAtEDBAlANCESHEEt ASAt30JUNE2014
Note
2014 £000
2013 £000
Fixed Assets
tangibleAssets 10 112,439 106,228
Investments 11 19,116 22,759
131,555 128,987
Endowment Assets 12 24,650 20,106
Current Assets
Investments 5,085 —
Stock 162 171
Debtors 13 681 922
Cash 14 2,578 3,573
8,506 4,666
Creditors: amounts falling due within one year 15 (4,807) (4,915)
Net Current Assets/(Liabilities) 3,699 (249)
Provisions for Liabilities and Charges — —
Creditors: amounts falling due after more than one year 16 (10,500) (5,500)
Net Assets excluding Pension Liability 149,404 143,344
Pension Liability 17 (2,038) (1,825)
Net Assets including Pension Liability 147,366 141,519
YearEnded30June2014|PrincipalA
ccountingStatem
ents
81
YearEnded30June2014|PrincipalA
ccountingStatem
entsCONSOlIDAtEDBAlANCESHEEtCONtINUED
Note
RestrictedFunds
£000
UnrestrictedFunds
£000
Total
2014
£000
Total
2013
£000
Capital and Reserves
Deferred Capital Grants 18 19,508 — 19,508 18,804
Endowments
Expendableendowments 19 1,240 — 1,240 1,197
Permanentendowments 19 15,432 7,978 23,410 18,909
16,672 7,978 24,650 20,106
Reserves
Generalreservesexcludingpensionreserve 20 — 94,376 94,376 93,637
Pensionreserve 20 — (2,038) (2,038) (1,825)
Operationalpropertyrevaluationreserve 20 — 7,240 7,240 7,314
Fixedassetrevaluationreserve 20 — 3,630 3,630 3,483
— 103,208 103,208 102,609
Subtotal of Endowment & Reserves 16,672 111,186 127,858 122,715
Total 36,180 111,186 147,366 141,519
theseaccountswereapprovedbythetrusteeson28November2014andaresignedontheirbehalfby:
ProfGRGrimmett,Master
82
YearEnded30June2014|PrincipalA
ccountingStatem
ents CONSOlIDAtEDCASHFlOWStAtEMENtFORtHEYEARENDED30JUNE2014
2014£000
2013£000
A. Operating Activities
OperatingSurplusBeforetax 320 336
Profitondisposal — (221)
Depreciation 1,396 1,393
Less: Investment Income (1,686) (1,548)
MovementinPensionDeficit (52) (47)
Interestpayable 395 268
DonationIncomeexpendedinyear (215) (203)
Increaseincurrentassetinvestments (5,021) —
Decrease in Stocks 8 —
Decrease/(increase)inDebtors 171 (102)
Decrease in Creditors (264) (342)
Net Cash Outflow from Operating Activities (4,948) (466)
B. Returns on Investments and Servicing of Finance
IncomefromEndowments 1,652 1,543
Other interest received 34 5
Interestpaid (394) (268)
Net Cash Inflow from Returns on Investments and Servicing of Finance 1,292 1,280
C. Contribution to Colleges Fund — —
D. Capital Expenditure and Financial Investment
Purchaseoftangiblefixedassets (3,387) (771)
Donationsandotherdeferredcapitalgrantsreceived 4,941 2,947
Netpurchaseoflongterminvestments (3,882) (1,697)
Netpurchaseofotherinvestments (10) —
Net Cash (Outflow)/Inflow from Capital Transactions (2,338) 479
Net Cash (Outflow)/Inflow before Financing (5,994) 1,293
83
CONSOlIDAtEDCASHFlOWStAtEMENtCONtINUED
2014£000
2013£000
E. Financing
Bondfunding 5,000 —
F. Decrease in Cash
(Decrease)/IncreaseinCashinthePeriod (994) 1,293
Bondfunding (5,000) —
NetFundsbroughtforwardat1July2013 (1,928) (3,221)
NetFundscarriedforwardat30June2014 (7,922) (1,928)
G. Analysis of Changes in Net Debt
At1July2013 £000
Cashflows £000
At30June2014 £000
Cash at bank and in hand 3,572 (994) 2,578
Loan (5,500) (5,000) (10,500)
(1,928) (5,994) (7,922)
YearEnded30June2014|PrincipalA
ccountingStatem
ents
86
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtS
1. Academic Fees and Charges 2014 £000
2013 £000
College fees:
FeeincomepaidonbehalfofundergraduatesatthePublicly-fundedUndergraduaterate(percapitafee£4,500-£4,068)(2013:£4,500-£3,951) 1,667 1,555
Privately-fundedUndergraduatefeeincome(percapitafee£7,350-£6,270)(2013:£6,999-£5,970) 340 309
FeeincomereceivedattheGraduatefeerates(percapitafee£2,424)(2013:£2,349) 415 373
2,422 2,237
Research/teachinggrants 49 105
Other income 10 9
CambridgeBursaryScheme 232 245
Total 2,713 2,596
2. Residences, Catering and Conferences Income 2014 £000
2013 £000
ResidentialAccommodation College Members 2,471 2,321
Conferences 1,021 1,062
Internationalprogrammes 111 114
Catering College Members 658 593
Conferences 853 904
Internationalprogrammes 59 50
Total 5,173 5,044
3. Endowment and Investment Income 2014 £000
2013 £000
3a. Analysis
totalreturncontribution(seenote3b) 1,653 1,543
Currentinvestmentasset 21 —
Cash 13 5
1,687 1,548
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
87
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED
3b. Summary of Total Return 2014 £000
2013 £000
Income from:
Investmentportfolioandinvestmentproperties 1,058 1,314
Gains/(losses) on endowment assets:
Investmentportfolioandinvestmentproperties 1,575 1,531
Investmentmanagementcosts(seenote3c) (125) (85)
Total return for year 2,508 2,760
totalreturntransferredtoincomeandexpenditureaccount(seenote3a) (1,653) (1,543)
totalreturnforyearincludedwithinstatementoftotalrecognisedgainsandlosses 854 1,217
Unapplied Total Return at beginning of year 7,548 6,331
Unapplied Total Return at end of year 8,402 7,548
theseamountsdonotincludeanytotalreturnrelatingtotheCollegepropertiesfromfinancialyearsearlierthan30June2007.
