-
7/25/2019 11 07 2793-00-0vht 60ghz vs 5ghz Propagation Discussion
1/15
Novembe
r 2007
VinSlid
doc.: IEEE 802.11-07/2793r0
Submission
60 GHz vs. 5 GHz Propagatio !isc"ssio
!at#:2007-11-12
$"t%ors:
-
7/25/2019 11 07 2793-00-0vht 60ghz vs 5ghz Propagation Discussion
2/15
Novembe
r 2007
VinSlid
doc.: IEEE 802.11-07/2793r0
Submission
&'( Pat% &oss at 60 GHz
For LS condi!ions "a!# loss is mainl$ governed b$ !#e %ree-s"ace"ro"aga!ion %ormula& Some "a"ers #ave re"or!ed %e' dB less "a!# lossand some "a"ers %e' dB more !#an !#e %ree-s"ace %ormula& Fordis!ances u" !o 10m, %or LS condi!ions, i! seems like a reasonableassum"!ion (Friis %ormula)*
1020 log ( +(, ))lP d =
! 1m dis!ance "a!# loss is ./ dB and a! 10m dis!ance !#e "a!# loss is // dB&
S!andard devia!ion o% a""roima!el$ dB 'as re"or!ed in !#e li!era!ure !#a! accoun!s %or s#ado'ing& margin due !o
s#ado'ing #as !o be added i% 03 coverage is !o be de!ermined, %or eam"le& 4#e margin is a %unc!ion o% !#e "a!# losse"onen! and s!andard devia!ion&
-
7/25/2019 11 07 2793-00-0vht 60ghz vs 5ghz Propagation Discussion
3/15
Novembe
r 2007
VinSlid
doc.: IEEE 802.11-07/2793r0
Submission
)&'( Pat% &oss at 60 GHz
Ver$ %e' NLS measuremen!s 'ere made a! .0 68&
9i!# increasing carrier %re:uenc$ losses due !o
di%%rac!ion, re%lec!ion, and ma!erial "ene!ra!ion increase
%or NLS condi!ions&
9#en com"ared !o 68, 'e es!ima!e !#a! !#ese
addi!ional losses are in !#e -10 dB range ;1,2
-
7/25/2019 11 07 2793-00-0vht 60ghz vs 5ghz Propagation Discussion
4/15
Novembe
r 2007
VinSlid
doc.: IEEE 802.11-07/2793r0
Submission
*ota+ E,p#ct#d )&'( Pat% &oss at 60 GHz
opar#d to 5 GHz Free s"ace loss is addi!ional 21 dB&
Le!=s assume !#a! addi!ional di%%rac!ion, "ene!ra!ion andre%lec!ion losses are 7 dB&
4#e !o!al addi!ional "a!# loss e"ec!ed a! .0 68 '#encom"ared !o !#e 68 carrier %re:uenc$ ma$ be abou! 2/ dB&
ssuming NLS dis!ance "a!# loss e"onen! o% , !#is!ransla!es in!o communica!ion range (dis!ance) reduc!ion b$ a
mul!i"lica!ive %ac!or o% 0&2, i&e* >ange(.0 68) ? 0&2 >ange( 68)&
4#e calcula!ion above does no! include s#ado'ing s!andarddevia!ion, i! includes onl$ median "a!# loss&
-
7/25/2019 11 07 2793-00-0vht 60ghz vs 5ghz Propagation Discussion
5/15
Novembe
r 2007
VinSlid
doc.: IEEE 802.11-07/2793r0
Submission
60 GHz )&'( ag# #d"ctio
10 d &oss 15 d 20 d 25 d 30 d
ag#
actor
0.56 0.2 0.31 0.2 0.18
60 GHz copar#d to 5 GHz pat% +oss #,po#t 4 )&'(
Expected additional loss (includes path loss difference, antenna gain and
PA transmit power estimates)
-
7/25/2019 11 07 2793-00-0vht 60ghz vs 5ghz Propagation Discussion
6/15
Novembe
r 2007
VinSlid
doc.: IEEE 802.11-07/2793r0
Submission
60 GHz )&'( ag# #d"ctio: otd
10 d &oss 15 d 20 d 25 d 30 d
ag#
actor
0.6 0.32 0.22 0.15 0.1
60 GHz copar#d to 5 GHz pat% +oss #,po#t 4 3 )&'(
Expected additional loss (includes path loss difference, antenna gain and
PA transmit power estimates)
-
7/25/2019 11 07 2793-00-0vht 60ghz vs 5ghz Propagation Discussion
7/15
Novembe
r 2007
VinSlid
doc.: IEEE 802.11-07/2793r0
Submission
60 GHz &'( ag# #d"ctio
10 d &oss 15 d 20 d 25 d 30 d
ag#
actor
0.32 0.18 0.1 0.05 0.03
60 GHz copar#d to 5 GHz pat% +oss #,po#t 4 2 &'(
Expected additional loss (includes path loss, antenna gain and
PA transmit power estimates)
-
7/25/2019 11 07 2793-00-0vht 60ghz vs 5ghz Propagation Discussion
8/15
Novembe
r 2007
VinSlid
doc.: IEEE 802.11-07/2793r0
Submission
P$ Po#r
6iven curren! @ !ec#nolog$ develo"men!s, regula!ions,
and sa%e!$ reasons i! ma$ be e"ec!ed !#a! !#e consumer
grade @s a! .0 68 'ill #ave u" !o 10 dB less "o'er !#a!