3c. Investment Management Costs 2014 £000
2013 £000
Freeholdlandandbuildings 18 18
Quotedandothersecuritiesandcash 107 67
Total 125 85
4. Donations 2014 £000
2013 £000
Unrestricteddonations 244 172
Restricted donations 115 93
359 265
Releasedfromdeferredcapitalgrants(seeNote18) 215 203
Total 574 468
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
88
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED
5. Education Expenditure 2014 £000
2013 £000
Teaching 2,038 2,031
tutorial 552 497
Admissions 437 418
Research 143 160
ScholarshipsandAwards 483 450
OtherEducationalFacilities 480 469
total(Note8) 4,133 4,025
IncludedwithinScholarshipsandAwardsarepaymentsundertheCambridgeBursarySchemeamountingto£280,300(2013:£278,400).
6. Residences, Catering and Conferences Expenditure 2014 £000
2013 £000
ResidentialAccommodation College Members 2,369 2,228
Conferences 1,266 1,362
Catering College Members 957 828
Conferences 979 951
Total 5,571 5,369
Conferencesexpenditureisincludedaboveonafullycostedbasis,howeveronadirectcostbasistheconferencesprofitwouldbe£818,022(2013-£918,860).
7. Contribution under Statute G, II 2014 £000
2013 £000
UniversityContributionrelatingto2013/14 — —
UniversityContributionrelatingto2012/13 — —
— —
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
89
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED
8. Analysis of Expenditure by Activity
8a) Analysis of 2013/14 Expenditure by Activity Staff Costs (Note9)
£000
OtherOperatingExpenses
£000Depreciation
£000
Total2014£000
Education(Note5) 1,888 1,844 401 4,133
Residences,CateringandConferences(Note6) 2,441 2,141 988 5,570
Other 42 83 8 133
4,371 4,068 1,397 9,836
8b) Analysis of 2012/13 Expenditure by Activity Staff Costs (Note9)
£000
OtherOperating
Expenses £000
Depreciation £000
Total 2013 £000
Education(Note5) 1,810 1,861 354 4,025
Residences,CateringandConferences(Note6) 2,391 1,942 1,036 5,369
Other 71 80 4 155
4,272 3,883 1,394 9,549
theaboveexpenditureincludes£366,971asthedirectcostoffundraising(2013:£351,964). thisexpenditureincludesthecostsofalumnirelations.
8c) Auditors’ remuneration
Otheroperatingexpensesinclude:
2014 £000
2013 £000
AuditfeespayabletotheCollege’sexternalauditors 17 17
OtherfeespayabletotheCollege’sexternalauditors 3 3
20 20
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
90
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED
9. Staff Costs CollegeFellows
£000
OtherAcademics
£000
Non-Academics
£000
Total2014£000
Total2013£000
Staff Costs
Emoluments 887 — 2,971 3,858 3,769
SocialSecurityCosts 49 — 178 227 220
OtherPensionCosts 80 — 206 286 283
1,016 — 3,355 4,371 4,272
Average Staff Numbers (Full-time Staff Equivalents)
Academic 48 — — 48 49
Non-Academic 3 — 115 118 118
Total 51 — 115 166 167
Ofthe51Fellows,45Fellowsarestipendiary.
NoofficeroremployeeoftheCollegereceivedemolumentsofover£100,000.
thetrusteesreceivenoemolumentsintheircapacityastrusteesoftheCollege.
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
91
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED
10. Tangible Fixed Assets
Group and College Library Books
£000
CollegeBuildings& Site £000
Assetsunderconstruction
£000
Information Technology
£000
Furniture&Equipment
£000
Catering Equipment
£000
Total2014£000
Cost or valuation
Atbeginningofyear 758 106,417 — 942 4,398 284 112,799
Additions 31 2,752 372 41 320 21 3,537
Transfer — — 4,070 — — — 4,070
Atendofyear 789 109,169 4,442 983 4,718 305 120,406
Depreciation
Atbeginningofyear 276 1,863 — 854 3,346 232 6,571
Charge for the Year 29 1,016 — 71 259 21 1,396
Atendofyear 305 2,879 — 925 3,605 253 7,967
Net Book value
Atendofyear 484 106,290 4,442 58 1,113 52 112,439
Atbeginningofyear 482 104,554 — 88 1,052 52 106,228
theinsuredvalueoffreeholdlandandBuildingsat30June2014was£112,922,188(2013£112,229,688).
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
92
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED
11. Investments
Group and College 2014 £000
2013 £000
Balance at beginning of year 22,759 22,106
Additions 10 —
Disposals (150) (1)
Changeinmarketvalue (3,650) 629
Revaluation 147 25
Balance at end of year 19,116 22,759
Represented by: 2014 £000
2013 £000
Worksofart/silver 4,601 4,453
InvestmentinCambridgeCollegesFundingPlc 5 —
InvestmentinCambridgeCollegesFundingIIPlc 5 —
CapitalExpendableInvestments(Note12) 14,250 17,901
loantoJointCollege’sNurseryScheme 5 5
Land 250 400
Total 19,116 22,759
InvestmentsheldbytheCollegealsoincludeanadditional£5,002(2013:£5,002)investmentinthesubsidiaryundertakingsatcost(seeNote24)
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
93
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED
12. Endowment Assets
Group and College 2014 £000
2013 £000
Long term investments:
Balance at beginning of year 20,106 17,632
Additions 8,067 3,354
Disposals (3,867) (3,168)
Transfer (4,070) —
MovementinoverdistributionofMarketValuetoFunds (34) (93)
MovementinduefromExpendableCapital 70 64
MovementinamountincludedinInvestmentAssets 3,650 (629)
Changeinmarketvalue 1,565 1,531
Changeincashheldbyfundmanagers (837) 1,415
Total Long term investments 24,650 20,106
Represented by: 2014 £000
2013 £000
Property 12,964 17,079
Securities–Equities/HedgeFunds 20,220 13,625
Securities–FixedInterest 832 1,617
CashwithAgents 1,758 2,596
OverdistributionofMarketValuetoFunds 1,504 1,538
DuefromExpendableCapital 1,622 1,552
Total 38,900 38,007
lessamountsincludedasInvestmentassets(Note11) (14,250) (17,901)
Total 24,650 20,106
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
94
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED
13. Debtors
Group2014£000
College2014£000
Group2013£000
College2013£000
Members of the College 94 94 177 177
Rents 82 82 140 140
Conferences 94 27 203 47
Fees 11 11 1 1
Other debtors 401 1,021 401 439
Total 681 1,235 922 804
14. Cash and bank balances
Group2014£000
College2014£000
Group2013£000
College2013£000
Short-termmoneymarketinvestments — — 560 560
Bankdeposits 1,810 1,810 2,012 2,012
Currentaccounts 766 61 1,000 524
Cash in hand 2 2 1 1
Total 2,578 1,873 3,573 3,097
15. Creditors: amounts falling due within one year
Group2014£000
College2014£000
Group2013£000
College2013£000
Duetotradesmen&others 756 756 787 787
Members of the College 178 178 167 167
UniversityFees 9 9 1 1
Other creditors 2,242 1,731 2,408 2,446
Duetopermanentcapital 1,622 1,622 1,552 1,552
Total 4,807 4,296 4,915 4,953
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
95
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED16. Creditors: amount falling due after one year
Group and College 2014 £000
2013 £000
Bondfunding 5,000 —
Bankloanduemorethan5years 5,500 5,500
Total 10,500 5,500
theloanisrepayablein2048andinterestpayableisfixedat4.64%.
During2013-14,theCollegehasborrowedfrominstitutionalinvestors,collectivelywithotherColleges,theCollege’ssharebeing£5million.theloansareunsecuredandrepayableduringthe
period2043-2053,andareatfixedinterestratesofapproximately4.4%.theCollegehasagreedafinancialcovenantoftheratioofBorrowingstoNetAssets,andhasbeenincompliancewith
thecovenantatalltimessinceincurringthedebt.
17. Pension liabilities
Group and College 2014 £000
2013 £000
Balance at beginning of year 1,825 1,463
Movement in year:
Currentservicecostincludinglifeassurance 19 19
Contributions (102) (106)
Otherfinancecost 30 40
Actuariallossrecognisedinstatementoftotalrecognisedgainsandlosses 266 409
Balance at end of year 2,038 1,825
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
96
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED18. Deferred capital grants 2014
£0002013 £000
Balance at beginning of year
Buildings 18,782 17,873
Equipment 22 4
Donations received
Buildings 919 1,105
Equipment — 25
Released to income and expenditure account
Buildings (208) (196)
Equipment (7) (7)
Balances at end of year
Buildings 19,493 18,782
Equipment 15 22
Total balance at end of year 19,508 18,804
DeferredcapitalgrantsrepresentdonationsreceivedtowardsmajorbuildingprojectswhicharereleasedtotheIncomeandExpenditureAccountaccordingtotheaccountingpolicystated
intheseaccounts.
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
97
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED
19. Endowments
Group and College UnrestrictedPermanent
£000
Restricted Permanent
£000
Total Permanent
£000
Restricted Expendable
£000
Total 2014 £000
Total 2013 £000
Balance at beginning of year
Capital 7,000 11,824 18,824 1,038 19,862 17,452
UnspentIncome — 85 85 159 244 180
7,000 11,909 18,909 1,197 20,106 17,632
Incomereceivablefromendowmentassetinvestments 1,047 560 1,607 46 1,653 1,544
Expenditure (1,047) (491) (1,538) (28) (1,566) (1,473)
Nettransferfromincomeandexpenditureaccount — 69 69 18 87 71
Newendowmentsreceived 845 3,178 4,023 — 4,023 1,816
Increaseinmarketvalueofinvestments 133 276 409 25 434 587
Balance at end of year 7,978 15,432 23,410 1,240 24,650 20,106
Comprising:
Capital 7,978 15,296 23,274 1,063 24,337 19,862
UnspentIncome — 136 136 177 313 244
Balance at end of year 7,978 15,432 23,410 1,240 24,650 20,106
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
98
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED
19. Endowments continued
UnrestrictedPermanent
£000
Restricted Permanent
£000
Total
Permanent £000
Restricted
Expendable£000
Total 2014 £000
Total 2013 £000
Representing:
FellowshipFunds — 4,497 4,497 — 4,497 4,206
ScholarshipFunds 439 5,532 5,971 155 6,126 3,681
PrizeFunds 18 308 326 11 337 315
HardshipFunds — 1,037 1,037 2 1,039 977
travelGrantFunds — 34 34 — 34 34
GrantFunds 8 2,709 2,717 666 3,383 3,079
OtherFunds 7,513 1,315 8,828 406 9,234 7,814
7,978 15,432 23,410 1,240 24,650 20,106
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
99
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED
20. Reserves
Group and College
General Reserves £000
Designated
BuildingsReserve £000
OperationalProperty
RevaluationReserve £000
FixedAssetInvestment
RevaluationReserve £000
PensionReserve £000
Total 2014 £000
Total 2013 £000
Balance at beginning of year 15,198 78,439 7,314 3,483 (1,825) 102,609 102,097
Surplusretainedfortheyear 180 — — — 53 233 267
Actuarialloss — — — — (266) (266) (409)
transfer of depreciation on revalued
operationalproperties 74 — (74) — — — —
Revaluationofworksofart — — — 147 — 147 —
Increaseinmarketvalueof
investments485 — — — — 485 654
transferofdesignatedbuildingreserve (5,548) 5,548 — — — — —
Balance at end of year 10,389 83,987 7,240 3,630 (2,038) 103,208 102,609
21. Capital Commitments 2014 £000
2013 £000
Capital commitments at 30 June 2014 are as follows -
Authorisedandcontracted 930 768
Authorisedbutnotyetcontractedfor 8,777 399
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
100
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED
22. Financial Commitments
At30June2014,theCollegehadannualcommitmentsundernon-cancellableoperatingleasesasfollows 2014 £000
2013 £000
Land & Buildings
Expiringwithinoneyear — 6
Expiringbetweentwoandfiveyears — —
Expiringinoverfiveyears 7 7
Other
Expiringwithinoneyear — —
Expiringbetweentwoandfiveyears 5 5
Expiringinoverfiveyears — —
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
101
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED23. Pensions
theCollegeoperatesaninsuredmoneypurchasepensionschemeforitsstaff.theassetsoftheschemeareheldseparatelyfromthoseof the College.