!#e ones %or !#e 68 9LN a""lica!ions, %or eam"le(10 m9 vs& 100 m9)&
Some o% !#e lo'er @ "o'er can be com"ensa!ed %or b$
an!enna gain&
-
7/25/2019 11 07 2793-00-0vht 60ghz vs 5ghz Propagation Discussion
9/15
Novembe
r 2007
VinSlid
doc.: IEEE 802.11-07/2793r0
Submission
$t#a Gai at 60 GHz a"tio
ig# direc!ivi!$ an!ennas in a sca!!ering environmen! lose gain'#en com"ared !o !#e omnidirec!ional an!ennas& An !#e li!era!ure!#is is regarded as an!enna 6>F (gain reduc!ion %ac!or)&
irec!ive an!ennas am"li%$ onl$ some "ro"aga!ion ra$s, o!#ers area!!enua!ed and !#ere%ore mul!i"a!# com"onen!s are los! !#a! resul!sin a loss o% "o'er, loss o% diversi!$, and reduced rank %or CACs$s!ems !#a! reduces s"a!ial mul!i"leing gains&
mnidirec!ional an!ennas am"li%$ all ra$s evenl$, in mos! cases&
4#ere%ore, in "a!# loss calcula!ions, nominal (adver!ised) an!ennagain de!ermined in an anec#oic c#amber #as !o be reduced b$ 6>F&
A! 'as s#o'n !#a! %or ou!door environmen!s !#e 6>F is signi%ican!(-7 dB %or 20o#ori8on!al an!enna beam'id!# (-5dB beam'id!#
"oin!s))&
Andoor environmen!s e"erience more sca!!ering !#an ou!doorenvironmen!s "o!en!iall$ resul!ing in larger 6>F& >e:uires %ur!#erinves!iga!ion&
-
7/25/2019 11 07 2793-00-0vht 60ghz vs 5ghz Propagation Discussion
10/15
Novembe
r 2007
VinSlid
doc.: IEEE 802.11-07/2793r0
Submission
&'( !#+a Proi+#s or !i#r#t $t#a
#aidt%s at 60 GHz
With decreasing antenna beamwidth LOS component is amplified and reflected
components are attenuated b the antenna pattern !"#$
%x Omni Antenna
&x Omni Antenna
%x Omni Antenna
&x '
o
Antenna
%x Omni Antenna
&x
o
Antenna
d*+ d*
" d*
-
7/25/2019 11 07 2793-00-0vht 60ghz vs 5ghz Propagation Discussion
11/15
Novembe
r 2007
VinSlid
doc.: IEEE 802.11-07/2793r0
Submission
+oc;ag# E#cts
A% !#e LS com"onen! is blocked b$ a "erson, %or eam"le, i!'as re"or!ed in !#e li!era!ure !#a! u" !o 20 dB o% signal "o'ercan be los! ;,
-
7/25/2019 11 07 2793-00-0vht 60ghz vs 5ghz Propagation Discussion
12/15
Novembe
r 2007
VinSlid
doc.: IEEE 802.11-07/2793r0
Submission
+oc;ag# E#cts: otd
4o avoid large signal "o'er loss in !#e case o% !#e direc!LS "a!# blockage, es"eciall$ in !#e direc!ional an!ennacase, ada"!ive beam an!ennas ma$ be "re%erable&
A! is no! clear #o' !#e ada"!ive beam an!ennas 'ould"er%orm '#en com"ared !o !#e omnidirec!ional an!ennas in!#e case o% a blockage&
A% !#e #ig# reliabili!$ link is !o be e"ec!ed, !#e blockagescenario #as !o be care%ull$ considered and solu!ion %ound