theCollege’scontributionstotheschemeamountedto£25,137(2013Nil),withcontributionsof£17,773(2013Nil),outstandingatthebalance sheet date.
theCollegeparticipatesintwodefinedbenefitschemes,theUniversitiesSuperannuationScheme(USS)andtheCambridgeCollegesFederatedPensionsScheme(CCFPS).theassetsoftheschemesareheldinseparatetrusteeadministeredfunds.thetotalpensioncostfortheyearwas£261,057(2013:£282,132).
23a Universities Superannuation Scheme
theinstitutionparticipatesintheUniversitiesSuperannuationScheme(USS),adefinedbenefitschemewhichiscontractedoutoftheStateSecondPension(S2P).theassetsoftheschemeareheldinaseparatefundadministeredbythetrustee,UniversitiesSuperannuationScheme Limited.
thelatesttriennialactuarialvaluationoftheschemewasat31March2011.thiswasthesecondvaluationforUSSunderthescheme-specificfundingregimeintroducedbythePensionsAct2004,whichrequiresschemestoadoptastatutoryfundingobjective,whichistohavesufficientandappropriateassetstocovertheirtechnicalprovisions.theactuaryalsocarriesoutregularreviewsofthefundinglevels.Inparticular,hecarriesoutareviewofthefundingleveleachyearbetweentriennialvaluationsanddetailsofhisestimateofthefundinglevelat31March2014arealsoincludedinthisnote.
thetriennialvaluationwascarriedoutusingtheprojectedunitmethod.theassumptionswhichhavethemostsignificanteffectontheresultofthevaluationarethoserelatingtotherateofreturnoninvestments(i.e.thevaluationrateofinterest),theratesofincreaseinsalaryandpensionsandtheassumedratesofmortality.thefinancialassumptionswerederivedfrommarketyieldsprevailingatthevaluationdate.An“inflation riskpremium”adjustmentwasalso includedbydeducting0.3% from themarket-implied inflationonaccountofthehistoricallyhighlevelofinflationimpliedbygovernmentbonds(particularlywhencomparedtotheBankofEngland’stargetof2%forCPIwhichcorrespondsbroadlyto2.75%forRPIperannum).
tocalculatethetechnicalprovisions,itwasassumedthatthevaluationrateofinterestwouldbe6.1%perannum,salaryincreaseswouldbe4.4%perannum(withshort-termgeneralpaygrowthat3.65%perannumandanadditionalallowanceforincreasesinsalariesduetoageandpromotionreflectinghistoricschemeexperience,witha furthercautionaryreserveontopforpastserviceliabilities)andpensionswouldincreaseby3.4%perannumfor3yearsfollowingthevaluationthen2.6%perannumthereafter.
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
102
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED
23. Pensions continued
Atthevaluationdate,thevalueoftheassetsoftheschemewas£32,433.5millionandthevalueofthescheme’stechnicalprovisionswas£35,343.7millionindicatingashortfallof£2,910.2million.theassetsthereforeweresufficienttocover92%ofthebenefitswhichhadaccruedtomembersafterallowingforexpectedfutureincreasesinearnings.
theactuaryalsovaluedtheschemeonanumberofotherbasesasatthevaluationdate.Onthescheme’shistoricgiltsbasis,usingavaluationrateof interest inrespectofpastserviceliabilitiesof4.4%perannum(theexpectedreturnongilts) thefundinglevelwasapproximately68%.UnderthePensionProtectionFundregulationsintroducedbythePensionsAct2004theschemewas93%funded;onabuy-outbasis(i.e.assumingtheschemehaddiscontinuedonthevaluationdate)theassetswouldhavebeenapproximately57%oftheamountnecessarytosecurealltheUSSbenefitswithaninsurancecompany;andusingtheFRS17formulaasifUSSwasasingleemployerscheme,usingaAAbonddiscountrateof5.5%perannumbasedonspotyields,theactuaryestimatedthatthefundinglevelat31March2011was82%.
Aspartofthisvaluation,thetrusteeshavedetermined,afterconsultationwiththeemployers,arecoveryplantopayofftheshortfallby31March2021.thenextformaltriennialactuarialvaluationisasat31March2014.Ifexperienceuptothatdateisinlinewiththeassumptionsmadeforthiscurrentactuarialvaluationandcontributionsarepaidatthedeterminedratesoramounts, theshortfallat31March2014isestimatedtobe£2.2billion,equivalenttoafundinglevelof95%.thecontributionratewillbereviewedaspartofeachvaluationandmaybereviewedmorefrequently.
Aspartofthisvaluation,thetrusteehasdetermined,afterconsultationwiththeemployers,arecoveryplantopayofftheshortfallby31March2021.In2011theactuaryestimatedthatifexperienceremainedinlinewiththeassumptionsmade,theshortfallat31March2014wouldbe£2.2billion,equivalenttoafundinglevelof95%.
However,changesinmarketconditionsbetweenMarch2011andMarch2014havehadanimpactonschemefunding.thenextformaltriennialactuarialvaluationwilltakeplaceasat31March2014,andworkiscurrentlyunderwaytoupdatetheactuarialassumptionsandallowforanyadjustmentstotheoverallfundingapproachadoptedbythetrusteeboardinconsultationwithstakeholders.
Asworkonthe2014valuationisnotyetcompletethetrusteecannotprovidethefinalfigurehowever,anestimatehasbeenprovidedusingtheassumptionsusedtodeliverthe2011actuarialvaluation.Onthatbasis,theactuaryhasestimatedthatthefundinglevelundertheschemespecificfundingregimewillhavefallenfrom92%at31March2011to85%at31March2014.thisestimateisbasedontheresultsfromthevaluationat31March2011allowingprimarilyforinvestmentreturnsandchangestomarketconditions.
thefundinglevelhasdecreasedmainlyduetoadecreaseinrealgiltyields,reducingtheimpliednetdiscountrateandthereforeplacingahighervalueontheschemesliabilities.thisincreasehasbeenpartiallyoffsetbyahigherthanexpectedinvestmentreturn.
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
103
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED
23. Pensions continued
OntheFRS17basis,usinganAAbonddiscountrateof4.5%perannumbasedonspotyields,theactuaryestimatesthatthefundinglevelat31March2014was75%.Anestimateofthefundinglevelmeasuredonahistoricgiltsbasisatthatdatewasapproximately61%.
Surplusesordeficitswhichariseat futurevaluationsmay impacton the institution’s futurecontributioncommitment.Adeficitmayrequireadditionalfundingintheformofhighercontributionrequirements,whereasurpluscould,perhaps,beusedtosimilarlyreducecontributionrequirements.
thetechnicalprovisionsrelateessentiallytothepastserviceliabilitiesandfundinglevels,butitisalsonecessarytoassesstheongoingcostofnewlyaccruingbenefits.thecostoffutureaccrualwascalculatedusingthesameassumptionsasthoseusedtocalculatethetechnicalprovisionsbut theallowance forpromotionalsalary increaseswasnotashigh.Analysishasshownveryvariable levelsofgrowthoverandabovegeneralpayincreasesinrecentyears,andthesalarygrowthassumptionbuiltintothecostoffutureaccrualisbasedonmorestable,historic,salaryexperience.However,whencalculatingthepastserviceliabilitiesofthescheme,acautionaryreservehasbeenincluded,inaddition,onaccountofthevariabilitymentionedabove.
AsatthevaluationdatetheSchemewasstillafullyFinalSalarySchemeforfutureaccrualsandtheprevailingemployercontributionratewas16%ofsalaries.
FollowingUKgovernmentlegislation,from2011statutorypensionincreasesorrevaluationsarebasedontheConsumerPricesIndexmeasureofpriceinflation.HistoricallytheseincreaseshadbeenbasedontheRetailPricesIndexmeasureofpriceinflation.
SincethevaluationeffectivedatetherehavebeenanumberofchangestothebenefitsprovidedbytheschemealthoughthesebecameeffectivefromOctober2011.theseinclude:
New entrants-otherthaninspecific,limitedcircumstances,newentrantsarenowprovidedfor on aCareer RevaluedBenefits (CRB)basisratherthanaFinalSalary(FS)basis.
Normal pension age-theNormalpensionagewasincreasedforfutureserviceandnewentrants,toage65.
Flexible retirement-flexibleretirementoptionswereintroduced.
Member contributions increased -contributionswereupliftedto7.5%p.a.and6.5%p.a. forFSSectionmembersandCRBSectionmembersrespectively.
Cost sharing -ifthetotalcontributionlevelexceeds23.5%ofsalariesperannum,theemployerswillpay65%oftheexcessover23.5%andmemberswouldpaytheremaining35%tothefundasadditionalcontributions.
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
104
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED
23. Pensions continued
Pension increase cap-forservicederivedafter30September2011,USSwillmatchincreasesinofficialpensionsforthefirst5%.Ifofficialpensionsincreasebymorethan5%thenUSSwillpayhalfofthedifferenceuptoamaximumincreaseof10%.
USSisa“lastmanstanding”schemesothatintheeventoftheinsolvencyofanyoftheparticipatingemployersinUSS,theamountofanypensionfundingshortfall(whichcannototherwiseberecovered)inrespectofthatemployerwillbespreadacrosstheremainingparticipantemployersandreflectedinthenextactuarialvaluationofthescheme.
At31March2014,USShadover162,000activemembersandtheinstitutionhad76activemembersparticipatinginthescheme.
the total pension cost for theCollegewas £261,057 (2013: £269,790).the contribution rate payable by theCollegewas 16%ofpensionablesalaries.
23b Cambridge Colleges’ Federated Pension Scheme
theCollegeisalsoamemberofamulti-employerdefinedbenefitscheme,theCambridgeColleges’FederatedPensionScheme(CCFPS),intheUnitedKingdom.theSchemeisadefinedbenefitfinalsalarypensionschemethatwasoriginallysetup,underaninterimtrustDeed,on19 July1977asadefinedbenefit scheme.theScheme isdeemed tobea registeredpensionschemeunder the termsofSchedule36oftheFinanceAct2004.theCollege’semployeescoveredbytheSchemearecontractedintotheStateSecondPension(S2P).