in order no! !o break !#e communica!ion link& Dlosel$ s"aced mul!i"le !ransceivers ma$ mi!iga!e
s#ado'ing "roblem, bu! a! !#e #ig#er cos! and com"lei!$&
-
7/25/2019 11 07 2793-00-0vht 60ghz vs 5ghz Propagation Discussion
13/15
Novembe
r 2007
VinSlid
doc.: IEEE 802.11-07/2793r0
Submission
!isc"ssio
4o ge! be!!er #andle on .0 68 "ro"aga!ion !#e %ollo'ingim"or!an! measuremen!s s#ould be "er%ormed !#a! aremissing in !#e re"or!ed and "ublis#ed resul!s*
NLS measuremen!s (ver$ %e' 'ere re"or!ed)&
6>F - omni vs& direc!ional an!enna measuremen!s&
iversi!$, CAC measuremen!s - as a ne! s!e"&
-
7/25/2019 11 07 2793-00-0vht 60ghz vs 5ghz Propagation Discussion
14/15
Novembe
r 2007
VinSlid
doc.: IEEE 802.11-07/2793r0
Submission
!isc"ssio/oc+"sio
.0 68 %re:uenc$ band ma$ be sui!able %or a""lica!ionslimi!ed !o s#or! range communica!ion, mes#, or dis!ribu!ed(densel$ de"lo$ed) ne!'orks&
.0 68 %re:uenc$ band ma$ no! be sui!able %or a""lica!ions
!#a! re:uire similar range re:uiremen!s and a""lica!ions as/02&11a+b+g+n s$s!ems&
4o cover a regular #ouse a! 2& 68 or 68 %re:uenc$bands one 9LN ccess @oin! ma$ be re:uired, '#ile %or !#esame radio coverage a! .0 68 uni!s ma$ be re:uired (based
on sim"le assum"!ion !#a! >ange(.0 68) ? 1+5 >ange(68))&
ddi!ional measuremen!s and anal$sis s#ould be done a! .068 %re:uenc$ band&
-
7/25/2019 11 07 2793-00-0vht 60ghz vs 5ghz Propagation Discussion
15/15
Novembe
r 2007
VinSlid
doc.: IEEE 802.11-07/2793r0
Submission
##r#c#s
;1< @& F& C& Smulders and L& CA& Dorreia D#arac!erisa!ion o% @ro"aga!ion in .0 68 >adioD#annels, Elec!ronics and Domm& Eng& Gournal, "ril 17, ""& 75-/0&
;2< & Hang, @& F&C& Smulders and C& &&G& erben Andoor D#annel Ceasuremen!s andnal$sis in !#e Fre:uenc$ Bands 2 68 and .0 68, 200 AEEE @AC>D, ""& 7-/5&
;5< 4akes#i Canabe, Huko Ciura, and 4os#io A#ar' E%%ec!s o% n!enna irec!ivi!$ on AndoorCul!i"a!# @ro"aga!ion D#arac!eris!ics a! .0 68, in @roceedings o% AEEE @AC>D, 4oron!o,1, ""& 105-105&
;< I& Sa!o and 4& Canabe Es!ima!ion o% @ro"aga!ion-@a!# Visibili!$ %or Andoor 9irelessLN S$s!ems under S#ado'ing Dondi!ion b$ uman Bodies, Ve#icular 4ec#nolog$Don%erence, Vol& 5, 1/-21 Ca$ 1/, ""& 210 J 2115&
;< S& Dollonge, 6& Ka#aria, and 6& El Kein An%luence o% !#e uman c!ivi!$ on 9ide-BandD#arac!eris!ics o% !#e .0 68 Andoor >adio D#annel, AEEE 4rans& on 9ireless Domm&, Vol&5, No& ., Nov 200&
;.< 4& K'ick, 4& G& Beukema, and & Nam 9ideband D#annel Sounder 9i!# Ceasuremen!sand Codel %or !#e .0 68 Andoor >adio D#annel, AEEE 4rans on Ve# 4ec#nol, Vol& , No&
, Gul$ 200&