Afullvaluationisbeingundertakenasat31March2014andupdatedto30June2014byaqualifiedActuary.
theprincipalactuarialassumptionsatthebalancesheetdate(expressedasweightedaverages)wereasfollows:
2014 2013
Discountrate 4.2% 4.6%
Expectedlong-termrateofreturnonSchemeassets 6.2% 6.2%
Rate of increase in salaries 2.8% 2.8%
RetailPriceIndex(RPI)assumption 3.3% 3.3%
ConsumerPriceIndexassumption 2.3% 2.3%
Rateofincreaseinpensions(RPIlinked) 3.3% 3.3%
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
105
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED
23. Pensions continued
theunderlyingmortalityassumptionisbaseduponthestandardtableknownasSelf-AdministeredPensionSchemes(SAPS)mortalitytablesforaveragenormalpensionersprojectedinlinewiththeCMI2009projectionandatargetlong-termimprovementrateof1%.thisresultsinthefollowinglifeexpectancies:
• Maleaged65nowhasalifeexpectancyof22.3years(previously22years)
• Femaleaged65nowhasalifeexpectancyof24.3years(previously24.2years)
• Maleaged45nowandretiringin20yearswouldhavealifeexpectancythenof23.7years(previously22.9years)
• Femaleaged45nowandretiringin20yearswouldhavealifeexpectancythenof25.8years(previously25.3years)
Employee Benefit Obligations
theamountsrecognisedinthebalancesheetasat30June2014(withcomparativefiguresasat30June2013)areasfollows:
2014
£000
2013
£000
PresentvaluesofSchemeliabilities (5,674) (5,304)
MarketvalueofSchemeassets 3,636 3,479
Deficit in the Scheme (2,038) (1,825)
theamountstoberecognisedintheprofitandlossaccountfortheyearended30June2014(withcomparativefiguresfortheyearended30June2013)areasfollows:
2014
£000
2013
£000
Currentservicecost 20 19
Interest on Scheme liabilities 241 214
ExpectedreturnonSchemeassets (211) (174)
Total 50 59
ActualreturnonSchemeassets 212 370
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
106
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED
23. Pensions continued
ChangesinthepresentvalueoftheSchemeliabilitiesfortheyearending30June2014(withcomparativefiguresfortheyearending30June2013)areasfollows:
2014
£000
2013
£000
PresentvalueofSchemeliabilitiesatthebeginningoftheperiod 5,304 4,603
Servicecost(includingEmployeecontributions) 21 22
Interest cost 241 214
Actuariallosses 267 605
Benefitspaid (159) (140)
Present value of Scheme liabilities at the end of the period 5,674 5,304
ChangesinthepresentvalueoftheSchemeassetsfortheyearending30June2014(withcomparativefiguresfortheyearending30June2013)areasfollows:
2014
£000
2013
£000
PresentvalueofSchemeassetsatthebeginningoftheperiod 3,479 3,140
Expectedreturn 211 174
Actuarialgains 1 196
ContributionspaidbytheCollege 102 106
Employeecontributions 2 3
Benefitspaid (159) (140)
Market value of Scheme assets at the end of the period 3,636 3,479
theagreedcontributionstobepaidbytheCollegefortheforthcomingyearare11.73%ofContributionPayplus£9,620p.a.tocoverexpensesplus£85,671p.a.subjecttoreviewatfutureactuarialvaluations.theseratesexcludePHI.
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
107
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED
23. Pensions continued
themajorcategoriesofSchemeassetsasapercentageoftotalSchemeassetsfortheyearending30June2014(withcomparativefiguresfortheyearended30June2013)areasfollows:
2014 2013
EquitiesandHedgeFunds 70% 68%
Property 23% 8%
Bonds and cash 7% 24%
Total 100% 100%
theexpectedlong-termrateofreturnontheSchemeassetshasbeencalculatedbaseduponthemajorassetcategoriesintheabovetableandanexpectedrateofreturnonequitiesandhedgefundsof7.0%(2013:7.0%),property6.0%(2013:6.0%)andanexpectedrateofreturnonbondsandcashof4.0%(2013:4.0%).
AnalysisofamountrecognisableintheStatementoftotalRecognisedGainsandlosses(StRGl)fortheyearending30June2014(withcomparablefiguresfortheyearending30June2013)areasfollows:
2014
£000
2013
£000
ActualreturnlessexpectedreturnonSchemeassets 1 196
ExperiencegainsandlossesarisingonSchemeliabilities 81 (13)
ChangesinassumptionsunderlyingthepresentvalueofSchemeliabilities (348) (592)
Actuarial loss recognised in STRGL (266) (409)
CumulativeamountofactuarialgainsandlossesrecognisedintheStRGlfortheyearending30June2014(withcomparativefiguresfortheyearending30June2013)areasfollows:
2014
£000
2013
£000
Cumulativeactuariallossatbeginningofperiod (1,943) (1,534)
Recognisedduringtheperiod (266) (409)
Cumulative actuarial loss at end of period (2,209) (1,943)
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
108
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED
23. Pensions continued
Movementindeficitduringtheperiodending30June2014(withcomparativefiguresfortheyearending30June2013)areasfollows:
2014
£000
2013
£000
DeficitinSchemeatbeginningofyear (1,825) (1,463)
Servicecost(EmployerOnly) (20) (19)
ContributionspaidbytheCollege 101 106
Finance cost (30) (40)
Actuarialloss (266) (409)
Deficit in Scheme at the end of the year (2,038) (1,825)
Amountsforthecurrentandpreviousfouraccountingperiodsareasfollows:
2014 £000
2013 £000
2012 £000
2011 £000
2010 £000
PresentvalueofSchemeliabilities (5,674) (5,304) (4,603) (4,374) (4,361)
MarketvalueofSchemeassets 3,636 3,479 3,140 3,610 3,203
DeficitintheScheme (2,038) (1,825) (1,463) (764) (1,158)
ActualreturnlessexpectedreturnonSchemeassets 1 196 (630) 240 206
Experiencegain/(loss)arisingonSchemeliabilities 81 (13) (75) 8 192
Changeinassumptionsunderlyingpresentvalueof
Scheme liabilities
(347) (592) (33) 127 (591)
24. Principal Subsidiary Undertakings
CountryofIncorporationand
Operation
Cost£
Class of shares Proportionofsharesheld
DowningCollegeDevelopmentslimited UnitedKingdom 1 Ordinary 100%
DowningCambridgeConferenceslimited UnitedKingdom 1 Ordinary 100%
theMayBallCompanylimited UnitedKingdom 5000 Ordinary 100%
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
109
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED
24. Principal Subsidiary Undertakings continued
DowningCollegeDevelopmentslimitedwasincorporatedon29September2005.theprincipalactivityofthecompanyisdevelopmentofstudentaccommodationandotherfacilities.thiscompanyisincludedintheseconsolidatedfinancialstatements.
DowningCambridgeConferenceslimitedwasincorporatedon2April2007.theprincipalactivityofthecompanyistheprovisionofnoneducationalconferencefacilities.thiscompanyisincludedintheseconsolidatedfinancialstatements.
theMayBallCompanylimitedwasincorporatedon28July2010.theprincipalactivityofthecompanyistoadministertheoperationofthebi-annualCollegeMayBall.thiscompanyisincludedintheseconsolidatedfinancialstatements.
25. Related Party Transactions
OwingtothenatureoftheCollege’soperationsandthecompositionofitsGoverningBody,itispossiblethattransactionswilltakeplacewithorganisationsinwhichamemberoftheCollegeCouncilmayhaveaninterest.AlltransactionsinvolvingorganisationsinwhichamemberoftheCollegeCouncilmayhaveaninterestareconductedatarm’slengthandinaccordancewiththeCollege’snormalprocedures.
26. Contingent liability
USSisa“lastmanstanding”schemesothatintheeventoftheinsolvencyofanyoftheparticipatingemployersinUSS,theamountofanypensionfundingshortfall(whichcannototherwiseberecovered)inrespectofthatemployerwillbespreadacrosstheremainingparticipantemployers.
27. Sir Mortimer Singer Fund
OtherUnrestrictedFunds includes theSirMortimerSingerFundwhichwas funded fromabequestofSirMortimerSingeraFellowCommoneroftheCollege.themoneywasappointedtotheCollegebyladySingeruponthetrustsdeclaredbyadeeddated25March1952.thePensiontrustFundwasalsosetupfromthisbequest.BelowarethemovementsontheseFundsintheyear.
SingerFund
£000
Pensiontrust
£000
OpeningBalanceat1July2013 5,103 206
Income 152 9
Expenditure — (9)
ChangeinMarketValueofInvestments 80 5
ClosingBalanceat30June2014 5,335 211
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
110
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED
28. Analysis of Movement in Total FundsOpening Balance
£000
Net Income & Expenditure
£000
Transfers
£000
Other Gains/(losses)
£000
Closing Balance
£000
Restricted Permanent Funds
AlcanPrizeFund 9 — — — 9
AngharadJohnFellowship 191 — — 43 234
AlwynWHeongFund 235 — — 6 241
BarryMooreEconomicsPrizeFund 1 — — 11 12
BatteyFund 9 — — — 9
BenianluFund 2 — — 1 3
BJEverrittPrizeFund 14 — — — 14
BlankenshipBookFund 12 — — — 12
BlankenshiplawFund 37 — — 2 39
BradbrookFund 11 — — — 11
BuchananFund 228 — — 5 233
CharlesCampbellBookFund 3 — — — 3
S&MHaniffPhysicsFund 6 — — 7 13
CockerellFund 21 — — 1 22
CollinsFund 179 — — 5 184
DarleyFund 281 — — 6 287
DowningAssociationFund 36 — — 1 37
EdwardCollinsFund 106 — — 3 109
ErnestWilliamDenhamFund 25 — — 1 26
EverittFund 1 — — — 1
EverittButterfieldFund 438 — — 138 576
FahrenwaldtFund 12 — — — 12
FerrerasWillettsFund 258 — — 6 264
Florence&DavidJacobsMemorialPrize 6 — — — 6
Carriedforward 2,121 — — 236 2,357
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
111
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED
28. Analysis of Movement in Total Funds continuedOpening Balance
£000
Net Income & Expenditure
£000
Transfers
£000
Other Gains/(losses)
£000
Closing Balance
£000
Restricted Permanent Funds continued
BroughtForward 2,121 — — 236 2,357
FritschFund 361 — — 20 381
FuFund 4 — — — 4
GamlingayFund 72 — — 1 73
GeoffreyGrimmettPrize 5 — — — 5
GraystoneFund 162 — — 3 165
GulbenkianFund 1 — — 1 2
HallFund 10 — — — 10
HaroldHargreavesFund - — — 5 5
HarrisFund 410 — — 10 420
HarrisonFund - — — — —
HarrisonPrizeFund 2 — — — 2
HopkinsParryFund 983 — — 24 1,007
HughBrammerfund 20 — — 14 34
IvorEvansFund 18 — — — 18
JanHruskaFund 131 — — 3 134
JeanRuhmanFund 9 — — — 9
JohnMaplesAmericaFund - — — 143 143
JohnHawkinsMayWildFund 7 — — — 7
JohnstonFund 1 — — — 1
JudyPettyBookPrize&Scholarship 20 — — — 20
landerFund 219 — — 8 227
landrum&BrownScholarshipFund 10 — — 3 13
lordButterfield 143 — — 10 153
Carriedforward 4,709 — — 481 5,190
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
112
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED
28. Analysis of Movement in Total Funds continuedOpening Balance
£000
Net Income & Expenditure
£000
Transfers
£000
Other Gains/(losses)
£000
Closing Balance
£000
Restricted Permanent Funds continued
BroughtForward 4,709 — — 481 5,190
MaysWildFund 488 — — 14 502
AlfredMonkFund — — — 202 202
MoullinFund 2 — — — 2
OonKhyeBengCh'hiatsioMemorialFund 318 — — 11 329
OonKhyeBengCh'hiatsioMemorialPrizeFund 105 — — 8 113
OslerFund 92 — — 2 94
OwensFund 347 — — 8 355
PeterMathiasEconomicsPrizeFund 9 — — (8) 1
PilleyFund 328 — — 7 335
PlattFund 27 — — — 27
ProfessorAudusBotanicalFund 15 — — — 15
RichardsFund 49 — — — 49
RobertsonResearchFellowshipFund 568 — — 32 600
RobsonPhysicsPrize 6 — — — 6
RobsonPostgraduateFund — — — 279 279
SaintFund 38 — — 2 40
SaundersFund 39 — — 1 40
SavileFund 121 — — 3 124
SchreinerFund 58 — — 2 60
SetonFund 68 — — 2 70
SetonCavendishFund 1,673 — — 39 1,712
SirArthurWattsChoralAwards 11 — — 1 12
StevensFund 4 — — — 4
Carriedforward 9,075 — — 1,086 10,161
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
113
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED
28. Analysis of Movement in Total Funds continuedOpening Balance
£000
Net Income & Expenditure
£000
Transfers
£000
Other Gains/(losses)
£000
Closing Balance
£000
Restricted Permanent Funds continued
BroughtForward 9,075 — — 1,086 10,161
Susan&GeoffreyEggingtonScholarship — — — 15 15
tGJonesFund 673 — — 16 689
thomasFund 19 — — — 19
throwerFund 5 — — (1) 4
treherneFund 80 — — 2 82
UnwinFund 54 — — 1 55
VerjeeFund 249 — — 6 255
VerneyFund 2 — — — 2
Warner-lambertFund 192 — — 13 205
WhitbyMemorialFund 349 — — 8 357
WhiteFund 6 — — — 6
WhiteleggFund 52 — — 1 53
WhitworthFund — — — 1,900 1,900
WickstravelFund 12 — — — 12
WyattFund 1 — — 1 2
StudentHardshipEndowment 292 — — 1 293
StudentSupportEndowment 129 — — 54 183
1970’sGrantFund 68 — — 1 69
AlumniSportFund 46 — — 2 48
Fundraising-teaching 159 — — 4 163
Fundraising-Access 267 — — 256 523
Catalysis–teaching&learning 62 — — 56 118
Catalysis–Research&Discovery 9 — — 6 15
Carriedforward 11,801 — — 3,428 15,229
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
114
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED
28. Analysis of Movement in Total Funds continuedOpening Balance
£000
Net Income & Expenditure
£000
Transfers
£000
Other Gains/(losses)
£000
Closing Balance
£000
Restricted Permanent Funds continued
BroughtForward 11,801 — — 3,428 15,229
Catalysis–Heritage&Environment 17 — — 4 21
Catalysis–Support&Services 28 — — 86 114
Catalysis–Culture&Community 6 — — 1 7
Other 57 — — 4 61
11,909 — — 3,523 15,432
Restricted Expendable Funds
BartramFund 116 — — 2 118
ColinHillFund 1 — — 1 2
ColonelAndersontrustFund 94 — — 2 96
GoodeyFund 151 — — 4 155
RichensFund 535 — — 10 545
trehernePrizeFund 11 — — (1) 10
StudentHardshipEndowment 8 — — (6) 2
CatalysisConferenceFund 26 — — 11 37
CatalysisResearchFund 100 — — 2 102
Fundraising–Buildings 43 — — 1 44
Other 112 — — 16 128
1,197 — — 42 1,239
Total Restricted Funds 13,106 — — 3,566 16,672
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts
115
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
ntsNOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED
28. Analysis of Movement in Total Funds continuedOpening Balance
£000
Net Income & Expenditure
£000
Transfers
£000
Other Gains/(losses)
£000
Closing Balance
£000Unrestricted Permanent Funds
ClarkFund 2 — — — 2
FrenchFund 30 — — 1 31
JarvisFund 37 — — 1 38
libraryEndowmentFund 1,020 — — 24 1,044
RichmondFund 191 — — 5 196
StenningFund 51 — — 1 52
StevensonFund 1 — — — 1
Whalley-tookerFund 15 — — 1 16
YatesFund 8 — — — 8
YoungFund 171 — — 4 175
SingerFund(Pensiontrust) 206 — — 5 211
SmythBequest 459 — — 11 470
FleetBequest 49 — — 1 50
DerykProsserFund 395 8 403
CorporateCapitalFund 844 — — 19 863
GeneralCapital 3,521 — — 897 4,418
7,000 — — 978 7,978
Total Endowment funds 20,106 — — 4,544 24,650
116
NOtEStOtHEACCOUNtSCONtINUED
28. Analysis of Movement in Total Funds continuedOpening Balance
£000
Net Income & Expenditure
£000
Transfers
£000
Other Gains/(losses)
£000
Closing Balance
£000
General Reserve Funds
DesignatedBuildings 78,439 - 5,548 - 83,987
CorporateCapitalFund 14,343 595 - 292 15,230
SingerFund(Willtrust) 5,103 152 - 84 5,339
GeneralCapitalandOther (4,246) (567) (5,474) 107 (10,180)
RevaluationReserves 10,797 - (74) 147 10,870
PensionReserves (1,825) 53 - (266) (2,038)
Total General Reserves 102,609 233 — 364 103,208
DeferredCapitalFunds 18,804 — — 704 19,508
Total Reserves 141,519 233 — 5,614 147,366
YearEnded30June2014|NotestotheAccou
nts